As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

December 1894

11 articles

In the story →

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This single-item article reports that H. H. Holmes, held in Moyamensing prison on a murder charge, was confronted in his cell by an insurance company supervisor demanding the name of the New York doctor said to have supplied a cadaver for an insurance claim, but Holmes refused to give it.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 4 days earlier.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 3 December 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Swindler Holmes Remains Stubborn.

PHILADELPHIA, Dec. 3.—H. H. Holmes, the insurance swindler, is now, it is claimed, resting in his cell in Moyamensing prison under the charge of murder. Supervisor Perry, of the insurance company, visited Holmes in his cell and charged Holmes with murdering Pitezel, and demanded the name of the New York doctor who, according to Holmes' statement, furnished the cadaver on which the insurance was collected for Pitezel's death. Holmes refused to mention the name of his New York doctor.

See the clipping

The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Holmes, held in a Philadelphia prison on a murder charge, was confronted by an insurance company supervisor demanding the name of a New York doctor who allegedly supplied a cadaver, but refused to answer.

The Evening Herald · 3 December 1894 · page 3

Swindler Holmes Remains Stubborn

ATUOClTlllS IJV JATANlNE. Tim IluMirU of Their Cruellies lit I'ort London. Dee. !!. Tlie correspondent of Tho Times telegraphs as follows from lllrosliiiini. .Itijinn: "I hiivo jut returned from the heat of war and had a eonvemu tlon with Viscount MtitKii Munninit.n, tlio foreign minister, in regard to the mis conduct of tho Japanese at Port Arthur. I informed him that I hud watched tho Japan -so army enter the town. The Chlueso resisted to the Inst. 1 saw Chinese in plain clothes with firearms concealed on their persons. I also found oxploslve bul lets.

See moreSee less

Tho Japanese reported that civilians llredupon them from tho houses, and they thcreforo deemed It necessary to extermi nate them "The Jupaneso wero further excited by fludiug the mutilated remains of Japan ese prisoners. Some of these prisoners had been burned alive. I saw no resistance in tho town. During tlio noxt four iluys the Japanoso pillaged tho wholo town anil killed almost overy man. Very few women or children were killed. Those who wero killed wero probably killed unintention ally. I saw scores of Chinese prisoners pinioned, stripped nnd shot, hacked with knives, ripped open, disemboweled anil dismembered. Slauy bodies were partly burned. A Clio Foo dispatch says that n China man who escaped from Port Arthur states that there wero six generals of equal ail thority In command there. Two of tho generals havo arrived at Clio Foo. One ts still in hiding. Another has gone to Tlen stin, whoro he runs a great risk of being beheaded. Detllrutliif; a ltunslan Church, STI'.KATOlt, Ills., l)oo. 8. Tho unly dis tinctive Itussian edifice In tho l uitul States was dedicated yesterday by Ilislmp Nicholas, of Kitka, Alaska, assisted by ltcv. Maliarevesky of Minneapolis, Itcv. I. Pustlnskl of Sun Francisco, Hcv. Alexis Trevettkoff of 'VVilkesbarre and Ilev. Am brose Vretta of Chicago, the latter becom ing priest of tho church. The services wero very impressive, lasting five hours. Tho church Is built entirely of mm il which conies from Russia, and Is from the, remains of the ltussia vestibule lu the Manufacturers' building at tho World's fair. Tho congregation hero numbers over 200. Swindler Holmes Iteinuliis Stubborn. Philadelphia, Deo. a. II. II. Holmes, tho Insurance swindler, Is now, It is claimed, resting in his cell In Moyautens lng prison under tlio chnrgo of murder. Supervisor Perry, of tho insurance com pany, visited Holmes lu Ills cell and charged Holmes with murdering Pitezel, and demand ul tho name of the J ew York doctor who, according to Holt:.',' state ment, furnished the cadaver on liliii the Insurance was collected for Pitezi's death, llolmos refused to mention the n..mu of his New York doctor. Not Sent hy 1.1 Hung Chang-. Yokohama, Dee. a. Mr. l)etn.i, tao envoy who visited Japan for the purpose of lK'ipitlutinK a peaoe, and whose mission proved a fill lure, tho prime minister de clliilnif to nioet him, has written a private letter to tho prime minister denying that ho was sent to Japan hy 14 liuug Uhaug, Arthur Confirmed.

See the clipping

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

This damaged clipping from a newspaper published by O. and M. T. Maxon briefly refers to H. H. Holmes, described as up to date and currently held in jail in Philadelphia, but the text is too fragmentary to convey further detail.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 4 December 1894 · page 2

The jDemoemk O. and M. T. M AXON El. Publwhus. Up to data that dapper young niao, H. H. Holmes. who is In quod in Philadel

See the clipping

In the story →

The Hartford Herald · Hartford, Ky.

