As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

July 1900

37 articles

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The dispatch describes Earp provoking a quarrel with an unarmed man named Boyett, demanding he arm himself before a shootout in a saloon. Earp is reported killed instantly while Boyett escaped uninjured, with only the saloon proprietor witnessing the event from hiding.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 8 July 1900 · page 24 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

YUBA CITY, July 7.—Suit has been commenced in the Superior Court here to test the election law relative to a person's voting at a school election when not on the new register forty days prior thereto. T. J. Mulvany brings suit to oust P. Descher, who was elected School Trustee in the Nicolaus district. The case will be heard on the 20th inst. TANT SECRETARY OF TREASURY. by the presence of O. L. Spaulding, Assistant of the United States. He is stopping at the ot looking for notoriety. Many officers of the ee the gentleman yesterday afternoon and pay him.

See moreSee less

The presence of so many of the local offi- ostelry created the rumor that there was some of Mr. Spaulding. This thought was, however, d with my visit to this coast at this time," ernoon. "It is true that my trip is for the but it is also a pleasure, for it gives my wife our son, Lieutenant Spaulding, who is in the Winfield Scott. the Sound ports, looking through the customs to the far north. My business there will be ursued in the handling of goods bound for ports usands of miles it is sometimes difficult to un- the purpose of placing the Treasury Depart- ditions that I am here. The transportation of territory and matters pertaining to the bonded manner satisfactory to all parties concerned will I return to Washington I hope to be able to will be acceptable. It is not intended that my y, and I expect to be back in San Francisco in hington. There are no investigations to be of the term. I am simply going to obtain some of great assistance in making improvements the general public." se traffic with the northern mines will hear with particular satisfaction, as there are several instances arbitrary and unjust to miners and their seriousness is responsible for the long undertaken by the Assistant Secretary of the of the handsomest and most genial gentlemen the seat of Government. that if they ever quarreled again it would be to the death. Earp began a quarrel yesterday and Boyett was unarmed. Earp demanded him to get his gun, which he did, and the fight took place in a saloon. Earp was instantly killed. Boyett was uninjured. When the firing began the saloon was cleared and no one but the proprietor, who was in hiding behind the bar, witnessed it.

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch from Tucson reports that Virgil Earp was shot dead by John Boyett at Willcox after years of bad blood over a feud with cattle rustlers. It describes Earp taunting Boyett in a restaurant/saloon, leading to a fatal confrontation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Times · 8 July 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BORDER DESPERADO KILLED.

He Insists on Having Trouble and

See moreSee less

Gets a Full Share.

TUCSON, Ariz., July 7.—Virgil Earp, the youngest of the famous family of border desperadoes whose names were once the terror of Tombstone, was shot dead today by John Boyett, at Wilcox. There had been bad blood between Earp and Boyett for years, growing out of a feud between the Earp brothers and cattle rustlers.

Earp had a habit of running Boyett about the town, and Boyett always tried to avoid a quarrel. Not long ago Earp got Boyett in a saloon and, pressing a six shooter against his stomach, made him promise that if they ever quarreled again there would be a killing. The tragedy which he wanted took place this morning. The men met in a restaurant which connects with a saloon, and Earp began to taunt Boyett, and in the fight which followed Boyett killed Earp.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report describes Warren Earp, youngest of the Earp brothers, being shot dead by John Boyett in a Willcox, Arizona saloon after a long-running feud. It recounts their history of conflict, including Earp's past threats, and the confrontation that led to the gunfight.

The Sun · 8 July 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WARREN EARP SHOT DEAD.

THE TOMBSTONE DESPERADO FINALLY GOES TO HIS REWARD.

See moreSee less

Goads John Boyett Into Having a Shooting Match—Had Frequently Humiliated Boyett and Then the Worm Turned—The Notorious Earp Family and Their Shooting Record.

TUCSON, Ariz., July 7.—Warren Earp, the youngest of the famous family of border desperadoes, whose names were once the terror of Tombstone, was shot dead to-day by John Boyett at Wilcox. There had been ill feeling between Earp and Boyett for years, growing out of a feud between the Earp boys and the cattle rustlers. Earp had a habit of "running" Boyett about the town. Boyett always tried to avoid a quarrel.

Not long ago Earp got Boyett in a saloon and, pressing a six-shooter against his abdomen, made him promise that if they ever quarrelled again there would be a killing. The tragedy which he wanted took place this morning. The two men met in a restaurant which connects with a saloon and Earp began to abuse Boyett. They walked into the saloon together and Earp said:

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The dispatch describes a quarrel and shootout in Willcox in which Johnny Boyett killed an unarmed Warren Earp after a dare to get guns, then recaps the Earp-Clanton feud including the O.K. Corral fight and the killing of Frank Stilwell by Wyatt Earp. It notes Wyatt Earp is now running a gambling operation and once refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prizefight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 8 July 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE TOMBSTONE DESPERADO FINALLY GOES

Not long ago Earp got Boyett in a saloon and, pressing a six-shooter against his abdomen, made him promise that if they ever quarrelled again there would be a killing. The tragedy which he wanted took place this morning. The two men met in a restaurant which connects with a saloon and Earp began to abuse Boyett. They walked into the saloon together and Earp said:

"Boyett, go get your gun and we will settle this thing right here. I've got my gun, go get yours."

See moreSee less

Boyett left, and when he returned he began shooting and cleared the saloon of loungers. Earp, who had gone out, appeared at the back door. He advanced, throwing open his coat and said:

"I'm unarmed. You've all the best of this."

Boyett warned him not to come nearer, but Earp did not heed his words, and when within eight feet Boyett fired, killing Earp instantly.

Earp is the youngest brother of a family of boys who distinguished themselves in shootings in Arizona. The feud between the Rustlers and the Earps began in the 80's at Tombstone, when a large number of Government horses was stolen from Camp Rucker, in the Chiricahua Mountains by cowboys. They were tracked to the McLowry ranch by soldiers and the Earp boys and lost there. The Earps said the cowboys ran them off, and their statement to this effect precipitated a feud.

