As the Papers Told It

Wyatt Earp · The full archive

September 1900

12 articles

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The report quotes Wyatt Earp discussing the aftermath of his controversial decision as referee in a prizefight, where he disqualified a fighter and the purse money was tied up by court order before being awarded to the other man. Earp also mentions later financial troubles and a subsequent business venture tied to a Corbett fight in Carson City.

The Evening World · 1 September 1900 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

THE WYATT EARP DECISION.

In spite of the fact that we had the money tied up on an order from the courts, I lost again, however, for another court decided that the referee's decision was final, and of course Sharkey got all of the purse.

See moreSee less

Once again I went on the road and, like my previous experience at this game, I was "done" good and hard. My next sad experience occurred when I fought Jim Corbett at Carson City. I agreed to go into partnership with Dan Stuart, who pulled off the fight, as I

See the clipping

The Courier-Journal · Louisville, Ky. · and 2 other papers

Bob Fitzsimmons gives a first-person account of being swindled out of money throughout his boxing career, including the 1896 fight with Tom Sharkey where referee Wyatt Earp controversially ruled a foul against him despite what Fitzsimmons claims was a clean knockout. He claims to have lost roughly $125,000 total to dishonest managers and promoters over his career.

The Courier-Journal · 3 September 1900 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

SWINDLED BY MANAGERS

"In December, 1896, I suffered my second swindle. This happened in San Francisco during my fight with Tom Sharkey. I fought the sailor for a purse of $10,000, winner to take all. Well, I won fairly from Sharkey by knocking him out with a punch in the stomach. But the referee, Wyatt Earp, decided against me by declaring that I had fouled the sailor.

"In spite of the fact that we had the money tied up on an order from the courts, I lost again, however, for another court decided that the referee's decision was final, and of course Sharkey got all of the purse.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · 3 September 1900
  • The Saint Paul Globe · St. Paul, Minn. · 5 September 1900

The St. Louis Republic · St. Louis, Mo.

Boxer Bob Fitzsimmons recounts his career of financial swindles by managers, including the 1896 San Francisco fight against Tom Sharkey where he claims he won fairly but referee Wyatt Earp ruled against him. He also comments on the unlikelihood of a Fitzsimmons-Jeffries rematch.

The St. Louis Republic · 3 September 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

fered me.

"In December, 1896, I suffered my second big swindle. This happened in San Francisco during my fight with Tom Sharkey. I fought the Sailor for $10,000, winner to take all. Well, I won, fairly, but Wyatt Earp decided against me.

See moreSee less

"Once again on the road, and, like my previous experience, I was 'done' good and hard. My next sad experience occurred when I fought Corbett at Carson City. I agreed to go into partnership with Dan Stuart, who pulled off the fight, but we lost money and I was compelled to hand over to Stuart the purse of $15,000 I won and also my side bet of $2,500.

"Again I went on the road, but the same hard luck stuck to me, for I was again swindled by my managers.

"After figuring up my losses, I can safe-

See the clipping

The Hawaiian Gazette · Honolulu, Hawaii · and 1 other paper

This report covers a 1900 rematch between Tom Sharkey and Bob Fitzsimmons, noting Sharkey lost by failing to rise after a knockdown in round two. It references back to Wyatt Earp's controversial referee decision years earlier that had given Sharkey a foul-based win over Fitzsimmons in California.

The Hawaiian Gazette · 7 September 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

NO CHANCE FOR SHARKEY. Could not Get on His Feet After Two Rounds.

CONEY ISLAND, August 24.—Since the time that Referee Wyatt Earp decided that Thomas Sharkey defeated Robert Fitzsimmons on a foul in California several years ago the sailor has constantly maintained that he was the Cornishman's master in that encounter and could again demonstrate his superiority. Tonight in the Seaside Sporting Club's ring at Coney Island Sharkey, improved as to science and in the best physical condition possible, again had an opportunity to demonstrate to ring followers whether there was any truth in his continued statements. To the satisfaction of 5,000 spectators Fitz showed in every respect that he wa ssuperior to Sharkey, who was counted out in the second round because of his inability to get to his feet after the ten seconds had been counted by Referee White.

