The State Ledger · Topeka, Kan. · and 1 other paper
The clipping reports that Holmes, after his lawyers withdrew at his request, began conducting his own case and started questioning Enoch Turner, the first juror, with pencil and paper in hand.
The State Ledger · 1 November 1895 · page 2
H.H. HOLMES ON TRIAL THE NOTORIOUS CRIMINAL ARRAIGNED.
were forced to withdraw at Holmes’ request and he began conducting his own case. Holmes armed himself with pencil and paper and Enoch Turner, the first juror, was turned over to him, for ex
Hutchinson Gazette · Hutchinson, Kan. · 31 October 1895
Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.
A Philadelphia court heard Georgiana Yoke, who calls herself Holmes' wife, give whispered testimony implicating him, causing Holmes to weep, while his counsel expressed confidence in acquittal without presenting evidence.
Waterbury Democrat · 1 November 1895 · page 1
The Court Refuses to Admit Testimony ! Concerning the Murder of Pitezel's Chil dren Holmes Alleged Wife Causes a j Sensation He Is Deeply Moved. Philadelphia, Nov. 1. For about SO minutes yesterday the ncrvo at which all men have marveled forsook Holmes, and bowed and broken he sank his head into bis hands and sobbed like a child. Mean While the woman he persists in calling his wife and upon whom he had pinned his highest hope sat two yards away re lating a story that seemingly tightened the noose about his neck.
See moreSee less
For 1 hour and 40 minutes she whisper ed to the court crier the words that told how Pitezel had como to the Eleventh street house, whero they were stopping, the night before the murder, and how Holmes had been away for five hours of the next day, coming back flushed and excited and carrying hor hurriedly off to Indianapolis. It was the day after this that the corpse was found in the Callow hill street house. At the close of her ex amination in chiof Holmes asked to con duct the fcross examination himself, and etanding in a corner of the dock nervously wringing his hands he put a few ques tions. Then he said he would reserve the right to call her as a witness for the de fense. Throughout her testimony Miss Georgiana Yoke, for so she calls herself, never once bestowed a passing glance upon the man she once had loved. Dur ing the greater part of it she kept her blue eyes riveted on the floor, and when it be came necessary to raise them she was careful to shift them so that the pale, shrunken felon in the dock should not come in their path. The case progressed so swiftly that but few witnesses remain to be heard before the closing of .the commonwealth's case. Then the defense will open, and in spite of Holmes' statement that he would him self testify and also call Miss Yoke his counsel privately state that the defense would offer no evidence, but submit the case on argument alone. And they ex pressed supreme confidence in his acquit tal. Their first victory was gained, and it disappointed those morbid listeners who had counted on viewing the bones of the dead boy Howard. During the day several witnesses were sworn and mainly gave testimony corrob orative of the evidence already submitted by the prosecution. Holmes Alleged Wife Testifies. The most important witness at least the one furnishing the sensation of . the day was the alleged wife of the accused man. She gave her testimony in a whis per; whioh was interpreted by the court crier.' Georgiana Yoke, for so she gave her name, is a tall, slender woman of about 25 years, with flaxen hair and blue eyes. She was stylishly attired in black. For the first time Holmes broke down. He gazed steadily at her for a few r conds, while his hands twitched nervously and his lips opened and closed, but she care fully avoided meeting his eyes. Then ho suddenly bent forward over the little desk in his dock, and the tears began to trickle down his cheeks. He drew his handker chief out and for a moment or two sobbed. Then, quickly recovering himself, he dried his eyes and bowed his head, busily engag IN A DFCISION.
This brief, cut-off fragment describes a man named Holmes breaking down for the first time, staring at an unnamed woman with trembling hands and twitching lips before the text ends abruptly.
Waterbury Democrat · 1 November 1895 · page 1
For the first time Holmes broke down. He gazed steadily at her for a few r conds, while his hands twitched nervously and his lips opened and closed, but she care
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 1 other paper
A woman identified as Georgiana Yoke testified in a whisper that she knew the accused as H. H. Holmes and H. M. Howard, prompting him to weep, while questioning sought to fix his whereabouts on the day of the alleged murder.
Evening Journal · 1 November 1895 · page 2
Holmes* Alleged Wife Testifies. Tho most important witness—at least tho ono furnishing the sonsntlon of tho day—wns thu alleged wife of the accused man. Sho gave her testimony in a whis per, which wns Interpreted by tho court erler. Georgians Yoko, for so sho gave her name, Is a toll, slender woman of about 85 years, with flaxen hnlr and blue eyes. Sho was stylishly attired In black. For tho first time Holmes broke down. Ilo gazed steadily nt her for n few seconds, whilo his hands twltchod nervously and his lips opcnc-d nnd closed, but she care fully avoided meeting his eyes.
See moreSee less
Thon ho suddenly bent forward over tho little desk In his dock, and the tears began to trioklo down his cheeks. He drew his handker chief out and for a moment or two sobbed. Then, quickly recovering himself, ho dried his eyes nnd bowed his head, busily engag ing lilmsolf with Ills notes, but still occa sionally giving wny to a sob. Tho witness testified that she know the prisoner ns H. H. Holmes nnd H. M. Hownrd in St. Louis In June, 1894, nnd tamo to Philadelphia with him In August, 189 1. Mr Graham put a sortes of questions to fix Holmes' whereabout on the day the murder Is supposed to have been commit ted—Sunday, Sept 6, 1894.
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 1 November 1895
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The clipping reports that the day's most sensational witness was the accused man's alleged wife, who gave her testimony in a whisper that the court had interpreted.
Evening Journal · 1 November 1895 · page 2
LAST HOPE FOR THE ACCUSED
Holmes* Alleged Wife Testifies. Tho most important witness—at least tho ono furnishing the sonsntlon of tho day—wns thu alleged wife of the accused man. Sho gave her testimony in a whis per, which wns Interpreted by tho court
The clipping reports that detectives brought Holmes' papers and effects in tin boxes, including unmailed children's letters, and recounts Holmes telling an officer the body found was not Pitezel's but a substitute.
Evening Journal · 1 November 1895 · page 2
CtfMowhill street house. Pitezel's picture as the dead man found lying on thn floor. Detoetivo Thomas G. Crawford, who was sont to Doston te bring Holmes here, said ha also brought his papers and effects in two tin boxes. Detective Frank P. Geyer, who traced Holmes' movements throughout the ooun try, identified a number of papers taken from these boxes. Thoy were the letters written by the children to their mother nnd never niHiled liy Holmes. Detoetivo Gcyer said ho hnd an inter view with Holmes in tho cellroom of the city hall on Nov. 20. 1894, about the body found in the Cailowhill street house. Holmes said to him that it wns uot Pito zel's tiody, but a substitute. "He told mo Ho identified
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
A damaged clipping describes the prisoner Holmes weeping in the dock as a witness, Georgeanna Yoke, testified in a whisper about knowing him in St. Louis under two names and arranging lawyers for him before his move to Philadelphia.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 1 November 1895 · page 1
Sho was at d gave her testimony in a whisper, (which was repeated by tho crier. For the first time Holmes broke down. Ho gazed 'steadily at her for a fow seconds, while his hands twitched nervously and his lips opened and closed,but sho carefully avoided meeting his eyes. Then he suddenly bent forward over the little desk ln his dock, and the tears began to trickle down his Cheeks. He drew his handkorohlcf out, and for a moment recovering hlinself, he dried his eyes and bowod his head, busily engaging himself with bis notes, but still occasionally giv ing way to a sob.
See moreSee less
Georgeanna Yoke, for name, is a toll, slender woman, about 25 years old. She testified that she knew the prisoner In St. Louis by the names of H. H. Holmes and H. M. Howard. When he was ln jail in St.Louis she engaged Thomas If. Harvey to defend him. 8ho also be same acquainted with Lawyer Howe there, the came to Philadelphia In August, 1894, two sobbed. Quickly sho gave her
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The damaged clipping describes District Attorney Graham presenting letters from a box belonging to Holmes despite Mr. Rotan's objection, and separately mentions a bishop-presided case ordering convicted men to a retreat and a $69 fine, with the men claiming a packed jury.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 1 November 1895 · page 1
«ailed. District Attorney Graham handed jltim a bundle of letters, and Geyer stated Itbat they wore letters found ln a box, bo jlanglug to Holmes, which he had delivered over to the district attorney. Mr. Rotan object«!. He argued that it diocese, ordorod them to the retreat of St. Joseph Benoit, near Montreal, and to pay a lino of $69 for costs of oourts. Tho bishop presided, and tho convicted men oh sert that they are the victims of a pocked jury.
When a judge refused a 60-day continuance in H. H. Holmes's murder trial, his lawyers withdrew and he refused court-appointed counsel, examining jurors himself before a jury was seated and court adjourned until afternoon.
The State Ledger · 1 November 1895 · page 4
HOLMES Is Conducting His Own Battle For Life. He Is Being Tried For the Pitezel Murder.
Philadelphia, Pa., Oct. 28.—When the case of 11. H. Holmes, the multi-murderer, was called this morning the defense asked for a continuance of 60 days on the ground that they were not prepared to go on. Judge Arnold overruled the motion and then the defendant’s lawyers, W. H. Shoe maker and Samuel P. Rotan, withdrew. The case was then resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense. Lawyers Shoemaker and Rolan were told by the court that they would be open to dis barment by taking such a step “on the eve of a murder trial.” Still further sensation was created when Holmes relused to accept the services of Attorneys Everett A.
See moreSee less
Schofield and Joseph R. Fahey, appointed to defend him. The work of securing a jury was .then taken up and Holmes examined the talesmen himself. Mrs. Pitezel, who the District At torney said, was indisposed, was not in court this morning. A number of Toronto wit nesses were in attendance. In addition to the murder of Pitezel, the prisoner is also accused of the murder at loronto, Ont., of Pietzel’s two young daugh ters, Alice and Nellie, of the murder at Irv ington, Ind,, of the young son, Howard Pite zel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes castle at Chi cago. Benjamin F. Pitezel’s body was found in a house at 1316 Callowhill street on Sep tember 3, 1894. It was supposed that he had been accidentally burned to death, but a claim lor SIO,OOO insurance by Jeptha D. Howe, of St. Louis started an investigation, which resulted in Holmes being accused of Pitezel’s murder for the purpose of obtaining the insurance money. The jury was selected at noon and adjourn ment taken until afternoon. Holmes made another appeal to the court for a postponement until to-morrow, but the Judge decided against him and said that as he (Holmes) had discharged his lawyers he must defend himself. What prospects, if any, Holmes has for se curing an attorney, are not known. When Holmes pleaded “not guilty” to the indictment he did so in a firm voice, which was in keeping with his calm de’ meanor throughout.
The clipping reports from Philadelphia that Holmes' attorneys will argue suicide as the defense, a strategy foreshadowed by their recent questions, though the text breaks off mid-sentence and is too damaged to read further.
The Evening Times · 1 November 1895 · page 1
QUEER BOOK IN EVIDENCE
Philadelphia, Nov. 1. The defense In the Holmes trial will be suicide. That this would'be the defense has been foreshad owed for scveraldaisbyUiequestionsaskvcl by Holmes' attorneys. That Pitcel committed suicide Is tho
A garbled courtroom account describes a denial of conspiracy to defraud, an accusation about trying to add burdens regarding Mrs. Pitezel's insurance, and an objection raised during questioning about her travels and her husband.
The Evening Times · 1 November 1895 · page 1
MRS. PITEZEL'S ARREST
and was then rtUa.v-iinhe denied that she had entered into any conspiracy to de iraudauy oi.e. But what siieoid wastopro and accused Mr.rs. hhueinuktraiid Rotnu of trying to uUl 10 tiie liurdens of Mrs. Pitezel uy nllegmg that she was In the iusarance svrluals question ot Judge Areola, Mr. Ruiau said mat. they warned to show that in her Journeying around the tountrv Mrs. Pitezel tecl her Mm band. Here Mr.irauamJnteriiosed an objection, They denied this, and in answer to the
This damaged fragment describes a courtroom exchange in which Mr. Rotan questioned a witness about manuscript handwriting and showed a book to Miss Long, with Mr. Graham objecting to marks that were erased before she examined it, while Holmes appeared interested and had pencilled certain passages.
The Evening Times · 1 November 1895 · page 1
copied. Mr. Rotau asked the witness If the hand writing of the manuscript was all the same evidence, and taking tile bonk showed Mr. Rotan parts In It to submit to Miss Long. but when Mr. Rotan was about lo give the book to Miss Long Mr. Uraham objected to the marks. They were erased and the book given to Miss Long, and she was askrd She said she thought it was. Holmes seemed greatly iuterested in the Holmes lead pent lied e-ertaln passages,
The clipping reports that the defense blocked testimony about the Pitezel girls' bodies found in Toronto, and summarizes the prosecution's case so far, including motive, body identification, and Holmes's claim that the dead man committed suicide.
Evening Star · 1 November 1895 · page 12
THE CASE AGAINST HOLMES
In the afternoon, after The Star's report closed, the defense in the Holmes trial aI Philadelphia yesterday scored an important victory and one that will keep the prosecu tion down to narrow lines. Detective Geye was telling his story, and when he reached the point that referred to Toronto and the finding of the bodies of the Pitezel girls, Mr. Rotan objected. Mr. Graham fought him with all the v!goi at his command. But the young lawyei downed his older and more experienced opponent. Judge Arnold decided that thi quest!ons not be asked.
See moreSee less
This means thal the small army of witnesses from othe places cannot tell their stories unless the' bear directly on the case of Pitezel. The) cannot relate the story of the murder of the two little girls and of the little boy. This means much. There was no session last night, and intc the late hours of the night Mr. Graham %nt Mr. Barlow were together mapp:ng out net Lnes of battle. So far they have shown a motive for mur der, they have established that the bodN Is that of Pitezel and they have shown thai Holmes profited by the man's death. Bot by the prisoner's own confession and b5 the testimony of others they have establisa. ed that there was a conspiracy to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Association and that Holmes and P'tezel had been jointly engaged in other questionable enterprIses. They have shown that Pitezel was lasi seen alive on Saturday night and that be died between then and Monday. They have shown that the body was arranged by som hand; that the corpse was burned and thc furniture in the room arranged. They navy brought medical te3timony to indicate hos he died. They have developed suspclous ac tions on the part of Holmes, and the fact that he was away from his w!fe on Sunday the day the murder is believed to have oc curred, for five hours, returning warm ind excited and leaving at once for Indtanap olis. Holmes admts the body to be that of Pite. zel. but says the dead man committed sli cide. On this latter line Holmes will probabl make his defense. He will tight hard tc prove his point. If he does, it means his re. lease from one of the many accusationi made against him. What Helmes Said About the Corpse. After Miss Yoke, or Mrs. Holmes No. .1,
The clipping details evidence of a conspiracy to defraud an insurance association and suspicious circumstances surrounding Pitezel's death, while Holmes claims the dead man committed suicide and that the corpse found was a substitute, not Pitezel's body.
Evening Star · 1 November 1895 · page 12
THE CASE AGAINST HOLMES
der, they have established that the bodN Is that of Pitezel and they have shown thai Holmes profited by the man's death. Bot by the prisoner's own confession and b5 the testimony of others they have establisa. ed that there was a conspiracy to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Association and that Holmes and P'tezel had been jointly engaged in other questionable enterprIses. They have shown that Pitezel was lasi seen alive on Saturday night and that be died between then and Monday. They have shown that the body was arranged by som hand; that the corpse was burned and thc furniture in the room arranged.
See moreSee less
They navy brought medical te3timony to indicate hos he died. They have developed suspclous ac tions on the part of Holmes, and the fact that he was away from his w!fe on Sunday the day the murder is believed to have oc curred, for five hours, returning warm ind excited and leaving at once for Indtanap olis. Holmes admts the body to be that of Pite. zel. but says the dead man committed sli cide. On this latter line Holmes will probabl make his defense. He will tight hard tc prove his point. If he does, it means his re. lease from one of the many accusationi made against him. What Helmes Said About the Corpse. After Miss Yoke, or Mrs. Holmes No. .1, had been cross-examined by Holmes with out bringing out anything important, De tective Frank P. Geyer testified regarding a statement by Holmes in his cell on No vember 20, 1894, about the body found in the Callowhill street house. Holmes said to him that it was not Pitezel's body, but a substitute. "He told me he left the 11th street house cn Sunday, September 2, in the 'morning
The clipping reports that District Attorney Graham believes circumstantial evidence proves Holmes killed Pitezel, and describes how Miss Yoke's testimony and Judge Arnold's ruling led to the prisoner's breakdown in court.
The Morning News · 1 November 1895 · page 1
MISS YOKE CONFRONTS HIM IN COURT.
H'.lmos killed the Pitezel children, Dis tri i Attorney Graham Is convinced that t evidence he has already presented to tinjury will convict Holmes. Although t ■ direct evidence possessed by the cora i nwi alth that Holmes killed Pitezel is t umstantial, so strong Is this chain or j: sumptlve testimony that, to any one who has followed It. there can hardly re i in a doubt that on that Sunday, In Sep tember, a year ago, Holmes killed Pitezel In the house at No. 1316 Callowhill. Notwithstanding the decision of Judge Arnold to-day, much Indirect evidence has Ij.
See moreSee less
• n Introduced, showing that Holmes unquestionably made way with the Pile s' 1 children and this, in every probabil ity, will have weight with the jury and, even if unconsciously, will, in all likeli hood, influence their mlnls.in arriving at a verdict in the 'case before them. The decision of Judge Arnold and the confrontation in the w itness box of Holmes by tho woman whom he deceived into believing she was his legal wife, and llie breakdown of the prisoner that followed, were the leading fatures of the preceding? to-day. After several witnesses had tes tified this morning the name of Miss Yoke was called. Holmes had
A damaged clipping describes Judge Arnold permitting Miss Yoke to testify after Holmes's counsel said the prisoner would cross-examine her himself, her account touching on Pitezel's visit and Holmes's movements but showing little direct knowledge of the murder.
The Morning News · 1 November 1895 · page 1
MISS YOKE CONFRONTS HIM IN COURT.
least one, and probably two other wo men, with whom Holmes had gone through a legal marriage ceremony was convincing, and Judge Arnold allowed Miss Yoke to testify. , Before she began her testimony, Holmes counsel stated to the court that the pris oner would cross examine the witness himself. Miss Yoke was one ot the star ■witm-.-. s for the commonwealth, but, be \ :j 1 proving that Pitezel called on Holmes i!if night before the day he was killed, a1 1 that Holmes told her that he had an t Moment with Pitezel on the next day a t was absent from the house from 10:30 i lock In the morning until 4:30 in the e .
See moreSee less
rnoon on Sunday. Ip"- evidence was not so damaging to t prisoner as those in the court room *xi ivied. She seemed to have no know -1 uc ot any of the events bearing direet p noon the murder of Pitezel or the ,j ilui-cn. Throughout the period of time in which the events occurred she was tantly with Holmes, but he leadily ,i V c, i her as to the reason for their r ’•!ii movements from city to city by
A damaged account describes Holmes sobbing in court while Miss Yoke testified about his movements before a murder, and recounts a Fort Worth witness's testimony about a disputed promissory note used to defraud money.
The Indianapolis Journal · 1 November 1895 · page 1
SHE GIVES EVIDENCE AGAINST THE MAN SHE ONCE LIVED WITH
Tettlmony ns to the Killing of the rictxel Children Not to lie Admit ted Frank C.eyer'si Evidence. PHILADELPHIA, ' OcU a. For about thirty minutes to-day the nerve at which all men have marveled forsook Holmes, and, bowed and broken, he sank his head into his hands and sobbed I'.ke a child. Meanwhile, the woman ho persists In call ing his wife, and on whom he hai pinned his highest hope, sat two yards away, re lating a story that skij but surely tight ened the noo.se on hi neck. For one hour and forty minutes she whipere-l to the court crlr th woris that' told how Pjtxel had comw to the Eleven!
See moreSee less
h.stveet house where they wVre stopping the niht before the murder, an l how Hclines, who had Wen S4wt for tlve hours of the next day. came &: Jluxhed anl excited, and carried her hurrleJIy 01T o 'Indianapolis. It was the day after. this, that the corpse was found In the iallowhiir house. At the cloft of her ex amination In chief, Holmes a?ked to con duct tho cro.js-examination himself, an J, standingin corner of the dock, nervously moving his hauls, he put a few questions. Th:i ho said he would icwve th r'ht to call h"r as a witness for the dfens. Throughout her testimony. Miss (leoygianna Yo!;e. for :o she calls herself, never once bestowed a pa.?lng glance on the mau she onf? loved. Miss Yoke is a tall, slen.ier llon:le of th? futKlued type, and demeaned h-telf like a soman of rennemsnt an.l in-ttllUr-ncc. '.ie was .tastefully dressed in deep black. Too case progressed so swiftly to-day that but few witnesses remain to be hear! be fore the closing of the Commonwealth's ca?e. Then the defense will opon, and. In spite of Holmes's statement that he would
A damaged fragment reports that although Holmes had said he would testify and call Mls Yoke, his counsel privately stated the defense would offer no evidence, but sub (text cut off).
The Indianapolis Journal · 1 November 1895 · page 1
HELD FOR HIS OWN DEFENSE
spite of Holmes's statement that he would himself testify and also call Mls Yoke, h!s counsel privately rtated to-night, that th drfnso would offer no ev'dencc. but sub
At the day's Holmes murder trial session, attended by many spectators, Holmes appeared calm and lively, dominating a long conversation with his attorneys Shoemaker and Rotan as if directing them, then chatted with court officers near his barred cage.
Abendblatt · 1 November 1895 · page 2
Holmes dem Galgen näher. Eine seiner Frauen wendet sich gegen ihn, und das bricht ihm das Herz. Der Schuldbeweis wird heute oder morgen geschlossen.
Philadelphia, Pa., 31. Okt. Zu der heutigen Verhandlung des Holmes schen Mordprozesses hatten sich fast eben so viele Männer wie Frauen eingefunden. Die ineisten derselben hatten ihre Sitze in dem gewöhnlich für Zeugen bestimmten Theile des Gerichtssaales eingenommen, einige saßen sogar innerhalb des für die Gerichtsclerks durch Schranten abgesperrten Raumes. Hol—- mes erschien um 10 Uhr auf der Anklagebank. Er sah so ruhig und unbekümmert aus wie immer. Kaum hatte er Platz genommen, als seine Vertheidiger, die Anwälte Shoe—- maker und Rotan, auf ihn zugingen, worauf sich sofort eine lange, anscheinend sehr ernste Unterhaltung entspann.
See moreSee less
Holmes führte bei dieser Unterredung das große Wort. Der Mund stand ihm fast nicht still und sein gan zes Auftreten und Gebahren zeigte, daß nicht etwa er seine Vertheidiger um Rath fragte, sondern daß im Gegentheil er den beiden Rechtsgelehrten Winke und Rathschläge, wenn nicht gar Verhaltungsbefehle ertheilte. Er sah munterer, frischer, schneidiger aus als je zuvor, seitdem der Prozeß seinen Anfang genommen. Als die Unterredung mit seinen Vertheidigern ihr Ende erreicht und Holmes die Beiden mit huldvoller Handbewegung entlassen hatte, knüpfte er mit zwei Gerichts— beamten, welche dem aus vergoldeten Eisen—- stangen gebildeten Käfig, in welchem Holmes
A German-language newspaper account describes witness Samuels' testimony about a note signed by Benton T. Lyman and presented by a man called Pratt (identified as Holmes), followed by Inspector Gerry's testimony regarding a woman claiming to be Holmes's wife and a letter Holmes asked him to mail.
Abendblatt · 1 November 1895 · page 2
war glatt rasirt und seine kleinen dunkeln Augen hatten einen schalthaft verschmitzten Ausdruck. Er sprach scharf und bestimmt, und wenn auf Holmes die Rede kam, so re dete er von diesem nur als,„dem Individuum da“. Letzterer Ausdruck amüsirte den An—- geklagten nicht wenig, denn so oft der Zeuge sich desselben bediente, verzog er sein Gesicht zu einem behaglichen Schmunzeln. Di— striktsanwalt Graham zeigte den Wechsel vor, welchen Frau Pitzel gestern als denjeni gen identificirt hatte, den Holmes angeblich in der St. Louiser Bank bezahlte, zu welchem Zwecke er sich von der Frau die SSOOO hatte geben lassen.
See moreSee less
Zeuge Samuels erklärte, daß das auf dem Wechsel Geschriebene von ihm herrühre. In der zweiten Hälfte des April oder Anfang Mai 1894, sagte er, sei in Fort Worth ein Mann gewesen, der daselbst als H. M. Pratt bekannt gewesen sei. Dieser Pratt sei „das Individuum da“ gewesen. Dieses Individuum, Holmes, habe die Auf—- sicht über den Bau eines dreistöckigen Hauses gehahbt als Agent für Benton T. Lyman, den angeblichen Eigenthümer. Pratt (Holmes) sei zum Zeugen gekommen und habe versucht, eine Anleihe von $16,000 zu machen, indem er eine Hypothek auf das Grundstück und das auf demselben im Bau begriffene Gebäude für den Pump als Sicherheit angeboten habe. Nach einigen Unterhandlungen sei der Wech—- Jel ausgefertigt und mit Benton T. Lyman unterzeichnet worden. Der Wechsel sei vom 14. Mai 1894 datirt gewesen. Nicht lange nachher habe Pratt (Holmes) behauptet, er habe den Wechsel verloren, und habe dann einen zweiten, dem ersten ähnlichen Wechsel ausgefertigt. Der Wechsel habe ursprüng— lich auf P. S. Samuels, den Bruder des Zeugen, gelautet. Der Wechsel sei jedoch nie indossirt worden und auch die Anleihe sei nicht bewilligt worden. Zeuge identific irte sowohl die ursprüngliche als auch die später ausgefertigte Note. Bezirksanwalt Graham versuchte darzuthun, daß der Wechsel nie— mals ein gesetzlich gültiges Schriftstück ge wesen sei. Inspektor Gerry von der Ver sicherungsgesellschaft wurde hier abermals auf den Zeugenstand gerufen, da Graham sagte, er wolle durch ihn den Beweis liefern, daß Holmes ein vielfach verheiratheter Mann. sei, und daß Fräulein Yote nicht seine gesetz lich angetraute Frau sei, wie Holmes be—- haupte, und daß dieselbe aus diesem Grunde unfähig sei, als Zeugin aufzutreten. Gerry sagte, er habe im Hause des Angeklagten in Willamette, 111., eine Frauensperson gese— hen, die sich für Frau H. H. Holmes ausge geben habe. Er identificirte eine Pholo— graphie von ihr. Im Dezember vorigen Jahres sah Zeuge den Holmes im hiesigen Gefängnisse und sagte ihm, daß er in Willa— mette gewesen sei. Holmes sagte, er wünsche einen Brief an seine Frau zu schreiben und habe dies auch gethan und den Zeugen gebe— ten, denselben auf die Post zu geben. Auf dem Umschlage des Briefes sei keine Adresse gewesen, indem Holmes die Adressirung dem Zeugen überlassen habe. Später habe Zeuge mit Frl. Yote, die als Frau Howard bekannt gewesen sei, gesprochen. Sie sei nicht die Frau gewesen, die er in Willamette gesehen. Holmes sagte dem Zeugen, er habe SIOOO von der Versicherungssumme bei einem ge— wissen Blackman von Chicago, sintn Grundeigenthumsagenten, deponirt, damit „Frau Holmes“ auf dieses Geld hätte ziehen können. Die Vertheidigung erhob gegen alle von Gerrh betreffs Frl. Yoke gemachten Aus sagen Einspruch, jedoch wurde derselbe vom Richter zurückgewiesen. Zwei andere von Holmes geschriebene Briefe wurden vorgelegt. Einer derselben war von Columbus aus an H. H. Caß, den Chicagoer Agenten der Ver sicherungsgesellschaft, adressirt und enthielt eine genaue Personalbeschreibung Pitzel's behufs seiner Identificirung. Hier öffnete sich eine Seitenthüre und herein trat Frl. Yote, oder Frau Howard, Holmes' angeb— liche Frau. Sie wurde sofort auf den Zeu— genstand gebracht und machte ihre Aussgen im Flüstertone, die von einem Gerichts beamten laut wiederholt wurden. Der An— blick der Zeugin hatte auf Holmes eine so aufregende Wirkung, daß er einige Secunden starr auf die Zeugin hinblickte, seine Hände in nervöser Aufregung zusammenpreßte und die Lippen bald öffnete, bald wieder fest zu— sammenschloß. Zeugin vermied es sorgfäl—- tig, seinen Blicken zu begegnen. Plößtzlich
The clipping reports that Holmes dismissed his counsel to conduct his own defense at the start of his trial, then abruptly shifts into a garbled, seemingly unrelated account of a fatal train collision on a curve.
The Goodland Republic · 1 November 1895 · page 1
Made Hid Opening Address. Philadelphia, Oct. 29. A sensation ras created in the Holmes trial, which was begun this morning, by counsel for the prisoner withdrawing at Holmes' request after they had made an inef fectual attempt to secure a postpone ment. Holmes is conducting his own case. Arraved acainst him as the Dight Tuesday night. A Lorribb reck resulted, both engineers being killed and both firemen and several passengers being fatally injured. The two truina dashed into each other around a sharp curve. The en gines were ditched by the fearful f orco of the collisston. If the report given out is true, some blunderer is responsi ble for the accident. The trackmen !
The clipping reports that Holmes briefly dismissed his counsel to conduct his own defense after a continuance plea was refused, then recalled his lawyers as testimony resumed with key witnesses still to be heard.
The Goodland Republic · 1 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES SENT FOR HIS LAWYERS, Snpposed Murderer of Pitzel Gives Up Coa Philadelphia, Oct. 31. It has be startling features of H. H. Holmes' career were not to be confined to his de continent, for with each successive day comes something still more strange and unexpected. Monday he dismissed his counsel and began to try his own case because the court refused to grant the plea made by them for continuance. They left the court in spite of Judge Arnold's threat to disbar them and re fighting single handed over the machin ery of the commonwealth and the ap has been forced around him, he threw up his hands and sent for his lawyers, Messrs.
See moreSee less
Shoemaker and Ilotan. Then he told the court what he had done, and consent to their continuing with the de sion that this was but another part of the byplay following Holmes' personal effort to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by making himself a much wronged man, forced to fight alone what would be his last battle, de spite his ignorance of the technicalities of the law and his alleged physical in firmity. The important work of the trial the taking of testimony was begun Tues day morning at 10 o'clock and with the exceptions of brief intermissions at lunch and supper time was continued until nearly 9 p. ra. It had been the in the absense of a witness hindered this and an adjournment was taken. Tho star witnesses cf the trial Mrs. Pitzel, Detective Geyer, Agent Perry of the swindled insurance company, and the arch crimiual himself remain to be heard, as also two score of others. Dis trict Attorney Graham remarked that there was a liklihood of the trial outriv ducttag His Own Case. come apparent that the picturesque and structive wanderings over the American ligiously kept away. Tuesday, after parently overwhelming evidences which fense was given. There was an impres tention of the court to sit until 10, but alling the Durrant case in point of tinie,
The clipping, a brief fragment, describes byplay in court as Holmes personally tried to win the sympathy of the court and jury by portraying himself as a wronged man forced to fight.
The Goodland Republic · 1 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES SENT FOR HIS LAWYERS,
the byplay following Holmes' personal effort to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by making himself a much wronged man, forced to fight
The clipping reports that a Fort Worth lawyer testified about a disputed $16,000 note used to extort money from Mrs. Pietzel, while an insurance agent recounted meeting a woman at the prisoner's Wilmette house who claimed to be Holmes' wife, and letters written by Holmes were read into evidence.
The Evening Bulletin · 1 November 1895 · page 1
FOURTH DAY'S PROCEEDINGS.
Philadelphia, Nov. 1. Tho fonrfh day of tho Holmes trial opened with ...o prisoner looking as fresh and bright as when ho was first arraigned in court. When placod in tho dock ho Bcanned a letter, aud that tho man is not wholly nerveless was shown by tho way' tho paper shook in his hand. After conrt opened there was quite a wait for tho district attorney. Holmes passed tho interval by consulting with liia counsel aud chatting and laughing with the court officers. The testimony of Sidney D. Samuels, a Fort "Wor' Tox.)
See moreSee less
lawyer, showed that Holmes or Pietzel never obtained any money on the $1G,00Q note, but used it to extort tlio 5,000 from Mrs. Pietzel. Whether it is possible that Holmes could have been plotting Pietzel's death in April or May, he only probably knows, but ho certainly had somo mo tive for obtaining n regularly drawn up note. Tho way ho retained possession of it was to tell Mr. Samuels that ho had lost the original note aud another one was drawn up, lenvinf the first in his hands. William F. Gary, the agent of tho Fidelity Insurance company, was re called; and testified to seeing and talking to woman in Willmette who was known as Holmes' wife, and so acknowledged, to be by' him. Mr. Gaiy said that ho had seen at the prisoner's hou&e in Willmette, Ills., a woman representing herself as Mrs. H. H. Holmes. Ho identified a photograph of her. Last December ho saw Holmes in Moyamensiug prison, this city, wheii ho tela him of his visit to Willmette. Holmes then said lie wanted to write a lottei to his wife and did so, asking tho witness to mail it. Tho envelope was not addressed Holmes leaving it to tho witness. Subsequently witness had spoken to Mi-s Yoke, known as Mrs. Hbwa'd. Sho was not tho woman ho had sen in Willmotto. Holmes told the witness he had deposited 1 ,000 of tho insurance money with a Mr. Blackmail of Chicago, his real estate agent, so that "Mrs. Holmes" could draw upon it. Tlio defense entered a foraial objection to ul) of the evidence of Mr. Gary con cerning Hiss. Yoke, but was overruled. The letter was read to t)io jury. Two other letters were offered, written by Holmes, ono from. Columbus to H. M. Caw, Chicago, agent of tho insurance company, living him u detailed descrip tion of Piet.:el for the purpose of identi
A woman identified as Mrs. Yoko, or Mrs. Howard, the alleged wife, was brought in through a side door and testified in a whisper interpreted by the crier, causing Holmes to break down for the first time.
The Evening Bulletin · 1 November 1895 · page 1
FOURTH DAY'S PROCEEDINGS.
fication. At this point a side door in tho room was opened, and Mis Yoko, or Mrs. Howard, the alleged wifo, was ushered iu. She a. as at once called to tho stand and' gavo testimony in a whisper, which was interpreted by tho crior. For tho first time Holmes broke down. Ho gazed
A witness describes travels with Holmes under the alias H. M. Pratt and identifying Pietzel's picture, after which the judge ruled evidence about the children's deaths inadmissible in the trial for the father's murder.
The Evening Bulletin · 1 November 1895 · page 1
ing housa on Park Place. On Oct. 18 wo went to Toronto. Wo remained thero until tho 26th, I believe. Whilo there he told mo ho was going off on a pleasure trip." After detailing their travels in Can ada and Vermont, and tho arrest in Bos ton, sho said that duriug theso travels she had never seen Mrs. Pietzel or tho childron. Sho identified Pietzel's pio tnro as a man sho had known in Fort Worth as B. T. Lyman. Holmes was known as H. M. Pratt, and this ho ex plained by saying tho business arrange ments about property were complicated and ho thought it best to uso that name.
See moreSee less
"Cross-cxamino," said tho district at ronto." Detectivo Geyer was horo temporarily withdrawn, i.nd Mr. Graham olFered to provo the fiuuing of tlio boues of How and in Irvington, a suburb of Indianap olis, and tho bodies of tho girls in a cel lar of tho house ut G St. Vincent street, Toronto. The defenso objected nnd tlio jury wero taken to their rooms' whilo a lengthy argument of tlio admissability of tho testimony wns made on both sides. Judge Arnold caused a mild sensation by deciding that the killing of tho chil dren had no connection with the trial of Holmes for tho murder of tho father, and that no such evidenco could bo in
The clipping reports that the murder trial of H. H. Holmes, also called Herman Budgett, began Tuesday in Philadelphia, with his attorneys withdrawing and Holmes acting as his own counsel before later asking for help.
Semi-Weekly Interior Journal · 1 November 1895 · page 2
and killed Wednesday. The trial of H. H. Holmes, or Herman Budgett, for the murder of Bonja-min p PintKnl. tipcran Tuesday at Phila- .t.lnh!ii. TTolmea1 attorneys withdrew from the case, and he declined the services of others whom the court wished to appoint, and went Into tho trial as his own attorney, afterwards, however, calling for help. The arch fiend of the 10th century seems near the rope's end.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The clipping names the attorneys in the Holmes trial, lists additional murder charges against the prisoner, and recounts how Pietzel's body was found, misidentified via an exploded lamp, buried in potter's field, then claimed through a lawyer for an insurance claim.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 1 November 1895 · page 7
Holmes Conducts His Defense- COURT DENIED A POSTPONEMENT.
A \ ’ 11. H. HOLMES. nold presided. The commonwealth was rep resented by District Attorney George S. Graham and Assistant District Attorney Thomas W. Harlow, and the defense was conducted by W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel R. Rotan. In addition to the murder of Pietzel, the prisoner is also accused of the murder nt Toronto, Ont., of Pietzel's two young daughters, Alice and Nellie, of the murder at Irvington, Ind., of the young son, Howard Pietzel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes castle at Chicago, Benjamin F.
See moreSee less
Pietzel's body was found in the house at 1316 Callowhill street, Sep tember 3, 1894., A shattered lamp was found by the side of the body, which bore evidence of having been burned, and the coroner’s jury concluded that the oil lamp had exploded and that Pietzel, who was at the time known as B. I'. Perry, had been burned to death and accordingly rendered a verdict of accidental death. There was no claimant for the body and it was buried i in potter's field. Subsequently an assertion > came from Pietzel’s lawyer at St Louis, Jeptha Howe, that the body was that of Benjamin F. Pietzel and a claim was made iam the Fidelity Mutual life association of
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The clipping describes how Pietzel's exhumed body was identified by his daughter, prompting the insurance company, doubting accidental death, to use detectives who then arrested Mudgett, alias Holmes, in Boston and took him to Philadelphia.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 1 November 1895 · page 7
H. H. HOLMES.
isany carried on Pietzel's life. The body ^•as exhumed and was fullyidentified by i®s daughter, who was brought from St wmis as that of Pietzel. The insurance Smpany paid the claim, but not satisfied £ it Pietzel hail met his death accidentally L ] once placed detectives on the ease to solve | i mystery. This resulted in the arrest . -Boston of Mudgett. alias Holmes. ” Be was taken to Philadelphia and placed
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The clipping reports arguments over a requested postponement, citing witness availability, Mrs Pietzel's health, and new testimony, before Judge Arnold overruled the defense's motions for continuance.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 1 November 1895 · page 7
H. H. HOLMES.
xS declaring that the state’s witnesses ^eseut at their own volition and that Jitihuiiiice should be granted, it would J?‘the absolute destruction of the com 3-alth’s case.” Mrs Pietzel’s health (impaired, Mr Graham further said, if the case should be postponed, the m would intensify her illness. Lawyer .And P. Rotan, for the defense, pleaded / time in which he and his colleague could /alias on Holmes’s assets and thus bring Ja-itnessvs to Philadelphia who will not come r unless their expenses are paid. The dis coverv of new testimony within the past ► foui-. or five days which he wanted to in vestigate was a further plea of the attorney for ,i. continuance. . Judge Arnold overruled the motions for t postponement in a very few words and
Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.
A garbled fragment states that conducting his own defense proved a Herculean task for Holmes, and separately mentions a meeting of bankers and others interested in Northern Pacific affairs.
Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 1 November 1895 · page 5
^l» we always have. I MRS. P. F. HOSCH. I TOO MUCH FOR HOLMES, Conducting His Own Defense Herculean Task. hUK CONFERENCE. WM Meeting of IUIKM and Others Interested in .Northern i'aclflu Affairs.
This front-page index lists a brief headline noting that H. H. Holmes 'partially broke down' during ongoing court proceedings. It offers no further detail, appearing only as one line among many news bulletins of the day.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1895 · page 1
Holmes Partially Breaks Down.
The people of Hot Springs want something hot, but the governor in sists that the hose be turned on them. ' I The battleship Indiana is having a regular Hoosier run of luck. She ran into the mud three times on her first voyage. State Teasurer Koerner has Just now over a million dollars in hand. He won't be able to us? it for sealskin sacques and cigarettes.however. It may be some consolation to H. It may be some consolation to H. H. Holmes to know that there is a greater criminal than he in the world In the person of Abdul Hamid, sultan of Turkey.
See moreSee less
yyyy~ '■ The latest evidence of returning The latest evidence of returning prosperity in North Dakota is found in the fact that a Grand Forks man yesterday purchased $30,000 of Fargo city bonds. A gentleman named Bourgeois has A gentleman named Bourgeois has been asked to form a French cabinet. He'll feel quite nonpareil after the chamber of deputies has taken a few votes on him. St. Paul's grand jury was exces sively industrious. It got its lorgnette on everything from the wine rooms to cemeteries. It indicted two men who are dead. '.-.■■■' ' . Democratic harmony has reached & pleasing climax when Senator Hill publicly reads letters from President Cleveland indorsing the New York — — _o_ ~o_ -— au
The clipping remarks that H. H. Holmes may take some consolation in knowing a greater criminal than himself exists in Abdul Hamid, sultan of Turkey.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1895 · page 1
EVENTS TODAY.
