As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

August 1900

23 articles

Cottonwood Report · Cottonwood, Idaho

The dispatch claims Wyatt Earp, who had refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons boxing match, was shot recently in the saloon he ran at Cape Nome. It notes that at last accounts he was still alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 7 days later.

Wrong

Cottonwood Report · 3 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp Shot at Nome. San Francisco, July 16.—News has been received from Cape Nome that Wyatt Earp, who refereed the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight, and gave the decision to Sharkey on a foul, was shot recently in the saloon which he is running at Nome. At last accounts Earp was still alive.

See the clipping

Daily Inter Mountain · Butte, Mont.

The item reports that gunfighter Wyatt Earp, now running a saloon and gambling house at Cape Nome, was shot in the arm by a visitor on June 30. It adds that military authorities jailed Earp while releasing the shooter, since the shooting appeared to be in self-defense.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 8 days earlier.

Daily Inter Mountain · 4 August 1900 · page 16 · transcribed from the page image

Wyatt Earp, the famous Arizona gun fighter, who stole a fight from Fitzsimmons in San Francisco when Bob put Tom Sharkey where he belonged, is now at Cape Nome, and on June 30 was shot in the arm by a visitor to his saloon and gambling house. In addition to this, the military authorities threw Earp in jail and let the other fellow go, as it was

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

A 1900 sports article previewing a Ruhlin-Fitzsimmons fight references the earlier controversial Sharkey-Fitzsimmons bout, describing Wyatt Earp as the 'notorious' referee who manipulated the decision. It characterizes Earp as refereeing 'for revenue only,' implying corruption in that earlier contest.

The Saint Paul Globe · 5 August 1900 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

RUHLIN'S DIFFICULT TASK. Because Gus Ruhlin administered a clean defeat to Tom Sharkey it does not follow that he can master the hard-hitting Cornishman. Fitzsimmons has lost but one fight in his career in the ring—barring the "barney" with Jim Hall, in his early days. The decision given to Sharkey over Fitzsimmons has never been regarded as meaning more than a plot to defeat the Cornishman in a game in which he was a novice—ably manipulated by the notorious Wyatt Earp, who was in the business of refereeing for revenue only.

See moreSee less

Jim Jeffries was the victor in the battle for the championship in which he and Fitzsimmons met, and his victory was clean and unquestionable. Yet that cuts little figure in the Fitzsimmons-Ruhlin match. Jeffries has also defeated Sharkey, and Ruhlin is no better off from a record standpoint than is the champion. And as for Ruhlin, he has suffered far more defeats than have many of the most promising heavyweights now clamoring for a shy at the belt. He is big and strong—but so is Dunkhorst, and so was Maher when he met Fitzsimmons, and yet Fitz made them look like selling platers in a stake race. Ruhlin has the task of his career before him, and should he win will stand out as one of the greatest of the big boxers.

See the clipping

Decorah-Posten · Decorah, Iowa

A Danish newspaper reports that Warren Earp, youngest of the notorious Earp brothers, was shot dead in an Arizona saloon by John Boyett after a long-running feud between the Earps' stagecoach-robbing gang and cattle rustlers. It recounts a tense earlier confrontation where Warren threatened Boyett, and describes the fatal shootout in detail, also noting Wyatt Earp's gambling business in San Francisco and his past refereeing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Decorah-Posten · 7 August 1900 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Fire Brødre. Warren Earp skudt i en Saloon i Arizona. To Brødre dræbt før. Forvovne Brande. Skudt ihjel i en Saloon i Arizona.

Julian havde bidt i Græsset paa samme Maade for flere Aar siden. Kun en af den berygtede Bande Brødre, som levede af at plyndre Diligencer, lever. Det er Wyat Earp, som var Opmand ved Nævekampen mellem Fitzsimmons og Sharkey den 3die December 1896. Han driver for Tiden det fæleste Gamblinghus i 'Frisco.

Den Mand, som pumpede Warren Earps Krop fuld med Bly i Wilcox for nogle Dage siden, var John Boyett som i flere Maaneder havde været Stive for Earps Spydigheder. Boyett

See the clipping

Decorah-Posten · Decorah, Iowa

This Scandinavian-language report describes the shooting death of Warren Earp by a cowboy named Boyett after a long feud, framed as part of ongoing warfare between the Earps and cattle rustlers. It adds wildly fictionalized backstory, including invented siblings Julian and Jessie Earp, claiming Virgil was killed in Tombstone and that Ike Clanton married and later had to be killed by the Earps.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Decorah-Posten · 7 August 1900 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

"Aa —" bemærkede Mr. Earp, idet han sprang frem. Boyetts Pistol knaldede, og den tredie Earpbroder faldt, skudt i Hjertet.