See moreSee less

Gen. E. S. Webb and L. B. Howard, of San Diego, have interested San Francisco capital in the development of the Tempustete iron mines, and an experimental foundry will be built at San Diego. The furnaces will handle all kinds of ores.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Pacific Commercial Advertiser · Honolulu, Hawaiian Islands · 5 September 1900

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A dispatch describing conditions in Nome, Alaska, including claim-jumping, legal disputes over gold claims, disease, and population figures. It notes that an earlier report claiming Wyatt Earp was shot was erroneous, as he had had no serious trouble before the informant left.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 18 days earlier.

Arizona Republican · 14 September 1900 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LIFE IN NOME CITY

ably stay through the winter.

The report that Wyatt Earp was shot was erroneous ,as he had had no serious difficulty up to the time Mr. Bark left. An inquiry regarding religious advantages was made and Mr. Bark said there was one Presbyterian minister preaching in a tent and a Holiness band was also pointing out the straight and narrow path.

See moreSee less

A new strike has recently been reported in the Bluestone district, north and east of Nome.

There was lots of typhoid fever and pneumonia through the summer, though probably not so much as many imagine, from newspaper reports. Pneumonia never bothers a man but two days, however. After that nothing bothers him in this world.

There were probably 30,000 people there at one time during the summer and about 5,000 will spend the winter

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A 1900 article about fake boxing matches in San Francisco references the notorious scheme by Wyatt Earp to rig the Sharkey-Fitzsimmons fight as an established example of ring corruption. The piece argues that since that scandal, boxing fans have repeatedly been duped by fraudulent prize fights.

The San Francisco Call · 14 September 1900 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

The proverb says: "Though you pound a fool in a mortar, yet will not his folly depart from him." The fool that supports the prize ring of these days is surely of that kind. Over and over and over within a time comparatively short have the "sports" of this city been duped by fake fights so raw, so crude and so flagrantly fraudulent that no one could have any pity for the gang that was taken in by them. Since the notorious trick by which Wyatt Earp rigged up a scheme to give Sharkey a victory over Fitzsimmons there have been repeated frauds committed upon the ring patrons of San Francisco, and yet, with the gullibility of true suckers, they were as ready to part with their money on the latest fake as on the first.

No one can have any pity for the dupes of such games, but at the same time it is not right that the fakers should be permitted to ply their fraudulent trade in the city. The police, which of late has been so zealous in fighting against poolrooms and side entrances to saloons, ought to exert some energy in an effort to break up this swindling pug business. It has become as gross an evil as any other of the time, and should be suppressed as promptly as the force of the law can do it.

See moreSee less

An easy remedy against the wrong is available to the municipal authorities. No permit for holding "boxing matches" should be permitted to any except clubs composed of responsible persons and known to be genuine athletic associations. Under proper control and management such sports may be conducted fairly,

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Prompted by Virgil Earp's nomination for Yavapai county sheriff, the paper reprints a New York Sun reminiscence about his Tombstone days. The story recalls Virgil, Frank Carlin, and a young English greenhorn who irritated the local gamblers in boomtown Tombstone.

Arizona Republican · 24 September 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

HE NEEDED TAMALES

lican convention held in Prescott on Saturday, will make timely the following story printed in a recent issue of the New York Sun: "I remember an incident that happened down in Tombstone when Tombstone was in the middle of its whiz and all to the good so far as material prosperity went, said a buyer from the southwest to a Sun reporter. Virgil Earp, who, for all the stories about him was the squarest man of that heap

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A tall-tale style account describes a haughty young Englishman in Tombstone who mistreated locals, including a Chinese cook named Moy Sing, and demanded tamales while bragging about his disdain for the food. Virgil Earp and Frank Carlin witness his behavior at Moy Sing's shack, setting up an apparent comeuppance involving the tamales.

Arizona Republican · 24 September 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

to get the jolt that he soon got. "One afternoon he walked into the feed shack of Moy Sing, as square a Chink as ever wore hair in a plait, and demanded some tamales. He anounced loudly that he'd never tried the miserable trashy things, but that he hadn't found anything else fit for a dog to eat in Tombstone, so that he might as well experiment. He demanded that Moy step lively about getting the tamales ready, and in general he lugged in a lot of personally conducted talk and conduct that sort o' made Virgil Earp and Frank Carlin, who were peaceably partaking of their ham and eggs in the back part of the shack, twist some in their chairs.

