Four physicians' postmortem reports fail to establish cause of death for the woman and three children found in the Gunness ruins, leading toward an open verdict. Dr. Gray's report reveals previously suppressed evidence of a right arm and rings with puzzling inscriptions bearing initials 'J.S.' and 'P.S.' that don't match known identities.
Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 1
AUTOPSY PHYSICIAN MAKES HIS REPORT
the ho. - The coroner's statement OOtsnisM ol a recapitulation of her victims and the money she obtained from them This totaled, according to the state? ment U^.mt. Today was last Sunday over a^ain, thousands tramping the acres of the Gunness farm, d amontf the debris for grewesome evidences of crime, carrying away the bricks of the ?rrecked walls of the house, eatin^r j.ionic dinners and supper* under the idowi of trees near whieh other bodies will probably be found stand
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Dr. Gray's report on the jewelry, clothing, and remains of an adult female and infant found in the Gunness ruins concludes the cause of death could not be determined. Searchers also uncover nearly two dozen scissors and knives in the cellar ashes, fueling theories about the murder weapon and a struggle involving chloroform or poison.
Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 1
AUTOPSY PHYSICIAN MAKES HIS REPORT
?rrecked walls of the house, eatin^r j.ionic dinners and supper* under the idowi of trees near whieh other bodies will probably be found stand ing in i,rrou}?s of hundreds, listening to thr bawkingo! vendors who rehash? ed the story and looking at the - ton form* n the improvised morgue, lion trains brought thousands into the eit> from all parts of India Illinois, and Michigan The town was unable to pto. - Orient food for the thrones of people who made the tj teem with the life of its busiest weekday.
See moreSee less
The pasto-s of tin* etty churches ;nn made the tragedy and its les nsthe topic for pulpit discourses. Tomorrow before daylight thc body of Gie Budsbertf, of lola. Wis., will tv taken from the barn Jon Murder Hill to the morgue in this city and prepared for shipment to the home. i ? io Laporte in 1901 on a matrimonial mission. He was th< IO and within a few day* aft* si he disappeared. Bis > death.. third practical identification of th< > .n the morgue was made today with the rrival of J. G. Kenden, of Manfred. N. Dak., who. after walk _ ;. oni; the shrouds which covered each, came to a body, which he de? clared to l>e that of his half brother. John K. Moe, of Elbow Lake. Minn., who is bsJaeeed to have been murdered the ni^ht of December 3(5, 1907, the same ni^ht or the night following the tragic fate of Jennie Olsen. There was a Christmas party at the Gunness house, in which Jennie Olesen and John Moe were purticipants. Circumstances point to the conclusion that on the night marking the close of the day, of Yuletide festivities in the Gunness home, both Jennie Olesen and John Moe met their end in the death ehaml>er. Mrs. Gunness obtained *1,500 from Moe.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
The report details physical evidence from the Gunness farm, including bent scissors and knives believed used to dismember victims, and confirms chloral poisoning as the cause of death for the ten exhumed bodies. It also notes that farmhand Ray Lamphere is alleged to have set the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her three children.
Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
AUTOPSY PHYSICIAN MAKES HIS REPORT
admitted this fact. Tho, mystery surrounding four of the fourteen deaths known to have oc curred at the place is cleared by the allegation thnt Ray Lampherc, the farm hand prisoner, set lire to the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness on the
Investigators report the ten victims died from chloral poisoning administered in fatal doses, with dismemberment evidence and knives found in the farmhouse ruins. Separately, Gus Gunness, brother of Belle's second husband Peter, recounts the couple's marriage history, including the unexplained death of their baby and Peter's own fatal sausage-grinder accident.
Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
TELLS OF HER MARRIAGE Uy Associated Tress. MINNEAPOLIS, Minn.. .May , 12.— Gus Gunness. brother of Peter S. Gun no-;.-, tho second husband of Mrs. Bella Gunness, the Laportc murderess, lives in this city ai 210S Thirtieth avenue south. Today lie tulil of his brother's mar riage to the woman, said thai twice ho himself was at her Indiana farm and was once urgo.d by Mrs. Ounncsa to manage tho place. " "I first met Mrs. Gunness when wo lived Jn Janesville, Wis.," he . said. "Mrs. Gunness lived there for a time.
See moreSee less
Peter knew her before that in Chicago. He boarded with her there when ho worked in a butcher shop and when she came to Janesville she often called on our mother. Peter did not meet her through a matrimonial agency. "Peter was married after he came to Minneapolis. He lived at 3024 Hen nepln avenue and worked as an order man for a grocery house, tila wife died about six years ago at the llen nepln avenue house and be suddenly left. The next we heard of him be was in Laporte and had married Mrs. Gun ness. We thought nothing of it ex cept that he married pretty soon after the death of his wife. Neither mother nor myself knew anything at that time against his wife. My brother wrote frequently and said they had a nice place there. "When he went to Laporte, Peter took his daughter Swanhtlde and baby Philip with him. Three months after the marriage in Laporte tho baby died and the ailment was never diagnosed. They called a physician and death was attributed to natural causes, although there was no official investigation. "Five years ago last December Mrs. Gunness wrote me that Peter had been accidentally killed. A sausage grinding machine fell on his head. Bhe wrote. I went immediately to Laporte and ar rived there before the funeral, which took place from the house. There was a small wound on top of Peter's head, which Mrs. Gunness said was caused by the machine falling from a shelf back
A brother-in-law recounts how Peter Gunness married Belle in Laporte and died under suspicious circumstances when a sausage grinding machine allegedly fell on his head; an investigation at the time found no clear wrongdoing. A separate item reports Mrs. Gunness sent a letter to a Kansas laborer demanding $1000 before she would marry him.
A short editorial item remarks that Indiana novelists have been outdone by reality, calling the Gunness mystery farm story stranger than anything they could have imagined. It is a passing comment amid a column of unrelated local quips and items.
Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Investigators in La Porte report evidence pointing to three additional victims of Belle Gunness, amid a day of contradictory developments for both prosecution and defense. Post-mortem reports on the bodies found in the fire fail to establish cause of death, and the coroner's jury may return an open verdict while prosecutors continue building a case against Ray Lamphere.
New-York Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 4
THREE MORE VICTIMS
ON GUNNESS RELICS LA PORTE, Ind., May 30. —A mor bid crowd of curiosity seekers gath ered at the home of Mrs. Belle Gun ness yesterday, to buy articles that were put up at auction. There were about 5.000 persons who were anxious to become the possessors of some relic of the "house of death." Most articles brought between $5 and $lO, or twice as much as they were worth. Within easy reach of all theaters— Oles’ Case anil Restaurant —Stroh’s Bo hemian Beer on tap.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Doctors' reports to the coroner's jury revealed previously undisclosed details about the body believed to be Mrs. Gunness, including confusion over which arm was intact and rings with unexplained inscriptions. The prosecutor continues building a case against Ray Lamphere while identifying three more victims among the farm's remains.
New-York Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 4
THREE MORE VICTIMS
A.K. Helgeleln, last of the victims of Mrs. Ounnecs, was buried at La port. The fragments of Jawbone found in the ruins of the farmhouse were Identified by a dentist as from Mrs. Outness sknlL Ten thousand persons were carried by Sunday excursions to the Gunness farm near Laporte, Ind. Efforts to Identify one of the bodies as that of John Moe failed. . .-. ' That one of the seven unidentified bodies dug up In Mrs. Gunness' barn yard near Laporte, Ind., Is that of woman was , reveal by the autopsy, and St Is thought to be the body of woman who disappeared from the farm at the same time as Jennie Olsea.
See moreSee less
That Mrs. Gunness was dead was made certain by the finding of her false teeth In the ruins of her home
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Jewelry found in the ashes is believed to have belonged to Peter Gunness's first wife, and three more missing men—John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Berry—are named as likely victims of Mrs. Gunness. Separately, a Methodist minister confirms Ray Lamphere made a confidential statement to him about the fire and deaths, but declines to reveal its contents.
New-York Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 4
THREE MORE VICTIMS
Laporte, Ind. With early dawn Friday morning, Sheriff Smutzer and a detail of deputies renewed dig ging on the Gunness farm, and there will be no delay In the work until ev ery foot of suspected spots has been dug over to a depth sufficient to dis cover new graves, if there are more to be found in the arch fiend's burying ground. Coroner Mack filed his verdict in the case of the three Gunness children Lucy, Myrtle and Philip Friday morn ing. His finding is that they came to their death through felonious homi cide, and that, the perpetrator thereof Is unknown.
See moreSee less
Coroner Mack failed to return his verdict in the case of An drew Htgeleln or other victims. Ray Lamphere Friday began show ing the pallor of fear. He passed a restless night. He spent several hours In prayer. He fingered again and again the leaves of the time-marked Bible In which he has sought solace since his Jail confinement. He knows that the grand jury will indict him. that he will have to answer the charge of killing Mrs. Gunness and her three children, and that he will be indicted as an accessory in the murder of An drew Helgeleln, the South Dakota ranchman.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Three rings found on the corpse have been identified by witnesses as belonging to Mrs. Gunness, including a wedding band from Peter S. Gunness. Dr. J. L. Gray's official autopsy report states there is no longer doubt that the woman and her three children perished in the fire, though the body itself is not conclusively pronounced to be hers.
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 3
HARPER PERISHED IN HOUSE
The Lady From La Porte. My goodness, Mrs. Gunness, We hope it isn't true ’Bout you being scattered From Connecticut to Ogden, (J. It makes us feel so creepy
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Dr. Meyer's examination of an infant's body found in the ruined house could not determine the cause of death, while reports on other victims from additional doctors were expected soon. Bone fragments recovered from the fire are being guarded as evidence, and a letter has surfaced naming Henry Guerholt as a possible additional victim who went to work for Mrs. Gunness and then vanished.
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 3
6. Ray Lamohere. 7. Fish Trap Lake. 8. Ruins of Mrs. Gunness' house. 9. Crowd of Sijjht Seers on grounds. 10. Wagon used as Morgue. 11. Crowd in front of Morque. 12. Ruins of cellar where four bodies were found. 13. Helgelin's body. 1-1. Miner sluicing for gold teeth as means of identification. 15. Watching miner sluicing for gold. 16. Removing bodies from chicken yard. 17. Coroner Mack viewing the bodies. 18. Where 10 bodies were found. 19. General view of Gunness farm. 20. The finish. "Indiana State Prison."
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A farmer named George Bradley, who vanished last October after mentioning plans to marry a widow with a farm near La Porte, is believed by his employer to be one of Mrs. Gunness's victims. Separately, a Baltimore minister, Rev. B. A. Schell, discusses having urged Ray Lamphere—accused of burning Gunness's house and murder—to confess fully to prosecutors.
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 3
6. Ray Lamohere. 7. Fish Trap Lake. 8. Ruins of Mrs. Gunness' house. 9. Crowd of Sijjht Seers on grounds. 10. Wagon used as Morgue. 11. Crowd in front of Morque. 12. Ruins of cellar where four bodies were found. 13. Helgelin's body. 1-1. Miner sluicing for gold teeth as means of identification. 15. Watching miner sluicing for gold. 16. Removing bodies from chicken yard. 17. Coroner Mack viewing the bodies. 18. Where 10 bodies were found. 19. General view of Gunness farm. 20. The finish. "Indiana State Prison."
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
This is a humor column item joking that someone will soon claim to have met Mrs. Gunness and escaped alive, then go on stage. It mocks sensationalized survivor stories amid widespread public fascination with the Gunness case.
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 6
La Porte Indiana, coucluded from the finding of her gold filled false teeth that she was incinerated in the fire. WüKMyou come to think over bow many possessions the United States now has. scattered all over the world, there are many good reasons presented why this coun try should provide itself with a strong and sufficient navy to meet any emergency that may arise on abort notice. Now that the fiat has gone out
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A humor/miscellany column makes a passing joke that after the 'Gunness revelations,' leap-year marriage proposals may become more popular than answering matrimonial want ads. The reference treats the Gunness murders as already widely known shorthand for lonely-hearts deception.
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 6
Whii.b you are thinking up something interesting to occupy your mind, why not calculate which has the largest area, old England or the state of Texas. — The latest report has it, that Mrs. Gunness is masquerading in a man’s clothes. To all of which the masculine race will moat stren uously object. Every day for a week past has added to the list of lives lost and the destruction of property by wind and floods over a large area of North Texas.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Dr. J. L. Gray's official autopsy report describes an adult right arm and hand found with the body, bearing three rings including one engraved with Peter S. Gunness's initials. The report concludes there is no longer any doubt that the woman and her three children perished in the fire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 3
VERNON, Tex., June 1.—Julius Truel ion, the New York man who made a Sensational confession in connection with the Gunness murder, has broken ‘down and retracted his whols state
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Dr. J. L. Gray's official autopsy report describes rings and clothing fragments found with the burned female body, including an engraved ring reading 'P.G. to J.S.' that puzzled officials. The report states the exact cause of death could not be determined, and mentions bones being carefully preserved alongside letters about two more possible victims.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 3
“Confession” Fits Story. His statements, however, fit falrly well into the grewsome story of the Gunness farm murders. Sheriff Smutzer did not credit all of the young man’s Statements, but hopes to get from him sufficisnt light to clear up some of the ‘murders committed by Mrs. Gunness. Truelson sald that he read Mrs. Gun ness’ matrimonial ad. in a Milwaukee y paper, and that he met her early in 1904 in Chicago. He says he went with her to the La Porte farm and was tcld by her that though he was too young to marry her, she could give him employ ment on the farm.
See moreSee less
“Mrs, Gunness told me that she was practicing mid-wifery iliez=liv, and that she frequently had to dispose of the bodies of her victims. She told me she had a man named Ray Lamphere help ing her, but that one was not enough. I did not like the prospect and left the next day for Chicago.”
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Medical examiners Dr. Gray and Dr. Mever report they cannot determine cause of death for the adult female and infant remains found in the Gunness house ruins. Meanwhile, letters arrive identifying two more possible victims, Henry Guerholt and George Bradley, both lured by promises of marriage to a wealthy widow near Laporte.
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 3
“Confession” Fits Story. His statements, however, fit falrly well into the grewsome story of the Gunness farm murders. Sheriff Smutzer did not credit all of the young man’s Statements, but hopes to get from him sufficisnt light to clear up some of the ‘murders committed by Mrs. Gunness. Truelson sald that he read Mrs. Gun ness’ matrimonial ad. in a Milwaukee y paper, and that he met her early in 1904 in Chicago. He says he went with her to the La Porte farm and was tcld by her that though he was too young to marry her, she could give him employ ment on the farm.
See moreSee less
“Mrs, Gunness told me that she was practicing mid-wifery iliez=liv, and that she frequently had to dispose of the bodies of her victims. She told me she had a man named Ray Lamphere help ing her, but that one was not enough. I did not like the prospect and left the next day for Chicago.”
Investigators say a gold-crowned molar found in the cellar debris was identified by a dentist as work he performed for Belle Gunness, which authorities accepted as conclusive proof she died in the fire. A charred hand bearing three rings, including her wedding band, was also found clutched among the ashes.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
HARPY PERISHED IN BURNED HOUSE
Rings on Hand Identify the Body of the Murderess.
See moreSee less
GOLD TEETH ARE ALSO FOUND
Dentist Identifies Crown on Hollow Molar as Work Done by Him for Mrs. Belle Gunness—Mystery Yet in Meaning of Inscriptions in Circlets Worn by the Monster.
Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Mrs. Belle Gunness, the multi-murderess, died in the fire that destroyed her home on the morning of April 28.
. That fact was apparently settled beyond cavil to-day, when one of the workmen in the debris in the cellar brought to light a gold-crowned tooth, which a dentist identified as his workmanship, and said that he did it for Mrs. Gunness. The tooth is a hollow molar, and the crown is to some extent indented and partially incrusted with cinders. It bears every evidence of having come from the incinerated skull of Mrs. Gunness, and the find has been accepted by the authorities as conclusive of the death of the woman in the incendiary fire that destroyed her home.
Close to the torso on the slab in the morgue was a chunk of what was taken to be charcoal. It was so badly burned that it did not seem to resemble flesh. The cinder was broken open, and was found to be what was left of a human hand, the fleshless fingers tightly clutched. On the skeleton fingers were three rings that had withstood the heat of the flames. Two of them were plain gold bands, and a microscopic examination showed one to be the wedding ring given
Ray Lamphere, held in connection with the Gunness farm murders, denies making any confession to Rev. E. A. Schell or anyone else. Authorities continue sifting debris from the ruined cellar for evidence while the prosecutor delays rushing the case to trial to strengthen the state's position.
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE DENIES DOMINIE'S STORY
Laid Plans to Kill Wife. Truelson married the O'Reilly woman ir. August, 1904, and he says he deserted Ler two weeks later. He enlisted in the ‘navy in 1905, deserted a short time later, ‘and within a few months was sent to the Elmira Reformatory for passing worthless checks. He was parcied QOc tober 20, 1906. He communicated again with Mrs. Gunness, as he was ready then for any life of crime. He says she sent for him to come to La Porte and lie arrived there Christmas night, 1906. That night "Truelson says he and Lamphere huried the body of Jennie Olsen, an adopted daughter of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness, who, he was told, had died from an operation. He and Lamphere were not regularly employed by Mrs. Gunness at that time. The next night Truelson says he helped to bury the body of John Moe. Not until then, Truelson says, did he realize that Mrs. Gunness was running a regular murder farm. He started to leave, he says, but was paid $500 to stay over another night, On this third night, Truelson says, he and Lamphere huried the bodies of a man and woman, after which he left, fruelsgn returned to his wife, and in June, 197, he says he took ker to the Gunness farm, where Mrs. Gunness Killed her by administering chloral hedrate
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The coroner has completed investigations on the four burned bodies and other identified victims, declaring them closed matters, while identification of other remains remains unlikely due to decomposition. Prosecutor Smith is reconsidering rushing to trial as the defense mounts a stronger effort, with investigators now tracing bank transactions to link more missing men like John Moe and Henry Gerholt to the farm.
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 1
PROSECUTION'S NEW TURN
Andrew Helgelein, of South Dakota. Coming East again, Trueison says he married Belle Vreeland, and that a short time later he wrole to Mrs. Gunness, asking her if he might bring his wife, : She answered him to come alone, as she was being suspected. + He went back to the farm, me: Lam phere, and when told that there was no danger of detection, the two decided *to kill Mrs. Gunness and her three chil dren, burn the place, and skip out. He ' says they tossed a coin to see which
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Investigators traced victims like Moe, Budsberg, and Helgelein through bank transactions at Laporte financial institutions, suggesting more victims could be found through similar records. Meanwhile, Rev. Dr. Schell denied reports that Lamphere confessed to killing the Gunness children, clarifying his privileged communications only concerned the Helgelein case.
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 1
6. Ray Lamnhere. 7. Fish Trap Lake. 8. Ruins of Mrs. Gunness' house. 9. Crowd of Sight Seers on grounds. 10. Wagon used as Morgue. 11. Crowd in front of Morgue. 12. Ruins of cellar where four b3d.es were found. 13. Helgelin's body. 14. Miner sluicing for gold teeth as means of identification.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The report states that newly found relics in the ashes of the Gunness homestead prove she died in the fire, disproving earlier theories that she fled to Chicago or Europe. It notes this strengthens the case against farmhand Ray Lamphere, accused of arson, while lamenting that many victims remain unidentified.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 6
The Arch Murderess a Victim
6. Ray Lamnhere. 7. Fish Trap Lake. 8. Ruins of Mrs. Gunness' house. 9. Crowd of Sight Seers on grounds. 10. Wagon used as Morgue. 11. Crowd in front of Morgue. 12. Ruins of cellar where four b3d.es were found. 13. Helgelin's body. 14. Miner sluicing for gold teeth as means of identification.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A humor column of filler items references the 'Gunness woman' case, comparing her murder count favorably to Harry Orchard's, and jokes that reporters covering the Laporte, Indiana crime may soon outnumber the town's residents. This is a brief, tangential mention within a collection of unrelated witty newspaper quips.
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A local minister, Dr. Schell, describes how Lamphere confided in him and predicts Lamphere will testify truthfully despite his lawyers' advice. He also details the Gunness house's long history as a disreputable property dating back decades, and names local officials connected to the case.
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 10
I did not know personally of the supposed victims of Mrs. Gunness. Jennie Ol - sen, I am told, came to our Sunday J school once or twice, but I never met her. I had seen the man Holgelein?he was a big. strapping fellow?hut 1 did not know him personally. "Of course I know very well all the
The report describes community tensions in Laporte involving church and legal figures connected to the case, and the house's history as a disreputable property before Gunness bought it. It also details a new suspected victim, Henry Gurholt, who had planned to marry Gunness and vanished after she claimed he left with a horse trader.
Evening Star · 13 May 1908 · page 10
House Formerly Disreputable House. "Worden, the lawyer engaged by Lamphere. is a law partner of Mayor Darrow - of Laporte " The "house In which llrs. Gunness lived. Dr. Schell said, l ad borne a bad name
A La Porte pastor, Rev. E. A. Schell, who heard Lamphere's confession, insists the body found in the fire was not Belle Gunness and that she is still alive. He states he believes Lamphere innocent of all the farm murders except that of Andrew Helgelein.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 13 May 1908 · page 11
MRS GUNNESS ALIVE MINISTER ASSERTS Sure Lamphere Is Innocent of All But One Murder
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Rev. E. A. Schell, who heard Ray Lamphere's first confession, claims the body found in the fire was not Mrs. Gunness and that she is still alive. He states he is certain Lamphere was innocent of all murders except that of Andrew Helgelein.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 13 May 1908 · page 11
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE, MINISTER ASSERTS
ALL—STARTLING POINTS. VERNON, Tex., June I.—Swearing that with Ray Laiuple-re he acted as aide to Mrs. Belle Gunness. of I.a Porte. Ind., in her career of murder, and then declaring his wnolo story a lie, Julius Cl. Truelson, Jr., of New York, is puzzling the officers here. Hlj retraction came only as Sheriff Smutzer. of i.a Porte, was about to leave with him for Indiana. Truelson has been in jail here since March 29 charged with swindling by representing himself to be Jonathan G. Thaw, of Pittsburg, and passing forged checks and drafts.
See moreSee less
His father, J. G. Truelson, a piano manufactur er, of 340 West Forty-Sixth-st., New York, hus abandoned his son to his fate after futile efforts to redeem the young man. Truelson swore that he took his wife, Mae Frances O’Reilly, of Ro chester, N. Y., to the Gunness farm to have her put out of the way, help ed Lamphere bury her and assisted In disposing of six other bodies in the private cemetery of the lai Porte mur deress. Mae O'Reilly Is missing. Jewelry beating tho name of Mae F. O'Reilly was found in the Gunness ruins.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A minister who heard Lamphere's confession says he believes Lamphere was innocent of all the Gunness murders except that of Andrew Helgelein, out of jealousy. The clergyman refuses to reveal details of any statement, saying Lamphere should make his own statement to prosecutors.
The Washington Times · 13 May 1908 · page 11
MINISTER ASSERTS
If You IFant the Truth You Will Find It Here. SWEARS HE WAS MRS. GUNNESS’ AIDE J. G. TRUELSON, JR., OF NEW ) YORK, WHOSE STORY SEEMS PLAUSIBLE, LATER DENIES IT ALL—STARTLING POINTS. VERNON, Tex., June I.—Swearing that with Ray Laiuple-re he acted as aide to Mrs. Belle Gunness. of I.a Porte. Ind., in her career of murder, and then declaring his wnolo story a lie, Julius Cl. Truelson, Jr., of New York, is puzzling the officers here. Hlj retraction came only as Sheriff Smutzer. of i.a Porte, was about to leave with him for Indiana.
See moreSee less
Truelson has been in jail here since March 29 charged with swindling by representing himself to be Jonathan G. Thaw, of Pittsburg, and passing forged checks and drafts. His father, J. G. Truelson, a piano manufactur er, of 340 West Forty-Sixth-st., New York, hus abandoned his son to his fate after futile efforts to redeem the young man. Truelson swore that he took his wife, Mae Frances O’Reilly, of Ro chester, N. Y., to the Gunness farm to have her put out of the way, help ed Lamphere bury her and assisted In disposing of six other bodies in the private cemetery of the lai Porte mur deress. Mae O'Reilly Is missing. Jewelry beating tho name of Mae F. O'Reilly was found in the Gunness ruins. Met Woman in Chicago. In his confession, Truelson said that early in 1904 be read Mrs. Gun ness’s matrimonial advertisement in a Danish paper published In Milwau kee, and met her In the Sherman House, at Chicago. From there he ac companied her to Porte. Truelson declared Mrs. Gunness told him she was practicing as a mid wife illegally and that many of her patient* died and it was part of her contract to dispose of the bodies. She said she had one man, but it required two to do the work. Truelson described a horse and sur rey that fitted well the rig owned by the murderess. He then told of re turning to Chicago and of having wan dered during the next tw s o years. Including his meeting his first wife. Mae Frances O'Reilly, who, he says, was a dissolute woman, at Saratoga, on August 3, 1904, and marriage 6n the following day in Albany by Rev. Frank J. Knapp, curate of St. Peter's rhurch. He said he took his bride to j Rochester to the Powers hotel and deserted her in two weeks. Helped Bury Jennie Olsen. Truelson says he arrived in La Porte on Christmas night and the lame night met Lamphere and helped bury the body of a girl. He later learned from Lamphere that it was; Jennie Olsen. The confession runs on that Truel son remained three days, on the sec ond night helping bury the body of a man Lamphere said was John Moe. Truelßon declared that then he realiz ed Mrs. Gunness was not practicing midwifery, but murder, and that he confronted her and said he wanted to get out of it, but was Induced by the promise of SSO to remain another night. Truelson said he received SSOO from Mrs. Gunness and went back to Chi cago and to New York. His last trip to the Gunness farm was described in great detail. He was going to take his second wife. Belle Vreeland, there. He wrote to Mrs. Gunness from Quebec on March 10 that he would arrive with his wife in a week and told her to reply to him at the Place Vtger hotel, Mo treal. She did write there, but told him to come alone.
Clipping to come
The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.
Sheriff Smutzer's men built a sluicing apparatus to wash through the ashes of the burned Gunness home in search of evidence. Investigators speculated that dirks found in the cellar may have been used to kill the victims, though inconsistencies with Andrew Helgelien's body raised doubts about this theory.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Pensacola Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 1
SLUICE ASHES OF BURNED HOME OF MURDERESS
Jennie Olsen. The confession runs on that Truel son remained three days, on the sec ond night helping bury the body of a man Lamphere said was John Moe. Truelßon declared that then he realiz ed Mrs. Gunness was not practicing midwifery, but murder, and that he confronted her and said he wanted to get out of it, but was Induced by the promise of SSO to remain another night. Truelson said he received SSOO from Mrs. Gunness and went back to Chi cago and to New York. His last trip to the Gunness farm was described in great detail.
See moreSee less
He was going to take his second wife. Belle Vreeland, there. He wrote to Mrs. Gunness from Quebec on March 10 that he would arrive with his wife in a week and told her to reply to him at the Place Vtger hotel, Mo treal. She did write there, but told him to come alone.
Clipping to come
The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.
A report details Dr. Meyer's autopsy findings suggesting chloroform and poison, not just knife wounds, killed Andrew Helgelien after a struggle. It also recounts a neighbor's account of seeing a belt with knife sheaths on Belle Gunness, plus news of the defense gaining a new attorney and the grand jury investigation into Ray Lamphere.
