As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

The Gallows

7–13 May 1896

Holmes was hanged in Philadelphia’s county prison on the morning of 7 May 1896. Even then, the papers could not agree on what he had done.

Hanged at 10:12

Holmes was hanged at 10:12 that morning, and the Jersey City News had it the same day. The crowd the prison expected never came, since there was nothing to see outside the walls. The paper adds that a letter from his six-year-old daughter, the week before, had made him burst into tears.

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

The Jersey City News · 7 May 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES' DOOMSDAY

The Arch-Murderer Dies on the Scaffold in Philadelphia.

See moreSee less

WITH A FALSEHOOD ON HIS LIPS

Denial of All Responsibility for the Death of the Pitezel.

COOL AND BRAVE TO THE LAST

No Sensational Episodes in the Execution—Post-Mortem Mysteries.

PHILADELPHIA, May 7, 1896.—Holmes was hanged at 10:12 o'clock this forenoon.

There were but comparatively few persons gathered on the outside of the County Prison during the early part of the morning, and the morbid throng which the prison officials expected would be drawn there because of the execution of Holmes was lacking. The fact that Holmes would be hanged within the prison walls made the sightseers' mission fruitless, but the celebrity of the case, it was believed, would attract a large crowd. Access to the prison, prior to the entrance of those permitted to witness the execution, was not allowed and nothing could be learned about Holmes' condition or how he passed the night.

The persons holding tickets of admission to the jail began to assemble as early as 8:30 o'clock, and at 9 o'clock they passed within the iron gates.

Lawyer Samuel P. Rotan, who defended Holmes, was asked late last night if there was a possibility of Holmes committing suicide. Mr. Rotan said decidedly:—"Not a bit. I am positive he would not kill himself if he had the means to do it. He has declared so to me at least a dozen times, and I believe he means what he says."

One of the reasons given Mr. Rotan by Holmes for not wanting to die by his own hand is the position in which such an act would necessarily place the prison authorities.

"It would get them into trouble," Mr. Rotan says Holmes declared, "and probably cause them to be charged with a neglect which might result in the loss of their positions."

Mr. Rotan declined to say whether or not Holmes intended to make any restitution to Mrs. Pitezel or provision for any of the three women to whom he was married. Pressed upon this point, the lawyer evaded any reply for a time and finally said that he was not in a position to make public what the condemned man had directed him to do in this connection.

If anyone gets anything from Holmes' estate it will probably be Miss Ida J. Belknap, who was the second woman the murderer married. She is living at Wilmetta, Ill., a suburb of Chicago, and has with her the six-year-old daughter, of whom Holmes is the father. This little girl last week wrote the condemned man a brief letter couched in such childishly pathetic terms that the man who is accused of having killed a dozen people or more burst into tears when he read it.

Although in erecting the gallows only bolts and screws are used and little or no noise is made, Holmes' acute ears made him aware of what was being done soon after the work started yesterday, and the knowledge made him nervous and uneasy, although he tried to conceal it. Only to the Rev. Father Dailey, his spiritual adviser, and Mr. Rotan did he speak of the scaffold, and to them he said but a word or two.

All the arrangements for the burial of Holmes have been intrusted by the murderer to Mr. Rotan. The place of interment has, it is understood, already been selected, but those who are most likely to know where the grave is to be will not divulge the location. Up to a late hour it was said that the undertaker had not been decided upon.

Whoever may finally have charge of the burial, if it should take place at once, will have to file some time today after the execution a "return of a death" with the Board of Health. This must give the name of the deceased, his color, sex, age, married or single, date of death, cause of death, occupation, place of birth and date of burial.

Mrs. Pitezel has decided to remain in Philadelphia until she is certain either that she can secure some of the money of which Holmes defrauded her or that all hope of obtaining restitution is lost. There is an obscure chance that the murderer may have made a will and the wronged woman hopes in that event to obtain at least part of that to which she is entitled. Thomas Fahy, Mrs. Pitezel's lawyer, has little hope that Holmes will make voluntary restitution to his client. He says that in his opinion it will be necessary for him to attach the murderer's money if he wants any of it.

Arthur McDonald, the United States Government criminologist, arrived here last night from Washington to attend the execution.

Mr. McDonald has paid several visits to the condemned man since his incarceration, and has made a careful study of the criminal. The criminologist believes that crime is due more to conditions than heredity. He is of the opinion that Holmes was, in many of his crimes, a victim of circumstances.

While the exact time of the execution was as usual unannounced, it was generally supposed that the hour would be about ten o'clock. Two hours before that time, however, those who were to attend began arriving, but admission to the prison was denied every one except to those officials in direct touch with the institution until nine o'clock. The gates were then opened and the four score or more having tickets pressed into the inner court. Sheriff Clements had preceded the crowd and was awaiting the arrival of those comprising his jury that they might be sworn. The jury comprised six physicians and a like number from other walks in life, all prominent in their respective stations. They were ex-Sheriff Wm. H. Wright, Dr. Benjamin Pennebacker, John J. Ridgway, Councilman R. B. Bringhurst, Samuel L. Wood, Dr. W. Joseph Hearn, Dr. W. J. Roe, A. B. Detwiller, Dr. M. B. Dwight, Dr. J. C. Guernsey, James Hand and Dr John L. Phillips. In response to the calling of their names they arranged about the desk behind which stood Sheriff Clements and then solemnly swore "to witness the execution of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, and certify the time and manner of such execution according to law."

Mr. Wood, one of the Sheriff's jury, was also a member of the jury that convicted Holmes.