Several killings have taken place over it, a notable one being that of Frank Stillwell at the Tucson depot by Wyatt Earp. Virgil Earp had been shot at Tombstone by cow punchers and was being taken to San Francisco when Stillwell attempted to shoot him through the car window. Stillwell was shot by Wyatt Earp.

The bloodiest fight in the feud was at Tombstone between four of the Clanton and McLowry gang and four of the Earps and Doc Holloday. More than fifty shots were fired and when the McLowrys fled they left two dead. All the Earps were wounded but none was killed. Warren Earp was a freighter. Jim was killed by rustlers and Virgil lives in Prescott, Ariz.

Wyatt Earp served as umpire in the famous prizefight in San Francisco between Fitzsimmons and Shackey and gave the notorious decision against Fitzsimmons. Wyatt Earp is now running a gambling outfit.

Goebel Trial to Begin To-Morrow.

FRANKFORT, Ky., July 7.--The trials of the alleged conspirators in the Goebel murder case will be called at Georgetown on Monday on a change of venue and while there have been all kinds of rumors that a postponement would be asked, it is known that unless an extremely good reason is given why postponement should be granted the trials will proceed. It is expected that Henry E. Youtsey will be the first called for trial.

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

The report describes Warren Earp, youngest of the Earp brothers, being shot dead by John Boyett in a saloon confrontation in Wilcox, Arizona, stemming from a long feud with cattle rustlers. It recounts Wyatt Earp's background, including his controversial role as referee in the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey prize fight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Saint Paul Globe · 9 July 1900 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

YOUNGEST EARP SHOT DEAD. Famous Desperado Looked for Trouble, and Found It. TUCSON, Tex., July 8.—Warren Earp, the youngest of the famous family of border desperadoes, whose names were

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

A brief dispatch reports that Warren Earp, youngest of the notorious Earp family once feared in Tombstone, was shot dead by John Boyett at Wilcox. The item appears among a list of unrelated telegraphic news briefs from across the country.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 9 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

busines houses on the north side of Main street, Windom, Minn., Saturday. Loss, $60,000. A tornado Sunday did much damage to the Illinois College of Photography, at Effingham, Ills. The northwest portion of the main building was demolished. Warren Earp, the youngest of the famous family of border desperadoes, whose names were once the terror of Tombstone, was shot dead by John

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Warren Earp was shot dead by Johnny Boyett at Willcox after a long history of Earp bullying Boyett while drunk. The report describes Earp forcing a final confrontation, Boyett arming himself with two revolvers, and a shootout in a saloon and restaurant.

Arizona Republican · 10 July 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

WARREN EARP KILLED

Shot at Willcox by Johnhy Boyett on July 6th.

See moreSee less

Warren Earp was shot and killed at Willcox on Friday by Johnny Boyett. There has been bad blood between

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The report describes a late-night confrontation in a Willcox saloon where Warren Earp, after goading rancher John Boyett into arming himself, was shot dead despite declaring he was unarmed and raising his coat to prove it. Witnesses said Boyett warned Earp repeatedly not to advance before firing the fatal shot.

Arizona Republican · 10 July 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

WARREN EARP KILLED

Willcox on Friday by Johnny Boyett. There has been bad blood between them for some years. Earp had a disagreeable habit when under the influence of liquor of running Boyett all over town. Boyett it seems never sought a quarrel and always sought to avoid Earp when he was looking for trouble. Recounting the tragedy the Citizen says:

It was not long ago that Earp got Boyett in a saloon, and with a six-shooter pressed to his stomach, made him promise that if he and Earp ever had another quarrel a killing would result.

See moreSee less

Friday morning about 1 o'clock the long deferred tragedy took place. The two men met in a resturant at the back of Brown's saloon. Earp was under the influence of liquor and started to abuse Boyett. Bystanders say that they never heard any man take such abuse. After some minutes the two men went into the saloon, where Earp said: "Boyett, get your gun and we will settle this thing right here. I've got my gun, you go and get yours."

Boyett then went out to the hotel, secured two 45-calibre Colts and returned to the saloon. He advanced to the middle of the room and called out, "Where is that ---- ----" Just then Earp appeared in the door of the restaurant. Boyett fired some shots at him, whereupon all ran out of the saloon but Brown, the proprietor, who jumped behind the bar.

Boyett fired two more shots, both into the floor, and Earp disappeared from the restaurant door. In a few seconds he entered the saloon by another door, having gone out of the rear room and walked around the building. Boyett was still standing in the middle of the saloon, and as Earp entered he warned him not to come near him. Earp advanced and throwing up his coat, said, "Boyett, I'm unarmed. You've all the best of this," but still continued to advance in spite of the warning. Brown says that Boyett repeated his command not to advance four or five times. When Earp had approached within eight or ten feet of him, Boyett fired one shot and Earp plunged forward, dead.

In Earp's hand was found a small pocket knife, half opened, but aside from that there was nothing on his person that might have been used as a weapon.

Deputy Sheriff Page, who brought the news of the killing to Tucson, says that Boyett was always a peaceable man and put up with a great deal from Earp. Earp is well known in Tombstone, belonging to a family which has figured largely in the annals of that camp. Boyett is a small rancher and cattle man at Hot Springs.

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

The report describes a long-running feud between Warren Earp and rancher Johnny Boyett, culminating in Earp's drunken provocation and fatal shooting at a Willcox saloon. It details the confrontation, including Boyett arming himself and the final deadly encounter after Earp challenged him.

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 11 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A KILLING AT WILLCOX, Warren Earp Is Shot Dead by a Rancher After Repeatedly Intimidating the Latter.

Yesterday a killing occurred in Willcox which had some of the aspects of a suicide. There had been bad blood between Warren Earp and Johnny Boyett for some years. Earp had a disagreeable habit when under the influence of liquor of running Boyett all over town. Boyett, it seems, never sought a quarrel and always sought to avoid Earp when he was looking for trouble.

