The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Rings Found in a Hunk of Flesh Identified as Those of Mrs. Gunness and All Say Wom- an Is Dead.
See moreSee less
LAMPHERE'S FATHER WILL ASSIST HIM.
Has Arrived at Laporte and Will Do Everything He Can For Son Who It Is Said, Will Be Convicted.
Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Identification of Mrs. Gunness' corpse is about finished, due to the finding of three rings. Close to the remains in the morgue, a chunk of badly charred flesh which was broken into pieces disclosed the fact that it was a portion of a human hand. The fingers tightly clutched contained rings, one of which appeared to be a wedding ring, and another a plain gold band, and the third a diamond ring. They are now in the possession of Coroner Mack who claims that persons familiar with them have identified them as those worn by Mrs. Gunness. It appears to be the belief of the majority of people in Laporte that the woman died in the fire which ruined her home.
Laporte, Ind., May 12.—A complete solution of the mysteries of the Gunness farm is expetced within 48 hours. A final step will be taken either today or tomorrow by the men who have brought the investigation of the horror to its culmination, and with it is promised an answer to all the questions which have arrayed themselves before the public during the past week.
The exact nature of the action is not disclosed, but from an authoritative source it has been learned that the climax of the great case is at hand.
The inquiry, which has been carried on almost entirely in secret, has been pronounced successful, and men who have directed it wear smiles of elation as the end appears in sight.
Each of them is discreet in his utterances, but there is not one to whom the secret has been disclosed who does not admit that the clouds of doubt are to be dispelled. There is satisfaction expressed in the attitude of every man upon whose shoulders rested the responsibility for placing the culpability behind at least 14 deaths.
Four of these are crossed from the list by absolute certainty that Ray Lamphere, the prisoner in the county jail, set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness on the morning of April 28 and thereby caused the death of the widow and the four children.
Indictments to be Sought.
For this he is liable, under the peculiar provisions of the Indiana state laws, to conviction for murder in the first degree as well as for arson. Indictments against him upon both these charges will be asked of the grand jury, which met in its first session yesterday, but will not reach his case before Wednesday.
As to the crucial movement which in itself will reveal the manner of death of the 10 murdered persons whose bodies were guarded by closely woven wire netting, the silence of the officers of the law in response to queries as to the arrest of one or more accomplices provides the only answer.
It is certain that they came to their death through the use of poison. The administration of a deadly amount of chrloral has been proved. The places at which the drug was purchased in the past eight years have been found. The inanimate corpses were dismembered either in a "chamber of horrors" on the second floor of the Gunness home or in the basement. Two knives, one a six-inch dagger, and the other a needlepointed double razor-edged surgeons knife, are in their possession.
That the big, stolid Norwegian woman enticed some of the men into her lair by the bait of matrimonial advertisements and there had an active hand in killing them and disposing of their bodies is established without question by those expected to answer the riddle.
Remaining Question.
The one remaining question, "Whether or not she had assistance in her crimes?" is to be met by the action that is expected almost hourly.
The arrival at this point has been preceded by a hunt for details, only rumors of which have been given to the public. Here and there bits of evidence have leaked out, but the great array of facts, it is said, was secured from statements made by Ray Lamphere, the former hired man who blackmailed the Gunness woman through the possession of knowledge concerning her dark secrets.
He has not been "sweated" at any time. No attempt at the "third degree" has been made, but it is from his utterance that the chain of testimony has been forged.
The chief agent in securing the confidence of the prisoner has been a minister, Rev. E. A. Schell, pastor of
(Continued on Page Seven.)
CORPSE FOUND IN RUINS IS THAT OF THE BORGIA
(Continued From Page One.)
the first Methodist church. Ever since the first day of the prisoner's incarceration the clergyman has been a visitor at his cell. For hours at a time he has been locked in with the man who might carry the secret with him to the gallows.
The man has been cautioned by his legal counsel to avoid giving any information concerning his knowledge of his actions upon the night of the disappearance of Andrew Helgelein, the last victim of the arch murderess, his observations upon that and later occasions and his actions upon the night of the fire which cost the lives of the woman and her children.
Damaging Admissions.
In spite of these warnings, the accused man has made admissions that, in addition to the earlier proof that he fired the building, have led to the conviction that he either was a witness or an active participant in the putting away of Andrew Helgelein.
According to Lamphere's statements shortly before June 27, 1907, Mrs. Gunness stopped him on the street and asked him if he could go to her farm and do some carpentering and other general work. He accepted her offer and on that date began his work repairing a floor in the house.
On the first night their relations passed to a stage of intimacy and it was not long before his room was changed from the lean-to, at the rear the house, to a chamber opposite to that of the widow, and she made to him a proposal of marriage.
She urged that this step be taken as soon as possible, but that it must be preceded by his having his life insured. She pointed out that under the state law none but a relative could be the beneficiary of an insurance policy and that, if issue should result from their close association, there would be no provision for the future in case of his death.
This aroused no suspicion in his mind but his delay in acting upon her suggestion caused Mrs. Gunness to order him to his former bed chamber in the rear of the house. It was about this time, somewhere near January 4, that he discovered that Helgelein had come to the house. One afternoon, when he had been ordred by Mrs. Gunness to build a fire in the sitting room stove, he was startled by the appearance of a stranger, who came down the stairs.