Farligt i Tombstone.

See the clipping

Decorah-Posten · Decorah, Iowa

This sensational Danish account claims the Earp brothers themselves led a gang of stagecoach robbers in Tombstone, opposed by Ike Clanton's cattle-thief faction, and invents a tale of Clanton marrying sister Jessie Earp before being killed in a family feud. It portrays the famous gunfights as internal family vendettas and criminal enterprise rather than law enforcement.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Decorah-Posten · 7 August 1900 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Diegh blev dræbt i Tombstone og Julian i Gunnison.

Ike Clauton, et navnkundigt Medlem af Kvægtyvene, som var Diligenceplyndernes Oppositionsparti i Tombstone, ægtede Jessie Earp. Saa fandt han det nødvendigt at dræbe hendes Bror Julian, og saa fandt Warren og Wyat det nødvendigt at dræbe Clauton og gjøre sin fortryllende Søster til Enke. Thi Jessie havde fordristet sig til at ægte en Mand, med hvem hendes Brødre laa i Feide, og hun maatte straffes.

See moreSee less

Alle Earpbrødrene brugte Pistoler, fordi det morede dem; de var modige og hævngjerrige. Hver af dem dræbte mange Mennesker. Man sagde i Cochise County rundt omkring Tombstone, at hver af Earpbrødrene kunde trække Revolveren og skyde i mindre end et Tiendedels Sekund.

I de tidlige Ottiaar, medens Virgil og Wyat Earp anførte Tombstones Diligenceplyndrere, anførte Ike Clauton, Johnny Behan og Jack Ringo Kvægtyvene. Diligenceplyndrerne var Republikanere og Kvægtyvene Demokrater. Earpbrødrene dræbte Folk for Adspredelse og Moros Skyld og plyndrede Diligencer for at leve; for der var ingen Penge i Mord. Tyvene søgte sin Tidsfordriv omtrent paa samme Maade; men de spenderede mere Tid paa Whisky og Farobank.

Politiske Embeder havde ogsaa sine Tillokkelser for de to Faktioner. Johnny Behan var demokratisk Sheriff af Cochise County, og Virgil Earp var republikansk Marshal i Tombstone. Og hver Side husvalede den anden med mangt et Mord.

Virgil Earp havde et Kompaniskab med Barschel Williams, som den

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

John Farley, back from a three-month trip to Nome, gives an interview about mining conditions, water shortages, and local business, and explicitly states that the report of Wyatt Earp being shot at Nome is not true. He also praises the soldiers' policing of the town.

CorrectionThis set right 7 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 15 July 1900, The Indianapolis Journal, 30 July 1900, The Indianapolis Journal, 30 July 1900, Cottonwood Report, 3 August 1900, Decorah-Posten, 7 August 1900, Decorah-Posten, 7 August 1900, Decorah-Posten, 7 August 1900.

The San Francisco Call · 10 August 1900 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

ing piles of money. The report that Wyatt Earp was shot at Nome is not true. The police service by the soldiers is excellent. General Randall is doing splendid work. The town is not under martial law, but the streets are patrolled at night by the soldiers with fixed bayonets. "The Hobbs boys have just started a brewery and are doing well. I have as the fruits of my trip an interest in a claim from which I expect good results. The sanitary condition of the town is fair, but if anybody is taken with an illness he is almost sure to die.

See moreSee less

Whether I shall return to Nome or not is a hard matter to decide." John Farley was accompanied back on his trip by Charlie Asher, the well-known sporting man, who corroborates Farley's statements.

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky.

This boxing news roundup covers an upcoming Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight and mentions that Fitzsimmons has a grudge after losing to the Sharkey-Earp combination in San Francisco. Other items include boxer Reddy Hamilton defending his decision not to fight Tom Williams over money concerns.