It was not long ago that Earp got Boyett in a saloon, and with a six-shooter pressed to his stomach, made him promise that if he and Earp ever had another quarrel a killing would result.

See moreSee less

Yesterday morning about 1 o'clock the long deferred tragedy took place. The two men met in a restaurant at the back of Brown's saloon. Earp was under the influence of liquor and

See the clipping

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.

The account describes an armed confrontation between a man named Earp and a rancher named Royett in a saloon at Willcox, Arizona, that ended with Royett shooting the unarmed Earp dead. A deputy sheriff is quoted vouching for Royett's generally peaceable character, and the piece notes Earp belonged to a family well known in Tombstone.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 11 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A KILLING AT WILLCOX

Boyett fired two more shots, both into the floor, and Earp disappeared from the restaurant door. In a few seconds he entered the saloon by another door, having gone out of the rear room and walked around the building. Boyett was still standing in the middle of the saloon, and as Earp entered he warned him not to come near him. Earp advanced and throwing open his coat said: "Boyett, I'm unarmed; you've all the best of this," but still continued to advance in spite of the warning. Brown says that Boyett repeated his command not to advance four or five times. When Earp had approached within eight or ten feet of him, Boyett fired one shot and Earp plunged forward dead.

In Earp's hand was found a small pocket knife half open, but aside from that there was nothing on his person that might have been used as a weapon.

See moreSee less

Deputy Sheriff Page, who brought the news of the killing to Tucson, says that Boyett was always a peaceable man and put up with a great deal from Earp. Earp is well known in Tombstone, belonging to a family which has figured largely in the annals of that camp. Boyett is a small rancher and cattle man at Hot Springs, Tucson Citizen.

See the clipping

In the story →

Tombstone Epitaph · Tombstone, Ariz.

The report states that John Boyett, who shot and killed Warren Earp in Willcox on Friday night, has been exonerated by a coroner's jury after Earp allegedly advanced on him with a knife despite warnings. It notes the two men had been on bad terms and that the official verdict had not yet been formally received by the paper.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

Tombstone Epitaph · 15 July 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

WARREN EARP KILLED

John Boyett Exhonorated by the Coroners Jury

See moreSee less

Word was received here today that John Boyett who killed Warren Earp at Wilcox on Friday night has been exhonerated by the coroner's jury. Earp was a member of the widely known Earp family of Tombstone fame. Boyett is a wellknown cattleman. It is understood the two men have not been on friendly terms for some time. At the time of the killing both met at a saloon in Wilcox and it is said Earp became abusive and told Boyett to get his gun. The latter did so and returning found Earp in bad mood. Earp started for Boyett with a pocket knife in his hand, at same time saying he was unarmed. Boyett warned Earp to stop as he would take no chances and ordered him not to proceed farther on pain of being killed. The deceased paid no attention to the warning and in advancing received the fatal shot. It was latter found that Earp was unarmed save the pocket knife. This is in effect the report of killing as reached here. The verdict of the coroners jury has not yet been officially received here.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A dispatch from San Francisco claims Wyatt Earp, the boxing referee who gave Sharkey the decision over Fitzsimmons on a foul, was shot recently in a saloon he ran at Cape Nome. The report states he was still alive at last accounts.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Arizona Republican · 15 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP SHOT. San Francisco. July 14.--News has been received from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight and gave the decision to Sharkey on a foul, was shot recently in a saloon which he was running at Nome. At last accounts he was still alive.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The steamer San Jose brought news from Alaska that the notorious Wyatt Earp had been shot but not fatally wounded on June 23 after pulling a gun on a man in a saloon who proved quicker. The report came secondhand via ex-Coroner E. E. Hill, a passenger on the ship.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The San Francisco Call · 15 July 1900 · page 31

and collection of rncllon tho little island the San, Francisco and. North. Pacific Kail. wasperfect; ¦¦ His -success, in this as well ; way '»¦ ferry 5 slip at '11:80 to-morrow morn- &&¦ other welirhtr'mlssiona' highly . recomIns, -4 , ¦ ¦¦ • < .; ¦••-':. • . .tween them. In pert at Dutch Harbor .Uuly 11. >: mi Pier North I"ork:Huinboldt were the Hero, Ranier, Lawton and JJulr 3*. - prciPler Pt. Arena.. Point Arena.. ti Perry. Corona .... San Di**o — ..Julr 18. 11am Pier |j .'Julr 1?. Ham Pl?r The San Jose brines the news that the Columbia ..

See moreSee less

Portland .'Julr IT. S pmiPlcr notorious Wyatt Earp had been shot, but Orizaba ..JHumboldt ; > .i-Tuly is. 12 m!PM* Xewport ...IN. Y. v. Pan. not fatally wounded, on June 23. Ha .(July 19, 9 am;PI»r Bonita .'....San Pe<1rr>. pulled a gun on a man in a saloon, but

See the clipping

The Times · Washington, D.C.

A letter from a former San Francisco coroner now in Nome reports that Wyatt Earp, notorious as an Arizona gunfighter, was shot in the arm after provoking a quarrel with a customer at his saloon. The account claims Earp drew his pistol first but the other man fired back, wounding him, ending the altercation.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Times · 15 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP WOUNDED.

Finds a Man at Nome Who Is Also Quick With a Gun.

See moreSee less

SAN FRANCISCO, July 14.—In a letter received from ex-Coroner Hill, of San Francisco, now at Nome, comes the news that Wyatt Earp, the notorious Arizona gun fighter and bad man, was shot in the arm by a man on whom he started to pull a gun in his saloon. Earp was badly wounded and before he recovers he wil[l]

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A letter from an ex-coroner in Nome claims Wyatt Earp was shot in the arm by a customer at his saloon after reaching for his own gun, and was jailed by military authorities. The report also notes his brother Warren Earp was killed in Arizona around the same time.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 26 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 15 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP SHOT AT NOME.

THE ARIZONA "BAD MAN" NOT QUICK ENOUGH WITH HIS GUN.

