As the Papers Told It

H. H. Holmes · The full archive

February 1896

28 articles

In the story →

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Mr. Rotan argued before the court that Holmes's conviction should be overturned, citing lack of trial funding, improper admission of testimony about unrelated crimes, disputed competency of a witness named Miss Yoke, and errors in the judge's charge to the jury.

Evening Star · 3 February 1896 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

HEARING HIS APPEAL

Another Page in the History of the Holmes Case.

See moreSee less

BEFORE THE SUPREME COURT

Argument Regarding the Evidence on the Trial.

REVIEWING THE AFFAIR

PHILADELPHIA, Pa., February 3.—Another page was turned today in the manifold misadventures of H. H. Holmes, murderer. The supreme court of the state listened to a long and tedious argument on the appeal taken by the defense from the verdict of murder in the first degree, rendered last November.

Since that time the lower court refused a motion for a new trial, the sentence of death was passed upon Holmes and arrangements were set on foot to expeditiously remove the extraordinary criminal from the face of creation. Even condemned murderers have rights, however, and Holmes' lawyers fought at every step. Today is next to the last. Should the court affirm the decision of the jury Governor Hastings may be appealed to for executive clemency, and, should he decline to interpose, then Holmes must hang.

For some time prior to the opening of the court at 11 o'clock this morning, a big gathering filled the room. Promptly upon the stroke of the hour the court, clad in its sable gowns, entered. All the judges were present, headed by Chief Justice Sterrett. The others are Justices Williams, Green, McCollum, Mitchell, Dean and Fill.

The commonwealth was represented by District Attorney Graham and Assistant District Attorney Barlow.

Samuel P. Rotan conducted the opening argument for the appeal, and associated with him was R. O. Moon. William A. Shoemaker, originally the senior counsel for Holmes, who became involved in a charge of procuring the production of false testimony in the case, did not appear.

Mr. Rotan began the proceedings. First he recited to the court the details of the charges against Holmes, and the conduct of the recent trial. In support of the appeal it was urged that the verdict was against the law and the evidence. Upon the finding of the bodies of the Pitezel children, counsel declared, the commonwealth had jumped to the conclusion that Holmes had murdered Pitezel, although there was no testimony to support such an accusation. He referred to the unsuccessful applications by counsel for a continuance of the trial, and their withdrawal as a consequence of the court's refusal. They had wanted the case postponed because they suffered from a lack of funds and could not get all their witnesses. Eventually they had been obliged to go to trial practically without a defense.

The most important fact dwelt upon by counsel, however, was the introduction of irrelevant evidence, regarding the other crimes charged against Holmes, and having no connection with the death of B. F. Pitezel, for whose murder Holmes was on trial.

At the very outset, Mr. Rotan declared, this tremendous error had been made by District Attorney Graham, in his opening address to the jury, when, because of their temporary withdrawal, the prisoner was without counsel. In that speech Graham went over all the outside crimes, and even went so far as to intimate that Holmes had seduced little Alice Pitezel in the house of Mrs. Alcorn, 1905 North 11th street, where he afterward had his alleged wife, Miss Yoke, or Mrs. Howard. All this testimony was ruled out by the court when offered.

The next point taken up was the testimony of this Miss Yoke. The defense objected to this on the ground that she was the legal wife of Holmes, and could not, therefore, testify against him. The commonwealth, however, had gained its point by claiming to prove that she was only one of several "wives" and therefore competent to testify.

In conclusion, the lawyer took up the charge of Judge Arnold to the jury, and pointed out in it errors in expressions calculated to influence the jury against the prisoner.

District Attorney Graham replied to Mr. Rotan's argument. He took up the objection to his opening speech to the jury, and said that after the fullest review and consideration, he had been convinced that every particle of the testimony concerning the other crimes should have been admitted. In overruling the motion for a new trial, the court had said that it should have been admitted. They were not separate affairs, argued Mr. Graham, but all were part and parcel of a single crime committed upon a number of victims. No man could take the story in detail without feeling that every act in this marvelous drama was linked together by a single purpose, and to dismember it would be to destroy it.

Mr. Graham next dwelt upon the competency of Miss Yoke's testimony, contending that it had been proved beyond question that she was not Holmes' wife. He then took up every other question involved and argued them at much length. Mr. Moon made the closing address in favor of the appeal.

