As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

The Hunt

August – October 1895

Through August and September the story ran in every direction at once: a second building in Texas, a convict selling what he knew, Holmes’s Chicago ‘castle’ dug up and then burned, and the search for the third child, Howard.

A second death trap, in Texas

In Fort Worth, investigators find a building Holmes put up with a room of 12 exits and a chute to the basement, laid out like his Chicago den. Holmes admits his relations with Emily Cigrand, who had worked for him, but says she is alive in a convent. The convict Allen claims Minnie Williams is alive too, and Arkansas’s governor may pardon him if what he knows can convict a murderer.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 1 other paper

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Journal · 1 August 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

ANOTHER DEATH TRAP. It Was Built by Holmes In Fort Worth, Tex.

PLANNED LIKE HIS CHICAGO DEN.

See moreSee less

Holmes Admits His Relations With Emily Cigrand, but Says That the Girl Is Now In a Convent—Quinlan Makes a Damaging Admission, and a Convict Talks.

FORT WORTH, Tex., Aug. 1.—William Cappa, who is now in Chicago on the Holmes case, belongs to the firm of Cappa & Canley of this city, who some time ago instituted suit against the present holders of property owned by the Williams sisters. The suit is brought at the instance of the heirs of the girls, and it is claimed that the deeds were forged by Holmes.

Allen, the Arkansas convict, who is so anxious to tell his connection with the murders, was at one time in the employ of Holmes in this city. Allen went by the name of Mascott in this city, and it is believed here that he can tell a great deal about Holmes and his transactions if he wants to. Allen was an ex-convict from the prison at Joliet.

While Holmes, or Pratt, as he was known here, was living in this city he started to put up a large building. It was objected to on the ground that it was a regular fire trap, and the authorities forced him to remodel it somewhat. In view of the recent developments in Chicago the authorities have made an investigation of the building which leaves no room for doubt that Holmes had planned it for a death trap.

One room at the top of the house has 12 exits by which a person can escape, while an inclosed chute runs down to the basement of the building, in which a body could be transferred without any one being the wiser. In this basement a large archway had been built over the sewer in such a way that he could easily put in a trapdoor opening into the sewer.

Under the floor of the house was found a large pit, the intended use of which can only be conjectured. Holmes probably intended this building to be used as he afterward used his house in Chicago.

Convict Allen Talks.

LITTLE ROCK, Aug. 1.—Governor Clark has not yet heard directly from the Illinois authorities as to the pardoning of Convict Allen, who is said to possess valuable information in connection with the criminal career of H. H. Holmes. The governor said:

"If I am convinced that Allen can convict a man of murder who is guilty and would otherwise go unpunished, I would be strongly inclined to pardon him."

When seen by a reporter, Convict Allen said:

"My name is not Hatch, and I never at any time passed under that alias. My real name is Caldwell, but I have passed under the aliases of Allen and Fogg and was known in Fort Worth often as Mascott. I can unravel the Fort Worth swindle," said he, "if I am paid for it, and I can show that Minnie Williams was not murdered. I heard from her a few months ago, and she is afraid to come to this country."

When reminded that turning state's evidence by Quinlan would put him in a very tight place and convict Holmes, he said, with some excitement:

"Quinlan shall never be allowed to have Holmes hanged, for of the two Holmes is much more of a gentleman, and as for me, he does not know anything to cause me trouble. If he did, I would have left the country."

Allen's present job in the penitentiary is not a hard one, and he says that a pardon would be no inducement unless he could also get some money out of it. Notwithstanding his strong denials it is probable that Allen and Hatch are the same persons.

Quinlan Makes a Break.

CHICAGO, Aug. 1.—Experiments were made with the liquid found in the bottom of the vat in the cellar of Holmes' house, and it was found that whenever mixed with benzine or kerosene it would emit a vapor so deadly that no human being could live in it. Whether or not Holmes used the vapor for suffocating his victims is not known, but the police are inclined to favor such a theory.

