Thousands of visitors flocked to the La Porte farm of Belle Gunness, suspected of murdering at least 10 people whose remains were found buried on the property. Officials prepared to resume searching for bodies and sift the ashes of her burned farmhouse, where she and her three children were believed to have died in an April 28 fire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 10
GREAT CROWDS Of Sightseers Flock to Indiana Death Farm. Search For Bodies of Victims to Be Resumed Today. Expert Miner Will Sift Ashes of Burned Gunness Home.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Sheriff Smutzer declares with certainty that the body found in the ruins was Mrs. Gunness, citing a ring and keys found with it. New evidence—a lock of brown hair clutched in Andrew Helgelein's dead hand, matching Ray Lamphere's hair—suggests he fought for his life before being murdered and buried among Gunness's victims.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1
LOCK OF HAIR MAY SEND LAMPHERE TO GALLOWS
fßjmember the Forgotten Man, LOCK OF 01 MAY SEND LAAAPRERE TO CALLOWS ANDREW HELGELEIN, IN DEATH GRIP CLUTCHED BROWN CURL LIKE PRISONER’S—EVIDENCE MRS. GUNNESS IS DEAD. • LA PORTR, Iml . May 11.—“ Mia. Belle Gunness is dead. It is her body which wus found with those of her children In the ruins of the house inhere she murdered probably a acore of men and women. We have known this for four days. On one of the tinners of the body wus a gold ring which was Identified as one Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ress wore. Her keys lay In the eid ders beside the body. We are sure she is dead." This Is the declaration of Sheriff Smuizer which, made today, shows why the authorities of La Porte, or at least some of them, have not entered into the search for the Indiana mur deress with any great enthusiasm.
Investigators find hair matching Ray Lamphere's at the murder farm, while the county council debates offering a reward despite the sheriff's belief that Mrs. Gunness is dead. Meanwhile over 10,000 sightseers flood the farm, and a doctor now suspects a six-month-old infant who died there in 1902 was strangled by Mrs. Gunness.
The Detroit Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Chicago and other hundreds were picked up all along the route. Add to these the La Porte residents who succumbed to curiosity ami It Is clear that no fewer than 10.000 persons vis ited the murder farm yesterday.
A doctor who treated Belle Gunness's infant in 1902 now believes she strangled the child after signing a death certificate for lung edema. Chicago police report dozens of sighting claims, and an anonymous letter directs investigators to a pond near the farm where Gunness's body and a missing head might be found.
The Detroit Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Wrote Michigan Preacher. VASBAR, Mich., May 11—Archibald McKenzie, while at lApeer about two years ago, received a letter from the matrimonial bureou at Chicago stat ing that a well-to-do woman by the name of Mrs. Gunness would like a life companion, but he did not an swer. and a short time after received a letter personally from Mrs. Gun ness, stating that she would meet him at Chicago, but he did not go. He Is a middle-aged man and a minister of the reorganized church. He Is now employed at the general store of MeOmbers and Intends to make his home here.
See moreSee less
CHICAGO. Muy 11.—Assistant Chief of Police Shuettler, speaking of the possibility that Mrs. Belle Gunness is alive, apld that In the last three days he hud received 26 letters from persons who declare they ure positive they have seen Mrs. Gunness since her reported death. Postotflce officers are seeking to find the writers of sev eral letters addressed to Mrs. Gun ness since her disappearance. These were held by the La Ports postmaster until Sunday, when they were turned over to postul Inspectors.
La Porte's police chief rushes to a nearby town investigating reports that a cemetery was robbed, hoping it may clarify the identity of the body found in the Gunness ruins. Meanwhile a grand jury is sworn in, Louis Schultz sifts the ashes for evidence like Gunness's diamond earrings, and a new clue about a possible additional grave surfaces via a young girl's account.
The Detroit Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1
LA PORTE POLICE CHIEF IN MAD BUGGY RIDE HEARS BODY-SNATCHERS ARE AT WORK IN CEMETERY OF NEARBY TOWN AND IS EAGER FOR EVIDENCE
Judge Richter. No special instruc tions were given on the Gunness case, but it is known that the Jury will take up the matter almost at once. A sluice was built In the mur der home ruins and Louis Schultz began the task of “panning” the ashes and debris In search of evi dence that Mrs. Gunness died in the flames. "She always wore diamond earrings.” said Sheriff Smutzer, today, “3nd I expect to find them In the ashes.” Anew clew that may reveal an other of Bella Gunness’ graveyard plots war, furnished to the La Porte authoritiee today, through Hazel Zahrt.
See moreSee less
little daughter of Mrs. Edward Zahrt. According to a story, the girl and her moth er crnf»ed the Gunness farm late last summer and Hazel discover ed a grave tome rods away from the place where the first scries of graves have been excavated. The hole had Just been dug, the fresh earth disclosing that fact. The pit was on the slope cf the hill facing Fishtrap lake.
Sheriff Smutzer declares with certainty that the burned body found is Belle Gunness, citing a ring and keys as proof, while ash-sifting continues for her diamond earrings. Meanwhile a new grave clue surfaces and an autopsy report reveals hair clutched in Andrew Helgelein's hand, seen as key evidence against Ray Lamphere.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1
LA PORTE POLICE CHIEF IN MHO BOGGYJIBE HEARS BODY-SNATCHERS ARE AT WORK IN CEMETERY OF NEARBY TOWN AND IS EAQER FOR EVIDENCE. LA PORTE, Ind., May 11.—In tense excitement was created in La Porte today, by a mad drive that Chief of Police Cochran and one of hi 6 men made from this city to a nearby town in search n* body-snatching evidences. "I have just received definite Information,” the police chief cte cMred when he ordered his buggyv "that the cemetery in a town not! far from here has been rifled, ll am going there at once to make j personal investigation.
See moreSee less
It migst throw some light on the identity •f the body in the Cunness ruins.” The chief drove through Main st. at full speed and disappeared on a country road, refusing to tell his destination. At about the same time the grand was boing sworn by Judge Richter. No special instruc tions were given on the Gunness case, but it is known that the Jury will take up the matter almost at once. A sluice was built In the mur der home ruins and Louis Schultz began the task of “panning” the ashes and debris In search of evi dence that Mrs. Gunness died in the flames. "She always wore diamond earrings.” said Sheriff Smutzer, today, “3nd I expect to find them In the ashes.” Anew clew that may reveal an other of Bella Gunness’ graveyard plots war, furnished to the La Porte authoritiee today, through Hazel Zahrt. little daughter of Mrs. Edward Zahrt. According to a story, the girl and her moth er crnf»ed the Gunness farm late last summer and Hazel discover ed a grave tome rods away from the place where the first scries of graves have been excavated. The hole had Just been dug, the fresh earth disclosing that fact. The pit was on the slope cf the hill facing Fishtrap lake. LA PORTE, hut., May 11.—“ Mrs. Bolle Gunucss Is dead. It is her body which was found with those of her children lit the ruins of the house where she murdered probably a score of meu and women. We have known this for four days. On one of the fingers of the body was a gold ring which was Identified as one Mrs. Gun ness wore. Her keys lay in the cld ders beside the body. We are sure she Is df^ad." This Is the declaration of SherlfT Sruutzer which, made today, shows why the authorities of l.a Porte, or at ]>>ast some of them, have not entered Into the search for the Indiana mur deress with any great enthusiasm.
A Detroit hairdresser claims a woman matching Belle Gunness's description visited her salon twice two weeks earlier, once with a young girl thought to be one of the children who died in the LaPorte fire. The woman reportedly seemed upset after failing to convince a wealthy Woodward Avenue woman to return home with her.
The Detroit Times · 11 May 1908 · page 3
MRS. GUNNESS WAS IN DETROIT RECENTLY
Hiding. a person femiliar with the history and habits of the principals in the famous Gunness case that lias stirred the country by the terrifying crimes committed, at Laporte, Ind., is em ployed at the local packing plant In stalling a sprinkler system. Lew Waggoner, referred to above is a resident of Laporte and tells many un complimentary things about the Gun ness house with which he is familiar, .v having been at the place several times. .The place bears a bad reputation says Mr. Waggoner( and people in that vicinity regard it as haunted.
See moreSee less
Mr. Waggoner tells of a Swedish girl he knew who quit working for Mrs. Gunness because she was afraid of her. The girl said there was one room on the second floor that was al ways kept locked with 3 padlocks. Mr. Waggoner says Ray Lamphere was "nutty* and thinks Mrs. Gunness Is in hiding some place and says she reads the newspapers and knows ex actly how to dodge the police. Mr. Waggoner says the house had a bad name, two men having committed Btdcide there and the neighbors said jit' was "hawrted," and at one time it jbad been used as a bouse of iljfame, "but when Ktrs. Gunness bought it she 'soon made a beautiful place of it |Tbe house stood about 2 miles out itl! laporte on the bank of a small /lake.
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
Diggers at the Gunness farm in La Porte found two additional skeletons, believed to be a man and a woman, buried in the same grave as earlier remains. Only three of the eleven bodies found so far have been identified, and investigators have few clues to the identities of the rest.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 11 May 1908 · page 2
bers of the watch corresponded | the numbers of Moe's posses Lamphere said Mrs. Gunness |him the watch. bodies of the seven unidenti Jead will be buried tomorrow potter's field. Christian ser vlll be conducted over them and
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
A search of Minneapolis marriage license records found no record of Belle Gunness's marriage, though police received charred photographs from Laporte bearing a Minneapolis photographer's mark. The photos, believed to show Gunness and a husband she met and married in Chicago, were damaged by fire.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 11 May 1908 · page 2
bers of the watch corresponded | the numbers of Moe's posses Lamphere said Mrs. Gunness |him the watch. bodies of the seven unidenti Jead will be buried tomorrow potter's field. Christian ser vlll be conducted over them and
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
Dr. H. H. Long, who performed the autopsy, states the burned body found in the Gunness house ruins is not that of Mrs. Gunness, citing differences in weight, height, and hand condition. He argues the corpse belongs to a smaller, more refined woman, not the large, powerfully built Gunness.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 11 May 1908 · page 4
WOMAN STILL LIVING
Other He Often Saw. La Porte, Ind., May 19. Just be fore noon today Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Schultz, who are sluicing the ashes In the debris of the Gunness Sre, found the upper, and lower plates which" : earned from:,- .'.Mrs. V. Gunness: iriouth, bothcontaining -herfalse teeth. Dr. I. P. Norton, who made the lower plate Immediately Identified them and also identified the upper plate, frequently having seen It, al though it was made before he be came her dentist. "This proves beyond a shadow of doubt." said Sheriff Smutzer, "that Mrs. Gunness was burned to death in the fire."
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
An expert argues the burned body found on the Gunness farm is too short and refined to be Belle Gunness herself, while Syracuse police mistakenly arrest and release an innocent woman. A report also surfaces suggesting Gustav Thun, a matrimonial-bureau correspondent, may be another victim.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 11 May 1908 · page 4
Other He Often Saw. La Porte, Ind., May 19. Just be fore noon today Sheriff Smutzer and Miner Schultz, who are sluicing the ashes In the debris of the Gunness Sre, found the upper, and lower plates which" : earned from:,- .'.Mrs. V. Gunness: iriouth, bothcontaining -herfalse teeth. Dr. I. P. Norton, who made the lower plate Immediately Identified them and also identified the upper plate, frequently having seen It, al though it was made before he be came her dentist. "This proves beyond a shadow of doubt." said Sheriff Smutzer, "that Mrs. Gunness was burned to death in the fire."
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A dispute has broken out among LaPorte officials over the identity of the body believed to be Belle Gunness, with factional politics blamed for conflicting attitudes. Dr. H.P. Long denies issuing a statement doubting the corpse's identity, saying he only expressed a personal opinion, while Dr. Meyer insists he has no doubt it is Mrs. Gunness.
Omaha Daily Bee · 11 May 1908 · page 1
SURE MRS. GUNNESS IS DEAD. Statement from Doctors Contradicts the Theory That She is Alive.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A controversy emerged over whether Dr. Long had publicly doubted the identity of Mrs. Gunness's corpse, though he claimed he only voiced a personal opinion. The four autopsy physicians were reported unanimous on physical findings, with no skull fractures or brain hemorrhages found on the children, supporting suffocation rather than blunt trauma, and the size discrepancy in the female corpse attributed to heat damage rather than a substituted body.
Omaha Daily Bee · 11 May 1908 · page 1
SURE MRS. GUNNESS IS DEAD
ONE GRAVE. • I.A FORTE, lud., May 19.—Murder of foui persona whom she had invited lo her "house of honor" us her guests ai a hriatmas part), is the latest atrocity chained to Mrs. belle Gun ness, La Porte's arch-assassin, who Is being sought today by the police of practically the whole world. ( From a caieful examination v 1 unidentlhed bodies which have been recovered from the ‘‘soft spots' of firookside farm and the comparison of other evidence It Is now almos' certain that the woman slayer com mitted her quadruple clime on biisi mas night of 19U6.
See moreSee less
Jennie Olson. John .vloe, of Elbow Lake, Mum., j.cid u man and woman known only as tit** •protessor and his wife," were on that ulgnt the victims of the Gun ness woman’s passion for .daughter This discovery corroborate* in de tail the statement by Emil Greening on< -* Mrs. Gunness' chore boy. who has been Intervi* wed in Oklahoma City.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
The sheriff plans to sift the cellar ashes for gold tooth fillings and other metallic evidence to confirm Belle Gunness's identity, and is considering digging furrows in the barnyard to search for more bodies. New witnesses, including John Rye, claim Ray Lamphere went to the farm the night Andrew Helgelein disappeared, saying there would be 'something doing there.'
Omaha Daily Bee · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Prepared Weeks Ahead. There ate reasons to believe that. Mis. Gunness prepared for this slaughter weeks ahead. The grave in which the four bodies w*-i*- found, was dug two months ahead by Uiljiski. a Polish laborer, who did odd jobs for j Mrs. Gunness. The preceding October
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
LaPorte's City Council prepares a $5,000 reward for capture of Belle Gunness, now theorized to have poisoned her children before being killed by farmhand Roy Lamphere. District Attorney Smith asserts Lamphere was her accomplice in murder and decapitated her body to cover his tracks before setting the house afire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 11 May 1908 · page 1
$5,000 REWARD FOR CAPTURE OF GUNNESS HARPY
Prepared Weeks Ahead. There ate reasons to believe that. Mis. Gunness prepared for this slaughter weeks ahead. The grave in which the four bodies w*-i*- found, was dug two months ahead by Uiljiski. a Polish laborer, who did odd jobs for j Mrs. Gunness. The preceding October
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
District Attorney Smith theorizes that Roy Lamphere murdered and decapitated Belle Gunness after learning she planned to flee, then burned the farmhouse to hide evidence. The report also claims Lamphere was Gunness's accomplice in her murders, citing hair found in victim Andrew Hegelein's hand as corroborating evidence.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 11 May 1908 · page 1
SHE PREPARED TO FLEE.
*Pj:rumbir the I’orggtten Man. MBS. GUNNESS IS; 'OEM; TOOTH . PLATEJIND ARC M-S LAYER’S DENTIST POSI TIVELY IDENTIFIES GOLD MOL ARS AS HERB—STATEMENT AC CEPTED AS FINAL PROOF. LA PORTE, |nd., May 19. Mrs. Belle Gunneee Is dead. She met death In the house to which ehe lured her victims. Positive proof was adduced to. day, when a plate bearing several gold teeth were found by Miner Schultz In sluicing. Dr. 1. N. Norton positively identified the j teeth ae those of Mrs. Gunness. He was her dentist and his state ment Is accepted as proving be yond question that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness went to her death the morning of the fire. J LA PORTE, Ind., May 19.—The Issuing of r. certificate of death of Jennie Olson and the turning over of the body by Coroner Mack to her relatives In Chicago puts the official stamp of Identification upon one of the bediee found at the Gunness farm, regarding which there has been much con troversy. * LA PORTE. Ind . Muy 19. —“1 have decided not to marry the widow," written in a strange hand, supposed ly by Mrs. Belle Gunness, or an ac-, complice In her tragedies, Is believed Ly State's Attorney Smith to solve the mystery surrounding the disap pearance of Gh«, Kiedlger, of Dela field. Wia. A letter received this rrorning from Delafield, stated that Riediger left that place a year ago with H.UOn In hi. possession with the statement that he was going to La Porte to marry a rich widow. Several days later Delafield relatives receiv ed the letter with the mystifying handwriting The *I,OOO which Rieu liter brought with him to the Gunness charnel house evidently marked him for death, decapitation and dismem berment In the chamber of horrors TRONDHJEM. Norway. \lav 10 BrynhlKl Poulsdutter w.is tiu' maiden name of Mrs. Belle Gunness. accord ing to a report just tu tde by the an-' thoriiies of the village of Selbe to the Trondhjem police The woman was horn at Selbe. Nov. 11. 1859, and left Norway to go to America 30 years ago. Her only surviving relative lu 1 the village, a sister, died lust Friday.! &AGIXAW, Mich , May 19.—Saginaw | haa «-netlm—ofthtr thrnmue death farm In the belief of the vvife of Dav-i Id Newman, who lives at 334 Cronk *l.. This »lt;. Mrs. N9WSSB is con vinced that her busbar; l fell Into the clutches of the Indiana murderers and that he was killed and hurled on her farm
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
A witness named Wheatbrook testifies about Ray Lamphere's behavior and statements on the day of the Gunness farm fire, including his claim he avoided the scene for fear of suspicion. The district attorney questions inconsistencies in Lamphere's account during what appears to be an inquest or preliminary hearing.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 11 May 1908 · page 2
SLAIN BY SPURNED
LA PORTE, Ind., May 19.—The Issuing of r. certificate of death of Jennie Olson and the turning over of the body by Coroner Mack to her relatives In Chicago puts the official stamp of Identification upon one of the bediee found at the Gunness farm, regarding which there has been much con troversy. * LA PORTE. Ind . Muy 19. —“1 have decided not to marry the widow," written in a strange hand, supposed ly by Mrs. Belle Gunness, or an ac-, complice In her tragedies, Is believed Ly State's Attorney Smith to solve the mystery surrounding the disap pearance of Gh«, Kiedlger, of Dela field.
See moreSee less
Wia. A letter received this rrorning from Delafield, stated that Riediger left that place a year ago with H.UOn In hi. possession with the statement that he was going to La Porte to marry a rich widow. Several days later Delafield relatives receiv ed the letter with the mystifying handwriting The *I,OOO which Rieu liter brought with him to the Gunness charnel house evidently marked him for death, decapitation and dismem berment In the chamber of horrors TRONDHJEM. Norway. \lav 10 BrynhlKl Poulsdutter w.is tiu' maiden name of Mrs. Belle Gunness. accord ing to a report just tu tde by the an-' thoriiies of the village of Selbe to the Trondhjem police The woman
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
Mayor Darrow vowed a vigorous investigation into the Gunness murder mystery, ordering all nearby ponds dragged for evidence. He also planned to investigate Pine Lake Cemetery to confirm no substitute cadaver had been buried in place of the body found in the fire.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 11 May 1908 · page 2
Murdered Four at Pary. LA PORTE, lnd.. May Id.—Murder of four pet sons w hom she had tin ted to her "house of horror” as her guests at a Christmas party, is the latest atrocity charged to Mrs. Belle G ill ness, La Porte’s arch-assassin, wuo •£ being sought today by the police of practically the whole world. From a careful examination of the unidentified bodies which have been recovered from the "soft spots" of j Brookside farm and the comparison of other evidence it Is now almost certain that the woman slayer com milled her quadruple crime ttt Christ mas night of 19u6. Jennie Olson, John Moe, of Elbow Lake. Minn., and a man and woman known only as the i "professor and his wife." were on j
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Authorities, including Sheriff Smutzer, report new evidence—melted coins and a safe deposit key—supporting the theory that Belle Gunness died in the farmhouse fire. Lamphere's lawyers meanwhile claim another man set the fire and a witness says he saw Lamphere fleeing the scene.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Perth Amboy Evening News · 11 May 1908 · page 1
NOW BELIEVE MRS. GUNNESS DIED IN FIRE
Heyburn charged that the b!ll was a land-grabbing measure, permlUmg a sin gle settler to take 3 Instead of 1 seres of ron-Srrigbl land. Mr. Heyburn pro ceeded to make good hla threat to talk the session to a close, and after an hour had passed. Mr. Nelson of Minnesota suggested to Mr. 8 moot that the conference report be withdrawn, and that course "was fol lowed. BADDER THAN MRS. GUNNESS
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
A witness claims to have seen Lamphere fleeing the burning Gunness house, and Lamphere allegedly admitted to the prosecutor that he was at the fire. Authorities remain uncertain whether the charred female body found in the ruins is Belle Gunness, as the head was destroyed and no expert identification has been made, though Lamphere will be charged with the murders of Gunness, her children, and Andrew Helgelein.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Seven=Day Crime Carnival. LAPORTE, Ind., May 19.—The issuing of a certificate of death of Jennie Olsen and the turning over of the body by Coroner Mack to her relatives in Chicago puts the official stamp of identification upon one of the bodies found at the Gunness charnel farm, re garding which there has been much controversy. The authorities believed Jennie had been a victim of her monstrous foster mother. The grand jury resumed its sessions today. Seven unidentified bodies, one female and the others males, exhumed from Mrs. Gunness's barnyard, were burled today in the potter’s field.
See moreSee less
It has developed that another of Mrs. Gunness’s victims was a woman, doubt less the “professor's” wife, who disap peared from the murder farm when Jennie Olsen, the adopted daughter, was said by Mrs. Gunness to have gone to Los Angeles to school. From this discovery it appears certain that the four victims found in the same grave were slaughtered within a week. Roy Lamphere, the former Gunness farmhand, who may suiter capital pun ishment as Mrs. Gunness's accomplice, tried to backnmil the mistress of the "House of Horrors” by threatening to send her to the gallows.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
Excursion trains brought throngs of sightseers to the Gunness farm to view the morgue and grisly relics, with many making rude comments. The sheriff plans to continue investigating by sifting through the heaps of ashes and cinders in the ruined home's cellar.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 1
THRONGS VISIT LAIR OF MODERN BORGIA
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Authorities investigating the La Porte murders say they have only begun their probe and plan to exhume a cemetery grave, believing Mrs. Gunness may have stolen a body to fake her own death. Police continue searching for her.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 11 May 1908 · page 1
STILL PROBING MURDER
i plates were encrusted win ashes hut I the bright gold caught th eye of Lout I Schultz the Vstern placer miner m soon as the object of his search roan dipped up In his gold pan n hUi rude sluice i Sheriff Hmutier who was pre en when the find was made threw his aj Into the air and let out a shout that was echoed by every one of < ho grimy dig gore who have worked early and late weekday and Sunday sifting and wasn lag the ashes and cinders Smutzer grabbed the teeth ran to his Automobile and drove full speed from the Gunness farm to give the news to States Attorney Smith who was before th Grand Jury Even to the lawyers defending Hay 1 Lamphere the former lured man er charged with arson and the murder of Mrs Gunnels and her children tho
Clipping to come
Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
Laporte's mayor vows to vigorously push the Gunness murder investigation, including dragging nearby lakes and checking Pine Lake cemetery for substituted bodies. Meanwhile, Roy Lamphere's grand jury hearing is postponed a week, and Pittsburg police investigate a reported sighting of Belle Gunness arriving by train.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Bluer the tlndlng of the iiodiea ui tier xlcllms in toat she pmauyl murdcrud four of them ut one time An autopsy yesterday show that ono of the un vlctlms j ulentillea victims was a woman It was about Christmas Iini that Sirs Gunness had John Moe of 11 bow Lake limn and a professor
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.
La Porte officials, led by Mayor Darrow, vow to intensify the investigation into the Gunness murder mystery, including dragging nearby lakes and inspecting a cemetery to rule out a substituted body. Meanwhile police pursue a woman believed to be Belle Gunness to Pittsburg, and Ray Lamphere's grand jury hearing is postponed as his attorneys claim evidence points to Gunness, not Lamphere, as the one who set the fire.
Albuquerque Citizen · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Notified to Keep a Close fL Watch (or Woman Fiend. La Porte, In J., May 11. Lemuel Darow, mayor of La Porte after a conference with prominent citizens lastnlght, declared the Investigation into the, Ounnrw murder mystery woul i be pushed with great vigor. "tieveral lakes in the vicinity of the Gunness farm will be dragged," said Darrow. "I suspect more tragedies will be discovered. We intend to push this inquiry the way is should be pushed." ll is the intention of the mayor and his friends to almi Investigate Pine luke cemetery, two miles north of the Gunness farm, with a view of sat isfying themselves thai no bodies have been removed and substituted by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gummas for the body in the tire which generally Is accepted as thul of the murderess. The grand Jury was to have met today tu consider the case of Hay Lamphtre but this procedure has been postponed a week. Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney, is anxious to bring Lamphore to trial during the term of court which opened today. The altitude of the defense has not yet been revealed. The prisoner has received stringent orders from his attorneys not to dis cuss the c.i.'rges against him with any or ;-. His attorneys claim they 1'ave "i"jof that Mrs. Gunnes and not Lamp here set tire to the house. That Andrew ll-gclein did not give up his life at the Gunness farm without a struggle Is evidenced by the fact that In one of his clinched hands was a tuft of brown hair said to closely correspond with the hair on the head of Hay Lamphere, who Is held in Jail here on the charge of murder. This new phase of the mys tery was disclosed in the deposition of Dr. J. H. William Meyer, who made an exhaustive examination of Helgciein's body. Dr. B. O. Bowell, physician to the Gunnels family, stated today it was Ills belief that Mrs. Gumiess was a Victim of epilepsy. iOoLing I 'r SUrtiMtf. Pittsburg, May 11. Police and de
Authorities in Pittsburg, Chicago, and Laporte report sightings and searches for a woman believed to be Belle Gunness, including a druggist's identification of her trying to buy chloroform. Meanwhile, investigators plan to drag nearby lakes and inspect a cemetery for evidence, while Ray Lamphere's attorneys claim proof that Gunness, not Lamphere, set the fire.
Albuquerque Citizen · 11 May 1908 · page 1
FOR MRS. GUNNESS
Notified to Keep a Close fL Watch (or Woman Fiend. La Porte, In J., May 11. Lemuel Darow, mayor of La Porte after a conference with prominent citizens lastnlght, declared the Investigation into the, Ounnrw murder mystery woul i be pushed with great vigor. "tieveral lakes in the vicinity of the Gunness farm will be dragged," said Darrow. "I suspect more tragedies will be discovered. We intend to push this inquiry the way is should be pushed." ll is the intention of the mayor and his friends to almi Investigate Pine luke cemetery, two miles north of the Gunness farm, with a view of sat isfying themselves thai no bodies have been removed and substituted by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gummas for the body in the tire which generally Is accepted as thul of the murderess. The grand Jury was to have met today tu consider the case of Hay Lamphtre but this procedure has been postponed a week. Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney, is anxious to bring Lamphore to trial during the term of court which opened today. The altitude of the defense has not yet been revealed. The prisoner has received stringent orders from his attorneys not to dis cuss the c.i.'rges against him with any or ;-. His attorneys claim they 1'ave "i"jof that Mrs. Gunnes and not Lamp here set tire to the house. That Andrew ll-gclein did not give up his life at the Gunness farm without a struggle Is evidenced by the fact that In one of his clinched hands was a tuft of brown hair said to closely correspond with the hair on the head of Hay Lamphere, who Is held in Jail here on the charge of murder. This new phase of the mys tery was disclosed in the deposition of Dr. J. H. William Meyer, who made an exhaustive examination of Helgciein's body. Dr. B. O. Bowell, physician to the Gunnels family, stated today it was Ills belief that Mrs. Gumiess was a Victim of epilepsy. iOoLing I 'r SUrtiMtf. Pittsburg, May 11. Police and de tectives are looking for Mrs. Belle Gunness here. Conductor C. D. Bur linghiini ays he brought a ivoman here on his train over the Cleveland ami Pittsburg division of the Pennsyl vania railroad yesterday morning. She bourde-j the train at. Alliance. Ohio. The conductor telephoned the po lice to board the train at Liverpool, Ohio. An officer did so but did not arrest the woman, fearing to make a mistake.
Police in multiple cities search for Belle Gunness, believed to be alive and possibly fleeing to Norway, after a Chicago druggist claims she tried to buy chloroform from him. A relative of one victim insists the body found in the fire ruins is too small to be Gunness, while Pinkerton detectives pursue a theory she was linked to a Chicago murder gang disposing of bodies in trunks.
Albuquerque Citizen · 11 May 1908 · page 1
-woman who has been at tho hotel fre quently ir lk vi is rignt Mrs. Gunness has made her dinippoarance complete. The police have been unable to find trace f her elsewhere In the city. The officers in New York have been instructed to be on the lookout for her. as she is believed to be on Iter way to Norway. Mrs. George ulander, sister of Jenti. OLsen. one of Mrs. Gunness' viei tin:s, Is positive the body In the ruins of the burned home is not that of ; Mi 4.
See moreSee less
Gunnes. This body was that of a medium-sized woman, and would not have weighed more than 130 pounds in life. Mrs. Gunness is said to have weighed close to 240 pounds, i Plnkerion detectives are working upon the theory that Mrs. Gunness was associated with a gang of Chicago murderers and disposed of the bodies of their victims, shipped here in I
Investigators report additional suspected victims of Belle Gunness, including Ole Budsberg of Iola, Wisconsin, and Olaf Lindboe, a Norwegian immigrant who reportedly planned to marry her before vanishing. Ray Lamphere, questioned with his attorney present, described his work and financial dispute with Gunness but denied digging holes or seeing trunks delivered.
Albuquerque Citizen · 11 May 1908 · page 4
Trondhjom, Norway, May 10. Bryndhl'd Poulsdnttor was tho maid en name of Mrs. Hello Gunner, whog "murder farm" nt La Porte, Ind., In America, Is now tho contei of an investigation. According to a report made by tho nuthotitloB of Solbo, a vlllago in Norway, tho woman was born there on Novomber 11, 1S50. Her only surviving reintlv In Solbo, was a alitor, who died last Friday. Th? pollco hero are convlncod that Mrs. Hollo Gunnoas did not. return to Norway.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.
Ray Lamphere gave a cool, consistent statement to investigators about his work and dispute with Mrs. Gunness over wages, denying digging holes or seeing trunks arrive. Sheriff Smutzer meanwhile received numerous inquiries about men who had vanished after corresponding with women through matrimonial agencies.
Albuquerque Citizen · 11 May 1908 · page 4
Special Correspondence to The Free* LAPORTE, Ind., May 19.— ''Whatever my enemies may say ot me, I still have a conscience. And that conscience does not accuse me of arson or murder. I can sleep well, too, for I Know that every thing will come out all right in the end." Calm, confident and without a symptom of fear in his face, Ray Lamphere made the statement in his cell here today. Tho man on whom the state of Indiana will attempt to fix the guilt of the destruction of the Gunnes, family, looked me straight in the eye when he spoke.
See moreSee less
He talked ■lowly, almost convincingly. I studied his face hard for some facial characteristics of the aver age criminal. He withstood the close scrutiny without a sign of weakness. His face remained a pic ture of absolute confidence. This kind of acting, if It Is act ing, has even the police baffled. They do not understand him. Those who remain unprejudiced by the circumstantial evidence against Lamphere declare they cannot de cide whether his facial character istics are those of a good or a bad man. Men study him closely, go away, and come back and study him again. Then they say: "He is all good or all bad. You can only see a little way into his eyes. His manner of returning your gaze is mystifying. You can't de cide." Lamphere Is easily the most re markable murder suspect Indiana has ever had. Although he has been arrested several tttmes. he has few lines In his face that indicate the demon he must he if the police ver sion of him is correct. When I saw Lamphere - just after a shay face was pleasant. His jaw was not of the common criminal type It, too, Is of the type that makes you uncertain how to classify it. The face shows something more than average intelligence, and there are no crime producing mal formations of the skull. His speech Is polite, clear-toned and exceeding ly deliberate. Lamphere impresses one, if in any decisive way, as lacking in will power You would take him at first sight for a man who has had few opportunities, poor training, hard ships, discouragement and a lack of will to overcome obstacles. This impression Is sustained In the views of Lamphere'a physician, lir It. O. Howell, and also by i.ani phere's own story of his life. "Ray Lamphere I* not a criminal in physical disposition," sa>'» Or.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A physician, Dr. H. H. Martin, tells investigators he believes Belle Gunness strangled an infant who died in November 1902, shortly after the Gunnesses brought the child to LaPorte as their own. This adds another suspected victim to the growing list of murders attributed to Gunness amid ongoing digging at her farm.
