As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

Shot in the Dark

July – August 1881

On the night of 14 July 1881 Pat Garrett shoots the Kid dead in a dim bedroom at Fort Sumner. Within days the papers are arguing over who he was: a New York murderer named McCarthy, say some; a boy raised at his mother’s stage station in New Mexico, says a lawyer who knew him. Towns raise money for Garrett, and a newspaper office puts the Kid’s finger on show.

Killed at last

The first word in the New York papers: Garrett found him in a cabin at Fort Sumner on 14 July and shot him dead. The dispatch adds that the Kid was a New Yorker, ‘his real name being McCarthy,’ a claim the papers argued over for weeks.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

New-York Tribune · 19 July 1881 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

"BILLY THE KID" KILLED AT LAST.

Las Vegas, N. M., July 18.—The Gazette has positive information that "Billy the Kid," the notorious murderer and outlaw, who for several years has been the terror of New-Mexico cattle men, was killed on July 14 by Patrick Garrett, Sheriff of Lincoln County. Garrett had been on his trail some time, and on July 14 found him in a cabin at Fort Sumner and shot him dead. The "Kid" was a native of New-York City, his real name being McCarthy.

See the clipping

‘Say, that’s him’

The Las Vegas Optic’s account: Garrett is sitting in Pete Maxwell’s dim bedroom when a man in his stocking feet comes through the door asking ‘Who are you?’ Maxwell whispers ‘Say, that’s him,’ and Garrett shoots him through the heart. The Optic adds his life story and a count of ‘twenty-one men,’ all of whose names, it says, ‘can be given.’

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill. · and 1 other paper

Chicago Daily Tribune · 20 July 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

THE KID KILLED. Dispatch to St. Louis Globe-Democrat.

Las Vegas, N. M., July 18.—The Daily Optic to-night gives an interesting account of the killing of William Bonney, alias Billy the Kid, the noted desperado, at Fort Sumner on Thursday night. Immediately after receiving the news that Billy the Kid was lurking near Fort Sumner, Pat Garrett, Sheriff of Lincoln County, went to that place, taking with him John Peoe and Kit McKinney. Arriving in town, they went to the house of Pete Maxwell, where Pat advanced and entered, leaving his companions at the door, and in a low tone of voice asked Pete if Billy the Kid were on his premises. He was told that he was not, but was not far off. The conversation between the two men had not lasted two minutes when a man in his stocking feet, heavily armed and with a stealthy step, pushed the open door noiselessly aside, and entered. Maxwell took in the situation at a glance, and whispered in scarcely audible tone, "Say, that's him." Pat knew what that meant, but had not time to prepare himself for action until the outlaw approached the bed on which Maxwell was reclining, and near which sat Garrett. Seeing a third party in the room, he asked, "Who are you?" The second time the question was asked, and as he came nearer with a pointed revolver in his hand, aimed at a man he little thought was Garrett. The latter, who had taken advantage of the dim, uncertain light to get his weapon ready for use, brought it to bear on the Kid, shooting him through the heart at the first pull of the trigger. He died in two minutes without uttering a word.

See moreSee less

The Optic to-night editorially says of the affair: "Billy the Kid was the terror not only of Lincoln County, but of the whole Territory; a young desperado who has long been noted as a bold thief, a cold-blooded murderer, having, perhaps, killed more men than any person of his age in the world, has at last received his just dues. All mankind rejoices, and the newspapers will now have something else to talk about. It is now in order for Pat Garrett to be well rewarded for his services in ridding the Territory of this desperado. He is in very moderate circumstances, but has spent many dollars in his pursuit of the Kid. Already we understand a subscription paper is circulating for this purpose. It should be signed by all, and other counties who alike breathe easier because the Kid is dead should join in and make a substantial showing of their appreciation of Pat Garrett. Garrett is in Las Vegas, and is receiving an ovation of congratulations from the citizens. He will probably be tendered a banquet.

"Billy was only 20 years and 10 months old, good-looking, and hailed from New York. His career commenced four years ago at Camp Apache, where he shot and killed James J. Young, a Government blacksmith. The celebrated Lincoln County war in 1878 gave him full sway. In June of that year he and four companions killed Sheriff Brady and Deputy-Sheriff Hindman at Lincoln, riddling them with bullets from behind. In July of the same year, he and five others killed Morris Bernstein, clerk, and James Roberts, watchman, at the Mescalero Reservation. A couple of weeks after they took four of Chisum's herders, Robert Beckurts, Charles Crawford, William P. Morton, and Frank Baker, prisoners, and shot them down in cold blood. One of his own men, John McCloskey, remonstrating, he shot and killed him. Last year he shot and killed James Grant and John Garrish at Fort Sumner. He was captured last December by Sheriff Garrett, at Stinking Springs, tried in April, and sentenced to be hanged on May 13. He escaped on April 27, killing his guards. He openly boasted that he had killed twenty-one men, which is so, as their names can be given. For three long years this boy has kept a large and populous section in a state of terror, and our citizens are now overjoyed that he has at last met his fate. The Territory will pay Sheriff Garrett a reward of $500, and the citizens of the Territory will endeavor to raise him $2,500 more."

