As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

Old-Timers and Legends

October 1885 – April 1930

For the next forty-five years the men who were there tell it, and everyone else retells it. A traveller meets a modest Garrett; an old-timer of Lincoln remembers saddling the pony for the escape and will not blame the Kid for his guards; Lew Wallace recalls the pardon he offered at midnight. Garrett is shot dead in 1908 and his obituaries are the Kid’s. By then the Kid is a touring play and a newspaper serial; by 1926 there are stories that he never died; and in 1930 Hollywood casts a football star to play him.

Meeting Pat Garrett

A traveller in Lincoln County hears that the Kid killed ‘twenty-one men’ there and that Garrett was made sheriff to clean out the gang. Brought face to face with the hero, he finds a tall, soft-spoken man who will not talk about it: ‘O I guess I am.’

Savannah Morning News · Savannah

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from 161 days earlier.

Savannah Morning News · 29 October 1885 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

"In Lincoln county, N. M., one hears a great deal about the exploits of Billy the Kid and his gang, and how they were eventually cleaned out by Pat Garret, who was elected Sheriff for that purpose. It appears that Billy the Kid, who had killed, with Winchester and revolver, twenty-one men in that county, was the leader of a gang of thieves and murderers that stole horses and cattle as they pleased, and defied the authorities. The people finally became excited, and some of the leading men induced Pat Garret to accept the office of Sheriff.

See moreSee less

One of them told me that they obtained his consent to act by explaining to him that he was a quick, dead shot, and that the gang were afraid of him. They said: 'You can clean them out; you may get killed, but if you can get away with them you will make your reputation and fortune.' Pat Garret went to work without delay, and himself killed Billy the Kid and two of the gang, his deputies killed two more, and the rest fled from that part of the country. The result is that peace and order prevail, and Pat Garret is the hero of the county. "Having a curiosity to see the man I was one day brought face to face with him and introduced with the remark: 'This is Pat Garret.' He is a man about 6 feet 5 inches tall, with mild blue eyes and low, pleasant voice, and seemed to be too modest and backward to fight even if imposed upon. He was such an entirely different type to what my imagination pictured that I thought my friends were having a little joke at my expense, and I said to him: 'The boys are fooling me; you ain't Pat Garret.' He said, 'O I guess I am,' and then turned the conversation away from himself. There is nothing of the braggart about Pat Garret, and no one can get him to tell about what he did and how it was done except his intimate friends.

See the clipping

The man who saddled the pony

An old-timer who lived behind the Lincoln court-house tells how Bell died in his arms, Olinger fell at his feet, and he saddled the pony the Kid rode away on; he offers to share Garrett’s sin for half the reward. Of the two guards he writes: ‘This is the only murder I know of Billy ever committing. I did not blame him then—I don’t blame him now. Life is sweet.’

The Lincoln County Leader · White Oaks, N.M.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Los Angeles Daily Herald, 9 January 1890, Arizona Weekly Citizen, 11 January 1890.

The Lincoln County Leader · 1 March 1890 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Once upon a time, it was, if I mistake not, in the month of April 1880, 1881, or perhaps 1882, whilst Mr. Sam. Wortley, the now possessor of a rich coal mine at Salado, and myself, were raising a vegetable garden behind the court house at Lincoln, that Billy the Kid was brought back from Dona Ana County, where he was traced, for murder, and sentenced to be hanged in Lincoln. About a week after the date I am writing about, he killed his two keepers and escaped. As the County had no jail then he was kept under guard in the upper story of the court-house.