Another link in the chain binding Quinlan to the alleged crimes of H. H. Holmes was forged by an admission made by Quinlan when questioned by Chief of Police Badenoch. He said he was hired by a man named Allen to go to Fort Worth, Tex. At the time he was engaged he said he had one day's acquaintance with Allen, and on the following day he started for Fort Worth.

Quinlan had previously claimed that he had no knowledge of any crimes committed by Holmes, although he had admitted that in Fort Worth he met and knew a man called Mascott. Now that Allen and Mascott are practically proved to be one and the same man, Quinlan's contradictory stories have placed him in a still worse light with the police.

Says She's In a Convent.

PHILADELPHIA, Aug. 1.—H. H. Holmes was seen in his cell by a reporter and talked freely about the charges made against him, especially those relating to Emily Cigrand. He admitted that he had betrayed the girl in Chicago and that she had afterward told this fact to a priest, who insisted that a marriage ceremony be performed. Holmes says that he took her to an obscure place in Minnesota and married her under an assumed name, the ceremony being fraudulent. Pat Quinlan, he declared, knew of Holmes' relations with the girl, having found her in his room one night when there was a fire near the "castle."

In May, 1892, the prisoner continued, Miss Cigrand left his employ and went into a convent, where she now is. Quinlan, he asserted, knows all about her and can produce her at any time. Holmes added that in justice to Quinlan and "Mascott" he desired to say that they knew little about his movements.

See the clipping

A poison vat in the castle

Chicago police test the liquid from a vat in the castle cellar and find that, mixed with benzine, it gives off a vapor no one could survive. In Julia Conner’s rooms they follow a trail of human blood to a secret trap door and down into the basement, and Illinois sends a lawyer to Little Rock to offer the convict Allen his freedom for evidence.

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · and 2 other papers

The Princeton Union · 8 August 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

KILLED BY HOLMES.

FURTHER EVIDENCE OF MURDER IN HOLMES' CASTLE.

See moreSee less

Detectives Searching the Building Find a Pair of Bloody Overalls—They Will Be Placed Upon Quinlan, the Suspected Janitor.

Chicago, Aug. 2. — Experiments were made to-day with the liquid found in the bottom of the vat in the cellar of Holmes' house and it was found that when mixed with benzine or kerosine it would emit a vapor so deadly that no human being could live in it. Whether or not Holmes used the vapor for suffocating his victims is not known, but the police are inclined to favor such a theory. Pat Quinlan, under the questioning of the chief of police, has let the cat out of the bag by admitting that "Mascott" was H. H. Holmes' confidential man in Fort Worth, Tex. "He engineered all the big deals for him," said Quinlan. "I was not good enough for the fine work." From further questioning the police believe that Hatch, A. E. Bond (through whom Minnie Williams' property in Fort Worth was conveyed to Benton T. Lyman), John C. Allen, A. C. Caldwell and "Mascott," who figure in different times and places in the Holmes case, are one and the same man. The man confined in the Little Rock penitentiary claims to be able to give the history of Holmes' deeds from first to last, but insists that he be pardoned out first. Detective Rea, of Fort Worth, last night telegraphed that Allen is the much-wanted "Mascott," and that he has given up some valuable information. By agreement between State's Attorney Kern, Mayor Swift, Chief Badenoch and Attorney Capp, the latter will leave to-night for Little Rock with credentials and authority granting him the power to represent the State of Illinois, and requesting the absolute and permanent release of Allen from the Arkansas penitentiary, such immunity being granted on condition that he fasten the crime of murder on Holmes by unmistakeable and existing evidence in this city.

Chicago, Aug. 3.—The police to-day acknowledge their complete defeat so far in the effort to secure direct evidence against H. H. Holmes. Dozens of promising clues have been carefully investigated, witness after witness who was confidently expected to tell all has been examined without result, and at last the detectives are forced to admit that their efforts have been unavailing so far as real proof of guilt is concerned. This was admitted by Inspector Fitzpatrick to-day.

