Authorities digging in the burned Gunness farmyard discover four mutilated bodies, including that of John Heldgren, a suitor from South Dakota, and the missing adopted daughter. Investigators suspect jailed suspect Ray Lamphere may have knowledge of these additional murders.
Kingsbury County Independent · 15 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER SOUTH DAKOTAN; BODY TORN IN PIECES
fewer in number rapidly. Heavier tlve, but Pittsburg reports transac tions smaljqr. Prices are higher, Failures' for the week" number 273. Wheat exports for tho week nggre Rate 5,699,314 bushels. Corn exports for, the week are 239,717 bushols. ' ' Says Mrs. Ounness Is Alive, Attorney Worden, who is defending Hay Lamphure, now on trial at La porte, Ind., for the murder of Mrs, Belle Gunness and her children, made public a letter received' by spe--clal delivery by his law partner, Mayor Darrowv The writer, whoao full name .and address is withheld by Mr.
See moreSee less
Wor den, says he knows that Mrs, Gunness Is alive and declares that he waB the man who accompanied her to the Gun ness farm on July 0, the date on which T. M. Hutson and hla daughters Bay they saw Mrs. Gunness and a man drive away in a buggy.
Clipping to come
Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D.
Investigators in LaPorte report that the headless female body found in the burned Gunness farmhouse may not be Belle Gunness herself, suggesting she substituted a victim's corpse and is still alive, possibly hiding in Chicago. A brother's suspicions about a dispute over money between Gunness and her hired man Lamphere are also cited as supporting the murder theory.
Kingsbury County Independent · 15 May 1908 · page 3
MURDER FIEND WHO LURED MEN, LIVES
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Kingsbury County Independent · Desmet, S.D.
Investigators now believe two bodies found at the Gunness farm are adult men, not children as first thought, reigniting theories that Belle Gunness may still be alive. Authorities detail her suspicious marriages, insurance payouts, mysterious trunks shipped from Chicago, and push to extract a confession from Lamphere.
Kingsbury County Independent · 15 May 1908 · page 3
15. 6URHESS (By United Press.) LA PORTE, Nov. 27. ? 1 The Jury In the case of Lamphere, tried on charges of murder and arson result ing in the death of Mrs. Gunnc-ss and tier three children, today' return ed a verdfA of guilty of arson. He was promptly sentenced on two counts to a term of twenty years In the penitentiary. Lamphere was in the employ of the woman Gunness, who Is alleged to have carried on a system of mur der and robbery at her farm near this city causing half a dozen known deaths and suspected of many others. Lamphere is thought to have mur dered her and then fired the house to conceal the crime.
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
Searchers at the Gunness farm found two more watches in the ruins, bringing the total to ten men's watches despite only nine male bodies having been unearthed. Sheriff Smutzer plans to resume digging, focusing next on the area beneath the barn's basement flooring.
The Madison Daily Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 1
TWO MORE WATCHES FOUND
Him For Five Years. LAPORTE. Ind., Nov. 26. Ra? Lamphere. charged with the murder of Mrs. Belte Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Qnnness
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
An estimated 15,000 curious visitors descended on the Gunness farm in LaPorte, overwhelming local transportation, hotels, and authorities who became mere spectators. Among the crowd were relatives searching for missing loved ones, including a man whose brother had worked for Mrs. Gunness and vanished after supposedly intending to marry her.
Paper unidentified · 15 May 1908 · page 6
MORBID HORDE LOOSE GUNNERS MURDER FARM OVER. RUN WITH CURIOUS THRONG.
Investigation of the case by the au thorities hailed, the sheriff and other officials who went to the farm being compelled to become mere spectators also. Several of the out of town visit ors, however, were seeking informa tion concerning missing friends and relatives. Olaf Llnboe, of Chicago, said that his brother Thomas worked for Mrs. Gunness three years ago, and that the last letter that he had from him contained the information that Thomas intended to marry his employ er. Olaf wrote to the woman a little later, and she replied that Thomas Llndboe had gone to St.
See moreSee less
Louis and that she had had no word from him. Olaf Llndboe viewed the unidentified corpses, but was unable to find any likeness to his brother in the decayed bundles of bones and flesh. The crowds began arriving in La porte when the first train from the east arrived shortly after 5 o’clock in the morning. Along the roadside in front of the farm were several lemon ade stands and lunch wagons.
Large crowds converged on Laporte, Indiana to see the Gunness farm, overwhelming local transportation and forcing officials to become mere spectators rather than active investigators. Separately, an elderly man in Warsaw, Indiana committed suicide after becoming deranged from reading newspaper accounts of the Gunness murders, while visitors sought information about missing friends and relatives believed to have worked for Gunness.
The Charles Mix New Era · 15 May 1908 · page 3
Hon concerning missing friends and relatives. Olaf Linboe, of Chicago, said that his brother Thomas worked for Mrs. Gunness three years ago. and that the last letter that he had from him contained the information that Thomas intended to marry his employ er. Olaf wrote to the woman a little later, and she replied that Thomas LJndboe had gone to St. Lou ft and that she had had no word from him. Olaf Lindboe viewed the unidentified corpses, but was unable to And any likeness to his brother in the decayed bundles of bones and flesh The crowds began arriving tn La porte when the first train from the eaat arrived shortly after S o'clock in the morning.
See moreSee less
Along the roadside In front of the farm were several ade stands and lunch wagona.
A newspaper opinion column on race relations and politics makes a passing comparison, noting that 'the civilized Negro race has not produced a Mrs Gunness.' The reference treats her name as already synonymous with notorious criminality, used rhetorically rather than as news reporting.
The Nashville Globe · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Orono. Me.: 2 companion was rescued by other students. — Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in the destruction of the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness. at LaPorte, Ind. but was not held responsipie for the death of Mrs. Gunness and her th children. ——— The balloon Pittsfield,
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Coroner's physicians reported that jaw bones found at the Gunness farm came from an adult human skull, which prosecutors say helps establish corpus delicti against suspect Ray Lamphere. Sheriff Smutzer plans to resume searching the farm's refuse piles for further evidence.
Paper unidentified · 15 May 1908 · page 3
MURDER WEB ENTANGLING LAMPHERE
Orono. Me.: 2 companion was rescued by other students. — Ray Lamphere was found guilty of arson in the destruction of the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness. at LaPorte, Ind. but was not held responsipie for the death of Mrs. Gunness and her th children. ——— The balloon Pittsfield,
Clipping to come
Bryan Morning Eagle · Bryan, Tex.
A brief dispatch from La Porte, Indiana reports that two additional watches were discovered amid the debris of the burned Gunness house. This is part of the ongoing excavation and search of the property following the fire.
Bryan Morning Eagle · 15 May 1908 · page 2
IS GUILTY OF ARSON VERDICT of JURY in LAKPHT.rf, I CASE—GETS FROM 2 TO 21 YEAR S IMPRISONMENT. $5000 FINE AND DISFRANCHISED. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder ot Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gup ness house, was found guilty of ar son last night by the jury, which had deliberated since 5:30 o'clock the night before. Within five min utes after the verdict the defendant was sentenced to the state prison at Michigan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to 21 years, fined $5000 and was disfranchised for five years.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worden, for the defense, said that a motion for a new trial would he made, and should it be re fused, an appeal to the Indiana su preme court would follow. The In diana supreme court is two years behind in its work, so this case could not be reached until after he had served the minimum time of his sentence. Mr. Worden declared the verdict to be ridiculous. "If he was guilty at all," Bald the attorney, "he was guilty of mprder. He should have been acquitted. The motion for a new trial will be based on the judge'B instructions that a jury could find Lamphere guilty of arson." Should the case be carried to the supreme court and sent back for re trial, Lamphere coOld not be tried on any charge in thlB particular case except arson, the crime for which he was convicted. However, in an event of that kind the state would elect to try him on one of the In dictments, probably the Helgelein case. Members of the Jury are reticent in discussing what occurred in tbe jury room, but enough has been learned to know that but for two members Lamphere would have been feund guilty of murder or man slaughter, the verdict being a com promise. Several members of the Jury held out for murder In the first degree, with a life sentence. So far as could be learned none was for hanging.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A St. Paul man claims he saw and spoke with Belle Gunness earlier that week, insisting she matched newspaper photos despite his wife's presence. Meanwhile in Laporte, searchers found human jawbone fragments and a piece of skull with possible hair traces in the farmhouse cellar.
The Salt Lake Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 3
SEEN THIS TIME BY ST PAUL MAN
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Investigators in Laporte examined jawbone fragments and charred vertebrae found at the farm, uncertain whether skin and hair came from an animal or human scalp. A separate dispatch from Christiania recounts Belle Gunness's childhood performing as a rope dancer with her father, a traveling conjurer and magician.
The Salt Lake Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Mrs. John H. McJunkin of Coraopolis, Pa., has written to the LaPorte sheriff believing her husband may be one of the victims at the Gunness farm. She says he disappeared in December 1905 after corresponding with a LaPorte woman and was carrying $700 at the time.
The Salt Lake Herald · 15 May 1908 · page 3
A Possible Victim
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
This index entry references a front-page report that searchers sifting the burned ruins of Belle Gunness's Laporte, Indiana home have uncovered additional evidence related to the crimes. It appears only as a table-of-contents listing within the larger newspaper index.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 1
Ashes of Gunness's home at Laporte, Ind., yield up more evidence of crime
Talks of Appeal. Attorney' Worden announced this morning he would make a motion Monday before Judge RJchter for a new trial, and upon the same being denied, he expected to perfect an ap peal. The transcript alone in the case will cost over $500, and as Lamphere's family have no means, his friends by subscription have provided for his de fense. The general opinion is the ap peal will never be perfected. Galltr of A moo. LaPorte, Ind.. Nov. 27. "We, the jury, find the defendant guilty of ar son, and that he is 38 years old-!--' This wis" tne Verdict given last night by the jury which tried Ray Lamphere for the murder of the archmurderess, Mrs.
See moreSee less
Belle .Gunness, and her three children at Brookslde farm last spring. Lamphere was sentenced by Judge Richter after tfie verdict had been read to Imprisonment in the peniten tiary at Michigan City for a term of from 2 to 21 years, fined $5,000 and disfranchised for five years, which constitutes the penalty for the crime of arson.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Investigators sifting ashes in the Gunness farmhouse cellar found pieces of human jawbone and a piece of skin possibly from a scalp, along with metal pieces and a watch. Doctors examined the bone fragments while prosecutors called them the most valuable evidence yet found; meanwhile over 100 crank letters poured in to authorities.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 1
CELLAR YIELDS UP EVIDENCE OF CRIME
Talks of Appeal. Attorney' Worden announced this morning he would make a motion Monday before Judge RJchter for a new trial, and upon the same being denied, he expected to perfect an ap peal. The transcript alone in the case will cost over $500, and as Lamphere's family have no means, his friends by subscription have provided for his de fense. The general opinion is the ap peal will never be perfected. Galltr of A moo. LaPorte, Ind.. Nov. 27. "We, the jury, find the defendant guilty of ar son, and that he is 38 years old-!--' This wis" tne Verdict given last night by the jury which tried Ray Lamphere for the murder of the archmurderess, Mrs.
See moreSee less
Belle .Gunness, and her three children at Brookslde farm last spring. Lamphere was sentenced by Judge Richter after tfie verdict had been read to Imprisonment in the peniten tiary at Michigan City for a term of from 2 to 21 years, fined $5,000 and disfranchised for five years, which constitutes the penalty for the crime of arson.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Workers sifting through clay in the cellar found two pieces of human jawbone and a piece of skin, prompting a hurried examination by physicians assisting the coroner. Separately, prosecutors claimed a new witness would testify that Lamphere received $300 from Mrs. Gunness, supporting a blackmail theory.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 15 May 1908 · page 1
SIFTING ASHES OF HOUSE
Verdict Is Compromise. It developed after the conclusion of the' case that the jury, which deliber ated on the case for 24 hours, reached its verdict as a matter of compromise, two members of the jury refusing to convict Lamphere of murder. Thl3 development aroused considerable ex citement and resulted in an unusual proceeding on the part of the members of the jury who signed a statement to the public, which was as follows: "We, the undersigned-jurors, impan eled and . sworn in the case of the state of Indiana vs.
See moreSee less
Ray Lamphere, hereby say that it was our judgment in the consideration of this case that the adult body found in the ruins of the fire was that of Belle Gunness, and that the case was decided by us on an entirely different proposition."
Clipping to come
Middlebury Register · Middlebury, Vt.
Post-mortem reports on the woman and three children found in the burned Gunness home failed to establish cause of death, likely leading to an open verdict from Coroner Mack. New evidence emerged including a gold-crowned tooth believed to be Mrs. Gunness's, three inscribed rings found on the body by Dr. Gray, and numerous bent scissors and knives resembling surgical instruments found in the cellar debris.
Middlebury Register · 15 May 1908 · page 8
V GUILTY OF ARSON HESPONSIELE FOR BURNIMO OP ' GUNNESS HOME, CAUSING WOMAN'S DEATH. I c.ut For Indeterminate Term of From Twj j. i W 91 Varo Defense Sav Motion
Clipping to come
The Seattle Republican · Seattle, Wash.
A general opinion piece on politics briefly describes the Gunness case, noting about twenty bodies found near Laporte and that she lured mostly Swedish men with marriage and farm offers. It also mentions the claim that the burned female body was not Gunness herself, suggesting she faked her death and remains at large.
The Seattle Republican · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Lamphere stated that he wished to make a statement, but the judge re fused to hear it. After the verdict had been read Judge Richter asked Lamphere if he cared to make a statement, but he said that, it would do no good now. He also declined to give any reason why sentence should not be passed. Judge Richter then sentenced him to the state prison in Michigan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years, fined him $3,000 and disfranchised him for five year. Lamphere was then returned to Jail. The attorneys fo rthe defense stat ed tonight that a motion for a new trial would be made and if refused an appeal would be taken to the su-
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified · and 1 other paper
A gold crown tooth was discovered in the debris of the burned Gunness home, believed to belong to Belle Gunness. Investigators allege farmhand Ray Lamphere set the fire that killed her and her three children, and claim chloral poisoning and dismemberment of victims has been established.
Paper unidentified · 15 May 1908 · page 3
GOLD TOOTH IS FOUND IN RUINS
At Laporte, Ind., Ray Lam phere,,charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to her house April 28th, was found
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Pullman Herald · Pullman, Wash. · 16 May 1908
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The report identifies Ole Budsberg of Iola, Wis. as a probable victim who had corresponded with Belle Gunness and traveled to her home with $2,000; his body is believed to be among those exhumed. Separately, a dentist's identification of a jawbone is said to confirm the body found in the fire's ashes was Mrs. Gunness herself.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Spokane Press · 15 May 1908 · page 1
OLE BUDSBERG
Ray Lmphere, churged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and lior three children by Retting fire to the Gunness house at Laporte, Ind., April 28, was Thursday evening found guilty of arson by the Jury, which had the case since 6:30 o'clock Wednes day evening. Within five minutes af ter the verdict was reported Judge Rlchter had sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one yenrs. The verdict was reached within half an hour after the Jurors had returned from supper.
See moreSee less
Word was conveyed to Bailiff Metz, who at once telephoned Judge Rlchter and the attorneys In the case. The lights in the big court room were turned on, and within fif teen minutes the court was filled. Lamphere was brought over from the
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The passage includes a flashlight photo of Ray Lamphere taken in the Laporte jail, captioned as the new picture of him. He is identified as being held by police in the Indiana multi-murder mystery, suspected of complicity in the crimes at the so-called House of Horrors.
The Spokane Press · 15 May 1908 · page 1
NEW PICTURE OF LAMPHERE
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
Ralph A. Smith, prosecuting attorney for Indiana's Thirty-second district, is identified as the attorney who will prosecute Ray Lamphere. Lamphere is described as a suspect in complicity regarding the Gunness murder case.
The Spokane Press · 15 May 1908 · page 1
RALPH A. SMITH
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
The report draws on inquest testimony about the death of Joseph Philip Gunness, Belle Gunness's second husband, to portray her as having a deliberate, skilled method of dismembering bodies similar to how she butchered livestock. Neighbors testified she always insisted on cutting up her own animals, and she herself testified she was finishing butchering work the day before her husband died.
The Spokane Press · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Special Correspondence to The Press. LA PORTE, Ind., May 15—Not an ordinary, cumbersome mutilator of bodies like the perpetrators of Ma fia outrages, but a scientific butch er of either human beings or ani mals —such was Mrs. Bella Gun ness. Close scrutiny of the records of the inquest over the body of Joseph Philip Gunness, the woman's sec ond husband, adds a new and weird accomplishment to the most fa mous of America's murderesses. Mrs. Gunness was a skilled butch er. With her dismembering bodies was a science. Neighbors testified she butchered all her own live stock.
See moreSee less
She always insisted upon cutting it up for smoking or salting. It was her "specialty." she said. On the witness stand at the in quest of her second husband she testified that "on the day before he died I was trying to finish up the butchering business."
Physicians examining the remains of Jennie Olson and Andrew Helgelien noted the scientific precision of the cuts, suggesting the work of a skilled surgeon or butcher. Police theorized Belle Gunness dismembered bodies not only to destroy identity but to fit them into gunnysacks and disguise burial holes.
The Spokane Press · 15 May 1908 · page 4
Gunness' reason for cutting up the bodies, other than tot destroy their identity, was to make them easy to carry in gunnysacks and to make them fit holes that did not resem ble graves.
A La Porte dentist, Dr. I. T. Norton, examined the jaw bone found in the fire's ashes and identified it as belonging to Belle Gunness. This discovery was said to practically confirm that the body recovered was hers.
The Evening Statesman · 15 May 1908 · page 1
DENTIST IDENTIFIES MRS. GUNNESS.
OP ; (Associated Press.) LAPORTE (Ind.), Nov. 26. Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting Are to the Gunness home, was this evening found guilty of arson by the Jury which had the case since 5:30 last night. Within five minutes after the verdict was reported, Judge Rlchter had sentenced the defendant to the state prison at Michigan City, to . . . serve an indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years, fined htm for $5000, and disfranchised him for five years. An appeal , will be taken. v . A FAST RELAY ' Associated Press.) V SAN JOSE (Cal.). Nov. 26. Sixty-one SECRET OFPABTY mm NEW YORK. Nov. 26. Governor
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
A dentist, Dr. L. T. Norton, examined a jaw bone found in the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse ruins and identified it as belonging to Belle Gunness, confirming the charred remains were hers. The report also recounts her background as a Norwegian immigrant obsessed with money.
The Seattle Star · 15 May 1908 · page 5
TEETH THOSE OF WOMAN FIEND
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
Richland County, Wisconsin is noted for unusual four-legged chickens, with one owned by Mrs. C. S. Scott and another hatched at J. W. Paul's farm. The article jokingly references the notorious Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana, noting no local resident visited it for matrimonial purposes.
Eagle River Review · 15 May 1908 · page 2
CHICKENS ARE FREAKS.
i.; . ... .. i.. ... i . i . ... , I, " in in. inin n.ini uie riemuv oi in person, who sent to Attorney Worden. today, from Michigan City, a letter Signed "Mrs. Hctle Gunness" declaring that Mrs. Gunness would be found at Michigan City, at the address given in the letter." The communication concludes as follows; "If you attempt to have me arrested I will kill you. Come nt 10:30 o'clock and come alone. Call for Mrs. McConnell," The defense in the trial of Ray Lamphere for the nlleged murder, of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, began today the intro duction of final bits of evidence in behalf of the prisoner, the expectation being that the defense would rest its case tonight
Clipping to come
Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis. · and 1 other paper
Two more skeletons are unearthed at the Gunness farm, fueling speculation that bodies were brought from Chicago to stage her death. An unnamed source claims she was seen boarding a train, prompting police to investigate whether she is still alive.
Watertown Weekly Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 6
GUINNESS WOMAN NOT DEAD, HIDING. IS LATEST BRIEF ALLEGED OGRESS THOUGHT TO HAVE ESCAPED FLAMES WHICH BURNED HER HOME. TWO MORE BODIES ARE FOUND Possibility That Skeletons Dug Up Are Remains of People Murdered in Chicago. OFFICERS WORK EVERY CLUE.
OFFICERS WORK EVERY CLUE. ' LAPORTE, Ind., May G.—l Special.] Two more ghastly finds were made on the farm of Mrs. Belle Guinness today when the skeletons of two adults were
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · 15 May 1908
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis. · and 1 other paper
Police investigate a tip that Belle Gunness boarded a train to flee to Norway, while also probing an alleged Chicago insurance murder ring suspected of shipping bodies to LaPorte in trunks. The report also recounts an earlier strange incident where Gunness claimed to witness a child's murder, which the police chief now believes was her own crime.
Eagle River Review · 15 May 1908 · page 6
OFFICERS WORK EVERY CLUE.
cludes the supposition that she feared Roy Lamphere, her former employe, was about to expose her through jealousy. Suspect Insurance Plot. The sheriff has notified the Chicago police to be on the lookout for a gang in that city believed to be in a murder plot
Watertown Weekly Leader · Watertown, Wis. · 15 May 1908
Eagle River Review · Eagle River, Wis.
A deliveryman recounts carrying heavy, ironbound trunks to the Gunness home in 1907, now suspected of containing bodies. The coroner states the body identified as Andrew Helgelein does not match him, citing fresh condition and expert dismemberment, casting doubt on the identification.
Eagle River Review · 15 May 1908 · page 6
Coroner Makes Statement. Dr. T. H. W. Meyer, the coroner here, said today: “The body identified yes terday as that of Andrew Helgelein bears no resemblance whatever to him. Helgelein disappeared about the first of the year aud if he was buried then his body by now would of course be badly decomposed. The bodies dug up yesterday are in excellent condition. The skin is apparently fresh, there Is not a
A doctor examining a body states its condition and dismemberment suggest expert anatomical work, doubting it belongs to Helgelein. Belle Gunness's nephew, John Larson, gives a detailed family history and asks to take the four fire-ruin bodies to Chicago, believing them to be his aunt and her children.
Watertown Weekly Leader · 15 May 1908 · page 6
Negress Is Suspected. Prosecuting Attorney Smith said today that he would cross examine Lamphere in an effort to obtain a confession from him. He further said that a negress named Lizzie Smith, who killed a prom inent attorney at Laporte, knows, in his opinion, something of the murders at the Guinness house.
The report describes local family connections to the Laporte, Indiana case, noting that Peter Gunness's daughter Swanhilda and brother Carl live in Wisconsin. Swanhilda recounts cruelty from her stepmother, and the family is arranging legal representation to protect her interests and assist in investigating her father's death.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 15 May 1908 · page 5
Trial. Is .Not, Granted. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 26. Ray Lamph-ere, charged with the mur derof Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting fire to the Gunness house on April 28, was this evening found guilty of arson by the jury, which has had the case since 5:30 o'clock last evening. Within five minutes after the verdict was re ported, Judge Richter had sentenced the defendant to the state peniten tiary at Michigan City for an inde trminate term of from two to twen ty-one years, Lamphere will be taken to Michigan City to-uiorrow to begin his sentencel The Verdict was reached within half an hour after the jurors had returned from supper.
See moreSee less
Attorney Worden of the defense said to-night that a motion for a new trial would be made, and should it be refused an appeal to the In diana supreme court will follow. Mr. Worden declared the verdict to be ridiculous. If he was guilty at all," said the attorney, "he would have been guilty of murder. He should have mm
Clipping to come
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · Edgerton, Wis.
A coroner's dig at the Gunness farm uncovers another body, bringing the total of unidentified victims to ten, in addition to the four Gunness family members killed in the house fire, for a total of fourteen deaths. New evidence, including letters from Belle Gunness urging Ray Lamphere to return, strengthens the murder case against him.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 15 May 1908 · page 6
ONE MORE CORPSE HAS BEEN DUG UP Scraps of Humanity That Make the Gunness Murders Number Ten. THEY MAY HAVE BEEN A WOMAN Total of the Deaths in the Tragedy, Including the Gunness Family, Now Fourteen.
One more body lias been added to tbe death roll of the Guinness farm, npar La Porte, Ind., the grewsome relics now numbering ten. Then there are the bodies of Mrs. Guinness and her three children burned to death in their home, making fourteen in all, Coroner Mack had at first announced that the grave opened yesterday con tained one complete cadaver and por tions of a second, but later said that what he had at first believed to be ad ditional thigh and arm bones are in reality pieces of the first set.
See moreSee less
* Developments in the case came thick and last during the evening, each ad ditional circumstance brought to light being of a uature to strengthen the charges against Ray Lamphere, who is accused of first degree murder be cause of the deaths of Mrs. Belle Guin ness and her three children. Lamphere sent a request to his attorney, H. \Y. Worden, asking the latter to send to the farm of John Wheatbrook for the trunk which Lamphere left there when he was arrested April 28. But before this word had reached the attorney the trunk had been con fiscated by the local authorities. It con tained a number of letters written by Mrs. Guinness to Lamphere after the latter had taken employment at tbe farm of John Wheatbrook, near Spring ville, seven miles north of this city. The exact dates on these letters were not announced, but that they were re cent is evidenced by tbe fact that Lam phere went to the Wheatbrook farm on Feb. 3, 1908. Tlie woman wrote to Lamphere urg ing him to return to her farm, and to 4, bring your sweetheart with you if she has money enough.” The identity of the woman is a and neither does Mrs. Guinness mention the amount deemed necessary for her re ception at the Guinness farm. Along *VVith the letters were found several tromen’s finger rings, some of which of unusual size and may have been the property of Mrs. Guinness.
Excavators uncover a tenth badly decomposed body, likely a woman's based on shoes and purse remnants found in the grave. A new witness, Peter Colson, tells the prosecutor that Ray Lamphere admitted attempting to blackmail Belle Gunness, supporting a theory that extortion and conflict motivated the farmhouse fire.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 15 May 1908 · page 6
Man Who Heard Lamp here Threaten to Betray Mrs. Guinness. Other impor ant developments of the day includes the following: Peter Col son, anew witness in the case? told R. N. Smith, the prosecuting attorney, that Ray Lamphere had ackncwledg m 1 attempts to blackmail Mrs. Guinness. This is considered as deiiuitely estab lishing a motive for a disagreement between Lamphere and the woman which resuited later In the burning of the farmhouse. Prosecutor Smith has been endeavoring to establish a defi nite disagreement between Lamphere and the Guinness woman, and Coul son’s testimony is important in that respect.