The Courier-Journal · 20 August 1900 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

BIG FIGHT FOR NEXT FRIDAY

Fight Date Changed Again. New York, Aug. 19.—The management of the Seaside Athletic Club has again changed the date of the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight. The date originally set for the contest was August 24, but on account of the great crowd that would be drawn to the island on the 25th to see the Futurity run at the Sheepshead Bay racetrack, the management, with a veiw to obtaining an increased attendance, made the date of the bout Saturday, August 26. Tom O'Rourke, acting for the Seaside Athletic Club, announces that in compliance with a general request the fight will take place on the original date, Friday, August 24.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The article previews the upcoming Fitzsimmons-Sharkey contest, noting Fitzsimmons' complaints that Wyatt Earp, as referee of their earlier California fight, unfairly awarded the bout to Sharkey on a foul. Fitzsimmons expresses confidence he can beat Sharkey and plans to challenge Jeffries or the Corbett-McCoy winner afterward.

The San Francisco Call · 23 August 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

of distance and inability to block blows successfully. While the increase in Fitzsimmons' speed has been marked, it would be an exaggeration to say that he is as fast with his hands and on his feet as he ever was. He believes he can beat any heavyweight in the world. Fitzsimmons says that he polished off Sharkey when he got ready in their battle in California, but owing to unfairness on the part of Wyatt Earp, the referee, he was not credited with victory. Earp awarded the bout to Sharkey on a foul.

As matters stand to-day Sharkey feels that he has the best of things. His knowledge of the game has increased greatly since he fought Fitzsimmons. His hitting power is also greater, and altogether he is much more active than his rival is likely to be on Friday night.

See moreSee less

"When I'm feeling all right," said Fitzsimmons to a Call correspondent, "I never give my weight a thought. If I feel well I know my hitting power is there and my speed also. Sharkey may have ten or twenty pounds the best of it in weight, but that advantage gives me no concern. I am confident that I can beat him just as easily as if I weighed 200 pounds. After I dispose of Sharkey I will probably arrange a contest with Jeffries or the winner of the McCoy-Corbett bout. If Corbett wins over McCoy he can have first call, otherwise I will take on Jeffries for the championship. I give Corbett preference because he has all along claimed that I beat him through foul means at Carson. Some people think I'm an old fellow and that Corbett would have the best of it if we were to meet now. I can beat Corbett at any old age, and if he doubts it, let him step up to the captain's office and sign articles for a fight with me."

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

Previewing the Fitzsimmons-Sharkey rematch, the paper recaps their earlier famous bout in California, noting Fitzsimmons' claim that he had defeated Sharkey but was denied the win due to unfairness by referee Wyatt Earp, who awarded the fight to Sharkey on a foul. The piece focuses mainly on the fighters' current conditioning and prospects for the new bout.

The Evening Times · 23 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

PUGILISTS IN FINE SHAPE

Concerned Over the Sailor's Advantage in Weight--Likely to Make a Match With Corbett, if He Wins.

NEW YORK, Aug. 23.--Judging from the splendid work "Bob" Fitzsimmons had been doing in practice at his training quarters in Bergen Beach for his battle with "Tom" Sharkey at Coney Is'and tomorrow night, the former heavyweight champion will take a lot of beating when he meets the sailor. Every conceivable form of exercise conducive to strength and fitting one thoroughly for a contest of skill and endurance has been practiced by Fitzsimmons since he has been in training.

See moreSee less

As a result, the Australian looks more sturdy than when he fought Ruhlin. That battle appears to have done the former heavyweight champion a lot of good. In his practice bouts with "Bob" Armstrong and George Dawson he has shown more speed and better judgment in delivering and blocking blows than marked his efforts in the early part of the battle with the "Akron Giant." There were periods during the Ruhlin-Fitzsimmons contest when "Lanky Bob" caused his backers a lot of uneasiness, due to lack of judgment of distance and inability to block blows successfully.

While the increase in Fitzsimmons' speed has been very marked, it would be an exaggeration to say that he is as fast with his hands and on his feet as he ever was. He believes that he can beat any heavyweight in the world. Fitzsimmons says that he polished off Sharkey when he got ready in their battle in California, but owing to unfairness on the part of Wyatt Earp, the referee, he was not credited with a victory. Earp awarded the bout to Sharkey on a foul.

At the time Fitzsimmons and the sailor had their famous battle Fitzsimmons was at the zenith of his career as a pugilist, and it was shortly after this contest that he won the championship of the world from Corbett at Carson City. While Fitzsimmons had a thorough knowledge of all the tricks of the prize ring, Sharkey only had a crude idea of the elementary principles. In spite of his deficient knowledge of the finer points of sparring and ring generalship the sailor kept Fitzsimmons puzzled for a considerable period.

As matters stand today Sharkey feels that he has the best of things. His knowledge of the game has increased greatly since he fought Fitzsimmons. His hitting power is also greater, and altogether he is much more active than his rival is likely to be tomorrow night.