See moreSee less

San Francisco, July 14 (Special).—In a letter received from ex-Coroner Hill, of San Francisco, now at Nome, comes news that Wyatt Earp, the notorious Arizona gun fighter and bad man, was shot in the arm by a man on whom he started to pull a gun in his saloon. Earp was badly wounded, and before he recovers he will have received intelligence of the death of his youngest brother, Warren, who last week was shot at Willcox, Ariz.

According to Hill, Wyatt Earp, who keeps a saloon and gambling house in Nome, has been the terror of the town because of his reputation as a dead shot. He bullied every one, and he was particularly offensive in his own place after he had had a little liquor. On June 30 Earp quarrelled with a customer, and, being greatly enraged, reached for his gun, which was behind the counter. The customer, who had a large navy revolver, didn't wait for the bad man to heel himself, but opened fire, and put a bullet through Earp's right arm. This ended the fight, for Earp's arm was rendered useless, and he lost much blood.

The military authorities investigated the affair and lodged Earp in jail. His followers swore vengeance, but there were too many troops for them to do anything. Wyatt Earp gained notoriety here at the time he gave the decision against Fitzsimmons and in favor of Sharkey. Before he entered the ring as the referee the police made him deliver up his big revolver, and after the fight he went around heeled with two guns and dared any one to hint that he had made a crooked decision.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A dispatch from San Francisco states that Wyatt Earp, known for refereeing the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, was recently shot in the saloon he operates in Nome. The report notes that at last word, Earp was still alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 15 July 1900 · page 5

Wyatt Enrp Shot nt Nome. SAN FRANCISCO, July 14. News has been received from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzslm-mons fight and gave the decision to Shar key on a foul, was shot recently in the sa loon which he is running at Nome. At last accounts Earp was still alive.

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

A letter from ex-Coroner Hill in Nome claims Wyatt Earp was shot in the arm by a customer after a quarrel in his saloon, and that military authorities jailed him afterward. The report also notes that his youngest brother Warren had recently been shot and killed at Willcox, Arizona.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Scranton Tribune · 16 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP SHOT AT NOME

On June 30 Earp quarreled with a customer, and, being greatly enraged, reached for his gun, which was behind the counter. The customer, who had a large navy revolver, didn't wait for the bad man to heel himself, but opened fire, and put a bullet through Earp's right arm. This ended the fight, for Earp's arm was rendered useless, and he lost much blood.

The military authorities investigated the affair and lodged Earp in jail. His followers swore vengeance, but there were too many troops for them to do anything. Wyatt Earp gained note-

See the clipping

The Savannah Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The item claims gunfighter Wyatt Earp, who runs a bar and gambling house at Cape Nome, was shot twice in his shooting arm by a customer before he could draw his own revolver. It frames the incident as proof that the fastest draw rules at Nome just as it did in the old Black Hills days.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Savannah Morning News · 17 July 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp, the notorious gun fighter of Arizona, the man who robbed Fitzsimmons of the decision against Sharkey in San Francisco some years ago, has met more than his match at Cape Nome, where he runs a bar and gambling house. Earp quarreled with one of his customers and reached for his revolver, but before he could draw it the other man had sent two bullets through his shooting arm, thus putting him out of the game. The man who can draw and shoot first is the big man at Nome, just as was the case in the Black Hills in their boom days.

See moreSee less

The death of Senator Gear of Iowa will open the way for Representative Dolliver to get into the Senate; provided the Governor of the state thinks Dolliver is as big a man as did some of those who were mentioning him at Philadelphia for the vice presidential nomination. The Legislature of Iowa will not meet until January, 1902, so that the ad interim appointee will have a good, long time to serve.

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Star · Honolulu Oahu

Warren Earp, younger brother of Wyatt Earp, was shot and killed in a saloon altercation with cowboy John Boyett in Wilcox, Arizona Territory. The report notes the two had quarreled years earlier during border conflicts.

The Hawaiian Star · 17 July 1900 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WYATT EARP'S BROTHER SHOT. WILCOX, A. T., July 7.—Warren Earp, youngest brother of Wyatt Earp, the famous border gun fighter, was shot and instantly killed yesterday in a saloon row with a cowboy named John Boyett. The men had quarreled years ago during the early border fights. Wyatt Earp is the man who refereed the prize fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey some years ago in San Francisco.

See the clipping

Albuquerque Daily Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

A coroner's jury in Willcox exonerated John Boyett for fatally shooting Warren Earp, ruling self-defense after Earp advanced on him with a knife despite warnings. The report states the two men had been on bad terms and that Earp, though claiming to be unarmed, had a pocket knife.

Albuquerque Daily Citizen · 17 July 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

the Tombstone Prospector, that John Bovett, who killed Warren Earp at Wilcox, on Friday night, has been exonerated by the coroner's jury. Earp was a member of the widely known Earp family, of Tombstone fame. Bovett is a well-known cattle man. It is understood that the two men have not been on friendly terms for some time. At the time of the killing both met in a saloon at Wilcox, and it is said Earp became abusive and told told Bovett to get his gun. The latter did so and returning found Earp in a bad mood.

See moreSee less

Earp started for Bovett, with a pocket knife in his hand, at the same time saying he was unarmed. Bovett warned Earp to stop, as he would take no chances, and ordered him not to proceed further on pain of being killed. The deceased paid no attention to the warning, and in advancing, received the fatal shot. It was later found that Earp was unarmed, save for the pocket knife.

See the clipping

The Arizona Range News · Willcox, Ariz.

A brief item relays a report from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp was shot recently in a saloon he was running there. The last word received was that he was still alive.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Arizona Range News · 18 July 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

LOCAL AND PERSONAL.

In consequence of the shortage of water the Dos Cabezas Consolidated Minning Company have layed off ten of their men. They still have about ten men at work.