"When we started on the case," he said, "we knew it would be almost impossible to get any one who could possibly connect Holmes with any case of murder, yet we thought it our duty to investigate, and we have done the best we could. We believe several crimes have been committed, and believe that Holmes and his confederates are guilty of several murders, but so far we are unable to prove our belief correct. We have no evidence that would even cause an indictment against any of the men under suspicion if it were presented to the grand jury."

Pat Quinlan was given a six-hour session in the sweat box to-day, but the result was as unsatisfactory as the previous examinations of the ex-janitor. Quinlan gives no evidence of weakening, and stubbornly sticks to his statement that he knows absolutely nothing of any killing. The police received word to-day of the mysterious hauling away from the Holmes house at night of several large boxes. The boxes were taken from the "Castle" during Holmes' residence there, and several detectives were detailed on the new lead in the case.

Philadelphia, Aug. 3.—Holmes, the alleged wholesale murderer, was questioned to-day in an interview: "Can you explain how so many bones came to be concealed in the basement and other parts of your Chicago house?"

"I will answer that question in this way," replied Holmes. "Every person who has known me is aware that I am a doctor by profession. It is also known perfectly well in Chicago that there was a restaurant in my building during the world's fair. At that time there were lots of bones from fowls and other cooked animals thrown outside the buildings. Lots of these bones, no doubt, found their way to the cellar. During the time I lived in the building I brought several cadavers there, both for scientific and pecuniary purposes. This may account for the bones the Chicago police say they have found."

Chicago, Aug. 4.—The police have at last obtained a partial confession from Pat Quinlan, the janitor of the Holmes castle, and have, they believe, positive evidence that Benjamin Pitzel was murdered in this city by Holmes and the corpse sent to Philadelphia.

The confession was wormed out of the Quinlans by means of a tip given the local officers by Detective Geyer of Philadelphia, who arrived in this city to-day. The exact nature of the story told by the Quinlans the police will not reveal, and in fact Chief Badenoch and Inspector Fitzpatrick have both denied that Quinlan or his wife made any confession at all. Notwithstanding the denial of the police, however, it is positively known that Quinlan made and signed a confession, because it was left where Quinlan's signature on the document could be seen, although the subject matter under which he wrote his name could not be ascertained. It has been learned that a confession was made covering all the details of the murder of Pitzel, with the exception of the actual place in which the crime was committed. This, the police declare, they will have to-morrow and they declare that in less than three days they will have indisputable evidence that Pitzel came to his end through the direct agency of H. H. Holmes. The confession was obtained from the Quinlans only after the hardest kind of work, and at the price of a promise of immunity from punishment for all part the Quinlans may have borne in the murder of Pitzel or other crimes committed by Holmes.

Saw Mrs. Connor's Body.

Mrs. Pat Quinlan knew of the disappearance of Mrs. Julia L. Conner in Holmes' castle and saw the body of the woman after she was dead. She further knew and has admitted that Pearl Conner disappeared in the castle after her return from the Quinlan farm at Lake Michigan. Chief Badenoch took Mrs. Quinlan and her husband to the castle to-day with Inspector Fitzpatrick and Detectives Fitzpatrick and Norton. The object of this trip was more for the purpose of letting Quinlan and his wife meet than any other. They were closeted together alone for an hour in the room in which the Julia Conner carpet lies and the chair belonging to the murdered woman stands. What took place between them no one knows, but Chief Badenoch and the detectives are nearer the solution of the Holmes mystery than they ever were before. They now have positive proof that Mrs. Conner and her daughter Julia or Cora Quinlan were murdered in the building while the mother was in his employ. Mrs. Quinlan has given information within the last three or four days which brings the charge of murder near to Holmes. Quinlan and his wife, while demonstrating to the police that they were at no time guilty of the crime of murder themselves, have made admissions by which the chief could use them on the stand as valuable witnesses against Holmes in proving that Mrs. Conner and a child were made away with by Holmes for the purpose of securing insurance which Mrs. Conner carried on her life.