The entire argument was upon the law questions involved. The court reserved its decision.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This damaged, fragmentary clipping garbles references to a House committee hearing on rivers and harbors, a secretary's dealings with a Prussian minister, court charges against someone named Holmes, and a presidential race, but is too incomplete to summarize coherently.

Evening Star · 3 February 1896 · page 1

REVIEWING THE AFFAIR

pose of a hearing before the House com he recited to the court the details of the mittee on rivers and harbors in favor of a charges against Holmes, and the conduct of provision for a continuous contract for the ret'ary Olney in reference to the Prussian chance to count noses, test each other and minister's acts, and the New York insurance of the bill of particulars upon which th< party must stand in the presidential race No sound money Senator undertook th

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

The State Supreme Court heard lengthy arguments on Holmes' appeal from his first-degree murder conviction of last November, with defense counsel Rotan arguing the commonwealth had jumped to conclusions about the Pitezel murder without sufficient testimony. The defense also noted they had been forced to trial without adequate preparation after a continuance was denied.

The Providence News · 3 February 1896 · page 3

tamuel P, Hotan conducted the openl‘x;s nrfument for the appeal and associa with him was K. O, Moen, W. A, Shoe maker, orlgflnauy the senior counsel for Holmes, who became involved in a charge of procuring the production of false testi mony in the case, did not appear. Mr,

See the clipping

The Providence News · Providence, R.I.

Attorney Rotan presented an appeal on behalf of Holmes, arguing the court wrongly refused a continuance for lack of defense funds and improperly admitted irrelevant evidence about other alleged crimes unconnected to Pitezel's murder. He also disputed that the discovery of the Pitezel children's bodies proved Holmes murdered Pitezel.

The Providence News · 3 February 1896 · page 3

HOLMES' MISADVENTURES

of the recent trial. In support of the ap {)eal it was urged upon the finding of he bodies of the Pitezel children, counsel declared, the commonwesalth had jumpea to the conclusion that !fllmu had murd ered Pitezel, although there was not testi mony to support it such an accusation, He referred to the

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says the appeal of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted murderer of Benjamin F. Pitezel, came up for argument in the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia that day.

Alexandria Gazette · 3 February 1896 · page 2

TELEGRAPHIC BREVITIES. Spencer W. Coe, aged about 63 years, died at Meadcw Brook Farm, near Winsted, Conn., last night. Calvin French, aged five, and Harry Evans, seven years, were drowned near ? irana Ripids. Mich , yesterday by breaking through the ice. The First Unitarian Church at Meet? ing House Hill, Boston, an old land mark, was burned this morning. Two firemen were injured by falling walls. There was a serious accident jester day in San Francisco caused by a street car jumping the track. Seven people were badly hurt and other passengers were more or less bruised.

See moreSee less

Thp appeal of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, the convicted mur? derer of Benjamin F. Pitezel, came up for argument in tbe Supreme Court of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia to day. Former Police Commissioner Stephen B. French, of New York, committed suicide this morning at his residence by shooting himself in the left breast. Tbe cause of the deed is supposed to be business reverses. Wm. Deering, a farmer, living near T< m )kics Centre, Mich., shot his wife last night and then turned tbe pistol on himself. The wife is believed to be fatally wounded, but tbe husband will recover. He accuses Mrs. Deering of infidelity and deserting her five child? ren. Two boy?, Denison and Freddie, aged five and eight years, children of Charles D. Spencer, of Davisville, R. I., were drowned Sunday while at play on the ice. The water was from two to eight feet deep where thev broke through the ice with their sled." Their fath? r heard their cries, but before he could reach them life was extinct. Col. W. P. Thompson died at 9 o'clock 'his morning of pneumonia at his home in New York city. Col. Thompson was the proprietor of the Brookdale stud and also owner of the Brookdale stable and was a great power on the turf. Col. Thompson was born in West Virginia, arid was a Confederate sol? dier of distinction. He was president of the National Lead Company, and a director of several banks, railroads mining and other companies. Wm. E. Wheelock & Co., piano man ufactuiers, New York, aaaigaed to-day.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

This fragment reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted of murder, had his case heard on appeal before Justice Mitchell in Philadelphia, with arguments made by attorneys before the text cuts off.