The Sun · 11 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS'S BABY A VICTIM, LAPORTE, PHYSICIAN THINKS CHILD WAS STRANGLED, POISON THOUGHT TO HAVE BEEN HER MEANS OF KILLING MANY
Special Correspondence to The Free* LAPORTE, Ind., May 19.— ''Whatever my enemies may say ot me, I still have a conscience. And that conscience does not accuse me of arson or murder. I can sleep well, too, for I Know that every thing will come out all right in the end." Calm, confident and without a symptom of fear in his face, Ray Lamphere made the statement in his cell here today. Tho man on whom the state of Indiana will attempt to fix the guilt of the destruction of the Gunnes, family, looked me straight in the eye when he spoke.
See moreSee less
He talked ■lowly, almost convincingly. I studied his face hard for some facial characteristics of the aver age criminal. He withstood the close scrutiny without a sign of weakness. His face remained a pic ture of absolute confidence. This kind of acting, if It Is act ing, has even the police baffled. They do not understand him. Those who remain unprejudiced by the circumstantial evidence against Lamphere declare they cannot de cide whether his facial character istics are those of a good or a bad man. Men study him closely, go away, and come back and study him again. Then they say: "He is all good or all bad. You can only see a little way into his eyes. His manner of returning your gaze is mystifying. You can't de cide." Lamphere Is easily the most re markable murder suspect Indiana has ever had. Although he has been arrested several tttmes. he has few lines In his face that indicate the demon he must he if the police ver sion of him is correct. When I saw Lamphere - just after a shay face was pleasant. His jaw was not of the common criminal type It, too, Is of the type that makes you uncertain how to classify it. The face shows something more than average intelligence, and there are no crime producing mal formations of the skull. His speech Is polite, clear-toned and exceeding ly deliberate. Lamphere impresses one, if in any decisive way, as lacking in will power You would take him at first sight for a man who has had few opportunities, poor training, hard ships, discouragement and a lack of will to overcome obstacles. This impression Is sustained In the views of Lamphere'a physician, lir It. O. Howell, and also by i.ani phere's own story of his life. "Ray Lamphere I* not a criminal in physical disposition," sa>'» Or.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Dr. H.H. Martin recounts how in November 1902 he was called to the Gunness home in La Porte to examine a six-month-old infant brought by the family that summer, finding only mild bronchial symptoms. Two days later the baby was dead, and though he certified the death as edema of the lungs, he now believes, given what is known about Belle Gunness, that she strangled or suffocated the child.
The Sun · 11 May 1908 · page 1
I corpse was that of Jennie Olson. The body was the first found on the farm, j Mrs. Gunness told neighbors that the I Olson girl had gone to Los Angeles. Mrs, Gunness Dead. LAPORTE, May 1?.—All doubt as to ! the fact that Mrs. Gunness died in the
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Dr. Meyer testified before the coroner that a bunch of man's hair was found clutched in the hand of one victim, suggesting Belle Gunness had a male accomplice in the killings. The report also states authorities confirmed the burned body in the ruins is Mrs. Gunness, identified by a ring and keys, while Ray Lamphere remains jailed for arson and a reward is being considered.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Sun · 11 May 1908 · page 1
AN ACCOMPLICE, SAYS DR. MEYER
I corpse was that of Jennie Olson. The body was the first found on the farm, j Mrs. Gunness told neighbors that the I Olson girl had gone to Los Angeles. Mrs, Gunness Dead. LAPORTE, May 1?.—All doubt as to ! the fact that Mrs. Gunness died in the
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
An estimated 10,000 sightseers descended on the Gunness farm on Sunday as authorities began making gruesome discoveries, arriving by foot, carriage, and chartered excursion trains from Chicago and South Bend. Vendors sold souvenir postcards depicting Gunness and her children at ten cents apiece amid carnival-like conditions that hampered methodical investigative work.
The Sun · 11 May 1908 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Thousands of sightseers roamed the Gunness farm, buying souvenir postcards and photographs from a local photographer while picnicking near the murder plot. Visitors poked at graves with sticks and impromptu digging parties searched the ruins, with guards posted at only two points.
The Sun · 11 May 1908 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report describes the Gunness farm murders near La Porte, Indiana, as one of the most gruesome crimes in American history, noting the death toll has reached sixteen. It characterizes Belle Gunness as a scheming, sordid woman who lured men to her farm, likening her to a 'female bluebeard' or 'modern Cleopatra in low life.'
Paper unidentified · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Most Grewsome Crime in History
files Ids formal verdict. heard the stories of a number of witnesses In the Gunness case. TikecellenL progress was made, but the greatest part of the week will bo consiinied in tlie Investigation.
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
Thousands of sightseers flooded LaPorte by train, trolley, and car to gawk at the ruins of Belle Gunness's farmhouse, with vendors selling postcards and souvenir hunters prying apart debris. Officials remained uncertain of Gunness's fate and the city council planned to offer a $5,000 reward for her capture.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 11 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A doctor reports finding brown hair clenched in victim Andrew Helgelien's hand, suggesting he fought his killer before death. Police reportedly lean back toward the theory that Belle Gunness died in the house fire, while a new witness describes a frightening night at her farm.
Daily Capital Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 4
GUNNESS VICTIM FOUGHT
HOUSE WHERE HER CRIMES WERE COM I MITTED—THE ARROW INDICATES SITE. i materials for (lie construction of the strange story of her career. She is ! supposed to have lured rich men to her den liy matrimonial advertisements and then made away with them for their money and also to have run a murder “fence” for the benefit of her partners in the awful trade of human slaughter, the latter operating in Chi cago and sending (lie1 bodies of their victims to her for burial. The burning of the house at La porte, in which Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness lived with her three little children a short time ago. led to the remarkable revela tions as to her history. The story of the Laporte murder farm recalls the notorious doings of, ihe 1 tender family in Montgomery county, Kan., about forty years ago, and the famous case of Ilenry 11. Holmes, who swindled insurance com panies and was held responsible for the murder of quite a long list of per sons. lie was hanged in Philadelphia. The Benders, husband and wife and son and daughter, were supposed to have murdered nine or ten persons and buried the bodies in the vicinity of their home, robbery being their mo tive. The Benders mysteriously disap peared, and their fate is unknown, al though rumors were abroad at the time that indignant citizens put an end to their infamous careers.
Clipping to come
Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon
George Anderson of Mo. claims Mrs. Gunness once hovered over him at night during a visit to answer her matrimonial ad, and now believes she meant to kill him after bodies were found on the farm. Leon Townsend of Kansas reveals he received letters from her and had planned to visit before the killings were exposed.
Daily Capital Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 4
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD. | Artificial Teeth Positively Identified at Laporte. Laporte, Ind.. May 18.—Louis Schultz, the expert | miner to-day found in the ashes of the Gunness
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Thousands of sightseers overwhelmed Laporte, Indiana to view the Gunness farm where bodies had been unearthed, with authorities also receiving new tips like Olaf Lindboe's report about his missing brother. The report notes uncertainty over whether Mrs. Gunness died in the house fire along with her children or escaped.
The Morning Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 1
LAST HEARD FROM AT GUNNESS FARM
BROTHER SINCE. Laporte, Ind.,. May 10—All roads !n La • parte county to-day led to the farm of Mrs. Bella Gunness, alleged murderess of at least 10 persons, whose bodies have been unearthed in the barnyard, and now thought to have been burned to death with her three children in a fire that de stroyed her farmhouse on April 28. Up wards of 15,000 sightseers visited the place before sunset of the first Sabbath to p.tss since the news of the mystery. Nearly every able-bodied resident of La porte went to the farm and railroads and • trolley lines brought about 4000 non-resi dents to the city.
See moreSee less
Mayor Darrew found It necessary to issue stringent orders that the Bunday closing laws be strictly enforced. Hotels and restaurnts were overrun with pa trons. Every conveyance in lAporte was pressed Into service in an attempt to pro vide transportation to the farm, which is a mile north of Laporte. Hundreds, how ever, were forced to walk. Near-by vll lages reached by electric railways were almost deserted to-day, while citizens hastened to Laporte to satisfy their curi osity. Strangers had no difficulty in find
Thousands flocked to the Gunness farm on a Sunday outing, treating the murder site like a carnival with vendors, picnics, and souvenir postcards. Amid the chaos, some visitors provided leads on missing persons, including Olaf Lindboe, who feared his brother Thomas was among the victims after losing contact with him following his engagement to Mrs. Gunness.
The Morning Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 1
had a baby cab as a nucleus. Along the roadside were several lem onade stands and lunch wagons. At the gate were venders of souvenir postal cards and those bearing a group picture of Mrs. Gunness and the three little ones who met death with her found ready sale. During the rush to Laporte in the after noon several farm horses, frightened by automobiles started to run away. A buggy was upset and Mrs. Benjamin Zanelar of Laporte suffered a broken arm. Several pickpockets did a thriving business while the throng waited for homeward-bound trains.
See moreSee less
One saloon keeper was arrested for opening his bar on Sunday. Investigation of the farm for more bod ies halted to-day. The sheriffs and other officers were forced to become spectators •also. Several visitors, however, were seeking information concerning missing friends or relatives; and some further In formation regarding the positive Identity of the victims of the farm resulted from their inquiries. • The most definite information came from Olaf Lindboe of Chicago. He said that his brother Thomas worked for Mrs. Gunness three years ago and that the last letter from Thomas said that Thomas Intended to matry Mrs. Gunness. Olaf wrote to Mrs. Gunness later and she re plied that Thomas had gone to St. Louis unrl that she had had no word from him. Olaf Lindboe has not hoard of Thomas since. He viewed the unidentified corpses
Sheriff Smutzer plans to sift cellar ashes for gold tooth fillings and dig further at the farm, while an anonymous letter claims Mrs. Gunness's body lies in a nearby pond. The defense suggests she killed her children, planted another woman's body, and fled, and plans to inspect Pine Lake Cemetery for disturbed graves.
The Morning Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 1
for a day or two. Anonymous letter, dated Chicago and received to-day by Mayor Darrow, said the mystery of the farm would be solved by the examination of the water of a pond just east ef the farm house. There, the writer said, would be discovered the corpse of Mrs. Gunness and the head of the body found In the basement of the burned house. The letter concluded: ' "Other valuable Information will be forwarded as soon as the body Is found.” Mayor Darrow’ said to-day that the de fence would Investigate the Pine l>ake ' emetery, an old burial ground about a mile from the Gunness farm Tt Is the theory of the defence that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness killed her children, placed the bodv » *s*® woman near them, sot fire to house to cover up her crime and then fled. If it is discovered that any of the graves | n Pine Lake Cemetery rav*» been Ustifbed recently, Mayor Darrow thinks that this theory will ’be more or less substantiated. Mystery Attends Finding of Woman’s Body.
A physician who performed the autopsy claims the recovered female body does not match Belle Gunness's known size, build, and physical traits. He argues the corpse is too small, too light, and shows signs of grooming inconsistent with Gunness's appearance.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Madison Daily Leader · 11 May 1908 · page 4
W0M1I STILL LIVING Body In Ruins of Gnniiess Home Not That of Murderess* NO DEVELOPMENTS IN CASE Total Bodies Recovered on the Wo man's Farm Near Laporte, Ind., Re mains at Ten and of TfMM TRfte Have Been Identified. Laporte, Ind., May 11.—Dr. H. H. IiOQg, one of the physicians who per formed the autopsy on the body of the woman found in the ruins of the Gun ness home after the fire, has made a statement that the body is not that of Mrs. Ounness. His statement is as follows: "In my opinion the body of the wo man found in the house is not that of Mra.
See moreSee less
Gunness because it Is not cor rectiy proportioned. It Is that of rather plump woman of the same gen eral contour of Mrs. Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness was literally a sueces Bion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned off was found beside the body and is well formed. The Angora show evidence of careful manicuring and that wa* something that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Basing my statements on the sta tistlcs and figures of eminent physi clans of this country and Great Brit Bin 1 find that the body at the morgue Is almost live inches shorter than the body of Mrs. Gunness would be under similar circumstances. Tho fire would, of course, cause tho body to lose weight, but the general physical out line of the woman would remain. Mra. Gunness waa a woman of unusual ap pearance. She was largo, bony, power ful looking, with square Jaws and black eyes. "She was a woman who would at tract atteution anywhere from her lack of womanly characteristics. She wore a large fur coat during the win ter and her long strides, together with her remarkable countenance and her generally vicious appearance, gave her an aspect that was almost terrify ing." No additional bodies have been un earthed on the Gunness farm, the number recovered standing at ten. Of these three have been identified.
A physical examination suggests the burned body found at the farm may be shorter than Mrs. Gunness, raising doubts about identification; meanwhile Syracuse police wrongly arrested a woman they suspected was Gunness, who quickly proved her true identity. The report also mentions a possible new victim, Gustav Thun, who vanished after corresponding with a matrimonial bureau.
The Madison Daily Leader · 11 May 1908 · page 4
WRONG WOMAN ARRESTED
Have Been Identified. Laporte, Ind., May 11.—Dr. H. H. IiOQg, one of the physicians who per formed the autopsy on the body of the woman found in the ruins of the Gun ness home after the fire, has made a statement that the body is not that of Mrs. Ounness. His statement is as follows: "In my opinion the body of the wo man found in the house is not that of Mra. Gunness because it Is not cor rectiy proportioned. It Is that of rather plump woman of the same gen eral contour of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness was literally a sueces Bion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned off was found beside the body and is well formed. The Angora show evidence of careful manicuring and that wa* something that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Basing my statements on the sta tistlcs and figures of eminent physi clans of this country and Great Brit Bin 1 find that the body at the morgue Is almost live inches shorter than the body of Mrs. Gunness would be under similar circumstances. Tho fire would, of course, cause tho body to lose weight, but the general physical out line of the woman would remain. Mra. Gunness waa a woman of unusual ap pearance. She was largo, bony, power ful looking, with square Jaws and black eyes. "She was a woman who would at tract atteution anywhere from her lack of womanly characteristics. She wore a large fur coat during the win ter and her long strides, together with her remarkable countenance and her generally vicious appearance, gave her an aspect that was almost terrify ing." No additional bodies have been un earthed on the Gunness farm, the number recovered standing at ten. Of these three have been identified.
A tuft of hair found in the clenched hand of murder victim Andrew Helgelein reportedly resembles suspect Ray Lamphere's hair, according to a deposition from examining physician Dr. Myer. Authorities continue gathering evidence against Lamphere while deciding whether to resume excavations at the Gunness farm, which have been hampered by crowds of onlookers.
Paper unidentified · 11 May 1908 · page 1
COIL FOR LAMPHERE TIGHTENS
Established by Means of a Scar. Laporte, Ind., May 11. —That An drew Helgelein did not give up his life without a struggle is evidenced by the fact that in one of his clenche I bands was a brown tuft of short hair, which is said to closely resemble the hair covering the head of Ray Lamp here, who is being held in the Laporte county jail as a suspect in the burn ing of the house on the Gunness farm and causing the death of Mrs. Gun ness and her three children, and also as a suspect in the murder of Andrew Helgelein.
See moreSee less
This new phase of th? mysteries was disclosed in the depo sition of Dr. Myer, one of the exam ining physicians who went into an ex haustive examination of Helgeleln’s body. Picking up shreads of evidence which will be relied upon to connect Lamphere with the death of Mrs. Gun ness and her three children and per haps also the fate of Andrew Helge lein, will be the main object of the authorities here today. Whether the search for more bodies will be pros ecuted has not been finally deter mined, Sheriff Snutzer indicating yes terday that further excavations may be postponed until tomorrow. The sheriff has found difficulty in carry ing on the work because of the horri bly curious persons who flocked to the place where 10 corpses were discover ed last week. Friday the excavating in the barnyard was hindered and Saturday it was halted by the crowds. It is expected, however, that the num ber of visitors will be lessened today, some 15,000 persons having inspected the grounds yesterday and presumably satiated their curiosity. The grand jury was to have met today to consid er Lamphere’s case, but this proced ure was postponed for a week.
A medical deposition on Andrew Helgelein's autopsy adds new evidence as authorities seek to connect Ray Lamphere to the deaths of Mrs. Gunness, her children, and Helgelein. Excavation at the farm continues amid massive crowds, with the grand jury hearing on Lamphere's case postponed a week.
The report recounts the Belle Gunness case, describing how victims lured by matrimonial ads disappeared at her Laporte farm, which later burned revealing a headless, burned skeleton. Investigators found ten bodies total and arrested farmhand Roy Lamphere as a suspected accomplice, while a new theory suggested the burned corpse was not Gunness herself but that she had escaped after setting the fire.
Paper unidentified · 11 May 1908 · page 1
ceipts; Hogs, 9000; cattle, 9000; sheer, 10,000. cused of being responsible for the deaths of 10 people at her farm near Laporte, Ind., and Roy Lamphere. a farm hand, who is being held as a probable accomplice. The story of these crimes rivals that of any page in the wildest fic tion. Lured from their homes by mat rimonial want ads, a number of her victims made the journey to Mrs. Gunness* home, a magnificent coun try place, near Laporte, where they mysteriously disappeared. Recently the house burned and in it was round the remains of a skeleton, supposed to be that of a woman About this time the farm hand, Lamphere, lead the officers of the law to believe that the premises concealed evidences of murder.
See moreSee less
An investigation resulted in finding 10 bodies, some of them male and some female. The queer situation excited the of ficers, who caused Lamphere’s arrest on the charge of being an accomplice in the tragedies. Then came the ques tion of identifying the corpse found in the cellar. The head was missing and the body was badly burned. Then the theory was sprung that the body was not that of Mrs. Gunness, but that she fired the house and escaped after a’ series of tragedies almost un paralleled. When the Identity of the
A relative, Mr. Larson, describes a distinctive eight-inch scar on Mrs. Gunness's chest that could help identify whether she died in the fire, noting it wasn't checked amid the confusion after the blaze. A separate anonymous letter claims Mrs. Gunness was related to notorious killer Kate Bender and suggests Ray Lamphere may be kin to her as well.
Paper unidentified · 11 May 1908 · page 8
COIL FOR LAMPHERE TIGHTENS
Another body was dug up on Mrs. Guinness' farm near Laporte, Ind., making ten found. More incriminat ing evidence against Ray Lamphere was obtained. Fully 15,000 morbid sightseers from Laporte and many other towns spent Sunday picnicing on the Gun ness farm. There were not enough vehicles in Laporte to carry them all. Three more names were added to the list of supposed victims of Mrs. Bella Gunness on her farm near La porte, Ind. Evidence was obtained by Laporte officials that Mrs. Gunness had an ac complice who aided in luring victims to her farm. Four miners were killed and three injured by a fall of rock in a colliery
Clipping to come
Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah
Thousands of sightseers descended on the Gunness farm in Laporte, overwhelming local transportation and hotels, with souvenir postcards being sold at the scene. Investigation efforts were hampered by crowds, though some visitors offered information about missing friends or relatives who might be among the unidentified victims.
Deseret Evening News · 11 May 1908 · page 8
GUNNESS FARM SIGHTSEERS MECCA
4 t 1 GUNNESS FARM y I iii SIGUTSEERSMECCA r I Thousands Visit Scene of Many liln t bid Curiosity I i Murders to Gratify Mor J l j I < J i SOUVENIR POSTALS ARE SOLD
More than 1500 local sightseers and about 4000 visitors arriving by rail and trolley descended on the La Porte, Indiana farm where the murders occurred. The mayor had to enforce Sunday closing laws amid the crush, and investigation by authorities was to resume the next day.
The Salt Lake Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1
HUNDREDS OF CURIOUS ONES VISITED FARM
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Officials and the sheriff were overwhelmed by crowds of out-of-town visitors arriving at the Gunness farm by train, many searching for information about missing relatives who might be among the unidentified victims. Olaf Lindboe of Chicago offered the most definite lead, reporting his brother Thomas had worked for Mrs. Gunness and planned to marry her, but he could not identify any of the decayed remains as his brother.
The Salt Lake Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Thousands of spectators arrived in La Porte by train, excursion cars, and various vehicles to see the Gunness farm where bones and remains had been found. Roads were choked with traffic as crowds numbering in the thousands came from Elkhart, Indianapolis, and other towns to view the site.
The Salt Lake Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Sheriff Smutzer plans to continue his investigation at the Gunness farm, sifting ashes and cinders in the cellar for Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings. Hundreds of curious visitors swarmed Laporte, causing traffic congestion, a buggy accident, and pickpocket complaints, while ten bodies have reportedly already been unearthed.
The Salt Lake Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2
HUNDREDS OF CURIOUS ONES VISITED FARM
People are crowding the Gunness farm, viewing the grewsome bone piles and eating picnic dinners un der the shade on the neighboring lawn, and generally appear to be having' a good time. Pictures show ing groups of people curiously and joyfully examining the collections of bones representing the victims of Mrs. Gunness,' will no doubt appear on the market in due time.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A brief newspaper aside jokes that Belle Gunness and the earlier murderess Kate Bender must be related, since 'the devil was the daddy of both.' It reflects early public commentary during the unfolding investigation into Gunness's crimes.
The Salt Lake Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 4
Ruins So She Is Prob ably Dead Laporte* Ind., May 19.—-If any thing additional were needed to prove the contention of Sheriff Smut zer and Prosecutor Smith that Mrs. Bella Gunness, at whose door are laid a dozen deaths, two husbands an ten others people, was really dead, it was supplied today when Lewis Schultz, an expert, found in the ashes of the Gunness house, the upper and lower bridges contain ing the false teeth of the woman. Smutzer is investigating the claim that William Redinger, a farmer, at ness' victims.
See moreSee less
In a letter received today David Dicken, a friend, living at Waukesha, Wis., tells of the dis appearance from home of Rieding, ness, sold some crops which netted him one thousand dollars and left for some place in Northern Indiana, who after a visit from Mrs. Gun* 'to marry a wealthy widow," he said. Miss Jennie Graham of Waukesha, Wis., is seeking her brother, who left home to marry a rich widow In Indiana and was never heard from after that. What is considered positive proof that Henry Gurholt of Scandivian, Wis., came to Laporte, and was put "out of the way by Mrs. Gunness, was exposed today when Sheriff Smutzer received a letter containing the de scription of him which tallies with one ofthe watches found in the ruins. He had with him one hundred dol lars when he came to Laporte.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
The report claims Belle Gunness's burned body was identified with no doubt among those who know the evidence, found alongside her three children in the fire that destroyed her house on April 28. It also describes forensic evidence that murder victim Andrew Helgelien fought his killer, with hairs found in his clenched hand that could belong to either Gunness or Ray Lamphere.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Alexandria Gazette · 11 May 1908 · page 2
Report Mrs. Gunness Dead
IS MRS. GVNNESS ALIVE? The world is reluctant to believe that Mrs. Gunness, the arch fiend of La porte, Ind., who made a trade of enticing men to her pretty farmhouse, murder ing them for their money and then dismembering them and burying them in her private cemetery, was burned in her house. There has been no positive identification of the female body found in the ruins, as the head has not been found. The theory that the monster, after firing her house to get rid of her children and make it appear that she perished in the flames, fled to enjoy in other scenes and under another name the fruits of her awful crimes, is, how ever, disproven by the finding of her false teeth in the debris of the house.
See moreSee less
But the world would rather the woman did not perish, in the hope that human jus tice may reach her. A PATERSON CHAMBER OF COMMERCE.
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
A doctor's examination of Andrew Helgelien's exhumed body revealed a lock of hair clutched in his hand, suggesting he struggled against his killer before dying. The finding indicates he was not killed instantly but fought desperately before the fatal blow.
The Spokane Press · 11 May 1908 · page 1
LOCK OF HAIR FOUND IN DEAD VICTIM'S HAND
Lampher· Trial Far Off. The grand Jury continued its labors on the case of Hay Lamphere, charged with the murder of the Gunness fam ily. Prosecutor Smith is of the opin ion that the entire week may be con sumed before the grand Jury Is ready to make its report. There is little ei pectation that the trial of Ray Lam phere will take place this spring, al though State Attorney Smith made the statement that bo will be ready for trial next week. τSheriff Smutzer Is Investigating the claim that William Rledlnger, a farm er at Delafleld, Wis., was one of Mrs. Gunness' victims. In a letter received
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The coroner reports finding several brown curly hairs clenched in the fist of Andrew Helgelein, the first body discovered buried on the Gunness farm, suggesting he pulled them from his killer during a struggle. Police now doubt the original theory that Belle Gunness herself died in the fire that destroyed her home.
The Spokane Press · 11 May 1908 · page 1
CLUE TO THE CRIMES - ANDREW HELGBLEIN - His Body Was the First One Found Buried on the Gunness Farm
What is considered proof that Hen fry Gurholdt of Scandinavia, Wis., came to Laporte and was put out of the way ly Mrs. Gunness was supplied when Sheriff Smutzer received a letter con taining a description of Gurholdt'a ,watch, which tallies with one of the watches found in the ruins of the burn ed house. Gurholdt had $1,600 In cash when he left home to come to Laporte to see lilrs. Gunness, with whom he had cor responded. Coroner Mack prepared his reports on the fire remaining skeletons of uniden tified dead, but no formal findings *were entered. The seven unidentified tlead were burled in the potter's field.
Clipping to come
The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.
Dr. Meyer reported finding brown curly hairs clenched in the fist of Andrew Helgelien's corpse, suggesting he fought desperately against his killer before dying. Police now lean toward accepting the theory that Mrs. Gunness herself died in the fire that destroyed her home.
The Evening Statesman · 11 May 1908 · page 1
FOUGHT SLAYER TO THE LAST
FOUND FALSE TEETH OF MRS. BELLE GUNNESS La Porte, Ind., May 20. In sluic ing the -ashes today at the Gunness farm the upper and lower plates which came from Mrs. Gunness' mouth were found. They were identified by the dentist who made one of the plates. This is considered proof positive that the woman is dead.
Clipping to come
The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
The Laporte County grand jury convened to investigate the Gunness murders and the fate of Andrew Helgelein, with authorities gathering evidence connecting Ray Lamphere to the deaths. A tuft of hair resembling Lamphere's was found clenched in Helgelein's hand, suggesting he fought for his life.
The Daily Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 1
GRAND JURY TO TAKE HAND
Have Died in the House of Mystery IAPOUTE Ind Mav OThat nay Iriunphere who Is held In Jail on enrptclon of having caused the deaths of Mrs Gunness and others at the Gun ne farm may have returned to tho home of Ellrabjih Smith after MttlnB
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
Laporte's mayor Samuel Darrow announces the Gunness murder investigation will be pushed hard, with nearby lakes dragged and Pine cemetery checked to ensure no bodies were swapped for the one found in the fire. Meanwhile the grand jury session on suspect Ray Lamphere has been postponed a week, and his attorneys have ordered him not to discuss the case.
The Laramie Republican · 11 May 1908 · page 1
MAYOR OF LAPORTE TO PUSH GUNNESS CASE
pushed.” Will Investigate Cemetery. It is tlhe intention of the mayor and his friends to also investigate the Pine cemetery, two miles north of the Gunness tarm, with the view of satisfying themselves that no bodies have been removed and substituted by Mrs. Gunness for the body found in the fire, which generally is asserted as iliat of the murderess.
A deposition reveals Andrew Hengelin died fighting back, with hair resembling Roy Lamphere's found in his clenched fist, while a doctor suggests Belle Gunness suffered from epilepsy. Meanwhile, a train conductor and police report possible sightings of Mrs. Gunness alive in Ohio and Pennsylvania, and authorities investigate a related bombing attempt in Chicago aimed at silencing witnesses.
The Laramie Republican · 11 May 1908 · page 1
a charge of murder. Disclosed in Deposition. This new phase of the mystery was disclosed In the deposition of Dr. J. H. Williams-Meyer, who made an ex . haustive examination of Hengelin’s . body. Dr. B. O. Bowell, physician to > the Gunness family, stated today that 1 it was his belief that Mrs. Gunness , was a victim of epilepsy.
Investigation continues at the Gunness farm, delayed by rain, as Sheriff Smutzer and Louis Schultz prepare to sluice ashes from the burned cellar to help identify the body believed to be Mrs. Gunness. Dr. Meyer's autopsy report reveals Andrew Helgelein had a mass of hair clenched in his severed fingers, suggesting a violent struggle, while the prosecutor denied reports of a ring found on the charred corpse's hand.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
EVIDENCES OF STRUGGLE
Stanley V*aber for the short term, j There should be more candidates for ln'se positions in order to make the lection interesting. . The age of wonders has not yet passed, 'he democratic state convention of Washington placed a prohibition plank m its platform. The republicans put a <>cal option plank in their platform and iie democrats went them one bettor. IVrily, temperance leaven is working. Nevada will yet feel its effects. It is now l>elieved thet Mrs. Gunness, he La Porte, murderess, perished in
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Dr. Meyer's autopsy findings reveal that both Andrew Helgelein and Jennie Olsen died unnatural deaths, with Helgelein's body showing signs of a violent struggle including a mutilated hand clutching hair. Meanwhile, officials denied two previously circulated rumors: that a gold ring was found on the charred corpse's hand, and that the Gunness children reported being beaten before the fire.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
EVIDENCES OF STRUGGLE
Stanley V*aber for the short term, j There should be more candidates for ln'se positions in order to make the lection interesting. . The age of wonders has not yet passed, 'he democratic state convention of Washington placed a prohibition plank m its platform. The republicans put a <>cal option plank in their platform and iie democrats went them one bettor. IVrily, temperance leaven is working. Nevada will yet feel its effects. It is now l>elieved thet Mrs. Gunness, he La Porte, murderess, perished in
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Examiners describe Andrew Helgelein's exhumed body, noting signs of a death struggle, a mutilated clenched hand holding reddish-brown hair, and a severed wrist, with officials unable yet to determine cause of death. Former farmhand Emil Greening separately claims Mrs. Gunness may have killed three victims a month and suggests searching old stump holes on the property for bodies.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
EMIL GREENING TALKS.
Mra. Gunness. LA -PORTE, May 19,-That Mrs. Bella Gunness died in the flames which destroyed her home on April 28 was conclusively shown today when the searcher in the ruins discov ered the upper and lower bridges con taining the false ttcth of the woman The lower set of teeth tally exactly with the description and diagram furnished by Dr. Norton, the dentist who built the bridge and who today identified the teeth positively as those of Mrs. Gunness. In view of this un mistakable evidence including the find ing one week ago of rings belonging to the murderess, Coroner Mack stat ed today that he would render an official rinding that the burnt adult female body was that of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness. Tonight a few skeptical persons remain and their argument is j that Mrs. Gunness after killing the children and setting fire to the house threw her teeth in the fire.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
A brief sarcastic note warns that no large, fierce-looking woman should travel freely until Mrs. Gunness is caught or the headless body found in the ruins is confirmed as hers. It mockingly ties this uncertainty to an unrelated jibe about Andrew Carnegie.
Arizona Republican · 12 May 1908 · page 2
Bryan. He knows. No "large,"" fierce looking'' woman ought to set out on & journey, beyond the reach of means of ready identifi cation, until Mrs. Gunness has been captured or until it is proved that the headless corpse in the ruins of the OJunness home is her's. There is a report abroad that Mr, Carnegie has taken to writing poetry, but it must be remembered that great men are sometimes outrageously slan dered, u tiff A Now Jersey preacher advises hus bands always to allow their wives to
Rain hampered excavation at the Gunness farm, but Sheriff Smutzer and Louis Schultz worked between showers to clear debris and bricks from the basement where the house burned. The sluicing operation aims to find evidence about the identity of the woman's body found in the ruins, which some believe to be Mrs. Gunness.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
SOLVING FARM MYSTERY, Mining Operations Begin To-day on Ashes of Gunness' House
The end came suddenly and unex pectedly. A fall of rock and coal in the Prospect colliery at Midvale, Pa., killed four mine workers and injured three others. Little apparent headway has been made toward solving the mystery of the fourteen deaths thus far discovered on the farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness near
Clipping to come
The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.
Coroner's physician Dr. Meyer, during a second examination of the body found in the ruins of the Gunness home, discovered three rings on the hand—a plain gold band inscribed with initials and two diamond rings—matching jewelry acquaintances said Mrs. Gunness wore. The find is described as largely removing doubt that the body was hers, while a separate report notes Norwegian police have found no trace of her background despite a week of searching.
