As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

The Children

18–31 July 1895

In July 1895 the bodies of two of Pitezel’s daughters were found in a Toronto cellar, and the swindle became a murder story overnight. In June the papers in this collection printed 7 articles about Holmes. In July they printed 555.

Two bodies in Toronto

Alice and Nellie Pitezel have been found buried in a cellar on St. Vincent Street in Toronto, and the expressman who carried Holmes’s trunk into the house picks his photograph out of a pile. Detective Geyer believes Minnie Williams, the stenographer Holmes says took the children to England, was murdered too. Questioned by the district attorney’s staff, Holmes lets slip, ‘I suppose I’ll swing for this,’ though his lawyer says he was not in Toronto when the children were killed.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 18 July 1895 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

INDIANAPOLIS, IND., July 16.—The Journal to-day prints an article containing the statement that the Pietzel boy, the brother of Alice and Nellie Pietzel, whose dead bodies are supposed to have been unearthed at Toronto yesterday, was beyond doubt murdered in this city on October 6th last, presumably by Holmes, the insurance swindler, now in custody at Philadelphia.

It was developed that a certain express driver, by the agreement with Holmes, called at the old Circle House on that date and removed through a rear door, a large trunk which is believed to have contained the boy's remains. The driver, Louis by name, has identified the picture of Holmes as that of the man who employed him.

See moreSee less

The three Pietzel children were in this city at three different hotels for some time, under the guardianship of Holmes.

TORONTO, ONT., July 16.—The bodies of the two Pietzel children, which were exhumed in the cellar of a vacant house yesterday, were to-day removed to the morgue. Drs. Caven and R. B. Orr are engaged in a post mortem to-day, to discover by what means the little ones met their death. The inquest will be reopened as soon as the autopsy is concluded.

Efforts will be made to extradite Holmes at once, and to give him the benefit of swift and, sure Canadian justice.

THE INQUEST.

TORONTO, ONT., July 17.—The inquest on the bodies of Ella and Nellie Pietzel was opened last night. Evidence was taken as to the finding of the bodies and then the jury adjourned until to-night, to await the postmortem report of the medical men entrusted with the examination of the bodies.

Detectives Geyer and Cudahy are hard at work. To-day they discovered the expressman who took the trunk which has invariably accompanied Holmes in all his journeys, into the St. Vincent street house, and this man had no difficulty in picking out Holmes' photograph from a number of others.

Detective Geyer thinks he has clues that will lead to the discovery of the fate of Minnie R. Williams, Holmes' Chicago stenographer, who he says went to England with the children, but whom Geyer believes Holmes to have murdered.

HOLMES' ADMITS HIS GUILT.

PHILADELPHIA, PA., July 17.—H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgetts, has virtually confessed to the murder of the two Pietzel children, whose bodies were found in the cellar of a Toronto house. It was learned to-day at the office of the district attorney that during the two hours' interview Holmes had yesterday with three members of the district attorney's staff he said:

"I suppose I'll swing for this." This is the only remark dropped from Holmes' lips which in any way would tend to criminate him, and the district attorney takes this as a practical admission of Holmes' guilt.

COUNSEL CLAIMS AN ALIBI.

Notwithstanding Holmes' remark, his counsel says he can prove an alibi in his client's case. He says that Holmes was not in Toronto when the Pietzel children were murdered. This, he states, can be proven by Mrs. Howard, Holmes' third wife, who is at present living with her mother in Franklin, Ind.

The authorities place but little credence in the alibi story and are satisfied that Holmes is the murderer.

See the clipping

Digging in Chicago

Police start tearing up Holmes’s building in Englewood, Chicago, and find charred bone, burned cloth and a shoe button in the cellar stove; Chicago even credits him with an old kidnapping. In an interview, Holmes blames an accomplice named Hatch, whom detectives call a myth.

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Herald · 21 July 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES' INFAMY GROWS

A Chicago Kidnaping Now Accredited to His Villainy

See moreSee less

Says He Can Prove an Alibi as to the Murdered Pitzel Children Found at Toronto

PHILADELPHIA, July 20.—The Press today publishes an interview with H. H. Holmes, who says he can prove an alibi with reference to the murder of the Pitzel children at Toronto, and that the authorities here cannot prove that Pitzel was murdered in this city. He insists that Hatch, who, he says was engaged in fur smuggling with him, is not a myth, as the detectives say, and he could tell what became of the Miss Williams and the Pitzel children, as when Holmes saw them last Hatch was with them and was to see them off for Europe.

CHICAGO, July 20.—Search for the body of the missing Williams girl was begun early today in the house at Englewood formerly occupied by the alleged murderer, H. H. Holmes. Yesterday's developments lead to the belief that evidences of the supposed crime were concealed somewhere about the house, and suspicion of neighbors and detectives pointed strongly towards a large cellar in which a disageeable odor had been detected. Every inch of ground will be dug up. Examination of a large grate of Holmes' stove today resulted in another startling discovery, when two charred bones, resembling human ribs, were found among the ashes. The finding of the supposed ribs with the burned woman's shoe button and pieces of cloth, was considered by the police practically proving that at least a portion of the body of the woman had been cremated. The stove is six feet high and four feet in diameter, and would easily hold a body.

