As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

November 1895, part 2

104 articles

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, reports that the defense in the Holmes case rested on Saturday, Nov. 8, without calling witnesses, and notes a receiver was appointed for the New York State Mutual.

The United Opinion · 8 November 1895 · page 3

THE WEEK'S NEWS

Defense in the Holmes ease rests with Fire Insurance corporation Vigorous Saturday, Nav. 8. out calling witnesses Receiver ap pointed for the New York State Mutual

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

This compilation of brief news items from early November 1895 includes a line stating that a jury found Holmes guilty of murder in connection with a killing. The surrounding items cover unrelated events such as railroad wrecks, fires, and international affairs.

The United Opinion · 8 November 1895 · page 3

A. McGregor, Tex., arrested for robbery Cuban insurgents routea spanisn troops IDU uanuiin. southern railroad lines once more profess to favor a rate agreement James Brown, self-confessed train robber, to be extradited from Michigan to Indiana First anni Csar of Russia, commemorated at Berlin drews sentenced to a year in the house of correction for inducing a dot to suai lor him. . v. ... 4.nM far the klllinsT of B. F. uo uj O r - . M freight trains at Edge worth, Mass. Brakeman killed ana so persons lujureu n i.-..n.

See moreSee less

flr.r 1:1 md 000 more to ChiiWCH'CI'i - ' ongo university Frank W. Breed of Lynn, Mass.; asaaunea oj '"" ! pot so heavy as In 1393 -4 John Dawson cf Cambridge,; Mass., claims' his wife has titt. for many years a well-known Bosawu ' - 1 n . unify icii."-'"- , lance Social prejudice in New Xork fn evidence in connection with prepara T . Onariill njtt.lnnil hank nuhler at , i untniail m. f.nlrknnl Wnatam and versary of the death of Alexander II, T.F.n iMuu 1 atorakeener named An day, Kav. 9. Jury found Holmes guilty of murder In i villi al on of nasaenirer 'and Intendent of his shoe factory The politi cal mail at the Boston office this year is j i.w J..hn linin D. W. Merk.,.i m&n la aeaa r nui m. inktMl fnr mavor of rovi tions for the approaching home show

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

The damaged, OCR-garbled clipping mentions items related to H. H. Holmes, called an alleged mass murderer, planned as a main attraction, and refers to an Eleventh of November celebration arranged by the club 'Morgenroth.'

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 8 November 1895 · page 4

ſchen H. H. Holmes, des angeblichen Maſſenmörders, werden unter den Haupilſehenswürdigleiten ſein. Die vom Club „Morgenroth“ ar rangirte Elfte November ~ Feier findet Gltkter November.

See the clipping

The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, describes the Philadelphia Criminal Courts' trial of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, as an unusually dramatic and surprising case beginning in October, though the text breaks off before further detail.

The Webster Echo · 8 November 1895 · page 5

The Criminal Courts of Phila delphia have in their day been the theatres of many a strange murder trial of which the whole country has been an interested spectator; but never, it is safe to say, have they presented a case surpassing or even rivaling in all its varied phases—its surprises, its swift dramatic turns, its mysteries and its intensities—the case of Her man VV. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, who was on October The Trial of If. H. Holmes.

See the clipping

The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

The clipping reports that Henry H. Holmes, described as a great insurance swindler and murderer, was convicted of the murder of Benjamin P. Pitezel at Philadelphia the previous Saturday.

The Clarksburg Telegram · 8 November 1895 · page 1

Henry H. Holmes, tho great j insurance swindlerand murderer. ; was convicted of the murder of Benjamin P. PItezel at Philadel-: phia last Saturday.*

See the clipping

The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark.

The damaged clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, accused of at least six murders for insurance money, was found guilty at Philadelphia, though the remainder of the text is garbled and unreadable.

The Osceola Times · 9 November 1895 · page 2

mat ter to their commit tees. 11. 11. Holmes, who is accused of at 1 least six murders to get the insurance i HWnCV On thb lives of his victims, was ‘ found guilty dt Phitadel|lhik bf thfi

See the clipping

The Osceola Times · Osceola, Ark.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree at Philadelphia on the 2d for killing Benjamin Pe.tzel, coughing slightly as the only sign of reaction to the verdict.

The Osceola Times · 9 November 1895 · page 2

CONDENSED TELEGRAMS

nt Dallas, Texas, on the 4th from j hydrophobia, resulting from the bit© of a cat. Throe months ago he was bitton । «>n ths hand by a cat. Ho paid little j attention to the wound and it soon , healed up. but something like rheu ! matic pains attacked him and the phy sician pronounced it a violent attack of hydrophobia. Eugene Field, poet and humorist, died at Chicago on the 4th. For some days Mr. Field had been ailing, but it was suppesod he was suffering from bis usual stomach trouble and no serious turn was anticipated.

See moreSee less

President Cleveland has issued a proclamation designating Thursday. November 38th, as Thanksgiving Day. , Farm er Joseph Vincent, near Pana, j 1)1.. is in a dangerous condition from poisoning, taken into his system by eating buckwheat cakes in which chinch bugs were ground up in the wheat. The average monthly deficit in reve nues produced by the Wilson-Gonnan bill since it became *. law, as compared with tho expenses of the government, has been $5,009,000. It is ascertained fro.n reliable sources that the entire orange crop of the State of Florida will not exceed 50,000 boxes this season. The crop of last season, as reported by the agricultural bureau, was 5,0CX),000. At Philadelphia, Pa., on the 2d H. H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree for the killing of Benjamin I’. Pe.tzel. Ho coughed slightly when be heard the words. That was the only sign. 1 he official speed of tho American ram Katahdin ia 16.13 knots, and the vessel stands rejected under her con tract, and bears the distinction of being the first vessel of the new navy failing to reach contract requirements. At Minneapolis, Minn., on the 3d Augustus Hanson, in a twenty-four hour bicycle ride made 375 miles, tho best previous record being 367 miles. At Edna, Texas, on the 31st while playing with a pistol B. B. Pierce accidentally killed Tipps Hensely.

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that Holmes's attorneys withdrew after a postponement was refused, Judge Arnold threatened disbarment, Holmes conducted his own defense skillfully, and the prosecution plans to show a motive involving insurance fraud and Pitezel's Fort Worth property.

The Washington Bee · 9 November 1895 · page 2

first Juror was sworn in Holmes's law Shoemaker, abruptly withdrew from the case and left the court room, their uppeal for a postponement of the trial having been denied. They were warned by Judge Arnold that he would punish them for their action, and would take steps to have them disbarred. The prisoner seemed entirely at ease, and after his counsel left he conducted his own case .with much more skill than might be expected from a layman. His counsel subsequently returned and took up the case. The prosecution hopes to convict Holmes of the murder of PItezel, and Incidentally, as showing a motive for taking the life of his old associate, will produce witnesses to tell how Alice and Nellie Pitezel were killed in Toronto, Ont., and Howard Pitezel in Irvingtonr Ind.

See moreSee less

This motive, it was charged, was to obtain the insurance on Pitezel's life and to secure possession of property valued at $50,000 in Pitezel's name in Fort Worth. Texas. Pitezel, too, who was well acquainted with many of Holmes's schemes, had become unruly and threatened to expose his former partner. Holmes's plan of operations was to secure insurance for a large sum upon yers, Samuel P. Rotan and William A.

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

This damaged, jumbled fragment references a long-threatened police shake-up and describes a man named Holmes as educated with medical knowledge, but the text is too fragmentary to establish a coherent story.

The Washington Bee · 9 November 1895 · page 2

The Bee is the people paper and j& Colored American with backbone. Indeed. pathy being extended to the slayer in Holmes is a man of education and all such cases. possesses considerable medical knowl The big police shake-up, which has been threatened for some weeks, has at edge. He has manifested the utmost

See the clipping

The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga.

This damaged clipping describes a courtroom scene where Judge Arnold entered as the jury prepared to deliver a verdict, with the prisoner brought in and placed in the dock before an ordering directed at someone named Holmes, but the text is too garbled to convey more.

The Savannah Tribune · 9 November 1895 · page 1

GUILTY IS HOLMES. The Jury Takes Only One Ballot to Decide His Fate.

.c Kr^wn supplivx efore raised in so great The list of new cotton mills Re ported for the week includes a s^,- Arnold that the jury was ready to re 48 iurn the verdict. When Judge Arnold id entered the room there were nearly as re many people present as had attended as the day session. The prisoner was brought in and placed in the dock. The jury came in and took their places. The court ordered Holmes to

See the clipping

The Democratic Advocate · Westminster, Md.

This damaged clipping reports H. H. Holmes found guilty of first-degree murder in Philadelphia, a diphtheria outbreak of 54 cases and 18 deaths in Yorktown, Indiana, and a fragmentary legal notice signed by Benj. F. Crouse, Clerk.

The Democratic Advocate · 9 November 1895 · page 2

i each of three (3) successive weeks before the to the meadows and standing corn. At last re-! ! 2nd day of December, 1895. ports the fire was beyond control. In Philadelphia, Pa., Herman W. Mud-1 i $725.40. gett, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with killj mg Benjamin F. Plet/.el, was found guilty on i nov9 3tBexj. F. Crouse, Clerk. Saturday night of murder in the first degree, i Diphtheria is raging in Yorktown, Indiana. | There have been 54 cases and 18 deaths. The j G. W. MORNINGSTAR, The report states the amount of sales to be 38 West Main St., BENJ. F. CROUSE. Clerk. True Copy.—Test: novdtf WESTMINSTER, MD.

See the clipping

The News Boy · Benton, Mo.

The item reports that the Interstate Commerce Commission began proceedings against nearly all western railroads for violating the long and short haul clause, and that H. H. Holmes was convicted of first-degree murder in the killing of Benjamin F. Pietzet at Philadelphia.

The News Boy · 9 November 1895 · page 4

The interstate commerce commis sion has commenced proceedings against nearly all the western rail roads for infraction of the long and short baul clause. . H. H. Holmes, the multi-murderer, was convicted of murder in the first degree for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzet, at Philadelphia.

See the clipping

Lyon County Times · Silver City, Nev.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, charged with a dozen murders, was convicted in Philadelphia of murdering Benjamin F. Pitzel in only a week, with a double guard placed on his cell to prevent suicide until execution, contrasting with the three months needed to convict in the Durrant case.

Lyon County Times · 9 November 1895 · page 3

The Kant More Speedy. H. H. Holmes, charged with a dozen murders, has been convicted in Philadelphia of murdering Ben jamin F. Pitzel. Extra care has been taken so that he cannot com mit suicide. A double guard has been placed on his cell and will re main there until he is executed. It is a noteworthy fact, as showing the difference in proceedings East and West, that it required only a week to convict Holmes while it re quired over three months to secure a like result in the Durrant case.

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

This fragment describes spectators leaving the courtroom after the judge's charge to discuss the likely verdict, with opinions divided though most leaned toward believing the case against Holmes had been established.

Narragansett Herald · 9 November 1895 · page 8

HOLMES GUILTY. Verdict of Murder in the First Degree.

nold’s eharge, and the .:Socutors streamed out into the corridors eazerly discussed what the verdiet would probably be. There was considerable difference of opinion, as many believed the commonwealth had not thoroughly established its case against Holmes, but the majority were inclined to be

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

The jury returned a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree against Holmes, who showed little visible emotion upon hearing the word. His attorney moved for a new trial, with the judge setting a hearing for November 18, while the district attorney expressed doubt that a new trial would be granted.

Narragansett Herald · 9 November 1895 · page 8

The charge of tho’-dgo must have fore shadowed what his fate weuld be, but the word “Guilty” fell upon Holmes with stun ning force. He made no outery nor exhibited emotion of any kind. He sat down while the jury was polled, and as each man pro nounced his sentence Holmes stared vacant ly before him. His face was that of a corpse.

See the clipping

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The clipping states that a jury found Holmes guilty of murder in the first degree within twenty minutes, describing the jury as relentless but just.

Martinsburg Independent · 9 November 1895 · page 2

Holmes found a relentless, though a just jury, which found a verdict against him of murder in the first de gree, within twenty minutes after

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A fragment quotes a letter from District Attorney Graham thanking witnesses, including some from Fort Worth, Tex., who attended voluntarily, for aiding the commonwealth of Pennsylvania in the trial of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with homicide.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 10 November 1895 · page 1

FRIENDS OF JUSTICE.

j Fort Worth, Tex., who voluntarily at ! tended court without any process of j law. To these witnesses D 'strict Attor , ney Graham has addressed the follow ing letter: "I desire to express to you mv warm appreciation of the manner in which you aided the commonwealth of Penn sylvania in the recent trial of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with homicide. Your loyalty

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, on trial for murder in Philadelphia, indicated his defense would claim Pitezel committed suicide while drunk.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 13 November 1895 · page 6

Domestic. James Doylo and Joe Eramett. two of Bu falo BUl's rough riders, quarrelled at A lanta, Ga. Doyle shot and killed Emme and made his escape. Theshootingoccurre In a camp at the exposition grounds. The Rev. V. Snlndler, of Shakopee, Minn was either murdered or in a fit of desponi ency took his own life. The bsdy was foun in a little irrove. Three bullet holes wei found near his heart and a revolver lay b< side him. Dr. Orlando E. Bradford, the convicts counterfeiter, turned State's evidence i New York City against the Brockway ganj Judge Brown in the United States Circu sentenced him to six years in the King Pftiinfr Ponlfonfiort* A crash in industrial sharps created gre; excitement on the Philadelphia Stock Ej chance.

See moreSee less

There was a shrinkage in the valu of Ave industrial specialties of 84,650,000' i two hours. Burglars entered the PostofTlce at Dariei Conn., blew open the safe, stole stamps an money and then set fire to the building. The General Term. Supreme Court, sui tained Justice B'-afh's decision forhiddin the use of the State Democracy's emblei (the rooster) above the New York Democrat! State ticket on the official ballot. Chief Engineer Green,of the Dock Depar ment, New York City, swore in the Account Commissioners' investigation that he ser two *125 checks to Kichard Croker in orde to hold his position. At Columbia, S. C.. the Constitution! Convention took a vote on the. propositio to allow woman's suffrage with property an educational qualifications. The cause < woman was beaten by a vote of 121 to twei ty-slx. ' H. FI. Holmes, on trial for murder in Phi adelphia, Penn., indicated that his line < defence would be that Pitezel committe suicide while drunk. Holmes's lawyer ri turned to his defence. An enthusiastic meeting was held i Cooper Union. New York City, for the pui pose of arousing enthusiasm for the issuanc of SO.OuO.OOO of bonds for the improvemer of the canals of the State. James J. Van Alen was arrpstea in i>ev port, R. I., on ii writ sworn out by Colom S. P. Colt, charging alienation of hia wife affections, and gave $200,000 bail. In New York City. District Attorney Fe lows recommended the dismissal of Lexo inquiry indictments, and the Committee c Seventy's representatives consented. The faculty of the University of Virginii Charlottesville, Ya.. appointed a comrnitte to secure the rebuilding of the burned rc tundn. Justice Beac'a decided, in New York Citj that the Stnte Democracy's emblem (th rooster) could not be printed on the officii ballot above the names of tho candidates o the Democratic State ticket. Thirty million bushels of eoal, ready fc shipment from Pittsburg could not be move owinc to low water. Epidemics of diseae caused by staenant water are productive c distress in Western Pennsylvania. Dr. James B. Carpenter, brother-in-law < ex-Governor P.aswell P. Flower, killed bin self in Qouverneur, N. Y. The 213th anniversary of the landing < William Penti was celebrated by the 13J,0C public school pupils of Philadelphia. Cuban Day. at tho Atlanta Exposition, hs been postponed to December 17. Great anxiety is felt for the winter when crop in the West, because of the long coutit ued drought. Patrick King Callahan, of New Yori. jumped from the highest part of the Pougl keepsie (N. Y.) Bridge? i distance of 212 fee ?and died. He once jumped from th

See the clipping

Randolph Enterprise · Beverly, W. Va.

A jury convicted Howard Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, of murdering Benjamin F. Pietzel, his counsel moved for a new trial, and Holmes afterward claimed innocence while admitting he had staged the corpse to look accidental for insurance money.

Randolph Enterprise · 13 November 1895 · page 1

Howard Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was found guilty Saturday evening of the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel. The jury retired at 5:10 o'clock in the afternoon, and though their verdict was unanimously reached on the first ballot, they thought it befitting the gravity of the occasion to pause before returning to court. Consequently, they ate their sup per and were back in court at 10 minutes before 9 o’clock. When the verdict was announced Holmes stood in the dock, his pallor only seeming to grow a little deeper than usual.

