This damaged clipping is a garbled list of murder-related items, mentioning a conviction for murdering someone named Blanche, H.H. Holmes being found guilty of murdering someone, and William Kuntz accused of murdering Mrs. Caroline Menn and a girl, but the text is too fragmentary to read fully.
The Climax · 1 January 1896 · page 1
THE MORE STARTLING CRIMES.
rant found guilty of murdering Blanche L?fVAt Philadelphia, H.H Holmes found guilty of murdering B. ?.Vvm Nov. 13TVilIlam Kuntz murdered Mrs, Caroline Menn and girl, at San PranclS50,Theodoreur
This clipping is too damaged and fragmentary to make out, containing only disconnected phrases about a house, a proceeding against people in charge of something called the Defender, and a mention of a new trial for Holmes.
Weekly Union · 1 January 1896 · page 1
in a New York House. i against the people in charge of the NEW YORK, Dec. 30.—1 n the five- { Defender, was commenced this morn to obtain anything of an official char a new trial for Holmes. acter.
This damaged, jumbled clipping reports a Philadelphia grand jury indictment against William A. Shoemaker, one of H. H. Holmes' attorneys, for perjury related to an effort to secure Holmes a new trial, amid other barely legible, unrelated news fragments.
Fritz Krlodmann, tho great Berlin lawyer, an absconder Victims of Turkish atrocities lu Arabklr alon? aro said to yesterday afternoon madn a return to number 2000 Railroad agent stabbed, Judgo Hnro In tlio quarter sessions court, shot and robbed in Watoryllle, O John of tho bills acted upon by them during tho V, Lookwood, a Now York broker, past few duys. Among tho Indictments drowned William H, Wnllls,- a veteran found was ono against William A, Shoe actor, died lu Philadelphia Peter Mu hur's stylo disappointed a big crowd at his Holmes, the convicted murderer.
See moreSee less
The bill benefit tn Xew York Ex-Mayor Lam chnrpes Shoemaker with attempted sub bert of Xow Cumberland, W, Va., unsuccessful effort to secure a now trial arrested on chnrgo of embezzlemont for Holmes. Diphtheria prevalent nt Lynn, Muss. HOLM EH' LAWYER INDICTED. Philadelphia, Dec. St. Tho grand Jury maker, ono of tho attorneys for H. H. ornation of perjury In connection with the
This damaged, fragmentary clipping lists disjointed news items including a murder conviction in San Francisco, a man found guilty of killing someone in Philadelphia, a wreck near Wheeling, a tenement fire in New York, a death, and large fires in Decatur and elsewhere.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 3 January 1896 · page 2
guilty of murder at San 2. H. H. Holmes found Benjamin Pltzel at Phils 8. Four killed In B. & O Ing, W. Va....Four bun' York tenement house fir* 5. Death of Eugene' $800,000 fire at Decatui 5. Republican landsll In New York. snclsco. illty of murder of ilphla. reck near Wheel to death In Newt at Chicago....! .$1,500,000 fire
The clipping lists a day-by-day chronicle of events from November and December, including fires, disasters, deaths, crimes, political news, and football results across American and European cities.
The Mitchell Capital · 3 January 1896 · page 3
November. 1. Earthquake at Rome... .Durrant found guilty of murder at San Francisco. 2. H. H. Holmes found guilty of murder of Benjamin PItzel at Philadelphia. 3. Four killed In B. & O. wreck near Wheel ing, W. Va... .Four burned to death In New York tenement house fire. 6. Death of Eugene Field at Chicago.... $300,000 fire at Decatur, 111. 5. Republican landslide... .$1,500,000 fire' In New York. 6. Forty killed by boiler explosion In De troit, Mich., Journal building... .Ryan fam ily of six die In their burning house at Brooklyn.
