As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

October 1895

249 articles

The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn.

A roundup notes frost in Kansas and Missouri, a Cuban presidential choice, a trial date set for a murder case, a steel mill strike's end, and a church's call to a co-pastor.

The Redwood Gazette · 3 October 1895 · page 8

SUMMARY OF WEEK'S NEWS Sunday night. dent of the Cuban republic. murder of B. F. Pietzel has been set down for trial Oct. 28, at Philadelphia. Iron and Steel company's mill at Pitts burg has been declared off, the men notifying the firm of their willingness to return at the company's terms. terian church at Washington has voted to extend a call to Rev. T. De Wirt Tal mage to be co-pastor. Mr. and Mrs. Cleveland are members of this church. Tuesday, Sept. 84. Frost occurred in Kansas and Missouri Bartola Masso has been chosen presi The trial of H. H. Holmes for the The strike of finishers at the Oliver The congregation of the First Presby

See the clipping

Bellows Falls Times · Bellows Falls, Vt.

The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was arraigned before Judge Finletter in Philadelphia on a murder indictment, pleaded not guilty, and had his trial set for October 28 despite his counsel's objection.

Bellows Falls Times · 3 October 1895 · page 8

Holmes, wa arraigned before Judare Finletter, at Philadelphia, in court of oyer ana terminer last week on the indictment charging him with the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel in that city on September 2, 1894. Upon the advice of his counsel the prisoner pieaaea not guilty, uistnct Attorney Graham asked that Monday, October zs, De nxea ior me Beginning of the trial. Holmes' counsel objected to this date, but tne judge, alter hearing argu meut on both sides, stated that he thought October 28 would give the defence sufficient time in which to pre the-trial be set down for that dav with the understanding that when the time arrived neither side could expect to come into court and obtain a continu ance on paltry excuses.

See moreSee less

Holmes Pleaded Not Guilty. Herman W. Mudeett. alias H. H. pare its case. He then ordered that

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

Delegates from Irish organizations gather in Chicago for a national convention on Irish independence, while in Philadelphia Herman M. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, is arraigned for murder, with the account cut off mid-sentence.

Grant County Herald · 3 October 1895 · page 7

For Irish lndr|>eii<lence. Chicago, Sept. 23. —Delegates from th* different Irish organizations throughout country are already arriving in the city to attend the national convention The con vention will lx? held at the hall of the Young Men’s Christian association and the sessions will continue three days. The object of the meeting is to devise waysand means best suited to the accomplish ment of Ireland's independence. Holmes Pleads Not Guilty. Philadelphia, Sept. 23.—Herman M. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was ar raigned before Judge Fi nolet ter in the court of oyer and terminer on the indict ment charging him with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitxel on Sept. 2, 1894. Upon the advice of his counsel the prisoner

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · and 3 other papers

The clipping sarcastically invites anyone not murdered by H. H. Holmes to stand and be counted, then trails off mid-sentence about waiting for Uncle Sam to act.

The American Citizen · 4 October 1895 · page 3

All those who have not been mur dered by H. H. Holmes will please rise and remain standing until counted. Wait until Uncle Sam gets ready to

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Wheatland World · Wheatland, Wyo. · 20 September 1895
  • Platte Valley Lyre · Saratoga, Wyo. · 26 September 1895
  • The San Juan Times · Farmington, N.M. · 1 November 1895

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

The German-language clipping reports a request to police to arrest or pursue William Wood, a former printing shop owner whose shop at 63rd and Sherman stood opposite H. H. Holmes's house.

Abendblatt · 4 October 1895 · page 4

mittel zu erhöhen, sondern die hochwohl löbliche Polizei zu ersuchen, William Wood, einen Druckereibesitzer, der früher daselbst gewohnt, einzusperren resp. ihn, wenn : hier nicht mehr zu bekommen wäre, zu ver—- folgen. Besagter Wood betrieb früher an der Ecke der 63. und Sherman e gegenüber dem Hause des berüchtigten H H. Holmes eine Druckerei. Anfangs ging

See the clipping

Eagle River Democrat · Eagle River, Wis.

H. H. Holmes, indicted in Philadelphia for the Pitezel murders, told a reporter he was denied a pet bird or violin in prison. He recounted secretly incubating a raw egg by a heat register until it hatched into a chick, which later died from lack of sunlight.

Eagle River Democrat · 7 October 1895 · page 8

HATCHED A COMPANION. Queer Treat of Holmes, the Alleged Mur derer of the Peitzels and Others, H. H. Holmes, the alleged poly-mur derous convict, who is under indictment at Philadelphia, tkus unbosomed himselt to “Megargee”’ of the Philadelphia Times: “If they would only let me have a canary bird in my cell or permit me the use of a violin upon which I could play, either would be a companion and relieve the ter rible monotony of prison life as it is regu lated in this city. I have asked for such privileges, but they have been denied me, For awhile, however’—and here Holmes laughed merrily—*l had a companion ot which the keepers had no knowledge.

See moreSee less

1 am permitted to obtain food from the outside at my own expense and once a week I am supplied with raw eggs, which I eat without cooking. Last spring, when the prison was artificially heated, 1 covered one of these eggs snugly and kept it beside the hot air register. In twenty-one days a little chick pecked its way through the shell. For one month it was my joy and solace. @ 'When the keepers visited me I hid it benéath my bed, but there was no sun to warm its young life and it sickened and died. No words can tell what that loss meant to me.”’

See the clipping

The State Herald · Holyoke, Colo.

The fragment states that Fraker and Holmes pursued life insurance companies by different methods but both ended up in jail, noting that H. H. Holmes, the alleged murderer, never touched intoxicants.

The State Herald · 11 October 1895 · page 2

Fraker and Holmes went after the life Insurance companies In different ways, but they reached tho satno result—the JalL H. H. Holmes, tho alleged murderer, never touched intoxlcnnts, but thore's

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

The clipping jokes that those not murdered by H. H. Holmes should stand and be counted, then cuts off mid-sentence about waiting for Uncle Sam to act.

The American Citizen · 11 October 1895 · page 2

All those who hav» nut been mur dered by H. H. Holmes will please rise and remain standing until counted. ! Wait until Uncle Sam gets ready to

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

This garbled, fragmentary clipping mixes disjointed one-liners on subjects including a notorious murderer's victims, presidential politics, a boxing match, quinine for Spanish troops in Cuba, and Vanderbilt horse-buying, without coherent connecting text.

The American Citizen · 11 October 1895 · page 2

near future promises to take the of accumulations of portraits A Holmes’ victims. seen on Sundays, when the city spreads out over the neighboring counties hunt ing for something to drink. contains anything more impressive than the profound silence enshrouding the present group of presidential pos sibilities. average man inclines toward civil-ser vice reform. One is when he assumes office, and the other is when he is kicked out. ference. Dallas ministers declare the Corbett-Fitzsimmons fight would be a burning shame, and Manager Du Stewart says it will be a hot thing.

See moreSee less

pounds of quinine for the fever-stricka Spanish regulars in Cuba. Better gin them a little iron, too. General; & campaign seems to require a tonic. cook is to be seriously censured. 2 she was a good cook what right had ha to monopolize her, forever deprivisj the rest of humanity of her services! buke the foreigners who are trying to introduce bull-fights to this country 2 there were no danger of some impu^ person’s mentioning the subject^ prize-fights. into the Vanderbilt coffers, but uds-' cessfully. Just when hope had b*® abandoned William has shown his dis’ position to aid the public by buyiM race horses. west available for moving the new cW If handled well they will bring a P15 deal of stuff to market. Besides that there is a great fleet ready to enlist it the same work. Philadelphia, and Chicago to tars Holmes over to her she could sendo^ Campos and all his army home intrust Holmes with the entire job °* annihilating Cuba. One of the collecting manias o?d» The ideal Greater New York is nos It is doubtful if American history There are just two periods when the Th? point of view makes all the dif Gen. Campos has ordered 1,3 W The New York man who married his It vzould be an easier matter to re Everybody has been trying to bre*k There are 50,000 cars in the ne If Spain could persuade Toron* 01

See the clipping

The San Juan Times · Farmington, N.M.

This damaged fragment notes that two girls named Minnie Williams were recently murdered, allegedly by Holmes in Chicago and by Durrant in San Francisco, then shifts to musings on bicycles replacing elopements and on cruel riding or driving habits.

The San Juan Times · 11 October 1895 · page 2

linnie Williams is an unfortunate e. Two girls bearing the name been murdered recently, one, it Leged, by H. H. Holmes in Chithe other, it is alleged, by TheoDurant in San Francisco. l-date fathers with charmlig ers must needs learn to ride the The young people have disthe advantages of the wheel as l6ry to the elopement act, and ler on horseback, unless he owns 'not in it." stooper is no more cruel to in the driver who hogs his sad up in the air is to that rhe stooper, in fact, may be descendant of the hog-bridle ithstanding that his operain entirely different direc-

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Detective Geyer reappears in Indianapolis, testing a key found on Holmes at the Irvington house where Pitzel was murdered and burned, confirms it fits, and arranges to take witnesses and the boy's remains and clothing to Philadelphia on the 26th.

Waterbury Democrat · 12 October 1895 · page 3

HOLMES CASE AGAIN. Detective Geyer Brings to Usht Additions INDIANAPOLIS, Oct. 12. Interest in thi H. H. Holmes case Is revived hero by thi reappearance of Detective Geyer of Phila delphia. He turned up unexpectedly il Irvington, going to the houso whore How ard Pitzel was murdered and his bodj burned. Geyer fitted a key from his pock efc in the front door nightlatch. It worked perfectly. The key had besn found on thi person of Holmes after hi3 arrest in Phil' adelphia. Dr. Thompson, who lived in the houci beforo Hclmcs occupied it, recoguized thi key as the one ho had himself carried fo: two years.

See moreSee less

Geyer arranged to take Dr Thompson, Dr. Byram and other witnes3 es from Irvington to Philadelphia on Oots 26. Ho will take with him tbe remains o the Pitzel boy, including the teeth, mount ed. He will also tako the clothes identi fiod by the family. Evidence.

See the clipping

In the story →

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif. · and 4 other papers

Detective Geyer tested a key found on Holmes in Philadelphia at the Irvington house where Howard Pitzel was murdered, and it fit the front door latch, confirming identification; Geyer plans to take Dr. Thompson, Dr. Byram, and other witnesses along with the Pitzel boy's remains to Philadelphia on October 26.

The San Francisco Call · 12 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

EVIDENCE AGAINST HOLMES. He Carried a Key to the Cottage Where Pitzel Was Murdered. INDIANAPOLIS, Ind., Oct. 11.—Interest in the H. H. Holmes case was revived here to-day by the reappearance of Detective Geyer of Philadelphia. He turned up unexpectedly in Irvington this afternoon. Going to the house where Howard Pitzel was murdered and his body burned Geyer fitted a key from his pocket in the front door night latch. It worked perfectly. The key had been found on the person of Holmes after his arrest in Philadelphia. Dr. Thompson, who lived in the house before Holmes occupied it, recognized the key as the one he had himself carried for two years.

See moreSee less

The detectives regard to-day's discovery as final in identifying Holmes as the man who moved into the house with Howard Pitzel. Geyer has arranged to take Dr. Thompson, Dr. Byram and other witnesses from Irvington to Philadelphia on October 26. He will take with him the remains of the Pitzel boy.

See the clipping

Also printed in 4 papers
  • The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif. · 12 October 1895
  • New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y. · 12 October 1895
  • The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa. · 12 October 1895
  • Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va. · 12 October 1895

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Detective Frank Geyer returned to Irvington and tested a key found on H. H. Holmes after his arrest in Philadelphia, fitting it to the night latch of the house where Howard Pitezel was murdered and his body burned. Dr. Thompson, a former occupant of the house, recognized the key as one he had carried for two years.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 12 October 1895 · page 3

terday by tho reappearance of Detective Geyer, of Philadelphia. He turned up expectedly In Irvington, and going to the h where Howard Pitezei dered and his body burned Goyer fitted a key from his pooket in tho front door night lAtch. It worked perfectly. The key had been found the person of Holmes after his arrest in Philadelphia. Dr. Thompson, who lived in the house be fore Holmes occupied It, recognized tho key as the he had himself carried for two years. On the Retired Lilt of Washington, Oct. 12.—Colonel George

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

The clipping reports a new Durrant court session set for Tuesday, describes a Fort Wayne clerk called John Smith inheriting a German barony and estates, and notes a Philadelphia detective's return reviving interest in the Holmes case.

Abendblatt · 12 October 1895 · page 2

Kirche ermordet aufgefunden wurde. Außer Durrant wurde gestern Chas. T. Lenahan nochmals vernommen, den Pfandleiher Op— penheim irrthümlich für Durrant gehalten hatte. Die nächste Gerichtssitzung wird am Dienstag stattfinden. Fort Wayne, Ind., 11. Okltbr. Ein hier ansässiger junger Mann, der sich John Smith nennt und in einem hiesigen Musikaliengeschäft angestellt ist, erhielt heute von dem deutschen Consul in New York die Nachricht, daß sein älterer Bruder, Baron von Seckendorf, gestorben sei. „Smith“ erbt dadurch den Baronstitel und mehrere, in verschiedenen Theilen Deutschlands lie— gende Güter im Werthe von einigen Millio— nen, und wird zugleich Mitglied des preu— ßischen Herrenhauses.

See moreSee less

Eine Schwester des Barons ist die Gattin des Fürsten Windisch— grätz, der sich gegenwärtig in Amerika be—- findet und. heute oder morgen hier eintref fen wird. Der Baron wird ihn zu veran—- lassen suchen, bis zu Fort Wayne's Centen—- nial-Feier in nächster Woche hier zu bleiben und wird dann die Reise in die alte Heimath antreben. Ein hiesiger Zeitungsberichter statter Namens Ludwig Balthasar, mit dem er intim befreundet ist, wird ihn begleiten und eine gute Anstellung auf einem seiner Güter erhalten. Indianapolis, Ind., 11. Olt. Das Interesse an dem Falle des H. H. Holmes wurde heute durch das Wiederein— treffen des Geheimpolizisten Geher von Phi— ladelphia von Neuem wachgerufen. Der Beamte erschien heute Morgen ganz uner—

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The clipping, a brief fragment from Indianapolis, reports that interest in the H. H. Holmes case was revived by the reappearance of Detective Geyer of Philadelphia, but the text breaks off incomplete.

The Salt Lake Herald · 12 October 1895 · page 1

INDIAiNArPOLIS Ind Oct 11 In terest in the H H Holmes case was revived here today by the reappear ance of Detective Geyer of Philadel I

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

Printed in German, this report says detective Geyer of Philadelphia unexpectedly arrived in Irvington and went to the house where Howard Pithel was murdered, amid renewed interest in the Holmes murder case, while a separate note mentions a pending Supreme Court decision.

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 12 October 1895 · page 1

egenwärtig das Supremegericht. Die eun ob Letzteres das ſiciheii des unteren Gerichts beſtätigen wird, wird viel erörtert. Die Entiſcheidung ſoll mocgen abgegeben werden. Der o meo· all ſlndianapolis, Ind., 11. Ott Das Intereſſe in der Angelegenhen von H. H. Holmes, der des vielfaſten Mordes beſchuldigt wird, wurde heute durch das Erſcheinen des Geheimpoli~ ziſten Geyer von Philadelphia wieder erwecht. Ganz unvermuthet traf er heute Vormittag in Irvington ein, be~ gab ſich in das Haus, in welchem How— aͤrd Pithel ermordet worden iſt, und

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

Printed in German, this report sits among other items, describing a condemned man named Lyons writing a farewell letter before execution, and separately notes Geyer arranging for Dr. Thompson and other witnesses, plus Howard Pitzel's identified remains and clothing, to be brought to Philadelphia against Holmes.

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 12 October 1895 · page 1

Das Swaffot war im nordöſtlichen Flügel des County-Gefängniſſes auf~ geſtellt. Daſſelbe iſt 17 Fuß hoch, die Falltlappe befindet ſich etwa 814 Fuß vom Steinflur. Sämmtliche Ge fangene dieſes Flüaels wurden nach dem ſüdlichen überführt. Privatperſo— nen waren bei der Execution nicht zu— gecen, nur 40 Deputies, etwa 24 Ver— treter der Preſſe und die aus 12 Aerz ten beſtebende Juryh. Nachdem die Fury ſich davon überzeugt hatte daß das Leben dem Körper entflohen, wurde die Leiche an dem Knoten der Schlin~ ge hinter dem Ohre abgeſchnitten und der Leichenbeſtatter-Firma I. D.

See moreSee less

MeGrae und Bros., No. 399 Loomis Straße übergeben, welche die Leiche dem Bruder des Gerichteten, Edward Lyons, No. 47 Walnut Straße wohn—~ haft, zuſtellte. Letzterer hatte ſich die Erlaubniß erbeten, für das Begrä— niß Sorge iragen zu dürfen. Ein an derer Bruder des Gehenkten, Mathew Lyons und der Vater wohnen eben~ falls im Hauſe, No. 47 Walnut Str. Die Sicherheitswache wurde von der Oſt Chicago ~ Ave. - Polizeiſtation ge ſtellt. Lieutenant Loughren mit einer Vompagnie Poliziſten b~ſorate die Abſperrung. Louahren hatte vor acht Jehren ein Rencontre mit „Butch“ Lyons und zwar in dem damaligen „Wunderland“ Theater an der Ecke von Halſted und Congreß Straße. Lunons betruag ſich damals in dem Theater derartig deſperat. daß Louah—~ ren, der damals noch gewöhnlicher Pa trolman war ihn hinausbringen ſollte. Lyons zog ſeinen Revolver und gab drei Schüſſe auf Louahren aus unmit— telbarer Nähe ab. Glücklicher Weiſe traf leine der Kugeln. Seine letzte Nacht verbrachte Lyont ſchlaflos. Er rauchte naunterhrochen und hörte verſchiedene Geſchichten, die ihm von der Todtenwache, Pat. Gill— hooly und James Murphy, erzählt wurden, lächelnd an. Vorgeſtern Abend um neun Uhr theilte Sheriff Peaſe dem Todeskandidaten mit, daß der Goupereneur das Gnadengeſuch abaelehnt habe. Auch dieſe Nachticht nahm Lyons ruhig hin. Bis Nachts um 12 Uhr verblieb Vater Dore bei ihm, mit ihm betend. Lon Mitter~ nacht bettat Deputy-Sheriſff George Albriaht mehrere Rale das Todten~ zimmer und unterhielt ſich mit Lyons, ebenſo Deputy-~Sheriff Capt. Calder. Von 3 bis 5 Uhr ſchrieb Lyons einen Brief an ſeinen Bruder M. Lyons, ſchloß dieſen und ließ ſich dann eine Brieſmarle geben, mit der er den Brief verſah. Capt. Calder wollte den Brief beſorgen. doch aab Lyons denſelben ſeinem Morgens um 6 Uhr eintref~ fenden Vertheidiger. Auf ſpeziellen Wunſch des Todes-Candidaten wurde der Gaſtwirth Tom. Burle, Ecle Divi~ ſion und Nord Clart Straße, gerufen. der bis zum früh:n Morgen bei ihm blieb. — : ſeive in Philadelphia verhaftet wurde. Dt. Thompſon, der vor Holmes das,/ Haus bewohnte, identificirte den Schlüſ~ ſel als denjenigen, der er zwei Jahre lang benutzt hatte. Geyer traf Vor~ tehrungen, um Dr. Thompſon, Dr. Brhan und andere Zeugen nach Phila~ delphia zu bringen, um gegen Holmes aufzutreten. Außerdem nahm er die Ueberreſte und die von der Mutter iden~ tificirter Kleidungsſtücke Howard Pit~ zels mit ſich. Lie Federation of Labor. Peoria, 11., 11. Ott. In einer Verſammlung der Fede~ cation of Labor des Staates Illincis reichte heute Morgen da~s Comite einen Bericht in Bezug aut Sträflingsarheit ein. Au aleicher I witd di~ Leais~ erſchuna « veu —

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

A fragmentary report describes two masked men robbing Thompson's house after chloroforming him despite Mrs. Lafayette's escape, and separately says Detective Geyer found a key on H. H. Holmes that fit a night latch, identified by Dr. Thompson as his own.

The Times · 13 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES' TELL-TALE KEY

Kept most of his money in the house. Af ter supper Thompson was means near the parlor fire, his housekemer, Mrs, Lafa yette, near him. Suddenly the door was opened and two masked men entered, One threw Thompson to the floor and the other started to bind and gag Mrs, Lafa yotte, She darted through the door he. fore the thief could intercept her, Be fore Mrs, Lafayette couid alarm the neighbors the robbers had ehloformed Thompson and ransacked the whole house and escaped. They discovered the box in which Thompson Kept his money, and secured near Siv on, .

See moreSee less

Holmes Tetb-Tale Kev. INDIANAPOLIS, oct, W.—Detective Geyer, of Philadelphia, came here yes terday from livington, went to the house where Howard Pitezel was murdered and cremated, and found that a key that was | on H. H. Holmes’ person when he was arrested in Philadelphia fitted the nixht latch perfectly. Dr. Thompson, who lived in the house before Holmes occupied it, recognized the key as one he had himself carried for two years, Geyer arrauged to take Dr. Thompson, Dr. Byram and other witnesses {rom Irvington to Philadelphia on Uctober 26th. He will take algo the re.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This damaged clipping mixes a note about novel readers favoring fiction at a library with an unrelated mention of fabric goods and a key that fits the door of a house where a murder victim was found.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 13 October 1895 · page 4

took out instructive books. Novel readers are usually voracious, and most of the work of the library is now devoted actory goods for wear and wash Holmes pocket. It fits the door of the ing. Used for skirts, shirts, etc. house in which Pitzel was murdered.

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, among a column of news briefs this report says Philadelphia detective Geyer arrived to secure evidence against Holmes for the murder of old Pitzel, seeking to bring several witnesses, including a Mr. Nudel who had rented Holmes the house where the Pitzel girls' bodies were found, to Philadelphia.

Abendblatt · 15 October 1895 · page 2

forderte, die denn auch nach 48stündiger Vnterhandlung erfolgte. Der „Temps“ veröffentlicht ein Tele gramm, welches besagt, daß Antananarivo von 15,000 Hovas vertheidigt wurde, von denen 7000 mit Gewehren bewaffnet waren. Außerdem verfügten die Hovas über eine Anzahl Kanonen. Geheimpolizist Geyer von Philadelphia, der sich durch seine Thätigkeit in der Auf— hellung der von H. H. Holmes verübten Mordthaten einen Namen gemacht hat, traf heute Nachmittag hier ein, um Beweisma— terial zu sichern, welches gegen Holmes in dessen Prozeß wegen Ermordung des alten Pitzel benutzt werden kann. Er wird ver— suchen, sieben oder acht Zeugen von hier, darunter Herrn Nudel, von dem Holmes das Haus miethete, in dessen Keller die Leichen dr ermordeten Pitzel'schen Mädchen gefunden wurden, nach Philadelphia zu bringen.

See moreSee less

Kleinere Scharmützel der Regierungs— truppen und Insurgenten werden aus La—- vigneta, Pesso Sierra, Guanaja und Simo— nes gemeldet. Bei Cecalita haben die In—- surgenten den Sergeanten Gregorio Calve gefangen genommen, getödtet und seinen Leichnam verstümmelt. Ein kleiner, 20 Mann starker und von Alajandre Rodriguez befehlichter Freischärlerhaufen ist in Puerto Principe gelandet. New York, 14. Oktober. Die „World“ bringt heute Morgen fol— gende Depesche: Fu Tschau, China, 15. Okt. (Dienstag). Infolge der Unterredung, welche die engli—- schen Consuln mit ihm hatten, hat der Vice—- könig die sofortige Hinrichtung weiterer acht zehn Personen, welche der Ermordung von Missionären angeklagt waren, angeordnet. Die Consuln und der Taotai (Magistrat) sind ermächtigt, in Zukunft rechtsverbind—- liche Urtheile ohne Berufung an den Vice— tönig zu fällen. Diese Zugeständnisse sind der Anwesen heit von fünf britischen Kriegsschiffen zu verdantken. San Francisco, Cal., 14. Okt. Da der Hauptvertheidiger Theodore Dur— rant's durch einen Rheumatismusanfall an's Bett gefesselt ist, wird voraussichtlich in der morgigen Gerichtssitzung der Antrag gestellt werden, die Verhandlungen auf einige Tage auszusetzen. Falls der Gerichts hof, was wahrscheinlich ist, dem Antrage Folge leistet, wird der Prozeß schwerlich vor dem nächsten Montag seinen Fortgang nehmen. Mittlerweile verbleibt Durrant natürlich, der statt seiner früheren Sorg—- losigkeit und Gleichgültigkeit seit seinem Verhör vor Rüchter Murphy einen sorgen— Ernst, verbunden mit großer Ge— reiztheit an den Tag legt, in feiner Zelle, die er übrigens niemals verläßt, um im Korridor auf und ab zu gehen. Wie der Anwalt Dickinson heute bemerkie, hofft die Vertheidigung im Stande zu sein, in höchstens zwei Tagen den Rest ihres Ent lastumgsmaterials vorzubringen. Trotzdem dürfte mit den langwierigen Kreuzverhö— Doronto, 14. Ott. Havana, 14. Ott ——

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report says Geyer visited Detroit to persuade three local people to testify against Holmes at his trial starting October 28, and recounts how, a year earlier, Holmes had lodged two Pietzel children at Mrs. Burns's boarding house before they vanished and a rented house on Canfield Avenue was suspected as the murder site.

Abendblatt · 16 October 1895 · page 3

HH. Holmes ermordeten Pietzel Kinder zu finden, war vor wenigen Tagen in Detroit, um drei dortige Personen zu bewegen, als Zeugen gegen Holmes aufzutreten in dem Prozß, welcher am 28. Oktober beginnen und jedenfalls einer der sensationellsten Mordprozesse unserer Zeit werden wird. Am Sonntag war's ein Jahr seit Holmes mit zwei der PietzelKinder in Detroit eintraf und im New Western Hotel registrirte. Am nächsten Tage brachte er die Kinder im Kost haus der Frau Burns, 91 West-Congreß straße, unter und von dort verschwanden sie drei Tage später. Geyer hatte ermittelt, daß Holmes ein Haus in der Ost-Canfield Avenue in Detroit gemiethet hatte und anfangs alaubte man, daß die Kinder dort ermordet worden seien. Später wurden deren Leichen

See the clipping

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

Detective Geyer of Philadelphia returns to Indianapolis and travels to Irvington, where a key found on Holmes after his arrest perfectly fits the lock of the house where Howard Pitezel was murdered and burned. Dr. Thompson, a former resident, identifies the key, and Geyer arranges to bring him, Dr. Bryan, and other witnesses along with the boy's remains and identified clothing to Philadelphia on October 26.

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 16 October 1895 · page 2

Verbrecher und Verbxechen. H. H. Holmes. Das Interesse an· dem Falle des H. H. Hobmes wurde durch das Wiederein—- treffen des Geheimpolizisten Geher von Phi—- ladelphia von Neuem wachgerufen. Der Beamte erschien in Indianapolis ganz uner— wartet, woselbst er sich nach Irvington, dem Hause begab, wo Howard Pitzel ermor— det und dann verbrannt worden war. Mit einem bei Holmes nach seiner Verhaftung in Philadelphia gefundenen Schlüssel ver— suchte Geyer die Thüre aufzuschließen und siehe da, der Schlüssel paßte vollkommen in das für den Nachtschlüssel bestimmte Schlüsselloch. Dr. Thompson, der in dem Hause lebte, ehe Holmes dasselbe bezog, er kannte den Schlüssel als denjenigen, den er selbst zwei Jahre lang benutzt hatte.

See moreSee less

Geher traf dann Anstalten, um Dr. Thompson, Dr. Bryan und andere Zeugen von Irving— ton am 26. Oktober nach Philadelphia zu bringen. Er wird die Ueberbleibsel von Howard Pitzels Leiche, unter anderen auch die Zähne desselben und die von seiner Mut— ter identifizirten Kleider mitnehmen. Des Giftmeyers Mordlust. Sage, der Direktor des Zuchthauses in Sing Sing hat die Entdeckung gemacht, daß tr berüchtigte Giftdokttor Henry F. C. Meyher den Plan zu einem neuen Morde entworfen hat, seitdem er wegen des an Ludwig Brandt begangenen Giftmordes zu lebenslänglicher Zuchthausstrafe verurtheilt wurde. Das jetzt geplante Verbrechen ist dem an Brandt begangenen ähnlich und zielt auf die Erlanguna von Versicherungsgel— dern hin. Das auf diese Weise erlangte Geld, sollte dazu dienen, den Giftdoktor aus dem Gefängnisse zu befreien. Die Beweise dafür bestehen in Briefen und Notizen, die in Meyers Zelle gefunden wurden. Es scheint unzweifelhaft zu sein, daß es Meyer feit seiner Einsperrung ermöglicht hat, Briefe an seine Frau und an andere Personen zu schicken, und in diesen Briefen 01l er seinen Verbündeten Anweisungen gegeben haben, wie sie die gewünschte Ver sicherungspolice für das Leben des in Aus sicht genommenen Opfers zu erlangen hät— len und in welcher Weise der Plan ausge führt werden sollte. Während des Sommers waren Maurer und andere Handwerker im Zuchthause be schäftigt, und es wird vermuthet, daß es dem Sträfling dadurch gelungen ist, sich mit seinen Spießgesellen außerhalb des Ge— fängnisses in Verbindung zu setzen. Vor einiger Zeit übergab Meher dem Zuchthausgeistlichen einen Brief zur Besor— gung; derselbe war in deutscher Sprache geschrieben und an die Frau Meyer gerich lel. In demselben hieß es, daß er an einem gewissen Tage einen „underground“-Brief schicken würde, in welchem das zu verwen— dende Recept angegeben sei. Aus dem In—- halt des Briefes ging deutlich hervor, daß Meyer bereits mehr Briefe vermittelst der „underground“-Post befördert hatte. Der Direktor Sage ordnete deshalb eine genaue Durchsuchung von Meyers Zelle an, wobei Briefe, Notizen und andere Beweise gefun den wurden, welche die Behörden auf die Spur dieses neuen Verbrechens führten. Er-Pastor Wagner's Schwulitäten. Dominick Wagner bekannte sich, als in St. Joseph Mich.; die vier gegen ihn vorgebrachten Antklagen aufgerufen wurden, nichtschuldig. Der Verhandlungstermin wurde auf den 17. Okltober festgesetzt, und zwar wird sich Wagner zuerst auf die Anklage wegen Un—- terschlagung zu verantworten haben. Wagner soll bei seinen Schwindelpraktiken sehr ver wegen zu Werke gegangen sein. So wird behauptet, daß er der Gemeinde gehörige Gelder, die er vorher der Kirchenkasse ent nommen hatte, im Namen seines Bruders dem Bischof Burke zum Besten der Kirche geliehen hat. Der Angeklagte erschien im gewöhnlichen bürgerlichen Anzug vor Gericht. Moörder verhaftet. Tom Adams von Benton, 111., wurde am Sonntag Abend auf einen in Cairo ausgestell ten Haftbefehl hin unter der Anklage der Er— mordung des I. I. Malone verhaftet. Ma— lene, Adams und George Hindman waren am 15. April zusammen in Cairo. Malone verschwand plötzlich und einige Tage später wurde seine Leiche imMississippi treibend ge funden. Da sich Spuren von Gewaltthat an

See the clipping

The Sioux County Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes will be tried October 23 for killing Benjamin Y. Pietzel, citing costs for bringing witnesses, an additional appropriation secured by the district attorney, and notes on Mrs. Pietzel and Mrs. Howard, described as Holmes's third living wife.

The Sioux County Journal · 17 October 1895 · page 2

weaving about H. H. Holmes, who is to be put on trial here October U3, on '.he diarge of killing Benjamin Y. PlelZel. It Is Said that the cost of lirinclng the commonwealth's witnesses here will 1 S2.5U). The district atiomey has sec jrrd an additional spproprtH lion of g:l,0 for the cane. Mrs. 1'iet tel. who is now at her home in Illinois, will be here in two or three weeks with tier two remaining children. Airs. Howard, the third living wife of Holmes, is in constant communication with the oflicers of the commonwealth Hid within easy reach. Can't II I p the t ut.

See the clipping

The Sioux County Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

This damaged clipping mentions H. H. Holmes, due to be tried October 23 for killing Benjamin Y. Pietzel, and references the cost of bringing something, but the rest of the text is illegible.

The Sioux County Journal · 17 October 1895 · page 2

weaving about H. H. Holmes, who is to be put on trial here October U3, on '.he diarge of killing Benjamin Y. PlelZel. It Is Said that the cost of lirinclng

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.

Detective Geyer of Philadelphia traveled to Irvington and successfully fitted a key found on Holmes into the nightlatch of the house where Howard Pitezel was killed and burned. The key was identified by a previous resident, Dr. Thompson, as one he had carried for two years, and Geyer arranged to bring witnesses and evidence, including the boy's remains, to Philadelphia.

Eagle River Review · 17 October 1895 · page 2

MHOLMES KEY FITS. ! 9 > T ) ———e, Detective Tries it in the Door of the House Where Howard Pitzel was Killed. Indianapolis, Ind., Oct. 11.—Interest in the H. H. Holmes case was revived here today by the reapoearance of De tective Geyer of Philadelphia. e turned up in Irvington this forenocon, going to the house where Howard I'it zel was murdered and his body burned. Geyer fitted a key from his pocket in the front door nightlatech. It worked per fectly. The key had been found on the person of Holmes after his arrest in Philadelphia.

See moreSee less

Dr. Thompson, who lived in the house before Holmes cccubnied it, recognized the key as the one he had himself carried for two years. Geyer arranged to take Dr. Thompson, Dr. Byram and other witnesses from Irving ton to Philadelphia on Getober 28, Hao will take with bim the remains of the Pitzel boy. including the tecth, mounted. Ile will also take the clothes identified by the family.

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

Detective Geyer tested a key found on Holmes after his arrest, which fit the night latch of the house where Howard Pitzel lived and was recognized by Dr. Thompson as his own, and Geyer plans to take witnesses and the boy's remains to Philadelphia on Oct. 26.

Grant County Herald · 17 October 1895 · page 5

m fiHoward Pitzel was murdered and his body burned, Geyer fitted a key from his pocket in the front door night latch. It worked perfectly. The key had been found on the person of Holmes after his arrest in Philadelphia. Dr Thompson, who lived in the house be fore Holmes occupied it. recognized the key as one he had himself carried for years Tlie detectives regard the discov ery as final in identifying Holmes as the man who moved into the house with How ard Pitzel. Geyer has arranged to take Dr. Thompso.'. Dr Byram, and other witnesses from Irvington to Philadelphia cn Oct. 2t>. He will take with him tlie re mains of tl«- Pitz.el boy. HOWARD PITZEL.

See the clipping

Sullivan Republican · Laporte, Pa.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Detective Geyer arrived in Toronto to secure evidence, including testimony from a man named Nudel and his daughter who allegedly rented Holmes the house where children's skeletons were found, for use in Holmes's trial for the murder of Pitezel in Philadelphia.

Sullivan Republican · 18 October 1895 · page 3

The many friends of Mr. and Mrs. L'. B. Cole, who reside at a distance from here, will regret to learn that ihey are still confined In the asylum at Danville. While "Dent," as he was familiiarly called, is enjoying health physically, his mental powers have not improved, with no i probabilities of recovery in the future. Mrs. Cole is also enjoying good bodily health, ber mental powers have improved somewhat but she is still afflicted with that dread char acteristic of her malady—melan choly. The case of Mr. and Mrs Cole is a peculiarly sad one and ap peals to the deepest sympathy of all their fricuds, yet all are powerless to aid them in their sad mental afflictions.

See moreSee less

A'l is being done for them that medical science, and skill can suggest, and we trust their re covery may yet result from thorough treatment.—Benton .1 rgua, Mr. and Mrs. Ilussel Karns and Mr. and Mrs. S. B. Karns of Laporte paid Mr. and Mrs. Cole a visit at the Danville Asylum on Thursday ol last week. Mrs. F. W. Meylert ol Lnporte, U quite ill. She has been suffering with a bail cold for several days past, and was taken with a coughing spell at the funeral of Mrs. Mason and re turned to her home. Dr. Voorhees is in att 11 dance. ile|er'» Evidence. Toronto, Oct., 14.—Detective Geycr, who has made himself famous in the Holmes' case came to Toronto 1 this afiornoon to secure evidence that may be used again ts Holmes at his trial for the murder of Pitezel. He will endeavor to secure the atten dance of seven or eight witnesses from here, among whom will be Mr. Xudel and daughter, from whom Holmes is alleged to have reuted the house in the cellar of which the skeletons of the murdered children were found. Geycr does not think that Holmes will ever be tried iu Toronto, as he claims he has a complete chain of evidence against him for the murder of I'ite/.el, in Philadelphia.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A self-styled mind reader named Tyndall writes to attorneys offering to hypnotize accused murderer H. H. Holmes to compel the truth about the crimes he is alleged to have committed, citing past cases where hypnotism proved an accused person's innocence.

The San Francisco Call · 19 October 1895 · page 3

TYNDALL'S LATEST EFFUSION

TYXI>AL,TSS LATEST EFFUSIOX. The SoCalled MindHeader Wants to Hypnotize Hohnea. SAN BERNARDINO, Cal.. Oct. 18.— Professor Tyndall, the so-calied mind reader, ha? sent a letter to the attorneys with a series of murders, in which he says: "Having used hypnotism with more or less success in criminal cases, and having proved the guilty guilty and the innocent innocent by compelling accused persons to tell the truth under hypnotic influence, I am prepared to make the following offer: I will place H. H. Holmes, the alleged murderer of Minnie "Williams and others, in what is called perfect state of hypnotism and compel him to tell the truth in regard to the particular crimes he is said to be guilty of.

See moreSee less

If innocent he will doubtless make statements and prove an alibi for gotten in a natural state, which under hypnotic influence would come out vividly and be the subject of proof; but if guilty he had better keep away from hypnotism, for the truth will come out and his guilt be proven." Tyndall cites the proving of the inno cence of James O'Brien, arrested in Los Angeles as Lee Harrold, the Rio Vista murderer, and other instances and con cludes: "I make the above proposition to you in the interests of science and the prisoner if innocent."

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

This damaged German-language fragment states that H. Holmes and his daughter Dessa are in the city, and notes that detective Geyer had visited them at their home in the West, before breaking off mid-sentence.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 21 October 1895 · page 6

Frau Pietzel in Philadelphia

H. Holmes, nebst ihrer Tochter Dessa iit der Stadt weilt. Geheimpolizist Geyer hatte sie auf seiner letzten Reise nach dem Westen in ihrem Heim in

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A Portland, Mich. dispatch reports that Pat Quinlan, known for his connection to the H.H. Holmes case, threatens to commence proceedings against the Chicago police and newspapers.

The Evening Times · 23 October 1895 · page 1

ThrentensProceedliiR Against tbePo Portland, Mich., Oct. 23. Pat Qulnlan, notorious through his connection with the celebrated H.H. Holmes case, threatens to commence proceedings against the Chicago PAT QULNLAX MAD. llce nnd .Newspapers.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The clipping, a fragment from the Philadelphia Record, begins an interview with H. H. Holmes, who is said to be charged with probably more murders than anyone, and notes he discusses anything with perfect calmness.

The Indianapolis Journal · 23 October 1895 · page 4

HOLMES IS FULL OF TALK. Rendr to Dlscnss Anything and Everythlna; with Perfect Calmness. Philadelphia Record. In an interview with H. H. Holmes, who Is charged with probably more murders

See the clipping

Der Fortschritt · New Ulm, Minn.

The clipping recounts how Geyer sought Detroit witnesses against Holmes before his trial starting October 28, describing the children's year-earlier stay at the New Western Hotel and Frau Burns's boarding house before their disappearance and the later discovery of their bodies in Toronto.

Der Fortschritt · 24 October 1895 · page 2

drei angeblich von H. H. Holmes et mordeten Pietzel^Kindet zu finden, war vor wenigen Tagen in Detroit, um drei dortige Personen zu bewegen, als Zeugen gegen Holmes aufzutreten in dem Prozeß, welcher am 28. Oktober beginnen und jedenfalls einer der sen sationellsten Mordprozesse unserer Zeit werden wird. Am Sonntagwar's ein Jahr seit Holmes mit zwei der Pie tzel Kinder in Detroit eintraf und im New Western Hotel regtstrirte. Am nächsten Tage brachte er die Kinder im Kösthaus der Frau Burns, 91 West-iCongreßstraße, unter und von dort verschwanden sie drei Tage spä ter. Geyer hatte ermittelt, daß Holmes ein Haus in der Ost-Cansield Avenue in Detroit gemiethet hatte und anfangs glaubte matt, daß die Kinder dort ermordet worden seien. Später wurden deren Leichen in Toronto und

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

The item wryly asks everyone not murdered by H. H. Holmes to stand and be counted, mocking the large number of suspected victims attributed to him.

The American Citizen · 25 October 1895 · page 3

All those w’ho have not been mur dered by H. H. Holmes will please rise and remain standing until counted.

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash. · and 2 other papers

This damaged clipping fragments two stories together, mentioning witnesses from several cities regarding a man named Holmes and separately describing a fierce gale over Lake Michigan with an incident causing screaming and confusion.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 28 October 1895 · page 2

FOR THE MURDER OF B. F. PITZEL

Boston. Chicago. Indianapolis, Irvington, 2nd., ad almost every city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. What revelations these witnesses will ChScaeo. Oct. 27—Lake Michigan was hanging limp. Women screamed, and ex swept by a terriffic gale today. During citement and confusion followed. Some the afternoon, from 1 to 3 o'clock, the shouted to bring him water. By some

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · 28 October 1895
  • The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 28 October 1895

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

The clipping describes preparations for Holmes' trial over the alleged murder of Pitzel, including jury selection difficulties, exclusion of the public, arrival of remains as evidence, and the prosecution and defense teams involved.

Waterbury Democrat · 28 October 1895 · page 1

JUSTICE IN PHILADELPHIA.

months traveling extensively throughout the country in search of evidence of Holmes' guilt, will be one of the princi pal witnesses for the commonwealth. The skull and portions of the body of Pitzel, as woll as the remains of the boy, Howard Pitzel, who is thought to have been mur exhibited during the course of tho trial. and he has signified his intention of hold terested can stand the strain. The prose cution is in the hands of District Attor while the interests of the prisoner are guarded by Messrs. Shoemaker and Ro lan, younr?

See moreSee less

members of the local bar. Con sequent upon the widespread publicity given ' ' case, it is feared that several days w bo occupied in securing a jury of mon who have not already formed de cided opinions concerning the guilt or in nocence of Holmes. mately the number of witnesses to be called on either side, but that there will be a goodly number Is apparent from tho precautions that will be taken to insuro thoir entrance to the courtroom. be admitted, and an increased corps of court officers, augmented by a detail of reserve policemen, will enforco this order at the doors. occurred more than a year ago. The body, burned and blackened as if by an explo Callowhlll street, this city, on Sept. 3. 1894, and as he had been known as an in that ho had met death by accident while experimenting. Subsequently the charge was made that Pitzel had been murdered by Holmes in an attempt to defraud the Fidolity Mutual Lifo association of Phil paid by the company to Mrs. Pitzel, who was supposed to have been a party to the conspiracy, Holmes having first introduced Pitzel to the company. 17, and Mrs. Pitzel is in custody as prob a speedy conclusion. found in the Irvington House, were brought to this city last night by Detecs carried in a small box and were immedi office, where they will be kept until such time as they will be brought into the case. velopments. Detective Geyer, who has been for dered by Holmes in,, Indianapolis, will be Judge Arnold will be upon the bench, ing three sessions a day morning, after noon and night so long as tho persons in ney Graham and a corps of assistants, Jfeis impo'siWo to learn errn approxi The Public Will Be Excluded. Announcement has been made that on ly those who have business therein will The murder of Pitzel, if murder it was, sion, was discovered in the house 1326 ventor named Perry the supposition was adelphia out of $10,000, which had been Holmes was arrested in Boston on Nov. ably the principal witness against him. There is a likelihood of the case con suming soveral weeks' time, unless un foreseen circumstances arise to bring it to The remains of young Howard Pitzel, tive Richards of Indianapolis. They were ately taken to District Attorney Graham's

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The clipping reports that the District Attorney in Philadelphia has finished preparations to prosecute H. H. Holmes for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, with the trial expected to start promptly at 10 o'clock the next morning.

The San Francisco Call · 28 October 1895 · page 1

TRIAL OF' HOLMES. Tlie Case Against the Charnal Souse Fiend Will be Called To-Day. PHILADELPHIA. Pa., Oct. 27.— The District Attorney has completed his prep aration for conducting the prosecution of H. H. Holmes on the charge of murdering Benjamin F. Pitzel, and when, to-morrow at 10 o'clock, the accused is placed in the dock it is confidently expected that there will be no further instance of the prover bial delays of the law, but that the case will be carried straight through to a prompt conclusion.

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

The clipping reports that remains of Pietzel and the boy Howard Pietzel will be shown at Holmes' trial under Judge Arnold, while separately describing letters suggesting Governor Clark would tolerate a private prizefight near Hot Springs if unadvertised.

The Herald · 28 October 1895 · page 1

traveling extensively throughout the country in search of evidence of Holmes' movements, and will be one ot tbo prin cipal witnesses for the commonwealth. The skull and portions of the body of Pletzel.as well as the remains ol tlie boy, Howard Pietzel, who is thought to have been murdered by Holmes in Indianap olis, will be exhibited during tbe course of tlie trial. Judge Arnold will be upon tha bench ami he has already signified his intent'on of holding three sessions a day —morning, afternoon and night—so long as the per sons interested can stand the strain.