See moreSee less
According to Colson, Lamphere said a few days before the fire of April 28: “I made her get down on her knees last night, and I am going to make her get down tonight unless she comes up with some money. I know things about her that would raise an awful row if they were told. She bought me this suit of clothes that I am wearing, but she doesn’t like to come up with the coin, and that is what I need and must have.” It is the prosecutor’s theory that Lamphere had gained knowledge of the means by which Andrew Helgelein was done to death; that the prisoner attemDted to use this knowledge to ex tort money from the woman, and this led up to the woman’s prosecution of Lamphere as a lunatic, and other moves against him, and finally to the burning of the Guinness home by Lamphere. Matt and Oscar Budsberg have de parted for lola, Wis., after making ar rangements to have the body of their father, Ole O. Budsberg, shipped to that town as soon as Coroner Mack releases it for burial. Before their de parture the boys made inquiry as to the watches found in the ruins of tbe farm house, saying that their parent purchased anew timepiece just prior to his departure from the Wisconsin town in March, 1907. Upon beingshown the watches they said that one of Ihem. was like their father’s watch. All roads led to the Guinness farm Sunday, upwards of 15,000 sight seers visiting the place of death be fore the sun set Practically every able bodied resident of this city made the trip, and the railroads and trolley lines brought about 4,000 more to the city. Practically every conveyance in the town was pressed into service in an attempt to provide transportation for the crowds, and in the afternoon these proved insufficient and late-comers were forced to make their way to the place on foot. That Andrew Helgellen did not give up his life without a struggle is evi denced by the fact that in one of his clinched hands was a brown tuft of hair which is said to correspond closely with the hair cove: mg the bead of Ray Lamphere, who is being held in the La Porte county jail for burning the house on the Gunness farm and causing the death of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, and also as'a suspect in the murder of Andrew Hel gclien. This now phase of the mysteries was disclosed in the disposition of Dr. J. H. William Meyer, one of the ex amining physicians, who went into an exhaustive examination of HeJgelien’s body. After a full report of the ffearL. lungs, intestines and other parts of the corpse, all of v which were found to be well presetted, he says one of the hands of Helgdien held the lock of brown hair. ~ f
Crowds of over 15,000 visited the Gunness farm to view the scene, while examining physician Dr. Meyer reported finding a tuft of brown hair clenched in the dead Andrew Helgelien's hand. The hair reportedly resembles that of suspect Ray Lamphere, already jailed for the farmhouse fire and deaths.
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · 15 May 1908 · page 6
NEW WITNESS IN THE CASE
That Andrew Helgellen did not give up his life without a struggle is evi denced by the fact that in one of his clinched hands was a brown tuft of hair which is said to correspond closely with the hair cove: mg the bead of Ray Lamphere, who is being held in the La Porte county jail for burning the house on the Gunness farm and causing the death of Mrs. Gunness and her three children, and also as'a suspect in the murder of Andrew Hel gclien. This now phase of the mysteries was disclosed in the disposition of Dr.
See moreSee less
J. H. William Meyer, one of the ex amining physicians, who went into an exhaustive examination of HeJgelien’s body. After a full report of the ffearL. lungs, intestines and other parts of the corpse, all of v which were found to be well presetted, he says one of the hands of Helgdien held the lock of brown hair. ~ f
A dentist who had worked extensively on Mrs. Gunness's teeth examined jaw bone fragments dug up on the Gunness farm and declared they strongly resembled her lower jaw. However, further searching of the farm that morning turned up nothing new.
The Daily Telegram · 15 May 1908 · page 1
JAW DONE Dug Up On Gunness Farm Re sembles Mrs. Gunness's Dentist Declares. LAPORTB, Ind.. May 15?Dr. Nor ton. dentist. Who performed a large amount of work on the teeth of Mrs
Custer Weekly Chronicle · Custer City, S.D. · and 2 other papers
Authorities digging in the burned Gunness farmyard discovered four dismembered bodies, including that of Andrew Helgelien (misspelled Heldgren) of South Dakota, who had come to visit Mrs. Gunness after meeting her through a matrimonial agency. Investigators suspect jailed suspect Ray Lamphere may have knowledge of these additional killings.
Custer Weekly Chronicle · 16 May 1908 · page 2
MURDER SOUTH DAKOTAN; BODY TORN IN PIECES
adult body In the fire was that of Mrs Gunness He roltoiatoa hUt Innocence In the niattoroV bQttlng Die to the house though admitting that ho was on the road and viw the lire that night tle nlho declared that he did not see Mrs Gunnossj kill Hclegein I have no complaint to make abput tho ver dict Things looked pretty blue but thoverdlct might have been woiso Tpnlghf airaiie rriembeiror the jury made thefolllowlng signed stajement We the undersigned juiprs im paneled and sworn In thsscase of the stxte of Indiana veisusJlayLamphere hereby ay that ltwnsour judgment In fhei consideration of this eibo that tho adult body found in tho ruins of thoillro was that of Belle Gunner and that the COBG Was decided by us on an enliioly different proposition P
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The Bon Homme County Independent · Tabor, S.D. · 14 May 1908
The Citizen-Republican · Scotland, S.D. · 14 May 1908
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
Investigators searching the debris of the burned Gunness house in Laporte, Indiana found two additional watches. This find adds to evidence being collected at the site as part of the ongoing investigation.
The Prescott Daily News · 16 May 1908 · page 4
Two More Watchaa Found.
adult body In the fire was that of Mrs Gunness He roltoiatoa hUt Innocence In the niattoroV bQttlng Die to the house though admitting that ho was on the road and viw the lire that night tle nlho declared that he did not see Mrs Gunnossj kill Hclegein I have no complaint to make abput tho ver dict Things looked pretty blue but thoverdlct might have been woiso Tpnlghf airaiie rriembeiror the jury made thefolllowlng signed stajement We the undersigned juiprs im paneled and sworn In thsscase of the stxte of Indiana veisusJlayLamphere hereby ay that ltwnsour judgment In fhei consideration of this eibo that tho adult body found in tho ruins of thoillro was that of Belle Gunner and that the COBG Was decided by us on an enliioly different proposition P
Clipping to come
The Prescott Daily News · Prescott, Ark.
A letter postmarked Brooklyn warned Prosecuting Attorney Smith of La Porte, Ind., that he would be killed within two weeks if he did not stop pursuing the investigation into Mrs. Gunness. The item appears amid a roundup of brief, unrelated news items.
The Prescott Daily News · 16 May 1908 · page 5
MERELY MENTIONED.
TO PRISON LA PORTE, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the mur der of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to their home, was last night found guilty of arson and sentenced to state's prison for from one to 21 years. He was also fined $5,000 and disfranchised for five years. The case had been with the jury since 5:30 o'clock Wednesday evening. Lamphere's attorney made a statement in which he declared he would immediately prepare a nio-
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
Coroner Mack announces he will return an open verdict Monday regarding whether Belle Gunness and her children died in the house fire, and plans to drag Fish Trap Lake for more victims. A report from Milwaukee claims a friend, Mrs. Emma Bussell, saw Gunness alive there that week.
Like Belle Gun nets. Dgallala, Neb., Nov. 27. —Sheriff fc°al of this city has been examining the record of Mrs. Jennie Minor, who charge that John Dale Smith, who is believed to be her husband, killed Vol ley Mann near Ogallala, A striking ’’eseniblance between the woman and the published pictures of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the La Porte murderess, was Boted. Careful inquiry that followed releaved that Mrs. Minor has a long with the police of numerous
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A dentist identified a charred jawbone fragment from the farmhouse ruins as belonging to Belle Gunness, based on the pattern of missing teeth matching his dental work on her. The prosecutor declared this definitive proof that she died in the fire, refuting rumors she had escaped.
Like Belle Gun nets. Dgallala, Neb., Nov. 27. —Sheriff fc°al of this city has been examining the record of Mrs. Jennie Minor, who charge that John Dale Smith, who is believed to be her husband, killed Vol ley Mann near Ogallala, A striking ’’eseniblance between the woman and the published pictures of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the La Porte murderess, was Boted. Careful inquiry that followed releaved that Mrs. Minor has a long with the police of numerous
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A newspaper filler column of brief topical quips mentions that the Gunness murder farm has become LaPorte's Coney Island, drawing daily crowds and new attractions. It also jokes that Mrs. Gunness proved herself a match for Bluebeard.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 4
The faot that the body o f Mrs. Gunness was not found, that the fact that she was really dearf was estab lished only by circumstantial evi dence, probably saved the neck of the man Lamphere whom the Jury was convinc?d burned the house and her body and those of her children. Twenty years of quiet he will have to think It over. If there are gold nuggets lying round on the beach for geese to eat Is it not pretty good demonstration of the truth that lies under the faith of those mining optimists that have always declared we would yet have a mine in Skagway?
See moreSee less
When Uncle Joe says he believes the tariff will be revised this next session it sounds like a confession that he has grown Impotent. Emperor William needs an editor.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The article reflects on Mrs. Gunness, the 'multi-murderer of La Porte, Ind.,' as a case of criminological interest given the skeletons found on her farm. It notes that despite the work of specialists like Lombroso, science has not adequately explained the causes of such depraved crime.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 4
MONSTER CRIMINAL.
RAY WHERE GOES TO THE PEN IN STYLE He Is in a Position to Choose the Kind of Clothes HeWants. La Porte, Nov. 27. Ray Lamphcre, convicted of having set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, went to prison in style today. He rode from the interurban station to the prison gate in an automobile. Stepping up to the window of Chief Clerk Lorimer. the sheriff handed that official the commitment papers and the prisoner's name was entered upon the register. He was assigned number 4140 and ihen passed along to the receiving clerk, who es corted him to the Bertillion room.
See moreSee less
There he was given a bath, photo graphed, measured and garbed in a prison suit of grey, the middle grade. I'pon his future conduct depends whether he will be given stripes or a better grade of blue suit.
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
Andrew K. Helgelein of Mansfield, S.D., the last man killed by Belle Gunness, was the first victim given a Christian burial, interred at Patton's cemetery in La Porte. The body was released after Coroner Mack received Bertillon identification reports matching records from the Minnesota penitentiary at Stillwater.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 16 May 1908 · page 1
BURY GUNNESS VICTIM
RAY LA WHERE CONVICTED Escaped Charge of Killing Mrs Gun ness But Found Guilty of Arson Laporte Ind Nov SRay Lam phere charged with arson and the murder of Mrs Belle Gunnes and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness home on April 28 wan found
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
The report identifies Olaf Jenson, about 23, formerly of Christiania, as a possible victim after he left Carroll County, Indiana two years ago, lured by Mrs. Gunness' marriage advertisements, and traveled to La Porte. He has not been heard from since.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 16 May 1908 · page 6
RAY LA WHERE CONVICTED Escaped Charge of Killing Mrs Gun ness But Found Guilty of Arson Laporte Ind Nov SRay Lam phere charged with arson and the murder of Mrs Belle Gunnes and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness home on April 28 wan found I guilty of arson last night by the jury which had the case under considera tion for twentyfour hours Within five minutes after the verdict was reported Judge Richter sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twentyone years Attorney Worden for the defense declared the verdict to be ridiculous If he was guilty at all said he he was guilty of murder He should have been acquitted If you suffer from constipation and liver trouble Foleys Orino Laxative will cure you permanently by stimu lating the digestive organs so they will act naturally Foleys Orino Lax ative does not gripe is pleasant to take and you do not have to take lax atives continually after taking Orino Why continue to be the slave of pills and tablets Solrf by all druggists
Clipping to come
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · Globe, Ariz.
A cable from Christiania (Oslo) reports that news of the La Porte murders has caused a sensation there, with fears that a missing young Norwegian man may be another victim of the accused murderess. Friends are reportedly seeking to have the American legation investigate his whereabouts.
Daily Arizona Silver Belt · 16 May 1908 · page 6
FEARS FOR YOUNG NORWEGIAN
been acquitted The motion for a 1 new trial will be baaed on the courts Instructions that they could find Lamphere guilty of arson Should the case be carried to the supreme court and sent back for re trial Lamphere could not be tried on any charge in this particular case ex cepting arson the crime of which he was convicted However in an event of that kind the state would elect to try him on one of the other indict ments probably the Helgelein case
Clipping to come
The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.
A special report from Christiania, Norway describes Belle Gunness's childhood, noting she assisted her father Peter Paulsen, a traveling magician, performing as a rope dancer at fairs. It states her siblings also took part in the show and that her father eventually retired to property near Trondheim.
The Daily Sentinel · 16 May 1908 · page 1
THE MURDERESS WAS A ROPE DANCER
LAMPHERE GOES TO PRISON Given indeterminate Term on Convifr tion for Arson. L&porte, Ind., 'Nov. 28.—Before Say Lamphere, under sentence from two to twenty-one years, was taken to the state prison in Mictigan City to be gin his term he received a visit from his aged mother. Though not with him during the trial she came here fiom South Bend in order to say good bye to bim and cheer him up. The meeting of mother and son was a pathetic one, the mother breaking down and crying as she clasped her son in her arms.
See moreSee less
The prisoner bore up well, though there was a mistiness about his eyes. Later in the day Lamphere was taken to prison. In a statement be said that he intended to become an exemplary prisoner so as to get the benefit of all good time and would be paroled after his first two years. Lamphere, who was charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson by the Jury after it had been out about twenty four hours. Attorney Worden of the defense said that a motion for a new trial would be made and, should it be re fused, an appeal to the Indiana su preme court would follow. The In diana supreme court is two years be hind in its work and so this ise could not be reached until after he had served the minimum time of his sentence.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Prosecuting Attorney Ralph Smith declares a charred jawbone fragment found in the farmhouse ruins conclusively proves the body in the cellar was Belle Gunness, based on dental evidence from Dr. O.P. Norton matching remaining teeth. The report also notes the burial of Andrew Helgelein, identified through fingerprint comparison with Minnesota prison records.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 4
ON MRS. GUNNESS DEAD Prosecuting Attorney Declares Piece of Skull Gives Conclusive Proof. DENTIST GIVES EVIDENCE
State Makes Another Hit. LaPorte, Ind Nov. 25.—The state scored a victory today in the Lamphere trial, when Judge Richter, after ex haustive arguments by both sides, an nounced that he would instruct the jury that if the evidence showed that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, even if the fire did not cause the death of the persons therein, the jury must find him guilty of arson. The state scored another victory when it secured the Incorporation in the instructions of a paragraph by which, if the jury finds that any one of the four persons in the house lost his life as the result, of the fire, and that Lamphere set the fire, then it must find Lamphere guilty of murder or manslaughter.
A dentist has declared that a jawbone recovered from the farm ruins belongs to Mrs. Gunness, based on dental work. This identification is presented as resolving questions about whether she died in the fire.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 16 May 1908 · page 7
JAWBONE IDENTIFIED
JAVVBONEJDENTIFIED. Dentist Declares It Is That of , - Mrs. Gunness. HELGELEIN'S BODY. INTERRED Laid to Rest Aft.r Baing Examined by Bartillon Experts, Whoie Figures
Dental evidence from a charred jawbone fragment found in the Gunness farmhouse ruins matched Mrs. Gunness's known dental characteristics, bolstering the prosecutor's claim that she died in the fire rather than escaping. Separately, Andrew Helgelein's body was released for Christian burial after Bertillon experts compared his remains to prison records from Stillwater penitentiary.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 16 May 1908 · page 7
HELGELEIN'S BODY INTERRED
Laporte,' Ind., May jfl.-"Ideutlflca-Hon of the piece of Jnwbone taken from the rulna of the tJunness farm house at a portion of Mrs. Belle Gun ness' skull bears out most conclusively the contentious of the aiate regarding the identity of the bodies found In the cellar on April 28. It Is the clinching bit of evidence which should set at rest the rumors that Mrs. Gunness had es caped." . . ' This statement was made by Italpa N. Smith, prosecuting attorney. It fol lowed a report from Dr. C.'P. Norton, a dentist, who found that the piece of charred bone presented characteristics which he had observed while working on the teeth of Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness. Only two natural teeth, a cuspid on each side of the lower jaw, had remained in the woman's mouth, and the piece of bone found shows that all the teeth ex cept the cuspids had been extracted from the jaw of the skull to which it belonged. : The first of the Gunness victims to be buried with Christian rites was bur ied by lantern light in a cemetery on the outskirts of Laporte. The corpse was that of Andrew K. Helgelein of Mansfield, S. D., the last man to meet his death In the trap to which Mrs. Gunness lured her victims.
A dental expert confirms charred remains as Mrs. Gunness's based on her distinctive teeth, while Bertillon experts identify another body as Andrew Helgelein, who is given a Christian burial. Separately, Norwegian sources trace Belle Gunness's early life as the daughter of a traveling magician father and detail her confirmation and first marriage.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 16 May 1908 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
JAWBONE IDENTIFIED.
Dentist Declares It Is That of Mrs. Gunness.
See moreSee less
HELGELEIN'S BODY INTERRED
Laid to Rest After Being Examined by Bertillon Experts, Whose Figures Are Compared With Measurements of Woman's Supposed Victim.
Laporte, Ind., May 16.--"Identification of the piece of jawbone taken from the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse as a portion of Mrs. Belle Gunness' skull bears out most conclusively the contentions of the state regarding the identity of the bodies found in the cellar on April 28. It is the clinching bit of evidence which should set at rest the rumors that Mrs. Gunness had escaped."
This statement was made by Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney. It followed a report from Dr. C. P. Norton, a dentist, who found that the piece of charred bone presented characteristics which he had observed while working on the teeth of Mrs. Gunness. Only two natural teeth, a cuspid on each side of the lower jaw, had remained in the woman's mouth, and the piece of bone found shows that all the teeth except the cuspids had been extracted from the jaw of the skull to which it belonged.
The first of the Gunness victims to be buried with Christian rites was buried by lantern light in a cemetery on the outskirts of Laporte. The corpse was that of Andrew K. Helgelein of Mansfield, S. D., the last man to meet his death in the trap to which Mrs. Gunness lured her victims.
Body Examined by Experts.
The body was released for burial after Coroner Mack had received the reports of Bertillon experts who have examined it and compared their findings with figures taken from the records of the Minnesota penitentiary at Stillwater. Two officials of the Michigan City prison performed the work, and Edward A. Evens of the Chicago police identification bureau did similar work. Both reports were to the effect that it was the body of Helgelein.
The search of the Gunness premises revealed little of importance. The screening of the ashes produced several additional bits of bone, but none of them is of sufficient size or well enough preserved to furnish proof of their origin.
Some relics showing that Mrs. Gunness had made a study of surgical lore were picked up. Charred leaves of books on which sufficient print remained to show that the folios were devoted to anatomy were found. Another ruined book was a treatise on hypnotism.
Andrew Helgelien, the last man lured to his death by Belle Gunness, is given Christian burial in La Porte after Bertillon experts examined his remains. Separately, a dentist confirms a jawbone found on the farm is human and likely Gunness's own, based on distinctive dental work including gold he had placed.
The San Francisco Call · 16 May 1908 · page 5
ONE DEATH FARM VICTIM INTERRED
LA PORTK. Ind., Nov. 3n.-Attorneys f"r Ray Iamphere, who has begun his term of Imprisonment for conviction of arson In connection with the burning of the Ujn ness house, In which Mrs. Gunness and three children lost their lives, today took an appeal to the Indiana supreme court, after Judge Rlchter had overruled a mo tion for a new trial. The motion rr a new trial tes based on the allegation that the court erred In refusing to give nine instructions submitted by the de fense by giving nine other alleged objec tionable Instructions. One of these was the one under which the jury brought In a verdict of arson, though the indictment waa for murder by arson.
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Andrew Helgelein, the last known victim lured by Belle Gunness, was buried with Lutheran rites after Bertillon experts compared his remains to prison records. A dentist who had treated Gunness's teeth examined a jawbone found on the farm and said it strongly resembled hers, pending confirmation from a gold filling.
Los Angeles Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS VICTIM DECENTLY BURIED BODY OF A. K. HELGELEIN IS INTERRED JAWBONE MAY BE THAT OF MRS. GUNNESS
Mrs. Eleanor Merron Cowper, a widely-known playwright and actress, fatally shot herself in her room al the St. Regis hotel. New York. John Gardner Coolidge, the Amori can minister to Nicaragua, resigued from the diplomatic service. Ray Lamphere, charged With the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunn'ess and her three children, by setting fire to th 6 Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson at Laporte, Ind. Judge Richter sentenced him to the state prison for an indeterminate term oi from two to 21 years, lined him $5,000 and disfranchised him for five years.
See moreSee less
At Vermillion, S. D. Mrs. Christina Clark, accused of the murder of her divorced husband, was found guilty of manslaughter in the second degree. Public Printer John S. Leech re signed and Samuel B. Donnelly of Brooklyn was appointed to the place. Wilbur Carr, who murdered Marshal Thomas Nicholson of Gowrie, la., last summer, was sentenced to life impris onment in the Fort Madison peni tentiary. George R. Sheldon, treasurer of the Republican national committee, filed the list of contributions for the recent national campaign. It shows 12,330 contributors. The total amount con tributed was $1,579,578.27.
Clipping to come
The Freeman · Indianapolis, Ind.
A newspaper miscellany column lists various brief items including farm weather, politics, and a sarcastic one-line remark that 'Mrs. Gunness did a land office business.' The reference reflects the widespread public fascination with the unfolding Gunness murder farm investigation.
The Freeman · 16 May 1908 · page 4
SATURDAY, MAY 16, 1908. Been having corn "sizzling” weath er. Mrs. Gunness did a land office busi ness. The farmers are delighted with the prospects of good weather after the long gloom spell.
A dentist's examination of a charred jawbone fragment from the farmhouse ruins is declared conclusive proof that Belle Gunness died in the fire, according to the prosecuting attorney. The report also describes the burial of victim Andrew Helgelein after Bertillon identification, and further search of the ashes yielding only minor bone fragments and evidence of her study of surgical lore.
New-York Tribune · 16 May 1908 · page 4
MRS. GUNNESS DEAD. Fragments of Bone Conclusive—Studied Anatomy and Hypnotism.
MONTICELLO, The Ne ws-Seinii tar. of Mem-* phis, has been thrown into the hands of a Receiver. The paper failed to meet its current expen ses. Rnv Lamphere, who was re centlv tried at Michigan City. Indiana, on a charge of murder ing Mrs. Bella Gunness, the
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Screening of ash and debris from the Gunness cellar, done to search for the woman's gold tooth, turned up two watches and bone fragments including a suspected jawbone piece. Dentist Norton believes the jaw fragment is part of Mrs. Gunness's jaw based on its shape and missing teeth, though it remains undetermined whether other skull fragments belong to her or to the children.
The Washington Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 3
MRS GUNNESS IS DEAD Dentist Identifies Piece of Jawbone Found In Laporte Debris
L5 a l THURSDAY DEC 3 1908 t NOTWITHSTANDING that Mrs Gunness was an undesirable citi zen whose removal was a boon to v the world the jury at Laporte I Ind trying Roy Lamphere on charge of causing the death of O Mrs Gunness and herthildren found him guilty and gave him twentyone years in prison 1 r x THERE is said to be a movement on foot among the county boards of control of the Burley Tobacco Society to make President Clar ence LeBus a Republican an in dependent candidate for Govern sor of Kentucky next term Three years is a long way off and things are liable to happen meanwhile + IF the next Congress under takes genuine tariff reform of the RooseveltTaft kind there r will be something Joing on the It r part of the sndpattcrs If the I Republican leaders were not so J rf smart there would be grave dan r ger of a split of the Republican r party but the Democrats ar e =
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
Investigators screening the debris from the Gunness farm fire found two watches and bone fragments, including what Dentist Norton identified as part of a woman's jawbone missing teeth forward to the cuspid. Authorities were still determining whether some remains belonged to the children rather than Mrs. Gunness.
The Washington Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 3
SURE MRS. GUNNESS IS DEAD.
L5 a l THURSDAY DEC 3 1908 t NOTWITHSTANDING that Mrs Gunness was an undesirable citi zen whose removal was a boon to v the world the jury at Laporte I Ind trying Roy Lamphere on charge of causing the death of O Mrs Gunness and herthildren found him guilty and gave him twentyone years in prison 1 r x THERE is said to be a movement on foot among the county boards of control of the Burley Tobacco Society to make President Clar ence LeBus a Republican an in dependent candidate for Govern sor of Kentucky next term Three years is a long way off and things are liable to happen meanwhile + IF the next Congress under takes genuine tariff reform of the RooseveltTaft kind there r will be something Joing on the It r part of the sndpattcrs If the I Republican leaders were not so J rf smart there would be grave dan r ger of a split of the Republican r party but the Democrats ar e =
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A satirical newspaper column making light commentary on various current events briefly references the Gunness case, joking that Indiana novelists could not match the facts of the case even across three trials. The remark is an aside within a miscellany of unrelated political and social jokes, not a direct news report.
The Washington Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 6
that is to be. Mrs. Eleanor Merron Cowper, a widely-known playwright and actress, fatally shot herself in her room at the St. Regis hotel, New York. John Gardner Coolidge, the Ameri can minister to Nicaragua, resigned from the diplomatic service. Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting fire to the Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson at Laporte, Ind. Judge Richter sentenced him to the state
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Andrew Helgelein was buried, marking the start of the final stage of the Gunness farm investigation, while two more bodies were tentatively identified as Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg. Seven bodies remain unidentified, and investigators doubt the cause of death will ever be determined.
Evening Star · 16 May 1908 · page 5
BURIAL OF CADAVERS
An editorial writer in World's Work for September asserts that the Belgians are the thriftiest and most contented of any people in Europe and few of them emigrate, and at the same time they are the greatest beer drink ers in the world. Ray Lamphere, who was charged at La Porte, Indiana, with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch fiend, and her three children by setting fire to the house, has been found guilty of arson and sentenced to serve an inde terminate period of from two to twenty years.
