As the Papers Told It

Belle Gunness · The full archive

May 1908, part 3

250 articles

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The report updates the Gunness farm investigation, noting the Syracuse arrest story was false and the woman there was released after proving identity. It details Mrs. Gunness's habit of buying quicklime from H.W. Richter and describes three adult skeletons found dismembered in the barnyard excavation.

The Lake County Times · 9 May 1908 · page 3

MAY GET PRISONER TO CONFESS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

Investigators find decaying bones with ax or cleaver marks on a thigh bone, buried in gunnysacks treated with quicklime beneath yard debris. A mystery arises because victims killed months apart were buried together, suggesting Gunness stored corpses in her forbidden cellar before burial.

The Lake County Times · 9 May 1908 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

This report lays out a chronological list of suspicious deaths, insurance collections, and disappearances connected to Belle Gunness from 1900 onward, culminating in the April 1908 farmhouse fire and subsequent discovery of multiple bodies. It also includes a secondhand account from a schoolteacher about the Gunness children's fear of their mother.

The Lake County Times · 9 May 1908 · page 3

CHRONOLOGY OF INDIANA'S MULTI-MURDER MYSTERY

.If the remains found in tho nilna 'mean slap at VloPresidont Falr of the Gunness homo at Laporte, Indlhanks by tho Methodist general con ana, were really thoo of tho mistress ference at Baltimore. or the "House of Hororrs," tho public will bo deprived of much wnsatloiuil readlncr :m1 Iho nriinn i.ml i ...111 I. l.., .. , ... .. ii nau mrc.il uiuiiiicu ub inuugii Went jmiftt .bo a total abstainer wa a It would bo a relief to know Just Ih In the how much trouble thero and how tOUUCeO UUKT1C18 Ol UIIIO

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A woman arrested on a train suspected of being Belle Gunness proves she is actually Mrs. Cora Herron of Pennsylvania, traveling with her mother. Meanwhile in La Porte, the coroner and physicians conducting the autopsy reportedly conclude that the measurements of the burned body do not match those of Mrs. Gunness.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SENSATION CAUSED. Coroner Finds Body in Fire Not That of Mrs. Gunness. La port e, Ind., May i. The under taker who prepared the fragments of the body of Andrew Helgelein for bur Sal, claims that he found a handful of yellow hair in one hand indicating that, the murdered man had made a fctruggle for his 1'fe. Harry W. Richter. a dealer in Jmilding materials, says that Mrs. Clunness purchased quick lime sever al times during the past year, and also flives evidence that she purchased a kiumber of gunnysacks.

See moreSee less

The coroner today completed his Snvestigatiou of the burning of the 1unness home and finds that the body In the morgue is not that of Mrs. dim ness. The finding has caused a sensa tion. Drs. Long. Wilcox and Meyer con ducted an autopsy on the headless body in the morgue and report, it. their npinion that it is not Mrs. Gunness.

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Doctors conducting an autopsy conclude the headless body found in the fire is not Mrs. Gunness, overturning earlier identification. Investigators also report new evidence including a bloody axe, letters from Gunness to suspect Ray Lamphere, and jeweled rings found in his trunk.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SENSATION CAUSED

Bloody Trunk Found. Word has come from the Chicago of ficials that they have information that 2drs. Gunness is alive and also that an examination of the premises she form erly occupied in Austin is likely to idisclose many additional murders. The discovery of a blood-covered ax Twui a trunk containing important let lers that, will shed light on the mys tery of the Gunness murders followed the exhumation of the tenth body Yrom the lime-filled murder farm that Jiow occupies the shocked attention of the nation. The trunk, the property of Ray Jamphere.

See moreSee less

accused of the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, "was found in a barn at the W'heat Vrook farm, near Springville. where Jie had been employed since February t, after his quarrel with Mrs. Gunness. After learning of the trunk seizure, Attorney Worden. counsel for Lamp Jiere. was refused admission to the Jail. He thereupon announced that lie would seek his client's release on B writ of habeas corpus.

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Detectives seized a trunk belonging to Ray Lamphere containing love letters from Belle Gunness pleading for his return, along with women's rings possibly tied to victims. Separately, a blood-stained ax was unearthed in a woodshed on the Gunness farm as investigators search for more buried remains.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SENSATION CAUSED

Hours before this message was de livered to Lamphere's attorney, de tectives had found the trunk and had brought it here. More important rev elations are cxpeded after the con tents of the trunk have been exam ined. The telltale ax. reddened with blood believed, to have coursed through hu man veins, was found on the Gunness farm in a wood shed, burieu under a pile of rubbish. Sheriff Sniutzer and his aids uncovered it when searching the shed for traces of more murdered victims' graves. Officials both here and from Chica go express the firm belief that there are still 2.") bodies in the ground about the farm or In the sealed basement of the house.

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Coroner Hoffman declares the earth under the Austin home is likely filled with bones of men murdered by Belle Gunness, and states he now believes the body found in the Laporte ruins was not hers. He cites new information from an undisclosed source suggesting Gunness may still be alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 7

LITERALLY FILLED

Xaay Murders Committed. At Laporte, Ind., a terrible murder mystery is now being investigated. Mrs. Bell Gunness, who was the promoter of a matrimonial agency for many years past, is alleged to have killed a score or more people during her career. It is said tnat she would have men call to see her and would then get them out of the way by

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Coroner Hoffman states that evidence suggests Belle Gunness killed before coming to Laporte, possibly using a matrimonial agency for a decade. Sheriff Smutzer brings in Chicago detectives to assist in the ongoing murder investigation, while witnesses linked to Ray Lamphere are placed under surveillance.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 7

Xaay Murders Committed. At Laporte, Ind., a terrible murder mystery is now being investigated. Mrs. Bell Gunness, who was the promoter of a matrimonial agency for many years past, is alleged to have killed a score or more people during her career. It is said tnat she would have men call to see her and would then get them out of the way by

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Imported detectives work the LaPorte murder mystery, finding evidence state's attorney believes strengthens the case against Ray Lamphere. Witnesses including Ralph Colson and Lizzie Smith are placed under surveillance, while the sheriff seeks information from a former Gunness farmhand about disturbing incidents at the house.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 7

Bella Gunness. The tooth was found In the debris of the cellar while Sheriff Smutzer was continuing his preparations to begin the sluicing of the ashes. The relic is a hollow molar, with a gold crown, the metal being indented and to some extent encrusted by cinders. The tooth, however, bears every evi dence of having come from the incin erated skull of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Unoxplalnable evidence, hitherto suppressed, has been made public in |the Gunness tragedy. It Is contained In the report of Dr. J. L. Gray, who performed the autopsy on the body which the authorities have steadfastly claimed is that of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Bella Gunness. Dr. Cray, in his report, tells of three rings which were lound upon the corpse anil also reveals the fact that tho right hand, hitherto declared miss ing, is still in existence. The rings, which might be expected to reveal the identity of the wearer, only add to the mystery of the case. Two of them contain Inscriptions, one

Clipping to come

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

Detectives brought a woman from Syracuse to Utica suspected of being the notorious murderer Belle Gunness. She insisted her name was Mrs. L.A. Hearon of Chicago, and officials began to believe the arrest was a mistake.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

One of the daughters of the infamous murderess Gunness was found near Janesville, Wisconsin, hidden by relatives. Her uncle, Gus Gunness, had taken her from her mother's home fearing for her safety, and steps were being taken to secure her inheritance from the La Porte estate.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 9 May 1908 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Dziennik Chicagoski · Chicago, Ill.

Chicago newspapers report that 16-year-old Polish girl E. Wachowska, who left home in October after answering a newspaper ad to go to Indiana, is likely among Belle Gunness's victims. Her brother Maksymilian is traveling to La Porte, Indiana to attempt to identify her remains.

Dziennik Chicagoski · 9 May 1908 · page 8

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A former La Porte coroner asserts the body recovered from the fire scene is 50 pounds lighter and five inches shorter than Belle Gunness, concluding she is still alive. Meanwhile, a Syracuse woman mistakenly arrested as Gunness is cleared, and investigators pursue leads on a possibly missing farmhand named Canary.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Rock Island Argus · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Considered Sufficient Proof That LaPorte Murderess Is Still Alive. ARREST IS A MISTAKE Syracuse, N. Y., Police Too Hasty and Now Regret Their Action. Ia Porte, Ind., May 9. Dr. Harry H. Long, for two terms coroner of a Porte county, who assisted in the post mortem examination over the body supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness, today declared the body in the morgue Is that of a woman who weighed fully 50 pounds less than d'.d Mrs. Gunness, and is five inches shorter than Mrs. Gunness. Long says Mrs. Gunness is still alive.

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A woman arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Belle Gunness proved her identity and was released, while digging resumed at the Gunness farm with a tenth body found. Investigators sought to trace possible victims including a young man named Canary and a New York man whose buggy was found on the property, and denied rumors that Lamphere had confessed.

Rock Island Argus · 9 May 1908 · page 1

ARREST IS A MISTAKE

Victim From Xfw York. About a year ago a man arrived in La Pol te from some place in the state of New York. He said he had made arrangements to work for Mrs. Gun ness and that she was going to buy a horse and buggy which he had. H5 has never been hea'd of since. liis buggy today was identified while standing in a shed on the Gunness place. Not at School.' i. It has been conclusively proven a story given out by Mrs. Gunness that Jennie Olsen went to attend a Lu theran school at Fergus Falls, Minn., - J .

See moreSee less

1 i 1 . . . : i i . us laisu. a iciier was receive", to day from the authorities of the in stitution declares Jennie was never V, . . , 1 i )..- nn....M Iw.rM-.l ..f Iw.M See the 'I'rlnouer. The threatened clash between the authorities and H. B. Worden, attor ney for Ray Lamphere, over his right to see the prisoner was averted today Worden having been admitted to jail where he talked with Lamphere for more than an hour. Worden strongly denied the story that any trunk had been found containing letters written by Lamphere to Mrs. Gunr.ess and asserted there was absolutely no truth In the statement Lamphere desired to confess or had anything to confess

See the clipping

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

Attorney Worden met with Ray Lamphere in jail and denied reports of a confession or incriminating letters found in a trunk. Coroner Mack revised the body count at the Gunness farm after determining some bones belonged to an already-found corpse, while a new witness claimed Lamphere admitted to blackmailing Mrs. Gunness.

Rock Island Argus · 9 May 1908 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Police in Syracuse concluded that the woman arrested, claiming to be Mrs. L. A. Herron, was not Belle Gunness after her teeth did not match the Laporte description. Lamphere reportedly wants to discuss the situation but is being restrained by his lawyer.

The Topeka State Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 9

The police say the woman is not Mrs. Gunness. Two traveling men who left a New Tork Central eastbound train after 10 o'clock last night, at Rochester, re ports to the police of that city, that two women, one resembling Mrs. Belle Gunness, the Laporte, Ind., alleged murderess, were passengers on the train. The police called up the Syra cuse police and detectives boarded the train and after locating the women went on to ,Utlca In order to question them. They returned with the women and the police put them through an examination. The suspected woman said that she was Mrs. L. A. Herron, that her companion was her mother and that they were on their way to New York.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A woman wrongly suspected of being Belle Gunness was identified as Mrs. L. A. Herron of Franklin, Pa., confirmed by her sister in New York. Meanwhile, jailed suspect Ray Lamphere said he wants to reveal information that could help his case, but his attorney has told him to stay silent.

The Topeka State Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 9

taken into custody. Lamphere Wants to Talk. Laporte, Ind., May 9. A sharp contest between the prosecution and defense in the case of Ray Lamphere, who is accused of having caused the death of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children is scheduled for today. H. V. Worden, attorney for the pris oner, said last night, that he would file an action in court here today with the object of compelling the author ities to abandon their policy of keep ing Lamphere in seclusion. Worden complains that when he went to the jail last night he was refused admit tance despite the fact that his client had sent for him.

See moreSee less

A possible explanation of the re fusal of the sheriff to admit Worden to Lamphere's cell is found in the fact that the former hired man of Mrs. Gunness said yesterday that he was willing to break the silence which he has maintained since his arrest provided that his attorney will agree to such a procedure. "I want to tell something I know because I know that it will help my cause if I do so," said Lamphere. "But my attorney says I must not talk and I won't until he says I can." This attitude of the prisoner has given the prosecution hope that he may soon reveal secrets which they have been endeavoring to solve by the slow system of circumstantial evi dence. At the same time it is realized that Attorney Worden will srarcelv change his attitude regarding the prisoner's making any admissions con cerning relations with Mrs. Gunness and that after the two have conferred on the subject, that silence will again enshroud the prisoner. So if Attor ney Worden begins court action against the prosecution, his move ments prooaDiy will De resisted stren uously. Yesterday's developments, outside the discovery of one more body on the farm centered mainly also about Lamphere's possible connection with the deaths. Many more witnesses were Interviewed by the prosecuting uiin-in ttnu ui iKasi two were sub poenaed formally. This brings the present nsi oi witnesses to 21. Most important of the evidence cured yesterday was the trunk which Lamphere left on the farm of John Wheatbrook where he was employed stnee February last. It was secured early yesterday, but it was not until well along in the eveninsr that th. fact that the authorities had found it became known. The Wheatbrook farm Is in the vi cinity ot opringvnie, a hamlet seven miles north of here and in the noi.h. borhood where Lamnhere snent hlo boyhood. His father was formerly a justice of the peace in that township and the earlier habits of Lamphere are to be investigated by the Pinker ton operatives who are aiding Sheriff Smutzer. Letters from Mrs. Gunness found in Lamphere's trunk urged him tn turn to the death farm and to bring his sweetheart with him. These let ters were sent to Springville and the Investigation to be made may result in discovering the "sweetheart" men tioned by Mrs. Gunness. Thus far ner laenuty is unratnomable.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Lamphere tells reporters he wants to reveal information that could help his case, but his attorney has ordered him to stay silent for now. Meanwhile investigators found Lamphere's trunk at the Wheatbrook farm containing letters from Mrs. Gunness urging him to return to the farm with his sweetheart, and a new body was discovered on the Gunness property.

The Topeka State Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 9

WANTS TO TALK

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Paper unidentified

A brief news item reports that eleven bodies have been taken from the private graveyard of Mrs. Belle Gunness, described as an 'arch murderess,' at LaPorte, Indiana. The item appears among other short national news dispatches with no further detail.

Paper unidentified · 9 May 1908 · page 2

Remains at Ten. Laporte, Ind.. May 9.—Dr. II. H. hong, one of the physicians who per formed the autopsy on the body o£ the wgnian found in the ruins of the Gun liess home alter the fire, has made a statement that the body is not. that or Mrs. Gunness. His statement is as follows: ''In my opinion the body of the wo mfiii found in the house is not that of Mjs. Gunness because it is not. cor rectly proportioned. It is that of a rather plump woman of the same gen eral contour of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness, but weighing between 150 and ICO pounds. JIi-s. Gunness was literally a succes sion of billows of flesh and weighed Sully 1123 pounds. "The arm that was burned off was found beside the body ami is well formed. The lingers show evidence dt careful manicuring and that was sqjpetiiiiig that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Rasing my statements on the sta tistics and figures of eminent physi cians of this country and Great Brit ain I find that the body at the morgue is almost five inches shorter than the laibd.y of Mrs. Gunness would be under similar circumstances. The lire would, of course, cause the body to lose \Veiglit, but the general physical out luie of the woman would remain. Mrs. Otmness was a woman of unusual ap pearance. She was large, bony, power ful looking, with square jaws and black eyes. "She was a woman who would at tract attention anywhere from her lack of womanly characteristics. She \vfore a large fur coat during the win ter and herVong strides, together with ifer remarkable countenance and her generally vicious appearance, gave lvt an aspect that was almost terrify ing." No additional bodies have been un earthed oil the Gunness farm, the yjmber recovered standing at ten. Of tliese three have been identified.

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

A woman thought to be Belle Gunness was arrested on a train near Syracuse, NY, but police now believe she is actually Mrs. F.B. Herron of Chicago, not the alleged murderess. Meanwhile in La Porte, Indiana, no new bodies were found and digging continues in the cellar and a private graveyard on the farm.

Paper unidentified · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Five bodies of persons supposed to have been murdered by Mrs. Belle Gun ness were dug up near the house, a mile northwest of Laporte. Ind., where she and her three children recentl.v perished in flames. It is believed she also caused the death of her two hus bands. Ray Lamphere is suspected of having been her accomplice. Four more bodies wrere dug up in the barnyard of Mrs. Guinness' farm, near Laporte, Ind., making nine found so far. The mystery of the “death house” is growing deeper, though there is evidence that the bodies were shipped to Mrs.

See moreSee less

Guin ness. probably from Chicago, in trunks and boxes which draymen tell of carting to her house. Another of the bodies dug up on the farm of Mrs. Guinness near La porte. Ind.. was identified as that of Ole B. Budsberg of iota. Wis., whom the woman lured there by a matri monial advertisement. New witnesses against Roy Lamphere were found. Another body was dug up on Mrs. Guinness' farm near Laporte. Ind., making ten found. More incriminat ing evidence against Ray Lamphere was obtained. Seventy-two men who for more than 2-4 hours had been facing death in the raging sea near Fire island, were rescued from the crumbling hulk of the big German ship Peter Rickmers. Charges of rioting against Univer sity of Michigan students were ail dis missed after the boys bad reimbursed the county. P. b. Sullivan was burned to death

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Investigators reveal Max Sorenson's death was precisely timed to allow Belle Gunness to collect on two life insurance policies. A nephew advances a theory that part of the farm was once a private burial ground used by a former owner, while another dismembered female body is unearthed at the site.

Paper unidentified · 9 May 1908 · page 1

AT T t rr mony Together. i.a, Porte, I ml., May 13,—Mrs Guin ness’ hired man, Ray Lamphere, vigor ously denied today that he had made ail}’ confession or promise to Rev. E. i A. Schell o;- any one •dsn Lamphere . ; und'V arrest, here charged with com plicity in the wholesale murders a:

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified

Coroner's examination left the identity of the burned torso uncertain, with Dr. Harry Long doubting it was Belle Gunness, as the sheriff continued digging for more remains. Meanwhile, new evidence against Ray Lamphere emerged, including a trunk containing letters from Gunness urging his return to the farm, found with women's rings.

Paper unidentified · 9 May 1908 · page 4

Schell, the .Methodist minister who gave out an interview at Haliimore | yesterday that Hay l.anipliere liaci j confessed to him in connection with i the burning of the home of Mrs. llelle Gunness, murderess of sixteen per-!

Clipping to come

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A tenth corpse was exhumed from the Gunness farmyard in La Porte, adding to the grim collection already found. Coroner Mack's initial report of two bodies was later corrected to one, and authorities now believed Belle Gunness herself was still alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 12

ONE SKELETON Added to Gruesome Col* lection at La Porte. Found Friday at liie Home oi Missing Mis. Guinness. Authorities Now Convinced That She Is Still Alive. La Porte, Ind . May 8.— One more body was added to the death roll of th<* Bella Guinness farm today, mak ing a total of 10 corpses and skeletons exhumed in the yard besides the four bodies found in the ruins of the farm house which was burned on April 28. Coroner Mack at first announced that the grave opened this morning con tained one complete cadaver and sev eral bones of a second skeleton, but this evening he said that what he had first believed to be additional thigh and arm bones, belong to the first body re covered today.

See moreSee less

Resumption of excavation at the Guinness farm today again drew an immense crowd of spectators. The rush of visitors has become so great that livery men have established a regular omnibus line from La Porte to the farm. The announcement by Coroner Mack that two bodies had been discovered served only to increase the rush of curiosity seekers. The scraps of human ity were found in the barnyard, which had already given up nine cadavers and were discovered under circumstances similar to those which prevailed on Tuesday and Wednesday. About four feet below the surface, the excavators encountered bits of bone and burlap and a few strokes more of the spades and hoes revealed a skull, a decom posed torso and leg and arm bones. This corpse was far the least pre served of any of the 10 grewsome relics. Besides the usual traces of lime, the body showed that a less skilful hand had dismembered it. The legs had been severed above the knee joint, but the bones were splintered. The should; blade was shattered in cleaving the head from the body. The skull was ly ing near the pelvis. Nothing but a jumbled heap of decayed flesh and crumbling bor.es was left to indicate the identity of the persons. It was thought, however, that the corpse was that of a woman for a pair of woman's Oxford shoes and the metal frame of a woman's purse were found in the grave. While the investigations were going on a*, the farm. Prosecutor Smith, aid ed by Deputy Sheriff Roy Marr, was collecting additional evidence concern ing Latnphere's alleged particiuation in the. deaths of Hclgelein, Mrs. Guin ness and her three children. Lamphere is accused of first degree murder be cause of the deaths of Mrs. Guinness and iier three children. Lamphere today sent a request t« his attorney, H. W. Worden, asking the latter to send to the farm of John Weatherbrook for a trunk which Lam phere left there when he was arrest ed after the burning of the Guinness house. But before this word had reached the attorney, the trunk had been seized by the police. It con tained a number of letters written bj Mrs. Guinness to Lamphere, after the latter had taken employment at the farm of John Wheatbrook. sever miles north of La Porte. The exaei date of these letters was not an nounced. Mrs. Guinness wrote to Lam pherB urging him to return to hei farm and to “bring your sweetheari with you if she has money enough.' The identity of the woman is a mys tery and neither does Mrs. Guinness mention the amount deemed neces sary for her reception at the Guinnes: farm. Along with the letters wen found several women's finger rings some of which were of unusual siz. and may have been the property o Mrs. Guinness. n ii urjoto one OI me nsi new today was Peter Colsen. According t< Colson. Lamphere said a few days lie fore the burning of the Guinness house “I made her get down on her knees las night, and I am going to make her ge down tonight unless site comes up witl : some money. I know things about he that would raise an awful row if the; were told. She bought me this suit o clothes that I am wearing but she doesn' like to come up with the coin and tha is what I must have.” It is the prosecutor's theory that Lam p|,ere had gained knowledge of the mean by which Andrew Helegelein was done b death; that the prisoner attempted to us this knowledge to extort money from th woman: that she became frightened a his threats and undertook the series o prosecutions against him which resultei In his trial before a lunacy com.nissioi and in his being thrice arrested at he instigation; that Lampliere attempted b wreak vengeance on her for these ac tions, and for her refusal to give hin money or to continue the relations wnicl had existed between them prior to th appearance in Januaiy of Helegelein that the fire at the Helegelein home wa started, by Lamphere; but tlint he ha.

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

Excavators found a tenth, poorly preserved corpse at the Gunness farm, identified as likely female by a pair of Oxford shoes and a purse frame found nearby. Meanwhile prosecutors gathered evidence against Ray Lamphere, including a seized trunk with letters from Belle Gunness and witness testimony about his threats against her.

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 12

ONE SKELETON

grave. While the investigations were going on a*, the farm. Prosecutor Smith, aid ed by Deputy Sheriff Roy Marr, was collecting additional evidence concern ing Latnphere's alleged particiuation in the. deaths of Hclgelein, Mrs. Guin ness and her three children. Lamphere is accused of first degree murder be cause of the deaths of Mrs. Guinness and iier three children. Lamphere today sent a request t« his attorney, H. W. Worden, asking the latter to send to the farm of John Weatherbrook for a trunk which Lam phere left there when he was arrest ed after the burning of the Guinness house.

See moreSee less

But before this word had reached the attorney, the trunk had been seized by the police. It con tained a number of letters written bj Mrs. Guinness to Lamphere, after the latter had taken employment at the farm of John Wheatbrook. sever miles north of La Porte. The exaei date of these letters was not an nounced. Mrs. Guinness wrote to Lam pherB urging him to return to hei farm and to “bring your sweetheari with you if she has money enough.' The identity of the woman is a mys tery and neither does Mrs. Guinness mention the amount deemed neces sary for her reception at the Guinnes: farm. Along with the letters wen found several women's finger rings some of which were of unusual siz. and may have been the property o

See the clipping

Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.

A dispatch reports that a tape measure comparison showed the headless trunk found in the fire ruins was too small to be Belle Gunness, and that friends confirmed it was not her body. The report suggests Gunness faked her death and is still alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Daily Kennebec Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 12

MRS. GUINNESS LIVING. Body of Dead Woman in the Ruins Is Not Her's. Chicago. May 8.—A dispatch to the Inter-Ocean from La Porte, Ind., says: Mrs. Belle Guinness, high priestess of murder, who at the back door of her farmhouse kept a private grave yard from which nine bodies have been un earthed. is alive. Ttiis was' established beyond a rea sonable doubt yesterday. An ordinary tape measure proved the agent which may solve the perplexing mystery of the long series of startling crimes. Careful measurements were taken of the headless trunk of the woman found in the ruins of the burned home, which at first was thought to tie the body of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Guinness. This resulted in the astounding revelation that the dead woman was not more than halt the size or weight of the siren who is sup posed to have lured a score of men to their death. In addition to the convincing testi mony of the tape, halt a dozen of the intimate friends of Mrs. Guinness as serted with the positiveness of abso lute conviction that the dead body was not that of the mistress of the castle of death on the Mcl’lung road.

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

Police in Syracuse are interrogating a woman detained on a train, suspecting she may be murderess Belle Gunness traveling under a false identity as a Chicago widow named Mrs. Herren. Her story cannot be verified and her companion is also being questioned in hopes of extracting a confession.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 1

MRS. GUNNESS SUSPECT IS SWEATED

She deciaree ehe it Mrs. L. A. Herren, of Chicago,. The only Mre. Herren known In that city, and the only one given In the city directory, it Mre. A. L. Her ren, of No. 4743 Evans-ave., the widow of Abraham Herren, a dry gooda man. Mre. Herren la at her home, and said that she knew of no Mre. Herren who would answer the description of the woman da tained in Syracuse. SYRACUSE. N. Y. t May 9—Strong !n their suspicion that the younger of the two women taken from a train hert.

See moreSee less

Is Mrs. Belle Gunness. who Is wanted for a score of murders on heT farm at 1-n Porte. Ind.. detectives early today began to give her the "third degree" The woman’s statement that she la Mrs. L. F Herron, a widow of Chi cago. was gravely doubted from her refusal to give the name of a slater In New York whom she claimed she was on her way to visit. The older woman who accompanied the oraan thought to be Mrs. Gun ness. nlso ill be subjected to the most severe questioning. From her, now that she is removed from her com panion’s Influence, it Is hoped to gain edmlssions which will send the sup posed Mrs. Gunness hack to La Porte to face trial for the moat atrocious series of murders ever known In Am erica. The woman supposed to be the nrchalayer. was In such a state of collapse when she left the train here that she could only talk for a few moments. Then she became tnore composed. She said that her hus band, a dealtr in oils In that city, died on Jan. 1, and that she came east a few weeks ago to stay with u brother

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

A woman resembling Belle Gunness was pulled from a train berth in Syracuse after fellow passengers alerted police, and is being questioned in hopes of linking her to the Indiana murders. Meanwhile in La Porte, coroner's crews continue exhuming bodies from Gunness' property, bringing the known victim count toward twenty.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SYRACUSE, N. Y., May 9.

LA PORTE. Ind., May 9.—The find ing yesterday of three more bodies in Mrs. Gunness’ yard has spurred on the coroner's staff of special grave diggers to extra efTort. While the total number of Mrs. Gunness' known vic

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

Pinkerton detectives and the prosecutor expressed belief that the headless body found in the burned Gunness cellar is that of Belle Gunness, though ash-sifting continues to search for her gold teeth as final proof. The report also describes new leads: missing stockmen, a reported Chicago 'baby farm,' and a schoolteacher's account of the Gunness children being punished for trying to enter the cellar.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Two Stockman Missing. The sheriff has begun an investi gation to determine if a number of the bodies found are not those of stockmen who passed through this county from time to time and several of whom disappeared Mysteriously. At the Gunness barn there are now several horses and buggies for which the widow said she had traded. One horse and buggy belonged to a Mon tana man who stopped at a resort near by and said that he was going to Mrs Gunness'a to sell her the rig At the same time the excavations are being made, the Chicago police will investigate a report which has reached headquarters that for a num ber of years Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness was the proprietress of a "baby farm" on the west side In that city. Lixzle Smith, the colored woman at whose place Lamphere was on the night of the murder, is under surveil lance by the police. Her home is be ing constantly watched.

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

A cabdriver gave a secret statement to Sheriff Smutzer describing how he drove a young, well-dressed Chicago woman to the Gunness farm at midnight, where he later heard screams and saw the woman struggling with Mrs. Gunness before she fled hysterical. The story suggests the girl witnessed or was victim of an attack inside the house.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 1

DEEOEO TO CHICAGOAN. LA PORTE, Ind., May 9.—A graphto chapter In "the house of death" tales was revealed today by a cab driver who was secretly closeted with Sheriff A. F. Smutzer. It is the story of how a young and pretty Chicago girl was lured to the Widow Gunness’ isolated farm and there either witnessed a murder or was hcr«elf attacked. "The driver Is an honest man," said Sheriff Smutzer, “and he asked me not to reveal his name, but this is his story: . "‘About nine months ago Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gun ness asked him to meet a late train, with a closed carriage. A young wo man was to be on the train from Chi cago and should be driven to the farm. "The girl, who was well dressed and pretty, stepped Into the cab and was hurried out to the Gunness place. It was midnight, but there were lights burning brightly In every room. "The driver waited. He thought that the girl might wish to go back later. Mrs. Gunness herself opened the door. She spoke cordially to the girl, usher ed her into the house and closed the door again, the heavy bolts ringing be hind her. I "It was perhaps half an hour later that the cabby heard suppressed shrieks in the house. He leaped down from his seat, and stood wondering, uncertain for a moment. "Then the bolts flew back and the door burst open. In the flood of light he could ace Mrs. Gunness and the

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

The report describes a cabby's dramatic account of a girl's terrified escape from the Gunness house, along with news that Mrs. Gunness had deeded her farm to a Chicago man shortly before vanishing. It also covers the mistaken arrest and release of a woman in New York wrongly suspected of being Belle Gunness.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 1

DEEDED TO CHICAGOAN

NEW YORK. May 9.—The woman arrested on a New York Ceutral train near Syracuse today, because of an alleged striking resemblance to Mrs. Belle Gunnens, the La Porte, Ind., arch-murderess, has been Identified and released by the police. Martin Condon, the chief of police of Syracuse, wired a New York news paper to aid him in finding if Mrs. Charles P. Rockefeller, of 317 West Fortieth-st., knew anything of the woman. It then developed that the prisoner held with her mother is Mrs. Cora Bello Herron, of FranTtlln, Pa., widow' of a vice president of the Seth ners Chemical Cos., of Chicago, who was on her way to Manhattan to make a visit. Previous to thlß, the chief had said; "I believe a mistake has been made by my subordinates.”

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

The passage includes a photo captioned 'Mrs. Belle Gunness and Her Children,' describing her as a reputed mass murderess believed to have lured as many as a score of people to their deaths at her La Porte, Indiana farm. It states her own three children are believed to be among her victims, along with several other women.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Mrs. William Diesling, who lives on a farm near that of the Gunness place, today told of the mysterious disap pearance of a baby. One of the surprises of the day came when it was discovered that, shortly before her disappearance, Mrs. Gunness deeded her farm and other possessions to a Chicago man. State’s Attorney R. N. Smith refuses to talk about this angle of the case or give the name of the man. This, taken In connection with the fact that she made her will the day before her house was burned, gives rire to even stronger belief that she is living.

See the clipping

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

Travelers claim to have spotted a woman resembling Mrs. Gunness on a train near Syracuse, NY, though a witness disputes the match to her published photo. Meanwhile in La Porte, the state's attorney dismisses the capture report, and a doctor's examination concludes the dismembered body found cannot be Gunness, fueling belief she is alive.

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 6

CABDRIVER SAW GIRL FIGHT WITH MRS. GUNNESS

'.Continued from race One) ness children but had no pari in the slaying of any man except Helgelelu. "I have, made no statement regarding this or any other detail of my Interview with Lamphere except that Lamphere's communications to me were wholly privileged, and unless ho shall himself make statements to Prosecutor Smith, they will be maintained as an inviola ble secret." Dr. Schell added that, like many oth ers, he behoved that .Mrs. Gunnesa was alive, but that he had no knowledge of the fact. It was merely his personal opinion.