See moreSee less

Tbe prosecution will be in the hands of Dis trict 1 Attorney Oraham ami a corps of as sistants, while the interests of the prison tory for the lighters. The fact that tbe Hot Springs Athletic Club has engaged a circus tent seems to indicate, however, that some private snot bas been selected. A close friend of Governor Clark lias been shown letters from Hot Springs which tend to confirm tbe belief that a fight will occur. One of these letters is said to have come from Attorney Martin, and stated that preparations were being made for a private tight. Governor Clark, in 1 speaking of this information, is said tn have remarked that lie did nut care how much they fought, as long as it was con ducted in private and without being ad vertised.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's trial for the murder of B. F. Pitezel began before Judge Arnold, with out-of-town witnesses present and courtroom access restricted to those directly connected to the case.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 28 October 1895 · page 3

MURDERER HOLMES ON TRIAL

Philadelphia, Oct. 28.—The trial of H. H. Holmes, for the murder of B. F. Pito eel was called this morning before Judge Arnold. There are a number of witnesses present from outside of tho city, and Mrs. Pitezel and her daughter, Dessa, will bo called by the prosecution. The trial prom ises to be of the most celebrated crirai nal case in tho history of Phlladelphl, and in order to avoid the overcrowding of the court room, orders have been Issued to allow in Its confines except those directly associated with tho case. A

See the clipping

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that the case against Holmes will proceed quickly, with the identities and travel of out-of-state witnesses being kept confidential by both prosecution and defense.

The Morning Times · 28 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES' TRIAL TO BEGIN

of the law, but that the case will be carried straight through to a prompt con clusion. The movements of the witnesses, many of whom will liave to Journey from other States, are being kept quiet, both by the prosecution and the defense. Just who they are or what light they-may be able to sheil on the scenes or tragedies with which Holmes stands accused, if possible, will be kept secret until such time as they

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

H. H. Holmes's defense counsel have resigned and he has refused court-appointed replacements, leaving him to act as his own lawyer. The report describes the courtroom scene in Philadelphia (the 'Quaker City') surrounding this development.

The Evening Times · 28 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES HIS OWN LAWYER

ard Pltezei, and also of the murder of various other persons In the famous Holmes elastic at Chicago. STORY OP THH ARREST. tary C. W. Daluiey, Thomas Nelson Page, I'ruf. Montague and other men. of nigf rank. 1 Besides Prof. Cabell, toe vice presidents It Is staled upon the same authority that over 150 Armenians were killed. The inliabitnuls ot llic-se villages had

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The fragment reports that Holmes refused the services of two attorneys, risking their disbarment, with a further sensation occurring just before his murder trial, though the text is too damaged to follow clearly.

The Evening Times · 28 October 1895 · page 1

notwithstanding an injunction from tho court that they would be open to disbar murder trial." Holmes refused to accept the services of Attorney! Everett A. Sehofield and Joseph. ment by taking such a step "ou the eveof a Stili further sensation was created wiien

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The clipping describes the opening of Holmes's murder trial before Judge Michael Arnold, detailing the courtroom security, the prosecution and defense attorneys present, and Holmes's appearance and demeanor as the jury panel was called.

Evening Star · 28 October 1895 · page 1

AN EVENTFUL SESSION Holmes. who, according to his own remark able confessions, stands at the head of the list of modern*crimInaia. was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminerthis morning for the murder of Benjamin Plettel. wealth's prosecutors were District Attorney George S. Graham and his special assistant, Thomas W. Barlow, while the counsel for the prisoner were Wiliam A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, young members of the junior bar of this city. Judge Michael Arnold was upon the bench. for the opening of the court room, on the sixth floor of the big city hall, a crowd be San to gather in the .corridors without.

See moreSee less

Thanks to the announcement that only those having business with the case would be admitted to the court room, there were not so many as were to have been expected. Every door of the room was barred and" guarded by a force of court offlicers, aided by a special detail of reserve policemen. and, in consequence of these admirable ar rangements, the witnesses, jurors and news paper men were accommodated without difficulty. By these means enough of the general public were admitted to well fill the room without uncomfortable crowdiig, and thereafter the doors were locked and no one else allowed to pass In. different parts of this country were escort ed into court shortly before 10 o'clock by Detective Frank Geper. --whs -travels thrdughout the United States in a search for evidence against Hol.-k sd1W re puted to have been conapicuously su'cess ful-have been from Wt16 time published. unmesning "Oyez, oyes," was pronounced by the crier, and as,-n--- --MMe arose, court was formally declared open. goWn, the wearing, of which is a new de parture with the Philadelphia jnilifdlary. was in his seat on the bench. Crier Hart immediately began the calng of the panel of jurors. B. - A moment later the Iron door of the large "cage " leading from the cell. oomaelenad, and Holmes was brought in by a tipstaff, and placed in the smaller dock is the center of the room, at the further corner of the jury box, imemediately back of his attorneys' table and surrpundsd. by the desks of the newspaper representatives. A stalwart officer stood at either s'de of the dock. Holmes, who has grown a full black heard since his confinsent in Moyamenaifig prison, looked pale and wan, but Imomacu lately neat. His hair was carefully parted, his beard trimmed almost to a poInt, and the black cheviot suit he wore was scrupu lously clean. He was plainiy nervous, and looked about 'the room. with a shifty bx pression in his steely blue eres. OWason ally he would lean forward and address a whispered word to his counsel, anM.on one occasion, as he glanced from right to left. a smile, forced and unreal, playedaboutthe corners of his thin lips. pearance of Mr. Shnsiaye of counsel for the defense, who did not lode 1tit vourt until 10:15 o'clocL ?lMs loed shook hands with Holmes, and, taing -t Mr. Graham instanty asked Ahat the .case proceed. formally told of hi. right to challenge jU rors. He received the "lformation Im passively. cluded, Mr. Shoemaker arose and asked for a continuance of the case. He urged as his basis the lack of time which had ham pered the preparation of the defense. In this case," he urged, "and we have had only as much time as would be adequate for the preparation of one." - obtained not only from distant points in this country, but also from abroad. which the defense have been unable to procure in the short space of t!me left to them since the fnding of the indictment-evidence wh'ch would be of the utmost Importance to the defense. The prosecution," Mr. Shoemaker added, "have been working on their case Uer three hundred days, while the defense -have had but sixty." fied In asking for . continuance of sixty days to give them an opportunity to gather their witnesses. Many of these would pre sent newly dscovered eidence of such vital Importance that Holmes would undoubtedly be acquitted of this charge, dress, Mir. Graham arose and said he would 'protest with all his vigor agaInst the grant lng of a continuance. After dwelling upon the difficulty and expense Io which the com monwealth had been put inI securing wit nesses, he declared that a postponement meant the absolute destruction of the com monwealth's base. No legal grounds had been laid for the request, but It was simply left to the court's d:scretion. strain under which Mrs. Pitesel has been put. and sid an examination Into her men tal cond~tion had made It apparent that were a continuance granted the commonwealth would lose Its most Important witness. plea for a respite. He arg ted that to properly try this case, they must be fully ad thiroughly informed of the other mur der chardes cgainst Holmes. But it wan not altogether a quest:on of lime, he went on. Money was needed to bring witnesses here, and, as it was generally known, Holmes has suflent asets to realise a goodly sum, were the extenslon allowed. Mr. Rotan also announced that within the rcast four or five days evidence had come to theIr knowledge which would put -an en' tirely dIfferent aspect upon the case. unable to go on wit this case. The de fense Is not prepared. This case has neres been postponed, snd the arrtignment w-as made only five weeks ago. If, as the coet monwealth asserts, Mtrs. Piteral is In adj unhealthy aste, we do not core to take. ad teimony to be takeft nos', or at any time. Or. If the commonwealth will agree not to introduce any' of the testimony bearinog uton the cases, we will go on at once. But, earn astly beg a cant nuance." tion for a continl nttce Is overruled." the defense bad been fuliy apprised that no such motIon would be entertain~ed. Such was still the case. Mr. Shoemaker and Mr. Retanl then creat ed a mild sensation by sayIng In turn to the court. If the judge's decision wasIrrevoc able they would withdraw from the case, hut Judge Arnold spdfled this boemerag by declaring that a member of the bar who would withdaw from at munter case en the PHILADELPHIA, October 28.-H. H. Arraigned against him as the common For nearly an hour before the time fixed The witnesses brought from Canada and Promptly at 10 o'cle. -the dismal 4ad Judge Arnold, clad - ia-Ms 40ag'"Tiatk HeilmesCee. . The first wait was caused by the sea-ap Holmes was thefi'btefetvd &-tsiaa&as The moment this formality had been con "There are three hom'cide cases involved "There is evidence," he continued, "to be Under these circumstances he' felt justi Protests Against Delay. At the conclusIon of Mr. Shoemaker's nd Br, Graham then dwelt upon the revere Mr. Rotan of the defense renewed the in conclusIon, he said: "We are utterly vantge f tat.We are willing to tralve th rgt ofth defendant. and allow ter otewshandIcapped as we are, we must Judge Arnold mnp'ly replied: "The mo He bredy called attention to the fact that P'rieonese Cosmmsel Withdraw.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The fragment reports that newly discovered evidence was of such vital importance that the accused would undoubtedly be acquitted, after which Mr. Graham rose to protest vigorously against a granted delay.

Evening Star · 28 October 1895 · page 1

sent newly dscovered eidence of such vital Importance that Holmes would undoubtedly be acquitted of this charge, Protests Against Delay. At the conclusIon of Mr. Shoemaker's nd dress, Mir. Graham arose and said he would 'protest with all his vigor agaInst the grant

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

This damaged fragment references Mudgett's first crime as less daring than a later one but formative, mentions lingering civic unrest, and begins a list of dead rioters before cutting off.

The Indianapolis Journal · 28 October 1895 · page 1

of the many crimes with which Holmes's name has been directly or Indirectly con to appear. Mudgett's first crime was not so daring as the last, but It served to harden his heart ably over, though the city is still in a fer ment. The dead rioters are:

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report says H. H. Holmes (Herman Mudgett) goes to trial tomorrow before Judge Arnold for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, having pleaded not guilty, with witnesses including detective Geyer and remains of Pitzel and his son Howard to be presented, District Attorney Graham prosecuting and attorneys Shoemaker and Rotan defending.

Abendblatt · 28 October 1895 · page 2

Philadelphia, Pa., 27. Okt. H. H. Holmes, oder wie er sich auch ge nannt hat, Herman Mudgett, von dessen ver ruchten Mordthaten monatelang in allen Zei tungen des Landes die Rede gewesen ist, wird morgen im hiesigen Oyer and Terminer Ge— richt prozessirt werden. Er wird sich wegen der Ermorbdung Benjamin F. Pitzel's zu ver antworten haben. Er hat bereits amtlich ertlärt, daß er nicht schuldig sei. Aus Bo— ston, Chicago, Indianapolis, Irvington, Ind., und fast aus jeder anderen Stadt, wo er sich aufgehalten, sind bereits Zeugen hier eingetroffen. Einer der Hauptzeugen ist der Geheimpolizist Geyer, der im ganzen Lande herumgereist ist, um Beweismaterial gegen Holmes zu sammeln.

See moreSee less

Der Schädel und Theile des Körpers Pitzel's, ferner die Ueber—- bleibsel der Leiche des Sohnes des Letzteren, Howard, der angeblich von Holmes in In— dianapolis ermordet worden ist, werden wäh— rend der Verhandlung vorgezeigt werden. Richter Arnold, vor dem der Prozeß zur Verhandlung kommt, hat bereits angekün diet, daß er täglich drei Sitzungen, Vormit tags, Nachmittags und Abends, abhalten wird, so lange die bei dem Falle interessirten Personen die Anstrengung aushalten können. Der Staat wird durch Distriktsanwalt Gra ham, dem eine Anzahl Assistenten zur Seite stehen werden, vertreten sein, während die Anwälte Shoemaker und Rotan die Verthei digung übernehmen werden. Die Zusam— menbringung der Jurh wird ohne Zweifel, da es schwer hält, Leute zu finden, die sich

See the clipping

Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report recounts Pitzel's charred body found in 1894, the insurance fraud allegation against Holmes, and notes Mrs. Pitzel will be the chief witness against him.

Abendblatt · 28 October 1895 · page 2

schuld des Angeklagten ein Urtheil gebildet en, längere Zeit in Anspruch nehmen. Pitzel's Ermordung, wenn er überhaupt er— mordet worden ist, ereignete sich vor etwas mehr als einem Jahre. Seine Leiche war am 3. Septbr. 1894 verbrannt und ge schwärzt, als wie in Folge einer Explosion, in dem Hause No. 1326 Callowhill gefun— den worden. Man vermuthete damals, Pitzel sei das Opfer eines Unfalles gewesen, wäh— rend er chemische Versuche angestellt habe. Später wurde dann behauptet, Pitzel sei von Holmes ermordet worden, um die Fi—- delity Mutual Life Association von Phila—- delphia, in der Pitzel versichert war, um die Versicherungssumme im Betrage von $lO,-- 006 zu beschwindeln.

See moreSee less

Das Geld war der Frau Pitzel bereits ausgezahlt worden, und es wurde gegen sie der Verdacht rege, daß sie in die Ermordung ihres Mannes verwickelt sei. Holmes wurde am 17. Novbr. vorigen Jahres in Boston verhaftet. Frau Pitzel, welche hier unter Bewachung ist, wird als Hauptzeugin gegen ihn auftreten. Wie lan ge der Prozeß dauern wird, darüber lassen

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

This damaged clipping fragment states that crimes linked to Holmes have received wide publicity and notes the cold, implacable demeanor he has shown throughout, but the text breaks off incomplete.

The Evening Bulletin · 28 October 1895 · page 1

ON TRIAL FOR HIS LIFE

crimes with which Holmes' name has been directly or indirectly connected have boon given such publicity and tho cold iniplucable demeanor which has characterized tho man throughout, has

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

This damaged clipping jumbles unrelated fragments, mentioning a man believed murdered by Holmes in Indianapolis, the son of a late general named Cepedes, and a vessel that ran aground near piers.

The Evening Bulletin · 28 October 1895 · page 1

ON TRIAL FOR HIS LIFE.

nwife and three small children. He was an excellent officer nnd cry pop Pietzel, who is thought to have Carlos Manuel Des Cepedes is tho been murdered by Holmes in Indianapo only son of tho lato General Cepedes. went aground just inside tho piers, list ed over to one sido several feet and lay

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

Among other items, this report says H. H. Holmes goes on trial today in Philadelphia's Court of Oyer and Terminer for the murder of Benjamin E. Pietzel, having pleaded not guilty, with witnesses gathered from several cities and sensational developments expected.

The Evening Bulletin · 28 October 1895 · page 1

EVENING BULLETIN for AtteinnMul Murder. ular. JUMPED 212 FEET derclothing and woie heavy leather MAYSVZLLE, KY., MONDAY, OCTOBER 28, 1895. ON TRIAL FOR HIS LIFH. SUCCOR FOR CUBANS II. II. Helmet Will Soon Face Ilia Aocui Philadelphia, Oct. 28. H. H. Arms and Men to Aid the Insurgents. Holmes, or Herman Mugett, whoso name or alios has rung throughout the length and breadth of tho continent ns tho most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of EXPEDITION ON THE HIGH SEAS. modern times, will bo placed on trial for his lifo to-day in the court of Oyer and Terminer of this city.

See moreSee less

Tho specific) Carlo .Manuel !. Oped, .Son nf the charge to which he will be called upon Former PreoliU'iit of the Cnliun Ito to answer is he murder of Benjamin E. public, Accompanied by Ncnrly One Pietzel, and he has already officially de Hundred Young .Men, All Well Armed, clared himself not guilty. Tho revolting details of the many Are Now En Ilouto to Cuba. crimes with which Holmes' name has New York, Oct. 28. Carlos Manuel been directly or indirectly connected Des CepedoB, son of the first presidont of have boon given such publicity and tho tho Cuban provincial republic of 20 cold iniplucable demeanor which has characterized tho man throughout, has years ago, is upon tho high seas, at the been so frequently commented upon, head of a secret expedition, which ex that tho trial will probably pass into pects to land in Cuba in a few days. Ho history as the most celebrated case is accompanied by nearly 100 enthusias known to tho criminal nnuals of tho tic young men, all armed, who have de Western Hemisphere. Tho common termined to fight tho Spaniards for Cu wealth has already expended thousands ba's liberation. of dollars in its effort to bring the pris The expedition was quietly filled out oner to summary justice, and there is this city during the past three months an indication that should a conviction juul no money was spared to make it n for murder in tho first degree be ob success. It started from tho Delawaro tained, ho will bo "railroaded" to tho gallows. iTer early last wok. Witnesses have leeu brought to this The vessel which carries Des Ccpcdes city from Button, Chicago, Indianapo and his men to Gt.ba is a largo schooner lis, Irvington, Ind., nnd almost every of the clipper stylo, fitted with rapid city where Holmes is known to have fire guns. Sho has in her hold 500 Win lived nt various times. What revolu chester and Remington rifles, 500,000 tions theso witnesses will make lias cartridges, two Gatling guns, 500 ma been kept a profound secret by the pros chetes and half a ton of dynamite. ecuting officers, but there is expectation Tho men who accompany Des Cepedes of sensational developments. Detective are well drilled suul uniformed. They Geyer, who has been for months I ravel received their military instructions in ing extensively throughout the country this city, and long before tho expedition in search of evidences of Holmes' move started, they wero trained to the use of ments, will bo ono of the principal wit the rifle, broadsword and machete. nesses for tho commonwealth. Tho Upon their arrival in Cuba, they expect skull and portions of the body of Piet.el, to join the regular revolutionary army so well as tho remains of the boy, Hoi -ard under General Maximo Gomez. Pietzel, who is thought to have Carlos Manuel Des Cepedes is tho been murdered by Holmes in Indianapo only son of tho lato General Cepedes. lis, ill be exhibited during the 'ourso He was born in this country 23 years of the trial. ago, nnd speaks English fluently. Judge Arnold will bo upon t'.ie bench Des Cepedes and his followers left and he has already signified his inten Jersey City for Philadelphia on Sunday. Hardy Act. tion of holding three sessions a day They did not all go over the same routo, but selected different ways to reach morning, afternoon and niltt so long as tho persons interested cm etuud tho their destination. Upon their arrival strain The prosecution will be in tho in Philadelphia, they went to different hands of Distinct Attorney Graham and hotels, and tho following morning, u corps of assistants, whilo the interests boarded a large ocean-going tug which ol tho pri&ouors will bo guarded by had been chartered to tako the party Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan, young down tho Delawaro. members of tho local bar. WAR NEWS FROM HAVANA. Consequent upon the widespread pub licity given tho case, it is feared thut Insurgents Mnko Advnuccn nnd lliuo several days will bo occupied iu secur Itetreut Austin. ing a jury of men who have not already Havana, Oct. 2S. Lieutenant of Vol formed decided opinions concerning tho nnteers Benin, with it detachment of V guilt or innocence of Holmes. troops surprised an insurgent band . It is impossiblo to learn evon approxi Acea, nt the farm of Luisa, killtl five of mately tho number of witnesses to bo called on either sido, but that there will them, and took three rifles. bo a goodly uumbcr is apparent from The prison nt Santa Clara is overflow tho precautions that will bo taken to in ing and 20 "olitical prisoners confined sure their entrance to the courtroom. thoro have been released and a numb' Announcement has been made that only of incendiaries, who were also amo. those who have business therein will bo tho prisoners, have been sent to Cieu admitted and an increased corps of court officers, augmented by a detail of fuegoes. Tho insurgents have burned the plan reserve jinlieomoii, will enforce this or tation of San Rafael in tho district nl der at tho doors. Remedies. Tho murder of Picvzel, if murder it Chief Mnnez, with 200 insurgents, at was, occurred more than a year ago. tacked the village of Abreuse, iu the The body, Vairned and blackened as if district of Cienfuegoes. They burned by tui explosion, was discovered in tho one store and ono citizen was hurt ai tho house, Xo. 1J12G Callowhill street, one volunteer was killed. The insuj this city, on Sept. !5, 1894, and as he had gents ictiied upon the upprouch of tin been known as an inventor named Per ry, tho girip(siti.ii was that ho had mot troops. Lieutenant Melinodo of tho battalion death by accidont whilo experimentimr. Cararias at Lajas, whilo laboring uni Subsequently tho charge was made that strong montal excitement, woiiudi . Pietzel had been murdered by Holmes in three soldiers, one of them seriously. an attempt to defraud the Fidelity Mu Ho was imprisoned and thereupon com tual Lite fsftociation of Philadelphia, mitted suicide. out of sjlo.000, which hud been paid by General Cumpos has signed the sent tho company to Mrs. Pietzel, who was ence of death of a soldier who deserted suppose to hue boon a party to the to tho insurgents at Barucoa und who cons iracy. HoJmos having first intro was nftcrwa d captured. duced Pietol to the company. The mayor of the town of Quomad" Holmes was arrested in Boston on Gmuiis, district of Sagun, with a fort Nov. 17 ami Mrs. Pietzel is in custody, of 20, fired upon a band of GO insurgent. as, probably, tho principal witness who left one killed upon their retreat. against him. The force f Captain Mala at tho plan There is a likelihood of the case con tation of Indio, district of Sagua, ha suming several weeks' lime, unless un capturod 20 wounded insurgents. foreseen circumstances arise to bring it to a speedy conclusion. No Cuban Day nt the Kxpnltlon. era In Court. Michigan. Vemeln. denly rolled up. until tho storm subsides. and the weather was clear. her. all on board would bo lost. again retired names of the injured: bruised about tho head.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The clipping reports that remains linked to the case will be exhibited at trial, Judge Arnold will hold three daily sessions, District Attorney Graham will lead the prosecution against Shoemaker and Rotan for the defense, and courtroom access will be restricted and policed.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 28 October 1895 · page 1

of the body of Pietzel, as' well as the remains of \ the | boy, Howard Pietzel, who is thought to have been murdered by Holmes in Indianapo lis, will be exhibited ' during the course of the trial. ~ " \ Judge Arnold will be ; upon the bench, and he has already signified his intention of holding three ses sions a day— morning, afternoon and night— so long as the persons inter ested can stand the strain. The prosecution will be in the hands of District Attorney Graham and a corps of assistants, while the inter ests of the prisoner will be guarded by Messrs.

See moreSee less

• Shoemaker : and Rotan, j young members of the local bar. . Consequent upon the wide-spread publicity given thecase, it is feared that several days will be occupied in securing a jury of men who have not already formed decided opin ions concerning the guilt or inno cence of Holmes. •' - : > •' It is impossible to learn 'even ap proximately the number of witnesses to be called on either, side, but that there will be a goodly number is ap parent from the precautions that will be taken to insure their entrance to the court room. - ;- Announcement has been made that only those who have business there in will be admitted and an increased corps of court officials, augmented by a detail of reserve policemen, will enforce this order at the doors.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This damaged clipping lists evening events (a performance and a charity ball) and shipping movements, then breaks into an incomplete fragment noting that Holmes' crimes and cold demeanor have been widely publicized.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 28 October 1895 · page 1

CHIEF OF FIENDS.

EVENTS TODAY. Grand— Katie Emitted. 8.15. Metropolitan — Charity Ball, 9. MOVEMENTS OF STEAMSHIPS. details of the many crimes with which Holmes' name has been di rectly or indirectly connected have been given such publicity, and the < cold, implacable demeanor which ! has characterized the man through- | out has been so frequently com

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A Philadelphia dispatch reports that H. H. Holmes, also called Herman Mudgett, will go on trial tomorrow for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, having pleaded not guilty.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 28 October 1895 · page 4

TRIAL OF H, H, HOLMES

He IUIiIMI.m!. Philadelphia, Oct. ST.-1I. II. Holme', or Herman Mudgrtt, whoe hatne or nlln tins rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent a the mot unscrupulous and skillful murderer or modern times, will be placed on trial for his life to-morrow morning In the court of oyer and terminer of thin city. The specific charge to which lip will lie called to answer l the murder of tlPiiJamlti V. Pletr.et, and he has already otllclnlly declared himself not guilty. The revolting details of the many crimes with which Holmes' .mime has been dlretly or lndlrpct connected have been given such

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The clipping reports that a detective's extensive travels gathering evidence will make him a key prosecution witness, that skeletal remains of Pletzel and a boy will be shown at trial, and that a judge will preside.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 28 October 1895 · page 4

TRIAL OF H. H. HOLMES

kepi a profound seciet by the prosecuting olllcers but there Is expectation of sen sational developments. Detective dryer, who has been ror mouths traveling exten sively throughout the country In search or evidence or Holmes' movements, will be one of the principal witnesses ror the com monwealth. The skull nnd portions or the body or l'letzel, ns well as the remains or the boy. Howard Pletzel, who Is thought to have been murdered by Holmes In Indian apolis, will b exhibited during the course of the trial. Judge Arnold will be upon the bench and he has already slgiilllcd his Intention of

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The fragment states that Pietzel, known as an inventor named Perry, died on a city street on September 2, 1894, apparently by accident, but it was later alleged Holmes murdered him in an insurance fraud scheme.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 28 October 1895 · page 4

TRIAL OF H. H. HOLMES.

lowhlll street, this city, on September :!, IS!) I, and as he had been known as an In ventor named Perry, the supposition was that he had met death by accident, while experimenting. Subsequently the charge was made that Pietzel had been murdered by Holmes, In nil attempt to defraud the

See the clipping

In the story →

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · and 1 other paper

The clipping reports that Detective Geyer and other secret witnesses will testify against Holmes, and that Pitzel's skull and remains, along with those of the boy Howard Pitzel, will be presented as evidence.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 28 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES ON TRIAL.

Stands Charged With the Murder of Benjamin E. Pitzel.

See moreSee less

WITNESSES FROM MANY CITIES.

Three Court Sessions Daily Until Trial Ends.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 28.—H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudget, whose name or alias has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times, was placed on trial for his life this morning in the court of oyer and terminer of this city.

The specific charge to which he is called upon to answer is the murder of Benjamin E. Pitzel, and he has already officially declared himself not guilty. The revolting details of the many crimes with which Holmes' name has been directly or indirectly connected have been given such publicity, and the cold, implacable demeanor which has characterized the man throughout has been so frequently commented upon, that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of the western hemisphere. The commonwealth has already expended thousands of dollars in its efforts to bring the prisoner to summary justice, and there is an indication that, should a conviction for murder in the first degree be obtained, he will be "railroaded" to the gallows.

Prosecution's Plans Kept Secret.

Witnesses have been brought to this city from Boston, Chicago, Indianapolis, Irvington, Ind., and almost every city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. What revelations these witnesses will make have been kept a profound secret by the prosecuting officers, but there are expectations of sensational developments. Detective Geyer, who has been for months traveling extensively throughout the country in search of evidence of Holmes' guilt, will be one of the principal witnesses for the commonwealth. The skull and portions of the body of Pitzel, as well as the remains of the boy, Howard Pitzel, who is thought to have been murdered by Holmes in Minneapolis, will be exhibited during the course of the trial.

Judge Arnold is upon the bench, and he has already signified his intention of holding three sessions a day—morning, afternoon and night—so long as the persons interested can stand the strain. The prosecution is in the hands of District Attorney Graham and a corps of assistants, while the interests of the prisoner are guarded by Messrs. Shoemaker and Rolan, young members of the local bar.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Providence News · Providence, R.I. · 28 October 1895

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietsell, with a jury of twelve seated by 1:45 and Holmes conducting his own defense after his counsel withdrew and a requested continuance was denied.

Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 28 October 1895 · page 1

Philadelphia, Oot. 28. H. H. Holmes, who aooording to his own remarkable oonfessions, stands at the head of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial In, the court of Oyer au3 Terminer, this morning, for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietsell. The commonwealth prosecutors are Distriot Attorney Geo. 8. Graham and Speoial Assistant Thos. W, Bartow. . For the prisoner, wm. a. o&oemaser ana Samuel P. Rotam, young members of the bar, appeared. Judge Michael Arnold is upon the bench. Holmes has been oaretnl to shift the main responsibility for the various mur ders, with which he admits having been oonneoted, to other shoulders.

See moreSee less

Thos during thirty-eight years of a life devoted almost entirely to law breaking, this is his first experienoe as a felon on trial for bis life. - A sensation was created by the counsel for the prisoner withdrawing at Holmes' request, after tbey had made an ineffectual attempt to secure s postponement. Holmes is conduoting his own case. At 1:45 twelve jurors had been seleoted. The oourt took a rcoees till 8 p. m. Law yer R. C. Moon deolined to participate in the case for Holmes unless a continuance was granted and as Judge Arnold deolined to do this Holmes will nave to act as his own lawyer.

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

H. H. Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin E. Pitezel, pleading not guilty. Witnesses were gathered from many cities, prosecution plans were kept secret, and expectations of sensational testimony were high.

The Providence News · 28 October 1895 · page 7

Until Trial Ends. PRILADELPHIA, Oct. 28.—H, H. Holmes, or Herman Mudget, whose namé or alias has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the Imost un scrupulous and skilifu! murderor of mod ern times, was placed on trial for his life this morning In the court of oyer and ter miner of this city. The specific charge to which he Is called upon to answer Is the murder of Benjamin E. Pitzel, and he has already officially deolared himself not gulilty. The revolt ing detalls of the many erimes with which Holmes' name has been direotly or indi rectly connected have been given such pub licity, and the cold, implacable demeanor which has characteriged the man through out has been so frequently commented upon, that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case kunown to the criminal annals of the wastern hemisphere.

See moreSee less

The commmonwealth has already expended thousands of dol lars in its offorts to hring the prisoner to summary justice, and there is an indiea tion that, should a conviction for murder in the first degree be obtained, he will be “ral Iroaded” to the gallows. Prosecution's Plans Kept Secret, Witnesses have been brought to this city from Beston, Chicago, Indianapolis, Irv ington, Ind,, and almost every city where Holmes 1s known to have lived at various times. What revelations thege witnesses will make have heen kept a profound secret by the prosecuting oflicers, but there are expoctations of sensational developments. Detoctive Geyer, who has been for months traveling extensively throughout the country in search of evidence of Holmoes' guilt, will be one of she prineipal wit nesses for the commonwealth, The skull and portlons of the body of Pitzel, as well a 8 the remalns of the boy, Howard Pitzel, who is thought to have heen mur dered by Holmes in Minneapolis, will be exhibited during the course of the trial, Judge Arnold is nupon the bench, and he has already signified his intention of hold ing three sesslons a day-—morning, After noon and nighe—so long as the persons in wrested can stand the strain. The prose qution is in the hands of District Attorney araham and a corps of assistants, while the Interests of the prisoner are guarded by Messrs, Shoemaker and Rolan, young members e the local bar.

See the clipping

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

The murder trial of H. H. Holmes, whose baptismal name is given as Herman Mudgett, began in Philadelphia, with Holmes now conducting his own defense after his attorneys withdrew from the case.

San Antonio Daily Light · 28 October 1895 · page 5

Philadelphia, Oct. 28. — The trial of H. H. Holmes, for the mur der of Benjamin F. Pietzell, began here this morning. His baptismal name is Herman Mudgett. The prosecution is determined to secure his conviction and sentence of death, and hasten the execution as much as possible. A sensation was caused by Holmes’ attorneys withdrawing from the case today, after unsuc cessfully trying to secure a post ponement. Holmes is therefore conducting his own case. Holm-<a on Trial.

See the clipping

In the story →

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C. · and 1 other paper

H. H. Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia for Pietzel's murder, saw his lawyers withdraw and refused court-appointed counsel, conducted his own defense, and a jury was seated by 1:45.

Alexandria Gazette · 28 October 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

TO-DAY'S TELEGRAPHIC NEWS

Holmes's Trial Commenced.

See moreSee less

PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Oct. 28.—Herman W. Mudgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, the self-confessed life insurance swindler and the alleged mult-murderer, was placed on trial this morning on the charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pietzel. In addition to the murder of Pietzel, the prisoner is also accused of the murder at Toronto, Ont., of Peitzel's two young daughters, Alice and Nellie, of the murder at Irvington, Ind., of the young son, Howard Peitzel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes castle at Chicago.

Holmes walked jauntily into the dock, a tipstaff being on either side of him. He was rather pale from long confinement. He took his seat with a calmness that was noticeable.

When the trial was called the counsel for the defense asked for a continuance of sixty days on the ground that they were not prepared to go on. Judge Arnold overruled the motion and then the defendant's lawyers, W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, withdrew from the case, notwithstanding an injunction from the court that they would be opened to disbarment by taking such a step on the eve of a murder trial. Still further sensation was created when Holmes refused to accept the services of attorneys Everett A Schofield and Joseph R. Fahy, whom the court was about to appoint to defend him. The case was then resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense. Holmes himself pleaded to the court for a postponement, but the judge declared that the case must go on. The trial was then resumed, Holmes conducting his own defense.

The work of securing a jury was then taken up and Holmes examined the talesmen himself. Mrs. Pietzel, who, the district attorney said, was indisposed, was not in court. The work of securing a jury was completed at 1:45 o'clock and then a recess was taken until 3 o'clock.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me. · 29 October 1895

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgett, pleads not guilty and goes on trial tomorrow for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, with witnesses gathered from several cities and the remains of Pitzel and a boy, Howard Pitzel, to be exhibited in court.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 28 October 1895 · page 2

FOR THE MURDER OF B. F. PITZEL

Philadelphia. Oct. 27 H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudgett. whose name, or alias, has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most un scrupulous and skillful murderer of mod em times, will oe placed on trial for his life tomorrow morning in the court of oyer and terminer, of this city. Tne spe cified charge to which he will be called up on to answer is the murder of Binjam.n F. Pitzel, and he has already officially declared himself not guilty. The revolting details of the many crimes wah which Holmes' name has been direct ly or indirectly connected have been given publicity, and the cold, implacable demean or which has characterized the man throughout has been so frequently com mented upon that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of the Western hemisphere.

See moreSee less

The commonwealth has alreaiy expended thousands of dollars in its efforts to bring the prisoner to sum mary Justice, and there is an indication that should a conviction for murder in the first degree be obtained he will be quickly ••railroaded" to the gallows. Wit nesses have been brought to fhis city from Boston. Chicago. Indianapolis, Irvington, 2nd., ad almost every city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. What revelations these witnesses will make has been kept a profound secret, but there ia expectation of sensational de velopments. Detective Geyer has been for months traveling extensively throughout the country In search of evidence of Holmes' movements, and he will be one of the principal witnesses for the common wealth. The skull and portions of the body of Pitzel, as well as the remains of tne boy, Howard Pitzel, who is thought to have boen murdered by Holmes in Indianapolis, will be exhibited during the course of the trial. Judge Arnold will be ur>on the bench, and he has already signified his in tention of holding three sessions a day, morning, afternoon and night, so long as the Persons Interested can stand the strain. The prosecution will be in the hands of District Attorney Graham and a corps of assistants, while the interests of the pris oner win be guarded by Shoemaker and R>tan. young members of the local bar. Consequent upon the widespread publicity given the case, it is feared that several days will be occupied in securing a Jury of men who have not already formed de cided opinions concerning the guilt or in nocence of Holmes. It is impossible to learn even approximately the number of wit nesses to he called on either side, but there will be a goodly number Is ar>- parrnt from tht? precautions that will be taken to insure their entrance to the court room. Announcements have been made that only those who have business therein will be admitted, and that an increased corps of court officers, augmented by a detail of reserve policemen, will enforce the order at the doors. The murder of Pitzel, If murder It was, occurred more than a year ago. The body, burned and blackened as if by an explo sion. was discovered in the house, No. "1"2<5 Callow Hill street, this city, on Septem ber 3. 1534. As he had been known as an Inventor named Perry, the supposition was that he had met death by Occident while experimenting. Subsequently, tha charrre was made that Pitzel had been murdered bv Holmes In an attempt to de fraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Association, of Philadelphia, out of *IO,OOO. which had been paid by the company to Mri. IPtzel, who was supposed to have been a party to the conspiracy. Holmes having first In troduced Pitzel to the company. Holmes was arrested In Boston November 17, and Mrs. Pitzel is in custody as probably the principal witness against him. There is a likelihood of the case consumig several weeks, unless circumstances arise to bring It to a speedy conclusion. The remains of youn«r Howard Pitzel. found In the Irvington bouse, were brought to this city tonight by Detective Pochards, of Indianapolis. They were carried In a small box anl were lmmdiatelv taken to District Attorney Graham's office, where fhey will be kept until such time as they will be brought into the case.

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The clipping describes Holmes' notorious courtroom demeanor and the commonwealth's costly effort to convict him, noting a first-degree murder conviction may follow.

Wheeling Register · 28 October 1895 · page 1

THE REVOLTING DETAILS of the many crimes with Which Holmes’ name has been directly or indirectly connected, have been given such pub licity, and 'the cold, Implacable de meanor which has characterized the man throughout, has been so frequent ly commented upon, that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of Lite western hemisphere. The commonwealth has already expended .thousands of dollars in its efforts to bring the prisoner to summary jus tice. and there is an indication that should a conviction for murder in the first degree be obtained, he will bo

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The clipping reports that witnesses from several cities have been brought in against Holmes, with Detective Geyer a key witness, and mentions remains believed to be Pietzel's found in Indianapolis.

Wheeling Register · 28 October 1895 · page 1

“RAILROADED" TO THE GALLOWS. Witnesses have been brought to this city from Boston, Chicago, Indianapo lis, Irvington, Ind., and almost every city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. What revelations these witnesses will make has been kept a profound secret by the prosecuting officers, but there is expectation of sen sational developments. I>eiect;ve (ley er, who has been for months traveling extensively throughout the country in search of evidences of Holmes’ move ments, will be one of the principal wit nesses for the commonwealth. The skull and portions of the body of Plet zel, who is thought to have been mur dered by Holmes in Indianapolis,

See the clipping

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Judge Arnold will preside over sessions held three times daily, with Graham leading the prosecution and Shoemaker and Rolan defending, amid efforts to screen jurors and control courtroom admission, while remains found in a house were brought to the city and delivered to the district attorney's office.

Wheeling Register · 28 October 1895 · page 1

during the course of the trial. and he has already signified his inten tion of holding three sessions a (lay morning. afternoon and night -so long as the persons interested can stand the strain. The prosecution will be in the hands of District Attorney Graham and a corps of assistants, while the inter ests of the prisoner will be guarded by Messrs. Shoemaker and Rolan, young members of the local bar. publicity given the case, it is feared that several days will he occupied of men who have not already formed decided opinions concerning the guilt or innocence of Holmes.

See moreSee less

proximately the number of witnesses to be called on either side, but that there will l>e a goodly number is ap parent from the precautions that will he takpn to Insure their entrance to tho court room. only those who have business therein will be admitted, and an Increased corps of court officers, augmented by a detail of reserve policemen, will en force this order at the doors. if murder it was, occurred more than a year ago. The body, burned and black ened as if by an explosion, was discov ered in the house, No. 1326 Oa'.lowhlll street, this city, on September 3, 1834, and as he had been known as an in ventor named Perry, the supposition was that he had met death by accident, while experimenting. Subsequently, the charge was made that Pietzel had been murdered by Holmes in an at tempt to defraud the Fidelity Mutual Life Association, of Philadelphia, out of $10,000, which had been paid by tha company to Mrs. Pietzel, <\no was sup posed to have been a party to the con spiracy. Holmes having first introduced pietzel to the company. November 17th and Mrs. Pietzel is in custody a?, probably, the principal wit ness against him. suming several weeks time, unless un forseen circumstances arise to bring it to a speedy conclusion. in the Irvington house were brought to this ettv to-night by Detective Rich ards. of Indianapolis. They were car ately sent to District Attorney Gra ham's office, where they will bo kept until such time as they will be brough into court. West Virginia: Generally fair Monday with northwesterly winds and a cold wave. t ers in the early morning, followed by fair: cold wave: westerly wind3. with a moderate cold wave; westerly winds. WILL BE EXHIBITED Judge Arnold will be upon the bench, Consequent upon the widespread IN SECl HI.Mi A Jl 1U lit is impossible to h^arn even ap Announcement has been made that the murder of pietzel, Holmes was arrested in Boston on There is a likelihood of the case con The remains of Howard Pietzel found c nnd wet Weather Indications. Washington. D. C.. October 27.—For For Western PennsylvaniaShow For Ohio: Generally fair Monday

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The clipping describes the opening of the trial, naming the prosecuting and defense attorneys, and recounts how Pietzel's body was found, declared accidental death, exhumed and identified, insurance paid, and Holmes's subsequent arrest, guilty plea to conspiracy, and the detective work that led to murder charges.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 29 October 1895 · page 2

sided. The commonwealth was represented by District Attorney George L. Graham and Assistant District Attorney Thomas W. Barlow. The defence was conduct ed by W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan. In addition to the murder of Pletzel the prisoner Is also accused of the murder at Toronto, Ontario, of Plet zel's two young daughters, Alice and Nellie; of the murder at Irvington, Ind., of the young son. Howard Pletzel, and also of the murder of various other per. sons in "the famous Holmes castle at Chicago. Benjamin F. Pietzel's body was found in a house at 1316 Callowhlll street on September 3, 1894.

See moreSee less

A shattered lamp was found by the side of the body.whlch bore evidence of having ibeen burned, and the coroner's jury concluded that the oil lamp hud exploded, and that Pletzel, who was at the time known as B. F. Perry, had been burned to death, and accordingly rendered a verdict of accidental death. There was no claimant for the body, and It was buried in Potter's field. Sub. sequently an assertion came from Piet zel's lawyer at St. Louis, Mr. Jephtha Howe, that the 'body was that of Ben jamin F. Pletzel, and a claim was made on the Fidelity Mutual Life association of Philadelphia for J10,000, which that company carried on Pietzel's life, The body was exhumed and was ful ly identified by his daughter, who was brought from St. Louis, as that of Plet zel. The insurance company, however, paid the claim, but notbeing satisfied tnat t'letzei naa met nis aeatn aeciaen. tally, at once placed detectives on 1he case to solve the mystery. This result ed In the arrest at Boston of Mudgett, alias Holmes. He was brought here and was placed on trial, charged with conspiracy to de fraitd the insurance companies. Holmes pleaded guilty to this charge, but to combat the more serious chargfe of mur der asserted that Fietzel was still liv Ing, and that aTjody was,obtained from a New York dissecting room and plac ed in the building pn Callowhlll street. After burning the skfn slightly and throwing a lamp on t;he floor, Holmes said that he and Pletzel left the city and subsequently informed Mrs. Pietzel that the Ibody was that of her missing husband, and had her press her claim for the insurance. ' Holmes was sent 't& prison to await sentence on the conspiracy trial, and District Attorney Graham started De. tective Geyer out to visit Toronto, Chi cago and other western cities in an en deavor to obtain evidence against Holmes which would warrant his being arraigned for murder. Detective Geyer succeeded in finding the bodies of the children. Oother facts which he gleaned satisfied District At torney Graham that Holmes could be convicted of the murder of Pletzel, Detective Geyer also brought Mrs. Pietzel end others from various parts of tb west and Canada to this city to take th stand as witnesses against Holmes. The approaches to the eourt room were close guarded, and none but pereons directly interested in the case and newspaper men were admitted. The case was called shortly after 10 o'clock. Holmes walked jauntily into the dock, a tipstaff being on either side of him. 'He was rather pale from long confinement in the county prison. His black beard was neatly trimmed. He took his seat with a calmness that was noticeable, and while he evinced a decided interest ir the matters at issue there was no look of fear upon his coun evidence of .nervoustenance nor any ness in his action. After the formalities in connection with the opening of the court had been concluded Attorney W. H. Shoemaker of counsel for the prisoner in an address of some length asked for a postpone ment of the case for sixty days. Mr. Shoemaker's contention was that the de fence was not prepared for trial; that no witnesses were present. District Attorney Graham strenuously opposed the motion. He said that the state's witnesses were present at thrlr own volition, and that if a continuance should be granted it wnuld mean "the absolute destruction of the common wealth's case." Mrs. Pietzel's health was impaired, Mr. Graham further eaid, and if the case should be postponed the strain would intensify her illness Lawyer Samuel P. Koian, for the de fence, thpn addressed the court, and , cuiimed, that as Holmes was charged

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

At the opening of Holmes's murder trial, his attorneys sought a 60-day postponement, citing unprepared witnesses and unresolved related cases, but Judge Arnold refused and ordered the trial to proceed. Holmes's lawyers then withdrew, as did two court-appointed replacements he rejected, leaving Holmes to conduct his own defense.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 29 October 1895 · page 2

Holmes himself pleaded to the court for a poetponement, 'but the judge de clared that the case must go on. The trial was resumed, Holmes conducting his own defence.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The clipping, a fragment, reports that Holmes' two attorneys asked for a continuance when the judge took his seat on the bench, but the request was refused due to prior delays.

The San Francisco Call · 29 October 1895 · page 1

FIGHTING FOR LIFE

his seat upon the bench, Holmes' two at torneys asked for a continuance of the case. This, however, was refused, as there had already been more than enough of the law's

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The clipping describes Holmes rejecting his court-appointed lawyers to conduct his own defense, his conduct during jury selection and the District Attorney's opening argument, his request to contact his wife, and defense motions for a trial postponement that were opposed by District Attorney Graham.

The San Francisco Call · 29 October 1895 · page 1

picture made by Holmes at this point. j Slender, erect and more youthful tban his j pictures make him appear, and with an j added delicacy given his naturally clear cut and refined face by bis long confine- | ment in prison, Holmes arose to his feet j and addressed the court. His voice was weak and quivering like that of a man who had been ill and hardly carried the short distance that separated him from the court. He announced that he would not accept the lawyers appointed by the court and that he would conduct his own defense.

