As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

December 1895

76 articles

Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

This damaged clipping jumbles unrelated items—a unanimous re-election of a leader, remarks on Costa Rica's uncultivated land, condemnation of Abdul Hamid over Armenian killings, and a judge pronouncing a death sentence on a man called Holmes—without clear connection between them.

Birmingham State Herald · 1 December 1895 · page 1

HOLMES MUST HANG.

of the election of a chairman of the cau guide us, with full knowledge of his gel showed that of 31,000 square miles in cus. Mr. William A. Stone of Pennsyl capacity and ability, he was by unani Costa Rica only one-tenth was cultivated, vania, who has been the personal man mous action and by hearty acclamation though every foot was rich. The canal ager for McDowell and those associated again chosen our leader. murderers who are engaged in wiping 1868. He was again chosen in 1875 and Judge Arnold then pronounced the death out the Armenians there is no one who held the position uninterruptedly until a sentence.

See moreSee less

Holmes, who had been Is so brutal and criminal as this wretch. few weeks ago. when he resigned on ac brought Into court to hear the opinion, Abdul Hamid, whose very existence Is a count of continued 111 health. was not affected by the adverse opinion,

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A Philadelphia dispatch of November 30 reports that Holmes was that morning refused a new trial and must pay the death penalty for murdering Pitzel.

The San Francisco Call · 1 December 1895 · page 3

SENTENCED TO BE HANGED

SENTENCED TO ItE It AMi En. Holmes Must Pay the /tenth Penalty for Murdering Pitzel. PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Nov. 30.— H. H. Holmes was this morning refused a new

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

The Court of Oyer and Terminer denied Holmes a new trial in a lengthy opinion by Judge Arnold, after which the judge formally sentenced him to be hanged, and Holmes was returned to the County Prison under death watch pending the governor's setting of an execution date.

New-York Tribune · 1 December 1895 · page 1

ON THE MURDERER,

ing, in the Court of Oyer and Terminer, sentenced to be hanged. The opinion denying a new trial was delivered hy Judge Arnoid, it having been concurred in by Judges Thayer, Willson and Arnold, who heard the application for a new trial. Holmes was placed In the dock, and hig counsel, Messrs. Rotan and Shoemaker, took thelr ac customed places at the bar of the court, DistrictAttorney Graham, who secured the conviction of the prisoner, sat within the rail and beneath the bench where sat Judge Arneld, before whom Holmes was tried.

See moreSee less

Only once during the delivery of the long opinton did Holmes move in his seat, and then he leaned forward to catch the words of the Judge as he sald that It was “the unanimous opinion of the Court that the verdict of murder in the first degree is fully justified by the evidence.” The opinion coverad thirty-seven typewritien pages, and Judge Arnold occupied an heur in Its Every phase of the noted case was , delivery. gone into, and the fifteen points ralsed by the defendant's counsel in the application for a new trial were disposed of seriatim. When Judge Arnold had finished, District-Attorney Graham moved that judgment be pronounced upon the prisoner, to which there was no objection from counsel for the defence. Holmes was told to stand up by the clerk, and as he did so every one In the courtroom rose with him. The clerk then asked the prisoner the usual question: “Have you anything to say why sentence of death should not be pronounced upon you?" “Nothing to say at present,” came in low tones from the prisoner, and then followed the sentence of the Court. Judge Arnold arse and addressed Holmes as follows, ir impressive tones: Herman W. Mudgett, allas H. H. Holmes, 1 have nothing to ea) to you further than what is contained in the opinion I have just read. There remaina notoing for me to do but to proceed and pass the sentence which the law has imposed, and that is that you be taken hence to the place from whence vou came, and from thence (o the place of execution, and there hanged by the neck until yon are dead. And may God have mercy on your goul, While sentence was being pronounced, Messrs. Rotan and Shoemaker stood close to the prisoner, leaning on the rail of the dock. Holmes kept his eves fixed on the Judge, but betrayed no conselousness of the import of the words. Then he turned to his guard, and, with the remark, “That is all,” as if glad it was ovr, he walked out of the courtroom with a nimble ctep, attended by three officers, Holmes was returned to tne County Prison and the death watch was placed over him. The date of *he execution will be fixed by Governor Ha ‘ngs. It is believed that the case will be appealed to the Supreme Court. eee

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The clipping reports from Philadelphia on November 30 that Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, received the death sentence without showing emotion, though the text is cut off before giving further details.

The Morning News · 1 December 1895 · page 1

HOLMES SENTENCED TO HANG

HOLMES SESTEXCED TO HA.XG. He Listens to the Fatal Words With* out a Show of Emotion. Philadelphia, Nov. 30.—Herman W. Mud gett, alias H. H. Holmes, who was con

See the clipping

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

Judge Arnold refused Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, a new trial for the murder of B. F. Pitezel, ruled Miss Yoke's marriage to him invalid due to prior wives, and formally sentenced him to death.

The Indianapolis Journal · 1 December 1895 · page 5

PHILADELPHIA. Nov. CO. In the Court of Oyer and Terminer to-day Judge Arnold rtfu.M to grant Herman W. Mudgett, alias II.; H. Holmes who was convicted on Nov. 2 of th murder, in this city, on Sept. 2. 1S9I, f B. F. Pitezel, a new trial and sentenced the condemned murderer to death. Holmes, when b came into court, looked careworn tr.d enrrd to have lost that air of confi dence which has clung to him throughout ti ordeal. Court opened with a brief tilt between Jjdge Arnold and lawyer Rotan, counsel for the defendant.

See moreSee less

Judge Arnold charged that Mr. Rotan had offered an Insult to the court by sending briefs to President Judge Thayer and Judge Willson, who had sat with Judge Arnold when Holmes's counsel had argued for a new trial, but had neg lected to send him a copy. Mr. Rotan dis claimed any Intention of insulting Judge Ar r.oM. and pleaded haste as an excuse for having neglected to rend him a brief. Judge Arnold then proceeded to read the court's answer to Holmes's counsel's rea fons for a new trial. He took up the fif teen exceptions to the verdict, one at a time, and dwelt at length on each. The main reasons for a new trial which were put forth by the defendant's counsel were tha admi??ion of the testimony of Miss Yoke, whom Holmes claimed as his lawful wife-: the district attorney's opening speech to-the jury, when he brought the murder! cf the children into the case, and part of Mrs. TitezM's testimony, in which she said the last time she saw hr children "was in the morgue at Toronto." In reference to Miss Yoke's eligibility as a witness, the Judge said that It was the opinion of the court that Holmes was not enly married to the Willlamette (III.) woman when he wedded Miss Yoke, but that he had also a wife In Oilman, N. H. Therefore, the marriage to Miss Yoke was t.ull and void, and the evidence was ad r.iisible. The opening epeeoh of the dis trict attorney, he said, wa not open to objection. It was the evident Intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to take off the entire Pitezel family in order to secure property belonging to the murdered man. .As to the statement of Mrs. Pitezel. the Judge hail instructed the Jury not to be in fl uencad by the woman's statement. He closed by saying that the court approved the verdict and refused a new trial. District Attorney Graham then arose and sked that sentence be pronounced. Holm was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said: "Herman W. Mudgett, have you anything to say?" "Holmes replied in a barely audible voice: I have nothing to say." Judge Arnold "then pronounced the death ffntence in the usual fonn, after which 3toIma was taken from tho court to pris on. Governor " Hastings , "will fix the day of Holmes's-fix ecu tl on, . An .appeal, to the-Su-, prpm Court will hs taken at onc. When the words that sealed his doom wero pronouncefl In low. Impressive tones, Holmes was unmoved. Durir.pt the entire time he did not tlinch, but looked the judge fquarely in the eye and .as the last sound flied away he turned to one of his attorneys and remarked quietly: "Well, that settles all." He was then led from the dock. The opinion denying the new trial covered sbout forty rages cf typo-written copy. All the facts brought out in the evidence were carefully set forth and the varied state ment made by the prisoner regarding the identity of the body and th manner of death were critically analyzed. Every one cf the numerous reasons submitted by the defense was overruled and In more than one lnstantv the court reprimanded the prisoner's counsel. In, d!smlsing the exception to the opening speech made by District Attorney Graham, the court remarked that the very subject c-hjected to was sug?eted by "the defense when the abdication for a postponement was made. At that time counsel gave as one of their reasons the statement that three murders were charged and they were un rrepared to meet them all. In the course of hi opinion Judee Arnold referred to the other murders alleged to have been com mitted by Holmes and said. Incidentally, that evidence as to them might have been Emitted n tending to show the motive. The court summed up the case as follows: "t'p' - tv M'Hr'o te we are convinced that the Commonwealth proved such a fiain of circumstances as 'ed irreslst My to the conclusion that the defendant !id kill and murder Benjamin V. Pitezel en Sept. 2. 1W. as charged In the b'll of indictment; that Pitezel was killed by chloroform poisoning administered by the defendant, and whether Pitezel was asleep or under the influence of liquor at the time the chloroform was administered Is not important. The theory advanced by the defendant and argued by Ms counsel to th jurv, that Pitezel committed suicide, and the defendant arranged his body In ri-h a manner as to make the death ap pear tr have been the consequence of an explosion, has no substantial evidence on which it can le based. An act of that kind would require coolness and delibera tion, whereas the testimony showed that th defendant immediately after he had left Pitezel was excited, nervous and wor T!d and his underclothing was wet with perspiration. This was the condition of a rran who had committed a gTeat crime rather than cf one who was trying to con ceal th evidence of a suicide. If Pitezel bad committed suicide and the defendant imply tried to conceal the suicide It Is rot probab'e that he would have fled from the city. Flight is the act of a guilty man and not th act of a running mn. PHng firmly convinced of the guilt of the rUffndant we approve the verdict and re fuse a new trial."

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The clipping describes Holmes remaining unmoved and staring directly at the judge as his sentence was pronounced in low, impressive tones.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 December 1895 · page 17

MISS YOKE'S MARRIAGE NULL

"THAT'S ALL," HE SAID. When the words that sealed his doom were pronounced in low, "Impressive tones, Holmes was unmoved. During the entire time he did not flinch, but looked the judge squarely in the eye,

See the clipping

St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.

The clipping, a fragment, notes the court's reference to other murders allegedly committed by Holmes as possible evidence of motive, before beginning its summary of the case.

St. Paul Daily Globe · 1 December 1895 · page 17

"THAT'S ALL," HE SAID.

to the other murders said to have been commited by Holmes, and said, inci dentally, that evidence as to them might have been admitted as tending to show the motive. The court summed up the case as follows:

See the clipping

The Anaconda Standard · Anaconda, Mont.

This badly garbled clipping is too damaged to clearly interpret, but it references a congressional figure, naval construction plans, and ships of about 10,000 tons.

