As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

The Trial

October – November 1895

The trial opened in Philadelphia on 28 October 1895. It was about one death, Benjamin Pitezel’s. Everyone in the courtroom knew about the children, and so did every reader. It lasted six days, and the jury needed one ballot.

Witnesses from many cities

As the trial opens, the prosecution has brought witnesses from almost every city Holmes lived in, and plans to show the jury Pitezel’s skull. Judge Arnold means to sit three times a day, morning, afternoon and night. The paper puts Howard’s murder in Minneapolis. It was Irvington, one of the towns its witnesses came from.

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · and 1 other paper

Foster's Daily Democrat · 28 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES ON TRIAL.

Stands Charged With the Murder of Benjamin E. Pitzel.

See moreSee less

WITNESSES FROM MANY CITIES.

Three Court Sessions Daily Until Trial Ends.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 28.—H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudget, whose name or alias has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times, was placed on trial for his life this morning in the court of oyer and terminer of this city.

The specific charge to which he is called upon to answer is the murder of Benjamin E. Pitzel, and he has already officially declared himself not guilty. The revolting details of the many crimes with which Holmes' name has been directly or indirectly connected have been given such publicity, and the cold, implacable demeanor which has characterized the man throughout has been so frequently commented upon, that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of the western hemisphere. The commonwealth has already expended thousands of dollars in its efforts to bring the prisoner to summary justice, and there is an indication that, should a conviction for murder in the first degree be obtained, he will be "railroaded" to the gallows.

Prosecution's Plans Kept Secret.

Witnesses have been brought to this city from Boston, Chicago, Indianapolis, Irvington, Ind., and almost every city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. What revelations these witnesses will make have been kept a profound secret by the prosecuting officers, but there are expectations of sensational developments. Detective Geyer, who has been for months traveling extensively throughout the country in search of evidence of Holmes' guilt, will be one of the principal witnesses for the commonwealth. The skull and portions of the body of Pitzel, as well as the remains of the boy, Howard Pitzel, who is thought to have been murdered by Holmes in Minneapolis, will be exhibited during the course of the trial.

Judge Arnold is upon the bench, and he has already signified his intention of holding three sessions a day—morning, afternoon and night—so long as the persons interested can stand the strain. The prosecution is in the hands of District Attorney Graham and a corps of assistants, while the interests of the prisoner are guarded by Messrs. Shoemaker and Rolan, young members of the local bar.

See the clipping

The trial opens

Holmes walks ‘jauntily’ into the dock. When the judge refuses to delay the trial, his lawyers quit on the spot, and Holmes questions the jurors himself.

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C. · and 1 other paper

Alexandria Gazette · 28 October 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TO-DAY'S TELEGRAPHIC NEWS

Holmes's Trial Commenced.

See moreSee less

PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Oct. 28.—Herman W. Mudgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, the self-confessed life insurance swindler and the alleged mult-murderer, was placed on trial this morning on the charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pietzel. In addition to the murder of Pietzel, the prisoner is also accused of the murder at Toronto, Ont., of Peitzel's two young daughters, Alice and Nellie, of the murder at Irvington, Ind., of the young son, Howard Peitzel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes castle at Chicago.

Holmes walked jauntily into the dock, a tipstaff being on either side of him. He was rather pale from long confinement. He took his seat with a calmness that was noticeable.

When the trial was called the counsel for the defense asked for a continuance of sixty days on the ground that they were not prepared to go on. Judge Arnold overruled the motion and then the defendant's lawyers, W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, withdrew from the case, notwithstanding an injunction from the court that they would be opened to disbarment by taking such a step on the eve of a murder trial. Still further sensation was created when Holmes refused to accept the services of attorneys Everett A Schofield and Joseph R. Fahy, whom the court was about to appoint to defend him. The case was then resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense. Holmes himself pleaded to the court for a postponement, but the judge declared that the case must go on. The trial was then resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense.

The work of securing a jury was then taken up and Holmes examined the talesmen himself. Mrs. Pietzel, who, the district attorney said, was indisposed, was not in court. The work of securing a jury was completed at 1:45 o'clock and then a recess was taken until 3 o'clock.

See the clipping

Holmes defends himself

A Delaware paper runs through the first day: a delay refused, his lawyers walking out under threat of disbarment, Holmes turning down the counsel the court appointed, and finally standing up to try his own case. Nearly a year in prison has left him gaunt and pale, but his beard is trimmed and his black suit spotless.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 2 other papers

Evening Journal · 29 October 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE MULTIMURDERER.

Homes, Alias Mudgett, In the Prisoner's Dock.

See moreSee less

HE ACTS AS HIS OWN COUNSEL.

Sensational Opening of the Trial of the Greatest Alleged Criminal of Modern Times—Spirited Tilts With District Attorney Graham.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 29.—H. H. Holmes, or Herman W. Mudgett, which he says is his baptismal name, was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminer yesterday for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel in this city on Sept. 2, 1894, and the developments of the first day verified better perhaps than ever before the force of the maxim that truth is stranger than fiction From the nature of] the case and the startling stories concerning it which have gained currency during the past year, sensational revelations were naturally to be expected when he, who has come to be regarded as the most skillful and audacious criminal of modern times, was placed on trial for his life. Yet what did occur in court so far surpassed all expectations that the most vivid flights of imagination could scarcely have conceived the day's events.

Protestations and entreaties for a continuance of the trial summarily overruled; the sudden withdrawal of the lawyers who had hitherto represented the prisoner in the face of threats of disbarment; the appointment by the court of new counsel and the refusal by the prisoner to accept them as his defenders; the declination of another lawyer to serve after being selected by Holmes, and finally the prisoner trying his own case. This, not to speak of sundry dramatic passages at arms between Holmes and the commonwealth's prosecuting officer, is a summary of what occurred.