See moreSee less
11. Chicago dallies reduce to 1 cent. 10, Twenty killed In a street car accident at Cleveland, Ohio... .Death of Dr. S. F. Smith, author of "America," at Boston.... News of another massacro by Turks in Ar menia 800 slain..-. .Consolidation of Chicago Journal and Press. 19. Furious snow and wind storm In North-' west Lowell, Mass. Dallas, Texas and. Purcell, I. T., haya big fires. 21. $000,000 fire .n Springer Building, Chi cago... .Eugene V. Debs released from Woodstock, 111., jail Sultan of Turkey forced to a peace policy by the powers, after he had countenanced many Armenian massa cres. 22. Five firemen lose life In a $500,000 Chi cago blaze... .Release from jail and enthusi astic reception of E. V. Debs, labor leader, at Chicago... .Foreign fleets rendezvous In the Dardanelles. 25. Tremendous damage at Chicago by storm of snow, sleet and rain all car lines blocked, wires down... .Fire at Chicago does $200,000 damage... .Seventy killed by explo sion In cartridge factory at Palma, Island of Majorca. 20. Three vessels go ashore at Glencoe, 111. crews of 26 men Baved....Riot In Jackson, Mich., prison. 27. Death of Alexandre Dumas, Jr., at Paris. 28. Day of doom for the turkey... .Foot ball games: Michigan beats Chicago Boston' and Chicago, tie Pennsylvania defeats Cor-, nell Purdue defeats Illinois Louisville wins* from De Pauw Columbia Athletic downs Co lumbia University Brown defeats Dart-' mouth. December. 2. Assembling ot Fifty-fourth Congress Reed elected Speaker of the House... .Zero weather In Northwest... .Further massacres in Armenia. 7. 5350,000 fire In San Francisco... .Europe storm-swept British boat and twenty-seven sailors lost off Scotland. 8. $000,000fires in Chicago... .Death of Ge.o A. Sala, London journalist... .Tug Campbell and seven men lost In Lake Superior. 9. Chilton, Wis., razed by lire. 10. St. Louis gets next National Republican Convention... .Sultan permits guard ships to pass Dardanelles... .Harry Hayward hanged at Minneapolis. 11. Burning of Catholic Orphan Asylum at Milwaukee 200 children rescued... .Steamer Germanic sinks the Cambrae, at London no lives lost. ...Mob threatens Kansas Medical College at Topeka, because of grave-robbing. 12. Death of Allen G. Thurmau at Colum bus, Ohio. 15. German ship Athena with a cargo of naphtha explodes off Cape May 14 lives lost. 17. Cleveland's Venezuelan message arouses great enthusiasm at home and astounds Great Britain... .Philadelphia in the hands of a mob during a strike. 18. Explosion on liner St. Paul killed six men and injured five... .House passes $100, 000 appropriation for Venezuela commission ....Rioting in Philadelphia entire street railway service suspended... .Death of Capt. Isaac Bassett, doorkeeper of tlia Senate. 19. Thirty-six lives lost In Newfoundland Ashing fleet by storm... .Forty-three killed In a North Carolina mine... .Tremendous rainfall at Chicago. 20. Panic on Wall street... .Senate unani mously passes House bill for Venezuelan commission... .Cleveland sends financial message to Congress... .Twenty-four miners at Dayton. Tenn., killed... .Unprecedented flood at Chicago.
The fragment names several Venezuelan commission appointees, notes President Cleveland has not yet notified them, and reports a Philadelphia grand jury returned bills to Judge Hare, though the text breaks off before detailing them.
Narragansett Herald · 4 January 1896 · page 1
JUSTICE DAVID J. BREWER. Frederic R. Coudert of New York. Daniel C. Gilman of Maryland, presideat of Johns Hopkins university. President Cleveland has not yet notified the appointees to the Venezuelan commission Collins of Boston. Holmes' Lawyer Indicted. PHILADELPHIA, Pa, Jan. 2—The grand jury made a return to Judge Hare in the quarter sessions court of the bilis acted upon
A Philadelphia grand jury reported indictments to Judge Hare, including one against William A. Shoemaker, an attorney for H. H. Holmes, charging him with attempted subornation, though the clipping is cut off before completing the charge.
East Providence Eagle · 4 January 1896 · page 3
PHILADELPHIA, Pa, Jan. 2—The graud jury made a return to Judge Hare in the quarter sessions court of tke bilis acted upon by them during the past few days. Among the indictments found was one against William A. Shoemaker, one of the attorneys for H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer. The bill charges Shoemaker with attempted sub Holmes' Lawyer Indicted.
A Philadelphia grand jury indicted William A. Shoemaker, one of H. H. Holmes's attorneys, for attempted subornation of perjury. The charge stemmed from an unsuccessful effort to secure a new trial for Holmes, described as the convicted murderer.
Spirit of the Age · 4 January 1896 · page 4
The mlll was owneil and operated by O. Z. Colllns of Boston. Holmea' JUawyer Indiotetl. I'HILADELPUIA, Pa , Jan. 2-Tho grand Jury made a return to Judge Ilare in the quarter sessions court of the blils acted tipon by them during tho past fewdays. Among the indlctments'fpnud was one against Wllllam A. Hhoemter, ono of the attorneys for H. H. Holmes, tbo eonvlcted murderer. The blll obarges Sboemaker with attempted sub ornation of perlury in conMCtion with tbe unsucces3ful effort to sccure n new trial for Holmes.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.
The clipping, a damaged fragment, reports that H. H. Holmes' appeal from his first-degree murder conviction for the alleged killing of Benjamin F. Pitezel was called in Philadelphia on January 7.
The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 8 January 1896 · page 3
Phlladelphia.Jan. 7.--The appeal of H. H. Holmes from' his conviction of mur der in the first degree for the alleged killing of Benjamin F. Pitezel was call Holme' Appeal.
The clipping mixes a brief note on H.H. Holmes's murder appeal with a fragmentary, garbled account of an officer named Groff being attacked by a would-be highwayman and his accomplices.