The Pensacola Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 1
ALLEGED CONFESSION PROVES GROUNDLESS. La Porte, Ind., June 1. With the return today of Sheriff Smutzer from Vernon, Texas, -where he went to in vestigate the alleged confession of a New York man named Truelson who wrote Prosecutor Smith that he had been an accomplice of Mrs. Gunness in several murders, it became known that the sheriff did not bring Truel son with him for the reason It Is claimed that the confession does not hold good, having been made by the prisoner in order to escape a forgery charge in Texas.
See moreSee less
Truelson has been In jail at Vernon since March 9 charged with swindling by represent ing himself to be Jonathan G. Thaw, cousin of Harry K. Thaw, and passing forged checks. According to his alleged confession he took his wife, Mae Frances O'Reil ly, of Rochester, N. Y., to the Gun ness farm to have her put out of the way and helped Lamphere bury her and assfsted In disposing of six other bodies. Mae O'Reilly is missing and Truel son has retracted his alleged, confes sion. There was jewelry bearing the name of Mae F. O'Reilly in the Gun ness ruins, and the police of Roches ter reported that Mae F. O'Reilly dis appeared from that city about the time Truelson left there. Truelson declared in his confession that Mrs. Gunness told him she was practicing as a midwife, Illegally, and many of her patrons died and it was a ' part of her contract to dispose of the bodies. He answered her matri monial advertisement in 1904 and met her at the Sherman House in Chicago, She said, according to his story, that although h'e had no money and was too young to marry her she could put htm in the way of making, money by helping her dispose of the bodies of persons who died under her care, New York, June l.-Julius G. Truel son, whose alleged confession in con nectlon with the Gunness farm mys tery and subsequent retraction were made public today, Is believed 'by his family to be mentally unsound. His brother Harry said today that Ju lius had been irresponsible since he was struck by a trolley car a few years ago. " '
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Ray Lamphere denied making any confession to Rev. E. A. Schell or anyone else regarding the Gunness farm murders. Schell, while declining to detail their privileged conversation, denied reporting that Lamphere helped kill the Gunness children, saying he only implicated him in Helgelein's death.
Evening Times-Republican · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Julius TruoJson Is In the Texas Jail j himself as Jonathan O Thaw of Pitta charged with swindling by representing burg The despatches from Vernon say he tears the marks of long dissipation j and seems to be addicted to drugs In f bis confession to the Texas Sheriff he gays he married Mae Francis OReilly 1 f Rochester lured her to the Gunness farm at Laporte where he helped to
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Ray Lamphere denies confessing to Rev. Schell, while Schell clarifies he never said Lamphere helped kill the Gunness children, only that he had a role in Helgelein's death. La Porte banks agree to share Mrs. Gunness' financial records with prosecutors, a watch found in the ruins is confirmed as victim Ole Budsburg's, and more gold (dental fillings) is found in the ashes.
Evening Times-Republican · 13 May 1908 · page 1
SCHELL GAVE NO STATEMENT
Julius TruoJson Is In the Texas Jail j himself as Jonathan O Thaw of Pitta charged with swindling by representing burg The despatches from Vernon say he tears the marks of long dissipation j and seems to be addicted to drugs In f bis confession to the Texas Sheriff he gays he married Mae Francis OReilly 1 f Rochester lured her to the Gunness farm at Laporte where he helped to
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Investigators identify a watch found in the ruins as belonging to supposed victim Ole Budsberg, and inquire about missing man Emil Tell who carried $3,000. Sheriff Smutzer reports more gold globules found in the ashes believed to be from Mrs. Gunness's dental fillings, while a Cleveland citizen's letter provides the first evidence suggesting Gunness had accomplices in her crimes.
Evening Times-Republican · 13 May 1908 · page 1
1 further he Intended taking his second i wife Sarah Arabella Vreeland daugh ter of C P Vreeland of East Ninety f second street Canarsie U I with i whom ho eloped In March last to have her killed by Mrs Ounness but received t a lettter from the archmurderess tell log him that the Sheriff was making inquiries My brother Is crazy said Harry Truelson lie was struck on the head I by a 11 iiy car at Twentythird utreet and Broaiway live years ago and has boon ITUZJ since He was paroled from Elmira htformatory on the llrst of last January and he was a prisoner when Mn Gunness was active killing persons ell was sent to the reforma
One dispatch has Ray Lamphere denying he confessed or promised a confession to Rev. E. A. Schell, while another from Baltimore has Schell confirming Lamphere made some statement to him, though not a confession to arson. Schell says his lips are sealed but hints Lamphere seemed penitent and believes Mrs. Gunness is still alive.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 13 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
REPORT FALSE SAYS LAMPHERE DID NOT CONFESS TO REV. SCHELL, NOR HAS HE ANY SUCH INTENTION— DETAILS YET LACKING. LA PORTE, Ind., May 13.—Ray Lamphere, under arrest charged with complicity in the wholesale murders at the Gunness farm, denies vigorously that he made a confession or any promise of one to Rev. E. A. Schell.
SAYS LAMPHERE CONFESSED.
See moreSee less
Dr. Schell of La Porte Has a Statement From Him. BALTIMORE, May 13.—That Ray Lamphere, charged with the burning of the Gunness home and the death of its occupants, near La Porte was admitted by Mr. Schell. The latter, who is a pastor of the Methodist Episcopal church at La Porte and a delegate to the Methodist Episcopal general conference here, refused to divulge anything as to its nature.
"My lips are sealed," said Mr. Shell. "I got these things as though in the confessional. I found that the prosecuting officers were sweating Lamphere, and I appealed for fair play in his behalf. I said that he should be allowed to have a lawyer and I told them so.
"But I advised Lamphere to tell the prosecutor exactly what he told me, and I think he will do so. He seems to be a thoroughly penitent man."
Mr. Schell says that he has no doubt that Mrs. Gunness is alive. Pressed as to the details of the statement made to h[i]m by Lamphere he said that the statement did not include a confession that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, but related exclusively to matters that had transpired a month or more before.
Investigators travel to Warsaw, Indiana seeking a man believed to be an accomplice of Belle Gunness, a matrimonial advertiser who allegedly lured victims to her farm using aliases. Banks are turning over financial records to help trace Gunness's movements and identify additional victims.
The Lake County Times · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Chicago, 111, June 1. —A dispatch to the Record-Herald from LaPorte, Ind., says: Herman W. Worden, of counsel for Ray Lamphere, held on a charge of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children by setting fire to their home, in a statement yesterday indi cated that the defense would make a determined effort tc prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. “We have every reason to believe that she is alive. - ' said Mr. Worden. “I expect letters tomorrow which will Indicate the readiness of the man who received a letter from Mrs. Gun ness as late as May 4 to come to LaPorte to prove the fact.”
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Autopsy physicians examining the burned remains found three gold rings on the charred fingers of a woman's hand, which they took as definitive proof that the body was Belle Gunness. The article declares her death in the house fire now beyond reasonable doubt, closing the question of her fate.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Lake County Times · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Chicago, 111, June 1. —A dispatch to the Record-Herald from LaPorte, Ind., says: Herman W. Worden, of counsel for Ray Lamphere, held on a charge of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children by setting fire to their home, in a statement yesterday indi cated that the defense would make a determined effort tc prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. “We have every reason to believe that she is alive. - ' said Mr. Worden. “I expect letters tomorrow which will Indicate the readiness of the man who received a letter from Mrs. Gun ness as late as May 4 to come to LaPorte to prove the fact.”
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Investigators identified rings found in the fire ruins as belonging to Mrs. Gunness, confirmed by close friends the Christoffersons, resolving the mystery of the body's identity. Authorities report accelerating evidence and hint at an imminent breakthrough involving a possible accomplice, new witness, or confession from Ray Lamphere.
The Lake County Times · 13 May 1908 · page 3
Took Her Life. I.aporte, Ind., June 2.—With the re turn of Sheriff Smutzer from Vernon, Tex., where he went to Investigate the alleged confession of a man named Truelson. who wrote to Prosecutor Smith that he had been an accom plice of Mrs. Gunness in several of her murders, the details of the sequel to that confession do not hold good, having been made by the prisoner in order to escape, it is alleged, a for gery charge in Texas. The confession, if true, would solve many mysteries of the Gunness mur der farm and posibly hang both Truel son and Ray Lamphere, the suspect now under indictment.
See moreSee less
The Vernon prisoner is twenty-two years old and gives his name as Julius Truelson, Jr. He claims to be the son of a wealthy manufacturer. Truelson has been in jail at Ver non since March 29, charged with swindling by representing himself to be Jonathan O. Thaw, of iPttsburg, a cousin of Harry Thaw, and passing, it is alleged, forced checks. According to his alleged confession Truelson took his wife, Mae Francis O'Reilly, of Rochester, N. Y., to the Gunness farm to have her put out of the way and helped Lamphere bury her and assisted in disposing of six other bodies at the Gunness farm. Sheriff Smutzer left I.aporte May 22 for Vernon. Tex., but because nf floods in Texas was not able to reach Vernon until May 27. Truelson made a complete confession to him and then repudiated the confession, admit ting it was made for the purpose of getting away from Texas. Sheriff Smutzer left Vernon May 30 and reached Laporte Monday morning. 'I will continue investigation into the alleged confession of Truelson, even though he has since repudiated it," says the sheriff.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Investigators are rapidly accumulating evidence they believe will clarify the Gunness murder mystery, possibly leading to an arrest, new witness, or confession from Ray Lamphere. Rev. E. A. Schell telegraphs that Lamphere's prior statements were preparatory to a full confession he expects in June.
The Lake County Times · 13 May 1908 · page 3
Took Her Life. I.aporte, Ind., June 2.—With the re turn of Sheriff Smutzer from Vernon, Tex., where he went to Investigate the alleged confession of a man named Truelson. who wrote to Prosecutor Smith that he had been an accom plice of Mrs. Gunness in several of her murders, the details of the sequel to that confession do not hold good, having been made by the prisoner in order to escape, it is alleged, a for gery charge in Texas. The confession, if true, would solve many mysteries of the Gunness mur der farm and posibly hang both Truel son and Ray Lamphere, the suspect now under indictment.
See moreSee less
The Vernon prisoner is twenty-two years old and gives his name as Julius Truelson, Jr. He claims to be the son of a wealthy manufacturer. Truelson has been in jail at Ver non since March 29, charged with swindling by representing himself to be Jonathan O. Thaw, of iPttsburg, a cousin of Harry Thaw, and passing, it is alleged, forced checks. According to his alleged confession Truelson took his wife, Mae Francis O'Reilly, of Rochester, N. Y., to the Gunness farm to have her put out of the way and helped Lamphere bury her and assisted in disposing of six other bodies at the Gunness farm. Sheriff Smutzer left I.aporte May 22 for Vernon. Tex., but because nf floods in Texas was not able to reach Vernon until May 27. Truelson made a complete confession to him and then repudiated the confession, admit ting it was made for the purpose of getting away from Texas. Sheriff Smutzer left Vernon May 30 and reached Laporte Monday morning. 'I will continue investigation into the alleged confession of Truelson, even though he has since repudiated it," says the sheriff.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A filler humor column of miscellaneous quips and advice includes a brief joke referencing the 'crop' on the Gunness farm as unlike any ever raised before. It is otherwise unrelated light content about walking, politics, and fashion.
The Laporte county grand jury convened and was instructed to investigate all murder crimes in the county. This means the Gunness murder case will receive a thorough hearing.
A roundup of morning news items includes a brief note that Laporte police believe Roy Lamphere is close to making a full confession in the Gunness murders. It also states that two more victims have been identified.
The Lake County Times · 13 May 1908 · page 4
THE CREAM OF THE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A Baltimore minister who heard Ray Lamphere's partial confession claims he is certain Belle Gunness is still alive, though he won't explain why. Meanwhile in Laporte, investigators report that what was thought to be a gold tooth crown from the farm remains is actually just a piece of picture frame, and rumors swirl of a coming break in the case involving an accomplice or a damning witness.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE WILL CONFESS TO HIS PART OF CRIMES
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE, IS PLEA. Will Lamphere's Counsel Says He Show Letter She Wrote May 4. Laporte, Ind., June 1.—Herman W i, worden of cousel for Ray Lamphere, held on a charge of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children by setting fire to their home, in a state ment todav indicated that the defense S would make a determined effort to prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. "We have every reason to believe that she is alive," said Mr. Worden. "I expect letters tomorrow which will indicato the readiness of the man wh) received a letter from Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness as late as May 4 to come to Laporte to toy prove the fact. "We. have investigated the character of this man and find that it is without Jssi a flaw. He was in correspondence with ft Mrs. Gunness with a view of marrying her. He is now married to anothor woman. He has offered to give into i-'n our keeping the letters.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Laporte authorities report rapidly accumulating evidence, including a mysterious out-of-town clue and rumors that Ray Lamphere may confess, with a pastor telegraphing his belief in a coming confession. The defense is expected to claim Gunness used Lamphere to deliver a forged letter to mislead Helgelein while she carried out his murder.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE, IS PLEA. Will Lamphere's Counsel Says He Show Letter She Wrote May 4. Laporte, Ind., June 1.—Herman W i, worden of cousel for Ray Lamphere, held on a charge of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her three children by setting fire to their home, in a state ment todav indicated that the defense S would make a determined effort to prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. "We have every reason to believe that she is alive," said Mr. Worden. "I expect letters tomorrow which will indicato the readiness of the man wh) received a letter from Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness as late as May 4 to come to Laporte to toy prove the fact. "We. have investigated the character of this man and find that it is without Jssi a flaw. He was in correspondence with ft Mrs. Gunness with a view of marrying her. He is now married to anothor woman. He has offered to give into i-'n our keeping the letters.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The report describes mounting evidence against Lamphere and details about Andrew Moo, a probable victim of Mrs. Gunness, including his bank withdrawal before disappearing. It also reveals previously suppressed details from Dr. Gray's autopsy report on the body claimed to be Mrs. Gunness, including rings found on the corpse.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 May 1908 · page 8
LAMPHERE WILL CONFESS TO HIS PART OF CRIMES
Budsbcrg and Andrew K. Helgeiein. I On December 21. 1 Moo drew 1 oo from the First National Bank in Laporte, when he was staying at the Gunness farm. His friends have not heard from him since. Puzzling Evidence, Much unexplainable evidence, which has hitherto been suppressed has been made public. It is contained in the report of Dr; J. L. Gray, who perform ed the autopsy on the body which the authorities have steadfastly claimed is that of Mrs. Gunness. Dr. Gray in his report tells of three rings which were found on the corpse and also rehitherto declared missing, is still in existence.
See moreSee less
The ring's, which might be expected to reveal the identity of the wearer, only add to the mystery of the case. Two of them contain inscriptions, one
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Investigators are puzzled by inscribed rings found among remains, unable to identify who J.S. was. A neighbor recounts seeing a hidden knife belt on Mrs. Gunness and a disquieting visit by her daughter shortly before Jennie Olsen vanished.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 May 1908 · page 8
Exposed Knife Belt. A strong breeze through this open ing blew aside the folds of a loose house dress which Mrs. Gunness was wearing and revealed about her body a wide be!t containing pouches of var ious sizes and sheaths, which seemed to have been constructed for knives. As a sequel to this experience. Mrs. Lapham's daughter is said to have re lated an experience at the house when she had accepted nn invitation to sup per there. Miss Lapham said that she engaged the Gunness children in con versation regarding their home, but that in the midst of their talk Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness admonished the children, and that they thereupon became "strange ly silent and disquieted." This took place some two weeks before Jennie Olsen disappeared, the latter having been more or less of an intimate friend of Miss Lapham.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Medical examiners Dr. Gray and Dr. Meyer report they cannot determine the cause of death for an adult female victim and a male infant found in the ruins. Sheriff Smutzer's men sift the ashes for gold dental fillings and uncover bent scissors and a dirk believed to be the murder weapon.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 13 May 1908 · page 8
Impossible to Tell. Dr. Gray's report was concluded as follows: "From the examination of this adult female it is impossible to determine the exact cause of death." Accompanying the findings of Dr. Gray was a report by Dr. J. H. W. Meyer on the body of the male infant found in the ruined house. It describes the condition of the corpse as already revealed, the finding being that the cause of death could not be determin ed. The "raining" operations which have been promised by Sheriff Smutz er for several days have been started in earnest in the ruins of the Gunness home.
See moreSee less
Louis Schultze, who was em ployed by the sheriff to sluice the ash es in the cellar, completed his appar atus and began the tests to determine whether or not his arrangements were of the character demanded by the work at hand. Early in the mining operations Schultze caught the shimmer of gold. The article found resembled a charr ed tooth containing gold filling. It was turned over to Dr. I. T. Norton, a La port e dent'st, but, to the disappoint ment of the authorities, it. proved to be a piece of a gold picture frame. Ultimate success In the mining is doubted by some, as it is believed the gold in the teeth must have been fus ed. Additional evidence regarding the methods by which the persons whose corpses were found on the Gunness farm met death has been unearthed. Two dozen pairs of scissors, bent and curved in the fashion of surgical in struments, were found in the ashes in the cellar, and. in addition, three knives, two of sergical character and another an unmistakable dirk, were picked up.
A woman arrested in Pittsburgh on suspicion of being Belle Gunness was identified as Shirley Roff of McKeesport, Pa., and released. Meanwhile, Laporte police expect her alleged accomplice Lamphere to give a detailed confession, and two more victims have been identified.
Dziennik Chicagoski · 13 May 1908 · page 5
can policy were to be Mrs. Gunness was what might be termed a gay deceiver. Mrs. Gunness certainly had more admirers than fall to the lot of most women. Mrs. Bell Gunness will more than likely turn up, bat as much mayn't be said of her victims lower lirnbs." legs, either." no chance to set down."
Clipping to come
Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.
The report connects the sensational discoveries at widow Gunness's farm near La Porte to Chicago, claiming two local men—Herman Konitzer and Olaf Lindboe—were among her victims. Konitzer, an educated former estate manager from Poznań, had reportedly corresponded with a La Porte widow before disappearing, while Lindboe's brother claims to have positively identified his remains among those exhumed.
Dziennik Chicagoski · 13 May 1908 · page 5
ECHA CHICAGOSKIE SPRAWY "GUNNESS Z LA PORTE."
CI Laporte Ind May 28 Several hOgs wallowing in the pond at the age of a tot on the Gunness farm near here this morning brought ui a bone of a human arm The finding 4f the bone has convinced Sheriff Smutzer that other bodies have been buried beneath the mud at the bot tom of the pond The entire shore will be gone over with long rakes in an effort to bring any bodies the water may secrete to the surface OASXonxA
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Ray Lamphere, Mrs. Gunness's hired man and murder suspect, denied making any confession to a reverend or anyone else. Meanwhile, La Porte banks agreed to share records of Mrs. Gunness's financial transactions, a watch found in the ruins was identified as belonging to a suspected victim, and a mail carrier revealed she used three different aliases to conduct matrimonial correspondence.
Rock Island Argus · 13 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE DENIES
LA FORTE, lnd.. June 2.—Declaring his belief that Mrs Gunness. the mur deress. of Brookslde farm, was head and front of a band of slayers and that it is possible that Julius G. TruelBon. of New York, who has confessed in Vernon. Tex., was Indeed one of her accomplices. State’s Prosecutor Smith and SherifT Smutzer today began a searching Investigation into his career. They will trace his every step since he left the family home at 340 West Forty-seventh-st., New York, until his arrest at Vernon for impersonating and swindling under the name of Thaw, aud will delay prosecution of Rav Lamphere until they are saytis fled. i Propose to prove or disprove the of Truelson before I pro ceed with the trial of Lampbere,” said
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
This report profiles Belle Gunness, the Norwegian-born widow suspected of murdering victims whose bodies were found on her burned Laporte farm, noting her two husbands who died under suspicious circumstances. It details the theory that the headless female corpse found with her children's remains was a victim substituted to fake Gunness's own death, since her extensive gold dental work would have identified her.
Rock Island Argus · 13 May 1908 · page 6
' f ,n i, . 1 - ' . v.. s ' - i MRS. BELLE GUNNESS, OF UPORTE'S MURDER FARM.: Mrs. Belle Gunness, the widow suspected of the murder of the persons Trhone bodies were dug up from the premises of her burned home a mile from Laporte. Ind., was a Norwegian woman whose maiden name was raulson. She was married first to Max Sorensen, who died under suspicious circum stances. Her second husband. Philip Gunness, died under similar cireuni , stances. It was reported at first that the body , of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunuess was found with those of her three children in the ruins of her houses. The head of the charred remains of the woman found in the rulna was missing, which fact caused the authorities to suspect that "Mrs. Gunness herself had killed her children and set fire to the dwelling after placing in the bouse the decapi tated body of oue of her adult women victims In an effort to cause the belief that she had perished In the fire. Mrs. Gunness had had an enormous quan tity of gold work done on her teeth. The grewsome mystery of the missing head, if was said by those who held the theory of the flight of Mrs. Gunuess, . was explained by the woman's fear that if she -left Iter substitute's, head on the body It would be evident that she herself was not a victim of the fire. ' Supervisor of drawing Miss Abi PENMANSHIP TO gail Dean. . -; Director of manual training .Alba
Ray Lamphere, former farm hand for Belle Gunness, was arrested in LaPorte on suspicion of burning her farmhouse and murdering her and her children, allegedly out of jealousy after being spurned romantically. Nine bodies, including that of adopted daughter Jennie Olsen, were found buried on the Gunness property, and Lamphere was found hiding in a hollow tree.
Rock Island Argus · 13 May 1908 · page 6
RAY LAMPHERE, WIDOW GUNNESS' FARM HAND
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Joseph Maxson, who worked for Mrs. Gunness, showed investigators specific spots in the yard of the burned farmhouse where he said she had instructed him to dispose of items. The report also references the nine victims murdered by Mrs. Gunness.
Rock Island Argus · 13 May 1908 · page 6
- i - y S I I ma rami or sir, iieue (.unnecs near beeu iustructed by Mrs. Gunuess from as wan to lie1 thrown away. - The nine Itn'xx murdered by Mrs. Gunness were
Authorities investigating Belle Gunness's farm say they are certain the headless body found in the ruins is hers, based on rings found on the corpse's fingers. A Methodist pastor reports that Ray Lamphere, Gunness's former hired hand now jailed, seemed remorseful during a prison visit and may soon confess; meanwhile two more exhumed bodies are identified as suitors who answered her matrimonial ads.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Dziennik Narodowy · 13 May 1908 · page 1
ECHA ZBRODNI WDOWIEJ. PASTOR METODYSKI MA NADZIEJĘ, ŻE LAMPHERE PRZYZNA SIĘ WKRÓTCE DO ZBRODNI.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Authorities in Laporte, Indiana, continue sifting debris from the ruined Gunness farmhouse cellar, but few new discoveries are expected. The prosecutor is reconsidering a rushed trial for Ray Lamphere as the defense mounts a stronger effort, while Coroner Mack has released findings on most identified bodies except one.
The Topeka State Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Laporte, Ihd., May 13. Unless the sluicing of the powdered debris taken from the cellar of the ruined Gunness farm house results in startling dis coverles today, the production of further tangible evidence in the big tragedy is not likely. Yesterday's de velopments exhausted most of the sources from which have sprung the sensations of the case ana the authorities are now confronted with the task of endeavoring to find the corroborative details of the main DOints already deduced and of forg ing the missing links In. the chain of testimony with which they are bind ing the more or less scattered parts of the baffling cases into a coherent whftlp.'
See moreSee less
' Just how successful they will be In this work is not likely to.be revealed until Ray Lamphere is brought to trial. Prosecutor R. N. Smith has evidently modified his previous deter mination to rush the case into court, finding that the state's side may be atrengthened'in many particulars. He insists that 'the evidence already avail able is sufficient to prove the state's contentions-but-the recent activity of the defense and the strengthening of its forces show-that a desperate nght is to be made on behalf of Lamphere With botlrsides-of the Lamphere case working behind the scenes and with Sheriff Smutzer occupied with the slow going sluicing operations on the farm there Is little m sight to satisiy the -nublic curiosity in the affair. Coroner Mack has received ana made nublic the results of his in vestigations on all the known bodies except that supposea to nave Deen C1p. Fturisbere? or tola. wis. me iour burned bodies found in the ruins of the house are dead issues so far as further investigation by the coroner, is concerned. '
The report describes Coroner Mack's investigation into the unidentified bodies found on the Gunness farm, noting that most remains are too decomposed for identification. It details how bank records helped link victims John Moe and Henry Gerholt to the farm through cashed checks, similar to earlier cases of Budsberg and Helgelein.
The Topeka State Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 1
IdenUacatlon Difficult. None of the other bodies has been identified to any degree and it is scarcely likely that they will be. The decomposed fragmentary masses of flesh and bone are almost precluded from identlflcatidnr - What developments do come prob ably will be in the direction of estab lishing the identity of more of the mysterious men who were seen to en ter the farm house but never to leave it. Yesterday three such persons were connected up with the Gunness wo man, the evidence regarding John Moe of Albow Lake, Minn., and Henry Gerholt of Scandinavia, Wis., being al most conclusive.
See moreSee less
The fate of George Brady of Tuscola, 111., is less certain. Moe was traced to the farm by means of the banking actions which preceded his visit. The facts shown were startling, similar to those brought to light in the cases of Ole Budsburg and Andrew Helgelein. Each of the men cashed a check draft or note for a considerable amount at one of the local banks and at the desks of the cashiers all the trails ended. It is considered probable that an in spection of the books of the banks mveal further evidence of a similar nature and perhaps determine the fate of several individuals whose relatives have lost track of therri. The officials of the Laporte financial insti tutions, however, seem loam iu im part such information, if they have it, oi.i,r,Vi -nrniineenough to reveal full details when once the identity of a
A brother of Peter Gunness describes how Peter met and married Mrs. Gunness in Laporte after his first wife died, and recounts the suspicious circumstances of baby Philip's unexplained death and Peter's own death from a falling sausage machine. He notes no official investigation was conducted into either death despite only Mrs. Gunness being present.
The Topeka State Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 8
WORKED OUT. (Continued from Page One.) twice he himself was at her Indiana farm and was once urged by Mrs. Gunness to manage the place. "I first met Mrs. Gunness when we lived in Janesville, Wis.," he said. "Mrs. Gunness lived there for a time. Peter knew her before that In Chi cago. He boarded with her there when he worked In a butcher shop and when she came to Janesville she often called on our mother. Peter did not meet her through a matrimonial agency. Peter was married after he came to Minneapolis.
See moreSee less
He lived at 3024 Hennepin avenue and worked as an order man for a grocery house. His wife died about six years ago at the Hennepin avenue house and he suddenly left. The next we heard of him he was in Laporte and had mar ried Mrs. Gunness. We . thought nothing of it except that he married pretty soon after the death of his wife. Neither mother nor myself knew anything at that time against his wife. My brother wrote frequent ly and said that they had a nice place there, "When he went to Laporte Peter took his daughter Swanhilde and baby Philip wth him. Three months after the marriage In Laporte the baby died and the ailment was never diagnosed. Tftey called a physician and death was attributed to natural causes, although there was no official Investigation. "Five years ago last December Mrs. ijunnesa wrote inu uieli rcici had been accidentally killed. 'A sausage machine fell on his head,' she wrote. I went immediately to La porte and arrived there before the funeral, which took place from the house. There was a small wound on top of Peter's head, which Mrs. Gunness said was caused by the ma chine falling from a shelf back of the stove. Only he and Mrs. Gunness were in the house at the time. "Her explanation excited some sus picion and there was an investigation. The woman said Gunness was leaning over to tie his shoe when the shelf gave way and the machine fell on his head. She rushed into the room to find him dead. The coroner was summoned and after weighing the machine and measuring the distance of the fall he said the blow could easily have caused death. Neighbors talked some but nothing ever came of it. "I stayed there several days. Mrs. Gunness begged me continuously to stay with her and manage the farm. 'We can get along nicely together," she said, 'and we will make good money for I know you are a good farmer. "However, I refused. I didn't like her looks." In spite of all the crimes charged against the woman Gunness says phe was really fond of children and treated his niece Swanhilde and her own children well.