This article describes a $10,000 life insurance fraud scheme involving H. H. Holmes of Chicago, who used aliases to help a man obtain a policy before a body was substituted as his corpse in Philadelphia, with a lawyer paid $2,500 to collect the claim.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The Monmouth Inquirer, 29 November 1894, The Jasper Weekly Courier, 30 November 1894.

The Hartford Herald · 5 December 1894 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

$10,000 FOR A CORPSE THIS AMOUNT PAID FOR A SUPPOSED DEAD MAN. A "Stiff" was Obtained from a Medical College and Palmed Off on the Unsuspecting Company. A LAWYER'S FEE OF $2,500 [Louisville Star.]

An attempt to defraud a life insurance company out of $10,000 by substituting a dead body for the man who carried the policy, and who is still alive, has excited a great deal of attention throughout the United States, and has a local flavor which the Louisville people will now learn for the first time. The story is one of thrilling interest. The scheme to defraud the insurance company was daring in its conception, and required a good deal of pluck and nerve to carry it out. It takes shrewd, wily men to sell an insurance company a corpse for $10,000. The plan worked out, but soon afterward the insurance company got wind of the fraud and put the detectives on the track of the swindlers. They are now in jail, have confessed, and the doors of the penitentiary are yawning for them.

See moreSee less

The most interesting phase of the story is the implication of Jeptha D. Howe, of St. Louis, the lawyer who received $2,500 for collecting the money from the insurance company. Howe is only twenty-two years of age, and a brother of Ben Howe, the manager of the real estate department of the Germania Trust Company, at First and Market streets, in this city. He passed through Louisville with the little daughter of the supposed dead man to identify the corpse in Philadelphia. They spent the night with his brother here, and Mr. Ben Howe has since had some correspondence with his brother in St. Louis and his law partner, Marshall DeMonald.

H. H. Holmes, of Chicago, with the aliases of Dr. Howe, Howard and Howell, is the man who received and engineered the scheme. He was a builder and capitalist in Chicago, and when he introduced his friend, Mr. Benjamin F. Pitezel, to the agent of the Philadelphia company in Chicago, he was accepted for the policy of $10,000.

The New York World tells the rest of the story as follows:

"In Philadelphia, during the latter part of August of the present year, a man about forty years old, who called himself B. F. Perry, rented an office and began a real estate business. After he had been in the place about two weeks it was noticed one morning that his street door was open. The next morning it was in the same condition, and on a third morning there was no change. Then the police were notified and found Mr. Perry lying dead on the floor of his chamber, apparently from the effects of the explosion of a bottle of benzine. He was partly dressed at the time, and the supposition which was at first accepted was that he was examining the naptha bottle while smoking and that the explosion was caused by a spark from his pipe. The broken bottle and the corncob pipe were found on the floor beside him, and his face and the upper part of his body were burned from the ignited fluid in a manner which made this the first natural deduction. An autopsy placed a different face on the matter. The Coroner found that the interior of the mouth had not been burned from inhaling the flames, nor were the intestines injured in this way, as would have been the case had the man been alive at the time of the explosion. A quantity of chloroform was also found in the stomach.

"The man had no known friends or relatives, and all the evidence the police could obtain was that his name was B. F. Perry. Under that name he was finally buried in Potter's field and the accident theory changed to the one of murder. About a week after the finding of the body the insurance company received a letter from Mrs. Pitezel, of St. Louis, who stated that she had seen the accounts of the mysterious corpse in the papers, and added that she believed the victim to have been her husband, as he had been doing business in Philadelphia under the name of Perry. She explained that he had changed it from Pitezel on account of business troubles, which forced him to move to another city and assume an alias. She incidentally added that her husband had been insured in the company and that she had the policy.

"The reply from the company came in the form of a request for her to come to Philadelphia and identify the body. The company had also learned through its Chicago agent that Mr. Holmes had recommended Mr. Pitezel for insurance, and at the request of the company Mr. Holmes also came to Philadelphia.

Mr. Holmes stated that if the dead man was his old friend Pitezel he could readily identify him by his peculiar teeth, a scar on his leg, a wart on the back of his neck and by a discolored thumb nail caused by a blow. When the body of the victim was disinterred every one of these peculiar marks were found. Mr. Holmes pronounced it without hesitation the body of Pitezel, and Mrs. Pitezel and her daughter, judging from the teeth, pronounced it the body of her husband and father.