Long before 10 o'clock, the hour set for the opening of court, an eager crowd thronged into the courtroom.

The clocks of the town had scarcely ceased striking 10 when Judge Arnold, clad in the long black gown which was recently adopted by the Philadelphia judiciary, entered and took his seat upon the bench, and what promises to be the most sensational case in the criminal jurisprudence of this country was begun. The prisoner, closely guarded, was brought in and placed in the dock.

Holmes' Marvelous Display of Nerve.

Holmes, who at the time of his arrest in Boston on Nov. 17 last was a stockily built man of middle height, has since his long confinement grown gaunt and hollow chested. The prison bleach has brought his peaked face to a deathlike pallor, heightened by the dark, closely cropped beard. In appearance as he sat in the dock he was neatness itself. The beard was carefully trimmed, the hair smoothly parted, and the black cheviot suit he wore betrayed no spot or blemish. His demeanor throughout, save on one or two occasions, when he gave way to slight bursts of anger, directed at the district attorney, was characterized by that marvelous display of nerve which has become associated with his name.

The original intention of the commonwealth was to hold three sessions of court daily—morning, afternoon and night—but so much time was consumed by the unexpected developments that it was nearly 5 o'clock when District Attorney Graham concluded his opening address to the jury. In view of this and to avoid breaking the testimony of the first witness by the supper recess it was decided to adjourn until today. Hereafter, however, the original programme will be followed.

The day's proceedings began when Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan moved for a 60 days' continuance on the ground of lately discovered evidence. This was promptly refused, as was also their motion for a continuance until today. Finding the judge inexorable, they, as a last resort, declared that they would withdraw from the case. Judge Arnold warned them that if they did so they would lay themselves open to disbarment.

Thereupon Holmes declared from the dock that under the circumstances he would not permit them to defend him. He therefore dismissed them from his service, and the lawyers left the room in spite of the court's threats. Judge Arnold then appointed E. M. Schofield and J. M. Fahy to assume charge of the defense, but again Holmes interposed. He declared that he would not place his life in the hands of two young men who know the case only by hearsay, and eventually, when his personal entreaties for a postponement were refused, he declared that he would himself try the case. Meanwhile he expressed a desire to secure the services of Attorney R. O. Moon, but that gentleman, after learning from the judge that he could not obtain a continuance, declined to accept the grave responsibility.

The selection of a jury consumed several hours, Holmes freely exercising his prerogative of challenge, and after 12 men had been secured a recess was taken.

The afternoon session was devoted largely to District Attorney Graham's opening address to the jury, in which he outlined the case in detail and subjected the prisoner to a scathing denunciation.

The Prosecution's Scathing Arraignment.

The district attorney spoke an hour and 25 minutes, concluding at 4:40 o'clock. He then held a brief talk with the judge at the side bar and agreed with him that in view of the lateness of the hour it would be inexpedient to begin the taking of testimony, as the examination of the first witness would be interrupted by the supper recess. It was therefore decided to adjourn court until 10 o'clock today.

When this became known to Holmes, he arose in the dock, and the last sensation of a day replete with extraordinary incidents occurred.

"May it please your honor," he began, his weak voice vibrating with the emotion which his wonderful self control prevented from betraying in his face, "I am forced to ask that certain privileges be accorded me in prison. They are not very extensive privileges. I must ask the district attorney to allow me to have in my cell light, paper and writing materials, that I may be enabled to prepare my case. I shall also ask the privilege of sending, or having some one connected with the court, sent to Fort Worth, Tex., for certain papers essential to me. How essential I did not know until I heard Mr. Graham's address. Again I ask that I be furnished with a list of the witnesses to be called by the commonwealth."

"I decline to give that," said the district attorney emphatically. "I will furnish that to nobody."

"Then," continued Holmes, "I repeat my request for an interview with a certain party—the party I spoke of this morning." And observing an inquiring look from Mr. Graham he exclaimed sharply and with a defiant gaze at that official, "My wife."

"Which wife?" retorted the district attorney sharply.

There was a suspicion of tears in the voice of the friendless man as he responded, with a bitterness that was real: "You well know whom I mean, Mr. Graham. The person you have seen fit to designate as Miss Yoke, thereby casting a slur on both her and myself."

"She will not see you," the district attorney declared. "You had the opportunity to speak to her in my office, but she shunned you."

Holmes Declares He Was Legally Married.

"I never had," Holmes cried. "I say that I was legally married to this woman two years ago, and there has been no separation except that brought about by you, Mr. Graham. At least," he pleaded, and there was no one in the tribunal who could for the moment repress a feeling of pity for the unfortunate man, "at least allow me to write and ask her, so that she may answer and I can read in her writing that she does not want to see me."

"She told you so to your face," exclaimed Mr. Graham.

"I beg to differ with you, sir." And an angry flush for an instant suffused the cheeks bleached with the prison pallor.

Here Judge Arnold interposed. "Mr. Holmes," he said, "you will be allowed to write a letter to her, and it will be sent by one of the court officers."

"I do not want it taken by any officer who is in any way connected with the district attorney," said Holmes, with a look of scorn at Mr. Graham.

"You have had every opportunity of speaking to her," the latter repeated. "It is indifferent to me whether you see her or not."

"Then, will you answer a direct question?" demanded Holmes searchingly. "Have you or have you not intercepted letters from me to her since last July? Haven't you done everything in your power to keep us apart? Answer yes or no."

"You have no right to so question me, but I will say that I have never in my life addressed six words to her."

"Mr. Holmes," said Judge Arnold, "these are mere idle suspicions. You may write your letter. It will be taken by a court officer, and no one but she shall see it."

"And," added the district attorney, "I will have her in court tomorrow morning besides."

"I will see," concluded the judge, "that you get light and writing materials."