See moreSee less
Frank H. Hitchcock has been offered and has accepted the portfolio of postmaster general. This is a fitting reward for Mr. Hitchcock's excellent work in conducting the republican presidential campaign. It is the first and only cabinet position so far filled
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 1 other paper
Dental evidence confirms the jawbone found in the ruins belonged to Belle Gunness, and three experts identify the first barnyard body as Andrew Helgelein. The report states that the murder method and identities of the other seven bodies may never be known, leaving Ray Lamphere's role to be settled only by grand jury and trial.
Evening Star · 16 May 1908 · page 5
QUESTIONS FOR THE COURT
An editorial writer in World's Work for September asserts that the Belgians are the thriftiest and most contented of any people in Europe and few of them emigrate, and at the same time they are the greatest beer drink ers in the world. Ray Lamphere, who was charged at La Porte, Indiana, with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch fiend, and her three children by setting fire to the house, has been found guilty of arson and sentenced to serve an inde terminate period of from two to twenty years.
See moreSee less
Frank H. Hitchcock has been offered and has accepted the portfolio of postmaster general. This is a fitting reward for Mr. Hitchcock's excellent work in conducting the republican presidential campaign. It is the first and only cabinet position so far filled
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas · 16 May 1908
Evening Star · Washington, D.C. · and 2 other papers
The case is being handed to the grand jury and courts, as recent developments have mostly involved chasing down false or misleading clues. LaPorte is returning to normal after an unprecedented wave of press coverage, with nearly a million words transmitted about the case in eleven days.
Evening Star · 16 May 1908 · page 5
QUESTIONS FOR THE COURT
Gunness could not have gone through the Are and that the four persons whose bodies were found in the rains of the lire died of poisoning.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 2 papers
The Globe-Republican · Dodge City, Kan. · 21 May 1908
The Chanute Times · Chanute, Kan. · 22 May 1908
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
The defense for Ray Lamphere is mounting a complete denial that the bodies found in the Gunness death house have been properly identified, shifting the burden of proof to the state. Attorney Ellsworth Wier will represent Lamphere, funded from an unknown source, and will contest identifications made by Harvey Flava of the Michigan penitentiary and Chicago police official Edward A. Evans.
The Washington Times · 16 May 1908 · page 2
DENIES IDENTITY OF GUNNESS DEAD
Must. Disprove Gunnees Death. Attorney Worden contended that the question to determine was wheth er Ray Lamphere Is guilty of having burned Mrs. Gunness and the children -to death. Continuing, he said: "First, It will be necessary to prove the identification of the bodies. We be lieve that we will be able to show that It was not her body. Even that will not settle the question of Ray Lanv phere's guilt or innocence. Our evi dence will show that Mrs. Ounness is still alive. She had a motive In set ting fire to the house and escaping."
See moreSee less
The state rested Friday noon in the trial of Ray Lamphere, accused of the murder of Mrs. Belle Ounness and her three children by setting Art to her ^vv-^K bouse, when the defense finished the cross-examination of Deputy Sheriff Anstfss.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A letter suggests Belle Gunness may have sent Jennie Olson to a convent in California, though not Los Angeles as first reported. The defense theorizes Olson is living under a new name or still cloistered where news of the Indiana murders has not reached her.
The Washington Times · 16 May 1908 · page 2
"'-'Sir &]&*%" deny having seen Mrs. Gunness kill Helgelein second, Anstiss' statement that Lamphere had said he would plead guilty to arBon were It not for his mother. The defense had decided that Lam* phere would not take the stand, but now Lamphere's lawyers find that un less their client is placed on the stand the admissions said to have been made by Lamphere to Anstiss cannot be controverted.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Lamphere's legal team, led by new attorney Ellsworth Weir, denies all identification of bodies found in the Gunness house and rejects charges against him, arguing the body identified as Helgelien was too decomposed for certain identification. The defense also presents correspondence suggesting Jennie Olson may have been sent to a convent in California, possibly still alive under a new name.
The Washington Times · 16 May 1908 · page 2
DENIES IDENTITY OF GUNNESS DEAD
S( aure and bring four or five hundred dollars. This! man, whose name he does not give, came back to Oglesby in January. 1907, shortly after Jen nie Olson dlsapeared from the Gun ness place bringing with him a young wife, and Marsh declares this woman is the image of Jennie Olson's jpicreMarsh says he is in danger of be ing kill'ed, but he wants Sheriff Smut zer to come to Oglesby at once and to bring with him eJnnie Olson's sis ters, who live in Chicago, so that they may identify the woman.
See moreSee less
Marsh also thinks that the man is the fellow who wrote Mayor Darrow from Chicago. on November 23, say ing he was the man who accompan ied the suppose*! Mrg. Gunness to Laporte July 9./ arsh says he is a miner, employed by the Illinois Zinc company. It is not likely that any investigation of the story will be made by Prosecutor Smith or Sheriff Smutzer, but the lat ter stated tonight that he would prob ably send a detective to, Oglesby to interview Marsh. vv :.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Reports describe the Lamphere defense's strategy to challenge identification of Gunness's body as too decomposed and mutilated for certainty, using expert witnesses. It also reveals correspondence suggesting Jennie Olson may have been sent to a California convent and could still be alive there.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 16 May 1908 · page 2
S( aure and bring four or five hundred dollars. This! man, whose name he does not give, came back to Oglesby in January. 1907, shortly after Jen nie Olson dlsapeared from the Gun ness place bringing with him a young wife, and Marsh declares this woman is the image of Jennie Olson's jpicreMarsh says he is in danger of be ing kill'ed, but he wants Sheriff Smut zer to come to Oglesby at once and to bring with him eJnnie Olson's sis ters, who live in Chicago, so that they may identify the woman.
See moreSee less
Marsh also thinks that the man is the fellow who wrote Mayor Darrow from Chicago. on November 23, say ing he was the man who accompan ied the suppose*! Mrg. Gunness to Laporte July 9./ arsh says he is a miner, employed by the Illinois Zinc company. It is not likely that any investigation of the story will be made by Prosecutor Smith or Sheriff Smutzer, but the lat ter stated tonight that he would prob ably send a detective to, Oglesby to interview Marsh. vv :.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Diggers at the Gunness death farm uncovered two more watches, suggesting at least ten male victims though only nine bodies had been found so far. Detectives also pursued an accomplice who delivered mail and lured a Cleveland man toward the farm with a photograph of Gunness.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 16 May 1908 · page 4
TWO WATCHES DUG UP TODAY! GIVE EVIDENCE THAT RURAL BORGIA'S MALE VICTIMS NUMBERED TEN IN ALL
Ilurnetl tlio Gunness Home (jBp-irte, Intl., Nov, 20 Buy Liunpliere, clmrged with tlio murder of Mru. Belle Gunness and her tlireo children by eettlng fire to tlio Gunnete lioufo April 28, was thin evening found Ruilty of ariort by the Jury, which had the cine since 0:80 last evening. Withiu live mluuten after the
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Detectives in northern Indiana searched for a male accomplice who allegedly collected mail for Belle Gunness and tried to lure victims like Fred Hafle to her farm. Meanwhile, a boy identified Ray Lamphere as the man seen fleeing the burning house, and a watch found on him was linked to victim Andrew Helgelein.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 16 May 1908 · page 4
Mrs. Eleanor Merron Cowper, a widely-known playwright and actress, falally shot herself in her room at the St. Regis hotel, New York. John Gardner Coolidge, the Ameri can minister to Nicaragua, resigned from the diplomatic service. Kay Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting Are to the Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson at Eaporte, Ind. Judge Richter sentenced him to the state prison for an indeterminate term of from two to 21 years, fined him &,uuu and disfranchised him for five years.
See moreSee less
At Vermillion, S. D. Mrs. Christina Clark, accused of the murder of her divorced husband, was found guilty of manslaughter in the second degree. Public Printer John S. Leech re elcrnail nrwl Rami lei B. Donnelly of Brooklvn was annotated to the place, Wilbur Carr, who murdered Marshal Thomas Nicholson of Gowrle, la., last summer, was sentenced to life impris onment in the Fort Madison pent tentiarv. George R. Sheldon, treasurer of the Republican national committee, filed the list of contributions for the recent national campaign. It shows 12,330 contributors. The total amount con tributed was $1,579,578.27.
Clipping to come
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa
Detectives positively identified the watch found on Lamphere as belonging to murder victim Andrew Helgelein, and Lamphere reportedly confessed to Deputy Sheriff Anstiss about finding Mrs. Gunness burying Helgelein's body. Detective Smith and Pinkerton agents also traced Gunness' past marriage bureau business and her many aliases while hunting for her accomplice.
Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 16 May 1908 · page 4
Lamphere expressed a similar belief in the first extended statement lie has made to other than his attorneys since the trial began. ITe said he consid ered himself lucky, in view of the evi dence produced, in getting off as easily as he has. lie maintained his inno cence, however. Contrary to expectations, Lamphere's attorneys made no motion for a new trial. Unofficially, however, they ex pressed such intention, but in view of Lamphere's light sentence in compari son with the heavy punishment which another jury might bring in were the new trial secured there is little likeli hood of his being tried again.
See moreSee less
In his cell Lamphere professed that he expected acquittal, but his unwont ed buopancy belied his words. Ho re sponded to congratulations on the light ness of the vordice with whole heart edness.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A California nun reports a girl resembling missing Jennie Olson has turned up at her convent, prompting Prosecutor Smith to investigate. Separately, a Cincinnati woman says her brother vanished after visiting Gunness with money in February 1908, challenging the belief that Andrew Helgelein was her last victim; Helgelein's body is buried in Laporte.
The Lake County Times · 16 May 1908 · page 1
LAMPHERE 18 GUILTY. „ , .. - Jurors Return n Verdict Charging Arson. Ray Lmphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house at Laporte, lnd., April 28, was Thursday evening found guilty of arson by the Jury, which had the case since 5:30 o'clock WednesA day evening. Within five minutes af ter the verdict was reported Judge Richter had sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years.
See moreSee less
The verdict was reached within half an hour after the Jurors had returned from supper. Word wus conveyed to Hailiff Metz, who at once telephoned Judge Richter and the attorneys in the case. The lights In the big court room were turned on, and within fif teen minutes the court was filled. Lamphere was brought over from the
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
Andrew Helgelein, believed Mrs. Gunness's last victim, was buried in Patton's cemetery after the coroner released his body following Bertillon examination. A letter from a Cincinnati woman suggesting her missing brother may also have fallen victim casts doubt on Helgelein being the final one.
The Lake County Times · 16 May 1908 · page 1
GUilTY OF ARSON Man Accused of Murder of Mrs Belle Gunness and Children Gets a Compromise Verdict Has Been Sentenced to State Prison for Indeterminate Term of From
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A jawbone recovered from the ashes of the Gunness farmhouse in Laporte has been positively identified by her dentist as belonging to Belle Gunness. This identification was presented as forensic confirmation of her skull among the fire debris.
The Lake County Times · 16 May 1908 · page 4
Laporlo IndRay Lampherc charged with the murder of Mrs Hello Gunnoss and her three children ly Bolting tiro to tho Gunness home April 28 was on Thursday evening found guilty of arson by the jury which had the case since 530 oclock Wednesday evening Within five min utes after the verdict was reported Judge Richter had sentenced the do Pendant to time state prison nt Michi gan City for an Indeterminate term of from two to twentyone years lined him 5000 and disfranchised him for jflvo years Attorney Vorden for tho defense cald Thursday night that a motion for n new trial would be made and phould It he refused an appeal to the Indiana supreme court would follow Should the case be carried to tho supreme court and sent back for re trial Lamphere could not be tried on nny chargo In this particular case ex cepting arson the crime of which ho was convicted However In an event of that kindtho state would elect to try him on one of the Indictments probably tire Helgelcln case Members of the Jury are reticent in discussing what occurred In tho jury room but enough has been learn ed to know that but for two mem bers Lamphere would have been found guilty of murder or manslaughter the verdict being a compromise Sev eral members of tho jury It Is un derstood held out long for murder In the first degree with a life sentence So far as could be learned nono was ilqr hanging o
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
This is a routine local news column from Whiting, Indiana, covering social visits, club meetings, illnesses, and minor court cases. One item notes that Charles Wellette and friends went to LaPorte to see the Gunness farm, reflecting public curiosity about the case.
The Lake County Times · 16 May 1908 · page 6
WHITING NEWS
that is to be. Mrs. Eleanor Merron Cowper, a widely-known playwright and actress, fatally shot herself in her room at the St. Regis hotel, New York. John Gardner Coolidge, the Ameri can minister to Nicaragua, resigned from the diplomatic service. Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting fire to the Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson at Laporte, Ind. Judge Richter sentenced him to the state prison for an indeterminate term of from two to 21 years, fined him $5,000 and disfranchised him for five years.
See moreSee less
At Vermillion, S. D. Mrs. Christina Clark, accused of the murder of her divorced husband, was found guilty of manslaughter in the second degree. Public Printer John S. Leech re signed and Samuel B. Donnelly of Brooklyn was appointed to the place. Wilbur Carr, who murdered Marshal Thomas Nicholson of Gowrie, la., last summer, was sentenced to life impris onment in the Fort Madison peni tentiary-
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The defense for Ray Lamphere, backed by an expert lawyer and unknown funding, will deny all identifications of bodies found in the Gunness house and challenge the state to prove them absolutely. Correspondence suggests Jennie Olson was sent to a California convent, and a dentist has identified a jawbone as Belle Gunness's by dental fillings.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 16 May 1908 · page 1
IN THE GUNNESS CASE AT LAPORTE
ies That Are Found. EXPERT CRIMINAL LAWYER IS ENGAGED. Money Is Being Furnished From an Unknown Source Jennie Olson Did Go to California Convent. Laporte, Ind.. May 16. A complete denial of all the identification of bod ies found in the Gunnesb house, throw ing on to the state the burden of prov ing their identity and a;i absolute de nial of every incriminating act charg ed against lamphere amf the intro duction of important evidence on be half of tin? prisoner is t.ie latest sen sation sprung by the defense.
See moreSee less
Ells worth Weir, the famous criminal law yer will become counsel for Ijumphere and money is being fminshed for the defense from an unknown source. The defense will attempt to prove the body of Helgelein as identified by expert Harvey of Michigan City peni tentiary, was in such an advanced state of decomposition and mutilated tiiat no certain identification was pos sible. The startling feature of the days developments is the correspon dence between Attorney Worden and Mother Superior of Convert Califor nia, which indicates Mrs. Gunness ac tually did send Jennie Olson to the convent. A farmer near Springville locked a woman book agent, in his barn for three hours Thursday night, believing he had the arch murderess. He re fused to release the frightened wom an until the sheriff arrived. Dr. It. T. Norton, Mrs. Ginness's dentist has identified a jawbone found in the ruins as that of the woman. He recognized it by several of the teeth, which were filled with a special kind of cement. None of the gold or por celain teeth has yet been found. The formation of Mrs. Gunness's jaw bone, was peculiar, the dentist de clared, several of the back teeth hav ing been removed. The cavities were filled in the jawbone by Dr. Norton, who says he also found parts of the ce ment, he used at the time. A diseased condition of the jawbone also aided the dentist in making the identifica tion. The Laporte prosecutors of Lam phere were overjoyed at the state ment of Dr. Norton and pressure is be ing brought on Coroner Mack to pre vent an open verdict. Lamphere was on the verge of a con fession early today when State's Attor ney Smith visited him in his cell. '"Say, Smith," he said, "you come back here in twenty minutes. I've got rtomething to tell you." "All right." the prosecutor said. "I'll be back at-" "Oh. never mind." broke in Lamrhere. "I've changed my mind. I thought I'd confess I set fire to the Gunness home." "Why don't, you." Smith asked. "Well. I just happened to think' that my mother would feel awful bad if I told such a lie as that." The case against Kay Lamphere probably will be brought before the Grand jury Monday, according to the first revision of the schedule in this regard. The time of his trial is less certain. Until Sheriff Smutzer has exhausted the possibilities of the farm house it is scarcely likely that the case will be docketed for trial. Accord ing to the present rate of progress this will mean a delay of months.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The defense attorney Ellsworth Weir is engaged for Ray Lamphere, while Dr. Norton the dentist claims to have identified Mrs. Gunness's jawbone by distinctive dental work and cement fillings. Lamphere almost confesses to setting the fire but stops himself, and prosecutors debate delaying the trial pending further investigation of the farmhouse ruins.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 16 May 1908 · page 1
LAWYER IS ENGAGED
California Convent. Laporte, Ind.. May 16. A complete denial of all the identification of bod ies found in the Gunnesb house, throw ing on to the state the burden of prov ing their identity and a;i absolute de nial of every incriminating act charg ed against lamphere amf the intro duction of important evidence on be half of tin? prisoner is t.ie latest sen sation sprung by the defense. Ells worth Weir, the famous criminal law yer will become counsel for Ijumphere and money is being fminshed for the defense from an unknown source.
See moreSee less
The defense will attempt to prove the body of Helgelein as identified by expert Harvey of Michigan City peni tentiary, was in such an advanced state of decomposition and mutilated tiiat no certain identification was pos sible. The startling feature of the days developments is the correspon dence between Attorney Worden and Mother Superior of Convert Califor nia, which indicates Mrs. Gunness ac tually did send Jennie Olson to the convent. A farmer near Springville locked a woman book agent, in his barn for three hours Thursday night, believing he had the arch murderess. He re fused to release the frightened wom an until the sheriff arrived. Dr. It. T. Norton, Mrs. Ginness's dentist has identified a jawbone found in the ruins as that of the woman. He recognized it by several of the teeth, which were filled with a special kind of cement. None of the gold or por celain teeth has yet been found. The formation of Mrs. Gunness's jaw bone, was peculiar, the dentist de clared, several of the back teeth hav ing been removed. The cavities were filled in the jawbone by Dr. Norton, who says he also found parts of the ce ment, he used at the time. A diseased condition of the jawbone also aided the dentist in making the identifica tion. The Laporte prosecutors of Lam phere were overjoyed at the state ment of Dr. Norton and pressure is be ing brought on Coroner Mack to pre vent an open verdict. Lamphere was on the verge of a con fession early today when State's Attor ney Smith visited him in his cell. '"Say, Smith," he said, "you come back here in twenty minutes. I've got rtomething to tell you." "All right." the prosecutor said. "I'll be back at-" "Oh. never mind." broke in Lamrhere. "I've changed my mind. I thought I'd confess I set fire to the Gunness home." "Why don't, you." Smith asked. "Well. I just happened to think' that my mother would feel awful bad if I told such a lie as that." The case against Kay Lamphere probably will be brought before the Grand jury Monday, according to the first revision of the schedule in this regard. The time of his trial is less certain. Until Sheriff Smutzer has exhausted the possibilities of the farm house it is scarcely likely that the case will be docketed for trial. Accord ing to the present rate of progress this will mean a delay of months.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Coroner Mack announces he will return an open verdict of 'death from causes unknown' regarding Mrs. Gunness, her children, and two other victims found at the farm. Lamphere's defense attorneys complain about restricted access to their client while witnesses are subpoenaed to testify before the jury.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 16 May 1908 · page 7
SENSATION SPRUNG IN THE GUNNESS CASE AT LAPORTE
LAMPHERL GUILTY OF ARSON. Jury Ignores Murder Charge—Sen tence from 2 to 21 Years. Hay Larnphere was found guilty of arson after the jury had been out twen ty-six hours in Laporte, Ind. Judge John C. Richter immediately sentenced him to the penitentiary for an indeter minate term of from two to twenty one years and assessed a fine of $5,000. The verdict was in the nature of a compromise, ten of the jurors having held out from the first for a verdict of murder in the second degree, with a penalty of life imprisonment.
See moreSee less
Two stubborn members all day contended for a verdict of arson and not guilty, respectively. Following the sentencing of Larn phere all the jurors signed a statement thnt they were convinced by the evi dence at the trial that the adult body found in the ruins with the bodies of the three children was that of Mrs. Gunness. Larnphere expressed a similar belief in the first extended statement he has made to other than his attorneys since the trial began. He said he consid ered himself lucky, in view of the evi dence produced, in getting off as easily as he has. lie maintained his inno cence, however. Contrary to expectations, Lamphere's attorneys made no motion for a new trial. Unofficially, however, they ex pressed such Intention, but in view of Lamphere's light sentence in compari son with the heavy punishment which another jury might bring in were the new trial secured there is llttle'likeli hood of his being tried again. In his cell Larnphere professed that he expected acquittal, but his unwont ed buopancy belied his words. lie re sponded to congratulations on the light ness of the verdice with whole heart edness. "I'm ready to start and take my med icine like a man," he said. "Consider ing the circumstantial evidence that was produed against me I suppose I am lucky. I haven't got a word to say against It. "I'm just as innocent as you are of what I was charged with, but it ain't any wonder the jury thought what it did. The way I acted that morning of the fire certainly looked suspicious when it was presented in court. "I thought Belle Gunness was not in the fire, because all the money she must have had wasn't shown up. But after hearing the evidence it looks to me as if that must have been her body in the •ire."
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
County Prosecutor Smith stated he is confident of securing convictions regardless of the coroner's verdict, citing corroborated testimony and documentary evidence. He expects a grand jury indictment with five murder counts against Lamphere for killing Belle Gunness, her three children, and Helgelein, plus an arson charge for burning the Gunness home.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 16 May 1908 · page 7
"I thought Belle Gunness was not in the fire, because all the money she must have had wasn't shown up. But after hearing the evidence it looks to me as if that must have been her body in the •ire."
Clipping to come
Rock Island Argus · Rock Island, Ill.
One of nine bodies exhumed from Belle Gunness's farm near Laporte was identified as Andrew Helgelein, a wealthy South Dakota stockman who had come to marry her after withdrawing $3,000 from his bank. Authorities believe Gunness killed him for his money.
Rock Island Argus · 16 May 1908 · page 9
ANDREW HELGELEIN, ONE OF MRS. GUN NESS' VICTIMS One of the nine bodies disinterred from the premises of Mrs.' Belle Gunness. near Lnporte, Ind., was identified as that of Andrew Helgelein, a wealthy stK-kuian of Atwrdeeu. S. I., forty years of age. He was a Norwegian, as waa Mm (riiuiH'ss. who had advertised for a prospective husband with means llelgHeiu skirted for Laitorte .Ian. 3, since which date nothing was beard from lit in by his relatives, who were aware tha: he hurl gone to the Indiana widow's home with matrimonial intentions.
See moreSee less
It was known also that he bad drawn SsUHX) from Ills Aberdeen bank account after arriving at Laporte. The theory , in that Mrs. Gunness killed Helgelein to get his money. CITY IMPROVEMENT HINTS WHERE DO YOU BUY? lost lo liK" com nuiiity. It cautiot even lx roadie:! by the tax collector to be
A newspaper editorial column jokes that Belle Gunness has provided enough material for a sensational novel, comparing her case to literary works. It is a passing satirical reference rather than a direct news report on the case itself.
The Topeka State Journal · 16 May 1908 · page 4
It will be well to nail down your possessions more firmly than ever, for the prospects are that 49 more lawyers will soon be turned -loose on the state. That many candidates for admission to the bar are soon to take their final law examinations. - . As a companion book to "A Gentle man From Indiana," it is up to Booth Tarkington or some one else to write one called "A Perfect Lady from In fllana." Mrs. Belle Gunness has cer
Dental records confirm a jawbone belongs to Belle Gunness, while forensic experts identify the first barnyard body as Andrew Helgelein. With most major identifications made, the report notes that the cause of death and Ray Lamphere's role in the killings may never be fully known.
The Topeka State Journal · 16 May 1908 · page 9
THE CURIOUS DEPART
Ray Lamphere, on trial at La Porte, Ind., for the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness, was convicted of arson and given an indeterminate sentence of from two to twenty-one years. The verdict was a compromise.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
The report describes the meticulous but slow investigation at Sheriff Smutzer's farm and notes that excitement in Laporte is subsiding. It details the enormous volume of press material generated—nearly one million words transmitted via telegraph, mail, and phone over eleven days—though the daily output is now declining.
The Topeka State Journal · 16 May 1908 · page 9
MOTHER GOOD-BYE UPottc, Ind., Nov. IT.—Before Raj Lamphere, under sentence for from two to twenty-one years, was taken to the state prison in Michigan city to begin his term, he received a visit today from his aged mother. Though not with him during the trial, she came here from South Bend in order to say good-5y* to him and cheer him up. The meeting of the mother and ?on was pathetic. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lam* phere, charged with the murder of Mrp. Bella Gunness and her three children, by setting Are to the Gunness home, April 28, was last night found guilty of arson by the Jury which had the case since 5 o'clock Wednesday even ing.
See moreSee less
Within Ave minutes after the ver -diet was reported uJdge Ricbter had sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years. He wil be taken to Michigan City today to begin his sen tience. The verdict was reached within half
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
County commissioners approved $14,000 to help solve the Gunness murder mystery, including a $7,000 reward for Mrs. Gunness's capture if she is alive. The coroner received $5,000 for investigation expenses and the sheriff $2,000; Andrew Helgelien was buried without mourners the same day.
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 1
COUNTY PUTS UP $7000 TO CLEAR GUNNESS MYSTERY
MOTHER GOOD-BYE UPottc, Ind., Nov. IT.—Before Raj Lamphere, under sentence for from two to twenty-one years, was taken to the state prison in Michigan city to begin his term, he received a visit today from his aged mother. Though not with him during the trial, she came here from South Bend in order to say good-5y* to him and cheer him up. The meeting of the mother and ?on was pathetic. La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lam* phere, charged with the murder of Mrp. Bella Gunness and her three children, by setting Are to the Gunness home, April 28, was last night found guilty of arson by the Jury which had the case since 5 o'clock Wednesday even ing.
See moreSee less
Within Ave minutes after the ver -diet was reported uJdge Ricbter had sentenced the defendant to the state penitentiary at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to twenty-one years. He wil be taken to Michigan City today to begin his sen tience. The verdict was reached within half
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report describes the ongoing investigation at the La Porte, Indiana farm of the 'veuve Gunness' (Belle Gunness), noting that exhumations have now revealed ten cadavers and that thousands of curious visitors have flocked to the site. It also notes difficulties identifying the decomposed remains, political interference by county officials, and competing theories about whether Gunness died in the fire or whether Lamphere is responsible for her death and the arson.
