As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · As the Papers Told It

Act Five

The Kid Who Wouldn’t Stay Dead

July 1882 – January 1883

Dead a year, the Kid will not lie still. Puck turns him into a comic poem; a paper reports the death of Nellie, who is said to have ridden with his gang in buckskin and won his heart; a ‘statistical writer’ has him born in Rhode Island. In January 1883 a dispatch from Montana has vigilantes shoot him, and the New-York Tribune has to explain that the real Kid is still dead and the Montana man had only borrowed the name. ‘He is very numerous,’ says a Wisconsin paper.

Puck laughs at the legend

A year after his death the comic weekly Puck sends the Kid up in verse: he spits on a passing farmer, is thrown into a tree, and is shaken down by his mother ‘from a tree with a trammel-hook.’ None of it happened; the legend is already big enough to mock.

Daily Globe · St. Paul, Minn.

Daily Globe · 9 July 1882 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

STRANGE HISTORY OF BILLY THE KID.

This is what came to Billy the Kid, And these are the wondrous deeds he did:

See moreSee less

Three times on his dainty hands he spat, And three times crumpled his new felt hat;

And gracefully on a gate-post there He leaned with an attitude of debonnair;

And his brawny arms he akimbo placed, And the landscape picture was truly graced.

A man came riding adown the way, And he rode aloft on a pile of hay;

And as he went lumbering past the gate, Billy at him did expectorate.

And the man grew wrathful, as well he might, And bared his arms for a bloody fight.

To the ground he sprang with a mighty stride, And soon he stood by Brave Billy's side.

He took the Kid by his Roman nose, And he mopped the road with his Sunday clothes.

And he pulled him up, and he threw him down, Till he looked much like a circus clown.

And then he pitched him up a tree, And a scarecrow there Bill seemed to be.

And this, despite that Bill's pockets bore A pistol famed for the scent of gore.

Then the man jumped back on his fragrant load, And gayly meandered down the road.

And he whistled aloud in savage glee, So long as Billy he could see;

And he said; "Young man, let me you implore In the future to use a cuspidor."

Then Billy's mother came out, and shook That boy from a tree with a trammel-hook.

And she boxed the ears on his aching head, And kept him a week or more in bed.

This is a tale from the ages dim Of Billy the Kid, and what came to him. —Puck.

See the clipping

Nellie, who rode with the gang

A paper reports the death at Fort Sumner of Nellie Pickett, said to have ridden with the Kid’s gang ‘in a buckskin suit astride a horse,’ spied for it, and buried Charles Bowdry before the Kid ‘succeeded finally in winning her affections.’ It was while visiting her, the story goes, that Garrett trapped and killed him.

Orange County Observer · Hillsborough, N.C.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 25 days earlier.

Orange County Observer · 14 October 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A Woman Desperado Nellie Pickett, the most noted female character ever in New Mexico, died recently at Fort Sumner, aged twenty-four years. She was born in Lafayette County, Mo. When she was healthy, vivacious, and pretty, she married Tom Pickett and moved with him to Texas. They lived there a year, and then came to New Mexico. At the time of the Lincoln County war, in 1880, Pickett became a member of the band of Billy the Kid and after the war was over Nellie joined him, and herself became a member of the gang, of bandits.

See moreSee less

She was a fearless horsewoman, a crack shot, beautiful, and with great strength of mind. She ruled the band with despotic sway. Pickett was killed in a fight with officers, when Nellie became the mistress of the First Lieutenant, Charles Bowdry. Dressed in male or female attire, as suited her purpose, she acted as a spy for the gang, carrying messages from one rendezvous to the other. When in male attire she always rode in a buckskin suit astride a horse. Bowdry was killed in the fight with Sheriff Garrett and his posse. She was as true to him as his own wife. She found his body after the fight and buried it. Billy the Kid succeeded finally in winning her affections. Last year, while a heavy price was on his head, he visited her at Fort Sumner. While there Garrett ascertained the facts entrapped and killed him.

See the clipping

Rhode Island claims him

A ‘statistical writer’ says Rhode Island has bred more famous devils than any other northern state, and puts the Kid’s birth at Watch Hill, beside Wild Bill from Providence and Calamity Jane from Newport. Four years later a New Mexican, defending the territory, calls him ‘a New York city boy.’

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 1,547 days later.

Wrong

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 25 November 1882 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BREAKFAST TABLE TALK

A statistical writer says: Rhode Island has furnished more men of national reputation for inherent deviltry than any other northern state. Wild Bill was born in Providence. "Billy, the Kid," of recent unsavory renown, came originally from Watch Hill, and "Calamity Jane" is a native of fashionable Newport. "Texas Jack," for whom, like Homer, seven cities claim the honor of his birth, was born in Bristol, and "Yellowstone Kelley," the scout of Montana, is a native of Pawtucket.

See the clipping

The real Kid is still dead

A dispatch has ‘Billy the Kid’ shot down crossing a river in Montana, and the New-York Tribune sets it straight: the original, killed by Garrett, ‘has not been resurrected again,’ and his skull is ‘said to ornament a physician’s office.’ The Montana outlaw had only borrowed the name, which every band of desperadoes gives its youngest member.

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Sacramento Daily Record-Union, 17 January 1883, Alexandria Gazette, 17 January 1883, Daily Republican, 18 January 1883, New-York Tribune, 18 January 1883.

New-York Tribune · 20 January 1883 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

It may be interesting to know that the original "Billy the Kid," who was shot by Sheriff "Pat" Garrett in New-Mexico, has not been resurrected again, as a dispatch from Weeksville, Montana, might indicate. The New-Mexican hero was not only killed, but his skull and various other portions of his anatomy are said to ornament a physician's office. The Montana outlaw, who has just been shot down in crossing a river, had evidently so fallen into the habit of appropriating the belongings of others that he had taken the name of his illustrious prototype. But there are plenty of "Kids" in the Western country, for the youngest member of every band of desperadoes is given that touching appellation, which suggests more innocence than actually exists.

See the clipping

Killed again, in Montana

The Weeksville dispatch now runs as a one-line item: vigilantes clearing the town of thieves have ‘shot and killed the notorious desperado.’ The man they shot was a Montana outlaw who had taken the Kid’s name.

Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J. · and 2 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Gloucester County Democrat · 25 January 1883 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A vigilance committee in Weeksville, M. T., in getting rid of the thieves in that town, shot and killed the notorious desperado, "Billy the Kid."

See the clipping

‘He is very numerous’

The same day a Wisconsin paper names the habit: whenever news is thin, ‘some one kills or captures a “Billy the Kid.”’ There must, it says, be ‘lots of him in the land that is warmer than this.’

The Manitowoc Pilot · Manitowoc, Wis.

The Manitowoc Pilot · 25 January 1883 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy the Kid" has been killed again. Whenever there is a dearth of sensational news some one kills or captures a "Billy the Kid." He is very numerous and there must be lots of him in the land that is warmer than this.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Four: The Making of a Legend