As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · As the Papers Told It

Act One

“Kid” Antrim

April 1878 – December 1880

The papers first name him in April 1878, as ‘Kid, alias Antrim,’ running out under fire for the rifle of the sheriff his party had just shot. That summer one paper counts him among the dead of the battle at Lincoln. Two years later he is ‘Billy the Kid,’ at the head of a gang on the Pecos, and Pat Garrett is riding after him.

The first time the papers name him

Sheriff Brady is shot dead in the plaza at Lincoln by men firing from McSween’s house. As Brady falls he drops his rifle, and ‘Kid, alias Antrim,’ one of the attacking party, runs out to take it and is wounded. It is the earliest mention of him in this collection.

Arizona Citizen · Tucson, Ariz.

Arizona Citizen · 26 April 1878 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

CIVIL WAR IN NEW MEXICO.

Reign of Terror in Lincoln County!

See moreSee less

The Mesilla Valley Independent inform us that affairs have reached a critical condition in Lincoln county. On Monday 1st instant, at the town of Lincoln, Sheriff Brady while walking towards the court-house in the plaza, was fired upon by a party of men posted on McSween's house, and instantly killed. George Windman was shot and killed same time. When Brady fell he dropped his rifle. Kid, alias Antrim, who it appears, was one of the attacking party ran out to secure it. He was fired upon by Mathews and wounded. McSween, Robert Widerman and W. P. Shields were subsequently arrested and taken to Stanton where they are held as prisoners.

On Thursday the 4th instant a party of fourteen regulators under command of Richard Brewer rode up to the Indian agency and Blazer's mill and dismounted and asked for food. Godfrey, the Indian agent, told them they might have dinner, which they partook of, leaving two of their party outside. While they were still inside a man named Roberts, whom they were in search of, rode up. He was evidently unaware that this party were inside and inquired if a posse had been there. He immediately discovered that he had committed a fatal mistake and indicated a disposition to sell his life dearly. Frank Coe came out and sat down by Roberts outside the house, and engaged him in conversation. In the meantime the balance of the party scattered out and disposed themselves, so as to obtain a cross fire on Roberts. Suddenly Coe sprang to one side, leaving Roberts standing alone, and the firing commenced. It is not positively known who fired the first shot. Roberts was shot in the side, the ball traversing the bowels and inflicting a fatal wound. He however, shot one of the attacking party, named Middleton, through the lungs. George Coe was shot through the hand and Bowder was slightly wounded in the side.

Roberts then took shelter in Doctor Blazer's room, barricaded the doors with matrasses, &c., and made a desperate fight, not for his life, for he was already a dead man to all intents. Brewer, who was very much engaged, ordered Dr. Blazer and Maj. Godfrey to turn Roberts out. This they refused to do. Brewer then threatened to burn the house unless the wounded man was turned over to him. Mrs. Godfrey pleaded with Brewer for the life of Roberts, who was a stranger to her, but without avail. Finding that the inmates of the house could not be persuaded or intimidated into turning Roberts over, Brewer proceeded to the sawmill, about one hundred and twenty-five yards from the door of the room in which Roberts had taken shelter, and getting behind a saw-log glanced over it at the door. Roberts caught a glimpse of the top Brewer's head and fired, the ball entering Brewer's eye, killing him instantly.

The band left shortly afterwards, taking with them Middleton, who is perhaps fatally wounded, and leaving Brewer's body, which was buried by Dr. Blazer and Maj. Godfrey the next day. Roberts died the following day.

See the clipping

Reported dead, the first time

An Arizona paper’s casualty list for the fight at Lincoln counts eight of the McSween party dead, ‘including McSween and the "Kid" Henry Antrim.’ He was not dead; two years later he was leading a gang on the Pecos. It is the first time the papers report him killed, and not the last.

Arizona Silver Belt · Globe City, Ariz.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 848 days later.

Wrong

Arizona Silver Belt · 8 August 1878 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Lincoln County, N. M., is still in the hands of the respective factions which have so greatly disturbed the peace of that community for months past. The latest news from there is that nine persons were killed in the town of Lincoln. Eight of the McSween party including McSween and the "Kid" Henry Antrim, and Bob Beckwith of the Sheriff's posse. The number wounded is not stated. The fight is reported as having lasted eight hours. The McSween party, after the fall of their leader, retreated.

See the clipping

Billy the Kid’s gang at home

By December 1880 the papers call him ‘Billy the Kid,’ at the head of a gang that keeps guards posted at its camp at the Portales, splits up to raid the ranches of the Pecos country, and rides into Fort Sumner to run the town, ‘drinking, carousing, rowing and giving balls.’ The Las Vegas paper calls on the county to wipe the gang out.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 848 days earlier.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 3 December 1880 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

DESPERADOE,S STRONGHOLD.

An Organized Gang Assisted by Nature and Defiantly Reckless.

See moreSee less

Who Terrorize the Country to the East Of Us.

There is a duty which the people of San Miguel county should immediately discharge in the ousing of a powerful gang of outlaws, who are continually harrassing the stock men in the Pecos and Panhandle country and terrorizing the people of Ft. Sumner and vicinity.

Between thirty and forty miles from Sumner is a place called the Portales, a lake on the edge of the Staked Plains, the shore of which is fringed with rocks, and is by nature and situation one of the wildest places in the country.