See moreSee less

He made a great ex hibition of nerve as the wonts that may send him to the gallows were announced. His counsel, Mr. Rotan, immediately made a motion for a new trial, based nptyi the in sufficiency of the evidence that Pietzel had been murdered, and Judge Arnold fixed November 18 as the date for hearing argument upon the motion. 11 Judge Arnold refuses a new trial the case will probably be carried to the Supreme Court. After being taken back to jail Holmes made a statement in which he said that he was innocent, and that while lack of time and money to prepare his case had brought about this temporary defeat of jus tice, he was sure of being vindi cated in the end. He claimed that he had told the truth when he ad mitted that the body found was reallj that of Pietzel, and that he had arranged the corpse so as to suggest accident, in order that his family might get the insurance money. Holmes is suspected of having murdered 28 persons to defraud in surance companies of the amount of the policies upon'their lives. Be side the murder of Benjamin F, Pietzel, he is alleged fo have killed Alice, Minnie and Howard Pietzel, child.en of Benjamin; Julia A Con nor, her daughter, Pearl Connor; Emeline C. Cigraml, his stenogra pher; Robert E. Phelps, who ac

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A formal application for a new trial for Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of Benjamin P. Pitzel, was filed in the Quarter Sessions Court, with argument to be heard Monday.

The San Francisco Call · 14 November 1895 · page 3

HOLMES ` APPLICATION FILED. Date Set for the Arguments on tit* Motion for a JVeto Trial. PHILADELPHIA, Pa.. Nov. 13.-For mal application for a new trial for Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, recently convicted of the murder of Benjamin P. Pitzel, was to-day filed in the Quarter Ses sions Court. The document was presented by Lawyers Samuel P. Kotan and William A. Shoemaker, and the court will hear the argument on Monday next. Fog Whistle Will Sound.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A brief, cut-off clipping from Philadelphia reports that H. H. Holmes has formally filed a motion for a new trial, with the grounds to be argued shortly, before the text breaks off.

The Herald · 14 November 1895 · page 2

MULTLMURDERER HOLMES Makes Application for Another Trial of His Case The Grounds of the Motion Are Formally Sit Forth-The Question Will Be ArgueJ ."loudly PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 13.— H. H.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A Philadelphia dispatch dated Nov. 13 reports that a formal application for a new trial has been filed, though the clipping is cut off and the name is garbled in the OCR.

The Morning News · 14 November 1895 · page 1

HOLMES’ NEW TH INI.. The Application nf His Attorneys Now on File, Philadelphia, Nov. 13.—Formal applica tion for u new trial for Herman W. Mud

See the clipping

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

The fragment states that H. H. Holmes, recently found guilty of murdering B. A. Pitzel, had his attorney file a petition with the court demanding something, but the text is cut off before the demand is specified.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 14 November 1895 · page 1

topada. — H. H. Holmes, u znany niedawno winnym za mordowania B. A. Pitzla, przez swego adwokata wniósł do są du podanie z żędaniem, odno

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A garbled fragment in which Holmes argues his case should be granted, claiming charges against him were baseless and describing methods used regarding district assemblies and votes, though the text is too damaged to follow clearly.

The Topeka State Journal · 14 November 1895 · page 2

WANTS A NEW TRIAL.

Holmes Sets Forth a Long List of Reason Why It Should Be Granted. He explained the methods which he knows his charges against me were without foundation. There never was had been used to weed out the district a time when his combined vote and assemblies, and said the assembly for mine would have nominated him in

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The clipping reports H. H. Holmes, convicted of murder, is seeking a new trial with a motion to be argued next month, then abruptly shifts into an unrelated, fragmentary account of political maneuvering involving Senator Ingalls and a Mr. Burton over congressional and Senate support.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 14 November 1895 · page 1

work and put forth our -whole efforts to ward the advancement of tho equal suffraga cause." HOLMES WANTSA NEW TRIAL. bets I orth 11 l.oiiK I Ibt nf ICeatons liy It houtd Ho (irtiuted t'o Jto Argued cxt Moult..). rlill.idelphln, Nov. 13. H. H. Holmes, tlio nllesed multl-inurilcier, who was lecenlly convicted of tho murder of for congress und came within ouo vote of seeming the ltcpubllcau caucus nomi nation at tlio time when thu succe.sbor to Senator .Mm tin was being balloted for. Ho bus kept up lilt, oiganlzntlou nml Is very strong In tho btate, Senator Ingalls has lost noun of his personal prestige but the men upon whom ho telled In tho past for tmppott are mostly dead or gone away.

See moreSee less

Sir. Burton luus tho best of the light, so far as organisation is eoncerneil." "Will tho Democrats be In the con

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This damaged clipping reports a runaway train car fatally crashing into a locomotive near Shorthill, killing engineer Ruben Tidill and injuring fireman Hiram Rush, alongside brief items on foreign stock markets, Cincinnati stockholders disputing liability, H. H. Holmes's counsel filing for a new trial, and a college cornerstone laying in Iowa.

The Anaconda Standard · 14 November 1895 · page 2

Holmes Files His Appeal

Delaware. Lackawana & Western rail way. near Shorthill. to-day. ,broke away from the locomotive sad ran back at a great speed, crashing into the lo. comotive of a aswsoaper tN The engineer of the newspaper at was killed and the fireman bedly injured. The englneer was Ruben Tidill of Washington. N. J.. and the freman Hiram Rush. Th,, ForreigS Xarkhe London, Nov. il--The tendeacy was firm in both mining shares and forelg_ stocks to-day. Paris, Nov. l-.-The markdt to-day is recovering from the reent depression. Berlin. Nov. L--BDusiess on the boutes to-day was fiat.

See moreSee less

vasellating and generally weak on bad reports from Vienna. Vienna. Nov. 13.-The market to-day was decidedly weak. Cimeinmmatl .oekheldks. Cincinnatl Nov. 12.-Residents of this city holding l$8,000 stock o"f he Co lumbia Niat fnasl biFr Tacoma met to-day. preparatory to the me~oting of all the stckholders in CMcago Nov. 31. Tie : -;-k was or.ginally $"0A.OO and a.ftern ard Increased to $500000. Of thil addItional $300.000, orgy $137.004 was paid up. The Ctncinnatt stockh lders inaintain that they are not liable for the new stock. lloimes Filee His 4pseas. Philadietphia. Nov. 1S.-H. H. Holmes. ta:e all ied multi-murderer. w>h, was S.n:tly c-nvicted of the murder of B. F. l'::.. I. t,-day. t'rough -hs c"unsel. !!1 I rt - .ns ,r a new trial. L id T'ecr Cormer btss.. Lam nr. Iowa. Nov. 13.-The La.tter l.ay S..+a:s laid the corner stone of I t.ti1r colhere to-dav. Bhhon . L Ke1lly

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The fragment lists claimed trial errors, including the district attorney's mention of children's deaths and morgue findings, and rulings on what Mrs. Pitezel was or was not allowed to testify about her husband.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 14 November 1895 · page 1

For the reason that the district attorne in his closing speech mentioned the deatg of the children and the finding of theis dead bodiés in the morgue. The court erred in allowing Mrs. Pitezel to testify or state what her husband had told her; in not allowing Mrs. Pitezel tq testify of her own knowledge to the do: ings of her husband in Terre Haute, Ind.; in allowing the testimony of Mrs. Pitezel

See the clipping

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

A short humorous item quotes Holmes complaining that a man named Durant is receiving more notoriety than he deserves. The brief aside treats Holmes as a recognizable public figure amid ongoing press coverage.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 14 November 1895 · page 3

Professional Jealousy. It seems to me this man Durant is got ting a great doal more notoriety than he is entitled to.—H. H. Holmes.—Chicago Tribune.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering B. F. Pitezel, has filed reasons for a new trial through his counsel, to be argued the following Monday. The grounds cite prejudicial statements by the district attorney about other crimes and the deaths of the children, plus alleged errors in evidentiary rulings and jury instructions.

The Providence News · 14 November 1895 · page 7

PHILADRLPHIA, Nov, 14.—H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitezel, through his oounu"; yesterday, filed rea sous for a new trial’on the grounds which will be argued next Monday, namely: ¥or the reason that the distriet attorney in his opening speech made statements which related to other crimes which could not be part of the evidence, and they were of such a terrible nature that their effect on the jury was so adverse to the defend ant that it was impossible for them to de eide purely upon the evidence in this case.

See moreSee less

For the reason that the district attorney in his closing speech mentioned the death of the children aud the finding of their dead bodles in the morgue. The court erred in allowing Mrs. Pitezel to testify or state what her husband had told her; in not allowing Mrs, Pitezel to testify of her own knowledge to the do ings of her husband in Terre Haute, Ind.; in allowing the testimony of Mrs. Pitezel

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitezel in Philadelphia, has filed reasons for a new trial, based chiefly on the district attorney and Mrs. Pitezel mentioning other crimes attributed to him.

Alexandria Gazette · 14 November 1895 · page 2

NEWS OF THE DAY.

ough have given up the Virginian trip, and will Bail for Genoa on Saturday. of bis feeble health there was no cele? bration of the event. Scotland, was yesterday presented to Ambassadar Bayard upon the occasion Australia. Hillyen, and Missouri as his home, was mont Methodist Episcopal church, New York, on Tuesday declined to E. Andrews, on the ground that it was Georgia Legislature in the hall of the House of Delegates at Atlanta last night The fight will b9 a hot one, as the elec? NEWS OF THE DAY. The Duke and Duches* of Marlbor Judge Allen G.

See moreSee less

Thurman was eighty two years old yesterday. On account The freedom of the city of Dundee, of his opening the Fine Art Exhibition. Elizabeth Kelly, aged twenty-five years, daughter of a gardner in Phila? delphia, is said to have fallen heiress to $15,000.000 by the death of an uncle in Mr. John T. Gray, clerk of the Court of Common Pleas, and ex-marshal of police of Baltimore, died suddenly last night of heart disease at his residence in Baltimore. A man giving his name as Thomas arrested at the White House, in Wash? ington, yesterday, and his sanity will be inquired into. It is understood that a feature of tbe treaty for the surrender of Port Arthur is that its evacut tion by Japan will not be followed by a cession of the fortress by China or any other power. Rev. D. Searle3, pastor of the Tre baptize the dying child of Dr. Walter not essential lor the child's salvation. Ex Speaker Crisp addressed the on tbe issues of the day. Hoke Smith, Secretary of the Interior, has been in vited to make a similar address at his convenience. H. H. Holmes, convicted of tbe mur? der of B. F. Pitezel, in Philadelphia, has filed bis reasons why he should have a new trial. He bases his appli? cation principally on the mention by the district attorney and Mrs. Pitezel of other crimes attributed to Holmes. Pinkney Bennett (democrat), of Car? roll county, Md., just re-elected to the State Senate, died yesterday. It is supposed that an election lor his suc? cessor will be ordered immediately. tion of a republican will .give the con? trol of the State Senate to the republi? cans.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va. · and 1 other paper

A formal application for a new trial for Herman W. Mudgett alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin F. Pietzel, was filed in Quarter-Sessions Court, citing fifteen reasons including newly discovered evidence and improper remarks by the District Attorney.

The Times · 14 November 1895 · page 2

HOLMES ASKS 10 4 NEW TRIAL, New Matter Alleged to Have Been Dis covered since the Trial, PHILADELPHIA, PA., Nov. 13.—For mal application for a new trial for Her man W. Mudgett alias H. H. Holmes, recently convicted of the murder of Beu jamin F. Pietzel, was to-day filed In the Quarter-Sessions Court. The document was presented by Law vers Samuel PP. Rotan and W. A. Shoe maker, and the Court will hear argu ment on Monday next. [fifteen reasons why a new trial should be granted are given, the first three alleging that the verdict is contrary to the evidence, The fourth asserts that new matter has been discovered since the trial, and the fifth declares that *‘the Distriet Attorney, in his opening speech, made statements which were not proved, and which re ated to other crimes, which could not be part of the evidence, and they were of such a terrible nature that their ef fect on the jurors was of necessity so adverse to the defendant that it was im possible for them to decide purely upon the evidence in this case.” It is urged that the District Attorney in his closing address mentioned the death of the children ,and the finding of thelr dead bodies, and it is claimed that the Court erred in several particu lars, specitied.

See moreSee less

&

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 14 November 1895

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This badly damaged clipping references H. H. Holmes's conviction for the murder of B. F. Pitxel and separately mentions Constantinople and a Turkish minister of foreign affairs, but the surrounding text is too scrambled to summarize further.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 14 November 1895 · page 1

te-.-*ttfv to see tng M'lhlner with Miss Lewis Philadelphia, Nov. 13. H. H. Holmes, the em the lawn of Mooar' s house, and to alleged multi-murderer, who wu recently prove further that, instead of leaving at convicted of the murder of B, F. Pitxel, to | their very lives, has been due to the sub stantial and vigorous action of Mr. Ter < onstantinople. Nov. 13.-The Turkish j reil a* the sublimt* port*, and in every minfster ->f foreign affairs. T. «fik Pasha,

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

The clipping reports that Holmes, convicted of murder in Philadelphia, expects a new trial and is cheerful, while Hooker T. Washington wrote Senator Tillman opposing denying education to negroes in South Carolina.

Mineral Point Tribune · 14 November 1895 · page 2

Howe was among the thirty delegates, II 11 Holmes, convicted of the mur der of Benjamin K. Pitezel, in Phila delphia. Pa,, fully expects to have a new trial, and is cheerful in conse quence. Hooker T Washington, a southern negro lender, wrote an open letter to Senator Tillman against the proposi tion to deny education to the negroes of South Carolina.

See the clipping

Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, tried in Philadelphia for killing Benjamin F. Pitezel, was convicted of murder in the first degree, with a fragmentary, unclear reference to burglars in Henderson, Minn.

Iowa County Democrat · 14 November 1895 · page 2

H. H. Holmes, tried in Phlladel phla for 'lining llenjnmln I l ’. Pilz.'d, was convicted of murder in the first degree. Henderson, Minn,., burglars are

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

The clipping sarcastically invites anyone not murdered by H. H. Holmes to rise and remain standing until counted.

The American Citizen · 15 November 1895 · page 1

All those who have not been mur dered by H. H. Holmes will please rise and remain standing until counted.

See the clipping

The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.

Among other items, this report says H. H. Holmes, described as a multi-murderer, was found guilty of murdering B. F. Pietzel in Philadelphia, alongside Theodore Durant's conviction in San Francisco.

The Webster Echo · 15 November 1895 · page 1

A GOOD INbTITUTION. Webster Springs Sanita • - , ■- ■•.../ -v ... • . Starts Out With Flattering Prospects and is an Undoubted Success Fiom the Very Statt—Is Un der Direction of Skillful The Webster Springs Private Sanitarium means business. This "winter the cure and its merits will be advertised in different papers and journals throughout West Vir_ .•ginia. A pamphlet will soon be out in the interest of the Sani» tarium, and will be circulated far and near. It will contain, besides treaties upon drug habits, etc., a HI iull analysis of the famous salt anlphur water, its merits and great ►curative properties; also, a full ^ v-' .description of picturesque Addi ; ^eon and Webster county.

See moreSee less

__ y . This cure is no experiment—is isafe, sure and speedy. It has been ! '-deduced by arduous study of the I toxic effect of alcohol and its anti -dote. The manager is operating . * ' the latest improved cure, adopted =aDd authorized by a large Chicago -stock company of eminent physi cians. The most careful^'attention will he given the treatment—the best of medical attention to the phys 1 ical condition of each patient, each being thoroughly examined four dimes a-day. Addison has a first-class bath house, and hot and cold baths will be prescribed throughout the course of treatment. Dr. Simpson is here to stay. Be , is now fitting up convenient and well appointed office rooms m the , 4*» - Hamrick block, and aside from making a success of the Sani ftarium, the doctor will be a wide .a-wake and progressive citizen, , always oh the alert for the best in ' derests of both town and county* Let the mothers, wives and sis ters help in this noble effort to re store :the fallen ones that are dear do their hearth-stones. Already .-several cases for inebriacy and to # bacco are undergoing treatment, while the management is in cor respondence with numerous others , ' looking in that direction. Two of the moat remarkable murdex .cases ever tried in this country ended last week with ver dicts of guilty of murder in first -degree in each case. Theodore Durant was found guilty of mur dering Blanche Lament in San .Francisco, and H. H. Holmes, the multi-murderer, was found guilty of murdering B. F. Pietzel in Philadelphia. These cases have „ .been the main topicof discussion an the newspapers for months and ithere appears to be no doubt of the .guilt of both men. They each appear to have developed a mania for killing. Durant has killed two innocent girls and there is no telling the number of Holmes’ wictims according to all reports.— 'Tribune. '■: rium.; Physicians.