Chicago, Aug. 6.—I. L. Conner, husband of Mrs. Julia Conner, who is supposed to have been one of the Holmes victims at the Englewood castle, claims that he has discovered considerable that the police know nothing about, and that he is convinced that Holmes murdered his wife and little girl, and that Quinlan was an accessory. He bases his opinion of Quinlan's guilt on the fact that considerable of the furniture that the Quinlans have been using was the former property of Mrs. Conner. Conner says he will insist that the warrants be served at once so that there may be no possibility of Quinlan getting away.

While searching through a collection of rubbish in the dark chamber in the Holmes castle to-day Detectives Fitzpatrick and Norton found, under a pile of dirt, a pair of bloody overalls. They could not determine to whom they belonged, but they will be brought into the central station to see if they fit Quinlan. A more thorough search of all the debris in the castle will be made to-morrow to discover other articles of clothing which Holmes or Quinlan may have hidden.

A letter from A. L. Jones to H. H. Holmes was found yesterday and, on its face, makes it appear that Jones knew more about what was going on in the castle than he has admitted in the past.

Part of a dress or a wrapper belonging to Mrs. Julia Conner has been found and identified. The manner of identification was peculiar. Mrs. Conner was a Miss Smythe of Davenport. She and her sisters were expert dressmakers, and had a peculiar method of finishing up the under side of seams in their dresses. The seam sewing on the gown found has been closely compared with other work of Mrs. Conner, and has been found to be identical. The sleeves of the garment have been badly cut. An effort will be made to prove that it was the gown worn by Mrs. Conner on Christmas day, 1891, when she was last seen alive. It is thought Mrs. Crow and Mrs. Lawrence can identify it as have been worn by her that day.

Chicago, Aug. 7.—Human blood was found to-day in the Holmes castle bespattered from one room to another. Science aided Detectives Fitzpatrick and Norton where other agencies had failed, and uncovered more startling evidence against Holmes and Quinlan than has yet been found in the castle.

There was found in the castle by the detectives and a medical expert a trail of blood leading from the doorway of the dining room of Mrs. Julia L. Conner to the sink in the same room; from there into the dark chamber where she and Pearl slept, and from there to the inside of the door opening into the bathroom where the secret trap door was located, and down to the secret staircase which led to the false elevator shaft and thence into the basement. The blood was human. A clot of blood mixed with human hair was found.

In Pat Quinlan's private rooms were found two trunks of the theatrical type, one being purchased from Meeks in Denver. On both trunks were the initials "M. R. W." These letters had been painted over. The initials are those of Minnie R. Williams. Pat Quinlan stated after his being taken into custody that both of the trunks belonged to him. Detectives Norton and Fitzpatrick have now the truth that both trunks belonged to Minnie Williams. Quinlan will be confronted with this evidence. He will also be faced with books found in his possession and which

Belonged to Minnie Williams.

There are magazines bearing date as late as April, 1894, demonstrating that Minnie Williams was alive at that time. The fact that one of her trunks was bought in Denver is explained by the information secured by Chief Badenoch that after she entered the employ of Holmes and finally left Chicago, she entered the theatrical business in Denver.

Chief Badenoch believes all this evidence to be the most important of any save the partial confession of Mr. and Mrs. Quinlan that has yet been secured. The inference drawn by the officers from the trail of blood which was discovered was that blood being human, came from some person who was killed in the dark chamber, dragged from there to the trap door, thence down the secret stairway to the basement underneath.

See the clipping

Murder, says the Toronto jury

The Toronto coroner’s jury names Holmes as the murderer of Nellie Pitezel. That same day, 19 August, his castle in Chicago burns.

The Coconino Weekly Sun · Flagstaff, Ariz. · and 1 other paper

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Coconino Weekly Sun · 22 August 1895 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A Verdict of Murder Against Holmes. Toronto, Ont., Aug. 19.—The inquest on the body of Nellie, the youngest of the two Pietzel children whom H. H. Holmes is suspected of murdering, was resumed last night, when the jury, after having the evidence tendered at the inquest on Alice, the eldest girl, read to them, returned a verdict of murder against Holmes.

