As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

Captured, Condemned, Escaped

December 1880 – July 1881

Garrett’s posse catches the gang in the last week of December 1880 and nearly has to fight a Las Vegas crowd to get the prisoners onto a train. In April the Kid is tried at Mesilla, convicted and sentenced to hang on 13 May. At the end of April he kills his two guards at Lincoln and rides away, and the papers start crediting him with fresh killings, not all of them real.

Captured, and a standoff at the depot

Garrett’s men break up the gang, killing two and taking four ‘including the leaders,’ and bring them to Las Vegas, where there is talk of lynching. When Garrett puts his prisoners on the train for Santa Fe, the Las Vegas sheriff comes to the depot with 300 men to take one of them, Riedabaugh, and for a while a fight seems certain. A compromise lets the train go.

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Daily Globe · 29 December 1880 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

ALMOST BLOODSHED. LAS VEGAS, N. M., Dec. 28.—The notorious gang of outlaws composed of about twenty-five men, who, under the leadership of "Billy the Kid," have for the past six months overrun Eastern New Mexico, murdering and committing other deeds of outlawry, was broken up last Saturday by killing two and capturing four others, including the leaders. The prisoners were lodged in the Las Vegas jail and calls of lynching were provoked, but the vigilance of the captors, Deputy Sheriff Garrett and others, prevented. Yesterday forenoon Garrett and others of the captors boarded a train with the prisoners for the purpose of taking them to Santa Fe.

See moreSee less

Sheriff Romero remonstrated against taking Riedabugh, one of the prisoners, who killed Las Vegas, deputy sheriff, to Santa Fe, but with no effect. He then went to the depot with a posse of 300 men and made a formal demand for the prisoners, but was told if he wanted the prisoners to take them. The sheriff then stationed men at the engine to cover the engineer, and the balance of the sheriff's posse crowded about the train, the platforms of which were crowded with additional guards, pressed into service by Garrett, and nearly every window in the cars served for port holes for rifles. Somebody suggested to take them prisoners now. Stewart, of Garrett's party, said the instant the first shot was fired he would unlosse every man and arm him. For a while a fight seemed imminent. Chief Engineer Robinson appeared and demanded that the train be allowed te proceed. The master of transportation said if the train was not allowed to proceed he would arm all the railroad men and take it out. Detective J. F. Morely, of the post-office department, jumped into the cab with a pair of six shooters and told the engineer to leap out. A conference had just concluded a compromise being effected by which it was agreed that the sheriff and two men should go to Santa Fe with the party and if the governor agreed bring Riedabaugh back to Las Vegas. The train then proceeded.

See the clipping

‘This is the man,’ says the Kid

On the coach south to his trial at Mesilla he meets ugly crowds. At Las Cruces, when someone asks which one is Billy the Kid, he puts his hand on his own lawyer’s shoulder and says, ‘this is the man.’ He tells the letter-writer that two hundred men have died in Lincoln County in three years, ‘but that he did not kill all of them.’

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 5 April 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Billy the Kid. Billy the Kid seems to be having a stormy journey on his trip Southward as the following sketched from the New Mexican will show: An extract from a letter written by W. S. Fecher from Mesilla to a gentleman in this city reads about as follows: Tony Neis and Francisco Chaves, deputy U. S. Marshals arrived Tuesday night with Billy, the Kid, and Billy Wilson. They met an ugly crowd at Rincon, where some threats were made, but Tony's crowd were too much for them. At Las Cruces an inquisitive mob gathered around the coach and some one asked which is "Billy the Kid."

See moreSee less

The Kid himself answered by placing his hand on Judge Leonard's shoulder, and saying "this is the man." The Kid weakened somewhat at Las Cruces, where he found quite a number of Lincoln county men, who are to appear against him as witnesses. He says that at least two hundred men have been killed in Lincoln county during the past three years, but that he did not kill all of them. I think that twenty murders can be charged against him. He was arraigned yesterday (Wednesday) before the United States Court for the murder of Roberts, on the Mescalero Apache reservation, in 1878. Judge Leonard was assigned to his defense.