The San Francisco Call · 4 February 1896 · page 3

Holmes' due A.rgued. PHILADELPHIA, Pa., Feb. 3.— The case of H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, was up be fore Justice Mitchell to-day on appeal. After arguments Dy Attorneys Moon and

See the clipping

The Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

This fragment reports that H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of Benjamin Pietzel, had a court matter up on February 3 in Philadelphia, but the clipping cuts off before further detail.

The Record-Union · 4 February 1896 · page 8

( use of IT. IT. Holmes. PHILADELPHIA, Feb. 3.—The case of H. H. Holmes, convicted of the mur der of Benjamin Pietzel, was up before

See the clipping

The Morning News · Savannah, Ga.

In Philadelphia, the appeal of Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin F. Peitzel, was argued before the supreme court, with named attorneys for both prosecution and defense.

The Morning News · 4 February 1896 · page 5

WAIFS FROM THE WIRES

Philadelphia, Pa.. Feb. 3.—The appeal of Herman \v. Mudgett. alias H. H. Holmes, the eonvlcted murderer of Benjamin F. Peitzel, came up for argument In the su preme court to-day. District Attorney Graham and Assistant District Attorney Barlow appeared for the prosecution, and the defendant was represented hy Law yers Samuel P. ltotan and It. o. Moon. The latter having been engaged since the conviction. A Georgina Arrested In Trzas.

See the clipping

The Evening Bulletin · Maysville, Ky.

The clipping reports that Herman Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin E. Pietzel, had his case argued before the supreme court, with his counsel contesting the admissibility of Miss Yohe's testimony on marital relations grounds, before Judge Arnold, who had presided at the original trial.

The Evening Bulletin · 4 February 1896 · page 4

HOLMES SEEKING A NEW TRIAL

Herman Mudgett, alius H H Holmes, the convicted uiuulererof Benjamin E Pietzel, came up for argument in tho supremo court yesterday. Holmes' counsel based their argument upon the alleged inadmissibility of the evidence of Miss Yohe, because of marital rela tions. Judgo Arnold, before whom Holmes was tried in the court of oyer

See the clipping

Der Deutsche Correspondent · Baltimore, Md.

Printed in German, this fragment from Philadelphia notes an appeal filed on behalf of H. H. Holmes, alias Herm. W. Mudgett, the convicted murderer of Benj. F. Pietzel, but the text breaks off before giving further detail.

Der Deutsche Correspondent · 4 February 1896 · page 1

Im Interesse ves.Mörders Holmes. Philadelphia, 3. Febr. Die Appellation von H. H. Holmes, alias Herm. W. Mudgett. dsm über führten Mörder von Benj. F. Pietzel.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

The clipping reports that convicted murderer H. H. Holmes is appealing his sentence, with lawyer Rotan making a long, eloquent plea on his behalf in Philadelphia, though the account is cut off.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 4 February 1896 · page 1

LAST EFFORT. H. H. Holmes, Convicted Murderer, Trying to Escape Gallows. Lawyer Rotan Makes Long and Eloquent Plea for the Prisoner. Philadelphia. Feb. '■>.—The appeal of

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

This damaged clipping mixes disjointed fragments referencing a pneumonia illness, an appeal in H. H. Holmes' case, Havana excitement and watching for filibustering steamers, and police detecting something at a street intersection.

The News & Observer · 4 February 1896 · page 1

Tazewell 171 lett. of Virginia, seriously and parcel of a single crime com “My Indiana friends have been most ill with pneumonia.— H. H. Holmes' mitted upon a number of victims. levoted and faithful, and I am their lawyers argue on the appeal taken eral special agents in this port watch when policeman Rice and Howard, Spa nia ids. ing for possible filibustering steamers. while patrolling their beats at Broad “The excitement in Havana is in and Chestnut streets, detected the

See the clipping

The News & Observer · Raleigh, N.C.

This damaged clipping reports that an ex-Police Commissioner of New York shot himself, mentions lawyers fighting at every step in a trial, and references troops moving supplies and ammunition near a southern city.

