As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

November 1894

142 articles

In the story →

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that a life insurance policy's true beneficiary was named Pnzel rather than Perry, and that inquiries about the policy led to H. H. Holmes, who had shared a building with the deceased in Chicago during the World's Fair.

The Washington Times · 18 November 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

$10,000 FOR A BOGUS BODY

That Price Was Paid by the Fidelity Mutual Life Association.

See moreSee less

BUT THE CORPSE WAS A FAKE

The Slick Methods by Which Mr. Holmes Secured a Fortune Upon the Alleged Death of B. F. Pitzel—Is Finally Arrested in Boston—The Deed Done in Philadelphia.

PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 17.—An elaborate life insurance swindle has come to light in this city.

On September 3 last, the corpse of a man was found at 1316 Callowhill street, this city, and was buried by the coroner under the name of B. F. Pitzel. Now it appears that the corpse was a bogus one substituted for the purpose of defrauding the insurance company of $10,000.

B. F. Pitzel rented the house on Callowhill street during the summer under the name of B. F. Perry, and while there conducted a patent medicine business. The last week in August he disappeared and on September 3 a man with whom he had had business relations, went to the house and found Perry dead on the floor. Death was attributed to the explosion of a jar of cleaning fluid.

After the body had been buried in the potters' field a communication was received by the Fidelity Mutual Life Association, dated St. Louis, and signed by an attorney of that city, J. D. Howe. It stated that he had seen the death notice in a Philadelphia newspaper and that he represented the dead man's widow.

The letter further stated that the real name of the deceased was B. F. Pitzel, a beneficiary of the company, the name of Perry having been assumed on account of financial difficulties in Tennessee.

The policy had been issued through the agency of a reputable business man, but when he was questioned he referred the inquirer to H. H. Holmes, who had had a desk in the same building with the deceased in Chicago during the World's Fair.

The general manager could not locate Holmes at first, but found his wife, and by her was told that her husband was a traveling man and she would communicate with him.

The manager left with her a clipping, referring to a body found in Chicago, and a few days later the office received a letter from Holmes, offering to come to Chicago if his expenses were paid.

The next day, however, Holmes wrote to the Philadelphia office stating that he had learned that the death was in Philadelphia, and that as he expected to be in Baltimore soon he would stop in Philadelphia.

Meanwhile Attorney Howe appeared in Philadelphia, accompanied by a young girl whom he represented as the daughter of the dead man. He also produced a letter of introduction to Superintendent of Police Linden from a former assistant district attorney of St. Louis, and Supt. Linden sent him to President House, of the insurance company.

Holmes came to hand about the same time, and, though examined separately and denying acquaintance with each other, both men gave a corresponding description of the dead man.

It was then decided to exhume the body, which was done by officials of the coroner. The officials of the company were satisfied and the body was reburied, and Attorney Howe received the $10,000, representing the sum due Mrs. Pitzel.

The insurance company never doubted the truth of the identification, although they had a belief that the case was one of murder, rather than accident. A month ago, however, one of the company's agents, while in St. Louis, became cognizant of some of the facts, and he formulated the theory of conspiracy.

Additional detectives were put on the case and Holmes was chased all over the country. The mother of the supposed dead man was found and from minute descriptions of her son it at once appeared that the corpse found was not his. In the meantime it was discovered that Holmes' real name was Herman Mudget and his home New Hampshire. His aliases were legion. He is known in New York, Chicago, Fort Worth, St. Louis, and almost [e]very other big city.

Then it was learned that Pitzel and Holmes obtained, by some means or other, a corpse from the New York Hospital, brought it here, surrounded it by the evidences of a violent death in the Callowhill street house, and obtained the $10,000 as above described.

Holmes was arrested in a west end boarding-house in Boston by Pinkerton detectives, who are now after the other conspirator, Pitzel.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping reports that Philadelphia detectives, police, and a coroner suspect the corpse used in an insurance fraud was actually the murdered beneficiary, and that the arrested man's confession was a ruse to hide the killing.

Evening Journal · 19 November 1894 · page 1

_ THAT iNbOHANCE SWINDLE Mndgtl's Confession Is Not Relieved, an4 Grave Mispleions Are Sir-Id. PllH.AUKl.PHlA, Nov. 1». —The prevail Ing Impression In this olty regarding tin gigantic Insurance swindle which rosulo od In the arrest In Boston Saturday oi Herman Mini get. otherwise known as H H. Holmes and a variety of other aliases, Is that the corpse found In theOaldownil. street house and upon which the $1,U0( was obtained was not a bogus corpse, but was In reality Unit of the beneficiary, B. F. Pltaoll, and that be was murdered bj Holmes This Is the belief not only ol tho detectives of the Fidelity Insurant» company, which w Izcil, but of Superintendent of Police Lin den and the coroner.

See moreSee less

They think that th« confession inado by Holmes detailing tht conspiracy was a ruse to avert tho theory of bis having made away with the mar, who for eight years was his partner lu crime Mrs Pltzoll, wife of tho victim or con splrator, will bo arrested today, but Levi G. Foviso, tho president of the company, thought It prudent to keep secret until then her present whereabouts. A thorough Investigation has been mad« Iu this olty and has raised strong doubl ns t« tho truth of Holmes' story of tin manner iu which they get the body. Not the slightest clew to show that It wai brought hero iu a trunk about the tlrnt*"" of tho discovery has been found. Mr. Fouso says that ox-AssIstant Dis trict Attoruey Marshall F. Donald of St Louis will not be arrested. It was be wbc In 188» prosecuted tho famous Maxwell 1'rollor murder case, and much surprise has been expressed that a man of bis prominence should ho oven Indirectly con ueelod with suoh an affair as this. so cleverly victim

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The article reports that H. H. Holmes, arrested for swindling an insurance association by faking a policy holder's death, may also face a murder charge, as evidence about the rigidity of the found body contradicts his claim it was transported in a trunk, and theories are presented suggesting the body was either the policy holder's, deliberately disfigured and killed, or another man's substituted for him.

New-York Tribune · 19 November 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES MAY BE TRIED FOR MURDER. Philadelphia, Nov. 18.—H. H. Holmes, alias H. H. Howard, the man arrested in Boston charged with swindling the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance Association, of this city, out of $10,000, by palming off a bogus corpse as the body of B. F. Pitzel, a policy-holder of the company, will be brought here to-morrow and arraigned on the charge. The charge of swindling may not be the only one Holmes will have to answer, for the more serious crime of murder may be laid to him. When the body of the supposed Pitzel was found in the room at No.

See moreSee less

1,316 Callowhill-st., on September 3 last, it was stretched flat upon the floor and was perfectly rigid. The Coroner's physician holds that the body could not have been brought here in a trunk from another city, as confessed by Holmes, for the reason that it was stiff, and a body once bent does not again become rigid. Furthermore, if it had been in the trunk it would have shown marks of where it had been doubled up, and no such marks were upon the body. A theory is advanced that the body found was really that of Pitzel and not of any one else. As a basis for this theory it is argued that Pitzel and the other conspirators plotted to disfigure the former by burning his face with some chemical and then calling in a physician to prescribe for his injuries. A body was then to be procured and similarly disfigured as Pitzel's was, and then it was to be given out that the man had died of his injuries, and it was trusted that the attending physician would not discover the fraud and would give a certificate of death in accordance with the facts told by the conspirators. It is supposed that Pitzel had his fellow conspirators administer chloroform to him so that he would not feel the pain of the burns when they were inflicted, and that he either was given an overdose and died from the effects or was killed while unconscious by his treacherous friends. Another theory in support of the belief of murder is that a man resembling Pitzel was decoyed to the room, chloroformed and killed and his face disfigured so as to render identification more difficult.

See the clipping

In the story →

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

The clipping describes how Holmes and Pitzel allegedly used a body from a New York hospital to fake Pitzel's death and collect a $10,000 life insurance payout from a Philadelphia company, prompting a manhunt for Pitzel.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Abendblatt · 19 November 1894 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Boston, Mass., 18. Nov.

In hiesiger Stadt wurde H. H. Holmes auf die Anklage, im September an einem Versicherungsschwindel in Philadelphia betheiligt gewesen zu sein, verhaftet. Holmes hatte einen Freund, Namens B. F. Pitzel, der angeblich ein Grundeigenthumsgeschäft in Philadelphia betrieb. Das Leben dieses Pitzel war durch eine Chicagoer Agentur in der Fidelity Mutual Life Association zum Betrage von $10,000 versichert. Eines schönen Tages wurde eine in New York erlangte Leiche in Pitzel's Bureau gebracht und Holmes identificirte sie als die seines Freundes Pitzel, der an Brandwunden gestorben sein sollte, die er bei einer Benzin-Explosion davongetragen hatte. Die Versicherungsgesellschaft zahlte zwar das Geld aus, machte sich aber an eine Untersuchung. Sie verfolgte Holmes' Spur nach Chicago und Denver und von dort nach dem Osten. Der Verhaftete legte ein volles Geständniß ab. Er bekannte, daß Pitzel noch am Leben sei und daß er (Holmes) seinen Antheil an den $10,000 Versicherungsgeldern erhalten habe. Die Bostoner Polizei glaubt, Holmes sei ein Mann, der in Chicago als des Mordes beschuldigt gesucht werde. Sicher ist, daß er in Fort Worth, Texas, wegen Pferdediebstahls gewünscht wird.

See moreSee less

Philadelphia, Pa., 18. Nov.

Am 3. September d. J. wurde in No. 1316 Callowhill Straße die Leiche eines Mannes gefunden und vom Coroner als die von B. F. Pitzel begraben. Ein Mann dieses Namens miethete das Haus an der Callowhill Straße im Laufe des Sommers unter dem Namen B. F. Perry und betrieb darin ein Patent-Medizingeschäft. In der letzten Woche des August verschwand er und am 3. September ging ein Mann, mit dem er in Geschäftsverbindung stand, in das Haus und fand Perry todt auf dem Fußboden liegend. Der Tod wurde angeblich durch die Explosion eines Kruges Benzin herbeigeführt. An der Leiche wurden eine kleine Summe Geldes und zwei in St. Louis zur Post gegebene Briefe gefunden, die von der Frau des Todten zu sein schienen und worin dieselbe ihre Absicht mittheilte, nach Philadelphia zu kommen. Die Leiche lag elf Tage in der Morgue, ohne identificirt zu werden. Die Leichenschau-Geschworenen gaben einen auf zufälligen Tod durch Brandwunden lautenden Wahrspruch ab. Nachdem die Leiche auf dem Armenfriedhofe beerdigt worden war, erhielt die Fidelity Mutual Life Association einen in St. Louis geschriebenen und von einem Anwalt jener Stadt, J. D. Howe unterzeichneten Brief, worin er schrieb, daß er die Todesanzeige in einer Philadelphiaer Zeitung gelesen habe und die Wittwe des Todten vertrete. Weiter hieß es, der richtige Name des Todten sei B. F. Pitzel, eines in der Gesellschaft Versicherten, und er habe den Namen Perry nur angenommen wegen finanzieller Schwierigkeiten, die er in Tennessee gehabt habe. Die Versicherungsgesellschaft weigerte sich, dem Anwalt die zur Ausfüllung bestimmten Papiere zu schicken, und ersuchte den General-Director in Chicago, wo die Police ausgefertigt worden war, um eine Beschreibung des Mannes, der sie erlangt hatte. Die Police war im Bureau eines angesehenen Geschäftsmannes ausgestellt worden, als er aber seine Aussagen machte, verwies er auf H. H. Holmes, der während der Weltausstellung in demselben Gebäude wie der Todte sein Bureau gehabt hatte. Der General-Director konnte zuerst den Aufenthaltsort Holmes' nicht ermitteln, fand jedoch seine Frau und erfuhr von dieser, daß ihr Mann ein Geschäftsreisender sei. Sie versprach, sich mit ihm in Verbindung setzen zu wollen. Der Director ließ einen auf eine in Chicago gefundene Leiche bezüglichen Zeitungsausschnitt zurück, und ein paar Tage später traf ein Brief im Bureau der Gesellschaft ein, worin Holmes sich erbot, nach Chicago zu kommen, falls die Auslagen bezahlt würden. Am folgenden Tage schrieb Holmes aber an das Bureau der Lebensversicherungsgesellschaft in Philadelphia und sagte, er habe gehört, der Todesfall habe sich in Philadelphia zugetragen, und da er bald in Baltimore zu sein gedenke, würde er nach Philadelphia kommen. Inzwischen traf Anwalt Howe in Gesellschaft eines jungen Mädchens in Philadelphia ein, das er für die Tochter des Todten ausgab. Er legte auch einen Empfehlungsbrief an den Polizeidirektor Linden von einem früheren Bezirksanwalt in St. Louis vor und der Polizeidirektor schickte ihn zu dem Präsidenten der Versicherungsgesellschaft. Es wurde dann beschlossen, die Leiche auszugraben, was die Beamten des Coroners thaten. Die Beamten der Gesellschaft erklärten sich jetzt zufrieden, die Leiche wurde wieder begraben und Anwalt Howe erhielt die Frau Pitzel schuldige Summe von $10,000.

Die Versicherungsgesellschaft zweifelte nicht an der Glaubwürdigkeit der Identifikation, doch glaubte sie, daß es eher ein Fall von Mord als von einem Unglück sei. Vor etwa vier Wochen nun hörte einer der Agenten der Gesellschaft, während er sich in St. Louis aufhielt, etwas von den Thatsachen und kam auf die Vermuthung, daß eine Verschwörung dahinter stecke. Nun kam es an's Licht, daß Pitzel und Holmes auf irgend eine Weise eine Leiche aus dem New York Hospital erlangt und den oben beschriebenen Betrug ausgeführt hatten. Geheimpolizisten fahnden jetzt auf Pitzel.

New York, 18. Nov.

Holmes war in Chicago unter dem Namen Howe bekannt. Er war Arzt gewesen und hatte einmal eine Apotheke. Er hatte Glück im Geschäft und als die Weltausstellung kam, baute er mit anderen ein großes Hotel, das Weltausstellungsgäste aufnehmen sollte. Er war als Contraktor und Kapitalist bekannt und als er sich in der Philadelphiaer Gesellschaft versichern ließ, nahm ihn der Chicagoer Agent, Fay, ohne Bedenken an. Einen Monat später stellte er seinen Freund, Benjamin F. Pitzel, dem Beamten vor, der sein Leben für $10,000 versichern lassen wollte. Auf die Empfehlung seines Arbeitgebers, Holmes, wurde Pitzel angenommen. Nach Auffindung der Leiche Perry's in Philadelphia, suchte man Holmes in Chicago. Der Chicagoer Agent ging nach dem Hotel, das Holmes gebaut hatte, und erfuhr, daß Holmes seinen Antheil verkauft und Chicago verlassen habe. Holmes hatte auf einem westlichen College Medizin studirt und im Westen praktizirt. Nach Auszahlung des Geldes traf Holmes mit Pitzel zusammen, das Geld wurde getheilt und Holmes ging nach Chicago zurück. Dann verließ er Chicago, bereiste New Hampshire und ging nach Boston. Wie es heißt, wird er auch in Chicago gewünscht.

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Among a column of news briefs, this report, printed in German, says H. H. Holmes was arrested in Boston on charges of involvement in a Philadelphia insurance swindle involving a faked death of his friend B. F. Pitzel, and that Holmes confessed Pitzel was alive and that he had received his share of the $10,000 insurance payout.

Abendblatt · 19 November 1894 · page 2

Die der Spionage beschuldigten deutschen Reserveoffiziere v. Kessel und v. Schoen beck behaupten immer noch, des ihnen zur Last gelegten Vergehens nicht schuldig zu sein,obwohl eine Anzastl belastender L>christ stücke in ihrer Wohnung gefunden worden ist. Die Offiziere behaupten, vermögende junge Leute zu sein, die sich nur zum Ver gnügen eine Zeit lang in Paris aushielten. Und v. Kessel soll wirklich durch etliche an muthige Elsässerinnen bereits um 43000 erleichtert worden sein. Die beiden Offi ziere wohnten früher in einem schön einge richteten Stockwerke in der Ruc Marbcaux, mußten aber ausziehen, weil sie die Micthe nichr bezahlen konnten.

See moreSee less

Sie sollen viel mit den Freundinnen französischer Offiziere verkehrt haben, jedenfalls um durch sie werthvollc Nachrichten zu erhalten. Der Dreysus-Fall ist immer noch in geheimnißvollcs Dunkel gehüllt. Nachdem Dreysus zuerst seine Unschuld betheuert hatte, legte er schließlich, nach Ent deckung verschiedener belastender Schrift stücke ein Geständniß ab. Kricgs minister Mercier hat nun zwar gesagt, Dreyins habe einen untergeordneten Posten bekleidet und hätte wichtige Dokumente nicht sehen, geschweige denn vcrralhen können, allein es wird trotzdem angenom men, daß Dreysus alle Pläne der Re gierung vcrralhen hat. Ueber die Behaup tung der hiesigen deutschen Botschaft, Dreysus habe ihr keine Schriftstücke ein gehündigt, lächelt man, da die allgemeine Ansicht dahin geht, daß er sie durch eine Mittelsperson direct an den Generatstab ui Berlin hat gelangen lassen. Wie Dreysus zuerst in Verdacht kam, er zählt folgende Geschichte: In Paris be steht eine Art Club, wo der Tcrpsichore und dem Bachus gehuldigt und der von Spionen, auch weiblichen, gern ausgesucht wird. Der Platz ist wohlbekannt und wird vom Kriegsdepartcment beobachtet. Gelegentlich werden Stabsoffiziere in bürgerlicher Kleidung dorthin geschickt, um sich zn überzeugen, wer daselbst ausund eingehl und was getrieben wird. Vor einem Jahre war einer der Offiziere nicht wenig erstaunt, Dreysus daselbst anzutreffen. Aus die Frage, ob er den Charakter des Platzes kenne, antwortete Dreysus bejahend ui d fügte als Erklärung seiner Anwesenheit hinzu, er gehe dahin, um sich im Deutschen zu üben, und die Sprache nicht zu ver gessen, was in Kricgszeiten sehr vortheilhaft sein würde. Seitdem wurde Dreysus genau beobachtet und schließlich ging er in die Falle. Eine Depesche aus Grand Bassam in Nord-Guinea meldet, daß die Franzosen die Veste der eingeborenen Akapleß ohne Verluste eingenommen haben. Rio Janeiro, 18. Nov. Kundgebungen des Vertrauens in Prä sident Moraes werden allerorten in Brasi lien offenbar. Die Spitzen aller Militärund Civitverwalttingen haben ihm ihre Ach tung bezeugt und ihn ihres Beistandes bei seinen Bemübungen, den Frieden aufrecht zu erhallen und die Republik zu befestigen, versichert. Neue Truppen sind hier angekommen. Die Bevölkerung schwärmt für Krieg mit Guaremata. City of Mexico, 18. Nov. Im Kriegsdeparlement herrscht fieber hasle Thätigkeit. San Tristobal de LasIn diesem Sraate herrscht die größte Begeisterung zn Gunsten des Krieges mit Guatemala. Die Negierung wurde ersucht, Freiwillige auzunehmen. Boston, Muss., 18. Nov. In hiesiger Stadt wurde H. H. Holmes auf die Anklage, im L>eptember an einem Versicherungsschwindel in Philadelphia be theiligt gewesen zu sein, verhaftet. Holmes hatte einen Freund, Namens B. F. Pitzel, der angeblich ein Grundeigenthumsgeschäst in Philadelphia betrieb. Das Leben dieses Pitzel war durch eine Chicagoer Agentur in der Fidelity Mutual Lise Association zum Betrage von 410.000 versichert. Eines schönen Tages wurde eine in New Bork erlangte Leiche in P itzel's Bureau gebracht und Holmes identificirte sie als die seines Freundes Pitzel, der an Brandwunden ge storben sein sollte, die er bei einer BenzinExplosion dnvongetragcn hatte. Die Ver sicherungsgesellschaft zahlte zwar das Geld aus, machte sich aber au eine Untersuchung. Sie verfolgte Holmes' Spur nach Cbicago und Denver und von dort nach dem Osten. Der Verhaftete legte ein volles Geständniß ab. Er bekannte, daß Pitzel noch am Le ben sei und daß er (Holmes) seinen Antheil an den 410,000 Versicherungsgcldern er halten habe. Die Bostoner Polizei glaubt, Holmes sei ein Mann, der in Chicago als des Mordes beschuldigt gesucht werde. Sicher ist, daß er in Fort Worih, Texas, wegen PterdedicbstahlS gewünscht wiritt Phi lad elp hi a, Pa., 18. Nov. Am 3. September d. I. wurde in No. 1316 Callowhill Straße die Leiche eines Mannes gefunden und vom Coroner als die von B. F. Pitzel begraben. Ein Mann dieses Namens miethcte das Haus an der Callowhill Sttaße im Laufe des Sommers unter dem Namen B. F. Perry und betrieb darin ein Pcttcnt-Medizingcschäft. In der letzten Woche des August verschwand er und am 3. September ging ein Mann, mit dem er in Geschäftsverbindung stand, in das Haus und fand Perry tobt aus dem Fuß boden liegend. Der Tod wurde angeblich durch die Explosion eines Kruges Benzin herbeigeführt. An der Leiche wurden eine kleine Summe Geldes und zwei in St. Louis zur Post gegebene Briefe gefunden, die von der Frau des Todten zu sein schienen und worin dieselbe ihre Absicht mitthcittc, nach Philadelphia zu kommen. Die Leiche lag elf Tage in der Morgue, ohne ideniisicirl zu werden. Die Leichen schau-Geschworenen gaben einen aus zu fälligen Tod durch Brandwunden lautenden Wahrsprnch ab. Nachdem die Leiche ans dem Armcnfriedhofe beerdigt worden war, erhielt die Fidelity Mutual Lise Association einen in Sl. Louis geschriebenen und von einem Anwalt jener Stad:, I. D. Howe Unterzeichneten Brief, worin er schrieb, daß er die Todesanzeige in einer Philadelphiacr Zeitung gelesen habe und die Wittwe des Todten vertrete. Weiter hieß es, der rich tige Name des Todlcn sei B. F. Pitzel, eines in der Gesellschaft Versicherten, und er habe den Namen Perry nur angenom men wegen finanzieller Schwierigkeiten, die er in Tennessee gehabt habe. Die Ver sicherungsgesellschaft weigerte sich, dem Anwalt die zur Ausfüllung bestimmten Papiere zn schicken, und ersuchte den Gene rat-Direclor iu Chicago, wo die Police ausgeferligt worden war, um eine Beschrei bung des Mannes, der sie erlangt hatte. Die Police war im Bureau eines angesehe nen Geschäftsmannes ansgestellt worden, als er aber seine Anssagen machte, verwies er auf H. H. Holmes, der während der Weltausstellung in demselben Gebäude wie Paris, 18. Nov. Paris, 18. Nov. Comita n, 18. Nov. Caras, 18. Nov. s

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The article reports that H. H. Holmes, accused of swindling an insurance association using a disguised corpse claimed to be B. F. Pitzel, will be brought to Philadelphia amid new theories questioning whether the body was actually Pitzel's and suggesting possible conspiracy or murder.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 19 November 1894 · page 2

Philadelphia, Nov. IS.—H. H. Holmes, alias H. H. Howard, the man arrested in Boston, charged with swindling the Fidelity Mutual I.ife Insurance Associa tion of this city, out of *10,000, by palm ing off a I signs corpse as the itody of B. !'\ Pitzel. will he brought here, tomorrow. He may !>c charged with murder. When the body of the supposed Pitzel was found in the room here. Sept. '■!, it was stretched flat upon the floor and per fectly rigid. The coroner's physician claims the body could not have boon brought here iua trunk from another city, as stated by Holmes, because it was stiff, and a body once bent dints not again be come rigid.

See moreSee less

It showed no marks of where it had Ix-cn doubled op in a trunk. The theory is advanced that the body was really that of Pitzel. It is argued that Pitzel and other conspirators plotted to disfigure the former by bunting the face with some chemical and calling in a physician to presentsfor the injuries. The body was then to Ikprocured and disfigured ns Pitzel'swas, and then it was to Ikgiven out that the man died of the injuries and a trusted physician would give a certificate of death in accordance with the facts told by the conspirators. It is supposed that Pitzel had fellow conspirators administer the chloroform, so that he would not feel the pain of tin horns, anil that he was either given tin ' overdose and died from the effects or was purposely killed while unconscious by Ids treacherous friends. Another theory is that a man resembl ittg Pitzel was decoyed to tinrooni.chloroI formed and killed, and his face disfigured to render identification more difficult. Another suspicious circumstance is that Mrs. Pitzel. .about a month ago. visited her parents in Illinois, and said nothing about the death of her husband.

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

The clipping, partly garbled, reports that H. H. Holmes, arrested in Boston for allegedly swindling an insurance association with a bogus corpse, will be arraigned, with a coroner's physician disputing his explanation and suggesting murder charges may follow.

The Scranton Tribune · 19 November 1894 · page 1

WAS THE CORPSE PITZEL'S?

By the Vnited Press. H. H. Holmes, alias II. II. Howard, the man arrested in Boston charged with swindling the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance association, of this city, out of $10,000 by palming oft a bogus corDse as the body of B. V. Pltzel, a policy holder of the company, will be brought here tomorrow and arraigned on the charge. The charge of swind will have to answer, for the more seri him. Whi n lh body of the supposed Pltzel was found in the room of 1316 Callowhill flat upon the floor und was perfectly rigid.

See moreSee less

The coroner's physician claims that the body could not have been brought here in a trunk from another city, as confessed to by Holmes, for the Philadelphia, Nov. 13. ling may not be the only one Holmes ous crimeof murder may le laid to

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The clipping describes a 1887 Boston insurance fraud involving Thomas, Frost, and Bray's false drowning claim, then notes Superintendent Cornish's remarks comparing it to the Holmes case, said to involve even greater finesse.

Pawtucket Tribune · 19 November 1894 · page 3

DETECTIVES WORKING HARD

stated, the police decline to divulge the names of such of these men as they ifinow, in the fear that the chase may become a stern one of length. They are even silent as to the number of other people con cerned. \ notable of those which have occurred in Boston for some years. That was the cel ebrated affair which was reported as long ago as Feb. 10, 1887, when Henry J. Thomas of Boston, Charles L. Frost and Walter E. Bray were arrested by Saperin tendent Cornish and other detectives.

See moreSee less

Accident assoclation of New Yk for $5OOO, the beneficiary named lei®® Mary A. Leonard of Dover street. while in a boat in Beverly harbor with him Thomas fell out and was drowned. Frost stated that Thomas was a compara tive stranger to him, the payment of the claim which was made was fortunately delayed on account of the fact that Thomas’ corpse did not come to light. tives were placed on the track. While shadowing one of the conspirators in Cam bridge the officers accidentally ran across Thomas in the flesh. He, with the others, were then arrested, and out of five indict ments attention to detail and the finesse which induced the company to pay over the money, far excelled the one mentioned above. course cf a day or two there will be de velopments which will render the matter a very remarkable one in the history of crime in the United States, college in the west, along with his New York friend, practiced for a year or so. Since then he has posed as a capitalist, builder, etc., in fact, as Mr. Cornish puts it, “lived by his wits.”” He is undoubtedly a man of eonsiderable talent. Celebrated Case Reecalled. This case recalls to mind oneof the most Thomas had been imsured in the Mutual Some time afterward Frost reported that There was no body in this case, so that The case was suspicious, and the detee Four Ceonvictions Were Secured. The Holmes case, however, in point of Superintendent Cornish says that in the Holmes, who graduated in a reputable

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

A Philadelphia report says authorities believe the corpse used to obtain $10,000 insurance was actually the murdered beneficiary B. K. Pitezel, not a bogus body as Holmes confessed, and that Mrs. Pitezel will be arrested, with no evidence found that a body was brought in a trunk.

The Providence News · 19 November 1894 · page 8

An Investigation Leads to the Belief That Pitezel Was Murdered.

PrnApgLrnia, Nov. 19.—The prevalling fmpression in this clt,{ regarding the gl gantic insurance swindle, whieh resulted fu the arrest in Bosten of Herman Mudge, otherwise known as H. H. Holmes and a variety of other alinges, is that the corpse found in the Callowhill strest house, and npon which the §lO.OOO was obtained, was not & bogus corpse, but was in reality that of the benoficiary, B. K. Plizel, and that he was murdered. g intendent of Police Linden and th coner think that the confession made by Holmes, detailing the eonspiracy was a moro ruse.

See moreSee less

Mrs. Pluzel, wife of the vietim, will be arrestad, ' A thorough investigation has been mad. in this city, and has euised strong doul as to the truth of Holmes' story of the manner in which the conspirators got the body. Not the siightest clew to show thai it was brought here in a trunk’ has bee: found.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says an attorney named Howe was arrested on the charge of conspiring with H. H. Holmes, also known as H. H. Howard, to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company of $10,000.

The Herald · 20 November 1894 · page 2

THE PITZEL INSURANCE SWINDLE

for 1880-87. The reassessment on the Central Pacifio, Southern Pacific, Cali fornia Pacific, Northern raiiroad, San Pablo and Tular6, for 1887, and the South Pacific coast roads is $789,173.10, of which $17,990,82 has been paid, leav ing $771,382.28 yet due. Of the regular assessments oc the same roads, the taxes amount to $531,161 70, the first inataliment of which, $205,580.45, will also be paid this week, making the aggregate $051,271.99 which will be turned into the treasury. This ia inde» pendent of the taxes paid in local assessments in 42 counties in tha state, amounting to more than $250,000.

See moreSee less

HOPE SPRINGS ETERNAL. having left Boston together. Mrs. Pitzel, Denver, Nov. 20.—Captain Constant it ie said, was decoyed from Burlington, Williams of the Seventh infantry has Vt., to Boston, hy a ' communication forwarded to the headquarters of the which she supposed to be from lloimes. department of Colorado the particulars Si. Louis, Nov. 19.—JephthaD. Howe, an attorney having en office with the of tne trouble with the Moqui Indians. law firm of McDonald & Howe, of this The Moqui Indians are few In number city, was arrested today on the charge of and dwell in the mountains of Arizona conspiring with oue H. 11. Holmes to ■ about 100 mileß from Fort Wingate, the defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insur ! nearest military post. The; are a peace' ance company of Philadelphia, out of ful and industrious tribe, but ignorant $10,000. Holmes, or 11. 11. Howard, as he was of all matters outside their awn little known in this city, got into trouble here villages. It is even said that they be lutt summer by selling a stock of drugs lieve they are the only people in tbe on which there was a shortage. world, witb tbe exception of tbe four Late tonight Chief Harrigan decided companies of United Statea cavalry that to talk concerning Howe'a arrest and appeared on tbe oooaaion of their late tbe part he had iv unearthing the plot i outbreak.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · and 3 other papers

A Philadelphia grand jury indicted Herman Mudgel (alias H. H. Holmes), lawyer Jephtha D. Howe, and a widow for conspiracy to defraud an insurance company, while officials debated whether the dead man was truly the policyholder and reported the widow's confession and arrest.

The Herald · 20 November 1894 · page 2

By the Aatoctated Pre«. Philadelphia, Nov. 19.—The grand jury late this afternoon found a true bill against Herman Mudgel, alias H. H. Holmes, now a prisoner in Boston; Jephtha B. Howe, the St. Louiß lawyer who collected the insurance money on B. F. Pitzel's policy for the latter's widow, aud tbe widow herself. Tbe in dictment reads for conspiracy to cheat and defraud. Alexander MclCnight, vice-president of tbe Fidelity Mutual company, made the following statement this afternoon : "While suspicion has grown until we are nearly positive that B. F. Pitzel was murdered, the only charge made before the grand jury was that of conspiracy to defraud."