The Morning Times · 8 January 1896 · page 1
of the llaarlng. Philadelphia, Jan. 7. The appeal of H.H. Holmes from his conviction uf murder in tho first degree for the alleged killing of Benjamin F. Pitezel was called to the attention of the State supreme court today ny his counsel, tjamuel 1'. Kotan. Mr. Rotnn-stated to the court that under Its rules the appeal would come up for argument on the 20th It stant and by tbe reouirenient of another rule he would be compelled to have his liaper, books and all thestrengthot his right arm and knocked him down.
See moreSee less
Then the would-be highway man arose to his feet with the help of lha inspector, who quickly put the nippers on his man. - Then it was that three other men. pals of the vanquished bandit, rushed to his aid anil made Joint war on Grorr. One was armed with a stout club with rough bark on it, and he used this over the hands and arms of Groff, with such effect that bo had to release the man whom he had ar
A Philadelphia dispatch dated Jan. 7 reports that the Supreme Court has set Feb. 3 as the hearing date for H. H. Holmes's appeal of his murder conviction.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 8 January 1896 · page 2
Sets Hearing on Appeal of the Convicted Murderer Holmes for Feb. 3. Philadelphia, Jen. T.—The appeal of H. H. Holmes from the conviction of murder SUPREME COURT.
This damaged clipping mixes disjointed fragments referencing Armenian relief efforts, a telegram to a president at Pretoria about a reform committee, a motion for a new trial for someone named Holmes based on new evidence, and a wet, damaged ship cargo being jettisoned.
The Portland Daily Press · 8 January 1896 · page 1
relations was animated by a most earn Marshal Campos Sends a Telegram De est desire to relieve the Armenians, if Tho motion to be heard is for a new alone to himself and official associates. at Pretoria, to President Kruger, con trial for Holmes on the ground of newly It was simply a matter of conjecture discovered evidence and because the ver as to why that justice should allow his taining the reform committee’s formal go is wet and she will jettison that por tion of it in the after hold whloh Is dam
The clipping reports that H. H. Holmes's counsel, Samuel P. Rotan, asked the State Supreme Court in Philadelphia for a continuance of Holmes's murder-conviction appeal, citing the defendant's poverty and difficulty preparing testimony copies, and requested leave to substitute typewritten copies for the court's use.
Richmond Dispatch · 8 January 1896 · page 3
APPEAL OF H. H. HOLMES, Case Set for the First Monday in QUIEN ST JY: THE, WT Ty Tiana. TT PHILADELPHIA, PA. January 7. The appeal of H. H. Holmes from his conviction of murder in the first degree for the alleged killing of Benjamin F. Pietzel was called to the attention of the Sta'te Supreme Court to-day by his coun sel, Samuel P. Rotan. Mr. Rotan stated to the court that under its rules the appeal would come up for argument on ‘the 20th instant, and by the requirement of other rules he would be compelled to have his papers, books, and all such matter placed in the hands of the District Attorney by Thurs day nxt.
See moreSee less
He asked the court for a con tinuance of the case, because, by reason of the poverty of the defendant, he had not been able to prepare copies of the testimony, which cover from 300 to 90 typewritten pages, and he also asked the court for leave to substitute typewritten copies of the testimony for the use of ‘he court and counsel, instead of having it CREE. - February. Fehruary.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The clipping lists miscellaneous news items and temperature readings for Thursday and Friday, including deaths, an indictment, an earthquake, a yacht sailing alone, and a grandstand collapse injuring people at Louisville, Ky.
Delaware Gazette and State Journal · 9 January 1896 · page 6
SEPTEMBER
State convention. Return of Thomas F. Bayard. Jr., fr«mi Europe. Thursday, Sept. 12—-Temperature 78, 91, 92, (56 »leg. Death of Prof. Her Koe. The Defender sailed alone. IfII. Holmes indicted f«ir murder. Earthquake in Tonnessoe. Alleged Cuban filibusters indict»-»!. Many peo ple injured at Louisville, Ky., by tho collapse of a grand stand. Friday, Sept. 13—Temperature 74, 71, 73, 50 deg. Death of C. T. R. Bates.
A report that Holmes murdered a man named Barriers years ago in Morgantown, WV was investigated after Holmes wrote from prison denying he was there. The mystery was resolved when it emerged the man in question was named Mudgett (one of Holmes's aliases) and the supposed victim had simply lost money gambling and fled, unharmed.
The Journal · 9 January 1896 · page 3
l HOLMES INNOCENT FOR ONCE. Supposed Murder of a Man in Morgantown Has Been Explained. Parkersburg, W. Va.. Jan. 8.?H. H. Holmes, the murderer, now Under sen
A compilation of brief news items from January 8 notes that H. H. Holmes received a continuance on his appeal from conviction. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated national and international news briefs.