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Ray Lamphere charged with tho murder of Mrs Belle Gunncss and her thrco children by setting flro to tho Gunness house April 28 wns found guilty of arson at Laporte Ind Judge RIchter sentenced him to tho stato prison for an Indetermlnato term of from two to 21 years fined him 5000 and disfranchised him for five years At Vermillion S D Mrs Christina Clark accused of the murder of her divorced husband was found guilty of manslaughter in the Bccond degree I rubllc rrinter John S Leech re
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The report describes the district attorney's investigation into Ray Lamphere as a possible accomplice or scapegoat in the Gunness murders, noting authorities possess evidence against him but won't reveal it. It also recounts Belle Gunness's newspaper advertisement for suitors and how a dozen men arrived with luggage at her farm and were never seen leaving.
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Mrs. Eleanor Mcrron Cowper, a widely-known playwright and actress, fatally shot herself in her room at tho St. Regis hotel, New York. John Gardner Coolldge, tho Ameri can minister to Nicaragua, resigned from tho diplomatic scrvlco. Ray Lamphore, charged with tho murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, by setting nro to tho Gunness house April 28, was found guilty of arson at Laporto, Ind. Judge RIchter sentenced him to tho stato prison for an Indeterminate term of
Clipping to come
St. Tammany Farmer · Covington, La.
A brief note states that the 'Gunness Horror' is attracting large numbers of people to the scene of the crime. No further details of the case are given in this fragment, which is embedded within an unrelated report on the Louisiana legislature convening.
St. Tammany Farmer · 16 May 1908 · page 1
The Gunness Horror AtI tracts Large Number to Scene of Crime --6 Baton Rouge, La., May 11.-With out a contest on the floor of either
Thousands of sightseers, including nonresidents brought by rail and trolley, swarmed the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana, turning the site of the murders into a spectacle with lemonade stands, souvenir postcards, and a festive atmosphere. The search for additional bodies was halted for the day as officials struggled to manage the crowds.
St. Tammany Farmer · 16 May 1908 · page 1
bodied .Wpident of Laporte went to the Gunness farm, and railroads and trolley lines brought about 4000 non residents to the city. • Mayor Darrow found it necessary to issue stringent orders that the Sunday closing laws should be strictly enforced. Hotels and restaurants were, overrun '.vith patrons. Every conveyance in Laporte was pressed into service in an attempt to provide transportation to the farm, which is a mile north. Hundreds, however, were forced to walk. There was nothing in the attitude of the crowd to indicate that they were visiting a place where tragedies occured.
See moreSee less
Jokes and laughing com ments were heard on every side, and exclamations of joy from successful relic hunters were numerous. Along the roadside .were several lemonade stands and lunch wagons. At the gates were venders of souve nir postal cards, and those bearing a group picture of Mrs. Gunness and the ~sn little anew 'ho met death Zt. rnnmanp farmer "The Blessings of Government, Like tape Dew from Heaven, Should Descend Alike Upon the Rich and the Poor."
La Porte authorities announce that a charred jawbone fragment, matched by a dentist to Belle Gunness's known dental work, conclusively proves she died in the farmhouse fire. The prosecutor declares this settles rumors that she escaped, while separately the body of victim Andrew Helgelein is identified via Bertillon measurements and given burial.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 May 1908 · page 2
IDENTIFICATION COMPLETE
TE*AS REPUBLICANS Leave Loophole Open to Start a Stam pede for Roosevelt. Fort Worth. Tex., May 15—The state Republican convention here today passed resolutions for Taft for the Presidency and endorsed the adminis tration’ of President Roosevelt. The delegates, were not Instructed for Taft at the Chicago convention and it is jlo clared by the delegates that this action was taken to permit the Texas delega tion to start a stampede for Roose velt's nomination if the situation be came favorable. Instructed for Taft. Portland, fire., May 15.—The 1st Con gressional district Republican conven tion yesterday elected delegates to the national convention and instructed them for Tuft.
See moreSee less
Massachusetts Bryan Men. Boston, May 15.—Democratic con ventions in the 1st, 8th and 10th dis tricts today instructed for Bryan. The 9th voted down a Bryan resolution. IDENTIFICATION complete. Authorities Satisfied That Mrs. Gun ness Perished In Her Home. , La Porte, Ind., May IS.—"Identifica tion' of the piece of jaw hone taken from the ruins of the dullness farm house ns a portion of Mrs. Hello dim ness’ skull, bears out most conclusively the contentions'of the state regarding the identity of the bodies found in the cellar April L’X. It Is the clinching bit of evidence which should set at rest the rumors that Mrs. Gunncss had es caped." This statement was made by Ralph N. Smith, prosecuting attorney, to night. It followed a report from Dr. C. P. Norton, a dentist, who found that the piece of charred bone had characteristics which he had observed while working on her teeth. Only two natural teeth, a cuspid on each side of the lower Jaw. had remained in the woman's mouth and the piece of hone found yesterday shows that all the teeth except the cuspids had been ex tracted from .the Jaw of the skull to which it belonged. The first of the Gunncss victims to be burled with Christian rites was buried by lantern light tonight in a comet co on the outskirts of La Porte. The corpse was that of Andrew K. Helgelcin of Mansfield, S. Du the last man to meet his death in the trap to which Mrs. «tini ness lnro.i her victims hTe body was released for burial tliis evening after Coroner Mack had received the reports of Bertllion experts who have examined it and compared their findings with figures taken from the records of the Minnesota penitentiary at Stillwater. Two officials of the Michigan City prison performed the work yesterday and Ed ward A. Evans of the Chicago police identification bureau did similar work to day. Both reports, w>Ofe to the effect that It was the body,-of Helgelcin. The search of the Gunness premises to day revealed little of importance. Tlio screening of the ashes produced several additional, bits of b0ne, but none of them is of sufficient s^e or well enough pre served to furnfSt! pfoof of their origin. Some relics showing that Mrs Gunness had made a *i}«y uf surgical lore were picked “up. Charred leaves of books on which siitficlent print remained to show that the folios .were,, devoted to anatomy wei-e found. Another ruined book was a treatise oa hypnotism. (t Mrs.Hattie Hamilton" Gained Flesh on Peruna. Mrs. Hattie Hamilton, R. F. D. No. 2, Sparta, Ky., writes: “I have taken two bottles of Pernna and commenced on the third one. I did not really need the third one, but thought it best to take another bottle. “I have always weighed 102 pounds, but since I began taking Peruna I weigh 120,for the first time in all my life, and I am now thirty-three years old. Your medicine has surely done me a great deal of good, and X have recommended it to several others who have begun taking it. “My mother, who is seventy-six years old, had grown so weak she could scarcely walk. She took two bottles of Peruna and is fleshier and looking well.” Internal Catarrh. Mrs. M. F. Jones, of Burning Springs, Ky., writes: “No family should ever be without Peruna, for it is an unfailing cure for colds, and it is an excellent remedy to prevent and relieve croup. “And to speak from a standpoint of experience, I can candidly say that it is the remedy for internal catarrh. I shall not hesitate to recommend it, especially to all suffering women. “Peruna has gained full confidence and a permanent 6tay in our home.” 60th CONGRESS. (Continued from Page One.) in lawful money or securities named in tile bill but that two-thirds be In cash. The prohibition against a na tional bank loaning money to or in vesting in the stock of corporations the fdlicers or directors of which are officers or directors of the bank mak ing the loan or investment. The committee also added sections providing for a commission of nine senators and nine members of the House to be appointed by the presiding officers, to be called the national mon etary commission, whose duty it shall be to "inquire into and report to Congress what changes are necessary or desirable in the monetary system of the United States or in the laws re lating to banking." All of the Democratic members of the committee voted to support the Aldrich bill in preference to the Vrce land measure, but on the floor 4>f the Senate ail but four members of the minority voted against the passage of the bill as amended. • The final vote v. as 47 ayes and 2t> nays.
Bertillon experts confirmed remains found at the Gunness farm were those of Andrew K. Helgelien, allowing his burial with Christian rites. Further searching of the ashes yielded bone fragments and charred books on anatomy and hypnotism, suggesting Mrs. Gunness had studied surgical and medical lore.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 16 May 1908 · page 2
which it belonged. The first of the Gunncss victims to be burled with Christian rites was buried by lantern light tonight in a comet co on the outskirts of La Porte. The corpse was that of Andrew K. Helgelcin of Mansfield, S. Du the last man to meet his death in the trap to which Mrs. «tini ness lnro.i her victims hTe body was released for burial tliis evening after Coroner Mack had received the reports of Bertllion experts who have examined it and compared their findings with figures taken from the records of the Minnesota penitentiary at Stillwater.
See moreSee less
Two officials of the Michigan City prison performed the work yesterday and Ed ward A. Evans of the Chicago police identification bureau did similar work to day. Both reports, w>Ofe to the effect that It was the body,-of Helgelcin. The search of the Gunness premises to day revealed little of importance. Tlio screening of the ashes produced several additional, bits of b0ne, but none of them is of sufficient s^e or well enough pre served to furnfSt! pfoof of their origin. Some relics showing that Mrs Gunness had made a *i}«y uf surgical lore were
The item is a newspaper photograph caption showing the temporary morgue established at La Porte, Indiana, where the bodies unearthed on the Gunness murder farm were being kept. It identifies the location as part of the ongoing investigation into the discovered remains.
The Detroit Times · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Th.'a picture shows the temporary morgue at La Porte, Ind., where the bodiec unearthed on the Gunntti murder farm are kept. mer Jury having cast Its ballots w’ith deliberation. Foreman Peck announc
A photo caption describes searchers at the Gunness 'House of Death' in La Porte, Indiana, examining a brick partition three feet thick in the basement ruins. The wall was believed to conceal a mass of human bones.
The Detroit Times · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Searchers in Gunness Home Ruins Do Not Leave Any Stone Unturned
Searchers in Gunness Home Ruins * ' / '' “Edwin, how many more votes do you expect to come in?” "A dozen or so.” said Henderson.
The passage includes a captioned photograph showing the temporary morgue established in La Porte, Indiana, where bodies exhumed from the Gunness murder farm were being kept. The surrounding page contains unrelated advertisements and local Detroit news items.
The Detroit Times · 16 May 1908 · page 4
quality of service rendered. We .-have every reason to expect a favorable verdict at the hands of the telephone using public of Detroit. Homs Telephone Company Competition made the railroad rates u hat they are today Temporars\ Morgue for the Gunness Victims Thl* picture ehowe the temporary morgue at La Porte, Ind., where the bodiee unearthed on the Gunneta murder farm are kept.
A snapshot shows searchers breaking apart a three-foot-thick brick partition in the basement of the Gunness 'House of Death' at La Porte, Indiana. The caption states investigators believed the partition was built to conceal a vault containing human bones.
The Detroit Times · 16 May 1908 · page 4
Searchers in Gunness Home Ruins Do Not Leave Any Stone Unturned
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
La Porte authorities issue a semi-official report naming 22 people allegedly murdered by Belle Gunness, including her two husbands and numerous suitors lured by matrimonial ads. The report notes digging for more bodies continues and that the total could rise to 25 if a headless body found in the fire ruins proves not to be Gunness herself, with a grand jury investigation set to begin Monday.
The Detroit Times · 16 May 1908 · page 7
TWENTY-TWO DEATHS NOW LAID AT DOOR OF MRS. GUNNESS - REPORT ISSUED BY LA PORTE, IND., AUTHORITIES - DIGGING RESUMED—CLAIM JENNIE OLSEN STILL LIVES
Mads Sorenson, first husband; Pe ter Gunness. second husband; An drew Hetgelein. Mansfield, S. D.; 01# O. Budsberg, 101 a. Wis.; Jennie Ol son, Chicago; Henry Gurholt, Scan dinavia, Wis.; John Moe. Elbow Lake, Minn.; Charles Edmonds, New Cas tle, Ind : Sam Hopping, Harrison, O.; Herman Komtzer, Chicago; Emil Tell, Osage City, Kai.; George Berry, Tus
The defense challenges identification of a body as Helgelein, calling it too decomposed for certain identification, while new correspondence suggests Jennie Olson may have been sent to a California convent under a different name. The report also notes unrelated local incidents, including a mistaken vigilante detention and the release of two Italian men accused of Black Hand activity.
The Detroit Times · 16 May 1908 · page 7
JENNIE STILL LIVES
A startling feature of the day's de velopments consists In a correspond- { ence between Atty. H \V. Worden I and the mother superior of u convent In California. A letter received to 1 day is believed to indicate Mrs. Gun ! ness actually did send Jennie Olsen j to a convent in California, but not In ; lais Angeles, as originally given out. ; The defeuse is proceeding on the : theory that Miss ulseu Is marrted j and living und*r anew name in Cali fornia. or that she is still an Inmate!
See moreSee less
of the convent, where newspapers do not penetrate and Information of the tragedy in Indiana might not become known for months A farmer near Sprlngwells locked i woman book agent in his barn for three hours Thursday night, believing he had the arch murderess of Laporte. He refused to release the frightened wotnun when ordered to. The man was ordered to do so by telephone from the sheriff's office and a deputy had to be sent out.
Laporte banks agreed to supply records of all financial transactions involving Mrs. Gunness to aid Prosecutor Smith's investigation. A letter from a Cleveland citizen suggested accomplices had tried to lure men to visit her, while the sheriff reported finding more gold tooth fillings believed to be hers.
The Irish Standard · 16 May 1908 · page 7
THOROUGH PROBE NEAR COMPLETION
—LAPORTE, Dec. 19.—Attorney V.'or den, who defended Ray Lamphere, de clared today that he had evidence that Mrs. Gunness is alive. He said that a LaPorte woman who knew Mrs. Gunness well, made an affidavit tnat she rode with her twenty miles on a train in Iowa. She said that she was sleeping in a seat across the isle and recognized her when she woke, and talked with her. She left the train abruptly with a man. 4~'V
Clipping to come
The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.
A letter to the police chief from an anonymous Cleveland citizen is called the first conclusive evidence that Mrs. Gunness had accomplices who tried to lure men to her farm. The sheriff continues sluicing for gold dental fillings, the coroner has completed reports on most bodies, and prosecutors prepare for Ray Lamphere's trial amid a strengthening defense.
The Irish Standard · 16 May 1908 · page 7
NEAR COMPLETION
"The white man's burden." or that portion of it. at least which is devoted to the maintenance of supremacy in the pugilistic arena, has taken on added terror because of the ease with which Jack Johnson, the negro, wrested the heavyweight fighting championship from Tommy Burns. That she has not been seen in Kan sas before has probably been disturb ing to the few in this state who think that Kansas should be first or well to the front In all things of this sort. But the fact that Mrs. Gunness has been
Clipping to come
The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.
Authorities consider inspecting La Porte bank records to trace missing persons connected to the Gunness farm, while sorting through numerous letters of varying reliability about supposed visitors. The coroner received Andrew Helgelein's prison record and Bertillon measurements from Stillwater penitentiary, and a Pinkerton detective pursued leads on letters Mrs. Gunness allegedly sent under aliases.
The Irish Standard · 16 May 1908 · page 7
To Probe Bank Dealings
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A dentist who had treated Mrs. Gunness's teeth testified that the jawbone recovered from the fire-ravaged farmhouse ruins belonged to her. This dental identification was offered as evidence confirming that the remains found were indeed those of Belle Gunness.
Omaha Daily Bee · 16 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A humor column notes that despite 'rather convincing proof' that Mrs. Gunness is dead, amateur sleuths keep claiming to spot her around the world whenever news is slow. It mocks the ongoing public fascination with sightings of her despite evidence to the contrary.
Omaha Daily Bee · 16 May 1908 · page 10
Rather convincing proof that Mrs Gunness is dead will not prevent amateur sleuths from locating her in dif ferent parts of the world whenever
United Press wire reports that a woman believed to be Belle Gunness arrived in Fort Worth, Texas from St. Louis and was met by a man she had wired from New Albany, Indiana. The Pullman conductor and station agent both suspected the woman was Gunness.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Union aqunre. New York, killing himself nnd companion and injuring four po licemen. Mnjr tJ Five bodlea of persona utip posedly murdered by Mrs. Ilelle Gnn ncnn duff up nt ruins of Iter home nt I,a l'orte, Ind., where "be nnd Iter two children vfero thought to hnve died In burning home. 6 Four moro bodies found on Gunness farm at La Porte, Ind.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
A dentist, Dr. C. P. Norton, testified that a charred jawbone fragment found in the farmhouse ruins matched dental characteristics he recalled from treating Mrs. Gunness, which the prosecutor says proves she died in the fire. Meanwhile, the body of Andrew Helgelein, one of her victims, was buried after Bertillon experts confirmed his identity using prison records.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 16 May 1908 · page 2
JAWBONE IS IDENTIFIED
Union aqunre. New York, killing himself nnd companion and injuring four po licemen. Mnjr tJ Five bodlea of persona utip posedly murdered by Mrs. Ilelle Gnn ncnn duff up nt ruins of Iter home nt I,a l'orte, Ind., where "be nnd Iter two children vfero thought to hnve died In burning home. 6 Four moro bodies found on Gunness farm at La Porte, Ind.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
Experts matched dental work and Bertillon measurements to confirm that a body found in the Gunness ashes was Andrew Helgelein, who was buried with Christian rites. The search of the premises also turned up charred books on anatomy and hypnotism, suggesting Mrs. Gunness had studied surgical techniques.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 16 May 1908 · page 2
IDENTITY IS PROVEN FIRST
Union square, New York, killing himself and companion and Injuring four po . Ilcemen. May 6 Five bodies of persons sup posedly murdered by Mrs. Ilelle Gun ness du up at ruins of her home at La Porte, Ind., where ahe and her two children were thousht to have died In burning home. B Four more bodies found on Gunness farm at La Porte, Ind.
Clipping to come
Perth Amboy Evening News · Perth Amboy, N.J.
This dispatch from Christiania reports that Belle Gunness's father was a traveling magician of Romani-Swedish origin, with whom she performed at Norwegian fairs as a child. It adds details of her 1875 confirmation, an early marriage to an engineer, her father's recent death, and an unfinished divorce case from before she left Norway.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 16 May 1908 · page 7
.Union square, New York, killing himself ana companion ana injuring luur pu-llcemen. Slay S Five bodies of persons sup posedly murdered Iiy Kirs, Hello unn ness (liinr up nt ruins of her home nt I.n Porte, Ind., where she nnd her trro children Trcre thoueht to hnve died In burning; home. 6 Four more bodies found on Gunness farm at La Porte, Ind.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Citizen · Albuquerque, N.M.
Railroad station officials in St. Louis believe a woman matching Belle Gunness's description in every detail passed through on a train the previous Saturday night, traveling to Fort Worth, Texas, where she then disappeared. She reportedly left her berth only once during the trip.
Albuquerque Citizen · 16 May 1908 · page 1
RAILROAD OFFICIALS SAY GUNNESS
nrnrram. 15 Ray Lamphere, charged with murder of Mrs. Belle uunness, was rouna guuty of arson ana sentenced to from i to zi years in state prison, by Laporte, Ind., 1urv. Dec. 10 Abe Ruf, former San Francisco political boss, convictea el Drioery.... Charles E. Davis found not guilty of murder of Dr. Frederick Rustln.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Mayor Darrow publicly criticized the Sheriff's office for allowing witness David Havens, who helped dig bodies from the fire ruins, to leave the state. Sheriff Smutzer denied responsibility, said Havens could be found if needed, and announced digging would resume at the Gunness farm, including removing a barn floor that had been suspiciously relocated two years prior.
The Sun · 16 May 1908 · page 3
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
Andrew K. Helgelin, the last man lured to his death by Belle Gunness, became the first of her victims to receive a Christian burial, interred at Pattona cemetery near LaPorte, Indiana. A Lutheran minister read the burial rites at the morgue before the coffin was carried to the grave by lantern light with only two mourners present.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
Prosecutor Ralph N. Smith announces that a charred piece of jawbone found in the ruins of the Gunness farmhouse matches dental characteristics observed by a dentist who had treated Mrs. Gunness, confirming her identity among the bodies found in the cellar. The search of the farm also turned up charred remains of books on anatomy and hypnotism, though further ash-sifting produced little else of evidentiary value.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 16 May 1908 · page 1
JAWBONE FOUND IN ASHES
The horrible developments upon the murder farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness. near La Porte. Ind the unlawful activi ties of the night riders In Tennessee mid Kentucky, and the race riots In Springfield. III., are dark spots upon the record of the year. The principal events of 1908 may be thus epitomized:
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
The article compares Mrs. Belle Gunness's Laporte murder farm to the earlier Bender family killings in Kansas, noting both buried victims near their homes and were motivated by robbery/insurance money. It recounts how the Benders disappeared after suspicion fell on them following Dr. York's murder, and notes Gunness's victims included two husbands, her children, and others lured to the farm.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 16 May 1908 · page 13
The horrible developments upon the murder farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness. near La Porte. Ind the unlawful activi ties of the night riders In Tennessee mid Kentucky, and the race riots In Springfield. III., are dark spots upon the record of the year. The principal events of 1908 may be thus epitomized:
Clipping to come
The Marion Daily Mirror · Marion, Ohio
The report states that the headless body found in the ruins is now believed to be another victim, not Mrs. Gunness, while the children's bodies were found intact. Police theorize Gunness set the fire herself and escaped after robbing or collecting insurance from her victims.
The Marion Daily Mirror · 16 May 1908 · page 13
SEEK MRS GUNNESS MONEY Relatives of Victim of Laporte Woman Make Test Case Laporte IndTho first of several roses to recover blood money obtained by Mrs Hello Gunness from tho men she lured Into her murdorhouso on s tho promise of marrlago was brought In the Loporto circuit court Friday Asel Hclgeleln bringing action for 2E9320 the amount Hollo Gunness
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
La Porte officials announced that county commissioners voted to offer a $7,000 reward for the capture of Mrs. Gunness. The action reflects the ongoing search for her following the farm investigation.
East Oregonian : E.O · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Court Will Have Homo in TWs City i Strnigthciis Argunieiu for C'reaReward for Sir. Guhhcm. lion of New District autl Lotiiiloit , La Porte, May 16. Seven thousand of Jiealquarters In lidlctoii dollar" ha8 been appropriated as a re , ward for the arrets of Mrs. Gunness If
Prosecuting attorney Ralph Smith announces that a dentist's identification of a jawbone fragment from the farmhouse ruins confirms it belonged to Belle Gunness, countering rumors she had escaped. The first victim, Andrew Helgelein, is given a Christian burial while searchers continue sifting the ashes for more remains.
The Morning Tribune · 16 May 1908 · page 3
JAWBONE BELIEVED THAT OF MRS. GUNNESS
Make Test Case. Laporte, Ind. The first of several msec to recover blood money obtained by Mrs. Belle Gunness from the men rbe lured into her murder-house on the promise of marriage was brought In the Laporte circuit court Friday, Asel Ilelgeleln bringing action for Vi.ivi.zv, tne amount lie lie uunnesa obtained from Andrew Ilelgeleln be fore she killed him. It to understood that In the event judgment is awarded Ilelgeleln. relatives of other victims will bring suit for the amounts alleged to have been contributed to the amass ing of Mrs. Gunness' estate by the men she duped into visiting her under promise of marriage.
Clipping to come
The Morning Tribune · Providence, R.I.
The coroner's physician confirmed that remains found at the Gunness farm came from an adult human's skull, supporting the corpus delicti needed for the case against Ray Lamphere. Investigators also examined fused metal globules possibly from dental work, using the intensity of the fire as evidence that a body could have been incinerated.
The Morning Tribune · 16 May 1908 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
Dr. I.P. Norton, who had performed dental work on Belle Gunness, examined a jawbone found on her farm and declared it human and strongly resembling her lower jaw. His statement provided tentative identification evidence in the investigation into the death farm.
The Madison Daily Leader · 16 May 1908 · page 1
JAW OF MRS. GUNNESS
MURDERER IS SLOWLY DYING (By United Press.) LA PORTB. Ind., April 3? Roy Lamphere, who was sentenced to Oe state penitentiary in connection with the notorious "Gunness muriler faint mysteries," is dying of consumptl >n in the Indiana penitentiary. He still maintains he is innocent <>f the crime charged. Wireless company intended to estab lish stations in all the southeastern Alaska coast towns and that Skagway station will be installed as soon as a competent operator can be secured. The United Wireless company have already established a station at Ketch ikan.
See moreSee less
Mrs. G corgi' \V. Dillon, the wife of Chief of Police Dillon. died at 12:10 o'clock 'his morning at the family residence after a long Illness cansei! by a complication of diseases M-s Dillon had every attention hut h? : health was broken by the long sleg. ol illness and her death was Inewi able. Mrs. Dillon came to Skagway el? ven years ago from Seattle She was a quiet, reserved woman, and de vo'ed to her home and children; but she had a lovable disposition and leaves many friends who will mourn l.er death. Mrs. Dillon was born .*!s years aso n* Chicago, ller maiden name was Isabella Lodge. She marrl'-d Mr. I ?il lon twenty years ago and for a num ber of years they made their home in Seattle. Itesides her husband Mrs Dillon Is survived by the following children: Mrs Eugene Smith, Kdwin D . Mary. Elsie, Stanley, George. Elizabeth ami
Clipping to come
The Waxahachie Daily Light · Waxahachie, Tex.
A Pullman conductor on a Missouri-Kansas-Texas train claims he saw a woman matching Belle Gunness's description disembark at Fort Worth, with her distinctive eyes, mouth, and double chin. The woman had traveled from Louisville via St. Louis, and a station master corroborates hearing a similar account, noting she telegraphed a man to meet her and later departed with him.
The Waxahachie Daily Light · 16 May 1908 · page 1
SHE CAME FROM ST. LOUIS
SLOWLY DYING (By United Press.) LA PORTB. Ind., April 3? Roy Lamphere, who was sentenced to Oe state penitentiary in connection with the notorious "Gunness muriler faint mysteries," is dying of consumptl >n in the Indiana penitentiary. He still maintains he is innocent <>f the crime charged.