Many prominent men were in attendance, several from other cities. Notable among them were Dr. McDonald of Washington, the famous criminologist; Sheriff S. R. Mason of Baltimore, Professors W. Easterly Ashton and Earnest Laplace of the Medico-Chirurgical College; Dr. John S. Miller of St. Joseph's Hospital; Detective Frank Geyer, who conducted the case; President Fous and Solicitor Campbell, of the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance Company; Dr. J. Howard Taylor, representing the medical staff; Captain of Detectives Miller, and Lawyer Rotan, who conducted the defence of Holmes during the trial.

Mr. Rotan was early at the prison, but had been preceded by the Rev. Father Daily and Father McPake, who administered the last rites of the church to the condemned man. They arrived shortly after six o'clock and only a few minutes after Holmes had arisen. Last evening they remained with him until half-past ten o'clock. The death watch was then being kept by Keeper George Weaver, who remained until relieved at seven o'clock this morning by Keeper Henry. Weaver said this morning that Holmes had retired about midnight and slept soundly during the entire time until called at six o'clock. So sound were his slumbers in fact that twice was he called before awakening when the arrival of the Rev. Fathers Daily and McPake was announced. He greeted them warmly, but with no show of undue emotion, and with the same air of self-possession that has marked his conduct throughout the entire case. They were come to administer the sacrament of communion and every possible facility for privacy was extended by Superintendent Perkins of the prison. For nearly two hours they remained in the cell within and then were almost immediately succeeded by Lawyer Rotan, the legal adviser of Holmes. Pleasantly also he greeted him. There were several matters pertaining to his worldly affairs that will have to be settled up after his death, and this time was taken for giving the final details and explanations.

While discussing his affairs breakfast was served, and he seemed to heartily enjoy the meal. It was substantial but plain, consisting of eggs, toast and coffee, which were taken with an evident relish. "He enjoyed it more than I could, even though only his attorney," remarked Mr. Rotan, after leaving the cell. "He is the most and cool and possessed of all in any way connected with the case."

The remark seemed in no wise exaggerated. Every story was to the same effect, and to the end he maintained the same stoicism. It was not the blustering braggadocio of the foul-mouthed bully or desperado who curses the hand that offers spiritual solace, but the calm demeanor and quiet bearing that are compelled by a will of iron.

When the morning meal was ended and shortly before nine o'clock Holmes prepared to dress himself. Contrary to the general custom he refused to don a new suit, but arrayed himself in trousers, vest and cutaway coat of some dark mixed goods, of a pepper and salt effect, that had been worn by him frequently before. Even in this he was careful, giving every attention to even the most minute details of his toilet.

Collar and necktie were, of course, not worn, but their place was taken by a white handkerchief knotted carelessly about the neck.

The time had been slowly dragging along as the many details and incidents were being enacted. Ten o'clock had just sounded when a call came from the cell corridor for Sheriff Clements. He had been gone but a moment when the doors leading through the long corridor in which were placed the gallows were opened, and two by two, led by the Sheriff's jury, the party passed down. The cell of Holmes was to the left of the corridor, and the tramp of the many feet must have been plainly audible to him, as he sat behind the closed and covered door. The gallows was about half way down the corridor, and to either side was a high partition, that once through the doors shut off any view of the approach of the condemned man as he came to the scaffold. Affairs were quickly approaching a crisis, and the other incidents of the execution seemed to take shape and pass away with lightning-like rapidity. The last man of those attending had just passed through the doors and the latter closed when from beyond was heard the slow and measured tread of the little coterie comprising the death party. The greatest stillness prevailed among the group watching with up-turned faces for the first glimpse of the condemned. From the other side could be heard the approaching party, their muffled tread like a solemn accompaniment to queries of the priests and the low-toned responses of Holmes. The suspense was almost painful, brief though it was, and then preceded by Sheriff Clements and Superintendent Perkins, Holmes stepped onto the trap. On the right was Father Daily, to the left Father McPake, and bringing up the rear were Lawyer Rotan and Assistant Superintendent Richardson. The little party stood for a moment looking down, and then in response to a sign from one of those beside him, Holmes stepped forward and spoke. Pallid, naturally, after his incarceration, there was no other evidence of any fear or disquiet. He spoke slowly and with measured attention to every word—a trifle low at first, but louder as he proceeded until every word was distinctly audible.

"Gentlemen," he said, "I have very few words to say; in fact, I would make no statement at this time except that by not speaking I would appear to acquiesce in life in my execution. I only want to say that the extent of my wrong doings in taking human life consisted in the death of two women, they having died at my hand as the result of criminal operation. I wish to also state, however, so that there will be no misunderstandings hereafter, I am not guilty of taking the lives of any of the Pitezel family, the three children or father, Benjamin F. Pitezel, of whose death I am now convicted and for which I am today to be hanged.

"That is all."

As he ceased speaking he stepped back and kneeling between Fathers Daily and McPake, joined with them in silent prayer for a brief minute or two. Again standing, he shook the hand of all of those about him, and then signified his readiness for the end.

Coolest of the entire party, he even went to the extreme of suggesting to the assistant superintendent, Richardson, that the latter need not hurry himself. "Take your time; don't bungle it," he remarked as the official exhibited some little haste, the evident outcome of nervousness. These were almost his last words. The cap was adjusted, a low-toned query, "Are you ready?" and an equally low-toned response, "Yes, good bye," and the trap was sprung.

The neck was not broken and there were a few convulsive twitches of the limbs that continued for about ten minutes.