See moreSee less

A hum of astonishment went around the courtroom, but, alone and without a friend by his side, the nerve that has enabled this man to leave behind him. a trail of dead without a show of compunction or remorse bore him up under the trying or deal of the desertion of his counsel. Holmes exercised his right of challenge, and before the jury was obtained eighteen men had been set aside by him. When court reconvened this afternoon Holmes sat in the dock busily engaged taking notes during his terrible arraignment by the District Attorney in his opening argument. An occasional flush that suffused his cheek and once in a while a slight lifting of the eyebrows when the District Attor ney became particularly earnest were the only marks of emotion exhibited by Holmes. When the District Attorney had con cluded his argument Holmes requested that he be allowed light and writing ma terials in his cell in the County Prison. This was granted him, and then Holmes asked to be allowed to see his wife. A sharp interchange of dialogue occurred between the prisoner and the District At torney as to which wife he wanted to see, and finally Holmes was driven to say that it was the last woman who had been de ceived into marrying him. This woman has refused to see Holmes, but he obtained a promise from the court that a letter should be given her to-night, and that if she would comply an answer to it should be sent to him from her. The case was called shortly after 10 o'clock. After the formalities in connec tion with the opening of court had been concluded, W. H. Shoemaker, of counsel for the prisoner, in an address of some length, asked for a postponement of the case for sixty days. Mr. Shoemaker's con tention was that the defense was not pre pared for trial; that no witnesses were present. District Attorney Graham stren uously opposed the motion, declaring that the State's witnesses were present at their own volition, and that if a continuance should be granted it would . mean "the absolute destruction of the common wealth's case." Mrs. Pitzel's health was impaired, Mr. Graham further said, and if the case should be postponed the strain would intensify her illness. Lawyer Samuel P. Rotan for the defense also pleaded for time in which he and his colleague could realize on Holmes' assets and thus bring witnesses to Philadelphia who will not come unless their expenses are paid. The discovery of new testimony within the past four or five _ days which he Great excitement prevailed. Ministry, was as follows: Dupuy Dutemps. ties. Canal Affair. de Reinach.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The clipping is a garbled fragment combining a discussion of a proposed $50 excursion rate to California expected to draw 5000 travelers with disjointed references to telegraphic news capacity and a court proceeding where a judge refused a postponement and insisted the case proceed as a real trial.

The San Francisco Call · 29 October 1895 · page 2

FIGHTING FOR LIFE

as any of the roads. We are always working for the interests of California. Fifty dollars would be an extremely liberal rate, but I be lieve the roads can afford to make such a rate, if the volume of travel is large enough, and I believe it wilt be. This rate is $12 50 less than the single trip rate from Chicago to this City. There ought to be at least 5000 people to make that rate possible, and I think that many will certainly come. and who in fact had taken seats in the companies could handle, say 100,000 words dally, readily enough, and 100,000 words chairs vacated by Messrs.

See moreSee less

Shoemaker and means the distribution of a vast amount of Rotan. Schofield and Fahey also with news if the best use is made of it. It would drew. Holmes himself pleaded to the not meet the requirements, however, if every court for a postponement, but the Judge great paper in the country wanted its special declared the case must go on. and exclusive letters of tens of thousands of Judge Arnold here stated that this words daily. But I think the journals wouia would be no farce in court, but a trial, all readily recognize the situation and its re quirements.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

After Holmes rejected court-appointed attorneys and his original counsel withdrew, Judge Arnold insisted the trial proceed, and jury selection began with a juror named Enoch Turner before the prisoner asked to address the court.

The San Francisco Call · 29 October 1895 · page 2

was created when Holmes refused to ac cept the services of Attorneys Everett A. Schofield and Joseph R. Fahey, whom the court was about to appoint to defend him, and who in fact had taken seats in the chairs vacated by Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan. Schofield and Fahey also with drew. Holmes himself pleaded to the court for a postponement, but the Judge declared the case must go on. Judge Arnold here stated that this would be no farce in court, but a trial, and again directed that the jury be called and the prisoner tried on the indictment.

See moreSee less

The first juror called to be examined was Enoch Turner, a conductor. District Attor ney Graham said he desired to state to the juror and ask the attention of other jurors at the same time to avoid the necessity of repetition ; that the case about to be tried was that of the Commonwealth vs. Her man W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel. After asking the juror several questions the District Attorney turned him over to the defense, but Attorney Shoemaker, addressing Judge Arnold, said : "Will you allow this case to go over until to-morrow In order to make what preparation we can in regard to it?" The court said: "The case must go on." At this point Attorney Rotan informed the court that the prisoner wished to be heard, and Holmes, rising from his seat in

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The clipping reports that at Holmes's murder trial his attorneys withdrew after a continuance was denied, prompting him to refuse court-appointed counsel and conduct his own defense before the jury was seated.

The Record-Union · 29 October 1895 · page 1

MURDERER HOLMES

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 28.—Herman j W Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmea, was j arraigned a t the bar of justice of the j Criminal Court of Philadelphia to-day to j defend his life against the charge of hayj ing murdered ltenjamin F. Pietzel in j this city on the lid of September, 1894. The widespread publicity given this sen sational case attracted ;i great throng of people to the corridors of the City H all leading to the courtroom, but in antici patiou of the crowd of morbid people •who are attracted by the spectacle of a man battling for his life as are moths arouud the candle, cordons of police puarded all the entrances and only those having business in the courtroom were h incited.

See moreSee less

The very opening of the trial luruished an unusual incident iv court proceedings, aud was in kedping with the strange phases that have made this case unique in the criminal records of the country. Directly after the prisoner had been placed iv the docK aud Judge Arnold had taken his seat upon the bencU Holmes'two attorneys asked lor a can tinuauco of the ease. This was relused, as ;hero had already been more ihan enough ot the lav's delays, and Judge Amoid ordered the trial proceeded with. then the uoienuant's lawyers an nounced they would withdraw Irom tho cane, 'l'he Judge oxprossod his surprise at such unprecedented action at tne i>e giiiinng ol a murder trial, and told tho two attorneys that i: they withdrew they placed themselves in jeopardy of being disbarred. Nevertheless, with tne pros pect of disbarment, the two lawyers per sisted in their reiusal to conduct the case and left the courtroom. Tho i-ourl there upon appointed two others to conduct the prisoner's doirnso. Although accused of crimes that would revolt a barbarous savage, there was some thing pathetic in the picture made by iioimes at tiiis point. Slender, erect and more youthful tliau his pictures make him appear and with au added delicacy given ins naturally clear cut aud refined lace by his long confinement in prison. Holmes arose to his leet and addressed the court. jiis voice was weak aud quivering like that of a man who uad iieen ill and hardly carried the short dis He announced that he would not accept the lawyers appointed by the court and that ho would conduct his own defense. A hum of astonishment went arouud the courtroom, but al-.ne and without a abled tiiis man to leave behind him a trail of dt^.d without a show of compunc tion or remorse, bore him up uuder tno counsel. lenjro, and belore the jury uas ootained eighteen men had been set n-i le bj the dnck busi.y engaged in tafelug during his terrible arraignment District Attorney, in ining argu ment. An occasional flash that suffused ids cheek, and on«.-e in a wnile a slight iittinK of tho eyebrows when t::O I 'ir. trict Attorney became parileu.iirly «arn est, wore the marks of emotion exui >- itei by Holmes. W hen the District At torney had concluded his aru iioimea i that ho be all >w I a light and writing materials iv his cell in the county prison. This was granted him, an>l then Holmes ask_d to bo al lowed to see hia wife. A sharp interchange of dialogue nc ouned between the prisoner aud Din to see, and linaliy Holmes was drive,-! To nay that it was tlu< last woman who jlo obtained a promise Irom th-3 court and, if she would comply, au answer should be sent to him iroin her. Alter tho formalities in connection with the opening of court had been con . Attorney \v. 11. Shoemaker of counsel lor tho defense, in au U'kiross ol some sixty days. Mr. Shoemaker's contention was that the defense wan not prepared lor trial; tiiat no witnesses were j i District Attorney Graham strenuously opposed the motion, he d< . tat the State's witnesses were present at their own volition, and mat ii a continuance should be granted it would mean "tho absolute destruction of the cominou vealth's cs Mrs. 's Health wan impaired, Mr. * r said ■ houl.i be postponi i t:.u strain would m teusily her illness. Lawyer Samuel P. Rotan, for the de feiiHe, it.so pie.-ided lor tune in which ho and bis colleague couid rea,i/.e on Holn : thus bring wiii to Philadelphia, who will not come unless their expenses are . Judge Arnold overruled the motions for postponement in a very lew words, and oruered the trial to ;oon, J;i^: at mis a startling climax \v;is oi Lawye . .er aud lvotft:i from the case, notwithstanding an injunction from the court that thoy would bo open to disbarment i»y taking such a step '*on the eve ot a murder trial." StiU lurthor seusstlon was crested when Holmes re fused to accopt the services of Attorneys iioy, whom tho court was ab'^ut to ap point to defend him and who fo (act had hiuiseif pleaded th« court for a posi tho ca.'io must c<) OS. .luige Arnold here stated that this would be no faros, but a trial, and again directed that the jury he called and tiie jirisoner tried on the indictment. The jurors at tho name tune LO avoM the i;o --eessity of repetition, that the caeeaboat to bo tried wai mat of the Common wealth v§. Herman >'.'. Mudgett. ana-* H. H. Holmes, charged \%ith tho mjrder of Benjamin i. Pi nceL After askiuy the juror several question, tho District At tArnoy turned him ovor to the defense, but Attorney Mioomakor, addreeati £ Judce Arnold. s;uj ; "Will you allow this caso to no ovor until to-morrow, in ovder to make vrhat prepaxation wo can with regard toi iho court: "Th« case must goon." At this punt Attorney Kotan informed the court that the prisoner ■ ished to be beard, and Hohnes.risiUi; irom his scat in tbedock aud addressing the court, said : "May it p;oase the court, 1 have no in clination to a^k thecouusol to continue in the case where 1 can see it will be against their own inteiestw. l;oariu>: this lact in mmd, I have within the last low moments tiincharted them from the case." Jno court—They cannot be uischarct-d Jrom tne case, and if they lohvo the court they will be puuished as lawyers are puu jituod lor disobedience. • i that separated him from the court. : by his side, the nerve that ims en leal of the desertion of his mes exercised his right of cbal a court reconvened Holme1* eat iv attorney ;:s lo wbicii \\;:e ho wanted . deceived into marrying him. • letter should be given her to-nißiit, j, asked (ax a postponement lor ted whicb resmtu.i in the withdrawal toneld and Joseph I . sests in the chairs vacated by irs. Shoemaker aud Kotan. Scho md 1 aht-y ai.so withdrew. Holmea ment, but the Jud^e declart-d th.a ,nror called to l>a examined was Turner, aconducior. District At y i iranam suid ne desired to state to aror, and ask tne attention of other

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

The clipping reports that the case to be tried was Commonwealth v. Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, charged with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, and that after questioning a juror the District Attorney turned him over to the defense.

The Record-Union · 29 October 1895 · page 1

to bo tried wai mat of the Common wealth v§. Herman >'.'. Mudgett. ana-* H. H. Holmes, charged \%ith tho mjrder of Benjamin i. Pi nceL After askiuy the juror several question, tho District At tArnoy turned him ovor to the defense,

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, also known as Herman Mudgett, went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin F[itzgerald?]zel, with the first day's startling developments and failed pleas for a continuance surpassing all expectations.

The Herald · 29 October 1895 · page 1

MULTI-MURDERER HOLMES On Trial for the Killing of B. F. Pitzel

AN OUTBREAK IS EXPECTED Anti-Foreign Feeling Among tbe Chi nese Soldiery The Kins of Corea liai Chosen a New Queen and Assumed a Hlgh-Sound insc Title LONDON, Oot. 28.-In spite of the statement made by the Graphic today, that an official hiub in authority says tho alarming dispatch nf the Times from Hongkong regarding important conces sions made *>y China to Russia "bears no resemblarce to the actual facts," the news seems to be confirmed today from two sources. Air. G, B, Morrison, who re3ently traveled through China, writes that as far back as AOffUlt last the Chi nese newspapers outlined a scheme by i which China proposded to reward Gerj many, France and Russia for their inter- ; vention against Japan.

See moreSee less

Germany, he i says, was to have concessions of land at tho treaty ports of Hankow and Tien ; Tain; France was to be granted certain I privileges in southeast China, and Russia I was to be allowed to extend her railway j system to Port Arthur. The second ground for believing the report may be correct is found in a dis patch to the Daily Telegraph from Vien na, published today, giving an outline of an interview with a well known Hussion statesman, who practically admits the truth of tho news telegraphed from Hongkong to the Times. Keferring to the Americans, tbe Rus "Tlie Americans are our friends in Eu rope. They are specially zealous in es pousing our causo when wo need no out siders' help, tint In the far oast they are our enemies or rivals." At the Russian embassy here, however, the s'-atement fs rondo that them is abso lutely no foundation for tbe announcement made by the Times. It is asserted by tbe Russian officials that no such treaty has been concluded between the governments of Russia and China, ana it. is further assrerted by them that the Russian government is not animated by any anti-English feeling in its policy in connection with the far oast. The Times tomorrow will publish a dis patch from Hong Kong which says: Speaking at a public banquet at Viaai vostook on September 27th, which was given in his honor on the occasion of his AMoct&ted Press RdocI&I Wlra PHILADELPHIA. Oct. 28.— H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudgett, whi h ha says is his baptismal name, was pot on trial in the court of oyer and ten • «r today for the murder of Benjamin F zel in this city on September 2, 1894. ana tlie developments of the first day w > lietter perhaps than ever befora tha foroe of tbe maxim that truth is stranger than notion. From the nature of the case and the startling stories concerning ie w!>i < have gained currency during the naat year, sensational revelations wero natar ally to be expected when he win has become recognized as the most SKlllful and audacious criminal of modern time*, was placed on trial for his life. Vet when it occurred in court it so far scr rassad all expectations thst tho ~iost vivid flights of imagination could sores ly have conceived the day's events. Protestations and entreaties lor a "on ■ tinuance of the trial were overruled; tbe sudden withdrawal of iho lawyer who had hitherto representstha prisoner in the race of throats of dirbar* ment; tho appointment by tbe oomt of new counsel and the refusal by tho prii oner to acoept them as his defenders ; tho declination of another lawyer to after being selected by Holmes, and tin ally the prisoner trying his own Ihese, not to speak of the sharp cast aces at arms between Holmes and tho • ora nionwealth's prosecuting oilicer, sui ia> rize what .occurred. Long betore 1 oclock, the hour »c the opening of the court, an eager c.owd thronged tho corridors without, regulations were so complete, how that none but the lawyers, witne I, jurors and nowspaper reportrs wera per mitted to pass the cordon of police v formed a Barrier across th« entrar the corridor leading to ttie court and the officers who guarded tbo ver trance to the room. This i n due crowding, although every seat ii room w»s occupied. Thj general p will be admitted to the capaoity o 'ie gallery, which will seat about 200, wbea the taikng of testimony is begun tomor row. Holmes, who, at tlie time of his a s; in Boston on November 17th last, ' slockily built man of middle jhc ;hi, since his long confinement {has grow:. gaunt and hollow cheated. The prison bleach Has brought bis face to a death like pallor, heightened by the dark close cropped beard. In appearance as h in the dock today bo was neatness i i The beard was carefully tiimmed

See the clipping

The Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A fragmentary news digest reports English opinion on the Nicaragua canal, the start of a murder trial at Philadelphia, and a Bering Sea hearing dependent on an unspecified condition.

The Herald · 29 October 1895 · page 1

PHILADELPHIA. Oct. 28.— H. H.

BY TELEGRAPH—EngIish opinio; ai to the Nicaragua canal—fieginni tbe Holmes murder trial at Phil pbia — Hearing of Bering sea cl I dependent on tho condtion oi THE NEWS

See the clipping

In the story →

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · and 2 other papers

H. H. Holmes, also known as Herman W. Mudgett, went on trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, with the first day marked by withdrawal of his lawyers, refusal to accept court-appointed counsel, and Holmes ultimately conducting his own defense.

Evening Journal · 29 October 1895 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE MULTIMURDERER.

Homes, Alias Mudgett, In the Prisoner's Dock.

See moreSee less

HE ACTS AS HIS OWN COUNSEL.

Sensational Opening of the Trial of the Greatest Alleged Criminal of Modern Times—Spirited Tilts With District Attorney Graham.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 29.—H. H. Holmes, or Herman W. Mudgett, which he says is his baptismal name, was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminer yesterday for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel in this city on Sept. 2, 1894, and the developments of the first day verified better perhaps than ever before the force of the maxim that truth is stranger than fiction From the nature of] the case and the startling stories concerning it which have gained currency during the past year, sensational revelations were naturally to be expected when he, who has come to be regarded as the most skillful and audacious criminal of modern times, was placed on trial for his life. Yet what did occur in court so far surpassed all expectations that the most vivid flights of imagination could scarcely have conceived the day's events.

Protestations and entreaties for a continuance of the trial summarily overruled; the sudden withdrawal of the lawyers who had hitherto represented the prisoner in the face of threats of disbarment; the appointment by the court of new counsel and the refusal by the prisoner to accept them as his defenders; the declination of another lawyer to serve after being selected by Holmes, and finally the prisoner trying his own case. This, not to speak of sundry dramatic passages at arms between Holmes and the commonwealth's prosecuting officer, is a summary of what occurred.

Long before 10 o'clock, the hour set for the opening of court, an eager crowd thronged into the courtroom.

The clocks of the town had scarcely ceased striking 10 when Judge Arnold, clad in the long black gown which was recently adopted by the Philadelphia judiciary, entered and took his seat upon the bench, and what promises to be the most sensational case in the criminal jurisprudence of this country was begun. The prisoner, closely guarded, was brought in and placed in the dock.

Holmes' Marvelous Display of Nerve.

Holmes, who at the time of his arrest in Boston on Nov. 17 last was a stockily built man of middle height, has since his long confinement grown gaunt and hollow chested. The prison bleach has brought his peaked face to a deathlike pallor, heightened by the dark, closely cropped beard. In appearance as he sat in the dock he was neatness itself. The beard was carefully trimmed, the hair smoothly parted, and the black cheviot suit he wore betrayed no spot or blemish. His demeanor throughout, save on one or two occasions, when he gave way to slight bursts of anger, directed at the district attorney, was characterized by that marvelous display of nerve which has become associated with his name.

The original intention of the commonwealth was to hold three sessions of court daily—morning, afternoon and night—but so much time was consumed by the unexpected developments that it was nearly 5 o'clock when District Attorney Graham concluded his opening address to the jury. In view of this and to avoid breaking the testimony of the first witness by the supper recess it was decided to adjourn until today. Hereafter, however, the original programme will be followed.

The day's proceedings began when Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan moved for a 60 days' continuance on the ground of lately discovered evidence. This was promptly refused, as was also their motion for a continuance until today. Finding the judge inexorable, they, as a last resort, declared that they would withdraw from the case. Judge Arnold warned them that if they did so they would lay themselves open to disbarment.

Thereupon Holmes declared from the dock that under the circumstances he would not permit them to defend him. He therefore dismissed them from his service, and the lawyers left the room in spite of the court's threats. Judge Arnold then appointed E. M. Schofield and J. M. Fahy to assume charge of the defense, but again Holmes interposed. He declared that he would not place his life in the hands of two young men who know the case only by hearsay, and eventually, when his personal entreaties for a postponement were refused, he declared that he would himself try the case. Meanwhile he expressed a desire to secure the services of Attorney R. O. Moon, but that gentleman, after learning from the judge that he could not obtain a continuance, declined to accept the grave responsibility.

The selection of a jury consumed several hours, Holmes freely exercising his prerogative of challenge, and after 12 men had been secured a recess was taken.

The afternoon session was devoted largely to District Attorney Graham's opening address to the jury, in which he outlined the case in detail and subjected the prisoner to a scathing denunciation.

The Prosecution's Scathing Arraignment.

The district attorney spoke an hour and 25 minutes, concluding at 4:40 o'clock. He then held a brief talk with the judge at the side bar and agreed with him that in view of the lateness of the hour it would be inexpedient to begin the taking of testimony, as the examination of the first witness would be interrupted by the supper recess. It was therefore decided to adjourn court until 10 o'clock today.

When this became known to Holmes, he arose in the dock, and the last sensation of a day replete with extraordinary incidents occurred.

"May it please your honor," he began, his weak voice vibrating with the emotion which his wonderful self control prevented from betraying in his face, "I am forced to ask that certain privileges be accorded me in prison. They are not very extensive privileges. I must ask the district attorney to allow me to have in my cell light, paper and writing materials, that I may be enabled to prepare my case. I shall also ask the privilege of sending, or having some one connected with the court, sent to Fort Worth, Tex., for certain papers essential to me. How essential I did not know until I heard Mr. Graham's address. Again I ask that I be furnished with a list of the witnesses to be called by the commonwealth."

"I decline to give that," said the district attorney emphatically. "I will furnish that to nobody."

"Then," continued Holmes, "I repeat my request for an interview with a certain party—the party I spoke of this morning." And observing an inquiring look from Mr. Graham he exclaimed sharply and with a defiant gaze at that official, "My wife."

"Which wife?" retorted the district attorney sharply.

There was a suspicion of tears in the voice of the friendless man as he responded, with a bitterness that was real: "You well know whom I mean, Mr. Graham. The person you have seen fit to designate as Miss Yoke, thereby casting a slur on both her and myself."

"She will not see you," the district attorney declared. "You had the opportunity to speak to her in my office, but she shunned you."

Holmes Declares He Was Legally Married.

"I never had," Holmes cried. "I say that I was legally married to this woman two years ago, and there has been no separation except that brought about by you, Mr. Graham. At least," he pleaded, and there was no one in the tribunal who could for the moment repress a feeling of pity for the unfortunate man, "at least allow me to write and ask her, so that she may answer and I can read in her writing that she does not want to see me."

"She told you so to your face," exclaimed Mr. Graham.

"I beg to differ with you, sir." And an angry flush for an instant suffused the cheeks bleached with the prison pallor.

Here Judge Arnold interposed. "Mr. Holmes," he said, "you will be allowed to write a letter to her, and it will be sent by one of the court officers."

"I do not want it taken by any officer who is in any way connected with the district attorney," said Holmes, with a look of scorn at Mr. Graham.

"You have had every opportunity of speaking to her," the latter repeated. "It is indifferent to me whether you see her or not."

"Then, will you answer a direct question?" demanded Holmes searchingly. "Have you or have you not intercepted letters from me to her since last July? Haven't you done everything in your power to keep us apart? Answer yes or no."

"You have no right to so question me, but I will say that I have never in my life addressed six words to her."

"Mr. Holmes," said Judge Arnold, "these are mere idle suspicions. You may write your letter. It will be taken by a court officer, and no one but she shall see it."

"And," added the district attorney, "I will have her in court tomorrow morning besides."

"I will see," concluded the judge, "that you get light and writing materials."

"I thank you, sir, for the privilege," replied Holmes, politely drooping his head.

The court was then adjourned, the jurors locked in their rooms under careful guard, and the man who is accused of being the greatest criminal of modern times was conveyed back to prison to prepare the story which he hopes will save him from the hangman's noose.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 30 October 1895
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 31 October 1895

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping notes that Holmes, a stockily built man of middle height at his arrest in Boston on Nov. 17 last, has since grown gaunt and hollow during his long confinement.

Evening Journal · 29 October 1895 · page 2

HE ACTS AS HIS OWN COUNSEL

Holme»' Marvelon« Display of Nerve. Holmes, who at the tirna of his arrest in Boston on Nov. 17 last was a stocklly bullt man of middlo height, has since his long confinement grown gaunt and hollow

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

Holmes told Judge Arnold he discharged his counsel Rotan and Shoemaker, who then withdrew despite the judge's warning, and Holmes refused replacement attorneys while seeking a postponement to secure R. O. Moon.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 29 October 1895 · page 3

THE TRIAL OF H. H. HOLMES

member of the bar who would withdraw from a murder would be called upon to show cause why ho should not bo disbarred for unprofes sional conduct. J udge Arnold then ordered the elling of a jury. One juror had boon ad mitted by the commonwealth when there was another sensation. Holmes arotso in the dock, and In a high quavering voice said to Judge Arnold: "May it please the court, I have no in clination to continue with the trial of this case with Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker my counsel, feeling that, in view of their desire to withdraw, my interests would bo damaged.

See moreSee less

I therefore discharge them as my counsel." "You cannot discharge them, Holmes," answered J udge Arnold. "That is for the court, and if they withdraw from this they will be punished." "If," continued Holmes, his tones still more trembling, "if your honor will give mo until tomorrow to secure additional counsel—" "We will have Holmes. The matter is decided." The examination of jurors was about to proceed when Mr. Shoemaker again aroso and stated that the prisoner absolutely for bade them from representing him in the case, and declared that he (Holmes) would examine the jurors and witnesses himself. Judge Arnold said he would permit Holmes to question the jurors if he sired. Then Holmes himself took up the exam ination of jurors, and peremptorily chal lenged the first accepted. At this juncture Messrs. Rotan and Shoemaker declared that they felt obliged to withdraw from the case regardless of oonsequenoos. "You must take the consequences, then, ' ' said the judge, and the two lawyers, with out further ado, left the court room. The services of Everett J. Schofield and J. M. Fahy, young members of the bar, were offored to Holmes, but ho refused their services, and asked for a day's post ponement in order that he might R. O. Moon. The judge, however, again : I of its trial empan more debate, Mr. da The second one ho M 1

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, reports that a lawyer named Graham told the jury he had convincing proof that Holmes had murdered Benjamin F. Pitezel, after which Holmes addressed the court asking for a lighted cell at night.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 29 October 1895 · page 3

HOLMES CONDUCTS HIS OWN CASE

the jury. He declared that be had x* vincing proof that Holmes had murdered Beujamiu F. Pltezel. At the conclusion of Mr. Graham's ad dress Holmes addressed tho court, asking that he be allowed to have a lighted cell during the evening and night; that bo bo

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A garbled account describes Holmes's indifferent handling of a body during an identification and insurance-related exhumation, followed by a separate item quoting the Grand Army of the Republic's commander-in-chief voicing long-held support for Cuba's freedom from Spain.

The Evening Times · 29 October 1895 · page 1

oiuiui n-coguizcii uoimes as a man whom he once saw at ritezel's house on Callowhlll stre-et, but he never knew who he was until thev met .it 11,0 iim .. ..... exhumation or the body of Pltezel r(r the p-irpose or .identliicallou In securing the Insurance muney. Smith said that Holmes offered $30 at that time to have the corp-e cremated. Ileal sotold or the grewsome task of Holmes at t luj time. When the body was not readily idctnlflcd by (he pbyslcinus in thar-e or the matter. Holmes took a scalpel Irom his pocket and readily showed the marks upon the body.

See moreSee less

Holmes handled the body as indiffer WAI.KElt FOIt FB.EE CCHA. Commander-in-Chief of Grand Army Volees Geiicriil Sentiment. Indianapolis. Ind., Pet. 29. "For forty years I have hoped for Hie annexation or Cuba to tlie United Stales," said Col. Ivan --. vvaiker. coiumancier-in-cnier or ine li. A. R., when asked what he thought or the proposed mass meetlngln this city tocspress sympathy with tbe Cubans. Continuing, the colonel said: "Some of the best friends I have ever bad have offered up their lives in attempts to free Cuba from the yoke ot Spain. "I rccev e-d a letter a Jew days agol from

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that prosecutors will open the day by proving Pitezel's identity and cause of death, while Holmes spent the night in his cell writing pages of foolscap, sleeping only an hour before resuming work until court began.

The Evening Times · 29 October 1895 · page 1

great a crowd this morning as yesterday, as the public had learned they would not be ad mitted to the court room. ' Tlie prosecution to-day will begin Its case by calling witnesses to prove tlie ldcnllty of Pltczel, and tho manner or bis death. Throughout all last night, in the loneliness of his cell in the county prison. Holmes worked steadily preparing his case. He filled shctt'nfltr sheet of foolscap, and the watchersoutsIdchUcclldoor wondered when he would seek some ret. It was only as tlie first rajs of the sun be'gan to find its way through the narrow slit that docs duty for windows in the cells or the county prison that Holmes threw him seir on bis cot.

See moreSee less

He slept but an hour, and then was up again, and once more became busy writing until told it was lime to start forcourt. JEANETTi; P1TE7.EL CALLED.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Holmes was brought into the courtroom without counsel and, when asked which wife might be a witness, angrily insisted the woman called "Miss Yoke" was his wife, while the district attorney retorted that he had married her with two wives already living.

Evening Star · 29 October 1895 · page 1

IN A DOUBLE ROLE

listener somehow feels that he does not get Ilarrison and Gov. McKinley are person altogeti-er the worst of the argument. ally the best known to the local leaders. At Ilo o'clock the jury was brought into Both have visited the sooth. Gov. Mortor the room and, Judge Arnold appearing a moment later, court was formally opened. has just made a visit to Atlanta, but is Meantime Holmes, in the custody of a something of a stranger to our people. court officer, was placed in the dock. He Neither Mr. Reed nor Mr.

See moreSee less

Allison has been showed no cbange in personal appearance down to see us, though both are in high or demeanor from yesterday, and while the repute with our people. But what should crier was pronouncing the stereotyped our preference as amiong so admirable a formula which declares the court open and list matter? What man among them who, concludes with the prayer, "God save the if nominated and elected next year, would commonwealth and this honorable court," fail as President to treat the south right? Holmes stood up in the lock, his hands Why should not the southern republicans, clasped in front of him and his head slight this breg true, hold back and let the test ly inclined. He busied himself for some of personal popularity be made where the moments afterward arranging his pape.s decision of the question will signify?" in lawyer-like fashion on the desk in front of him, and reading over notes qr perhaps his defense, so far as arranged by himself INSPECTING TIlE HOT SPRINGS. last night in the dismal rolitude of his cell. pathy for the prisother, I mean, as a mat trouble: tEr of grace to him" because he is without "It has always appeared to me that Ire counsel, to ask all the witnesses connected lard and Cuba are :n the same boat, both uith any part of the case to retire. Were having for years upon years furnished sup he to be represented by counsel, I would plies for the use of the aristocracy of Eng fight such a proceeding at every step." land and Spain, respectively. where in toth After the witnesses Oad all left the roam :ristances the people of the two islands are Holmes asked if his. wife was to be a wit looked down upon by their masters. I be ne~ss. lieve that the people of the United States "Again I must ask," said the district at are tired of having either k ngs or queens tcrney, "which w!fe you mean?" or their representatises rul'ng the inhabi "You know," responded Holmes, with a tants of any part of the American cnti flush of anger. "The woman you see fit to nent." designate as Miss Yoke, thereby casting a Speaking of home affairs, Mr. McG:tire slur upon her and myself. That woman is med twenty-eight inches by her head to get said: "I am a populist, but there are only my wife." about 2ol.0000 of us in New York state, so we "You cast a slur on her." Mr. Graham do not cut much ilgure in politics. it is, retorted, "when you married her with two however, my impression that the republicans wives living. I call her by the name she wilr carry the state and Tammany Hall the gives me, which is Miss Yoke." city of New York. The e:ty oteies are at stores to the aft store rooms, not now cued. It perhaps may be also necessary to add some permanent ballast. "As to the list~ng of the Maine to star bcard, this is not 1 mattcr of im',ortance. It can be easly corrected by adjustment of we:ghts in loading. Tie Atlanta and Boston have both proved to be very serviceable sh:ps, but in each of these there is a list near ly double that of the Maine, and this Is cor rected by loading. These vessels both list when unloaded about seven degrees, or near ly double the list of the Maine. The old frigate United States, which was a spliendid vessel in her day, was required to be :r.m her full speed." Personal Mention. Mrs. Jenness Miller, the dress reform

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This damaged clipping disjointedly mixes a courtroom scene involving a prisoner and officers, a reference to Gen. Harrison and Gov. McKinley, a K. of L. figure named Sovereign discussing Cuban trouble, and an unrelated note about ship trimming tanks and store rooms.

Evening Star · 29 October 1895 · page 1

UNUSUAL COURT SCENE

or parry from the court or from the keen Known. and scornful cfficers of the commonwealth, Holmes is equal to the emergency and the "Nobody can safely answer that. Gen. listener somehow feels that he does not get Ilarrison and Gov. McKinley are person of the K. of L., who was present during arose and said to the court: "In v!ew of the circumstances of this The Star reporter's interview with Mr. case, and the evident desire to create sym Sovereign, . said, referring to the Cuban pathy for the prisother, I mean, as a mat trouble: much as she is, but this w'11 be correeted by the use of the after trimni:ng tank provced for lhi:s purpose, and by some shiftiTg of stores to the aft store rooms, not now cued.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The clipping describes Holmes acting as his own counsel with notable skill, a dispute over a brief interview with a woman called Miss Yoke or Mrs. Howard, and his request for a house plan and other items to be produced in court.

Evening Star · 29 October 1895 · page 1

UNUSUAL COURT SCENE

Holmes From a Recent P'hotograph, very last moment, displayed the nerve which has Invariably characterized him, and undertook his own defense. The result was not what most perEons expected. Instcad of the case thereby degenerating into a farce, ashis recent attorneys had predicted, the gaunt and pallid prisoner in the dock revealed a quickness of percep tion and an instinct of self-defense in the sharply-put questions of which many a young barrister would be proud. And so far had his pleadings for right and justice met recognition that a little table provided with pens, ink and paper was placed in the prisoners' dock that he might have all the privileges ordinarily accorded to at torneys.

See moreSee less

With : man of less nerve facce and brain power then Holmes, .acting the composite role of prisoner at the bar and counsel for the defense, the -spectacle would indeed have been farcical. But not for an instant does he lose control of himself. Be it thrust or parry from the court or from the keen and scornful cfficers of the commonwealth, Holmes is equal to the emergency and the listener somehow feels that he does not get altogeti-er the worst of the argument. At Ilo o'clock the jury was brought into the room and, Judge Arnold appearing a moment later, court was formally opened. Meantime Holmes, in the custody of a court officer, was placed in the dock. He showed no cbange in personal appearance or demeanor from yesterday, and while the crier was pronouncing the stereotyped formula which declares the court open and concludes with the prayer, "God save the commonwealth and this honorable court," Holmes stood up in the lock, his hands clasped in front of him and his head slight ly inclined. He busied himself for some moments afterward arranging his pape.s in lawyer-like fashion on the desk in front of him, and reading over notes qr perhaps his defense, so far as arranged by himself last night in the dismal rolitude of his cell. The day's proceedings were begun by District Attorney Graham, who arose and said to the court: "I desire to say to the court in view of what was said last night before the adjournment of court, that the lady, known as Miss Yoke and Mrs. How ard, was sent for, saw the prisoner and had ample opportunity for an interview with him." Holmues Contradicts the District At This is the woman concerning whom there was a warm passage-at-arms last evening between Mr. Graham and Holmes, the lat ter declaring that the woman was his wife and that Mr. Graham had done all in his power to separate them. When Mr. Graham concluded Holmes said that he had only had a three-minute inter view with the woman, and asked that it be renewed during the noon recess. H-s re quest was granted. Then the prisoner asked that a plan be produced of the Callowhill street house, in which he is alleged to have murdered Ben jamin F. Pitezel. The district attorney said such a plan was in court and would be produced at the proper time. "I also ask," Holmes continued, "that a quantity of the liquor which Mr. Graham said I used in my efforts to esterminate the Pitezel family be submitted to analysis. I want to prove that while it contains a small quantity of nitro-glycerine, it Is en tirely harmless, and is sold in every drug store." "Do you mean the liquor you left with Mrs. Pitezel In Burlington, Vt,.?" "Yes." "That has never been In my possession." Then came another request from the pris oner. He wanted to know if during the tes timony of one witness all the others should not he excluded from the court room. Judge Arnold answered that this would be done if the exigency arose. There was a lull for a moment, and then began the big work of the trial--the taking of testimony. Jeannette Pitezel, "Deas.a" the daughter of the dead man, was the first witness called. She is a slender, pale girl, of about seventeen, and was neatly attired in dark gray. She was called merely to identify several large crayons of her father, which she did. "Cross-examine," said the district attor rgey. hv "I haeno questions now," replied Holmes, but when told that "now or never" was the time to questien the witness, at least on lhe picture question, he asked: "Are these good pictures of your father as you last saw him, or two years -before?" "As I last saw him." "That is all."-. John Townsend, a photographer em ployed in the detective service, and Win. H. Kau, a private photographer, then iden tified photographs of Holmes taken by them after his arrest. Eugene Smith, who found Pi-tezel's bodly In the Callowhill street house on Sep tember 4, 1895, then told a detalled story of his discovery, whic-h has heen already fully published. He had become acquaintedl torney. Taking Tetmony.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says the trial of H. H. Holmes began in Philadelphia, drawing unusual attention due to the number of crimes attributed to him, though only one murder's evidence would be presented, and the opening was marked by unusual scenes as the prisoner's counsel retired.

New-York Tribune · 29 October 1895 · page 6

THE NEWS THIS MORNING. FOREIGN.—The Frencn Ministers handed their resignations to President Faure, the Chamber of Deputies having passed a vote of censure on their course in regard to the Southern Railway scandals. ==== More than one hundred and fifty Armenians are reported to have been killed in a massacre near Baiburt, some of them being burned allve, The engagemen: of Princess Maud of Wales to Prince Karl of Denmark is announced, - The Foreign Office in London discredits the story that & Russo-Chinese treaty has been signed. === The King ,f Corea is reported to have chosen another Queen and proclaimed himself Emperor, against the protest of the representatives of the Powers.

See moreSee less

DOMESTIC.—The trial of Holmes, the murderer, was begun in Philadelphia. === The faculty of the University of Virginia has appointed a committee to secure the rebuilding of the rotunda. Serious fires, the result of drouth, are reported from several States. =———= A. B. McDonell, of Rochester, rode 100 miles on a bicyele in 4:40:09, lowering the record. === Ex-Postmaster General Don M. Dickingon criticised the refusal of Secretary Herbert to psrmit the building of warships on the lakes. CITY AND SUBURBAN.—Ex-Pary Commissioner Edward Bell resigned from the Tammany Hall Executive Committers, === Ex-Dock Commissioner J. Sergeant Cram testified before the Comiaissioners of Accounts in the Dock Board inquiry. The managers of St. Luke's Hospital decided to raise $200,000 to equip its new Pathological Building. A discharged salesman Killed himself with a revolver when riding in a Brooklyn cab. ——= The stock market was irregular and unsettled. THE WEATHER.—Forecast for to-day: Fair, colder, with northerly winds. Temperature yesterday: Highest, 62 degrees; lowest, 47 degrees, Osborne or Oshorn is a name of ill omen in the Dutchess-Columbia-Putnam Senate District. The people of the district, and the people of the State, have not forgotten Edward B. Osborne, who was sent to the Senate in 1801 as the result of Maynard's theft of the Dutchess election return, nor the verdict of the people upon Maypard's monstrous crime. Now the Democrats have nominated in that district another man of the same name with the omission of the final letter. It Is perfectly natural that William C. Osborn should have a nervous dread of being confounded with Edward B. Osborne. The eleuient of poetic justice has not been overlooked in that the Republican candidate for Senator, William C. Daley, was one of the leaders in the movement to keep Edward B. Osborne ont of the Senate, and that the prospect of Daley's election are good. — lp The trial of H. H. Holmes, which was begun yesterday in Philadelphia, will attract unusual attention on account of the nmuber of crimes of which he stands accused, though, of course, the evidence connecting him with only a single wurder will be presented. The opening of the rial was marked by scenes out of the ordinary; the prisoner's counsel retired from the case because unable to secure a postponement, Holmes refused to accept lawyers assigned by the Court, and the selection of a jury was proceeded with while he acted as his own counsel. Judge Arnold showed plainly that he was not to be trifled with by either the defendant or the lawyers whom he claimed to have discharged. A capital case of extraordinary interest has seldom, if ever, before been opened under such peculiar circumstances. r———ll — The proverbial law's delays are partleularly to be deprecated when the problem of getting a

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This badly garbled clipping fragment mentions investigations in a cellar of a house occupied by someone named Holmes and references charges against Ministers of Justice, Interior and War, but is too damaged to summarize further.

New-York Tribune · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES ON TRIAL AT LAST

: erpe i . ly-'v as made ‘estigations in the cellar of | ‘wan ; NE QERN y " charging the Ministers of Justice, Interior and War | y gs | the house occupied by Holmes while here. He | HAD TO BE DONE—INSTANCES OF FAVOR-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The fragment describes guards controlling courtroom entry and notes that after the prisoner was placed in the dock and the judge took the bench, Holmes's two attorneys, Messrs. Rotan and another unnamed, were present.

New-York Tribune · 29 October 1895 · page 1

guarded all the entrances, and only those having | business in the courtroom were admitted. Directly after the prisoner had been placed In | the dock and Judge Arnold had taken his seat on | the bench, Holmes's two attorneys, Messrs, Rotan :

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This damaged clipping fragment mixes a courtroom scene involving Holmes, Judge Arnold, and a fraud charge against an insurance association with unrelated, disjointed references to resignations, gendarmes, and unrest, making a coherent summary impossible.

The Morning News · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES WITHOUT A LAWYER. REFUSED A CONTINUANCE, HIS COUNSEL WITHDRAW.

plosion." Holmes did not wince under court of oyer and terminer on a charge this. of having murdered Benjamin F. Pitezel. Mr. Graham told off the conspiracy Judge Arnold presided. The common against the Fidelity Mutual Life Associa forehand to the governor of Ualburt for filed out of the chamber to carry their protection against raids of Mussulmans, resignations to President Fatire at the but the governor sent only three gen Elysee. Great excitement prevails In the darmes, who did not arrive until the mur

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga. · and 1 other paper

Holmes went on trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, but after a continuance was denied his lawyers withdrew and the judge appointed new counsel, which Holmes then protested.

The Morning News · 29 October 1895 · page 1

discussion during the past several months, j was placed on trial this morning in the J court of oyer and terminer on a charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pitezel. Judge Arnold presided. The common wealth was represented by District At torney George 8. Graham and Assistant District Attorney Thomas W. Barlow, and the defense was conducted by W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan. As soon as the formality of arraigning Holmes had been concluded Attorney Shoemaker asked for a continuance of sixty days upon the ground of lack of time for preparation.

See moreSee less

Mr. Graham protested against the grant ing of a continuance and the other mem ber of Holmes' counsel, Mr. Rotan, re newed the idea of his associate. Judge Arnold briefly replied: "The mo tion for a continuance is overruled." Messrs Shoemaker and Rotan then an nounced their intention to withdraw from the case. To this Judge Arnold rejoined that a member of the bar who would withdraw from a murder case on the very eve of its trial would be called upon to show cause why he Should not be disbarred tor unprofessional conduct. Lawyer Rotan’s final plea was for a continuance until to-morrow, but this too was overruled. It was evident from the Judge's man ner that he believed the withdrawal of Holmes’ original counsel from the ease had been decided upon In the event of a failure to -secure a postponement. The calling of a jury was then begun. Enoch Turner was the first talesman, and when the district attorney had ac cepted him as a Juror, Holmes rose from his seat in the dock and stated to the court that he had discharged his attor neys, and asked for a continuance until he could secure counsel. Judge Arnold declared with consider able firmness that the case must gd on to-day, that his lawyers had no right to withdraw, but, if they did he (Holmesi eoukl secure counsel In time for them to appear to-morrow. The Judge-* declaration was made more emphatic by this statement: “Mr. Holmes, I think you ought to understand that I don’t want any advice from you as regards this case.” Holmes then turned his attention to examining Talesman Turner, and chal lenged him peremptorily. Turner was then excused. Frederick Slump, Sr., was the next talesman.and he was accepted as a Juror. At this time Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan left the court room and thus dis regarded the ruling of the court that they could not retire from the case and that disbarment would be a remedy for such a step. This left Holmes without counsel (al though he announced that he had dis charged the lawyers hlmselfj and the district attorney conferred with the court as to what should be done. Everett A. Schofield, who was in the court room, was privately asked by Judge Arnold if he would take up the defense. Mr. Schofield, who is well known as a criminal lawyer, accepted and selected Joseph R. Fahy, a young counsellor, to assist him. They had taken their seats within the bar, and were awaiting formal appointment by the court, when Holmes again rose and protested against this selec tion, upon the ground that the lawyers were not familiar with the case. The only alternative was for Messrs. Schofield and Fahy to withdraw, and this they did. The court, in ordering the trial to pro ceed, stated that Holmes could secure counsel by to-morrow. Holmes, in the course of his efforts to secure delay, had stated that he could secure the services of Attorney R. O. Moon to-morrow. The selection of a jury was then completed, Holmes conducting his own case. At 1:45 o'clock a Jury had been obtained and the court took a recess until 3 p. m. The Jury Is composed of the following: Foreman. Andrew Hertel, a shoemaker; Robert Chambers, a carter; Robert J. Kinkade, a florist; Samuel Wood, a man ufacturer; Richard Johnson, a painter; Lewis Reese, a farmer; William P. Han sell, a wagon builder; James Kenney, a machinist; Linford Biles, a paymaster; Thomas Sloan, a driver; John J. Smith, an engineer, and George D. Clash, a soap maker. When the talesmen were being examined, Law yer Moon, who has had some con nection with the Holmes case, appeared in court and had a whispered conference with the prisoner. At its conclusion Mr. Moon stated to the court that while he probably knew more about the ctfse than an outsider, he could not undertake the defense without making some prepara tions. As the court had decided that the case must proceed, Mr. Moon declined to en ter into it on short notice and Judge Ar nold excused him. Holmes made another appeal to the court for a postponement until to-morrow, but the Judge decided against him and said that as he (Holmes) had discharged his lawyers, he must de fend himself. What prospects, if any, Holmes has for securing an attorney are not known. Holmes exercised his right of chal lenge and before the Jury was obtained eighteen men had been set aside by him. It was 3:10 o'clock when the trial was resumed and nearly all of the session, which continued until 4:55, was taken up bv District Attorney Graham in outlin ing the case to the Jury. The opening address of the district, attorney was forcible throughout, but his denuncia tions of Holmes, which at times were particularly severe, had no outward ef fect upon the accused. Holmes’ compos ure was wonderful, and during the narra tive, he busied himself in taking copious notes of the prosecuting officer's address. Mr. Graham at the outset stated that under the indictment and providing the the evidence should warrant, it would be possible for the jury to find a verdict either of manslaughter, of murder In the second degree, of murder in the first de gree or of acquittal. He declared, how ever, that he would ask for a verdict of first degree murder. The district attorney went into the story of Benjamin F. Pitezel's death and the incidents connected therewith, at great length. He told of the finding on Sept. 24, 1894, of a partly decomposed and mutilated body in the house No. 1.316 Callowhill street, in this city, which was supposed to be the remains of “B. F. Perry," and who, it was believed, had been killed by an accidental explosion of chemicals; narrated the subsequent sending of a letter to the Fidelity Mutual Life Association of Philadelphia by JepI tha D. Howe, a St. Louis attorney, in ! which he stated that the body found in the Callowhill street house was not that of a man named “Perry,” but was In real i ity the corpse of Benjamin F. Pitezel, and

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va. · 29 October 1895

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

After District Attorney Graham's scathing opening address against Holmes, Holmes rose and asked the court for writing materials in his cell, help obtaining papers from Fort Worth, and a list of prosecution witnesses, which the district attorney refused.