The News & Observer · 4 February 1896 · page 1

HOLMES' LAST CHANCE OF LIFE

tion.- Ex-Police Commissioner French The Ex-President Thanks His Friends however, and Holmes' lawyers fought of New York commits suicide by shoot for Their Support and Says ing himself. —Wlieelock A Co., piano at every step. sions and ammunition, and conveyed But the Official Dispatches from by troops between San Felipe and Poso Removed in Safety to the Other Spanish Authorities Report the Redondo, south of this city and not far

See the clipping

Foster's Daily Democrat · Dover, N.H.

The clipping reports that the state supreme court, with the chief justice presiding, heard a long argument on the defense's appeal of H. H. Holmes's murder conviction, reserving its decision.

Foster's Daily Democrat · 4 February 1896 · page 6

was turned in the manifold misadventures of H. H. Holmes, murdercr. ke suprem: eourt of the state listened to a long an: tedious argument on the appeal taken b: the defense from the verdict of murder i the first Gegree rendercd last November All the judges were present, headed kChief Justice Sterrett. Decision wus ro served. Hearing In Holmes’ Case, PHILADELPHIA, Feb. 4.—Another page Will State His Position.

See the clipping

The Times · Richmond, Va.

The clipping reports that Herman W. Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin F. Pletzel, had his appeal argued before the Supreme Court in Philadelphia, with named attorneys for both prosecution and defense.

The Times · 4 February 1896 · page 2

Halmeos Case Vn Aran, PINLADELPHIA, PA, Feb, 3.—-The ap. peal of Herman W. Mudgett allas H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer of Benamin FF, Pletzel, cane up for argu ment in the Supreme Court to-day. Dis trict Attorney Graham and Assistant Dis. trict Attorney Barlow appeared for the progecution and the defendant was rep resented by Lawyers Samuel P. Rotan, and R. O, Moon, the latter having been engaged since the conviction, Mavhe Tenth jc at the Bottom JACKSON, X{188., Feb. 2.—Mr. George hd

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

This damaged clipping mixes disjointed phrases about a political caucus admitting no amendments, a court case involving a man named Holmes and an attorney named Ttotan, wounded soldiers, and a dispatch from Pinar del Rio, Cuba, but is too fragmentary to make out a coherent story.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 4 February 1896 · page 1

t have written, will recognise in this can members are under Instruction asslMtan-t, -represented 'the state and B. from their caucus to admit no amend expression the aubetance of what I have P. Ttotan appeared for Holmes. The ments and the Democrats are commit latter claimed that the verdict from and six soldiers were wounded. I Hon. E. B. Dyer, of Charleston, It* at Advices received here to-day from the * the National Hotel. rovince of Plnar del Rio say that the

See the clipping

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · Chicago, Ill.

The report describes the Monday hearing before the state supreme court on H. H. Holmes's appeal of his death sentence for the murder of B. F. Pitezel. It notes that prosecutors Graham and Barlow represented the state while attorney S. P. Rotan argued for Holmes, and that the court reserved its decision.

Illinois Staats-Zeitung · 5 February 1896 · page 2

Der Prozeß Holmes

Louiser Milbonär Dr. Arihur Duestrow, der seit einem Monat die öffentliche Auf merksamlkeit in Anspruch nahm, tem. Montag zu Ende, indem die Geschwore nen entschieden, daß er des Mordes im ersten Grade schuldig ist. Duestrow hat bekanntlich vor zwei Jahren seine Gattin und sein Kind kaltblütig ermordet. Bolln mit dem Dreck am Stecken. Das Sündenregister des früheren städti— schen Schatzmeisters Bolln von Omaha, Nebraska, schwillt zu immer größeren Dimensionen an, und die Freitag erfolgte Wiederverhaftung des Edlen wegen einer auf Unterschlagung von $lO5, 000 lautenden Anklage, sowie die gleichzeitig gemachte Ent deckung, daß seine Bürgschaft für 3800, 000 als Schatzmeister des Schulraths verschwun— den sei, hat die ganze Stadt in unbeschreib liche Aufregung versetzt.