See moreSee less

Virgil and Frank looked a long time at the Englishman and then they looked at each other, but they didn't say anything. They just tossed around in their chairs some, as I say, and carved their ham kind o' spitefully, and listened to the young Britisher a-shootin' off his mouthpiece

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

A colorful retrospective tale recounts an incident at Moy Sing's Tombstone tamale stand, where a British visitor insulted the food and Virgil Earp and Frank Carlin took offense on the cook's behalf. The story is told in a folksy, humorous style decades after the supposed events, emphasizing local color rather than hard news.

Arizona Republican · 24 September 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

back of his blouse for his hot tamales.

"Consequently when this young man from the other side took a little nibble at one of the tamales Moy had dished up for him, and sniffed at it, and then deliberately spat out the morsel, at the same time making use of a lot of cuss words bearing on the 'filthiness of the confounded things,' the warm blood of Earp and Carlin began to course through 'em on the double, and it was all they could do to keep from butting it right there. But they only glanced expressively at each other again and went on with their repast. Meanwhile the Britisher demanded Moy Sing's eye and ear and divers and sundry other portions of the surprised Chink's anatomy, and demanded Moy to remove the tamales and throw 'em into the discard barrel in the rear of the shack.

See moreSee less

"Presently Virgil Earp and Fron's

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Virgil Earp, nominated for Yavapai County sheriff, gave a speech at a Republican ratification meeting recounting his law enforcement history in Dodge City in 1874 and Prescott in 1876. He described being asked to take the Dodge City marshalship to curb lawlessness, and later facing troublemakers in Prescott who had fled Dodge City.

Arizona Republican · 26 September 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

VIRGIL EARP'S RECORD

The Kind of a Man Yavapai Republicans Want for Sheriff.

See moreSee less

Virgil Earp was nominated for sheriff by acclamation, by the republican

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Virgil Earp describes being asked to serve as marshal in Dodge City, Prescott, and Tombstone, each time reluctantly accepting at the urging of local citizens and business owners. He cites witnesses like Judge Wells and E.B. Gage to vouch for his conduct, and mentions his later nomination for sheriff of Yavapai County.

Arizona Republican · 26 September 1900 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

VIRGIL EARP'S RECORD

you must help us to overcome the lawlessness in this city.' I replied, 'I don't want it; give it to some one else.' They said: 'If you don't take the city marshalship we will have to leave town.' So in the interest of law and order I accepted, and I leave it to the law-abiding citizens of Dodge City as to whether I performed my duty or not.

"The year 1876 saw me in Prescott. On my arrival I soon found out that some of the boys whom I had driven out of Dodge City were there. As soon as they saw me they concluded that if they were going to make any gun plays or shoot up the town they had better do it before I became identified with the country, so they started in at once to shoot up the town and defy the authorities of Prescott. Ed Bowen was sheriff. Do you remember that time, Eddie?" said Earp, addressing Judge E. W. Wells, who was in the chair.

See moreSee less

"I do, well, Virgil," responded the judge.

"Well," continued Earp, "Bowen asked me to go with him and arrest the gang and I said, as at Dodge City, 'I don't want to go; I am a new comer; get some one else.' But he insisted. Whether I performed my duty then you ask Judge Wells and others.

"A few years later I was in Tombstone, and I tell you, gentlemen and ladies, she was a hot town. I had been there a short time when such men as E. B. Gage came to me. They said: 'Virgil, you must be city marshal and clean up this town of its disorderly and lawless elements.' I said: 'I don't want it; get

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A newspaper account describes a backyard boxing match between two boys, Ed Clancey and Ned Brosnan, complete with admission fees and a referee named 'Face' Root. The piece notes that Root had read about Wyatt Earp once officiating a Fitzsimmons-Sharkey fight while armed with a revolver.

The Indianapolis Journal · 30 September 1900 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

ADMISSION CHARGED

He once read of the time when Referee Earp officiated at a fight between Fitzsimmons and Sharkey and was armed with a revolver. The spectators were in a fever of excitement when it was announced that the boys would fight to a finish. They were fairly well matched, and when they donned their gloves they eyed each other cautiously.

See the clipping