Holmes' Castle Burned. Chicago, Aug. 19.—H. H. Holmes' castle at Sixty-third and Wallace streets, which is said to have been the scene of numerous murders by the owner, was discovered to be on fire at 12:30 o'clock this (Monday) morning. It was believed it would be entirely consumed, and adjacent property was in great danger.

See the clipping

Howard is found

The third child. Under the porch of a vacant cottage Holmes rented in Irvington, outside Indianapolis, detectives find the missing trunk, and in the stove pit, the charred bones and teeth of a boy of eight to ten. Howard’s overcoat turns up at a grocery nearby, where Holmes had left it.

The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D. · and 5 other papers

The Bottineau Courant · 31 August 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BONES ARE FOUND

CONCLUSIVE PROOF THAT HOLMES IS A MURDERER.

See moreSee less

The Charred Remains of Little Howard Pietzal, for Whom Detectives Have Long Been Searching, Are Found in a House In Indianapolis

HOLMES SURELY HIS SLAYER.

It Is Known That Holmes Occupied the House for a Few Days and That the Boy Then Disappeared.

Indianapolis, Aug. 29.—Indianapolis will claim the right to try H. H. Holmes for murder. This claim will be based upon the horrible developments of to-day, which include the finding of the charred remains of nine-year-old Howard Pietzel, and evidence which before any jury in the country would convict Holmes of having murdered him and then partially burned his body in a stove.

Detectives Geyer of Philadelphia, Richards of Indianapolis and Inspector Gary, of the Fidelity Insurance company, have been at work for weeks hunting for traces of the boy's body. He was traced here with Holmes and disappeared. The city was scoured and work began in the suburbs hunting the house rented by Holmes on Oct. 10, 11 or 12 of last year. This morning the detectives went to Irvington, a suburb of the city and the seat of Butler college, and before they had been at work an hour their attention was called by a local real estate dealer to a small vacant cottage in the woods at the edge of town and far removed from any other building. In a few minutes after the officers had entered this cottage they found beneath the side porch the missing trunk which was taken from the side door of the Circle house in this city Oct. 10 by H. H. Holmes and which was thought to have contained the body of the boy.

Great excitement followed and hundreds flocked to the scene as soon as the discovery leaked out. The house was guarded and work began searching for additional evidence. Developments followed and the chain of evidence is damning.

In a barn connected with the house was a large stove of the same pattern as Holmes bought in Cincinnati. He rented the house under the same alias. The stove had been moved from the house to the stable by the owner of the house after Holmes left. Search for the remains began, for it was concluded that the body had been burned in the stove.

Later Dr. J. F. Bannhill's attention was called by a small boy named Walte Jenny to the stove hole where the stove had been. It was filled with refuse. This was pulled out and the remains of the boy were found. Physicians and dentists were there and in this pile of refuse hundreds of pieces of charred bones were found. The teeth showed that the body was that of a boy between eight and ten years of age, and all the other bones confirmed this. All were charred, and pieces of flesh clung to some of them. The skull bones and pelvis added to the same convincing truth. The body had evidently been burned in a cob fire and in the huge stove found in the barn. Howard's overcoat was found at a grocery store near by where Holmes had left it, saying the boy would call for it. Owners of the house recognize Holmes from pictures, and several neighbors distinctly remember his face. All identify him as the man who last October rented the house with the same story he told in Toronto and other places; came with the boy and the big stove, wash stand and bed, stayed two days and then disappeared. Several persons identified him and all doubt is removed. Other developments are expected to-morrow, and with this evidence Indianapolis will demand Holmes for trial.