The Anaconda Standard · 1 December 1895 · page 1

were proneanet) Is low, interior; Dr. ,Von Boesttohere, t vice Holmes was usamoei. Durls time he did net fiach, but premident of the oeanon of mattsters Fifty bmth congreca Hon. Galima plans for the sum fled by congress as Grow. who was speaker ot the hems the ultimate cost of tbe two ships The in INS, nomtnated Reed in the ewes new boats will be about 10,00 toes die

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This damaged clipping is a jumble of unrelated fragments—mentioning a Prussian interior minister's death, a withdrawn appeal, a British steamer landing at Plymouth, and misappropriation involving public works and a city sewer—too incoherent to summarize as a single story.

The Salt Lake Herald · 1 December 1895 · page 2

HOLMES LIKELY TO STRETCH HEMP Refuse a New Trial and Sentenced to Death

death the Prussian minister for the interior THE RING Holmes when he came Into court Dr Von Boetticher the vicepresident of now complete yet not complete years in prison Accordingly his appeal them out to prevent clogging hence for a new trial has been withdrawn from By the very slowest methods possible PLYMOUTH Eng The British steamer the practical usefulness of the gravity Rose Morran has arrived here and landed the supreme court Flood misapropriated the board of public works and the city sewer in my mind is problematical

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

This damaged fragment reports that Judge Arn noted other murders said to have been committed by Holmes, which were unprepared for inclusion among the charges, though the text is too garbled to convey full details.

The Salt Lake Herald · 1 December 1895 · page 2

murders were charged and that they were unprepared to meet them all old referred to the other murders that I In the course of his opinion Judge Arn are said to have been committed by Holmes and said Incidentally that evi

See the clipping

In the story →

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

Judge Arnold refused H. H. Holmes a new trial for the murder of B. F. Pietzel, rejected defense objections including testimony about Miss Yoke, and formally sentenced Holmes to be hanged, with an appeal to the supreme court planned.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 1 December 1895 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

SENTENCED TO DEATH.

Holmes Refused a New Trial by Judge Arnold Yesterday.

See moreSee less

PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Nov. 30.—Judge Arnold to-day refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of murder of B. F. Pietzel, in this city September 2, 1894, and sentenced him to death. Promptly at 10 o'clock Holmes, accompanied by his counsel, came into court. He looked careworn, but seemed to have that air of confidence which has clung to him throughout the trying ordeal. Court opened with a brief tilt between Judge Arnold and Lawyer Rotan. counsel for the defendant. Judge Arnold charged that Mr. Rotan had offered an insult to the court by submitting briefs to the president judge.

Judge Wilson said Holmes' counsel had argued for a new trial, but neglected to send him a copy. Mr. Rotan said that the papers had been prepared hurriedly and if the judge had been overlooked it was a mistake. He said: "I do not want permission to go forth if I have done wrong. There was no disrespect intended when I sent the briefs to Judges Thayer and Wilson and as a member of this bar you should have more confidence in me" Judge Arnold made no further comment, but proceeded with reading the answer to Holmes' counsel.

The main reasons for a new trial, which were put forth by the defendant's counsel, were the admission of the testimony of Miss Yoke, whom Holmes claimed as his lawful wife; the district attorney's opening speech to the jury when he brought the murder of the children into the case, and Mrs. Pietzel's testimony, in which she said the last time she saw her children was in the morgue at Toronto.

In reference to Miss Yoke's eligibility as a witness the judge said that as Holmes was not only married to the Willimeet, Ills., woman, Miss Yoke, but he also had a wife in Gilman, N. H., therefore the marriage to Miss Yoke was null and void and the evidence was admissible. He closed by saying that the court approves the verdict and refuses a new trial. District Attorney Graham asked that sentence be pronounced.

Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said: "Herman W. Mudgetts, have you anything to say?" Holmes replied, in a barely audible voice: "I have nothing to say."

Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence, as follows: "It is the sentence of this court that you be taken hence from whence you came, and there be hanged by the neck until you are dead. May God have mercy on your soul."

The expression of Holmes' face remained the same. He was taken from the court to prison. Governor Hastings will fix the day of Holmes' execution. An appeal to the supreme court will be taken at once.

See the clipping

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

This damaged clipping reports that a governor will set Holmes' execution date pending a supreme court appeal, alongside unrelated fragments about a lodge event and a list of product qualities.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 1 December 1895 · page 4

the court to prison. Governor Haetlngs Cornedlau, Unland Beed, In "Tho Poli? will fix the day of Holmes' execution tician. " An appeal to tbe supremo court will bo Roanoko Lodgo No. 197, B. P. O. Elks, taken at once. have arranged with the eminent cotn will not shrink. Fourth. Becausethoy will not warp and getont ot shape. _ Seventh. Because they will last longer, Eighth. Because tncy are much better in every respect.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A Philadelphia court, via Judge Arnold with concurrence from Judges Thayer and Wilson, denied Holmes's request for a new trial and formally pronounced a death sentence for the murder of Benjamin Pietzel. Holmes showed no reaction to the ruling, was returned to prison under a death-watch, and the execution date awaited the governor's decision, with an appeal to the Supreme Court considered likely.

Richmond Dispatch · 1 December 1895 · page 17

Herman W. Mudgett alias H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of murder in the first degree for having caused the death In this city of Benjamin F. Pletzel, was this morning, in the Court of Oyer and Ter miner, refused a new trial and sentenced to be hanged. The opinion denying the accused a new trial was delivered by Judge Arnold, it having been concurred in by Judges Thayer, Wilson, and Arnold, who heard the application for a mew trial. Judge Arnold then pronounced the deathsen tence. Holmes, who had been brought into court to hear the opinion, was not affect ed by the adverse decision, and when Judge Arnold, in deliberate tones, sen tenced him to be “hanged by the neck until dead,” the alr of apparent Indiffer ence, which was so manifest throughout the celebrated trial, was not deviated from by the alleged multi-murderer.

See moreSee less

Holmes was then returned to the coun ty prison, and a death-watch was placed over him. The date of execution will be fixed by Governor Hastings. : The opinion covers sixty-seven typewrit ten pages, and Judge Arnold employed an hour in its delivery. Every phase of the noted case was gone into, and the fine points raised by the defendant’s coun gel in the application for a new trial were disposed of seriatim. It is believed that the case will be appealed to the Supreme Conrt

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

In Philadelphia on Nov. 30, H. H. Holmes was refused a new trial and sentenced to death for the murder of Benjamin F. Pletzel.

The Times · 1 December 1895 · page 1

PHILADELPHIA, PA, Nov. 30.—-H. H. Holmes was this morning refused a new n trial, and sentenced to death for the mur der of Benjamin F. Pletzel,

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

This brief item, embedded amid unrelated shipping and battleship-bidding news, states that H. H. Holmes has been sentenced to die. No further details or content accompany this headline fragment in the passage.

The Times · 1 December 1895 · page 1

The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

Judge Arnold stated Holmes intended to kill off the entire Pitzel family for property, dismissed Mrs. Pitzel's statement, upheld the verdict, and pronounced the death sentence on Herman W. Mudgett (Holmes), who said he had nothing to say, with an appeal to the supreme court to follow.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 1 December 1895 · page 6

SENTENCE OF HOLMES. The Horrible Multi-Murderer Ordered to Be Hanged.

was the Intention of Holme*, sard Jud&e Arnold, to : ilc off the er.t re Pitzel family in order to secure property h*lonK.r.r to the murdered man. As to the statement of Mrs. PitaeJ. thQ judpe hai instructed the jury not to be Influenced by the woman's statement. He closed by saying th» court approved the verdict an! refused a new trial. E>istr t Attorney Graham ask1 :..at sentence be pronounced. Holmes waus orderedto stand. J'ilge Arnold said: "Herman W Mudgett, have vo x anything to say T* Holmes repii-d in a fa rly audible voice: "I hava nothing to say."

See moreSee less

Judff" Arnold then pronounced the death sentence in the usual form. Gov. Hastings will fix the day of execution. An appeal to the supreme co art will oe Liken a: onoe. When the words staling his doom were

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This damaged clipping jumbles a judge's refusal to grant a new trial to a man convicted of murder with unrelated details about wood block samples and a steamer loading wheat at an elevator.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 1 December 1895 · page 6

H. H. HOLMES

city, having Just arrived from San Fran to arrive In a few days. In reply to the letter. Stetson &* Post cisco. It I* 30.400 feet long, weighs about A slight delay was caused to the Lake at once forwarded tw samples of Seattle BS,OOO pounds and cost JT.uuQ. It now lies Washington branch of the Fnion Trunk bio ks. one of cedar, the other of fir. Mr. day refused to grant a new trial to H. H. and went over to the elevator at West by the defense when the application for Seattle to load wheat.

See moreSee less

Holmes, convicted <}f the murder of B. F. appointment was made. " At the time Tig Magic towerj in steamer Utopia Pitzel in this city September 21, and the counsel gave as one of the reasons the

See the clipping

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · Seattle, Wash. Terr. Wash.

This damaged, jumbled clipping intermixes a courtroom scene involving a judge, a lawyer named Rotan, and mention of murders attributed to someone named Holmes, with unrelated fragments about a cable, a wooden keg factory, and two Seattle vessels sold to Victoria parties.

The Seattle Post-Intelligencer · 1 December 1895 · page 6

H. H. HOLMES

"The n>"w cable was made by the Wash no reason why Washington should not A WOODEN KV VK FACTORY. ton.. M 'en Manufacturing Company, of reach on? and secure a poruon of the trade. Ban Francis o, and is one of th© best ever Th s application, coming so closely on the Another Enterprise to Me Ope rust In J :dge Arnold and Lawyer Rotan, counsel other murders that are said to have been Two Seattle vessels have been recently for the defense. The judge charged that committed by Holmes, and said, inci sold to Victoria parties, the Allie Algar, which has been engaged in sealing and Rotan offered an insult to the court by dentally, that evidence as to them might

See the clipping

The Wilmington Daily Republican · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping reports that Judge Arnold refused a new trial and sentenced Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin P. Pitezel, to be hanged, noting he showed no emotion during the proceeding.

The Wilmington Daily Republican · 2 December 1895 · page 3

T HOLMES* DEATH SENTENCE. ' T out Betraying Emotion. Philadelphia, Dee. ».—A new trial was refused by Judge Arnold in the Holmes, the oonvioted murderer of Benja min P. Pitezel, In the oourt of oyer and terminer on Saturday, and the prisoner was sentenosd to be hanged. The scene was an intensely impressive one. No per son In tho oourt room, however, betrayed less emotion during Holmes' ordeal than the cool, calculating murderer himself. He had been duly Informed by his oouusel He what the result peal from the judgment of the oyer and to be, and that »P

See the clipping

The Morning Times · Washington, D.C.