See moreSee less

Speaking further concerning the case, Dr. Schell said: "Mrs. linn ness, as I stated yesterday, was nil at tractive woman In her way. She dressed richly, and even you might say in good taste, but her manner of talking and her speech Itself—her vagaries of gram mar—betrayed a low origin. She could best be described as 'Mrs. New-Rich.' "Lamphere is a man who drinks hard and has borne an unpleasant reputa tion. He was the son of a drunkard. and a. man to be pitied because of his ancestry and training, or lack of it. On two or three occasions recently he has come into town with a roll of bills, which he has generally managed to get rid of In a day or a. night. Some time ago I constituted myself a sort of civic league and went after certain saloon keepers in the town who violated the law, and I found a slot machine run ning in one of them in which Lamphere had lost $60 a night or two before. They say he lost it playing the ma chine, but the suspicion is that he Rot drunk and was relieved of his money. Lamphere sent for me and told me his story, and that is how I got mixed up in the case. Despite the advice of his lawyers. I believe lie will tell the whole truth when he goes on the witness Stand. I did not know personally any of i the supposed victims of Mrs. Gun ness. Jennie Olson, I am told, came to our Sunday school once or twice, but I never met her. I have seen the man Helgeleln. He was a big fellow, but I did not know him personally." "The house in which Mrs. Gunness lived had borne a bad name for years as a house of crime, and twenty years ago as a place of resort for the gilded ye th of. Chicago, which was only fif ty -'nine miles away, and for some men of wealth and prominence who were not exactly youths. When tic woman who ran it sold out another took it up, and ii became a disreputable house of the i Reaper grade. "Three years ago when Mrs. Gunness came from Boston and bought the house people thought its character would change, because at that time she was looked upon as entirely respect able. The place was a rather imposing one, for the neighborhood, the house being worth $7000 or $8000 and the farm containing seventy-five acres."

Clipping to come

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

Reports describe a false alarm capture of Belle Gunness near Syracuse, which officials dismiss, while a medical expert insists the dismembered body found earlier cannot be hers. Meanwhile investigators pursue new evidence—sacks, a bloody ax, letters, and jewelry—tying Ray Lamphere to the case and hinting at more bodies buried at a Chicago house.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Detroit Times · 9 May 1908 · page 6

MRS. GUNNESS

'.Continued from race One) ness children but had no pari in the slaying of any man except Helgelelu. "I have, made no statement regarding this or any other detail of my Interview with Lamphere except that Lamphere's communications to me were wholly privileged, and unless ho shall himself make statements to Prosecutor Smith, they will be maintained as an inviola ble secret." Dr. Schell added that, like many oth ers, he behoved that .Mrs. Gunnesa was alive, but that he had no knowledge of the fact. It was merely his personal opinion.

See moreSee less

Speaking further concerning the case, Dr. Schell said: "Mrs. linn ness, as I stated yesterday, was nil at tractive woman In her way. She dressed richly, and even you might say in good taste, but her manner of talking and her speech Itself—her vagaries of gram mar—betrayed a low origin. She could best be described as 'Mrs. New-Rich.' "Lamphere is a man who drinks hard and has borne an unpleasant reputa tion. He was the son of a drunkard. and a. man to be pitied because of his ancestry and training, or lack of it. On two or three occasions recently he has come into town with a roll of bills, which he has generally managed to get rid of In a day or a. night. Some time ago I constituted myself a sort of civic league and went after certain saloon keepers in the town who violated the law, and I found a slot machine run ning in one of them in which Lamphere had lost $60 a night or two before. They say he lost it playing the ma chine, but the suspicion is that he Rot drunk and was relieved of his money. Lamphere sent for me and told me his story, and that is how I got mixed up in the case. Despite the advice of his lawyers. I believe lie will tell the whole truth when he goes on the witness Stand. I did not know personally any of i the supposed victims of Mrs. Gun ness. Jennie Olson, I am told, came to our Sunday school once or twice, but I never met her. I have seen the man Helgeleln. He was a big fellow, but I did not know him personally." "The house in which Mrs. Gunness lived had borne a bad name for years as a house of crime, and twenty years ago as a place of resort for the gilded ye th of. Chicago, which was only fif ty -'nine miles away, and for some men of wealth and prominence who were not exactly youths. When tic woman who ran it sold out another took it up, and ii became a disreputable house of the i Reaper grade. "Three years ago when Mrs. Gunness came from Boston and bought the house people thought its character would change, because at that time she was looked upon as entirely respect able. The place was a rather imposing one, for the neighborhood, the house being worth $7000 or $8000 and the farm containing seventy-five acres."

Clipping to come

The Diamond Drill · Crystal Falls, Mich.

Investigators digging on the Gunness farm near La Porte have found five bodies, including those of Andrew Helgelein and Jennie Olson, after a tip from Helgelein's brother led to a hired hand's suspicious digging. The report states Belle Gunness herself died with her three children in the burning of her home.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Diamond Drill · 9 May 1908 · page 7

SHE HERSELF WAS THE CHIEF

CHE HEIISELF WAS THE CHIES Eody of a South Dakota Man Daj Up on Her Farm. Alao an llb-ven-Yrar-Obl Girl and Thres Other Persons Hired 51 an Is IlHIrved an Accomplice. With five bodies already unearthed Sheriff Smutzer and Coroner Mack, of La Forte, Ind., are continuing their March fur other alleged vic tims of Mr. Hclle Gunness, wb to all Indications, was one of the most ItendUh murderess of the cen tury, and who was n ioutly ..killed, wlti her three child rou through 'the buraln:? of hor country homo one mile north east of Lal'orte.

See moreSee less

Of the bodies o far unearthed two Lave tn-en ldentilh:l They are those of Andrew Helgclelu, a wealthy bachelor of Mansfield, H, I)., and Miss Jennie Olon, clevru-j rear old stepdaughter of Mr. Gunnes. Tha othor three bodies are po badly dee im posed as to make Identification Impos Hole. Hired .Man Had Dug Hole. The discovery of the bodies was brought about by the appearnnce of A. J. Hclgelelu, or Aberdeen, S. D., brother of Andrew llelgelein. in La l'orte lp search tor the missing man. With Information that his brother An drew had come to La Porte to wed Mrs. Cunness, and -that he had turned over his property to her, be Is'came con vinced that he had been made the ljtl.u of foul play. While questioning Joseph MaxHon, a hired hand on the (Junness farm, he learned of the mys terious digging of boles by him. all of thpin belli;; tiJled at a later date by Mri. Ounnoss. He led llelgelein and the officers to the spot where the holoi had been dug, about 10 feet from tin liouse and there, after digging a few minute, was uncovered the lody of llelgelein. llelgelein' I tody Dismembered. The remains were only four feet un der ground and were enclosed in .a gunny nack. The legs and anus had teen dismembered, but were with the trunk. About thirty-five feet further on from the remains the four other person were found. Lying on top of a mattress were the skeleton of two men and a woman. Underneath the mattress" was the body of an eleven-year-old Kill, said to be Jennie Olson. All the bodies were taken In charge by the coroner, and are now locked in a box iii the farm. The discovery of the todies led ex pressmen to tell of th delivery of tire trunks to the Gunnoss farm during the last six months, and this fact has caused, the authorities to work on tht theory that the place was a clearing house for murderers. They suKjvect that wealthy persons, after being lured to Chicago and killed, were packed In these trunks and sent to Lal'orte and dlposed of. Did 8 ho Kill Her Husband? The developments of the day also caused the authorities to recall that the two husbands of Mrs.Gunness dlel tinder suspicious circumstances, Nith meeting violent deaths. The first, K ! ward Sorenson, was Insured for IV GOO. and the second, (Junness, for 600. This Insurance was paid over to Mr. (Jurim'su by the companies. Hay Lnmphere, the ex -aired man of Mrs. Gimness. who was arrested after the woman's house had been destroyed by fire and the IhsIIcs of Mrs. (Junness and her thiee children had been found In the ruins, was charged with mur dering the family. - llelievr lie Killed family, lie now wni le avned of being nn afcomnllce of Mrs. Gnnncss lu the nmrderii.g if the alleged victims of th IaPorti woman. It H Isdieved that :Lfiruphcro, (angered U-anse Mrs. Gun nes refused to keep hhn slip) He d with money, killed her and the children out of revenre. and then tired the bouse to cot or the' (Thru. It has devi'lojwd that l.ainphere had leeu seen wearing a fur oveu-oat. answering (be elescnp tlon of one belonging to Andrew He I ge'elu. several times during the m-mtu of February. Mrs. (Silliness also won the coat on several ooc.ish'ns, and when asked concerning It stated tli.it It had been given to her by nn ad mlrer. Karly Wednesday morning the d'u glng In the yard was resumed and an other body was soon discovered, bring ing the total up to six. Four Morn I tod Irs Found. A possible solution of the mystery, which has been deepened by four ad dltlonal boilhs being ft und'lu the barn yard, has developed. Lvldence th.a the nine dismembered eorpM'S ui earthed so far had been ehlpi ed to Id city, piobably from ("Memo, e n.ie t Ikdtt. the testimony of dniy un o w h had eaitod trunks and Ihics to i C.uineM home heating thl ill, In id el'.tlm th loeal Hi thi'iiti.'s te. . I.c'.li that f onuntlr.il t wt , trnuU en 'nd. to "Mrs. i; una t. LiPo t hi I it in p' e were be i! t eis l ! f . pi the l.ir hl.ll'H r ( b !'' M e l' iiiii.i . ' f I!k Co!. :'g- ! '.! at n. e. pr. ; 'e lis i i .. i Ai It'ii tiirw Two Itodn 1'wo of I he 1:1.1. --it. l::ive 1 rell P! 'hti.lr.l r t ll: ly. Af ' !'e I viewed the remains fupposed to b those of Jennie Olson,. the slxtcen-yrar old fostcrdaughter of Mrs. Gulnes and pronounced them those of hi daughter. A sNter of the dead girl Mrs. Leo Olander. uNo of Chicago, ae co-npanled the father, and added he: testimony regarding her sister's char flctcihttes. Frohsbl Mote lor Crime. A r.'otive for t!if wholesale murder has not been ftdiy estat l'hhed. The dr cumst.uu e surroun ling tie dhapix-ar nn'es of Ilelgehdn and Ole li.-Ttud br-g, of lola. Wis., are, however, start llfcly enough similar to give u tlew s to the object of the person or per ?o i". who committed the criuu s. IM re!ilr al seeun'd J.'H.M) through lh I'irst Natio-.il bank here shortly le fo"e lie was losi trade of. I'.tnlsbery negotiated the., sale of n moitgag' tJirouL,'!t the LalVrte Savings lank which yl hied hln'i I.(H(i. lie drew thl iu ney April (1, Hh7. N recur i of h!fu rt her appearance In the llesl habeen found.

See the clipping

The Diamond Drill · Crystal Falls, Mich.

Diggers uncover the dismembered body of Helgelein along with four more victims near the LaPorte farm, bringing the total to six and then nine as digging continues. Authorities suspect the farm was a clearing house where wealthy victims were killed in Chicago, shipped in trunks, and buried, while Ray Lamphere is held as an accomplice believed to have killed Mrs. Gunness and her children out of revenge.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Diamond Drill · 9 May 1908 · page 7

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.

Investigators found four mutilated bodies buried in the yard of the burned Gunness home, with reports of three more including a man and woman. A former farmhand named Lamphere, suspected of jealousy over Mrs. Gunness and victim Heldgren, was seen wearing the dead man's coat and carrying his gun.

The Irish Standard · 9 May 1908 · page 7

UNEARTH WHOLESALE MURDER.

A farm of corpses have been un earthed at La Porte, Indiana, being the farm owned by the supposed murderess, Mrs. Bella Gunness, who with her three children were also murdered by some one and her house burned. Great ex citement prevails there. Adozen hodies have been dug up in the yard and farm. Some of the victims were shipped in trunks from Chicago to Mrs. Gunness, and she buried them. Robbery was the incentive to this bloody work, A hired man is in jail as an accomplice and ag being the murderer of Mrs. Gun ness and children, because she didn’y keep him supplied with money.

Clipping to come

The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.

A dispatch claims measurements prove the headless trunk found in the ruins was not Belle Gunness, as she was much larger than the corpse. Meanwhile, diggers unearth two more skeletons, a man and a woman, near the earlier found bodies.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Beatrice Daily Express · 9 May 1908 · page 1

TWO MORE BODIES FOUND BY DIGGERS

•.:§§&$ Banks to Aid Proseoution. a conference of the officials of three Laporte banks today it was de termined that the most effective way in aiding the authorities in untaugliug the murder mysteries was to furnish a list of all the transactions in which Mrs. Gunness paid out, deposited or received money. With a complete lfst of this kind Prosecutor Smith ex pects he will be able to secure valua ble information.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A newspaper digest item reports that two more bodies were dug up on the farm of Mrs. Gunness at La Porte. It appears as a brief domestic news summary line pointing readers to a fuller story on page 1.

Omaha Daily Bee · 9 May 1908 · page 1

•.:§§&$ Banks to Aid Proseoution. a conference of the officials of three Laporte banks today it was de termined that the most effective way in aiding the authorities in untaugliug the murder mysteries was to furnish a list of all the transactions in which Mrs. Gunness paid out, deposited or received money. With a complete lfst of this kind Prosecutor Smith ex pects he will be able to secure valua ble information.

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

A dispatch claims measurements prove the headless trunk found in the ruins is not Belle Gunness, as it is only half her size, with friends confirming this. Meanwhile, two more bodies—a man and possibly a woman—are unearthed at the farm as crowds of over 1,000 gather to watch.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Omaha Daily Bee · 9 May 1908 · page 1

MYSTERY ABOUT HER DEEPENING

Buried at Night. "We were walking to a farmhouse as In the country out of Laporte," said one of the men to State's Attorney Smith. "It was a bright, moonlight night and tne ground was white un der three inches of snow. It was pos sible to see across the glistening land scape a great distance. "As we passed the Gunness farm house we saw Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness. Both were working busily In the fenced inclosure at the side of the yard. We became interested in wljat they were doing and stopped in the road. We started to shout to '-tliem, but for some reason or other ijjld not 40 it. Mrs. Gunness made two into the house and back to Oystr Clam (Continued on page 8.) Corn anl

Clipping to come

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Diggers uncover a second skeleton, believed to be a woman's, buried beneath the first at the Gunness farm, drawing over 1,000 sightseers by mid-morning. Authorities expect more bodies to be found and are building evidence linking Ray Lamphere to the deaths through witness testimony.

Omaha Daily Bee · 9 May 1908 · page 1

MYSTERY ABOUT HER DEEPENING

M. fit THE MORBID IN HUMANITY. 'There is a morbid streak in human ity, a love of the grewsome that is sometimes hard to understand. Yes terday these curious souls had a tV4# Jte veritable feast at the Gunness farm,

Clipping to come

Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.

The report recounts the discovery of fifteen bodies on Belle Gunness's Laporte farm, the arrest of farmhand Ray Lamphere, and the tip from A. K. Helgelein that led searchers to dig up nine bodies in the yard. It states authorities believe Gunness murdered her children, burned the house, and escaped after also killing two husbands and various victims.

Perth Amboy Evening News · 9 May 1908 · page 1

It wasn't the same with the morbid crowds at the Gunness farm. They were seeking excitement and they would have been better pleased if there had been more bodies to view, more grewsome butcheries to furnish them amusement.

Clipping to come

Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.

Detectives tracked a woman matching Belle Gunness's description from Rochester to Syracuse to Utica, where she identified herself as widow Mrs. L. A. Herron from Chicago traveling to visit her sister in New York. Contacts in New York and Franklin, Pa. seemed to corroborate her story, though officers remained uncertain whether she was truly Mrs. Gunness.

Perth Amboy Evening News · 9 May 1908 · page 1

•TORY OF HIS MOVEMENTS. Laporte, Ind., May 12.—Unex pteinable evidence which has hitherto been suppressed was made public in the Gunness trag edy this morning. It is contained In the report of Dr. Lucien Gray, •who performed the autopsy on the body which authorities have steadfastly claimed is that of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Qray tells of three rings which were found up on the corpse and also reveals the fact that the right hand hitherto 7 declared to be missing, is still In existence.

Clipping to come

Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.

Detectives began examining letters from Mrs. Gunness to Lamphere found hidden in a barn loft, while digging resumed at the Gunness farm. A doctor who knew Mrs. Gunness examined the body found in the burned house and declared it was not hers, citing manicured nails and incorrect height, even as two more dismembered bodies were unearthed.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Perth Amboy Evening News · 9 May 1908 · page 1

has not been heard of since July 4, 190C. Laporte, Ind., May 12. Ray Lam phere has confessed that he caught Mrs. Belle Gunness red handed in the act of burying the dismembered body of Andrew Hegeleln, her last victim, by lantern light at midnight in her back door graveyard on "murder farm." The farm hand, under arrest on a charge of arson and murder in connection with the Gunness trage dies, made this confession to a friend whom the local authorities have lo cated in South Dakota, after tracing him by telegraph from Massachu setts.

See moreSee less

The name of the new witness, the most important discovered since the beginning of the investigation, which has unearthed eleven victims of the female cornerer of the murder mar ket, has not been made public. But Sheriff Smutzer has in his possession a detailed outline of the confession Lamphere is said to have made. Witness to Return, Sheriff Smutzer is making strenu ous efforts to persuade the witness to return to Laporte and repeat the story Lamphere told him. He expects to hear definitely from the man soon.

Clipping to come

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

Two women resembling Mrs. Belle Gunness and a companion were detained in Syracuse after a tip from train passengers, but the woman identified herself as Mrs. L. A. Herron of Franklin, Pennsylvania, and was later cleared by police. Meanwhile in Laporte, a doctor who performed the autopsy on the body found in the fire ruins indicated it was not the body of Mrs. Gunness.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 9 May 1908 · page 1

has not been heard of since July 4, 190C. Laporte, Ind., May 12. Ray Lam phere has confessed that he caught Mrs. Belle Gunness red handed in the act of burying the dismembered body of Andrew Hegeleln, her last victim, by lantern light at midnight in her back door graveyard on "murder farm." The farm hand, under arrest on a charge of arson and murder in connection with the Gunness trage dies, made this confession to a friend whom the local authorities have lo cated in South Dakota, after tracing him by telegraph from Massachu setts.

See moreSee less

The name of the new witness, the most important discovered since the beginning of the investigation, which has unearthed eleven victims of the female cornerer of the murder mar ket, has not been made public. But Sheriff Smutzer has in his possession a detailed outline of the confession Lamphere is said to have made. Witness to Return, Sheriff Smutzer is making strenu ous efforts to persuade the witness to return to Laporte and repeat the story Lamphere told him. He expects to hear definitely from the man soon.

Clipping to come

Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.

A sister says Mrs. L.A. Herron, arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Belle Gunness, was actually a lifelong Pennsylvania resident whose husband worked for a Chicago flavoring company. Meanwhile in La Porte, Dr. H. H. Long states the body found in the Gunness fire ruins does not match Belle Gunness's size and weight, casting doubt on her death.

Santa Fe New Mexican · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Facts About Woman’s Body. The reports made to the coroner's Jury by Drs. J. L. Gray, H. H. Long, J. H. William Meyer and F. T. Wilcox revealed several circumstances, the existence of which has been carefully guarded from public knowledge. This is particularly true of the document signed by Dr. Gray and having to do with the adult body, supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness. \Jf*he new facts brought to light con 'Siita. ' 1 body are as follows: That the right arm is practically complete and that most of the left forearm and hand are in existence.

See moreSee less

Hitherto the complete arm had been known as the left and the right arm was supposed to have been completely consumed In the Are. That three rings, two containing in scriptlons, had been found on the hands. Puzzle of the Rings. The rings presented a puzzle which thus tar has not been solved. The in scriptions contain initials which are unaccountable except upon one hy pothesis, that being that the orna ments were the property of Peter Gun ness’ first wife, that he presented them to Mrs. Gunness, or that she obtained possession of them after his death and that Hhe wore them on the night when the house was burned.

Clipping to come

Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

This report provides a chronological summary of events in the Belle Gunness case, from the mysterious death of her first husband through the discovery of multiple bodies buried on her farm. It also describes the sheriff resuming excavation of the farmyard, attracting crowds, with digging to continue until the entire yard is examined.

Albuquerque Citizen · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SHERIFF RESUMES DIGGING ON FARM

Yard Is Examined. La Port. Ind.. May . Following Is a summary of the lnddents leading up to the disappearance of Mrs. Belle Gunness and the finding of a private graveyard in the barnyard on her farm, one mile north of this city: - v Max Albert Sorenson, Austin, 111., dies mysteriously (1900). His widow collect 18,500 Insurance. Peculiar fire destroys Austin home. Insurance collected. Widow buys candy store at Llzabeth street and Grand avenue, Chicago, with Insurance money. It burns. Insured Widow morrles Joe Gunness. Moves to La Porte farm.

See moreSee less

Adopt Jennie Olsen. Gunness killed (1904). Widow says meat cleaver fell on his head. Collects 3.r.00 Insurance. Ray Lamphere goes to work for Mrs. Gunness as nlred man. Widow seta dogs on visitors. Neighbors see lanterns on farm at 2 a. m. Jennie Olsen disappear. Real parents are told she Is In Los Angeles sehoo!, iiut -cannot t'ni her (1906). Andrew Helgpleln, Aberdeen, 8. D., answers matrimonial ad. and arrive at La Porte farm. Loans Mrs. Gunness 11,500. DIsappears with like amount in pocket. Widow say he went to Norway. Mrs. Gunness (1907) tells sheriff strange man killed a child in woods near farm. SherIff finds only empty grave. Ray Lamphere arrested for

See the clipping

Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

A timeline recaps the Gunness case (Helgelein's disappearance, the farmhouse fire, discovery of bodies, and Maxwell's confession to digging holes) before shifting to news that a Pennsylvania woman, Mrs. L. A. Herron, was detained in Syracuse on suspicion of being the fugitive Belle Gunness. Police and her sister confirmed she was not Gunness, clearing her of suspicion.

Albuquerque Citizen · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Mistaken Ideality. Syracuse, N. V.. May 9. To trav eling mi n who left New York on an eastbound train after 10 o'clock last night, ut Rochester reported to the police of that city that two women, one resembling Mrs. Relle Gunness of La Porte, Ind., the alleged murderess, were passengers on the trsln Two detective from Syracuse boarded the train here and arrested the women. The suspected woman said she was Mrs. L. A. Herron, that her, companion was her mother and that they were on their wav to New York.

See moreSee less

This morning, after a long interview with Mrs. Herron, Chief of Police Ca din said she did not answer the de scription and at the request of the woman he forwarded a telegram ad dressed to Mr. Charle P Rockefel ler of New York City. The mother gave her name a Mrs. Luey Rurton.

See the clipping

Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

A physician who performed an autopsy argues the body found in the burned Gunness home cannot be hers, citing mismatched weight and height. Meanwhile, digging resumes at the farm and a woman arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Belle Gunness is cleared after being identified as Mrs. L. A. Herron.

Albuquerque Citizen · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Porte, lnd., May it. The work of iliKging on the Gunnels furm was resume,! touay, only one man, how ever, being put to work. lp to 10 o'clock this morning there had been no new developments and no trace of add.tional bodies had been discov ered. Dr. H. H. Long, one of the pnysl clans who performed an autopsy on the body of the woman found In the ruins of the Gunness home after the fire, said today: In my opinion the body of the wo man found in the house inot that of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness because if is not correctly proportioned. It Is that of a rather plump woman of the same general contour of Mrs. Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 110 pounds Mrs. Gunness was literally a succes sion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds." The doctor added that he found the houy almost live Inches shorter than Mrs. Gunneas. He scorned the sug gestion that the missing head of the

See the clipping

Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

A humor column of brief jokes and witticisms includes one line noting that the 'Gunness woman who murdered nine men' lured them to her home via want-ad advertising. The rest of the piece is unrelated filler humor about golf, politics, marriage, and daily life.

Albuquerque Citizen · 9 May 1908 · page 2

DAILY SHORT STORIES

no alternative. Joe Bailey. United Slates senator from Texa. does not seem quite so deeD down or as tar out with the Democratic voters of his state as It has been runnriaH that he was. He had no trouble In winning out as a candidate to be one of the delegates at large from Texas to the Democratic national con vention at the recent primaries which were held In the Lone htar state. It Is real handy for a bunch of golf enthusiasts to be millionaires when their golf links are forty miles away.

See moreSee less

This condition of affairs prevails among a certain set in Chicago and they are going to build a private railroad forty miles long so that they can go to their links speedily and comfortably if rvovernor Johnson of Minnesota should happen to got the Democratic nomination for president he ought to poll a big vote among the baseball fan of the country. It develops that at one time he was a star amateur player and was offered a berth with one of the major league teams. This Is not a Joke. A waiter in a Brooklyn madhouse dropped dead th ther nla-ht when a man gave him a three dollar tip. There are likely man waiters ill these parts who would succumb if they got hold of a twenty-fly cent tip. It Days to advertise. The Gunness woman who murdered nine me, in Juced them to visit her home by advertising in a want column. What will Peary Is going to make another attempt to reach the pole, lie do when he gets there?

See the clipping

Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

A La Porte report describes how Mrs. Gunness attended church regularly after committing murders, appearing devout and respected by her pastor. Her sister, Mrs. Nellie Larson, recalls that Belle always valued money and luxury over genuine affection for men.

Albuquerque Citizen · 9 May 1908 · page 5

Gunness and the three little ones who met death with her finding the read iest sale. Mayor Darrow, a law partner or is. W. Worden, who is defending Ray Lamphere, said that the defense will start an investigation of the Pine Lake cemetery, an old burial ground about a mile from the Gunness farm. It Is the theory of the defense that Mrs. Gunness killed her children, placed the body of a large woman near them, set (ire to the house to cover up her crime and then lied. If It Is discovered that any of the graves in Pine Lake cemetery have been dls turbsd recently Mayor Darrow thinks that this theory will be more or less substantiated

Clipping to come

Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.

Mrs. Nellie Larson, Belle Gunness's sister, tells reporters her sister always cared more for wealth and luxury than for the men who provided it, even claiming Belle admitted she wouldn't have stayed with her first husband without his fine home. Larson also mentions estrangement from her sister over a family dispute.

Albuquerque Citizen · 9 May 1908 · page 5

The most definite information came from Olaf Llndboe, 610 La Salle av enue, Chicago. He said that hts broth er Thomas worked for Mrs. Gunness three years ago and that the last let ter which he had from him contained the information that Thomas Intended to marry his employer. Olaf wrote to the woman a little later and she replied that Thomas Llndboe had gone to St. Louis and that she had had no word from him. Olaf Llndboe viewed the unidentified corpses, but wa£ unable to find any likeness to his brother in the decayed bundles of bones and flesh. Crowds on All Trains.

Clipping to come

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A woman dressed in mourning was pulled from a train in Syracuse on suspicion of being fugitive murderess Belle Gunness of Laporte, Indiana. She became distraught but later claimed to be Mrs. Hearst of Chicago, wife of an oil dealer.

The Sun · 9 May 1908 · page 1

ARRESTED AS MRS GUNNESS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Detectives arrested a woman on a train, acting on tips from two traveling men who recognized her from newspaper photos resembling Mrs. Gunness. The arrested woman pleaded with detectives not to tell her sister in New York that she had been detained.

The Sun · 9 May 1908 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Witnesses describe a heavyset, veiled woman resembling pictures of Indiana murder suspects seen boarding a train. Meanwhile, excavations at Belle Gunness's property uncover three more skeletons, and Dr. H.H. Long disputes that the body found is actually Mrs. Gunness, citing incorrect proportions and weight discrepancies.

The Sun · 9 May 1908 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

Detectives in Syracuse mistakenly arrested Mrs. Cora Belle Herron and her elderly mother, believing Herron resembled the fugitive murderess Belle Gunness. The women were roughly treated before being released, and they plan legal action against the railroad and police.

The Evening World · 9 May 1908 · page 2

i POLICE ERR IN Mrs Gunness the fusltlve owner of t > lnporte murder farm was a stout woman with plenty of gold In her front t

See the clipping

Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.

A woman believed to be Belle Gunness, the alleged LaPorte, Indiana murderess, was reported passing through Syracuse, NY on an eastbound train at midnight. Detectives boarded the train and followed her to Utica.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 9 May 1908 · page 1

BELIEVE WOMAN MRS. GUNNESS

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

Dr. Henry Long of Laporte declares the burned torso found in the ruins is too short and too well-formed to be Belle Gunness, insisting she is not the victim. Meanwhile a woman arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Gunness is cleared, identified instead as Mrs. Cora Belle Heeron of Franklin, Pa.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Marion Daily Mirror · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Section One BODY FOUND NOT the Remains. Laporte, Ind., May 9. After core Cut and scientific examination of body now held by tho coroner and general ly supposed to bo that of Mrs, Belle Guinness, Dr. Henry (I. Long, of Laporto, today stated unqualifiedly that tho burned torso was not that of tho mistress of Laportc's ''Houso of llorrors." Ho said, "Tho lody at the morgue is well formed and rounded, Mrs. Gunlnncfcs' arms wcro not. Tho body Is, at .most, five inches shorter than tho body of Mrs. Gunness would bo under tho same circumstances Tho body Is Hint of a resort vlctlli It Is not that of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Guinness. I am siirc of that." Pranklln, Pa., May 'J. Mrs. C. 11. Hceron, arrsotcd In Syracuse ,N. Y., on suspicion of being Mrs. Belle Guinness, the Laporto arch-murder ess, lives 111 tho country about eight ,iinu f.. i,r ci,n vni,iou ,iit, her mothor, .Mrs. Lucy Burton, -.Mrs. Hceron was raared in this vlclnlty and Is well known hero. Her husband died In Uio south last winter and Mrs. Hcoron brought tho body hcro for burial. Slnco hen sho has been In Chicago much or the tlmo but had arranged lo spciul tho summer with her mothor.

See the clipping

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

Another skeleton was unearthed in the burned Gunness farmstead's private graveyard, bringing the total to ten bodies besides four found in the ruins. Coroner Mack believes as many as twenty-five more bodies may lie in the plot, as crowds and relatives of missing persons gather at the scene.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 9 May 1908 · page 1

IN THE RUINS THAT OF BELLE GUNNESS

Horrors." Laporte, Intl., May D.Tho discov ery of another human skeleton In the private graveyard of Mrs. Bolle Guinness 1ms Intensified tho excite ment over this most amazing mys tery. Coroner Mack declares ho bc Hovcs there arc at loast .twenty-live nioro bodies In tho ''death plot" sur rounding tho iburned homestead. This brings up to ton tho total of corpses and skeletons exhumed In thu yard, beside tho four bodies round In the ruins of tho farmhouse that burned April 2S. Coroner Mack at first announced that the gravo opener yesterday morning contained one completo cadaver and several bone: of a second skeleton, but this ovonlin lie said that what ho at first bellcvcf to bo In additional thigh and arm bones in reality belonged to the firs body recovered today.

See moreSee less

Names of mysterluosly mining mo.i mie mmlng to light hourly, and on every utuu incro are nrriviux men airwomen 4rom all parts ot tho

See the clipping

The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio

Authorities remain divided on whether Belle Gunness died in the fire or faked her death after killing another woman as a substitute body. Multiple reported sightings, a telephone call, and a witness statement about the children being whipped the day before the fire are detailed, while the prosecutor insists she is dead.

The Marion Daily Mirror · 9 May 1908 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon

A La Porte physician, Dr. Harry H. Long, examined the charred remains found in the Gunness farmhouse ruins and declared they are not those of Belle Gunness. He asserts she staged her own death using another woman's body and is convinced she is still alive.

Daily Capital Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 1

AS CLEVER RUSE DOCTOR'S EXAMINATION SHOWS THAT MHS. IIELLE GUNNESS HURXED HER CHILDREN WITH ANOTHER WOMAN. United Press Leased Wire.) La Port, Ind, Mny 9. Convincing

See the clipping

Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon

Investigators believe Belle Gunness staged a substitute woman's body to be mistaken for her own corpse and those of her children, aiming to escape suspicion. New evidence suggests she had an accomplice in Aberdeen, South Dakota, who helped mislead relatives of her victims, including sending a fake telegram about Bert Chase's death.

Daily Capital Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 1

GunneBs herself, to throw off suspU clon, thereby lending thoio who found tho corpses to tho bo'lef thnt thov wero those of Mr. Gunness nnd her three children. As tho result or Dr. Long's discovery the police nn thorltles mny send throughout tho country circulars benrlnir-n upturn of Mrs. Gunness nnd her description, Evldonco dlncoverod today Indi cates thnt Mrs. Gunness wns In league with someone In Abordeen, 8 D for tho purpose of misleading mo ruinuvcs or nor alleged victims as to tholr wherenbouts. Onp irntnnco Is cited in tho enso of Dert ChnBo, of Mlshawa, Ind., near La Porto, who disappeared eometlmo ago.