Rock Island Argus · 29 October 1895 · page 6

MERDAS HTOGETT, ALIAS HOLMES, ON TRIAL AT LAST

HOLMES LISTENS TO A BOASTING. Bo Than Baa a Brenh with Dietrlet Attor District Attorney Graham, when a jury had been obtained, made his opening ad dress outlining the charge and proof against Holmes (he particular murder is that of Fjtsel), and it goes without saying that he did not spare the prisoner prose cuting attorneys never do. Throughout the address Holmes sat with his legs crossed, taking copious notes and listen ing with intence interest but without a shade of expression, even when Graham's resonant voice rang out in tha moat scath ing denunciation.

See moreSee less

But at the close of tke address, and when It became known to him that a night ' session would not be held, and that adjournment would t taken until today be arose and addressed tbe court. "May It please your honor, ho began bis weak voice vibrating with tbe emotion which his wonderful self-control prevented from betraying in bis face, "lam forced to ask that certain privileges be accorded me in prison. They are not very extensive privileges. X must ask tbe district attor ney to allow roe to have in my cell light. paper and writing materials, that I may DO enaMMWX W VT"" J "OP. A nwi also ask the privilege of sending ear haw ing some one connected ' with the court aent to JTprt v orcn, xez., ior retrain par iiisi nam mail to me how aeaennal I 414 not know until I heard Mr. riiitneni'sadr drean this afternoon. Agatm,. I aak that I be furnished with a list of the witneewas to be called br the commonweath. "I decline to give that," said the district ney C retinae,

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

This fragment reports that Holmes, on trial for murder, had his rarely used real name, rendered as Mndgett, read aloud in court, provoking a reaction from the packed audience.

Rock Island Argus · 29 October 1895 · page 6

Holmes for murder. The prisoner's real name, Mndgett, has been so little used tar tbe newspapers that when it was read out in court the audience which packed

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

The clipping describes jury selection and the district attorney's opening address against the prisoner, followed by defense counsel's request for more time and the judge's ruling allowing the prisoner to write a letter under court supervision.

Rock Island Argus · 29 October 1895 · page 6

responsibility. The selection of a Jury consumed several hours, Holmes freely ex ercising his pre Popitlvo of challenge, and after twelve men had been secured a recess taken. The afternoon session was devoted largely to District Attorney Graham's opening address to the jury, in Which he outlined the case in detail and subjected the prisoner to a scathing de nunciation. Application for? More Time- . ! In asking for a continuance Counsnl Shoemaker aaid: "There are three homi cide cases involved in this case, and we have had only as much time as woul be uequate preparation on one.

See moreSee less

xa waa ex life addresseu six words to her." Mr. Holmes," said Judge Arnold, "these ore mere Idle suspicions. You may write your letter; it will be taken by a court officer and no one but she shall 1 It." 'And," added the district attorney,"! Will have her in court tomorrow morning besides. I will see." concluded tho judge, "that you get light and writing materials.' I thank you. Mr, ior too pnviicire, re plied Holmes, politely bowing his head. The court then adjourned. HAYTI MAY YETBE HAPPY.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

This single item describes the opening of the trial, including Holmes's exchanges with District Attorney Graham over a woman visitor and liquor evidence, and early testimony from the victim's daughter and photographers identifying him.

The Topeka State Journal · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES AS LAWYER

the big city hall in an effort to at least catch a glimpse of the outer door of the room in which the straugesi criminal narrative of the age is being gradually unfolded. While the crier was pronouncing the stereotyped formula which declares the court open and concludes with the prayer: "God save the commonwealth aud this houorable court," Holmes stood up in the dock, his hands clasped in front of him aud his head slightly iucliued. The dav's proceedings were begun by District Attorney Graham, who arose and said to the court: "I desire to say to the court, in view of what was 6aid last night before the adjournment of court that the lady known as SJissYoke and.Mrs.Howard was sent for, saw the prisouer, and h ad ample opportunity for an interview with him."

See moreSee less

This is the woman concerning whom there was a warm pass-at-arms last even ing between Mr. Graham and Holmes, the latter declaring that the womau was his wife and that Air. Graham had done all in his power to separate them. When LIr. Graham concluded, Holmes said that he nad only had a three minuto inter view with the woman and asked that it be renewed during the noon recess. His request was granted. Then the prisoner asked that a plan be produced of the Callow Hill street house wtiere he is believed to have murdered Pitzel. The district attorney said such a plan was iu court and would be produced at the proper lime. "I also ask" Holmes continued "that a quantitv of the liquor which Mr. Gra ham said I used in my efforts to extermi nate the Pitzel family be submitted to analysis. 1 wact to prove that while it contains a smail quantity of uitro-giycer-ino it is entirely harmless, and is sold iu everv drug store." "l3: you mean the liquor you left with ilrs. Pitzel in Burlington, Vt.?"' "Yes." "That ha3 never been in mv possess ion." Then came another request from the prisoner. He wanted to know if during the testimony of one witness all the others should not be excluded from the court room. Judge Arnold answered that this would be done if the exigency arose. There wa3 a lull for a moment, and then besaa the big work of the trial the taking of testimony. Jeanette Pilzel, "Dissa," daughter of tho dead man, was the first witness called. She is a slender, pale giri of about 17 j ears, and was neatly attired in dark gray. She was called merely to identify several large crayons of her father, which she did. "Cross-examiue," said the district at torney. "I have no questions cow," replied Holmes. But whea told that then or never was the time to question the wit ness at least on the picture question, he said: "Are these good pictures of your fath er as vou last saw him, or two years be fore?" "As I last saw him." "That is alL" John Townsend a photographer em ployed in the detective service, and Win. II. llau, a private photographer. tVn identified photographs of Holmes taken by them after his arrest. Eugene Smith who found Pifzel's body in the Callow Hill street house on Sep tember 4, 1894, then told a detailed story of his discovery, which has been already fully published, lie had become acLATEST PICTURE

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The fragment describes a mob of armed men attacking Armenian villages, burning homes and schools and killing or burning captives, then shifts to a courtroom scene where a man named Holmes refuses to let two young men handle his case and insists on trying it himself after a postponement is denied.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 29 October 1895 · page 1

BROUGHT TO TRIAL

cewwl here, a mob of 500 Alussulmans assSnf "1 e Tv. rjod Lazes, the great majority of vteom again Holmes interposed Hedeclered were armed wtth Alarttm-Henrjrifles, that he wouJd not place his He in t3ie made an attack uoon the Armenians i hands of two young men who knew lrfenbltortg several vUiages in that n-, the case only by nearsay and eventuahy cjnAtv and s fire to their houses and ' iyhen hts personal entivatfes for a post echools. As h? Armenians fled in ert ponement were refused.he declared that tor they wereeSiot down, and a number t he -would himself try the case.

See moreSee less

Alean of men and women wiho were cautured. while he expressed a desire to secure it is added, wore fast-mod o stakes and burned alive. Aratenmn women who the services of Attorney R. O. Aloon. but that gentleman after learning from

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

This damaged fragment describes a prisoner, Holmes, brought under guard from a prison in a van and placed in a small square dock near the jury box, alongside a brief mention of a young bar member named Samuel Protan.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 29 October 1895 · page 1

Samuel Protan, young members of the bar. During the wait, Holmes, who had been brought up from Aroyamen fring prison, in the van, guarded even inside the closed wagon by an officer, was placed in Che small dock. This is a small square enclosure at the fur ther end of the jury box and lmmedi-

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's trial for the alleged murder of Benjamin Pietzel opened before Judge Arnold in Philadelphia, recounting the discovery of the burned body, the insurance fraud claims, and Holmes's arrest in Boston.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 29 October 1895 · page 1

Philadelphia. Pa.. 28. Okt. oder mit seinem Taufnamen Herm. W. Mudgett, den und angeblichen Massenmörder, dessen haarsträubendeßerbrechen ivährend der jüngst verflossenen Monate in Aller Munde gewesen sind und überall, wo sie vernommen, Grausen und Entsehen erregt haben, nahm hier heilte vor Richter Arnold im „Dner und ner Gerichte" seinen Anfang. s ist dies wohl der sensationellste Prozeß, welcher von der Eriminalgescluchte des Landes in den letzten Jahren zu ver zeichnen gewesen ist'. Die Einzelheiten der Vielsachen, surchtbaren Anklagen, welche gegen Holmes erhoben worden sind und die von Philadelphia, De troit, Toronto, Chicago n 'd Indiana polis immer neue schanr tung erfahren haben, sind noe ch in der Erinnerung, um hier wiederholt werden zu brauchen.

See moreSee less

In diesem spe ziellen Falle handelt es M um die an gebliche Ermordung von Benjamin Pietzel, dessen und ver brannte Leiche am 3. September 189-li in dem Hause Nr. 1316, Eallowhill Straße. Hierselbst entdeckt wurde. ES wurde damals behauptet, daß Pietzel bei'm Erperimentiren mit Erplosiv siosfen verunglückt sei, und der Leich nam. ohne daß ein anderer Berdacht rege wurde, dem Sckwoße der Erde übergeben. Pietzel hatte derzeit den Namen Perry angenommen und war auch nur unter diesem den Nachbarn und Denen, mit welchen er in Berüh rung kam. betannt. Drei Wochen spä ter erschien indessen Anwalt lephta D. Howe aus St. Louis in Philadelphia und behauptete, der Todte sei uicht Perrh, sondern Pietzel gewesen und er sei gekommen, um für dessen Gattin in Ehieago die ihr zustehende Versiche rnngssumme von von der „Mntuat Lebensversicherung zu erheben. Die Letztere zahlte, wenn auch mit Sträuben, den Betrag ans. nachdem H. H. Holmes und die 16 Jahre alte" Tochter Alice deS Berstor Venen den wieder ausgegrabenen nam alSdenjenigenPietzel'sidentisizirt. betraute aber, da sie an einen Schwin del glaubte, indem sie annahm, daß Pietzel noch lebe und eines fremden Leiche substituirt worden sei, Geheim polizisten mit der Aufarbeitung deS Falles. Am 17. November letzten Jahres erfolgte dann in Boston die Berhaftung Holmes'. Er wurde be schuldigt, an einem Eomplot zur Be schwindelung der genannten Gesell schast betheiligt gewesen zu sein, und bekannte sich anch, um der schwereren Anklage des Mordes zu entgehen, schuldig, doch umsonst. ES wurden immer neue furchtbare Entdeckungen gemacht u. jetzt steht Holmes unter dem Äerdachte. nach und nach fast ein Dutzend Menschenleben bei Seite bracht zn haben, um die Spuren seines ersten Berbreedens zu verwischen. Punkt 10 Uhr heute Bormittag wurde der Gefangene in den Gerichts faal geführt. Er war in einen feinen schwarzen Ebeoiot Anzug gekleidet, sein, in Folge der tangeil Gefängniß hast bleiches Gesicht umrahmte ein schwarzer Bollbar! und das Haar mar sorgsältig gescheitelt. Die Anwälte Holnies', W. H. Shoemaker u. Sam. P. Rotan, ersuchten den Nichter um einen Ausschub der Behandlungen, doch wies der Nichter den Antrag ab. Beide Herren verzichteten hierauf, trotz desHinweiseS desßichters auf die mög liche Strafe der Ausschließung von der Praris, noch weiter als die Vertheidi ger des Angeklagten zu sungiren. Die HH. Everett A. Sckwfield und Jos. A. Fahey stellten ans Initiative des Rich ters dem Gefangenen ihre Dienste znr Beifügung, aber Holmes lehnte dieses bcn ab und bat den Nichter, ihm eine eintägige Frist zur Engagirung eines anderen Vertheidigers, als welchen er Hrn. R. T. Moon in Aussicht genom men habe, zu gewähren. Nach der ab schlägigen Antwort des Richters mii dem Bemerten, daß er sich im Laufe des nächsten Tages nach einem solchen umsehen könne, ward dann zur Aus - loosung der Geschworeneu geschrittci, wobei Holmes selbst die in Vorschlag georachten Personen eraminirte. Kur; vor 2 Uhr w?.r das schwierige Werk vollendet. Das Geschworenen Eolle gium setzt sich, wie folgt, zusammen: Wm. P. Hansell,Grobschmied; Linsord Biles, Zahlmeister; Robert El>ambers, Kärrner; Geo. B. Elasb, Teisensieder; Louis Reese, Farmer; Thomas Sloan, Fuhrmann; John I. ?mitli, Masch: nist; Andr. Hertel, Schuhmacher; Ri chard Johnson, Anstreicher; Jas. Ken nr?, Vormann; Robert I. Kinkaide, ! Florist; Saml.Wood, Fabrikant. Hier ! auf trat in den Verhandlungen eine ! Pause bis 5 Uor ein, wann DistriktsAnwalt Graham den Geschworenen eine kurze, aber klare Skizze des Falles entwars und mittheilte, daß er um ein Verdikt des Mordes im ersten Grade nachsuchen würde. Der Angeklagte be wahrte trotz der heftigen Ausfälle ge gen seine P:rson während der Rede eine > stoische Ruhe, unbeweglich dasitzend, nur dann und wann eine slüchtigeNotiz aus das vor ihm liegende Papier wer fend oder mit den kalt blickenden stahl grauen Aucun einen schnellen Blick zur Seite wertend. Auch als Hr. Gra ham bei der Schilderung des Auffin dens von Pietzel's Leichnam, mit dem Finger aus ilm deutend, eindrucksvol len Tones sagte: „Dort steht der Mann, ! der Pietzel ermordete. Er war es, der den Körper des Todten so ver brannte, als seien die Wunden durch eine Erplosion veranlaßt." schien Hol mes völlig unberührt. Des Weiteren gab der Distriktsanwalt eine Darstel lung der von dem Geheimpolizisten Frank Geher erzielten Erfolge, wie der selbe die verkohlten Usberreste vonAlice und Nellie Pieycl in Toronto fand und auch diejenigen des kleinen How ard Pietzel in Jrvinaton, Ind., ent deckte. Nach Schluß der Rede fand Bertaguna b'S morgen statt, nachdem einem Ersuchen dcs Angeklagten um eine hellere Zelle, sowie um Lieferung von Schreibmaterial stattgegeben, ibm auch erlaubt worden war, in briefli chen Verkehr mit seiner Gattin, die aber angeblich Nichts von ihm wissen will, zu treten. 5 ist gestern Franl Ware in Fort Worth, Ter., wegen Vergiftung von MartinJ. Black, einem Lokomotivführer an der '„Fort Worth u. DenverEisenbahn," und dem Liebhaber seiner Gattin, ver urtheilt wordeit. Ter Prozeß gegen H. H. Holincs. Zu lebenslänglichem Gefängnisse ! >

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Printed in German, this report describes Holmes's arrest for conspiring to defraud a named company, noting he pleaded guilty to that charge to avoid a murder accusation, while new discoveries increasingly implicate him in further suspected crimes.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 29 October 1895 · page 1

Berhaftung Holmes'. Er wurde be schuldigt, an einem Eomplot zur Be schwindelung der genannten Gesell schast betheiligt gewesen zu sein, und bekannte sich anch, um der schwereren Anklage des Mordes zu entgehen, schuldig, doch umsonst. ES wurden immer neue furchtbare Entdeckungen gemacht u. jetzt steht Holmes unter dem Äerdachte. nach und nach fast ein

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

The clipping, in German, describes how Holmes personally examined proposed jurors and that just before 2 o'clock the difficult task was completed, listing Wm. P. Hansell, a blacksmith, as the jury selection begins to be enumerated before the text cuts off.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 29 October 1895 · page 1

wobei Holmes selbst die in Vorschlag georachten Personen eraminirte. Kur; vor 2 Uhr w?.r das schwierige Werk vollendet. Das Geschworenen Eolle gium setzt sich, wie folgt, zusammen: Wm. P. Hansell,Grobschmied; Linsord

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The clipping recounts how Holmes was arrested and tried for conspiracy to defraud an insurance company, claimed Pietzei was alive and a substitute body used, and describes Detective Geyer's travels to gather evidence, find the children's bodies, and bring witnesses to testify against Holmes.

The Portland Daily Press · 29 October 1895 · page 2

This resulted in the arrest in Boston of Mudgett, alias Holmes. The latter was brought here and was placed on trial charged wlith conspiracy to defraud the insurance company. Holmes pleaded guilty to this charge of swindling, but denied the charge of mur der, claimed that Pietzei was still living, that a body had been obtained from a New York dissecting room and placed in the building on Callowhill street, after burning theskin slightly and throwing a lamp on the floor. Holmes claimed that he and Pietzei left the city and subsequently informed Mrs.

See moreSee less

Pietzei that the body was that ot her missing husband and had her press her claim for the insurance. Holmes was sent to prison to await sentence on the conspiracy trial, and District Attorney Graham started Detective Geyer out to visit Torono,Chicago, and other western cities to endeavor to obtain evidence against Holmes which would warrant his being arraigned for murder. Detective Geyer’s success in finding the dead bodies of the children is well known and other facts which he gleaned satisfied the district attorney that Holmes could be convicted here of the murder of Pietzei. Detective Geyer also brought to this city Mrs. Pietzei and others from vairous parts of the west and Canada to take the stand as witnesses against Holmes.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The clipping, a fragment, describes the defense asking for time to raise money from Holmes's assets to pay for witnesses' travel to Philadelphia, noting new testimony found in recent days.

The Portland Daily Press · 29 October 1895 · page 2

fense pleaded for time in whioh he and his colleague could realize on Holmes's assets and thus bring witnesses to Phila delphia who will not come unless their expenses are paid. The discovery of new testimony within the past four or five

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This damaged clipping notes that Holmes is conducting his own case, remarks he should test the efficacy of prayer, and begins to raise a question about the constitutionality of a Minnesota law before cutting off.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 October 1895 · page 1

Holmes is conducting his own case. ; This is probably a good place for . him to test the efficacy of prayer. The raising of a question as to the | constitutionality of the Minnesota

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This damaged clipping jumbles courtroom details—Holmes's role in his own case, a judge overruling a defense plea for a respite—with a society item describing ornate ball gowns, including Mrs. John W. Merriam's attire.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 29 October 1895 · page 1

declination of another lawyer to .SOME OF THE COSTUMES.;^ i serve, after being selected by Holmes; and, finally, the prisoner try Some . of the gowns . worn by the ' ing his own case." This, not to speak ladies who danced were most elab orate. | Among those that were noticed of sundry dramatic passages at arms were: .*;-''■• V. • ' -"• ' *'; between Holmes and the common Mrs." John W. Merriam— Paris wealth's prosecuting officer, is a mull, over pale blue silk; -diamond or naments. "■•. • .

See moreSee less

5 summary of what occurred. and said an examination into her men tal condition made It apparent that were a continuance granted the com monwealth. would lose its most impor tant witness. Mr. .Rotan, for the defense, renewed the plea for a respite, but it was over ruled by Judge Arnold. Mr. Shoe

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

At the opening of H. H. Holmes's murder trial before Judge Michael Arnold, his attorney Shoemaker asked for a continuance citing insufficient preparation time, claiming new evidence would secure acquittal.

The Anaconda Standard · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HE IS HIS OWN ATTORNEY

HEIS HIS OWN ATTORNEY TheTrial Opens With a Sensation^^Tho Accused Fires His Coun^^sel bodily - Tilts With^the Jucigo. Philadelphia,Oct. 2^^H. H. Holmes, who,according to his own remarkable j^confession, stands at the head of the |^list of criminals, was put on the stand^In MM court of oyer and terminer this^morning for the murder of Henjamln .^K. rsll^1 The prosecutors are District^Attorney George Gr.m.im and Special^AitsrHtal Thomas W. Hrasiow. Will^^iam Siiu. maker and Samuel Rotan,^young members of the bar, appeared^for Holmes. Judge Michael Arnold Is |^upon tlie bench, only enough people I^were admitted to 1111 the court room !^without uncomfortably crowding It.^Witnessed from Oanada and different^parti of Che country were escorted Into^court shortly before 10 o'clock by De^^tective Frank Ueyer, whose travels !^throughout the United Slates In his j^search for evidence against Holmes^have been from time to time pub^^lished.

See moreSee less

Promptly at 10 o'clock Holmes^was placed In the dock. He was plainly^nervous and looked about the room^with a shifting express ion. Shot-maker^asked for a continuance. He urged^the tack of time for prei^a ration.^^There are three homicide eases In^^volved In this case,^ he urged, ^and^we had only such time as to lie ade^^quate for tlie preparation of one. It^was expected Is) present MM ne.vly dis^^covered evidence of such vital Import^^ance that Holmes will undoubtedly be^acquitted of i'hls charge.''

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

Holmes tells the court he discharges his attorneys Rotan and Shoemaker fearing their desire to withdraw will harm him, but Judge Arnold refuses his request and denies him time to secure new counsel.

The Anaconda Standard · 29 October 1895 · page 1

MayIt please the court, I have no^inclination to continue with the trial^of this case with Mr. Rotan and Mr,^Shoemaker as my counsel, feeling that,^in view of their desire to withdraw,^my interests will toe damaged. I there^^fore discharge them as my counsel. Youcannot discharge them, Mr.^Holmes,^ answered Judge Arnold.^^That Is for the court, and If they^withdraw from this case they will be^punished. If,^continued Holmes In tremulous^tones, ^you will give me until to-mor^^row to secure additional counsel Wewill have no more debate, Mr.^Holmes, the matter Is decided.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

This badly garbled OCR fragment mentions a British Columbia expedition, a commander, a Vancouver Island exploring expedition, a boundary dispute, an injured bridge jumper, and an invitation to citizens to attend some gathering, but the text is too damaged to summarize coherently.

Omaha Daily Bee · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES' TRIAL BEGINS TODAY

the British Columbia expedition and commander - stake In this hemisphere Il cannot resist the mander or the Vancouver Island exploring tenlptatiOn . on the pretext of boundary Ilsexpedition . during which he charted all the out tile country In search of evidence uf Calbaian's exhibition of ners'e. 'fhe bridge Holmes' movements . will be one or the jumper was seriously injured anti mid ( for sItuation wIll be canvassed lhoroughly aud all classes or citIzens are Invited to attend.

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The clipping reports that only those with business will be admitted to the court, recounts how a burned body found in a house the prior year was first thought to be an inventor's accidental death before Holmes was charged with murdering Pitzel in an insurance fraud scheme, and notes Pitzel's remains were brought to the city and taken to the District Attorney's office.

Omaha Daily Bee · 29 October 1895 · page 1

: precaut ns _ , , , thai wi be1talc n' tO . ii cUre thelr , nfr ot .lho , coUr , $ I ! " ' ; . FEW WILL-DE' ADMITTED. - . Announcements have been made thal only those who have buslnet therein Will be adniltted . , and that an , Increased corps or court ocer. augmented b a detail of reserve , policemen . wIll enforce this order al the. doors. The murder of Pltzcl . If murder It was , occurred mere than a year ago , The body burned and blackened os if I hy an explosion WS discovered In the 1101150 No.

See moreSee less

132tl Callow 11 street this city , on September 23. 1894 As he had been known as an Inventor named Perry . the suppositIon was that he had met death by accident Willie experimentng , Sub. sequenly the charge was made that Ilzel hal ' been murdered by Holmes In an attempt to defraud the Filely Mutual LIfo associaton of PhIladelphIa out oC $10,000. which hal been paid by the company to Mrs. Pltzei . who wa supposed to hove been a party lo the conspiracy 10lmes having fml Inlrolucel , Iltzel lo the companr. holmes waD arrested In Boston November 17. and Mrs. Ilzel Is In custody as . probably , the principal wllnesH Jgalnbl him. There Is a lIkelIhood of the case consuming several weel19. unles unforeseen - seen clrcumlancea arIse to bring Il to an earlIer conclusion The remains at young Pllzel , found In the Ivlngton house , were brought to thh cIty lonlghl hy Detective Hchards oC Indianapols , They were carried In a smal box and were Immediately taken to District Attorney Graham's 0111cc . where they wIll - ;

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

In a Philadelphia murder trial, the judge denied a delay after the defense lawyers withdrew amid disbarment threats, leaving the prisoner to reject new court-appointed counsel and begin conducting his own defense as the district attorney opened with a scathing denunciation.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 29 October 1895 · page 1

TRYING HIS OWN CASE.

JUDGE REFUSES A CONTINUANCE. lawyers For the Defense Withdraw From i the Case at the Outset—Twelve Jurymen Secured and District Attorney Graham Made His Opening; Address—Scathing Denunciation of the Prisoner. Philadelphia, Oct. '29. — H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudget, which he says is his baptismal name, was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminer Monday for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzelin this city on Sept 2, 1894, and the developments of the first day veri fied better, perhaps, than ever before, the force of the maxim that truth is stranger than fiction.

See moreSee less

From the nature of the case and the startling stories con cerning it, which have gained currency during the past year, sensational revela tions were naturally expected, when he, who has come to be regarded as the most skillful and audacious criminal in modern times, was placed on trial for his life. Yet, when it occurred in court, it so far surpassed all expectations that the most vivid flights of imagina tion could scarcely have conceived the lay’s events. Holmes’ Lawyers Withdraw. Protestations and entreaties for a con tinuance of the trial were summarily overruled; the sudden withdrawrals of the lawyers who had hitherto repre sented the prisoner in the face of threats of disbarment; the appointment of the court of new counsel and the refusal by the prisoner to accept them as his de fenders; the declination of another lawyer to serve after his selection by Holmes; and finally the prisoner trying his own case. This, not to speak of other' sharp passages at arms by Holmes and the commonwealth’s prosecuting officer, is a summary of what occurred. Long before 10 o’clock, the hour set for the opening of court, an eager crowd thronged the corridors without. The regulations were so complete, however, that none but lawyers, witnesses, jurors ana newspaper reporters were peruuueu to pass the cordon of police which formed a barrier across the entrance to the particular corridor leading to the courtroom and officers guarded every entrance to the room. This prevented undue crowding, although every seat in the room was occupied. The general public wall be admitted to the capacity of the gallery, which will seat about 600, whent the taking of testimony is begun. The clocks had scarcely ceased striking 10 when Judge Arnold, clad in the long, black robe which he recently adopted, entered and took his seat upon the bench. District Attorney Graham and his special assistant, Thomas W. Barlow, in whom the prosecution is vested, were already in court, but a de lay of 15 minutes was occasioned by the nonappearance of counsel for the de fense, William A. Shoemaker and Sam uel Pro tan, young members of the bar. During the wait Holmes, who had been brought up from Mocamensing prison in a van, guarded even inside the closed wogon by an officer, was placed in the small dock. This is a small square en closure at the further end of the jury box and immediately behind the tables allotted to the prisoner’s attorneys. Marvelous Display of Nerve. Holmes was, at the time of his arrest in Boston on Nov. 17 last, a stcckily built man of middle height, has since his long confinement grown gaunt and hollow chested. The prison bleach has brought his face to a death like pallor, heightened by the dark close cropped beard. In appearance as he sat in the dock he was neatness itself. His hair and beard were carefully trimmed, the hair smoothly parted and the black cheviot suit he wore betrayed no spot or blemish. His demeanor throughout save on one or two occasions, when he gave way to a slight burst of anger di rected at the district attorney, was characterized by that marvelous display of nerve which has become associated with his name. The original intention of the commonwealth was to hold three sessions of court daily—morning, after noon and night—but so much time was consumed by the unexpected develop ments that it was nearly 5 o’clock when District Attorney Graham concluded his opening address to the jury. In view of this and to avoid breaking the testimony of the first witness by the supper recess, it was decided to adjourn for the day. Hereafter, however, the original program will be followed. The day’s proceedings began when Messrs. Shoemaker and Rolan moved for a 60-day’s continuance, on the ground of lately discovered evidence. This was promptly refused, as was also their motion for a continuance for a day. Finding the judge inexorable, they, as a last resort, would withdraw from the case. Judge Arnold warned them that if they did so, they would lay themselves open to disbarment. There upon Holmes declared from the dock that under the circumstances he wrould not permit them to defend him. He j therefore dismissed them from his serv i ice and the lawyers left the room in i spite of the court’s threats. Judge Ar i nold then appointed E. M. Schofield and \ J. M. Fahy to assume charge of the de L fense, but again Holmes interposed. Ha declared that he would not place his i life in the hands of two young men who knew the case only by hearsay, f and eventually when his personal en j treaties for a postponment were re | fused, he declared that he would him i tself try the case. — : p Secured a Jury. * Meanwhile he expressed a desire to f secure the oerviees of Attorney R. O. 1 Moon, but that gentleman, after learn ing from the judge that he could not ^obtain a continuance, declined to accept the grave responsibility. The selecting ofiajm^jionsuTTicd^^iwprallinm*. Conducts His Own Case.

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

This brief, damaged fragment mentions the prisoner conducting his own case and sharp exchanges between him and the commonwealth's prosecuting attorney, but gives no further details.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 29 October 1895 · page 1

JUDGE REFUSES A CONTINUANCE.

Holmes; and finally the prisoner trying his own case. This, not to speak of other' sharp passages at arms by Holmes and the commonwealth’s prosecuting

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

This damaged clipping jumbles references to a prisoner acting as his own counsel, Turkish officials, insurance companies, and a note that a man will marry a Mrs. Fannie T. Hellen of Yadkin county on Wednesday.

The News & Observer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

IT WAS A DAY OF SENSATIONS

yer to serve after being selected by will give me until to morrow to tenure aftrr the slaughter was ended. Holmes; and finally the prisoner trying ad firi nal counsel .” The Turkish officials, it is claimed, his own case. ment which seems to hi felt by everyone here for the Southern Railway Company, whole of our citizens had net conspired will be married on Wednesday to Mrs. is very marked.' against a few “wild cat” insurance com Ic is not of course, possible to calcu Fannie T. Helleu, of Yadkin county.

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

H. H. Holmes went on trial in Philadelphia for the murder of B. F. Pietzel, with the first day marked by denied continuance requests, defense lawyers withdrawing under threat of disbarment, and Holmes ultimately refusing new counsel and trying his own case.

The News & Observer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

IT WAS A DAY OF SENSATIONS

Philadelphia, Pa., Oct. 23 H. H. Holmes, or Herat an W. Mudgett, which he sav 8 is bis baptismal namo, was put on trial in the Court of Oyer and Ter miner to-day for the murder of B. F. Piet*:l, in this city, on September 2. 1894, and th“ developments of the first day verifi d, better perhaps than ever before, t e force of the maxim that truth is stranger than fiction. From the nature of the ease and start ling st >rn*s cone rung it. whioh have gained currency daring the past year, sensational revelations were naturally to be expected when he who has come to be regarded av the most skillful aud auda cious crimiual of modern times was placed ou trial for his life; yet what did occur in court so far surpassed all ex pectations that the most vivid fights of imagination c >uld scarcely have con ceived the day’s events.

See moreSee less

Prostestations and entreaties for a con tinuance of the trial summarily over ruled; the sudden withdrawal of the lawyers who had hitherto represenred the prisoner, in the face of threats of disbarment; the appointment by the court bf a new counsel a id the refusal by the prisoner to accept them as his de fenders; the declination of other law yer to serve after being selected by Holmes; and finally the prisoner trying his own case. This not to speak of sundry dramatic passages at arms between Holmes and the commonwealth’s prosecuting officer, i* a summary of what occurred Arraigned against Holmes as the com monwealth prosecutors are District At torney George S Graham and his special assistant, Thomas W. Barlow, while the counsel for the prisoner at the opening of court were Wm. A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Kotan young members of the bar of thi city. Judge Michael Arnold presided. For nearly an hour before the time fixed for the opening of the court room, on the sixth flo r of the big city hail, a crowd began to gather in the corridors without. Thanks to the announcement that only those having business with the case would be admitted to the court room, there were not so many as were to have been expected. There will be some gruesome exhibits introduced in evidence during the pro gress of the trial. Among these are the skull and pans of the body of the elder Pietael; the chirred remains of his youngest 8 >n. Howard Pietzel, who is thought to have been murdered by Holmes in Irvington, Indiana, and the stove in which they >vere found in the cottage in that city. Jhese were brought here by Detective Richards, of Indian apolis, who arrived last night. The stove is a huge affair, with a body round like a large barrel, and big enough to pat two or three children into. Promptly at 10 o’clock court was formally declared open. Holmes, who has grown a full black board since his confinement in Moyamen sing prison, looked pale and wan, but immaculat ly neat. He was plainly nervous and looked about the room with a shifty expression in his steely blue eyes. The first wait was caused by the non appearance of Mr. Shoemaker, of counsel for the defense, who d d not come into court utml 10:15 o’clock. He stopped and shook hands with Holmes, and tak ing his seat, Mr. Granam instantly asked that the case proceed. Holmes was then ordered to rise, and was formally told of his right to chal lenge jurors He received the informa tion implacably. The moment this for mality had been concluded, Mr. Shoe maker arose and asked for a continuance of the case. He urged, as his basis, the lack of time which had hampered the preparation of the defense. “Tnere are three homicide ca es in volved in t is case,” he urged, “and we have nad only as much time as would be adequate for the preparation of one.” There is evidence, he con tinned, to be obtained not only from distant points in thi* country, but also from abroad, which the defense had been uaabl 3 to procure ia the short space of time left to them since the finding of the indictment— evidence which would be of the utmost impir a nee r.o the defense. The prosecu tion, Mr. Shoemaker added, bad been working on its case for throe hundred days, while the defense had had but sixty. Under these circumstances he felt justified in asking for a continuance of sixty days to give them an opportunity to ga'her their witnesses At the conclusion of Mr. Shoemaker’s address, Mr. Graham arose and said he would protest with all his vigor against the granting of a continuance. He de clared that a postponement meant the absolute destruction of the comm >n wealth’s case. No legal grounds had been laid for the request, but it was a n ply lefi to thecourt’sdiscretion. Mr Gra ham then d welt upon the severe strain under which Mrs Pietzel has been put and said an < xammation into her mental condition had made it apparent that were a continuance granted the commonwealth

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

The clipping, a fragment, describes Holmes being permitted to question jurors himself while counsel considered how to proceed, and notes he took up pencil and paper as Enoch Turner, the first juror, was called.

The News & Observer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

Holmes to question the jurors, if ha so desired, while counsel considered the question of their proceeding.” Holmes armed himself with pencil and aud paper, and Enoch Turner, the first

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, also known as Herman Mudgetts, went on trial in the Court of Oyer and Terminer for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, whose corpse was found on Sept. 3, 1894, with Judge Michael Arnold presiding and Shoemaker and Rotan defending.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 29 October 1895 · page 6

3‘ of the Crime Oharged to Holmes. who, acéording to his own confessions, stands at the head of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial in the Court of Oyer and Terminer this morning for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel. The eounssl for the prisoner, William A. Shoe maker and Samuel P. Rotan, young mem bgrs of the bar of this oity, appeared for the defense. Judge Michael Arnold pre sided. So many aliases have been worn by the man on trial during the course of his spectacular career that his baptismal name, Herman Mudgetts, has almost been lost sight of.

See moreSee less

- On Sept. 3, 1894, the corpse of a man was found in the second story of a ramshackle building at 1316 Callowhill strecs, this PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 20.—H. H. Holmes,

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The clipping recounts how an insurance company paid out on Pietzel's death after identifications by Holmes and Alice Pietzel, describes Holmes's arrest in Boston following a tip from a jailed train robber, and notes his many contradictory confessions ahead of his trial.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 29 October 1895 · page 6

H. H. HOLMES.

company, for which amount a policy had ‘been made out in fafimr of Mrs. Pietzel a year ago. Meanwhile, Holmes, who had introdiced Pietzel to the insurance agents, when the latfer was insured, was induced by the latter o come to Philadelphia and identify the body., Alice Pietzel, the 16year-old girl of the dead man, also identi fled the body. With this the . Insurance Company Paid the Mouey, ' Boon after this Marion C. Hedspeth, the notorious train robber, in jail in St. Louis, ene day made a remark that Holmes, while in an adjoining cell, had conspired with Pietzel and Howe to swin dle a Philadelphia insurance company by substituting a body supposed to be that of Pietzel.

See moreSee less

Detectives took up this clue, and worked for weeks, but not a trace could be found of Pietzel, Mrs. Pietzel or the children. Holmes, however, was ar rested on Nov. 17 in Boston. Mprs.. Pietzel, inducing her to come to Boston. She did so and wasarrested, and together they were brought to Phila d@phia. The woman was subsequently released, but has since been under the surveillance of the police. Holmes has been confined in Moyamensing prison, and at intervals has issmed statements and stories almost beyond belief. He has made -many conflicting explanations of every affair with which his name has been ~eonnected. "By his own confession, he has been implicated, directly or indirectly, in three deliberate murders, the disappear ance and possilile murder of three childrén; bigamy, many conspiracies (to one of which he has already pleaded guilty in eourt) and, in fact, almost every erime in she calendar. Which, if any, of these re markable narrations are true, will, it is eppected, be shown during the course of flhie present trial. duct throughout to be a man of unlimited merve, easy of manner, elogquent of speech, pefined in appearance, self-confident and ambitious. for the opening of the courtroom a crowd began to gather in the corridors without, but o v enough were admitted to flll the room ‘hout uncomfortably crowding it. He was made to write a decoy letter to ‘Holmes has proved himself by his con For nearly an hour before the time fixed

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

This damaged, jumbled clipping fragments together an item about a deputy sheriff's writ tied to a dispute between rival theatrical managers with an unrelated report on Lord Salisbury's dissatisfaction over a sultan's verbal guarantees.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 29 October 1895 · page 1

DAY OF SENSATIONS.

last evening. He was driven to “Walke LoxNDpoN, Oct. 29.—The Daily News says that it hears that Lord Salisbury is dis hurst,”” his residence here. The deputy sheriff who holds the writ for Van Alen’s satisfled with the sultan’s verbal guaran flssued yesterday. The injunction is the trial was resumed, Holmes conducting his result of a gquarrel between rival theatri cwn defense. cal managers as to which should have asking the government to prosecute all those who have been found to be impli cated in them, and submit to the chamber

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The clipping describes a trial day of unexpected drama, including a denied continuance, defense lawyers withdrawing under threat of disbarment, the prisoner rejecting court-appointed counsel, and his decision to conduct his own defense.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 29 October 1895 · page 1

TO CONDUCT HIS OWN DEFENSE

on trial for his life. Yet what did occur in court so far surpasse&hfill expectatiens that the most vivid flights of imagination could scarcely have conceived the day’s events. Protestations and entreaties for a con tinuance of the trial summarily over ruled; the sudden withdrawal of the law yers who had hitherto represented the prisoner, in the face of threats of disbar ment; the appointment by the court of new counsel and the refusal by the prisoner to accept them as his defenders; the de clination of arother lawyer to serve after being selected by Holmes, and, finally, the prisoner trying his awn case, this, not to speak of sundry dramatic passages at arms between Holmes and thz common

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The clipping describes Holmes rejecting appointed attorneys Schofield and Fahy, pleading unsuccessfully for a postponement, and then proceeding to examine jurors himself after the judge ordered the trial to continue.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 29 October 1895 · page 1

TO CONDUCT HIS OWN DEFENSE

open to disbarment by mkt'x 'such a step ‘“‘on the eve of o mtirder L A still further sensation was created when Holmes refused te accept the services of Attorneys . A. Schofield and J. R. Fahy, whom the ¢ourt was about te appoint to defend him, and who, in faect, had taken seats in the chairs vadated by Sheemaker and Rdtan, Schefield ahd Fahy also with drew. Holmes himself pleaded to the court fora postpongment, but the judge declared that the case must go oen. The trial was resumed, Holmes conducting his cwn defense. The work of securing a jury was then taken up, and Holmes examined the tales

See the clipping

Daily Independent · Elko, Nev.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says the trial of H. H. Holmes, called "the many times murderer," began in Philadelphia the day before, and that he discharged his attorneys in court after the judge refused to grant a continuance.

Daily Independent · 29 October 1895 · page 3

house of representatives. It will need a parachute to come over the Alle ghenies. Webster Patterson laid off the foun dation of the high school building to day. The building will face the street ruiining on the east side of the courthouse aud can be plainly seen from the railroad. Self denial is the one thing most ! difficult to inculcate and always bard to practice, especially when there are good things to eat within reach. But i there is no self-denial necessary if you take Simmons Liver Regulator. It promotes digestion, prevents Dyspep sia and a dose after a hearty meal of delicacies will prevent any discom fort.

See moreSee less

It's the best good-night toddy The trial of H. H. Holmes, the many times murderer, began in Phil adelphia yesterday. Holmes dis charged his attorneys in the court room because the Judge would not grant him a continuance. The returns of the recent school elections in Connecticut showed that the women cast only 1,90G votes, as compared with 3,241 in 1994 and 3,806 in 1893. This seems to imply that the women do not care much about the ballot after they get it. An attempt was made to wreck pas senger train No. 4 about two miles west of Golconda Sunday. The Sil ver State 6ays a tie had been placed across the track, but the engineer for tunately saw it in time to stop the train before reaching the obstruction. There is no clue to the perpetrators, though it was doubtless the dastardly work of tramps. Avoid Pneumonia, diphtheria and typhoid fever by keeping the blood pure, the appetite good ind the bodily health vigorous by the use of Hood's Sarsaparilla. Hood's Pills have won high praise for their prompt and efficient yet easy action. /

See the clipping

The Dalles Daily Chronicle · the Dalles, Or.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, on trial in Philadelphia for many murders, has dismissed his attorneys and is now conducting his own case, but the fragment ends mid-sentence.

The Dalles Daily Chronicle · 29 October 1895 · page 2

H. H. Holmes, now on trial in Phila delphia, charged with many murders, has discharged his attorneys and is con ducting his own case. If he succeeds in

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash. · and 1 other paper

A damaged clipping reports Col. Morrow mustering a militia company at a location rendered as 'Muitan,' alongside fragmented references to testimony, an arrest in Boston, and a demand that a minister of justice publish documents, but the text is too corrupted to follow clearly.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

COURT REFUSES A CONTINUANCE

der was not given. Col. Morrow mustered in a company of militia at Muitan today, many being working miners. The mem a' out V¥>, whe'n the taking of testimony is Company, Seattle; Sterr.s Commission Co.. begun tomorrow. Holmes, at the time of Spokane; Snake River Fruit Company, his arr >t in Boston on November 17 last, Spokane; Charles I'hden, Spokane; Win on behalf of the Southern railway*. Ha d stri.-t attorney'* n»xt step was to out demanded th-it the minister of justice, M. line the story of the crime, from the tini!» Trarieux, publish :he documents in th* of the discovery of the body n the Callow

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · the Dalles, Or. · 2 November 1895

The Daily Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

At his Philadelphia trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, Holmes, representing himself, questioned jurors about a dime museum exhibit resembling him and asked the court for writing materials, papers from Fort Worth, Texas, and a witness list, the last request being refused by the district attorney.

The Daily Morning Astorian · 29 October 1895 · page 1

WITH WELL CHOSEN WORDS HE

Special to the A&torlan. Philadelphia, Oct. 28.-H. H. Holmes whs put on trluil today for the murder of Benjamin F. PeKsel. Holmes refused to accept the services of counsel and fas conducting his ow.i cos?. Holmes continued questioning the Jurors as they caime up. His words, whivh em biUced the usual technical - qucis:ion, 'were well chosen. In addition to tha questloins as -to whief'Jhcr or net Jurcrs had formed any opinion as to the gulH or Innocence ot tlhie prleoner and the enter tainment of conscientious sorup'es sa ns: raipltol punlbhment, HoCmes aim asked: ' "Have you vWited the dime museum at Ninth and Arch streets?"

See moreSee less

- The reason for thia question was Hhs fact itthat 'there has been on exhibition In the museum for some wek a counterpat of Holmes, "the multi-murderer," as he Is there caT.ed, togethler with niodelv ot the Irvlngton, Ind.,' house und the Chi cago 'Vsustle." AM who had seen tihts were peremptorily challenged by Holmies. After title district attorney concluded1 his open ing statement HoOmes arose 1n the dock, and blue last senotatlon of the day, replete with extraiondlnary Indldjats, occurred. "May It JJease your honor," he began, his weak voice Vibrating with the e-mo-'tion .which to! iwondorful seat-control pre vented from betraying n Ms face, "I am forced to ask ithait oertu-ln privileges bo acoordled me in prison. They are net ve-y exttehiSIve prtvE'ege I must ssk 'tha C'-k trlct attorney (to aKoiw me to have In my cell, MBht, paper and writing miatcrluta that I mayjre enabled to prepace my case and I ask t'lie jirlvllege of se.idlng, or buy ing Borne one connected with the court, sent 'to Fort Worth, Teras, for cei'taln papers emenfthil to ime, how essential 1 did not know until 1 heard Mr. Graham's addiress Hhtla. eifteirnoon. AgJiln I ask that 1 be furnlflhext mltUi a lUit of-the witnesses "I decline to give that," said ths H Su it riot attorney, eovpTHait'laally,' "I will fur nbh that to nobody." The Judge ordered thtait Holmes be fur nished Willi writing materials. '

See the clipping

The Evening Dispatch · Provo, City, Utah

The clipping, somewhat garbled, reports that H. H. Holmes, also known as Herman Mudgett, went on trial in Philadelphia's court of oyer and terminer on October 28 for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel.