See the clipping

The Diamond Drill · Crystal Falls, Mich.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia of the murder of H. F. Pitzel.

The Diamond Drill · 16 November 1895 · page 2

through his counsel filed reasons for a liew trial. Laredo, Tex., and then killed himself. the United States from Hawaii to suc Frnnclivo. 0., killing William Lamest, John Adams nnd two unknown men. Allen O. Thurman passed his !2d birth there was no celebration of the event. Nevada, Mo. She w as born In Missouri ii 1 years before it became a state. train near Pirmlmham, Ala., nnd Tony Cunningham, Mose M cGce and Stephen McDonald were killed. 1he laughter of William Kelly, u poor purdener in Philadelphia, receives $15, ii Worcester, Mass.

See moreSee less

paper box factory in LJchmond, Ya., was totally det-. troyed by lire, the loss being $150,000. of Labor in Washington Giand Master Sovereign declared t he order to be In u flourishing condition. foundered off Locknwuy inlet, near New York, and th? five jn-rsons on board were drovv ned. leeeiver with liabilities of $:;oo,0(i0. In New Jeisey for governor show a to 1.15,1 for MeGill (dem.), making CrL'g' plurality 2 -v40. that all the Armenian Christian teach distr icts had Ik en kill 1 by Turks. Thomas FIIm and Frank Orr were suf Unlimited aid independent e'dnege of silver at the r-tio of sixteen to one. itants. LATER. H. H. Holmes, convicted in Philadel phia of the murder of H. F. Pitzel, William Kuntz murdered Mrs. Caro line Menu and her ten-year-old girl ut A. T. Hatch, 'appointed minister to ceed Minister Thurston, arrived at San Freight trains collided near Warw ick, At his home in Columbus, O., Judge day. On account of his feeble health Mrs. Purnett ()uiek, aged M, died nt A freight train collided with a work I'.y the death of an uncle In Australia ()';i .onit. The National Grange Patrons of Hus bandry opened i t h "'Jth annual scs:.ion The main building of the Landolph At the national assembly of Knights The steamboat James W. Hoyle The Marinette Iron works at West Du 1" t It, Minn., went Into the hands of n The riHieial returns of the elcition tal vote of l(,.J.r,:).J for Griggs (rep.) and A dispatch from Constantinople ray ers in the T rliionde nnd Fl.erouiil At J!ii!ow, Did., .1 in I Linden, focated by foul fin in a well. In an nddrrss before th Gcorgin leg b la t are ''x Speaker Crisp d clrt i d him self tine.iiioc iliy in fator of the free,

See the clipping

The Madisonian · Virginia City, Mont.

The clipping reports Chicago roads refusing to aid the Great Northern against a possible strike, a mine reopening at Amasa, and brief criminal news items including a murder conviction, a silk-theft scheme, and a hotel death.

The Madisonian · 16 November 1895 · page 7

All Chicago roads have decined to aid the Great Northern should the A. R. U. declare a strike. President Hill of the Great Northern says that he is not afraid of any strike on that road. Should there be a strike, he adds, the road is well prepared for any emergency which may arise. The Hemlock mine at Amasa, the northernmost mine of the Menominee range, -«ill 6tart up this week with a fair force. The property has been idle since 1893, when it shipped 12,000 tons. Although there is some trouble on the Great Northern system, the threatened strike has not yet assumed serious pro portions.

See moreSee less

Officials are confident that they are in a position to maintain regu lar train service. criminal news. Ten persons in Mexico were burned as heretics by order of a judge. The arrest of an Italian disclosed a big silk stealing system in New York. Octave Thanet; defends Miss Flagler for shooting the negro hoy,Ernest Green, at Washington. Durrant was convicted of the murder of Blanche Lamont at Ban Francisco. His sentence is death. The relatives of Dr. Fraker have agreed to return the money received from insurance companies. » Mrs. H. B. Branch was found dead in ! an Indianapolis hotel. Her husband • said that she killed herself, Tipton (Mo.) boys and girls will be ' prosecuted for disturbing the peace [ while celebrating Halloween. H. H. Holmes was found guilty of the 1 LA BOR NEWS. ! • ' [ 1

See the clipping

The Jamesburg Record · Jamesburg, N.J.

The clipping, cut off mid-sentence, reports that a life-size figure of H. H. Holmes, recently convicted of murder in Philadelphia, has been added to an unnamed chamber.

The Jamesburg Record · 16 November 1895 · page 1

AMUSEMENTS.

H. H. Holmes, the great criminal who wa« recently convicted of murder in Philadelphia, in the shape of a life-size figure lias been added to the chamber of

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Philadelphia American reports that Hall Caine visited H. H. Holmes in Moyamensing prison with two companions, describing an emotional meeting after which Caine said he was thankful he was not a judge and could never carry out such a sentence.

The Indianapolis Journal · 18 November 1895 · page 4

He Could Never Do II. Philadelphia American. Hall Calne, the noted novelist, and H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer, on Mon day shook bands in Moyamcr.sing. Mr. Calne. Just prior to hi departure from - the city, and In company with Prof. H. H. Hay and Dr. Charles M. Seltzer. Journ.yed to the prison to virlt the famous criminal, and uron his return said: it is true that I went to Moyamensinr to see him. I am reluctant that It should get out. because It might look si If I wer trying to arouse sympathy for Holmes, the lat thins In the world which I would do.

See moreSee less

Before I went there I hesitated some time, to satisfy myself that it wa not morbid curiosity that took me. I have always been deeply interested In remarkaole criminals. In Holmes's face I saw nothing of crlmlnat appearance. He seemed to me Itke a man -of Intellect, and I was reminded of the great poisoner Wainwrlght. The interview affected me very Touch. After we had talked a little the tear came to his rye and his voice choked. That wa too much for me. and I broke down ani had to leave, t'nderstand me. I am rot in any way plead ing for him. nor would I lift a rtneer to stay the hand of Justice. But as I walked away I said to myself: "Thank God. I'm not a Judge, 1 could never do it!". s'

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Brief news items report Cuban insurgent defeats, a denied-likely retrial motion for Holmes over the Pitezel murder, a Jamestown merchant's suicide, a fatal duel in Indiana, new races in Mexico City, and Venezuela's suppression of revolutionists.

Alexandria Gazette · 18 November 1895 · page 2

TELE?RAPHIC_BREVITIES. Reports of further insurgent defeats come from Cuba. A motion for a new trial for Holmes, convicted of the murder of Pitezel, was made in Philadelphia to-day, but will probably be refused. Homer S. Atwood, 50 years of age, a leading merchant of Jamestown, N. Y., and a prominent member of the M. ?. Church, committed suieide by hanging himself in his store this morning. A blcoly duel was fought Saturday at Whitehall, a small hamlet west of Blooming ton, Ind., bet wen Sam Neil I and Thomas Wil? liams, two highly respected young men, over the affections of a well-known young laiy.

See moreSee less

Neill was fatally iojured by a dirk in the hands of Williams. The inaugural races of E. C. Pate's now track were held at the City of Mexico yester? day under most favorable auspicie*. The wealth and fash:on of the capital turned out, and more than five thousand persons, at? tended. The Venezuelan government has succeeded in frustrating the plans of the revolutionists. The principal leaders have been captured and peace will be established in a very short time. Methodist Conference. Richmond, Va., Nov. IS.?The morn ing services of the Methodist Confer? ence of "Virginia were occupied in dis? cussing the reports on temperance and Sunday schools and in its delivery of memorial addresses.

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

This damaged clipping mixes an unrelated adoption item with a claim that Shoemaker paid a woman $20 to swear a murder victim had committed suicide, alongside fragmentary health warnings about vitality.

Waterbury Democrat · 19 November 1895 · page 3

HE WAS EXPOSED IN OPEN COURT

home by rheumatism. Judge Benton and wife have gone to Cheshire to-day to try to get, for adop tion, a twelve "years old girl, whose par ents were relatives of Mrs Benton's, but who have passed away. tending to prove that Benjamin F. Pite nervous energies. It brings weakness zel, of whose murder Holmes was convict and loss of vitality. It adds new dangers ed two weeks ago, committed suloide, and to her condition. What doe3 it do to that . he (Shoemaker) paid a woman $20 to future generations? It robs them of the sign and swear to this. But tho common robust vitality and nervous force they wealth had supplied the woman, although ought to have. It starts them in life weak I otter means aro exhausted."

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 3 other papers

A Chicago paper reports that streetcar conductor James McNeary claims Pitezel boarded his car disguised by a beard, admitted his identity, asked for silence, and was also recognized by motorman Letterman before transferring to another line.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Waterbury Democrat · 19 November 1895 · page 3

Chicago, Nov. 19. A local paper publishes the following story James MoNeary, conductor on of the Sixty-third street electric line, has sprang a new sensation in the Holmes case by stating that Benjamin F. Pitezel is alive, and that he recently talked with him on his car. Mr. MoNeary claims there could be no mistake, aa he worked nine months for Pitezel and knows the peculiarities of his voice. According to MoNeary, Pitezel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes' trial. Pitezel's beard had grown around the greater part of his face, so that he was completely disguised.

See moreSee less

When ad dressed, however, he admitted his identity and asked aa a friend that McNeary keep silent, as he was on his way to Philadel phia, but McNeary called in Motorman Letterman, and he, too, claims that he had a conversation with Pitezel, who took a.-transfer to the Cottage Grove line. i2r..-iLObert.CJorbett viha haa -been fal Pitezel Said to Be Alive. car 676 !

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · 19 November 1895
  • Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · 19 November 1895
  • The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me. · 20 November 1895

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · and 1 other paper

A Philadelphia dispatch reports that William Shoemaker, senior defense counsel in the Holmes murder trial, was held under $1,500 bail after a sting operation by detectives and the district attorney showed he had arranged for a woman to sign a false affidavit claiming the murder victim had spoken of suicide.

The Herald · 19 November 1895 · page 1

SUBORNATION OF PERJURY

Asioclated Press Special Wire. PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 18.-Tbe evil ■pirit that presides over ttae destinies of H. H. Holmes, the king of murderers, •nd eventually destroys all who ally themselves with him, found another vic tim today. The nist swift turn this extraordinary case to k was on tue brat day of the recent trial, wneti the arch criminal dismissed his lawyers and "the prisoner at the bar" became counsel for the defense. Today the tables were turned ami senior counsel for the de tense became a prisoner at the bar. William Shoemaker, the young attorney Wbose first association with the ctse is obscured in the mystery whicn envelops Its every detail, passed through an ordeal today as seveie as any his cl ent has been compelled to f ice and tin crisis came when be was held under $1501) bill to an swer a charge ol suoornation of perjury.

See moreSee less

This meuns that the manufactured evi dence tending to prove that Benjamin Jr. Pilzel, for whose murder Holm's was Convicted two weeks ago, committer sul ci le and that be. Sbosroak r. paid a wo man $21) to sign and swear to this, but the commonwealth had supplied the wo man, although Shoemaker was ignorant of this, ami after be bad produced this "after discovered evidence" and read it with great impresslveuess to the court and asked that the argument on tbe mo tion lor a new trial, which nad been fixed lor today, be postponed to give him and bis associate cuu isel, Samuel I. Kotan, timt to run out this and other clues re cently obtained, tben it waa that tbe district attorney arose and exposed tbe pl.t. His declaration came like a thun derbolt. The ciuit stared in wide-eyed amazement, the spectators turned In their cnairs and gasped, the accused lawyer Bank back in bis seat livid and tremulous while his innocent associate glared at biru with unveiled horror, but tue pris oner in tbe dock rested bis cold blue eyos on tbe sbri .king tig ore of his legal representative and smiled w.th score. .Briefly toll.- the uct.uls of t c cbarge are these: Tbe Irial tor tue Pitzel mur der was not two days old wheo Sbo»mak er appnaoued a private detectivenamed John Bcuneichler and asked him to pro euro a woman mo lived around Four teenth and Callowbill or Vance street, who would swear to certain facts In con nection witn the finding of Pilzel's body, tichwe.chler assented, but instead of straightway getting the woman, he told his story to Detective Geyer, who, tor the comoinn wealth, brought to light the evidence uf Holme*' murdar of the chil dren. Uoyer submitted it to tbe district attorney, and a must skilful tr.,p was prepared, ■ trao which has brought about tbe ruin of the oppos ng attorney. Under instructions, Geycr went to Mrs. Mmgaret Keab, matron of the Fourtn district police station, mid she, under the name of Blanche A. Hannigan, was taken to Shoemaker by Bcbweichler. Meantime hnoemaker had prepared an atfldaivt, stat.ng that the deponent had ki.own Pils land lo her be bad expressed his intent.on ol committing suicid '. Mrs. Hannigan readily signed and swore to tn s, and Shoemaker gave her two $10 bill* for so doing. On each bill she marked the initials "B. A. H.," and to day s.ie exhibi.ed them in court. bnoemaKer walked into the trap blind fold. Wil li i,u read tbe ..tfiilavil to the court he declared that its contents bud been dictated to uiin by the woman. - A moment afterwards irrefutable testimony was produced snowing that he had vim self made up the affidavit atid dictated it to a stenographer before he had even asked bchweiculer lo procure a woman to sign it, and tuat he hud not so much as read or explained its purport to Mrs. Ha.rugan. Judge Arnold, who was upon the bench during the triul, had called in Jud es Thayer and vVil«on to bear and decide with him on the merits of today's argu ments for a new trial. As tue Miange revelations come the ihreo judges uid not liesit te by their bear.ng an i word* to manifest their sense of tna graiily of the aci used lawyer's situation. Juoge Arn old afterwards privately stated that din barmen! pro.i.edings would he consuleied after the disposition of tbe pending charge uuainsi Shoemaker, j, Bhnemaker hud nothing to say. He whs Stunned and shookeu beyond [l eis ure, hot said Ibis was not the time lor him to talk. Kotan, bis associate, ex presse I I.is confide ice in his coll ague's final exiineniti but he admitted that the cvi ence of bis guilt was overwhelm ing. liotau hi ns If was unimirobed. Tue witi es c-, the district attorney and. the court were cnretul to make that dear an I the voting liarnsleT. who had fought practically single-handed a battle against treme dn s ud Is, with some skill and some fortitude, was visibly affected. A stiunge *tory is wiiipsered about Bhoen.ak. r's mil al appearance in this cas '. A little over a ve.r n..0, it in said, lie li st came to P:iiladuipnia. Whi'iice be tame no one teemed lo know, but a tale is tn the effect that he hud been for some time in a little town tn Indiana. Upon his arrival here he is smd to have epuken of the reception of a leiter from Boston signed "H." It staled the writer desired to retain vim as counsel in s cuse vih eh would soon afterward co ne up in Phiia nil hia, and enclosed a 100 note as are siner fee. A few aye afterward Holmewai arrested in Boston and the Story of biS manifold crimes came out. No* it is said that the Utile town in whc.li Shi o.naker lived was but a short distance irom nnotner town where Holmes had lived and fostered his multi farious schemes. It is even said mat in ft hue maker's office has men found a map of the cuiintry in which these two towns 'fie, and thai a line is drawn in red ink Vdaeen toe | laces, but so drawn as to avoid railroads and settlements, cutting through the tare cuuntrv. This curious story is not given out officially, but with those who know of it there is an unanim ity as to its details. The Hoi nes case was tbe first Shoemake, tried in Phila delphia. It is also rooably the lust. ■indue Arnold, who presided during the trial whirl] resulted in Holmes' con viction for murder of B. F. Pitzel, was today joined by Judges Tnayet and Wil

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · 19 November 1895

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping, garbled by OCR, describes how Schwechler was asked to find a woman to swear to facts about Pitezel's body being found at 1816 Callowhill street, but instead told Detective Geyer, leading to evidence against Holmes.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 19 November 1895 · page 1

SENSATIONAL SCENE IN COURT

8ohwechler and asked him to procure a a Î oman who lived around Twelfth hlrteenth and Callowhill or Vino streets, who would swear to certain facte in noctlon with the finding of Pitozel'g body at 1816 Callowhill street. Schwechlcr •entod, but instead of straightway getting the woman he told Ills story to Detective Geyer, who, for the commonwealth, brought to light the evidence of Holmes'

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This damaged clipping is too fragmentary to follow clearly, but it refers to a meeting at which it was claimed children were killed by Holmes and that the defence was not ready to proceed.