See moreSee less

Pert told his brother thnt he wns gelnp: to visit n "wealthy widow owning a flno farm in Indiana." That was the Inst Boon of him by his frlendi or rolntlves. Later tho brother recolved a telegram from Aberdeen, 8. D., nnnwwrlng thnt Bert Chnso had bfon killed In a rail road accident. Tho brother Imme diately wont to Aberdeen, wlmrn . dlcovered thnt tho nnme signed to the mossago was fictitious. Aslie Holga'lno, whoso brother's body was found In n sack In tho "murder grave yard," today received from .iieruoen additional lotto timt

See the clipping

Daily Capital Journal · Salem, Oregon

Dr. Long argues the morgue body cannot be Belle Gunness, citing manicured fingernails and a weight discrepancy (225 lbs vs. 150 lbs). Meanwhile, a woman arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Gunness is determined by police to actually be a Mrs. F.R. Herron of Chicago.

Daily Capital Journal · 9 May 1908 · page 1

ai auout it'll. Police lu Error. Syracuse, N. V., N. Y., Mny 0. ARer questioning tho womnn arrest ed early this, morning on a New York Contra' train on suspicion that sho was Mrs. UciiJah Ounno s, who Is said to have couvcrtod the grou'il near tho back door of her farm Ijoubo near La Porto. Ind., Into n gravo yard, Chief of Police Condln an nounced today thnt ho thinks she Is Mrs. F R. Horron of Chicago aa sho says. This Is Hio name alio gave tho detc-ctlveu when sho was arrested.

See moreSee less

Further proQf that she Is not Mrs. Gunness came from Franklin, Pa., in a telegram announcing that tho womnn in custody Is undoubtedly Mm, Herron, whose mother Jives 1 1 auraal SALEM, ORKGONV SATURDAY, MAY 0, 1008 , NO dl7 I J ' ' ' ' -Ml' J I ' i ' ' i l i i . i i i HI

See the clipping

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

A woman detained on a train in Utica, New York, and claiming to be Mrs. A. L. Herron of Chicago, was suspected of being Belle Gunness, but authorities increasingly believe she is not. Meanwhile, evidence from La Porte suggests the charred body found in the burned farmhouse is also not Gunness's remains.

East Oregonian : E.O · 9 May 1908 · page 1

MURDERESS IS STILL ALIVE

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

Dr. Long argues the woman's body found in the ruins is not Mrs. Gunness, citing manicured fingernails and a weight discrepancy of over 60 pounds. Evidence suggests Gunness had an Aberdeen, South Dakota accomplice who sent a fake death telegram to mislead relatives of victims, while suspect Ray Lamphere grows hysterical in custody.

East Oregonian : E.O · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Evidence jf Accomplice. Evidence has been discovered which Indicates that Mrs. Guinness had an accomplice In Aberdeen, South Dakota, for the purpose of misleading the relatives of her alleged victims as to their whereabouts. An Instance is given In the case of Bert Chase who lived as Mlshawaka, Ind. Chase told his brother he was going to visit a widow near La Porte. "That was the last seen -of him. The next they 'heard was a tele gram from Aberdeen, S. D., stating that Bert Chase had "been killed In a railroad accident.

See moreSee less

Investigation at Aberdeen by the brother of Chase re vealed the fact that the message was flrtltlous. Aslle Helglline, brother of Andrew, whose body was found in a sack In the "murder graveyard,' kiitr iiiuiuii r hi t , j u i u, muaj fi i tween Mrs. Guinness and Andrew. He began writing to Mrs. Guinness In August, 1906. age.

See the clipping

East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.

No new bodies were found at the Gunness farm, with searchers believing the excavation complete, while suspect Ray Lamphere reportedly became hysterical claiming Belle Gunness was haunting him. Separately, authorities in Utica, NY were trying to identify a woman found on a train who some believed might be the fugitive Belle Gunness.

East Oregonian : E.O · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Inmpliere Is llyslrrlcjil. No more bodies were found today and It Is thought that the last have been dug up. Ray Lamphere, arrested for cotnp pllclty In the burning of the Guinness home. Is hysterical today, crying out constantly that Mrs. GutJiness Is 'haunting him.

See the clipping

The News-Democrat · Providence, R.I.

A woman detained in Syracuse, NY as a possible Belle Gunness was identified as Mrs. Herron after her sister confirmed her identity via telegram, and she called the arrest an outrage. Meanwhile, the coroner in Indiana said he believed the ground beneath Gunness's former house might be filled with victims' bones, with excavation set to begin Monday.

The News-Democrat · 9 May 1908 · page 1

MRS. GUNNESS IS NOT ARRESTED

Wash., The mlaitter is being looked into Iby the police. The story of the many murders committed on mo man's farm a mile from La Porte, Ind., is familiar ,to most of our readers, we believe. The Gunness farm residence was recently burned and it was sup­ posed that Mrs. Gunness and her three children were cremated. Tihe cihildren

Clipping to come

The News-Democrat · Providence, R.I.

Former coroner Dr. Harry H. Long states the body found at the Gunness farm, believed to be hers, actually weighed 50 pounds less and was five inches shorter, insisting Mrs. Gunness is still alive. Separately, Ray Lamphere's attorney seeks a court order to end his client's enforced seclusion from visitors.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The News-Democrat · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Woman Eiiroute to 'Washington undoubtedly were burned, for their 'bodies were found in the ruins. The body of a woman wias also found in the ruins, but it foas been suggested that Mrs. Gunness, feiardmg detection of the murders she bias committed, placed a corpse in the house, then fired the building then made her es­ cape. Her rings were found in the ruins, ibut these could have been placed on tihe hands of tihe corpse. The murders committeed on the Gunness farm were the most atrocious in many years. The woman advertised for a husband and when she received lan answer she required tihe prosper tive husband to rake all the cash he could get together and visit her home.

See moreSee less

She would get her clutches on the intoney and the man would be see no more. She would explain 'tlhat he was the price ttoit mot suited and -had went away. Sevr eral victims disappeared mysteriously and aifter tihe ihiouse was burned the •premises were searched. In the barn ylard close to 'tihe (house item bodies Wave ailready been found, most of them buried in a pine coffin and in a nude condition. In nearly every case the 'bodies were out to pieces. Ray Lamiphere, a carpenter and gardner, who worked on the Gunness farm, has been arrested charged with murder, it being belieevd thlait he helped tihe wo­ man to kill the victims.

Clipping to come

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

A dispatch reports that tape measurements of the headless trunk found in the burned Gunness farmhouse show it belonged to a much smaller woman than Belle Gunness. Friends of Mrs. Gunness reportedly agree the body is not hers, fueling theories she faked her death and is still alive.

The Morning Tribune · 9 May 1908 · page 2

MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE

Laporte, Ind., May 7.—One more body has been disinterred on the Ouinness farm near here, making a total of six. It is believed that more

Clipping to come

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

This editorial piece discusses the Belle Gunness case in Indiana, framing her as commonly called a 'fiend in human form' but arguing fiendishness is actually a natural element of human nature not yet eliminated by evolution. The writer suggests civilization's veneer over basic brutality remains thin, using Gunness as a stark example.

The Morning Tribune · 9 May 1908 · page 4

Perslateaee ef the Fiendish. 1 his Gunness woman out in Indiana, into whose miserable life in its every shocking corner the merciless searchlight of publicity has now been suddenly

See the clipping

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

An editorial reflects on the La Porte case, briefly entertaining the theory that Gunness merely sold cadavers to medical students, but rejecting it given the horrific state of the exhumed bodies. The writer muses on the exceptional, almost inhuman cruelty required to lure suitors with promises of wealth only to kill them for their savings.

The Morning Tribune · 9 May 1908 · page 4

THE LA PORTE MYSTERY

The record la not devoid of cases as horrible, as shockingly abnormal, as thia, but they are rare. The moat brutal man will generally shrink from killing, and If he kill In passion, in self-defence, or for gain, will be ever apprehensive of discov ery, a prey to fear If not remorse. We j scarcely believe now all the tales of murI der told about the Romans and the de generates of the Middle Ages, Yet the 1 worst of them is not worse than thia 1 story of the Indiana widow, who called ; herself rich, enticed suitors to her house i with their savings in their pockets, and | then killed them or had them killed.

See moreSee less

The I supposed murderess and her victims acorn J to be In a class apart from the general ity of mankind. If the widow of Laporte was really what ahe now seems to be she had little or none of the attributes which distinguish man from the beasts; she must have been a stranger to and sentiment, devoid alike of pit«y and tsar, unmoved by the sight of blond, and free from any sense of responsibility. Yet she was a mother and, presumably, fond of her children.

See the clipping

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

Detectives in Utica, NY detained a woman from an eastbound train who matched descriptions of fugitive Belle Gunness. The woman identified herself as Mrs. L. A. Herron, a Chicago widow, and produced some corroborating letters, though officers remained uncertain of her true identity.

The Morning Tribune · 9 May 1908 · page 1

DETENTION IN THE - DETECTIVES TAKE PASSENGER ON NEW YORK CENTRAL TRAIN EASTBOUND INTO CUSTODY - WOMAN REPORTED TO RESEMBLE DESCRIPTION OF MRS. BELLA GUNNESS, BUT CLAIMS TO BE MRS. L. A. HERRON OF CHICAGO - ANOTHER BODY EXHUMED AT

OTHER BODY EXHUMED AT Utica, N. Y., May 9.—The Syracuse po lice took a woman from a train reaching here this morning at 1:30 from the West on suspicion that she might be Mrs. Bella the alleged Laporte murderess. The officers were informed from Roches ter that the woman answered the descrip tion of MTs. Gunness and they boarded the train at Syracuse. The woman was asleep and the train pulled out while she was dressing and the officers came on here. Un arriving at this station the woman said that she was Mrs.

See moreSee less

L. A. Herron and that she was a widow from Chicago on the way to New York to visit her sister, She said that she had been visiting her old home in Franklin, Pa., and that she took the train at Ashtabula, Ohio. She resembles in many particulars the pictures published of Mrs. Gunness, but the ocers are In doubt as to her being the woman wanted.

See the clipping

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

Excavation at the Gunness farm uncovered a tenth body, a poorly preserved corpse showing signs of crude dismemberment, found about four feet below the surface. Large crowds continued to gather at the farm, prompting liverymen to run a regular omnibus service from Laporte.

The Morning Tribune · 9 May 1908 · page 1

ANOTHER BODY EXHI MED. Tenth Found to Date on the Gunness Farm. Imports. Infl . May B.—One more body nas added to the death roll of the Bella Gunness farm to-day, making a total of 10 corpses and skeletons exhumed in the yard besides the four bodies found in the ruins of the farmhouse, which was burned on April 28. Coroner Mack at first announced that the grave opened this morning contained one complete cadaver and several Irones of a second skeleton, but this evening he said what he had first believed to be additional thigh and aim bones, belong to the first body re covered to-day.

See moreSee less

Resumption of excavation at the Gun nels farm to-day again drew an immense crowd of spectators. The rush of visitors has become so great that liverymen have established a regular omnibus line from Laporte to the farm. Hundreds of men and women made the trip by this means

See the clipping

The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.

A tenth body, likely a woman's based on shoes and purse remnants, is exhumed from the Gunness farm, showing cruder dismemberment than previous finds. Meanwhile, investigators seize a trunk containing Mrs. Gunness's letters to Lamphere and women's rings, as Lamphere hints he may break his silence about the case.

The Morning Tribune · 9 May 1908 · page 1

ANOTHER BODY EXHUMED

at the farm Prosecutor Smith, aided by Deputy Sheriff Roy Marr was collecting additional evidence concerning Lam phere’s alleged participation In the deaths of Helgeleln. Mrs. Ounness and her three children. Lamphere is accused of first de gree murder because of the death of Mrs. Gunness and her three children.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A trunk belonging to hired man Ray Lamphere was found to contain letters from Mrs. Gunness, suggesting he had knowledge of her activities. Meanwhile more bones were dug up in the farm's barnyard, and a woman resembling Belle Gunness was detained by detectives in Utica, New York, after being arrested under the name Mrs. A. L. Hearon.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1908 · page 1

LAMPHERE HAD KNOWLEDGE OF WOMAN'S DEEDS

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Detectives in Utica arrested a woman matching Belle Gunness's description traveling under the name Mrs. A.L. Hearon. Meanwhile in Laporte, authorities seized a trunk left by suspect Ray Lamphere containing letters written to him by Mrs. Gunness urging his return to the farm.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Authorities seized a trunk containing letters from Belle Gunness to Ray Lamphere, written after he took a job at a farm near Springville, urging him to return and bring a wealthy sweetheart. The trunk also held women's rings of unusual size, possibly belonging to Gunness, while Lamphere hinted he might soon speak about his case.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The article reports Lamphere's threats to extort money from Belle Gunness by claiming knowledge of her crimes, including the death of Andrew Helgelein. Prosecutor Smith's theory suggests Gunness had Lamphere arrested and declared insane to silence him, which led Lamphere to seek revenge.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1908 · page 5

LAMPHERE HAD KNOWLEDGE OF WOMAN'S DEEDS

MRS. GUNNESS HAD ACCOMPLICE Evidence Unearthed That In diana Borgia Did Not Work Alone in Luring Victims to Their Doom, By Hurninx .lourmil Hurclul I mttnl Wirs l

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Prosecuting Attorney Smith theorizes that Lamphere knew how Andrew Helgelein was killed and tried to use that knowledge to extort money from Mrs. Gunness, leading her to have him arrested multiple times; in revenge, Lamphere allegedly set the fire that killed her and the children, though without intending their deaths. A witness also recounts seeing two mysterious strangers at the farm before Jennie Olson's disappearance.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1908 · page 5

KNOWLEDGE OF WOMAN'S

MRS. GUNNESS HAD ACCOMPLICE Evidence Unearthed That In diana Borgia Did Not Work Alone in Luring Victims to Their Doom, By Hurninx .lourmil Hurclul I mttnl Wirs l

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A witness named Mrs. Greening testified to the prosecutor that her son Emil, who worked at the Gunness farm, saw two strange visitors the night before Jennie Olson disappeared—one a man dressed in women's clothing. Mrs. Gunness explained them as a professor and his wife from a California school, and all three reportedly left on a late train; separately, suspicion arose over the timing of her first husband Sorenson's death relative to his insurance policies.

The Salt Lake Herald · 9 May 1908 · page 5

KNOWLEDGE OF WOMAN'S

Laporto, Ind., May 11 Donlala hy Laporto officials that tho Rev. Dr. B. A. Sehcll had revealed to thorn tho substanco of .his conver sations with Lamphcro, and tho discovery of ovldenco Uiat Mrs. Bella Gunness was aided by an ecoompllco In luring nor victims to the farm, wcro tho chief devcl. opments In the case. In addition II. W. Wordon, at torney for tho prisoner, Issued a formal statement thai, ho had glv. en hts client strict injunctions not to discuss itho charges against him and concluding: Tha-fact .JsthatUunpUrrelias jiever-rnddo a confession lo any ono and never will.

See moreSee less

Ho luia nothing to confess." TJo ovldonco regarding tho aids of (Mrs. Gunness enmo In a letter from a resident of Cleveland addressed to tho local chief of pollcoa Clinton Coohrano. It told of tho writer having mot a stranger In that city Inst August who gavo him a photograph of "a rloh widow who resided In Laporte, ' and tried to poreuodo "him to como hero to see tho woman. Tho photograph is a fairly good .likeness of Mrs. Gunnooa and was ovldontly takon some tlmo ago. It Is a small nega tive wWch acorns to (hivo been rut from a photograph, tho arm

Clipping to come

The Free Lance · Fredericksburg, Va.

Investigators report finding remains of four additional persons in the yard of Mrs. Gunness' farm, with evidence suggesting bodies were shipped from Chicago to La Porte. Witnesses describe trunks being carried to the house and men digging in the barnyard under her direction, while her sister calls her 'crazy for money.'

The Free Lance · 9 May 1908 · page 4

| The best clew which has yet been | found came to light immediately fol | lowing the discovery of the last three bodies. John A. Welker, a liveryman, and Leo Wade, his employe, told of having carted heavy trunks to the Gunness farm in the summer and au tumn of 1906. Clyde Sturgis, employ #d by Foster & Degarmo, another liv ery concern, remembered that he took two smaller trunks to the place about a year ago. In addition, several heavy boxes, marked variously “potatoes” and “wall paper,” were carted to the house at dierent times.

See moreSee less

If these trunks contained dismem bered corpses, disposal of the bodies at the farm would have been compara tively simple. Joseph Maxson, man of all work at the Gunness place since {last February; Roy Lamphere, the prisoner in the case, and Fred Brick man, a neizl:bor, have told of digging trenches in tie barnyard at Mrs. Gun | ness’ directions. ————— Nrz, Gunness Was Crazv Cor Money sae’ To NHN AED SoPdy WE - WEOMECY Chicago, May 7.—Mrs. Nellie Lar

See the clipping

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A woman believed to be Belle Gunness, accused of a dozen or more murders at her LaPorte, Indiana home, was reportedly arrested by Syracuse detectives on a train. She was taken to Utica, the train's next stop, after detectives acted on word from LaPorte authorities, reportedly en route to New York.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Alexandria Gazette · 9 May 1908 · page 2

Minnesota Democratic Convention. Mra Gunness. This man claimed that Chicago INSIST neaoti Uils fall It ho Is. nominated nt Denver. National Committeeman Hudson would nolthon atllrm nor deny that

Clipping to come

Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.

A La Porte physician who knew Belle Gunness examined the charred torso held by the coroner and declared it was not her remains. Separately, Pinkerton detectives found letters Gunness wrote to farmhand Ray Lamphere hidden in a trunk, prompting him to say he might confess.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Alexandria Gazette · 9 May 1908 · page 2

Berry of TuHcola, 111. After having killed those she lared to her farm,. Mrs. Gunness showed remarkable Ingenuity in disposing of their bodies. The shears nhat were found were bent and twist ad so that they became hnndy nir ?lcal instruments. In the us hog alEj were found two surgeon's knives, ' nd from the manner In which uici.1 of the bodies wero cut up it is evi dent the woman had acquired a fair knowledge of anatomical surgery. The report of the physicians who erformed autopsies on the bodies .

See moreSee less

ifl were found on the Gunness farm was made public. The autop sy on the body of the woman sup nosed to have been Mrs. Gunness loes not establish definitely It was ;he. Three rings were found on the angers of one hand. Two of the .-lngs bore Inscriptions, but the let ierlng only added to the myBtery as to whether Mrs. Gunness died in the flames. The inscription on one "l the rings was "P. S. to J. 8., Au tust 22, '01." and the other, "P. 0. J. S., 2-5, '95." Mrs. Ounness's husband was Peter Gunness, but the fllcials were unable to learn who T. S." and "J. S." were. What appeared to be a gold tooth ilao was found among the ashes. The finding of the supposed tooth used ft report to spread that all toubt as to Mrs. Gunness having 41ed In the flames had vanished. The "tooth" was sent to a local dentist tor Investigation and he reported that the find was not a human molar ut a piece of gilded wood. The theory that Mrs. Gunness set upon her victims when their backs vere turned toward ber and stabbed hem Is accepted by the police. No -sound waa found upon the body of ielgelin, but as he undoubtedly put p a hard fight against being killed t Is believed the woman finally over Towered him and covered his face :1th a handkerchief saturated with .ihloroform. An interesting sidelight on the haracter of Mrs. Gunness was hrown by Mrs. C. O. Lapham of La Wt. She was a neighbor of the ,'unnesB woman for six years, and n that time she only visited her ?nce. When she reached the house, lrs. Lapham said, she saw Mrs, Gun ness seated in an armchair near the jpen window. A strong breeze blew ilde the folds of a thin house dress thich the woman wore and revealed . wide belt about her body. The elt contained pouches of various ilaes and sheaths which seemed to iv been constructed for knives. The virand Jury In all probability Ttll hear the charges against Ray "amphere, formerly a hired man on ie Gunness place. The Investiga tion wus postponed several days ago til May 18, but the authorities ba 've they have sufficient evidence row on which to obtain Indictments ixt murder and arson agaliiBt Lam-.-fcere.

Clipping to come

Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.

Four more bodies are exhumed from the Gunness farm, bringing the total to fourteen victims. Liverymen recall delivering heavy trunks and boxes to the property, suggesting victims' remains were shipped from Chicago, while investigators still believe Gunness herself died in the house fire with her children.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Spirit of the Age · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SHIPPED IN TRUNKS

Berry of TuHcola, 111. After having killed those she lared to her farm,. Mrs. Gunness showed remarkable Ingenuity in disposing of their bodies. The shears nhat were found were bent and twist ad so that they became hnndy nir ?lcal instruments. In the us hog alEj were found two surgeon's knives, ' nd from the manner In which uici.1 of the bodies wero cut up it is evi dent the woman had acquired a fair knowledge of anatomical surgery. The report of the physicians who erformed autopsies on the bodies .

See moreSee less

ifl were found on the Gunness farm was made public. The autop sy on the body of the woman sup nosed to have been Mrs. Gunness loes not establish definitely It was ;he. Three rings were found on the angers of one hand. Two of the .-lngs bore Inscriptions, but the let ierlng only added to the myBtery as to whether Mrs. Gunness died in the flames. The inscription on one "l the rings was "P. S. to J. 8., Au tust 22, '01." and the other, "P. 0. J. S., 2-5, '95." Mrs. Ounness's husband was Peter Gunness, but the fllcials were unable to learn who T. S." and "J. S." were. What appeared to be a gold tooth ilao was found among the ashes. The finding of the supposed tooth used ft report to spread that all toubt as to Mrs. Gunness having 41ed In the flames had vanished. The "tooth" was sent to a local dentist tor Investigation and he reported that the find was not a human molar ut a piece of gilded wood. The theory that Mrs. Gunness set upon her victims when their backs vere turned toward ber and stabbed hem Is accepted by the police. No -sound waa found upon the body of ielgelin, but as he undoubtedly put p a hard fight against being killed t Is believed the woman finally over Towered him and covered his face :1th a handkerchief saturated with .ihloroform. An interesting sidelight on the haracter of Mrs. Gunness was hrown by Mrs. C. O. Lapham of La Wt. She was a neighbor of the ,'unnesB woman for six years, and n that time she only visited her ?nce. When she reached the house, lrs. Lapham said, she saw Mrs, Gun ness seated in an armchair near the jpen window. A strong breeze blew ilde the folds of a thin house dress thich the woman wore and revealed . wide belt about her body. The elt contained pouches of various ilaes and sheaths which seemed to iv been constructed for knives. The virand Jury In all probability Ttll hear the charges against Ray "amphere, formerly a hired man on ie Gunness place. The Investiga tion wus postponed several days ago til May 18, but the authorities ba 've they have sufficient evidence row on which to obtain Indictments ixt murder and arson agaliiBt Lam-.-fcere.

Clipping to come

Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.

Draymen recall delivering heavy, corded trunks and boxes to the Gunness home, with two trunks still held at a Chicago express office. Witnesses describe Mrs. Gunness's secretive, strong-handed behavior with the trunks, while workers recall digging trenches in the barnyard at her direction.

Spirit of the Age · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SHIPPED IN TRUNKS

Berry of TuHcola, 111. After having killed those she lared to her farm,. Mrs. Gunness showed remarkable Ingenuity in disposing of their bodies. The shears nhat were found were bent and twist ad so that they became hnndy nir ?lcal instruments. In the us hog alEj were found two surgeon's knives, ' nd from the manner In which uici.1 of the bodies wero cut up it is evi dent the woman had acquired a fair knowledge of anatomical surgery. The report of the physicians who erformed autopsies on the bodies .

See moreSee less

ifl were found on the Gunness farm was made public. The autop sy on the body of the woman sup nosed to have been Mrs. Gunness loes not establish definitely It was ;he. Three rings were found on the angers of one hand. Two of the .-lngs bore Inscriptions, but the let ierlng only added to the myBtery as to whether Mrs. Gunness died in the flames. The inscription on one "l the rings was "P. S. to J. 8., Au tust 22, '01." and the other, "P. 0. J. S., 2-5, '95." Mrs. Ounness's husband was Peter Gunness, but the fllcials were unable to learn who T. S." and "J. S." were. What appeared to be a gold tooth ilao was found among the ashes. The finding of the supposed tooth used ft report to spread that all toubt as to Mrs. Gunness having 41ed In the flames had vanished. The "tooth" was sent to a local dentist tor Investigation and he reported that the find was not a human molar ut a piece of gilded wood. The theory that Mrs. Gunness set upon her victims when their backs vere turned toward ber and stabbed hem Is accepted by the police. No -sound waa found upon the body of ielgelin, but as he undoubtedly put p a hard fight against being killed t Is believed the woman finally over Towered him and covered his face :1th a handkerchief saturated with .ihloroform. An interesting sidelight on the haracter of Mrs. Gunness was hrown by Mrs. C. O. Lapham of La Wt. She was a neighbor of the ,'unnesB woman for six years, and n that time she only visited her ?nce. When she reached the house, lrs. Lapham said, she saw Mrs, Gun ness seated in an armchair near the jpen window. A strong breeze blew ilde the folds of a thin house dress thich the woman wore and revealed . wide belt about her body. The elt contained pouches of various ilaes and sheaths which seemed to iv been constructed for knives. The virand Jury In all probability Ttll hear the charges against Ray "amphere, formerly a hired man on ie Gunness place. The Investiga tion wus postponed several days ago til May 18, but the authorities ba 've they have sufficient evidence row on which to obtain Indictments ixt murder and arson agaliiBt Lam-.-fcere.

Clipping to come

Spirit of the Age · Woodstock, Vt.

A news digest reports that five bodies were found buried in a yard at Laporte, Indiana, with authorities believing seven more people may have met similar fates. Mrs. Belle Gunness, thought to have died in a fire with three children, is now suspected of being involved in the killings.

Spirit of the Age · 9 May 1908 · page 1

raise a like sum. Four persons were killed by the explosion of n kitchen gas stove In a tenement at St. Johnsbury, Vt. Three more corpses were found on the farm of Mrs. Delia Guinness, at Laporte, Ind. The Euclid Avenue Trust Com pany, of Cleveland, O., has made an assignment. The oil-tank steamer Washtenaw went ashore off Monmouth Heach, N. J.

Clipping to come

The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.

No further bodies were found on the Gunness farm, with officials believing the excavation complete. Ray Lamphere, held for complicity in burning the Gunness home, reportedly became hysterical, crying that Mrs. Gunness was haunting him.

The Spokane Press · 9 May 1908 · page 1

SHE HAUNTS HIM

robbed a safe In a baggage car of a Denver und Rio Grande train. The shed on the Guinness arm. at Laporte, Ind., containing the remains of the victims was broken Into anj the bodies seriously disturbed. Joe Qarcia. alias Joe Cordova, whe

Clipping to come

The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.

A woman detained in Utica, N.Y., claiming to be Mrs. A. L. Herarson of Chicago, is investigated as a possible match for Belle Gunness. Meanwhile in LaPorte, Harry H. Long claims his scientific examination shows the burned body found in the Gunness house ruins is not hers, suggesting she may still be alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Spokane Press · 9 May 1908 · page 1

CATCH WOMAN THOUGHT TO BE MURDERESS

."tftwelve ox the crimes. Until this time it shad been accepted as true that she and tiher three children had met death In tie ,^£lie that destroyed their home, but now «fthe suspicion arises that the bodies that •Were found in the smoldering ruins •Were bropght from some hospital or •^nodical school for the purpose of cre ating the belief that Mrs. Gunness and 'Sier family had passed from existence. Xtfwt Of Known Victim*, Hclgelem, Andrew, 40 years old, bach

Clipping to come

The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.

Investigators note the manicured fingernails and lighter weight of the burned body suggest it is not Belle Gunness, who weighed far more. New evidence points to an Aberdeen, S.D. accomplice who sent fake death telegrams to mislead victims' relatives, while a Syracuse arrest of a suspected Gunness is also being discounted.

The Spokane Press · 9 May 1908 · page 1

Widow marries Joe Gunness. Moves to Laporte farm. Adopts Jennie Olsen. Gunness killed (100-1). Widow says meat cleaver fell on his head. Collects $3,500 insurance. -. /, Ilay L»ampihere goes to work for Mrs. Gunness as hired man, Widow pets dogs on visitors. Neighbors see Jsmterns on farm at 2 a. m. Jennie Olson disappears. Real .parents are told sJi'e is in Los Angeles school, but can not find her (190G). Andrew Helgelein, Aberdeen (S. D.), answers matriih&nial ad, and arrives at Laporte. farm. Loans Mrs. Gunness $1, 500., DisaiX{Vears with like amount in (pocket. Widow says ihe went to Norway. MrS. Gunness (1907) tells sheriff strange man killed a child iti woods near farm. Sheriff finds only empty grave. Ray 'Lamphere. arrested for annoying

Clipping to come

The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.

Dr. Long of Laporte examines the charred remains and declares they cannot be Belle Gunness, citing manicured fingernails and incorrect body weight as evidence. Police circulate her description nationwide while a woman matching her description is detained in Utica, NY for identification.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening Statesman · 9 May 1908 · page 1

. p t . |- ( ; |~d.. May y.—Convincing tuat the body of the woman the ruins of the Gunness ~ ■ , is not that of Mrs. Beulah W sis pronounced today by Dr. ;i Long of Laporte, who made . , xamination of the c harred I is examination proves the thai of the supposed murL ng declares be knew Mrs. , . well and is convinced she is : believed thai the body found was . m ..j a nd the fire started in or • , [hi' .\ off suspicion.

See moreSee less

: result of Long's discovery, the have wired descriptions of Mr-. . , ... . •! over the country • , principal reasons for Dr. tng ' f i„ |i, 1 <.hai the body of the wor n. f oU i i( i in the rains of the Gunness ... [ S not thai of .Mrs. Gunness, is th ■ ■ 1 • the finger nails of the deal , :; tre manicured. Long is P 'sltlve that Mrs. Gun nt-ver seen the inside of a mani ns rler Mrs. Gunness weighed - pounds, while the body of ... an found could not have Pc :e N:.b Strange Woman. today to identify the wom i, n the New York Central s M - Belle Gunness. the alleged rte, InJ., murderess whose back • ; ... „ ~.averted into a private v; rd for lie:- supposed victims. ■ - L-ai«] she has bei v recognised by . : who claims to have known the omaa before she became Mrs. Gun ■ l; may be necessary to take her ick to Lj Porte for complete Identifi ti n, If in the meantime she does net .ye that she is n it Mrs. Pell Gun --. Thf man v. ho recognised her got

See the clipping

The Evening Statesman · Walla Walla, Wash.

Police determine that the woman detained on a train at Utica is not Belle Gunness but a Mrs. Harmon of Chicago, confirmed by her mother in Pennsylvania. Separately, investigators uncover evidence that Gunness had an accomplice in Aberdeen, S.D., who sent fake telegrams to mislead relatives of her victims.

The Evening Statesman · 9 May 1908 · page 1

An Accomplice In Aberdeen. uA PORTE, May 9. —Evidence has b.-on discovered which indicates that Mr. Gunness had an accomplice in Aberdeen, S. P.. for the purpose of misleading relatives of th" alleged vic times as to their' whereabout"*. An instance is given in the case of Part chase who lived at Mishawaka. Ind. Chase told his brother t.iat he was goin? to visit a widow near LaPorte, That was the last seen of him. The next heard was a telegram from Aberdeen, S. P.. stating that Pert Cnase had been killed in a railway ac cident.

See moreSee less

Investigation at Aberdeen by the brother of chase, revealed the fact that the message was fictitious. Aslie Helgelline's brother, Andrew, whose body was found in a sack In the •'murder giaveyard" today re ceived more letters which passed be tween Mrs. Gunness and Andrew. He began writing Mrs. Gunness in Au gust, P*o«. _____ ted up that will provide for the car rvir : of all in a comfortable manneH. The talf hour service will last all af ternncii and evening. I r the hist time the "Shoot the chutes" will be opened to the public and those who have not yet been treat ed to that < xhilirating joy will have an < pportunty to experience it. The "Ocean Wave" and other attractions will be open as w* ll and Prof. Smalley will make a balloon ascension during the afternoon. No admission will be ttaiged to the park grounds.

See the clipping

The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

A woman arrested on a New York Central train near Syracuse was suspected of being Belle Gunness, the Laporte murderess, but was released after her identity as Mrs. L.A. Herron was confirmed. Relatives and business associates corroborated her true identity, clearing her of suspicion.

The Daily Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 1

ARREST WAS ON TRAIN.

NEW YORK. May 9?Mrs. Charles P. Rockefeller, of this city, is a sis-' tor of Mrs. L. A. Ilerron. detained at] Syracuse and suspected or being -Mrs.! Gunness. She sahl Mrs. Horron llv od raott or her lire in Franklin Fa !

See the clipping

The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.

Digging resumed at the Gunness farm but no new bodies were found by noon. Dr. Long, who performed the autopsy, testified that the body thought to be Mrs. Gunness was actually a lighter, shorter woman, while Lamphere's attorney denied reports of a confession or incriminating letters.

