The first article: an insurance swindle
The story breaks in Washington the day after Holmes’s arrest in Boston. The Fidelity Mutual Life Association has paid $10,000 on a man who died in Philadelphia as ‘B. F. Perry,’ really Benjamin Pitezel, and the trail leads to H. H. Holmes, who had a desk in the same Chicago building. The headline says the corpse was a fake. It wasn’t: it was Pitezel, and Holmes had killed him.
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
The Washington Times · 18 November 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
$10,000 FOR A BOGUS BODY
That Price Was Paid by the Fidelity Mutual Life Association.
See moreSee less
BUT THE CORPSE WAS A FAKE
The Slick Methods by Which Mr. Holmes Secured a Fortune Upon the Alleged Death of B. F. Pitzel—Is Finally Arrested in Boston—The Deed Done in Philadelphia.
PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 17.—An elaborate life insurance swindle has come to light in this city.
On September 3 last, the corpse of a man was found at 1316 Callowhill street, this city, and was buried by the coroner under the name of B. F. Pitzel. Now it appears that the corpse was a bogus one substituted for the purpose of defrauding the insurance company of $10,000.
B. F. Pitzel rented the house on Callowhill street during the summer under the name of B. F. Perry, and while there conducted a patent medicine business. The last week in August he disappeared and on September 3 a man with whom he had had business relations, went to the house and found Perry dead on the floor. Death was attributed to the explosion of a jar of cleaning fluid.
After the body had been buried in the potters' field a communication was received by the Fidelity Mutual Life Association, dated St. Louis, and signed by an attorney of that city, J. D. Howe. It stated that he had seen the death notice in a Philadelphia newspaper and that he represented the dead man's widow.
The letter further stated that the real name of the deceased was B. F. Pitzel, a beneficiary of the company, the name of Perry having been assumed on account of financial difficulties in Tennessee.
The policy had been issued through the agency of a reputable business man, but when he was questioned he referred the inquirer to H. H. Holmes, who had had a desk in the same building with the deceased in Chicago during the World's Fair.
The general manager could not locate Holmes at first, but found his wife, and by her was told that her husband was a traveling man and she would communicate with him.
The manager left with her a clipping, referring to a body found in Chicago, and a few days later the office received a letter from Holmes, offering to come to Chicago if his expenses were paid.
The next day, however, Holmes wrote to the Philadelphia office stating that he had learned that the death was in Philadelphia, and that as he expected to be in Baltimore soon he would stop in Philadelphia.
Meanwhile Attorney Howe appeared in Philadelphia, accompanied by a young girl whom he represented as the daughter of the dead man. He also produced a letter of introduction to Superintendent of Police Linden from a former assistant district attorney of St. Louis, and Supt. Linden sent him to President House, of the insurance company.
Holmes came to hand about the same time, and, though examined separately and denying acquaintance with each other, both men gave a corresponding description of the dead man.
It was then decided to exhume the body, which was done by officials of the coroner. The officials of the company were satisfied and the body was reburied, and Attorney Howe received the $10,000, representing the sum due Mrs. Pitzel.
The insurance company never doubted the truth of the identification, although they had a belief that the case was one of murder, rather than accident. A month ago, however, one of the company's agents, while in St. Louis, became cognizant of some of the facts, and he formulated the theory of conspiracy.
Additional detectives were put on the case and Holmes was chased all over the country. The mother of the supposed dead man was found and from minute descriptions of her son it at once appeared that the corpse found was not his. In the meantime it was discovered that Holmes' real name was Herman Mudget and his home New Hampshire. His aliases were legion. He is known in New York, Chicago, Fort Worth, St. Louis, and almost [e]very other big city.
Then it was learned that Pitzel and Holmes obtained, by some means or other, a corpse from the New York Hospital, brought it here, surrounded it by the evidences of a violent death in the Callowhill street house, and obtained the $10,000 as above described.
Holmes was arrested in a west end boarding-house in Boston by Pinkerton detectives, who are now after the other conspirator, Pitzel.