It may be some consolation to H. H. Holmes to know that there is a greater criminal than he in the world In the person of Abdul Hamid, sultan of Turkey. yyyy~ '■ -—
The clipping, a fragment, reports that despite Holmes' statement he would testify and call Miss Yoke, his counsel privately said the defense would offer no case and submit on the evidence presented.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1895 · page 5
SOBS IN THE DOCK
the defense will open, and, in spite of Holmes' statement that he would himself testify and also call Miss Yoke.his counsel privately stated to night that the defense would offer no defense, but submit the case on
During Holmes's murder trial, witness Sidney Samuels testified about a fraudulent mortgage note Holmes negotiated in Fort Worth under the alias H. M. Pratt. The defense won a ruling excluding further evidence about the children's murders, while prosecutors sought to prove Holmes was already married, undermining Miss Yoke's competency to testify for him.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 November 1895 · page 5
spoke quickly and sharply, and invar iably referred to Holmes as "the indi vidual.". This amused even Holmes, who smiled broadly whenever the term was used. District Attorney Graham produced the note identified by Mrs. Pietzel yesterday as the one Holmes
The clipping reports that Mr. Graham questioned Holmes about his whereabouts on the day the murder is supposed to have occurred, but it is fragmentary and gives no further detail.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 1 November 1895 · page 1
HIS ALLEGED WIFE ON THE STAND.
Mr. Graham then put a series of ques tions as to Holmes’ whereabouts on the day the murder is supposed to have been Holmes’ Whereabouts.
A woman recounting travels in Canada and Vermont and an arrest in Boston said she never saw Mrs. Pitzel or the children, but identified Pitzel's picture as a man she had known in Fort Worth as B. T. Lyman.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 1 November 1895 · page 1
After detailing their travels in Canada and Vermont and the arrest in Boston she said that during these travels she ? had never seen Mrs. Pitzei or the child ly reu. She identified Pitzel’s picture as a man she had known in Fort Worth as B. T. Lyman. Holmes was known up Identified Pitzel’s Picture.
The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudgett, known as H. H. Holmes, went on trial in Philadelphia before Judge Arnold for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, with his lawyers' motion for a 60-day continuance denied and their subsequent withdrawal, leaving Holmes to conduct his own defense.
Fisherman & Farmer · 1 November 1895 · page 1
known as H. H. Holmes, the self-confessed life insurance swindler aud alleged multi-mur derer, whose supposed crimes have been the topic for general discussion during the past sev Monday morning at Philadel murdered Benjamin F. Pietzel. Judge Arnold presided. for a continuance of 60 days on the ground that they were not prepared to go on. Judge Ar then the defendants' lawyers (V. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan) withdrew. 1 he case was then resumed, Holmes con ducting his own defense. Herman W. Mudgett, 'better eral months, was placed on trial phia, on the charge of having Counsel for the defense asked nold overruled the motion, and
This damaged clipping fragment describes Martin Julian and Robert Fitzsimmons leaving a court room, with disjointed references to Holmes's absence and a court conference, but the text is too garbled to follow clearly.
The News & Observer · 1 November 1895 · page 1
SOBBED LIKE A CHILD
out of the court room close upon the heels Holmes bad been away for five hours of of Martin Julian and Robert Fitzsimmons the next day, coming back flushed and as they made their way back to their conferring witb the Turks of that city personal appearance on that occasion, and neighborhood as to the means to be and then told the court he would re
The clipping describes Miss Georgiana Yoke's lengthy testimony against Holmes, his emotional breakdown in court, his self-conducted cross-examination, and the defense's successful objection to further evidence about the children's alleged murders.
The News & Observer · 1 November 1895 · page 1
HIS WIFE TURNED AGAINST HIM And She Never Bestowed a Glance on the Man She Once Had Loved as, for One Hour and Forty Minutes, She Related a Story that Slowly bat Sure ly Tightened the Noose Aronnd His Neck-Holmes Conducted the CrossExamination Himself. Philadelphia, Pa., Oct. 31 —For about thirty minutes to-day, the nerve at which all men have marvelled forsook Holmes, and, bowed and broken, he sank his head into his hands and sobbed like a child. Meanwhile, the woman he persists in calling his wife, and upon whom he had p;nned his highest hope, sat two yards away, relating a story that slowly, but surely tightened the noose on his neck.
See moreSee less
For one hour and forty minutes she whispered to the court crier the words that told how Pietzal had come to the Eleventh street house, where they were stopping, the night before the murder; and how Holmes bad been away for five hours of the next day, coming back flushed and excited, and carrying her hurriedly off to Indianapolis. It was the day after this that the corpse was found in the Callow hill street house. At the close of her examination-in chief, Holmes asked to conduct the cross examination himself, and standing in a corner of the dock, nervously wringing his hands, he put a few questions. Then he said he would reserve the right to call her as a witness for the defem e. Throughout her testimony, Miss Georgiana Yoke, for so she calls herself never once bestowed a pas-ing glance upon the man she once had loved. During tho greater part of it, she kept her blue eyes riveted on the floor, and when it b came necessary to raise them, she was careful to lift them so that the pale, shrunken face in the* dock should not come in their path. The case progressed so swiitly to-day that but few witnesses remain to be heard before the closing of the common wealth’s case. Then the defense will open and, in spite of Holmes’ statement that he would himself testify and also call Miss Yoke, his counsel privately stated to night that the defense would offer no evidence but submit the case on argument alone. And the* express supreme confidence in his acquittal. Their first victory was gained to night and it disappointed those morbid listeners who had counted on viewing the bones of the dead boy, Howard. The defense strenuously ob jected to the introduction of any further evidence touching the alleged murder of the children, and Judge Arnold sus tained the contention. This was evi dently a blow to the commonwealth, and District Attorney Graham fought against it with great vigor. Holmes showed no elation at the triumph, but hta lawyers were unfeignedly jubilant. The taking of testimony was resumed at 10:20 a. m. The first witness was Sidney Samuels, a member of the bar of Fort Worth, Texas, who told about Holmes’ coming to him, under the name of Pratt to have him draw up the note which Mrs. Pietzel testified Holmes pre tended to pay at St. Louis. The note was never indorsed, nor the loan made. After Inspector Gary of the insurance company has given some testimony tend ing to show that Holmes was a much married man, Miss Yoke cr Mrs. How ard, was called to the stand. For the first time Holmes broke down. He gazed steadily at her for a few sec onds, while his hands twitched nerv ously and his lips opened and closed, but she carefully avoided meeting his eyes. Then he suddenly bent forward over a little desk in his dock and the tears began to trickle down his cheeks. He drew his handkerchief ont and for a mo ment or two sobbed. Then quickly recov eringhimself.he dried his eyes and bowed his head, busily engaged himself with his notes but still occasionally giving way to a sob. She gave her name as Geor giana Yoke, said she was in St. Louis in June 1694, and knew the prisoner, who was in the drug business and went under the names of H. H. Holmes and 11. M. Howard. She came to Philadel phia in August and remained here four weeks. Mr. Graham then put a series of questions to fix Holmes’ whereabouts on the day the murder is supposed to have been committed—Sunday, Sept. 2,1894. “I was in my room on the evening of Saturday, Sept. 1. I had been ill part of the time in bed. The prisoner was at home. Some one called during the evening and he went down stairs. When he came up he said it was a messenger from the Pennsylvania Railroad to see him about a copying deal with the com pany. Afterwards he said the caller was B. F. Piet zel. This was the day be fore we left for Philaoelphi Was he at home the next day?” “Part of the day. He went out about half past ten in the morning, and came back between 3 and 4 in the afternoon. He said he had been at Nieetown, a sub urb of Philadelphia. We left on the 10:15 train. The prisoner remained with me in Indianapolis for a day or two. Tnen he went away, saying he was going to St. Louis. When he came back, he went with me to my mother’s home in Franklin, Ind, From there we returned to Indianapolis, and a few days afterwards he went to Philadel-
The clipping quotes H. H. Holmes saying his trial will prove he is a much better man than either Hayward or Durrant in his line, followed by an unrelated fragment about a horseless carriage.
Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 1 November 1895 · page 4
THIS trial will prove that I am a much better man than either Hay ward or Dur rant, in my line—H. H. Holmes. AND as soon as the horseless carriage
H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgett, pleads not guilty and goes on trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, with witnesses brought from several cities and sensational revelations expected.
The Oregon Mist · 1 November 1895 · page 1
Philadelphia, Oct SO. H. H. Holmes, or Hennan Mudgett, whose name or alias, has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times, will be placed on trial for bis life tomorrow in the court of oyer and terminer, of this city. The spooified charge to which he will be called upon to answer is the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, and he has already officially declared himself not guilty. The revolting details of the many crimes with which Holmes' name has been directly or indirectly connected have been given much pub.
See moreSee less
licity, and the cold, implaoablo de moaner which has characterized the mun throughout has been so frequently commented upon that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of the Western hemisphere. The commonwealth has already ex. ponded thousands of dollars in its efforts to bring the prisoner to sum mary justice, and there is an indica tiou that if a conviotion of murder in the first degroe be obtained he will be quickly "railroaded" to the gallows. Witnesses have been brought to this city from Boston, Chicago, Iudianapo us, lrvlngton, Inch, and almost every city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. What revela tious these witnesses will make has been kept a profound secret by the prosecuting oflicors, but there is expec tation of sensational developments.
The clipping reports witnesses' testimony on Pitezel's death—identification of his body, chloroform poisoning evidence, and Holmes's mutilation of the corpse—followed by brief unrelated items on destroyed land improvements in Luzerne County and a Quaker minister barred from speaking at a Berwyn church.
The Cambria Freeman · 1 November 1895 · page 4
HOLMES BACKS DOWN
ham. Jeannette Pitezel, Dessa. the daugh ter of the dead man, was the first wit ness called. She is a slender, pale girl of about 17, and was neatly attired in aarK gray. She was tailed merely to identify several large crayons of her father, which she did. Eugene Smith, who found Pitezel's body in the Cailowhill street house on Sept. 4, btM. then told a detailed story of his discovery, which has been al ready fully published. He had seen Holmes at Pitezel's house during his lifetime. The witness was present when the corpse of Pifev.el was ex humed from the potter's field, and was there first introduced to Holmes.
See moreSee less
Law yer Howe of St. Louis, Alice Pitc-zel, the young daughter, and the iusurauce officers were there. The body was recognized by the witness as Pitezel's Holmes offered iO to have the corpse cremated. Holmes told the insurance people of the marks of identification. Dr. William J. Scott, who examined Pitezel's body after it was discovered, explained the situation of the room and the arrangement of the windows so that the sun's rays should fall upon the corpse and hasten decomposition, to gether with the position of the burns on the body, the broken jar, pipe, etc. He verified the district attorney's as sertion that the pipe could uot have failed from the lips of Pitezel to the place where it was found, ami that the jar could not have been broken by au explosion, because the pieces of glass were not scatttred about the room, but were inside the ;ar. The doctor dwelt upon the discovery of chloroform in the stomach, and said large quantities of t!i6 drug had been used, and from the contend condition of the lungs and the empty heart it was apparent that the man had met a sudden and violent death from chloroform poisoning. Dr Mattern corroborated Dr. Scott's testimony and dilated on the ghastly scene at the potter's field, when, in the presence of a half dozen other persons, including the officers of the swindled insurance c nipauv and the young daughter of the dead man, Holmes took a lancet and coldly and ruthlessly cut and hacked off portions of tl-'e corpse of the man he is charged with Laving murdered. Other witue.-ses gave testimocj c. miLui importance. He Ila1 Too Mtictt Land. Wit.kf.sbarre. Pa.. Oct 30. Williatr Thorpe, a wealthy railroad contractor with an office at 45 Broadway. New V ork. recently purchased 1.400 acre of land in the lower end of Luzerne county. He erected a number of build ings, planted trees and built fences The buildings have been destroyed by incendiaries, the trees torn up and the lences destroyed. It is alleged that some people living in the v;iV:tT Kaid that 1,400 acres of laud were toe much for one man to own. Objected to the Onaxer. Bfrwyn, Pa.. Oct. 30 Somewhat of a sensation was created here when the Presbyterian congregation declined to permit Isaac Wilson of Canada, a well known minister of the Society of Friends, to address a meeting in "their church. Home of the officers of the church objected, fearing that the speak er of the day. whose liberal views are well kuown, might say .something not strictly orthodox. An Kx-Iianker on Trial. Lancaster, Pa., Oct. 30. After nu merous delays E. K. Smith, the Colum bia banker who failed in lSi3. has been placed on trial on one of the numerous lucictmeuts found against him for em
The clipping, a fragment, describes testimony that Holmes took a lancet and coldly cut and hacked portions of a corpse, the man he is charged with murdering, in the presence of the dead man's daughter, with other witnesses giving testimony of minor importance.
The Cambria Freeman · 1 November 1895 · page 4
daughter of the dead man, Holmes took a lancet and coldly and ruthlessly cut and hacked off portions of tl-'e corpse of the man he is charged with Laving murdered. Other witue.-ses gave testimocj c. miLui importance.
The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa. · and 1 other paper
The clipping reports that Judge Arnold excluded evidence about the Pitezel children's murder from Holmes's trial, prompting the prosecution to seek more time, while Holmes broke down emotionally when Miss Yoke, the woman he had deceived into marriage, took the witness stand.
The Scranton Tribune · 1 November 1895 · page 1
SCENE CAUSED BY MISS YOKE
Pl!alelphla, Oct. 31. The first gleam of hoptthat has oome to Holmes lnce he was arraigned for 'the murder of Benjamin F. Pltezel today broke through the rift of the dark cloud of damaging evidence In which he has been enveloped. Mis attorneys this af ternoon succeeded .in keepingfrom the Jury, all evidence bearing directly upon the murder of the Fltezel children. The decision of the cjurt ruling this evi dence out left the prosecution In. con fusion, and. In consequence, the dis trict attoreny asked for time In which to rearrange his case.
See moreSee less
The court grant ed the request and the regular night session was not held, and the case went over until tomorrow morning. iDespite the decision of the court In refusing to adni'.t testimony showing that Holmes killed the Pltesel children. District Attorney Graham is convinced that the evidence already present ed to the Jury will convict Holmes. Although the direct evidence possessed by the commonwealth that Holmes killed Pltesel is 41rcuft)stlal, so strong is thlschara of presumptive testimony that, to any one who has followed it, there can hardly -remain a doubt that on that Sunday In September, a year ago, Holmes killed Pltesel In' the house at 1316 Callowhlll street. - Notwithstanding the .decision of Judge Arnold today, much indirect evi dence has been introduced showing thait Holmes unquestionably made way with the Pltesel children, and this, in every probability, will 'have weight with the Jury, and even If unconsciously, will, in all likelihood, influence their minds In, arriving at a verdict in the case be fore tlhem. Whin Holmes Broke Down. The decision of Judge Arnold and the confrontation In the witness 'box of Holmes toy the -woman whom he de ceived dm to believing she was his legal wife, and the break-down of the prison er that followed were the leading feat ures of the proceedings today. After several -witnesses had testified this morning the name of "(Miss Yoke" was called. Holmes had expected that the woman whom he haJA lured Into mar riage with the belief that he was single would 'be called upon to give testimony against him, tout the prospects of her appearance on the witness stand completely unnerved him. He called eagerly to his counsel and urged with eagerness to object to the witness. In the meanwhile, however. Miss Yoke had taken her place in the -witness stand. From his behavior as she did so it would seem as if Holmes really loved this -woman. As -he came for ward his pallid face flushed to the brows and then the blood retreateU, leaving him ghastly white. He looked appealir.'gly at her, but she carefully avoided a-lanalng In his direction, When we girl , sor evidently avoided even so much as looking at him, Holmes bowed his head and struggled with a sob that shook his frame. While he wiped the tears from Ms face. He appealed plteously to his lawyers to have the witness taken from the stand,. They com batted as well as they coulu the evidence of the district at torney that Miss. Yoke was not his legal wife and was therefore competent un der the statutes of this state to testify against the prisoner. The testimony that there was at least one and probably two other women with whom Holmes had gone through a legal marriage ceremony was convincing, and (Judge Arnold allowed Miss Yoke to testify. Miss Yoke a Stsr Witness. Before she began her testimony Holmes' counsel stated to the court that the prisoner would cross-examine' the witness himself. Miss Yoke was one of the star witnesses for the com Pltezel called on Holmes the night be fore the day he was killed, and that Holmes told her that he had an engage ment with Pltesel on the next day and was absent from the house from 10.30 In the morning until 4,30 In the af ternoon on Sunday, her evidence was not so damaging to the prisoner as those in the court room expected. She seemed to have no knowledge of any of the events bearing directly upon the murder of Pltesel or the children. Throughout the period In which these events occurred she was constantly with Holmes, but he readily deceived her as to the reason for their hurried movements from city to city by spe cious lies. (During ' 'Miss Yoke's testimony Holmes recovered his composure, and when he arose to cross-examine her his voice was steadier and louder than it has been at any time since the trial began. His examination of the wit ness was no'.. long, and he succeeded in abstracting from her some statements that were favorable to himself, Dcteetlvo Gcycrs Story. - At this afternoon's session, Detective Geyer, who traced Holmes' movements with the Pltezel children, and discov ered their bodies, was placed upon the stand. Geyer was expected to be tin chief witness of the prosecution. He told of the conflicting stories related to him "by Holmes of the manner of Pitezel's death. . One of these stories was that the body found in the house on Callowhlll street was a bogus corpse and the last one, and the one to which Holmes has since stuck to, was that Pltesel commute! suicide, and that he discovered the body, and with it carried out the scheme to defraud the insur ance company. -." When 'Mr. Graham started to have the witness tell of the finding of the bodies of the Pltezel children the de fense made the most stubborn fight tha-t It has waged since the trial be gan. . ; - , Judge 'Arnold, without hesitation, de cided that the killing of the children had no direct bearing upon the mur der of Pltesel. He said that If Holmes was acquitted here he could be taken either to Toronto or Indianapolis to be tried for the murders committed there, and that be ruled the evidence out. Holmes had watched the face of the Judge attentively while he spoke, and when he rendered his decision a gleam of relief passed over his coun tenance, and there came a sudden gulp ing In his throat. Attorneys for Defense Rejolee. ' , The attorneys of the defense were Joy ful over the deolslon of Judge Arnold and they -now affect to believe that there Is a prospect of the Jury return ms; verdlot of acquittal against Holmes as they claim no evidence has been product showing directly that the prisoner killed Pltesel. On the con trary, Mr. Graham Is equally confident tht he has placed a noose around Holmes' neck by the evidence he has already presec-ted. - Judge Arnolds decision has cut off U MKimonr w Mnt nrty witn monwealth, but beyond proving that
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · 1 November 1895
The Mitchell Capital · Mitchell, S.D.
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's murder trial is expected to be as long and sensational as the Durrant trial, and notes that Topeka, Kansas, has taken up efforts to liberate the Cubans since Chicago is not making progress on it.
The Mitchell Capital · 1 November 1895 · page 4
H. H. Holmes, who is credited with having murdered any number of peo ple, is being tried for murder and it is expected the trial will bo as of long duration as the Durrant trial, with an equal number of sensational episodes. •Since Chicago is not making any great headway in relieving the de pressed Cubans the town of Topeba. Kanses. have undertaken their libera tion.
This damaged clipping is too fragmentary to follow clearly, but it references a Presbyterian pastor at Chautmont, N.Y. whose congregation petitioned to dissolve his pastoral relation, and mentions a prisoner's case involving a clerical brother and multiple aliases.
The Mitchell Capital · 1 November 1895 · page 6
upper and the nether millstone, with tne red notion pressure screws working auto matically. peek of trouble. Forty-three of the el-jhtv-eieht members of the Presby terian Church at Chautnont, X. Y.. of which he is the pastor, have petitioned which he is the pastor, have petitioned spectacular career that his baiflj the Presbytery to dissolve the pastoral name, Herman Mudgett has almost b« GrTver's Loyrl Brother. effectual attempt to securc tnent. The prisoner is The President's clerical brother is in a own case. man on trial during the cours* of nnctriPol N. HOLMKS. to, COUdur So many aliases have been wu worn trrU
The clipping reports that forty-three of the eighty-eight members of a Presbyterian church, where the President's clerical brother serves as pastor, have petitioned the Presbytery to dissolve the pastoral relationship, though the text then breaks into garbled, unrelated fragments about a trial and aliases.
The Mitchell Capital · 1 November 1895 · page 6
H. H. HOLMES
matically. GrTver's Loyrl Brother. The President's clerical brother is in a peek of trouble. Forty-three of the el-jhtv-eieht members of the Presby terian Church at Chautnont, X. Y.. of which he is the pastor, have petitioned which he is the pastor, have petitioned spectacular career that his baiflj the Presbytery to dissolve the pastoral name, Herman Mudgett has almost b« effectual attempt to securc to, tnent. The prisoner is COUdur own case. So many aliases have been wu worn trrU man on trial during the cours* of nnctriPol
This damaged clipping reports that District Attorney Gram produced a note, identified by Mrs Pitzel, said to be the one Holmes pretended to pay at a St Louis bank, amid references to Holmes being called 'the individual.'
The Salt Lake Herald · 1 November 1895 · page 1
CASE PROGRESSES SWIFTLY
Worth Tex He invariably referred to Holmes as the individual Holmes smiled broadly whenever the term vas used use District Attorney Gram produced a note identified by Mrs Pitzel yesterday a the one Holmes pretended to pay at the St LoutS ban c fo which he took
The clipping records Miss Yorke's testimony that she was in St Louis in June 1894 and knew the prisoner by the names H H Holmes and H I Howard, who was then in the drug business.
The Salt Lake Herald · 1 November 1895 · page 1
CASE PROGRESSES SWIFTLY
Were you in St Louis in June 1S94 was I was the lirst question asked Miss Yorke Knew the Irihoner Did you know the prisoner I did By what name H H Holmes and H 1 Howard What was his business then The drug business
The prosecution rested its case after Mrs. Pitezel's emotional breakdown on the stand, with the defense expected to claim suicide though the evidence against Holmes was reportedly weak.
Alexandria Gazette · 1 November 1895 · page 2
TO-DAY'S TELEGRAPHIC NEWS Philadelphia, Nov. l.?The ques? tions asked by Holmes'* attorneys in? dicate that they will claim that Pitezel committed suicide, which is the only defence that could be offered. It is more than probable that Holmes will be put upon the stand, as he is anxious to testify. Mrs. Pitezel was the first witness placed upon the stand to-day. The strain upon Mrs. Pitezel upon the stand broke her down and when she was taken into tbe corridor she became hysterical and her screams penetrated to the court room.
See moreSee less
She was carried in? to the district attorney's office and re? storatives were applied and she became quieter. After some unimportant testimony Mr. Graham gave notice that the case f jr tbe commonwealth was closed. The case made out against Holmes was woefully weak as far as any direct evidence implicating the accused'in the murder of Pitezel. The defense, how ever, appeals to haveno defense, that can be called worthy of such a name. The Holmes Trial.
This garbled, fragmentary clipping describes a crowded courtroom where H. H. Holmes conferred with his counsel, appeared cheerful, and joked with court officers as a witness began testifying.
Wheeling Register · 1 November 1895 · page 1
: rial of H. H. Holmes, the confessed conspirator and alug d murderer of ne>n, women and children v proceeding, there appeared to l>e almost as many women as ni n pre-nit. Most of them f. ! i seats in the sp ■* usually reserved tor witnt - s. anu a number sat within tiie court clerk’s enclosure. ever, was placed in :i » dock at 10 j o’clock. H;s com: »!, Messrs. Shoe mil: er and Rotan, promptly went to dim and a long and earnest colloquy ensued. was apparently off irg sug?* -tior.s or perhaps civil g his orders.
See moreSee less
He appear ed to be brighter and more cheerful than at any time since the trial began, and a’ er a:> counsel had r mi 1 their s> i s, h ch t< il and laughed with two court off. r < atio: d n xt to the little c Id barr-d • igo in which he sat. The first ftitne-s of th* day proved to be a f 31.—'When the J ged persons had been permitted , enter the court room in which the Holmi s. as calm . i unmoved as • Holmes did most of ch talking and
This fragmented courtroom account describes disputed promissory notes tied to a Fort Worth property deal, then testimony from an insurance inspector and the emotional appearance of Miss Yoke, also called Mrs. Howard, as Holmes wept while she testified.
Wheeling Register · 1 November 1895 · page 1
■1 or- ; Ldm-s pretended to which purpose he took $5,000 from her. Mr. S -nm Is said the body of the note w , in Lis ha; Iwr' ing. In the iruter r irt of April or early in May, 1^94, ha -aid. there v.as in Fort Worth a man irdividual." H* v .ui oversaving the erection of a three-story structure as acnt I r Benton T. Lyman, the sup : - i owner, l'ratt came to the wit n -s and trh 1 to negotiate a loan of $16.0C0 by mortgeging the prop rty, and after some transactions.
See moreSee less
the note was drawn up and signed Benton T. Lyman. It was dated May 14, 1891. Subsequently Pratt claimed to have lost i; and tohi ".Ifness he had drawn up a j second note similar to this. The note was orli,1 rally drawn to the order of B. p. s .-,m is, brother of the witness. The note was never endorsed nor the loan made, however. Witness identi fied bath h. original note and the sub stitute, Mr. Graham seeking to prove that the note was never a legal docu ment. pany, >s recalled. Mr. Graham saying he proposed to prove by him that Hol mes was a much-married man and that. Miss Yoke was not his lawful wife, as he asst-r; <1. and is therefore incompe tent to testify. oner’s house at Willi unotte, ills., a wo Holmes. He identified a photograph of her. l ast December witness saw Ho’rnes in Moyamsing prison, this city, when he told him of the visit to \Vil liamette. a I tier to his wife, and <iid so. asking the witness to mail it. The envelope was not addressed. Holm s leaving it to t^e witness. Subsequently witness had spoken to Miss Yoke, known a> Mrs. Howard. She was not the woman fci had seen in Williamette. Holmes tol l the witness he h d demited ?1 o,i0 of the insurance money with a Mr. Bla<ktusn, o; Chicago, his real estate av-at. so that “Mrs. Holmes” could draw upon it. tion to 11 the evidence of Mr. Gary r pi ' a ing Miss Yoke, btu were over niled. The letter was read to the jury. ten by II dm -s. one from Columbus to H. H. Cass. Chicago, agent Of the in surance company, giving him a detailed -11 serif ion - f l’ietzel for the purpose of identification. ws s opened, and Miss V kc. or Mrs. Howard, the alleged wife, was ushered 1 in. rind gave her testimony in a whisper, which was interpreted by the crier. For the first time Holmes brok< down. Hi -aaed steadily at her for a few sec onds. His hands twitched nervously it in'! his lips opened and closed, but she carefully avoided meeting his eyes. • ' ..n he* sudd> ulv b* • -t forward over die to trickle down his cheeks. ib* drew his handkerchief out. and for a moment rr two sobbed. Then quickly reccvei i- . himstdf.be dried hiseye. and bowed Ms bead, busily engaged himself with his notes, but still occasionally giving wav to a sob. '.V voa-s w ih flaxen hair and blue evP; She was stylishly attired in was the first question. ; Lie St. 1. mis bank, and for . . wn as H. M. Pratt If was “this lrpector Gary, of tV Insurance Com Mr. Gary said he had soon at the pris ting h ra if as Mrs. H. KL Holmes then said he wanted to write, The defense entered a formal objec Two other letters were offered, writ At this point a side door in the room Pho was at once called to the stand, desk in his dock and tears began Georgiana ooko, ior m * is a tall, slender woman of about •Were you in St. Louis in June, 1894?” * l was.” „„ • Did vou know the prisoner. "I Md.” “Bv what names? „ „ "H. H. Holmes and H. M. Howard.
This damaged fragment describes a moment when a man named Holmes reportedly broke down, staring at a woman while his hands twitched and his lips opened and closed.
Wheeling Register · 1 November 1895 · page 1
For the first time Holmes brok< down. Hi -aaed steadily at her for a few sec onds. His hands twitched nervously it in'! his lips opened and closed, but she
H. H. Holmes's trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel opens in Philadelphia, with Holmes clashing with the judge over his defense counsel and failing to gain a continuance or new lawyer.
The Meeker Herald · 2 November 1895 · page 2
The Swindling Murderer Hu Trouble Holmes, who, according to his own re markable confessions, stands at the head of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial In the court of oyer and terminer this morning for the mur der of Benjamin F. Pietzel. Arranged against him as the commonwealth pro secutors are District Attorney George S. Graham and his special assistant. Thomas W. Bartow, while the counsel for the prisoner are William A. Shoe maker and Samuel I*. Rotatn. young iueinl>ers of the junior bar of this city. Judge Michael Arnold is upon the bench.
See moreSee less
to secure a continuance of the case, but on tbe protest of the state’s attorney, tills was refused. Holmes’ lawyers then threatened to withdraw from the case, but were told by the Judge that they were liable to disbarment. Holmes then declared that he would uot allow them to act for him and asked to be giveu un til to-morrow to engage Lawyer Moon. This was refused aud tbe examination of jurors continued. Holmes examining them himself. Mr. Moon came In, but after a conference with Holmes, refused to undertake the case if not allowed HOLMES ON TRIAL. With the Judge. Philadelphia. Pu., Oct 28.—H. H. Holmes and his attorneys attempted more time. He got no satisfaction from the Judge, and the case proceeded.
Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
The article reports that Judge Arnold's ruling limiting testimony to the Pitezel murder shortened the Holmes trial, excluded gruesome evidence and many witnesses, and prompted the defense to suggest Mrs. Pitezel may have led Holmes rather than the reverse.
Waterbury Democrat · 2 November 1895 · page 1
FOR HOLMES' DEFENSE. HIS ATTORNEYS DEPEND ON THE PROSECUTION'S WEAKNESS.
Philadelphia, Nov. 3. Tonight tho world will probably know whether or not Holmes will hang. Incidentally Holmes, (vho Is not now a part of the world, but a mere shrunken figure, with a number, a cage and all men's enmity, will himself know. Apart from this a small army of ex hausted men lawyers, court officials and newspaper reporters will offer up thanks for the termination of, in many respects, the most extraordinary case tried since Lady Justice bandaged up hnr eyes and itarted in business. When the trial began last Monday, iverybody anticipated a siege of at least two weeks, but Tuesday the case took one ludden turn and yesterday another, which will help to push it to swift conclusion.
See moreSee less
The decision of Judge Arnold that no tes timony would bo admitted other than that bearing directly on the murder of Benjamin F. Pitozel had the effect of keeping out a group of grewsomo exhibits and silencing about SO witnesses brought here from Canada, New England and the west and supported for six days at tho commonwealth's expense. It prevented the offering in evidence of the" mcldered bones of the boy, Howard Pitezel, tho gtove in which he was burned, the clothes the little fellow wore when he had a body to put inside of them and the toys ho played with and the trunk which emoth Bred out tho lives of the girls Alico and Nellie. Besides, it put a quietus on De tective Geyer, whose detailed narrative of his travels over the continent in a suc cessful search for evidences of Holmes' de thrilling tale. District Attorney Graham fought as hard as he knew how to get thi3 evidence in, but the law was against him, and the defense scored its first and proba bly its last victory. When he found him self defeated, he said he would close his case, and he kept his word. He did not even exhibit the skull of Pitezel, thereby disappointing a lot of people who love to revel in the horrible. There is an impression 'that Lawyer R. O. Moon will do the talking for tho de fense, and his forensio ability is of no mean order. It was he whom Holmes called upon last Monday when he dismiss ed his lawyers, Mr. Moon declining the task through lack of time for preparation. He admitted being familiar with the main facts and will be well qualified to address the jury. There was no change, in Holmes de havo perceived a deeper pallor on his cheeks and in his blue eyes the subdued glare of a wild beast tracked to earth at last. But it needed a keen eye to detect it. Was Mrs. Tltezel the STengali? Mrs. Pitezel was again recalled for a moment to tell that she, too, had boen in jail on a charge of conspiracy and had been discharged. In cross examination tho deJense said it would show that it was Mrs. Pitezel who had led Holmes about the country, and not tho defendant who had moved her from town to town. The district attorney sneered at that and spoke of subjecting the "poor woman Dn the stand" to a still greater strain. Mr. Rotan, who is a hearty, honest and rather impulsive young man, blurted out - that the prosecuting officer was under stood; that he was simply talking for ef fect on the jury. The black gowned Judge Arnold want ed to know if the defenso was going to show that Mrs. Pitezel was the Svengali. A dapper young man, wearing a light suit, red necktie, and with curly black hair, came forward when the name of John King was called. He testified to the fact that he read the manuscript of a book entitled "Holmes' Own Story." He re ceived tho manuscript from Lawyer Shoe maker, one of the counsel for the defense. He could not say whether it was written by Holmes, as it was typewritten when he received it. The typewriter, a pale faced, solemn Tisaged, spectacled young woman, who made tho copy, was in the courtroom and was ' next sworn. She gave hor name as Amy Long and acted as if she thought a fliro fate was about to overtake her at any moment, or that she had committed some awful orime in making a copy of the manuscript. A copy of the book was handed to her, and she was asked if she Lad typewritten it. She thought she had. I didn't read the book, " she said earnestly. Sho saiij the manuscript had been in pencil and didn't know if she could recognize the same writing again. Some writing was shown to her, and sho said it looked like the same writing. She had secured the Cfiiglnal manuscript from Shoemaker. Dr. Leffman came back to tell about deaths from chloroform. According to his own statement, ho has never seen a death produced by chloroform. He was called ac an expert by the prosecution. Mr. Rotan wanted to know from the witness if it were possible for a person to take chloroform without outside assist ance; tnac trie aerense wanted later on to show that Pitezel had committed sui cide. Chloroform, he thought, invariably pro duced inflammation of the membrane of the stomach. No inflammation was dis covered in wie stomach of Pitezel, though it . j j more tnan an ounce 01 cnioroiorm was found there. Mr. Rotan tried to pin the witness down to the statement that if the choloform had been taken half an hour before death it would not have produced Inflammation, but the witness wouldn't say that positively. Mr. Rotan did get from the witness, however, that chloroform might have been taken 15 minutes before death and not produce inflammation. Mr. Rotan got him to Bay also, and to Holmes it was worth more than all tho rest in his fa vor, that the difference between the in lamination caused by alcohol and chloro form could not bo determined with any certainty. The physicians had all testifiod that in flammation, supposed to have been caused by alcohol, was found in tho stomach o PitszeL . structive movements would have made a meanor, although a keen observer might Suicide Theory Advanced.
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · 2 November 1895
Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.
The fragment lists items connected to the boy Howard Pitezel, including his bones, the stove in which he was burned, the clothes he wore, and his toys.
Waterbury Democrat · 2 November 1895 · page 1
PROSECUTION'S WEAKNESS
bones of the boy, Howard Pitezel, tho gtove in which he was burned, the clothes the little fellow wore when he had a body to put inside of them and the toys ho
A damaged clipping lists names with donation amounts and mentions Detective Geyer's narrative of his travels searching for evidence of Holmes' movements, alongside a reference to District Attorney Graham.
Evening Journal · 2 November 1895 · page 4
FOR HOLMES' DEFENSE His Attorneys Depend on the Prosecution's Weakness. NO EVIDENCE WILL BE SUBMITTED.
''bailee K.Woods. Jc.sei.li K . Adams. Meadog. James Monaghan. William Mlehae, Byrue Rotiert G. Harman. V H. Bacon. tective Geyer, whose detailed narrative of ■ '. INI his travels over the continent In u sue 1.00 ccssfnl search for evidences of Holmes' de 1.00 " structive movements would have made a 5 IN) thrilling tain. District Attorney Graham •• . (.
The fragment states that travels across the continent searching for evidence of Holmes' destructive movements would have made a thrilling tale, and that District Attorney Graham fought hard to get this evidence admitted, but the law was against him.
Evening Journal · 2 November 1895 · page 4
NO EVIDENCE WILL BE SUBMITTED
his travels over the continent In u sue ccssfnl search for evidences of Holmes' de structive movements would have made a thrilling tain. District Attorney Graham fought as hard as lie knew how to get this evidence in, but the law was against him,
H. H. Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, initially dismissing his lawyers to conduct his own defense. After a strong cross-examination performance, the strain led him to recall his attorneys to resume his defense.
The Weekly Call · 2 November 1895 · page 2
The Insurance Swindler and Alleged Murderer's Case Begun at Philadelphia. PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 29. —H. H. Holmes, who is placed by the police authorities of many cities of this coun try at the head of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminer yesterday morning for the murder of Benjamin E. Pietzel, one of his partners in past crimes. Arraigned against him as the commonwealth prosecutors were Dis trict Attorney George S. Graham and his special assistant, Thomas W. Bar low. The counsel who appeared for the prisoner were William A.
See moreSee less
Shoe maker and Samuel P. Rotam, young members of the bar of this city, but just after the case was called both were forced to withdraw at Holmes’ request and he began conducting his own case. The second day’s proceedings com menced with the examination of wit nesses. Three sessions of court were held. On the cross examination Holmes displayed wonderful ability as a lawyer and held his own with the prosecution, but the strain was telling on him and he sent for his lawyers who will conduct his defense.
This damaged clipping mixes disjointed items: a navy yard worker's death by scalding, statistics on liquor license applications, a planned joint meeting of white and colored ministers, and a brief mention of a photographer and someone named Holmes in a dock.
Evening Star · 2 November 1895 · page 1
MR. GRAHAM ARGUES
curring among the navy yard workmen. Of women. The camera fiend was on hand. How he the enlisted force but one death occurred got in is a mystery, but there he was, up in which was suicidal. Among the navy yard the gallery, with his machine leveled on workmen one death occurred by scalding Holmes in the dock. by steam." With respect to the naval proving grounds Holmes' Acquittal Predicted. The Came Stated. that 580 applications for -retail liquor li The case is stated with some earnestness censes had been flied and 15 applications for wholesale had been receivdd.
See moreSee less
This is )y those familiar with the situation. It re muired a good deal of courage to repudiate a decrease of nine bar room applications ir.dorse them. A joint meeting of the white and colored ministers will be held Monday, and at that time the resolutions will be pre scr.ted to the white ministers for their action. The fact that the white ministers have heretofore manifested much iiterest
A packed Philadelphia courtroom awaited District Attorney Graham's closing argument in the Holmes murder trial, as defense co-counsel Rotan reported colleague Shoemaker had suffered nervous prostration, prompting Graham to waive his right to a second address.
Evening Star · 2 November 1895 · page 1
SHOEMAKER IS PROSTRATED PHILADELPHIA, November 2.-Seats in the criminal court were at a higher pre mium this morning than at any time since the Holmes trial began. The series of the atrical incidents which crowded upon one another all week culminated in yesterday's climax, where the defense resolved to go to the jury without evidence, relying on the supposed weakness of the commonwealth's case, had such an effect on the public that before 7 o'clock this morning there was a pushing, surging crowd in the corridors, waiting and hoping to gain entrance.