A relative describes the mysterious deaths of Peter Gunness's baby and later Peter himself, noting Mrs. Gunness's implausible sausage-machine explanation that raised but did not confirm suspicion. Dr. Schell separately denies claims about Lamphere's confession details and states his personal belief that Mrs. Gunness is still alive.
Dr. D. E. Sehell of Laporte denies saying Lamphere helped kill the Gunness children, insisting Lamphere's statements to him remain privileged unless disclosed to the prosecutor. Sehell shares his personal belief that Mrs. Gunness may be alive, along with his impressions of her character and Lamphere's troubled reputation.
The Topeka State Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 8
BELIEVES SHE IS ALIVE.
Baltimore, Md., May 13. Dr. D. E. Sehell of Laporte, Ind., in speaking to day about the Gunness farm tragedy, denied that he had .said that Ray Lamphere helped to kill 'the Gunness Children, but had no part in slaying any men except fielgeleln.. "I have made no statement regard ing this or any detail of my Interview with Lamphere, except to say that Lamphere's comumnieatlons to me were wholly privileged and unless he shall himself make the statements to Prosecuting Attorney Smith, it will be maintained as an Inviolable secret." Dr. Sehell added, that like many oth ers, he believed that Mrs. Gunness was alive, but that he had no knowledge of the fact. It was merely his personal opinion. Speaking further concerning the case, Dr. Sehell said:
Sheriff Smutzer reports that miner Louis Schultz, sluicing the ashes at the Gunness farm, has panned out several small globules of gold. The sheriff believes these are remnants of gold dental fillings from Mrs. Gunness's teeth.
The Topeka State Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 10
HE FINDS GOLD.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A brief item within a multi-topic news roundup reports that investigators in LaPorte, Indiana claim the full story of the Gunness murders will be revealed within 48 hours. It asserts that chloral was used to kill victims lured to her farmhouse, dubbed the 'castle of crime.'
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 2
At LaPorto, Ind., in tho Gun ness murder cases, it is claimed that within forty-eight hours the whole story of the Gunness murders will be told; that chlo ral was used to kill the men and
A new mutilated body, possibly a 12th victim, was unearthed near the ruins of Belle Gunness's burned house, found severed and wrapped in gunny sacking between two earlier excavation sites. Authorities continued digging nearby and suspected several more bodies remained to be found, including evidence pointing to a second possible burial location.
The Hartford Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
TWELVE MYSTERIOUS DEATHS
FIVE thousand people bid briskly for the personal effects of the Gunness murderess at LaPorte, Ind., which were put up at auction a few days ago.
Clipping to come
The Hartford Herald · Hartford, Ky.
Diggers at the Gunness farm uncover a severely mutilated, headless body wrapped in sacking, raising suspicion of a cleaver-wielding killer and possible ties to Chicago murderers. Rumors swirl that Mrs. Gunness may still be alive, having killed a substitute woman and her own children before fleeing to Norway.
The Hartford Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
TWELVE MYSTERIOUS DEATHS
FIVE thousand people bid briskly for the personal effects of the Gunness murderess at LaPorte, Ind., which were put up at auction a few days ago.
Clipping to come
The Hartford Herald · Hartford, Ky.
The report speculates that Belle Gunness is not dead, having substituted another woman's headless body and fled, possibly to Norway, in collusion with Chicago criminals. It also describes the ongoing discovery of bodies on her farm, trunks shipped from Chicago, and eccentric behavior noted by neighbors.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Hartford Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
TWELVE MYSTERIOUS DEATHS
More Gunness Bones Found. Laporte. Ind.—Several hogs’ wal lowing in the pond at the edge of a lot on the Gunness farm, near here, brought up the bone of a human arm. The finding of the bone has convinced Sheriff Smutzer that other bodies have been buried beneath the mud at the bottom of the pond. The entire shore will be gone over with long rakes.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Rev. E.A. Schell claims Ray Lamphere made a partial confession admitting he chloroformed and burned the Gunness children, though he denies the body found in the ruins is Belle Gunness herself. Separately, authorities report evidence that Gunness poisoned victims with chloral and hacked up their bodies before burying them in the yard.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE COLLAPSES WHEN HE HEARS THAT MINISTER TELLS OF CONFESSION
FIRST WIFE IS NO Γ FOUND Laporte, Ind., June 3.—Did or did no» Julius G. Truelson, Jr., of New York Oity assist In the murders committed In tbe Gunness bouse? Tills ls the
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Prosecutors describe evidence that Belle Gunness poisoned male visitors with chloral, then hid their hacked-up bodies in a secret chamber before burying them in the yard. The report also details witness testimony being prepared against Ray Lamphere, including an alarm clock discrepancy and a sighting of him fleeing the burning Gunness home.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Confessions Are Consistent. Skilled attorneys, after making a Mtreful comparison of three confes sions, each more voluminous than tbe •ther, combined In tbe opinion that tftch corroborates the other. There <fras not a mistake in date and not an Wror in the matter of detail. {The next sensational move in the CM·, if the plans of the authorities Mn be encompassed, will be the bring 10* of Truelson to Laporte. They believe that If he is thrust Into Uie same cell with Lamphere, who, he
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
A Norwegian laborer near Kansas City received a letter signed 'Mrs. B. S. Gunness' dated May 1, 1908, three days after the fire in which she was supposedly burned to death with her children. The letter matched earlier ones in soliciting the man to visit her farm with $1,000 in cash, prompting speculation among La Porte authorities about whether she had actually died.
The Detroit Times · 13 May 1908 · page 4
MRS. GUNNESS LETTER DATED SINCE FIRE : LA PORTE. Ind., May 12.—A letter [received by Christen Hansen, a Nor wegian laborer, living in a suburb of pCansaa City, signed “Mrs. B. S. GunMiess,” caused much speculation when Ktbe authorities here heard of it. today. s|t was dated May 1, 1908, three days rgfter the fire In which Mrs. Gunness fa supposed to have been burned to death with her children, and did not reach its address until last Saturday. The letter was similar in purport, to those of Mrs. Gunness already pub lished. It set forth her attractions «nd those of her farm and told him to bring SI,OOO lo currency. - o
Physicians' post-mortem reports fail to establish how Mrs. Gunness and her three children died, and the coroner's jury may return an open verdict. New findings include that the supposedly consumed right arm was largely intact, three inscribed rings were found on the hands, and the famous 'gold tooth' is actually gilded wood from a picture frame.
The Detroit Times · 13 May 1908 · page 6
GORY REPORT IN GUNNESS POST-MORTEM FAIL TO ESTABLISH MANNER IN WHICH WOMAN AND CHILDREN MET DEATH—"GOLD TOOTH" GILDED WOOD
to hav» visited ids slater in New' oYrk. Truelson In bis confession claimed he brought Mae O Reilly to Imports June 24. 19<r7. ih.it she was put out of the way hy Mrs. Guness and himself an dtbat her body was burned on the farm. Sheriff Smutzer hopes to-morr<»w to resume the work of searching for more bodies.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Investigators report new findings on the body believed to be Mrs. Gunness, including corrected arm identification and a 'gold tooth' revealed to be gilded wood. Watches and bank drafts help identify additional victims, including Ole Budsberg and John Moe, linked to Gunness's matrimonial scheme.
The Detroit Times · 13 May 1908 · page 6
GILDED WOOD
AND CREMATES HIM. ■TLK. June 3 — Accused of mur : 5 r husband and admitting that , ped his body to pieces with an x " and burned it. Mrs. Edward King rtsoned at Port Orchard, story of the alleged crime is sim ' • methods of Bella Gunness. ■ K'lto murderess. The woman und her husband dead in a ? Angered by his previous treat
Clipping to come
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.
Dr. H. H. Long, who performed the autopsy, states that the badly burned female body found in the Gunness farmhouse ruins does not match Belle Gunness's known physical proportions, being too light and short with manicured fingers. He argues Gunness was a much larger, heavier, and more masculine-looking woman than the corpse recovered from the fire.
New Ulm Review · 13 May 1908 · page 2
NO DEVELOPMENTS IN CASE
Remains at Ten. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—Dr. H. H. Long, one of the physicians who per formed the autopsy on the body of the •woman found in the ruins of the Gun ness home after the fire, has made a statement that the body is not that of Mrs. Gunness. His statement is as follows: "In my opinion the body of the wo man found in the house is not that of Mrs. Gunness because it is not cor rectly proportioned. It is that of a rather plump woman of the same gen eral contour of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness was literally a succes sion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned off was found beside the body and is well formed. The fingers show evidence of careful manicuring and that was something that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Basing my statements on the sta tistics and figures of eminent physi cians of this country and Great Brit ain I find .that the body at the morgue is almost five inches shorter than the body of Mrs Gunness would be under similar circumstances. The fire would, of course, cause the body to lose "weight, but the general physical out line of the woman would remain. Mrs. Gunness was a woman of unusual ap pearance. She was large, bony, power ful looking, with square jaws and felnok eyes. "She was a woman who would at tract attention anywhere from her lack of womanly characteristics. She wort a large fur coat during the win ter and her long strides, together with her remarkable countenance and her generally vicious appearance, gave her an aspect that was almost terrifyNo additional bodies have been un earthed on the Gunness farm, the number recovered standing at ten. Of these three have been identified.
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn. · and 2 other papers
An expert argues the burned body found is too short to be Belle Gunness, noting manicured fingernails inconsistent with her character, while coroners report a tenth body unearthed on the farm. The report also reveals Mads Sorenson's suspiciously timed death just before his insurance lapsed.
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · 13 May 1908
Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D. · 14 May 1908
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.
The article reproduces the matrimonial 'ad' Belle Gunness placed to attract wealthy suitors to her Laporte farm, and a sample letter she sent to one correspondent, Carl Peterson of Waupaca, Wis. The letter describes her property and background, illustrating the method by which she lured victims to their deaths.
New Ulm Review · 13 May 1908 · page 3
DEATH LURING AD.
FOUND IN THE GUNNESS GRAVEYARD. Laporte, Ind., May 28. —Hogs, wal lowing in the lowlanu, just below the private cemetery of Mrs. Belle Gunness, yesterday brought to the surface two human bones. One was from an arm and the other from a leg. The hogs dragged the bones around the hog yard for some time before their presence became known. Asa result, Sheriff Smutzer today will begin turning the surface of the hog run and dragging the pond which borders on it.
Clipping to come
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.
The passage reproduces a letter signed by Mrs. P. S. Gunness, describing her farm, children, and widowhood, and demanding that suitors deposit $1,000 cash before she will consider them as a partner. This letter was being circulated as evidence of the method she used to lure victims to her farm.
New Ulm Review · 13 May 1908 · page 3
DEATH LURING AD
ever, Turns Out to Be In nocent and Crazy. I,a Porte, Ind., June 2—Just when the officers, battled in every other direction, believed that they had a clue that at least partly solved the Ounness murders, Julius G. Truolson, who yesterday afternoon confessed to being an accomplice of Mrs. Ounness, this morning repudiated this confes sion. At first the oftlcers accepted Truolson's confession as the truth but now they see the flaws in It and are inclined to the belief that ho is crazy. In his confession the man gave har rowing details of the manner in which the murders were committed, and he oxhonoratcd Ray Lamphere from any complicity In the crlmo.
See moreSee less
Lamphero is still in jail awaiting trial on the in dictments brought by the grand jury but there is a general exprossod be lief that the ovidonco against him is Insufficient to obtain a conviction. Truelson is to bo examlnod by a lunacy commission. It is believed that his mind became doranged by reading accounts of the crimes to which ho confessed.
Clipping to come
New Ulm Review · New Ulm, Minn.
The item reports that Mrs. Gunness' 'populous private graveyard' at Laporte is being dug up, with eleven murdered persons found buried there. It notes that police had never suspected murder before the discovery.
New Ulm Review · 13 May 1908 · page 4
Appelton Press. Mrs. Gunness' populous private graveyard is being dug up at Laporte. Eleven murdered persons buried in it and never even a murder suspected by the police. The New Ulm police are mere pikers to this record.—Le Sueur
Mower County Transcript · Lansing, Minn. · and 1 other paper
A physician who performed the autopsy states that the body found in the burned Gunness home cannot be Belle Gunness's, citing its smaller size, lighter weight, and manicured hands inconsistent with her known appearance. He contrasts the corpse's proportions with detailed descriptions of Gunness's large, powerful build and striking features.
Mower County Transcript · 13 May 1908 · page 6
NO DEVELOPMENTS IN CASE
Remains at Ten. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—Dr. H. H. 1*rag, one of the physicians who per formed the autopsy on the body of the woman found in the ruins of the Gun Bess home after the fire, has made a statement that the body is not that •f Mrs. Gunness. His statement is as Hollows: "In my opinion the body of the wo #«i found in the house is not that of illrs. Gunness because it is not cor irectly proportioned. It is that of a Irather plump woman of the same gen eral contour of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 160 pounds. |Mrs. Gunness was literally a succes sion of billows of flesh and weighed Bully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned off was ound beside the body and is well lormed. The fingers show evidence |«f careful manicuring and that was something that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Basing my statements on the sta tistics and figures of eminent physi •laas of this country and Great Brit jaln 1 find that the body at the morgue Ma almost five inches shorter than the ^•Ajr of Mrs. Gunness would be under Similar circumstances. The fire would, [of course^ cause the body to lose weight, but the general physical out jttne of the woman would remain. Mrs. |Ou&ness waa a woman of unusual ap-
The report reproduces the personal advertisement Mrs. Gunness ran describing herself as a comely widow with a large LaPorte County farm seeking a well-off gentleman, requiring a personal visit rather than a reply by letter. This ad is identified as the device used to lure victims to her farm.
Mower County Transcript · 13 May 1908 · page 6
TO LURE HER VICTIMS. Copy of Matrimonial Ad Used by Mrs. Guinness. 4,'.:-Chicago May 7.-—'The, following is Mrs. Guinness' matrimonial ad with Which victims were lured to death: ffr*i* *5* v. PERSONAL—Comely widow, who owns large farm in one of ft the finest districts in Laporte county, Ind., desires to make the It acquaintance of a., gentleman squally well provided. with view ffr of joining fortunes. No replies It by letter considered unless the sender is willing to follow, an it swer with personal visit. 4? 4* 4» 4» 4» ^4 vu- ^4"., .flak'"' f+thtif THOMASIN COMMAND
The item offers a brief remark that Ray Lamphere is, as far as reported, the only man known to have lodged in Mrs. Gunness's house without paying for it with his life. It appears amid unrelated filler content about coins and economic optimism.
Okolona Messenger · 13 May 1908 · page 1
RUINS OF GUNNESS HOUSE, LAPORTE. to toe htoupe t»serye $s a bitod to effecting bar own escape from justice. RAY LAMPHERE, WIDOW GUNNESS' FARM HAND. ana of those found buried on the premises, along with eight others, caught Lamphere was hiding in a hollow tree. v. IÜ »a v?
Clipping to come
The Enterprise · Harlem, Mont.
The report describes the discovery of multiple bodies buried near Belle Gunness's farmhouse outside Laporte, Indiana, where she and her children died in a fire. Nine bodies have been found so far, including one identified as Ole B. Budsberg, lured by a matrimonial ad, with Ray Lamphere suspected as her accomplice.
The Enterprise · 13 May 1908 · page 2
Five bodies of persons supposed to have been murdered by Mrs. Belle Gun ness were dug up near the house, a mile northwest of Laporte, lad., where she and her three children recently perished in flames. It is believed she also caused the death of her two hus bands. Ray Lamphere is suspected of having been her accomplice. Four more bodies were dug up in the barnyard of Mrs. Guinness' farm, near Laporte, Ind., making nine found so far. The mystery of the "death house" is growing deeper, though there is evidence that the bodies were shipped to Mrs.
See moreSee less
Guin ness, prolbably from Chicago, in trunks and boxes which draymen tell of carting to her house. Another of the bodies dug up on the farm of Mrs. Guinness near La porte, Ind., was identified as that of Ole B. Budsberg of Iola, Wis., whom the woman lured there by a matri monial advertisement. New witnesses against Roy Lamphere were found. Utah Republicans declared R6ose velt their first choice and Taft their second choice. Taft instructions were given by the Republican conventions of Wyoming and Kentucky. Massachusetts Democrats instructed their delegates-at-large for Bryan. Irene Dolph, 17 years old, was sen tenced at Clinton, Ia., to eight years in prison for killing her husband. Aldermen Carty and Reynolds of Rockford, Ill., pleaded guilty of ac cepting bribes and were fined. Gov. John A. Johnson carried the Minnesota Democratic primaries against William J. Bryan.
The shed holding victims' remains on the Gunness farm was mysteriously disturbed, and Coroner Mack determined the three children found in the house ruins had been struck in the forehead with a hammer-like instrument before the fire, not merely injured by falling debris. Rain halted further digging, while Asle Helgelein provided new details about how Belle Gunness lured victims, including Ray Lamphere's errand to meet Andrew Helgelein's supposed cousin.
The Enterprise · 13 May 1908 · page 2
BODIES OF VICTIMS MOLESTED IN SHED REMAINS OF CHARNEL HOUSE SLAIN AT LAPORTE, IND., ARE DISTURBED
Further Exhumation. Laporte, Ind., May 8.-The shed on the Guinness farm containing the re mains of the victims has been broken into and the bodies seriously disturbed in a mysterious manner. Coroner Mack found that the three children whose bodies were lo cated in the ruins of the Guinness home were murdered and were struck in the forehead with a hammer or other instrument prior to their burn ing. The little boy had a large hole in the front of his skull and it was believed at first that the hole had been made by a falling brick. Fur ther investigation, however, shows that each of the other children has a bole in the forehead and that the
Investigators now believe holes in the children's skulls were caused by flames eating through cracks rather than a hammer or falling brick, revising initial theories. The report also details Mrs. Guinness's attempts to lure Andrew Helgelein's brother to the farm via letters, and notes Lamphere was sent to meet a cousin before Helgelein's disappearance.
The Enterprise · 13 May 1908 · page 2
RAY LAMPHERE
to induce him to visit this city. Offers to Hunt Brother. "Sell your brother's stock and come here, and we will hunt your brother together," was the gist of the epistles written in Norwegian, and as yet only partially translated. The letters are jealously guarded by Helgelein under orders of Ralph Smith, prosecuting at, torney. But enough was revealed to show that the woman had not hesitated to dare to attempt to gain a hold over the nearest relative of her latest vic tim. Rain interfered with further ex humations Thursday on the death en shrouded farm of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Guinness. Sher iff Smutzer announced that' the down pour, which began early Thursday morning, made it impossible to ex plore the lawn of the homestead, where, it is believed, more bodies have been concealed. Efforts to Implicate Lamphere. Ray Lamphere, accused of first de gree murder in connection with the
Dr. Harry B. Long examines the body thought to be Belle Gunness and declares it is not hers, citing manicured nails and a weight discrepancy of over 60 pounds. Police pursue leads including a woman arrested in Syracuse, later cleared, while suggesting Gunness may have had an accomplice to mislead victims' relatives.
The Western News · 13 May 1908 · page 2
MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE BODY SUPPOSED TO BE HERS IS THAT OF ANOTHER. POLICE LOOKING FOR HER
No More Bodies Found. At noon today no more bodies had been located. The sheriff believes no more will be found. The digging now begins under the ruins of the house. Loy Lamphere, held for a witness In regard to the Gunness killings, became hysterical today. He declares that the Gunness woman is haunting him. Woman Arrested.
George Anderson describes narrowly escaping Mrs. Gunness after answering her matrimonial ad two years earlier, and is traveling to LaPorte to testify. Meanwhile a mistaken arrest in Syracuse is cleared up, the body count holds at twelve, and officials debate whether the headless corpse is truly hers.
A neighbor tells the sheriff of several mysterious men who visited and then vanished from the Gunness home, and one body is identified as missing girl Jennie Olson. The report now suggests Belle Gunness burned her own house and children but escaped alive, rather than dying in the fire as first believed.
The Western News · 13 May 1908 · page 7
WOMAN KILLS MANY SIX BODIES FOUND AND DEVELOPMENTS COME FAST. BELIEVED TO BE ALIVE
from all over the middle west and west it would almost seem as if there was scarely a ham let but possesses s nno man who almost or quite fell into the clut ches of Mrs. Gunness, so strong is the desire for notoriety how ever unenviable.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
Christian Hansen, a Norwegian laborer in Kansas, received a letter from Belle Gunness dated March 1908 offering marriage if he could produce $1,000 cash. The letter, printed in part, describes her farm and children and warns against coming merely as hired help.
Omaha Daily Bee · 13 May 1908 · page 2
ONE OF LAST BUSINESS LETTERS
It is reported that a man who answered one of the advertisements of Mrs. Gunness, and who was sup posed to have mingled his bones with those of her other victims, in reality made his escape and migrat ed to Lincoln where he felt he could live down and perhaps forget his folly. We are glad to note that no Beatrice victims, dead or living, of the Indiana fiend are reported.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A Norwegian packing-house worker named Hansen reveals a letter he received from Mrs. Gunness demanding $1,000 in cash before she would marry him, and describes his narrow escape after the LaPorte exposure. Separately, friends of Herman Konitzer, missing since January 1904, now believe he was one of Gunness's victims.
Omaha Daily Bee · 13 May 1908 · page 2
board Air Line by Judge Pritchard. Mr. Martin got his commission on May 19, and in the meantime, was making his bond of $150,000 and his! disbursing bond of $10,000. There will be no changes in the ferae here. Laporte, Ind., June 2 Sheriff Smut zer and prosecutor Smith" think there may be something in the talk of Julius Truelson, held at "Vernon, Texas, on account of his confession that he had aided Belle Gunness in her murders, and had taken his wife, May O'Reilly, to the farm to be killed, and the New York record of this young man is te be dug up today.
See moreSee less
The father of Truel son admits that the boy always was wild and that he was already married when he made May O'Reilly his wife. Blit May's relatives in New York and Rochester say she is alive and well and living in the former city. Harvy Truelson, a brother of Julius, says Julius was in an Elmira reformatory at the time he now claims to have been helping the Gunness woman on her murder farm in Indiana.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
Friends of Herman Koultzer, who disappeared in 1907 shortly after arriving from Germany, believe he was one of Belle Gunness's victims. They note he received a marriage proposal letter from her and that his general description matches a tall, dark-haired skeleton found on the Gunness property.
Omaha Daily Bee · 13 May 1908 · page 2
KOULTZER BELIEVED TO BE DEAD
board Air Line by Judge Pritchard. Mr. Martin got his commission on May 19, and in the meantime, was making his bond of $150,000 and his! disbursing bond of $10,000. There will be no changes in the ferae here. Laporte, Ind., June 2 Sheriff Smut zer and prosecutor Smith" think there may be something in the talk of Julius Truelson, held at "Vernon, Texas, on account of his confession that he had aided Belle Gunness in her murders, and had taken his wife, May O'Reilly, to the farm to be killed, and the New York record of this young man is te be dug up today.
See moreSee less
The father of Truel son admits that the boy always was wild and that he was already married when he made May O'Reilly his wife. Blit May's relatives in New York and Rochester say she is alive and well and living in the former city. Harvy Truelson, a brother of Julius, says Julius was in an Elmira reformatory at the time he now claims to have been helping the Gunness woman on her murder farm in Indiana.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Gust Gunness, brother of Belle's late husband Peter, recounts visiting her farm and being urged to marry her, which he refused due to her unsettling eyes. Meanwhile in Laporte, investigators work to identify three additional victims as postmortem reports are released amid contradictory developments.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
LIKE HER EYES
La porte, Ind., June 4.—The confes sion of Julius Truelson, the New York youth under arrest lu Texas, that he was Implicated In the Gunness crimes was somewhat shattered by the receipt of a letter by Sheriff Smutzer written by David Hecken of Waukesha, Wis. Hecken says he has a letter written by Frank Rledlnger, who Is said to be living In or near Lincoln, Neb. Truel son said he assisted In burying Rle dlnger after Mrs. Gunness had mur dered him. Sheriff Smutzer telegraph ed the Lincoln authorities to locate Rledlnger.
See moreSee less
The state was able to throw some light on the Identity of the supposed college professor who was murdered Christmas night. Information from Youngstown, O., tells of the disap pearance In October, 1006, of Professor B. F. Plato, a single man, with con siderable money, who bad been corre sponding with an Indiana woman.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Authorities in La Porte collected evidence identifying three additional victims, including Ole O. Budsberg, confirmed via a watch serial number from an Iola bank. The prosecutor continued building a case to connect Ray Lamphere to the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her children, ahead of grand jury proceedings.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
RAY LAMPHERE. Farm hand who is held for alleged compile ity in tinLiiporte dud.) mur der horrors. and lunch-stand owners did a thriv ing business. At one time during (he day more than 500 rigs wore tied about the farm. The greatest interest centered in the siile of the horse driven by Mrs. Gunness before the Are, the pony and cart, driven by the Gunness children, and a shepherd watch dog. AH of these were secured by local people and all brought fancy prices, the dog alone selling for $107.
Clipping to come
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.
Evidence emerges to identify three more victims found at the Gunness farm, including mysterious rings possibly belonging to the first Mrs. Gunness. Post-mortem reports fail to establish cause of death, likely resulting in an open verdict, while prosecutors continue building a case against Ray Lamphere.
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 13 May 1908 · page 2
MORE PUZZLES SHOW UP
Unbalanced —Crime in General. l^aporte, Ind., June 1. —With the re turn today of Sheriff Smutzer from Vernon, Tex., where he went to in vestigate the alleged confession of Julius Truelson. jr., who wrote to Prosecutor Smith that he had been the accomplice of Mrs. Gunness in several murders, the confession be came known. Confession No Good.
Clipping to come
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.
Prosecutors continue gathering evidence to link Ray Lamphere to the deaths, while new findings reveal the body's right arm was more intact than previously thought, with three mysterious rings found on the hands. Separately, sluicing operations at the burned Gunness farm uncover bent scissors and knives, including a dirk suspected as a possible murder weapon.
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 13 May 1908 · page 2
MORE PUZZLES SHOW UP
Mentally Unbalanced. New York, June 1. —Julius G. Truel son. whose alleged confession in con nection with the Gunness farm mys tery and subsequent retraction were made public today, is believed by his family to be mentally unsound. His brother, Harry, said today that Julius had been irresponsible since he was struck by a trolley car a few years ago. Harry said the story Julius told of his connection with the Gunness farm murders could not possibly be true, as he was serving a sentence in the Elmira reformatory at the time cov ered by his confession. The Truelson family say they will do nothing more for Julius.
Clipping to come
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H.