New-York Tribune · 19 November 1895 · page 1

HOLMES'S LAWYER ARRESTED

An important feature of the meeting was the ing that the child:an were Killed by Holmes that the defence was not ready to proceed and

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping, partly garbled, reports a defense attorney named Rotan arguing in closing that Holmes's physique made it improbable he overcame and chloroformed Pietzel, and urging the court to weigh the medical evidence presented at trial.

New-York Tribune · 19 November 1895 · page 1

THE AFFIDAVIT PROVED FALSE.

4 8iv. af “ I ACG - 4 b mn 8 Cit) O A4.most tl atest de | A Here the report says: conventions, Ing — - On thal, In our judgment uent LI I nanged FTA , ver Four weeks do not afford sufficient time to pre a condittons in each district. The camps fan com the Court in his closing argument, dwelt on the improbability of a man Holmes's physique . On overcomirg Pietzel and kiliing him with chloroform. He alsc contended that though the Commonwealth had produced evidenes to show thai Pietzel bought a pint of whiskey the night before he died, there was no evidence to show that he was drunk on the day he died, thereby enabling Holmes to administer chloroform to him In | clostirg his argument Mr.

See moreSee less

Rotan asked the (Court to take particular note of the medical evidence offered at the trial, which, he contended, was in-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping reports that Holmes was arrested in court in Philadelphia on a charge of subornation of perjury, and notes a letter received from Francis Schlatter, the Denver healer, saying he would be in Chicago.

New-York Tribune · 19 November 1895 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING.

Holmes, was arrested in court in Philadelphia on a charge of subornation of perjury. —=—= A letter has been received from Francis Schlatter, the Denver healer, saying he would be in Chi-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says one of Holmes's counsel was arrested for procuring a false affidavit claiming Holmes's victim Pietzel intended suicide, a scheme the District Attorney exposed, implicating the lawyer and a man named Shoemaker.

New-York Tribune · 19 November 1895 · page 6

! people generally, for hardly improbable than the constitutional amendment that would be necessary to bring about such a change. A thousand or more housesmiths and ironworkers in this city went on strike yesterday, as the result of the troubles which have exist ed for some time between them and the manu- | facturers who employ them, The m he sald to thelr eredit, have tried repeatadly nave the disagreement settled by arbitration, put have been unable to make any impression | on the Tron League, as the combination of mann facturers Is called.

See moreSee less

The strike puts a stop to part of the work in a number of buildings in the city, but the other workmen will not quit unless an attempt is made to fill the strikers’ places with non-union men. In that case a sympathetic strike of large proportions doubtless will ensue. The matters in dispute seem capable of adjust ment by arbitration, and It is to be hoped that the members of the State Board of Arbitration will be successful in their efforts to hring about a settlement, Sabornation of perjury Is a grave crime, and, fortmately, an infrequent one. Not often, at any rate is it charged upon a reputable member of the bar, as was the case yesterday when one of the connsel for Holmes, the murderer recent. Iv convicted in Philadelphia, was arrested on the ground that he had heen concerned in procuring a perjured atiidavit bearing on the case. A new trial had been asked for Holmes, and the affidavit was produced to prove that the murderer's victim, Pietzel, nad expressed an intention of committing suicide. The District Attorney easily showed that the affidavit was false, and Shoemaker, the victim of a plot. been an easy vietim, NEW-YORK DAILY ee — — ————— ——— anything is more - en, it should | a - — the testimony directly implicated the lgwyer. He alleges that he is If so, he seems to have t oo

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

During the new-trial argument before three judges in Philadelphia, a police station matron confessed she had signed a fictitious-name letter falsely claiming Holmes intended suicide, and a detective's exposure of the plot caused a lawyer to collapse in court.

The Morning News · 19 November 1895 · page 1

IN THE HOLMES CASE. A Police Station Matron Admits That She Committed Perjury When She i Signed Vnder a Fictitious Name a 1 l’uuer Claiming That Pitexel Had Expressed an Intention to Commit Snlelde The Lawyer Collapses When a Detective Exposes the Whole Plot to the Court. Philadelphia, Nov. 18.—The argument for j anew trial in the ease of the convicted murderer Holmes was heard this morni lng in the criminal court before Judge , Arnold, who tried the case, Judge WTI- ! sou aud Judge Thayer, the presiding judges i of the court.

See moreSee less

Lika ail the phases of this 1 singular ease, this ordinarily routine pro- \ eedure furnished a sensation. Holmes was brought from prison to 1 court The weeks of confinement sines \ his conviction has added to the emavla- | tion that was so marked when he was in court before, and a hectic flush has taken the place of his former pallor. He has also lost the easy look of confidence I that he wore during his trial, and ai- !

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A planted affidavit claiming a dead man had spoken of suicide was shown to be fraudulent, after which the prisoner's attorney argued for a new trial and the district attorney countered with evidence of a divorce filing and a wife's affidavit.

The Morning News · 19 November 1895 · page 1

IN THE HOLMES CASE.

Hannigan. In the affidavit the witness swore that she kept a cigar store on Cal lowhill street, near the house where Pite- ! zel was killed, and that she knew the dead man, and that he told her that he intended to commit suicide. District Attorney Graham asked that ] the witness be called to the stand and 1 Mr. Shoemaker replied that he did not j know where she was. Then Mr. Graham called a private dej tective named Swetzler to the stand. The i detective testified that Mr. Shoemaker, 1 weeks ago had written out the affidavit J and given f'J) to pay someone to swear l to it.

See moreSee less

Jhen Detective Geycr was called and he testified that Swetzler had shown him the affidavit before it was signed. Then a woman was called to the stand who said she was the “Blanche Ranni gan” who signed the affidavit. She sWore that she knew nothing about the state ments In tho affidavit. Her name instead of being Hannigan Is Rhea, and she is the matron in the Fourth police district. It was at the suggestion of Detective Geyer that she went with Swetzler to Mr. Shoe maker and impersonated “Blanche Han nigan.” *lr. Shoemaker gave her S2O and took her before a notary public and she swore to the statement. This astonishing testimony that seemed to clearly point to a perjured affidavit evidently surprised the court, and when Mr. Shoemaker attempted to make some confused statement, judge Thayer sug gested to him that his greatest safety lay in silence. „ Mr. Rolan, Holmes' other attorney, stated to the court that lie knew nothing of the affidavit, and then he began the argument for anew trial. The main points of the reason for asking for a trial were given in these dispatches last week when the application lor a new trial was tiled. T.ie principal alle gations for asking for tffe trial are that the district attorney influenced the jury in introducing evidence showing that the children were killed by Holmes; that the defense was not ready to proceed and that he court erred on a number of points in the trial. Mr. Rotan argued for an hour and fifty minutes and District Attorney Graham replied. In his argument Mr. Rotan had dwelt upon the inadmissibility of the ev idence of Miss Yoke, on ground that the commonwealth had not clearly shuwn she was not the prisoner's wife, and she was not therefore a competent witness. Mr. Graham reproduced the prisoner's letters to the Willlmette, 111., wife, ac cording the ceremony of marriage, and then Mr. Graham sprung a surprise on Holmes that perceptibly took him back. Mr. Graham put ltt evidence, a record from the Chicago courts of an applica tion for a divorce tiled by Holmes, ask ing for a separation from his real wife, who lives in Gilmerton, N. H. He also produced an affidavit from this wife that while making the now famous journey with Mrs. Pitezel and Miss Yokes, Holmes came to see her and resumed his rela tions as a husband with her. Mr. Gra ham review the contentions set up by the defense, and step by step demolished them, and in a manner that was abso lutely conclusive shed a flood of con vincing light upon Holmes’ guilt. During tlie trial Mr. Graham was fre quently restrained by points of law re ferring to the prisoner, but in his re view of the evidence he was restrained by no such conditions, and he fairly with ered Holmes with bis scorching arraign ment of his various crimes. The weak point In Mr. Graham's case during the trial was how Pitezel was act ually killed. His inference was that Pitezel was chloroformed to death by Holmes, but he never brought this out clearly. Judge Wilson seemed struck by this and asked Mr. Graham how Pitezel was killed. Mr. Graham said that it was the contention of the commonwealth that Holmes chloroformed him to death, but the district attorney did not make clear how the man was murdered. Mr. Rotan seized on tiffs point, and in addressing the court in his closing argument, dwelt on the improbability of a man of Holmes’ physique overcoming Pitezel and killing him with chloroform. He also contended that though the commonwealth had pro duced evidence to show that Pitezel bought a pint of whisky the night be fore he died, there was no evidence to show he was drunk on the day he died, and thereby enabled Holmes to adminis ter the chloroform to him In that condi tion. In concluding his argument. Mr. Ro tan used the court to take particular note in their derision of the medical evidence offered at the trial, which, he contended, was incomplete and inconclusive. Judge Thayer replied that the court would consider this phase of the case and especially as requested by Mr. Ro tan. Then Judge Thayer, addressing Mr. Shoemaker, told him that he had a most unpleasant duty to perform. He said that in view of the use Mr. Shoemaker made of the affidavit he presented in the court this morning the court had no al ternative but to hold him in $1,500 bond for subordination of perjury. Mr. Shoe maker stood pallid and nerveless while Judge Thayer was speaking and when his honor had finished he made an inar ticulate effort to say something, but his voice choked and he sat down silently. The court reserved its decision upon granting Holmes anew trial, but that the new trial will b'4 refused from the line of questioning adopted by the bench is not doubted. Mr. Shoemaker procured hail, but re fused to make any statement in regard to the affidavit. He would only say that it was a most cruel aud unexpected de velopment to him, and that he understood his whole professional career was at stake. Mr Rotan, Mr. Shoemaker's colleague, was greatly worried over the affair, as he feared It would reflect upon him, but at it was clearly shown in court that he had had no hand In procuring tile affi davit, the bench of judges exonerated him from blame. Mr. Rotan expressed the opinion that Mr. Shoemaker would be able to show his innocence of any guilty intent, and that he fell into a trap that i was set for him.

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

The clipping reports that William A. Shoemaker, defense attorney in the Holmes murder trial, was arrested and exposed in court for paying a woman to sign and swear to a false statement claiming Pietzel committed suicide, a scheme uncovered by detectives working for District Attorney Graham.

Abendblatt · 19 November 1895 · page 2

Philadelphia, 18. Nov. Der böfe Geist, welcher über dem Schicksal des Mörderkönigs H. H. Holmes schwedt und schließlich Alle vernichten wird, die sich mit ihm verbündet haben, hat ein neues Opfer gefunden. Der Leiter der Verthei— digung in dem Mordprozesse, William A. Shoemater, wurde wegen Verleitung zum Meineide verhaftet. Er, der junge Anwalt, dessen Verknüpfung mit dem Proceß auf einem Geheimniß beruht, hatte heute ein Verfahren als Angeklagter durchzumachen, welches ihm die zutünflige Carriere abzu— schneiden droht. Die Krisis trat ein, als Shoemater unter 1500 Bürgschaft gestellt wurde, um sich von der Anklage zu reinigen, Beweismaterial „fabriciri“ zu haben.

See moreSee less

Es handelte sich für ihn darum, zu „beweisen“, daß Benjamin F. Pitzel, dessen Ermordung Holmes vor 14 Tagen überführt wurde, Selbstmord beging. Shoemaker wurde über— führt, einer Frauensperson 20 dafür bezahlt zu haben, daß sie eine von Shoemaker aus gearbeitete falsche Aussage unterzeichnete und ihren Inhalt eidlich bestätigte, also Meineid beging. Die Staatsanwaltschaft hatte diese Frauensperson dem Advokaten in die Hände gespielt, der im Gericht mit Pathos die „Ent— hüllung neuen Beweismaterials“ antündigte und eine Wiederaufnahme des Beweisver—- fahrens verlangte, um dann in elender Weise als Betrüger entlarvt zu werden. Kaum hatte Shoemaker u mdie Erlaubniß gebeten, daß die Erörterung der Wiederauf nahme des Beweisverfahrens verschoben werde, da er das „neur“ Beweismaterial sichten müsse, als Distriktanwalt Graham auftrat und den Anwalt als Schwindler bloß stellte. Diese Enthüllung wirkte wie ein Blitz aus heiterem Himmel. Die Rich ter waren sprachlos; das Publikum war wie vom Donner gerührt, der angeklagte Ad—- votat sank zitternd in seinen Stuhl und der Schurke Holmes blickte auf das Ganze mit höhnischem Grinsen. Der Pietzel'sche Mordprozeß hatte knavp den zweiten Verhandlungstag erreicht. als Shoemaker sich dem Geheimpolizisten John Schweichler mit der Bitte näherte, ihm eine Frau zu beschaffen, die in der Gegend der 12. oder 13. und Callowhilloder Binestr. wohne und die gewisse Thatsachen zu ke— schwören bereit sei, die sich auf Pietzel's Tod bezögen. Schweichler erklärte sich bereit, jedoch anstatt sich auf die Suche nach einem passenden Frauenzimmer zu begeben, suchte er den Geheimpolizisten Geyher auf, der für die Anklage thätig war. Geyer unterbreitete die Sache dem Districts-Anwalt Graham, und es wurde dem Anwalt Shoemater in sehr geschickter Weise eine Falle gestellt, die seinen Ruin herbeiführt. Im Auftrage Graham's begab sich Geher zu Frau Margaret Reah, der Schließerin in der Polizeistation des 4. Bezirkes. Unter dem Namen Blanche A. Hannigan wurde sie von Schweichler dem RechtsanwaltShoe mater vorgestellt. Inzwischen hatte Shoe—- moker eine Aussage ausgearbeitet, in der die Deponentin erklärte, daß sie Pietzel gekannt und daß er ihr gesagt habe, daß er sich um's Leben bringen werde. Frau Hannigan un terzeichnete die Aussage und beschwor sie, und Shoemaker gab ihr 20 in zwei $lO - Auf jeden Schein malte sie ein „D. A. H.“, und dieses Geld wurde dann im Gericht produzirt. Shoemater ging in die Falle. Als er den Richtern die Aussage vorlas, sagte er, sie sei ihm von der Hannigan dictirt worden. Ei— nen Augenhblick später wurde dann bewie—- sen, daß er selbst die Aussage dictirte, ehe er Schweichler bat, ihm eine passende Person zu besorgen, und daß er Frauù Hannigan die Aussage nicht einmal vorlas, noch sie das Document lesen ließ. Richter Arnold und die Collegen Thaher und Wilson sollten über die Frage entschei— den, ob eine Wiederaufnahme des Beweis— verfahrens zu gestatten sei. Dann kamen die Enthüllungen. Sofort begriffen die Richter den Ernst der Lage, in der sich Shoe—- maker befand, und der Anwalt wurde we—- ger Verleidung zum Meineide unter Bürg—- schaft gestellt, um aus dem Advokatenstande ausgestoten zu werden. Shoemaker hatte keine Entschuldigung mehr vorzubringen. Sein College Rotan ertlärte jedoch, daß Shoemaker sich verthei— digen wird, sobald dazu die Zeit sei, obgleich der Schein wider ihn sei. Ueber Shoemater's anfängliche Bekannt—- schaft mit Holmes cursiren seltsame Ge— rüchte. Man sagt, daß Shoemaker vor reich lich einem Jahr nach Philadelphia kam. Woher er kam, schien Niemand zu wissen; Einige sagten, er komme aus einer kleinen Etadt in Indiana. Bei seiner Ankunft hier soll er von dem Empfange eines Briefes gesprochen haben, der die Unterschrift „H.“ irug. Dieser Brief soll für Shoemaker eine Engagementsofferte als Anwalt enthalten haben. Der Prozeß, für dessen Führung „H“ den Anwalt zu engagiren wünschte, würde bald in Philadelphia zur Verhandlung kommen, hieß es in dem Brief, welchem SIOO beigelegt waren. Einige Tage darauf wurde Holmes in Boston verhaftet, und seine scheußlichen Verbrechen kamen an den Tag. Nun heißt es, daß die kleine Stadt, aus welcher Shoemaker kam, nicht weit von dem Orte liegt, wo Holmes wohnte und seine entsetzlichen Mordthaten aushrütete. a man sagt sogar, daß in Shoemaker's Bureau sich eine Landkarte des County befindet, in welchem die beiden Orte liegen, und daß mit rother Tinte darauf eine Linie gemalt ist, welche die beiden Orte verbindet, daß je doch diese Linie alle Eisenbahnen und schaften umgeht, und nur durch unbe wohnte Gegenden führt. Diese Geschichte wird zwar nicht amilich bestätigt, jedoch Diejenigen, die sie kennen, kennen sie in all ibren Einzelheiten. Der Holmes-Prozeß war der erste Fall, d der Anwalt Shoemater in Philadelphia hrie. Es ist wahrscheinlich auch sein 3

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

This damaged clipping reports that David Henderson, a colored school teacher at Dunlap, attempted an assault on 14-year-old Dora Ray near Emporia, Kan., with the remaining text badly garbled and mixed with unrelated fragments about hanged negroes near Port Barrios and a trial involving bribery allegations.