Judging from the number of wit nesses subpoenaed by the prosecution in the Barnes murder case. Walla Walla county will have a pretty penny to pay. It is deplorable that the tax payers' good money, must of necessi ty be expended in thi s manner, yet so ciety and the law demands that crime be punished. Let us be thankful that it is not a Gunness horror or a Thaw
A disturbed grave near the Gunness farm was found empty, fueling speculation that a corpse was stolen to impersonate Belle Gunness's headless body. Doctors also noted the body lacks a scar her nephew says she had, deepening doubts about her death.
Judging from the number of wit nesses subpoenaed by the prosecution in the Barnes murder case. Walla Walla county will have a pretty penny to pay. It is deplorable that the tax payers' good money, must of necessi ty be expended in thi s manner, yet so ciety and the law demands that crime be punished. Let us be thankful that it is not a Gunness horror or a Thaw
A disturbed grave and empty coffin fuel theories that Mrs. Gunness faked her death using a headless corpse, as the body lacks a scar her nephew says she had. Investigators pursue identification through gold tooth ash-panning and hair found clenched in victim Helgelein's severed fingers, possibly matching suspect Ray Lamphere.
Death Farm. Laporte, Ind., May 15.—"There is no question but that the piece of jaw bone found on the Gunness farm Thursday is from a human being. Furthermore it bears a strong resem blance to the lower jaw of Mrs. Gun ness." This positive statement of identi fication was made by Dr. I. P. Norton, the dentist who performed a large amount of work on the teeth of the
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Reports from La Porte describe lingering local belief that Belle Gunness may still be alive despite evidence from the farm, with suspect Ray Lamphere jailed for her murder and that of Andrew Helgelein. It also notes a tuft of hair found clutched in Helgelein's dead hand, suggesting a violent struggle, and plans to sift the burned house's ashes for Gunness's gold dental fillings.
Three more names were added to I th» list of supposed victims of Mrs. Bella Gunness on her farm near La porte. Ind. Evidence was obtained hr Laporte officials that Mrs. Gunness had an ac complice who aided in luring victifhs to her farm. A. K. Helgelein. last of the victims of Mrs. Gunness, was buried at La pone The fragments of jawbone found in the ruins of the farmhouse were identified by a dentist as from
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
An exhumation found a tuft of brown hair in Andrew Helgelein's clenched hand, said to closely match Ray Lamphere's hair, suggesting he fought for his life. The grand jury's consideration of Lamphere's case was postponed a week as prosecutors strengthened evidence, including the discovery of his trunk containing letters.
The San Francisco Call · 12 May 1908 · page 1
HAIR BROWN LIKE SUSPECT'S
This Spring. Lapbrte, Ind., May 20. Louis Schultz, the expert miner, found In the ashes of the Gunness house the uppei and lower bridges, containing what the officials. here pronounce the false teeth of Mrs. Belle Gunness, who, It It thought, murdered a dozen persons. The lower set of teeth tally exactly with the description and diagram fur nished by Dr. I. r. Norton, the dentist who built the bridge and who identi fied the teeth positively as those of Mrs. Gunness. In view of the unmis takable evidence, Coroner Mack stated that he would probably render an offi cial jflndlng that the burned adult fe male body was that of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness. Dr. Norton, who built the lowei bridge, said: "The upper jaw was probably bridg ed In Chicago, but the work done in the lower Jaw I can positively identify as that done by me about a year ago. At that time I made a lower anterior bridge for Mrs. Gunness, consisting of six dummies and two crowns for the two remaining teeth, making a total of eight teeth, and swung them from the lower two cuspids. The gold In the rear of the crowns was of solid 18 carat and bears my private style of workmanship, thus eliminating any possibility that the teeth are those of any one else."
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A railroad conductor claimed to recognize a female passenger as the La Porte murderess and alerted police, who sent an officer to meet the train. Also reported: Ray Lamphere's father arrives to assist in his son's defense but is denied a jailhouse interview.
The San Francisco Call · 12 May 1908 · page 5
PITTSBURG ON QUI VIVE
It will be a sad blow to would-be detectives all over the country If Mrs. Gunness was really burned. Something wrong about that story from Pittsburg about the Indictment
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
George Anderson of Tarkio, Mo. tells reporters that his lack of money is likely what saved him from being murdered by Mrs. Gunness near La Porte, and he is traveling to Chicago to give authorities his testimony and letters from her. He claims Gunness is still alive, set her own farmhouse on fire, and that her eldest daughter knew of her crimes; separately, the passage also reports a woman suspected of being Gunness was tracked by train but not arrested due to police caution after a prior misidentification in Rochester, N.Y.
The San Francisco Call · 12 May 1908 · page 5
POVERTY SAVED HIM
It will be a sad blow to would-be detectives all over the country If Mrs. Gunness was really burned. Something wrong about that story from Pittsburg about the Indictment
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Investigators at the ruined Gunness farm report progress despite rain halting excavation, as Sheriff Smutzer prepares equipment to sift ashes in the cellar. A doctor's deposition reveals that victim Andrew Helgelein died struggling, with a tuft of hair resembling suspect Ray Lamphere's found clenched in his hand.
Los Angeles Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
DEAD HAND HOLDS HAIR IMPORTANT CLEW FOUND IN GUNNESS CASE HELGELEIN STRUGGLED TO SAVE HIS LIFE
SAY MRS. GUNNESS IS STILL LIVING LAPORTE, Ind., May 21—In spite of evidence to show that she died In tho lire which destroyed her home. Mrs. Belle Guinness was alive on May 4, a
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Examining physicians report finding a tuft of hair matching Ray Lamphere's in the clenched hand of murder victim Andrew Helgelein, while sluicing operations begin to search cellar ashes for Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings. A Polish farmhand testifies he dug holes at Mrs. Gunness's direction that were later found to contain bodies, and a doctor claims she suffered from epilepsy.
Los Angeles Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
dences of More Bodies on “Murder Farm.” LA FORTE, Ind., May 21.—Observers ‘of the Gunness case anticipate that the big murder mystery is likely to be thrown anew before the public in a manner as sensationa! as its first ap pearance, Saveral new spots of susoiclous ap peerance were discovered vesterday on the Gunness premises, and Shenifl Sraut Zer. announced that digging for new bbdies will be resumed on Friday, by which time the sluicing operations at the ruins of the farmhouse will have been
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
A miner sluices the burned cellar for gold tooth fillings while a witness describes digging pits later found to contain bodies. The grand jury convenes to investigate the murders, and Lamphere's case is postponed as new evidence—his trunk with letters—emerges implicating him.
Los Angeles Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Zer. announced that digging for new bbdies will be resumed on Friday, by which time the sluicing operations at the ruins of the farmhouse will have been finished and indictments probably will have been returned against Ray Lam phere, The position of the State in Lam phere’s case was materially strengthens ed yesterday a*ernecn by the formal verdict on the death of Mrs. Delle Gun ness, rendered by Coroner C. S. Mack. In this report the coroner said: “It is my verdict that th+ body so ‘viewed is that of Belle Gunness; that she came to her death through felonious ‘ homicide, and that the perpetrator” thereof is to me unknown.” Mrs.
See moreSee less
H. Whitzer, of Toledo, Chic, ar ‘rived in town vesterday morning to in vestigate the report that her daughter, who, in 1902 attended the University of Valparaiso, Ind., nine m.les west of La Porte, was among Mrs, Gunness* vic tims, The body of Jennie Olson, of Chicago, was buried yesterday afternoon. William Mingay., formerly coachman for a wealthy family at 66 West Fifty ‘second street, New York, may have fallen a vietim to Mrs. Gunness. He left New York about April 1, 1904, pre. sumably for the Gunness far a,
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
A new clew involving a dead hand holding hair is reported to strengthen the case against Lamphere as an accomplice, while physicians' post-mortem findings reportedly contradict the defense's claims. The report also notes widespread public belief that Belle Gunness may still be alive, which could complicate jury selection, and includes a man's account of narrowly escaping her due to his lack of money.
Los Angeles Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 2
DEAD HAND HOLDS HAIR IMPORTANT CLEW FOUND IN GUNNESS CASE HELGELEIN STRUGGLED TO SAVE HIS LIFE
(Continued from Pax* One) them by Lamphere's attorneys, while the facts found by four physicians who performed post mortem examinations on the corpses do not bear out the con- : tentions of tho defense. It is thought, ! , hotv«ver, that Lamphere's attorneys 1 have concealed carefully the chief points upon which they will rely, en deavoring meanwhile to swing public opinion in favor of tho prisoner. Political and business friends of the attorneys have been busy discussing the case wherever opportunity afford ed. the argument being mainly that i Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was too shrewd a woman to b« caught in a tiro and thai She might therefore have escaped. Prose cutor Smith denounces these methods, but there is no painsaylng the fact that the Impression that Mrs. Ounness Is still alive is widespread, despite the almost total absence of evidence to support it. This circumstance will make tho task of picking a trial Jury difficult, and there is scarcely a man or woman in the community who has not formed or expressed an opinion on the subject. Talesmen from the rural dis tricts, however, may lighten the labors of the attorneys in this regard.
George Anderson describes answering one of Mrs. Gunness's matrimonial ads two years earlier, then fleeing her farm after she pressed him for money and he found another man (whom he now believes was Ray Lamphere) with her. He is traveling to Chicago to give authorities his letters and testimony, believing Gunness set the fire herself and remains alive.
An anonymous Austin, Illinois resident recounts suspicions that Belle Gunness tried to poison her husband Sorenson before his death, describing her as degraded and violent-tempered. The report also covers nationwide manhunt leads, including a Kansas horse dealer she solicited and a possible sighting by Pittsburgh police based on a train conductor's tip.
Los Angeles Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 2
BEFORE SORENSON'S DEATH
Saturday last Kinil Greening, a car penter, and Fred Greening, his brother. ii painter, who live here and worked last summer on tin Gunness farm in Laporte, gave circumstantial details of the mysterious arrival nml disappear ance of h d<>7.' n different men at the Gunness place. The man quoted today In an Interview Is not one of tho Green ings.
The report notes Mrs. Gunness (or Guinness) conducted a 'land office business' at La Porte, Indiana, implying she lured many victims to her farm. It observes that in digging up the land, investigators found many people who had paid dearly—with their lives—to know her, and doubts that one woman alone could have committed such extensive crimes.
Evening Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 4
FARM HOUSE. LA PORTE, Ind., May 21.—That Ray Lamphere, held in jail on sus picion of having caused the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and others at the Gunness farm, may have returned to the home of Elizabeth Smith after setting fire to the Gunness house and then made another start for the Wheatbrook farm, where he was employed, 1 b a new theory ad vanced by the state. Representatives of the prosecu tion profess to have discovered evi dence to show that not only was Lamphere seen to go towards the Gunness house at about 3:30 on the morning of April 28 but that he was also seen to retrace his steps.
See moreSee less
This was at about the time that other witnesses will testify they saw lire shooting from the Gunness house. This new theory is that after re turning to the Smith house Lam phere made A fresh start for the country about an hour after the first departure, but that on his second trip he took the Guenther road, from which he could have seen the lire. If the state is able to fully sup port this theory it will be a blow to Lamphere's defense, for the ac cused is somewhat relying on an ali bi that will show that he went north that morning on the Guen ther road about an hour after the fire was started. Mrs. H. Whitzer of Toledo, O., ar rived today to investigate whether her daughter, who in 1902 attended the University of Valparaiso, 10 miles west of La Porte, was among Mrs. Gunness' victims. The girl disappeared from school after writ ing her mother that she was going on a visit. She was never heard of afterwards.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A photograph accompanies the report showing excavated graves on Mrs. Gunness's farm in La Porte, Indiana, from which bodies were taken. The image documents the ongoing search of the property for victims.
New-York Tribune · 12 May 1908 · page 4
SEEKING BODIES ON MRS. GUNNESS'S FARM
FARM HOUSE. LA PORTE, Ind., May 21.—That Ray Lamphere, held in jail on sus picion of having caused the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and others at the Gunness farm, may have returned to the home of Elizabeth Smith after setting fire to the Gunness house and then made another start for the Wheatbrook farm, where he was employed, 1 b a new theory ad vanced by the state. Representatives of the prosecu tion profess to have discovered evi dence to show that not only was Lamphere seen to go towards the Gunness house at about 3:30 on the morning of April 28 but that he was also seen to retrace his steps.
See moreSee less
This was at about the time that other witnesses will testify they saw lire shooting from the Gunness house. This new theory is that after re turning to the Smith house Lam phere made A fresh start for the country about an hour after the first departure, but that on his second trip he took the Guenther road, from which he could have seen the lire. If the state is able to fully sup port this theory it will be a blow to Lamphere's defense, for the ac cused is somewhat relying on an ali bi that will show that he went north that morning on the Guen ther road about an hour after the fire was started. Mrs. H. Whitzer of Toledo, O., ar rived today to investigate whether her daughter, who in 1902 attended the University of Valparaiso, 10 miles west of La Porte, was among Mrs. Gunness' victims. The girl disappeared from school after writ ing her mother that she was going on a visit. She was never heard of afterwards.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
At La Porte, excavation of the Gunness farm continued despite rain, with sheriff and workers preparing to sluice cellar ashes to search for Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings. Dr. Meyer's autopsy report revealed a mass of hair clenched in the severed hand of murder victim Andrew Helgelein, suggesting a struggle with his killer.
New-York Tribune · 12 May 1908 · page 4
HAND CLASPED HAIR
Farm Tonight. Laporte. Ind., May 21. Sheriff Smutzer will this evening finish the sluicing of the debris of the Gunness house and tomorrow morning he will resume digging In the hope of finding more bodies. Mayor Darrow received an unsigned letter from Omaha, Neb., the writer claiming to have been in Laporte three times last year to visit Mrs. Gunness and to have met her in Ogden, Utah, on May 4, when she said she was on her way to California to visit Jennie Olsen. Inquiries were received today by the authorities regarding George W. Will lams of Wapawallopen. Pa., who is un derstood by friends to have come to Laporte. in answer to matrimonial advertisements from a rich widow. He never returned home.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Dr. Mayer's coroner report described a mass of hair found clenched in the fist of a body believed to be Andrew Helgelein, with severed fingers still grasping it. The report also covers autopsy findings on remains thought to be Jennie Olsen, Mrs. Gunness's foster daughter.
New-York Tribune · 12 May 1908 · page 4
HAND CLASPED HAIR
Laporte, Ind., May 17. The burial Friday night of Andrew M, Helgeleln marks the beginning of the final stage of the Qunness farm, mysteries so far as human knowledge is concerned. Two more corpses, supposed to have been those of Jennie Olsen and Ole O. Budsberg, have been partially iden tified but to the Identity of the remain ing cadavers no clew exists that gives promise of fulfillment. The relics tak en from the death farm, such as watches and rings, may ultimately lead to the determination that some cer tain missing individual wad caught In the Gunness trap but this will give
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State Attorney Smith and Pinkerton detectives believe the charred body at Cutler's morgue is indeed Mrs. Gunness, and that Ray Lamphere set fire to her house, likely out of revenge. The report notes lingering questions about whether she is alive, whether she killed herself and her children, and how the prosecution plans to present its case to a grand jury.
The Washington Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
LETTERS FORM CLEW / GUNNESS CASE NOT CLEARED
Fuller who now holds the place would soon resign and it is not customary to appoint one of tho Associate Jus tices chief Mr Root is probably tho moat brilliant lawyer in flits country and there is no reason to believe that he will not make a great Chief Jus tics but ho was in his younger years connected with several big trusts and for that reason he will bo violently opposed by many men As Roosevelt has a sort of reputation for hating the trusts and as he has been In close contact with Mr Root for years it is likely that Mr Root Is pretty safe for tho country MRS iUNNESS DEAD Positive proot that Mrs Gunness tho great murderess was burned In the rulna of her home was found Tuesday when miners discovered the false teeth plates which bad been fastened In her moiith
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State Attorney Smith and detectives, including Pinkertons, conclude that the charred body is that of Mrs. Gunness and that Ray Lamphere set the fire, while defense counsel argues Lamphere feared her too much to kill her and suggests suicide or substitution theories instead. Smith promises startling new evidence at the upcoming inquest to prove Lamphere's guilt.
The Washington Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
Loporte IndThe first of tho Oun ness victims to be Interred with Chris tlon rites was burled Friday night In 1atlonn cemetery on the outskirts of aporte Tho corpse was that of Andrew K Helgeleln of Mansfield S D the last man to meet his death In the trap to which Mn Gunness lured her victims The body was released for burial after Coroner Mack had received the reports of the Dertlllon experts who hare examined It and compared their findings with figures taken from the records of the Minnesota penitentiary at Still water
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
States Attorney Smith is assembling evidence for an inquest convening Wednesday, promising startling testimony to prove Ray Lamphere's guilt. A witness, George Anderson, is expected to testify that Mrs. Gunness nearly killed him after he admitted his farm story was false.
The Washington Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith and Pinkerton detectives believe the charred body is Mrs. Gunness and that Lamphere set the fire, while defense counsel argues Lamphere feared her too much to kill her, suggesting suicide or a substituted corpse instead. Evidence is being gathered for an inquest set to convene Wednesday.
The Washington Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
LETTERS FORM CLEW
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD tLATE8 CONTAINING HER FAL8E 1 TEETH FOUND IN A8HE8. Sheriff Still Trying to Qet Evldtnca at Gunnesa Farm Grand Jury Bs gins Its Work at Laportt Offlcar
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Smith prepares evidence for the inquest, asserting Lamphere set fire to the house and murdered the Gunness family, while defense counsel argues for suicide or that Mrs. Gunness killed her children and faked her own death. A witness named George Anderson is expected to testify about a frightening night at the Gunness home and possibly identify Lamphere as her accomplice.
The Washington Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
GUNNESS CASE NOT CLEARED
Tho Laporte grand Jury convened ond began investigation of tho mys tery surrounding the death of fourteen persons nt tho farm of Mrs. Bello Gun ness. Prosecutor Smith questioned tho wltncssos and the testimony is be ing noted by a court stenographer. Prosecutor Smith received another threatening letter from Brooklyn, N. Y. Ho Is threatened with death un Icsb he resigns his office and drops the Gunness Investigation. He also re ceived a threatening letter from "Washington, D. C. Chief of Police Cochrane is In receipt of a letter from New York saying his life will pay for feit unless ho ceases his activity. The bodies of tho sovon unidentified dead will bo buried In tho pottersfleld.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Authorities plan to confront witness Anderson with suspect Ray Lamphere to test an accomplice theory, while a locked room full of men's clothing fuels fears of more victims. Experts will examine Helgelein's stomach for poison and sift cellar debris for gold teeth, though a tuft of hair found in his hand complicates the murder theory.
The Washington Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
GUNNESS CASE NOT CLEARED
Tho Laporte grand Jury convened ond began investigation of tho mys tery surrounding the death of fourteen persons nt tho farm of Mrs. Bello Gun ness. Prosecutor Smith questioned tho wltncssos and the testimony is be ing noted by a court stenographer. Prosecutor Smith received another threatening letter from Brooklyn, N. Y. Ho Is threatened with death un Icsb he resigns his office and drops the Gunness Investigation. He also re ceived a threatening letter from "Washington, D. C. Chief of Police Cochrane is In receipt of a letter from New York saying his life will pay for feit unless ho ceases his activity.
See moreSee less
The bodies of tho sovon unidentified dead will bo buried In tho pottersfleld. Mrs. Gunness' Teeth Found. That Mrs. Gunness died In tho ames which destroyed her home April 28 was conclusively shown when a searcher In the ruins discovered tlw upper and lower bridges, containing tho false teeth of the woman. Tho lower set of teeth tally exactly with tho description nnd diagram furnished Ty Dr. I. P. Norton, tho dentist, who "built the bridge, and who identified the teeth positively as thoso of Mrs. Gunness. in view qf the unmistakablo evidence, including the finding ouo week ago of rings belonging to tho murderess, Coroner Mack stated that ho would render an ofllclal finding that (he burned adult female body was that of Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Dr. Gray's previously suppressed autopsy report details three rings found on the corpse believed to be Belle Gunness, with inscriptions that puzzle officials since they don't clearly match known names. A gold-crowned molar was also found in the cellar debris, believed to belong to Mrs. Gunness, as Sheriff Smutzer prepared to sluice the ashes for further evidence.
Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 1
FORGING THE LINK IN LATE CRIME
While mucl), is said about the work of plowing up bones on the Gunness farm, no reference is made to the condition of this year’s wheat and . corn crops on the place. Are the crops suffering neglect while the vic tims of Mrs. Gunness are being col lected and invoiced? People are mistaken in assuming more right to hurt another by insin uation than by direct charges. Hint ing at “graft” is no more just, With out proof, than a positive allegation, for the injurious effect from the for mer may equal that from the latter, and it is the effect that counts.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Investigators examine jewelry found in the Gunness fire debris, including inscribed rings whose owners remain unidentified, and a gold-crowned tooth believed to be from Belle Gunness's skull. Autopsy reports on the adult female and infant bodies conclude the exact cause of death cannot be determined, while Sheriff Smutzer begins sluicing the ashes for further evidence.
Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 1
While mucl), is said about the work of plowing up bones on the Gunness farm, no reference is made to the condition of this year’s wheat and . corn crops on the place. Are the crops suffering neglect while the vic tims of Mrs. Gunness are being col lected and invoiced? People are mistaken in assuming more right to hurt another by insin uation than by direct charges. Hint ing at “graft” is no more just, With out proof, than a positive allegation, for the injurious effect from the for mer may equal that from the latter, and it is the effect that counts.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The report discusses forensic theories about how victims were killed, including possible use of a dirk-like weapon, chloroform, and poison, with evidence of a struggle by Andrew Helgelein. It also describes a neighbor's account suggesting Belle Gunness concealed knives on her body, and notes the defense team adding attorney Ellsworth E. Weir as the grand jury session continues.
Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Porte are completed no one will be in a position to say whether LaPorte has a horror or a mystery. If all reports be confirmed, then, indeed, we will have to accept the Italian proverb: "The woman is seldom wicked, but when she is, she surpasses the man."
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Prosecutor Smith is preparing depositions to bring charges against Ray Lamphere before the grand jury, possibly as soon as Thursday, though the process depends on Coroner Mack receiving physicians' reports on the Gunness bodies. A Chicago Tribune dispatch claims officials expect a complete solution to the murder farm mystery within 48 hours.
Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 2
SOLUTION NEAR AT HAND
today. A few days ago this investigation was postponed until May 18, but yesterday Prosecutor Smith again declared himself ready to proceed and last night he prepared the depositions which the sheriff and his deputies will swear to ? for grand Jury purposes. Most of the criminal cases In this state are presented to the court on affidavits of belief filed by the state's attorney. As the important cases before the present inquisitorial body are few It.is expected that the Lamphere charges will be considered not later than Thursday at the outside. Last nigbt Prosecutor Smith said that he might take the case before the Jury tomorrow, but he may even hasten this
The report describes the ongoing investigation into the Gunness murder farm, noting that officials expect a complete solution within 48 hours. It details evidence against Ray Lamphere for the deaths of Gunness and her children by arson, and outlines findings on the ten other victims, including chloral poisoning and dismemberment, while raising the question of possible accomplices.
Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 2
SOLUTION NEAR AT HAND.
They refused, however, to make known their purposes further than to say that the final step may be taken today or tomorrow at the latest. The mystery surrounding four of the fourteen deaths which are known to have occurred at the place is cleared by the allegation that Ray Lamphere, the former farmhand, prisoner in the county Jail, set fire to the
Investigators report that knives found in the ruins support the theory that Belle Gunness lured victims through matrimonial ads and killed them, with the key remaining question being whether Lamphere assisted her. Rev. E. A. Schell, who gained Lamphere's confidence in jail, confirms Lamphere made a statement but refuses to disclose its contents, citing ministerial confidentiality.
Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 2
CLERGYMAN HOLDS THE KEY
ChurCh at Laporte, and a delegate to the Methodist Episcopal general conference here, refused to divulge anything as to its nature. "My lips are sealed." said Mr. Schell. **I got these things in the confessional. I found that the prosecuting officers were sweating* Lemphere and I appealed for fair play in his behalf. I said that he ?hould be allowed to have a lawyer, and I told them so." "But I advised Lamphere to tell the prosecuting attorney exactly what he told me. and I think he will do so. He seems to me to be a thoroughly penitent man. "I received a message from Laporte this
A physician re-examining the body from the Gunness house ruins found three rings on one hand, including a gold band inscribed with initials believed to be her second husband's and a diamond ring with another inscription. Acquaintances confirmed she always wore exactly these three rings, which investigators say removes most doubt that she perished in the fire and strengthens the case against suspect Ray Lamphere.
The Washington Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD, SO RINGS INDICATE - Most Doubt About Her Fate Removed by Latest Discovery - STRONG EVIDENCE AGAINST LAMPHERE
Slayer of Woman Who Kill ed Nearly Score. L.A PORTE. Ind, May 12.-Coroner's Physician Meyer, during the second ex amination today of the body of tie wo man taken from the ruins of the Gun ness home, found three rings cn one of the hands. One was a plain gold ring and the others diamond rings. The gold ring hed this inscription on the inside: “P. G. to J. S.—August 22, "M4." Mrs. Gunness’ Rings. “P. G" is believed to stand for Philip Gurness, Mrs. Gunness’ second husband. One of the diamond rings bore this in scription: ‘“P.
See moreSee less
8. 0 J. 8.35%." The third ring had no inscription. The discovery is believed to remove most of the doubt that Mrs, Gunness perished in the fire. : Persons who knew Mrs Gunness de ciare she wore three rings, two dia mond rings and a plain gold band ring. The rings were not found when Dr. Myer first examined the body because the fingers were so badly charred that the rings had sunk into the flesh. Dr. Myer and Dr. J. 1. Gray in an official report of their examination to the ‘coromer, said the woman and her three children had evidently met death while they were in bed or preparing to retire, Fragments of night gowns were found on the woman's body and on the bodies of the children. The report says the woman's body bore no scars nor evidence of violence.
Doctors Myer and Gray's official report states the woman and three children died in bed or while retiring, with no scars or evidence of violence on the woman's body; rings were found sunk into her charred fingers. State Attorney Smith claims strong new evidence against Ray Lamphere, including bloody clothing found in his trunk hidden in a barn near the Gunness home.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
| MRS. GUNNESS DEAD, S0 RINGS INDICATE Most of Doubt About Her Fate Removed by Latest Discovery. STRONG EVIDENCE AGAINST LAMPHERE More Facts Point to Suspect as Slayer of Woman Who Kill ed Nearly Score. L.A PORTE. Ind, May 12.-Coroner's Physician Meyer, during the second ex amination today of the body of tie wo man taken from the ruins of the Gun ness home, found three rings cn one of the hands. One was a plain gold ring and the others diamond rings. The gold ring hed this inscription on the inside: “P.
See moreSee less
G. to J. S.—August 22, "M4." Mrs. Gunness’ Rings. “P. G" is believed to stand for Philip Gurness, Mrs. Gunness’ second husband. One of the diamond rings bore this in scription: ‘“P. 8. 0 J. 8.35%." The third ring had no inscription. The discovery is believed to remove most of the doubt that Mrs, Gunness perished in the fire. : Persons who knew Mrs Gunness de ciare she wore three rings, two dia mond rings and a plain gold band ring. The rings were not found when Dr. Myer first examined the body because the fingers were so badly charred that the rings had sunk into the flesh. Dr. Myer and Dr. J. 1. Gray in an official report of their examination to the ‘coromer, said the woman and her three children had evidently met death while they were in bed or preparing to retire, Fragments of night gowns were found on the woman's body and on the bodies of the children. The report says the woman's body bore no scars nor evidence of violence. Has Evidence Against Lamphere. State's Attorney Smith today an nounced that he has strong evidence against Ray Lamphere. He claims to have reached a complete solution of the mystery surrounding the whole af fair and says the final steps in clear ing the matter up will be taken today or tomorrow. The report ‘8 current that the author itles, besides letters from Mrs. Gun ness, found bloody clothing in Ray Lamphere's trunk, which was hidden in the hay loft of a barn near the CGunness home. Coroner Mack and State's Attorney Smith refuse toc make a statement regarding this report, but it iz believed to have much to do with their announced solution of the mys tery. Latest evidence indicates that Mrs. anness strangled her victims io death aad did not administer drugs. A close examination of the body of Andrew Helgelein shows this, State's Attorney Smith is expected to bring the Lamphere case before the grand jury and a speedy indictment is sure to follow. |
Authorities discovered bloody clothing hidden in Ray Lamphere's trunk in a barn near the Gunness home, and an autopsy reportedly showed victim Andrew Helgelein was strangled rather than drugged. A letter signed by Mrs. Gunness, dated four days after the fire, was received by a Norwegian man in Kansas, deepening the mystery over whether she died in the blaze.
The Washington Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Has Evidence Against Lamphere. State's Attorney Smith today an nounced that he has strong evidence against Ray Lamphere. He claims to have reached a complete solution of the mystery surrounding the whole af fair and says the final steps in clear ing the matter up will be taken today or tomorrow. The report ‘8 current that the author itles, besides letters from Mrs. Gun ness, found bloody clothing in Ray Lamphere's trunk, which was hidden in the hay loft of a barn near the CGunness home. Coroner Mack and State's Attorney Smith refuse toc make a statement regarding this report, but it iz believed to have much to do with their announced solution of the mys tery.
See moreSee less
Latest evidence indicates that Mrs. anness strangled her victims io death aad did not administer drugs. A close examination of the body of Andrew Helgelein shows this, State's Attorney Smith is expected | to bring the Lamphere case before the grand jury and a speedy indictment is sure to follow. |
A second examination of the body from the Gunness farmhouse ruins found three rings, including an inscribed gold band believed to confirm the victim as Belle Gunness. The coroner's report also noted no signs of violence on the body, while prosecutors announced mounting evidence against suspect Ray Lamphere.
The Washington Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD, SO RINGS INDICATE
Mrs. Gunness’ Rings. “P. G" is believed to stand for Philip Gurness, Mrs. Gunness’ second husband. One of the diamond rings bore this in scription: ‘“P. 8. 0 J. 8.35%." The third ring had no inscription. The discovery is believed to remove most of the doubt that Mrs, Gunness perished in the fire. : Persons who knew Mrs Gunness de ciare she wore three rings, two dia mond rings and a plain gold band ring. The rings were not found when Dr. Myer first examined the body because the fingers were so badly charred that the rings had sunk into the flesh.
See moreSee less
Dr. Myer and Dr. J. 1. Gray in an official report of their examination to the ‘coromer, said the woman and her three children had evidently met death while they were in bed or preparing to retire, Fragments of night gowns were found on the woman's body and on the bodies of the children. The report says the woman's body bore no scars nor evidence of violence.
Investigators report finding Mrs. Gunness's rings melted into the charred body, supporting the belief she died in the fire, while the coroner's report notes no signs of violence and death apparently occurring in bed. Meanwhile, State's Attorney Smith claims strong evidence against Ray Lamphere, including bloody clothing and letters found in his trunk, and a letter signed by Mrs. Gunness and postmarked after the fire raises new doubts.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
The report reproduces one of Belle Gunness's matrimonial advertisement letters, in which she poses as a lonely Norwegian widow seeking a husband with $1,000 in cash. It also reports that Norwegian police, after a week-long search of records and emigrant lists, found no trace of her true identity or origin.
The Washington Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Not Found in Norway CHRISTIANA, May 12.—A week's hunt by the police in which records have been searched and every possible in quiry made, has failed utterly to de velop the slightest fact regarding Mrs. Eelle Gunness, the American archmur deress. Not a person has been found who ever heard of her and no record of any description has been unearthed although the pest men in the depart ment have been detailed on the case. A minuts investigation at Trondhjem has convinced the authorities there that Mrs. Gunness dia not come from that city. It is believed she Intentionally gave the wrong name of her home town. : An examination of the lists of emi grants has been made without result. -
Investigators in LaPorte report no major new discoveries but note progress, while four rival theories circulate explaining the bodies and Belle Gunness's disappearance. These range from murder-suicide to flee-and-substitute-corpse, to her hired hand Ray Lamphere, to a Chicago murder gang.
The Ocala Evening Star · 12 May 1908 · page 8
THE GUNNESS FARM HORROR
- Digging In Gunness Rulnai Laporte, Ind., May 22. The cellar floor of the Gunness house of crime was dug up to a depth of three feet, but the suspected spot revealed no bones of victims of the murderess. Digging, has been resumed in other suspicious places. The basement was cleared of ruins, and the placer min er's task of washing the ashes will be completed In a day or two. A bushel 'of "tailings," saved for closer observa tion from the process of sluicing, will be "panned" for gold melted from the Jewelry which Mrs. Gunness kept as mementoes of her crimes. -
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
Medical examiners cannot conclusively identify the bodies found in the Gunness house ruins, with rings on one corpse reportedly not matching those owned by Mrs. Gunness, fueling speculation she may still be alive. Separately, evidence from Dr. Lucien Gray's report reveals chloral was used to poison victims, and a possible new victim, Henry Gurholt, is named.