See moreSee less

Sam. and myself lived in a house together, behind the court house. That memorable day I came out of my room, whence I had gone to light my pipe, and was crossing the yard behind the court-house, when I heard a shot fired, a tussle up stairs in the court house, somebody hurrying down stairs, and deputy sheriff Bell emerging from the door running toward me. He ran right into my arms, expired the same moment, and I laid him down, dead. That I was in a hurry to secure assistance, or perhaps to save myself, everybody will believe. When I arrived at the garden gate leading to the street, in front of the court house, I saw the other deputy sheriff, Olinger, coming out of the hotel opposite, with the other four or five county prisoners where they had taken their dinner I called to him to come quick. He did so, leaving his prisoners in front of the hotel. When he had come close up to me, and while standing not more than a yard apart, I told him that I was just after laying Bell dead on the ground in the yard behind, and before he could reply, he was struck by a well directed shot fired from a window above us, and fell dead at my feet. I ran for my life to reach my room and safety, when Billy the Kid called to me: "Don't run, I would'nt hurt you—I am alone, and master, not only of[?] the courthouse, but also of the town, for I will allow nobody to come near us You go," he said, "and saddle one of Judge Leonard's horses, and I will clear out as soon as I can have the shackles loosened from my legs." With a little prospecting pick I had thrown to him through the window he was working for at least an hour, and could not accomplish more than to free one leg, and he came to the conclusion to await a better chance, tie one shackle to his waist-belt, and start out. Meanwhile I had saddled a small skittish pony belonging to Billy Burt, as there was no other horse available, and had also, by Billy's command, tied a pair of red blankets behind the saddle. I came near forgetting to say, that whilst I was busy saddling, and Mr. Billy Kid trying hard to get his shackle off, my partner, Mr. Sam. Wortley, appeared in the door leading from the garden where he had been at work, into the yard, and that when he saw the two sheriffs lying dead he did not know whether to go in or retreat, but on the assurance of Billy the Kid that he would not hurt him he went in and made himself generally useful. When Billy went down stairs at last, on passing the body of Bell, he said, "I'm sorry I had to kill him but could'nt help it." On passing the body of Olinger he gave him a tip with his boot, saying, "You are not going to round me up again." We went out together where I had tied up the pony, and he told me to tell the owner of same, Billy Burt, that he would send it back next day. I, for my part, did'nt much believe in this promise, but, sure enough, next morning, the pony arrived safe and sound, trailing a long lariat, at the court house in Lincoln. NUMBER 21 NUMBER 21 And so Billy the Kid started out that evening, after he had shaken hands with everybody around and after having had a little difficulty in mounting on account of the shackle on his leg, he went on his way rejoicing. That he was afterwards killed at Ft. Sumner by Pat. Garrett, is known to everybody. In conclusion I would like to say, that I have lately seen an article in a newspaper in which Mr. Pat. Garret is said to have expressed himself that whenever a friend introduced him to a stranger, the latter will generally reply, "Ah, very glad to get acquainted, Mr. Garrett—you are the man who killed Billy the Kid," and therefore he often wishes that Billy had got the better of him. It is possible, and does it not look very much like it, that Mr. Pat. Garret is sorry for having killed Billy—perhaps his conscience troubles him. If this should be the case I will tell him one way thro' which he may perhaps find a little consolation. Let him turn over to Sam. Wortley and myself half of the money he made by killing Billy the Kid, let him join a church no matter of what denomination, and we will promise to take on our shoulders half of the sin, if there was any committed, and in the bargain we promise to intercede for him on the "other side of Jordan," and use our best endeavors to secure forgiveness for his other short and long comings on this sphere. This bargain Mr. Garret should be very willing to make with us, as had we done our duty, as some ignorant people say to this day, and have killed Billy the Kid, instead of letting him get away, he would not have had the precious game, for killing of which he pocketed such a big pile of lucre, and also, it might tranquilize his conscience to some degree. In regard to the guilt or innocence of Billy the Kid I will here state, that Billy himself, in many conversations I had with him during the two or three years I was acquainted with him prior to his death, never denied that he was in the habit of stealing cattle from John Chisum, of Roswell, against whom he professed to have a claim, for wages I believe, which Chisum refused to pay, and hence he was determined to secure himself. He always said to me that he had never killed anybody, and would never do so except in self defense. A couple of years before his tragic end he told me that during the time he was an outlaw in the Capitan Mountains all of Pat. Garret's deputies who tried to round him up were once in partnership with him stealing cattle from John Chisum. I do not now recollect for what murder Billy the Kid was tried and sentenced to death, but let me tell your readers that the late Judge Leonard, who defended him at his trial in Dona Ana County, often told me that he was condemned by a prejudiced jury, solely because his name was Billy the Kid, under which name many heinous crimes had been committed by Mexicans and outlaws from Texas and other States imported to this county, not by Billy the Kid, but by the principals of the then fighting two parties, which contest was called the "Lincoln County War," and left innumerable graves all over the county. Who will blame Billy the Kid for killing his two guards at the time of his escape from Lincoln, whilst he himself was to be hung up the week following?—This is the only murder I know of Billy ever committing. I did not blame him then—I don't blame him now. Life is sweet.

See the clipping

The governor’s bargain

Lew Wallace, once governor of New Mexico, tells how he met the Kid at midnight in a desert cabin and offered to let him go ‘scot-free with a pardon in your pocket’ if he would testify to the murder of the lawyer Chapman. The retelling around it runs to legend, from Jesse James among the men arrested to ‘a man for each year he had lived.’

Harrison Press-Journal · Harrison, Nebraska

Harrison Press-Journal · 31 July 1902 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

Interesting Tale in Autobiography of General Lew Wallace.

New York letter: General Lew Wallace has surpassed all his efforts as a fiction writer in the true story which he will tell in his forthcoming and long-awaited autobiography—the tale of his own personal encounter with one of the most dreaded depseradoes this country has ever known.

See moreSee less

The story is one of Gen. Lew Wallace's exciting experiences while governor of the territory of New Mexico, when he was brought face to face in the middle of the desert, at dead of night and under extraordinary attendant circumstances, with "Billy the Kid," who of all the many picturesque outlaws whose careers are part of the Wild West's history, stands out a distinct and solitary personality.

Instances are on record of strange assignations made between defiers of the law and its representatives, where the latter sought to gain some legitimate end by holding the perilous interview, but romance in its wildest flights never imagined any episode more absolutely in recital than this record of stern reality.