See the clipping

‘God bless Pat Garrett’

Roswell writes to the Las Vegas paper asking the whole Territory to raise a purse for Garrett. One man predicts that ‘God bless Pat Garrett for his good work’ will be on many lips, and that Lincoln County will soon be ‘one of the most law abiding in the Territory.’

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

Las Vegas Daily Gazette · 22 July 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Words of Commendation and Encouragement. Immediately on the receipt of the news of the killing of Billy "the Kid" by Sheriff Garrett, prominent citizens of Roswell and the lower Pecos wrote us giving particulars and expressing satisfaction at the brave deed. Capt. J. C. Lea, of Roswell, wrote asking that the Gazette should request the people of the Territory generally and of Las Vegas, Santa Fe and the Pecos river country, particularly, to get up a liberal contribution to Sheriff Garrett as part compensation for the dangers, hardships and risks he has taken in capturing and bringing to justice this noted desperado.

See moreSee less

Mr. A. H. Whetstone also of Roswell, writes: "An almost universal shout of rejoicing will go up in this county at the death of this shrewd thief and desperate murderer. The words, 'God bless Pat Garrett for his good work' will escape from many a lip, and people will never cease to love him for his great achievements. He has already accomplished wonders during his short administration. Before its expiration Lincoln county will be one of the most law abiding in the Territory."

See the clipping

Justifiable homicide

The coroner’s jury rules the killing justifiable homicide and says Garrett deserves ‘the thanks of the whole community.’ The same paragraph has the Kid boasting of a man killed for every year of his life. The Optic had counted twenty-one; a week later the New York World put it at thirteen.

The Cecil Whig · Elkton, Md.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Cecil Whig · 23 July 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

—A dispatch from Las Vegas says that the coroner's jury on the body of "Billy the Kid" returned a verdict of justifiable homicide, coupled with a statement that Pat Garret deserved the thanks of the whole community for ridding the country of the desperado. The Kid was 21 years old, and boasted that he had killed a man for every year of his life.

See the clipping

Not a New Yorker, says a man who knew him

New York claims him as Michael McCarthy, who fled the Fourth Ward in 1876 after killing a brush-maker. A Santa Fe lawyer visiting the city says no: he knew the Kid by sight from the jail, and the boy grew up in New Mexico at a stage station kept by his mother, where he was always ‘a hard boy.’

Memphis Daily Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.

Memphis Daily Appeal · 29 July 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"BILLY THE KID"

A Product of the Country where He Lived and Died.

See moreSee less

New York World.

Since "Billy the Kid," alias William Bonney, was shot by Sheriff Garrett, of Lincoln county, New Mexico, it has been claimed that the young desperado was Michael McCarthy, and that he was born on Vandewater street, this city. McCarthy answered the description of the "Kid" very well as to age, general appearance and bad character, he having fled from New York after killing Thos. Moore, a brush-maker, at the corner of Pearl and Hague streets, September, 9, 1876. It has been further asserted, to make the identification complete between the escaped Fourth Ward murderer and the robber of the plains, that a detective who was in New Mexico on business accidentally became acquainted with "Billy the Kid," and that the latter admitted he was from New York. In contradiction of these stories Mr. Charles H. Gildersleeve, a Santa Fe lawyer, at present in this city, said to a reporter yesterday that he knew "Billy the Kid" very well by sight, having frequently seen him in jail. Mr. Gildersleeve also knew the history of the robber, which showed that he was brought up in New Mexico at a stage-station kept by his mother, who married a soldier about fifteen years ago. This stage-station, a cross between a tavern, restaurant and saloon, was the place where Billy received his education, and he was always considered "a hard boy." So far as the record goes to show he has killed thirteen men in cold blood, some of them on the most trivial pretext or without any pretext at all, although he claimed to have killed a man for every year of his life. The actual band of freebooters and assassins under his control was not large, but was composed of the most desperate men; and he had a majority of the people within a radius of one hundred miles in a thorough state of terror of their lives, by which means he kept farmers and stock-raisers in complete subjection. Sheriff Garrett had been on his trail for four months, and when he started he swore that he never would return until he had captured or shot the "Kid." Now that he has succeeded, he has announced his intention to retire from public life to his ranch, his highest ambition as an officer having been satisfied. Subscriptions are being raised for him by the citizens of Santa Fe, Las Vegas and other towns.

See the clipping

The Kid’s finger, in alcohol

A friend at Fort Sumner sends the Las Vegas Optic the index finger of Billy the Kid, ‘well preserved in alcohol.’ If the crowds keep coming, the paper says, it will buy a small tent and open a side show.

Lyon County Times · Silver City, Nev.

