MRS PITEZEL TESTIFIES. WIDOW OF HOLMES' ALLEGED VICTIM TELLS HER STORY. The Third Day's Proceedings In the Great Murder Case at Philadelphia—Evidence Regarding the Insurance Frauds—Holmes Remains Stolid and Unmoved.
PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 31.—The interest in the Holmes case, instead of flagging, has grown with each successive session, and it is not confined to the morbidly curious "general public," for during the greater part of the day Judge Arnold was at intervals receiving well known men upon the bench, while in the court clerk's inclosure sat a group of gayly dressed society ladies, friends of the court officials, gazing curiously at the various actors in the story and drinking in every word of the testimony.
See moreSee less
Still the wonder continues at the exhibition of coolness and nerve made by the man Holmes. Not a change passed over his features during the day, and at many critical points of the testimony he sat carelessly reading a newspaper.
Four long hours, under the scrutinizing gaze of a courtroom crowded with strangers to her, a pale, worn woman underwent an ordeal which well might have broken the nerve of many a strong man. She was Mrs. Carrie Alice Pitezel. With bravery and fortitude she stood the test, in spite of the fact that her physical condition has been so shattered by the battalion of woes, under which she has all but succumbed, that she was obliged to interrupt her pitiful narrative at frequent intervals to accept spoonfuls of medicine from the trained nurse who attended her. In a voice broken with grief she told the whole distressing story, and so affecting was the recital that even District Attorney Graham, long used to tales of misery and distress, paused in the examination to wipe away a furtive tear.
Third Day's Proceedings.
The first witness of the day was a plump, black eyed woman, Miss Susan Hurley of 1002½ Race street. She keeps a boarding house there. She was called to show that Pitezel had boarded at her house. She thought the man in the picture had remained at her house a week and a day; had only seen him there once, and on cross examination wasn't so very sure it was he.
Miss Alice Pierce, who keeps a cigar store at 1304 Callowhill street, where Pitezel bought cigars, identified the crayon picture as that of the murdered victim.
Deforest Perry, assistant treasurer of the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company, was called to establish the fact that a policy of insurance had been issued to Pitezel. The policy was taken out in 1893 for $10,000. It was paid Sept. 24, 1894—22 days after Pitezel's body was found.
After the payment of the money the matter was closed until a letter was received by President Fouse of the insurance company from Superintendent of Police Harrigan of St. Louis. This contained the declaration of Hedspeth, the train robber, that while in jail in St. Louis he had overheard Holmes and Pitezel talking of forming a conspiracy to defraud an insurance company out of $10,000 by the substitution of a corpse for Pitezel. Inspector Gray of the insurance company was sent to St. Louis and interviewed Hedspeth. On the information thus obtained a warrant was sworn out for Holmes on the charge of conspiracy, and upon this he was arrested in Boston. The witness went to that city and identified Holmes. The latter had made a verbal statement to the witness in the presence of Deputy Superintendent Hanscom, Chief of Police Watts and John Cornish of a Boston detective agency in Chief Watts' office.
Inspector William E. Gray of the insurance company told of a trip to St. Louis, where he procured Hedspeth's statement. This was produced, but not yet offered in evidence. In consequence of it the tracking of Holmes was begun. He was first located in Ogdensburg, N. Y., then at Prescott, Canada, various points in New Hampshire, Burlington, Vt., and Boston.
Anna M. Robbins, the stenographer who took the examination of Holmes by Deputy Hanscom, identified a copy of the statement.
District Attorney Graham offered the statement in evidence, and Assistant Barlow read it to the jury.
Mrs. Pitezel on the Witness Stand.
During its reading three women were ushered into court by a side door. One was Dessa Pitezel and another her mother. There was a buzz in the courtroom when District Attorney Graham called:
"Mrs. Pitezel."