"But he suffered none after the drop." said Dr. Scott, the prison physician. The trap was sprung at precisely 10:12½ and fifteen minutes later Holmes was pronounced dead, though the body was not cut down until 10:45.

When it was laid out on the stretcher occurred the only incident approaching the revolting in connection with an affair naturally gruesome. The knot had become jammed and the best efforts of the doctors failed to loosen it as they attempted to remove the noose from about the neck. The head was twisted about from side to side in the unavailing attempt and finally it was decided to cut the rope. Superintendent Perkins objected, however, and the knot was undone after several minutes of trying work.

The remains were given into the charge of Lawyer Rotan at the request of Holmes, and he turned it over to an undertaker. At three P. M. it was placed in a vault in Holy Cross Cemetery. There were no services.

The two women referred to by Holmes in his confession from the scaffold were Julia Connor, of Chicago, who with her daughter were believed to have been murdered by him, and Emily Cygrand of Anderson, Ind.

See the clipping

The papers’ verdict: ‘an atrocious liar’

The day after the hanging, a Kansas paper runs the whole case in one long article: the forgery arrest in Terre Haute, the Callowhill Street body that police first took for an accident while a man lit his pipe, the capture, the trial, and at least eight other victims. It calls Holmes ‘an atrocious liar’, because several of the people he confessed to killing had since denied it ‘with their own lips.’ It ends: ‘the true story of his strange career will probably never be known.’

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 8 May 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

GIVES ONE FOR MANY

HOLMES YIELDS UP HIS LIFE AT THE HANGMAN'S HANDS.

See moreSee less

NERVY TO THE LAST

DENIES HIS "CONFESSION" ALMOST AS HIS LAST ACT.

DIES WITH SCARCELY A TREMOR

EXECUTION AS NEAT A JOB AS HOLMES HIMSELF EVER DID.

Sketch of the Life and Criminal Career of America's Most Scientific Exterminator, Which Ends in Mysteries.

Philadelphia, May 7.—H. H. Holmes was hanged in Moyamensing prison this morning. The drop fell at 10:12:30 o'clock. It was not until half an hour that he was pronounced dead. His neck was broken by the fall. The marvelous nerve of the man never deserted him to the very end. Even on the scaffold he was probably the coolest person in the solmen assemblage. In a few well chosen words he proclaimed his innocence of any murder, including that for which he was convicted and hanged. He declared the only wrong doing in taking human life for which he could be held responsible consisted in the death of two women who had died as the result of criminal operations at his hands. He did not name these victims.

Holmes spent the greater part of his last night on earth writing letters. At midnight he went to bed and slept soundly until 6 o'clock, this morning. He received a visit from his spiritual advisers, Fathers Daly and MacPeak, who administered the last sacrament. Later he ate a breakfast of eggs, dry toast and coffee. At 10:02 o'clock the sheriff called together the official jury and the march to the gallows began. The doloruos chant of two priests accompanying the condemned man to the scaffold could be heard. At 10:08 they mounted the platform. A moment for prayer elapsed then Holmes stepped to the front of the scaffold and made a statement of his innocence. It was received in absolute silence. In two minutes, at a silent signal from the priests, he bent to his knees, his eyes fixed on the crucifix clasped in his hands. Until 10:12 prayer continued. Immediately afterwards he arose shook hands with the priests and lawyers, and in a firm voice bade them good bye. His hands were tied, the black cap adjusted and the noose was placed about his neck. Then after an instant of terrible stillness, the crack of the bolt rang out like a pistol shot and the murderer had fallen to his doom. Consciousness left him instantly although his heart beat feebly for fifteen or twenty minutes.

HOLMES' CAREER.

The murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, for which Herman Mudgett, alias H H. Holmes, was hanged today, occurred on Sunday, September 23, 1894. The crime was the culmination of a conspiracy between the men to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life association, of this city, of $10,000, and the swindle was successfully accomplished.

Holmes and Pitezel became acquainted in Chicago in 1890. Pitezel was married and had six children. He was poor, and was not averse to engaging in dishonest business if it were lucrative.

Holmes had been practicing forgery, and he induced Pitezel to enter the sam "line" In January, 1893, Pitezel was arrested in Terre Haute, Ind., for pasisng forged paper. Holmes went there and gave $1,800 straw bond for Pitezel, who thereupon ran away. Holmes sent him to Fort Worth, Texas, under the name of Benton T. Lyman. He had with him a deed to property valued there at $40,000, which belonged to Minnie R. Williams, another of Holmes' victims. Holmes and a woman he called his wife subsequently joined him there, and, giving out that they intended to build the finest building the in town, the men succeeded in borrowing something like $50,000. Then they fled, stealing two carloads of horses as they went, and shipping them to St. Louis.

PITEZEL'S LIFE INSURED.

It was after this incident that Holmes conceived the idea of having Pitezel's life insured. He told Pitezel how easy it was to beat an insurance company with a substitute body, and Pitizel fell into the scheme. A $5,000 policy was secured in the Washington Life Insurance company of New York, but for some reason or other it was permitted to lapse. Then the Fidelity policy was taken out. The application was made at the Chicago agency. Pitezel was in full health, and the risk was considered first rate. They left Chicago together to search for a body. Meanwhile Pitizel told his wife, who was living in St. Louis, that he and Holmes were playing a game on an insurance company, and to his eldest daughter, Dessa, said: "If you ever hear that your papa is dead, don't worry, and don't let your mother worry. I will be all right, and come to you some day, no matter what they say."

PITIZEL FOUND DEAD.