Investigators sluice the cellar ashes and uncover bent scissors and knives, including a dirk suspected as the murder weapon, alongside details of a neighbor's account describing a suspicious knife belt worn by Mrs. Gunness. The grand jury proceedings against Ray Lamphere also advance, with new defense counsel joining the case.
New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 13 May 1908 · page 2
WEAPONS FOUND IN RUINS.
Mentally Unbalanced. New York, June 1. —Julius G. Truel son. whose alleged confession in con nection with the Gunness farm mys tery and subsequent retraction were made public today, is believed by his family to be mentally unsound. His brother, Harry, said today that Julius had been irresponsible since he was struck by a trolley car a few years ago. Harry said the story Julius told of his connection with the Gunness farm murders could not possibly be true, as he was serving a sentence in the Elmira reformatory at the time cov ered by his confession. The Truelson family say they will do nothing more for Julius.
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
A Baltimore clergyman, Rev. E. A. Schell of Laporte, reports that Roy Lamphere told him in jail that Belle Gunness is still alive, having chloroformed her children and burned the house to fake her own death. Schell also claims Lamphere called the farmhouse a long-standing "house of crime" used by wealthy Chicago men.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 13 May 1908 · page 14
Is Still Alive. PRISONER A STUPID BRUTE. HIS IMPRESSION Says Home for Twenty Years Was a “House of Crime.” [Special to the Evening Star.] BALTIMORE. May 13.—Positive belief that Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch elayer of I.aporte, Ind., is still alive was expressed today by the Rev. E. A. Schell, pastor of the chief Methodist Church In that town, to whom Roy Lamphere, the farm hand suspected of having slain the murderess, made a long statement in jail. The Rev. Schell Is here attending a conference of min isters. “The Gunness little ones were chloroformed by their mother and then the house was fired.
See moreSee less
1 do not know what woman’s body was placed in the farmhouse by Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere. I am certain that the head ' less torso is not that of Mrs. Gunness. The house In which Mrs. Gunness lived, Dr. Schell said, had borne a bad name for years; "a bouse of crime,” he described it; and twenty years ago “a. place of resort for the gilded you'll of Chicago—which is only lifty-nine miles away, and for some men of wealth and prominence who were not exactly youths. “Three years ago, when Mrs. Gun j ness came from Boston and bought the 11UU Ol I Jiuwpiv LIIUUQMl > ' " >•■■ would change, because at that time sho was looked upon as entirely respecta ble. The place was rather an im posing one for the neighborhood, the house being worth $7,000 or $8,000, and the farm containing seventy-five acres.’' Then the pastor told of Lamphere’s corning lo him. "He was firmly convinced that he would be killed. He was trying to norve himself fur the end. When I talked Willi him he broke down and poured out his dreadful story. 1 advised him at once to make bis statement to the pros ecuting attorney. "Lamphere scut for me. I do not know tlic man at nil. lie is a moral degenerate and inclined to ail excesses. He used to come into town every few weeks with n large amount of money, which Mrs. Ounness had given him, and would go on a protracted spree. Unless the sifting and sluicing of the powdered debris from I lie cellar of the ruined Ounriess farm house results In startling discoveries today the produc tion of further tangible evidence in the big tragedy is not likely.. Just how successful they will lie in this work is not likely to lie revealed until Ray Lamphere is brought to trial.
A pastor, Rev. E. A. Schell, states he is certain the headless torso found is not Mrs. Gunness's body, while describing Lamphere's anguished visit and alleged confession. Lamphere himself denies ever confessing anything to Schell or anyone else, amid ongoing sifting of farmhouse debris for evidence.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 13 May 1908 · page 14
Crime.” [Special to the Evening Star.] BALTIMORE. May 13.—Positive belief that Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch elayer of I.aporte, Ind., is still alive was expressed today by the Rev. E. A. Schell, pastor of the chief Methodist Church In that town, to whom Roy Lamphere, the farm hand suspected of having slain the murderess, made a long statement in jail. The Rev. Schell Is here attending a conference of min isters. “The Gunness little ones were chloroformed by their mother and then the house was fired. 1 do not know what woman’s body was placed in the farmhouse by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and Lamphere. I am certain that the head ' less torso is not that of Mrs. Gunness. The house In which Mrs. Gunness lived, Dr. Schell said, had borne a bad name for years; "a bouse of crime,” he described it; and twenty years ago “a. place of resort for the gilded you'll of Chicago—which is only lifty-nine miles away, and for some men of wealth and prominence who were not exactly youths. “Three years ago, when Mrs. Gun j ness came from Boston and bought the 11UU Ol I Jiuwpiv LIIUUQMl > ' " >•■■ would change, because at that time sho was looked upon as entirely respecta ble. The place was rather an im posing one for the neighborhood, the house being worth $7,000 or $8,000, and the farm containing seventy-five acres.’' Then the pastor told of Lamphere’s corning lo him. "He was firmly convinced that he would be killed. He was trying to norve himself fur the end. When I talked Willi him he broke down and poured out his dreadful story. 1 advised him at once to make bis statement to the pros ecuting attorney. "Lamphere scut for me. I do not know tlic man at nil. lie is a moral degenerate and inclined to ail excesses. He used to come into town every few weeks with n large amount of money, which Mrs. Ounness had given him, and would go on a protracted spree. Unless the sifting and sluicing of the powdered debris from I lie cellar of the ruined Ounriess farm house results In startling discoveries today the produc tion of further tangible evidence in the big tragedy is not likely.. Just how successful they will lie in this work is not likely to lie revealed until Ray Lamphere is brought to trial.
Investigators conducted a minute search of the burned Gunness property, believing she killed her children and placed a headless woman's body beside them before burning the house and fleeing. Sifting through the cellar ashes failed to turn up Mrs. Gunness's gold-filled teeth, strengthening suspicion she did not die in the fire.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 13 May 1908 · page 7
Ruins of Gunness Horror House And Search For More Murder Clews.
Impelled by (he belief that Mrs. Belle Qunnese, tbe Laporte (Jnd.) Çlyebeard, murdered her children and placed HARBOR M A§£PR—William Flynn, cmGOVERNMENT. FACTS ΑΒΟΓΤ PERTH AMBOY. Population, 80,000.
Authorities report evidence identifying three additional victims of Belle Gunness—John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Brady—amid a day of contradictory developments. Post-mortem reports on the bodies found in the ruins failed to establish cause of death, while prosecutors continued building a case linking Ray Lamphere to the killings.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 13 May 1908 · page 7
CASE AGAINST RAY LAMPHERE
Facts About Female Corpse lASE AGAINST RAY LAMPHEREI Laporte, Ind., May 13—Evidence to ! ■stabllsh the identity of three nddl lonal victime of Sire. Belle Gunness ivas the most positive development of j ι day filled with contradictory happen ngs here. The new victims of Mrs. Gunness ire supposed to have been John Moe of Elbow Lake, Minn.; Ilenry Gerhalt of Scandinavia, Wis., a small town near lola, from which Ole Ο. Budslwrg :ame, and George Brady of Tuscola, 111. Both prosecution and defense re vived setbacks from the discoveries and revelations, but on the whole subj stant(al progress was made teward bringing the case to the stage where It will be transferred to the courts.
See moreSee less
The reports of the four physicians I who conducted the poet mortem ex aminations on the bodies found In the rnlns of the Gunness home April 28 | were given to the coroner's Jury. They fall to establish the manner in which the woman and three children met death, and it Is probable that the coro ner's jury will return an open verdict | regarding them.
Four physicians' post mortem reports on the bodies found in the Gunness ruins failed to establish cause of death, likely leading to an open verdict from the coroner's jury. New details emerged about the adult body, including a previously unknown intact right arm, three rings with unexplained initials, and fragments of bedding and clothing, while prosecutor Smith continues building a case linking Ray Lamphere to the deaths.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 13 May 1908 · page 7
Case Against Lamphsre. Prosecutor Β. N. Smith Js still col lecting evidence, which, he asserts, will connect Ba^ Lamphere with the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her three | children, and in this work he Is being aided by the sheriff. It is possible therefore that the case against Urn
Investigators in La Porte, Indiana, say a complete solution to the Gunness farm murders is expected within 48 hours, with arrests of accomplices anticipated. They allege Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed Belle Gunness and her children, and report that chloral poisoning caused the deaths of other victims found buried on the property.
The Cimarron Citizen · 13 May 1908 · page 6
MYSTERY TO BE SOLVED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
Ray Lamphere, held as an accomplice in the Gunness farm murders, denied making any confession to Rev. E. A. Schell or anyone else. Investigators continued sluicing debris from the burned cellar, but no major new evidence had emerged.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 13 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE DENIES HE HAS CONFESSED
ED AND WILL AID. Saratoga, N. Y., June 5. Mae O'Reil ly, who, according to Julius G. Truel son, Jr., In a "confession" to the Texas authorities, was murdered on the Gun ness farm at Laporte, Ind., is in this village alive and well. Daniel F. Elch, a member of the family with whom she is stopping, says she has been employed in New York City the past year. "Miss O'Reilly has had no corre spondence with Truelson," Welch de clared," since the time when he was sent to Elmira. After her marriage with him in 1905 she went to work and has heard nothing of him since then.
See moreSee less
She knows nothing of his story, ex cept that part of it in which he refers to his marriage with her. She de clares further that she has never been in Laporte, Ind. In July, lltoT, when Truelson alleged in his confession,' that he and Mrs. (innness killed her, she was at Rochester, sue explained." The local police consider that, their theory that Truelson is mentally un balanced is materially strengthened by the discovery of Mae O'Reilly here.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.
Investigators continue sifting burned debris from the Gunness farmhouse cellar hoping to find evidence of Mrs. Gunness's fate, with no new developments reported. Ray Lamphere, held on suspicion of complicity in the murders, denies having confessed or promised to confess to anyone.
Albuquerque Citizen · 13 May 1908 · page 1
SLUICING DEBRIS FORM EVIDENCE
BACKING SHERIFF. County Commissioners to Aid in the Probe. Laporte, Ind., June .".After an all day session the county commissioners last night announced that they would stand by Sheriff Smutzer in his deter mination to probe the Belle Gunness mystery to the bottom and would fur nish such money as may be necessary to probe all clews. The Chief of . Police is in receipt of a letter from Antwerp, Belgium, written by X. Goranson, who makes inquiry re garding his brother, Lars Goranson, who had $r0.xio, and that, he vanished after a last letter from St. Louis, and he now fears he may have been one of
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A man named George Bradley is identified as a likely victim after his employer Burk reports Bradley vanished last October after mentioning a widow near La Porte he planned to marry. Separately, miner Schultz's sluicing uncovers more melted remains and a child's tooth, while Dr. Schell by telegram confirms that Ray Lamphere has been making conflicting statements preparatory to a full confession.
The Sun · 13 May 1908 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Ray Lamphere declines to make a full confession unless advised by his attorney, Worden, contrary to advice he was given to come clean with the prosecutor. Albert Herpin of La Porte recounts how Mrs. Gunness wrote to him twice, first asking about his finances and suggesting a business offer, then urging him to come manage her farm, both of which he refused.
The Sun · 13 May 1908 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Rev. Dr. Schell maintains that Ray Lamphere confessed to him about involvement in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, though Lamphere denies making any confession. Schell also shares his personal opinion that Belle Gunness may still be alive, along with impressions of her character and speech.
The Evening World · 13 May 1908 · page 1
MINISTER INSISTS THAT LAMPHERE DID CONFESS MURDERS
Gunness 01 I said yesterday was an I attractive woman In her way She dressed rlohly and ven you mlpht say In good taste but her manner of talking and her speech Itself her va garies of Krammar botraved a low origin She could best he described as Mr Newrloh Lamphere Hard Drinker Iamphcre Is a man who drinks hard
A local doctor, Schell, discusses his personal opinions on the Gunness case, including his belief that Belle Gunness may still be alive, and describes Ray Lamphere's drinking habits and gambling losses. He also recounts the sordid history of the Gunness farmhouse as a former house of ill repute frequented by wealthy Chicago men.
A young woman's body was found in the bay with no identifying papers and signs her clothing marks had been deliberately removed, while police sought a missing black boy for information. Meanwhile Ray Lamphere's lawyer denied reports that he confessed to the Gunness murders or that Helgelein's watch was found among his effects, and bankers agreed to turn over Mrs. Gunness's papers to authorities.
The Evening World · 13 May 1908 · page 2
MINISTER INSISTS THAT LAMPHERE DID CONFESS THE MURDERS
Their Victims. Now York, June 6. The New York World print the following copy righted discussion of the La Porte crime by Ccsare Lombroso, the great IUt.ian criminologist:
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
A Binghamton woman wires Coroner Mack seeking identification of a missing young woman who left for Laporte, while officials reportedly plan to arrest an accomplice to pressure Lamphere into confessing. Dr. Schell denies claiming Lamphere confessed to killing the children, though he states his personal belief that Mrs. Gunness is still alive.
The Evening World · 13 May 1908 · page 2
CONFESS THE MURDERS
di of Home. "If. as It seems, Mrs. Gunness re ceived corpses in consignment from assassins In Chicago to cause them to disappear, and if she had a special room for murdering, It Is probable she proceeded, 'like Holmes, and per hnps in imitation of him, by chem ical means.
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
A minister reports Ray Lamphere made a partial confession and promised full details in June, causing Lamphere to collapse. Meanwhile, three more possible victims are reported missing and a grand jury is gathering evidence, though authorities remain uncertain whether Mrs. Gunness was actually murdered and cremated.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Collapse. Partial Confession was Made by Lamphcre to the Minister and Promise was Made to Tell All, in June Three More MisBing Persons, One Woman and Two Men, are Re ported to the Sheriff Web of Evidence is Being Woven Around the Suspected Persons Authorities are not Sure About Mrs. Gunness Having Been Murdered and Cremated. Laporto, Ind May, 13 Following an opinion, official or otherwise, It the statement by Rev. 13. A. Scholl, this regard." at Baltimore, that Kay Lamphero , trosccutor It. N. Smith Is nllll col had made a partial confession to lectins evidence which lie asserts will him of ills part in Uio Gunness connect Hay Lamphcre with tin tmgedy 'iUio crisis in the case is deaths of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and her throe expected today. I-amphoro is in a ei,IIdron and In this work ho is being Btate of collapso and tho author!. nI(,C(1 ,,y tho 8llorlfr ai, tho iMnkcr ties look for a stntomont ironi him ;lon 0,eratives whom the latter has within a row hours. L,.ii,i i n i,in
Contradictory evidence has emerged in Laporte regarding the identity of the bodies found in the Gunness farmhouse ruins, with physicians' autopsy reports given to the coroner's jury. Indiana law means Dr. Mack alone will issue findings, and he states there is not yet sufficient evidence to establish the victims' identities or manner of death.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 13 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Investigators discuss unidentified rings found at the farm, theorizing they belonged to Peter Gunness's first wife. Evidence including letters is used to tentatively identify three more victims as John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Brady.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 13 May 1908 · page 1
CONFESSION "Poison." He said that ho hnd no middle name nnd that ho hud novo heard nny nicknames, fl'hc rings presontod a puzzle which thus far haa not been solved. Tho Inncrlptlons contain Initials .whloli r unnccotintablo oxcept upon 0110 liypotheels, that being that the orna ments were tho property of Potor Gun nes.V first wife; that ho presented thorn to .Mrs .Gunness, or that sho obtained possession of them aflcr liW death and that sho wore them on tho night tho 'liouso was burond. Tho now victims of Mrs. 011111104 am supposed to have been .John Mop
An editorial questions whether the remains found in the ruins of the Gunness home in Laporte, Indiana are truly those of Belle Gunness, suggesting the public has already assumed her guilt. It criticizes detectives for 'weaving a web' once a reward was announced for her capture.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 13 May 1908 · page 4
.If the remains found in tho nilna 'mean slap at VloPresidont Falr of the Gunness homo at Laporte, Indlhanks by tho Methodist general con ana, were really thoo of tho mistress ference at Baltimore. or the "House of Hororrs," tho public will bo deprived of much wnsatloiuil readlncr :m1 Iho nriinn i.ml i ...111 I. l.., .. , ... .. ii nau mrc.il uiuiiiicu ub inuugii Went jmiftt .bo a total abstainer wa a It would bo a relief to know Just Ih In the how much trouble thero and how tOUUCeO UUKT1C18 Ol UIIIO
A Methodist minister, Rev. A. S. Schell, who heard Ray Lamphere's confidential statement regarding the burned Gunness home and deaths, refuses to reveal details but says he sought fair treatment and legal counsel for Lamphere. Schell adds he personally believes Mrs. Gunness is still alive, though Lamphere reportedly denied burning the house, admitting only to earlier matters.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 13 May 1908 · page 4
LAMPHERE Continued from Pago Ouc. tho debris on tho Guinness farm. Baltimore, Md., May 13. TPJiiit Ray Uimphoro, charged with tie burning of tho Gunness homo ai
A Baltimore report quotes Methodist minister Rev. E. A. Schell claiming that Ray Lamphere confessed to him that he helped burn Mrs. Gunness's children, while also asserting Lamphere told him the body found was not Mrs. Gunness and that she is still alive. The account is attributed to Lamphere's own words relayed through the clergyman.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Capital Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 9
MINISTER ACCUSES LAMPHERE - LA PORTE MURDER - METHODIST PASTOR SAYS LAMPHERE CONFESSED BURNING WOMAN AND CHILDREN - MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE
Arrabelle Vreeland, daughter of C. P. Vreeland of East Ninety-second street, Canarsie, Long Island, with whom he eloped in March last, to the Gunness farm. All that prevented him, he says, was a letter from Mrs. Gunness, telling him -the sheriff was making inquiries about the disap pearance of some of her victims, and advising him to come alone. Truelson's story, as told to the offi cials at Vernon, and repeated by them to Sheriff Smutzer, was that, in 1904, he read Mrs. Gunness' ad
Clipping to come
Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon
Sheriff's office receives letters from across the country describing people who vanished and are feared to have been murdered and buried at Belle Gunness's farm. Specific cases mentioned include Emil Kell of Kansas, Charles Eggman of New Castle, Indiana, and an unnamed young woman from Binghamton, New York, all of whom withdrew savings before disappearing.
Daily Capital Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 10
Letters from different partB of tho country descrlbhlg -tho disappearance of soveral ' persons who ' aro now thought to bo their friend and rela tives that 'havo been slain on the premises of Mrs. Bollo Gunncs? nnd burled in her private graveyard are! beginning to pour in. Tho sheriff wbb told today that Enill Kell, of Kansas, droW $2000 from the bank two years ago and dis appeared. No word hnsbeen re ceived from him .since. His frlondd feel suro that he answered one of Mrs. QunnesB' matrimonii "ads." and went to tho "murder farm."
See moreSee less
Chnrlos Eggman, of Now Castle, Ind also numbered among the missing. After taking $3000 of his savings from the bank he left Now CaBtlo and hns not been heard from. A young woman nl'o dlsnpnonre'd from Blnghnmton, N. Y., under peculiar circumstances. Her relatives write I that they fear she became acquainted with Mrs. Gunness nnd wna murder ed.
Lamphere denied promising Rev. Schell a full confession in June. A Cleveland man's letter revealed a well-dressed man posing as a cattleman had approached him last August offering a rich widow seeking a husband, and police believe this man acted as Gunness's recruiting agent.
Daily Capital Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 10
GAMBLER HAS HAD ENOUGH
For the first time since the Gun ness murder mystery developed the authorities wore told today of cir cumstances Indicating that a woll dressed man hnd been acting ns Mrs, iGunnesseB' agsnt; that It h probable that ho helped to "rope" in tho vic tims. This now evidence 1b given In a let ter from a Cleveland man whose name Chief of Police Cochrano re fuses to divulge. Tho writer says that last August ho was waiting for n car when ho mot a well dressed man who represented himself to bo a cnttlo mnn from Chicago.
See moreSee less
Ho said ho knew a rich widow who wanted a "mnn." Tho stranger asked Coch rano's Informant If ho would like to go to La Porte, nnd ho ropllod thift ho would not. Tho strnngor then snld tho womun would go to .Cleve land If her fare wan paid. A mom ent lator ho presented tho Cleveland man with u ponny photograph of Mrs. Gunness. The pollco claim to havo ovldonco that this mnn win nn ngent for Mrs. GuuneuH and that ho collected mnll addressed to her in soveral towns, In. eluding Chicago. Motonnnn Carlson has Informed tho pollco that tho de scription glvon by tho writer tnllIon with a man who frequently alighted fromn atroetcnr at the' corner near est to the Gnnncn homo,
Letters arriving from across the country describe people who vanished after apparently answering matrimonial advertisements, with suspicion they were lured to Mrs. Gunness's farm. Ray Lamphere denies having made a complete confession to a reverend.
East Oregonian : E.O · 13 May 1908 · page 7
Arc ever existed, but the News Editor evi dently believes that Mrs. Gunness of Laporte, Tnd., is a live one. State Journal. Dr. Edward Everett Hale, in his June page in Woman's Home Companion, gives three rules for conduct of life: 1. Live in the
Clipping to come
The Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon
Four physicians' post-mortem reports on bodies found in the Gunness home ruins failed to establish cause of death for the woman and three children, likely leading to an open verdict. A Chicago Tribune dispatch claims a full solution is expected within 48 hours, with Ray Lamphere alleged to have set the fire that killed four of the fourteen known victims.
The Morning Astorian · 13 May 1908 · page 8
Substantial Progress Was Made Towards Bringing the Case to a State Where it Will be Transferred to the Courts
CHICAGO, May 12.-A despatch to the Tribune from LaPorte, Ind., says: , A complete solution of the myster ies of the Gunness murder farm is ex pected within 48 hours. The officials who have been conducting the search for the victims of the house of many deaths practically admitted this fact yesterday. They refused, however, to make known their purposes further than to say that the final step may be taken today or tomorrow at the latest. The mystery surrounding four of the fourteen deaths which are known to have occured at the place is cleared by the allegation that Pay Lamphere, the farm hand prisoner in the county jail set fire to the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness on the morning of April 28
The report states that farmhand Ray Lamphere will be indicted for first-degree murder and arson for allegedly burning Belle Gunness's home and killing her and her three children. It also details investigators' findings that the ten exhumed victims were killed with chloral and dismembered using knives found in the ruins.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Morning Astorian · 13 May 1908 · page 8
HORROR GUINNESS Physicians' Reports Given to a Coroner's Jury CONTRADICTORY HAPPENINGS Substantial Progress Was Made To wards Bringing the Case to a State Where it Will bo Transferred to the Courts. LA PORTE, May I2-The evidence to establish the identity of the three additional victims of Mrs. Guinness was the most positive development of the day filled with contradictory happenings. Both the prosecution and the defense received setbacks from discoveries and revelations but on the whole substantial progress was made toward bringing the case to a state where it will be transferred to the courts.
See moreSee less
The reports of the four physicians who conducted the post mortem examinations on the bodies found in the ruins of the Guin ness home were given to a coroner's jury this morning. They failed to es tablish the manner in which the wom en and three children met their death and it is probable that the coroner's jury will return an open verdict re garding them. The proccedure in Indiana does not provide for the coro ner's juries to consider the individual conclusions of Dr. Mack. CHICAGO, May 12.-A despatch to the Tribune from LaPorte, Ind., says: , A complete solution of the myster ies of the Gunness murder farm is ex pected within 48 hours. The officials who have been conducting the search for the victims of the house of many deaths practically admitted this fact yesterday. They refused, however, to make known their purposes further than to say that the final step may be taken today or tomorrow at the latest. The mystery surrounding four of the fourteen deaths which are known to have occured at the place is cleared by the allegation that Pay Lamphere, the farm hand prisoner in the county jail set fire to the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness on the morning of April 28 and thereby caused the death of the widow and the three children. For this, if proven guilty, he is liable, under the provisions of the In diana state laws, to coviction for murder in the first degree as well as for arson. Indictments against him upon both these charges will be asked of the grand jury on Wednesday." As to the manner of death of the ten murdered persons whose bodies were uncovered in a little patch of ground guarded by closely woven wire netting the silence of the officers in response to queries as to the arrest of one or more accomplices provides the only answer. That the victims came to their death through the administration of a deadly amount of chloral has been proven. The places at which the drug was purchased during the last eight years have been found. That the inanimate corpses then j were dismembered either in a cham ber of horrors on the second floor of the Gunness home or in the basement has been shown to the satisfaction of the investigators. Two knives, one a six inch dagger and the other a needle-pointed double razor edged surgeon's knife, have found in the ruins. paper was greater under the consoli dation than under the individual own ership of the paper mills. The contract which the New York Times has with the paper company was denied to the committee and in this connection Chairman Mann took occasion to state that while news papers arc insisting on speedy action
A newspaper commentary column briefly criticizes the public spectacle made of Belle Gunness's farm, noting that the gruesome work she had done did not need to be further exposed through inspection by thousands of curious women. The remark appears amid a series of unrelated political and social commentary items.
The Morning Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
At Laporte, Indiana, investigators reported rings found on a hand at the Gunness farm bearing initials suggesting they belonged to Peter Gunness's first wife, while evidence was also developing to identify three additional victims. Post-mortem reports given to the coroner's jury failed to establish cause of death for the woman and children found in the ruins, and prosecutors continued gathering evidence to connect Ray Lamphere to the deaths.
The Morning Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 1
RINGS ON HAND FOUND AT GUNNESS FARM A PUZZLE
Our readers are doubtless all familiar with the horrible discovery that has Just been made in Indiana where a woman said to be a Mrs Gunness turned out to be a multiplied mur deress and the authorities are now in serious doubt whether she be now living or dead In spite of the womans predilections for such atrocious crimes she was none the less a good church member consistent In her sacred duties and occupied a front seat in the Meth odist Episcopal church at Laporte every meet Ing Her children atended the Sunday school and she was to all intents and purposes an Ideal Christian woman a true and faithful church member and a contributor to the Christian cause This exceedingly tainted money deliberately stolen from the clothing of her numerous victims found Its way Into the church coffera was used for Christian pur poses and probably aided in an extension of the cause being a devout believer she has of course managed to get purified before tak ing on Immortality and Is now supposed to safely and snugly esconsced up near the throne of the Most High Of course she knew she was doing wrong in committing murder but being familiar with the text that telleth that While the lamp holds out to burn The vilest sinner may return
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Investigators led by Smith report new findings on the body believed to be Belle Gunness, including details about which arm was more intact and three rings found on the hands with puzzling inscriptions. Three more suspected victims are named: John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Berry.
The Morning Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 1
ROCHESTER, N. Y., June 6. 1'. was established today that Mao O'Reilly, whom Julius Truelson or New York "confessed" he took to the Gunness farm at La Porte, Ind , where she was murdered, is alive and well at Saratoga, where she is visit ing. The supposed murder of the woman, who is Truelson s wife, was the most important point in his selfincriminating statement. The police here believe that the rest of his al leged confession that he participated in the Gunness crimes, will now fall o pieces and that he will be found to be demented. v.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Investigators surmise a dirk found at the scene may have been the primary murder weapon, though lack of penetrating wounds on Andrew Helgelien's body complicates the theory, with chloroform suspected as a subduing agent instead. A neighbor, Mrs. Lapham, recalls seeing a belt of knife sheaths hidden under Gunness's housedress.
The Morning Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 1
DIRK MAY HAVE BEEN CHIEF WEAPON
If Harry Orchard had answered one f Mrs. Gunness' matrimonial adver sements there would have been a hot ine in LaPorte long before the fire mt destroyed the Gunness inferno. ?