See moreSee less

- Der Prozeß Holmes. Im Staatsobergerichte kam Montag die Appellation in dem Prozesse des Massen— mörders H. H. Holmes zur Sprache. Der Angeklagte war bekanntlich der Ermordung des B. F. Pitzel überführt und züm Tode ver wurde. Niemand weiß über den Mörder oder die Ermordete Etwas anzugeben. Die Samstag Abend auf die Spur des Mö— rders losgelassenen Bluthunde lenkten ihre Schritte nach dem eine Meile nordwestlich sich vorbehalten wolle. von Fort Thomas gelegenen Covingtoner Reservoir No. 2, wo sie plötzlich Halt machten und ein lautes Gehbelle anhuben. Sie wurden nur mit Mühe von der Stelle gebracht. Samstag Nacht wurde das Wasser aus dem Reservoir abgelassen, da man hoffte, den Kopf des ermordeten Frauen— zimmers und möglicherweise die Leiche des Mörders zu finden, allein das Reservoir ent hielt nichts Derartiges. Der Schauplatz der Blutthat zeigt, daß zwischen dem Mörder und seinem Opfer ein verzweifelter Kampf stattgefunden hat. Allem Anscheine nach ist zum Abschneiden des Kopfes ein stumpfes Fleischermesser benutzt worden. Die Ermor— dete dürfte gegen 35 Jahre alt gewesen sein. Im Gefängnisse im Dorfe Ludlow, Kentuckh, sind zwei Landstreicher ein— Selbstmorde. gesperrt, in deren Einem man den Mörder des Frauenzimmers vermuthet. Dieser Eine ist George Henrohan, der dabei ertappt wurde, wie er in einer Quelle einen blutigen Hemdärmel wusch. Sein Beglei—- ier George Morgan, wird als Zeuge fest gehalten. Beide sagen, daß sie nach Lexing— ton hätten gehen wollen, um daselbst als Pferdeknechte Arbeit zu suchen. hatte, ihn zu heirathen. . Ein Krümmling erhängt sich. . Der Kafssirer George Barnard von der Fort Stanwix Nationalbank in Rome, New Hork, hat Selbstmord began— gen und die Bank bleibt während der vom Direktorenrathe verfügten Untersuchung der Bücher geschlossen. Barnard hatte sich seit Mittwoch Morgen nicht mehr in seiner Wohnung sehen lassen und wurde am Frei— tag in einem Zimmer des 4. Stocks erhängt gefunden. Er war 57 Jahre alt. Seit 1875 war er Kassfirer der Bank gewesen und hatte sich stets des Vertrauens seiner Mitbürger erfreut. Er war auch einer der Trustees der hiesigen Sparbank. Er hatte der Stadt als Bürger— meister, als Canalzolleinnehmer und Su— befanden. : pervisor und in anderen Stellungen gedient. In seinen Taschen wurden mehrere Wechsel für hohe Summen und ein Brief an seine Frau gefunden.

See the clipping

The Roanoke Daily Times · Roanoke, Va.

The clipping reports that Holmes's lawyers argued before the state supreme court against his murder conviction citing irrelevant evidence, while separately noting earthquake shocks felt in Nebraska and South Dakota and the sudden death of a Picayune proprietor in New Orleans.

The Roanoke Daily Times · 5 February 1896 · page 1

THE MURDBBBR HOLMES, , Desperate Efforts of Counsel to Save His Philat ki.th ia, Pa,, Feb. 4 ?Another page was turned yesterday Id tho mani? fold misadventures of H. H. Holmes, murderer. Tho supreme court of the State listened to a long and tedious ar? gument on the appeal taken by the defense from the verdtot of murder in the first degree rendered last Novem? ber. Since that time tho lower oourt refused a motion for a now trial, the sontenoe of death was passed upon Holmes, and arrangements were set on foot to expeditlouBly remove tho extra?