Report came from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp was shot recently in a

See the clipping

The Honolulu Republican · Honolulu, T.H. · and 1 other paper

The report announces that Warren Earp, youngest of the Earp brothers, was killed in a gunfight with cowboy Johnnie Boyett at Willcox, Arizona, recounting the old Tombstone feud and prior shootings involving Morgan, Virgil, and Wyatt Earp. It notes a coroner's jury ruled the killing justifiable homicide in Boyett's favor.

The Honolulu Republican · 19 July 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

WARREN EORP, OUTLAW, DIES IN HIS BOOTS.

TUCSON, Ariz., July 7. — Warren Earp was killed this morning at Wilcox by Johnnie Boyett, a cowboy. A feud sprang up at Tombstone between the Earp boys and a band of cowboys some years ago, in which Morgan Earp was killed, and there have been several shooting affairs since. In one Virgil Earp was shot in the arm. He was pursued to Tucson by Frank Stillwell, who attempted to finish him, and was shot himself by Wyatt Earp.

See moreSee less

Warren was the youngest of the family, which was noted for the number of shooting scrapes they indulged in in Arizona, all of which were precipitated by the existing feud. Boyett is a cowboy who belonged to the band that opposed the Earps.

Warren Earp had frequently attacked him, and recently the men made a vow that if they ever quarreled again it would be to the death. Earp began a quarrel yesterday and Boyett was unarmed. Earp demanded him to get his gun, which he did, and the fight took place in a saloon. Earp was instantly killed. Boyett was uninjured. When the firing began the saloon was cleared and no one but the proprietor, who was in hiding behind the bar, witnessed it. A Coroner's jury found a verdict of justifiable homicide in favor of Boyett.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif. · 8 July 1900

The Colfax Gazette · Colfax, Wash.

A brief news item reports that Wyatt Earp, known for refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in San Francisco, was shot but is still alive at Nome. The claim appears amid a roundup of miscellaneous state and national news items.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Colfax Gazette · 20 July 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

at Seattle.

Wyatt Earp, who refereed the famous Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight at San Francisco, is reported shot, but still alive at Nome.

See moreSee less

United States Senator John H. Gear of Iowa died suddenly at Washington.

A committee of gold democrats issued a call for a meeting July 18 to devise the best method of placing in nomination a third ticket for president and vice president upon a platform "denouncing and combatting the fallacies and unusual creeds of both of the old parties." The call is signed by gold democrats of New York, Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Colorado.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The report describes the fatal shooting of one of the Earp brothers in a saloon in Willcox, Arizona, by a cowboy named Johnny Boyett, stemming from an old feud. It recounts the brother confronting Boyett unarmed and being shot dead, and recaps the Earp-cowboy feud's origins in Tombstone.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 July 1900 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

[Third of the Earp Brothers Meets a] Violent Death. Virgil Earp, the third of the four Earp brothers, Warren, Julian, Virgil and Wyatt, "died with his boots on" at Wilcox, Ariz., recently. He was shot through the heart in a saloon by Cowboy

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The report recounts a sensationalized, embellished feud between the Earp family and cowboys/rustlers, including a gunfight where Boyett kills an unarmed Earp, along with fantastical claims about a sister named Jessie Earp marrying Ike Clanton and being pursued through a mine tunnel. It mixes in unrelated wire content about Mexican President Diaz's re-election.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 20 July 1900 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

DIED WITH HIS BOOTS ON

heed his words, and Boyett fired, killing Earp instantly.

The feud between the rustlers and the Earp boys began in the 80's at Tombstone, when a large number of government horses were stolen by cowboys. They were tracked to the McLow ranch by soldiers and the Earp boys and lost there. Earp said the cowboys ran them off, and his statement to this effect started the bad feeling.

See moreSee less

Several killings have grown out of it, a notable one being that of Frank Stillwell at Tucson depot by Wyatt Earp. In 1883 even the people of Tombstone refused to tolerate the presence of the "Earp gang" any longer and they were ordered to move.

After a little altercation, resulting in the sudden death of Warren Earp, the family withdrew to the Gunnison country, where for a year and a half they continued their career.

Their sister, Jessie Earp, fell in love with Ike Clanton in the Gunnison and ran away with him. The three ran down Clanton and their sister in a mine tunnel. The miners demanded that Clanton be given a chance for his life, and Julian took up the challenge and was shot dead by Clanton.

Two years later Virgil and Wyatt found their sister in Colorado and killed her husband on his own doorstep.

Virgil Earp killed three men in one day in a Colorado camp, and Wyatt by leading a fake pursuit got him safely away. Virgil and Wyatt have drifted apart of late years. Wyatt was referee of the Fitzsimmon-Sharkey prize fight in San Francisco in 1896.--New York World.

See the clipping

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho

A dispatch from San Francisco relays news from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp, who had refereed the controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, was shot recently in the saloon he runs there. The report notes that at last accounts Earp was still alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Kootenai Herald · 21 July 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp Shot at Nome. San Francisco, July 16.—News has been received from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, and gave the decision to Sharkey on a foul, was shot recently in

See the clipping

The Silver Blade · Rathdrum, Idaho

A dispatch from San Francisco states that Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, was recently shot in the saloon he runs at Cape Nome. It notes that as of the last update, Earp was still alive.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Silver Blade · 21 July 1900 · page 4

Wjatt Efarp Shot nt Atome. San Francisco, July 16.—News has been received from Cape Nome that Wyatt Karp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsim mons fight, and gave the decision to Sharkey on a foul, was shot recently in the saloon which he is running at Nome, At last accounts Earp was still alive. At

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

This report recounts the violent reputation of the Earp brothers after news that Wyatt Earp was shot in his saloon at Cape Nome, Alaska. It claims Wyatt is the last surviving brother, with Virgil and a brother named 'Julian' said to have died in gunfights years earlier, and Warren recently killed at Willcox, Arizona.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Times · 22 July 1900 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

MURDERS WERE THEIR PASTTIME

The news of the shooting and wounding of Wyatt Earp in his own saloon at Cape Nome by a customer he had tried to bully, has revived interest among those who knew him as the notorious Arizona gun fighter and bad man and his equally noted brothers.