The story, too, brings into sharpest contrast the West of the past and the West of today. Imagine such an occurrence happening at the present time!

It was twenty-five years ago. Billy the Kid was in 1879 the personification of all that meant terror to the people of New Mexico—his name was the watchword of a desperate and devoted following.

Hoping to find out something that would inure to the benefit of the law, Gen. Wallace exposed himself to infinite peril in risking his meeting with the outlaw.

But Billy the Kid was himself far from secure in agreeing to meet the governor; he stood in peril of his life by making the appointment and keeping it. Between the two principals, of course, the strictest honor and good faith was observed.

The meeting was held, near midnight, in a lonely cabin on the desert near Santa Fe. General Wallace was on the spot first, and sat waiting for the outlaw with no other companion than the solitary owner of the cabin. When Billy the Kid arrived he stood at the door, covering, with a revolver and a Winchester, the two men inside. He first asked "if the governor was one of the two?" as he had an appointment with him at that precise hour. He looked like a boy, this notorious Western terror, slim and soft-voiced, yet he stood there the living embodiment of resistance to law and order.

The general offered his hand, but the outlaw did not take it until he had uttered the formal statement that he had been promised the official protection. When this was reassured to him, he and the governor took seats facing each other at a small rough table. The two came to terms before they parted and the result of the interview was very valuable from the governor's point of view. Here is General Wallace's explanation, in his own words, of the purpose of the midnight meeting::

"Shortly before I had become governor of New Mexico, Chapman, a young attorney at Lincoln, had been murdered. Half a dozen men were arrested, accused of the crime. Among them was Jesse James. While it was more than probable that one or more of the men charged with the murder were guilty, it was impossible to prove the allegation, for the witnesses, filled with terror, fled the country. When I reached New Mexico it was declared on every hand that 'Billy the Kid' had been a witness to the murder. Could he be made to testify?

"That was a question on the tip of every tongue.

"I had been sent to the Southwest to pacify the territory; here was an opportunity I could not afford to pass by. Therefore I arranged the meeting by note deposited with one of the outlaw's friends, and at midnight was ready to receive the desperado should he appear. He was there on time—punctual to the second.

"When 'Billy the Kid' stepped to the chair opposite mine, I lost no time in stating my proposition.

"'Testify,' I said, 'before the grand jury and the trial court and convict the murderer of Chapman and I will let you go scot-free with a pardon in your pocket for all your own misdeeds.'

"'Billy' heard me in silence; he thought several minutes without reply.

"'Governor,' he said, 'if I were to do what you ask they would kill me.'

"'We can prevent that,' said I.

"Then I unfolded my plan. Billy was to be seized while he was asleep. To all appearances, his capture was to be genuine. To this he agreed, picking the men who were to effect his capture. He was afraid of hostile bullets and would run no risk. Another stipulation was to the effect that during his confinement he should be kept in irons. 'Billy the Kid' was afraid also of the loss of his reputation as a desperate man."

As arranged, therefore, next morning the famous outlaw was arrested and lodged in the jail of Lincoln county. In prison, by the governor's permission, the desperado gave some wonderful demonstrations of his attainments as a dead shot. The general asked whether there was not a trick in the wonderful marksmanship.

"Well, general," replied the desperado, "there is a trick to it. When I was a boy I noticed that a man in pointing to anything he wished observed, used his index finger. With long use, unconsciously, the man had learned to point with it with unerring aim. When I lift my revolver, I say to myself, 'Point with your finger.' I stretch the finger along the barrel and, unconsciously, it makes the aim certain. There is no failure; I pull the trigger and the bullet goes true to its mark."

Billy was asked that he be subjected to all the regular routine of prison discipline. Here he found opportunity for springing further surprises on the prison authorities. After breakfast one day he stood still, and, as if done by a conjuror, the handcuffs fell from his wrists. Then, before the guards could recover themselves, "the Kid" walked out the prison gate, and without even hurrying himself in doing it. Some one had left a horse, saddled, standing at a door in the street. He mounted it, and rode away.

General Wallace, after a close investigation, became convinced that the escape was a miracle of hypnotism—the guards were in no league whatever with the prisoner; he had in some mysterious way held them spell bound with the mere force of his personality.

Some weeks later "Billy the Kid" was again a prisoner in the same jail. This time he was in the hands of Sheriff Garrett of Lincoln county, who, it was said, was, of all men in the Territory, the only one not afraid of "Billy." General Wallace soon received a note from the captive, who for some reason, had now lost his amazing self-confidence. The note said that "Billy" had some papers the general would not care to have exposed.

But General Wallace understood the outlaw's game. He thus refers to the incident:

"I knew what he meant." He referred to the note he received from me and in response to which he appeared at the hut on the mesa. He was threatening to publish it if I refused to see him. I thwarted his purpose by giving a copy of the letter and a narrative of the circumstances connected with it to the paper published in the town. It was duly printed and upon its appearance a copy was sent to 'Billy' in his cell. He had nothing further to say."