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A report from La Porte, Indiana describes the gruesome discovery of five bodies buried in the yard of Belle Gunness, who died in a house fire with three children. Authorities identify two victims as Andrew Helgelien, a suitor, and Jennie Olson, an adopted daughter, and suspect Ray Lamphere in the dismemberment of Helgelien's body.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
If Harry Orchard had answered one f Mrs. Gunness' matrimonial adver sements there would have been a hot ine in LaPorte long before the fire mt destroyed the Gunness inferno. ?
Clipping to come
The Lexington Dispatch · Lexington, South Carolina
The report describes Mrs. Bell Gunness of Laporte, Indiana, as a matrimonial agency operator suspected of murdering a score or more people for their property. It states that her crimes were discovered after her house burned down and several bodies were found in the debris during the ongoing investigation.
The Lexington Dispatch · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Xaay Murders Committed. At Laporte, Ind., a terrible murder mystery is now being investigated. Mrs. Bell Gunness, who was the promoter of a matrimonial agency for many years past, is alleged to have killed a score or more people during her career. It is said tnat she would have men call to see her and would then get them out of the way by
Investigators digging in the yard of Belle Gunness's burned Indiana farmhouse uncover five murder victims, two identified as suitor Andrew Helgelien and adopted daughter Jennie Olson. Suspicion falls on hired hand Ray Lamphere, already jailed for the fatal fire, with authorities speculating he dismembered Helgelien's body.
Edgefield Advertiser · 13 May 1908 · page 4
ROBBERY A PROBABLE MOTIVE
Forsyth oeople do not believe that R. D. McBride fell a victim to the murderous activity of Mrs. Gunness at La Porte, Indiana. McBride left Forsyth several months ago with string of race horses and a bunch of money. He was traced to Iowa and there disappeared and nothing has since been heard of him. It is ported that he may have been lured to La Porte by the Gunness wretch but his friends hardly cerdit such
Clipping to come
Edgefield Advertiser · Edgefield, S.C.
The report identifies one of the bodies found as Jennie Olsen, Mrs. Gunness's adopted daughter, while three others remain unidentified. It speculates that Lamphere, not Gunness, likely murdered Heldgren to steal $1,500 he possessed, with only vague suggestion that Gunness herself may have known of the killings.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Edgefield Advertiser · 13 May 1908 · page 4
ROBBERY A PROBABLE MOTIVE
TO SEARCH FURTHER Laporte, Ind., June 5. But a few days ago Coroner Mack ordered the burial In tho pauper field of tho skel etons dug from the cofflnless graves
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
The passage reproduces a sample of Belle Gunness's matrimonial advertisement letter demanding suitors bring $1,000 in cash. It also names Henry Gurholt and Herman Konitzer as additional men believed to have been lured to her farm and killed.
The Madison Daily Leader · 13 May 1908 · page 1
MUST BRING ALONG $1,000
Another Alleged Victim. Chicago, May 13.—Friends of Her man Konitzer, who suddenly disap peared in January, lflOG, have become convinced that he was a victim of Mrs. Gunness. He had been the man agar of an estate at Posen, Germany, and was well versed in farming. It was known by his friends that he had received a letter proposing marriage from a widow at Laporte and that he went there to see her. Since then nothing habeen heard him. of
Investigators say no major new evidence is likely until ashes from the burned Gunness farmhouse are further sifted, with banks agreeing to open records for possible clues. The coroner has reported findings on most bodies, though several remain unidentified, and hired man Ray Lamphere denies rumors of a confession.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
BANKS TO LEND AID
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
Coroner Mack has completed investigation on most bodies except Budsperg, with identification of Moe and Gerholt nearly conclusive but Brady's fate uncertain. Lamphere denies confessing to Rev. Schell, while Laporte banks agree to share Mrs. Gunness's financial records to aid prosecutors.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 1
BANKS TO LEND AID
the postoffice, Austin, Minn. the SOME claim that Mrs. Gunness. If Indiana murderess, is not dead, she is not, she ought to be. SOME of our recalcitrant congress
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Four physicians' postmortem reports on the bodies found in the Gunness home ruins were given to the coroner but failed to establish how Mrs. Gunness and her three children died. The day brought contradictory developments, including evidence identifying three additional victims, with setbacks for both prosecution and defense.
The Salt Lake Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
REPORTS FROM FOUR DOCTORS Manner in Which Mrs Gunness and Her Children Met Death Not Yet Established
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A Kansas City laborer named Christian Hansen received a letter from Belle Gunness offering marriage if he could produce $1000 in cash, a sum he did not have. The report reprints the letter in full, showing her soliciting a husband for her farm and children.
The Salt Lake Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
WAS SHORT $1000, LACK OF ENOUGH CASH SAVED THE LIFE OF CHRISTIAN HANSEN
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
The report reproduces a letter Belle Gunness sent proposing marriage to a man named Hansen, requesting he bring $1,000 to prove he was not a grafter. Hansen, a Cudahy Packing employee, explains he only had $700 and hesitated to withdraw it, so he delayed responding.
The Salt Lake Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A brief humorous editorial aside remarks that Mrs. Gunness was the 'soul affinity' of convicted murderer Harry Orchard, lamenting their paths never crossed. It's a passing topical joke embedded among unrelated political and society items.
The Salt Lake Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 4
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
A newspaper index entry states that further investigation into the Gunness murders at Laporte, Indiana, has only added to the mystery surrounding the case. No specific new details are given in this brief listing.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Friday, June 5. In a collision of electric cars at Ken aebunkport. Me., Miss Sarah E. Corliss, aged 30, received injuries which re sulted In her death and five other per sons were hurt, some of them severely. Mae O'Reilly, whom Julius G. Truel son, Jr., In a "confession" to the Texas authorities, declared was murdered on the Gunness farm at La .Porte, Ind., Is alive and well at Saratoga, N. Y. Eight non-commissioned officers of the German guard artfllery regiment were sentenced to terms of Imprison ment varying from two weeks to fifteen months for the maltreatment of sub ordinates.
See moreSee less
At the convention of the Internation al Association of Police Chiefs a reso lution was adopted declaring that ik Hcemen are entitled to more respect and consideration. After serving Richmond, R. I., as town clerk for fifty-6ix years Halsey P. Clarke, 90 years of age, met his first defeat at the polls. His former sup porters feared he was too old to fulfil the duties of the office. Rev. Samuel Freuder of New York, a clergyman of the Episcopal church, has renounced his orders and has be come a Jew. Freuder was formerly a 7ewlsh rabbi, but seventeen years ago he was converted to Christianity. Just at the close of the ceremonies attending the canonization of Emlle Xolu' in the Pantheon, Louis A. Gregorl, 1 niillhtry writer of note, fired two
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Investigators in La Porte report contradictory findings as they try to identify three more victims and determine how Mrs. Gunness and three children died. New evidence from Dr. Gray's autopsy report reveals rings on the body claimed to be Gunness's and notes her right hand still exists, deepening rather than resolving the mystery of her identity and fate.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 1
QUESTION IF MURDERESS WAS HERSELF KILLED
Balloonists complain that the Massa chusetts farmers shoot at them Well havent they always been Urged to mate their aims high We hope that the Democrats will put in Independence for the Philippines plank in their platform1 We want to settle that too while settling Bryan It is quite dangerous for any middle aged hard featured woman to travel anywhere out West They are discov ering a Mrs Gunness at almost any old station almost any old time now The aeronauts are insistently point ing out that the accidents among the chauffeurs are much more numerous than among the sky sailors Certainly but this is on the basis of white sheep eating more than black ones At last reports Col Stewart was en joying the pleasant seclusion of Fort Grant Ariz his chief source of unhap ipiness being that there was nobody un der or over him that he could make unhappy Oklahoma business men are worry ing much with reason over the bad reputation given their State by its poli tics It is certainly hard to attract capital and enterprise to a State with such a Government The people on the Zone propose to have great Fourth of -July celebrations at Cristobal and other prominent places These will undoubtedly -do much good In awaking everjbody to a proper ap preciation Americanism
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
The coroner's jury failed to determine how Mrs. Gunness and three children died, likely resulting in an open verdict. Dr. Gray's previously suppressed autopsy report reveals three inscribed rings and an intact right hand, deepening the mystery of the body's identity.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 1
WAS HERSELF KILLED
Balloonists complain that the Massa chusetts farmers shoot at them Well havent they always been Urged to mate their aims high We hope that the Democrats will put in Independence for the Philippines plank in their platform1 We want to settle that too while settling Bryan It is quite dangerous for any middle aged hard featured woman to travel anywhere out West They are discov ering a Mrs Gunness at almost any old station almost any old time now The aeronauts are insistently point ing out that the accidents among the chauffeurs are much more numerous than among the sky sailors Certainly but this is on the basis of white sheep eating more than black ones At last reports Col Stewart was en joying the pleasant seclusion of Fort Grant Ariz his chief source of unhap ipiness being that there was nobody un der or over him that he could make unhappy Oklahoma business men are worry ing much with reason over the bad reputation given their State by its poli tics It is certainly hard to attract capital and enterprise to a State with such a Government The people on the Zone propose to have great Fourth of -July celebrations at Cristobal and other prominent places These will undoubtedly -do much good In awaking everjbody to a proper ap preciation Americanism
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
The report reproduces one of Belle Gunness's letters soliciting a husband, describing her farm near La Porte and demanding $1000 in cash from the suitor. It also profiles Hansen, a Cudahy Packing Company employee and former Norwegian artillery captain connected to the case.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 2
GUNNESS MURDER MYSTERY BAFFLES
Laporte county commissioners Thursday night announced they would stand bySheriff Smutzer in his determination to fully in vestigate the Belle Gunness mys tery and would furnish necessary money to complete the inquiry of all clews. Flag day will be observed this year on Monday, June 15th, in stead of on the fourteenth day of the month, which falls on Sun day. Fkig day is the anniversary of the raising of the Stars and Stripes for the first time, at Fort
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
A Kansas packing house worker named Hansen reveals he received a marriage lure letter from Belle Gunness but declined due to the amount requested, narrowly avoiding her scheme as the Laporte skeletons were uncovered. Separately, Rev. E. A. Schell confirms Ray Lamphere made a confidential statement about the Gunness case but refuses to disclose its contents, citing it was given in confidence.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 13 May 1908 · page 2
Sent to Laporte. Eau Claire, Wis., June 10. Chris tian Hilkven, who formarly resided in Dover, four miles south of Chetek, and who mysteriously disappeared from there In 1906, after Belling his farm for J2.000 In cash, Is believed to have been a victim of Mrs. Qunness of Laporto. The editor of the Decorah la.) Posten, for which Hilkven sub scribed, writes Hllkven's friends that the latter had his paper changed to laporte and the postmaster at Laporte 'writes that Hllkven's mail was deliv ered to Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A brief news digest entry reports that five murdered bodies were discovered in the yard of Mrs. Bella Gunness's home near Laporte, Indiana. It states that Gunness and three of her children died in a house fire on the night of April 28.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 7
Bella Gunness, who, with three of her children, was burned to death on the night of April 28 at Laporte, Ind. The condition of former President Grover Cleveland, who is suffering from acute indigestion, continues to show improvement. The New Jersey Republican state convention to select delegates to attend the national convention at Chicago named a delegation that is uninstructed and voted down resolutions endorsing the candidacy of Taft for president. Dr. Amos T. Raker, acting superin tendent of the Matteawan state hos pital, alleges that Harry K. Thaw is in sane. Raker has had Thaw under observation during his confinement In Matteawan.
The report notes that four additional bodies were found in the barnyard near Laporte, Indiana, deepening the farm mystery. Evidence suggested the nine dismembered corpses unearthed had been shipped there, probably from Chicago.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 7
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
A news digest item reports that one more body has been added to the death toll at the Belle Gunness farm near La Porte, Indiana, bringing the total to ten corpses and skeletons exhumed in the yard. This is in addition to four bodies previously found in the ruins of the burned farmhouse.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 7
One more body has been added to the death roll of the Bella Guinness farm near La Porte, Ind., making a total of ten corpses and skeletons exhumed in the yard, besides the four bodies found in the ruins of the burned farmhouse. The Euclid Avenue Trust company of Cleveland hm made an assignment. It is understood that the deposits amount to between $1,200,000 and $1,300,000. A million and a quarter dollars is the loss on a fire which swept over two blocks of business property at Atlanta. The combined Atlantic and Pacific fleets of battleships, armored cruisers, torpedo boat destroyers and auxiliaries were reviewed in San Francisco harbor by Secretary of the Navy Metcalf.
See moreSee less
Henri Itochette, the Flench promoter of financial institutions and mining en terprises, who was arrested on a charge of swindling on an enormous scale, has been released in $40,000 hall.
Letters pour in from across the country describing people who vanished after corresponding with Mrs. Gunness, including men who withdrew large sums before disappearing. Ray Lamphere denies having given a complete confession to Rev. Schell as previously claimed.
The Spokane Press · 13 May 1908 · page 1
MORE GUNNESS VICTIMS
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The report reproduces the text of Belle Gunness' will, said to have been made the day before the night of the fire at the Gunness home. It directs payment of debts and funeral expenses, and bequeaths her property to her three children, Myrtle, Lucy, and Philip.
The Spokane Press · 13 May 1908 · page 3
THIS IS MRS. GUNNESS' LAST WILL
surance collected. Widow marries Joe Gunness. Moves to Laporte farm. Adopts Jennie Olsen. Gunness killed (1904). Widow says meat cleaver fell on his head. Collects $3,500 insurance. Ray Lamphere goes to work for Mrs. Gunness as hired man. Widow sets dogs on visitors. Neighbors see lanterns on farm at 2 a. m. Jennie Olsen disappears. Real parents are told she is in Los Angeles school, but can not find her (1906). Andrew Helgelein, Aberdeen (S. D.), answers matrimonial ad, and arrives at Laporte farm. Loans Mrs. Gunness sl,- 500. Disappears with like amount In pocket. Widow says he went to Norway. Mrs. Gunness (1907) tells sheriff strange man killed a child in woods near farm. Sheriff finds only empty grave. Hay Lamphere arrested for annoying Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The report quotes portions of Belle Gunness's will, naming her children as heirs with property reverting to the Norwegian Children's Home in Chicago if all died without issue. It also states her wish to be buried at Forest Home cemetery in Oak Park, Illinois, with Wesley Fogle named executor.
The Spokane Press · 13 May 1908 · page 3
WAS THE LEADER LAPORTE, Ind., June S. Twelve accomplices of Mrs. Gunness in her numerous murders, live in Chicago, and the woman herself is alive, ac cording to information received by Chief of Police Cochrane today. Four other members of the gang, two men and two women, live in Milwaukee. A letter, without signature, bearing the Milwaukee postmark, conveyed the news to the chief. The addresses of the supposed accomplices are given and an investigation is being mado. The letter says Mrs. Gunness was the chief of a murder gang, under aliases of Gibson, Buck and Springer, and that the police ' records of Chi cago will show that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was connected with a case in which a man was suffocated to death. Mrs. Gunness is said by the writer to be in correspondence with a Mrs, Harring ton in Milwaukee. Letters written by ttfc murderess have been received.
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
Police in multiple cities search for Belle Gunness, believed alive after a Chicago druggist claims she tried to buy chloroform from him. The hotel she allegedly stayed at has no record of her name, deepening the mystery of her disappearance.
The Spokane Press · 13 May 1908 · page 4
POLICE OF MANY CITIES LOOKING FOR MURDERESS
WAS THE LEADER LAPORTE, Ind., June S. Twelve accomplices of Mrs. Gunness in her numerous murders, live in Chicago, and the woman herself is alive, ac cording to information received by Chief of Police Cochrane today. Four other members of the gang, two men and two women, live in Milwaukee. A letter, without signature, bearing the Milwaukee postmark, conveyed the news to the chief. The addresses of the supposed accomplices are given and an investigation is being mado. The letter says Mrs. Gunness was the chief of a murder gang, under aliases of Gibson, Buck and Springer, and that the police ' records of Chi cago will show that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was connected with a case in which a man was suffocated to death. Mrs. Gunness is said by the writer to be in correspondence with a Mrs, Harring ton in Milwaukee. Letters written by ttfc murderess have been received.
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
Police report no trace of Belle Gunness in the city and have alerted New York officers to watch for her, believing she may be heading to Norway. Additional victims are traced to the Gunness farm, including Ole Budeberg of Iola, Wisconsin, and Olaf Limbo, a Norwegian immigrant who had intended to marry her.
The Spokane Press · 13 May 1908 · page 4
ttfc murderess have been received. 'ring the postmark of a town n ritish Columbia, says the missive. The writer says that the insertion of a personal advertisement in a Mil waukee papfir will place him in per sonal touch with the Laporte authori ties. Mrs. R. Mario Svendkerud of Chris tlania, Norway, through Acting Con sul Faye of Chicago made inquiry of Sheriff Smulzer for her son, Olaf Jen sen of Capron, 111., who in 1906 left Chicago for Laporte to marry a Nor wegian widow, whom ho had met through a matrimonial advertise ment. The mother believes he war? one of Mrs. Gunuens' victims. Jennia Svenkerud Haltorb, a sister of thj missing man, lives in Chicago.
Clipping to come
The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.
Letters arriving from across the country describe various men who vanished and are believed to have been lured to Mrs. Gunness's farm, nicknamed the 'house of death and horrors.' One example cited is Emil K. of Kansas, who withdrew $2,000 from a bank two years earlier and disappeared.
The Evening Statesman · 13 May 1908 · page 1
TRACE MANY MISSING MEN LAPORTE, May 13.—Letters from all " v, ' r the country r-Uf. in-tan. t> of the disappearance »f -Various persons who arc believed ft* hay c been lured into the "house of death and horrors" which it is at;?god was operated by Mrs. Gunness and it is thought are yet to be found in the "murder garden." Emil K. 11 of Kansas, is one of these. Two years ago he drew $2000 from a bank and mysteriously disappeared. to Light, *, ised to.
Authorities now believe Ray Lamphere, Mrs. Gunness's former hired man, acted as her accomplice in murdering victims, motivated by revenge after she withheld money from him. The report also recalls suspicious deaths of her two husbands, insurance payouts, and theories that Jennie Olson was killed to silence her.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Vernon County Censor · 13 May 1908 · page 7
MAY CLAIM GUNNESS VICTIM. Chicago Woman Partially Identifies Body Found on Death Farm. LAPORTE, Ind.. June G.—More fully convinced than ever that her husband met death on the Gunness farm. Mrs.
Clipping to come
The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
Ray Lamphere, Belle Gunness's hired man, denied making any confession to Rev. Schell or anyone else. Investigators continue sifting debris from the burned farmhouse cellar hoping for new evidence.
The Daily Telegram · 13 May 1908 · page 1
RAY LAMPHERE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The New Era · Walden, Colo. · and 3 other papers
The report describes police suspicions that Ray Lamphere was Belle Gunness's accomplice who killed her in jealousy and burned the house, while detailing the discovery of bodies in the ruins and yard, including Andrew Helgelein and Jennie Olson. It notes Gunness profited from insurance on dead husbands and speculates she may have faked her own death.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The New Era · 14 May 1908 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
The Colorado Statesman · Denver, Colo. · 9 May 1908
The Idaho Springs Siftings-News · Idaho Springs, Colo. · 9 May 1908
The Elk Mountain Pilot (Irwin, Colo.) · Ruby Camp · 14 May 1908
The New Era · Walden, Colo. · and 1 other paper
A sixth body, buried over a year ago, is unearthed from the Gunness farm, bringing the death toll to eleven with signs of a thirteenth victim. Ray Lamphere, under arrest, claims Belle Gunness was the mastermind of the murders, while police suspect he killed her and burned the house.
DEATH HOUSE AT LA PORTE MISSING WOMAN BELIEVED TO HAVE BEEN GUILTY OF MANY MURDERS. MORE BODIES FOUND SUSPECTED MURDERERS MAY NOT HAVE BEEN BURNED AS WAS THOUGHT.
miners in response to their wage scale. , The operators ask that they be pul on | the same basis with the non-union mines, where the wane scale is 10 cents per ton under that of the union. The miners asked for a consideration of the proposi tion until the 27th inst., but the commit tee of the commercial operators would not grant it, claiming that non-union mines in the state had’ the larger number of mines and worked the greater number of miners, and that they were being placed at a big disadvantage. The union in this state is under 4000 now, and la not nearly as effective as it was four years ago. Mrs. Gunness May Be In Mexico.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Colorado Statesman · Denver, Colo. · 9 May 1908
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D. · and 1 other paper
Diggers at the Gunness farm near Laporte found two additional skeletons buried in the same grave, believed to be a man and woman underground for about two years. Only three of eleven total bodies have been identified so far, with investigators struggling due to the remains' long burial time.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 3
Be an Attraction. Great preparations are being made through South Chicago Swedish so cieties for attending their annual pic nic and excursion, which will be held this year at LaPorte, Ind. ". At least two special trains and pos sibly three will leave South Chicago over the Lake Shore road Sunday morn ing to convey the local aggregation of South Chicagoans to the Gunness city.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 9 May 1908
The Oakes Times · Oakes, N.D. · and 1 other paper
A Laporte pallbearer recounts how Mrs. Gunness was mysteriously absent during her husband Philip's funeral, later explaining she had gone to consult a lawyer about possible murder charges. A Missouri man, George Anderson, describes narrowly escaping her scheme and now suspects she set fire to her farmhouse and is still alive.
The Oakes Times · 14 May 1908 · page 2
SUSPECTS GUNNESS WOMAN Strong in Hit Protestations That His Offspring la Incapable of the Brutal Murders With Which He 8tanda Charged. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—\V. W. Lam phere, father of Ray Lamphere and a justice of the peace at Springfield, Ind., has arrived to assist In the de fense of his son. Sheriff Smutzer re fused him permission to interview the latter. H. W. Worden, attorney for Ray Lamphere, declares he will bring about an interview with" father and •on If he is compelled to bring Ray to court. The father la strong In protesta tions of the innocence of his son and asserts that he believes Ray Lam phere inoapable of the murders with which he stand* charged.
See moreSee less
Mr. Lamphere, senior, saya that at one time Mrs. Gunness bought fifty fence posts of him and that while she was at the place he waa strongly prejudiced against her. He ques tioned his son Ray about the latter'a posalble marriage with Mrs. Ounness and, advising against it, Ray told him that he never would marry the wo man. Charles Way, a resident of Laporte, gave out an interesting interview in connection with the funeral of Philip Ounness, the second husband of Mrs. Gvpness, who waa said to have been killed bjr being struck on the head by a falling sausage machine. Mr. Way •ays that he waa a pallbearer at the funeral of Gunness. At the conclu sion of the funeral ceremony, when the cortege was about to start for the cemetery, Mrs. Gunness could not be found and it developed that she had not been present at the ceremonies. Considerable uneasiness was felt by those present at the funeral sermon for fear that the shock incident to the sudden death of her husband had un balanced the woman's mind and that •he had made away with herself. The matter was about to be placed in the hands of the authorities when Mrs. Gunness drove up the MoClung road. Everybody present waa astounded when, as she drove up to the front of the house, she calmly remarked: "Go ahead and bury him. I guess It's all right." It developed later that she had come to the city during the funeral cere mony to consult with her lawyer about her possible arrest for the mur der of her husband. This action was considered at the time as sensational, aa at that time no one had the slight est suspicion that Gunness had come to his death by any means other than purely accidental and Mrs. Gunness was not under any suspicion what ever.
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 12 May 1908
Audubon Republican · Audubon, Iowa · and 3 other papers
Investigators digging near Belle Gunness's burned house near Laporte, Indiana, found additional bodies, bringing the total to ten. One was identified as Ole B. Budsberg, lured by a matrimonial advertisement, and new evidence mounted against suspected accomplice Ray Lamphere.
hiding. The attorneys for Ray Lam phere are grasping at every cluo, which promises to establish a ques tion as to whether the woman perish ed in the fire, which burned her homo tho morning of April 28. The attorneys for Lamphere are now
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
The Columbus Journal · Columbus, Neb. · 13 May 1908
The Loup City Northwestern · Loup City, Neb. · 14 May 1908
The Greenville Journal · Greenville, Ohio · 14 May 1908
Courier Democrat · Langdon, N.D. · and 1 other paper
The report reproduces the personal advertisement Mrs. Gunness placed seeking a well-off widower to join fortunes with her, insisting replies be followed by a personal visit. This ad was reportedly the means by which she lured men to her farm.
Courier Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 2
TO LURE HER VICTIMS.
HIS DEATH WELL TIMED. Mrs. Gunness' First Husband Expired Day Eefore Insurance Lapsed. Chicago, .May s.—A sinister fact in connection with the death of Mads
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · and 1 other paper
Searchers sifting the burned debris of the Gunness home found a gold crown tooth believed to be from Belle Gunness's skull. An autopsy report by Dr. J. L. Gray also revealed three rings on the corpse bearing inscriptions to mysterious initials 'J.S.' and 'P.S.', deepening rather than resolving questions about the body's identity.
GOLD 11l AGUES Officials Search Debris in Rains of the Qunness Home. fcOW BELIEVE WOMAN DEAD Relic Appears to Have Fallen From the Incinerated Skull of the Al leged Multi-Murderess. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—A gold crown tooth has been found In the debris of the Gunness home. It Is be lieved to be from the head of Mrs. Bella Gunness. The tooth was found in the debris of the cellar while Sheriff Smutzer was continuing his preparations to begin the sluicing of the ashes. The relic is a hollow molar, with a gold crown, the metal being indented and to some extent encrusted by cinders.
See moreSee less
The tooth, however, bears every evi dence of having come from the incin erated skull of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Unexplainable evidence, hitherto suppressed, has been made public in the Gunness tragedy. It is contained In the report of Dr. J. L. Gray, who performed the autopsy on the body which the authorities have steadfastly claimed is that of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Dr. Gray, iu his report, tells of three rings which were found upon the corpse and also reveuls the fact that the right hand, hitherto declared miss ing, is 81 ill in existence. The rings, which might be expected to reveal the Identity of the wearer, only add to the mystery of the case. Two of them contain inscriptions, one being “P. S. to J. S. Aug. 22, ’94,” and tho other “P. G. to J. S. 3-5-95.” Mrs. Gunness’ husband was Peter Gunness, but the Identity of “J. S.” and “P. S.” is a puzzle which none of the local officials would attempt to explain.
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 13 May 1908
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · and 1 other paper
Four mutilated bodies were discovered buried in the backyard of the burned Gunness home in Laporte, Indiana, where Mrs. Gunness and her children were believed to have died in the fire. Investigators concluded that murder had been committed in each case.
ANOTHER "MURDER FARM" LIKE THAT OP MRS. gunness rbuxi) ijy hoy WHO PARADES WITH SKL'LL. (United I'rrm Leased Wire.) Snn Bernardino, Cal., June 17. Great excitement prevails hero to
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · 13 May 1908
The Alaska Prospector · Valdez, Alaska
Authorities investigating the farm fire discover letters indicating Belle Gunness lured at least twelve men through matrimonial ads, demanding $1,000 deposits before murdering them. Ray Lamphere, her alleged accomplice, is under arrest on suspicion of killing her and her children to protect himself.
The dramatists are pretty slow this time. None of them has as yet, so far a.i we know, put Mrs. Gunness on the stage. Mrs. Sage, it is announced, may give
Clipping to come
The Alaska Prospector · Valdez, Alaska
The report details investigators' belief that a man, identified as Ray Lamphere, must have helped Belle Gunness dispose of bodies on her farm, as a woman alone could not have moved them. It states authorities now have enough evidence to charge Lamphere with the murders of Gunness, her children, and several victims.
