As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

Waiting for the Rope

December 1895 – April 1896

Sentenced to hang, Holmes spent his last five months appealing, praying, and finally writing a confession to 27 murders that the papers printed and then picked apart.

Sentenced to hang: ‘I have nothing to say’

On 30 November Judge Arnold refuses a new trial and rules that Holmes’s ‘marriage’ to the witness Miss Yoke was void, because he also had a wife in New Hampshire, so her evidence was admissible. Asked if he has anything to say, Holmes answers, barely audibly, ‘I have nothing to say.’ He is sentenced to hang.

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 1 December 1895 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SENTENCED TO DEATH.

Holmes Refused a New Trial by Judge Arnold Yesterday.

See moreSee less

PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Nov. 30.—Judge Arnold to-day refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of murder of B. F. Pietzel, in this city September 2, 1894, and sentenced him to death. Promptly at 10 o'clock Holmes, accompanied by his counsel, came into court. He looked careworn, but seemed to have that air of confidence which has clung to him throughout the trying ordeal. Court opened with a brief tilt between Judge Arnold and Lawyer Rotan. counsel for the defendant. Judge Arnold charged that Mr. Rotan had offered an insult to the court by submitting briefs to the president judge.

Judge Wilson said Holmes' counsel had argued for a new trial, but neglected to send him a copy. Mr. Rotan said that the papers had been prepared hurriedly and if the judge had been overlooked it was a mistake. He said: "I do not want permission to go forth if I have done wrong. There was no disrespect intended when I sent the briefs to Judges Thayer and Wilson and as a member of this bar you should have more confidence in me" Judge Arnold made no further comment, but proceeded with reading the answer to Holmes' counsel.

The main reasons for a new trial, which were put forth by the defendant's counsel, were the admission of the testimony of Miss Yoke, whom Holmes claimed as his lawful wife; the district attorney's opening speech to the jury when he brought the murder of the children into the case, and Mrs. Pietzel's testimony, in which she said the last time she saw her children was in the morgue at Toronto.

In reference to Miss Yoke's eligibility as a witness the judge said that as Holmes was not only married to the Willimeet, Ills., woman, Miss Yoke, but he also had a wife in Gilman, N. H., therefore the marriage to Miss Yoke was null and void and the evidence was admissible. He closed by saying that the court approves the verdict and refuses a new trial. District Attorney Graham asked that sentence be pronounced.

Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said: "Herman W. Mudgetts, have you anything to say?" Holmes replied, in a barely audible voice: "I have nothing to say."

Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence, as follows: "It is the sentence of this court that you be taken hence from whence you came, and there be hanged by the neck until you are dead. May God have mercy on your soul."

The expression of Holmes' face remained the same. He was taken from the court to prison. Governor Hastings will fix the day of Holmes' execution. An appeal to the supreme court will be taken at once.

See the clipping

One line in the year’s news

By New Year’s Eve the case is one line in a digest of 1895: ‘Holmes convicted of the murder of Pitezel.’

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · and 5 other papers

Rock Island Argus · 31 December 1895 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

2. Criminal: Holmes convicted of the murder of Pitezel.

See the clipping

A detective says Holmes killed no one

With the appeal pending, a private detective named Robert Corbett claims Pitezel, Minnie Williams and the Conners are all alive, and that Holmes never killed anyone in Chicago. Pitezel, he says, is living within a hundred miles of the city. Three months later Holmes’s own confession would list Minnie Williams among his victims.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 2 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Star · 22 January 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

PITEZEL SAID TO BE ALIVE. Efforts to Secure Evidence for H. H. Holmes.

CHICAGO, January 22.--A local paper says: "If the story told by Robert Corbett, a private detective who has been in this city for a few weeks working on the Holmes case, is true, H. H. Holmes is not guilty of committing a single murder in Chicago.

See moreSee less

"The Pitezel murder case, which is now pending in the supreme court of Pennsylvania, will come up for a hearing within a few days, and the defense is making a determined effort to secure the reversal of the finding of the jury and lower court on technical grounds.

"If these fail, then the information gathered by the defense will be resorted to, and it is believed that they will be able to prove beyond a doubt that his alleged victim, Benjamin Pitezel, is alive and living within one hundred miles of Chicago at the present time.