Clipping to come
The Waxahachie Daily Light · Waxahachie, Tex.
A Katy railroad conductor reportedly claimed that Mrs. Gunness, described as 'the several times a murderess,' had recently passed through Fort Worth on his train. The brief item treats this as local gossip amid other town notes and advertisements.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Waxahachie Daily Light · 16 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Paper unidentified
Fort Worth police search for a mysterious woman passenger from St. Louis believed to be Belle Gunness, who vanished after being met by a man at the station. A separate report from El Paso also speculates she may be hiding in the southwest.
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Mrs. Gunness, and appeared nervous and held aloof from the other pas sengers. The conductor said the wo man’s ticket showed she went to St.
Witnesses in El Paso and St. Louis report seeing a nervous woman resembling Belle Gunness traveling through Albuquerque, Rincon, and Fort Worth. Meanwhile in Laporte, dental evidence and burials continue to identify victims from the farm, with Helgelein's remains interred.
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 1
FT. WORTH IS STIRRED
Victims Buried. Laporte, Ind., May 16—The burial last night of Andrew K. Helgeleln marks the beginning of the final stage ol the Gunness farm mysteries so far as human knowledge is con
The report describes the burial of Andrew Helgelein and partial identification of two more victims' bodies at the Gunness farm, with a dentist claiming to have matched a jaw bone to Mrs. Gunness herself. It also includes a detailed physical description of Belle Gunness based on accounts from those who knew her.
Paper unidentified · 16 May 1908 · page 1
PEN PICTURE OF MRS. GUNNESS
Victims Buried. Laporte, Ind., May 16—The burial last night of Andrew K. Helgeleln marks the beginning of the final stage ol the Gunness farm mysteries so far as human knowledge is con cerned. Two more corpses, supposed to have been those of Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsburg. have been par tially identified, but as to the identity of the remaining cadavars no clew exists that gives promise of fulfill ment. The potter's field will most likely be the ultimate resting place of the seven bodies. The dentist who bridged Mrs. Gun ness’ lower jaw with artificial teeth claims to have established that the lower jaw bone found in the mins Is from her skull.
See moreSee less
Three experts claim that the first body taken from the barn yard farm was that of Andrew Helgeleln. The finality of these conclusions leaves few major matters which are capa ble of solution.to lie brought to light. The methods by which the victims of the farm were put to death prob ably will never be known and weighing about 220 pounds. she was far from attractive.
Bertillon experts compared a jawbone fragment found on the Gunness farm with prison records as part of the investigation into Ray Lamphere. Andrew Helgelein, the last known victim lured by Belle Gunness, was given a quiet Lutheran burial in Laporte.
The Salt Lake Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 1
JAWBONE MAY CLEAR MYSTERY
(lterent de elqpmenits Indicate that a man who was a professional biga mist and who was a minister, as a sort of side Issue, was ono of the victims of Mrs. Belle Gunness. the nirytress of the "Port or .Missing Men." The public will now have n hotter opinion of Mrs. Gunness. A Detroit ponce Judge lias ruled that a father has a right to bpank his seventeen jear old daughtet, in moderation. TJieie are some .Ma rion girls of about that 'age raring about the streets ai night, who need spanking, hut not In moderation.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A dentist who treated Belle Gunness identified a jawbone found at the farm as hers, while coroner's physicians confirmed it came from an adult human skull. Officials said this evidence helps establish the corpus delicti needed for the prosecution of Ray Lamphere.
The Salt Lake Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 1
COILS APPARENTLY TIGHTEN ABOUT
/I-"' ,• THE GUiNINESS TRAGEDY The Pictures Used by the State of Indiana as Evidence, Lectured pn by 'Deputy Sheriff D. R. Da* vidson, of 'LaPorte, Ind,
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A brief item references the recent disclosures at the Gunness farm as a cautionary tale against the folly of marrying 'sight unseen.' It mocks men who pursue matrimonial matches without meeting their brides first, calling them idiots in light of the Gunness revelations.
The Salt Lake Herald · 16 May 1908 · page 4
/I-"' ,• THE GUiNINESS TRAGEDY The Pictures Used by the State of Indiana as Evidence, Lectured pn by 'Deputy Sheriff D. R. Da* vidson, of 'LaPorte, Ind,
Clipping to come
The Bennington Evening Banner · Bennington, Vt.
Investigators digging in the cellar of the Gunness farmhouse found portions of human jaw bones and a piece of skin with hair, believed possibly to be part of Mrs. Gunness's body. Prosecutors called the find highly significant, as it could counter defense claims about the identity of the adult corpse found after the fire.
The Bennington Evening Banner · 16 May 1908 · page 3
PART OF JAW BONES FOUND
BIJOU THEATER THE GUNNESS TRAGEDY The of Indiana as Evidence, Lectured on by Deputy Sheriff D. R. Da vidson, of LaPorte, Ind. GRADELLA AND BERNIDEZ
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
LaPorte county commissioners approved a $7,000 reward for the arrest of Mrs. Gunness if she is still alive, plus funds for the coroner's and sheriff's investigations. The report states it is not thought there are any more bodies on the farm.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Spokane Press · 16 May 1908 · page 1
$7,000 REWARD OUT FOR MRS. GUNNESS
BIJOU THEATER THE GUNNESS TRAGEDY The of Indiana as Evidence, Lectured on by Deputy Sheriff D. R. Da vidson, of LaPorte, Ind. GRADELLA AND BERNIDEZ
Clipping to come
The Spokane Press · Spokane, Wash.
A special correspondence from Edgerton, Wisconsin describes an interview with 12-year-old Swanhilda Gunness, daughter of Belle Gunness's late husband Joe Gunness by his first wife. The girl recounts her fear of Mrs. Gunness and of another household member, Jennie Olsen, and describes being forbidden from going to school or into the cellar.
The Spokane Press · 16 May 1908 · page 1
EXTRA THE GREAT GUNNESS FARM TRAGEDY 3000 FEET OF NEW PICTURES ILLUSTRATED SONG THE OLD FOLKS AT HOME MISS MAUD RAYNE Singing Soubrette Mtlnee 4 p m prices 5c and 10c
Clipping to come
The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.
Friends of Frank Mendinger, a young farmer from Delafield who vanished in 1907 after traveling to Indiana to marry a woman he met through a matrimonial advertisement, believe he was murdered by Belle Gunness. They plan to ask the German consul in Chicago to investigate his disappearance.
Residents of Kenosha are following the search for bodies at the Gunness farm near Laporte, Indiana, suspecting that missing local woman Lena Tillman may be among the victims. Tillman had left Kenosha two years earlier for a farm near Laporte and her last letter mentioned poor health and an invitation to the countryside.
The Superior Times · 16 May 1908 · page 1
FEAR KENOSHA GIRL MURDERED, Friends Think Lena Tillman May Be One of Mrs. Gunness' Victims. Kenosha. Kenosha people are watching with a great deal of interest the developments in the search for bodies at the Gunness farm at La norte. Ind., as it is thought possible that Lena Tillman, formerly of this city, is one of the women buried he neath the "soft places" on the farm The woman disappeared two years igo, and at that time sin* had Just left Laporte to go to a farm near that city. Tlie last letter received from iter stated that site was not in good health, and that she had been invited to go out into the country for an in definite time.
See moreSee less
Lena Tillman was a handsome brunette. She had been estranged from her mother, who still resides In this city.
Prosecutor Ralph Smith declared that a dentist's identification of dental work on charred bone found in the cellar proves Mrs. Gunness did not escape. The report also notes the first Gunness victim, Andrew Helgelein, was buried last night, while searchers continue finding bone fragments too fragmentary to identify.
A gruesome murder mystery is reported near Laporte, Indiana, where over a dozen bodies have been unearthed at the farm of Belle Gunness, believed killed for money after she lured men via matrimonial ads. The report states coroner's evidence confirms Gunness and her three children died in the house fire, while farmhand Ray Lamphere is under arrest as her accomplice.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The West Virginia News · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Terrible Murder Mystery
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The West Virginia News · Ronceverte, W. Va.
The report describes the discovery of 14-15 dismembered corpses on the Gunness farm, with three identified victims and theories about insurance fraud and murder by axe or poison. It states that coroner's evidence confirmed Belle Gunness and her three children died in the house fire, despite suspicions she had staged her death.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The West Virginia News · 16 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
Amid coverage of the Thaw trial, a brief note reports that Belle Gunness, called 'the arch murderess,' was said to have been seen aboard a train headed for Texas. No further detail or confirmation is given.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Laramie Republican · 16 May 1908 · page 1
During the last quarter of a century there have been several cases of wholesale murders committed to gain money, from the Bender murders in the seventies to tho Gunness murders
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
Union Station officials in St. Louis believe a woman matching Belle Gunness's description passed through last Saturday night, traveling onward to Fort Worth, Texas. She reportedly left her berth only once during the entire trip before disappearing in Fort Worth.
The Laramie Republican · 16 May 1908 · page 1
MAY BE MURDERESS
Mrs. Belle Gunness set fire to her house near I.aporte, Ind., and was burned to death with her three chll dren. When the ruins of the farm house were searched many human bones were discovered, and suspicions were aroused. Six bodies were found on land belonging to the woman, and were Identified as those of men who had answered her advertisements for a husband. In all, Mrs. Gunnes was believed to have committed eleven murders, two of the victims being women. , An Australian named Deeming was hanged in London, Kngland, about ten years ago for murdering his wife and burying her under the floor of the kitchen, which he had cemented.
See moreSee less
In vestlgatlons made by the police In Knland and Australia by digging up the doors of the kitchens of the houses in which Deeming had lived under various aliases showed that he had murdered twenty-five women whom he had married for their money.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
County commissioners in LaPorte, Indiana appropriated $9,000, including a $5,000 reward, convinced that Belle Gunness faked her death and the body found in her burned home was not hers. If she is not captured, Ray Lamphere will stand trial for her death instead.
SAILOR DECLARES HE KILLED MRS. GUNNESS. ^CHRISTIANIA, Norw ay. May 26.-A yjiung United States sailor Is under hi In Frederlckstad, near Christiania. mt a self-confessed murderer. He told his captain that he helped Mrs. Belle Gunness kill four persons on her farm Bear La Porte, Ind., and that he then Mrs. Gunness herself.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
La Porte county commissioners argued bitterly over whether Belle Gunness was truly dead, with some officials like John Matthews insisting she was alive based on the mismatched burning of the headless body versus the children's remains. They compromised on a $9000 appropriation to continue investigating the mystery and possibly locate her.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS MAY STILL BE LIVING
SAILOR DECLARES HE KILLED MRS. GUNNESS. ^CHRISTIANIA, Norw ay. May 26.-A yjiung United States sailor Is under hi In Frederlckstad, near Christiania. mt a self-confessed murderer. He told
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
During preparations for Ray Lamphere's trial, a La Porte county council member publicly doubted that Mrs. Gunness was dead, citing the mismatch between her severed head and the merely scorched heads of the children. The council compromised by appropriating $9000, with $5000 earmarked as a reward for her capture alive rather than confirmation of her death.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 1
COMMISSIONERS IN A ROW
FIVE GUNNESS FARM MURDERS WAS ACCOMPLICE OF MM. OUN NIM IN KILLING FOUR; ° MURDIIKD WOMAN. „ ■m on i»" farm, tirair La I'nrln, , hi.l., and il"»i kUl>--i Mn u>um,'»« ' ll* ma nlartxl hiiil.t *th i by Ilia .
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
This is a humorous miscellany column making light of current events, including brief sarcastic references to Mrs. Gunness leaving skulls behind and nickelodeons dramatizing her 'methods of farming.' It treats the case as already widely known public scandal material for jokes, alongside other current events like the Thaw case and presidential politics.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 28
American under arrest I' rc ing saiior hs near Lajorte, Ind and that he then killed Mrs. Gunness herself. The man did net impress the cap tain as* being Insane, but as one forced bv his conscience to teil the truth. as to his mental condition. The case has been reported to H. H. D. Peirce the American minister to Norway. The house occupied by Mrs. Gun ne?s was burned with all its occu pants April 28, 1S'S. and the woman's numerous crimes *ere then revealed. Through advertisements she had iured men with money to her farm and had then killed them, burying their bodies near the house. What were supposed
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
A brief one-line aside notes that Mrs. Gunness has supplied ample material for sensational Indiana crime novelists. It appears embedded among unrelated political ads and business notices, offering no new facts about the case.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 17 May 1908 · page 10
American under arrest I' rc ing saiior hs near Lajorte, Ind and that he then killed Mrs. Gunness herself. The man did net impress the cap tain as* being Insane, but as one forced bv his conscience to teil the truth. as to his mental condition. The case has been reported to H. H. D. Peirce the American minister to Norway. The house occupied by Mrs. Gun ne?s was burned with all its occu pants April 28, 1S'S. and the woman's numerous crimes *ere then revealed. Through advertisements she had iured men with money to her farm and had then killed them, burying their bodies near the house. What were supposed
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A brief newspaper index entry states that seven victims recovered from the Gunness murder farm near La Porte, Indiana, will probably never be identified. It appears among other news digest items listing various stories and their page numbers.
The San Francisco Call · 17 May 1908 · page 25
RAY LAMPHERE DYING. Gunness Accomplice a Victim of the White Plague. Laporte, Ind.. June 15. In response to a letter from her brother, Ray Lamphere, Mrs. James Finley hurried
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Searchers finished screening ashes at the Gunness farm with no major new findings, while a sluice box operator worked without panning tailings. Of the unidentified remains, seven victims likely will never be identified, though two bodies were tentatively linked to Jennie and Ole Budsberg, and crowds of tourists continued flocking to the site.
The San Francisco Call · 17 May 1908 · page 29
PROBING MURDERS ON CHARNEL FARM
POTTEItS FIELD FOII VICTIMS The burial last night of Andrew M. He!gele!n marked the beginning of the final stags of the Gunness farm mysteries so tar as human knowledge is concerned. Two more corpses, sup posed to have been those of Jennie and Ole O. Budsberg, hay« been partially, identified, but to the Iden tity of the remaining cadavers no clew exists that gives promise of fulfill ment. The relics taken from the death farm.* such as watches and rings, m*y ultimately lead to the determination that Rome certain missing Individual \u25a0was caught la the Gunness trap, but this will give almost no aid in Identify ing any particular body.
See moreSee less
The potters Seld is most likely to be the ultimate resting place of these seven bodies. Yesterday witnessed two conclusive findings regarding the bodies unearthed In the barnyard or taken from the smoldering ruins of the farmhouse. One by th<? dentist who bridged Mrs. Outness* lower jaw with artificial tf-th and established that the piece of Jaw bnr.e found in. the ruins was from her skull: th<i other subscribed to by three experts show thct the first body tftken from the barnyard of the farm v.r iS that of Andrew Helgelein.
Dentist confirms a jawbone fragment as Belle Gunness's using her dental bridge work, while three experts identify the first barnyard body as Andrew Helgelein. The identities of seven remaining corpses remain unknown, the method of death is unsolved, and Ray Lamphere's guilt awaits grand jury and trial proceedings.
METHOD OF DEATH UNSOLVED The finality of these conclusions s^2<ss f«v.- ms jor matters which are capable of to be brought to light. The methods by which the vic tims of the farm were put to death probably may never be known; to date tlicre is a total lack of ovidenc* on thic point. Tho identity of the seven corpses remaining unknown is another puzzle, and the extent to which Ray Lamphere shared in the secrets of Mrs. Gunness a third. Only the last of these may be determined, and until the man is taken to trial and either acquitted or < or.victed nothing approaching cer tainty will be known on this point.
See moreSee less
The state insists that it has positive evidence against Lajnphere. and the de fense as positively states that the prisoner cannot be proven guilty. The circumstances which have become known are almost equally balanced so far as Lamphere's part In the tragedy is concerned, and ludtcial process only can make clear thejr relative value. The case has. in short, reached a stage where only the, courts, through grand Jury and open trial proceedings, can be relied upon to settl« the questions which anto be brought before them. The grand jury, it is announced, will begin to investigate the «vidence gath ered by Sheriff Smulzer and Prosecutor Smith Monday. Its findings, however, Till shed little light on the subject and the details of Its deliberations are not likely to become known.
A Los Angeles-area hoax involving a reported murder-suicide turned out to be false, with searchers combing canyons for bodies that did not exist. The article references the 'famous Gunness tragedy at Laporte' only as a point of comparison for the scale of the false alarm.
Los Angeles Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 1
DARK TRAGEDY ENDS IN COMEDY MURDER AT LOCKWOOD JOKE ON SOMEBODY SMALL ARMY SEEKS TRACE OF AWFUL CRIME
THE GUNNESS H nviiir I LAPORTE, Ind., June IS. Ray I.am-. phere, serving a sentence of twenty years in prison for arson in cotinec IIYI Nil ) U 1 II lU j
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Searchers finished screening ashes at the Gunness farm and plan to dig near the old barn next week, a site not yet explored due to lack of funds. Crowds of thousands continue visiting the farm, and two more bodies have been tentatively identified as Jennie Olsen and Ole Budsberg, though most remains are unidentified.
TO SEARCH BARN LOT NEXT MOVE SUSPECTED SPOT WILL BE DUG INTO ' LAPORTE LOOKS FOR CROWD OF MORBIDLY CURIOUS , ; Identification of Jawbone and Body Are Considered Conclusive Find ings In Qunness Mysteries. Problem Up to Courts By Associated Press. LAPORTE, Ind., May Work at the Ounness farm today was . without especial result. The screening of the ashes was finished and the task of cleaning the place begun. ■ Miner Louis Schulte worked all day wltl. his new and larger sluice box, but made no effort to pan out the tailings.
See moreSee less
The sheriff said he expects to search the ground before the old barn next week. This Is one of the suspected spots which have not been explored, the work having been delayed for lack of funds. ■ The restaurant, hotel and livery stable proprietors are preparing for an other bin crowd tomorrow. The rail roads are also prepared to handle an Increased number of passengers, and It is likely if fair weather results last Sunday's sights will be repeated, when 15,000 morbidly curious went to the farm. ", ' ' The burial last night of Andrew M. Helgeleln marks the beginning of tho final stage of the Ounness farm mys teries, so far as human knowledge -Is concerned. Two more corpses, sup posed to have been those of Jennie Olsen and Ole O. Budsberg, have been partially Identified, but to the identity of the remaining cadavers no clew ex ists that gives promise of fulfillment. The relics taken from the death farm, such as watches and rings, may ulti mately lead to the determination that some certain missing individual whs caught In the Gunness trap, but thli will give almost no aid in identifying any particular body. The potters' field is most likely to be the ultimate resting place of/hese seven bodies. ' ■ Two Conclusive Findings Yesterday witnessed two conclusive findings regarding the bodies unearthed In the barnyard or taken from the smoldering, ruins of the farmhouse. One, by the dentist who bridged Mrs. Ounness' lower Jaw with artificial teeth and established that the piece of Jaw bone found In the ruins was from her skull: the other subscribed to by the experts show that the first body taken from the barnyard of the farm was that of Andrew Helgeleln. The finality of these conclusions leaves few major matters which are capable of solution to be brought to light. The methods by which the vic tims of the farm were put to death' probably may never be known. Today there is a total lack of evidence on this point. The Identity of the seven corpses remaining unknown is another puzzle, and the extent to which Lamphere shared In the secrets of Mrs. Gunness is a third. Only the last of these may be determined, and until the man is brought to trial and either acquitted or convicted nothing approaching certainty will be known on this point. The state asserts that It has positive evidence against I-.amphere and the de fense as positively states that the prisoner cannot be proven guilty..
Dental records confirmed the jaw bone found in the ruins belonged to Belle Gunness, while experts identified the first body exhumed from the barnyard as Andrew Helgelein. The report notes that the identities of seven other bodies and Lamphere's role remain unresolved, pending grand jury and trial proceedings.
Los Angeles Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 3
that of Andrew Helgeleln. The finality of these conclusions leaves few major matters which are capable of solution to be brought to light. The methods by which the vic tims of the farm were put to death' probably may never be known. Today there is a total lack of evidence on this point. The Identity of the seven corpses remaining unknown is another puzzle, and the extent to which Lamphere shared In the secrets of Mrs. Gunness is a third. Only the last of these may be determined, and until the man is brought to trial and either acquitted or convicted nothing approaching certainty will be known on this point.
See moreSee less
The state asserts that It has positive evidence against I-.amphere and the de fense as positively states that the prisoner cannot be proven guilty.. Courts Must Decide The circumstances which have be come known are almost equally bal anced, so far as Lamphere's part in the tragedy Is concerned, and Judicial pro
LaPorte County Council appropriated $9,000 to fund officers investigating the murders at Belle Gunness's farm and determining how she and her three children died in the house fire. The report notes Ray Lamphere's arrest for arson, funding for his defense, and continued crowds of visitors to the farm.
New-York Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 1
TO SOLVE GUNNESS MYSTERY
CLAPP TO MAKE FIGHT. #111 Have Vigorous Backing for His Tax Amendment. Washington, June 30.—Senator Clapp, Of Minnescota, is going to make a hard fight in the senate to secure the adoption of his amendment to the corporation tax proposition, making holding companies subject to the oper ation of the tax. By express terms these companies are exempt in original draft of tax section and Clapp says that such a proposition, If put into law, would be recognition by the government of the trusts. It would also, he believes, greatly encourage the formation of holding companies for the purpose of evading the tax.
See moreSee less
The Minnesota senator is to make a Speech in favor of his amendment and will be strongly supported by Senators Cummins, Borah, Bristow, La Follette, Beveridge and Dolliver, and there may be considerable other support. Some of the democrats will join them, but bow many is not known. HELGELEIN ESTATE WIN3 CASE. Administrator Awarded $3,000 from Gunness Estate. La Porte, Ind., July 1.—Fred M. £itner, administrator of the estate of Andrew Helgeleln, of Aberdeen, S. D„ who was lured to Laporte in January, 1908, by Mrs. Belle Gunness, was awarded $3,146 yesterday by a jury in the Laporte circuit court in a suit against Wesley Oogle, executor of the will of Mrs. Belle Gunness, this being the amount with 17 months' Interest, which Mrs. Gunness is alleged to have Obtained from Helgelein before she murdered him.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
The Laporte County Council appropriated $9,000 to support Sheriff Smutzer's investigation and Coroner Mack's chemical analysis of remains from the Gunness farm. The report also notes continued morbid public interest, with large crowds expected and funds raised for Ray Lamphere's legal defense.
New-York Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 1
TO SOLVE GUNNESS MYSTERY
Gunness Estate. La Porte, Ind., July 1.—Fred M. £itner, administrator of the estate of Andrew Helgeleln, of Aberdeen, S. D„ who was lured to Laporte in January, 1908, by Mrs. Belle Gunness, was awarded $3,146 yesterday by a jury in the Laporte circuit court in a suit against Wesley Oogle, executor of the will of Mrs. Belle Gunness, this being the amount with 17 months' Interest, which Mrs. Gunness is alleged to have Obtained from Helgelein before she murdered him.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Amid listings of New York variety theatre and vaudeville acts, the Eden Musée advertises a new wax figure of Mrs. Gunness, depicted as she appeared before her home burned. The item is one entertainment novelty among many theatrical notices of the week.
New-York Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 46
VARIETY THEATRES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
An entertainment advertisement lists Eden Musee's current exhibit featuring 'Mrs. Gunness, the Female Bluebeard' as an afternoon and evening attraction. The notice appears among other theater and amusement listings, showing the case had already become popular spectacle.
New-York Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 47
EDEN MUSEE
Alter me iaps.e or eignr months, digging was resumed on the Gunness farm in order that it might be settled positively whether or not any more virtims of Mrs. Bella Gunness lay buried in the private burial ground ficm which ten bodies were taken. Governor Stubbs served notice on the directors of ihe Topeka club that he will cancel his membership unless the plan of keeping liquor at the club is abandoned. Mrs. Albert Pulitzer, wife of the well known journalist, died in New
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A short filler item jokes that the Black Hand Society seems capable of handling anyone the 'Widow Gunness' may have overlooked in her killings. It is a brief sarcastic aside amid unrelated news items.
The Washington Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 7
IN THE KILLING BUSINESS
FredLnpincer, aamintsrraror of the estate of Andrew Helgelien, of Aber deen, S D., who was luied to Laporte in January, 1909, by Belle Ganness was awarded (3,145 on July 1, by a jury in Laporte circuit court at Laporte, Ind., in a suit against Wesley Gogle, execu tor of the will of Mrs. Guuness. This was the amount with seventeen months interest, which Mrs. Gunness is alleged to have obtained from Helgelien before
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
The Laporte county council appropriated $9,000 to continue investigations into the murders at Belle Gunness's farm and to determine whether she died in the house fire. Meanwhile, relatives raised funds for Ray Lamphere's legal defense, and searchers prepared to examine the area near the old barn next week.
Evening Star · 17 May 1908 · page 2
EFFORTS TO SOLVE MYSTERY - INVESTIGATION TO CONTINUE ON THE GUNNESS FARM
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A satirical newspaper humor column lists various political and social jabs, including a sarcastic remark dismissing evidence that Belle Gunness wasn't burned up in the fire. The item treats the question of her survival as a joke rather than a serious claim.
The Washington Times · 17 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A satirical news-commentary column briefly mentions that evidence suggesting Mrs. Gunness wasn't burned up doesn't seem worth considering, among many unrelated quips on coins, battleships, and politics. The item is a passing joke rather than a substantive report on the case.