See moreSee less

ordinary oriminal from the faoeof crea? tion. Even condemned murderers have rights, however, and Holmes' lawyers fought at evey step. To-day's la next I to the last, should the oourt affirm the i decision of the jury, Governor Hastings may be appealed to for executive olomency and should ho decline to in? terpose then Holmes must hang. A big orowd filled the room. The Commonwealth was represented by District Attorney Graham and Assistant District Attorney Barlow. Samuel P. Rotan conducted the opening argument for the appeal and associated with him. was R. O. Moon. The most Important fact dwelt upon by counsel for Holmes was the Introduc? tion of lrrevelant evidence, regarding the other orimes oharged against Holmes and having no connection with the death of B. F. Pletzel, for wboae murder Holmes was on trial. The entire argument was upon the law questions involved. The oourt reserved its decis? ion. _ earthquake: shocks. Severe Ones Felt in Nebraska and Dakota Vesterday. Omaha, Neb., Feb. 4.?Telegrams from Northern Nebraska towns report two dlstlnot earthquake shooks at 5:45 this morning, undulations from north to to south A dispatch to Minneapolis, Minn., sayB: Dispatches from Elk Point, Lyn? don, Hurley and points in Southeastern South Dakota, report an earthquake there this morning about 6 o'clock. 16 was sevoro enough to sway hanging articles and to rattle doors and wlndowa severely, It passed toward the east, George Nicholson Dead. Nkw Om.BANs. La., Feb. 4.?-George Nicholson, ons ot the proprietors of the Picayune, died suddenly this afternoon. Meek.

See the clipping

The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio

The Pennsylvania supreme court heard arguments on H. H. Holmes's appeal from his murder conviction and death sentence, with counsel disputing trial errors, and reserved its decision.

The Stark County Democrat · 6 February 1896 · page 1

AN APPEAt FOR HOLMES. Mtitlnr Vol n Illche? Court Trtl Hit AlRiicil ll J'hlliuteljihlK Philadelphia Feb 4 The saprerr. court of Pennsylvania bar listened in argument!' on the motion of an appeal in the case of 11 II Holmes, convicted of the inurdt-i of B F Pitezel and tinder Bentenee of death A full bonth wd present IJlstnct Attornoy Griv ham and Mr. Barlow, his assistant, rep resented the state, and S I' Rotan up pearcd for Holmes Tiie latter claimed that the verdict from which anneal if desired was con trary to tho law and evidenco Tho specific points ulleged wero against the opening uddiess of tho district attorney, the admission of the evidence of Miss Yoke, tho alleged wife of Holmes and tho charge to the jury by Judge Arnold District Attorney Gruham replied The court reseived decision.

See the clipping

The Savannah Tribune · Savannah, Ga.

Among a column of news briefs, this report says H. H. Holmes's appeal in the murder of Benjamin Pietzel came up for argument before the Pennsylvania supreme court on Monday, with Lawyers Rotan and Romoon representing him.

The Savannah Tribune · 8 February 1896 · page 1

DON’T FORGET STALL No. 31. And All Voters Opposed to the Single Senator Marion Butler, chairman of the populist state committee of North Carolina, has issued au address to the North Carolina populists and all other voters of the state who are opposed to the single gold standard. He declares that the overshadowing issues in this year’s campaign are national, and of all these the greatest and most mo mentous is the financial. “We have proposed to co-operate again with the republicans, making the basis the silver pledge adopted by the silver convention at Raleigh, Septem ber 25th.

See moreSee less

A large majority of the vo ters of North Carolina are opposed to the single gold standard, and indorse that pledge, and we invite all those who are for the money of the con stitution to co-operate with us to give North Carolina’s eleven electoral votes to a candidate who is an American patriot and who will iight to the bitter death the in famous gold conspiracy. The people are tired of goldbugs, but they are more tired of straddle-bugs, humbugs and hypocrites, and they want to see the issue squarely drawn between the people and the common enemy. In the coming campaign the people will have an opportunity to vote for au electoral ticket that is sound upon this great question. They will have an opportunity to vote for a state ticket and for congressmen and for a whole ticket that is equally sound and relia ble from top to bottom. The fight will be drawn square in the nation from ocean to ocean and in North Carolina from the mountain to the sea. Let every patriot prepare for the struggle in which our homes, liberty and prosperity are all at stake. ” The appeal of H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer of Benjamin Piet zel, came up for argument in the su preme conrt of Pennsylvania Monday. The defendant was represented by Lawyers Rotan and Romoon, the lat ter having been engaged since the con viction. . BUTLER TO POPULISTS, Gold Standard. Appeal of Holmes Argued.