"Corbett, who has been running down the various stories charging Holmes with murder in Chicago, claims to have evidence showing that H. H. Holmes did not commit a single murder in the city of Chicago, and that Holmes' confession regarding the death of Nannie Williams is substantially correct. The girl was beyond a doubt killed on July 6 at the flat occupied by Holmes and Minnie Williams, at No. 1220 Wrightwood avenue. The body was then taken to the 'Castle' and destroyed by fire. The skull found by the police at the 'Castle' was that of Nannie Williams.

"Corbett also makes the following statements: That Minnie Williams is alive and has been seen on the streets of this city within the past two weeks; that Emeline Cigrand is alive, and is now living in Iowa; that Julia Conners and her daughter Pearl are alive, and at present living in Michigan, and that Holmes will be able to prove a complete alibi in the murder of Howard Pitezel at Indianapolis.

"In concluding his statement, Corbett said: 'Holmes is a peculiar man, and his relations with the various young women are the cause of his present predicament.'"

See the clipping

The appeal is argued

Before Pennsylvania’s supreme court, Holmes’s lawyer argues that the prosecution only decided Pitezel was murdered once the children’s bodies were found, and that the jury should never have heard about them.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Evening Star · 3 February 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HEARING HIS APPEAL

Another Page in the History of the Holmes Case.

See moreSee less

BEFORE THE SUPREME COURT

Argument Regarding the Evidence on the Trial.

REVIEWING THE AFFAIR

PHILADELPHIA, Pa., February 3.—Another page was turned today in the manifold misadventures of H. H. Holmes, murderer. The supreme court of the state listened to a long and tedious argument on the appeal taken by the defense from the verdict of murder in the first degree, rendered last November.

Since that time the lower court refused a motion for a new trial, the sentence of death was passed upon Holmes and arrangements were set on foot to expeditiously remove the extraordinary criminal from the face of creation. Even condemned murderers have rights, however, and Holmes' lawyers fought at every step. Today is next to the last. Should the court affirm the decision of the jury Governor Hastings may be appealed to for executive clemency, and, should he decline to interpose, then Holmes must hang.

For some time prior to the opening of the court at 11 o'clock this morning, a big gathering filled the room. Promptly upon the stroke of the hour the court, clad in its sable gowns, entered. All the judges were present, headed by Chief Justice Sterrett. The others are Justices Williams, Green, McCollum, Mitchell, Dean and Fill.

The commonwealth was represented by District Attorney Graham and Assistant District Attorney Barlow.

Samuel P. Rotan conducted the opening argument for the appeal, and associated with him was R. O. Moon. William A. Shoemaker, originally the senior counsel for Holmes, who became involved in a charge of procuring the production of false testimony in the case, did not appear.

Mr. Rotan began the proceedings. First he recited to the court the details of the charges against Holmes, and the conduct of the recent trial. In support of the appeal it was urged that the verdict was against the law and the evidence. Upon the finding of the bodies of the Pitezel children, counsel declared, the commonwealth had jumped to the conclusion that Holmes had murdered Pitezel, although there was no testimony to support such an accusation. He referred to the unsuccessful applications by counsel for a continuance of the trial, and their withdrawal as a consequence of the court's refusal. They had wanted the case postponed because they suffered from a lack of funds and could not get all their witnesses. Eventually they had been obliged to go to trial practically without a defense.

The most important fact dwelt upon by counsel, however, was the introduction of irrelevant evidence, regarding the other crimes charged against Holmes, and having no connection with the death of B. F. Pitezel, for whose murder Holmes was on trial.

At the very outset, Mr. Rotan declared, this tremendous error had been made by District Attorney Graham, in his opening address to the jury, when, because of their temporary withdrawal, the prisoner was without counsel. In that speech Graham went over all the outside crimes, and even went so far as to intimate that Holmes had seduced little Alice Pitezel in the house of Mrs. Alcorn, 1905 North 11th street, where he afterward had his alleged wife, Miss Yoke, or Mrs. Howard. All this testimony was ruled out by the court when offered.

The next point taken up was the testimony of this Miss Yoke. The defense objected to this on the ground that she was the legal wife of Holmes, and could not, therefore, testify against him. The commonwealth, however, had gained its point by claiming to prove that she was only one of several "wives" and therefore competent to testify.

In conclusion, the lawyer took up the charge of Judge Arnold to the jury, and pointed out in it errors in expressions calculated to influence the jury against the prisoner.

District Attorney Graham replied to Mr. Rotan's argument. He took up the objection to his opening speech to the jury, and said that after the fullest review and consideration, he had been convinced that every particle of the testimony concerning the other crimes should have been admitted. In overruling the motion for a new trial, the court had said that it should have been admitted. They were not separate affairs, argued Mr. Graham, but all were part and parcel of a single crime committed upon a number of victims. No man could take the story in detail without feeling that every act in this marvelous drama was linked together by a single purpose, and to dismember it would be to destroy it.