"On the next day the insurance money was paid over to a representative of the family, and the body was delivered to Mrs. Pitezel. The insurance men were satisfied as to the identity of the dead man, but the question of the cause of the accident continued to puzzle them. As Holmes was in Chicago at the time it must have occurred, and as Mrs. Pitezel and her daughter were undoubtedly in St. Louis, they did not suspect them in connection with the affair and concluded to let the matter drop.

"Later the insurance company grew suspicious and began a search for Holmes. He had fled from Chicago, but was finally run in New Hampshire. He was arrested, and for fear of being accused of Pitezel's murder, confessed. Holmes said that he and Pitezel planned the matter last summer. He helped Pitezel pick out the place, and then he went to New York for the purpose of procuring a corpse. He packed the body in a trunk and carried it to Philadelphia. At Philadelphia he met Pitezel, and the latter must have had a "creepy" feeling - that is, if he had any at all - when he received the check for his own body, and after obtaining it, carted it to his house. The rest of the work was done by Pitezel, who had been instructed by Holmes how to treat the body to make it appear as if it had been burned. The benzine was poured on the corpse and lighted, then the bottle was broken, the corncob pipe placed in position, and Pitezel fled."

A special from Philadelphia to the St. Louis Star-Sayings says:

"According to the story told by Holmes, Howe was cognizant of the plot almost from the time of its inception. In his story Holmes says that when first he and Pitezel determined upon the conspiracy, he (Holmes) was told by Hedgepeth, the St. Louis train robber, who is now in jail, that Howe was a cool and nervy man, and one that could be trusted. Holmes visited Howe and outlined the plot to him.

"Howe inquired closely into the details of the affair, and was unwilling to appear as the principal in it. He advised that if it was successful that some friend of the family identify the corpse first, as insurance companies are liable to be suspicious of attorneys who appear in cases where there is no evident need of their services. Howe's advice was followed, and he and Holmes and Alice Pitezel came East to identify the body. Holmes left Alice and Howe in Washington, and came on here first.

"The identification of the body followed, as has been told, and then Howe put in the claim for $10,000. It was paid and they returned to St. Louis. Of the $10,000 Howe retained $2,500 for counsel fees and $490 for expenses.

"Pitezel got $2,000; Holmes sent $1,000 to a broker named Blackman at 69 Dearborn street, Chicago; deposited $1,000 in the Merchants' National Bank, at Indianapolis, in his wife's name; gave Mrs. Pitezel $500 and retained the balance as his share."

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A Philadelphia dispatch reports a box sent from Chicago was opened and said to contain nothing important, in a fragment that breaks off while introducing Mrs. H. H. Holmes, wife of the alleged insurance [sentence cut off].

The Times · 5 December 1894 · page 1

HOLMES' TIN BOX OPENED

HOLMES 1IN BX OPENED, Sent from Chleago, but Is Said to Contain Nothing Important. PHILADELPHIA, PA. Dec. 4.-Mrs. H. H. Holmes, wife of the alleged insurance

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

Among a column of news briefs, this report details the alleged criminal record of Charles W. Jacobs, arrested in Milwaukee for a mock marriage, and states that Chicago police give no credence to the theory that he is Pitzell, confederate of the insurance swindler H. H. Holmes.

Pawtucket Tribune · 6 December 1894 · page 1

Is Not a Very Clean One, According to State CHICAGO, Deec. 6.—Charles W. Jacobs, who was arrested in Milwaukee, while at tempting to marry Mrs. Helen Buck of Chicago, by an alleged mock ceremony, has according to the police officials of this city a glittering record. Jacobs secured his diploma from a Cincinnati medical college, and practiced medicine in Omaha and Kansas City. While inthe latter city, several years ago, he married the daugh ter of Millionaire David S. Kelton, and it is claimed made, an unsuccessful attemps to secure a divorce there.

See moreSee less

Jacobs’ favorite plan for obtaining money was, it is sald, the offering of $3O worth of work for a deposit of $5, but the transaction invariably ended, the police say, when he received the dep :. He was also a dealer in diamonds, which business was carried on without the aid of dia monds. Jacobs is also said to have large con tribution.. from western farmers through divers and questionable schemes. The theory that he is Pitzell, the confederate of the insurance swindler, H. H. Holmes, is given no credence here. NEW YORK, Dec. 6. —=The board of re view of the National Trotting association met again yesterday. One of the most im portant cases that has ever come before the board was acted on, when the tempo rary reinstatement of C. H. Nelson was made permanent. Nelson’s difficulty grew out of the Nelson-Alcryon $lO,OOO stallion race, trotted at Beacon park, Bogton. JACOBS' RECORD ments of Chicago Police. End of a Famous Turf Case.

See the clipping

The Jersey City News · Jersey City, N.J.