See the clipping

The Kootenai Herald · Kootenai, Idaho

The Pennsylvania supreme court, under Chief Justice Sterrett, heard the appeal of murderer H. H. Holmes against his death sentence, denying a postponement and waiving its usual printed-brief rule due to his poverty, with a decision expected within a day to a month.

The Kootenai Herald · 8 February 1896 · page 7

FINAL APPEAL OF MURDERER HOLMES Supreme Court of Pennsylvania Listened Philadelphia, Feb. 3.—The appeal of the now celebrated murderer, H. H. Holmes, from the verdict of a Philadel phia jury, that consigned him to the gallows for one of his many crimes, was the special order in the state supreme court today, with Chief Justice Sterrett presiding. Vigorous efforts had been made by the defense to secure a postponement of the matter until the second week in March, but at an informal confer ence of the justices it was decided that there were no grounds for further de laying the presentation of the appeal to the highest tribunal.

See moreSee less

The brief of the defense, and abstract of the testi mony upon which the appeal is based, covers some 850 pages of typewritten legal cap. This is the first case in many years that the court has waived its rule, Insisting upon printed copies of the brief and testimony, a special exception being made in Holmes' case by reason of the poverty of the defend ant; although the district attorney, in the interest of fair play, offered to have the matter printed out of the funds appropriated by this department. Holmes Is represented by Lawyer S. P. Rotan, while District Attorney Gra ham looks after the people's side of the case. The decision of the court may be announced within 24 hours, or, on the other hand, it may be delayed for not more than a month. to Arguments. .

See the clipping

Passaic City Record · Passaic City, N.J.

This fragment reports that Holmes, convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitezel, sought to have the jury's verdict set aside, and notes that a lumber and shipping trust was formed on the Pacific coast with a capital of an unstated amount.

Passaic City Record · 8 February 1896 · page 3

NEWS OF THE WEEK.

Holmes, convicted of the murder of B. F. Pitezel, to have the verdict of the jury set aside.-A lumber and shipping trust was formed on the Pacific coast, with a capital of

See the clipping

The Kimball Graphic · Kimball, S.D.

The clipping reports that Holmes' counsel, Samuel P. Rotan, argued Miss Yohe's testimony was inadmissible due to marital relations, though Judge Arnold had allowed it after ruling a prior marriage nullified the union, with a court decision expected within a day to a month.

The Kimball Graphic · 8 February 1896 · page 2

timony, a special exception being made In Holmes' case by reason of the pover ty of the defendant although the dis trict attorney, In the Interest of fair play, offered to have the matter printed out of the funds appropriated to his de partment. Holmes Is represented by Lawyer Samuel P. Rotan, while District Attorney Graham looks after the peo ple's side of the case. The decision of the court may be announced within twenty-four hours, or, on the other hand, it may be delayed for not more than a month.

See moreSee less

Holmes' counsel based their ar gument upon the alleged Inad missibility of the evidence of Miss Yohe, because of marital relations. Judge Arnold, before whom Holmes was tried in the court of oyer and terminer, admitted this testimony on the ground that a prior marriage nullified the un* ion.

See the clipping

The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn. · and 1 other paper

The clipping reports that a lynched man was shown innocent at Knoxville, that Pennsylvania's supreme court reserved decision on H. H. Holmes's appeal, that a jury awarded $1,000 in a saloon death suit, and that a Brooklyn widow suffering neuralgia and grief shot herself.

The Princeton Union · 13 February 1896 · page 2

jealou husband and the" victim his Wife',s Developments which came to light at Knoxville, Tenn., show that Lee Sellers, who was lynched there ten and robbery of Edward Mainess, was an innocent man. The supreme court of Pennsylvania listened to arguments on motion for an appeal in the case of H. H. Holmes, convicted of the murder of B. F. Pietzel, and under sentence of death. The court reserved decision. One year ago Joe King, a farmer, was killed in John Smiser's saloon at Petersburg, Ind., by being thrown to the floor by some .drunken toughs.

See moreSee less

Mrs. King sued Smiser and his bonds men for damages. The jury returned a verdict for $1,000. A sensational suicide was that of Mrs. Augusta Schwartz, a wealthy widow who owned a handsome resi dence in Berkeley place, the aristo cratic section of Brooklyn. For some time past she has been a constant suf ferer from neuralgia, and that, togeth er witn the fact that her husband, An ton Schwartz, a prominent member of the brewers' exchange, had ibeen found dead about a year ago under peculiar circumstances in New York city, had given her great mental worry, and led her to shoot herself. ago for the supposed murder

See the clipping

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D. · 21 February 1896

Southern Christian Advocate · Charleston, S.C.