"I thank you, sir, for the privilege," replied Holmes, politely drooping his head.

The court was then adjourned, the jurors locked in their rooms under careful guard, and the man who is accused of being the greatest criminal of modern times was conveyed back to prison to prepare the story which he hopes will save him from the hangman's noose.

See the clipping

The lawyers come back

After a day fighting the prosecution alone, Holmes gives up and sends for his lawyers, Shoemaker and Rotan, and the court lets them rejoin. Pitezel’s daughter has already testified, and witnesses are identifying photographs of Holmes.

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 2 other papers

Waterbury Democrat · 30 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES HAS COUNSEL.

THE PRISONER TIRES OF TRYING HIS OWN CASE.

See moreSee less

Witnesses Tell What They Know of the Story of Pitezel's Murder—The Murdered Man's Daughter Testifies—Holmes' Photographs Identified.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 30.—It is apparent that the picturesque and startling features of H. H. Holmes' career were not to be confined to his destructive wanderings over the American continent, for with each successive day comes something still more strange and unexpected.

After fighting tooth and nail single handed against the tremendous machinery of the commonwealth and the apparently complete chain of evidence which has been forged around him, Holmes last night threw up his hands and sent for his lawyers, Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan. Then he told the court what he had done, and a reluctant consent to their continuing with the defense was given. There was an impression that this was but another piece of byplay following Holmes' personal failure to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by making himself out a much wronged man, forced to fight alone what may prove to be his last battle in spite of his ignorance of the technicalities of the law and his alleged physical infirmity.

The big work of the trial—taking testimony—was begun at 10 a. m., and with the exception of brief intermissions at lunch and supper time was continued until nearly 9 o'clock at night.

The star witnesses of the trial—Mrs. Pitezel, Detective Geyer, Agent Perry of the swindled insurance company and the alleged arch criminal himself—yet remain to be heard, as also nearly two score of others. District Attorney Graham remarked that there was a likelihood of the trial outrivaling the Durant case in point of time, but that if night sessions were held regularly it might be concluded within a month or less. Holmes made a plea asking the court to hold but two sessions a day. In plaintive tones he said that his physical condition was such that he felt unable to continue the cross examination of the witnesses, and besides he was subject to sick headaches. Judge Arnold insisted, however, on holding an extra session last night.

Facing the Picture of His Alleged Victim.

All day, as Holmes sat in the dock, the eyes of the man he is charged with murdering gazed at him from a large crayon portrait placed upright on the district attorney's desk in full view of the entire court. Next to this was an equally large sized picture of the daughter Alice, whose death is also laid on his shoulders. But Holmes did not seem to be affected. His stolid demeanor never deserted him for an instant.

The announcement that the taking of evidence would begin drew a still larger crowd to the city hall, but the admirable police arrangements kept everybody out of the courtroom except attorneys and those concerned in the case.

The interest manifested in the case is not confined to one class. During the day Judge Arnold had no less than eight visitors—all judges from this and other cities in the state. Besides, the head of every municipal department was noticed in the room at different times, including the mayor.

The first witness called was Jeannette Pitezel, one of the children of the dead man, who escaped the fate of the bigger part of the family.

She was a slim girl, with rather dull features and by no means pretty. She was attired for the occasion and conscious of it. Miss Pitezel was kept on the stand long enough to identify a crayon portrait of her father as presenting an excellent likeness of him as he appeared two years ago.

Holmes cross examined her for a moment as to whether there hadn't been a change in the appearance of her father, occasioned by the removal of his beard. She said her father had had a small goatee at one time.

Holmes' Photographs Identified.

John Townsend, a photographer employed in the detective service, and William H. Rau, a private photographer, then identified photographs of Holmes taken by them after his arrest.

Eugene Smith, who found Pitezel's body in the Callowhill street house on Sept. 4, 1894, then told a detailed story of his discovery, which has been already fully published. He had become acquainted with the dead man on Aug. 22, 1894, through business concerning patents which Pitezel was supposed to have held. He saw him several times during the following week. The witness drew a packet of papers from his pocket when he came to the dates. Holmes objected to his referring to them unless they were in his own handwriting. Smith admitted that the papers had been "prepared," and the court sustained the objection.

Smith said that during his first visit to Pitezel, Holmes came in and went upstairs. A moment later Pitezel excused himself and followed. He returned shortly. The witness was present when the corpse of Pitezel was exhumed from the potter's field and was there first introduced to Holmes. Lawyer Howe of St. Louis, Alice Pitezel, the young daughter, and the insurance officers were there. The body was recognized by the witness as Pitezel's. Holmes offered $30 to have the corpse cremated and asked Howe about it. The lawyer answered that the widow would first have to be consulted.

Dr. Scott was called and told his story, which concerned his having been called in to examine Pitezel's body, after its discovery. He explained the situation of the room and the arrangement of the windows so that the sun's rays should fall upon the corpse and hasten decomposition, together with the position of the burns on the body, the broken jar, pipe, etc. He verified the district attorney's assertion of yesterday that the pipe could not have fallen from the lips of Pitezel to the place where it was found, and that the jar could not have been broken by an explosion because the pieces of glass were not scattered about the room, but were inside the jar. The doctor dwelt upon the discovery of chloroform in the stomach and said large quantities of the drug had been used, and from the congested condition of the lungs and the empty heart it was apparent that the man had met a sudden and violent death from chloroform poisoning.

Holmes then subjected Dr. Scott to a lengthy and detailed examination touching the effects of chloroform, but obtained few answers that would tend to throw the balance in the slightest degree in his favor. The witness was regarded by the commonwealth's officers as one of their medical experts, and he was positive and uncontradictory in everything he said in spite of the fact that his questioner—the prisoner—is a medical man by education. Holmes kept up a steady fire of questions and never felt obliged to pause for a word or thought. The calmness with which he volubly exchanged technical terms and discussed chemical and medical possibilities with the doctor was admirable.