Acting on a Philadelphia detective chief's request to search a house Mrs. Pitzel occupied with H. H. Holmes in Burlington, Vt., police found a buried bottle of dark liquid hidden beneath a potato bin's false bottom and notified the Philadelphia authorities.

The Jersey City News · 10 December 1894 · page 1

IS IT NITRO-GLYJERINE? BURLINGTON, Vt., Dec. 10, 1894.—Chief of Police Dumas, on Saturday, received a letter from the Chief of the Bureau of Detectives in Philadelphia, asking him to search the house occupied by Mrs. Pitzel, while she was here with H. H. Holmes, for a bottle of nitro-glycerlne, w ill' ll nuiuica u»v* pcucicu. Yesterday a bottle containing a half nlnt of dark liquid was found beneath the false door of a potato bin It was buried in the outskirts or the city, and the Philadelphia authorities notified,

See the clipping

Pawtucket Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A search of the house where Mrs. Pitzel had stayed with H. H. Holmes turned up a half-pint bottle of dark liquid, suspected nitro-glycerine, hidden beneath a false floor in a potato bin, which was buried outside the city, after which Philadelphia authorities were notified.

Pawtucket Tribune · 10 December 1894 · page 4

search the house occupied by Mrs. Pitzel, while she was here with H. H. Holmes, for a bottle of nitro-glycerine which Holmes had secreted A bottle contain ing a half-pint of dark liquid was found beneath the false floor of a potato bin. It was buried in the outskirts of the city and the Philadelphia authorities notified. : Railrcad Stock For Sale.

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

This damaged clipping is too fragmented to follow clearly, mentioning the election of directors for a concern, a man named Holmes meeting a young woman, and a reference to someone named M. S. Bridges.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 11 December 1894 · page 8

KING OF CRIMINALS

tion of directors for the ensuing year, aud "the preliminaries necessary for tho formation of this concern. Holmes tmado the acquaintance of a pretty girl Aad teraTc indeed. U ha -ho derst. Far he has seas yon t year worse. M. S. Bridges, is Pci.

See the clipping

Bellows Falls Times · Bellows Falls, Vt.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says the Fidelity insurance company's suit against H. H. Holmes was dismissed after Mrs. Holmes sent the attorneys a $600 check, the full amount the company expected to recover.

Bellows Falls Times · 13 December 1894 · page 1

archy. The St. Johns, N. F., Commercial bank has suspended. Liabilities un known. A run is now being made on the Union bank. A financial crisis prevails. Several commercial firms have failed. The immediate cause is the suspension of Prowse, Hall & Mor ris of London, financial agents, and other firms. The suit against H. H. Holmes, the insurance swindler, brought in Indian apolis, Ind., by the Fidelity insurance company, has been dismissed. The reason for the dismissal is that Mrs. Holmes sent a check to the company's attorneys for $600, which she had de posited in an Indianapolis bank and which was all the company expected ; to get.

See moreSee less

- A circular by Privy Councillor Dur novo, Russian minister of the interior forbids Stundist prayer meetings, and declares this religious sect to be most dangerous to church and state. The Stundists are a Protestant sect resem bling somewhat both the German ' Methodists and Baptists of America, and number about 250,000 persons. The enforcement of this decree is not in line with the liberal policy which it has been predicted Nicholas II would follow. Lord Duuraven's letter and challenge for America's cup was posted at the New York Yacht club Saturday night. The challenge is virtually the same as that of 1892. The new yacht will be named the Valkyrie and will be a cut ter 89 feet on the load water line and will differ but slightly from the old Valkyrie. Dun raven suggests several slight changes in the rules over the last contest, but doe not iusist on any pos itive changes. He asks that the races be sailed earlier than October and pre fers one gun to start. He alao asks' that all races be started to the wind-wrd.

See the clipping

The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.

A damaged clipping reports detectives probing a well poisoning at W. H. Goodrich's home, where poison tracks led toward colored residents' quarters, alongside fragmentary, mostly illegible mentions of a disputed case involving Yale and a letter to a police chief about someone named Holmes.

The United Opinion · 14 December 1894 · page 1

Holmes Secreted Bottle

tectives are still working vigorously on the attempt to poison the family of W. H. Goodrich. The board of health or dered the well. Into which paris green was thrown, filltnl up. Tracks of the poison were found wv.- 1! r.xW from the house near the home i-f cu! ci-d parties. A Mc.tt-d liratrd Case. or figured corduroy, any color, filled with hair, and team. Yale has made no charges what ever, and If any eharges should be made by ns, they will be announced as official and coming from our association." Holmes fteeresod Bottle. BCKLIxoton, Vt, Deo. 10. Chief of Police Dumas received a letter from de tectives In PhlladelDhla. aaklna. fcli .

See the clipping