It was expected that there would be serious trouble at Cape Nome after the shooting of Earp, as his followers, all bad and reckless characters, swore vengeance. The military authorities, however, lodged Earp in jail, and as the troops are too many for them, it is hardly likely that the wounded desperado's friends will commit any overt act. It is likely that before Earp recovers from his wound he will receive news of the death of his youngest brother, Warren, who was shot and killed last week at Willcox, Arizona.

See moreSee less

AS PRIZE FIGHT REFEREE.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The report notes Wyatt Earp is in jail recovering from a gunshot wound while troops guard against reprisals, and that his brother Warren was killed days earlier in Arizona. It then recounts a garbled, largely fictional history of the Earp brothers in Tombstone, including an invented sister named Jessie supposedly married to Ike Clanton.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Wrong

The Times · 22 July 1900 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

cox, Arizona.

AS PRIZE FIGHT REFEREE.

See moreSee less

Wyatt Earp gained a new notoriety at the time he gave decision against Fitzsimmons in the latter's fight with Sharkey in this city. Before he entered the ring as the referee the police made him dliver up his big revolver, and after the fight he went around heeled with two guns, and dared any one to hint that he had made a crooked decision.

Wyatt Earp is the last of the four notorious Earp brothers, who combined in the early days to make Tombstone live up to its name. Virgil and Julian, the first to die, were killed in "gun plays" several years ago. Warren, true to his instincts, had the coroner remove his boots when he was killed a few days ago, and now Wyatt, the survivor, seems to have had a close call from what will be his end.

When the Earp brothers lived in Tombstone they did much toward making it a thrilling place of residence, for the four brothers were much in evidence thereabouts in the early 80's. In 1883, however, the community decided it had had enough of the quartette, and a solid front, made up of six-shooters and Winchesters, was presented to them. So they left Tombstone and migrated to the Gunnison country. Finally they were run out of the Gunnison, and Wyatt Earp migrated to California, while Warren clung to his native heath in Arizona.

They had a sister, Jessie, too, who lived with them in Tombstone. She was known as the virtuous one of the family, Virgil as the oldest, Wyatt as the wisest, Julian as the bravest and Warren as the most foolhardy. Virgil was killed in Tombstone and Julian in the Gunnison.

THRILLING FAMILY TRAGEDY.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This 1900 feature recalls the Earp brothers' reputation as deadly gunfighters in Tombstone, claiming Wyatt killed ten men and describing the family's alleged involvement in stage robbery alongside Doc Holliday, opposed by Sheriff Behan's 'rustler' faction. It also notes Wyatt's later career as a Seattle gambling house proprietor and boxing referee before joining the Nome gold rush.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 22 July 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

News has come that Virgil Earp, of the Earp brothers, was killed in a saloon at Wilcox, Ariz., July 7, making the third of that famous or rather notorious quartette to meet death in his ordinary foot gear, after the traditional manner of the Western bad man. And a bad man was Virgil Earp. So were all the other Earps. It was their chosen profession and they were all living exemplifications of the old adage that informs the ambitious youth that there is room at the top. For of the top rung of the ladder of this chosen profession of theirs they held full possession. Not always undisputed possession, it is true, but those who were disposed to argue the point usually came to grief in the form of the manner of death above mentioned.

There were seven of the Earps, the best known of whom were Virgil, Wyatt, Warren and Julian, forming the quartette referred to. All of them were gunfighters and men of prompt and bitter courage. Wyatt Earp is credited with ten men, one of them his own brother-in-law. Every one of the Earps had killed his men--not man--and were famed in Tombstone, Ariz., and the Cochise country round about as qualified to pull and make a center shot in less than one-tenth of a second. They all filed the sights from their guns and shot by instinct rather than by aim. Triggers were a superfluous piece of mechanism and all were addicted to the process, in a fight, technically known as "fanning" their guns. By this means a man with a brace of Colts six-shooters becomes for the moment an animated machine gun.

See moreSee less

The one of the Earps best known in Seattle was Wyatt, who refereed the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. His connection with Seattle centers in the fact that not long ago he was the proprietor of the gambling house at 111 South Second. He was carried along by the Nome rush, however, and is now engaged in similar pursuits in that city.

Hot Times in Tombstone.

In the early eighties the Earp family abode at Tombstone, Ariz., and did much toward making that hamlet a thrilling place of residence.

There were then two factions at Tombstone, Virgil and Wyatt Earp led one--the stage robbers; Johnny Behan, Ike Clauton and Jack Ringo, led the other--the rustlers. The stage robbers were in politics Republican and stood up stages and plundered express companies for a livelihood. The rustlers were Democrats, and devoted themselves to cattle stealing, murder, whisky and faro bank as steady pursuits. In these days Johnny Behan was sheriff of Cochise county and Virgil Earp was the marshal of Tombstone. Behan, as stated, belonged to the cow-thief Democracy party, while Earp robbed stages and voted with the Republicans.

Barshell Williams was then Wells Fargo agent at Tombstone, and when big money went out on the stage he tipped it off to

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This 1900 article presents a highly embellished, largely fabricated narrative of gunfights in Tombstone, including a theater shootout, a siege, and multiple invented deaths of Earp family members. It blends real figures like Wyatt Earp, Doc Holliday, and Ike Clanton with fictional events like a 'Julian Earp' being killed and Earp's sister eloping with Clanton.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 22 July 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Enthusiastic Shooting.

Much good and enthusiastic shooting ensued. Twelve men were killed and wounded; none of the Earps, however. Williams, the confederate of Virgil and Wyatt Earp in the stage robbing, was badly shot up. He expected to die, and confessed. At this Wyatt Earp and his three brothers, with others of their gang, fortified themselves in an old doby house on the edge of Tombstone. Behan and the cow thieves put in what time they could spare from faro bank and theft to besieging them. The siege was a stand-off. At last Warren Earp--the foolhardy one--heeled himself and came down from the doby fortress to play faro bank. He had just set a stack of blues on the king open when a cow thief listlessly put a bullet through his head.