See the clipping

The convict’s story: a plan to kill Pitezel

The convict Allen’s statement reaches the papers. In Fort Worth, he says, Holmes and Pat Quinlan talked over putting Pitezel out of the way because he drank too much and knew too much, and a large trunk was bought to hold the body: ‘Mascot, it is $10,000,’ Holmes told him. Allen still insists Minnie Williams was sent off to India; Holmes would later confess to killing her.

The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D.

The Black Hills Union · 6 September 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

STORY OF DARK CRIMES. Convict Allen Tells of His Connection With Holms.

LITTLE ROCK, Ark., Aug. 29.—J. C. Allen, alias Caldwell, the convict serving a ten years' sentence here for horse stealing, has made a statement to Warden Moore in regard to H. H. Holmes and his operations. The warden believes the man knows a great deal more than he has told, but he had the statement put in writing, read to Allen and verified in every particular.

See moreSee less

He first met Holmes under the name of Pratt in Tennessee in the fall of 1892. About three weeks afterward Holmes, Pietzel, Minnie Williams and Allen met in St. Joseph and Minnie's Fort Worth property was deeded to Allen in the name of A. E. Bond. The deal was made with the understanding all around that it was to be swindling operation. After making trips to Leadville and Denver they went to Fort Worth.

"Pietzel's conduct at Fort Worth caused Holmes to send him to Kansas City. While in Kansas City Pietzel wrote several threatening letters to Holmes, in which he said that he would turn up all the rascality unless Holmes sent him money. Pietzel was furnished money three times sent by me at Holmes' request. Holmes visited Pietzel at Kansas City to get him to sign the necessary papers to secure a loan of $16,000 on the Fort Worth property. While Pietzel was in Kansas City, Holmes and Pat Quinlan, who had joined us at Fort Worth a short time before we left that place, had several talks about putting Pietzel out of the way, because Holmes had become afraid of him on account of his drinking too much and knowing too much. (It was known to us all that Pietzel carried a $10,000 life insurance policy). At our last talk upon this subject, three days before leaving Fort Worth, it was understood that Pietzel was to be killed. I was selected to assist Holmes in doing the job, but in what manner it was to be done was not definitely settled, only that Holmes remarked that he had something that would make the job easy, and a large trunk was purchased in Fort Worth in which to place Pietzel's body after being killed. At this point Holmes patted me on the back and said: 'Mascot, it is $10,000 and a trip to Long Branch, and from there to California and more buildings. That night I advised Holmes to quit the business, as he had enough money not to resort to murder. He replied that he had been at the business so long that it had become perfectly natural to him, and he would not quit it.

"The plan agreed upon to dispose of Pietzel was that we were to meet him in St. Louis and together go from there to Chicago, where he was to be 'fixed.' It was between Fort Worth and Denison that Holmes told me that I must have my life insured for $10,000 in favor of my little niece. Remembering the large trunk bought for Pietzel's body, I determined to part company with Holmes, which I did at Denison, and I have never seen him since, but received as many as three letters from him.

"The last time I saw Minnie Williams was at our meeting in St. Joseph. Holmes told her that she must leave the United States for a period of three or four years. India was agreed upon as the country to which she should go. I went to the depot with her, while Holmes bought her ticket and checked her baggage, but where to I did not know. While at Fort Worth I read three letters from Minnie Williams to Holmes. They purported to be from India, the place I have forgotten. If Minnie Williams is dead she has been put out of the way since this excitement was gotten up in regard to Holmes.

"The building in Chicago known as the 'Castle' was erected especially for a 'death trap,' and during my association with Holmes I was in it often, and in fact occupied a room there. A stranger to the city during the world's fair was decoyed into the castle and murdered for his money. He did not have as much money as Holmes thought—only $3,700. A bright little boy was enticed into the castle during the fair and held in a room for five days for a reward for his recovery. No reward being offered they were afraid to turn him out and the gas was turned into his room at night and he was suffocated. I could mention other such cases of crime committed in the 'castle' and discussed in my presence, but these are sufficient except one, and that was of Nannie Williams. The cause of her killing, as explained by Holmes, was that one of the girls must be put out of the way and that he could manage Minnie easier than he could Nannie. Minnie Williams was crazy in love with Holmes and she was jealous of her sister, as Holmes was paying her some attention too. He took particular pains to increase her jealousy to work her up to the point of putting Nannie out of the way."

