As the Papers Told It

Billy the Kid · The full archive

May 1881

17 articles

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

Reports relayed via Socorro officials state that Billy the Kid escaped from the Lincoln County jail, killing deputy sheriffs J.W. Bell and Bob Olinger. The news originated from Sheriff Pat Garrett via courier and was considered reliable though unofficial, with a follow-up dispatch confirming the account.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 1 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

CONFIRMED. Special to the Gazette. San Marcial, April 30.—The New Mexican has information that "Billy, the Kid," escaped from the jail at Lincoln, night before last, killing the deputy sheriff, J. W. Bell, and Robert Olinger, another of his guards. The news came from Sheriff Garrett, by courier, to the sheriff of Socorro county, and is no doubt true. There are no further particulars.

See the clipping

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

The article describes Billy the Kid's escape from the Lincoln County jail, in which he killed both of his guards and fled armed on horseback. It falsely claims he then murdered William Mathews and another person, and threatens to kill Governor Wallace and Sheriff Garrett.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Chicago Daily Tribune · 5 May 1881 · page 1

A host remarkable and daring jail escape is reported from Lincoln County, Now Mexico. Lilly Bonnoy, alius “ Hilly the Kid,” one of the most desperate and determined scoun drels known In the criminal annals of America, was confined In* the Lincoln County Jail. Las't Saturday, while one of the two guards of the Jail worn absent, he attacked and killed the other, and the second being called to the spot by the report of a pistol shot, he killed him also. His hands were shackled all the time. After ho had finished the second guard, ho managed to strike off his shackles with a hatchet; made a mitn in the jail yard saddle a horse for him, and arming himself with a rifle and four re volvers* rodo away.

See moreSee less

Afterwards ho mur dered William Mathews, who onco shot him In tho thigh, and who gave evidence against him In a recent trial. lie also murdered an other party with fthom ho fell In. He threat ens to murder Gov. Wallace, Sheriff Garrett, and a number of other persons, and says that

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

A dispatch from Santa Fe reports that after his escape, Billy the Kid murdered William Matthews and another man while riding with them. Matthews was said to have been a witness at the Kid's trial during the Lincoln County War.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 5 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

COMMITTING MURDER WHILE ESCAPING.

Santa Fe, N. M., May 4.—Intelligence has been received here that "Billy, the Kid," after his escape, murdered William Matthews and another man with whom he was riding. Matthews was a witness at the "Kid's" trial during the Lincoln County War.

See the clipping

In the story →

Savannah Morning News · Savannah

The article reports that the outlaw "Billy, the Kid," under sentence of death at Lincoln, shot and killed Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and United States Marshal Robert Olinger and escaped, prompting Governor Wallace to plan a large reward for his recapture.

Savannah Morning News · 5 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

"BILLY, THE KID."

The Noted New Mexican Desperado Kills His Guards and Escapes.

See moreSee less

Santa Fe, New Mexico, May 4.—A telegram from Socorro, sent by special messenger from Lincoln, informed Governor Wallace that the notorious outlaw, "Billy, the Kid," in jail at Lincoln, the county seat of Lincoln county, under sentence of death, managed to kill his guards, Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and United States Marshal Robert Olinger, by shooting them, and effecting his escape. "Billy, the Kid" is quite a young man, but a most noted desperado. He was very prominent in the Lincoln county troubles three years ago, in the murder of Sheriff Brady and two Deputy Sheriffs, in the murder of Tunetall and Roberts, and others. He was captured last fall, after a desperate fight, by Deputy Sheriff Garrett, who received a large reward for his capture. He was tried at the District Court at Lamesilla and convicted of triple murder, and sentenced by Judge Bristol to be hanged at Lincoln on the 13th of May. He applied to Governor Wallace for a pardon, but was refused. This noted man is now again at large, and it is feared his capture can only be effected by much bloodshed. Governor Wallace will offer a large reward for his apprehension.

See the clipping

Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis.

This article reports that outlaw Billy the Kid, sentenced to death for three murders, escaped from jail in Lincoln by shooting dead Sheriff Bell and Marshall Olinger, with his execution had been set for May 13 and Governor Wallace vowing to retake him dead or alive.

Wood County Reporter · 5 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Billy, the Kid. a noted outlaw of New Mexico, who had been sentenced to death for three murders, escaped from jail at Lincoln, by shooting dead Sheriff Bell and Marshall Olinger. The day set for his execution was May 13. Governor Wallace is determined to retake him, dead or alive.

See the clipping

Eureka Daily Sentinel · Eureka, Nev.

A dispatch from Santa Fe claims that after escaping jail by killing two officers, Billy the Kid went on to murder Wm. Matthews and another man while riding with them. Matthews was identified as a witness at the Kid's trial who had shot him during the Lincoln County War.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.

Wrong

Eureka Daily Sentinel · 6 May 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

"Billy, the Kid," Kills Two Men. SANTA FE (N. M.), May 5.--Advices have been received here that "Billy, the Kid," after his escape from jail, where he was under sentence of death for one of his numerous murders, and who made his escape by killing two officers, murdered Wm. Matthews and another man with whom he was riding. Matthews was a witness at the Kid's trial, and during the Lincoln county war shot him in the thigh.