The Topeka State Journal · 19 November 1895 · page 2

The Murderous Assault of a Colored School Teaoher. Emporia, Kan., Nov. 19. Late yes terday afternoon, David Henderson, a colored school teacher at Dunlap, thirty miles north of here, attempted an assault on Dora Ray, a 14-year-old ditional clues otal importance to special dispatch from Port Barrios, the case which would result in Holmes' dated November 15, says five negroes acquittal. were found hanging by guards six Graham said that it became his duty miles from town. They were recog to make a painful declaration. During the early part of the recent trial he lately arrived here to work on had received imformation that efforts the railroad construction, but who had been made to procure false testi became dissatisfied and fled.

See moreSee less

An in mony by bribery. Subsequently he leorned that these efforts were being nized as being some of the negroes vestigatson was made, but nothing re

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The item notes Chicago has renewed coverage of the Holmes case as a blood-and-thunder serial, and reports that Minnesota bill posters will fraternize at Waseca on Nov. 21.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 November 1895 · page 1

The public must resign itself to en dure another blood and thunder serial. Chicago has taken a fresh Btart on the Holmes case. That there's nothing stuck-up about the Minnesota bill posters is proved by the fact that they will fraternize at Waseca Nov. 21.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

During argument for a new trial, testimony revealed that defense attorney Shoemaker had dictated a false affidavit before the witness was even found, leading to a heated confrontation with Judge Thayer and District Attorney Graham. The court acquitted co-counsel Rotan of wrongdoing, ruled the affidavit fraudulent, and ordered the new trial argument to proceed.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 November 1895 · page 6

j .Mr. Graham was pursuing the in ! :(iuiry about the making of affidavits, j when Shoemaker excitedly jumped to ' his feet and said: \ "I will acknowledge that I dictated the affidavit to the stenographer." f "Sit down; don't say a word," mut i tered Rotan to Shoemaker. ? ..'7>?v During all this scene Holmes sat In the dock, his cold, blue eyes leveled at

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Holmes' lawyers obtained a transcript of his 1887 divorce suit against his wife, filed under his real name Herman Mudgett, which was dismissed for lack of evidence. They intend to use it to argue in a new trial motion that Holmes had only one legal wife, undermining claims about his other marriages.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 19 November 1895 · page 6

HOLMES' DIVORCE SUIT

. CHICAGO Nov. 18.— A Chicago paper quotes Gov. Altgeld as follows: "You j can say ln your paper that Altgeld Is out of politics. I am eagerly looking forward to the close of the next four teen months, when I will turn over to the people the finest state government on earth and quit politics forever. I want to get back to my law practice and make some money." To California on tnefOlaple Leaf.*' Every Tuesday the Chicago Great Western Railway (Maple Leaf Route) run a Tourist Sleeper via the Santa Fe Route to Los Angeles— 24 hours shorter than by any other line!

See moreSee less

Tick ets at Maple Leaf Ticket Office, Rob ert and Fifth street*. ..._,_. ?„_?_„. The charge made against the wife was j infidelity. Mudgett said he was mar- | ried at Acton, N. H., on July 4, 1878, : i and lived with his wife until 1883. The j case was heard and dismissed by the court for lack of evidence to support the charge. It is said that Holmes' lawyers want the transcript for use in i arguing the motion for a new trial, the ; purpose being to Show that Holmes ; had but one legal wife, and that the ! other .women said to have been at I times married to him were not legal wives.

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The clipping reports that attorney William Shoemaker was held under $1,500 bail for subornation of perjury after allegedly paying a woman, secretly supplied by the prosecution, to swear Pitzel had spoken of committing suicide.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 19 November 1895 · page 1

TABLES WERE TURNED.

IS CLEVERLY CAUGHT IE A TRAP Attorney Shoemaker Pays Mrs. Hannlgan Twenty Dollars to Sign and Swear to an ; Affidavit That Pitzel Expressed His In | tent ion of Committing Suicide—Woman | Was Furnished by the Prosecution. Philadelphia, Nov. 19.—The evil spirit that presides over the destinies of H. H. Holmes, king of murderers, and eventually destroys all who ally them selves with him, has found another vic tim. The first swift turn this extraor dinary case took was on the first day of the recent trial when the archcriminal dismissed his lawyers and the “prisoner at the bar” became counsel for the de fense.

See moreSee less

Monday the tables were turned and the counsel for the defense became a prisoner at the bar. William Shoemaker, the young at torney whose first association with the case is obscured in the mystery which envelops its every detail, passed through an ordeal as severe as his client had been called to face and the crisis came when he was held under $1,500 bail to answer a charge of subornation of perjury. This means that the manu factured evidence tending to prove that Benjamin F. Pitzel, for whose murder Holmes was convicted two weeks ago, committed suicide and that Shoemaker paid a woman $20 to sign and swear to this. Prosecution Supplied the Woman. But the commonwealth had supplied the woman, although Shoemaker was ignorant of this, and after he had pro duced this “after-discovered evidence” and read it with great impressiveness to the court, he asked that the argument on the motion for a new trial, which had been fixed for Monday,be postponed to give him and his associate counsel, Samuel P. Rotan, time to run out this and other clues. Then it wras that Dis trict Attorney Graham arose and ex ploded the plot. His declaration came ^ like a thunderbolt. The court stared in wide eyed amazement; the spectators lurried in their chairs and gasped; the accused lawyer same DacK in ms seat, livid and tremulous, while his innocent associate glared at him with unveiled horror, but the prisoner in the dock rested his cold blue eyes on the shrink ing figure of his legal representative and smiled with scorn. Briefly told, the de tails of the charge are these: k The trial of the Pitzel murder case ■was not two days old when Shoe maker approached a private detective named John Schweichler and asked him to procure a woman who lived around Twelfth and Thir teenth and Callow Hill or Vine streets who would swear to certain facts in con nection with the finding of Pitzel’s body at 1316 Callow Hill street. Sch weichler assented,but instead of straight way getting the woman, he told his -■ r' "ry to Defective Geyer, who, for the commonwealth brought to the light the evidence ot Holmes’ murder of the children. Geyer submitted it to District Attorney Graham and a most skillful trap was prepared, a trap w hich has brought about the ruin of the op posing attorney. Under instructions, r Geyer went to Mrs. Margaret Reah, matron of the Fourth district police station and she, under the name of Blanche A. Haunigan, was taken to Shoemaker by Schweichler. Shoemaker Walked Into the Trap. Meantime Shoemaker had prepared an affidavit stating that the deponent had known Pitzel and that to her he had expressed his intention of commit ing suicide. Mi’s. Hannigan readily 1— Signed and swore to this and Shoemaker , gave her two $ 10 bills for so doing. On each bill she marked the initials D. A. H. and she exhibited them in court. Shoemaker w’alked into the trap blind folded. When he read the affidavit to the court he declared that its contents had been dictated to him by the womau. A moment afterwards irrefutable testi mony ■was produced showing that he 1 had himself made up the affidavit and

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The clipping reports an unofficial but widely credited story that a map found in Shoemaker's office showed a red-ink line, avoiding railroads and settlements, connecting his town to one where Holmes had lived.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 19 November 1895 · page 1

arrested in Boston and the story of his manifold crimes came out. Now it is said that the little town in which Shoe maker lived was but a short distance from another town where Holmes had lived and fostered his multifaroua schemes. It is even said that in Shoe maker’s office has been found a map of the county in which. these two towns lie and that a line is drawn in red ink between the places, but so drawn as to avoid railroads and settlements, cutting through the bare country. This curious story is not given out officially, but with those who know of it there is an unanimity as to its details. The Holmes case was the first Shoemaker tried in Philadelphia. It is probably also the last.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The fragment recounts how Schwechler, asked to find a woman to confirm facts about the discovery of Pitezel's body at a Callowhill street address, instead told his story to Detective Geyor, who used it to uncover evidence against Holmes.

The Evening Herald · 19 November 1895 · page 1

SHOEMAKER IS A PRISONER

who would swear to certain facts in con nection with tho finding of Pitezel's body at 1!J10 Callowhlll street. Schwechler as sented, but instead of straightwny getting tho woman ho told his story to Detective Geyor, who, for tho commonwealth, brought to light tho ovldonco of Holmes'

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

The clipping reports that attorney Shoemaker, acting for Holmes, was shown to have paid a woman $20 to swear false testimony, and was held in $1,500 bail for subornation of perjury while Holmes, present in court, appeared visibly worn.

The Scranton Tribune · 19 November 1895 · page 1

and showed that Mr. Shoemaker, the atttorney of Holmes who offered it, had paid the woman who swore to it $20 for aoing so. Shoemaker was so overcome by this exposure that he could make no explanation and at the conclusion of the argument he was held in $1,500 ball by the court to answer to the charge of subornation of perjury. Holmes was In court during the argu ment, and he has failed perceptibly in

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A streetcar conductor claims Benjamin Pitezel, supposedly murdered by Holmes, boarded his car alive with a grown beard and admitted his identity before asking for silence. Others, including a bank investigator, also claim to have seen the same man, fueling doubt about Pitezel's death.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Providence News · 19 November 1895 · page 7

A YARN FROM CHICAGO

McNeary, conductor on the Sixty-third street oleotric line, has sprung a new sen sation in the Holmes ecase byluun:.t;h“ Benjamin F. Pitezel is alive, and that he recently talked with him on his car. MeNeary claims there could be no mistake, a 8 he worked nine months for Pitezel and knows the peculiarities of his volce. According to McNeary, Pitezel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes' trial, Pitezel's beard had grown around the greater part of his face, so that he was ocompletely disguised. When addressed, however, he admitted his identity, and asked ns a friend that McNeary keep 4i lence, as ho was on - his way to Philadel-

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This damaged clipping jumbles court testimony about a woman's character and a man's murder conviction with an unrelated dispatch about a treasure-laden train and a special detective train leaving at midnight.

The Salt Lake Herald · 19 November 1895 · page 1

AN ATTORNEY'S BAD BREAK

AI have no recollection of mention The court says The evidence shows the ing this case defendant to be a woman of not only QYou do not recollect it vile character but possessed of an ut ANo sir Secretary Oddie ten read the ap ing to prove that Benjamin F Pietzel hung in the balance but he would pended letterNew for whose murder Holmes was convict not discuss it at this time New York Nov 18 1895 ed two weeks ago committed suicide Cloud with the treasure I is not known at this hour whether the passen gers wero molested A special train with city detectives on board left at mid

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This damaged clipping mixes a question about a commission regarding a Hardy case with a separate account of Mr. Rotan reviewing testimony against Holmes and urging a jury that guilt had been proved beyond reasonable doubt.

The Salt Lake Herald · 19 November 1895 · page 1

QNow when you spoke to Lund Commission About Ford Hardy Case Confirmed did you tell him abut that or just say be careful fender the trust placed in me by the Charged with Subornation of Per Mr Rotan reviewed the testimony New York Yacht club and the good against Holmes in detail and urged name of my country whose reputation jury that the case had been proved beyond for fair play will be involved in the the possibility of a reasonable doubt

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

This damaged, partly German-language clipping fragment mentions a letter to the Czar, confiscated counterfeit notes and coins worth $5,000,000 in Milwaukee, and an accusation made in open court against Wm. A. Shoemaker, one of the defenders of the murderer H. H. Holmes.

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 19 November 1895 · page 1

Starker Tabak

bringt dem deutſchen Kaiſer einen ei— verurtheilt worben. Aus Milwautee iſt dem „Rettor genhändigen Brief des Zaren, in dem anderie und falſche Noten, falſche wortung flüir den Schritt übernähme. Münzen u .. w. im nominellenWerthe Dr. Lueger antwortete darauf mit der von $5,000,000 ſind confiscirt wor— Wm. A. Shoemaler, einer der Ver— theidiger des Mörders H. H. Holmes, wurde heute in offenem Gericht beſchul~

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The clipping describes courtroom testimony in which Mr. Shoemaker, questioned by Mr. Graham, excitedly admitted dictating an affidavit to a stenographer, while Holmes sat silently in the dock as someone muttered for Shoemaker to sit down.

Wheeling Register · 19 November 1895 · page 1

CORROBORATED THIS STORY

Four or five days afterwards, Mr. Shoe maker dictated the affidavit to a steno grapher. This was before the woman had been procured. After Sweckler had been given the affidavit 'he turned it over to Detective Geyer, who said he would procure the woman. Mr. Graham was pursuing the inquiry about the making of the affidavit when Shoe maker excitedly jumped to his feet and said: “I will acknowledge that I dictat ed the affidavit to the stenographer.” tered Rolaji to Shoemaker. During all this scene Holmes sat in the dock, “Sit down; don't say a word,” mut

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Chicago conductor and motorman say they recently spoke with a bearded man who admitted being Pietzel, while a bank investigator describes a similar encounter and notes Mrs. Pietzel now doubts the identification.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 19 November 1895 · page 1

IS BEN PIETZEL DEAD? A Chicago Street Car Conductor Who Know Him. Kaj'ft He Met Him Urgently Kolx'rt t <»rl>ett llelleveH llim Alive -Say He has Located Minnie Williams, Also . Chicago, November IS.—The Dally Nows this evening publishes the follow ing story: James McNary, conductor on car No. 676. of the Sixty-third street electric line, had sprung a new sensation in the Holmes case by stating that Benjamin F. Pietzel is alive and that he recently talked with him on his car. Mr. McNary claims there could be no mistake, as he worked nine months for Pietzel and knows the peculiarities of his voice.

See moreSee less

According to McNary, Piet zel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes’s trial. Pietzel’s beard had grown around the greater part of his face, so that he was completely disguised. W lien, however, addressed, he admitted his identity and a3ked as a friend that McNary keep silence, as he was on his way to Phila delphia. but McNary called in Motor man Letternian, and he, too. ela:ms that he had a conversation with Pietzel. who took a transfer to the Cottage Grove ca ble line. Mr. Robert Corbett, who lias been following the case for months in behalf of the Farmers and Mechanics’ National Bank, Forth Worth. Texas, claims that j he also has seen Pietzel. “I never believed that Pietzel was dead,” he declared to a Daily News re porter this morning, "for the folowing reasons: First, when I was searching the castle months ago, the man who resem bled the man seen by the conductor and, niotorman, and who 1 then thought was Pietzel, found me in the building looking over some papers. He asked me if I had seen a tool chest. I told him there was one in the front room. He said that one was not his, that he had left it in the room where 1 was en gaged. I asked him who he was. He said Mrs. Pietzel sent him there for the tool chest, and when I asked him his name, i^e said, after thinking a moment: ‘Andrews, and left. “Saturday I learned that Mrs Pietzel i was stopping at 6233 May street with Mr. Hayward and sent over to ask her if she ever sent for the tool che3t. Both* she and her daughter ifessa declared that they had not, and I also discovered that Mrs. Pietzel is wavering in her belief in the identification of Pietzel,

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A fragment states that an acquaintance of Holmes from this city and New York saw him with Minnie Williams at the Sherman house in fall 1893, while Holmes's own books say he met Minnie at a hotel.

The Portland Daily Press · 20 November 1895 · page 2

AROUND CHICAGO

this city and New York, and who had dealings with Holmes, deolares that he saw Holmes and Minnie Williams at the Sherman house in the fall of 1893, and in his books Holmes states that he met Minnie at a hotel, where he made

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, the alleged multi-murderer recently convicted of the murder of B. F. Pietzel, has filed reasons for a new trial.

Morris Tribune · 20 November 1895 · page 1

CRIMINAL NEWS.

A motion for a new trial of the Dur rant case will be argued on Nov. 22. Colorado Springs express robbers got $20,000, but left a package containing $35,000. Pickpockets robbed Chief of Police Taylor of Louisville, Ky., while he was attending a religious meeting. An attempt was made to hold np a Great Northern passenger train near St. Cloud. No booty was secured. The sentence of Captain Henry W Howgate to four years' imprisonment was confirmed by the supreme court. William Dickerman, publisher of The Counterfeit Money Detector, has been arrested for passing counterfeit money, Broker H.