See the clipping

He kills Matthews, says New York

A New York paper reports that after his escape he ‘murdered William Matthews and another man,’ Matthews having been a witness at his trial. Three years earlier a Mathews had shot and wounded him at Brady’s killing. A week later a letter reached the papers saying Matthews was alive.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 5 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

COMMITTING MURDER WHILE ESCAPING.

Santa Fe, N. M., May 4.—Intelligence has been received here that "Billy, the Kid," after his escape, murdered William Matthews and another man with whom he was riding. Matthews was a witness at the "Kid's" trial during the Lincoln County War.

See the clipping

Condemned, and gone

The escape report says what came before it: he was convicted at Mesilla of ‘triple murder’ and sentenced to hang at Lincoln on 13 May, and Governor Wallace refused him a pardon. Now he has shot his guards, Bell and Olinger, and ‘it is feared his capture can only be effected by much bloodshed.’

Savannah Morning News · Savannah

Savannah Morning News · 5 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"BILLY, THE KID."

The Noted New Mexican Desperado Kills His Guards and Escapes.

See moreSee less

Santa Fe, New Mexico, May 4.—A telegram from Socorro, sent by special messenger from Lincoln, informed Governor Wallace that the notorious outlaw, "Billy, the Kid," in jail at Lincoln, the county seat of Lincoln county, under sentence of death, managed to kill his guards, Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and United States Marshal Robert Olinger, by shooting them, and effecting his escape. "Billy, the Kid" is quite a young man, but a most noted desperado. He was very prominent in the Lincoln county troubles three years ago, in the murder of Sheriff Brady and two Deputy Sheriffs, in the murder of Tunetall and Roberts, and others. He was captured last fall, after a desperate fight, by Deputy Sheriff Garrett, who received a large reward for his capture. He was tried at the District Court at Lamesilla and convicted of triple murder, and sentenced by Judge Bristol to be hanged at Lincoln on the 13th of May. He applied to Governor Wallace for a pardon, but was refused. This noted man is now again at large, and it is feared his capture can only be effected by much bloodshed. Governor Wallace will offer a large reward for his apprehension.

See the clipping

Matthews is alive

On Billy’s whereabouts ‘the reports are all wrong’: he is known to have stolen a horse from Bell’s ranche above Fort Sumner and is thought to be on the lookout for Barney Mason. Then the correction: Billy Matthews ‘is still alive and has not had any encounter with Billy since he escaped.’

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Eureka Daily Sentinel, 6 May 1881, New Ulm Weekly Review, 11 May 1881.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 12 May 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Billy "the Kid."

After all that has been said concerning the whereabouts of Billy "the Kid," who made his bold dash for liberty from Lincoln, it is only necessary to state that the reports are all wrong. Billy is known to have stolen a horse from Bell's ranche, above Ft. Sumner, on Saturday last. On Sunday he was seen by quite a number of people in the neighborhood of Sumner, and was talked with on that day by men who know him well. It is thought that Billy is on the lookout for Barney Mason, who was then in Sumper. "The Kid" never had any great love for Barney, and especially since he assisted in the capture of Billy and party at Stinking Springs. He is said to have sworn to kill Mason, and will undoubtedly make an effort to work out his vengeance. If he remains much longer in Lincoln county hovering about to pay off old scores, he is likely to be shot when he is not prepared to do his best shooting.

See moreSee less

The Mesilla News announces that Col. Rynerson has received a letter stating in effect that Billy Matthews, who was reported to have been killed by "the Kid," is still alive and has not had any encounter with Billy since he escaped.

See the clipping

How he got out

The full story of the escape reaches Pennsylvania. Shackled and handcuffed, the Kid jumps his guard Bell ‘with the swiftness of a wildcat,’ shoots him with his own pistol, knocks off his shackles with a hatchet, and from upstairs kills Olinger with a gun loaded with buckshot as he runs back from supper. Governor Wallace, the paper adds, signed his death warrant at Santa Fe the same day.