Fitzsimmons has aged considerably, and, while he won a victory over Ruhlin, he is far from being as quick a man as in his championship days, and some persons are taking the short end of the wagers, believing that if the battle tomorrow night is fought on the same lines as the Ruhlin-Fitzsimmons contest Sharkey will win. One thing in Sharkey's favor is that he is absolutely fearless. He is always ready to take a blow in order to land one.

Fitzsimmons trains hard every day. Yesterday the Australian put in a hard days work. It consisted of bag punching, tugging and wrestling with his pet pony and

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

This article previews a 1900 Fitzsimmons-Sharkey boxing rematch at Coney Island, noting neither man holds the championship since both have lost to Jeffries. It recalls their 1896 San Francisco bout where referee Wyatt Earp controversially awarded Sharkey the win on a foul despite Fitzsimmons having him nearly beaten.

The Evening Times · 24 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

NEW YORK, Aug. 24.—Ex-Champion of the World Robert Fitzsimmons and Thomas Sharkey, who gave Champion James J. Jeffries a hard fight, will meet tonight, before the Seaside Sporting Club at Coney Island, in what promises to be one of the fiercest ring battles of recent years. The bout is scheduled to go twenty-five rounds.

It will not be for the championship, as that is held by Jeffries, who has defeated both men. It will not be the first time either that Fitzsimmons and Sharkey have met in the ring. On December 2, 1896, they fought in San Francisco.

See moreSee less

Sharkey was beaten to helplessness and was practically out, but to the surprise of the crowd, Wyatt Earp, the referee, insisted upon by Sharkey and his friends, awarded the victory to Sharkey on an alleged foul, and Fitzsimmons lost the $10,000 purse, which it was generally admitted belonged to him by right.

At that time Fitzsimmons was at the zenith of his career as a pugilist, and it was shortly after this contest that he won the championship of the world from Corbett at Carson City.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The article recalls how referee Wyatt Earp awarded Tom Sharkey the win over Bob Fitzsimmons on a disputed foul in their 1896 San Francisco bout, costing Fitzsimmons a large purse. It then shifts to describe both men's current training camps ahead of a new upcoming fight.

The Evening Times · 24 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

At that time Fitzsimmons was at the zenith of his career as a pugilist, and it was shortly after this contest that he won the championship of the world from Corbett at Carson City. Both men are said to be in fine condition. Fitzsimmons has been training hard at Bergen Beach. His working partners are "Bob" Armstrong, Jeff Thorne, Prof.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

Previewing a new Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout in 1900, the article recalls their earlier clash in San Francisco where referee Wyatt Earp awarded Sharkey the win on a disputed foul claim, costing Fitzsimmons a $10,000 purse many felt he deserved. It notes this happened shortly before Fitzsimmons won the world title from Corbett.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Times · 24 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

READY FOR THE BATTLE

Sharkey has been training at Sheepshead Bay. He has five assistants, who box with him. "Matty" Matthews, welterweight, is his principal partner at this work. His meals are prepared by his sister, who recently arrived from Ireland.

The betting on the fight is at odds of 2 to 1 on Fitzsimmons. This is doubtless largely due to the relative showing of the two men against "Gus" Ruhlin, who defeated Sharkey in a decisive way, only to be badly beaten by Fitz in their recent battle.

See moreSee less

Quiet prevailed in the camps of the two men this morning. Fitzsimmons, at his home in Bergen Beach, arose at his usual hour, and after a short sprint over the muddy road near his home was given a rub-down by his trainers. Then he partook of his breakfast, which consisted of soft-boiled eggs, chops, and coffee. After reading the morning papers he walked to gymnasium and punched the bag for fifteen minutes. He was then given another rub-down. The lanky pugilist will sleep the greater part of the afternoon, and at about 7 o'clock will be driven to Coney Island. He will rest at Ben Cohen's Hotel until the time for him to enter the ring.

Sharkey was satisfied to loaf about his house at Sheepshead Bay. He was up as early as usual, and had eaten his breakfast when a reporter called. He was given a rub-down and then took a few wallops at the punching bag.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

This report previews the upcoming Fitzsimmons-Sharkey bout, recalling an earlier match where Wyatt Earp, as referee, awarded Sharkey a disputed victory on a foul claim, costing Fitzsimmons a $10,000 purse. It also details both fighters' training routines and conditioning ahead of the new fight.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Times · 24 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

READY FOR THE BATTLE

Bay. He has five assistants, who box with him. "Matty" Matthews, welterweight, is his principal partner at this work. His meals are prepared by his sister, who recently arrived from Ireland.