When finally convicted and sentenced to death, "Billy the Kid," like Macbeth, was not afraid, for he declared that none of womanborn could harm him. In the condemned cell they guarded him vigilantly with a detail of nine men, night and day. But his chance was to come.

It was the day before that on which he was to die, and the desperado was at dinner. The absent-minded guard stooped towards the ground for an instant. It was a fatal act for him, for the quick-eyed prisoner dashed his heavily-manacled hands upon the head of the unsuspecting guard, took the man's revolver, with which he terrorized the other guards as they ran up, and broke his way out of the prison.

The outlaw had duplicated his daring feat. But this second time he had escaped from a different sort of captor—Sheriff Garrett was not the one to be easily cheated of his quarry. General Wallace relates how the sheriff followed the desperado to the mountains, tracking him down in a half-ruined fort. Garrett lay in wait near the gate of the fort until nightfall, and at a late hour he saw "Billy the Kid" at last come out into the yard.

The regular residents of the fort were Billy's sweetheart and her father. The sheriff entered, confronting the old man, whom he at once held up at the revolver's point; then he concealed himself behind the head of the bed. In an instant Billy re-entered, and instinctively realizing the presence of an enemy, demanded of the startled old man: "Who is here?" Upon this the sheriff, in pointing his revolver, fully revealed himself. The outlaw instantly fired at him, but the sheriff was quite as quick—simultaneous shots were heard, and one of the shooters dropped. It was not the sheriff, however, for in that single moment of his marvelous career "Billy the Kid" had forgotten to shoot straight. The sheriff bent unhurt above the form of his fallen foe, through whose heart a brace of bullets from Garrett's pistol had passed in swift succession. The terror of the Teritory had turned in his checks.

Thus, at 21, passed the man who had crowded into a few short years of early youth enough crime to make full records for a dozen desperadoes of the deepest dye. He had murdered a man for each year he had lived.

GEORGE MORRIS.

See the clipping

Garrett is dead

Pat Garrett is shot dead near Las Cruces in a quarrel over a ranch lease, and his obituary is mostly the Kid: a bandit of twenty-one who had killed twenty-one men ‘just to see them kick,’ ended by one shot at Maxwell’s bedside. It puts the killing in 1880; the papers had reported it in July 1881.

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill. · and 1 other paper

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Rock Island Argus · 8 April 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

ENEMY OF THE BAD

Pat Garrett, Slayer of "Billy the Kid," Has Been in Many Daring Exploits.

See moreSee less

SKILLED AS REVOLVER SHOT

How Hunter of Notorious Outlaw Who Recently Died With His Boots on, Disposed of Desperado.

Patrick F. Garrett, the former sheriff of Dona Ana county, in Texas, who was recently shot and killed by J. Wayne Brazle, a youthful ranchman, one of his tenants, near Las Cruces, N. M., in a dispute over a ranch lease, won popular fame in 1880 when he put to an end the bloody career of "Billy the Kid," the twenty-one-year-old bandit, who had killed twenty-one men "just to see them kick." For two years or more "the Kid" had been the terror of New Mexico with his thieving, marauding and his frequently recurring man killings. He had met all comers, and they were easy, but he hadn't met Pat Garrett. When he did, he erred.

Garrett had first come into notice as a foe of "bad men" in New Mexico about two years before he finally hunted down and killed the notorious "Kid," and he was anything except a green man at the game of fighting desperate criminals when the climax of his career came. Along about 1878, when Garrett was first made sheriff of Lincoln county, largely through the influence of General Lew Wallace, then governor of New Mexico, no one knew much about the young officer or of his mode of handling a gun, says the Kansas City Star. One day a friendly desperado, attracted by Garrett's innocent appearance, took him aside for a bit of counsel and advised him to go back to Texas, where there were lucid intervals of peace sometimes.

"This country is too warm for the like o' you," urged the desperado, "and you'll not last through the summer."

"Thanks," drawled Pat Garrett. "I can stand considerable heat, and I guess I'll stay."

It was said of Garrett that he could pull and shoot in about the time it takes a fly to get from under the hand that tries to catch it, and it seems to have been literally true.

Garrett gave the first demonstration of his skill with the revolver for the benefit of a western gentleman indulging in a little western saloon merriment. The gentleman, one Greenfelt, with a weakness for other men's horses, was amusing himself in a saloon making a couple of men dance by shooting at their feet. A third, whose terpsichorean skill or bashfulness had met the disapproval of the horse thief, lay on the floor with a bullet inconveniently concealed in his person when Pat Garrett casually dropped in.

"Three hands around!" whooped the horse thief, shifting his pistol toward Garrett, and almost on the last word he lunged forward on his face with a bullet through his heart. The last sound he heard in this world was Garrett's drawling comment:

"You're a poor caller."

Gave His First Demonstration.