The Elk County Advocate · Ridgway, Pa.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Elk County Advocate · 19 May 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A Desperado's Escape. A communicatin from Santa Fe, New Mexico, says: Full particulars of the escape of Wiliam Bonney, alias "Billy the Kid," fom the jail of Lincoln county have reached here. The Kid was in charge of Bob Alinger and J. W. Bell, deputy sheiffs, cool and brave men. It seems, however, that by docile behavior the prisoner put them off their guard. On the evening of the day in question Alinger had gone to supper, leaving Bell to watch the prisoner. Bell was sitting on the floor talking, when the Kid, who was heavily shackled and handcuffed, approached him pleasantly and suddenly jumped at him with the swiftness of a wildcat, hitting him on the head and fracturing his skull.

See moreSee less

He then snatched Bell's pistol and shot him in the breast. Bell ran down the steps and fell at the foot a corpse. The Kid kicked open the door, procured a hatchet and knocked off his shackles. He also broke open the door of the armory and took possession of several guns and pistols. Bob Alinger, hearing the shot, left his supper and ran toward the jail. When entering a small gate leading through the jail fence, the Kid, who was upstairs, shot him with a gun loaded with buckshot, killing him instantly. The town of Lincoln seemed terror-stricken, and nobody thought of opposing the Kid. He stole a horse and rode off, armed with four revolvers and a Winchester rifle. He has expressed a determination to kill Governor Lew Wallace, who failed to pardon him, and who, by a curious coincidence, signed the Kid's death warrant at Santa Fe on the same day that he escaped at Lincoln.

See the clipping

Three more killings, on paper

A Los Angeles paper, copying the Las Vegas Optic, has him ride into one of John Chisum’s cow camps near Roswell and shoot three men, sparing a fourth to carry a message: Chisum owes him $5 a day for the war. No other paper in this collection reports it.

Daily Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Daily Los Angeles Herald · 17 June 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

"BILLY, THE KID."

Three More Men Fall Victims to His Deadly Aim.

See moreSee less

"Billy, the Kid," has been heard from again, this time near Roswell, in Lincoln county, and three more murders are set down against him. About dusk a few days ago he rode up to a cow camp of John Chisum, in which there were four men, three sitting around the fire engaged in preparing supper, and the fourth some distance away hobbling horses. Approaching the last mentioned man he asked, "Are you working for John Chisum?" and receiving a reply in the affirmative he remarked, "Well, here is your pay" and killed him. The remaining three seeing their comrade thus ruthlessly murdered jumped to their feet, but, before they could draw their revolvers, the Kid had killed two of them, and leveling his pistol at the fourth one commanded him to throw up his hands; the order was promptly obeyed; and, after informing him that his life had been spared so that he could deliver a message to Chisum, the Kid told him that he had fought for Chisum all through the Lincoln county war and that Chisum had agreed to pay him therefor $5 per day and that he had never received one cent from him. "Tell him I am living now to get even with my enemies; I shall kill his men wherever I find them and credit him with $5 for each man I kill. Whenever I see him I will him and call the account square," said this incarnate fiend. The county is thoroughly aroused over this heartless triple murder, although no organized effort, so far as we can learn, has been made to capture him.

He expressed the intention of remaining in that country until he has gotten even with his enemies, and at the rate he is now going, he will soon depopulate Lincoln county.—Las Vegas Optic, June 10.

See the clipping

A boy who wants to be him

A week before Garrett finds him, a Los Angeles boy of fourteen or fifteen, jailed for pulling a revolver on a playmate, tells the other prisoners he means to follow the deeds of Billy the Kid. ‘He aims high,’ says the paper.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 7 July 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A lad about fourteen or fifteen years of age, who was recently confined in the Los Angeles jail for drawing a revolver on a playmate, declared to his fellow prisoners his ambition to some day emulate the deeds of Billy the Kid. He aims high.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: “Kid” Antrim