The Washington Times · 17 May 1908 · page 6
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The LaPorte County board of commissioners appropriated $9,000 to continue investigating the Gunness mystery after a contentious debate, with member John G. Matthews arguing Mrs. Gunness is still alive since her head could not have burned off while her children's heads were barely scorched. The report also notes opposition to a larger $14,000 request and details sheriff Smutzer's discovery that a trusted detective was actually a spy for Ray Lamphere's defense.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 17 May 1908 · page 1
For the Defense. La Porte, Ind., May Hi The board of county commissioners, after a bit ter debate here today, in which the conviction was expressed by its mem bers that Mrs. Belle Gunness is still alive, appropriated .f.(K;o to be spent clearing up the mystery of the "House of Death." When an attempt was tna.de in the city council to obtain an appropriation of $14,000 to pay detec tives, coroners, special assistants and providefor the expenses of the trial Of Ray Lamphere, unexpected opposi tion was developed. John G. Mat thews, one of the most potential mem bers of the body, declared he did not believe Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness was dead and in sisted that all of his neighbors and friends were of the same opinion. Mr. Matthews has a wide acquaintance End his statement indicates very near ly the trend of public opinion on the Gunness case in. Laporte county.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The LaPorte city council argued over a $14,000 appropriation for detectives and trial expenses, with councilman Matthews insisting Belle Gunness was still alive, citing the condition of the burned bodies as proof. A compromise fund was approved, partly earmarked as a reward for her capture, while Sheriff Smutzer discovered a supposed detective was secretly working for Lamphere's defense.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 17 May 1908 · page 1
Thinks She Lives. Matthews argued it was ridiculous to suppose Mrs. (Junness's head could tiave been burned off her body, while the heads of her c hildren were scarcely tnore than scorched. "What sense is there in appropriat ing money to pay detectives who insist &.t the start that Mrs. Gunness is dead," remarked a member of the Council. This attitude of Matthews started a tiot discussion that lasted all day. The Gunness case in all the phases of the mystery were discussed. In its final net ion the council agreed upon a com promise resolution appropriating .?!, passed to stand reading which practically amounts to its final adop tion.
See moreSee less
Of $!,KK, $r,MX was appropri ated for the county commissioners, Hvho are to use it as they desire in tin ravelins the mystery, but "it is tacit ly understood most of the $,.hh is to be offered for the apprehension of Mrs. Gunness.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Sheriff Smutzer discovers that a supposed Chicago detective he trusted and shared case information with was secretly working for Lamphere's defense team. The report also notes the trial may last weeks due to circumstantial evidence and mentions a letter describing a frightening encounter at the Gunness farm.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 17 May 1908 · page 1
USES MUCH STRATEGY
Must Show Proof. To earn the reward proffered on these terms, it will be necessary for the detectives to prove Mrs. Gunness Is alive and return her into court. It Is admitted by the attorneys for the prosecution and defense that the trial tf Lamphere may last for weeks, so tnany elements of uncertainty have arisen. Proof throughout must be cir cumstantial. The defense believes it will be able to shut off the so-called ponfession made to the Rev. Mr. fcchell. Sheriff Smutzer is in receipt of a letter from I.
See moreSee less
X. Youster of Carper, NVyo.. who tells his interesting experi ence on the Gunness farm. He says he once visited Mrs. Gunness's home With $70O in currency and sr.cn in drafts in his pocket. He was a ped dler. Mrs. Gunness's children were Dice to him and Mrs. Gunness told them to go away and not pay any at tention to the old man. The writer fays he is convinced he would have been murdered for his money, but for the fact that his shabby clothes con cealed his prosperity. Sheriff Smutzer was amazed today to discover that the supposed Chicago City detective, in whom he had trusted Is really in the employe of the defense. J?mutzer and his deputies had given the man all the information regarding the case against Lamphere in the pos session of the sheriff's office. Coun ty Prosecutor looks upon this piece of Strategy on the part of the attorneys for Lamphere as both a calamity ana End an outrage.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A woman resembling Belle Gunness was reportedly seen traveling by rail from St. Louis to Fort Worth, Texas, appearing drugged and avoiding her berth, with speculation she was heading to Mexico. Passengers and a porter noted her suspicious behavior and telegrams sent on her behalf.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 17 May 1908 · page 4
MRS. GUNNESS MAY BE IN MEXICO
SUPPOSED VICTIM OF MRS GUNNESS ALIVE By Associated Press Milwaukee AVis Aug 26It is re ported from Waukesha Wis that Frank X Reidinger supposed to have been a victim of Mrs Belle Gunness at LaPorte Indiana is alive and at Freeport Neb A letter was receiv ed from him today
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
The LaPorte County Board of Commissioners appropriated $9,000, believing Belle Gunness is still alive and that the burned body was another woman's; $6,000 is offered as reward for her capture and the rest for prosecuting Ray Lamphere. Lake dragging near the farm has found no new bodies, though the prosecutor still believes Gunness is dead.
The Hattiesburg News · 17 May 1908 · page 1
IS STILL LIVING
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
A satirical one-line quip speculates that if Belle Gunness had advertised as a red-headed, dimple-cheeked widow, she could have lured and killed victims across all of Indiana. It appears amid unrelated local political and newspaper business items in a miscellany column.
The Hattiesburg News · 17 May 1908 · page 4
changed, we'll bet the bananas that Governor Noel, of Mississippi, reniged. Rich people who now and Uu n make propositions to give certain s, provided poor people will come across with like amounts, should cut the strings and make their donations regardless. . jr a z ; ' ' = If Mrs. Gunness had only adver tised herself as a red-headed widow, with dimpled cheeks, she might have converted the whole state of Indiana Into a cemetery. Joe Bailey's victory in Texas was probably nothing to brag about, but If Bryan does as well in November the country will be saved.
See moreSee less
Governor John A. Johnson's thrill ing rescue of the South from the clutches of Mr. Bryan will not be staged this season. > man prefers to he lied An Afternoon Newspaper. With this issue, the Daily News abandons the morning Held and be comes an afternoon newspaper. This change has been under consideration for several weeks, but per manent arrangements for the change were not Consummated until yester day, when arrangements were made with the Hearst News Service for the full afternoon report of that great news agency. As a morning newspaper, the Dally News has done well—better than mlgth have been expected under the trying business conditions of the past six months. But there are several serious obstacles In the way In the first place, it of morning newspaper publication in Hattiesburg, has been impossible to secure electric power service to drive presses and typesetting machinery from 2 to 4 o'clock each morning. Just at the time During the late hours of the when most needed by a morning paper, night, when the electric plant is running, the direct current is irregu lar and unreliable and has necessitated much provoking delay and need 50c less expense. When the News first entered the morning field. It was assured that the all night power service would be furnished within a short time, but subsequent conditions have prevented the construction of the new plant and the service has not Improved. All newspaper readers know that It costs more money to Issue a morn Men will not work at Ing paper than to print an afternoon edition, Lights are ex night for the same salaries they receive for day labor, pensive and the newspaper office which remains open all night consumes lots of electricity. These and other reasons have impelled the present management to make the change. And we have no apologies to offer. As an afternoon paper, the News will continue to print the NEWS, and all of It. Editorially, it will remain fair, but fearless—earnestly en deavoring at all times to promote the best Interests of Hattiesburg and South Mississippi.
Searchers sifting the burned Gunness farmhouse found a partially burned book on hypnotism, pages from an anatomy text, and a scrap of an unfinished letter in Mrs. Gunness's hand expressing despair and terror. Sheriff Smutzer continued screening debris for bones and gold particles, while unconfirmed reports placed Gunness alive in California, Mexico, and Indianapolis.
The Sun · 17 May 1908 · page 10
FOUND IN THE RUINS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
Sheriff Smutzer's men keep sifting debris and ashes, finding only burned bone fragments and possible gold particles. Meanwhile unconfirmed sightings of Mrs. Gunness pour in from across the country, and two more men come forward describing matrimonial correspondence and near-fatal visits to her.
The Sun · 17 May 1908 · page 10
IN THE RUINS
bookkeeping expmaf. f One of the Supposed victims of the Infamous Mrs. Gunness Is alive and well. . Ia.ll of which goes to show that most
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
An Illinois man, O.W. Catchousen, thanks God he is alive after narrowly avoiding a visit to marry Belle Gunness, who had demanded he bring $2000; an Indianapolis man also received letters from her and an accomplice urging a meeting. Meanwhile, Andrew Helgelien was buried, and the sheriff announced funding to dig further for additional bodies in Gunness's graveyard.
The Sun · 17 May 1908 · page 10
1 By Vailed FT»*» Laporte Ind , Aug. 27.—One of the suppostd victims of Mrs Belle Gunnest, the arch murdereao and Ixdieved to I* buried here ialive. It is Frank X Reidmger of Delafield Wisconsin who disappeared from 1 his home after announcing he wi< < uning to Indiana to marry a wealthy * idow and when the Gunner ‘disclosure* were made Kriding. r was given up for dead Reports from Wisconsin say that Reidingvr writes from Freeport Nebraska that he is working on a farm there and ' needs some money. Hi* property at 1 Delafield was recently sold for IML Ray Lamphere who was convicted of burning the Gunners home, tes tified that Reidinger was in love with Mrs. Gunm-s ami vanished shortly afterwards.
Clipping to come
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · Tonopah, Nev.
The screening of ashes at the Gunness farm has been completed and cleanup work has begun. The sheriff plans to search the area near the old barn next week, a site not yet explored due to lack of funds.
Tonopah Daily Bonanza · 17 May 1908 · page 1
SEARCHING FOR GUNNESS VICTIMS
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Evening Tribune · Providence, R.I.
The Laporte County Council appropriated $500 for officers investigating the mystery surrounding the murders at Belle Gunness's farm and the circumstances of the fire that killed her and her three children on April 28. Searchers finished screening ashes at the site without important results, and the sheriff plans to search near the old barn next week, one of the suspected spots not yet explored due to lack of funds.
The Evening Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 3
TRYING TO SOLVE MYSTERY
Baldwifi of Abilene Texas Bald win followed Webb into a restaurant and continued shooting until the lat ter fell Baldwin surrendered to oa the police but refuses to make a statement A special from Waukesha Wis says Frank X Reidinger who was supposed to have been a victim of Mrs Belle Gunness at Laporte Ind is alive andwell on a farm near Freeport Nebraska according to a letter received supposedly from him After a bitter fight extending nearly a year State Senator George Wilhelmi wins out in his contest for postmaster of Newp > rt to succeed John H Meyer the incumbent This is a big victory for Senator Bradley who took up Wilhelmio fight in the face of great adds Meyer who
Clipping to come
Laredo Weekly Times · Laredo, Tex.
Coroner Mack announced he would return an open verdict stating Mrs. Gunness and her three children died in the fire that destroyed their home, with plans to drag Fish Trap lake for more victims. A separate report claimed a friend had seen Mrs. Gunness alive in Milwaukee that week.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 1
GUNNESS HOME HORROR The Coroners Verdict Will Be. That The Mother And Three Children Were Burned. fuiUdPr.»» Laporte. May 16—Coroner Mack who is investigating the crimes of Mrs. Belle Gunness has announced
A Cincinnati report claims Mrs. Jeannette Morris said asylum inmate Jacob Krebs told her he led a gang that murdered over a score of poor people in Chicago, insuring them before killing them and shipping bodies to Indianapolis. The story draws a comparison to Mrs. Gunness as an equally monstrous killer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 9
THAT HOUSE OF HORRORS. ONE OF THE CHIEF MURDER ERS FOUND IN INSANE ASYLUM. Say* He Murdered Score* ol Poor People to Secure Life Iniur anee end Shipped Bodies to Indianapolis. By United Prr»s. Cincinnati, 0., May 11.— If the story told by Mrs. Jeannette Mor ris concerning Jacob Krebs, an in mate of the Longview Insane Asylum be true, he is as much an arch murderer as Mrs. Gunness. Mrs. Morris says that Krebs told her before he was confined in the Asylum that he had headed a gang who murdered over a score of peoI pie in Chicago and sent their bodies lo Indianapolis. The plan was to insure poor people and then slay them.
The city council of LaPorte offered a $5,000 reward for the capture of Mrs. Belle Gunness or her accomplices. A grocer named Minnick reported seeing Gunness and Lamphere together the afternoon before her home burned, and authorities were sifting the cellar ashes for clues.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 9
$5.000 REWARD OFFERED. Sy United Wtpm LaPorte, May 11.—The city council tonight will offer five thou sand dollars reward for the capture of Mrs. Belle Gunness or any of her accomplices. James Minnick, a grocer, declared that Mrs. Gunness and Lamphere met in his store, the afternoon before the Gunness home was burned. She bought oil and l<amphere tobacco. Minnick, declares that I Mrs. Gunness eyes were red as if she had been crying. Lamphere did not speak to her and the two left going in opposite directions. Today the ashes in the cellar are being sifted
Investigators report finding a gold ring and keys belonging to Belle Gunness in the ruins of her burned farmhouse, leading police to halt the search for her. Attention now turns to proving the guilt of farmhand Ray Lamphere, accused of killing her in jealousy after helping with other murders.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 9
"THE HOUSE OF HORRORS." i. Gold Rinfi And Bunch Of Key* Bdonfiinx To Mr*. Gunnc» Found In Ruin*. By rain'd Pr»M. !<a Porte, Ind. May lI.—A gold ring and a bunch of key* belong* ing to Mrs. Belle Gunness, the murdererous farm keeper, have been found in the ruins of her home, and the police have stopped further search for her. They are now try ing to establish the guilt of Ray Lampbere, the farm hand, whom to allege murdered her in a tit of jealousy as he had helped her to murder others
Sheriff Smutzer plans to drag the lake near the Gunness home after a tip that the bodies of Mrs. Greening and Will Greening may be there. The tip came from a woman identifying herself as Jennie Olson's Oklahoma City sweetheart, who believes the bodies are submerged in the lake.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 13
THE "HOUSE OF HORRORS."
STRONG IDENTIFICATION Dentist Declares The Woman's Jawbone Found In Ruins Is Thal Of Mrs. Gunness. K* Ukited !>•*■ u Porte. May 15 - Dr. I. T. Norton, who has done Mrs. Gun
A Kansas City laborer named Christian Hansen received a letter dated May 1 from Laporte, signed by Mrs. B. S. Gunness, inviting him to visit and bring $1,000 in currency. Investigators believe the letter was written by Gunness and forwarded through an agent.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 5
A COSTLY INVITATION Kansas City Man Invited To Visit Mrs. Gunness. f BvVaiMiPf»" I Kansas City Mo., May 12.— Christian Hansen, a laborer at i Armourdale Kansas received a
The coroner and a physician reported finding three rings on the fingers of the woman recovered from the Gunness house ruins, including one inscribed with initials believed to belong to her second husband, Peter Gunness. Investigators said this evidence reduces doubt that the body is Mrs. Gunness, along with a fragment of a gold tooth crown matching her known dental work.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 5
K» Vblimí Pr»*»* La Porte, Ind. May 12. The coroner and Physician '.Myer today found three rings on the fingers of the woman taken from the ruins of the Gunness home. One was plain gold, another a diamond gold ring inscribed: “P. G J- $• August 22. 94" and one diamond ring inscribed “P. S. to J. S. 3-595 P. G." which is believed to lie PhillipGunness.the woman's second husband. The discovery is believed to remove most of the doubt that Mrs. Gunness perished in the fire. It is reported that Mrs.
See moreSee less
Gunness wore three rings. These rings were not found before, because the fingers were so badly charred that the rings had sunk into the flesh. A report to the coroner, says the woman and her three» children evidently met death while in lied, or preparing to retire. The body bon» no marks of violence. Portion of the gold crown of a tooth was found in the ruins of the Gunness home. It is believed to be one of the three crowns Mrs. Gun ness is known to have had in her mouth.
A letter held by Mayor Darrow suggests Belle Gunness lured Lamphere away from the house on the day John Moo was murdered, and police now believe Jennie Olson was killed the same day. A Baltimore minister, Rev. Schell, claims the Gunness children were chloroformed before the house was burned, insists the body found is not Mrs. Gunness, and says Lamphere is innocent of all murders except possibly Jennie Olson's out of jealousy.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
LAMPHERE THE SUSPECT INNOCENT OF BURNING OF THE GUNNESS "HOUSE OF HORRORS." Mayor Darrow Has Letters which May Acquit Him Of The Crime Charged. By United Press. Laporte Ind., May 13.— Ray 13.—Ray Lamphere may be acquitted of the charge of being an accomplice with Mrs. Gunness. A letter in possession of Mayor Darrow shows the arch murderess got Lamphere away from the house by a ruse the day that John Moo of Elbow, Lake Minn, was murdered. The police now declare from the evidence that Jennie Olson was slain on the same day. Rev. L. A. Schell in a letter from Baltimore declared that Lamphere made a confession to him regarding the burning of the Gunness home but the minister refuses to divulge it.
Ray Lamphere is reported near collapse after Rev. Schell claimed he made a partial confession to burning the Gunness home. Lamphere denies promising a full confession, and a new possible victim, Emil Kellu, is named.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 11
BORDERING ON COLLAPSE Rsy Lsmpherc Accused of Burn ing Gunness Home Worried Over Reports of His Con fession. Hy I'altMf Pm» [^aporte. May 13 — Ray Lam pherr is bordering on a collapse
Prosecutor Smith plans to call Rev. E. A. Schell as his chief witness, to testify that Ray Lamphere confessed involvement in burning Belle Gunness's home. Digging will resume at the site of a former storehouse where freshly dug earth was found, as police suspect more bodies remain buried.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 3
METHODIST MINISTER. PROSECUTING ATTORNEY WILL SUMMON REV. E. A. SCHELL AS A WITNESS.
Killing Helgelin. By UNiuafh 1 »» («aporte, Ind., May 14 —Rev. h. A. Schell, Methodist minister who gave out the interview at Baltimore yesterday that Ray Lamphrrr had confessed to Inin in connection with the burning of the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the murderers of sixteen people, will be made the chief witness against lamphere. Prosecutor Smith says he will con vict him of this crime or the mur der of Andrew Helgelin. John Zach, a house mover, says the pro secutor, moved the store house some months ago and found at the time freshly dug earth. On this information digging will tie reBurned tomorrow at the spot where the wtMid house had been. The police believe more bodies will In* unearthed.
Sheriff Smutzer of Laporte received a letter from a John Williamson in Milwaukee claiming Mrs. Gunness is alive. Williamson says he will produce her if offered a $5,000 reward.
Laredo Weekly Times · 17 May 1908 · page 3
MRS. GUNNESS LIVING. Will Be Produced If $5 000 Re ward Is Offered. By United Pro* Laporte, Ind. May 14.—Sheriff Smutxer. received a letter from
This feature article compares Belle Gunness's murders to those of other infamous killers like H.H. Holmes, the Bender family, Johann Hoch, and Herman Billik. It describes her as combining intelligence and physical strength to carry out murders alone, with discovery of at least a score of victims on her property.
Paper unidentified · 17 May 1908 · page 21
BELLE GUNNESS
Novelette * URiDERER HOLMES, who dealt /I out death as a druggist does an r * ordinary prescription; Luet rt of sausage fame, who put his fe under the knives in his factory Id destroyed her body in a vat of Id; Kate Bender, who Inveigled men her sheet curtained frontier room, tere they w*ere knocked in the head her masculine relatives; Johann pch, to whom bigamy became a pfession and killing a pastime; Lrman Billik, whose alleged victims n high in numbers —the homicidal pievements of these past masters I crime and their prototypes pale to insignificance when compared Ith the apparently proved acconi shments of Mrs. Belle Gunness, the Lporte, Ind., widow whose murder
The report compares Belle Gunness to infamous killers like the Benders and Holmes, calling her a possible 'master of crime.' It presents competing theories about whether she acted alone or was part of a criminal gang operating out of Chicago, while noting at least 11 victims found buried on her farm.
Paper unidentified · 17 May 1908 · page 21
BELLE GUNNESS
of which have made the world stand agape, the preponderance of evidence so far uncovered indicates that the supreme master of criminology was a woman, who superficially was coarse, almost vulgar, and not ac credited. even by those who knew her best, with even average intelli gence. Yet this woman, it now appears, has been able to outwit for many years her neighbors and the police of several communities. In her subur ban home near Laporte there is no question but that she did to death at least 11 people, dismembered their bodies and disposed of their remains in various parts of the 60-acre farm adjoining the home.
See moreSee less
There is yet a grave question whether or not Mrs. Gunness had ac complices. Opinion is divided, but the preponderance of evidence lends color to the belief that the "horror house,” from which the bodies of an as yet untold number of victims were taken and without ceremony dumped Into holes in the barn yard or thrown into vaults, was the clearing house for a band of murderers whose principal scene of operation was Chicago and other of the larger cities, and with whom Mrs. Gunness, herself formerly a Chicago woman, was closely con nected. Still another theory which has many supporters would indicate that the -woman herself committed all the crimes, disposed of the bodies of her victims by her own hand and profited from their money and private effects.
The report describes the discovery of numerous bodies buried on the Gunness farm and speculates on whether she had accomplices, comparing her cunning favorably to H.H. Holmes. It details how victim Andrew Helgelein was lured via a matrimonial advertisement in a Norwegian-language newspaper, suggesting this was her method for attracting many victims, following the house fire that supposedly killed Gunness and her three children.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 17 May 1908 · page 21
of which have made the world stand agape, the preponderance of evidence so far uncovered indicates that the supreme master of criminology was a woman, who superficially was coarse, almost vulgar, and not ac credited. even by those who knew her best, with even average intelli gence. Yet this woman, it now appears, has been able to outwit for many years her neighbors and the police of several communities. In her subur ban home near Laporte there is no question but that she did to death at least 11 people, dismembered their bodies and disposed of their remains in various parts of the 60-acre farm adjoining the home.
See moreSee less
There is yet a grave question whether or not Mrs. Gunness had ac complices. Opinion is divided, but the preponderance of evidence lends color to the belief that the "horror house,” from which the bodies of an as yet untold number of victims were taken and without ceremony dumped Into holes in the barn yard or thrown into vaults, was the clearing house for a band of murderers whose principal scene of operation was Chicago and other of the larger cities, and with whom Mrs. Gunness, herself formerly a Chicago woman, was closely con nected. Still another theory which has many supporters would indicate that the -woman herself committed all the crimes, disposed of the bodies of her victims by her own hand and profited from their money and private effects. Mystery in Tale. Except for the increasing number of grewsome exhibits, the latter theory would probably have the greatest weight. But in the light of discoveries already made and indica tions of those yet to come it seems scarcely credible that any person, however, astute, capable, cold blooded and versed in the arts of murder, would be able to do away with as many victims as it now appears have been buried on the Gunness farm during the eight years or so of Mrs. Gunness’ occupancy.i In any event, whether the woman had accomplices or whether she did not, the finesse with which she worked indicates that even Holmes, the archmurderer of modem times, was a “selling plater" compared with this woman of extraction. Mystery worse confounded has been ejected into this latest horror tale through the presumably tragic death of the woman and her three children. The entire family is supposed to have been wiped out in a mysterious fire which razed the two-story brick residence. one of the most notorious houses in northern Indiana, formerly the home of Mattie Altik. a member of the demimonde, whose exploits made her notorious through the country. The destruction of the Gunness house occurred on the night of April 28. It came as a climax to a strenuous investigation inaugurated by a brother as to the whereabouts of Albert Hei gelein. a South Dakota rancher, who is supposed to have been one of the last victims of the wiles of the Nov wegian widow. Matrimonial “Ad” Lures. Helgelein. like probably several others of the Gunness farm victims, was lured to the snare of a viper
Workers finished screening the ashes at the Gunness farm and began cleaning the site, while a miner worked with a new sluice box but did not yet pan the tailings. The sheriff plans to search near the old barn next week, and local hotels and railroads prepare for another large crowd of sightseers.
The Salt Lake Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 3
PREPARING FOR CURIOUS CROWD
Mrs. Belle Guaaess, the wicked Indiana woman who sowed her farm with the remains of entrapped vic tims, is reported to hare been seen again—this time on a train in Texas. Whenever there is a little lull in othdr matters «f public interest, the Gunness woman is beard -of. v
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
Authorities plan to search the ground near the old barn next week, delayed by lack of funds, while hotels and railroads prepare for another large crowd of visitors like the 15,000 who came the previous Sunday. Prosecutors finish subpoenas for the grand jury that will consider the case against Ray Lamphere.
The Salt Lake Herald · 17 May 1908 · page 3
PREPARING FOR CURIOUS CROWD
SEES MRS. GUNNESSI EL. PASO, Tex, Oct 8 A special from Dalhart, Texas, says a former citizen of Laporte, Indiana, recogniz ed Mrs. Belle Gunness on board a
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
Workers finished screening ashes at the Gunness farm and began cleanup, while a miner tested a new sluice box without panning results. The sheriff plans to search near the old barn next week, and local businesses prepare for another large crowd of visitors expected the following day.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 2
NO NEW DEVELOPMENTS IN GUNNESS TRAGEDY
SEES MRS. GUNNESSI EL. PASO, Tex, Oct 8 A special from Dalhart, Texas, says a former citizen of Laporte, Indiana, recogniz ed Mrs. Belle Gunness on board a
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah
A humor column making wry one-line jokes about current events mentions Mrs. Gunness, suggesting she may have at least destroyed public confidence in matrimonial advertisements and agencies. It is a brief satirical aside amid a list of unrelated quips on politics and society.
The Salt Lake Tribune · 17 May 1908 · page 6
II jfy wore opposed to the Laws. ;l ly! Mrs. Gunness may have accomplished jj one good, though, if only she has sue uoeded in destroying all confidence in matrimonial advertisements and agen-
A Pullman conductor claims a woman matching Belle Gunness's description left his train at Fort Worth, a claim corroborated by crew members though the conductor won't give his name. The Fort Worth stationmaster adds that the woman telegraphed ahead to a man who met her at the station and escorted her away.
The Prescott Daily News · 18 May 1908 · page 2
Ray Lamphere, convicted at La Porte, Ind., of the murder of Mrs. Gunness, yho ran the notorious "mur der farm,” Is dying in jail. Chicago jury commissioners have been ordered to turn 6ver their books to the State’s attorney, who is in vestigating frauds in the jury’s drawings. Charged with misapplication of $17,000 of the concern’s funds, Noah B. Barnes, president of the Cotton wood Copper company, was arrested yesterday at New York.
Clipping to come
The Daily Guard · Batesville, Ark.
Authorities offer a large reward for information clearing up the Gunness farm murders, with competing theories about whether Belle Gunness died in the fire or escaped after killing a substitute victim. The report notes twelve bodies exhumed so far and notes Ray Lamphere may be pressured to talk.
BIG REWARD. — PARTIES WHO CLEAR UP MURDER FARM MYSTERY TO BE WELL PAID.
