Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Following the fire that killed Belle Gunness and three children on April 28, digging on her property uncovered the remains of fourteen people, including Andrew Heldgren and adopted daughter Jennie Olsen. Authorities suspect Ray Lamphere, already held for the Gunness family deaths, may have also killed and dismembered Heldgren.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Springfield Weekly Republican · 14 May 1908 · page 9
GREWSOME MURDER MYSTERY.
engraved initials “P. 8. to J. 8.” and “P. G. to J. 8S.” She went once by the name of Jennie Sorensen. Must Show Metive., Before it can prove its case the State must also show that Lamphere had a motive for the death of Mrs. Gunness. The State will try to prove that he was very jealous of her and that she had dis carded him and that he thought she kept a large sum of money in her home and wished to rob her. But the strangest the ory of the State will be that Lamphere assisted her in the murder of Heigelein; that he knew this death was to be inves tigated, he knew the body would be found buried on the murder farm, and that he would be jointly accused with Mrs, Gunness for the crime, and that if he killed her and her children and burned the house he would stop the in vestigation.
See moreSee less
The State will attempt to prove that he said he would burn her house to “get even with her,” that he came to town the night before without good reason, and that he followed Mrs. Gunness into a grocery when she bought coal oil, and that he knew where she kept the oil on a porch where he could reach it easily. The State will attempt to prove that Lamphere might have slept at the home of Lizzie Smith, and yet have time to get to the Gunness house and kill them and get away. It will attempt to show that he was near the Gunness home soon after the fire burst forth, and that he did not Keep to the road in going away, but cut across fleids, and that he ran part of the way, going ten miles without breakfast, a suspicious circumstance in itself. The State will show that Mrs. Gun ness loved her children, and will argue the improbability of her murdering them and of committing suicide simply to es cape prosecution for murder. Turn of Defense, Then will come the turn of the de fense. It will first dispute the death of Mrs. Gunness, introducing numerous wit
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
Physicians' post-mortem reports on the woman and three children found in the Gunness ruins fail to establish cause of death, likely leading to an open coroner's verdict, while prosecutors separately build a case against Ray Lamphere for the murders. Additional victims are identified as men lured by matrimonial ads, including Budsberg, identified by his sons, with suspicion also falling on whether Belle Gunness knew of the killings.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Springfield Weekly Republican · 14 May 1908 · page 9
GREWSOME MURDER MYSTERY.
In order to simplify matters and save time will those portions of the country In which Mrs. Gunness has not been seen please place themselves on rec ord? A new play Is called "Stubborn On derella." Probably,' like most women, she declared she could wear the glass slipper, although It was three sizes too small. One Russian citizen accused of being a revolutionist was acquitted In St. Pet erslmrg yesterday. Hut we know one judge who Is going to lose his Job when the Czar hears of It. An Ohio man claims to have Invented an airship that "will stay up for months."
See moreSee less
It will doubtless make a hit with men who occasionally find It neces eary to dodge their creditors. Vu Ting-fang visited the Gunness farm nt Laporte. Probably some of the
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Authorities in La Porte made little progress identifying the burned woman's body as Mrs. Gunness, with a laborer unable to confirm diamond rings found on the corpse. Threatening anonymous letters were sent to the prosecutor warning officials to stop searching, while banks agreed to provide transaction records tied to Mrs. Gunness's various aliases.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 1
THE BANKS WILL HELP UNTANGLE MYSTERY.
Women are growing more timid, ac cording to Prof. Q. Stanley Hall, who has apparently never heard of Mrs. Gunness. The New York, New Haven ft Hart
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Investigators used bank transaction records to trace missing men John Moe and Henry Gorholt to the Gunness farm, paralleling earlier findings on Budsberg and Helgelein, with local banks agreeing to supply full transaction lists. Separately, Rev. Schell denied reports that Lamphere confessed to helping kill the Gunness children.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 1
STORIES UNTRUE
Women are growing more timid, ac cording to Prof. Q. Stanley Hall, who has apparently never heard of Mrs. Gunness. The New York, New Haven ft Hart
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Authorities note a watch taken from Lamphere resembles one owned by Andrew Helgelein's brother, and a mail carrier describes delivering letters to Mrs. Gunness under several aliases. Rev. Dr. Schell denies claiming Lamphere helped kill the Gunness children, says Lamphere's confession to him is privileged, and offers personal impressions of Mrs. Gunness, Lamphere, and local officials.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 1
STORIES UNTRUE.
Investigations are being made at Loganeport. IntL, In the state where the horrors of the Gunness murders only recently were revealed, into the death of George Welch, who lived at a boarding house conducted toy Mro. Mary Wright In that city. The re mains will be exhumed to determine whether the man died of poison, which he is said to have tokl a physician, was being giv«n him. When It became known that Mrs. Wright was facing a murder charge here the authorities at Logansport de cided to exhume Welch's body.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Physicians' post-mortem reports fail to determine how Mrs. Gunness and her three children died, likely leading to an open coroner's verdict. New findings reveal the supposed gold tooth was actually gilded wood, and rings found on the body present an unsolved puzzle, while the prosecutor continues gathering evidence linking Ray Lamphere to the deaths.
The Detroit Times · 14 May 1908 · page 6
DOCTORS REPORT IN GUNNESS POST-MORTEM FAIL TO ESTABLISH MANNER IN WHICH WOMAN AND CHILDREN MET DEATH—"GOLD TOOTH" GILDED WOOD
In order to simplify matters and save time will those portions of the country In which Mrs. Gunness has not been seen please place themselves on rec ord? A new play Is called "Stubborn Cin derella." Probably, like most women, she declared she could wear the glass slipper, although It was three sizes too small. One Russian citizen accused of being a revolutionist was acquitted In St. Pet ersburg yesterday. Rut we know pne Judge who is going to lose his Job when the Czar hears of It. An Ohio man claims to have invented an airship that "will stay up for months." It will doubtless make a hit with men who occasionally find It neces sury to dodge their creditors.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Investigators reveal that the body's right arm (not left) is mostly intact, and three rings were found on the hands, while the supposed 'gold tooth' is actually gilded wood from a picture frame. New victims are named including John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and Ole Budsberg, with a watch found in the ruins identified as belonging to Budsberg.
The Detroit Times · 14 May 1908 · page 6
GILDED WOOD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
The report credits Asle Helgelien, brother of victim Andrew Helgelien, with having pursued the case until the Gunness murders were uncovered. His photograph is included alongside that of his murdered brother, whose body was found buried at the La Porte farm.
The Detroit Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
ELECTRIC THEATRE “Skinney’s Finish” “The Gunness Tragedy” “The Animated Clock” The best way to possess ready money is to .SAVE AS YOU EARN. The best way to save is to put it in some
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
A witness recounts that she and Mrs. Greene heard a revolver shot after Metsker and Morgan left the house, then watched from a window before officers arrived and arrested the Metskers. Another witness, who discovered the fire in which Mrs. Gunness may have perished, described trying to rouse those inside but being driven back by smoke.
The Detroit Times · 14 May 1908 · page 4
RA Y LAMPHERE TRIAL IS SET Hearst News Service. Laporte, Ind., OctoDer 3.—The trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of the mur many other murders, has been set for November 9. Lamphere says that he is anxious for a hearing and that
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Sheriff Smutzer suddenly resumed digging at the Gunness farm, which many believe signals he has undisclosed evidence of more bodies. Authorities are tracking several missing persons linked to Gunness, and debate continues over whether she is alive, with sightings reported near Hobart.
The Detroit Times · 14 May 1908 · page 7
SPADES AGAIN AT WORK IN GUNNESS FARM YARD
FONTINELLE a brilliantly lighted stage and the audience is given every opportunity of inspecting its mechanism. During the engagement of Fontinelle, peo ple Monday noon, will have every op portunity of seeing the mysterious marvel at close range for it will drive an automobile through the streets of the city. -v A. For feature in the animated"pic tures the management will show "Mre. Gunness," the great Laporte, Ind., mystery, and it is bound to please one and all. The other two subjects will be "June Bug" and "Tbe Mother-in-law," Mr. Moore will sing "If You Cared for Me as Cared for You." The matinee today -will open at 8 at 8 and 0 o'clock, Come early and avoid ttie rosh.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
The report describes continuing disagreement among officials and Lamphere's attorneys over whether Mrs. Gunness is alive, with letters still arriving about missing relatives. It also details a letter suggesting Gunness used a marriage solicitor in Cleveland to recruit victims with a photograph and promises of a rich widow.
The Detroit Times · 14 May 1908 · page 7
P, jf audience is given every opportunity of inspecting its mechanist. During the engagement of Fontinelle, peo ple Monday noon, will have every op portunity of seeing the mysterious marvel at close range for it will drive an automobile through streets of the city. For a feature in the animatod pic tures /the management will «how "Mra. Gunness," the great Laporte, Ind., mystery, and tt is bound to please one and all. The other two sabj«ets will be "June Bag*' and "The Mother-in-law^" Mr. Moore will sing "If You Cared for Me Cared for You" The matinee today trill open at 3 and o'clock. Come early and 8 avoid the rash.
Clipping to come
Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J. · and 3 other papers
After a fire destroyed Belle Gunness's farmhouse near LaPorte, Indiana, killing her and three children, authorities searching for a missing suitor's body instead uncovered as many as fifteen dismembered bodies buried on the property. A handyman, Ray Lamphere, has been jailed as a suspect, and local authorities suspect Gunness faked her own death by killing another woman in her place.
Gloucester County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Indiana Murder Farm.
Robert Hitt made a business trip to Texarkana today. 5 or 6 doses of “666” will cure any case of Chills and fever. 25c The liTo of Mrs. Gunness .tin1
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
The Owosso Times · Owosso, Mich. · 15 May 1908
Morris Tribune · Morris, Minn. · 16 May 1908
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D. · 22 May 1908
Belding Banner · Belding, Mich.
The report describes ten bodies found buried on the Gunness farm, including three of her own children, and questions whether the charred female corpse found is truly Belle Gunness or a decoy. It cites emerging evidence of a Chicago accomplice who helped lure victims to the farm, suggesting Gunness may still be alive and evading capture.
Belding Banner · 14 May 1908 · page 2
THE LAPORTE MURDERESS EVIDENCE POINTS TO THE VIEW THAT THE GUNNESS FIEND IS ALIVE
5 or 6 doses of “666” will cure any case of Chills and fever. 2 lie Sam T White leTt this morn ing on a business trip tollosboro. The Fortnightly Club will be entertained this afternoon at the home of Mrs. Chas. F. Pittman, Mrs. W. G. Kennedy returned to Little Rock this morning, after spending several days herewith her husband. t The ILife of Mrs. Gunness. the Female Bluebeard, that famous murderess is on at the Then to’iuin tonight.
Clipping to come
Belding Banner · Belding, Mich.
The coroner changes his official records to list the burned body as an unidentified woman rather than Belle Gunness, now believing she faked her death. Investigators also uncover evidence of a female accomplice in Chicago who helped lure victims to the farm.
Belding Banner · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Many a man has been bunkoed by Judging a woman’s disposition by her •mile._ A rolling stone gathers no moss, they say. But who wants to gather moss anyway? From Its Gunness farm Laporte has harvested a large and profitable crop of sightseers. The Filipinos think they want inde pendence. What do they think they would do with It? So far the detectives have turned up no evidence to prove that Sirs. Gunness
Clipping to come
Wiarus · Winona, Minn.
Detectives traveled to Utica, N.Y., investigating a man named Parks suspected of ties to the notorious murderess Belle Gunness of Indiana. Inquiries to Chicago later revealed the arrest had been a mistake.
Wiarus · 14 May 1908 · page 5
So far the detectives have turned up no evidence to prove that Sirs. Gunness ever wore a Merry Widow hat. If the man who says that be owns
Clipping to come
The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.
The report describes Belle Gunness as a monstrous killer who lured men via matrimonial ads, took their money, and murdered them, with ten dismembered bodies found and fourteen deaths suspected. It states that her hired man Ray Lamphere set fire to the house, killing Gunness and her three children, with identification made via a gold tooth and rings found on a woman's corpse.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Princeton Union · 14 May 1908 · page 1
A DIABOLICAL HORROR
Before a doctor could reach him he cattle show, all the women and many of the men leaving the grounds. .In the circuit court at Laporte, Ind., Judge Richter set for trial on Nov. 9 the case of Ray Larnphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Larnphere is also accused of complicity with Mrs Gunness In the murder of Andrew Helgelein. State's Attorney Smith said yesterday that lie would have nc difficulty in proving the death of Mrs. 0unness. Attorneys for the defense maintain that Mrs. Gunness is not dead.
Clipping to come
The Princeton Union · Princeton, Minn.
The report describes evidence of murder victims lured by matrimonial ads, with tools used for dismemberment found in the ruins. It also claims Lamphere set the fire and that Mrs. Gunness and her children died in it, while noting a possible sighting of her in New Mexico.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Princeton Union · 14 May 1908 · page 1
A DIABOLICAL DEED
Porte, Ind., the city made famous by the celebrated Gunness mystery, are among the visitors in the city. C. E. Hammond, who is Interested In real estate in the McAllen com
Clipping to come
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · and 1 other paper
A tenth body was uncovered at the Gunness farm, though Coroner Mack initially thought it was two bodies before concluding the extra bones belonged to the same corpse. The remains, likely a woman's based on shoes and a purse frame found nearby, showed cruder dismemberment than previous discoveries.
Reporter and Farmer · 14 May 1908 · page 7
HIS DEATH WELL TIMED. Mra. Gunness’ First Husband Expired Day Before Insurance Lapsed. Chicago, May B.—A sinister fact in connection with the death of Mads
The Worthington Advance · Worthington, Minn. · 15 May 1908
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
Officials sifting debris at the burned Gunness home found a gold crown molar believed to be from Belle Gunness's skull, bolstering belief she died in the fire. A previously suppressed autopsy report also revealed three rings on the corpse, two bearing mysterious inscriptions to 'J.S.' that local officials could not explain.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 14 May 1908 · page 2
GOLD TOOTH IN ASHES
At. the trial of Ray Lamphere for complicity in the Gunness murders, Attorneys Darrow and Worden declar ed that they expected to prove Mrs. Gunness alive. They declare they have three witnesses who saw Mrs. Gun ness July 9. Whatever doubts may have been entertained by the Japanese of the genuineness of American expressions of good will is removed as the result of the memorable meeting between the mikado and Admiral Sperry at the imperial palace and the inter change of greeting on Denan or rne emperor and President Roosevelt. The Isthmian canal commission asks $35,000,000 for work on the Pan ama canal during the fiscal year 1909 according to estimates submitted to
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
A newspaper reveals previously suppressed details from Dr. J. L. Gray's autopsy report on the body identified as Mrs. Bella Gunness, including three rings found on the corpse and the fact that her supposedly missing right hand still exists. The inscriptions on the rings reference unidentified initials 'J.S.' and 'P.S.', deepening confusion about the body's true identity.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 14 May 1908 · page 2
At the trial of Ray Lamphere for complicity in the Gunness murders, Attorneys Darrow and Worden declar ed that they expected to prove Mrs. Gunness alive. They declare they have three witnesses who saw Mrs. Gun ness July 9. Whatever doubts may have been entertained by the Japanese of the genuineness of American expressions of good will is removed as the result of the memorable meeting between the mikado and Admiral Sperry at the imperial palace and the inter change of greeting on behalf of the emperor and President Roosevelt. The Isthmian canal commission asks $35,000,000 for work on the Pan ama canal during the fiscal year 1909 according to estimates submitted to
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
Reports surface that Henry Gurholt of Wisconsin and Herman Konitzer of Chicago, both of whom vanished after corresponding with a matrimonial advertisement, are believed to be victims of Mrs. Gunness. Both had reportedly traveled to meet a widow near Laporte before disappearing.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 14 May 1908 · page 2
At tho trial of Ray Lamphero for roiupllcity in the Gunness murders, AUornoys Darrow and Worden declar ed l hat they expected to provo Mrs. thinness alive. They declare they havo three wltnesseb who saw Mrs. Gun ness .luly 9. Whatever doubts may have been entertained by 11' 3 Japanese of the genuineness of American expressions of tood will is removed as the result of tho ineniornblo meeting between the nilkado and Admiral Sperry at tin imperial palace nnd the Inter i range of greeting on behalf of the tniperor and President Uoosevelt. Tho Isthmian canal commission asks $35,000,000 for work on the Pan ama canal during the fiscal year 1909 nr cording to estimates submitted to
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
Ray Lamphere, held as an accomplice in the Gunness farm murders, denies making any confession to a reverend or anyone else. Meanwhile, Laporte banks agree to share financial records on Mrs. Gunness, a mail carrier reveals she used three aliases, and a watch found in the ruins is identified as belonging to victim Ole Budsberg.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 14 May 1908 · page 3
DENIED BY LAMPHERE
At the trial of Ray Lamphere for complicity in the Gunness murders, Attorneys Darrow and Worden declar ed that they expected to prove Mrs. Gunness alive. They declare they have Mrs. Gun three witnesses who saw
Clipping to come
The Hope Pioneer · Hope, N.D. · and 1 other paper
An estimated 15,000 people descended on the Gunness farm in La Porte, treating the murder site as a carnival with souvenir sellers and sightseers. Sheriff's deputies guarded the property to prevent looting of crime-scene debris, and further excavation for bodies was impossible due to the crowds.
The Hope Pioneer · 14 May 1908 · page 2
BIG PICNIC CROWD OVER 15,000 PEOPLE MAKE MERRY ALL DAY IN MRS. GUNNESS' GRAVE YARD
La Porte, Ind., May 11.—The con fines of the Gunness farm, still laden with the gruesome evidence of one of the greatest murder mysteries of modern times, yesterday rang with the laughter of little children, the quips and jests of country Bwains and sweethearts, the jargort of postcard "street men" and the loud disputa tions of souvenir hunters. It is estimated that at least 15,000 people poured into La Porte on speoial excursion trains,interurban earn,auto mobiles and all sorts of smaller vehi cles to attend an organized feast of the morbid and curious, beleived to be without parallel in the United States.
See moreSee less
Had an admission fee of 50 cents a head been charged, enough money might easily have been raised to de fray the expenses of employing an additional corps of detectives to work on the case.' To have done so would not materially have increased the commercial aspect of the place of butchery to-day. Sheriff Smutzer and Deputies Le roy, Marr and William Ansliss stood guard all day to prevent the debris in the cellar of the house from being carried off by the bagftl. Digging for more bodies was out of the ques tion. The sightseers would have swamped all attempts to conduct ex cavations.
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 3 other papers
Investigators digging in the yard of Mrs. Belle Gunness's burned Laporte, Indiana home uncovered multiple mutilated bodies, suggesting she orchestrated a series of murders. The report questions whether Gunness and her children truly died in the earlier house fire, speculating the fire victims may have been substituted corpses.
Wood County Reporter · 14 May 1908 · page 6
WOMAN CALLED A BLUEBEARD
GUNNESS MURDER CASE. Fifty Witnesses Called for Opening of Lamphere Trial. LA PORTE, Ind.. November 5.?Fifty witnesses were called upon today to be ready to testify next Monday, when
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · 14 May 1908
Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 15 May 1908
The Crook County Monitor · Sundance, Wyo. · 12 June 1908
Wood County Reporter · Wisconsin Rapids, Wis. · and 3 other papers
The report recounts Ray Lamphere's arrest and conflicting statements, along with suspicions that the Gunness farm served as a 'clearing-house' for murders via trunk deliveries. It includes a detailed chronology of events from Mads Sorensen's death in 1900 through the discovery of multiple bodies at the farm in May 1908.
Wood County Reporter · 14 May 1908 · page 6
WOMAN CALLED A BLUEBEARD
MRO. GUNNESS LIVES, DECLARE ATTORNEYS In Trial of Ray Lamphere Murder Farm Story to Be Retold. LA PORTE, Ind. Nov. 5—Whether Mrs. Belle Gunness is alive, or died in the fire that burned her three children, will be the quastion at the trial of T§¥ Lamphere, on Monday, on the charge ef murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children. His attorneys declare they will prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. They declare thai the people in La Porte saw the women on Juiy 9. The murder, for wnich Lamphere is held, was committed in April.
See moreSee less
The story of the fifteen murders at the Gun ness farm will be retold at the hearing. Attorneys for the derense say that they have discovered startling evidence. Tha prosecution declares that new evidence connecting Lamphere with the atrocities of the murder farm will be introduced.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 3 papers
Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb. · 14 May 1908
Dakota Farmers' Leader · Canton, S.D. · 15 May 1908
The Crook County Monitor · Sundance, Wyo. · 12 June 1908
Mexico Missouri Message · Mexico, Mo.
Authorities in Laporte, Indiana, uncovered an eighth body in the yard of Belle Gunness's farm, with evidence suggesting more victims may be buried there. The coroner speculated that Gunness substituted another body in the fire and escaped, possibly with an accomplice.
Mexico Missouri Message · 14 May 1908 · page 2
3 MORE GRAVES IN CRIME PLOT MRS. GUNNESS BELIEVED TO HAVE SUBSTITUTED BODY AND MADE ESCAPE
Be Retold. LA PORTE, Ind. Nov. 5—Whether Mrs. Belle Gunness is alive, or died in the fire that burned her three children, will be the quastion at the trial of T§¥ Lamphere, on Monday, on the charge ef murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children. His attorneys declare they will prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. They declare thai the people in La Porte saw the women on Juiy 9. The murder, for wnich Lamphere is held, was committed in April. The story of the fifteen murders at the Gun ness farm will be retold at the hearing. Attorneys for the derense say that they have discovered startling evidence. Tha prosecution declares that new evidence connecting Lamphere with the atrocities of the murder farm will be introduced.
Clipping to come
Oxford Eagle · Oxford, Miss.
Diggers at the Gunness farm in La Porte uncovered the skeletons of a man, a woman, and a third partially disarticulated body, raising the death toll attributed to Belle Gunness to around 18. Authorities now doubt the charred female body found in the house ruins was Gunness herself, and believe she fled, possibly back to Norway, with roughly $20,000 in stolen funds.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Oxford Eagle · 14 May 1908 · page 1
THREE MORE BODIES FOUND.
Be Retold. LA PORTE, Ind. Nov. 5—Whether Mrs. Belle Gunness is alive, or died in the fire that burned her three children, will be the quastion at the trial of T§¥ Lamphere, on Monday, on the charge ef murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children. His attorneys declare they will prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. They declare thai the people in La Porte saw the women on Juiy 9. The murder, for wnich Lamphere is held, was committed in April. The story of the fifteen murders at the Gun ness farm will be retold at the hearing. Attorneys for the derense say that they have discovered startling evidence. Tha prosecution declares that new evidence connecting Lamphere with the atrocities of the murder farm will be introduced.
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Coroner Mack initially reported a new body found at the Gunness farm, bringing the total to ten, but later clarified the extra bones belonged to a previously found skeleton. Meanwhile, the prosecutor gathers evidence against Ray Lamphere, including letters from Belle Gunness found in his abandoned trunk.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
TEN BODIES DUG UP ANOTHER VICTIM ADDED TO GUNNESS FARM DEATH ROLL.
Be Retold. LA PORTE, Ind. Nov. 5—Whether Mrs. Belle Gunness is alive, or died in the fire that burned her three children, will be the quastion at the trial of T§¥ Lamphere, on Monday, on the charge ef murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children. His attorneys declare they will prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. They declare thai the people in La Porte saw the women on Juiy 9. The murder, for wnich Lamphere is held, was committed in April. The story of the fifteen murders at the Gun ness farm will be retold at the hearing. Attorneys for the derense say that they have discovered startling evidence. Tha prosecution declares that new evidence connecting Lamphere with the atrocities of the murder farm will be introduced.
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Investigators recovered a trunk containing letters from Belle Gunness to Ray Lamphere urging him to return, along with women's rings, while a new witness claimed Lamphere admitted blackmailing her. Excavation at the farm continued amid crowds of spectators, with nine bodies already found and a coroner's premature report of two more fueling further rumors.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
GUNNESS FARM DEATH ROLL
Aberdeen, S. D. It Is the accepted be. lief of the authorities that the activ ity of Helgeleln's brother In investigat ing the mystery of the former's dis appearance led Lamphere to put the widow and her children out of the way in order to save himself. Lamphere had been employed for some years on the Gunness farm and that he had a guilty knowledge of the nefarious traffic carried on by the wid ow seems certain. Considerable doubt exists, however, as to the extent of his complicity in the wholesale murders. He logically answers etaoHRDLUUU He logically appears In the light of a possible accomplice, on the theory that the woman could not have done her murderous work alone. However, his
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Excavators at the Gunness farm uncovered another dismembered body in the barnyard, bringing the total found to ten, with evidence suggesting a less skilled hand performed this dismemberment. Prosecutor Smith, gathering testimony from witnesses like Colson, outlined his theory that Lamphere tried to extort money from Belle Gunness using knowledge of Andrew Helgelein's murder, leading to their falling out and his setting the fire that killed her and the children.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Aberdeen, S. D. It Is the accepted be. lief of the authorities that the activ ity of Helgeleln's brother In investigat ing the mystery of the former's dis appearance led Lamphere to put the widow and her children out of the way in order to save himself. Lamphere had been employed for some years on the Gunness farm and that he had a guilty knowledge of the nefarious traffic carried on by the wid ow seems certain. Considerable doubt exists, however, as to the extent of his complicity in the wholesale murders. He logically answers etaoHRDLUUU He logically appears In the light of a possible accomplice, on the theory that the woman could not have done her murderous work alone. However, his
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
The death count at the Gunness farm is corrected to ten after the coroner determines that supposed additional remains were actually part of the first body found. Meanwhile, prosecutors gather new evidence against Ray Lamphere, including letters from Belle Gunness found in his trunk urging him to return to the farm.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 3
TEN BODIES DUG UP ANOTHER VICTIM ADDED TO GUNNESS FARM DEATH ROLL
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Attorney Worden sought Lamphere's trunk, which contained letters from Mrs. Gunness urging him to return to her farm with his sweetheart if she had money, plus women's rings. New witnesses emerged, including one alleging Lamphere tried to blackmail Gunness, while crowds continued flocking to the farm amid a premature report of two more bodies found.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 3
GUNNESS FARM DEATH ROLL
Special to the Herald La Porte Ind Nov 5 Interest in the Gunness murder case which ex cited the attention of the entire coun try > last spring will he revived next vyeefc when Ray Lamphere alleged to have heen the righthand man o Mrs Bella Gunness in conducting her mui der farm is placed on trial Lam phere Is under indictment for the murder of Mrs Gunners and her thiee children hy burning her farm house and Is charged also with complicity in the killing of several of the womans victims It Is probable the youth will be tried first for the murder of Mrs Gun ness although the prosecuting attor ney claims to have avery strong case against him on the charge of complic ity in the murder of Andrew Helge lein Helgelein who was a South Dakota farmer came here with 2900 after a correspondence with Mrs Gunness and was never more heard of He was but one of a dozen or njore men who are believed to have fallen vic tims to the womans wiles In addition to the murder of Helge lein Lamphere is charged with com plicity in the murder of several others but the killing of Helgelein which is said to have occurred January 14 last is believed to furnish the strongest case against him The destruction of the Gunness house and the burning of the widow and her three children occurred on the night of April 28 It came as a climax to a strenuous investigation by a brother as to the whereabouts of Al bert Helgelein who is believed to have been the last victim of Mrs Gun nessT Helgelein was lured to the Gun ness farm through a matrimonial ad vertisement After his arrival he was Induced to turn into the womans hands nearly 3000 which he had earned as a rancher on his section of land near Aberdeen S D It is the accepted belief of the authorities that the activity of Helgeleins brother in investigating the mystery of the for mers disappearance led Lamphere to put the widow and her children out of the way in order to sav6 himself Xiamphere had been employed for
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Excavators at the Gunness farm uncovered a tenth decomposed body, poorly dismembered and showing lime traces, as crowds gathered despite a premature report from the coroner. Prosecutor Smith, building his case against Lamphere, theorized that Lamphere tried to blackmail Belle Gunness over his knowledge of Andrew Helgelein's murder and set the fatal fire in revenge, though without intending to kill her.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 3
Special to the Herald La Porte Ind Nov 5 Interest in the Gunness murder case which ex cited the attention of the entire coun try > last spring will he revived next vyeefc when Ray Lamphere alleged to have heen the righthand man o Mrs Bella Gunness in conducting her mui der farm is placed on trial Lam phere Is under indictment for the murder of Mrs Gunners and her thiee children hy burning her farm house and Is charged also with complicity in the killing of several of the womans victims It Is probable the youth will be tried first for the murder of Mrs Gun ness although the prosecuting attor ney claims to have avery strong case against him on the charge of complic ity in the murder of Andrew Helge lein Helgelein who was a South Dakota farmer came here with 2900 after a correspondence with Mrs Gunness and was never more heard of He was but one of a dozen or njore men who are believed to have fallen vic tims to the womans wiles In addition to the murder of Helge lein Lamphere is charged with com s plicity in the murder of several others but the killing of Helgelein which is said to have occurred January 14 last is believed to furnish the strongest case against him The destruction of the Gunness house and the burning of the widow li and her three children occurred on the night of April 28 It came as a climax IS c to a strenuous investigation by a brother as to the whereabouts of Al bert Helgelein who is believed to have been the last victim of Mrs Gun nessT Helgelein was lured to the Gun ness farm through a matrimonial ad vertisement After his arrival he was Induced to turn into the womans Is1 hands nearly 3000 which he had earned as a rancher on his section of land near Aberdeen S D It is the accepted belief of the authorities that the activity of Helgeleins brother in investigating the mystery of the for mers disappearance led Lamphere to put the widow and her children out of the way in order to sav6 himself Xiamphere had been employed for 4 Wgxsg > some years on the Gunness farm and f 38 fe ttiafrhehad of the K a knowledge
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
Four doctors' post-mortem reports on the bodies found in the Gunness ruins fail to establish cause of death, leading the coroner's jury toward an open verdict. A dentist examining a supposed tooth found on the farm declares it merely gilded wood, not human remains.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 4
TOOTH NOT FOUND IN ASHES
Special to the Herald La Porte Ind Nov 5 Interest in the Gunness murder case which ex cited the attention of the entire coun try > last spring will he revived next vyeefc when Ray Lamphere alleged to have heen the righthand man o Mrs Bella Gunness in conducting her mui der farm is placed on trial Lam phere Is under indictment for the murder of Mrs Gunners and her thiee children hy burning her farm house and Is charged also with complicity in the killing of several of the womans victims It Is probable the youth will be tried first for the murder of Mrs Gun ness although the prosecuting attor ney claims to have avery strong case against him on the charge of complic ity in the murder of Andrew Helge lein Helgelein who was a South Dakota farmer came here with 2900 after a correspondence with Mrs Gunness and was never more heard of He was but one of a dozen or njore men who are believed to have fallen vic tims to the womans wiles In addition to the murder of Helge lein Lamphere is charged with com s plicity in the murder of several others but the killing of Helgelein which is said to have occurred January 14 last is believed to furnish the strongest case against him The destruction of the Gunness house and the burning of the widow li and her three children occurred on the night of April 28 It came as a climax IS c to a strenuous investigation by a brother as to the whereabouts of Al bert Helgelein who is believed to have been the last victim of Mrs Gun nessT Helgelein was lured to the Gun ness farm through a matrimonial ad vertisement After his arrival he was Induced to turn into the womans Is1 hands nearly 3000 which he had earned as a rancher on his section of land near Aberdeen S D It is the accepted belief of the authorities that the activity of Helgeleins brother in investigating the mystery of the for mers disappearance led Lamphere to put the widow and her children out of the way in order to sav6 himself Xiamphere had been employed for 4 Wgxsg > some years on the Gunness farm and f 38 fe ttiafrhehad of the K a knowledge
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
A Norwegian laborer near Kansas City received a letter purportedly from Belle Gunness, the accused Laporte murderess, asking him to send $1,000 if he wished to marry her. The letter had sat undelivered in the local post office for several days before reaching him.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 4
he could be nu one elsa than M. Gunness. I approached within fifty feet of the couple and co.ild sre that the man's hair was streaked w.th gray above his ears. The woman hurried to a wagon on my approach
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
A day of conflicting developments in the Gunness case included evidence suggesting three additional victims, while physicians' post-mortem reports failed to establish how the woman and three children died. A dentist examined the supposed tooth found on the farm and declared it merely gilded wood, likely from a picture frame.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 5
TOOTH NOT FOUND IN ASHES
Worsen attorneys fr Lamphere. I am ready to swear that I could not have been mistaken."' This news has fallen upin the prosecution as a great surprise, al though persons from one end of the country to the other have made "positive" Identifications of women they Imagined wre the La Porte murderess since the controversy fol lowing the burning of her home as to whether Mrs. Gunness was the woman who died In the ruins w;th her three children. On the th ory that the woman was alive, numerous women who bore nome resemblance to the murderess were detained, one being arrested and taken from a sleeping car p-tfs-lng through Iltlca.