Danqiiet tendered to Governor Coffin of Connecticut in New York H, H. Holmes got a oontlnu ince on his app:l from conviction McGotutl ks to his confossion of tho killing of H ti Hoss ot Troy, N. Y Patnl shooting affair at a wedding nt Vatrbury, Conn All tho old city officials nt New port, It. I., re-elected five I one Deadlock lu tho Kverett (Mnss.) hoird of aldermen over the choice of president Lord Dunravon s.ild to have lost ensto In Kngland T. W. Douglas of Peru, la., a defaulting banker, arrested at Cannn (bilgun, N.
See moreSee less
Y Vermont hotel keepers nrgnul7e to oppose tho prohibitory law Fees for liquor llconscs In Ne,v York city rnlscd to the top notch Kngland claims tho Islnnd ot Trlnldr.de ns her own prop 01 ty, giving flint ns reason of refusal to arbitrate Mlllis (Mass.) Savings bank closed by order of bank commissioners Charges against the Manchester (N 11.)
The Hood River Glacier · Hood River, Or. · and 1 other paper
This damaged clipping lists brief news items including a St. Louis collision killing two and fatally injuring three, a central U.S. earthquake, a Rome earthquake, and guilty verdicts for Durrant in San Francisco and H. H. Holmes in Philadelphia for Pitzel's murder.
The Hood River Glacier · 10 January 1896 · page 1
Two killed, three fatally hurt. In a col lision In St. Louis. 81. Earthanake throughout the central belt of the United States; no fatalities, little dam age, ..." 1 "' November, 1. Earthquake a't Rome. .. .Durrant found guilty of murder at San Francisco. i. H. H. Holmes round guilty or muraer oi Benjamin Pltzel at Philadelphia.
The Corvallis Gazette · Corvallis, Or. · 9 January 1896
The Oregon Mist · St. Helens, Or.
A garbled digest of November happenings lists an earthquake at Rome, murder convictions of Durrant and Holmes, fatal wrecks and fires, Eugene Field's death, and a $300,000 fire at Decatur, Ill.
The Oregon Mist · 10 January 1896 · page 1
age. November. 1, Earthquake at Rome. ,, .Durrant fonnd OMilltv nf murder st Rsji Francisco. 2. H. H. Holmes found guilty of murder of uenjamin ruse at Philadelphia. 8. Four killed in B. k O. wreck near Wheel ing, W, Va. .. .Four burned to death In New York tenement house fire. A. Death of Eugene Field at Chicago..,.' $300,000 Ara at Decatur. III.
The clipping reports that Holmes obtained a continuance on his appeal from conviction, that McGough maintains his confession to killing Robert Ross of Troy, N.Y., and references a fatal shooting affair.
The United Opinion · 10 January 1896 · page 6
Holmes got a continuance on his appeal from conviction McGough sticks to his confession of the killing of Robert Ross of Troy, N. Y Fatal shooting affair
The Cape Girardeau Democrat · Cape Girardeau, Mo. · and 3 other papers
Among a column of news briefs listing killings and suicides through the year, this report notes that on Nov. 2 at Philadelphia, H. H. Holmes was found guilty of murdering B. F. Pitzel.
The Cape Girardeau Democrat · 11 January 1896 · page 7
THE MORE STARTLING CRIMES. Jan. 8 State Treasurer W. W. Taylor, of South Dakota, missing; accounts snort Jan. 14 John Harris and wife killed their baby anil themselves to avoid starvation ue;.r paxton. Neb. Jan. IS Samuel Hotelilng. of Rolling Oi-.-cn, Minn., killed his wife and her par ents: was then slain by pursuers. Mar. 12 Five men killed in riot by (white) dock laborers In New Orleans: was result of race war Nine Italians killed by American miners in the Walsenburg (Col.) district. Apr. 12 Four men killed In railway lalKirers' riot at Siloam Springs.