A tall, slender woman, dressed in shabby black, her face pale and worn, took the witness stand. In answer to a long series of questions from Mr. Graham she said:
"My name is Carrie A. Pitezel, and Benjamin F. Pitezel was my husband. In July, 1894, we lived in St. Louis. My husband had taken a policy in the Fidelity company for $10,000. On July 29 he left for Philadelphia in connection with the matter. I know the prisoner. Before July, 1894, I had seen him several times with my husband when he came to our house in St. Louis and when we lived on Madison avenue, Chicago. I corresponded with my husband while he was in Philadelphia. The letters were addressed to 1316 Callowhill street. He answered them, and in one he spoke of settling in Philadelphia. He said he was in the patent business in this city. I knew he was living under the name of Perry."
"Did you know anything about the property of Holmes—the Sixty-third street castle?"
"By my husband telling me about it."
"Did he have any interest in that?"
"My husband said he did."
"Did you know that your husband had been in Fort Worth before he came to Philadelphia?"
"Yes."
Mrs. Pitezel said: "Holmes said to me that he had put $5,000 in Fort Worth property to pay off a note due Sept. 18, 1894. My husband said he had a half interest in the Fort Worth property. It was in the name of Benton T. Lyman. Holmes told me this. Lyman was my husband. The Chicago property, he said, was in the name of Perry on account of the Terre Haute trouble."
"Did you have any talk with Holmes about the insurance case before it was carried out?"
"Once he spoke to me about it when he came back from the south and asked me if Ben had told me about it. I said 'Yes,' and that I did not want anything to do with it. He said Ben would be home from the south soon; that he was sick down there."
Continuing, Mrs. Pitezel said:
"I knew Howe through Homes. By his advice I employed Howe and gave him the power of attorney to collect the money. I don't know who prepared it, but Howe brought it to be signed. I saw in a paper that a man named Perry had been killed by an explosion, but Holmes told me my husband was all right."
"In whose care did Alice leave St. Louis?"
"In Howe's. She went at Holmes' suggestion to Philadelphia to identify the body because I was sick. I asked Howe to take care of Alice, and Holmes said he would. Minnie Williams, Holmes' cousin, he said, would take care of her, and if I grew very sick he would send Benny to take care of me. I next saw Holmes on Sept. 27, when he came to our house and said he had brought Alice back to Cincinnati. He said he would take Howard and Nellie to Alice, so she would not be alone, and had made arrangements for Alice to meet them in Indianapolis.
"I took Nellie and Howard to the depot. Howe was there and said the insurance money had been paid. Holmes said to me, 'You had better give her some money,' and Howe gave me $5. I bade the children goodby, and they got on the car.
She Saw Holmes on Oct. 12.
"On Oct. 12 Holmes came to the house in St. Louis, and I went to Howe's office. Holmes was there, and Howe said the scheme was a fraud, and he washed his hands of it. They wanted me to sign a paper in regard to Howe's fee, and after being assured that I would not be implicated in the affair I did so Holmes there went under the name of Howard. He demanded $300 or $400 of me, and I gave it. He wanted to go to some bank to pay off the note due on the Fort Worth property. I got the $5,000, and he took it. We went around to the bank. The money was in $100 bills, all but one old note, a $1,000 bill. He took the money and went to a side window. Then he came back and brought the note, saying it was paid. He told me to take care to show it to Ben when I saw him."
"How much in all did you get of this insurance money?"
"I received $500. That was all I ever got."
"After this money transaction, what became of Holmes?"
"He took another $500 for the children, who, he said, would need some in Indianapolis. He went away, and some time afterward he sent me a letter from Detroit to come on there to see my husband."
"Did you see your husband?"
"No. He then sent me to visit my parents at Galva, Ills."
In answer to further questions Mrs. Pitezel went on: "When I went to Detroit with Dessa and the baby, he met us and took us to Geese's European hotel. I said I expected to hear from the children, and he said they would write in a few days. Holmes registered me there as Mrs. Adams. We remained in Detroit until Oct. 18."
"Did he explain why your husband was not there?"