See moreSee less
Ev erybody understood that when the argument would begin, upon the assembling of court today, the opening address to the jury by District Attorney Graham would be the ef fort of his life. For the first time since the trial began last Mc.nday the gallery was opened to the public having the necessary credentials to pass the police lines, after the lower floor had been filled. Most of the spectators therein were women. The camera fiend was on hand. How he got in is a mystery, but there he was, up in the gallery, with his machine leveled on Holmes in the dock. Holmes' Acquittal Predicted. Contrary to all expectation, the consensus of opinion last night and this morning seemed to be that Holmes would be acquit ted. Nine out of every ten persons ques tioned on the subject, be they lawyers or laymen, agreed that he ought to hang "on general principles," enough crimes having been fastened upon him, but that the mur der of Pitezel had not been brought home to him beyond a reasonable doubt. Even bets were being freely made last night on his acquittal. When the jury filed into court a moment after 10 o'clock this morning they looked tired and unkempt, and there was a thin growth of beard on every cheek. There was a uniform expression in their twenty-four eyes-an expression telling of resignation to present misfortune and hope for the near future. At 10:15 o'clock Mr. Rotan, junior counsel for the defense, came into cturt and asked Judge Arnold for a few minutes' indulgence, -saying he had just received word from a neighboring drug store that his colleague. Mr. Shoemaker, was sick there, and he de sired to join him. Mr. Rotan himself showed the strain un der which he has labored. Dark rings en circled his eyes and his face was pale. He returned a half hour later and said he had found Mr. Shoemaker under the care of a physician, suffering from complete nervous prostration. He called this to the attention of the court, in view of a point of law re garding the commonwealth's right to make the closing address to the jury when the de fense presented no evidence. Mr. Graham, however, ended the question by offering to waive his right to the last speech, and there will be but one address on each side, instead of two by the prosecution. Col. William B. Mann, the venerable pro thonotary, whose eloquence. when district attorney years ago, sent many a felon to the gallows, came into court to listen to Mr. Graham's address. . District Attorney's Opening. This was begun at 10:55 o'clock. He open ed by referring to the relief with which the jury must contemplate the approaching end of the trial. "I am going to ask you," he continuei, "to give me your best attention and your best thought while I reason with you about the evidence, and then my young friend will do the same for the prisoner. "The commonwealth of Pennsylvania is the prosecution in this case and asks no victim. If you are satisfied when we have done that this prisoner did not commit this crime you must and ought to acquit him. "My task is to point out from the evidence the fact conclusively that this prisoner at the bar did t'his murder-so conclusively that there must be no doubt lurking in your mind -so that you, as conscientious jurors, shall find but one verdict-a verdict of murder in the first degree. The commonwealth is bound to prove its case from the initial step down to the last syllable of evidence. The commonwealth has done so. One by one we have established each link, making the chain complete and perfect." Reviewing the Evidence. The district attorney reviewed the evidence in detail. Beginning with the question of the identity of the corpse found in the Callowhill street house, he went over the testimony of each witness, who positively said it was that of Pitezel. Thence he proceeded to the ex plosion theory and the condition of the body, whfh, he contended, the medical testimony had incontrovertibly proved could not have been produced except by chloroform. - Thus, he said, the Jury reached the first step in the case-that the man died of chlo roform poisoning. The next was that this chloroform was not self-administered, and this, too, was proved beyond a shadow of doubt by the expert testimony. Leading up to the motive for the murder, Mr. Graham declared that the common wealth of Pennsylvania was the prosecutor in this case and not the insurance com pany, which was merely the dupe. Mr. Graham rehearsed in minute detail Holmes' every transaction in connection with Pitezel's murder, tracing his move ments from place to place, and drawing out every little circumstance that weighed against the prisoner with infinite clearness and force, When he caste to the testimony of Mrs. Pitezel, he told the jury never in his offi cial experience had he heard such a tale as that told in the broken sentences of that despairing, hopeless woman-that will-o' the-wisp-whom he kept flying from place to place in the vain hope of meeting her husband. And all the while he was carry ing with him three separate detachments, Mrs. Pitezel, Hiss Yoke and the children all within four blocks of each other, almost traveling together, under Holmes' leading strings, and yet each party ignorant of the presertce of the other two. "What marvelous ingenuity, what craft, what cunnmng," cried the dastrict attorney. "Why did he resort to all this duplicity2 Wi y did he adopt so many subterfuges, and why did lie tell these many storie0? It was because he had murdered Benjamin F. Filtezel." Mr. Gs'ahatn declared that there was nof one word of evidence to show that Pitezel lhad committed or even contemp:ated sut c'de. By the statements of Holmes him, self, made more than once, the speaker de clared5 his presence in that house on the day of the murder had been fixed. From IC; o'clock on that Saturday morning to 4 in th" afternoon he was in the Callowhill street house. This was fixed by his own statements, and hit questions to Miss Yoke on the witness stand, leading her on to say that he was hot fiushel and excited when he returned home that afternoon. in conctusion Mr. Graham said he desir ed the jury to consider only the evidence connected with the murder of Pitesel in the Cailowhill street house, -and niothing else. He paid a glowing tribute to Detec tive Geyer for his work In unfolding the story.. "This strangre trial is drawring rapinly to -The Finai Appeai.
A collection of brief, witty newspaper items touches on Holmes and Durrant, Senator Hill's claim of being a democrat, a possible Tammany defeat, an unsafe Washington printing office, scarce peanuts, and Tammany bosses, ending in an incomplete fragment.
Evening Star · 2 November 1895 · page 4
Holmes and Durrant are starting at op posite ends of the country, but there is no telling where they may meet, Senator Hill is now waiting to see how much companionship he has in his cele brated sentiment, "I am a democrat" There will be a lange number of people to join in the "we did It" chorus If Tammany is defeated In this election. A season of exceptional wire-pulling and leg-pulling is approaching its close. The Government's Discredit, From te Baltlmore American. It is a discredit to the governmerit that the prInting office in Washingfon should be allowed to continue it such an unsafe conditIon.
See moreSee less
There Is always a possibility of another catastrophe such as that which threw Washington into mournIng only a few years ago. The Incoming C'ongress should deal with the matter promptly. Presto, Chasgel Fran lhe Philadelpial Inqirer. Peanuts are said to be very scarce. It must be that they have all turned intt politicians. Bosses and Bessed. From the Newe York Wet-d. The Tammany bosses got it and got away with it. What liave the Tammany bosserd
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's lawyers decided not to introduce any testimony on his behalf, and that the case was to be given to the jury the following day.
New-York Tribune · 2 November 1895 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING.
The lawyers for H. H. Holmes decided not to introduce any testimony in behalf of thelr client; the case is to be given to the jury to-day, ——=—=
The clipping reports that the prisoner's counsel offered no evidence and rested on the jury's mercy amid weak circumstantial evidence, while separately noting a Washington dispatch contrasting a large deficit under the current tariff act with a surplus under the McKinley tariff law over similar periods.
New-York Tribune · 2 November 1895 · page 6
"dertook his own defence, so at the close there was another surprise, Holmes's counsel declaring that they would offer no evidence in his behalf, but were ready for the summing up. The trial has been devoid of those sensational features “which were looked for on account of the long series of ghastly crimes laid to the prisoner's charge. No direct evidence that Holmes mur dered Pletzel has been produced, and it is not cortain that the circumstantial evidence is strong enough to secure his conviction, The defence, nt all events, has assumed that it is not, and the prisoner has virtually thrown himself on the merey, not of the court, but of the jury.
See moreSee less
It is Can extraordinary case mm varions respects. | — National issues are cutting no large figure in the campaign in this State, but this is hy no means true of all the States—of Ohio, for example. Nevertheless, special Interest attaches just now to the workings of the new tariff law, which has been in operation for a year and two months. In a special dispatch from Washington this morning a comparison is drawn between the results for that period and the first four teen months of the McKinley tariff Taw, which is extremely Instrnctive and saggestive, Under the Wilson act there has been a deficit for every month save two, when an appearance of a surplus was artificially created, and the total deficit is more than £70,000,000, In the same length of time the McKinley act produced a surplus of $28,000,000, These figures carry their own Ceomment, | | | |
The report describes how Holmes's attorneys rested without offering a defense after the commonwealth's case, noting the weak circumstantial evidence, the ruling out of testimony about the children's murders, and a failed attempt to argue the victim's death was suicide.
The Morning News · 2 November 1895 · page 1
throw himself upon the mercy of the jury. When the commonwealth closed Its case this afternoon, his attorneys announced that they considered the prosecution had not made out It* charge of mulller and they would rest their case upon the evi dence offered by the commonwealth and submit no testimony in defense of th* prisoner. Tills decision was made by Holmes upon the advice of a well known lawyer who was at ona time retained by the prisoner. The move seemed like a bold one, but was unquestionably done more In desperation in the hope of In fluencing the Jury and creating the Im pression In their minds that, being con scious of his Innocence and not having had time to prepare a proper defense.
See moreSee less
Holmes trusted himself to their sense of Justice. In reality Holmes has no defense. and his black record would tell terribly against him, even If he were able to offer something like substantial proof that he did not kill Pitezel. The commonwealth presented no direct proof that Holme* murdered Pitezel. Their chain of cir cumstantial evidence, even, was not as strong as was expected, and but for th* admissions at various times of Holmes himself the district attorney would hava had a most difficult task In proving ths charge. That the commonwealth hesi tated to arraign Holmes for murder hero until the discovery of the bodies of the Pitezel children, it well known. When the bodies of these children were found th* district attorney was then absolutely con vinced that Holmes killed I’itezel and that the murders of the children were the di rect outcome of the first assassination. When, the remains of ihe three children wer unearthed and Holmes muiio his ad mission that he had been alone in th* house with the cleud body of Pitezel, Air. Graham was satisfied of the strength of his case and brought the accused man t trial. sensational in the extreme, but after Judge Arnold ruled out all the evidence bearing upon the murder of the children, the most ghastly features of Holmes’ se ries of crimes were eliminated. Instead of furnishing any sensation, the trial Itself has been as dull and unlterestlng to th* spectators In the court room as the ma jority of ordinary murder caseß are. Hut two incidents out of the ordinary have broken the monotony of the proceedings. These were tile appearance upon the wit ness stand of Mrs. Ptetzel and her pathetlo tale of her Journey with Holmes, and the testifying against the prisoner of the girl that he deceived into believing that she was Ills legal wife. to the stand to-day. The do. fense this morning had derided that they would attempt to prove that Pitezel committed suicide, anil was not murdered. Expert testimony bearing upon this theory Introduced by Mr. Gra ham must have shown the attorneys for Holmes that the defense they had out lined would require greater resources to maintain than they had at their com mand. They further made two blunder* to-day. Mrs. Pitezel was recalled to th* stand to Identify some articles of cloth ing belonging to hor husband, and under cross examination, the defense attempted to show that she was perfectly cognizant of the scheme to swindle the insurance company, and that in the Journey sh* took with Holmea she was trying to avOld arrest for her share in it, and was not seeking her children and husband. Mr. Graham resented this form of examina tion indignantly, and accused the defens* of attempting to add to the woman’s al ready heavy burden of grief. He showed by the witness’ statements that although arrested for conspiracy no Indictment wus ever brought against her, and that she was discharged because there was no evidence showing that she had any direct connection with the swindle. Th* questions of the attorney for the de fense brought tears to the eyea of th* broken woman upon the stand, and her appearance excited the sympathy of all In the court. When she was removed from the stand and led Into the corridor she was attacked by a nervous fit, and her screams rang through the room. endeavoring to elicit from Miss Yoke the opinion that she still believed herself to be the legal wife of Holmes. When Mr. Graham saw the drift of the question* being asked he had the witness tell th* entire story of how Holmes had deceived her In the marriage, and the lies and de ception he practiced upon her. During this recital Holmes became confused and hung his head in a shamefaced manner. Graham announced that the prosecution had closed its case. ...... lawyers, and when they came Into court Mr Itotan boldly asked Judge Arnold to either discharge the prisoner, on the ground that the commonwealth had not made out a case against him, or else charge the Jury to acquit him. This Judge Arnold refused to do. Then they asked for a continuance for at least three or four hours, in which to prepare their evi dence. Judge Arnold refused to grant them this much time, but gave them half an hour. They retired with the prisoner, and upon their return Mr. Rotan an nounced that they would rest their cans upon the evidence of the commonwealth, lie said they were satisfied that the prosecution had sot proven the charge of murder, and they were willing to go to the Jury without calling any witnesses. It was then arranged that the closing ar gument and the charge of the Judge will probably consume the better part of to morrow, but the case will, In all likeli hood, be given to the Jury to-morrow af ternoon. Philadelphia, Nov. I.—Holmes to-daY Not a witness has appeared for him, It was expected that the case would b* Hut nine witnesses were called The defense’s second blunder was It* Just before the recess was taken, Mr. During the recess Holmes consulted his
The Silver Blade · Rathdrum, Idaho · and 1 other paper
After briefly dismissing his lawyers and trying his own defense, Holmes reinstated counsel Shoemaker & Rotan as the court began taking testimony, with the prisoner making several requests, including an analysis of a liquid and exclusion of witnesses during testimony.
The Silver Blade · 2 November 1895 · page 2
IN A TIGHT PLACE
Philadelphia, Oct. 29.—It became ap parent tonight that the picturesque and startling features of H. H. Holmes' career were not to be confined to his de structive wanderings over the Amer ican continent, for with each successive day comes something still more strange and unexpected. Yesterday he dismiss ed his counsel and began to try his own case, because the court refused to grant the plea made by them for a continu ance. Tonight, after fighting single-handed against the tremendous machinery of the commonwealth and apparently overwhelming evidence which has been forged around him, he threw up his hands and sent for his lawyers, Shoe maker & Rotan.
See moreSee less
Then he told the court what he had done and consented to their continuing with the defense. The important work of the trial—the taking of testimony—was begun this morning and with the exception of brief intermissions at lunch and supper time, was continued until nearly 9 o'clock tonight. The star witnesses of the trial—Mrs. Pietzel, Detective Geyer, Agent Perry of the swindled insurance company and the arch-criminal himself—remain to be heard, as well as tw r o others. The announcement that the taking of evi dence would begin today drew a still larger crowd to the city hall, but the admirable police arrangements kept ev erybody out except attorneys and those interested in the case. Holmes, in custody of a court officer, was placed in the dock. The day's pro ceedings were begun by District Attor ney Graham, who arose and said: "I desire to say to the court, in view of what was said last night before the adjournment of court, that the lady known as Miss Yorke and Mrs. Howard, was sent for, saw the prisoner and had ample opportunity for an interview with him." When Mr. Graham concluded, Holmes said that he had only had a three minute interview with the woman, and asked that it be renewed during the noon recess. His request was granted. Then the prisoner asked that a plan be produced of the Callow Hill street house where he is believed to have murdered Pietzel. The district attorney said such a plan was in court and would be produced at the proper time. "I also ask," Holmes continued, "that a quantity of liquor which Mr. Graham said I used in my efforts to exterminate the Pietzel family be submitted to an alysis. I want to prove that while it contains but a small quantity of nitro glycerine, it is entirely harmless, and is sold in every drug store." "Do you mean the liquor you left with Mrs. Pietzel in Burlington, Vt.?" "Yes." "That has never been in my posses sion." Then came another request from the prisoner. He wanted to know if during the testimony of one witness, all the other witnesses should not be excluded from the room. Judge Arnold answered that this would be done if the exigency arose.
The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · 2 November 1895
The Silver Blade · Rathdrum, Idaho · and 1 other paper
The clipping, a brief fragment, describes Holmes being brought into the dock in custody of a court officer as District Attorney Graham rose to speak, but his remarks are cut off.
The Silver Blade · 2 November 1895 · page 2
THE TAKING OF TESTIMONY
Holmes, in custody of a court officer, was placed in the dock. The day's pro ceedings were begun by District Attor ney Graham, who arose and said: "I
The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · 2 November 1895
The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · and 1 other paper
This single-item clipping describes testimony identifying Pietzel's photographs and exhumed body, Holmes's offer to have it cremated, and a witness's unshaken cross-examination.
The Kootenai Herald · 2 November 1895 · page 6
would be done if the exigency arose. Jeanette Pietzel, "Dessa," the daughI ter of tho dead man, was the first wit ness called. She was called to Identify several large crayons of her father, which she did. John Townsend, a photographer era ployed In the detective service, and William II. Ran, a private photograph er, then identified the photographs of Holmes taken by them after his arrest. Eugene Smith, who found Pletzel's body in the Callow Hill street house on September 4, 1894. then told a detailed story of his discovery, which has been already fully published.
See moreSee less
The witness was present when the corpse of Pietzel was exhumed from the potter's field and was there first Introduced to Holmes. Lawyer Howe of St. Louis. Alice Piet zed, the young daughter and the Insur ance officers were there. The body was recognized by the witness as PletzeTs. Holmes offered $30 to have the corpse cremated, and asked Howe about It. The lawyer answered that the widow would first have to be consulted. Holmes told the insurance people of the marks of Identification, and after the body had been dug up he pulled out a lance and cut a wart and other marks from the corpse. At this time the witness had recognized Holmes as the man he had seen go up stairs in the Callow Hill street house. Holmes, on cross-examination, asked a number of Immaterial questions, but showed much legal skill in their structlon. Holmes subjected Smith to a long and searching cross-examina tion, dwelling upon every point of the testimony adduced by the wealth, hut the witness was unshaken. WITNESSES CALLED. WITNESSES KEPT OUT. 1 ! 1 | con common
The Silver Blade · Rathdrum, Idaho · 2 November 1895
The Citizen · Chicago, Ill.
In Philadelphia, Judge Arnold opened the murder trial of H. H. Holmes, whose real name Mudgett confused the crowded courtroom, with proceedings delayed fifteen minutes by the defense counsel's absence.
The Citizen · 2 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES IS ON TRIAL. Faces a Jary at Philadelphia to Answei for Murder. Philadelphia, Oct. 30.—The clocks ol the town had scarcely erased striking 1C when Judge Arnold, clad in the long Mack gown which was recently adopted by the Philadelphia judiciary, entered and took his seat upon »he bench to try H. H. Holmes for mlarder. The prisoner’s real name, Mudgett, has Men so little used in the newspapers that when it was read out in court the audience which packed the room had to think a moment beiforo it was assured that tSie trial it had coane to 1 hear was coming off.
See moreSee less
District Attorney 1 Graham and his special assistant, 'Phomas W. Barlow, in whom the prosecution is vested, were already in court, but a delay of fifteen minutes was occasioned by the non appearance of counsel for the defense,
This fragment lists headlines—evidence in the Holmes case, a guilty verdict for Durrant, a fight location dispute, support for a Mid-Continent exposition, and trouble among letter carriers—with page references but no further detail.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 2 November 1895 · page 1
Evidence In In Holmes Case. Durrant Found Guilty. . Paara Will FIR-ht Elsewhere. Mid-Continent Expo Favored, Letter Carriers in Trouble. . PAGE .1. PAGE 2. ■
This fragment briefly mentions Holmes having numerous aliases, Fitzsimmons skillfully avoiding an issue like a politician, and suggests it is time for the governor of Louisiana to make a declaration.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 2 November 1895 · page 1
Holmes and his intimates had aliases enough to fill a directory. Mr. Fitzsimmons avoids an issue Mr. Fitzsimmons avoids an issue with the adroitness of a politician. This appears to be the hour for the governor of Louisiana to declare ■■>
Mrs. Pietzel testified about destroyed shirt cuffs and faced cross-examination about her travels with Holmes, after which an insurance agent described meeting a woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes holding Holmes' child.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 2 November 1895 · page 1
PRAYED IN VAIN FOR TIME.
MRS. PIETZEL REAPPEARS. Today's session was begun by the recalling of Mrs. Pietzel. Mr. Graham asked her if there were any cuffs to the shirts she yesterday identified as her husband's, and she replied that Holmes had -taken them from the trunk and destroyed them. This was the only question. On cross-examination Mr. Shoemaker rigidly questioned the unfortunate woman concerning her travels with ' Holmes and her subse quent arrest for conspiracy. His apparent intention was to show that Mrs. Pietzel had been the controlling Influ ence during the ramblings throughout the country and that she carried Holmes about In an attempt to evade arrest.
See moreSee less
"You want to prove that she was not Trilby, but Svengali," suggested Judge Arnold; "that she led him."' ; This remark was drawn out by a i dispute over the relevancy of the cross j examination, which was not pushed further. ''y'JEdward H. Cass, Chicago agent for the insurance company which Holmes defrauded, testified that he had visited Holmes in. Willamette, 111. 'He did not see Holmes, but Siet a woman calling herself Mrs. V. Holmesl :. He ldenitlfl-f her picture, in which she is shown holding an infant, Holmes' child, lovI ingly against her face. * j John King, |of New York, who said
This damaged clipping mentions a 9-year-old named Theodore Hammons, a large corn crop, the trial of H. H. Holmes described as a notorious insurance murderer, and Nick Schlosser's purchase of property for $750, but the text is too garbled to form a coherent narrative.
The News Boy · 2 November 1895 · page 1
NEWS IN GENERAL.
. Theodore Hammons, a 9-year-old 1 he corn crop is so big that hands t.u,i.Uv 6U..v6uU,u1N lhe trial of H. H. Holmes, the Nick Schlosser bought the Dannennotorious insurance, murderer, com- 'mueller property in the north end of mi-iiii-M i, x iiuaw:ipiiici, m.. i-ioiitown. Consideration $750,
The article reports that H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgett, is to go on trial for his life for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, with witnesses gathered from several cities and remains of Pietzel and a boy expected to be exhibited in court.
The Washburn Leader · 2 November 1895 · page 2
PIETZEL'i? MURDER. Holmes Will he Placed on Trial fof HI* Life ,To-l»ay. Philadelphia. Oct. 20. H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudgett, whoso name or alias has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modem times, will be placed on trial for liis life to-morrow morning in the *ourt of oyer and ter miner of this city. The specific charge to which he will be called upon to an swer Is the murder of Benjamin F. Peitzel, and lie lias already officially himself not guilty.
See moreSee less
The re declared volting details of the many crimes witii which Holmes' name has been directly or indirectly connected havo been given such publicity, and the cold, implacable demeanor which has characterized the man throughout, has been so frequently commented upon that the trial will probably pass into history af» tlio most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of the Western Hemisphere. The common wealth has already expended thou sands of dollars in its effort to bring the prisoner to summary justice, and there is an indication that a convic tion for murder in the first degree will lie obtained, and if so, lie will proba bly bo "railroaded" to the gallows. Witnesses have been brought to this city from Boston. Chicago, In dianapolis, Irvington. Ind., and al most every city where Holmes Js known to have lived at various times. What revelations these witnesses will make has been kept a profound se cret by the prosecuting officers, but there Is expectation of sensational de velopments. Detective Geyer, wflio has been for months traveling extensive ly throughout the country In search of evidence of Holmes' movements, will be one of the principal witnesses for the commonwealth. The skull and portions of the body of Pletzel, as well as the remains of the boy, Howard Pletzel, who Is thought to have been murdered by Holmes in Indianapolis, will be exhibited during the course of the trial. The murder of Pietzel, if murder it was, occurred more than a year ago. The body, burned and blackened as if by an explosion, was discovered in the house. No. 1326 Callow Hill street, this city, on Sept. 3,1894. As he had been known as an inventor named Perry, the supposition was that he had met death by accident while experi menting. Subsequently the charge was made that Pietzel had been murdered by Holmes, an attempt having been made to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Association of Philadelphia out of .$10,000 which had been paid by the .company to Mrs. Pietzel, who was supposed to have been a party to the conspiracy, Holmes having first intro duced Pletzel to the company! He was arrested in Boston on Nov. ^7. and Mrs. Pietzel Is In custody as, prob ably, the principal witness against him. There is a likelihood of the case consuming several weeks' time unless unforeseen circumstances arise to bring it to a speedy conclusion. Insuring' Consumptives. Cincinnati. Oct. 2t.—Special.—Reports say that a leading life insurance com pany is accepting risks to the amount of $300,000 on lives of consumptives taking the Amick Chemical Treatment for lung disease. The Amick Chemical Co. of Cincinnati is actually paying the premiums on this insurance and presenting policies to their patients. This company claims to have the most complete statistics on consumption in the world, and that these risks are good, providing the patients take a course of the Amick treatment.
H. H. Holmes (Herman W. Mudgett) went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, while in Owensboro, Ky., John Snyder cut his wife's throat in a jealous rage and was shot by Will Hall, his brother-in-law.
The Bottineau Courant · 2 November 1895 · page 6
H. H. Holmes, or Herman W. Mud gett, was put on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel in that city on September 2,1894. At Owensboro, Ky., John Snyder (col ored) suddenly became crazed with jealousy and cut his wife's throat. He was then shot by Will Hall, his brothor iii-law.
H. H. Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, but his attorney W. H. Shoemaker asked the court for a 60-day postponement, saying the defense was unprepared.
The Bottineau Courant · 2 November 1895 · page 6
Philadelphia, Oct. 29.—Herman W. Mudgett, better knowti as H. H. Holmes, the self-confessed life insurance swin dler, and the alleged multi-murderer, whose supposed crimes have been a topic for general discussion the past several months, was placed on trial Monday morning in the court of oyer and terminer on the charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pitzel. Judge Arnold presided. The com monwealth was represented by Dis trict Attorney George S. Graham and Assistant District Attorney Thomas W. Barlow, and the defense was conducted by W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P.
See moreSee less
Hoi an. After the formalities in conneition with the opening of court had been oncluded, Attorney W. H. Shoemaker, of counsel for the prisoner, in an ad dress of some length, asked for a post ponement of the base for 60 days. Mr. Shoemaker's contention was that the defense was not prepared for trial
After the judge denied postponement motions, Holmes's attorneys withdrew and he rejected newly appointed counsel, conducting his own defense as jury selection concluded and the district attorney delivered a lengthy opening address.
The Bottineau Courant · 2 November 1895 · page 6
H. H. HOLMES
that no witnesses were present. Dis trict Attorney Graham strenuously op posed the motion, he declaring that the state's wi\nesses were present at th^ir own volition, and that if a continuance should be granted it would mean "the absolute destruction of the common wealth's case." Mrs. Pitzel's health was impaired, Mr. Graham further said, and if the case should be postponed the strain would intensify her illness. Lawyer Samuel P. Kolan for the de fense also pleaded for time in which ho and his colleague could realize on Holmes' assets, and thus bring wit nesses to Philadelphia who will not rome unless their expenses nre paid.
See moreSee less
Judge Arnold overruled the motions for postponement in a very few words and ordered the trial to go on. Just at this juncture a startling climax was reached, which resulted in the with drawal of Lawyers Shoemaker and Ko lan from the case, notwithstanding as injunction from the court that they would be open to disbarment by taking 6uch a step "on the eve of a murder trial." Still further sensation was created when Holmes refused to accept th& services of Attorneys Everett A. Scho fleld and Joseph 1{. Fahey, whom the court was about to appoint to defend him, and who, in fact, had taken seats in the chairs vacated by Messrs. Shoe maker and Rolan. Schofield and Fa hey also withdrew. Holmes himself pleaded to the court fora j»ost poneinent, but the judge declared that the case must go on. The trial was resumed. Holmes conducting his own defense. Holmes continued questioning the jurors as they came up. His words, which embraced the usual technical questions,were well chosen. He listened to District Attorney Graham's formal inquiries with the keenest interest, an almost imperceptible flush relieving the pallor of his cheek. Besides the usual questions as to whether or not the jurors had formed any opinion as to the guilt or Innocence of the prisoner and the en tertainment of conscientious scruples against capital punishment, Holmes also asked: Have you visitod tho dime museum at Ninth and Arch streets?" The reason for this question was the fact that there has been on exhibition in the museum for some weeks a wax counterpart of Holmes, "the multi murderer," as he is there called, to gether with models of the Irvington (Ind.) house and the Chicago "castle." All who had seen these'were peremp torily challenged by Holmes. The work of securing a jury was com pleted at 1:45 o'clock and then a recess was taken until three o'clock. It was 3:10 o'clock when the trial was impined, and nearly all of the session, which continued until 4:55 o'clock, was taken up by District Attorney Graham in outlining the case to the jury. The opening address of the district attorney was forcible throughout, but his de nunciations of Holmes, which at times were particularly severe, had no out ward effect upon the accused. Holmes' composure was wonderful, and during the narrative he busied himself in tak ing copious notes of the prosecuting of ficer's address i When the district attorney had con cluded his argument Holm« requested that he be allowed light apd \Vriting materials in his cell in the county prison* Wilkesbarre, Pa.*, Oct. 25.—George A. Luce and John Gay, of Auburn, Pa., while attempting to cross the Lehigh Valley railroad tracks at Black Walnut, near Trunkhannock, Thursday after noon in a wagon were struck by a west bound freight train. Luce and his horse were instantly filled and Gay was fatally injured. President Kipram Sympathy. Washington, Oct. 29.—Secretary Olney h«n cabled -Vmbassador Eustis convey ing to him an, expression of condolence on behalf of President Cleveland and himself upon the death of Mrs. Eustis. H. H. HOLMES. Struck by Train.
This badly garbled clipping, mixed with an unrelated advertisement about blood and digestion, briefly references dramatic developments in the Holmes case since its trial began on Monday, but is too damaged to make out further details.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 2 November 1895 · page 3
THE STATE RESTS
O TETALAS o/ B B sk A ‘ £ T A F R | PRGSO Fieeitpae 3'2:"*‘:’ 00 Blood is made by your digestive 01gans, by the dramatic unfolding of the plot in Holmes case since it was called for trial on Monday, that today's developments
Miss Yoke was recalled for re-cross-examination about her marriage with Holmes, testified briefly, then was overcome and led from the courtroom before a recess was taken.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 2 November 1895 · page 3
THE SPECTATORS DISAPPOINTED.
district attorney. The defense here asked to recall/ Miss Yoke for re-cross-examination on the question of her marriage with Holmes, which was not brought out in her exam ination. She was brought into court and given a seat on the witness stand, where she told of her marriage. Miss Yoke, at the conclusion of her testimony, retired to the crier's desk and laid her bead in her hands on the back of a chair Then she was led from the court room. Her presence did not move Holmes today. Court at 1 o’clock took an hour's recess. Good Thing For Savannah.
The clipping reports that a judge's ruling restricted evidence to only the death of Benjamin F. Pietzel, excluding testimony and exhibits about the children's deaths, after which the commonwealth recalled Mrs. Pietzel, heard testimony from an insurance agent, and rested its case.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 2 November 1895 · page 3
THE SPECTATORS DISAPPOINTED.
by the dramatic unfolding of the plot in Holmes case since it was called for trial on Monday, that today's developments would be even more sensational than those of its earlier chapters, there was a large crowd seeking admission to the courtroom this forenoon. The common: wealth has promised to close its case to day, and, in all probability the prisoner will be the flrst and, perhaps, the only witness for the defonse. There is a pretty general belief that if he goes on the stand he will do more to hang himself than all the evidence of the commonwealth.
See moreSee less
Judge Arnold’s decision last night that no evidenee bearing on the murders of the children or anything but the death of Benjamin F. Pietzel shall be introduced was a disappointment to the common wealth. . It will keep out the thrilling story of Detective Geyor’s soarch and discovery of the children’s bodies. It will also prevent the introduction in evidence and the exhi bition in open court of the bones of the boy, Howard Pietzel; the stove in which he was burned; the toys and clothing which the mother identified, and the trunk in which Alice and Nellie were smothered. Nearly 30 witnesses gathered from distant eities by the prosecution cannot now give their testimony. This has brought about the sudden closing of the commonwealth's case, Today’s session was begun by the re calling of Mrs. Pietzel. Mr. Graham asked her if there were any cuffs to the shirt she yesterday identified as her husband’s, ~nd she answered that Holmes had t+ =0 them from the trunk and destroyed t. : This was the only question. On cross-examination IMr. Shoemaker rigidly questioned the unfortunate woman concerning her travels with Holmes and her subsequent arrest for conspiracy. His apparent intention was to show how Mrs. Pietzel had been the controlling infla ence during the rambles throughout the country, and that she carried Holnzes about in an attempt to evade arrest. ‘“You want to prove that she was not Trilby but Svengali,” suggested Judge Arnold. “That she led him.” This remark was drawn out by a dis pute over the relevancy of the cross-oxam ination, which was not pushed further. Edward H. Cass, Chicago agent for the insurance company which Holmes de frauded, testified that he had visited Holmes’ house in Willamette, Ills. Ho did not see Holmes, but met a woman calling herself Mrs. Holmes. He identi fled her picture, in which she is shown as holding an infant, Holmes’ child, lovingly against her face. The commonwealth offered in evidence the letters and papers, pictures and the Holimnes book, and rested its case. This was another blow to the morbidly in clined, who, cheated of a view of the bones of the murdered boy and the other ghastly accessories of the story, had counted on sceing at least the skull of the murdered Pitezel, which is in the custody of the district attorney.
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's trial for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel continued with the prisoner conducting his own defense, and notes the Pennsylvania Railroad ratified a traffic agreement.
Passaic City Record · 2 November 1895 · page 5
the trial was continued of H. H. Holmes for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, the prisoner conducting his own defense.-The Pennsyl vania Railroad ratified the traffic agreement
After two jurors withdrew and Holmes's plea for postponement was denied, the trial continued with Holmes himself questioning prospective jurors while District Attorney Graham posed formal inquiries.
Perrysburg Journal · 2 November 1895 · page 3
in the chairs vacated by Messrs. Shoe maker and Bolan. Schoticld and Fa hey also withdrew. Holmes himself pleaded to thecourtfora postponement, but tho judge declnred that the case must go on. The trinl was resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense. Holmes continued questioning the jurors os they came tip. His words, which embraced the usual technical questions, were well chosen. He listened to District Attorney Grnhnm's formal inquiries with tho keenest interest, nn almost imperceptible Jiush relieving the pallor of his cheek. Besides the usual qucstlonsas to whether or not the jurors qucstionsustowhothe ion ns to the guilt
The garbled fragment notes that H. H. Holmes took his seat calmly and showed little interest in the proceedings, though the surrounding text is too damaged to make out fully.
Perrysburg Journal · 2 November 1895 · page 3
HIS OWN LAWYER
a dressy appearance. The accused took his scut with a calmness that was no interest In the matters nt issue there It. II. HOLMES. ticeable, and while he evinced a decided
Holmes refused court-appointed attorneys and chose to defend himself after his previous lawyers withdrew, prompting the judge to proceed with the trial. He questioned prospective jurors, including asking if they had seen his wax likeness at a dime museum, and a jury of twelve was seated before District Attorney Graham delivered a lengthy opening statement.
Perrysburg Journal · 2 November 1895 · page 3
HIS OWN LAWYER
' ln th. ,m,scul. fof f00 weeks a wax counterpart murderer," ns ho Is thero called, to gether with models of the Irvlngton of Holmes, "the multi
This fragmentary clipping refers to Holmes, called a multi-murderer now on trial in Philadelphia, as a gentleman and scholar, before cutting off as the court takes a recess.
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 2 November 1895 · page 1
of murderers, and Holmes, the multi murderer, who is now on trial in Phila delphia, is a gentleman and scholar. When the court took a recess until
A witness named Gerry testified that he had seen a woman at the prisoner's house in Wilmette, Ill., calling herself Mrs. H. H. Holmes, and that Holmes later asked him to mail a letter to his wife and mentioned depositing $1000 of insurance money for her, evidence the defense objected to but which was allowed.
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 2 November 1895 · page 1
prove by him that Holmes was much married, and that Miss Yoke was not his lawful wife, and is, therefore, incom petent to testify. Gerry said he had seen at the prison er's house in Wilmettee, III., a women representing herself as Mrs. H. H. Holmes. He identified the photograph of her. She was not Miss Yoke. Last December witness told Holmes, in prison, of his visit to Wilmette. Holmes said he wanted to write a letter to his wife and did so, asking witness to mail it. Holmes told witness he deposited $1000 of the insurance company's money with Mr.
See moreSee less
Blackman, of Chicago, his real es tate agent, so "Mrs. Holmes" could draw upon it. The defense entered a formal objection to all the evidence of Gerry concerning Miss Yoke, but it was overruled.
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes' murder trial for the killing of Benjamin F. Pietzel began in Philadelphia, detailing a defense request for continuance, Judge Arnold's refusal, and Holmes' statement expressing reluctance to continue with his current counsel.
The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 2 November 1895 · page 4
MURDERER HOLMES NOW
MtTBDEBEB HOLMES MOW. A' Bemarkable Trial Begins, the Jury Being Secured In Four Honrs. As the Durrant trial draws to a close that of H. H. Holmes begins in Phil adelphia. The selecting of a jury be gan yesterday, and as the proceedings are so decidedly unique we give them in full, as shown in the dispatches yes terday: '. "H. H. Holmes, who, according to his own remarkable confession, stands at the head of the list of modern crim inals, was put on trial in the court of oyer, and teru4uer this morning for the.
See moreSee less
murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel X he . common wealth prosecutors are District Attorney George S. Graham, and Special Assistant Thomas W. Barstow. . , William A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, young members of the bar appeared for Holmes. Judge Micha i Arnold is upon the bench. Only enough people were admitted to fill thecouitroom without uncomfortably crowding it. Witnesses from Canada and different parts of the country were escorted into court shortly before 10 o'clock by Detective Frank Gray, who travels throughout the United States in search for evidence against Holmes, which has been from time to time pub lished. Promptly - at 10 Holmes was placed in the dock. He was plainly nervous, and looked about the room with a shifting expression. Shoe maker asked for a continuance. He urged lack of time for preparation. ?There are three homicide cases In volved In this case," he urged "and we had only such time as would be ade quate preparation for one." It was expected to present newly discovered evidence of such vital importance that Holmes would undoubtedly be ac quitted of this charge. Graham pro tested against having a continuance. He dwelt upon the severe strain under which Mrs. Peltzel had been put and said an examination into her mental condition made it apparent that were a continuance granted, the common wealth would lose its most important witness. Rotan, of the defense, re Of newed his plea for a respite. It was overruled by Judge Arnold. Shoe maker and Rotan created, a mild sen sation by saying if the judge's decision were irrevocable they would withdraw. Judge-Ar nold spoiled this by declaring a member of the Dar who would with draw from a murder case on the very eve of its trial would be called upon to show cause why he should not be dis barred for unprofessional conduct. . "So far as the plea of lack of money is concerned," said Graham, "I have positive knowledge that large sums' of money L were offered within the last week, to. prominent attorneys at this bar to come into the case as associate counsel for the defense, showing there are funds at hand." "Will your honor allow the case to go. over till tomorrow . morning?'.' pleaded Rotan. ' ""Call' the jury," said the judge firmly. ' ' One juror had been admitted by the commonwealth when Holmes, in a quavering voice said to Judge Arnold: "May it please the court, I have no in clination to continue with the trial of this case. with. Mr. . Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker as my counsel, feeling that, in view, of their, desire to , withdraw, my, interests would . be damaged. therefore, discharge them as my coun seL" r ."You cannot discharge .them,. Mr, Holmes." said Judge Arnold; '.'that Is for the court, and If they withdraw from this case, they may be punished. , 'I," continued Holmes, in tremulous tones, "your honor will give ine until tomorrow to secure the additional counsel.".-". : "We will have no more debate, Mr. Holmes; the matter, is decided.'1 . The examination of the jurors was about to be proceeded with, when Shoe maker strted that the prisoner abso lutely forbade them from representing him in the case, and declared he would examine the jurors and witnesses him self. . Judge Arnold said he would permit Holmes, to question the jurors, if he so desired. Enoch Turner, the first juror, was turned over to Holmes for examination. He had already stated he had formed an opinion in the case, but could nevertheless try it according to the evidence. Holmes challenged him preemptorily," Frederick Slump, sr., was accepted by both Graham and Holmes. .Rotan and Shoemaker arose, and declared they felt obliged to with draw from the ease," regardless of con sequences. . "You must take the consequences, then," said the judge, and they left the courtroom.. - The commonwealth's officers, con sulted with the judge and then called upon Everett A. Scbofield and J. M. Fahay, young lawyers, who agreed to assume the "grave responsibility, with all aid possible . from Mr. Graham. Holmes objected on the ground as he knew nothing of these gentlemen he should not care to entrust bis life to them. "So far as aid from Graham is concerned," he Added, with unveiled bitterness, nI had abundant proof last year what promised aid from the dis trict attorney's office means. .May. I be allowed a postpohemenXtnT'tomor row tosee R.,O..Moon, who Is already familiar .with the case, and whom I know I can engage?" "Do you, then," refuse to allow these gentlemen to defend you?' V I do, sir; if 1 am not allowed a con tinuance until tomorrow I must ask to try the case myself." - We will go bn" today," said the udge, "and we will see about engag ing Moon later on." ' ' The examination of jurors was then resumed.: At 1:45 p. if. 12 jurors had been selected. The court took recess until 3 P. M. Lawyer Moon, declined to participate in the case unless a con tinuance was granted," and as Judge Arnold refused this, Holmes will have to act as his own lawyer.
This fragmentary clipping mixes reports of drought-stunted wheat and halted plowing, a factory fire brought under control, a sick-ridden town of Yorktown with closed schools, prairie fires near Perry, Ok., and Holmes cross-examining a witness named Jeannette Pietzel about her dead father.
Narragansett Herald · 2 November 1895 · page 1
MAN OF IRON NERVE
the crop and the great over-produetion of task. In less than one hour from the start corn, an immensely inereased acreage of the fire was under coatrol and at 9.30 was winter wheat was planted, and muech of it practically ont. has not come up at all. Other wooden buildings were close on every On the highlands particularly the ground hand, and only the hardest and oniv the is entirely dried out, owing to the continued hardest and mos: skillful work saved them. absence of rain, and plowing, as a conse The passenger shop and old foundry were quence, has been entirely stopped.
See moreSee less
both considerably damagzed by fire and water. When Holmes seated himself, the first wit Yoritown, Ind, Of a povulagion of 300 fifty four are or were sick. Eighteen deatns have pess was called in the person of Jeannette oceurred. The pubilic schools have been Pietzel, cne of the children of the dead man. cloBed for six weeks and littie or no business and who escaped the fate of the larger part of the family. Holmes cross examined her a is being transacted. few moments as to wuether there hadn’t Fierce prairie fires ragzed 30 miles from been a change in the appearanee of her father Perry, Ok., aiong the Arkansas river. Maay
East Providence Eagle · East Providence, R.I. · and 1 other paper
This single item covers trial testimony from carpenter Eugene Smith, who found the body, and Dr. Mattern, whose inquest notes Holmes copied and used to cross-examine on chloroform poisoning, before Holmes's withdrawn lawyers resumed the case.