See moreSee less

"I am positive that the body found on September 4th at No. 1310 Callowhill Btreet, on which an inquest was held the next day aa that of B, F. Perry, is none other then that of B. F. Pitzel." sold Coroner Axbridee today. "I am not at liberty at present to disclose my reasons for this assertion, but if I were and pointed them out you would be con vinced." It was stated tbis af'ernoon that Mrs. Pitzsl had been arrested in Burlington, Vt., and made a confession. Tbe detectives have practically aban doned the murder theory and now think they ore on the track of Pitzel in the person of n man calling himself B. F. Lyman, whose whereabouts tbey refuse to divulge. They stated tonight that Mra. Pilzel had mada a confession sub stantially the same as that ot Holmes, except that she believes tier husband to be iv South America. Sho has not seen bim Bince the alleged crime was com milted. The insurance officiala profess also to have received word that Holmes and Mra. Pitzel were en route to this city, having left Boston together. Mrs. Pitzel, it ie said, was decoyed from Burlington, Vt., to Boston, hy a ' communication which she supposed to be from lloimes. Si. Louis, Nov. 19.—JephthaD. Howe, an attorney having en office with the law firm of McDonald & Howe, of this city, was arrested today on the charge of conspiring with oue H. 11. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insur ance company of Philadelphia, out of $10,000. Holmes, or 11. 11. Howard, as he was known in this city, got into trouble here lutt summer by selling a stock of drugs on which there was a shortage. Late tonight Chief Harrigan decided to talk concerning Howe'a arrest and tbe part he had iv unearthing the plot to defraud tha Philadelphia concern. Said he: "Marion C. lisdgpeth, the famous Glendale, Mo,, trainrobber, now a prisoner iv the city jail, has told me of Howe's effortß to smuggle him keys and tools on various occasions to aid him in his attempts to escape. Howe is a brother of McDonald's partner and McDonald ia Hedgpeth'd attorney. "The first information I had was from Hedgpetb. His letter to me and the statement that followed, written by bim at my request, tell tbe story of the discovery of the plot. They are as fol lows : Major Lawrence Hnrrigiin, Chief 01 Police. Dear Sir: —There has been a $10,000 swindle worked upon a Philadelphia life insurance company and possibly a mur der committed iv working it. Seventy-rive hundred dollars of the money has already been paid and $2500 is yet in bunk, owing to a iquabble over the fee that Howe is wanting for his part in it. I can give some interesting information regarding it, and perhaps save the insurance com pany something ii they are notified at once. [Signed.] Marion C. HeduPhth. J. 0. Armstrong, a jail guard, iv a statement, also in possession of Chief of Police liurrigan, deposed that ho was approached by J. D. Howe for the pur pose of getting hiss assistance in secur ing liedgpeth's escape. The statement of Hedgpeth, before mentioned by Chief Harrigan, is as follows: "When H. M. Howard wbs here come two mouths ago, be told me he would like to talk to me. After we gut ac quainted he told mo ha had a scheme by which he could make $10,0i>0 aud that tio needed some lawyer who could be trusted, and said if I could introduce him to one he would give-me $.S(JU for so doing. He told that Pitzei's life was insured for $10,OUO; that Pitzel aud he were going to work the insurance company for tbat eurc. He told me how they were going to do it. He Baid he wbb an expert at it and that he had worked it before, and that, being a drugmitt, he could easily de ceive the insurance company by having Pifzsi fix himself up according to his direction and make it appear that he was mortally wounded by an explosion, and then put a corpse in the place of Pitzsl's body and have it identified aa tbat of Pitzsl. In a few days Mr. Howe came to me and told me that Howard had been to him ani introduced himself, saying I tecom mended him and that he (Howard) had laid the whole plot open to bim. Howe told me that he would eeo tbat I got my |500 if it worked, und that Howard was going on east ut once to attend to it. "Howe told me it was the Fidelity Mutual of Philadelphia. When notices appeared in the newspapers of Pitzei's death, Howe came down at once and told me it was only a matter of a few days until we got the money. Later Howe and a little girl—l think it was Pitzei'e daughter—succeeded in having the body recognized and identified as that of li. F. Pitzsl. ' Howe told me that Pitzei's wife wee privy to the whole thing. He says now that Howard would not let Mra. Pitzel go to Philadelphia to identify the body of her husband, aud that he (Howe) feels almost cat tain that Howard de ceived i'iizsl, and that Pitzel, in following Howard's instructions, was killed, and that it was really the body of Pitzel; that the policy was made out to the wife, and when tbe money was put into the hank, Howard sopped it and left the wife to settle with Howe for bis nerviees. She was willing to pay him ; 100,1, but he wanted 12000 Soss!soo is hold until they get through squabbling over it. "It is hardly worth while to say that October 19, 1894.

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn. · 20 November 1894
  • The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont. · 20 November 1894
  • The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash. · 20 November 1894

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This badly scrambled OCR fragment mentions a death sentence respite granted until Dec. 21, a disputed body identification, and an insurance company matter, but the text is too damaged to follow coherently.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 20 November 1894 · page 1

NO PROOFS OF MURDER AS YET.

They thought they d add star Malice shines in every Une of tun arllole. whether the body found ut 1810 Cnllowhill stripe for every Htate that and A derecL not Pitzell's. While tho street w admitted Into the union. They did caused admitted. Insurance company people until ttie fifteenth stole Inclined or James B. Rice. A friend tried to talk or In ued when they found that if they believe that it , there is proof to old jail aud for a state prison and work the bark Hosper, who old in in Juso on Friday for tho murder of Fitzger ami for the contract system for for telephone service yesterday supplies.

See moreSee less

ald. The president now grants a respite nonce of the death The report was approved, but referred ^ until Dec. 21. The supposition is that the baoK to the committee for cotnpletiou. ali the telephone, but us usual executit hung iu Han

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This badly garbled clipping jumbles references to the original thirteen colonies, a United States supreme court appeal involving unnamed accomplices, a suggestion that prison reform lies in preventing inheritance of criminal tendencies, and a paper read by someone named Daniel W. Taylor.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 20 November 1894 · page 1

NO PROOFS OF MURDER AS YET

tho Irishman's boot, all width und no Rico was well known throughout tho the company's. It is, how length; so they wont buck to tho thirteen, Htate, aahe at one lime was Past Graud , agreed by others that if Holmes representing tho thirteen original colonies, Uh'inuellorof the Knights of Pythias of which were, namely: New Hampshire, Delaware. Philadelphia in preference Connecticut, Rhode Island,Massachusetts, tion of the United States supreme court briefly, commending whit he had heard well ku of appeals on St. Clair's accomplices, Spurt und suggested that the basis of true true ho at unit and Hanson, und that in the event of Its prison reform would be found in prevent inheritance of oriininul tendencies. decision sustaining the verdict and sou Daniel W. Taylor read excellent paper tane

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping reports H. H. Holmes confessed in Boston, claiming the Philadelphia body was not Pitezel's, while Mrs. Pitezel, arrested in Burlington, told police she believes her husband is alive but does not know where her children are.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 20 November 1894 · page 1

| city, upon the death of B. F. Pitezel, The bill | charges “conspiracy to cheat and defraud.” Dis | trict-Attorney craham stated this afternoon that, while the charge of raurdering Pltezel was not named in the bill of indictment, he expected the (se to develop into a trial for murder, Vice-President MeKnight, of the Fidelity Mutual Life Assoclation, announced this afternoon that Mra, Pitezel had been arrested to-day in Burlington, Vt, and that she had confessed to the conspiracy. Mir. McKnight further stated that Lawyer Howe | was arrested to-day in St.

See moreSee less

Louis, Boston, Nov. 19.—H. H. Holmes, the life insurance windler. arrested in this city, was taken from the city prison to Pollee Headquarters to-day. In the Mynicipal Court Judge Ely dismissed the case aghinst him hers, so that he might be delivered to the police of Philadelphia. He was again taken to headgquariens and made a full confession. He Is | <1id to have been careful not to implicate others with himself, and he positively stated that the body found in the room at Philadelphia was not that of 1’. Pitezel, the man insured, but the body of some unknown person, whose corpse he obtained from a medical friend in New-York. The police au thorities are somewhat inclined to disbelieve klolme 8's story tn that connection, and it is stated { Lat jhe fool almost positive that Pitczel was maar dere Mr: Carrie Pltezel, the wife of the man whose Ife was insured for $10,000, was found in Burling ton, Vth and came to this city to-day with a Pink erton detective and Inspector Whitman, She is held on the charge of conspiracy after the fact, | When she arrived at Police Headquarters she real ized] for the first time that she was under suspi i, her trip to Boston having been made ostensi | bly for tl purpose of meeting Holmes, She went into a dead faint, but titer recovered her com | posure and told the oillcers what she Knew of the | CadBe | She believes that her husband is alive, but of this she 1s not certain, Neither does she know where her three children are, besides the two who are with her. All she knows is that she has been told repeated!y by Holmes that she would meet | Pitezel and tae children in different places, only | to be disappointed when she went there. She has t not seen her daughter Alice since the day, Septem | her 22 or 23, that she left her home in St. Louls to | 0 to Philadelphia with Holmes to identify the | Body supposed to be that of her father. Mrs. Piteze! says she has not seen her husband since he left her in July. They were then in St. Louis, Her husband informed her that he was going to Chi cago on business, and later on she says she re. ceived word from him in Philadelphia, stating that he had assumed the name of Perry, as a result of come difficulties he had got into in the South. She saves that about a week after the death of the man | in Philadelphia, who was supposed to be Pitezel, «he read tn a St. Louis paper of the death of a man named Perry. She believed that the man might Le her husband, and consulted a friend in reward to the matter. It was deemed best to let the matter drop for two or three days, and within that period she alleges that she received a call | from Holmes at her home in &t. Louis. She called his attention to the death of B. F. Perry in Phila. delvhta, She had known Holmes, alias Howard, <everal vears, as her husband had been in busi ness with him | She says Holmes told her not to worry, as her hushand was not dead, and everything would turn out all right. He told her that a corpse had been anbetituted to do duty as that of her husband. She wis toed that the purpose was that of getting the insurance money, She was asked to assist Holmes | | |

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, Mrs. Carrie Pitezel and Jeptha D. Howe are under arrest for participation in a fraudulent life insurance scheme in Philadelphia.

New-York Tribune · 20 November 1894 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING Foreign.-—The funeral and burial of the Czar took place, with stately ceremontes, in the For tress Cathedral in Si, Petersburg. Japaneses. warships are watching Wei-Hai-Wei, where the Chinese fleet is, = The Balinese stronghold was captured by the Dutch, who lost 150 killed and wounded, while the enemy's lose was several hundred. ——= The Conservatives carried the by election for the seat made vacant by Sir John Rigby's appointment to be a Lord of Appeal. Domestic.—Two men wera blown to pieces anil a third fataily injured by an explosion in, a powder mill in New-Jersey, = The Navy De partment ordered a court of inquiry to fix the responsibility for the accident to the Cincinnati, =——==- Officials in the Indian Territory requested that troops be sent there to suppress lawless.

See moreSee less

ness, —=— Winners at St. Asaph: Gallatin, Mc Kee, Marshall, Jewel, McIntyre, Our Jack and Vaucluse, =——— A disaster resulting in the loss of several lives occurred on a branch of the Pennsylvania Railroad in Pennsylvania. =— H. H. Holmes, Mrs. Carrie Pitezel and Jeptha Db. Howe are under arrest for participation in a fraudulent: life insurance scheme in Philadelphia, City and Suburban.—The conference called to form a State federation of woman's clubs be gan its session at Sherry's. === The right to tax in this city the estate of Jay Gould and the property of his children, who declare they do not live here, was affirmed in the Supreme Court. -——-—— A brilliant attendance at the Metropolitan Opera House witnessed the opening performance of the new season. ——== The stock market was under pressure all day, but showed strength, and closed firm, The Weather.—Forecast for to-day: Falr. Temperature yesterday: Highest, 47 degrees; lowest, 24; average, 37%.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A damaged clipping reports that a Philadelphia grand jury found a true bill against Herman Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, a prisoner in Boston, and Jeptha D. Howe, a St. Louis lawyer who collected insurance money, regarding an alleged insurance conspiracy.

Evening Star · 20 November 1894 · page 9

Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, now a pris Louis lawyer, who collectAd the In4irance THE PHILADELPHfMINYSTERY. Indeitmenti AMainst tIllj&4Ieged Pitzel Insurance Conspiratnorx. The grand jury at Philadelphia yesterday afternoon found a true hill agairit Herman oner in Boston; Jeptha 14. Howe, a St.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A Philadelphia grand jury returned a true bill against Herman Mudgett (H. H. Holmes), lawyer Jeptha Howe, and Pitezel's widow for conspiracy to defraud the insurance company. Officials, including the coroner, expressed growing certainty that the body found in September was indeed Pitezel's, despite rumors he had fled to South America.

The Indianapolis Journal · 20 November 1894 · page 5

INDICTMENTS AT PHILADELPHIA. Conspiracy to Defraud Charged - Indications of Murder.

INDICTMENTS AT PHILADELPHIA.. k m wm Conspiracy to Defraud ChargedIn v IHLADELPH1A, Nov. 19, The grand Ju.y. late this afternoon, found a true bill against Herman Mudget, -ali.as H. W. Holmes, now a prisoner in Boston; Jeptha B. Howe, the St Louis lawyer, who col lected the insurance money cn B. F. Pite zel's policy for the latter's wid&w, and the widow herself. The indictment reads for "Conspiracy to cheat and defraud." Alex ander McKnight vice president of the Fi delity Mutual company, made the following statement this afternoon to a representa tive of the Associated Press: "While the suspicion has grown until we are nearly positive that Benjamin F.

See moreSee less

Pitezel was mur dered, the only charge made before the grand -Jury was. that of conspiracy to de "I am positive that the body found on Sept. 4. at No. 1316 Callow Hill street, on which an Inquest was held the next day as that of B. F. Perry, is none other than that of B. F. Pitezel," said Coroner Ashbrldge to-day.. "I am not at liberty at present to disclose my reasons for this assertion, but if I were, and pointed them out, you would be convinced, notWifnstandng the stories as to the wretched man's expatriation in South America or elsewhere, that he met his death rignt here in Philadelphia." The detectives have practically . aban doned the murder theory, and now think they are on the track of Pitezel in the rer- , son of a man calling himself B. F. Lyman, ! whose whereabouts they refuse to divulge. They stated tw-nlcht that Mrs. Pitezel had made a confession substantially the Fame as that of Holmes, except, that she be lieves her huchand to be in South Amer ica. She has not seen him since the alleged crime was committed. The insurance offi cials profess also - to have received word that Holmes and Mrs.. Pitezel were ea route to this city, having left Bontc-n to night JS.Irs. Pitezel. It is stated, was dea communication which she supposed to from Holmes. dications of Murder. fraud." v

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report says a Miss Williams, a stenographer employed by Holmes, has disappeared along with him and left behind an inherited $50,000 fortune, details Holmes's rise from drugstore clerk to hotel owner in Chicago and his flight to Fort Worth, and describes his arrest in Boston on suspicion of the murder of B. F. Pitezel, whose insurance money he admits collecting but has only partly paid to Pitezel's wife, who is also under suspicion.

Abendblatt · 20 November 1894 · page 1

gesehen worden. Die Thalsache, daß sie grade gleichzeitig mit Holmes verschwand, läßt befürchten, daß ihr irgend ein Unglück zugestoßen ist, ja, daß sie vielleicht nicht mehr zu Lebenden zählt, denn Holmes be findet sich jetzt in Boston nicht nur wegen umfangreicher Schwindel, die er angeb lich begangen haben soll, sondern auch we gen der, wie man annimmr, von ihm ver übten Ermordung von B. F. P itizel in der Untersuchungshaft. Ein anderer Umstand, der höchst sonderbar erscheint, ist, daß Frl. Williams augenscheinlich ihr auf H 50,000 geschätztes Vermögen im Stiche gelassen hat.

See moreSee less

Dieses Vermögen erbte sie von ihren Ellern, die schon mehrere Jahre todt sind. Frl. William hat aber trotzdem ihren Be ruf als Stenographistin nicht aufgegeben, sondern demselben zum Zeitvertreib ferner hin obgelegcn und zwar, als Angestellte des besagten Holmes. Letzterer war der In haber der No. 701 63. Str. gelegenen Apo theke. Vor etwa sieben Jahren trat er als Clerk in dieselbe ein und schon ein Jahr darauf, war er deren alleiniger Eigen thümer. Nach Verlaus weniger Monate kaufte er das ganze Grundstück, auf dem die Apotheke stand, an, ließ diese abtragen und ein dreistöckiges Backsteingebäude auf führen. Als die Wcllausstellungszeil her anrückte, richtete er das Gebäude von oben bis unten ein und cröffnctc ein Hotel. Dieses lhat er Alles zum größten Theil auf Pump, da er nie einen bedeutenden Ueberschuß aus den Einnahmen in seiner Apotheke gewonnen hatte. Es gelang ihm jedoch immer wieder, sich seine Gläubiger vom Leibe zu Hallen, bis er vor Kurzem sein Geschäft einem Manne "Namens Jones verkaufte und nach Fort Worth, Texas, answanderlc. Dort etablirte er sich mit einem New Yorker, Namens Yaies, unter dem Namen Campbell als Möbel-Fabri kant. Natürlich borgte er sich die dazu nö thigen Gelder, doch ließen sich seine Gläu biger dort nicht so leicht absertigen, wie hier in Chicago und so mußte er eines Nachts lautlos aus Fort Worth verschwin den. Vor nicht gar langer Zeit nun wurde ein Mann, Namens B. F. Pitezel. der mit seiner Frau in dem Hause No. 6909 Pau linastraßc gewohnt und viel bei Holmes verkehrt Halle, in dem Hause No. 1316 Callowellslraße in Philadelphia todt auf gefunden. Allen Anzeichen nach war er ermordet worden, was um so glaubwür diger erschien, als sein Leben für HIO,OOO versichert war. Nach den angestrengtesten Nachforschungen der Polizei wurde endlich der Verdacht auf Holmes gelenkt, infolge dessen dieser am letzten Samstag in Boston in Haft genommen wurde. Er leugnet na türlich, irgend etwas von der Ermordung Pilezel's zu wissen, giebt aber zu, die Le bensversicherung desselben erhoben und bis jetzt nur HSOO davon der Frau Pitczcl's zu gewicsen zu haben. Letztere wird übrigens auch verdächtigt, über den Tod ihres Gatten Näheres zu wissen. Heute Vormittag wurde vor Richter Chetlain die Anklage des Mordes gegen John Burke abgeschlossen. John Burke war angeklagl, am 2. März d. I. in der Wirthschast von B. Simon, No. 395 W. Taylor Str., den Schankkellner David Boiarski ermordet zu haben. Die Anklage war durch Hülfs-Staats anwait Pearson mit dem ehemaligen Staatsanwalt Joel M. Longenecker als Beistand vertreten. Kickham Scanlan führte die Verteidigung und hatte aus eine Jury verzichtet. Der Angeklagte hatte sich des Todtschlags schuldig bekannt. Die Zeugen der Anklage erzählten, daß Burke mit seinem Freund John Butler nach der Wirthschast kam und daß cs zu einem Streit zwischen den Güsten und dem Schankkellner über die Zeche kam. Burke verließ die Wirthschast und Butler setzte den Streit mit David Boiarsky fort. Wäh rend desselben wurde die Kunde dem vor der Wirthschast stehenden Burke gebracht, daß Butler von dem Schankkellner ange griffen sei. Burke eilte in die Wirthschast zurück und schoß den Boiarsky ohne Weite res nieder. Die Vertheidigung machte geltend, daß das Gesetz einem Dritten das Recht giebl, wenn er einen Menschen in Lebensgefahr sieht, einzuspringcn und um das Leben des Angegriffenen zu retten, selbst zur Waffe greisen dürfe. Der Schankkellner habe mit dem schweren Eisschaber ausgehotl, um Butler zu erschlagen, in diesem Augenblick schoß Burke. Dieses Zeugniß wurde von dem Wirts) B. Simon als unwahr hingestellt. Er er klärte, daß er niemals einen Eisschaber oder eure Eisaxt oder irgend ein anderes den Tod herbeiführendes Instrument hin ter dem Schanktisch gehabt habe; nicht ein mal ein Revolver lag hinter dem Schank tisch. Der Eismann zerkleinerte das Eis, wenn er es brachte und der Schankkellner hatte nur einen kleinen etwa drei Zoll lan gen Stastlstift, mit welchem er die größeren Stücke zu zerstoßen pflegte. Andere Zeugen berichteten, daß Boiarsky dem Butler nur mit einem gefahrlosen Staubwedel in's Gesicht fuhr, als Burke den mörderischen Schuß abfeuerte. Die Frau, Mutter und Vater und viele Bekannte waren mit der Familie in dem Gerichtssaal erschienen, um beim Richter einen Eindruck zur Milde hervorzurufen. In seiner Entscheidung erklärte der Richter, daß kein Schimmer einer Noth webr nach dem von ihm sehr sorgsam über dachten Beweismaterial zu finden sei. Die Tödtung von David Bomrsky warein bru taler Mord. Die Strafe soll aus 30 Jahre Zuchthaus festgesetzt sein. Wie vom Donner gerührt, standen die Angehörigen des Verurlheilten da; weinend sielen ihm Mutter, Vater und Frau um den Hals; das einer lebenslänglichen Zucht hausstrafe fast gleichkommende Urtheil er schien als ein vernichtender Schlag gegen das Lebcnsglück des Verurlheilten.

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

A Philadelphia grand jury indicted Holmes, attorney Jeptha Howe, and Mrs. Pitzel for conspiracy to defraud an insurance company, while the coroner insisted the body found was indeed Pitzel's despite Holmes's claims otherwise. Howe was separately arrested in St. Louis and released on bail after signing a statement.

Abendblatt · 20 November 1894 · page 2

um iu Philadelphia dem Gericht vorgelegt zu werden. Holmes hütete sich, irgend Jemand, außer ihm selbst, in den Fall zu verwickeln, und behauptete steif und fest, die in dem Hause in Philadelphia gefun dene Leiche sei nicht die des versicherten B. F. Pitzel gewesen, sondern eine von einem befreundeten Arzte empfangene. Die Polizei schenkt dieser Angabe keinen Glau ben, sondern ist überzeugt, daß Pitzel er mordet wurde. Philadelphia, Pa., 19. Nov. Die Großgsschworenen haben heute gegen Abend Anklagen gegen Hermann Mndget, alias H. H. Holmes, jetzt in Boston in Hast befindlich; Jeplha B.

See moreSee less

Howe, den St. Louiser Advokaten, welcher die Ver sicherungsgeldcr ans B. F. Pitzel's Po lice für des Letzteren Wittwe einzog, und gegen die Wittwe selbst erhoben. Die Anklage lautet ans „Verschwörung, zu betrügen und zu hinlergchen." Der Vice-Präsident der „Fidelity Mu tual Company", Alexander McKnight, sagte heute Nachmittag zu einem Vertreter der Presse iolgendes: „Obwohl unser Ver dacht, daß B. F. Pitzel ermordet wurde, immer mehr zugenommen hat, wurde vor den Großgcschworenen doch nur die Klage auf Verschwörung zu Betrug erhoben". Leicheubeschauer Ashbridge sagte: „Ich bin überzeugt, daß die am 4. September in No. 1316 Callow Hill Straße gefundene Leiche, über welche am folgenden Tage als die von B. F. Pcrry die Leichenschau ge halten wurde, keine andere als die von B. F. Pitzel war. Ich kann jetzt die Gründe für meine Behauptung nicht angcben, wenn ich es aber thäte, so würden Sie trotz der Geschichten über die Verbannung des Unglücklichen in Süd-Amerika oder an derswo überzeugt sein, daß er hier in Philadelphia zu seinem Tode kam. Heute Nachmittag hieß es, Frau Pitzel sei in Burlington, Vermont, verhaftet worden und habe ein Geständniß abgelegt. Jeptha D. Howe, ein Mitglied der Ad vokatenfirma McDonald L Howe in hiesi ger Stadt, wurde heute auf die Klage, sich mit einem gewissen H. H. Holmes ver schworen zu haben, um die „Fidelity Mu tual Lise Insurance Co." von Philadel phia um HIO.OOO zu betrügen, verhaftet. Die Verhaftung fand in Verbindung mit dem aus Philadelphia gemeldeten Versiche rungsschwindelsalle statt. Anwalt Howe wurde dem Cbies Harri gan in den Four Courts vorgeführt. Der St. Louiser Vertreter der „Fide lity Co.", W. E. Gary, wohnte der Be sprechung bei. Am Schluffe derselben wurde Howe unter G3OOO Bürgschaft gestellt und freigelassen. Howe Unterzeichnete ein Schriftstück, das der Chef mitnnlerzeicbnete und das Garv übergeben wurde. Weder Gary noch Harrigan wollten den Vertre tern der Presse etwas mittheilen. Howe machte jedoch folgende Aussagen: „Ich werde Ihnen dasselbe sagen, was ich Gary und dem Chief gesagtihabe. Zuerst glaube ich nicht, daß ein Betrug begangen worden ist. Ich glaube, daß die von P itzels Tochter idenlisizirte Leiche die ihres Vaters war. Die Zeichen der Identification waren vollständig. Wie Pitzel zu seinem Tode kam, kann ich nicht sagen. Wie ich be reits zu Gary gesagt habe, wenn ein Betrug begangen wurde, so wünsche ich so dringend wie irgend Jemand, daß es untersucht werde und werde alles thun, was in meinen Kräften steht, um die Schuldigen der Strafe zu überliefern. Ich habe den Fall in gutem Glauben übernommen und nur gcthan, was jeder andere Advokat auch ge than haben würde. Gary frug mich, ob ich bereit wäre, wenn ein Betrug nachgewie sen würde, der Gesellschaft meine Sporteln zurückzuzahlen und ich antwortete ihm, ich würde nicht nur bereit dazu sein, sondern unter keinen Umständen auch nur einen Theil davon behalten." Howe sagt, er fürchte den Ausgang der Sache nicht, doch säge ihm die Nororietät, die er dadurch bekomme, nicht zu. Die „Fidelity Mutual Lise Insurance Co." begann heute ein BeschlaglegnngS vcrsahrcn im Kreisgericht gegen I. D. Howe und Carrie A. Pitzel, die Wittwe des angeblichen Todtcn. Sobald Frau Pitzel das Geld erhielt, soll sie mit ihrer Familie nach Davenport, lowa, gezogen sein. Sie soll in der hiesigen Merchants National Bank Geld eingelegt haben. Holmes oder H. H. Howard, wie er sich hier nannte, hatte vergangenen Sommer hier Schwierigkeiten durch den Verkauf von Medizinen, auf denen eine Hypothek ruhte. Geheimpolizisten behaupten, Howard habe sich verschiedenen Mitgefangenen ge genüber dahin geäußert, daß er einen famosen Plan habe, um eine Versicherungs gesellschaft zu beschwindeln, wenn er unr einen geriebenen Advokaten bekommen könne, der ihm zur Hand gehe. Während Howard im Gesängniß war, wurde er mit dem Anwalt Howe bekannt. Nachdem er hier freigekommen war, ging Howard dem Anscheine nach nach Phila delphia und nahm den Namen Holmes an. Die Bekanntschaft Pitzel's will er hier ge macht haben. Er sagt, Pitzel's Frau und Tochter seien an der Verschwörung belhei ligt und auch Anwalt Howe wisse von der Verschwörung. Seit Pitzel's angeblichem Tode hat man keine Spur von ihm ge sehen. Philadelphia, Pa., 19. Nov. Die Geheimpolizisten haben die Mord lheorie anfgegeüen und glauben, daß sie sich auf der Spur Pitzel's in der Person eines Mannes Namens B. T. Lyman be finden. Heute Abend sagten sie, Frau Pitzel yabe ungefähr dasselbe eingestanden wie Holmes, ausgenommen, daß sie glaubt, ihr Mann befinde sich in SüdAmerika. Sie hat ihn nicht gesehen, seil das angebliche Verbrechen begangen wurde. Die VersicherungSbeamten sagen, sie hätten Nachricht erhalten, daß Holmes und Frau Pitzel sich aus dem Wege hierher be fänden. Frau Pitzel wurde durch einen Brief von Burlington, Vt., nach Boston gelockt, von dem sie glaubte, daß er von Holmes käme. Chief Harrigan sagte heute Abend spät: „Ich will Ihnen sagen, was ich vom jungen Howe weiß. Der Zngräuber Marian C. Hedgepalh, der sich im Staatsgesängniß befindet, hat mir von Howe's Bemühungen, ihm (Hcdgcpath) Schlüssel znzustecken und zur Flucht zu verhelfen, erzählt. Sie wissen, daß Howe ein Bruder von McDo nalds Geschüftstheilhaber ist und McDo nald ist Hedgepalh's Anwalt. Die erste Nachricht übel den Vcrsiche rungsschwindel erhielt ich bon Hcdgcpath. Sein Brief an mich und die folgenden Aussagen, die er ans mein Verlangen nie dergeschcicben hat, zeigen, wie das Com plott entdeckt wurde." Diese Aussagen lauten allerdings sehr belastend für den jungen Howe, und es geht ans denselben klar hervor, daß er an dem Complott betheiligl war. SaranacLake, N.Z)., 19. Nov. Der nördliche Theil des Staats New St. Louis, 19. Nov. St. Louis, 19. Nov.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Printed in German, this report describes how attorney Howe and a man named H. H. Holmes separately identified exhumed remains believed to be Pitezel's using marks and a crippled nail, allowing Howe to collect $10,000 insurance for the widow, while the insurer's detectives grew suspicious of foul play.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 20 November 1894 · page 2

chem er in Geschäfts -Verbindung?!! stand, ihn aussuchen wollte, fand er die Thür des Hauses ndverjch'ossen. Da er aus sein Klopsen keine Antwort er hielt, ging er iort: als er jedoch auch am nächsten Tage daS Haus ossen fand und keine Antwort erhielt, ging ec nach dem oberen Stock und fand dort vor dem Kamin einen Maon. den er für Perry hielt, leblos ani Boden liegend. Neben demselben lagen die Scherben ei ner Flasche, welche Benzin und andere entzündliche Subslaineu enthalten haiie, soivie eine Pfeife und ein angebranntes Sireichholz. Man nahm an, daß Perri) seine Pseise habe anzünden wollen, wäh rend er die Flasche unyersch.!oss.'N in der Hand hielt, daß eine Erplonon erfolgte nnd daß er derselben zum Opfer gefallen sei.

See moreSee less

Der Körper zeigte erhebliche Brand wunden, welche jedoch auch dadurch ent standen sein konnten, daß die Flüssigkeit übe: die Leiche gegossen und angezündet wurde. In den Taschen des Cannes wurden eine kleine Geldsumme und zwei Briese aus St. Louis, die anscheinend von der Frau deS Mannes kamen, ge sunden. Iu dem Schreiben gab die Frau ihre Absicht kuud, daß sie nach Philadelphia kommen ivolle. Die Leiche wurde, obwohl sie erheblich verbrannt und entstellt war, von den Nachbarn leicht ldeutifizirt. . 'Niemand schien über die Vergangenheit des MamieS EtwaS zu wlssen, und die Leiche lag 11 Tage in der Morgne, ohne daß sie ideutisizirt worden wärc. Es herrsch! kein Zwetsel darüber,, daß der Mann vier oder fünf Tage vor Auffindung der Leiche das Le ben verloren hatte. Nachdem die EoroiierL-InNi-ein Ver dikt abgegeben hatte, daß der Mann in Folge von Brandwunden und der Ein athmung vöu Ehloiosoiiu . das Leben verloreu chabe. und nachdem die Leiche ans dein ?timen-Foiedhote beerdigt war. traf ein. Brief des Advokaten I.- D. Howe vou St..Louis bei der in Phila delphia eiabliricii .Fidelity - MutualLise-Association" ein, ln welchen.! derselbe sagte, er habe von dem Tode des Perry, alraS Peitzel, in Philadelphier Zctlnil gen gelxsen und sei von der Wittwe be auftragt,. dcrey. Interesse zu vertreten. Perry'S wahrer Name sei Peitzel, und dieser Name sei bei der Association für 510,000 versichert; den 'Namen Perry habe , sinr angenöiiimefl,. .um sich vor suiav.zicllen in Tenncsscc zü schützl-n. Howe verlangte, die Asso ciation mög? ihm die üblichen Formu lare einschicken, damit er im Namen der Wiluve Ansprüche auf die Vcrfiche rnngssumm? erheben könne.. Stäkt Ties u thun, schrieben die hie sigen Beamten an . die Hauptosfice in Chicago, bei welcher die Versicherung abgeschlossen war, und virlangtul eine Personalbeschreibung des Peitzcl. Tie Police war am 10. "November 1693 durch hie a.ngesehc n.n Gcichästsmavv.cs. erlangt worden; da aber dieser sich nicht mehr au. den Fall, erinnerst konnte, verwies er die Geheimpolizisten der Tlssoxiation an ei nen gewissen H,.H. HolmeS,. der wüh lend der Weltausstellung iy. Chicago Mit Peitzcl in dem uämlich.u Zemmer eine Oftice gch.ibl hafte. Holmes, ein G:schäsl.srci;xp.dcr, war.nicht zn stiide::; seine (vrau, welcher, er einen Äusschnttt über, eiijey To.des.sall in Chlcagy gab. sagte aber dem Gchtimpoli.zistcn, sie wolle ihn EinigeDage späier erhielt der Geschüs.lssührex in Ehicggo von Holmes einen in welchem sich derselbe erbot, nach Chicago za kommen, wenn die Kosten vergütet würden. . . . . AM.riächstjüi.Tage schrieb Holmeö an die Philadelphier Ofsi<e, er. habe.ge hört. daß Pertzel dort gestorben sei, und da er in.Baltimore EnvaS zn thun ha be,.so werde er in Plz'lädelhhia Behufs Jöcutisizir.ing der Leiche vorsprechen. Mittlerweile wär Advoka: Howe in der Philadelphier Ossic: in Begleitung c:ues Mädchens erschienen, welches er sür die Tochter des Verstorbenen aue gab. Er brachte dem Polizei-Superu!- trndeuten Landen einen Empsehlungs bllcf von dem fiühcreü Hülfs-DistriltsAnwalt McDonald in St. LlZnis, und dieser gab ihm einen Empfehlungsbrief än den Präsidenien dcr.VcrsichernngrEesellschiist, L. G. Fonse. Um die nämliche Zeit.-tras auch Hol meS liier ein, und' obwohl beide Män ner sich nicht zn kennen vorgaben, gaben sie doch eine übereinstimmende Beschrer biing des Verstorbenen. Beide machten den Eindruck intelligenter, reputirlichcr Geschäftsleute. Es wurde daün be schlossen, die Lcicke des Peitzel auszu graben ; Dies geschah in Gegenwart der Versicherungs-Beamten nnd des Holmes durch Angestellte des Eoroncr?-Büre2us. Tie Leiche wir stark in Verwesung über gegangen, und während der CoronerSArzt nach einem Muttermale aiu Nacken des Mannes suchte, wurde Holmes un geduldig, sich des Doktors Hand schuhe und Messer geben und brachte schnell dieie HaulstcUe zum Vorschein. Auch eine Nar,b: am Brut und ein ver krüppelter Nagel wurden gesunden; die Jdeiilifiziruug wurde als vollständig er achtet.. Die Leiche wurde auf dem „Mechanics' Friedhofe" wieder begra ben, uud Anwalt Howe erhiell sür Fiau Pcitzct hie Versicherungssumme von 5101000 baar ausbezahlt. Alles blieb eine Zeit lang ruhig, die Vcrsichcrtuigs-Gesclischaft war vou der einen Verdacht hegte, daß ein Mord stall iines Unfalles vorliege. Aus die sem Grunde ließen die Geheimpolizist?!! der Gesellschaft die beiden Leute nicht aus den Augen. Ein Agent brachte bei einem Besuche in St. Louis in Erfah rung, daß Holmes und Howe, welche sich nicht zu kennen vorgaben, genau mit einander bekannt gewesen seien. Howe hatte dcu Holmes, welcher unter dem Namen H. H. Howard verhaftet worden war, erfolgreich vertheidigt. Außerdem follte die Ädvotalcn-Firma McDonald und Howe eine zweifelhafte Reputation haben. Bald nachher wnrde entdeckt, daß HolmeS und Peitzel in Chicago während der Weltausstellung zusammen Geschäfte betrieben hallen. Tie sollen ein Hotel mit Privat-Zimmern gehalten haben, in welchem sie erschwindelte Kaufmanns gütcr versteckt hallen. Die Firma hieß Eanchbcll,. <k Co., und ihr Etablissement hieß das „Worlds - FairHotel." "Nr. 701, 63. Straße-. Holmes soll anch ans gesälschte Besitztitel Hopo> theken ausgenommen haben, auch wollen die Detektive entdeckt haben, daß derselbe Bankraub, .Fälschung und Pserdedieb stahl betrieben habe. Peitzel' Police November 1893 in Chicago herausgenommen, Holmes versicherte sich um einen Monal später; Beide gaben als Zahlung Notep; die des Peitzel wurden bezahlt, während die Police des Holmes wegen "Nichtbe zahlung der Wechsel verfiel. Die Versicherungs - Compagnie hielt cs nun für angezeigt, ihre ganze Detek tiv-Force mit der Anssindnug der Spur bis Holmes zu beauftragen. Man hatte in der Zwischenzeit die Mütter deS Peitzel gesunden und von dieser erfah ren, daß ihr Sohn kein Muttermal am Nacken, dagegen einen verkrüppelten Fuß.gehabt habe, den man unmöglich hätte übersehen können.. Holmes war ciu sehr gewandter Geselle, doch gesaug es den Detektiven, seine Spur behal ten. Tie brachten dabei in Erfahrung, daß s in Name Norman Mudget sei, daß er in New - Hampshire geboren fei, daß er sich H. H. HolmeS, H. H. M. Hsivard, H. M. Eywards, H. H. Ho well und H. H. Apis genannt habe, und daß er außerdem mit Frau Peitzel fehr gut stehe.. . ! Am Samstag nun ist der Mann mit vielen Namen iu Boston arretirk worüberzeugt, wenn sie auch

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The clipping reports that some believe Holmes, facing a horse-stealing indictment in Texas, would not choose Philadelphia over Texas if guilty of murder, suggesting he may prefer a conspiracy sentence to a harsher penalty elsewhere.