Allen concluded by saying that every word in his statement was true and that he did not make it to secure a pardon; that he knew Governor Clarke too well to believe that he would issue a pardon unless the evidence would break Holmes' neck.

See the clipping

Charged with murder at last

Ten months after his arrest, a Philadelphia grand jury indicts Holmes for the murder of Benjamin Pitezel. Of all the deaths now laid at his door, this is the one he will be tried and hanged for.

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M. · and 3 other papers

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 12 September 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MURDERER AND SWINDLER.

The Notorious H. H. Holmes Indicted in Philadelphia for Murder.

See moreSee less

Philadelphia, Sept. 12.—H. H. Holmes, the notorious murderer and swindler, was to-day indicted by the grand jury for the murder of B. F. Pietzel, whose mysterious death in this city, and the subsequent collection of $10,000 insurance on his life for Holmes, led to the unveiling of the latter's remarkable criminal record.

See the clipping

The Quinlans sue the police

Held by the Chicago police for nearly a month, Pat Quinlan and his wife sue the chief of police and an inspector for $20,000 apiece. The janitor who had been August’s chief suspect is never charged in these papers.

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · and 4 other papers

St. Paul Daily Globe · 17 September 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

QUINLANS GO TO LAW. Alleged Pals of Holmes Suing Now for Damages.

CHICAGO, Sept. 16.—An echo of the recent investigation by the police in this city for evidence against H. H. Holmes was heard today, when papers in two suits, each for $20,000 damages, were filed against Chief of Police Badenoch and Inspector Fitzpatrick. The complainants are Patrick Quinlan and his wife, who for nearly a month were held by the police on suspicion of having guilty knowledge of the manner in which some of the many alleged victims of Holmes disappeared.

See the clipping

Holmes pleads not guilty

Arraigned in Philadelphia under his real name, Herman W. Mudgett, Holmes pleads not guilty, and the trial is set for 28 October. Four months earlier he had pleaded guilty to the fraud. To murder, he says no.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 10 other papers

Evening Star · 23 September 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Holmes to Be Tried October 28. PHILADELPHIA, September 23.—Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was arraigned before Judge Finletter in the court of oyer and terminer today on the indictment charging him with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezell, on September 2, 1894. Upon the advice of his counsel, the prisoner pleaded not guilty. District Attorney Graham asked that Monday, October 28, be fixed for the trial of the case, which was done.

See the clipping

The key that fit

Detective Geyer turns up in Irvington with a key taken from Holmes’s pocket at his arrest, and it opens the front door of the cottage where Howard was killed. The doctor who lived there before recognizes it as his own old key. Geyer will bring the witnesses, and the boy’s remains, to Philadelphia for the trial.

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif. · and 4 other papers

The San Francisco Call · 12 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

EVIDENCE AGAINST HOLMES. He Carried a Key to the Cottage Where Pitzel Was Murdered. INDIANAPOLIS, Ind., Oct. 11.—Interest in the H. H. Holmes case was revived here to-day by the reappearance of Detective Geyer of Philadelphia. He turned up unexpectedly in Irvington this afternoon. Going to the house where Howard Pitzel was murdered and his body burned Geyer fitted a key from his pocket in the front door night latch. It worked perfectly. The key had been found on the person of Holmes after his arrest in Philadelphia. Dr. Thompson, who lived in the house before Holmes occupied it, recognized the key as the one he had himself carried for two years.

See moreSee less

The detectives regard to-day's discovery as final in identifying Holmes as the man who moved into the house with Howard Pitzel. Geyer has arranged to take Dr. Thompson, Dr. Byram and other witnesses from Irvington to Philadelphia on October 26. He will take with him the remains of the Pitzel boy.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: The Children