Late this afternoon a bunch of human hair was found in the chimney of the Holmes house by newspaper reporters. The police were notified and upon examination of the hair it was pronounced that of a woman. The appearance of the locks led to the belief that they had been burned from the head and drawn up the stove pipe.

While the workmen were digging in the cellar they encountered an obstruction, which exploded with terrible force, seriously injuring four men. Two of them are thought to be fatally hurt.

The men injured by the explosion are: Timothy Mulhale, Joseph Patrello, Thomas Olefort, Joseph Kenyon, fire marshal; Joseph Dally, Thomas Guers, James Meagher, and Edward McCormick. The first three were laboring men. All of them were badly, though not fatally burned. The others were firemen who were overcome by gas. An investigation showed that the gas came from a large tank fifteen feet deep and ten feet in diameter. It was partially filled ed with a peculiarly smelling liquid, the exact nature of which has not been determined. From the other side of the tank numerous pipes extended, the end projecting inside the tank, being carefully wrapped in burlaps. Several of the men were strangely affected by the gas. The opinion is that the tank was a swindling device of Holmes, who at one time while living here claimed to have a new process for the manufacture of gas.

CHICAGO, July 20.—Some years ago Chicago was startled by the bold kidnapping of little Annie Redmond, daughter of a South Side blacksmith. Her abductors, while keeping their identity a secret, admitted in a series of notes sent to the parents of the child their sole object was to hold her for a big ransom.

See the clipping

The list keeps growing

By late July every disappearance near Holmes is being added to his account. From an Arkansas prison, a convict named Allen points the sheriff of Fort Worth to Milford Cole, a Baltimore lumberman who met Holmes in Texas, went to Chicago when Holmes wired for him, and, the story goes, was never seen again. Allen will be heard from again.

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va. · and 1 other paper

Wheeling Register · 29 July 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ANOTHER PROBABLE MURDER.

Charged Up to the Account of Holmes—A Lumber Man's Disappearance.

See moreSee less

Little Rock, Ark., July 28.—It is probable that John C. Allen, alias John C. Caldwell, the associate of insurance swindler H. H. Holmes, who is serving a fifteen-year sentence in the penitentiary here for horse stealing, may be the means of fixing upon Holmes the responsibility for another murder. Sheriff McRae, of Fort Worth, Texas, who was in this city last week, had a long talk with Allen, and in their conversation the disappearance last year of Milford Cole, a wealthy Baltimorean, was mentioned. Cole came here a year ago last spring as the representative of a Baltimore lumber syndicate. He at once became prominent in lumber circles, buying a saw mill near Beebe, north of here, on the Iron Mountain road, and contracting for the purchase of 25,000 acres of timber lands in Southwestern Arkansas. In July, 1894, he spent two weeks at Fort Worth, Texas, becoming well acquainted with Holmes, who tried to interest him in some business enterprises. These facts Cole mentioned to friends on his return to Little Rock. About three weeks afterward he was summoned to Chicago by a telegram from Holmes, and, so the story goes, has not been seen or heard of since. Both Allen and Sheriff McRae, it is said, recalled Cole's association with Holmes at Fort Worth last year, and Cole's subsequent disappearance.

See the clipping

Holmes’s suicide story

Holmes’s fullest version yet: he found Pitezel dead beside a suicide note, then disfigured the body so the insurance claim would work. Three months later a jury decided he had killed Pitezel himself.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 July 1895 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE DEATH OF PITZEL

Holmes Declares That His Late Pal Committed Suicide.

See moreSee less

THE CORPSE THEN BURNED.

Holmes Put His Dead Friend's Body to Account—The Alleged Skeleton Wirer Crazy.

Philadelphia, July 29.—The Bulletin today prints the following: An entirely new statement has just been made by H. H. Holmes, the supposed murderer of the Pitzel children. In it the man of many crimes gives in detail his version of how Pitzel came by his death last September, and also states his (Holmes') connection with the tragedy. The statement was given to a close friend of Holmes' in Philadelphia, who gave it to a Bulletin reporter.

Holmes says that on the Saturday night preceding the death of Pitzel the latter came to his house on North Eleventh street, where he was staying with "Mrs. Howard." Pitzel told Holmes a heart-rending story of his pecuniary difficulties, and of the sickness of his daughter in St. Louis, saying: "I must have money," or words to that effect, "to send to my wife in St. Louis." Holmes remonstrated with Pitzel as to his spendthrift habits, and spoke substantially to him as follows: "You have been a good friend of mine; I'll admit that I have made lots of money through you, but I cannot keep this thing up. Where is that $50 I gave you the other day? If you don't quit drinking, you and I will have to separate."

This conversation is said to have been carrried on along Eleventh street, the men walking north until Morris street was reached. When they arrived at the corner Pitzell exclaimed: "I am of no benefit to you. I will soon get rid of my difficulties. Life has become a nuisance to me."

Holmes then avers that he jokingly remarked to Pitzel: "Well, your body is as good as any other, but I would not advise you to do anything rash."