Garrett had a number of other adventures before he finally came to the point in his life where "Billy the Kid" demanded his attention. But that time finally came. The bandit had just been out on one of his usual forays, which terminated in a saloon brawl and the ruthless killing of a man. It was the outlaw's twenty-first victim and his last.

When Garrett set out for "the Kid" he departed on no ordinary mission even for a man used to the capture and killing of border outlaws. The bandit was a wild and lawless youth, cunning, brave and dashing and as clever and fast with a gun as any man that ever trod the west, even though he was only a boy in years. Billy was both unscrupulous and cunning, albeit not without a leaven of chivalry and romance. His adventures had been numerous, and he was New Mexico's desperado hero, but Garrett didn't mind.

When the plucky sheriff overtook the bandit, "the Kid" took a look at his opponent, whom he knew immediately by repute, and decided that it was better to give up. He was tried and convicted of murder and sentenced to death. But the bandit was destined to die in another fashion than on the scaffold. Two careless deputies were outwitted, and he escaped.

A less experienced man would have gone out in pursuit while the trail was hot. Not so Garrett, who knew the ways of the desperate and wily outlaw. Instead he set out for the Maxwell ranch, near Carizzoo, in Lincoln county, where "the Kid's" sweetheart lived. Garrett and his men lay in wait until they saw a man dodge into the house under cover of the night. Garrett single handed slipped in after him and posted his men on the porch. Garrett knew Maxwell and walked to his room to ask whether the bandit had come in. Maxwell was asleep and had to be awakened. He knew nothing of "the Kid" and wasn't expecting him, but Garrett was pretty certain and on guard. He had just turned from Maxwell's bed in the darkness when "the Kid" entered the room. There was a tense moment. The bandit advanced to the bed, believing to speak to Maxwell.

"Who are they?" he asked, noticing the men on the porch.

In an instant he knew that Maxwell was not alone. The boy bandit made a quick, catlike move backward and whipped out his gun with incredible swiftness, but he was yet too slow. A bullet from Garrett's gun made him a bandit no longer. Garrett filled his own prophecy that he would die with his boots on.

See the clipping

The Kid on the stage

By 1913 ‘Billy the Kid’ is a touring play, praised in Arkansas for its ‘local color and well drawn types’ and booked into the Grand for Monday night.

The Log Cabin Democrat · Conway, Ark.

The Log Cabin Democrat · 11 January 1913 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

"BILLY THE KID."

Local color and well drawn types are again one of the features of the play, "Billy the Kid," which is being successfully presented again this season. Not that there are not many strong and dramatic situations, for there are, but the play is said to be exceedingly deftly written and to afford the actors many excellent opportunities of which they take the utmost advantage. The company is said to be made up of the best actors possible to obtain and includes the names of many favorites. "Billy the Kid" will be presented at the Grand Monday night.

See the clipping

The Kid as a demon

A newspaper series, ‘Men of the West,’ makes the Kid a model boy of seventeen turned ‘a butcher who took delight in slaying the defenseless,’ and has Garrett hand him a revolver so they can face down a lynch mob back to back. By 1913 the papers print the legend as adventure.

The Clio Messenger · Clio, Mich.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Clio Messenger · 14 February 1913 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

BILLY THE KID THE MOST FAMOUS OF THE BAD-MEN OF THE WEST by Frank J. Arkins © BY THE RIDGWAY CO.

A HOWLING mob of fortune-hunters crowded into Silver City, New Mexico, in the seventies. The uncovering of mineral wealth was beset with great danger. The Apaches were on the war-path. It was hazardous to travel in the country without an escort, but the magnet of wealth in the mines drew men to the scene notwithstanding. In the citizenship of the community there were rough men, for the early days were typical of those of other mining-camps isolated in the mountains and distant from civilization.

See moreSee less

In that community there lived a boy of seventeen years of age, respected and loved by all. He was a favorite among the young men and considered a model youth by the old. He was gentle as a child. His face was delicately molded, his skin as fair as a girl's, his hands small and fingers tapering. Lithe, graceful, self-reliant, he gave every promise of an honorable career.

This boy—William H. Bonney—was employed in a local store and was considered a most accommodating clerk. The gruff community was convulsed with horror and dumfounded with astonishment one afternoon when the news spread like wildfire that Bonney had hacked a man to death with a butcher-knife and was fleeing for his life on the back of a stolen horse.

The murder was particularly atrocious It was the result of an altercation in which young Bonney was crossed. Prior to this the boy had never been questioned. In an instant he was transformed into a demon, within a few minutes he had added theft to murder, and in seeking a place of safety left behind him a trail as broad as though he were following a macadam road.

At the point of a revolver he compelled strangers to exchange horses with him, seized the best mounts at the various ranches along his way and spread consternation wherever he went. He followed the Mimbres river toward Deming, pursued by a posse from Silver City. Closely pressed, he escaped eastward over the Oregon mountains, when it was thought he was headed for Mexico.

The Start of a Bad Man's Trail.

