$10,000 FOR A CORPSE THIS AMOUNT PAID FOR A SUPPOSED DEAD MAN. A "Stiff" was Obtained from a Medical College and Palmed Off on the Unsuspecting Company. A LAWYER'S FEE OF $2,500 [Louisville Star.]
An attempt to defraud a life insurance company out of $10,000 by substituting a dead body for the man who carried the policy, and who is still alive, has excited a great deal of attention throughout the United States, and has a local flavor which the Louisville people will now learn for the first time. The story is one of thrilling interest. The scheme to defraud the insurance company was daring in its conception, and required a good deal of pluck and nerve to carry it out. It takes shrewd, wily men to sell an insurance company a corpse for $10,000. The plan worked out, but soon afterward the insurance company got wind of the fraud and put the detectives on the track of the swindlers. They are now in jail, have confessed, and the doors of the penitentiary are yawning for them.
See moreSee less
The most interesting phase of the story is the implication of Jeptha D. Howe, of St. Louis, the lawyer who received $2,500 for collecting the money from the insurance company. Howe is only twenty-two years of age, and a brother of Ben Howe, the manager of the real estate department of the Germania Trust Company, at First and Market streets, in this city. He passed through Louisville with the little daughter of the supposed dead man to identify the corpse in Philadelphia. They spent the night with his brother here, and Mr. Ben Howe has since had some correspondence with his brother in St. Louis and his law partner, Marshall DeMonald.
H. H. Holmes, of Chicago, with the aliases of Dr. Howe, Howard and Howell, is the man who received and engineered the scheme. He was a builder and capitalist in Chicago, and when he introduced his friend, Mr. Benjamin F. Pitezel, to the agent of the Philadelphia company in Chicago, he was accepted for the policy of $10,000.
The New York World tells the rest of the story as follows:
"In Philadelphia, during the latter part of August of the present year, a man about forty years old, who called himself B. F. Perry, rented an office and began a real estate business. After he had been in the place about two weeks it was noticed one morning that his street door was open. The next morning it was in the same condition, and on a third morning there was no change. Then the police were notified and found Mr. Perry lying dead on the floor of his chamber, apparently from the effects of the explosion of a bottle of benzine. He was partly dressed at the time, and the supposition which was at first accepted was that he was examining the naptha bottle while smoking and that the explosion was caused by a spark from his pipe. The broken bottle and the corncob pipe were found on the floor beside him, and his face and the upper part of his body were burned from the ignited fluid in a manner which made this the first natural deduction. An autopsy placed a different face on the matter. The Coroner found that the interior of the mouth had not been burned from inhaling the flames, nor were the intestines injured in this way, as would have been the case had the man been alive at the time of the explosion. A quantity of chloroform was also found in the stomach.
"The man had no known friends or relatives, and all the evidence the police could obtain was that his name was B. F. Perry. Under that name he was finally buried in Potter's field and the accident theory changed to the one of murder. About a week after the finding of the body the insurance company received a letter from Mrs. Pitezel, of St. Louis, who stated that she had seen the accounts of the mysterious corpse in the papers, and added that she believed the victim to have been her husband, as he had been doing business in Philadelphia under the name of Perry. She explained that he had changed it from Pitezel on account of business troubles, which forced him to move to another city and assume an alias. She incidentally added that her husband had been insured in the company and that she had the policy.
"The reply from the company came in the form of a request for her to come to Philadelphia and identify the body. The company had also learned through its Chicago agent that Mr. Holmes had recommended Mr. Pitezel for insurance, and at the request of the company Mr. Holmes also came to Philadelphia.
Mr. Holmes stated that if the dead man was his old friend Pitezel he could readily identify him by his peculiar teeth, a scar on his leg, a wart on the back of his neck and by a discolored thumb nail caused by a blow. When the body of the victim was disinterred every one of these peculiar marks were found. Mr. Holmes pronounced it without hesitation the body of Pitezel, and Mrs. Pitezel and her daughter, judging from the teeth, pronounced it the body of her husband and father.
"On the next day the insurance money was paid over to a representative of the family, and the body was delivered to Mrs. Pitezel. The insurance men were satisfied as to the identity of the dead man, but the question of the cause of the accident continued to puzzle them. As Holmes was in Chicago at the time it must have occurred, and as Mrs. Pitezel and her daughter were undoubtedly in St. Louis, they did not suspect them in connection with the affair and concluded to let the matter drop.
"Later the insurance company grew suspicious and began a search for Holmes. He had fled from Chicago, but was finally run in New Hampshire. He was arrested, and for fear of being accused of Pitezel's murder, confessed. Holmes said that he and Pitezel planned the matter last summer. He helped Pitezel pick out the place, and then he went to New York for the purpose of procuring a corpse. He packed the body in a trunk and carried it to Philadelphia. At Philadelphia he met Pitezel, and the latter must have had a "creepy" feeling - that is, if he had any at all - when he received the check for his own body, and after obtaining it, carted it to his house. The rest of the work was done by Pitezel, who had been instructed by Holmes how to treat the body to make it appear as if it had been burned. The benzine was poured on the corpse and lighted, then the bottle was broken, the corncob pipe placed in position, and Pitezel fled."
A special from Philadelphia to the St. Louis Star-Sayings says:
"According to the story told by Holmes, Howe was cognizant of the plot almost from the time of its inception. In his story Holmes says that when first he and Pitezel determined upon the conspiracy, he (Holmes) was told by Hedgepeth, the St. Louis train robber, who is now in jail, that Howe was a cool and nervy man, and one that could be trusted. Holmes visited Howe and outlined the plot to him.
"Howe inquired closely into the details of the affair, and was unwilling to appear as the principal in it. He advised that if it was successful that some friend of the family identify the corpse first, as insurance companies are liable to be suspicious of attorneys who appear in cases where there is no evident need of their services. Howe's advice was followed, and he and Holmes and Alice Pitezel came East to identify the body. Holmes left Alice and Howe in Washington, and came on here first.
"The identification of the body followed, as has been told, and then Howe put in the claim for $10,000. It was paid and they returned to St. Louis. Of the $10,000 Howe retained $2,500 for counsel fees and $490 for expenses.
"Pitezel got $2,000; Holmes sent $1,000 to a broker named Blackman at 69 Dearborn street, Chicago; deposited $1,000 in the Merchants' National Bank, at Indianapolis, in his wife's name; gave Mrs. Pitezel $500 and retained the balance as his share."