See moreSee less
Ark. Apr. 13 Henry Long shot his wife and brother-in-law. Joe Whidington, then killed himself, at Purvis. Miss.: Jealousy John Sejpar. of Cleveland, killed Carl Richter. wounded Albert Kichter.a brother.and two others, then killed himself. ...Mike Pfeifle. of Tacoma, Wash., killed his sweetheart. Moggie Koender, then himself; Jealousy. Apr. 2." Robert Owen killed his wife and Dr. J. F. Simmons at Houston, Tex., then himself. Apr. 3 Fulton Gordon killed his wife and Archie Brown, son of governor of Ken tucky. In bawdv house In Louisville James Young killed his wife at Hoosier ville. then went to Brazil. Ind.. and killed himself Abbott and John Fulgham (brothers) and Beauregard Towr.send and his son killed in pitched battle at Newbern, Tenn. Mav fi James Herbert, of New York, killed his wife, then drowned himself: jealousy In discussion over text-books in selieolhouse near omo. nl., Benjamin Rate! iff e killed Samuel K. Taylor. L. F. Mo Curdy and George D. Wyatt. all members of school board. Jun. b (. D. Moore, postmaster at Keavy. Ky., and Tipton Steern. assistant postmaster, killed each other in duel. Jun. l." Frank Williams, of Francis. Kan., attempted to kill his wife. Mils Alice Smiih and William Smith, then killed his two children and self. jun. ! While insane Mrs. Fanford Glllls poisoned her three children and self, near Shellsburc, la. Jul. 1 At Jeffersonville. Ind.. Mrs. Nancv Bennett poisoned her two children and self. Jul. 4 Augustus Fields, of Meadowville, Mo., killed wife, child ar.d self. J.d. 23 Three whites and six Indians killed in fight at Jackson's Hole. Wyo Four killed In a quarrel at a social party at Union Itidee. W. Va. Jul. 27 Henry Bradshaw killed his wife, daughter and self, near Paris, Tex. Aug. 4 Forty negroes wounded In battle between whites and blacks, at Spring Valley, 111. Aug. 24 Three killed and 1 fatally wounded in fight between Con and Thomas families near Whltesbury. Ky. Aug. 3') Jack Wilson shot his wife at Battle Creek. Mich., then killed himself. Oct. 9 Thomas Spoor, of Pike county, Ga.. killed his nine children. Oct. 27 Sheriff's force firing on mob at Tifiin. O.. killed Christian Mott and Henry bhultz. Nov. 1 At San Francisco. Theodore Dur rant found guilty of murdering Blanche Lamont. Nov. 2 At Philadelphia. H. H. Holmes found guilty rf murdering B. F. Pitzel. Nov. 13 William Kuntz murdered Mrs. Caroline Menn and her 10-year-old girl, at Laredo, Tex. Nov. 23 Hans Allen killed William Cross, wounded a girl and killed himself, near Mc Gregor. Ia.: Jealousy Fred Banker killed Miss Cora Harrison, then himself, at Amsterdam. N. Y. ; jealousy. Dee. 7 Near Dexter. Ia., Grant Hlhbs shot his wife, then killed himself: insanity. Dec. 9 August Nibleen fatally shot An nie Bundy, at Peshtigo, Wis., then killed himself William Ray killed his wife and self at Coal Creek. Col. Dec. 10 Harry Hayward hanged at Minneapolis for murder of Catherine Glng. Dec. 15 Mose Goodrich fatally shot his wife at Philadelphia,-then killed himself. Dec 18 Rensselaer Tripp killed George Calpln at Cortland, X. Y., then shot him self. Dec. -Mrs. Mary Grossman at Ann Arbor, Mich., drowned her child and self. Dec. 20 Near Castana, George Wolfe
San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex. · 5 January 1896
The Coconino Weekly Sun · Flagstaff, Ariz. · 9 January 1896
Western Kansas World · Wakeeney, Kan. · 11 January 1896
Staunton Spectator · Staunton, Va.
This damaged fragment describes an attempted arrest of W. G. Hogan by Berger and Harry Brumfield that ended in gunfire killing Hogan and wounding Berger, and mentions a Lincoln county, W. Va. case involving a man named Charles H. H. Holmes, but the text is too incomplete to summarize further.
Staunton Spectator · 15 January 1896 · page 2
Justice Harlan in 1893. Berger and Harry Brumfield attempt ed to arrest W. G. Hogan. In the shooting which followed Hogan was killed and Berger seriously wounded. In Lincoln county, W. Va., Charles H. H. Holmes, the notorious murder
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 2 other papers
A Chicago report quotes a detective claiming evidence that Holmes committed no Chicago murders, that several alleged victims are alive in Iowa, Michigan and Chicago, and that Pitezel may still be living.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Evening Star · 22 January 1896 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
PITEZEL SAID TO BE ALIVE. Efforts to Secure Evidence for H. H. Holmes.
CHICAGO, January 22.--A local paper says: "If the story told by Robert Corbett, a private detective who has been in this city for a few weeks working on the Holmes case, is true, H. H. Holmes is not guilty of committing a single murder in Chicago.
See moreSee less
"The Pitezel murder case, which is now pending in the supreme court of Pennsylvania, will come up for a hearing within a few days, and the defense is making a determined effort to secure the reversal of the finding of the jury and lower court on technical grounds.
"If these fail, then the information gathered by the defense will be resorted to, and it is believed that they will be able to prove beyond a doubt that his alleged victim, Benjamin Pitezel, is alive and living within one hundred miles of Chicago at the present time.
"Corbett, who has been running down the various stories charging Holmes with murder in Chicago, claims to have evidence showing that H. H. Holmes did not commit a single murder in the city of Chicago, and that Holmes' confession regarding the death of Nannie Williams is substantially correct. The girl was beyond a doubt killed on July 6 at the flat occupied by Holmes and Minnie Williams, at No. 1220 Wrightwood avenue. The body was then taken to the 'Castle' and destroyed by fire. The skull found by the police at the 'Castle' was that of Nannie Williams.
"Corbett also makes the following statements: That Minnie Williams is alive and has been seen on the streets of this city within the past two weeks; that Emeline Cigrand is alive, and is now living in Iowa; that Julia Conners and her daughter Pearl are alive, and at present living in Michigan, and that Holmes will be able to prove a complete alibi in the murder of Howard Pitezel at Indianapolis.