East Providence Eagle · 2 November 1895 · page 3
H. H. HOLMES, Now being tried for many murders.
Eugene Smith, carpeater, the man who found the body of Pietzel. He told how he had gone to the house once, and had seen Perry’s (be knew Pietzel by that name) hat and cuffs in the ball but did not see Perry. He waited awhile and went away. He returned to the house on the following morning. The hat and cuffs were in the same position. No furciture was disarranged on either occasion Smith discovered the body of P.etzel, and as Smith told of it there came a point where an objeetion would be of great value to the de fence.
See moreSee less
Holmes listened for a moment, arose and made the objection. Judge Arnoid promptly sustained the objection. Smith, who did not make a good witness at all, said he had found Perry in the back room, the feet toward the windows, which were open. Smith, when asked whose body it was he rad found, said it was that of Henry B. Pietzel, How he knew that he didn’t explain, and the man who thinks he is smart enough to .conduet his own defence didn’t realize that another point had been reached where he should have made an objection, and a vigorous one, for the answer, which &* best was only a eonclusion on the part of the wit ness, should have been stricken from the records, and would have been bad Holmes had a lawyer representing him. Holmes be gan to cross-examine Smith, who, properly handled, would have gone all to pieces ina short time. stand and Holmes put him through a eciose examination as to the condition of the body and probable cause of death. In this Holmes' knowledge of medicine helped him materialiy but he brought out nothing to help his case. The witness expressed the opinion that at the time he saw the body, Pietzel had been dead about three days, which is the period the commonwealth alleges elapsed between the day Pietzel was killed and the day his body was found. Mattern. The doector was asked tha eolor of Pietzel’s moustache and hair and replied that the former was reddish and the latter dark brown. At the request of Holmes the court directed Dr. Mattern to read the notes he took of the deseription of the body at the time he held his inquest. As Dr. Mattern read his notes, Holmes copied them all down. Holmes subjected the witness to a long te: hnical examination upon the con dition of the stomach and brain would be in after chloroform poisoning and excess in aleoholie liquors. Dr. Mattern would not say from the coundition the body was in whether the chloform in the stomach had been injected hypodermically, or whether it had been forced down the throat. court reconvened, Holmes stated that, owing to the criticism leveled at his counsel for withdrawing, he had asked them to resume charge of the case. In a moment Messrs. Shoemaker and Rolan, the two lawyers who withdrew from the case, came into the court, and the former made an explanation to Judge Arnold, and he permitted them to take up the case again. The next witnesswas one of importance, It was on his second visit he spoke of that Dr. Seott next took his place in the witne:s Holmes then began to eross-examine Dr. Before a witness had been called. after the
Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I. · 2 November 1895
Narragansett Herald · Narragansett Pier, R.I.
This single-item clipping describes witness Eugene Smith finding Pietzel's body, Dr. Scott's and Dr. Mattern's testimony on the body's condition and time of death, and Holmes conducting his own cross-examinations while acting as his own defense counsel.
Narragansett Herald · 2 November 1895 · page 1
H. H. HOLMES.
The next witnesswas one of importance, Eugene Smith, carpenter, the man who found the body of Pietzel. He told how he had gone to the house once, and had seen Perry’s (he knew Pietzel by that name) hat and cuffs in the hall but did not see Perry. He whaited awhile and went away. He returned to the house on the following morning. The hat and cuffs were in the same position. No furniture was disarranged on either occasion 1t was on his second visit he spoke of tha* Smith discovered the body of P.etzel.
See moreSee less
and as Smith told of it there came a point where an objection would he of great value to the de fence. Holmes listened for a moment, arose and made the objection. Judge Arnold promptly sustained the objection. Bmith, who did not make a good witness at all, sai! he bad found Pecry in the back room, toe feet toward the window=, which were open. SBmith, when asked whose body it was he »ad found, said it was that of Henry B. Pietzel, How he knew that he didn’t explain, and the man who thinks he is smart enough to conduet his own defence didn’t realize that another point had been reached where he should have made an objection, and a vigorous one, for the answer, which at best was only a conclusion on the part of the wi:- ness, snould have been strickea from the records, and would have been had Holmes had a lawyer representing him. Holmes be gan to cross-exumine Smith, who, properly hand’ed, would have gone all to pieces ina short time. Dr. Scott next took his place in the witne<s stand and Holmes put him through a close examination as to the condition of the body and probable cause of drath. In this Holmes' knowledge of medicine Lelped him materially but he brought out nothing to help his case. The witness expressed the opinion that at the time he saw the body. Pietzel had beea dead about three days, which is the period the commonwealth a’'leges elapsed between the day Pietzel was killed and the day his body was found. Holmes then began to cross-examine Dr. Mattern. The doctor was asked th» color of Pietzel’s moustache and hair and replied that the former was reddish and the latter dark brown. At the request of Holmes the court directed Dr. Mattern to read the notes he took of the deseription of the body at the time he held his inquest. As Dr. Mattern read his notes, Holmes copied them all
Acting as his own counsel, Holmes cross-examined witness Jeannette Pietzel about a change in her father's appearance from a removed beard, staring at her until she grew visibly uncomfortable.
East Providence Eagle · 2 November 1895 · page 3
MAN OF IRON NERVE
that he bad been up the better part of the night sreparing what ke thinks will make a good defence when the time comes. He started to conduct his own case. When Holmes seated himself, the first wit ness was called in the person of Jeannette Pietzel, one of the children of the dead man, and who escaped the fate of the larger part of the family. Holmes cross examizad her a few moments as to w.ether there hadn't been a change in the appearance of her fathee occasioned by the removal of his beard, She said her father hal a small goatee a one time, Holmes iooked her straight in the eye as he questioned ber, and the girl seemed un comfortable under his gaze.
See moreSee less
She kept her eyes on him while he questioned her, but it was plain she could have done so but a littie while longer.
When Judge Arnold denied a sixty-day continuance sought by his attorneys, Herman W. Mudgett (H. H. Holmes) saw his lawyers withdraw, leaving him to conduct his own defense after a jury was seated.
The Kimball Graphic · 2 November 1895 · page 2
Ills ConuRci Withdraw Philadelphia, Oct. 28.—Herman W. Mudgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, the self confessed life insurance swind ler, and the alleged multi-murderer, whose supposed crimes have been a top ic for general-discussion during the past several months, was placed on trial this morning in the court of oyer and ter miner on the charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pltzel. Judge Arnold pre sided. The commonwealth was repre sented by District Attorney George S. Graham and Assistant District Attor ney Thomas W. Barlow, and the defense was conducted by W.
See moreSee less
H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Ratan. In addition to the murder of Pltzel, the prisoner i3 also ac cused of the murder at Toronto, Ont., of Pitzel's two young daughters, Alice and Nellie, of t'he murder at Irvington, Ind., of the young son, Howard Pietzel and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous castle at Chicago. When the trial was called, counsel for the defense asked for a continuance of sixty days, on the ground that they were not prepared to go on. Judge Arnold overruled the motion and then defend ant's lawyers, W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, withdrew. The ease was then resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense. The work of securing a jury was com pleted at 1:45 o'clock and then a recess was taken until 3 o'clock. luctllg IliN Own HIK! H« IS Con-
This fragment reports that the jury entered the box at 10 o'clock and Holmes appeared fresh despite a sleepless night, while the district attorney announced that Holmes' latest wife had seen the prisoner, before the text cuts off.
The Kimball Graphic · 2 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES WORKS ALL NIGHT
Promptly at 10 o'clock the jury filed into the box. A moment after, Holmes entered. Despite his long and sleepless night he looked fresh and bright. Dis trict Attorney Graham announced tc the court that Mrs. Howard, as Holmes' latest wife Is known, had seen the pris
The report announces that H. H. Holmes, described as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times, went on trial Monday in Philadelphia's Court of Oyer. It predicts the case will become the most celebrated in the criminal history of the Western hemisphere due to his crimes and cold demeanor.
The New Dominion · 2 November 1895 · page 2
Miss Consuelo Vanderbilt and the Duke of Marlborough will soon be married if the Duke can be kept out of jail and away from chorus girls long enough to perform the ceremo ny. The purchase price paid for the Duke is $3,000,000, and he is said to be investing a part of it in Kentucky horses. This is a sad commentary on the horses. H. H. Holmes, the most unscrupu lous and skillful murderer of modern times, was placed on trial at Phila delphia Monday in the court of Oyer. The revolting details of the many crimes with which Holmes’
The clipping, a brief fragment, notes that most believed the jury would convict Holmes, and that at 8:45 o'clock word was sent to Judge Arnold that the jury was ready to return.
The San Francisco Call · 3 November 1895 · page 1
MUDGETT MUST HANG
case against Holmes, but the majority were inclined to believe tbat the jury would convict him. At 8:45 o'clock word was sent to Judge Arnold that the jury was ready to return
The clipping reports that a Philadelphia jury took one ballot to convict Herman W. Mudgett, known as H. H. Holmes, of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel, with the prisoner showing little visible emotion as the verdict and a motion for a new trial, set for November 18, were announced by Judge Arnold.
The San Francisco Call · 3 November 1895 · page 1
PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Nov. Her man W. Mudgett, or, as he is better known, H. H. Holmes, was to-night convicted of murder in the first degree for killing Ben jamin F. Pietzel in this city on September 2, 1894. The jury needed but one ballot to reach this decision. The jury retired at 5:45 o'clock, at the conclusion of Judge Arnold's charge. After the retirement of the jury from the courtroom the spectators streamed out into the corridors and eagerly dis cussed what the verdict would probably, be. There was considerable difference of opinion, as many believed the common wealth bad not thoroughly established its case against Holmes, but the majority were inclined to believe tbat the jury would convict him.
See moreSee less
At 8:45 o'clock word was sent to Judge Arnold that the jury was ready to return the verdict. When Judge Arnold entered the room there were not nearly as many people present as had attended the day session. The prisoner was brought in and placed in the dock. He was as impassive as ever as he took his seat. The jury came in and took their places and it needed but little skill as a mind reader to know what the word would be that the foreman would pronounce. The court ordered Holmes to arise and then in reply to the question of the court the foreman of the jury pro nounced the fatal words, "Guilty of mur der in the first degree." . The verdict was greeted, with absolute silence. .The charge of the Judge mu.t have foreshadowed what his fate would be, but the word "Guilty" fell ' upon Holmes with stunning force. He made no outcry or exhibition of emotion of any kind— the blow was too stunning for noisy outbreaks. He sat down and while the jury was polled and each man an swered to his name and as each pro nounced his sentence, Holmes stared va cantly before him. ' His face was that of a corpse. It was as . absolutely expression less as a mask. Only a nervous twitching of the eyelids. and dilation of the eyes showed that there was a liviner, breathing man that sat in the dock. As the effect of the shocks began to die away Holmes be gan to recover himself. >:^ |He realized that his attorney was mak ing a motion for a new trial. His under lip fell ' and he ran his tongue across it, and moistening and clasping his hands to gether he leaned forward to hear what the Judge had to say. ; ' The Judge said he would hear the mo tion for a new trial on Monday, November 18, and" an expression 'of something like hope broke across Holmes' dull face. Turning to the court officials he said in an eager whisper, "Monday, November. 18." These were the only words he uttered. Judge Arnold then expressed to Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker his i appreciation of how difficult their task had been. He complimented V them that ; they had been able to make as good a show for the de fense as they did. He intimated that their withdrawal from the case was a device oi the prisoner, p . v. '.''_; '••' . / *, In a manly, honest way Mr. Rotan gave the court to understand that their with drawal * was , no i device of . theirs, but was done ' from a sincere . conviction because they believed that they had not been given time to prepare their case. ■■-. "k Judge Arnold then ordered .the prisoner
This damaged clipping refers to massacres occurring along racial lines and separately notes that a defendant called Holmes showed signs of strain when brought into court that morning.
The San Francisco Call · 3 November 1895 · page 1
not to have heard of this arrangement, for savage massacres are proceeding on strictly racial lines. wished to do. When Holmes was brought into court this morning he showed that the strain
The clipping describes the courtroom scene as the jury returns a guilty verdict against Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, noting his composed demeanor and Judge Arnold's remarks afterward.
The Herald · 3 November 1895 · page 2
2 fating goes against bim, Holmes bas yet ■one time to spend on earth, fiom which ke> is alleged to bare sent so many fellow mortals. Tbe rardict wai a surprise to many per sons who did not beliero ths crime had keen fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt. Wnen tbey beatd it tbey said: "Well, it is on general princi ples and it is just as good." This is not the meaning of the law, but in this case everybody agrees that "it la just as good." There is no word of pity or sympathy for the oondemned man.
See moreSee less
He is reguried as a menace to so ciety. Up in Gilmanton, N. H., there are two old people, his father and moth er. And he has also two brothers and two sisters. Not one of bis kin was ueard from during the trial. When the jury went out an indefinite recess was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in tbe building until mid night if necessary, and if no verdict had been reached by that time he would come to court at in ociouk tomorrow morning. Nobody believed tnere would be occasion for this. Thero were many wagers that the verdict would be in tonight, and more as to its nature. At S:10 oclock there was a nnstlc of moving people in the packed court room, and it became known tbat the jury was coming in. A moment later Judge Arnold took his seat. District Attorney Graham and nis associ ates entered and the jury tiled solemnly in and took their seats in the box. Tnen Holmes was brought in ann placed In the dock. For a moment there was not a sound. The silence was literally pain ful, and every hear' in thai crowded room throbbed. The man who was about to hear his doom pronounced stood erect in tbe dock, the same deatb-1 ke pallor, which could ttrow no deeper, on his face. Ha stared at the jury bla.ikly, his hands clasped behind his back. Once or twice he moistened his lips with his tongue. There was no other sign of agitation. Then from the deep-voiced clerk came the awful words: "Jurors, look upon the prisontr; prisoner, look upon the jurors. How say you, gentlemen of the jury ; do you find the prisoner at the bar, Herman 'W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benja min F. Pitzel, or not guilty?" The condemning syllables came from the foreman: "Guilty of murder in tbe first degree." "Hem," uttered Hnlmts, clearing his throat: but his shrunken form never trembled and his lips betrayed no quiver; his marvelous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of the nands foldod behind him. Then lie slowly sat down, and at the request •f counsel tbe jury was polled. As each name was called Holmes wrote it on tbe margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The verdict was formally record ed by the court; the motion for a new trial was made, and after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to counsel fur the defense because of last Monday's incurrence, when they withdrew from the case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruitless labors. Holmes was taken to his cell room. A tew moments later tbe jurymen were thanked tor their at tention and labors and sent home; the court adjourned, and the most extraor* dinury case In the annals of American couns was ended. The last da> was uneventful except for the last tragic scene. District Attorney Graham onencd tho session with bis ad dress to the jury. |H» was followed by Bolan who In nis speech presented the only form ol the defense—that Pitzel had committed suicide, resting On the ai sumption th. t the con monwealth had not made out a case beyond a reasnnacle doubt. Judge Arnold charged tne jury for more than nn hour. The district at torney said his insiructions were fair. The general idea was that if they leaned toward either side it was toward the commonwealth, hut. the charge consisted mainly in a review of the evidence and a exposition of the law of murder. When the t'ial began last Monday everybody, including the commonwealth's officers, unticipateil tbat it would lengthen into many weeks. It lasted six days. This was the result of tLecourt's decision that no evidence touching upon Holmes'other crimes should bo introduced into th s Dsrlicular case and the conduct of coun sel in presenting no other defense other than argument. Tbe swift developments treading upun each other's heels and every one outdoing its torerunner for sensa tionalism are of public knowledge. When the jury tiled into court at 10 oclock this morning they looked liruJ and unkempt. At 10:15 oclock Mr. Rolan, junior counsel for the defense, cume into court and asked Judge Arnold for a few moments' Indulgence), saying that he had Just received word from a neighboring drug store that his colleague, Mr. Shoe maker, was sick there and he desired to join him. Mr. Bolan, himself. Showed tbe strain under which he has labored. He returned half an hour later and said he l a i found Mr. Sheemaker under tbe care of a physician, suffering from com plete prostration. He called this to the attent'on of the court in view of a point of law regarding the commonwealth's right to make the closing argument to the jury when the defense presented no evidence. Mr. Graham, however, ended the question by offering to waive nis right, to the last speech. The district at torney reviewed the evidence in detail. Beginning with the question of tho identity of the corpse found in the Callow hill street house, he went over the tes timony of each witness who positively said that it was tho body of Pitzel. Then lie proceeded to the explosion theory and the condition of the body, which lie con tended, the medical testimony had proved could not have been produced except by ohloroforin. d'bus, he said, the jury reached tbe lirst step in the case—that the man died of chloroform, not self-ad ministered, anil this, too, was proven be yond a shallow of doubt by the expert testimony. Leading up lo the motive of the mur der, Mr. Graham rehearsed in minute details holmes' every transaction In con nection with Pitzel's muruer, tracing nis movements from place to place ami draw jug out every little circumstance that weighed against the prisoner with in linite olcariiess and force. When ho came to tne testimony of Mrs. J'itzel, ho tohl tbe jury tbat never In his ollicial experience hasd lie heard such a tale as that told in tiie broken sentences of that despairing, hopeless woman whom lie had kept hitting from place to place in the vain hope ot meeting her husband, and till the while he was carry ing with him three separate detachments,
The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · and 1 other paper
The clipping, a fragment, describes Holmes being taken to his cell while jurymen were thanked for their labors and sent home before the court adjourned.
The Herald · 3 November 1895 · page 2
case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruitless labors. Holmes was taken to his cell room. A tew moments later tbe jurymen were thanked tor their at tention and labors and sent home; the court adjourned, and the most extraor*
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 3 November 1895
The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The clipping, a damaged fragment, describes a court's decision barring evidence of Holmes' other crimes in this particular case and notes counsel's defense relied only on argument.
The Herald · 3 November 1895 · page 2
was the result of tLecourt's decision that no evidence touching upon Holmes'other crimes should bo introduced into th s Dsrlicular case and the conduct of coun sel in presenting no other defense other than argument. Tbe swift developments
A damaged clipping from Philadelphia reports that a motion was made for a new trial and that a judge set a day for hearing, with a brief mention of a person called Herman W. Mudgett, also known as H. H.
The Morning Times · 3 November 1895 · page 1
JURY TOOK ONLY ONE BALLOT
teen Minutes Motion Made for a New Trluf When Judge Set a Duy for Jlciirlii-r. It Holmes Jlrlghtencd. Philadelphia, Nov. 2. Herman w. Mud celt, or as lie is belter known, H. H.
The clipping reports that opinions differed on whether the commonwealth had fully proven its case against Holmes, though most believed the jury would convict him.
The Morning Times · 3 November 1895 · page 1
what the .verdict would probably be. There was considerable difference or opin had not throughly established its case against Holmes, but the majority were In clined to believe that the Jury would con ion, as many believed Hie commonwealth vict him.
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y. · and 3 other papers
The clipping reports that Herman W. Madgett, known as H. H. Holmes, was convicted on one ballot of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel, with the jury returning its verdict to Judge Arnold the same evening.
New-York Tribune · 3 November 1895 · page 1
AND INCIDENTS OF THE GREAT TRIAL. Philadelphia, Nov. 2.—Herman W. Madgett, or, as he Is better known, H. H. Holmes, was to-night convicted of murder In the first degree for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel in this city on September 2, 1894. The jury needed but one ballot to reach this decision. They retired at 5:45, at the conclusion of Judge Arnold's charge. After the retirement of the jury from the courtroom the spectators streamed out into the corridors and eagerly discussed what the verdict would probably be. There was considerable difference of opinion, as many believed the Commonwealth had not thoroughly established its case against Holmes, but the majority were inclined to belleve that the jury would convict him.
See moreSee less
At 8:35 word was sent to Judge Arnold that the jury,was ready to return the verdict, When Judge Arnoid entered the room there were not nearly as many people present as had attended the day session. The prisoner was brought in and placed in the dock. He was as Im- | passive as ever as he tock his seat. The jury came in and took their places, and It needed but little skill as a mind-reader to know what the word would be that the foreman would pro-
The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · 3 November 1895
Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa. · 8 November 1895
Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va. · 9 November 1895
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
The fragment notes that Holmes withstood the trial's strain well but seemed slightly nervous upon entering court that morning, trailing off mid-sentence.
New-York Tribune · 3 November 1895 · page 1
THE COURTROOM CROWDED.
crowd would have been enormous. Holmes has stood the strain of the trial remarkably well, bue when he was brought into court this morning he geemed to be a trifle nervous. He greeted his
The clipping describes District-Attorney Graham criticizing Holmes's lies and reacting with contempt and scorn upon reaching Mrs. Pietzel's testimony, which caused Holmes to shrink back.
New-York Tribune · 3 November 1895 · page 1
THE DISTRICT-ATTORNEY'S ADDRESS
criticism and occasionally lashing scorn Holmes's tangle of lies in the many statements he has made. But it was when he came to the testimony of Mrs. Pietzel that Mr. Graham poured out on the prisoner the vials of his contempt, georn and denunciation. beneath the DistrictAttorney's bitter words Holmes shrank a little,
The clipping reports British claims of German duplicity behind England's isolation, unrest on the Constantinople Bourse, Canadian independence talk, a German crown concession from China, and a first-degree murder verdict against H. H. Holmes for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel, before cutting off mid-sentence.
New-York Tribune · 3 November 1895 · page 6
THE NEWS THIS MORNING. FOREIGN.—The British press say England's Misolation' is due to German duplicity. The unsettled state of the Constantinople Bourse continues. An Ontario club adopted a platform to promulgate the principles of Canadian independence, Germany is said to have obtained another crown concession from China. DOMESTIC.—A verdict of murder in the first degree was returned by the jury in the trial of H. H. Holmes for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel In
Among a column of news briefs, this report says Holmes's conviction of murder at Philadelphia came the night after Durrant's conviction in San Francisco, noting Holmes's apparent motive was insurance money from his victims.
New-York Tribune · 3 November 1895 · page 6
Anything that can tend to relieve the congested condition of the schools will meet with the approval of the readers of The Tribune, who, like all patriotic and publie-spirited citizens, are heartily interested in the extension of popular instruction in New-York. Much satisfaction will therefore be created by the news that plans have been completed for the erection of a fine new school building in the Twenty-third Ward, on St. Ann's-ave., opposite St. Mary's Park. The designs provide for an entirely different method of construction from that hitherto employed in any public school building in New-York City, and embrace all the most modern improvements and progressive ideas.
See moreSee less
Rarely has a football game been played under euch unfavorable conditions of weather as those which prevailed yesterday throughout the match between Princeton and Harvard. Yet the cold, chilling rain, which converted the gridiron into a perfect sea of mud, proved incapable of dampening either the dash and vigor of the players or the enthusiasm of the spectators, whose numbers bore striking tribute to the popularity of this particular branch of sport. The game was hotly contested, and, contrary to general expectation. resulted in a victory for Princeton, the betting having been all in favor of Harvard, Durrant's conviction of murder at San Francisco on Friday was followed by that of Holmes at Philadelphia last night. Three deaths are laid at the door of the California assassin, while no one save Holmes himself can tell with any degree of exactitude the appalling number of his vietims. In his case the motive seems to have been the money derived from the insurance policies of those whom he destroyed, while that of Durrant was of a more degraded character. So monstrous are the crimes of each, however, that one feels tempted to believe that they are homicidal maniacs, possessed of all the cunning and craftiness of madmen, instead of possessing the normal degree of sanity, and being as such responsible for their actions. Secretary Herbert has decided to reject the new Ammen ram Katahdin, designed and built strictly for harbor defence. According to a dis, patch from Washington published to-day, his action in the matter Is based upon the report of the trial board, which gives her official speed at only 16.13 knots, in lieu of the 17 required by the Navy Department. The failure of the vessel to satisfy the Government appears to be in a great measure attributable to the rashness of the builders in permitting the trial to take place on Friday last under the most adverse conditions of tide and wind, instead of in the smooth water stipulated by the contract. There appears to be an Lmpression among experts that — —— etl. —— fp
This single item describes Holmes's expressionless reaction as the jury pronounced him guilty of murder in the first degree, his brief hopeful whisper on hearing a new trial motion was set for Nov. 18, and the judge's closing remarks to the withdrawn defense counsel and jury.
The Morning News · 3 November 1895 · page 1
jority were inclined to believe that the jury w ould convict him. At 8:35 o’clock word was sent to Judge Arnold that the jury was ready to re turn the verdict. When Judge Arnold en tered the room there was not nearly as many people preei at as had attended the day session. The prisoner was brought in a I placed In the dock, lie was as Im passive as ever, as ho took -his seat. The jurv came In and took their places, anil it needed but little skill as a mind reader to know what the wold would be that tin foreman would pronounce.
The fragment describes Holmes recovering his composure and walking from the courtroom with his usual quick step as the judge thanked the jurors for their attention.
The Morning News · 3 November 1895 · page 1
MURDERING PITEZEL
removed. By this time Holmes had recovered much of his composure, and he walked from the room with the quick, springy step that is natural to him. The judge thanked the jurors for their attention and
The clipping, a damaged fragment, quotes Rev. K. J. Wilcox saying that at a January 17, 1834 ceremony, Holmes appeared as innocent as a lamb, with no reason then for close scrutiny of his face.
The Morning News · 3 November 1895 · page 5
POINTS ABOUT HOLMES
less than two years ago,” says the Kev. K. J. Wilcox, "Holmes was as innocent looking as a lamb." At the time of the ceremony. Jan. 17, 1834. there was no oc casion for any especially close examina tion of the now world-famous murderer’s physiognomy, but now there is especial Table.
A jury found Holmes guilty of murdering Benjamin P. Tletzei after brief deliberation, a new trial hearing was set for the 18th, and no relatives attended the trial.
The Indianapolis Journal · 3 November 1895 · page 1
TO THE SUPREME COURT.
PHILADELPHIA, Pa.. Nov. l-IIenry II. Holmes was convicted of murJer in th firpt degree at S:51 o'clock to-night for killing Benjamin P. Tletzei. He coughed Flightly when ho heard the words. That was tho only sign. The Juror3 retired to deliberate at 5:W o'clock this afternoon. According to one of their number, they reached their ver dict before tho doors of their room closed upon them. For hunger's sake they ato their supper first Then they took a ballot, and, without hesitation, every man of tho twelve answered, "Guilty of murder in tho first degree."
See moreSee less
But, however atrocious the crime, however fiendish the criminal, it is hard to send a man to the gallows In one minute's time. So, for decency's sake, they talked about the case for a seemly reriod, about an hour and a half. Then word was sent Into court that they had agreed. This was at 8:15 o'clock. It took, a half hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict. Such things are not done ' too quickly. Holme3 spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker, in tho cell room before he was takea back to Moyamenslng prison. To them he said: "I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trial." He would say no more than that. Immediately after the winouncement of the verdict the usual application for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. Dis trict Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion, and Judge Arnold fixed the ISth of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation of the defense. Should a new trial be refused, an appeal will be taken to the Supreme Court, and argument heard at its next sitting in this city, January, 1S9G. So, even If everything goes against him. Holmes has yet some time to spend on. the earth, from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow-mortals. The verdict was a surprise to many persons, who did not be lieve the crime had been fastened on Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt. When they heard It: "Well, it was on general princi ples, and it's just as good." That is not the meaning of law, but in this case everybody agrees that "it's just as good." There is no word of pity or sympathy for the condemned felon. He is regarded as a menace to so ciety. Up In Gilmanton, X. H., there arc two old people, his father and mother. And also ho has two brothers and two sisters. Not one of his kin was heard from during tho trial.
The clipping reports defense attorney Rotan's closing argument that Holmes staged a suicide as an insurance swindle and would not have voluntarily returned to the city had he committed murder, urging the jury to give him benefit of the doubt.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 3 November 1895 · page 1
DOOM IS PRONOUNCED
compary. CONTENDS FOR SUICIDE. Coming down to the time of the kill ing, the speaker denied that there was j anything to show alcoholic indications in the man's stomach to bear out th commonwealth's assertion that Holmes I had chloroformed him while he was drunk. ConcerningChe hurried departure of Holmes and hte alleged wife from the Eleventh street house on the night of the murder. Holmes having come home flushed and warm, and ordered her to pack her trunk, Mr Rotan urged that Miss Yoke's testimony showed beyond question that they had the night before resolved to leive town on Sunday night.
See moreSee less
The commonwealth relied on the medi cal testimony that the body culd not have been found in the reposeful posi tion in which it was. had Pietzel eom mitted suicide by inhaling chloroform. The dfrnse admitted the truth of this, but as fl ' at it was placed in such a position by Holmes after Pietzel had committed suicide, leaving a night for him to utilize the corpse to consum mate the insurance swindle. Mr. Rotan reminds the jury of the fact that when arrested in Boston for conspiracy. Holmes asked to be brought to this city to and trial rather than gn to FVrt Worth, where he tabs wanted for stealing a horse. Would any mm havemflde such a choice, he dmandM unless h know jut what crime b had committed? Would he. the lauyr de manded, have avoided a trival charge in a far distant place to put his neck In danger by coming voluntarily to tills cltv haa he commuted a murder here? In conclusion he begged the jury to carefully weigh the facts and then give the prisoner the benefit of the doubt. CHARGE TO THE JURY.
The clipping reports that Holmes's guilty verdict surprised some who doubted the evidence, notes no sympathy was expressed for him, mentions his parents and siblings in Gilman ton, N.H. did not appear during the trial, and describes the jury's deliberations and a judge named Arnold awaiting the verdict.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 3 November 1895 · page 1
moved so many fellow-mortals. NO WORD OF SYMPATHT. The verdict was a surprise to many persons who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond reasonable doubt. "When they heard the verdict, they said: "Well, it was on general principles and it is lust .and Rood." That is not the meaning of the idw out in this case everybody agrees that "it is just as good." There is no word of pity or sympathy for the condemned felon. He is regardea as a menace to society. Up In Gil man ton.
See moreSee less
X. H., there are two old peo pZe, his father and mother. And he has two brothers and two sisters. Not one wnis Kin was neara trom during the trial. When the jury went out an indefinite recess was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in the buildinsr until midnight if necessary and if no verdict had been reached by that time he wouia come to court at 10 o'clock to be occasion for this. There were many wa-prs that the verdict would be in to night and many as to its nature. morrow. Nobody believed there would
The clipping describes the tense courtroom scene as the jury returned and the foreman pronounced Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of murder in the first degree in the death of Benjamin F. Pietzel, with Holmes showing no visible emotion beyond clasping his hands tighter.
The Wichita Daily Eagle · 3 November 1895 · page 1
night and many as to its nature. TWENTY MIUTES OF NINE At twenty minutes of nine there was a bustle of moving people in the packed court room and it became known that the jury wero coming In. A moment later Judge Arnold took his sent. Dis trict Attorney Graham and his associ ates entvrd and tho jury filed solemnly In and took their seats in the box. Then Holmes was brought in and placed In the dock. For a moment there was not a sound. The silence was literallv pain ful and every heart in that crowded room throbbed.The man who was about to near his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same deathlike pallor, which could grow no deeper, on his face.
See moreSee less
lie starjlat the jury blankly his hands claspflr behind his back. Once or twice he moistened his lips with h.'s tongue. There was no other sign of agitation. Then from the deep voic ed court clerk came the awful words "Jurors look upon the prisoner, prison er look upon the jurors. How say vou. gentlemen of the jury, do you find the prisoner at the bar. Herman W. Mudg- . alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the i lurder of Benjamin F. Pietzel. or not guilty?" The condemning syllable came from the foreman, "guilty of murder in the first degree." Hem." uttered Holmes, clearing his thro-it. but his shrunken form never trembled: his lips betrayed no quiver; his marvelous nerve had not forsaken hm. Then was only a tighter clasp of his hands folded behind him. WROTE THEIR NAMES.
After a jury found Holmes guilty of first-degree murder, he remained outwardly calm while his lawyers sought a new trial, which Judge Arnold set for a hearing on the 18th.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 3 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES IS GUILTY MURDERER OF MEN, WOMEN AND CHILDREN MUST DIE ON THE GALLOWS
twelve answered, "Guilty of mur der in the first degree." But, how ever atrocious the crime, however fiendish the criminal, it is hard to send a man to the gallows in one min ute's time. So, for decency's sake, they talked about the case for a seemly, period — about an hour and a half. Then word was sent Into court that they had agreed. This was at 8:15 o'clock. It took a half-hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict. Such things are not done too quickly.
See moreSee less
Holmes spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker, in the cell room be fore he was taken back to Moyamen sing prison. To them he said: "I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trial." He would say no more than that. Immediately after the announce ment of the verdict the usual ap plication for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. District Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion, and Judge Arnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hear ing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation of the defense. Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the ' supreme - court, and argument heard at its next sitting in this city, NOT A QUIVER. "Hem," uttered Holmes, clearing his throat. But his shrunken form never trembled, his lips betrayed no quiver, his marvelous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of the hands folded behind him. Then he slowly sat down, and at the request of counsel the jury was polled. That Is, each of the twelve men separately lis tened to the clerk's query and re sponded with the finding. As each name was called Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper In his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The verdict was formally re corded by the court; the motion for a new trial was made; and after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to counsel for the defense because of last Monday's occurrence, when they with drew'from the case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruitless labors, : Holmes was taken to his cell room and a few moments later to prison. Then the jury was thanked for their atten tion and labors and sent home, the court adjourned, and the most ex traordinary case in the annals' of American courts was ended. The proceedings of the last day were uneventful, except for the last tragic scene. District Attorney Graham open ed the session with his address to the jury. He was followed by Mr. Rotan, who in his speech presented the only form of the defense,- thatPietsel had j committed suicide, restingon, the as-
This damaged clipping describes Col. W. O. Bradley as a skilled Republican stump speaker and lawyer, then shifts to discussing a possible new trial or appeal for a man named Holmes, with the state supreme court set to hear arguments in January 1896.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 3 November 1895 · page 1
I once attorney general of the state. He j is" a rich man, but every one calls him Wat, and he prides himself on his democratic manners. . Col. W. O. Bradley," the Republican candidate, is.also a lawyer, and. a suc cessful one. He has. been In the storm • and stress -of -political i life for years and has been defeated for many offices, j He is counted as one of the best stump J speakers in a state where orators are ing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation of the defense.
See moreSee less
Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the ' supreme - court, and argument heard at its next sitting in this city, i in January.. 1896... .50, even if r every ? I thing goes against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on the" earth from which he is alleged to have sent
The clipping reports that Henry H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree in Philadelphia for killing a man named (garbled in the OCR) and merely coughed slightly upon hearing the verdict.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 3 November 1895 · page 7
Philadelphia, Nov. S TTcnrj H. Holmes was convleteHl or murder In the first de cree at S 61 to-night for killing UenJ.untn V. IUt7.Pl. He coughed elli-htly when tho heard the words. Thnt was the only (dun.
This damaged fragment states that the matter will be taken to a special court with argument to be heard at its next sitting in January, meaning Holmes still has time remaining even if things go against him.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 3 November 1895 · page 7
WONDERFUL NERVE OF HOLMES.
taken to the speelal court ami argument lienrd ut Its net sltttnir in thin city, Jan uary, HDfi. So, ecn if every thliiK rocs against him, Holmes has yet Mmc time to
This fragment records the courtroom formula asking the jury how they find the prisoner, named as Herman V. MuVett, alias H. H. Holmes, on the charge of murdering Benjamin F. Pitezel, with the verdict itself cut off.
Kansas City Daily Journal · 3 November 1895 · page 7
WONDERFUL NERVE OF HOLMES.
cine lie awful words- ."Jurors, look upon the nrl-'oner: prisoner look upon the Juiors. How Fay jou. Gentlemen of the Jury, do "ou tlncl the prisoner at the bar, llernnn V MuVett. alias H. H. , Holmes guilty of the minder of Uenjamln F, 1'iuel or
This fragment is too jumbled and disjointed to summarize clearly, but it references a courtroom applauding a judge's charge to jurors, a $10,000 agreement involving an Attorney General, and a stag hunt near Potsdam.
The Anaconda Standard · 3 November 1895 · page 1
A TRAGIC SCENE, INDEED
and expects to 'he pardoned after a fe'w sons. who did not believe the crime Fancy Oak, Iron, Marble and months' imprisonment. had been fastened upon Holmes beyond Onyx. Beautiful new designs. a reasonable doubt. Call and see them. Son of 01 a Elsa 1. Dead. anot'her tramdt of country had the build was applauded in the court room and $10,000 ready to accept Brady's proposi ing of a shooting Modge mear Oberhas that The Jurors were thus shown what tion to-day if possible. The agreement bach, Absace. A great stag bootue wall they were expected to do. Dickinson to which Attorney General Kinaworthy be held In Wild park, Pottadam. on
This single-item clipping reports that Holmes was found guilty of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pitsei, describes the jury's deliberations and the courtroom scene, and notes a new trial hearing was set for the 18th.
The Anaconda Standard · 3 November 1895 · page 1
A TRAGIC SCENE, INDEED
Philadelphia. Nov. 2.--Heary H. Holmea was convicted ot murder in the first derree at 8:51 o'clock to-etgeht for killing Beniamin F. Pitsei. The jury retired to deliberate at 5:10 o'clock. Aooording to one of their number they had reached their verdict before the doors of their room closed upon them. For hunger's sake they ate their suppers first. Then they took a ballot and without hesitation every men of the 12 answered "guilty of murder in the first degree." But, how ever atrodo as the crime, however fiendish the criminal. It is hard to send a man to the .allows in one minute's time.
See moreSee less
So, for decency's sake they talked about the case for a seemingly period of sbout an hourand a half.T'hen word was sent into court that they had agreed. It -took half an hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict. Holmes sooke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker. In the cell room, be fore he was taken back to the prison. He said: "I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trial." He would say no more than that. Imme diately after the verdict the usual ap plioation to file a motion for a new trial was made. District Attorney Gra ham did not oppose the motion and Judge 4rnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation for the defense. Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the supreme court and ar guments helard at Its next sitting in this city. January. 1896. So even it everything goes against him. Holmes has yet some time 4o spend on the earth from which he i alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals. The verdict was a surorise to many per sons. who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt. There was no word of sympathy for 'the condemned felon. He 4s regarded as a menace to soolety. Up in Glanan ton, N. H.. there are two old people, his father and another: and he has also two brothers land two sisters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial. When the jury went out an indefinite recess was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in the building until midnight if necessary and if no verdict had been reached by that time be would oome 'to the court at 10 o'clock to-morrow morning. Nobody believed there would be occasion for this. There were many wagers that the verdict would be in to-night, and more as to its nature. At 20 minutes of 9 o'clock there nits t ustle of moving people in the packed court room and it became known that the jury was coming in. A moment later Judge Arnold took his seat. District Attorney Graham and his associates entered and the jury filed solemnly in and took their seats in the box. Then Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. The Silence was literally painful and every heart In that crowded room throbbed. The man who was albout to hear his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock. the same deathlike pallor, which could grow no deeper, on his face. He stared at the jury blankly. his hands clasped behind his back. Then from the deen voiced court clerk came the awful words. "Jourors, look upon the prisoner; prisot er. look upon the jurors. How say you,}gentlemen of the jury, do you find the prioner at the bar. Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benjiamin F. Plitzel. or not guilty?" The condemning syllables came from the foreman: "Guilty of murder in the first decree." "Ahemn." uttered Holmes, cleasing his throalt, 'but his shrunken torm never trembled; his lips betrayed no qtSver; his xuarvebous nerve 4iad not forsaken him. There was only a GIgbter clasp of his bands folded behind Mm. Then he slowly eat down, ,ad at 'the request of counsel, (the jury 'ws poled. As eadh saame was called, Hohnee wrote it on the margie of a newspaper in his hand, and Rite flrgers boliding 'the pencil never shook. The verdidt was formally recorded Ly the cowit; .the mdtion for a new trial vacs acade, and after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to the counsel for the defense because of last MAonday's oocurrenee when they withdrew from the case, and apprecia tion for their arduous but fruitless la bor. Holmes wwas tisken to his cell room a few minutes later; the jury was thanked for its attention and labors and sent home; *the court adjourned, and 'the molt ewtcaordlnary case in fhe annals of Annerican counts was ended. The last day was uneven'tful excet for t e last tragic scene. District At torne 'graham .pened rhe e-.won aihh his ,tidress to the jury. He was f Il.w 'd by Mr. Roileu who, in h;is s ,h, prestne:.n' the only form of 'tht ldfenso -.:hat Pitsel had crnmtrr:ed suaicde. rtsting on the a-ssumpgion that the oe imonw'ealt, h hat n "t made tt a oase bt y ond a reasonable doubt. Judg Am >11 ctarged * he jury for more than arn hnur Tim:- *1 "r: ikttarney ref~e'w tUe ev'1. t in detail. Beginning with the qu. ." of :t'e identi:y of 'o '--,'se . 1 :n the COa!ow-.tl .tree:
In closing remarks, Mr. Graham notes two parties acting under Holmes' direction, each unaware of the other, and says the jury should consider only evidence tied to the murder at Pitezel in the Callowhill street house.