This damaged clipping jumbles unrelated snippets, including remarks on Congress's limited legislative agenda, a yacht's depth change blamed on stowed newspapers, a question about pardoning a defaulter versus a starving thief, and a brief mention of an arrested female moonshiner.

The Morning Times · 2 December 1895 · page 4

graciously received. These utterances, to to be Mr. Reed's views, make it tolerably certain that comparatively little tariff or financial legislation will be had, and that the workot thellousewillbelargelylimitcd to the passage of appropriation bills and other routine matters. Congress on his Lands bat not tho same Congress, however. rope, and may soon be at the end of another. change in Defender's depth was due to tho weight of some copies of the London Times, carelessly left on board by Dunraven. Bardsley than the poorest criminal who stole to keep from Etarving?

See moreSee less

To pardon the defaulter and bank wrecker would be an outrage. gether with what are generally understood Today PresidentClcveland willagalnhave Mr. H. H. Holmes Is now at the end of his The mystery has been explained. The What more claim on clemency has John A female moonshiner has been arrested

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

Judge Arnold rejects a new trial for Holmes, who declines to speak when asked, and pronounces the death sentence, with Governor Hastings to set the execution date and an appeal to the supreme court expected at once.

The Evening Bulletin · 2 December 1895 · page 1

Holmes, said Jtidpp Arnold, to take off 1 tl'o entire PMzol family in order to se- , cure property belonging to the murdered man. As to the statement of Mrs. Pietzel, tho judge bad instructed tho jury not to bo influenced bv tho woman's state nient: ho closed bv saying tliat tho court a liovcs tho vorii-t and rofnres a new trial. District Attorney Graham flien nroco and asked that sentence be pronounced. Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said: , "Herman W. Mudgetts, havo you any TTilmos replied in a barely audible vr if o: "I havo nothing to say."

See moreSee less

Judge Arnold then pronounced tho dith sentence in the usual form, after 1 nil Holmes was taken from th" v,rrt to prison. Governor Hastinf". will fix tho day of Holmes' execution. Am nppal to the puprenie court will be Liken at or.ee. thing to say?"

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Printed in German, among other news items this clipping ends with a fragment stating that the murderer Holmes has been sentenced to death, before being cut off mid-sentence.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 December 1895 · page 2

Der Mörder Holmes zum Tode verurtheilt

Münzdirektors betrug der MetallgeldVorrath im Lande am 1. Juli d. I. 949 in Silber. Wenn das nicht ein Beweis ist, daß wir wirklich ein bime tallis'isches Land sind, welchen weite ren erwartet man? Gattin des reichen C a n d y f a b r i kanten Christian F. Winke meier in Brooklyn, N.-N-' dessen Maitresse sich kürzlich an den Stufen seines Hauses in selbstmörderischer Absicht schoß, machte am Samstag ihre Klage auf absolute Scheidung im Superior-Gericht vor Richter Gaynor anhängig und stellte einen Antrag auf Bewilligung von wöchentlichen Alimenten und.??99Advokatengebühr, bis der Fall vertändelt werden kann.

See moreSee less

Hrn. Winkemeier's Anwalt sagte, daß der Verklagte das ihm zur Last gelegte Vergehen eingestehe aber gegen die verlangte Summe Einwand erhebe. Ferner bewies der Anwalt durch be schworene Angaben der Maitresse Win kemeier's daß derselbe mit ihr inner halb von sechs Monaten durch gebracht habe. Winkemeier soll in ih rer Anwesenheit d'e Bemerkung ge macht haben, er werde seinen Bankerott und eine Übertragung des Gesü>äfrs anmelden, um der Alimenten-Zahlung zu entgehen. Uebrigens hat nun auch der „kleine Willie," welcher von Winke meier für alles Unheil, das ihn betrof fen, verantwortlich gemacht wird, sein Herz erleichtert und eine „Erklärung" erlassen. Willie Finch, welcher mit seinen Eltern neben Winkemeier wohnt, war einAugenzeuge der Schießerei und halte schon vorher von den intimen Be ziehungen zwischen der Frau und dem Zuckerwaaren-Fabrikanten Kenntniß gehabt. In dem von Winkemeier ein geleiteten Scheidungsprozeß war er als Mitbeklagter aufgetreten. Der „tleine Willie." wie er in Folge feiner Jugend und schmächtigen Statur in den Ver handlungen genannt wurde, vermochte jedoch sein Unschuld zu beweisen, und die Klage blieb indessen erfolglos. Winkemeier hatte schon vorher seine Gattin aus dem Hause gejagt und be zahlt ihr gegenwärtig H 39 wöchentliche Alimente. Tcr Mörder Holmes zum Tode Nach dem Berichte des in Gold und H 625,853,- ?srau Maud B. Winkemeicr, die vernr-ycilt.

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Printed in German, this report describes Judge Arnold pronouncing the death sentence on H. H. Holmes for the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, after denying a motion for a new trial, with Holmes remaining calm and declining to speak.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 2 December 1895 · page 2

Philadelphia, Pa., 1. Dez. —- „Das Urtheil des Gerichtshofes lautet, daß Sie von hier nach dem Platze ge bracht werden, von welchem Sie gekomj men sind, und von dort mich der Richt stätte, und daß Sie dort am Halse aus gehängt werden, bis Sie todt sind. Möge Gott Ihrer Seele gnädig sein!" Mit diesen Worten fällte Richter Ar nold gestern Morgen das Todesurtheil über den Mörder H. H. Holmes, wel cher vor einiger Zeit nach einem der sensationellsten Prozesse der Neuzeit, der Ermordung des Benjamin F. Piet zel schuldig erkannt worden war, dem aber noch eine ganz: Reihe von Mor den und anderen Verbrechen zur Last gelegt werden.

See moreSee less

Nur wenige Personen wohnten der vorläufigen Schlußszene in diesem Schauerdrama bei, da nur die Eingeweihten wußten, daß der An trag der Vertheidiger des Mörders auf Bewilligung eines neuen Prozesses zur Erledigung kommen würde, unter die sen weniLen Anwesenden gab sich aber durchaus keine Sympathie für den Mörder kund. Holmes wurde um 19 Uhr Vormittags in den Gerichtssaal geführt und nahm seinen Platz im Ge fangenenverfchlage ein. Seine An wälte, Rotan und Shoemaker, standen ihm zur Seite. In feinem Aeußeren zeigte Holmes keine Veränderung seit dem Prozesse. Ruhig und gefaßt hörte er dem Richter Arnold zu, als derselbe ein umfangreiches Dokument verlas, in welchem er die Gründe darlegte, die den Gerichtshof veranlaßt hatten, den Antrag auf Bewilligung eines neuen Prozesses abzuweisen. Nur einmal be wegte er sich unruhig auf seinem Sitze und lehnte sich weit über die Brüstung vor, als Nichter Arnold die Worte ver las: „Es war die einstimmige Ansicht des Gerichtshofes, daß das auf Mord im ersten Grade lautende Verdikt durch das Beweismaterial vollständig ge rechtfertigt war." Die Verlesung der Entscheidung des Richters nahm unge fähr eine Stunde in Anspruch. In der selben wurde das Bcweismaterial aus führlich in Bezug auf die verschiedenen Gründe, die für Bewilligung eines neuen Prozesses angegeben worden wa ren. einer Erörterung unterzogen, aber das Hauptgewicht verlegte der Richter auf die hervorragendsten Punkte der Beweisführung deZ Distriktsanwaltes, welche, wie der Richter sagte, unwider stehlich zu dem Schlüsse führen müsse, daß Pietzel von dem Angeklagten mit Chloroform getödtet worden sei. Kaum hatte der Richter das Dokument verle sen, so beantragte Distriktsanwalt Graham, daß das Urtheil verkündet werde. Der GerichtZschreiber Henszey erhob sich langsam und sich an den Ge fangenen wendend, frug er mit feier licher Stimme: „Hermann W. Mud gett, alias H. H. Holmes, haben Sic irgend einen Grund anzugeben, wes halb das Urtheil dieses Gerichtshofes nicht verkündet werden sollte?" Hol mes schüttelte mit dem Kopfe und er klärte dann laut und deutlich: „Ich habe gegenwärtig nichts zu sagen." Richter Arnold erbob sich darauf, au.v der Gefangene und sämmtliche Anwe. senden, und sagte mit bewegter Stim me: „Außer dem Rechtsgutachten, wel ches ich soeben verlesen, habe ick nichts mehr zu sagen. Ich will Ihre Gefühle nicht weiter erregen, indem ich irgend etwas mehr sage, als mir daH Gesetz vorschreibt." Hierauf erfolgte die Ver kündigung des Todesurtheils. Hol-

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · and 3 other papers

A Philadelphia court report describes Judge Arnold's refusal to grant Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, a new trial for the murder of B. I. Pietzel, following a dispute with defense counsel Rotan, after which sentencing of death proceeded.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 2 December 1895 · page 3

"NEW TRIAL DENIED. H, XX, Holmes’ Last Hope Gone—Sentenced to Death by the Court. PHILADELPHIA, Dec. 2.—ln the court of of oyer and terminer Saturday Judge Ar nold refused to grant Herman W. Mudg etts, alias-H. H. Holmes, who wgs con victed on Nov, 2. for-the murder in this city on Sept. 2, 1894, of B. I. Pitezel, a ‘new trial and sentenced the condemned murderer to death. Promptly at 10 o’clock Folmes’ eounsel aecompanied by Holmes came into court. He looked ecareworn,and seemed to have lost that air of confidence which has clung to him throughout his trying ordeal, The court opened with a brief tilt between Judge Arnold and Lawyer Rotan, counsel for the defendant.