The Daily Telegram · 9 May 1908 · page 1

' N. B. Worden. attorney for Ray Lamphcre. who is In jail In connec tion with tho murders, asserted to day that there Is no truth in the statement that Lanipherc desired to confess or that he had anything to c.infess. Ho denied that any trunk wa.v found containing letters written by Lamphcro to Mrs. Gunness.

See the clipping

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

Detectives in Syracuse arrested a woman on a train after travelers reported she resembled Belle Gunness, the alleged La Porte murderess. She identified herself as Mrs. L. A. Harron, and police determined she did not match the wanted description after interviewing her and her sister.

The Laramie Republican · 9 May 1908 · page 1

WOMAN ARRESTED IN THE LAPORTE AFFAIR TAKEN FROM TRAIN AT SYRACUSE BY TWO DETECTIVES OF THAT CITY ON INFORMATION RECEIVED

The Gunnesa case in Indiana has been taking up considerable space in the papers lately Mrs Gunness is i supposed to have murdered at least ten persons and buried the bodies in her barn yard The excitement is great and thousands of people are visit ing the premises to seek informa tion This issue of the Gazette contains the announcement of Mr W F Templeton for the of fice of Constable of Precinct 8 Lavaca County Mr Templeton is a man who is well qualified to fill the offico and if elected he promises his best services to tho people of the pre cinct He announces subject to the Democratic primaries in Ju ly Remember his candidacy when you come to vote Mr V7 E Rabb comes be fore the neople of Lavaca county this week as a candidate for rep rpsontativo to thd 01st Legislrt

Clipping to come

The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.

Mrs. Harron, arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Belle Gunness, is ordered released by Chicago's police chief as having no connection to the case. Meanwhile in La Porte, digging resumes without new discoveries, and Dr. H. H. Long states the burned body found is too small and not the right build to be Mrs. Gunness, dismissing fire as the explanation for the missing head.

The Laramie Republican · 9 May 1908 · page 1

The Gunnesa case in Indiana has been taking up considerable space in the papers lately Mrs Gunness is i supposed to have murdered at least ten persons and buried the bodies in her barn yard The excitement is great and thousands of people are visit ing the premises to seek informa tion This issue of the Gazette contains the announcement of Mr W F Templeton for the of fice of Constable of Precinct 8 Lavaca County Mr Templeton is a man who is well qualified to fill the offico and if elected he promises his best services to tho people of the pre cinct He announces subject to the Democratic primaries in Ju ly Remember his candidacy when you come to vote Mr V7 E Rabb comes be fore the neople of Lavaca county this week as a candidate for rep rpsontativo to thd 01st Legislrt

Clipping to come

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

Police in Syracuse arrested Mrs. Cora Holle Herron, mistaking her for the LaPorte murderess Belle Gunness, causing a sensation before her identity was confirmed. Outraged by the false arrest and notoriety, Herron threatened a $50,000 lawsuit against the city and refused to release police from liability.

CorrectionThis set right 12 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 9 May 1908, New-York Tribune, 9 May 1908, The Washington Herald, 9 May 1908, The Washington Herald, 9 May 1908, The Washington Herald, 9 May 1908, The Washington Times, 9 May 1908, Evening Times-Republican, 9 May 1908, The Detroit Times, 9 May 1908, Tonopah Daily Bonanza, 9 May 1908, The Salt Lake Herald, 9 May 1908, Alexandria Gazette, 9 May 1908, The Spokane Press, 9 May 1908.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 10 May 1908 · page 1

AWFUL BLUNDER OF SYRACUSE POLICE

v'OI, XTV. Syracuse, XY„ May Mrs. Cura Holle Herron, tha handsome inking widow of a prominen; ('hi.-ngi lue-i tiess lnait. v. ho was ar, >• ( under sensational eircumstauces early ihis morning as Hollo dimness, ihe ma.s :er murderess of LaPorte, Ind., left hero fur New York at 1 o'clock this afternoon. Angry and outraged over her arrest and the notoriety brought upon her by the necessity of establish ing her identity. Mrs. Herron abso lutely refused to sign a release re lieving the police of the responsibil ity of her arrest, and detention and de clared that she would immediately consul!

See moreSee less

lawyers in New York and bring suit against, the police officials and tile city of Syracuse for Ihe blun der. Fifty thousand dollars was named by Mrs. Herron as the sum she believes she is entitled to for ftfflse arrest. The rn.-v. she says, is aggra vated by the fact that her aged ] I' -arst N v. s Siji i-i; :<< : .1. (I. ;,ii'.!;r_ t'olma Arena, San Fram-isco. May 9.- -Stan 11 ;• Ketch-dl of Mon:ana libs af'.ernoon knock. I 0.1 Jack (Twin) Sullivan in 1 !<•• Hv-'niici ii round of fighting in tl: • open air 1 healer. Ivetcliell had the bes;, of the fight throughout a; 1 put out his opponent by a success - n of body punches. The vk o becomes the middle • weight champion of the world. Sulli van put up a game light, but tin* fas: fighting of Ketchell in the las: four rounds w.i • more than lie could stand. I11 the twentieth round, when knock out occur: 1. .Tack danced around in a

See the clipping

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.

Investigators plan to use $300 worth of gold from Belle Gunness's teeth to determine if a headless corpse found in her burned home was hers. An experienced miner will sift through the ashes at the farm, while searchers continue digging up the property without finding additional bodies that day.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Waterbury Evening Democrat, 9 May 1908, The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram, 9 May 1908, Rock Island Argus, 9 May 1908, Alexandria Gazette, 9 May 1908.

Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Gold May Lead to Identification I I learn News Special to the Graphic LaPorte, Ind., May 9.—Three hun dred dollars worth of gold which Mrs. Belle Gunness wore in her teeth will be the means for the police to reach the conclusion whether or not the headless corpse found in the burned ruins of her home was that of then master murderess. An experienced ! miner will sift the ashes at the poijit of discovery, using ail tests to dis cover the trace of melted gold. Mo no lew al\ bodies were discovered today, though a good part of the murder gar den was dug up.

See moreSee less

Two Night Riders Shot By Farmer Hearst News Special to the Graphic Lexington, May 9.—The killing two ’ negro “night riders” at Kirksville. j Ky., 10 days ago was just learned to- ( day. The negroes are part of a band ' which scraped the tobacco beds of a Kirksville farmer. They called the1 farmer to his door and he responded ! with a fusillade One white man had his arm shot off. \ WL. Dewoody will leave this week ; jfor Little Rock, where he will attend /the annual meeting of the State Phar maceutical Association and with othi ers, from this city, will make a deter-; mined effort to get the next convenj tion for Pino Bluff.

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Authorities in La Porte remain uncertain whether Belle Gunness is dead, planning to use a gold miner to sift cellar debris for melted gold from her false teeth to confirm the headless body is hers. Lamphere's trunk and letters from Gunness are being examined for evidence he was an accomplice.

CorrectionThis set right 9 earlier articles: The Ketchikan Miner, 9 May 1908, The Gazette, 9 May 1908, The Washington Herald, 9 May 1908, Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier, 9 May 1908, Daily Kennebec Journal, 9 May 1908, The Diamond Drill, 9 May 1908, The Diamond Drill, 9 May 1908, The Beatrice Daily Express, 9 May 1908, Spirit of the Age, 9 May 1908.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

IS FOUL MURDERESS IN LAND OF LIVING?

Authorities Are Still Puzzled Over the Guinness Case At La Porte GOLD MIR WILL TRY TO PROVE WOMAN'S DEATH Headless Body Is Declared To Be Someone Else Than Mrs. Guinness and Many OtherVbofile ‘Are Said To Be Missing. La Porte, Ind., May 9.—(Special.)—La Porte settled down today after the ex citement following the Syracuse arrest, 1 to digging in the garden grave yard of Sheriff Sinutzer is preparing for a test on Monday such as lias never be fore been made in the investigation of any murder case. It will bo in the ef- , fort to account for the missing head of the body now in the morgue be lieved to be the bedy of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness. The sheriff lias employed an experi enced miner, who he says is now in La Porte with his pan, his cradle, his rocker and all the other paraphernalia of the primitive California gold miner. Tills miner will go down to the cellar of the “House of Death” Monday morn- , ing and begin to sift the debris in search of gold. The authorities mat i tain that If gold is found at the point where the headless body wras recovered it will prove that Mrs. Gunness' head was consumed by fire and that $300 Worth of metal in her false teeth was melted by the heat. Lamphere's trunk is still in the of fice of the state's attorney. What the letters from Mrs. Gunness to Lamphere may say is known only to the author!- j ties and Ray Lamphere himself. These questions were poii to Deputy Sheriff Austin today:

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A hired gold miner will sift the cellar debris of the 'House of Death' to search for melted gold from Belle Gunness's false teeth, which authorities say would prove the headless body found was hers. Deputy Sheriff Austin also discusses Lamphere's letters and evidence suggesting he knew of or returned the night Helgelein was murdered, while depositions continue on the three positively identified victims.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

TO PROVE WOMAN'S DEATH

Michigan City during the da!y of Jan » fiary 14, and the night following; that lie returned to the farm in the morn ing and that Helgelein was gone. He asked Mrs. Gunness what had become of him and was told that he had de parted for Michigan City. “I have evidence to prove, not be yond a reasonable doubt, but beyond the shadow of doubt, that Lampher*' returned to the farm before 11 o’clock on the night of January 14 and the probabilities are that Helgelein was murdered, dismembered and buried on » that night. Lamphere, at least, got some inkling of what was going on.”

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Coroner's physicians disagree over whether the burned corpse is Belle Gunness, with two declining to state opinions pending the official report. Investigators found a Colt revolver with three fired shells in the cellar ruins, and received letters disputing Jennie Olson's supposed schooling and raising a report of a missing man from Pennsylvania.

CorrectionThis set right 6 earlier articles: Evening Journal, 9 May 1908, The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram, 9 May 1908, Daily Kennebec Journal, 9 May 1908, Omaha Daily Bee, 9 May 1908, Perth Amboy Evening News, 9 May 1908, The Marion Daily Mirror, 9 May 1908.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Authorities Are Still Puzzled Over the Guinness Case At La Porte GOLD MIR WILL TRY TO PROVE WOMAN'S DEATH Headless Body Is Declared To Be Someone Else Than Mrs. Guinness and Many OtherVbofile ‘Are Said To Be Missing. La Porte, Ind., May 9.—(Special.)—La Porte settled down today after the ex citement following the Syracuse arrest, 1 to digging in the garden grave yard of , Mrs. Belle Guryness' home. Sheriff Sinutzer is preparing for a test on Monday such as lias never be fore been made in the investigation of any murder case.

See moreSee less

It will bo in the ef- , fort to account for the missing head of the body now in the morgue be lieved to be the bedy of Mrs. Gunness. The sheriff lias employed an experi enced miner, who he says is now in La Porte with his pan, his cradle, his rocker and all the other paraphernalia of the primitive California gold miner. Tills miner will go down to the cellar of the “House of Death” Monday morn- , ing and begin to sift the debris in search of gold. The authorities mat i tain that If gold is found at the point where the headless body wras recovered it will prove that Mrs. Gunness' head was consumed by fire and that $300 Worth of metal in her false teeth was melted by the heat. Lamphere's trunk is still in the of fice of the state's attorney. What the letters from Mrs. Gunness to Lamphere may say is known only to the author!- j ties and Ray Lamphere himself. These questions were poii to Deputy Sheriff Austin today: Deputy Sheriff Questioned. “Is there anything in any of these letters which leads you to believe that Ray Lamphere was an accomplice of Mrv. Gunness in the murders which peopled her • f: grave,,. r'V’ ’• “I can't say that there is,” replied the deputy. “Is there anything in them to make you think Lamphere assisted in the murder of Andrew Helgelein?” “I don't know that there is," was the deputy’s answer. “But I believe he'has some knowledge of it. Helgelein was last seen on January 14, when he and Mrs. Gunness came to the First Na tional bank in La Porte to collect the darft of $2893.20 on the First National bank of Aberdeen, S. D., his nome town. “Lamphere has said that he was in Michigan City during the da!y of Jan » fiary 14, and the night following; that lie returned to the farm in the morn ing and that Helgelein was gone. He asked Mrs. Gunness what had become of him and was told that he had de parted for Michigan City. “I have evidence to prove, not be yond a reasonable doubt, but beyond the shadow of doubt, that Lampher*' returned to the farm before 11 o’clock on the night of January 14 and the probabilities are that Helgelein was murdered, dismembered and buried on » that night. Lamphere, at least, got some inkling of what was going on.” Taking Depositions. From time to time Coroner Mack is taking depositions in connection with tlie murders of Andrew Helgeleln, Jen nie Olson, adopted daughter of the . woman of Gunness Hill, and Ole O. Budberg of lola, Wis., who are the only three out of the total of 14 bodies thus recovered from tlie barn yard burial grounds to be positively Identi fied. Frank J. Pittner, cashier of tlie First National bank in La Porte made iiis depositions this morning. It covers several pages of large legal paper, closely written. Kxpert opinion with regard to the identi ty of the headless body In the morgue labeled Belle Gunness is conflicting. Dr. H. H. Long, one of the four physicians who performed an autopsy on the charred corpse for Coroner Muck, believes the murderess has fled, leaving another body 4 behind to bear the weight of her crimes. Dr. J. IT William Myer, another of the physicians on the coroner's board, took the oppsite view. He also backs up his statement by the dimensions of the corpse. The other two physicians, Dr. F. T. Wilcox and Dr. J. L. Gray, although admitting that they have opinions as to the identity of the body, decline to say what these opinions are in advance of the official report. Miner Ready For Work. Little progress was made today with the digging. Sheriff Smutzer now being chiefly interested in his gold mining ex periments. His assistant, Hutson, did a little prowling about the ruins of the house in tlie cellar this afternoon and \ picked up a Colt's revolver, the size generally carried by army officers and cowboys. It contained five shells, three of which had been discluirgod. The sher iff thinks It peculiar that If the three cartridges were exploded, by the heat of tlie fire, the other two remained In tact. The revolver, together with an axe which some one picked up around the barn, under tlie Impression that it con tained blood stains, are now in the sher iff's office in La Porte. Sheriff Smitzer today received a letter I from the president of the Lutheran col r lege at Fergus Falls, Minn., stating that Jennie Olson had never been a pupil there mid that, he had never heard of Jennie or Mrs. Gunness. Jennie’s married sister says that when tlie Gunness woman was making prepara tions to put her adopted daughter in the 4., garden burying ground, she ordered her , to write a letter to her ChiCRgo rela ifc ' tives stating that she was going to

See the clipping

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A man named Berry, a Civil War veteran, reportedly left with a woman matching Belle Gunness's description two years ago and was never heard from again. Carpenter Emil Greening recounts his sweetheart Jennie Olsen's final days before her mysterious disappearance from the Gunness farm.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 4

IS FOUL MURDERESS IN LAND OF LIVING?

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Emil Greening, a former worker at the Gunness farm, describes his sweetheart Jennie Olsen's sudden disappearance after her adoptive mother claimed a professor had taken her to California. He also details a pattern of numerous male visitors to the farm who arrived with trunks but were rarely seen leaving.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 4

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

A witness recounts how a cousin named Moo disappeared from the Gunness farm without anyone seeing him leave, and how Mrs. Gunness was evasive about his absence. The witness also describes finding about 15 trunks and a room full of men's clothing, plus a fenced-off area near the kitchen that Mrs. Gunness angrily forbade anyone from approaching.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 4

Five bodies of persons supposed to have been murdered by Mrs. Belle Gun ness were dug up near the house, a mile northwest of Laporte, Ind., where she and her three children recently perished in flames. It is believed she also caused the death of her two hus bands. Ray Lamphere is suspected of having been her accomplice. Four more bodies were dug up in the barnyard* of Mrs. Guinness’ farm, near Laporte, Ind., making nine found so far. The mystery of the “death house” is growing deeper, though there is evidence that the bodies were shipped to Mrs.

See moreSee less

Guin ness, probably from Chicago, in trunks and boxes which draymen tell of carting to her house. Another of the bodies dug up on the farm of Mrs. Guinness near La porte, Ind., was identified as that of Ole B. Budsberg of lola, Wis., whom the woman lured there by a matri monial advertisement. New witnesses against Roy Lamphere were found. Another body was dug up on Mrs. Guinness’ farm near Laporte, Ind., making ten found. More incriminat ing evidence against Ray Lamphere was obtained. Fully 15,000 morbid sightseers from Laporte and many other towns spent Sunday picnicing on the Gun ness farm. There were not enough vehicles in Laporte to carry them all.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Political factions in La Porte are reported to be feuding over the investigation into the Gunness farm deaths, with rumors that the female corpse found may not be Belle Gunness. A former coroner denies starting these rumors, while another physician insists he has no doubt the body is hers.

CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Evening Star, 9 May 1908, The Lake County Times, 9 May 1908, The Lake County Times, 9 May 1908, The News-Democrat, 9 May 1908.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 10 May 1908 · page 1

DISSENSIONS IN LA PORTE

III II DEBRIS Of the Gunness House Are Found, Pointing to More Murders. LAPORTE Ind., May 14?Two more* watches were found In the debris of the ruined Guinness house and those,

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Rival camps aligned with the sheriff and prosecutor spread conflicting claims about whether the body identified as Belle Gunness was actually someone else, with one coroner's physician denying he issued such a statement. The coroner admitted changing his first identification report, while prosecutor Smith criticized La Porte police inactivity amid talk that Mayor Darrow ordered them to stay out of the investigation.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 10 May 1908 · page 1

DISSENSIONS IN LA PORTE.

III II DEBRIS Of the Gunness House Are Found, Pointing to More Murders. LAPORTE Ind., May 14?Two more* watches were found In the debris of the ruined Guinness house and those,

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Searchers found a money belt buckle and a safety deposit box key in the basement ashes, and investigators refuted the theory that the found head had been severed before burning, citing the spine's position above the charred shoulders. The sheriff paused the body search to gather more identification evidence, and an anonymous letter claimed Mrs. Gunness was related to notorious killer Kate Bender and to Ray Lamphere.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 10 May 1908 · page 1

NBVV YORK, May 9?Mrs. Charles P. Rockefeller, of this city, is a sis ter of Mrs. L. A.-Herron, detained at Syracuse and suspected of being Mrs. Gunness. She said Mrs. Herron liv ed most of her life in Franklin, Pa., and her husband died last Christmas. Mrs. Rockefeller said her sister was on tho way to this city to search for employment, when she was taken In to custody. 'CHICAGO, 111.. May 9?It Is de clared at the office cff the Sethness Company, manufacturers of flavoring extracts, of this city, that F.

See moreSee less

B. Her ron. husband of Mrs. L. A. Herron. was vice president of tho company until January of this year. He died in Vicksburg, Miss. It is declared that the statement made by Mrs. Herron that she lived in Franklin, Pa., Is correct.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Physicians who examined the remains found in the ruins of the Gunness home concluded that the body of the woman was that of Mrs. Gunness. This finding came amid intense scrutiny of the farmhouse fire and the search for the truth about her fate.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 25

LAPORTE, Ind.. May 9?Digging was resume^ on the Ginnness farm today and up to noon no additional bobdies had been discovered. Important evience, which if true,

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

La Porte doctors cite identifying marks confirming the charred corpse is Belle Gunness, not a stranger, but officials are feuding over the investigation along political lines. A woman arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being the fugitive Gunness proves to be someone else, adding to the confusion.

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 33

SIREN'S CORPSE NOT STRANGER'S FOUND IN RUINS

Ll«t of Knovpu Victims. Helgelein, Andrew, 40 years old bach elor, Aberdeen, S. D. suitor for Mrs. •Gunness' hand, who came to Laporte in -January and disappeared one month later after loaning the woman $1,500 body dug up to-day. Gunness, Jennie Olson, 16 years old, adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness disap peared in September, 1906, ostensibly to attend school at Los Angeles body dug up to-day. Unidentified man, believed by Sheriff 1 Smnizer to have been an admirer of the 1 -woman. Unidentified boy, apparently S years old mutilated body in gunnysack.

See moreSee less

Unidentified girl, about 7 years old mutilated body in gunnysack. Gunness, Joseph, husband of Sirs. Gun aess, whose death at Laporte four years I ago had always remained a mystery. Sorenson, Mads, woman's first hus hand, who died under mysterious circum stances in Chicago eight years ago. Gunness, Mrs. Bella, believed to have been burned to -death in fire whicjh de atroyed her home. Sorenson, Myrtle, 11 years old, eldest daughter of Mrs. Gunness thought to have perished in the fire. if Sorenson, Lucy,-, 9 years old, another daughter 'also believed to have been a victim of the fire. Gunness, Philip, 5 years old, youngest child said to have Keen killed in the fire. Lindblom. Olaf, 35 years old. of Wis consin employed by Mrs. Gunness on the farm. When he disappeared Mrs. Gun ness gave it out that he had gone to Norway. Gerbalt, Eric, 40 years old, of Wiscon ain worked five months for Mrs. Gun ness, then he disappeared. Man from Ohio. 50 years old, name not learned worked the farm and owned a horse' and buggy. Disappeared and Mrs. Gunness fell heir to the horse and In the arrest of Ttay Y^ninnhere, a former servant of the woman, Sheriff Smulzer believes, some light may be thrown upon the circumstances sur rounding the deaths of at /least some •af the victims. Lamphere1 before the fire had trouble iwith Mrs. Gunness. lie had declared •bout town she was trying to "get rid" of him because he knew too much. He has told several conflicting stories concerning his relations with the wom an and his presence in tho neighbor hood of the Gunness home the night It burned.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

La Porte officials are reportedly split along political lines over confirming the identity of the burned corpse believed to be Belle Gunness, with rumors that the body is someone else traced to a disgruntled former coroner. Physicians on the autopsy board insist they were unanimous in their findings, denying earlier claims that the children's skulls showed blunt-force fractures.

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 33

Thf. reports of murder from the town ol La Porte. Ind., at the Gunness home, are occupying columns of the dailies. It is be lieved that the woman and her children all were murdered and burned in the house which had been the scene of her desperate deeds, and it is to be hoped that this is true It would be a gr?at pity if any of her blood were above ground. After doing their utmost to block legislation, the Democratic congressman will go into the cam paign and criticise the Republi cans for not doing anything.—

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A coroner's board of four doctors unanimously found no skull fractures or brain hemorrhages on the children's bodies, contradicting earlier reports of blunt-force wounds. They concluded the dilated hearts and collapsed lungs indicated death by suffocation, and cited the adult corpse's fat layer, a ring, and a money belt buckle as evidence it was indeed Mrs. Gunness, countering theories of a substituted body.

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 33

CORPSE OF MRS. GUNNESS

Thf. reports of murder from the town ol La Porte. Ind., at the Gunness home, are occupying columns of the dailies. It is be lieved that the woman and her children all were murdered and burned in the house which had been the scene of her desperate deeds, and it is to be hoped that this is true It would be a gr?at pity if any of her blood were above ground. After doing their utmost to block legislation, the Democratic congressman will go into the cam paign and criticise the Republi cans for not doing anything.—

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

The sheriff suspends the body search temporarily to employ a former miner to sift cellar ashes for gold teeth fillings that would confirm Belle Gunness's remains. Meanwhile new witnesses implicate Ray Lamphere in Helgelein's death, and a bank cashier describes Gunness insisting on cash payments during Helgelein's withdrawals.

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 34

MAY BE MORE BODIES

The sheriff received today several in quiries from outside points regarding missing ptnon* who may have been among the victims of Mrs. Gunness. None of these was connected directly with the farm, the fears of their rela tives being baaed upon circumstantial evidence. New witnesses regarding Lamphere • alleged connection with the death at the farm "were also discovered. The more Important of these were William Blat ter and John Rye. The latter asserts that on the day when Kelgeleln Is sup posed to have been killed he and Lam phere drove to Michigan City.

See moreSee less

They returned at night and Lamphere alighted when they reached a point opposite the Gunness farm and cut across the fields toward it. remarking that there would be "something doing there" that night. Dnovn nEwniiKis out Slatter and Lamphere occupied the catne bed on many occasions following the prisoner's dismissal from the Gun ness establishment. He says that Lnm phere told him that he had driven Hclgeleln out of Mrs. Ouni»es» f house at the point of a revolver on one ac casion, but that the SouthD.ikofan returned later and remained. v A deposition was made here today by Frank J. Pitner. cashier of the First national bank of La Porte, who handled the transactions by which Hel geleln collected $2,890 from the bank tn Mansfield. S. D. Pltnrr asserts that Mrc. Gunnees accompanied Helgeleln on his visits to the bank and when the money was withdrawn refueed. to let her visitor take a cashier's check in part payment. Mrs. Gunnees insisted that currency only would figure in the transaction. Search was instituted today for traces of K. 2. Tjef.and. a resident of Minne apolis, who is said to have come here about a year agro. An advertisement In a Minneapolis newspaper is >ai« to have been the lure by which Tiefiand was led to open correspondence with Mrs. Guaness.

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A La Porte bank cashier describes how Mrs. Gunness accompanied Helgelein to withdraw cash, insisting on currency rather than a check. Carpenters who worked on the farm recount strange visits by men to the house and the unexplained disappearance of adopted daughter Jennie Olsen.

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 34

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Cmile Greening, who worked at the Gunness farm and courted Jennie, recounts her sudden disappearance after Mrs. Gunness claimed a professor was taking her to California, though he never saw or heard any such man. He also describes a stream of male visitors who arrived with trunks and were never seen leaving, with Mrs. Gunness slow to admit when each one was gone.

The San Francisco Call · 10 May 1908 · page 34

LEFT MYSTERIOUSLY

I did not bear^any man's voice. * _ 1 ' "Mrs. Gunness later t«ld me ' that \u25a0Jennie hfcdJ eft at -4 o'clock that same mcrnlnc, but no one «* her, leave and no one About the. place ever saw the prof essorl . ' . • \u0084 "All the day f olio win % thedisappear ance Mrs. Guinness was very nervous. ,\EVEII JEE.V TO LEAVE

See the clipping

In the story →

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Dr. Harry M. Long, La Porte county coroner, states the body found in the morgue is not Belle Gunness's, citing a fifty-pound weight difference, a five-inch height discrepancy, and manicured fingernails inconsistent with her known habits. He concludes that Mrs. Gunness is still alive.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE

DECLARED BY CORONER.

See moreSee less

Bones Found in Burned House Those of Much Smaller Woman.

La Porte, Ind., May 9.—Dr. Harry H. Long, coroner of La Porte County, who assisted in the post-mortem examination of the body supposed to be that of Mrs. Gunness, declares positively that the body in the morgue is that of a woman who weighed fully fifty pounds less than did Mrs. Gunness; also that it is five inches shorter than Mrs. Gunness. He says Mrs. Gunness is still alive.

Dr. Long's statement follows:

A strange coincidence is that the foreheads of all the children were burned at the same place. This is extraordinary. A skull crushed by a blow at any point and then subjected to fire would be more likely to burn away at that point than at a sound place, as the heat and fire would reach the bony structure and thus attack the cartilages from both sides. The theory that the head of Mrs. Gunness had been entirely burned away is disproved by the fact that, being subject to the same intensity of heat and flame, and being harder, it could not have been burned away as easily as the skulls of the children.

The body at the morgue is not that of Mrs. Gunness, because it is not correctly proportioned. It is that of a rather plump woman of the general contour of Mrs. Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness weighed fully 225 pounds.

The arm that was burned off was found beside the body and is well formed. The fingers show evidence of careful manicuring, and that was something that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about.

Basing my statements on the statistics and figures of eminent physicians of this country and Great Britain, I find that the body at the morgue is almost five inches shorter than the body of Mrs. Gunness would be under similar circumstances. The fire would, of course, cause the body to lose weight, but the general physical outline of the woman would remain.

Mrs. Gunness was a woman of unusual appearance. She was large, bony, powerful looking, with square jaws and black eyes. She was a woman who would attract attention anywhere from her lack of womanly characteristics. She wore a large fur coat during the winter and her long strides, together with her remarkable countenance and her generally vicious appearance, gave her an aspect that was almost terrifying.

Only one man was occupied in digging at the Gunness farm to-day, and his work was without result.

The authorities are endeavoring to trace a young man named Canary, who it is believed may have been one of the victims of Mrs. Gunness. A letter was received this morning from his mother at Pink Lake, Ind., saying that her son, who was about twenty years old, disappeared almost two years ago. It is known that young Canary worked for Henry Bizge, who lived about a quarter of a mile from the Gunness farm. He disappeared from La Porte in June, 1906. Mrs. Canary declares in her letter that the boy was not bright and that he once burned an empty cottage for the pleasure of seeing it destroyed.

A great crowd of sightseers is expected to-morrow to view the Gunness farm. An extra force of deputies and guards will be on duty to see that the fences and other appurtenances of the place are not dismantled and carried off by relic hunters.

Oklahoma City, Okla., May 9.—Emil Greening, a carpenter, and his brother, Fred, a painter, both of whom worked last summer on Mrs. Gunness's Indiana farm, told to-day of the mysterious visits of a dozen men to the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness and of their more mysterious disappearance. Jennie Olsen, seventeen years of age, the adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness, was Emil Greening's sweetheart. Emil said to-day:

Jennie and I were good friends, and when her mother announced one night that she had decided to send Jennie to California with a professor, who, she said, had come after Jennie, but whom I never saw, Jennie came to me and declared that she would never go.

In the morning I did not see Jennie. Her mother told me that Jennie was still asleep, and, when I returned from an errand late that afternoon, I was told that Jennie had gone. I wrote to her, but I gave the two letters to Mrs. Gunness, and I never received any answer. I don't believe there ever was a professor, for I did not hear any man's voice or see any strange man about the house at that time.

Mrs. Gunness received men visitors all the time. A different man came nearly every week to stay at the house. She introduced them as cousins from Kansas, South Dakota, Wisconsin and from Chicago. Most of the men that came brought trunks with them; but they rarely took the trunks away. Mrs. Gunness kept the "cousins" with her all the time in the parlors and her bedroom. She was always careful to make the children stay away from her "cousins," who rarely tried to show them any affection.

I never knew of Mrs. Gunness bestowing her affections on any of her hired men, except Ray Lamphere.

So many men came and I saw so little of them that I cannot remember many of them, but I distinctly remember a Mr. Moo, who came from Chicago the day before Christmas, 1906. He was with Mrs. Gunness almost constantly.

When he left, his trunk stayed behind, and no one saw him go. It was several days before Mrs. Gunness announced that he was gone.

Shortly afterward, Mrs. Gunness sent me to Michigan City to get a horse that she said Moo had promised to give her. I took a day to make the trip. When I got to Michigan City something was wrong, and I was told to come back for the horse later. When I returned to the farm another "cousin" who was there when I left was gone.

In about two weeks I was again sent to Michigan City, and still there was no horse, but when I got back another cousin was missing, and no one around the place had seen him leave.

Moo's trunk was in the Gunness home on July 11, 1907, when I left the place. His was not the only one. There were about fifteen other trunks, and one room was packed full of all kinds of men's clothing, which Mrs. Gunness said her "cousins" had left, and she was not certain that they would be back for them.

In the light of what has transpired, I believe that many murders were done right under my nose.

Mrs. Gunness had a little place fenced off just south of the kitchen. She never allowed any of the hands to go near it, and she would fly in a rage if a man looked that way when he was passing. Two sides of it were barricaded with barrels and boxes, shutting off the view, but from the other two sides you could see that it looked like a garden in spots.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

An analysis argues the recovered body is five inches shorter than Belle Gunness would be, fueling doubts about her death, while authorities seek a missing young man named Canary believed to be a possible victim. Witnesses, the Greening brothers who worked at the farm, describe mysterious male visitors and the sudden, suspicious disappearance of adopted daughter Jennie Olson.

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 8

DECLARED BY CORONER

RE mm mill RAF ur 7] Canallior HH aman Those of Much Smaller Woman. la Porte. ind.. May 9.—Dr. Harry H. Long, cor oner of La Porte County, who assisted in the post mortem examination of the body supposed 10 be that of Mrs. Gunness, de-larves positively that the body in the morgue ie thai of a woman who weighed fully fifty pounds less than did Mrs. Gun ness: also that it is five inches shorter than Mrs. Guuness. le savs Mrs. Gunness is still alive. Dr. Long's statement follows: A strange coincidence is that the foreheads of all ihe children were burned at the same place.