See moreSee less

B. Martin was indicted at San Antonio, Tex., charged with at tempting to tribe three Texas congress men. Mrs.l^r&eib was held up in broad day light on the street in Dallas, Tex., and relieved of a purse and diamonds worth $1,000. The Taylor brothers, $iecondemned murderers of the Meeks family, were caught with burglar tools in their pos session. At Cincinnati John Kech, while drunk and jealous, shot his'wife and then himself. Both are in a dangerous condition. Grand foxy returned indictments against keepers of 83 gambling houses at St. Joseph, Mo., and there is an hegira into Kansas. H. H. Holmes, the alleged multi murderer, who was recently convicted of the murder of B. F. Pietzel, has filed reasons for a new trial, Systematic attempts were made to wreck trains in the railroad yards at Leavenworth, Kan., by a discharged employe, it is believed. In spite of elaborate precautions by police, several of the guests at the Paget-Whitney wedding are said to have been relieved of valuables by pick pockets. CRIMINAL NEWS. rs

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

The clipping reports brief items on a Holmes-case sighting claim, a Northwestern immigration convention, the death of hymn author Rev. Dr. S. F. Smith, an elderly Black River Falls couple, and various political and postal notes including a possible Cleveland message on finances.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Providence News, 19 November 1895, Wheeling Register, 19 November 1895.

Morris Tribune · 20 November 1895 · page 4

•4H9999999999999999999999999999Q news, as they have resurrected Pitzel and Minnie Williams, two victims 0 H. H. HolmesThat is, it is claimed by a street car conductor that he saw Pitzel and talked with him a few days ago. The conductor must be spiritualist. The Northwestern immigration con vention i!3 in session in St. Paul, and is attended by some of the ablest talent of the West. It is held for the purpose of inducing immigration westward. There are thousands yp on thousands of available farms yet unsettled in Minnesota alone. Rev. Dr.

See moreSee less

S. F. Smith, author of "America," died of heart failure last Friday in the New England depot Boston. He was eighty-seven years of age and was made famous by his composition of the national anthem "America." Black River Falls is noted for hav ing the oldest couple in the United States. Mrs. Darvin died last Fri day at the age of 101, and her hus band, who is 107 years old, survives her. They were married nearly eighty years ago. Governor Brown of Kentucky .ousriit the man who said that he (Brown h«d voted the Republican tecliet recency. A call has been issaeti for a confer ence of 16 to 1 Democrats of Tennessee at Nashville to effect an organization Reports of inspectors show the "etter carrier systems of a number of Western towns to be all right. Deputy Collector McNair at Circle City, Ala«ka. says that a company of troops is needed at that po.nt. Admiral Walker hacks General Miles' view that the coast and naval defenses of the United states are inadequate. Ind.aa £choo.s Superintendent Hail man, :n his annual report, reconmi'-nds interesting the states in Indian educa tion. secretary Olney is reported to have persuaded the president to recommend to congress the recogmtion of the Cu i»an insurgents. It is statod that in case' Carlisle is is made Jackson's successor, Perry Be.niont is likely to be made secretary of the treasury. Sixteen Chicago letter carriers have been removed from the service by order of the first assistant postmaster general as a result of spotters' work in that city. It is stated upon apparently high au thority that President Cleveland's com ing message will deal principally with the financial question. He will urge retirement of greenbacks.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Beobachter · New Philadelphia, Ohio

The clipping reports Holmes's lawyers filing for a new trial despite little doubt of his guilt, an Italian steamer with emigrants wrecked near the Strait of Gibraltar, German complaints about delayed Chicago World's Fair diplomas, and a Brussels bank cashier robbed of millions of francs who was arrested in Paris.

Der Deutsche Beobachter · 20 November 1895 · page 1

Das Scheusal Holmes

durch seine Anwälte das Gesuch um ei neit neuen Prozeß ein. Die Ueberfüh rung im Falle Pietzel scheint allerdings noch einige Lücken offen gelassen zu ha ben, gleichwohl besteht an seiner Schuld nicht der mindeste Zweifel. Ueberdieß liegen für mehrere seiner übrigen Mor de die Beweise viel vollständiger bereit. Die Anklagen für letztere, die anderswo zu prozefsiren wären, durchzuführen, hat natürlich keinen Sinn, da Holmes doch nur einmal gehängt werden kann. Die Gestattung eines neuen Prozesses ist in deß wenig wahrscheinlich. nach Südamerika Aus der Fahrt am strandete südlichen Eingange der Straße von Gibraltar der italienische „Solferino" 1200 Dampfer mit wanderern.

See moreSee less

In Deutschland beklagt man sich bit ter darüber, das die Chicago Weltaus 'tellungs-DiPlome immer noch nicht er hältlich sind. ist die Bank Societe In Brüssel tierale von ihrem Kassier um 2£ Mil lionen Franken beraubt worden. Der konnte in Paris verhaftet wer Kassier den. Aus­ Ge-

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

A Philadelphia jury, after little deliberation, found H. H. Holmes guilty of first-degree murder in the death of Benjamin F. Pitezel, with the defense having called no witnesses and Holmes showing no emotion as the verdict was read.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 20 November 1895 · page 6

H. H. HOLMES TO HANG

nal America has ever produced,.must die on! diet of murder in the first degree. Without having called a single witness tff testify in his defence Holmes's case was 9 given to the jury at forty-flve minutes part 5 o clock on the afternoon of the sixth day , of the trial. The jury were out only a few . _ hours when they came In with their verdiof.'! f Judge Arnold, in his charge to the Jury, said the evidence was entirely circumstantial, '' but that was not unusual in a murder case.]'-.

See moreSee less

He said there was no doubt Piteael was .. murdered, and his charge, on the whole, was.'':; unfavorable to the prisoner. District dress to the Jury, argued that it was lm*f possible for Piteael to have committed ?ui-< clde and that the evidence pointing t? Holmes's guilt was clear and concise. Mr. Botan. In pleading for the life of the pris-j oner, said he had decided to offer no de* fence, having confidence that the Commons wealth had not made out its case, and that n the reasonable doubt in the matter had not! ' After tho retirement of the Jury from the( court room, the spectators streamed oat .Into the corridors ana eagerly discussed what the 8 veraict would probably be. There was oonV slderable difference of opinion, 4s many "be* lieved the Commonwealth had not ?8tab-< t llshed its case against Holmes, but the! , I mAi'nvitv nrarn IncHnfirl to hnllftVfl that thr Jury would convict. 3 At 8.85 word was sent to Judge Arnold that. the jury was ready to return the verdict/ /. j Tie prisoner was brought in and placed 1ft ' , the dock. He wa?impassive as ho took hlrf Bfat. The jury came In and took their places, 'f The Coort^ordered Holmes to arise, iand 0 then, in teply to the question ol the Court,"' . . ' . the foreman of the jury pronounced the verj. 9 The verdict was greeted with absolute - and exhibited no emotion of any kind. ,t He sat down, and while the jury waa polled and each man answered to his name _ and gave his verdict Holmes stared vacantly. before him. His face was like that ot al . ; 1 corpse. It was absolutely expressionless. away Holmes slowly recovered. He realized ' that his counsel was making a motion for jat' j" new trlaL His under lip fell and he ran hi* yri tongue over it. - ed 1>y ihe District Attorney. . I V-r H. H. Holmes, the most remarkable crlmK the gallows for the murder of his fellow! swindler, Benjamln F. PitezeL The jury as tjt Philadelphia, Penn., after onl* > one ballot, brought in a vew Clasping his hands together he leaned fory i *

See the clipping

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

This damaged fragment describes a prisoner being brought into court before Judge Arnold, with references to the Commonwealth's case and a jury preparing to return a verdict, but the OCR is too garbled to follow clearly.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 20 November 1895 · page 6

VERDICT DAZES THE PRISONER.

t llshed its case against Holmes, but the! , I mAi'nvitv nrarn IncHnfirl to hnllftVfl that thr 3 At 8.85 word was sent to Judge Arnold that. j Tie prisoner was brought in and placed 1ft ' , the dock. He wa?impassive as ho took hlrf 'f The Coort^ordered Holmes to arise, iand 0 then, in teply to the question ol the Court,"' . . ' lieved the Commonwealth had not ?8tab-< Jury would convict. the jury was ready to return the verdict/ /. Bfat. The jury came In and took their places,

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C.

This damaged, jumbled clipping describes a jury that deliberated briefly before convicting Holmes, after which District Attorney Graham showed jurors evidence including a stove, burned skull fragments, and teeth tied to the case.

The Abbeville Press and Banner · 20 November 1895 · page 6

VERDICT DAZES THE PRISONER.

posuro and he walked from the room with a l the jury for tbeir attention and discharged * . retired from the court room they had sup* per, and then a brief discussion took place< ~ One ballot was taken, and every man voted '/ minutes If they had wished to do so. Holmes and showed them the mass of evidence coU , Thomas W. Barlow, but excluded from the ; " trial. This lnoluded the stove In which . Holmes burned little Howard Pltezel'a body near Indianapolis, the fragments of skull * and the teeth found in the chimney, and t; many other ghastly relics.

See moreSee less

time Holmes had recovered much of his comj quick, springy step. The Judge thanked them, and so ended the trial. their retirement from the court room, but they could have found a verdict in fifteen . for condemned murderers. After the Court was closed District At- . > torney Graham took the jury into his office lected under the direction of Attorney

See the clipping

Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.

A roundup of short news notes covers a Methodist conference decision, Cuban-related developments, a clergy appointment, Holmes's bid for a new trial, Senator Sherman's remarks on McKinley, and a salesmen's celebration in Atlanta.

Staunton Spectator · 20 November 1895 · page 3

NTON , i^A» Virginia conference Methodist Epis copal Church South decided to hold its next session in Lynchburg. A commit tee was appointed to try the charges against Rev. Dr. George W. Carter. The Cuban General Masso is believed to have come to this country to aid In the movement to secure recognition for the insurgents. The steamer Laurada, which is believed to have carried the Cespedes expedition to Cuba, has been seized at Charleston, South Carolina. Rev. John Sword, of St. John's Epis copal Church, Lexington, Ky., has ac cepted a call to Trinity Church, in Chicago.

See moreSee less

H. H. Holmes, convicted of the mur der of B. F. Petzel, in Philadelphia, has filed his reasons why he should have a new trial. He bases his appli cation principally on the mention by the district attorney and Mrs. Petzel of other crimes attributed to Holmes. Senator Sherman, writing to a friend concerning the recent elections, said he believed they opened the way for the nomination and election of Gov ernor McKinley to the Presidency. Five thousand traveling salesmen celebrated their day at the Atlanta Ex position last Wednesday by a parade, speeches and a barbecue.

See the clipping

The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.

The clipping reports that building the Nicaragua canal would take 20,000 men six years, a plot to assassinate President Alfaro of Ecuador has been foiled, and Holmes's counsel have filed a motion for a new trial.

The Globe-Republican · 21 November 1895 · page 2

creasing. It will take 20,000 men six years to build the Nicaraugua canaL A plan to assassinate President Alfaro of Ecuador has been frustrated. Counsel for murderer H. H. Holmes have filed a motion for a new trial.

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

A Philadelphia dispatch reports that attorney Shoemaker, counsel for Holmes, was held on $1,500 bail after testimony alleged he paid a woman to sign a false affidavit claiming the dead man had spoken of committing suicide, a claim corroborated by detective testimony and the woman herself during arguments for a new trial.

The Stark County Democrat · 21 November 1895 · page 1

PiilLADKi.riitA, Nov. 19. Attorney Shoemaker, senior counsel for Holmes, has been hold in if 1,500 ball for court on a chargo of subornation of perjury. Judgo Arnold stated privately that tho oourt was contemplating disbarment proceedings, but nothing would bo douo in that rogard until uftor tho disposi tion of tho charge. Tho sonsatiou developed when tho application for a cow trial for Holmes was arguod. Mr. Shoemaker proseuted an affidavit from a witness purporting to be named Blanche Hnnnigan,- who swore that sho kept a cigar store ou Callowhlll street, near tho houso whoro Pitozel was killed, and that sho know tho dead man, and that he told her ho lutendod to commit suicide.

See moreSee less

District Attornoy Graham asked that the wit ness bo called to tho stand, and Mr Shoemaker replied that he did nut know whoro she was. District Attorney Graham then said: "I will produco her and show that sho was omployod by Mr. Shoemaker; that she was taken to his olllco and quos about tho cuso, and tho attorney told nor that was all right; and that sho was induced, upon tho payment to her of $20, to sign the affidavit, which had al this statement by Mr. Graham, Detec tive Goyer, being sworn, testified that during the trial ho was called upon by John Sohweohlor, who said that Mr. Bhoemakor hud asked him to procure a woman who lived around Thirteenth and Callowhlll or King street, who would swear to certain facts. The next day Sohweohlor again called and showed hirn the typewritten affidavit.- This was before tho woman had beeu looked for. Mr. Geyor submitted the matter to the district attorney, and ou his ad tho woman. Ho introduced her to Schwoohler, who in turn, took lior to Bhoomaker. After several interviews with him, she siguod tho aflldavit aud received the money in two $10 bills, whloh sho had marked with her ini tials for tho purposo of identification. The supposed Mrs. Hannigan, who said her name was Margaret Heah, took the stand and corroborated this story iu de Shoemaker muddled up thing badly by trying to explain, but was shut otf by the judges. Tho court and district attornoy uuitod in clearing Hotan, Holmes' other attorney. Rotau in his argument for a new trial argued that Pite.el hodcommittod suicide, aud that the commonwealth hod produced no ovidouce to coutrovert that assertion. Distriot Attorney Graham reviewed tho tostimony against Holmes in detail, aud urged that tho case had boon proved beyond tho possibility of a rea der advisement. A straugo story is whispored about Shoomaker's initial uppearauce in this easo. A little over u yoar ago, it. is said, ho first camo to Philadelphia Whouco he camo no one seoms to know, but a tale is told that ho had beon for some time iu a little town iu Indiana Upon his arrival horo ho is said to have spoken of tho receipt of a letter from Boston signed "H." It is stated that thekwriter uesirod to retain him as couusol in a case which would soon afterwards come un iu Philadolnhia. and unclosed u $ 100 note as a rotaiuing roe. A row days afterwards Holmes was arrested in Boston, and tho story ot his manifold crimes came out. Now, it is said that the little Indiana town in which Shoemaker lived was but a short distanco from another town whoro Holuios hud lived anil fostered his multifarious schemos. It is oven said that in Shoemaker's ofllco has been found a mup of tho countv in which those two towns lio, aud that it line is drawn in rod ink between tho placos, but so drawn as to avoid railroads and settlements, cutting through tho bare country. This curious story Is not given out officially, but with tliose who know of it thoro is an unanimity as to its dotails. Tho Holmes case was tho first Shoemaker triod iu Philadelphia. It is probably also the Inst. tlonod; that sho said she know nothing ready boon prepared. In support of vloe, after tho trial, Goyer procurod tail, producing the niouey. sonable doubt. Tho o.-tbo was taken un

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

A Chicago conductor and motorman claim they spoke with a bearded Benjamin F. Pitezel on their streetcar, who asked them to keep silent as he was heading to Philadelphia, while a bank investigator says he too has seen Pitezel and has his Philadelphia address.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Stark County Democrat · 21 November 1895 · page 1

DECLARE PITEZEL IS AulVE. Three Ciiicaoo, Nov. 111. .lames McNearyj conductor oil car (17(1 of the Sixty-third street electric line, has sprung a uew sousation in the Holmes case by stating that Benjamin F. Pltezel is alivo, aud that he recently talked with him ou his car. Mr. MoNeary claims thoro could lm uo uiistako, as ho workod nino mouths for Pitozol aud knows tho peculiarities of his voice. According to McNeary, Pito.ol boafdod his car a fow days pro Pitezel's board had grown around the greater pait of his face, so that he win completely disguUad.