A western town was never more surprised The majority of the people still defended him; there was some reason, his friends declared, for his strange act. But as news came of the way he was striking terror in the Valley of the Pecos where the roughest men in the southwest lived, the mind of the public was changed. From that time on his murderous exploits filled the hearts of men with fear. The boy's name in western history became forever after Billy the Kid. His name of Bonney is all but forgotten. As the Kid, he stands as one of the great historical figures of the cow country, one of the worst youths that ever lived, prince of bad men, the youngest bad man of all.

His appearance among the prospectors and amid the mining camps of the Oregon mountains was electrical. Here he conceived the idea that to evade arrest he must fight his way to the front single-handed He boldly traded horses, obtained credit, bought supplies, because he could shoot straight with a revolver and had threatened the lives of a number of men. Then with all dispatch he pushed on to the Valley of the Pecos. This was the scene of the boy's exploits in the taking of human life.

The Pecos Valley was filled with men who had been driven out of Texas by the Rangers, and Billy the Kid's association with these men developed his mania for shedding blood. In his first altercation he realized that it was his life or the other man's. The fact that he was quick with a gun made him feared. He became embittered against one of the stockmen immediately upon his arrival in the valley.

"I'll make this valley too hot for him and dangerous to his punchers," said the boy.

At once he commenced to use this man's cowboys as targets to practice on. He began a campaign that drew upon him the enmity of everybody. The murder of these innocent men, purely to gratify a spite against their employer, made him a leader among the bands of armed thugs of the region. He had at a bound become a celebrity, and every group of bad men wanted to claim him. But the Kid would have none of that. By degrees he gathered a band of his own

How Many Men Did He Kill?

The Kid killed more men, wantonly and for sheer love of murder, than any other man of whom there is a record in the west. It will never be known just how many he assasinated. He was a butcher who took delight in slaying the defenseless. He knew no pangs of conscience. He had not one single redeeming trait. He would murder a friend as quickly as an enemy.

He thought nothing of appearing before a cook in charge of a "chuck" wagon, on a lonely desert range, ask for something to eat, compliment the man upon the quality of the food he had prepared, with apparent gratitude. He would ask him, as if the idea had suddenly popped into his head, whether he was an officer—or had been. Then, as though in doubt, he would shoot him in his tracks. This is no exaggeration. A man whom he left for dead, and who survived long enough to tell the story, was authority for the statement, shortly after his arrival on the Pecos river.

The boy was a terror before whom everybody fled. He rode the fastest horses, he helped himself to the best there was in every community he visited, wiggled out of any number of tight places, and shot his way to freedom a dozen times.

Shortly after his arrival in the valley, he was persuaded, because of his reputation as a bad man, to assist in the arrest of three men charged with murder. They were captured without the firing of a shot, placed on horses, ironed and started jailward. To the deputy sheriff, who with him followed the prisoners across a long, dusty sand plain, he turned suddenly and said,

"Let's kill those fellows."

"Why? They haven't done anything to us."

"They're guilty anyway, and we'll just save the county expense."

"No, Billy, they have not given us a chance to shoot at them—they have not tried to escape."

The deputy tried to argue with him, for he could see the light of murder dancing in the fellow's eyes.

The Kid rode forward, compelling the officer to do likewise, and, according to the story told, shot all three men. The deputy spurred his pony, the Kid after him. They exchanged shots, and the officer escaped with a few wounds.

From that time on it was dangerous for the Kid to enter a community. He raided north through Lincoln county, which was larger than many eastern states. There was not a line of railway or telegraph in it, and no telephones. It was easy to get away.

At that time there was rivalry between the different outfits. The country was filled with bad men, and they were about evenly divided among the cowmen. Cattle stealing was a common thing. The Kid became involved in a number of rows, and he took sides. His reputation as a "killer" grew.

Undoubtedly a number of these men were killed as a result of trouble among themselves, and the killing laid to the door of the Kid It was easy. He could not deny it. No one would have believed him if he had. Besides, the more murders credited to him, the greater the fear in which he would be held.

Thus it was that it finally became impossible to get any one to accept the position of sheriff of Lincoln county, for it was only a question of time when he would run across the youthful demon.

The Kid knew that he had terrorized the country. He knew that the instant he let down his guard he would be killed. His safety lay in continuing.

The Turn of the Tide.

Then, one day, even those hard characters who professed to be his friends were amazed by the report that for some trivial incident he had killed a member of his own band. The outlaws were now as anxious to end his career as were the law-abiding people of the village. His friends commenced to murmur. The Kid was now reported in a dozen places at the same time, and these stories he turned to his advantage by appearing at irregular, though frequent, intervals in widely separated cow camps for more than a hundred and fifty miles north and south of the Pecos river.

Pat Garrett, a lanky Alabaman, who had helped organize the Texas Rangers and had assisted in driving the bad men out of Texas to the first water west of the Staked Plains, was invited by the cattlemen to locate in New Mexico They wanted him to restore order. The only way that could be done was either to arrest or to kill the Kid.

Garrett's record in Texas as a man-hunter and bad man tamer was known all over the southwest. In addition to being quick with a gun, he was absolutely without fear.