When the storms come, the herds are driven there for shelter, and no matter from what direction the storm blows it is sure to carry with it a rich bovine tide.

Taking advantage of this, a gang of outlaws have made it their rendezvous, and building dugouts, have made for themselves a little camp, which with the natural advantages of the locality, they consider well nigh impregnable.

The gang includes from forty to fifty men, all hard characters, the offscouring of society, fugitives from justice, and desperadoes by profession. Among them are men, with whose names and deeds the people of Las Vegas are perfectly familiar, such as "Billy the Kid," Dave Ruterbaugh, Charlie Boudre, and others of equally unsavory reputation.

When J. J. Webb, who was convicted of the murder of Kelliher, made his escape from the Las Vegas jail a few weeks since, he made a break for the Portales and is now reckoned as one of the fold.

The band is well armed and have plenty of ammunition, and as they have no hankering to be "pulled in" are very determined.

One circumstance, however, has made them very incautious, which inspires the hope that if a well organized raid is made on them, they may yet be brought to justice. The bivouac of the desperadoes is on what may be termed disputed territory. Lying on or near the boundaries of Valencia, Lincoln, and San Miguel counties, it is yet held by many that it is included within the limits of the former county.

From this very uncertainty, officials of the three counties have made it an excuse for hesitating about raiding them, each claiming that it is outside of their jurisdiction. This the raiders are perfectly aware of, as they are equally well informed of all matter going on in the neighborhood, which leads to the belief that there are otheres in league with them, who are never engaged in action.

If the truth were known, it is safe to say that men right here in Vegas would be called before the bar of justice to answer to the charge of complicity in this nefarious calling.

Although the band has been organized for some time, it never was so strong as it is to-day, and the party of old offenders who have been obliged to change their quarters many times, are the nucles of the present organization.

The time during which they have committed depredations extends over a period of a number of months, but each time they have changed base they have attracted to them others of the same ilk.

Lincoln county people who have been made the victims of their depredations, at last rose in their might and making it too hot for them, finally and forever drove them from their territory.

The gang is under the leadership of "Billy the Kid," a desperate cuss, who is eligible to the post of captain of any crowd, no matter how mean and lawless. They spend considerable time in enjoying themselves at the Portales, keeping guards out, and cutting the country for miles around before turning in for the night.

Whenever there is a good opportunity to make a haul they split up in gangs and scour the country, always leaving behind a detachment to guard their roost and whatever plunder they may have stored there.

Another resort is the old ranch at Canaditas, ten or eleven miles from Sumner, about which they hover, before swooping down on the ranges and ranches in the Pecos country. Whenever the caprice seizes them, they flock into Ft. Sumner and take possession, running things to suit themselves, drinking, carousing, rowing and giving balls.

They run stock from the Panhandle country into the White Oaks and from the Pecos country into the Panhandle, equalizing the herds, but true middle-men style always make heavily by the transaction. Only a short time ago, a considerable amount of stock was found at the Oaks, which it is positively known was stolen from the Panhandle.

Are the people of San Miguel county to stand this any longer? Shall we suffer this horde of outcasts and the scum of society, who are outlawed by a multitude of crimes, to continue their sway on the very border of our county?

We believe the citizens of San Miguel county to be order loving people, and call upon them to unite with the little bands, scattered throughout the country lying to the east of us, in forever wiping out this band. Now is the time to act, for every storm enriches them by driving to their rendezvous large herds from which they make their selection. If anything is done, reinforcements in plenty could be secured from the Panhandle country, and resolute men from the association of stockmen could be drafted into the army of vengeance.

See the clipping

‘Not long for this world’

The Kid’s band reads the Gazette religiously, the Las Vegas paper reports, and at Fort Sumner Billy swore that if he got ‘those GAZETTE fellows down here’ he would ‘make it hot for them.’ The paper is delighted he has read its ‘little obituary notice’ of him, ‘for from all accounts he is not long for this world.’ Sheriff Pat Garrett and a posse of thirteen men have set out after him, with Frank Stewart’s ‘Panhandle boys’ to help. Within the week Garrett has him.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 22 December 1880 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

"The Kid's" Compliments.

"The Kid's" band show very good taste in reading the GAZETTE religiously, and thus learn what is stirring the outside world, from which they are practically exiled. On numerous occasions we have sought to rouse the people of the country to the east of us to organize a brisk campaign that the gang might be captured or driven out of the country. One article in particular in which we represented the members to be more black than they are usually painted naturally fell into the hands of the band. Last week while Billy "the Kid" and some of his band were in Sumner they indulged in many threats of what they would do. "By ——," exclaimed Billy with much fervor, resorting to the dash dialect very frequently, "onlp let me get those GAZETTE fellows down here, and I'll make it hot for them.

See moreSee less

We are delighted to know that Billy has read our little obituary notice for from all accounts he is not long for this world. It is a special privilege that Livingston, the African explorer, Marshal Bazaine and a few others only have enjoyed, to read their abituary notices and the outlaw should feel himself favored.

"The Kid" and several of his party started for Ft. Sumner from their rendezvous the latter part of last week. Sheriff Pat Garrett and a posse of thirteen men started in pursuit of them, and Frank Stewart's Panhandle boys were expected to act in concert with them. The prospect is that they succeeded in correling them, and that a brisk fight has taken place long ere this

See the clipping

← Back to The Setting: The Lincoln County War