See moreSee less

Thus died the first of the Earps. There was more fighting then, and at last the Earps were driven out of Tombstone and into the Gunnison. Their sister Jessy went with them. Ike Clauton, one of the Democrats and cow thieves, followed them to Colorado and eloped with Jessy. This was too much for the Republican stage-robbing blood of Wyatt Earp and his brothers. They pursued. They ran Clauton and his bride into a mine tunnel. The miners interfered. There must be fair play. Ike Clauton offered to fight Virgil, Wyatt or Julian Earp for their sister. Julian took it up. The two shot it out with pistols, and Julian was killed.

Thus died the second Earp. Ike Clauton and Jessy, nee Earp, lived in peace two years. Then Wyatt Earp, Virgil Earp and Curley Bill crossed up with Clauton, and there was another feast of guns. Clauton was killed, and took with him Curley Bill to the happy hunting grounds. Wyatt Earp, when the smoke blew away, was also full of well made bullet holes, but he got well.

The Third Earp Goes.

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

Warren Earp, youngest of the Earp brothers, was reported shot dead by John Boyett at Willcox, Arizona. The report attributes the shooting to long-standing ill feeling from a feud between the Earps and cattle rustlers.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: The Colfax Gazette, 20 July 1900, The Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 20 July 1900, The Kootenai Herald, 21 July 1900, The Times, 22 July 1900.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 25 July 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Crop Failure in Chile. Owing to continuous rains in Chile wheat sowing is impossible and the next crop will be very scarce. Prices are very high, but there is no stock on hand.

Warren Earp Shot Dead. Warren Earp, the youngest of the famous family of border desperadoes, whose names were once the terror of Tombstone, who was shot dead by John Boyett at Wilcox, Ariz. There had been ill feeling between Earp and Boyett for years growing out of a feud between the Earp boys and the cattle rustlers.

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

A brief news item states that it is rumored Wyatt Earp, described as a famous gambler, has been killed at Nome, Alaska. No further details or confirmation are given.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 27 July 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

J. W. Yerkes has been nominated for Governor by Kentucky Republicans.

Portland exporters are suing for the return of duties collected at Manila.

See moreSee less

The Goebel law will be made the issue of the campaign in Kentucky this fall.

The anti-Imperialists may put a third ticket in the field and nominate Dewey.

The Populists and Democrats of South Dakota have nominated a fusion ticket.

A crucible steel trust has been organized in Pittsburg with a capital of $50,000,000.

It is rumored that Wyatt Earp, the famous gambler, has been killed at Nome.

Andrew Carnegie refuses to give $50,000 towards the restoration of the Acropolis.

Major J. C. Caperton, a prominent Kentuckian, died at Chicago of heart failure.

Albert B. White has been nominated for Governor by the West Virginia Republicans.

Dr. John Fryer of Berkeley may remain in China, where he is a high mandarin.

Coomassie has been relieved by the column under command of Col. Willcocks.

A $4,500 bulldog owned by Frank Croker, son of the Tammany boss, has been stolen.

Fifteen persons are known to have perished in a cloudburst at Coleman, Texas.

The rebellion in Colombia continues but Panama is held by the Government troops.

George Gould wants to run for Congress on the Republican ticket in New Jersey.

European monarchs are not going to the French fair though the Shah may

See the clipping

Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah

This passage recounts a tense shootout involving Boyett and a man named Earp, ending with a fatal shot through the heart. It reflects back on the Earp brothers' reputation from their Tombstone days as a lead-in to the story.

Deseret Evening News · 28 July 1900 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

the cattle rustlers, of whom Boyett was one. One day last week Earp walked into a saloon where Boyett was drinking with some of his cattle rustling friends.

"There's my gun, cur!" yelled Earp, tossing his colt 45 into the air and deftly catching it again; "where's yours?"

See moreSee less

"Ain't got it," was Boyett's reply.

"Go an' get it then," said "Wicked

See the clipping

Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah

This sensationalized account claims the four Earp brothers (Wyatt, Virgil, Julian, Warren) ruled Tombstone through gunplay until the town tired of them, after which they drifted to Gunnison and California. It alleges Virgil was killed in Tombstone, Julian died in Gunnison killing a cattle thief named Clanton, and that Warren and Wyatt killed Clanton to avenge their sister's marriage.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Deseret Evening News · 28 July 1900 · page 16

When the Xarp Ja > carp brothrs brother b th lived In InTombatone InTombetolM InTombstone Tombstone they the did fd much toward mak making maleIII ¬ lug III It a thrilling place of reUdenoe for forthe torthe fort t the e tour brother were re much In evi evidence evidence vl vl4ene ¬ dence thereabouts In the early 11 M 10e In InIMS tnWI influ flu however the th community tommun decided decidedIt 4ecl 4eclIt It had had enough of tlw quartette and anda nd ndtolld a wild front made up of 1xahooterf 1xahooterfand bootn bootnnd and nd Wlnrheatera was preawted pre sated to tothem tothem tothem them So they th left Tombetnaa tad d ml mlgrated mirated mlgrated grated rated to Qunnlaon aunty OIunt Finally Finallythey Ilnallthy PInIlythey they were run out of the Uunnlaon and andWyatt aDdWyatt andWyatt Wyatt Earp migrated to California Californiawhile Calltornla1Ihlle qalttornlawhile while Warren clung chIt to hu native nativeheath natlvheth nativeheath heath In Arizona ArlionaThey ArllO ArizonaThey L LTh They Th had a lIter Jennie too who wholived whOlived wholived lived with them In Trimbatnt She Bhewa Shewa Shewas wa was known a the virtuous pa oat of thefamily the thefamily thelamll family Virgil VI I M the oldent Wtt Wttthe an anthe uthe the wuett Julian JuU u a the tll br bfavest ve t and andWarren andWarren andWarren Warren aa I the moat foolhardy foolh Virgil Virgilwa Vlrtw Virgilsou wa w killed In Tombstone TomlN lOlll and Julian Julian In Inthe Inth n nthe the th Qunnlaon QunnlaonIke Ike Ctautoa a famous number > r of ofthe ofthl ofthe the cattle thieve the opposition fac faction factlon factlon ¬ tlon to the stage ta robbers In Tombstone Tombctonemarried Tomb Tombstonemarried lonel lonelmarried married Jessie J larD Then be f tuno tunoIt ftund ftundit und undIt i It neceuary nl < to kill her brother bl tbr Julian Julianand Jllilftnand Julianand and then Warren and Wyatt found itnecesaary It Unecetaary ItDllel necetaary Dllel to kill Clauton and make maketheir mllkeIhelr maketheir their charming chllrml tleter a widow For ForJeiale FIFJle ForJe5le Jeiale had dared to marry a man with withwhom withwhllm withwhom whom her brother had a feud and she IIhemuet shemust he hemuet muet tw b disciplined disciplinedAll dl lplined lplinedAll All of the Karp were re gun fighter nghtcrefor fighterMr < < hlerl hlerlfor for the love of It and Dd men of prompt promptcourage prllmptcour prumptcourage courage cour and ad bitter bitt revenge eq Each of ofthem ofthcm ofthem them na hal killed numerous mm Wyatt WyattIt It I credited rectlte with Ith tn and Warren with withfully withtullY withfully fully aa many maa It used to be said In Inthe Inthe inthe the fochle O hl countiy round about abnntTombitone aboutTombtone aboutTombstone Tombstone that any an of the Karp was WAIfit wulit waslit lit to pull and center a shot In n less leMUian Ie IeUIn lessthan than onetenth of a second tecondIn If < Ond OndIn