See moreSee less

This is extraordinary. A skull crushed by a blow at any point and then subjected to fire would be more ilkely te burn away at that point than at a sound place, as the heat and fire would reach the bony structure and thus attack the cartilages from both sides. The theory that the head of Mrs. Gunness had been entirely burned away is disproved by the fact that. being subject 10 the same intensity of beat and fiame, and being harder, it could no: have heen burned away as easily as the skulls of the «hildren. The body at the morgue is not that of Mrs. Gun ness, because it ie not correctly proportioned. Tt 4s that of a rather plump woman of the general contour of Mrs. Gunness, but weighing between 150 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness weighed fully 225 The srm that wae burned off was found beside the body and is well formed. The fingers show evidence of careful manicuring. and that was eomething that Mrs Gunness knew nothing about. Basing my statements on the statistics and figures of vminent physicians of this country and Great Writain. 1 fing that the body st the morgus is al most five inches shorter than the body of Mrz. Gunness would ba under similar circumstances Tne fire would, of course, cause the body 10 Jose weight, but the general phresical outline of the woman would remain. Mrs. Gunness was a woman of unusual appear snce. She was laige, bonv, powerful looking. with ware jaws and biack eres. She was a woman who would attract attention anywhere from her Jack of womanly enaracieristics. She wore 3a large fur coat during the winter and her long strides, together witn her remarkable countenance and her generaliv vicious apnpearance, gave her an aspect that was a:most terrifying. Only one man was occupied in digging at the Gunness farm to-day, and his work was without Yeeult The authorities are endeavoring to trace a young man named Canary. who it is believed may have heen one of the victims of Mrs. Gunness. A jetter was received this morning from his mother at Pink Lake. Ind.. saving that her son. who was about twenty vears old. disappeared almost two Years ago. It is known that young Canary worked for Henry Bizge. who lived about a quarter of a mile from the Gunness farm. He disappeared from La Porte in June, 19%. Mrs Canary declares in her jerter that the boy was not bright and that he once burned an empty cottage for the pleasure of seeing it destroyed. A mreat crowd of sightseers is expected tomor yow to view the Gunness farm. An extra force of deputies and guards will be on duty to see that the fences ana other appurtenances of the place are not dismantled and carried off by relic hunters.

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Emil Greening, who worked on the Gunness farm, describes a stream of male visitors—introduced as 'cousins'—who arrived with trunks but mysteriously vanished without ever being seen leaving. He also recounts the suspicious disappearance of Jennie Olson after being told she went to California with a professor he never saw.

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 8

at the house. She introduced them as cousins from Kansas, Dakota. Wisconsin and from Chi cage. Most of the men inat came brought trunks with them: but they rarely taok the trunks awar. Mrs. Gunness kept the “cousins” with her all the time in the parlors and her bedrooin. fhe was =#l wavs careful to make the children stay away from her “cousins.” who rarely tried to show them any affection. : i never knew of Mrs. Gunness bestowing her affections on any of ner hired men, except Ray Iamphere So many men came and 1 saw so little of them that T cannot remember many of them.

See moreSee less

but 1 dis tinctly remember z Mr. Moo. who came from hi cago the day before Christmas. 1906. He was with Mrs. Gunness almost constantly. Then he left. his trunk staved behind. and no one saw him go. It was several davs before Mrs. sunness announced that he was gone. Shortly afterward. Mrs. Gunness sent me to Alichigan City to get a horse that she =aid Moo had promised to give her. I tock a day to make the trip... When 1 got to Michigan City some thing was wrong. and 1 was told to come back for the herse later. When 1 returned te the farm another “cousin” who was there when J left WES gone. In about tno necks 1 was again sent to Michigan City. and still iliere was no horse. but when 1 got back another cousin was missing, and no one sround the place had seen him leave. Moo's trunk was in the Gunness home on July 11. 16%. when I left the place. His was not the only one. There were about fifteen oiher trunks. and one room was packed full of alli Kinds of men's clothing, which Mrs, Gunness said her “cousins” had left. and she was not certain that they would be back for them. In the light of what has transpired. I believe that many murders were done right under my ncse. . Guuness had a little place fenced off just south of the Kitchen. She never allowed any, of ' the hands to go near it. and she would fly if a if 2 man looked that way when he was pass Two sides of it were barricaded with barrels and boxes, shutting off the view, but from the other two sides vou could see that it looked like a in spots. ———————— ee eee

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

La Porte County coroner Dr. Harry Long states the body found in the morgue weighs 50-70 pounds less and is five inches shorter than Mrs. Gunness, concluding it cannot be her. He argues the skull burning pattern and well-manicured arm found nearby further contradict identification as Gunness.

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 8

MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE DECLARED BY CORONER. Bones Found in Burned House Those of Much Smaller Woman.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Dr. Long presents detailed anatomical reasoning—including height, weight, and manicured hands—to argue the burned body found at the farm cannot be Belle Gunness. He also notes authorities are trying to trace a missing young man named Canary who may have been a victim.

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 8

DECLARED BY CORONER

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Investigators seek to trace a young man named Canary, believed a possible victim, after his mother wrote that he vanished from La Porte in 1906. Carpenter Emil Greening, former Gunness farmhand and sweetheart of her adopted daughter Jennie Olsen, describes Jennie's sudden disappearance and the parade of unexplained male visitors Mrs. Gunness entertained.

New-York Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 8

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

After no additional bodies were unearthed in Belle Gunness's garden on this day, Laporte residents express surprise, having expected the search to yield more remains. The report offers a character study of the woman now regarded as a murderess, noting that neighbors had long suspected and shunned her.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Laporte, Ind., May 9.—There is no bet ter way of indicating the demoniacal qualities now generally ascribed to Mrs. Belle Gunness hereabouts than by saying that. when it was announced at nightfall to-day that no more bodies had been dug up in that garden of death on the Gun ness place, everybody in Laporte was sur prised. Always in her lifetime. suspected and feared, the woman has now become in the public mind a perfect paragon of blood lust, craft, and treachery. Apparently nobody would be surprised to learn that every square yard of her fifty-acre farm is sown with the bodies of her victims.

See moreSee less

Meantime, where is Belle Gunness? Are those fragments of a female body that lie in the morgue, charred past recogni tion, really hers, or are they the remains of some one more of her victims, intended to throw dust in the eyes of the police until the multi-murderer makes good her escape?

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report describes continued uncertainty in Laporte over whether the charred body found is truly Belle Gunness or a disguised victim meant to aid her escape. It notes that despite conflicting theories, diggers have now uncovered the remains of about fourteen bodies on the farm.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report identifies Jennie Olson, the 18-year-old adopted daughter of Belle Gunness, as the last of the bodies found in the farm's death garden. It theorizes that most victims were murdered for financial gain, but suggests Olson and some others died simply because their silence was valuable to Gunness.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

April 28, there is some doubt. Three of them were children of this Tucretia Bor gia, of Laporte—two girls and & boy— Myrtle, aged eleven; Lucy, nine, and Philip, five. In the identity of the fourth lies the solution of the problem. Murder for revenue only wag apparent ly the passion that consumed Belle Gun ness. That several of her victims were persons from whose death she could get prefit in & pecuniary way in no man ner controverts this statement, In every case of wholesale murder there have heen | some victims who died because their silence was deemed more precious than gold.

See moreSee less

In such a position Jennie Olson doubtless found herself. This adopted daughter was a simple-minded. quiet girl, who was known to the neighbors chiefly because she did more work than any hired man, She was Belle Gunness’ pret ty slave. And vet the mistress feared the slave, So the slave died, and was buried in quicklime in the same death garden that had receiveq the bodies of others who died because they had money, Not Attractive Personally, . What sort of woman was this astound ing murderer? That is a hard question, and yet something can be done toward answering. She was a Norwegian who lacked ahout two years of the halfcen tury mark. Sbe was born in Norway, end came to America as a young girl, In Cli~ago in 1883 she married Max Soren son, fellow-countryman. He died sud denly in 1890. Two years later she married Gunness. He also died suddenly, as will be seen. Death, sudden and mysterious, attended Belle Gunness for many years. When she came to Laporte six years ago with Gunness, Mrs. Gunness was a fat, coarse featured woman, who stood about five feet seven, and weighed about 220 pounds. She had a big, heavy head, a mop of coarse hair of a muddy brown, little eyes that just missed being black, huge hands and arms, but feet grotesquely small for

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report describes how Belle Gunness's property had a prior reputation as a disreputable resort before she took it over, and how neighbors grew suspicious after her husband's death and her habitual daily trips to mail letters. It reveals she was writing to Andrew Helgelien, one of her alleged murder victims, under the guise of a love letter while plotting against him.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

LURED TO DEATH BY LOVE LETTERS

Lamphere, Wife-Deserter. WILKES BARRE, Pa., May 15Ray Lamphere, the alleged murderer of Mrs. Belle Gunness. of The death farm at l.a Porte. Ind.. has a crim inal record and a deserted wife at Sayre, near here. lamphere is well known to many of the residents of Sayre, particularly to teamsters. He worked around blacksmith shops of Sayre and Towanda as a horseshoer. In the latter part of 1900 he was ar rested on a charge of breaking Into freight cars ou the I>*bigh Valley railroad, and was taken to Towanda for trial.

See moreSee less

There he was convicted and served a sentence for the crime. After his release from prison be returned to Sayre, but remained there only a short time when he deserted his wife and left, presumably for the west. Nothing more was heard of him until his arrest for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three chil dren. *

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report describes how Belle Gunness wrote frequent letters to the post office during the period she was planning her murders, including one tender love letter to victim Andrew Helgelien dated January 1908. The letter, written in her broken English, lures him with promises of love and describes her farm and happiness awaiting him.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

LURED TO DEATH BY LOVE LETTERS

Four more bodies were aug up in the barnyard of Mrs. Guinness* farm, near Laporte, Ind., making nine found so far. The mystery of the “death house” is growing deeper, though there is evidence that the bodies were shipped to Mrs. Guin ness, probably from Chicago, in trunks and boxes which draymen tell of carting to her house. Another of the bodies dug up on the farm of Mrs. Guinness near La porte, Ind., was identified as that of Ole B. Budsberg of lola, Wis., whom the woman lured there by a matri monial advertisement.

See moreSee less

New witnesses against Roy Lamphere were found. Another body was dug up on Mrs. Guinness’ farm near Laporte, Ind., making ten found. More incriminat ing evidence against Ray Lamphere was obtained. Fully 15,000 morbid sightseers from Laporte and many other towns spent Sunday picnicing on the Gun ness farm. There were not enough vehicles in Laporte to carry them all.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A fragment of a letter from Mrs. Belle Gunness to Andrew Helgelien, discovered by his brother Asle Helgelien in the Gunness carriage house, is reproduced. The letter urges Andrew to come stay at the farm forever, professing love and describing the healthful breezes and kind neighbors.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Reporters describe the ongoing excavation of Belle Gunness's farm, where searchers have been digging for five days without finding new bodies that day. The report questions whether the charred remains in the morgue are truly Gunness's or another victim meant to mislead police while she escapes.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

LURED TO DEATH BY LOVE LETTERS

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Excavators have unearthed remains of ten victims at the Gunness farm, with three identified as Andrew Heigelien, O.C. Budsberg, and adopted daughter Jennie Olson. The report profiles Belle Gunness as a murderous widow who lured men with promises of marriage and killed for money, describing her physical appearance and marital history.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

DIG UP MURDER GARDEN Residents of Laporte Expect to Find More Bodies. History of Strange Woman and Scenes Enacted at Her Home Com ing to Light—Character Study eof the Muarderess for Revenue as Re vealed by Neighbors, Who for Years Had Shunned Her, Laporte, Ind., May 9.—There is no bet ter way of indicating the demoniacal qualities now generally ascribed to Mrs. Belle Gunness hereabouts than by saying that. when it was announced at nightfall to-day that no more bodies had been dug up in that garden of death on the Gun ness place, everybody in Laporte was sur prised.

See moreSee less

Always in her lifetime. suspected and feared, the woman has now become in the public mind a perfect paragon of blood lust, craft, and treachery. Apparently nobody would be surprised to learn that every square yard of her fifty-acre farm is sown with the bodies of her victims. Meantime, where is Belle Gunness? Are those fragments of a female body that lie in the morgue, charred past recogni tion, really hers, or are they the remains of some one more of her victims, intended to throw dust in the eyes of the police until the multi-murderer makes good her escape? Mystery Is Not Cleared. There are so many circumstances to support either theory that the case re mains to-day as mysteriods as it was last Tuesday when the murder garden yielded up its first grim fruit. Meantime certain things stand out as facis—hard and brutal facts that cannot be expla’ red away. Since little Dan Hudson and Joe Max son got to work with their picks and spades five days ago, they have dug up what the doctors say are the remnants of ten human bodies. Four of them were buried in a single pit about four by seven feet. Only three of them have been identi fied with any certainty. The first was Andrew K. Heigelien, a n:iddle-aged Nor wegian, lured from his home at Aber deen, 8. Dak., by the expectation of mar riage with the well-to-do widow. The second was O, C. Budsberg, an elderly farmer from Iola, Wis. The same bait brought him to his death. The last of the three identified bodies was Jennie Olson, an eighteen-year-old girl, and the adopted daughter of Bellis Gunneess All the remaining six whose bodies this ter rible liitle garden has vielded were men, with a single execoption, and when that is said, all that is known of them has been stated. All Ten Are Slain, That all ten of these were murdered there is no doubt. As to the four whose bodies were found buried beneath the ruins of the house on the morning of April 28, there is some doubt. Three of them were children of this Tucretia Bor gia, of Laporte—two girls and & boy— Myrtle, aged eleven; Lucy, nine, and Philip, five. In the identity of the fourth lies the solution of the problem. Murder for revenue only wag apparent ly the passion that consumed Belle Gun ness. That several of her victims were persons from whose death she could get prefit in & pecuniary way in no man ner controverts this statement, In every case of wholesale murder there have heen | some victims who died because their silence was deemed more precious than gold. In such a position Jennie Olson doubtless found herself. This adopted daughter was a simple-minded. quiet girl, who was known to the neighbors chiefly because she did more work than any hired man, She was Belle Gunness’ pret ty slave. And vet the mistress feared the slave, So the slave died, and was buried in quicklime in the same death garden that had receiveq the bodies of others who died because they had money, Not Attractive Personally, . What sort of woman was this astound ing murderer? That is a hard question, and yet something can be done toward answering. She was a Norwegian who lacked ahout two years of the halfcen tury mark. Sbe was born in Norway, end came to America as a young girl, In Cli~ago in 1883 she married Max Soren son, fellow-countryman. He died sud denly in 1890. Two years later she married Gunness. He also died suddenly, as will be seen. Death, sudden and mysterious, attended Belle Gunness for many years. When she came to Laporte six years ago with Gunness, Mrs. Gunness was a fat, coarse featured woman, who stood about five feet seven, and weighed about 220 pounds. She had a big, heavy head, a mop of coarse hair of a muddy brown, little eyes that just missed being black, huge hands and arms, but feet grotesquely small for the burden they had to support. Every body who knew her agrees that she was far from attractive. Most of her acquaintances deseribe her as repulsive. Some of her neighbors go further. “More a devil than a woman,” was the way William Dessielen put it, and he ought to know, because his. farm is next to the Gunness place.

See the clipping

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The article describes Belle Gunness's background as a Norwegian immigrant whose first husband Max Sorenson died suddenly in 1890, followed by her marriage to Gunness who also died suddenly. Neighbors and her nephew describe her as physically imposing, unattractive, and personally cold or even sinister.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

This is a humor/miscellany column riffing on various news items of the day, including a brief sarcastic aside comparing Mrs. Gunness unfavorably to Bluebeard. It is not a substantive news report but a collection of quips on unrelated topics.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 6

Bella Gunness. The tooth was found in the debris the cellar while Sheriff Smutzer flru continuing his preparations to ftegin the sluicing of the ashes. The relic is a hollow molar, with a gold irown, the metal being indented and |o some extent encrusted by cinders, the tooth, however, bears every evi­ nce of having come from the incin­ erated skull of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Unexplainable evidence, hitherto luppressed, has been made public in the Gunness tragedy. It is contained the report of Dr. J. L. Gray, who performed the autopsy on the body vhich the authorities have steadfastly ilaimed is that of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Bella Gunness. Dr. Gray, in his report, tells of three rings which were found upon the fcorpse and also reveals the fact that the right hand, hitherto declared miss aag, is still in existence. The rings, which might be expected to reveal the identity of the wearer, ttnly add to the mystery of the case. Two of them contain inscriptions, one

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report gives neighborhood background on the Gunness farm's sinister reputation and her husband's suspicious death, then reproduces one of Belle Gunness's love letters luring victim Andrew Helgelien to her farm. It frames her correspondence as part of a deliberate murder scheme.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

LURED TO DEATH BY LOVE LETTERS

HIS DEATH WELL TIMED. Mrs. Gunness' First Husband Expired Day Before Insurance Lapsed. Chicago, May 8.—A sinister fact in connection with the death of Mads

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report quotes romantic letters Belle Gunness wrote luring Andrew Helgelein to her Laporte farm, promising love and a life together. It also describes the day Helgelein arrived, noting neighbors saw him but never saw him leave, and mentions Ray Lamphere's arrest for arson.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

the tooth, however, bears every evi I tface of having come from the incin ated skull of Mrs. Bella Ounness. TJnexplainable evidence, hitherto luppressed, has been made public in fee Gunness tragedy. It is contained jl the report of Dr. J. L. Gray, who performed the autopsy on the body which the authorities have steadfastly ilaimed is that of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Dr. Gray, in his report, tells of three tings which were found upon the Corpse and also reveals the fact that Ihfe right hand, hitherto declared miss­ ing, is still in existence. The rings, which might be expected, to reveal the identity of the wearer, inly add to the mystery of the case, rwo of them contain inscriptions, one

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report reconstructs how Andrew Helgelein was last seen entering the Gunness farm before vanishing, with hired man Ray Lamphere describing Mrs. Gunness's suspicious behavior around his disappearance. It also notes that a Syracuse woman mistakenly arrested as Belle Gunness was quickly cleared and released.

The Washington Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

HIS DEATH WELL TIMED. Mrs. Gunness' First'Husband Expired Day Before Insurance Lapsed. Chicago, May 8.—A sinister fact in connection with the death of Mads Sorenson, the first husband of Mrs.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Reporters describe the LaPorte community's fear and fascination with Belle Gunness, debating whether she is dead or has faked her death to escape after murders were discovered. The report notes conflicting facts and describes her as having married twice and possessing a powerful build with small feet.

Evening Star · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Remains at Ten. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—Dr. H. BL boas, one of the physicians who per­ formed the. autopsy on the body of the Woman found In the ruins of the Gun MM home after the fire, has made a •tatemeat that the body Is not. that •f Mrs. Ghinneas. His statement is as lollowa: "In my opinion the body of the wo found in the house is not that of Mrs. Qunness because it is not cor­ rectly proportioned. It is that of a rather plump woman of the same gen­ eral oontour of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Qunness, but weighing between 159 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness was literally a succes­ sion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned oft was found beside the body and is well formed. The fingers show evidence at eareful manicuring and that was ppgpethlng that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Rafting my statements on the sta Mitfcs and figures of eminent physi­ cians of ihis country and Great Brit­ ain I find that the body at the morgue almost five lnohes shorter than the Mf of Mrs. Gunness would be under limllar oiroumftances. The fire would. eourse. cause the body to lose 4t weight, bat the general*physical out-

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Investigators have exhumed what doctors identify as portions of ten human bodies from the farm, including three positively identified victims: Andrew Helgelien, Ole Budsberg, and Jennie Olson. The report speculates Belle Gunness killed for profit and to silence witnesses, describing her as 'more devil than woman.'

Evening Star · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Remains at Ten. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—Dr. H. BL boas, one of the physicians who per­ formed the. autopsy on the body of the Woman found In the ruins of the Gun MM home after the fire, has made a •tatemeat that the body Is not. that •f Mrs. Ghinneas. His statement is as lollowa: "In my opinion the body of the wo found in the house is not that of Mrs. Qunness because it is not cor­ rectly proportioned. It is that of a rather plump woman of the same gen­ eral oontour of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Qunness, but weighing between 159 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness was literally a succes­ sion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned oft was found beside the body and is well formed. The fingers show evidence at eareful manicuring and that was ppgpethlng that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Rafting my statements on the sta Mitfcs and figures of eminent physi­ cians of ihis country and Great Brit­ ain I find that the body at the morgue almost five lnohes shorter than the Mf of Mrs. Gunness would be under limllar oiroumftances. The fire would. eourse. cause the body to lose 4t weight, bat the general*physical out-

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The report describes Jennie Olson as a silenced victim and portrays Belle Gunness as a large, repulsive woman with a history of husbands who died suddenly. It also details investigators' uncertainty over whether Gunness died in the farmhouse fire or is still alive and at large.

Evening Star · 10 May 1908 · page 1

HAD BEEN MARRIED TWICE

Ll«t of Knovpu Victims. Helgelein, Andrew, 40 years old bach elor, Aberdeen, S. D. suitor for Mrs. •Gunness' hand, who came to Laporte in -January and disappeared one month later after loaning the woman $1,500 body dug up to-day. Gunness, Jennie Olson, 16 years old, adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness disap peared in September, 1906, ostensibly to attend school at Los Angeles body dug up to-day. Unidentified man, believed by Sheriff 1 Smnizer to have been an admirer of the 1 -woman. Unidentified boy, apparently S years old mutilated body in gunnysack.

See moreSee less

Unidentified girl, about 7 years old mutilated body in gunnysack. Gunness, Joseph, husband of Sirs. Gun aess, whose death at Laporte four years I ago had always remained a mystery. Sorenson, Mads, woman's first hus hand, who died under mysterious circum stances in Chicago eight years ago. Gunness, Mrs. Bella, believed to have been burned to -death in fire whicjh de atroyed her home. Sorenson, Myrtle, 11 years old, eldest daughter of Mrs. Gunness thought to have perished in the fire. if Sorenson, Lucy,-, 9 years old, another daughter 'also believed to have been a victim of the fire. Gunness, Philip, 5 years old, youngest child said to have Keen killed in the fire. Lindblom. Olaf, 35 years old. of Wis consin employed by Mrs. Gunness on the farm. When he disappeared Mrs. Gun ness gave it out that he had gone to Norway. Gerbalt, Eric, 40 years old, of Wiscon ain worked five months for Mrs. Gun ness, then he disappeared. Man from Ohio. 50 years old, name not learned worked the farm and owned a horse' and buggy. Disappeared and Mrs. Gunness fell heir to the horse and In the arrest of Ttay Y^ninnhere, a former servant of the woman, Sheriff Smulzer believes, some light may be thrown upon the circumstances sur rounding the deaths of at /least some •af the victims. Lamphere1 before the fire had trouble iwith Mrs. Gunness. lie had declared •bout town she was trying to "get rid" of him because he knew too much. He has told several conflicting stories concerning his relations with the wom an and his presence in tho neighbor hood of the Gunness home the night It burned.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Investigators debate whether the decapitated female body found in the fire ruins is Belle Gunness, with theories about heat exposure versus deliberate beheading. Sheriff Smutzer employs a miner to sift ashes for metallic evidence like gold dental fillings, while crowds of sightseers flock to the farm and morgues.

Evening Star · 10 May 1908 · page 2

Ball, an undertaker, who handled the bodies, says tlmt there was no evidence that tlie flesh or skin about the shoulders iiad been severed with any sharp instrument. Buckle and Bing Found. A finger ring, a buckle for a money Mtuf Ct gft fpt V 'Honnci# vonH L-otr oil ?? - ?-% ' * i .? i"? "?? t * nui v , an identified as personal belongings of Mrs. Gunness. were found in the ruins near

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The sheriff continues searching the Gunness farm for more bodies despite crowds of sightseers, postponing excavation due to the spectators. Meanwhile, from Oklahoma City, a carpenter named Emil Greening describes his sweetheart Jennie Olson's sudden disappearance and recounts the string of male visitors who came to stay with Mrs. Gunness, introduced as cousins, who brought trunks but left without them.

Evening Star · 10 May 1908 · page 2

Story From Oklahoma. OKLAHOMA CITY. Okla.. May P.?Emil Greening, a car|>eiiter, and his brother, Fred, a painter, both of whom worked last summer on Mrs. Gunness* Indiana farm, today told of the mysterious visits (i, a uozen men to hip nome or Mrs. Bella Cunners and of iheir more mysterious disappearance. TinGreenings live in Oklahoma City,

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A former hired hand recounts how Jennie Olson disappeared without anyone seeing her leave, and how numerous male visitors ('cousins') to Mrs. Gunness's farm also vanished mysteriously, their trunks left behind. A related dispatch reports a Maryland man, Isaiah Stoner, narrowly escaped becoming a victim after answering her advertisement.

Evening Star · 10 May 1908 · page 2

Many Men Visitors. "Mrs. Gunness received men visitors all th time. A different male visitor camp nearly every week to stay at the house, she introduced them as cousins from Kansas. South Dakota, Wisconsin and !ioin Chicago. Most of the men that can.e brought trunks with them, hut they

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Guards moved prisoner Ray Lamphere secretly to a barn for safekeeping amid fears of mob violence. Separately, letters from Belle Gunness to Andrew Helgelein reveal she had a woman accomplice in Chicago who met him at the train.

The Washington Times · 10 May 1908 · page 2

WOMAN A PLOTTER - AN ACCOMPLICE MURDERESS

IN fARM N1UROfRS i Finding of Skull Supposed to Be That of Mrs Gunness Completes Case LAPOfiTP Illd May 1iThe rrport of the Coroners physicians to the of

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Asa Helgelian's brother, disgusted with officials' incompetence, vows to spend his fortune pursuing the murderess himself. Meanwhile, the sheriff hires an experienced miner to sift the ashes of the Gunness house cellar for gold dental fillings, hoping to prove the headless body was indeed Mrs. Gunness.

The Washington Times · 10 May 1908 · page 2

April IS Tho ClUe agahiBt Hay Lamphere probably will be brought l > fore the Grand Jury Monday according to the first revision of the schedule In this regard The tlmo of Ills trial Is less

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

La Porte authorities search for melted gold (from dental work) at the site where the headless body was recovered, hoping to prove Mrs. Gunness's head was consumed by fire. Meanwhile, her trunk and letters to Lamphere remain under guard, and a deputy sheriff candidate suggests Lamphere knows more than he admits about the disappearance of Helgelein, last seen leaving with Mrs. Gunness in January.

The Washington Times · 10 May 1908 · page 2

push the matter forward Dieting on the farm has been again topped as it has been decided to first drag the pond In the vicinity for bodies which Mrs Gunness might have weight ed down Lampheres Wife Found Ray Lampheros deserted wlte has beat found near Sayre Pa Ho once

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

Investigators found letters written by Belle Gunness to victim Andrew Helgelein describing a woman accomplice in Chicago who would meet and entertain him before Gunness arrived. Separately, Sheriff Smutzer hired an experienced miner to sift the debris of the farmhouse cellar for dental gold to help identify the headless body found in the ruins.

The Washington Times · 10 May 1908 · page 2

WOMAN PLOTTER AIDED MURDERESS

Mayor Tom L. Johnson of Cleve. land Is .now roiping .the wrath of a peoplo whom he has befrlondod and for whom he plans other uuutmiu. all -nil. The .people of Ohio are susplc lonlng .that the troops la the to bacco districts are being used to nllay the fears of a few panicky olIlQers. A Milwaukee man says he will deliver Mrs. Belle Gunness to the authorities of Laporte, Inulinn, for

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A gold miner is hired to sift cellar debris for melted gold tooth fillings that might prove the headless body was Mrs. Gunness. Deputy Anstiss states he has evidence beyond doubt that Lamphere returned to the farm the night Helgelien disappeared and likely participated in his murder and dismemberment.

The Washington Times · 10 May 1908 · page 2

AIDED MURDERESS

Not Die Easily. La Porte, May 11. Evidence came to light today Indicating that the body of Andrew Helgallne, one of Mrs. dMinneBs alleged victims, did not fall a victim to his death blow until af ter he had made a desperate fight for his life. Dr. J. B. Meyer, who made an ex amination of the corpse, reported to . the coroner , that he found several brown curly ' hairs in the clenched flat of Hellgallne's right hand. It Is supposed that In the death struggle he pulled the hair out of the scalp of his slayer. Police are now willing to accept the original theory that Mrs. Guinness died In the fire which destroyed her home.

Clipping to come

The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.

A denial is issued that any trunk of letters between Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness was found, and reports that Lamphere intended to confess are called untrue. Meanwhile, a Syracuse woman mistakenly arrested as Belle Gunness is quickly released after proving her identity.

The Pensacola Journal · 10 May 1908 · page 7

LA PORTE MYSTERY IS NOT YET SOLVED

Not Die Easily. La Porte, May 11. Evidence came to light today Indicating that the body of Andrew Helgallne, one of Mrs. dMinneBs alleged victims, did not fall a victim to his death blow until af ter he had made a desperate fight for his life. Dr. J. B. Meyer, who made an ex amination of the corpse, reported to . the coroner , that he found several brown curly ' hairs in the clenched flat of Hellgallne's right hand. It Is supposed that In the death struggle he pulled the hair out of the scalp of his slayer. Police are now willing to accept the original theory that Mrs. Guinness died In the fire which destroyed her home.

Clipping to come

The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.

A woman mistaken for Belle Gunness was detained in Syracuse but proved her identity as a Pennsylvania visitor. Meanwhile Chicago police chased unreliable sightings of Gunness, and a doctor who performed the Laporte autopsy declared the burned body found in the ruins was not hers.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Pensacola Journal · 10 May 1908 · page 7

Along the Way—Thieves Also Busy in Rubbernecking Throng. All roads in Laporte county, Ind., led to the Gunness farm Sunday, up wards of 15,000 sightseers visiting the

Clipping to come

The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.

A doctor who performed the autopsy states his opinion that the badly burned body found in the Gunness house ruins is not that of Belle Gunness herself. He cites discrepancies in body weight, hand condition suggesting manicured nails, and burn patterns on the skull as evidence the corpse belongs to someone else.

The Pensacola Journal · 10 May 1908 · page 7

Investigation of the case by the au thorities hailed, the sheriff and other officials who went to the farm being compelled to become mere spectators also. Several of the out of town visit ors, however, were seeking informa tion concerning missing friends and relatives. Olaf Llnboe, of Chicago, said that his brother Thomas worked for Mrs. Gunness three years ago, and that the last letter that he had from him contained the information that Thomas intended to marry his employ er. Olaf wrote to the woman a little later, and she replied that Thomas Llndboe had gone to St.

See moreSee less

Louis and that she had had no word from him. Olaf Llndboe viewed the unidentified corpses, but was unable to find any likeness to his brother in the decayed bundles of bones and flesh. The crowds began arriving in La porte when the first train from the east arrived shortly after 5 o’clock in the morning. Along the roadside in front of the farm were several lemon ade stands and lunch wagons.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Sheriff Smutzer has hired an experienced miner to sift through remains in LaPorte to search for melted gold dental work that could help identify the headless body believed to be Belle Gunness. Meanwhile, a letter from Atlantic City claims a woman resembling Gunness was seen leaving a train in Philadelphia after acting strangely.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 1

GOLD MINER TO SIFT FOR GUNNESS TEETH

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Sheriff Smutzer hires a miner to sift the fire debris from the Gunness cellar, hoping to find melted gold from false teeth to prove the headless body is Belle Gunness. Deputy Anstiss is questioned about letters in Lamphere's trunk, hedging on whether they prove Lamphere's complicity in the murders.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Detective Warren links missing men Helgelein and Tiefland to Belle Gunness as likely murder victims, while Elkhart authorities nearly confirm one exhumed body as Jennie Olson/May Loeffler. Lamphere, jailed and losing weight, rants about visions of Gunness, and a signed check found in the farmhouse ruins opens a new investigative lead.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

The report lists witnesses summoned to testify against Ray Lamphere, including saloonkeepers, associates, and a former employer who claim he boasted of controlling Belle Gunness and threatened to burn her house. Several witnesses also claim to have seen Lamphere near the Gunness property around the time of the fire.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 2

GOLD MINER TO HUNT FOR GUNNESS TEETH

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A Chicago nerve specialist offers a psychological profile of Belle Gunness, comparing her to Jack the Ripper and other blood-fixated degenerates. He argues her crimes were motivated by an uncontrollable bloodlust rather than financial gain, and suggests she remains at large due to criminal cunning.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 2

LOVED SIGHT OF BLOOD.

MRS. GUNNESS SCIENTIFIC BUTCHER Special Correspondence to The Press. LA PORTE, Ind., May 15—Not an i The body of Jennie Olson Gun ness, one of the 12 victims, was so cleverly severed at the neck that

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A specialist's theory about Belle Gunness's habitual decapitation and dismemberment of victims is reported, with Pinkerton detectives said to be pursuing this same theory in their investigation. The piece draws parallels to other similar cases of extreme mutilation as a psychological pattern.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 10

GOLD MINER TO HUNT FOR GUNNESS TEETH

Special Correspondence to The Press. LA PORTE, Ind., May 15—Not an ordinary, cumbersome mutilator of bodies like the perpetrators of Ma fia outrages, but a scientific butch er of either human beings or ani mals —such was Mrs. Bella Gun ness. Close scrutiny of the records of the inquest over the body of Joseph Philip Gunness, the woman's sec ond husband, adds a new and weird accomplishment to the most fa mous of America's murderesses. Mrs. Gunness was a skilled butch er. With her dismembering bodies was a science. Neighbors testified she butchered all her own live stock.