The Evening Dispatch · 29 October 1895 · page 1

Holmes or Herman Mudgett, which he says is his baptismal name, was put on trial In the court of oyer and terminer today for the murder of Benjamin F. Piezel in this citv onyUr'nbar 2,1891, HOLMS Jon TBIA&. Philadelphia, Pa Oct, 28. H. H.

See the clipping

The Evening Dispatch · Provo, City, Utah

A garbled fragment describes someone discovering a silver-handled oak casket in a house, then shifts to describe a stockily built, now gaunt and pale defendant appearing in court before an eager crowd awaiting the session's opening.

The Evening Dispatch · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES ON TRIAL

next corner to got tho dimensions of it I struck the other corner so quick that it made my hair raise right up. I knew Uiere was only one thing they build ot such shape, and that's a coffin. "I turned my light on it, and it was a big oak casket, one of the kind they make now'days, square and solid, and it had three silver handles on each side I didn't dare look in, hut I felt aa though I ought to have them handles. The head was toward the front of the house and the foot toward tho dining room.

See moreSee less

I set my lamp down and got my yerifled, better perhaps than ever be fore the force of the maxim that truth is stronger than uiction. Long before 10 o'clock, the hour set for the opening of court, an eager crowd thronged the corridors without. Holmes was, at the time of his ar rest, in Boston on November 17, last, a stockily built man of middle heieht, but since his long confinement has grown gaunt and hollow cheated. Tne prison bleach has brought his face to a deathly pallor, heightened by the dark close cropped beard. In appearance as he sat in the dock today, he was neat

See the clipping

The Evening Dispatch · Provo, City, Utah

This damaged fragment jumbles an editorial about alleged Democratic reduction of a city's debt, a Hood's Sarsaparilla scrofula testimonial, a list of names, and a note that a man using the name Holmes or Herman Mudgett was put on trial in a court of oyer and terminer.

The Evening Dispatch · 29 October 1895 · page 1

the centor. I came to it presently and for farther on in the editorial which m Wm. H. Snyder, Fairfield. B L. B. Rodeback. Cedar Fort. contains the above imitation "tariff found it very solid feeling, with a sort H Wm. H WlnnLehi. picture" appears the following: of molding or carving along the edge. Hj Henry Moyle, Alpine. "There is a claim made that demo I had struck it on a side apparently, Hj James H. Clarke, American -Fore. crata reduced the city's indebtedness. and so I felt toward the dining room now rejoice oyer a per aianent cure by Philadelphia, Pa Oct, 28.

See moreSee less

H. H. Hood's Sarsaparilla. Scrofula may Holmes or Herman Mudgett, which he appear as a humor, or it may attack says is his baptismal name, was put on the glands of the neck, or break out in trial In the court of oyer and terminer dreadful running sores on the body and

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C. · and 1 other paper

On the second day of his trial, Holmes, acting without a lawyer, requested books to prepare his defense, cross-examined prosecution witnesses about Pitezel's identity and death, and asked whether his third wife, Miss Yoke, would testify.

Alexandria Gazette · 29 October 1895 · page 2

The Holmes Trial. Philadelphia, Oct. 29.?The second day of the Holmes trial was began this morning. Throughout all last night in tbe loneliness of his cell Holmes work? ed steadily preparing his case. When court opened, Holmes asked that he be granted some further privileges in the way of books, &c, to enable him to conduct his case. He also complained ol the lack of a lawyer. The pros? ecution began its case by calling wit? nesses to prove the identity of Pitezel and the manner of his death. Holmes' object in his cross-examina?

See moreSee less

tions of witnesses was to discredit them with the jury as to their recollections of evedts. Holmes asked if his wife, Miss Yoke, tbe third woman he married, was pres? ent and would be a witness. Mr. Gra? ham said she was not present, but de? clined to say whether she would be a witness. Picked up at Sea.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D. · 2 November 1895

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

This damaged clipping fragment describes a courtroom scene in which Shoemaker requested a sixty-day continuation citing lack of time, charges against President Lawrence were dismissed, and Holmes rose to speak before Magistrate Crane, but the text is too garbled to follow clearly.

Richmond Dispatch · 29 October 1895 · page 7

| Shoemaker asked for a continuation of | against President Lawrence, principally | the same as that against Sturgis, should sixty days, upon the ground of lack of be dismissed. Magistrate Crane then pa the conclusion of the address, but before the charge of coming into the State for unlawful purposes, and the mysterious this was announced by the crier, Holmes arose from his seat in the dock, and ask attitude of the Governor's scouts here,

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This fragment notes that Holmes, stockily built when arrested in Boston on November 17 last, has grown gaunt and hollow-chested during his long confinement, as proceedings are set to begin tomorrow.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

begun tomorrow. Holmes, at the time of his arr >t in Boston on November 17 last, was a stockily built man of middle height, but since his lons confinement has *rown Kaunt and hollow chested. Th» prison

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This fragment describes Holmes appearing nervous in the dock at 10 o'clock while his suit showed no spot or blemish, and reports that Shoemaker asked for a continuance citing lack of time, though the clipping cuts off before explaining further.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

COURT REFUSES A CONTINUANCE

suit hr wore betrayed no spot or blemish. Promptly at 10 o'clock Holmes was pla ed in the jjock. He was plainly nerv ous, and looked about the room with a shifting expression. Shoemaker asked for a continuance. He urged lack of time for

See the clipping

Wisconsin Vorwärts · Milwaukee, Wis.

The clipping reports that amid a series of sensational revelations about Holmes's murders, a new sensation arose in court this morning caused by an action of Holmes's defenders, though the text breaks off before explaining what it was.

Wisconsin Vorwärts · 29 October 1895 · page 1

die Reihe ſenſationeller Entdeckungen wn Holmes' ſchen Mordthaten, mit delchen die Leſer der „Freie Preſſe“ unigermaßen vertraut ſein dürftlen. Heute Morgen wurde im Gericht rine Senſation dadurch hervorgerufen, daß die Vertheidiger des Holmes auf

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

This badly scrambled OCR fragment mentions a District Attorney Graham speaking regarding Holmes (also called Herman Mudcott), and references a warning given to John D. Rockefeller about an outbreak, but the text is too damaged to clearly follow.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

HE WILL BE HIS OWN ADVOCATE

donunciatiou. Holmes, or Herman Mudcott, which he UXIlTlONiL INCInn.1T. Diitrict Attorney Graham apoko lor >aya Ii his baptiamai name, wat put on ml at Hankow, It is now known, was on baturday, tint Jubu D. Kockufullar warnod that an outbreak would occur at is interested iu the Morganititlou ol the Wa Cheng on b'opimbor, 12, whou the Wisconsin Central, but it is lonrno.l on

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

In a courtroom exchange, Holmes demands to know if the district attorney has intercepted his letters to a woman, but Judge Arnold dismisses this as suspicion and permits Holmes to write her a letter to be delivered by a court officer.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 29 October 1895 · page 1

AI.LOWBD TO WHITE. More Judgo Arnold Interposed. "Mr. Holmes," he aaid, "you will bo allowed to writo a lottor to her, and it will be oont by one of tho court ofllcera." "I don't want it taken by any ofUcor who in in any way connocted with tho diitrict attorney." laid Holmes, with a look of scorn at Mr. Graham. "You tiara had every opportunity of upoaktiiii to her," tho lattor ropeatod. "It is Indifferent to mo whotheryou aeo her or not." .Jt'i ill . ,11 "11100 Will vou mnnoi uiiouo ijmii* tion ?

See moreSee less

* demanded Holuioi, ioarchl(iK>r? "llavo you or havo you not iiitercoutod lottera from mo to hor *lnco lint July? Havon'tyou dono orerrthlmr In your powor to keop us apart? Answer jroi or no." "You have no right to ao quoition mo, but I will sav that I have nerurln my lifo addrossod lix words to hor?" "Mr. llolmod," oald Juiltfo Arnold, "these aro inoro i Ho suspicions. You inny writo your lottorj it will ho taknu l?y a court nlllcer ami no ono but alio 0I1 nil loo it." "And," nddoTI the district attorney, "I will havn hor in court to-morrow morning boildoi." "I will noo," concluded tho judgo, noaa tho trial.

See the clipping

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

The clipping, garbled in places, reports that H. H. Holmes, also called Herman Mudgett, went on trial for murder, with a jury selected amid disputes over his counsel before the district attorney delivered a scathing opening address.

Arizona Republican · 30 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES, Entreaties for Continuance Overruled. Defendant's Lawyer Withdraws From the Case.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 29. H. H. Holmes, or Herman Mudgett, which he says is his batismal name, was put on trial today for the murder of Benja ber 2, 1894. Protestations and entreaties for a continuance of the trial were sm represented the prisoner In the face of threats of disbarment, and the ap sel and refusal 'by the prisoner to ac being selected by Holmes and which finally led to the prisoner trying his own case. These three, not to speak of the sharp passages at arms between Holmes and the commonwealth's pros curred.

See moreSee less

The selection of a jury consumed several hours, Holmes freely exercis ing his prerogative of challenging and after twelve men had been secured, a recess was taken. The afternoon session was devoted largely to District Attorney Graham's opening address to the jury, in which he outlined the case in detail and then subjected the prisoner to a scathing denunciation. Holmes, however, was imperturable and sat with his legs crossed calmly taking notes. min F. Pietzel, in this city on Septem marily overruled. The sudden with drawal of the lawyer who had hitherto pointment by the court of a new coun cept them as his defenders, the decla ration of another lawyer to serve after ecuting officer, summarizes what oc

See the clipping

In the story →

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn. · and 2 other papers

This single article reports that Holmes abandoned his own defense to retain counsel Shoemaker and Rotan, as witnesses testified at length in his Philadelphia trial over Pitezel's murder.

Waterbury Democrat · 30 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HOLMES HAS COUNSEL.

THE PRISONER TIRES OF TRYING HIS OWN CASE.

See moreSee less

Witnesses Tell What They Know of the Story of Pitezel's Murder—The Murdered Man's Daughter Testifies—Holmes' Photographs Identified.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 30.—It is apparent that the picturesque and startling features of H. H. Holmes' career were not to be confined to his destructive wanderings over the American continent, for with each successive day comes something still more strange and unexpected.

After fighting tooth and nail single handed against the tremendous machinery of the commonwealth and the apparently complete chain of evidence which has been forged around him, Holmes last night threw up his hands and sent for his lawyers, Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan. Then he told the court what he had done, and a reluctant consent to their continuing with the defense was given. There was an impression that this was but another piece of byplay following Holmes' personal failure to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by making himself out a much wronged man, forced to fight alone what may prove to be his last battle in spite of his ignorance of the technicalities of the law and his alleged physical infirmity.

The big work of the trial—taking testimony—was begun at 10 a. m., and with the exception of brief intermissions at lunch and supper time was continued until nearly 9 o'clock at night.

The star witnesses of the trial—Mrs. Pitezel, Detective Geyer, Agent Perry of the swindled insurance company and the alleged arch criminal himself—yet remain to be heard, as also nearly two score of others. District Attorney Graham remarked that there was a likelihood of the trial outrivaling the Durant case in point of time, but that if night sessions were held regularly it might be concluded within a month or less. Holmes made a plea asking the court to hold but two sessions a day. In plaintive tones he said that his physical condition was such that he felt unable to continue the cross examination of the witnesses, and besides he was subject to sick headaches. Judge Arnold insisted, however, on holding an extra session last night.

Facing the Picture of His Alleged Victim.

All day, as Holmes sat in the dock, the eyes of the man he is charged with murdering gazed at him from a large crayon portrait placed upright on the district attorney's desk in full view of the entire court. Next to this was an equally large sized picture of the daughter Alice, whose death is also laid on his shoulders. But Holmes did not seem to be affected. His stolid demeanor never deserted him for an instant.

The announcement that the taking of evidence would begin drew a still larger crowd to the city hall, but the admirable police arrangements kept everybody out of the courtroom except attorneys and those concerned in the case.

The interest manifested in the case is not confined to one class. During the day Judge Arnold had no less than eight visitors—all judges from this and other cities in the state. Besides, the head of every municipal department was noticed in the room at different times, including the mayor.

The first witness called was Jeannette Pitezel, one of the children of the dead man, who escaped the fate of the bigger part of the family.

She was a slim girl, with rather dull features and by no means pretty. She was attired for the occasion and conscious of it. Miss Pitezel was kept on the stand long enough to identify a crayon portrait of her father as presenting an excellent likeness of him as he appeared two years ago.

Holmes cross examined her for a moment as to whether there hadn't been a change in the appearance of her father, occasioned by the removal of his beard. She said her father had had a small goatee at one time.

Holmes' Photographs Identified.

John Townsend, a photographer employed in the detective service, and William H. Rau, a private photographer, then identified photographs of Holmes taken by them after his arrest.

Eugene Smith, who found Pitezel's body in the Callowhill street house on Sept. 4, 1894, then told a detailed story of his discovery, which has been already fully published. He had become acquainted with the dead man on Aug. 22, 1894, through business concerning patents which Pitezel was supposed to have held. He saw him several times during the following week. The witness drew a packet of papers from his pocket when he came to the dates. Holmes objected to his referring to them unless they were in his own handwriting. Smith admitted that the papers had been "prepared," and the court sustained the objection.

Smith said that during his first visit to Pitezel, Holmes came in and went upstairs. A moment later Pitezel excused himself and followed. He returned shortly. The witness was present when the corpse of Pitezel was exhumed from the potter's field and was there first introduced to Holmes. Lawyer Howe of St. Louis, Alice Pitezel, the young daughter, and the insurance officers were there. The body was recognized by the witness as Pitezel's. Holmes offered $30 to have the corpse cremated and asked Howe about it. The lawyer answered that the widow would first have to be consulted.

Dr. Scott was called and told his story, which concerned his having been called in to examine Pitezel's body, after its discovery. He explained the situation of the room and the arrangement of the windows so that the sun's rays should fall upon the corpse and hasten decomposition, together with the position of the burns on the body, the broken jar, pipe, etc. He verified the district attorney's assertion of yesterday that the pipe could not have fallen from the lips of Pitezel to the place where it was found, and that the jar could not have been broken by an explosion because the pieces of glass were not scattered about the room, but were inside the jar. The doctor dwelt upon the discovery of chloroform in the stomach and said large quantities of the drug had been used, and from the congested condition of the lungs and the empty heart it was apparent that the man had met a sudden and violent death from chloroform poisoning.

Holmes then subjected Dr. Scott to a lengthy and detailed examination touching the effects of chloroform, but obtained few answers that would tend to throw the balance in the slightest degree in his favor. The witness was regarded by the commonwealth's officers as one of their medical experts, and he was positive and uncontradictory in everything he said in spite of the fact that his questioner—the prisoner—is a medical man by education. Holmes kept up a steady fire of questions and never felt obliged to pause for a word or thought. The calmness with which he volubly exchanged technical terms and discussed chemical and medical possibilities with the doctor was admirable.

Dr. William K. Mattern, coroner's physician, was next called. Holmes at once arose and begged the court to grant him a continuance until tomorrow. He pleaded that as Dr. Mattern would prove a most important witness he felt unequal to the strain, the cross examination of Dr. Scott having exhausted him. He hoped to feel stronger tomorrow.

Judge Arnold asked the district attorney whether he would agree to this, and Mr. Graham replied with emphasis:

"No, sir. I want to go on. This is only more byplay."

"That is your opinion," said Holmes, with the scarce subdued scorn which has marked all his intercourse with the district attorney since the trial began.

"That is my opinion."

Holmes suppressed a sigh and sat down, and the district attorney smiled slightly, with the thought which he has made evident throughout that Holmes is playing the role of a weak, helpless unfortunate, oppressed and crushed by the mighty machinery of the state, in order to get the sympathy of the jury.

Testimony of Coroner's Physician.

Dr. Mattern's examination was then begun.

The witness said he had made the post mortem examination at the morgue on Sept. 4, and the conditions were the same as described by Dr. Scott. There had been paralysis of the heart, causing sudden death, and evidence of chloroform in the stomach. He dilated on the ghastly scene at the potter's field, when, in the presence of a half dozen other persons, including the officers of the swindled insurance company and the young daughter of the dead man, Holmes took a lancet and coldly and ruthlessly cut and hacked off portions of the corpse of the man he is charged with having murdered. The girl Alice had then positively identified the body, and Holmes himself, the witness said, did not hesitate to declare that it was Pitezel's body.

Dr. Henry Leffmann, the well known analytical chemist, was the next witness. He said it was impossible for a man to fix himself in an attitude as reposeful as that in which Pitezel's body was discovered after having administered chloroform to himself.

Holmes merely asked a few questions on cross examination, but reserved the right to call Dr. Leffmann as a witness for the defense after his (Holmes') testimony had been taken.

Coroner Samuel H. Ashbridge produced two affidavits identifying the body of Pitezel, made respectively by Alice Pitezel and Holmes. They were read to the jury and offered in evidence.

Holmes Asks For His Attorneys.

The evening session began a few moments after 7 o'clock. The taking of testimony was about to be resumed when Holmes, who could probably be more aptly called the "arch actor" than anything else, brought out a new piece of byplay.

He arose in the dock, and addressing the court said: "If your honor please, I have a request to make. In consequence of the severe physical strain to which I have been subjected and also because of the criticism leveled against my former counsel, Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan, I have within the past half hour sent for them and asked them to again assume charge of my defense. I should like to ask if the court will permit this?"

"Let them come in," said the judge.

A moment later the two counsellors, looking pale and worried, entered the courtroom, and Mr. Rotan, going up to the bar, was about to enter upon a lengthy explanation when Judge Arnold curtly interrupted with: "No apology is necessary. Go on with the case."

The dock, with its occupant, was then moved back to its former place, and Holmes' counsel took seats at the desk.

William Moebins and Frederick Richards, saloon keepers, testified as to Pitezel's drinking habits.

Mrs. Adela Alcorn, a physician who lives on Eleventh street, was called. Holmes had been at her house from Aug. 5 to Sept. 2, 1894, under the name of Howell. He had hired rooms there. The witness was not sure that his wife was with him, but he brought her later. He said she was very tired, as she had come from Chicago, and he would rather have her at the house than at a hotel. The witness again saw him on the afternoon of Sept. 19 in her parlor. He went out and came back in the evening. He said his wife and little sister would be there later; that they were then in Atlantic City. Holmes told her he was himself going there Saturday and would bring them back with him the following Monday for the winter. On the 19th a man called to see Holmes, or Howell, as he was there known, and was shown to his room, according to instructions. She identified Pitezel's picture as that of the caller. Later she saw him go out. On cross examination she was questioned as to her belief that the picture was that of the caller, and she was positive.

John Grammer, who lives in the Eleventh street house, corroborated the greater part of Mrs. Alcorn's testimony, and added that when Holmes came back the second time he had a little girl with him. Witness identified Alice Pitezel's picture as that of this girl. They remained until the following Sunday, the 19th, and then went away.

Josiah W. Richmond had known Pitezel well and had taken him to his sister's house to get board. Pitezel had told him that Perry was not his right name and spoke of bringing his wife and children from the west.

John F. Hughes, furniture salesman, had sold a bill of goods to Pitezel on Aug. 17, 1894. Holmes accompanied him. The furniture was sent to 1316 Callowhill street.

Walter W. Shedaker, real estate agent, rented the house to Pitezel on Aug. 18, 1894.

The court adjourned until 10 a. m. today.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del. · 30 October 1895
  • The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 30 October 1895

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

After abandoning his own defense and reinstating his lawyers, Holmes sat through a long session of testimony-taking as Jeannette Pitezel was called as the first witness, with portraits of the alleged victims displayed before him in court.

Evening Journal · 30 October 1895 · page 2

HOLMES HSS COUNSEL

Plltt.ADFl.PHIA, Oct. 80.—It is apparent that tlio picturesque and startling fea tures of H. H. Holmes' career were not to be confined to his destructive wander ings over tho American continent, for with each successive day comes something still more strange and unexpected. After fighting tooth afiti nail single hand ed against tho tremendous machinery of tho commonwealIh ami tho apparently complote chain of evidence which has (icon forged around him. Holmes Inst night throw tip his hauls and sent for his law yers, Messrs. Shoemaker and Kotnn. Then ho told the court what lie bad done, and a reluctant consent to their continuing with tho defense was given.

See moreSee less

There was an impression that this was lint another piece of byplay following Holmes' per sonal failure to catch tho sympathy of the court ami jury by making himself out a in iidi wronged man, forced to light alone what may prove to be ids last battle in splto of ids ignorance of tho technicalities of tho law and his alleged physical infirm ity The big work of the trial—taking testi mony—was begun at 10 a. m., and with the exception of brief intermissions at lunch and supper time was continued un til nearly U o'clock at night. The star witnesses of tho trial—Mrs. Pite/.ol, Detective Geyer, Agent Perry of tho swindled insurance company und tho alleged arch criminal himself—yet remain to lie heard, as also nearly two score of others. District Attorney Graham re marked that there was a likelihood of the trial outrivaling the Durant caso in point of tlrao, but that if night sessions were held regularly it might bo concluded with in a mouth or less. Holmes made a plea asking the court to hold but two sessions u day. In plaintive tones lie said that his physical condition was such that ho felt unable to continue the cross examination of the witnesses, and besides he was sub ject to sick headaches. Judge Arnold In sisted, however, on holding an extra ses sion last night. Facing the I'lotnre of HU Alleged Victim. AH day, as Holmen sat in tho dock, the eyes of tho man ho is charged with mur dering gazed at him from a large crayon portrait placed upright on tho district at torney's desk in full view of the entire court. Next to this was an equally largo sized picture of tlio daughter Alice, whose death is also laid on Ills shoulders. Hut Holmes did not seem to bo affected. His stolid demeanor never deserted him for an instant. Tho announcement that the taking of evidence would begin drew a still larger crowd to tho city ball, but tho admirable police arrangements kept everybody out of tlio courtroom except attorneys and those concerned in the case. The Interest manifested In tho case is not confined to out class. During tho day Judge Arnold had no less than eight vis itors—all judges from this and other ottios in the state. Besides, tho head of every municipal department was noticed in tho room at different times, including the mayor. Tho first witness called was Jeannette Pitozel, one of tho children of tho dead man, who oseaped tho fate of tho bigger part of the-family. She was a slim girl, with rather dull features and by no moans pretty. She was attired for the occasion and conscious of It. Miss Pitozel was kept on t)io stand long enough to identify a crayon portrait of her father as presenting an excellent like ness of him as ho appeared two years ago. Holmes cross examined lier for a mo ment os to whether thorp hadn't been a obango in tho appearance of her father; occasioned by the removal of his beard. Nile said her father had huda small goatee at one time. Holm«»' Photograph» Identified. John Townsend, a photographer em ployed In the detective service, and Wil liam H. Hau, a private photographer, then identified photographs of Holmes taken hy them after his arrest. Eugene Smith, who found Pltozel's body in the Callowbtll street house on Sept. 4, I8Ü4, then told a detailed story of his discovery, which has been already fully published. Ho bad become acquainted with tho dead man on Ang. SS, 1 Hit i, through business concerning patents which Pitozel was supposed to have held. Ho saw him several tiroes during the fol lowing week. The witness drew a packet of papers from his pocket when ho came to tho dates. Holmes objected to his re ferring to them unless they were in his own handwriting. Smith admitted that lau papers had been "prepared," and the court sustained the objection. Smith said that during his first visit to Pitozel, Holmes came in and went up stairs. A moment later Pitozel excused himself and followed. He returned short ly. Tho witness was present when tlio corpse of Fitezcl was exhumed from tho potter's field ami was there first introduced to Holmes. Lawyer Howe of St. Ianils, Alice Pitozel, the young daughter, and the insurance ofiioors wore there. Tho body was recognized hy tho witness ns Pitezol's. Holmes offered 8!10 to have the corpse cremated and asked Howe about it. Tho lawyer answered that the widow would first have to bo consulted. Dr. Scott was called ami told his story, which concerned his having been called In to examine Pltezol's body, after its discovery. Ite explained tho situation of tho room and the arrangement of tho windows so tliat tlio sun's rays should fall upon tlio corpse and hasten decomposition, together with tho position of the burns on tho body, tho broken jar, pipe, etc. verified the district attorney's assertion of yesterday that tho pipe could not have fallen from tho lips of Pitezol to tho place where It was found, and tliat the jar could not have been broken by an explosion be cause the pieces of glass were not scattered about the room, but were inside tho jar. Tlie doctor dwelt upon the discovery of chloroform tu tho stomach and said largo quantities of the drug had been used, and from the congested condition of tho lungs and Ihu empty heart It was apparent that the man had met a sudden and violent death from chloroform poisoning. Holme« CroM Examines Srott, Holmes then subjected Dr. Scott to a '■•ut'hy and detailed examination touch ing tqe effects of chloroform, but obtained few answers that would tend to throw tlio bat«nee in tho slightest degree in his fa vor. Tlie witness was regarded by the eemmou'.vcalth's officers as one» of their medical experts, and he was positive and He

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

At the trial's opening, District Attorney Graham noted a woman called Miss Yohe/Mrs. Howard met the prisoner, who claimed she was his wife and asked for a longer interview and for testing of a liquor he said contained harmless nitro-glycerine, while a daughter of the dead man identified crayon portraits in court.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 30 October 1895 · page 3

Holmes Gives Up the Attempt to Conduct His Own Defense. THE TAKING OF TESTIMONY BEGUN.

Pf!rT.Af>n.t*fti|A, Oct. 90 —At the open ing of the Holmes trial yesterday District Attorney Grab un announced that "the woman known as Miss Yohe and Mrs. Howard was sent for, saw the prisoner, d had ample opportunity for an Inter view with hlm.r This is the woman who Holmes declared on Monday vu his wife, «barging that tyr. Graham had done all in his power tol separate them. Holmes •aid that he ban had only a three minute interview with bhe woman, and asked that It be renewed during the recess.

See moreSee less

His re quest was gran Then tho p produced of tBolCaUowhlH street house in Which he Is all sei. The dlstr was in court, and would be produced at r time, e prop* 'T also ask," Holmes continued, "that a quantity of the|llqnor which Mr. Graham said I used in the Pitezel family be submitted to analy sis. I want to prove that while It oontalns • small quantity of nttro-glyoerine, it is entirely harm less, and is sold In every drug store." ''Do you Mrs. Pltozol In Burlington, Vt.f" 44 Yea.'' '•That has ne-tar been in my possession." Thon the prisoner wanted to know wliethor, during the testimony of nose, all the otL from the court room. Judge Arnold wered that this would be don« if the Igency arose. Jeannette Pitezel, "Dessa," the 17-year old daughter of the dCad man, first witness called. She was called merely to Identify several large crayon portraits Here. ked that • plan be d to have murdered Plte attorney said such a plan y efforts to exterminate l the liquor you left with should not be excluded Wit* tue

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The damaged clipping describes a witness identifying portraits of her father and recounts Eugene Smith's discovery of Pitezel's body, followed by a lengthy, unsuccessful cross-examination by Holmes.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 30 October 1895 · page 3

THE TAKING OF TESTIMONY BEGUN.

of her father, which she did. Holmes asked her If thpy were good portraits of her father, and she answered In the affirm ative. Eugene Smith, who found Pitezel'sbody In the Callowhlll street house on Sept. 4, 1891, then told the story of his discovery, which has beei Holmes submi nation, dwelling upon every point of the testimony adduced by tho commonwealth, but the witness whs unshaken. At last, bccoijalng exasperated at his In ability iu this of an iminato already fully published. >d Smith to a long exami peot, and in oonsequenoe remark thrown in by

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping describes courtroom disputes between Holmes and attorney Graham over excluding witnesses and over whether a woman called Miss Yohe is Holmes's wife, followed by Dr. William J. Scott's testimony on chloroform found in a body's stomach and signs of decomposition.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 30 October 1895 · page 3

THE TAKING OF TESTIMONY BEGUN.

At last, bccoijalng exasperated at his In ability iu this of an iminato Mr. Graham, Ject to the bloodthirsty manner in which tho district attorney and this witness are trying to draw the inference that I rushed Into this potterfs field and mutilated the dead body of m(y friend." "You are drawing the Inferences your self," said Mr. Graham. Dr. William J. Scott was called, and at this juncture Holmes renewed his request that all witn stand be excluded from the room. Mr. Graham pbjcotedto this,and Holmes sarcastically said: 4, I would like to know whether you, hfr Graham, or the honor able court is tol make the rulings In this .

See moreSee less

I have been anxious to know this since the trial began." Judge Arnold upheld the dlstrlofe at torney and Holmes asked for and granted then asked thitfc the witnesses oonnected with the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel be excluded. This was granted him. After the witnesses had all left the room Holmes asked if his wife was to be a witn "Again I must ask," said th« district at torney, ''which wife you mean." "You know.l' responded Holme»; "the woman you see fit to designate as Miss Yohe, thereby basting a »lur ou her and myself. That woman I» my wife." "You oast a slur on her," Mr. Graham retorted, "whejn you married her with two wives living, glvee me, which is Miss Yohe." "That is for nor to say," said Holmes. "Well, she i* not in the oourt concluded tho prosecutor, "and I decline to say whether! or not she will be a wit Dr. Scott w*H then permitted to tell his ■tory, which concerned hi» haring boon '.led In to Its discovery. ! Flo explained tho situation of the room ailid the arrangement of the windows so th|it the sun's rays should fall npon the corpse and hasten decomposi tion. The doctor dwelt upon the disoor ery of chiorofolrm in the stomach, and said that large quantities of the drug had been used, and froni the congested oondltlon of the lungs and Ithe empty hoart it was ap peot, and in oonsequenoe ï remark thrown in by olmos exclaimed: "I ob excopt the one on the tlon to the ruling. Holmes call her by the name she irinino Pitozel's body after

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The third day of the Holmes trial opened at 10 a.m. with a larger crowd than before, as Holmes, smiling as usual, greeted court officers after spending the previous night consulting lawyers and reviewing his notes.

The Evening Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

INSURANCE MAN'S STORY.

Philadelphia, Pa, Oct. 30. The third day of the Holmestrfal opened pruinptly at 10 o'clock this morning. Holmes came In with 'the usual half smile upon his face that he bas worn every morning, and saluted tbe court, officers cheerfully. More people were In the courtroom this morning than any day yet, in anticipation or more sensational evidence than has yet been ottered. Among the spectators were several wellknown society women, who craned their necks eagerly as the prisoner was brought In. Holmes held a long consultation with his lawyers last night, and after they left him he worked tell into the morning, guingover tne note he made of yesterday's proceedings.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping describes a courtroom dispute in which attorneys argued over a witness's reluctance to answer fully, touching on a third warrant for Holmes from Philadelphia's coroner and a claim about Pitezel being in South America.

The Evening Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

LEGAL QUIBBLES.

The point was finally smoothed over, and then another squabble took place. The wit ness was stubbornly determined not to an absolutely necessary, and the defendant's attorneys were equally determined to make blm answer more explicitly tban he did. They extracted from the witness that there was a third warrant for Holmes by tho coroner of Philadelphia. The prisoner's attorney tried to bring out tbe point that this warrant was held over Holmes' head In the way of a threat to induce him to confess to the conspiracy charge. That tbls was so could not bo proven by means of tbe witness, and the district attorney took exception to tho line of questioning, which was sustained by the court.

See moreSee less

The dis'trict attorney then took tbe witness, and he told of Holmes' story of Pitezel being in South America with tbo swer any quesllon more fully than was

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The garbled fragment indicates that, owing to exhaustion, Holmes yielded control of his case to his attorneys after Dr. Scott's testimony, as Dr. Wm. K. Mattern, the coroner's physician, was then called.

Evening Star · 30 October 1895 · page 11

HOLMES' COUNSEL RETURN. 0bwing to Exhaustion He Yields the At the conclusion of Dr. Scott's testi mony in the Holmes murder trial at Phila delphia yesterday Dr. Win. K. Mattern, Lcroner's physician, was called. Holmes at Conduct of His Case.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This item describes Holmes requesting a continuance and shorter sessions due to exhaustion, Dr. Mattern testifying that death was caused by chloroform poisoning, and Holmes recalling his former lawyers Shoemaker and Rotan to resume his defense before testimony continued.

Evening Star · 30 October 1895 · page 11

HOLMES' COUNSEL RETURN.

r.nce arose and begged the court to giant iim a continuance until today. He pleaded that as Dr. Mattern would prove a most important witness, he felt unequal to the strain, the cross-examination of Dr. Scott having exhausted him. He hoped to feel stronger today. Judge Arnold asked the district attorney whether -he would agree to this, and Mr. Graham replied with emphasis: "No, sir; I waut to go on. This Is only mere by-play." "That is your opinion!" said Holmes, with the scarce subdued scorn which has marked all his intercourse with the district attor ray since the trial began.

See moreSee less

"That is my opinion.". Holmes suppressed a sigh and sat down and the district attorney smiled slightly, with the thought which he has made evi dent throughaut that Holmes is playing the role of a weak, helpless unfortunate, op pressed and crushed by the mighty ma chinery of the state, in order to get the sympathy of the jury. The doctor unqualifiedly declared that death had been caused by chloroform poi soning. The cross-examination consumed nearly two hours and a half, and the great majority of the questions put by Holmes were entirely irrelevant. District Attorney Graham, after main taining silence for a long time, eventually lost patience and presented his objections to this sort of questioning. Thereupon Holmes brought the examination to a close. Before the court took a recess until 7 o'clock Holmes made an appeal to the court to hold but two instead'of three sessions a day on the ground that his physical condi tion would not stand the strain. Judge Arnold answered: "Well, we will hold a night session tonight." The taking of testimony was about to be resdmed at the evening session, when Holmes arose, and, addressing the court, said: "If your honor please, I have a re quest to make. In consequence of the severe physical strain to which I have been subjected, and also because of the criti efsm leveled against my former counsel, Messrs. Wm. A. Shoemaker and Samuel F. Rotan, I have, within the past half hour, sent for them and asked them to again as sume charge of my defense. I should like to ask if the court will permit this?" "Let them come in,'l said the judge. A moment later the two lawyers, looking pale and worried, enteredithe court room, and Mr. Rotan, going, up. to the bar, was about to enter upon an eyplanation, when Judge Arnold curtly Interrupted with: "No apology Is necessary.'Go on with the case." The dock, with itsoccupant wasthen moved back to its forier place and Holmes' counsel took seats at the desk. The taking of testimony was then proceeded with in the usual way. -- Several witnesses gave testimony con recting Holmes and Pitezei before the mur der, identifying Pitezel by a portrait in court.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping describes Holmes cross-examining Smith about whether Pletzel drank or showed signs of trouble, apparently to support a suicide defense, until Mr. Graham objected that the questioning was irrelevant.

New-York Tribune · 30 October 1895 · page 1

FIGHTING FOR HIS LIFE.

Ing of the body. Then Holmes took a new tack and asked Smith if he had ever seen Pletzel drunk, or if he thought he appeared as if he had any trouble on his mind His evident purpose in asking these questions was to sustain what will undoubtedly be his line of defence, that Pletzel committed sulcide while Arunk, and because he was In many difficulties. He did not get much support from Smith, es the witness had never seen Pletzel drunk or thought him a man who had any great trouble, Finally Mr. Graham protested against Holmes's ne of cross-examination as being utterly irrele4 Holmes ¥ 1

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This badly garbled clipping, mixing courtroom testimony about a witness named Smith and a defendant named Holmes with unrelated fragments about a schooner and burned buildings, is too damaged to summarize coherently.

New-York Tribune · 30 October 1895 · page 1

LINES OF DE- | him, and that he was trying by inference to show FENCE. A A Apia a feet with bliste he shadow of the gallows loomin dark! Smith's testimony was not changed by Holmes, | 4 prNDp . y . i PLACE was a 24%-ton schooner, and was built in Bath, Pn the witness was dismissed. AFTER ALL~THE ULTIbruises and cuts, which tell | ter, Mr. Andrade, received mall advices to-day THE BURNED BUILDINGS,

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's murder trial continued in Philadelphia with the accused recalling his counsel, and that ex-Consul Waller's wife received a letter from her husband.

New-York Tribune · 30 October 1895 · page 6

DOMESTIC.—The trial of H. H. Holmes for murder proceeded in Philadelphia; the accused man recalled his counsel. =—=—— The wife of exConsul Waller received a letter from her hus-

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This damaged clipping mixes a garbled account of a legislative chamber's turmoil over railway scandals with disjointed fragments describing a man being strapped into a chair for an apparent execution and a court adjournment.

The Morning News · 30 October 1895 · page 1

railway scandals instead of voting the government down. The result is. these Journals say. that the chamber has af forded the country a spectacle of incon slit that does duty for windows in the the chamber of death. He faltered slight ly as he came, in sight of the chair, but cells of the county prison that Holmes it was only for an instunt. He was strapp threw himself on his cot. He slept but an ed into the chair and at 11:57 o'clock a cur court adjourned until to-morrow morning in compliance with hi? request, the woman whom he had deceived Into the belief that she was his legal wife under

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This damaged clipping mixes unrelated items—a mutiny headline, a graphic murder description, a note that a district attorney will give Holmes ample time at trial, and a reference to separating claims for the court of claims—making a coherent single subject impossible to discern.

The Morning News · 30 October 1895 · page 1

PUTS HIS CASE ALL DAY

CHINESE SAILORS MUTINY. body was almost nude. The fiend, after trict Attorney Graham proposes to allow assaulting her, cut her throat from ear to Holmes every latitude and will not op ear and completely disemboweled her pose any objections to the amount of time he may consume. The district attorney Secretary Carlisle to hear them separately as to sending their claims over to the court of claims for adjudication.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The clipping reports that Holmes, after a sleepless night writing in his cell, spent the second trial day asking witnesses lengthy questions apparently aiming to argue Pitezel's death was suicide, a defense the district attorney's evidence seemed to undermine.

The Morning News · 30 October 1895 · page 1

CONDUCTS HIS CASE ALL DAY

Man W ho Found the Corpse Among •he Day’s Witnesses. Philadelphia. Oct. 29.—The second day of the Holmes trial did not attract nearly so great a crowd this morning as yester day, as the public had learned they would not be admitted to the court room. Throughout all last night in the loneli ness of his cell dn the county prison. Holmes worked steadily, preparing his case. He filled sheet after sheet of fools cap, and lha watches outside his cell door wondered when he would seek some rest. It was only as the first lays of the sun began to find its way through the narrow slit that does duty for windows in the cells of the county prison that Holmes threw himself on his cot.

See moreSee less

He slept but an hour, and then was up again and was busy writing until told it was time to start for court. Promptly at 10 o'clock the Jury filed into the box. A moment afterwards Holmes entered. Despite his long and sleepless night, he looked fresh and bright, and while wait ing for the district attorney to come In he ehatted with the court offleers. In compliance with Holmes’ request, the dock was much nearer the bar than yes terday. The change was made in order that Holmes might better heur the court, and be heard. A small deal table with foolscap and pens and ink was in front of him. District Attorney Graham announced to the court that Mrs. Howard, as Holmes latest wife, is known, had seen the pris oner this morning before he was brought into court. What took place at this in terview is known, only to the prisoner and the wuman. The proceedings at this morning's ses sion were dull and uninteresting on the surface, but an undercurrent of Interest was given them by the appearance of what will probably be Holmes' defense. The prisoner consumed much unneces sary time in asking witnesses immaterial questions and with a constant succession of requests preferred to the court. Dis trict Attorney Graham proposes to allow Holmes every latitude and will not op pose any objections to the amount of time he may consume. The district attorney does this because of Holmes' desperate position alone and without counsel, and that when the trial is over It cannot be said that the prisoner has not had every chance. The commonwealth has about twenty five witnesses to call and Holmes also pro poses to call some. At the rate of pro gress made this morning the trial would consume fully two weeks, but as night sessions arc going Ufehe Ijehl from now on, and ua it is likely That Holmes will ex haust the patience of the oourt in his consumption of time. It Ms probable the trial will be expedited. It would aeem from the line of question ing pursued by Holmes this morning that he will base his defense on the theory that Pitezel committed suicide. From the district attorney’s opening argument, and from the testimony of the few witnesses already examined this defense is untena ble, and unless Holmes can bring out some stronger facts than appear he is al ready a convicted man. The witnesses at the morning’s session of the court were Pltezel’s eldest daugh ter, Jeannette, Eugene Smith, thn man who discovered Pitezel’* body, and who knew Pitezel under the name of Perry, these two for purposes of identification; and two physicians, Drs. Scott and Mat tern, who testified that the death was caused by chloroform tsfisonlng. During the recess llolmes again saw his wife (Miss Yohe). The court reconvened at 2:30 o’clock. Dr. Scott resumed his place on th 6 wit ness stanfl, and Holmes began his cross examination. Dr. Mattern, who is physician to the coroner, was also cross examined, and he was followed by Dr. Henry Leffman, an expert In chemistry. In these exam inations, Holmes displayed his thorough medical knowledge and preparation fi >r this trial. Holmes announced his inten tion to call all three medical men as wit nesses for himself later on. Coroner Ashbridge was the next witness, and then affidavits made by Holmes and Pit eztd's daughter In the suits to recover the insurance on Pitezel’s life were read. Holmes asked the court if it would not order two session a day Instead of three, as he was afraid of breaking down under tbe strain and becoming sick. He said that he was subject to sick headaches, 1 and that he had been suffering from one all day. The court said that a session would be held to night, and then Holmes’ request would be considered. At 5:20 o'clock the court adjourned until 7 o’clock. The court reconvened promptly at 7 o’clock, and while waiting for the district attorney to come in. Holmes busied him self In reading an account of the day's proceedings In an afternoon paper. Be fore a witness had been called Holmes stated to tne court that, owing to the criticism leveled at his counsel for with drawing, he had asked them to resume charge of his case. In a moment Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan. tha two lawyers who withdrew from the case yesterday came to court and the former made an ex planation to Judge Arnold, and he per mitted them to take up the case again. They conducted Holmes’ side of the case from that time. All of the testimony at the evening ses sion was directed to establishing the iden tity of the body found as that of Pitezel. and to some of the movements of Holmes in Philadelphia at the time of the death. The court adjourned at 8:60 o’clock until to-morrow. Throughout his long and trying ordeal to-day Holmes never once allowed him self to become angry or excited. Only occasionally when the district attorney would interpose objection to his mean ingless questions there would come a tightening of the lips beneath the brown mustache and a sudden cruel, hardening of the clear eyes, that showed that the man was putting a great restraint upon himself. With the evident purpose of try ing the effect upon Holmes’ nerves, the district attorney compelled him to sit op posite all day to a large crayon portrait of the man for whose murder he is being tried. But. If such was Mr. Graham's in tention, the portrait might as well have been placed before the Syhynx as far as any effect was produced upon Holmes. In answering the district attorney or In making his frequent Inquiries of the court. Holmes’ manner was mild even unto supplication, and although, more than one covert sneer was directed to the prosecuting officer, at no time through out the day was this singular man's voice raised much above a whisper. From his line of questioning witnesses, ft would seem that at one moment he had decided upon adopting for big defence the theory that Pitezel committed sui cide while drunk, and then he would sud denly swerve off into an entirely different direction, and it would appear that he Intended to base his dental of the mur der on the plea that the body was not that of Pitezel at aJI, but a substitute of the corpse placed in the houso to deceive the insurance company. If either of these ideas of defence were Holmes’ they were untenable, for he ha? already made sworn affidavits that would contradict them. His medical knowledge was of some as sistance to him In his cross examination

See the clipping

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

Printed in German, this report describes H. H. Holmes, whose true name is given as Herman Mudgett, being arraigned before Judge Michael Arnold in Philadelphia on charges of murdering Benjamin F. Pitzel, with prosecutors George S. Graham and Thomas W. Barlow against defense attorneys William A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan.

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 30 October 1895 · page 2

Verbrecher und Verbrechen. Der Mörder Holmes vor Gericht. H. H. Holmes, welcher seinem eigenen Ge— ständnisse nach an der Spitze der Liste der modernen Verbrecher steht, wurde in Phila— delphia unter der Anklage, den Benjamin F. Pitzel ermordet zu haben, dem „Oyer & Ter— miner“ Gerichte vorgeführt. Die Anklage wird vom Bezirksanwalt George S. Gra— ham und seinem Spezialgehülfen Thomas W. Barlow geleitet, während die Anwälte William A. Shoemaker und Samuel P. Rotan die Vertheüdigung des Angetlagter übernommen haben. Auf der Richterbank befindet sich Richter Michael Arnold. Der Angeklagte hat während seiner Verbrecher laufbahn so viel Namen geführt, daß sein Taufname Herman Mudgetts beinahe ver—- gessen worden ist.

See moreSee less

Wild und abenteuerlich, wie seinem eige— nen Geständniß nach sein Lebenslauf wac, in welchem er sich selbst Verbrechen anklagt, welche einen weniger gewandten Berbrechir schon lange an den Galgen gebracht haben würden, hat Holmes schlauer Weise die Hauptverantwortlichteit seiner verschiedenen Mordthaten auf die Schultern anderer Per— sonen gewälzt. Obgleich er während se.nes achtunddreißigjährigen Lebens fast nur Ge setzübertretungen begangen hat, keht er jetzt zum ersten Male, eines todeswürdigen er brechens angektlagt, vor Gericht. Die Be— hörden wissen, daß er kein gewöhnlicher Ver— brecher ist, sondern daß sie es mit einem ge— wandten und sachverständigen Künstler im Verbrechen zu thun haben. Es ist mehr als ein Jahr seit der Ent—- deckung des Verbrechens vergangen, wegen dessen Holmes jetzt vor Gericht steht, und es sind seitdem so viele widersprechende Ge— schichten über ihn in Umlauf gesetzt worden; von denen die eine die nächste immer · noch

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Holmes sent for his lawyers Shoemaker and Kotan after fighting his case alone, and later asked the court to hold only two sessions a day, with key witnesses including Mrs. Pietzel, Detective Geyer, and Agent Perry still to be heard.