WILL NOT PAROLE LAMPHERE. Declaring that the demands of jus tice have not yet been met, Gov. Mar shall of Indiana has declined to parole Ray JLamphere. convicted of setting fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness of LaPorte murder fame. Lamphere is suffering from tubercu losis in the Indiana penitentiary.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
A county grand jury is set to convene to investigate the Belle Gunness case, with reports estimating four to six days needed to hear evidence. Thousands visited the farm to view skeletons of unidentified victims, while a relative of a missing man failed to positively identify one set of remains.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 1
GRAND JURY READY TO TAKE UP GUNNESS CASE
WILL NOT PAROLE LAMPHERE. Declaring that the demands of jus tice have not yet been met, Gov. Mar shall of Indiana has declined to parole Ray JLamphere. convicted of setting fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness of LaPorte murder fame. Lamphere is suffering from tubercu losis in the Indiana penitentiary.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
Crowds gathered at the Gunness farm to view the scene, though nothing remained but fragments of unidentified bodies. A grand jury of fifty witnesses was set to begin its investigation into the case that day.
Arizona Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 1
A MORBID THRONG AT GUNNESS FARM
KONG GUNNESS FARM vr i b I H a is Unidentified Dead ot tlw 3Iyslery Today Through a Hall Hundred Witnesses. r.iite, Ii..V. M.-.y IT. Tinsi -i-ns THOUSAND Forty witnesses will be summoned
A miscellaneous commentary column makes a passing sarcastic reference to the 'ghastly details of the Gunness matrimonial bureau' while quoting Elinor Glyn on love. It is a brief aside within a column of unrelated local anecdotes, not a dedicated news report on the case.
Arizona Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 2
"Love today is chilled emotion," says Elinor Glyn. She never would have f-aid this if she had read the ghastly details of the Gunness matrimonial bu
James Helmer of Phoenix recalls seeing the Paulsen family, including a girl he believes may have been Belle Gunness as a child, performing at Norwegian coastal fairs. He describes the traveling theatrical family's circuit along the west coast of Norway and notes they were thought to be Danish rather than Norwegian.
Arizona Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 5
HE HAD PROBABLY SEEN MRS. GUNNESS AS CHILD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
A man named Mr. Helmer recalls the Paulsen family of traveling singers, dancers, and trapeze performers who toured Norway, claiming Belle Gunness was one of the little girls who sang in their troupe as a child. He describes the family's background, noting they were called Danes but were possibly descended from Tyrolese settlers.
Arizona Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 5
MRS. GUNNESS AS CHILD
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Daily Sentinel · Grand Junction, Colo.
The LaPorte county grand jury began investigating the Gunness farm mystery, while the prosecutor received threatening letters and searchers continued sluicing for gold teeth and dragging the pond for evidence. A new probable victim, Abraham Phillips, was named, and the report notes 10,000 sightseers visited the farm over the weekend, viewing skeletal remains displayed in a temporary morgue.
The Daily Sentinel · 18 May 1908 · page 1
ANOTHER VICTIM OF THE WOMAN FIEND
(By Associated Press.) scenes of last Sunday were repeated yesterday at the Gunness farm. Fully 10,000 people visited the “farm of mystery” and saw all there was to be seen, even to viewing the skeletons of the seven unidentified dead, for the temporary morgue was opened part of the day. and persons were permitted' to gaze at the bones of Mrs. Gunness’ victims. Hundreds brought their luncheons along, for the day was an ideal one, and at noon family groups dotted the grounds and orchards of the Guu uess farm. Souvenirs of all k.inds were *sold on the grounds, the people buying readily, nobody going away without a reminder of some kind.
An old prospector from Ouray had corresponded with a Chicago matrimonial agency and exchanged letters and photos with Belle Gunness about a year and a half earlier, drawn by the prospect of sharing his mining 'nest egg.' The courtship ended only because his mining deal fell through, sparing him from potentially becoming a victim buried in the Gunness farm cellar.
The Daily Sentinel · 18 May 1908 · page 5
Laporte Officer Visits Mys terious DeMotte Resident. Laporte. Ind., Nov. 24. Information " from Shelby, Ind., this afternoon rela tive to Mrs. Christina Justedt, on whose farm, south of Demotte, the parts of a 1 burled automobile were recovered yes ' terday. Is of a startling nature. Resi ' dents of Jasper county are confident the woman is Mrs. Belle Gunness. She ' came to Demotte the last of April, 1908, a. few days after the burning of the Gunness house here. She is 52 years 1 of age, weight 200 pounds, rawboned, 5 ' feet 4 Inches. Neighbors speak of the many mys terious visits made by strange people, and to satisfy public clamor Chief of Police Cochrane will go to Demotte to identify the woman if possible.
Clipping to come
Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.
Coroner's physicians reported that jaw bones found on the Gunness farm came from an adult human skull, which prosecutors said was needed to establish corpus delicti against Ray Lamphere. Separately, gold globules found in the excavation were being examined by a jeweler to determine if they were dental fillings from a woman's teeth.
Semi-Weekly Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 2
Minnesota Man Brings Suit. Laporte, Ind. Tonness P. Lien, Rushford, Minn., today retained counsel to bring action against the estate of Mrs. Belle Gunness, multi-murderess, for $1,000, the amount given tho T^nan by Samuel Lien, who is believed to uive been one of her victims.
Clipping to come
Semi-Weekly Herald · Durango, Colo.
A newspaper's miscellaneous commentary column makes a brief sarcastic remark that 'Mrs. Gunness and her morgue' have not yet been turned into a stage drama, implying the case was already widely sensationalized. It treats the Gunness murders as common public knowledge amid other unrelated political and crime items.
Semi-Weekly Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Thousands of visitors returned to the Gunness farm, viewing the unidentified skeletons displayed in a temporary morgue and buying refreshments and souvenirs sold on the grounds. A county grand jury was set to convene the next day to begin hearing evidence in the case.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Laporte county grand jury began hearing the case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children and burning her home. Forty witnesses were present, and extra bailiffs guarded the grand jury room.
The New Haven Union · 18 May 1908 · page 8
: ! La Porte, Ind.,, Dec. 4.—*ls Mrs. Gunness wanted there? If so, what reward? \Wire at once.” This tele -Igram Sheriff Anstiss received yester |day from 1. H. Williams, sheriff of | Delta, Colo.
A bank teller and the half-brother of John Moe of Elbow Lake, Minn., positively identify him as a victim of Belle Gunness after he withdrew $1,100 before disappearing. The report also notes wildly varying estimates of Gunness's total take and a possible sighting of her boarding a steamer in Galveston.
Waterbury Evening Democrat · 18 May 1908 · page 6
ANOTHER GUNNESS VICTIM.
borative evidence. About six weeks ago he wrote a lot ter to the sheriff of La Porte county, but received no reply. Yesterday, thinking that the woman was about to make some move, he sent a tele gram which is quoted in the dispatch from La Porte. He said last night that he would take no further action unless stronger evidence developed or a reward was offered which would justify him in going into the case more thoroughly. el Mrs. A. W. Root is dangerously, ill at her home in the city. L a3
Clipping to come
The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
Thousands of sightseers visited the La Porte farm where Belle Gunness's victims were found, bringing picnics and buying souvenirs and refreshments sold by local vendors. The La Porte county grand jury was set to convene the next morning to take up the case.
The San Francisco Call · 18 May 1908 · page 1
PICNIC CROWDS THRONG GUNNESS MURDER FARM
Evidently there are notable excep tions to the rule that large bodies knove slowly. It didn't take President Taft very long to write his IB, 000 (word message to congress after he got started. According to the general managers of the railroads in the northwest the strike of the switchmen, which tied them up pretty effectively, is as good as broken. It Is to be noticed, though, that the roads are not handling much freight. Mrs. Belle Gunness has been locat
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
Thousands of sightseers again visited the Gunness farm, viewing the skeletons of unidentified victims amid a carnival-like atmosphere with vendors and excursion trains. The Laporte County grand jury was set to convene the next morning, with forty-one witness summonses already issued.
Los Angeles Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 2
EXCURSION TRAINS ARE RUN TO LAPORTE
By Associated Press. LAPORTE, ma., May I".—The scenes of last Sunday were repeated today at the Gunness farm. Fully 10,000 people— quite as many as a week visited the "farm of mys tery" and saw all there was to be seen, even to viewing the skeletons of the seven unidentified dead, for the temporary morgue was open part of the day and persons were permitted to gaze at the bones of Mrs. Gunnees' victims. , . -Hundreds brought their lunches along, for the day was an ideal one, and at noon family groups dotted the orchard and the large front lawn of the • Gunness farm.
See moreSee less
Souvenirs of all kinds were sold on the grounds, the people buying readuy, nobody going away without a reminder of some kind. Refreshments also were dis pensed on the grounds ny enterprising owners of lemonade, ice cream and peanut stands. Excursion trains were run on the Pore Marquette and Lake Erie rail roads, while all Lake Shore trains car ried extra coaches for I-aportr. The traction cars also were crowded all day. The Laporte county grind jury will convene tomorrow morning for the purpose of taking up the Gunness case. Forty'one summonses for wit nesses have already been served, and it. is estimated that at least ten more witnesses will be called, making' fifty in all. It is expected that from four to six days will be required for the grand jury to hear all of the. evidence, and so no report Is looked for until the end of tho week. The grand Jury is composed of six men. Coroner Mack tonight signed a re lease, for the body of Ole Budsberg, which was identified last week by the two sons. The body will be shipped to Tola, Wts., where it will be buried in tli^ family lot. Budsberg came to Imports in April, 1907; and drew $1200 from an lola hank through a Laporte bank, Mrs. Gunness being with him at the time. Budsberg never left the Gunness farm. Coroner Mack gave the cause of death as unknown.
Large crowds visited Laporte via excursion trains and crowded streetcars, with vendors selling refreshments. The Laporte county grand jury was set to convene to hear evidence in the Gunness case, with fifty witnesses expected, while the body of victim Ole Budsberg was released for burial in Iola, Wisconsin.
The Laporte grand jury took up the case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children and setting fire to the Gunness home. Forty witnesses were on hand, and the coroner received a letter from a Toledo woman fearing her daughter was among Gunness's victims.
Evening Journal · 18 May 1908 · page 3
LAMPHERE ACCUSED OF MURDERING MRS. GUNNESS.
IN PENTENTIARY Man Serving a Term for Burnlpg Up mi the Gunness Home, Died In His Ceil. LA PORTE. Ind., Dec. 31.—Roy Lam phere, aged thirty-eight, slayer of Mrs.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A brief newspaper digest line reports that investigators estimate Belle Gunness swindled or looted about $46,000 from victims, with the information tied to Cleveland. The item appears only as a short headline in a broader news roundup, without further detail.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Laporte Coroner Mack released a statement saying Belle Gunness killed both from an uncontrollable mania for taking life and for financial gain, recapitulating her victims and the money obtained from them, totaling $46,169. The sheriff also described seeing a tray full of jewelry and a secret room in her house, while a third body was identified by a man from North Dakota.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 1
TOTALS $46,169
Laporte, Ind., May li.—Corener Mack gave out a statement to-night showing that the archmurderess, Mrs, Gunness, not only killed because she evidently had an uncontrollable mania for taking
Coroner Mack's statement says Belle Gunness killed not only from a mania for murder but also for money, having obtained about $46,169 from her victims. Meanwhile thousands of sightseers again flocked to the ruined Gunness farm, digging for evidence and picnicking near the site.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Laporte, Ind., May li.—Corener Mack gave out a statement to-night showing that the archmurderess, Mrs, Gunness, not only killed because she evidently had an uncontrollable mania for taking human life, but that the lust for money ‘was another impelling motive for luring victims to her chamber of death. The statement consists of a recapitula tion of her victims and the money she obtained from them. This totaled, ac cording to the statement, $46 900, To-day was last Sunday over again, thousands tramping the acres of the Gun ness farm, digging among the debris for grewsome evidence of erime, carrying away the bricks of the wrecked walls of the house, eating picnic dinners and suppers under the shadows of trees near which other bodies will probably be found, i standing in groups of hundreds listening to the hawking of vendors, who rehashed the story of the tragedy to better sell their wares, and looking at the skeleton forms in the improvised morgue.
A humor column of miscellaneous one-liners includes a quip that the Laporte, Ind. police have reduced the Gunness case to the statement that she is alive if she isn't dead. It's a satirical aside amid unrelated jokes about politics, peace conferences, and prosperity.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 6
Michigan City. Laporte, Ind.. Dec. 30.-Ray lam phere. 38 years of age, convicted slayer I of Mrs. Belie Gunness and her chil dren, died tonight of tuberculosis in the Mlchigan City penitentiary, wh're he was serving an Indeterminate term for arson. Lamphere on April 8. 1908, , set fire to the Gunness home near La porte and Incinerated the family. He had been employed by Mrs. Ounness as a workman on her farm. Following the fire bodies of several persons murdered by Mrs. Gunness were uneartherd in the yard. It was shown that Lamphere was probably, cognisant of some of the qunness crimes and that he was angry with her. me a t' ouww,' a* I
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
A humor miscellany column jokes that the one man who visited Mrs. Gunness and survived could profit by selling his story to newspapers or magazines. It treats the Gunness case as already widely known public knowledge.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 6
Michigan City. Laporte, Ind.. Dec. 30.-Ray lam phere. 38 years of age, convicted slayer I of Mrs. Belie Gunness and her chil dren, died tonight of tuberculosis in the Mlchigan City penitentiary, wh're he was serving an Indeterminate term for arson. Lamphere on April 8. 1908, , set fire to the Gunness home near La porte and Incinerated the family. He had been employed by Mrs. Ounness as a workman on her farm. Following the fire bodies of several persons murdered by Mrs. Gunness were uneartherd in the yard. It was shown that Lamphere was probably, cognisant of some of the qunness crimes and that he was angry with her. me a t' ouww,' a* I
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
This miscellaneous humor column references the ongoing confusion over Belle Gunness's fate, quoting police as saying she is alive if she isn't dead. It also jokes about a man who visited her and survived, suggesting he could profit by selling his story.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 6
RAY LAMPHERt DEAD Slayer of Mrs. Guinne6s Died With out Confession I.aporte, Intl., Dec. 30. Kay I.amp hero, tho slayer of Mrs. Belle Gun tiB.ss and her children, died tonight r? tuberculosis in the Michigan City penitentiary where he was serving an indeterminate term for arson. He was attended at death by the -physc-ian chaplain, but made no statement about the Gunness eases. NORTH BENNINGTON Miss Kinnia Bryant is at her home in Manchester for a short vacation. George Norton Phillips of Cam bridge, Mass., is spending a few days in town.
See moreSee less
Miss Jennie itandistol of Kenning ton is spending a week with her eou Kin, Mrs. Coney Fiuiirieh of Water street. Ikitt't forget I hut t Ii ? Fish anil Game club will hold their annual ball tonight in tank hall. .Music will be furnished by Goldsmith's orchestra. The annual meeting of the North Bennington Cemetery association will be held at the First National hank of North MenninKton on Monday the third day of January, A. IX, 1910 at 7: o0 o'clock p. ni., to transact nec essary business and elect officers for the ensuing year.
Clipping to come
The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.
This brief line from the Herald's daily news summary references a separate story reporting that Mrs. Gunness' stolen loot amounted to $46,500. It gives no further detail, merely indexing the story for readers.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 1
HERALD NEWS SUMMARY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Laporte's coroner released a statement showing Belle Gunness murdered both from bloodlust and for money, totaling $46,900 taken from victims. Meanwhile crowds continued flocking to the farm, picnicking and collecting souvenirs while a third body was identified.
Thousands of sightseers converged on the wrecked Gunness farm, picnicking and collecting souvenirs while searching for evidence, as excursion trains brought visitors from several states. Authorities identified another victim, John Moe, and prepared for the grand jury session set to begin the next day.
The Washington Herald · 18 May 1908 · page 1
To-morrow before daylight the body of Ole Budsberg, of Iola, Wis, will be taken | from the barn on Murder Hill to the morgue in this city and prepared for shipment to the home town. Budsberg came to Laporte in 1%7 on a matrimonial mission. He was the bearer of $2,000, and within a few days after his arrival he disappeared. His fate was death. The third practical identification of the bodies in tite morgue was made to-day with the arrival of J, G. Renden, of Manfred, N. Dak., who, after walking among the skeleton forms, lifting the shroud which covered each, eame to a body which he declared to be that of his half-brother, John E.
See moreSee less
Moe, of Elbow Lake, Minn, who is believed to have been murdered the night of December 25, 187, the same night or the night fellow. Ing the tragic fate of Jennie Olsen. Attend Christmas Party, "There was a Christmas party at the Gunness house, in which Jennie Olsen and John Moe were participants. Cireum | stances point to the conclusion that on the night marking the close of the day of Yuletide festivities in the Gunness home, both Jennie Olsen and Join Moe met their end in the death chamber. Mrs. Gunness obtained $1,500 from Moe, The half-brother identified the body from the contour of the skull and the color of the hair which still adhered to the skull. Renden is so confident of identification that the body will be taken to the littie Minnesota town for burial, and this body will escape the potter's field, To-morrow the grand jury will begin its history-making session. State's At torney Smith does not believe the labors of the body wlll be concluded before Thursday or Friday. Probably forty witnesses will be examined. The mgst significant statement proving the mur derous plotting developed to-day with the statement by Ray Lamphere that when he was employed at the house he one day got a glimpse into one of the mysterious chambers of Mrs, Gunness on the second floor. He said it wag almost completely filled with men’s clothing, while upon another occasion she showed him a tray completely filled with men's watches and rings. She had a treasure room which con tained the loot taken from the bodies of har wiotimme
The Laporte county grand jury began investigating the deaths of fourteen persons at Belle Gunness's farm, while the prosecutor and police chief received threatening letters demanding they drop the case. The sheriff denied rumors he had located Gunness aboard an outgoing steamer, and investigators examined a new possible victim, Abraham Phillips.
Evening Star · 18 May 1908 · page 8
GRAND JURY HAS THE CASE INVESTIGATING DEATH OF 14 ON GUNNESS FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
A new probable victim, Abraham Phillips of West Virginia, is identified after he vanished in 1907 to marry a 'rich widow' believed to be Mrs. Gunness. Sheriff Smutzer denies rumors of her capture, continues sluicing and digging the farm for remains, and plans to drag a nearby pond and move the barn to search for more bodies.
Evening Star · 18 May 1908 · page 8
ON GUNNESS FARM.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
The La Porte county grand jury began hearing the case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her three children and burning her home, with forty witnesses summoned. Hamburg authorities were asked to arrest a suspected woman traveling overseas, while Coroner Mack received a letter from a Toledo mother fearing her missing daughter was among Gunness's victims.
The Washington Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A woman resembling Belle Gunness was identified by witnesses in Galveston boarding the Hamburg-American liner Dania, claiming her husband had died and she was traveling to Germany to settle his estate. Hamburg police were cabled to arrest her upon arrival, and passengers noted her nervousness and suspicious denial of knowledge about the La Porte case.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Washington Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
SUSPECTED WOMAN ON OCEAN
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
The La Porte county grand jury began hearing testimony from forty witnesses in the case against Ray Lamphere, accused of murdering Belle Gunness and her children and burning her home. Authorities believe Mrs. Gunness escaped aboard the liner Dania to Europe, with Hamburg police asked to arrest her, while digging for more victims' remains continues at the farm.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Washington Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
LANPHERE CASE BEFORE GRAND JURY
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Passengers aboard a ship departing Galveston claim to have identified a woman matching Belle Gunness's description, noting her nervous curiosity about the La Porte case and her story about settling her late husband's estate in Germany. The report also tallies over $50,000 in suspected murder profits from her victims.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Washington Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
ON WAY OVER SEA
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
This is a newspaper's front-page table of contents listing multiple stories, including items about threats against officers involved in the Gunness investigation and a grand jury beginning its probe. The passage itself is an index rather than a full article, mixing unrelated local and national news headlines.
Evening Times-Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
The grand jury convened to investigate the deaths of fourteen people at Belle Gunness's farm, while the prosecutor and police chief received anonymous letters from New York threatening their lives if they continued the investigation. Separately, authorities began investigating the disappearance of Abraham Phillips, a West Virginia man who came to LaPorte in 1907 to marry a wealthy widow and was never seen again.
Evening Times-Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Evening Times-Republican · Marshalltown, Iowa
A joking item mocks the flood of contradictory reports that Mrs. Gunness has been seen in many places at once, suggesting she must have an airship to be everywhere simultaneously. It pokes fun at the unreliable, conflicting sighting reports circulating about her.
Evening Times-Republican · 18 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho
As a grand jury convenes to investigate the deaths of 14 people at Belle Gunness's farm, Prosecutor Smith receives another threatening letter from Brooklyn demanding he resign and drop the case. The police chief has received similar death threats.
Lewiston Evening Teller · 18 May 1908 · page 1
WHO SENDS THESE LETTERS PROSECUTOR AND CHIEF OF POLICE AT LA PORTE THREATENED WITH DEATH UNLESS THEY DROP INVESTIGATION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
The report references a 'startling series of incidents' known about Mrs. Gunness and her actions prior to the fire at her farm. It appears to be part of ongoing investigative coverage examining her behavior leading up to the fatal fire.
The Lake County Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A humor column of random jibes and one-liners includes a pun referencing the 'Laporte ogress' and the sacks used in disposing of victims. It treats the ongoing Belle Gunness case as a topical joke rather than reporting new facts.
The Lake County Times · 18 May 1908 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A local news roundup item notes that another large crowd of Gary residents traveled to Laporte to view the scenes of the Gunness tragedy, numbering about fifteen, similar to the previous week. The rest of the passage covers unrelated local news from Gary, Clark Station, Dyer, and Hobart.
The Lake County Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Lake County Times · Hammond, Ind.
A St. John community news column reports routine local happenings, including that Mr. and Mrs. Wm. Koehle made an automobile trip to Laporte on Sunday specifically to view the Gunness farm. The mention treats the farm as a now-famous local curiosity for sightseers.
The Lake County Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
ST. JOHN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The report credits Asle Helgelein's persistent efforts with unearthing the many murders allegedly committed by Mrs. Gunness. It includes a picture of Helgelein alongside an unrelated biographical sketch of Governor John A. Johnson.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 18 May 1908 · page 6
GOVERNOR JOHNSON INSTRUMENTAL IN UNEARTHING HORRORS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A photograph and caption identify Justina Loffler Hock as one of the victims of Mrs. Gunness of Laporte, Indiana. The item presents her as newly confirmed among those killed by the woman dubbed a 'modern Borgia.'
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 18 May 1908 · page 6
VICTIM OF MODERN BORGIA.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Sheriff Schultz resumes sluicing the Gunness farm seeking teeth and remains, with plans to drag the pond and dig under the barn. Separately, a woman who fled toward Germany via Galveston and St. Louis is suspected by witnesses to be Belle Gunness due to her resemblance and odd behavior.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 18 May 1908 · page 8
Revealed. 'laporte, Ind., May IS. Sheriff S6nmtzeiandExpert Miner Schultz re sumed sluicing 'the Gunness farm to Vlay. Schultz is confident that he willflnd thwomaa's teeth if they are tin the ruins. When the sluicing ia completed the eheriff . will excavate further in what is known as the -Gunness private hur-4algrounds, and expects to find more skeletons. It was also announced today that he will start the dragging of . pondmear theprivate cemetery in re ponsetnianydemand3 that this be 'done, althtough -hehas little hope of lfinding.anyth.lng. The barn is also to iie remowedi'this week and excavations taaada under the cement floor.
See moreSee less
Tfter woman who embarked at Galves toa,,Texae, forIIamhurg, and was in teccteWefi. bji James Stokes and Frank Dayton-' because they suspected her of telhfe, Mrs. Gunness onaccount of re semblance and-her peculiar actions, is believed to be the same woman who paseedi through. St. Louis recently and was suspected by union station employeKvtob Mrs. Gunness. She pur chasedtapullman .ticket there and reinainedinher berth until she reached Fortworth. To Stokes and Dayton ehe admitted being from Indiana and explained her trip as being for the pur pose jofselling an estate of her hus band' in Germany, who had recently died. She declared she had never heard anything about the Gunness hor rors in Indiana and displayed much nervousness when the subject was dis cussed in her presence. It is claimed she tallied closely with the missing murderess. Three -new graves have been located on the Gunness farm. Other discover ies are expected momentarily. The county grand jury began its in vestigation of the tragedies of the Gunness farm this morning. Prose cutor R. N. Smith presented the first of 50 witnesses to testify against Ray Lamphere, accused of burning Mrs. Belle Gunness and her children alive in their house on April 2S, and sus pected of having aided Mrs. Gunness in the murder of Andrew K. Helge lein on January 14. Indictments charging arson and murder in the first degree are looked upon as a foregone conclusion. There, is a strong possibility that an indlct mentwill be voted charging Lamphere withbeing, an accessory to the mur der of llfefgelein. In any case tho.actionof'the grand jury will precipitate a legal fight in which politics, and perhaps. some elements which at pre sent are 'not generally known, will have an -active part. The'grand jury is composed as fol lows: N. D. McCormick, ex-sheriff, foreman;- August Z. Anders, farmer;
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Investigators continued excavating the Gunness farm and dragging a pond for more victims, while a woman resembling Belle Gunness was being tracked after fleeing toward Germany via Texas. Meanwhile, the county grand jury began hearing testimony against Ray Lamphere, accused of murder and arson in the deaths of Belle Gunness and her children.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 18 May 1908 · page 8
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
The grand jury investigating the murder of Andrew Helgelein and the Gunness farm fire is expected to indict for arson and first-degree murder, possibly naming Lamphere as an accessory. Numerous witnesses, including Joseph Maxson, local women, officers, and bank officials, are set to testify about Lamphere's threats, Mrs. Gunness's bank deposits, and conflicting statements from a boy witness.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 18 May 1908 · page 8
Henry 'Keithlin, farmer; Fred II. fcahn, ex-county treasurer; Joseph Praser, .retired groceryman; August B arsken,f arm er. Amongthemore important witness will, be i Joseph Maxson. Mrs. Gun Iiess.' hired man, who escaped with tiis life. from the fire; Mrs. Nina Shoe maker and Bessie Wallace, who are expected to testify that Lamphere told themthat he knew enough to endMr8.( Gunness to the gallows, and displayed, enmity toward the woman on theeveof the fire, and Mrs. Eliza beth. Smith; at whose house Lamphere slept on the night the house was burn ed.