Evening Times-Republican · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Rings Found on Corpse of Woman in Ruins Not the Property of Mrs. Gunness - MEDICAL EXPERTS BAFFLED
'Laporte, .Ind., Preacher Admits That Much, But Nothing Further. (Baltimore, May 1)2.—(That Ray Lam phere, charged with .burning the Gunness home, and tlhe death of its occupants, near Laporte, Ind., made a statement connected with^the case to 1 Rev. IS. A. Schell, was admitted by iSchell today. The latter, however, who is pastor of the M. E. churoh at Laporte, and a delegate to the Metho dist Episcopal general conference here, refused to divulge anything as to its nature. 7A.
Dr. Gray's autopsy report reveals three rings found on a corpse believed to be Belle Gunness, with inscriptions that don't match known identities, deepening the mystery. The state's evidence suggests victims were poisoned with chloral before being dismembered and buried in the yard.
Evening Times-Republican · 12 May 1908 · page 1
USED POISON TO KILL. Evidence Procured Showing Mrs. Gunness Give Victims Chloral. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Mrs. Nellie Gunness, wholesale murderess, killed her love-lured victims with chloral. Evidence in possession of the state, which will prosecute Ray Lamphere, accused of (murdering Mrs. Gunness end 'her children, has led to the con|bodies clusion that adventurous men who set I tion. foot within her home and met their doom were clain with poison, and that their hacked-up bodies wer« then hid den in a secret chamber of the house of mystery until they were buried in (the yard.
See moreSee less
(That. Mrs. Gunness purchased quan tities of dhloral from druggists in La porte and surrounding cities has been established, and witnesses, whose iden tity is being guarded, will be pro duced to give testimony to tohls fact. Lamphere, who will be indicted for arson and murder in the first degree, told a dramatic story of a plot be tween Mrs. Gunness and Andrew Hel gelein her latest victim, to slay him. Lamphere, jealous of Helgelein, over heard the woman and her dupe in con versation one night early In January. "She had quarreled with me re peatedly over Helgelein," said Lam phere, "and I did .everything I could to find out what they were doing. One night I saw them go into the parlor to talk, and I listened to them from be hind a curtain. 'We must get rid of Lamphere,' I heard (Mrs. Gunness say. 'I love you and he is in our way. I'll tell you what ril do. I'll give him some chloral. How much do you think it would take to kill a man?' "Helgelein did not appear to be much surprised, and he answered: 'Why don't you try It on the dog? I don't know how much it would take.' "I had a dog at that time, and a few days the later the dog disappeared. After that I was very watchful of their movements. I was afraid and I went to a friend of mine and said: If I am (•and dead out there I want you to see '*Z.} to it that an autopsy is held. That woman throws poison right and loft. Relating his movements on the night that Helgelein was murdered, Lamp here told a remarkable story. Admit ting that ho returned from Michigan City the night of Jan. 14, Instead of remaining there all night as he had previously stated. Lamphere declared that he bored a hole in the sittlngroom lloor in order that he might listen to Mrs. Gunness and Helgelein from the cellar. "When I got to the house that night,-' he said, "I saw Mrs. Gunness and Helgolein walking toward "the barn. Mrs. Gunness was carrying a lantern. I feared that something was wrong and determined to spy on thorn. 1 hur ried into the cellar and picked up an auger. As quickly as possible I bored a hole thru the floor of the sitting room and got up on a box to listen. I waited and waited. No one came back for several minutes. The sus pense was grating on my nerves and finally I became frightened and left the house, cutting across the :'arm to town, where I slept all night at Lizzie Smith's. I never saw Helgelein after that." Evidence that will bo presented to the grand jury against Lamphere, tho not completely in hand, Will bo fur nished by a number of witnesses. Dep uty Sheriffs Marr and Anstiss, who ar rested Lamphere at the Wheatbrook farm the morning after the burning of the Gunness home, will be the first witnesses. John Ross, Lamphere's cousin, and Rev. Dr. Schell, pastor of the Laporte Methodist church, wlfl al so be called, tho attorneys for the de fendant will fight against the minister's testifying on the ground that anything related to hltn was done In professional confidence. An alarm clock may add an impor tant link in the chain of evidence against Lamphere relating to the death of the Gunness family and the burn ing of their home. Lizzie Smith, the negress with whom Lamphere spent much time after leaving Mrs. Gunness' employ, told the authorities that Lam phere had come in early the night of the fire and had gone to bed, setting the alarm clock for 4 30 in the morn ing.
Medical examiners Gray and Meyer report they cannot determine cause of death for an adult female body and a male infant found in the ruins. The state's case against Lamphere alleges Gunness poisoned victims with chloral before dismembering and burying them, supported by Lamphere's account of overhearing a murder plot against himself.
Evening Times-Republican · 12 May 1908 · page 1
USED POISON TO KILL
Evidence Procured Showing Mrs. Gunness Give Victims Chloral. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Mrs. Nellie Gunness, wholesale murderess, killed her love-lured victims with chloral. Evidence in possession of the state, which will prosecute Ray Lamphere, accused of (murdering Mrs. Gunness end 'her children, has led to the con|bodies clusion that adventurous men who set I tion. foot within her home and met their doom were clain with poison, and that their hacked-up bodies wer« then hid den in a secret chamber of the house of mystery until they were buried in (the yard.
See moreSee less
(That. Mrs. Gunness purchased quan tities of dhloral from druggists in La porte and surrounding cities has been established, and witnesses, whose iden tity is being guarded, will be pro duced to give testimony to tohls fact. Lamphere, who will be indicted for arson and murder in the first degree, told a dramatic story of a plot be tween Mrs. Gunness and Andrew Hel gelein her latest victim, to slay him. Lamphere, jealous of Helgelein, over heard the woman and her dupe in con versation one night early In January. "She had quarreled with me re peatedly over Helgelein," said Lam phere, "and I did .everything I could to find out what they were doing. One night I saw them go into the parlor to talk, and I listened to them from be hind a curtain. 'We must get rid of Lamphere,' I heard (Mrs. Gunness say. 'I love you and he is in our way. I'll tell you what ril do. I'll give him some chloral. How much do you think it would take to kill a man?' "Helgelein did not appear to be much surprised, and he answered: 'Why don't you try It on the dog? I don't know how much it would take.' "I had a dog at that time, and a few days the later the dog disappeared. After that I was very watchful of their movements. I was afraid and I went to a friend of mine and said: If I am (•and dead out there I want you to see '*Z.} to it that an autopsy is held. That woman throws poison right and loft. Relating his movements on the night that Helgelein was murdered, Lamp here told a remarkable story. Admit ting that ho returned from Michigan City the night of Jan. 14, Instead of remaining there all night as he had previously stated. Lamphere declared that he bored a hole in the sittlngroom lloor in order that he might listen to Mrs. Gunness and Helgelein from the cellar. "When I got to the house that night,-' he said, "I saw Mrs. Gunness and Helgolein walking toward "the barn. Mrs. Gunness was carrying a lantern. I feared that something was wrong and determined to spy on thorn. 1 hur ried into the cellar and picked up an auger. As quickly as possible I bored a hole thru the floor of the sitting room and got up on a box to listen. I waited and waited. No one came back for several minutes. The sus pense was grating on my nerves and finally I became frightened and left the house, cutting across the :'arm to town, where I slept all night at Lizzie Smith's. I never saw Helgelein after that." Evidence that will bo presented to the grand jury against Lamphere, tho not completely in hand, Will bo fur nished by a number of witnesses. Dep uty Sheriffs Marr and Anstiss, who ar rested Lamphere at the Wheatbrook farm the morning after the burning of the Gunness home, will be the first witnesses. John Ross, Lamphere's cousin, and Rev. Dr. Schell, pastor of the Laporte Methodist church, wlfl al so be called, tho attorneys for the de fendant will fight against the minister's testifying on the ground that anything related to hltn was done In professional confidence. An alarm clock may add an impor tant link in the chain of evidence against Lamphere relating to the death of the Gunness family and the burn ing of their home. Lizzie Smith, the negress with whom Lamphere spent much time after leaving Mrs. Gunness' employ, told the authorities that Lam phere had come in early the night of the fire and had gone to bed, setting the alarm clock for 4 30 in the morn ing.
Diggers at the Gunness farm uncovered two more skeletons, a man and a woman, bringing the total found in the yard to eleven. Pinkerton detectives continue working on clues to explain the killings, with total victims estimated at fifteen including those from the fire.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
MORE BODIES DUG UP IN YARD ON THE FARM OF MRS. GUNNESS. REMAINS OF MAN AND WOMAN FOUND
Explanation of Slaughter. La Porte, Ind., May 9.—Two more bodies were unearthed at the Gunness farm Friday In a grave near the spot where three of the four bodies were
Digging resumed at the Gunness farm after rain stopped, drawing over 1,000 curious onlookers who watched sheriff's men search for more remains. Eight unidentified bodies (two women, six men) remain unidentified after 18 months underground, prompting Pinkerton detectives to join the investigation, while Lamphere revealed a mysterious visitor who vanished after leaving his belongings behind.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Large Crowds Watch Digging. The rain ceased Friday and digging operations were begun by Sheriff Smutzer at an early hour. The sheriff departed at an early hour from his usual custom of having several men at work with the spade and put only one man in that capacity. It was predicted very strongly by authorities that other bodies would be uncovered and this drew large crowds to the Gunness farm, who, with morbid curiosity, stood huddled in groups about the place watching every turn of the dig gers. Two female corpses and those of six males yet remain unidentified.
See moreSee less
De spite the searching investigations of the sheriff and state's attorney there Is as yet almost no clew to the identi ty of these remains. Their task is complicated by the fact that the bodies have been in the ground for at least 18 months. That the Plnkerton opera tives who were brought into the affair may be able to discover fresh evi dence is the hope of Sheriff Smutzer and Prosecutor Smith. The'outsiders are in charge of C. J. Smith, and he is said to have four assistants. Two of these, it is said, have been de tailed to search neighboring farms for Information regarding Mrs. Gunness' establishment. The others are work ing under the direction of the sheriff. 8tranger "Who Left for South." Ray Lamphere made a statement to Mayor Darrow, who is the partner of Lamphere's attorney, a day or two ago and which was made public Friday that a man from Chicago, whose name he did not know, came to the Gunness farm several months ago and remained there for several days. He disap peared suddenly, leaving a trunk and a few belongings behind. Upon Lamphere's questioning Mrs. Gunness as to what had become of her visitor, she replied that he had gone south for his health and that probably he would not return. She ordered Lamphere to carry the trunk and other effects of the stranger to an upper story of the farm house. Nothing was ever heard of this person after he left the Gun ness place, and he is supposed to have met the same fate as those whose bodies are now being dug up at the Gunness farm.
Ray Lamphere told authorities a Chicago stranger stayed at the Gunness farm for days before vanishing, leaving his trunk behind, and that Mrs. Gunness claimed he had gone south for his health. Separately, Mrs. Gunness' stepdaughter Swanhilda was reported hidden by relatives in Wisconsin after being taken from the farm for her safety.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Information regarding Mrs. Gunness' establishment. The others are work ing under the direction of the sheriff. 8tranger "Who Left for South." Ray Lamphere made a statement to Mayor Darrow, who is the partner of Lamphere's attorney, a day or two ago and which was made public Friday that a man from Chicago, whose name he did not know, came to the Gunness farm several months ago and remained there for several days. He disap peared suddenly, leaving a trunk and a few belongings behind. Upon Lamphere's questioning Mrs. Gunness as to what had become of her visitor, she replied that he had gone south for his health and that probably he would not return.
See moreSee less
She ordered Lamphere to carry the trunk and other effects of the stranger to an upper story of the farm house. Nothing was ever heard of this person after he left the Gun ness place, and he is supposed to have met the same fate as those whose bodies are now being dug up at the Gunness farm.
George Anderson, who survived a frightening night at the Gunness farm two years earlier, travels to Chicago to give authorities his testimony and letters, believing Gunness set the fire herself and is still alive. Meanwhile, Laporte authorities prepare evidence against Ray Lamphere, including a tuft of hair found in a victim's clenched hand matching the suspect, ahead of next week's grand jury.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 1
TOILS TIGHTENING AROUND LAMPHERE
Anderson Had Narrow Escape. y$**"s Two years ago while at Monvtv teith, Mich., he answered one of Mrs. Gunness' advertisements posing himself as a wealthy far s» mer. She wrote him to come on. He did so, but upon finding he had no money she was incensed, but told him to spend the night at sgher place. He went to bed but was awakened and found the woman bending over him. He p? j. spoke to her and she ran out of f-^the room. Greatly frightened, he did not close his eyes after that and at daylight he left the place.
See moreSee less
4 ik-i3''' -v kf Laporte, Ind., May 11. The au thorities of the county today are busy .1. -Vl\ weaving together the shreds of evi dence relied upon to connect Ray ':|l Lamphere with the deaths at the Gun ness farm, and will have their case as complete as possible when the grand jury meets next week. As yet the defense has not revealed to any great extent what attitude it will as sume. Neither Lamphere nor his coun sel will discuss the matter with any one further than to claim that Mrs. Gunness is still alive and that she fired her own house that burned her children to death. While Prosecutor Smith denounces this theory as absolutely improbable, yet this impression is becoming wide spread, despite the almost total ab sence of evidence to support it. The weather again today was very threatening. Some rain has fallen, though not insufficient quantities to delay the sheriff's operations at the Gunness farm.
Laporte authorities are assembling evidence against Ray Lamphere ahead of the grand jury, including a tuft of hair found in victim Andrew Hegelein's clenched hand resembling Lamphere's. Meanwhile, the theory that Belle Gunness is alive and set the fire herself is spreading despite little supporting evidence, and thousands of spectators flocked to the farm over the weekend.
Twenty thousand sightseers descended on the Gunness farm near Laporte, turning the murder scene into a carnival with vendors selling popcorn and ice cream near the excavation pits. A laborer, William Brogiski, testified he had dug three holes at Mrs. Gunness's request in 1906-07, all of which were later found to contain bodies.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Morbid Crowd at Farm Sunday. Twenty thousand people swarmed into Laporte yesterday to make a Ro man holiday of "murder farm.'' They came in trains, in automo biles, buggies, wagons, and on bicy cles and hundreds walked from neigh boring towns to see the ruins of the home and the private burying ground of this most fiendish murderess of the age. The scene at the Gunness "grave yard" farm was the strangest in mur der history annals. Never before has anything been enacted to equal it. Men and women were drawn from far and near by the uncanny fascina tion of terrible crimes, and when they approached the grewsome scene they were met by hawkers selling popcorn, ^peanuts, lemonade and pos tal cards.
See moreSee less
On the edge of a hole from which two of the bodies of the female Blue beard had been dug, a man had erect ed an ice cream booth and dispensed pink ice cream and cake to the visit ors.
The piece questions how one woman could have committed so many crimes alone and remained undetected for so long. It predicts investigation will reveal accomplices who helped with the murders and shared in the robberies, urging that justice be served to them as well.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 3
, All of the men in , the world will breathe .easier from now on. It has been established beyond a reasonable doubt that Mrs. . Gunness, the whole tale murderer, Is dead and that her body was one of those partially in cinerated by the fire which destroyed her house of crime at Laporte, Ind.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
A woman resembling Belle Gunness, Mrs. Cora Belle Herron, was wrongly arrested from a train near Syracuse and detained for hours before proving her identity. Meanwhile in Laporte, a doctor who assisted in the postmortem claims the body found in the morgue is significantly lighter and shorter than Mrs. Gunness herself, casting doubt on whether she is truly dead.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 5
ARRESTED FOR MURDER: MRS. CORA BELLE HERRON, WIDOW OF MANUFACTURER, TAKEN FROM TRAIN AT SYRACUSE, MAY SUE CITY FOR DAMAGES. PHYSICIAN WHO ASSISTED IN POSTMORTEMS SAYS WOMAN THOUGHT TO BE MURDERESS IS LIGHTER AND SHORTER.
Laporte, Ind., May 9. Dr. Harry H. Long, for two terms coroner of Laporte county,' who assisted in the post mortem exam ination of every body supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness, today declared the bodv in the morgue is that of a woman who weighed fully fifty pounds less than did Mrs. Gunness and is 5 inches shorter than Mrs. Gunness. Long says Mrs. Gunness is still alive. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—The work of digging on the Gunness farm was re sumed today, only men, however, being put to work.
See moreSee less
The local author ities are endeavoring to trace a young man named Canary whom it is be lieved may have been one of the vic tims of Mr. Gunness. A letter was re ceived today from his mother saying the son, who is about 20 years of age,
Dr. Harry H. Long, a former LaPorte coroner who helped conduct the post-mortem, says the body in the morgue is far lighter and shorter than Mrs. Gunness and insists she is still alive. Meanwhile, digging resumes on the Gunness farm and authorities seek a missing young man named Canary who worked near the property.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 5
1.00 CORSETS, WITH SUP PORTERS, ONLY [OE deress, today was able to prove her identity and will gt to New York this afternoon. She had come from Franklin, Pa., where she has a summer home, and was accompanied by her mother, Mrs. Lucy Burton. An effort is being made to have her sign papers re leasing the city of Syracuse from liability for her arrest. The woman was arrested on a New York Central railroad train between Syracuse and Utica shortly after 1 o'clock this morn ing, while asleep in her berth.
See moreSee less
She had boarded the tram in Ashtabula, Ohio, accompanied by an elderly woman, whose name is not known. The woman was held for hours aboard the train in the custody of detectives. Laporte, Ind., May 9. Dr. Harry H. Long, for two terms coroner of Laporte county,' who assisted in the post mortem exam ination of every body supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness, today declared the bodv in the morgue is that of a woman who weighed fully fifty pounds less than did Mrs. Gunness and is 5 inches shorter than Mrs. Gunness. Long says Mrs. Gunness is still alive. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—The work of digging on the Gunness farm was re sumed today, only men, however, being put to work. The local author ities are endeavoring to trace a young man named Canary whom it is be lieved may have been one of the vic tims of Mr. Gunness. A letter was re ceived today from his mother saying the son, who is about 20 years of age, Color EvdtU JSxeliutvelih Tultr ST* SalMtttuta. of tbe world. Ilia* MMI
Investigators report that a New York man who came to work for Mrs. Gunness vanished after his buggy was found at her farm, and that her claim Jennie Olson attended a Minnesota school was proven false by letter. Authorities also discovered a trunk belonging to jailed suspect Ray Lamphere containing what is called the first convincing evidence implicating him.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 12 May 1908 · page 5
Another Man Found Missing. About a year ago a man arrived in Laporte from some place in the state of New York. He said he had made arrangements to work for Mrs. Gun ness and that she was going to buy a horse and buggy which he had. He has never been heard of since. His buggy was today identified while standing in the shed on the Gunness place. It has been conclusively prov ed that the story given out by Mrs. Gunness that Jennie Olson went to at tend the Lutheran school at Ferguson Falls, Minn., was false.
See moreSee less
A letter was received today •frojm the authorities of the institution which declares Jennie never was there and that they never heard of her. AttorneySees Lamphere Threatened clash between the auth orities and H. B. Worden, attorney for Ray Lamphere, over his right to see the prisoner was averted today, Worden having been admitted to the jail where he talked with Lamphere tor more than an hour. Worden strongly denied the story that any trunk had been found containing let ters written by Lamphere to Mrs. Gunness and asserted there was abso lutely no truth in the statement that Lafnphere desired to confess or had anything to confess.
The report describes the ongoing excavation at the Gunness farm in LaPorte, Indiana, where eleven dismembered bodies have been dug up in a small enclosed area, with body parts wrapped in sacking and packed in lime. Only three victims have been positively identified so far, including Jennie Olsen, amid growing horror as the case is called one of the most gruesome murder mysteries in history.
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Evidence was obtained by Laporte officials that Mrs. Gunness had an ac complice who aided in luring victims to her farm. A. K. Helgelein, last of the victims of Mrs. Gunness, was buried at La porte. The fragments of jawbone found in the ruins of the farmhouse were identified by a dentist as from
Clipping to come
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa
The report describes mutilated bodies found packed in sacking and lime near the Gunness farm, with three victims positively identified: Jennie Olsen, Andrew Helgelien, and Ole Budsberg. It notes a prior correction regarding Helgelien's identification, and details rising suspicion—fueled by disagreement among inquest doctors—that the headless, charred body presumed to be Belle Gunness was actually someone else, sparking rumors of her being sighted across the country and a false arrest in Syracuse.
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Mrs. Gunness must have been a sort of reincaraaton of Kate Bender of Kansas, of imfamous memory. Michigan, South Carolina, Missouri and Alaska also joined the Bryan pro
Clipping to come
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa
A witness claims the headless, charred body presumed to be Belle Gunness was actually much smaller, fueling rumors she faked her death and is alive. Disagreement among inquest doctors feeds speculation; a false report of her arrest in Syracuse is debunked, and more suspected victims (Gustav Thun, Carl Nyberg) who answered her matrimonial ads are named as missing.
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Mrs. Gunness must have been a sort of reincaraaton of Kate Bender of Kansas, of imfamous memory. Michigan, South Carolina, Missouri and Alaska also joined the Bryan pro
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
Investigators panning ashes from the Gunness farm find bent scissors, surgical knives, and a dirk believed used in the murders and dismemberments, along with a gold tooth crown thought to be Belle Gunness's. An autopsy report adds a new mystery: rings on the headless corpse's hand are inscribed to 'J.G.', not matching Belle's husband Peter Gunness's initials.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 12 May 1908 · page 1
DEADLY DIRK HAS BEEN FOUND
Louis! LA PORTE May 12 —Louis! Schultze, employed by the sheriff sluice the ashes of the Gunness j home and pan for gold, completed his apparatus today and began the tests. Additional evidence of the meth ods by which the persons whose corpses were found in the Gunness farm were murdered were unearth group w *d today In the finding of about twoimony dozen pairs of scissors, bent and curved in the fashion of surgical in struments, and three knives, two of * surgical character and the third unmistakably a dirk.
See moreSee less
In the absence of evidence to the contrary, it is believed the dirk may have been the chief weapon employ ed in the series of murders. The knives and scissors are thought to to have been used for dismembering the bodieB. The gold crown of a tooth found In the debris of the Gunness home ___________ to, lay is believed to be from the: head of Mrs. BeUe Gunness. I
George Anderson, a Swedish man from Tarkio, Missouri, describes how he answered Mrs. Gunness's advertisement two years earlier and nearly fell victim to her after admitting he had little money. He says he is traveling to Chicago to give investigators his testimony and letters, and believes he can identify Ray Lamphere as a man he saw at her home.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 12 May 1908 · page 1
ESCAPED DEATH LURED INTO DEN OF MODERN LUCRETIA BORGIA. GEORGE ANDERSON AWAKES IN TIME TO PREVENT HIS MURDER.
TO PREVENT HIS MURDER. ST. JOSEPH, Mo., May 12.—"Be cause! had no money, I now believe, is the only thing that saved me being murdered by Mrs. Guinness, near La Porte, Ind.," Bald George
A miscellaneous local news column from an Indiana paper includes many unrelated items about townspeople's activities, illness, and business. Amid these local notes is a brief aside remarking on how Mrs. 'Butch' Gunness managed to deceive her neighbors.
The Berne Witness · 12 May 1908 · page 2
ADDITIONAL LOCALS
3 Wholesale Murder. The a6touuding developments at La Porte, Indiana, already places Belle Gunnes nmoDg the most notorious criminals of history Indeed, few have a longer record of lives taken than shp, her victims now numbering perhaps thirty. Not only adults but children are among them, and why the latter is most inexplicable, since she murdered for profit. According to the "evidence already at hand, Belle Gunness made a business of murder. Chicago aud its immediate vicinity have always supplied the most startling crimes of the country. The Cronin mur der, startling as it was at the time, paled into insignificance with the crimes com mitted in Holmes' castle, and even his butcheries were forgotten when Hock operated, and L-jetgert fed bis sausage factory with his wife's body.
See moreSee less
True, other ports of the country have had their sen sational crimes, but none has ever su perceded these in horror and diabolical fiendish neB:?. If Belle Gunness, is alive, she must begin to comprehend the depths of her depravity. If she is dead, she ia cer tainly scorching, if there is a hell; man or woman, no human being guilty of such crimes, can possibly escape deserv ed punishment.
Clipping to come
The Berne Witness · Berne, Ind.
A Decatur cab man reported seeing a large woman matching Belle Gunness's description being secretly transported, suggesting she faked her death and escaped. The report immediately clarifies that the man described was actually a local Reverend named Kattmann traveling with his wife to retrieve her sick mother.
The Berne Witness · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Decatur Cab Man Mixes Berne Preacher Into Gunness Murder.
3 Wholesale Murder. The a6touuding developments at La Porte, Indiana, already places Belle Gunnes nmoDg the most notorious criminals of history Indeed, few have a longer record of lives taken than shp, her victims now numbering perhaps thirty. Not only adults but children are among them, and why the latter is most inexplicable, since she murdered for profit. According to the "evidence already at hand, Belle Gunness made a business of murder. Chicago aud its immediate vicinity have always supplied the most startling crimes of the country. The Cronin mur der, startling as it was at the time, paled into insignificance with the crimes com mitted in Holmes' castle, and even his butcheries were forgotten when Hock operated, and L-jetgert fed bis sausage factory with his wife's body.
See moreSee less
True, other ports of the country have had their sen sational crimes, but none has ever su perceded these in horror and diabolical fiendish neB:?. If Belle Gunness, is alive, she must begin to comprehend the depths of her depravity. If she is dead, she ia cer tainly scorching, if there is a hell; man or woman, no human being guilty of such crimes, can possibly escape deserv ed punishment.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A woman named Alice Douglas returns from visiting the Gunness farm in LaPorte, horrified by what she saw there, and turns to drink. The report also lists suspected additional victims (George Berry and Henry Guthart) believed buried on the farm, and states investigators hope to extract a confession from Ray Lamphere within 24 hours.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
There was an actress in the Gunness tragedy in Hammond yesterday when a gray-haired woman dressed in black and wearinga black veil, walked into a Ilohman street saloon and ordered a drink of whisky. It became apparent from her manner that she was only partly intoxicated but was a bad char acter and a confirmed drunkard. After she had disposed of the drink she turned to the habitues of the place and remarked by way of apology for her unwomanly conduct that she had just returned from Laporte, where she bad visited the Gunness farm and iden tified some of the bodies.
See moreSee less
"That is enough to drive any one to drink' aid she. ' She claimed that she had at one time been . Mrs. Gunness' dressmaker and that while in her employ she had learned some of' the' secrets of her , shady life. The woman was too in toxlcated to be very responsible for what she was saying, but the fact that she had been to Laporte as a witness la the murder mystery was of interest to every one.
A disoriented, intoxicated woman falsely claimed to have identified bodies at the Gunness farm, but police found her story unreliable. Meanwhile, investigators report a possible breakthrough is near, including certainty that Ray Lamphere set the fire at the farm.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS.
, Mystery May Be ' Solved. A complete solution of the' mysteries of the Gunness farm is expected with in forty-eight hours. The officials who have been conducting the search for the victims of the house of many deaths practically admitted this fact today. T They refused, however, to make known their purposes further than to Bay that the final step may be taken tomorrow or the day after at the latest. The mystery surrounding four of the fourteen deaths which are known to have occurred at the place is cleared
Investigators say the Gunness farm mystery may be fully solved within 48 hours, and declare it 'absolute certainty' that Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed Mrs. Gunness and her three children. The report also notes Lamphere has been giving information to Rev. E. A. Schell, suggesting a confession may be forthcoming.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
LATEST DEVELOPMENTS
"by the absolute certainty that Ray Lamphere, the former farm hand, pris oner in the county jail, set fire to the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness on the morning of April 2S and thereby caus ed the death of the widow and the three children. Confesses to Dr. E. A. SchelL It will be of interest to Hammond people and especially local Methodists, to know that Rev. E. A. Schell. fortnerly pastor of the Methodist church In this city, has been largely instru mental in securing valuable Informa tion frpm Ray Lamphere, who is now believed to hold the secret of Mrs. Gun-
This editorial criticizes the morbid curiosity of well-dressed visitors from Chicago who flocked by automobile to LaPorte to view the scene of the Gunness murders. It laments that both high society and common people pushed and fought each other for a glimpse of the victims' dismembered remains.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 4
THE LAPORTE ORGIE
Gunness murders. . bodies of Mrs. Gunness' victims. "THIS DATS IN HISTORY." May 13. 1619 Barneveldt, the noted Dutch statesman,' beheaded at The Hague. 1670 The Hudson Bay company char
New evidence uncovered at Laporte on May 11 indicated that Mrs. Gunness poisoned her victims using chloral. This finding was reported among a roundup of brief national news items.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 4
University of Cincinnati induces Presi dent Dabaney to demand his resigna tion. Evidence uncovered at Laporte yes terday indicates that Mrs. Gunness poisoned her victims with chloral. John Armstrong Chanler Is granted a writ of protection to allow him to re turn to New York to testify without danger of being thrown Into the Bloom ingdale insane asylum. Mrs. Hetty Green receives a letter signed "The Black Hand" demanding ?5,000 and threatening death. General conference of the Methodist Episcopal church in session at Balti more invites the Methodist Protestant church to consolidate with it.
The report describes forensic evidence that victims died from chloral poisoning and were dismembered in a 'chamber of horrors,' supported by knives found in the ruins. It also recounts how Ray Lamphere, the former hired man, confided in Rev. E.A. Schell about his intimate relationship with Mrs. Gunness and her insistence he take out life insurance before marriage.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 5
A total of 11 watches have been found in the ruins of the Gunness home near La Porto, Ind. At the second day's session of the conference of governors at the White House, Gov. Johnson of Minnesota presided in the morning and Gov. Do-, neen of Illinois, in the afternoon. The Reserve Trust company of i Cleveland, has made an assignment. The liabilities are $2,700,000. The next national convention of the Kivers and Harbors congress will be
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Newspaper reports on Ray Lamphere's admissions describing his intimate relationship with Belle Gunness, her insistence he take out life insurance, and his growing jealousy over the appearance of suitor Andrew Helgelein. Lamphere claims he overheard Gunness discussing poisoning Helgelein with chloral and fled to warn a friend.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 5
A total of 11 watches have been found in the ruins of the Gunness home near La Porto, Ind. At the second day's session of the conference of governors at the White House, Gov. Johnson of Minnesota presided in the morning and Gov. Do-, neen of Illinois, in the afternoon. The Reserve Trust company of i Cleveland, has made an assignment. The liabilities are $2,700,000. The next national convention of the Kivers and Harbors congress will be
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
The report details Ray Lamphere's account of jealousy and surveillance of Belle Gunness and her suitor Andrew Helgelein, including overheard talk of poisoning with chloral. It also notes Lamphere's story has shifted under questioning, admitting he returned to the farm earlier than he first claimed.
The Lake County Times · 12 May 1908 · page 5
SHERIFF HUNTS FOR BODIES La Porte Officer Will Seek Additional Victims Unsigned Letter " Irons Oman a. LA PORTE. Ind., May 21. Sheriff Smut aer will this evening finish the sluicing of
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Coroner Mack reports that rings—a wedding band, a plain gold ring, and a diamond ring—found clutched in a charred hand have been identified by acquaintances as those worn by Mrs. Gunness. Most Laporte residents now believe she died in the fire that destroyed her farmhouse, with a full solution to the case expected within 48 hours.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
CORPSE FOUND IN RUINS IS THAT OF THE BORGIA
Rings Found in a Hunk of Flesh Identified as Those of Mrs. Gunness and All Say Wom- an Is Dead.
See moreSee less
LAMPHERE'S FATHER WILL ASSIST HIM.
Has Arrived at Laporte and Will Do Everything He Can For Son Who It Is Said, Will Be Convicted.
Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Identification of Mrs. Gunness' corpse is about finished, due to the finding of three rings. Close to the remains in the morgue, a chunk of badly charred flesh which was broken into pieces disclosed the fact that it was a portion of a human hand. The fingers tightly clutched contained rings, one of which appeared to be a wedding ring, and another a plain gold band, and the third a diamond ring. They are now in the possession of Coroner Mack who claims that persons familiar with them have identified them as those worn by Mrs. Gunness. It appears to be the belief of the majority of people in Laporte that the woman died in the fire which ruined her home.