See moreSee less

Judge Arnold charged that Mr. Rotan had offered an insult to the court by sending _briefs to Judge Thayer and Judge Willson, who had sat with Judge Arnold when Holmes counsel had argned for a new trial, but neglected to send him a copy. Mr. Rotan said the briefs had been pre pared hurriedly, and if the judge had been overlooked it was a mistake. He said: “I do not want the impression to go forth that T have done wrong. Ido not want to be attacked that way. There was no disrespect intended when I sent the briefs to Judges Thayer and Willson, and as a memper of this bar you should have that confidence in me. Judge Arncld made no further com ment, but proceeded to read the court’s answer to Holmes’ counsel's reasons for a new trinl. He took upthe 15 exceptions to the verdict one at a' time, and dwelt at length upon each. The main reasons for & new trial which were put forth by the defendant’s counsel were the admission of the testimony of Miss Yoke, who Holmes claimed as his lawful wife; the district at torney’s opening speech to the jury, when he brought the murder of the children into the case, and. that part of Mrs. Piet zel's testimony in which she said the last time she saw her children was “in the morgue at Toronto.”’ In referenco to Miss Yoke's eligibility as.a witness the judge said that it was the opinion of the court that Holmes was not only married’ to the Williamette (Ills.) woman when he wedded Miss Yoke, but he also had a wife in Gilmanton, N. H. Therefore the marriage to Miss Yoke was null and veid and the evidence was ad missible. The opening speech of the district attor ney, ke said, was not open to objection. It was the evident intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to take off the entirc Piet zel family, in order to secure property be longing to the murdered man. As to the statement of Mrs. Pletzel, the] judge had instructed the jury not to be influenced by the woman’s statemednt. He closed by saying that the court ap proves tho verdict and refuses a new trial, District Attorney Graham then arose and asked that sentence be passed. Holmeg was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said: “Herman W. Mudgett, have you any \

See the clipping

Also printed in 3 papers
  • The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb. · 2 December 1895
  • The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan. · 5 December 1895
  • Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D. · 6 December 1895

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of Benjamin F. Pietzel, was sentenced to death by Judge Arnold after an appeals court denied a new trial, with the execution date to be set by Governor Hastings.

The Scranton Tribune · 2 December 1895 · page 2

The Murderer Condemned to the Gallows Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, who was convincted of murder in the first de this city, of Benjamin F. Pietzel. was yesterday sentenced to be hanged. An opinion denying a new trial was de was concurred In by Judges Thayer, Wilson and Arnold, who heard the ap the Judge, but he did not betray any emotlun. Ho turned to his guard with the remark, "That is all," and walked out of the court room. The case will bo appealed. The date of execution will be fixed by Governor Hastings.

See moreSee less

HOLMES IS SENTENCED. by JudRO Arnold. Philadelphia, Dec. 1. Herman "W. gree for having caused the death, in livered by Judge Arnold. The opinion plication for a new trial. During the pronouncing of tho sent ence, Holmes kept his eyes fixed upon

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The clipping, cut off mid-sentence, reports that Judge Arnold refused to grant a new trial to the man convicted of murdering Pietzel, and that Holmes was sentenced to death.

The Madison Daily Leader · 2 December 1895 · page 3

ME. H. H. HOLMES SENTENCED Murderer of Pletcel Condemned to Death at I'blladelphl*. PHILADELPHIA, Dec. 2.—Judge Ar nold refused to grant a new trial to

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The clipping is a jumbled OCR fragment mixing a school board partisanship dispute, a reference to a wholesale murderer, and unrelated notes on a livestock show and cooperative manufacturing businesses, making the original text too damaged to summarize clearly.

The Salt Lake Herald · 2 December 1895 · page 4

choice of members on > the board I will not get a new trial but he will I WHOLESALE MURDERER H H Holmes Partisanship and taxes seems to be the meaning of a Republican partisan get his just deserts I majority on the school board THE LIVE stock show in New York ufactures Clothing sho > s furnitures of censure The Tribune will scarcely flour candy soap and other factories sip TitBits assert that there has Why not come are doing good business and even out in a frank manly way and say steamships are owned and run by co that Mr Toronto is a Democrat and operative associations that is its objection to him Everything is done on business prin

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

This damaged clipping is too fragmentary to follow clearly, but it references a court opinion involving a Mr. Butler, a grand jury matter over fees, and an interview touching on the Turkish government and protection.

The Laramie Republican · 2 December 1895 · page 1

SENTENCED TO DEATH.

persecution, claiming that It will tend to make the Socialist party stronger and ■ more harmonious. as a witness, the judge said ILjraa the Mr. Butler; the fact that he has been be8 opinion of the court that Holmes h as not fore the grand jury charged with extortc only married to the Williamette, ills., Ing nolle prossequl fees was sufficient to c Turkish government to furnish protection. He reviewed the affairs of that country in an interview, in the course of which he bit1

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

This damaged clipping, mixing unrelated items, mentions Constantinople and the sultan's obstinacy, Governor Hastings setting an execution date for Holmes with an appeal expected, and Col. Matt Adams defaulting on official obligations to a county.

The Laramie Republican · 2 December 1895 · page 1

HE HAS NOTHING TO SAY.

t provocation which might lead to noting in Constantinople and the sultan's ob stinacy in the matter is all the more an Governor Hastings will fix the day for “It appears that Col. Matt Adams, late execution of Holmes. An appeal to tne clerk of this court, made default in his < supreme court will be taken at once. official obligations to the county and 1 f it planned to do through the regular mix ed commission of Christians and jmU cut mans, and the reply, in Dr. Talmage's

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

This damaged clipping fragment mentions H. H. Holmes as credited with twenty-three murders and quotes Mrs. William Chisholm of Rochester saying the Lord is with her, but the text is too incomplete to convey more.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 3 December 1895 · page 4

that H. H. Holmes, with twenty three murders to his credit should l>e math fill exception to the rule. Mrs. William Chisholm of Rochester, "%*. y,, says the Lord is with her in her

See the clipping

Willmar Tribune · Willmar, Minn. · and 1 other paper

A letter from Aden describes an Arabian revolt against the sultan in Yemen, noting its danger to Mecca and that the sultan's officials have denied the rebellion's existence; a brief mention follows that a judge refused a new trial to a convicted murderer.

Willmar Tribune · 3 December 1895 · page 5

HOLMES SENTENCED TO HANG.

ARE LIABLE TO LOSE MECCA. The Holy City in Danger of Capture by Rebe s. LONDON, Dec. 2.—A letter from Aden, Arabia, dated Nov. 20, gives details of the Arabian revolt against the sultan in Yemen, the coffee growing district of Southwestern Arabia. The importance of the outbreak lies in its proximity to Mecca. The loss to the sultan of the Mussulman Holy City would probably mean his deposition. Hence the strenu ous ^official denials which have been made of the existence of the rebellion. HOLMES SENTENCED TO HANG. Judge Arnold Refuses a New Trial Trial to Pietzel's Murderer.

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Redwood Gazette · Redwood Falls, Minn. · 5 December 1895

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

A Philadelphia judge rejects a new trial for H. H. Holmes, condemns him to death for murdering B. F. Pitzel, and the clipping also begins reporting a confessed murder case involving a young man named Lloyd Montgomery near Brownsville, Oregon.

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 4 December 1895 · page 2

DVerbrecher und Verbrechen. Holmes zum TCode verurtheilt. Im Ohyerund Terminer - Gericht zu Philadelphia wies Richter Arnold „den Antrag, dem Herman W. Mud— getts, alias H. H. Holmes, der am 2. November überführt worden war, am 2. Sept. 1894 den B. FPitzel ermor—- det zu haben, einen neuen Prozeß zu be— willigen, zurück und verurtheilte ihn zum Tode. Holmes sah heruntergekommen und be kümmert aus und hatte offenbar jene Schnei— digkeit, die er während seines Prozesses zur Schau getragen, vollständig verloren. Rich— ter Arnold verlas die Erwiderung des Ge— richtes auf die von den Vertheidigern des An— geklagten eingereichten fünfzehn Gründe für einen neuen Prozeß.

See moreSee less

Der von den Anwälten des Angeklagten geltend gemachte Haupt— grund für die Bewilligung eines neuen Pro— zesses war die Zulassüng der Aussagen des Fräulein Yoke, welche Holmes für seine ge setzlich ihm angetraute Frau ausgab; ferner die Eröffrungsrede des Distriktanwalts an die Jurh, in welcher derselbe die Ermordung der Pitzel schen Kinder erwähnte und jener Theil von Frau Pitzel's Aussagen, in wel— chen Zeugin erklärte, daß sie ihre Kinder zum letzten Male in der Morgue in Toronto ge sehen habe. Betreffs der Zulassung von Frl. Yoke als Zeugin sagte der Richter, daß ñach Ansicht des Gerichtshofes Holmes nicht nur mit dem Frauenzimmer in Willamette, 111., verheirathet gewesen sei, als er Frl. Hote hei rathete, sondern daß er auch eine Frau in Gilman, N. H., gehabt habe. Aus diesem Grunde sei die Heirath mit Frl. Yoke un— gültig und die Aussagen derselben feien zu— lässig gewesen. Die Eröffnungsrede des Di— striktanwalts sei unanfechtbar. Holmes habe offenbar beabsichtigt, die ganze Pitzel' sche Familie aus dem Wege zu räumen, um sich das Vermögen Pitzels anzueignen. Zum Schluß sagte der Richter, daß der Gerichts hof den Wahrspruch der Jurh gutheiße und einen neuen Prozeß verweigere. Hierauf er— hob sich der Distriktanwalt Graham und er— suchte um Verkündigung der Strafe. Holmes wurde aufgefordert, sich zu erheben, und der Richter fragte ihn, ob er etwas zu sagen habe. Holmes erwiderte mit kaum vernehmlicher Stimme, daß er nichts zu sagen habe. Der Richter sprach sodana das Todesurtheil über ihn aus. Holmes wurde nach dem Gefäng—- niß zurückgebracht. Gouverneur Hastings wird den Tag der Hinrichtung bestimmen. Die Anwälte des Verurtheilten haben sofort an das Oberge— vicht appellirt. Holmes zeigte bei der Verkündigung des Todesurtheils nicht die mindeste Bawegung. Er hatte während der ganzen Zeit dem Rich ter fest in die Augen geblickt und als das letzte Wort des Urtheils verklungen war, wandte er sich an einen seiner Anwälte und bemerkte mit großer Kaltblütigkeit: „Na, so weit wären wir!“ Er wurde dann aus dem Gerichtssaale abgeführt. Ein geständiger Moöörder. Lloyhd Montgomery, jener 18jährige junge Mann, der wegen Ermordung seiner Eltern bei Brownsville, Oregon, seit Dienstag sich in Haft befindet, hat ein volles Geständniß abgelegt und zugegeben, daß er die Eltern und auch Daniel MeKucher ermordet hat. Erläuternd behauptet er, sein Vater habe auf ihn geschimpft, so daß er sich geärgert habe, und an der Mutter und MecKucher habe er sich vergriffen, weil diese beiden Personen für den Vater Partei nahmen. Fwei Neger agelyncht. Freitag Ahbend um 8 Uhr wurden die Neger Joe Robinson und Ozies MeGaheh von einem aus Leuten bon Lincoln und Marshall Countyh bestehenden Mob aus dem Gefäng— nisse in Fayhetteville, Tenn., genommen und aufgeknüpft. Die Neger waren am Morgen von Nashville nach Lewisburg, Marshall County, gebracht, wegen Nothzuchtversuches prozessirt, üherführt und zu der höchsten ge— setzlichen Strafe verurtheilt worden. Eine Familie umgebracht. George MeLain, ein Photograph aus Green River, Wyo.,, begab sich mit seiner Frau und zwei Kinldern anfangs des Frühjahres nach Jackson's Hole. MeLain wechselte bis zur Zeit des Ausbruches ber Feindseligkeiten mit den Bannock-Indianern regelmäßig Briefe mit seinen Verwandten. Letzte Woche kehrte ein junger Mann aus der Gegend von Jackson Hole hierher zurück und berichtete die Zerstörung eines photographi schen Ateliers in Jackson Hole, und dies deutet darauf hin, daß Mec Lain und seine F amilie ermordet wurden.