See moreSee less

She always insisted upon cutting it up for smoking or salting. It was her "specialty." she said. On the witness stand at the in quest of her second husband she testified that "on the day before he died I was trying to finish up the butchering business."

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

The sheriff's office reports a clue suggesting Belle Gunness had outside help from Chicago, as she could not have done the killings alone. Meanwhile, postoffice inspectors Purr and Fletcher investigate a mysterious wealthy widow in La Porte who anonymously sends flowers to jailed suspect Ray Lamphere, hinting she may hold information about the case.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 10 May 1908 · page 10

FLETCHER ON CASE

OFFICERS WORK EVERY CLUE. ' LAPORTE, Ind., May G.—l Special.] Two more ghastly finds were made on the farm of Mrs. Belle Guinness today when the skeletons of two adults were

Clipping to come

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This report presents an appalling list of victims allegedly murdered by Mrs. Gunness for financial gain, and raises doubt about whether she is actually dead or alive. It also suggests she may have killed her own children and discusses a theory that she had an accomplice, with ten bodies found so far, only three identified.

The Sun · 10 May 1908 · page 1

DEATH HARVEST OF MRS GUNNESS

cludes the supposition that she feared Roy Lamphere, her former employe, was about to expose her through jealousy. Suspect Insurance Plot. The sheriff has notified the Chicago police to be on the lookout for a gang in that city believed to be in a murder plot

Clipping to come

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

By nightfall on May 9, officials in La Porte reported no further bodies had been unearthed at the Gunness farm, bringing the total to ten, only three of which had been identified. Townspeople increasingly viewed Belle Gunness as monstrous, while questions persisted over whether charred remains at the morgue were hers or another victim's, and whether an accomplice had helped her escape.

The Sun · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Suspect Insurance Plot. The sheriff has notified the Chicago police to be on the lookout for a gang in that city believed to be in a murder plot for purposes of collecting insurance. The gang is believed to have disposed of parts of the bodies in Laporte. On Sat urday, April 25, two days before her home was burned, Mrs. Guinness re ceived by express from Chicago, four large trunks. What their contents were has not been learned. Sheriff Smutzer is confident, however, that they contained bodies of murdered people, shipped here from Chicago.

See moreSee less

This leads the officers to suspect that Mrs. Guinness conducted a “murder fence” to dispose of bodies of persons murdered in Chicago for their life insurance. The startling revelations hnve awak ened Laporte people to a recollection of some strange occurrences at the Guin r css home during the last year. East summer Mrs. Guinness reported to Chief of Police Cochran that a child had been murdered in the woods, back of her house by a man and woman who had driven past her home.

Clipping to come

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Diggers Hudson and Maxson have uncovered the remains of about ten human bodies in Belle Gunness's garden over five days of digging, including a mass grave holding four bodies. Three victims have been positively identified: Andrew Helgelein, Ole B. Budsberg, and Jennie Olson, the adopted daughter of Belle Gunness.

The Sun · 10 May 1908 · page 1

One more body lias been added to tbe death roll of the Guinness farm, npar La Porte, Ind., the grewsome relics now numbering ten. Then there are the bodies of Mrs. Guinness and her three children burned to death in their home, making fourteen in all, Coroner Mack had at first announced that the grave opened yesterday con tained one complete cadaver and por tions of a second, but later said that what he had at first believed to be ad ditional thigh and arm bones are in reality pieces of the first set.

See moreSee less

* Developments in the case came thick and last during the evening, each ad ditional circumstance brought to light being of a uature to strengthen the charges against Ray Lamphere, who is accused of first degree murder be cause of the deaths of Mrs. Belle Guin ness and her three children. Lamphere sent a request to his attorney, H. \Y. Worden, asking the latter to send to the farm of John Wheatbrook for the trunk which Lamphere left there when he was arrested April 28. But before this word had reached the attorney the trunk had been con fiscated by the local authorities. It con tained a number of letters written by Mrs. Guinness to Lamphere after the latter had taken employment at tbe farm of John Wheatbrook, near Spring ville, seven miles north of this city. The exact dates on these letters were not announced, but that they were re cent is evidenced by tbe fact that Lam phere went to the Wheatbrook farm on Feb. 3, 1908. Tlie woman wrote to Lamphere urg ing him to return to her farm, and to 4, bring your sweetheart with you if she has money enough.” The identity of the woman is a and neither does Mrs. Guinness mention the amount deemed necessary for her re ception at the Guinness farm. Along *VVith the letters were found several tromen’s finger rings, some of which of unusual size and may have been the property of Mrs. Guinness.

Clipping to come

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The report quotes a nephew and neighbors describing Belle Gunness as aloof and quarrelsome, noting her farm had long been known as a disreputable resort before she and her husband took it over. It details how she quickly alienated locals through property disputes and unfriendly behavior.

The Sun · 10 May 1908 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

This report describes neighbors' recollections of Belle Gunness's daily buggy trips to town, her unfriendly and masculine demeanor, and her broken English. It notes that during this same period she was writing love letters to Andrew Helgelien, a man she was secretly planning to murder.

The Sun · 10 May 1908 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

A letter from Belle Gunness to victim Andrew Helgelien, found by his brother in the carriage house, reveals her romantic manipulation of him before his death. Neighbors recall seeing Helgelien arrive and wander the farm with Gunness, but no one ever saw him leave.

The Sun · 10 May 1908 · page 2

THE LAST OF ANDREW HELGELIEN

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

See the clipping

Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.

Dr. Long, who performed an autopsy on a body thought to be Mrs. Gunness, clarified he had not stated disbelief in its identity, only offered a personal opinion. No new bodies were found on the Gunness farm that day, though the sheriff said he would seek further evidence and many inquiries about missing persons were arriving.

Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 10 May 1908 · page 1

JAW DONE Dug Up On Gunness Farm Re sembles Mrs. Gunness's Dentist Declares. LAPORTB, Ind.. May 15?Dr. Nor ton. dentist. Who performed a large amount of work on the teeth of Mrs

Clipping to come

Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.

Emile Greening, a carpenter who worked on the Gunness farm and was in love with Jennie Olson, described many strange men who came to the farm with trunks but were never seen leaving. He said Mrs. Gunness kept the men isolated in parlors and bedrooms, and he stated he did not believe Jennie Olson had been murdered.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Sunday—Relic Hunters and In quirers of Relatives or Friends Kept the Officials Busy. Laporte, Ind., May 10.—All roads in Laporte county led to the Gunness farm Sunday, more than 1500 sight seers visiting before the sun set the place of death, the spot where the bodies of 11 persons have been dug up. Practically every able-bodied resi dent of the city made the trip, and the railroads and trolley lines brought about 4000 more to the city. Mayor Darrow found it necessary to ■K sue strict orders that the Sunday

Clipping to come

The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.

A woman arrested in Syracuse as a possible Belle Gunness was identified as Cora Belle Herron, widow of a Chicago chemical executive, and was released to continue her trip to New York. Separately, investigators in Laporte examined leads on missing suitor E. J. Tieflund and the farm's history, including a former outlaw occupant.

The Evening Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.

Carpenter Emil Greening describes mysterious male visitors to Mrs. Gunness's farm who were introduced as cousins and later vanished, leaving trunks behind. He also recounts the suspicious disappearance of his sweetheart Jennie Olsen, Gunness's adopted daughter, after being told she left with a 'professor' he never saw.

The Evening Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 1

CAME TO VISIT MRS. GUNNESS, SAYS GREENING

Woman’s Cousins. Jlsrpenter Who Worked on l.apnrte. Ind., Farm "Where Ten Rndire Hare Rcrii illumed Tells of Curious Hap pew lugs. Nays He Relieves That Many Mnrder» Were Done Kight l nder His Anae. Many Trunks Were Left Behind by the “Cousins." Opinions Differ on Question Whether Woman Is Dead or Alive. Oklahoma City, Okla., May 9. Emil Greening, a carpenter, and his brother Fred, a painter, both of whom worked last summer on Mrs. Gunness’s Indiana farm, told to-day of tho mysterious vis its of a dozen mon to the home of Mrs. Bella Gunness and of their more mys terious disappearance. .Jennie OTsen, the adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness. and who is missing, was Emil Greening’s sweetheart.

See the clipping

The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.

Emil Greening, former hired hand and Jennie's sweetheart, describes how Jennie vanished after Mrs. Gunness claimed a professor took her to California, though no one ever saw this man. He also details a pattern of male visitors, including one named Moo, who disappeared after leaving their trunks behind, with Greening sent on pointless errands while people went missing undetected.

The Evening Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 1

THEIR DEPARTURE

Emil Greening’s sweetheart. “Jennie and I were good friends. ’’ said Emil Greening to-day, "and when her mother announced one night that she had deided to • send Jennie to California with a professor, who she said had come after Jennie, but whom I never saw. Jennie cam« to me and declared she would never go. “In the morning I did not see Jennie. Jler mother told me that Jennie was still asleep, and when I returned from my er rand lam that afternoon I was told that Jennie had gone.

See moreSee less

I wrote to her. but I gave the two letters to Mrs. Gunness and I never received any answer. Finally 1 got so tired working around the place without seeing Jennie that I left. I don t believe there ever was a pro fessor, for I did not hear any man’s voice or see any strange man about the house at that time. "Mrs. Gtinncks later told me that Jennie had left at 4 o'clock that same morning, but no one saw her leave and no one al»out the place ever saw the professor. All the day following the disappearance of Jennie, Mrs. Gunness wan nervous.

See the clipping

The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.

A witness describes how various men who visited Mrs. Gunness, including one called 'Moo,' would disappear without anyone seeing them leave, leaving behind trunks and clothing. The report also notes officials remain divided on whether Mrs. Gunness died in the fire or is still alive.

The Evening Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 1

ANOTHER COUSIN MISSING

Alive or Bead Unsettled. Ewporlo, Ind., May 9.—Whether lira. Bella Gunness ia «til alive and subject to nrre it for alleged murdera committed on her farm near here or whether aha was burned with her three children in the fire which destroyed her home on April A la the problem that to-night loomed most prominently before the offi cers Investigating the mystery aurround tog tfie deaths of 10 persona whose bodies *ave been found burled in the Gunness barnyard. There la a division of opinion among the official* as to whether Mr* Gunness Is still alive.

See moreSee less

A majority of them believe •he was burned to death or that her body was partly Incinerated In that Are after gbp had been killed tjj some parson out* aid” the family. Previous assertions that Mra Gunness !• still alive were added to to-day by a BURCHARD “MENTIONED”

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

Diggers at the Gunness farm unearth a tenth skeleton, badly decomposed and possibly containing two bodies in one grave. The report also recounts suspicions about missing suitor Olaf Lindboe and daughter Myrtle Gunness's statement about being punished for entering the basement.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 11

THE HOUSE OF HORRORS' STILL SEARCHING FOR DEAD BODIES ON THE GUNNESS FARM

*aid he had returned to Norway. Myrtle Gunness was a school teacher and Jennie Garwood said Myrtle told her that her mother whipped her because she went tn । the basement of the house. This ( happened the day before the fire. Alongside of this last bunch of tames which showed burns, was to find the skull of the woman s . body found in the ruins of the ( house. The ashes in the cellar are ( to be screened in the effort to find some part of the skull. A Maxon , farm hand <ays Mrs. Gunness had planned to have the flower garden ( this ye; ron the spot where most , of the I» ••dies were found

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

Diggers at the Gunness farm uncover three more bodies on this day, bringing the total to twelve since Tuesday, with more unopened depressions found. The report also recounts suspicions about Olaf Limbo, a suitor who disappeared, and Myrtle Gunness's account of being punished for going into the basement.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 11

BODIES ON THE GUNNESS FARM

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

Following revelations from the Gunness 'House of Horrors' case in Laporte, Chicago's District Attorney Sims ordered the arrest of every manager of any matrimonial bureau in the city. The action was taken in direct response to the scandal's exposure of how such services could be exploited.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 11

MATRIMONIAL BUREAUS.

Once Occupied By Mrs. Gunness. lb Uno»! Chicago, Ills ~ May H. The police department today began dig ging in the yard of a place once oc ciipied by Mrs Gunness when «he

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

Sheriff Smutzer and deputies continue searching soft ground at the La Porte farm, expecting to find more than 20 bodies as evidence against Mrs. Gunness. State's attorney theorizes she headed a Chicago-based 'Murder Trust' that shipped victims to her after she seduced them.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 3

THE LA PORTE HORROR. Still Digging For Bodies Of Victims Of The "Murder Trust.” M. Uef«t Pr Latirte, Ind. May «.—Sheriff Smutzer and deputies an l digging • soft places" where it is exported other holies will be found as evidence against Mrs. Gunness. The sheriff believes more than 20 liodies will be uncovered. The evidence shows that this woman was either the head nr agent of a Murder Trust which operated in Chicago which shipped bodies to her for disposal. States at torney Smith believes the woman first made love to her victims and then killed them when they wen unsuspecting. She weighed 225 pounds and could easily overpower men.

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

A short notice reports that officials are watching for Mrs. Gunness, who is charged with wholesale murder at her home near La Porte, Indiana. The item gives no further detail beyond the charge and the search for her.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 3

WATCHING FOR MRS. GUNNESS Who Is Charged With Wholesale Murder Al Her Home Near La Porte. Ind. II» United Prv»» La Porto, May 7.—The sheriff

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

The La Porte sheriff telegraphed New York authorities to watch for Belle Gunness, believed to be fleeing to Norway, while watches found in the ruins may help identify victims. Coroner Mack reported earlier victims showed fractured skulls while later ones were apparently asphyxiated, and love letters to Andrew Helgelien plus a witness statement about Ray Lamphere threatening to burn the place were also revealed.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 3

La Porte. Ind. II» United Prv»» La Porto, May 7.—The sheriff telegraphed the New York author ¡lies to watch for Mrs. Belle Gun ness at whose house of horrors more than a dozen bodies were found. She is believed to be enroute to Norway. । Six mens watches and one worn ans watch were found in the ruins of the Gunncss home. A circular will be sent out containing the case numbers in hope that the (jodies may be identified. Coroner Mack declared the bodies which were evidently killed earlier, show ed signs of fractured skulls, those killed later, have no such indica ' tion.

See moreSee less

They evidently were asphyx1 iated. Mrs. Gunness letters to Andrew Helgaline are full of pro • testations of love. One read: ••Come to me. your bride awaits, wo shall lie happy here as King and Queen in the most beautiful home in Northern Indiana Bessie Conklin. Kay Lamphers sweetheart, is being held as a 1 witness reported that «he said to Lamphere that hr would get even with Gunness and burn the place over her head. Because of the wet ground but little progress wa« ¡made today in the search for more IxMiies.

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

A coroner's careful scientific examination of a recovered body has led officials to generally believe it is that of Belle Gunness, confirmed by a local doctor who knew her. The sheriff continues digging at the ruined house and plans to plow the private graveyard, though no further bodies have been found.

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 1

UNSOLVING MYSTERY OF THE LA PORTE "HOUSE OF HORRORS."

Mrs. Gunness. By UsiU*d Pr Laporte, Ind. May 9. —After a careful and scientific examination of the body held by the coroner it is now generally sup|>osed to be that or Mrs Beile Gunness. Dr. Hardy ' H. laong, of Laporte who krew the | woman stated that the burned , torso was that of the mistress of the “House of Horrors.’ The I sheriff is still digging, but there is little hope of other bodies being 1 found. • At noon no more imdies were I found. The ruins of the house will be cleared and digging will begin in the cellar.

See moreSee less

The private graveyard is to be plowed. Lamp here became hysterical during the i night and said he saw the vision of a woman, who is down south i somewhere.

See the clipping

Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.

Mrs. Etta Rockefeller of New York confirms that the woman arrested on a sleeper train at Syracuse is her sister, formerly Mrs. Herron, whose husband died in a Vicksburg asylum. The report states Mrs. Gunness was arrested at 12:29 last night on the New York Central sleeper at Syracuse.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Laredo Weekly Times · 10 May 1908 · page 1

MRS ETTA ROCKEFELLER. Identifies Woman Arrested At Syracuse For Mrs. Gunness Her Friend By ! IT-” New York. N Y . May 9. —Mrs Etta Rockefeller to whom Mrs. Herron, telegraphed for inden tification. Mid Mr*. Herron and ! my mother were on their way here 'to make their home with me. What Mrs. Herron says is true Her husband diet! at Vicksburg. Miss., m a private asylum Mrs. Rock efeller. has a telegram announcing Mr. Herron s death. ''he was shocked at her sister* predicament. Mrs. Gunness was arrested at 12^9 last night on the New York i Central sleeper at Syracuse.

See the clipping

In the story →

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

The report asserts that the badly burned body found in the ruins is beyond doubt that of Belle Gunness, dismissing rumors to the contrary as spread by enemies of La Porte county officials. It also notes a Syracuse woman mistakenly arrested as Gunness was quickly released after proving her identity, and relays a reader's letter claiming Gunness descended from the same family as Kate Bender.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

BODY IN RUINS MRS. GUNNESS BEYOND DOUBT

Rumors to the Contrary Started by Enemies of County Officials.

See moreSee less

WOMAN ARRESTED AT SYRACUSE RELEASED

LA PORTE MURDERESS SAID TO BE DESCENDANT OF SAME MAN AS KATE BENDER.

Syracuse, N. Y., May 9.—Mrs. Cora Belle Herron, widow of Frederick B. Herron, former president of the Sethness Chemical company of Chicago, who was arrested by Syracuse detectives in a Pullman sleeper this morning on suspicion of being Mrs. Belle Gunness, the Laporte alleged murderess, was quickly able to prove her identity and went on to New York this afternoon.

An effort was made to have her sign papers releasing the city of Syracuse from liability for her arrest, which she characterized as "an outrage without the shadow of an excuse."

Louisville, Ky., May 9.—The editor of a Louisville afternoon paper today received the following unsigned communication in the mails:

Louisville, Ky., May 9.—"Dear Mr. Editor: I do not like my name to be known, hence I will not give it, but will tell you that the notorious Mrs. Gunness is descended from the same man as was Kate Bender of Kansas notoriety. Kate's father was also a brother to Mrs. Gunness' grandfather. I know this through my marriage ties.

"In my opinion Ray Lamphere is kin to Mrs. Gunness."

Laporte, Ind., May 9.—The dissensions which have been brewing among the officials of the city and county of Laporte interested in the solving of the mysteries of the Gunness farm, broke out today. It is openly charged that the political affiliations of some of the men concerned has much to do with their attitude towards the labors of the sheriff and the prosecuting attorney and a factional fight in the party to which the latter belongs is blamed also.

The widespread reports that evidence had been found tending to prove that the corpse supposed to be that of Mrs. Belle Gunness is in reality the body of another woman are said to have had their origin in the camp of the defense, the members of which are of opposite political faith to the sheriff and of the faction opposing the prosecutor.

Denied Issuing Statement.

These reports had their origin in a statement said to have been given out by Dr. H. P. Long, a former coroner, and one of the four physicians who performed the autopsies on the bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness home. Dr. Long, however, said today that he had not issued such a statement, but had merely expressed a personal opinion that he was not satisfied as to the identity of the corpse in question.

Two other members of the board refused to be drawn into the controversy, but Dr. J. H. William Meyer, the fourth member, said that he had no doubt but what the corpse was that of Mrs. Gunness. He, too, however, declined to reveal the findings of the physicians.

Report Changed by Coroner.

The attitude of the coroner as between the two factions, has not become manifest. At the prosecuting attorney's office, however, it was asserted that Dr. Mack, the coroner, had changed the first report as to the identity of the Gunness body and an inspection of the documents showed this to be the case.

All four doctors were unanimous as to the facts and conditions surrounding the bodies taken from the Gunness home.

Agreed as to the Facts.

"There was absolutely no difference among us," said one of the doctors, and this was confirmed by other members of the board. There is absolutely no indication that the skull of any of the bodies of the three children bore penetrating wounds. It has been asserted that fractures caused by some blunt instrument had been found on these sku[l]ls. Neither was there any kind of brain hemorrhages and the heart and lungs of at least two of the children revealed the same conditions found in these organs in the body of their mother. The hearts were all dilated and full of clots and the lungs had collapsed. This condition is found in the cases of persons who have died from suffocation and the circumstances is taken as another evidence that the theory regarding Mrs. Gunness having killed her children, substituted another woman's body for her own and then escaped after setting fire to the house is not tenable.

Heat Would Shrink the Body.

One of the alleged circumstances upon which that theory is based, is the fact that the body of the woman is much smaller than Mrs. Gunness was. The intense heat to which the corpses were subjected, according to Dr. Meyer, would, however, fully account for this circumstance.

Mrs. Gunness was an abnormally large woman in every particular. When the corpse was cut open a layer of fat two inches thick still existed over the abdomen.

Still further evidence that the body was that of Mrs. Gunness was found in the fact that the remains of a finger ring which she is known to have worn, were found in the ashes several days later. The buckle of a money belt, such as the woman is known to have used, was also picked up and later still a key which corresponds to the lock on her safety deposit box was discovered in the basement.

For the first time since Sheriff Smutzer began work on the farm he failed today to discover at least one additional body. Excavations were made at several points in the barnyard, but in none of them was there indications of human bones or flesh.

The search for bodies is to be abandoned, for a few days at least, the sheriff announcing that he will endeavor to secure additional evidence regarding the identity of the corpses found in the basement. With this object in view, he has employed Louis Schultz, who was formerly a miner, to sluice the ashes in the cellar, in the hope that additional metallic relics of Mrs. Gunness will be found. The gold filling which she is said to have had in several of her teeth, is to be an especial object of this search.

Search Not Abandoned.

The sheriff is not convinced that he has found all of the bodies which have been buried on the farm, but he has not fully determined the method by which he will conduct further explorations.

The crowds of visitors to the farm and the city were augmented today. In the city there was a constant stream of morbid sightseers visiting the morgues, where ten of the fourteen bodies are lying.

The sheriff received today several inquiries from outside points regarding missing persons who may have been among the victims of Mrs. Gunness. None of these was connected directly with the farm, the fears of their relatives being based upon circumstantial evidence.

New evidence regarding Lamphere's alleged connection with the deaths at the farm were also discovered. The more important of these were William Slatter and John Rye. The latter asserts that on the day when Helgelein is supposed to have been killed, he and Lamphere drove to Michigan City. They returned at night, and Lamphere alighted when they reached a point opposite the Gunness farm and cut across the fields toward it, remarking that there would be "something doing" there that night.

Slatter and Lamphere occupied the same bed on many occasions following the prisoner's dismissal from the Gunness establishment. He says that Lamphere told him that he had run Helgelein out of Mrs. Gunness' house at the point of a revolver on one occasion, but that the South Dakotan returned later and remained.

Insisted Upon Currency.

A deposition was made here today by Frank J. Pitner, cashier of the First National bank of Laporte, who handled the transactions by which Helgelein collected $2,890 from the bank in Mansfield, S. D. Pitner asserts that Mrs. Gunness accompanied Helgelein on his visits to the bank and when the money was withdrawn, refused to let her visitor take a cashier's check in part payment. Mrs. Gunness insisted that currency only should figure in the transaction.

Search was instituted today for traces of E. J. Tiefland, a resident of Minneapolis, who is said to have come here about a year ago. An advertisement in a Minneapolis newspaper is said to have been the lure by which Tiefland was led to open correspondence with Mrs. Gunness.

Asle K. Helgelein, whose insistence that his brother had been murdered, caused the first excavating to be done on the death farm, departed for his home in Mansfield, S. D., this evening, after he had made arrangements to have the body of his brother given a Christian burial.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

An anonymous letter to a Louisville editor claims Belle Gunness is related to the notorious Kate Bender and suggests Ray Lamphere is also kin. Meanwhile in Laporte, political infighting among officials is blamed for interference in the investigation, amid persistent rumors that the body found may not be Mrs. Gunness but another woman.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

AS KATE BENDER

Transcript to come.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Conflicting reports claim evidence shows the corpse found in the Gunness ruins is not Belle Gunness but another woman, with rival political factions trading accusations. Dr. Long denies issuing a statement doubting identity though admits personal doubts, while another physician insists the body is Gunness's, and the coroner is accused of altering his original report.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

Sheriff Smutzer's excavation at the farm found no new bodies after barnyard digging, so the search is suspended for a few days while more evidence is sought. Former miner Louis Schultz is hired to sluice the basement ashes, hoping to find metallic relics like gold dental fillings to confirm Belle Gunness's identity among the remains.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

BODY IN RUINS MRS GUNNESS BEYOND DOUBT

Rather convincing proof that Mrs Gunness is dead will not prevent amateur sleuths from locating her in dif ferent parts of the world whenever

Clipping to come

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

New evidence has emerged regarding Ray Lamphere's alleged connection to the deaths at the Gunness farm, with witnesses William Slatter and John Rye coming forward. Rye claims that on the day Helgelein is believed to have been killed, he and Lamphere drove to Michigan City, and upon returning Lamphere headed toward the farm saying something would happen there that night.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah

A witness testifies that Lamphere shared his bed and claimed to have run Helgelein off Gunness's property at gunpoint, though Helgelein later returned. A bank cashier's deposition reveals Mrs. Gunness insisted Helgelein withdraw his $2,890 in cash rather than a cashier's check, while authorities search for another suitor, E.J. Tiefland.

The Salt Lake Herald · 10 May 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

A carpenter named Emil Greening, who worked on the Gunness farm, recounts how his sweetheart Jennie Olson vanished suddenly after supposedly being sent to California with a mysterious professor he never saw. He grew suspicious after never receiving replies to his letters and recalls hearing no man's voice in the house despite the claimed visitor.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 1

EMPLOYE WHO WORKED FOR MRS. BELLE GUNNESS OF LA PORTE TELLS STARTLING STORY. SUITORS CAME OPENLY, NOT SEEN TO LEAVE. SOME LEFT TRUNKS IN HOUSE OF SIREN WHO LURED EXPECTANT LOVERS TO DEATH.

SgKLAHOMA OTTT, May P. Here, twying because ho can not hear from ;?hurie Olson, 17 years old and protly, gWadopfced daughter of Mrs. Hello iinness, -whoso murdered bod3 has TgjSi found near Laporte, Tnd., "Emil ehing, a carpenter, and Iub brother a painter, who both worked last arjmier on tho farm, tell stories of the ijpts of mysterious ' men to tho wo OTafs house and their nrj-stcrious dis

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

A former hired hand named Greening recounts how Jennie Olson vanished suddenly after being told she was going to California with a mysterious professor no one ever saw. He also describes a parade of male visitors to Mrs. Gunness's farm, including a man named Moo, who arrived with trunks but were never seen leaving.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 1

NOT SEEN TO LEAVE

SjfBeeu to leavo the plarn, 3S$ Left Trunks Behind. ilrjManv men that came brought tlieir Sijinks with them and tliey rareb" took trunks away. We never knew 'lien to expect these fellows, but they Ufi08t always had inonev. tjpi&Mrs. Gunness kept them with her ijailtho time in the parlors and her rooms. She was alwa-s careful to SSiTke the children stay away from her aUiu6. who rarely tried to show them S'VRff&ffection. pLfter Jennie left the visitors wore lapsed to occupv her room, which .(fhfgext to mine, but J. was never able jotmear them at night.

See moreSee less

jttfnpver knew of Mrs. Gu'Miess be-jjii-'fing her afTections "upon any of her hands, except Kay Lampiicro. .faSfSo many men came, and I saw so fjtfjleiof them, that T cannot remember irgjty of them, but I distinctly reniem ''Msybv. Moo, who came from Chicago Ji'day before Christmas, 190(5. Ho itTimwith Mrs. Gunness almost contrfTfvVhen he left his trunks stayed bc- - fl??au(l uo oue savv h'n) R was rfcjral days before Mrs. Gunness ad r sfc'd that he was goue. .'itphortJv afterward Mrs. Gunness ,jfejmo to Michigan City to got a jtfCfc.tlhat she saia Moo had promised ,ff. ?te her. I took a day to make the rfi&W Wlien I got to Michigan City '5jf (Ifilting was wrong, and I was told j'.wme back for tho horse later. iosf'-R Another "Cousin" Gono.

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

A farmhand recounts how various men, called 'cousins,' visited Belle Gunness and then mysteriously disappeared without anyone seeing them leave, leaving trunks and clothing behind. He also recalls being suspicious of a fenced-off garden area she never allowed hands to enter.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 1

iosf'-R Another "Cousin" Gono. Jf'jjfeut when I returned to the farm rarcr cous'n TS'no was thcro when I ih'-M&yvRti gone. ,h about two weeks was again -" to Michigan City and still tnere no horse, but when I got back au 'pJ,J .f cousin was missing and no one y?;n ft the place had seen him leave. -,$3; loo's trunk was in the Gunness -i ;Julv 11, 1007. when I left tho Flrtjf A Bis wasn't the only ono. There jjjitt? kabout 1.1 other trunks and one -21 r; was parked full of all kinds of , clothing. Mrs. Gunness said ---wf.the cousins had left their clothes

See the clipping

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

Investigators gathered new evidence linking Ray Lamphere to deaths at the Gunness farm, including witness accounts from John Poe and William Slatter about Lamphere's suspicious remarks and admissions. A bank cashier also testified that Mrs. Gunness insisted Andrew Helgelein withdraw his funds in cash rather than by check.

The Salt Lake Tribune · 10 May 1908 · page 2

\ Katy conductor is authority for the statement that Mrs. Gunness, the several times a murderess, recently eii'i red I'ort Worth on his train. Fort Worth et his to be getting everything. As I: · spi. ndid quality of Wax aba· hi·· inineia' water becomes more generally known the number of h'-.iltt: e-kei incTi.i · and the lie ces sit y for better hotel facilities grow.- Ά'·· n't lo-iii;· a deal. I/*t's build it now.

Clipping to come

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn. · and 2 other papers

Only three of eleven bodies found at the Gunness farm have been identified, and crowds gather as digging resumes despite investigators having few clues to the unidentified remains. Separately, it's revealed that Mrs. Gunness's first husband Mads Sorenson died suspiciously just before one insurance policy lapsed and after a new one took effect.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: The San Francisco Call, 10 May 1908, The Salt Lake Herald, 10 May 1908.

The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 11 May 1908 · page 2

HIS DEATH WELL TIMED

Mrs. Gunness, and appeared nervous and held aloof from the other pas sengers. The conductor said the wo man’s ticket showed she went to St.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 2 papers
  • The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D. · 9 May 1908
  • Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D. · 14 May 1908

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

An estimated 15,000 people visited the Gunness farm near La Porte, Indiana, where bodies had been unearthed, with vendors selling souvenir postcards and lemonade amid a carnival-like atmosphere. Investigation for more bodies was halted for the day as officers became mere spectators to the crowds.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 3

ALL WORK IS SUSPENDED

St. Louis Interested. St. Louis, Mo., May 16. —A woman answering in every detail the descrip tion of Mrs. Belle Gunness of La porte, Ind., is believed by union sta tion officials to have passed through here last Saturday night. The wo man first attracted attention on leav ing St. Louis by her extreme nervous, ness and which was noticed by the trainmen and passengers. She pur chased a Pullman ticket at St. Louis and left her berth only onco during the entire trip to Fort Worth, Tex., where she disappeared.