See moreSee less
Another sensa tional feature of the case was the at tempts to Implicate other persons. Notable among these was the fake
Clipping to come
The Alliance Herald · Alliance, Neb.
A Norwegian laborer in Kansas received a letter purportedly from Belle Gunness, the Laporte murderess, offering to marry him if he produced $1,000 in cash. The letter had sat in the local post office for several days before delivery.
The Alliance Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 5
"confession" of Julius O. Truelson. Jr., of New York, son of a well-to-do piano manufacturer, who swo-e In the Jail In Vr-rnon, T"X., that h" wn an accompl cc of Mrs. Gunness and that Ray Lam phi re n s'sted h'm to dispose of several bodies after Mrs. Gunness hnd murdered them. Truel son is stlM in the Texas jail, hld for forgery, his "confession" thoroughly disproved. Since the enso dropped partly from public attention the. chemical analy kIb of the stomachs nf te womsn and two of the children had been eomplrted snd has changed sveral respects rf the prosecution of lamp here.
See moreSee less
Arsenic and strychnine were found In ouantitlcs sufficient to have caused death, leading to the supposi tion that the woman may hav pois oned herself and her three children and then set fire to the houso. On this theory tho defense of Lt mphere would have rested with gi od chanc nf acquittal had not H'idson, the neighboring farmer come forwara with the statement that he and his daughters have see.n Mrs. Gunness ai: ve. The trial may lust two weeks though one wees: Is counted on hy the defense to gain Lamphere's lib erty. The state has elected to go to tilal on the indioement for the mur der nf Mrs. Gurness. If on that charge Lamphere be acqu'tted ft may place him on trial on the Indict ment charging complicity in tha murder of Andrew . Helgelein, tho last victim, who was lu-e to tie farm last Christmas, robbed of near ly 13 000, poisoned, his body oinsect ei and burled In the dooryard. In this cas.i the state will attempt to prove. If It goes to trial, that ijimi here on the right of Helgeleln'a murder, returned with a friend
Clipping to come
Valentine Democrat · Valentine, Neb.
An estimated 15,000 sightseers flooded roads to the Gunness farm in Laporte county on Sunday, overwhelming hotels, transportation, and local authorities. Investigation stalled as officials themselves became spectators, while some visitors searched the unidentified remains for missing relatives, including a man seeking his brother Thomas Lindboe.
Valentine Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 2
CURIOUS THRONG MURDER FARM OVERRUN WITH CURIOUS THRONG
! 3"or Mrs. Gunness three years ago , am Jthat the last letter that he had fron ! him contained the information tha 'Thomas intended to marry his employ- .er. Olaf wrote to the woman a littlt
Sheriff Smutzer believes at least 38 people were killed by Belle Gunness and suspects she faked her death, planning to flee to Norway in disguise. State's Attorney Smith disagrees, maintaining that Ray Lamphere set the fire for revenge and that Gunness died in the blaze.
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 14 May 1908 · page 1
WORSE THAN BLUEBEARD.
ARCH MURDERESS. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 7. Startling rev elations are promised by the prosecu tion in the trial of Ray Lamphere, ac cused of burning to death Mrs. Bella Gunness, the modern borgia, and her three adopted children by setting fire to the Gunness house of death last April. Judge John Richter will try the case which opens Monday. Cor respondence between the Gunnesj woman and two men now living in the vicinity of Laporte in the possession of Prosecutor, Ralph N. Smith, indi cates that Lamphere had for a long time been threatening Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness with exposure, unless she regularly paid him stipulated sums of money. The letters are said to make plain Lamphere's motive in' committing the crime. Both these men will be summoned as witnesses and their identity is be ing closely guarded. Prosecutor Smith is confident that Lamphere will be convicted on the evidence.
Clipping to come
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.
Mrs. Cora Bell Herron, arrested in Syracuse on suspicion of being Belle Gunness, was released after proving her residence in Franklin, Pa., and claimed mistreatment by detectives. Meanwhile, a rumor from Laporte claimed Ray Lamphere had confessed enough to State Attorney Smith to hang him, though Bessie Wallace remained the principal witness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Lamphere Confident. Lamphere declared in the jail today that he was confident of acquittal. They may twist and turn the evidence all they like." he said, "but if they prove that I set fire to the house they will have to do it by false testimony. Whatever I may have been guilty of, I did not do that. I have been the vic tim of circumstances and my actions on the night the house burned have been misrepresented. "I have been made to tell twenty different stories, according to other people, but really I have only told one.
See moreSee less
I have led a pretty loose life, maybe, and possibly I drank too much at times, but there are others who have done as bad as I who are walking the streets of Laporte free today. I knew nothing about the house of crimes, as they called It. I worked for Mrs. Gunness once, but I didn't see her kill anybody and didn't know she had killed anybody. I think that something could be cleared up about all these bodies that would show a great mistake has been made."
Clipping to come
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.
Sheriff Smutzer reports that the autopsy on the body found in the burned Gunness house confirms it was Belle Gunness, noting hair clutched in her hands resembling that of jailed suspect Ray Lamphere. County authorities plan to offer a $10,000 reward for her capture, as some believe she is still alive.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 14 May 1908 · page 6
Luring Men to Her Place by Meant of Matrimonial Advertisement,. Laporte, Ind., Nor. 9. Ray Lam phere was placed on trial in the cir cuit court here today on a charge of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness, her three children and Andrew Helgelein by setting fire to the Gunness home last April. The question of whether Mrs. Gun Bess Is dead or alive forms fcne of the wain features of the trial of Lam phere, who was employed by Mrs. Gun Bess on her farm, near this place. State's Attorney R. H.
See moreSee less
Smith de clared that by the Introduction of evi dence he would prove that Mrs. Gun ness. who by means of matrimonial adhi. on th .h. mirht rK ,k ... then murder them, died in her own home on the morning of April 28, 1909: that her body was burned to a crisp, that It was held for weeks at Cutler's morgue in this city and that it now lies buried in Forest Home cemetery, Chi cago. Attorney Worden for the defense wiil use Lamphere as his principal witness, and around the story which the fnrm hand will tell the lawyer says he will
Clipping to come
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · Goldsboro, N.C.
A well-dressed woman traveling with her mother was pulled off a train in Syracuse after travelers claimed she resembled published photos of Belle Gunness. She denied being Gunness, identifying herself as Mrs. Cora Bell Herron, but police held and questioned both women at length.
Goldsboro Weekly Argus · 14 May 1908 · page 8
IS IT MRS. GUNNESS? Not The First Tims T fiat Unfortunate Re semblance Gets Innocent People in the Lime Light. Special to Thk Arqtts. Syracuse. N. Y., May 9. A woman
Ray Lamphere's father, a justice of the peace, travels to Laporte to assist in his son's defense, insisting Ray is incapable of murder. A witness also recalls suspicious circumstances at Peter Gunness's funeral, where Belle Gunness was mysteriously absent from the burial procession.
George Anderson describes his harrowing visit to Belle Gunness's farm two years earlier, claiming his lack of money spared him from being murdered. He says he now believes Gunness faked her death by fire and is still alive, and recalls the eldest daughter's fearful behavior.
The Oakes Times · 14 May 1908 · page 2
St. Joseph, Mo., May 12.—"Because kily had no money I now believe Is the thing that saved me Jrom being murdered by "Sirs. Gunness near La porte, Ind.," said George Anderson of Tarklo, Mo., as he boarded the Rook bland train for Chicago, where he will offer his personal testimony and letter* written him by Mr*. Gunness to the authorities. "I think the woman is still alive and that *he set fire to the farmhouse herself. I believe that the eldest girl knew of her mother's crimes. I now recollect that she acted very strange ly.
See moreSee less
She would eye me with a pitiful look and when I glanced at her during a meal she was as white as a sheet." Anderson is a Swede thirty-nine years old. Two years ago while at Monteith, Mich., he answered one of Mrs. Gunness' advertisements, posing himself as a wealthy farmer. She wrote him to come on and he did so. The second day she asked him point blank how much money he had. He claimed only a few hundred dollars cash, but bad a 320-acre farm. She told him to sell the farm and bring the money to her and they would b'e married. He went away for a few day* and returned one night without notifying Mrs. Gunness. He found a ^nan he now believes to be Ray Lam phere In her company. He confessed to her that he had no money. She waa incensed, but told him to spenr the night at her place. He went to ted, but was awakened and found the Woman bending over him. He spoke and she ran out of the room. Greatly frightened he did not olose his eyes after that and at daylight left the place.
A train conductor identifies a large woman matching Belle Gunness's description traveling with a supposed interpreter toward Seattle, noting she briefly spoke fluent English despite claiming otherwise. The report recaps the farm fire and presumed deaths before police begin investigating this lead.
The Ward County Independent · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Wash., The mlaitter is being looked into Iby the police. The story of the many murders committed on mo man's farm a mile from La Porte, Ind., is familiar ,to most of our readers, we believe. The Gunness farm residence was recently burned and it was sup posed that Mrs. Gunness and her three children were cremated. Tihe cihildren
A newspaper recounts the atrocities on the Gunness farm, including dismembered bodies found in the barnyard and a female corpse in the burned house, suggesting Belle Gunness may have substituted another body and escaped. It also reports a train conductor's claim that she passed through Minot on May 5, prompting investigation, alongside news of Ray Lamphere's arrest as an accomplice.
The Ward County Independent · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Did LaPorte, Ind. Murderess Pass Thru Minot -- Conductor Benton of the G.N. is Certain That She Did, on the Night of May 5 -- Matter is Being Investigated -- Woman Enroute to Washington
Woman Eiiroute to 'Washington undoubtedly were burned, for their 'bodies were found in the ruins. The body of a woman wias also found in the ruins, but it foas been suggested that Mrs. Gunness, feiardmg detection of the murders she bias committed, placed a corpse in the house, then fired the building then made her es cape. Her rings were found in the ruins, ibut these could have been placed on tihe hands of tihe corpse. The murders committeed on the Gunness farm were the most atrocious in many years. The woman advertised for a husband and when she received lan answer she required tihe prosper tive husband to rake all the cash he could get together and visit her home.
See moreSee less
She would get her clutches on the intoney and the man would be see no more. She would explain 'tlhat he was the price ttoit mot suited and -had went away. Sevr eral victims disappeared mysteriously and aifter tihe ihiouse was burned the •premises were searched. In the barn ylard close to 'tihe (house item bodies Wave ailready been found, most of them buried in a pine coffin and in a nude condition. In nearly every case the 'bodies were out to pieces. Ray Lamiphere, a carpenter and gardner, who worked on the Gunness farm, has been arrested charged with murder, it being belieevd thlait he helped tihe wo man to kill the victims.
A seventh body is discovered on the Gunness farm, buried four feet deep and dismembered like earlier victims, bringing the total to six confirmed bodies. Disputes continue over the identity of the body thought to be Andrew Helgelein, while a new investigation opens into the disappearance of Ole Budsberg.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 2
AFFAIR CLOUDED IN MYSTERY
Laporte, Ind., May 7.—One more body has been disinterred on the Ouinness farm near here, making a total of six. It is believed that more
Investigators disinter more bodies at the Gunness farm, including two adult corpses previously thought to be children, while disputes continue over identifying the man believed to be Andrew Helgelein. A new disappearance case, Ole Budsberg, emerges as officers theorize the male victims were suitors defrauded and killed, and speculation grows that Belle Gunness faked her death and remains alive.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 2
AFFAIR CLOUDED IN MYSTERY
'tola. Wis. Budsberg came to Laporte In March, 1907. He was acquainted wttb Mrs. Guinness and in company wtth her visited the Laporte Savings bank, where he deposited a note for $1,000 to be collected by the Farmers' Stat* bank of Iola, Wis. The note was paid April 6, 1907, and Budsberg CftseivejL. LLOQft from the Laporte
Investigators float the theory that Belle Gunness is still alive, possibly in Chicago, having faked her death by substituting a female victim's headless body in the fire. The report also notes identification of Jennie Olson's remains by her father and details an autopsy showing murder victims had skull fractures, plus reprints the matrimonial ad used to lure victims.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 2
40# might be alive Includes tbe sup jnltion that she feared Lamphere [Mb about to expose her through Jeal- *7* oflHova also have the mystery 0t five trims shipped from Chicago lo the Ouinness farm to solve. These feunks ill arrived In Laporte during
Ray Lamphere's father, a justice of the peace, arrived in Laporte to help defend his son and insisted Ray was incapable of the murders. A pallbearer at Peter Gunness's funeral recounted that Belle Gunness mysteriously vanished before the burial procession departed, raising suspicion.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 4
FATHER TO DEFEND HIS SON
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
George Anderson of Tarkio, Mo., describes answering Mrs. Gunness's matrimonial advertisement and nearly falling victim to her after revealing he had little money. He now believes she is alive, set the farmhouse fire herself, and suspects her eldest daughter knew of her crimes.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 4
HIS POVERTY SAVED HIM
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
A gold-crowned molar found in the ashes of the burned Gunness farmhouse is reported as evidence from the incinerated skull of Belle Gunness. Dr. J. L. Gray's previously suppressed autopsy report is said to confirm this identification, despite ongoing doubts about whether the burned body was truly hers.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 6
Laporte. LAPORTE, 1Ind.,, Nov. 10.—With twelve men in the jury box accepted by the State, but only four of them exam ined by the defense, the second day's sessjon of the trial of Ray lL.amphere on the charge of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children began today. The speed with which the four Jurors were accepted surprised every one. The jurors accepted are James Nelson, farmer; Henry Mills, farmer; V. W. Bartholemew, merchant; Charles Schlaak, merchant. The questions put to veniremen today by Attorney Worden, for Lamphere, brought out the line of defense.
See moreSee less
Every man was asked “Are you firmly con vinced that Mrs. Belle Gunness is not alive?” Andrew L. Ames and O. L. Small, veniremen accepted by the State, were challenged by the defense when they admitted that they were convinced the woman is dead.
Clipping to come
Jamestown Weekly Alert · Jamestown, N.D.
Reports describe two more men, Henry Gurholt and Herman Konitzer, believed to be victims of Belle Gunness after corresponding with her matrimonial ads. A Kansas man also received a letter from Gunness demanding he bring $1,000 cash before she would marry him.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 14 May 1908 · page 6
Laporte. LAPORTE, 1Ind.,, Nov. 10.—With twelve men in the jury box accepted by the State, but only four of them exam ined by the defense, the second day's sessjon of the trial of Ray lL.amphere on the charge of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children began today. The speed with which the four Jurors were accepted surprised every one. The jurors accepted are James Nelson, farmer; Henry Mills, farmer; V. W. Bartholemew, merchant; Charles Schlaak, merchant. The questions put to veniremen today by Attorney Worden, for Lamphere, brought out the line of defense.
See moreSee less
Every man was asked “Are you firmly con vinced that Mrs. Belle Gunness is not alive?” Andrew L. Ames and O. L. Small, veniremen accepted by the State, were challenged by the defense when they admitted that they were convinced the woman is dead.
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
Investigators reveal that Belle Gunness used male agents and drummers, not just advertisements, to recruit victims, including one approached in a Cleveland public square. Letters show an agent collected her mail under her name and aliases from several towns, while hundreds of letters from anxious relatives pour in to authorities.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 14 May 1908 · page 5
HER AGENT APPROACHED MAN IN PUBLIC SQUARE
LAPORTE, Ind., May 14—That Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch-slayer, employ ed drummers as well as < matrimonial advertisements to find victims, is the latest amazing development of the murder-farm atrocities. A letter came to Chief of Police Cochrane from a man in Cleveland, O. The letter says that last August while the latter was standing in the Cleve land public square a well-dressed man engaged him in conversation. He asked the writer casually if ho was married and the writer replied that ho was not. Immediately the stranger told him about a rich widow living In Laporte who wanted "a man.” The stranger asked the writer if he was willing to go to Laporte to sec the woman, and when the latter declined the stranger said the woman would go to Cleveland If hen faro was paid.
See moreSee less
The stranger also turned over a picture of the Laporte widow. It is a picture of Mrs. Gunness, of the “penny" variety. The authorities also got evidence to ahow that an agent for Mrs. Gunness had collected mail addressed to her un der her own name and two aliases at the post offices in Chicago, Peru, Ind.;
Authorities investigating Belle Gunness uncovered an agent who collected her mail under aliases from multiple towns, while hundreds of letters from anxious relatives poured in seeking missing loved ones. Defense attorneys for Lamphere sought a witness who allegedly found bodies in the cellar before the fire, while metal globules from the farm were sent to a jeweler to determine if they were dental gold.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 14 May 1908 · page 5
Lrilrra Reveal Pitiful Stories. Hundreds of letters revealing pitiful stories of anxious par;nts, brothers, sisters and wives who have waited long months for word from their loved ones, are being received by the authorities investigating the atrocities of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch-slayer. The letters show that in an aston ishing number of cases the habits, characteristics or physical peculiarities of tlie missing persons have been either unknown or forgotten, so that the au thorities are powerless to give the aid sought. The attorneys for Lamphere, the ac cused farm hand, are said to be looking for David Havens, who, it is reported, aided in unrovering the bodies of the persons whom Lamphere is accused of murdering.
See moreSee less
The attorneys say that Havens has declared that the bod ies were found in the cellar of the Gunness Home, thus showing that the bodies had been placed in the cellar previous to thr beginning of the fire which destroyed the farm house.
A letter signed 'John Williamson' mailed from Milwaukee offered to turn Mrs. Gunness over to police within three days for a $5,000 reward. Separately, officials were investigating reports of an automobile seen leaving the fire scene carrying a man and a woman thought to be Mrs. Gunness.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MAN IN LETTER OFFERS TO FIND MRS. GUNNESS
National Municipal league; revival of interest in the famous Gunness "death farm" tragedies at La Porte; the trial of Kay Lamphere, Mrs. Gunness' farm nanil; also in the case of Herman
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Indiana prosecutor Ralph Smith declares Ray Lamphere will be convicted of murdering either Belle Gunness or Andrew Helgelein, citing mounting evidence. Deputy Sheriff Anstiss reports Lamphere's statements suggest he witnessed Gunness dismembering Helgelein's body, and Lamphere's identification of rings helps confirm the burned corpse as Gunness herself.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE TO STAND TRIAL Will Hang for One of Two Crimes, Says Prosecutor in Indiana Murder Mystery. MRS. GUNNESS' ACCOMPLICE
National Municipal league; revival of interest in the famous Gunness "death farm" tragedies at La Porte; the trial of Kay Lamphere, Mrs. Gunness' farm nanil; also in the case of Herman
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
A Cleveland man writes to police describing a stranger who tried to recruit him to meet a 'rich widow' in Laporte, Indiana, offering a photograph that turned out to be of Mrs. Gunness. He only connected the odd encounter to the murder farm after reading news reports, and police plan to investigate further.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
MRS. GUNNESS' ACCOMPLICE
WAS LAMPHERE'S ADVISER. Laporte, Nov. 11. Because the In diana law prohibits a spiritual adviser from testifying in a criminal case, it is probable tha't the Rev. E. A. Schell who is alleged to have obtained a par tial confession from Ray Lamphere, will not be called to the witness stand in the Gunness case. Nine veniremen were excused this morning, none being acceptable. Ev cry one had a fixed opinion as to Mrs. Gunness being dead or alive. The second special venire in the Ijemphere case was exhausted Tues day without a jury having been obtain ed.
See moreSee less
Judge Rlchter at once ordered a third venire, the members of which were ready for examination today. Ten jurymen , were - in the jury box Tuesday.. The proceedings, attended by a large crowd, which manifested much interest, were prosy, although attor neys, for Lamphere brought new life into the case by making public some new evidence in their . possession Fred Lambright, a neighbor of Mrs. Gunness, and who - claims that one night in July, as he was driving to town, he saw a man and a woman in a buggy drawn by a gray horse drive into the Gunness yard, will be a wit ness for the defense. According to his story, he watched them and heard the woman say, "The money ain't here." after she had jumped out of the . rig and walked around the ruins of the burned house The woman, he alleges, was very much like Mrs. Gunness in appearance and the voice was similar to that of the alleged murderess. The man he did not recognize. He says he did not tell anybody about the matter at that time because he was afraid of being laughed at. ; This evidence, Attorney Worden states, is to be used to corroborate the story of D. M. Hudson and his two daughters, who will testify that they saw Mrs. Gunness on July 9. Lam bright does not fix a date, but ie de fense declares that it must have been on the 9th.
Clipping to come
The Monmouth Inquirer · Freehold, N.J.
Investigators digging up bodies on the Gunness farm now suspect the headless corpse found in the burned house may not be Belle Gunness herself, but a substitute brought from Chicago. A nearby cemetery was found robbed of a body, fueling theories she staged her death and fled after murdering suitors and her own children.
The Monmouth Inquirer · 14 May 1908 · page 2
HER OWN DEATH REPORTED
WAS LAMPHERE'S ADVISER. Laporte, Nov. 11. Because the In diana law prohibits a spiritual adviser from testifying in a criminal case, it is probable tha't the Rev. E. A. Schell who is alleged to have obtained a par tial confession from Ray Lamphere, will not be called to the witness stand in the Gunness case. Nine veniremen were excused this morning, none being acceptable. Ev cry one had a fixed opinion as to Mrs. Gunness being dead or alive. The second special venire in the Ijemphere case was exhausted Tues day without a jury having been obtain ed.
See moreSee less
Judge Rlchter at once ordered a third venire, the members of which were ready for examination today. Ten jurymen , were - in the jury box Tuesday.. The proceedings, attended by a large crowd, which manifested much interest, were prosy, although attor neys, for Lamphere brought new life into the case by making public some new evidence in their . possession Fred Lambright, a neighbor of Mrs. Gunness, and who - claims that one night in July, as he was driving to town, he saw a man and a woman in a buggy drawn by a gray horse drive into the Gunness yard, will be a wit ness for the defense. According to his story, he watched them and heard the woman say, "The money ain't here." after she had jumped out of the . rig and walked around the ruins of the burned house The woman, he alleges, was very much like Mrs. Gunness in appearance and the voice was similar to that of the alleged murderess. The man he did not recognize. He says he did not tell anybody about the matter at that time because he was afraid of being laughed at. ; This evidence, Attorney Worden states, is to be used to corroborate the story of D. M. Hudson and his two daughters, who will testify that they saw Mrs. Gunness on July 9. Lam bright does not fix a date, but ie de fense declares that it must have been on the 9th.
Clipping to come
Gloucester County Democrat · Woodbury, N.J.
A daily news summary lists major stories including the Gunness Murder Farm Exposure horrifying the public, alongside unrelated foreign and political news like an Afghan invasion of India. The item itself provides no details on the Gunness case, only referencing it as a headline within the broader digest.
Gloucester County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
La Porte officials, including the coroner, sheriff, and prosecuting attorney, report that Rev. E. A. Schell revealed conversations with Ray Lamphere pointing to evidence that Belle Gunness did not act alone in luring her victims. Lamphere's attorney counters this, stating his client has never confessed to anyone and never will.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS HAD ACCOMPLICE Evidence Unearthed That In diana Borgia Did Not Work Alone in Luring Victims to Their Doom, By Hurninx .lourmil Hurclul I mttnl Wirs l
Two additional watches were found in the debris of the Gunness farmhouse, bringing the number of men's watches found to ten, though only nine male victims had been unearthed. Sheriff Smutzer announced he would resume digging in hopes of finding more skeletons.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 14 May 1908 · page 1
TO RESUME DIGGING ON GUNNESS FARM
.Home, With Woman and Chil dren, After Aiding to Mur der Hen Lured Thither. Laportc, Ind., Nov. 0. Ray Lam VPhere, former farmhand for Mrs. Belle Gun n oss, proprietor of the "mur der fnrm," was placed on trial here to day on the charge of murdering the woman, her three ehlldreu and An drew Helgeleln. Judge Hlcbter presides at the trial. A special venire has been called to provide a jury, and It Is the Intention of Prosecuting Attorney Smith to car ry through the trial without delay. Lnmphere's attorneys, Messrs.
See moreSee less
Darrow and Worden, are determined to clear their client an soon as possible. "We shall make a determined effort to prove that Lamphere set Are to Hip Gunness house, thereby causing the deaths of Mrs. Gunness and her chll dreu," said Mr. Smith. "We also be lieve that we can connect him with the - murder of Andrew Helgeleln." ;"We are going to clear Lamphere," said Attorney Worden. "The state has no case against him for the death of Mrs. Gunness." Opinion as to the farmhand's guilt seems to be about equally divided In the town. There are. those who hold that he was a willing tool of Mrs. Gunness In doing away with the
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Letters arrive from across the country asking about missing people possibly connected to Gunness, while Lamphere's attorneys continue to doubt she is dead. Physicians confirm the body is hers after microscopic comparison of rings, despite disputes over whether a gold object found was a tooth or picture-frame gilding.
The Sun · 14 May 1908 · page 3
WAY LAJlfHUKhi. men whom she murdered after rob bing them and that jealousy brought him to the point of burning up the woman and her children. Others 'hold that he Is not mentally accountable and not capable of planning so atro cious a crime. Fifty witnesses In the case have been called upon to bo ready today to tell what they know of the proceed lags at tho "murder farm." The Gunness case startled the world last spring, when It was demonstrated beyond a doubt that the woman had lured hither a number of men from various parts of the country by means of advertisements in matrimonial pa pers and had then done them to death for their money.
See moreSee less
Among them was Andrew Helgeleln. The finding of bones on the farm after the place was burned led to the disclosure of the crimes. For many days the remains t of the woman and her children were sought. It was .reported that she was seen in varlous-'parts of the United States, but the reports were not veri fied. The coroner's verdict was that she perished in the fire. Before this verdict was reached Lamphere had been arrested on the charge of killing Mrs. Gunness and aiding her In put ting out of the way the men who had been traced to Laporte.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A letter sent to Chief of Police Cochrane describes a stranger in Cleveland who tried to recruit a man to visit a rich widow in Laporte, showing him a photo of Mrs. Gunness. Authorities then found evidence that an agent for Mrs. Gunness had been collecting mail under her name and aliases (Jennie Blackley, Jennie Sorenson) at post offices in Chicago, Peru, and Champaign.
The Sun · 14 May 1908 · page 3
WAY LAJlfHUKhi. men whom she murdered after rob bing them and that jealousy brought him to the point of burning up the woman and her children. Others 'hold that he Is not mentally accountable and not capable of planning so atro cious a crime. Fifty witnesses In the case have been called upon to bo ready today to tell what they know of the proceed lags at tho "murder farm." The Gunness case startled the world last spring, when It was demonstrated beyond a doubt that the woman had lured hither a number of men from various parts of the country by means of advertisements in matrimonial pa pers and had then done them to death for their money.
See moreSee less
Among them was Andrew Helgeleln. The finding of bones on the farm after the place was burned led to the disclosure of the crimes. For many days the remains t of the woman and her children were sought. It was .reported that she was seen in varlous-'parts of the United States, but the reports were not veri fied. The coroner's verdict was that she perished in the fire. Before this verdict was reached Lamphere had been arrested on the charge of killing Mrs. Gunness and aiding her In put ting out of the way the men who had been traced to Laporte.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Investigators traced an agent who collected mail for Mrs. Gunness under her name and aliases (Jennie Blackmer, Mrs. Jennie Sorenson) from post offices in Chicago, Peru, and Champaign. A motorman and a newsboy separately identified Ray Lamphere as the man seen near the Gunness property and fleeing the yard before the fire broke out.
The Sun · 14 May 1908 · page 3
the Lamphere trial for the murder of Mrs Guhness This comes as a big surprise as it had been reported that the prisoner had made a confession to Snell Another hard blow to the stafe comes in the declareiion that Mrs Lizzie Smith will probably furnish an alibi for Lamphere by proving that he was at her house until 4 oclock the night the Gunness home was burned Great difficulty is being experienced in getting a jury and up to this time only nine have been secured
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A miner named Schultz was searching through the ashes of the burned Gunness farm, reportedly finding gold fillings believed to be from the teeth of Mrs. Gunness. The sheriff expressed confidence that these findings would help confirm her identity among the remains.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
A Milwaukee man claims he can locate Belle Gunness alive for a $5,000 reward, while a Cleveland man reports being approached by a possible accomplice trying to lure him to the farm. Doctors remain undecided on whether Gunness died in the fire, and Lamphere's attorney denies any confession was made.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 14 May 1908 · page 1
SAYS HE WILL HAND GUNNESS TO THE OFFICERS FOR $5,000
Laporto, Ind., May 11 Donlala hy Laporto officials that tho Rev. Dr. B. A. Sehcll had revealed to thorn tho substanco of .his conver sations with Lamphcro, and tho discovery of ovldenco Uiat Mrs. Bella Gunness was aided by an ecoompllco In luring nor victims to the farm, wcro tho chief devcl. opments In the case. In addition II. W. Wordon, at torney for tho prisoner, Issued a formal statement thai, ho had glv. en hts client strict injunctions not to discuss itho charges against him and concluding: Tha-fact .JsthatUunpUrrelias jiever-rnddo a confession lo any ono and never will.