The Evening Herald · 20 November 1894 · page 3

NO PROOFS OF MURDER AS YET

same mind as tho company's. It Is, how ever, agreed by others that If Holmes was a guilty party to murder ho would hardly elect to come to Philadelphia in preference to going to Texas, where ho Is under in dictment for horse stealing. Holmes' willingness to como here would Eecm to Indicate that he is in a position to establish his innocence of any capital crime In Pennsylvania and that ho prefers a term of Imprisonment for conspiracy rather than a more serious punishment for auy other offense committed elsewhere.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

The clipping reports that Mrs. Pitzel reportedly confessed similarly to Holmes but believes her husband is in South America and has not seen him since the alleged crime, with a St. Louis dispatch mentioning an attorney named Jeptha Howe, before the fragment breaks off.

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 November 1894 · page 3

THE PLOT THICKENS.

divalge. They stated last night that Mrs. Pitzel had made a confession substantially the same as that of Holmes, except that she believes her husband to be in South America. She has not seen him since the alleged crime was commirted. A dispatch from St. Louis says: Jeptha Howe, an attorney having an office with the law firm of McDonald & Howe of this CARPENTERS

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A fragmentary report describes a grand jury indictment for conspiracy against Mudgett (alias H. H. Holmes), attorney Jeptha B. Howe, and Pitzel's widow, amid detectives' doubts about the murder theory and disputed claims over the identity of the body and the insurance payout.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Pawtucket Tribune · 20 November 1894 · page 3

THREE PERSONS ARRESTED.

Prirapeiriia, Nov., 20.—The grana jury late yescerday afternoon found a true bill againse Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, now on the way from Boston; Jeptha B. Howe, the St. Louis lawyer, who collected the insurance money on B. F. Pitzel’s policy for the latter’s widow, and the widow herself. The indictment reads for *‘conspiracy to cheat and defraud.” The detectives have practically aban ew'cd the murder theory, and now think #%=.y are on thoe track of Pitzel in the per son of a man calling himself B. F. Ly man, whose whereabouts they refuse to divalge.

See moreSee less

had made a confession substantially the same as that of Holmes, except that she believes her husband to be in South America. She has not seen him since the alleged crime was commirted. Howe, an attorney having an office with the law firm of McDonald & Howe of this city, was arrested yesterday on the charge of conspiring with one H. H. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insur ance company of Philadelphia out of $lO,OOO. The arrest was made in connec tion with the insurance swindle case re ported from Philadelphia last Saturday night. . Harrigan at the four courts. At the con ference W, E. Gary, St. Louis manager of the Fidelity Mutual, was present. At the conclusion of the confe:ence Howe was Howe signed a document, to which the chief also pnt his signature, and it was turned over to Gary.” N¢ her Gary nor Chief Harrigan would tals about the case. of his case, but dislikes the notoriety it gives him. company began an attachment suit yes terday in the circuit court against J. D. Howe ‘and Carrie A. Pitzel, 'the reputed widow of the supposed dead man. The suit is for $lO,OOO. The writ was executed by garnishing the Merchants National bank, where it is stated the Pitzels have some funds. Assoon as she received the money Mrs, Pitzel and family are said to have moved to Davenport, la, Enown in this e¢ity, got into trouble here last summer by selling a stock of drugs on which there was a mortgage. It-is claimed by detectives here that Howard stated to several prisoners in the jail, so that it came to the ears of the guard, that he had the best scheme ever conceived for swindling an insurance company, if he could only get some sharp attorney to help him. While in jail Howard against him, Howard went to Philadiel phia and assumed the names of Holies. While here Howard 18 said to have made the acquaintance of B. F. Pitzel, whose supposed body was found in Philadelphia. The allegations now made by Howard, who is under arrest, is that the boly is not that of Pitzel, but one that he, as a druggist, had cbtained from a medical college. were also in the conspiracy, anl it is Howard who claims that Attorney Howe knew of the conspiracy. Howe claims he Eknew of no conspiracy, and that the first he knew of the case was when Mrs, Piizel came to him and asked him 1, take charge of it for her. This hed.d, and went on 10 Philadeiphia, taking Piizel's daughter with him to identily the body and coilect the money. Since Pitzel's supposed death no trace of him huas been seen. They stated last night that Mrs. Pitzel A dispatch from St. Louis says: Jeptha Attorney Howe was taken before Chief Released on a $lOOO Bond. Howe says he has no fear of the result The Fidelity Mutnal Life Insurance Holmes, or H. M. Howard, as he was Became Acquainted With Howe. After being released on the charge He says that Pitzel’s wife and daughter

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The fragment advertises a play called Wax Figures, arranged with Oliver Byron and billed as a sequel to a prior Byron success, connected to an insurance company matter, with cast member J. Gordon Edwards listed.

The Providence News · 20 November 1894 · page 4

THREE ARRESTS MADE.

In Connection With the Pitzel-HolmesHowe Insurance Company. WAX FIGURES (By special arrangement with Oliver Byron, Esq.) L\ soquel to s yron’s old time success, ‘Aorou.t?u Contin at.” In the east. J. Gordon Edwards,

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The clipping reports that St. Louis attorney Jeptha D. Howe, of the firm McDonald and Howe, was arrested on a charge of conspiring with H. H. Holmes to defraud an insurance company.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 20 November 1894 · page 1

ATTORNEY \IUU;S1ED, Charged With Coniplrluir to DefronA an Inauranoc Company. St. Loch, Ma, Nov. 10.?Jeptha D. Howe, an attorney having an office with the law firm of McDonald and Howe, o( tbla city, waa arrested to-day on a charge of conspiriug with H. H. Holmes

See the clipping

The Daily Texarkanian · Texarkana, Ark.

This damaged clipping contains disjointed fragments mentioning a declination, the Western Passenger Association, a person named Holmes, a property, and a man in a white hat asking about wintering in California, but is too incoherent to summarize further.

The Daily Texarkanian · 21 November 1894 · page 1

MYSTERIOUS MURDER.

; void a positive declination, and yet 1 o show than an acceptance would Western Passenger Association as was said to be Holmes. On this it has existed up to the present property Lyman began the erection California" said the horsey-looking man with the white hat at a hotel “Going to winter in California?

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A damaged clipping describes a session in which Holmes, seated beside a detective, related the sensational story of his whole life, though the text is fragmentary and cuts off.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Herald · 21 November 1894 · page 1

STRANGER THAN FICTION.

tbe moat important feature of which was the relation by Mr. Holmes of the story of bis whole life. It reads like tbe moat sensational of romances. Holmes Bat beside tbe detective with

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A fragmentary clipping reports that the alleged Pitzel case conspirator Holmes is charged in Fort Worth, Texas with a double murder, alongside unrelated brief items about a singer and a late-night train to London.

Evening Journal · 21 November 1894 · page 3

started on a special train for London a little before midnight. Will Be Mr*. Poiter'a Guest. Mias Eleanor Mayo, who will sing hi "Princess Bonnie" to morrow night, secretary, was In this city to-day. HOLMES' TEXAS CAREER. The Alleged Pltzel Case Conspirator X. Charged Willi a Douille 31 order. Fort Worth, Tex., Nov. SI.—There Is

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A damaged clipping describes a weakened Mrs. Piteel being supported into the Central station, and Detective Crawford recounting how the handcuffed prisoner Holmes told him his whole sensational life story during the train ride from Boston.

The Washington Times · 21 November 1894 · page 1

HE SUPPORTED THREE WIVES

it a bote! fa tbe neighborhood of police head vjis such that tho was unable to walk from Droad Street station to the Central station X rose the street, and had to be supported by D'tectrve Crawford and a policeman. !ter their urnval the party was rloseted V i.D Superintendent of Police Linden until tit it in the afternoon. When the conference V s over. Detective Crawford detailed the tor. of the trip, tbe moet important feature if which was tbe relation made to him by Holmes of the story of hie. whole life. It ea.is Mke the most sensational of romances. Holmes sat beside the detective with haadVuffb on. and the train bad scarcely emerged rom tne Boston oeiot before the prisoner iiarter. Mrs. Piteel's nervous condition

See the clipping

The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis · and 1 other paper

A St. Louis attorney named Jeptha D. Howe was arrested on charges of conspiring with H. H. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance Company of $10,000, then released on a three-thousand-dollar bond after a conference with company officials.

The Indiana State Sentinel · 21 November 1894 · page 1

ST. LOUIS, Nov. 19. -Jeptha D. Howe, an attorney having an office with the law firm of McDonald and Howe of this city, was j arrested today on the charge of conspiring j with one H. H. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity mutual life Insurance company of ' Philadelphia out of $10,0. The arrest was made la connection with the Insurance swindle case reported from Philadelphia laut Saturday night. Attorney Howe was taken before Chief Harrigan at the Four Courts. At the conference W. K. Gary, St. Louis manager of the Fidelity mutual, was present.

See moreSee less

At the conclusion of the con Neither tiary nor Chief llarrliran would talk about the case to representatives of the press. ference Howe wa-s released on a three-thousand-dollar bnd. Howe signed a doc ument to which the chief also put his sig nature, and it was turned over to Gary.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · 24 November 1894

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A Philadelphia telegram reports that H. H. Holmes arrived in custody of a detective and a special agent, accompanied by Mrs. Pitzel and her two children and a woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes, who disappeared soon after arrival.

Rock Island Argus · 21 November 1894 · page 1

Arrives at the Quaker City. A telegram from Philadelphia says: Arch-Conspirator H. H. Holmes, accom panied by Mrs. Pitzel and a pretty wom an who calls herself Mrs. Holmes, ar rived in this city in the custody af Detective Crawfurd and Sin-cial Agent Perry, of the Fidelity Mutual Life association. Mrs. Pitzel's 10-vear-old laughter Meila and her 1 -year-old liy were also with tho pHrty. Mrs. Holmes lisnpicatvd soon after her arrival and no clew to her whereabouts could lie ol tained. It Is thought that she is stopping at n hotel in the neighborhood of police headquarters. Mrs. Pitzel's nervous con dition was such that she was unable to

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Among a column of news briefs, printed in German, this report says Holmes arrived in Philadelphia with Mrs. Pitzel, her daughter Meta and infant son, and another woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes, guarded by detectives, with Holmes allegedly attempting to bribe a detective to let him hypnotize his way to escape.

Abendblatt · 21 November 1894 · page 2

20 Meilen von Port Arthur erneuert ha ben, an der nämlichen Stelle, wo sie am Sonntag mit einem angeblichen Verluste von 300 Mann znrückgeschlagcn wurden. Trotz des verzweifelten Widerslandes der Chinesen wurden dieselben schließlich von, den Japanern aus ihren Ver schanzungen vertrieben. Die Verluste ans beiden Seiten waren sehr bedeutend. Die Chinesen sind nach Port Arthur geflohen. Kapitän McClure, der englische Offizier, der vom Tsung-Li-Bamen zum Vizeadmiral der chinesischen Flotte ernannt wurde, ist in Wei Hai Wei angckommcn und hat den Oberbefehl über die Flotte übernommen. A m sterdam , 20.

See moreSee less

Nov. Der Befehlshaber der holländischen Truppen in Lombock bei Java meldet, daß er das Land in der Umgegend von Tjakra Negara ausgekundschastel habe, ohne aus Widerstand zu stoßen. Er hält es für wahrscheinlich, daß der alte Najah verwun det wurde und in nördlicher Richtung ge flohen sei. Der Befehlshaber fügt noch hinzu, daß er 230 Kilo Gold und 3,810 Kilo Silber nach Ampanam geschickt habe. Philadelphia, 20. Nov. Frau Benjamin F Pitzel, die Frau des Mannes, aus dessen angeblichen Tod hin die Fidelity Mutual Lite Association in hiesiger Stadl eine Versicherungssumme von tzIOMO ansbczahlt halte, traf heute mit ihrer sechzehn Jahre alten Tochter Meta und H. H. .Holmes, alias Hermann Mudget, unter Bewachung von zwei Pin kerton'schcn Geheimpolizisten ans Boston hier ein. Das Prozeßverfahren wird erst cingelcitet werden, wenn der der Thcil nahme an der Verschwörung verdächtige Anwalt Howe aus St. Louis hierher ge bracht sein wird. Philadelphia, 20. Nov. Der Hauplverschwörer H. H. Holmes traf heute in Beglcilung von Frau Pitzelund einer hübschen Frau, die sich Frau Holmes nennt, unter Bewachung des Ge heimpolizisten Crawford und des SpezialAgenten der Fidelity Mutual Lise Asso ciation Perry hier ein. Bei ihnen befand sich auch Frau Pitzel's 16 Jahre alte Tochter und ihr einjähriger Knabe. Frau Holmes verschwand bald nach ihrer Ankunft und es konnte nicht in Erfahrung gebracht werden, wohin sie sich gewandt hatte. Doch glaubt mau, daß sic in einem Hotel in der Nähe des Polizei hauptquarliers abgesticgen ist. Der Zug, welcher gestern Abend 18 Uhr von Boston abging, hatte sich in Folge eines Eisenbahnunglücks bei Bristol verspätet. Frau Pitzel war so angegriffen, daß sie nicht allein gehen konnte und sich führen lassen mußte. Nach ihrer Ankunft fand eine bis gegen Abend dauernde Besprechung mit dem Polizeidirector Linden statt. Nach derselben erzählte Geheimpolizist Crawford die Geschichte der Fahrt, deren wichtigster Theil die von Holmes mit getheilte Beschreibung seines Lebens war. Dieselbe klingt wie ein hochsensationeller Roman. Holmes saß mit Handschellen neben dem Geheimpolizisten. Der Zug batte kaum den Bostoner Bahnhof ver lassen, als Holmes auch schon einen Be stcchnngsversnch machte. Er bot dem Poli zisten tzsoo an, wenn er ihm gestatten wollte, ihn zn hypnotisiren, damit er ent springen könne. Er sagte, er habe oft Per sonen hypnotisirt und die Kunst von dem Professor eines College im Westen gelernt. Das Geld würde er von seiner Frau und Frau Pitzel bekommen. Als er sah, daß seine Worte keine Wirkung hervorbrachten, fing Holmes an zn plaudern und erzählte seine Lebensgeschichte. Er sagte, er sei in Burlington, Vt., aus gewachsen und habe in den dortigen Schu len eine so gute Erziehung genossen, daß er bereits mit fünfzehn Jahren selber unter richtet habe. Daraus besuchte er ein dortiges College und später eins in Detroit, Mick. Hier machte er die Bekanntschaft eines Studenten der Medizin, der ihm später in New Nork die Leiche lieferte, die bei dem Schwindel benutzt wurde. Seinen Namen gab er nicht an. Während der Ferien arbeiteten Beide auf Farmen, um von dem Verdienst ihre Ausgaben ans dem College zu bestreiten. Einen Sommer hatten sie keine Mittel und damals war es, wo der Mediziner auf die Idee kam, eine Leiche zu besorgen und eine Versicherungs gesellschaft zn beschwindeln. Das war vor zwölf Jahren. Der Doctor versicherte sein Leben für H 12,000. Sie verschafften sich eine Leiche in Ehicago, ließen sic identi fiziren und bekamen das Geld, mit dessen Hülse sie ihre Studien fortsetzten. Die be schwindelte Gesellschaft wollte er nicht nennen. Später setzten sie diese Schwindeleien er folgreich fort und erlangten Gelder in Höhe zwischen HIO,OOO und tz20,000. Einmal versicherte Holmes sein Leben für H2OMO. Er ging nach einem Hotel in Rhode Island. Damals trug er einen Barl. Er verschaffte sich eine Leiche in Chicago, schnitt ihr den Kopf ab und brachte die Leiche an eine ein same Stelle nicht weit vom Hotel. Dann rasirte er sich den Bart ab, kehrte in das Hotel zurück, fragte nach Holmes und mie lhete ein Zimmer, um auf ihn zu warten. Den Kops hatte er mitgebracht und ver brannte ihn im Kaminseuer des Hotels. Dieser Plan aber mißlang. Seine Schwie germutter kam hinter die Geschichte und drohte, es der Polizei zu melden. Er floh nach dem Westen. Dann erzählte er weiter: Während sei nes Aufenthaltes in Chicago vor 11 Jahren verliebte er sich in eine Maschincnschreibe rin und richtete ein Haus in der Vorstadt ein, wo sie zusammenlebten. Eine jüngere Schwester kam zu Besuch und die Frau wurde so eifersüchtig aus sie, daß sie sie eines Tages beim Streit mit einem Stuhl über den Kopf schlug und tödlete. Um die Frau, mil der er lebte, zu retten, that er, so sagte Holmes, die Leiche in einen Koffer, beschwerte ihn mit Steinen und versenkte ihn im See. Dieses Mädchen besaß Eigen lhum in Texas und er und Pitzel nahmen es ihr ab und schickten sie ansßeisen. DasEigen thum war tz40,000 Werth. Nachdem sie es erlangt hatten, zogen sie durch Texas und kauften Wagenladungen voll Pferden auf Noten. Da sic jedoch keinen gesetzlichen Besitztitel aus das Eigenthum hatten, ! waren die Noten werlhlös und deshalb ka z men sie in Texas in Schwierigkeiten. ! Um dieses Eigenthum zn retten, faßten ! Holmes und Pitzel den Plan, die Fidelity Company zn beschwindeln. Er sagte den Polizisten, für die Verbrechen, die er be gangen habe, verdiene er ein Dutzend Mal gehenkt zu werden. Holmes hat keinen Mangel an Geld, denn er gab zu, daß er zur Zeit beinahe zwei Dutzend Personen unterstütze, dar unter das Mädchen, das seine Schwester ermordete, ihre Mutter und einen schwach sinnigen Bruder; zwei Waisen in Ehicago, die in einem seiner Häuser wohnen, drei angebliche Frauem und ihre Kinder und seine eigenen Eltern in Kankakec. Die Namen der Frauen wollte er nicht nennen. Er behauptet fest, Pitzel lebe in San Sal vador und er würde von ihm hören durch eine Anzeige unter „Persönliches" in einer New Zjorker Zeitung.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Mr. Perry described Holmes' arrest in Boston and how Pitzel was decoyed from Burlington, saying nothing in today's secret conference refuted his original theory that Pitzel had been murdered.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 21 November 1894 · page 1

MRS PITZEL BELIEVED INNOCENT

.Mr. Perry related in detail the Btory of Holmes' arrest iu Boston and the manner iu which ,Mr. PitZel WAS decoded frnm Burliuston. He s.dd that m ttie Bfcret i coufereuci: loday nothing bad been stid that would in the slightest degree refute his oriciuai tneory that Pitzel had becc murdered.

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

Mrs. Benjamin F. Pitzel, her 10-year-old daughter Alice, and H. H. Holmes (alias Norman Mudgett) arrived in Philadelphia from Boston in Pinkerton custody, with legal proceedings awaiting Lawyer Howe's arrival from St. Louis.

The Evening Bulletin · 21 November 1894 · page 1

Insurance Fraud

Philadelphia, Nov. 21. Mrs. Ben jamin F. Pitzel, the wifo of tho man upon whoso supposed death $10,000 wero fraudulently colloctod from tho 10ir1fU-v. r...-...1 T ze z..li i ii '""""J .mumm uuu USSUUlUUUIl oi cms city, together with her 10-ye.ir-old daughter, Moda and H. H. Holmes, anas "iiormau JYludgott," arrived in this city Tuesday from Boston iu tho custody of two Piukertou men. It is not expected that any legal proceedings will bo prosecuted beforo Lawyer Howo is brought ou from St. Louis. Claims Ho .Made It Gootl.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me. · and 1 other paper

The clipping reports that Herman Mudgett, alias Holmes, and Mrs. Pitezel were brought from Boston to Philadelphia for arraignment in a conspiracy case, with Holmes recounting past insurance swindles and a failed hypnotism escape bribe to his detective escort.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 November 1894 · page 1

Philadelphia, Nov. 20.—Developments, today, in the conspiracy and possible mur der case whereby $10,000 insunuict* was obtained from the Fidelity Mutual Life Insuramv Association. wen* the arrival in Philadelphia of Herman Mudgett, alias Harry H. Holmes, alii^s Howard, the arch conspirator; Mrs. Benjamin F. Pit/el, i alias C<M)k. wife or widow of the victim, with her 10-year-old daughter Meda, and 1-year-old ix>v; Holmes’ wife: and then evipt of the intelligence that lawyer Howe, St. I»uis. who had been indict<il sis a conspirator, is on the way hither. The date when Holmes.

See moreSee less

Howe and Mrs. Pitezel will Ik* arraigned in court has not Ixvn fixed. Holmes and Mrs. Pitezel wen* brought from Boston by Detective (’rawfonl and Supervisor «»f Claims Perry of the Fidelity Association. Mrs. Holmes is not under arrest, hut accompanied her husband, and the Pitezel ehildreu wen* in the company of their mother. Detective Crawford told the story of the trip from Boston. The |>arty left Boston at 7.30 last evening. On the train. Holmes, handcuffed to the detective, went over his adventures from his boyhood. When the train .vas parsing Providemv, Holmes turned to his custodian and slid: “Svhere, Crawford. 1 think my wife and Mrs. Pitezel can raise lx-twivn them $500. I’m a hypnotizer. If you’ll let me hypnotize you, so we can escape. I'll give you $500. “Hypnotism,” returned the detective, "always spoils my appetite. I’m afraid $500 is no inducement when weighed against possible dyspepsia. ” Holmes told the detective that he was raised in Burlington, Vt., and attended the schools there until 15 years old. He taught school fora time, and afterwards went to the local college, working in the slimmer timetopiiy hisfct*s. He graduated at Burlington and went to Michigan Col lege, where he made the acquaintance, as a student, of tlx* physician who, he alleges, agnvd to supply the body used in the* last fraud. The two young men worked during tlx* vacation. About 12 years ago, one summer they were short of funds. Holmes’ friend thought of an insurance swindle, in which a I ogus lxsiy was to Ik* had. The friend, now a physician, had Ids life insured for $12,500; a body was procured in Chicago, identification with tlx* insured doctor made, aixl Holmes collected the money. The scheme was reprated several times. On one occasion Holmes insured his own lift* for $20,000. Then he went to a hotel in Rhode Island, wearing a l>enrd. Ib got a body, t«x>k it two miles from tlx* hotel,rut the head off and buried the rest. He shaved, went to the hotel.and register ing under a new name, asked for Holmes. They said he had gone out, but was stay ing at the hotel. The swindler t<x»k tin head. churn'd it in tlx* hotel furnace, and tried to identify it ax his own. This par ticular scheme fell through. The areh-c< aspirator, without giving any names, dwelt upon his dealings with Miss Williams, as narrated, today,in a dispatch from Chicago. In Chicago, he said,where he was living with his second wife, lx* Ik came intimate with a young girl, a type writer. He furnished apartments for her. where she was visited by an elder sister. Tlx* young girl, infatuat'd with Holmes, became jealous of her sister.and oix* day. in his absence, brained her with a stool. “When 1 came back.” Holmes said to the detective. “I found the dead body in tlx* rooms. I took tlx* corpse, put it in a trunk and sunk it in tlx* lake. This was a year and a half ago. The younger sister, in danger of arrest for murder, was anx ious to escape. She owned some pro perty at Fort Worth, amounting to $40, non. Pitezel and I took this projx'rtj off her hands and gave her tlx* money to fly the country. W<* bought horses, getting credit on the strength of the Fort Worth pro]k rty, but the deeds were not straight, and as we ne«*dod the money to keep tla thing going, tlx* two of us agreed to work tlx* insurance scheme again, and that’s how this trouble began." Supervisor Perry declared, this morn ing, that he lvlieved the case to Ik* mur »ier; that Pitezel in reality is dead. Mr. Perry said that Holmes has three wives, one in New Hampshire, who is divorced and with whom then* is a 13-years-old child; another in Illinois, who has a child of six years; and th* spouse who aeeom panied him to Philadelphia, and whom Perry lx*lieves to Ik* innocent. When asked how Holnx*s accounted for the disappearance of three of Mrs. Pit« z»Ts children, the supervisor said : “ He claims to have left one child at a hotel in Indian apolis, while he went t > Detroit, where he delivered tlx* other two to the father.” Regarding Mr-. PiteaeFs connection with the affair. Perry further said : “ I believe she may have Ixvn accessory after the fact, forced to sign papers and consent to tlx* actions of the others by treachery. She told me. hist night, that she received only $800 of the cash. Holmes, she said, t«x»k $5000 and put it in a land specula tion at Fort Worth. Holmes afterwards admitted that this was true. I think Mrs. Pitezel was told by Holmes to do this.and that everything would lx* all right. Glad to have s >me one to obey and follow, she act* d on his instructions ignorantly and trustingly. I do n< t believe she is in any way r»*sponsible for herhushand’s death.” This aflernrxm. President Fouse of the Fivielity Association, said: “I have re ceived word tl a the at.-cu*ed Lawyer Howe is «-n the way Kaxt from St. Ixmis, accompanied by his partner. Me Donald, the former di-trict attorney of that city. Mc Donald do- > not come as a prisoner nor is he even formally accused. He is simply an advisor to Hi we. ” Assistant I)istr ct Attorney Kinsey, to day, stated that the district «ttor.iey had not yet taken any action upon the murder allegations. “No evidence <-f murder has

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y. · 21 November 1894

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A damaged clipping quotes Mr. Perry saying he believed the case was murder and that Pitezel is actually dead, and that Holmes has three wives, including a divorced one in New Hampshire with a 13-year-old child.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 21 November 1894 · page 1

ing, that he lvlieved the case to Ik* mur »ier; that Pitezel in reality is dead. Mr. Perry said that Holmes has three wives, one in New Hampshire, who is divorced and with whom then* is a 13-years-old

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

The clipping is a single item describing detectives bringing in Holmes and Mrs. Pitezel, detailing Holmes' schooling, staged-body insurance frauds, and his own account of a girl's death and the disposal of her sister's body.

The Evening Herald · 21 November 1894 · page 3

Pna.uiBi mi, n'iv. St. CltyDetiH-tlve Crawford n nl r-'unrrvKor Pony, of ;'.) Fidelity Mat i. il. iirrived ,vcitprda.v wit i tw of tlio in i, -cd llfiInsurtilice awln dlors, Mmtgi'tt. alias Holm, mid Mm. l'ltuzi'l, wlfi or widow of the mlHriinrr mnn on wlitwo policy Slo.lWO wns follwtwl frmiduloiitly. Holmes was raised In Hiirllngton, Vt., and studied In tho schools there until hu was 10 years old. Hu taught school for a time, and nflorwnrtts attended the local college, working In Btunmer time to pay Ills fees. Graduating in Hurllngton ho went to a Michigan college, and thero lnado the aciiualntnnce, an a student, of tho physician who, he alleges, agreed to supply the body used In this last fraud from New York.

See moreSee less

Tho two young men worked during vacations, as Holmes had dono in the cast. About twelve, years ago, ono summer, they were short of funds, nnd Holmes' friend thought of an insur ance swindle, in which a bogus body was to bo used. Tho friend, now a physician, hail his llfo insured for 112,000; the body was procured In Chicago; tho identifica tion with tho Insured doctor was made, and Holmes collected the money. The schomo was repeated several times. On one occasion Holmes insured his own llfo for tSO.OOO. Then lie went to a hotel In Ithode Island, wearing a beard. Ho got a body, took It two miles from tho hotel, cut tho head off, and buried tho rest, lie shaved, went to tho hotel, regis tered under a now name, and asked for Holmes. They said he had gono out, but was stnying at tho hotel. The swindler took the head, charred It in the hotel fur naco and tried to identify it as his own. This particular scheme fell through. An account is given of tho mysterious disappearance of a young womun who was Intimate with Holme. The story was continued by the criminal himself lu his conversation with Crawford. In Chicago, ho suld, whero he wa living with his sec ond wlfe.hc became Intimate with nyoung girl, a typewriter. He furnished apart ments for her, where she was visited by her sister, oldrthnu she. The young girl, infatuated with Holmes, becumo jealous of her sister, and one day, in his absence, brained bur with a stool. "When I came back," continued tho swindler, "I found tho dead body In tho rooms. I took tho corpse, put it in a trunk and sunk it In tho lake. This was a year and a half ugo. The younger sis ter, in danger of arrest for murder, was anxious to escape. She owned some prop erty at Fort Worth amounting to $10,000 Pitezel and 1 took this property off her hands and gave her money to fly the coun

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A damaged clipping recounts Holmes's train journey with a detective, including an alleged bribery and hypnotism offer, followed by his claimed life story involving staged deaths, insurance fraud, and a killing covered up by sinking a body in a lake.

Pawtucket Tribune · 21 November 1894 · page 3

STEEPED IN CRIME.

alias H. H. I‘olmes, Mrs. B. F. Pitzel, the wife or widow of the victisa, with her 16year-old daughter Meda and 1-year-old boy, and Holmes’ wife, have arrived here. the trip, the most important feature which ~as the revelation made to him by Holmes of the story of his life. Holmes sat beside the detective w.'» handecuffs on, and“the train had scarc v ¢inorze | from the Boston depot before the poson - tried to bribe his captor. He offered thic . -tective $5OO if he would allow him to hypuotize him so that he could escape.