The Topeka State Journal · 30 October 1895 · page 2

tooth and nail singlehanded against the tremendous machinery of the commonwealth and the apparently complete chain of evidence which has been forged around him, he threw up his hands and sent for his lawyers, Messrs. Shoemaker & Kotan. Then he told the court what he had done and a reluctant consent to their continu ing with the defense was given. There was an impression that this was but another part of the by-play following Holmes' personal failure to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by making himself out a much-wronged man, forced to fight alone what would be his last battle, in spite of his ignor ance of the technicalities of the law and his alleged physical infirmity.

See moreSee less

The big work of the trial taking testimony was begun yes erday, and with the exception of brief intermis sions at lunch and suDDer time, was continued until nearlv 9 o'clock last I night. The star-witnesses of the j trial Mrs. Pietzel, Detective Geyer, S Agent Perry of the swindled insurance i company, and the arch-criminal, hini 1 self remain to be heard, as also j nearly two score of others, i Holmes made a plea last evening j asking the court to hold but two ses I sions a day. In pleading he said his and crimes has discouraged and meas ear and completely disemboweled her. urably stopped frauds. A posse was quickly organized, led The death of many witnesses and by Deputy Smitn. of Tyler, who with the age of claimants has made it quite lanterns in hand and aided by a hound, difficult in many cases lately to obtain ttacked the negro to within four miles proof sufficient for the granting of of the spot, where, at 4 a. m., they pensions. found him fast asleep in a cotton pen. The report shows that the number Soon after the officers had him hand of pensioners June 30, 1894, was 969,544, cuffed a mob of some 200 men, heavily new pensioners added during the year, armed, arrived on the scene and de 39,185; dropped pensioners restored, 4,206; deaths during the year, 29,816; the prisoner, which was reluctantly dropped for cause, 14,17a, making a given. The mob started for the scene net increase of pensioners during the of the murder, where they arrived year of 860. Pensions claims allowed yesterday afternoon at 3 o'clock. The during the year, 39,185; denied, 103,355; crowd continued to gather at the' cases pending, 552,210. The appropri scene of the horrible crime until ation fo.i the year was $160,000,000, nearly 2,000 citizens of Tyler and vi and there was paid during the year cinity were there. 8138,807,337. The estimate for pen A few moments before the fiend was sions for 1897 is 8140,000,000 for pen brought to the place, a meeting was sion payments, 8800,0 10 for surgeons' held and a committee was appointed fees and S450.000 for clerk hire at to investigate his identity. Witnesses pension agencies, and about $200,000 were summoned and closely ques for other expenses. The commissioner commends the identification. In a few minutes an vigor of the department of justice and officer approached from over the hill, of pension examiners in prosecuting followed by 300 determined and well dishonest attorneys and others who armed men. When near the scene the were engaged in pension frauds. Two officers were overpowered and dis hundred an ninety-four persons were armed, and the negro, Henry Hilliard, convicted during the year for frauds. was brought before the committee. He made a full confession, and wrote manded the immediate surrender of tioned. The result was a thorough

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

This brief fragment states that Holmes failed to win the sympathy of the court and jury by portraying himself as a wronged man forced to fight alone, part of a larger by-play.

The Topeka State Journal · 30 October 1895 · page 2

LIMIT TO ENDURANCE.

another part of the by-play following Holmes' personal failure to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by making himself out a much-wronged man, forced to fight alone what would

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

A damaged courtroom account describes Judge Arnold questioning the district attorney, followed by a tense exchange with Holmes, who reacts with suppressed scorn while the district attorney smiles, suggesting Holmes is feigning weakness.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 30 October 1895 · page 1

HE HIRES THEM OVER

Judge Arnold asked the district attorney whether he would agree to this, and "Xo sir, I want you to go on only more time play." "That Is your opinion," said Holmes, with the scarce subdued scorn which has marked all his intercourse with the district attorney since ithe trial began. "That is my opinion." Kolmes suppressed a sigh and sat down, and 't!he district attorney smiled slightly, with the thought v.ihich he has made evident iChroughout, that Holmes ss playing Che rrole of a weak, neipiess - - .T. j . J ...T. A V... This is

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

This damaged clipping describes testimony that a body was identified as Petzel's and Holmes beginning a cross-examination, then breaks into an unrelated fragment questioning why U.S. authorities would act if the government denies being at war with Cuba.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 30 October 1895 · page 1

,was but another part of the by-play, t Holmes himself, ithe witness said, did following Holmes' personal failure to ' not hesitate to declare that It was the , catch the sympathy of the court and ' body of Petzel. jury by making out a much wronged ' Holmes began a cross-examination or government has always denied that it la engaged In war with Cuba. If that be the case I see no reason why the United States authorities prevent us

See the clipping

The Wichita Daily Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

The clipping is a brief fragment describing the courtroom opening, noting the jury's entrance, Judge Arnold's arrival, and Holmes being brought in by a court officer, before the text breaks off.

The Wichita Daily Eagle · 30 October 1895 · page 1

JUST LUCE A LAWYER. At 10 o'clock the jury was brought in to the room and Judge Arnold appear ing a moment later, court was formally opened. Meantime. Holmes, in custo dy of a court olllcer, was placed in the

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn. · and 2 other papers

In Philadelphia, H. H. Holmes was arraigned in the court of oyer and terminer for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, with Graham and Barlow prosecuting, Shoemaker and Rotan defending, and Judge Arnold presiding.

New Ulm Review · 30 October 1895 · page 2

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 29. H. H. Holmes, who, according to his own re markable confessions, stands at the head of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminer for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel. Arraigned against him as the commonwealth's prosecutors are Dis trict Attorney George S. Graham and his special assistant, Thomas W. Bar low, while the counsel for the prisoner are William A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, young members of the junior bar of this city. Judge Arnold is upon the bench. So many aliases have been worn by the man on trial during the

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Hutchinson Gazette · Hutchinson, Kan. · 31 October 1895
  • The State Ledger · Topeka, Kan. · 1 November 1895

New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.

The article recounts how Holmes, now facing his first felony trial after a life of crime, identified a body as Pietzel's, enabling collection of a $10,000 insurance payout before a second stage of the affair began.

New Ulm Review · 30 October 1895 · page 2

THE HOLMES MURDER CASE.

course of his spectacular career, that hits baptismal name, Herman Mudgett, has Almost been lost sight of. Not so his manifold exploits in half a dozen of the big cities of this country, which have been marvelled at wherever men can read. Wild and weird as is the confessional story of his life, in which he accuses himself of offenses which would long since have given a less skillful criminal his quietus, Holmes has been care ful to shift the main responsibility for the various murders with which he admits having been connected, to other shoulders Thus during the 38 years of a life devoted almost entirely to law breaking, this is h^s first experience as a felon on trial for his life.

See moreSee less

The au thorities have recognized that this is no common criminal, but one who might be called a technical and most expert artist in crime. It is therefore their de termination, in the event of securing his conviction for a capital offense to "railroad" him to the gallows. Some of Holmes' Crimes. More than a year having passed since the discovery of the crime for which Holmes is now on trial, and so many I conflicting tales havingsincebeen told, each outdoing the other in weirdness and atrocity, a rehearsal of the facts of 1 this chapter of the story is relevant. On Sept. 8, 1894, the corpse of a man was found in the second story of a ram shackle building at 1316 Callowhill street, this city. The dead man had been known as B. A. Perry. The body was lying on the floor, and by its side was a pipe, partly filled by tobacco. The face was blackened and blistered as if from burns, and nearby lay a broken bottle which had contained benzine. From appearances, an explosion had occurred while the man was lighting his pipe. Some small drops of blood on the floor were credited to slight wpunds on his neck. The coroner's physicians heldan *autopsy and finding evidences of chloroform and congested lungs, the jury gave a verdict of death from 'in haling the fumes of chloroform. About thrae weeks after this occur rence, Jeptha D. How, a St. Louis at torney, after corresponding with Cor oner Ashbridge, came to this city and asserted that the body of the supposed Perry was that of Benjamin P. Pietzel of St. Louis, and that he, How, was here to collect 10,000 insurance from the Fidelity Mutual Insurance com pany, for which amount a policy had been made out in favor of Mrs. Pietzel in Chicago a y$ax before. Meanwhile Holmes, who had introduced Pietzel to the insurance agents when the latter was insured, was induced by them to come to Philadelphia and identify the body. This he did positively, aad *o did Alice Pietzel, the 16-year-old daughter of the dead man. With this unequivocal testimony, the insurance company paid the money. Here the first stage of this extraordinary affair came to a close. The second opened go: H. HOLMES. Ho Appears.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A front-page digest lists brief headlines on topics including a possible fight, a governor's denial, a lawyer recall, a charities annual, a suicide attempt, a jailbreak, a burning at the stake, and a train collision in St. Louis.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 October 1895 · page 1

Sports Say There Will Be a Fight. Gov. Clarke Says Not. _ Holmes Recalls Ills Lawyers, Charities Annual, Faribault. Girl Tries to Kill Herself. Two Men Break Jail. Texan Burned at the StakeTrains Collide in St. Louis. PAGE 1.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This is a column of brief satirical or witty one-line political and social observations from various states, touching on topics like Arkansas prison fights, French politics, Kentucky elections, and prohibition. One line compares the facial expressions of Prime Minister Ribot and H. H. Holmes as seen in newspaper photos, a passing joke unrelated to the main Holmes case.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 October 1895 · page 1

In spite of anything the weather bureau can do, a flood of light will be thrown on things political next week. V ,-;:- The drink dispensers of St. Paul have unexpectedly consented to act as pallbearers at the wine room funeral. From their pictures in the papers It is evident that Prime Minister Ribot and H. H. Holmes feel about alike about it. Van Alen doesn't appear to be on the road to the poor house. He gave 5200,000 bail yesterday with the ease of a Croesus. How can. North Dakota be expect ed to be a strictly prohibition state when the temperature gets below zero in October?

See moreSee less

The Socialists in the French cham ber of deputies rejoice very fre quently because they hurrah every time a cabinet falls. --aaa* ssaas «a» «3B-

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

A damaged clipping describes Smith's testimony about Holmes and Pitezel, a charity and correction conference in Faribault featuring Dr. F. W. Wines, and a brief, unclear mention of a negro denying guilt amid a threatening crowd.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 October 1895 · page 1

SIGNS OF DISTRESS

been "prepared," and the court sus tained the objection. Smith said that during his first visit to Pitezel, whom he knew by the name of Perry, Holmes came in, andafter' giving a nod or sign to Pitezel, went up stairs. A moment later Pietzel : excused himself and followed him. He ' returned very shortly, but Holmes re meeting tonight was held at the • Faribault opera house. The first ad dress was Dr. F. ,W. Wines, of the Johns Hopkins university, one of the foremost men in the charity and correction work in the United States.

See moreSee less

Hon. A. O. Wright, president of the national association; Messrs. Bick him, but the rapidly gathering crowd of excited citizens made it very doubtful whether .he would reach there alive. _. The negro denied his guilt, but said he would never reach Tyler alive. -

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

This damaged clipping jumbles an account of a railroad official's superintendent postings with an unrelated testimonial about Munyon's pellets and a courtroom scene involving witnesses and a man named Holmes.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 October 1895 · page 6

SIGNS OF DISTRESS

ing he was superintendent of the Wyo Under the. head "Patriotism and' ming division of the Union Pacific, Pensions" he says: "Those men who and later was placed in charge of the enlisted early and fought the battles Nebraska division of the same ■ road. of the war were not moved 1 by Late In 1890 he was named superintend mercenary considerations, and un ent of the Chicago & Evanston, Chi less actually disabled did not show cago & Milwaukee, and Chicago & trouble for many years, and during an der of Benjamin E.

See moreSee less

Pietzel be exclud unusually severe attack last month a ed. This was granted, and as Holmes friend gave me a small bottle of Mun called out the names of these witnesses yon's pellets to try, from which I re j they* left the room. Not haying a full ceived almost Instant re'lef. I find ' list of the witnesses, however, he was that these pellets produce nounpleas-' suspicious that ail had not left, and ant effects, while performing most ex

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Dr. Scott testifies that putrefaction would have been slower in a cool, darkened room, estimates the man had been dead three or four days, and withstands a lengthy cross-examination by the prisoner, Holmes, on chloroform's effects.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 October 1895 · page 6

PIETZEL'S CORPSE

j zel'. to the place where it was | found, i and. that, the jar. could not have been j broken by an explosion, ..because . the | pieces'- of glass were not scattered ' .about the room, but were' lnside the ! jar. The doctor dwelt on the discovery ! of chloroform iii the stomach 'and said large quantities of the drug had been used-. • J - y'i" "; : . ; , ' '.' i: '*y ' ' After the noon recess "Dr Scott was turned over to Holmes for cross-ex amination.

See moreSee less

~ '.: : " '■•':• -- :.-. -■ ■'•': .. "Are you prepared to say, ''he asked, j , "that the decomposition 1 of the body i-. would not have occurred had it been |in a darkened room?" " ..'>:. -- . : ; "Yes, sir.' Had it been •in a v cool, darkened room, putrefaction" would not j have come so quickly. Here it was in j warm weather, and the body so ar | ranged in. relation to the windows that the rays of the sun would fall upon it." "Did you at that time express any opinion .as to the length of ! time the man' had been, dead?" » ■ •" "I said from all appearances he had been dead three or four days," . Holmes then subjected Dr.. Scott to 'a lengthy . and detailed examination I touching, the effects of chloroform, but j . obtained few answers .that would tend to throw -the balance in the slightest degree, in his favor. The witness was regarded by the commonwealth's, offi cers as one of their medical experts, and he was positive and uncontradicted . in everything he said, in spite of the ' fact that his questioner, the prisoner, j is a medical man by education. Holmes kept up a steady fire of questions and never felt obliged to pause for a word . or thought. The calmness with which j he volubly exchanged technical terms and discussed chemical and medical ; possibilities with the doctor was ad mirable.

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

Holmes asked Judge Arnold for a continuance before Dr. Mattern's testimony, claiming exhaustion from cross-examining Dr. Scott, but District Attorney Graham refused, calling it mere by-play.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 30 October 1895 · page 6

NO. DELAYS. - At the conclusion of Dr. Scott's tes timony, Dr. William K. Mattern, cor oner's physician, was called. Holmes at once arose and - begged the court to grant his a continuance until to morrow. He pleaded that, as Dr. Mat tern would prove a most Important witness, he felt unequal to the strain, the cross-examination of Dr. Scott having exhausted him. He hoped to feel stronger tomorrow. ' Judge Arnold asked the district at torney whether he would agree to this, and Mr. Graham replied with empha !

See moreSee less

sis '. . "No, sir, I want to go on. I This is only more by-play." "That is your opinion," said Holmes, with the scarce subdued scorn which has marked all his - intercourse with : . the district attorney since the trial be '■ gan. ' -| "That Is my opinion." -'■ > '■'■> ;,iv | Holmes suppressed a sigh and sat dowij-, and. the district" attorney, smiled j slightly, with the thought which ,he I "made evident throughout '. y that Holmes is playing the role of a weak, lielp jess unfortunate, oppressed and crushed by the mighty machinery of the State, in order to get the sympathy

See the clipping

The Greenville Times · Greenville, Miss.

The clipping recounts accusations that the prisoner murdered Pitezel and his children, and describes how Detective Geyer's investigation and discovery of the children's bodies led authorities to seek Holmes's conviction, bringing witnesses to testify against him.

The Greenville Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

In addition to the murder of Pitezel, the prisoner is also accused of the mur der, at Toronto, Ont, of I'itezel's two young daughters, Alice and Nellie; of the murder, at Irvington, In J., of the younj son, Howard Pitezel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes castle, at Chica ga lijuj., F. I'itezel's body was found in a house at lUln Callow Hill street, on September 3, lH'Jt. It was supposed ho hud been accidentally burned to death, but a claim for 110,000 Insur ance by Jeptha D.

See moreSee less

Howe, of St Louis, started an investigation, which re sulted in Holmes balng accused of I'itezel's murder for the purpose of ob Detectlre Geyer weut out to visit Toronto, Chicago and other western cities to endeavor to obtain evl dence against Holmes which would warrant his being ar ruigned for murder. Detective Geycr'i success in finding the dead bodies of the children is well known and other facta which he gleaued satisfied Dis trict Attorney Graham that Holmes could bo convicted here of the murder of Pitezel. Detective Geyer also brought to this city Mrs. Pitezel and others from various parts of the west and Canada to take the' staud as wit nesses against Holmes. taining the insurance money.

See the clipping

The Greenville Times · Greenville, Miss.

This damaged clipping mixes a reference to F. Pitezel's body being found in the Holmes castle with unrelated fragments about a fire, a road, and a governor sending protection against raids, too garbled to summarize further.

The Greenville Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

IN THE COURT OF OYER AND TERMINER.

denied by the London Oraphlc. loss by fire Sunday. The local fire de Secretary Olney's reform methodi partment was unable to cope with the soon be built It has been longer talked of the murder of various other persons ol than any road In ths State. He fore in the famous Holmes castle, at Chica ga lijuj., F. I'itezel's body was found any other road waa constructed In Mis the governor of Hslburt for protection gainst the raids of the Mussel man, but the governor sent only three gen

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The clipping, which ends abruptly, reports that Holmes asked the court to hold only two sessions a day due to poor health, but Judge Arnold insisted on a night session anyway.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 30 October 1895 · page 1

TRIAL COMMENCES IN EARNEST.

Holmes made a plea in the morning asking the court to hold but two sessions a day. In pleading he said that his health was such that he felt unable to continue his cross-examination of the witnesses, and besides he was subject to sick headache. Judge Arnold insisted, however, on holding a night session. During the recess which followed the incident Holmes privately said that the

See the clipping

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

The item sarcastically comments on the start of the Holmes trial and its expected flood of sensational coverage, mocks ongoing talk of a Corbett-Fitzsimmons fight and a governor's self-praising stance on militia, and jokes about a post-election sale of discredited affidavits.

The Beatrice Daily Express · 30 October 1895 · page 2

The trial of H. H. Holmes has opened with a good deal of red tire and tom tom music. We were just beginning to recover from a three months deluge of Durrant literature, and now we are in for a deluge of Holmes literature. If we are not totally depraved in the course of a few months, it will not be the fault of the news agenoies. Corbett and Fitzsimmons are still talking fight, and Gov. Clarke, of Ark ansas, is still playing to the grand stand and throwing an occasional bouquet at himself.

See moreSee less

It is a pity that a governor can’t be found who has the nerve to keep the state militia suppressed, and let these plug-uglies slaughter them selves. After the election the demo pop headquarters will have a grand closing out sale of slightly injured affidavits. They will be sold regardless of cost, as the stock milst be cleared away, to make room for winter goods.

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

This damaged clipping describes testimony involving a shattered, burned lamp found beside a body and an expert opinion that chloroform could not have been self-administered, before Holmes begins cross-examining Smith.

Weekly Union · 30 October 1895 · page 1

tion by Alice Pietzel, a daughter of the 3, 1894. A shattered lamp was found deceased and by Holmes. : by the side of the body which bore evi Mr. Graham graphically pictured the dence of having been burned and the opinion that the chloroform could not on the body. have been self-administered under the Holmes then began his cross examina conditions. | tion of Smith. While Holmes was

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The clipping recounts the district attorney's opening address describing Pietzel's death, the insurance fraud claim filed by lawyer Jeptha Howe, and the discovery and identification of Pietzel's and his children's remains, with the prosecution alleging chloroform was used in Pietzel's killing.

Weekly Union · 30 October 1895 · page 1

Shoemaker and Samuei R. Rotan. In addition to the crime Holmes, the prisoner, is also accused of the murder at Toronto, Ont,, of Pietzel’s two young daughters, Alice and Nellie; of the mur der at Irvington, Ind., of the young son Howard Pietzel and also of the murber of various other persons in the famous Holmes castle at Chicago. Benjamin F. Pietzel’s body was found in a house at 1316 Callowhill street, Sept. 3, 1894. A shattered lamp was found by the side of the body which bore evi dence of having been burned and the coroner’s jury concluded that the oil lamp had exploded and that Pietzel, who was at the time known as B.

See moreSee less

F. Perry, had been burned to death. There was no claim for the body and it was buried in potter’s fiéld. Subsequently an assertion came from Pietzel’'s lawyer at St. Louis, Mr. Jeptha Howe, that the body was that of Benjamin F. Pietzel, -and a claim was made in the Fidelity Mutual Life association of Philadelphia, for SIO,OOO, letter to the Fidelity Mutual Life asso ciatio of Philadelphia, by Jeptha Howe, a St. Louis attorney, in which he stated that the body found in the Callowhill street house was not that of a man named ‘“Perry,”” but was in rsality the corpse of Pietzel anu demanding on the behalf of }ietzel’s widow the SIO,OOO in surance which Pietzel had on his life and followed up he burial of the body in Potter’s Field, its exhumation by the insurance company and its identifica tion by Alice Pietzel, a daughter of the deceased and by Holmes. : Mr. Graham graphically pictured the many features of the case and laid special stress upon the work of Detec tive Geher in finding the charred re mains of the children, Alice and Nel lie Pietzel, in Toronto; of ‘the remains of the boy Howard Pietzel and of the suspicioun that the three children were victims of the accused. During his address Mr. Graham indicated that the commonwealth expected to prove that Pietzel was chloroformed to death while drunk. Returning to the finding of the body in Philadelphia, the district-attorney

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The clipping recounts how an insurance company paid a claim on Pietzel's life, grew suspicious, had Holmes arrested in Boston, and describes his guilty plea to conspiracy, his murder claim defense, and Detective Geyer's investigation and witness-gathering across western cities and Canada.

Weekly Union · 30 October 1895 · page 1

association of Philadelphia, for SIO,OOO, ;vfhich that company carried on Pietzel’s ife. The body was exhumed and was ful ly identified by his daughter, who was brought from St. Louis, as that of Pietzel. The insurance company paid the claim, but not satisfied that Pietzel had met his death accidentally, at gnce placed detectives on the case. This resulted in the arrest in Boston of Mudgett, alias Holmes. The latter was brought here and was placed on trial charged with conspiracy to de fraud the insurance company. Holmes pleaded guilty to this charge, but to combat the more serious charge of murcer, claimed that Pietzel was still living, that a body was obtained from a New York dissecting room and placed in the building on Callenhill street, after burning the skin lightly, and throwing a lamp on the floor.

See moreSee less

Holmes claimed that he and Pietzel left the city and ;übsequently in formed Mrs. Pietzel that the body was that of her missing husband, and had her press her claim for the insurance. Holmes was sent to prison to await sentence on the conspiracy trial, and District-Attorney Graham started De tective Geyer out to visit Toronto, Chi cago and other western cities to en deavor t o obtain evidence against Holmes, which would warrant his be ing arraigned for murder. Detective Guyer’s success in finding the dead bodies of the children is well known and to the facts which he gleaned satisfied the district attorney that Holmes could be convicted here of the murder of Pietzel. Detective Geyer also brought to this city Mrs. Pietzel and others from various parts of the west and Canada to take the stand as witnesses against Holmes. Upon the opening of the case Attor

See the clipping

Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.

The Philadelphia district attorney has finished preparing the prosecution of H. H. Holmes for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, with the accused set to appear in court the next morning. The prosecutor expects the trial to conclude within a week and reach the jury.

Weekly Union · 30 October 1895 · page 4

PROSECUTION OF HOLMES, District Attorney Expects Case Wiil Be in Judge’s Hands in a Week. PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 27.—The dis trict-attorey has completed his prepa ration for the prosecution of H. H.

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

This damaged, scrambled clipping references intense excitement over a smuggled body, a daughter named Alice whose death is also blamed on someone, a message conveyed to St. Petersburg by a dispatched figure, and an unmoved Holmes, but the text is too fragmentary to follow clearly.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 30 October 1895 · page 1

STRAIN TOO SEVERE

The excitement caused by the finding of rest all those implicated in smuggling the body was so intense that had the crim there. The board of revenue has swung inal been found at that time, the perpe the daughter, Alice, whose death is alsc was conveyed to St. Petersburg by Wong laid on his shoulders. But Holmes did Chi Chuan, who was dispatched to Russia, not seem to be affected. His stolid de ostensibly for the purpose of congratula

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · and 1 other paper

This damaged clipping fragments describe a steamer that met boats carrying cases of goods off Cuba and separately mention a lengthy procession and a courtroom failure to win sympathy, but the text is too garbled to follow clearly.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 30 October 1895 · page 1

FINALLY RECALLED HIS COUNSEL

nations,” made up by a cluster of Ameri vests, with plain dark trousers and slip can colors, a cluster of army colors, the pers, which latter were talken off as they but another piece of by-play following Laurada. Later in the voyage they wera Holmes’ personal failure to catch the sym disembarked off Cuba. The steamer alsg met two other boats which carried 32 cases pathy of the court and jury by making cession of over a mile in length. The cot ton mills, lumber manufactures, jobbers and retailers of the city were nearly all

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Providence News · Providence, R.I. · 30 October 1895

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

This fragment reports that Holmes showed no reaction despite being blamed for the daughter Alice's death, remaining stolidly composed as the announcement came that evidence-taking would begin the previous day.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 30 October 1895 · page 1

FINALLY RECALLED HIS COUNSEL

the daughter, Alice, whose death is alsc laid on his shoulders. But Holmes did not seem to be affected. His stolid de meanor never deserted him for an instant, The announcement that the taking of evidence would begin yesterday drew a

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Daily Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon

A damaged Philadelphia dispatch reports that H. H. Holmes dismissed his counsel and tried his own case after a continuance was refused, then, facing the evidence, sent for lawyers Shoemaker and Rotan to resume his defense.

The Daily Morning Astorian · 30 October 1895 · page 1

THREW UP HIS HANDS.

Phlladefphtia, Oat. 29. It became eppar ent that the plc'turesqiue and startling fea to be confined to his destructive wander Wiil'.i eaC'i Bucceslvs day comes some Yesterday he dismissed his couwiwf and began to try hlls own case because the court refused to grant the plcia mode by them for a oonMnumice. Tonight after nghitlng single Handed against ths Ire and 'the apparently overwhelming evi he threw up his hands ami sent for Irs lawyers, Vfnssrs. Shoemaker and Rotan. Then he told the court what he had dons ormI a consent to their continuing with the defenoe was given.

See moreSee less

turels of H. H. Holmes' career were not ings over tihe American continent, for hlnft stll more strange and unexpected. mendoiM machinery of the lorrmumweiiJh dence which has been fonrxl around htm,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The fragment states that Holmes failed to gain the sympathy of the court and jury by portraying himself as a wronged man fighting alone what may prove to be his final battle, though the sentence is cut off.

The Providence News · 30 October 1895 · page 5

SEVERE STRAIN. Holmes Pleads for Discontinuance of Night Sessions. FINALLY RECALLED HIS COUNSEL

Holmes' personal failure to catch the sym pathy of the court and jury by wmaking himself out & much-wranged man, forced to fight alone what may prove to be his

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

This fragmentary clipping describes Holmes as stolid and unaffected despite something being laid on his shoulders, with the text cut off during an announcement about a taking of something unspecified.

The Providence News · 30 October 1895 · page 5

FINALLY RECALLED HIS COUNSEL

laid on his shoulders, But Holmes did not seem to be affected. His stolid de meanor never deserted him for an Instant. The announcement that the taking of

See the clipping

Semi-Weekly Register · Brookings, S.D.

This damaged clipping fragment mentions a place where Holmes is known to have lived and refers to security holders and six men gathering on a lawn around 1:15 a.m., but the text is too garbled to convey a clear narrative.

Semi-Weekly Register · 30 October 1895 · page 1

FOR PIETZEL'S MURDER.

city where Holmes is known to have lived at various times. tion, but the whole of the security peacemaker. About 1:15 a. m. six men holders.” gathered ou the lawn about 50 feet from

See the clipping

Freie Presse Für Texas · San Antonio, Tex.

Printed in German, this report states that the accused H. H. Holmes is conducting his own defense with the skill of a seasoned lawyer, posing as the embodiment of "wounded innocence."

Freie Presse Für Texas · 30 October 1895 · page 4

führt der Angeklagte h. H. Holmes feine Vertheidigung felbft mit der Ge wondtheit eines in feinem Berufe er grauten Advokaten. Cr spielt sich auf die »getritnkte Unschuld« auf.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The clipping reports that court adjourned early due to a missing witness, noting that Mrs. Pitzel, Detective Geyer, Agent Perry of the swindled insurance company, the accused, and nearly two score others still remain to be heard, with the District Attorney remarking the trial may outrival something unspecified.

The Salt Lake Herald · 30 October 1895 · page 1

THE BATTLE FOR HIS LIFE

been the intention of the court to sit I until 10 but the absence of a witness i hindered this and an adjournment was i taken The star witness of the trial Mrs Pitzel Detective Geyer Agent Perry of the swindled insurance com i pany and the archcriminal himself 1 remain to be heard as also nearly two scores of others District Attorney Graham remarked today that thorp was a likelihood of the trial outrivaling

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This fragmented and disjointed clipping, badly damaged by OCR errors, mixes mentions of a crowd gathering, officers, an affidavit, and a prisoner's planned transfer, but is too garbled to summarize clearly.

The Salt Lake Herald · 30 October 1895 · page 1

DEVELOPS GREAT SKILL

I I learn from Swaner that George f was reluctantly given The mob started hotel was taken out in a semicon I arrived this afternoon at 3 oclock The worked OD for the benefit of the Re Cannon and Ben Rich procured the affi for the scene of the murder where they scious condition from the effects of pabllcan party which will descend to j davit to be made and the circular to I j smoke but it is thought that all will be issued Whatever a man might say crowd continued to gather nit the scene recover So far as I am able to learn arvthinjr in order to carry the election 1 of these men would be inadequate I of the horrible crime until nearly 2000 at this hour no one was injured fur I ther than above mentioned was but another part of the byplay county for trial as he contemplated do at 830 oclock and his destination was following Holmes personal failure to ing He was too slow I some point in Arkansas not revealed catch the sympathy of the court and He Tinned His Hand by the ticket purchased I is certain jury by making himself out a much that he will not go to Texarkana as he and lost his game Officers from this I wronged man forced to fight alone has been notified that the governor has r what would be his last battle despite an officer there to arrest him i It is

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The clipping describes a crowded courtroom at the opening of a trial, with the prisoner placed in the dock and the district attorney informing the court that a woman called Miss Yorke, also known as Mrs. Howard, had been sent for and given ample opportunity to interview the prisoner.

The Salt Lake Herald · 30 October 1895 · page 1

all judges from this and other cities besides the head of every municipal department was noticed in the room at different times Including the mayor At 10 oclock the jury was brought into the room and Judge Arnold ap pearing a moment later the court was formally opened Taking Testimony Begins Meantime Holmes in custody of a court officer was placed in the dock The days proceedings were begun by District Attorney Graham who arose and saM to the court HI desire to sa to the court in view of what was said last night before the adjournment of the court that the lady known as Miss Yorke and Mrs Howard was sent for saw the prisoner and had ample op portunity for an interview with him This is the woman corccernins whom there was a warm passage atarms last

See the clipping

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

The fragment describes Holmes calmly and fluently discussing chemical and medical matters with a doctor regarding the effects of chloroform, amid an appeal for funds.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

THE ALLEGED MULTI-MURDERER

8econd Day's Trial of H. H. Holmes at Philadelphia. ing the eileets of chloroform, and tho calmness with which Holmes volubly exchanged technical terms and dis? cussed ohumicil and medical possibili? ties with the doctor was admirable. An Appeal For Funds in Restor?

See the clipping

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

The clipping reports that Holmes, who had dismissed his counsel, recalled lawyers Shoemaker and Rotan after a failed attempt to conduct his own defense, and describes courtroom exchanges over a woman called Miss Yoke or Mrs. Howard plus early witness testimony identifying the dead man's photographs and recounting the discovery of his body.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

THE ALLEGED MULTI-MURDERER

Philadelphia, Ost. 29?Ik became apparent to-night that the plctureique and startling features of H. H Holmes' career was not to be confined to bis dOBtructivo wandorlngs over the Amer lean continent, for with each successive day comos something atill more Btrange and unexpected. Yesterday bo dismissed his counsol and began to try his own case beoause tbe court refused to grant the plea made by them for a continuance. The; loft the court In spite of Judge Arnold's threats to disbar them and religiously kep. away. To-night, after righting tooth and;nallslnglohanded against the tremendous machinery of the common?

See moreSee less

wealth and the apparently complete chain of evidence which has been forged I arour.d him bo threw up bis hands and 8)nt for Bis law yore, Messrs. Shoemaker and Rotan. Then ho told the court what ho had done, and a reluctant consent to their continuing with the defense was given. There waB an impression that thiB was but another pice of by-play following Holmes' personal failure to catch the sympathy of the court and jury by mak? ing himself out a much wronged man, forcod to fight alone what may prove to be his lass battle, in spite of hla Igno? rance of the technicalities of the law and hin alleged physical infirmity. At 10 o'clcck the jury was brought into the room and court was formally opened. The day's proceedings were bo gun by District Attornoy Graham, who arose and said to the court: "I desire to aay to the court, in view of what was a*td last night before the adjournment of court, that the lady known as Miss Yoko and Mrs. Howard was sent for, saw the prisoner and had ample oppor? tunity for an interview with him." This in the woman concerning whom thero was a warm passago at arms last evening between Mr. Graham and Holmes, the latter declaring that the woman was his wife, and that Mr. Gra? ham hsd done all in his power to separ? ate them. When Mr. Graham conoluded Holmes said that he had only bad a three minute Interview with the woman, and asked that it be renewed during the noon recess. His request was granted. Jeannette Pioizel, "Dessa," the daughter of tbe dead man, was tbe first wltnoss called. She was called merely to identify leveral largo crayons of her father, which she did. Eugene Smith, who found Pietzel'a body in a Callowbill Btreet bouBe on September 4, 1804, then told a detailed story of his discovery, which baa already been fully publlahod. He had become acquainted with the dead man on August 22, 1804, through business con? cerning paten;.o, which Pietzal was sup? posed to have hold. Ho saw him sev? eral times during thn following week. WitnesB drew a pacUot of papers from his pecket whon he cimn to the dates. Holmes objected to nls referring to them unloBS they were In his own hand? writing. Smith admitted that tbe papers had boon "prepared," and the court sustained the objection. Smith said that during his first visit to l'ii ' /. 'I, whom ho knew by the name of Percy, HoIoipb came in, and, giving a nod or sign to Pletxel, went upatalrs. A moment later Pietzel excused him self and followed him. He roturned very shortly, but Holmes remained up Btairs The witness was present when the corpse of Pletzal was exhumed from the Potters' Field, and was them first introduced.to Holmes. Lawyer Howe, of Sr.. Louie, Alice Ple'zsl, the voting daughter, and the insurance officers were there. Tuo body was recognized by ;tho wit? ness as Pie z-jiV. Holmes offered S30 to have tbo corpse cremated and asked Howe about it. Tee lawyer answered that the widow would first have to be consulted. Holmes told tbe insurance peoplo of tbe marka of identification and after tbe body had been dug up he pulled out a lance and cut a wart and other marks from the corpse. At this time witness had recognized Holmes as the man he had seen go upstairs in the Callowblll street house. Holmes, on cross-examination, asked a number of immaterial questions, but showed much legal skill In their con? struction. Dr. Wm. J. Scott waa called, and at this juncture Holmes asked to have all witnesses, except the one on the stand, excluded from the room Mr. Graham objected io this and Judge Arnold upheld the dlBtrict attor? ney. Holmes asked for and was granted an exception to the ruling. Holmes compromised by asking that the wit? nesses conneoted with the murder of Benjamin F. Pielzed be excluded. This was gramed him, and as Holmes called out the names of these wltnoases, they loft the room. After the witnesses bad all left the room, Holmes asked if his wife waa to be a witness. "She is not in the court? room," said tbe prosecutor, "and I de? cline to sav whether or not she will be a witness " Dr. Scott was then permitted to tell his story, which concerned his having been called in to examine Pietzel'a body, after its discovery. Ho explained tbe situation of the room and the arrange? ment of thn windows so that tbo sun rays would fall upon the corpse and hasten decomposition and dwelt upon tbo d(s-"cov*Tv of chloroform in the Btom*.sh nr.d said large quantities of the drug had been used and from the con? gested condition of tho lungs and tbe empty heart It was apparent that the man had met a sudden and violent death from chloroform poisoning. I Holmes subjected Dr. Scott to a

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

On the trial's third day in Philadelphia, a crowded courtroom awaited sensational testimony as the commonwealth planned to show Holmes's connection to an insurance fraud scheme and his motive for killing Pitezel.

Alexandria Gazette · 30 October 1895 · page 2

The Holmes Murder Trial. Philadelphia. Pa., Oct. 80.?The third day of the Holmes trial opened this morning. More people were in the court room than any day yet in an? ticipation of sensational evidence. Holmes held a long consultation with his lawyers la9t night and after be was placed in the dock this morning. The commonwealth to-day will offer evi? dence showing Holmea's connection with the scheme to defraud tbe insur? ance company and his consequent motive for killing Pitezel. Trouble with Indians Feared.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

H. H. Holmes temporarily recalled his attorneys during his murder trial after losing composure when a picture of little Alice Pitezel was shown, and he indicated he would claim Pitezel committed suicide while drunk.

Alexandria Gazette · 30 October 1895 · page 2

H. H. Holmes, on trial in Phila? delphia for the murder of Be; j. F. Pite zel, continued to act as his own coun? sel yesterday, but in the evening sent for his lawyers. At the conclusion of the afternoon's session Holmes stated to the court that the strain was prov? ing too great for him, and he asked that only two sessions of the court be held a <';iy, instead of three. This was denied him, and then it was he determined to call his old counsel. When the court convened at.

See moreSee less

night Holmes explained that he had again called in bis two at? torneys and they took charge of the case. Both are youDg men and lack experience. Holmes last night for the first time seemed to lose his nerve. A large pic? ture of little Alice Pitezel was sud? denly introduced by the district at? torney, and the sight of it mos: evidently upset him, aDd when the commonwealth proposed evidence showing that Holmes, io addition to his o;h?r crimes, had made this child the victim of his passions, the man was greatly discompostd and showed his nlief iu bis face when the evidence bearing upon this point was ruled out by the court. The commonwealth having com? peted its identity of Pitezel, the court iK. journed until this morning. In compliance with his request, the woman whom he hud deceived into the belief that she was his legal wife, un? der the name of Mrs. Howard, met Holmes yesterday morning in the dis? trict attorney's office in the presenceof her mother. Tbe object of Holmes in seeking the interview was to obtain from the girl the return to him of cer? tain properties that he had deeded over to her. This, she told him, she would be only too glad to do, and that she uever again wished to see him. Holmes asked for another interview wi h "Mrs. Howard" at noon, but she was too much prostrated by the fir.-t interview with him to see him again. Holmes indicated that his line of de? fence would be that Pitezel committed suicide while drunk. THE HOLMES TRIAL.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

The clipping, cut off mid-sentence, reports that the third day of the Holmes trial opened in Philadelphia with a larger court room crowd than on any previous day.

Alexandria Gazette · 30 October 1895 · page 2

The Holmes Murder Trial. Philadelphia. Pa., Oct. 80.?The third day of the Holmes trial opened this morning. More people were in the court room than any day yet in an?

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The clipping describes Holmes spending a sleepless night writing in his cell before court, then arriving fresh and chatting with officers as the jury filed in and the District Attorney noted his wife had visited him.

The Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES HARD AT WORK

morning as yesterday, «42 LUG pul fm learned that they would not be admit ted to the court-room, Throughout all last night, in the loneli ness of his cell, in the county prison, Holmes worked steadily preparing his case. He filled sheet after sheet of foolscap, and watchers outside his cell door wondered when he would seek some rest, It was only as the first rays of the sun began to find their way through the narrow slit that does duty for windows in the cells of the county prison. that Holmes threw himself on his cot.

See moreSee less

He slept but an hour, and then was up again, and once more became busy writing until told that it was time to start for court, : Promptly at 10 o'clock the jury filed into the box. A moment afterwards Holmes entered, Despite his long and sleepless night, he looked fresh and bright, and while waiting for the Dis triet Attorney to come in, he chatted with the court officers, In compliance with Holmes’ request, the dock was much nearer the bar than yesterday. District Attorney Jraham announced to the Court that Mrs. Howard, as Holmes' latest wife is known, had ‘seen the prisoner this morning hefore he was

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, notes the prisoner's desperate, unaided position, states the Commonwealth has about twenty-five witnesses with the prisoner also calling some, and estimates the trial could last two weeks at the current pace.

The Times · 30 October 1895 · page 1

WORK ON HIS CASE,

does this because of Holmes' desperate position, alone and without . ny and that when the trial is over it cannot be sald that the prisoner has not had every chance, | The (Commonwealth has about twenty five witnesses to call, and Holmes also | proposes to call some. At the rate of progress made this morning the trial would consume fully two weeks, but as

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, after briefly dismissing his lawyers and conducting his own defense, recalled attorneys Shoemaker and Rotan as testimony continued into the night and the trial was predicted to last up to a month.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 October 1895 · page 3

HOLMES BACKS DOWN

pfciladriphia. Oct — —lt became known pdgbt that the p cturesque and startling jgtant of H. H. Holmes' career were not u i* oooftned to hia -destructive waaderIjspi over the American continent, for *,is earn successive day comets aomwthias jaii more strange and unexpected. Yes terday he dismissed his counsel and a TS his own ca me because the court re fawd to grant the plea made by triem for jconti/iuaUon They left the court m .pit. tf Judge Arnold's threats to disbar them, sad IwP l away. Tonight, after Uguting < fcawry of the commonwealth and the ap fUtutir overwhelming evidence which iu bet a forged around him.

See moreSee less

he threw up bands and sent for hia lawyers, Shoc saker and Kotan. Then he told the court wi*'. ht had done, and consent to th*ir «96tlnuiiiK with the defense was given. *Vre an impreiwlon that this was hut taotber part of the by-play following Holmes' personal failure to catch the sympathy ot the court and jury by making out a much-wronged man. forced tufifht alone wiiat would be his last bat lie, despite his ignorance of the techni calities of the law and his alleged physiuul tefirmity. The important work of the trial—the uJting of testimony—was begun this aorniag at 10. and, with the exception of mef intermissions at lunch and supper rjne, was continued until nearly t o'clock tonight. It had l>een the Intention of the «eurt to sit until 10, but the alraence of a witnesshindered this, and an adjournment w taken. The star witnesses of the trial -Mr*. I'ltzel, I>eteetlve ueyer, Agent Pht>, of the swindled insurance company, aad the arch-criminal himself—remain to be heard, and also nearly two score of others. District Attorney Graham r»*- narked today that there was a likelihood »f U»e trial outrivaling ths Durrant caao in point of time, but that if night sessions *frc hsld regularly it mig'nt l«e concluded • ithiti a month or lees. Holmes made a pka this evening, asking the court to hold but two sessions a day. In pleading he iiid his health v.aa such that he felt ur tbie to continue his tedious examinations <rf the witnesses, and beside he was sub jected to sick headache*. Judge Arnold insisted, however, on holding an extra session tonight at least, and said that to ■errow could he attended to when it cam». Dur.ng the supper recess, which follow ed this Incident, liolmos said that prepSMtion of his case In his cell last night Md kept him up until 4 o'clock In the swrnire, and he wa* roused from bed two iours later. In addition to this he hail sot eaten anything from last night until 1 •'clock tills afternoon. It was after mak ing th's statement that he sent for his sttome>s. Up to that time there had been * general Impreselon that human nature could not stand the terrible ordeai which had set for himself, and that it he per sisted In going on with his own ea*>e there would be a breakdown beforfe long. All lay, as he sat In the dock, the eyes of the msti he is charged with murdering «azed st him front a large* ctayon portrait placed upright on the district attorney's desk, in fall view of the entire court. Next to this wt# an equally lar*e sized picture «>f th«- 4»u|hter Alice, whose death le also laid on his shoulders, but he did not seem to bf sff#cted. His stolid demeanor never de serted him for an Instant. The announcement that th* taking of •fidence would be begun today drew a •till larger crowd to the clt\ hall, but the admirable police arrangements kept e\» r\- body out except the attorneys and those Interested In the cane The day's proceed ings were tjegun by District Attornev Gra ham, who arose and said to the court- "I desire to say to the court. In view of what was said last night before the adjourn ment of court, that the lady known as Miss Yorke and Mrs. Howard was s*r.t for. saw the prisoner, and had ample op portunity for an Interview with him " This Is the woman concerning whom there was a warm passage at arms last evening between Mr. Oraham and Holmes, the latter declaring that the woman was his wife. *nd that Mr Craharn had done all In his power lo separate them. When Mr. Graham had concluded Holmes sa «<1 that h-> had only a three-minute Interview with the woman, and asked that it be renewed during the noon recess. His request was granted Jeanette lltnl, "Pessa." the daughter of the dead man. w as the first witness call el She is a slender, pale Rirl of about 17 y'Hrs She was called merely to Identify several large crayons of her father, w hich •ho d'd Eugene Smith, who found Pltiel's bodv In the Caltowhill street house, then told a if la lied story of his discovery. which h.s been already fully published. The witness was pnvseat when the corpse of Pitxel w.is exhumed from the potter s rteld. and was thrrt* tirst Introduced to Holmes Lawyer Howe, of St. Alice nisei, the young daughter, anrt the Insurance ntflcers were there. The body was recognlted by the witness as Pitx"i's Holmes ottered »> to have the corpse cremated, and asked Howe about It The lawyer an»»> red that the widow would first have to be consult ed. Holmes told the Insuran.e p. opl«* of the marks of Identification, and after the body had b««en dog tip ho pulled out a lance and cut a wart and other marks from the corpse. Holmes in cross-examination 1 a number of immaterial questions, out showM much lepal «Ktli in thrm. lie ; t.sent wl .1 stra >ge picture, standing n the do K with his pencil leveled at the witness, try ing to confuse hlsn. Holmes subjected Smith to a long <nl searching cross-exMRlnarioti, Iwell.ng upon every po;n* of tie testimony adduced by the common wealth, nit the witness was unshaken. Erentjillv • >m'.n* exasperated :n c i « of an Immaterial word from Mr. G'Jhitn. Holmes exclaimed t "1 ibject to '.'ts bl>o :r**> re inner <n which the 1 «- frict attorney .ml this witness are trying t» Srinr the Inference *hat 1 rush.*d Into t*i# pot'er's fi- . ! in ! mutilated the dead of my friend." "Vou are drawing th» srs'err' voipc!'" sa'd Mr itraham l>r. W"ill im J Soott was called, and at th% Juncture Holm'* renewed his plea to all the « ■» e\ -ept the one on l"* ttj;id from the nwm. Mr. Gfaham c <ot i to this, and Holmes, without a chanrtr of expression. vut with 'vl-jte * i i "*1 would I'k* to ksow whether yc • Mr. t»raham, or the < urt. i» » make the rulings I* this ci • i iv" !>, rR inxious io know * sins-,, the tr'al began." Judge Arnold the i,«tri,*t attorney. and Holmes i«k«sl "n* an' 1 in rxc y.lon to tha raituli < <mpromised > that t*-.' » < connected wtth the lluntrr o' Bsrvir- •• I* P:tsel he »*clild •*- This *i« w !■ • «i, in-! as Holmes ***•* l out rumps of these *ttne«se* t>»y "ef» . , >n , ~ having a full 1 »t e-. th« wttr; >*, ver, he was susp!* f t ">* •* the <*t*tru -lev'a protest a "ion* Jse fthe ma . earnestly, ad Irees :r.g | to the court. ia4 J l ** 3 * Mr Oraham "I wsh T could get Mr t»r ittn. 'Vit somesotiv In against the tremendous mat • -s tr 1 " tin illr re-

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

A damaged fragment reports that if held regularly the trial might conclude within a month, and that Holmes made a plea asking the court to hold only two sessions a day due to his health.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 30 October 1895 · page 3

HOLMES BACKS DOWN.