Dr. William K. Mattern, coroner's physician, was next called. Holmes at once arose and begged the court to grant him a continuance until tomorrow. He pleaded that as Dr. Mattern would prove a most important witness he felt unequal to the strain, the cross examination of Dr. Scott having exhausted him. He hoped to feel stronger tomorrow.

Judge Arnold asked the district attorney whether he would agree to this, and Mr. Graham replied with emphasis:

"No, sir. I want to go on. This is only more byplay."

"That is your opinion," said Holmes, with the scarce subdued scorn which has marked all his intercourse with the district attorney since the trial began.

"That is my opinion."

Holmes suppressed a sigh and sat down, and the district attorney smiled slightly, with the thought which he has made evident throughout that Holmes is playing the role of a weak, helpless unfortunate, oppressed and crushed by the mighty machinery of the state, in order to get the sympathy of the jury.

Testimony of Coroner's Physician.

Dr. Mattern's examination was then begun.

The witness said he had made the post mortem examination at the morgue on Sept. 4, and the conditions were the same as described by Dr. Scott. There had been paralysis of the heart, causing sudden death, and evidence of chloroform in the stomach. He dilated on the ghastly scene at the potter's field, when, in the presence of a half dozen other persons, including the officers of the swindled insurance company and the young daughter of the dead man, Holmes took a lancet and coldly and ruthlessly cut and hacked off portions of the corpse of the man he is charged with having murdered. The girl Alice had then positively identified the body, and Holmes himself, the witness said, did not hesitate to declare that it was Pitezel's body.

Dr. Henry Leffmann, the well known analytical chemist, was the next witness. He said it was impossible for a man to fix himself in an attitude as reposeful as that in which Pitezel's body was discovered after having administered chloroform to himself.

Holmes merely asked a few questions on cross examination, but reserved the right to call Dr. Leffmann as a witness for the defense after his (Holmes') testimony had been taken.

Coroner Samuel H. Ashbridge produced two affidavits identifying the body of Pitezel, made respectively by Alice Pitezel and Holmes. They were read to the jury and offered in evidence.

Holmes Asks For His Attorneys.

The evening session began a few moments after 7 o'clock. The taking of testimony was about to be resumed when Holmes, who could probably be more aptly called the "arch actor" than anything else, brought out a new piece of byplay.

He arose in the dock, and addressing the court said: "If your honor please, I have a request to make. In consequence of the severe physical strain to which I have been subjected and also because of the criticism leveled against my former counsel, Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan, I have within the past half hour sent for them and asked them to again assume charge of my defense. I should like to ask if the court will permit this?"

"Let them come in," said the judge.

A moment later the two counsellors, looking pale and worried, entered the courtroom, and Mr. Rotan, going up to the bar, was about to enter upon a lengthy explanation when Judge Arnold curtly interrupted with: "No apology is necessary. Go on with the case."

The dock, with its occupant, was then moved back to its former place, and Holmes' counsel took seats at the desk.

William Moebins and Frederick Richards, saloon keepers, testified as to Pitezel's drinking habits.

Mrs. Adela Alcorn, a physician who lives on Eleventh street, was called. Holmes had been at her house from Aug. 5 to Sept. 2, 1894, under the name of Howell. He had hired rooms there. The witness was not sure that his wife was with him, but he brought her later. He said she was very tired, as she had come from Chicago, and he would rather have her at the house than at a hotel. The witness again saw him on the afternoon of Sept. 19 in her parlor. He went out and came back in the evening. He said his wife and little sister would be there later; that they were then in Atlantic City. Holmes told her he was himself going there Saturday and would bring them back with him the following Monday for the winter. On the 19th a man called to see Holmes, or Howell, as he was there known, and was shown to his room, according to instructions. She identified Pitezel's picture as that of the caller. Later she saw him go out. On cross examination she was questioned as to her belief that the picture was that of the caller, and she was positive.

John Grammer, who lives in the Eleventh street house, corroborated the greater part of Mrs. Alcorn's testimony, and added that when Holmes came back the second time he had a little girl with him. Witness identified Alice Pitezel's picture as that of this girl. They remained until the following Sunday, the 19th, and then went away.

Josiah W. Richmond had known Pitezel well and had taken him to his sister's house to get board. Pitezel had told him that Perry was not his right name and spoke of bringing his wife and children from the west.

John F. Hughes, furniture salesman, had sold a bill of goods to Pitezel on Aug. 17, 1894. Holmes accompanied him. The furniture was sent to 1316 Callowhill street.

Walter W. Shedaker, real estate agent, rented the house to Pitezel on Aug. 18, 1894.

The court adjourned until 10 a. m. today.

See the clipping

The widow testifies

Carrie Pitezel spends four hours on the stand, stopping to take medicine, while society ladies watch from the clerk’s enclosure. Holmes reads a newspaper through some of it. The papers can’t get over how calm he is.

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Waterbury Democrat · 31 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MRS PITEZEL TESTIFIES. WIDOW OF HOLMES' ALLEGED VICTIM TELLS HER STORY. The Third Day's Proceedings In the Great Murder Case at Philadelphia—Evidence Regarding the Insurance Frauds—Holmes Remains Stolid and Unmoved.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 31.—The interest in the Holmes case, instead of flagging, has grown with each successive session, and it is not confined to the morbidly curious "general public," for during the greater part of the day Judge Arnold was at intervals receiving well known men upon the bench, while in the court clerk's inclosure sat a group of gayly dressed society ladies, friends of the court officials, gazing curiously at the various actors in the story and drinking in every word of the testimony.