See moreSee less

He said he had fre quently hypnotized persons, having ac quired the art from a college professor in the west. He said he could get the money at once from his wife and Mrs. Pitzel. fect, Holmes entered into general conver sation and then told the story of his life. He said he was raised in Burlington, Vt., and so well educated in school there at 13 years he was teaching. For some time afterward he went to college there and later in Detroit. Here he formed the ac quaintance of a medical student who, he said, furnished the body in the New York inquest case. He refused to divulge his name. During vacations they worked on farms to raise their college expenses, but one summer they found themselves with out means, and it was then that the medi cal man suggested the idea of getting a body and beating an insurance company. his life insured forsl2,ooo. They obtained a body in Chicago, took it east, arranged the details of identiflcation and success fully got the money with which they con tinued their studies. He refused to name the company thus swindled. They worked the scheme afterward with suc cess, Holmes continued, obtaining sums for $20,000. He went to a hotel in Rhode Island. At that time he wore a beard. He secured a corpse in Chicago, cut off the head and took the body to a lonely spot not far from the hotel. Then he shaved off his baard, returned to the hotel, asked for Holmes and ngaged a room to wait for him. He | brought the head with him and burie. .. beyond recognition in the fireplace of the hotel. The scheme, however, fell through, the mother of his wife, when she discovered it, threatening to tell the police, and Holmes fled to the west. while living in Chicago, about 18 months ago, he fell in with a typewriter girl and furnished a house on the outskirts, where they lived together. A younger sister came to visit them, and the elder girl be came so jealous of her that in a quarrel one day she struck her over the head with a stool and killed her. To save the wo man with whom he was living, Holmes sald he put the body in a trunk, loaded it with stones and sunk it in the lake. and Pitzel took it off her hau. . and sent her abroad. It was worth, he said, §,- 000, and after getting it in their han .s, they went through I’ ‘xas buying ecarloads of horses on notes on this property. The notes were worthless, and it is for this af fair they are wanted in Fort Worth. To save this property, Holimes said, he a' d Pitzel formed the scheme of swindling tue Fidelity company. He told the detective that for the crimes he has committed he deserves to be hlinself said that at the.present time he is supporting nearly two dozen persons, in cluding the girl muarderess, her mother and imbecile brother, two orphans in Chicago who live in one of his properties, three separate alleged wives and their children, and his own mother and father in Kankakee. He would not give the names of the women. He firmly main tains that Pitzel is alive in San Salvador, and that he will hear from him through the personal column of a certain New York newspaper. Fouse of the Fidelity company, to the effect that Howe, the St. Louis lawyer, was en route to this city with McDonald, in the capaecity of his ‘“‘adviser.” Holmes’ arrest in Boston and the manner in which Mrs. Pitael was decoyed from Burlington. Mrs. Pitzel, he continued, was perfectly innocsnt of any complicity in the whole affair. She had been forced, through ignorance and pressure of various kinds, to sign certain papers, but she told ’erry that she had received only $3500 in cask. She said Holmes had taken $5OOO of the money and putit in a land specula tion in Fort Worth, in which Pitzel was also interested. Holines told Perry that this was true. name of H. M. Pratt. .He added that Perry, B. F. Pitsel and B. T. Lyman are one and the same man. Mr. Perry further said that Holmes is said wo have one wife in New Hampshire, from whom he claims to have been divorced, and by whom he has a child, 18 years old; another in Illinois, whom Mr. Perry himself saw, and by whom there is a 6-year-old child, and the wife who is at present in this city. lleve that in this matter Mrs. Pitzel has been duped and robbed. She acted under instructions, and she has thus far anu will hereafter tell the truth. I believe that her husband was murdered. About the children I have nothing to say.” theory that two had been made away with, he said, in a tone which left doubt of hisopinlon on the subject: ““I hope pot.” every reason to believe that H. H. Holmes is guilty of murdering Minnie B. Will iams and her sister, Annie Williams, the crime having probably been committed in Chicago, and In this crime a man who claimgd when here to be a citizen of Chicago, and calling himself Benton T Lyman, ils an accomplice. Minnic B. Willlams had been working for a type writing concern in Chicago known as Allen & Co. PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 21.—H. Mudgett, Detective Crawford detalled the story of When he saw that his words had no ef This was 12 years ago.. The doector got Ranging From $lO,OOO to $20,000. Once Holines got his own life insured Resuming his story, Holmes said that This girl had property in Te<as, and he Hanged a Dozen Times. Holmes is not lazking (or inoney, as he A telegram was received by President Mr. Perry related in detail the story of Perry said Holmes operated under the In conclusion, Mr. Perry said: “I be When pressed to give his opinion on the A Story From Fort Worth. ForT WoORTH, Tex., Nov. 21.—There is

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Arriving in Philadelphia with Mrs. Pitzel and her children, Holmes, in custody of Detective Crawford, tried to bribe the detective, then described his schooling in Burlington and Detroit, insurance swindles with a medical-student accomplice, a faked death using a stolen corpse's head, and a killing involving a typewriter girl and her sister.

The Providence News · 21 November 1894 · page 8

ey b w 1 ADELPHIA, Now 21, Arch-Con ater H. H. Holmes, accompanied by m. Pitzel and » protty wornan who calls o) Mrs. Bolmgs, arrivedsn this city 1o '?‘, pody of Detective Orawford and polal Agent Perry of the Fidelity Mutual ““hl. Mrs. Pitzel’s 16-year-old gh Meda and her l-year-old boy p® adso with the party. Mrs, Pitzel was FoTy Rervous condition. o Crawford detailed the story of 3" he most bmportant feature which 8 the revelation made to him by Holmes story of his Mife. Holmes sat beside 8 detective with handcufls on, and the M had searcely emergoed from the Boston ) before the prisoner tried to bribe his ) He offored the detective $6OO if ho Vo allow him te hypneotize him so that escape.

See moreSee less

He said he had fre y hypnotized persoms, having ac the art from a college professor in jo west. He said he could get the money from his wife and Mrs. Pitzel. Stery of His Career. R n hoe saw that his words had no ef. Holmes enterad into general conver plon And then told the story of his life. 'sald he was raised in Buarlington, Vt., hd wo well educated in school there at 16 he was teaching. For some time ’ d he went to college there and for in Detroit. Here he formed the ac aalntance of a medical student who, he 4, furnished the body in the New York guest case. Ile refused to divualge his ) During vacations they worked on rms to ralse their college expenses, but e summer they found themselves with it means, and it was then that the medi man suggested the idea of geotting a pdy and beating an Insurance company. This was 12 years ago. The, doctor got B life insured forsl2.ooo, They obtaineda gy in Chicagoe, took it east, arranged m of identification and success iy got the money with which they conSinued their studies, He refused to name ocompany thus swindled. They prked the scheme afterward with suc s, Holmes continued, obtaining sums iging from $lO,OOO to $20,000. oo Holmes got his own life insured 90,000, He went to a hotel in Rhode ‘ At that timne he wore a beard. He ared a corpse in Chicago, cutoff the "Q.d took the body to a lonely spot % far from the hotel. Then he shaved 'his baard, returned to the hotel, asked b pés and engaged a room to wait { He had brought the hecad with ind burned it beyond recognition in ‘ ‘l’pl‘cl' of the hotel, The scheme, , fell through, the mother of his , when she discovered it, threatening gell the police, and Holmes fled to the " Murder Figures In the Case, Resuming his story, Holmes said that e living in Chicago, about 18 months phe fell in with a typewriter girl and .;," a house on the outskirts, where f lived together. A younger sister )to visit them, and the elder girl be -30 80 jealous of her that in a quarrel jday she struck her over the head with 00l and killed her. To save the wo with whom he was living, Holines he put the body in a trunk, loaded it ) stones and sunk it in the lake, Ma girl had property in Texas, and he L Pit: took it off her hands and snt .; . I was worth, he said, $40,- i after getting it in their hands, t through Texas buying carieads i om notes on this property. The \' werthl and it is for this af

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, accompanied by Mrs. Pitzel, her daughter Meda, her 1-year-old boy, and a woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes, arrived in custody of a detective and a special agent, after which Mrs. Holmes disappeared with no trace found.

The Salt Lake Herald · 21 November 1894 · page 1

WHERE THE SWINDLING IDEA WAS FORMED

conspirator H H Holmes accompan ied by Mrs Pitzel and a pretty woman 1 who calls herself Mrs Holmes arrived in this city today in thecustody of Detective Crawford and Special Agent Perry of the Fidelity Mutual Life as sociation Mrs PitzeLs 16yearold daughter Meda and her 1yearold boy were also with the party Mrs Holmes dis appeared soon after her arrival and no clue to her whereabouts could be

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A handcuffed prisoner being escorted by train from Boston offered a detective $500 to let him escape, claimed he could hypnotize people, and, failing to sway the detective, launched into an account of his life.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 21 November 1894 · page 2

most sensational of romances. Holmes sat %eside the detect; t« with handcuffs on. Th« train had scarcely emerged from the Boston depot before the prisoner tried to bribe bis captor, lie offered the detective $.500 if he would allow him to escape. He said he had frequently hypnotised persons, having acquired the art from a college professor in the West. He said he could get the money his wife and Mrs. Pitxel. When he saw his words had no effect he entered into a general conversa tion and told the story ot his life. Holmes said he was raised in Barling

See the clipping

The Press · Stafford Springs, Conn.

The clipping states that H. Holmes fraudulently collected $10,000 from the Fidelity Company, the amount of insurance on the life of H. F. Pitzeil, by passing off a bogus corpse.

The Press · 22 November 1894 · page 3

H. Holmes, who fraudulently collected of the Fidelity Company-fl0,000, being the amount of insurance upon the life of H. F. Pitzeil, a bogus corpse being passed

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

This single item describes a daughter's account of a conversation with Holmes about her father's reported death, then recounts Holmes's interview with President Fouse detailing attorney Howe's involvement in the insurance conspiracy and his claim that Pitzel is in South America.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 22 November 1894 · page 1

MRS. PITZEL WAS EXCITED

be safe, no matter what you hear." The! girl had barely finished making thisstatement when her mother sprang w mi,, iwvniiif uer actus aboutwildly eatchvfmed:, : r.. .- "Suefc lies! Such falsehoods . I have rave never met with as in this affair, nd even you, my ownchilld, have de ceived me heartlessly and mercilessly, - As the mother finished she. oast a. look of scorn on (her daughter's cringing . ngure. - . . . The girl further said that after the death of her father was reported she met Holmes in Boston.

See moreSee less

Holmes said to her; . "1 suppose your father told you what to tmiuc it his death was reported?" To this Meda made an affirmative an swer, whereupon Holmes declared: "Well, that's all right" ." President Fouse's interview with Holmes was mainly directed toward discovering jthe extent to which Howe, the St Louis attorney, Is implicated in the conspiracy to swindle the Insur ance company.-' According to Holmes, Howe was cognizant of the plot almost from its inception. Holmes says that aedgpeth, the St Louis train robber, notrin jail, told him that Howe was a good, nervy man, who could be trusted. Holmes outlined the plot to Howe. Howe -was unwilling to appear as the principal in It He advised that, If it was successful some friend of the family identified ''thecorpse .. first Howe's advice was followed. Of the $10,000 received from the Insurance Company, Howe retained $2,600 for coun sel fees and $400 for expenses. ' Holmes says Pltzel is either in South Amerioa or in. the extreme southern pari of the country and could not have possibly been in' Chicago within the past two weeks, . Holmes asserts that the doctor from whom he claims to have secured, the. body was recently engaged in .a swindling insurance scheme and has suppositlously died, Holmes takes his arrest coolly, and eats well, Mrs. Pltzel is seriously ill irom nervousness. The detectives seem to be sill at Bea. Every energy is being bent toward un earthing Holmes' medical friend.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This damaged clipping fragment mixes disjointed references to an anarchist leader who attempted suicide, bravado shown by someone named Franch, naval vessel figures, and an insurance swindler known as Holmes and Mudgett, without coherent context.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Morning Call · 22 November 1894 · page 1

PITZEL IS ALIVE.

became a leader among the anarchists. rate) §169,907 58 and the Petrel (fourth Twice after capture he attempted suicide. rate; £103,502 78. These fieures afford an Franch displayed the utmost bravado. transactions with him. and that it is im oped here that H. H. Howard, the insur possible for him to be mistaken. When ance swindler known as Holmes and Mud they met Bryan did not know Pitzel was gett, has been here often. On September

See the clipping

In the story →

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A report that Miss Kate Durkee, feared murdered by H. H. Holmes after a property dispute, has reportedly been found alive in Omaha living with her brother and admitting dealings with Holmes over transferred property.

The Morning Call · 22 November 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ONE MORE MURDER. Victims Found Wherever Holmes Was Known.

CHICAGO, Nov. 21.—Following close on the story of the mysterious disappearance of the Williams sisters at the hands of Holmes, the life insurance swindler, comes a third woman victim, namely, Miss Kate Durkee. Miss Durkee had property, and documents representing the property came into the hands of H. H. Holmes by theft. Then the woman mysteriously disappeared and Holmes showed title to the property.

See moreSee less

Miss Durkee was not Miss Williams. She had dark eyes and hair, while Miss Williams was blonde. Just one year ago to-day twenty-five creditors of H. H. Holmes met at the office of George B. Chamberlain and made a desperate effort to find out who and where Miss Durkee was. It was supposed she was an accomplice of Holmes and that the property illegally obtained was being transferred to her name. The creditors therefore wished to reach it, when suddenly Kate Durkee dropped entirely from sight, and, like the Williams sisters, has left no trace behind.

"I believe she was murdered," said Chamberlain to-day. "I believe also that both the Williams girls were murdered."

Mr. Chamberlain is the proprietor of the Lafayette Mercantile Agency and he began an investigation of Holmes' career over a year ago.

Late to-night it is stated that Miss Durkee has not been murdered. She has been found by a reporter of the Inter Ocean in Omaha.

A dispatch from that city to-night says: Miss Kate Durkee lives here with her brother, who is assistant auditor of the Burlington Railroad Company. She expressed surprise when the correspondent called on her and asked concerning her connection with the Holmes family in Chicago, where she visits yearly. She never heard of but one wife. She recently visited Mrs. Holmes in Chicago and made Holmes transfer a piece of property for her. She refused to explain what property this was or give any of the details, but declared that Holmes' Chicago lawyer was familiar with the deal.

Attorney D. Duncombe of Chicago, who was at one time the attorney for Holmes, and who in the course of his business for him had occasion to meet the Miss Kate Durkee who figured in a real-estate transaction in this city in 1892 said to-night:

"Holmes employed me to attend to some business for him, and in the course of the action for which I was retained it became necessary to take the deposition of Miss Kate Durkee. In her evidence she said she was related to the wife of Holmes. It was to this woman that I transferred certain Chicago property."

Mr. Duncombe said he had frequently seen Pitzel in company with Holmes, and that he would know whether the corpse in question was the body of Pitzel, if he saw it.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · and 1 other paper

President Fouz of the Fidelity Life Insurance company reports that a Chicago business man named Bryan claims to have met and had a drink with B. F. Pitzel, the supposed murdered man, less than two weeks ago.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Herald · 22 November 1894 · page 1

By the Associated Press, Philadelphia, Nov. 21. —The Pitzel mystery deepens as time wears on. To day many theories in regard to the mys tery were knocked in the head by tbe announcement tbat 13. F. Pitzel, the supposed murdered man, was seen in Chicago less than two weeks ago. Pres ident Fouzof the Fidelity Life Insurance company said today: "This morning my Chicago represen tative telegraphed me tbat a Mr. Bryan, who is a bueiness man in Chicago, called on him and said that B. F. Pitzel was in tbat city less than two weeke ago.

See moreSee less

Mr. Bryan says be bas known Pitzel for many years, and had frequent business transactions with him, and it is impos sible fot him to be mietaken. When they met, Bryan did not know Pitzel wae euppoeed to be dead, and tbe two greeted each otber cordially and re paired to a near-by ealoon where they bad a drink together. Then tbey sep arated and Bryant saye he doee not know whether Pitzel was to remain in thecity or not. However, our men there and tbe Pinkerton detectives have taken up the clew, and it is my opinion that Pitzel will be produced within a few dayp." President Fcuz called on Mrs. Pitzel

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis · 28 November 1894

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The fragment describes Holmes questioning a daughter about something her father told her in Chicago, while Mrs. Pitzel exclaims she has been deceived even by her own daughter, before the damaged text breaks off mid-sentence.

Evening Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 2

MISS PITZEL TALKING

newspaper. As soon ns sho hod finished tho story, Holmes said to her, "Do you remember what your fatlior told you the aftornoon you wore walking In Chicago?" During Mr. Fame's interview with the daughter Mrs. Pitzel grew excited arid dramatically exclaimed, "They have rail deceived mo—ovon my own daughter.'' Mr. Fouso also had a talk with Mrs. Pitzel. Sho said sho remembered recolv

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A clipping describes a letter from Alice recounting her trip east with Howe and Holmes to identify Pitezel's body, and reports Ex-Assistant District Attorney McDonald's arrival to deny complicity by Howe or himself, calling Howe merely an office boy influenced by Holmes.

Evening Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 2

HARRY HOWARD HOLMES, lng a letter from hor daughtor Alice, the one who assisted in tho identification of Fitzel's body, in which she hail related hor exporlonce while coming east for the purpose of identifying tho body. Alice, In hor letter, stated that Ilowo and Holmes both accompanied her, and the former was very attentive to hor ou tho train. Him also stated that Hnwo and Holmes wore very sociable on the trip oast. Ex-Assistant District Attorney Mc Donald of St. Louis, low portnor of Jcp tha D. Howe, who acted as counsel for Holmes, arrived hero.

See moreSee less

Howo did not make his appearance, but McDonald call od on Police Superintendent Linden and told him that bis partner was on his way here and would probably arrivo today. Tho iinprossion Is, howovor, that Howo is cither now In tho city or near by, and that ho resorted to this device to avoid a night In a coll. MoDonald emphatically denied any complicity In the affair, either by Howe or himself. Tho former, ho added, was meroly an office boy lu his omploy nnd had been inllucncod by Holmes, but when indicted for conspiracy McDonald, ac cording to that lawyer's story, advised him to come to Philadelphia and clear himself, and his advlco was promptly aotod upon. ' J IW

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A St. Louis lawyer surrendered to Philadelphia police over a fraudulent $10,000 insurance claim linked to H. H. Holmes, with his partner insisting he was deceived rather than a conspirator, while an Indianapolis dispatch describes a thank-you letter from Mrs. Pitzel that the insurance company had circulated as advertising.

Evening Star · 22 November 1894 · page 2

MOWE WAS MISLED. It is Not Believed That Me Was a Conspirater With Holines. PHILADELPHIA, Pa.. November 22. Jeptha D. Howe. the young St. Louis law 7or who, in connection with H. H. Holmes, -t charged with defrauding a local Insur ance company out of $10,000, reached Phil adelphia at noon today from Washington, where he stopped over on his way from St. Louis yesterday. He was met at the depot by Marshall F. McDonald of St. Louis, who is the law partner of young Howe's brother, and together they went to the o9bee of Superintendeat of Police Linden, where he surrendered himself, and a conference Is now In progress.

See moreSee less

When seen by a representative of the Associated Press today Lawyer McDonald mid: "This arch-conspirator, H.H. Holmes, or H. M. Morgan, the name he was known by in St. Louis, came to the office while I was absent in Colorado and proposed the ease, saying that Mrs. Pitzel wanted some ons to repeesent her. It was the first case the boy had ever been offered and he jumped right into it with all the ardor and enthusiasm of youth. He did'not wait for Is to return, and the result was that this slick crooA Imposed upon him. My young fltandmay have been indiscreet, but he is no criminal." Superintindent of Police Linden places implicit confidence In what Mr. McDonald says In reference to young Howe, and Is 4d the opition that the latter has been misled by Holmes. lawyer McDonal called on A. 8. L. Shields, the noted criminal lawyer, at the latter's office and asked Mr. Shields to act s counsel for young Howe. The facts of the case were briely stated and Mr. Shields agreed to take charge of the case. Howe will. In all probability. be released on ball. - INDIANAPOLIS, Ind.. November 22. The insurance company which insured and paid the $K000 policy on the life of Pitsel, on September 24, a few days afterward re ceived a letter from Mrs. Pitsel, thanking them -for their promptress and expressing titude of the consideration shown her her children. This Itter was copied and scattered broadcast as an advertise met by the company. The letter Is re produced verbatim, and is preceded by the company's statement that satisfactory dwidenie of Pitsel's death had been secured.

See the clipping

The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

Boston police, after questioning Holmes and Carrie Pitezel, believe B. F. Pitezel is dead and was killed by Holmes rather than having fled after the insurance fraud. A Philadelphia grand jury has indicted Holmes, lawyer Jephtha Howe, and Mrs. Pitezel for conspiracy to defraud the insurance company.

The Oskaloosa Herald · 22 November 1894 · page 2

LOOKS DARK FOR HOLMES

LIT* He Had Insured for 810,000. Boston, Nov. 21.—Mrs. Carrie A. Pitezel, wife af the man whose life was insured for 910,000, was brought here Monday from Burlington, Vt. by Pinkerton men and booked at police headquarters on the charge of conspiracy after the fact, She and Holmes were taken to Philadelphia by Inspector Crawford of that city. The police, after rigid questioning of Holmes and Mrs. Pite zel, incline to the belief that the miss ing man is dead, and that he met his death at the hands of Holmes, Holmes tells a very strange and seemingly improbable story of his doings since the payment of the insurance money, a story that is only partially corroborated by Mrs.

See moreSee less

Pitezel. The police do not think she knew any thing about the swindle until after Holmes had completed it She free ly confessed her part as acces sory after the fact. * She has not seen her husband since he went to Philadelphia a year ago and Holmes has takan three of her chil dren from her and she does not know their whereabouts. The case deepens and murder is likely to be charged against Holmes, who acknowledged he had duped Mrs. Pitezel as to the whereabouts of her husband and only gave her SSOO of the insurance money. Philadelphia, Nov.;2l.—The grand jury found a true bill against Herman Mudget, alias H. H. Holmes, now a prisoner in Boston; Jephtha B. Howe, the St Louis lawyer who collected the insurance money on B. F. Pitezel’s policy for the latter’s widow, and the widow herself. The indictment reads for “conspiracy to cheat and defraud.”

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

An Inter Ocean reporter in Omaha found Miss Kate Durkee alive and living with her brother, though scrambled OCR text also includes Mr. Chamberlain's claims about Holmes and murdered Williams sisters.

The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 2

hind "I believe she was murdered," said Mr. Chamberlain in speaking of the matter to this statement on the ztrenKth, not of pub of the matter.' Mr. Chamberlain, who is proprietor of the Lafayette Mercantile Agency, bean his Investigation of Holmes a year ago last Saturday-. . Mis Darkee iot Murdered. CHICAGO. Nov. 21. Miss Durkee has not been murdered. She has been found by, a fepresentatlve of the Inter Ocean in Omaha. A dispatch from that cityto-night says: In an elegant residence, at No. 4020 Dur has lived here six years with her brother, who is assistant auditor of the Burlington Itailroad Company.

See moreSee less

She expressed surprise "when the correspondent of the Inter Ocean called on her and asked concerning her con of his trouble. She said she was on inti saw little of - Holmes during these visits. She never heard of but one wife. She re had Holmej transfer a piece of property for her. She refused to explain what property this was or give any of the details, apday. "I believe also that both of the Wil liams sisters were murdered, and I make lished reports, but what I know personally 'tfette street, in Omaha, lives Miss Kate Dur kee, a handsome blonde of about thirty. She nection with Holmes.- She had not heard mate terms with the Holmes family In Chi cago, where she visits yearly, though she cently visited Mrs. Holmes in Chicago, and

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Attorney D. T. Duncombe recounts representing Holmes in a lawsuit involving a property transfer to Kate Durkee, describing a deposition trip to Omaha and noting he could identify Pitzel's body if he saw it.

The Indianapolis Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 2

she declared that Holmes's Chicago lawyer wai familiar with the deal." Attorney D. T. Duncombe, of Chicago, vas at one time the attorney for H. 11. Holmes, and In the course of his business for him, had occasion to meet the Miss Kate Durkee who figured in a real estate transaction In this city in 1S92. Mr. Dun him and in the course of the action for "which I was retained it became necessary to take the deposition of Miss Kate Dur represented the tther side, wanted to make a personal examination, so Holmes and I accompanied Mi.

See moreSee less

Musgrove to Omaha, where we met Miss Durkee at the office of the commissioner .who had been appointed to take the evidence. In her evidence she Raid that she was related to the wife of Holmes. It was to this woman that a trans fer of. certain property, near the corner of Thirtyninth and Cottage-grove avenue, was made. The suit brought by. the firm, with which Mr. Musgrove is connected, was on behalf of John F. Plummer & Co.. wholesale druggists, who sought to have the transfer et aside in favor of a mortgage that they Mr. Duncombe said that he had 'frequently eeen Pitzel in company with Holmes, and that he would know whether the corpse In question was the body of Pitzel if he 6aw It. combe said of his ex-cllent: "Holmes em ployed me to attend to some business for kee. I was willing to send the interroga tions on to Omaha, but Mr. Musgrove, who

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The clipping describes a mortgage signed by Kate Durkee that was recalled for correction and never returned, prompting suspicion that Holmes's referenced associates were fictitious, with creditors questioning him under shorthand record.

Rock Island Argus · 22 November 1894 · page 4

ONE MORE VICTIM.

HOLMES "SPOUTS" A MORTGAGE. Be Gets It for Correction and It Kevet Materialize. Again TltxeL. "Kate Durkee" was the name signed to a mortgage on some real estate of consid erablo value. The mortgage was turned over to Mr. Chamborlain for the benefit of creditors. So far, all seemed fair, but a clerical error was found in the document lielieved to have been purposely inserted and Holmes asked to have it returned for correction. The mortgage was returned and never seen again. At this time the Misses Williams had disappeared, and when a search for the giver of the mort gage ff ilod to disclose any such person the creditors became suspicious, and at the second meeting above referred to Holmes was questioned and his answers taken down in shorthand.

See moreSee less

In answer to suspicions expressed bv those present that these people were myths. Holmes gave references. As to Minnie illiams ho referred to Isaac It. Hltt, Isaac K. Hitt, Jr., and Willis B. Hitt. Also to "a party at 150 Lake street. who is manager of the Revere Rubber company." As to Kate Durfeo he gave four references to people whose names cannot now be disclosed. Investigation showed that these people had met a dork woman, "who had been introduced as Miss Kate Durfec," but did not know her personally. Benjamin F. FitzcL who, according to Holmes confession, was a party to the conspiracy to defraud the Fidelity Mutual

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The clipping reports that Benjamin F. Fitzcl, named in Holmes's confession as party to a conspiracy to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Insurance company of Philadelphia, is known to the Pinkerton Detective agency and described in their records, though the description itself is cut off.

Rock Island Argus · 22 November 1894 · page 4

HOLMES "SPOUTS" A MORTGAGE.

Benjamin F. FitzcL who, according to Holmes confession, was a party to the conspiracy to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Insurance company, of Philadelphia, is well known to the Pinkerton Detective agency and in their records is described as

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Jephta D. Howe, accused with H. H. Holmes of swindling an insurance company, arrived in Philadelphia with Marshal McDonald and surrendered to Police Chief Linden, who, along with McDonald, believes Howe was merely deceived by Holmes, and a lawyer named Shields has been retained for his likely release on bail.

Abendblatt · 22 November 1894 · page 1

Philadelphia, 22. Nov. Jcphta D. Howe, der junge St. Louiser Advokat, welcher in Verbindung mit H. H. Holmes beschuldigt ist, eine hiesige Ver sicherungsgesellschaft um Plo,ooo beschwin delt zu haben, ist heute Mittag von Wash ington, wo er sich aus der Reise von St. Louis gestern ausgehalten hatte, hier angc kommen. Er wurde am Bahnhofe von Marshal F. McDonald von St. Louis, dem Geschäststheilhaber von Howe's Bruder, empfangen und Beide begaben sich darauf zum Polizeiches Linden, dem sie sich überlieferten. Der Advokat McDonald äußerte sich heute einem Berichterstatter der assoc. Presse gegenüber folgendermaßen: „Die ser Erzverschreicr 3k.

See moreSee less

H. Holmes, oder H. M. Morgan, unter welchem Namen er in St. Louis bekannt war, kam in mein Bureau, während ich in Colorado war, und sagte, daß Frau Pitgcl Jemanden als ihren Vertreter wünsche. Es war der erste Fall, den der junge Mann hatte, der griff mit beiden Händen danach. „Er wartete nicht aus meine Rückkehr, und die Folge war, daß er von dem schlauen Betrüger hintergangen wurde. Mein jun ger Freund mag unklug gehandelt haben, aber ein Verbrecher ist er nicht." Der Polizeiches Linden schenkt den Aus sagen McDonald's über den jungen Howe vollen Glauben und ist der Ansicht, daß derselbe von Holmes getäuscht wurde. Der Advokat McDonald hat den bekann ten Criminaladvokcuen A. S. L. Shields als Anwalt für den jungen Howe gewon nen; der letztere wird wahrscheinlich gegen Bürgschaft aus der Haft entlassen werden.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The clipping reports that a man who saw Ryan learned he could not locate Pitezel after the two parted ways leaving a saloon, and notes a Pinkerton agency representative is working on a clue that may lead to finding Pitezel soon.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 1

man subsequently saw Ryan, and the; latter declared his inability to locate j Pitezel. the two having imrted after lcav ing the saloon. The Pinkerton agency j has a representative now at work upon a j clue, and 1 should not Iksurprised if Pitezel is found in a few days.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes is suspected in the mysterious disappearance of Kate Durkee, whose mortgage he allegedly obtained and never returned, with a creditors' agent believing she was murdered.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 1

STILL ANOTHER MISSING.

Chicago, Nov. 21.—H. H. Holmes, the insurance swindler, is charged with being the cause of the mysterious disappearance of a third woman during his operations in Chicago. • That person is Miss Kate Durkee. Site is said to have hud con siderable property. A year ago the credi tors of Holmes made a desperate effort to find out who and where Miss Durkee was. It was supposed tit the time that site was tin accomplice of Holmes and that the property illegally obtained was being transferred in her name. Suddenly Kate Durkee dropped from sight and like the Williams’ sisters, left no trace behind.

See moreSee less

George B. Chamberlain, proprietor of the Mercantile Agency, who represents tt number of Holmes’ creditors, believes that Miss Durkee was murdered. Kate Durkee was the name signed to a inert gige on some real estate of considerable value. The mortgage was turned over to Chamberlain for the benefit of the credi tors. Shortly after the mortgage was given to Holmes at, his request, to have a clerical error corrected, and the document was never returned. At tliis time the Misses Williams disap peared, and a search for the giver of the mortgage failed to disclose any stteii per son, although Holmes’ had given several references. Investigation showed that these people met a dark woman who was introdlteed as Miss Kate Durkee. but they tlid not know her personally.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The passage references B. F. Pitzel in connection with a $10,000 matter, though the text is cut off before details are given. This appears to allude to the insurance fraud scheme central to the Holmes case.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 22 November 1894 · page 2

the seventh or eighth ear much easier than a man can signal from the first car | by a Ik-11 l-ope. The C. P. R. Company’s | ears are furnished with the compressed air signals. In the instruction car is n ! mode! of the company's ear heating appa ratus which is attached to all their ears. The steam is taken from the locomotive and is carried along beneath the ears in a pipe, it is arranged so that all the coaches are heated uniformly. The C. P. R. have in their employ a large corps of men whom they aninstructing in the use of these improvements free of cha-ge.

See moreSee less

The ear is kept going all the year. Mayor Baxter laid a caller, Monday, who came on a rather unusual errand, al though that is nothing new for the mayor, who is the target of every crank ami odd character in the city. This caller i was no crank, however, hut a straightfor ward man of business from over the bor I der—Montreal. The proposition that he brought with him was that Portland i should have a winter carnival in January, somewhat similar to the "times” they have in Montreal and Quebec. His propo sition is to build an ice palace and to have all of the other sports, sleighing carnivals, snowshoc races, tolxigganing matches, etc., that our Canadian cousins revel in every winter.—Right here it may lxre marked that this gentleman did not tiring the cold wave that struck town yesterday. It only hapix-ned so, very opportunely for his scheme, as it set everyone thinking of the cold, cold winter s(xm to lxlien-. The Montrealer has lx-en around among every two weeks. the railroad and steamboat men, and they have till expressed themselves favorably as to his project. It is not understood that quoted a week a£o. the city will lxcalled upon to do anything more than lend moral support to the en terprise, but a suliseription will lxstarted among railroads and steamboat lines and business houses, it will take about $8000 to make the thing go off in first elass last week. shape, if everything is done in gixxl style so that people shall come from a distance to see it. every cent expended will some liack in increase of travel and consequent business. The projector has gone away but will be lxick in a short time to perfect his Arrangements.—Portland Argus. MRS. M. M. YEAUY. j*!1 Springfield. Green County, Mo. wmmmniiiii life insurance swindle at Philadelphia, was arrested at Terre Haute, Ind.. on October lS'.Kj. for attempting t » pass for ged checks under the name of Robert Jones. After arrest he admitted that his name was B. F. Pitzel. He remained in jail several weeks, when H. H. Holmes, who is under arrest in the East, came

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

President Fouse says he believes a man other than Pitzel was murdered, describes efforts by Pinkerton agents to trace a clue involving a man named Ryan, and recounts Pitzel's daughter Meda's claim that her father predicted reports of his death would be false and her tense exchange with her mother and prior conversation with Holmes.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Portland Daily Press · 22 November 1894 · page 1

TOLD HIS DAUGHTER

Lawyer Howe is^ expected to arrive his evening, from 3t .Louis, with At torney McDonald, to answer to a charge of conspiracy. President Fouse states he expects to reoover a portion at least of the 410,000 fraudulently seoured (from the associa tion “We procured an attachment in St.Louis against Howe,” he added, “to recover $2200 ofjthe money received.” As Holmes maintains the three missing Pitzel childrenjare with their father, the discovery of the supposed viotim will probably clear up the mystery regarding the offspring. President Fouse had an interview this afternoon with Mrs.Pitzel.