Laporte, Ind., May 12.—A complete solution of the mysteries of the Gunness farm is expetced within 48 hours. A final step will be taken either today or tomorrow by the men who have brought the investigation of the horror to its culmination, and with it is promised an answer to all the questions which have arrayed themselves before the public during the past week.
The exact nature of the action is not disclosed, but from an authoritative source it has been learned that the climax of the great case is at hand.
The inquiry, which has been carried on almost entirely in secret, has been pronounced successful, and men who have directed it wear smiles of elation as the end appears in sight.
Each of them is discreet in his utterances, but there is not one to whom the secret has been disclosed who does not admit that the clouds of doubt are to be dispelled. There is satisfaction expressed in the attitude of every man upon whose shoulders rested the responsibility for placing the culpability behind at least 14 deaths.
Four of these are crossed from the list by absolute certainty that Ray Lamphere, the prisoner in the county jail, set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness on the morning of April 28 and thereby caused the death of the widow and the four children.
Indictments to be Sought.
For this he is liable, under the peculiar provisions of the Indiana state laws, to conviction for murder in the first degree as well as for arson. Indictments against him upon both these charges will be asked of the grand jury, which met in its first session yesterday, but will not reach his case before Wednesday.
As to the crucial movement which in itself will reveal the manner of death of the 10 murdered persons whose bodies were guarded by closely woven wire netting, the silence of the officers of the law in response to queries as to the arrest of one or more accomplices provides the only answer.
It is certain that they came to their death through the use of poison. The administration of a deadly amount of chrloral has been proved. The places at which the drug was purchased in the past eight years have been found. The inanimate corpses were dismembered either in a "chamber of horrors" on the second floor of the Gunness home or in the basement. Two knives, one a six-inch dagger, and the other a needlepointed double razor-edged surgeons knife, are in their possession.
That the big, stolid Norwegian woman enticed some of the men into her lair by the bait of matrimonial advertisements and there had an active hand in killing them and disposing of their bodies is established without question by those expected to answer the riddle.
Remaining Question.
The one remaining question, "Whether or not she had assistance in her crimes?" is to be met by the action that is expected almost hourly.
The arrival at this point has been preceded by a hunt for details, only rumors of which have been given to the public. Here and there bits of evidence have leaked out, but the great array of facts, it is said, was secured from statements made by Ray Lamphere, the former hired man who blackmailed the Gunness woman through the possession of knowledge concerning her dark secrets.
He has not been "sweated" at any time. No attempt at the "third degree" has been made, but it is from his utterance that the chain of testimony has been forged.
The chief agent in securing the confidence of the prisoner has been a minister, Rev. E. A. Schell, pastor of
(Continued on Page Seven.)
CORPSE FOUND IN RUINS IS THAT OF THE BORGIA
(Continued From Page One.)
the first Methodist church. Ever since the first day of the prisoner's incarceration the clergyman has been a visitor at his cell. For hours at a time he has been locked in with the man who might carry the secret with him to the gallows.
The man has been cautioned by his legal counsel to avoid giving any information concerning his knowledge of his actions upon the night of the disappearance of Andrew Helgelein, the last victim of the arch murderess, his observations upon that and later occasions and his actions upon the night of the fire which cost the lives of the woman and her children.
Damaging Admissions.
In spite of these warnings, the accused man has made admissions that, in addition to the earlier proof that he fired the building, have led to the conviction that he either was a witness or an active participant in the putting away of Andrew Helgelein.
According to Lamphere's statements shortly before June 27, 1907, Mrs. Gunness stopped him on the street and asked him if he could go to her farm and do some carpentering and other general work. He accepted her offer and on that date began his work repairing a floor in the house.
On the first night their relations passed to a stage of intimacy and it was not long before his room was changed from the lean-to, at the rear the house, to a chamber opposite to that of the widow, and she made to him a proposal of marriage.
She urged that this step be taken as soon as possible, but that it must be preceded by his having his life insured. She pointed out that under the state law none but a relative could be the beneficiary of an insurance policy and that, if issue should result from their close association, there would be no provision for the future in case of his death.
This aroused no suspicion in his mind but his delay in acting upon her suggestion caused Mrs. Gunness to order him to his former bed chamber in the rear of the house. It was about this time, somewhere near January 4, that he discovered that Helgelein had come to the house. One afternoon, when he had been ordred by Mrs. Gunness to build a fire in the sitting room stove, he was startled by the appearance of a stranger, who came down the stairs.
Ordered Him to the Barn.
This was Helgelein, he learned later, for at that time Mrs. Gunness returned to find the two men engaged in questioning each other as to his identity. In a rage she ordered Lamphere to go to the barn, "where he belonged."
The jealousy which sprang up in the heart of Lamphere led him to watch the woman and her new lover closely. He listened at windows and doors and on one of these instances heard Mrs. Gunness tell Helgelein that she was "sick of having Lamphere around."
"I am going to give him a dose of chloral," she said. "How much will I give him to kill him?"
"I can't tell," replied Helgelein. "He's got a dog. Why don't you try it on the dog?"
Thoroughly frightened, Lamphere went to a friend in Laporte and told him what he had heard. He was advised to "pack his kit and clear out," but returned to the farm. A few days later his dog disappeared and he revisited his confidant, whom he advised that, in case of his sudden death an autopsy should be held.
Louis Kelting, shoestore proprietor, declared that he had been selling shoes to Mrs. Gunness for years and that he knew she had a large foot and wore a No. 9 shoe. This conflicts with the statement of Prosecutor Smith that the woman's foot was small.
Discovery was made that there was a quilt between the body of Mrs. Gunness and those of the three children. Pieces of the burnt quilt, which were found upon the body of the woman, by a close inspection brought the announcement from the prosecuting attorney that he believes the woman was covered with it when the fire was burning.
Sheriff Smutzer has decided that he would have the barn moved and the ground under it dug up.
A conference of the officials working on the case was held today. The common council of Laporte county has been called to take action of the Gunness farm mystery. A vote of the common council is needed to expend public funds to carry on the investigation.
Pinkerton detectives working under Superintendent C. J. Smith report that they are securing valuable information. They believe that Mrs. Gunness is dead and that Lamphere can clear up the entire mystery.
Expects to Convict Lamphere.
"I expect to have Ray Lamphere tried and convicted of the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness," said Prosecutor Smith. "There is not the shadow of a doubt that Mrs. Gunness is dead. The gold ring on the finger of the corpse lying in the basement of the burned building is one that Mrs. Gunness constantly wore during her lifetime.
"That ring, now in the possession of the authorities, has been positively identified by several persons. The ring was found on the dead woman's finger.
"The sheriff and his men, assisted by the Pinkerton detectives, who have been getting evidence for the state, have gathered proof, in addition to that of the gold ring, which demonstrates conclusively that Mrs. Gunness is dead."
Hitherto unpublished evidence regarding the movements of Ray Lamphere on the day of the fire in the Gunness house have strengthened the case for the state. County Prosecutor Smith is responsible for the statement that Lamphere's comings and goings have been so closely followed that not half an hour is unaccounted for.
Neighbors who were first awakened at the time of the Gunness fire agree that it started about 4 o'clock in the morning. Lamphere's own statement has been that he left "Negro Liz's" house at 4:30 o'clock in the morning. This contention by Lamphere was the one stumbling block that has been in the prosecutor's way.
"More likely he left at 3 o'clock; it fits our corroborative evidence better," remarked the prosecutor.
This corroborative evidence is an important result of the work of the Pinkerton detectives and the local sheriff's officers. Five witnesses have been found who saw Lamphere that morning.
"In all Lamphere traveled on foot more than 16 miles the day of the fire," said the prosecutor. "I believe that he left the graveled road at the railroad crossing, went half a mile to Mrs. Gunness's house and set it on fire, hid in the woods to watch the blaze and was running away when Ira Hoover saw him."
Entirely Circumstantial.
In main this is the state's case against Lamphere; it is admitted that it is entirely circumstantial. But the prosecutor insists that he has corroborative witnesses of importance who are not named.
While not willing to discuss the important evidence in detail, County Prosecutor Smith says that he, in person, found the letters in a trunk in one of the outbuildings of the Gunness place.
More than a hundred letters were in the trunk, but only four or five were from Mrs. Gunness to Lamphere.
Prosecutor Smith says the statement of the defense that Mrs. Gunness could not write English is not true. The letters are in her handwriting, but the spelling is crude.
Refused Admission to Son.
W. W. Lamphere, father of Ray Lamphere and a justice of the peace at Springfield, Ind., arrived here to assist in the defense of his son. The father was refused permission for an interview with the son by Sheriff Smutzer. H. W. Worden, attorney for Ray Lamphere, declares he will bring about an interview with father and son if he is compelled to bring Ray to court.
The father is strong in protestations of the innocence of his son and asserts that he believes Ray incapable of the murders with which he stands charged.
Lamphere, senior, says that at one time Mrs. Gunness bought nearly 50 fence posts of him, and that while he was at the place he was strangely prejudiced against her. He questioned his son Ray about the latter's possible marriage with Mrs. Gunness and advising against it, and Ray told him that he never would marry the woman.
MURDER FARM OF THE WIDOW GUNNESS
RUINS OF THE BURNED HOME, PLAT OF THE GARDEN AND THE OUTBUILDINGS.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Investigators report they have conclusively tied Ray Lamphere to the April 28 fire that killed Belle Gunness and her four children, and will seek indictments for both murder and arson. Separately, officials confirm ten other victims were poisoned with chloral and dismembered, though whether Lamphere had an accomplice remains unresolved.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE'S FATHER WILL ASSIST HIM. Has Arrived at Laporte and Will Do Everything He Can For Son Who It Is Said, Will Be Convicted. Laporte, Ind., May 12. Identifica tion of Mrs. Gunness' corpse is about finished, due to the finding of three Jrlngs. Close to the remains in the (morgue, a chunk of badly charred flesh fwhich was broken into pieces disclosed the fact that it was a portion of a liu 5nan hand. The fingers tightly clutch ed contained rings, one of which ap peared to be a wedding ring, and an other a plain gold hand, and the third d diamond ring.
See moreSee less
They are now in Hie possession of Coroner Mack who iclalms that persons familiar with them &ave Identified them as those worn by pirs. Gunness. It appears to be the belief of the majority of people in I-a-morte that the woman died in the fire twhich ruined her home. Laporte, Ind., May 11.. A complete solution of the mysteries of the Gun aieBS farm is expetced within 4S hours. final atep will be taken either to !lay or tomorrow by the men who Ibave brought the investigation of the iiorror to its culmination, and with it is promised an answer to all the ques tions which have arrayed themselves before the public during the past flweek. The exact nature of the action is riot disclosed, but from an authorita Nive source it has been learned that the cMmax of the great case is at hand. ' The inquiry, which has been carried yon almost entirely in secret, has been pronounced successful, and men who jiAve directed it wear smiles of elation jB the end appears in sight. Each of them is discreet in his ut terances, but there is not one to whom the secret has been disclosed who -does not admit that the clouds of Htlotibt are to be dispelled. There is satisfaction expressed in the attitude . rf every man upon whose shoulders Jested the responsibility for placing 'the culpability behind at least 14 Vteaths. Four of these are crossed from the "list by absolute certainty that Ray 1-amphere, the prisoner in the county jail, set fire to the home of Mrs. Helle Gunness on the morning of April 2S jnnd thereby caused the death of the l"wldow and the four children.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Investigators report that chloroform purchases and dismemberment tools (a dagger and a surgeon's knife) have been found, confirming Belle Gunness lured men via matrimonial ads and killed them. The remaining question is whether she had an accomplice, with key testimony coming from former hired man Ray Lamphere, aided by a minister's intervention.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Remaining Question. The one remaining question. '"Whether or not she had assistance in her crimes?" is to be met by the ac tion that is expected almost hourly. The arrival at this point has been preceded by a hunt for details, only rumors of which have been given to the public. Here and there bits of evi dence have leaked our, but the great srray of facts, it is s:id. was secured from statements made by Ray Lamp l ( re. the former hired man who black mailed the Gunness woman through the possession of knowledge concern ing her dark secrets.
See moreSee less
lie has not been sweated" at any Time. No attempt at the "third de gree" has been made, but it is from his utterance that the chain of testi mony has been forged. The chief again in securinc the eon fidence of the prisoner has been a minister. Rev. K. A. Schell. pastor of i (.Continued on Page Seven.)
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The report describes jailed suspect Ray Lamphere's admissions to a visiting clergyman, detailing how Belle Gunness hired him, began an intimate relationship, and urged him to take out life insurance before marriage. It also notes his later discovery around January that victim Andrew Helgelein had met his fate on the farm.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 7
IS THAT OF THE BORGIA
FOR MORE BODIES (By Associated Press.) LA PORTE, Ind., May 21. Tomor row promises developmenst in the Gunness case. Early this 'morning Coroner Mack will file his official re ports on the death of the three chil dren of Mrs. Gunness. Some time during the day the Grand Jury will complete its labors.' If true bills arj voted, indictments will be reported to Judge-Richter in the Laporte Cir cuit Court. Sheriff Smutzer resumos the digging for bodies tomorrow in the Gunness yard. On Friday, May 29th, Executor Fogle will hold a pub lic sale of the personal property left
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Ray Lamphere recounts his intimate relationship with Belle Gunness, her insistence he get life insurance, and his growing jealousy over her new suitor Andrew Helgelein. He claims to have overheard Gunness discussing poisoning him with chloral, after which he fled and warned a friend to demand an autopsy if he died suddenly.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 7
cases of Andrew Helgeleln, Ole Buds berg and Jennie Olson and of the other unidentified victims. This ver dict will also bo filed tomorrow. Today has been devoid of sensations In the Gunness tragedy. There were no grewsome finds, no bodies taken
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Prosecutor Smith declares he has no doubt Mrs. Gunness is dead, pointing to a gold ring found on the burned body that has been positively identified by multiple people. The report also notes a shoe salesman's conflicting claim about the size of Mrs. Gunness's foot, and describes Pinkerton detectives and officials gathering further evidence, including a quilt found between the woman's and children's bodies.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 7
cases of Andrew Helgeleln, Ole Buds berg and Jennie Olson and of the other unidentified victims. This ver dict will also bo filed tomorrow. Today has been devoid of sensations In the Gunness tragedy. There were no grewsome finds, no bodies taken
Clipping to come
Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.
The report describes Ray Lamphere's arrest in connection with the Gunness farm crimes and claims he is charged with bigamy, with three wives said to be living. It also reports that a railroad conductor allegedly identified Belle Gunness switching trains in Pittsburgh, along with new evidence of arson (purchased kerosene) and poisoned candy, and a neighbor's account of digging body-filled pits for her in 1906-07.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Dziennik Chicagoski · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.
A short Chicago news note reports that police have decided, for now, not to search the grounds of two houses where Belle Gunness, the sensational murderess from LaPorte, Indiana, once lived. The item appears amid other brief city items about fires, suicides, and petty crime.
Dziennik Chicagoski · 12 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A gold-crowned tooth was discovered in the debris of the burned Gunness home and is believed to belong to Belle Gunness. Rings were also found on the fingers of recovered remains, though inscriptions on them are proving difficult to decipher.
Rock Island Argus · 12 May 1908 · page 1
GOLD CROWNED TOOTH BELIEVED TO HAVE BEEN HERS FOUND IN THE RUINS. RINGS ON THE FINGERS
Positive That She Is Dead. LaPorte, Ind., May 20.—If any thing additional were needed to prove the contention of Sheriff Smut zer and Prosecutor Smith that Mrs. Bella Gunness, at whose door are laid a dozen, deaths, two husbands and ten others, it was supplied yes terday when Louis Schultz, expert miner, found in the aShes oi the Gunness house upper and lower bridges, containing the false teeth of the woman, Smutzer is Investigating the claim that "William Riedinger, a farmer at Delafield, Wis., was one of Mrs. Gun ness' victims.
See moreSee less
In a letter received yesterday, David Hicken, a friend, living at "Waukesha, Wis., tells of the disappearance from home of Rie dinger, who, after a visit from Mrs. Gunness, sold some crops whic!h net ted him one thousand dollars and left for some place in northern In diana, "to marry a iwealthy widow" he said. (Miss Jennie Graham. Waukesha, Wis., is seeking her ibrother, who left Ihome to marry a rich widow In Indiana and was never heard from after that. What is considered positive proof that Henry Gurholdt of Scandinavia, Wis., came to LaPorte and was put out of the way by Mrs. Gunness, was supplied yestefday when Sheriff Smutzer received a letter containing a description of Gurholdt's watch, vrhiclh tallies with the one found. Gurholdt had fifteen hundred dollars in cash when he left home to come to LaPorte.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Dr. Lucien Gray's previously suppressed autopsy report reveals three rings and a right hand on the body claimed to be Mrs. Gunness, deepening the mystery since the rings bear initials unrelated to her known identity. The exact cause of death for both the female corpse and a male infant found in the ruins could not be determined.
Rock Island Argus · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Positive That She Is Dead. LaPorte, Ind., May 20.—If any thing additional were needed to prove the contention of Sheriff Smut zer and Prosecutor Smith that Mrs. Bella Gunness, at whose door are laid a dozen, deaths, two husbands and ten others, it was supplied yes terday when Louis Schultz, expert miner, found in the aShes oi the Gunness house upper and lower bridges, containing the false teeth of the woman, Smutzer is Investigating the claim that "William Riedinger, a farmer at Delafield, Wis., was one of Mrs. Gun ness' victims.
See moreSee less
In a letter received yesterday, David Hicken, a friend, living at "Waukesha, Wis., tells of the disappearance from home of Rie dinger, who, after a visit from Mrs. Gunness, sold some crops whic!h net ted him one thousand dollars and left for some place in northern In diana, "to marry a iwealthy widow" he said. (Miss Jennie Graham. Waukesha, Wis., is seeking her ibrother, who left Ihome to marry a rich widow In Indiana and was never heard from after that. What is considered positive proof that Henry Gurholdt of Scandinavia, Wis., came to LaPorte and was put out of the way by Mrs. Gunness, was supplied yestefday when Sheriff Smutzer received a letter containing a description of Gurholdt's watch, vrhiclh tallies with the one found. Gurholdt had fifteen hundred dollars in cash when he left home to come to LaPorte.
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
Medical examiners report they cannot determine exact cause of death for a female body and an infant found in the Gunness ruins, while inscribed items deepen the mystery of victim identities. Meanwhile, new possible victims are identified: Henry Gurholt of Wisconsin and Olaf Jensen of Norway, both believed to have corresponded with Gunness through matrimonial ads before disappearing.
Rock Island Argus · 12 May 1908 · page 1
"'Urr den is positive that his brother was murdered by Mrs. Gunness, but he was not able to identify any of the remaining skeletons and so will not be able to provide proper burial for his brother. The bodies of the sev en unidentified will be buried in the Potters Field. The christian ser vice will be conducted over them and a small stone will be erected with an inscription telling the circumstance of their death. The body of Jennio Olsen has been turned over to the relatives. Ole Budsberg's body was yesterday shipped to Iola, AVis., for burial.
Clipping to come
Dziennik Narodowy · Chicago, Ill.
Police in Laporte report finding that Belle Gunness purchased large quantities of chloral to poison her victims, while prosecutors build a case against her former hired hand Lamphere for the murders of Gunness and her three children. Lamphere changes his earlier alibi, now claiming he was at the farm the night Andrew Helgelein died and overheard Gunness and Helgelein plotting to poison him first.
Dziennik Narodowy · 12 May 1908 · page 1
WŁADZE WYKRYŁY, ŻE GUNNESSOWA TRUŁA OFIARY CHLORALEM
THE LA PORTE MURDER FARM. Cmmomi' Hrvrlatlona There It, ad Mkr n Story of the Mld-t>nlnrir. Like n chapter from the hlooily rec ords of the mtd-centuries is the ter rible story unfolded b; the authorities of I,h Porte, Ind., where wholesale mur der was done for years without anyone knowing or susi>eeting it. Criminal rec ords contain no parallel of the grew somc story revealed In the finding of the clearing house for murders kept by Mrs. Belle Gunness near the Indiana town. Just how mnny persons met their fate in connection with the bloody business carried on there will perhaps never be known.
See moreSee less
The skeletons dis covered on her premises and the fact that expressmen had many times de livered to her boxes and trunks now believed to contain human bodies form the chief muterlals for the construction of the strange story of her career. She is supposed to have lured rich men to her den by inatrlmoniul advertisements and then made away with them for their money, and also to have run a murder “fence” for the benellt of her partners In the awful trade of human slaughter, the latter operating In Chi cago and sending the bodies of their victims to her for burial. It Is the theory of the prosecution that Mrs. Gunness deliberately lured men to her farm by means of an advertisement In a Chicago newspai>er, In which she represented herself as an attractive and andable widow looking for a mate. She alleged that she was the owner of a valuable farm and sought a well-to-do farmer as a husband. After a visit from such a candidate she generally In duced him, it appears, to sell Ills farm and come to her with the proceeds of the sale, at which time she would de liberately murder him and bury his body cn the premises. For years this strange woman Is said to have conducted her murder mill.
Clipping to come
Dziennik Narodowy · Chicago, Ill.
News from America about Belle Gunness's mass murders in La Porte is causing a sensation in Christiania, Norway. It is suspected that one victim was Olaf Jensen, a man who left Norway two years earlier to find Gunness after a matrimonial correspondence, and who has not been heard from since.
Dziennik Narodowy · 12 May 1908 · page 1
NOWA OFIARA GUNNESSOWEJ
Gunness deliberately lured men to her farm by means of an advertisement In a Chicago newspai>er, In which she represented herself as an attractive and andable widow looking for a mate. She alleged that she was the owner of a valuable farm and sought a well-to-do farmer as a husband. After a visit from such a candidate she generally In duced him, it appears, to sell Ills farm and come to her with the proceeds of the sale, at which time she would de liberately murder him and bury his body cn the premises. For years this strange woman Is said to have conducted her murder mill.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A gold crown tooth believed to belong to Mrs. Gunness was found in the cellar debris as Sheriff Smutzer continued sifting the ashes. A previously suppressed autopsy report revealed three rings on the corpse identified as Mrs. Gunness, with inscriptions to mysterious initials 'J.S.' that authorities could not explain.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 1
FOUND TOOTH
DR.J.H. WILLI An Y£R_. uncertainty. A fire which destroyed the Gunness home also disclosed the fact that her three children had either been murdered before the fire or that they had perished In the flames. In some respects the methods of Mrs. Belle Gunness seem similar to those of the Infamous Bernier family In Kan sas. Vet it is doubtful If the blood thirsty Kate Bender In her palmiest days was ever equal to the awful crimes that are laid at the door of the Gunness woman. The story of the La Porte murder farm recalls the noto-
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The report reproduces a letter Belle Gunness sent from Laporte to Norwegian laborer Christian Hansen, demanding he bring $1,000 cash before she would marry him. Hansen, who had only $700, thus escaped becoming one of her victims.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 1
HE WAS $300 SHORT.
Story That Greening Told. Greening worked for Mrs. Gunness at the time that Jennie Olsen disap peared, and his story was to the ef fect that on a certain day in Septem ber a man and woman came to the house, and that night Mrs. Gunness asked Greening to sleep in the barn, for the two, whom she said were the professor and his wife from the Los Angeles college which Jennie was to attend, would spend the night at the house, and would require Greening’s bedroom. In the morning Greening saw nothing of Jennie nor the man and woman, and was informed by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness that they had left on an ear ly train, taking Jennie along. Buds berg in the .Same Grave. This body which is now declared to be that of a woman was taken from the same hole as was that of Jennie Olsen, and in that hole also were the bodies of Ole Budsberg, of loin, Wis., and the remains of a male person. All the bodies were dismembered, but the trunks of the four were in such condi tion that it was possible to identify the bodies of Jennie Olsen and Buds berg, and also possible by the autopsies to determine that one of the other two was that of a female.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Ray Lamphere reportedly confessed details of the Gunness case to Rev. E.A. Schell, who refuses to disclose the content but says Lamphere is penitent and advised him to tell the prosecutor. Separately, investigators uncover that John Moo cashed a large draft in 1906, claiming it was to pay off a mortgage on the Gunness farm, linking him further to the case.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 7
Three Murders in One Night. The theory now advanced is that Mrs. Gunness may have on the same night—the night that Greening slept ia the barn murdered not only Jennie. Olson but also the man and woman. To Coroner Mack. Sheriff Snnitzer and Prosecutor Smith this seems almost inconceivable; but they consider, in the light of recent developments, that noth ing appeared impossible for this arch murderess. The stomachs of the four victims in this hole have been removed, and the contents will be analyzed for poison. The disappearance of Jennie Olsen, as well as the couple, occurred in September, 1900, while Budsberg was disposed of in May, 1907.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Investigators in La Porte examine a financial transaction by John Moo, tied to Mrs. Gunness's farm, while friends of missing men Herman Konitzer and Henry Gurholt suspect they too were victims who corresponded with her matrimonial ads. The report details circumstantial links between these men and the ongoing Gunness case.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 7
Moe’s Watch Identified. The mystery surrounding the watch found on the person of Ray Lamphere when he was arrested has been cleared up. ,T. G. Ramden, of Manfred, N. D., who came here*to investigate the dis appearance of his halfbrother, John Moe, of Elbow Lake, Minn.- identified the timepiece as the one owned by his brother when he left home. The num bers of the watch corresponded with the numbers In Ramden’s possession. Lamphere said that Mrs. Gunness gave him a watch. Ramden is positive that bis brother was murdered by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness, but be was not able to iden tify any of the remaining skeletons, and so will not be able to provide prop er burial for his brother. Threats against the life of Prosecu tor Smith continue to be made. He has received another letter similar to the odc received last week. Both were postmarked Brooklyn, N. Y. He is ad vised to resign his office under peualty of death.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The report describes Sheriff Smutzer's renewed excavation at the burned Gunness farm, with a sluicing apparatus built to sift the cellar ashes for remains and clues. It also continues an account of a Norwegian man, Hansen, who nearly sent Mrs. Gunness money after receiving one of her matrimonial letters before the murders were exposed.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 8
Gunness Home. Laporte, Ind., May 12. The "min ing" operations which have been promised by Sheriff Smutzer for sev eral days, started in earnest today In the ruins of the Gunness home. Louis Schultze, who was employed by the sheriff to sluice the ashes In the cellar completed his apparatus early and be gan the tests to determine whether his arrangements were of the character demanded by the work at hand. Schultze yesterday constructed a sluicing box nine feet long and a foot square and connected it with the tank of a windmill, near the house, by means of a line of heavy hose.
See moreSee less
An attachment from a street sprinkler is used to distribute the water through the box. Additional evidence regarding the matters by which the persons whose corpses were found on tne Gunness farm met their deaths was unearthed
Sheriff's hired expert begins sluicing operations through the ashes of the burned Gunness cellar, uncovering nearly two dozen bent scissors and several knives including a dirk believed used in the murders. Investigators theorize victims were drugged or chloroformed before being stabbed and dismembered, though Andrew Helgelein's body showed signs of a struggle instead.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 8
SCISSORS AND KNIVES.
Gunness Home. Laporte, Ind., May 12. The "min ing" operations which have been promised by Sheriff Smutzer for sev eral days, started in earnest today In the ruins of the Gunness home. Louis Schultze, who was employed by the sheriff to sluice the ashes In the cellar completed his apparatus early and be gan the tests to determine whether his arrangements were of the character demanded by the work at hand. Schultze yesterday constructed a sluicing box nine feet long and a foot square and connected it with the tank of a windmill, near the house, by means of a line of heavy hose.
See moreSee less
An attachment from a street sprinkler is used to distribute the water through the box. Additional evidence regarding the matters by which the persons whose corpses were found on tne Gunness farm met their deaths was unearthed this morning. Almost two dozen pairs of scissors, bent and curved in the fashion of surgical instruments are said to have been found in the ashes In the cellar and in addition three knives, two of a surgical character, and another unmistakable dirk were picked up. In the absence of evidence to the contrary. It is believed that the tflrk may have been the chief weapon employed in the series of murders. An expert hand could easily have slipped the snakelike weapon between the ribs of the victims and penetrated the heart. The fact that there was no mark of penetrating wounds on Andrew Helge lein'e body Is a possible refutation of this theory. But it is pointed out that Helgelein, according to the findings of Dr. J. H. William Meyer as made pub
Dr. Meyer's autopsy findings reveal Helgelein fought his killer and tore out a handful of hair before being subdued, likely with chloroform, then poisoned. The report also describes a neighbor's account of Mrs. Gunness wearing a knife-pouched belt, and notes Lamphere's defense team has grown and the grand jury may soon consider charges.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 8
Ruins of Gunness Horror House. Laporte, who for six years was a j neighbor of the woman. Mrs. Lap-1 ham says that on the only occasion on which she called upon her neighbor, her hostess sat near an open window. A strong breeze through this opening blew aside the folds of a loose house dress which Mrs. Gunness was wear ing and revealed about her body a wide belt containing pouches of various sizes and sheaths which seemed to have been constructed for knives. As a sequel to this Mrs. Lap ham's daughter is said to have related an experience at the house when she had accepted an Invitation to supper there.
See moreSee less
Miss Lapham, it is reported, said that she engaged the Gunness children in conversation regarding their home but that in the midst of their talk Mrs. Gunness admonished the children and that they thereupon became strangely silent and dis quieted. This happened some two weeks before Jennie Olsen dis appeared, the latter having been more or less of an intimate friend of Mrs. Lapham. The legal forces of the defense were strengthened yesterday by the addi tion of Ellsworth E. Weir, an attorney of some note in this section. His re tention followed the arrival of Wil liam Lamphere, the father of the pris oner. There is a bare possibility that the grand Jury which convened here yes terday will begin consideration of the charges against Ray Lamphere today. A few days ago this investigation was postponed until May 18, but yesterday Prosecutor Smith again declared him self ready to proceed and last night he prepared the depositions which the sheriff and his deputies will swear to for grand Jury purposes. Most of the criminal cases In this state are pre sented to the court on affidavits of be lief filed by the states attorney. As the Important cases before the present inquisitorial body are few, it is ex pected that the Lamphere charges will be considered not later than Thursday at the outside. Last night Prosecutor Smith said that he might take the case before the Jury tomorrow, but he may even hasten this programme. Much depends upon the attitude of Coroner C. S. Mack, who thus far has shown little inclination to push the cases to a conclusion. If he decides today to receive the reports on the Gunness bodies which have been prepared by four examining physicians, it is possi ble that the court procedure will be hastened. Until these reports are in, however, the prosecuting attorney will be embarrassed in his attempts to prove corpi delecti in the case of Ray Lamphere.
A local Topeka newspaper item jokes that the cellar-like excavation found on Mrs. Gunness's farm in LaPorte, Indiana, was prepared for a visiting suitor, A. C. Townsend of Topeka. The item is part of a miscellany of unrelated local news briefs.
The Topeka State Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 10
Judge of Second Judicial District, CHARLES E. CARPENTER of Albany County. If some of us old-timers in this val ley do not Htep lively wo are likely to be run over and killed. Things are moving faster than most of our eyes can follow. Well, since they have found Old Lady Gunness' teeth among the ruins of her Indiana abattoir pernaps that nlne-days wonder may be listed with the Bender affair and the matter dropped. And the Laramlo plain? arc to have a great Carey act project, too. That is what push and knowing how brings about.
See moreSee less
This first one will doubtless be followed by others till this valley blossoms as the rose. A Cheyenne electric light “trouble” man received a shock of 2,400 volts and did not lay off on account of it. There has been so much trouble at Cheyenne over electric light matters that, this little occurrence was as a summer zephyr to him. Poor old Platt! Ruined in health, dircredlted by his people and dragged into court through scandalous divorce
Clipping to come
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.
Another mutilated body was unearthed at the Gunness farm, bringing the total to eight victims found since the search began, amid 16 mysterious deaths linked to the case. A new theory emerged that Mrs. Gunness did not die in the house fire but is alive in hiding, since the headless body found in the ruins has never been matched to her with certainty.