Mr. Graham next dwelt upon the competency of Miss Yoke's testimony, contending that it had been proved beyond question that she was not Holmes' wife. He then took up every other question involved and argued them at much length. Mr. Moon made the closing address in favor of the appeal.

The entire argument was upon the law questions involved. The court reserved its decision.

See the clipping

The last appeal fails

Pennsylvania’s supreme court upholds the verdict: no substantial error, and the evidence ‘fully sustains’ it. The district attorney says there is nowhere left to appeal. Holmes has already asked the archbishop to send him a priest.

Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · and 2 other papers

The paper set one line twice, ‘District Attorney Graham, who prose-’. It is printed here as the paper printed it.

Birmingham State Herald · 5 March 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES MUST HANG. The Supreme Court Has Affirmed the Verdict of Murder.

Philadelphia, March 4.—The state supreme court this morning affirmed the verdict of murder in the first degree in the case of Herman Mudget, alias H. H. Holmes, found guilty in the court of oyer and terminer of this city for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel.

See moreSee less

The opinion, which was delivered by Justice Williams, overrules all the assignments of error and affirms the judgment of the lower court. It holds that no substantial error was pointed out and that the evidence fully sustains the verdict. Lawyer Samuel P. Rotan of the counsel for Holmes this afternoon conveyed the finding of the court to his client. The recent action of Holmes in requesting Archbishop Ryan of the Roman Catholic church to send a clergyman to him and the subsequent visit to the condemned man of Rev. Dr. P. J. Daily, rector of the Church of the Annunciation, is believed to indicate that Holmes gave up hope of securing a new trial before the decision of the supreme court was made. Now that the highest tribunal in the state has decided that the alleged slayer of Pietzel shall hang, the visits of Father Daily will probably be made regularly.

District Attorney Graham, who prose- District Attorney Graham, who prosecuted Holmes, is authority for the statement that the case cannot be appealed to the supreme court of the United States and the decision of the state supreme court is final.

See the clipping

‘Be careful, Sheriff, or you will bump your head’

The sheriff comes to Holmes’s cell to read the death warrant: he will hang on 7 May. Holmes suggests the window for better light, says he is willing to die, and as the sheriff leaves under the low doorway, warns him to mind his silk hat. The sheriff was the one visibly shaken.

The Norfolk Virginian · Norfolk, Va.

The Norfolk Virginian · 10 March 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES IN FINE HUMOR

You Can Find Me Here Whenev.r You Want Me Said He To The Jail Officials.

See moreSee less

BE CAREFUL YOU WILL BUMP YOU HEAD

The Condemned Man Listens to the Sheriff Read the Warrant Which Sounds the Death Knell of the Multi-Murder-By Far the Coolest Man in the Whole Party.

Philadelphia, Pa., March 9.—The death warrant, which Gov. Hastings signed for the execution of H. H. Holmes on May 7th, was received by Sheriff Clement to-day from Harrisburg. The Sheriff accompanied, by his solicitors, A. S. L. Shiels and Attorney-Grow and Lawyer S. P. Rotan, of counsel for Holmes, went to the county prison at noon, where the warrant was formally read to the condemned man by Sheriff Clement. The latter declined to allow any reporters to accompany the party. The Sheriff announced before going to the prison that the witnesses at the execution would not be in excess of the attendance at less important hangings.

When the Sheriff and his party reached the prison they were met by Deputy Anderson and the party was conducted to Holmes' cell. He had been reading, and when he rose to greet his visitors he tossed the book upon his cot and smiled a welcome. Lawyer Rotan introduced the sheriff and others, and, then without further ado, Sheriff Clement drew the death warrant from his pocket and proceeded to read it. The spot in the cell where the sheriff stood was not adapted to reading owning to a lack of light. Holmes observed the sheriff's dilemma, and remarked in a cheerful tone, "Step over to the window, Mr. Sheriff, you will find more light there."

Throughout the reading Holmes maintained an affable manner. At the conclusion Sheriff Clement, who was visibly affected, turned to the condemned man and, extending his hand, offered his sympathy and implored him to make his peace with God. Holmes thanked the Sheriff and expressed himself as willing to die. There was another round of handshaking and the Sheriff, lawyers and the Deputy, left the cell. As the Sheriff was passing out he omitted to bow his head to clear the upper part of the low entrance to the cell. Holmes observed that the official's silk hat was in danger of collision with the door and he called out: "Be careful, Sheriff, or you will bump your head." This caused a ripple of laughter. As the Sheriff was moving down the corridor, Holmes called after him: "You can, of course, find me here when you want me."