The fragment reports lawyers working to save H. H. Holmes from the gallows, three piano manufacturing companies in N.Y. failing, strained German-British relations, Spanish and insurgent reports from Cuba, a proposed convention of American Republics, and Lord Leighton's burial.

Southern Christian Advocate · 13 February 1896 · page 8

MONDAY. FEB. 3.

H. H. Holmes are making strong efforts to save their client from the gallows.— Three large piano manufacturing com panies in N. V. fail. WORLD—On Sunday, February 2nd, strained relations between the govern ments of Germanyjand Great Britain said not to be in any way improved.—Span ish reports announce various Cuban de feats. On Monday, February 3rd, news from Cuba favorable to insurgents.—Move ment started for convention of American Republics with view to unifying them — Lord Leighton buried with imposing pprpmnnips

See the clipping

The Barbour Democrat · Philippi, W. Va.

The clipping reports that Herman Mudgett, alias H. H. Holmes, convicted of murdering Benjamin K. Pietzel, had his appeal argued before the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania, with his counsel challenging the admissibility of Miss Yohe's testimony on marital grounds, though Judge Arnold had allowed it after ruling a prior marriage voided their union.

The Barbour Democrat · 13 February 1896 · page 4

PLEADS A NEW TRIAL

The ap; cal of Herman Miuigett, alias -H, H. Holmes, the convicted murderer of Benjamin K. .Pietzel, came up for argument in the Su preme Court of Pennsylvania at Philadelphia, last week. Holmes’ counsel based their argumentupon the alleged inadmissibility of the evidence of Miss Yohe, because of martial relations. Judge Arnold, before whom Holmes was tried in cour! of Oyer and Terminer, ad mitted (he testimony on the ground that, a prior marriage nullified their union. PLEADS A MW TIDAL

See the clipping

The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan.

The clipping jokes that those not murdered by H. H. Holmes should rise and be counted, then remarks that matrimonial agencies remain a chief source of income for divorce lawyers.

The American Citizen · 14 February 1896 · page 4

626 Minn. AveAll those who have not been mur idered by H. H. Holmes will please rise and remain standing until counted. 1 Che so-called agencies for the pro motion of matrimony are still one of i the chief sources of income of the | divorce lawvers.

See the clipping

Also printed 4 more times, in 1 paper
  • The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · 31 January 1896
  • The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · 13 March 1896
  • The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · 27 March 1896
  • The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · 15 May 1896

The Camden Chronicle · Camden, Tenn.

A Frankfort dispatch reports republicans made a revolutionary legislative move amid a deadlocked librarian and senatorial race, with a ballot showing Hunter 54, Blackburn 46, scattering 9, while separately H. H. Holmes's appeal in the Pietzel murder conviction was argued before the Pennsylvania supreme court.

The Camden Chronicle · 14 February 1896 · page 4

Appeal of Holmes Argued

Now. A special from Frankfort, Ky., eaysr The republicans made their first revo lutionary move in the legislature Sat urday, which indicates that they intend to attempt to gain the senatorship by main force after the armistice ends on February 6th. The librarian race has been linked with tho senatorial race and deadlocked. When the joint meeting convened Saturday there was much suppressed excitement, as revo lutionary tactics were expected. It was known that Lieutenant Gov ernor Worthington intended to over rule any motion tor further balloting in the librarian race, holding that the constitutional time for an election had passed, and stormy scenes were ex pected to follow.

See moreSee less

There was no outburst, howcver.un til after the senatorial ballot,wliich re sulted: Hunter, 54; Blackburn, 46; ecattering, 9, There were thirteen pairs, leaving only 110 present. Appeal of Holmes Argufu The appeal of H. H. Holmes, the convicted murderer of Benjamin Piet zel, came up for argument in tho su premo conrt of Pennsylvania Monday. The defendant was represented by Lawyers Rotan and Romoon, the lat ter having been engaged since the conviction.

See the clipping