See moreSee less
Ho luia nothing to confess." TJo ovldonco regarding tho aids of (Mrs. Gunness enmo In a letter from a resident of Cleveland addressed to tho local chief of pollcoa Clinton Coohrano. It told of tho writer having mot a stranger In that city Inst August who gavo him a photograph of "a rloh widow who resided In Laporte, ' and tried to poreuodo "him to como hero to see tho woman. Tho photograph is a fairly good .likeness of Mrs. Gunnooa and was ovldontly takon some tlmo ago. It Is a small nega tive wWch acorns to (hivo been rut from a photograph, tho arm
A letter writer claims Mrs. Gunness is alive and offers to turn her over to police for a $5,000 reward. Laporte officials deny Rev. Schell revealed Lamphere's confession, while new evidence suggests an accomplice helped lure victims, though Lamphere's attorney insists his client has nothing to confess.
A correspondent recounts being approached by a stranger who described a wealthy widow in La Porte, Ind., owner of a large cattle ranch, looking for a husband, offering to pay her train fare to meet him. He includes a physical description of the man and a photograph of the woman, believing it may assist the investigation into Mrs. Gunness.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Minnesota Democratic Convention. Mra Gunness. This man claimed that Chicago INSIST neaoti Uils fall It ho Is. nominated nt Denver. National Committeeman Hudson would nolthon atllrm nor deny that
Investigators found shears and dirks in the Gunness cellar, concluding the killer used surgical-like methods to dismember victims. Three more victims were identified, while rings found on the burned body's hand raised doubts about whether it was truly Belle Gunness.
The Columbian · 14 May 1908 · page 6
THREE MORE VICTIMS
Berry of TuHcola, 111. After having killed those she lared to her farm,. Mrs. Gunness showed remarkable Ingenuity in disposing of their bodies. The shears nhat were found were bent and twist ad so that they became hnndy nir ?lcal instruments. In the us hog alEj were found two surgeon's knives, ' nd from the manner In which uici.1 of the bodies wero cut up it is evi dent the woman had acquired a fair knowledge of anatomical surgery. The report of the physicians who erformed autopsies on the bodies .
See moreSee less
ifl were found on the Gunness farm was made public. The autop sy on the body of the woman sup nosed to have been Mrs. Gunness loes not establish definitely It was ;he. Three rings were found on the angers of one hand. Two of the .-lngs bore Inscriptions, but the let ierlng only added to the myBtery as to whether Mrs. Gunness died in the flames. The inscription on one "l the rings was "P. S. to J. 8., Au tust 22, '01." and the other, "P. 0. J. S., 2-5, '95." Mrs. Ounness's husband was Peter Gunness, but the fllcials were unable to learn who T. S." and "J. S." were. What appeared to be a gold tooth ilao was found among the ashes. The finding of the supposed tooth used ft report to spread that all toubt as to Mrs. Gunness having 41ed In the flames had vanished. The "tooth" was sent to a local dentist tor Investigation and he reported that the find was not a human molar ut a piece of gilded wood. The theory that Mrs. Gunness set upon her victims when their backs vere turned toward ber and stabbed hem Is accepted by the police. No -sound waa found upon the body of ielgelin, but as he undoubtedly put p a hard fight against being killed t Is believed the woman finally over Towered him and covered his face :1th a handkerchief saturated with .ihloroform. An interesting sidelight on the haracter of Mrs. Gunness was hrown by Mrs. C. O. Lapham of La Wt. She was a neighbor of the ,'unnesB woman for six years, and n that time she only visited her ?nce. When she reached the house, lrs. Lapham said, she saw Mrs, Gun ness seated in an armchair near the jpen window. A strong breeze blew ilde the folds of a thin house dress thich the woman wore and revealed . wide belt about her body. The elt contained pouches of various ilaes and sheaths which seemed to iv been constructed for knives. The virand Jury In all probability Ttll hear the charges against Ray "amphere, formerly a hired man on ie Gunness place. The Investiga tion wus postponed several days ago til May 18, but the authorities ba 've they have sufficient evidence row on which to obtain Indictments ixt murder and arson agaliiBt Lam-.-fcere.
Physicians' autopsy reports on bodies found at the Gunness farm left doubt about whether one corpse was truly Mrs. Gunness, based on ambiguous ring inscriptions. A supposed gold tooth was revealed to be gilded wood, and police theorized Mrs. Gunness killed victims with knives and chloroform; the grand jury was expected to indict Ray Lamphere for murder and arson.
Three additional corpses were discovered on the farm of Mrs. Delia (Belle) Gunness at Laporte, Indiana. The shed holding the victims' remains was later broken into and the bodies disturbed.
The Fulton County News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
robbed a safe In a baggage car of a Denver und Rio Grande train. The shed on the Guinness arm. at Laporte, Ind., containing the remains of the victims was broken Into anj the bodies seriously disturbed. Joe Qarcia. alias Joe Cordova, whe
Thousands of visitors descended on the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana, on the Sunday after news broke of the murder mystery, overwhelming the town's hotels, transportation, and police. The report describes the carnival-like atmosphere as locals and travelers came to see the site where at least ten bodies had been found and where Belle Gunness and her children were believed to have died in a house fire.
The Fulton County News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
THE DEATH FARM A PICNIC GROUND 15,000 Sightseers Visit the Guinness Place. FINDING SOME GRUESOME BITS.
Stands Are Set Up. Laporte, Ind. (Special). -All roads in Laporte County Sunday led to the farm of Mis. Belle Guinness, alleged murderer of at least 10 persons whose bodies have been unearthed in the barnyard, and now thought to have been burned to death with her three children In a fire that destroyed her farmhouse on April 28. I'pwards of In, 000 sightseers visit ed the place of death before sunset of the first Snhhath to pass sine" news of the mystery transpired. Nearly every able-bodied resident of Laporte went to the Guinness farm, and railroads and trolley lines brought about 4,000 nonresidents to the city.
See moreSee less
Mayor Harrow found It necessary to Issue Btrlngent orders that tho Sunday closing laws should be strict ly enforced. Hotels and restaurants were overrun with patrons. Every conveyance In Laporte was pressed Into Bervice In an attempt to provide transportation to the farm, which Is a mile north of Laporte. Hundreds, however, were forced to walk. Nearby villages reached by electric railways were almost deserted while citizens hastened to Laporte to satisfy their curiosity. The strangers had no difficulty in finding their way to the death farm. The constant stream of carriages, cabs, omnibuses, auto mobiles, motor cycles, bicycles, farm wagons and carriages pointed unmis takable directions to those who were tompelled to walk.
Thousands of visitors descended on the Gunness farm in a carnival-like atmosphere, buying souvenir postcards and snacks while investigators continued searching for remains. Sheriff Smutzer planned to sift the ashes and cinders from the cellar for gold dental fillings, while some visitors provided leads about missing persons possibly connected to the farm.
The Fulton County News · 14 May 1908 · page 2
FINDING SOME GRUESOME BITS.
lealli with ber found ready sale. In the rush to Laporte In the after loon several farm horses, frightened y automobiles, started to run away. buggy was upset, and Mrs Ben lamin Zanelar, of Laporte, suffered i broken arm. Several pickpockets did a thriving luslness while the throng waited for komewardbound trains. One saloon teeper was arrested for opening his lar on Sunday.
Investigators in La Porte make little progress identifying the 14 bodies found on Belle Gunness's farm, with doubt remaining whether the burned female corpse is even Gunness herself. Meanwhile, the prosecuting attorney receives anonymous threatening letters postmarked Brooklyn warning officials to stop searching for Gunness.
The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 1
DEATH THREAT SENT TO PROSECUTING ATTORNEY
LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 12—A new and startling angle in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the mureder of Mrs. Belle Gunness developed today, when detec tives in the employ of the State found evidence of many automobile parties arriving at the Gunness farm late at night. The new evidence was brought to light during the sgarch for Addie Lan dis, the young woman sought by Pros ecutor Smith as a witness, who was driven insane by a scene she witnessed in a midnight visit to Mrs. Gunness. Information as to the present where abouts of Miss Landis was secured late Wednesday in Chicago, and today it was announced that Chicago men who had several times made night trips to the farm with women might be sum mcned to identify Lamphere as having been in the house at stated times.
See moreSee less
The statement is now made that Miss Landis had answered an advertisement inserted in a newspaper by Mrs. Gun ness for a young woman companion and had received word from the maur deress to be sure and come at night. She was told to let Mrs. Gunness know when she started. When Miss Landis reached the farm, Mrs. Gunness was evidently not expecting her, for the young woman is declared to have said she saw the woman cutting off a man’s head, while a man of medium height, with a mustache stood near her holding an open sack. There are three witnesses to the fact that Miss Landis went violently insane after the scene she witnesser at the farm. Jt may be the State's intention to
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Efforts to identify jewelry found on the burned bodies and a watch taken from Ray Lamphere produced no clear results, while threatening anonymous letters warned officials to stop the search for Belle Gunness. The estate's executor filed an inventory of her property, and officials disputed reports of a jailhouse conversation involving Lamphere.
The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 1
UNSUCCESSFUL
LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 12—A new and startling angle in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the mureder of Mrs. Belle Gunness developed today, when detec tives in the employ of the State found evidence of many automobile parties arriving at the Gunness farm late at night. The new evidence was brought to light during the sgarch for Addie Lan dis, the young woman sought by Pros ecutor Smith as a witness, who was driven insane by a scene she witnessed in a midnight visit to Mrs. Gunness. Information as to the present where abouts of Miss Landis was secured late Wednesday in Chicago, and today it was announced that Chicago men who had several times made night trips to the farm with women might be sum mcned to identify Lamphere as having been in the house at stated times.
See moreSee less
The statement is now made that Miss Landis had answered an advertisement inserted in a newspaper by Mrs. Gun ness for a young woman companion and had received word from the maur deress to be sure and come at night. She was told to let Mrs. Gunness know when she started. When Miss Landis reached the farm, Mrs. Gunness was evidently not expecting her, for the young woman is declared to have said she saw the woman cutting off a man’s head, while a man of medium height, with a mustache stood near her holding an open sack. There are three witnesses to the fact that Miss Landis went violently insane after the scene she witnesser at the farm. Jt may be the State's intention to Jrove that Lamphere held the sack. 'rosecutor Emith refused today to dis cuss the matter. Three jurors remain to be secured before the trial can be proceeded with.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Workmen continued excavating the Gunness property despite heavy rain, using a pump to sluice debris, while Laporte banks agreed to compile records of Mrs. Gunness's financial transactions for Prosecutor Smith. A watch found in the ruins was identified as belonging to Ole Budsberg, a suspected victim, and a mail carrier confirmed she received letters under multiple aliases.
The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 1
before the trial can be proceeded with. ad will see the completion vf the ury. % Emissaries of the defense are secret ly digging for more bones at the farm, the explorations being chiefiy in the vicinity of the old graves dug up last spring. Public opinion in Laporte is that the headquarters of the QGunness murder bureau was in Chicago and that further search will reveal many more bodies.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Dr. Schell comments on Belle Gunness's appearance and speech, and on Ray Lamphere's drinking and sudden possession of cash, suggesting suspicion he was robbed after gambling. He also describes his personal connections to the prosecutor and sheriff involved in the case, illustrating local community dynamics.
The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 2
DEATH THREAT SENT TO PROSECUTING ATTORNEY
Jury Today. tl h# LA PORTE, Nor. 12.—Attorney Worden for the defense of Lamphere announced today the name of Mrs. Gunness to head the list of defense witnesses, summoned for trial. A subpoena summoning the woman will be placed in the hands of the sheriff. Sensational testimony is promised by the counsel for Lamphere. A wit ness will be subpoeaned today who will tell about the automobile parties which were held at the Gunness home after midnight. The witness was a former farm laborer at the Gunness farm but he left because he feared the woman.
See moreSee less
It is believed that the jury will be completed today in time to be gin taking the testimony. It is estimated today thaht Prose cutor Smith will build the case on the murder of the Gunness children in stead of the death of Belle. It is a blow to the defense.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Dr. Schell describes how Lamphere lost money gambling and later confided in him, claiming he would tell the truth on the stand. He also notes community ties to the prosecutor and sheriff, and describes the Gunness house's troubled reputation.
The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 2
PROSECUTING ATTORNEY
About the Campaign. * Hot Springs, Va., Nov. H. —Presi dent-elect Taft and his national chair »man, Frank H. Hitchcock, had a long and pleasant chat Tuesday over the many phases of the campaign. It was the ttrst opportunity for such an ex tended and cordial exchange of views, ar,d at its conclusion both expressed their pleasure in the interview. Mr. Taft was told about the cam pcign fund, which Mr. Hitchcock is to make public in detail in a few days The national chairman said that this fund was smaller in its aggregate than any similar fund since the record oi such funds had been kept and that 11 was collected from every state in the union and represented a wider distrl button of support than ever before.
See moreSee less
TEN LAMPHERE JURORS. Progress in Finding Men to Try Al
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
The report recounts the notorious Bender family killings in Kansas, noting their disappearance and unproven lynching rumor, then compares their crimes to Belle Gunness's. It suggests Gunness's case may be even more horrific since she likely acted alone without an accomplice's support.
The Morning Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 4
BENDER FAMILY OUTDONE.
IS ON. Laporte. Ind.. Nov. 10.-Contrary to all expectations, the stare .against Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, passed the lurv late yesterday, there by givine its willingness ro accept the twelve men who then filled the jury box. As a result, the indications last night, were that not later tha*i this afternoon the introductions will com mence. The special panel of twenty-five having been exhausted anofher special venire of the Fame number was order ed last evening and Sheriff Smutzer wnd his deputies hav served the sum mons, en that the veniremen will be in court today.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worclen questioning touched whetlfer the veniremen had formed an opinion the death of Mrs. Gunness and whether tnev had reach ed any conclusion as to the guilt or in noccnce of Lamphere. Those accept ed by the state all favored capital punishment if the evidence warranted, while those so far accepted by the de fense stated that although they had read much on both sides of the theory, they had formed no opinion as 10 whether Mrs. Gunness was dead or Blive and had no fixed opinion as to whether Lamphere was guilty or in nocent. Throughout the proceedings yesterday Lamphere exhibited con siderable concern at limes and held whispered consultation with his at torney. At other times he sat down low in his chair, apparently oblivious to all that was going 011. The crowd yesterday overflowed the court, room while the indications are that as the case progresses the crowds will increase. Many persons are present from out of the city. History of the Crimes. It. was on the morning of April 28 that the Ounness case first clainjed the attention of the country, although it was not until a. week later that it be came the sensation of the hour! With her three children, two girls and a boy. Mrs. Gunness. a wealthy widow, lived on a well kepi farm nortii of La.Porte. Her first husband, Philip Sorensen, had died in Chicago under circumstances which gave: rise to the belief that he had been poisoned by the woman. The second husband, Peter Gunness, died from the effects of a crushed skull,, received one night after the family moved to La Porte. The widow said a meat, chopper had fallen on him, but the people had a different idea, though nothing was done Jn the matter. Later a child died rather mysteriously and yet 110 general investigation followed. During the winter ot 1908 Mrs. Gun ness came into the limelight again
Clipping to come
Fort Mill Times · Fort Mill, S.C.
A dispatch from Laporte, Ind. reports that following the discovery of five murdered bodies in the yard of Belle Gunness's burned farmhouse, four more bodies were found, bringing the total to nine. Investigators suspect Ray (Guy) Lamphere of the murders, including the dismemberment of Andrew Helgelein, while some speculate Mrs. Gunness herself may have only known of the killers rather than committed them.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Fort Mill Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
TALE OF HORROR Eleven Bodies Found Buried in Farmhouse Yard. HAD BEEN MURDERED.
IS ON. Laporte. Ind.. Nov. 10.-Contrary to all expectations, the stare .against Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, passed the lurv late yesterday, there by givine its willingness ro accept the twelve men who then filled the jury box. As a result, the indications last night, were that not later tha*i this afternoon the introductions will com mence. The special panel of twenty-five having been exhausted anofher special venire of the Fame number was order ed last evening and Sheriff Smutzer wnd his deputies hav served the sum mons, en that the veniremen will be in court today.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worclen questioning touched whetlfer the veniremen had formed an opinion the death of Mrs. Gunness and whether tnev had reach ed any conclusion as to the guilt or in noccnce of Lamphere. Those accept ed by the state all favored capital punishment if the evidence warranted, while those so far accepted by the de fense stated that although they had read much on both sides of the theory, they had formed no opinion as 10 whether Mrs. Gunness was dead or Blive and had no fixed opinion as to whether Lamphere was guilty or in nocent. Throughout the proceedings yesterday Lamphere exhibited con siderable concern at limes and held whispered consultation with his at torney. At other times he sat down low in his chair, apparently oblivious to all that was going 011. The crowd yesterday overflowed the court, room while the indications are that as the case progresses the crowds will increase. Many persons are present from out of the city. History of the Crimes. It. was on the morning of April 28 that the Ounness case first clainjed the attention of the country, although it was not until a. week later that it be came the sensation of the hour! With her three children, two girls and a boy. Mrs. Gunness. a wealthy widow, lived on a well kepi farm nortii of La.Porte. Her first husband, Philip Sorensen, had died in Chicago under circumstances which gave: rise to the belief that he had been poisoned by the woman. The second husband, Peter Gunness, died from the effects of a crushed skull,, received one night after the family moved to La Porte. The widow said a meat, chopper had fallen on him, but the people had a different idea, though nothing was done Jn the matter. Later a child died rather mysteriously and yet 110 general investigation followed. During the winter ot 1908 Mrs. Gun ness came into the limelight again
Clipping to come
Fort Mill Times · Fort Mill, S.C.
Investigators found nine dismembered bodies at the Gunness farm, suspecting Lamphere, a carpenter, committed the Helgelein murder based on the dismemberment technique. Evidence suggested bodies may have been shipped from Chicago, and two bodies were tentatively identified as Jennie Olson and Andrew Helgelein, though an autopsy disputed the Helgelein identification based on burial time.
Fort Mill Times · 14 May 1908 · page 1
On the following Monday A. K. Hclgelfiin came to La Porte from Aber deen, S. T".. after learning of the Gun ness firij. lo investigate the disappear ance of his brother. Andrew Helgelien. who came to La Porte to see Mrs. Gunness, and who had disappeared after drawing $r'.,000 through a La Porte bank from the Aberdeen bank. On May th" flismembered body of Andrew Helgelein. wraped in gunny sacks. was found buried in a shallow grave liuring the next, four days nine more bodies were found in the little grave yard 011 the Gunness $trm.
See moreSee less
One was identified as that of Jennie, who lived with Mrs. (jiinness, but who had dis appeared and was said by Mrs. Gun ness to have gone to California to school. Another body was identified as that of Olaf Budsberg, but the others were never fully identified, al though evidence was found to show that at least seven other men had been lured to La Porte by Mrs. Gun ness through matrimonial advertise ments in Norwegian papers, and lhat she had undoubtedly robbed and then murdered them.
Clipping to come
Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D.
Authorities digging in the burned Gunness property in La Porte, Indiana, uncovered four mutilated bodies, including that of Andrew Helgelien (misspelled 'Heldgren') of South Dakota and Gunness's adopted daughter. Helgelien had come to visit Mrs. Gunness after meeting her through a matrimonial agency and had loaned her $1,600; investigators suspect jailed suspect Ray Lamphere may know more about the killings.
Forest City Press · 14 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER SOUTH DAKOTAN BODY TORN IN PIECES
Calling Lamphere Jealous. I.aPort Ind.. Nov. 12. For the pur pose of rendering every assistance pos sible to the authorities in their efforts' to unravel tiie Gunness mystery. A. K.
Clipping to come
Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D.
The report describes a developing theory in the La Porte investigation that Belle Gunness may still be alive, having substituted another woman's body for her own before the fire. It also notes her brother Henry Helgelein's suspicion that Andrew Helgelein was murdered after a falling-out between Gunness and Lamphere over stolen money.
Forest City Press · 14 May 1908 · page 3
BROTHER'S OPINION AS TO MURDER
Aberdeen. N. I. He will be one of the main witnesses for the state for through him Prosecu tor Smith will introduce a number of letters received by him from Mrs. Gun ness during the time that Mr. Helgelein was endeavoring to find some trace of his brother. Mrs. Gunness asserted that,the broth er, after visiting her. had gone to Nor way on a trip. At the tima she wrote his dismembered body law in her pri vate cemetery, where she had buried it after securing $3,000 which .he had drawn from his Aberdeen, S. D. bank, through a Laporte bank. These letters were all written in Nor- ' Continued on page 5.
Clipping to come
Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D.
Authorities investigate newly exhumed adult bodies, theorize Belle Gunness may still be alive and motivated by greed, and examine suspicious trunks shipped from Chicago. The identification of one body as Andrew Helgaline is now in doubt, while officers press Ray Lamphere for a confession.
Forest City Press · 14 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Turner County Herald · Hurley, S.D.
Reporters detail the exhumation of multiple mutilated bodies from Belle Gunness's yard in La Porte, raising the count of known or suspected victims to fifteen. The report questions whether Gunness and her children really died in the earlier house fire, suggesting the burned bodies may have been substitutes brought in to fake their deaths.
Turner County Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 7
WOMAN CALLED A BLUEBEARD
*i#loiy Aberdeen, S. D. suitor for Mrs. •3unness' hand, who came to Laporte in January and disappeared one month later *after loaning the woman $1,500body .•4ug up to-day. Gunness, Jennie Olson, 10 years old, ^adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness disap -•eared In September, 1900, ostensibly to •Attend school at Los Angeles body dug *«p to-day. Unidentified man, believed by Sheriff aJSmulzer to have been an admirer of the •Uroman. Unidentified boy, apparently 0 years 4*ld mutilated body in gunnysack. Unidentified girl, about 7 years old "Mutilated body in gunnysack. Gunpess, Joseph, husband of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gun ness, whose death at Laporte four years «*go had always remained a mystery. Sorenson, Mads, woman's first hus band, who died under mysterious circum •«tances in' Chicago eight years ago. Gunness, Mrs. Bella, believed to have •fceen burned to death in fire which de "•treyed iher home. Sorenson, Myrtle, 11 years old, eldest ittghter ol Mrs. Gunness thought to ive perished in "the fire. Sorenson, Lucy, 9 years old, another' ••aiightcr also believed to have been a irictim of the fire. Gunness, Philip, 5 years old, youngest *hild said to have been killed in the fire. Lindblom, Olaf, 85 years old, of Wis »nsin employed by Mrs. Gunness on the irm. When he disappeared Mrs. Gun-
The report lists known and suspected victims of Belle Gunness, including Andrew Helgelein, Jennie Olson, and unidentified bodies found on her farm, alongside her own family believed killed in the fire. It also provides a chronology of suspicious deaths, fires, and insurance collections linked to Gunness going back to 1900, while noting suspicion that the female body found may not be hers.
This report presents a detailed chronology of the Belle Gunness case, from her first husband's suspicious death through the farmhouse fire, Ray Lamphere's arrest, and the discovery of multiple bodies buried on the property. It also notes new details like missing workers, unidentified victims, and testimony from a farmhand about digging holes at Mrs. Gunness's orders.
Turner County Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 7
CHRONOLOGY OF INDIANA MULTI-MURDER MYSTERY
Widow marries Joe Gunness. Moves to Laporte farm. Adopts Jennie Olsen. Gunness killed (100-1). Widow says meat cleaver fell on his head. Collects $3,500 insurance. -. /, Ilay L»ampihere goes to work for Mrs. Gunness as hired man, Widow pets dogs on visitors. Neighbors see Jsmterns on farm at 2 a. m. Jennie Olson disappears. Real .parents are told sJi'e is in Los Angeles school, but can not find her (190G). Andrew Helgelein, Aberdeen (S. D.), answers matriih&nial ad, and arrives at Laporte. farm. Loans Mrs. Gunness $1, 500., DisaiX{Vears with like amount in (pocket. Widow says ihe went to Norway. MrS. Gunness (1907) tells sheriff strange man killed a child iti woods near farm. Sheriff finds only empty grave. Ray 'Lamphere. arrested for annoying
Ray Lamphere, held as an accomplice in the Gunness farm murders, denies making any confession to a reverend or anyone else. Investigators are compiling bank records and testimony, including from a mail carrier who says Mrs. Gunness used three aliases, and identify a victim's watch found in the ruins.
The Madison Daily Leader · 14 May 1908 · page 2
DENIED BY LAMPHERE
; MORE BONES STARTLING DEVELOPMENT IN THE TRIAL OF RAY LAMPHERE FOR THE MURDER OF INDIANA'S WOMAN MONSTER ■ ■ LA PORTU, lud., Nov. 11.—A start
Clipping to come
Pierre Weekly Free Press · Pierre, S.D.
A brief item reflects on the shocking scale of the Gunness farm murders, questioning how so many crimes went undetected for so long. It speculates that Belle Gunness must have had accomplices, and hopes justice will be served if this is proven.
Pierre Weekly Free Press · 14 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D.
A relative searching for missing Andrew Helgelein prompted excavation of the Gunness farm, uncovering five bodies on Tuesday (one identified as Helgelein) and four more on Wednesday. Authorities suspended digging due to rain and instead gathered evidence against suspect Ray Lamphere, who was already under arrest for arson.
Union County Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 4
Evidence Accumulates That Many More Lives Were Taken by Laporte Fiend. ONE MORE BODY IS FOUND. Evidence of at Least Nine More Victims—Six Men, a Woman, a Girl and an Infant.
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D.
Excavation at the Gunness farm yields a tenth body, with authorities gathering evidence including letters from Mrs. Gunness to Ray Lamphere and witness testimony about blackmail attempts. The findings are said to strengthen the first-degree murder charges against Lamphere.
Union County Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 4
ONE MORE BODY IS FOUND
It was on the morning of April 21 that the Gunness case first claimed the attention of the country. With her three children, two girl and boy, Mrs. Gunness, a well-to-do widow lived on n farm north of Laporte Het first husband, Philip .Soronsen, had died in Chicago under circumstance! which gave rise to the belief that h had' been poisoned by the woman. The second husband, Peter Gunness, died from the effect of a, crushed skull, re celved one night after the fnmllj moved to Laporte. The widow said a meat chopper had fallen on him.
See moreSee less
Later a child died rather mysteriously and yet no general Investigation -followed, last spring Mrs. Gunness cams Into the limelight again by reason of her troubles with Ruy lnrnphere, who was employed by her as a farm hand Twice she had liim arrested for an noylng nor after she had discharged him and finally whe sought to have him sent to the' Insane asylnm. ' Sh claimed that be had threatened hei
Clipping to come
Union County Courier · Elk Point, S.D.
A new witness claims Ray Lamphere admitted trying to blackmail Belle Gunness, suggesting a motive for conflict preceding the farmhouse fire. Thousands of sightseers flocked to the farm amid ongoing excavations, while evidence pointed to at least nine more victims and Sheriff Smutzer continued his investigation.
Union County Courier · 14 May 1908 · page 4
SIGHTSEERS FLOCK TO FARM
It was on the morning of April 21 that the Gunness case first claimed the attention of the country. With her three children, two girl and boy, Mrs. Gunness, a well-to-do widow lived on n farm north of Laporte Het first husband, Philip .Soronsen, had died in Chicago under circumstance! which gave rise to the belief that h had' been poisoned by the woman. The second husband, Peter Gunness, died from the effect of a, crushed skull, re celved one night after the fnmllj moved to Laporte. The widow said a meat chopper had fallen on him.
See moreSee less
Later a child died rather mysteriously and yet no general Investigation -followed, last spring Mrs. Gunness cams Into the limelight again by reason of her troubles with Ruy lnrnphere, who was employed by her as a farm hand Twice she had liim arrested for an noylng nor after she had discharged him and finally whe sought to have him sent to the' Insane asylnm. ' Sh claimed that be had threatened hei
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
This editorial reflects on the Gunness murders at La Porte, Indiana, concluding that no adequate motive like greed can explain her crimes since she was already financially comfortable. It speculates she treated murder as a normal business, luring victims via advertisements, with bloody axe and pistol findings suggesting her methods.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 4
THE GUNNESS MURDERS. One searches the record in vain for in adequate motive for the appalling crimes of the Gunness woman at La porte, Ind. One is forced to conclude Ihat she is simply a low type of the criminal delinquent, a perverted wo man who did not require a motive in order to commit the most horrible : rimes. One cannot find an adequate motive ta the desire for gain. Thousands of men and women love money more than they should and desire the things that money will buy, without being driven to murder to gratify their desires.
See moreSee less
It appears that Mrs Gunness was in com fortable circumstance*, so that there Is no analogy between her and the criminal who kills to get money to Ive on. She seems to have coolly gone into the business of murder as a normal person would go into any other bus iness, and the fact that she was com mitting crime seems not to have en tered into her calculations as a moral factor, but merely as something that forced her to act secretly tn order to avoid punishment. The facilities for carrying on her gruesome trade were admirably adapted to her purpose. She was mistress of a farm and big house in the country, where she could oper ate in seclusion and with little fear of prying eyes. She resorted to advertis ing to lure her victims to her. She baited her advertisements with the hope of gain which she shrewdly cal culated would attract men of a dertain simple class. No one who ever went to her house was seen again alive. How she wont about her horrible work we do not know. There are sug gestions in the finding of a bloody axe and a pistol that she used the most primitive and brutal methods to dis pose of her victims. There is no evi dence of the refinement of crime in her work. It was simply a case of luring her victim to her house and then kill ing him at the most convenient sea son. probably when he was asleep. The dismemberment of the bodies was probably done to make it easier to handle them and also to make Iden tification the more difficult. Burial as a method of putting the bodies out of sight was in line with the other prim itive, yet astonishingly successful, methods she used. One shudders over the contemplation of how long this wunan might have continued her bloody work if one of her victims had not had a brother of an inquiring turn of mind and who. when once started on the scent, would not give it up until he had unearthed the most remarkable crimes and crim inal of this century. It is not easy to believe that Mrs. Gunnesss is dead. She would hardly be caught in her own trap. The burn ing of the house and the headless body which has been taken as hers are probably parts of her clever ruse to stop pursuit. With only three months to go Bexar county still has a big balance of its budget money left. An aldermanic committe has begun to probe for unauthorized private sew 4rs. The city ought to take charge of all of them. Negro who raised a row on a street car because a white man wanted to share a seat with him is fined $lO. Of course the negro probably deserved the fine for causing a disturbance in stead of registering his protest quiet ly, but if we are going to separate the races on the street cars, let the law be enforced on both sides. A white person has no more right to occupy a seat that is reserved for negroes than a negro has to invade the white man's part of the car. Standard oil has been yanked up to the bar again. The nabitual criminal law will begin to operate pretty soon. The stork flagged a Southern Pa cific train, and you can bet your sweet life the train stopped.
A Cleveland man reportedly evaded a lure from Mrs. Gunness seeking another victim, while attorneys for defendant Lamphere search for witness David Havens. Havens allegedly observed bodies lying on the cellar floor without debris beneath them, which the defense claims proves the bodies were placed there after the fire began.
Paper unidentified · 14 May 1908 · page 9
ESCAPES NET OF MODERN CIRCE, MRS. GUNNESS
Mrs Hecien who lives In Brooklyn dc Uaies that she suffered such a shock e that neither she nor her mother has completely recoveicd t HAY LAMIHBRBS T1UAL 1 Laportc Ind Nov 11 For the pur potie of rendering v assistance pos sible to the authorities In their efforts t to unravel tho great Gunncs mystery AlclIglgelelll brother of Andrew lIelg lchlJhu lust known victim of r Mrs GunncBS arrived In Laporte to
Clipping to come
Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.