See moreSee less

The latter’s 16-year-old daughter Meda, was in the cell, and the talk had not proceeded far when the girl declared she believed her father to be alive. The daughter told of a conversation she had with her father in Chicago, in August last, dur ing which Pitzel said: “My daughter, if at any time you hear I am dead, or that anything very serious has happened to me, do not,.believe it. I will be safe, no matter what you hear.” The girl had barely finished making this statement when her mother sprang to her feet, threw her arms about wildy, and exclaimed: “Suoh lies, such fase hoods I never met with as in this affair. Even you, my own child, de ceived me heartlessly,and mercilessly. As the mother finished, she cast a look of scorn on her daughter’s cringing figure. The gi rl further said, that after the death of her father was reported she met Bolmes in Boston, and Holmes said to her “I suppose your father told you what to thinkjif his death was report ed? To this Meda made an affirmative reply. Whereupon ;Holmes declared: “Hell, that’s all right.” President Fouse secured additional in e X!_mkiah de4 to show that Howe was in league with Holmes. Mr. Fouse afterwards held a long conversation with Holmes.

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

This damaged OCR clipping jumbles disconnected fragments—mediation talks, officials meeting, a W.C.T.U. session ending, a changed dome top, and a dialogue about what someone's father said—too corrupted to summarize coherently.

The Helena Independent · 22 November 1894 · page 1

MYSTERY DEEPER AS TIME PASSES

her accept American mediation, and tha her accept American mediation, and Ls at Intervals of about fifteen see Shs omoddmared It. Attorney-General Olney, Secretary oada. The dome-like top had disap The Workers in the W. C. T. U. Close Their Lamont and Secretary Smith held a peared and been replaced by a fiat top As soon as she had lAnshed the story Holmes said to her: "Do you remember what your father told you the afternoon

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

The damaged clipping reports creditors' fruitless search a year ago for a missing woman feared murdered, identifies Holmes as a man named Herman W. Mudgett whose wife gave an interview, and notes B. F. Pitezel's past troubles in St. Joseph.

The Helena Independent · 22 November 1894 · page 1

MYSTERY DEEPER AS TIME PASSES

ie thy thef. i lm dmad and hair. while MIes W=Ili-es wa blonde. A year ago to-day twents4A creditors of H. ]. Holmes met at ofloe of George B. Chamberln made a desperate ebrt to And out w and where Miss Durkee was. It supposed she was an secom Holmes and that the property obtained was being traastrred to name. The creditors wished to it. Suddenly ate Durbee entirely from ight. and ike the lame slsters has left no trace bLehid. "I believe also that both the lme girls were murdered."

See moreSee less

Mr. berlin, proprietor of the Lafayette cantile agency, began an tnvestiga of Holmes a year ago. Tliton. N. Y., Nov. 21.-The Identi of H. H. Howard, alla Holmes, been clearly establised here as a tive of this state, Herman W. Mu His wife, in an Interview during she was first made aequalnted with true cbhracter of her bhbaed, ilv much interesting Information lag his early life. She le l heng quietly with her fifteen year old and Is supporting herself by dress mak Ing. She lost all trace of the man he visited her in 1888 and told her h was going to Chicago on business ant he came to her home about two wee ago. He remained a few hours and le for Boston, promising to come agat soon. St. Joseph, Mo., Nov. t1.-B. F. Pit sel. who Is the central figure In th Philadelphia Insurance swindle, f which offence H. H. Holmes Is undde arrest, is a former resident of this city and left here about three years ago an der a cloud. He left numerous unpai bills.

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes is being claimed as a criminal in many Northern states, including a story that his scheme of buying a body to pass off as a well-insured man's corpse was originally suggested by Hedgepeth, who was cheated out of his share.

The News & Observer · 22 November 1894 · page 1

In Limbo at Last

sociation by the übiquitous H. H. Holmes. Holmes is being claimed as a I criminal in nearly every State in ihe| North, and one of the stories published j is that Holmes’ plan of purchasiug a j body and palming it off as the corpse of ! a well-insured man was originally sug-1 gested by Hedgepeth, who was cheated out of his share of the proceeds.

See the clipping

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

This damaged clipping jumbles an account of a young man misled into representing a client for a deceptive figure with unrelated items about Xicak Indians near New Mexico's border and a postmaster's return from a trip to Stein's pass and the Solomon valley.

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 22 November 1894 · page 1

ME known in St. Lonis, came to my office while I was absent in Colorado and said that a Mrs. Pitzel wanted someone to represent her. It was the first case the boy had ever been offered and he jumped right into it with all the ardor and en us to return and the result was that this slick crook imposed upon him. My young friend may have been indiscreet but he is no criminal." Superintendent of Police Linilley is of the opinion that Howe was misled by Holmes. XICAK INDIANS AT LARGE.

See moreSee less

Deplorable Condition of the People on the Southwestern Border of thusiasm of youth. He did not wait for Postmaster Gable and wife retorned yesterday trera a trip to Stein's pasa and and vicinity, iu the Solomon valley, where they spent several days with Co!. J. T. MoWbirt, Mrs. Gable's father. Mr. New Mexico.

See the clipping

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

This damaged clipping fragments a street fight in which a man named Charles Boulter was knocked down while intervening, alongside disjointed references to an insurance fraud case and other unclear names and events.

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 22 November 1894 · page 1

HIS FIRST CASE.

ively, fought in the street early to-day. Charles Boulter attempted to separate them. They knocked him down and he and sister to Bill and Jim Cook, is in connection with H. H. Holmes, is charged Muskogee. It is believed she is here to with defrauding a local insurance com plan a release for Wade Chamblee, the pany out of $10,000, reached this oity to

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The clipping reports that Mrs. Myrtle Holmes refused to discuss her husband H. B. Holmes, while Miss Kate Dirkee, found living in Omaha, denied any wrongdoing and described a property transfer involving Holmes and his Chicago lawyers.

The Evening World · 22 November 1894 · page 1

HOLMES DIDN'T KILL HER. Miss Knte Dlrkee Fonnd Alive and Well In Omaha. (Br Aaaoclatad Praaa ) CHICAGO, Nov: 22. Mrs. Myrtle Holmes, the wife of H, B. Holmes, who resides at Wllmette, positively refuses to talk about her husband. She said: "I will not talk at all, and the next news paper man who comes here will get a pall of hot water thrown over him." A despatch from Omaha says: "In an elegant residence at 4320 Burdette street, Omaha, lives Miss Kate Dlrkee, whom Holmes was suspected of having run away with, a handsome blonde ot about thirty.

See moreSee less

8he lives with her brother, who Is assistant auditor of the Burlington Railroad Company. She had not heard of Holmes's trouble. She was on Inti mate terms with the Holmes family In Chicago, she said, but had seen little of Holmes. She said she never heard of his having but one wife. She said she recently visited Mrs. Holmes in Chicago, and hid Holmes transfer a piece of property for her, but refused to explain what property this waa or give any of the details. She declared that Holmes's Chicago lawyer was familiar with the deal. Attorney D. T, Duncombe, of Chicago, was at one time the attorney for H. B. Holmes, and met Miss Kate Dlrkee In a real estate transaction In this city in 1892. Duncombe says that he. Lawyer Musgrave, who represents the other side, and Holmes went to Omaha, where they met Miss Dlrkee. In her evidence before a commissioner she said that she was related to Holmes's wife. It was to this woman that a transfer of certain prop erty, near the corner of Thirty-ninth street and Cottage Grove avenue, was made. Musgrave was counsel for John E. Plummer & Co., wholesale druggists, who sought to have the transfer set aslds in favor ot a mortgage tbat they had been holding without having It re corded. Duncombe said that ha had frequently seen PitKl In company with Holmes, and that he would know whether the corpse In question was the body ot Pltsel If he saw It. 11 w The Embriio Is Up. (By Aaaoclatal Praaa.) - WASHINGTON. No. Too Dtvartniaat ot flat baa rMlra4 th Helal notlca from United fttaaW bUntatar BiaJtr. at Oooasbaiaa. ot lha yatuttlw of (ha deeraa bw.atalr reblbttln k Importation Into Denmark ot Americas cattle tal eVaaaad baef. CT4wyw Vlttnl (5wwa 6c, V ' I ' t

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A Chicago report describes Kate Durkee, another woman believed defrauded and possibly murdered by H. H. Holmes, while a Philadelphia report recounts Pitzel family statements suggesting Pitzel's reported death may be faked and questioning Howe's claimed unfamiliarity with Holmes.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Pawtucket Tribune · 22 November 1894 · page 1

IS PITZEL STILL ALIVE?

CHICAGO, Nov, 2 —rollowing close on the story of the mysterions disappearance, of the Williams sisters at rhe hands of Holmes, comes a third woman vietim, nainely, Miss Kate Durkee. Again it is the gquestion: “Where is she?” and again she answer, “Probably murdered.” Az: all evenis, Kate Durkee had prop erty. The documents representing the property came into the hands of H. H. Holmes by theftt The woman mysteriously dicappeared and Holines showed the title to the property. Who ever Miss Durkee was, she was not Miss Williams =he was of dark complexion, dark oves ana hair, while Miss Williams was a blonde.

See moreSee less

One vear ago yesterday 25 creditors of “H. H. Holmes” met at the office of George B. Chamberlin and made a desper ate effort to find out who and where Miss Purkee was. It was supposed at that time that she was an accomplice of Holmes’ and that property illegally obtained was being transferred inte her name, and the ereditors wished to reach it. Suddenly Kate Durkee dropped out of sight, and, like the Williams sisiers, has left no trace behind. “] believe she was mmurdered,” said Mr. Chamberlin in speaking of the matter yesterday. “I believe alsothat both of the Williams sisters were murdered, and 1 make this statement on the strength, not of published reports, but what I know per sonally of the matter.” Mr. Chamberlin, who is proprietor of the Lafeyette Mercantile agency, began his Investigation of Holmes a year ago. PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 23 President Fouse called on Mrs. Pitzel and her daugh ter at the Central station yesterday and received valuable information from the daughter in reference to her father. The danghter said that she remembered while walking with her father one Sunday after noon in Chicago, the latter had said to her: “If you hear through the news papers, or in any other way, that I have been found dead, do not believe it. 1 will be all right.” Later, while in Boston, she read the story of her father s death in an afternoon newspaper. As soon as she had flnished the story Holmes said to her: “Do you remember what your father told you the afternoon you were walking in Chicago?”’ Daring Mr. Fouse's interviey with the daughter, Mrs. Pitzel grew excited and dramatically exclaimed: “They have all deceived me, even my own daughter!” Mr. Fous: also had a talk with Mrs. Pitzel. She said she remembered receiv ing a letter from her daughter Alice, the one who assisted In the identification of Pitzel’'s body, in which she had related her experience while coming east for the purpose o. identifying the body. Aliee, in her letter, stated that Howe and Holmes | both accompanied her, and that the former was very attentive to her on the train. She also siatod that Howe and Holmes were very sociable on the trip east. This sets at rest the claim of Howe that he never met Holmes until introduced to him by President Fouse on his arrival in this city. . i s Is Pitzei Alive?

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

Holmes, wife of H. H. Holmes, told a reporter she would not discuss her husband's affairs and threatened to throw hot water on the next newspaperman who came to her.

San Antonio Daily Light · 22 November 1894 · page 4

Holmes, the wife of H. H. Holmes, positively refused to discuss her husbands any way. She said last night: “I will not talk at all and the next newspaper man who comes here will get a pail of hot water thrown over him.’,

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The article reports that investigators and acquaintances suspect H. H. Holmes murdered Minnie Williams and her sister for their Texas property, describes a cellar vault and elevator at his building, notes forged trust-deed dealings involving Col. Belknap and D. E. Fisk, and mentions Minnie Williams' unopened trunk held by Wells, Fargo Express and Holmes' apparent double life with a wife and children.

San Antonio Daily Light · 22 November 1894 · page 4

HOLMES AND MISS WILLIAMS.

e Chicago, 111., Nov. 22.-—Mystery f still surrounds the Chicago career t of H. H. Holmes. The sleuths of • the land are at their wits’ ends to f discover just what he did after he - arrived in this city. Holmes’best 0 friends are Inclined to think him - apt to be guilty of murder which 1 would serve well his own ends. 1 His confession of the crimes of his ' blackened life Is looked upon by his intimate friends as a cleverly • planned ruse to mislead the officers r of the law, especially as to the ' whereabouts of Minnie Williams.

See moreSee less

• With herold neighbors,about 63rd • and Wallace streets state place, ’ the belief prevails that she and her > sister were murdered by Holmes i or his accomplices for the sake of their Texas property. A thorough . search has failed to reveal the . slightest clue, since the time when Holmes went to Texas and claimed to improve the Fort Worth lands left to Minnie by her uncle. “There is a mud floor in this basement,” said E. D. Davis, the jeweler, last night, “and no one will ever know all its secrets until it is dug up from end to end. Ido not know anything, but I believe that mystery of the dis appearance of Miss Williams and her sister might be solved by dig ging in this cellar. Holmes had a vault in his room, whose closed door would stifile any cries, and an elevator from his floor to the cel lar, which he could operate alone, i made it easy for him to convey the ' evidence of his crime.” The mysi tery of the disappearance of Miss ( Williams is complicated by a sup posed connection she may have had as an accomplice in the carry ing out of Holmes’ scheme to make ( money. Holmes confessed in ’ writing that he had forged the * trust deed from Col. Belknap, his < wife’s grand uncle, to D. E. Fisk, * as trustee, and those who investi gated the case surmised that Mary’ Lelly, the notary public who pro tended to have Belknap’s acknowl8 edgement, and Minnie R. Williams c were one and the same. Holmes’ ' confession of the crime and the re payment of all sums due, settled that case, but left the Belknap property in Wittman still standing ® of record in the name of Minnie J Williams. Willis M. Hitt is now , foreclosing a trust deed on that 1 property in w’hich Minnie Williams * is grantor. Minnie Williams’ * trunk is still held unopened by the Wells, Fargo Express company. It came here July 7th, 1893, ad- . dressed to Miss Nannie Wil liams, care of Mr. H. Gordon, 1220 Wrightwood avenue, Chicago. ’ The way bill reads from Midlo- > thian, Texas. It was evident that ‘ Holmes was leading a double life, in fact, at times, it might be said j, he was leading a quadruple life. He had a wife and three children at Willamette and built a fine home. In the meantime Holmes, j Minnie Williams and Pltzell had j moved to a house on Dearborn t avenue. Suddenly Holmes blos somed out as he had laid hand on “ considerable money and hired apartments at the hotel. I learned from the clerk of the hotel that the party had registered as Holmes and wife. The clerk said Miss Williams had told him Pitzell was her brother. We found while Min nie was living at the Southside hotel she had been attended by a doctor, who had never been paid for his services. I managed to get the bill put into my hands, for collection, and in the guise of a collector, went to Holmes. He in troduced me to Minnie Williams, saying: ‘This is Mrs. Holmes.’ The woman was of medium height, with a well developed figure, big brown eyes, light hair and I a baby face. I managed to col- |> lect the bill. The next time I B saw Holmes was in the office of a „ certain insurance company where « ho had come as Hiram Campbell 1 to receive the amount of his in surance money. He recognized a me as the supposed collector and c was directly uncomfortable. He ® was detained there while I went c over to the Plaza Hotel and called c on Minnie Williams. I secured i from her a complete admission of e the fraudulent character of the fire I and also secured the insurance i papers. When this was done my t work was at an end. I had no furr ther Interest in the case and 1 don’t * know what became of the o utflt. a Those people in Englewood who „ knew Holmes and the Will lams girl can tell enough stories to fl 11 a book.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

An insurance company official reports that a Chicago businessman named Bryan claims to have met and had drinks with B.F. Pitzel less than two weeks ago, contradicting reports of his murder. The daughter of Pitzel also recalls her father's cryptic warning not to believe reports of his death, while Mrs. Pitzel expresses feeling deceived by everyone including her own daughter.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Salt Lake Herald · 22 November 1894 · page 2

THE PLOT THICKENS

gether Then they separated and I L Bryan says he does not know whether I Pitzel was to remain in the city or ciy Pinkerton I t not However our men there and the detectives have taken I up The clew and i is my opinion that Pit

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Dateline reports Holmes's wife, calling him Herman W. Mudgett, describes their marriage and his schooling and medical studies, while a Philadelphia dispatch says insurance official Fouse received word that B. F. Pitzel, thought murdered, was seen alive in Chicago, and recounts Pitzel's daughter's and wife's statements.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 22 November 1894 · page 3

PITZEL PROBABLY NOT DEAD.

frtW. N Y., Nov. 2L—The identitv of 0. H. Hoaard. aha* Holme*, has been es«rir e»ta lulled here «.» a nativof tb.« g&t. Herman W. KttdjfStl. Hi* wife, in gj; lutfrv.ew dirtng which *be waa frst made acquainted with the true dttuvwr of Her Husband, give* much teiMssiiog information regarding his m r<i lie. bbe i* living here with ber 15-year-old son, and is support.ne herself by dressmaking, fine gcyssbe married Mudgett in London, this #a;e. about sixteen years ago. and thai for ttitfte he taujrht school in GUmanton and Alum.

See moreSee less

Alter ward be atudied raedK .rt at iiirlington, Yt., and later Michigan university, during wfiich time she resided wltb her Ittfeer at London. She finally ]o>n«d him Aon Art/or, but returned to Giimauton. TUen sbe lost ait trace of the man alter he Visited her in I8&J and to:d h?r he wa* gon.f to Cincago on business, until he came to her home about two week* ago. H* remained only a few hours, when he tyt for i> >*ton, promising to come aga.n gpori. piiiijiPELPHU, Nov. 2L —Tba Pitxel ■jrsterv deej»en» as time wear* on. Today ■any theorie* in regard to the mystery were knocked in the head by tha an aaunrftuent that 15. F. Pitxei, the *up pose-1 murdered man, was seen in Chicago lass than two weeks ago. President Fouxe, #f tbe Fidelity Life Insurance Company, said today: ••This morning mv Chicago repr—nta tivs telegraphed ma that a Mr. Bryan, •ho is a business man in Chicago, called on h'm and said B. F. Pitxel in in that mr lest than two weeks ago. Mr. Bryan Hii a* has Known Petzel (or many years ard had trequaftt business transactions «ith him, and that it is impossible for blai to be mistaken. When they met Krjran did not know Pitxel was supposed to be dead, and the two greeted each other gardiallr and repaired to a near-by saloon, where they had a drink together. Then tiisv separated, and Bryan say* ha doea got know whether Pitc»l was to remain in the city or not. However, our men there and the Pinkerton detectives have taken aptbeciew, and it ia my opioion that Pit srl will be produced wituin a few day*." President Fouie called on Mrs. Pi tee! sj:>l her daughter at the Central atation today, and received valuable Information from the daughter In reference to her father. The daughter said she remem bered. while walking with her father one Sunday, that the latter had amid to her: "If you ever hear throngh the newspapers or any other way that 1 have Deen found de&d, do not believe it. I will be all right." Later on, while in Boston, she read the story of her father's death in a Bssspaper. As soon a* aha had finished the story Holme* said to her: "Do you remember what your father told you the afternoon you were walking in Chicago?" During Mr. Fouce's interview with the daughter Mrs. I'itzel grew exCited and exclaimed: "They have all deceived me, even my own daughter." Mrs. I'itzel aaid she remembered receiving • letter from her daughter Alice, in which •he related her experience while coming East for the purpose of identifying her father's body. Alice stated that Howe and Holiues accompanied her, and both vsre sociable with each oiher on the trip E**t. This sets at rest the claim of Howe that he never met Holmes until intro duced to him by President Fouse on his arrival in this city. l*t>;AHAroiis, NOT. 2L—lt developed here today that 11. H. Howard, ttie in surance swindler known as Holmes and has been her* often. On Hspteinlier 24 he brought ft young ( g>rl with him, whose name he wrote on the register of the hotel as Etta I'iuel, of St. Loais. Howard explained to tbe clerks thai she was the daughter of an old friend of his who had just died, and he was taking her home. T&e cierk savs that he Relieves that he has seen the grl on the street since the time she * supp'>f«sl to have left. She was •bout 13 years old. Four WORTH, Te*., Nor. 21.—There is • avery reason to believe that H. H. Holmes, who went by the name of' O. C. I'ratt in Fort Worth, is guilty of murdering Minnie K. Williams and her sister Anna, the crime having probably been committed in Chicago, and that In this crime a man •ho claimed when here to i»e a citisen of Chicago and ca.ied himself Benton T. Ly man, is an accotnp.ioe. Some tune in February he came here from Chicago and placed on record a deed from one Bond to Lyman, for lot) feet front ou Rusk and Second streets. Bond got title by a deed from Minnie R. Williams, exeei ed before a notary wlice name was said to l>e Holmes (in this property Lyman began the erection of a three-story building. Ly man had so.d one lot to a F >rt Worth Iran who, tearing his title might t>e Clou .e J. !<egan to investigate. He found that Mi-.nie R. Williams wrote late in Wi to her a ster. Miss Anna W i tsams. of Midlothian, Ui., to come to Chicago; that she *as going to be married and go to Europe. No word ever came from •nherof tie sisters. Minnie R. Williams byai.i teft half a block of property in the he.irt oi Fort Worth, vaiue<t ai WO. ati-i a mria v.dued at fli.OiW. ihis prot e t alienated, osiensib.y be >. Wii.isms. A detective has f>een recei :i se-i: t • and the gir.s, but no tra e Can be discovered. *'*»; N r. Jl.- Tollowlng close on thr *t. ;h* tuysienous diaaj jearance of ttie W %?tis sisters at the bands of H •s, ;..e 1. e insurance swindler, comes a third ■< u victim, namely. Miss Kate I'nrke ■ n Durkee had property. Tbe decu , t representing the propertv eaaie into tfie hauls of 1L 11. R-'lmes :>,* thetu The woman mys b s t-u-ed, and Holmes showed titis to t e proiiarty. Mias Durkee waa not M-a \\ i Sha had dark eyes and tair w Widiams was a blonde. A ear t twe .ly-hve c red iters of I'-. 11. H ' rues met at the office of tieorge b. ( i: L. er.in and made a desperate ef fort to f, i out who and where Miss I'urkee w-s. It was su| jx*se i that she •as an a .ice of Holmee; that the Jt : erirhad <— n i. ec* iy obtained, and nnr u m-:errcd to her name. The credit.-rs wished to tea«°h it. Sudden.y k »te » r-opi ed entirely from sight. • «•!, . *«? i W tiiiams sisters, has le!t no t-ao* . | "I she aas mur <ered," » t Cbar.iberiin today. "! believe, •<«r\ierr : ' Mr. Chtmter in, proprietor •f the { a ivvtte Mercantile Agency, begad •a inv» -i.gat ii of Ho.roes a year ago. tt.» Williams girls were

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A badly OCR-damaged clipping fragment states that something was produced and shown to a property, noting that Miss Durkee had dark eyes while Williams was a blonde.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 22 November 1894 · page 3

b s t-u-ed, and Holmes showed titis to t e proiiarty. Mias Durkee waa not M-a \\ i Sha had dark eyes and tair w Widiams was a blonde.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

This damaged, jumbled clipping mixes a resolution thanking federated unions of Cleveland with a fragmentary account of an early-morning incident and a mention of someone named Ryan discussing a man called Pitzel, but the text is too scrambled to follow clearly.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 22 November 1894 · page 1

MORE MYSTERY

"Jltaolvtd, That we render our tbanks through the glass before any one could to the federated unions of Cleveland for stop him. The Incident occurred at 3 their complote arrangements for the o'clock this morning, a snort distance week* ago. Mr. Ryan says that he has part of tho work, it wai McCarver's known Pitzel for many years and has effort to intimate that Richardson was had frequent business transactions with < the mine, he is also hereby oeniurod."

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

The clipping reports that Joseph Pitzel, linked to a Philadelphia insurance swindle, once ran a detective agency in St. Joseph and left owing money, while separately Mrs. Myrtle Holmes of Wilmette refuses to discuss her husband and threatens reporters with hot water.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 22 November 1894 · page 1

PITZEL WAS CEOOKKD. I A St. Joseph, Ma, dispatch says: ! Joseph Pltuel, who is the centre of atj traction in the Philadelphia insurance I swindle, was a former resident of this ' city ana left here about three yoars ago ' under a cloud. While here, ho and a I man named John Carpenter conducted a detective agency and made a number of important captures, one notable case being that of working up and securing the aid of noted criminals who fired buildings at Garden Grove, Iowa, and shot an officer while escaping.

See moreSee less

He f left St. Joseph owing considerable f money. Mr*, tlolwaa Slake* a Threat. ( Chicago, Nov. 21.?Mrs. Myrtle Holmes, the wife of H. EL Holmer, who resides at Wilmette, positively refusea to discuss lier husband in anyway. She said to-night: "I will not talk at all, and the next newspaper man who comes hero will pet a pall of hot water thrown over him."

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

The clipping reports that some believe H. H. Holmes murdered Minnie Williams and her sister for Texas property, citing a jeweler's suspicions about a basement vault and elevator, Holmes' confession of forgery, an unopened trunk held by Wells-Fargo express, and his apparently double or quadruple domestic life.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 23 November 1894 · page 3

NUMEROUS SURMISES ARE AFLOAT

Many Believe Heine* Murdered Minnie William* and Her Sister For the Sake of Their Texas Property—Other* Think They Are Assisting Him and Will Yet Make Their Appearance* Chicago, Nov. —Mystery still sur rounds the Chicago career of H. H. Holmes. The slouths of the land are at their wits ends to discover just what he did after he arrived in this city. Holmes’ best friends are inclined to think him apt to be guilty of murder, which would , serve well his own ends. His confes- | eion of the crimes that has blackened his I life is looked upon by his intimates as a cleverly planned ruse to mislead the officers of the law.

See moreSee less

Especially aB to the whereabouts of Minnie Williams are his old neighbors about Sixty-third and Wallace street skeptical. The belief prevails here that she and her sister were murdered by Holmes or his accomplices for the sake of their Texas property. A thorough search has failed to reveal the slightest clew since the time when Holmes went to Texas and claimed and improved the Fort Worth property left to Minnie by her uncle. “There is a mud floor in this base ment,” Baid C. E. Davis, the jeweler, last night, “and no one will ever know all its secrets until it is dug up from end to end. I don’t know any thing, but I believe the mysterious dis appearance of Miss Williams and her sister might be solved by digging in this cellar. Holmes had a vault in his room whose closed door would stifle any cries. An elevator from his floor to the cellar, which he could operate alone, made it easy for him to convey the evidence of his crime.” lne mystery or the die appearance of Mias Williams ie complicated by a sup posed connection she may have had as an accomplice in the carrying out of Holmes’ schemes to make money. Holmes confessed in writing that he had forged the trust deed from Colonel Bel knap, his wife's grand uncle, to D. E. Fisk, as trustee and those who investi gated the case surmised that Mary Kelly, the notary public, who pretended to have the Belknap acknowledgement and Minnie R. Williams were one and the same. Holmes’ confession of crim inal and his repayment of all sums du9 settled that case, but left the Belknap property in Wltemnnn still standing on record in the name of Minnie Williams. Wiliis M. Hitt is now foreclosing a trust deed on that property in which Minnie Williams is grantor. Minnie Williams' trunk is held un open* d by the Wells-Fargo express. It came here July 7, 1808 addressed to Miss Nannie Williams, care of H. Gor don, 1320 Wrightwood Ave. Chicago. Tho waybill reads from Midlothian, Tex. It was evident that Holmes was lead ing a double life in fact at times it might be said he was leading a quadru ple life. He had a wife and three chil dren in Willamette ami built a fine house there. In the meantime Holmes, Minnie Williams and Pi reek had moved to a house on Dearborne avenue. Suddenly Holmes blossomed out as if lie had lain his hands on considerable money, and hired apartments at the hotel. A de tective who was at work on the caso says: “I learned from the clerk of the hotel that the party was registered as Holmes and wife. The clerk said Miss Williams had told him Pit/.el was her brother. I found while Minnie was living at the South Side hotel she had been attended by a doctor who had never been paid for bis services. I managed to get the bill put into my hands for collection and in the guise of a collector went :o Holmes. He introduced me to Minnie Williams saying, “This is Mrs. Holmes.” The woman was of medium height with a well developed figure, big brown eyes, light hair and a baby face. I managed to collect the bill. “The next time I saw Holmes was in the office of a certain insurance com pany, where ho had come as Hiram Scampbell to receive the amount of his insurance money. He recognized mo as tho supposed collector and was decid edly uncomfortable. He was detained there while I went over to the Plaza ho- | tel and called on Minnie Williams. I secured from her a complete admission of the fraudulent character of the fire and had secured the insurance papers. When this was done my work was at I an end. I had no further interest in the case and I do not know what became of the outfit." Tbe people in Englewood who knew Holmes an' tho Williams girls can t .dl enough stories to fill a book. To some Minnie Williams was known as Mrs. Holmes, to others by her right name and to still others as a consin of Holmes. It was in her character of “cousin” that she witnessed Holmes’ marriage to Miss Yoke in Denver. People in Engle wood who saw Minnie every day for months a year ago and knew her well say she was last seen in Englewood Dec. 15, 1893, in company with her sis ter. Anna. The two were seen together several times jogt previous to the dis appearance of Holmes from Englewood. The story told by Holmes to the police in Philadelphia that he saw Minnie kill Anna aqd that he helped dispose of tbe body and aide d Minnie to escape to Europe is generally doubted. Several persons who know Holmes say they be lieve Holmes, aided by Pltzel, killed both the Williams girls to get posses sion of the fortune belonging to them

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

A detective describes posing as a bill collector to investigate H. H. Holmes and Minnie Williams, discovering their fraudulent insurance claim and Holmes' double identity as 'Hiram Scampbell.' The report also notes conflicting accounts of Minnie Williams' identity and status among Englewood residents, and expresses skepticism about Holmes' claim that Minnie killed her sister Anna.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 23 November 1894 · page 3

NUMEROUS SURMISES ARE AFLOAT.

Holmes. He introduced me to Minnie Williams saying, “This is Mrs. Holmes.” The woman was of medium height with a well developed figure, big brown eyes, light hair and a baby face. I managed to collect the bill. “The next time I saw Holmes was in

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

The clipping, which ends abruptly, reports that Holmes, Mrs. Carrie Pitezle, and Jeptha D. Howe were arrested for participating in a fraudulent life insurance scheme in Philadelphia, and that Holmes has made a confession.

The Willimantic Journal · 23 November 1894 · page 3

Holmes, Mrs. Carrie Pltezle and Jeptha D. Howe are under arrest for participation in a fraudulent life Insurance scheme in Philadelphia. Holmes has made a con

See the clipping

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Holmes, the insurance swindler of many aliases, was taken to Philadelphia where he denied the murder of Pitzel, was identified as Herman Mudgett, and three women call him husband.

The Willimantic Journal · 23 November 1894 · page 3

Wednesday, Nov. 91. Seven men were killed and four Injured by a mine explosion at Colliers, W. Va. -Two apartment bouses in Chicago ware burned. The 250 women and chil- • dran were rescued with much difficulty -The funeral of ex-President MoCosb wee held at Princeton-The National W. C. T. U. elected offloers, with Miss Frances E. Willard as president——The Knights of Labor re-eleoted General Mas ter Workman Sovereign and most of the other officers-The cold wave was gen eral tboughout New York state. At Pots dam the mercury registered 10 degrees below zero-The annnal dinner of the New York chamber of commerce was held at Delmonlco’s-A rabbi and a member of his flock who were bunkoed by green goods men In New York laid tbelr case before Lawyer William Travers Jerome, who referred them to police headquarters — Holmes, tbe insurance swindler of many aliases, was taken to Philadelphia, where he denied the mnrder of Pltzel.

See moreSee less

He was Identified as Herman Mudgett, smd three women call him husband-A strange animal has terrified the inhabit ants of the bill country about Kenslco lake, New York, who have seen It and shot at it without stopping Its terrlflo cries John Garvin, tbs tramp who slept in Mrs. Astor’s New York house Saturday night and was released from jail Monday, was rearrested on a charge of attempted bnrglary made by Mr. Actor’s butler E. S. Jaffray Sc Co.’s storage building and contents at 109 and 111 Leonard street. New York, were destroyed by Are. Loss, $360,000——-Fertytwo cases of ty phoid fever are reported from New Haven. The disease was traced to tainted oysters s——Anna Cabot Lowell, who died at Bos ton, left $37,000 to public institutions Amos Holt and Georga Sherman were drowned while duok hunting at Fall River—The Massachusetts entile com missioner began the work of Inoculating all tbe cattle In tbe state with tuberoulin, a preventive of consumption——Jennie Griffin, 18 was found dead at Marlboro. Mass. She had burst a blood vessel. A week ago her father was found dead un der similar circumstances The Chinese are reported to be flying from Port Ar thur. Severe fighting has taksn pines thsrs-It was officially announoed In St. Peterborg that tbe marriage of tbe czar will take place soon-The French chamber of deputies voted oonfldenee In tbe government by a large majority-. Tbe German troops won a victory In East Afrloa, killing hundreds of the natives and liberating 1,500 slaves-Anton Gregor Rubinstein, the famous pianist, died at Paterhof, Russia.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This clipping is a damaged, disjointed fragment combining partial phrases about acceptability to China, a torpedo-boat in London, a supposed death under another name, and the Catholic Church, with no coherent subject discernible.