See moreSee less

When addressed, however, ho admitted to his identity, and uskod us it tilend that MuNoury keep sileuco, as ho was ou his wuy to Philadelphia, but MoNeary oallod in Motorinuu i.ettermau, and he, too, claims that ho had a conversation vith Fltebl, who took u transfer lor tho Cottugo Uiovo cable lino, Mr. Kt.bert Corbett, who has Ixeu following the case for mouths in behalf of the l armors' and Mechanics' Na that lie a so n ts seen Pitozol, and that ho citinii tn i.ie Holmes castle once when ho iCorbetti was searching the pluco. Saul ho ! believe thut if Holmes is not guinted u new trial Pltezel wilt deolare himself to tho governor of Pennsylvania, whon all other moans uro exhausted, aud Isaao It. Illtt, Jr., and myxolf both havo his address in Philadelphia. Minnie Williams is stop of Mrs. K. M Oardenor, while Pltezel li known a G D Hall." i'4.o'e ( Inlm to lUve Talked l lllui In CI Iciiyo. vious to Holmes' trial. tional baniv. Fort Worth, Tex., oloims ping ut the same place uuder tho tiuuie

See the clipping

In the story →

The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or.

A Chicago street railway conductor named McNary says he recognized and spoke with a bearded, disguised Pitezel on his car, a motorman named Letterman supports the claim, and a bank investigator named Corbett recounts a similar encounter with a man who gave the name Andrews.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Corvallis Gazette · 21 November 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

SAYS HE SAW PITEZEL

Sensational Story Published in a Chicago Paper.

See moreSee less

SURE THERE WAS NO MISTAKE

James McNary, a Street Railway Conductor, Claims That He Talked With Him But Recently.

Chicago, Nov. 20.—The Daily News this evening publishes the following story:

James McNary, a conductor on car No. 635, of the Sixty-third street line, has sprung a new sensation in the Holmes case, by stating that Benjamin F. Pitezel is alive, and that he recently talked with him on his car. McNary claims there could be no mistake, for he worked nine months for Pitezel and knows the peculiarities of his voice. According to McNary, Pitezel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes' trial. Pitezel's beard had grown around the greater part of his face, so that he was completeiy disguised. When addressed, however, he admitted his identity and asked as a friend that McNary keep silent, for he was on his way to Phiadelphia; but McNary called in Motorman Letterman and he, too, claims that he had a conversation with Pitezel, who took a transfer to the Cottage Grove cable line.

Robert Corbett, who has been following the case for months in behalf of the Farmers' & Merchants' National bank, Fort Worth, claims he has also seen Pitezel. He said to a Daily News reporter:

"I never believed Pitezel was dead, for the following reasons: First, when I was searching the 'castle,' some months ago, this man, who resembles the one seen by the conductor and motorman, and who, I then thought was Pitezel, found me in the building looking over some papers. He asked me if I had seen a toolchest. I told him there was one in the front room. He said that one was not his; that he had left it in the room where I was engaged. I asked him who he was. He said Mrs. Pitezel sent him there for a toolchest, and when I asked him his name he said, after thinking a moment, 'Andrews,' and left."

See the clipping

The Kanabec County Times · Mora, MN · and 3 other papers

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted in Philadelphia of murdering B. F. Pitzel, had his counsel file reasons for a new trial, with a fragment about an address before the Georgia legislature left incomplete.

The Kanabec County Times · 22 November 1895 · page 2

H. H. Holmes, convicted in Philadel phia of the murder of B. F. Pitzel, through his counsel filed reasons for a new trial. In an address before the Georgia leg

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Ely Miner · Ely, Minn. · 20 November 1895
  • Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 22 November 1895
  • The Cape Girardeau Democrat · Cape Girardeau, Mo. · 23 November 1895

In the story →

The Forrest City Times · Forrest City, Ark.

During the argument for a new trial for convicted murderer H. H. Holmes, the district attorney proved an affidavit claiming the victim contemplated suicide was false and that attorney Shoemaker had paid a woman $20 to swear to it, leading the court to hold Shoemaker in $1,500 bail for subornation of perjury while reserving its decision on the new trial.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Forrest City Times · 22 November 1895 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

THE HOLMES CASE.

The Argument in Support of the Motion for a New Trial Leads Up to a Sensation—Attorney Shoemaker Held in $1,500 Bonds for Subornation of Perjury in Securing an Affidavit to Support His Case.

See moreSee less

PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 19.—The argument for a new trial for the convicted murderer H. H. Holmes was heard yesterday in the court of oyer and terminer, and this remarkable case furnished another sensation.

One of the counsel for the prisoner produced an affidavit in court alleging to show that Pietzel, the murdered man, contemplated suicide. Amidst the silent amazement of the spectators and the shocked astonishment of the court, District Attorney Graham proved the affidavit to be false, and showed that Mr. Shoemaker, the attorney of Holmes, who offered it, had paid the woman who swore to it $20 for doing so.

Shoemaker was so overcome by this exposure that he could make no explanation and at the conclusion of the argument he was held in $1,500 bail by the court to answer to the charge of subornation of perjury.

Holmes was in court during the argument. He has failed perceptibly in looks since his trial. He has lost the prison bleach which paled his cheek and a hectic flush has taken its place. His eyes are bloodshot and dark rings around them tell of anxious days and nights. His manner was not as cool and unconcerned as it was during his trial, and he showed an almost feverish interest in the proceedings. As formerly, however, he retained his self-possession and took notes of the district attorney's argument, and prompted his lawyer during his address.

The argument consumed the entire day and the court reserved its decision, but from the questions asked by the judge it seems certain a new trial will be refused.

See the clipping

Hopkinsville Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.

The clipping, a fragment, reports that H. H. Holmes of Philadelphia was held in $1,500 bonds on a charge of subornation of perjury in procuring a fraudulent affidavit, with the text cutting off before explaining what it supported.

Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 22 November 1895 · page 5

H H Holmes ai Philadelphia has been held in SI 500 bonds on a charge of subornation of perjury in procur ing a fraudulent athdavit in support

See the clipping

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · Stanford, Ky.

A clipping reports that Holmes's counsel was held under $1,000 bail, accused of paying a witness $20 to swear that Pietzel, whom Holmes was accused of murdering, had committed suicide.

Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 22 November 1895 · page 2

Holmes counsel, has been held under $1,000 bail charged with having paid a witness $20 to swear that Benjamin F. Pietzel, whom Holmes was accused of having murdered, committed snicide.

See the clipping

The Hood River Glacier · Hood River, Or.

A streetcar conductor and motorman claim to have recently spoken with Benjamin Pitezel, whom they recognized despite a beard disguise. A bank investigator also claims to have encountered a man resembling Pitezel while searching Holmes' castle.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Hood River Glacier · 22 November 1895 · page 1

Conversed With Him. Chioago, Nov. 20. The Daily News this evening publishes the following story: , ' James McNary, a conductor on car No. 685, of the Sixty-third street line," has sprung a new sensation in the Holmes oase, by stating that Benjamin F. Pitezel is alive, and that he reoently talked with him on his car. McNary olaims there oould be no mistake, for ho worked nine months for Pitezel and knows the peculiarities of his voice. Aooording to MoNary, Pitezel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes' trial.

See moreSee less

Pitezel's beard had grown around the greater part of his faoe, so that he was completely disguised. When ad dressed, however, he admitted his identity and asked as a friend that Mo Nary keep silent, for he was on his way to Philadelphia; but MoNary called in Motorman Letterman and he, too, olaims that he had a conversation with Pitezel, who took a transfer to the Cottage Grove'Oable line. Robert Corbett, who has been fol lowing the case for months in behalf of the Farmers' & Merchants' National bank, Fort Worth, claims he has also seen Pitezel.- He said to a Daily News reporter: . , I never beleived Pitezel was dead, for the following reasons: First, when I was searching the castle, some months ago, this man, who resembles the one seen by the conductor and motorman, and who, I then thought was Pitezel, found me in the building looking over some papers'. He asked me if I had seen a toolohest . I told him there was one in the front room. He said that one was not his; that he had left it in the room where I was engaged. I asked him who he was. fie said Mrs. Pitezel sent him there for -a toolohest, and when I asked him his name he said, after thinking a mo ment, 'Andrews,' and left"

See the clipping

The Hood River Glacier · Hood River, Or.

A streetcar conductor and motorman claim to have encountered a bearded man who admitted being Pitezel, asking them to keep silent about it. A bank investigator adds he also encountered a man resembling Pitezel at the castle months earlier, who gave the name 'Andrews' when pressed.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Hood River Glacier · 22 November 1895 · page 1

Conversed With Him. Chioago, Nov. 20. The Daily News this evening publishes the following story: , ' James McNary, a conductor on car No. 685, of the Sixty-third street line," has sprung a new sensation in the Holmes oase, by stating that Benjamin F. Pitezel is alive, and that he reoently talked with him on his car. McNary olaims there oould be no mistake, for ho worked nine months for Pitezel and knows the peculiarities of his voice. Aooording to MoNary, Pitezel boarded his car a few days previous to Holmes' trial.

See moreSee less

Pitezel's beard had grown around the greater part of his faoe, so that he was completely disguised. When ad dressed, however, he admitted his identity and asked as a friend that Mo Nary keep silent, for he was on his way to Philadelphia; but MoNary called in Motorman Letterman and he, too, olaims that he had a conversation with Pitezel, who took a transfer to the Cottage Grove'Oable line. Robert Corbett, who has been fol lowing the case for months in behalf of the Farmers' & Merchants' National bank, Fort Worth, claims he has also seen Pitezel.- He said to a Daily News reporter: . , I never beleived Pitezel was dead, for the following reasons: First, when I was searching the castle, some months ago, this man, who resembles the one seen by the conductor and motorman, and who, I then thought was Pitezel, found me in the building looking over some papers'. He asked me if I had seen a toolohest . I told him there was one in the front room. He said that one was not his; that he had left it in the room where I was engaged. I asked him who he was. fie said Mrs. Pitezel sent him there for -a toolohest, and when I asked him his name he said, after thinking a mo ment, 'Andrews,' and left"

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Windham County Reformer · Battleboro, Vt.

The clipping is a garbled fragment blending Holmes's signed statement blaming Hatch and his mistress Mamie Williams for the Pitezel children's murders with an unrelated grocer's advertisement listing meat, produce, and canned goods prices.

The Windham County Reformer · 22 November 1895 · page 6

maker in his viliiany. The latter, of course, protestshis innocence and claims that the detective has put up a job" on him, but he is held under bail for further investigation. Holmes himself made a long signed statement in the New York World Sunday, advancing the theory that the Pitezel children were all murdered by Hatch au ac Holmes admits the guilt; and that Hatch did them at the instigation of his mistress, Mamie Williams, who form erly bore tho same relation to Holmes, and that her motive m it was to get Holmes behind tho bars so that he would never "peach" on her for the murder of her sister, whom Holmes so as to remember where to buy your meets and provisions.

See moreSee less

Sauage, 10c per lb., 3 lbs. for i"c. Lamb, fore nilflrtj.ra. i tiinfl l'Jc Chickens, ltk? per lb. Bacon, sliced, loe per lb. Bacon, whole strip, 13c per lb. Lard. 8c per lb. Cottoline, 8c per lb. Halt Pork, 10c per lb., 11 lbs. for $1.00. complice in his swindles, of which Fraukforts. 12c per lb. Bologna, 10c per lb. pareribs. fork. Sic. per lb.. 3 for ).-. Pork Steak, 10c per lb. Ham, sliced, 15c, whole. 11c per lb. Lamb, leg, 15c per lb., chops, 12 to 15c And the lowest prices for Beef of all kinds "uui-ii nam. Oysters. 35c a quart. Whole Hog, 5 l-c per lb. Tripe, fie per lb., 2 1-2 lbs. for 10c. And a full line of Cnnued Goods. 'oru, 8c a can. Peas, 8c a can. Beans, 8c a can. Tomatoes Sc a can. 2 Cans Peaches for 2 c. t abbages, 5c and 8c a he ml.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Windham County Reformer · Battleboro, Vt.

The clipping, a jumbled fragment, reports Holmes's World confession blaming a man named Hatch and Mamie Williams for the Pitezel children's deaths, alongside a Chicago conductor's claim that Pitezel himself is alive and in Philadelphia.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Windham County Reformer · 22 November 1895 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

The case of Holmes, the multi-murderer, has had several more sensational developments this week. When his application for a new trial came up in the ciminal court at Philadelphia Monday, on the claim of new evidence to the effect that a woman had been found to whom Pitezel said just before his death, substantially, that he was going to commit suicide, Mr. Schoonmaker, one of Holmes' counsel was confronted with a charge of suborning perjury in getting this affidavit from the woman. The woman herself and the detective who got her to make the affidavit swore that it was perjured.

See moreSee less

The woman said she got $20 for swearing to it. The detective testified that Schoonmaker employed him to hunt up some woman who would swear to such a story, furnishing the affidavit all prepared beforehand, and the detective at once consulted with the district attorney and went ahead with the scheme so as to entrap Schoonmaker in his villiany. The latter, of course, protests his innocence and claims that the detective has "put up a job" on him, but he is held under bail for further investigation. Holmes himself made a long signed statement in the New York World Sunday, advancing the theory that the Pitezel children were all murdered by Hatch, an accomplice in his swindles, of which Holmes admits the guilt: and that Hatch did them at the instigation of his mistress, Mamie Williams, who formerly bore the same relation to Holmes, and that her motive in it was to get Holmes behind the bars so that he would never "peach" on her for the murder of her sister, whom Holmes says she killed in a jealous fit of rage on discovering that she was intimate with Holmes. Holmes devotes considerable effort to showing that Hatch, whose existence has thus far seemed more or less shadowy, is a real person, and he declares that the last time he ever saw him was at the depot in Burlington when it was arranged that Hatch should take Mrs. Pitezel and two of her children to London. A despatch from Chicago Monday tells of a street car conductor who asserts that within a few weeks he has seen and talked with B. F. Pitezel, the man whom Holmes is convicted of murdering, and that Pitezel admitted his identity to the conductor and to another man. The story is that Pitezel is now in Philadelphia with Minnie Williams and that he will declare himself to save Holmes' life. In this view Holmes' World story would seem to have been a bad miss.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash. · and 3 other papers

The clipping describes how Shoemaker arranged for a woman, secretly a police matron posed as Blanche A. Hannigan, to sign a prearranged affidavit about Pietzel, only for testimony to prove he had dictated it before even seeking her out.

Pullman Herald · 23 November 1895 · page 3

FOUNDATION OF THE CHARGE. Briefly told, the details of the charge are these: The trial for the Pietzel murder was not two days old when Shoemaker ap proached a private detective named John Schweiler and asked him to pro cure a woman who lived around Twelfth and Callow Hill streets, who would swear to certain facts in connec tion with the finding of Pietzel's body. Schweiler assented, but instead of straightway getting the woman, he told his story to Detective Geyer, who, for the commonwealth, brought to light the evidences of Holmes' multi-murder of children.

See moreSee less

Geyer submitted it to the dis trict attorney, and a most skilfull trap was prepared, a trap which has brought about the ruin of the opposing attor ney. Under instructions Geyer went to Mn. Margaret Reah, matron of th« Fourth district police station, and she, under the name of Blanche A. Hanni gan, was taken to Shoemaker by Schweller. Meantime Shoemaker hail prepared an affidavit stating that the deponent had known Pietzel, and to him had expressed his intention of committing suicide. Mrs. Hannlgan readily signed and swore to this, and Shoemaker gave'her two $10 bills for so doing. On each bill she marked the Initials "D. A. H." and today she exhib ited them in court. Shoemaker walked into the trap blindfolded. When he read the affida vit to the court, he declared that its contents had been dictated to him by the woman. A moment afterwards Ir refutable testimony was produced show ing that he had himself made up the affidavit and dictated it to a stenog rapher before he had even asked Schweiler to procure a woman to sign it, and that he had not so much as read

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory · 22 November 1895
  • The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · 23 November 1895
  • Red Lodge Picket · Red Lodge, Mont. · 23 November 1895

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · and 1 other paper

The clipping describes how Shoemaker's request for false swearing testimony was reported to Detective Geyer, who with the district attorney set a trap using a police matron posing under a false name to expose the scheme.

The Kootenai Herald · 23 November 1895 · page 7

BY PITCH DEFILED

scorn. FOUNDATION,OF THE CHARGE. Briefly told, the details of the charge are these: The trial for the Pietzel murder was not two days old when Shoemaker ap proached a private detective named John Schweller and asked him to pro cure a woman who lived around Twelfth and Callow Hill streets, who would swear to certain facts in connec tion with the finding of Pietzei's body, Schweiler assented, but Instead of straightway getting the woman, he told his story to Detective Geyer, who, for the commonwealth, brought to light the evidences of Holmes' multi-murder of children.