"In concluding his statement, Corbett said: 'Holmes is a peculiar man, and his relations with the various young women are the cause of his present predicament.'"
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind. · 23 January 1896
Abendblatt · Chicago, Ill.
A German-language report describes an English newspaper's two-column sensational article claiming that private detective Robert Corbett possesses undeniable proof about H. H. Holmes, sentenced to death in Philadelphia for the murder of Benjamin Pitzel, though the clipping breaks off mid-sentence before revealing the claim.
Abendblatt · 22 January 1896 · page 2
Erstaunliche Mittheilung
Eine englische Zeitung tischte heute Mor— gen itren Lefern eine sonderbare Sensation auf, der sie zwei ganze Spalten gewidmet hatte. In dem Artitel, wenn man ihn so nennen will, behauptet jenes Blatt, daß ein Privat-Detectiv, Namens Robert Corbett, der sich zur Zeit hier aufhalte, die untrüg— lichsten Beweise dfür in Händen habe, daß H. H. Holmes, der vielbesprochene mörder, der jetzt in Philadelphia von Ben—- jamin Pitzel zum Tode verurtheilt ist, gar
The clipping reports that a private detective named Robert Corbett claims he can prove that H. H. Holmes, under sentence of death at Philadelphia for the Pitzel murder, is innocent.
Canton Weekly Register · 23 January 1896 · page 8
England through rose colored spectacles. , She admires everything there but tho clij Says Holmes Is Innocent, CHICAGO, Jan. 23.—Robert Corbett, a private detective, says ho can prove that H. H. Holmes, now under sentence of death at Philadelphia for the Pitzel mur
The fragmentary clipping reports a private detective's claim that Benjamin Pietzel is still alive and that Holmes did not commit murder in Chicago, with the Pietzel case pending in a supreme court, though the text is garbled and incomplete.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 23 January 1896 · page 6
HOPE FOR HOLMES
BENJAMIN PIETZEL IS STILL ALIVE jaid to Be Living Near Ohquo—:llnnlo Robert Corbett, a private detective who has been in this city a few weeks working on the Holmes case is true. H. H. Holmes is not guilty of committing a single mur der in Chicago. The Pietzel murder case s fiow pending in the supreme court of Willlams and Other Victims Are Also Accounted For—Holmes Told the Truth About Death of Nannie Willinms—Story Reads Like Romance, =~ = ! CHICAGO, Jan. 28.—1 f the story told by
The clipping reports Corbett's claim that Holmes committed no Chicago murders, that several supposed victims are alive in various locations, and that Holmes can prove an alibi in the Pitezel case.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Foster's Daily Democrat · 23 January 1896 · page 6
.prove beyond a doubt that his alleged vic ;m. Benjamin Pietzel, is alive and living within 100 miles of Chicago at the present time. . : + Corbett, who has heen running down the various stories charging Holmes with murders in Chicago, claims to have evi dence showing that H. H. Holmes did not | commit a single murder in the city of Chi eagn, and that Holmes’ confession re garding the death of Nannie Williams is | substantially correst. The girl was be-} yond a doubt killed on July 6 at a flat oc cupied by Holmes and Minnie Williams | at 1220 Wrightwood avenue.
See moreSee less
The body was then taken to the ‘‘castle’” and de stroyed by fire. The sknll found by the police at the “‘castle’ was that of Nannie IWilliams, as the marks and fracturcs ghow, ment; That Minnie Williams is alive and | has been scen on the Streets of this city within the past weeks; that Emeline Cigrand is alive and is now living in Jown; that Julia Conners and her daugh ter Pearl are alive and at present living in Michigan; and that Holmes will be able to prove a complete alibi in the murder of Howard Pitezel at Indianapolis. said: ‘“Holmes is a peculiar man and bis celations with the various women was the sause of his present predicament.’’ Corbett also makes the following state In concluding his statement, Corbett
The clipping reports that Corbett, investigating murder charges against H. H. Holmes, claims evidence that Benjamin Pitzel is alive near Chicago and that Holmes committed no murder.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Salt Lake Herald · 23 January 1896 · page 1
IS HOLMES GUILTY Strange Story Told By One Robert Corhett CHICAGO Jan 22A local paper says saysI the story told by Robert Corbett a private detective who has been in this city fo a few weeks working on I the Holmes case is true H H Holmes i is not guilty of committing a single I murder in Chicago The Pitzel murder case is now pend ing in the supreme court of Pennsyl vania and will come for a hearing within a few days and the defense is making a determined effort to secure the technical grounds If these fail then the information gathered by the defense will be resorted to and it is believed that they will be able to prove beyond a doubt that his alleged victim Benjamin Pitzel is alive and alve living within a radius of 100 miles of the city of Chicago at the present time I Corbett who has been running down the various stories charging Holmes with murder in Chicago claims to have evidence showing that H H Holmes did not commit a single murder I in the city of Chicago and that I Holmes confession regarding the death of Minnie Williams ts substantially I correct that the girl was beyond a doubt killed on July 6 at the flat oc i cupied by Holmes and Minnie Williams lams at 1220 Wrightwood avenue The body was then taken to the castle and burned The skull found by the police at the castle was that of Minnie Williams lams as the mark and fractures show Corbett also makes the following statement 1 TiHat Nannie Williams is alive and I I has been seen on the streets of this I Emiline Cigrand is alive and is now I city within the past two weeks that living in Iowa that Julia Connors and her daughter Pearl are alive and at I present living in Michigan and that Holmes will be able to prove a com I plete alibi in regard to the murder of Howard Pitzel at Indianapolis is cer t i tain Holmes is a peculiar man and i 1 his relations with various young wo i men was the cause of his present pre dicament
The item sarcastically invites survivors of H. H. Holmes to stand and be counted, then remarks that matchmaking agencies remain a chief source of income for divorce lawyers.