Clipping to come

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala. · and 1 other paper

Sightseers flocked to the La Porte farm amid a carnival-like atmosphere of vendors and souvenir postcards, even as digging for more bodies was halted for the day. Sheriff Smutzer plans to resume excavation, autopsy reports are pending, and Lamphere's defense team floats a theory that Mrs. Gunness killed her children and substituted another woman's body before fleeing.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 3

ALL WORK IS SUSPENDED

Victims Buried. Laporte, Ind., May 16—The burial last night of Andrew K. Helgeleln marks the beginning of the final stage ol the Gunness farm mysteries so far as human knowledge is con

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • St. Tammany Farmer · Covington, La. · 16 May 1908

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

Examining physicians say they are ready to report findings on four bodies to the coroner, who is undecided on a joint or individual report and wants the inquest kept open for more evidence. Meanwhile, Ray Lamphere's defense plans to investigate a nearby cemetery under a theory that Gunness faked her death, while Chicago police consider excavating her former residence and report dozens of claimed sightings of her alive.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 3

ern university, and is a son of Dr. and Mrs. W. F. Whyte of this city. May Be Gunness Victim. Delatield.— Friends of Frank Med inger, a well-known young fanner of the town if Delafield. who disappeared in ll'd", when he went to Indiana to marry a woman with whom ho became acquaintt and through a matrimonial ad vert isomer, t, believe that he was a vic tim of Mrs. Belle thinness, the I.a port©. Indiana, alleged murderess, ami '!i, German consul at Chicago will he asked to investigate.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

An estimated fifteen thousand sightseers visited the Belle Gunness farm near La Porte, Indiana, on the first Sunday after news of the murders broke, overwhelming local hotels and transportation. The investigation for more bodies was halted for the day as officers themselves became spectators amid a carnival-like atmosphere of vendors and souvenir sales.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Montgomery Advertiser · 11 May 1908 · page 6

VISIT GUINNESS FARM FIFTEEN THOUSAND PEOPLE ATTRACTED TO PLACE.

ern university, and is a son of Dr. and Mrs. W. F. Whyte of this city. May Be Gunness Victim. Delatield.— Friends of Frank Med inger, a well-known young fanner of the town if Delafield. who disappeared in ll'd", when he went to Indiana to marry a woman with whom ho became acquaintt and through a matrimonial ad vert isomer, t, believe that he was a vic tim of Mrs. Belle thinness, the I.a port©. Indiana, alleged murderess, ami '!i, German consul at Chicago will he asked to investigate.

Clipping to come

The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.

Sheriff Smutzer plans further excavation at the Gunness farm, including the cellar floor, while four physicians prepare autopsy reports for the coroner, who hesitates to close the inquest. Lamphere's defense team announces plans to investigate a nearby cemetery, floating a theory that Mrs. Gunness killed her children and placed another woman's body to fake her own death before fleeing.

The Montgomery Advertiser · 11 May 1908 · page 6

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

More than 15,000 sightseers flocked to the Gunness farm, halting the official investigation as officials became mere spectators. Sheriff Smulzer plans to resume searching tomorrow, sifting ashes for gold tooth fillings and digging the cellar floor further where ten bodies have already been found.

Arizona Republican · 11 May 1908 · page 4

THE MORBID BY THOUSANDS

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

A brief news item reports that investigators now believe Mrs. Gunness died in the farmhouse fire, shifting from earlier suspicions she had escaped. It notes that a farmhand connected to the woman has given a statement to authorities.

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 11 May 1908 · page 8

WORKING AT MYSTERY Mrs. Gunness Now Believed to Have Died In Fire. WOMAN'S FARMHAND TALKS.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

The report claims evidence now proves Belle Gunness died in the fire, with her body among those found in the ruins. It also describes conflicting medical opinions on body identification and a witness claiming to have seen Lamphere fleeing the scene.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 10 May 1908, The Pensacola Journal, 10 May 1908, Tonopah Daily Bonanza, 10 May 1908.

Wrong

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 11 May 1908 · page 8

WOMAN'S FARMHAND TALKS.

POTTEItS FIELD FOII VICTIMS The burial last night of Andrew M. He!gele!n marked the beginning of the final stags of the Gunness farm mysteries so tar as human knowledge is concerned. Two more corpses, sup posed to have been those of Jennie and Ole O. Budsberg, hay« been partially, identified, but to the Iden tity of the remaining cadavers no clew exists that gives promise of fulfill ment. The relics taken from the death farm.* such as watches and rings, m*y ultimately lead to the determination that Rome certain missing Individual \u25a0was caught la the Gunness trap, but this will give almost no aid in Identify ing any particular body.

See moreSee less

The potters Seld is most likely to be the ultimate resting place of these seven bodies. Yesterday witnessed two conclusive findings regarding the bodies unearthed In the barnyard or taken from the smoldering ruins of the farmhouse. One by th<? dentist who bridged Mrs. Outness* lower jaw with artificial tf-th and established that the piece of Jaw bnr.e found in. the ruins was from her skull: th<i other subscribed to by three experts show thct the first body tftken from the barnyard of the farm v.r iS that of Andrew Helgelein.

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Connecticut

Lamphere's attorneys claim proof that someone else set the Gunness house fire, a confederate in her murders, while prosecutors have a secret witness who saw Lamphere fleeing the scene. The body's identity remains unconfirmed by medical experts, fueling theories Belle Gunness staged her own death using another woman's corpse.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 11 May 1908 · page 8

METHOD OF DEATH UNSOLVED The finality of these conclusions s^2<ss f«v.- ms jor matters which are capable of to be brought to light. The methods by which the vic tims of the farm were put to death probably may never be known; to date tlicre is a total lack of ovidenc* on thic point. Tho identity of the seven corpses remaining unknown is another puzzle, and the extent to which Ray Lamphere shared in the secrets of Mrs. Gunness a third. Only the last of these may be determined, and until the man is taken to trial and either acquitted or < or.victed nothing approaching cer tainty will be known on this point.

See moreSee less

The state insists that it has positive evidence against Lajnphere. and the de fense as positively states that the prisoner cannot be proven guilty. The circumstances which have become known are almost equally balanced so far as Lamphere's part In the tragedy is concerned, and ludtcial process only can make clear thejr relative value. The case has. in short, reached a stage where only the, courts, through grand Jury and open trial proceedings, can be relied upon to settl« the questions which anto be brought before them. The grand jury, it is announced, will begin to investigate the «vidence gath ered by Sheriff Smulzer and Prosecutor Smith Monday. Its findings, however, Till shed little light on the subject and the details of Its deliberations are not likely to become known.

Clipping to come

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

A special dispatch from La Porte reports that a gold band ring and keys found on the charred corpse confirm it is Belle Gunness, who died in the fire that destroyed her farmhouse along with her three children. The district attorney had withheld this evidence because it strengthens the case against Ray Lamphere, the farmhand suspected of the killings and fire.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The San Francisco Call · 11 May 1908 · page 7

MRS. GUNNESS PAID PENALTY OF DEATH Gold Band Ring Found on Finger of Corpse Proves Identity of Murderess SPECIAL DISPATCH . TO THE CALL LA PORTE, Ind.. May 10. — Mrs. Belle Gunness paid the penalty of her 10 or more fiendish murders in the fire; that destroyed her charnel house on the morning of April 28. The woman's body," burned almost beyond j recogni tlon.that was dug from the ruins with those . of her three children, • has been identified so positively as to leave no doubt in the mind, of any -one who knows the evidence which the authori ties of La Porte county haVe been con cealing from the public- \u25a0 It was learned today, direct from Dis trict Attorney Ralph X.

See moreSee less

Smith that -a gold band ring found on the finger of the charred corpse has been identified positively as that worn by Mrs. Gun ness. The woman's keys also were found In the ruins near the body and were identified by the . one which un locked her safe deposit box In the local bank, in which she placed $700 on the Saturday before she was killed. District Attorney Smith's reason for guarding this information ao< closely was that the circumstantial evidence pointed so clearly to Ray Lamphere. the former man of all work at the mur der farm, that it was considered of vital importance that the state's case against him should not be disclosed. CROWDS VISIT FARM All roads In La Porte county led to the Guuness farm today, more than 1,500 sight seers visiting the place of death before the sun set. Practically every able bodied resident of this city made the trip and the railroads "and trolley lines brought about 4,000 more to the city. • Majyr Darrow found it necessary to issue orders that the Sunday closing laws should be strictly enforced, and the hotels and restaurants were.over run with patrons. Practically every conveyance in the town' was pressed Into service in an attempt to provide transportation for the crowds. The constant stream of carriages, cabs, omnibuses, automobiles, motor cycles, bicycles,. farm wagons and car ryalls points unmistakable directions to those who were unable to obtain places -in the conveyances and were compelled to walk. .

See the clipping

The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.

Sightseers flocked to the Gunness farm for a festive outing, treating the site of gruesome murders like a fairground with picnics, lemonade stands, and souvenir postcards. Vendors sold group photos of Mrs. Gunness and the children who died with her, while nearby a baseball park drew additional crowds.

The San Francisco Call · 11 May 1908 · page 7

PICNICS HELD ON LAW.

of souvenir postal _ cards, those bearIng a group picture of Mrs. Gunness and the . three little ones; who met deaths with her " finding the readiest sale. . . . . : A baseball park in the vicinity was represented by strong voiced barkers, who indicated to the jaded sight seers the place for fresh . entertainment.

See the clipping

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A news summary briefly notes that the Gunness farm at Laporte, described as a death trap for nearly a score of victims, has been turned into a picnic ground. Sightseers are now visiting with ball games and other entertainment provided on the property.

Los Angeles Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

that of Andrew Helgeleln. The finality of these conclusions leaves few major matters which are capable of solution to be brought to light. The methods by which the vic tims of the farm were put to death' probably may never be known. Today there is a total lack of evidence on this point. The Identity of the seven corpses remaining unknown is another puzzle, and the extent to which Lamphere shared In the secrets of Mrs. Gunness is a third. Only the last of these may be determined, and until the man is brought to trial and either acquitted or convicted nothing approaching certainty will be known on this point.

See moreSee less

The state asserts that It has positive evidence against I-.amphere and the de fense as positively states that the prisoner cannot be proven guilty.. Courts Must Decide The circumstances which have be come known are almost equally bal anced, so far as Lamphere's part in the tragedy Is concerned, and Judicial pro

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

An estimated 15,000 sightseers visited the Gunness farm near LaPorte, overwhelming local transportation and officials, while authorities' own investigation was effectively halted by the crush of onlookers. Among the crowd, relatives of missing men sought information, including a Chicago man inquiring about his brother Thomas Lindbo, a former farmhand who had allegedly planned to marry Mrs. Gunness.

Los Angeles Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

THOUSANDS SEEK TRACE OF VICTIMS SIGHTSEERS MINGLE WITH ANXIOUS RELATIVES PICNIC PARTIES ENJOY DAY AT GRUESOME PLACE

that of Andrew Helgeleln. The finality of these conclusions leaves few major matters which are capable of solution to be brought to light. The methods by which the vic tims of the farm were put to death' probably may never be known. Today there is a total lack of evidence on this point. The Identity of the seven corpses remaining unknown is another puzzle, and the extent to which Lamphere shared In the secrets of Mrs. Gunness is a third. Only the last of these may be determined, and until the man is brought to trial and either acquitted or convicted nothing approaching certainty will be known on this point.

See moreSee less

The state asserts that It has positive evidence against I-.amphere and the de fense as positively states that the prisoner cannot be proven guilty.. Courts Must Decide The circumstances which have be come known are almost equally bal anced, so far as Lamphere's part in the tragedy Is concerned, and Judicial pro

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

An estimated 15,000 visitors converged on Belle Gunness's La Porte farm on the first Sunday after news of the murders broke, turning the site into a carnival with food stands and souvenir postcards. The official search for more bodies was halted for the day as sheriffs became spectators themselves amid the chaotic crowds.

New-York Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 2

For the Defense. La Porte, Ind., May Hi The board of county commissioners, after a bit ter debate here today, in which the conviction was expressed by its mem bers that Mrs. Belle Gunness is still alive, appropriated .f.(K;o to be spent clearing up the mystery of the "House of Death." When an attempt was tna.de in the city council to obtain an appropriation of $14,000 to pay detec tives, coroners, special assistants and providefor the expenses of the trial Of Ray Lamphere, unexpected opposi tion was developed. John G. Mat thews, one of the most potential mem bers of the body, declared he did not believe Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness was dead and in sisted that all of his neighbors and friends were of the same opinion. Mr. Matthews has a wide acquaintance End his statement indicates very near ly the trend of public opinion on the Gunness case in. Laporte county.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Sightseers crowded the La Porte farm, buying souvenir postcards and causing a runaway buggy accident, while pickpockets worked the crowd. Sheriff Smutzer paused excavation for the day but planned to resume sifting ashes and digging for gold teeth and more bodies tomorrow.

New-York Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 2

THRONG GUNNESS FARM

Thinks She Lives. Matthews argued it was ridiculous to suppose Mrs. (Junness's head could tiave been burned off her body, while the heads of her c hildren were scarcely tnore than scorched. "What sense is there in appropriat ing money to pay detectives who insist &.t the start that Mrs. Gunness is dead," remarked a member of the Council. This attitude of Matthews started a tiot discussion that lasted all day. The Gunness case in all the phases of the mystery were discussed. In its final net ion the council agreed upon a com promise resolution appropriating .?!, passed to stand reading which practically amounts to its final adop tion.

See moreSee less

Of $!,KK, $r,MX was appropri ated for the county commissioners, Hvho are to use it as they desire in tin ravelins the mystery, but "it is tacit ly understood most of the $,.hh is to be offered for the apprehension of Mrs. Gunness.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

On the first Sunday after news broke, over 15,000 sightseers descended on the La Porte farm of Belle Gunness, treating the site of alleged mass murder as a carnival with vendors and souvenir postcards. The official search for more bodies was halted for the day, though visitors seeking missing relatives provided some leads on victim identities.

New-York Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 2

Must Show Proof. To earn the reward proffered on these terms, it will be necessary for the detectives to prove Mrs. Gunness Is alive and return her into court. It Is admitted by the attorneys for the prosecution and defense that the trial tf Lamphere may last for weeks, so tnany elements of uncertainty have arisen. Proof throughout must be cir cumstantial. The defense believes it will be able to shut off the so-called ponfession made to the Rev. Mr. fcchell. Sheriff Smutzer is in receipt of a letter from I.

See moreSee less

X. Youster of Carper, NVyo.. who tells his interesting experi ence on the Gunness farm. He says he once visited Mrs. Gunness's home With $70O in currency and sr.cn in drafts in his pocket. He was a ped dler. Mrs. Gunness's children were Dice to him and Mrs. Gunness told them to go away and not pay any at tention to the old man. The writer fays he is convinced he would have been murdered for his money, but for the fact that his shabby clothes con cealed his prosperity. Sheriff Smutzer was amazed today to discover that the supposed Chicago City detective, in whom he had trusted Is really in the employe of the defense. J?mutzer and his deputies had given the man all the information regarding the case against Lamphere in the pos session of the sheriff's office. Coun ty Prosecutor looks upon this piece of Strategy on the part of the attorneys for Lamphere as both a calamity ana End an outrage.

Clipping to come

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Sightseers crowded the La Porte farm amid a carnival-like atmosphere of vendors and souvenir sellers, while pickpockets worked the crowd and an accident injured a woman. Sheriff Smutzer paused body recovery due to the throng but planned to resume searching ashes and the cellar floor for evidence, including Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings.

New-York Tribune · 11 May 1908 · page 2

THRONG GUNNESS FARM.

changed, we'll bet the bananas that Governor Noel, of Mississippi, reniged. Rich people who now and Uu n make propositions to give certain s, provided poor people will come across with like amounts, should cut the strings and make their donations regardless. . jr a z ; ' ' = If Mrs. Gunness had only adver tised herself as a red-headed widow, with dimpled cheeks, she might have converted the whole state of Indiana Into a cemetery. Joe Bailey's victory in Texas was probably nothing to brag about, but If Bryan does as well in November the country will be saved.

See moreSee less

Governor John A. Johnson's thrill ing rescue of the South from the clutches of Mr. Bryan will not be staged this season. > man prefers to he lied An Afternoon Newspaper. With this issue, the Daily News abandons the morning Held and be comes an afternoon newspaper. This change has been under consideration for several weeks, but per manent arrangements for the change were not Consummated until yester day, when arrangements were made with the Hearst News Service for the full afternoon report of that great news agency. As a morning newspaper, the Dally News has done well—better than mlgth have been expected under the trying business conditions of the past six months. But there are several serious obstacles In the way In the first place, it of morning newspaper publication in Hattiesburg, has been impossible to secure electric power service to drive presses and typesetting machinery from 2 to 4 o'clock each morning. Just at the time During the late hours of the when most needed by a morning paper, night, when the electric plant is running, the direct current is irregu lar and unreliable and has necessitated much provoking delay and need 50c less expense. When the News first entered the morning field. It was assured that the all night power service would be furnished within a short time, but subsequent conditions have prevented the construction of the new plant and the service has not Improved. All newspaper readers know that It costs more money to Issue a morn Men will not work at Ing paper than to print an afternoon edition, Lights are ex night for the same salaries they receive for day labor, pensive and the newspaper office which remains open all night consumes lots of electricity. These and other reasons have impelled the present management to make the change. And we have no apologies to offer. As an afternoon paper, the News will continue to print the NEWS, and all of It. Editorially, it will remain fair, but fearless—earnestly en deavoring at all times to promote the best Interests of Hattiesburg and South Mississippi.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A doctor in Laporte, Indiana recalls being called to examine an infant in the Gunness household who appeared only mildly ill, then was summoned again at 2 a.m. to find the baby dead, with symptoms he attributed to pulmonary edema. Authorities now suspect the child was actually strangled and its death falsely certified, adding it to the list of Belle Gunness's suspected murders.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

changed, we'll bet the bananas that Governor Noel, of Mississippi, reniged. Rich people who now and Uu n make propositions to give certain s, provided poor people will come across with like amounts, should cut the strings and make their donations regardless. . jr a z ; ' ' = If Mrs. Gunness had only adver tised herself as a red-headed widow, with dimpled cheeks, she might have converted the whole state of Indiana Into a cemetery. Joe Bailey's victory in Texas was probably nothing to brag about, but If Bryan does as well in November the country will be saved.

See moreSee less

Governor John A. Johnson's thrill ing rescue of the South from the clutches of Mr. Bryan will not be staged this season. > man prefers to he lied An Afternoon Newspaper. With this issue, the Daily News abandons the morning Held and be comes an afternoon newspaper. This change has been under consideration for several weeks, but per manent arrangements for the change were not Consummated until yester day, when arrangements were made with the Hearst News Service for the full afternoon report of that great news agency. As a morning newspaper, the Dally News has done well—better than mlgth have been expected under the trying business conditions of the past six months. But there are several serious obstacles In the way In the first place, it of morning newspaper publication in Hattiesburg, has been impossible to secure electric power service to drive presses and typesetting machinery from 2 to 4 o'clock each morning. Just at the time During the late hours of the when most needed by a morning paper, night, when the electric plant is running, the direct current is irregu lar and unreliable and has necessitated much provoking delay and need 50c less expense. When the News first entered the morning field. It was assured that the all night power service would be furnished within a short time, but subsequent conditions have prevented the construction of the new plant and the service has not Improved. All newspaper readers know that It costs more money to Issue a morn Men will not work at Ing paper than to print an afternoon edition, Lights are ex night for the same salaries they receive for day labor, pensive and the newspaper office which remains open all night consumes lots of electricity. These and other reasons have impelled the present management to make the change. And we have no apologies to offer. As an afternoon paper, the News will continue to print the NEWS, and all of It. Editorially, it will remain fair, but fearless—earnestly en deavoring at all times to promote the best Interests of Hattiesburg and South Mississippi.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A coroner receives a letter about a missing man from Wisconsin, possibly matching one of Gunness's victims, though none exhumed so far fit his description. Investigators now largely agree she used poison or chloroform to kill victims before mutilating and burying them, reasoning she could not have overpowered strong men by force alone.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The report describes how Belle Gunness allegedly poisoned victims and waited for blood to congeal before dismembering them to reduce bloodshed and discovery. It also reveals that Asle Helgelein personally exhumed the mutilated remains of his brother Andrew, one of her many victims, and that local officials had long kept secret how the hunt for victims began.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

GUNNESS HOME HORROR The Coroners Verdict Will Be. That The Mother And Three Children Were Burned. fuiUdPr.»» Laporte. May 16—Coroner Mack who is investigating the crimes of Mrs. Belle Gunness has announced

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A man recounts driving past the burned Gunness farm the day after the fire and being asked by Sheriff Smutzer to drive Asle Helgelein, brother of a missing man, back to town. Helgelein told him he never believed Mrs. Gunness's story that his brother had simply gone away.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2

By United Prr»s. Cincinnati, 0., May 11.— If the story told by Mrs. Jeannette Mor ris concerning Jacob Krebs, an in mate of the Longview Insane Asylum be true, he is as much an arch murderer as Mrs. Gunness. Mrs. Morris says that Krebs told her before he was confined in the Asylum that he had headed a gang who murdered over a score of peoI pie in Chicago and sent their bodies lo Indianapolis. The plan was to insure poor people and then slay them.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A witness recounts how Asle Helgelein, brought to the Gunness farm by the sheriff, described his suspicions about his missing brother Andrew and his decision to dig in the garden. Following hired man Joe Maxson's tip about a recently dug and refilled hole, Helgelein dug down and discovered gunnysacks containing his brother's body.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2

By United Prr»s. Cincinnati, 0., May 11.— If the story told by Mrs. Jeannette Mor ris concerning Jacob Krebs, an in mate of the Longview Insane Asylum be true, he is as much an arch murderer as Mrs. Gunness. Mrs. Morris says that Krebs told her before he was confined in the Asylum that he had headed a gang who murdered over a score of peoI pie in Chicago and sent their bodies lo Indianapolis. The plan was to insure poor people and then slay them.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Asle Helgelein describes digging into the garden where hired man Maxson had buried a hole, striking gunnysacks containing his brother's body with the first stroke of a spade. Ten bodies have now been exhumed from the farm, and the sheriff halts digging due to mobs of curious spectators overwhelming the site.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2

By UtiMl Pr*M Laporte, May 15. — Sheriff Smutzer, will drag the lake near the Gunness home, for the bodies of Mrs. Greening and Will Grinning, the Oklahoma City sweetheart of Jennie Olson, having notified Smutzer, that she is sure the bodies are in the lake.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Asle Helgelien describes how he suspected his brother Andrew was murdered by Belle Gunness after she stopped writing, leading him to search the farm. He found a hired man who recalled digging a hole for her, and upon digging there himself discovered buried remains just beneath the surface.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2

BABY A VICTIM OF MRS. GUNNESS

STRONG IDENTIFICATION Dentist Declares The Woman's Jawbone Found In Ruins Is Thal Of Mrs. Gunness. K* Ukited !>•*■ u Porte. May 15 - Dr. I. T. Norton, who has done Mrs. Gun

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Asle Helgelein digs in the Gunness garden and immediately finds his brother's gunnysack-wrapped body; eventually ten bodies are exhumed from the murder farm. Huge crowds of up to 10,000 overwhelm the site on a Sunday, halting digging, while four doctors disagree on whether the charred female body is Belle Gunness or another woman.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2

K» Vblimí Pr»*»* La Porte, Ind. May 12. The coroner and Physician '.Myer today found three rings on the fingers of the woman taken from the ruins of the Gunness home. One was plain gold, another a diamond gold ring inscribed: “P. G J- $• August 22. 94" and one diamond ring inscribed “P. S. to J. S. 3-595 P. G." which is believed to lie PhillipGunness.the woman's second husband. The discovery is believed to remove most of the doubt that Mrs. Gunness perished in the fire. It is reported that Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness wore three rings. These rings were not found before, because the fingers were so badly charred that the rings had sunk into the flesh. A report to the coroner, says the woman and her three» children evidently met death while in lied, or preparing to retire. The body bon» no marks of violence. Portion of the gold crown of a tooth was found in the ruins of the Gunness home. It is believed to be one of the three crowns Mrs. Gun ness is known to have had in her mouth.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

An estimated 10,000 visitors toured the Gunness farm as four doctors examined the fourth charred body but could not agree whether it belonged to Belle Gunness. Rumors of a mysterious pre-dawn automobile and an anonymous letter claiming Gunness's body lies in a nearby lake fueled speculation that she had escaped.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 2

A PREACHERS STATEMENT. Rev. Schell Saya Gunness Chil dren Were Chloroformed, Be fore Novae Waa Burned. By I'nurd Pt**» Baltimore, May 13.— Rev. L. E Schell of the (.aporte, Methodist

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A doctor who treated the Gunness baby in 1902 now believes Belle Gunness strangled the six-month-old child, originally attributed to natural causes (oedema of the lungs). Authorities are considering a $10,000 reward, and opinion remains divided on whether Gunness is dead or alive.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

BABY A VICTIM OF MRS. GUNNESS

A PREACHERS STATEMENT. Rev. Schell Saya Gunness Chil dren Were Chloroformed, Be fore Novae Waa Burned. By I'nurd Pt**» Baltimore, May 13.— Rev. L. E Schell of the (.aporte, Methodist church ia here and today aaid: “1 he Gunness children were cloroforma! then the houae tired over them. But the woman’s body found in the ruina ia not Mra. Gunnels lam sure Mmphere ia innocent of all theae murders but that of Helgaline because of the latter, he waa jealous. It would not lie fair for me to aay that lamphere confessed to Hegel eina murder.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Dr. Martin reveals he treated a Gunness child for minor illness, then was called at 2 a.m. to find it dead of apparent lung edema, but now believes Gunness deliberately strangled it. The report also covers doubts about whether the burned body is Gunness, reward discussions, and other investigative leads including possible other victims and poisoning theories.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

DOCTOR TELLS OF DEED

BORDERING ON COLLAPSE Rsy Lsmpherc Accused of Burn ing Gunness Home Worried Over Reports of His Con fession. Hy I'altMf Pm» [^aporte. May 13 — Ray Lam pherr is bordering on a collapse

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

Coroner Mack seeks to identify victims using descriptions from relatives, while investigators conclude Belle Gunness likely used poison or chloroform before dismembering bodies, since no signs of violent struggle were found. Asle Helgelein is revealed to have personally dug up his brother Andrew's mutilated remains, and the account of how the investigation began is finally disclosed.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 1

Killing Helgelin. By UNiuafh 1 »» («aporte, Ind., May 14 —Rev. h. A. Schell, Methodist minister who gave out the interview at Baltimore yesterday that Ray Lamphrrr had confessed to Inin in connection with the burning of the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the murderers of sixteen people, will be made the chief witness against lamphere. Prosecutor Smith says he will con vict him of this crime or the mur der of Andrew Helgelin. John Zach, a house mover, says the pro secutor, moved the store house some months ago and found at the time freshly dug earth. On this information digging will tie reBurned tomorrow at the spot where the wtMid house had been. The police believe more bodies will In* unearthed.

Clipping to come

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

A humor/filler column of short topical jokes includes a quip imagining Lucretia Borgia hiring Belle Gunness to run her 'slaughter house.' It treats Gunness's notoriety as already widely known shorthand for mass murder.

The Washington Herald · 11 May 1908 · page 4

Killing Helgelin. By UNiuafh 1 »» («aporte, Ind., May 14 —Rev. h. A. Schell, Methodist minister who gave out the interview at Baltimore yesterday that Ray Lamphrrr had confessed to Inin in connection with the burning of the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the murderers of sixteen people, will be made the chief witness against lamphere. Prosecutor Smith says he will con vict him of this crime or the mur der of Andrew Helgelin. John Zach, a house mover, says the pro secutor, moved the store house some months ago and found at the time freshly dug earth. On this information digging will tie reBurned tomorrow at the spot where the wtMid house had been. The police believe more bodies will In* unearthed.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

Sheriff Smutzer postpones further body searches at the LaPorte farm due to overwhelming crowds of curious visitors, with about 15,000 people visiting the site in one day. Evidence against Ray Lamphere strengthens with discovery of his trunk containing letters implicating him in Helgelein's murder, though the grand jury session has been delayed a week.

Evening Star · 11 May 1908 · page 1

THE ATTITUDE OF THE DEFENSE

Novelette * URiDERER HOLMES, who dealt /I out death as a druggist does an r * ordinary prescription; Luet rt of sausage fame, who put his fe under the knives in his factory Id destroyed her body in a vat of Id; Kate Bender, who Inveigled men her sheet curtained frontier room, tere they w*ere knocked in the head her masculine relatives; Johann pch, to whom bigamy became a pfession and killing a pastime; Lrman Billik, whose alleged victims n high in numbers —the homicidal pievements of these past masters I crime and their prototypes pale to insignificance when compared Ith the apparently proved acconi shments of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the Lporte, Ind., widow whose murder

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The grand jury hearing on Lamphere's case was postponed a week despite the prosecutor's readiness, as new evidence from his trunk and letters strengthened the case against him. The defense's theory that Mrs. Gunness, not Lamphere, set the fire and that the headless corpse was another victim remains unsubstantiated by the physicians' post-mortem findings.

Evening Star · 11 May 1908 · page 1

THE ATTITUDE OF THE DEFENSE

Novelette * URiDERER HOLMES, who dealt /I out death as a druggist does an r * ordinary prescription; Luet rt of sausage fame, who put his fe under the knives in his factory Id destroyed her body in a vat of Id; Kate Bender, who Inveigled men her sheet curtained frontier room, tere they w*ere knocked in the head her masculine relatives; Johann pch, to whom bigamy became a pfession and killing a pastime; Lrman Billik, whose alleged victims n high in numbers —the homicidal pievements of these past masters I crime and their prototypes pale to insignificance when compared Ith the apparently proved acconi shments of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the Lporte, Ind., widow whose murder

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The defense's claims that Mrs. Gunness set the fire and escaped, and that the headless corpse was another victim, are reported but not substantiated by the physicians' post-mortem findings. A new detail emerges: a tuft of brown hair resembling Lamphere's was found clenched in murdered victim Andrew Helgelein's hand, suggesting he fought his killer.

Evening Star · 11 May 1908 · page 1

THE ATTITUDE OF THE DEFENSE

of which have made the world stand agape, the preponderance of evidence so far uncovered indicates that the supreme master of criminology was a woman, who superficially was coarse, almost vulgar, and not ac credited. even by those who knew her best, with even average intelli gence. Yet this woman, it now appears, has been able to outwit for many years her neighbors and the police of several communities. In her subur ban home near Laporte there is no question but that she did to death at least 11 people, dismembered their bodies and disposed of their remains in various parts of the 60-acre farm adjoining the home.

See moreSee less

There is yet a grave question whether or not Mrs. Gunness had ac complices. Opinion is divided, but the preponderance of evidence lends color to the belief that the "horror house,” from which the bodies of an as yet untold number of victims were taken and without ceremony dumped Into holes in the barn yard or thrown into vaults, was the clearing house for a band of murderers whose principal scene of operation was Chicago and other of the larger cities, and with whom Mrs. Gunness, herself formerly a Chicago woman, was closely con nected. Still another theory which has many supporters would indicate that the -woman herself committed all the crimes, disposed of the bodies of her victims by her own hand and profited from their money and private effects.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

La Porte's mayor announces renewed, vigorous investigation into the Gunness murder mystery, including dragging nearby lakes and inspecting a cemetery for hidden bodies. Meanwhile, a nephew of Mrs. Gunness plans to travel to La Porte to try to establish whether she truly died in the fire.

Evening Star · 11 May 1908 · page 2

TO PUSH INVESTIGATION. Mayor of Laporte Confers With Prominent Citizens. LA PORTE. lnd.. May 11.?Lemuel L>arrow. major of laporte. after a conference with prominent c'tlzens last night.

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A nephew of Belle Gunness travels to Laporte claiming he can confirm via a distinctive chest scar whether the body found in the fire is truly his aunt's. Meanwhile, Pittsburgh police pursue a separate lead after a train conductor reports a woman resembling Gunness aboard his train.

Evening Star · 11 May 1908 · page 2

"When mother and I went to 1-aporte j at the time of the fire owing to tlie confusion we did not look for the scar on my aunt's body, although my mother 'knew it was there. The scar I know positively is on the body of Mrs. Gunness. and if tlie body in the undertaker's care at Laporte lias a scar on the chest there is no doubt but what It s her body."

See the clipping

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A train conductor named Burlingham describes how he suspected a woman boarding his train resembled Belle Gunness due to her gold-plated teeth hidden under gum, and alerted police in two cities, but she vanished before being detained in Pittsburgh. The report also includes a separate account from a man who believes he narrowly escaped being murdered by Gunness.

Evening Star · 11 May 1908 · page 2

SEARCH IN PITTSBURG.

the alleged murderess that he telegraphed Supt McQuaide of the local police department to send an officer to meet the traitat East Liverpool. Ohio. This was done, hut the officer, although agreeing with Burlingham ihat the woman resembled portraits of Mrs. Gunness. hesitated to make the arrest. Burlingham then wired or. to Pittsburg for two officers to meet ihe train, but the telegram went astray. While the' conductor and another tra nman tried to j keep the woman under surveillance after, reaching Pittsburg, she disappeared. Bur- [ lingham says the woman appeared nerv-; nue every time she saw any one coming near her.

See moreSee less

Burlingham had heard that some of Mrs. Gunness" upper front teeth were heavily plated with gold. When he engaged the woman In a moment's conversation under ?<>mc pretext his suspicions were again stimulated by the fact that her upper teeth were covered with chewing gum. as if she were trying to conceal them.

See the clipping

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

In a rambling editorial about Governor Hoch's comments on credulity and the Jonah story, the writer notes that many people are secretly hoping authorities will not catch Mrs. Gunness. The piece then shifts to unrelated news about the Vanderbilt divorce proceedings.