See moreSee less

Still the wonder continues at the exhibition of coolness and nerve made by the man Holmes. Not a change passed over his features during the day, and at many critical points of the testimony he sat carelessly reading a newspaper.

Four long hours, under the scrutinizing gaze of a courtroom crowded with strangers to her, a pale, worn woman underwent an ordeal which well might have broken the nerve of many a strong man. She was Mrs. Carrie Alice Pitezel. With bravery and fortitude she stood the test, in spite of the fact that her physical condition has been so shattered by the battalion of woes, under which she has all but succumbed, that she was obliged to interrupt her pitiful narrative at frequent intervals to accept spoonfuls of medicine from the trained nurse who attended her. In a voice broken with grief she told the whole distressing story, and so affecting was the recital that even District Attorney Graham, long used to tales of misery and distress, paused in the examination to wipe away a furtive tear.

Third Day's Proceedings.

The first witness of the day was a plump, black eyed woman, Miss Susan Hurley of 1002½ Race street. She keeps a boarding house there. She was called to show that Pitezel had boarded at her house. She thought the man in the picture had remained at her house a week and a day; had only seen him there once, and on cross examination wasn't so very sure it was he.

Miss Alice Pierce, who keeps a cigar store at 1304 Callowhill street, where Pitezel bought cigars, identified the crayon picture as that of the murdered victim.

Deforest Perry, assistant treasurer of the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company, was called to establish the fact that a policy of insurance had been issued to Pitezel. The policy was taken out in 1893 for $10,000. It was paid Sept. 24, 1894—22 days after Pitezel's body was found.

After the payment of the money the matter was closed until a letter was received by President Fouse of the insurance company from Superintendent of Police Harrigan of St. Louis. This contained the declaration of Hedspeth, the train robber, that while in jail in St. Louis he had overheard Holmes and Pitezel talking of forming a conspiracy to defraud an insurance company out of $10,000 by the substitution of a corpse for Pitezel. Inspector Gray of the insurance company was sent to St. Louis and interviewed Hedspeth. On the information thus obtained a warrant was sworn out for Holmes on the charge of conspiracy, and upon this he was arrested in Boston. The witness went to that city and identified Holmes. The latter had made a verbal statement to the witness in the presence of Deputy Superintendent Hanscom, Chief of Police Watts and John Cornish of a Boston detective agency in Chief Watts' office.

Inspector William E. Gray of the insurance company told of a trip to St. Louis, where he procured Hedspeth's statement. This was produced, but not yet offered in evidence. In consequence of it the tracking of Holmes was begun. He was first located in Ogdensburg, N. Y., then at Prescott, Canada, various points in New Hampshire, Burlington, Vt., and Boston.

Anna M. Robbins, the stenographer who took the examination of Holmes by Deputy Hanscom, identified a copy of the statement.

District Attorney Graham offered the statement in evidence, and Assistant Barlow read it to the jury.

Mrs. Pitezel on the Witness Stand.

During its reading three women were ushered into court by a side door. One was Dessa Pitezel and another her mother. There was a buzz in the courtroom when District Attorney Graham called:

"Mrs. Pitezel."

A tall, slender woman, dressed in shabby black, her face pale and worn, took the witness stand. In answer to a long series of questions from Mr. Graham she said:

"My name is Carrie A. Pitezel, and Benjamin F. Pitezel was my husband. In July, 1894, we lived in St. Louis. My husband had taken a policy in the Fidelity company for $10,000. On July 29 he left for Philadelphia in connection with the matter. I know the prisoner. Before July, 1894, I had seen him several times with my husband when he came to our house in St. Louis and when we lived on Madison avenue, Chicago. I corresponded with my husband while he was in Philadelphia. The letters were addressed to 1316 Callowhill street. He answered them, and in one he spoke of settling in Philadelphia. He said he was in the patent business in this city. I knew he was living under the name of Perry."

"Did you know anything about the property of Holmes—the Sixty-third street castle?"

"By my husband telling me about it."

"Did he have any interest in that?"

"My husband said he did."

"Did you know that your husband had been in Fort Worth before he came to Philadelphia?"

"Yes."

Mrs. Pitezel said: "Holmes said to me that he had put $5,000 in Fort Worth property to pay off a note due Sept. 18, 1894. My husband said he had a half interest in the Fort Worth property. It was in the name of Benton T. Lyman. Holmes told me this. Lyman was my husband. The Chicago property, he said, was in the name of Perry on account of the Terre Haute trouble."

"Did you have any talk with Holmes about the insurance case before it was carried out?"

"Once he spoke to me about it when he came back from the south and asked me if Ben had told me about it. I said 'Yes,' and that I did not want anything to do with it. He said Ben would be home from the south soon; that he was sick down there."

Continuing, Mrs. Pitezel said:

"I knew Howe through Homes. By his advice I employed Howe and gave him the power of attorney to collect the money. I don't know who prepared it, but Howe brought it to be signed. I saw in a paper that a man named Perry had been killed by an explosion, but Holmes told me my husband was all right."

"In whose care did Alice leave St. Louis?"

"In Howe's. She went at Holmes' suggestion to Philadelphia to identify the body because I was sick. I asked Howe to take care of Alice, and Holmes said he would. Minnie Williams, Holmes' cousin, he said, would take care of her, and if I grew very sick he would send Benny to take care of me. I next saw Holmes on Sept. 27, when he came to our house and said he had brought Alice back to Cincinnati. He said he would take Howard and Nellie to Alice, so she would not be alone, and had made arrangements for Alice to meet them in Indianapolis.

"I took Nellie and Howard to the depot. Howe was there and said the insurance money had been paid. Holmes said to me, 'You had better give her some money,' and Howe gave me $5. I bade the children goodby, and they got on the car.

She Saw Holmes on Oct. 12.