Ray Lamphere, Belle Gunness' hired man, strongly denied making any confession or promises to officials investigating the murders. Prosecutors arranged for local banks to supply records of all financial transactions involving Mrs. Gunness to aid the investigation.
Bryan Morning Eagle · 14 May 1908 · page 4
MADE NO CONFESSION.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Rev. Dr. E. A. Schell denies claiming Ray Lamphere admitted helping kill the Gunness children, saying Lamphere only confessed involvement in Helgelein's death. Schell states Lamphere's communications to him are privileged and will remain secret unless Lamphere speaks to prosecutors himself; he also personally believes Mrs. Gunness is alive but has no proof.
Bryan Morning Eagle · 14 May 1908 · page 4
INVIOLABLE SECRET.
With Vurder of Children. Baltimore, May 13. Rev. Dr. E. A. Schell of l.aporte Ind., who Is attend ing the Methodist general conference, In talking about the Gunness farm tragedy, denied that he said Kay Lamphere helped kill the Gunnels children, but took no part in slaying any of the men except Helgeleln. "I made no statement regarding this or any detail of my Interview with Lamphere except to say Lamphere's communications to me are wholly privileged, and unless he shall himself make statements to the prosecuting attorney thoy will be maintained as an Inviolable secret." Mr Sfhull mlrWil like tiianv others.
The report notes the Gunness case in Indiana has dominated newspaper coverage, with Mrs. Gunness suspected of murdering at least ten people and burying them in her barnyard. It describes great public excitement, with thousands visiting the property seeking information.
Shiner Gazette · 14 May 1908 · page 4
The Gunnesa case in Indiana has been taking up considerable space in the papers lately Mrs Gunness is i supposed to have murdered at least ten persons and buried the bodies in her barn yard The excitement is great and thousands of people are visit ing the premises to seek informa tion This issue of the Gazette contains the announcement of Mr W F Templeton for the of fice of Constable of Precinct 8 Lavaca County Mr Templeton is a man who is well qualified to fill the offico and if elected he promises his best services to tho people of the pre cinct He announces subject to the Democratic primaries in Ju ly Remember his candidacy when you come to vote Mr V7 E Rabb comes be fore the neople of Lavaca county this week as a candidate for rep rpsontativo to thd 01st Legislrt
Laporte officials including the coroner, sheriff, and prosecuting attorney deny reports that Lamphere confessed to Rev. Dr. Schell, while Lamphere's attorney states his client has never made a confession. Investigators continue probing evidence suggesting Belle Gunness had an accomplice luring victims to the farm.
The Salt Lake Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
LAMPHERE HAS NOT CONFESSED Rev Dr Schell Believes He Will Tell the Truth on the Stand NOTHING NEW AT LAPORTE OFFICIALS STILL WORKING ON GUNNESS FARM HORROR
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Authorities including the coroner, sheriff, and prosecutor denied reports of new evidence suggesting Ray Lamphere had an accomplice in luring Belle Gunness's victims. Rev. Dr. Schell also clarified that he never said Lamphere confessed to murdering the Gunness children, only denying involvement in some killings, and stated he personally believed Mrs. Gunness was still alive.
The Salt Lake Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
INTERVIEW DISTORTED
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Dr. Schell tells reporters he personally believes Mrs. Gunness is still alive, though he has no evidence for this. He also describes her as outwardly refined but of low origin, and characterizes Ray Lamphere as a hard-drinking man with a troubled background who may finally tell the truth.
The Salt Lake Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
La Porte authorities deny reports that Lamphere confessed to Rev. Schell or that an accomplice helped Belle Gunness lure victims. Coroner Mack has completed investigation of identified bodies while continuing to link missing men like John Moe and Henry Gerholt to the farm.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 1
MORE MEN WITH MONEY STRANGELY DISAPPEARED
life imprisonment. Prosecutor Smith stated: "All we are required to show is that the defendant set fir$ to"the house and that the xccupants' lrVst -their lives by reason 'of this act.'V"Mr. Smith said that the evi dence wYll show that Lamphere made remarKs, to various persons indicating his hatred for Mrs. Gunness and his intention to do her harm, including statements that he knew how to get money from her. ...... Th. Snr that Mrs r.nniMHS fflt of Lamphere was touched on and then thJH prosecutor took up the story of the night .of the fire and what the state would prove.
See moreSee less
He said that by Lam phere's own statement it would be proven that he set the alarm clock at Mrs. Smith's house where he, spent the night, f"r three ju'clock on the morning of April 18." and that 15 or 20 minutes la tor he left there. "We will also prove," continued the state's attornev,. "by Lamphere's own statement that he took the road going by the Gunness house and that he was on the spot when the fire broke out about 4 o'clock." '' Continuing he said, the state would prove that Mrs. Gunness and her five year old son, Phillip, sjept io a bed in the northwest corner on the second floor and that the two girls slept in a room in the southwest corner; that the fire was started In the southwest corn er and was driven toward the north by the wind, that Mrs. Gunness and the boy were overcome . and that . later when the fire entered the girls' room.; they ran into their mother's room thereby getting into the hottest of the flames.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Investigators report evidence that John Moe and Henry Gerholt were lured to the Gunness farm after cashing large checks or drafts at La Porte banks, with their trails ending there, similar to the cases of Ole Budsberg and Andrew Helgelein. The fate of George Brady of Tuscola, Illinois, remains less certain, and officials suggest Gunness may have had an accomplice.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 14 May 1908 · page 1
STRANGELY DISAPPEARED
Own Statements on Night of Burning of Mrs. Ounness' HouseWill Estab lish His Guilt in Great Measure. LAPORTE, Ind., November 12. The introduction of endcnco n tho trial of Ray Larrfphcro for tho murder of Mrs. Beilo Gunness nnd her three children
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
Authorities in LaPorte continue systematic investigation of the Gunness farm murder mystery, with banks providing lists of all Mrs. Gunness' financial transactions. No additional corpses were unearthed and no new information surfaced about whether Mrs. Gunness died or escaped.
The Spokane Press · 14 May 1908 · page 1
NO MORE CORPSES DISCOVERED TODAY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Aberdeen Herald · Aberdeen, W.T.
After a Syracuse suspect proved not to be Belle Gunness, investigators in Laporte resumed digging in the murder farm's ruins. Sheriff Smutzer hired a miner to pan the cellar debris for melted gold from the dead woman's teeth, hoping to confirm the headless body was indeed hers.
Aberdeen Herald · 14 May 1908 · page 3
His. Delia Gunness Had Fillings of the I'reelous Metal. I.»aporte, I nd.—After learning that the woman arrested in Syra cuse, X. Y., was not Mrs. Bella Gun ness, Laporte settled down again to digging in the graveyard of the Gun ness home. Sheriff Smutzer Is preparing for a test this week such as has never lie fore been made in the Investigation of any murder case. It will be in the effort to account for the missing head of the body in the morgue, said to be the body of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness. The sheriff has employed an ex perienced miner, who is now in La porte, with his pan, his cradle, his rocker and all the other parapher nalia of the primitive California gold hunter. This miner—the sheriff declines to give his name—will go down in the cellar of the "house of death" and begin to sift the debris in search of gold. Never before has gold been so generally sought. A grain of it recovered from those ashes will be valued at more than a pound of gold by the authorities of Laporte county. They will maintain that if gold is found at the point where the head less body was recovered it will prove that Mrs. Gunness' head was con sumed by fire and that the three hundred dollars' worth of precious metal In her teeth was melted by the heat. Ray Lamphere's trunk Is still In the office of the state's attorney, Its contents carefully guarded from pry ing eyes. What the letters from Mrs. Gunness to Lamphere may say Is known only to the sheriff, the state's attorney, the sheriff's deputy, William Anstiss, and Kay Lamphere himself. Positive evidence was obtained that Mrs. Gunness had an accom plice In Chicago, who acted as the woman's agent In luring people to the "murder farm" outside of La porte. The accomplice was a woman whose attractiveness was used to lead victims on until they fell a prey to Mrs. Gunness' lust for murder. The facts were unearthed by an examination of eighty-two letters written by the woman to Andrew Helgelien.
Investigators plan to sift the cellar debris of the Gunness farmhouse for melted gold from teeth, which would help confirm the headless body is Belle Gunness. Authorities also claim to have found evidence, via letters to Andrew Helgelien, of a female accomplice in Chicago who lured victims to the farm.
Friends and neighbors of Frank Riedinger, a Waukesha County farmer who vanished in February 1907 after answering a matrimonial ad to marry a woman in Indiana, now believe he was a victim of Belle Gunness. A suspicious unsigned letter claiming he had changed his mind and gone west mirrors the pattern seen in other Gunness disappearances.
The Manitowoc Pilot · 14 May 1908 · page 2
: FRIENDS OF FRANK RIEDINGER BE LIEVE HE WAS MURDERED BY MRS. GUNNESS. I DISAPPEARED IN FEBRUARY. ' Answered Matrimonial “Ad'’ and Said He Was Going to Indiana
Frank Uiedinger, who vanished after borrowing money and leaving for Chicago to marry a woman he'd met through correspondence, was investigated by the German consul with no trace found. Friends now suspect, given the LaPorte disclosures, that he may have been one of Belle Gunness's victims.
The Manitowoc Pilot · 14 May 1908 · page 2
Affairs Are Closed Up. Uiedinger's affairs wore placed in the hands of local attorneys by a nephew who is said to now be residing at Phila delphia and the personal property was sild. His debts were paid and there is -till a balance here to his credit. The mortgage on his farm is to he foreclosed. The recent disclosures in the Laporte affair lead friends of Uiedinger to believe that he may have been one of the victims and it is probable that the German con sul at Chicago will be asked to make further investigations.
An estimated 15,000 people flocked to the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana on Sunday, overwhelming local transportation and lodging. Amid the chaos, visitors offered tips to authorities, including one man's account suggesting his missing brother may have been a victim.
River Falls Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 2
MORBID CROWDS AT "DEATH FARM" FIFTEEN THOUSAND FLOCK TO GUNNESS PLACE SUNDAY
Laporte, Ind., May 11. —All roads in Laporte county led to the Gunness farm Sunday, upwards of 15,000 sight seers visiting the place of death.
Trains packed with spectators arrived in Laporte from surrounding towns, with over a thousand visitors touring the gruesome murder farm throughout the day. Visitors turned the scene into a picnic outing with lemonade stands and souvenir postcards, while Olaf Lindboe failed to identify his missing brother Thomas among the unidentified remains.
River Falls Journal · 14 May 1908 · page 2
THRONG ON EVERY TRAIN
Crowds on All Trains. The crowds began arriving in La porte when the first trains from the east arrived shortly after five o’clock in the morning. Nearly 100 passen gers from Elkhart, Mishawka, South Bend, New Carlisle, Rolling Prairie and other towns debarked from the coaches and formed the advance guard of the army which invaded the Gun ness property during the day. An other train from the same points brought in nearly 200 more spectators three hours later, and at ten o’clock, at 11 and 1:30, over 1,000 more reached here from the same towns.
See moreSee less
It was reported that more than 500 tickets to Laporte had been sold in Elkhart alone. Another large crowd came from In dianapolis and the intervening cities, villages and hamlets on an excursion train over the Lake Erie & Western railroad. Fewer passengers were brought from the towns west of here, because the trains from that direction made only one. or two stops between here and Chicago. Nevertheless, the traffic was far beyond the ordinary and at least 250 persons debarked here from these trains.
A. K. Helgelein's search for his missing brother led to excavations at the Guinness farm, uncovering nine bodies including Andrew Helgelein's remains. Ray Lamphere, a former farmhand, is held as a suspected accomplice while authorities believe victims were lured via fake matrimonial ads.
Ladysmith News-Budget · 14 May 1908 · page 4
NINE MORE ON LIST OF ARCH-CRIMINAL
Point In Controversy. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 13. The de fense In the Lamphere murder trial in Its effort to prevent certain informa tion goingto the Jury, suffered its first defeat today when Judge Ritcher ruled that the report of the coroner's verdict was admissible as primary evi dence. The ruling followed exhaustive arguments and the citation of many authorities by the attorneys for the state and for Lamphere. The jurymen looked fresh and alert when they en tered court this morning after their first night's confinement on the third floor of the court house.
See moreSee less
They had enjoyed a walk, breakfasted at a hotel and read morning papers from which all reference to the trial had been expunged. The defendant looked paler than on yesterday. He was, unnerved consid erably during the opening statement made yesterday afternoon by Prosecu tor Smith and this morning looked as though he had not slept well. When questioned, he said Mr. Smith's state ment was very strong, "but there is nothing in the claim that I went past the Gunness house that morning." Coroner Mack was the first witness
Clipping to come
Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis.
A tenth body was discovered at the Gunness farm, and investigators uncovered letters and witness testimony suggesting Ray Lamphere attempted to blackmail Belle Gunness, establishing a motive for the fire. Authorities believe the victims were lured by fraudulent matrimonial advertisements and that bodies were shipped in from Chicago.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Ladysmith News-Budget · 14 May 1908 · page 4
ONE MORE BODY IS FOUND
Point In Controversy. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 13. The de fense In the Lamphere murder trial in Its effort to prevent certain informa tion goingto the Jury, suffered its first defeat today when Judge Ritcher ruled that the report of the coroner's verdict was admissible as primary evi dence. The ruling followed exhaustive arguments and the citation of many authorities by the attorneys for the state and for Lamphere. The jurymen looked fresh and alert when they en tered court this morning after their first night's confinement on the third floor of the court house.
See moreSee less
They had enjoyed a walk, breakfasted at a hotel and read morning papers from which all reference to the trial had been expunged. The defendant looked paler than on yesterday. He was, unnerved consid erably during the opening statement made yesterday afternoon by Prosecu tor Smith and this morning looked as though he had not slept well. When questioned, he said Mr. Smith's state ment was very strong, "but there is nothing in the claim that I went past the Gunness house that morning." Coroner Mack was the first witness
Clipping to come
Ladysmith News-Budget · Ladysmith, Wis.
Thousands of sightseers converged on the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana, treating the site of a notorious multiple murder as a tourist attraction with picnics and relic-hunting. Investigators meanwhile tied at least nine more victims to Belle Gunness, while Sheriff Smutzer continued his inquiry.
Ladysmith News-Budget · 14 May 1908 · page 4
SIGHTSEERS FLOCK TO FARM
B AUTO PARTI EB. K&APOETB. Ind., Nor. 12—A new HI startling angle of Ray Lamphere H «hi> murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness iKaftoped today, when detectives in of the state found evidence SpUtny automobile parties arriving at BftOunneas farm late at night. EHm new evidence waa brought to the search for Addle HE|la the young woman sought by Smith as a witness, who lnsane by a scene she wlt lljßgjjjrt In a midnight visit to Mrs. IPia statement is now made that |H| Landis had answered an adver ppbent Inserted In a newspaper by for a young woman comIjjpfon and received word from the
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
A tenth body is found at the Guinness farm, and a witness claims Ray Lamphere admitted to blackmail attempts against Mrs. Guinness, establishing a motive. Other witnesses report strangers seen at the farm the night Jennie Olsen disappeared, raising the possibility Mrs. Guinness had accomplices.
Iowa County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 4
MRS. GUINNESS HAD ASSISTANTS - STRANGERS SEEN AT FARM ON NIGHT OF JENNIE OLSEN'S DISAPPEARANCE - INCRIMINATING LETTERS ARE FOUND FROM WOMAN TO LAMPHERE
B AUTO PARTI EB. K&APOETB. Ind., Nor. 12—A new HI startling angle of Ray Lamphere H «hi> murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness iKaftoped today, when detectives in of the state found evidence SpUtny automobile parties arriving at BftOunneas farm late at night. EHm new evidence waa brought to the search for Addle HE|la the young woman sought by Smith as a witness, who lnsane by a scene she wlt lljßgjjjrt In a midnight visit to Mrs. IPia statement is now made that |H| Landis had answered an adver ppbent Inserted In a newspaper by for a young woman comIjjpfon and received word from the
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
Authorities seized a trunk belonging to Ray Lamphere containing letters from Belle Gunness urging him to return with a wealthy sweetheart, along with women's rings possibly belonging to victims. Witnesses also reported strangers seen at the farm the night Jennie Olsen disappeared, suggesting possible accomplices.
Iowa County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 4
LAMPHERE
are unequaled at the price. Let us show you. murderess to be sure and come at night She was told to let Mrs. Gun neas know when she started. When Miss Landis reached the farm, Mra Gunness was evidently not expecting her, for the young woman is declared to hare said she saw’ the woman cut ting off a man’s head, while a man of medium height with a moustache, stood near her holding an open sack. ■ ■■■*••«
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
Investigators at Laporte continue searching for evidence in the Gunness farm tragedies, focusing on identifying the burned woman's remains and additional victims. Three rings found on the body's hands bear inscriptions suggesting ties to a first husband, but authorities and the coroner remain uncertain whether this proves the body is or is not Belle Gunness.
Iowa County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 5
FARM MYSTERY STILL UNSOLVED AUTHORITIES AT LAPORTE CONTINUE TO SEARCH FOR EVIDENCE
Hmoi the treasurer of the Republican national oommittee. Hr • • • ' The prosecutor in the Lamphere case says he can prove Mrs. Gunness dead, to which Mrs. Gunness should not object if alive.
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
Investigators debate whether rings found on a dismembered hand belonged to Gunness or were planted as part of a ruse to fake her death; Coroner Mack suggests she had the cunning to stage such evidence. Separately, a Wisconsin man's disappearance after corresponding with a matrimonial bureau is added to the suspected victim list, while a minister claims Ray Lamphere believes Gunness is still alive.
Iowa County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 5
SMILESITBONES OF CUNNESS SKULL MURDER-SUSPECT LAMPHERE THROWB THEM CONTEMPTU OUSLY DOWN. LAPORTK, Ind., Nov. 13.—A clamor ing crowd struggled for admission to the courtroom at the reopening today of the trial of Ray Lamphere for mur dering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her throe children. When the first witness, Cotoner C. S. Mack, took the stand, scores of wo men and several hundred men were seeking admission In vain. Coroner Mack’e memory proved ex tremely defective. He could afford no information of value without referring to bis notes. Tlio fragments of bone, said to be from Mrs.
See moreSee less
Uunnees* skull, placed be fore tho jury, were so small and so charred that the abaurdlty of an at* tempt to Identify them as having be longed Rs Mrs. Ounneaa’ body was at once urged by the defense. When the pieces of charred bone were placed on the table Lamphere rose from fill chair hnd walked to the attorney's table to examinn them. He look some of the fragments In hie hand and turning them over, smiled cynically, “Alas, poor Yorik," whispered the assistant counsel for the state as lamphere tossed the ploee of bone contemptuously on the table, Four Children Bum te Death. ALLIANCE, 0„ Not, ll,—Four ohll, dren were burned to death today In a fire that destroyed the home of John Wampler, a milk dealer, The father was badly burned In attempting to rescue his children, of whom there were seven, Jumpers nt the H*ree Shew, NEW YORK, Nov, lfiy-Whlle t* day's program at the horse ahow will be one of the vnoet varied of the week, hunters and Jumpers trill hold the most prominent positions in the ring, bass** >#T>i trt twin jm 9mm rr <z**4&*£
Clipping to come
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis.
The report describes Henry Gurholt, a Scandinavian immigrant believed murdered on the Gunness farm after corresponding with her through a matrimonial bureau. It also reproduces a letter Mrs. Gunness sent to Christian Hansen of Kansas, asking him to bring $1,000 in cash to marry her.
Iowa County Democrat · 14 May 1908 · page 5
OUSLY DOWN. LAPORTK, Ind., Nov. 13.—A clamor ing crowd struggled for admission to the courtroom at the reopening today of the trial of Ray Lamphere for mur dering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her throe children. When the first witness, Cotoner C. S. Mack, took the stand, scores of wo men and several hundred men were seeking admission In vain. Coroner Mack’e memory proved ex tremely defective. He could afford no information of value without referring to bis notes. Tlio fragments of bone, said to be from Mrs. Uunnees* skull, placed be fore tho jury, were so small and so charred that the abaurdlty of an at* tempt to Identify them as having be longed Rs Mrs.
See moreSee less
Ounneaa’ body was at once urged by the defense. When the pieces of charred bone were placed on the table Lamphere rose from fill chair hnd walked to the attorney's table to examinn them. He look some of the fragments In hie hand and turning them over, smiled cynically, “Alas, poor Yorik," whispered the assistant counsel for the state as lamphere tossed the ploee of bone contemptuously on the table,
Clipping to come
The Fairmont West Virginian · Fairmont, W. Va.
A deputy sheriff reported an automobile carrying a man and woman seen speeding through Hobart, Indiana on the morning of the fire that destroyed the Gunness home. Separately, a man signing himself John Williamson wrote to the sheriff claiming Mrs. Gunness is alive and demanding $5,000 reward to turn her over to police.
The Fairmont West Virginian · 14 May 1908 · page 1
JOHN WILLIAMSON WANTS REWARD OF $5,000 TO TELL WHERE WOMAN IS
• • • p . Maybe Mr. Bryan could get some enlightenment as to how It happened fIPMI the treasurer of the Republican national committee. • • o The prosecutor In the Lamphere case says he can prove Mrs. Gunness |a dead, to which Mrs. Gunness should not object if alive. • • • With both the president and the vice-president enthusiastic devotees, «g|f le bound to become popular as a matter of course. • • •
Clipping to come
The Daily Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
Searchers at the ruined Gunness farmhouse in La Porte, Indiana, found two more pocket watches in the debris, bringing the total recovered to ten. Combined with nine bodies already found, authorities believe at least one more victim is unaccounted for.
The Daily Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 1
III II DEBRIS Of the Gunness House Are Found, Pointing to More Murders. LAPORTE Ind., May 14?Two more* watches were found In the debris of the ruined Guinness house and those,
Authorities in La Porte, Indiana continue investigating the fourteen deaths linked to Belle Gunness's farm, with ten bodies found in the barnyard and four in the burned farmhouse ruins. Investigators remain uncertain whether the burned female corpse is actually Gunness herself, and are attempting to identify victims through jewelry, including a ring traced to a local purchase just before the fire.
Bluefield Evening Leader · 14 May 1908 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
Ray Lamphere, Belle Gunness's hired man, denied making any confession to Rev. Schell or anyone else. Investigators continued sifting debris from the burned farmhouse cellar hoping for further evidence.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 1
Are Selected Laporte, Ind., Nov. 12.—The intro duction of evidence in the trial of Ray Lampher for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and Iher three children by setting fire to the house will begin tomorrow morning, a jury having been Secured late this afternoon and States Attorney Smith 'having made 'his open ing statement to the jury before the adjournment of wurt. The twelve men accepted are: Henry Mill, 65 retired farmer Wm. Glagow, 34, farmer Jared Drollinger, 58, farmer Richard H. Hollond, 53 farmer Bruce MlcOormick, 50, car penter Charles Travis, 48, farmer Gifford Hull, 56, township assessor L. B." Collings, 40, farmer Gay lor Jessup, 58, farmer Frank A. Block, 54, merchant.
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
A woman arrested on a train near Syracuse on suspicion of being fugitive murderess Belle Gunness was released after establishing her true identity as Mrs. L.A. Herron. Family members and acquaintances confirmed her background in Franklin, Pennsylvania, disproving the suspicion.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 2
WOMAN ARRESTED IS NOT MURDERESS
NBVV YORK, May 9?Mrs. Charles P. Rockefeller, of this city, is a sis ter of Mrs. L. A.-Herron, detained at Syracuse and suspected of being Mrs. Gunness. She said Mrs. Herron liv ed most of her life in Franklin, Pa., and her husband died last Christmas. Mrs. Rockefeller said her sister was on tho way to this city to search for employment, when she was taken In to custody. 'CHICAGO, 111.. May 9?It Is de clared at the office cff the Sethness Company, manufacturers of flavoring extracts, of this city, that F.
See moreSee less
B. Her ron. husband of Mrs. L. A. Herron. was vice president of tho company until January of this year. He died in Vicksburg, Miss. It is declared that the statement made by Mrs. Herron that she lived in Franklin, Pa., Is correct.
Mrs. L. A. Herron, detained in Syracuse on suspicion of being Belle Gunness, was released after relatives and acquaintances in Chicago and Franklin, Pa. confirmed her identity and husband's death. Meanwhile at the Gunness farm, digging resumed with two more bodies found, and a doctor who performed the autopsy claimed the body believed to be Gunness's was actually that of a smaller, lighter woman.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 2
ARREST WAS ON TRAIN
N. B. Worden, attorney for Ray Lamphore, who Is In jail In connec tion jylth the murders, asserted to day that there Is no truth in the statement that Lamphero desired to confess or that he had anything to confess. He denied that any trunk was found containing letters written by Lamphero to Mrs. Gunness. LAPORTE. Ind., May 8?When the rain ceased this morning the soarch was resumed at the Gunness farm and in a short time two more bodies were found, making eleven recovered In all. One was tho skeleton of a man and the other Is supposed to be that ot a woman.
See moreSee less
Tho digging continued and It is predicted that other bodies will bo uncovered. A largo crowd watches the men digging. Detectives ot n prlvato agency were brought Into the alTalr yeater No other'disease causes sucH wide-spread suffering as Rheumatism. II ft a. nerve racking torture, and so thoroughly does it dominate the system, when it becomes entrenched in the blood; that its victims are usually com plete slaves to pain. Rheumatism is dn$ to an excess of uric acid in the blood brought on by stomach troubles, weak kidneys, indigestion, and a sluggish condition of the system. The natural refuse of the body, instead
Authorities in Laporte are gathering evidence connecting Ray Lamphere to the deaths of Mrs. Gunness, her three children, and Andrew Helgelein. A tuft of hair resembling Lamphere's was found clenched in Helgelein's hand, suggesting a struggle, as the county grand jury convenes to investigate the case.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 5
WHO TO TAKE HAND In the Mysterious Murders at Laporte
WILL START TODAY Taking of Testimony Begins This Begins Morning States Attorney Smith Completes Opening Statement Twelve Jnrors Chosen to Decide Lamphere's Fate. .' .jsfc »§?il§ip La Porte, Ind., Nov. 12.—The in troduction of evidence in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the house will be gin to-morrow morning, a jury havand States Attorney Smith having made his opening statement to the jury before the adjournment of court. The twelve men accepted are: Henry Mill, 65 retired farmer William Glasgow, 34, farmer Jared
Clipping to come
The Clarksburg Telegram · Clarksburg, W. Va.
Investigators report finding a gold tooth crown in the debris of the burned Gunness home, believed to belong to Belle Gunness herself. The find, along with bent scissors resembling surgical tools found in the cellar, is seen as evidence she died in the fire and used the instruments in the farm murders.
The Clarksburg Telegram · 14 May 1908 · page 6
GOLD CROWN IS FOUND
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Kendrick Gazette · Kendrick, Idaho · and 2 other papers
Sightseers treated the Gunness farm like a carnival, picnicking, buying souvenir postcards, and searching for relics amid the ruins. Sheriff Smulzer planned to continue investigations, including sifting the cellar ashes for Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings.
The Kendrick Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 7
SOME FINDS WERE MADE
nucleus. Along the roadside in front of the farm were lemonade stands and lunch wagons. At the gates were venders of souvenir postal cards, those bearing a group picture of Mrs. Gunness and the three little ones who met death with her finding the readiest sale. A base ball game in the vicinity was repre sented by strong voiced barkers. Shen iff Smulzer will continue his investi gations at the Gunness farm tomor row. The first object of searching will be the heap of ashes and other refuse in the cellar of the ruined house. The ashes and cinders are to be carefully bifted and then sluiced by a miner in an effort to discover the gold fillings which are said to have been in Mrs. Gunness' teeth.
The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich. · and 1 other paper
Investigators dug up ten bodies at Belle Gunness's Laporte, Indiana farm, including one identified as Ole B. Budsberg lured by a matrimonial ad. Evidence mounted against suspected accomplice Ray Lamphere while thousands of sightseers flocked to the farm.
The Yale Expositor · 15 May 1908 · page 2
GENERAL NEWS.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
River Falls Journal · River Falls, Wis. · 14 May 1908
The Montgomery Tribune · Montgomery City, Mo. · and 1 other paper
The hired man Joseph Maxson describes hearing victims' screams and being used to dig graves and destroy trunks stained with blood. Meanwhile, the coroner claims Belle Gunness faked her death and fled to Europe, while the state's attorney announces charges against Ray Lamphere as an accomplice.
Mrs. Gunness Is Dead. _ Laporte, Ind., November 13—The state is well satis Bed with the evidence which was presented today in the trial of Raj Bamphere, on a charge of murdering Mrs. Belie Gunness and her children, to prove that the four bodies removed from the ruins of the burned Gunness house on April 2S were those or Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Judge Richter permit ted the coroner's verdict to go before the jury and later informed the jurors that they should disregard the verdict as proof of the death of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness. The testimony of Dr. J. B. Gray, who conducted the autopsy on the body of the adult female found in the burned rulnst and declared by the state to be that of Mrs. Bello Gunness, proved of material
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Mexico Missouri Message · Mexico, Mo. · 14 May 1908
Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D. · and 1 other paper
Officials report ongoing excavation of the Gunness farm, with the identification of one body as Andrew Helgelien now in doubt due to discrepancies. Six bodies have been found so far, and suspect Ray Lamphere, under interrogation, reacts with shock upon learning of the death toll.
Kingsbury County Independent · 15 May 1908 · page 3
remnants of a child's clothing. He stated that he believed that in life the person had weighed 200 pounds. I his was about the weight of Mrs. Gunness. Ho testified that a body which had gone through 12 hours of fire would slirinK about two-thirds. He said the body of the woman after the fire weighed 73 pounds. Dr. Gray said the cause of the woman s death was asphyxia, caused by fire. Dr. Gray testified that the clenched hand was a postmortem condition that frequently follow-ed death by suffocation. The witness added that a similar con dition of the body followed death due to strychnine poisoning. The trial will proceed tomorrow-.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Forest City Press · Forest City, S.D. · 14 May 1908
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
Ray Lamphere denied making any confession about the Gunness murders to Rev. E. A. Schell or anyone else, while Schell confirmed Lamphere's statements remain privileged and undisclosed. Laporte banks agreed to supply records of Mrs. Gunness's financial transactions to aid the prosecutor's investigation.
AFTER QUARREL. Laporte, Ind., Nov 13.—The de fense in. the Lamphere case in its ef forts to prevent certain information going to the jury suffered its first de feat when Judge Richter ruled tftat the report of the coroner's verdict was ad missible as primary evidence. The ruling followed exhaustive arguments. Coroner Mack was the first witness. He testified to finding the bodies in the ruins and said that one was that of an adult female t.nd the other three were those of children. He also found a number of bones, Including the seventh vertebrae and the part of the lower jaw bone of a human being.
See moreSee less
The bones, which had •been sealed in a jar, were introduced in. evidence. The report of the cor oner's inquest was also offered in evi dence.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
Police in LaPorte reported finding a skull amid the ruins of Belle Gunness's burned home, with the jaw torn off and features unrecognizable, which they believed confirmed the earlier headless trunk was hers. Physicians disagreed on whether the skull was male or female, and a heap of bones nearby was thought to be a seventeenth victim.