As was expected Holmes proved to be the coolest one of the party. Assistant Superintendent Richardson will probably not remove Holmes from his present cell for a week, but the prisoner will be more closely guarded. It is usual to set the regular death watch about a week previous to the day of execution. When that shall be done the condemned man will be taken to a better lighted cell, after first being submitted to a change of clothing to prevent his having in his possession anything that would permit suicide.

Lawyer Rotan had a long conversation with Holmes after the warrant had been read, the subject of which Mr. Rotan refused to make known.

See the clipping

The detective’s book goes on sale

Before Holmes is even hanged, Detective Geyer’s book about the case is advertised for sale: ‘The Greatest Crime of the Century,’ in which the ‘Arch Criminal planned seven murders and executed four.’

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The Portland Daily Press · 11 March 1896 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

THE HOLMES-PITEZEL CASE—A History of the Greatest Crime of the Century. By the world-famous Detective, Frank P. Geyer. A true Detective Story in which the Arch Criminal planned seven murders and executed four. Published by authority of the District Attorney and Mayor of Philadelphia. Agents make $25.00 a week. Outfit free to Agents for 10 cents to pay cost of mailing. P. W. ZIEGLER & Co., 214 Levant street, Phila.

See the clipping

Holmes’s lawyer is suspended

Shoemaker, the lawyer behind the paid-for suicide affidavit, is suspended from Pennsylvania’s courts for a year.

Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · and 2 other papers

Dakota Farmers' Leader · 3 April 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

HE WAS HOLMES' LAWYER.

For Unprofessional Conduct Shoemaker Temporarily Disbarred.

See moreSee less

William A. Shoemaker, a brilliant young Philadelphia lawyer, who was senior counsel for the notorious Holmes on his trial last fall, has been suspended from the privileges of the Pennsylvania courts for one year. He was found guilty of subornation of perjury in that case and was sentenced Saturday. Shoemaker got a woman to sign a false affidavit to the effect that Pitezel, the man murdered by Holmes, had in her presence expressed an intention to commit suicide.

See the clipping

Holmes confesses

The Philadelphia North American prints Holmes’s confession, nearly three newspaper pages in his own handwriting. It opens, ‘I was born with the very devil in me,’ claims his face is slowly changing to look like Satan’s, and says he took 27 lives. Within days the papers would start checking his list of victims, and finding some of them alive.

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · and 2 other papers

Warning The last part of this clipping is Holmes’s own account of taking a surgical knife to his young son in a barn.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 11 April 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

IN HANDS OF SATAN. Murderer Holmes Gives His Candid Opinion of Himself.

MADE MURDER A LIFE STUDY.

See moreSee less

Unable to Overcome His Passion For Mutilation.

PHILADELPHIA, April 11.—The North American this morning prints what purports to be sentences from the confession alleged to have been made by Murderer H. H. Holmes. Among other things, the story says:

In prefacing the confession, which covers in full nearly three newspaper pages written in Holmes' own handwriting, he opens with the statement, "I was born with the very devil in me." Even now he believes that the evil spirit is the guiding genius of his destiny. He believes that he is fully under the spell of the damned, and despite the assertions to the contrary that he is receiving the attentions of a minister of God and is gradually imbued with the spirit of forgiveness and religion, he feels that he is lost hopelessly.

He even goes further. He asserts that he is gradually changing in appearance in figure; that his face is becoming distorted, and he sees—whether in the distortion of his bloody imagination, which conjures up hosts of vengeance-calling dead, or not—his face assuming the look, the eyes the leer, and the very ears the exact similitude of the picture of satan himself.

H. H. HOLMES.

"Yes, I was born with the devil in me," says he, in one part of his confession. "I could not help the fact that I was a murderer no more than the poet can help the inspiration to song, nor the ambition of an intellectual man to be great. I was born with the evil one standing as my sponsor beside the bed where I was ushered into the world, and he has been with me since.

"The inclination to murder came to me as naturally as the inspiration to do right comes to the majority of persons. Where other hearts were touched with pity, mine filled [with cruelty, and where in] others the feeling was to save life, I reveled in the thought of destroying the same.