A grand jury in La Porte, Indiana has begun investigating the Gunness murder mystery. The report also notes threatening letters have been received in connection with the case.
Rock Island Argus · 18 May 1908 · page 1
TAKES UP WORK
Trace Found of Another Probable Vic tim, Abraham Phillips of Bel ington W. Va. LaPorte, Ind., May IS. The county grand jury convened this morning and immediately began work toward an investigation of the mystery surround ing the death of 14 persons at the
The LaPorte county grand jury convenes to investigate the deaths of 14 persons at Belle Gunness's farm, while threatening letters warn the prosecutor and police chief to drop the case. A new probable victim, Abraham Phillips of West Virginia, is identified after he vanished in 1907 while traveling to marry a rich widow.
Rock Island Argus · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Trace Found of Another Probable Vic tim, Abraham Phillips of Bel ington W. Va. LaPorte, Ind., May IS. The county grand jury convened this morning and immediately began work toward an investigation of the mystery surround ing the death of 14 persons at the farm of Mrs. Belle Gunness. Prosecutor Smith today received letter from Brooklyn, N. Y., which threatened him with deathN unless he resigns his office and drops the Gun ness investigation. Chief of Police Cochrane is in receipt of a letter from New York saying his life will pay the forfeit unlesshe ceases his activity.
Coroner Mack ordered autopsies on seven unidentified bodies exhumed from Belle Gunness' farm, with two containing preserved organs to test for poison. One body was identified by her father and sister as Jennie Olson, while Sheriff Smutzer denied rumors of Gunness being located on a departing steamer.
The Topeka State Journal · 18 May 1908 · page 7
JENNIE OLSON'S BODY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A Des Moines woman claims Andrew Helgelein was guided by a medium's clairvoyant vision to the exact burial spot of his brother at the Gunness farm. She says he only revealed this reasoning to a hotel acquaintance shortly before leaving La Porte.
The Topeka State Journal · 18 May 1908 · page 8
SPIRITS TOLD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A clairvoyant reportedly told Asle Helgelein the details of his brother's murder and burial location before he traveled to La Porte and pointed out the exact grave site. Meanwhile, Sheriff Smutzer continues sluicing farm debris for gold and teeth, plans to dig the burial ground three feet deep, drag the pond, and possibly move the barn, as the grand jury takes up the case.
The Topeka State Journal · 18 May 1908 · page 8
TOLD HIM THE SPOT
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Authorities plan to dig the entire burial plot three feet deep and drag the nearby pond for more victims, while the Laporte grand jury begins hearing testimony. Prosecutors and police report receiving threatening letters demanding they drop the case, and a search begins for a possible new victim, Abraham Philips.
The Topeka State Journal · 18 May 1908 · page 8
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
A photograph caption describes a holiday crowd of curious onlookers peering into one of the many graves discovered on the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana. The caption notes that four bodies of murdered victims were found in pits close to the site.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Holiday Crowd of the Morbidly Curious Peering Into One of the Graves on the Gunness Farm
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
The report claims Belle Gunness has been identified aboard the liner Dania crossing the Atlantic, based on tips from Sheriff Smutzer and witnesses who spoke with her in Galveston. It also tallies her alleged insurance fraud proceeds from victims at $52,900.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
MRS. GUNNESS ON HER WAY ACROSS ATLANTIC
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
A woman resembling Belle Gunness was identified in Galveston boarding the liner Dania for Germany, prompting a cable request to Hamburg police for her arrest upon arrival; she claimed to be settling her late husband's estate. Meanwhile, Sheriff Smutzer found a new grave on the murder farm and tallied Gunness's insurance and murder profits at over $50,000.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Authorities in La Porte, Indiana issued a report charging Belle Gunness with twenty-two murders, including her two husbands and various men believed to be suitors. Digging for more bodies continued at the farm, with officials noting the total could rise to twenty-five if Gunness proved to still be alive and the headless body found was another victim.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
22 MURDERS NOW LAID AT DOOR OF MRS. GUNNESS - REPORT ISSUED BY LA PORTE, IND., AUTHORITIES
SCN STILL LIVES. I.A PORTE. I ml., May Hi —Twenty ’two death* are now charged to Mr* Bell** GuDuesa, arcb*njurdt*ri‘»* of th** age. lu a report given out ! b> the authorities, today. Saould il he proved later, that Mrs. Gunness it* alive an l that the headless body of a won.an found in the ruins is that of another victim the total number will be increased by three, counting the t»o children who jjert>hed lu the Are. and ’he total number of muruers for which Mrs. Guuness will have to an swer will reach twenty-five.
See moreSee less
The digging for mure bodies that was begun early in the day. it is tho j belief of the sheriff, will disclose stii 1 I more victims, if the quick-lime in w hich all the dismembered bodies j Were buried, bas not destroyed all : traces of human semblance. The list given out is as follows: Mads Sorenson, first husband; N*** ter Gunness. second husband; An drew Heigeietn, Mansfield, S. D»:
The sheriff's office released an expanded list of suspected victims found in the Gunness farm, while digging for more bodies continued. Lamphere's defense team denied all identifications, including that of Helgelien, and suggested Jennie Olson might still be alive in a California convent.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
Tho ■*. ji.rv »i u claimed v 11 begin Monday to investigate the evi dence gathered by Sheriff Smutzer and Prosecutor Smith. LA PORTE. Ind.. May 16—Com plete denial of all Identification of bodies found In the Guoness "house of death, •’ throwing on the state the burden of proving identity in each case; absolute denial of every In criminating act charged against Ray Lamphere and the introduction of im portant evidence in behalf of the prisoner, is the latest sensation sprung by the defense in the most mysterious series of murders the world has ever known. It is now settled that Ellsworth \Veir ; famous criminal lawyer, will be of counsel for Lamphere anJ money is being furnished for his de fense from an unknown source
The defense plans to argue that the body identified as Andrew Helgelein was too decomposed for certain identification, while new correspondence suggests Jennie Olsen may be alive in a California convent rather than Los Angeles. Meanwhile, a Michigan farmer mistakenly held a traveling book agent captive, believing her to be Belle Gunness.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
I three hours Thursday night, believing he had the arch-murderess of Laporte. He refused to release the frightened woman when ordered to. The man was ordered to do so by telephone from the sheriff's office and a deputy had to be sent out.
A photo caption describes holiday crowds of the morbidly curious peering into one of the many graves discovered on the Gunness farm near La Porte, Indiana. Four bodies of murdered persons were reportedly found in a pit near the wire fence.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.
Sheriff Smutzer receives information that Belle Gunness is crossing the Atlantic on the liner Dania, having been identified in Galveston by witnesses before sailing. The woman reportedly aroused suspicion through her curiosity about the case and claimed she was traveling to Germany after her husband's death.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
Ii SHERIFF SMUTZER. LAPORTE, j IND. TWO CLAIM TO HAVE ! [ IDENTIFIED ARCH SLAYER. Martinss' Bloody Traffic . Britt(bt Hir $52,900 DUPES INSURANCE* Mads Sorenson I b.Oo» Feter Qunnui ? Chas. Erdman Merman Konitsor 6.000 Fire inaurunce company, for •tore, Chicago 3.500 Fire Insurance company, for house. Austin. 11l i ** o '? Ole O. Budsberg 2.000 John O. Moo l.»o« Andrew Helgeleln 2.000 Geo Berry lo^o Henry Oerhall 1.000 Four other murder victims 11.000 each •* 000 It unknown correspondents. 11.000 each 15.000 Total 352,t00 I'i I 'LA PORTE.
See moreSee less
Ind., May 18 Mrs ft Belie Gunness. arch-murderess and of the ’house of horror." ■to Which her suitors were lured for ■ •Utughter, Is today speeding across Ktik* Atlantic uu the Hamburg-Amerl ■mb liner Dania, according to lnforma BfelOO received by Sheriff Smutzer The authorities at Hamburg have asked by cable to arrest the ■proman upon her arrival. ftßthe Identification In Galveston of a woman who tallies ex act ' ■ with the missing murderess, was by James Stokes and Frank who talked with the woman ■Plat as she was about to sail on the Several of the passengers were the gruesome La Porte and their first suspicion that |Khe woman with whom they were was Mrs. Gunnesg was arous ■d by the curiosity which she maul ■kited and the frequency with which flUhe declared she had never before KSiftrd adything about the case. If Said She Visited Indiana. [■pShe said she was familiar with InKflana. having visited In Indianapolis Bf number of times. In explaining her B Object In going abroad, she said that ■Per husband had just died and that Kobe was going to Germany to settle H Pis estate. [I L This woman is believed to have iftPsen the same one who passed ■through St. Louis a day earlier and HrWho was thought by Union station of ■Petals to be Mrs. Gunness. She atK tracted attention by her extreme nerWousness. At St. Louis she purchas ed a Pullman ticket and left her bwtb only once during the entire trip to Port Worth, Tex., where she dlsap Reared. r Find a New Grave. L Anew grave has been found on the murder arm and Sheriff Smutzer ex pects to unearth another body before Bight. The spot is about forty rods worn the place where 10 bodies were; The ground Is soft, and when a pipe was pounded Into the earth evli dence was given that a body had been Purled there. Two other suspicious •pots lave been located, and those trill be excavated as soon as they can [Pe reached in the course of ihe in1 veetlgatlon. Profitable Murder Traffic. Careful calculations of the amount ■’■•f money which Mrs. Gunness realized by her traffic in human life, sets the amount at over $50,000. The follow [lag abulatlon shows the amounts she Obtained from various victims p From Mads Sorenson, her first husIftPand. life Insurance, $8,000: Peter U.'Gunness. second husband, life insur [fiance, $4,000; Charles Erdman. New ■Carlisle. Ind., $5,000; Herman Konit ftpor. Chicago, $5,000; fire in Gunness Knitore. Grand-ave. and Elizabeth-st.. ■Chicago, insurance, $3,500; fire in ftCtmnesß house in Austiu, 111., insur ■pice. $1,500; Ole O. Budsberg. Ida. f Wla.. $2,000; John O. Moo. Elbow Kl*ke. Minn., $1,500; Andrew Helgel ftain, Aberdeen, S. D.. $2,900; Geo. Ber »**, Tuscola, 111.. $1,500; Henry Ger [■all, tola, Wis , SI,OOO, four men other ■pan the above, whose bodies were! ftfoand in Mrs. Gunness' graveyard (es Mmated at SI,OOO each), $4,000; 15 ■ether men, who were In correspond ifteaee With Mrs. Gunness and myste ■Haaaly disappeared (estimated at sl. m. #•<> each), $15,000. Total, 152.900. | , Sheriff Smutzer and his men have | Spade careful inquiries in endeavor-1 Stag to learn what Mrs. GunDess did' fthrith all this money. They H re as « touch in the dark after their Invest!-1 ftpatlon as they were before it is like-i miy that the $720 that Mrs. Gunness! ft, put In a safety deposit vault, the day iftdf the Are, was all the money she! m then possessed.
Authorities pursue a woman believed to be Belle Gunness aboard the liner Dania, cabling German authorities to arrest her, while another suspected grave is found on the murder farm. A detailed financial tabulation claims Gunness profited over $50,000 from insurance fraud and murder.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
MRS. GUNNESS ON HER WAY ACROSS ATLANTIC
INFORMATION RECEIVED BY SHERIFF SMUTZER, LAPORTE, IND. — TWO CLAIM TO HAVE IDENTIFIED ARCH-SLAYER.
See moreSee less
Murderess' Bloody Traffic Brought Her $52,900
DUPES. INSURANCE. Mads Sorenson ... $8,000 Peter Gunness ... 4,000 Chas. Erdman ... 5,000 Herman Konitzor ... 5,000 Fire insurance company, for store, Chicago ... 3,500 Fire insurance company, for house, Austin, Ill. ... 1,500 Ole O. Budsberg ... 2,000 John O. Moo ... 1,500 Andrew Helgelein ... 2,900 Geo. Berry ... 1,500 Henry Gerhall ... 1,000 Four other murder victims, $1,000 each ... 4,000 15 unknown correspondents, $1,000 each ... 15,000 Total ... $52,900
LA PORTE, Ind., May 18.—Mrs. Belle Gunness, arch-murderess and proprietress of the "house of horror," to which her suitors were lured for slaughter, is today speeding across the Atlantic on the Hamburg-American liner Dania, according to information received by Sheriff Smutzer. The police authorities at Hamburg have been asked by cable to arrest the woman upon her arrival.
The identification in Galveston, Tex., of a woman who tallies exactly with the missing murderess, was made by James Stokes and Frank Dayton, who talked with the woman just as she was about to sail on the Dania. Several of the passengers were discussing the gruesome La Porte case and their first suspicion that the woman with whom they were talking was Mrs. Gunness was aroused by the curiosity which she manifested and the frequency with which she declared she had never before heard anything about the case.
Said She Visited Indiana.
She said she was familiar with Indiana, having visited in Indianapolis a number of times. In explaining her object in going abroad, she said that her husband had just died and that she was going to Germany to settle his estate.
This woman is believed to have been the same one who passed through St. Louis a day earlier and who was thought by Union station officials to be Mrs. Gunness. She attracted attention by her extreme nervousness. At St. Louis she purchased a Pullman ticket and left her berth only once during the entire trip to Fort Worth, Tex., where she disappeared.
Find a New Grave.
A new grave has been found on the murder farm and Sheriff Smutzer expects to unearth another body before night. The spot is about forty rods from the place where 10 bodies were found. The ground is soft, and when a pipe was pounded into the earth evidence was given that a body had been buried there. Two other suspicious spots have been located, and those will be excavated as soon as they can be reached in the course of the investigation.
Profitable Murder Traffic.
Careful calculations of the amount of money which Mrs. Gunness realized by her traffic in human life, sets the amount at over $50,000. The following tabulation shows the amounts she obtained from various victims:
From Mads Sorenson, her first husband, life insurance, $8,000; Peter Gunness, second husband, life insurance, $4,000; Charles Erdman, New Carlisle, Ind., $5,000; Herman Konitzor, Chicago, $5,000; fire in Gunness store, Grand-ave. and Elizabeth-st., Chicago, insurance, $3,500; fire in Gunness house in Austin, Ill., insurance, $1,500; Ole O. Budsberg, Iola, Wis., $2,000; John O. Moo, Elbow Lake, Minn., $1,500; Andrew Helgelein, Aberdeen, S. D., $2,900; Geo. Berry, Tuscola, Ill., $1,500; Henry Gerhall, Iola, Wis., $1,000; four men other than the above, whose bodies were found in Mrs. Gunness' graveyard (estimated at $1,000 each), $4,000; 15 other men, who were in correspondence with Mrs. Gunness and mysteriously disappeared (estimated at $1,000 each), $15,000. Total, $52,900.
Sheriff Smutzer and his men have made careful inquiries in endeavoring to learn what Mrs. Gunness did with all this money. They are as much in the dark after their investigation as they were before. It is likely that the $720 that Mrs. Gunness put in a safety deposit vault, the day of the fire, was all the money she then possessed.
The report details a financial tabulation of over $50,000 Mrs. Gunness allegedly obtained through insurance fraud and murder, listing specific victims and amounts. Sheriff Smutzer's investigation into what happened to the money found little trace, suggesting most was unaccounted for.
The Detroit Times · 18 May 1908 · page 6
Profitable Murder Traffic. Careful calculations of the amount ■’■•f money which Mrs. Gunness realized by her traffic in human life, sets the amount at over $50,000. The follow [lag abulatlon shows the amounts she Obtained from various victims p From Mads Sorenson, her first husIftPand. life Insurance, $8,000: Peter U.'Gunness. second husband, life insur [fiance, $4,000; Charles Erdman. New ■Carlisle. Ind., $5,000; Herman Konit ftpor. Chicago, $5,000; fire in Gunness
A dentist who had treated Belle Gunness's teeth examined a jaw bone fragment found on her farm and declared it human, noting it closely resembled her lower jaw. The identification was made by Dr. I. P. Norton at the request of the coroner.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 18 May 1908 · page 2
JAW OF MRS. GUNNESS.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
In Laporte, Indiana, the grand jury began investigating the Gunness farm murder mystery on May 18. The brief dispatch notes only that the inquiry has started, without further detail.
The Hattiesburg News · 18 May 1908 · page 1
♦ grand Jury today began the work ♦ on ♦ of Investigating the Gunness farm ♦ murder mystery. ***** *******A**A , It has been suggested be a good Idea for the FJ of this county to get by oounty unions to .. «• ^ t Ion SOI
The report states that Mrs. Belle Gunness is believed to be alive and en route to Hamburg, Germany aboard the steamer Dania, prompting Sheriff Smutzer to cable police overseas to arrest her upon arrival. Meanwhile, digging resumes at the Gunness farm for more victims, and a reward offer has reignited public doubt over whether the murderess truly died in the house fire.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Hattiesburg News · 18 May 1908 · page 1
SHERIFF SMUTZER CONFIDENT
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
The Hattiesburg News · Hattiesburg, Miss.
A brief newspaper filler item sarcastically notes that Belle Gunness of Indiana has gained notoriety for murdering transient guests, remarking that she has not matched the infamy of Kansas killer Kate Bender. Alongside it is an unrelated rumor from Colorado about a missing man possibly being one of her victims, which the item dismisses as likely a hoax.
The Hattiesburg News · 18 May 1908 · page 4
The highly sensational rumor comes from Colorado that a man who mysteriously disappeared from that state some months ago is not believed to have been one of Mrs. Gunness' vic tims. Sounds like a fake. It Is understood that more than one of the visiting governors took a good look through the White House and wondered how the domestl* arrange ments would suit "the good woman at home." Ex-Governor Vardaman announces that his weekly paper, The Issue, has attained a circulation of nearly 12,000 already. This is a most remarkable record for a Mississippi newspaper. 4 4 4 Air. Taft's manager says thaj ie on the first baj. 1 '- p ro ^.
About ten thousand sightseers visited the Gunness farm again, viewing the skeletons of seven unidentified victims displayed at a temporary morgue, while vendors sold souvenirs and refreshments to the crowds. The La Porte county grand jury was set to convene the next day, with forty-one witness summons already served and four to six days expected for proceedings.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 18 May 1908 · page 3
SIGHTSEERS PICNIC AT GUNNESS FARM
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
Detectives search hotels, lodging houses, and train stations in Chattanooga for a woman believed to be Belle Gunness, while authorities in LaPorte claim she is aboard a German steamer with most of $448,300 stolen from victims. Sheriff Smutzer has cabled Hamburg police to arrest her upon arrival.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 18 May 1908 · page 3
IS. GUNNESS NOW' . I IN CHOUGH ■- I Detectives Searching Hotels and Lodging Houses and Guard ing Stations. BELIEVED TO BE ABOARD STEAMER FOR GERMANY i Authorities Positive She Has; Most of $448,300 Procured j from Victims. CHATTANOOGA. Tenn., May 18. The ubiquitous Mrs. Gunness has been spotted in this city, and the detectives are all agog in their search for her. Hotels and lodging houses are being searched from top to bottom. It is said the woman who is believed to be Mrs. Gunness was first seen at Fort Union, O., to Sloan's Valley, Ky., thence to Chattanooga.
See moreSee less
Detectives are at all the railroad stations. [Special to the Evening Star.] LAPORTE, Ind., May IS.—With most of the half million dollars she is known to have realized from her ghastly crimes m a money belt, Mrs. Belle Gunness, the arch murderess, who was at first thought to have perished in the ruins of her home with her children, is now believed to be aboard a German ship which cleared from New York within the past few days. Hamburg Police Notified. So much new evidence has been dis covered to substantiate this latest the ory that Sheriff Smutzer has cabled to Hamburg asking police authorities there to arrest a woman answering the de scription of Mrs Gunness upon her ar rival there. A carefully tabulated record of the amounts Mrs. Gunness is now known to have wrung from her victims brings the total up to the amazing sum of $448,300. It is the mystery concerning the dispo sition of this money which now con vinces authorities that the woman criminal is yet alive and in possession of most of it. It is now believed that the $750 which Mrs. Gunness put in a local safety vault the day of the fire was intended for a blind to make more plausible the theory that the woman perished with her children when the house was burned. The gruesome work of searching the Gunness farm for bodies continues. The lakes are to be dragged, and the entire yard dug up. J. G. Ramden, of Manfred, N. D„ whose half-brother, John Moe, of Elbow Lake, came to Laporte in December, 1900, reached here today and identified one of the bodies as that of Moe. Moe had saved $1,500 when he was caught in the web spun for him by Mrs. Gun ness. He bought drafts for $1,100 from the bank at Elbow Lake December 30, 1906, saying that he was going to use the money to pay off the mortgage on a farm. He toid his brother if he was successful he would write, and if not, he would be back soon. As a result of the personal investl ! gation of H. W. Worden, counsel for Ray Lamphere, who stands accused of I having slain Mrs. Gunness and her i children, a prominent citizen of La porte, is in hourly danger of arrest. Knew of Her Crinies. It is alleged that for many months this man had known that Belle Gun ness murdered two of her hired men. It is said she confessed she killed Olof Lindoe and Henry Gerlialt becuuse she owed them wages and she believed they suspected some of her earlier crimes. And Now Teachers of West New York, N. J., Threaten to
Authorities now believe Belle Gunness is alive and aboard a German ship bound for Hamburg, carrying most of the $448,300 she swindled from victims. Sheriff Smutzer has cabled Hamburg police to arrest her on arrival, while the search of her farm for more bodies continues.
The Star and Newark Advertiser · 18 May 1908 · page 3
STEAMER FOR GERMANY
Hamburg Police Notified. So much new evidence has been dis covered to substantiate this latest the ory that Sheriff Smutzer has cabled to Hamburg asking police authorities there to arrest a woman answering the de scription of Mrs Gunness upon her ar rival there. A carefully tabulated record of the amounts Mrs. Gunness is now known to have wrung from her victims brings the total up to the amazing sum of $448,300. It is the mystery concerning the dispo sition of this money which now con vinces authorities that the woman criminal is yet alive and in possession of most of it.
See moreSee less
It is now believed that the $750 which Mrs. Gunness put in a local safety vault the day of the fire was intended for a blind to make more plausible the theory that the woman perished with her children when the house was burned. The gruesome work of searching the Gunness farm for bodies continues. The lakes are to be dragged, and the entire yard dug up. J. G. Ramden, of Manfred, N. D„ whose half-brother, John Moe, of Elbow Lake, came to Laporte in December, 1900, reached here today and identified one of the bodies as that of Moe. Moe had saved $1,500 when he was caught in the web spun for him by Mrs. Gun ness. He bought drafts for $1,100 from the bank at Elbow Lake December 30, 1906, saying that he was going to use the money to pay off the mortgage on a farm. He toid his brother if he was successful he would write, and if not, he would be back soon. As a result of the personal investl ! gation of H. W. Worden, counsel for Ray Lamphere, who stands accused of I having slain Mrs. Gunness and her i children, a prominent citizen of La porte, is in hourly danger of arrest.
A half-brother's visit to Laporte confirms John Moe, a Norwegian laborer from Elbow Lake, Minnesota, as one of Belle Gunness's victims; a bank teller verified his identity via photograph. The report also notes wildly varying estimates of Gunness's total take from victims, and a separate unconfirmed sighting of a woman resembling her boarding a steamer in Galveston bound for Hamburg.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 18 May 1908 · page 7
ANOTHER GUNNESS VICTIM IDENTIFIED
Was Slain by the Indiana Woman. Importe, Ind., May 18.—Identification of John Aloe of Elbow Lake, Minn., ai one of the victime of Mrs. Belle Gun ness was made -positive by the arrival of Moe's half brother, J. 0. Rendfen of ι Manfred, N. D. ' Alfred Peglow, paying teller of the First National bank of Laporte, at which Μοβ cashed drafts for $1,100, said "that is the man" as soon as Ren den showed him his brother's photo graph. Renden could throw little new light on the manner of his brother's ensnare ment and death.
See moreSee less
Moe was a frugal Norwegian laborer, forty-two year» old. He had saved about $1,500, which made him big enough flsh for Mrs. Gunness' bait. Ho bought drafts for $1,100 from the bank of Elbow Lake on Deo. 20, 1900, saying he was going to use the money to pay off a mort gage on a farm. Ile did not tell his brother the purpose of his trip. "I'm going away on a short trip," Moe said to Renden, "and if I am sue· 1 cessful I will write you shortly. If I am not, I will be home soon." Estimates are being made of the | amounts of money probably obtained by Mrs. Gunness from her victims. The estimates range from $50,000 to $500,000, but It is not explained how ι the woman was almost penniless after making her will leaving only the $720 she placed In the bank the day before her supposed death In the flre.
The report identifies a Norwegian laborer, who had withdrawn $1,100 in drafts before disappearing, as a probable victim of Belle Gunness, while estimates of her total theft from victims range wildly from $50,000 to $500,000. It also notes an unconfirmed sighting of a woman resembling Gunness boarding a steamer from Galveston to Hamburg.
Perth Amboy Evening News · 18 May 1908 · page 7
VICTIM IDENTIFIED
May Have Been Mre. Qunneee. Galveston, Tex., May J.8.—A woman answering the description of Mrs. Gunness sailed from here on the Ham burg-American line steamer Dauja for Hamburg. James Stokes and Frank Dayton, who talked with her and ob served her actions, declare that If the woman charged with the murders οt the Laporte diystery Is alive the Dania passenger and she are the same.
A mining expert named Louis Schultz began sluicing operations at the ruins of the Gunness farm in La Porte, Indiana. He believed this method could help locate the bodies of victims believed killed by the accused murderess.
Santa Fe New Mexican · 18 May 1908 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Santa Fe New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
Sluicing operations continue at the Gunness farm as authorities search for evidence including Mrs. Gunness's teeth, while the grand jury begins investigating the 14 deaths. Prosecutor Smith and Chief Cochrane receive death threats demanding they drop the case, and another possible victim, Abraham Phillips, is identified as missing after visiting with money to marry the widow.