See the clipping

American Citizen · Canton, Miss.

The item reports that Billy the Kid, under death sentence in the Lincoln, New Mexico jail, escaped a few days earlier. In doing so he killed Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and Deputy U.S. Marshal Bob Olinger.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Chicago Daily Tribune, 5 May 1881, New-York Tribune, 5 May 1881.

American Citizen · 7 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

the lady back to England. "Billy the Kid," in jail at Lincoln, N. M., under death sentence, escaped a few days ago, killing Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and Deputy United States Marshal Bob Slinger.

See the clipping

The Pioche Weekly Record · Pioche, Nev.

A special messenger informed Governor Wallace that Billy the Kid killed Deputy Sheriff J.W. Bell and a lawman named Robert Algier while escaping the Lincoln jail. The report notes he had been sentenced to hang May 31st and that a reward would be offered for his recapture.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Pioche Weekly Record · 7 May 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

per cent of the cases prove fatal. Santa Fe, May 2. A special messenger from Lincoln informs Governor Wallace that the notorious outlaw, "Billy the Kid," under sentence of death in the Lincoln jail, killed Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and United States Marshal Robert Algier, by shooting them, and effected his escape. He was involved in three murders. A large reward was paid for his capture to Deputy Sheriff Garrett, and he was sentenced to be hanged May 31st. Governor Wallace will offer a large reward for his apprehension.

See the clipping

Southern Standard · McMinnville, Tenn.

The item reports that Billy the Kid, under death sentence in the Lincoln, N.M. jail, escaped a few days earlier. In doing so he killed Deputy Sheriff J.W. Bell and Deputy U.S. Marshal Bob Olinger.

Southern Standard · 7 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Walter Lloyd and Thos. Stanton, miners, were fatally injured at Baste Colliery, Pottsville, Pa., by an explosion of sulphur.

The Earl of Shrewsbury has eloped with Mrs. Miller Mundy, of Shepley, Derbyshire. The fugitive pair fled to Strasburg, where the lady's relatives overtook them, gave the Earl a sound thrashing, and brought the lady back to England.

See moreSee less

"Billy the Kid," in jail at Lincoln, N. M., under death sentence, escaped a few days ago, killing Deputy Sheriff J. W. Bell and Deputy United States Marshal Bob Slinger.

Two well-to-do merchants committed suicide the other day—John W. Minturn, of

See the clipping

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

The report recounts Billy the Kid's history as an outlaw leader running a cattle-rustling operation between Arizona and Mexico, his trial and conviction at Mesilla, and his sentencing to hang on May 13. It then details his dramatic escape from the Lincoln County courthouse, killing deputies Bell and Olinger with their own weapons.

Omaha Daily Bee · 10 May 1881 · page 3

The affair at the Greathouse ranche and the brutal killing of Jas.1 Carlyle ind his final arrest by Pat. Garrett , ; ho sheritfof Lincoln county , are yet

See the clipping

Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

The article recounts the fates of various Las Vegas-area desperadoes like Alkali, Dutchy, Sheeney Frank, and Monte Bob, noting deaths, disappearances, and arrests. It ends by noting that Billy the Kid is sentenced to be hanged at Mesilla.

Morning Journal and Courier · 11 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

he did not kill himself he had ought to. "Monte Bob" died at Alamosa about one year ago. "Billy the Kid" is sentenced to be hanged at Mesilla.

Store for Rent.

See moreSee less

THE large and desirable store No. 385 State street, now occupied by S. O. Northrop Apply to

See the clipping

New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn.

The report describes Billy the Kid's escape from the Lincoln County jail, detailing how he killed guards J. W. Bell and Robert Olinger before fleeing on horseback. It further claims he murdered two more men during his escape and had fled to Mexico.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

New Ulm Weekly Review · 11 May 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

[Ba]nk of Newark, N. J., have been indicted for conspiring and aiding the falsification of books.

At the annual meeting of the Civil Service Reform Association in New York George William Curtis was re-elected President.

See moreSee less

Three contractors for star-route service in Texas—Joseph Funk, Joseph Blackman, and William R. Cason—have been arrested in Philadelphia on charge of defrauding the Government.

West.

A convention of delegates from the Land Leagues of Illinois was held in Chicago, and a State organization formed to perpetuate the agitation in Ireland and England. The association pledged itself to raise this year $250,000 or more to aid the cause.

The particulars of the escape of Billy Bonney, alias "Billy the Kid," from the Lin[coln county (New Mexico) jail read like a]

See the clipping

National Republican (Washington City) · D.C.

A correspondent describes arriving in Santa Fe, New Mexico, detailing its geography, population, and unusual layout compared to American towns. The piece lists topics to be covered including meetings with friends, a tragedy involving 'Billy, the Kid,' Governor Lew Wallace, pioneer life, and a Mexican home, but the visible text only covers the city's physical description.

National Republican (Washington City) · 12 May 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

OUR SPECIAL FROM SANTA FE.