The Anaconda Standard · 3 November 1895 · page 1
er under Holmes' leading satanes, nand yet each party ignorant of the present of the other 9wo. In conclusion, Mr. Graham said he desired the jury to con elder only the evddence connected with the murder at Pitsea in the Callowh!1l street house, and nothing else.
This badly scrambled OCR fragment mixes mentions of a flag-raising salute by the Forsyth Rifles, a reference to Mme. de Novikoff, and disjointed phrases involving Holmes, Watson, and a jailor, making the original subject impossible to determine clearly.
The News & Observer · 3 November 1895 · page 1
even if everything goes against man had been killed or committed of the world, it will be a matter for sin him, Holmes has yet some time to snend suicide? cer congratulation and a decided tri been materially the same. I would have membend that Mme. de Novikoff has Watson. After the raising of the flag a got up yesterday but my mother, several for yean past been looked upon as the salute was given by the Forsyth Rifle friends and the chief jailor closed in
The clipping reports that District Attorney Graham, in a two-and-a-half-hour address, detailed Holmes's movements and deceptions regarding Pietzel's murder, arguing the uncontradicted evidence proved his guilt, after which a recess was taken.
The News & Observer · 3 November 1895 · page 1
THE JURY FIND HIM GUILTY
Mr. Graham rehearsed in minn’e de tail Holmes’every transaction in connec tion with Pietzel’s murder, tracing his movements from place to place, and drawing out every little circumstance that weighed against the prisoner with infinite elearness and force. When he came to the testimony of Mrs. Pietsc), be told tne jury never in his of ficial experience had he heard such a tale as that told in the broken sentences •f that despairing, hopeless woman that will-o-tbe wisp whom she kept flying from place to place in the vain hope of meeting her hosoand.
See moreSee less
And all the while he was carrying with him three separate detachments, Mrs. Pietzel, Miss Yoke and the children, all within four blocks of eaeh other, almost traveling together, under Holmes’ leading strings, and yet each party ignorant of the presence of the other two. “What marvelous ingenuity, what craft, what cunning," cried the District Attorney. “Why did he resort to all this duplici ty I Why did he adopt so many subter fuges, and why did he tell these many stork*! It was because he had murder ed Benjamin F. PietzeL” Mr. Graham declared that there was not one word of evidence to show that Piet* 1 had committed or even contem plated suicide. In conclusion, Mr Graham said he de sired the jury to consider only the evi denee aonnecfed with the murder of Pietsel in the Oallowbill street house and nothing else. “I ask you to remember this testi mony. I ask you to remember that it is nneontradicted, unchallenged and unre mitted. On the face of that testimony there ean be but one conclusion—that this man is guilty in the maimer and form a-i he stands indicted.” Mr. Graham’s address lasted two hours and a half. Holmes appeared to shrink from the District Attorney’s accusing finger, and nervously shifted in bus seat as the thunderous tones of the prosecut ing officer rang through the court room At the conclusion cf his address a recess was taken. The afternoon session was beguu at a quarter to three o’clock, when Mr. Ro tan, after a moment’s conversation with H H. HOLMES.
This damaged clipping jumbles unrelated items—Holmes's arrest in Boston, Turkish attitudes amid Russian and French protection concerns, and a quoted denial by Durrant—into an incoherent fragment that cannot be reliably summarized.
The News & Observer · 3 November 1895 · page 1
H. H. HOLMES.
fact that when arrested in Boston, for budding. Consequently the Turks fall have done that this prisoner did not conspiracy, Holmes asked to be brought ing back upon the protection, thus commit this crime you must and ought to this city to stand trial rather than go openly given, of Russia and France, view of the concern felt in the United cide, Durrant said : up stair. Drake cut a hole through the States and England as to the threaten “Never. I think of no such thing. I brick wall and let himself down by tying ing attitude of the Turkish populace to think that a man is a coward who would
A Philadelphia jury found Henry H. Holmes guilty of murder in the first degree for killing Benjamin F. Pitezel, reaching a unanimous verdict after deliberating for about three hours, though they had informally agreed within minutes. Holmes showed little reaction beyond a slight cough and later told his attorneys he felt the trial had been unjust.
The Salt Lake Herald · 3 November 1895 · page 1
I PHILADELPHIA Nov 2 Henry H Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree at 851 tonight for kill ing Benjamin F Pitzel He coughed slightly when he heard the words
The clipping lists attendees at a meeting, including academic and professional figures and representatives from a Richmond alumni association, though OCR errors garble several names.
The Times · 3 November 1895 · page 1
THE FINDING WAS A STUNNING BLOW
Kin School, near Alexandria; Thomas Nelson Page, Solicitor-General Holmes Conrad, Professor W. M. Thornton, Pro fessor Schele De Vere, who was for nearly fifty years a member of the Uni versity faculty; Professor W. DD. (fabell, Dr. W. Bb. Glazebrook, Rey, Dr. McKim, Gardiner (+. Hubbard, and others, Rope resentative Tazewell Ellett and W. K. Meredith, president . of the Richmond Alumni Association, who had coma from Richmond to attend the meeling, were in the audience,
A German-language announcement lists Wonderland's new lineup, including dancers, singers, a sword swallower, a Bowie-knife duel, lasso and whip displays, and a wax reproduction of H. H. Holmes, the alleged mass murderer.
Vorwärts · 3 November 1895 · page 4
Noch zu keiner Zeit in der Geſchichte des Wonderland iſt ein beſſeres Pro— gramm von Manager Marion arran~ girt worden als in der beginnenden Woche. Im Haupttheater : Baler und Lyon Duo, Eddie Moore, der bekannte Tänzer, Miß Ella Carlington, ſingende und tanzende Soubrette und Banjo~ Spieler, Eddie Collins Geſangsund Tanzkünſtler. Der muſitaliſche Ran~ fins und Chas. Fox, der deutſche Schauſpieler, werden auftreten. Auf der Bijou-Bühne wird die Hullshof Specialitäͤten Compagnie er~ ſcheinen und in der Curio Halle die zwei Eremiten von den Rockh Moun-~ tains, Prinz Le Vard, der berühmte Schwertgänger, und der Apache George und Arizona George mit ihrem er~ ſchütternden Bowie-Meſſer-Duell und Vorführung ihrer Gewandtheit mit dem Laſſo und der Bullenpeitſche, und die Reproduktion in Wachs des notor ſchen H.
See moreSee less
H. Holmes, des angeblichen Maſſenmörders, werden unter den Hauptſehenswürdigleiten ſein. Wonderland.
The clipping describes the tense courtroom scene as Herman W. (Holmes) was pronounced guilty of the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, with the jury polled and the verdict recorded amid what observers called an extraordinary scene.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 3 November 1895 · page 1
11 taken to the Supreme Court * gun nt h ird at Its next si.ting . even if everything goes against ... H mats has yet some time to spend t ue earth trom which he is alleged nve p nt so many f ‘llow mortals. Tiio verdict was a surprise to many ns who did not believe the crime on fa-tened upon Holmes be . a reasonable doubt A twency minutes to nine, there was tie of moving people in the packed r n, and tt became known that was coming in.
See moreSee less
A moment ’.ge Arnold took his seat. Dis «>mey Graham and his assist l, and the jury filed solernn J _ook their seats in the box. T , .mid an oppressive silence, as brought in and placed in oment there was not a sound. >■ vs as literally painful. and rt in that crowded room . fa ter. The man who was hear his doom pronounced : in the dock, the same death . which could grow no deeper me. He stared at the jury is hi.,nis clasped behind his < ;■ twice he moist* tied his h s tongue. There was no of agitation. Then from the court civrk came the awful '. look upon the prisoner; pris nthni- ’i of the jury, do you fin ! pr '*»(: i • the bar, Herman W murd r of B tjn.isn F. Piet/>.i or The condemning syllables came “Guilty of murder In the first de Hem.” uttered Holmes, clearing his -t. but his shrunken form ne\ r >led; 1 lips betrayed no quiver, marvelous nerve had not forsaken There was only a tighter clasp \ he slowly sat down, and at the of counsel, the jury was polled; e :h uf the twelve men separate l to the clerks query and re wUh the finding. As each “ called, Holmes wrote k on of a newspaper in his hand, angrs holding the pencil never "'lie: was formally recorded by the motion for a uew trial and after Judge Arnold had "■ >rd of regret to the counsel > b -tu.se of last Monday’s when they withdrew from nd appreciation for their t fruitless labors. Holmes 1 to his cell room am! a few later to prison. Then the nked for their attention and ^•nt home, the court ad - the most extraordinary ” annals of American courts
A damaged clipping describes crowds surging into the Criminal Court before the Holmes trial's closing arguments, with public opinion split on guilt but many expecting acquittal on the Pietzel murder charge.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 3 November 1895 · page 1
the Criminal Court were at a higher premium this morning than at any time since the Holmes trial began. week, culminating in yesterday's cli max, when the defense resolved to go to the jury without evidence, relying on the supposed weakness of the common wealth's case, had such an effect on the public mat before seven o'clock this morning there was a pushing, surging crowd in the corridors, waiting and hoping to gain entrance. arguments wouid begin, upon the as sembling ol to irt to-day, the optuing address to the jury by District Attorney Graham would be the effort of uis life.
See moreSee less
last Monday, the gallery was opened to the surplus portion oi the public having police lines, ai.er the lower floor had b< an filled to its caps icy. Most of the spectators therein.were women. he got in w.13 a mystery, but there he chine 1* veled on Holmes in the dock. i conn ! for the defense. cann**lnto oouro The series of theatrical incidents which crowded ujion one another ail Everybody understood that when the 1 or the first time since the trial bagan, me nt\..-mry credentials to pass the The camera fiend was on hand. How whs, up in the gallery with his ma Contrary to all expm ion the eon morning d.i d to b . .. Holmes would be aqukted. N*ine out of every ' a p> rsons questioned on the subject, be they lawyers or layman, a, reed that j ' pies," «:tough crimes iving ?en fast ened upon turn, but tl; t the murder of I*ietzel had nc: t en brought home to him beyond a reasonable doubt. Even bets were being trulj made last night on his acquittal. When th( jury filed into court a mo ment after tea o'clo* his morning they look d in d and unkempt, ivnd there was a thiu growth of beard on ev ry ch t. her waa uniform ex pression in their twenty-four eyes—an express! -i •. iling of rsignation to pre sent misfortune and hope for the near future. A: I 'T.". o’clock, Mr. Rotan. junior ‘
This badly damaged OCR fragment mentions Holmes in the dock and a morning that, contrary to expectation, did something unclear, but the text is too corrupted to determine its meaning.
Wheeling Sunday Register · 3 November 1895 · page 1
chine 1* veled on Holmes in the dock. Contrary to all expm ion the eon morning d.i d to b . .. Holmes ‘
The Indianapolis Journal · Salt Lake City, Utah · and 1 other paper
After deliberating about an hour and a half, the jury returned a guilty verdict of first-degree murder against H.H. Holmes. Holmes told his counsel he felt the trial was unjust, and his attorneys immediately moved for a new trial, with Judge Arnold setting a hearing date and noting an appeal to the Supreme Court remained possible.
The Indianapolis Journal · 4 November 1895 · page 1
JURY OUT THREE HOURS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Also printed in 1 paper
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah · 3 November 1895
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
The clipping, cut off mid-sentence, reports that H. H. Holmes, described as a noted criminal and swindler, was found guilty of first-degree murder in Philadelphia the previous Saturday night.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 4 November 1895 · page 2
H. H. Holmes, the noted criminal and swindler, was found guilty of murder in the first degree in Phila delphia last Saturday night for t he
The clipping reports that Holmes wrote the verdict steadily without his hand shaking, that the court formally received it, and that after his attorneys moved for a new trial without opposition from District Attorney Graham, Judge Arnold set a hearing for the 18th of the month.
Waterbury Democrat · 4 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES FOUND GUILTY.
oalled Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook! The ver dict was formally received by the court. A motion was made by hi3 attorneys for a new trial. District Attorney Graham did not op pose the motion, and Judge Arnold fixed the ISth of this month for a hearing.
The clipping reports that the convicted murderer spent a quiet day in his Moyamensing prison cell, slept well, remains confident of his innocence, and is now guarded to prevent suicide, with brief unrelated notes on steamer arrivals.
The Herald · 4 November 1895 · page 3
PHILADELPHIA, Nov. a-H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer of Ben jamin F. Pitzel, spent a quiet day in his ceil in Moyamensing prison. "This man of steel and heart of stone," as the district attorney describetl him tn the jury, does not evince in tbe slightest any outward signs of breaking down. Witn death actually before biro now he is the same cool and callous Holmes. The prison regulations prevent any ono from interviewing him today but" a message was sent out that be slept well last night aud was feeling comfortably and still confident that his innocenoe would yet be established.
See moreSee less
Extra care has been taken,, so bu cannot commit suicide. A double guard has been placed in bis cell and will remain there until ho is execut cd. He is still in tbe untried depart ment, but as soon as the death sentence is pronounced he will he taken to a cell in "murderers' row." NEW YORK.Nov. 3.-Arrived: Spanrn dam, Rotterdam; Berlin, Hamburg. HAVRE, Nov, 3.—Arrived: La cham pagne, New York. The best and purest is sought by a 1. Be sure tv order Huyler's Cocoa and Chocolates iroru your grocer. Holmes' Heart of Stone Steamer Arrivals
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 2 other papers
A Philadelphia jury deliberated a few hours before convicting H. H. Holmes, alias Herman W. Mudgett, of first-degree murder in the killing of Benjamin F. Pitezel, after which his attorneys moved for a new trial, a motion the district attorney did not oppose and which the judge set for a hearing on the 18th.
Evening Journal · 4 November 1895 · page 3
HOLMES FOUND GUILTY. The Verdict of the Jury Wai SInrdcr la the First Degree. PllllADEkPHlA, Nov. 4.—The verdict ol tho jury in the Holmes case was prompt and not unexpected, though the prosecu tion had not mado as strong a case as Win nnticipated at tho opening of the trial. H. H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the flrst degree fur the killing of Benja min F. Pitozel. Tho jury retired from the courtroom foi deliberation at 5:40 p. m., and at 8:16 tbo jurors returned with thoir verdict. The man who was now about to heal his doom pronounced stood ereot In the dock, tho same deathlike pallor, which could grow no deeper, on hlB face.
See moreSee less
He stared nt tho jury blankly, his hnndf clasped behind his iMick. Once or twice he moistened his lips with his tongue. Thore wns no other sign of agitation. Then from tho deep voiced court clerk came the awful words: ''Jurors, look upon tho prisoner. Pris oner, look upon the jurors. Now, siiy you gentlomen of the jury, do you And the prisoner nt tho bur, Herman W. Mud gett, allas H. U. Holmes, guilty of tho murder of Bonjumin F. Pitozel or not guilty?", The condemning syllables ctune prompt ly from the foreman: ''Guilty of murder In tho flrst dogree." "Hem!" muttered Holmes, clearing his throat, but his shrunken form never trem bled; bis lips betrayed no quiver; his mar velous nerve had not forsaken him. Tliero was only a tighter clasp of the hands fold ed behind him. Thon ho slowly sat down, and nt the request of counsel the jury wns polled— that is, each of the 12 men separately lis tened to the clerk's query and responded with the finding. As each name was called Holmes wroto it on tho margin of a newspaper In his hand, and tho lingers holding tho pencil never shook. The ver dict was formally received by tho court. A motion was made by his attorneys for n now trial. District Attorney Graham did not op pose tho motion, and Judge Arnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hearing.
Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 4 November 1895
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · 7 November 1895
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The clipping reports that a Philadelphia jury unanimously and quickly convicted H. H. Holmes of murdering Benjamin F. Pitezel, describing his calm courtroom demeanor despite inner fear, his penny-tossing bravado while awaiting the verdict, and his counsel's plan to appeal.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 4 November 1895 · page 3
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
This damaged, fragmentary clipping describes someone named Holmes walking with a jaunty, swinging gait through a narrow lane between crowded onlookers toward a grilled door into a court room, but the garbled OCR text makes much of the passage unclear.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 4 November 1895 · page 3
unlocked the tho tho tunnel and court room. He advanced through a nar row lane between closely packed throngs and women. As if by of of abandoned for grilled door that ends Holmes stepped into the effort he his jaunty, swinging
The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.
The clipping describes the dramatic final day of Holmes' murder trial, the defense's closing arguments, and his family's emotional reaction to his conviction, alongside an unrelated report of a woman burned to death in a house fire.
The Wilmington Daily Republican · 4 November 1895 · page 3
"Well, the jury has more to regret than I I have In this verdict. I knew what it was the the moment I saw little Hertel'a face. He could not look at bling as he stood up. Look at mine. Does It It tremble?" Holmes held oat his right hand. It did not waver. It not The lMt day of the trial was, of course, the the most dramatic. Mr. Shoemaker, of Holmes' counsel, prostration, and in his absence Dis trict Attorney Graham agreed to forego trict his his privilege of making two addresses to the jury.
The clipping describes newspapers printing mismatched photo captions, including pictures of Edgar Allan Poe and James J. Corbett labeled as Theodore Durrant, others as H. H. Holmes, and one of Benjamin Harrison labeled as Dwight L. Moody.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Morning News · 4 November 1895 · page 4
newspaper versatility. We have seen pie | tures of Edgar Allan Poe and James J. Corbett pose as likenesses of Theodore Durrant, pictures of Gov. Altgeld and Calvin S. Bric-e presented as likenesses of H. H. Holmes, and a picture of exPresldent Benjamin Harrison with the , name of Dwight L. Moody undeit. There
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · and 3 other papers
The clipping reports that convicted murderer H. H. Holmes remained calm and confident in Moyamensing prison under double guard, while in Boston his parents and first wife reacted with shock upon being told of his conviction, and a New York paper sought comment from prosecuting attorneys on a possible appeal.
The Indianapolis Journal · 4 November 1895 · page 2
PHILADELPHIA, Nov. 3. H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer of Benjamin F. Pictzel. spent a quiet day In his cell in Moyamensing prison. "This man of steel and heart of stone." as the district attorney described him to the Jury yesterday, does not evidence in the slightest . any outward signs of breaking down.' With death actual ly before him now he is the same cool and callous Holmes. The prison regulations pre vented any one fcpm interviewing him to day, but a message was sent out that he slept well last night and was feeeling com foi table and still confident his innocence would yet be established.
See moreSee less
Extra care has been taken that the man shall not irustrato the efforts of the prose cution by committing suicide. A double guard has been placed on his cell and will remain there until he has paid the penalty of bis crime. He is still In the untried de tence is pronounced he will be taken to a cel in "murderers' row." As to the other actors in this greaUdrama of the past week, many have returned to their ordinary pursuits. Some of the chief ones, however, are still here. Mrs. Pietzel and Des.-ie drove through Falrmount Park to-day and saw some of the places her daughter Alice spoke of in the letters con will return to Ga'.va, 111. Miss Yoke, the Indiana woman, Holmes's third wife, will return to Denver shortly and endeavor to have her marriage with Holmes set aside as being illegal. - How the MndjrettM Heard the News. ROSTON, Nov. 3. The news of the con vlcticpi of Holmes was taken to his parents here by a reporter. Old Mr. Mudgett an sweredt the knock on the door. ' In the par lor his own wife and his convicted son's first wife were sitting. Mrs. Holmes looked haggard and careworn. "I have brought news to you about the result of the trial of Herman. Will you permit me to tell you about it?" eald the reporter. "He is discharged, I suppose," , said Holmes's mother, "but they won't let him be free. They will take him for: something else now," she added. "He Is free, I suppose." said old Mr. Mud gett, "1 wish to ask you, my friends, to pre pare yourselves for the worst," the reporter answered. Holmes's wife became faint. She closed her eyes and lay down on the lounge, seem ingly in great agony. She anticipated the bad news, and when it was broken to 'her she became almost hysterical. Mr. Mudgett simply mumbled to himself, as If absolutely overwhelmed by his great sorrow. Old Mrs. Mudgett at last said: "The newspapers have done us great In justice In this awful ordeal. I want you to say that until Herman left us. some six years ago, he was the cleanest youth in town. We are not responsible for his con duct since." "I think." said Holmes's wife, "he must be out of his mind." "o Cnse Against Holmes nt Chicago. NEW YORK. Nov. 3. The World has se cured the following statements from prose cuting attorneys concerning the .Holmes case: "Indianapolis If 11. 11. Holmes is success ful on appeal for retrial In Philadelphia, about which I express no opinion, steps will be taken to extradite him at once and try him here for the murder of Howard Pietzel. CHARLES S. WILTS! E. "Detroit Police here have enough testi mony to try Holmes for murder. I will ask for his extradition If he escapes punish ment in Pennsylvania. partment, but as soon as tne ueath sen fiscated by Holmes. In a few days they State's Attorney.
Idaho County Free Press · Grangeville, Idaho Territory · 8 November 1895
The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho · 9 November 1895
The Silver Blade · Rathdrum, Idaho · 9 November 1895
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
The clipping reports that Henry H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree in Philadelphia, alongside a brief mention of Governor Altgeld's appeal for Hon. Edward Lane's election in the Eighteenth Illinois congressional district.
The Indianapolis Journal · 4 November 1895 · page 6
der, SO.uOO pounds. Governor Altgeld made a strong appeal for the election of Hon. Edward Lane in tho Eighteenth - Illinois congressional district. Holmes to Hnng. PHILADELPHIA, Pa.. Nov. 2. Henry' H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first
A garbled satirical column presents brief invented first-person remarks attributed to various named public figures on topics including prizefighting, alimony, elections, and foreign atrocities, though OCR damage makes parts unreadable.
The Indianapolis Journal · 4 November 1895 · page 7
Fair Estimate
Pittsburg Chronicle-Telegraph. I make no claim to being a thing of beauty, but who dare deny that 1 am a Jaw forever. Robert Fitzslmmons. I think my nice, new red winter hat will be becoming to my style of beauty. Mgr. Satolll. That San Francisco verdict should not be taken as a precedent. That person Dur Holmes. It may bo in the interest of law and order to stop prize fighting, but how am I to get my $100 a week alimony if gate re I view with some alarm the fact that thirteen States will hold elections on Tues through a graveyard.
See moreSee less
James E. Campbell. I hope I shall not b accused of unwar might let Armenia alone awhile and pay nome attention to atrocities In Texas. Ab Brief Meditations. rant is really a very bad man. Boneyard ceipts are cut off. Mrs. Oil ie Ex-Corbett. day. It is an ominous number, but I be lieve lit whistling, even while trotting rantable interference la other people's af fairs, but 1 really think the great powers dul Hamld II, Sultan.
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · and 1 other paper
H. H. Holmes was found guilty of first-degree murder after the judge's charge favored the prosecution, and he issued a statement denying he had taken human life.
The Topeka State Journal · 4 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES IS CONVrCTED. M order in .the First Degree the Verdict Philadelphia, Nov. 4. H. H. Holmes, the arch-criminal of the pres ent time, accused of at least six murders and countless numbers of other crimes, but never before put on trial for his misdeeds, was found guilty of murder in the first degree, at 9 o'clock Saturday night. He took the verdict calmly, and left the court room as nonchalently as he bad en tered it on any day of his trial, not stares him in the face. Judge Arnold's charge, was against the prisoner on every point.
See moreSee less
In re lation to the story of Holmes' wander ings with Mrs. Pietzel, he said: "It presents the most remarkable picture of the influence of mind over mind that I ever saw. No novel ever writ ten contains such a story as that of the way this man dragged that woman about the country in search of her husband." The theory of the 3efense that Holmes had discovered Pietzel's dead body in the house and had arranged it with a view to making the death ap pear accidental was disposed of by the judge in these woids: "If he were in that house that day his natural in stinct would be to go for the police. He did not do so, but according to his own statement, he dragged the body down a flight of stairs, burned it, and made other preparations with a view to making it appear that death had re sulted from an explosion. After that Miss Yoke tells us of his flight and his nervous condition." Judge Arnold instructed the jury that any other verdict than acquittal or murder in the first degree would be absurd in the face of the evidence. The jury retired at 5:30 o'clock and deliberated until about 8:45 o'clock. Holmes has given out a lengthy statement reviewing the trial, con "Early in my life I was thrown much m the company of an old man, upon whom 1 grew to look almost as an oracle. Often he would say to me: He that seeks sympathy receives rid icule.' Bearing this in mind, and in no sense wishing to appear before the public as a martyr, yet more for the sake of others than myself, I ask that for a time, at least, I be dealt leniently with, for in the name of Almighty God and in the name of those who are near and dear to me, I state that I have not taken human life." of the Jury. withstanding the fact that death cluding as follows:
The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan. · 7 November 1895
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.
A Philadelphia jury took only one ballot to find H. H. Holmes guilty of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel. Holmes showed little emotion as the verdict was read, though he reportedly shuddered briefly before regaining composure.
The Portland Daily Press · 4 November 1895 · page 3
—It May Mot Bo the End. Philadelphia, November 2.—Herman W. Jludgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, was tonight convicted of murder in the flrst degree for the killing of Benjamin F. Pietzel in t is city on September 2, 1894. Tho jury needed but one ballot to reach this decision. The jury retired at 5.45 at the conclusion of Judge Arnold’s charge and tho spectators streamed out into tho corridors and eagerly diseussod what tho verdict would nrobably be. Considerable difference of opinion was found, as many believed the commonwealth had not thoroughly established its caso against Holmes, but the majority wore inclined to believe the jury would convict him.
See moreSee less
At 8.35, word was sent to Judge Arnold that tho jury was coaly to roturn the verdict. When Juage Arnom entered too room more were not nearly as many people present as bad attended the day’s session. The prisoner was brought in and placed in the dock. He was as impassive as evor as he cook his seat. The jury came and took their places and it needed but little skill as a mind reader to know what word the foreman would pronounce. The court ordered Holmes to riso and then in reply to the quostion of the court, the foreman of the jury pronounced the fatal words: “Guilty of murder in the first degree.” The verdict was greeted with silence. The charge of the judge must have foreshadowed what Ins fate would be, hut the word “guilty” fell upon Holmes with stunning force. He made no outcry or exhibited any emotion of any kind. He sat down. While the jury was poiled each man arose to his name and as each pronounced his sentence,
The jury returns a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree against H. H. Holmes, who shows little visible emotion beyond a slight twitching. Judge Arnold sets November 18 for a hearing on the defense's motion for a new trial.
The Portland Daily Press · 4 November 1895 · page 3
—It May Mot Bo the End. Philadelphia, November 2.—Herman W. Jludgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, was tonight convicted of murder in the flrst degree for the killing of Benjamin F. Pietzel in t is city on September 2, 1894. Tho jury needed but one ballot to reach this decision. The jury retired at 5.45 at the conclusion of Judge Arnold’s charge and tho spectators streamed out into tho corridors and eagerly diseussod what tho verdict would nrobably be. Considerable difference of opinion was found, as many believed the commonwealth had not thoroughly established its caso against Holmes, but the majority wore inclined to believe the jury would convict him.
See moreSee less
At 8.35, word was sent to Judge Arnold that tho jury was coaly to roturn the verdict. When Juage Arnom entered too room more were not nearly as many people present as bad attended the day’s session. The prisoner was brought in and placed in the dock. He was as impassive as evor as he cook his seat. The jury came and took their places and it needed but little skill as a mind reader to know what word the foreman would pronounce. The court ordered Holmes to riso and then in reply to the quostion of the court, the foreman of the jury pronounced the fatal words: “Guilty of murder in the first degree.” The verdict was greeted with silence. The charge of the judge must have foreshadowed what Ins fate would be, hut the word “guilty” fell upon Holmes with stunning force. He made no outcry or exhibited any emotion of any kind. He sat down. While the jury was poiled each man arose to his name and as each pronounced his sentence, HOLMES STARED VACANTLY before him. His face was that of a corpse. It was as expressionless as a mask. Only a nervous twitching of the eyelids and the contraction and dilation of the eyos showed that it was a living man that sat in the dock. As the effects of tiio blow began to die away, Holmes slowly re covered, Ho realized that his counsel was making a motion for a new trail. His under lip fell and ho ran his tongue across it, moistening the dryness, and clasping his hands together, he leaned forward to listen to the judge s decision. When Judge Arnold said ho would hear the application for a now trial on Mon dav. November IS, an expression of something like hope broke across his dull
District Attorney Graham gave a two-hour-forty-minute closing argument reviewing the evidence against Holmes, emphasizing the physical evidence that chloroform was forced into Pietzel's stomach after death, refuting the defense's suicide theory. Holmes reportedly listened intently, taking extensive notes throughout the address.
The Portland Daily Press · 4 November 1895 · page 3
HOLMES STARED VACANTLY
the more unimportant, ones and refreshed • _oviiilnnnn I In . Li JO JUIJ B llimuuij -- „ tbo more important testimony Mr. Gra* ham dealt at greater length. He exposed Holmes’ tangle of lies in the many state I ments he made. It was when he came to the testimony given by Mrs. Pietzel that Mr Grabanrpourod out upon the prison er the vials" of his seorn and denuncia tion. Beoeath the district attorney’s bit t - words Holmes shrank a little, and, sinking his head,affected to be busy tak ing notes of Mr. Graham’s words. Mr Graham’s closing argument was a sifting and analytical review of the testi mony which was placed with clearness and skill before tbo jury.
The clipping, which is cut short, reports that the World collected statements from prosecuting attorneys indicating that Holmes would not escape prosecution even if freed on appeal.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 4 November 1895 · page 3
OTHERS WANT HOLMES. He Will Not Escape Even If He Gets Free on Appeal. NEW YORK, Nov. 3.— The World has secured the following statements from s prosecuting attorneys concerning the
A northbound passenger train derailed near Waxahatchie, killing engineer Mike Murphy and injuring 22 people, while convicted murderer H. H. Holmes reportedly passed a quiet day in his cell showing no signs of distress.
The Anaconda Standard · 4 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES IS WELL.
ANOI HER WRECK. atglnevr Eanted sad 3s People seolesely Dallas. Teas. Nov. 3.-News was re oetsed In the city this evening of the wri of the northbound passenger train oa the "Katy" at 11 a. m., about four msiles north of Wazahatchie. H. K. Smith of this city, who was a pas seager on the train, arrived at 7:30 o'clock this evening. He am . "Owing. I suppose, to a spread of ' r. .1s. the engine and four ca's were derailed. There Immediately arose a cry of d's Uresa, mingled with moans, iadleating may of the passengers had been hurt.
See moreSee less
The engineer. Mike Murphy, was kfled, and in all 22 people were in jured. 13 of them more or less seri oumly." HOLMES IS WELL. (a Wil "e Ezerelsed se That He Will %.et Commit Ieleide. Pbhaddphla. Nov. 3.-H. H. Holmes. the convicted murderer of Benjanin Pitsl. went a quiet day in his cell. *This man of deel and healt of stone," as 'tme dtriot attrney described him to *te jury. does not evtnse In the sligAsel any outward algns of breaking down. With death sounaly before him now. be is the same cool and callous Holhues. The prismo agia eions pre vent say one erom interviewing him tofhy. bet a message was sent out halt he snot ial lug ANSI and was lajured.
This fragment reports that a jury deliberated for 13 hours before sending word to the court that they had agreed on a verdict, with Holmes speaking to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker, beforehand.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 4 November 1895 · page 1
HE KILLED PITEZEL
degree.”’ ; %‘or decency sake they talked about the cage for 13 hours. Then word vivvg sent into court that they had agreed. lis was at 8 156 o’clock. It took a half hour to get the court in readiness to receive the ver diet. : Holmes spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker, in the callroom, befo: "‘he was
The clipping recounts how Holmes was tried for insurance conspiracy after Pitezel's death, claimed Pitezel was alive with a substitute corpse used, and describes Detective Geyer's investigation gathering evidence and witnesses for a possible murder charge.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 4 November 1895 · page 1
The insurance company paid the cldis, gut not being satisfied that Pitezel ! 1§ death accidentally, atwpmc: placed detectives on the case. This re#iited in the arrest in Boston of Mudgett, alias Holmes. . The latter was bromght here and was placed on trial, charged with con spiracy to defraud the insurance eompany. Guilty of Consplracy.%%fl Holmes pleaded guilty to this charge, but to combat the more serious charge of murder claimed that Pitezel was still liv ing; that a body was obtained from a New York dissecting room and placed in the building on Callowhill street after burning the skin slightly and throwing a lamp on the floor.
See moreSee less
Holmes claimed that he and Pitezel left the city and subse quently informed Mrs, Pitezel that the body was that of her missing husband, and had her press her claim for the insur ance. Holmes was sent to prison to await sen tence on the conspiracy trial, and District Aftorney Graham started Detective Geyer out to visit Toronto, Chicago and other western cities to endeavor to obtain evi dence against Holmes which would war. rant his being arraigned for murder. De tective Geyer’s success in finding the dead bodies of the children is well” known, and other facts which he gleamed satisfied the districv attorney that Holmes could be convigted here of the murder of Pitezel, Detective Geyer also brought to this city Mrs. Pitezel and others from various parts of the west and Canada to take the stand as witnesses against Holmes.
This damaged clipping jumbles disparate reports—insurgents near Santa Clara burning houses, an exhumed body identified in connection with a life insurance matter tied to Pitezel, and a Times editorial calling Turkish news grave and disquieting—too fragmentary to summarize coherently.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 4 November 1895 · page 1
nople bourse. All the banks in Turkey appealed to the supreme court on the are understood to be still meting all their ground that the Judge erred im a number of his rulings during the trial. Attorney ““I have brought news to you about the from Santa Clara, are in a state of panic. pany carried on Pitezel's life. The ey result of the trial of Herman. Will you The insurgents have burned 24 houses and was exhumed and was linally identifle@by permit me to tell you about it?”’ some of those who lived in them were con The Times says editorially: Turkish news is of a grave and disquieting char acter. Like other things Turkish, td
The Dalles Daily Chronicle · the Dalles, Or. · and 1 other paper
The clipping, followed by unrelated patent-medicine advertisements, describes the courtroom scene as the jury found Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of first-degree murder in the death of Benjamen F. Pitezel, noting his calm demeanor as the verdict was read and recorded.
The Dalles Daily Chronicle · 4 November 1895 · page 1
THE JURY WAS OUT FOUR HOURS
painful, and every heart in the crowded room throbbed. The man who was about to hear ' his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same death like pailor which could grow no deeper on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped behind his back. Once or twice he moistened his lips with his tongue. There was no sign of agitation. Then from the deep-voiced clerk came the awful words : "Jurors, loon upon trie prisoner; pris oner, look upon the jurors. How say you, gentlemen of the jury ; do you find the prisoner at the bar, Herman W.
See moreSee less
Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder "of Benjamen F. Pitezel, or not guilty. The condeming syllables came from the foreman : "Guilty of murder in the first degree." "Hem," uttered Holmes, clearing his throat; but his shrunken form never trembled ; his lips betrayed no quiver ; his marvelous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of' his hands folded behind him. Ihen he sat slowly down, and at the request of counsel the jury was polled. As each name was called. Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The verdict was formally re corded by the court ; the motion for a new trial was made, and, after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to counsel for tne defense because of last Monday's occurrence, when, they with drew from the case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruitless labors. Holmes was taken to his cellroom : a few minutes later the jury was thanked for their attention and labor?, and sent home; the court adjourned, and the most extraordinarv case in the annals of American courts was ended. Dr. J. H. McLean's Liver and Kidney Balm is an unfailing remedy for all dis eases of the Liver, Kidneys or Urinary Organs. It is a certain cure for Dropsy, Diabetes, Bright's Disease, Gravel, Kid ney Weakness. Incontinence of Urine, Bed Wetting in Children, Biliousness, Liver Complaint and Female Troubles. A trial of this great remedy will con vince you of its potency. Price $1.00 per bottle. For sale by Snipes-Kinersly Drug Co. There are so many accidents to live stock whicn cause delay and Iobs to the farmer in his work. In a large number of instances the delay would be but trifling if a remedy was promptly applied. Dr. J. H. McLean's Volcanic Oil Lini ment has for many years been regarded as the farmer a friend. Its heaucer on flesh of domestic animals is immediate and permanent. Price 25c, 50c and $1.00 per bottle. For sale at Snipes-Kinersly Drug Co.
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or. · 6 November 1895
The Evening Herald · Shenandoah, Pa.
A fragmentary clipping mixes local election commentary urging votes for Republican candidates (including Judge Lyon and Steve Middleton), notes that Holmes was found guilty of Pitezel's murder despite some doubt, and includes an advertisement testimonial about a merchant's wife cured of neuralgia by Pain Balm.
The Evening Herald · 4 November 1895 · page 2
morrow. It now looks as if the people will make the board of Directors of the Poor unanimously Republican. Holmes has been found guilty of the murder of Pitezel in the first degree. While almost every one will acknowledge tho man's guilt, yet thcro exists a grave doubt that t)ie commonwealth had proved that ho committed tho crimo beyond a shadow of doubt. Tho jury, nevertheless, were unanimous m their verdict, and the judge's chargo was favorable to tho commonwealth. ArTEit to-morrow our young friend Bechtel can take himself to tho woods and reflect upon his own beauty.
See moreSee less
Tho other fellow will draw the salary. We believe tho justice of tho claim of tho Republicans in asking for minority repre hearty approval at tho hands of tho voters of all political beliefs to-morrow. Judge Lyon's legal attainments aro of n high order, and his fitness for tho position of Orphans' Court judgo has never been questioned by even those who oppose his election. Tho silly reason the latter oll'er in support of tho Dem ocratic nominee is purely partisan, and politics should not enter into tho present, con (est. Judge Lyou now prosidos over tho Orphans' Court, and should be continued in that position, and will if we mistake not the tcmpemiuent of tho voters of this county. Mil. Skveun will continuo to control the Controller's office, if tho people havijasay and to-morrow they'll do tho talking. Rm'UIU.icanh, if you fail to letiiin Judge Lyon upon tho bench you will havo no repre personal grievance it should be vast wide In deference to so momentous a question. Steve Middlkton, the candidate for Poor Director, lias held many positions of trust at tho hands of the people of Gilbwtou, hU home. The opposition aro putting up a strong fUjht againut him, showing that, they reeogniw) his popularity. Steve, however, appears ountluent and says he will be tho next Poor Director. Tho wifo of Mr. Leonard Wells, of East Hrlmfield, Mass., had been suffering from neuralgia for two days, not being able to sleep, or hardly keep still, when Mr. Holdon, the inerclmnt there, sent hera bottle of Cham it a thorough trial. On meeting Mr. Wells the next day he was told that sho was all right, tho pain hail left her within two hour, and tliat the bottle of Pain Balfri'vvns worth fP.OQ f H could not be liad far lew. For sale at 50 cents per bottlo by uruhlor Bros., Druggists. sentation upon tho bench will meet with sentative upon that tribunal. If you have a lierUviu'g Pain IMlm, and asked that she givo
After Judge Arnold set a Nov. 18 hearing on a motion for a new trial and praised defense counsel for their effort despite withdrawing from the case, the jury—which had unanimously voted to convict after one ballot—was discharged, and the condemned man spent the following Sunday quietly in his cell, refusing visitors.
The Scranton Tribune · 4 November 1895 · page 1
sionless. After the effects of the blow began to pass away Holmes slowly recovered. He realized that his counsel was mak ing a motion for a new trKl. His under lip fell and he ran his, tongue over it. Clasping his hands together he leaned forward to listen to tne Judge's decis ion. When Judge Arnold said that he would hear the application for a new trial on Monday, Nov. 18, an expression of something like hope came over his dull face. Turning to the court officers he said In an eager whisper: "Monday, Nov.
See moreSee less
18?" These were the only words he uttered. Judge Arnold then expressed to Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker his appre ciation of their difficult task, and com plimented them on being able to make as good a defence as they did. He Inti mated that their withdrawal from the case was a device of the prisoner. In a manly, honest way, Mr. Rotan gave the court to understand that their withdrawal was no device of their own, but was done from a sincere conviction, because they believed time had not been given to them to prepare their case. Judge Arnold then ordered that the prisoner be removed. By this time Holmes had recovered much of his composure and he walked from the room with a quick, springy step. The Judge thanked the Jury for their atten tion and discharged them, and so ended the trial. The Jury was never In doubt. When they retired from the court room they had supper, and then a brief discussion took place. One ballot, was taken, and every man voted to convict. They con sumed three hours for their retirement from the court room, but they could have found a verdict In fifteen minutes If they had wished to do so. Every one actively identified with the Holmes trial was glad that to-day was Sunday and took advantage to rest and reouperate from the great nervous ten sion under which they had labored for a week. After the ordeal of the trial the quiet monotony of a prison cell was welcome to Holmes and he snent to-day appar ently unconcerned by the death sen tence which hangs over him. The con demned man's appetite takes but little of his attention, lie still maintains his air of Injured Innocence and reads and writes when not absorbed In thought No visitors were allowed to see him to day and Holmes himself strengthened the prison rules by stating that he did not wish to see anybody.
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia on Saturday evening of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pitzel there on September 2, 1894, without calling any defense witnesses.