Says Lamphere Was Gunness' Aid. The jury to try Ray Lamphere on the charge of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and lieithree children was completed at 4 o'clock yesterday aft ernoon. Ten minutes after the jurors had been sworn in Judge John oejore C. Bichter, Prosecutor Ralph N. Smith outlined the case of the state in an opening statement. His speech disclosed that the mur der of Andrew K. Helgeleln, the South Dakota farmer whose body was among those found, dismembered and sewn in gunnysacks, in shallow graves in Mrs. Gunness' chicken yard, is to be as much the subject of testi mony as the charge of murder by ar son against Lamphere, which is the formal question before the jury.
See moreSee less
With the avowed purpose of develop ing the motive for the burning of the Gunness house Prosecutor Smith de clared that he will prove Lamphere knew of the murders by Mrs. Gunness and was her active accomplice in dis posing of Helgelein's body. Further, the attorney for the state said he would show that Lamphere shared in the loot taken from Hel geleln and later blackmailed Mrs. Gun-' ness until this method of obtaining money created such animosity be tween them that he fired her house. This statement, showing that Lam phere virtually is on trial on a charge of t^e murder of Helgelein, injected tremendous interest into the case. It meant that whatever secret evidence exists concerning the operations of the mistress of the murder farm is to be given on the winess stand in open court. Personnel of the Jury, The jury is composed of the follow ing men:
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Investigators sifting through ashes in the Gunness farmhouse cellar discovered portions of human jawbones, a piece of skin with hair, and charred vertebrae. Prosecutors called these the most valuable findings yet, though some fragments were too damaged for positive identification.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 1
RELICS FOUND ON THE GUNNESS FARM
Says Lamphere Was Gunness' Aid. The jury to try Ray Lamphere on the charge of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and lieithree children was completed at 4 o'clock yesterday aft ernoon. Ten minutes after the jurors had been sworn in Judge John oejore C. Bichter, Prosecutor Ralph N. Smith outlined the case of the state in an opening statement. His speech disclosed that the mur der of Andrew K. Helgeleln, the South Dakota farmer whose body was among those found, dismembered and sewn in gunnysacks, in shallow graves in Mrs. Gunness' chicken yard, is to be as much the subject of testi mony as the charge of murder by ar son against Lamphere, which is the formal question before the jury.
See moreSee less
With the avowed purpose of develop ing the motive for the burning of the Gunness house Prosecutor Smith de clared that he will prove Lamphere knew of the murders by Mrs. Gunness and was her active accomplice in dis posing of Helgelein's body. Further, the attorney for the state said he would show that Lamphere shared in the loot taken from Hel geleln and later blackmailed Mrs. Gun-' ness until this method of obtaining money created such animosity be tween them that he fired her house. This statement, showing that Lam phere virtually is on trial on a charge of t^e murder of Helgelein, injected tremendous interest into the case. It meant that whatever secret evidence exists concerning the operations of the mistress of the murder farm is to be given on the winess stand in open court. Personnel of the Jury, The jury is composed of the follow ing men:
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A miscellaneous editorial paragraph column references the Laporte, Indiana case, noting 'Dead men do tell tales at Laporte, Ind.' and that 'Indiana's Bluebeard will live in the stories' of novelists and playwrights. The brief mentions are embedded among unrelated commentary on music education, politics, and current events.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 4
RINGS, TESTIFY. Lanorte. Ind.. Nov. 14. Witnesses were placed on the stand in the Lam phere case today to establish the fact that the gold rings and bridge work In the jawbone found In the ruins of the Gunness home were Ms. Gunness's nronertv. The jeweler who had cleaned her rings for her and the dent ist who fixed her teeth testified. The prosecution is thoroughly satisfied it will move the identification of the body as that of Mrs. Gunness. The state is well satisfied with the evidence which was presented Friday for the purpose of proving that the four bodies removed from the ruins of the Gunness house on April 28 were those of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Belle Gunness and her tnYee children. The exhibits of the day included the rings taken from the fingers or Mrs. Gunness and the children, a
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
This is a miscellaneous editorial/filler column making light of current events, including jokes about 'Mrs. Gunness' becoming a byword for murderous wives and travelers needing to prove they aren't her. It also contains unrelated brief news items on nominations, divorces, and a Senate fistfight.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 4
AND STTTSr-TFXimre AM. Ray Lamphere, who is charged with killing and burning Mrs. Gunness and her three children, is now on trial at Laporte, Ind. The defense alleges that the remains of the woman found were not those of Mrs. Gunness, but of a cadaver. The defense also will attempt to prove that Mrs. Gunness still lives-. Notwithstanding these claims the state will attempt to prove that the woman is dead and Ray Lam phere was directly responsible for her demise.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Investigators sifting the ashes of the burned Gunness farmhouse cellar found human jawbone fragments, a piece of skin with hair, charred vertebrae, and two watches, bringing relic finds to ten items. The coroner was uncertain if the bones were human or animal, while officials compared Andrew Helgelein's prison measurements to an unearthed corpse.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 15 May 1908 · page 1
HUMAN JAWBONES FOUND ON THE GUNNESS FARM
AND STTTSr-TFXimre AM. Ray Lamphere, who is charged with killing and burning Mrs. Gunness and her three children, is now on trial at Laporte, Ind. The defense alleges that the remains of the woman found were not those of Mrs. Gunness, but of a cadaver. The defense also will attempt to prove that Mrs. Gunness still lives-. Notwithstanding these claims the state will attempt to prove that the woman is dead and Ray Lam phere was directly responsible for her demise.
Clipping to come
The Newspaper · Paonia, Colo.
A small opinion item notes that reports of murder from the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana, are filling newspaper columns. It expresses hope that the belief that Belle Gunness and her children were murdered and burned in the house is true.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Newspaper · 15 May 1908 · page 4
SUBSCRIBERS ATTENTION! Under tlie poßtal rules we tire prohibited from sending papers to subscribers that are more than one year in arrears. If this paragraph Is marked with a blue pencil it is a notice that you are one year back and that the paper will not be sent again unless pnld for. While the other f Hows arc capturing the resolutions. Mr Bryan is industriously harvesting votes —Lake City I'honogi ph Thf. reports of murder from the town ol La Porte. Ind., at the Gunness home, are occupying columns of the dailies.
See moreSee less
It is be lieved that the woman and her children all were murdered and burned in the house which had been the scene of her desperate deeds, and it is to be hoped that this is true It would be a gr?at pity if any of her blood were above ground. After doing their utmost to block legislation, the Democratic congressman will go into the cam paign and criticise the Republi cans for not doing anything.—
A newspaper opinion column criticizes Syracuse police for arresting Mrs. Herron as a suspect in the Gunness case without sufficient cause. It notes the arrest harmed an innocent woman and calls the investigation flawed.
The New Haven Union · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Syracuse police are In bad odor. There Ifloecn’t seem to have been the slight est exouse for the arrest of Mrs. Her ron, taken as a Gunness suspect. It
Ray Lamphere, arrested in connection with the Gunness farm tragedy, has been disowned by his brothers and sisters due to his degenerate life. His elderly mother, however, still loves him and is reportedly prostrated with grief, hiding at her daughter's home in South Bend after her whereabouts became known through a son-in-law.
The New Haven Union · 15 May 1908 · page 5
Laporte. Ind., Nov. 14. For' the purpose of taking advantage of every opportunity so as to finish the trial of Ray Lamphere before Thanksgiving, the circuit court continued in session today. Prosecutor Smith was -well satisfied with the progress made yes terday. He said: "We have shown by the testimony of Coroner Mack, Sheriff Smutzer and Doctors Wilcox, Long and Gray that two rings introduced by us In evidence were taken from the fingers of the adult female body found in the fire. Sheriff Smutzer swore they were simi lar to rings he had seen on the finger of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness during her life, but we will establish their ownership with out question by the testimony of Her man Klbogan, a jeweler, who had them In his possession for cleaning and several times had seen them on
Searchers sifting debris from the burned Gunness house found bone fragments, scalp skin, a razor-sharp knife, and two more watches (eleven total). Investigators say this suggests the murderess's missing head was not removed, though the defense for Ray Lamphere may dispute this at trial.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 May 1908 · page 9
MAY BE MISSING HEAD
Identified, Then tho Prose cution Must Fail. LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 13. The stato in the Lamphcro case todaj' presented evidence to prove that the four bodies removed from the ruins of the Gunness house on April 2S were those of Mrs. Belle Gunucss ,aud her throo children. Judge Kichtcr permitted the coroner's verdict to go bofore tho jury, but later informed the jurors that they should disregard tho verdict as being proof of I ho death of Mrs. Gunness. Court will be held tomorrow. The exhibits of tho day included tbc rings taken from the fingers of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and the children, a piece of cloth found, clenched in tho hand of one of the children, three pieces of bonc, identified by Coroner Mack. Sheriff Smutzer and Doctors Long. Wil cox and Gray, and photographs of the scenes of the burned house and the bodio3. The bones consisted of a heel bone, n lower jaw and several ocvrienl vertebrae. ShoriffSmutzer described in detail tho positions in which tbo bodies were found, the fact that under neath them was dobris of considerable thickness, and ho swore to the removal of the rings from the fingors.
Investigators found a concealed razor-blade knife and additional watches in the ruins of the Gunness farm, bringing the watch total to eleven. Using Bertillon records, officials positively identified the dismembered remains as Andrew Helgelein, and the sheriff announced plans to resume digging for more bodies, including under the barn floor.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 15 May 1908 · page 9
SHARP KNIFE IS UNEARTHED
JCrfdence Introduced to Show Hod Found Wu That of Hr?, Gunue". LAPORTE. IND.. N'ovomber 13.?Tli fitate is well satlsfled wlth the evi dence, whlch was presented to-day 1 the trial of Ray Lamphere on a charg pf murderlng Mrs. Hello Gunness an her chlldren, to prove that the fou bodies removed from tno rulns of th burned Gunness house on Aprll 25tl ?were those of Mrs. Gunness and he three children. Judgo Rlchter per rnlttod the coroncr's verdict to go hc fore the Jury and lator Informed th Jurors that they should dlsregard th verdict as proof of the death of Mr Gunness.
See moreSee less
Tha testlmony of Dr. J. E. Gray, wll aonducted the autopsy on the body < the adult female, found ln the burnc rulns, and declared by tha State to b that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, proved < materlal value to the State. Dr. Gray testified that the head i the body was mlsslng and the uppi vertebrae, down to the seventh, wei also gone. Condltion of Uody.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Searchers sifting the ashes in the Gunness farmhouse cellar found pieces of human jawbone and a piece of skin with hair that may be a scalp, along with charred vertebrae. The count of men's watches found has risen to ten, even though only nine male bodies have been unearthed so far.
The San Francisco Call · 15 May 1908 · page 9
BONES OF JAW AND HAIR ARE DUG UP
JCrfdence Introduced to Show Hod Found Wu That of Hr?, Gunue". LAPORTE. IND.. N'ovomber 13.?Tli fitate is well satlsfled wlth the evi dence, whlch was presented to-day 1 the trial of Ray Lamphere on a charg pf murderlng Mrs. Hello Gunness an her chlldren, to prove that the fou bodies removed from tno rulns of th burned Gunness house on Aprll 25tl ?were those of Mrs. Gunness and he three children. Judgo Rlchter per rnlttod the coroncr's verdict to go hc fore the Jury and lator Informed th Jurors that they should dlsregard th verdict as proof of the death of Mr Gunness.
See moreSee less
Tha testlmony of Dr. J. E. Gray, wll aonducted the autopsy on the body < the adult female, found ln the burnc rulns, and declared by tha State to b that of Mrs. Belle Gunness, proved < materlal value to the State. Dr. Gray testified that the head i the body was mlsslng and the uppi vertebrae, down to the seventh, wei also gone. Condltion of Uody.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Investigators examine bone specimens believed to be from a human jaw, while the count of watches found belonging to male victims has risen to ten, exceeding the nine bodies unearthed. Authorities continue digging and sifting through public tips, most of which lack identifying details needed to match remains to missing persons.
The San Francisco Call · 15 May 1908 · page 9
TEN WATCHES FOUND
Dr. J. M. Osborn, of La Porte. In idana, is in the valley for the pur pose of looking over the country, and may decide to locate in this sec tion of the state. The doctor is from the town in which the notorious Mrs. Gunness lived, the fiend in female form that, has lived in the United States since ihe time the Benders operated in Kansas. He graduated from a medical colleg? last spring and also was married at that time, and they have been on their honey moon since the spring. He intended since the sprint. He had intended going east to take up his practice, but is so in love with the country that he has decided to cast his lot in the west.
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Letters from the public fail to identify unknown skeletons, with most ignoring that remains had been buried for years. Defense attorneys for Lamphere seek witness David Havens, who allegedly claimed the bodies showed no debris beneath them when found, suggesting they were placed before the fire—though the sheriff and physicians' findings contradict this.
The San Francisco Call · 15 May 1908 · page 9
DAVID HAVENS IS SOUGHT
THE GUNNESS MURDER TRIAL ImporUnt Witne»» For Defendant Won't Appear Defeme Will Set Up An Alibi H\ Unit»*»* Pt»»* ' Laporte, Ind. Nov. IL—lt is an nounced that Rev E. A. Shell,
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Diggers at the ruined Gunness farmhouse found human jaw bone fragments, a piece of skin possibly from a scalp, and charred vertebrae, along with two more watches. Prosecutors called the day's finds highly significant, while defense attorneys for Ray Lamphere sought a witness, David Havens, who allegedly disputed details of how the bodies were originally found.
Los Angeles Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 1
FIND BONES AND HAIR IN CELLAR
SKIN MAY BE PORTION OF HUMAN SCALP
DAY'S DISCOVERIES INCLUDE VERTEBRAE
students corporation turned up at’ | the Cniversity at an early hour determined to keep the Pan-Ger mans out. three hundred of the Jewish students were blockading the main stair cases of the I’niver sity. Apprised of the situation the Pan-Germans gathered in force and stormed the stair cases which lead to the balcony. Tha fighting for a few minutes was fierce and in 1 the midst of it the balcony crashed Ito the ground currying with it the students, most of whom were injur cd and some seriously. THE GUNNESS MURDER TRIAL
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
An Associated Press dispatch from Christiania reports that locals remember Belle Gunness as a girl assisting her father, a traveling magician, performing as a rope dancer at Norwegian fairs. It notes her siblings also performed and that her father eventually retired to property near Trondhjem, with Mrs. Gunness still having many relatives in Norway.
Los Angeles Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 1
CHRISTIANIA RECALLS MRS. GUNNESS AS GIRL
OUT IN MRS GUNNIES MURDER CASE—MANY WITNESSES. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 16.—For the purpose of taking advantage of every opportunity to finish the trial of I.amphere before Thanksgiving, the circuit court continued in session Saturday. Prosecutor' Smith is well satisfied with the progress. He said: "We have shown by testimony of Coroner Mack, Sheriff Suzier and IJrs. Wilcox, Long and Grey that two rings introduced by us in evidence, were taken front the fingers of the adult female body found in the fire. Sheriff Sulzer swore they were sim ilar to rings lie had seen qn the fing et of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness during her life, but we will establish their owner ship without question by tlie testi mony of HermanSlbogan, a jewel er who had them In his possession for cleaning and had several times seen them on Mrs. Gunness' fing et*. "Neighbors will also support this testimony. This we will follow up with the introduction of dental work found in the ruins near the bodies and by testimony of Dr. Nor ton we will prove that the bridge had been made for Mrs. Gunness and fitted in her mouth." Dr. ,1. L. Grey tvho testified that in It is opinion the cause of death on female adult body found in the ruins was asphyxiation, resumed the wit ness stand today for the completion of his cross-examination.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
A brief digest item reports that additional evidence of wholesale murder has been dug up at the Gunness death farm. The item gives no further detail, appearing only as a one-line news summary among other unrelated stories.
Los Angeles Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 1
METHODS OF GUNNESS WOMAN SHOWN BY LETTERS TO HELGELIN Arch Murderess Invited Broth er of Man She Killed to ' Visit Her. LA PORTE, .In'd., Nov. 1G. Prose cutor Smith played' another trump card today when with A. K. Helgelln, of Aberdeen, S. D., on the stand, he offered in evidence and read to the Jury copies of three letters written by Mrs. Belle dimness to the witness during March and April of this year. In which references to "that crazy Lamphere are made, These letters portray the methods empioyea Dy me .Brcu-muraeress in allaying the suspicions of relatives of persons she murdered.
See moreSee less
Even with uu, ..WCV...H W'"b iieu4iM-i in ner private graveyara. sne was asking his brother to come to La Porte to Investigate and to bring plenty of. money with him. , T. , . "'ii""-u"w ""- !"", Ktfnn huh him ninti r;u Minni iikhk was also offered in evidence. Cashier Pitner having Identified a photograph of Andrew Helgellnas the man who came to the bank with Mrs. Qunness early in January and drew $2900. Mrs. Ounness is supposed to have iuuiucicu irascuu ou uouuarjr it. O
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Searchers sifting ashes in the cellar of the Gunness farmhouse found parts of human jaw bones, a piece of possible scalp, and charred vertebrae. Prosecutors called the findings valuable to their case, as they could help confirm the headless adult body found after the fire was indeed Mrs. Gunness.
New-York Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 7
MORE HUMAN RELICS.
TESTIMONY GIVEN ABOUT LAMPHERE Former Intimates of Accused Man Tell of Incidents Previous to Gunness Murders. I Nye, at the Lamphere trial today re-1 phere went to Michigan City, spend
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Physicians are preparing a formal report on charred bone fragments found in the ruins, which may confirm the body found was human and support the theory that fire destroyed Mrs. Gunness's head. Separately, Bertillon measurements of Andrew Helgelein were compared to an unearthed body and reportedly matched closely, while Christiania sources describe Belle Gunness's childhood as a performer with her conjurer father.
New-York Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 7
MORE HUMAN RELICS.
Nye identified a coat and gun allegthe murdered Hclgeleln, as the propout a erty of Lamphere. Bessie Wallace, a' former intimate Lamphere testified of Inn nmi6™ fi Wan "g March*!Evans, Wallace stating she heard Lamphere, say "the old woman and I had a fall ing out, and I left her a few days ago. She owes me some money which I can make her give me. If she don't fork it over, I'll get even with her." "The old woman," referring to Belle, Bossie Interjected, "I thought you folks were married by this time," and\ alleged Lamphere replied, "no what's thfc use of getting married." 'i Broke Live Stock Recorded*"*
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Searchers sifting the ashes in the Gunness farmhouse cellar found human jaw bone fragments, a piece of possible scalp, charred vertebrae, and two watches, bringing the total relics to ten. Investigators say the jaw fragments, if confirmed human, would counter defense claims that the adult body's identity is uncertain, supporting the theory the fire destroyed Mrs. Gunness's head.
New-York Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 7
MORE HUMAN RELICS.
Bring Plenty of Money. LaPorte, Ind., Nov. 17. The Lam phere case progressed rapidly yester day, and when court adjourned in the evening the state had presented con siderable testimony intended to con nect Lamphere with the death of Mrs. Gunness and her children. The star witness yesterday was A. K. Helgelein of Aberdeen, S. D., who identified three letters written by Mrs. Gunness to him during March and April, this year, in which references to "that crazy Lamphere" were made.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A filler paragraph jokes that women within 25 pounds of Belle Gunness's weight and similar hair color should travel with large, muscular escorts for safety. It appears amid unrelated news snippets about mint farming, Harry Orchard, Taft, and German cruisers.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 6
cutor Smith today played another of Aberdeen, S. D., on. the stand, he trump card, when with A. K. Helgelein offered in evidence and read to the jury copies of three letters written by a Mrs. Belle Gunness to the witness dur ing March and April t:his year, in
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Two more watches were found in the ruins of the burned Gunness home, bringing the total to twelve, more than the number of skeletons recovered, suggesting additional bodies remain buried. Authorities also found a child's ring and bone fragments believed to be from Mrs. Gunness, while detectives pursue leads on a mysterious man who collected her mail in various cities.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 11
MORE BONES SOUGHT: Death Farm Supposed to Contain Other Victims
NOT liO ON STAND HAN WITH Mtmtftft OF MRS GUNNESS AND CHILDREN ^WIUNOT TESTIFY ,114 .• .L OWN DEFENSE. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 17.—That Ray
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Detectives investigate reports that Mrs. Gunness employed a man to collect her mail from various cities, and a streetcar conductor recounts seeing a man meet a woman in a buggy near the farm to hand off a bag. Meanwhile, a bone believed to be from Mrs. Gunness's head and other relics were found at the farm, though their connection to the case remains unclear.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 11
MORE BONES SOUGHT
.• .L OWN DEFENSE. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 17.—That Ray "liamphere will not go on the stand in own defense against the charge Of murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness, and s jtoer three children is a foregone con clusion. Attorneys Worden and Weir, When asked if Lamphere would tell JUs story on the stand, said, that they ^ad not decided positively but from present Indications he would not. The state cannot require Lamphere to testify and so the prosecutor can h&ve no chance to question him un tfss he voluntarily goes on the stand or does so at the bidding of his at tbrney.
See moreSee less
John Wheatbrook was the first wit -ness today. He testified to Lamphere's Hrrival at his place at 6:30 o'clock on (lie morning ot the fire and Lam ^here's remark that he saw the Gun Hess house burning.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A streetcar conductor recounts noticing a mysterious man who met Mrs. Gunness and carried a bag of matrimonial-ad replies, matching descriptions in a letter to police. Separately, a boy named John Solyam who saw a man running from the burning Gunness home is taken to the jail and, after initially failing to identify anyone, points out Ray Lamphere in a staged lineup.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 11
CLEVELAND BOY IDENTIFIES LAMPHERE
DEFENSE ID CUI SHE IS SUICIDE Frjend of R Lamphere Testifies t That Mrs. dimness had Promised . , to Marry ueienaant By Associated Press La Porte Ind., Nov. 17 That Ray Lamp here had confessed to intimacy with Mrs, Belle Gunness. and that he had chased Andrew Helgelein with a gun, and that Mrs. .Gunness had promised to marry Lamphere when he joined some secret society and took out insurance, were sen sational facts, testified today by Wm. Slater, a friend and neighbor of the de fendant. The first positive statement of the defense in conrt to show its line of defense was made by Attorney Warden, when he remarked that an effort would be made to show that Mrs. Gunness was a suicide. ,
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Investigators digging at the Gunness farm found two more gold and silver watches, bringing the total to twelve, along with a child's ring and bone fragments believed to be from Mrs. Gunness. Authorities believe more victims remain buried since the number of watches exceeds identified skeletons, while detectives also pursue leads on a mysterious man who collected Mrs. Gunness's mail.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 11
TWO GOLD WATCHES FOUND
LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 1G. Prose cutor Smith today played another trump 'card, when, with A. Iv. Helgelein of Aberdeen, S. D., on the stand, he offered incidence and read to the jury copies of three letters written by Mrs. Dcllo Guuness to the witness during . March and April this year, in which references to "that -crazy Lanhero" arc made. These letters portray the methods employed by. the archmurdcr css to allay tho suspicions of the rcla tives of persons she had murdered. Even with Andrew Helgelein lying dis membered in her private burying ground, she wns asking his brother to j come to Laporte to investigate and j bring plenty of 11101103' with him.
See moreSee less
A. K. Helgelein was tho star witness j today. He told of his anxiety over the . disappearance of his brother, and that ! in reply to his first letter of inquiry to Mrs.' Gunness ho received the follow ing: ' "Laporte. Ind.. March 27, 100S. "Mr. Axel W. Helgelein:" "I havo 3'our recent letter in which you wish to know where your brother Audrew keeps himself. Well, that i ,iust what I would, like to kuow. "He came here about the middle of January. When ho left here he said ho wanted to find his brother. Ho thought, he was in Chicago or New irork, or possibly had gone to Norway. Up wanted to spend pome time with us when he returned. When he was iu Chicago, he said ha would be there so abort a time that I need uot write. m I havo neither seeu. nor hoard from him sinco then". I saw a man who faid he had gone back to South Dakota., "BELLE GUNNESS." .
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Investigators pursue leads on a man who regularly carried a grip bag to meet a woman believed to be Mrs. Gunness near the farm, based on a streetcar conductor's detailed testimony. The report also mentions newly found relics, including a ring and bone fragments possibly from Mrs. Gunness, and references the identification of Ray Lamphere.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 11
I.nmiiliere Placed on Trlnl. Ilav Lnmphere was taken from the county jap in ljjporte. Ind.. to the Cir cuit Court room Monday to answer to the charge of murder in the first degree for the death of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A streetcar conductor recounts observing a mysterious man meeting a woman believed to be Belle Gunness to exchange bags of matrimonial correspondence. Separately, 15-year-old John Solyam recounts how he positively identified Ray Lamphere in a jail lineup as the man he saw running from the burning Gunness home.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 11
EVIDENCE IN THE I GUNNESS CASE Joseph Maxson Tells of a Stay at the Gunness Home Night of -the Fire. LA PORTE, Nov. 18.—Joseph Max
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A satirical newspaper humor column makes light of the ongoing search for Belle Gunness, joking that women resembling her description should travel with large escorts. It also jests that no evidence has shown she was a 'Florodora girl'.
The Washington Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 6
I ~-8tate to Conclude This Week! LaPorte, tod., NOT. 18.—Associate 'Counsel Sutherland of the state's at torney's office, announced this morn lrtgthat the state would not use a number of witnesses originally sub poenaed in the Gunness murder case, because it was felt certain the propo sition had already been fully estab lished and that further evidence along these lines would be superfluous. "We feel," he said, "that so far we jbave mkde out a good case and have proven every contention that we have set out to show, and we will try to shorten up the trial as much as possi ble.
See moreSee less
Lamphere'a setting of the fire will next be shown. "We expect to fin ish our evidence Friday or Saturday." From a statement today It became known that the attorneys for Lamp: •here will not be worried if the state does prove Lamphere set fire to the house, for the contention of defense now is that Mrs. Gunness disposed of the children and then committed sui cide, and that all were dead before the house burned, consequently even if 7 Lamphere fired it the jury will fiave to acquit him, under these circum stances, of murder. In an effort to establish the fact that Lamphere was hounding Mrs. Gunness and making life miserable for her, and to show definitely the date of the Hel gelein murfter, in the profits of which Lamphere ia supposed by the prosecu tion to have shared and over the di vision of which it is contended Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere first fell out, the state today offered considerable evidence to the Jury. It became known 'tills afternoon "that Judge Richter was investigating a report that an attempt bad been made to tamper with some oi the state's witnesses.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A short filler item notes it is strange that Mrs. Gunness' neighbors did not know her business, amid unrelated political and humor snippets. It offers no new facts, just a passing observation on the ongoing La Porte case.
Evening Star · 15 May 1908 · page 6
I ~-8tate to Conclude This Week! LaPorte, tod., NOT. 18.—Associate 'Counsel Sutherland of the state's at torney's office, announced this morn lrtgthat the state would not use a number of witnesses originally sub poenaed in the Gunness murder case, because it was felt certain the propo sition had already been fully estab lished and that further evidence along these lines would be superfluous. "We feel," he said, "that so far we jbave mkde out a good case and have proven every contention that we have set out to show, and we will try to shorten up the trial as much as possi ble.
See moreSee less
Lamphere'a setting of the fire will next be shown. "We expect to fin ish our evidence Friday or Saturday." From a statement today It became known that the attorneys for Lamp: •here will not be worried if the state does prove Lamphere set fire to the house, for the contention of defense now is that Mrs. Gunness disposed of the children and then committed sui cide, and that all were dead before the house burned, consequently even if 7 Lamphere fired it the jury will fiave to acquit him, under these circum stances, of murder. In an effort to establish the fact that Lamphere was hounding Mrs. Gunness and making life miserable for her, and to show definitely the date of the Hel gelein murfter, in the profits of which Lamphere ia supposed by the prosecu tion to have shared and over the di vision of which it is contended Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere first fell out, the state today offered considerable evidence to the Jury. It became known 'tills afternoon "that Judge Richter was investigating a report that an attempt bad been made to tamper with some oi the state's witnesses.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Sheriff Smutzer's search of the Gunness farm has turned up jawbones believed to be from an adult human skull, pending formal confirmation by the coroner's physicians. The find is seen as important to building the case against Ray Lamphere, who is due before the grand jury Monday.
Evening Star · 15 May 1908 · page 15
JAWBONES IN KEY
I ~-8tate to Conclude This Week! LaPorte, tod., NOT. 18.—Associate 'Counsel Sutherland of the state's at torney's office, announced this morn lrtgthat the state would not use a number of witnesses originally sub poenaed in the Gunness murder case, because it was felt certain the propo sition had already been fully estab lished and that further evidence along these lines would be superfluous. "We feel," he said, "that so far we jbave mkde out a good case and have proven every contention that we have set out to show, and we will try to shorten up the trial as much as possi ble.
See moreSee less
Lamphere'a setting of the fire will next be shown. "We expect to fin ish our evidence Friday or Saturday." From a statement today It became known that the attorneys for Lamp: •here will not be worried if the state does prove Lamphere set fire to the house, for the contention of defense now is that Mrs. Gunness disposed of the children and then committed sui cide, and that all were dead before the house burned, consequently even if 7 Lamphere fired it the jury will fiave to acquit him, under these circum stances, of murder. In an effort to establish the fact that Lamphere was hounding Mrs. Gunness and making life miserable for her, and to show definitely the date of the Hel gelein murfter, in the profits of which Lamphere ia supposed by the prosecu tion to have shared and over the di vision of which it is contended Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere first fell out, the state today offered considerable evidence to the Jury. It became known 'tills afternoon "that Judge Richter was investigating a report that an attempt bad been made to tamper with some oi the state's witnesses.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · and 1 other paper
Searchers continue sifting and sluicing the fire ruins for evidence, including possible gold fillings from Mrs. Gunness's teeth melted into cinders. The Lamphere case may go to the grand jury soon, but prosecutors expect to delay trial for months due to hostile public opinion and incomplete evidence gathering.
The Topeka State Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 1
WAITING ON PUBLIC
Say Lamphere Made Threat. LaPorte, Ind., Nov. IS. That Ray Lamphere made numerous threats against Mrs. Belle Gunness was the testimony given by a number of the state's witnesses who testified yester day in the trial of Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Through these witnesses, Prosecutor Smith tried to prove the allegation that a strong motive existed for the defendant to annoy Mrs. Gun ness and that this annoyance termin ated on the morning of April 28 in Lamphere setting fire to the house. The love affairs of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and Lamphere were also told in an inter esting manner by William Slater, and in his testimony the state found much of value to strengthen its position that it was because of the falling out be tween the two that Lamphere sought to harm his former sweetheart and mistress, for Slater swore to the fact that Lamphere had told him that Mrs. Gunness would come to his room at night and remain until morning.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · 15 May 1908
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A newspaper miscellany column remarks that there is 'reasonable assurance' Mrs. Gunness really burned to death in her house, rather than being alive and still dangerous. The brief note treats her death as settled fact, offering readers comfort.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 15 May 1908 · page 6
Say Lamphere Made Threat. LaPorte, Ind., Nov. IS. That Ray Lamphere made numerous threats against Mrs. Belle Gunness was the testimony given by a number of the state's witnesses who testified yester day in the trial of Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. Through these witnesses, Prosecutor Smith tried to prove the allegation that a strong motive existed for the defendant to annoy Mrs. Gun ness and that this annoyance termin ated on the morning of April 28 in Lamphere setting fire to the house. The love affairs of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and Lamphere were also told in an inter esting manner by William Slater, and in his testimony the state found much of value to strengthen its position that it was because of the falling out be tween the two that Lamphere sought to harm his former sweetheart and mistress, for Slater swore to the fact that Lamphere had told him that Mrs. Gunness would come to his room at night and remain until morning.