See the clipping

Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn.

This damaged clipping mixes a report that a showman closed his tent after poor attendance and fled with only four of ten engagements filled, a note that H. H. Holmes has been denied a new trial with the governor to set an execution date, and a Hood's Sarsaparilla testimonial letter from a Minnesota woman praising the medicine and Hood's Pills.

Morris Tribune · 4 December 1895 · page 4

then to be poor feed, as it turned the night ago. He was going to take the meat into a flabby fat which was of Western people by storm, but he no use except for grease, etc. But found only empty seats to storm, so in the meantime experiments have he closed his tent and silently sneaked proved diffdrent, or entirely opposite, back to New York withonly four of and it is now claimed to be one of the his ten engagements filledHis sub Hood's Sarsaparilla and I thought I would try it and after taking one bottle H.

See moreSee less

H. Holmes, the Philadelphia and a half I began to feel better. I took murderer, is doomed. He has been Six Bottles and Was Cured. We have taken it since and always keep denied a new trial and ordered it in the house. We would not like to be hanged. The governor will fix the without it. We have also tried Hood's Pills and found them to be just date of execution. as represented." MRS. J. C. KNTTDSOX, Albert Lea, Minnesota. Get. HOOD'S.

See the clipping

The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb.

A Philadelphia judge on December 1 refused to grant another trial to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of murder, according to this garbled clipping.

The Columbus Journal · 4 December 1895 · page 2

Jadge Araeld Refaeed to Graat the Arch Philadelphia, Dec. 1. Judge Ar to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of HOLMES MUST HANG. Criminal Aaether Trial. nold today refused to grant anothertrial

See the clipping

Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Judge Arnold of Philadelphia refused H. H. Holmes a new trial after his conviction for the murder of B. F. Pitezel on September 2, 1894, sentencing him to death with the Governor to fix the execution date.

Staunton Spectator · 4 December 1895 · page 3

CONGRESSIONAL. The 54th Congress met at noon, Mou ) day last. U. S. Senate.—The Senate was call ed to order by Vice President Steven son. The offerings were unusually . abundant. In his prayer the chaplain , referred to the affliction in the family , of ex Senator Wilson, of lowa, and also | alluded to the absence of the veteran doorkeeper, Isaac Bassett, who is dan ' gerously ill. After new members had ' been sworn in, a committee, composed of Senators Vilas and Allison were ap pointed to wait on the President and .

See moreSee less

notify him that Congress was ready to receive any communication the execu tive branch desired to present. After a recess of one hour the Senate ad journed until Tuesday. House op Representatives. — Monday at noou the House was called to order by Hon. James Kerr, clerk of the last House. Prayer was offered by the chaplain, Rev. Mr. Bagby. The roll was called, and Mr. Kerr announc ed that-341 out of 356 members were present. Nominations for Speaker were made, and Mr. Reed received 234 votes; Mr Crisp, 95; Mr. Bell, 6; Mr. Culberson, 1. Mr. Reed was declared elected, and made a speech of accept anee. The members then took the oath to support and defend the con stitution. The officers of the House nominated by the republican caucus on Saturday were then formally elected. A com mittee was appointed to join with a similar committee from the Senate to wait upon the President. The bienni al lottery, or seat drawing, was then begun, and as soon as it was completed the House adjourned until Tuesday. .. m . Two train robbers stopped a north bound passenger train on the Fort Worth and Denver Railroad, near Chil dress, Texas, Thursday night, but se cured no booty, as the express messen ger could not open the safe. A woman by the name of Miller, em ployed as a domestic by Gen. J. H. Williams in Woodstock, was found dead Thursday, heart failure being cause of death. According to Spanish reports Gen. Gomez, with 6,00) insurgeuts under his co.nmand, has beea recently defeated by Generals Oliver and Luque in the province of Santa Ciara. Rev. Mr. Johnstone, a missionary, and his wife and child, have beeu killed during a riot in the capital of Madagascar. Judge Sener states that Col. Lamb was elected voluntarily and without opposition to the chairmanship of the State Republican committee of Vir ginia and also m imber of the national committee. Judge Moise, of New Orleans, who committed the district attorney to jail for contempt of court last week, was on Saturday indicted by the grand jury for oppression in offlje and slan der. Branoss Blanche de Berzsenyi, of Hungary, has sued Mrs. Alva S. Van derbilt, mother of the Duchess of Marl borough, for $500, the value of a tran tulas cup, which was sent to Mrs. Van derbilt's house for inspection and never returned. Judge Arnold, of Philadelphia, has refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitezel, in Philadel phia, September 2, 1894, and sentenced him to death. The Governor will fix the day of execution. Miss .Lizzie Cols ion, of Martinsburg, VV. Va., has been appointed by Judge E. Boyd Faulkner stenagrapher for the judicial circuit composed of Berkeley, , Jefferson and Morgan counties.

See the clipping

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 2 other papers

Judge Arnold condemned Holmes, accusing him of trying to kill the entire Pitezel family for money, and pronounced a death sentence by hanging, with the governor to set the execution date and an appeal planned.

Connecticut Western News · 5 December 1895 · page 1

H. H. HOLMES.

missible. The opening speech of the district at It was the evident Intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to take off tbe entire Pltesel family In order to secure property belonging to tbe murdered men. As to the statement of Mrs. Pitezel, the judge had Instructed the jury not to be influ enced by it He closed by saying that the oourt ap District Attorney Graham then arose and asked that . sentence be pronounced. Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said, "Herman W. Mudgett, have you anytlhng to sayf" Holmes replied in a barely audible voioe, "I have nothing to say."

See moreSee less

Judge Arnold then prononnoed the death sentence as follows: "It is the sen tence of this oourt that you be taken henoe from whence you came and there be hanged by the neck until you are dead May God have mercy on your souL" The expression on Holmes' face remained the same. He was taken from the oourt to prison. Governor Hastings will fix the day ot Holmes) execution. An appeal to the supreme court will be taken at once. torney, be said was not open to objection. Soatoaeod to Death. proves the verdiot and ref usee a new trlaL Mrs. K. n. Morgan Injured.

See the clipping

Also printed in 2 papers
  • Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H. · 2 December 1895
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 5 December 1895

Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.

A Philadelphia court under Judge Arnold refused Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, a new trial and sentenced him to death for the murder of B. F. Pitezel, after a brief courtroom dispute.

Connecticut Western News · 5 December 1895 · page 1

HOLMES SENTENCED. A NEW TRIAL DENIED AND THE DEATH PENALTY IMPOSED.

The Murderer of. PIUmI Baa Lost Moon f His Air of Coafldeaeo A Sharp Tilt Between Bis Counsel and the Froaidlag JuaMea. Philadelphia, Nov. 80. In the court of oyer and terminer Judge Arnold re fused to grant Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. II. Holmes, who was convicted on Nov. 3 for the murder In this city on Sept a, 1894, ot B. F. Piteeel, a new trial and sentenced the condemned murderer to death. Promptly at 10 o'clock Holmes, accompanied by his counsel, came Into court He looked careworn and seemed to have lost that air of confidence whioh has clung to him throughout 1I i trying or deaL Court opened with a brief till bePENALTY IMPOSED.

See the clipping

Waterbury Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

W. A. Shoemaker, senior counsel for H. H. Holmes, is ordered to appear in court on Dec. 14 to show cause why he should not be disbarred after Blanche Hannigan testified he paid her $20 to sign a false affidavit claiming Pitezel had spoken of suicide.

Waterbury Democrat · 5 December 1895 · page 1

AFTER HOLMES' ATTORNEY. Shoemaker Cited to Show Canse Why Die Should Not Be Disbarred. Philadelphia, Dec. 5. W. A. Shoe maker, senior counsel for H. H. Holmes, tho convicted murderer of Benjamin F. Pitezel, has been ordered by Judge Thayer to appear in the court of oyer and termi nuk on Dec. 14 and show cause why he should not be disbarred for making a falso affidavit in the Holmes case. On Nov. 18. when Judges Thayer, Wil son and Arnold were engaged in the hear ing of a motion for a new trial for Holmes, Lawyer Shoemaker produced an affidavit signed by Blanche Hannigan in which 6he was alleged to have said that Pitezel had told her he contemplated suicide.

See moreSee less

A sensation was caused when District Attorney Graham called Blanche Hanni gan to the stand, and the latter denied ever having made such an affidavit, but said that she was paid f 20 by Shoemaker to sign her name to the affidavit. Shoe maker was held in $1,500 for suborna tion of perjury, and yesterday's develop ments is but another chapter in the fa mous Holmes case.

See the clipping

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.

The clipping reports that Judge Arnold refused to grant H. H. Holmes, also called Herman W. Mudgett, a new trial for the murder of B. F. Pitezel and sentenced him to be hanged, leaving Gov. Hastings to set the execution date.

Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 5 December 1895 · page 5

Judge Arnold on Saturday Denied the Arnold to-day refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes who vieted of the murder of B. F. Pitezel, in this city, September 2d, 1894. death. said: "Herman W. Mudgetts have you anything to say?" NO HOPE FOR HOLMES. a New Trial Him to Death. Philadelphia, Pa., Nov. 30.— Judge Judge Arnold then sentenced him to In sentencing Holmes Judge Arnold Holmes replied, in a barely audible voice: "I have nothing to say.'' Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence as. follows: "It is the sentence of this court that you be taken hence from whonoe you came and there be hanged by tho neck until 3.

See moreSee less

May God have mercy dead von on your eoul. " on Holmes' face re The expression mained the same. He the court to prison. Gov. Hastings will fix the day of Holmes' execution. to tho Supreme Court will at STRICKEN IN IliS PVLPIT. 6 taken from

See the clipping

Canton Weekly Register · Canton, Ill.

The judge ruled Miss Yorke's testimony admissible since Holmes's marriage to her was void due to prior wives, denied a new trial, and pronounced the death sentence after Holmes declined to speak.