Lyon County Times · 6 August 1881 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The Fatal Finger. An esteemed friend of the Optic at Fort Sumner, has sent us the index finger of "Billy, the Kid," the one that has snapped many a man's life into eternity. It is well preserved in alcohol and has been viewed by many in our office to-day. If the rush continues we shall purchase a small tent and open a side show, to which complimentary tickets will be issued to our personal friends.—Las Vegas Optic.

See the clipping

The Fourth Ward says he was McCarthy

The New York Sun goes to the Fourth Ward, where a policeman remembers Michael McCarthy, who knifed a brush maker in 1876 and fled West: same height, same eyes, ‘the same projecting teeth.’ Twenty neighbours agree, and one says a childhood acid burn would settle it. A Santa Fe lawyer who knew the Kid had already told the New York World otherwise.

The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Russellville Democrat · 18 August 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CLAIMING BILLY THE KID.

New York People Who Think He Was Born Among Them.

See moreSee less

New York Sun.

There is a general belief in the Fourth Ward that, notwithstanding statements to the contrary, "Billy the Kid," who on Saturday last was shot dead by Sheriff Garrett at Fort Sumner, New Mexico, was born and brought up in that ward. The dispatch announcing his death reported that his real name was McCarthy, and that he was a New Yorker by birth. The Fourth Warder's name was McCarthy. He is described as answering in personal appearance to the description of the Kid, and it is said that he fled to the West in 1876 after committing a murder in this city.

"I'm convinced that Billy the Kid and McCarthy are one and the same persons," said Policeman Thomas Dwyer of the Oak street station last evening. "McCarthy was of the same height as the Kid, had hair and eyes of the same color, and the same projecting teeth. I remamebr McCarthy well, and the murder he committed was the most brutal that ever came under my notice. It happened on the night of Sept. 9, 1876. He had been on bad terms with Tom Moor, a brush maker, living at 9 Vandewater street. Moore worked in a factory in Fulton street, and was the only support of his mother. He was not 20 years old, and was a fine, broad-shouldered fellow. On the night of the 9th he went to the grocery store of Matthew Dwyer at the corner of Pearl and Hague streets. There McCarthy met him, and they quarrelled, McCarthy ran into the grocery store, and picking up a beer glass with one hand and a large knife, such is used to slice ham with, in the other, came out. He threw the glass at Moore, who dodged it, and attempted to clinch with him. McCarthy met him with the knife, sending it through Moore's chin, cutting into his throat, and burying the blade ten inche deep in his breast. One of Moore's thumbs was cut off as he held up his hand to ward off the blow. McCarthy ran down Hague street and through a passage to 84 Frankfort street where he threw away the knife. Moore staggered to the front of 357 Pearl street, and fell dead into the arms of a friend. McCarthy was traced to Brooklyn, where he was lost sight of. His father kept a fruit stand at the corner of Nassau and John streets, and was thought to have money. Shortly after his son's disappearavce he left the city, and was gone for several months. It was said at the time that he had taken McCarthy to Ireland. When he returned I know that his son came with him, and I afterward learned that son went West. In 1878 the old man died, and Dad' McCarthy, his other son, and Mrs. McCarthy died a few months later. There are two girls of the family still living. McCarthy was bad from a child, and had some Western experience before he fled West in 1876. When 13 or 14 years old he was sent to the House of Refuge, and through the Children's Aid Society, I think he was bound out to a Western farmer. He stayed a year or so, and then he escaped and came back to this city. He was born in Vandewater street and went to the Vandewater street school. His given name was Michael, but I have heard that he changed it after the murder. He was a little pased 17 when he killed Moore, and looked younger. His teeth were strong and white, but the two front upper teeth were longer than the rest and projected. He was then about five feet five inches tall, but may not then have got his growth. He had blue eyes and brown hair. His face was somewhat tanned. He learned to ride, I know, while on the farm out West."

"As soon as I read the account of Billy the Kid's death, and saw that his real name was McCarthy," said the man into whose arms Moore had fallen after being stabbed, "it occurred to me at once that he was Moore's murderer. The descriptions tallied, and McCarthy was just the man to turn out a desperado."

A Sun reporter talked last night with twenty Fourth Warders, all of whom had known McCarthy. They were all of the opinion that he and "Billy the Kid" were identical. "There is one way to make sure of it" said a young man employed in a grocery shop in Pearl street, near Hague. "McCarthy when 10 years old, was badly burned with acid, and was treated at the Chambers Street Hospital; but I think he must have a scar on the upper part of one of his legs and on his body."

See the clipping

London approves

In London the Saturday Review gives two columns to praising Garrett and thinks him ‘exactly the man for Galway County.’

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Salt Lake Herald · 23 August 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

The Saturday Review devotes two columns of laudation to Sheriff Garrett, who shot "Billy the Kid," and thinks him exactly the man for Galway County.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: Captured, Condemned, Escaped