"On Oct. 12 Holmes came to the house in St. Louis, and I went to Howe's office. Holmes was there, and Howe said the scheme was a fraud, and he washed his hands of it. They wanted me to sign a paper in regard to Howe's fee, and after being assured that I would not be implicated in the affair I did so Holmes there went under the name of Howard. He demanded $300 or $400 of me, and I gave it. He wanted to go to some bank to pay off the note due on the Fort Worth property. I got the $5,000, and he took it. We went around to the bank. The money was in $100 bills, all but one old note, a $1,000 bill. He took the money and went to a side window. Then he came back and brought the note, saying it was paid. He told me to take care to show it to Ben when I saw him."

"How much in all did you get of this insurance money?"

"I received $500. That was all I ever got."

"After this money transaction, what became of Holmes?"

"He took another $500 for the children, who, he said, would need some in Indianapolis. He went away, and some time afterward he sent me a letter from Detroit to come on there to see my husband."

"Did you see your husband?"

"No. He then sent me to visit my parents at Galva, Ills."

In answer to further questions Mrs. Pitezel went on: "When I went to Detroit with Dessa and the baby, he met us and took us to Geese's European hotel. I said I expected to hear from the children, and he said they would write in a few days. Holmes registered me there as Mrs. Adams. We remained in Detroit until Oct. 18."

"Did he explain why your husband was not there?"

"He said he had looked all over the town and could not find a vacant house where it would be convenient for me to see Ben. On the morning of the 18th he said we'd better go to Toronto. He thought Dessa should join the other children in Indianapolis, where they were in charge of a widow, he said. I asked him the name of the widow my children were with, and he said: 'It's a peculiar name. I cannot think of it now.' We went to Toronto, where he also registered me as Mrs. Adams. My husband, he said, was in Montreal waiting for word to come on.

"We were in Toronto from Oct. 18 to Oct. 25. Holmes did not stop at the same house with us. I don't know where his different stopping places were. On the afternoon of the 25th he came to the hotel and said he wanted me to hurry up and go to Prescott, Canada, and there cross over to Ogdensburg, N. Y. We went to Prescott and staid at the National hotel until Nov. 1.

Mrs. Pitezel Takes the Name of Cook.

"From there we went to Burlington, Vt. He told me that I had worn out the name of Adams and to go by the name of Cook. He claimed to be sending diamond dyes to Ben in Montreal. The second week we were at Burlington I said I was not going to stand it any longer. I wanted to see Ben, and I told Holmes I believed he was lying to me. He denied this. I said, 'I do not hear from my children, and you said I would get the rent from the Fort Worth property, and I have not a scratch to show.' I said I would go to the children in Indianapolis, but he said, 'No, not until you see Ben.' He said he was going to take Ben to the United States and get him to sign papers about the Fort Worth property and sell it.

"For two or three days I did not see him, and then he came and told me he had taken the children to Toronto. He said he had put heavy coats on them, so they wouldn't catch cold, and that they were perfectly happy. He said he would have to go to Montreal, as Ben had been drinking and was not taking care of the diamond dyes. He told me to go into the cellar, and under the potato bin I would find a bottle of dynamite, which I should carry to the attic. I did not carry it up stairs, though. Holmes was there known as Judson. He told me Ben had been drinking and was sick and asked me what I'd do if he should die. He said, 'I have one grave marked for him.' All my letters were given to Holmes to mail. He said he sent them to Chicago, where Pat Quinlan, the janitor of the castle, took care to get them to my husband."

A number of letters written by the witness and given to Holmes to mail were identified by her. None had been mailed. She was shown two others written by Alice and Nellie.

"Have you ever seen your husband since he left St. Louis for Philadelphia?"

"I have never seen him since July 29, 1894, nor heard from him since Aug. 29, when I got the last letter in his own handwriting," she answered tearfully.

"That was from Philadelphia?"

"Have you seen or heard from Alice, Nellie or Howard since this man got possession of them?"

"I have not heard from them."

"Have you seen them since?"

Sobbing bitterly, the woman answered: "I saw Alice and Nellie lying side by side in the morgue at Toronto. I never saw Howard except what belonged to him in Indianapolis in the coroner's office."

This ended the examination in chief.

In answer to questions from Mr. Rotan the witness said she was married to Pitezel in Galva, Ills., in 1878. She did not know where he and Holmes had first met. She thought it was in 1889. She first met Holmes in the restaurant at Sixty-third and Wallace streets, Chicago (the castle) when she was with her husband there in 1893. She did not see much of Holmes until this insurance matter came up.

A long line of questions were put to Mrs. Pitezel, many of which were ruled out on the ground of irrelevance. The cross examination lasted nearly two hours, but developed nothing to controvert her evidence in chief.

District Attorney Graham then showed her the crayon portrait of Pitezel, and she said, "Yes, that is a good picture of my husband as he left home."

She gave way for her daughter Jeannette (Dessa) whose testimony was largely corroborative of that given by her mother concerning the departure of the children and the subsequent travels of Dessa and her mother under Holmes' guidance to the various cities named.

Mrs. Pitezel was recalled, and the district attorney questioned her further regarding the stay in Burlington, attempting to show that Holmes had dug a hole in the cellar there, as he had done in every other case where he had rented a house.

The defense objected to this line of evidence on the ground of irrelevancy, and Judge Arnold sustained the objection.

The court then adjourned until 10 a. m. today.

See the clipping

Guilty on the first ballot

On 2 November the jury finds Holmes guilty of first-degree murder. One juror says their minds were made up before the door closed: a single ballot, all twelve for guilty, then an hour and a half of talk for decency’s sake. Holmes tells his lawyers it was an unjust trial; not one of his family in Gilmanton, New Hampshire, was heard from.