The Morning Call · 23 November 1894 · page 1

HOWE'S BAD LUCK

austerity which bas not, however, pre vented hi* being most accep'able to China. thing, he claims, was euiirely professional. London. The weather conditions were perfect, and the torpedo-boat was skim After the supposed death ot Pitzel under another name he claims that he did not heaven has thus given to the Catholic Church since the days of our Lord and his

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The clipping reports that Howe, who had delayed the Pitzel case until Mrs. Pitzel confirmed the dead man's identity, was released on a $2500 bond and declined to discuss his connection with Holmes, while Superintendent Lindley believes he was misled by Holmes and A. S. L. Shields will serve as his counsel.

The Morning Call · 23 November 1894 · page 1

NOT MEANING TO BE A CRIMINAL.

After the supposed death ot Pitzel under another name he claims that he did not proceed with the case until Mrs. Pitzel sat isfied him that the dead man was her hus band. Howe was taken to court and released under a bond of (2500. He was asked to spy something about his connection with Holmes in the matter. 'T do not desire to say anything about that at this time," he replied, "nor about several matters with which my name has been connected." Superintendent of Police Lindley be lieves Howe was misled by Holmes. A. S. L. Shields the noted criminal lawyer, will act as counsel for young Howe.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif. · and 2 other papers

Kate Durkee of Omaha explains how Holmes, the insurance swindler, had her hold property and stock for him, and the clipping also notes Holmes ran a copying-machine company selling worthless territory to agents in Chicago.

The Morning Call · 23 November 1894 · page 1

MISS DURKEE'S STORY. Holmes Used Her to Defraud His Chicago Creditors. Omaha, Nebr., Nov. 22.— Miss Kate Durkee, whose connections witb Holmes, the insurance swindler, has. been so widely heralded and who it was thought might have been murdered, is living in this city with her brother, the assistant auditor of the Burlington ro'-d. Miss D irkee says she only kuew Holmes through his wife, with whom she was intimate in her child hood. She had visited Mrs. Holmes fre quently in Chicago, and during one of her visits the real estate deal which brought her into prominence was made.

See moreSee less

This was about four years ago. Holmes asked Miss Durkee as a favor to allow him to transfer his city property to her. He said that as he was situated at the time it would be a great convenience. Miss Durkee' consented without asking questions. He explained at tbe time that it was only a matter of form, and being ignorant of business affairs she accepted his statement as being true. The property was deeded to her and she never had the deed record ed. Some time afterward Holmes came to her and requested her to have him ap pointed as her administrator, so that he could handle the property as he wanted to. Sbe did so, and at bis request deeded tbe property to a man in Chicago named Campbell, but she does not know who he is or what was bis occupation. After this Holmes sent her some stock in some enter prise in which be was Interested, asking her to keep it for him awhile, in the lat ter part of May or the first of June, 1892, Holmes and several persons came to Omaha to take her deposition regarding the prop erty. Each of them was represented by a lawyer, also from Chicago, and one of them explained at the time that they had been of the opinion tbat she was a mythical person. The cause of their coming here was a suit brought against Holmes by some drug company in Chicago to whom be owed a sum of money. This was the last of the transactions between Holmes and Miss Durkee. 'rk'- : -'t. After the transfer of the property to her Miss Durkee was summoned to Omaha by telegraph on account of tbe sudden 'illness of her brother, and she left without an op portunity to explain her unexpected de parture. This^ihe believes, is the founda tion fir the story that she was murdered. Last August Miss Durkee was again in Chicago. Holmes was out of the city and sbe was told by Mrs. Holmes that he had gone to Philadelphia to attend to some business in regard to an insurance case. Miss Durkee says she is almost sure that the name mentioned was Pitzel, and that Holmes went in behalf of Mrs. Pitzel. sold Patent rights. Holmes Not Particular as to Who Were the Purchasers. Chicago, Nov. 22.— T0-day it became known that Holmes was the head of what purported to be an incorporated company called the A. B. G. Copying Comoany.with headquarters in the Monon building on Dearborn street, this city. The copying machine which Holmes sold was without merits, 'out the sale of : territory to agents was a great source of revenue. It is said that the State of Ohio sold for $5000 cash. Both the Dakotas and a majority of the Western States were disposed of. A com pany was organized in New York and paid $500 par month for merely the agency of that city. Some of the States were sold as many times, it is said, as Holmes could find purchasers. Holmes had in the office two stenographers, one of whom tallied closely with the description of Miss Kate Durkee of Omaha, ami the other is unques tionably Minnie Williams. •', Must Be Settled in Court. Buenos Ayres, Nov. 22.— The decision of the Attorney-General in the Balfour

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Washington Times · Washington, D.C. · 23 November 1894
  • The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 23 November 1894

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The clipping, partly garbled, reports that Miss Durkee was told by Mrs. Holmes that Holmes had gone to Philadelphia on an insurance case, and Miss Durkee believes the name mentioned was Pitzel.

The Herald · 23 November 1894 · page 3

DR. HOLMES AND HIS DUPES.

Last August Miss Durkee wee again in Chicago. Holmes was ont of the city, and she wue told by Mre. Holmes tbat he bad gone to Philadelphia to attend to some business in regard to an insurance case. Misa Darkea says she it almost cure that the name mentioned was Pitzel •nd tbat Holmes went in behalf ol Mri. filial, LAWYIR, HOWE IN CUSTOnY.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

A garbled clipping describes an attorney's account of having a woman and a little girl help identify marks on a body, receiving payment from a company, and getting a receipt from his client Mrs. Pitezel, before declining to comment further on his connection to Holmes.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 23 November 1894 · page 3

HOLMES' CHICAGO RECORD.

the the body "I thereupon callod tlio woman In and "I told lier sho must give what identification told murks she could that would assist the pauy in bringing pauy husband, and I read her the coroner's let ter. She told ter. sent tho information to tho coroner and sent received information from him that they were not sufficient. I told the widow then were thaï thaï must come the body, and she said the little girl could the to do that. 1 brought tho little girl do and the body and pany's satisfaction and to mine.

See moreSee less

Ö per per "The company paid tho money to and 1 returned to St. Louis and got i and ceipt iu full from my client, Mrs. Pitezel, ceipt for tho amount of money, und I gave heru for the the receipt for my fee. The latter That was the Inst I saw of her.' That Mr. Howe about his connection with Holmes in the matter. "I do not desire to say anything about that at this time," ho replied, "nor about that soveral other matters with which my name has been connected. Much will depend has n waits upon the manner of my treatment by upon and of of President Fousc and the general nuture of the proceedings here." the raty HOLMES' CHICAGO RECORD. has Pitezel's. the identity of her of theso marks, and I here and identify here identified to the 12,5(30. asked wlmt lie had to say

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A young St. Louis lawyer accused with H. H. Holmes of defrauding an insurance company of $10,000 reached Philadelphia at noon after stopping in Washington, and was met at the depot by Marshall F. McDonald of St. Louis, law partner of the lawyer's brother.

The Washington Times · 23 November 1894 · page 1

HOWE'S DEALS WITH HOLMES

the young St. Louis lawyer, who, In conneo tion with H. H. Holmes, is charged with de frauding a local insurance company oat of 610.000, reached Philadelphia at noon to-day from Washington, where ho stopped oyor on his way from St. .Louis yesterday. Ho was met at the depot by Marshall F. McDonald, ol St. Louis, who is the law partner of young Howe's brother, and together they wont to

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping recounts a woman's statement that she deeded property to Dr. Holmes's associate at his request, later appointed him administrator, and held stock he sent her, with the account breaking off mid-sentence about events in 1892.

The Washington Times · 23 November 1894 · page 1

KATE DURKEE NOT MURDERED

Ho explained at the time that it was only a matter of form, and being ignorant of busi ness affairs, she accepted his statement as be ing true. The property was deedod to her and she never had the deed recorded. Some time afterward Dr. Holmes came to her and requested her to have him appointed as ber administrator, so that he could handle the property as he -wanted to. She did so, and at ids request deeded the property to a man in Chicago, named Campbell, but she does not know who ho is or what his occupation was.

See moreSee less

After this Holmes sent her some stock in some enterprise in which he was interested, asking her to keep it for him a while. In the latter part of May, or the first of June, 1892, Holmes and several other persons

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Philadelphia lawyer Howe, printed in German, recounts how Mrs. Pitzel asked him to pursue her insurance claim, leading to correspondence with the coroner and police chief about identifying a body listed as B. F. Perry.

Abendblatt · 23 November 1894 · page 2

Aufregung, die durch dieselbe hervorgerufen wurde, aufgegeben. Die „Times" erfährt ans Berlin, daß derßundesralh die anlircvolutionären Vor lagen an einen Ausschuß verwiesen habe. Die Spannung zwischen den norddeutschen und süddeutschen Sozialdemokraten wird von Tag zu Tag größer. Sogar Liebknecht weist Bebel's Behauptung zurück, daß die jetzigen Sozialdemokraten gegen die frühe ren an innerer Tüchtigkeit zurückständen. St. I o hn s, 22. Nob. Der Dampstr „Corcan" von der Allan Linie, Kapitän Main, der heute von Glas gow und Liverpool hier eintraf, hatte mit entsetzlichem Wetter zu kämpfen und ent ging mehrere Male mit knapper Roth dem Untergang.

See moreSee less

Die Decks wurden wiederholt von der Spitze bis zum Stern übcrflulhet iinv alles was nicht nictund nagel fest war, wurde weggerissen. Es war unmöglich, die Maschinen in Gang zu erhalten und drei Tage lang war der Dampfer hülflos Wind und Wetter preisgegeben. Das Barometer sank auf 28.22. Am Donnerstag, den 15. November, herrschte der heftigste Sturm wahrend der ganzen Reise, er nahm mit jeder Minute an Heftigkeit zu und artete zuletzt in einen regelrechten Orkan aus. Während der paar Tage herrschte bittere Kälte, so daß der Dampfer in eine dicke Eiskruste einge hüllt war. Trotz des entsetzlichen Wetters befanden sich alle Passagiere und die Mann schaft wohl und munter, und abgesehen von dem an Deck angerichteten Schaden scheint der Dampfer in völlig gutem Zustande zu sein. Eine Depesche aus Rom an den Stan dard sagt, daß der Papst einen Fond zur Unterstützung der durch das Erdbeben Heimgesuchtcu hergegeben habe. Philadelphia, Pa., 22. Nob. Advokat Howe machte heute Nachmittag folgende Angaben über seine Verbindung mit dem Holmes-Pitzel-Falle. Er sagte: Jeden Tag wird man neues über diesen Fall zu hören bekommen; was ich jedoch heute darüber zu sagen habe, ist nicht viel. Diese Frau Pitzel kam zu mir, und ersuchte mich, als ihr Anwalt ihre Versicherungs forderung zu betreiben. Ich nahm mich dex Sache an und benachrichtigte zunächst, wie ich glaube, den Agenten der VerVersicherungsgesellschaft in St. Louis und dieser, setzte sich, glaube ich, mit der hiesigen Gesellschaft in Verbindung. Ich fand dann, daß sie alle ihre Geschäfte durch ihre Hauptosfice besorgten. Ich schrieb an den Polizeichef von Philadelphia und ich glaube auch au die Gesellschaft oder den Coroner. Wenn ich nicht irre, so schrieb ich an den Coroner zuerst. Er sowohl w'e der Polizeichef Linden antworteten mir. In dem ersten Briese des Coroners hieß es, daß die Leiche hier sei und idcntifizirt wer den müsse. Der Schreiber des Briefes sagte, cs sei dis Leiche von B. F. Perrh und falls dieselbe nicht ander weitig identifizirt würde, so würde sie unter diesem Namen beerdigt werden. Ich fragte die Wiltwe, wie sich das verhalte worauf sie mir erklärte, daß ihr Mann wegen irgend welcher Geschichten, die er gehabt, diesen Namen geführt habe. Ich sagte ihr, die Sache müsse ins Reine ge bracht werden, ehe sie ihr Geld bekommen könne. Sie zeigte mir eine Anzahl Briefe, die sie von diesem Perry erhalten hatte, und eS schien mir, daß sie so ziemlich den Beweis lieferte, daß diese Briefe von ihrem Manne herrührten, da in denselben von ihren Kindern und Familienangelegen bciten die Rede war. So wurde unter anderem in dem Briefe gesagt, daß eines der Kinder ihm auf den Daumen getreten sei und denselben verletzt habe. Es ist mög lich, daß dieser Mann ihr Gatte war. Ich sagte ihr, sic werde mit hierherkommen müssen. Ich erhielt dann, glaub' ich, einen Brief vom Coroner, in welchem cs hieß, daß wir sichere Beweise für die Jdentifixi rung beibringen müßten, Beweise, durch welche wir darthun könnten, das die Leiche die des Pitzel sei. Ich ging dann zur Frau und sagte ihr, sie müsse mir alle Beweise für die Jdentisizirung geben, die sie bei bringen könne, um der Versicherungsgesell schaft bei der Feststellung der Persönlichkeit ihres Mannes bchülflich zu sein und ich las ihr zu diesem Behufe den Brief des Coro ners vor. Sie gab mir dann einige Kennzeichen und ich theilte dieselben dem Coroner mit, der mir darauf erwiderte, daß dieselben nicht genügend seien. Darauf sagte ich der Wittwe, sie müsse selbst hierher kommen und die Leiche identisiziren; ich würde für das Kind sorgen und ihr einen guten Platz aus der Eisenbahn besorgen. Als sie mir sagte, daß sie das Geld nicht habe, erklärte ich ihr, daß ich selbst arm sei und daß sie das Geld auftreiben müsse. Schließlich er hielt sie das Geld von ihrem Grocer und als es Zeit war abzureisen, ging ich zu ihr. Ich fand sie krank im Bett. Ich sagte ihr Jemand müsse mit mir gehen, um die Leiche zu identisiziren, worauf sie sagte, daß ihr Töchtcrchen das thun könne. Anfangs er hob ich Einspruch dagegen, ging jedoch spä ter auf den Vorschlag ein. Ich brachte das Mädchen hierher und die Leiche wurde dann zu meiner und der Gesellschaft Zufrieden heit identifizirt. Die Versicherungsgesellschaft zahlte mir das Geld aus und ich kehrte nach St. Louis zurück und erhielt eine Quittung für den vollen Betrag des Geldes von meiner Clien tiu, Frau Pitzel, und ich gab ihr eine Quittung über die mir bezahlten Gebühren. Dieselben betrugen 42500. Seit der Zeit habe ich sie nicht wieder gesehen. Später ging ich nochmal nach ihrem Hause, erfuhr aber, daß sie ausgezogen sei. Zeuge wurde dann gefragt, was er über feine Verbindung mit Holmes in der An gelegenheit zu sagen habe. „Ich möchte gerade jetzt hierüber, sowie über verschiedene andere Angelegenheiten, mit denen mein Name in Verbindung gebracht worden ist, nicht sprechen." Nach einer Unterredung in Superinten dent Liudens Amtsstube, bei welcher der Letztere, ferner McDowald,Howe und Präs ident Fonsc zugegen waren, wurde Howe nach der Amtsstube des Bezirksauwalts gebracht, wo er bis gegen 3 Uhr verblieb. Dann wurde er vor Gericht gebracht. Howe's Anwalt beantragte, den Verhafte ten zur Bürgschaft zuzulassen und zwar möge dieselbe so niedrig als möglich ange setzl werden. Richter Bregy setzte dann die Bürgschaft auf 42500 an und der Verhaf tete wurde entlassen. Minneapolis, Minn.. 22. Nov. Das angebliche Opfer von H. H. Holmes, B. F. Pitzel, kam im vergangenen Juli nach Minncapolis und versuchte einen Plan für den Bau von Fahrstühlen in lowa, Minnesota, und den Dakotas, woran, wie er behauptete, Clucagoer Kapitalisten be theiligt seien, zur Ausführung zu bringen. Er blieb nur ein paar Wochen und von seinem Unternehmen hat man nichts wie der gehört. London, 22. Nob. L ondon, 23. Nov.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Howe described giving $10,000 to Mrs. Pitezel and admitted receiving $2500 from her, was released on $2500 bail, and that lawyer W. A. Shoemaker received an anonymous $100 offer to defend Holmes.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 November 1894 · page 1

HOWE'S STORY,

conceal in their own spo-ehes that they think they have not boon honest up to this time. They say in their constitution: “The method of the Is-ague shall lie to enlist the conscience, intelligenece and patriotism of New Kngland against the system called protection, which, at the dictation of organized wealth, taxes the whole American people for the benefit of the few.” Well, I am glad that these gentlemen have not only changed their name and their principles, and resolved to live an honest political life lien-after, blit have changed their venue.

See moreSee less

They appeal to the conscience, intelligence and patrotism of the people of New Kngland. The only eon science, intelligence ami patriotism they have succeeded to satisfy up t i this timw is the conscience, intelligence and patriii5 tism of Tammany Hall and the Black Belt of the South. The bureau of education published, after the census of lsso, a map which it called the map of illiteracy, where the different parts of the 1'nited States were shaded with black, or were left in proportion to the ignorance which the census disclosed. If they had accompanied it with a similar map which had shown the regions where secession or disunion sentiment had prevailed in the time of the war, North or South, and if they had aoeollijwtnied it with a similar map showing where the free trade sentiment of the country had lieen the strongest, the three maps would have been substantially Identical.and each j to the satisfaction of tint company and I ! got tho 110,000. Hot timing to St. Louis, 1 ) gave it to Mrs. Pitezel find t«x>k her re ! ecipt for it. I gave her my receipt for my I fee and that is all 1 have soon of tier or of j the ease.” j Howe admitted that Mrs. Pitezel |inltl him 12500. When asked as to ids eounoc | tint! with Holmes anil what, lie knew of | him, Howe said at present he did not earn ; to talk alxmt Hint part of the ease. I Neither did he care to discuss the eonnec tioti of Train Kohlxr Hedgepath with tho 1 case. Lite this nfterntxin. District Attorney : Hmhaiii nnnoiinetsl that lie would occo|>t ! $2500 liail for Howe's release. Through j the aid of McDonald, Howe succeeded jin getting ball. P ft was learned, today, tliat W. A. Shoe : maker, a young lawyer, bad a call front a | man who is a stranger, Wednesday. This man gave Shoemaker an unnddresxetl en I velope in whleh was n short note ail dresstsl to Shtx'inaker. One hundred dol I lnrs was enclosed ami the writer stab si | that he wished Mr. Hhisunaker to under | take the defence of Holmes and secure the services of two of the Ijcst criminal law yers in Philadelphia. Money in nhiin | dance to conduct the ease was protnlsetl, and if lie was not aide to come himself, he ! said, a man designated ns“H" would come in his place. The letter was signed "I*. L.,” and dated Chicago, Nov. lit. Shoemaker questioned tlie Ix'an rjof the note closely anti learned practically noth

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This fragment combines a list of Democratic party policies the public allegedly dislikes with an unrelated account of efforts to identify a body, which the coroner said would be buried as Perry's unless otherwise identified, though a widow claimed it was her husband Pitezel living under that name.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 November 1894 · page 1

HOWE'S STORY

FEN'ATOH HOAR tion of tinprinciple and policy of the Democratic party. The people do not like their Income tax; j They do not like their way of dealing ' with the Sugar Trust; They do not like what they have done for the Whiskey King; They do not like their foreign policy; They do not like their plan of r. pealing the tax on state banks’ circulation and reviving the wildcat currency of the times lief ore the war; They do not like their sectional policies ; They do not like their protecting sugar .and rice of the Smith, and their putting notify the St.

See moreSee less

Lulls agent of the insurance eomimny, relying upon him to communl cate with the main olfioe in Philadelphia. I next wrote tho superintendent of poll.'', Capt. Linden, to the eomimny and to fix' roroiHT. The coroner, in replying, said the 1msly litre must l«' Idcntllled, ‘for.’ said he, ‘we know it as the lxxly of H. K Perry anti unless therv In Homo other itlciitillcntlon it will lx' burietl as the lxxly of Perry.’ 1 asked tlie widow alxmt tho conflict in the name. She told me that Pitezel was iter husband, living ill Philadelphia under I lie until?' of Perry, and showed me a number uf letters froin blm tliat eotivineed [ me that the writer was her husband. I

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Among a column of news briefs, this report quotes Lawyer Howe recounting how, with Mrs. Pitezel too ill to travel, her daughter Alice was sent to identify a body, satisfying the insurance company and securing $10,000.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 23 November 1894 · page 1

HOWE'S STORY

Just the hour of the earthquake shock. You see, of course, if you are not a dunce,• How it went to pieces,and all at once. All at once, and nothing tirst Just as bubbles do when they burst.” This is not merely a meeting for con gmtillations.. The Home Market Club, 1 suppose, means to maintain this contest until it is settled, and settled rightly. I have been much delighted with the do ings of a meeting held in Boston, night liefore last, of the gentlemen who, 1 slip pose, you are to consider as your untug onists.

See moreSee less

One of their speakers said that lie envied the Home Market Club, because it had always boldly saitl what it meant and meant wlmt it said. Those gentlemen purpose henceforth to throw oil the mask of tariff reform, wiheli they admit, has been a mask, and to stand out as free traders. Their speakers hnvo licen in the habit of saying politely that we lied when wo said that they were free traders. They propose to lie honest hereafter, and hardly conceal in their own spo-ehes that they [ transmitted them to the coroner. 1 again | received word from tlie coroner—or some one else—that still the Identification was inxullit ient. ‘That,’ said I to Mrs. Pitezel, ‘means that you must goto Philadelphia.' She replied Hint, her baby wits not well,and she could not leave it. 1 told her that 1 would toko care of tlie child. 'I lien slit* said she had no money. I was pis.r and could not pay her way. I told her she uniat raise tho money herself." At fids |x.int Ltwyer McDonald, who was present, exclaimed, “1 don't sts* tho ust. of going into all these details.’* “True," rejoined Howe. Kcxuming, he said: “Anyway, Mrs. Pitezel raised tlie money; she got It from tier groccrymnn. When ) went for her I found her sick in hed. I told her that someone must go. She said her little girl i (Alice) could go. I did not like Hie idea, l.ut It was the Ixst we could do, for Mrs. Pitezel was too ill to move. I brought the child with me. She identified the lxidy j to the satisfaction of tint company and I ! got tho 110,000. Hot timing to St. Louis, 1

See the clipping

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.

A Philadelphia grand jury indicted Hermann Mudget (alias H. H. Holmes), a St. Louis lawyer, and a widow for conspiracy to defraud an insurance company over a policy, with vice president Alexander McKnight commenting that murder is suspected though only fraud was charged.

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 23 November 1894 · page 3

Three Indictments Returned in the Pltxel jury has found a true bill against Her­ mann Mudget, alias H. H. Holmes, now a prisoner in Boston Jeptha B. Howe, the St. Louis lawyer who col­ lected the insurance money on P. F. Pitzel's policy for the latter's widow, and the widow herself. The indict­ ment reads for "conspiracy to cheat and defraud." of the Fidelity Mutual company, made the following staten it to a represent-, ative of the Associated Press: "While the suspicion has grown until we are nearly positive that B. F. Pitzel was murdered, the only charge made before the grand jury was that of conspiracy to defraud." INSURANCE SWINDLERS. Cane at Philadelphia. PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 20.—The grand Alexander McKnight, vice president

See the clipping

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.

In St. Louis on November 20, attorney Jeptha D. Howe was arrested on charges of conspiring with H. H. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company of $10,000, and after appearing before Chief Harrigan was released on a $3,000 bond.

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 23 November 1894 · page 3

*!i»e Is Arrested. ST. LOUIS, NOV. 20.—Jeptha D. Howe, an attorney of this city, has been arretted on the charge of con­ spiring with one H. H. Holmes to de­ fraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insur­ ance company of Philadelphia out of $10,000. Attorney Howe was taken be­ fore Chief Harrigan at the four courts. At the conclusion of the conference Howe was released on a $3,000 bend.

See the clipping

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn. · and 1 other paper

The clipping reports that Holmes, arriving in Philadelphia in custody with Mrs. Pitzel and a woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes, tried to bribe his detective escort and then recounted a long, sensational personal history involving insurance fraud schemes, a fatal quarrel between women, and a Texas property scheme with Pitzel.

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 23 November 1894 · page 4

A BAD RECORD

PHILADELPHIA, NOV. 21.—Arch Con -ipirator H. H. Holmes, accompanied by Mrs. Pitzel and a pretty woman, who calls herself Mrs. Holmes, has arrived in this city in the custody of Detective Crawford and Special Agent Perry of the Fidelity Mutual Life association. Mrs. Pitzel's 16-year-old daughter, Meda, and'her 1-year-old boy were also -with tb.e party. Mrs. Pitzel's nervous ^condition .was such that she was unable to walk from Broad street station to the Central station across the street and had to tw supported by Detective Craw lord and a policeman. After their ar­ rival the party was closeted with Superintendent of Police Linden until late in the afternoon.

See moreSee less

When the con­ ference was over Detective Crawford the moat important feature of which was the relation made to him by Holmes of the story of his whole life. It reads litce the most sensational of romances. Holmes sat beside the de­ tective, with handcuffs on. The train had scarcely emerged from the Boston depot before the prisoner tried to bribe his captor. He offered the detective $500 if he w6nld allow him to hypnotize him so that he could escape. He said he had frequently hypnotized persons, having acquired the art from a college professor in the West. He said he could get the money from his wife and Mrs. Pitzel. When he saw that his words had no effect, Holmes entered into a general .conversation and He said he was raised in Burlington, Vt., and so well educated in school there that at 15 he was a teacher. For some time afterwards he went to col­ lege there aud later in Detroit, Mich. Here he formed the acquaintance of a medical student, who, he said, fur­ nished the body in New York in the present case. During vacations they worked on farms to raise their college expenses, but one summer they found themselves without means, and it was then that the medical man suggested the idea of getting a body and beating an insurance company. This was 12 years ago. The doctor got his life in­ sured for $12,500. They obtained the body in Chicago, took it East, arranged the details of identification and success­ fully got the money, with which they continued their studies. He refused to name the company thus swindled. They worked this scheme afterward with success, Holmes said, obtaining sums ranging from $1,000 to $30,000. While living in Chicago about 15 months ago he fell in with a typewriter girl and furnished a house on the out­ skirts, where they lived together. A younger sister came to visit them, aud the woman grew so jealous of her that in a quarzel one day she struok her over the head with a stool and killed her. To save the woman with whom he was living, Holmes said he put the body iii a trunk, loaded it-with stones and sunk it in the lake. This girl had property in Texas, and he and Pitzel took it off her hands and sent her abroad. It was worth, he said, $40, 000, and after getting it in their hands, they went through Texas, buying car­ loads of horses on notes on this prop­ erty, but as they never had legal title to the property and it is for this affair that they are wanted in Fort Worth. To save this property he and Pitzel formed the scheme of swindling the Fidelity com­ pany. He told the detectives that for the crimes he committed he deserved to be hanged a dozen times. Holmes is not lacking for money, as he himself admitted that at the present time he is supporting nearly two dozen persons, including the girl murderess, her mother and an imbecile brother two orphans in Chicago, who live in one of liis properties three separate alleged wives and their children, and his own mother and father in Kanka­ kee. He firmly maintained that Pitzel is aiive in Salvador and that he will hear from him through the personal column of a Gertain New York news­ paper. DULUTH, Nov 21.—LouiRouchleau has completed a big iron deal on behalf of the Rouchleau-Ray Iron Land com­ pany, having sold government lot 3 and the southeast quarter of northwest quarter of section 5, township 57, range 17, for $200,000 cash, to the Fayal Iron company, which is controlled by the Minnesota Iron company. The stand­ ing pine on the property is excepted from the sale. FARGO, N. D., NOV. 21.-—Beyond the opening statements of the attor­ neys for the plawtiff, butlining evi­ dence they proposed to introduce, the Hirschfield divorce case lacked sensa­ tional features. Defendant, Mrs. Hirschfield, appeared in court for the first time. Detailed the Story of the Trip, Told the Story of His Life. Were Successful Schemers. The Notes Were Worthless Big Iron Land Seal. The Hlrschfield Case.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn. · 24 November 1894

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

Jeptha P. Howe surrendered in Philadelphia on fraud charges linked to H. H. Holmes, with his law partner and others defending him as misled rather than criminal, and he was released on $2,500 bond after giving a partial statement.

The Helena Independent · 23 November 1894 · page 2

Philadelphia, Nov. .2.- Jeptha P. Hlowe, the young St. Louls lawyer who. in connection with II. H. Holmes. is charged with defrauding a local in \esrance company of 10,000, relched this dty to-day. He was met by Mar "hal F. McDonald, of St. Louis. a law partner of young Howe's ,broth.r, and surrendered himself. Lawyer Mr t]nnald said: "This arch-onmspirator. H. H: Holmes. or H. M. Morgan, the n.one by which he is known in It. Louts. came to the oldee while I was ab sent in Colorado and proposed the case.

See moreSee less

saying Mrs. PItsel wanted snme one to represent her. It was the flat case the boy had ever been offered, and he jumped right into It with all the ardor and enthuslasm of youth. He did not watt for us to return, and the result was this sllck crook imposed upon him. My young friend may have bheqs indis creet, but he Is no criminal." upilerintendent of Police Lindsay be. "Ieves Howe was misled by Holmes. A. B. L. Shlelda. tha noted criminal lawyer, will act as counsel for young Howe. Lawyer Howe gave out a statement in reference to his connection with the Holmes-Pitsel affair. It was a com plete denial of the . rrminal nmotivel\ attributed to him, and detailed how, he came to be engaged as counsel. The whole thing, he claims, was entirely professional. After the supposed doslh of PItsil, under another name, hie claims he did inot proceed with the case until Mrs. Plttel was satisfied that the dead man was her husband. Howe was taken to court and released under bond of 2.500. Mr. Howe was asked to may something about his con nection with Holmes in the matter. "I do not desire to say anything about that at this time," he replied, nor about several matters with which my name has been connected." Omaha. Nov. 22.-Miss Kate Durkee. whose connection with HIolmes, the insurance swindler, and wiho. it is thought, might have been murdered,

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb. · and 1 other paper

A young St. Louis lawyer accused with H. H. Holmes of defrauding an insurance company surrendered to Philadelphia police, with his associate Marshal McDonald insisting the youth was deceived by Holmes and was no criminal, and a noted lawyer agreed to take his defense ahead of a likely bail release.

Omaha Daily Bee · 23 November 1894 · page 1

InlniR Ho Is an Innocent Victim ol Holmes * PHILADELPHIA , Nov. 22. Jeptha D. lowe , Ihe young St. Louis lawyer , who , In onncctlou with H. H. Holmes , is charged Ith defrauding a local insurance company f $10,000 , reached this city al noon today ram Washington , where he ( topped over on Is way from St. Louis yesteday. He was net'nt ' the depot by Marshal F. McDonald of t. Louis , who Is the law partner of young lowe's brother , and togelher they went to ho office of Superintendent of Police Linden , hero he surrendered himself.

See moreSee less

A conference s now in progress. When seen by an Associated press reorter today Lawyer McDonald said : "This rchconspirator , H. H. Holmes or H. L , lorgan , the name by which he was known n St. Louis , came to the olEce while I was abent In Colorado and proposed the case , sayng that Mrs. Pltzcl wanted some ono to epresent her. It was the first case the boy iad ever been offered and ho Jumped right nto It with all the ardor and enthusiasm ot outh. He did not wait for us to return and the result was that this slick crook 1mlosed upon him. My young friend may have ecn Indiscreet , but he Is no criminal. " Superintendent of Police Linden places mpllclt confidence In what Mr. McDonald ays In reference to young Howe and Is of he opinion that the latter has been misled jy Ilnlmcs. Lawyer McDonald called on A. S. L. Shields , Iho noted criminal lawyer , at ho latter's ofilco and asked Mr. Shields to act as counsel for young Howe. The facts f the case were briefly stated and Mr. Shields agreed to take charge of Iho case. lowc , In all probability , will be released on ball. ball.INDIANAPOLIS U llei.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 23 November 1894

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says an insurance company publicized a thank-you letter from Mrs. Pitzel after paying a $10,000 policy, and that Holmes ran an incorporated A. B. C. Copying company in Chicago, selling worthless machine territories repeatedly to agents nationwide.

Omaha Daily Bee · 23 November 1894 · page 1

lowc , In all probability , will be released on ball. ball.INDIANAPOLIS INDIANAPOLIS , Ind , . Nov. 22. The Inuronce company which insured and paid the 10,000 policy on the life of Pltzel on Septem- > er 21 a few days afterward received a letter Yom Mrs. Pitzel , thanking them for their piomptness and expressing gratitude for the lonslderrtlon shown her nnd her children. This letter was carried and scattered broad cast as an advertisement by the company. The letter Is reproduced verbatim and Is preceded by the company's stalement that wtlsfactory evidence of Pltzel'a death had > een secured.