The Alaska Prospector · 14 May 1908 · page 4
If Mis. Gunness was or is a reincar nation of Kate Bender she has outdone the ghastly achievements of her former life. Of the Bender family’s known victims there were only sevenThe tally of the Gunness woman’s crimes may never be made up, but it already has surpassed that of the Benders’ butcheries. The parallelism of the two affairs is otherwise remarkable. The circumstances of the earlier were as follows: In 1871 a family of four came over from Germany and opened a small store on the country road which runs from Independence, Kan., to the Osage mission.
See moreSee less
The members of the family were father, called both William and John; his wife; their son, John; and their daughter, Kate, a girl of 25, who claimed to be a spirit medium. It was through the machinery of spiritualistic seances that the crimes were commit ted. The victim was seated in the usual dark room with his head against a curtain. One of the Benders, stand ing behind the curtain, then struck him over the head with a hammer. After wards, to make certain, the victim’s throat was cut, he was stripped of his valuables, and was buried at night. Dis covery came May 4, 1873, through the disappearance of Dr. William H. York, whose brother traced him as far as the Benders’ store. Unable to follow the trail beyond, the brother returned to the Benders’ place and there caught sight of something that had belonged to Dr. York. As a result of these sus picious circumstances an investigation began, but measures were not taken, so far as is known, to detain the Benders, who disappeared and never were heard of again. There was a rumor that the Kansas farmers of Labette county lynched them, but it is wholly unsup ported by evidence and therefore is almost certainly untrue. The crimes of the Benders were the wonder of a gen eration and the name of Kate Bender especially occupies a terrible eminence in the history of crime. Yet if the evi dence in the Laporte affair is not mod ified or in part belied the case of Mrs. Gunness is more singular and horrific. The Benders had the moral (or im moral) support of one another —the ter rible relief which comes to those who share a fatal secret. Mrs. Gunness may have had an accomplice in Lamphere or another, but that has not yet been established, and it is not improbable that many if not most of her crimes were committed by her alone. In any event she achieved a terrible immor tality, leaving a name at which the world may well grow pale. The possi bilities of the human soul seem infinite in evil as in good.
Clipping to come
Woodruff County News · McCrory, Ark.
An estimated 15,000 sightseers visited the Gunness farm on Sunday, overwhelming the town's transportation and accommodations while investigation work was effectively halted. A Chicago man, Olaf Londoe, provided information suggesting his missing brother Thomas may have been one of Gunness's victims after corresponding with her about marriage plans.
Woodruff County News · 14 May 1908 · page 4
15,000 AT GUNNESS FARM.
FATHER A GUNNESS VICTIM. Chippewa Falls Woman Believes Par. ent Murdered. Chippewa. Falls. Wis., June 14. —. Mrs. Ole S. Remol yesterday after noon received back from the postmas
Clipping to come
Woodruff County News · McCrory, Ark.
Thousands of visitors overwhelmed the Gunness farm investigation, with some seeking information about missing relatives potentially among the unidentified victims. Sheriff Smulzer plans to sift through ashes for gold dental fillings, while the defense pursues a theory that Mrs. Gunness staged her own death using a substitute body.
Woodruff County News · 14 May 1908 · page 4
15,000 AT GUNNESS FARM.
To Bury Qunness Bodies. Laporte, Ind., June 17.—The bodies of Mrs. Bella Gunness and four chhll dren, who lost their lives in the de struction of the Gunness house on April 28, were Thursday ordered by Coroner Mack turned over to the pub lic executor who has arranged for shipment of the bodies to Chicago for burial Thursday la Forest Home cemetery.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
Ray Lamphere denies confessing to anyone about the Gunness murders while authorities continue sifting debris from the burned farmhouse. Coroner Mack has released findings on most bodies, though several victims including John Moe and Ole Budsberg remain unidentified with certainty.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 14 May 1908 · page 1
AT T t rr mony Together. i.a, Porte, I ml., May 13,—Mrs Guin ness’ hired man, Ray Lamphere, vigor ously denied today that he had made ail}’ confession or promise to Rev. E. i A. Schell o;- any one •dsn Lamphere . ; und'V arrest, here charged with com plicity in the wholesale murders a:
Coroner Mack releases identification findings on most bodies from the Gunness fire while others remain unidentified. Rev. Schell will be the key witness against Ray Lamphere, and a house mover's tip about freshly dug earth prompts police to resume digging for more bodies.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 14 May 1908 · page 1
REV. SCHELL CHIEF WITNESS
Schell, the .Methodist minister who gave out an interview at Haliimore | yesterday that Hay l.anipliere liaci j confessed to him in connection with i the burning of the home of Mrs. llelle Gunness, murderess of sixteen per-!
A tenth body was found at the Gunness farm, and new evidence—including a trunk of letters from Belle Gunness to Ray Lamphere and found rings—strengthens the first-degree murder case against him. The letters show Gunness urged Lamphere to return to the farm, possibly bringing another woman.
The Nevada County Picayune · 14 May 1908 · page 2
THE DEATH ROLL OF THE GUNNESS FARM NOW NUMBERS TEN.
ASKS FOR MONEY Counsel for Ray Lamphere Wants Mrs. Gunness Captured. IS THE WOMAN DEAD? Laporte, Ind., June 20. The asser tion of David Hickens of Delafield,
Clipping to come
The Nevada County Picayune · Prescott, Ark.
Lamphere requested his attorney retrieve a trunk left at the Wheatbrook farm, but local authorities confiscated it first, finding letters from Mrs. Gunness urging him to return and bring his sweetheart, plus several women's rings. Tensions among investigators and private detectives were also reported amid the ongoing probe.
The Nevada County Picayune · 14 May 1908 · page 2
NET CLOSING ON LAMPHERE
Smitzer that Frank Riedinger, cata logued victim of the Gunness house, was alive and living at Lincoln, Neb!? was today established as untrue, thus confirming the belief that Riedinger met his fate when he came here to marry the woman. Attorney H. W. Worden, counsel for Ray Lamphere, is preparing a state ment today which he will issue to the public asking for contributions to the fund for finding Mrs. Gunness. The defense hopes for a reward fund which will be iarger than any issued in the United States for the apprehension' of a person guilty of crime. With the state scouting the idea that Mrs. Gunness is alive and the defense declaring they will prove she is alive public opinion is about equahy divided.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
La Porte officials deny that a minister revealed details of a confession from Ray Lamphere, and Lamphere's attorney insists his client has made no confession and has nothing to confess. A letter from Cleveland describes a stranger showing a photograph of Belle Gunness while trying to lure the writer to visit her, suggesting she had an accomplice.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
DEVELOPMENTS IN LA PORTE TRAGEDY
Smitzer that Frank Riedinger, cata logued victim of the Gunness house, was alive and living at Lincoln, Neb!? was today established as untrue, thus confirming the belief that Riedinger met his fate when he came here to marry the woman. Attorney H. W. Worden, counsel for Ray Lamphere, is preparing a state ment today which he will issue to the public asking for contributions to the fund for finding Mrs. Gunness. The defense hopes for a reward fund which will be iarger than any issued in the United States for the apprehension' of a person guilty of crime. With the state scouting the idea that Mrs. Gunness is alive and the defense declaring they will prove she is alive public opinion is about equahy divided.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A Cleveland letter described a stranger showing a photograph of a woman resembling Mrs. Gunness, while a store clerk testified Gunness feared Lamphere would burn her farmhouse. Meanwhile, sluicing of the cellar ashes yielded fused metal possibly containing gold, and a threatening letter warned officials to stop searching for Mrs. Gunness.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS FEARED HIM
STILL LIVING. Laporte, Ind., June 20. Coroner Mack has received from Dr. Walter Haynes of Rush Medical college, Chi cago, Information to the effect that he had found in his examination of the stomach of Andrew Helgelein, of Ab erdeen, S. D., whose dismembered body was found buried with nine oth ers on the farm of Mrs. Bella Gunness traces of both arsenic and strichnine. Dr, Haynes will make a formal and de tailed report In a few cays. The finding of the traces of poison in the stomach gives the first authen tic information on the manner in which Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness disposed of her victims. Attorney H. W. Worden, who is looking after the defense of Ray Lam phere. charged with the murder of Mrs. Bella Gunness. her three children and Andrew Helgelein, is very much wrought up over the attitude of the county officials in the Gunness case, and has made a public appeal to the citizens to come to the rescue of the defense by signing notes to be paid in the event of the apprehension of Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
This editorial describes the Gunness farm case as still shrouded in mystery, noting that 14 bodies were found in the burned house and yard but it remains unknown if Belle Gunness is alive or dead. It emphasizes that until investigations are complete, no one can say whether La Porte has witnessed a horror or merely a strange disappearance.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 4
Orchard’s La Porte Rival La Porte, in northern Indiana, is a pretty town of about 10,000 people, near Chicago, and the farm of the Widow Gunness is located about a
A column of witty one-line observations on current events lists Belle Gunness among other newsmakers, joking that she wanted to be 'let alone' like corporate magnates. It references the grim excavation at the Gunness farm, calling the unearthed remains 'the ghastliest crop ever recorded' and comparing the case to Poe's fiction.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 4
Wilbur and Orville Wright continue to fly like birds and they continue to keep secret their methods. Those who refer to Mrs. Gunness as another Lucretia Borgia are slander ing the dead of long ago. The new' Vreeland bill is Currency Bill No. 4, and It is strictly a cam paign measure at that. Minnesota is the only state that
A brief aside speculates that the fashionable 'merry widow' hat was named after the notorious Widow Gunness. It wryly notes the hat is broad enough to 'cover a multitude of crimes,' showing her case had already become fodder for popular jokes.
Arizona Republican · 14 May 1908 · page 2
IE I ATT 0 RXE V CE RTAIN THAT ijSf , MRS. GUNNESS LIVES tvS ' LAPORTE, Tnd.. June 20. n. W. !K j Worden. attorney for Hay Lamphcre, it .indicted for 1 he' murder of Mrs. Gunp , ness, her three children and Andrew ill -JTelgelein, toclav, in a formal statement. ifM jscored the county authorities for their actions, and also" made a public appeal
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
La Porte officials denied that Rev. Schell had disclosed details of Lamphere's conversations to them, while evidence emerged suggesting Belle Gunness had an accomplice in luring victims to her farm. Lamphere's attorney issued a statement denying any confession was ever made by his client.
Arizona Republican · 14 May 1908 · page 7
GUNNESS HAD HELP IN LURING HER VICTIMS
IE I ATT 0 RXE V CE RTAIN THAT ijSf , MRS. GUNNESS LIVES tvS ' LAPORTE, Tnd.. June 20. n. W. !K j Worden. attorney for Hay Lamphcre, it .indicted for 1 he' murder of Mrs. Gunp , ness, her three children and Andrew ill -JTelgelein, toclav, in a formal statement. ifM jscored the county authorities for their actions, and also" made a public appeal
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
La Porte officials, including the coroner, sheriff, and prosecuting attorney, denied that Rev. Dr. T. A. Schell had revealed details of a Lamphere confession implicating an accomplice in the Gunness farm murders. Lamphere's attorney also stated his client never confessed and never would.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Forthcoming. today when Dr. Walter Mayns, o! Hush Medical c I lege, Chicago, re poited Informally to C miner .Mack that he had found traces of arsenic strychnine in th sumach of Andre ,v j' Helgelein, of Ab.-nletm, S. D.. wloso dismembered b dy w.n the list if the 10 found alter the fire which, it is shippi.se.l, caused tiie death of Mrs. (innnens and her three children. A to.--mal report will lie made later. II. W. Wordrn, attorney for Rav Lampht-ro. indicted for the murder of Mrs. dullness, her children aid An drew Helgelein. today, in a f, rial
Clipping to come
The Elk Mountain Pilot (Irwin, Colo.) · Ruby Camp
Coroner Mack unearths a sixth body in the Gunness yard, bringing the count to eleven victims, with bone fragments suggesting a possible thirteenth. Ray Lamphere, under arrest, claims Belle Gunness was the mastermind of the killings, while police suspect he was her accomplice who killed her and burned the house.
The Elk Mountain Pilot (Irwin, Colo.) · 14 May 1908 · page 2
DEATH HOUSE AT LA PORTE MISSING WOMAN BELIEVED TO HAVE BEEN GUILTY OF MANY MURDERS MORE BODIES FOUND SUSPECTED MURDERERS MAY NOT HAVE BEEN BURNED AS WAS THOUGHT
Forthcoming. today when Dr. Walter Mayns, o! Hush Medical c I lege, Chicago, re poited Informally to C miner .Mack that he had found traces of arsenic strychnine in th sumach of Andre ,v j' Helgelein, of Ab.-nletm, S. D.. wloso dismembered b dy w.n the list if the 10 found alter the fire which, it is shippi.se.l, caused tiie death of Mrs. (innnens and her three children. A to.--mal report will lie made later. II. W. Wordrn, attorney for Rav Lampht-ro. indicted for the murder of Mrs. dullness, her children aid An drew Helgelein. today, in a f, rial
Clipping to come
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn.
Investigators digging on Gunness's farm have found ten bodies and now suspect she may have faked her own death by substituting a headless corpse, possibly stolen from a nearby cemetery. The report also recounts her background as a Norwegian immigrant whose first husband died suddenly in 1890.
Connecticut Western News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
HER OWN DEATH REPORTED
Way toAll Victims. Lnporte, Ind., May 13. The Interest In the case of Mrs. Belle Gunness, on whose farm ten bodies -were dug up. centers in the possibility of Identifying one of the bodies as her own. She Is believed to have murdered the others, among them her own three young chil dren. Digging still continues on the farjn. There la now a . suspicion Mrs. Qun ness may not have died In the fire which destroyed the farmhouse , on April 28. Doubt exists over the head less body of a woman found in the ruins, and it is thought Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness may have had a body brought here from Chicago and after firing the house made her own escape. She is believed to have enticed men with matrimonial advertisements and then to have rob bed and murdered them. It was discovered that a seldom vis ited cemetery a few miles away from her farm had recently been robbed of a body. A laborer passing through It found a disturbed grave and an empty coflln. Chief of Tolice Cochran and two detectives are investigating.' , They heard, though not authoritative ly, that it was xl woman's body which had been stolen. If this proves to be so, they anil many others firmly be lieve the first theory that Mrs. Gun ness left a corpse without a head to impersonate her while she fled after the house was fired.
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · and 1 other paper
Police investigate a robbed grave near the farm, suspecting Belle Gunness used a stolen female corpse to fake her own death in the fire. The report also recounts her background as a Norwegian immigrant and details the suspicious deaths of her two husbands and the growing count of victims found on her property.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 14 May 1908 · page 2
HER OWN DEATH REPORTED
CHEMIST FINDS POISON. -Proof of How Mrs. Gunness Disposed of Her Victims. Laporte, Ind., June 22.—The first positive information on the manner In which Mrs. Bella Gunness disposed of
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · 14 May 1908
Connecticut Western News · Salisbury, Conn. · and 1 other paper
An investigation into the Gunness farm murders finds that all ten victims were killed by spike blows to the back of the skull. Two bodies are tentatively identified as Jennie Olson and Andrew Helgelein, though a doctor's autopsy findings cast doubt on the Helgelein identification, while suspect Roy Lamphere is questioned but offers no new evidence.
Connecticut Western News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Roy Lamphere, who Is held on a charge of first degree murder as a re sult of the fire that destroyed the Gun ness home and caused the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, gave no new evidence despite repeated questionings. Ralph W. Smith, prose cuting attorney, asserted that a con fession is not necessary, so far as Lamphere is concerned. "We have evidence In the shape of Jetters con necting Lamphere with alleged mur ders at the Gunness farm," he said. The exact nature of these letters was carefully guarded by Mr. Smith. Lamphttv tells a weird story about a DIGGING JJPGORPSEi Indiana Woman's Farm Yields
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J. · 14 May 1908
Paper unidentified
Officials in La Porte report little progress identifying the four bodies found in the burned Gunness farmhouse ruins, with the charred woman's identity as Belle Gunness still unconfirmed despite attempts to match rings to her. The prosecutor received anonymous threatening letters warning him to stop the search, while investigators also tried to trace a watch found on suspect Ray Lamphere.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 9
OFFICIALS BALKED
Mrs. Ole S. Remol of Chippewa county has received back from the postmaster* at West by and Blooming ton letters which she had written to her father, Christian Headkleve, with the statement that he had not been there. This leads her to give up hope that be is alive, and she fears be has been murdered by Mrs. Gunness. After being lost to family and friends for 14 years, P. Adams, aged 7k years, once a prosperous manu facturer of Hokah, Minn., has been discovered in the lui Crosse county poorhouse. His daughter, Mrs, Wall of Chicago, upon hearing of her father's predicament, took her aged parent home with her.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Efforts to identify rings found on burned corpses from the Gunness ruins continue without success, with a laborer unable to confirm diamond rings though he recalled similar band rings. Threatening letters arrived at the prosecutor's office, and officials attempted to trace a watch found on suspect Ray Lamphere, which he claimed was a gift from Mrs. Gunness.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 9
BODY STILL UNIDENTIFIED
Mrs. Ole S. Remol of Chippewa county has received back from the postmaster* at West by and Blooming ton letters which she had written to her father, Christian Headkleve, with the statement that he had not been there. This leads her to give up hope that be is alive, and she fears be has been murdered by Mrs. Gunness. After being lost to family and friends for 14 years, P. Adams, aged 7k years, once a prosperous manu facturer of Hokah, Minn., has been discovered in the lui Crosse county poorhouse. His daughter, Mrs, Wall of Chicago, upon hearing of her father's predicament, took her aged parent home with her.
Clipping to come
The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.
A Hobart deputy sheriff says he saw a speeding automobile carrying a man and a woman resembling Belle Gunness heading toward Chicago on the morning of the fire. Separately, Sheriff Smutzer received a letter from a 'John Williamson' claiming to know Gunness's whereabouts and offering to turn her in for a $5,000 reward.
The New Haven Union · 14 May 1908 · page 5
FLED IN AUTOMOBILE
II THE AT PIE MRS. GUNNESS The Famed Bluebeard of LaPorte, Indiana, at the Keylor Grand, Friday, Saturday and Sunday. A picture that is fresh in the minds of everyone. The first time this picture lias ever been shown to the public. * REFINED VAUDEVILLE AND MOVING PICTURES TEN and TWENTY CENTS THREE SHOWS DAILY
State Attorney Ralph Smith declares Ray Lamphere will hang for either the murder of Belle Gunness or farmhand Andrew Helgelein. Lamphere, under further interrogation, reportedly admitted walking in on Mrs. Gunness dismembering Helgelein's body, and identification of the headless corpse as hers was bolstered by his recognition of her rings.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 7
II THE AT PIE MRS. GUNNESS The Famed Bluebeard of LaPorte, Indiana, at the Keylor Grand, Friday, Saturday and Sunday. A picture that is fresh in the minds of everyone. The first time this picture lias ever been shown to the public. * REFINED VAUDEVILLE AND MOVING PICTURES TEN and TWENTY CENTS THREE SHOWS DAILY
Clipping to come
Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut · and 1 other paper
Deputy Sheriff Anstiss reports Lamphere admitted walking in on Mrs. Gunness as she dismembered Helgelein's body, and Lamphere identifies rings on the headless corpse as hers. A letter from a Cleveland man describing a matrimonial-bureau solicitor fuels the theory that Gunness had an accomplice and that more victims may be buried at the farm.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 7
Kt of their wheat now to be able to end some of it In Improving the coun ty roads. Mrs. Gunness said she was an ex cellent cook. She was also a pretty fair hand at butchering. If appear ances are net deceitful. A Los Angeles woman was In a (ranee for 81 days. Some women will Mort to anything to arold doing their Ebar of the house-cleaning. If Mrs. Gunnesa Is alive and baa noted that the newspapcra are calling
A man from Cleveland wrote to authorities describing a suspicious encounter with another man who tried to arrange for him to meet a woman with a ranch near Laporte, offering to pay travel fare. He included a photograph that was identified as Belle Gunness, and he came forward after reading news of the murders, also noting her estate was nearly depleted of the $3,000 taken from a victim.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 7
Kt of their wheat now to be able to end some of it In Improving the coun ty roads. Mrs. Gunness said she was an ex cellent cook. She was also a pretty fair hand at butchering. If appear ances are net deceitful. A Los Angeles woman was In a (ranee for 81 days. Some women will Mort to anything to arold doing their Ebar of the house-cleaning. If Mrs. Gunnesa Is alive and baa noted that the newspapcra are calling
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
La Porte officials and Lamphere's attorney deny reports that he confessed to a minister, with the attorney insisting there is nothing to confess. Meanwhile, gold tooth fillings believed to belong to Mrs. Gunness are found in the farm ashes, and only one body (possibly Ole Budsberg) has been positively identified, though evidence increasingly points to John Moe and Henry Gerholt as victims.
The San Francisco Call · 14 May 1908 · page 9
DENY CONFESSION IN GUNNESS CASE
LA PORTE, Ind., May 13.— Denials by La Porte offlclals that Rev. T. A. Fchell had revealed to them the sub stance of his conversations with Lam phere and the discovery of evidence that Mrs. Bella Gunness was aided by an accomplice in luring her victims to the farm were the chief developments in the case today. • In addition, H. W. Worden, attorney for the prisoner, Issued a formal state ment that he had given his client strict instructions not to discuss the charges against him and concluding: "The fact Is that Lamphere has never made a confession to any one and never will.
See moreSee less
He has nothing to confess." Sheriff Smulter is authority for the statement that several more globules of gold have been panned out by Louis Schultz. the miner who Is sluicing the ashes on tho Gunness farm. The sher iff is certain that the discoveries are portions of gold filling from the teeth of Jtfrs. Gnnness.
Investigators report gold dental fillings found in sluiced ashes, likely from Mrs. Gunness herself, while Coroner Mack confirms identification of Ole Budsberg's body and near-certain links to John Moe and Henry Gerholt via banking records. A La Porte pastor also voices his personal belief that Mrs. Gunness may still be alive.
The San Francisco Call · 14 May 1908 · page 9
of gold have been panned out by Louis Schultz. the miner who Is sluicing the ashes on tho Gunness farm. The sher iff is certain that the discoveries are portions of gold filling from the teeth of Jtfrs. Gnnness. OXLV BODY IDENTIFIED Coroner Mack has received and made public the results of his investigations on all the known bodies except that supposed to have been Ole Budsberg of lola, Wis. None of the other bodies has been Identified to any degree and it is scarcely likely that they will be. Testerday three persons were con nected with the Gunness woman, the j evidence regarding John Moe of Elbow < Lake, Minn., and Henry Gerholt of Scandinavia.
See moreSee less
Wis..' being almost con clusive. The fate of George Brady of Tuscola. 111., Is less certain. Moe was traced to the farm by means of the banking transactions which pre ceded his visit. The facts were shown startlingly similar to those brought Ito light in the cases of Ole Budsberg and Andrew Helgelein. Each of the men drew from one of the local banks, and at the desks of the cashiers all the trails ended.
A news summary roundup from the Los Angeles Herald lists brief items from local, eastern, coast, and foreign news. Among them is a one-line note stating that evidence shows Mrs. Gunness had an accomplice in luring victims to their deaths, alongside a mention that a Los Angeles detective captain commented on the Laporte, Ind. murders.
Los Angeles Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
LaPorte officials deny that a minister revealed details of a confession by Ray Lamphere, while Lamphere's own attorney insists his client made no confession at all. Meanwhile, investigators report finding gold fillings believed to be from Mrs. Gunness' teeth and evidence suggesting she had an accomplice in luring victims.
Los Angeles Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
OFFICIALS KNOW NOTHING OF CONFESSION
From the Philadelphia North American. Shocked and horrified beyond ex pression, the world recently read of the atrocious crimes of Mrs. Belle Gun ness, disclosed after the burning of her house when more than a score of bodies and skeletons were found on the isolated farm near Laporte, Ind. In this little necropolis lie the ghasf ly records of almost inconceivable crimes, of murders executed in cold blood because of lust for gain. The name of this murderous ogress of In diana will go down in the annals of crime as one of the most notorious blood-women of time, ranking with Loeusta, Messalina, Lucrezia Borgia.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Coroner Mack has released findings on most bodies except Ole Budsberg, with the four burned bodies now considered fully investigated while other remains are too decomposed to identify. Authorities are tracing additional missing men—John Moe, Henry Ghreit, and George Brady—through bank transactions similar to those of Budsberg and Helgelein, as Prosecutor Smith strengthens the case ahead of Lamphere's trial.
Los Angeles Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
From the Philadelphia North American. Shocked and horrified beyond ex pression, the world recently read of the atrocious crimes of Mrs. Belle Gun ness, disclosed after the burning of her house when more than a score of bodies and skeletons were found on the isolated farm near Laporte, Ind. In this little necropolis lie the ghasf ly records of almost inconceivable crimes, of murders executed in cold blood because of lust for gain. The name of this murderous ogress of In diana will go down in the annals of crime as one of the most notorious blood-women of time, ranking with Loeusta, Messalina, Lucrezia Borgia.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Dr. Schell denies that Lamphere made any confession to him beyond details about the Helgelein killing, insisting their conversation was privileged. He also shares his personal, unconfirmed belief that Mrs. Gunness may still be alive, while describing Lamphere's troubled background and reputation.
Los Angeles Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
2 GOLD GLOBULES MAY BE FILLINGS OFFICIALS KNOW NOTHING OF CONFESSION LAMPHERE'S ATTORNEY DENIES HE MADE STATEMENT
'.Continued from race One) ness children but had no pari in the slaying of any man except Helgelelu. "I have, made no statement regarding this or any other detail of my Interview with Lamphere except that Lamphere's communications to me were wholly privileged, and unless ho shall himself make statements to Prosecutor Smith, they will be maintained as an inviola ble secret." Dr. Schell added that, like many oth ers, he behoved that .Mrs. Gunnesa was alive, but that he had no knowledge of the fact. It was merely his personal opinion.
See moreSee less
Speaking further concerning the case, Dr. Schell said: "Mrs. linn ness, as I stated yesterday, was nil at tractive woman In her way. She dressed richly, and even you might say in good taste, but her manner of talking and her speech Itself—her vagaries of gram mar—betrayed a low origin. She could best be described as 'Mrs. New-Rich.' "Lamphere is a man who drinks hard and has borne an unpleasant reputa tion. He was the son of a drunkard. and a. man to be pitied because of his ancestry and training, or lack of it. On two or three occasions recently he has come into town with a roll of bills, which he has generally managed to get rid of In a day or a. night. Some time ago I constituted myself a sort of civic league and went after certain saloon keepers in the town who violated the law, and I found a slot machine run ning in one of them in which Lamphere had lost $60 a night or two before. They say he lost it playing the ma chine, but the suspicion is that he Rot drunk and was relieved of his money. Lamphere sent for me and told me his story, and that is how I got mixed up in the case. Despite the advice of his lawyers. I believe lie will tell the whole truth when he goes on the witness Stand. I did not know personally any of i the supposed victims of Mrs. Gun ness. Jennie Olson, I am told, came to our Sunday school once or twice, but I never met her. I have seen the man Helgeleln. He was a big fellow, but I did not know him personally." "The house in which Mrs. Gunness lived had borne a bad name for years as a house of crime, and twenty years ago as a place of resort for the gilded ye th of. Chicago, which was only fif ty -'nine miles away, and for some men of wealth and prominence who were not exactly youths. When tic woman who ran it sold out another took it up, and ii became a disreputable house of the i Reaper grade. "Three years ago when Mrs. Gunness came from Boston and bought the house people thought its character would change, because at that time she was looked upon as entirely respect able. The place was a rather imposing one, for the neighborhood, the house being worth $7000 or $8000 and the farm containing seventy-five acres."