Canton Weekly Register · 5 December 1895 · page 9

JUDGE REFUSES A NEW TRIAL

In reference to Miss Yorke’s elegibility as a witness the judge said that it was the opinion of the. court that Holmes was not only married to the Williamette, Ills., wo man when he wedded Miss Yorke, but that he also had a wife in Gilman, N. 11. j Evidence A <1 in Usable. Therefore the marriage to Miss Yorko was null and void and the cvidenco was admirable. /L’ho opening speech of the district attorney, ho said, was not open to objection. It was the evident intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to tako off the entire Pitzel family in order to secure property belonging to tho murdered man.

See moreSee less

As to tho statement of Mrs. Pitzel tho judge had Instructed tho jury not to be in 11 ucneed by tho woman’s statement. He closed by saying that tho court ap proves the verdict and refuses a new trial. District Attorney Graham then arose and asked that sentence bo pronounced. | Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge! Arnold said: “Herman \V. Mudgotts, havo you any thing to say?'’ Holmes replied in a barely audible voice: 1 “1 have nothing to say.” Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence in the usual form, after which Holmes was taken from the court to prison. Governor Hastings will fix the dif^ of Holmes’execution. An appeal to the supremo court will bo taken at once. Would-Be Bobber* Arrested.

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

The clipping is a damaged fragment reporting that Thayer served a rule on attorney William A. Shoemaker, counsel for convicted murderer H. H. Holmes, to show cause for dismissal, followed by garbled, unrelated text about a church bazaar.

The Portland Daily Press · 5 December 1895 · page 2

Thayer today served a rule upon Attorney William A. Shoemaker, one of the coun sel for the convicted murderer, H. H. Holmes, directing him to show cause why ho should not be dismissed. The rule is completed as yet, but will have by the next shooting night, next Saturday. Tho TnoiYia ormaiof. c\f a wnrtr) oivoil parlor, a coat room, and shooting room, adies of High street church in their restry, opened last evening and was argely attended. The various booths with their many useful and ornamental

See the clipping

Der Nordstern · St. Cloud, Minn.

Printed in German, this report states that a new trial was denied for H. H. Holmes, found guilty of murdering R. F. Pietzel in this city, and that he was sentenced to death.

Der Nordstern · 5 December 1895 · page 4

nes neuen Prozesses für H. H. Holmes, welcher der in hiesiger Stadt erfolgten Ermordung von R. F. Pietzel schuldig befunden wurde, und verurtheilte ihn zum Tode.

See the clipping

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn.

Judge Arnold denied H. H. Holmes's request for a new trial following his Philadelphia conviction for the murder of Pitzel, and formally sentenced him to death. Pennsylvania's governor would set the execution date.

Warren Sheaf · 5 December 1895 · page 2

THE EAST. The firm of S. Clevering & Co., com mission merchants in Philadelphia, failed for $100,000. At Arlington Heights, N J., TAgtaas Colt, a photographer, 6hot MisiTTar rie Pla te and then killed himself. Jeal ousy was the cause. Earth and rock fell at a mine near Carmel, N. Y., killing 14 men A train ran into an open switch at Preble, N. Y., killing the engineer and fatally injuring the fireman. Judge Arnold refused H. H. Holmes, who was convicted in Philadelphia of the murder of Pitzel, a new trial and sentenced him to death.

See moreSee less

Gov. Hast ings would fix the day of execution. the upsetting of a skiff in the ville and California, Pa., Joseph Mcln' tosh and wife, John Pickermip, William Ashton and Mrs. James Stevens were drowned. In Pennsylvania 1.538 persons we re killed on the steam railroads and 10,- 605 injured during the fiscal ye ar ended June 30, 1895.

See the clipping

Warren Sheaf · Warren, Minn.

Judge Arnold in Philadelphia refused H. H. Holmes's request for a new trial after his conviction for the murder of B. F. Pitezel. Holmes had been sentenced to death, and the governor was expected to deny clemency, with Governor Hastings to set the execution date.

Warren Sheaf · 5 December 1895 · page 2

New Trial for Holmes Refused. Philadelphia, Dec. 2.Judge Arnold has refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitzel in this city Sep tember 2, 1894, and sentenced him to death. The governor will all proba bility refuse executive clemency. Gov. Hastings will set the day for the execu tion.

See the clipping

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Judge Arnold of the Oyer and Terminer court in Philadelphia has sealed murderer H. H. Holmes's fate, and that Holmes told his attorney, "Well that settles all."

The Butler Weekly Times · 5 December 1895 · page 4

The Sutton brothers are thought to have been lynched near Unadilla, Ga. An unknown traveling man com mitted suicide on a train en route to Chicago from St. Louis. As a result of last Octobers's earthquake cisterns in parts of the Ohio Valley will not hold water. Governor-elect Bushnell of Ohio predicts that McKinley will be the Republican presidential nominee. The Anchor Line steamer Cali fornia had smallpox and was detain ed at Quarantine off New York. A new toud? woman invaded a New York shooting contest Thanks giving and carried off the turkeys.

See moreSee less

Waverlj (Neb.) citizens publicly denounced a doctor and druggist who eloped with two young ladies. The inauguration of Governor place December 10 with elaborate ceremonies. Mrs. Helen Barnes of Oswego, N. Y., as cashier and clerk, is charged with having robbed her employes of $11,000. Daring a fire in a church at Owensboro, Ky., the congregation continued to worship and maintain' ed perfect order. Between praying for the Arme nians and praying for Bob Ingersoll, the Christian world has the greatest task, short of an armed crusade, it has ever undertaken. Pest-Dispatch A long line of confederate infan try, cavalry and artillery moved through the streets of Nashville, Thanksgiving carrying the stars and stripes. This is additional evidence that the war is over. The fate of murderer H. H Holmes, has been sealed by Judge Arnold of the Oyer and Terminer eourt irmiadeiphia. When the words that sealed his doom were pronounc ing by the court, Holmes turned to his attorney and remarked. "Well that settles all." The business men of St. Louis are makiig an effort to secure the two national conventions, republican and democratic for that city in 1896. For that purpose a big meeting was held Monday night at the Mercantile club roams and $26,000 was sub scribed. C. C. Dickinson, of Henry county has trotted out as a candidate for the Democratic nomination for Con gresB. There are quite a number of other lawyers in the district who are auxiuumy loosing inai way, but we have an idea that DeArmond is still ia the lead. Pleasant Hill Gazette. The official figures from the Ken tucky election show the entire pop ulist vote of the state to be but 16, 911, and is 7,000 short of the vote of 1892. The democratic vote was 163, such a showing in a state election it is not to be wondered at that the chairman of the state populist com rmttee should resign, followed by the county committeemen. In his book - of memories just is sued benator John Sherman makes this bold declaration, which has raised the ire of his friend Genera! Alger, lhe Senator says: "I believe I had conclusive proof that the friends of Gen. Alger substantially purchased the Totes of many of the delegates from the southern states wno hud been instructed by their conventions to vote for me." sou to deliver the annual address tue senior class of the Missouri University is in very bad taste. Bv .this action the boys not only wouc At ' - IS meir momer school deepjv, bu ouiirtu me reputation ol the entire state, and at the same time evince elect Bradley of Kentucky will take : i i i ii , . 962, and republican 172,436. With mi . - ine selection of Kobtrt G. Inger

See the clipping

The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.

Judge Arnold rejected defense objections including Miss Yoke's testimony and the district attorney's opening speech, denied a new trial, and sentenced Holmes to hang, with an appeal to the supreme court planned.

The Monmouth Inquirer · 5 December 1895 · page 2

H. H. HOLMES.

tween .Judge Arnold and Lawyer Rotan, counsel for the defendant. Judge Arnold charged that Mr. Rotan had offered an in sult to the court by briefs to President Judge Thayer and Judge Willson, who had sat with Judge Arnold when Holmes’ counsel had argued for a new trial, but neglected to send him a copy. Mr. Rotan said the briefs had been pre pared hurriedly and if the judge had been overlooked it was a mistake. He said: “X do not want the impression to go forth that I have done wrong.

See moreSee less

I do not want to be attacked that way. There was no disrespect intended when I sent the brief to Judges Thayer and Willson, and as a member of this bar you should have that confidence in me.” Judge Arnold made no further com ment, but proceeded to read the court’s answer to Holmes’ counsel’s reasons for a new trial. He took up the 15 exceptions to the verdict, one pt a time, and dwelt at length upon oaoh. The main reasons for a new trial, which were put forth by the defendant’s counsel, were the admission of the testimony of Miss Yoke, whom Holmes claimed as his lawful wife; the district attorney’s opening speech to the jury, when he brought the murder of the children into the case, and that part of Mrs. Pitezel’s testimony in which she said the last time she saw her children was in the morgue at Toronto. In reference to Miss Yoke's eligibility as a witness, the judge said that it wa3 the opinion of the court that Holmes was not only married to the Wilmette (Ills.) woman, when he wedded Miss Yoke, but that he also had a wife in Gilman, N. H. Therefore the marriage to Miss Yoke was null and void and the evidence was ad missible. The opening speech of the distriot at torney, he said, was not open to objection. It was the evident intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to take off the entire Pitezel family in order to secure property belonging to the murdered man. As to the statement of Mrs, Pitezel, the judge had instructed the jury not to be influ enced by it. Sentenced to Death. He closed by saying that the court ap proves the verdict and refuses a new trial. District Attorney Graham then arose and asked that sentence be pronounced. Holmes was ordered to stand up. Judge Arnold said, “Herman W. Mudgett, have you anytihng to say?” Holmes replied in a barely audible voice, “X have nothing to Bay.” .Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence as follows: “It is the sen tence of this court that you be taken hence from whence you came and there be hanged by the neck until you are dead. May God have mercy on your soul.” The expression on Holmes’ faoe remained the same. He was taken from the court to prison. Governor Hastings will fix the day of Holmes’ execution. An appeal to the supreme court will be taken at once. ■■ H. H. HOLMES. No New Trial.

See the clipping

Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.

This damaged clipping is too jumbled to follow clearly, but it mentions H. H. Holmes seeking a new trial amid references to pessimistic orators, demagogues, voteseekers, and a note handed to an editor for publication.

Turner County Herald · 5 December 1895 · page 1

pessimistic orators and demagag H. H. Holmes a ndw trial, and ic voteseekers have led them to I igfactory way to purchase goods I tor of an exchange for publication. It the next thing in order will be a besides that there is only one satThe following was handed to the edi-

See the clipping

The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.

The clipping, reprinted from a Milwaukee paper, mocks Chicago residents and officials for noticing nothing unusual about a house built with hidden doors, secret passages, and acid-proof vats.