Clipping to come
Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa
Evidence suggests three more victims of Belle Gunness: John Moe, Henry Gerhalt, and George Brady. Physicians' post-mortem reports on the adult female body reveal puzzling new details, including confusion over which arm was which and unexplained initials on rings found on the hands.
Iowa State Bystander · 15 May 1908 · page 2
THREE MORE MEN MISSING. NEW VICTIMS OF MRS. GUNNESS MAY BE REVEALED.
Ham Slater and In his testimony the state found much of vatae to strengthen Its position that It was be cause of the falling out between the two that Lamphero sought to harm Mrs Gunness Other witnesses for the state testi fied on lines similar to those brought out at the coroners Inquest and pub lished at that time A K llelgetein the star witness told of his anxiety over the disap pearance of his brother In reply to tho first letter of Inquiry to Sirs i
Clipping to come
Iowa State Bystander · Des Moines, Iowa
Medical examiners' reports to the coroner's jury revealed previously undisclosed details about the adult body believed to be Mrs. Gunness, including confusion over which arm was intact. Three rings with inscribed initials were found on the hands, raising unresolved questions about whether they belonged to Peter Gunness's first wife.
Iowa State Bystander · 15 May 1908 · page 2
MAY BE REVEALED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A dentist in La Porte states that a piece of jawbone recovered from the burned Gunness farmhouse is human and closely resembles the lower jaw of Mrs. Gunness. The finding is presented as evidence to help the coroner reach a definite verdict, and prosecutors are reportedly pleased with the progress.
Evening Times-Republican · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Bones of Head Found in Ruins of Home, Believed to Be Those of Mrs. Gunness — Jaw Identified by Dentist
2 Down SOc a Week one way or another has taken the let IetIler ter from Andrew ho had sent to jnoi Tho man who is working for me found a piece of the letter In the bare Ifound one evening when Lamphere was around There la l no namo on this paper but I know his wrltlnn
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A dentist who had worked on Mrs. Gunness's teeth examined a jawbone fragment found in the fire ruins and declared it strongly resembled hers. Despite this and other physical evidence, the coroner was expected to return an open verdict, complicating the prosecution's case against Ray Lamphere.
Evening Times-Republican · 15 May 1908 · page 1
DENTIST EVIDENCE PARTIALLY CLEARS UP MYSTERY
SENSATION IN LAMPHERE TRIAL Hearst News Service. La Porte, Ind., November 18.—It leaked out today that the defense In the trial of Ray Lamphere will not contend that Mrs. Belle Gunness is
Clipping to come
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · Decorah, Iowa
The report says excavation at the Gunness farm has stopped due to huge crowds of onlookers overwhelming police, so no new bodies have been found. It claims it is now beyond doubt that the charred body found in the ruins was Mrs. Gunness's, while also noting suspicion that John O. Moe, who disappeared after cashing bank notes in La Porte, may be another victim.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Decorah-Posten Og Ved Arnen · 15 May 1908 · page 1
While the state of Indiana is try ing to weave a net of circumstantial evidence about one Lamphere, charged with the murder of the no torious Belle Gunness, it Is not sure
Clipping to come
Svenska Monitoren · Sioux City, Iowa
In a Swedish-language interview, Emil Gretening describes his friendship with Jennie Olson and her reluctance to leave with a supposed professor who no one ever saw. He also recounts how Belle Gunness regularly received male visitors who arrived with trunks but rarely left with them, and who were introduced as cousins from various states.
Svenska Monitoren · 15 May 1908 · page 6
While the state of Indiana is try ing to weave a net of circumstantial evidence about one Lamphere, charged with the murder of the no torious Belle Gunness, it Is not sure
Clipping to come
Svenska Monitoren · Sioux City, Iowa
The report recounts that Mrs. Gunness had been married twice, with her first husband believed poisoned and the second killed in an unexplained accident. It also describes how a Swedish suitor, Anders Hellgren, who had lent her money, mysteriously vanished shortly after withdrawing $3,000 in cash.
Svenska Monitoren · 15 May 1908 · page 7
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Diggers at the Gunness farm uncovered two more watches, bringing the total of men's watches found to ten even as only nine male victims' bodies had been unearthed. Authorities continued investigating metal globules thought to be dental gold and a letter suggesting an accomplice helped lure victims to the farm.
11 1 ff i Ind < Nov lj That ttuy Lam hcli mado numerous IhicuUi again it Mrs Bella Guilncss was testi itod tobyf < t numbei of the i states wlt iosss today nnd thrilueh them ulso Ijoicctilor Smith mado an effort to bilng out IhttUa stiong motive oxistcd for tho defendant to annoy Airs < 0un ncs nnd that this unrloyanco termin ated on < the night of AprilIS InLam iiheie vjltlng llro to iho housp The love aftnliH of Jlrs Ounncss and Limphoio worb also ielated by William Sla nundlnhh testimony tho stato rtalnki It hag found much to th n its poaltton that It vas becnuse of tho falllns out between tho two that Lam pliero sought to hJim Mrs Gunness With Joseph Maxon Iho man who fcaped ilio fioin the burning houso on the stand thoTlist piirt of his story oft1lcfhc was told today JC differs little from the story which he told fol loulng Iho tho Peter Colsoli tcbtilled that Mrs Oun nfts in1 times unkind to Jomilo Olson The way In hlch ho rolated bin concisitlons with I imphcre his own ep < ilences with Mis Gunness his lovo loi tlio woman and Ills suspicions wcio tmlquo nndlUralghlforwaid his broken Kngllsh addlng to the effectiveness of the > stoiy Louis Kuehl a saloonkeeper teatltled that Lampheio hllClnhlsplaejof hushiosiF ono night made tho remark that If tho old woman did not leave him alone ho wdultl send her over tho road Austin Cutler a local undertaker tcstlllod to the length of time Iho bodies of Sirs Gunness and thu children wcro at his morgue before being shipped to Chicago He Bald about 200 persons lodlnl 1l1rrhcis supposition iu that fiom this testimony Prosecutor Smith will loartAH ° doubt uis to how the poison got into thy stomachs Irnnk J Pitner cashier of the First Xatioifal flankr tostlllecl that Mrs Gun ness andjAncfrew Helgeloinctino to tbo Ijank i16i 100S and Ii1lL thu man loft three1 ccrlineatos of deposit issued by thelirst National Bilnk of Aber deen S D Tho Laporto b ksellL f them Iii for collection and received in j loturn a draft forf2800 which sum was turned over JoHIISi lioryJau 34 Mrs Gunness accompanying him to the bank ytia money was paid in cash and Mr Pitner asked what they wero going to r do with so much money Mrs Gunness told hlm ltvaSiroiiQ of hlsbuslness Jaiwiris the night Helgelcln Is sup posed tg have been 1uqen dIYJlrrs
Clipping to come
Troy Weekly News · Troy, Idaho
More than 1,500 people visited the Gunness farm in La Porte on Sunday, with thousands more arriving by rail and trolley, overwhelming local accommodations and transportation. Amid the sightseeing frenzy, some visitors searched for missing relatives, including a man named Olaf Lindboe who believed his brother may have been a victim but could not identify any of the bodies.
Troy Weekly News · 15 May 1908 · page 3
THOUSANDS VISIT GRUESOME PLACE OF MURDER
Laporte, Ind.. May 10.—All roads in led to the Gunness county Laporte Sunday, more than 1500 sight (arm visiting before the sun set the seers of death, the spot where the place of 11 persons have been dug ^^Practically every able-bodied resl
Visitors treat the Gunness farm site like a carnival, with souvenir sellers, lemonade stands, and picnicking families amid talk of the murders. Sheriff Smulzer plans to continue searching the ashes for gold dental fillings from Mrs. Gunness's remains.
Troy Weekly News · 15 May 1908 · page 3
PLACE OF MURDER.
*a?ons. At the gates were venders of I souvenir postal cards, those bearing a group picture of Mrs. Gunness and the I Guve little ones who met death with her finding the readiest sale. A base toi game in the vicinity w'as repre sented by strong voiced barkers. Sher Smulzer will continue his Investi gations at the Gunness farm t.omor row - The first object ot searching will te the heap of ashes and other refuse in the cellar of the ruined house. The ashes and cinders are to be carefully sifted and then sluiced by a miner in an effort to discover the gold fillings »'hich are said to have been in Mrs. Gunness' teeth.
Sightseers flocked to the Gunness farm as if attending a fair, buying souvenir postcards and refreshments while relic hunters searched the grounds. Sheriff Smulzer planned to continue sifting the cellar ashes the next day to search for Mrs. Gunness's gold dental fillings.
Camas Prairie Chronicle · 15 May 1908 · page 2
Gunness Murder Trial On. The trial of Ray Lamphere for his connection with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and others at her place has begun at Laporte, Ind. It has not been fully established that the woman is dead, but the story of the unearthing of several murdered vie tims bodies in her dooryard is still fresh.
The report speculates that the body found in the burned Gunness farmhouse may not have been Belle Gunness herself, suggesting she escaped to Chicago and is hiding among criminal associates. It also compares her to the notorious Bender family killers and claims she had a male partner now in custody, with unverified rumors of a Chicago crime ring shipping dismembered bodies to her farm.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Idaho Republican · 15 May 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
A MATCH FOR KATE BENDER. A woman nemed Belle Guuness who has a farm at LaPorte, Indiana, has been running a polite kind of killing pen at her home for some time and has just been discovered.
Her house burned down last week, and three corpses were found in the ruins. They were supposed to be Mrs. Gunness and two adopted children, but on investigation there is some reason to believe that it was some of her victims that burned, and that she escaped to Chicago, and is now in hiding there among friends for whom she has put troublesome people out of the way.
See moreSee less
A story is circulated to the effect that Mrs. Guuness is a cousin of Kate Bender, one of the family that had a stage station in Kansas many years ago, and killed and robbed so many people while at lunch, and buried the bodies in the garden.
Mrs. Gunness worked on the matrimonial plan, and lured men to her home as suitors, and then disposed of them during their visit, retaining their money and valuables. Many bodies were disinterred on her premises, and there is reason to believe that she had a man partner who helped her in the work. He is now in custody, and the police are on the lookout for Mrs. Gunness all over the country. She was a big muscular woman, and it is thought that she dispatched many of her victims with a dirk of a cleaver. There are indications also, that she was in league with robbers and murderers in Chi- tions Chicago who killed and robbed people in the city and shipped the dismembered bodies in trunks to the Gunness farm for burial in the night.
Authorities in LaPorte, Indiana say they have completed identification of the headless corpse as Belle Gunness after three rings were found at the morgue and a laborer discovered a gold-crowned tooth in the ruins of her burned house. A dentist confirmed the tooth as his own work, and the rings included wedding bands from her two husbands and a diamond chip ring.
The Berne Witness · 15 May 1908 · page 6
Body of Murderess Identified by Rings.
Proved Woman’s Death. "We have proved beyond a doubt that Mrs. Gunness is dead and it was her body found in the ruins of the fire, with the bodies of her three children,” said Mr. Sutherland. “We also Introduced a lot of evfi
Clipping to come
The Jasper Weekly Courier · Jasper, Ind.
New developments emerged in the Gunness case after the arrival of the dead woman's sister and the sister of her adopted daughter. It was revealed that Mrs. Gunness had been corresponding with a Wisconsin man about marriage, telling him she needed a husband because of threats against her life.
The Jasper Weekly Courier · 15 May 1908 · page 2
Librarian dence to prove threats made against Mrs. Gunness by Lamphere. Lam phere’s setting the Are will next be shown. We expect to finish our evi dence by Saturday.”
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Officers are still searching for Mrs. Gunness's missing teeth, while a dentist declares a jawbone found in the ruins is human and matches her jaw. A Bertillion expert is brought in to verify Andrew Helgelin's identity amid conflicting tips accusing the hired man Maxson and others, and a surgeon's knife found at the farm is linked to her nursing background and the dismembered bodies.
The Lake County Times · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Seek Gunness Witness. La Porte, lud.—Attorney Worden, who is defending Ray Lamphere, now on trial for the murder ot' Mrs. Bella Gunness and her children, made pub lic Sunday night a letter which he declares was received Sunday by special delivery by his law partner, Mayor Lemuel Darrow. The writer, whose full name and address is with held by Mr. Worden, says that Mrs. Gunness is alive, and that he was the man who accompanied her to the Gunness farm on July 9th, the date on which D. M. Hutson and his daughters say they saw Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness and a man drive away in a buggy. Mr. Worden Sunday night said he had been trying all day to reach the writer by telephone in order to have him come to La Porte Monday to testify, but so far he had failed to find him. From present indications the case will go to the jury by Wednesday.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Various anonymous letter writers offer theories implicating the hired man Maxson or a LaPorte accomplice in the Gunness crimes. A surgeon's knife is found in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse, supporting theories that the victims were dismembered by someone skilled in its use, possibly Mrs. Gunness herself given her nursing background.
The Lake County Times · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 18. —That Ray Lamphere made numerous threats against Mrs. Belle Qunness was con clusively shown by a number of the state's witnesses Tuesday, and through them also Prosecutor Smith was able to bring out quite clearly the fact that a strong motive existed for the defend ant to annoy Mrs. Gunness, and that this annoyance terminated on the morning of April 28 In Lamphere's set ting fire to the house. The love affairs of Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere were also told in an in teresting manner by William Slater, and in his testimony the 'state found much of value to strengthen its posi tion that It waa beeause of the falling out between the two that Lamphere sought to harm his former sweetheart and mistress.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Diggers at the burned Gunness house found ten men's watches but only nine male bodies, suggesting an undiscovered victim. Sheriff Smutzer kept one watch separately for consultation with the prosecutor, while newly found jawbone fragments were being examined to help confirm whether the headless body was Belle Gunness.
The Lake County Times · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Peter Colson Testifies. Peter Colson testified that Mrs. Gun ness was at times unkind to Jennie Olson. The way in which he related his conversations with Lamphere, his own experiences with Mrs. Gunness, his love for the woman and his suspi cions was straightforward, his broken English adding to the effectiveness of the story. Louis Ruehl, a saloon-keeper, testi fied that Lamphere while in his place of business one night made the re mark that if “the old woman did not leave him alone he would send her over the road.” Lamphere also bor rowed two dollars on a watch which, It is claimed by the state, belonged once to one of Mrsk Gunness' victims.
See moreSee less
Leo Wade, a hack-driver, testified to seeing Lamphere wearing a big gray fur-lined overcoat. He also testified to seeing Mrs. Gunness wearing a man’s fur coat.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Investigators continue sifting fire debris, finding bone fragments, skin, and a ring later confirmed to belong to Belle Gunness. Witness testimony from Mrs. Greening describes Gunness's secrecy about her cellar, large sums of cash, and a suspicious reaction when joked about murder.
The Lake County Times · 15 May 1908 · page 5
MAY CLEAR MYSTERY
Maxson Tells His Story. Joseph Maxson, the far-famed hired man, described the premises and the Gunness family circle fully. He told of seeing Lampherc skulking around the premises at night and that he ran when discovered. He also testified to depredations committed by Lamphere on the place, such as cutting the wire fence, etc. Maxson told of Mrs. Gun ness going to Laporte on the after noon of April 27, and her return with a large supply of groceries, a dan of kerosene, etc. Maxson then told of being awakened iu the morning by the smoke, of the brick part being all aflame when he got up, of his efforts to break into the main part of the house and of the arrival of the lirst people ou the ground.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Searchers sifting the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse cellar uncovered human jaw bone fragments and a piece of scalp with hair, which prosecutors called the strongest evidence yet. Separately, authorities claimed to have traced Belle Gunness and her suspected accomplice to Warsaw, believing they fled by automobile after the fire.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 15 May 1908 · page 1
JAW BONES ARE FOUND.
DEFENDANT MADE THREATS State's Wltneaa Telia of Love Affairs of Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere Testimony of Other Witnesses. - , ' Laporte, Ind, Nov. 18. That Ray Lamphere made numerous threats agalnet Mrs, Belle Gunness was testi fied to by a number of the state's witnesses Tuesday, and through them also Prosecutor Smith made an effort to bring out that a strong motive ex lsted for the defendant to annoy Mrs. Ounness and that this annoyance ter minated on the night of April 18 in Lamphere setting fire to the house.
See moreSee less
The love affairs of Mrs. Ounness and Lamphere were also related by William Slater, and in his testimony the state claims it has found much of value to ' strengthen its position that it was because of the falling out between the two that Lamphere sought to harm Mrs. Gunness. With Joseph MaxBon. the man who escaped alive from the burning house, on the stand the first part of his story of the fire, was told Tuesday. It differs but little from the story which he told following the fire. Until Tuesday there had been nc demonstrations by the spectators and the outbreak when Witness Slater told of the relations between Lam. phere and Mrs. Gunness will probably not be repeated, for Judge Relchtet will order the court room cleared, it It happens again. Peter Colson testified that Mrs. Gun ness was at times unkind to .ennle Olson. The way In which he related his conversations with Lamphere, his own experiences with Mrs. Gunness, his love for the woman and bis sus picions, were unique and straightfor ward, his broken Engusn adding to the effectiveness of the story. Louis Ruebl, a saloonkeeper, testi fied that Lamphere while In his place of business one night made the romnrk that If "the old woman did not leave him alone he1 would send her over the road.", ' 1 Austin Cutler, a local undertaker, testified to the length of time the bodies of Mrs. Gunness and the chil dren were at his morgue before being shipped to Chicago. He said about 200 persons viewed them. The suppo sition Is that from this testimony Prosecutor Smith will lead up to doubt as to how the poison got into tne tnmaphl 1 .. . Leo Wade, a hack driver, testified to seeing Lamphere wearing a big gray fur-lined overcoat. He also tes tified to seeing Mrs. Gunness wearing a man's fur coat. The troubles of Lamphere and Mrs. Gunness, as shown by the records ot Justice Graver's court, were then of fered In evidence. The court records show that one trespass case, one surety of the peace action and proceedings to have Lamphere adjudged Insane, all
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A man named M. M. Lacey of Fountain City, calling himself a 'doctor of crime,' wrote to Sheriff Smutzer and Coroner Mack claiming he could locate and produce Mrs. Gunness alive for payment. The article notes that authorities have been flooded with similar letters and are giving them no serious consideration.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 15 May 1908 · page 8
M. M. La coy of Fountain City is among those who have written letters to Sheriff Smutzer of I-aporte, Coroner Mack and other officials offering to lo cate Mrs. Gunr.ess, the noted murder ess. Lacey states he is a "doctor of crime,-' and offers to produce Mrs. Gunness alive for a consideration of The mails have been crowded with such letters and the authorities are giving them no consideration.
A LaPorte dentist named Norton examined a jawbone recovered from the burned Gunness farm and stated it appeared human and bore strong resemblance to Mrs. Gunness's jaw, based on his prior dental work on her teeth. The identification was described as partial, not conclusive.
Rock Island Argus · 15 May 1908 · page 1
DENTIST BELIEVES IT IS MRS. GUNNESS' JAW
GUNNESS MTJKDEB CASE , Trial of Alleged Slayer of the Paiaily Opens at Laporte. The opening at Laporte. Ind. , of tht trial of R.'iy Laniphere for tlie murder of 'Mrs. ' Bt'lle Gunncss ami Iicr ithree children by burLiug them to death in the Ounncss "house of a hundred crimes" last April brougUi crowds of farmers and their families to attend the sessions of the famous case. While interest in the country at largo is centered in such further develop ments as the trial may bring out con cerning the amazing career of the wom an who is alleged to have slain eleven human beings , inhabitants of the terri tory immediately adjacent to that abode of horrors , "the Brookside Farm , * ' are intent on the establishment of guilt or innocence for Kay Lamphere , the ob-
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Coroner's physicians are expected to confirm that jawbones found at the Gunness farm belong to an adult human, which prosecutors say establishes the corpus delicti against Ray Lamphere. Sheriff Smutzer continues sifting through ashes and debris at the farm, hoping to find further evidence, while neither prosecution nor defense seems eager to rush the trial.
The Topeka State Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 1
TRIAL FAR AWAY.
GUNNESS MTJKDEB CASE , Trial of Alleged Slayer of the Paiaily Opens at Laporte. The opening at Laporte. Ind. , of tht trial of R.'iy Laniphere for tlie murder of 'Mrs. ' Bt'lle Gunncss ami Iicr ithree children by burLiug them to death in the Ounncss "house of a hundred crimes" last April brougUi crowds of farmers and their families to attend the sessions of the famous case. While interest in the country at largo is centered in such further develop ments as the trial may bring out con cerning the amazing career of the wom an who is alleged to have slain eleven human beings , inhabitants of the terri tory immediately adjacent to that abode of horrors , "the Brookside Farm , * ' are intent on the establishment of guilt or innocence for Kay Lamphere , the ob-
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The report describes prosecutors' hesitance to rush the Gunness case to trial due to unfavorable public opinion, suggesting a postponement until sentiment cools. It also recounts her early life in Norway, where she performed as a rope dancer with her father's traveling magic show.
The Topeka State Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 1
She Was a Rope Dancer
Mrs. Gunness is dead. The body found in the ruins of the farmhouse apparently was the same length as that of Mrs. Gunness , and later a gold plate , made
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Dr. I. P. Norton, the dentist who had worked on Mrs. Gunness's teeth, examined a jawbone found at the farm and declared it strongly resembled hers, ruling out an animal origin. He noted that gold he had placed on her cuspid teeth had not yet been found among the debris, which would make the identification complete.
The Topeka State Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 7
Laporte, Ind., May 15. "There is no question but that the piece of Jawbone found in the Gunness farm yesterday is from a human being. Futhermore it bears a strong resemblance to the low er Jaw or Mrs. Gunness. This positive statement of identiflca tion was made by Dr. I. P. Norton, the dentist, who performed a large amount of work on the teeth of the owner of the death farm, after he had examin ed the specimen brought to him by the coroner. "There is almost no chance that the bone came from the Jaw of an ani mal," he said.
See moreSee less
"There only remains to be discover ed some of the gold which I placed upon the -cuspid teeth to make the identification of this piece of bone post tive and complete. So far as I myself am concerned, I am certain as to the .origin of the bone now." Sheriff Smutaer also brought into Dr. Norton, a number - of new bits of metal found in the debris this morn ing. They proved, however, to be brass. Otherwise . the search at the farm was , iruitiess.
The report lists a timeline of suspicious deaths, disappearances, and insurance collections tied to Mrs. Belle Gunness, from her first husband's death through the farmhouse fire. It details the discovery of Andrew Helgelein's body, Jennie Olson's remains, and eight other unidentified victims buried near the house.
Tensas Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 3
LA PORTE MURDER MYSTERY
LAMPHEREI XORNEREDr Evidence Stron§ That He Caused Death of Fe cale Bluebeard He Is. Closely Conneiei WithNrs.6«e»es^ HelgeBne Deai Laporte, Ind., 'Nov. lS^^-Carefully working up to' the denouement?' tlie Vevidence by whidh lt is sought to show that Ray LMppbere s6t fire to the home of Mrs Belle Gunness and thereby caused the death of her and her three children, Prosecutor Smith today unravelled beforp the jurjr jtjie storiea Ot.*h^ flre ttjld bF the" j|^n who were 'earliest on the scene. The greatest Intereet naturally cen? tered sbout the testimony of Jos.
See moreSee less
Max -i son, the hired msaiv ^ut it varied in no great particular from the story he told to the court, and whieij he relate^ •before the coroner's jurjfc' ^'Indirectly wSlr, for the defense, on cfoes examination, tried to Imply^titsat Mrs. Gunness, on tite night of the fins had "doped", Maxson ia-.t^i^ oranges whid^ he ate, but 'M denied this, 1» lAooording to t®wr defense, Maxaoa Ifw^^-sister such a Story, buthe denied positively ntW stand that he had made such a declaration or-that lie ever believed that there was any1 "dope" In, the oranges, The explanation of the $10,000 story referred to in the letter .from Mrs. Gunness to A. K. Helgeline regarding the disappearance of his btotht'r, was made today. Lamphere. is under in dictment for the murder of Aridrew Helgeline and for alleged complicity with Mrs. Gunness in murder. vthat Sheriff Smutzer told on the stand of the circumstances whksh could have prevented Helgeline's presence in Laporte. He said that early in January Lamphere came to "him and said: "If I want to tell something, I can make it interesting for her." Sheriff Smutzer understood him to mean Gunness. Lamphere went on to tell the siheriff that Mrs. Gunness was looking for a man named Helgeline, who waa wanted In South. Dakota for murder, having held up a man in'a gambling house and had seized $10,* 000, but ha4-~been fprced to kill the fellow before.he could get away, Sheriff Smutzer Immediately ^rl'f^d the authorities in Aberdeen, the town named by Lamphere, and received in reply, a telegram that said that there had been no murder nor $10,000 rob bery and that Andrew Helgfellne was a well known former in that vicinity and that be was not wanted there for any crime. Sheriff Smutzer, with this disclos ure, paid nd attention 'to Lamphere. A month .later Lamphere, when ques tioned by the sheriff regarding Helge line, told the officer that Hielegeline had left Laporte for Chicago that •morning on the 5:10 train. Sheriff Smutzer also testifiedto See ing Lamphere watching Mrs. Gunness one day in the court house, when she came to. his office. She complained about Lamphere annoying" her and ^wjten the -'sheriff went to Lamphere and aslfed him why he did not leave the wjoma^ aloi^^e, did not ahswer.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Workers sifting the cellar ashes of the Gunness farm under Sheriff Smutzer's direction found pieces of human jaw bone, a scrap of skin with possible hair, and charred vertebrae. Prosecutors called these the most valuable evidence yet found, though doctors could not confirm whether the skin was human or animal.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 2
The La Porte, Ind., Murder Mystery.
HelgeBne Deai Laporte, Ind., 'Nov. lS^^-Carefully working up to' the denouement?' tlie Vevidence by whidh lt is sought to show that Ray LMppbere s6t fire to the home of Mrs Belle Gunness and thereby caused the death of her and her three children, Prosecutor Smith today unravelled beforp the jurjr jtjie storiea Ot.*h^ flre ttjld bF the" j|^n who were 'earliest on the scene. The greatest Intereet naturally cen? tered sbout the testimony of Jos. Max -i son, the hired msaiv ^ut it varied in no great particular from the story he told to the court, and whieij he relate^ •before the coroner's jurjfc' ^'Indirectly wSlr, for the defense, on cfoes examination, tried to Imply^titsat Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness, on tite night of the fins had "doped", Maxson ia-.t^i^ oranges whid^ he ate, but 'M denied this, 1» lAooording to t®wr defense, Maxaoa Ifw^^-sister such a Story, buthe denied positively ntW stand that he had made such a declaration or-that lie ever believed that there was any1 "dope" In, the oranges, The explanation of the $10,000 story referred to in the letter .from Mrs. Gunness to A. K. Helgeline regarding the disappearance of his btotht'r, was made today. Lamphere. is under in dictment for the murder of Aridrew Helgeline and for alleged complicity with Mrs. Gunness in murder. vthat Sheriff Smutzer told on the stand of the circumstances whksh could have prevented Helgeline's presence in Laporte. He said that early in January Lamphere came to "him and said: "If I want to tell something, I can make it interesting for her." Sheriff Smutzer understood him to mean Gunness. Lamphere went on to tell the siheriff that Mrs. Gunness was looking for a man named Helgeline, who waa wanted In South. Dakota for murder, having held up a man in'a gambling house and had seized $10,* 000, but ha4-~been fprced to kill the fellow before.he could get away, Sheriff Smutzer Immediately ^rl'f^d the authorities in Aberdeen, the town named by Lamphere, and received in reply, a telegram that said that there had been no murder nor $10,000 rob bery and that Andrew Helgfellne was a well known former in that vicinity and that be was not wanted there for any crime. Sheriff Smutzer, with this disclos ure, paid nd attention 'to Lamphere. A month .later Lamphere, when ques tioned by the sheriff regarding Helge line, told the officer that Hielegeline had left Laporte for Chicago that •morning on the 5:10 train. Sheriff Smutzer also testifiedto See ing Lamphere watching Mrs. Gunness one day in the court house, when she came to. his office. She complained about Lamphere annoying" her and ^wjten the -'sheriff went to Lamphere and aslfed him why he did not leave the wjoma^ aloi^^e, did not ahswer.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Doctors debate whether bone and hair fragments found in the fire debris are human or animal, with the coroner noting contamination from repeated searching of the ruins. Bertillon measurements of Andrew Helgelien were compared to an exhumed corpse and reportedly matched closely, while the sheriff plans to resume digging at the farm.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 2
?ji JLapoite, lnd., Nov. 19.—The chain of evidence which la gradually being drwan around Ray L&mphere for the murder of Mrs. Bell Gunness and her three children was somewhat tighten ed today by strengthening several of the points already Introduced, No tiew evidence except matters tending to ellnch points already made was In troduced. Other Evidence Carefully working up to the de nouement, the evidence by which It Is sought to show that Ray Lamphere Met flie to the home of Mra. Belle Gun ness and thereby caused the death of her and her three ohlldren, Prose cutor Smith today unraveled before the Jury the stories of the fire, told by the men who were earliest on the scene, The-greatest interest natural ly centered abdut the testimony, of Joseph Maxson, the hired man, but it varied In no great partloular from the story he told the coroner and which he related before the grand Jury, Indirectly, Attorney-.
See moreSee less
Weir for the defense, on cross examination, tried to Imply that Mra, Gunness on the night of the flre, had "doped" Maxson in the orange* which ha ate, but he denied this, According to the defense Maxson was alleged to have told his sister such a Ptory, but he denied poaltiveiT on the stand that he had ever made such a declaration or that heaver believed that there was any "dope" in the oranges, •Explanation of the $10,660 story re ferred to la the letter from Mrs, Qun to A, K, Helgetein, regarding the of hia br«thev, waa
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Investigators at the Gunness farm are examining metal globules found in mining operations to determine if they are dental gold from the woman's teeth. Authorities are also being overwhelmed with inquiries about missing persons as identification of remaining unmarked bodies remains unlikely.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 2
MANY INQUIRIES
?ji JLapoite, lnd., Nov. 19.—The chain of evidence which la gradually being drwan around Ray L&mphere for the murder of Mrs. Bell Gunness and her three children was somewhat tighten ed today by strengthening several of the points already Introduced, No tiew evidence except matters tending to ellnch points already made was In troduced. Other Evidence Carefully working up to the de nouement, the evidence by which It Is sought to show that Ray Lamphere Met flie to the home of Mra. Belle Gun ness and thereby caused the death of her and her three ohlldren, Prose cutor Smith today unraveled before the Jury the stories of the fire, told by the men who were earliest on the scene, The-greatest interest natural ly centered abdut the testimony, of Joseph Maxson, the hired man, but it varied In no great partloular from the story he told the coroner and which he related before the grand Jury, Indirectly, Attorney-.