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho · and 3 other papers

The Weiser Signal · 7 November 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES IS GUILTY

One Minute's Deliberation Pronounced His Doom.

See moreSee less

WERE UNANIMOUS FOR DEATH

The Man of Iron Nerve Stood Up to Hear the Awful Sentence Without a Quiver.

Philadelphia, Nov. 2.—Henry H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree at 8:51 tonight for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel.

The jury retired to deliberate at 5:30 o'clock this afternoon. According to one of their number, they had reached their verdict before the doors of their room closed upon them. For hunger's sake they ate their supper first. Then they took a ballot and without hesitation every man of the 12 answered "guilty of murder in the first degree." But, however atrocious the crime, however fiendish the criminal, it is hard to send a man to the gallows in one minute's time. So, for decency sake, they talked about the case for a seemingly period, about an hour and a half. Then word was sent into court that they had agreed. It took half an hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict. Holmes spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker in the cell room, before he was taken back to the prison. He said: "I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trail." He would say no more than that.

Immediately after the verdict the usual application for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. District Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion and Judge Arnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation for the defense. Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the supreme court and arguments heard at its next sitting in this city in January, 1896. So, even if everything goes against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on the earth, from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals.

The verdict was a surprise to many persons who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt.

There was no word of sympathy for the condemned felon. He is regarded as a menace to society. Up in Gilmanton, N. H., there are two old people, his father and mother, and he has also two brothers and two sisters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial.

A MAN OF IRON NERVE.

When the jury went out an indefinite recess was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in the building until midnight if necessary, and if no verdict had been reached by that time he would come to court at 10 o'clock tomorrow morning. There were many wagers that the verdict would be in tonight, and more as to its nature. At 20 minutes of 9 there was a bustle of moving people in the packed courtroom and it became known that the jury was coming in. A moment later Judge Arnold took his seat. District Attorney Graham and his associates entered, and the jury filed solemnly in and took their seats in the box. Then Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. The silence was literally painful, and every heart in that crowded room throbbed.

The man who was about to hear his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same death-like pallor which could grow no deeper on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped behind his back. Then from the deep-voiced clerk came the awful words: "Jurors, look upon the prisoner; prisoner, look upon the jurors. How say you, gentlemen of the jury? Do you find the prisoner at the bar, Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, or not guilty?"

The condemning syllables came from the foreman: "Guilty of murder in the first degree."

"Ahem!" uttered Holmes, clearing his throat, but his shrunken form never trembled, his lips betrayed no quiver, his marvelous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of his hands folded behind him. Then he slowly sat down, and at the request of his counsel the jury was polled. As each name was called Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The verdict was formally recorded by the court. The motion for a new trial was made, and after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to counsel for the defense because of last Monday's occurrence, when they withdrew from the case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruitless labor, Holmes was taken to his cell room. A few minutes later the jury were thanked for their attention and labors and sent home, the court adjourned, and the most extraordinary case in the annals of American courts was ended.

EVENTS OF THE LAST DAY.

The last day was uneventful except for the last tragic scene. District Attorney Graham opened the session with his address to the jury. He was followed by Mr. Rotan, who, in his speech, presented the only form of defense—that Pietzel had committed suicide—resting on the assumption that the commonwealth had not made out a case beyond a reasonable doubt. Judge Arnold charged the jury for more than an hour. The district attorney reviewed the evidence in detail. Beginning with the question of identity of the corpse found in the Callowhill street house, he went over the testimony of each witness, who positively said that it was the body of Pietzel. Leading up to the motive of the murder, Mr. Graham rehearsed in minute details Holmes' every transaction in connection with Pietzel's murder, tracing his movements from place to place and drawing out every little circumstance that weighed against the prisoner with infinite clearness and force.

When he came to the testimony of Mrs. Pietzel, he told the jury that never in his official experience had he heard such a tale as that told in the broken sentences of that despairing, hopeless woman, whom he had kept flitting from place to place in the vain hope of meeting her husband, and all the while he was carrying with him three separate detachments—Mrs. Pietzel, Miss Yorke and the children—all within four blocks of each other, almost traveling together under Holmes' leading strings, and yet each party ignorant of the presence of the other two.

In conclusion Mr. Graham said he desired the jury to consider only the evidence connected with the murder of Pietzel in the Callowhill street house and nothing else.

THE TRIAL.

When court opened today at 10 o'clock for arguments in the Holmes case, Mr. Rotan, junior counsel for the defense, announced that his colleague, Shoemaker, was suffering from complete nervous prostration and was under the care of a physician. He called this to the attention of the court in view of the point of law regarding the commonwealth's right to make the closing address to the jury when the defense presented no evidence. Graham ended the question by offering to waive his right to the last speech, and there will be but one address on each side, instead of two by the prosecution. District Attorney Graham began his address at 10:55 o'clock. He said: "The commonwealth of Pennsylvania is the prosecutor of this case and it asks no victim. If you are satisfied, when we have done, that this prisoner did not commit the crime, you must acquit him. The commonwealth is bound to prove its case from the initial step down to the last syllable of the sentence. The commonwealth has done so. One by one we established link by link, making the chain complete."

The district attorney reviewed the evidence in detail. The condition of the body, he contended, medical testimony had proved could not be produced except by chloroform.

Graham's address, which was confined for the most part to review of the details of evidence, lasted two hours and a half. Holmes nervously shifted in his seat as the thunderous tones of the prosecutor rang out. At the conclusion of his address a recess was taken until 2:30 p. m.

The defense then spoke until 5:30, when the case was given to the jury.

See the clipping

‘Pitezel is alive’

Less than three weeks after the verdict, a Chicago streetcar conductor swears he recently chatted with Pitezel on his car, and the papers print it. Pitezel had been dead for fourteen months.