"Not only that; I was not satisfied in taking it in the ordinary way. I sought devices strange, fantastical and even grotesque. It pleased my fancy. It gave me play to work my murderous will, and I reveled in it with the enthusiasm of an alchemist who is hot on the trail of the philosopher's stone.

"This inclination," continues Holmes, "came to me early in life. I remember when a mere lad my ambition to study medicine that I might know the relative effects of poisonous gases; that I might fully become acquainted with their uses and learn to be an expert in handling them.

Changed From Human Being.

"I am convinced," he declares, "that since my imprisonment I have changed wofully and grewsomefully from what I formerly was in feature and in figure. If you look at my picture when I was first taken into custody in Boston, nearly two years ago, and look at my face, you will maybe begin to observe something of what I mean.

"I mean, in fact, that my features are assuming nothing more or less than a pronounced satanical cast; that I have become afflicted with that disease, rare but terrible, with which physicians are acquainted, but over which they seem to have no control whatever. The disease is a malformation or distortion of the osseous parts, causing deformity so marked that in many cases men are made to assume likenesses to the inferior animal.

"It began with pains in all the joints, followed by excruciating symptoms, local on the head and bones of the face. These I attributed at first to rheumatic trouble, until I found that they were gradually causing a change to take place in my whole figure, quite in keeping with my character.

"The real nature of the malady then began to dawn, and I recollected having studied once about a man whose features had become deformed by this disease in such a way that he gradually grew to resemble a monkey. The horror of the thing did not pall on me, for it was quite in keeping with my nature, and like a true medical student, I began to study the new conditions that had arisen.

"From what I can see, I believe fully that I am growing to resemble the devil; that osseous parts of my head and face are gradually assuming that elongated shape so pronounced in what is called the degenerate head, and that similitude is almost complete. In fact, so impressed am I with this belief," continues Holmes, "that I am convinced that I have no longer anything human in me."

Holmes' confession from this on speaks of his early experiences of his boyhood days on the farm up in Vermont, and the life he led until he entered college to study medicine in Michigan. It was not until after he was graduated, fully equipped with the knowledge of poisons and the easiest way to sever the simple thread of life, that Holmes began his career as a murderer and mutilator.

When he begun, he admits himself, he was ruthless and never once halted until he took 27 lives. "And I would have committed six other murders," he added, "had not certain occurrences intervened. I had planned them and was several times about to carry them out when something intervened."

Possibly one of the worst, most brutal, revolting and disgusting crimes this archmutilator ever committed, was one he speaks of in a chapter devoted to his boy--

Fost[er's Daily Democrat.]

the son of his first wife, whom he married in New England, while but a youth. The chapter in question, tells a story that is hardly credible, coming as it does from the lips of a father, and outranks for barbarous cruelty any act he ever committed. The only explanation he offers is that he did it simply to gratify his love of mutilation.

"It was shortly after I was married," he declares, "and our boy was then but a youngster and playing about with other lads of his own size and age, that I was seized with a wild desire to destroy. I called him in from the road where he was frollicking about like an innocent with a lot of other lads, and took him out to a rear barn.

"I don't know what it was possessed me, but I took a surgical knife along with me. It was not the sudden impulse nor maddening desire of a father seeing his child about to grow up and enter a world of sorrow and sin that led me to the deed. No; it was not that. It was simply the craving of the murderer within me that inspired me to make a subject of my little one.

"I noticed that there was a terrible look of fear on the little fellow's face as I took him into the barn, and he trembled as I took the knife and told him to undress. I have often though since that it was like the look of the scared rabbit laid on the operating table, as its tearful eyes search the group about it, and see them all intent only on the anticipated incision."

With the utmost abandon and with here and there an expressed sigh of regret, Holmes then tells how he went through the operation of mutilating his own son. He tells how his own flesh and blood was made to submit to the barbarous blade, and there and then was mutilated simply to pacify the cravings of a murderer's heart. Finished with that, Holmes felt satisfied and did not murder his boy outright.

See the clipping

Holes in the confession

Four days later the confession to 27 murders is already falling apart. Four of Holmes’s ‘victims’ have been seen alive and well, and a fifth, a wealthy banker, seems never to have existed.

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis. · and 1 other paper

Watertown Republican · 15 April 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES' "CONFESSION."

Some Big Holes have Been Found in It.

See moreSee less

Four of His Alleged Victims Prove to be Alive and Well.