See moreSee less
Weir for the defense, on cross examination, tried to Imply that Mra, Gunness on the night of the flre, had "doped" Maxson in the orange* which ha ate, but he denied this, According to the defense Maxson was alleged to have told his sister such a Ptory, but he denied poaltiveiT on the stand that he had ever made such a declaration or that heaver believed that there was any "dope" in the oranges, •Explanation of the $10,660 story re ferred to la the letter from Mrs, Qun to A, K, Helgetein, regarding the of hia br«thev, waa
Clipping to come
The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich.
The report states that despite the gruesome discovery of ten bodies buried on the Gunness farm, no further remains were found over the weekend, surprising the townspeople of Laporte. It suggests mounting evidence, including a possible Chicago accomplice, that the murderess may still be alive and the burned body found may not be hers.
The Yale Expositor · 15 May 1908 · page 2
THE LAPORTE EVIDENCE POINTS TO THE VIEW THAT THE GUNNESS FIEND IS ALIVE.
LAMPHEBE MURDER CASE By Associated Press La Porte, Ind., Nov. 19 Sheriff Smittzer was on the witness stand nearly all morn ing in the trial of Ray Lamphere and told of finding ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness grave yard and of sifting the ashes from the ruins, resulting in the finding of watches, jewelry, bracelet, etc. On cross examination it was brought out that Mrs. Gunness had visited the sheriff's office three times with reference to the fact that Lamphere was annoying her.
Clipping to come
The Yale Expositor · Yale, Mich.
The report explores evidence suggesting Belle Gunness staged her death and fled with help from a female accomplice in Chicago who lured victims. Coroner Mack has officially changed the death record to list an unidentified woman instead of Gunness, while Helgelein vows to pursue her and Lamphere to justice.
The Yale Expositor · 15 May 1908 · page 2
LAMPHEBE MURDER CASE By Associated Press La Porte, Ind., Nov. 19 Sheriff Smittzer was on the witness stand nearly all morn ing in the trial of Ray Lamphere and told of finding ten bodies in Mrs. Gunness grave yard and of sifting the ashes from the ruins, resulting in the finding of watches, jewelry, bracelet, etc. On cross examination it was brought out that Mrs. Gunness had visited the sheriff's office three times with reference to the fact that Lamphere was annoying her.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
The report claims Mrs. Gunness received a telegram warning from a male accomplice on the day her house burned, and that this 'death agent' who lured victims has now been located in Warsaw, Indiana. It speculates she staged her own death using a headless body and fled, possibly planning to escape to Europe with her accumulated money.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 15 May 1908 · page 1
*l(jmember the Forgotten Man. MRS.GUNNESS WAS WARNED BY WIRE TOJLEE CONFEDERATE SAID TO HAVE BEEN LOCATED IN WARSAW, IND—BELIEF SPREADB THAT THE WOMAN IS HIDING. LA PORTE, Ind, May 15.—0n the day her house was burned, Mrs. Gunness received a tele gram of warning from an accom plice. It Is believed that this con federate—a man—fearful perhaps, that the woman mignt be arrested and make a confession of the workings of the whole horrible “murder syndicate/' hurried to La Porte early in the night In an auto. The poljce say the plan of flight was formulated by Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness. She may easily have reconciled herself to the sacrifice of her chil dren since they were merely ac cessories to her game of murder if they were only adopted. It is believed she induced Lamphere to set fire to the house after the body of a headless woman had been placed so as to convey the impression that Mrs. Gunness her •elf had perished in the flames. Then she fled. LA PORTE. Ind.. May 15.—The “death agent" employed by Mrs. Belle Gunness to lure victims to her farm, has been located In Warsaw, Ind., and his arrsst is expected today. The capture of this man is ex pected to put into the hands of the authorites the real story of the murder syndicate whose opera tions filled Brookside Farm with the bodies of a score of victims. It is further hoped to discover by this means the present hiding place of the arch-murderess if, as is now generally believed, she ! Is in concealment waiting for a (chance to escape to Europe with the money she must have accum ! ulated by means of her crimes. it is now considered certain that • the “death agent,” is the man who escaped with Mrs Gunness In the mad auto race toward Chi cago from the scene of the crimes. An auto carrying a man and a woman who answers the description of the arch-murderess, was seen speed ing through Hobart on the morning after the Are. Deputy Sheriff Gill de clared the machine was running at a tearful rate of speed and that It came Into Hobart from the dtrectlon of La Pcrte. There Is little doubt now In the minds of the citizens of La Porte that Mrs. Gunness, the slayer of perhaps q score or more of men and children whose bedy was supposed to have been found on her “murder farm.” escaped, and there is little thought that the three children who perished In the flames were not her own, but were adpoted by her as a part of her cunning scheme to make herself ap pear a respectable, well-to-do widow who would make a desirable wife. All La Porte Is Inclined to believe that this man with whom she fled is one of her mysterious conspirators, or confederates.
The article claims Mrs. Gunness staged her death using a headless adopted body and escaped by automobile with a 'death agent' accomplice who lured victims to the farm. It reports this accomplice has been traced to Warsaw, Indiana, and connects wife-deserter Ray Lamphere to the case, suggesting he may have set the fire at her instruction.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Detroit Times · 15 May 1908 · page 1
THE WOMAN IS HIDING.
Lamphere, Wife-Deserter. WILKES BARRE, Pa., May 15Ray Lamphere, the alleged murderer of Mrs. Belle Gunness. of The death farm at l.a Porte. Ind.. has a crim inal record and a deserted wife at Sayre, near here. lamphere is well known to many of the residents of Sayre, particularly to teamsters. He worked around blacksmith shops of Sayre and Towanda as a horseshoer. In the latter part of 1900 he was ar rested on a charge of breaking Into freight cars ou the I>*bigh Valley railroad, and was taken to Towanda for trial.
See moreSee less
There he was convicted and served a sentence for the crime. After his release from prison be returned to Sayre, but remained there only a short time when he deserted his wife and left, presumably for the west. Nothing more was heard of him until his arrest for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three chil dren. * CHRISTIANIA, Norway, May 15 Mrs. Belle Gunness, the central figure in the La Porte, Ind, murder mystery, details of which have been received here, Is remembered In Christiania as u girl, assisting her father, Petters Paulsen, a traveling conjurer and magician who gave performances at all the fairs In Norway. She performed as a dancer and often was seen In skirts and fleshings, half freezing before the tent, extend ing on Invitation to the public to step inside. Her three sisters and brother, also took part In the show. The fa ther made enough money eventually to retire to a small property near Trondhjem. Mrs. Gunness has many relatives In Norway.
Ray Lamphere, accused in the Gunness murders, is identified as having a criminal record and a deserted wife in Sayre, Pennsylvania, where he once worked as a horseshoer. A separate dispatch from Christiania, Norway describes Belle Gunness's early life as the daughter of a traveling magician.
The Detroit Times · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Lamphere, Wife-Deserter. WILKES BARRE, Pa., May 15Ray Lamphere, the alleged murderer of Mrs. Belle Gunness. of The death farm at l.a Porte. Ind.. has a crim inal record and a deserted wife at Sayre, near here. lamphere is well known to many of the residents of Sayre, particularly to teamsters. He worked around blacksmith shops of Sayre and Towanda as a horseshoer. In the latter part of 1900 he was ar rested on a charge of breaking Into freight cars ou the I>*bigh Valley railroad, and was taken to Towanda for trial.
See moreSee less
There he was convicted and served a sentence for the crime. After his release from prison be returned to Sayre, but remained there only a short time when he deserted his wife and left, presumably for the west. Nothing more was heard of him until his arrest for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three chil dren. *
Four more bodies were dug up at Mrs. Gunness's farm near Laporte, Indiana, bringing the total to ten, with evidence suggesting victims were shipped to her in trunks and boxes. One body was identified as Ole B. Budsberg, lured by a matrimonial advertisement, while new witnesses and evidence implicated Ray Lamphere.
The Ely Miner · 15 May 1908 · page 2
Four more bodies were aug up in the barnyard of Mrs. Guinness* farm, near Laporte, Ind., making nine found so far. The mystery of the “death house” is growing deeper, though there is evidence that the bodies were shipped to Mrs. Guin ness, probably from Chicago, in trunks and boxes which draymen tell of carting to her house. Another of the bodies dug up on the farm of Mrs. Guinness near La porte, Ind., was identified as that of Ole B. Budsberg of lola, Wis., whom the woman lured there by a matri monial advertisement.
See moreSee less
New witnesses against Roy Lamphere were found. Another body was dug up on Mrs. Guinness’ farm near Laporte, Ind., making ten found. More incriminat ing evidence against Ray Lamphere was obtained. Fully 15,000 morbid sightseers from Laporte and many other towns spent Sunday picnicing on the Gun ness farm. There were not enough vehicles in Laporte to carry them all.
Danish-American newspaper reports that the woman found dead in the farmhouse fire is not Belle Gunness herself, but likely one of her murder victims, decapitated to disguise the crime. It states that Gunness has fled and is being hunted nationwide, with at least 11 victims uncovered so far, mostly men lured by marriage advertisements for money.
St. Paul Tidende · 15 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A gold-crowned molar believed to be from Belle Gunness's skull was found in the cellar debris as Sheriff Smutzer prepared to sluice the ashes. A previously suppressed autopsy report also revealed three rings on the corpse bearing puzzling inscriptions with initials not matching known Gunness family members.
The Worthington Advance · 15 May 1908 · page 8
NOW BELIEVE WOMAN DEAD
Bella Gunness. The tooth was found in the debris the cellar while Sheriff Smutzer flru continuing his preparations to ftegin the sluicing of the ashes. The relic is a hollow molar, with a gold irown, the metal being indented and |o some extent encrusted by cinders, the tooth, however, bears every evi nce of having come from the incin erated skull of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Unexplainable evidence, hitherto luppressed, has been made public in the Gunness tragedy. It is contained the report of Dr. J. L. Gray, who performed the autopsy on the body vhich the authorities have steadfastly ilaimed is that of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bella Gunness. Dr. Gray, in his report, tells of three rings which were found upon the fcorpse and also reveals the fact that the right hand, hitherto declared miss aag, is still in existence. The rings, which might be expected to reveal the identity of the wearer, ttnly add to the mystery of the case. Two of them contain inscriptions, one
A newly opened grave at the Gunness farm yielded a tenth set of remains, initially thought to include two bodies but later determined to be one poorly preserved corpse. Items found with the remains, including women's shoes and a purse frame, suggested the victim was female.
The Worthington Advance · 15 May 1908 · page 9
HIS DEATH WELL TIMED. Mrs. Gunness' First'Husband Expired Day Before Insurance Lapsed. Chicago, May 8.—A sinister fact in connection with the death of Mads Sorenson, the first husband of Mrs.
A physician who performed the autopsy states that the badly burned female body found in the Gunness farmhouse ruins cannot be that of Belle Gunness, citing mismatched weight, height, and manicured fingernails inconsistent with her known appearance. He details Mrs. Gunness's large, powerful build and distinctive features to argue the corpse belongs to someone else entirely.
Little Falls Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 7
Remains at Ten. Laporte, Ind., May 9.—Dr. H. BL boas, one of the physicians who per formed the. autopsy on the body of the Woman found In the ruins of the Gun MM home after the fire, has made a •tatemeat that the body Is not. that •f Mrs. Ghinneas. His statement is as lollowa: "In my opinion the body of the wo found in the house is not that of Mrs. Qunness because it is not cor rectly proportioned. It is that of a rather plump woman of the same gen eral oontour of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Qunness, but weighing between 159 and 160 pounds. Mrs. Gunness was literally a succes sion of billows of flesh and weighed fully 225 pounds. "The arm that was burned oft was found beside the body and is well formed. The fingers show evidence at eareful manicuring and that was ppgpethlng that Mrs. Gunness knew nothing about. "Rafting my statements on the sta Mitfcs and figures of eminent physi cians of ihis country and Great Brit ain I find that the body at the morgue almost five lnohes shorter than the Mf of Mrs. Gunness would be under limllar oiroumftances. The fire would. eourse. cause the body to lose 4t weight, bat the general*physical out-
A physical description expert argues the burned corpse found in the ruins does not match Belle Gunness's known build, noting discrepancies in height, hands, and general appearance. The report also notes a tenth body has been recovered from the farm, though the latest find was badly preserved and tentatively identified as female by shoes and purse remains found with it.
The report reveals that Mads Sorenson's death was suspiciously timed to allow his widow, Mrs. Gunness, to collect on two insurance policies totaling $5,000. It also reprints the matrimonial advertisement she used to lure victims to her Indiana farm.
Little Falls Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 7
TO LURE HER VICTIMS.
Day Before Insurance Lapsed. Chicago, May 8.—A sinister fact in connection with the death of Mads Sorenson, the first husband of Mrs. Gunness, was revealed when it be came known that he died just one day before an insurance policy which he had been carrying for some years would have expired and two days after a second policy which he intend ed to substitute for the first became Operative. Sorenson had for some years car ried Insurance for $2,000 in a fraternal OManlsatton known as the Independ ent Order of Mutual Aid, but, deter mining to drop this, he had taken out another for $3,000 in the North Amer ican Vnion. His death was So timed that the widow collected both policies.
The report lists known and suspected victims of Belle Gunness, including Andrew Helgelein, her adopted daughter, and several unidentified bodies found on her farm. It also raises suspicion that the bodies found in the fire ruins may have been brought from a hospital to fake her death, and notes the arrest of former servant Ray Lamphere as a suspect.
Dakota Farmers' Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 3
WOMAN CALLED A BLUEBEARD
Ll«t of Knovpu Victims. Helgelein, Andrew, 40 years old bach elor, Aberdeen, S. D. suitor for Mrs. •Gunness' hand, who came to Laporte in -January and disappeared one month later after loaning the woman $1,500 body dug up to-day. Gunness, Jennie Olson, 16 years old, adopted daughter of Mrs. Gunness disap peared in September, 1906, ostensibly to attend school at Los Angeles body dug up to-day. Unidentified man, believed by Sheriff 1 Smnizer to have been an admirer of the 1 -woman. Unidentified boy, apparently S years old mutilated body in gunnysack.
See moreSee less
Unidentified girl, about 7 years old mutilated body in gunnysack. Gunness, Joseph, husband of Sirs. Gun aess, whose death at Laporte four years I ago had always remained a mystery. Sorenson, Mads, woman's first hus hand, who died under mysterious circum stances in Chicago eight years ago. Gunness, Mrs. Bella, believed to have been burned to -death in fire whicjh de atroyed her home. Sorenson, Myrtle, 11 years old, eldest daughter of Mrs. Gunness thought to have perished in the fire. if Sorenson, Lucy,-, 9 years old, another daughter 'also believed to have been a victim of the fire. Gunness, Philip, 5 years old, youngest child said to have Keen killed in the fire. Lindblom. Olaf, 35 years old. of Wis consin employed by Mrs. Gunness on the farm. When he disappeared Mrs. Gun ness gave it out that he had gone to Norway. Gerbalt, Eric, 40 years old, of Wiscon ain worked five months for Mrs. Gun ness, then he disappeared. Man from Ohio. 50 years old, name not learned worked the farm and owned a horse' and buggy. Disappeared and Mrs. Gunness fell heir to the horse and In the arrest of Ttay Y^ninnhere, a former servant of the woman, Sheriff Smulzer believes, some light may be thrown upon the circumstances sur rounding the deaths of at /least some •af the victims. Lamphere1 before the fire had trouble iwith Mrs. Gunness. lie had declared •bout town she was trying to "get rid" of him because he knew too much. He has told several conflicting stories concerning his relations with the wom an and his presence in tho neighbor hood of the Gunness home the night It burned.
Investigators in Laporte, Indiana discovered an eighth body in the yard of the Gunness farm, with Coroner Mack predicting many more graves would be found. Authorities now believed Belle Gunness substituted a corpse in the fire that destroyed her house and children, escaping with a possible accomplice.
The Montgomery Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 6
MORE GRAVES IN CRIME PLOT
> Four children perished in a fire that t destroyed the country home of John r SS T Wampfler near Alliance O The jury in the Lamphere murder I case at Laporte Ind was completed S the states attorney made his open I Ing s atE 11cnt and the introducing of 0 evidence was begun George S Terry of New York has T been appointed assistant treasurer of the United States to succeed Hamilton S 4 Fish i S The Illinois state board of equaliza S S tion fixed the total assessed valuation S of properly In the state at 1263 5 S 5151 5fi against 1251974306 in 1907
Clipping to come
Hattiesburg Daily News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
A skull discovered in the burned ruins of Belle Gunness's home is believed by police to be part of her body, though physicians disagree on whether it is male or female. A grand jury is expected to indict Ray Lamphere this week, with trial set to begin Monday.
Hattiesburg Daily News · 15 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Sheriff Butler of La Porte, acting on a tip from John Heldgren of Aberdeen, exhumed the dismembered body of Andrew Heldgren and a woman believed to be Jennie Olsen from the grounds of Belle Gunness's burned farmhouse. The report also notes suspect Ray Lamphere is under arrest and suspected of involvement in the Heldgren murder as well.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 15 May 1908 · page 2
Horrible Crime Brought to Light
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
This report describes the discovery of a seventh dismembered body on the Gunness farm and details suspicions that Andrew Heldgren was murdered after lending Belle Gunness money. It also recounts Gunness's background, her two husbands' suspicious deaths, and speculation about Chicago accomplices and her possible survival.
Paper unidentified · 15 May 1908 · page 2
GUNNESS MTTBDER CASE. Trial of Alleged Slayer of the Fam ily Opens at Laporte. The opening at Laporte, Ind., of the trial of Itay Lainphere for the murder of 'Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by burning them to death in the Gunness "house of a hundred crimes" last April brought crowds of farmers and their fumilies to attend the sessions of the famous case. While interest in the country at large Is centered in such further develop ments as the trial may bring out con cerning the amazing career of the wom an who is alleged to have slain eleven human beings, inhabitants of the terri tory immediately adjacent to that abode of horrors, "the Brookside Farm," are intent on the establishment of guilt or innocence for Itiiy Liiniphere, the ob scure farm hand arouiul whose ppi*son ality has IXHM built an extraordinary structure of bitterness that involves the whole of Laporte County.
See moreSee less
As a result of the local feeling and of the wide spread publicity given the case, 600 people had gathered near the court house before the doors were open for the lirst session. After the first week of excitement attending the discoveries of the fifteen bodies on Mrs. Gunness' farm, where it is believed twenty-five were murdered, attention turned to the mistress of the place and the various theories concern ing her death or escape became the sol* topic of discussion. Nine persons out of ten decided that she is alive, and to this day the major ity of residents think she escaped after setting fire to her home and killing her children. So it remained for the State's Attorney to pick only jurors who be lieve her dead, or it would be Iinpoe slhle to convict anyone for her murder. The most natural conclusion is that Mrs. GunnesB is dead. The body found in the ruins of the farmhouse apparent-
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Metal globules found in the ruins of the Gunness farm are being tested to determine if they are gold dental fillings, which could help identify victims. Authorities are also overwhelmed with inquiries about missing persons and suspect Lamphere may have engaged in blackmail.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 1
BELIEVE ASHES WILL SHOW GOLD GLOBULES OF METAL FOUND IN DEBRIS OF GUNNESS FARM
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 13.—The intro duction of evidence in the trial of Ray Lamphere, for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the house, has begun a jury having been secured late this afternoon.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Authorities remain overwhelmed with inquiries about missing persons, though most unidentified remains are too deteriorated for identification. Lamphere's defense team seeks witness David Havens, who allegedly claimed the bodies showed no debris beneath them, suggesting they were placed before the fire—a claim contradicted by the sheriff and physicians who found evidence of nightclothes and bedding among the remains.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 1
PROBLEMS UNSOLVED
Iamphere set fire to the home of iMrs. Belle Gunness and thereby sup posedly caused the death of .Mrs. Gun *pess and her three children, Prosecu or Smith in the trial of Lamphere 'today unraveled before the jury stories '.f the fire, told by men who were first .on the scene. The greatest inter est naturally centered about the testi mony of Joseph Maxson, Mrs. Gun ness' hired man, who escaped from the burning Gunness home, Indirectly Attorney Weir, for the de tense on cross examination, tried to imrply that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness on the night of the fire had "doped" Maison' in the oranges which he ate, but he denied this. Explanation of the $10,000 story referred, to in the letter from Mrs. "Gunness to A. K. Helgelein, regarding the disappearance of his brother, was mAde today. Sheriff Smutzer told of the circum stances connected with the Andrew Helgelein's presence in Laporte. He Said that early in January, Lamphere came to him and said: "If I want to tell something I cah Silake it interesting for her.' Sheriff Smutzer understood him' to mean Mrs. Gunness. Lamphere went to tell the sheriff that Mrs. Gunness was then looking for a man named Helgelein, who was wanted. in South Dakota for murder, having held up a man in a gambling house and secdred $10,000, but had been forced to kill the fellow before he could get away. Sheriff Smutzer immediately wired to the authorities in Aberdeen and re ceived ih reply a telegram which said that there had been no murder, no $10;000 robbery, that Andrew Helgel ein was a well known farmer in that vicinity and that he was not wanted there for any crime. A month later Lamphere, when questioned by Sheriff Smutzer regarding Helgelein, told the officer that Helgelein,had left Laporte for' Chicago that morning on the 6:10 train. Sheriff 'Smutzer said he was notified of the fire about 5 o'clock on the morn ing of April' 28, and told of going there immediately. He told of taking charge of the bodies and of keeping a gang of men at work all day and of finding the bodies in the northeast corner, where the fire had been the hottest all day and where the greatest amount of debris w"s found. The finding of Hel gelein's dismembered body was also described' by the witness.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Attorneys for a suspect argue trial testimony will show the bodies were placed in the cellar before the fire, but physicians' findings of night robes and bedding contradict this theory. The state also claims a witness will testify that Mrs. Gunness paid Lamphere $300, supporting a blackmail theory, while crank letters flood investigators.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Iamphere set fire to the home of iMrs. Belle Gunness and thereby sup posedly caused the death of .Mrs. Gun *pess and her three children, Prosecu or Smith in the trial of Lamphere 'today unraveled before the jury stories '.f the fire, told by men who were first .on the scene. The greatest inter est naturally centered about the testi mony of Joseph Maxson, Mrs. Gun ness' hired man, who escaped from the burning Gunness home, Indirectly Attorney Weir, for the de tense on cross examination, tried to imrply that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness on the night of the fire had "doped" Maison' in the oranges which he ate, but he denied this. Explanation of the $10,000 story referred, to in the letter from Mrs. "Gunness to A. K. Helgelein, regarding the disappearance of his brother, was mAde today. Sheriff Smutzer told of the circum stances connected with the Andrew Helgelein's presence in Laporte. He Said that early in January, Lamphere came to him and said: "If I want to tell something I cah Silake it interesting for her.' Sheriff Smutzer understood him' to mean Mrs. Gunness. Lamphere went to tell the sheriff that Mrs. Gunness was then looking for a man named Helgelein, who was wanted. in South Dakota for murder, having held up a man in a gambling house and secdred $10,000, but had been forced to kill the fellow before he could get away. Sheriff Smutzer immediately wired to the authorities in Aberdeen and re ceived ih reply a telegram which said that there had been no murder, no $10;000 robbery, that Andrew Helgel ein was a well known farmer in that vicinity and that he was not wanted there for any crime. A month later Lamphere, when questioned by Sheriff Smutzer regarding Helgelein, told the officer that Helgelein,had left Laporte for' Chicago that morning on the 6:10 train. Sheriff 'Smutzer said he was notified of the fire about 5 o'clock on the morn ing of April' 28, and told of going there immediately. He told of taking charge of the bodies and of keeping a gang of men at work all day and of finding the bodies in the northeast corner, where the fire had been the hottest all day and where the greatest amount of debris w"s found. The finding of Hel gelein's dismembered body was also described' by the witness.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Laporte officials deny reports that Rev. Dr. Schell revealed details of a Lamphere confession, while evidence suggests Belle Gunness had an accomplice luring victims. Lamphere's attorney states his client has made no confession and has nothing to confess, as prosecutors reconsider rushing the case to trial due to a weak state case.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 3
LAMPHERE DID NOT CONFESS LAPORTE OFFICIALS SAY THEY KNOW NOTHING OF IT.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Authorities report exhausting major leads and now seek corroborating details linking victims John Moo, Henry Gerholt, and George Brady to the Gunness farm through bank transactions. Local banks agree to provide transaction records to help trace men who visited the farm and vanished, while the prosecutor acknowledges the state's case against Lamphere needs strengthening before trial.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 3
NO NEW SENSATIONS
The Lamphere Trial Laporte Ind Nov 18 That Hay Lamphero made numerous threats against Mrs Dello Gunness was tho testimony of a number of the states witnesses Tuesday In tho trial of Lamphere for the murder of Mrs Gunness Tho love affairs of Mrs Gunness and Lamphere were told by
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
Authorities enlist Laporte banks to compile records of transactions linked to Mrs. Gunness, hoping to trace missing men like Brady, Budsberg, and Helgelein who vanished after cashing checks. A watch found in the ruins is identified as Ole Budsberg's, and another taken from Lamphere is believed to have belonged to Andrew Helgelein, while a mail carrier reveals Gunness used multiple aliases in her matrimonial correspondence.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 3
The Lamphere Trial Laporte Ind Nov 18 That Hay Lamphero made numerous threats against Mrs Dello Gunness was tho testimony of a number of the states witnesses Tuesday In tho trial of Lamphere for the murder of Mrs Gunness Tho love affairs of Mrs Gunness and Lamphere were told by
Clipping to come
The Billings Gazette · Billings, Mont.
This is a satirical 'state press comment' column mixing jokes about local politics, weather, and current events with references to the Gunness case, including a joke that fleshy women with gold teeth should prove their identity until Mrs. Gunness is found dead or captured. It treats the case as ongoing news fodder for humor rather than factual reporting.
The Billings Gazette · 15 May 1908 · page 4
,t ' ness Killing Helgelein. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 20 Tho State today rested Its enso against Itay Lamrheiu, accused of tho murder f Mis. Belle Chimin's ami nor child ren. 'Attorney Wonlon outlined the dcfer.so nnd said ho expected to provo Mrs. launness was nllvo mil had been scon near hor old home months nftor tho flro. i Wonlon Intimated thnt tho body pr tho woman found In tho mint UUIU10S6. was that of n woman iwho visited Mrs. (iunneps a week beforo tho lire tihd that tho dofimBO would show that 'Mrs;-dimness had a motlvo tor killing her children ami disappear' ' ing.
See moreSee less
"' 'lMie -defenso clnlnu that tho fire 1 broke' out 1G minntoa (hoton; 'Lamp here left' lht' Houso of Kllzabst1) HirtlUii 'a negros, ilivl thoroforo ho could" -not -linYo Uml Ww bltlldln; which fbt a inllo from the negress' hft nonle,
Clipping to come
The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb.
Coroner Mack revises his count of remains at the Gunness farm, clarifying that bones once thought to belong to a second body are actually part of the first. Investigators also reveal letters from Belle Gunness found in Ray Lamphere's trunk, along with women's rings, and note a new witness has come forward.
The Red Cloud Chief · 15 May 1908 · page 7
ANOTHER VICTIM ADDED TO GUNNESS FARM DEATH ROLL
,t ' ness Killing Helgelein. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 20 Tho State today rested Its enso against Itay Lamrheiu, accused of tho murder f Mis. Belle Chimin's ami nor child ren. 'Attorney Wonlon outlined the dcfer.so nnd said ho expected to provo Mrs. launness was nllvo mil had been scon near hor old home months nftor tho flro. i Wonlon Intimated thnt tho body pr tho woman found In tho mint UUIU10S6. was that of n woman iwho visited Mrs. (iunneps a week beforo tho lire tihd that tho dofimBO would show that 'Mrs;-dimness had a motlvo tor killing her children ami disappear' ' ing.
See moreSee less
"' 'lMie -defenso clnlnu that tho fire 1 broke' out 1G minntoa (hoton; 'Lamp here left' lht' Houso of Kllzabst1) HirtlUii 'a negros, ilivl thoroforo ho could" -not -linYo Uml Ww bltlldln; which fbt a inllo from the negress' hft nonle,
Clipping to come
The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb.
Investigators uncovered letters from Belle Gunness to Ray Lamphere, found among items at the Wheatbrook farm, along with women's rings, while new witnesses suggested a possible motive and accomplices. Excavation at the Gunness farm continued amid large crowds, with coroner Mack's premature report of two more bodies fueling public curiosity.
The Red Cloud Chief · 15 May 1908 · page 7
GUNNESS FARM DEATH ROLL
Woman Who Lured Him to Her Home. Laporte, Iud., Nov. 18. Kay Lainphere, the farmhand accused of mur dering Mrs. Belle Guliness and her three children by setting lire to their home, wept In court when the spec tators, Indignant ut the revelntlons made by witnesses for the prosecu tion, shouted out angry threats against him. Several witnesses testified that Laraphere made numerous threats ngalnst Mrs. Belle Gunuess. Through these witnesses Trosecutor Smith tried to prove that a strong motive existed for Liunphere to nunoy Mrs. Gunness and that this alleged annoyance terminat ed on the morning of April 28 In Lain phere setting tire to the Gunuess house and burning the murderess and her children.
See moreSee less
The love affairs of Mrs. Gunuess and Lampherc were told by William Sla ter, and his testimony tended to veri fy the state's contention thnt it wns because of the falling out between the two that Lamphere sought to harm his former sweetheart and mistress. The relations between Lamphere and Mrs. Gunuess as described by Slater caused a demonstration in the crowd ed courtroom, which was packed to suffocation, while hundreds hung around the outside unable to gain ad' mittance. Peter Colson said he left the em ployment of Mrs. Gunness because he had been infatuated with her, but later he became suspicious, and, fear ing her, he concluded to get away. He said he had been suspicious of the woman since the death of her hus band, retei Gi.7ir.es3. He said Lain phere had threatened to get even with Mrs. Gunness, who had turned Lam phere down for Helgelein. The troubles of Lamphere and Mrs, Gunness, as shown by the records of Justice Grover's court, were offered In evidence. The court records show ed one trespass case, one surety of the peace action and proceedings to have Lamphere adjudged Insane, all insti gated by Mrs. Gunness. Joseph Mnxson, a hired man, who escaped alive from the burning Gun ness home, described the premises and the Gunness family circle fully. He told of seeing Lamphere skulking around the premises at night and said that Lamphere ran when discovered.
Clipping to come
The Red Cloud Chief · Red Cloud, Neb.
Excavation at the Gunness farm uncovers a tenth decomposed body, found under similar conditions to previous discoveries. Meanwhile, Prosecutor Smith gathers evidence suggesting Lamphere tried to extort money from Belle Gunness using knowledge of Helgelein's death, and that he set the fatal fire out of revenge, not intending to kill her or the children.
The Red Cloud Chief · 15 May 1908 · page 7
In the trial at La Porte, Ind., of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, wit nesses positively identified the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness house as that of Mrs. Gunness. Two rings found on the fingers of the deal body were declared to have belonged to Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
Dakota County Herald · Dakota City, Neb.