Holmes accounts for making this remark by saying that he and Pitzel had under consideration the defrauding of the Fidelity Mutual Insurance Company. Holmes says Pitzel then became angry and again avowed that he would commit suicide. Holmes then explained that Pitzel left him with the intention of going home. Holmes says, he gave him no money that night, but promised to meet him at the Callow Hill street house the following morning. It was about 10 the following day (Sunday), Holmes goes on to say, that he went to visit Pitzel at the Callow Hill house. When he reached the place, no one was apparently about. Holmes sat in the kitchen for almost twenty minutes waiting for Pitzel. The latter, Holmes supposed, had gone out for breakfast. The time wore on, and Ben was not to be seen. The conspirator then says that he became anxious about his friend's whereabouts, and began to search the house for him.

"As I rose to go upstairs," says the criminal, "I noticed a note lying on the counter in the front part of the house. It was addressed to me." Holmes explains that he tore the note open. It directed him to go to the second floor and open a closet, in which he would find a large blue bottle containing another letter addressed to him. Holmes followed the directions. He found the note in the bottle as described, and was horrified when he read it. It was from Benjamin Pitzel, and advised Holmes that his (Pitzel's) dead body could be found in the house. The latter pleaded that Holmes look after Pitzel's children, and suggested that there would be no difficulty in getting the insurance money from the Fidelity company, now that the dead body of Pitzel could be produced in evidence. Holmes then told his friend of the appearance of the corpse, and said he sat in the room with the body for over an hour. He was dazed, and hardly knew what course to follow. He finally made up his mind that since Pitzel had taken his life there would be no harm in destroying any evidence of suicide; that he might be able to get the insurance on his life without difficulty.

Holmes confessed that he then dragged the dead body to the second floor, laid the corpse on the floor, pried open the mouth of the dead man and poured in a quantity of explosive chemicals. He then says he placed a lighted match to the dead man's mouth, when the explosion which so horribly disfigured the corpse followed. To give a forcible impression that Pitzel came to his death by an accidental explosion, Holmes stated to his friend that he got a pipe of Pitzel's, filled it with tobacco, lighted it, then blew out the flame after the tobacco had been partly consumed and placed the pipe beside the dead man's body. It was nearly 4 o'clock in the afternoon before he left the Callow Hill street house. He put on a hat of Pitzel to partially conceal his identity, and placed his own hat, which was a felt one, under his coat. The criminal went directly to the Broad street station, so he alleges, and inquired at what hour the first train left for Chicago. Holmes says he does not distinctly remember at what hour the railway officials told him a Chicago train would leave, but believed it was between 8 and 9:30 o'clock at night. He then went to the house where he was staying and made preparations to leave the city. He and his wife, Holmes alleges, then left for Chicago that night.

It is understood that if the prosecution decides to indict Holmes for the murder of Pitzel in Philadelphia they will produce a witness who, it is said, heard the conversation between Holmes and Pitzel on that eventful evening, when the latter threatened to do away with his life. It has also been learned that the state has another witness who was on the train on which were Holmes and his wife, en route to Chicago. This witness, it is understood, can testify that Holmes sat in an apparent stupor on his way West; that he had a novel before him for over an hour, and was seemingly so much dazed that during that time he never turned a page of the book.

Chicago, July 29.—Another case of mysterious disappearance which may yet be charged to Holmes was reported to the police today by the neighbors of Dr. Russeler, who disappeared in 1892. Dr. Russeler for several months had an office in Holmes' building. He and Holmes were often together, apparently being intimate friends. Some time in 1892, the date being a matter of doubt, the physician dropped out of sight. He had few acquaintances, and, although his disappearance caused some talk among the neighbors, little attention was paid to it.

Charles Chappell, son of M. S. Chappell, who claims to have been the assistant of Holmes and to have articulated skeletons for him, says his father has been of unsound mind for several years, and expresses the belief that his father knows nothing whatever of Holmes' doings.

See the clipping

A child’s bones in quicklime

Workmen in the basement of the Chicago building find a child’s skeleton in a bed of quicklime, thought to be Pearl Conner’s, and then a bone from a second body. Pearl and her mother, Julia, had not been seen since the summer of 1892.

Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · and 2 other papers

Mower County Transcript · 31 July 1895 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

BURIED IN QUICKLIME.

Workmen Unearth a Large Quantity of Human Bones.

See moreSee less

CHICAGO, July 27.—The men at work in the basement of the Holmes building unearthed in a bed of quicklime what is pronounced to be the skeleton of a child. The workmen, continuing their search in another portion of the basement, found a second bed of quicklime. In this, just before their labors ended for the day, they discovered one of the bones of a human body. The first body is supposed to be that of Pearl Conner, the daughter of Julia L. Conner, former wife of C. I. Conner, once of Muscatine, Ia., later of this city. Both the mother and child have been missing since the summer of 1892. The woman was betrayed by Holmes, her husband secured a divorce from her and she lived with Holmes at the castle. Some time in July or August, 1892, she and the child disappeared.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: First Hints of Suspicion