Alexandria Gazette · 4 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES CONVICTED. H. H. Holmes was convicted in Phil? adelphia on Saturday evening of mur? der in the first degree for the killing of Benjamiu F. Piuzel in that city on September 2,1894. Without having called a single wit? ness to testify in his defense Holmes'
Printed in German, this report states that at 8:51 that evening in Philadelphia, Pa., the jury delivered its verdict in the trial against H. H. Holmes, finding him guilty of murder in the first degree.
Wisconsin Vorwärts · 4 November 1895 · page 1
Holmes schuldig befunden
Philadelbhia, Pa. 2. Nov. Heute Abend 8:51 verkündeten die Geſchworenen in dem Prozeſſe gegen H. HHolmes ihr Urtheil. Es lautet auf Mord im erſten Grade. Holmes ſchntdig beſundtn : Kanada. : Cornwall, Ont. 3. Nov.
The Eden Musée's Chamber of Horrors has unveiled a new wax figure depicting H. H. Holmes behind prison bars, keeping its exhibits current with real crime news. The report notes Holmes was condemned a few days earlier for murder, calling him the greatest criminal in the country.
New-York Tribune · 5 November 1895 · page 3
history. wax disp.ay abreast of contemporaneous The latest movement in this ine was shown by a figure placed on « vhib!tion last evening. Behind the prison bars of a new cell that has been constructed in the Chamber of Horrors sits H. H. Holmes, who was condemned a few days ago for murder, the greatest criminal in the country. - - -> - —
A reproduced letter signed Miss E. A. Pitezel describes staying at the English Hotel in Indianapolis near a monument, mentions Mr. H. leaving on a late train, and asks Mamma to come soon.
The Indianapolis Journal · 5 November 1895 · page 5
PITEZEL'S CHILDREN LETTERS WRITTEN BY THE LITTLE ONES TO THEIR MOTHER
"If you are worse telegraph to the above address." On Oct. 1. ISM, under date of "Indianapo lis, O.," Nellie Pitezel wrote: "Dear Mamma. Ilaby and D. We are all well here. Mr. H. is going on a late, train to-night. He is not here now. I just saw him go by the hotel. He went some place, I don't know where. I think he went to get his ticket. "We are staying in another hotel In In dianapolis. It is a pretty nice one. We came here last night fiom C.
See moreSee less
"I like it here lots better than in C it is quite warm here und I have to wear this warm dress because my clothes ain't ironed. We ate dinner over to the Stubbing Hotel, where Alice stayed, and they knew her, too. We are not staying there. We are at the English H. "We have a room right in front of a mon ument. It is about three times as big as a five-story building, and we saw another monument, and I think It was A. Lincoln's. Come as soon as you can. because I want to see you and baby. too. It is awful nice ter. MISS E. A. PITEZEL.
This damaged German-language clipping briefly mentions H. H. Holmes, described as an alleged mass murderer, alongside an unrelated advertisement praising a pure malt-and-hops beer called 'Münchner.'
Wisconsin Vorwärts · 5 November 1895 · page 4
ſchen H. H. Holmes, des angeblichetn Maſſenmoörders, werden unter den Hauptſehenswürdigleiten ſein. Vlat „Münchner“, ein abjolut ret nes Malz· und Hopfen · Bier, kräftig ——— — — ““““—
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · the Dalles, Or. · and 1 other paper
This single item recounts the jury's return after about ninety minutes' deliberation, Holmes's reaction to his counsel, the granting of a hearing on a new trial for November 18, and the tense courtroom scene as the verdict was delivered.
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 6 November 1895 · page 1
THE JURY WAS OUT FOUR HOURS
gree." But, however atrocious the crime, however fiendish the criminal, it is hard to send a man to the gallows in one min ute's time ; so, for decency's sake, they talked about the case for a seemly period about an hour and a half. Then word was sent into court that they had agreed. This was at 8:15. It took half an hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict'. Holmes spoke to his coun sel, Rotan and Shoemaker, in the cell room because he was immediately taken back to Moyamensing prison.
See moreSee less
To them he said : "I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trial." He would say no more than that. Im mediately after the verdict, the usual ap plication for leave to file a motion fo" a new trial was made. District Attorney Graham did not oppose tne motion, and Judge Arnold set the 18th of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the prepa ration of the defense. Should a new trial be refused, an appeal will be taken to the supreme court, and argument heard at its next sitting in this city, January, 1896. So, even if everything goes against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on earth, from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals. . The verdict was a surprise to many persons, who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt. When they heard it they said: "Well, it was on general principles, and it is(juet as good." That is not the meaning of the law; but in this case everybody agrees that "it is just as well." Theie is no word of pity or sympathy for the condemned man. He is regarded as a menace to society. Up in Gilmanton, N. H., there are two old people, his father and mother. And he has also two brothers, and two sisters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial. When the jury went out, an indefinite receES was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in the building until mid night, if necessary; and if no verdict had been reached by that time, he would come again at ten tomorrow morning. Nobody believed there would be occa sion for this. There were many wagers that the verdict would be In tonight, and more as to its nature. At 8 :40 there was a bustle of moving people in the packed courtroom, and it became known that the jury was coming in. A moment later, Judge Arnold took his seat. Dis trict Attorney Graham and his associates entered the courtroom, and the jury filed solemnly in and took their seats in the box. Then Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. For a moment, there was not a sound. The silence was painful, and every heart in the crowded room throbbed. The man who was about to hear bis doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same death like pailor which could grow no deeper on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped behind his back. Once or twice be moistened his lips with. his tongue. There was no sign of agitation. Then from the deep-voiced clerk came the awful words : '.' Jurors, look upon the prisoner; prie ouer, look upon the jurors. How say you, gentlemen of the jury; do you find the prisoner at the bar, Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benjamen F. Pitezel, or not guilty. . . Tlie condeming syllables came from the foreman : "Guilty of murder in the first degree." Hem," utttred Holmes, clearing hia
The clipping reports that Theodore Durrant was convicted in San Francisco of murdering a young girl in a church belfry, and H. H. Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia of murdering a man over fraudulent insurance transactions, both on first jury ballots and circumstantial evidence, with both men suspected of multiple murders and national notoriety.
Smyrna Times · 6 November 1895 · page 2
Two notable murder trials came to an end last week. One hail occupied over two months of the time of the court in San Francise •, and Theodore Durrani, a young medical student, was convict ed on the first ballot by the jury of the murder of a young girl in the belfry of a church. The other case, tried in Philadelphia, had only lasted five days and H. H. Holmes was convicted on the first ballot cast by the jury of the murder of a man with whom he had had fraudulent insurance transactions.
See moreSee less
Holmes had a knowledge of chemistry and drugs. Both Durrani and Holmes are supposed to have murdered more than one person. Both of the men were convicted on circumstantial evi dence, and both of them had made what may be called a national reputa tion. _
The piece comments on Pingree's plan to have Detroit's poor plant potatoes, approves of a Duke's refusal to attend a church wedding rehearsal as un-American spectacle, and notes that letters from the Pitezel children traveling with Holmes reveal their pathetic efforts to stay contented.
The Indianapolis Journal · 6 November 1895 · page 4
SaSBBSBBaBSMBBBSMSBBaSBBBBBSBSSaBBasSBaBBSBBSaWSaBB Pingree set the poor of Detroit to planting potatoes. Rev. Mr. Milburn would do the same for Indiana's con firmed criminals If he could find a suffi cient number of arable islands not otherwise In use. If the dear good man had only been consulted when the map was made he would have had two good Islands about the premises somewhere for this useful purpose. It Is said the D-ke c Marlborough did not attend the church rehearsal of the wedding In which he i soon to be a conspicuous figure because he regarded It as unbecoming the solemnity of the ceremony.
See moreSee less
There Is some reason In this view of the case. The Idea of making a church wedding a spectacular affair and rehearsing it In advance like a theatrical performance is peculiarly American, and, In some respects, rather calculated to strike an intelligent and cultured foreigner unpleasantly. This Is not the first evidence that the Duke has given since his arrival In this coun try that i he is a modest , and sensible young man. The letters written by the Pitezel children while they were traveling About the country with Holmes throw av stronger light upon the experiences of those poor little unfortunates than any discoveries of the detectives and the conclusions drawn therefrom by the lawyers and the Jury. The efforts of the little girls to be contented while they wandered about the country for reasons they could not understand are pathetically shown In these childish
The clipping, a brief fragment, states that letters written by the Pitezel children during their travels with Holmes shed stronger light on their experiences than other evidence, but the text is cut off before elaborating further.
The Indianapolis Journal · 6 November 1895 · page 4
The letters written by the Pitezel children while they were traveling About the country with Holmes throw av stronger light upon the experiences of those poor little unfortunates than
Printed in German, this report describes the courtroom scene as Holmes, pale and composed, stood before the jury to hear the verdict announced, with his lawyers Rotan and Shoemaker, his reaction, the granting of a hearing for a new trial motion set for the 18th, and public reaction described as surprised but unsympathetic.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 6 November 1895 · page 2
Verbrecher und Verbrechen. Holmes des Mordes schuldig befunden.
doch anstandshalber noch eine anderthalb— stündige Besprechung des Falles abgehalten und dann das Gericht benachrichtigt, daß die Jury sich betreffs eines Wahrspruches ge— einigt habe. Dies war um 15 Minuten nach 8 Uhr. Es dauerte eine halbe Stunde, bis der Gerichtshof bereit war, den Wahrspruch! entgegenzunehmen. Ehe Holmes nach Moyamensing-Gefängnisse abgeführt wurde, hatte er im Zellenraume eine Unterredung mit seinen Vertheidigern Rotan und Shoe— maker. Er sagte denselben: „Ich fühle, daß dies mein Schicksal besiegelt. Es war ein ungerechter Prozeß.“ Das war Alles, was er sagen wollte. Sogleich nach der Verkün— digung des Wahrspruches wurde das übliche Gesuch um die Erlaubniß zur Einreichung eines Antrages auf einen neuen Prozeß ge— stellt.
See moreSee less
Distriktsanwalt Graham erhob kei— nen Einspruch gegen den Antrag. Der Rich—- ter setzte den 18. d. Mts. für die Verhand— lung des Antrages fest. Als Hauptgrund wird Mangel an genügender Vorbereitung für die Vertheidigung angegeben werden. Sollte der Richter einen neuen Prozeß ver— weigern, so wird an das Obergericht appel—- lirt und der Fall in der im Januar nächsten Jahres stattfindenden Sitzung des Gerichtes verhandelt werden. Holmes kann also noch eine Zeit lang auf dieser Welt zubringen, aus der er angeblich so viele seiner Mitmenschen hinausbefördert hat. Der Wahrspruch war für viele Leute, welche nicht glaubten, daß Holmes' Schuld über allen vernünftigen Zweifel hinaus er— wiesen sei, eineUeberraschung, doch ist schließ—- lich Jedermann mit demWahrspruche zufrie—- den und von einer Theilnahme oder gar Mitgefühl für den Verurtheilten ist nichts zu verspüren. Seine Angehörigen in Gilman— ton, N. H., wo die Eltern und zwei Brüder und zwei Schwestern des Mörders wohnen, haben während des Prozesses nichts von sich hören lassen. ; Die meisten Zuhörer im Gerichtssaale er—- warteten bestimmt, daß der Wahrspruch noch am Abend abgegegen werden würde. Um 20 Minuten vor neun Uhr machte sich eine Aufregung im Saale bemertbar, als es hieß, daß die Jury nach dem Saale unterwegs sei. Einen Augenblick später nahm Richter Arnold seinen Sitz ein, DistrictAnwalt Graham und seine Assistenten erschienen und dann schritten die Geschwore— nen in feierlichem Zuge zu ihren Sitzen. Unter tiefer, fast beängstigender Stille wurde dann Holmes -hereingebracht. Aller Augen waren auf ihn gerichtet. Holmes stand ker— zengerade da; sein Gesicht von todesähnlicher Blässe bedeckt. Er blickte fest nach der Jury hinüber, während er seine Hände auf dem Rücken fest zusammengepreßt hatte. Ein—- oder zweimal befeuchtete er seine Lippen mit der Zunge. Sonst war kein Zeichen der Aufregung an ihm zu bemerken. Plötzlich vernahm man die mit tiefer Stimme gesprochenen ver— hängnißvollen Worte des Gerichtsclerts: „Geschworene, blicken Sie auf den Ange— klagten! Angeklagter blicken Sie nach den Geschworenen! Wie sagen Sie, meine Her ren von der Jury, finden Sie den hier stehenden Angeklagten, Herman W. Mudget, alias H. H. Holmes, der Ermordung des Benjamin F. Pitzel schuldig, oder nicht?“ Ohne Zaudern antwortete der Obmann der Jury: „Schuldig des Mordes im ersten Grade!“ :
Printed in German, this fragment reports that Holmes may remain alive longer, since the verdict did not settle his guilt for many who doubted it, though the text breaks off mid-sentence.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 6 November 1895 · page 2
verhandelt werden. Holmes kann also noch eine Zeit lang auf dieser Welt zubringen, aus der er angeblich so viele seiner Mitmenschen hinausbefördert hat. Der Wahrspruch war für viele Leute, welche nicht glaubten, daß Holmes' Schuld
Printed in German, this report describes Holmes's calm demeanor as the jury's verdict was read, the judge's remarks to the defense, courtroom cheering and weeping, and Durrant's mother embracing him as sentencing and a further trial date were set.
Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 6 November 1895 · page 2
Kaltblütigkeit. Alles was von Aufregung an ihm zu bemerken war, war ein etwas krampfhafteres Ineinanderschlingen der auf seinem Rücken ruhenden Hände. Dann setzte er sich nicder und auf Ersuchen ver Vertheidiger wurden dann die Geschwore—- nen zur Abgebung ihres Urtheils aufge fordert. Holmes notirte jeden Ausruf auf dem Ranhde eines Zeitungsblattes, das er in der Hand hatte und die Finger, die den Blei— stift hielten, zitterten nie auch nur im Min— desien. Der Wahrspruch wurde dann förm— lich vom Gerichtshofe prototollirt, der Antrag auf ein neues Verhör wurde gestellt und nach dem Richter Arnold den Vertheidigern sein Bedauern über den Vorfall vom letzten Montag ausgedrückt hatte, wo nämlich die Vertheidiger sich von dem Fulle zurückgezogen und nachdem er ühnen für ihre schwere aber vergebliche Arbeit seine Anerkennung gezollt, wurde Holmes nach seinem Zellenraume und später nach dem Gefängnisse abgeführt.
See moreSee less
Donn wurde die Jury, nachdem ihr für ihre Aufmerksamkeit und für die Anstrengungen, grunde des Gerichtszimmers lauter Beifalls— weinten vor Erregung. Der Gerichtsdiener ; ruf. Männer schrien„Hurrah!“ und Frauen befahl Ruhe, aber es dauerte eine volle Mi— nute und darüber, ehe die Ordnung wieder— hergostellt war. Als Bezirksanwalt Barnes aufstand und verlangte, daß ein Tag für die Vollstreckung des Todesurtheils festgesetzt werden sollte, sagte Richter Murphy, das Ur theil werde nächsten Freitag gesprochen wer— den und es werde dann auch der Tag für die Prozes sirung Durrant's wegen der Ermor—- dung von Minnie Williams bestimmt wer— den. In dem Tumult, welcher auf die Verkün— digung des Wahrspruches folgte, kümmerte ⁊ sich Niemand um Durrant und seine Mut—- ter, ausgenommen die ihnen zunächst Sitzen den. Sobald die letzten Worte des Wahr—- spruches verhallt waren, schien Durrant Miene zu machen, aufzustehen, allein ehe er es thun konnte, schlang seine Mutter unter Wehtklagen ihre Arme um seinen Hals und sank in ihren Stuhl zurück. Der Schmerz
The clipping reports that the jury in the H. H. Holmes case at Philadelphia returned a first-degree murder verdict at 8:51 p.m. Saturday after three hours eleven minutes, followed by a disjointed, incomplete fragment describing a prehistoric forest buried by material from a large volcano.
The Hartford Herald · 6 November 1895 · page 2
Tbo jury in the H. H. Holmes case at Philadelphia returned a verdict of murder in tbo first degree at 8:51 o'clock Saturday evening, after being out three hours and eleven minutes. that is to say, at somo remoto day, geologically speakiug, there grow a great forest, which was covered up by tho ejected material from a great volcano, rivaling iu size Mount Etna, that is known to havo existed somo mi leu to
Printed in Danish, and sitting among other news briefs, this report says a Philadelphia jury found insurance man H. H. Holmes guilty of murder in the first degree for killing Benjamin Pitzel, a verdict reached in one minute though announced after a half-hour wait, with an appeal expected.
Fergus Falls Ugeblad · 6 November 1895 · page 5
tænfer (i bette Orbs boatlige Betyb ning),men han brugte beSuagtet Bibe len flittigt, og oplæste lange Stykket af ben. Om Prester paasiob hzn, at de holdt Folk i Uotbenheb og Forbom. Han var imob 6e almindelige Stri ker, antagelig forbi be vor for fmaa, thi han bebubebe, at ber nu ftulbe blive Opstanb over hele Serben, og at Arbeidernes TrældornStid var om trent forbi. Han talte noget om Gibeon og hanS 300 Manb forat belyfe, at bet iffe altib er Antallet, fom gjør bet, men han beflit en ganfle flem Bommert ber, ibet han sagbe, at Gideon rumste tebe meb Krubt.
See moreSee less
Bibelen fortæller o#, at han alene brugte tomme Kmt. ter sg Fatler, og Historien fortæller, at Krubtet først blev opfundet saaban en 2—3000 Aat efter GibeonS Doge. Han fagbe ogfaa, at bet vat Efau eller selvfølgelig hanS Efterkommere, fom hele Tiden har undertrykt ben store Mængde af Folfet eller Arbeibs klaSsen, men Bibelen lærer, at bo Patriarken Jacob ftulbe velsigne ham, lom bet profetifie Orb, at Efau ftulbe „tjene sin Broder". Taleten talbte Atbeibetne Abra hams Børn. Det er naturligvis ikke faa godt at vibe, hvorlebes han vil forklare bet, men vi focstob bet ialfalb faa, at Atbeibetne er be, ?om cc flikkede for Himlen, menS Prester, Sagførere og lignende, fom han paa stod ikke arbeider, hører Mørkets Ri ge til. Nuvel, dette er jo trøsteltgt for Atbeibetne, men vi tror, det er en noget utryg Sære at stole paa. Efter benn. ManbS Udsagn, flal Arbeiderne tomme til at udoandte til Asien igjen iil Østen som han Theodore Durant, fom var an klaget for at have myrbet te Piget i en Baptistkirke i San Francisco ifom* mer, blev fiste Fredag af Juryen fun den flyldig i Mordet paa ben ene af Pigerne. Blanche Samont. Retten hor ikke behanblet Anklagen for Mor bet paa ben anben myrbebe Pige. Durant er svært foldblodig og erklæ ret, at han er uflylbig. og Sagen vil sanbsynligvis blive appelleret. I Philadelphia har Juryen affegt Dom over den Manb, fom i Bladene omtales fom en „Ertebiævel" af vor Tib, nemlig Asjurancefoinbteren H. H. Holmes, fom fornben Bebtageri erne nu ogfaa er beflylbt for at have myrbet mange Mennefter for at faa fat i deres SivSaSfutance. Den før fte Anklage gik ud paa, at han havde myrdet Benjamin Pitzel i Philadel phia. Denne Sag paabegyndtes for rige Mondag, og gforhanblingeme ba rebe til Sørdag. Paa et Minut var Juryen enig om Dommen, der lød: „Skyldig i Mord i første Grad." For FormenS Skyld ventede Juryen en halv Time, før den indgav fin Kjen delfe. Holmes' Sag vil ogfaa blive appelleret. A. C. Greenlee. Bedste SlagS kunstige Tcender $10. Tän der udtr-ekkeS uden Smerte. Alt Arbeide garanteres at vare af bedste Slags. Kontor over Fergus Falls Rational Bank. ... 3. C. Knoff anbefaler
The garbled clipping reports that H. H. Holmes was found guilty of murder in the first degree in the killing of B. F. Pietzel, with a confused reference to an Assistant Postmaster Lambert.
Morris Tribune · 6 November 1895 · page 1
killing of B. F. Pietzel. The verdict was murder in the first degree. H. H. Holmes was found guilty of the Assistant Postmaster Lambert of
The clipping, a garbled fragment, reports that H. H. Holmes was found guilty of murder in the first degree in the killing of B. F. Pietzel, with a confused mention of an Assistant Postmaster Lambert.
Morris Tribune · 6 November 1895 · page 1
CRIMINAL EVENTS
killing of B. F. Pietzel. The verdict was murder in the first degree. H. H. Holmes was found guilty of the Assistant Postmaster Lambert of
This badly garbled clipping is too damaged to make out clearly, but it contains fragmentary references to McKinley, bulldogs, a sentencing on an unspecified Friday, and a person named Holmes.
Morris Tribune · 6 November 1895 · page 4
McKinley will strain every nerve to blow. All sportive bulldogs hu comes out us usual saying the men will exist as long as man's, nature is will be sentenced next Fi ktay, Holmes
A damaged clipping notes sentencing set for next Friday, a hearing for Holmes on the 18th regarding a new trial argument, and mentions Hayward's appeal was argued before the (text cuts off).
Morris Tribune · 6 November 1895 · page 4
will be sentenced next Fi ktay, Holmes will be heard the 18th. tf this monti oii au argument for a mw trialHay ward's appeal was Argued before the
Amid a column of miscellaneous humorous and news items, a short line reports that the trial of H. H. Holmes has concluded with the jury convicting him of the murder of Pitezel. No further detail is given.
The Ely Miner · 6 November 1895 · page 4
The trial of H. H. Holmes has passed and the jury have convicted him of the murder of Pitzel. H,. H. Holmes, H. Hayward, hanging and h—l hits hard.
The clipping reports the Society of the Army of the Tennessee will seek a $100,000 congressional appropriation for a Grant monument in Washington, and notes that in the Holmes trial in Philadelphia, Mrs. Carrie Pitzel testified about her husband, with the account cut off incomplete.
The Ely Miner · 6 November 1895 · page 6
SIOO,OOO. A monument to Gen. Grant at Wash ington, D. C., is an object that the So ciety of the Army of the Tennessee will ask the next congress to make an appro priation for. In the Holmes trial in Philadelphia Mrs. Carrie Pitzel told how her hus
The item reports Princeton's 12-4 football win over Harvard's second team, a murder conviction in Philadelphia, a planned divorce suit by a brewer's son, a fatal Cleveland fire, yellow fever deaths in Havana, several destructive fires in the US and Canada, a fatal boxing match in Massachusetts, a $3,000,000 Rockefeller gift to the University of Chicago, and a four-month debt moratorium ordered by the Turkish sultan.
The Ely Miner · 6 November 1895 · page 6
LATERThe Princeton football team defeated Harvard, the 2d, at Princeton, N. J., by a score of 12 to 4. Henry W. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree at Philadel phia, Pa., for killing Benjamin F. Peit zeL The verdict had but little appar ent effect upon the prisoner. ■ Gus Pabst, son of the Milwaukee brewer, has decided to sue for a divorce from his wife, Margaret Mathei Pabst, who was a well known actress, and who horsewhipped her husband a short time ago on the streets of Milwaukee.
See moreSee less
Mrs. Helen Landorf was burned to death atCleveland, 0., the 3d. Her hus band and children barely escaped. The cause of the fire is not definitely known. Yellow fever has appeared at Ha vana, Cuba. There were 43 deaths in ten days. Fire destroyed all the business places but one at Arcadia, 10., the 3d. The loss is over $55,000. The village of Hall, Canada, was wiped out by fire the 3d. Fire destroyed the sweat shop of Weil & Meyer, New York, the 3d. Jacob Shaptro, Isaac Person and Mor ris Disschover were killed. Ralph W. Eldridge was killed the 2d during a boxing match with another young man named John Peterson at the Casino club Natick, Mass., Peter son was arrested, but those who saw the affair claim it was an accident. - " John D. Rockefeller, the 2d gave $3,000,000 to the university of Chicago. He had already given the institution $4,600,000, and the' additional endow ment announced will swell the total amount to $7,600,000. The sultan of Turkey has ordered a four months’ internal moratorium, i. e., a government decree granting ex tension of all debts, private and public, for four months. The sanitarium at Green Springs, 0., burned the 3d. Loss, $40,000.
The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudgett, known as H. H. Holmes, went on trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel after his lawyers withdrew when a postponement was refused, leaving Holmes to conduct his own defense with notable shrewdness.
The Ely Miner · 6 November 1895 · page 6
READY FOR THE JURY.
Trial of the Alleged Multi-Murderer in Mudgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, the self-confessed life insurance swin dler, and the alleged multi-murderer, whose supposed crimes have been a topic for general discussion the past several months, was placed on trial Monday morning in the court of oyer and terminer on the charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pitzel. with the opening of court had been concluded, the defense asked for a postponement of the case for 60 days. This was refused, and the lawyers of the defense withdrew, notwithstanding the court’s warning that they made themselves liable to disbarment.
See moreSee less
Holmes refused to accept other coun sel, and proceeded to conduct his own case. The questions he put to the jur ors as they came up showed great shrewdness. Holmes also showed much skill in his cross-examinations in Tuesday’s sessions. However, he stated to the court Tuesday evening that Philadelphia—Resume of Proceedings —Defense Think State’s Case Is Weak. Philadelphia, Oct. 29.—Herman W. After the formalities in connection
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin Pitezel, remains cool and callous in Philadelphia's Moyamensing prison, with extra guards placed to prevent suicide until his death sentence is pronounced and he is moved to murderers' row.
The Greenville Times · 6 November 1895 · page 1
PITEZEL'S MURDERER
Holmes Coot and Confident, Ills Convle PuiLAnKf.ritiA, Nor. 4 II. II, Holmes, convicted of the murder of Benjamin 1'ltezol, does not evince any outward signs of breaking down. With denth actually before him now, ho Is the same cool and callous Holmes. Extra care has been taken to forestall any attempt to commit sui on his cell and will remain there for the present He is still in the untried department of the Moyamensing prison, but as soon as the death sen tence hi pronounced he will be taken to a cell In ' murderers' row." PITEZEL'S MURDERER. tlon Notwithstanding. cide. A tlon bio guard has been placed
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · Mifflintown, Pa.
A Philadelphia jury took twenty minutes to convict Herman Mudgett alias H. H. Holmes of murdering his partner Benjamin Pietzel for $10,000 insurance, after also cheating Pietzel's wife and killing two of the Pietzel children.
Juniata Sentinel and Republican · 6 November 1895 · page 3
Herman Mudgett alias H. H Holmes was found guilty in 20 min ntes by a Philadelphia jury after the cose was given them last Saturday of murdering Benjamin r . Pietzel for $10,000 insurance. Holmes and Pietzel were partners in swindling life insurance companies, and when the gamij got scarce, Holmes murder ed Pietze!, cheated Pietzel's wife of her share of tho insurance, excepting $500, and then to get rid of two of the Pietzal children, murdered them. Holmes is a fiend in hu
A Philadelphia dispatch reports that H. H. Holmes was convicted of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel in that city on Sept. 2, 1894, with the jury needing only one ballot to decide.
The Manning Times · 6 November 1895 · page 3
Holmes Was convicted. PHILAnELPHIA. Nov. 5.-H. H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first de gree for kiming Benjamin F. Pietzel in this city on Sept. 2, 1894. The jury needd but one ballot to reach this de cision. _ _ _ _ French Journalist Dead.
The clipping recounts how an insurance company paid out before a tip from a jailed train robber exposed a conspiracy involving Holmes, leading to his arrest, conflicting confessions to multiple crimes, and the opening of his trial before Judge Arnold after a continuance was denied.
The Manning Times · 6 November 1895 · page 3
HE IS CONDUCTING HIS OWN CASE
ter of the dead man. With this une guivocal testimony the insurance com pany paid the money. Here the first stage of the extraordinary affair came to a close. The second opened some time after ward in a manner smacking strongly of the dime novel. Marion C.. Hedspeth, the notorious train robber, in jail in St. Louis, Mo., one day made a remark that Holmes, while in an adjonig cell, had conspired with Pietzel and Howe to swind~e a Philadelphia insurance com pany by substituting a body supposed to be that of Pietzel.
See moreSee less
Detectives took up this clue and worked for weeks but not a trace could be found of Pietzel, Mrs. Pietzel or the .children. Holmes, however, was arrested on Nov. 17, in Boston. He was made to write a decoy letter to Mrs. Pietzel, in-I ducing her to come to Boston, where she was arrested, and tgher they were brought to Philadlha The womnan was subsequently rlae, but has since been under the surveillance of the po lice. Holmes has been confined in Moy amensng prison dnd at intervals, from that time to the present, has made many and conflicting explanations of every affair with whiceh his name has been as sociated. By his own confession he has been implicated, directly or indirectly, in three deliberate murders, the disap pearance and possible murder of three children, bigamy, many conspiracies, (to one of which he has already pleaded guilty in court) and, in fact, almost every crime in the calendar. Holmes has proved himself to be a man of unlimited nerve, e~ of manner, eloquent of seech, refinedin appear ance, self conddent and ambitious. Onl enough people were admitted to well the courtroom without uncom fortably crowding it. Proniptly at 10 o'clock Holmes was brought into court and placed in the dock. Mr. Shoemaker asked for a contin uance of the case, but it was refused. Mfr. Rotan, .of the defense presented the plea for a respite, but it was over ruled by Judge Arnold and the trial pro ceeded. A. K. Ward In Honduras.
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, defending himself after his counsel withdrew, went on trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, recounting the discovery of a burned corpse identified as B. F. Perry in a Callowhill street building.
The Manning Times · 6 November 1895 · page 3
HE IS 0ONDUOTING HIS OWN OASE. Holmes, who according to his own re markable confessions. stands at the head Pietzel. Arraigned against him as the Attorney George S. Graham and his A sensation was created by counsel for Holmes is conducting his own case. bench. So many aliases have been worn by the man on trial during the half a dozen of the big cities of this wherever men can read. Wild and weird as is the confessional sto of his After an Ineffectual Attenapt to Have the Hearing Postponed. Counsel For the De fense Withdrew-A Story of the Crime For Which Holmes Is Being Tried-HIS lany Offense.
See moreSee less
PHrrADELPHA, Oct. 29. - H. H. of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial in the court of oyer and termi ner for the murder of Benjamin F. commonwet&h's prosecutors are District special assistant, Thomas W. Barlow. the prisoner withdrawing from the case after they had made an ineffectual at tempt to secure a postponement. Judge Michael Arfiold is upon the. oourse of his spectacular career that his baptisilial name, Herman Mudgetts, has almost been lost sight of. Not so with his manifold exploits in country, which have been marveled at life, in which he accuses himse of of fenses which would lonsince have given a less skilled crimina his quietus. Holmes has been careful to shift the main responsibility for the various mur der with which he admits having been connected, to other shoulders. Thus, during the 88 years of a life de voted almost entirely to law breaking, this is his first experience as a felon on trial for his life. The authorities have recognized that this is no common crin inal, but one who might be called a tech nical and most expert artist in crime. It is, therefore, their determination in the event of his conviction for a capital offense, to "railroad" him to the gal lows. More than a year having passed since the discovery of the crime for which Holmes is now on trial, and so mian conflicting tales having since been told, each outdoing the other - in weirdness and atrocity, 4 rehearsal of the facts of this chapter of the story is relevant. On Sept. 3, 1894, the corpse of a man was found in the second story of a ram shackle building at 1,516 Callowhill treet, in this city. The dead man had been known as B. F. Perry. The body was lying on the floor and by its side was a pipe partly filled with tobacco. The face was blackened and blistered as if from bums, and nearby lay a broken bottle, which ha oontain ed benzine. From a ces, an ex losion had occurred while the man was ting his pipe. Some small dro f blood on the floor were credited to slit wounds on his neck The police believ ed the afair *as an acoident, and, no ne for a moment entertaiied the theo ry of murder. Among the effects found in the room were several letters from Perry's wife in St. Louis, the signatures to which had been torn off. To the .neighbors Perry
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's murder trial concluded swiftly after Mrs. Peitzel and Holmes's alleged wife testified against him, and with no defense testimony offered, the jury returned a guilty verdict.
Yorkville Enquirer · 6 November 1895 · page 2
aud on that day also, the time for trying the case of the murder of Minnie Williams. ? The trial of H. H. Holmes, in "PViilfwlolntiin tViA mnnv t.imps murder. er, did not last for several weeks as was expected. It was disposed of in short order. Mrs. Peitzel, widow of the murdered man and mother of the murdered children, gave testimony that poiuted very clearly to Holmes as the murderer. Holmes's alleged wife went back on him and gave testimony that showed up for him most darkly. After the evidence of the prosecution was all in, Holmes attorneys decided that it might be a good idea to bank their hopes on a case of "not proven," and they put up no testimony.
See moreSee less
The jury remained out only a short time aud returned with a verdict of guilty. the legislature.
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, tried in Philadelphia for the murder of Pietzel, was found guilty of murder in the first degree and is also charged with murdering Pietzel's children.
Staunton Spectator · 6 November 1895 · page 2
HH. Holmes guilty.—H. H.Holmes, the notorious swindler and murderer, who was tried in Philadelphia for the murder of Pietzel, was found guilty of murder in the flrst degree. He is also charged with the murder of Pietzel's children. ♦- • . ' —' —
This damaged German-language clipping mentions items related to the alleged mass murderer H. H. Holmes as planned attractions, and separately references Keely's invention and a withdrawal of involvement, but the text is too fragmentary to summarize further.
Wisconsin Vorwärts · 6 November 1895 · page 4
ſchen H. H. Holmes, des angeblichen Maſſenmörders, werden unter den Hauptſehenswürdigleiten ſein. —— — Keeiy's Erſindung. John Jacob Aſter hat allen Anth~il New Yortk,s. Nov.
H. H. Holmes went on trial for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel after his attorneys' request for a continuance was denied and they withdrew, leaving Holmes to conduct his own defense and plead not guilty.
Randolph Enterprise · 6 November 1895 · page 1
Holmes Will Conduct His Own Defense Without an Attorney
Hl* Attorney* On Bala, BdM a Csa-: UaoaaU Threw Cp Che C—~*h« • ii Story of the CvhMi ' •? Herman W. Mudgett, betted known as H. H. Holmes, the seUE confessed life insurance swindler, and the alleged multi-murderer, whose supposed crimes have been a topic for discussion during the past several months, was placed op trial Monday morning in the court Of oyer and terminer for murdering Benjamin Feitzel. * T“ - The common wealth was represented by District Attorney George S. Graham and Assistant District Attorney Thomas W. Ilarlow.
See moreSee less
When the trial was. entiled, counsel for the defense asked for a continuance for sixty days on the ground that they warp not prepared to go on. Judge Ar* nold overruled the motion, and t lien the defendant's lawyers, W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Kotaa withdrew. The case was then ft. * Humed, Holmes conducting his ovs defense. In addition to the mnr* der of Pietzel, the prisoner Is alia, accused of the murder at Torontti ? Out, of Peitzel's two young daugh t«r«, Alioe and Nellie, of the mnr* der at Irvington, Indiana, of the .voung son, Howard Peitzel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes Oil* tie at Chicago. 4 benjamin P. Pletzel’s body wiris found in a house at 1316 Oallowhlll street, on September 3, 1894. It was supposed he had been acel* dently burnt to death, bat a claim for 110,000 insurance by Jeptha Tf. Howe, of St. Louis, started an in* vestigation which resulted fit ■ Holmes being accused of Pietsel's murder for the purpose of obtain* ing the insurance money. Detec tive Ueyer wont out to visitToron* to, Chicago and other western cities to endeavor to obtain evidence against Holmes which would war* rant his being arraigned for the murder. Mr. Oeyer’s snocess in finding the dead bodies of the chil dren is well known and other facts which he gleaned satisfied Attorney Graham that Holmes could ’to* tried here for the murder of Pietseli*' Mr. Geycr also brought to Phila delphia Mrs. Fietzel and others from various parts of the west and t Canada to take stand as witnesses against Holmes. Holmes plead “not guilty” to the indictment in the fom roles which is in keeping with his edn
A garbled Philadelphia dispatch dated Nov. 4 reports that H. H. Holmes, alias Herman W. Mudgett, was found guilty of first-degree murder in the killing of Benjamin F. Pitezel after the jury deliberated and returned its verdict, with his attorneys then moving for a new trial.
Connecticut Western News · 7 November 1895 · page 4
HOLMES FOUND GUILTY.
He Moat Sugar tha Pth .ranalty For the Jury in the Holmes ease was prompt and not unexpected, thonsrh tha nmam. tlon bad not made as strong a case as was anticipated at tne opening of the trial. H. H. Holmes was oonvlotea of murder In the first degree for the killing of Benja deliberation at-6:40 p. m., and at 8:16 the jurors returned with their verdict his doom pronounced stood erect in thr dock, the same deathlike -pallor, which eould grow no deeper, on his faoe. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped behind his back.
See moreSee less
Once or twloe he moistened, hi lips with his tongue. There was no other slim nf .u. Then from the deep voiced court clerk came tne awrui words: oner, look upon the jurors. Now, say you gentlemen of the. Jury, do you find the prisoner at the baa, Herman W. Mud srett alias H. H. Holmaa imtitw i murder of Benjamin F. Pltezel or not guilty?" ly from the foreman: throat but his shrunken form, never tremuiou; nis ups Deirayeo noqulTer; his mar was only a tiarhtar olaannf tha han m ed behind him. request Of counsel tha Inra tarua rvnllw that is, each of the 12 men separately lis with the flndincr. As AAlh mm. wa oalled Holmes wrote It on the margin of a newspaper In his hand, and the fingers holdlnethe pencil never shook. The ver (or a new trial. pose the motion, and Judge Arnold fixed HOLMES FOUND GUILTY. too Mardor of fit sal. Philadelphia, Nov. 4. The verdict of min F. Pltezel. The jury retired from the courtroom (or The man who was now about to hear - - v- -a.vu,uu. "Jurors, look nnon tha m-iannui ri. The condemning? rrll&hlM nam nnmn uuiity of murder In the first degree." "Hem !" mntterad Rnlm li. - v.v.iuk J velous nerve had not forsakan him t Then he slowly sat down, and at the tened to the clerk's query and responded dict was formally received by the oourt A motion was made by his attorneys Dlstrlot Attorner Rrah am iVlA nn ui una monw lor a hearing. -
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Among a column of news briefs, this report says Mr. Graham produced a note Mrs. Pitezel identified as one Holmes used to take $5,000 from her at a St. Louis bank, with Mr. Samuels describing the note's handwriting and testimony that a man called H. M. Pratt, acting for Benton T. Lyman, tried to mortgage a Fort Worth building for a $16,000 loan using a note dated May 16, 1894.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 7 November 1895 · page 1
THE HOLMES TRIAL.
preside. Cyrus D. Foss. Bishop Henry White Warron born in Williamsburg, Hampshire county, Mass.. January 4th, 1831. Ho was graduated at Wesleyan University in 1853, taught natural scionco for two became a minister of and in 18 "tho Methodist Episcopal Church in .the New England Conference. F years he tilled posts in Boston, Worces ter, Lynn, Westfield, Cumbridgcport and Charlestown. In 18(51-2 he w of tho Massachusetts 11« of Representatives, lie w the Arch Street Methodist Episcopal Church, Philadelphia, in 18i1-4 anil again in 1877-HU. In 1881 1881 he w elected by the Philadelphia conference a delegate to the gonerul conference that uuti, whe elected bishop.
See moreSee less
He he wi received tho degree f D. D. fron Dickinson College i 1872. Bisho] preacher, hi« V toil itoristics being a good chief chi young, clean-shaven man, with a twinkling oyo and tho most perfect self-possession. He spoke quickly and sharply and invariably referred to "tho individual." This Holmes auiused Holmes, who smiled broadly whenever tho term was used. Mr. Graham produced the noto iden tified by Mrs. Pitezel yesterday as tho Holmes pretended to pay at the St. Ixiuie bank, and for which purpose he took 85,000 from her. Mr. Samuels said tho body of tho noto handwirting. In the latter part of pastor of April or early in May, 185)4, he said, there was in Fort Worth, a man known H. M. Pratt, it was "this indi vidual." Ho w *oing the tiou of a three-story strueturo as agent for Benton T. Lyman, the supposed Cinuin » to tho witness ami nier. Pratt e tried to negotiate a loan of 81(5,000 by mortgaging tho property, and after some transactions tho noto was drawn up and signed "Bouton T. Lyman." It was dated May 16th, 185)4. Subse in his
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A damaged clipping mixes a notice about a local baseball match at Union street grounds with fragmentary testimony from a Philadelphia trial involving a prisoner and a person referred to as Holmes.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 7 November 1895 · page 1
Rivorview grounds. Their instructors »n and Rice. In the future L all games will commence at 3.30o'clock. Tho playing of tin» beal team de serves bettor patronage than it has been receiving. Warren and A. C. S. N. will play the Union street grounds next Saturday afternoou. Tho two to played and tho locals wo although tho opp* *nts playoil well, but sinco their i ' defeat here new tnato rial has boo »cured and the olovou has boon strengthened considerably. ni form Alcorn. I remained thoro «h long in Philadelphia, four weeks.