The American Citizen · 24 January 1896 · page 4
I All those who have not been mur dered by H. H. Holmes will please rise .and remain standing until counted. 11TE sc -called agencies for the pro •notion of matrimony are still one of the chief sources of income of the I divorce law vers.
Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. M. Bullock of Indianapolis claims to be able to prove that H. H. Holmes is not a murderer.
The United Opinion · 24 January 1896 · page 7
Funeral services of Charles Theodore Russell In the Shepard Memorial church, Cambridge, Mass Death of Hon. John B. Alley of Lynn, Mass General Weyler Hppointed to succeed Campos In Cuba and ca -ry on the war with vigor Triple alliance unshaken by England's hostility to Germany Abysslnians thought to be pteparing another attack Uicn Italian forces Hartwell Kendall, formerly of Boston, killed lilm.se If In Chicago Business block in Jersey City burned. Loks, $70,000 Horseman Kneebs' case may lead to diplomatic communications between Berlin and Washington Gov ernor Busiei of New Hampshire to run for United St.itcs senate in 18D7 English papers talking of arbitration in the Ven ezuela matter Arrival of United States cruiser Baltimore (from Honolulu) at San Franvipco Brooklyn church ex tends a call to Rev.
See moreSee less
Leighton Parks, D.D., of Boston Two big apartment houses In Chicago burned. Loss, $300,000 Rev. James F. Albion installed as pastor of the First Universalist church of Mai den, Mass Lewis Bennett, the famous Indian runner, known as "Deerfoot," deatl Rumor that Portugal was to sell Delagoa bay to Great Britain officially de nied Preparation., for '99 Christian En deavor convention tygun at Washington -Young man accidentally killed by his brother near Manchester, N. H Fire man killed in a collision of freight and passenger trains near Von Ness station, N. Y H. M. Bullock of Indianapolis claims to bo able to prove that H. H. Holmes is not a murderer Earthquake shock felt in Colorado African M. E. churches of Boston and vioinlty united in lonoringthe memory of Bishop Way man -Dedication of the new chapel at the Homo for the Aged Poor in Somerville, Moss Active no-license campaign to be conducted in Watervllle, Me. Monday, Jan. 20.
The clipping reports that witnesses living in Michigan may help Holmes prove a complete alibi regarding the murder of Howard Pitzel, and notes his relations with young women caused his present predicament.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Dalles Weekly Chronicle · 25 January 1896 · page 1
OTHER REPORTED VICTIMS ALIVE
living in Michigan, and that Holmes will be able to prove a complete alibi in regard to the murder of Howard Pitzel "Holmes was a peculiar man, and his relations with various young women was the cause of his present predicament"
This is a column of miscellaneous political and local filler items, not a report on the Holmes case itself. It includes a passing joke suggesting Spain 'turn H. H. Holmes loose' on Cuban insurgents, using his name as shorthand for a notorious killer.
Fort Worth Gazette · 25 January 1896 · page 4
The Investigation1 of the yacht com mittee indicate that If there was any crookedness about the races It was not on board the Defender Russia would be glad to take charge of the Armenian matter if tho other nation of Europe would keep their hands off Fngland docs not care to purchase Cuba She has rows enough of her own on hand Just now without buying another If Spain wants to get rid of tho In surgents she should Insure their lives and turn H H Holmes looso on the Island One of the good resolves Fort Worth should make In the -beginning of 1806 Is when It wants anything to go after It The flying squadron of Dallas consist ing of the flagship Harvey la ctlll safe ly anchored on the Trinity IIae an Unrivraliiiitllnir New York Jan 2t A special to tho Herald rrom Berlin aa8 A Turkish functionary asserts that no alliance exists between Turkey and Russia but there is an understanding between the two countries of so intimate a character that it practically amounts to the same
The clipping reports on new evidence in H. H. Holmes's appeal, a suspicious man named R. M. Robb caught on Judge Brown's porch, upcoming postoffice inspector and civil service exams, and a marriage performed by Magistrate Johnston.