The Madison Daily Leader · 5 December 1895 · page 4

Dommtta Afhltcetan In CBiwgii. The inhabitants of Chicago are the least curious and observing people in the world. According to thoir own newM pajters, they permitted one H. H. Holmes to construct in their city a house so ex traordinary, so full of hidden dix)rs and socret passages anil acid proof vats that it would have attracted thousand* curious visitor* had it been built any where else!. But tbe guilele-sa aus susjieet nothing. Neither the i.t who issued tho building permit nor «!. men who did tho building raw anyihi.: unusual about the houn*.

See moreSee less

What irt matter? Is all Chicago blind, or acid proof vats and secret pavages purt and parcel of the ordinary Chicago dwelling Perhaps there is an interest ing chapter 1 written domestic arehitecu.u* i i Ci —Milv/aukre Sentinel. v 1 i u

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The clipping reports that Mrs. Higginson and young Smith reportedly sailed for Genoa with little money but some jewelry, and separately that Judge Thayer issued a rule for attorney William A. Shoemaker, counsel for convicted murderer H. H. Holmes, to show cause why he should not be disbarred.

The Times · 5 December 1895 · page 7

considerable comment. It is belleved that Mrs. Higginson and voung Smith took passage on the steam ship Columbia for Genoa November A0th. Young Smith, it is said, had very little money when he left home. Mrs. Hig ginson did not have any great amount of ready cash with her, but she did have some valuable jewelry. None of her friends can mecount Jor her conduct ex ules Acainst Shoemaker. PHILADELPHIA, PA, Dec. 4.-Judge Thayer to-day served a rule upon Attors ney William A. Shoemaker, one of the counsel of the convicted murderer, H. H. Holmes, to show cause why he should not be disbarred, : The rule is returnable in the Court of

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

The clipping reports that Judge Arnold refused to grant a new trial to Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, who appeared in court looking careworn, with mention of Miss Yorle's evidence.

Mineral Point Tribune · 5 December 1895 · page 3

HOLMES’ END. EVENTS INDICATE THAT ’TIS DRAWING NEAR. Condemned Man Appears in Court, Looking Careworn—Miss Yorle’s Evidence. Philadelphia, Dec. I.—Judge Arnold yesterday refused to grant anew trial to Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H.

See the clipping

Mineral Point Tribune · Mineral Point, Wis.

The report describes Judge Arnold's rejection of each defense exception, his ruling that Miss Yorke's testimony was admissible since Holmes's prior marriages voided that union, and his pronouncement of the death sentence, which Holmes received calmly before an appeal was planned.

Mineral Point Tribune · 5 December 1895 · page 3

DRAWING NEAR

read the court’s answer to Holmes’ counsel's reasons for anew trial. He took up the fifteen exceptions to the verdict one at a time and dwelt at length upon each. The main reasons for anew trial which were put forth by the defendant’s counsel were the admission of the testimony of Miss Yorke, who Holmes claimed as his lawful wife; the district attorney’s opening speech to the jury, when he brought the murder of the children into the case, and that part of Mrs. Pietzel’s testimony in which she said the last time she saw her children was in the morgue at Toronto.

See moreSee less

In refer ence to Miss Yorke’s eligibility as a witness the Judge said that it was the opinion of the court that Holmes was not only married to the Wlllmette, 111., woman when he wedded Miss Yorke, but that he also had a wife In Gilman, -N. H. Therefore the marriage to Miss Yorke was null and void, and the evi dence was admissible. The opening speech of the district attorney, he said, was not open to objection. It rvas the evident Intention of Holmes, said Judge Arnold, to take off the entire Pletzel family in order to secure prop erty belonging to the murdered man. He closed by saying the court ap proved the verdict and refused anew trial. Judge Arnold then pronounced the death sentence In the usual form. Gov. Hastings will fix the day of exe cution. doom were pronounced in low, impres sive tones. Holmes was unmoved. Dur ing the entire time he Looked the judge squarely in the eye, and as the last, sound died away, he turned to his at torneys and remarked quietly. "Well, that is all.” He was then led from the dock. h taken at once. When the words that sealed his An appeal to the supreme court will

See the clipping

Decorah Public Opinion · Decorah, Iowa

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted in Philadelphia of murdering Benjamin F. Pitezel, was denied a new trial and sentenced to death.

Decorah Public Opinion · 6 December 1895 · page 6

phia of the murder of Benjamin F. Pit "el, was denied a new trial and sen tenced to death. H. H. Holmes, convicted at Philadel

See the clipping

The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich.

H. H. Holmes, convicted at Philadelphia of the murder of Benjamin F. Pitzel, was denied a new trial and sentenced to death.

The Yale Expositor · 6 December 1895 · page 6

H. H. Holmes, convicted at Phlladel phla of the murder of Benjamin F. Pit zel, waa denied a new trial and sen tenced to death.

See the clipping

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · Little Falls, Minn.

A newly dedicated, debt-free $10,000 Catholic church in East Grand Forks burned down after a furnace fire spread while worshipers were inside, with $6,000 insurance covering part of the loss and plans to rebuild.

Little Falls Weekly Transcript · 6 December 1895 · page 3

New Church in Ashes. GRAND FORKS, N. D., Dec. 2.—Sacred Heart Catholic church, East Grand Forks, costing $10,000, dedicated two weeks ago, entirely free from debt, burned to the ground this morning. The flames started from a furnace, and were discovered while the edifice was filled with worshipers. Before the fire department was called out the flames were beyond control. The building 'was insured for $6,000 and will be re­ built. HOLMES IS SENTENCED. Judge Arnold Refuses a New Trial Trial

See the clipping

Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C.

The damaged clipping describes a religious conference with nearly one hundred delegates and an opening sermon, and separately reports that a man convicted in the death of Benj. F. Pitzel was denied a new trial and sentenced to hang, with the execution date to be set by Governor Hastings.

Fisherman & Farmer · 6 December 1895 · page 1

THE MURDERER HOLMES

siding. Nearly one hundred delegates were in attendance, and a large congregation was present to witness the proceed ings. The opening sermon was preached by Rev. P. R. Ander f 1 1 t ry the death of Benj. F. Pitzel, has been refused a new trial and sen tenced to be hanged. The date of execution will be fixed by Governor Hasting5. Praying for Ingersol

See the clipping

The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D.

This damaged clipping lists disjointed items including a photographer's murder-suicide, drownings, mine and railroad accidents, a death sentence confirmation, and statistics on railroad fatalities in Pennsylvania.

The Hope Pioneer · 6 December 1895 · page 2

Colt, a photographer, shot Miss Car rie Plate and then killed'himself. Jeal ousy was the cause. Carniel, N. V., killing 14 men. Preble, N. Y., killing the engineer and fatally injuring the fireman. who was convicted in Philadelphia of the murder of B. F. Pitzel, a new trial and sentenced him to death. Gov. Hast ings would fix the day of execution. Monongahela river between Browns ville and California, L'a., Joseph Mcin tosh and wife. John Pickernup, William Asliton and Mrs. James Stevens were drowned. killed on the steam railroruls and 10, 005 injured during the fiscal year ended June 30, 1S95.

See moreSee less

THE EAST. At Arlington Heights, N J., Thomas Earth and rock fell at a mine near A train ran into an open switch at Judge Arnold refused H. H. Holmes, P.y the upsetting of a skiff in the In Pennsylvania 1.53S persons were

See the clipping

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.

This damaged clipping from the official paper of Burleigh Co. is too fragmentary to follow clearly, but it mentions H. H. Holmes and refers to a wise provision regarding him.

Bismarck Weekly Tribune · 6 December 1895 · page 4

OFFICIAL PAPER BURLEIGH CO. name appears to be mud yet. AND as regards H. H. Holmes, his IT is A wise provision that, we have

See the clipping

Griggs Courier · Cooperstown, Dak. N.D.

H. H. Holmes, convicted in Philadelphia of murdering B. F. Pitzel, was refused a new trial and sentenced to death, with Gov. Hastings to set the execution date, while Joseph Reimean, his daughter, and Ernst Neiver were killed by the cars.

Griggs Courier · 6 December 1895 · page 6

H. H. Holmes, who was convicted in Philadelphia of the murder of B. F. Pitzel, was refused a new trial and sen tenced to death. Gov. Hastings would fix the day of execution. Joseph Reimean and his daughter and Ernst Neiver were killed by the cars

See the clipping

The Columbian · Bloomsburg, Pa.

Judge Arnold refused to grant H. H. Holmes a new trial after his conviction for the murder of B. F. Pietzel in Philadelphia on September 2.

The Columbian · 6 December 1895 · page 8

Judge Arnold refused to grant a new trial to H. H. Holmes, who was convicted of the murder of B. F. Pietzel, in Philadelphia, September 2,

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

Short dispatches report a Paris monument subscription for Pasteur, a small gold deposit under Secretary Carlisle's offer, a Pittsburg postmaster's resignation from a party chairmanship, and a Philadelphia judge's disbarment rule against a murder case attorney.

Richmond Dispatch · 6 December 1895 · page 3

Telegruphile Briefs. | Paris.—An international subscription is about to be opened for a monument to the late M. Pasteur Washington. —S8ince Secretary Carlisle's offer to pay express charges both ways for gold deposited in order to build up the gold reserve, slightly over $500.00 in gold has been deposited in conformity with the offer. Many million dollarg of gold hag been offered by national banks, but the conditions attached have been such that Secretary Carlisle has declined to receive it, Pittsburg, Pa. Postmaster John O'Don nell resigned the chairmanship of the Democratic City Committee.

See moreSee less

It is earned that he had received the following cone cise and plainly -worded letter from Posts master-General Wilson: “We are Informe ed that you are chairman of the Demo cratic City Committee of Pittsburg. You ‘will either have to resign that office or the postmastership.” Philadelphia, Pa. Judge Thayer served a rule upon Attorrey Willlam A, Shoe maker, one of the counsel of the con vicged murderer, H. H. Holmes, to show cause why he should not be disbarred,

See the clipping

The Van Buren Press · Van Buren, Ark.

At the court of Oyer and Terminer in Philadelphia, Judge Arnold refused Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, a new trial for the murder of B. F. Pitezel and sentenced him to death, with the governor to set the execution date.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Van Buren Press · 7 December 1895 · page 2

Is the court of Oyer and Terminer at Philadelphia Saturday Judge Arnold refused to grant Herman W. Mudgett. alias H. H. Holmes, who was con victed on November 2d of the murder in this city on September 2. 1881, of B. F. Pitezel, a new trial, and sentenced the condemned murderer to death. The governor will fix the date of execution.

See the clipping

The Madisonian · Virginia City, Mont.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes, the alleged multi-murderer recently convicted of the murder of B. F. Pietzel, has filed reasons for a new trial.