The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Corvallis Gazette · 21 November 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SAYS HE SAW PITEZEL

Sensational Story Published in a Chicago Paper.

See moreSee less

SURE THERE WAS NO MISTAKE

James McNary, a Street Railway Conductor, Claims That He Talked With Him But Recently.

Chicago, Nov. 20.—The Daily News this evening publishes the following story:

James McNary, a conductor on car No. 635, of the Sixty-third street line, has sprung a new sensation in the Holmes case, by stating that Benjamin F. Pitezel is alive, and that he recently talked with him on his car. McNary claims there could be no mistake, for he worked nine months for Pitezel and knows the peculiarities of his voice. According to McNary, Pitezel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes' trial. Pitezel's beard had grown around the greater part of his face, so that he was completeiy disguised. When addressed, however, he admitted his identity and asked as a friend that McNary keep silent, for he was on his way to Phiadelphia; but McNary called in Motorman Letterman and he, too, claims that he had a conversation with Pitezel, who took a transfer to the Cottage Grove cable line.

Robert Corbett, who has been following the case for months in behalf of the Farmers' & Merchants' National bank, Fort Worth, claims he has also seen Pitezel. He said to a Daily News reporter:

"I never believed Pitezel was dead, for the following reasons: First, when I was searching the 'castle,' some months ago, this man, who resembles the one seen by the conductor and motorman, and who, I then thought was Pitezel, found me in the building looking over some papers. He asked me if I had seen a toolchest. I told him there was one in the front room. He said that one was not his; that he had left it in the room where I was engaged. I asked him who he was. He said Mrs. Pitezel sent him there for a toolchest, and when I asked him his name he said, after thinking a moment, 'Andrews,' and left."

See the clipping

A $20 lie in open court

Arguing for a new trial, Holmes’s lawyer Shoemaker produces an affidavit saying Pitezel had talked of suicide. The district attorney proves the woman who signed it was paid $20. Shoemaker is held on $1,500 bail for suborning perjury.

The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Forrest City Times · 22 November 1895 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THE HOLMES CASE.

The Argument in Support of the Motion for a New Trial Leads Up to a Sensation—Attorney Shoemaker Held in $1,500 Bonds for Subornation of Perjury in Securing an Affidavit to Support His Case.

See moreSee less

PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 19.—The argument for a new trial for the convicted murderer H. H. Holmes was heard yesterday in the court of oyer and terminer, and this remarkable case furnished another sensation.

One of the counsel for the prisoner produced an affidavit in court alleging to show that Pietzel, the murdered man, contemplated suicide. Amidst the silent amazement of the spectators and the shocked astonishment of the court, District Attorney Graham proved the affidavit to be false, and showed that Mr. Shoemaker, the attorney of Holmes, who offered it, had paid the woman who swore to it $20 for doing so.

Shoemaker was so overcome by this exposure that he could make no explanation and at the conclusion of the argument he was held in $1,500 bail by the court to answer to the charge of subornation of perjury.

Holmes was in court during the argument. He has failed perceptibly in looks since his trial. He has lost the prison bleach which paled his cheek and a hectic flush has taken its place. His eyes are bloodshot and dark rings around them tell of anxious days and nights. His manner was not as cool and unconcerned as it was during his trial, and he showed an almost feverish interest in the proceedings. As formerly, however, he retained his self-possession and took notes of the district attorney's argument, and prompted his lawyer during his address.

The argument consumed the entire day and the court reserved its decision, but from the questions asked by the judge it seems certain a new trial will be refused.

See the clipping

Holmes blames Hatch

In a long signed statement in the New York World, Holmes says the children were killed by his old associate Hatch, at a Williams sister’s urging. Detectives had been calling Hatch a myth since July.

The Windham County Reformer · Battleboro, Vt.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Windham County Reformer · 22 November 1895 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

The case of Holmes, the multi-murderer, has had several more sensational developments this week. When his application for a new trial came up in the ciminal court at Philadelphia Monday, on the claim of new evidence to the effect that a woman had been found to whom Pitezel said just before his death, substantially, that he was going to commit suicide, Mr. Schoonmaker, one of Holmes' counsel was confronted with a charge of suborning perjury in getting this affidavit from the woman. The woman herself and the detective who got her to make the affidavit swore that it was perjured.

See moreSee less

The woman said she got $20 for swearing to it. The detective testified that Schoonmaker employed him to hunt up some woman who would swear to such a story, furnishing the affidavit all prepared beforehand, and the detective at once consulted with the district attorney and went ahead with the scheme so as to entrap Schoonmaker in his villiany. The latter, of course, protests his innocence and claims that the detective has "put up a job" on him, but he is held under bail for further investigation. Holmes himself made a long signed statement in the New York World Sunday, advancing the theory that the Pitezel children were all murdered by Hatch, an accomplice in his swindles, of which Holmes admits the guilt: and that Hatch did them at the instigation of his mistress, Mamie Williams, who formerly bore the same relation to Holmes, and that her motive in it was to get Holmes behind the bars so that he would never "peach" on her for the murder of her sister, whom Holmes says she killed in a jealous fit of rage on discovering that she was intimate with Holmes. Holmes devotes considerable effort to showing that Hatch, whose existence has thus far seemed more or less shadowy, is a real person, and he declares that the last time he ever saw him was at the depot in Burlington when it was arranged that Hatch should take Mrs. Pitezel and two of her children to London. A despatch from Chicago Monday tells of a street car conductor who asserts that within a few weeks he has seen and talked with B. F. Pitezel, the man whom Holmes is convicted of murdering, and that Pitezel admitted his identity to the conductor and to another man. The story is that Pitezel is now in Philadelphia with Minnie Williams and that he will declare himself to save Holmes' life. In this view Holmes' World story would seem to have been a bad miss.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

← Back to Act Three: The Hunt