He was elected without opposition and took hold with an iron hand. He was an organizer, and men flocked to his standard. They felt, instinctively, that at last a man had arrived who could cope with the situation.

The Capture of the Kid.

In November, 1880, Garrett came upon the Kid suddenly, after killing one man, with several others, after capturing one man.

Word had reached Garrett that the Kid and his gang of three were located in an old house a short distance from Sumner.

"We had better make plans to get him," said one of the deputies.

"The plan is to get there before he gets away. I'll tell you what to do on the way."

The way led down a sage-covered "draw," with several bends made by sand dunes around which the road curved for a distance of about five miles. Before he reached the last bend he pulled up his horse, and waiting for his deputies to come up to him, and then, in the even voice for which he was noted, said:

"I am going to ride ahead. All attention will be centered on me. That will give you a chance to surround the house. I am going to take my time and walk my horse. They may get me, but if they do I want you to make certain that you get him."

The deputies withdrew to right and left, advancing under cover of the sand hills in an ever-widening circle until they had surrounded the house. Then Garrett rode forward. From his position he could see his deputies, who had dismounted, advancing cautiously through the sagebrush. He permitted his horse to walk slowly, as though utterly unconscious of the presence of the gang At the door he called loudly.

Some one appeared at the window and, firing a shot at the sheriff, dodged back. It was done in an instant, but in that fraction of a second the man who had fired dropped dead in his tracks! Garrett had dismounted and with his deputies poured a fusillade of bullets through the sides of the thinly boarded shack. A white handkerchief at the window indicated the surrender of Billy the Kid and his gang.

"You Give Me a 'Six-Gun,' Pat!"

When Garrett reached the railroad with his prisoner he was menaced by a crowd that sought to lynch the Kid.

"It looks as though they are going to get me, Pat," the Kid remarked.

It was an ugly crowd, bent on dealing to the boy the fate he was certain to meet sooner or later.

"Not if I can help it, Billy. You are under my care, and I intend to protect you."

"You give me a 'six-gun,' Pat, and stand aside a few moments, and I will clean out the whole crowd. You'll see them stampede the minute you give me a gun."

"You could help—if you played square."

"I'd have to, old man I'm in the tightest place I ever was in my life. They'll 'get' us both, if you try it alone. They may get me, anyway. But you are up against it, if you try to defend me along."

"I'll trust you once, Billy; but understand, no foolishness. I'll 'drop' you if you try it."

The crowd grew more menacing. The demand for the life of the Kid became more insistent.

"Listen!" shouted the tall sheriff during a slight lull. "The man is my prisoner. You told me to arrest him. I have. He must have a fair trial. I know he is guilty. But it is for a jury to pronounce him so. You can not take him while I have a breath of life left, or while Billy the Kid has, either!"

Saying which he passed a revolver to the boy who had struck terror into the Pecos Valley.

"You must get two of us now."

Back to back the sheriff of Lincoln county and the most noted murderer in the southwest stood.

"Now, Billy," cautioned Garret, "don't shoot unless I tell you to. Remember that without me your life is not worth two bits today."

It was impossible to tell what was working in the mind concealed behind the childish face of the Kid. It was equally as impossible to read the thoughts of the determined sheriff who waited with apparent unconcern. The crowd knew and feared the Kid With only Garrett to fight, the members might have risked it. With a revolver in the Kid's hand, they hesitated.

Garrett was quick to see the advantage he had gained.

"Now you will all move quietly away," he announced decisively.

Sullenly the crowd obeyed.

Held at bay, Garrett placed the Kid aboard the train which arrived a few moments later.

The Keeper and the "Makings."

The Kid was tried in another county. He had no friends and no defense. There were plenty of witnesses against him now that he was a prisoner. He was defended by an attorney who made a brave fight. But he was sentenced to be hanged at Lincoln in July, 1881. He was brought back and confined in a jail built after the manner of Mexican houses, of adobe brick, with thick walls around a court or patio.

The day before he was to be hanged, half a dozen horses stood in the street, lines thrown over their heads—all that is necessary to make a cow pony remain in one place.

The Kid called from the gallery to the warden: "Hi, there, Bell! I'm going to swing tomorrow. Give me the 'makings,' will you?"

"Seguro, Miguel," shouted the warden, laughing. (Translated into English, the answer meant "Sure, Mike.")

The Kid stepped to the stairs. His hands were manacled in such manner that he had little use of them. The warden reached in his vest pocket for the cigarette paper, which he placed in his left hand, and with his right felt in his hip pocket for a sack of tobacco.

Like a flash the Kid raised his manacled hands and struck Bell square in the temple. The warden staggered As he did so the Kid jerked Bell's revolver from its holster, and dealt the jailer a blow on the head that crushed his skull.

"Unfasten the jewelry, and we'll both get away!"

He shouted these words to another prisoner standing inside a cell. The Kid had been allowed the freedom of the galleries. He passed the keys taken from the prostrate warden to the man in the cell, who unlocked his handcuffs Then, leveling the warden's revolver at the prisoner, he hissed:

"Give me back the keys!"