The Madisonian · 7 December 1895 · page 6

40 YEARS THE STANDARD. An attempt was made to hold up a Great Northern passenger train near £t. Cloud. No booty was secured. The sentence of Captain Henry W. Howgate to four years' imprisonment was confirmed by the supreme court. William Dickerman, publisher of The Counterfeit Money Detector, has been arrested for passing counterfeit money. Broker H. B. Martin was indicted at San Antonio, Tex., charged with at tempting to bribe three Texas congress men. Mrs.Ortleib was held up in broad day light 011 the street in Dallas, Tex., and relieved of a purse and diamonds worth $1,000.

See moreSee less

The Taylor brot hers, the condemned murderers of the Meeks family, were caught with burglar tools in their pos session. At Cincinnati John Kech, while drunk and jealous, shot his wife and then himself. Both are in a dangerous condition Grand jury returned indictments against keepers of s3 gambling houses at St. Joseph, Mo., and there i9 an hegira into Kansas. H. H. Holmes, the alleged multi murderer, who was recently convicted of the murder of B. F. Pietzel, has filed reasons for a new trial. * Systematic attempts were made to wreck trains in the railroad yards at Leavenworth, Kan., by a discharged employe, it is believed. In spite of elaborate precautions by police, several of the guests at the 1 Paget-Whitney wedding are said to have been relieved of valuables by pick pockets. The schedule committee of the West ern Base Ball league will meet in St. Paul Feb. 24. Corbett has resigned the heavyweight championship to Maher and Peter chal lenges Fitxsioimons and Goddard. Ju lian says Fit® will meet him. ■rOKTINff NEW«.

See the clipping

The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · the Dalles, Or.

The clipping reports that the wholesale murderer known as Holmes has been refused a new trial and must be executed, alongside brief unrelated notes on the critical situation in Turkey and a steamship builder seeking fostering.

The Dalles Times-Mountaineer · 7 December 1895 · page 1

HOLMES TO HANG The Wholesale Murderer is Refused The Situation In Turkey Remains Criticala New Trial and Must Stretch Hemp. Steamship Builder Want Fostering

See the clipping

The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted at Philadelphia of murder, was refused a new trial and must be executed for his crimes.

The New Dominion · 7 December 1895 · page 2

H. H. Holmes the notorious mur ducrer convicted at Philadelphia was refused a new trial and will have to swing for his numerous atrocious crimes.

See the clipping

The Manning Times · Manning, S.C.

The clipping, a damaged fragment, states that H. H. Holmes was convicted of first degree murder for causing the death of Benjamin Pietzel and appeared in the court of oyer and (terminer, text cut off).

The Manning Times · 11 December 1895 · page 5

tt, alias H. H. Holmes, who was cc -icted of murder in the first degree I iaving caused the death of Benjan Pietzel. was in the court of oyer a:

See the clipping

The Webster Echo · Addison, W. Va.

The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes, called a multi-murderer, was refused a new trial at Philadelphia and sentenced to be hung, then breaks off mid-sentence.

The Webster Echo · 13 December 1895 · page 4

H. H. Holmes, the multi-mur derer, was refused a new trial at Philadelphia and sentenced to be hung. The only sure way to get the

See the clipping

Pleasantville Weekly Press · Pleasantville, N.J.

The clipping notes that murderer H. H. Holmes calls it a disgrace that he is denied a new trial, while observing he never granted any of his victims one.

Pleasantville Weekly Press · 18 December 1895 · page 2

Murderer H. H. Holmes think it is "a burning disgrace on American crimina procedure” that he is denied a new trial for his life. In his own criminal pro cedure he never granted any of his vic tims a new trial.

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

The clipping reports that an attorney appealed H. H. Holmes's conviction to the supreme court, with argument set for January 1896, and that the Senate confirmed two nominations, though the second item is garbled by OCR errors.

The Morning News · 20 December 1895 · page 1

An Appeal la tbe Holmes Case. Philadelphia. Dec. 19.-An appeal to th* supreme court was taken to-day by At torney Rotan of the counsel for H H Holmes, th# convicted murderer. The ar. gurnent in th* caaa before tbe supreme court Is set down for Monday, Jan. tb. 1896, Two Nominations InslraH. Washington, Dor. 19 -The Nanais, In e*. M-uUve session to-day confirmed the f4. lowing nomination* Willis L Mo ora to be chief of the weather bureau, Wtoc-lock O Garvey, to be an interstate couiui>*>o* SYS ifll Hi j H d/1 llPf 1 VVHfWfPWWIW * 0 1

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says Attorney Rotan filed an appeal to the Supreme Court on behalf of convicted murderer H. H. Holmes, with argument scheduled for January 20th.

The Portland Daily Press · 20 December 1895 · page 5

THE NEW ORGAN was built by the famous Parrand & Vatey Company, the successors of the Roosevelt Co. and is one of the finest in New England. As it is of a most unusual type, its specification and a few descrip tive remarks will undoubtedly prove of interest to organ enthusiasts. The front of the Instrument presents a dignified ap pearance, harmonizing perfectly with the interior of the church. It is a two manual instrument of the first magnitude. The excellence, durability and finish Qf the work in every detail, however insig nificant, has been carried to the highest attainable standard, and the instrument as a whole, is a representative one of the perfection to which the art of organ building has been advanoed, and is in every way worthy of the church in which standard dollars at the Carson mint was always limited and wholly suspended early in 1893, and it is asserted that no suoh amount as $73,000 wag legally ooined in that year.

See moreSee less

The question, the paper says, naturally arises where did these dollars come from, and how did they reach the state treas ury? Did the treasury exchange gold for them, and if so, who reoeived the gold? They were not paid into the treasury in the regular course of business and many hold the opinion that silver bullion to this amount was clandestinely coined into silver dollars, at a profit of about 38 per oent and exchanged for gold in the tivas ury._ Holmes Appeals, ' Philadelphia, Deoember 19.—An appeal to the Supreme oourt Was taken today by Attorney Rotan of the counsel for H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer. Argu ment in the oase is set for January 20ch.

See the clipping

The Scranton Tribune · Scranton, Pa.

An attorney for convicted murderer H. H. Holmes filed an appeal to the Supreme court in Philadelphia, with argument set for Monday, Jan. 20.

The Scranton Tribune · 20 December 1895 · page 1

Appeal In the Holmes Case. Philadelphia, Dee. 19. An appeal to tho Supreme court wa taken today by Attor ney KcKhii. of counsel for H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer. The argument In tho case before 'the Supreme court is set town for Monday, Jan. 20.

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

The clipping, partly garbled, reports that Attorney Rotan filed an appeal to the Supreme Court on behalf of convicted murderer H. H. Holmes, with argument set for Monday, January.

Richmond Dispatch · 20 December 1895 · page 8

An appeal to the Supreme Court was taken today by Attorney Rotan, of coun sel for H. H. Holmes, the convicted mur derer, The proumhant before the Supreme Court, A set down for Monday, January

See the clipping

The Washington Bee · Washington, D.C.

This damaged clipping fragmentarily reports a $168,000 fire in Denver's Kichie block, references an unspecified development in the H. H. Holmes case near Kenton, Ohio, and mentions a man born in 1819 who was reportedly the last to leave the field of Chickamauga.

The Washington Bee · 28 December 1895 · page 1

TELEGRAMS IN BRIEF

A fire in the Kichie block in Den ver, Colo., did $168,000 daraago. The case of H. H. Holmes has been Kenton, O. -He was born in 1819. Pie was the last man that left the field ol Chickamauga.

See the clipping

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

A Philadelphia court hears the case of a lawyer for a convicted murderer, accused of bribing a woman to sign a false affidavit that might have won a new trial, with the lawyer claiming entrapment by the state's attorney's office.

The Kimball Graphic · 28 December 1895 · page 2

ONE OF HOLMES' COUNSEL Hearing of Lawyer Shoemaker, Charged With Unprofessional Con duct. Philadelphia, Dec. 21.—The hearing of the case o( Lawyer William A. Shoe maker, of counsel for H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer, to show cause why he shrould not be debarred for unprofession al conduct in securing affidavits in course of the proceedings growing out of that fa mous case, is the special order in the court of common pleas today, with Judge Thayer and Judge Arnold on the bench. It is charged that Bhoemaker bribedft"' woman not identified with the case to put her signature to an affidavit prepared In his office, which contained allegations that might have resulted In the granting of a new trial to the flend whose hands are believed to be stained with the blood of" at least half a dozen victims.

See moreSee less

Shoemaker claims that he is Innocent of any attempt to deceive the court, that the affidavit had,' been made by the person who brought it to him In good faith, and that the whole job was set up in thfc office of the state's attorney. It is admitted that city detect ives were employed to entrap Shoemaker, but it is said that evidence will be submit ted to the court showing that tho steps were only taken after proof positive that Shoemaker was engaged in crooked work had been obtained. The accused party is a comparatively new member of the bar, having come here from New Tork state less than two years since, and this was the flrst case in which he had figured in court. Washington Evening Star. "Who was it that murdered Hamlet?" asked the young man who Is very misty on his Shakespeare. "Don't ask me," responded the old legitimate star. "Some of the critics were disagreeable enough'to say I did. A Tender Sutyecf.- yfl

See the clipping

In the story →

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · and 5 other papers

One line in a digest of the year’s criminal news: “Holmes convicted of the murder of Pitezel.”

Rock Island Argus · 31 December 1895 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

2. Criminal: Holmes convicted of the murder of Pitezel.

See the clipping

Also printed in 5 papers
  • The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt. · 20 December 1895
  • Birmingham State Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · 29 December 1895
  • The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · 1 January 1896
  • Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 1 January 1896
  • The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 2 January 1896

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A Philadelphia grand jury returned an indictment to Judge Hare charging Shoemaker with attempted subornation of perjury in connection with the Holmes trial, but the clipping breaks off before further detail.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 31 December 1895 · page 2

SHOEMAKER INDICTED. He Must Answer for Attempted Subornation of Perjury in Holmes Trial. Philadelphia, Dee. 30.—The grand jury, today, made return to Judge Hare, in the

See the clipping

The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.

A Philadelphia grand jury returned an indictment against Wm. A. Shoemaker, an attorney for H. H. Holmes, charging attempted subornation of perjury tied to efforts to secure Holmes a new trial.

The Portland Daily Press · 31 December 1895 · page 1

and Italy. Holmes' Counsel Indicted. Phildelphia, December 30.—The grand jury this afternoon mado a returu to Judge Hare in the Quarter Sessions court, of bills acted upon during the past few days. Among the indiotments announced was one against Wm. A. Shoemaker, one of the attorneys for H. H. Holmes, convicted of murder. The bill charges Shoemaker with attempted subornation of perjury in connection with the unsuccessful effort to secure a new trial for Holmes. GROVER CLEVELAND.

See the clipping