An Ancient and Interesting Place—Meeting Friends—"Billy, the Kid"—A Tragedy—Governor Lew Wallace—Pioneer Life—A Mexican Home—San Miguel.

See the clipping

The Marietta Journal · Marietta, Georgia

A Santa Fe telegram describes Billy the Kid's April 30 escape from the Lincoln County jail, detailing his killing of guards Bell and Olinger before fleeing armed on a stolen horse. It also claims he vowed to kill Governor Lew Wallace and had already shot two more enemies dead on the road.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Marietta Journal · 12 May 1881 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

the escape of William Bonney, alias ‘Billy the Kid,’ on April 30 last, from the jail of Lincoln County, have reached here. The Kid was in charge of Bob Alinger and J. W. Bell, deputy sheriffs, cool and brave men. It seems, however, that by docile behavior the prisoner put them off their guard. On the evening of the day in question. Alinger had gone to supper, leaving Bell to watch the prisoner. Bell was sitting on the floor talking, when the Kid, who was heavily shackled and handcuffed, approached him pleasantly and suddenly jumped at him with the swiftness of a wildcat, hitting him on the head and fracturing his skull.

See moreSee less

He then snatched Bell's pistol and shot him in the breast. Bell ran down the steps and fell at the foot a corpse. The Kid kicked open the door, procured a hatchet, and knocked off his shackles. He also broke open the door of the armory and took possession of several guns and pistols. Bob Alinger, hearing the shot, left his supper and ran toward the jail —

See the clipping

In the story →

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

This article states that Col. Rynerson received a letter confirming Billy Matthews, previously reported killed by "the Kid," is alive and has had no encounter with him since his escape.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Eureka Daily Sentinel, 6 May 1881, New Ulm Weekly Review, 11 May 1881.

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 12 May 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Billy "the Kid."

After all that has been said concerning the whereabouts of Billy "the Kid," who made his bold dash for liberty from Lincoln, it is only necessary to state that the reports are all wrong. Billy is known to have stolen a horse from Bell's ranche, above Ft. Sumner, on Saturday last. On Sunday he was seen by quite a number of people in the neighborhood of Sumner, and was talked with on that day by men who know him well. It is thought that Billy is on the lookout for Barney Mason, who was then in Sumper. "The Kid" never had any great love for Barney, and especially since he assisted in the capture of Billy and party at Stinking Springs. He is said to have sworn to kill Mason, and will undoubtedly make an effort to work out his vengeance. If he remains much longer in Lincoln county hovering about to pay off old scores, he is likely to be shot when he is not prepared to do his best shooting.

See moreSee less

The Mesilla News announces that Col. Rynerson has received a letter stating in effect that Billy Matthews, who was reported to have been killed by "the Kid," is still alive and has not had any encounter with Billy since he escaped.

See the clipping

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · Las Vegas, N.M.

A telegraph dispatch from Las Cruces states that the chase for Billy the Kid has been called off after no trace of him could be found. It speculates that he has fled New Mexico Territory entirely.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.

Wrong

Las Vegas Morning Gazette · 14 May 1881 · page 1

Billy "the Kid." Special to the Gazette. Los Cruces, May 13. The chase. for Billv "the Kid" has been abandoned and no trace of him can be found. It

See the clipping

In the story →

The Elk County Advocate · Ridgway, Pa.

This article recounts how Billy the Kid, guarded by two deputy sheriffs, killed both men during a violent escape from the Lincoln county jail and fled armed on a stolen horse, vowing to kill Governor Lew Wallace.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 5 days earlier.

The Elk County Advocate · 19 May 1881 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

A Desperado's Escape. A communicatin from Santa Fe, New Mexico, says: Full particulars of the escape of Wiliam Bonney, alias "Billy the Kid," fom the jail of Lincoln county have reached here. The Kid was in charge of Bob Alinger and J. W. Bell, deputy sheiffs, cool and brave men. It seems, however, that by docile behavior the prisoner put them off their guard. On the evening of the day in question Alinger had gone to supper, leaving Bell to watch the prisoner. Bell was sitting on the floor talking, when the Kid, who was heavily shackled and handcuffed, approached him pleasantly and suddenly jumped at him with the swiftness of a wildcat, hitting him on the head and fracturing his skull.

See moreSee less

He then snatched Bell's pistol and shot him in the breast. Bell ran down the steps and fell at the foot a corpse. The Kid kicked open the door, procured a hatchet and knocked off his shackles. He also broke open the door of the armory and took possession of several guns and pistols. Bob Alinger, hearing the shot, left his supper and ran toward the jail. When entering a small gate leading through the jail fence, the Kid, who was upstairs, shot him with a gun loaded with buckshot, killing him instantly. The town of Lincoln seemed terror-stricken, and nobody thought of opposing the Kid. He stole a horse and rode off, armed with four revolvers and a Winchester rifle. He has expressed a determination to kill Governor Lew Wallace, who failed to pardon him, and who, by a curious coincidence, signed the Kid's death warrant at Santa Fe on the same day that he escaped at Lincoln.

See the clipping