See moreSee less
I Tho prisoner w in tho copying busi ness, looking after leases, deoils," &u. " She said ho had a culler ing of September 1st, whom Holmes B. F. Pitezel. id it w Holmes conducted tho er« recently tion of his wifo for awhile, and thon victorious. told the Court that ho would reserve what other questions ho had until ho called tho witness directly for tho defence. Philadelphia, 1 »a., Nov. 1.—Tho of the 11 trial romiudB I * 1 "- 1 tho e
Herman Mudgett, known as H. H. Holmes, was convicted of first-degree murder in Philadelphia for killing Benjamin F. Pitezel in September 1894; the jury deliberated only three hours. His counsel has filed a motion for a new trial, and Holmes is suspected of at least eight other murders.
The National Tribune · 7 November 1895 · page 8
South was wrong. Ho reviewed tho question in a semi-judicial and historical way, defend ing Gov. Woodbury. - Hoi in s a. Murderer. Herman Mudgctt, usually known as H. H. Holmes, ami possessed of many other aliases,
The Weiser Signal · Weiser, Idaho · and 3 other papers
A Philadelphia jury quickly found Henry H. Holmes guilty of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel, with a new trial hearing set for later in the month and no sympathy expressed for the condemned man.
The Weiser Signal · 7 November 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
HOLMES IS GUILTY
One Minute's Deliberation Pronounced His Doom.
See moreSee less
WERE UNANIMOUS FOR DEATH
The Man of Iron Nerve Stood Up to Hear the Awful Sentence Without a Quiver.
Philadelphia, Nov. 2.—Henry H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree at 8:51 tonight for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel.
The jury retired to deliberate at 5:30 o'clock this afternoon. According to one of their number, they had reached their verdict before the doors of their room closed upon them. For hunger's sake they ate their supper first. Then they took a ballot and without hesitation every man of the 12 answered "guilty of murder in the first degree." But, however atrocious the crime, however fiendish the criminal, it is hard to send a man to the gallows in one minute's time. So, for decency sake, they talked about the case for a seemingly period, about an hour and a half. Then word was sent into court that they had agreed. It took half an hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict. Holmes spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker in the cell room, before he was taken back to the prison. He said: "I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trail." He would say no more than that.
Immediately after the verdict the usual application for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. District Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion and Judge Arnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation for the defense. Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the supreme court and arguments heard at its next sitting in this city in January, 1896. So, even if everything goes against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on the earth, from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals.
The verdict was a surprise to many persons who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt.
There was no word of sympathy for the condemned felon. He is regarded as a menace to society. Up in Gilmanton, N. H., there are two old people, his father and mother, and he has also two brothers and two sisters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial.
A MAN OF IRON NERVE.
When the jury went out an indefinite recess was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in the building until midnight if necessary, and if no verdict had been reached by that time he would come to court at 10 o'clock tomorrow morning. There were many wagers that the verdict would be in tonight, and more as to its nature. At 20 minutes of 9 there was a bustle of moving people in the packed courtroom and it became known that the jury was coming in. A moment later Judge Arnold took his seat. District Attorney Graham and his associates entered, and the jury filed solemnly in and took their seats in the box. Then Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. The silence was literally painful, and every heart in that crowded room throbbed.
The man who was about to hear his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same death-like pallor which could grow no deeper on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped behind his back. Then from the deep-voiced clerk came the awful words: "Jurors, look upon the prisoner; prisoner, look upon the jurors. How say you, gentlemen of the jury? Do you find the prisoner at the bar, Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, or not guilty?"
The condemning syllables came from the foreman: "Guilty of murder in the first degree."
"Ahem!" uttered Holmes, clearing his throat, but his shrunken form never trembled, his lips betrayed no quiver, his marvelous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of his hands folded behind him. Then he slowly sat down, and at the request of his counsel the jury was polled. As each name was called Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The verdict was formally recorded by the court. The motion for a new trial was made, and after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to counsel for the defense because of last Monday's occurrence, when they withdrew from the case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruitless labor, Holmes was taken to his cell room. A few minutes later the jury were thanked for their attention and labors and sent home, the court adjourned, and the most extraordinary case in the annals of American courts was ended.
EVENTS OF THE LAST DAY.
The last day was uneventful except for the last tragic scene. District Attorney Graham opened the session with his address to the jury. He was followed by Mr. Rotan, who, in his speech, presented the only form of defense—that Pietzel had committed suicide—resting on the assumption that the commonwealth had not made out a case beyond a reasonable doubt. Judge Arnold charged the jury for more than an hour. The district attorney reviewed the evidence in detail. Beginning with the question of identity of the corpse found in the Callowhill street house, he went over the testimony of each witness, who positively said that it was the body of Pietzel. Leading up to the motive of the murder, Mr. Graham rehearsed in minute details Holmes' every transaction in connection with Pietzel's murder, tracing his movements from place to place and drawing out every little circumstance that weighed against the prisoner with infinite clearness and force.
When he came to the testimony of Mrs. Pietzel, he told the jury that never in his official experience had he heard such a tale as that told in the broken sentences of that despairing, hopeless woman, whom he had kept flitting from place to place in the vain hope of meeting her husband, and all the while he was carrying with him three separate detachments—Mrs. Pietzel, Miss Yorke and the children—all within four blocks of each other, almost traveling together under Holmes' leading strings, and yet each party ignorant of the presence of the other two.
In conclusion Mr. Graham said he desired the jury to consider only the evidence connected with the murder of Pietzel in the Callowhill street house and nothing else.
THE TRIAL.
When court opened today at 10 o'clock for arguments in the Holmes case, Mr. Rotan, junior counsel for the defense, announced that his colleague, Shoemaker, was suffering from complete nervous prostration and was under the care of a physician. He called this to the attention of the court in view of the point of law regarding the commonwealth's right to make the closing address to the jury when the defense presented no evidence. Graham ended the question by offering to waive his right to the last speech, and there will be but one address on each side, instead of two by the prosecution. District Attorney Graham began his address at 10:55 o'clock. He said: "The commonwealth of Pennsylvania is the prosecutor of this case and it asks no victim. If you are satisfied, when we have done, that this prisoner did not commit the crime, you must acquit him. The commonwealth is bound to prove its case from the initial step down to the last syllable of the sentence. The commonwealth has done so. One by one we established link by link, making the chain complete."
The district attorney reviewed the evidence in detail. The condition of the body, he contended, medical testimony had proved could not be produced except by chloroform.
Graham's address, which was confined for the most part to review of the details of evidence, lasted two hours and a half. Holmes nervously shifted in his seat as the thunderous tones of the prosecutor rang out. At the conclusion of his address a recess was taken until 2:30 p. m.
The defense then spoke until 5:30, when the case was given to the jury.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex. · 7 November 1895
Cottonwood Report · Cottonwood, Idaho · 8 November 1895
Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash. · 9 November 1895
The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan.
H. H. Holmes was found guilty of first-degree murder at 9 o'clock Saturday night, taking the verdict calmly as he had the whole trial. Judge Arnold's charge to the jury had gone against Holmes on every point, including the story of his travels with Mrs. Pietzel.
The Globe-Republican · 7 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES IS CONVICTED. Murder in the First Degree the Verdict of the Jury. Philadelphia, Nov. 4. H. H. Holmes, the arch-criminal of the pres ent time, accused of at least six murders and countless numbers of
A brief, fragmentary clipping from Philadelphia reports that H. H. Holmes, accused of at least six murders, was found guilty of murder in the first degree by the jury, though the text is cut off and incomplete.
Hutchinson Gazette · 7 November 1895 · page 6
GUILTY OF MURDER. HOLMES AND DURRANT MUST HANG.
HOLMES IS CONVICTED. Murder in the First Degree the Verdict Philadelphia, Nov. 5. II. H. Holmes, the arch-criminal of the pres ent time, accused of at least six of the Jury.
The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudgett, known as H. H. Holmes, was convicted on one jury ballot of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel in Philadelphia on September 2, 1891, with Holmes showing no reaction as the verdict was read.
Crittenden Press · 7 November 1895 · page 2
Philadelphia Nov 2 Herman W Mudgett or as he is tatter known II II Holmes was to night convicted o murder of in tho first degree for kil ling Benjamin F Piethel in this city on September 2 1891 The jury needed but one ballot to roach this decision The jury retired at 645 at the con clusion of Judge Arnolds charge After tho retirement of the jury from the court room the spectators streamed out into tne cornucra and eagerly dis cussed what the verdict would probably be At 845 word was sent to Judge Arnold that the jury was ready to return the verdict The prisoner was brought in and placed in the dock He was as impassive as ever as ho took his seat The court Ordered Holmes to arise and then in reply to tho question of the court the forman of the jury pronounced tho words Guilty of murder in the first degree The verdict was greeted with abso lute silence The chargo of the judge must have foreshadowed what his fate would be but the wunl guilty fell Holmes with stunning force He made no outcry or exhibition of emtiou of any kind The blow was too stunning for noisy outbreak He sat down and while the jury was pol led each man answered to his name and aa each pronounced his sentence Holms stand vaeanUr belbte kirn HiefaMwatUlaf
The Polish-language article reports on the sensational Philadelphia trial of H. H. Holmes for the murder of Pitzel, describing his alleged insurance-fraud murders in Chicago and elsewhere, the $25,000 trial costs, and his initial self-representation before his lawyers resumed his defense.
Wiarus · 7 November 1895 · page 5
H. H. HOliHEH Wszystkie gazety amery kańskie całe szpalty i stronice podają o toczącym się obecnie w naszem mieście procesie lekarza H. H. Holmesa oszuztwo. Natłok publiczności w sądzie przysięgłych jest niesłychany a reporterów zjechało się z całego świata wielka liczba. H. H. Holmes, który i pod innemi przybraaemi nazwiska mi w rozmaitych miastach Stanów Zjednoczonych i Ka nady figurował, jest to zbrod niarz nad zbrodniarzami. Były student medyczny wziął się do szczególniejszego sposobu ro bienia pieniędzy i tak zawiązywał on znajomości z rozmaitemi osobami i namawiał je, aby się dawały zabezpieczać na życie na wysokie sumy w kompaniach asekuracyjnych, po niejakim czasie mordował zabezpieczone osoby, trupy ich pałił, a w ii miejsce podsta wiał inne trupy i ściągał pie niądze assekuracyjne.
See moreSee less
W ten posób,o ile wiadomo dotychczas, wyprawił na tamten świat 7 osób, a ile ofiar padło z ręki, o których sądy nie wie dzą, któż dłużyć zdoła. W Chicago łotr ten w swoim domu w piwnicy miał urzą dzony umyślnie w tym celu piec do palenia znłok pomor dowanych przez siebie cfiar. Proces, który się obecnie toczy, ma na celu udowodnie nie morderstwa niejakiego Pitzla, zamordowanego przez Holmesa w domu tfiary przy Callowhill ul. Potem pewnie Holmes będzie oddany innym sądom do sądzenia za inne morderstwa w Chicago, St. Louis, Detroit i Toronto, Canada. Procesa tę będą nader kosztowne, albowiem świadków do procesu trzeba ściągać ze wszystkich stron Ameryki. Koszta tego procesu w naszem mieście obliczają na 25,000 dolarów. W pierwszem dniu procesu adwokaci Holmesa chcieli odłożyć sprawę na 2 miesiące, lecz sędzia prowadzą cy rozprawę odrzucił ich wniosek. Nadaremne były także ich usiłowania i Holme sa, aby przewlee sprawę bodaj o dzień jeden. Gdy sęd2ia i ten wniosek odrzucił, adwo kaci ecfaęlisię od obrony, a Holmes pierwszego i drugiego dnia sam się bronił, korzystając z przysługującego mu prawa sam odrzucał i przyjmował sędziów przysięgłych, rofrł wnioski i badał i nękał świad ków krzyżowemi pytaniami. Dopiero drugiego dnia wie czorem adwokaci zgłosili się napowrót do sędziego i objęli obronę Holmesa aa nowo. Z Pliiladelpliii. (Jego proces.) lego
Printed in German, this report says H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgett, went to trial in Philadelphia's Court of Oyer and Terminer for the murder of Benjamin C. Pietzel, pleading not guilty, with Judge Arnold presiding and prosecutor Graham for the state, but after a postponement was refused his lawyers Shoemaker and Rotan quit the case and Holmes was allowed to defend himself.
Der Fortschritt · 7 November 1895 · page 3
Der Pr -'s'. Philadelphia. 28. Okt. H. H. Holmes oder Herman Mudaett, der als der gewissenloseste und geschickteste Mörder moderner Zeiten bezeichnet wird, wird heute in 'dem Court of Oyer und Terminer dem Richter vor geführt werden und damit beginnt dann sein Prozeß. Er steht unter ber birecten Anklage, Benjamin C. Pietzel ermorbet zu haben und hat bereits of fiziell erklärt, nicht schuldig zu sein. Der Prozeß wird einer der berühmt: sten in den Verbrccher-Annalen wer 'den: Richter Arnold wird den Vorsitz süh rat und er hat erklärt, er gedenke täg lich drei Sitzungen, Morgens, Nach mittags und Abends, zu halten, so lange die interessirten Personen es aushalten können.
See moreSee less
Die Staatsanwalt schaft ist durch Distriktsanwalt Gra ham und mehrere Assistenten und der Gefangene durch zwei junge Advokaten, Shoemaker und Rotan, vertreten. Später: Als die Gerichtssitzung eröffnet war, erklärten die beiden An wälte des Angeklagten, als ihnen eine Vertagung des Prozesses verweigert worden war. daß isie nichts mehr mit letzterem zu thun haben wollten und verließen den Saal. Holmes bestand darauf, sich selbst zu vertheidigen, was ihm auch bewilligt wurde.
A roundup reports a G.A.R. commander's wish for Cuba's annexation, a stolen 1860 cannon recovered in Wisconsin, Holmes resting his case in the Pitezel murder trial, flooding in Madrid, and an exploring party's report on possible volcanic activity near Mount Olympus.
Oxford Eagle · 7 November 1895 · page 1
Col. Ita5 N. Walekb. commander in-chief of the Ck A. R. when asked what he thought of the proposed mass meeting in Indianapolis. InJ., to ex press sympathy with the Cubans, said: “For forty years I have hoped for the annexation of Cuba to the United States." Fox Laee (Wia.) republicans are re joicing over the recovery of a cannon which wma unearthed, on the SKh. by , Joseph Good while digging a trench. It was stolen and buried by local dem ocrats In I860, to prevent republicans celebrating the election of Abraham Lincoln.
See moreSee less
At the dose of the ee&e for the pro* rent ion in the Pitexel murder trial in Philadelphia, on the 1st. the defendant, H. H. Holmes, without offering snv testimony, submitted his cause, claim ing that the proseentioo had failed to make a case, and throwing himself unnn m»rcnf th* frirr A dispatch from Mndrid. on the 1st, said: The Gusdfilquiver has over flowed its beaks, submerging vast tracts of land. The railway tracks sre under water and railway trains sre unable to ran. Several boats have been capsized by rushing water and some of their occupants drowned. Thh Mount Olympus volcano explor ing party returned to Port Townsend. Wash., ou the 28th. from a fire-days’ trip into the heart of the range. They reported that while the outburst is not a regular volcano, there la good ground for the impression that a tierce subterranean convulsion Is in prog __ - — —
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · 7 November 1895
Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo.
The clipping reports that H.H. Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pietzel, and that the London Daily News says a Tyneside firm got a Japanese order to build three new battle-ships.
Iron County Register · 7 November 1895 · page 6
LATE NEWS ITEMS.
He net 1L Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia, on the 3d, of murder in the first degree for the killing of Ben jamin F. PietzeL The London Daily News announces that a Tyneside firm has received a Japanese order to build three new battle-ships.
The clipping reports that Holmes's attorneys, declaring the prosecution had failed to prove murder, rested on the commonwealth's evidence without offering a defense, hoping to win the jury's mercy, in a trial otherwise described as dull.
Iron County Register · 7 November 1895 · page 6
A BID FOR MERCY.
. It was expected that the case would -be sensational in the extreme, but af court room as the majority of ordinary murder cases are. - the proceedings. These were the ap Mrs. Pietzel and her pathetic tale of her journey with Holmes, and the tes girl that he deceived into believing that she was his legal wife. charge of the judge will probably con A BID FOR MERCY. adden Termination ot the Holmes Mur der Trial The Defense Submits XoTesw tlnaohy, bat. Contending that the Prose cution Has Failed to Make Oak a Case, Hmm a Rota Appeal to Slut Jury.
See moreSee less
PmLADELPHiA, Nov. " S. Holmes yesterday threw himself on the mercy of the jury. When the common wealth closed its case yesterday af ter noon his attorneys ' announced that they considered the prosecution had not made out its charge of murder, and they would ; rest their case upon the evidence offered by the common-, wealth and submit no testimony in de fense of the prisoner. . ; v -UVJ This decision was made : by Holmes upon the advice of a well-known law yer, who was at one time retained by the prisoner. The move seemed like a bold one," but was nnquestionabl y done more in desperation in the hope of influencing the jury and ; creating the impression in their minds that, be ing conscious of his innocence, and not having had time to prepare a proper defense. Holmes trusted him self to their sense of justice. ' -l In reality Holmes has no defense. The commonwealth has presented no direct proof that Holmes murdered PietzeL Their chain of circumstan tial evidence even was not as strong as was expected, and bat for the " ad missions at : various times" of Holmea himself the district attorney would have had a , most difficult . task in proving the charge. ter Judge Arnold ruled out all the evi dence bearing upon the murder of The children, the most ghastly features of Holmes' series of crimes ; were elimi nated .-. r' ,; '(- Instead of furnishing any sensation, the trial itself has been as dull and uninteresting to the spectators in the But two incidents out of the ordi nary have broken the monotony of pearance upon the witness stand of tifying against the prisoner of the The closing arguments and the sume the better part of to-day.
Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, charged with many murders and tried at Philadelphia for the murder of B. F. Pietzel, was convicted and sentenced to death.
The Butler Weekly Times · 7 November 1895 · page 4
Mara, who gets $500,000 Spain, ia 80 years old. Capitalists are building an eigh teen b tor j building in St. Louis. A regular blizzard and enow storm prevailed in Nebraska and the west Friday. Corbett and Fitzsimmons ought to go to some uninhabited island in the sea and knock it out. It is reported that Senator Gor man is seeking the chairmanship of the democratic national convention. Bepublican candidates for presi dent will apply to Quay and Flatt, bosses of the Republican party. In the twelve states which held elections Tuesday, not a thing was said about the Populist party.
See moreSee less
No mention was even made of the exist ence of such a party. The town of Arcadia, Iowa, was wiped out of existence by fire Sun day. The fire burned over four acres of ground and but one store was left standing in the place. The Oak Ridge Sanitarium, at Green Springs, Ohio, was destroyed by fire Sunday. There were about forty-eight guests in the building and all escaped. The loss is $40,000. In some states men were the issue and not the party. In Maryland it was Gorman; in Ohio, Brice; in New York, Hill; in Kentucky, Hardin. With the republicans it was Flatt, Quay, Reed, Sherman, Harrison and Allison. Bryant, a small town eighteen miles south of Little Rock, Ark., was almost destroyed by fire Mon day. Among the buildings burned were three stores, a newspaper office, a hotel and several residences. The loss is estimated av $50,000. H. H. Holmes, the man charged with many murders and tried last week at Philadelphia for the murder of B. F. Pietzel, was convicted by the jury and his punishment assessed at death. The career of Holmes is per haps one of the most remarkable on the criminal records of this country. The best free silver or sound money democrat is the one who in tends to stick to his party and party nominations. It required some time for the democrats to get together on the tarift question, and it may take some time to adjust the money question, but this will be accom plished within the democratic ranks. The democrat who talks about bolt ing ought to be kicked over the line into the republican party where he rightly belongs. Jefferson City Tribune. On June 30 there were 969,544 pensioners on the roll of the peacea ble Republic more than the com bined army pension lists of all the fighting European pewers. The net increase during the fiscal year was 860 and this thirty years after the close of the war. The estimate for next year foots up $141,450,000. And yet wonder is sometimes ex pressed that war taxes are still nec essary and the revenue is insufficient. E. O. Times. it semis wiser council has pre vailed and the unpleasant feeling which has existed in the democratic state central committee on the prominent issues, early and late con vention and calling the committee to meet has subsided and a most pleasant feeling exists among the members. The movement set on foot by one or two hot heads to oust Chairman Maffit has been quell ed and matters for the time being are allowed to drift along serenely. Secretary of State Lesueur, said, do not care to discuss what has been but I will eay that I haye talked with a number of the new members and they are all in favor of a con eervative course. None of them, with possibly one or two exceptions, wants to drive any one out of the party. If by making concessions, they can secure harmony, the con cessions, I think, will be made." from
The clipping reports that in Philadelphia on the 2nd, H. H. Holmes was convicted of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pitezel (rendered unclearly), coughing slightly as the only reaction to the verdict.
Oxford Eagle · 7 November 1895 · page 1
CONDENSED TELEGRAMS.
Ar Philadelphia. Pa. on the 2d H. H. Holmes was convicted of murder in the [ first degree for the killing of iienjamia F. I> tel He coughed slightly when ; be heard the surds. That was the only sign.
The damaged clipping suggests bodies of homeless people who sheltered in a burned building may lie in the ruins, and separately reports from Philadelphia, dated Nov. 4, that a person's surname begins with Henry H., convicted, though the text is too garbled to make out further details.
Oxford Eagle · 7 November 1895 · page 1
may be lying the bodies of homeless | and friendless tad or* who had found l shelter for the night within the wall* of the doomed building* Of Ito Rllllac mt r. ntesel la HOLMES CONVICTED raUanetsSia. Philaoclthli. Nov. 4 — Henry II.
The report states that H. H. Holmes, described as the arch murderer, was found guilty of murder in the first degree in Philadelphia the previous Saturday. This brief item appears amid a roundup of unrelated news items including elections and silver coinage.
The Philipsburg Mail · 7 November 1895 · page 4
"There will be more chance to make money in the United States of America in the next fiye years than in any part c of the world." James B. Walker, acting editor of the I Helena Herald, has, it is reported, ac cepted .a position on the Salt Lake Tribune, a H. H. Holmes, the arch murderer, was 0 found guilty of murder in the first do gree in Philadelphia last Saturday. President Cleveland has appointed I
Printed in German, this item reports H. H. Holmes (Hermann Mudgett) was convicted and sentenced to death in Philadelphia, then discusses a theft attempt, a jeweler's advertisement, Weather Bureau chief Willis Moore's forecasting statistics, balloon-based atmospheric research, and an advertisement for a remedy against hemorrhoids.
Nebraska Staats-Anzeiger · 7 November 1895 · page 8
Loyales. l-$ H. H. Holmes alias Hermann Mudgett, der Massenmörder, ist in Pl ladelphia schuldig besunden und zum Tdc verurtheilt worden. Am Mittwoch stahl ein Mann. Namens ffrank MrNiel, Äingbam aus dem Nisoley'schen ade, wurde aber dabei ertappt und eine Beute abge nommcn. Wer einmal im BestV eines Jewil Osens ivar, wird nie mehr eine andere Sorte kaufen. Dieselbe flnd nur bei Henry Ä e i Ih, 905 O Straße, zu haben und werden zu billigen Preisen abgegeben. Ir Die 23.1 (erkunde hat es in die fern ante schon recht weit gebrachi.
See moreSee less
Wie err Willis Moore, Ede des Wetter Bur'aus angiebi, erreiscn sich gegen artig nur zwanzig Prozent der Pro gnose:, IS urlhiimlich. Wenn eS den M:!eo:Llo.',k gelingt, die Geheimnisse der OberstiSmungen zu erforschen, die häuirz liiicrwartele Itürm' mitbringen, knn cie Nichtigkeit der Proznosen auf !,, Pivzeiil gebiach! werden, dg itf, in hundert fallen wäre höchstens sünf irrige srauoftanj(it möglich. Der Gewinn, eichen ein solcher gorlschri bringe urnite, schift Herr Moore auf hundert Liillionen i Keldeswerth. Es fehlt cjiv,eiualig noch an onichtun--gen, utomaliich arbeitende Thermo grapher,, Barometer a'a. in die HöZe von drei Meile zu senden, lLin Fessel ballen würde sich bei starmijqem Wer nicht bewäare. Aoer das rührige Wel reram: eroeumentir! eifrig, um j'i dem gerounichic Ziele zu gelangen und Hai egt t:.r.t iUx schmeistosen Trachea in Verbindung mik einen! rigarrensörmizen 3?alloa als P,rr:chZobiell. Ei solcher Äpparal wurde nahe gert Meyer Uno gusz doch emgzrgesandl uns registriite eine Di'ferenz von dreizehn Grad in diescr Höhe. Die Katz' im Sack gekauft! So keriki Mancher, der durch marklschrei rischc Änzeizea von Wuidermilteln ver leitet, sein ,,uies Geld hergiebt und eine Pfuschmedijin dadurch erhandelt hat. So lea'.l auch ohl Mancher, der von dem ziizcn Heilmittel des Dr. Z.Sildy geizen Hömorrdoelen, jlnakests. liest. seil a,,o vriichtig Zhr Leidenden, und sendet er'l noch einer Probe, die öucd P. Neu:d:cr2., Bor iri. Rem Zloik. aus erlanqe, ko'teusre, zufeade wer den, ehe dr ine Poe, all, zu kaufe iauch:. uen reomirlen fpoihe krn zu !,;l):n.
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · and 1 other paper
Among a column of news briefs, this report says Henry H. Holmes was convicted of first-degree murder in Philadelphia for killing Benjamin F. Pitzel, with a new trial motion to be made on the 18th.
River Falls Journal · 7 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES TO HANG.
From the state college in Philadel phia two students were expelled and 14 u.ore were indefinitely suspended for hazing. President Cleveland and the secretary of w ar have changed the name of B>andj Hook to Fort Hancock, in honor of the late Gen. Winfield Scott Hancock. At the age of 106 years Charles Ben son died at his home iu Tioga couuty, Pa. The firm of Moses Rosenbun & Co., dealers in dry goods and notions in New York, failed for $157,000. In New York S. M. Bixby & Co., manufacturers of shoe blacking and harness oils, failed for $245,000.
See moreSee less
Jacob Vogel and William Haberman, prominent business men, were killed by the cars at a crossing in Elizabeth, N. J., aud John Hughes, a hack driver, was fatally injured. Fire destroyed J. Lowentraub’s roller and ice skate factory at Newark, N. J., tile loss lieing $210,000. The death of Wilton Dimock Mott, editor ami proprietor of the Milford (Pa.) Dispatch and associate judge of Pike couuty, occurred at the age of 42 years. During the season just closed the Gloucester (Mass.) fishing fleet lost 11 vessels aud 90 men. Last year ’37 men were lost. Express companies of the country put into effect an advance of 33 1-3 per cent, in the carrying charges of currency between New Y’ork, Boston, Philadelphia and Chicago. At Rochester, N. Y’., Charles Shabei lowered the world’s bicycle road record for 2i*o miles from 11:58:30 to 11:46:63. In Philadelphia Henry 11. Holmes was convicted of murder in the first degree for killing Benjamin F. Pitzel. A mo tion for a new trial will be made on the 18th inst. Passenger trains collided at Edge worth. Mass., anil John Flaherty was killed and 2oother jiersons were injured and a large amount of property de stroyed. Flames destroyed a sweat-shop build ing in New York, and four person*per ished in the Haines. The American Federation of Labor will commence its tifteeuth annual con vention in New Y’ork city December 9. The 100 tanneries under the control of the United States Leather com)Miny of New York shut down for 60 days, throw ing 15,000 persons out of work. At Niagara Falls Junies Hi.ffa, of Philadelphia, committed suicide by jumped from the Goat Island bridge into the rapids. For hazing seven students of the Ger man theological seminary at Bloom field, N. J., were expelled. THE EAST.
The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D. · 23 November 1895
Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.
H. H. Holmes, described as a multi-murderer, was convicted in Philadelphia of the murder of B. E. Pitezel, with a motion for a new trial to be urged before sentencing.
Gloucester County Democrat · 7 November 1895 · page 2
R. H. Holmes, the multi-murderer, was convicted at Philadelphia last Saturday of the murder of B. E. Pitezel. Pending :le-itl> sentence a motion for a new tri-d i will be urgu.a.
Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J. · and 2 other papers
The clipping describes the Philadelphia trial in which a jury found Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of murdering Benjamin F. Pitezel, detailing the jury's deliberation, the courtroom scene, and the granting of a hearing for Nov. 18 on a motion for a new trial.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 7 November 1895 · page 2
THE CONVICT STILL NERVY
Philadelphia, Nov. 4.—Henry H Holmes stands convicted of murder in tht first degree for killing Benjamin F. Pite zel. Holmes coughed slightly when tht verdict was announced, but that was tht only indication the condemned man gavi when he heard the fateful words. The jury retired to deliberate at 4t minutes past 5 yesterday evening. Ac cording to one of their number, they hnc reached their verdict before the doors 01 their room closed upon them. For liun ger’s sake they ate their supper first Then they took a ballot, and, without hesitation, every man of the 12 answoreC “Guilty of murder in the first degree.’ But, however atrooious the crime, how ever fiendish the oriminal, it is hard tc send a man to the gallows in a minute’!
See moreSee less
time, so, for decency’s sake, they talked about the case for a seemly period—aboul IK hours. Then word was sent into court that they had agreed. This was ai 8:15o’olook. It took a half hour to get the court in readiness to receive the ver dict. At 20 minutes to 9 there was a bustle of moving people in tfio packed court room, and it became known that the jury was coming in. A moment later Judge Arnold took his seat, District Attorney Graham and his assistants entered, and the jury filed solemnly in and took then seats irathe box. Then amid an oppressive silence Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. For a moment there was not a sound. The silence was literally painful, and ev ery heart in that crowded room throbbed faster. The man who was about to heai his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same deathlike pallor, which could grow no deeper, on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands olasped behind his back. Onoo or twice he moistened his lips with his tongue. There was no other sign of agitation. Then from the deep voiced court olerk came the awful words: “Jurors, look upon the prisoner. Pris oner, look upon the jurors. Now, say you gentlemen of the jury, do you find the prisoner at the bar, Herman W. Mud gett, alias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel or not guilty?” The condemning syllables came prompt ly from the foreman: "Guilty of murder in the first degree." “Hemi” uttered Holmes, olearing hla throat, but his shrunken form never trem bled; his lips betrayed no quiver; his mar velous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of the hands fold ed behind him. Then he slowly sat down, and, at the request of oounsel, the jury was polled— that is, each of the 12 men separately lis tened to the clerk’s query and responded with the finding. As each name was called Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The ver dict was formally reoeived by the court. Immediately after the announcement ot the verdict the usual application for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. District Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion, and Judge Arnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be laok of time for the preparation of the defense. Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the supreme court and argument heard at its next sitting in this city, January, 1898. So, even if every thing goes., against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on the earth from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals. The motion for a new trial was receiv ed, and after Judge Arnold had spoken a word of regret to oounsel for the defense beoause of last Monday’s occurrences, when they withdrew from the case, and appreciation for their arduous but fruit less labors, Holmes was taken to his cell room, and a few moments later to prison. Then the jury was thanked for their at tention and labors and sent home, the oourt adjourned, and the most extraordin ary case in the annals of American courts was ended. The proceedings of the last day were uneventful, except for the last tmgio scene. Distrlot Attorney Graham opened the session with his address to the jury. He was followed by Mr. Kotan, who, in his speech, presented the only form of his defense—that Pitezel had committed sui cide—resting on the assumption that the commonwealth had not made out a case beyond a reasonable doubt. Judge Arnold charged the jury for more than an hour. The district attorney said his instructions were fair and impartial. The general idea was that if they leaned toward either side it was toward the commonwealth, but the charge consisted mainly in a re view of the evidence and an exposition of the law of murder. When the trial began last Monday, ev erybody, including the commonwealth’s officers, anticipated that it would lengthen Into many weeks. It lasted six days. Tfcse was the result of the court’s decision that no evidence touching upon Holmes’ other crimes should be introduced into this particular case and the oonduot of counsel in presenting no defense other than argument. The swift developments, treading upon each others' heels, and ev ery one outdoing its forerunner for sensa tionalism, are publlo knowledge. Holmes spoke to his counsol, Rotan and Shoemaker, In the cellroom before he was taken back to Moyamensing prison. To them he said: ‘‘I feel that this condemns me. It was an unjust trial.” He would ■ay no more than that. The Terdict. Holmes Says It Is Unjust.
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 7 November 1895
The Bottineau Courant · Bottineau, N.D. · 23 November 1895
Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.
This fragment describes Holmes writing each juror's name on a newspaper margin without his hand shaking as the verdict was formally received by the court.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 7 November 1895 · page 2
THE CONVICT STILL NERVY
with the finding. As each name was called Holmes wrote it on the margin of a newspaper in his hand, and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The ver dict was formally reoeived by the court.
The fragment notes that even if events go against him, Holmes still has some time left to live before January, 1898, despite being accused of causing many deaths.
Bridgeton Pioneer · 7 November 1895 · page 2
THE CONVICT STILL NERVY
city, January, 1898. So, even if every thing goes., against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on the earth from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals.
A damaged, jumbled fragment describes cries from women spectators affecting a convicted murderer's mother and his attorney seeking a new trial, interrupted mid-sentence by an advertisement for De Witt's Little Early Risers pills.
The News-Herald · 7 November 1895 · page 3
audience were women. The cries which went up from them fell upon the ear of the convicted murder er's mother like a blow, and it began to die awty, Holmes began to smallest dose that performs a cure is recover himself. He realized that his the best. De Witt's Little Early Risers attorney was making a motion for a are the smallest pills, will perform a new trial. It is a truth in medicine that the
The News-Herald · Hillsboro, Ohio · and 1 other paper
The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudget, known as H. H. Holmes, was convicted Saturday night of first-degree murder for killing Benj. F. Pletzel, describing his stunned reaction, the jury poll, and the judge's remarks before setting a November 18 hearing on a new trial motion.
The News-Herald · 7 November 1895 · page 3
Philadelphia, Nov. 4. Herman W. Mudget, or, as he is better known, H. H. Holmes, was Saturday night con victed of murder in the first degree for killing Benj. F. Pletzel In this city on September 2, 1891. The jury needed but one ballot to reach this decision. The jury retired at 5:45 o'clock, at the conclusion of Judge Arnold's charge. After the retirement of the jury from the court room the specta tors streamed out into the corridors and eagerly discussed what tho ver dict would probably be. At 8:45 word was sent to Judge Arnold that tho jury was ready to return tho verdict .
See moreSee less
The prisoner was brought in and placed in tho dock. He was as impas sive as ever as he took his seat The court ordered Holmes to arise, and then, in reply to the question of the court, the foreman of the jury pro nounced tho words "Guilty of murder in tho first degree." The verdict was greeted with abso lute silence. The charcre of the judge must have foreshadowed what his fato would be, but the word guilty fell upon Holmes with stunning force. He made no outcry or exhibition of emo tion of any kind the blow was too stunning for noisy outbreak. He sat 'down, and. whilo the jury was polled each man answered to his name, and as each pronounced his sentence, Holmes started vacantly be fore him. i Ills face was that of a corpse. It was as absolutely expressionless as a mask Only a nervous twitching of the eyelids and the contraction and di lation of tho eyes showed that there was a living breathing man that sat in the docks. As tho effect, of the shock began to die awty, Holmes began to recover himself. He realized that his attorney was making a motion for a new trial. Tho judgo said he would hear the motion for a new trial on Monday, No vember 18, and on expression some thing like hope broko across his dull face. Turning to the court officials ho said in an eager whisper: "Monday, November 18?" These were the only words ho ut tered. Judge Arnold then expressed to Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker his appreciation of how difficult their task had been. He complimented them that they had been able to make as good a showing for the defense as they did. He intimated that their with drawal from the case was a device of the prisoner. Judge Arnold then ordered tho prisoner removed. Everyone actively identified witn tne Holmes trial, which ended Saturday evening in the conviction of Holmes for the murder of Pietzel, was glad when Sunday came, and took advan tage to rest and recuperate from tho great nervous tension under which they had labored for a week. District Attorney Graham said Sunday, as to the granting of a new trial, he did not think the court after having heard the argument would do so, as there was nothing upon the records of tho trial that would show an error sufficient to warrant such a proceeding. After the ordeal of the trial the quiet monotony of a prison cell was welcome to Holmes and he spent Sunday ap sentence which hangs over him. He is still in the untried department but will be moved over with the convicts Monday. The condemned man's appe tite takes but little of his attention. He still maintains his air of injured in not absorbed in thought No visitors were allowed to see him Sunday, and Holmes himself strengthened the pris on rules by stating that he did not wish to see anybody. Jessie Pietzel is still in Philadelphia in charge of the society for the pre Pietzel has left the city and nearly all of the commonwealth witnesses have taken their departure. parently unconcerned by the death nocence and reads and writes when vention of cruelty to children. Mrs.
The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt. · 8 November 1895
Democratic Northwest and Henry County News · Napoleon, Ohio
The clipping reports that a ring-backed ticket lost an election, that Durant was found guilty of first-degree murder of Blanche Lamont with an appeal expected, and that H. H. Holmes was convicted of murdering Benjamin F. Ritzel.
Democratic Northwest and Henry County News · 7 November 1895 · page 4
The Napoleon Republican ring brushed aside such citizens as Han cock, Fisk, Musser, Weaver, and made up a ticket of men as the ring put it! The figures show the result. The men wern't in it even a little. The murderer Durant has been found guilty of murder in the first de gree, for the murder of Blanche La mont at San Francisco. The verdict was received with cheers by the citi zens. The aocused will ask for a new trial, and if that is not granted the case wilt be appealed on error.
See moreSee less
H. H. Holmes has been convicted of the murder of Benjamin F. Ritzel in Philadelphia on Sept. 2, 1894. Holmes is the man who is suspicion ed of committing innumerable mur ders throughout the country, but he has got to the end of his string and will end up with a halter around his neck.
This fragment reports that H. H. Holmes was found guilty of murder in the first degree, noting the jury was absent from the court room over two hours before reaching the verdict.
Turner County Herald · 7 November 1895 · page 1
bank, Sioux Falls. H. H. Holmes was found 'guilty of murder in the first degree." Though absent from the court room over two hours, the verdict
The clipping describes an unnamed man, now thirty-eight, whose criminal exploits astonished several major cities and who has shifted blame for murders onto others, with authorities determined to ensure his conviction and execution.
The Dakota Chief · 7 November 1895 · page 3
H. H. HOLMES ON TRIAL.
r ' i w w ■ aX i lost sight of. Not so his manifold ex ploits iu hulf a dozen of the big cities of this country, which have been marveled at wherever men can read. Wild and t weird, us is the confessed story of his life, in which he accuses himself of of fenses which would long since have given a less skillful criminal his quietus, Holmes has been careful to shift the main responsibility for the various mur ders with which he udmits having been connected to other shoulders.
See moreSee less
Thus dur ing the thirty-eight years of a life de voted almost entirely to law-breaking this is his first experience as a felon on trial for his life. The authorities have recognized that this is no common crim inal, but one who might be called a tech nical and most expert artist in crime. It is, therefore, their determination, in the event of securing his conviction for a capital offense, to “railroad” him to the gallows.
This damaged, fragmentary clipping jumbles election district and business listings with a brief mention of H. H. Holmes, convicted murderer of Benjamin, making the overall content largely illegible.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 7 November 1895 · page 2
HARDENED HOLMES.
J00O. The districts still to be heard from representatives in the lower house of the Darlsheimer & Wooms are nominally Republican. legislature. Tbe municipal ollieers elect Tlitinnn Rout nnd Shoe Co. . . ed to-day are live branches of the city John Pullman 4c Co tol shots in the neighborhood of Avenue i lung x.awtra.t, LatM i 324 30 DioojiCiiui.Cobf., SoU Prom, Bjijjj" I ; X and Thirty-fourth street drew the at Philadelphia, Xov. 3. H. H. Holmes, 307 70 the convicted murderer of Benjamin I. 403 07 tention of Officer Barbaries from his
The fragmentary clipping reports that letters confiscated by Holmes will soon be returned to Galva, Ill., and that Miss Yoke, described as Holmes' third wife, will return to Denver to try to have her marriage to him declared illegal.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 7 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES' SLIM CHANCE.
letters confiscated by Holmes. In a few days they will return to Galva. 111. Miss Yoke, Holmes' third wife, will return to Denver shortly nnd en Holmes set aside as being illegal. deavor to have her marriage With
This garbled fragment reports that Holmes still has time to spend regarding the crime he is accused of having sent many fellow mortals to, and that the verdict surprised people who doubted the crime had been proven beyond reasonable doubt.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 7 November 1895 · page 3
GUILTY OF MURDER IN THE FIRST
Sn. piTon if.!1 ...,-i.:.. nn:nDf Inn, Holmes lilag yet some time to spend mi flia Anvth rz l.!L. U . i. -11 A Oil 1 (Jiroui wuicu ue is uucgni u iiuvc neiiL j-go many tenow mortals. i.'he verdict was a surprise to many poisons, who I did not believe the crime lull been fastened upon Holmes beyond ii -easonablVh doubt, when these heard
The clipping describes the courtroom scene as the jury returned a guilty verdict against H. H. Holmes for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, noting his calm demeanor, the subsequent polling of the jury, and the brief closing proceedings of the six-day trial.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 7 November 1895 · page 3
... -i.. ,i Liu nooiutnnt pnterod and V.1I1UUU1 PUU '" ' , j T 1 . , ic jury filed solomniy in ana iouk t'l .. u kv Thon nniiil nn onnresioi;i m - --' . . ii e silence, Holmes was brought in and need in the docK. T or a mumem mnc wis not a souno. me '"-u literally painful and every heart in that crowded room throbbed faster, lbe hti,n who was about to hear his doom i. renounced stood erect in the dock, the same death-like pallor, which could grow i,i.