See moreSee less

CHICAGO , Nov. 22. Today It became mown that Holmes was th ? head ot what purported to lo an Incorporated company called the A. B. C. Copying company , with leadquartcrs In the Monon building on Dear- > orn street , this city. The copying machine which Holmes sold was without merits , but .ho sale of territory to agents was a great source of revenue. It Is said that the state ot Ohio told frr $5,000 cash. Both of the Dakotas and a maporlty of the western stales was disposed of. A company was organized In New York and paid $500 per mouth for merely the agency In that city. Some of the states \\ere sold as many times , It Is said , as Holmes could find purchasers. Holmes bad n the office , two stenographers , one ot whom tallied closely with the description ot Mlrs Kate Durkco of Omaha , and the other wan iinqttestlonably Minnie Wlll.ams. 11/Mi SUM3IOff CnUornln htrlkei-N Want to I'nt Him on the \ \ lines * Stand.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

This badly scrambled OCR fragment mixes references to Georgiana Yoke Howard, a First District ballot dispute, and a three-year statute of limitations, but is too damaged to clearly convey its subject.

The Evening World · 23 November 1894 · page 8

NO TRACE OF THE SISTERS

B, " i-tweeneorglana TVjke Howard and her An Error DUrnvrrerl That Seats 1 '" CauiUiarpassed through his ottlce. Three nnd Mny Elect Their Con. hHt, denied all knowledse of the parties. K v "d said he never met H. H. Holmes or RreNNman. f . AeorSana Yoke Howard. The cellar When the ballots of the First District Should tbe Indictments Be Qnaslied It pf llmiutlonh, which declares that an LliiTi"" c.aot bt brought after the expiration of three years from the time Would Be Difficult to Find .t.a.c.rilme.l!,..ll,c.overed. The 1 one exception to this law. and that Is when

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

The fragment reports suspicions about a confederate of Holmes, mail sent to Mrs. Mary Yoke with a Chicago return address denied by F. E. Blackman, plus unrelated brief items on a police captaincy exam and an eloped couple.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening World · 23 November 1894 · page 3

NO TRACE OF THE SISTERS.

VJ ' Many now believe that Minnie, at least, VJ J I is a confederate of Holmes, and that iVJ ' I the detection of I he incendiary fire at IVJ 8 Unglewood scared the outfit badly J I enough to make them get out of town , without taking Anna's trunk. ijJB ' f It has been discovered that mall is Jt I being sent to Mrs. Mary Yoke, the J I mother of Grorglana Yoke, at Franklin, J; y Ind., every few days. The envelopes St I were marked "Return to No.

See moreSee less

69 DearM( I born street, care of F, E. Blackman, I I Chicago." F. K. Blackman denies the 1 V statement that the correspondence be H I I tween Oeorglanai Yoke Howard and her P f mother passed through his office. J I He denied all knowledge of the parties, H I and said be never met H. H. Holmes or ' .1 Georglana Yoke Howard. The cellar J 1 flcor at 701 Sixty-third street still rests known there. Thirty-Ave After Captaincy The examination of sergeants In the competi tion for promotion to a captalney has been set down by Police Commlsslorei Welles, of Brook lyn, for Monday. The candidates number thirty n?e. Elopers) Will De ForffWen. Mr. A. S. SuIllTan, of Fannlngdsje, I. J., whose el ghUen-y ear-old daughter Alma eloped with young Edwin B Wilson, of TJrooklyn, last Wednesday night, said this morning that he had seen nothing ot the young couple. He says be would not hate opposed the match. STRIKERS ARE HUNGRY.

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Lawyer J. D. Howe surrendered to Philadelphia police on conspiracy charges related to defrauding an insurance company alongside H. H. Holmes. Howe and his associates claim he acted in good faith and was misled by Holmes, having been hired by Mrs. Pitzel to handle an insurance claim.

Pawtucket Tribune · 23 November 1894 · page 1

CASE OF REGULAR BUSINESS

PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 28.—Lawyer J. D. Howe of St. Louis, who is charged with econspiracy with H. H. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Insurance company of $lO,OOO, reached here yesterday after noon, and, accompanied by ex-District Attorney McDonald, went at once to the central station and surrendered himself to Superintendent of Police Linden. He de nies thas he had any guilty connection with the swindles. Lawyer McDonald sald: *‘‘This arch conspirator, H. H. Holmes, or H. M. Mor

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This fragment describes how a young man, eager for his first case, accepted a request to represent Mrs. Pitzel while his colleague was away in Colorado, acting before the colleague returned.

The Providence News · 23 November 1894 · page 4

Howe's Connection With the Pitzel Scrape. Holmes Once Did Quite a Bit of Swindling in Chicago.

. nl. the name he was known by in St y uls, came to the office while I was ab i sent in Colerado and proposed the case, 1.;1 saying that Mrs, Pitzel wanted someone ,? to represent her. It was the first case the . Dboy had ever been offered, and he jumped " right into it with all the ardor and enthu splasm of youth. He did not wait for us - to retugn, and the result was that this

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The clipping reports that Lawyer McDonald enlisted Mr. Shields as counsel for young Howe, expressed confidence Howe was misled by Holmes, and begins Howe's own statement about being hired by Mrs. Pitzel over an insurance claim.

The Providence News · 23 November 1894 · page 4

i{ slick crook imposed upon him. My young = friend may have been indiscreet, but he - s nocriminal.” Superintendent of Police Linden places - implicit confidence in what Mr. McDonald says ia reference to young Howe, and is of the opinion that the lafter has boen misE led by Holmes. - Lawyer McDonald called on S L Bhields, a eriminal lawyer, and asked Mr. Shields to aet as counsel for young Howae, The facts of the case were briefly stated, and Mr. Shields agreed to take charge of the case.

See moreSee less

Howe will in all probability be ‘Feleased on bail. Howe's Story. . Lawyer Howe gave out the following statement in reference to his connection with the Helmes Pitzel affair: ‘“‘Mrs. Pitzel oame to me and employed me as her attorney to look after the insurance claim. 1 took hold of the mattér, and first of all I

See the clipping

Fort Worth Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.

A heavily OCR-damaged clipping mixes an account of a lawyer's statement about Holmes and a Miss Durkee's dealings with an insurance claim with a separate, barely legible item about a Chinese customs official's visit to Japan amid indemnity talks.

Fort Worth Gazette · 23 November 1894 · page 1

M > loung frlenl ma > hae been In ihtlr coming here wuks a 7itt brougit discreet but h Is no criminal against Holmes by Ham drug company Huperlntendrnt Linden plsoes impor In ChUago to whom h oived a sum of tant conllderco in what Mr McDjnaU monev This was the Inst or the trans says In refer > nce to > oung Howe and action or of Holmes Mli Durkea savs is of the opinion that the latter had nfur lhe transactlan for the rroirty been misled by Holmes she was called to Omaha > Y lilegraph Lnwjcr Howe lut r In tho da > gave on account of tha sudden lUness of out the following statement In rtfer her brother and alio lett Li t Adj c nee to his connection with the lit lines j tin MIsaDurkce attain went to Chicago Pltnel arfalr i Holmes was out of th cit > and she Of course tlurc Is much to be nun told b > Mrs Holmes that he bad i > i > ever da > but gone to Phllidelphia to attend to X lino erj little to saj In the matter mme buslne > a regarding an ln ranee ii a uik w an Mrs l Ht cise Miss Durkee says she la nlmtst ml came to mo and emplojcd ine as sure the name mentlMiftl was Pltexel her attorney to Wok after an Insurance rlalm I took lold of the matUr unl He iiuubt pall Is accounted for by the otllclil state inent that an Indemnity would be seiurtd on the customs receipts ot China It has been one of the Japan ese contentions that she would ex lett in lecover tho customs receipts < t the big Chi new ports In case nn Indemntt was arranged It Is anil that tbe Lb In ess envoi ma bo the guist ot United Htatas Minister Dun utToklo Jui > aiie e ofllclnls ss he will be nccoidt < d ever tourles This depurlure ot the Chlneao cus tolni chief tu Japan Is regiinled b > ofllilala as lhe result of Japans de mand for n d reel offer from China The D Ting meiilhnied In the cnble

See the clipping

Fort Worth Gazette · Fort Worth, Tex.

This badly garbled clipping mentions a figure named Holmes and the New York police amid fragmentary, unclear statements, then reports that a fire in Marshall, Texas, burned a residence and its contents.

Fort Worth Gazette · 23 November 1894 · page 1

real culprit latter was W00 That w is he U HoLmes anl the New lork police ap I eaw of her I went to he liousi once pear to be strangers I know nothing afterwardi anl learnei that she had alimt tlUs mm wall h t Klllliea Marshall Tex Nov 22 Flrp last night burned tho resldcneO of Mr Juaay and all content alao tho rant

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This damaged clipping recalls childhood intimacy with Mrs Holmes and frequent visits in Chicago, mentioning a real estate deal from about four years earlier and a favor Holmes asked of Miss Durkee, but the text is too fragmentary to follow fully.

The Salt Lake Herald · 23 November 1894 · page 2

MISS DURKEE'S POSITION

she was intmate chldhOod I had visited Mrs Holmes frequently in Chicago and during one of her visits I j into prominence was enacted This the real estate deal which brought her lromnence J vas about four years ago Holmes 1 asked Miss Durkee as a favor to allow

See the clipping

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

A heavily garbled newspaper fragment references a denial by someone named Jewett of criminal motives connected to a case, alongside disjointed, unreadable mentions of a railroad and other unclear details.

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 23 November 1894 · page 1

An Indiscreet Lawyer

a • t Jeim'itt in reference to Lis spondent for n(’hi' , .ag > new-por-i ' ■'"•‘<■l ion with tie* Holmes Pitz.el I After remaining in tLc i-Jand** for .a 'lifer. 1! was a complete denial of; ; f<»w months L • n turriod p. San I'ran :lie criminal motive*- attributed to j I cisco ami obtaim'd ■■ up! * ■ n iom ami detailed how l»e . ame to b*< j I the Lm'hl new* pap •! . \f "A ni->iT' - I engae ( u| ?< s counsel The whole thing I The b i .1: ■ r I I ’ ; ('oL I I hii!

See moreSee less

"f tim Texas I ’acili • Ht Catcher < t ul-f '* do. -. 1 i; . , >sI oil W"ii :. iidnimm.r him ilia! a sible f.'A •s ■ a.• iI‘I \ ill t. : lie ■ .'3 • ii"!du)» of l‘t ■ ’ra : n was anticip ued Wi II" S' i•i‘ ■ - , ■ - < <ii ■ '. lig I' I L>i i• "'glit near Si raw u. T«*x. have S' 'n ■ i ' ’! 1 • - I •■: .; ' TinO i.u '.ill have a largo aipount I e.r four <■ - . '.-.ii.i:-'at'"a:r ( i.'ll' ... ' :■ • 'I . • t i'p .Ilf.-. 'i 'l'-', in ' • Ur k' " i-' ’ i' . i ill i ■ i}." 1 ■ 11. i t Imre ur d:m st t w•» .! : •] ; .1 «•*’.■<■: ■• ?- \ 1. • ■ . f • i .

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

This damaged clipping mixes a description of a Methodist Episcopal church conference's territorial boundaries with a denial by F. E. Blackman of contact with H. H. Holmes, a note about an undisturbed cellar floor, and a mention of delayed congressional district returns.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 24 November 1894 · page 3

SAW MINNIE WILLIAMS.

First Methodist Episcopal church south care of F. E. Blackman, Chicago. F. building. Rev. M. S. Hotchkiss, pastor E. Blackman flatly contradicts the in charge. statement that the correspondence be This is one of the larged conferences tween Qeorgiana Yoke Howard and her in the west. Its confines extend ns far mother passed through his oflice. He south as Freestone county, east to the said he never met II. II. Holmes or Trinity river, west to Tom Green Qeorgiana in his life. county, to the southeast ornev of New The cellar floor at 701 Sixty-third Mexico, and on the north to the north street still rests undisturbed.

See moreSee less

The neigh east corner of Texas, turning south to bors with their shovels did not appear the north fork of Red river, an l down to unearth the mysteries of the basement that to the northwest corner of Wichita official returns so far have been received from only two district*. But even if the certificates were filed representing all the districts of the entire country the clerk would not be disposed to issue the official roll of the next congress be fore the expiration of the present con gress. 1 he official in the clerk's office expresses the opinion that the comple tion of this list will be delayed until March 4.

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

The fragment states that none of Holmes' friends trust his confession, suggesting it may only be meant to mislead those investigating his record.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 24 November 1894 · page 3

SAW MINNIE WILLIAMS.

upon. None of Holmes’ friends place any reliance upon his confession except as it may delude those who would pry I into his record. _

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The clipping, a fragment, references a letter from Pitzel in St. Louis promising to clear debt on his furniture and remove it, noting four letters have been written.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Morning Call · 24 November 1894 · page 1

MAIL FOR PITZEL

from Pitzel from St. Louis in which he promised to soon clear the outstanding indebtedness on his furniture and effect its removal. Four letters have been written

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif. · and 1 other paper

Chicago police report new clews on Benjamin F. Pitzel, linked to H.H. Holmes, including unreturned letters sent to him in St. Louis, and say Minnie Williams may still be alive despite rumors of her murder.

The Morning Call · 24 November 1894 · page 1

Chicago, Nov. 23.— Chicago police have obtained a clew regarding Benjamin F. Pitzel, the accomplice of H.H. Holmes, alias Howard, who is now detained at Philadelphia on charges of having swindled an insurance company. The In surance was placed on Pitzei's life and on September 30 last a body supposed to have been his was found in Philadelphia. Pit zel had lived up to May 1 on Madison ave nue, near Fifty-third street. It was found that Pitzel had vacated his Morgan flat apartments on May 5, and that the fur niture had been stored at 492 Sixty-third street.

See moreSee less

On or about August 1 last he was In the city ostensibly to make arrange ments regarding the removal of his house hold effects to St. Louis, where he in tended making his home for the winter. The St. Louis address was given as 2306 Michigan street. A letter was received from Pitzel from St. Louis in which he promised to soon clear the outstanding indebtedness on his furniture and effect its removal. Four letters have been written to Pi'zel at St. Louis, aud none have been returned to the writer, despite the fact that the precaution was taken to place tbe writer's address with the usual request for return on the outside of each envelope. This, the police think, shows that if Pitzel himself is not alive and living at St Louis some one is representing him there who knows every detail connected with his business transactions. The handwriting of the St. Louis letter corresponds with that of the one mailed at Philadelphia by Pitzel. Nothing has yet been discovered as to the whereabouts of Minnie Williams and her sister Anna. The impression is gain ing, however, that Minnie, at least, is a confederate of Holme-. It is believed tbe detection of the incendiary fire at Engle wood scared the outfit badly enough to make them get out of town without taking Anna's trunk. It has been discovered that mail is being sent to Mrs. Mary Yobe, the mother of Georgian* Yohe, at Franklin, Ind., every few days. The en velopes-were marked, "Return to No. 69 Dearborn street, care of F. E. Blackman, Chicago." 71 * F. E. Blackman last night flatly contra dicted tbe statement that the correspond ence between Georgiana Yohe and her mother passed through his ofliee. He de nied all knowledge of tbe parties and said he never met H. H. Holmes or Georgiana Yohe in his life. He said his only connec tion with tbe case arose through lending money on the security of a lease on the Holmes bouse at Englewood. Some commercial traveler who alighted from the Erie train at Sixty-third street last evening saw a photograph of a young woman said to be Minnie R. Williams. "I saw tbat woman in Buffalo last week." was his comment, and when he was told the fair original bad been murdered, ac cording to popular supposition, some weeks before, be looked incredulous. The police also think Miss Williams is alive and able to make a report when called upon. None of Holmes' friends place any reliance upon his confession, except as it may delude those who would pry into his record. • Philadelphia, Nov. 23. — Holmes to night retracted many of the statements made or said to nave been made to a de tective when coming to tbe city from Bos-, ton. He declared that both tbe Williams girls were alive, and that Anna was re cently paid ?1000 by Pitzel in New York City. The story of her murder and numer ous other crimes with which bis name was linked, he characterized as "rot" invented to throw the detectives off the track.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me. · 24 November 1894

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Chicago police report tracing a possible trail of Benjamin Pitzel to St. Louis, citing letters and unpaid furniture bills as evidence he might still be living. Meanwhile Holmes reportedly retracts parts of an earlier confession given to a detective en route to Philadelphia.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Herald · 24 November 1894 · page 3

IS PITZEL AMONG THE LIVING?

from Pitzel from St. Louis, in which he promised to soon clear the outstanding indebtedness on his larnituie and effect ita removal. Four letters have been written to Pitzel at St. I. mis and none have been returued by him, despite the fact that the precaution was taken to place the writer's address with the usual request for return on tbe out aide of each envelope. This, the police think, chows that if Pitzel himself ia not alive and living at St. Louis, some one ia representing him there tbat knows every detail connected with hia business transactions.

See moreSee less

The handwriting of the St. Louis letter corresponds with the one mailed at Philadelphia by Pitzel. Philadelphia, Nov. 23. —Holmes to night retracted many of the statements. be ia said to have made to a detective when coming to the city from Boston. He declared both the Williams girls are alive, and that Anna was recently paid $1000 by Pitzel in New York city. The story of her murder, and sevoral other crimes witb wbich his name was linked, he characterized as "rot," invented to throw tbe detectives off tbe track.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

A St. Louis dispatch reports that relatives revealed the missing Williams girls, linked to a man named Holmes accused of insurance swindling, are currently in Europe, having gone there some time ago.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Evening Journal · 24 November 1894 · page 1

Williams Cilrls In Europe. St. Louie Nov. 34.—A special to Thi Republic from Now Orleans says: "A talk with relatives of tbe missing Wil Hams girls, who have gained so muot notoriety as tho result of their connectiez with Holmes, tbe alleged Insurance swin dler, reveals their whereabouts. Th. Misses Williams are In Europe, where the] wont some time ago.'' National Hank Suspends. Washington, Nov. 24.—The oomptrol

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping reports that officials plan to re-exhume the body believed to be Pitezel's for further identification, while Holmes and Mrs. Pitezel are jailed at Moyamensing and Holmes retracts earlier statements to detectives.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 24 November 1894 · page 3

HUNTING THE ALLEGED DEAD MAN. The Chicago Police Believe They Have a Clew ' Will Dead Pitezel—The Philadelphia Prisoners Now loyamenslng. In Philadelphia, Nov. 84.—Tho Piteael Holines-Howe conspiracy murder mystery has taken an interesting and important turn by tho announcement from an official source that the body of Perry, or Pltozel, will again be exhumed and auother effort made to identify it. It will bo rememl>ered by those who have followed the history of this extra ordinary cuso that Mrs. Pitezol never saw the dead body of tho man who was said to be her husband.

See moreSee less

The identification made by her daughter, and It was stated that within the last few days the daughter had expressed her doubts as to the elusiveness of the identifying marks. So that all doubt in this connection may be removed, tho intelligence comes from authoritative source that the body will be re-exhumed so that Mrs. Pitczel may bo given all tho facilities possible for de termining whether or not it is tho body of her husband. The body is burled in Me chanics' cemetery. Yesterday Holmes and Mrs. Pitczel committed to Moyamensing prison, there to await trial. Secretary Crow, of the So ciety for tho Prevention of Cruelty to Children, volunteered to take care of the 10-year-old daughter and the 1-year old baby, but Mrs. Pitczel objected to having her baby taken from her. Dr. Andrews expressed the opinion that the mother's physical condition would not pormit her to core for the baby unassisted, and It finally arranged that the children should accompany her. Lawyer Harry Hawkins has been re tained to defend Holmes, the money being furnished by a mysterious friend from Chicago. To Hawkins Holmes earnestly declared that he had never been guilty of murder. Lawyer Hawkins 6ays that Holmes complains bitterly of the spiriting away of his wife. He has not been per mitted to see her since he was locked up nt the Centrul station, and he does not know where she is. It is tho intention of the lawyer to go into court and apply for a vrrit of habeas corpus, and demand that Mrs. Holmes be produced. Holmes has retracted many of the state meuts made or alleged to have been made to a detective when coming to this oity from Boston. He declared that both tho Williams girls are alive, and that Anna ;ceutly paid $1,000 by Pitczel in New York city. Tho story of her murder and numerous other crimes with which his name was linked ho characterized "rot," invented to throw the detectives off the scent. The learuod that tho detectives when it looking for •n with Pitezel and who disap peaml about the time the body The theory is that either he had something to do with hauling tho body himself murdered. the Discovery of development yesterday expressman who had found. 1 G.':. ! *

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that Pitzel moved his household effects toward a St. Louis address, promised to clear his furniture debt, but four follow-up letters sent to him there, each marked for return, have gone unanswered.

The Washington Times · 24 November 1894 · page 1

BELIEVE PITZEL IS ALIVE

he was in the city, ostensibly to make arrange ments regarding the removal of his house hold effeote to St. Louis, where he intended making his home for the winter. The St. Louis address was given at 290G Michigan street. A letter was received from Pitzel from St. Louis, in which he promised to soon clear the standing indebtedness on his furniture And effect its removal Four letters have been written to Pitael at St. Louis and Bone has been returned, despite the faet that the precaution was taken to place the writer's eiiress, with the ufeual request far return on

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

This fragment notes that handwriting on a St. Louis letter matches one mailed from Philadelphia by Holmes, and says Minnie Williams and her sister Anna remain missing with growing suspicion Minnie is his confederate.

The Washington Times · 24 November 1894 · page 1

LETTERS IN HIS HANDWRITING

connected with his business transactions. The IiandwwUng of the St. Louis letter corres ponds with that of the one mailed at PbilaQeip&ia by fitse. Nothing has yet been discovered as to the whereabouts of Minnie Williams and her sister Anna. The impression is growing, however, that Minnie is a confederate of Holmes. It is believed the

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that the corpse's teeth show distinctive traits, including missing and overlapping teeth, which Mrs. Pitzel should recognize if she knew her husband's teeth well.

The Washington Times · 24 November 1894 · page 1

SHOULD KNOW HIM BY HIS TEETH.

the first attempt at identification. It is saia that the teeth of the coroe had several strik ing peculiarities which Mrs. Pitzel should readily recognise if she was ever familiar with her husband a teeth. Several of them are missing and & overlap each other.

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

The garbled item reports true bills of indictment against a person under arrest at Boston, Jeptha D. Howe (a St. Louis lawyer), and Mrs. Carrie A. Pitezel, alias Cork, in connection with Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes.

The Washington Bee · 24 November 1894 · page 4

true bills of indictment against Her who is under arrest at Boston; Jeptha D. Howe, a St. Louis lawyer, and Mrs. Carrie A. Pitezel, alias Cork, for man Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes,

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C. · 1 December 1894

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

H. H. Holmes and Mrs. Pitezel were moved from a Philadelphia police station to the county prison, with her children allowed to accompany her, while Chicago police reported finding clues about Benjamin F. Pitezel's movements before his reported death.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

New-York Tribune · 24 November 1894 · page 2

DITEZEL BEMOVED TO PRISON PITEZEL REMOVED To PRISON Philadelphia, Nov. 23.-H. H. Holmes and Mm, Pltezel, the alleged insurance conspirators, were res moved this afternoon from the central police station, where they have been since their arrival, to the county prison. No efforts to secure bail for eithes of them was made, The Soclety for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children proposed to take charge of Mrs. Pitezel's two children, but she begged =o pits ously that they be allowed to go to pri=on with he that the police surgeon. gave ft as his opinion that in the woman's nervous condition it woull be dan gerous to her health to separate her from them, and they were allowed by the society to 20 wi her.

See moreSee less

Thera !s Httie doubt that Holmes will plead gully to the charge of consplracy to defraud when he ls brought to trial, as he has repeatedly confessed hig crime. and to-day to his lawyers he sail he was weary of being a fugitive. To the charge of murder, however, he will make a defence to the last and fully expects to be able to prove that Pitezel is alive, without even having to produce him. Jeptha I. Howe, the young St. Louis lawyer who is indieted with Holmes, and Mrs. Piezo], spent toe fay in consultation with his attorney ant he will return to St. Louis to-morrow morning Mr. Hawkins, one of the attorneys engaged for Holmes, admitted to-day that his client hal strong friends somewhere in Philadelphia, and that they | were making every effort to aid him. Mr Hawking received an additional fee of £250 to-lay for under taking the defence of Holmes, but he de ned te say from whom the money had come Chicago, Nov. 23.—The Woodlawn police to-day obtained a clew regarding Benjamin F. Pitezel the | accomplice of H. H. Holmes, alias Howard, who 18 | now detained in Philadelphia on charges of having swindled an insurance company out of $10,000, | | Soon after the account of Holmes's arrest had | been published and the story of Pirezdis leath | had been given out, the police of the Woodlawn | station thought they recognized in the des ription | of Pitezel a man who had lived in the Morgan | flats in Madison-ave., near Sixty-third-st They | followed up the case and found that the suspect was Pitezel, and that he had left his Morgan flat apartments on May 1, storing his furniture at Curtis Brothers’ warehouse. Early © August, Pitezel was in the city ostensibly ‘o make are rangements regarding the removal of his houses hold effects to St. Louis, where he intended 10

See the clipping

Elmore Bulletin · Rocky Bar, Idaho

The clipping reports an attorney's arrest for conspiring with H. H. Holmes to defraud an insurance company, notes firm Australian wool auction results from Melbourne, and describes a funeral after a shooting near Massillon where family members vowed revenge and a mob formed to lynch the marshal involved, though the text is partly garbled by OCR errors.

Elmore Bulletin · 24 November 1894 · page 4

INSURANCE MEN ARE AFTER HIM.

«t. Louis, Nov. 10.—Jeptha E. Howe, an attorney having an office with the law firm of McDonald A Howe, of this city, was arrested today on the charge of conspiring with one H. H. Holmes to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life In surance Company of Philadelphia, ou» of *10,000. Holmes, or H. M. Howard, as he was known tn this city, got Into trou ble last summer by selling a stock of drugs on which there was a shortage. London, Nov. IL—Cable advices from Melbourne, dated today, say the wool aucUon sales there are progressing firmly.

See moreSee less

Ths competlUon, both British and continental, la active, excepting French, whfeft M siygglsh The Amerl growths are slightly weaker, hqt other sorts ays un ch anged Thj> total p of bales catalogued fpr rale Australia up to dato is 28.BM. of which 23.000 hsvs bran sold Massillon. O.. Nov. 1L—H4 Morgan, one of the gang charged with having outraged a woman at Pike Run. and who waa shot by Marshal Just, was bu rled yesterday. At tbs funeral Mor gante father and brother took an oath to kill Jam, and Mr* Morgan swore to be • ng«-d if either wars killed tn tbe at tempt A mob has been organised to lynch Just, bat as yet no leader has Australian Wool Sales. (JWd «*»«► open Seedy and burry a want a. «»**»» Bh ut

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The damaged clipping reports that a body will be disinterred so Mrs. Pitzel can attempt to identify it, with a garbled reference to officials including M. De Giers and Count Vorontsoff-Dachkoff.

The Indianapolis Journal · 24 November 1894 · page 5

body will be disinterred for the purpose of ill having Mrs. Pitzel endeavor to identify it. It will be remembered that Mrs. Pitiel was by M. De Giers, the Minister of Foreign Affairs, and by Count Vorontsoff-JJachkoff, the Minister of the Imperial Court. The

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The clipping reports that Holmes's lawyers told him he acted foolishly in confessing to Fidelity Mutual Life Association representatives, that Holmes insists Pitezel is alive, and that his lawyers refused to defend him against a murder charge, while Lawyer Hawkins wrote to Superintendent Linden protesting the authorities' secreting of Holmes's third wife and preventing her from seeing him; the text cuts off mid-sentence.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 24 November 1894 · page 2

DECLARES PITEZEL IS ALIVE.

Philadelphia, Nov. 23.—Lawyers Haw kins and Shoemaker had a long confer ence with Holmes, today. At the liegin ning of the talk, the lawyers informed their client that lie had acted the "part of a fool, pure and simple.” in unbosoming himself and making such startling confes sions as are alleged to have been made to ! representatives of the Fidelity Mutual Life Association. Holmes declared to his attorneys that Pitezel is alive, and said ' his whereabouts would be located when ; his (Holmes’) mail was forwarded from | Chicago.

See moreSee less

He was given to understand by his lawyers that they would not defend him if a murder charge was made. Lawyer Hawkins, today, wrote a letter I to Superintendent of Police Linden de i daring that the action of the authorities , j in secreting Mrs. Holmes, who is said to ' lie the arch-conspirator’s third wife, and i preventing her from seeing her husband j

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Chicago police traced Benjamin F. Pitezel, accomplice of H. H. Holmes, to former Madison avenue lodgings and a storage warehouse, and believe letters sent to him in St. Louis show he is still alive there.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 24 November 1894 · page 2

Lived in Chicago Las! May—Has Since Chicago, Nov. 23.—The Woodlawn police, today, obtained a clue regarding Benjamin F. Pitezel, the accomplice of II. H. lb lines, now detained in Philadel phia mi charges of having swindled an in surance company of f 10,000. Shortly af ter tinaccount of Holmes’ arrest was pub lished, the police at Wo xllawn station thought they recognized in the descrip tion of Pitezel a man who lived in Mor gan tints on Madison avenue. They fol lowed up the chase and found that the suspect was Pitezel.

See moreSee less

but that he liml vaca ted the apartments on May I. last, storing his furniture at Curtis Brothers’ ware house. Karly in August, Pitezel was ill the city, ostensibly to make arrangements re garding the removal of his household effects to St. i/mis, where he intended to make his home for the winter. He soon left for Philadelphia. Shortly afterwards a letter was received by Mr. Curtis from Pitezel in St. Louis, in which lie promised soon to dear his indebtedness on the furniture and effect a removal. Four letters were writen by Mr. Curtis to Pitezel at St. I/mis, Imt as none were returned to him despite the fact that the writer's address with the usual request to return, was placed on the outside of each envelope, the police believe Pitezel is still alive in St. Louis. CLUE TO PITEZEL. Written from St. Louis. —

See the clipping

The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.

Police report a clue about Pitsel, Holmes's alleged accomplice, tracing his movements and letters from St. Louis, while Holmes in Philadelphia retracted earlier statements and denied the Williams girls were murdered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Helena Independent · 24 November 1894 · page 1

QUICK, BUT NOT DEAD.

ve obtalned a clue regarding Bens. i. Sthe accomplice of H. H. Holmes, alias Howard, who is now detained at Philadelphia on the charge of having swindled an insurance company. A large insurance was placed on 'Pitsel's life, and Sept. 20 last the body supposed to have been his was found in Phila delphia. Pitsel had lived, up to May 1, on Madison avenue. near PFlfty-third street. It was found that Pitsel had vacated his Morgan fat apartments on May 5 and that the furniture had been stored at 412 Sixty-third street.

See moreSee less

On or about Aug. 1 last he was in the city os tensibly to make arrangements regard ing the removal of his household effects to St. Louis, where he Intended making his home for the winter. The St. Louis address was given as 230 Michigan street. A letter was received from Pitsel from St. Louis, In which he promised to soon clear the outstanding indebtedness on his furniture and effect its removal. Four letters have been written to Pitsel at St. Louis and none have been re turned. This, the police think, shows that if Pitsel himself is not alive and at St. Louis, some one is representing him there who knows every detail concerned with his business transactions. Philadelphia. Nov. 23.-Holmes to night retracted many of the statements made, or said to have been made, to a detective when coming to the city of Boston. He declared that both the Wil liams girls were alive and that Anna was recently pkid $1.000 by Pitsel in New York. The story of her murder and numerous other crimes with which his name was linked, he characterized as "rot." invented to throw detectives off the track.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A traveling man recounts a case he encountered about three years earlier involving a New Jersey family whose members held life insurance policies, beginning with the father's death from an apparent stomach ailment, before the clipping breaks off.

Omaha Daily Bee · 24 November 1894 · page 5

CHATS IN THE CORRIDORS

"The story of H. H. Holmes , the Insura : iwlndler , which has been published In newspapers during the last few days , rcci to my mind a case that came under my nol about three years ago , " said an eastern Ua\ Ing man who wu seated tn the corridor ot Mlllard hotel list night "H occurred Ir little Inland ; town. In New Jersey. A fan by the-name of Sbano , I think , were reside ot the placet It confuted ot father t mother , two eons and a daughter.

See moreSee less

All male membershid. . their lives Insured fo ; imall amount , about $3,000. t think tt i In favor of the wife arid mother. About th years ago last spring the father died site lingering sickness. A doctor's certificate > presented to the Insurance company , show test ho had died of a stomach trouble , i Hi

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

The clipping reports that Holmes, under arrest, insisted Pitzel was still alive and denied shedding blood, that his wife's whereabouts were being withheld prompting a habeas corpus threat, and that Woodlawn police believed they found a clew to Pitzel's whereabouts via stored furniture and a St. Louis letter.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

The Scranton Tribune · 24 November 1894 · page 1

PLAIN TALK BY HIS ATTORNEY

ference. At the very beginning of the talk Holmes was bluntly and emphatically Informed that he had acted the part of a fool, pure and simple, in unburdening himself and making such startling con fesslons as are alleged to have been made to the representatives of the in surance company. To his nttorney He declared with much emphasis that Pit zel was still alive, and that his wherea bouts can be located when his (Holmes) mall is forwarded from Chicago Holmes expressed himself as being su premely happy that he was under ar rest, and asserted that even If his cell door were thrown wide open he would not attempt to escape.