See moreSee less

Geyer submitted it to the dis trict attorney, and a most skilfull trap was prepared, a trap which has brought about the ruin of the opposing attor ney. Under instructions Goyor went to Mrs. Margaret Reah, matron of the Fourth district police station, and she, under the name of Blanche A. Hanni gan, was taken to Shoemaker by Schweiler. Meantime Shoemaker had 1 prepared an affidavit stating that the |

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash. · 23 November 1895

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · and 1 other paper

A Chicago Daily News story reports that a streetcar conductor named James McNary claims Benjamin F. Pietzel is alive and recently spoke with him, citing his nine months working for Pietzel as proof he recognized his voice.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Kootenai Herald · 23 November 1895 · page 7

SAV TUAT PIETZEL S STILL ALIVE Chicago People Spring a New Sensation in the loiimos Case. Chicago, Nov. 18.—The Daily News ■ this .evening publishes the following story: "James McNary, a conductor on the Sixty-third street line, has sprung a new sensation in the Holmes case, by stating that Benjamin F. Pietzel is alive and that he recently talked with him on his car. McNary claims there could be no mistake as he worked nine months for Pietze 1 and knows the pe culiarities of his voice. ''Robert Corbett, who has been fol lowing the case for months In behalf of j the Farmers' & Merchants' National

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash. · 23 November 1895

Red Lodge Picket · Red Lodge, Mont.

This damaged clipping is a jumbled fragment that references a claim that Pietzel committed suicide despite Holmes's conviction, alongside unrelated, disconnected scraps about a racing dispute, an explosion, and a railway claim, making coherent summary impossible.

Red Lodge Picket · 23 November 1895 · page 1

TOUCH PITCH AND BE DEFILED

min F. Pietzel, for whose murder H. H. today, nothing, absolutely nothing, exIn Holmes was convicted two weeks ago, cept great bluffs along the streams, risH i committed suicide, and that he, Shoe ing in the air, their sides seamed and cc a maker, paid a woman $20 to sign and 0 m. It spread rapidly and was aided Ci vestigate the first case, and the matter of of the conventiton. I n Dispute I'tween Turfinen in san Frant ewas settled and Henderson virtually ex by repeated explosions of whisky in Iii 'i 'Messages of greeting, have bien snt tt e d cisco Caused a Ruction.

See moreSee less

a barrels, which blew out windows and onerated. ment of the government's claim against the main line from the Missouri river to San Jose as it will stand July 1, 1896,

See the clipping

The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D.

This fragment describes a courtroom moment in which Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock amid a painful, total silence felt by everyone present.

The Bottineau Courant · 23 November 1895 · page 2

pressive silence, Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. For a moment there was not a sound. The silence was literally painful and every heart in that

See the clipping

Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.

The fragment reports that Holmes, discussing children's mutilated remains found burned in cellars of houses he tenanted, now names a mysterious man called Hatch as the murderer of young Howard Pitezel and his sisters Alice and Nellie.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Narragansett Herald · 23 November 1895 · page 1

HOLMES EXPLAINS. Declares Missing Hatch Killed the Pitezel Children. For the First Time Reveals Identity of Mysterious Witness.

m“lo-rod children, whose mutilated remains we™ fonnd burned in the cellars of houses tenantedd by Holmes. For the first time Holmes revea!s the identity of the mysteri ous man Hateh, and points to him as the murderer of young Howard Pitezel and hus little sisters, Alice and Nellie. Fdward Hatech. Who is he? Wha! counection has he with the Holmes i CASe - 1

See the clipping

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

A fragmentary item reports that attorneys Rotan and Shoemaker appeared before Judge Arnold in Philadelphia to show cause for securing a new trial for Henry Holmes, convicted a fortnight earlier.

The Kimball Graphic · 23 November 1895 · page 2

WORKING FOR HOLMES. The Attorneys of the Murderer Try* Philadelphia, Nov. 18.—Attorneys Rotan and Shoemaker appeared before Judge Arnold today, to show cause why Henry Holmes, convicted a fortnight insr to Secure a New Trial. 1

See the clipping

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

During arguments for a new trial for convicted murderer H. H. Holmes, a defense affidavit claiming the victim planned suicide was revealed as fabricated, with a police matron admitting she impersonated the supposed witness for payment.

The Kimball Graphic · 23 November 1895 · page 2

MOTHER HOLMES SENSATION

miladelphia, Nov. IS.—The motion for a new trial in the case of H. H. Holmes, the famous prisoner, who stands convicted of the murder of Benj. P. Peltzel, was presented In the court of oyer and terminer this morn ing before Jii'lge Arnold. Testimony was "begun in support of the motion. The argument for a new trial, in case of convicted murderer, Holmes, was heard this morning In the criminal court Like all the phases of this sin gular case, this ordinarily routine pro cedure furnished a sensation. It was furnished oy Mr.

See moreSee less

Shoemaker, one of Holmes' counsel. Mr. Shoemaker pre sented an affidavit from a witness pur porting to be named Blanche Hannigan. In that affidavit, the witness swore that she kept a cigar store on Callowhill street near the house where Peltzel was killed and that she knew the dead man, and that he told her he Intended to com mit suicide. District Attorney Graham asked that the witness be called to the stand and Mr. Shoemaker replied that he did not know where she was. Then Mr. Graham called a private detective named Swetzler to the stand. The detective testified that Shoemaker, weeks ago, had written out the affidavit and given him $20 to pay some one to swear to it. Then Detective Geyer was called and he testified that Swetzler had shown him the affidavit before was signed. Then a woman was called to the stand who said she was the "Blanche Hannigan" who signed the affidavit. She swore that she knew nothing about the statements in the affidavit. Her name instead of being Hannigan, was Rhea and she is the matron in the Fourth police district. It was at the suggestion of Detective Geyer that she went with Swetzler to Shoemaker and Impersonated "Blanche Hannigan." Shoemaker gave her $20 and took her before the notary public and she swore to the statement. This astonishing etstlmony that seemed to clearly point to a perjured affidavit, evidently surprised the court and when Shoemaker attempted to make some confused statement, the court suggested to him that his great est safety lay in silence. Mr. Rotan, Holmes' other attorney, stated to the court that he knew nothing of the affi davit, and then he began the argument for anew trial. The main points of his reasons for asking for a new trial were given in these dispatches last week when application for a new trial was filed. As Mr. Rotan proceeded it became evident from the questions of the court that the application for a new trial would be refused. Mr. Rotan argued for an hour and fifty minutes and then District Attorney Graham replied. In his argument, Mr. Rotan had dwealt upon the Inadmis sibility of evidence of Miss Yoke on the ground that the commonwealth had not clearly shown that she was not the pris oner's wife and that therefore she was not a competent witness. Mr. Graham reproduced the prisoner's letters to the Willamette. 111., wife, acknowledging the ceremony of marriage and then Mr. Graham sprung a surprise on Holmes that perceptibly took him aback. Mr. Graham put in evidence a record from the Chicago courts of an application for a divorce filed by Holmes asking for a separation from his real wife, who lives in Gilmerton, N. H. He also produced an affidavit from this wife that while making the now famous journey with Mrs. Peitzel and Miss Yoke, Holmes came to see her and resumed his re» latlons as a husband with her.

See the clipping

Wiarus · Winona, Minn.

The clipping reports that attorney William A. Shoemaker, defending H. H. Holmes, was arrested after prosecutor Graham exposed a plot in which Shoemaker, through a secret agent, had a prison matron pose as a woman willing to falsely swear that Pitzel had killed himself, paying her $10 for the forged statement.

Wiarus · 28 November 1895 · page 3

Główny obrońca oskarżonego William A. Shoemaker, został uwięzionym na podstawie o skarżenia namawiania do kzrywoprzysięztwa. Shoema ker starał się o to, ażeby przedstawić sądowi dowody, że Pitzel, go H. H. Holmes został na śmierć skazanym, nie został zamordowanym ale popełnił samobójstwo. Otóż dowiedzio no adwokatowi, że ofiarowy wał jednej kobiecie podpisze i zaprzysięże fałszy we zeznanie, napisane przez p. Shoemaker, czyli że starał się kobietę namówić do popełnienia krzywoprzysięz twn.Prokurator sam podstawi tę kobietę adwokatowi, który w dramatycznej mowie przed sądem, obiecywał przedsta wić nowe dowody niewinności swego klienta. Wówczas prokurator odkrył cały spisek i Shoemaker został aresztowanym.

See moreSee less

Zaraz 2 początkiem procesu H. H. Holmes, Shoemaker zwrócił się do tajnego ajenta Schweichler z proźbą o wyszukanie mu kobiety, która by była gotową, złożyć fałszywe zeznania. Ajent zgodził się na to, ale pacichu uwiadomił *prokuratora Gra ham. Ten kazał mu się udać do pani Margarety Reah, klucznicy we więzieniu kobiet, ta zaś pod przybranem naz wiskiem Blanche A. Hannigan przedstawiła się adwokatowi Shoemaker. Ten wypracował fałszywe zeznanie, w którem owa kobieta świadczyła, że Pitzela i że on jej powiedział, że sobie życie odbierze. PaniReah podpisała zeznanie i za to otrzymała $10 z tychże pani Reach, napisała B.|A. H.. i te pieniądze zostały przedstawione sądowi jako dowód. C. PHILADELPHIA, Pa. za zamordowanie które­ 4 #20 banknotach. Na każdym jeżeli $20, w dwu

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 1 other paper

The clipping, which breaks off incomplete, states that H. H. Holmes' attorney in Philadelphia is accused of subornation of perjury, asserting something about Pitzel, whose murder led to Holmes' conviction.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

Wood County Reporter · 28 November 1895 · page 6

H. H. Holmes’ attorney, in Philadel phia, is accused of subornation of per jury. It is asserted that Pitzel, of whose murder Holmes was convicted,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis. · 28 November 1895

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 4 other papers

A Philadelphia court denied Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, a new trial after reviewing fifteen exceptions to his murder conviction, then formally sentenced him to death.

Evening Star · 30 November 1895 · page 1

PHILADELPHIA, November 30.-In the court of oyer and terminer toaay Judge Ar i.old refused to grant Herman W. .Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, who was convicted on November li for the murder in this city on September 2, 1NI4, of B. F. Pitezcl, a new trial, and sentenced the condemned man to death. Promptly at 10 o'clock Holmes, accompa nied by his counsel, came into court. He looked careworn and seemed to have lost that air of confidence which has clung to Mm throughout his trying ordeal. Court opened with a brief tilt between Judge Arnold and Lawyer Rotan, counsel for the defendant.

See moreSee less

Judge Arnold charged that Mr. Rotan had offered an insult to the court by briefs to President Judge Thaycr and Judge Willson, who had sat wuh Judge Arnold when Holmes' counsel had argued for a new trial, but neglected to send him a copy. Mr. Rotan said that the briefs had been prepared hurriedly, and if the judge had been overlooked it was a mistake. He said: "I do not want the impression to go forth that I have done wrong. I do not want to be attacked that way. There wes no die respect intended when I sent the briefs to Judges Thayer and Willson, and as a mem* her of this bar you should have that confi dence In me." Judge Arnold made no further comment, but proceeded to rea.1 the court's answer to Holmes' counsel's reason for a new trial. He took up the fifteen exceptions to the verdict one at a time, and dwelt at Itngth upon each. The main reasons for a new trial which were put forth by the defendant's counsel were the admission of the testimony of Miss Yoke, whom lio?mes claimed as his lawful wife; the district attorney's opening speech to the Jury, when he brought the murder of the children into the caso, and that part of Mrs. Pitezel's testimony in which she said the last time she faw her children "was in the morgue at Toronto." In reference to Miss Yoke's eligibility as a witness, the Judge said that it was the opinion of the court that Holmes was not only married to the Wllliamette. 111., wo man when he wedded Miss Y'oke, but that he also had a wife in ililman, N. U. There fore, the marriage to Miss Y'oke was null ar.d void, and the e\idence was Admissible, The opening speech of the district at'or ney, he said, was not open to objection. It was the evident intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to take off the entire Pitezcl family in order to secure property belonging to the murdered man. As to the statement of Mrs. Pitezel, the judge had instructed the jury not to be influenced by the woman's statement. He closed by saying that the court ap proved the verdict and refused a new trial. District Attorney Graham then arose and asked that sentence be pror.ounced. Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said: "Herman W. Mud gett. have you anything to say?" Holmes replied in a barely audible voice: "I have nothing to say." Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence as follows: "It Is the sentence of this court that you be taken hence whence you came and there be hanged by the neck until yon are dead. May God have mercy on your soul." The expression on Holmes' face remained the s'tme. He was taken from the court to prison. Governor Hastings will fix the day of Holmes' execution. An appeal to the su preme court will l>e taken at once.

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 30 November 1895
  • Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C. · 30 November 1895
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 5 December 1895
  • The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · the Dalles, Or. · 7 December 1895

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report states that the Philadelphia court today denied the motion to annul the verdict against H. H. Holmes and sentenced the accused to death.

Abendblatt · 30 November 1895 · page 1

Der Gerichtshof in Philadelphia hat heute den Antrag der Kafsirung des Ur—- theils in Sachen des H. H. Holmes abge lehnt und den Angetlagten zum Tode Das ,Ashanti-Picknick.

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report states that Judge Arnold today refused to quash the verdict against H. H. Holmes for the murder of Benjamin F. (surname cut off) and pronounced the death sentence against the accused.

Abendblatt · 30 November 1895 · page 1

Das Scheusal Holmes Soll die Ermordung des Pitzel am Galgen bußen. Die Kassirung des Urtheils verweigert.

Philadelphia, 30. Nov. Der Richter Arnold hat heute die Kassi rung des Urtheils gegen H. H. Holmes we— gen Ermordung des Benjamin F—. Litn verweigert und das Todesurtheil über den Angeklagten ausgesprochen. ; —: Die deutsche und englische Handels— !

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A Philadelphia judge refused H. H. Holmes a new trial after his murder conviction and death sentence, while separately Richard North was arrested for assaulting J. B. Kaasebaum and held on $500 bond.

The Topeka State Journal · 30 November 1895 · page 3

HOLMES WILL HANG. He Can't Dodge it, and n Dozen Murders Must Go Unpunished in Consequence. ' Philadelphia, Nov. 30. Judge Arn old today refused to grant a new trial to H, H, Holmes, who was convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitzel in this city Sep tember 2, 1S94, and sentenced him to death. Iticlinrtl Xortti Arrested. Richard North who assaulted J. B, Kaasebauin yesterday was arrested by Deputy Sheriff Tom Wilkerson this morning and taken before Justice Guy who fixed his bond at $500. The pre week. Terrible Storms in Russia. liminary examination will ba held next

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

A Philadelphia dispatch reports that Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of first-degree murder, was refused a new trial, though the clipping breaks off before giving further details.

The Jersey City News · 30 November 1895 · page 1

HOLMES SENTENCED TO DEATH A New Trial for the VInlil-VInrderer Rcfn«»d—A I-etlirl!ty Opinion. PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 30, 1895.—Her man W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, who w'as convicted of murder in the first

See the clipping

Capital Journal · Salem, Or.

This damaged, jumbled clipping combines fragments of unrelated items, including a $2,860,000 shipbuilding bid, mention of uncollected premiums and balances, and a reference to H. H. Holmes being sentenced for the murder of B. F. Pietzel.

Capital Journal · 30 November 1895 · page 1

The Newport news ship building Ledger balances, uncollected and dry dock uompanv, of Virginia, premluuiB and balances put In a straight bid of $2,860,000 for duo from agenta 24,872 62 nold today refused to grant a new and Austria, on tho grouud that tho trial to H. H. Holmes, the convicted powers are not In accord, und that tho murderer or B. F. PIctzol In this city, dissenting powers wero behind Abduo September SI, '94, and Bentonced him

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

The clipping, which breaks off mid-sentence, reports that the author of 'The Manxman' visited H. H. Holmes in his cell and described being deeply affected when Holmes's voice choked and tears came to his eyes.

The Scranton Tribune · 30 November 1895 · page 11

LITERARY GOSSIP

The author of "The Manxman" visited the cell of H. H. Holmes. When he came away he saliT: "The interview affected me very much. After we had talked a little the tears came to his eyes and 'his voice choked. That was too much for me, and

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Judge Arnold in Philadelphia refused to grant H. H. Holmes a new trial. Holmes had been convicted of murdering Benjamin Pietzel and was sentenced to death.

The Providence News · 30 November 1895 · page 1

PHILADELPRIA, Nov, 30,--J ndfio Arnold todaé refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes, who was covicted of the murder ot B, Pietzei in this city, Sep. 2, 18905, and sentenced him to death,

See the clipping