The Washington Times · 11 May 1908 · page 6

(By Associated Press.) scenes of last Sunday were repeated yesterday at the Gunness farm. Fully 10,000 people visited the “farm of mystery” and saw all there was to be seen, even to viewing the skeletons of the seven unidentified dead, for the temporary morgue was opened part of the day. and persons were permitted' to gaze at the bones of Mrs. Gunness’ victims. Hundreds brought their luncheons along, for the day was an ideal one, and at noon family groups dotted the grounds and orchards of the Guu uess farm. Souvenirs of all k.inds were *sold on the grounds, the people buying readily, nobody going away without a reminder of some kind.

Clipping to come

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

A short item mentions that authorities are considering offering a $10,000 reward for information leading to Mrs. Gunness's capture. It wryly notes they likely hope not to actually have to pay it.

The Washington Times · 11 May 1908 · page 6

(By Associated Press.) scenes of last Sunday were repeated yesterday at the Gunness farm. Fully 10,000 people visited the “farm of mystery” and saw all there was to be seen, even to viewing the skeletons of the seven unidentified dead, for the temporary morgue was opened part of the day. and persons were permitted' to gaze at the bones of Mrs. Gunness’ victims. Hundreds brought their luncheons along, for the day was an ideal one, and at noon family groups dotted the grounds and orchards of the Guu uess farm. Souvenirs of all k.inds were *sold on the grounds, the people buying readily, nobody going away without a reminder of some kind.

Clipping to come

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

Authorities gathering evidence against Ray Lamphere found a Polish farmhand who dug three holes on the Gunness farm, told they were for rubbish, which later contained bodies. Medical examination of Helgelein's body also revealed hair clutched in his hand resembling Lamphere's.

Evening Times-Republican · 11 May 1908 · page 1

MAN FOUND WHO DUG GRAVES

Intended Victim—Morbid Crowds. ijafcAs1 •if La Porte," Ind., day 11.—Authorities of?the county today are busy weaving •together shreds of evidence relied upon to connect Ray Lam phere with the deaths at the Gunness farm and have their case as complete as possible when the grand jury meets next week. As yet the evidence has not revealed to any great extent what attitude it will .• assume. Neither Lamphere nor his counsel will discuss the matter with j^any one farther than to claim that |!j Mrs. Gunness is still alive and that she flred her ownhouse that burned her children to death.

See moreSee less

While the prosecutor still denounces the theory as abso lutely improbable, yet this impression is becoming widespread despite the al most total absence of evidence to sup port it. The weather agnin today was very threatening. Some rain has fallen, tho not in sufficient quantities to necessar ily delay the sheriffs operations at the Gunness farm. 7!. Evidence Against Lamphere.' i' That Andrew Helgelein did not give up his life without a struggle is evi denced by the fact that in one of his clenched hands wa.s a brown tuft of •i short hair, which is said to be in cor respondence closely with the hair cov ering the head of Kay Lamphere. This inew phase of the mysteries was dis closed in the deposition of .Dr. Myer, one of the examining physicians, who went into an exhaustive examination of Helgelein's body. i*.:''TO)lliain' Brogiski, a Polander living, with a farmer neighbor of Mrs. Gun j,, ness, was called upon during the years 1906-07 to dig three holes in the barn lot on the Gunness place. He was told by Mrs. Gunness that the holes were •-to be utilized for rubbish and farm re fuse. Mrs. Gunness designated the di mension of the holes, which Brogiski said were about six feet long and four feet. wide. In all these holes bodies have been1 found. 1 ______ •iZifiX*

See the clipping

Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa

Authorities in La Porte, Indiana are compiling evidence to present to a grand jury linking Ray Lamphere to the deaths at the Gunness farm. Lamphere maintains that Belle Gunness is still alive and set the fire that killed her children, a theory the prosecutor dismisses despite its growing public acceptance.

Evening Times-Republican · 11 May 1908 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The report describes crowds of 15,000 curiosity-seekers flocking to the Gunness farm to view the murder scene, while authorities investigate new developments. George Anderson of Missouri claims he escaped death at the farm after finding a man he believed was Ray Lamphere with Mrs. Gunness, who then threatened him with a knife.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1

NEW SENSATION

LaPorte, Ind May 11, 3 p. m. .One oC the b largest sensations iyet developed In the story of Gnnness, the . ogress came to flight .this afternoon. George Anderson, Tarkio, Mo,, escaped death at the Gunness farmibecause he. had no money. Once when a resident of Mon- ' tleth, Mich, he answered an adverrtsement and came to LnPorte to marry airs." Gonness. She ashed him to sell his farm and bring the money. He returned o Montleth and back; A to LaPorte on the following- .weelc He didn't advise her he wins coming and found a man i" with airs.

See moreSee less

Gunness, who he bellevea was Ray I-amphfr. He awoke In the middle of the - night and found the woman standing; over him with a knife. ' She ran out of the room. He left Immediately. Anderson will arrive tonight and attempt to Identify Lamphere as the man he saw at Mrs. Gunness home.

See the clipping

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The report catalogs recent unexplained deaths in Lake County, including a drowned man near Miller and the headless body of Joseph Schneider, invoking fears of a murderous band rivaling Mrs. Gunness. It also describes the discovery of a young woman's skeleton buried in the Schneider family cemetery plot when a grave digger's shovel struck boards four feet down.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 1

MYSTERIES STARTLE COUNTY

The hand of death Is raised over Lake county. Murders, suicide and dis appearances have occurred with such alarming frequency and are clouded in so much mystery, that a review of them is enough . to strike s terror into the hearts of the bravest and lead the thinking man to wonder if there is not some murderous band at work, whose fiendish crlme-3 will not rival those of Mrs. Gunness and the other arch mur derers of history. i - The latest and . most peculiar of the mysteries involving the life and death of a human being is that of the find ing of the body of a young girl In thV cemetery, lot of . Phillip . Schneider at

See the clipping

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

Large crowds of excursionists are reported descending on the scene of the Gunness murders. The item appears amid unrelated furniture advertisements and a sports calendar in the same newspaper page.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 3

Crowds of Excursionists Throng Scene of Gunness Murders

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

A brief caption-like fragment describes crowds viewing the ruins of the Gunness home and a crowd outside what is called the 'charnel house.' This suggests the site was being examined following the discovery of human remains.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 3

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

The murder farm near La Porte, Ind., continues to draw thousands of curious visitors, and new evidence shows Belle Gunness bought two gallons of kerosene just before the fire that destroyed her home. Chicago police also prepare to dig up the basement of her former Austin home.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 4

Revealed. 'laporte, Ind., May IS. Sheriff S6nmtzeiandExpert Miner Schultz re sumed sluicing 'the Gunness farm to Vlay. Schultz is confident that he willflnd thwomaa's teeth if they are tin the ruins. When the sluicing ia completed the eheriff . will excavate further in what is known as the -Gunness private hur-4algrounds, and expects to find more skeletons. It was also announced today that he will start the dragging of . pondmear theprivate cemetery in re ponsetnianydemand3 that this be 'done, althtough -hehas little hope of lfinding.anyth.lng. The barn is also to iie remowedi'this week and excavations taaada under the cement floor.

See moreSee less

Tfter woman who embarked at Galves toa,,Texae, forIIamhurg, and was in teccteWefi. bji James Stokes and Frank Dayton-' because they suspected her of telhfe, Mrs. Gunness onaccount of re semblance and-her peculiar actions, is believed to be the same woman who paseedi through. St. Louis recently and was suspected by union station employeKvtob Mrs. Gunness. She pur chasedtapullman .ticket there and reinainedinher berth until she reached Fortworth. To Stokes and Dayton ehe admitted being from Indiana and explained her trip as being for the pur pose jofselling an estate of her hus band' in Germany, who had recently died. She declared she had never heard anything about the Gunness hor rors in Indiana and displayed much nervousness when the subject was dis cussed in her presence. It is claimed she tallied closely with the missing murderess. Three -new graves have been located on the Gunness farm. Other discover ies are expected momentarily. The county grand jury began its in vestigation of the tragedies of the Gunness farm this morning. Prose cutor R. N. Smith presented the first of 50 witnesses to testify against Ray Lamphere, accused of burning Mrs. Belle Gunness and her children alive in their house on April 2S, and sus pected of having aided Mrs. Gunness in the murder of Andrew K. Helge lein on January 14. Indictments charging arson and murder in the first degree are looked upon as a foregone conclusion. There, is a strong possibility that an indlct mentwill be voted charging Lamphere withbeing, an accessory to the mur der of llfefgelein. In any case tho.actionof'the grand jury will precipitate a legal fight in which politics, and perhaps. some elements which at pre sent are 'not generally known, will have an -active part. The'grand jury is composed as fol lows: N. D. McCormick, ex-sheriff, foreman;- August Z. Anders, farmer;

Clipping to come

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

Local Crown Point newspaper reports that public garages were busy taking carloads of townspeople to LaPorte to view the notorious Gunness farm 'death house.' Several private automobiles also made the trip to see the now-famous murder site, amid other routine local social and business news.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 6

CROWN POINT NEWS

Real Estate Is Active. The real estate dealers are complain ing of a scarcity of deals and trans fers In town property, and although lots are bringing a good price, the owners are still hanging on to them. "With the advent of the street car line, and the free gravel roads. It 13 said that property owners will have no trouble in disposing of their property and the price will be higher than ever known. The public garages did a rushing business yesterday their machines be ing engaged to take parties of Crown Pointers to LaPorte to view the much discussed "death house" on the Gun cess farm there.

See moreSee less

Severay private ma chines also made the trip to visit the now celebrated murder spot. August and Will Klndberg and Pete Henning witnessed the Chicago-PItts-turg game at the "West Side ball park in the city yesterday. The Modern "Woodmen will send an initiation team to Griffith Wednesday evening and about thirty members from here will see the work performed. Lawrence Cox and a party of friends were in town yesterday coming down in his Stoddard-Dayton touring car, and returning in the evening. Among the Crown Pointers visiting

See the clipping

The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.

A small-town social notes column from Lowell mentions various local comings and goings, including that several citizens went to see the Gunness farm. This brief mention reflects public fascination with the crime scene during the active investigation.

The Lake County Times · 11 May 1908 · page 6

Word has been received here of the death of Byron Peterson at LaBelle, Mo. J He was a brother of Hiram and Hibbard Peterson and Mrs. Sarah Green of this place. Caplain Duntnall of Chicago, was the guest of his daughter, Mrs. Amos Peter son, Sunday. . Several of our citizens went over to see the Gunness farm. The commencement exercises of the

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Thousands of sightseers poured into Laporte by train, car, and trolley to gawk at the Gunness farm murder site, turning it into a carnival with souvenir and postcard sellers. Deputies guarded the cellar debris and the carriage house holding dismembered remains, while excavation was impossible due to the crowds.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 1

CURIOUS THRONGS ABOUT THE SCENE OF MURDER SUNDAY

Fight for Man's Life. Laporte, Ind., May 11. The grim Hconfines of the Gunness farm, still la Men with the grewsnino evidence! of one f the greatest murder mysteries of iinodern times, Sunday rang with the daughter of little children, the quibs and jests of country swains and sweet hearts, the jargon of postcard sellers, Hand "street men" and the loud dispu tations of souvenir hunters. It is es timated that at least 1.",m people poured into Laporte on special excur

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Crowds descend on the Gunness farm site like a fairground, buying postcards of victims' bodies and dismembered remains while vendors hawk ice cream and souvenirs. Sheriff Smutzer remarks on the lack of solemnity, noting the public treats the murder scene as entertainment.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 1

WARES TO VISITORS

Pack and forth through the crowd walked "Uncle Ben." a simple old negro from the country, armed with a forked willow "divining rod.' with which he essumed to detect hidden graves of murder victims. Thirty-seven in all he announced solemnly to the supersti tious. "Is there a dance down at the pavil ion tonight V" called a country boy with a bunch of lilacs in the button 'liole of his Sunday coat. "You bet." responded a Hoosier girl, with her mouth full of chewing gum. "Til be there witn hells on."

See moreSee less

re sponded the lad gleefully just n a postal-card vender started to drown him out with stentorian shouts of "Here's where you get your picture postal cards of the Gunness family; lo cents each or three for a quarter; better take li half dollar's worth and make a good selection." "Postals of Helgeleiu's body all pone," announced the vender. "Sold 'em all, but got some good ones left of Ihe other bodies." "This is just the way this body laid." announced another man with a bundle cf horrible pictures. "You see the liead here, the trunk there and the limbs as Mrs. Gunness sewed them up In the gunny sacking." "ice cream, ."" cents: ice cream. ." cents." piped a man with a white wagon at the edge of the road just as a surry. converted into a candy wagon and manned by wh ite rated men pulling white cream, dash.- THE r

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Crowds treat the Gunness farm site like a carnival while officials examine corpses found in the ashes, determining the victims died of suffocation from smoke and heat. Authorities now believe Ray Lamphere was Mrs. Gunness's confederate in murdering Andrew Helgelein, and Lamphere offers his own account to shift blame.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 1

MRS. GUNNESS

Spocial orders have been given to saloon keepers to forego their not nnusal custom of keeping back doors open. One firm was charged with having transgressed and an arrest was made. When the confusion of the day had given place to comparative ouiet at night. Sheriff Smutzer recalled that two brothers from Chicago, nametl I.indberg. had approached him on the grounds and saul that they were hunt ing for traces of a missing brother, who had left Chicago three years aco to work for Mrs. Gunness, The crowd was so great at the time that the brothers said they would see the sheriff later about the matter, and then were merged in the crowd with out giving their full names and ad

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

The item notes a rumor that one of Belle Gunness's dentists may have been paid for his work by being given a burial plot on her property. It also remarks that the Gunness case is notable for being the first to involve a gold mining expert among the array of specialists consulted.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 4

Many murder cases have had their handwriting experts, sanity experts, etc., but the Mrs. Gunness case is the first known to history where a gold mining expert has been callc-d into use.

See the clipping

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

Ray Lamphere describes how Mrs. Gunness sent him away on a pretext the day Andrew Helgelein vanished, later realizing Helgelein was likely murdered. His attorney also voices confidence in Lamphere's innocence, denying any conspiracy with Gunness.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 7

CURIOUS THRONGS ABOUT THE SCENE OF MURDER SUNDAY

Mrs. Belle Gunness, of Indiana, has achieved considerable distinction In the gentle art of murdering transient guests, but it can hardly be said that she has succeeded In making fragrant the memory of Miss Kate Bender, of Kansas. It is all right, perhaps, for the car toonists and jokesmiths to exaggerate the dimensions of the "Merry Widow" hats; but as a matter of fact these millinery creations do not average more than two and a half feet In di ameter. -» The lmpufsive statements would twist and distort the constitution to fit what he conceives to be the needs of the hour.

See moreSee less

The men who framed the Instrument fashioned It to meet the requirements of the centuries. The highly sensational rumor comes from Colorado that a man who mysteriously disappeared from that state some months ago is not believed to have been one of Mrs. Gunness' vic tims. Sounds like a fake. It Is understood that more than one of the visiting governors took a good look through the White House and wondered how the domestl* arrange ments would suit "the good woman at home." Ex-Governor Vardaman announces that his weekly paper, The Issue, has attained a circulation of nearly 12,000 already. This is a most remarkable record for a Mississippi newspaper. 4 4 4 Air. Taft's manager says thaj ie on the first baj. 1 '- p ro ^.

Clipping to come

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.

A witness recounts being warned by Mrs. Gunness not to talk with visitor Helgelein, describing her controlling behavior before his disappearance. Lamphere's attorney defends his client's innocence and disputes claims he was seen fleeing the burning house, while a new letter surfaces about another possible victim, Thomas Lindboe.

The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 11 May 1908 · page 7

The highly sensational rumor comes from Colorado that a man who mysteriously disappeared from that state some months ago is not believed to have been one of Mrs. Gunness' vic tims. Sounds like a fake. It Is understood that more than one of the visiting governors took a good look through the White House and wondered how the domestl* arrange ments would suit "the good woman at home." Ex-Governor Vardaman announces that his weekly paper, The Issue, has attained a circulation of nearly 12,000 already. This is a most remarkable record for a Mississippi newspaper. 4 4 4 Air. Taft's manager says thaj ie on the first baj. 1 '- p ro ^.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

In Warsaw, Indiana, Jacob Pouch, aged 60, committed suicide after becoming temporarily deranged from reading newspaper accounts of the Gunness murders. The item attributes his death to the shock and mental strain caused by the sensational coverage.

Rock Island Argus · 11 May 1908 · page 1

BROODED OVER THE MURDERS

[Special to the Evening Star.] LAPORTE, Ind., May IS.—With most of the half million dollars she is known to have realized from her ghastly crimes m a money belt, Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch murderess, who was at first thought to have perished in the ruins of her home with her children, is now believed to be aboard a German ship which cleared from New York within the past few days.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

Authorities in La Porte are assembling evidence connecting Ray Lamphere to the deaths at the Gunness farm ahead of the grand jury. New findings include a tuft of hair resembling Lamphere's found clenched in Andrew Helgelein's hand, and testimony that Belle Gunness had pre-dug burial-sized holes in the hog lot years earlier.

Rock Island Argus · 11 May 1908 · page 1

DARK FOR LAMPHERE

Was Slain by the Indiana Woman. Importe, Ind., May 18.—Identification of John Aloe of Elbow Lake, Minn., ai one of the victime of Mrs. Belle Gun ness was made -positive by the arrival of Moe's half brother, J. 0. Rendfen of ι Manfred, N. D. ' Alfred Peglow, paying teller of the First National bank of Laporte, at which Μοβ cashed drafts for $1,100, said "that is the man" as soon as Ren den showed him his brother's photo graph. Renden could throw little new light on the manner of his brother's ensnare ment and death.

See moreSee less

Moe was a frugal Norwegian laborer, forty-two year» old. He had saved about $1,500, which made him big enough flsh for Mrs. Gunness' bait. Ho bought drafts for $1,100 from the bank of Elbow Lake on Deo. 20, 1900, saying he was going to use the money to pay off a mort gage on a farm. Ile did not tell his brother the purpose of his trip. "I'm going away on a short trip," Moe said to Renden, "and if I am sue· 1 cessful I will write you shortly. If I am not, I will be home soon." Estimates are being made of the | amounts of money probably obtained by Mrs. Gunness from her victims. The estimates range from $50,000 to $500,000, but It is not explained how ι the woman was almost penniless after making her will leaving only the $720 she placed In the bank the day before her supposed death In the flre.

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A doctor's deposition reveals a tuft of hair matching Ray Lamphere's was found clenched in victim Andrew Helgelein's hand, suggesting a struggle. A Polish laborer testifies he dug three large holes at Gunness's request that were later found to contain bodies, while a survivor named George Anderson describes narrowly escaping murder and believes Gunness set the fire herself and is still alive.

Rock Island Argus · 11 May 1908 · page 1

DARK FOR LAMPHERE

LA P011J1J Ind May IS Interest In the Ounness murder farm mystery was r tranf rrort today to the In Port i I County CaurtHouoo where StateAt torn y Snllfi bean the Grand Jury tn vestarn The State will Introduce the evidence of forty witnesses throusi n number of whom It Is ex P < < t j to connect Ray Latnphcre wit the murJcr or Andrew HelgeleJn An Indlctnunt against him for the murder of Mrs Gllnnpsand her thlee children 1 a al i looked tor Lampher R lawyers who are working hard to meet all these charges an noiinced today that a witness had been found who would testify thru he saw the Ounress hoURs In tlaiies at 3SO A 1 M on April IS Lamphere left the house of Lizzie Smith In this place between 330 andi tctok A bltr force of bailiffs are on cuard at the Grand Jury room and all the wit

Clipping to come

Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.

A New York World op-ed likening Belle Gunness to historical female criminals, calling her murders a 'business' rather than crimes of passion. It ponders whether she died in the farmhouse fire or escaped to kill again elsewhere.

Rock Island Argus · 11 May 1908 · page 4

Mrs. Gunness, in the guise of a "come ly .widow"' enticed men to her side through, a matrimonial advertisement Were they, struck down while the in fluence . of her i charms were strong ixm them, or mercifully drugged or

See the clipping

The Cairo Bulletin · Cairo, Ill.

A newspaper commentary sarcastically notes that Belle Gunness, called 'the fate murderess,' has been arrested in two places since her supposed death, musing how many arrests might occur if she were actually alive. The piece pokes fun at the confused and contradictory reporting surrounding her case.

The Cairo Bulletin · 11 May 1908 · page 2

Blu Front Restaurant. The Hate murderess,. Sir. Guiuoess or Mrs, Gunness, has beeu arrested in two places since her death. In low many places she would have been arrested If she were living Is iuad dening to speculate upon.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

The report describes how Alonzo C. Townsend of Topeka, who had corresponded with Belle Gunness about marriage, was saved from traveling to LaPorte by a delay in spring planting. Gunness's crimes were exposed before he could complete his trip, sparing him from being one of her murder victims.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 1

Mrs. Belle Gunness, the notorious murderess" of .Laporte,' Ind., whose many horrible ' crimes " have been un earthed during theipast few days, was only prevented from Including in her lists or murders av Topeka . victim, by the sudden exposure) of her life of crime. Alonzo C.'S.Townsend is today congratulating himself upon his luck in escaping from the hand of this treacherous woman. "Lon," as he : is more familiarly known in Topeka' was to have left for Laporte in a few Mays to meet Mrs. Gunness, having arranged through a short correspondence that they should meet in Laporte and if they found in each other congenial companions they snoum join ineir xartunes and travel life's way together, i Townsend like so many of the other Victims of Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness, had seen her advertisement for a husband and had answered the ad. by giving glowing descriptions of his earthly possessions and Mrs. Gun ness attracted by the fortune of Townsend lured him on and had she gone on with her career of crime a few days longer, Lon Townsend would probably have perished by her hand. Townsend is a wealthy man. Townsend is now a farmer and he can thank providence for the delayed spring rains which prevented him from putting in his crops as soon as he had desired, as it had :been arranged that they should meet in Laporte as soon as he had his crops iij and could leave the woriL oi me tarm. -:as il now is aowub end is so pleased over his escape from his prospective "bride" that he left To peka today on an yearly morning train for Kansas City so that he could best celebrate his fofctuhate -escape. He escaped before the knowledge of his relations with the Gunness woman had gone beyond the cfrcies of bis most in timate friends. A meeting between the Gunness wo man and Townsend would - have fur nished an elaborate - opportunity for the cartoonist to. rise to fame. Mrs. Gunness was known as a large woman. who weighed in the neighborhood ot zao pounds and was so large in fact that she required a No hoe. Townsend is a few Inches nde six feet in height and weighs in the neighborhood of 800 pounds. . ' Townsend has lor years oeen a wen known character in Topeka -and . has enjoyed a unique reputation. He .has lived in "Topeka and vicinity ror-neany a quarter of a century or since young manhood for he is now aDout , mid years of age. i

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Lon Townsend, a wealthy former Topeka liquor dealer, answered Belle Gunness's matrimonial advertisement and arranged to meet her in Laporte, but delayed spring crops postponed his trip and likely saved his life. He celebrated his fortunate escape by leaving town once he learned of her crimes.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 1

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Emil Greening, a former Gunness employee, tells Oklahoma City reporters about digging stump holes on the farm that could have been used for burying victims and describes the house's layout. He also recounts how Lamphere came to work and board at the farm, and relates details Mrs. Gunness shared about her first husband Max Sorenson.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 7

PISTOLS EVERYWHERE.

MURDER HORROR. LAPORTE, May 18.—Seven thousand dollars has been appropriated as a re ward fo r the arrest of Mrs. Gunness if she is still alive. The county commis sioners took this step Saturday. The sum of $5000 is also set aside for the expense of the coroner and $2000 for the sheriff to investigate. It is not thought that there are any more bodies on the farm.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A witness named Greening recounts living in Belle Gunness's house, describing her talk of first husband Max Sorenson and the presence of numerous pistols, watches, and pocketbooks scattered about. He also recalls being sent away one night for expected visitors who never arrived, and noting trunks and men's clothing throughout the house.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 7

PISTOLS EVERYWHERE

La Porte, Ind., May 18.—The autopsy de livered today on the remains of the seven unidentified dead exhumed from Mrs. Gunness’ private burial ground was corn pieced this evening and revealed the fact, according to the reports of Drs. F. T. Wil cox and George Osborne, who conducted the autopsy under the direction of Coro ner Mack, that one of the seven was a fe male. This has aroused new interest in the •tory of Emil Greening of Oklahoma City, Okie*, who was employed by Mrs. Gun ness in the fall of 1904.

See moreSee less

Greening worked for Mrs. Gunness at the time that Jennie Olsen disappeared, and his story wras to the effect that on a certain day in Sep tember a man and woman came to the house and that night Mrs. Gunness asked Greening to sleep in the barn, for the 00upie, who she said were the professor and his wife, from the Los Angeles col lege, which Jennie was to attend, would spend the night at the house and would require Greening's bedroom. In the morn ing Greening saw nothing of Jennie nor the man and woman, and was informed by Mrs. Gunness that they had left on an early train, taking Jennie along. This body, which is now declared to be that of a woman, was taken from the same hole as was that of Jennie Olsen, [ and in that hole also were the bodies of Ole Budsberg of lola, Wls., and the re mains of a male person. All the bodies were dismembered, but the trunks of the four were such that it was possible to identify the bodies of Jennie Olsen and Budsberg, and made it possible by today’s autopsy to determine that one of the oilier two was that of a female. The theory now advanced is that Mrs. Gunness may have on the same night, the night that Greening slept in the barn, murdered not only Jennie Olsen, but also the man and woman. The mystery surrounding the watch found on the person of Ray Lamphere when he was arrested was cleared today when J. G. Ramden of Mansfield, N. D., who came here yesterday to investigate, f the disappearance •of his half brother, John Moe of Elbow Lake, Minn., identi fied the timepiece as the one owned by his brother when he left home. The number of the watch corresponded :! with the one in Moe’s possession. 1am phere said that Mrs. Gunness gave him the watch. Hamden is positive that ins brother was murdered by Mrs. Gunness, but he was not able to identify any of the remaining skeletons and so will not be able to provide proper burial for his ? j brother. The bodies of the seven unidentified dead will be buried tomorrow in the pot ters’ field. Christian services will be con ducted over them. Coroner Mack is still holding the bodies of the four persons who lost their lives ill the fire, and who, according to every pro duced evidence, are the bodies of Mrs. 1 Gunness and her three children. They will be held until Coroner Mack files his formal verdict. The La Porte county grand jury heard the stories of a number of witnesses in the Gunness case. The expectation is that the greater share of the week will be con sumed in the investigation.

Clipping to come

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Sheriff Smutzer halts excavation at the Gunness farm due to crowds of curious onlookers, while a Minneapolis detective reveals letters showing Andrew Helgelein corresponded affectionately with the widow before his disappearance. The grand jury's consideration of Ray Lamphere's case has been postponed a week.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 8

Gold Teeth In linins. Laporte, Ind., May 11. Picking up the hreds of evidence tending to connect Ray Lamphere with the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her three children and perhaps also of Andrew Helgelein, is the main purpose of the authorities here today. Whether search for more bodies will be prosecuted has not been finally determined. Sheriff Smutzer yes terday indicating that further excava tion may be postponed until tomorrow. The sheriff has found difficulty in car rying on this work because of the mor bidly curious persons, who have flock ed to the place where 10 corpses were discovered last week.

See moreSee less

Friday the exca vating in the barn yard was hindered and Saturday it was halted by the crowds. It is expected, however, that the number of visitors will be lessened today, some 15,000 persons having in spected the grounds yesterday and pre sumably satisfied their curiosity. The grand Jury was to have met to day to consider Lamphere's case, but this procedure has been postponed for a week. Experts who were called into the affair by Sheriff Smutzer advised this course although Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney for this Judicial district, had announced only a few hours before the decision was made, that he was ready to go into court with the evidence at hand. Since then the case has been strengthened by the dis covery of Lamphere's trunk, containing several letters which are raid to estab lish his participation in the murder of Helgelein and by information extract ed from a number of persons who were Intimate enough with the prisoner to learn from him much concerning his relations with Mrs. Gunness. If the sifting and sluicing of the ash es in the cellar of the home result in the discovery of yet more evidence, it Is likely the case will be pushed toward a conclusion rapidly. Prosecutor Smith Is anxious to bring Lamphere before a Jury during the term of court which opens today and will endeavor to clear the docket of several minor cases which are scheduled to I be heard.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

Excavation at the Gunness farm continues amid crowds of curious onlookers, while the grand jury's consideration of Lamphere's case is delayed a week to allow further evidence gathering. New evidence includes letters found in Lamphere's trunk and witness statements, while the defense claims the headless body found was another victim, not Mrs. Gunness.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 8

HE HAS HER LETTERS.

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

As the Lamphere trial begins, his attorneys claim Mrs. Gunness decapitated another victim to fake her own death, though physicians' autopsy findings do not support this theory. Separately, a tuft of hair resembling Lamphere's was found clenched in victim Andrew Helgelein's hand, suggesting a struggle.

The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1908 · page 8

Defense Is Kept Secret. The attitude of the defense has not been revealed to any great extent. The prisoner has received stringent orders from his atotrneys not to discuss the charges against him with any one and the attorneys . themselves have not committed themselves to a particular line of action. They have been free in announcing theories to account for Lamphere's actions before and follow ing his arrest and have also given out alleged evidence which they claim to have secured and which they say estab lishes the fact that Mrs.

See moreSee less

Gunness and not Lamphere set fire to the house. The adult headless corpse found with the blackened bodies of the children was, they assert, that of another vic tim of the Gunness woman, the theory being that the head was severed by Mrs. Gunness in order that it might be thought the body was hers. Thus far, however, efforts to substantiate the announcements by the defense have failed, several persons having repudi ated interviews accredited to them by Lamphere's attorneys, while the facts found by the physicians who perform ed postmortem examinations on the corpses do not bear out the conten tions of the defense. It is thought, however, that Lamphere's attorneys have concealed carefully the chief points upon which they will rely, en deavoring meanwhile to swing public opinion in favor of the prisoner. Political and business friends of the attorneys have been busy discussing the case wherever opportunity offered, the argument being mainly that Mrs. Gunness was too shrewd a woman to be caught In a fire and that she might therefore have escaped. Prosecutor Bmlth denounces these methods, but there is no gainsaying the fact that the Impression that Mrs. Gunness is still alive is widespread, despite the almost total absence of evidence to support it. This circumstance will make the task of picking a trial Jury difficult and there is scarcely a man or woman in the community who has not formed or expressed an opinion on the subject. Talesmen from the rural districts, how ever, may lighten the labors of the at torneys in this regard.

See the clipping

Paper unidentified

George Anderson describes waking to find Mrs. Gunness standing over his bed during a visit two years earlier, believing he escaped murder. A grocer also reports seeing Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere together the day before the Gunness home burned, and the city council offers a $5,000 reward for her capture.

Paper unidentified · 11 May 1908 · page 1

ANDERSON AWOKE SAW MRS GUNNESS STANDING BY HIM

Identified the time piece as tho ono owned by his brother when he left home. Numbers of the watch corres ponded with tho numbers in Moo's pos session. Lamphoro said Mrs. Gunness gave him tho watch. The bodies of tho seven unidentified dead will bo buried tomorrow in the potter's field. A Christian service will he conducted over them and a small stone will be erected with ian inscrip tion telling the circumstances of the deaths. The body of Jennio Olsen has been turned ovor to her relatives. Buds herg'a body was today shipped to Iola, Wis., for burial.

Clipping to come

The Daily Banner · Cambridge, Md.

An estimated 15,000-16,000 sightseers descended on the Gunness farm in La Porte, turning the scene of the murders into a carnival-like event with picnics, souvenir vendors, and lemonade stands. The crowd grew so large it halted the ongoing search for additional victims' remains, while some attendees were actually searching for missing friends or relatives among the dead.

The Daily Banner · 11 May 1908 · page 4

At the gates were venders of sou / venir postal cards, and those bearing I a group picture of Mrs. Guinness and the three little ones who met death with her found readiest sale. During the rush to La Porte several farm horses, frightened by automobiles, * started to run away. A buggy was upset, and Mrs. Benjamin Zanelar. of La Porte, suffered a broken arm. Sev eral pickpockets did a thriving busi ness while the throng waited for homeward bound trains. Investigation of the farm for more bodies was halted.

See moreSee less

The sheriff and other officers were forced to become spectators also. Several visitors, how ever, were seeking information con cerning missing friends or relatives, and some further information regard ing the possible identity of the vic tims of the farm resulted from their inquiries. 'The most definite information came from Olaf Lindboe..of Chicago. He said that his brother Thomas worked for Mrs. Guinness three years ago, and that the last letter from Thomas said that Thomas intended to marry

See the clipping