In August, 1894, Holmes and Pitezel came east, and Holmes rented the house 1316 Callowhill street, a ramshackled old building, for Pitezel to start in the patent rights business under the name of B. F. Perry. In the meantime Holmes had brought a woman whom he called his wife to a boarding house at 1905 north Eleventh street. Throughout August Holmes called on Pitezel frequently. Pitezel was seen up to 10 o'clock on Saturday night, September 1. That night he drank a great deal before he went to bed. Nothing was again seen of him until the following Monday when Eugene Smith, a carpenter, who had been employed to do some work in the house, found his body lying on its back room. The face was blackened back on the floor of the second-story and blistered, as if from burns, and near by lay a broken bottle which had contained benzine. By the side of the body was a pipe, partly filled with tobacco. Appearances indicated that an explosion had occurred while the man was lighting his pipe. The police believed the affair was an accident, and no one for a moment entertained the theory of murder.

Among the effects found in the room were several letters from "Perrys wife" in St. Louis, the signatures to which had been torn off. The coroner's physicians held an autopsy, and, finding evidences of chloroform and congested lungs, the jury gave a verdict of death from inhaling the fumes of chloroform.

JEPTHA HOWE APPEARS.

About three weeks after this occurrence, Jeptha D. Howe, a St. Louis attorney, after correspondence with Coroner Ashbridge, of this city, came here and asserted that the body was that of Benjamin Pitezel, and that he—Howe—was here to collect $10,000 insurance from the Fidelity company, for which amount a policy had been made out in favor of Mrs. Pitezel in Chicago a year before. Meanwhile Holmes who had introduced Pitezel to the insurance agents, was induced by them to come to Philadelphia and identify the body. This he did positively, and so did Alice Pitezel, the 16-year old daughter of the dead man. With this unequivocal testimony, the insurance company paid the money. Here the first stage of this extraordinary affair came to a close.

The second opened some time afterwards, when Marion C. Hedspeth, the notorious train robber, in jail at St. Louis, declared that Holmes, while in an adjoining cell, had told him of a conspiracy with Pitezel and Howe to swindle a Philadelphia insurance company by the substitution of a body.

HOLMES' CAPTURE.

Holmes' capture was a wonderful piece of detective work. It was discovered that letters were being sent to him under the name of Howard, and in care of a broker named Blackman, in Dearborn street Chicago, Blackman forwarded the letters to Gilmanton, New Hampshire, Holmes' birthplace, where has first wife and his mother and father were living. A detective started from Chicago on the train bearing one of these letters and there was a race across the country with the United States mail.

The detective beat the mail to the New Hampshire town, and found that the postmaster had a postal card instructing him to forward all mail for Holmes to another place. The detective waited for the letter to arrive, saw it addressed, and continued the chase, beating the letter to the next town. Thus Holmes was tracked from point to point and was finally arrested in Boston, while dropping a letter into a mailbox at astre etcorner.

From the moment of his arrest, Holme has been telilng stories — ingenious, though conflicting. First he declared that the body found was not that of Pitezel, but a substitute, and that Pitezel was in South America. Then he retracted this statement and averred that the body was Pitezel's, and that he had committed suicide, while despondent, and that he (Holmes) in order to secure the insurance money, had given the case the appearance of an accident.

HOLMES ON TRIAL.

Holmes was placed on trial in this city for Pitezel's murder on Monday, Oct. 28 last. The trial ended the following Saturday night in a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree. The jury was out two hours and a half—"for the sake of appearances." They had agreed upon their verdict in one minute's time. The trial was one of the most sensational known to this or any other city. After futile entreaties for a postponement by Holmes' lawyers, William A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, on the ground that they were unprepared to proceed, Judge Arnold decided that the case would have to go on without delay. Then Holmes discharged his attorneys and undertook the conduct of his own defense—which was the suicide story. He displayed much skill and shrewdness in questioning witnesses but the machinery of the commonwealth, whose case was managed by District Attorney George S. Graham, eventually overwhelmed him, and he was obliged to re-engage counsel.

The one witness whose testimony did more to convict Holmes than that of all the others was Geofgiana Yoke, otherwise Mrs. Howard, the woman who thought herself Holmes' wife. Upon her first appearance as a witness against him, Holmes broke down and wept in the dock, but he soon recovered his marvellous nerve and personally cross-examined her. She was living with him at the Eleventh street boardinghouse on the day of the murder, and told how he had left the house that morning, returning about five hours later, flushed and excited, and taking a train for Indianapolis with her that night.

EIGHT OTHER VICTIMS.

This is the story of the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, but with it is interwoven the schemes and acts which brought about the killing of at least eight other victims. These were Alice and Nellie Pitezel, the little daughters of Benjamin, who were asphyxiated in a trunk in Toronto, Canada; Howard Pitezel, the young son, killed in Indianapolis, Holmes cutting up and burning the remains in a stove; Julia L. Conner, divorced wife of I. L. Conner, and a bookkeeper for Holmes; Pearl Conner, her daughter; Emeline G. Cigrande, of Anderson, Ind., stenographer for Holmes; Minnie R. Williams, of Fort Worth, Tex., his private secretary, and Nana Williams, her sister.

The murder of these persons has been fixed upon him almost certainly, but there are at least a dozen other cases which have been laid at his door.

To tell the story of these it is necessary to explain something of the man himself—his personality and his marvelous brain power.

AN ATROCIOUS LIAR.