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 12 May 1908 · page 2
BLUEBEARD IN SKIRTS
Judge of Second Judicial District, CHARLES E. CARPENTER of Albany County. If some of us old-timers in this val ley do not Htep lively wo are likely to be run over and killed. Things are moving faster than most of our eyes can follow. Well, since they have found Old Lady Gunness' teeth among the ruins of her Indiana abattoir pernaps that nlne-days wonder may be listed with the Bender affair and the matter dropped. And the Laramlo plain? arc to have a great Carey act project, too. That is what push and knowing how brings about.
See moreSee less
This first one will doubtless be followed by others till this valley blossoms as the rose. A Cheyenne electric light “trouble” man received a shock of 2,400 volts and did not lay off on account of it. There has been so much trouble at Cheyenne over electric light matters that, this little occurrence was as a summer zephyr to him. Poor old Platt! Ruined in health, dircredlted by his people and dragged into court through scandalous divorce
Clipping to come
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.
Investigators float the theory that Mrs. Gunness is still alive, having substituted a victim's headless body for her own before burning the house; a false wall and hollow space are found in the basement. The report lists twelve bodies found so far and notes a bank deposit the day before the fire as evidence against the fake-death theory.
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 12 May 1908 · page 2
FOR MORE BODIES (By Associated Press.) LAPORTE, Ind., May 21. Tomor row promises developmenst in the dimness case. Early this morning Coroner Mack will file his official re ports on the death of the three chil dren of Mrs. Gunness. Some time during the day the Grand Jury will complete Its labors. If true bills ar; voted. Indictments will be reported to Judge Richter In the Laporte Cir cuit Court. Sheriff Smutzer resumes the digging for bodies tomorrow in the Gunness yard. On Friday, May 29th, Executor Fogle will hold a pub lic sale of the personal property left
Clipping to come
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · Hopkinsville, Ky.
Investigators at the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana, unearthed two more bodies near where three others had been found days earlier. One body was identified as a grown male, the other believed to be a woman's remains; the report also recounts neighbors' tales of mysterious men who visited Mrs. Gunness and vanished.
Hopkinsville Kentuckian · 12 May 1908 · page 3
Two More Bodies Found
Shortly after that a large man i I with a red mustache appeared and soon after disappeared Mrs Gun I ness said he answered her advertise ment for a husband but did not suit i i iI her I herTwo weeks after he disappeared third man said to have been in the lumber business in Wisconsin came 1 but dropped out of sight Two More Bodies Found Laporte Ind May 8Two more bodies were unearthed at the Guin ness farm today in a grave near the spot where three of the four bodies were exhumed Wednesday The first to be turned up is undoubtedly that of a grown male and the sec ond is believed to be the bonesof a woman
Coroner's physician Dr. Myer found three rings on the charred body taken from the Gunness farm ruins, including one inscribed with initials believed to be her late husband Peter Gunness. The report states the woman and three children died in bed or preparing for bed, with no marks of violence, while investigators also gathered testimony about her suspicious absence from her husband's funeral and a letter sent to a prospective victim.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 1
LAPORTE'S HOUSE OF HORRORS
' bJf igainst Lampbcro as an nc tviorv (lit killing of Hclgelein, it j nerrsian to indict Mrs. Gunness as , principal ILamphMo now stnnds before tho bar rHtifc ouimlly charged with arson, e murders and being the accessory another murder. Pigging today resulted in unearthing human kwl winch is believed be ep to one of the bodies dug up in the n yard two weeks ago. At the it three skeletons wero found in n -pool and why it was dropped thcro d tho rest of the body buried in the tit cemetery, the authorities cannot, plaia. Long hnir attached to the all is considered evidenco that it boswd to a woman. One of tho throe limbered bodies referred to was that ! a female.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
This opinion piece reflects on how Belle Gunness used want ads to attract and swindle lonely suitors at her LaPorte farm, likening it to a fool and his money being parted. It muses philosophically on human loneliness and the dangers of matrimonial advertising schemes.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
THE CUPID OF LAPORTE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
An investigator describes gruesome autopsy evidence on Helgelein's body showing signs of a violent struggle, including a severed hand clutching hair. A Pinkerton detective concludes after four days that Gunness died in the fire with her children, dismissing suicide theories and suspecting Lamphere or another enemy as the arsonist, even as public rumor holds she faked her death.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Neighbors and relatives in Austin claim none of the children living with Belle Gunness were her own, all having been adopted in infancy. A doctor recounts suspicious circumstances surrounding one supposed birth, suggesting it may have been staged.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Detroit Times · 12 May 1908 · page 1
NOT HODMAN’S EVIDENCE THAT LITTLE ONES LIVING WITH HER WERE MERELY ADOPTED. CHICAGO. May 12—It Is reported In Austin, the suburb where Mrs. Belle Gunness, the I.a Porte, Ind . murderess once lived, that none of the children sin* had living with her was her own. all having l»e» n adopted. Andrew Olson u cousin of Mads Sorenson, the first husband of the woman, said: “It was common talk among the neighbors, and even among her rela tives. that *he children were not ac tually hers, but were adopted In In ,fancy.'' I)r.
See moreSee less
J. B. Miller said: “I frequent ly attended Mrs. Sorenson and when she informed me that she was soon to become a mother, I was greatly surprised. A few mornings later I found a note under my door saying that I was wanted by Mrs. Sorenson. The note was dated at 9 o'clock the previdiis evenlYis, but It could not have been tho r e then for I passed through the door several times during the night. I immediately went over to the Sorenson house. 1 found Mrs Sorenson holding an infant. She said that she had sent for me. but when I could not he found, she had called an other physician, but 1 could never be lieve this story.’’ Looking for Jensen. CHRISTIANIA, May 12. News of the wholesale murders at La Porte, which has reached here, has caused a sensation. It is thought that one of the victim*, may have been Olar Jen sen. a youth about 23 years of age. who at one time lived in Christiania. Two years ago. attracted by Mrs. Gunness' marriage advertisements, he left Carroll county, ind.. whither he had gone from this city, and went to La Pbrte. He has not been heard from since, and his friends are now seeking to have the American legation here institute inquiries as to his w hereabouts. Senator William Alden Smith now has a club interest In Detroit, having Joined the new Michigan Republican club. His signed application was re ceived by Frank N. Renaud a couple of days ago v Hamtramck Democrats are getting Affidavits from persons whose names were marked ofT the registration books, losing them the chance to vote at the April election and will ask Prosecutor Yerkep to investigate the election dispute further. Mrs. YerkeS'Mizner Again in Spotlight; Robbed of Vanity Box IT i 3 TWr«. >rrkr«*Mltnrr, «th<mf picture la hprr «kim». I* nml* k»fnr» ikf pub lic. this llnif «• the » lc< lin of ■ thief, who atolo a ••vanity box,” brUaglaf 1‘ toJwr.
W. W. Lamphere, father of accused Ray Lamphere, arrives in Laporte to help his son's defense but is denied access to him by the sheriff. He insists his son is innocent and incapable of the murders, recounting a prior encounter with Mrs. Gunness.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 12 May 1908 · page 4
WILL DEFEND HIS SON
SUSPECTS GUNNESS WOMAN Strong in His Protestations Thst His Offspring Is Incapable of the Brutal Murders With Which He Stands Charged. Laporte, Intl., May 12.W. W. Lam phere, father of Ray Lamphere and a justice of the peace at Springfield, Ind., has arrived to assist in the de fense of his son. Sheriff Smutzer re fused him permissiun to interview the latter. H. W. "Worden, attorney for Ray Lamphere, declares he will bring about an interview with father and son if he is compelled to bring Ray to court. The father is strong in protesta tions of the innocence of his son and asserts that he believes Ray Lam phere incapable of the murders with which he stands charged.
See moreSee less
Mr. Lamphere, senior, says that at one time Mrs. Gunnoss bought fifty fence posts of hiiu and that while she was at the place he was strongly prejudiced against her. He ques tioned his son Ray about the latter's possible marriage wiih Mrs. Gunness and, advising against it, Ray told hi:r that he never would marry the wo man. a resident of Laporte,
A local man doubts Ray Lamphere capable of the murders, recounting that Lamphere once vowed never to marry Mrs. Gunness. Another account describes the funeral of Philip Gunness, where Mrs. Gunness was mysteriously absent and later revealed to have been consulting a lawyer about possible murder charges.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 12 May 1908 · page 4
man. Charles VTiy, a resident of Laporte, gave out an interesting interview in connection vith the funeral of Philip Gunness, tfc second husband of Mrs. Gunness, who was said to have been killed by being struck on the head by a falling sausage machine. Mr. Way says that he was a pallbearer at the funeral of Gunness. At the conclu sion of the funeral ceremony, when the cortege was about to start for the cemetery, Mrs. Gunness could not be found and it developed that she had not been present at the ceremonies.
See moreSee less
Considerable uneasiness wasfelt by those present at the funeral sermon for fear that the shock incident to the sudden death of her husband had un balanced the woman's mind and that she had made away with herself. The matter was about to be placed in the hands of the authorities when Mrs. Gunness drove up the McClung road. Everybody present was astounded when, as she drove up to the front of the house, she calmly remarked: "Go ahead and bury him. I guess
George Anderson of Tarkio, Mo., recounts how he answered Mrs. Gunness's matrimonial advertisement, was asked for money, and later woke to find her bending over him in his sleep. He now believes his lack of wealth spared him from being murdered, and speculates that she is still alive and that her daughter knew of her crimes.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Mrs. Gunness. St. Joseph, Mo., May 12."Because I had no money I now believe is the only thing that saved me from being murdered by Mrs. Gunness near La porte, Ind.," said George Anderson of Tarkio, Mo., as he boarded the Rock Island train for Chicago, where he will offer his personal testimony and letters written him by Mrs. Gunness to the authorities. "I think the woman is still alive and thai she set fire to the farmhouse herself. I believe that the eldest girl knew of her mother's crimes. I now recollect that she acted very strange ly.
See moreSee less
She would eye me with a pitiful look and when I glanced at her during a meal she was as white as a sheet." Anderson is a Swede thirty-nine years old. Two years ago while at Monteith, Mich., he answered one of Mrs. Gunness' advertisements, posing himself as a wealthy farmer. She wrote him to come on and he did so. The second day she asked him point blank how much money he had. He claimed only a few hundred dollars cash, but had a 320-acre farm. She told him to sell the farm and bring the money to her and they would be i.:arried. He went away for a few days and returned one night without notifying Mrs. Gunness. He found a Wan he now believes to be Ray Lam phere in her company. He confessed to her that he had no money. She was incensed, but told him to spend the night at her place. He went to bed, but was awakened and found the woman bending over him. He spoke and she ran out of the room. Greatly frightened he did not close his eyes after that and at daylight left the place.
Authorities in Laporte are gathering evidence to connect Ray Lamphere to the deaths of Mrs. Gunness, her three children, and Andrew Helgelein, including letters found in his trunk. The grand jury session was postponed a week on experts' advice, despite the prosecutor's earlier readiness to proceed, while excavation of the Gunness property continues amid crowds of curious onlookers.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 1
NO GRAND JURY
Laporte, Ind., May 11.-Picking up the shreds of evidence tending to con nect Ray .Lampnere with the deaths of,.Mrs. Gunness and her three chil. dren' and perhaps also of Andrew Hel gelein, is the main purpose of the au thorities here today. W.hether search for more more bodies will be prose cuted has not been finally determined, Sheriff Smulser indicating yesterday that further excavation may be post poned. The sheriff ha difmculty in carrying on this work because of the morbidly curious persons who have flocked to the place where the corpses wae discovered last week.
See moreSee less
Friday the excavating in the barnyard was hindered and. Saturday. it, Was halted by. the crowds. It is expected, how ever, that the number of visitors will be lessened today somewhat. The grand jury was to have met today to consider Lamphere's case, but this procedure has been post poned for a week. Experts who were called Into the affair by Sheriff Smul zer advised this course, although Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney for the judicial district, had an nounced only a few hours before the decision was made that he was ready' to go into court with the evidence at hand.
The grand jury session on Lamphere's case was postponed a week on expert advice, despite the prosecutor's readiness to proceed, as new evidence including letters from Lamphere's trunk strengthened the case against him. The defense claims the headless adult corpse was another victim and that Mrs. Gunness set the fire herself, but witnesses have repudiated these claims and medical examiners' findings do not support the defense's theory.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 1
NO GRAND JURY
Defense Not Revealed. The attitude of the depense has not been revealed to any great extent. The prisoner has received strict o. ders from his attorneys not to die cuss the charges against him and the attorneys themselves have not corn mitted themselves to any particular line of action. They. have been free in advancing theories to account for Lamphere's actions before and following his ar rest. and he has given out alleged evi dence which they ,claim to have se cured and which they say establishes the fact that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and not Lamphere set fire to the house. The adult headless corpse found with the blackened bodies of the children was, they assert, that of another victim of the Gunness woman, the theory being that the head was severed by Mrs. Gunness in order that it 'might be thought the body was hers.
Lamphere's attorneys allege evidence suggesting Belle Gunness is still alive and set the fire herself, killing another victim whose headless body was found among the ruins, but several people have repudiated the interviews used to support this theory and physicians' autopsy findings contradict it. La Porte's mayor criticizes the investigation as lukewarm and calls for more lakes to be dragged and a centralized effort to solve the mystery.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 1
side. Prosecutor Sh.ith denouncbes thbes methods, but there is no gainsa.in the fact that the impreselot. that Mf~ Gunness is still alive is widespread, despite almost total 'absende of evi dence to support it. This circum stance will make the task of picking a trial jury difficult and there is scarcely a man .or woman in the com munity who has not formed or ex
A satirical press commentary column jokes that since a relationship was traced between the Benders and Mrs. Gunness, someone should prove she is Kate Bender. It also remarks that the 'ghastly discoveries' at La Porte, Indiana are a tribute to the efficacy of advertising, referencing Gunness's matrimonial ads.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 4
which has been investigating the GunInstitutions. The message i3 a stinging arraignment of the committee ness house on the bill and its trage for unfairness, and Is very lengthy. It dies came into Judge Richter's court is backed up by voluminous records yesterday afternoon and returned from the state institutions and reports . three indictments. Lamphere is r of the superintendents of the same. j charged with arson in setting fire to The governor charges the committee the home of Mrs. Gunness on the with being biased and not endeavoring morning of April 28.
See moreSee less
He is charged to ascertain the true facts in regard to also with being a principal and an ac the institutions. At the conclusion the I cessory after the fact in the mufder cf Andrew Helgelein of Aberdeen, S. governor-aays: D., and with the murder of Mrs. Gun lues Vigorous IianiniaKr.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
George Anderson of Tarkio, Mo., describes surviving a visit to Belle Gunness' farm after admitting he had little money, waking to find her standing over him in the night. He says he believes she set the fire herself and may still be alive, and is heading to Chicago with letters to share with authorities.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 4
James Brimmingstall. aged 41, is a murderous urge of the Mra. Gunness type Is now said to be fully estab lished by the police, who claim that the man has confessed to the killing of six persons, although it is believed his victims number at least IC. Briminingstall's wife, on whose ac cusation he was arrested, says shv saw him kill oue man —linvid Husf — smothering him with pillows as he lay In bed. Her husband then told her (CoatlniM-d on Seoon«l I'lisO,
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
A Swedish suitor named Anderson describes how Belle Gunness demanded he liquidate his farm assets and bring her the money, and how he fled after finding her bending over him at night. A separate account from an Oklahoma resident recalls suspicious behavior at Gunness's Chicago store, including a poisoning scare involving her husband Sorenson.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 4
LACK OF MONEY SAVED HIM.
James Brimmingstall. aged 41, is a murderous urge of the Mra. Gunness type Is now said to be fully estab lished by the police, who claim that the man has confessed to the killing of six persons, although it is believed his victims number at least IC. Briminingstall's wife, on whose ac cusation he was arrested, says shv saw him kill oue man —linvid Husf — smothering him with pillows as he lay In bed. Her husband then told her (CoatlniM-d on Seoon«l I'lisO,
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Laporte county and city officials are reported to be in conflict over identification of the body found in the Gunness farm ruins, with political factionalism blamed for disputes between the sheriff and prosecutor's camps. Dr. H. H. Long denies issuing a statement questioning the corpse's identity, saying he only expressed a personal opinion of doubt, while another physician on the autopsy board maintains confidence in the identification.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 6
THEORIZING IN GUNNESS CASE
COMES TO LIGHT. LA PORTE, Ind., May 23.—Three tnfliotmeaLs, charging murder and arson against Ray Lamphere, Mrs Qonaeas’ former farm hand, were brought In by the grand Jury, yester day afternoon, lamp here Is charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children Myrtle, lacy and i Philip; with arson In burning down the house In which they are bettered ' to here perished and with being a \ principal and an accessory after the 1 fact in the murder of Andrew Helgelein, of Aberdeen, 8. D. The. state sets forth, is keeping I with the provisions of the law, that ! It will .prove the material allegations ‘by the evidence-of John . Rye, William Anstlss, Charles Hralth. D. M. Hutson,
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
A dispute arose between sheriff's and prosecutor's factions over reports that the burned corpse was not Belle Gunness but another woman, with one autopsy physician denying he made such a claim. Three of four doctors affirmed the body was indeed Mrs. Gunness, citing consistent autopsy findings across the bodies that contradicted theories of a substituted corpse.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 6
JACKSON. Mich.. May A*—K surmised that Edward Swanson.'who disappeared from Jackson last Sep tember, may have been s victim of Mrs. Gunness, of Deports, Ind. His Uls
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
A medical board found no evidence of blunt-force skull fractures or brain hemorrhages in the three children's bodies, countering theories of violent killing before the fire. Doctors argued heat distortion explained the headless woman's smaller size, and additional relics—a ring fragment, belt buckle, and matching key—further supported that the corpse was Belle Gunness herself, though searches for more bodies continued.
The Billings Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 6
WILL SLUICE THE ASHES
It to be.—Congress has passed a number of appropriation bills, and an especially strong ef fort, barked by the Governors' Conference, u making to force action on the forest reserve bill. The llrownsvllle case has been postponed for final action till next December The political conventions held these last f.-w days have not al tered the outlook for llryan and Taft Roth In j North Carolina and Virginia last »wk negro It* publicans held Independent Stale Conventions and elected delegateo-at-Jarge to the National Republican Convention who will contest the seat* of delegates elected by the regular "Illy white" organizations.
See moreSee less
Kx-Governor Daniel L. Russel, of North Carolina, died near Wilmington. Thursday, ag«*d sixty-three years Indiana ha* what prom ises to he one of the great criminal sensations of our time. For years past a Mrs Gunness ha* en ticed men to her homo with a matrimonial advi-r tlsernent, asking suitors to bring $1,000 a* a guarantee of good faith. Hho has murdered fourteen such suckers In the course of her career The scheme for old age pensions Is now »erl .1 I .. 1* .m I — a.. L'l .4 .. t I_^ ... . t • i « u'ltiwi n ** in' in ' ii la to bo paid persona over Keventy. Cotton had a turn upward for a time laat week, but the gen eral business situation la Improving only slowly Many Southern cotton mills are not running on full time, and In Kngland 30,000 operatives In the Lancashire district are out of work - With our next issue the usual full review of the news .will be resumed. * Tin: I’AitMi:it’s intkickht in tiik wiiiti:
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
A newspaper editorial column briefly comments on Mrs. Gunness, describing her methods of luring victims to death as rivaling medieval crimes. It characterizes her as having planned murders for financial gain with a complete absence of conscience.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 12 May 1908 · page 2
Stories of Mrs. Gunness’ methods of luring victims to death reveal a condition rivaling the crimes of the middle ages. Her carefully planned series of murders for pecuniary gain
A carpenter who worked at the Gunness farm, Emil Greening, recounts suspicious disappearances of men and suggests investigators search stump holes left after digging, believing the house claimed victims monthly. The report also notes earlier suspicions that Gunness had tried to poison a husband and describes how Lamphere came to work for and board with her.
Omaha Daily Bee · 12 May 1908 · page 2
NET CLOSES ON LAMPHERE
has The Laporte county council appropriated $9,000 for the use of of ficials concerned In the developments in the Gunness case. This assurer the continuance of Sheriff Smutzer's
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
Emil Greening, a former worker at the Gunness farm, describes digging stump holes that could have hidden victims and recalls odd details like scattered watches, pistols, and men's clothing. He also recounts how Mrs. Gunness lured Ray Lamphere to work and later depend on her, while George Anderson travels to La Porte to offer testimony and letters as a potential victim who escaped death only for lack of money.
Omaha Daily Bee · 12 May 1908 · page 2
Laporte citizens are convinced that Mrs. Gunness perished in the flames that destroyed her home, and that Ray Lamphere was responsible for the burning of the place. The general feeling is that it was wrong to burn up
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
George Anderson recounts a frightening encounter at Belle Gunness's farm two years earlier, claiming he saw a man he now believes was Ray Lamphere and that Gunness herself loomed over his bed at night; he believes she is still alive and set the fire herself. Separately, Pittsburg police pursue a woman suspected of being Gunness based on a train conductor's identification, though an officer hesitated to arrest her.
Omaha Daily Bee · 12 May 1908 · page 2
MAY IDENTIFY RAY LAMPHERE
FOR MORE BODIES (By Associated Press.) LAPORTE, Ind., May 21. Tomor row promises developmenst in the dimness case. Early this morning Coroner Mack will file his official re ports on the death of the three chil dren of Mrs. Gunness. Some time during the day the Grand Jury will complete Its labors. If true bills ar; voted. Indictments will be reported to Judge Richter In the Laporte Cir cuit Court. Sheriff Smutzer resumes the digging for bodies tomorrow in the Gunness yard. On Friday, May 29th, Executor Fogle will hold a pub lic sale of the personal property left
Clipping to come
The Monroe Journal · Monroe, N.C.
The report describes the uncovering of a series of deliberate murders committed by a woman at La Porte, Indiana, after her farm house burned down. It notes she lived with her three children and that the crime revealed knowledge of other victims.
The Monroe Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 2
The Bloody Record ol a Woman Who Turned Her Home Into a Murder ftoop. At laporte. Ind., cae of the mont en.uiuaal dicuerir of a srrit-s of ! JrhLerate murder by a woman ever known in this cvuutrjr has been unAs i often tbe raw, one
Sheriff Smutzer of La Porte announces he believes Belle Gunness killed at least 33 people and is still alive, having fled with stolen money rather than dying in the farmhouse fire. He reports that only two of five newly found bodies have been identified so far, including Andrew Helgelien and adopted daughter Jennie Olson, and vows to keep searching the property for more remains.
The Monroe Journal · 12 May 1908 · page 2
As i often tbe raw, one liete that site really ecaed and is now at large. After the burning the remains of five murdeied rns were found buried about the lot. She seems to have conducted a matrimo nial agency, passing as a rich widow, living on her farm, who wanted to get married to a man of equal means, who a as always required to go to her home to see her. Arriving there, his money was stvured and his body made way with. Sit far, only two of the bodies have hem identitiel.
See moreSee less
These are Andrew lleldgren, who came to this city from Aberdeen, S. 1., for the purpose of marrying Mrs. Gunness, whose ac quaintance he had made through a matrimonial bureau. The other is that of Jennie Olsru Gunness, a Chi cago girl, w ho had been adopted by Mrs. Gunness. She disappeared in
Investigators report finding a gold-crowned tooth believed to be from Belle Gunness's head, along with rings bearing puzzling inscriptions on the body authorities claim is hers. Bent scissors and knives resembling surgical instruments were also unearthed, suggesting she drugged victims before dissecting them.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 12 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS VICTIMS DISSECTED WITH SURGEON'S KNIVES
Arson and Five Murcers. Lamphcrc now stands before the bar of justice officially charged iwth arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the Helgeirin murder. Separate bills were reeturned against Lamphere for the murder in the first degree of Mrs. Belie Guinness and her three children. Philip Gunness,
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
Investigators sifting through the burned Gunness farmhouse find inscribed rings, scissors, and knives, including a dirk believed to be the murder weapon. A neighbor recalls Mrs. Gunness wearing a belt with knife sheaths, while authorities prepare evidence for the grand jury considering charges against Ray Lamphere.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 12 May 1908 · page 1
her three children. Philip Gunness, Myrtle Sorensen and Lucy Sorensen. The unusual feature of the seventh true-hill is its Indictment of the dead woman. It reads: "The grand jury presents that Belle Gunness. late of the county of Laporf". and state of Indiana, on the Hth day of January. lJWIS, did unlawfully, feloniously, wil? fully and with premeditated malice kill and murder Andrew Helgelrln. th?? means and manner of stich kill ing being to the grand jury unknown." Lamphere Not Arraigned. Ijamphere was not arraigned and this will probably not be done until theases are set for trial.
See moreSee less
Bench warrants, issued by Judge J. C. Rich? ter, were served upon lamphere in jail this evening. He expressed but .'light surprise as the returning of indictments had been anticipated. "I shall ask to have the eases set down for early tril this term." said Prosecutor Smith todav.
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
Prosecutor Smith prepares depositions for the grand jury to consider charges against Ray Lamphere, pending coroner's reports on the Gunness victims' autopsies. Officials state that chloral poisoning has been proven and expect to fully solve the murder-farm mystery within 48 hours.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 12 May 1908 · page 1
West Virginian a Victim. The latest news from the Gun ness murder farm at Laporte, Ind., is that Sheriff Smutzer has announced that he will start the dragging of the little pond at the foot 'of the private cemetery and may also move the barn to learn 1 if bodies were buried under the cement floor. Sheriff Smutzer has received an anonymous letter stating that a large number of bodies are buried under the barn, and he will make a thorough in vestigation. Another probable victim of Mrs. Gunness came to light when in vestigation was started for Abra ham Phillips, of Belington, Bar bour county, W.
See moreSee less
Va., who left there in February, 1907, to go to Laporte to marry a rich widow, name unknown. He left farm and other property in West Vir ginia, but took a big sum of mon ey with him. He has not been seen since. Coroner Mack has appointed
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Investigators found rings on a hand from the fire ruins, initially seeming to confirm the body was Belle Gunness, but a nearby cemetery grave was found robbed of a corpse, reviving suspicion she substituted another woman's headless body and fled. Physicians also noted the recovered body lacked a scar Gunness was known to have.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 12 May 1908 · page 2
FIND A GRAVE WAS ROBBED
Drs. F. T. Wilcox and George R. Osborn t o hold autopsies o n bodies and skeletons of seven un known persons exhumed from the Gunness farm. Two of these have trunks which contain inter nal organs and so it is expected it will be possible to determine if death was caused by poison of any kind. Complete and careful descriptions of all marks, teeth, skulls, etc., will be taken of the seven skeletons and these will be filed for the purpose of identifi cation in future. Finding was made by Coroner Mack that the body of the female found in the ground is that of Jennie Olson, she having been identified by her father and sister at Chicago.
See moreSee less
Coroner Mack stated that he would soon render his verdict in the cases of the fourteen dead in the Gunness mystery. At Philippi, Barbour county, , Mrs. Martha Duckworth was awarded $1,500 damages in a suit brought against Floyd Stalnaker, a saloonkeeper, for injuries to her \ husband. Duckworth became in \ toxicated in Stalnaker’s saloon l and the latter threw him out, | breaking both bones in his leg.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Police investigate a disturbed grave rumored to contain a stolen woman's body, fueling theories Gunness faked her death. Doctors note the headless corpse lacks Gunness's known scar, while an autopsy reveals hair clenched in victim Helgelein's severed-fingered fist, possibly matching suspect Ray Lamphere.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 12 May 1908 · page 2
HAIR FOUND IN CLENCHED FIST
CORONER REPORTS ON MRS. GUNNESS f VICTIMS Holds That Four Were Feloniously Killed by Persans Unknown to Him IJL POBTB. Ind^ MarJa^-^peolarlnx Chat they came to their deaths through felonious homicide. Coroner Mack this •vening filed his c facial reports on' tne Ceaths of four more vctlms ot the GunSiess farm. ; Th« verdicts are In the'eases of Jen "sJeOlsen of Chicago, Ole : Budsbnrg "of lola, Wis., and two unidentified bodies, one male and one female. •. The coroner holds that the persons who are re sponsible for their deaths are to him unknown. Six bodies still remain to be reported or_
Clipping to come
The Morris County Chronicle · Morristown, N.J.
Investigators suspect that Belle Gunness staged her own death in the April 28 fire, using a headless corpse possibly stolen from a nearby cemetery, while multiple murder victims are unearthed from her farm. Police are investigating the theory that she fled after murdering men lured by matrimonial ads.
The Morris County Chronicle · 12 May 1908 · page 8
DIGGING UP CORPSES: INDIANA WOMAN'S FARM YIELDS MANY DEAD BODIES. HER OWN DEATH REPORTED.
All Victims. I>aporte, Ind., May 12. — Mrs. Belle Gunness, a handsome, fascinating wo man, who herself came to a dreadful fate about two weeks ago, is believed to have been guilty of many murders. The bodies of her supposed victims were found burled in the yard of her home, where she and her three children were reported burned to deatb on the alight of April 28. There is now a suspicion Mrs. Gun ness may not have died in the fire Which destroyed the farmhouse on April 28. Doubt exists over the head less body of a woman found in the ruins, and it is thought Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness may have had a body brought here from Chicago and after firing the house made her own escape. She is believed to have enticed men with matrimonial advertisements and then to have rob bed and murdered them. It was discovered that a seldom vis ited cemetery a few miles away from her farm had recently been robbed of a body. A laborer passing through it found a disturbed grave and an empty coffin. Chief of Police Cochran and two detectives are investigating. They heard, though not authoritative ly, that it was a woman’s body which had been stolen. If this proves to lie eo, they and many others firmly be lieve the first theory—that Mrs. Guil tless left a corpse without a head to impersonate her while she fled after the house was tired.
A disturbed grave near the farm suggests a body, possibly a woman's, was stolen to impersonate Belle Gunness and allow her to escape after setting the fire. The report also details her background as a Norwegian immigrant, describes her appearance, and tallies fifteen suspicious deaths linked to her, including two husbands who died suddenly.
The Morris County Chronicle · 12 May 1908 · page 8
HER OWN DEATH REPORTED.
Murderess a Norwegian. What sort of a woman was this astounding murderer? That is a hard question, and yet something can he done toward answering. She was a Norwegian who lacked about two years of the half century mark. She was born in Norway, and came to America us a young girl. In Chicago in 1883 she married Max Sorenson, a fellow coun tryman. He died suddenly in 1890. Two years later she married Gunness. He died suddenly also. As will he seen, death, sudden and mysterious, at tended Belle Gunness for many years.
See moreSee less
When she came to Laporte six years ago with Gunness, Mrs. Gunness was a fat, coarse featured woman who stood about live feet seven and weigh ed about 220 pounds. She had a big, heavy head, a mop of coarse hair of a muddy brown, little eyes that just missed being black, huge hands and arms and legs and feet grotesquely small for the burden they had to sup port. Everybody who knew her agrees that she was far from attractive. Most of lier acquaintances describe her ns re pulsive. Some of her neighbors go fur ther than that. “More a devil than a woman,” is the way they put it. In all there are fifteen deaths which may be traced to Mrs. Gunness. The bodies of two men, one girl and two small children were found first. Two of the bodies found later were those of a man and a woman, and two were so terribly dismembered and hacked as to make it difficult to determine the sex. This fact will not lie known until the autopsy. It is believed Mrs. Gunness fired the house and that if she did not delltiorately wait for death in the flames that she was responsible for the death of the woman whose body may have been carried to the house to be taken for her own. In the flames the three small children of the woman were burned almost to cinders. This gives thirteen, and in addition the two husbands of the woman met sudden death. The first. Max Sorensen, drop ped dead, supposedly from heart dis ease. Ills relatives alleged that lie had been poisoned, but an order to exhume the body was not carried out.
Investigators report ten bodies found at the Gunness farm, killed by spike wounds to the back of the skull, with two identified as Jennie Olson. A disputed identification of Andrew Helgelein's body is accepted by the coroner despite autopsy evidence suggesting the body was buried more recently than his disappearance.
The Morris County Chronicle · 12 May 1908 · page 8
Identifies Corpse as Brother. Ask K. Helgelein, whose inquiries re garding his missing brother, Andrew, led to the first discoveries on the death haunted farm, became sure that the largest and best preserved of the corpses is that of his brother. Against this identification, however, is the re sult of the autopsy performed on this body by Dr. .T. H. Meyer. He found conditions which, to his mind, proved that the man perished long after An drew Helgelein disappeared last Jan uary. Dr. Meyer said that the corpse showed evidences of having been in the grouud less than two weeks.