Dr. Schell gives his personal impressions of Mrs. Gunness as a flashy 'new-rich' woman and Lamphere as a hard-drinking man of poor upbringing who recently lost money at a saloon slot machine. He also recounts the house's long history as a disreputable establishment before and after Gunness purchased it.
Los Angeles Captain of Detectives Paul Flammer writes an opinion piece analyzing the Gunness 'house of horrors' case, musing on whether a woman could be capable of such brutal murders. He suggests Belle Gunness likely had accomplices and characterizes Ray Lamphere as a weak-minded tool.
Los Angeles Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
GIVES VIEWS OF GUNNESS CRIMES
well in hand. So it is with the Gunness case. This case presents many remarkable features; some of them almost un believable. The first question which occurs to the mind is whether it is possible for a woman to be of such a nature that she can commit such brutal murders us have been brought to light by in vestigations in the so-called "house of horrors." Women Worst Murderers A •glance into history will show such a tiling is possible. In fact some of the most grewsome murders in the history of crime .have been committed by women.
See moreSee less
In many instances the murderers have been intelligent, beau tiful, accomplished members of the feminine gender, who, to their friends and acquaintances, appeared to be fe line,!, gentle women. Another thing, many of these wo men have used loving glances, words and actions to draw their victims to them. Judging from the reports I have read Of the Gunness murders the Indiana woman followed this method in entic
A man named Fred Hafle sent police a letter describing how a stranger tried to recruit him to visit a rich widow's farm in La Porte, enclosing a photograph that police confirmed was Mrs. Gunness. The letter is presented as the first solid evidence that Gunness had an accomplice helping lure victims to her farm.
New-York Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 4
MURDERESS HAD AGENT
Court Justice Mills at White Plains to-morrow. ———- One man was killed and twenty persons were injured by 2 rajlway wreck near Hazleton, Penn. caused by the spiking of the track. — = The Detroit police say that Mrs. Gunness, the alleged wholesale murderer of La Porte, Ind. has heen seen recently alive. ——— The gacbag of a balloon in which two women and three men made an ascent from Philadephia split and the passengers narrowiy escaped death in the
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A letter from Fred Hafle of Cleveland to La Porte police describes a man who tried to persuade him to visit Mrs. Gunness, posing as an agent for a rich widow seeking a husband. Police consider this the first solid evidence that Gunness had accomplices recruiting victims.
New-York Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 4
MURDERESS HAD AGENT
Court Justice Mills at White Plains to-morrow. ———- One man was killed and twenty persons were injured by 2 rajlway wreck near Hazleton, Penn. caused by the spiking of the track. — = The Detroit police say that Mrs. Gunness, the alleged wholesale murderer of La Porte, Ind. has heen seen recently alive. ——— The gacbag of a balloon in which two women and three men made an ascent from Philadephia split and the passengers narrowiy escaped death in the
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A Cleveland man describes being approached by a man who tried to recruit him to meet a wealthy widow in La Porte, later recognizing her photo as Mrs. Gunness. The report also covers gold dental fillings found in the farm's ashes and ongoing efforts to trace missing men linked to the case.
New-York Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 4
MURDERESS HAD AGENT
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
The sheriff's office receives numerous letters from across the country inquiring about missing relatives possibly connected to the Gunness murders. Photographs and trinkets found on a charred hand are claimed to match jewelry worn by the Norwegian woman, but Lamphere's attorneys still doubt she is dead, and even the dentist's earlier identification of a gold crown tooth is now in question.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
SCORES OF LETTERS TO GUNNESS MURDERESS - RINGS ON CORPSE IDENTIFIED
MRS. LIVES Two young women w'ho gave their names as Lulu Raymond, of No. 48 Columbia-st west and Grate Henson, whose address was not learned, were taken to police headquarters by De tectlves Wilson and Black, to explain their statements that they know the arch-murderess, Mrs. Belle Dullness, of Laporte. Ind.. is still alive. They were released Friday night, after a session with Capt. Baker. The police say they obtained valuable Informs tlon which may prove Mrs. Gunness did not perlßh In the flames when her home burned.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Despite Lamphere's attorneys and others doubting Mrs. Gunness is dead, physicians examined rings on the corpse's fingers under a microscope and matched them to rings in her photograph, affirming her identity. Pinkerton detectives were dispatched to Oklahoma to find a man who may know of Gunness's criminal past, and her estate inventory was filed showing modest assets.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
ASTOLD BELFRY AT LEXINGTON. Bodies of Mrg. Gunness and Tliree Children Taken to Chicago. ' Chicago, Special. The bodies of ed l p?rte nre victims were receiv
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A letter sent to Police Chief Cochrane from a Cleveland man describes being approached by a well-dressed stranger who tried to connect him with a rich widow in Laporte, showing him a picture later identified as Mrs. Gunness. Following this, authorities discovered an agent had been collecting mail for Gunness under her own name and two aliases at post offices in Chicago, Peru, Champaign, and Warsaw, Indiana.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
ASTOLD BELFRY AT LEXINGTON. Bodies of Mrg. Gunness and Tliree Children Taken to Chicago. ' Chicago, Special. The bodies of ed l p?rte nre victims were receiv
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Sheriff Smutzer receives numerous letters from across the country asking about relatives feared to be among Gunness's victims. Meanwhile forensic examination of rings found on the charred corpse match those worn by Mrs. Gunness in a photograph, though a supposed gold tooth has now been identified as gilding from a picture frame, fueling continued doubts from Lamphere's attorneys that she is dead.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
SCORES OF LETTERS TO GUNNESS HOME
The inurder farm ruu at Lnporte. Ina'.. by Mrs. Belle Gunness, or Guin ness, recalls a similar place, the Ben der f:irui. lu Montgomery county, Kan. The Mender family consisted of old
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Doubts persist about whether the body is Mrs. Gunness after a supposed gold tooth is retracted, but physicians confirm identification by matching rings under a microscope. Detectives pursue Andrew Helgelien's criminal record, a key witness in Oklahoma, and a matrimonial scheme letter describing how victims were lured to Laporte.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
RINGS ON CORPSE IDENTIFIED
their capture. Like the Benders. Mrs. Gunness bur led her victims In the yard near her house. They Included two men she had married, her three children and other men and women lured to the i farm and murdered or slain In Chica
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A letter reveals a mysterious agent recruiting lonely men for the 'rich widow' Mrs. Gunness through matrimonial ads, using aliases to collect mail in several towns. A newsboy also positively identifies Ray Lamphere as the man seen fleeing the Gunness property before the fatal fire.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
FRIDAY NIGHT The Female Blue Beard, Mrs. Gunness Admission 5 Cents THEATORIUM CHANGE OF PROGRAM TONIGHT THE MAN IN THE OVERALLS. A Fine Show. A GOOD ILLUSTRATED SONG.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A satirical miscellany column collects wry commentary on various news items, including one line joking that "Mrs. Gunness certainly had 'killing' ways." It treats her case as already widely known enough to be fodder for a pun among unrelated jokes about politics and society.
The Washington Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 6
FRIDAY NIGHT The Female Blue Beard, Mrs. Gunness Admission 5 Cents THEATORIUM CHANGE OF PROGRAM TONIGHT THE MAN IN THE OVERALLS. A Fine Show. A GOOD ILLUSTRATED SONG.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Officials investigating the LaPorte, Indiana tragedy are testing bits of gold found in the fire ruins to determine if they are dental fillings or crowns, which could help identify victims. The case has reached a stage focused on technical evidence as authorities work to clear or implicate Lamphere, while being flooded with mostly unhelpful inquiries from people seeking missing relatives among the Gunness victims.
Evening Star · 14 May 1908 · page 11
THE LAPORTE TRAGEDY
Dr. I. J. Norton, who pronounced the bit of gilded picture framing, said yes terday that gold of the fineness used by dentists always bubbles into globules under a fusing heat, and the specimens in questions are supposed to have been in the hottest part of the ruined Gunness home for twelve or more hours. The mystery has reached a stage where the determination of such facts is of major importance. The discovery of ad ditional bodies is a remote possibility and the identification of any of the seven cadavers remaining unmarked is even more distantly to be expected.
Authorities remain overwhelmed with unverifiable inquiries about missing persons as identification of remaining corpses stalls. Lamphere's attorneys are searching for a witness, David Havens, whose testimony about the bodies' position in the cellar might support their claim the victims were placed there before the fire, though this is disputed by the sheriff and other witnesses.
Evening Star · 14 May 1908 · page 11
TRYING TO CLEAR LAMPHERE
Laporte are powerless to give the aid sought or to satisfy the demands of their official consciences. Unsolved Problems. Yesterday's developments did little to elucidate the unsolved problems arising
A letter from a Milwaukee man named John Williamson claims he knows where Belle Gunness is and will turn her in for a $5000 reward within three days. The report also notes a possible sighting of her in an automobile near Hobart, Indiana, on the morning of the fire, while Lamphere's attorney claims witnesses have been spirited away.
The Washington Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
$5000 DEMANDS FOR MRS. GUNNESS
Prison Sentence. Laporte, Ind., July 11. The woman ibelleved by the sheriff at Hillsdale, I Mich., to be Mrs. Belle Gunness. was found to be a fortune teller named Nellie Williams. Tho resemblance to the murderess was unusual. Deputy ;Hnerui Anstiss, wno was assigned to identify the woman, declares that for a few moments he was positive he had located Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Deputy Sheriff Gill claims a man and woman resembling Belle Gunness were seen speeding through Hobart in an automobile the morning of the fire, heading toward Chicago. Meanwhile, defense attorney Worden alleges Sheriff Smutzer spirited away a defense witness, David Havens, and authorities continue investigating a letter describing a male accomplice.
The Washington Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
SEEN IN AUTO
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Authorities are investigating a letter to Cleveland's police chief about a man's operations and are searching Indiana towns for traces of him. State's Attorney Smith received two threatening letters signed 'X,' one claiming Belle Gunness is alive and hiding in Brooklyn with the writer, and that Lamphere did not start the fire.
The Washington Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
I | WHO KILLED ARCH-MURDER m BBS ON PRAIRIE. EyCHJCAQO. July IS. — That the la |c famous Bender family, of Kanban, who, fllkt Mr*. Belie Gunness. murdered
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A Milwaukee man claims he can produce Mrs. Gunness alive for a $5,000 reward, while a Hobart deputy reports seeing a woman resembling her speeding away by automobile the morning of the fire. Meanwhile, Lamphere's attorney accuses the sheriff of spiriting away a defense witness who helped recover the bodies.
The Washington Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
DEMANDS $5,000 FOR MRS. GUNNESS
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A Hobart deputy sheriff claims he saw Belle Gunness speeding away in a car hours after the fire, despite evidence she died in it. Meanwhile, Lamphere's attorney alleges a key witness was spirited out of town, and authorities search for a male accomplice named in a mysterious letter while threatening notes arrive from Brooklyn.
The Washington Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Marietta Journal · Marietta, Georgia
The item reports that a 'farm of corpses' has been unearthed at La Porte, Indiana, on property owned by Mrs. Belle Gunness, who along with her three children was allegedly murdered and her house burned. It claims robbery was the motive, some victims were shipped from Chicago in trunks, and a hired man is jailed as a suspect in her murder.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Marietta Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 4
— If you don’t argue politics you will feel a heap better. Try it. Judging from the number of straw ballots being taken, it would look like “straw’’ would soon be exhausted. Congressman Livingeton carried Rock- | dale county last Friday. It looks as if Lon will be re-nominated. Coweta county now has a Joe Brown club of nearly 1,500. And Joe goes marching on to vietory. Atlanta’s spirit is being displayed, and the burned block will be replaced by a better one. Dr. W. F. Goldinjhas withdrawn from the congressional race, leaving Hon, Gordon Lee without opposition, | \ Hon.
See moreSee less
Gordon Lee has no opposition for re-election to Congress. This is well. He deserves to go in without op position. Politics, as conducted by some candi dates, are about the most demoralizing and hurtful thing that this country has to contend against. Ex-Congressman Moses, of Coweta, made speeches at Bainbridge and Way- | cross last week for Hon. Joseph M. Brown. Misrepresentations, abuse and other dirty methods ought to be elimnated from polities. Lot the good people dis eountenance such methods.—Cuthbert Leader. Inman & Co., cotton dealers, of Au gusta, are in the hands of a receiver; liabilities, $1,500,000. The firm is com posed of F. M, McGowan and J. R. Gray, of Atlanta. Seeley, of the Atlanta Georgian, is a good one, He speaks with words of wisdom, and is giving the people one of the best, cleanest and newsiest papers in the State. May the Georgian con tinue to prosper. No matter who is elected, whether you are on the winning side or not, it will be a sweet relief to know that the election is over. Speed the fourth of el Mr, Seely, of the Atlants Georgian, says it is a ‘‘qualification”’ and not a ‘‘disfranchisement,”” The white man as well as the negro has to comply with the qualificatious or not be able to vote. It is said after next March 4th Presi dent Roosevelt will take a two years’ vacation, going to Africa and engage in hunting. This will be sad news to those who insist on President Roosevelt standing for re-election. The Walker P. Inman estate, valued at $4,000,000, has been put in the hands of a receiver. Forrest Adair is the re ceiver. James R. Gray and Mrs. Morris Brandon, executors are enjoined from interfering with the receiver. Tennessee has a red hot fight on for Governor. Carmarck candidate for state prohibition and Patterson for local option. We are hoping for Carmareck’s election. We want to see old ‘'booze”’ knocked out of Chattanooga. And =0 it goes. Joe Brown is now preventing Gov. Hoke Smith from at tending the Roosevelt conference of governors.—Augusta Chronicle. He is also preventing Hoke from staying in his office and enjoying the ne Hetty Green, the richest woman in the world, has quit her $4.00 per week apartments in a flat, and is now at the Plaza Hotel, New York, paying $3OO per month for rooms and $lO per day for meals for herseif and daughter. The daughter is to marry an Astor, is the cause of this sudden stylish living. At twenty-one a man starts out tore form the world; at thirty he has his doubts about it; at forty he decides that the world can’t be reformed; at fifty he is busy hanging on by his eye brows and letting the world reform him.—Piedmont (Ala.) Journal, Hope you have no reference to the Georgia gubernatorial race. The Pied ment bar has been closed by the pro hibitionists of Georgia. A farm of corpses have been un earthed at La Porte, Indiana, being the farm owned by the supposed murderess, Mrs. Bella Gunness, who with her three children were also murdered by some one and her house burned. Great ex citement prevails there. Adozen hodies have been dug up in the yard and farm. Some of the victims were shipped in trunks from Chicago to Mrs. Gunness, and she buried them. Robbery was the incentive to this bloody work, A hired man is in jail as an accomplice and ag being the murderer of Mrs. Gun ness and children, because she didn’y keep him supplied with money.
The Gunness death farm in La Porte, Indiana continued to produce additional corroborative evidence regarding the extent of the gruesome tragedies that occurred there. The report is truncated, cutting off further details.
Evening Times-Republican · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MORE GUNNESS CLUES
Mrs. Belle Gunness, was given a dose of stryhnine by the woman, according to Dr. Walter W. Haines, of Chicago. He has handed in his formal report of his analysis of the stomach of the ranchman. He concludes his report by saying: “I conclude that there was one and a half grains of the poison in the stomach, a quantity several times over the amount which would have produced death. The amount of arsenic present also was considerable.” Coroner Mack, after reviewing the evi dence in the Helgelein case, renders the folowing verdict: “It is my verdict that the body viewed is that of Andrew K. Helgelein and that he came to his death through felonious homicide and that the per petrator is to me unknown.”
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Ray Lamphere, held for allegedly setting fire to the Gunness home, denies having confessed to Rev. Schell as claimed in a Baltimore interview. Meanwhile, Laporte banks agree to furnish records of Mrs. Gunness's financial transactions to aid the prosecutor, while the state's attorney asserts Lamphere murdered her and burned the house.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE REPUDIATES CONFESSION MAN HELD FOR PART IN GUNNESS CRIMES DENIES THAT HE ADMITTED ACTS TO REV. SCHELL, NEW WESLEYAN HEAD BANKS WILL AID THE PROSECUTION
•.:§§&$ Banks to Aid Proseoution. a conference of the officials of three Laporte banks today it was de termined that the most effective way in aiding the authorities in untaugliug the murder mysteries was to furnish a list of all the transactions in which Mrs. Gunness paid out, deposited or received money. With a complete lfst of this kind Prosecutor Smith ex pects he will be able to secure valua ble information.
State's Attorney Smith asserts Mrs. Gunness was murdered by Ray Lamphere, who set fire to her house after being spurned and harassed by her. He cites circumstantial evidence, witness testimony of threats, and two men's claims of seeing Lamphere and Gunness burying Helgelein's body, while LaPorte banks agree to supply financial records to aid the investigation.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 1
PUBLISH ALL TRANSACTIONS
Says Woman Was Murdered. Before everything in this remark able case is made clear, answers must be found to the following questions: Did Mrs. Gunness commit suicide? "Was she murdered? If murdered, who killed her?. Who set fire to the house? 4 $ State's Attorney Smith said today: ®f| "Mrs. Gunness was murdered. Ray Lamphere is her murderer. He set her house on lire. He did it because the woman had spurned his love and IJP because she had harried htm in every Way possible. She had him arrested ®pi HP twice.
See moreSee less
She had attempted to have him committed to an insane asylum." "Have you sufficient evidence to convict Lamphere of this arson and |p| murder?" the prosecutor was asked. 4-fi "I have," replied Mr. Smith, em phatically. "Can you trace Mm to the Gunness & house on the morning of the fire?" m. "We can traoe him near enough. His pi own story of his trip from Lizzie Smith's house to Wheatbrook's farm on that fatal morning is full of con tradictions and falsehoods. He had told a dozen different stories of his movements. In addition we have half g,f a dozen witnesses who will testify 5^ ^at k® threatened to kill Mrs. Gun ness. We have witnesses to prove that she knew of his threats against her. We have a remarkably strong circumstantial case." "Aided in Slaying Helgelein.'' Jf i"' "Have you evidence to connect ,* Lamphere with the murder of Andrew Helgelein, whose dead body was dug vr*-" *1 from Mrs. Gunness' private ceme 7%* tery?" "I have. My evidence is almost con &r clusive." "On what case against the prisoner will you go to trial?" "I will try him first for arson and murder in connection with the burn ing of the Gunness home and the kill ing of the woman and her three chil dren." Two men living in Michigan City have told a startling story to the state's attorney that they saw Lam phere and Mrs. Gunness at the grew some task of burying the body of Helgelein in the "yard of horrors" at the Gunness home on the night of January 14. The men were taken to the Gun ness farm yesterday and identified the spot at which they saw the man and woman working. The spot mark ed the grave from which Helgelein's body was unearthed.
Two Michigan City men reported to the state's attorney that they witnessed Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness burying Andrew Helgelein's body in the farm's 'yard of horrors' on a moonlit January night. The prosecutor stated he would first try Lamphere for arson and murder connected to the burning of the Gunness home and the deaths of the woman and her three children.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Buried at Night. "We were walking to a farmhouse as In the country out of Laporte," said one of the men to State's Attorney Smith. "It was a bright, moonlight night and tne ground was white un der three inches of snow. It was pos sible to see across the glistening land scape a great distance. "As we passed the Gunness farm house we saw Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness. Both were working busily In the fenced inclosure at the side of the yard. We became interested in wljat they were doing and stopped in the road. We started to shout to '-tliem, but for some reason or other ijjld not 40 it. Mrs. Gunness made two into the house and back to Oystr Clam (Continued on page 8.) Corn anl
Fifteen thousand people swarmed the Gunness farm to glimpse the skeletons and dismembered bodies of victims, with vendors selling ice cream and ghastly postcards of the corpses. The report draws a parallel to a Salvation Army captain in Pittsburg who staged a mock funeral parade to attract a crowd.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 3
M. fit THE MORBID IN HUMANITY. 'There is a morbid streak in human ity, a love of the grewsome that is sometimes hard to understand. Yes terday these curious souls had a tV4# Jte veritable feast at the Gunness farm,
Large crowds traveled from hundreds of miles away to view the Gunness farm site, treating the scene of disinterred corpses as entertainment, with vendors selling ice cream, candy, and gruesome postcards. The report contrasts this morbid curiosity with a Salvation Army captain's theatrical funeral-themed revival meeting in Pittsburgh.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 3
THE MORBID IN HUMANITY
It wasn't the same with the morbid crowds at the Gunness farm. They were seeking excitement and they would have been better pleased if there had been more bodies to view, more grewsome butcheries to furnish them amusement.
Dr. Lucien Gray's previously withheld autopsy report reveals three rings found on the body claimed to be Belle Gunness, two bearing puzzling inscriptions referencing initials 'J.S.' that don't match known family members. The report also notes a missing hand was not actually missing, and mentions a new possible victim, Henry Gurholt, along with a reference to Lamphere's confession about helping bury Helgelein.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 6
NEW EVIDENCE IN GUNNESS CASE PUZZLES: HITHERTO SUPPRESSED STATEMENT OF AUTOPSY PHYSICIAN CONCERNING RINGS WITH ODD INSCRIPTIONS GIVEN OUT
•TORY OF HIS MOVEMENTS. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Unex pteinable evidence which has hitherto been suppressed was made public in the Gunness trag edy this morning. It is contained In the report of Dr. Lucien Gray, •who performed the autopsy on the body which authorities have steadfastly claimed is that of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Qray tells of three rings which were found up on the corpse and also reveals the fact that the right hand hitherto 7 declared to be missing, is still In existence.
Reports describe new evidence—a gold tooth and cryptic inscriptions—found in the Gunness farmhouse debris, plus a new suspected victim, Henry Gurholt. The bulk of the piece relays Ray Lamphere's reported confession to an unnamed friend, claiming he caught Belle Gunness burying the dismembered body of Andrew Helgelien at midnight.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 6
STORY OF HIS MOVEMENTS
has not been heard of since July 4, 190C. Laporte, Ind., May 12. Ray Lam phere has confessed that he caught Mrs. Belle Gunness red handed in the act of burying the dismembered body of Andrew Hegeleln, her last victim, by lantern light at midnight in her back door graveyard on "murder farm." The farm hand, under arrest on a charge of arson and murder in connection with the Gunness trage dies, made this confession to a friend whom the local authorities have lo cated in South Dakota, after tracing him by telegraph from Massachu setts.
See moreSee less
The name of the new witness, the most important discovered since the beginning of the investigation, which has unearthed eleven victims of the female cornerer of the murder mar ket, has not been made public. But Sheriff Smutzer has in his possession a detailed outline of the confession Lamphere is said to have made. Witness to Return, Sheriff Smutzer is making strenu ous efforts to persuade the witness to return to Laporte and repeat the story Lamphere told him. He expects to hear definitely from the man soon.
A man describes following fresh footprints at night to find Mrs. Gunness burying a body in lime, revealing it to be Andrew Helgelein. He claims this gave him power over her, demanding money or he would expose her to the gallows.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 6
•M&m v? the back porch I saw fresh foot prints in the snow. I looked in the direction they led and saw a light out on the side of the hill near the woodshed. I thought at first it was a will-o'-the-wisp. I looked closer and saw it was the light of a lantern. In the yellow shine of the lantern I saw Mrs. Gunness bending over. I walked up to the wire fence of the yard in which she was working and saw she was sprink ling lime over a dead body.
See moreSee less
She looked up suddenly and saw me. "My God." she cried, "I thought you were a ghost." I said nothing, but stepped through the gate and saw Helge lein's head staring at me from the grave. His body was in a gunny sack and his arms and legs had been tossed in upon it. I helped Mrs. Gunness ^^1 up the hole. From that nigbM^tave had her in my power. Sue must come across with plenty of money or I will send her to the gallows.
Witnesses recount watching Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness bury something in an enclosure where eleven corpses were later exhumed. Rings found among remains are identified by close friends as those always worn by Belle Gunness, including a wedding ring once belonging to Peter Gunness's first wife.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 8
LAMPHERE REPUDIATES CONFESSION
Monday, July 27. The Lackawanna Steel Co.’s plant at Buffalo, N. Y., has resumed opera tions on a large scale. The company now has but two idle mills, and more business has been done during the past two weeks than for any similar period since last October. The Petoskey Fiber Paper Co. of Petoskey, Mich., indicted with 23 oth er wrapping paper companies by the federal grand jury for violating the anti-pooling provision of the Sherman anti-trust act, pleaded guilty. Judge Hough imposed a fine of $2,000, which was paid. The sheriff’s office at Hillsdale, Mich., stated over the long-distance telephone that the report that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness had been discovered in Hills dale county is a mistake. The sheriff, who is away, was suspicious about a woman in the county and telephoned to the sheriff at Laporte, Ind., asking him to send an officer up to investi gate. The Laporte sheriff declined,
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Mrs. Christofferson, a close friend, identifies rings recovered from the Gunness farm as belonging to Belle Gunness, describing a tight-fitting gold band she never removed. The rings' inscriptions reveal a history connecting Peter Gunness's first wife and Belle's own past marriage.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 8
Monday, July 27. The Lackawanna Steel Co.’s plant at Buffalo, N. Y., has resumed opera tions on a large scale. The company now has but two idle mills, and more business has been done during the past two weeks than for any similar period since last October. The Petoskey Fiber Paper Co. of Petoskey, Mich., indicted with 23 oth er wrapping paper companies by the federal grand jury for violating the anti-pooling provision of the Sherman anti-trust act, pleaded guilty. Judge Hough imposed a fine of $2,000, which was paid. The sheriff’s office at Hillsdale, Mich., stated over the long-distance telephone that the report that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness had been discovered in Hills dale county is a mistake. The sheriff, who is away, was suspicious about a woman in the county and telephoned to the sheriff at Laporte, Ind., asking him to send an officer up to investi gate. The Laporte sheriff declined,
Clipping to come
The Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa
Four physicians' post-mortem reports to the coroner's jury failed to establish how the woman and three children died, likely leading to an open verdict. New details emerged about the adult body, including that the right arm was more intact than previously thought and that three rings were found on the hands.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MORE VICTIMS OF DEATH THREE OTHER MEN SUPPOSED TO HAVE BEEN KILLED. POST MORTEM REPORTS IN
Facts About Woman’s Body. The reports made to the coroner's Jury by Drs. J. L. Gray, H. H. Long, J. H. William Meyer and F. T. Wilcox revealed several circumstances, the existence of which has been carefully guarded from public knowledge. This is particularly true of the document signed by Dr. Gray and having to do with the adult body, supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness. \Jf*he new facts brought to light con 'Siita. ' 1 body are as follows: That the right arm is practically complete and that most of the left forearm and hand are in existence.
See moreSee less
Hitherto the complete arm had been known as the left and the right arm was supposed to have been completely consumed In the Are. That three rings, two containing in scriptlons, had been found on the hands. Puzzle of the Rings. The rings presented a puzzle which thus tar has not been solved. The in scriptions contain initials which are unaccountable except upon one hy pothesis, that being that the orna ments were the property of Peter Gun ness’ first wife, that he presented them to Mrs. Gunness, or that she obtained possession of them after his death and that Hhe wore them on the night when the house was burned.