The execution of Holmes closes one of the most extraordinary narratives in the criminal annals of modern times. The nerve, the calculation and the audacity of the man were unparalleled. Murder was his natural bent. Sometimes he killed from sheer greed of gain; oftener, as he has himself confessed, to gratify an inhuman thrist for blood. Not one of his crimes was the outcome of a sudden burst of fury—"hot blood," as the codes say. All were deliberate; planned and concluded with consummate skill. To him murder was indeed a fine art, and he revelled in the lurid glamour cast upon him by his abnormal genius. Even with the shadow of the noose dangling over his head, he evolved a so-called confession, detailing with horrible calmness how he had exterminated twenty-seven fellow-creatures, coldly setting forth the varied and bloody tortures he employed. One could almost se the fiendish grin on his thin and bloodless lips as, in the gloom of his cell in Moyamensing prison, he set down the terrible tale.

But the man was an atrocious liar, and several of those with whose murder he charged himself have since denied his story with their own lips. The statement was prompted by a perverted ambition to be regarded as the "greatest" monster who ever walked in the form of man, and an incongruous desire to gain for the education of his little son in Gilmanton, New Hampshire, the $5,000 offered for the "confession" by a newspaper.

WOMEN LOVED HIM.

This desire goes far to prove his possession of many conflicting traits. It proves that he knew something of human love, as the trial clearly demonstrated that he held affection for the woman he called his wife—Miss Yoke. It is a well known fact that women were attracted to him, and one not hard to understand when the superficial man is considered, for he was born of reputable parents, reared under the influence of a Christian home, and surrounded in his early years by every refinement. He was born at Gilmanton in 1858, so that he was 38 years old when the end of his spectacular career came. He was of medium build, with an erect and manly bearing. His hands and feet were small, and the skin smooth to the touch; the features were regular, the brown hair not too sparce, and a well-kept moustache shaded his small mouth. "Pretty" he might have been called, for the paleness of his cheek was modified by just a touch of color, and his big blue eyes, before the confining walls of a prison robbed them of their light, were mild and gentle. The voice was soft and low. Besides, he was well-educated. Although, while by no means effeminate, it was easy to consider that he was what is called a "lady's man."

His parents were among the most respected persons in their part of the state. His father had been postmaster for more than twenty-four years. Holmes had two married sisters, living in Boston and one brother. They were younger than he, and had grown up to be good citizens, respected and honored by their neighbors.

NOT A GOOD LITTLE BOY.

Holmes was not a good boy. He was always regarded as the scapegrace of the family. He worked on his father's farm and went to school in the winter. The one thing particularly noticeable about him was that he was a faithful student. When he got to be 20 years old he was still studying, though he had long before left school. Then he got married. His bride was Miss Clara A. Lovering, daughter of a well-to-do citizen of London, N. H. She was 18 years old. He had been courting her a long time. They went away together on the Fourth of July, 1878, and were married in the town of Alton by 'Squire John W. Currier. Holmes had some money at the time, and he was ambitious of studying medicine. His wife encouraged him, and he started in at the college at Burlington, Vt. The next year he went out to Ann Arbor, Mich., to study there. His money was gone. He determined to work his way through the university, and he did. Then his own story is that he began his criminal career. It was as a swindler of insurance companies. He says that a fellow-student in the university, who is now a physician in New York, was his accomplice. The thought came to him when he was in the dissecting room and a body was brought in, "Why couldn't a body like that be substituted for the body of a man whose life was insured?" He decided it could. His fellow-student was of the same opinion, and agreed to get his life insured for $12,000. A year later a body was obtained and successfully palmed off on the insurance company as that of the insured man. The money was divided.

BEATING HIS BOARD.

Whether this was Holmes' first serious crime or not it is impossible to say. Whether it ever happened as he said it did is a question. Certainly at a later period than this he appeared to be without money, and taught school for a living. This was at Mooers Forks, Clinton county, N. Y. He went there as a nursery agent for a firm in Maine, and was engaged as a district school teacher. He represented himself as single, and proposed marriage to two or three women. He boarded with a man named Hayes, ran up a big board bill, and then left in broad daylight, never to return. Holmes had lived with his wife off and on. She had borne him one child, a boy, and she spent nearly all her time with her parents in London. Shortly after the school episode he visited her, and then he left, it seems, for good.

Holmes is supposed to have gone from New Hampshire to St. Paul, where he started in business, earned the respect of his neighbors, and got appointed receiver for a restaurant. He stocked the restaurant with goods on credit, sold them all, and walked away, leaving his bondsmen to settle.

KALEIDOSCOPIC INIQUITY.

He was next heard of in Chicago. Then began his kaleidoscopic career. He began by marrying a Miss Myrtle Z. Belknap, daughter of a resident of Williamette, a suburb of Chicago. He had not been divorced from his first wife. He tried to get possession of her father's property by means of forged deeds. He failed in that, and then his wife left him, keeping with her the girl baby that had been born to them.

His third wife, Georgiana Yoke, he married in Denver under the name of Howard. She lived in Franklin, Ind., and is a woman of refinement and beauty.

The murder of the Peitzel children was probably Holmes' next crime after that of the father. When Holmes was called from St. Louis by the insurance company to identify Pitezel's body in this city he prevailed upon Mrs. Pitezel to allow the child Alice to go with him. Upon their arrival, the body was disinterred from the Potter's field, and Holmes, in the presence of doctors and officials of the company, calmly cut certain marks from the corpse. The identification being complete, the money was paid, and, as Mr. Pitezel swore at the trial, Holmes appropriated all but a few dollars, which he gave to her.

IN THREE SQUADS.