It was the work of but a moment to reach the barred gate that led into the street where the horses stood. A glance, and he took it all in. From where he stood he could see the form of the warden. Leveling his revolver, he fired a shot that ended his life, and then shot the man who blocked the door.

Once outside, he started a fusillade of bullets up and down the street to keep everybody in the houses. In another instant he was on the best horse and had stampeded the others so that pursuit would be delayed. In a few moments he was out of sight

Garrett was about twenty miles away at the time after some rustlers. Word was sent to him and he returned post haste, heard the story from excited lips, and stopped only long enough to saddle a fresh horse. Accompanied by a few friends he took the Kid's trail.

At the end of forty-eight hours of flight, when tired out, Billy the Kid stopped at the house of a man named Maxwell, near Sumner. Retiring, he figured, doubtless, that Garrett would have to pause for rest also.

It was early the second morning, probably about 3 a. m., when the silent sheriff saw in front of him the cabin in which the Kid slept. He and his men dismounted and approached the house. Garrett reached the porch with his deputies and quietly stepped into Maxwell's room.

There are several accounts of what took place. One is to the effect that Garrett left his deputies stationed outside beyond the house. He was whispering to Maxwell, when the Kid, who was a light sleeper, awoke, and tiptoeing across the porch, entered, revolver in hand, and asked:

"Who was that who just came? Where is he?"

From his position Garrett could see him distinctly, and had the Kid been looking, he might have distinguished the form of the sheriff, standing by the bedside of Maxwell. The Kid had his revolver in hand, prepared to use it. Garrett knew that, and fired the single shot that killed the Kid

See the clipping

Alive after forty-five years?

By 1926 there are stories that the Kid was never killed and has lived quietly in the Southwest ever since. An Arizona paper’s whole verdict is that they ‘are interesting and make good hot weather reading.’

Douglas Daily Dispatch · Douglas, Ariz.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 55 days earlier.

Douglas Daily Dispatch · 1 July 1926 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

Billy the Kid Myths

All these stories of Billy the Kid being alive and living quietly in the southwest for forty-five years after his reported demise, are interesting and make good hot weather reading.

See moreSee less

But like other summer fiction they must be read with an eye attuned to fiction.

We, like the rest of the United States, are apt to regard Billy the Kid and his Nemesis, Pat Garrett, as almost legandary characters, and perhaps may give an open ear to legendary tales about them.

But we must remember that Billy the Kid was a very real character, known to many men still living in this part of the country, while Pat Garrett, the redoubtable peace officer who risked his life in the day's work to end the outlaw's lurid career, lived here honored and respected, a friend of most El Paso pioneers for a quarter-century after the Kid's end.

Sheriff Garrett's reputation for honesty, bravery and fair dealing, is too well established to suffer from the mythical tales about the outlaw. To the men who knew the details of the Kid's crime and his death and burial, there never has been an instant of doubt.

In the first place, all of the official records of the Kid's death and burial are in order; there were plenty of men in those days, some of them dead now, who knew of the demise of the Kid in all its details.

In the second place, Pat Garrett's personal record is such that any suggestion of a plot to permit Billy the Kid to escape in which he could have been engaged is unthinkable. Garrett's fidelity to duty never was questioned in his lifetime.

The story of the Kid's escape is like the stories of a good many other celebrated criminals who now and then are resurrected after most of the eye witnessed are dead.

Fortunately there are enough men left who knew Garrett intimately to set at rest any such rumors.

As fiction it is interesting. But only as fiction.—The El Paso Times.

See the clipping

MGM casts the Kid

MGM gives the part to John Mack Brown, a former Alabama football star, for King Vidor’s film of Walter Noble Burns’s ‘The Saga of Billy the Kid,’ to be shot on location in New Mexico. Forty-nine years after Fort Sumner, the papers’ outlaw has become a picture.

The Indianapolis Times · Indianapolis, Ind.

The Indianapolis Times · 26 April 1930 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Here Is All A[bout]

John Mack Brown, former University of Alabama football star who has appeared in "Our Dancing Daughters," "Coquette," "The Fair Co-Ed" and many other films, has been assigned one of the most important Metro-Goldyn-Mayer roles of the year—that of Billy the Kid in King Vidor's forthcoming picturization of this famous bandit's career.

See moreSee less

No selection was made for this part until Vidor had canvassed the entire field of available talent to be certain of obtaining the best player.

Vidor's new picture is adapted from "The Saga of Billy the Kid," by Walter Noble Burns, with continuity by Wanda Tuchock, who prepared "Hallelujah," and dialogue by Laurence Stallings.

Production will start within the next two weeks, and most of the scenes will be made on location in New Mexico, the actual site of the noted young bravado's exploits.

Brown recently completed the chief masculine role in Joan Crawford's new starring picture, "Montana Moon."

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: The Kid Who Wouldn’t Stay Dead