Doctors' reports to the coroner's jury revealed the complete arm on the female body was actually the right, not left as previously believed, with the other arm mostly consumed by fire. Three rings with inscriptions were found on the body's hands, and new evidence pointed to three additional victims: John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Brady.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MORE VICTIMS OF DEATH THREE OTHER MEN SUPPOSED TO HAVE BEEN KILLED POST MORTEM REPORTS IN
Dr. Gray's post-mortem report reveals new details about the adult body found in the ruins, including confusion over which arm was intact and three rings with mysterious inscriptions found on the hands. Rev. E. A. Schell, Lamphere's pastor, states he believes Mrs. Gunness is alive, based on a confidential statement from Lamphere that did not include a confession to arson but suggested the woman's body was not hers.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
POST MORTEM REPORTS IN
Lamphere’s Pastor Talks. Baltimore, Md., May 13.—Rev. E. A. Schell, of La Porte, to whom Kay Lamphere made a confidential state ment concerning the La Porte sensa tion, who is attending the M. E. con ference here, said today that he has no doubt that Mrs. Gunness is alive. Pressed as to details of the statement made to him by Lamphere, he said that the statement did not Include the confession that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, but related exclu sively to matters that had transpired a month or more ago. “The Gunness children,” he said, "were chloroformed then the house was fired, but the wom an’s body found in the ruins is mot Airs. Gunness. lam sure Lamphere Is innocent of all murders except Hel galine’s.”
Officials report evidence identifying three additional victims of Belle Gunness: John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Brady, based on letters and witness statements. The report also notes contradictory developments in the case, including puzzling rings found on a body believed to be Mrs. Gunness, and mentions physicians' post-mortem reports being compiled.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
John Moe last January. Gerhalt Missing Since 1905. The word concerning Gertaalt came In a letter signed M. Gerhalt, and dated lola, Wls. It said that Henry Gerhalt left Scandinavia, Wls., on March 12, 1905, saying that he was go ing to work for Mrs. Gunness near La-' porte. Several letters were received from Gerhalt describing the farm where he was working and expressing satisfaction with the place. The last of these communications was dated ,luly 4, 1905. Gerhalt's brother wrote to Mrs. Gunness in December follow Ing and was told that Henry had left the farm to go to Chicago.
See moreSee less
The evidence regarding George Grady of Tuscola Is less definite. It Is reported that he left that town in July, 1905, saying that he was going .to Laporte, Ind., to marry a Mrs. Guu ness. He is supposed to have had jSi.avu wun mm.
Physicians' post-mortem reports on the bodies found in the Gunness ruins failed to establish cause of death, pointing toward an open verdict. New details emerged about the adult body's arms and rings, while testimony also covered missing men Gerhalt, Grady, and Moe linked to the farm.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
jSi.avu wun mm. Physicians Maks Reports. The reports of the four physicians Wfio" conducted tne post mortem ek' laminations on the bodies found In the ruins of the Gunness home April 28 were given to the coroner’s jury. They fail to establish the manner In which the woman and three children met death and It is probable that the coroner’s Jury will return an open ver dict regarding them.
An estimated 15,000 people flocked to the Gunness farm on Sunday, turning the murder site into a picnic ground with vendors selling souvenir postcards and refreshments. The report also notes defense attorneys plan to investigate a nearby cemetery to support their theory that Belle Gunness killed her children and substituted another woman's body before setting the fire.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 6
MORBID CROWDS AT 'DEATH FARM' FIFTEEN THOUSAND FLOCK TO GUNNESS PLACE SUNDAY. THRONGS ON EVERY TRAIN.
Gunness and the three little ones who met death with her finding the read iest sale. Mayor Darrow, a law partner or is. W. Worden, who is defending Ray Lamphere, said that the defense will start an investigation of the Pine Lake cemetery, an old burial ground about a mile from the Gunness farm. It Is the theory of the defense that Mrs. Gunness killed her children, placed the body of a large woman near them, set (ire to the house to cover up her crime and then lied. If It Is discovered that any of the graves in Pine Lake cemetery have been dls turbsd recently Mayor Darrow thinks that this theory will be more or less substantiated
Thousands of spectators flooded LaPorte by train to view the murder farm, overwhelming local transportation and forcing officials to become mere onlookers. Some visitors offered tips about missing relatives, including a man whose brother had worked for Gunness and planned to marry her before vanishing.
The Oskaloosa Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 6
THRONGS ON EVERY TRAIN.
The most definite information came from Olaf Llndboe, 610 La Salle av enue, Chicago. He said that hts broth er Thomas worked for Mrs. Gunness three years ago and that the last let ter which he had from him contained the information that Thomas Intended to marry his employer. Olaf wrote to the woman a little later and she replied that Thomas Llndboe had gone to St. Louis and that she had had no word from him. Olaf Llndboe viewed the unidentified corpses, but wa£ unable to find any likeness to his brother in the decayed bundles of bones and flesh. Crowds on All Trains.
Milk River Valley News · Harlem, Mont. · and 3 other papers
More than 1,500 local visitors and about 4,000 more arriving by rail and trolley flocked to the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana, turning the site of 11 exhumed bodies into a tourist spectacle. Officials struggled to manage the crowds, while some visitors provided leads about missing relatives, including a man whose brother had worked for Mrs. Gunness and intended to marry her.
Milk River Valley News · 14 May 1908 · page 6
NOW FAMOUS FARM THOUSANDS VISIT GRUESOME PLACE OF MURDER
% night at the New Gem Theater. A A great laugh provoker entitled "Why Men Rubber," comes direct, from the Schubert theater in New Orleans, where thousands saw it and laughed over it. A sensational picture, "A ■Woman's Sin and a Husband's Terrible Revenge," Is another feature for to day and tonight, and theL music and singing'is to be especially attractive For tomorrow evening and night the New Gem will have an election special in a great picture showing the Gunness farm tragedies and a life portrait of of the arch fiend, Mrs. Gunness, whose crimes have astounded th e world. PEOPLE TALKING
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
Camas Prairie Chronicle · Cottonwood, Idaho · 15 May 1908
The Kendrick Gazette · Kendrick, Idaho · 15 May 1908
Reports describe the ongoing search of the La Porte farm where authorities are digging up buried bodies, with early identifications including Andrew Helgelien and a young Chicago woman thought to have gone to Los Angeles. Additional unidentified remains of a man and two children are also mentioned.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 4
% night at the New Gem Theater. A A great laugh provoker entitled "Why Men Rubber," comes direct, from the Schubert theater in New Orleans, where thousands saw it and laughed over it. A sensational picture, "A ■Woman's Sin and a Husband's Terrible Revenge," Is another feature for to day and tonight, and theL music and singing'is to be especially attractive For tomorrow evening and night the New Gem will have an election special in a great picture showing the Gunness farm tragedies and a life portrait of of the arch fiend, Mrs. Gunness, whose crimes have astounded th e world. PEOPLE TALKING
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
The Gunness death farm search uncovered two more watches today, bringing the total to ten of the type typically worn by men, even though only nine male bodies have been found so far. Investigators plan to resume searching the premises.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 14 May 1908 · page 1
EVIDENCE OF MORE MURDERS
And Her Children. WANT LAMPHERE RELEASED ATTORNEY FOR THE ACCUSED MAN WILL ASK THAT HE BE GIVEN FREEDOM OR HIS BAIL REDUCED MATERIALLY. Laporte, Ind., July 31. By the re
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Deputies and witnesses report sightings and testimony implicating Ray Lamphere in the Gunness fire and murders of her children, while coroner's medical testing disputes some physical evidence. More bodies are expected as excavation resumes, and authorities receive numerous tips and letters.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS.
POISON FOUND IN STOMACH?. Many Theories in Gunness Case Arc ' Upset. Coroner Mack announced Thursday that Dr. Walter Haines, of Chicago. wio analyzed the stomach of Andrew
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A young witness named Solyam positively identified Ray Lamphere in a jail lineup as the man he saw running from the Gunness farm on the morning of the fire. The boy also claimed Lamphere had threatened to kill him if he didn't flee, and the report notes investigators suspect Gunness may have had accomplices in luring victims.
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
POISON FOUND IN STOMACH?. Many Theories in Gunness Case Arc ' Upset. Coroner Mack announced Thursday that Dr. Walter Haines, of Chicago. wio analyzed the stomach of Andrew
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Authorities investigate a theory that Belle Gunness used hired men as accomplices before killing them, while a search tied to a Warsaw suicide victim turns up nothing. A letter from a Cleveland man describes being approached by a stranger promoting a 'rich widow' matchmaking scheme resembling Gunness's lonely-hearts method.
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 3
NET OF EVIDENCE IS BEING TIGHTENED
t,sTHAT MRS. GUNNESS ABES WERE POISONED ?E, Ind., July HO. Coroner Mack TJjd today that Dr. Walter Haines, sSMedcal college, Chicago, who ii;the stomach of Andrew Helgelcln ieen. S. D., the last victim of mHVo Gunness, finding strychnine rifle In fatal doses, has also found immaclis of Mrs. Gunness and two jUIdrn arsenic; and strychnine In gjsufflclcnt to have cauaed death. ?5y. Worden, who represents Liim Warged with the Gunness murdera jjiAbelns au accomplice o Mrp. 'ijllii the Helgelein death, declaroj; dlHcoery shows that his client 1Mhad nothing todo with the i?Hho woman and her children, w'fresult of tho finding the lawyer faflboon announced that he would oJorepar' pupers to go before the ofcrt and either ask for the re '(ampherc upon a.
See moreSee less
v.-rlt of hahcaa rtjtask for the reduction of hall. nB .
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A witness describes being approached by a man promoting a rich widow in LaPorte as a potential bride, suspected to be an accomplice luring victims to Gunness. Meanwhile, investigators prepare subpoenas for the Lamphere trial and attempt to confirm identification of bodies through dental gold and a Bertillon expert for Helgelein's remains.
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 3
IS BEING TIGHTENED
FIND POISON IN BODY. Laporte (Ind.) Has Evidence Which May Prove That Mrs. Belle Gunness Killed Herself. LA PORTE. Ind., July BO.—Coroner Mack announced today that Dr. Wal
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Most locals in La Porte now accept that the burned body is Belle Gunness, reasoning she would have left jewelry behind if she staged her death. Searchers found gold globules possibly from her dental work, to be examined by a dentist, while witnesses gave uncertain testimony about identifying rings.
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 3
FIND POISON IN BODY. Laporte (Ind.) Has Evidence Which May Prove That Mrs. Belle Gunness Killed Herself. LA PORTE. Ind., July BO.—Coroner Mack announced today that Dr. Wal
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A humor column riffs on the ongoing mystery of Belle Gunness's whereabouts, joking that no reporter has yet managed to see her. It mixes flippant one-liners with a dark aside comparing the 'Gunness horror' to Lady Macbeth's crimes.
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 4
NO MAN HAS A CINCH IN THE WIDOW PROPOSITION FOR SHE KEEPS THE WISEST WISE GUESSING BOTH GOING AND COMING AND HE STANDS TO LOSE ON THE HUNCH
®&O o | WHEN JUDGE TAFT is notified there is going to be a flag rasing, fire- | works, booming of cannon, automobile rides, various banquets and at lealt‘ two speeches. | SR ONORY. | MRS. GUNNESS contiues to be discovered in several cities at the same time. She is probably in that limbo which swallowed Charley Ross and
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Asle K. Helgelein announces he will sue the Belle Gunness estate for $3,000 his murdered brother allegedly lost on the farm. A new clue suggests Gunness had an accomplice in the killings.
The Lake County Times · 14 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
About 140 Plymouth residents traveled to LaPorte to view the Gunness murder farm site, and on the return train pickpockets stole money and a ticket from three men. The thieves escaped before the thefts were noticed.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 1
ARE 'TOUCHED' AT LAPORTE
Mrs. Gunness has been discovered again this time in Grandoldtexas. That's punishment enough for her. The campaign Is warming up. He Is invariably referred to as "William Jen nings Bryan" in the newspapers nowa
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Investigators digging in the yard of Belle Gunness's burned Laporte, Indiana home have unearthed multiple mutilated bodies, including suitors and children, suggesting a long series of murders. Doubt now surrounds whether Gunness and her children actually died in the earlier house fire, with suspicion she staged her own death.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 2
WOMAN CALLED A BLUEBEARD
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified · and 1 other paper
The report catalogs identified and unidentified victims whose remains or disappearances were linked to Belle Gunness's farm, including Andrew Helgelein and several farmhands and children. It also notes the arrest of Ray Lamphere and the theory that trunks delivered to the farm may have been used to transport murdered victims.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 2
WOMAN CALLED A BLUEBEARD
POISON FOUND IN STOMACHS. Many Theories in Gynnesa Caw* Are L’ltseL Coroner Mack announced Thursday that Dr. Walter Haines, of Chicago, who analyzed the stomach ofAndrew Helgellen, the last victim of Mrs. Belle Gunness, finding strychnine and arsen ic in fatal doses, has also found in the I tomachs of Mrs. Gunnesm and her two children arsenic and strychnine in quantities sufficient to have caused the deaths. This discovery has upset many former theories In the case, and ha-, opened up the possibility of Mrs. Gun ness having killed the children In the same manner in which she took the lives of her victims and ended her on n life with a fatal dose.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · 14 May 1908
Paper unidentified
The report details Ray Lamphere's conflicting statements about his relationship with Belle Gunness and his presence near the farm the night it burned, including her alleged requests that he buy poison. It also presents a chronology of the case from Mads Sorensen's death through the discovery of multiple bodies at the Laporte farm and suspicions of a murder 'clearing-house' using trunks shipped from Chicago.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 2
CHRONOLOGY OF INDIANA MULTI-MURDER MYSTERY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
George Anderson describes visiting Belle Gunness two years earlier after answering her matrimonial ad, claiming she pressured him to sell his land and marry her. He says he awoke to find her leaning over his bed, fled the next day, and now believes she is still alive.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 5
ESCAPED DEATH BY WAKING.
Porte. He believes that a chance awaken ing in the night saved him from mur der at the hands of Mrs. Gunness. Two years ago he went to LaPorte
A miscellany column reports several South Bend residents traveled to LaPorte to view the site of the Gunness tragedy. It also notes that the case has drawn sensational and exaggerated newspaper coverage, now attracting more correspondents and photographers.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 8
But what does the man care? He knows it all. ow Gunness farm.—Ex. "bule." I 'm Jorgenson. Buffalo Bill's Wild .West Show has never been tbe
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A boy named Johnny Solyman identifies Ray Lamphere as the man he saw fleeing the burning Gunness home, with three other witnesses also claiming to have seen him near the farm. Sheriff Smutzer has also received a letter from a Milwaukee man claiming Mrs. Gunness is alive and demanding $5,000 for revealing her location.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 1
DOES MRS. GUNNESS LIVE?
But what does the man care? He knows it all. ow Gunness farm.—Ex. "bule." I 'm Jorgenson. Buffalo Bill's Wild .West Show has never been tbe
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
This report recaps the April 27 fire that destroyed Belle Gunness's farmhouse near Laporte, Indiana, leading to discovery of nine murder victims buried on the property. It notes that a headless female body initially believed to be Gunness's may have been placed there as a decoy to help her escape justice, per subsequent investigation.
Rock Island Argus · 14 May 1908 · page 6
If Mrs. Gunness was or Is a reincar nation of Kate Bender she bas outdone the ghastly achievements of her former life. Of the Bender family's known victims there were only seven. The tally of the Gunness woman's crimes
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Chicago police believe more bodies may be found linked to the Laporte murders, and new evidence suggests Belle Gunness was not killed in the farmhouse fire but escaped. The report traces the scheme's origins to a 1903 matrimonial advertisement used to lure victims to her farm.
The Topeka State Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 4
THE MATRIMONIAL BUREAU.
In the history of crime. Yet If the evi dence In the Laporte affair Is not mod ified or In part belled the case of Mrs. Gunness Is more singular and horrific. The Benders had the moral (or Im moral ) support of one another—the ter rible relief which comes to those who share a fntal secret. Mrs. Gunness may have had an accomplice In Lamphere or another, but that has not yet been established, and It Is not Improbable that many If not most of her crimes were committed by her alone. In any event she achieved a terrible Immor tality, leaving a name at which the world may well grow pale. The possi bilities of the human soul seem Infinite <n evil as In good.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The piece discusses how matrimonial bureau advertisements, like the one used by Belle Gunness to lure victims to her LaPorte farm, have long been associated with swindling and are now linked to actual murders. It notes postal authorities' efforts to curb such bureaus and hopes the publicity from the Gunness case will aid in shutting down the business.
The Topeka State Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 4
THE MATRIMONIAL BUREAU
In the history of crime. Yet If the evi dence In the Laporte affair Is not mod ified or In part belled the case of Mrs. Gunness Is more singular and horrific. The Benders had the moral (or Im moral ) support of one another—the ter rible relief which comes to those who share a fntal secret. Mrs. Gunness may have had an accomplice In Lamphere or another, but that has not yet been established, and It Is not Improbable that many If not most of her crimes were committed by her alone. In any event she achieved a terrible Immor tality, leaving a name at which the world may well grow pale. The possi bilities of the human soul seem Infinite <n evil as In good.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Investigators discovered two more watches in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse, bringing the total to ten watches despite only nine male bodies being recovered. The report also details letters from cranks offering to produce Mrs. Gunness, and new testimony alleging Lamphere blackmailed her for $300.
The Topeka State Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 8
FIND 2 WATCHES
Him $300. Laporte, Ind.,. May 14. The Gun Bess death farm today gave up more corroborative evidence. Two more watches were found in the debris of the ruined house. The bodies of nine male victims have been unearthed yet the record 'of watches belonging to men Is now ten. , Sheriff Smutzer announced after the finding of today that he will resume digging operations with the hope of uncovering additional skeletons. Af ' ter the watches were found today Prosecutor Smith and the sheriff held a hurried consultation but neither would reveal the details of their talk.
See moreSee less
Over 100 letters of the crank va riety were received by the sheriff, the coroner and other officials today. Some of them offered to produce Mrs. Gunness for a consideration. The state announced this morning that confirmation of their belief that Lamphere had endeavored to black mail Mrs. Gunness has been secured from a former resident of this city, who is now at Chesterton, Ind. They assert that a man named Charles Nel son will testify that he saw Mrs. Gun ness give $300 to Lamphere. Prose cutor Smith argues that this sum is far in excess of any amount which might have been due to Lamphere for the class of service which he per formed on the farm. -. : The defense also announced a new witness, Fred W. Freeze of Fort Wayne, who was in charge of the re moval of the bodies from the ruins of the burned Avelyne hotel recently. The attorneys for Lamphere say that the only possible Identification of some of these corpses was made by means of the teeth in the blackened skulls. They will draw a parallel between the fires at Fort Wayne and the Gunness farm and will argue that if the skulls remain Intact on the bodies of the Fort Wayne victims that it would not have been possible for Mrs. Gunness head to have been totally consumed in the conflagration, which totally de stroyed her home. Are the Globules Gold? The possible determination that the globules of metal found by the mining operations on the ' Gunness farm yesterday were bits of gold used by a dentist for flll-
Digging resumes at the Gunness farm for more skeletons while officials receive over 100 crank letters, some offering to produce Mrs. Gunness for payment. New witnesses emerge regarding alleged blackmail by Lamphere, and metal globules found in the ruins are being tested to determine if they are gold dental fillings from Mrs. Gunness's teeth.
Officials at Laporte are overwhelmed with inquiries about missing persons but most lack the dental or physical details needed to identify seven unmarked cadavers found on the Gunness farm. A letter from Cleveland about an accomplice trying to lure another victim reinforced theories of a murder-for-money scheme, while defense attorneys sought a witness, David Havens, said to have been run out of town by the sheriff.
The Topeka State Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 8
volunteer correspondents of Sheriff Smutzer, Coroner Mack and the other officials interested. Many of the letters reveal pitiful stories of anxious par ents, brothers, sisters, husbands or wives, who have waited long months or years for word from their loved ones. But they also show that in an astonishing number of 'cases the hab its, characteristics or physical peculi arities of the missing persons have been either unknown or forgotten. In the presence of these latter circum stances the authorities at Laporte are powerless to give the aid sought or satisfy the demands of their official Consciences.
See moreSee less
; Yesterday's developments did little to elucidate the unsolved problems, arising rrom tne corpse sown farm The letter from Cleveland, concern ing the attempts of an accomplice of - Mrs. Gunness to draw another victim into her net, served to strengthen the idea tnat tne woman was the cen
A man named Rhode in St. Paul claims he saw and spoke with Belle Gunness on Tuesday, insisting she closely resembled her published photographs. When shown an actual photo of Gunness, he reiterated with great certainty that he had seen her in the city.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Topeka State Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 10
SAW MRS. GUNNESS
By LEGAL EXPERT. Is there sufficient evidence to convince twelve unprejudiced jurors that Mrs. Gun ness is dead and that Lamphere killed her, or will the evidence submitted by the State's prosecutor simply becioud the minds of the jury and the public and leave the vanishment of the woman slayer a more inexplicable puzzle than it is now? There are seven indictments against Lamphere. Four of these charge him with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. One charges him with the murder of Andrew Helgelein, one charges that he was an accessory with Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness in the murder of Helgelein, and the seventh charges him with arson in the burning of the Gunness home. But an indictment is not an evidence of guilt. The iaw expressiy says so. In dictments are often returned on the merest suspicion of guilt, and often sim ply as a means to hold a prisoner in the hope that more evidence against him may be obtained. The jury which goes into the bex to try Ray Lamphere for his life will be th structed by the court that the indictment is no evidence of guilt and that he is pre sumed to be innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and that this presumption of innocence accompanies
Clipping to come
The Clay City Times · Clay City, Ky.
A Kentucky newspaper editorial argues that the Gunness farm murders in Laporte, Indiana are worse than Eastern Kentucky feud violence, yet Indiana will not suffer regional stigma as Kentucky does. It contends feud killings stem from perceived wrongs while the Gunness crimes were committed purely for robbery, with no excuse.
The Clay City Times · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Where is the Difference
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Investigators debate whether rings found on a burned female body belonged to Belle Gunness, with the mayor noting she said she never wore rings. Meanwhile, the coroner's medical report describes the woman and children's deaths, and the state's attorney claims strong evidence against Ray Lamphere, including bloody clothing found in his trunk.
The Bee · 14 May 1908 · page 5
NO ONE RECALLS SEEING JEWELRY
By LEGAL EXPERT. Is there sufficient evidence to convince twelve unprejudiced jurors that Mrs. Gun ness is dead and that Lamphere killed her, or will the evidence submitted by the State's prosecutor simply becioud the minds of the jury and the public and leave the vanishment of the woman slayer a more inexplicable puzzle than it is now? There are seven indictments against Lamphere. Four of these charge him with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. One charges him with the murder of Andrew Helgelein, one charges that he was an accessory with Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness in the murder of Helgelein, and the seventh charges him with arson in the burning of the Gunness home. But an indictment is not an evidence of guilt. The iaw expressiy says so. In dictments are often returned on the merest suspicion of guilt, and often sim ply as a means to hold a prisoner in the hope that more evidence against him may be obtained. The jury which goes into the bex to try Ray Lamphere for his life will be th structed by the court that the indictment is no evidence of guilt and that he is pre sumed to be innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and that this presumption of innocence accompanies
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
This editorial commentary compares the Gunness case to notorious male murderers like H.H. Holmes, suggesting she may have surpassed them in victim count. It muses on how so many victims could disappear without inquiry in a modern, well-settled community, with bodies still being uncovered on her farm.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 14 May 1908 · page 2
WOMAN AS MURDERER.
NOTED TRIAL NEAR Lamphere to Answer for the Death of Mrs. Gunness. CRITICAL ANALYSIS GIVEN Evidence For and Against the Only Prisoner in the Great Laperte Mystery Is Gome Over—Camn They Prove that the Woman Is Dead? Gtherwise Case May Be Dropped, By LEGAL EXPERT. Is there sufficient evidence to convince twelve unprejudiced jurors that Mrs. Gun ness is dead and that Lamphere killed her, or will the evidence submitted by the State's prosecutor simply becioud the minds of the jury and the public and leave the vanishment of the woman slayer a more inexplicable puzzle than it is now?
See moreSee less
There are seven indictments against Lamphere. Four of these charge him with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. One charges him with the murder of Andrew Helgelein, one charges that he was an accessory with Mrs. Gun ness in the murder of Helgelein, and the seventh charges him with arson in the burning of the Gunness home. But an indictment is not an evidence of guilt. The iaw expressiy says so. In dictments are often returned on the merest suspicion of guilt, and often sim ply as a means to hold a prisoner in the hope that more evidence against him may be obtained. The jury which goes into the bex to try Ray Lamphere for his life will be th structed by the court that the indictment is no evidence of guilt and that he is pre sumed to be innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and that this presumption of innocence accompanies the accused throughout the trial or until it is removed by evidence of guilt which the jurors cannot in reason doubt. Gunness Case First. The prosecution will undoubtedly elect to try Lamphere first upon the indictment charging him with the murder of Mrs. Gunness, for unless he can be convicted of that he cannot be «onvicted of any of the other six alleged crimes. The prosecution must first prove what is known in law as the “corpus delicti,” which means “the body, substance, or foundation of the offense,” which in this case is the dead body of Mrs. Gunness. Before the case against Lamphere can have any standing in court the prosecu tion must first prove that Mrs. Gunness is dead, and it must establish this fact beyond a doubt. If the prosecution should fail to prove this the defense would, at the end of the State's case, file a demur rer asking that the case be thrown out of court and the prisoner discharged for want of proof of the “corpus delicti” The State undoubtedly has enough evi dence of the death of Mrs. Gunness to warrant the judge in allowing the case to go to the jury. It will introduce Dr. J. 8. Norton, the dentist who put the gold bridgework in the mouth ef Mrs. Gunness, and he will testify that the bridge work found near the body in the cellar is the same. The rings found upon the hand of the dead woman will be intro duced in evidence, and the State will try to prove that they were hers by the engraved initials “P. 8. to J. 8.” and “P. G. to J. 8S.” She went once by the name of Jennie Sorensen. Must Show Metive., Before it can prove its case the State must also show that Lamphere had a motive for the death of Mrs. Gunness. The State will try to prove that he was very jealous of her and that she had dis carded him and that he thought she kept a large sum of money in her home and wished to rob her. But the strangest the ory of the State will be that Lamphere assisted her in the murder of Heigelein; that he knew this death was to be inves tigated, he knew the body would be found buried on the murder farm, and that he would be jointly accused with Mrs, Gunness for the crime, and that if he killed her and her children and burned the house he would stop the in vestigation. The State will attempt to prove that he said he would burn her house to “get even with her,” that he came to town the night before without good reason, and that he followed Mrs. Gunness into a grocery when she bought coal oil, and that he knew where she kept the oil on a porch where he could reach it easily. The State will attempt to prove that Lamphere might have slept at the home of Lizzie Smith, and yet have time to get to the Gunness house and kill them and get away. It will attempt to show that he was near the Gunness home soon after the fire burst forth, and that he did not Keep to the road in going away, but cut across fleids, and that he ran part of the way, going ten miles without breakfast, a suspicious circumstance in itself. The State will show that Mrs. Gun ness loved her children, and will argue the improbability of her murdering them and of committing suicide simply to es cape prosecution for murder.