*frc hsld regularly it mig'nt l«e concluded • ithiti a month or lees. Holmes made a pka this evening, asking the court to hold but two sessions a day. In pleading he iiid his health v.aa such that he felt ur

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Crook County Monitor · Sundance, Wyo.

This damaged, OCR-scrambled clipping fragment references H. H. Holmes, alias Howard, jailed in Philadelphia awaiting trial, and a classmate accomplice whose life was insured, but the text is too garbled to follow clearly.

The Crook County Monitor · 30 October 1895 · page 2

SSSKSJJMT doaen other allaaea, who la now In jail at Philadelphia awaiting trial on a sel case. His accomplice was a fellow latter class belongs student, and experience gained whlo H. H. Holmes, alias ho was a medical student enabled him Howard, and half a to succeoofully carry out the fraud. His classmate’s life was insured for

See the clipping

The Press · Stafford Springs, Conn.

The clipping reports that at the opening of H. H. Holmes's murder trial in Philadelphia his counsel withdrew, he briefly acted as his own lawyer before Judge Arnold, then asked his counsel to resume, suggesting a weak defence and a swift verdict.

The Press · 31 October 1895 · page 2

The trial of H. H. Holmes, which was begun Tuesday in Philadelphia, will at tract unusual attention on account of the number of crimes of which he stands ac cused, though, of course, the evidence connecting him with only a single murder will be presented. The opening of the tiial was marked by scenes out of the or dinary; the prisoner's counsel retired from the case because unable to secure a postponement, Holmes refused to accept lawyers assigned by the court, and the selection of a jury was proceeded with while he acted as his own counsel.

See moreSee less

Judge Arnold showed plainly that he was not to be trifled with by either the defendant or the lawyers whom he claimed to have discharged. A capital case of extraordi nary interest has seldom, if ever, before been opened under such peculiar circum stances. Holmes conducted his defence the second day until the evening session, but the foolishness of his venture was forced upon him, and he requested his counsel to resume charge of the case, which they did. The defence must be very weak and the public may expect a verdict in a very short time.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

This damaged clipping fragment describes a trial in which Holmes participated and the prisoner eventually argued his own case, noting dramatic exchanges between Holmes and the commonwealth's attorney, though much of the text is unclear.

Connecticut Western News · 31 October 1895 · page 1

ed by Holmes, and finally tho prisoner trying his own ease. This, not to speak of sundry dramatic passages at arms be tween Holmes and the oommon wraith's

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The clipping, a brief fragment, reports that Holmes used his right of challenge during jury selection until 19 men were secured, after which a recess was taken and the afternoon session continued the proceedings.

Connecticut Western News · 31 October 1895 · page 1

hours. Holmes freely exercising his pre rogatlve cf challenge, and after 19 men had been secured a recess was taken. The afternoon session was devoted

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, describes how during a court session large portraits of a murdered man and his daughter Alice were displayed near the district attorney's desk while the accused, Holmes, appeared unaffected by them.

Connecticut Western News · 31 October 1895 · page 1

All day, as Holmes sat In the dock, tht eyea of the man he Is cbnrgod with mur derlng gazed at him from a large rrayoi portrait placed upright on the district at torney'a dusk In full view of the entlri court Next to this waa an equally largi sized picture of the daughter Alice, whnsr death Is also laid on his shoulders. Bui Holmes did not scemNto be affected. Hi

See the clipping

In the story →

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

This article describes the third day of Holmes' Philadelphia trial, where a grieving Mrs. Carrie Alice Pitezel testified for hours while Holmes remained unmoved, and witnesses and an insurance official gave testimony about Pitezel's boarding, identification, and a $10,000 policy paid after his death.

Waterbury Democrat · 31 October 1895 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

MRS PITEZEL TESTIFIES. WIDOW OF HOLMES' ALLEGED VICTIM TELLS HER STORY. The Third Day's Proceedings In the Great Murder Case at Philadelphia—Evidence Regarding the Insurance Frauds—Holmes Remains Stolid and Unmoved.

PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 31.—The interest in the Holmes case, instead of flagging, has grown with each successive session, and it is not confined to the morbidly curious "general public," for during the greater part of the day Judge Arnold was at intervals receiving well known men upon the bench, while in the court clerk's inclosure sat a group of gayly dressed society ladies, friends of the court officials, gazing curiously at the various actors in the story and drinking in every word of the testimony.

See moreSee less

Still the wonder continues at the exhibition of coolness and nerve made by the man Holmes. Not a change passed over his features during the day, and at many critical points of the testimony he sat carelessly reading a newspaper.

Four long hours, under the scrutinizing gaze of a courtroom crowded with strangers to her, a pale, worn woman underwent an ordeal which well might have broken the nerve of many a strong man. She was Mrs. Carrie Alice Pitezel. With bravery and fortitude she stood the test, in spite of the fact that her physical condition has been so shattered by the battalion of woes, under which she has all but succumbed, that she was obliged to interrupt her pitiful narrative at frequent intervals to accept spoonfuls of medicine from the trained nurse who attended her. In a voice broken with grief she told the whole distressing story, and so affecting was the recital that even District Attorney Graham, long used to tales of misery and distress, paused in the examination to wipe away a furtive tear.

Third Day's Proceedings.

The first witness of the day was a plump, black eyed woman, Miss Susan Hurley of 1002½ Race street. She keeps a boarding house there. She was called to show that Pitezel had boarded at her house. She thought the man in the picture had remained at her house a week and a day; had only seen him there once, and on cross examination wasn't so very sure it was he.

Miss Alice Pierce, who keeps a cigar store at 1304 Callowhill street, where Pitezel bought cigars, identified the crayon picture as that of the murdered victim.

Deforest Perry, assistant treasurer of the Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance company, was called to establish the fact that a policy of insurance had been issued to Pitezel. The policy was taken out in 1893 for $10,000. It was paid Sept. 24, 1894—22 days after Pitezel's body was found.

After the payment of the money the matter was closed until a letter was received by President Fouse of the insurance company from Superintendent of Police Harrigan of St. Louis. This contained the declaration of Hedspeth, the train robber, that while in jail in St. Louis he had overheard Holmes and Pitezel talking of forming a conspiracy to defraud an insurance company out of $10,000 by the substitution of a corpse for Pitezel. Inspector Gray of the insurance company was sent to St. Louis and interviewed Hedspeth. On the information thus obtained a warrant was sworn out for Holmes on the charge of conspiracy, and upon this he was arrested in Boston. The witness went to that city and identified Holmes. The latter had made a verbal statement to the witness in the presence of Deputy Superintendent Hanscom, Chief of Police Watts and John Cornish of a Boston detective agency in Chief Watts' office.

Inspector William E. Gray of the insurance company told of a trip to St. Louis, where he procured Hedspeth's statement. This was produced, but not yet offered in evidence. In consequence of it the tracking of Holmes was begun. He was first located in Ogdensburg, N. Y., then at Prescott, Canada, various points in New Hampshire, Burlington, Vt., and Boston.

Anna M. Robbins, the stenographer who took the examination of Holmes by Deputy Hanscom, identified a copy of the statement.

District Attorney Graham offered the statement in evidence, and Assistant Barlow read it to the jury.

Mrs. Pitezel on the Witness Stand.

During its reading three women were ushered into court by a side door. One was Dessa Pitezel and another her mother. There was a buzz in the courtroom when District Attorney Graham called:

"Mrs. Pitezel."

A tall, slender woman, dressed in shabby black, her face pale and worn, took the witness stand. In answer to a long series of questions from Mr. Graham she said:

"My name is Carrie A. Pitezel, and Benjamin F. Pitezel was my husband. In July, 1894, we lived in St. Louis. My husband had taken a policy in the Fidelity company for $10,000. On July 29 he left for Philadelphia in connection with the matter. I know the prisoner. Before July, 1894, I had seen him several times with my husband when he came to our house in St. Louis and when we lived on Madison avenue, Chicago. I corresponded with my husband while he was in Philadelphia. The letters were addressed to 1316 Callowhill street. He answered them, and in one he spoke of settling in Philadelphia. He said he was in the patent business in this city. I knew he was living under the name of Perry."

"Did you know anything about the property of Holmes—the Sixty-third street castle?"

"By my husband telling me about it."

"Did he have any interest in that?"

"My husband said he did."

"Did you know that your husband had been in Fort Worth before he came to Philadelphia?"

"Yes."

Mrs. Pitezel said: "Holmes said to me that he had put $5,000 in Fort Worth property to pay off a note due Sept. 18, 1894. My husband said he had a half interest in the Fort Worth property. It was in the name of Benton T. Lyman. Holmes told me this. Lyman was my husband. The Chicago property, he said, was in the name of Perry on account of the Terre Haute trouble."

"Did you have any talk with Holmes about the insurance case before it was carried out?"

"Once he spoke to me about it when he came back from the south and asked me if Ben had told me about it. I said 'Yes,' and that I did not want anything to do with it. He said Ben would be home from the south soon; that he was sick down there."

Continuing, Mrs. Pitezel said:

"I knew Howe through Homes. By his advice I employed Howe and gave him the power of attorney to collect the money. I don't know who prepared it, but Howe brought it to be signed. I saw in a paper that a man named Perry had been killed by an explosion, but Holmes told me my husband was all right."

"In whose care did Alice leave St. Louis?"

"In Howe's. She went at Holmes' suggestion to Philadelphia to identify the body because I was sick. I asked Howe to take care of Alice, and Holmes said he would. Minnie Williams, Holmes' cousin, he said, would take care of her, and if I grew very sick he would send Benny to take care of me. I next saw Holmes on Sept. 27, when he came to our house and said he had brought Alice back to Cincinnati. He said he would take Howard and Nellie to Alice, so she would not be alone, and had made arrangements for Alice to meet them in Indianapolis.

"I took Nellie and Howard to the depot. Howe was there and said the insurance money had been paid. Holmes said to me, 'You had better give her some money,' and Howe gave me $5. I bade the children goodby, and they got on the car.

She Saw Holmes on Oct. 12.

"On Oct. 12 Holmes came to the house in St. Louis, and I went to Howe's office. Holmes was there, and Howe said the scheme was a fraud, and he washed his hands of it. They wanted me to sign a paper in regard to Howe's fee, and after being assured that I would not be implicated in the affair I did so Holmes there went under the name of Howard. He demanded $300 or $400 of me, and I gave it. He wanted to go to some bank to pay off the note due on the Fort Worth property. I got the $5,000, and he took it. We went around to the bank. The money was in $100 bills, all but one old note, a $1,000 bill. He took the money and went to a side window. Then he came back and brought the note, saying it was paid. He told me to take care to show it to Ben when I saw him."

"How much in all did you get of this insurance money?"

"I received $500. That was all I ever got."

"After this money transaction, what became of Holmes?"

"He took another $500 for the children, who, he said, would need some in Indianapolis. He went away, and some time afterward he sent me a letter from Detroit to come on there to see my husband."

"Did you see your husband?"

"No. He then sent me to visit my parents at Galva, Ills."

In answer to further questions Mrs. Pitezel went on: "When I went to Detroit with Dessa and the baby, he met us and took us to Geese's European hotel. I said I expected to hear from the children, and he said they would write in a few days. Holmes registered me there as Mrs. Adams. We remained in Detroit until Oct. 18."

"Did he explain why your husband was not there?"

"He said he had looked all over the town and could not find a vacant house where it would be convenient for me to see Ben. On the morning of the 18th he said we'd better go to Toronto. He thought Dessa should join the other children in Indianapolis, where they were in charge of a widow, he said. I asked him the name of the widow my children were with, and he said: 'It's a peculiar name. I cannot think of it now.' We went to Toronto, where he also registered me as Mrs. Adams. My husband, he said, was in Montreal waiting for word to come on.

"We were in Toronto from Oct. 18 to Oct. 25. Holmes did not stop at the same house with us. I don't know where his different stopping places were. On the afternoon of the 25th he came to the hotel and said he wanted me to hurry up and go to Prescott, Canada, and there cross over to Ogdensburg, N. Y. We went to Prescott and staid at the National hotel until Nov. 1.

Mrs. Pitezel Takes the Name of Cook.

"From there we went to Burlington, Vt. He told me that I had worn out the name of Adams and to go by the name of Cook. He claimed to be sending diamond dyes to Ben in Montreal. The second week we were at Burlington I said I was not going to stand it any longer. I wanted to see Ben, and I told Holmes I believed he was lying to me. He denied this. I said, 'I do not hear from my children, and you said I would get the rent from the Fort Worth property, and I have not a scratch to show.' I said I would go to the children in Indianapolis, but he said, 'No, not until you see Ben.' He said he was going to take Ben to the United States and get him to sign papers about the Fort Worth property and sell it.

"For two or three days I did not see him, and then he came and told me he had taken the children to Toronto. He said he had put heavy coats on them, so they wouldn't catch cold, and that they were perfectly happy. He said he would have to go to Montreal, as Ben had been drinking and was not taking care of the diamond dyes. He told me to go into the cellar, and under the potato bin I would find a bottle of dynamite, which I should carry to the attic. I did not carry it up stairs, though. Holmes was there known as Judson. He told me Ben had been drinking and was sick and asked me what I'd do if he should die. He said, 'I have one grave marked for him.' All my letters were given to Holmes to mail. He said he sent them to Chicago, where Pat Quinlan, the janitor of the castle, took care to get them to my husband."

A number of letters written by the witness and given to Holmes to mail were identified by her. None had been mailed. She was shown two others written by Alice and Nellie.

"Have you ever seen your husband since he left St. Louis for Philadelphia?"

"I have never seen him since July 29, 1894, nor heard from him since Aug. 29, when I got the last letter in his own handwriting," she answered tearfully.

"That was from Philadelphia?"

"Have you seen or heard from Alice, Nellie or Howard since this man got possession of them?"

"I have not heard from them."

"Have you seen them since?"

Sobbing bitterly, the woman answered: "I saw Alice and Nellie lying side by side in the morgue at Toronto. I never saw Howard except what belonged to him in Indianapolis in the coroner's office."

This ended the examination in chief.

In answer to questions from Mr. Rotan the witness said she was married to Pitezel in Galva, Ills., in 1878. She did not know where he and Holmes had first met. She thought it was in 1889. She first met Holmes in the restaurant at Sixty-third and Wallace streets, Chicago (the castle) when she was with her husband there in 1893. She did not see much of Holmes until this insurance matter came up.

A long line of questions were put to Mrs. Pitezel, many of which were ruled out on the ground of irrelevance. The cross examination lasted nearly two hours, but developed nothing to controvert her evidence in chief.

District Attorney Graham then showed her the crayon portrait of Pitezel, and she said, "Yes, that is a good picture of my husband as he left home."

She gave way for her daughter Jeannette (Dessa) whose testimony was largely corroborative of that given by her mother concerning the departure of the children and the subsequent travels of Dessa and her mother under Holmes' guidance to the various cities named.

Mrs. Pitezel was recalled, and the district attorney questioned her further regarding the stay in Burlington, attempting to show that Holmes had dug a hole in the cellar there, as he had done in every other case where he had rented a house.

The defense objected to this line of evidence on the ground of irrelevancy, and Judge Arnold sustained the objection.

The court then adjourned until 10 a. m. today.

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This fragment describes testimony about children's travels with Dessa and her mother under a guide's direction, and notes Mrs. Fltezel was recalled by the district attorney to be questioned further about their stay in Burlington.

Evening Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 3

MRS. PITEZEL TESTIFIES Widow of Holmes' Alleged Victim Tells Her Story

children and the subsequent travels of Dessa and her mother under Holmes' guidance to the various cities named. Mrs. Fltezel was recalled, and ths dis trict attorney questioned her further re garding the stay In Burlington, attempt

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping describes the third day of testimony in the Holmes trial, including Mrs. Pitezel's grueling four-hour ordeal and witnesses establishing Pitezel's boarding history, identification, and a $10,000 insurance policy linked to an alleged conspiracy.

Evening Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 3

IT IS A SAD AND TOUCHING RECITAL The Third llfty'i rroreedlngn In the firent Murder Case at rhihulelphiuKrtSrnce Itegardlogthe Insurance Frauda—Bol mes Itcmatua Stolid and t amoved, Philadelphia, Oot. hi.—T he interest In tho Holmes case. Instead of flagging, has grown with each successive session, r.nd It Is not confined to tho morbidly cu rious "general public," for during the greater part of tho day Judge Arnold was at Intervals receiving well known men upon the bench, whllu In the court clerk's Inclosure sal a group of ga.yly dressed so ciety Indies, friends of the court officials, gazing curiously at tho various actors iu tho story and drinking In every word of the testimony.

See moreSee less

■ Still the wonder continues at the exhi bition of coolness and nerve made by the man Holmes. Not n change passed over his features during the day, and at many critical points of. the testimony ho sat carelessly rending a newspaper. Four long hours, under the scrutinizing gaze of a courtroom crowded with stran gers to her, a pale, worn woman under went an ordeal which well might have broken tho nerve of many a strong man. She was Mrs. Carrie Alice Pltexel. With bravery .and fortitude she stood the tost, In spite of tho fact that her physical con dition has been so shattered by tho bat talion of woes, under which she has all but succumbed, that sho was obliged to Interrupt her pitiful narrative at frequent Intervals to accept spoonfuls of medicine from tho trained nurse who attended her. In a voice broken with grief sho told the whole distressing story, and so affecting was tho recital that ovon District Attor ney Graham, long used to talcs of misery and distress, paused In the examination to wipe away a furtive tear. Third Day'll rrocordlnit«. The first witness of tho day was a plump, black eyed woman, Miss Susan Hurley of 1003-4 Kaco street. She koopa a boarding house there. Sho was called to show that Pltexel had boarded at her house. Sho thought the man in the pic ture had reniai mil at her house a week and a day; hud only seen him there once, and on cross examination wasn't so very ■uro it was he. Miss Alice Pierce, who keeps a c igar store at 1304 Callowhill street, where Pltczol bought cigars, Identified the cray on picture as that of the murdered victim. Deforest Perry, assistant treasurer of tho Fidelity Mutual Life Insurance com pany, was culled to establish the fact that n policy of insurance had boon issued to Pltezel. Tho policy was taken out In 1893 for $10,000. It was paid Sept. 24, 1894— 23 days after Pitoxel's body was found. After tho payment of tho money tho matter was closed until a letter was re ceived by President Fouaeot tho Insurance company from Superintendent of Police Harrlgan of St. Louis. This contained tho declaration of Hcdspeth, the train rob ber, that while in jail in St. Louis ho had overheard Holmes and Pltezel talking of terming a conspiracy to defraud an insur ance company out of $10,000 by the sub stitution of a corpse for Fltezel. Inspector Gray of tho Insurance company was sent to St. Louis and Interviewed Hedspcth. On tho Information thus obtained a war rant was sworn out for Holmes on tho charge of conspiracy, and upon this he was arrested In Boston. Tho witness went to that city and Identified Holmes. Tho lat ter hud made a verbal statement to the ■

See the clipping

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping describes an insurance inspector's testimony tracing Holmes's movements, the reading of his statement into evidence, and Mrs. Carrie A. Pitezel's testimony about her husband's business dealings and policy with the prisoner.

Evening Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 3

K-'y 'J H. H. HOLMES AS BE APPEARS KOW. witness in tho presence of Deputy Super intendent Han seam, Chief of Police Watts and John Cornish of a Boston detective agency In Chief Watts' office. Inspector William K. Gray of tho jnsur anctLOompnny told of a trip to St. Louis, whore he procured Hedspeth's statement. This was produced, but not yet offered iu evidence. In consequence of it the track ing of Holmes was begun. Ho waa first located In Ugdeusburg, N. Y., then nt Prescott, Canudq, various points in New Hampshire, Burlington, Vt., and Boston.

See moreSee less

Anna M. Robbins, tho stenographer who took tho examination of Holmes by Deputy Hauscom, identified a copy of the statement. District Attorney Graham offered the statement In evidence, and Assistant Bar low read it to the jury. Mrs, Pltezel on the Witness Stand, During Us reading three women wore ushered into court by a side door. One was Dessa Pltezel and another her mother. There was a buzz in the courtroom when District Attorney Graham called: "Mrs. Pltezel." A tall, slender woman, dressed in shab by black, her face pale and worn, took the witness stand. In answer to a long series of questions from Mr. Graham sltb said: "My name is Carrie A. Pltezel, and Benjamin F. Pltezel was my husband. In July, 1894, we lived in St. Louis. My husband had taken a policy in the Fideli ty company for $10,000. On July 39 he left for Philadelphia in connection with the matter. 1 know the prisoner. Before July, 1894, I bad seen him several times with my husband when he came to our bouse In St. Louis and when wo lived on Madison avenue, Chicago. I corresponded with my husband while he was in Phila delphia. The letters wore addressed to 1816 Callowhill street, them, and in one he spoke of settling in Philadelphia. Ho said he was in the pat ent business in this city. I know he was living under tho name of Perry." "Did you know anything about the property of Holmes—the Sixty-third street castle?" "By my husband telling me about It." "Did ho have any interest iu that?" £ "My husband sold ho did. " "Did you know that your husband had been in Fort Worth before he came tt Philadelphlaf" "Yes." Mrs. Pltezel said: "Holmes said to mt that he had put $6,000 Iu Fort Worth property to pay off a note due Sept. 18, 1894, Jily husband said lie bad a Imlf in He answered

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This badly scrambled clipping is too damaged to follow clearly, but it touches on a Venezuelan incident, a wedding, and a man arrested for horse larceny who said he did not want to go to Fort Worth.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 31 October 1895 · page 1

tomorrow afternoon nominally governed by Queen Pomaro, a growing out of the Uruan Incident, os the ment will bo make Worth, Tax., saying he was wanted there native ruler. Venezuelan government seems desirous of Cemetery for "larceny of horso." (Holmes The veddlngof W 1 m Mi It *n to Ml s doing everything possible to repair any in wailed at this.) When arrested Holmes The Head of the Caban Party. Lucy AleCtta jury done to British subjects." said ho did not want to go to Fort Worth, talc bright 8 o'clock luter* possible.

See moreSee less

Hauber, Defender. gineor soldior and went 40 with tho cere White Olay Ureek Spenoer, St. John's.. mony. 40 a brief speech. He said that they were "Name this child," he gasped, reaching Rrady,*Hlgh bohool.. » «ported to have for tho third. Him ms. Wan en . piaoe yesterday.

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This damaged clipping mixes a report of a conspiracy warrant and arrest of someone named Holmes in Boston with unrelated items on a church organ, a fraternal lodge's growth to 343,000 members, a remark attributed to Henry VIII, and a coal and wood dealer's advertisement.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 31 October 1895 · page 1

HOW THE PRISONER DECEIVED HER

mooting this evening my cordiul congrat terior. and there is practically no military station Information thus obtained a warrant '1 be line pipe organ possessed by the ulations on the wise and patriotic declara there, although the oolonial government the charge of sworn out for Holmes of church hue b.*eu rebuilt, und the tions in their state platform oonoernlng has repeatedly asked the Imperial govern conspiracy, and upon this he was arrested mente of ths altar have b«en retouched the leading questions liefere the American ment for a supply of Maxim guns.

See moreSee less

and many exp«ti«lve and rich additions In Boston. Holmes made a verbal state people, and the assuranoe of my earnest the floor bearing her name. When King the order a good thing. In the twenty T. Sergeant, dealer in ooal, wood Henry VIII wus asked why he did not bulla and grain, yard 100 Maryland avenue. seven years since the organization of the the ibis call is necessitated by tha her a suitablo monument, he is said to Office 7th and King streets. Phone 545i, to lodge there have been formed thirty have replied that he left her the grandest tiST Large Pea Coal for family use. da p interest nunifisied in the four grand lodge», with a total membership firLarge load of wood for 81,50. monument which woman had, mean of 343,000. Now

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

This damaged clipping describes Holmes being arrested after a telegram from Fort Worth alleged horse-related larceny, with Holmes preferring to go to Philadelphia over a $10,000 fraud matter, and references a statement to Assistant District Attorney Barr, but the text is too scrambled to follow clearly.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 31 October 1895 · page 1

HOW THE PRISONER DECEIVED HER

tendent of police of Boston, directed Holmes' arrest Worth, Tax., saying he was wanted there for "larceny of wailed at this.) When arrested Holmes said ho did not want to go to Fort Worth, Imt that he would go without requisition 8o Philadelphia, where he had defrauded Mufld.Uty ; Holmes' statement to Perry Vend by Assistant District Attorney Bar a telegram from Fort horso." (Holmes pany of 810,000. then

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This damaged fragment describes Holmes being led from a cell room into a courtroom dock by a tipstaff, flanked by officers, and notes he looked pale but neat, having grown a full black beard during his confinement.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 5

HOLMES HIS OWN COUNSEL Startling Turn of Affairs in the Trial of the Famous Prisoner. DROPPED HIS LAWYERS IN COURT Judge Arnold Refused to Allow Them to Withdraw. TWO OTHERS ASSUMED THEIR PLACES

largo "cage" leading from the cell room clanged,and Holmes was brought in by a tipstaff and piucect in the smaller dock in the centre of tho room, at tho further corner of tho jury box, immediately back of his attorneys' tuble and surrounded by the desks of the newspaper reporters. A stalwart officer stood at either side of the «lock. Holmes, who has grown beard since his monsing prison, looked pale and but immaculately neat. His hair was tipstaff and placed i confinement in Moya a full black

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The fragment describes Holmes, who has grown a beard since his confinement, appearing pale but immaculately neat in court and occasionally leaning forward to whisper to someone beside him.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 5

officer stood at either side of the «lock. Holmes, who has grown beard since his monsing prison, looked pale and but immaculately neat. His hair was carefully parted, his beard trimmed almost to a point, and the black cheviot suit he wore was scrupulously clean. He was plainly nervous. Oc casionally, ho would lean forward and address a whispoyod word to his c •I. confinement in Moya a full black

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

This damaged fragment depicts a courtroom scene in which Holmes attempts to discharge his counsel, Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker, but Judge Arnold rules he cannot do so.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 5

TWO OTHERS ASSUMED THEIR PLACES

ov pleudcil Mr. Rotan. "Call a jury," firmly, and tho calling of jury monwealth, when the sensation. Holmes and in a quavering treblo voice, suid to Judgo Arnold : "May it pieuse tho Court, I have inclination to continue with the trial of this case with Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker as my counsel, feeling that, interests would be damaged. I there fore discharge them as my counsel." Thie device aliko proved ineffective, "Y Holmes," answered Judgo Arnold, until to-morrow morning?" echoed tho judgo, admitted by the Com juror re was another arose in tho dock of their desire to withdraw my cannot discharge them, Mr. A ttorney. A " I havo never" my

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

A Fort Worth, Texas lawyer testified identifying handwriting on a $15,000 note signed under an alias, used by Holmes to obtain $5,000 from a woman, as court resumed after a wait for the district attorney.

The Evening Times · 31 October 1895 · page 2

HOLMES' ALLEGED WIVES

us when ue was lirst arraigned in court. When placed in tueuociciitf acawieua let ter, und mat ihe man Is not wtiony nerveless was shown by the way tne paper snook In his hand. After court opened there wasquite a wait for ihe district attorney. Holmes passed the Interval ny consuit'iig with ins counsel ami mailing uuu luugmug wiui tne court, officers. Siilncj L. Samuels, a Fort Worth, Texas, lawjer, was tho lirst wliiiess today. He xns shown the note lor Jlb.000, signed by Pilezel under the name ru lltiuou T. Lyman and to take which Holmes got the $0,000 lrom Sirs.- Pltezcl. WllnibS ideniified the liandn rains In the tody of the note as his own.

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, describes a letter from Holmes to a woman in Wilmette about his marriage being read to the jury, the defense objecting to testimony on his marriages, and Holmes visibly breaking down in court.

The Evening Times · 31 October 1895 · page 2

THAT $5,000 NOTE.

tDortQ $2.50. A letter from Holmes to the woman In Wilmelle. in whic:i He (.peaks "f belr mar mnrrUige, was read tothe Jury. HOLMES WF.PT. The defense entered a general objection to any and all le-tllmonjbearing upon the question of Holmes' marriages. Just after this Holmes, lor Ihe first time since the trial, gave way. and so acute was

See the clipping

The Evening Times · Washington, D.C.

The fragment describes a courtroom scene where a man watches a woman and wipes away a tear, and Miss Yoke testifies she knew the prisoner as Holmes and Howard, having met him in St. Louis.

The Evening Times · 31 October 1895 · page 2

was her husband. He. on the contrary, looked longingly toward her, and occa sionally wled a tear away. Miss Yoke testified that she knew the prisoner under the names of Holmes and Howard. She met hun in St. Louis, and

See the clipping

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports Ben S. Calef's election as Life Underwriters president, armor plate bid invitations, a destructive fire in Prussian Poland, and the start of H. H. Holmes's murder trial, before breaking off mid-sentence about Patrick Callahan.

The National Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 8

BRIEF NEWS,

Ben S. Calef was unanimously elected Presi dent of the Life Underwriters at the National Convention at Philadelphia last week. LoUdon representatives of tho Carnegie Steel aud Bethlehem Iron Companies have received invitations from tho BtiB.-sian and Brazilian Governments to send bids for several thousand tons of Harveyized armor plato. A fire at Lasocin, Prussian Poland, destroyed most of the town and loaves 1,500 homeless. The trial of II. II. Holmes, charged with the murder of B. F. Pitezel, began at Philadelphia Monday. Patrick Callahan, who claimed to liavo

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A damaged clipping describes Mr. Graham producing a note, identified by Mrs. Piteel, that Holmes allegedly used to pretend payment at a St. Louis bank, with the amount illegible.

Evening Star · 31 October 1895 · page 2

LATE NEWS - BY WIRE

spoke quickly and sharply and invariably referred to Holmes as "the individual." This amused even HbImes, who smiled broadlywhenever the term was used. Mr. Graham produced the note Identified by Mrs. Piteel yesterday, as the one which Holmes pretended to pay at the St. Louis bank, and for which purpose he took $5^,t1)

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper

A witness named Gary testified about seeing a woman claiming to be Mrs. H. H. Holmes in Willamette, Ill., and recounted Holmes's prison letter and insurance money deposit, aiming to show Miss Yoke was not his lawful wife.

Evening Star · 31 October 1895 · page 2

PROGRESS OF THE CASE

was recalled, Mr. Graham saying he pro posed to prove by him that Holmes was a much-married mnan, and that Miss Yoke was not his lawful wife, as he asserted, and is therefore incompetent to testify. Mr. Gary said he had seen at the prison er's house in Willamette, Ill., a woman representing herself as Mrs. H. H. Holmes. He identified a photograph of her. Last December wItness saw Holmes in Moyam stag prison, this c'ty, wiren he told him of his visit to Willamette. Holmes then said he wanted to wr!te a letter to his wife, and ,iid ., asking the witness to mail it.

See moreSee less

The envelope was not audressed. Holmes leav ing it to the witness. Subsequently *it ness ha.1 spoken to Miss Yoke, known as Mrs. Howard. bhe was not the woman he had sen in Willamette. Holmes told the witness he had deposited $i,otai of the in surance money with a Mr. Blackman of Chicago. his real estate agent, so that "Mrs. Holmes could draw upon it." The defense entered a formal objection to all the evidence of Mr. Gary concerning -Msg'Yoke, but we'e overruled. The letter was read to the jury. T~o other letters were offered, written by Holmes, one from Columbus, to H. M. Cass, Chicago, agent of the insurance com pany, givirg him a detailed description of Pitezel for the purpose of identification. Holmes Breaks Dovwn.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Also printed in 1 paper
  • St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn. · 1 November 1895

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The clipping reports that Carrie A. Pitezel, widow of the murdered man, took the stand in the Philadelphia trial and began recounting her husband's dealings with the prisoner, including a $10,000 insurance policy and his July 1894 trip to Philadelphia, before the text breaks off.

Evening Star · 31 October 1895 · page 11

MRS. PITEZEL AND HOLMES Story of Her Relations With the Suspected Murderer.

Upon the conclusion of The Star's tele graphlc report yesterday of Holmes' trial in Philadelphia for the murder of Pltezel the widow of the murdered man took the stand and related at lenhtb the story of Holmes' connection with the Iitezels. It was a remarkable story of mutual decep tion, strange wanderings and collusion in crime. She began: "My name is Carrie A. Pitezel and Benja min F. Pitezel was my husband. In July, 18!4, we lived in St. Louis. My nusban-I had taken a policy in the Fidelity company for $10,000. On July 29i he left for Philadelphia in connection with the matter. I know the prisoner. Before July, 1894, 1 had seen him several times with my husband, when he

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This single item quotes Mrs. Pitezel's testimony on corresponding with her husband under an alias, the insurance case, Howe's involvement, and journeys to Detroit, Toronto and Prescott arranged by a man she knew as Holmes or Howard.

Evening Star · 31 October 1895 · page 11

MRS. PITEZEL AND HOLMES

soon; that he was sick down there." Contlnuing, Mrs. Piriecel said: "I knew Howe tiirough Holmes. By his advice I employed liowe, anl gave him the power of attorney to collect 'he money. I don't know who prepared it, but Howe brought it to he signel. "I saw in a paper that a man name-. Per-y had been killed by an xplosio-1, but Hoboes told me my husband was all rigrht." "In whose care did Alice ieave St. Loulo?" "In Howe's. She went aL Holm<-s' sug gestion to Philadelphia to identify the body because I was sick.

See moreSee less

I asked Towe to take care of Alice. and Holmes said le would. "On October :l Holmes came to the house in St. Louis, and we went to Howe's office. Holmes was there, and Howe said the scheme was a fraud, .nd he washed his hands of it. They wanted me to sign a paper in regard to Howe's fee. and after being as sured that I would not be implicated in the affair. I did so. Holnfes there went under the name of Howard." "How much did you get in all of this in surance money?" "I received $:AN). That was 't I ever got." "After this money transaction what be came of Holmes?" "He took another $100 for the children, who, he said, would need some in Indian apolis. He went away, and some time af terward sent me a letter from Detroit to

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping describes Mrs. Pietzel weakly testifying that she knew Holmes and that her husband had written, while Holmes appeared unaffected and took notes for his counsel's cross-examination.

New-York Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 2

eyes to Holmes's face, answered that she did, and quickly averted her look. Mrs. Pietzel was so weak that it was necessary for a court crier ! to repeat her answers to Mr. Graham's questions. It was slowly drawn from her that she knew Holmes and that her husband had written from line of questioning. Throughout the intensely dramatic and pathetic recital of Mrs. Pietzel, Holmes to all appearances wae as little affected as the most Indifferent person In the room. He busied himself while Mrs. Pietzel was giving her testimony in making notes for the use of hig counsel In the crose-examination. MRS. PIETZEL CROSS8-EXAMINED.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The clipping describes Mrs. Pietzel, visibly worn and sick, taking the witness stand to testify about Holmes's financial dealings and alias before undergoing cross-examination in which Holmes advised the defense attorney Rotan on questioning.

New-York Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 2

GREAT MURDER TRIAL.

assisted into the witness box there was a eraning of necks in the courtroom, for it was at once surmised that this was Mrs. Pietzel. Whether Holmes had schooled himself to face her, or whether the man really lacked sensibility, was impossible to say, but as she stood erect before him he exhibited no emotion of any kind, but, on the contrary, gazed fixedly at her for fully a minute. As the woman came into the full light of the courtroom she plainly ghowed that she had borne a burden of SOrrows that have proven too heavy for her.

See moreSee less

Her skin was salquestion for the purpose of showing Holmes's motive In killing Pietzel and the children. The Court overruled the objection, and Mrs. Pletzel said that Holmes told her that he would put $5,000 in the Fort Worth property and pay off a note falling due on September 18, 1804, The Fort Worth property was in the name of Benton F. Lyman, which was an alias of Pletzel. It was often necessary tc repeat the questions asked Mrs. Pietzel, for she seemed stunned and it evidently required some mental effort for her to understand and answer interrogatories. She testified that she employed Howe to collect the has failed vigibly In the last few months and she was an extremely sick woman when che was placed on the stand this afternoon. It was a question this morning whether she would he able to testify at all to-day, but she is a woman cf strong determination and she resolutely persevered and gave her evidence, Mrs. Pietzel resumed the stand this evening and her cross-examination was proceeded with, Before Mr. Rotan begun his examination of the witness Holmes talked eagerly with him for rome time, and was evidently advising him as to the I'ne of cuestioning he should pursue. The ev! dent object of the defence was to show that she

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A newspaper account describes Mrs. Pietzel's tearful courtroom testimony about discovering her children's fate, being pressured into signing papers, and losing most of the $10,000 insurance money to Holmes and Howe.

New-York Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 2

MRS. PIETZEL BREAKS DOWN. Throughout this long recital, Mrs. Pietzel had borne up with fortitude, but when Mr. Graham asked her if ghe ever .aw the children after she gave them into Holmes's charge, she gave way, and sobbed bitterly before she could answer. Not a whisper was heard in the courtroom as she ralsed her head, and, in a broken voice, replied: “I never saw my two little girls again until T saw them lying side by side in the morgue at Toronto, and I never saw Howard again, but was only shown some things that belonged to him in Indianapolis.” Mrs.

See moreSee less

Pietzel's testimony wag most damaging to Holmes, and the cross-examination by the counsel for the defence in no way served to help him. The prosecution belleves it has convincing ev- {dence to convict Holmes, and the DistrictAttorney and his assistant are satisfied that they will easily prove thelr case. She was finally persuaded into =igning | business. the paper by a Mr. Harvey. Alone and among these men she gave way and signed a paper that she was asked to put her name to. Holmes borrowed $300 from her and then took her out to the bank. As they went out of the door Harvey said: “Spring no traps.” Holmes took her to the bank under the pretence of paying off a note on the Fort Worth property for $5,000. She gave him the money, and Holmes gave her a forged note purporting to be the one he had taken up. All the money she got out of the $10,000 on her husband's life was $500. When asked what became of Holmes and Howe after paying the money, Mrs, Pletzel appeared to be overcome and could not answer for a time. Continuing, she sald that she went to the ticket office of the railroad company, and Holmes extorted another $100 from her on the plea that it would be necessary to pay the children's expenses. Holmes told her to write a few lines to the chil-

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A daily news roundup briefly mentions that Mrs. Pietzel testified in the trial of H. H. Holmes for the murder of her husband in Philadelphia. The item appears amid a broader digest of foreign and domestic news stories from October 31, 1895.

New-York Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 6

Exchange. Secretary Lamont named the — fortifications at Sandy Hook Fort Hancock. A negro was burned and tortured to death in the public square of Tyler, Texas, by a mob for assaulting and murdering a white woman, ———= Both the pugilists, Corbett and Fitzsimmons, are under arrest in Arkansas; the Governor is acting vigorously to prevent the prizefight at Hot Springs, === Mrs, Pietzel testified in the trial of H. H. Holmes for the murder of her husband in

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

This damaged clipping fragment describes materials brought to a scene for what appears to be an execution of an unnamed negro man, and separately references a denial or defense being attacked and denounced as a subterfuge, but the text is too scrambled to follow clearly.

The Morning News · 31 October 1895 · page 1

MRS. PITEZEL ON THE STAND. HOLMES ROBBED HER AFTER MURDERING HER FAMILY.

coal oil and tstraw were driven to the scene and nlgeed in position. The negro was then given an opportunity to speak, death, and have produced evidence in excited by Holmes’ friendless and forlorn support of the denial*. It is generally condition, was effectually killed in the coneedend that there were some mis has been attacked with great force on all sides, and denounced us a mere subter

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A damaged clipping mixes an account of a woman told by Holmes that her husband was alive and hiding over an insurance swindle with an unrelated closing letter signed James Longstreet discussing constitutional amendments.

The Morning News · 31 October 1895 · page 1

DECEIVING HER FAMILY

to Bltezel’s death. Then, she told of Holmes coming to Tier and telling her that her husband still lived, but was in hiding for his connection with the swin dle of the insurance company. How he things In the report which should ple are not averse to reading facts, sup not be there. Hail ft not been for these ported as they are by records of the events two amendments—the fourteenth and flf as they transpired. I remain respectfully tenth—there would be no need for this and truly yours. James Longstreet. convention. They might ransack all the

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

A Philadelphia news report describes Mrs. Pitezel's feeble, emotional courtroom testimony against Holmes, detailing how he deceived her about her husband's death and swindled her out of insurance money.

The Morning News · 31 October 1895 · page 1

Again After They Went Away With Holmes. Philadelphia, Oct, 30.—Branded though he Is as a liar, swindler and murderer, the picture drawn to-day of Holmes’ cold-hearted villiany by Mrs. Pltezel, the widow of the man for whose murder he is being tried, presents him in even a more revolting character than he has yet stood revealed. ( Whatever sympathy might have been excited by Holmes’ friendless and forlorn condition, was effectually killed in the breasts of all in the court room who heard Mrs. Pitezel’s story. She was placed upon Ups witness stand to-day and for three hours this afternoon and one ’hour to night she was subjected to an ordeal that no woman in her condition been called upon to face.

See moreSee less

Her storwfurnished the first really sensational feature that has yet been brought out. The whole scene and the events of th<) afternoon were Intensely dramatic. Mrs. Pltezel and Holmes have never been brought face to face until to-day since the dread ful revelations or her ctiJMfen’s murders have come out. "VpWhen a woman, feeble, was as sisted Into the witness box there was a craning of necHs in the court room, ror it was at once surmised that this was Mrs. Pltezel. Whether Holmes had schooled himself to face her. or whether the man really lacks sensibility, it was impossible to say, but as the woman stood erect be fore him he exhibited no emotion of any kind, but on the contrary gazed fixedly at her for fully a minute. As the woman came into the full light of the court room she plainly snowed mat she had borne a bur den of sorrows, troubles that have proven too heavy for her. Her skin was sallow and her face was heavy and lifeless. Above her sunken cheeks her lack-lustre eyes stared stead ily in front of her with a meaningless gaze. She more resembled a woman under the Influence of some strong drug that hgd dulled her senses, rather than one that is in full possession of her faculties. She sank into a chair and croughed there like an animal that stands in Mr of the lash. She was so weak that throffEliout the giv ing of her testimony the* court officers stood by her side and repWtted aloud her whispered replies to the qusstlorshjisked her. Only once throughou* J(he apd evening did she look in Homs’ direction. At the beginning of her testimony she was asked if she knew the* prisoahtt She cast one hurried glance in direction and then atilekly eyes replied that she dlt). It was a cdmfcv ing story of duplicity “ml she related to (he court. She was led somewhat hurriedly over the events prior to Bltezel’s death. Then, she told of Holmes coming to Tier and telling her that her husband still lived, but was in hiding for his connection with the swin dle of the insurance company. How he persuaded her to send her daughter Alice to identify the supposed body of her father, and returning to her home in St. Louis* extorted from her by sharp prac tices all but *SOO of the *9,760 she received in payment of her husband’s Insurance policy. She also told of the persuasions he used to secure possession of two of her other children whom he took away with him. It was from this period that Holmes’ cruel practices began. Yearning for a sight of her husband and children, Holmes led her from city to city with the illusive hope before her that she would soon meet her loved ones. So thoroughly w T as she under his influence that she gave him her letters to post to her husband and children and while her heart was breaking for word from her lit tel ones, he was carrying around In his pocket letters from them to her. Aftr tho death of the children. Holmes carried Ills deception so far as to bring to her a letter written in cipher and purporting to be from one of her little girls. He also worked this strategem In a letter alleging to be from her husband. Never once did he give her a hint that she would probably never see her hus band again, and he constantly told her that her children were-well and happy. Throughout this long recital, Mrs. Pietzel had borne up with fortitude, but when Mr. Oranam lasked her If she ever saw the children after she gave them into Holmes charge she gave way and sobbed quietly, but bitterly, before she could answer. Not a whisper was heard in the court room as the woman raised her head and, in a broken voice, replied: ”1 never saw my two little girls again until I saw’ them lying side by side in the morgue at Toronto, and I never saw Howard again, but was only shown some things that belonged to him in Indianap olis. Mrs. Pitezel’s testimony was most dam aging to Holmes and the cross examina tion by the counsel for the defense in no way served to help him. With the advent of his counsel into the case to day the current which was bearing Holmes swiftly away when he was alone, was slightly stemmed. Althought his two attorney’s have as yet decided up on no definite line of defense, they were better able to take advantage of tech nicalities that arose. Holmes himself was of great assistance to them, and suggested most of the questions that were asked the witnesses. The commonwealth to-day had Its wit nesses upon tlie stand to prove the con spiracy to swindle the Insurance compan ny, and tne consequent motive for the killing of Pltezel. When court adjourned to-night the prosecution had not offered all the testimony of this character and will have several witnesses to swear to these circumstances in the morning. The prosecution claims to have con vincing evidence to convict Holmes, and the district attorney and his assistant are satisfied that they will easily prove their case. The defense will ask of the court to morrow for a continuance for half a day or so in order to enable them to prepare their case.