See moreSee less
deeped, was on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped (,,,'iind his back. Once or twice he moistened his lips with his tongue. There v.is no other sign of agitation, Then, f rom the deep voiced court clerk came the awful words: "Jurors, look upon the isoner; prisoner iook upon me juiuia. jins W say you, gentlemen firrl tha nriannpr at the bar. Her j(, oin W. Mudeet. alias H. H. Holmes, -'inlty of the murder of Benjamin i. W etzel, or not guilty?" Vhe condemning syllables came litcimptly from the foreman: Guilty or v. urder "in the first degree." . 'Hem, hem," uttered jtioimes, umimis i troat, but his shrunken form never ii: ivered, his lips betrayed no quiver, marvellous nerve uuu .u Thpp was only a tighter clasp of ih hands folded behind. Then he sat 'own and at the request of the counsel i'ii jury was polled. As each name was r; lied Holmes wrote it on the-margin of a uewspaper in his hand and the fingers holding the pencil never shook. The 'crdict was formally recorded by the court; the motion for a new trial was made, and after Judge Arnold had spok en a word of regret to counsel for the de fease because of last Monday s occur vse, and appreciation for their arduous tut taitniess laDors, noiiueo wuo t. his sell room and a few moments later -Thon ha -lnrir wns thanked f.,r their attention and labors and sent l.o 'me. , , . The court adjourned and the most ex i i:n.v iinao in the onnntn ftf .AlTieri An..ta wna anrlpri. TtlA nrnPPpdinffS i,; the last day were uneventful, except . r the last tragis scene. District Attorney Graham opened the ..! .iv, hia arlHroHH tn thi iiirv. He v as followed by Mr. Rotan, who, in his i'eech,.preSented tne on., u ur fonse tnat rieuw; .. i-i.i. n thp nssumDtion that (lie commonwealth had not made out a ease beyond a reasouuuie uuuki.. Judge Arnold charged the jury for more than an hour. The district at forney said his instructions were fair and impartial. When the trial began last Monday ..vcrybody, including the common Sh's officer anticipated that .it won Id i intn mnnV weoks. It lUStCd SIX ''IS?'. .i i f iim pmirt's de J. U13 nun iuc runuii. uision iuui ii ciium-.-. -- . - ;, Holmes' other crimes should be lntroliuced into tnis pnrucuiar t londuct of counsel presenting no defense .1 . Vi .i nirv ' .i i,.r withdraw from the
This damaged clipping jumbles a dental advertisement about anaesthetics and a photograph studio with a brief, fragmentary mention that Holmes stands convicted of the murder of Pitezel, plus disjointed political text.
Herald and News · 7 November 1895 · page 2
EDITORIAL NOTES.
reliable Anaesthetics used in extracting, aa the PHOTOGRAPH EH?, Holmes stands convicted of the ease may require. Office over Buck's Printing worcs. murder of Pitezel. Now if it were tort. Insteadsof frankly admitting accomplished s lost the state ticket its mistake in '92, which it had in ef thousand4 of votes. But this is wholly
After being convicted Saturday night of first-degree murder for killing Benjamin F. Pitezel, Holmes's attorneys immediately filed for a new trial, unopposed by the District Attorney, with a hearing set for Nov. 18 and a possible supreme court appeal in January 1896.
Herald and News · 7 November 1895 · page 5
KILLED PITEZEL. Holmes Found Guilty of Murder In the First Degree.
Application For a New Trial Immediately filed-Story of the Crimea Uld at the Door of the Arch-Conaplrator. Philadelphia, Nov. 4. -Herman W. Mudgett., or, to use the name by which he Is better known, H. H. Holmes, was Sat urday night convicted of murder in the first degree for killing Benjamin F. Pite ,el in this city, on Sept. 8, 1894, ; I'nnnediiitcly after the announcement of the verdict the usual application for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. District Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion and Judgo Arnold Used Nov.
See moreSee less
18 for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the prepara tion of the defense. . . : ' Should a new trial be refused, an appeal trill be taken to the supreme court, and argument heard at its next sitting In this city. January, 1896. So, that even if everything goes against him, Holmes has
The clipping recounts Detective Geyer's investigation gathering evidence against Holmes for Pitezel's murder, details Holmes's past frauds and aliases, and lists persons he is accused of killing.
Herald and News · 7 November 1895 · page 5
KILLED PITEZEL
ance. Holmes was sent to prison to await seu fcnee on the ouspiracy trial, and District Attorney Gruhain started Detective Geyer out to visit Toronto, Chicago and other western cities to endeavor to obtain evi dence against Holmes which would war rant his being arraigned for murder. De tective Geyer's success in finding the dead bodies of the children is well knowri, and other facts which he gleamed satisfied the district attorney that Holmes could bo convicted hero of the murder of Pitezel. Detective Geyer also brought to this city Mrs.
See moreSee less
Pitezel and others from various parts of the west and Canada to take the stand as witnesses ngainst Holmes. Remarxnble Criminal History. Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. II. Holmes, alias H. H. Howard, was born Jn Burlingion. Vt., and later studied medi cine iu Ann Arbor, Mich. He was mar ried at the Inner place. He and a friend swindled an insurance company of Chi cago out o( tlS.UOO soon after graduating. He made auolher haul of flO.OOO in a sim ilar w:vy. Holmes went Into the drug business and speculated. ' His wife went homo, and he then ; married another woman, with whom he went to California Returning n about a year, he tried to cheat a lire Insurance company out of $(i0, 000, failed, and, learning that his type writer aud her sister had inherited 50, 003, laid a scheme to get the money. The sister came to live with them, and disap peared. Holmes next appeared In Terro Haute, Iud., where he balled B. F. Pitezel out of jail. From there he weut to Frank lin, Ind., where he married Miss Yoke, and they spent, their honeymoon In Den ver, where Holmes made $37,000 in specu lation. In Philadelphia, later on, he and Pitezel played the last card. Pitezel was insured in the Philadelphia Mutual for 10,000. On Sept. 3 his supposed body was found in the house at 1316 Callowhlll street. Pitezel's wifo and children identified the bodyas Pitezel's, and 175(10 of the Insurance money was paid over. Then Train Bobber Hedgcspelh gave the whole case away to Chief of Polico Harrison. Holmes waa traced to Toronto and Burlington, Vt., and later he was arrested. Meauwhile the Pitezel children had disappeared, the boy being traced to Indianapolis and the two Klrls to Toronto. - , v. " 'A Here is a list, of the persons Holmes is accused of having made way with : Conner, Julia L,. divorced wife of I. L. Conner and bookkeeper for Holmes. Conner, Pearl, daughter of Mrs. Conner. Cigrand, Emeline G., daughter of Pctof Cigrand of Anderson, Ind., steuographei tor Holmes. Phelps, Robert K , whom Holmes sayn inarrletl Miss Cigrand. ; . Pitezel, Benjamin F.. confidential agent nd fellow-criminal of Holmes, killed In Philadelphia. Pitezel, Alice, daughter of B. F. Pitezel, killed In Toronto. Pitezel, Nellie, daughter of B. F Pitezel, killed in Toronto. Pitezel. Howard, son of B. F. Pitezol, killed In Indiananolis Van Tassel, Emily, daughter of Mrs M. vau Tassel of Chicago. , Williams, Nana, of Fort Worth, Tex, m visiting her sister when she dlsappeared. Williams, Minnie R,., of Fort Worth, lex., private secretary to Holmes. Geore H. Thomas, killed near Colum bus, Miss. , ..i The names of these missing people have been printed almost daily. There is not n town or liumlet where the news has not penetrated and where some people are not talking about it. Yet not one of these missing persons has been heard from Hot kPRiNos, Ark., Nov. 4. Not only is the Corbatt-Fitzsimmons match dead and buried, but the Mahor-O'Donnell and fcmith-Ryan contests are yet in the future "overuor Clarke has won out on every puint. Corbett has left town. The End at Last.
This single editorial item cites the convictions of Theodore Durrant in San Francisco and of H. H. Holmes in Philadelphia as notable successes of the jury system despite purely circumstantial evidence, noting each jury reached its verdict on a single ballot.
The Islander · 7 November 1895 · page 2
THE JURY SYSTEM. Two most notable examples of con spicious success of the jury system in the trial and conviction of men charged with the greatest of all crimes, have occurred in the United States during the past few days—the one on the At lantic coast and the other on the Pa-' cific. And a fact that m:\kes these in stances especially noteworthy is that the evidence in each case was purely circumstantial. In San Francisco, Theodore Durrant, a supposedly model young man, a medical student, of quiet and gentlemanly demeanor and promi nent in church work, stands in the shadow of the gallows, convicted, after a trial lasting more than three months, of one of the most fiendish crimes in the history of the west—the murder of a bright and handsome young girl in the church where he was accustomed to masquerade as a Christian.
See moreSee less
And he stands accused at the same time of the equally horrid murder of another young girl in the same place, while the body of his first victim still lay undiscovered In the belfry obove the alter, where God's word was almost daily taught. In Philadelphia H. H. Holmes, a man of several aliases, formerly a druggist in Chicago and undoubtedly one of the most remarkable criminals of the century, stands convicted of one of the many murders of which he is accused, men, women and little children being numbered among his victims. In each case the abscence of doubt in the minds of the jurimen was evidenced by the fact that but a single ballot was neces sary to determine the result. We hear a great deal about the weakness of the jury By3tem-and it is a common thing to bold 4t responsible for the many miscarriages of justice which ought
The clipping reports that a jury swiftly voted Holmes guilty of first-degree murder, with the public deeming the verdict justified despite doubts, and notes his parents and four siblings in Gilmantown, N. H., stayed silent during the trial.
Eagle River Review · 7 November 1895 · page 2
sake they ate their supper first. Then they took a ballot and without hesitation every man of the twelve answered “guilty of murder in the first degree.” But however atrocious the crime, how ever fiendish the criminal, it is hard to send a man to the gallows in one min ute’s time. So, for decency’s sake, they talked about the case for a seemly peri od, about an hour and a half. Then word was sent into court that they had agreed. This was at 8:15 o’clock. The verdict was a surprise to many persons, who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt.
See moreSee less
When these heard it they said: - “Well, it was on general principles, and it’s just as good.” That is not the meaning of the law, but in this case everybody agrees that “it’s just.as good.” : There is no word of pity or sympathy for the condemned felon. He is regarded as a menace to society. Up in Gilmantown, N. H., there are two old persons, his father and mother. He has also two brothers and two sis ters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial. H. H. HOLMES.
The clipping announces ticket sales and a new organ performance for Sunday at the Stadttheater in Stettin, and describes Wonderland's weekly lineup of performers, including dancers, singers, a sword swallower, a Bowie knife duel act, and a wax reproduction of H. H. Holmes, the alleged mass murderer.
Wisconsin Vorwärts · 7 November 1895 · page 4
Stadttheater in Stettin. Der Ber tauf der Sitze für die Sonntags-Vor~ ſtelung iſt flott im Gange und ſind noch gute Sitze in allen Theilen des Hauſes zu haben, und zwar zu ſehr populäͤren Preiſen. Auch bie neue Orgel wird am Sonntag Abend wh— rend der Zwiſchenpauſen geſpielt wer—- den. Bach's vollſtändiges Orcheſter wird am Sonntag Abend das Händel'- ſche „Largo“ mit Orgelbegleitüng zur Aufführung bringen. Wonderland. Noch zu keiner Zeit in der Geſchichte des Wonderland iſt ein beſſeres Pro~ gramm von Manager Marion arran girt worden als in der beginnenden Woche.
See moreSee less
Im Haupttheater: Baler und Lyon Duo, Eddie Moore, der belannte Tänzer, Miß Ella Carlington, ſingende und tanzende Soubrette und Banjo—~ Spieler, Eddie Collins Geſangsund Tanzkünſtler. Der muſikaliſche Ran~ tins und Chas. Forx, der deutſche Schauſpieler, werden auftreten. Auf der Bijou-Bühne wird die Hullshof Specialitäten Compagnie er~ ſcheinen und in der Curio Halle die zwei Eremiten von den Rockh Moun— tains, Prinz Le Vard, der berühmte Schwertgänger, und der Apache George und Arizona George mit ihrem er ſchütternden Bowie Meſſer-Duell und Vorführung ihrer Gewandtheit mit dem Laſſo und der Bullenpeitſche, und die Reprodultion in Wachs des notori~ ſchen H. H. Holmes, des angeblichen Maſſenmörders, werden unter den Hauptſehenswürdigleiten ſein.
After the jury's verdict, Holmes told his counsel Rotan and Shoemaker it condemned him unjustly, and while a new trial motion was set for hearing Nov. 18, the piece notes his parents and siblings in Gilmanton, New Hampshire stayed silent throughout the trial and no sympathy was shown him.
Wood County Reporter · 7 November 1895 · page 7
GUILTY ON FIRST BALLOT
sake they taked about the cage for a seemly period—about an hour and a half. Then word was sent into the court that they had agreed. This was at 8:15. It took half an hour to get the court in readiness to receive the verdict. Holmes spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker, in ids cell room before he was taken back to the prison. To them he said; “I feel this condemns me. It was an unjust trial.” He would say no more. Immediately after the announcement of the verdict, the usual application for leave to tile a motion for anew trial was made.
See moreSee less
District Attorney (Trahan did not oppose the motion and Judge Arnold fixed Nov. IS for the hearing. The principal reason urged will be the lack of time for the prep aration of the defense. Should a new trial be refused, an appeal will be taken to the supreme count and the argument heard at its next sitting in this city in January. So, even if every thing goes against him, Holmes has yet sometime to spend on earth from which it is alleged he sent many fel low mortals. The verdict was a surprise to ma un persons. who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes be yond a reasonable doubt. There is no word of pity or sympathy for the condemned felon. He is regarded as a menace to society. Up in Gilman ron. New Hampshire, there are two old people, his father and mother, and he also has two brothers and two sis ters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial. Last night when the jury had taken their seats and the prisoner was brought in the silence was literally painful. The man who was about to hear Ms doom pronounced stared at the jury
An Indianapolis dispatch reports that County Prosecutor Wiitsie telegrammed that if Holmes was acquitted, steps would be taken to extradite him to answer for the murder of Howard Pietzel, with conviction believed certain there, before the clipping breaks off into a fragment detailing Holmes's aliases and criminal reputation.
Wood County Reporter · 7 November 1895 · page 7
GUILTY ON FIRST BALLOT
Indianapolis, Nov. 3.—County Pros ■ eeutor Wiitsie. of Marion county, sent a telegram yesterday saying that if Holmes was acquitted steps would be taken to extradite him and bring him here to answer the charge of murder ing Howard Pietzel. It is believed that certain conviction awaits Holmes should he be tried here. The story of the life of Herman W. Mudgett. alias H. Holmes, alias O. C. Pratt, alias H. H. Howard and George Howard, murderer, insurance swind ler. polygamist ami all around profes
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes was convicted of murdering B.F. Peitzel and sentenced to death, and separately notes a strong seismic disturbance felt from Chicago to New Orleans and across the Mississippi region on the 31st.
Greenbrier Independent · 7 November 1895 · page 2
Herman g. M^ett, t)etter known as H. H. Holmes, the notori-| on*. insurance swindler and multl murderer, was con vjc ted after a short trial in Philadelphia last week of the murder of B.F. Peitzel with a penalty Axed at death. The criminal career of this man has been most remarka-l hie, and there will be few to mourn when he pays the penalty of his many crimes on the gallows. -*?????? A HKiKMic disturbance of very con siderable violence was felt through out a large portion of the country on the 31st uit. The shock was felt dia. finely from Chicago to New Orleans and throughout the entire Mississippi
The Oregon Mist · St. Helens, Or. · and 1 other paper
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted murderer of Benjamin F. Pitzel, spent a calm day in Moyamensing prison, slept well, remained confident of innocence, and is now double-guarded to prevent suicide pending sentencing.
The Oregon Mist · 8 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES, THE MURDERER. How Philadelphia's Archfiend Pa.aed th Oar of Beat. Philadelphia, Nov. 6. H. H. Holmes, the oonvioted murderer of Benjamin F. Pitzel, passed a quiet day in his sell in Moyamensing prison. "This man of steel and heart of stone," a the district attorney de scribed him to the jury, does not evince in the slightest degree any out ward sign of breaking down. With death actually before him now, he is the same oool and callous Holmes. The prison regulations prevented . anyone from interviewing him today, but a message was sent out that he slept well last night and was feeling com fortable and still oonfident that his in nooenoe would yet be established.
See moreSee less
Ex tra care hat been taken to that he can not oomniit suicide. A double guard baa been placed in his cell and will re main there until he is executed. He iB still in the untried department, bnt as soon as the death sentenoe is pro nunced he will be taken to a oell in murderer'i row."
The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or. · 7 November 1895
The Monticellonian · Monticello, Ark.
This damaged clipping contains fragments of several unrelated news items, including a river flood, a dismissed boxing-related peace warrant case, a Vanderbilt bridal gift, a burning of heretics in Mexico, and a guilty verdict in a San Francisco murder trial.
The Monticellonian · 8 November 1895 · page 1
edition In the Pitezel murder trial in Philadelphia, on the 1st, the defenda .!. II. 11. Holmes, without offering nnv testimony, submitted his cause, claim ing that the prosecution had failed t > make a case, tn - rowing himself upon llie mercy of 1. • jury. 1st, saiil: The (Jnaduhjnivcr has over flowed its banks, submerging vast tracts of land The railway tracks are under water and rail wav trains are unable to run. Several boats have been capsized by rushing1 water and some of their occupants drowned. immediate departure from the state of Arkansas the peace warrant cases against both Corbett and Fitzsimmons and Julian and Brady were dismissed on the 2d.
See moreSee less
The injunction issued against them still holds good and will be invoked should there be any at tempt to pull off a light. Consuelo Vanderbilt will receive from her father as a bridal present, sho will give 83,000,000 to the former Mrs. Hammersley, now Lady Her ford and step-mother to the duke of Marlbor ough, her fiance, to reimburse her for expenditures in restoring Blenheim castle and settling the liabilities of the estate. morning paper from Pacliuca, Mt-x., on the Sd, told of the burning of ten persons, as heretics at Texaenpa, a smalltown inhabited by Indians and Mestizos (half breeds), by order of the auxiliary town judge, who claims be was acting according to the will of Ood, manifested to him in an extraor dinary* vision, accompanied by indica tions of divine wratli against heretics and people living immoral lives. the jury in the Blanche Lamont mur der case in San Francisco, returned o verdict, on the 1st, against Theodore At the close of the cn^e for the pros A DISPATCH from Madrid, on the On assurance of good behavior and Out of the 810.000,000 which Miss A speciai. dispatch to a Chicago After deliberating twenty minutes Durrant of min der in the tirst degree without any amrtmnu-udatiuu Sot mercy. I
Among a column of news briefs, this report says Henry H. Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia, on the 2d, of murder in the first degree for the killing of Benjamin F. Pitezel.
The Monticellonian · 8 November 1895 · page 1
British trader, Stokes, iu Africa, be tried by a court-martial, on tiie charge | of murder, and that Belgium pay an ! indemnity of 1,000,000francs to Stokes' ! family. John II. I h: HR A.\ns, 70 j'ears of ago, I was killed by a trolley carin Williams burg, Long island, ou the evening of the 1st. This death makes the one hun dred and thirtieth victim of Brooklyn ! trolley roads in three years. The citizens of Windsor and Essex county, Out,, who formed an “Inde pendence of Canada" club recently, have become a political party, and will promulgate its principles throughout the dominion.
See moreSee less
John W. Cabman, an uncle of Mrs. > leveland, wife of»the President, at tempted to commit suicide in Chicago, on t a2d, by shooting himself in the i mouth with a revolver. In Chili the democrats are using vio ! lent language in regard to Spain, and | a conflict between them and the ’ Spanish residents is imminent. Henry H. Holmes was convicted in Philadelphia, on the ad, of murder in tiie first degree for the killing of Ben ■ jamin F. Pitezel. The London Daily News announces ; that a Tyneside tirm lias received ! a Japanese order to build three new j battle-ships. The official speed of the Arameu ram Katahdin, built by tiie Bath (Me.) iron works, is 10.13 knots, as reported I to Secretary Herbert by the trial board, and the vessel stands rejected under her contract, bearing the dis tinction of being the first vesfc<-l of the new navy failing to reach contract re quirements. The Brazilians, according to a late Kio de Janeiro dispatch, are deter mined to recognize Cuba. Oliver Cijktis Perry, the train rob ber, has been transferred from Auburn (N. Y.) prison to the Malteawan state hospital for the criminal insane. LUC CACUIHIIIII IJI tlio
The clipping describes the tense courtroom scene as the jury returned a guilty verdict against Henry W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, noting the surprise of onlookers and the prisoner's unshaken composure.
The Monticellonian · 8 November 1895 · page 1
HOLMES FOUND GUILTY
The verdict was a surprise to many persons, who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes be 1'ond reasonable doubt. When these heard the news, they said: “Well, it was on general principles, and it is just as (rood." That is not the mean tig of law, hut in this ease everybody lgrees that “it is just as good.” There s no word of pity or sympathy for the condemned man. lie is regarded is a menace to society. Up in Oilman ton, H. H., there are two old people, ais father and mother, and he has also : wo brothers and two sisters.
See moreSee less
No one if his kin was heard from during the trial. When the jury went out, an in definite recess was taken. Judge Arnold said he would remain in the building until midnight, if necessary, mi! if no verdict had been reached by that time lie would reach the court at 10 o'clock Sunday' morning. Nobody believed there would be any occasion for this. There were many wagers that the verdict would be in to-night, and more as to its nature. At 8 h) there was a bustle of moving people in tiie packed court-room, and it became known that the jury was joining in. A moment later Judge Arnold took h is scat. District At torney (irnham and his assistants entered and filed solemnly in and Look their seats in the box. Then, amid an oppressive silence, Holmes was brought in and placed in the dock. For a moment there was no sound. The silence was literally painful, and every heart In that crowded room throbbed faster. The man who was about to hear his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock, the same death like pallor, which could grow no deep er, on his face. He stared at the jury blankly, his hands clasped behind his buck. Once or twice lie moistened his lips with iiis tongue. There was no other sign of agitation. Then from the deep-voiced court clerk came t he words: “Jurors, look upon the prisoner; prisoner, look upon the jurors. How sav you, gentlemen of the jury, do you find the prisoner at the liar, Henry W. Mudgett, alias il. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder of Benjamin F. Pitexcl, Or not guilty?” Tin' verdict carue promptly from the foremsi n: ‘ Huilty of murder in the first de gree-" “Hem,” uttered Holmes, clearing his throat, hut his shrunken form never trembled, his lips betrayed no quiver, his marvelous nerve had not forsaken him. There was only a tightening of the hunts folded behind him. Then lie slowly sat down. VERDICT A SURPRISE.
A filler joke asks all people not murdered by H. H. Holmes to stand and be counted, poking fun at his notoriety. It is not a factual report but a humorous aside reflecting his infamy.
The American Citizen · 8 November 1895 · page 1
All those who have not been mur dered by H. H. Holmes will please rise and remain standing until counted.
Cottonwood Report · Cottonwood, Idaho · and 1 other paper
The clipping reports that Holmes was found guilty of first-degree murder after brief jury deliberation, told his counsel the verdict was unjust, and that a motion for a new trial was filed and a hearing set for the 18th, with an appeal to the supreme court possible in January 1896.
Cottonwood Report · 8 November 1895 · page 2
"guilty of murder In the first dÇ^ee.' But, however atrocious the cryjpThow ever fiendish the criminal, iU^hard to send a man to the gallows'mone min ute's time. Sd, iTor decency sake, they talked about the case for a seemingly period, about an hour and a half. Then word was sent Into court that they had It took half an hour to get the -lu readiness to receive the ver Holmes spoke to his counsel, Ro Shoeraaker in the cell room, i was taken back to the prison. He said: "I feel that this condemns me.
See moreSee less
It w»* an unjust trail." He would sny no more than that. Immediately after the verdict the usual application for leave to file a motion for a new trial was made. Dis trict Attorney Graham did not oppose the motion and Judge Arnold fixed the 18th of this month for a hearing. The principal reason urged will be lack of time for the preparation for the de fense. Should a new trial be refused an appeal will be taken to the supreme court and arguments heard at its next sitting In this city In January, 1896. So, even If everything goes against him, Holmes has yet some time to spend on the earth, from which he is alleged to have sent so many fellow mortals. The verdict was a surprise to many persons who did not believe the crime had been fastened upon Holmes beyond a reasonable doubt. There was no word of sympathy for the condemned felon. He Is regarded as a menace to society. Up in Gllman ton, N. H., there are two old people, his father and mother, and he has also two brothers and two sisters. Not one of his kin was heard from during the trial. A MAN OF IRON NERVE.
The clipping gives a doctor's phrenological description of H. H. Holmes's head and temperament, then abruptly shifts to unrelated fragments about kindergarten music talks and new fashionable color names.
The Indianapolis Journal · 8 November 1895 · page 3
A PHRENOLOGICAL STUDY.
ly the wonderful head of the wonderful Holmes. Here is the Doctor's statement from his own pm: "H. H. Holmes, as he appeared to mf as I sat at his right side and a little to his back, .has a nervous, bilious temperament of very good quality. Such a temperament gives him a very positive mind and verr intense desires in the direction of his stronger faculties. He cannot be said to have a coarse nature by any means, but to be capable of ilne appreciation of refine mn t. already been well honored by time.
See moreSee less
discussed at a convocation of mothers and kindergarten teachers. One afternoon was Benares red, Russian green, Marie Antoi devoted to a talk on the "physical Advan nette blue, bishop's purple and dead-leaf tages of Singing, and the Effect or music brown are some of the old colors with new on the Child," and right and wrong kinds of music, as Illustrated by kindergarten names, and the tints which really delude songs. The value of sunshine, cheerfulness us with a gloss of novelty are the ame and serenity;, the value of an orderly nur thyst shades of pale pink and deeper violet, of employments which bring out a child's lizard green, and lapis lazuli, which deepens own activity, were also discussed In a way into purple, and the varying shades of dull that must have been a revelation to those sery; the value of pets and playthings, and
This garbled fragment mixes several unrelated items, including H. H. Holmes's murder conviction, a forger's arrest in Honduras, a quiet local election, and Rockefeller's gift to a Baptist university in Chicago.
The Kosciusko Star · 8 November 1895 · page 4
in Philadelphia for the murder of B. F. Feitzel, one of his many victims, has been found guilty of murder and will hang unless the supreme court reverses the verdict of the jury. and the prospects are that he will be brought back to the scene of his many crimes and spend a good many years in the penitentiary. said Mr. Brooke had turned over to the Populite party can be deliv next year. of intelligence, a fine citizen, ' a good neighbor, but he has no influ (In a horn.)
See moreSee less
doff our hat to the good ladies of Attala. God bless them they are all good Democrats. quietly in this county, only two or three fisticuffs and they were not about politics. additional $3,000,000 to the Bap H. H. Holmes, recently on trial A. K. Ward, the Memphis for ger, has been arrested in Honduras That mule that the Vindicator ered to the editor of the Vindica tor to enable him to make a crop Hon. P. T. Kiipatrick is a man ence in the Beat in which he lives. In the name of Democracy we The election passed off very John D. Rockfeller, the multi mil lionaire has recently given an tist University at Chicago.
This damaged, barely legible clipping fragment mixes references to road work, a land assessment, and a guilty verdict for H. H. Holmes, but the surrounding text is too garbled to make out any coherent details.
The Charlotte Democrat · 8 November 1895 · page 3
force camplete the work on the Lawyers' road, the camp be taken to the old Tuckaseije road. H. H. Holmes was found guilty oi f.A pn ' one remarkable trait in his charThe ass ssment of the lands of J M and J . . t. I ' " . . . . . .. j ... lfrpri nnlv at the earnest solicitation ot his mitteemen got stays in their possession,
This heavily garbled OCR fragment contains disjointed phrases about rectitude, virtue, a blow, and worms, with an apparent advertisement reference, but is too damaged to make out any coherent subject.
Fisherman & Farmer · 8 November 1895 · page 1
ing us with rectitude aud virtue, aud keeping alive of the blow died away Holmes which was ordered recorded and g?ggg hied. worms from our child. Mra.Phrlcn.KUia.J.- TtTonnar'.B'Auii.vf K<Rhmim ifllntmnt.
The report describes H. H. Holmes's demeanor as the jury was polled and his sentence pronounced, noting he showed no outcry but only nervous twitching of the eyelids. After the shock wore off, he listened as his counsel moved for a new trial.
Fisherman & Farmer · 8 November 1895 · page 1
of the blow died away Holmes which was ordered recorded and g?ggg slowly recovered. He realized that his counsel was making a hied. worms from our child. Mra.Phrlcn.KUia.J.- TtTonnar'.B'Auii.vf K<Rhmim ifllntmnt. E. Byrum, $9.25, for board beat for skin eruptions. Fllea, bore, CuU,eto D.
The clipping reports that Holmes objected to entrusting his life to attorneys he did not know, and he was then asked whether he refused to allow these gentlemen to defend him.
The Pioneer Express · 8 November 1895 · page 1
Holmes, however, objected that as be knew nothing of these gentlemen, lie did not care to entrust his life to them. "Do you then refuse to allow these gentlemen to defend you?"
The clipping, partly garbled, reports a train injuring Murphy and 22 passengers, and states that Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was found guilty of murder in the first degree for killing Benjamin F. Pitezel, with his counsel moving for a new trial.
The Penn's Grove Record · 8 November 1895 · page 1
THEJOHJfTRY. Murphy and 22 passenger injured. Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H, Holmes, charged with killing iJemja* min F. Pitezel, was found guilty of murder in the first degree. His counsel moved for a new trial.
This badly damaged clipping is mostly unreadable, mentioning Fitzsimmons, Durrant, H. H. Holmes, and Corbett alongside a fragmentary reference to custom tailoring, but no coherent story can be made out.
The State Rights Democrat · 8 November 1895 · page 4
and Fitzsimmonsi the latter two making on'y one affliction. Durrant, H. H. Holmes and Corbett lflB art Custom Tailoring. Besides his regular business W. R.
The fragment declares that Holmes's blackest deeds confront and convict him, noting that if he had only faced trial for the murder of Pitezel it would be significant, though the sentence breaks off incomplete.
Sullivan Republican · 8 November 1895 · page 3
man is Holmes. If ever a man's blaoK deeds rose up to confront and convict him, that man is Holmes. If Holmes had only been in the dock for the murder of Pitezel, it is an
The clipping reports that the jury in the Commonwealth's case against Herman W. Mudget, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel in Philadelphia around September 1, 1894, returned a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree.
The Columbian · 8 November 1895 · page 8
The case of the Commonwealth against Herman W. Mudget: alias H, H. Holmes, charged with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezd in Philadelphia about the hrst of oeptember, 1804, was committed, to the hands of the jury Saturday afternoon. They came into Court Sunday evening with a verdict of guilty of murder in the first degree. HOLMES FOUND GUILTY.
The fragment reports that H. H. Holmes, also called Herman Mudgett, described as a swindler, bigamist, and murderer, has been found guilty of murder in a degree likely to send him to the gallows, though the OCR-damaged text garbles many details of his alleged crimes.
The Mitchell Capital · 8 November 1895 · page 4
Gallows Awaits Him. iry H. Holmes, otherwise Herman [udgett, swiudler, bigamist, murder arch lieud, has been arrested iu his Of crime by a verdict of murder in iWri it degree, that is likely to send him •:his many victims into the unknown id the grave. The monster who 'UiH|in Chicago a labyrinth to snare and ||BK|L.Uman game without detection, who Tj^iginnocent children without reason or "function, who made a pastime of be women, who waded through blood P loney, who robbed widows and or FEIPL
This single-item clipping describes the jury finding Holmes guilty of murdering Pitzel, his calm demeanor as the verdict and poll were read, and his counsel's motion for a new trial.
The Mitchell Capital · 8 November 1895 · page 4
HOLMES HEARS HIS DOOM
pressed with the gravity of his duty, turned to the twelve men iu the jury box, and, in slow, measured tones, said the fateful form: (v.^'Jurors, er, look on the jurors. How say you, gen pptjemen of the jury? Do you find the pris oner at the bar, Herman W. Mudgett, ?jilias H. H. Holmes, guilty of the murder fejflf Benjamin F. Pitzel, or not guilty?" IjSfThe spokesman of the twelve men had |ifilpt beeu touched with pity for the pris g»]aer, for he answered promptly, clearly iltnd without a shadow of feeling: "Guilty of murder in the first degree."
See moreSee less
The accused stood like a statue as the ||rerdict was being pronounced. There as no tremor in his shrunken form no ijtwitcliing of a lip. His marvelous self mastery had not forsaken him. There •Was a tighter clasp on a paper he held $n his hand, but the eyes rested on the 'Jury as though held by a mysterious magnet. At last Holmes relieved the ten sion by clearing his throat with a hoarse "hem" as he slowly sank into his seat, and the people moved in their seats and turned to make whispered comments. This remarkable criminal, however was to give yet another evidence of hi? self-possession. His counsel requestei the clerk to poll the jury, and each of tin twelve men reaffirmed the verdict whicl. their foreman had already given. As eacli name was called Holmes wrote it on the margin of the newspaper. There was no trembling of the fingers which guided the lead pencil, and the writer glanced up at each juryman in turn, as though fixing the face iu his memory. The Court made a formal record of the verdict, and Holmes' counsel made the expected motion for a uew trial. Holmes followed the proceedings in silence, and when an officer indicated that he was no longer wanted he arose alertly without protest or apparent reluctance, and start ed out of the courtroom. He was taken to his cellroom, and a few minutes latih left for the prison, where he will proba bly remain several months uutil his ap peal is passed on. Holmes spoke to his counsel, Rotan and Shoemaker, iu the cellroom before he was taken back to Moyamensing prison. To them he said: "1 feel that his condemns me. It was an unjust trial." The specific offense for which Holmes was tried was the murder of his confed erate in fraud, Pitzel. They had planned that the latter should insure his life, that a dead body procured in some way should be palmed off on the insurance company as that of Pitzel, and the money be col lected and divided. Holmes simplified matters by murdering Pitzel and getting rid of a partner who would have insisted on a division of the spoils. The only dis puted question was whether Pitzel com mitted suicide or wns murdered. The evi dence satisfied the jury that he did not kill himself, but was murdered. That being the case they had no difficulty in arriving at the conclusion that Holmes was the murderer. He alone had a mo tive, and he had abundant opportunity. Sis conduct subs'Xjuent to Pitssei's death Cttrntahed ample corroborative evidence. HOLMES HEARS look on the prisoner. Prison 1
The clipping describes a tense courtroom scene in which a man called Holmes stood motionless and unflinching as the jury foreman pronounced him guilty of murder in the first degree.
Shenandoah Herald · 8 November 1895 · page 2
HOLMES FOUND GUILTY
wound. The silence was painful | and every heart in that crowded room throbbed faster. The mun who was about to hear his doom pronounced stood erect in the dock the same deathlike pallor, which could grow no deeper, on his face. | He stared at the jary blankly, his hands clasped behind his back. Oace or twice he moistenad his lips with his tongne. There was no other rign of agitation. the usarl question, 3aid “Gilty of murder in the first degree” Holmes cleared his throat, bat his shrank en form never trembled, his Ips be trayed no qaiver—his maryeloas nerve had pot forsaken him. There was only a tighter clasp of th» hands folded belind him, \Vhea the foreman, In answer (0
Among a column of news briefs, this report says Holmes's trial for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel continued with him conducting his own defense, that he cried as Miss Georgeanna Yoke, whom he calls his wife, gave damaging evidence, and that the defense would offer no evidence but submit on argument alone.
Highland Recorder · 8 November 1895 · page 1
Court at Newberne, N. C.——The sherift | closed the Union Ten Per Cent. Clothing Store of Mitchell & Brother, in Reading, Pa., on attachments amounting to over &18,000, The claimants are twenty New York clothing I dealers,—E. K. Smith, of Columbia, Pa. was convicted of embezzlement.—T. B, Walker was shot and killed near Suwanee Tenn., by Will Henley.——In Philadelphi: the trial was continued of H. H, Holmes fo the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, the prisoner conducting his own defense,——The Pennsyl. vania Railroad ratified the traffic agreemen by which the trunk line pool is reformed, — The large steam flouring mill of E, H.
See moreSee less
Houser at Stoney Brook, York county, Pa., was de stroyed by fire, together with all its contents ——The trial of Robert Schall for the murde; of Richard Jordan at York, Pa., is attracting considerable attention.—The South Caro: lina constitutional convention voted dow the woman suffrage amendment, have been forced to stop work on account o the drouth. The stop effects 1,200 men,— An explosion of molten metal at the Carnegi blast furnaces, at Braddock, Pa., fatall) purned Joseph Schwapps and Mike Goski and slightly injured a number of other work men.—At Trenton, N. J., Prosecutor Stock ton nolle prossed the indictment against Mrs Theodore Prieth, and also the remaining in dietment against C. S. Robinson, Emil Kraut ler and Otte Heinz for conspiracy against th state in the matter of printing contracts,— Holmes lost Lis nerve and cried while Mis Georgeanna Yoke, the woman he persists i calling his wife, gave evidence damaging t his case. It is understood that the defens “will offer no evidence, but submit the case 0; argument alone,——The “trial of Rober “Schall, who was charged with the murder Richard Jordan, at York, Pa., ended in a verdict of acquittal.——Miss May Hamiltor aged eighteen years, committed suicide i her home, at Fostoria, O.——Bert Fox she his wife and committed suicide at Gree Springs, O.— Mrs, Harry E. Branch, of th Chicago Lyceum Theater, killed herself in a hotel at Indianapolis.——Miss Mary Fannin | of Cuba, N. Y., blew out the gas in a hotel i Richmond, and is now in a serious conditior ——8ome snow fell near Lexington and Ha: risonburg, Va.——Benjamin Chandler, age twenty-three years, was accidentally killed b his brother near Cape Charles, Va,——Eartl quake shocks were felt in many places in th West and South. Nobody was killed, bu buildings were damaged in several cities, Three coal contractors at Hazleton, Pa. + rr II
Among a column of news briefs, this report says Hermon W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with killing Benjamin F. Pitezel for insurance money, was found guilty of murder in the first degree, with his counsel moving for a new trial.
Vermont Phœnix · 8 November 1895 · page 8
stantaneous. Newell Paine of Boston has given the Kellogg-IIubbard library at Montpelier a collection of more than 1000 well selected volumes from the library of the late Dr. Ezra Paine, his father. The mare Trill, record 2:35, owned by Fred Eirkwood, was almost Instantly killed Tuesday evening at Bennington by being run Into by a team that was going in an opposite direction. George Williamson of Warren, 10, was found guilty of ten offenses of liquor sell ing In tbe county court at Montpelier this week, and sentenced to pay a fine of $500, with the alternative sentence of three years in the house of correction.
See moreSee less
Tho quarries at Fair Haven, owned by Mlnogue &. Greer, will this week ship a car load of roofing slate to a point In South America, which will necessitate Its being transported about 200 miles over the Andes mountains on pack mules. Ilermon W. Mudgett, alias II. IT. Holmes, charged with killing Benjamin F. Pltezel, was found guilty on Saturday night of murder in the first degree. His counsel moved for a new trial, Holmes killed Pitezel in order to get Insurance money. Holmes's career, which has been reviewed in The Phoenix, tends to show that he is the arch-criminal of the country and that he deliberately murdered 10 to 12 persons. The school statistics of this country are decidedly Imposing. According to the re houses was 230,420, valued at $308,435, 030, and conducted at an annual cost of $105,000,000. The male teachers num 054. The public schools alone were at number of pupils enrolled in schools and colleges was 16,083,030, or 22.5 per cent of the total population. port of the United States School commis sioner for 1602-3 the number of school bered 122,050 and the female teach eas 200, tended by 13,510,718 pupils. The whole