Jacob Pouch, a 70-year-old man from Warsaw, Indiana, became temporarily deranged after reading newspaper accounts of the Gunness murders. He committed suicide on Monday as a result.
Dakota County Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 1
In the trial at La Porte, Ind., of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, wit nesses positively identified the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness house as that of Mrs. Gunness. Two rings found on the fingers of the deal body were declared to have belonged to Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
Dakota County Herald · Dakota City, Neb.
Laporte's mayor vows to push the Gunness murder investigation more vigorously, predicting more tragedies will be uncovered. Thousands of curious sightseers have overrun the farm and gawked at graves and skeletal remains, while authorities examine letters sent to Belle Gunness before the fire.
Dakota County Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 8
MURDER FARM IS A MAGNET.
In the trial at La Porte, Ind., of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Guimess and her three children, wit nesses positively identified the female body found in the ruins of the Gunness, house as that of Mrs. Gunness. Two rings found on the fingers of the dead body were declared to have belonged to Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
Dakota County Herald · Dakota City, Neb.
Photos show the Gunness farm at Laporte where bodies were found and the barn used as a morgue, which was broken into by two men claiming to be doctors. A woman named Bessie Wallace, who knows suspect Ray Lamphere, is expected to be an important witness in the case.
Dakota County Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 8
WOMAN WITNESS AND OFFICIALS.
Ind., Gats In Considerable Evidence. Laporte. Ind.. Nov. 20.—Excellent progress was mudii by the defence in the amount of testimony placed before the Jury today in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Rclle Gunness and her three children; but aside from two witnesses to show that the Are at the Gunness house occurred at 3 o'clock in the morning of April 28 no statement advanced by Attorney Worden in his opening statement was followed up. Court will be held to morrow, the expectation being that Dr. Walter Haines of Chicago, the de fence's main witness, will he here to testify that he found poison in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and three of the four bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness home.
See moreSee less
Dr. George Wasser, who was called as an expert, was shown the teeth and bridge work introduced by the state and identified by state witnesses as having come from the mouth of Mrs. Belle Gunness. He doubted whether a gold crown in the exhibit ever was made to fit the teeth stubs to which It was said by the state to have been attached. The defence tried to show that Mrs. Gunness might have removed the bridge work from her mouth and plac ed It In the fire to lend the impression ! that she was burned to death. Dr. Wasser said the crowns could have I been removed intact without burning UBS. MART MEYER. 8. MARY MEYER, Thomson Avenue, near Shell Road, Win field, L. 1., N. Y., writes: “I have been annoyed with a cough for years. Often it was so bad that I could not sleep half the night. Many people thought I had consumption. Consumption “A woman recom Was Feared.
Clipping to come
The Nebraska Advertiser · Nemaha City, Neb.
Investigators unearthed two additional bodies on the farm of Mrs. Gunness near La Porte, Indiana. This brings the total number of bodies discovered there to eleven.
The Nebraska Advertiser · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Nebraska Advertiser · Nemaha City, Neb.
Four additional bodies of murdered people were discovered on Mrs. Gunness's farm near La Porte, Indiana, bringing the total to nine unearthed so far. Authorities believe most corpses were shipped from Chicago to conceal crimes committed there, and the search for more bodies continues.
The Nebraska Advertiser · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
LaPorte officials, including the sheriff, coroner, and prosecutor, deny that Rev. Dr. Schell revealed any confession from Lamphere, and Lamphere's attorney insists his client has made no confession. Meanwhile, reports surfaced that evidence suggested Belle Gunness had an accomplice who helped lure victims to her farm.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 1
(By Asre. iatci Press ) LA PORTE, IND. No* 2?.?Excel-J lent progress was made by t de? fense In the amount <>f testimony] placed before ilnJury today in the trial of Buy Lamphere for the murder1 tf Mrs. Helle Qunness and her three children; but aside from t*o wl -] nesses to show that the fire, ai tin Gunness house, accurred al o'clock! In the morning o April 28. no pro position advanced by Attorney Wooden in his opening statement was followed up. Court will he held tomorrow, the expectation being I hitt Dr.
See moreSee less
Waltr Hayes, of Chicago, the defense's main] witness, will be here to testify that he found poison in the stomachs > f Andrew Helgeleiu and three of the. four bodies found in the ruins of the Gunness house.
Clipping to come
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · Norfolk, Neb.
U.W. Jones, a postal clerk from Norfolk, is visiting relatives near Laporte and toured the notorious Gunness farm, now called the 'murder farm.' The report notes that 15,000 visitors came to see the site the previous Sunday.
The Norfolk Weekly News-Journal · 15 May 1908 · page 8
Thla announcement was made when tbe defense finished the cross exami? nation cf Deputy Sheriff Anstlss. Tae State lsys great stress on two points In the testimony of Anstlss. Srst. the statement of Anstlss that Lamphere hnd admitted he won!.! not deny having seen Mrs. G?nnes, kill Helgelein, tbe second, Anstlss' state ment that f<an:,>here had ssid he would plead ratify to arson were it not for bis motVr.
Clipping to come
The Washburn Leader · Washburn, N.D.
Ten days after the Laporte fire, authorities investigating the barnyard burial ground believe Belle Gunness was responsible for at least nine deaths, including suitors lured by matrimonial ads. Andrew Helgelein of South Dakota has been identified as one victim, though the motive for killing women and children remains unclear.
The Washburn Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 7
CRIMINAL NEWS. That Mrs. Belle Guinness was re sponsible for at least nine and prob ably more deaths before she and her three children were incinerated in the Are which destroyed her home near Laporte, Ind., ten days ago is the the ory now held by the authorities, who are attempting to solve the puzzle of a barnyard burying ground found on the woman's farm. Of the nine bodies one has been identified as that of Andrew Helgelein of Mansfield, S. D.,
A tenth body has been uncovered in the excavation of the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana. The report notes the discovery as part of the ongoing search through the ruins and grounds.
The Washburn Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 7
One more body has been added to the death roll of the Gunness farm near Laporte, Ind., and the gruesome relics now number ten. Governor Gooding of Idaho has granted a reprieve to Harry Orchard, sentenced to be hanged May 15, to July 25.
A gold crown tooth was discovered in the ashes of the Gunness home, believed to belong to Belle Gunness, as Sheriff Smutzer continued sluicing operations. A previously suppressed autopsy report also revealed three inscribed rings found on the body and disclosed that the corpse's right hand, earlier said to be missing, actually still existed.
The Washburn Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 7
NOW BELIEVE WOMAN DEAD
Bella Gunness. The tooth was found in the debris of the cellar while Sheriff Smutzer was continuing his preparations to begin the sluicing of the ashes. The relic is a hollow molar, with a gold crown, the metal being indented and to some extent encrusted by cinders. The tooth, however, bears every evi dence of having come from the incin erated skull of Mrs. Bella Gunness. Unexplainable evidence, hitherto suppressed, has been made public in the Gunness tragedy. It is contained in the report of Dr. J. L. Gyay, who performed the autopsy on the body which the authorities have steadfastly qlaimed is that of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Bella Guuness. Dr. Gray, in his report, tells of three rings which were found upon the corpse and also reveals the fact that the right hand, hitherto declared miss ing, is still in existence. The rings, which might be expected to reveal the identity of the wearer, only add to the mystery of the case. Two of them contain inscriptions, one
Coroner's physicians report that jawbones found at the Gunness farm appear to come from an adult human skull, which would help establish the corpus delicti against suspect Ray Lamphere. Sheriff Smutzer continues sifting through farm debris for further evidence, including possible dental gold that could identify Mrs. Gunness's remains.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 15 May 1908 · page 13
GUNNESS CASE Public Opinion Decidedly Hostile to Prosecution of Lamphere, Fire Suspect.
Sheriff Smutzer continues examining debris from the Gunness farmhouse cellar, including charred vertebrae of uncertain origin and metal globules that may be dental fillings or crowns. The report notes growing public skepticism toward the prosecution's theory that intense fire heat destroyed Mrs. Gunness's head, with Lamphere's case possibly heading to grand jury but trial delayed pending further investigation.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 15 May 1908 · page 13
HEAT WILL BE FACTOR
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
A Christiania dispatch reports that Mrs. Belle Gunness, now notorious as the La Porte murderess, was well remembered as a rope-dancer who assisted her father, a traveling conjurer, in Norway. Her family's show was a group affair with her siblings, and her father later retired on property near Trondhjem.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 15 May 1908 · page 13
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Fragments of bone, skin, and a charred piece of scalp found in the Gunness fire debris are seen as near-conclusive evidence the murderess's head was not removed and carried away, countering a defense theory expected at Ray Lamphere's trial. A sharp knife and two more watches (bringing the total to eleven) were also unearthed, while officials examine the dismembered body of victim Helgelein.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 15 May 1908 · page 2
MAY BE THE MISSING HEAD
Ray Lamphere and Nettie 8mutzer, one of the principal witnesses at the trial of Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Gunness. EXTERNAL REMEDY FOR ECZEMA ■ Why Salves Fail While a 8imple ' Liquid Has Accompanied Thou ■ liquid. ' Such a liquid can be obtained by
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
A razor-blade knife and additional watches were found in the fire ruins, bringing the total to eleven watches recovered. Using Bertillon records, officials positively identified the dismembered body as Andrew Helgelein, while Sheriff Smutzer planned further digging for skeletons, particularly under the barn floor.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 15 May 1908 · page 2
MANY WATCHES IN THE RUINS
[By Associated Frees.] LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 23.-Efforts are being made to learn the Identity of the person who sent to Attorney Worden today from Michigan ( ity a letter signed "Mrs. Belle Gunness, and according to it Mrs. Gunness would be found at a Michigan City address given in the letter. The communication concludes: it you attempt to have me arrested 1 will kill you. Come at 10:30 o clock. Come at once. Call for Mrs. McCon nßThe defense In the trial of Ray Lamphere, for the alleged murder or Mrs Gunness and h*«r three children, began today the introduction of the final bits of evidence in behalf of the prisoner.
See moreSee less
Evidence intended to prove that an automobile -wjas seen to go down the Gunness road the morning of the burnInjr of the home of Mrs. Gunness, and also to show that the fire had been seen as early as 3 o'clock, was offered The' defense contends that the fire •was started before 3 o'clock and that, admitting that Lamphere left the Smith house at 3:30 as claimed by the state, he could not possibly have fired the house. Saw an Automobile Louise Gackle testified she saw an automobile on Park street, coming from the Gunness road at 3:30 on tho morning of the fire. The defense inti mates that this machine might have contained Mrs. Gunness fleeing from the fire after killing the children and firing the house. John Ball testified to seeing a skull removed from a vault on the Cunness place. The lower jaw was missing. The skull was introduced in evidence by the defense, the purpose being to tend to show it to be the missing head of Mrs. Gunness.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A dispatch from Christiania (Oslo) reports a belief that Belle Gunness, the 'murder monster' of Laporte, Indiana, is the daughter of Peter Paulsen, a once well-known Norwegian sword swallower at a fair. The report states she assisted him as a child and also performed as a rope dancer, and that Paulsen has been dead for some time.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Sun · 15 May 1908 · page 2
The' defense contends that the fire •was started before 3 o'clock and that, admitting that Lamphere left the Smith house at 3:30 as claimed by the state, he could not possibly have fired the house. Saw an Automobile Louise Gackle testified she saw an automobile on Park street, coming from the Gunness road at 3:30 on tho morning of the fire. The defense inti mates that this machine might have contained Mrs. Gunness fleeing from the fire after killing the children and firing the house. John Ball testified to seeing a skull removed from a vault on the Cunness place.
See moreSee less
The lower jaw was missing. The skull was introduced in evidence by the defense, the purpose being to tend to show it to be the missing head of Mrs. Gunness. In order to cast doubt upon the
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A conductor describes a mysterious woman and man who met regularly, with descriptions matching a letter received by Cleveland's police chief. A 15-year-old boy who saw a man running from the burning Gunness home is brought to view a lineup of prisoners to identify the suspect.
The Sun · 15 May 1908 · page 2
pr— JSJ Were by Poison, tia^orte, Ind. Nov. 23.—The trial of Ray Lamphere for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three ejajail children is drawing to aldose. Another dayJ will see the evidence all in, unless something 'unforeseen happens tomorrow. Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago will-.take.&e stand early tomorrow afternoon, acoprding tb calculations, to ..testify as to the finding of strychnine and arsenic In the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness and two of the children. %.As the case now stands the de fense lias introduced evidence to show that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was alive on July 9, more than two months after the fire in which the state contends sLe perished. The-'defense has also offered eyidence to sjiow that the firewas seen before the hour alleg ed by the :state that Lamphere left the Siplth residence, thereby laying ground for an alibi. Then, too, the defense'has offered evidence to show that Mrs. Gunness was so harassed by Lamphere, Hel geline and others that she committed
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Investigators note that only ten bodies have been found on the Gunness farm, while more people are known to have disappeared after associating with Mrs. Gunness, prompting Sheriff Sutter to order further excavations. The report lists numerous men and women whose disappearance is linked to her, and mentions a car speeding from Hobart toward Chicago amid doubts about whether the woman seen was actually Mrs. Gunness.
The Sun · 15 May 1908 · page 2
Opinion in Case Lapoite. lud.. Nov. hi.—Ur. Wal ter Haims, who came from Wash ington to testify for Ray igmipliere, admitted under cross examination to day that poison was found in the bodies of the woman and children taken from the ruins of the Gunness home, it might have been adminis tered after death, he said, Dr. .T. L. Gray said tincause of death was ^suffocation by fire.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
This brief headline indicates investigators were building a case against Ray Lamphere in connection with the Gunness murders. The accompanying text, however, is entirely devoted to the unrelated Harry Thaw murder trial testimony in New York.
The Evening World · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Net of Evidence Is Fastening About Lamphere in the Gunness Murders
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Coroner's physicians report that bone fragments found at the Gunness farm are part of an adult human skull, likely Mrs. Gunness's, which investigators say establishes the corpus delicti needed for the case against Ray Lamphere. Sheriff Smutzer continues sifting through ashes and debris, using screening and panning methods, hoping to find more evidence such as gold dental fillings before presenting the case to the grand jury next week.
The Evening World · 15 May 1908 · page 15
IN fARM N1UROfRS i Finding of Skull Supposed to Be That of Mrs Gunness Completes Case LAPOfiTP Illd May 1iThe rrport of the Coroners physicians to the of
Investigators continue screening and sluicing the fire ruins for melted metal that might be Mrs. Gunness's dental work, citing the intense heat as evidence her head was incinerated. The case against Ray Lamphere is expected to go to the grand jury soon, though trial timing remains uncertain amid plans to drag a nearby pond for more bodies.
The Evening World · 15 May 1908 · page 15
IN FARM MURDERS
April IS Tho ClUe agahiBt Hay Lamphere probably will be brought l > fore the Grand Jury Monday according to the first revision of the schedule In this regard The tlmo of Ills trial Is less
Sheriff Smutzer receives numerous letters from across the country inquiring about missing relatives possibly linked to Mrs. Gunness's victims. Meanwhile, conflicting dental and physical evidence leaves authorities and Lamphere's attorneys uncertain whether the burned body is truly Mrs. Gunness.
The Stark County Democrat · 15 May 1908 · page 1
WIDESPREAD INQUIRIES FROM ALL OVER THE COUNTRY
Degree Carrying Life Sentence. LAPORTE, November 25. Tho trial of Ray Lamphcrc for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunnels and her three chil dren was finished this afternoon, and at 5:30 o'clock, tho case was given to the jury, which at onco began its de liberations to dotermino whother Lam phcrc started the firo that consumed the homo of Mrs. Gunness and cause'd the death of the woman and her children. This was the fifteenth day of tho trial. Tho cntiro day was consumed in tbj argument, Attorney Sutherland opening for tho state, fo'lowed by Attorney Weir for the defense.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worden, who has been Lam phere's attorney from the day follow ing his arrest, last May, made a strong plea for his client and State's Attorney Smith mado tho closing argument. Tho jury was given six forms of ver dict and instructed to sign tho one on which it agreed. Tho forms were: Guilty of murder in tho first degree; death. Guilty of murder in the first de gree; life sentence. Guilty of murder in tho second degree; lifo scntenc. Guilty of manslaughtr. Guilty of ar son, ot guilty. After deliberating for four hours1 without reaching a verdict, tho jury at 10:15 was locked up for tho night.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
Investigators debate whether a gold object found in the ashes is a tooth or gilt picture-frame chip, while physicians insist the body is Mrs. Gunness based on microscopic comparison of rings in a photograph to those on the charred corpse. Meanwhile, Pinkerton detectives pursue witnesses, an inventory of Gunness's estate is filed, and new letters suggest she used solicitors to lure victims via matrimonial ads.
The Stark County Democrat · 15 May 1908 · page 1
FROM ALL OVER THE
HAINES, PROVED UNWIL DR. LING TO TESTIFY POISON CAUSED GUNNESS DEATHS. I^aporte. Ind., Nov. 25.—The state scored a big victory today in the Lamphere trial when Judge Richter announced that lie would instruct the jury that if the evi dence showed that Lamphere set fire to the Gunnesa house, even if the fire did not cause the death of any persons therein, the jury must find him guilty of arson. Also that if the jury finds any per son in the house lost his life as the result of the fire and that Jjampliere set that fire, then it must find Lamphere guilty o£ murder or manslaughter.
See moreSee less
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25. Testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with the ururder of Mrs. Belle Gun ness and her three children, was closed yesterday afternoon-, following expert testimony which was consider ed damaging to* the defense. Today was taken up with arguments and in structions to the jury. It is expected the case will be in the jury's hands by evening, with tho possibility ot a ver dict before midnight. Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago yes terday testified as a. medical expert. For an hour and ten minutes he occu pied the witness stand, telling what he found by analysis in the stomachs "f the three bodies tajcen from the dull ness house ruins. He also described the contents of the stomach of Andre\y Helgelein. In so far as the attorneys for the de. fense expected Dr. Haines to testify tha.l arsenic and strychnine in fatal quantities were found by analysis, their expectations were fulfilled. But the expert stated frankly he did not Know whether the poison was intro duced into the bodies before or after death. Unable to Tell Cause of Death. Dr. Haiues added he could not de termine the cause of death by his ana lysis, or even tell wnether the poi son had been inside or outside the stomach, owing to the fact that three stomachs were in one jar, and were in advanced stages of decompo sition. In the case of Helgelein, Dr. Haines said he found both strychnine and arsenic, in his testimony he said: "On May 27 received three seal ed jars form Laporte. One jar con other jar contained contents of the stomachs. A third jar contained the stomach of a man named Helgelein. I analyzed for poison. Hejgelein's stomach contained arsenic in abuntTob»™ed than one-third of a grain of strychnine. If the stomach was of uniform compo sition I would conclude the total amount of strychnine to have been about, one and a half grains. About --one-third of a grain is the smallest amount that records show has caused the death or an adult. "The stomachs in the other jar were run together to the only possible thing to do was to analyze .the whole I mass. I found an abundance of arsenic and concluded that the whole mass two grains— enough to cause the death of three persons. Dr.- Hainetwas followed by Alexan der Neddo. living two miles from th? Gunness place, who testified that saw the fin» at 3 o'clock on the morn ing of April 28. Prosecution Uses Its Bomb. In rebutfo! the prosecution exploded Its bomb £'.gainst the prison theory. Austin Cutler, undertaker, testified that before the autopsies were par-' formed on die bodies of the Gunness fhmily he embalmed them with from ten to fifteen pounds of arsenical com pound in powdered form and about jfwo gallons of light embalming fluid, Composed chifiy of formaldehyde. as he failed to account for the pres ence of strychnine, the defense seized upon this point to convince the jury that a reasonable doubt of Lamphere's pjllt exists. Tbe undertaker further testified that About 200 persons had access to the lodies before the autopsies, making it Appear that, opportunity existed for in troducing poison in the bodies while J»ey were iying in the morsue. i.-*-
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
The report details how authorities traced an agent collecting mail for Mrs. Gunness under aliases at several Indiana and Illinois post offices, with a motorman recalling a man matching the agent's description riding his interurban line. A newsboy, John Salkin, positively identified Ray Lamphere as the man he saw fleeing the Gunness property before the fire, strengthening authorities' belief that Lamphere set the fire that killed the widow and her children.
The Stark County Democrat · 15 May 1908 · page 4
INQUIRIES
Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25. Testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with the ururder of Mrs. Belle Gun ness and her three children, was closed yesterday afternoon-, following expert testimony which was consider ed damaging to* the defense. Today was taken up with arguments and in structions to the jury. It is expected the case will be in the jury's hands by evening, with tho possibility ot a ver dict before midnight. Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago yes terday testified as a. medical expert. For an hour and ten minutes he occu pied the witness stand, telling what he found by analysis in the stomachs "f the three bodies tajcen from the dull ness house ruins.
See moreSee less
He also described the contents of the stomach of Andre\y Helgelein. In so far as the attorneys for the de. fense expected Dr. Haines to testify tha.l arsenic and strychnine in fatal quantities were found by analysis, their expectations were fulfilled. But the expert stated frankly he did not Know whether the poison was intro duced into the bodies before or after death.
Clipping to come
The Stark County Democrat · Canton, Ohio
The report details Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children at the Laporte death farm, revealing he had a prior criminal record for breaking into freight cars near Sayre, Pennsylvania. It notes he deserted his wife there and vanished until his arrest in the Gunness case.
The Stark County Democrat · 15 May 1908 · page 8
RAY LAMPHERE Accused of Many Murders; Deserted Wife at Sayre, Pa.—Has Criminal Record
Prosecution Uses Its Bomb. In rebutfo! the prosecution exploded Its bomb £'.gainst the prison theory. Austin Cutler, undertaker, testified that before the autopsies were par-' formed on die bodies of the Gunness fhmily he embalmed them with from ten to fifteen pounds of arsenical com pound in powdered form and about jfwo gallons of light embalming fluid, Composed chifiy of formaldehyde. as he failed to account for the pres ence of strychnine, the defense seized upon this point to convince the jury that a reasonable doubt of Lamphere's pjllt exists. Tbe undertaker further testified that About 200 persons had access to the lodies before the autopsies, making it Appear that, opportunity existed for in troducing poison in the bodies while J»ey were iying in the morsue. a
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
A brief item reports that a man from Milwaukee claims he will deliver Mrs. Belle Gunness to authorities in LaPorte, Indiana, for a $5,000 reward. The sarcastic comment adds that this is more than she is worth.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Mayor Tom L. Johnson of Cleve. land Is .now roiping .the wrath of a peoplo whom he has befrlondod and for whom he plans other uuutmiu. all -nil. The .people of Ohio are susplc lonlng .that the troops la the to bacco districts are being used to nllay the fears of a few panicky olIlQers. A Milwaukee man says he will deliver Mrs. Belle Gunness to the authorities of Laporte, Inulinn, for
The Muskogee Cimeter · Muskogee, Indian Territory, Okla.
Four more bodies were discovered at the La Porte, Indiana farm of Mrs. Gunness, bringing the total found so far to nine. Authorities believe many of the victims were killed in Chicago and shipped to the farm to conceal the crimes, and the search for additional remains continues.
The Muskogee Cimeter · 15 May 1908 · page 7
. Standing. Laporte, Ind., Nov. 2C. Though out all night and having spent several hours this morning in deliberation the jury'in the Gunness murder case is unable to reach an agreement. Con flicting reports are heard outside the jury room but authentic information is uot obtainable. t Laporte, Ind., Nov. 2C. The jury went, to bed at 11 o'clock last night by permission of Judge John C. Hit-liter, without arriving at a verdict re specting the guilt or innocence of Ray Lamphere, accused of the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three chil dren by arson. According to rumors current among the watchers, the jury took four bal lots and were about equally divided;
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
A report from La Porte, Indiana states that the identity of the body found in the fire ashes was practically established as Belle Gunness. Dr. I. T. Norton, a dentist, identified the jaw bone found among the remains as hers.
East Oregonian : E.O · 15 May 1908 · page 5
Body of Mrs. Gunness
the watchers, the jury took four bal Where alfalfa pasturage is rented lots and were about equally divided; the price is 75 cents to $1 per month, on the question of ampheres culpaand the alfalfa furnishes nine months' bility. j pasture. A man from Texas rented Following a cruel denunciation by j 7,000 acres of native grass land 13 the state. In which he was pictured as years ago at $100 per year and began a murderer and an accomplice of the with COO cows. In addition to his arch fiend he is said to have restroybare existence on the ranch he has ed, Lamphere was reassured by his made $200,000 clear, represented by
Clipping to come
Condon Globe · Condon, Or.
A medical examination of Andrew Helgelien's body revealed brown curly hairs clenched in his fist, suggesting he fought fiercely before being killed. Police are reported as now accepting the original theory that Mrs. Gunness died in the fire that destroyed her home.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Condon Globe · 15 May 1908 · page 4
SOLD LIFE DEARLY One of Mrs. Guinness' Victims Did Not Die Easily. La Porte, May 11. Evidence came to light today Indicating that the body of Andrew Helgallne, one of Mrs. dMinneBs alleged victims, did not fall a victim to his death blow until af ter he had made a desperate fight for his life. Dr. J. B. Meyer, who made an ex amination of the corpse, reported to . the coroner , that he found several brown curly ' hairs in the clenched flat of Hellgallne's right hand. It Is supposed that In the death struggle he pulled the hair out of the scalp of his slayer. Police are now willing to accept the original theory that Mrs. Guinness died In the fire which destroyed her home.
The coroner's physician found three rings embedded in the flesh of a hand on the burned corpse found in the Gunness home ruins, which witnesses identified as belonging to Belle Gunness. One ring was inscribed with what was believed to be a reference to her second husband, Peter Gunness.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Condon Globe · 15 May 1908 · page 4
IS BURNED BODY IN RUINS IS IDENTIFIED BY RINGS. No Longer Koenis to He Any Doubt Arch Fiend Finally Met Her Equal Kings Wero Imbedded In Flesh and Were Not Noticed at First Ex amination One Gold Hand Form erly Belonged to Her Second Hue band. La Porte, Ind., May 12. The most convincing evidence so fur discovered hows that the body of the woman found in the ashes of the aunness home was that of Mrs. Belle Dullness, who had a private burying ground near her back door, was revealed to day1 when Dr.
See moreSee less
J. H. Meyers, the cor oner's physician, found three rings on one of the hands ot the corpse. One plain gold band bore the In scription. "P. G. to J. 8 Aug. 2, '94." It Is thought that "P. G." was Phillip Gunnoss, Mrs. aunness' second hus band. , inside the second ring, set with a diamond, was Inscribed, "H. 8. to J. S, l-V, '05." The third was not In scribed. Several people declare these to be the rings worn by Mrs. Gunness. The rings had sunk Into the flesh of the hand and were not noticed at the first examination of the body.
The item is a brief editorial comment noting that the discovery of Mrs. Gunness's rings in the Laporte fire ashes does not conclusively prove she died. It suggests that a woman lacking typical feminine attachment to her jewelry could have deliberately left them behind while fleeing.
The Morning Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Afraid of Being Shot. "There was too good a chance of getting a chunk of lead. Tho buggy had a yellow running gear and a black tot. The horse was a gray one with dapples on Its hips as big as a half dollar." On cross-examination tho witness said that he did not see tho woman's features er face, but could tell from her build and walk that it was Mrs. Gunness. Bvallno Hutson, 11 years old, who followed her father on the stand, testified that uho saw Mrs. Gunness in "hay time" near the woods.
See moreSee less
She was in a buggy with a man. They passed hor In the road. The girl said that Mrs. Gunness had on two veils, a black ono and a white one, the black one being over her face. Tho girl said: "When I saw her she "turned her face away from me." Eldora Huston, 9 years old, sister of the preceding witness said: "J was playing by tho big gate by tho road. I saw Mrs. Gunness go by with a man. She had on a double veil and a wide-brimmed hat. I did not know tho man." Attorney Worden, who is defending Lamphere made public Sunday night, a latter received Sunday by special delivery by his law partner Mayor Lemuel Darrow. The writer whose full name address Is withheld by Mr. Worden, says he kaows that Mrs. Gunness is alive, and declares that ho was the man who accompanied her to the Gunness farm on July 9, the date on which D. M. Hutson and his daughters say they saw Mrs. Gunness, and a man drive away In a buggy.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Workers sifting the ashes in the Gunness farmhouse cellar under Sheriff Sutter's direction found pieces of human jaw bone and a piece of skin with possible hair traces. Prosecutors called the discovery valuable to their case, though doctors noted some uncertainty about the skin's origin and the overall evidentiary value of the day's findings.
The Morning Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 3
GHASTLY RELICS FOUND IN RUINS OF GUNNESS HOME
Afraid of Being Shot. "There was too good a chance of getting a chunk of lead. Tho buggy had a yellow running gear and a black tot. The horse was a gray one with dapples on Its hips as big as a half dollar." On cross-examination tho witness said that he did not see tho woman's features er face, but could tell from her build and walk that it was Mrs. Gunness. Bvallno Hutson, 11 years old, who followed her father on the stand, testified that uho saw Mrs. Gunness in "hay time" near the woods.
See moreSee less
She was in a buggy with a man. They passed hor In the road. The girl said that Mrs. Gunness had on two veils, a black ono and a white one, the black one being over her face. Tho girl said: "When I saw her she "turned her face away from me." Eldora Huston, 9 years old, sister of the preceding witness said: "J was playing by tho big gate by tho road. I saw Mrs. Gunness go by with a man. She had on a double veil and a wide-brimmed hat. I did not know tho man." Attorney Worden, who is defending Lamphere made public Sunday night, a latter received Sunday by special delivery by his law partner Mayor Lemuel Darrow. The writer whose full name address Is withheld by Mr. Worden, says he kaows that Mrs. Gunness is alive, and declares that ho was the man who accompanied her to the Gunness farm on July 9, the date on which D. M. Hutson and his daughters say they saw Mrs. Gunness, and a man drive away In a buggy.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
Investigators continue sifting ashes at the Gunness farm, finding bone fragments including vertebrae and jaw bones whose human or animal origin is undetermined, along with two watches among the relics. Bertillon measurements of victim Andrew Helgelien were compared to an exhumed corpse and reportedly matched closely, while Coroner Mack awaits formal medical reports on whether jaw fragments are human, which could undercut the defense's claims about the identity of the adult body found after the fire.
The Morning Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 3
fewer in number rapidly. Heavier tlve, but Pittsburg reports transac tions smaljqr. Prices are higher, Failures' for the week" number 273. Wheat exports for tho week nggre Rate 5,699,314 bushels. Corn exports for, the week are 239,717 bushols. ' ' Says Mrs. Ounness Is Alive, Attorney Worden, who is defending Hay Lamphure, now on trial at La porte, Ind., for the murder of Mrs, Belle Gunness and her children, made public a letter received' by spe--clal delivery by his law partner, Mayor Darrowv The writer, whoao full name .and address is withheld by Mr.
See moreSee less
Wor den, says he knows that Mrs, Gunness Is alive and declares that he waB the man who accompanied her to the Gun ness farm on July 0, the date on which T. M. Hutson and hla daughters Bay they saw Mrs. Gunness and a man drive away in a buggy.