"He said he had looked all over the town and could not find a vacant house where it would be convenient for me to see Ben. On the morning of the 18th he said we'd better go to Toronto. He thought Dessa should join the other children in Indianapolis, where they were in charge of a widow, he said. I asked him the name of the widow my children were with, and he said: 'It's a peculiar name. I cannot think of it now.' We went to Toronto, where he also registered me as Mrs. Adams. My husband, he said, was in Montreal waiting for word to come on.
"We were in Toronto from Oct. 18 to Oct. 25. Holmes did not stop at the same house with us. I don't know where his different stopping places were. On the afternoon of the 25th he came to the hotel and said he wanted me to hurry up and go to Prescott, Canada, and there cross over to Ogdensburg, N. Y. We went to Prescott and staid at the National hotel until Nov. 1.
Mrs. Pitezel Takes the Name of Cook.
"From there we went to Burlington, Vt. He told me that I had worn out the name of Adams and to go by the name of Cook. He claimed to be sending diamond dyes to Ben in Montreal. The second week we were at Burlington I said I was not going to stand it any longer. I wanted to see Ben, and I told Holmes I believed he was lying to me. He denied this. I said, 'I do not hear from my children, and you said I would get the rent from the Fort Worth property, and I have not a scratch to show.' I said I would go to the children in Indianapolis, but he said, 'No, not until you see Ben.' He said he was going to take Ben to the United States and get him to sign papers about the Fort Worth property and sell it.
"For two or three days I did not see him, and then he came and told me he had taken the children to Toronto. He said he had put heavy coats on them, so they wouldn't catch cold, and that they were perfectly happy. He said he would have to go to Montreal, as Ben had been drinking and was not taking care of the diamond dyes. He told me to go into the cellar, and under the potato bin I would find a bottle of dynamite, which I should carry to the attic. I did not carry it up stairs, though. Holmes was there known as Judson. He told me Ben had been drinking and was sick and asked me what I'd do if he should die. He said, 'I have one grave marked for him.' All my letters were given to Holmes to mail. He said he sent them to Chicago, where Pat Quinlan, the janitor of the castle, took care to get them to my husband."
A number of letters written by the witness and given to Holmes to mail were identified by her. None had been mailed. She was shown two others written by Alice and Nellie.
"Have you ever seen your husband since he left St. Louis for Philadelphia?"
"I have never seen him since July 29, 1894, nor heard from him since Aug. 29, when I got the last letter in his own handwriting," she answered tearfully.
"That was from Philadelphia?"
"Have you seen or heard from Alice, Nellie or Howard since this man got possession of them?"
"I have not heard from them."
"Have you seen them since?"
Sobbing bitterly, the woman answered: "I saw Alice and Nellie lying side by side in the morgue at Toronto. I never saw Howard except what belonged to him in Indianapolis in the coroner's office."
This ended the examination in chief.
In answer to questions from Mr. Rotan the witness said she was married to Pitezel in Galva, Ills., in 1878. She did not know where he and Holmes had first met. She thought it was in 1889. She first met Holmes in the restaurant at Sixty-third and Wallace streets, Chicago (the castle) when she was with her husband there in 1893. She did not see much of Holmes until this insurance matter came up.
A long line of questions were put to Mrs. Pitezel, many of which were ruled out on the ground of irrelevance. The cross examination lasted nearly two hours, but developed nothing to controvert her evidence in chief.
District Attorney Graham then showed her the crayon portrait of Pitezel, and she said, "Yes, that is a good picture of my husband as he left home."
She gave way for her daughter Jeannette (Dessa) whose testimony was largely corroborative of that given by her mother concerning the departure of the children and the subsequent travels of Dessa and her mother under Holmes' guidance to the various cities named.
Mrs. Pitezel was recalled, and the district attorney questioned her further regarding the stay in Burlington, attempting to show that Holmes had dug a hole in the cellar there, as he had done in every other case where he had rented a house.
The defense objected to this line of evidence on the ground of irrelevancy, and Judge Arnold sustained the objection.
The court then adjourned until 10 a. m. today.