After the departure of Holmes and Alice for Philadelphia, the next time Mrs. Pitezel saw him was September 27. He said he had left Alice in Cincinnati in the care of his "cousin," Minnie Williams. Then he induced her to let him take Nellie and Howard there, so that Alice should not be lonely. She never again saw her children alive. Some time afterwards he took her to Detroit under the pretence that she was to meet her husband there. From that time to the day of his arrest he kept her moving from place to place throughout the country on some pretence or other. During these travels Holmes carried with him three separate detachments—Mrs. Pitezel, Miss Yoke and the children—all within four blocks of each other in all the different cities, almost traveling together, under Holmes' leading strings, and yet each detachment ignorant of the presence of the other two. Eventually he rid himself of the incumberances by murdering the girls in Toronto and the boy in Indianapolis.

NEW STORY OF HOLMES.

A remarkable illustration of the incongruous elements making up the man's character is offered right here, and it is a story that has never before been told in print. In some western city he registered at a hotel with Miss Yoke—or Miss Howard—his third wife, but she saw little of him, for he divided his time between her, the children at another hotel and Mrs. Pitezel at a third. His wife undoubtedly loved him, and chided him for neglecting her, of course ignorant of how his time was occupied. It was not Holmes' purpose, however, to spend any night at the hotel where she was, but, to quiet her remonstrances, he promised to be more devoted, and employed a plan which shows that he had in his make-up some grain of sentiment—perhaps of poetry. He told her he was very busy with important affairs, and that there were circumstances which would make it unwise for him to be known at the hotel as her husband. When he found an opportunity to be with her, he said, he would surreptitiously come to the hotel and toss a rose in her window. The lonely wife—wife in name only then—watched patiently for the symbol, but the welcome rose never came while she was there. Several times, when she returned from errands, she found it, but it was then too late, for Holmes had gone. This was his plan. He had watched from a hiding place until she had gone out, then tossed the rose in the window and fled. And even at this time he was calmly planning the slaughter of the innocents.

MURDERED IN A TRUNK.

It was also during these travels that he received from the children pathetic little scrawls to their mother, whom they thought was in St. Louis. He was to mail then to her, but upon his arrest, long after, nearly every one of the childish letters was found on him, unmailed.

At Toronto, Canada, Holmes, with the two girls, hired a house. The boy Howard had previously disappeared in Indianapolis, where his chared bones were afterwards found in a stove. The girls were murdered in this way: Holmes, probably by playing hide-and-seek with them, induced them to hide in a trunk. Then he shut down the lid, and filled the trunk with gas by means of a rubber tube inserted through a hole. Then he buried their bodies in the cellar.

All these discoveries were made by Detective Frank P. Geyer, of the Philadelphia department, who scoured the country unravelling the mysteries of Holmes' multifarious crimes.

HOLMES "CASTLE."

The scene of Holmes' other known murderous operations was the notorious "Castle," in Chicago, the building erected by him on the border of the world's fair grounds. The place was fitted up with padded rooms, secret chambers, vaults and quicklime vats, and this part of the story smacks of the romances of medieval times. Here it is thought sudden and violent deaths came to the Williams girls, Emily Cigrand, Mrs. Julia Conner and her 8-year-old daughter, Pearl.

Minnie Williams, when a child, inherited $40,000 from an uncle. When she became of age she went on the stage. In 1892 she met Holmes in Chicago, and became his stenographer, living with him as his wife. In 1893 she invited her sister, Nana, then a school teacher in Texas, to visit her at the Castle. She did so. Soon afterwards both girls disappeared forever. It is believed that Holmes killed them to get the $40,000. The Chicago police found several skeletons in the Castle, and two of them, they think, are all that remain of the hapless Williams sisters.

It should be stated here that Holmes, making a trade of murder, employed a private articulator, and had the skeletons of his victims mounted, and then sold for cash. He neglected no opportunity.

EMILY CIGRAND.

The murder of Emily Cigrand comes next in interest. She came from Lafayette, Ind. She was a blonde, and the prettiest of Holmes' victims. When 19 years old she was employed as a stenographer by Dr. Keeley, the gold-cure man. Pitezel met her when he was in the institution, and when he got out he told Holmes. Holmes wrote to the girl, offering a larger salary than she was then getting, and she came to the Castle. While in his employ she became engaged to be married to Robert E. Phelps, a very rich man, much older than herself; but one day she vanished from the face of the earth, and nothing has since been heard of her. It is believed that Holmes forced her to maintain illicit relations with him, and that, finding that she was learning too much of his affairs, he killed her.

THE CONNORS.

The alleged murder of Mrs. Julia Conner and her daughter, Pearl Conner, aged eight years, should be narrated next. The Conners went from Davenport, Ia., to Chicago, about 1890. Holmes was then running a drug and jewelry store at the corner of Wallace and Sixty-third streets. Conner got a job working in the jewelry department of Holmes' store. Holmes saw his wife who was a very pretty woman, and offered to give her a place as bookkeeper. She accepted it. Holmes made love to her, but Conner didn't suspect anything. The affair went on for some time, and Conner heard of it indirectly through Holmes himself. Conner consulted his friends and separated from his wife, leaving her with Holmes. She kept the child. Mrs. Conner was a woman of brains, and just the kind that Holmes would pick out to help him along in his schemes. She was last seen alive, still in Holmes' employ, about September, 1892. Then she disappeared like the rest of them. Her murder, if she was murdered, is supposed to have been one of the first that Holmes committed. He wrote several letters about her to a Mrs. Smythe, who was a friend of Mrs. Conner, which, it is alleged, were intended to divert suspicion from him on account of her sudden disappearance. The police believe they unearthed Mrs. Conner's body in their search of the Castle and that the bones of the child they found were all that were left of the little daughter.