See moreSee less
Ask Helgelein, however, refused to be con vinced by these findings, and his cer iainty led the qorotfer to accept his identification for tkd'ptasent. Roy Lnmphere, who is held on a charge of first degreemurder as a re sult of the fire that destroyed the Gun ness home and caused the deaths of Mrs, Gunness and Mffthree children
Investigators report finding nearly two dozen pairs of scissors, bent and curved like surgical instruments, along with several knives in the ashes of the Gunness farm cellar. The items are suspected to have been used as weapons on the victims found at the site.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 12 May 1908 · page 1
WEAPONS USED TO SLAY VICTIMS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
Investigators report finding nearly two dozen scissors bent like surgical instruments, along with knives and a dirk in the ashes of the Gunness cellar, believed possibly used as murder weapons. A gold crown tooth, thought to be Mrs. Gunness's, was also discovered, while the grand jury considers charges against Ray Lamphere.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 12 May 1908 · page 1
By UwitMl hw. Laporte Ind., May 18.— J. G. Renden, of Manfred N. D. step brutherof John Moo,of Elbow Lake, Minn., one of the victims of Mrs. Gunness, arrived here today and partially identified another of the bodies. If the body recovered by Renden is that of Moo identifica tion is uncertain at best, because the corpse is little more than a skeleton. More sub|K>enas have been sent out for 43 men, women and children to tell their stories to the jurors. The following is a tabulation of I the money obtained by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness from various victims: Mars Sorenson, first husband life in surance Peter Gunness, second husband, life insurance IL 00b. Charles Erdman, New Carlisle, Ind., 15,000. Herman Knitter, Chicago |G,OOOOle Budtburg lola, VVis., 12,000 John C. Moo Elbow I «alce, Minn., 11,500. Andrew
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.
A literary commentary piece compares Belle Gunness to other infamous criminals like the Benders, describing her murders as a calculated business rather than acts of passion. It raises the still-unresolved question of whether she perished in the fire or escaped to kill again.
Albuquerque Citizen · 12 May 1908 · page 2
IHurtW as a Profession De Quincey would have found the materials for a congenial character wtudy In Mrs. Bella Gunness, the Indiana murderess, ways the New York World. Here was a woman who made of murder not merely a fine art but a sys tem, one who commercialized homicide and put it on a divlde-nd-paylng basis. She was not actuated by revenge or to secure the opportunity for Intrigue, like Brlnvllllers. She practiced murder for a livelihood, as Cassie eChadwlck and Mme. Humbert practiced swindling, making it her vocation. The secret chamber In which her victims were despatched, the cellar In which their remains were stored before dismemberment and the manner of burial Illustrate the elaboration of hr methods.
See moreSee less
The Bender murders furnish a parallel only In the mutter of cold-blooded atrocity. The. Kansas family of assassins drew their supply of victims from chance lodgers In the ir lonely cabin. Mrs. Gunness In the guise of a "comely widow" enticed men to her side through a matrimonial advertise ment. Were they struck down while the Influence of her charms was strong upon them or mercifully drugged or poisoned? Did their slayer perish in the fire that burned her home or is he preparing In a new environment to continue her career of murder?
State's Attorney Smith and detectives conclude that the body found at the Gunness farm is hers, and that Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed her and her three children. The report states that few now doubt she is dead, either by her own hand or through the acts of an incendiary.
The Sun · 12 May 1908 · page 5
I THINK MRS GUNNESS IS DEAD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A witness describes how smoke filled the children's room during the fire and how Mrs. Gunness protected them as she died, while investigators note the significance of quilt fragments found at the scene. Separately, State's Attorney Smith reveals that a trunk belonging to Ray Lamphere, containing letters written to him by Mrs. Gunness, was discovered hidden at the farm, and Lamphere's elderly father visited him in custody.
The Sun · 12 May 1908 · page 5
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Local officers report what they regard as conclusive evidence on how Belle Gunness killed her victims: she used chloroform to render them unconscious in a specially deadened chamber off the parlor, then dismembered bodies in the cellar before burying them in the yard. The piece also describes Ray Lamphere's elderly father visiting him in jail, expressing belief in his son's innocence and calling Gunness a murderer.
The Sun · 12 May 1908 · page 5
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Rev. E. A. Schell of Laporte confirms Ray Lamphere made a statement to him about the Gunness case but refuses to reveal its contents, citing confessional confidentiality. He advised Lamphere to tell the prosecuting attorney what he had confided, noting conflicting statements had emerged from Lamphere during questioning.
The Evening World · 12 May 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE CONFESSED MURDER FARM SECRET MINISTER DECLARES
II t My Lips Are Sealed Says Rev E f A Schell but I Advised Him to Tell the Prosecuting Attorney tj What He Told Meu 1 BALTIMORE May 12That Ray Lunphere charged with the F rl burning of the Gunness home and the deaths of its occupants near i f La porte Ind made a statement connected with the case to Rev E A I 1 Schell of Laporte was admitted by Mr Schell today The latter how Ilt ever who is pastor of the M E Church at Laporte and a delegate to t the Metrodist Episcopal General Conference here refused to divulge f anything as to its nature i My lips are sealed said Mr Schell I got these things in the t confessional I found that the prosecuting officers were sweating 1 t Lamphere and I appealed for fair play in his behalf I said that he I l should be allowed to have a lawyer and I told them so I UDut I advlsrd Lamphere to tell the clothing and night robes found with prosecuting attorney exactly what he
State's Attorney Smith announces a major new sensation involving Lamphere, reportedly based on admissions made to his jailhouse visitor Rev. E.A. Schell. Lamphere's defense denies any confession and instead pushes the theory that Belle Gunness is still alive, claiming the body found in the fire was actually Gunness's first wife.
The Evening World · 12 May 1908 · page 2
MINISTER DECLARES
Smith announced that the greatest sen It salon yet developed In connection with t the Gunness murder farm would he un < covered probably within a few hours He added that It not only would siartlu the country but clarify the mystery L that has enshrouded the crlmer of the t c Indiana Borgia As this statement was made lawyer Worden of counsel for Uay Lamphere rushed a telegram to John U Larson a nephew of Mrs Belle Gunness who Is In Chicago to immediately start a search for the first wife of Philip Gun OBS who divorced her first husband to marry Gimnesii The exceptional activity of the do fense and the prosecuUon suggests that Lamphere is the central figure In the promised new sensation The prosecu k toln claims to hive damaging admis l sions from Iam her and the person through whom It is dfclnrfcd they have
Investigators pursue a theory that Belle Gunness faked her death by burning another woman in the fire, while the prosecutor insists a gold-crowned tooth and ring prove the corpse is hers. Dr. Gray's previously suppressed autopsy report is released, detailing rings, clothing remnants, and inconclusive findings on cause of death for the female body and an infant.
The Evening World · 12 May 1908 · page 2
Evidence which has been hitherto I tained In the report of Ur J L tray Dupprested was rnado public in the Gunness tragnly today Jt H con Who performed thw utoiay on the body 11 nvlilch thu a utliorit lea Imvc stoulfastfy
A La Porte physician, Dr. H. H. Martin, recounts how in 1902 he was called to examine and then pronounce dead a six-month-old infant brought by the Gunness household, originally attributing death to pulmonary oedema. In light of later revelations, he now believes Belle Gunness strangled or suffocated the child, adding another suspected victim to her growing list.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 May 1908 · page 1
LIST OF HER VICTIMS IS DAILY GROWING LONGER - BELIEVED TO HAVE KILLED CHILD
were no Bymptoms of any serious ill ness. The Bcond day after that" I was called from my bed at 2 o'clock In the morning to go out to the Qunness place. I drove out thero and found the child dead. It had all the symp torae of death from oedema of the lungs, and that was the cause that I gave In tho doath certificate. Oedema of tho lungs means that the lungs uftYObecorae filled with serum or ocfme other throat discharges that the plitient has' this been suffocated. It Is not at all an uncommon cause of tteath. among Infants. But in the light ol-what'we.know about Mrs. Gunness today there Is no doubt In my mind that she strangled or suffocated that child.71 --
A doctor recounts being called to the Gunness home to find a child dead, which he certified as death from pulmonary oedema at the time. He now believes, given what is known about Belle Gunness, that she actually strangled or suffocated the child. The report also covers ongoing developments: Lamphere jailed awaiting grand jury action, debate over a reward for Gunness's capture, and merchants recalling men she introduced as husbands.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 May 1908 · page 1
KILLED CHILD
before the Are," he demanded, "com plaining of; Larophere, her ex-paramour, having her will made and say ing she fearfed for her life,'' Ray Lamphere Is still locked up tin Jail accused of sotting tho Gunness
The report discusses letters from people seeking to identify possible victims among the Gunness farm exhumations, including a man with a crippled foot from Medina, N.Y. It details investigators' theory that Belle Gunness used poison rather than physical violence or chloroform to kill her victims, based on the lack of violence signs on bodies and the logistics of dismemberment after death.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Coroner Mack today got a letter from Wesley Fries, of Richmond Cen tre, Wis., saying that a forty year old friend of his had disappeared and would the coronei see it' any of tho .Gunness vlctlme answered his de scrlntlqn. The missing man had a
An unnamed source recounts driving Asle Helgelein back to town after he exhumed his brother Andrew's mutilated remains from Belle Gunness's property. Helgelein explains he suspected murder when his brother, who had gone to see Gunness, failed to return or write for four months.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 May 1908 · page 4
LIST OF GUNNESS VICTIMS GROWING
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
A correspondent recounts Asle Helgelein's own story of how he suspected Belle Gunness murdered his brother Andrew and searched the garden after the fire, finding his body buried beneath rubbish. The report notes ten bodies have now been exhumed from the farm, with authorities pausing excavation due to crowds of curious onlookers.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 May 1908 · page 4
VICTIMS GROWING
The Albuquerque Journal does not believe that was Mrs. Gunness' body found in the debris of her burned home. It admits the identity of the false teeth but accounts for their pres ence on the theory that the murderess had burned her bridges behind her. After all, what dlference does it make whether Madame Anna Gould has already married the Prince de Sa gan or is yet to marry him or if she never marries him. Both of these peo ple have been given more attention than they have really earned.
See moreSee less
If Mrs. Evelyn Thaw harbors a de lusion -that she can find anything of the property of the late William Thaw of Pittsburg lying around loose and unprotected, she ought to be sent to join her husband in the asylum. Prohibition ' Oklahoma must have enough water now to suit it.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
Asa Helgelein's digging led to ten bodies being exhumed from the Gunness farm, with authorities pausing excavation due to overwhelming crowds of spectators numbering around ten thousand. Doctors remain divided on whether the charred fourth body found in the fire is Belle Gunness herself, while rumors persist of a mysterious car seen fleeing the scene.
The Stark County Democrat · 12 May 1908 · page 4
VICTIMS GROWING
more. The known dead in Texas and Okla ——— homa floods were reported to be seventeen: six persons were drowned when a railroad bridge gave way at Dallas. —=—— The theory was ad vanced in Laporte that the body burned in the fire at the Gunness farm was that of Mav Reilley, of Rochesier, and that Mrs. Gunness es
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
A second medical examination convinced Dr. Meyer the burned body was indeed Belle Gunness, based on rings and clothing fragments, with evidence she and her children died in bed before the fire. Authorities claimed to have proof that Ray Lamphere set the fire and that other victims were poisoned and dismembered, saying the mystery would soon be fully solved.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Marion Daily Mirror · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MISTRESS OF Lapor.o, lnd May 12 A second examination, made today of tho body of the woman round In thu I ulna of the burned (JunnoEa homo has practically convinced the Coro ner's physician. Meyer, thu tho body Ib really that ot Mrs. Hello Uunness. On tho arm attached to tho body wcro ono plain gold ring and two diamond rings. The gold ring bore 'an Inscription apparent ly Indicating .that at was & .ring given to Mrs. Gunness by her first husband nnd ono die always woro. Dr. Meyer and Dr.
See moreSee less
Clray In an oillelal report of their examination to ,tho coroner said the woman and her three children mad evidently met death while they wcro In bed or were preparing to retlro. Frag, menu of night gowns were found on tho woman's body and on tho bodoa of tho ohlldrcn. ..Laporte, Ind., May 12.-Tho mys tery of tho Gulnnea "Port of Missing Men" will ho mado public within rdr ty eight hours. It 13 already solved. So doclara the officials of Laporte. rj"hy declare they have proof that JIay'Lamplioro sot Are to tho Guln jis .liome thereby causing the death of tho .woman and her threo children. f hoy declare tho ten other victims of tho house of death woro poisoned; that they luiow whero the poson wna purchased. Whey declare the bodies or tho vic tims -were dismembered after death, either In ia room on tho second floor of tho houso or In .tho baaeinout. Tjhey deolaro they have the knives iwlth wiiloh tho bodies were dlsniomColumbus, O., uMay 12-Tho coun ty salary law, under which all the county ofllclals of Ohio nro now nerving, la constltuUoual. Tho Biipromo ourt bo declared today In tho, case of John Ij. Theobold, re corder of Montgomery county, against) Edward T. Hall, a taxpayer. Theobald had refused to oboy the salary law, claiming It to bo un constitutional and Insisted on talc ing foes. Taxpayor Hall Biied to
Witnesses place Ray Lamphere near the Gunness farm before the fire, and experts say it was deliberately set with kerosene; his alibi is undermined by an alarm clock set for 3 a.m. though the fire began after 4. Sheriff Smutzer and Louis Schultz resume sluicing ashes in the basement ruins searching for further evidence after rain delays.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 12 May 1908 · page 1
WAS MURDERED AND CREMATED
near Iho farm before the afternoon I tho blaze started and experts have declared that It wan of Incendiary 'origin, that it was Marled outside the basemen! door, near tho southoist corttc by means of flvo gallons ot kero sene pour.'d from .1 tan iriat Tell with in tho line or the building ns the dsot; crumpled under tho Itatnes. I Ills rllbl that he was nt tho homo of Mis. IHlzab:th Smith, a seventy-year-old negro woman, wltliln the limits or laporte, at the time tho liro was started waa met by tho mute .tfllmony or H13 alarm clock that ho said awakened him.
See moreSee less
It was set lor 3 o'clock 31ml the firo wa3 discovered sl'irtly nfter 4 o'clock. He has ad mit! 'd that lie saw the ulazo from a distance, but he has not made a con fe'sbn or thu facts which, It is de clared, will bo shown aalust him when hln (iifc Is called. I 'Guinness' farm Mem day failed to re veal now mystenlos but progress wan mado toward solving the puzzles al ready Involved Jn the horiusuad which lies witnessed the tragic, deaths or ut Iccit fourteen persons. Heavy show m yrt.enlay undo excavations im possible, but between tho downpours 'Sheilft Smutzer and Imis Schultz worked on the apparatus with which
The La Porte city council offered a $5,000 reward for the discovery of the mistress of the farm dubbed the 'Port of Missing Men.' Crowds reportedly turned the Gunness farm into a scene resembling a county fair on Sunday.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 12 May 1908 · page 4
THE DOCTORS SUED FltESII LIGHT ON THE CHIMES OF MBS. GUNNESS. LA POUTK (Ina.). May 18. The autopsy held today on tho remains of tho Bovcn unidentified bodies exhum
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
Coroner's physician Dr. J. H. Meyers discovered three rings embedded in the flesh of a hand on the body found in the ashes of the Gunness home, previously unnoticed in the first examination. Several witnesses identified the rings, including one inscribed with the initials of Mrs. Gunness's second husband, as definitively belonging to Belle Gunness.
East Oregonian : E.O · 12 May 1908 · page 1
BODY IN RUINS IS IDENTIFIED BY RINGS
terns, value, $13.50, in nn sale price IU.UU h 8-3x10-6 Brussels rugs, assorted patterns, value $15.00, 12.50 ealo price i... has information proving Mrs. Gunness was alive and suggesting that com munication be opened with him. Mis. Charles, writing from West Side Chicago, wrote that she pos
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Neighbors and relatives in Austin, Chicago claim the children bearing Belle Gunness's name were adopted rather than born to her. A doctor recounts suspicious circumstances surrounding the birth of one child, doubting her claims of motherhood.
The Morning Tribune · 12 May 1908 · page 1
SORENSON CHILDREN MAY HAVE BEEN ADOPTED
terns, value, $13.50, in nn sale price IU.UU h 8-3x10-6 Brussels rugs, assorted patterns, value $15.00, 12.50 ealo price i... has information proving Mrs. Gunness was alive and suggesting that com munication be opened with him. Mis. Charles, writing from West Side Chicago, wrote that she pos sesses information which would war rant the arrest of other persons impli cated in the operating of the murder farm. Coroner Mack's verdicts which will be filed tomorrow morning will state that Jennie Olson, Ole Burdsburg and the unknown male and female, round In the same grave, camo to their death from felonious homicide, the perpe trators of which Coroner Mack de clares are unknown. Veteran Engineer Officer Retires. Washington, May 24 Brigadier Follow the Crowds
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Coroner's physician Dr. Meyer reports that both Andrew Helgelein and Jennie Olsen died unnatural deaths, with hair found clutched in Helgelein's severed fingers. Investigators also debunk two circulating rumors: that a gold ring was found on the charred body's hand, and that the Gunness children had complained of abuse before the fire.
The Morning Tribune · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MET UNNATURAL DEATHS
Indianapolis, In.'., May 2. Through a letter sent to Governor Hanly by Emma C, Kolh, of Smith Coventry, C'linn,, tlio Hliorllt of Imports county )ui3 ubtnlnoil a poKblfl cluo to the. sup pn.fil whereabouts of Mrs. Gunness, If ilio I.aporte womnn la still alive. The lot tor widen was received at the gov ernor's oflVe, was forwarded at once to tho Laporte county nhorlft. The Coven try womnn wrote at length, describing a mysterious womnn In black who has been swindling tho people over the eastern part of Connecticut nnd which tiho believes Is none, other thnn Mrs. GiiiiiiccK. The writer says she has seen a pleture of Mrs. dimness and that tho resemblance, between the mysteri ous swindler and Mrs. Gunness Is so
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
The decomposed corpse of Andrew Helgelien showed signs of a death struggle, with hair clenched in one mutilated hand and the other hand severed, though decay prevented determining exact cause of death. Separately, William Broglski, a Polish farmhand, was identified as the man who dug the graves Belle Gunness used for her victims, solving the mystery of how she managed the physical labor alone.
The Morning Tribune · 12 May 1908 · page 1
GRAVE DIGGER FOUND.
Indianapolis, In.'., May 2. Through a letter sent to Governor Hanly by Emma C, Kolh, of Smith Coventry, C'linn,, tlio Hliorllt of Imports county )ui3 ubtnlnoil a poKblfl cluo to the. sup pn.fil whereabouts of Mrs. Gunness, If ilio I.aporte womnn la still alive. The lot tor widen was received at the gov ernor's oflVe, was forwarded at once to tho Laporte county nhorlft. The Coven try womnn wrote at length, describing a mysterious womnn In black who has been swindling tho people over the eastern part of Connecticut nnd which tiho believes Is none, other thnn Mrs. GiiiiiiccK. The writer says she has seen a pleture of Mrs. dimness and that tho resemblance, between the mysteri ous swindler and Mrs. Gunness Is so
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
Ray Lamphere's father insists his son is innocent and incapable of the murders, citing past dealings with Mrs. Gunness. A Laporte resident recounts a strange incident at the funeral of her second husband, who died after a sausage machine fell on his head, when Mrs. Gunness was mysteriously absent.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Madison Daily Leader · 12 May 1908 · page 1
WILL BEf|) NIS SON Father of Ray Lamphere Arrives Laporte, InL SUSPECTS GUNNESS WOMAN Strong in His Protestations That His Offspring Is Incapable of the Brutal J*mmU Murders With Which He Charged. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—W. W. Lan phero, father of Ray Lamphere and a Justice of the poace at Springfield, Ind., has arrived to assist in the fense of his son. Sheriff Smutzer r fused him permission to interview tht: latter. H. W. Worden, attorney for Hay l^amphere, declares he will brin^ about an interview with father and •on if he is compelled to bring Ray to court.
See moreSee less
The father is strong in protesta tions of the innocence of his son and asserts that he believes Ray Lam phere incapable of the murders with which he stands charged. Mr. Lamphere, senior, says that at one time Mrs. Gunness bought fifty fence posts of him and that while she Wfcs at the place he was Btrongly prejudiced against her. He ques tioned his son Ray about the latter's possible marriage with Mrs. Gunness and, advising against it, Ray told him that he never would marry the tfo man. Charles Way, a resident of Laporte, gave out an interesting interview in connection with the funeral of Philip Gunness, the second husband of Mrs. Gunnefcs, who was said to have been killed by being struck on the head by a falling sausage machine Mr. Way says that he was a pallbearer at the funeral of Gunness. At the conclu sion of the funeral ceremony, when the cortege was about to start for the cemetery, Mrs. Gunness could not be found and it developed that she had not been present at the ceremonies. Considerable uneasiness was felt by those present at the funeral sermon for fear that the shock incident to the sudden death of her husband had un balanced the woman's mind and that she had made away with herself. The matter was about to be placed in the hands of the authorities when Mrs. Gunness drove up the mcClung road. Everybody present was astounded when, as she drove up to the front of the house, she calmly remarked: "Go ahead and bury him. I guess It's all right." It developed later that she had come to the city during the funeral cere mony to consult with her lawyer about her possible arrest for the mur der of her husband. This action was considered at the time as sensational, as at that time no one had the slight est suspicion that Gunness had come to his death by any means other than purely accidental and Mrs. Gunness was not under any suspicion what ever.
A Swedish farmer named Anderson, who had courted Mrs. Gunness after answering her matrimonial ad, travels to Chicago to give authorities his testimony and letters from her. He recounts how his lack of money may have saved his life, describing a frightening night when he awoke to find her bending over him.
The Madison Daily Leader · 12 May 1908 · page 1
HIS POVERTY SAVED HIM
sions. It makes the food mom ta^ty, nutritious and wholesome. Laporte, InL pm i l! ...a: i A ii -1 Tsrkio, Mo., as he boarded the Rock Island train for Chicago, where he will offer his personal testimony and letters written him by Mrs. Gunness to the authorities. 'I think the woman is still alive and thai she set fire to the farmhouse herself. I believe that the eldest girl knew of her mother's crimes. I now recollect that she acted very strange ly. She would eye me with a pitiful look and when I glanced at her during a meal she was as white as a sheet.'
See moreSee less
Anderson is a Swede thirty-nine years old. Two years ago while at Monteith, Mich., he answered one of J*mmU Mrs. Gunness' advertisements, posing himself as a wealthy farmer. She wrote him to come on and he did so. The second day she asked him point blank how much money he had. He claimed only a few hundred dollars oash, but had a 320-acre farm. She told him to sell the farm and bring the money to her and they would be married. He went away for a few days and returned one night without Notifying Mrs. Gunness. He found a tnan he now believes to be Ray Lam phere In her company. He confessed to her that he had no money. She was Incensed, but told him to spend the night at her place. He went to bed, but was awakened and found the woman bending over him. He spoke and she ran out of the room. Greatly frightened he did not close his eyes after that and at daylight left the place.
An autopsy report reveals rings with cryptic inscriptions found on the corpse believed to be Belle Gunness, along with the previously undisclosed existence of her right hand. Searchers sifting the ashes also uncover a gold-crowned tooth, numerous bent scissors, and knives including a dirk possibly used as a murder weapon.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MINER PANS THE DEBRIS
Mrs. Gunness in Ogden, Utah, May 4. Sheriff Smulzer to-day received a letter from J. B. Chapman, of Donalson, Ind., in which he said that he was engaged by Mrs. Gunness to build a woven wire fence
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Sheriff Smutzer's hired worker Louis Schultz sluices the cellar ashes at the burned Gunness home, finding a gold-crowned tooth along with bent scissors and knives resembling surgical instruments and a dirk, believed to be a murder weapon. A neighbor also recalls seeing Mrs. Gunness wearing a belt with knife sheaths under her dress.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MINER PANS THE DEBRIS
The State is slowly but surely weaving a network of evidence which will prove that Mrs. Gunness had several accom | plices in the murders she committed.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A miscellaneous column of local commentary and jokes includes a single offhand line comparing Mrs. Gunness to Bluebeard, the legendary wife-killer. No details of her case are given, just a passing editorial remark.
Paper unidentified · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Laporte, Ind., May 26.—The man who signed his letter “H,” giving the attor neys for Ray Lamphere the information that the arch murderess was allvg, reach ed Chicago to-day, and in a letter to Mayor Darrow informed him that he would come to Laporte when needed to give evidence bearing out the sensational theory of thé defense that Mrs. Gunness is alive. This witness will testify that he saw Mrs. Gunness in Ogden, Utah, May 4. Sheriff Smulzer to-day received a letter from J. B. Chapman, of Donalson, Ind., in which he said that he was engaged by Mrs. Gunness to build a woven wire fence
Clipping to come
Deseret Evening News · Great Salt Lake City, Utah
Sheriff Smutzer began sluicing the ashes in earnest to search for more victims, uncovering nearly two dozen bent scissors, surgical-style knives, and a dirk believed to be a possible murder weapon. Investigators debated whether the dirk could have been used to kill victims by slipping it between the ribs, though the absence of a penetrating wound on Andrew Helgelien's body complicated this theory.
Deseret Evening News · 12 May 1908 · page 1
iG IN RUNS OF GUNNESS HOME ieriff Smutzer Begins Opera tions in Search of More Bodies in Earnest HOW THEY MET THEIR DEATHS Scissors of Surgical Shape
News from Christiania reports that Olaf Jensen, a young man who left Norway two years ago after being attracted by Mrs. Gunness's marriage advertisements, is believed to be one of the victims found at the La Porte farm. Friends' inquiries about him had been fruitless since his departure.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
LEFT NORWAY TO MEET THE WOMAN
Mrs. George Reiland and Mrs. A. C. Huber of Gary were in LaPorte Monay and incidently paid a visit to the Gunness farm. Mr. I. L. Dent of Chicago, general attorney for the East Chicago Land company, was in town, yesterday on company business. Mr. Charles Miller of Chicago, was n town yesterday visiting his uncle,
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Investigators continue sifting through ashes and debris at the Gunness farmhouse cellar, delayed by rain, searching for more victims among at least fourteen deaths already linked to the site. Meanwhile, George Anderson of Tarkio, Missouri describes answering Mrs. Gunness's matrimonial advertisement and narrowly escaping death, believing only his lack of money saved him, and speculates she may still be alive and responsible for setting the fire herself.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
ESCAPED WITH HIS LIFE - Experience of a Man Who Answered Advertisement of Mrs. Gunness
VALPARAISO. Geo. Fassold of Indianapolis was Valparaiso visitor today. ftrnrtor W. B. Hutchinson, Jr. of TiTirhle-an City is in the city today look ing after his cement curb and gutter work here. James Burk of Laporte was in the city
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Andrew Anderson, a Swedish farmer, recounts answering Mrs. Gunness's matrimonial advertisement two years earlier and traveling to meet her, claiming wealth. After admitting he had little cash, she told him to stay the night, but he awoke to find her standing over him and fled at daylight, now believing a man he saw there was Ray Lamphere; a separate item begins about Emil Greening believing Mrs. Gunness is still alive.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Lamphere's Watch Mystery Solved. The bodies of the seven unidentified dead were buried la the potter's field. Christian services were conducted for them, and a small stone will be erect ed with an Inscription, telling the cir cumstances of their death. The body of Jennie Olscn has been turned over to relatives. Ole Cudsberg's body was shipped to Iola, Wis., for burial. Coroner Mack is still holding the four bodlt-H found in the fire ruins of the burned Gunness home and which, according to evidenced produced, are the bodies of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and her three children. They will be held until Coroner Mack files his formal verdict. Autopsies of the seven unidentified bodies has revealed th fact, ac cording to the reports of Dr. F. T. Wilcox and George It. Osborne, who conducted the autopsies" undT the di rection of Coroner Mack, that one of the seven was a female.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A carpenter who once worked at the Gunness farm describes finding weapons, watches, and pocketbooks scattered about the house, suggesting hidden murders. Separately, Pittsburgh police search for Belle Gunness after a railroad conductor claims to have transported her.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
In the event that Mrs. Gunness should be alive it would be interest ing to know, if she were brought to trial, just what would be the nature of
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A Pittsburgh conductor claims he transported a woman he believed was Belle Gunness, but police hesitated to arrest her after a recent false identification elsewhere. Separately, a Kansas farmer reveals he received letters from a woman claiming to be Mrs. Gunness inviting him to visit, having responded to one of her matrimonial ads.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
ANOTHER SUSPECT
In the event that Mrs. Gunness should be alive it would be interest ing to know, if she were brought to trial, just what would be the nature of
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A Kansas farmer, Lon Townsend, reveals he received letters from Mrs. Gunness inviting him to visit after answering her matrimonial ad, and planned to travel to Indiana. Separately, relatives claim her children were adopted rather than biological, and a Wisconsin farmer who went to meet a matrimonial ad woman in 1907 and never returned is suspected to be another victim.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 3
ANOTHER SUSPECT
Charged With Arson, Five Mun ders and Being Accessory in Helgelein Murder. SKULL IS DUG UP ON FARM Believed to Belong to One of Bodies of
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A newspaper commentary column briefly mentions that hired men who worked on the Gunness farm and escaped with their lives deserve to form a society and hold reunions, noting they faced more danger there than on a battlefield. This is a passing joke reference within a larger miscellany column covering unrelated topics like ministers' salaries and political nominations.
The Salt Lake Herald · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Their Dead. Laporte, Ind., May 27. —Several bogs wallowing in a pond at the edge of a lot on the Gunness farm this morn , Ing. brought up the bone of a human arm. The finding of the bone has convinced Sheriff Smutzer that other bodies are buried beenath the mud at the bottom of the pond. The entire Shore will be gone over with rakes, in an effort to bring any bodies the water may secrete to the surface.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
A second examination of the body from the Gunness farm fire found three rings, including one inscribed with initials believed to belong to Belle Gunness's second husband, seemingly confirming she died in the blaze. Meanwhile, Norwegian police report a week-long search has found no trace of any record or person matching Belle Gunness's claimed background.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Alexandria Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 2
WORLD BRIEFLY TOLD. In returning seven true bills against Ray Lamphere, the Laporte oounty (Ind.) grasd jury also in dicted Mrs. Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein of Mansfield. No warrant was issued for Mrs. Gunness, as she was de clared officially dead by the verdict of Coroner Mack, but in order to rote a true bill against Lamphere. ns an accessory in the killing of llelge lwin, it was necessary to indict Mrs. frunness as the principal. Lamphere now stands officially charged with arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the Helgelein murder.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
Prosecutors investigating Belle Gunness allege she poisoned victims with chloral before dismembering and burying them, with druggists confirming her purchases of the drug. Accused Ray Lamphere claims he overheard Gunness and victim Andrew Helgelein plotting to use chloral to kill Lamphere himself.
Alexandria Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 2
DRUG IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
Ray Lamphere testified that he overheard Belle Gunness and Andrew Helgelein discussing a plan to kill him with chloral, and that Helgelein suggested testing the drug on a dog first. Lamphere also admitted returning from Michigan City the night Helgelein was killed, contradicting his earlier alibi, and said he watched the pair walk toward the barn before fleeing in fear.
Alexandria Gazette · 12 May 1908 · page 2
DRUG IN GUNNESS CASE
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
A coroner's physician found three rings on the burned corpse's hand believed to be Mrs. Gunness's, though investigators noted the rings could have been planted to fake her death. The report also quotes excerpts from her letters to lonely-hearts suitors showing a pattern of romantic manipulation and requests for money.
The Spokane Press · 12 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS' RINGS FOUND ON BURNED CORPSE'S FINGER
' : ‘ It’s the Louisville Courier-Journal ‘which perpetrates this: "Gentlemen who attended week-end parties at Mrs. \ Ghirtness’ home agree that the lady Was 'perfectly killing1 at times.” A shocking tragedy was narrowly ‘(averted when the Chicago Socialist ‘convention adopted a Prohibitionist plank by mistake but fortunately dis covered It just before adjournment. They say now the Hughes boom is reviving. Some sort of story has to , he started to keep up interest in the - Republican presidential contest, so this Is as good and as improbable as , any. Judging from the inclination of the morbid public, Laporte, Ind., would make a hit by turning the Gunness
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The report reveals extracts from Belle Gunness' love letters to lonely farmers, showing how she lured victims through matrimonial ads and promises of wealth and romance. It also describes stolen poison bottles, a coroner's theory on chloroform versus shooting, numbered watches found in the ruins, and a $5,000 reward offered by La Porte's city council for her capture, suggesting authorities believed she had escaped alive.