Ordered Him to the Barn.
This was Helgelein, he learned later, for at that time Mrs. Gunness returned to find the two men engaged in questioning each other as to his identity. In a rage she ordered Lamphere to go to the barn, "where he belonged."
The jealousy which sprang up in the heart of Lamphere led him to watch the woman and her new lover closely. He listened at windows and doors and on one of these instances heard Mrs. Gunness tell Helgelein that she was "sick of having Lamphere around."
"I am going to give him a dose of chloral," she said. "How much will I give him to kill him?"
"I can't tell," replied Helgelein. "He's got a dog. Why don't you try it on the dog?"
Thoroughly frightened, Lamphere went to a friend in Laporte and told him what he had heard. He was advised to "pack his kit and clear out," but returned to the farm. A few days later his dog disappeared and he revisited his confidant, whom he advised that, in case of his sudden death an autopsy should be held.
Louis Kelting, shoestore proprietor, declared that he had been selling shoes to Mrs. Gunness for years and that he knew she had a large foot and wore a No. 9 shoe. This conflicts with the statement of Prosecutor Smith that the woman's foot was small.
Discovery was made that there was a quilt between the body of Mrs. Gunness and those of the three children. Pieces of the burnt quilt, which were found upon the body of the woman, by a close inspection brought the announcement from the prosecuting attorney that he believes the woman was covered with it when the fire was burning.
Sheriff Smutzer has decided that he would have the barn moved and the ground under it dug up.
A conference of the officials working on the case was held today. The common council of Laporte county has been called to take action of the Gunness farm mystery. A vote of the common council is needed to expend public funds to carry on the investigation.
Pinkerton detectives working under Superintendent C. J. Smith report that they are securing valuable information. They believe that Mrs. Gunness is dead and that Lamphere can clear up the entire mystery.
Expects to Convict Lamphere.
"I expect to have Ray Lamphere tried and convicted of the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness," said Prosecutor Smith. "There is not the shadow of a doubt that Mrs. Gunness is dead. The gold ring on the finger of the corpse lying in the basement of the burned building is one that Mrs. Gunness constantly wore during her lifetime.
"That ring, now in the possession of the authorities, has been positively identified by several persons. The ring was found on the dead woman's finger.
"The sheriff and his men, assisted by the Pinkerton detectives, who have been getting evidence for the state, have gathered proof, in addition to that of the gold ring, which demonstrates conclusively that Mrs. Gunness is dead."
Hitherto unpublished evidence regarding the movements of Ray Lamphere on the day of the fire in the Gunness house have strengthened the case for the state. County Prosecutor Smith is responsible for the statement that Lamphere's comings and goings have been so closely followed that not half an hour is unaccounted for.
Neighbors who were first awakened at the time of the Gunness fire agree that it started about 4 o'clock in the morning. Lamphere's own statement has been that he left "Negro Liz's" house at 4:30 o'clock in the morning. This contention by Lamphere was the one stumbling block that has been in the prosecutor's way.
"More likely he left at 3 o'clock; it fits our corroborative evidence better," remarked the prosecutor.
This corroborative evidence is an important result of the work of the Pinkerton detectives and the local sheriff's officers. Five witnesses have been found who saw Lamphere that morning.
"In all Lamphere traveled on foot more than 16 miles the day of the fire," said the prosecutor. "I believe that he left the graveled road at the railroad crossing, went half a mile to Mrs. Gunness's house and set it on fire, hid in the woods to watch the blaze and was running away when Ira Hoover saw him."
Entirely Circumstantial.
In main this is the state's case against Lamphere; it is admitted that it is entirely circumstantial. But the prosecutor insists that he has corroborative witnesses of importance who are not named.
While not willing to discuss the important evidence in detail, County Prosecutor Smith says that he, in person, found the letters in a trunk in one of the outbuildings of the Gunness place.
More than a hundred letters were in the trunk, but only four or five were from Mrs. Gunness to Lamphere.
Prosecutor Smith says the statement of the defense that Mrs. Gunness could not write English is not true. The letters are in her handwriting, but the spelling is crude.
Refused Admission to Son.
W. W. Lamphere, father of Ray Lamphere and a justice of the peace at Springfield, Ind., arrived here to assist in the defense of his son. The father was refused permission for an interview with the son by Sheriff Smutzer. H. W. Worden, attorney for Ray Lamphere, declares he will bring about an interview with father and son if he is compelled to bring Ray to court.
The father is strong in protestations of the innocence of his son and asserts that he believes Ray incapable of the murders with which he stands charged.
Lamphere, senior, says that at one time Mrs. Gunness bought nearly 50 fence posts of him, and that while he was at the place he was strangely prejudiced against her. He questioned his son Ray about the latter's possible marriage with Mrs. Gunness and advising against it, and Ray told him that he never would marry the woman.
MURDER FARM OF THE WIDOW GUNNESS
RUINS OF THE BURNED HOME, PLAT OF THE GARDEN AND THE OUTBUILDINGS.