Chicago, Ill., April 13.—Four of the victims who were slaughtered relentlessly Sunday morning in H. H. Holmes' "confession" have been seen alive and well since the dates on which they were officially murdered. One is in Englewood. One can be reached through the medium of the United States mail or either of two telegraph lines. The third has done business and failed in Chicago since the time at which the self-abhorred criminal asserts that he killed him. The fourth has been seen by those who know her well in the vicinity of the "castle" since Holmes, according to his story, declares that he suffocated her in the vault of his unique building. A fifth, claimed to be a wealthy Chicago banker, never was heard of in this city. The man whom Holmes says can throw light upon the dark places in his unsolicited testimonial to his own evil character is a myth, unheard of by the police of the two cities in which he is supposed to have operated.

Robert Latimer, the ex-janitor, whom his erstwhile employer credits with the feat of tearing out the bricks and mortar of the vault of the castle in his dying agony, may be seen any night after midnight swinging a red lantern at the railroad crossing at Sixty-third and Wallace streets. He is not a spook, for spooks do not figure on the pay roll of the Western Indiana railroad. He is the night flagman at that crossing and has been since midnight of July 3, 1894. His term of service for Holmes closed just before the third story was added to the castle. Ever since his old employer was arrested Latimer has protested that Holmes was innocent of all the murders charged up to him, and, further, that he did not believe that Holmes ever even swindled anybody. He still asserts the same, in spite of the evidence and Holmes' accredited confession. Latimer married in Englewood since he left Holmes. He has no children.

The other "victim," whose whereabouts are positively unknown, is Dr. Thomas Russell, to whom Holmes accords the distinction of first place in his chef-d'oeuvre of yesterday. Holmes asserts that he felled the doctor with a chair in a quarrel which arose over the latter's nonpayment of rent. This story was exploited last fall by some of the daily papers, and at that time Dr. Russell, who is at the head of a hospital at Grand Rapids, Minn., wrote a letter which was published, informing the public that he was the man referred to, and that the story was a canard. The doctor is a Canadian by birth and is a graduate of the University of Toronto. He had an office in Holmes' building in the spring of 1891.

The "Confession."

Philadelphia, Pa., April 11.—H. H. Holmes, who will be executed here May 7 for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, has made a confession of his crimes. He claims to have committed twenty-seven murders. He asserts that he would have committed six more but for intervening circumstances which stayed his hand.

Some of these persons were asphyxiated, others poisoned. Subsequently they were dissected by Holmes, their skeletons incinerated so far as possible and the remains buried in the basement of the "castle."

In addition to these he murdered in Toronto Annie and Nellie Pietzel, children of Benjamin Pietzel, and in Indianapolis Howard Pietzel. In this city he killed Pietzel himself. He had made arrangements for the killing of Mrs. Pietzel and her eldest daughter, Dessie, but his arrest for the murder here prevented him. It is believed that he had also planned for the killing of Patrick Quinlan and his wife, employes of his in Chicago; May Yoke, his last wife, and the Mrs. Holmes, his second wife, now living at Wilmette, Ill. These comprise the six contemplated murders to which he makes gruesome reference.

Holmes writes with the spirit of a fiend incarnate. He revels in the analysis of his own nature, his lust for human blood, the ever-present desire to kill. No modern "Jack the Ripper" approaches him in fiendishness.

"I am convinced," he writes, "that I no longer have anything human in me."

See the clipping

A week left: the governor says no

A week from the gallows, Holmes petitions the governor for a delay. He wants time to recover $40,000 in property for his heirs, and to prove he caused only two deaths, both from illegal operations, not the 27 he had confessed to that month. Mrs. Pitezel’s father writes to oppose any delay, and the governor refuses.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 3 other papers

Evening Journal · 30 April 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

DENIED A RESPITE. Holmes Must Suffer the Death Penalty on May 7.

HARRISBURG, April 30.—Governor Hastings has refused to grant a respite in the case of H. H. Holmes, who is to be hanged in Philadelphia on May 7 for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel.

See moreSee less

In behalf of Holmes a petition was sent to the governor, setting out various reasons why he should not be hanged on that date. The petition declares that he has $40,000 worth of property, of most of which he is being cheated, and that he wants time to recover it so that he may bequeath it to his heirs. He desires to produce evidence showing beyond the possibility of a doubt that he is guilty of the death of but two persons, their deaths being the result of criminal operations performed by him as a medical practitioner.

Governor Hastings was in receipt of a communication from R. Ganning of Galva, Ills., father of Mrs. Pitezel, protesting against the granting of a respite.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: The Trial