Emily Van Tassell was the name of a girl who worked for Holmes in the Castle, and who like the others suddenly disappeared. Very little is known of her story. Perhaps she, too, fell a victim to his lust for blood.

MURDER BY MACHINERY.

In the story of Holmes and his crimes there is nothing more interesting than the description of his Castle, where he is accused of having provided all sorts of devices for disposing of his victims. The Castle, is at 701 Sixty-third street, Chicago. It was built with the sole idea of convenience for the commission of crime. Holmes built it himself. He selected the workmen. Until the Chicago police began their investigations of the place, Holmes and Pat Quinlan, the janitor of the building, were the only men alive who knew anything to speak of about the interior of the place.

The building is three stories high. The style of architecture suggests the name the Castle. In the main it was built with the idea of renting it out as flats, and for business purposes. It was in Holmes' apartments and in the basement that the secrets were found. The rooms used as offices by Holmes were in the front of the building. Both rooms were on the second floor, just in the rear of the offices. From Holmes' own bath-room there was a secret stairway leading to the street and also to the basement. The entrance to it was through a trap door in the floor of the bath room. This door was concealed by a rug. There was a chute running from the roof to the cellar, with an entrance in the bath room through the trap door, and there was a blind wall between the secret stairway and the chute. On the third floor of the building there were also trap doors. One led into a room which was used as the laboratory of the drug store, which was on the level with the street, and another led into the bath-room. On the first floor in Holmes' offices there were vaults capable of being made air tight, and built around so that no sound could be heard from them. Then there were rooms with no means of ventilation except the door. When that was closed no air could get in.

IN THE CASTLE CELLAR.

It was in the cellar that the police made their greatest discoveries. Two sheet-iron tanks entirely covered by the cellar floor were found, and in the bottom were some bones, which were believed to be those of human beings. In an ash-pile near by were found pieces of linen blood-stained. There was also a fire-box, or furnace, in the basement. It was built into the wall. There was a grate covered with sheet-iron seven-eighths of inch thick. Underneath was another grate, intended to hold the fire. The top of the furnace was two feet, six inches above the top grate. There was an iron flue from the furnace which led to a tank. There was no other entrance to the tank. At the bottom of the vault was a white fluid, which gave forth an overpowering odor. In a hole in the middle of the cellar more bones were found.

Holmes' case was appealed to the Supreme court, which affirmed the jury's verdict. Then he began to make yarns in a desperate effort to gain a respite. All was of no avail, and on the 30th of last month, Governor Hastings refused to interfere. On the same day Jeptha D. Howe, the St. Louis lawyer, was acquitted of complicity in the conspiracy against the insurance company.

One thing may be said of Holmes in passing. To the woman he married he was always a model of virtue. He dispensed his money with a liberal hand and was invariably kind and gentle to them.

HOLMES AS A HOODOO.

Many imaginative theories have been advanced regarding this marvellous pervert, and whispers of "hypnotism" and "the evil eye" have been frequent. Without considering these, it's a strange fact that a sinister fate has befallen many of those connected with his case. William A. Shoemaker, one of the lawyers, attempted to foist upon the court a bogus affidavit, and was subjected to disgrace and finally disbarred for a period. Then Dr. William K. Mattern, the coroner's physician, who made an autopsy of Pitezel's body, suddenly dropped dead recently; and lastly, Linford T. Biles, who was foreman of the jury in the trial, was a few weeks ago shocked to death by a live wire. Altogether it is safe to assume that a sigh of relief will go up from the whole country with the knowledge that Herman Mudgett, alias Henry H. Holmes, man or monster, has been exterminated—much the same as a plague to humanity would be stamped out. But the true story of his strange career will probably never be known.

See the clipping

His last words: two women, no Pitezels

On the scaffold Holmes says his killing came to ‘the death of two women,’ who died after illegal operations, and denies taking any Pitezel life, the father he is hanged for included. A month earlier he had confessed to 27 murders. After all the confessions and denials, that is where his own account ends.

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis. · and 7 other papers

Watertown Republican · 13 May 1896 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES IS HANGED.

Most Notorious Criminal of the Century Pays the Death Penalty.

See moreSee less

Philadelphia, Pa., May 7.—Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was hanged in Moyamensing prison today. The drop fell at 10:12:30. It was fully a half hour later before he was officially pronounced dead.

A half minute before he was shot into eternity he made this declaration to the solemn assemblage gathered about the scaffold:

"Gentlemen, I have very few words to say; in fact, I would have no remarks at this time except that by not speaking I would appear to acquiesce in my execution. I only wish to say that the extent of my wrong-doing in taking human life consisted in the death of two women, they having died at my hands as a result of criminal operations. I wish to state here, so there can be no chance of misunderstanding, that I am not guilty of taking the lives of any of the Pietzel family—the three children and Benjamin, the father, of whose death I was convicted and for which I am today to be hanged. That is all I have to say."

MINNIE WILLIAMS.

The words were well chosen and distinctly enunciated. The voice of the condemned man never quavered; the hands clasped on the dark railing of the scaffold did not tremble. The nerve which had all along characterized this most marvelous of assassins did not desert him at the end.

As the last syllable fell from his lips he turned to his attorney, Mr. Rotan. Clasping the right hand of the young lawyer, Holmes placed his left on the other man's shoulder, and, gazing up into his eyes, said in a loud voice: "Good-by." Then he carefully buttoned his coat, nodded to the sheriff and an instant later he was shot into the air.