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Kansas City Journal wryly notes that H. H. Holmes feels young Durrant has monopolized public attention too long, since Holmes's own crimes and bone exhibit entitle him to equal notice as his Philadelphia trial opens.

The Indianapolis Journal · 31 October 1895 · page 4

SHREDS AND PATCHES.

Entitled to Attention. Kansas City Journal. . . Without wishing to appear discourteous, Mr. H. H. Holmes would remind young Durrant that hi3 case has monopolized pub lic, attention for quite a while now, and that others havo rights which mugt be respect ed. Mr. Holmes naturally feels that the character and magnitude of the crimes with which he is charged, backed by an -traordlnarlly him to the most conspicuous rla.;e In tho public eye during the progress of the inter esting trial which has Ju3t opened at Phil large exhibit of bones, entity

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes is conducting his own defense and seeking a postponement, then recounts that on Sept. 3, 1894, a corpse known as B. F. Perry was found in a ramshackle building at 1013 Callowhill street.

Canton Weekly Register · 31 October 1895 · page 6

H H. HOLMES. to secure a postponement. Holmes is con ducting his own case. More than a year having passed since the discovery of the crime for which Holmes is now on trial, and so many conflicting tales have since been told, each outdoing the other in weirdness and atrocity, a relirersal of tho facts of this chapter of tho story is reve lant. On Sept. 3, 1894, the corpse of a man was found in tho second story of a ramshackle building at 1013 Callowhill street, this city. The dead man had been known as B. F. Perry.

See the clipping

Crittenden Press · Marion, Ky.

The trial of H. H. Holmes, accused of numerous murders, began in Philadelphia on Monday. After failing to secure a continuance, his lawyers withdrew from the case, leaving Holmes to act as his own counsel.

Crittenden Press · 31 October 1895 · page 2

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Crittenden Press · Marion, Ky.

The clipping, a fragment, reports that the trial of H. H. Holmes, accused of many murders, began in Philadelphia on Monday, and notes he could not get a continuance, before cutting off mid-sentence.

Crittenden Press · 31 October 1895 · page 5

Tho trial of H H Holmes the mau accused cf so many murders was be gun In Philadelphia Monday Because he could not get a continuance his

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · and 1 other paper

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's murder trial began in Philadelphia, with defense counsel's request for a continuance denied by Judge Arnold, leading to tense exchanges before jury selection began and Holmes rose to address the judge.

The Princeton Union · 31 October 1895 · page 3

HOLMES ON TRIAL. THE FIRST DAY'S PROCEEDINGS RESULT IN A SENSATION.

Philadelphia, Oct. 30. H. H. Holmes, who, according to his own remarkable confessious. stands at the head of the list of modern criminals, was put on trial in the court of oyer and terminer for the murder of Ben jamin F. Pietzel. Arraigned against him as the commonwealth's prosecu tors are District Attorney George S. Graham and his special assistant, T. W. Barlow, while the counsel for the prisouer were William A. Shoemaker aud Samuel P. Rotan, young members of the junior bar of this city. Judge Michael Arnold is upon the bench.

See moreSee less

Holmes was brought in and placed in the the dock. He looked pale and wan. but neat. He was plainly ner vous and looked about the room with a shifty expression in his steelly-blue ejes. Occasionally he would lean for ward aud address a whispered word to ins counsel. Mr. Shoemaker, of counsel for defense, did not come into court until a quarter of an hour after court comened. Mr. Graham, for the prosecution, instantly asked that the tase proceed. Holmes was then or dered to rise and he was foimally told of his right to challenge jurors. Mr. Sluemaker asked for a continu ance of me case. He urged the lack of time tor the preparation of the de fence. 'There are three homicide cases iu vohed in this case," he urged, "and we ha\e had only as much time as would be adequate preparation on one.*' It was expected to present newly discovered evidence of such vital im poitaiue that Holmes would undoubt edly be acquitted of this charge. Mr. Giaham protested against the grant ing of a continuance, which, he said, would mean the absolute destruction of the commonwealth's cas\ Mr. Giaham dwelt upon the severe strain under which Mis. Pietzel had been put. and ,aid an examination into her mental condition made it apparent that weie a continuance granted the con.moi'wealth would lose its most im portant witness. Mr. Rotan, for the defence, lerewed the plea for a res pite, but it was overruled by Judge Arnold. Mr Shoemaker and Mr. Rotan cre ated a mild sensation by saying that If the judge's decision was irrevoca ble they would withdraw from the case, but Judge Arnold spoiled this by declaung that a member of the bar who would withdraw from a murder case on the er e^e of its trial would bo (ailed upon to show cause why he should not be disbaned for unprofes sional conduct. Counsel did not ap pear anxious to accept this alterna the. but before they could reply Mr. Giaham arose. "As lar as the plea of lack of money is concerned," he said, "I have posi tive knowledge that large sums of inonej weie offered within the last week to prominent attorneys at this bar to come in as associate counsel in this ca^e. showing that there are suf ficient tunds at hand." "Call a jury," sakl Judge Arnold. go o\ov until to-morrow morning V" pleaded Mr. Rotan. nold lirmly, and the calling began. One juror had been admitted by the commonwealth when theie was an other sensation. Holmes arose in the dock and, in a quhering voice said to Judge Arnold: in( lination to continue with the trial of this case with Mr. Rotan and Mr. Shoemaker as my counsel, feeling that, in -\iew of their desiie to with diaw, my interests would be dam aged. I theiefore discharge them as my counsel." Holmes." answered Judge Arnold. "That is for the court, and if they withdiaw fiom this case they will be ptur.shed." ti emulous, "if your honor will give me until to-moirovv to secure addiiional counsel" Holmesthe matter is decided." ceeded, when Shoemaker again aicse and stated that the prisoner absolute ly 1 ibade them from representing him in the case, and declared that he (Holmes) would examine the jurors and witnesses himself. Holmes to question the jurors if he so desired while counsel considered the question of their proceeding. Holmes armed himself with pencil and paper, and Enoch Turner, the first juror, was turned over to him for examination. He had already stated, in answer to Mr. Graham, that he had formed an opinion on the case, but he could nev ertheless try it according to the evi dence. nueiy: "Mr. Turner, are jou a mar ried man'' Aie you physically well? Are yott in condition to serve in this case without delaying it." took up the question of having formed an opinion, and challenged peremptor ily. giocer, had formed no opinion, and was accepted, both by Mr. Graham and by Holmes Shoemaker arose and declared that (hey felt obliged to withdraw from the case, regardless of consequences. then." said the judge, but the two law era without further ado left the court room. Still determined, howev er, to have no delay, the common wealth's officers, consulted with the judge, and tliiy,'. called upon Kverett M. Schdfield d*nd J. A. Fahey. young members of the bar, who agreed to as sume the grave responsibility, with all aid possible from Mr Graham. knew nothing ot these gentlemen, he did not care to entrust his life to them. con eir.ed," he added, with unveiled Creates a Scene. "Will your honor allow the case to "Call a jury," le echoed Judge Ar "May it please the con it. I have no "You cannot dircharge them, Mr. "It." continued Holmes, his tone still "We will have no more debate, Mr. rl pr. examination of jurors then pro Judge Arnold said he would permit Snprlslns Queries. Holmes began with the surprising Receiving satisfactory answers, he The next man, Frederick Slump, Sr.. At this juncture Messrs. Rotan and ""ion must take the consequences Holmes, however, objected that as he "As far as aid from Mr Graham is

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 8 November 1895

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.

This fragment describes the prosecution asking the case proceed, Holmes rising to be formally informed of his right to challenge jurors, and Mr. Sluemaker requesting a continuance.

The Princeton Union · 31 October 1895 · page 3

RESULT IN A SENSATION.

prosecution, instantly asked that the tase proceed. Holmes was then or dered to rise and he was foimally told of his right to challenge jurors. Mr. Sluemaker asked for a continu

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

This damaged clipping mixes a report of Mrs. Pitezel's completed court testimony with disjointed mentions of a Venezuela ultimatum, Bannock Indian treaty rights, and a bank robbery netting $10,000 to $12,000 in paper and gold.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 31 October 1895 · page 1

however, sustained hisline of questioning. The Uruan incident referred to by Mr. This concluded Mrs. Pitezel's direct Lees was that upon which the reported i RN testimeny, which had consumed 2 hours British ultimatum to Venezuela was that any man, however earnest and em The attorney general of the United pletely wrecking the safe. The booty se inent, had thought it worth while to add cured amounted to between SIO,OOO and Btates decided that the treaty rights of the to the difficulties with which the nations Bannock Indians were superior to the $12,000 in paper and gold. The bank ig

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

The clipping, interrupted by an unrelated medicine advertisement, describes Holmes' gaunt, pale appearance in the dock since his arrest and notes the judge barred him writing materials before he was returned to prison to prepare his defense.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 31 October 1895 · page 6

THE HOLMES TRIAL. THE PRISONER ACTS AS HIS OWN ATTORNEY.

Holmes’ Marvelous Display of Nerve. relief—it cures. It is not a false stirnu- < Holmes, who at the time of his arrest lant to the stomach, nor a violent pur gative to the bowels. Its action is < in Boston on Nov. 17 last was a stoekily quick, natural and easy. bnilt man of middle height* has since his It promotes digestion and aids as long confinement grown gaunt and hollow similation. Stops heartburn, pal pita tion, flatulence and other symptoms. * chested. The prison bleach has brought Is soothing in its effect on the nerves his peaked face to a deathlike pallor, —cures hypochondria, hysteria, heightened by the dark, closely cropped neuralgia.

See moreSee less

Relief comes quickly and certainly. I beard. In appearance as ho sat in the dock he was neatuess itself. The beard I tujiity to speak to her in my office, but \ she shunned you. ’ ’ The judge informed the prisoner that j he would 'uo allowed writing material in his call. The court was then adjourned, the 1 jurors locked in their rooms under careful : guard, and the man who is accused of be ing the greatest criminal of modern times was conveyed back to prison t.o prepare the story which he hopes will save him

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

The clipping is a fragment describing Holmes, arrested in Boston on Nov. 17 last as a stockily built man of middle height, but breaks off before explaining the change since then.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 31 October 1895 · page 6

Holmes’ Marvelous Display of Nerve. Holmes, who at the time of his arrest in Boston on Nov. 17 last was a stoekily bnilt man of middle height* has since his

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudgett, known as H. H. Holmes, went on trial in Philadelphia before Judge Arnold for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, with named prosecutors and defense attorneys, and notes he is also accused of other murders.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 31 October 1895 · page 8

TRIAL OF THE GREAT MURDER MYSTERY BEGUN IN PHILADELPHIA

PHILADELPHIA, Oot. 39.—Herman W. Hudgett, better known as H. H. Holmes, Iho self confessed life Insurance swindler ind alleged multimurderer, whose suppos ed orimes have been a topic for general discussion for the past several months, was placed on trial today in the oourt of oyer and terminer on the charge of having murdered Benjamin F. Pitezel. Judge Arnold presided. The commonwealth was represented by District Attorney George L. Graham and Assistant District Attorney Thomas W. Barlow. The defense was conducted by W. H. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan. In addition to the murder of Pitezel the prisoner is also accused of the murder at Toronto of Pitezel’s two young daughters, Alice and Nellie; of the murder at Irving

See the clipping

Bridgeton Pioneer · Bridgeton, N.J.

The clipping recounts how Pitezel's supposedly accidental death was later deemed murder by insurers, leading to Holmes's conspiracy guilty plea and arraignment, as his murder trial formally opens before Judge Arnold.

Bridgeton Pioneer · 31 October 1895 · page 8

H. H. HOLMES

ton, Ind., of the young son, Howard Pitezel, and also of the murder of various other persons in the famous Holmes cas tle at Chicago. Benjamin F. Pitezel’s body was found in a house at 1316 Callowhill street on Sept. 3, 1894. A shattered lamp was found by the side of the body, which bore evidence of having been burned, and the coroner’s jury concluded that the oil lamp had exploded, and that Pitezel, who was at the time known as B. F. Perry, had been burned to death and accordingly ren dered a verdict of accidental death.

See moreSee less

There was no claimant for the body, and it was buried in the potters’ field. Subse quently an assertion oame from Pitezel’s lawyer at St. Louis, Mr. JephthaHowe, that the body was that of Benjamin F. Pitezel, and a claim was made on the Fi delity Mutual Life association of Philadel phia for <10,000 which that company car ried on Pitezel’s life. Inanranoe Companies Skeptical* The body was exhumed and was fully Identified by his daughter, who was brought from St. Louis, as that of Pitezel. The InBuranoe companies, however, were not satisfied that Pitezel had met his death aooldentally, and at once plaoed detectives on the oase to solve the mystery. This re sulted in the arrest at Boston of Mudgett, alias Holmes. He was brought here and was placed on trial, charged with conspiracy to defraud the insurance companies. Holmes pleaded guilty to this charge, but to combat the more serious charge of murder asserted that Pitezel was still living, and that a body was obtained from a New York dissect ing room and plaoed in the building on Callowhill street. After burning the skin slightly and throwing a lamp on the floor Holmes said that he and Pitezel left the olty and sub sequently informed Mrs. Pitezel that the body was that of her missing husband and had her press for olalm for the insuranoe. Holmes was sent to prison to await sen tence on the conspiracy trial and Distrlot Attorney Graham started Detective Geyer out to visit Toronto, Chioago and other western oities to endeavor to obtain evi dence against Holmes whioh would War rant his being arraigned for murder. Deteotive Geyer succeeded in finding the bodies of the children. Other facts which he gleaned satisfied District Attorney Graham that Holmes could be oonvicted of the murds# of Pitezel. Detective Geyer also brought Mrs. Pite zel and others from various parts of the west and Canada to this city to take the stand as witnesses against Holmes. Promptly at 10 o’clock today the dis mal and unmeaning “Oyez, oyez” was pronounced by the crier, and as every per son present arose court was formally de clared open. Judge Arnold, clad in his long black gown, the wearing of which is a new departure with the Philadelphia judioiary, was in his scat on the bench. Crier Hart immediately began the calling of the panel of jurors. A moment later the iron door of the large cage leading from the cellroom clanged, and Holmes was brought in by a H. H. HOLMES A Day of Sensations.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A damaged fragment reports that Mrs Pletzel, questioned for several hours, took the stand to tell what she knew about the case, marking her first face-to-face encounter with Holmes since her revelations.

The Sun · 31 October 1895 · page 5

TO FIND HER HUSBAND

swindler Is accused of murdering went on the stand In tho trial today to tel what she knew I of the cane Bhe was questioned for three hour this afternoon and one this evening Mrs Pletzel and Holmes have not ben face to face until today since tho revelations of her

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The clipping describes a visibly weak, dazed female witness whose whispered testimony had to be repeated by court officers, and who looked toward Holmes only once during the proceedings.

The Sun · 31 October 1895 · page 5

and her face was heavy and lifeless Above her sunken cheeks her eyes stared steadily In front of her with a meaningless traze She more resembled a woman under the Influence nf tome strong drug than one In full possession of her faculties Bhe sunk Into n chair Shu waa so weak thnt throughout her testimony court officers stood by her side and repeated aloud her whispered replies to the questions asked her Only once throughout the day and evening did she look In Holmes direction At the beginning I Iaz

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The clipping reports that Holmes's two attorneys, aided by his own suggestions, began countering the prosecution's momentum, and that a witness from the Fidelity Mutual Life Association, swindled out of $10,000, identified an insurance document.

The Sun · 31 October 1895 · page 5

to Holmes and the crossexamination by the cnnniel for the defence In no way served t help him With the advent of hU counsel Into the CA today the current which was bearing Holmes swiftly away when he was alone was Ightly stemmed Although hla two attorneys have aa yet de cided upon no definite line of defence they wee better able to take advantage of techni calities that are Holme himself was of great assistance to them and suggested most of the questions that were asked the witnesses The first really Important witness of the day was C La Forrest Pry assistant to the Presi dent of the Fidelity Mutual Life Association the company which Holmes swindled out of 110000 Identified the Insurance

See the clipping

The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or.

The Philadelphia report states H. H. Holmes, alias Herman Mudgett, pleads not guilty and goes on trial tomorrow for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, with witnesses gathered from several cities and sensational developments expected.

The Corvallis Gazette · 31 October 1895 · page 1

HOLMES TO BE TRIED. The Prosecution a Profound Secret, but Sensational Developments Expected., Philadelphia; Oct. 29. H. ; H. Holmes,- or Herman Mudgett, whose name or alias, has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times,, will be placed on trial for his life tomorrow in the court of oyer and terminer, of this city. The specified charge to which he will be called upon to answer is the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, and he has already, officially declared himself not guilty.

See moreSee less

The revolting details of the many crimes with which Holmes' name has been directly - or indirectly connected have4een' grVea much pub licity, ' and . the cold,! implacable de meanor which has .' characterized the man throughout has been so frequently commented upon that the trial will probably pass into history as the most celebrated case known to the criminal annals of the Western hemisphere. The-' commonwealth has already ex pended thousands of dollars in its efforts to bring the' prisoner to sum mary justice,' and there is an indica tion that if a conviction of murder in the first degree be obtained he will be quickly "railroaded" to the gallows. Witnesses have been : brought ' to this city from Boston, Chicago, Indianapo lis, Irvington, Ind., and almost every city where Holmes is:. known to have lived at various times. What revela tions these witnesses will make has been kept a profound - secret by the prosecuting officers, but there is expec tation of sensational developments. .

See the clipping

Butler Citizen · Butler, Pa.

H. H. Holmes went on trial for the murder of Benjamin F. Petzel, briefly acting as his own counsel before recalling his attorneys, while separately the Republican National Committee was deciding the timing of its next convention.

Butler Citizen · 31 October 1895 · page 2

H. H HOLMES, or Herman Mudgett, wtto&e name or alias has rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times, was placed on trial in the court of Oyer and Terminer of Philadelphia, Monday. The specific charge to which he is called to answer is the murder of Benjamin F. Petzel, and he has already officially declared himself not gnilty. Holmes created a sensation in Court Monday by discharging his attorneys and conducting his case himself. A Jury was selected. Tuesday, he weaken ed and sent for his attorneys who came back to him; and considerable evidence was taken.

See moreSee less

• On Wednesday the case was continued, Holmes taking the lead on his side. Mrs. Pietzel told the remarkable and horrible story of the disappearence of her family, and of her finding their bodies at the morgue. THE Republican National Committer will shortly decide the time and place for holding the next National Convention. Chairman Carter, who was in Washing ton lately said that he had asked the opinion of every meml>er of the Commit tee by letter, and has had personal con ferences with a number of them. It is an inviolable rule that tie Committee meeting which decides the time and place for the Convention must be held six months previous to the date upon which the Convention meets. There is a diifer ence of opinion, both in and out of the Committee, as to whether the Convention should be as early as May, or whether it Rhould be held after the Democratic Con vention; —in words, whether the Presidential campaign shall be a long or a short one. Tludecision lies entirely with .he National Committee, although the action of its members will, of course, be largely influenced by the opinion of other leading Republicans. Should a majority of the Committee indicate their preference for holding the Convention in May, the Committee meeting will have to lie held sometime next month.

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

This damaged clipping contains fragments of several unrelated items, including a court continuance request, stolen ducks, a diphtheria concern, a returning traveler, and a broken screen shaft.

Freeland Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 1

ACTING FOR HIMSELF

stolen wire 011 it. to the danger of an epidemic of diph placed in the dock and Judge Arnold had "wild"' ducks which were shot that taken his seat upon the bench Holmes' theria being produced in tin; borough, morning. There he found eleven of the two attorneys asked for a continuance of driven away, and has engaged a Wilkcs it was decided that the secretary write company's birds, but lie had not the the case. This request was refused, as Michael Ward returned homo last night j prices, hut prices equally as after a month's stay in Connecticut. Dr. N. MALEY, Mr. Thorpe does not intend to be | reasonable. The screen shaft broke yesterday at ;

See the clipping

Freeland Tribune · Freeland, Pa.

At Holmes's Philadelphia murder trial for the killing of Benjamin F. Peitzel, his two attorneys withdrew after a continuance was denied, prompting Holmes to reject court-appointed counsel and conduct his own defense, including jury challenges.

Freeland Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 1

ACTING FOR HIMSELF

Philadelphia, Oct. 29.—Herman W. Mirdgett, alias H. H. Holmes, was ar raigned at the bar of justice of the crimi ual court of Philadelphia yesterday to defend his life against the charge of hav ing murdered Beujumiu F. Peitzel in this city on September 2, 1894. The widespread" publicity giveu this sensa tional case attracted a great throng of people to tho corridors of the city ball leading to the court room, but in antici pat ion of the crowd of morbid people who : were attracted by the spectacle of a man battling fos bis life, cordons of police guarded all the entrances and only those having business in the court room were admitted.

See moreSee less

The very opeuiugof the trial furnished an unusual incident in court procedure and was in keeping with the strange phases that have made this case unique in the criminal records of the country. His Lawyers Drop tlio Case. Directly after the prisoner had been placed in the dock and Judge Arnold had taken his seat upon the bench Holmes' two attorneys asked for a continuance of the case. This request was refused, as there had already been more than enough of the law's proverbial delay and Judge Arnold ordered the trial proceeded with. Then the defendant's lawyers announced they would withdraw from tho case. The judge expressed his surprise at such un precedented action at the beginning of a murder trial, and told the two attorneys that if they withdrew they placed themselves in jeopardy of being dis barred. Nevertheless, with tho prospect of disbarment before them, the two lawyers persisted in their refusal to con duct tho case and left the court room. Holmes Addresses tlio Court. The court thereupon appointed two attorneys the prisoner's de fense. Although accused of crimes that would revolt a barbarous savage, there was something pathetic in tho picture made by Holmes at this point. Slender, erect and more youthful than his pictures make him appear, and with an added delicacy given his naturally clear cut. aud refined face, by his long confinement in prisou, Holmes rose to his feet and addressed the court. His voice was weak and quavering like that of a man 'who has been ill and hardly carried the short distance that separated him from the court. He announced that lie would not ac cept the lawyers appointed by the court and that he would conduct his own de fense. A hum of astonishment went around tlie court room, but, alone and without a friend by his side, his iron nerve bore him up under the trying or deal of the desertion of his counsel, exercised his right of challenge and be fore the jury was obtained eighteen men had been set aside by him. Holmes sat in the dock busily engaged takiug notes during his terrible arruignuient by tlio district attorney in his opening argu ment. Few Signs of Emotion. An occasional flush that suffused his check and ouce in a while a slight lift ing of the eyebrows when the district at torney became particularly earnest were the only marks of emotion exhibited by Holmes. When the district attorney had concluded his argument Holmes re quested that he tie allowed light and writing materials in his cell in the county prison. Asked To See His Wife. This was granted, and then Holmes asked to ho allowed to see his wife. A sharp interchange of dialogue occurred between the prisoner and the district at torney as to which wife he wanted to see, and finally Holmes was driven to say that it was the last woman who had married him. This woman has refused to see Holmes, but he obtained a prom ise from the court that a letter should be given her, and that if she would comply an answer to it should be sent to him from her. The court adjourned until morning. His Iron Nerve.

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

A frail, sorrow-worn Mrs. Pitezel testified for hours in court, recounting how the prisoner deceived her about her husband's fate and swindled her out of most of the insurance money, while he stared at her without emotion.

The Scranton Tribune · 31 October 1895 · page 1

AWFUL CRIMES OF HOLMES

Philadelphia, Oct. 30. Itranded though he Is as a liar, swindler and' murderer, the pictures drawn today of Holmes' cold-hearted villainy by Mrs. Pitezel. the widow of the man for whose murd;r he la being tried, presents him In even a more revolting charcater than he has yet stood revealed. Whatever sympathy might have been excited by Holmes' friendliness and forlorn condi tion was effectually killed In the breasts of all the hearers in the court room of Mrs. Pitezel's storv. She was placed upon the witness stand today and for three hours this afternoon and one hour tonight she was subjected to an ordeal that no woman In her condition had ever been called upon to face.

See moreSee less

Her story furnished the first really sensation al feature thc-t has yet been brought out. The whole scene and the events of the afternoon were intensely dra matic. Mrs. Pitezel and Holmes have never been brought face to face until today, since the dreadful revelations of her chlldrens' murders have come out. When a woman bent and feeble was assisted Into the witness box there was a craning of necks in the court room, for it was at once surmised that this was Mrs. Pitezel. Whether Holmes had schooled himsrxlf to face her, or whether the man really lacked sensibil ity, it was impossible to say, but as the woman stood erect before him he ex hibited no emotion of any kind, but, on the contrary, gazed fixedly at her for fully a minuto. As the woman came Into tho full light of the court room she plainly showed that she had borne a burden of sorrows, trouble that have proved too much for her. As One Hypnotized. Hor skin was sallow and her face was heavy and lifeless. Above her sunken cheeks her eyes stared steadily In front of iher with a meaningless gaze. She more resembled a woman under Influence of some strong drug that had dulled 'her senses rather than one 'that Is In full possesion of her faculties. She rank into a chair and crouched there like an animal that stands in fear of the lah. She was to weak that, throughout tire giving of her testimony, the court olticors ktood by her itde and repeated alowl her whis pered replies to the questions asked her. Only once throughout the day and evening did the look in Holmes' direc tion. At the beginning of her testi mony he was asked If she knew 'the prisoner. She cast one hurried glance In his direction and then quickly avert ing her eyes replied 'that she did. It was a damning story of duplicity and knavery that she related to the court. She was led somewhat hurriedly over the events prior to FCtezel's death. Then she told of Holmes coming to her nr.d telling her that iher husband dill lived, but was 'In hiding for his con nection with the swindle of the In surance company. How he persuaded her 'to send her daughter, Alice, to identify the supposed body of her father returning to her home In St. Louis extorted from her by nharp prac tices all but $500 of the $9,700 she re ceived In payment of her husband's in surance poKcy; of the persuasions he used to secure possession of two of her other children, whom he took away with him. . . , It was from this period on that Holmes' cruel practices began. Team ing for a sight of her husband and children, (Holmes led her 'from city to city with the Illusive hope before her that she would soon meet her loved ones. So thoroughly was she under his Influence that she gave him her letters to post to her husband and children, and, while her heart was breaking for word from her little ones, he was carry ing around In his pocket letters from them to her. Deception of Holmes. After the death of the children Holmes carried his deception so far as to ;brln her a letter written In cipher and purporting to be from one of her little girls. He also worked this strategm In a letter alleging to be from her hur.band. Never once did he give her a hint that she would probably nev?r see her husband again, and he constantly told her that her children were 'well and happy. Throughout, this long recital Mrs. Pitezel had 'borne up with fortitude, but when 'Mr. Oraham asked her If she ever sar,v the children . after she gave them Into Holmes' charge, she gave way and robbed quietly, but bit terly, before she could answer. Not a whisper was heard in the court room as the woman raised her head and In a broken voice replied: "I never eaw my two little girls again until I saw them lying side by side in the morgue at Toronto, and I never sn.w Howard again, but was only sht'jvn seme things that belonged to him In Indianapolis." Cross-Kxnmmation Unavailing. Mrs. Pitezel's testimony was most damaging to Holmes, and the cross-examination by the counsel for the de fense In no way served to help him. With the advent of his counsel Into the case today the current which was bear ing Holmes swiftly away when he was alone was slightly stemmed. Although his two attorneys have ns yet decid ed upon no definite line of defense they were better able to taike advantage of technicalities that arose. Holmes himself was cf great assistance to them, and suggested most of the ques tion that were atfccd the witnesses. The commonwepjHh today had Its witnesses upon the rtand to prove the conspiracy to swindle the Insurance company, and the consequent motive for the kllllmg of Pitezel. When couri adjourned tonight tho prose-eutlon had not offered all the tes timony of this character, and will have several witnesses to swear to these cir ecution claims to have convincing evi dence to convict Holmes, and the Dis trict attorney and his assistant are satisfied that they will easily prove their case. The defense will ask of the court tomorrow for a continuance for half a day or so In order to enable them to prepare their case. cumstances in the morning. The pros

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

On the third day of the Holmes trial, Mrs. Pitezel tearfully testified about losing contact with her husband and identifying her children's bodies. Her account of seeing her daughters' bodies in the Toronto morgue moved the courtroom, prompting a defense objection that the judge overruled.

The Providence News · 31 October 1895 · page 7

MRS. PIETZEL TESTIFIES.

Then Mr, Graham, in a solemn volee, asked: “Have you ever seen any of your three (zhlldun since you gave them to this man?’ Mrs. Pitezel replicd: “I have never seen my little girls except lying side by side in the morgue at ‘Toronto, and I have never scen Howard, but I saw some of his little things in the coroner’s office at Indian apolis.” There was more than one moistened eve in the court while the sobbing womr was speakinlg, and the defense, realizing the probable cffect of the incident upon the jury, interposed an objection, Mr. Graham was so vehement in his Indignant reply to the defense’s objection

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · and 1 other paper

The clipping, cut off almost immediately, reports from Philadelphia that it became apparent during the evening that the picturesque and startling features of the proceedings were proving a herculean task for a man identified as H. conducting his own defense.

The Madison Daily Leader · 31 October 1895 · page 2

TOO MUCH EVEN FOR HOLMES. Conducting Hla Own Defense Was a Herculean Tank. PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 81.—It became apparent during the evening that the picturesque and startling features of H.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 31 October 1895

Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.

The clipping reports that Holmes, also known as Herman Mudgett, will go on trial tomorrow in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin F. Pitezel, having pleaded not guilty.

Reporter and Farmer · 31 October 1895 · page 3

PITEZEL'S MURDER

Holmes Util be lUnccri on Tilal for Holmes, or Herman Mudgett, whose name or alias lias rung throughout the length and breadth of the continent as the most unscrupulous and skillful murderer of modern times, will lie placed on trial for his life to-morrow morning in the court of oyer and ter miner of this city. The specific charge to which he will he called upon to an swer is the murder of ltenjamin F. Peltzel, and he has already officially declared himself not guilty. The re volting details of the many crimes with which Holmes’ name has been PIET*EL'S MURDER. Hl* Life To-Duy. Philadelphia, Oct. 29. H. H.

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

The clipping describes a chaotic trial opening in which a continuance was denied, defense lawyers withdrew under threat of disbarment, the prisoner rejected court-appointed counsel, and he ultimately argued his own case amid a crowd kept back by police.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 31 October 1895 · page 5

tion. From the nature of the case and the startling stories concerning it, which have gained currency during the past year; sensational developments were nat urally to be expected when he who haB come to be regarded as the most skillful and audacious criminal of modern times was placed on trial for his life. Yet what did occur in court so far surpassed all expectations that the most vivid flights of imagination could scarcely have I , conceived the day s events. J J Protestations and entreaties for a coni-Mlnuance of the trial summarily over ruled, sudden withdrawal of the lawyers who had hitherto represented the prisoner in the face of threats of disbarment, the appointment by the court of new counsel and the refusal of the prisoner to accept them as his defenders, the declination of another lawyer after being selected by Holmes, and finally the prisoner trying his own case.

See moreSee less

This, not to speak of sun dry dramatic passages at arms between Holmes and the commonwealth's prose cuting office is a summary of what oc curred. Long before 10 o'clock, the hour set for the opening of court, an eager crowd thronged the corridors without. n-i. i : !,. ever, that none but lawyers, witnesses, jurors and newspaper reporters were per mitted to pass the cordon of police, which

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

The clipping describes Holmes's murder trial opening in a packed Philadelphia courtroom, with Judge Arnold presiding, District Attorney Graham prosecuting, and defense lawyers Shoemaker and Rotan unsuccessfully seeking a continuance before threatening to withdraw.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 31 October 1895 · page 5

mitted to pass the cordon of police, which r formed a barrier across the entrance to the particular corridor leading to the f court room, and the force of court offi cers, who guarded every entrance to tne room. This prevented undue crowding, although every seat in the big room was occupied. The general public will be ad mitted to the capacity of the gallery, which will seat about 500, when the tak ing of testimony is begun tomorrow. kThe clocks of the town had scarcely l . . 1 H l 1 T l A 1.1 ceasea Binning wncu juugu Aruuiu, clad in the long black gown which was recently adopted by the Philadelphia juHintnrv.

See moreSee less

Antprerl atiH took his seat unnn V the bench. ff. District Attorney Goo. S. Graham and his special assistant, Mr. Barlo, in whom the prosecution is vested, was already in court, but a delay of 15 minutes was oc casioned by the non-appearance of coun sel for the defense, Wm. A. Shoemaker and Samuel P. Rotan, young members of the bar. During the wait HolmesJ who had been i' the van. guarded even inside the closed wagor. by an officer, was placed in the 'small dock. Holmes, who at the time of his arrest in Boston on November 17, last, was a sturdy built man of middle height, has, J and hollow chested. The prison bleach lias Drougnt nis peaitea iace to a aeatniiKe pallor, heightened by the closely cropped beard. In appearance, as he sat in the dock today, hewas neatness itself. The beard was carefully trimmed, the hair smoothly parted and the black cheviot suit he wore betrayed no spot or blemish. His demeanor throughout, save on one or two occasions, when he gave way to slight bursts of anger directed at the dis trict attorney, was characterized by that marvelous display of nerve which has be come associated with his name. The original intention of the common-' wealth was to hold three sessions of court daily morning, afternoon and night, but so much time was consumed by the unexpected developments that it was nearly 5 when District Attorney Graham concluded his opening address to the jury. In view of this, and to avoid breaking the testimony of the first wit ness by the supper recess, it was decided to adjourn until tomorrow morning. Hereafter, however, the original program will be followed. Philadelphia, Oct. 28. Holmes was brought into the dock at 10 o'clock, his counsel entering the court room with the prisoner. Mr. Shoniaker asked for a con tinuance of the case, urging lack of time for the preparation of the defense. Mr. Graham, for the prosecution, protested against the granting of a continuance which he said would mean the absolute destruction of the commonwealth's case. Mr. Rotan for the defense renewed the plea foi a respite, but it was overruled V-vcr Tn J tm A fnn1t -Mr. Shoemaker and Mr. Rotan created . a mild sensation by Baying that if the I judge's decision was irrevocable they 5 would withdraw from the case, but Judge ( Arnold spoiled this by declaring that a 'Vjraember of the bar who would withdraw from a murded case on the very eve of its trial would be called upon to show cause why he should not be disbarred for un professional conduct. Counsel did not appear anxious to accept this alternative, V but before they could reply Mr. Graham f arose and said: ' t "As far as the plea for lack of money i is concerned, I have positive knowledge of where large sums of money have been I .offered to attorneys to come into the case as associate counsel ior me ueieuse,

See the clipping

The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.

The clipping describes the district attorney's address at Holmes' trial, Holmes' subsequent request for writing privileges in his cell, and includes an unrelated cotton market letter with price and stock figures.

The Austin Weekly Statesman · 31 October 1895 · page 5

ramifications at considerable length. He pursued the history of Holmes' various movements, the disappearance of the Pietzel children and the many conflicting stories told by Holmes, all of which had been fully published. Throughout the district attorney's ad dress Holmes sat with his legs crossed, taking copious notes and listening with in tent interest, but without a shade of ex pression even when Mr. Graham's reso nant voice rang out in the most scathing denunciation. When District Attorney Graham con cluded it was decided to adjourn court until 10 o'clock tomorrow morning.

See moreSee less

When this became known to Holmes he arose in the dock and the last sensation of a day replete with extraordinary events oc curred. "May it please your honor," he began, his weak voice vibrating with the emo tion which his wonderful self control pre vented from betraying in his face, "I am forced to ask that certain privileges be accorded me in prison. They are not very extensive privileges. I ask that the district attorney allow me to have in my cell light, paper and writing materials that I may be enabled to prepare my case. I shall also ask the privilege of sending, or having some one connected with the court sent to Fort Worth, Tex., o O'DELL & CO.'S LETTER. (By private wire to AuBtin Cotton Ex change.) NPW York, Opt Oft Kntlin,.n aAxtinn show that weather during the past week was favorable for outdoor work and in a measure accounts fnr flip lihernl mnva. ment of cotton. The amount which Cflme into niirht dnrintr uronlr wna 493 - 000; last year, 523,429. Total now i'n signt, i,tf4u,4au, against Z,3ti7,U37 last year. Total visible, 3,128,455. against rotai American, 2,H4,r)5, nCflinRt 2 fitVi 113 Tntnrinr itonbi S')ti - 574, against 274,205. Stock in United States ports, 889,098, ngainst 704,918 Stock in New York, 149,087, against 64,285. An advance of 2-04 in Liverpool was not regaruea as sumcient uy tne lo cal talent nnrl mmtntimiR nnetiori ilnwn 12 points with market easy, but it soon Nirt-ugim-iiL"u anu auvancea to almost tne highest price of yesterday. The close Wflfl niuet ntlfl nliAU-n n nn-f Inaa ftt lin day of 7 points, or 8.51 for January. One ruvoruiuie icaiure noticeauie is tne ten dency to widen the difference between prices here and New Orleans. At our close it amounted to 10 points. Trans actions today amounted to 141,300. o AT ATLANTA.

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A frail, sorrow-worn Mrs. Pitezel testified for four hours, her whispered answers repeated aloud by court officers, describing how the prisoner deceived her about her husband's death and extorted insurance money before taking two of her children away.

Alexandria Gazette · 31 October 1895 · page 1

Mrs. Pitezel and Holmes were never brought face to face until yesterday since the dreadful revelations of her children's murders have come out. When a woman, bent and feeble, was arsisted into the witness box there was a craning of necks in the court room, for it was at once surmised that this was Mrs. Pitezel. Whether Holmes had schooled himself to face her, or whether the man really lacked sensibili?

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

On the fourth day of the Holmes trial, a Fort Worth lawyer identified Holmes regarding a $16,000 note, and Georgianna Yoke testified about knowing him under aliases and a Sunday night visitor later said to be Pitezel.

Alexandria Gazette · 31 October 1895 · page 2

The Holmes Trial. Philadelphia, Oct. 31.?The fourth day of the Holmes trial opened this morning. When placed in the dock be scanned a letter and that the man is not wholly nerveless was shown by the way the paper shook in his hand. While waiting for the district attorney Holmes passed the interval by consult? ing with his counsel and chatting and laughing with the court officers. Sidney L. Samuels, a Fort Worth, Texas, lawyer, was the first witness. He was shown the note for $16,000 signed by Pitezel under the name of Benton T.

See moreSee less

Lyman and to take up which Holmes got the $5,000 from Mrs. Pitezel. He identified Holmes "as the individual in the case there who I knew under the name of Pratt." A letter from Holmes to the woman in Wilamette in which he speaks of their marriage was read to the jury. Just after this Holmes gave way and wept. A fair, bloud-haired girl was led toward the witness stand. When Holmes saw her he started and grew deathly pale. He beckoned eager? ly to his attorneys and with tears run? ning dowu bis cheeks talked with great earnestness to them. The wit? ness gave her name as Georgianna Yoke. It was the girl whom he mar lie under the name of H. M. Howard. Holmes urged his lawyers to use every means in their power to prevent the witness from testifying but their efforts were useless. Miss York testified that she knew the prisoner under the names of Holmes and Howard. She met bim in St. Louis and while he was in jail en? gaged Thomas B. Harvey and Howe as lawyers to defend him. She said she was in Philadelphia with him in 1S94 and she remembered a man calling to see Holmes on Sunday night, Sept 1. Tnisman, Holmes has since told her, was Pitezel. Holmes said at the time that be had an engagement with the man the next day. Prospects of a Fight.

See the clipping

Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.

This damaged fragment lists meat and poultry prices per pound alongside garbled brief notices mentioning smallpox, a murder case, quarantine on Mexican cattle, a land suit, and the trial of H. H. Holmes beginning.

Burlington Weekly Free Press · 31 October 1895 · page 3

per lb.; pork, dressed, 6 1-2 to Cc. ; lamb 11 to 12c; mutton, 9c; fowls, nllvc, 9 to 10c; dressed, 14c; chickens. 15c per pound, alive; turkeys, 13c dressed. potted In hlrypt Smallpox broke out ' murder cas? at Waterhury, Cunn., di-apagain at Wliceliiiif Arizona raised tho pnar Trial of H. H. Holmes begun at qu iianlluo on Mexican catflo Tlires Pliiladelphln 1,-tnd suit lu West Vir

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

The fragment reports that Holmes's lawyers have withdrawn and he refuses new ones, and that a Brockton preacher delivered an address at the City theater criticizing authorities for alleged indifference, though the text is cut off before further details.

Herald and News · 31 October 1895 · page 5

HIS OWN COUNSEL

Holmes Lawyers Withdraw and He Refuses New Ones. Brockton Preacher Arraigns Aotllnrltles. For Alleged Indifference. Brockton, Ma.. Oct, i ft'V. ft A. Wnrfleld delivered an address at the City theater last evening, at the invitation of

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

This damaged, fragmentary clipping jumbles a reference to the murder of Benjamin E. Pitzel, a legal Order of Publication notice, and a prediction of future conflict involving British interests and Russia as an ally, making a coherent summary impossible.

Herald and News · 31 October 1895 · page 5

upon to wcr is the murder oi Benjam inevitable. It will arise on acE. PitzeT and he has V,",mlym.L1,1f count of British disregard for our direct i i r nnr. itiiiiiv. i im inuiir i ... . t . i v. uitiuh ing details of the many crimes with which Order of Publication. Holmes' name has Been oirecny or mm reetly connected have been given such pub vs. In Chancery, licity, and tho cold, implacable demeanor .,.!.. I. ,.l,nntarlil tllH IIIHII tlirOUShWUH:o i;u.v"lv' Interests. It will also be forced by British ......

See moreSee less

r? . encroachments upon other nationsau over the world. It will be fought by ua, hiiv ina Russia ns our European ally. As a war onensive on our ymr im uij not happen within 20 years. As a do

See the clipping

Herald and News · West Randolph, Vt.

This fragment is too damaged by OCR errors to make out a clear narrative, but it references Mudgett, also known as H. H. Holmes, and Mary, the 12-year-old daughter of John F. Brennan.

Herald and News · 31 October 1895 · page 5

A Day of Sensations

Mudgett, better known as H. H. Holmes. .,. . ifnnimcii 1 1 f b linnrftnoe swinT not. 9ft Marv. the JTJ I u i t - - 12 year-old daughter of John F. Brennan.

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

The clipping recounts how a $10,000 life insurance policy on Benjamin F. Pietzel led to a charred body being identified as his, a claim paid to a lawyer, and Holmes' subsequent arrest on suspicion of murder and conspiracy.

Wood County Reporter · 31 October 1895 · page 2

the nation, would fluid in Holmes’ case a confirmation of his theory. Here is 'the story from ithe start: In July of last year a policy of in surance for SIO,OOO on the life of Benjamin F. Pietzel was issued by the Fidelity Mutual Life association of this city. In September, 1594, the charred corpse of a man was found in the house, No. 1310 Callowihlll street, in which 'there had been a lire, following’ an explosion of some chemi cal. The Ca.llowhiill street house had been rented by a mam giving ills name as B.

See moreSee less

F. Perry, and 'the body found was supposed to be his. Subsequent ly, however, a claim was made ou the Fidelity company tor the insurance of Pietzel's life, and it was palid to Jeiptha Howe, a St. Louis lawyer, who with Pletzel’s 13-year-old daugh ter, Ailice, and Holmes, came to this duty and fully and positively identi fied the body as that of Pietzel. The ablest detectives in the country were put on the case by the insurance com pany, and in November Holmes was arrested in the mine city a day or two later, and Lawyer Howe was taken Into custody in St. Louis. The charge as first referred was one of conspir acy to defraud the insurance com pany, but the more serious one of mur der was soon laid against Holmes. The country was searched fora trace of Pietzel, who was believed to have been a party to the conspiracy. Holmes, in one of his stories, declared that he and Pietzel had bought a corpse in New York, shipped it to the Caillowh.il 1 street house and started tlhe fire. He persisted that Pietzel was still alive and would be produced at the proper time. All the clues were carefully worked out, however, and it is now generally believed that the body was that of Pietzel, and that Holmes killed him, Mrs. Pietzel says that last July her husband left her in St. Louis and went to Chicago. From there he wrote that he was going to Philadelphia, and from this city he wrote several letters, saying that he had established

See the clipping

Grant County Herald · Lancaster, Wis.

On the trial's second day, with a smaller crowd barred from the courtroom, prosecutors began proving Pitzel's identity and cause of death while Holmes worked through the night writing legal papers, slept only an hour, and had the dock moved closer to the bar.

Grant County Herald · 31 October 1895 · page 5

TRIAL OF H H. HOLMES. The Prisoner Puts in the Night Preparing Philadelphia, Oct. 29.—The second day of the Holmes trial did not attract nearly so great a crowd as the first day, as the public had learned it would not be ad mitted to the courtroom. The prosecu tion began its case by calling witnesses to prove the identity of Pitzel and the man ner of his death. Throughout the night in the loneliness of his cell in the county prison Holmes worked steadily preparing his case. He filled sheet after sheet of foolscap, and the watchers outside his cell door wondered when he would seek some rest.

See moreSee less

It was not until daybreak that he threw himself on his cot. He slept only an hour, and then was up again once more busy writing until told it was time to start for : court. Promptly at 10 o'clock the jury filed into the box. A moment after Holmes entered. He looked fresh and bright, and while waiting for the district attorney to come in he chatted with the court officers. In complance with Holmes’ request the dock was much nearer the bar. | The change was made that Holmes might' better hear the court and be heard. Remarkable Document Filed. llis Case.

See the clipping