Two bodies in Toronto
Alice and Nellie Pitezel have been found buried in a cellar on St. Vincent Street in Toronto, and the expressman who carried Holmes’s trunk into the house picks his photograph out of a pile. Detective Geyer believes Minnie Williams, the stenographer Holmes says took the children to England, was murdered too. Questioned by the district attorney’s staff, Holmes lets slip, ‘I suppose I’ll swing for this,’ though his lawyer says he was not in Toronto when the children were killed.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 18 July 1895 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image
INDIANAPOLIS, IND., July 16.—The Journal to-day prints an article containing the statement that the Pietzel boy, the brother of Alice and Nellie Pietzel, whose dead bodies are supposed to have been unearthed at Toronto yesterday, was beyond doubt murdered in this city on October 6th last, presumably by Holmes, the insurance swindler, now in custody at Philadelphia.
It was developed that a certain express driver, by the agreement with Holmes, called at the old Circle House on that date and removed through a rear door, a large trunk which is believed to have contained the boy's remains. The driver, Louis by name, has identified the picture of Holmes as that of the man who employed him.
See moreSee less
The three Pietzel children were in this city at three different hotels for some time, under the guardianship of Holmes.
TORONTO, ONT., July 16.—The bodies of the two Pietzel children, which were exhumed in the cellar of a vacant house yesterday, were to-day removed to the morgue. Drs. Caven and R. B. Orr are engaged in a post mortem to-day, to discover by what means the little ones met their death. The inquest will be reopened as soon as the autopsy is concluded.
Efforts will be made to extradite Holmes at once, and to give him the benefit of swift and, sure Canadian justice.
THE INQUEST.
TORONTO, ONT., July 17.—The inquest on the bodies of Ella and Nellie Pietzel was opened last night. Evidence was taken as to the finding of the bodies and then the jury adjourned until to-night, to await the postmortem report of the medical men entrusted with the examination of the bodies.
Detectives Geyer and Cudahy are hard at work. To-day they discovered the expressman who took the trunk which has invariably accompanied Holmes in all his journeys, into the St. Vincent street house, and this man had no difficulty in picking out Holmes' photograph from a number of others.
Detective Geyer thinks he has clues that will lead to the discovery of the fate of Minnie R. Williams, Holmes' Chicago stenographer, who he says went to England with the children, but whom Geyer believes Holmes to have murdered.
HOLMES' ADMITS HIS GUILT.
PHILADELPHIA, PA., July 17.—H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgetts, has virtually confessed to the murder of the two Pietzel children, whose bodies were found in the cellar of a Toronto house. It was learned to-day at the office of the district attorney that during the two hours' interview Holmes had yesterday with three members of the district attorney's staff he said:
"I suppose I'll swing for this." This is the only remark dropped from Holmes' lips which in any way would tend to criminate him, and the district attorney takes this as a practical admission of Holmes' guilt.
COUNSEL CLAIMS AN ALIBI.
Notwithstanding Holmes' remark, his counsel says he can prove an alibi in his client's case. He says that Holmes was not in Toronto when the Pietzel children were murdered. This, he states, can be proven by Mrs. Howard, Holmes' third wife, who is at present living with her mother in Franklin, Ind.
The authorities place but little credence in the alibi story and are satisfied that Holmes is the murderer.