He was undoubtedly the most stolid of any in that assemblage of more than fifty men. The pallor of his face was no deeper than the ordinary prison bleach and he stood erect, gazing steadfastly before him until the horrible black cap shut out his last look at earthly things.

Holmes' Last Day.

Holmes spent his last day of life uneventually. During part of yesterday Father Daily of the Church of the Annunciation visited him and said prayers. In the afternoon his lawyer, Samuel P. Rotan, spent a short time with him. The rest of the day Holmes spent in reading his Bible and other devotional books. Father Daily came again early in the evening and remained until 10:15 p. m.

After he left Holmes wrote letters of farewell until midnight. It is understood that the communications were addressed to his wife in Gilmanton, N. H., and Georgiana Yoke of Franklin, Ind., the so-called third wife, whose testimony did much to bring about today's execution. He also penned a letter of instruction to Mr. Rotan, his counsel. Absolute secrecy is maintained regarding the contents of these letters.

At 12 o'clock Holmes undressed and went to bed under the watchful eye of the keeper, Weaver, who was fearful lest the man in the cell beyond might

NANA WILLIAMS.

commit suicide. But apparently nothing was further from the abnormal mind of his charge. Holmes slept like an innocent babe and at 6 o'clock in the morning it required two calls to awaken him. At 7 o'clock Fathers Daily and McPeak arrived. Holmes received them silently and knelt with them while they went over the communion service. According to the rites of the Catholic church to which he had been converted during the past week, in form at least, he had been fasting since midnight. The service once over, his breakfast—dry toast and coffee—was brought in and he ate with an apparent relish.

The only sign of defiance that he made was just after the priest left. "Am I nervous," he demanded, stretching his hands out to Keeper Weaver. They were steady as a rock. Holmes smiled and retired to the rear of his cell. He declared that he had never felt better in his life. Soon after this the priests returned and remained with him until the end.

Meanwhile a nervously expectant crowd had gathered outside the gates of the gloomy old prison, which resembles in architecture a medieval fortress. A rope had been stretched across the entrance to the passageway leading to the convict department and inside of this were assembled the sheriff, city officials, jurors and newspaper reporters who had been admitted to witness the execution. The gates were opened at 9 o'clock and the party filed in. Sheriff's Solicitor Wagrew called the list of jurymen in the superintendent's office at the head of the corridor containing the scaffold. Those who responded included two ex-sheriffs of this city, seven physicians and an undertaker.

Procession to the Gallows.

Sheriff Clement administered the oath and at two minutes after 10 o'clock the procession to the gallows was begun, headed by Prison Superintendent Perkins and Assistant Superintendent Richardson. Fifty or more men, with uncovered heads, made up the solemn parade and halted before the scaffold.

The instrument of death loomed high in the center of the first corridor on the first floor of the convict side of the prison. The platform, which stood eight feet above the level of the floor, was approached by a flight of steps. The witnesses passed around the structure and faced it.

Silence followed for a moment. Then

HERMAN MUDGETT, ALIAS H. H. HOLMES.

A murmur arose from the other side of the scaffold. It was the prayers of the priests who were escorting Holmes to the gallows.

A moment later they mounted the steps and came into view. The priests arrayed in their secular vestments stood on either side of the condemned man and chanted the psalm miserere. Holmes, his eyes fixed upon a crucifix which he clasped in his hands, walked steadily between them. He wore a sack coat and trousers of gray material and a white shirt.

There was a pause as they reached the trap and then Holmes stepped forward and delivered his speech. It took him exactly two minutes to utter what nearly every man there regarded as the last of a series of lies. Father Daily knows, if any living man does, whether or not Holmes went into eternity with a lie on his lips, for to him Holmes either yesterday or today made a final confession. What the murderer confided to the priest is a secret of the confessional and will never be made public.

After shaking hands with his attorneys, who then left the scaffold, Holmes turned and bade farewell to Supts. Perkins and Richardson and the priests, who were the other occupants of the gallows. Then he and the clergy knelt in silent prayer. They arose at 10:12 o'clock. In another half minute the end had come. Holmes' hands were manacled behind him, the noose and the black cap was adjusted and the stillness was broken by a sound that echoed along the corridors like the sharp crack of a pistol. The body shot up and then hung without a tremor. As the echoes died away, the voices of the priests softly arose. They were chanting the prayers for those in the agonies of death. Five minutes later six physicians examined the body. They gave no official opinion, but Dr. Butcher privately stated that a broken neck had undoubtedly caused death. The heart beat feebly for fully fifteen minutes after the fall, but to all intents and purposes the man was killed by the drop.

The body was allowed to hang until 10:45 o'clock. Then it was cut down and placed in a coffin.

At half past 12 o'clock the big iron doors in the rear of the prison swung open and an undertaker's wagon rolled out. In it was a plain black casket containing the body. The wagon drove rapidly to Mount Morian cemetery, where it was placed in a vault. Here it will probably remain for two or three days, when it will be quietly interred in another graveyard. Whether or not it will be finally buried in consecrated ground depends upon Holmes' last words with Father Daily and the will of Archbishop Ryan.

Almost immediately after the execution a letter carrier walked up to the gates of the prison and delivered a newspaper addressed to H. H. Holmes. As the undertaker's wagon rolled out of the courtyard it was pursued for a distance by a crowd of gamins, who pounded gleefully on the sides of the vehicle until driven away by the police.

There will be no autopsy on the body of Holmes. Among his last words was a strict injunction to Attorney Rotan to forbid a dissection of his remains.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: Waiting for the Rope