The Indianapolis Journal · 29 January 1896 · page 3
poses. Movements of Holmes. Henry W. Bullock has been going over the tracks of H. H. Holmes, the Tletrel murderer. Th petition for a new trial for th convicted man comes up in th Su preme Court of Pennsylvania-next Monday. The attorneys of Holmes have been scour ing the country for evidence which may throw a different light on the case. Yes terday a letter wa,s received from Judge Marvey, of St. Ijouis, Indicating that Holmes was in that city Oct. 2 and 3. There is a letter In evidence which indicates that Holmes was In Chicago on the morning of Oct.
See moreSee less
11. Holmes claims that he has a chain of evidence showing he could not have murdered Howard Pietzel-at the time and place stated and the murder must have been committed by the mysterious Hatch. Found on Judjre Ilrowna Porch. Patrolman Robinson noticed a man try ing the doors of several houses in th northeast j-art of town yesterday morn ing. Upon seeing th officer, the man fled precipitately. Later the patrolman saw him on the porch of Judge Brown's house, corner of Broadway and Butler street. When taken in custody he remonstrated against his arrest as an outrago and de clared that he was an cvld frleud of Judge Brown. Judge Brown declared he did not know th fellow. Th man said his name was R. M. Robb, but would tell little about himself. Tae police believe be Is th man who has bcn robbing dwellings In the northeast part of town the past few days. - Postofllce Inspectors Examination. To-morrow there will be a special civil service examination at the postoffic for the purpose of filling two vacancies in th ranks of postoffic .Inspectors. This is a ' good position and one much sought after, but requires that the applicant should have had experience In postal work. There ar onlr two candidates for th places thus far. although more may make application to-day. Next Tuesday there will b a general clvll servlce examination, held In Y. M. C. A. Hall, for clerks and carriers in tho local postofllce. Never Knew Ilia Parents. Magistrate Johnston yesterday performed another marriage ceremony, uniting Wil liam A. Lundra and Ida R. Case. Th couple were rather youthful, the bride being but seventeen and th groom but twenty years old. Lundra said be was a peddler. His father and mother he had never known, he said, as they died while he was an in
This damaged clipping mixes disjointed fragments referencing a revolution, a Chinese native, a mayor willing to run for office, President Cleveland accepting an invitation, and Holmes' alleged victims, but the text is too scrambled to summarize coherently.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Morris Tribune · 29 January 1896 · page 1
CRIMINAL NEWS.
fearful about the outcome of the revo Confessed and Implicated Many. OF lution, for tbey are shipping large sums Kwee Che Soe, a native of China, now i Mayor V7albridge of St. Louis has dent Cleveland has accepted an invita all of H. H. Holmes' alleged victim? announced his willingness to run for are alive. tion from Attorney W. W. Foote to
Randolph Enterprise · Beverly, W. Va. · and 1 other paper
A Chicago paper reports detective Robert Corbett's claims that Holmes committed no Chicago murders, with several supposed victims alive while Nannie Williams was killed by her sister in jealousy.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Randolph Enterprise · 29 January 1896 · page 1
, committing n single murder in Chi | now pending in the Supreme Court | for a hearing within a few days. , ! The information gathered by the HOLMES AQ^IN. All Hb'Dnpimnl Victim* Sold to iM Alin, A ItoKttln'i Rtmarlnlilt Story, A Chicago paper prints the fol lowing: If the story of Robert Corbett Is trne.II. H. Holmes is not gnilty of cago. The Pietzel murder case is of Pennsylvania and will come up defense, it is believed, will enable it to prove that the alleged victim, Benjamin Pietzel, is alive and liv ing within a radius of 100 miles of the city of Chicago.
See moreSee less
Robert Cor bett, apiivato detective, has been in the city several days working on the Holmes case. He has several letters from Holmes and is working to run down the various stories charging Holmes with murder in Chicago. He claims to have evi dence showing that H. H. Holmes did not commit a single murder In the city of Chicago, and that Holmes’ confession regarding the death of the Williams girl is sub stantially correct. Ho says that Minnie Williams is alive and has been seen on the streets of Chicago within the past two weeks. She had a child and is now llv »ng in the city of Chicago. Nannie Williams in dead, and was beyond doubt killed on July 0 at the Hat occupied by Holmes and Minuie Williams. Holmes’ statement that she was killed in a tit of jealousy by her sister is beyond doubt true. The Iwdy of Nannie Williams was tak en to the “Castle” at Hixty third and Wallace st reets and destroyed by fire. The skull found by the police at the “Castle” was that of Nannie Williams, ns the marks and fractures show. Emeline Cigrand is alive and is now living in Iowa, and her friends know her where abouts. Pearl Connors is alive and is with her mother in Michigan. Julia Connors is alive and at present living in Michigan. The detective clai iub that Holmes will be able to prove a complete alibi in regard to the murder of Howard Peitzel at Indiauapolis.