The betting on the fight is at odds of 2 to 1 on Fitzsimmons. This is doubtless largely due to the relative showing of the two men against "Gus" Ruhlin, who defeated Sharkey in a decisive way, only to be badly beaten by Fitz in their recent battle.

See moreSee less

Quiet prevailed in the camps of the two men this morning. Fitzsimmons, at his home in Bergen Beach, arose at his usual hour, and after a short sprint over the muddy road near his home was given a rub-down by his trainers. Then he partook of his breakfast, which consisted of soft-boiled eggs, chops, and coffee. After reading the morning papers he walked to gymnasium and punched the bag for fifteen minutes. He was then given another rub-down. The lanky pugilist will sleep the greater part of the afternoon, and at about 7 o'clock will be driven to Coney Island. He will rest at Ben Cohen's Hotel until the time for him to enter the ring.

Sharkey was satisfied to loaf about his house at Sheepshead Bay. He was up as early as usual, and had eaten his breakfast when a reporter called. He was given a rub-down and then took a few wallops at the punching bag.

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

On the eve of a new Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight, a sportswriter recalls the controversial 1896 San Francisco bout where Wyatt Earp served as referee amid objections from Fitzsimmons' camp. The piece describes Earp being disarmed by police before entering the ring and presiding over Fitzsimmons' apparent knockout victory.

The St. Louis Republic · 24 August 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

BIG MEN WILL BATTLE

stand sullenly in their corners. Martin Julian is tearing frantically around the resined platform, registering objections to Wyatt Earp, acting as referee. Julian says that he has "heard things" during the day.

The other side insists, and Fitzsimmons and Julian are talked into "taking a chance." A tall man, with a drooping mus-

See the clipping

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

The article recounts the controversial 1896 prize fight where Wyatt Earp served as referee between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey, which ended with Sharkey awarded the win on a foul despite Fitzsimmons appearing to land a finishing blow. It previews an upcoming rematch between the two fighters, discussing their changed fortunes since that disputed bout.

The St. Louis Republic · 24 August 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

seems to land in the pit of the stomach. The Sailor is writhing on the floor. "Fitzsimmons wins!" is wafted to the multitude on the street, and is quickly followed by the correction, "Sharkey wins on a foul!"

Then the aftermath. Sharkey got the purse and Fitzsimmons the sympathy which is always extended to a man who is believed to be the victim of a rascally plot.

See moreSee less

May Be a Grudge Fight.

See the clipping

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

Mrs. L.B. Law, daughter of Virgil Earp, denies published reports that all the Earp brothers have died. She states Wyatt is in Nome, Jim is in San Francisco, and Virgil is alive in Kirkland, Arizona Territory.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 25 August 1900 · page 11

SOME OF FAMOUS FAMILY OF ARIZONA EARPS LIVING

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

The article recaps the Earp-Cowboy feud, describing a shootout in a theater between the Earp faction and the McLaury/Clanton brothers where twelve men were supposedly killed or wounded. It also mentions the wounding of Wells-Fargo agent Frank Marshall and later violence against Virgil Earp, before noting the Earps eventually left Arizona for California.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 25 August 1900 · page 11

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands

A newspaper feature recounts the Tombstone feud as told by Virgil Earp's daughter, who only met her father after seeing a newspaper account of the feud. It describes Virgil as city marshal, the stage robbery that triggered Earp suspicions, and anecdotal violence of frontier justice.

The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · 25 August 1900 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

CAUSE O FTHE FEUD. The immediate cause of the Tombstone feud was a stage robbery which the Earp brothers, Virgil as city marshal, Wyatt and Morgan as United States deputy marshals, had suspected

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A newspaper sports report on a new Sharkey fight at Coney Island recalls that referee Wyatt Earp once ruled Sharkey beat Fitzsimmons on a foul years earlier in California. It notes Fitzsimmons had long disputed that result and sought to prove his superiority again.

The Sun · 25 August 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Sensational Climax to the Fistic Battle Between Heavyweights at Coney Island—The Ex-Sailor Floors His Opponent in the First Round, but Grows Too Confident Afterward and Fitz Puts Him Out With a Left Swing on the Jaw—Wretched Management and Long Delays Exasperate the Crowd—Referee and Principals on Strike Until the Guaranteed Money Is Made Good.