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A New Orleans Times-Democrat piece recalls the Earp brothers' reputation in old Tombstone, claiming Warren Earp was just killed at Wilcox and Wyatt seriously wounded at Cape Nome. It also recounts Doc Holliday's role as the Earps' associate and his death from tuberculosis.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 30 July 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Profesional Desperadoes. New Orleans Times-Democrat. "Within the last few weeks," said a citizen who lived in the West when it was wild and woolly, "two once famous 'bad men' have been put out of action. Warren Earp was killed at Wilcox, Ariz., and his brother Wyatt was seriously wounded at Cape Nome. Both were shot by 'tenderfeet' whom they were trying to bully. There were originally four brothers in the Earp family," continued the speaker, "and a quarter of a century ago the whole frontier echoed of their prowess. The first time I ever saw them was at Tombstone, Ariz.

See moreSee less

They were standing quietly on a street corner, and I was surprised when somebody told me that they were notorious stage robbers. It seemed strange that no effort should be made to arrest them, but I soon discovered that public sentiment was divided as to the moral turpitude of robbing stages. A good many people regarded the business as an infant industry that ought to be protected; and when the Earps were around, that view was the only one openly expressed. It seems incredible, but the brothers kept Tombstone, which was a large and important town, abjectly terrorized for over a year. Then two were killed and the spell was broken. Their principle coadjutor, during their reign, was 'Doc' Holliday, a tall, lank, dreamy-looking individual from Valdosta, Ga. He was formerly a dentist, but was more expert at pulling guns than he was at pulling teeth, although his enemies said the results were about equally fatal. Strange to say, he died quietly of tuberculosis in Colorado. The Earp brothers all looked very much alike. They were big, raw-boned men, with mild blue eyes and long, tawny mustaches of the dragoon brand. They drawled in their speech, and, to give them full credit for the one decent quality they possessed, they were certainly insensible to fear. Wyatt Earp, as the sporting fraternity will remember, earned an unsavory reputation as the referee of the crooked Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in 'Frisco. According to advices from Nome, he will lose his right arm, which ends his career as a gun virtuoso. He and his brother Warren were almost the sole survivors of the tribe of professional desperadoes."

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A nostalgic, exaggerated account claims the Earp brothers terrorized Tombstone for over a year as notorious stage robbers with Doc Holliday as their accomplice, until two were killed and 'the spell was broken.' It also claims Wyatt Earp, tainted by the fixed Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, is reported from Nome to be losing his right arm.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 11 days later.

Wrong

The Indianapolis Journal · 30 July 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Professional Desperadoes.

New Orleans Times-Democrat.

See moreSee less

"Within the last few weeks," said a citizen who lived in the West when it was wild and woolly, "two once famous 'bad men' have been put out of action. Warren Earp was killed at Wilcox, Ariz., and his brother Wyatt was seriously wounded at Cape Nome. Both were shot by 'tenderfeet' whom they were trying to bully. There were originally four brothers in the Earp family," continued the speaker, "and a quarter of a century ago the whole frontier echoed of their prowess. The first time I ever saw them was at Tombstone, Ariz. They were standing quietly on a street corner, and I was surprised when somebody told me that they were notorious stage robbers. It seemed strange that no effort should be made to arrest them, but I soon discovered that public sentiment was divided as to the moral turpitude of robbing stages. A good many people regarded the business as an infant industry that ought to be protected; and when the Earps were around, that view was the only one openly expressed. It seems incredible, but the brothers kept Tombstone, which was a large and important town, abjectly terrorized for over a year. Then two were killed and the spell was broken. Their principle coadjutor, during their reign, was 'Doc' Holliday, a tall, lank, dreamy-looking individual from Valdosta, Ga. He was formerly a dentist, but was more expert at pulling guns than he was at pulling teeth, although his enemies said the results were about equally fatal. Strange to say, he died quietly of tuberculosis in Colorado. The Earp brothers all looked very much alike. They were big, raw-boned men, with mild blue eyes and long, tawny mustaches of the dragoon brand. They drawled in their speech, and, to give them full credit for the one decent quality they possessed, they were certainly insensible to fear. Wyatt Earp, as the sporting fraternity will remember, earned an unsavory reputation as the referee of the crooked Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight in 'Frisco. According to advices from Nome, he will lose his right arm, which ends his career as a gun virtuoso. He and his brother Warren were almost the sole survivors of the tribe of professional desperadoes."

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page