The Spokane Press · 12 May 1908 · page 1
ON BURNED CORPSE'S FINGER
' : ‘ It’s the Louisville Courier-Journal ‘which perpetrates this: "Gentlemen who attended week-end parties at Mrs. \ Ghirtness’ home agree that the lady Was 'perfectly killing1 at times.” A shocking tragedy was narrowly ‘(averted when the Chicago Socialist ‘convention adopted a Prohibitionist plank by mistake but fortunately dis covered It just before adjournment. They say now the Hughes boom is reviving. Some sort of story has to , he started to keep up interest in the - Republican presidential contest, so this Is as good and as improbable as , any. Judging from the inclination of the morbid public, Laporte, Ind., would make a hit by turning the Gunness
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The report describes Mrs. Gunness' eyes as piercing and hypnotic, noting she could switch from blazing anger to a kindly glow. It includes a diagram of the 'Murder Farm' showing the burned farmhouse, graveyard, morgue, and barn, with crosses marking found corpses and suspected burial sites, plus photos of her two husbands believed murdered.
The Spokane Press · 12 May 1908 · page 1
Remarkable Eyes of Mrs. Gunness, the Woman Bluebeard
THE DULY-DALLYING OF OOT THING WHICH STANDS OUT an-outslder In the Gunness horror, and all, is the procrastination or neglect of digging operations in the ogress' private
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
A shepherd dog, described as the pet of Mrs. Gunness and her children, is reported as the only survivor of the household after escaping the burning house. The dog now follows police as they conduct their grim investigation of the farm.
The Spokane Press · 12 May 1908 · page 2
THE DULY-DALLYING OF OOT THING WHICH STANDS OUT an-outslder In the Gunness horror, and all, is the procrastination or neglect of digging operations in the ogress' private
Clipping to come
Wausau Pilot · Wausau, Wis.
A dispatch reports that Belle Gunness is believed to be a notorious murderess, with nine bodies—including her own and family members—unearthed near Laporte, Indiana. The brief is one of several short news items compiled from across the country.
Wausau Pilot · 12 May 1908 · page 2
Kurin AVhs n slaughter Pen. Mrs. Belle Gunness is believed to have been the queen of murderers. Nine 1 todies, including those of herself and members of her family, have been unearthed near
Five mutilated bodies are dug up in the yard of Belle Gunness's Laporte home, bringing the known or suspected victim count to eleven, with suspicion falling on Gunness as the chief culprit. Though she and her children were thought to have died in a house fire a week earlier, authorities now suspect those bodies were substitutes brought in to fake her death.
Wausau Pilot · 12 May 1908 · page 2
WOMAN IS BLAMED AS CHIEF.
Wholesale murder—murder more ruthlessly premeditated ami diabolical ly executed than the famous Holmes castle crimes in was revealed at Laporte, ind.. Tuesday when five mutilated bodies were dug up in the back yard of the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness. who, together with her three children, are supposed to have met death when their house burned one week before. Eleven persons already have a place on the list ofi known or probably slain, and circumstances point to Mrs. Gun ness as the arch-conspirator in at least seven of the crimes. Until this time it had been accepted as true that she and her three children had met death in the fire that destroyed their home, but now the suspicion arises that the bodies that were found in the smoldering ruins were brought from s\me hospital or medical school for the purpose of cre ating the belief that Mrs.
The report catalogs eleven known victims connected to the Gunness farm tragedy, including Andrew Helgelein, Jennie Olson, two unidentified children, and Belle Gunness herself, believed burned in the fire. It also describes suspicions against Ray Lanphere and a theory that the farm served as a 'clearing-house' for murders via trunk shipments.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Wausau Pilot · 12 May 1908 · page 2
WOMAN IS BLAMED AS CHIEF. Death of Herself and Children in Incendiary Fire Only Adds to the Puzzle. Wholesale murder—murder more ruthlessly premeditated ami diabolical ly executed than the famous Holmes castle crimes in was revealed at Laporte, ind.. Tuesday when five mutilated bodies were dug up in the back yard of the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness. who, together with her three children, are supposed to have met death when their house burned one week before. Eleven persons already have a place on the list ofi known or probably slain, and circumstances point to Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness as the arch-conspirator in at least seven of the crimes. Until this time it had been accepted as true that she and her three children had met death in the fire that destroyed their home, but now the suspicion arises that the bodies that were found in the smoldering ruins were brought from s\me hospital or medical school for the purpose of cre ating the belief that Mrs. Gunness and her family had passed from existence. I.l*l of Known Victims. The eleven victims so far known to figure in tin* tragedy were: Helgelein. Andrew, 40 years old. bach elor, Aberdeen, S. D.: suitor for Mrs. Gunness' hand, who came to Laporte in January and disappeared one month later after loaning the woman $1,500; body dug up to-day. Gunness, Jennie Olson, 1G years old. adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness; disap peared in September, 1906. ostensibly to attend school at Los Angeles; body dug up to-day. Unidentified man, believed by Sheriff Sntulzer to have been an admirer of the woman. Unidentified boy, apparently 8 3-ears old: mutilated body in^gunnysack. Unidentified girl, about 7 years old; mutilated body in gunnysaek. Gunness. Joseph, husband of Mrs. Gun ness, whose death at Laporte four years ago had always remained a mystery. Sorenson. Mads, woman's first hus band. who died under mysterious circum stances in Chicago eight years ago. Gunness. Mrs. Bella, believed to have been burned to death in lire which de stroyed her home. Sorenson. Myrtle, ll years old, eldest daughter of Mrs. Gucness; thought to have perished iu the fire. Sorenson, Lucy. 9 years old. another daughter; also believed to have been a victim of the fire. Gunness, l’hilip, 5 3-ears obi, youngest child; said to have been killed in the fire. in the arrest of Ray Lanphere, a former servant of the woman. Sheriff Smulzer believes, some light may be thrown upon the circumstances sur rounding the deaths of at least some of the eleven victims. Lampliere before the tire bad trouble with Mrs. Gunness. lie bad declared about town she was trying to “get rid” of him because lie know too much. He also is said to have been seen wearing an overcoat belonging to Helgelein. and to Sheriff Smulzer and Coroner Mack he has told several conflicting stories concerning his relations with the wom an and his presence in the neighbor hood of the Gunness home the night it burned. The discovery of the bodies led ex pressmen to tell of the delivery of five trunks to the Gunness farm during the last six months. This fact has caused the authorities to incline to the theory that the place may have been a “clear ing-house” for murders. They suspect that wealthy persons, after being lured to Chicago and killed, may have been packed into those trunks, sent to La porte and disposed of there. Lamphere in his cell declared Mrs. Gunness fre quently asked lnm to buy poison for her. She wanted chloroform, ue said. Four of the bodies were found buried in a refuse pile about 150 feet from the house, while Helgelein's body was dug up within a few feet of the ruined home. It is t he opinion of Coroner Mack and physicians who examined the bodies that they were burned after death. Helgelein was easily Identified by his brother, although the remains had been badly mutilated. The body df the other man shows a red mustache. The discovery of the bodies primarily was due to the efforts of Ask K. Helge lein. of Mansfield, s. !>., brother of Andrew Helgelein. The former had known of his brother's correspondence wish Mrs. Gunness and of the latter's trip to Laporte. Whim Ask Helgelein arrived in T.andrte he demanded a thor ough search of the Gunness' premises. Two weeks 'go he had l>een informed in a letter written by Mrs. Gunness that bis brother had gone to Norway. Mrs. Arthur Olander. 2818 South Fark avenue. Chicago, sister of Jennie Olson Gunness. also sjient two days iu Laporte following the fire searclfing the ruins in quest of the girl. The theory now is advanced that Jennie knew too much concerning the death of Mrs. Gun ness' second husband, who succumbed to wounds received from a meat chop per four years ago.
The report describes Mrs. Belle Gunness luring men with money to her Indiana farm, murdering them, and burying them in her garden before her house burned down with her children and a headless body inside. It raises suspicion that the headless corpse was not hers, suggesting she staged her own death to escape capture.
Wausau Pilot · 12 May 1908 · page 4
Fifteen persons murdered, and by a woman ! This is the horrifying story told in all its details and comes from La Parte, Ind. Mrs. Belle Gunness, a widow, it seems, had been enticing men to her farm home, to enter into a mar riage compact. Her usual procedure was to find a man with a few thousand dollars and have him bring it all with him to her place. Usually it was the last ever seen of the man. The woman perhaps, drugged and then killed each victim and buried him in her garden patch, at last suspicions were aroused and wheD preparations were on foot to arrest the woman she killed her three little children, set hor house on fire and perished in the fire herself Avery strange thing about the affair is that the body supposed to be Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was headless and the fire was not fierce enough to destroy the bones of a body. As the woman could not cut off her own head and store it away where it could not be found, it is thought that the body is not ber’s, but that she perp3trated this scheme hoping to fool the people and escape.
A gold tooth crown was discovered in the debris of the burned Gunness farmhouse, believed to belong to Belle Gunness's remains. The find is cited as evidence disproving theories that she escaped the fire alive, alongside bent scissors thought used as murder tools.
The Daily Telegram · 12 May 1908 · page 1
GOLD CROWN IS PICKED UP
Perished. LAPORTE, Ind.. May 12?The gold crown of a tooth was found In the ddbrla at the Gunnels home to day. It Is believed to bo from the head' of Mrs. Bella Gunness, which would disprove the theory that she lutili alive. Almost two dozen pairs of scissors, bent and curved In the fashion of surgical Instruments, are said also to have boon fonnd In a cellar. It Is believed thete wca|>ons were esnployed In the series of mur ders on the farm.
Investigators in LaPorte reported finding a gold-crowned tooth in the ashes of the Gunness home, believed to be from Belle Gunness's own head, along with nearly two dozen bent scissors and knives thought to be murder instruments. The prosecutor indicated he was ready to proceed with grand jury charges against Ray Lamphere.
The Laramie Republican · 12 May 1908 · page 1
TOOTH MAY TELL TALE
That one of the seven unidentified bodies dug up in Mrs. Gunness' barn yard near Laporte. Ind., is that of a woman was reveal by the autopsy, and it is thought to be the body of a woman who disappeared from the farm at the same time as Jennie Olsen. That Mrs. Gunness was dead was made certain by the finding of her false teeth in the ruins of her home near Laporte Ind. The Laporte county (Ind.) grand jury returned seven true bills against Ray Lamphere. Mrs. Belle Gunness also was indicted, in order that a true bill might be found against Lamphere as accessory in the murder
Clipping to come
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · and 1 other paper
Sheriff and coroner in Laporte, Indiana, have unearthed five bodies on the farm of Belle Gunness, who died in a house fire with her three children. Victims identified so far include wealthy suitor Andrew Helgelein and her stepdaughter Jennie Olson, with more graves being dug by searchers following a hired hand's account of mysterious burial pits.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Vernon County Censor · 13 May 1908 · page 7
MODERN BORGIA IN INDIANA WITH HER FARM AS A PRIVATE GRAVEYARD
J. W. BURLEIGH. Kd. and Pub. \n exchange accounts for the suc cess of Mrs. Gunness, the Indiana murderess, bv the simple fact that she had such' “killing ways.”
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · 7 May 1908
Potosi Journal · Potosi, Mo. · and 5 other papers
Diggers at the Laporte farm uncover the skeletons of a man and woman plus a third unidentified body, bringing the known murder count to 16, or 18 including her two husbands. Investigators now believe the body found in the burned house was not Belle Gunness herself, suggesting she fled, possibly to Norway, with a fortune from fraud and murder.
Potosi Journal · 13 May 1908 · page 2
THREE MORE BODIES FOUND.
NEW GUNNESS CLEW. Former Farmhand Says Woman Spoke of Buried "Favorite Horse.” Laporte. I ml., May 27.—As u result of a statement made to the authorities by Harold Chapman, a former em ployee of Mrs. Belle Gunness, men un der the direction of Sheriff Smutzer began searching for bodies in a hither to unsuspected place. Chapman says that he was Instructed one day by Mrs. Gunness to build a wire fence around a certain part of the back yard. Mrs. Gunness superintend ed the work and watched every move very carefully.
See moreSee less
At a certain point she wanted Chap man to make a crook in the fence. There was considerable argument over the matter. Chapman said, but finally he yielded and made the bend around the place where Mrs. Gunness said she had a “favorite horse" buried. In returning seven true bills against Kay Lamphere the Laporte county grand jury' also indicted Mrs. Belle Gunness for the murder of Andrew Helgelein of Mansfield. 8. D. No war rant was issued for Mrs. Gunness, as she was declared officially dead by the verdict of Coroner Mack, blit in order to vote a true bill against Lamphere as an accessory in the killing of Helge lein it was necessary to indict Mrs. Gunness as the principal.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 5 papers
Woodruff County News · McCrory, Ark. · 14 May 1908
Mexico Missouri Message · Mexico, Mo. · 14 May 1908
The Tupelo Journal · Tupelo, Miss. · 15 May 1908
The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo. · 15 May 1908
Scott County Kicker · Benton, Mo. · 16 May 1908
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Investigators in La Porte report evidence suggesting three more victims of Belle Gunness, though contradictory developments slowed progress. The physicians' post-mortem reports were given to the coroner's jury but not made public, while prosecutors continued building a case linking Ray Lamphere to the deaths.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 1
EVIDENCE IS KEPT SECRET
I.nniphei'u (.'barged With Mimlei. Laporte, Ind., May -6. Th Giau-1 Jury which hs been probing t:e mysteries of the Gunnest murder farm returned oven Indictments against Ray Lamphere, the Gunness farmhand, lie Is alleged to have set tho iiouso aflr the day Mrs. Belle Gu mi ess and her children were burned to death. Lamphere is charge In the indictments with the murder of Mrs, Cunncss and her three children, participation In tho murder of Andrew Helgeleln, the last victim of ine widow, and arson in setting the aouse on fire. Ar raignment probably will take place J .uo 2.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Doctors' reports to the coroner's jury revealed discrepancies in the adult body believed to be Mrs. Gunness, including an incomplete right arm contrary to earlier claims and three rings found on the hands. New suspected victims—John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Brady—are named, though evidence linking them to Gunness is called indefinite.
I.nniphei'u (.'barged With Mimlei. Laporte, Ind., May -6. Th Giau-1 Jury which hs been probing t:e mysteries of the Gunnest murder farm returned oven Indictments against Ray Lamphere, the Gunness farmhand, lie Is alleged to have set tho iiouso aflr the day Mrs. Belle Gu mi ess and her children were burned to death. Lamphere is charge In the indictments with the murder of Mrs, Cunncss and her three children, participation In tho murder of Andrew Helgeleln, the last victim of ine widow, and arson in setting the aouse on fire. Ar raignment probably will take place J .uo 2.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A newspaper's list of witty political and social one-liners includes a joke that 'the headless Mrs. Gunness may appear at any time in any part of the country,' referencing ongoing doubt about whether a headless corpse found in the fire ruins was actually Belle Gunness. The remark reflects public skepticism and the unresolved mystery of her death.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 4
THE LA PORTE MURDER FARM. Grpwnonip It <■ vein I i<> n n Thpro Hoad MUt l a Story of the Ml(l-(>ntnrli‘s. Like a chapter from the bloody rec ords of the mld-centurlos is the ter rible story unfolded by the authorities of La Porte, I ml., where wholesale mur der was done for years without anyone knowing or suspecting it. Criminal rec ords contain no parallel of the grew some story revealed in the finding of the clearing house for murders kept by Mrs. Belle Gunness near the Indiana
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Four physicians submitted autopsy reports to the La Porte coroner's jury on the bodies found in the Gunness house ruins, but the reports fail to establish the manner of death, making an open verdict likely. Meanwhile prosecutor Smith, aided by the sheriff and Pinkerton detectives, continues gathering evidence to connect Ray Lamphere to the deaths, and evidence has emerged identifying three additional victims of Mrs. Gunness.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 13 May 1908 · page 1
GIVES REPORT OF AUTOPSY
If some of us old-timers in this val ley do not step lively we are likely to be run over and killed. Things are moving faster than most of our eyes can follow. Well, since they have found Old Lady Gunness’ teeth among the ruins of her Indiana abattoir pernaps that nine-days wonder may be listed with the Bender affair and the matter dropped. And the Laramie plains are to have a great Carey act project, too. That is what push and knowing how brings about. This first one will doubtless be followed by others till this valley blossoms as the rose.
See moreSee less
Anent The Republican editorial re lating to well-behaved boys and girls of Laramie, a reader says that we have some who are almost the limit. Well, it is necessary to have some bad boys with which to compare the good ones. Why seek to discourage the nomina tion of Mr. Bryan? He is used to defeat, and it will hurt him less than it would any other man who is likely to be named at Denver. Let all hu mane persons pull for Mr. Bryan.— Chicago Tribune.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Investigators revise earlier findings, now stating the right arm is nearly complete while the left forearm survives only partially, reversing prior assumptions. Rings with inscriptions suggest ties to Peter Gunness's first wife, new victims are named, and a minister reveals Ray Lamphere made a confidential statement implying Belle Gunness may still be alive.
If some of us old-timers in this val ley do not step lively we are likely to be run over and killed. Things are moving faster than most of our eyes can follow. Well, since they have found Old Lady Gunness’ teeth among the ruins of her Indiana abattoir pernaps that nine-days wonder may be listed with the Bender affair and the matter dropped. And the Laramie plains are to have a great Carey act project, too. That is what push and knowing how brings about. This first one will doubtless be followed by others till this valley blossoms as the rose.
See moreSee less
Anent The Republican editorial re lating to well-behaved boys and girls of Laramie, a reader says that we have some who are almost the limit. Well, it is necessary to have some bad boys with which to compare the good ones. Why seek to discourage the nomina tion of Mr. Bryan? He is used to defeat, and it will hurt him less than it would any other man who is likely to be named at Denver. Let all hu mane persons pull for Mr. Bryan.— Chicago Tribune.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Rev. Schell, a Methodist minister, declines to disclose what Ray Lamphere told him in confidence, saying he had urged prosecutors to give Lamphere fair treatment and a lawyer. He states Lamphere's statement did not include a confession to arson, and adds that he personally doubts Belle Gunness is dead.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Montgomery Advertiser · 13 May 1908 · page 1
WORLD BRIEFLY TOLD. In returning 6even true bills against Ray Lamphere, the Laportc county (Ind.) grasd jury also in dicted Mrs. Belle Gunncss for the murder of Andrew Helgelein of Mansfield. No warrant was issued for Mrs. Gunness, as she was de clared ofHcially dead by the verdict of Coroner Mack, but in order to vote a true bill against Lamphere. as an accessory in the killing of Helge lein, it was necessary to indict Mrs. Gunness as the principal. Lamphere now stands officially charged with arson, five murders, and being an accessory in the Helgelein murder.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
Investigators in La Porte identified three additional victims of Belle Gunness amid conflicting findings, while post mortem reports failed to determine how the woman and three children died. Searchers sifting the ruins found a gold tooth crown, scissors, and knives, suggesting surgical or violent methods used on victims.
Arizona Republican · 13 May 1908 · page 1
THE MYSTERY MORE MUDDY
Prime Minister Asquith took w long step Wednesday in the direction of encouraging the claims of women for enfranchisement when he replied to an important delegation of radical members of the house of commons, who were reputed to obtain his views on this matter. He declared that the government intended before the close of the present parliament to pass a comprehensive measure of electoral reform. He said he was not himself an advocate of woman suffrage, but he had an open mind on the subject, and if an amendment was introduced to the projected reform bill favor ing women suffrage on Democratic lines, the government would not op pose it.
See moreSee less
** "It is my verdict that the body so viewed is that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, and she came to her death through felonious homicide and that the per petrator thereof is to me unknown. (Signed) C. S. Mack, Coroner." Such was the verdict rendered late Wednesday afternoon by Coroner Mack. The official declaration that the body of the adult female found in the ruins of the fire of April 28, which destroyed the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was that of Mrs. Gunness, is the sequel to the report of .Dr. I. P. Norton, Mrs. Gunness' dentist, that the bridges holding various false and gold-filled teeth, were those of Mrs. Gunness. The body of an actress known as Mrs. J. M. Ramsey was found Thursday in a small lake near Gaha gan, La. She had been several months at Gahagan, to which place she and her husband came with a small show. The appearance of the body indicated that she had been struck over the head and shoulders with a blunt instrument. She was last seen Saturday. Her husband left Gahagan Sunday and is now sup posed to be in Alexandria, La. Let ters found on her person seem to have been written by relatives in Broken Arrow, Okla. The signature of these have been blotted out. A compromise has been agreed on practically in the Hollowell night rider damage suits at Paducah, Ky. It is reliably reported that the de fendants will pay the plaintiffs $10, 000 and all costs. The plaintiffs asked for $15,000. John G. Miller, chief counsel for the plaintiffs went to Evansville, Ind., to confer with his clients, and it is reported he will recommend the above settlement. Not a railroad in Oklahoma was in operation Sunday night as a re sult of heavy rains and cloudbursts, which occurred the past three days. The last road to suspend operations was the Missouri, Kansas and Texas, which was forced to quit at noon Sunday, when the bridge on the main line at Eufaula, went down. Mrs. Emma Moore Barret of Aus tin, Tex., announced at the natios al Sunshine convention at Houston a donation by her of a ten-acre tract of hunt on the Palisades of the Colo rado river, near Austin, for a home for feeble-minded children. John II. Kirby has donated lumber for the building. Georgia's first carload of peaches was shipped from Montezuma Friday night and goes to New York markets. It is predicted that this season's out put will be between 5,000 and 6,000 cars, the largest in the history of Georgia, and it is estimated the crop will be worth $3,000,000. Unless the state department of the United States interferes, the expe dition sent by Yale University to recover the remains of prehistoric glans on Desolation islands, in the Antarctic ocean, will be confiscated on its arrival at that place by the French government. T. 0. Durham was shot through the heart and instantly killed while inDr. Casey's drug store at Cle burne, Texas. Mart Black, an em ployee of the Santa Fe railroad, and a brother of Ed Black of Fort Worth is under arrest charged with the shooting. At Fairmont, W. Va., Rev. S. A. Coffman, aged 50, a clergyman, killed his wife Tuesday by cutting her throat. It is believed he is in sane. A Chinese school, where the child ren of Chinese mav be educated in Chinese, is to be built in San Fran cisco at once. A site has been pur chased, plans drawn and teachers selected. Orders have been received from Berlin for the shipment of 2,000,000 tube roses from the Texas coast country to Germany. Another or der calls for a half million cape jas [ s amines.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
Post-mortem results on the woman and three children found in the Gunness ruins failed to determine cause of death, likely leading to an open verdict. Sluicing of the ruins turned up a gold tooth crown believed to be Mrs. Gunness's, along with bent scissors, knives, and a dirk, while neighbors and friends of missing men speculate on further victims.
Arizona Republican · 13 May 1908 · page 1
■Gunness deliberately lured men to her farm by means of an advertisement in a Chicago newspaper, In which she represented herself as an attractive and amiable widow looking for a mate. She alleged that she was the owner of a \ Tillable farm and sought a well-to-do farmer as a husband. After a visit from such a candidate she generally in duced him, it appears, to sell his farm and come to her with the proceeds of the sale, at which time she would de liberately murder him and bury his body cn the promises. For years this strange woman Is said to have conducted her murder mill,
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Investigators in La Porte report progress in identifying three additional victims of Belle Gunness, with new findings about the burned body's arms and clothing fragments. Three rings found on the hands present a puzzle, possibly linked to Peter Gunness's first wife.
Paper unidentified · 13 May 1908 · page 4
VICTIMS IDENTIFIED
2?je ate ye . uncertainty. A fire which destroyed the Gunness home also disclosed the fact that her three children had either been murdered before the fire or that they had perished in the flames. In some respects the methods of Mrs. Belle Gunness seem similar to those of the infamous Bender family in Kan sas. Yet it is doubtful if the blood thirsty Kate Bender in her palmiest days was ever equal to the awful crimes that are laid at the door of the Gunness woman. The story of the La Porte murder farm recalls the noto-
Clipping to come
The New Haven Union · New Haven, Conn.
Rev. E. A. Schell of Laporte, who heard Ray Lamphere's first confession, claims the Gunness children were chloroformed before the house was set afire over them. He further asserts that the woman's body found in the ruins was not actually Belle Gunness, though he believes Lamphere was innocent except regarding Jennie Olson's death.
The New Haven Union · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Minister Makes Startling Statement in Laporte Case Baltimore, May 13.—"The Gunness children were chloroformed, of course," ■aid the Rev. E. A. Schell of the La
Investigators report evidence identifying three additional victims of Belle Gunness: John Moe, Henry Gerholt, and George Brady. Post-mortem reports on the bodies found in the house ruins fail to establish cause of death, while prosecutors continue building a case linking Ray Lamphere to the deaths.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 May 1908 · page 10
THREE BODIES NAMED
Arkansan Says Mrs. Gunness Lives. Mayor Darrow and his law partner, ! H. X. Worden, of LaPorte, Ind., who represent Ray I,ampere, charged with the murder of .Mrs. Gunness and three children, are greatly excited over the receipt of a letter from a man in Ar kansas, whose name they decline to make known, and who gives informa tion which they consider of much Im portance. The writer is known to Mayor Darrow, having formerly lived in Marshall county, Indiana, and therefore credence is placed in his Gtafement. The man positively declares that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness escaped in man's cloth ing and that he, not later than May 3, five days after she was burned to deajh. according to the offic ial state ment of Coroner Mack, received a letter from her. He says he will pro duce this letter and turn over to of ficers other letters, and will also give additional information regarding her if he is personally interviewed by the officers, either in La Porte or at his homo in Arkansas.
Four physicians' post-mortem reports given to the coroner's jury fail to establish cause of death, likely leading to an open verdict. New details emerge about the adult corpse, including a more complete right arm than previously known and three rings found on the hands, while prosecutors continue building a case against Ray Lamphere.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 13 May 1908 · page 10
FACTS ABOUT FEMALE CORPSE
Indiana Man. Laporte, Ind., May 23.—In returning seven true bills against Ray Lam phere, the Laporte county grand jury also indicted Mrs. Bella Gunness for I the murder of Andrew Helgeleiu of Mansfield, S. D. No warrant was issued for Mrs. Gunness, as she was de dared officially dead by the verdict of Coroner Mack, but in order to vote a true bill against Lamphere as an ac cessory in the killing of Helgelein, it was necessary to indict Mrs. Gunness as the principal. Lamphere now stands before the bar of justice offi cially charged with arson, five mur ders, and being an accessory in the Helgelein murder.
See moreSee less
Separate bills were voted against I Lamphere for the murder, in the first degree, of Mrs. Bella Gunness and her three children, Philip Gunness, Maytie
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A newspaper photo spread identifies figures connected to the Belle Gunness case: murdered farmer Andrew Helgelein, Jennie Olsen (thought burned to death in the house fire), Belle Gunness with her children, her first husband Mads Sorenson, and second husband Peter Gunness who died suspiciously years earlier. The images accompany ongoing coverage of the farm murders investigation.
The San Francisco Call · 13 May 1908 · page 1
BY MRS. GUNNESS AFTER THE FIRE row & Wordan, "S. H." showed Case and Gaerte a letter purporting to have been written by Mrs. Gunness, in which she told of escaping, attired in OYSTER BAY
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A Sunday Call report reveals previously suppressed evidence from Dr. J. Lucius Gray's autopsy report on the body authorities claim is Belle Gunness. The report describes three rings found on the corpse with inscriptions no one can explain, deepening doubts about the body's identity.
The San Francisco Call · 13 May 1908 · page 1
Rings Deepen Mystery in La Porte Horror / None Can Explain Inscriptions Found With Supposed Body of Mrs. Gunness
0^ Laporte, Ind., May 29.—Attorneys Dsrrow & Worden, representing Ray Lumphere, stated today that A. J. Case and C. E. Gaerte, working on the Gunness case, have located in Chi cago the mysterious "S. H.," who claims to have seen and talked with Mrs. Gunness in Ogden, Utah, six days after the fire here which de stroyed her home. According to Dar
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Dr. Gray's report describes disconnected adult arms found with the body, including rings engraved with initials and dates, plus remnants of clothing and nightgowns. Additional digging uncovers nearly two dozen bent scissors and knives, including a dirk suspected as the murder weapon, while a neighbor recalls Mrs. Gunness wearing a hidden belt with knife sheaths.
The San Francisco Call · 13 May 1908 · page 7
also found. STRANGE PARAPHERNALIA ' " An interesting sidelight on the char acter of Mrs. Gunness has been fur nished by Mrs. C. O. Lapham of La Porte, who for six years was a neigh bor .of the woman. Mrs, Lapham. says that on the only occasion on which she called upon -her neighbor her hostess sat near an open window until a strong breeze through this opening blew aside the folds of a loose dress which' Mrs. Gunness was wearing and \u25a0 revealed about her body a wine belt containing pouchee of various sizes and sheaths which seemed to have been constructed for knives.
See moreSee less
The "mining" operations which have been proposed by Sheriff Smulzer for several days were starred in earnest by Louis Schultze today In the fulris of the Gunness home. Additional evidence regarding the methods by which the persons . whose corpses were found on the Gunness farm met their deathswas unearthed this morning. Almost two dozen pairs of scissors, bent and curved In the fash ion of surgical Instruments/are said to have been found In the ashes in the cellar, and in addition three knives, two of a surgical " character, and an other, .'an unmistakable dirk, were picked up.. .
Investigators believe a dirk found among weapons in the cellar ashes may have been the chief murder weapon, with chloroform and poison possibly used to subdue victims before knives and scissors were used to dismember bodies. Separately, Gus Gunness, brother of Belle's second husband Peter, recounts Peter's mysterious death from a head wound blamed on a falling sausage grinder, which prompted suspicion but no charges.
The San Francisco Call · 13 May 1908 · page 7
MAY HAVE USED DIRK
Porrte and had married Mrs. .Gunness. We thought nothing of it, except that he. married pretty soon after the death of "his wife. • -When "he went to La Porte . Peter tooJcbis daughter, Swanhilde. and baby, Phlliji, with him, Three months after the marriage in La Porte the baby died and the ailment was never diagnosed. "Five* years ago last December Mrs. Gunness wrote. me that Peter had been accidentally killed. A sausage grind ing . machine fell on his . head, she wrote. I ; went Immediately .toLa Porte and arrived there before.the,fu neral; -whichtook place from.
See moreSee less
the house. Therewaa a : small wound . on top of Peter's head, which - Mrft -Gunness : said was';- caused by the machine.: falling from a shelf bAck of the stove. ; Only he and Mrs. Gunness were In the house ? at the. time." "'^Her explanation* excited some suspl -cio'n and there was an -investigation,' but tibthlng ever came of it." '
A report from near Scandinavia, Wisconsin, identifies Henry Guerholt as a possible victim of Mrs. Gunness. Friends say he corresponded with her through a matrimonial bureau advertisement and he has not been seen since leaving home in July 1905 to marry a widow.
The San Francisco Call · 13 May 1908 · page 7
ANOTIIER POSSIBLE VICTIM . lOlli, -WJs:, May ,i--— -Henry Guerholt of /the town ofScandinavia, near here, is believed to"; have been a victim: of Mrs. Gunness. v It 1s known; that. he had been 'communicating with :a matrimo nial' bureauwhose; advertisement? he had read ; in? a '. paper, and some -of his friends, declare -hoi corresponded v-'with' Mrs." Gunness. He has not.been 'heard br si rice 'July: 4,-1 90S, when -he left ; home saying; he was going to marry a widow.
Four physicians' postmortem report on bodies found in the Gunness home ruins failed to establish how the woman and three children died, likely leading to an open coroner's verdict. Separately, evidence pointed to three additional victims, while rings found bore initials not matching Mrs. Gunness, deepening the mystery.
Los Angeles Herald · 13 May 1908 · page 1
RINGS ARE PUZZLING INITIALS IN BANDS NOT THOSE OF MURDERESS AUTOPSY PHYSICIAN MAKES HIS REPORT
the ho. - The coroner's statement OOtsnisM ol a recapitulation of her victims and the money she obtained from them This totaled, according to the state? ment U^.mt. Today was last Sunday over a^ain, thousands tramping the acres of the Gunness farm, d amontf the debris for grewesome evidences of crime, carrying away the bricks of the ?rrecked walls of the house, eatin^r j.ionic dinners and supper* under the idowi of trees near whieh other bodies will probably be found stand