Since the time that Referee Wyatt Earp decided that Thomas Sharkey defeated Robert Fitzsimmons on a foul in California several years ago, the Sailor has constantly maintained that he was the Cornishman's master in that encounter, and could again demonstrate his superiority. Last night in the ring of the Seaside Sporting Club at Coney Island, Sharkey, improved as to science and in the best physical condition possible, again had

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

The article reports that Virgil Earp was shot and killed by a cowboy named Boyett in Wilcox, Arizona, becoming the fourth Earp brother to die violently after Morgan and others. It frames the Earp family as notorious frontier figures - gamblers and gunfighters - romanticizing their wild reputation from Tombstone's early days.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 18 days later.

Wrong

The Saint Paul Globe · 27 August 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

HANDSOME VIRGIL, ANOTHER OF THE EARP FAMILY, GOES TO HIS ACCOUNT - PISTOL SHOT FROM COWBOY

A fourth book in the wild, red history of the Earp family was closed in Wilcox, Arizona, last Sunday. Cowboy Boyett wrote "finis" with a pistol shot on the last page of handsome Virgil's record, just as it had been written by Ike Clanton for Julian and by some unknown for Morgan down in Tombstone twenty years ago.

In the early and tumultuous days of Tombstone the Earp boys were more famous than the mines that made the town, says a correspondent of the Philadelphia North American. Their record was written in red with a free hand, and they were admired, hated and feared as heartily and by as many men in the territories as ever were the James boys in old Missouri. Strong, daring, expert with lethal weapons and quick to use them, governing their relations with their fellow men by the simple, primitive code that Kentucky gave to the Southwest, the Earps were an epitome of the life of the frontier a quarter of a century ago, before the railroad carried the East and the ten commandments to the West, blotted out the frontier and brought its romance so near that it lost its lure and revealed its ugly blots and blemishes to the coldly critical eye of the law-abiding states.

See moreSee less

The Earps were the natural product of their time and the raw-edged social conditions of a pioneer community, and they were no worse than most of their fellows—better than many, because in them the qualities of sturdy, vigorous, impulsive manhood were more highly developed.

See the clipping

The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

The article reflects on the Earp brothers as emblematic figures of the vanished frontier, describing them as gamblers and gunfighters who killed men but mostly as law officers enforcing order. It includes a quote from Wyatt Earp himself defending his killings as necessary 'trouble' rather than crime.

The Saint Paul Globe · 27 August 1900 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THEY WERE BAD MEN.

Judged by the code of civilized, sober-minded society, they would not "stack up" very well. They were gamblers, faro dealers and fighters. They might not have been conscious of the impulses which made them seek those places where life was wildest and roughest, but they were in full natural sympathy with him who wrote:

See moreSee less

Oh, for a lodge in the red, red West,

On the crest of a crimson hill,

Where I can paint without restraint

Creation redder still.

The Earps were man killers. Now, that does not mean that they were assassins, murderers in the sense that Holmes was a murderer. But with them, as with most men of the border, there were other things more sacred than human life.

According to their code—the same code that all of us accept without a shiver as perfectly natural when we read "The Three Guardsmen," "A Gentleman of France," the Arthurian tales or any medieval or ancient romance or history—according to that code they were not malefactors when they shot a man in sudden quarrel or in enforcement of law.

As Wyatt Earp, the oldest and now the only living member of the quintette, said to me, complaining somewhat resentfully of the tendency of newspaper writers to speak disapprovingly of his feats of slaughter, "I can't blame myself for any of the trouble I've had."

Killing a man, in frontier parlance, is "trouble."

"I never killed a man unless I had to do it."

See the clipping

Marshall County Independent · Plymouth, Ind.

The report recounts that referee Wyatt Earp once controversially ruled Sharkey the winner over Fitzsimmons on a foul in California years earlier. It then reports that in a rematch at Coney Island, Fitzsimmons decisively defeated Sharkey, who was counted out in the second round.

Marshall County Independent · 31 August 1900 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Earp decided that Thomas Sharkey defeated Robert Fitzsimmons on a foul in California several years ago the sailor has constantly maintained that he was the Cornishman's master in that encounter and could again demonstrate his superiority. Friday night, in the ring of the Seaside Athletic Club at Coney Island. Sharkey, improved as to science and in the best physical condition possible, again had an opportunity to demonstrate to ring followers whether there was truth in his continued statements. To the satisfaction of 5,000 spectators Fitzsimmons showed that in every respect he was the master of Sharkey, who was counted out in the second round, because of his inability to get to his

See the clipping