See moreSee less

While he ad mitted that he was guilty of many crimes, he declared with much earnest ness that he was not guilty of shedding human blood, and that murder could not be charged up against him. Holmes seems to have a mania for hypnotism, and although uopn all other subjects he talks with rare Intelligence, when this, subject is brought up he seems to lose control of himself. Where Is .Mrs Holmes? When Mrs. Holmes came to this city In company wit her husband and Mrs. Pitzel ,she was placed in a hotel, but . afterward removed to a house, the ad dress of which the police have refused to make known. Today Lawyer Hawkins wrote a let ter to the superintendent, saying that the secreting of Mrs. Holmes and deny ing her the privilege of visiting and consulting with her husband In this, his greatest hour of need, was a wrong. He stated that unless the woman was produced at an early date, a writ of habeas corpus would be applied for to compel the superintendent or those hav ing the woman In custody to produce her. District Attorney Graham said this afternoon that no time had been set for the trying of the case. Clew to Pitzel's Whereabouts. Chicago, Nov. 23. The Woodlawn po lice today obtained a clew regarding B. F. Pitzel, the accomplice of H. H. Holmes, who is now detained In Philahla on charges of having swindled Insurance company.. .Shortly after e account of Holme's arrest wao pub lished and the story of Pitzel's death given out, the police of the Woodlawn station thought they recognized In the description of Pitzel a man who had lived in the Morgan flats on Madison avenue, near Sixty-third street. They followed up the case and found that the suspect was Pitzel, and that he had va cated his Morgan Hat apartments on May 1 last, storing his furniture at Curtis Bros', warehouse. Early In August Pitzel was In the city ostensibly to make arrangements regarding the removal of his household effects to St. Louis, where he Intended to make his home for the winter. He soon left for Philadelphia, and the above facts regarding his St. Louis ar rangements, It is said, are embodied In a letter written to Mr. Curtis from that place. The St. Louis address was given as 2,306 Michigan street. Shortly after ward a letter was received from Pitzel In St. Louis, In which he promised soon to clear the standing Indebtedness on his furniture and effect Its removal. Four letters have been written by Mr. Curtis to Pitzel at St. Louis, and as none have been returned to him the po lice firmly believe that Pitzel Is alive and in St. Louis. Nailed His Own Lies. Philadelphia, Nov. 23. Holmes and Mrs. Pitzel were removed this afternoon from the central police station to the county prison. The Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children pro posed to take charge of Mrs. Pitzel's two children, but she begged so plteous ly to allow them to go to mlson with her that Police Surgeon Andrews gave It as his opinion that in the woman's nervous condition It would be danger ous to her health to separate her from her children. To the charge of murder, Holmes will make a defense to the last and fully expects to be able to prove that Pitzel is alive without even having to produce him. Holmes nailed one of his own lies today by retracting the story that one of the Williams girls had been murdered 4n Chicago and that he had burled her body In the lake. He said that the girl had not been killed, but that she Is now traveling In Europe. tions pronounced. known. File an Account. Colonel Edward C. James. and Pacific railway. of the Soldiers' home. his estate has yet been filed. Sub-Treasury Gold. By the United Press. Amount of Income Tux. Bv the United Press. Wilson bill. with Typhoid lever. By the United Press. suffering with typhoid fever. moving to get one. ness to Jail. acre. sessors. .

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Chicago police have obtained a clue regarding Pitzel, accomplice of Holmes alias Howard, who is detained in Philadelphia on charges of swindling an insurance company out of $10,000.

Alexandria Gazette · 24 November 1894 · page 2

Dr. F. L. Sims, one of the most emi? nent physicians in that section, died at his homo in Memphis yesterday, aged sixty years. The amount to be appropriated for pensions for the next liscal vear is placed at $141,3S1,570,?$10,000,000less than last year. The Knights of Labor adjourned their general assembly at New Orleans yes? terday, after denouncing the issue of bonds by the United States government. The new convention of amity, com? merce, and navigation between the ^United States and Japan has been con? cluded and now awaits ratification by the Senate.

See moreSee less

The proposed extension of civil ser? vice principles and regulations to di? plomatic and consular service along the lines laid down in the Morgan bill is exciting comment. It is stated that the Rev. Father Rookes, vice-rector of the American College at Rome, will succeed the Rev. Father Papi as secretary to the apos? tolic delegation at Washington. For the first time in the history of North Carolina, a Roman Catholic has been elected a judge of the State Su? perior Court, in the person of W. S. O'B. Robinson, the republican-populist nominee for the Raleigh district. Mrs. W. I\ Evans, a dairyman's wife in Petuluma, Cal., yesterday saturated her clothing with coal oil and then set her garments on fire. She wag burned to death. She. had been previously in? sane, hut had been released from the asylum. The story current iu the West that Senator Jones, of Nevada, and Senator Dou Cameron, of Pennsylvania, are proceeding to the organization of a new political party designed to give Mr. Jones free silver, Mr. Cameron a presi? dential nomination and incidental ben? efits to the country is causing consider? able talk among politicians in Washing? ton. Carnegie's wire nail works, occupy? ing a whole square in Beaver Falls. Pa., were burned last night. The to? tal loss will reach $100,000. The works were equipped with the finest machinery, all of which was destroy? ed. Two hundred men will be thrown out of employment and the fire will likely stop the whole Carnegie inter? ests in that place. The Philadelphia authorities have decided to exhume the body upon which the Fidelity Life Insurance Com? pany paid to Holmes and his fellow conspiiators $10,000 and determine whether or not it is that of Pitezel. The Chicago police have obtained a clue regarding Pitzcl, the accomplice of Holmes, alia? Howard, who is now detained in Philadelphia on charges of swindling an insurance company out of $10,000. NEWS OF THE DAY.

See the clipping

The Morning Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This damaged, jumbled clipping mentions Franz Kossuth being seriously ill, criticism of an Archbishop's political involvement, a matter concerning one B. F. Pitezel, and Mount Rainier becoming visible again after unusual phenomena.

The Morning Call · 26 November 1894 · page 1

IS A MYSTERY YET.

The dispatch adds that Franz Kossuth.' the Western States and Territories are whose ac'ioEs in Hungary have given rise directly interested and pave the way for to much criticism, is seriously 111. Yoru of the Archbishop of St. Paul to sively wbat they nave done in the matter take part in a political contest was undig of undine B. F. Pitezel. It is believed they nified, disgraceful to bis Episcopal office will know something definite to-morrow Rainier became visible this afternoon for the first time since the phenomena at its summit were observed last Wednesday,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A clipping reports bicycle racer Otto Hardifer was badly hurt in a training crash at Clifton, N.J., and separately that Detroit police questioned a Mrs. Lucinda Burns, who first denied but then admitted having briefly cared for H. H. Holmes's Pitezel children before he took them away.

New-York Tribune · 26 November 1894 · page 1

TRAINING AT CLIFTON WITH TH FOR PION BICYCLE CHAMPIONS, While training yesterday afternoon on the old racetrack at Clifton, N. J., with the foreign cham pions, Otto Hardifer, the crack bicycle rider, whe is entered in the international tournament to open to-morrow evening, was badly injured. The rim ot his front wheel burst and the rider was thrown heavily forward. His skull was fractured, but how badly has not yet been determined, He was re moved to his home in Passaic. — ess rptrive THE CHILDREN OF PITEZEL Detroit, Mich., Nov.

See moreSee less

2i.—The Dcotroit police were last night asked to look up Mrs. Lucinda Burns and ascertain whether she had in her possession the two children of Pltezel, whom the Insurance swin dler, H. H. Holmes, confessed yesterday afternoon to Philadelphia police that he had left with Mrs. Burns while in this city October 12. The woman was found in a cheap boarding-house on Congress st. At first she refused to discuss the matter, but finally denied that she had the chiddren or Knew where they were, or had ever seen Holmes, Late last night Mrs Burns withdrew her denials, and said she had had charge of the Pitezel children for several weeks, Three weeks ago, however, Holmes came to the city and took them away, she knows not where, at the same time “beating” her out of 8 2 haard Bi lpr

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

This fragment is too damaged by OCR errors to make out clearly, though it appears to mention bids opened at the treasury department and a question of whether someone named Pitzel is dead or alive.

Rock Island Argus · 26 November 1894 · page 2

A baaa of Second tbH Matter TVawaparta. tfcan Keaaarfca oa ClvU Herrlce Whfck Is Kadkmlly Approred Tha Naw Secretary Carlisle were opened at the treasury department . at the appointed whether Pitzel is dead or nlive.

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

A German-language clipping describes how insurance association detectives, seeking information on a policy taken out for Peitzel in 1893, were directed to H. H. Holmes, who had shared an office with Peitzel during the Chicago World's Fair, and whose wife promised to notify him.

Freie Presse Für Texas · 26 November 1894 · page 1

langten eine Personalbeschreibung des Peitzei. Die Police war tm 10. Nov. 1893 durch die Vermittlung eines an gesehenen Geschäftsmannes erlangt worden; da aber dieser sich nicht mehr an den Fall erinnern konnte, verwies Ier die Geheimpoltzisten der Association an einen gewissen H. H. Holmes, der während der Weltausstellung in Chi cago mit Peitzel in dem nämlichen Zim mer eine Osfice gehabt hatte. Holmes, s ein Geschäftsreisender. war nicht zu finden; seine Frau, welcher er einen Auf-schnitt über einen Todesfall in Chicago gab, sagte aber dem Geheim polizisten, sie wolle ihn benachrichtigen. Einige Tage später erhielt der Ge-· schäftssührer in Chicago von Holmes

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

This damaged, OCR-garbled German-language clipping describes Holmes and a man named Peigel/Peitzel running businesses together in Chicago during the World's Fair, including a hotel used to hide swindled merchandise, and an insurance company's detectives tracing Holmes after a policy dispute.

Freie Presse Für Texas · 26 November 1894 · page 1

feiern Don-e hatte den Dolmes, wel cher unter dem Namen H. D. Doward verhaftet worden war, erfolgreich ver theidigt. Außerdem sollte die Advoka tenfirma McDonald und Howe eine zweifelhafte Reputation haben. dolmes und Peigel in Cbicaga with rend der Weltansftellnng zusammen Geschäfte betrieben hatten. Sie sollen ein Dotel mit Privat-Zimmern gehal ten haben, in welchem sie erfchwindclte Kaufmannsgütek versteckt hattet-. Die Firma hieß Camvdell, YateSFe Co« und ihr Ctabliffement hieß das »Worlds Fair Hotei«, No. 701 Sä. Straße. olmes soll auch» atkf gez fälfchte Be Stitel Haltet efen aufge-. nominen haben, auclx maen die De tektives entdeckt haben, daß derselbe Banxrgub, Falschng nnd Pserdedied Habt betrieben habe.

See moreSee less

ber 18 s m Chicago herausgenommen ’ aimes versicherte sich um einen Monat väter; Beide gaben als Zahlung Noten; die des Peiyel wurden bezahlt, während die Police des Halmeg wegen Nichtbezahlung der Wechsel verfiel. ed nun für angezeigt, ihre ganze De tektiv Force mit der Auffindung der Spur des Holmes zu beauftragen. enau mit einander bekannt gewesen Bald nachher wurde entdeckt, daß Pei .el’«·s Police wurde im Novem Die VersicherungssCompagnie hielt

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

A Terre Haute dispatch reports that H. H. Holmes was likely with Pitzel when Pitzel was arrested on Oct. 3 for trying to pass forged checks, and details Pitzel's bond, patent deeds, a Chicago lot transfer, and a prosecutor's inquiry into Pitzel's character.

The Indianapolis Journal · 27 November 1894 · page 2

HOLMES IX TEH RE HAUTE.- He Furnished Dud Paper for Pit-el to Special to the Indianapolis Journal. TERRE HAUTE. Ind., Nov. 26. It Is now thought that H. H. Holmes, the Phila delphia swindler, was in this city with Pitzel Oct. 3, 1S33, the day tho latter was arrested for attempting to pass forged checks. Pitzel told the several clothiers i In whose stores he selected clothing, to be called for later in the day, that he ex pected to receive money from an employer, a man named Morgan. This was the alias Holmes was using in St.

See moreSee less

Louis and else the stores after banking hours and of of an alleged Wisconsin lumber firm, say ing Morgan had arrived In the city after banking hours. One check was for $100 and another for $47, and he wanted the difference between the cost of clothing and the check In cash. He was not accom modated, but was arrested. A man who answers the description of Holmes was seen with him, but after his arrest was not seen. Pitzel said he came here from Indianapolis, where he had been selling patent rights. He sent his lawyer to Chi came here and, with E. S. Erney, signed Pltzel's bond for $500, thereby securing his release. The bond was forfeited, but never collected. Among Pitzel's effects were sev eral deeds for patents. There was also a deed for a lot in Chicago. It Is dated Jan. 21. 1893, and by James Shaw and wife transferred to Pitzel lot 32, in block 172, in Harvey's subdivision of Chicago. The consideration was $1,000. The instrument showed that here was a mortgage for $700 on the property, the mortgage being held by the Fidelity Building and Savings Union of Indianapolis. Acknowledgement Is made before Charles E. Garvin, a notary of Chi cago. Prosecuting Attorney Hamill visited Chicago while Pitzel was In jail, and says he was assured by respectable people there that Pitzel was an honorable man, and that what he ,did here was done while under the Influence of drink. eKOtiitte. where about that time. TiUel called at fered what purported to be certified checks cago to see II. If. Holmes. The latter

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The clipping details H. H. Holmes's crimes, comparing his insurance fraud schemes with bogus corpses to the Bonds of Charleston, though noting the Bonds never committed murder, and separately reports uncertainty over whether an English correspondent killed by Chinese forces near Port Arthur was Frederic Villiers.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Helena Independent, 24 November 1894, The Scranton Tribune, 24 November 1894.

The Morning News · 28 November 1894 · page 4

H. H. Holmes, the Philadelphia insur ance swindler and murderer, a sum mary of whose career was printed In this paper the other day, bids fair to show up as the most remarkable criminal Df the period. Every day adds blackness to the history of his life. He not only committed several murders for the purpose of getting Insurance money and worked several schemes to the same end with bogus corpses, but It appears from what he says that ho actually loved his work; he en joyed murder and reveled In fraud.

See moreSee less

His operations recall those of the Honda is Charleston several years ago; but the llonds were never murderers. They car ried on a brisk business In Insuring lie titious persons, having them die of Imag inary diseases, showing up bogus corpses and then collected the insurance money, but they did not kill people In order to get corpses. Our cable dispatches a day or two ngo reported that an English newspaper cor respondent bad been killed by the Chinese neur Port Arthur. It Is thought in lam don that the victim may have been Fred eric Yllllers, the artist-correspondent, who won fanie, along with Archibald Forties, in the Crimean war ami elsewhere. There are several American correspondents at the seat of war, but their home offices have little fear that either of them wuu the vli Uni.

See the clipping

Watertown Republican · Watertown, Wis. · and 1 other paper

A Philadelphia grand jury indicted Herman Mudget alias H. H. Holmes, lawyer Jeptha D. Howe, and Pitzel's widow for conspiracy to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company, while Indianapolis suits sought recovery of the $10,000 insurance money deposited there.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Watertown Republican · 28 November 1894 · page 2

PLAYED A BOLD GAME

Philadelphia, Pa., Nov. 20. —The grand jury yesterday afternoon found a true bill against Herman Mudget, alias H. H. Holmes, now a prisoner in Boston; Jep tba D. Howe, the St. Louis lawyer who collected the insurance money on B. F. Pitzel’s policy for the latter’s widow, and the widow herself. The indictment reads for “conspiracy to cheat and defraud,” but officials of the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company, which was defrauded out of SIO,OOO by the game, believe that Pitzel was murdered and that his body was the burned body found at 1310 Cal low Hill street on September last and identified as that of B.

See moreSee less

F. Perry. The detectives, however, have practically abandoned the murder theory, and now think they are on the track of Pitzel in the person of a man calling himself B. F. Lyman, whose whereabouts they refuse to divulge. They state that Mrs. Pitzel has made a confession substantially the same as that of Holmes, except that she believes her husband to be in South Amer ica. She has not seen him since the al leged crime was committed. Holmes when arrested claimed that the body found bv the firemen had been secured by himself and Pitzel from a St. Louis med ical student and shipped in a trunk. Then, as the confession runs, it was tucked away in the real estate agent’s bed, sub jected to a treatment of benzine and fired. The Philadelphia officers who in vestigated the case could find no trace of the trunk and professed to believe that Holmes had really caused the death of his old colleague. Holmes is credited with being a systematic swindler, his vic tims being scattered all over the country. Indianapolis, Ind., Nov. 20. —Lawyer Albert W. Wishnrd was instructed by tele graph from Philadelphia today to file suits , for the recovery of the money obtained by H. M. Howard, now under arrest at Bos ton, part of which is now on deposit in a bank in this city. The title of the com plaint tiled is the Fidelity Mutual Life as sociation against H. M. Howard alias H. M. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgett and Georgiana Howard. The plaintiff alleges that he is engaged in the business of life insurance and that he issued a policy on the life of one B. F. Pitzel for $10,00; that by a mistake on the part of the plaintiffs the deception and fraudulent representa tion on the part of the defendant ,the said Howard received the sum of $10,000; that afterward the plaintiff discovered that E. F. Pitzel was till alive; that the proofs of the claim were spurious and fraudulent and made for the express purpose of cheat ing the plaintiff out of the! insurance money; that he defendant fled the country turning over and paying to his codefendant, Georgiana Howard, a large portion of the SIO,OOO, which the defendant deposited in the bank i nthis city. An affidavit for writ of attachment is also tiled. ■ * .

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · 29 November 1894

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho

The clipping reports that B. F. Pitzel, central figure in the Philadelphia insurance swindle involving H. H. Holmes, formerly lived in St. Joseph, Mo., and left about three years ago owing numerous unpaid bills.

The Weiser Signal · 29 November 1894 · page 4

PITZEL MYSTERY HARD TO SOLVE

yei ago. PITZEL'S RECORD. St. Joseph, Mo.. Nov. 21.— B. F. Pit zel, who is the central figure in the Philadelphia insurance swindle, for which offense H. H. Holmes is now un der arrest, is a former resident of this city and left here about three years ago under a cloud. He left numerous un paid bills. DENTITY OF HOWARD.

See the clipping

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho

The clipping reports that Miss Kate Durkee, a third woman linked to H. H. Holmes, has mysteriously vanished after property obtained through alleged theft came into Holmes's hands, with creditor George B. Chamberlin saying he believes she, like the Williams sisters, was murdered.

The Weiser Signal · 29 November 1894 · page 4

PITZEL MYSTERY HARD TO SOLVE

rival In this city. MORE MURDER STORIES. Chicago, Nov. 21.—Following close on the story of the mysterious disappear ance of the Williams sisters, at the hands of Holmes, swindler, comes a third woman victim, namely, Miss Kate Durkee. kee had property, sentlng the property came int hands of H. H. Holmes by theft, woman mysteriously disappeared, and Holmes showed title to the property. Miss Durkee was not Miss Williams. She had dark eyes and hair, while Miss Williams was a blonde. A year ago today 25 creditors of H. H. Holmes met at the office of George B.

See moreSee less

Chamberlin, and made a desperate ef fort to find out who and where Miss Durkee was. It was supposed that she was an accomplice of Holmes: that the property Illegally obtained w transferred to her name. '» wished to reach it. Durkee dropped entirely from sight, and like the Williams sisters, has left no trace behind. murdered," said Chamberlin today. "1 believe also both the Williams girls were murdered." Mr. Chamberlin, propriet or of the Lafayette Mercantile agency, began an investigation of Holmes yei ago. PITZEL'S RECORD. the life insurance Miss Dur Doc mts repre the The being The credit Suddenly Kate "I believe she was a

See the clipping

The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho

A dispatch from Tilton reports that H. H. Howard, alias Holmes, has been identified as Herman W. Mudgett, with his wife describing his early life and a brief visit two weeks earlier before he left for Boston.

The Weiser Signal · 29 November 1894 · page 4

paid bills. DENTITY OF HOWARD. Tilton, N. Y„ Nov. 21.—The Identity of H. H. Howard, alias Holmes, has been clearly established here as a native of this state, Herman W. Mudgett. His wife, in an interview, during which she wm first mads acquainted with the character of her husband, gives much interesting information regarding his early life. She Is living here quietly with her 15-year-old son, and is support ing herself by dressmaking. She lost all trace of the man after he visited her in 1888 and told her that he was going to Chicago on business, until he came to her home about two weeks ago. He re mained a few hours and left for Boston, promising to come soon again.

See the clipping

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo.

A garbled Philadelphia report describes Holmes and co-defendants arrested in a Fidelity Mutual Life insurance fraud case, with a new dispatch claiming the supposedly dead Pitezel was actually seen alive in a Chicago saloon.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Iron County Register · 29 November 1894 · page 6

A GREAT SCOUNDREL.

Holmes, the Han of Many Aliases, and Frlnceipal Conspirator In the Plot Whereby the Fidelity Mutual Life In Scoundrels Unhung Pitzel, the Alleged Dead Man, Said to Have Been Seen In Chicago. Philadelphia, Not. 22. All the parties implicated in the conspiracy by which the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance Co. was defrauded out of $10,000, except B. F. Pitezel, the supposed dead man, are in Philadelphia to-day. H. H. Holmes, the arch-conspirator, accompanied by his alleged wife and Mrs. Pitezel, the latter having with her Meda, her 16-year-old of Detective Crawford and Special Agent Perry of the insurance company.

See moreSee less

Jephtha D. Howe, the St. Louis attorney, who is also under in affair, accompanied by his attorney, Marshall F. McDonald, arrived this morning. That Holmes is the most accom that has been taken into custody for some years is shown by his own con of his life. Philadelphia, Nov. 21. The sensa Mutual Life association, for which Herman Mudgett, alias Holmes, alias Howard; Lawyer Jeptha J. Howe, of St. Louis, and Mrs. Benjamin F. Pitzel have been indicted, the former and the latter being under arrest here, took a new and unexpected turn to-day. The development was in the nature of a dispatch received by President Fouse, of the Fidelity association, from the concern's Chicago representative, in which it was stated that Pitzel, the reported victim, was seen in that city within two weeks. Pitzel, according to the dispatch was located in Meyer's saloon on Sixty-ninth street, in com this shall prove to be true, it will con Pitzel is alive. President Fouse is inclined to the be he considers to be thoroughly reliable, that Pitzel is among the living. "1 think that murder was done," he stated this afternoon, "but I believe that the victim was a man other than Pitzel." GThen dwellingupon this development he continued: "Our representative fur whom Pitzel was seen, is a Chicago business man, who knows Pitzel well. "Our Chicago man subsequently saw Ryan, but the latter declared his ina parted after leaving the saloon." As Holmes maintains that the three missing Pitzel children are with their father, the discovery of the supposed victim will probably clear up the mys A GREAT SCOUNDREL. surance Co. was Swindled Ont of SIO, OOO Proves to Be One of the Greatest daughter, and baby boy, ar rived yesterday from Boston in custody dictment for being implicated in the plished and most desperate criminal fessions, which are made not as con fessions, but simply as giving the story Took a New and Unexpected Turn. tional conspiracy against the Fidelity pany with a man named Ryan. If firm what Holmes, the arch conspira tor, has persistently adhered to that lief, in view of this information, which ther says that the Mr. Ilyan, with bility to locate Pitzel, the two having tery regarding the offspring.

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

A Philadelphia grand jury indicted Holmes, lawyer Jeptha Howe, and Mrs. Pitzel for conspiracy to defraud an insurance company over B. F. Pitzel's death. Officials expressed growing suspicion that Pitzel was murdered, even as detectives reportedly abandoned that theory in favor of a fraud-only explanation.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Wrong

The Monmouth Inquirer · 29 November 1894 · page 3

MYSTERIOUS FRAUD.

She Kays She Was la the Plot, but Xow Has Fears That Holmes Has Made Way With Her Husband—Hhe I* Arrested; Also Holmes ami Lawyer Howe. Philadelphia. Nov. 20.—The grand j jury found a true bill against Mudgett, I alias H. H. Holmes, now a prisoner in Boston; Jeptha B. Howe, the St. Louis lawyer, who collected the insurance mon ey on B. F. Pltzel's policy for the latter's widow, and the widow herself. The In dictment reads for "conspiracy to cheat and defraud. ’ ’ Coroner Asbbridge and President Fouse of the Fidelity Mutual company gave the necessary evidence for the finding of the indictment.

See moreSee less

Alexander McKnigbt, vice president of the Fidelity Mutual com pany, made the following statement to a reporter: While the suspicion has grown until we are nearly positive^Ahat Benjamin F. j Pitzel was murdered, the only charge made : before the grand jury was a conspiracy to defraud.” "I am positive that the body found on ' Sept. 4 at 1310 Callowhill street, on which an Inquest was held the next day as that: of B. F. Perry, Is none other than that j of B. F. Pitzel, ” said Coroner Ashbrldge. “I am not at liberty at present to discloso my reasons for this assertion, but if I were aria pointed them out you would be con vinced, notwithstanding the stories as to the wretched man’s expatriation in South America or elsewhere, that be met his ‘death right here in Philadelphia.” It was stated that Mrs. Pitzel had been ar rested in Burlington, Vt., and made a confession. The detectives have practically aban* doned the murder theory, and now think they are on the track of Pitzel in the per son of a man calling himself B. F. Ly man, whose whereabouts they refuse to divulge. They stated that Mrs. Pitzel had made a confession substantially the same as that of Holmes except that she believes her husband to be in South America. She has not seen him since the alleged orime was committed. The insuranoe officials profess also to have received word that Holmes and Mrs. Pitzel were en route to this city, having left Boston last night. Mrs. Pitzel, it is Rtated, was decoyed from Burlington, Vt., to Boston by a communication which she supposed to be from Holmes.

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

The clipping reports on Mars observations by Percival Lowell, a W.C.T.U. resolution against vivisection, a judge's denial of the Goulds' tax cancellation request, swindling charges against H. H. Holmes, and silver men's plans to form a new party.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wood County Reporter · 29 November 1894 · page 6

Interesting changes are taking place j on the planet Mars, according to Perj cival Lowell, of the Lowell observa tory. The national W. C. T. U. at Cleve land adopted a resolution opposing vivisection and listened to reports on evangelistic work. Justice Lawrence denied the appli cation of the Goulds for cancellation of their taxes on the ground of non residence in New York. H. H. Holmes, arrested in .Boston, charged w T ith swindling an insurance company, left scores of victims in Chi cago. Silver men are said to have deter mined to organize a new’ party if the republicans do not declare for free coinage.

See the clipping

The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind. · and 1 other paper

The clipping details the conspiracy against the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance Co., describing Holmes (alias Mudgett) as the arch-conspirator, and reports a new twist as a dispatch claims Pitezel, the supposed murder victim, was recently seen alive in Chicago with a man named Ryan.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

The Jasper Weekly Courier · 30 November 1894 · page 6

I A GREAT SCOUNDREL. Itolmre. the Man of Many Allat. mad lrlncrliat CHilratur In thr VlmX Whrrrhy he it -Uty Mut im I Mr In turanrr Co. na SMlmllrtt Out ttt ll, OOO lrF to Mr On of thr (treatrftt SVouiidrrU t'f)huucflUel., J hAttrcttt Ii.-ad Man; Said to Have Ben Sh in Chirac. Pinuur.t piiia, Nov. SJ All the parties Implicated in the conspiracy by which the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance. ,Co, wä. defrauded out of "SIO.WO. ' except lt. F. Pitezel. the supposed dead man, are in Philadelphia to-day. H.

See moreSee less

II. Holmes, the arch-conspirator, accompanied by his alleged wife and Mrs. Pitezel, the latter having with her Meda. her 16-ycar-old rived yesterday from Iioston in custody of Detective "Crawford and Special Agent Perry of the insurance compauy. Jephtha D. Howe, the St Louis attorney, who u also under in affair, accompanied by his attorney, Marshall F. McDonald, arrived this morning. That Holmes is the most aceom plbhed and most desperate criminal that has been taken into custody for some years is shown by his own con of his life. Took a w and t'ncijwtrd Tarn. PitttAPELTiUA, Nov. 21. The sensa tional conspiracy against the Fidelity Mutual Life association, for which Herman Mudgett, alias Holmes, alias Howard; Lawyer Jeptha J. Howe, of St. Loui. and Mrs, Reujamin F. Pitzel have been indicted, the former and the latter being under arrest here, took a new and unexpected turn to-day. The development was in the nature of a dispatch received by President Foue. of the Fidelity association, from the concern's Chicago representative, in which it xvas stated that Pitzel, the reported victim, was seen in that city within two weeks. Pitzel, according to the. dispatch was located in Meyers saloon 03 Sixty-ninth street, in com pany with a man named Ryan. If this shall prove to be true, it will con firm what Holmes, the arch conspira tor, has persistently adhered to that Pitzel is alive. President Fouse Is inclined to the be lief, in view of this information, which ae considers to be thoroughly reliable, that Pitzel is among the living. "I think that murder was done," he stated this afternoon, "but I believe that the victim was a man other than Pitzel." CThen dwelling upon this development he continued: '"Our representative fur ther says that the Mr. Ryan, with whom Pitzel was seen, Is a Chicago business man. who knows Pitzel welL "Our Chicaco man subsequently saw Ryan, but the latter declared his ina bility to locate Pitzel. the two having parted after leaving the saloon. As Holmes maintains that the three missing Pitzel children are with their father, the discovery of the supposed victim will probably clear up the mys tery regarding the offspring daughter, and baby boy. ar dictment for being implicated in the fessions, which are made not as con fevsions. but shnpry as giving the story

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · 29 November 1894

The Willimantic Journal · Willimantic, Conn.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Detective W. E. Gary, also called Gerry, who solved the disappearance of Pitezel and the fraudulent $10,000 policy collection by the Holmes-Howe combination, is a native of Stafford.

The Willimantic Journal · 30 November 1894 · page 4

SCRAPS OF SENTIMENT. The announcement is now made positive that Gardiner Greene, Jr., of Norwich is added to the list of aspirants for the speakership of the next House. Detective W. E. Gary, or Gerry, as he is styled in most newspapers, who has been successful • in untangling the mystery surrounding the disappearance of Pitezel and the fraudulent collection of $10,000 policy by the Holmes-Howe combination, is a native of Stafford. Some of the railroad companies have Already begun to deduct the income tax from dividends. A Pennsylvania railroad company which pays 7 per cent annually took out 2 per cent before paying over its dividend.

See moreSee less

How will this strike the Demo oratic stockholders, we wonder. Mr., Coffin owes more to the people and less to the politicians than any governor elect in recent times.—Waterbury Repub lican. And Governor Coffin’s expressions (and he is a man who means what he says) indicate that he will pay more to the peo ple and less to the politicians than has been the custom lately. The amount of money expended by the spectators of a great inter-collegiate foot ball game is nothing short of prodigious and shows the hold that college sports and particularly football, have on the public mind and the public pocketbook. A con servative estimate of the legitimate ex penses of the crowd that saw the great game at Springfield Saturday, in getting to and seeing the game, at $150,000, to say nothing of the large sums that changed hands in wagers, _

See the clipping

Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory

H. H. Holmes, accompanied by Mrs. Pitzel and a woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes, arrived in Philadelphia in the custody of Detective Crawford and conferred with Superintendent of Police Linden, with Crawford detailing the story of Holmes's life and the trip.

Idaho County Free Press · 30 November 1894 · page 3

DEEP-DYED VILLAINY

Philadelphia. Pa., Nov. 20.—Arch conspirator H. H. Holmes, accom panied by Mrs. Pitzel and a woman who calls herself Mrs. Holmes, urrived in this city today in the custody of De tective Crawford of the Fidelity Mutual Insurance Association. Mrs. Holmes disappeared soon after her arrival and no clue to her whereabouts could be obtained. It is thought she Is stop ping at a hotel in the neighborhood of police headquarters. After the arriv al the party was closeted with Superin al tenden of Police Linden until late in the afternoon.

See moreSee less

When the confèrent*« was ovi the story of the trip, the most impor tant feature of which was the revelat tion made to him by Holmes of the story of his whole life. STORY OF A VILLAIN. r, Detective Crawford detail«*«'

See the clipping

The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind.

The garbled clipping states that Holmes is among the most accomplished and desperate criminals taken into custody in years, based on his own confessions, which are presented not as admissions of guilt but simply as his life story.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Jasper Weekly Courier · 30 November 1894 · page 6

A GREAT SCOUNDREL.

That Holmes is the most aceom that has been taken into custody for some years is shown by his own con of his life. Took a w and t'ncijwtrd Tarn. plbhed and most desperate criminal fessions, which are made not as con fevsions. but shnpry as giving the story

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Great Falls Weekly Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.

A damaged Philadelphia dispatch fragment reports that friends of young St. Louis lawyer Jeptha D. Howe claim he was also a victim of Holmes, though the rest of the text is cut off.

Great Falls Weekly Tribune · 30 November 1894 · page 2

d INSURANCE THIEVES. t His Friends Say Young Howe Was Also a a Victim of Holmes. PHILAdELPHIA, Nov. 22.-Jeptha D. C Howe, the young St. Louis lawyer who, c

See the clipping