As the Papers Told It

Belle Gunness · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

Did the Woman Die in Fire?

November – December 1908

Lamphere’s trial in November turned on whether Mrs. Gunness had died in the fire. Neighbors swore they had seen her in July, and the defense said the body in the ruins was another woman’s. The state read her letters urging Helgelein’s brother to come to La Porte with plenty of money, and Dr. Haines could not say whether the arsenic had been given before or after death. The jury found Lamphere guilty of arson only, and he was sentenced to two to 21 years at Michigan City.

The trial will turn on whether she died

A La Porte dispatch previews the trial of Ray Lamphere, opening Monday, for the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children: it will turn on whether she died in the fire at all. His attorneys say people in La Porte saw her on 9 July, while the state promises new evidence tying him to ‘the atrocities of the murder farm’.

The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.

The Washington Times · 5 November 1908 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

MRS. GUNNESS LIVES, DECLARE ATTORNEYS

In Trial of Ray Lamphere Murder Farm Story to Be Retold.

See moreSee less

LA PORTE, Ind., Nov. 5.—Whether Mrs. Belle Gunness is alive, or died in the fire that burned her three children, will be the question at the trial of Ray Lamphere, on Monday, on the charge of murdering Mrs. Gunness and her children. His attorneys declare they will prove that Mrs. Gunness is alive. They declare that the people in La Porte saw the woman on July 9.

The murder, for which Lamphere is held, was committed in April. The story of the fifteen murders at the Gunness farm will be retold at the hearing. Attorneys for the defense say that they have discovered startling evidence. The prosecution declares that new evidence connecting Lamphere with the atrocities of the murder farm will be introduced.

See the clipping

Lamphere turns over the skull fragments

Crowds are turned away as the trial resumes. Coroner C. S. Mack, who had ruled in May that the body in the ruins was hers, can say little without his notes, and the defense calls it absurd to identify the tiny charred fragments said to be from her skull. Lamphere picks up the pieces and turns them over; the paper says he ‘smiled cynically’.

The Detroit Times · Detroit, Mich.

The Detroit Times · 13 November 1908 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

SMILES AT BONES OF GUNNESS SKULL MURDER-SUSPECT LAMPHERE THROWS THEM CONTEMPTUOUSLY DOWN.

LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 13.—A clamoring crowd struggled for admission to the courtroom at the reopening today of the trial of Ray Lamphere for murdering Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children.

See moreSee less

When the first witness, Coroner C. S. Mack, took the stand, scores of women and several hundred men were seeking admission in vain.

Coroner Mack's memory proved extremely defective. He could afford no information of value without referring to his notes.

The fragments of bone, said to be from Mrs. Gunness' skull, placed before the jury, were so small and so charred that the absurdity of an attempt to identify them as having belonged to Mrs. Gunness' body was at once urged by the defense.

When the pieces of charred bone were placed on the table Lamphere rose from his chair and walked to the attorney's table to examien them. He took some of the fragments in his hand and turning them over, smiled cynically.

"Alas, poor Yorik," whispered the assistant counsel for the state as Lamphere tossed the piece of bone contemptuously on the table,

See the clipping

Her letters to the dead man’s brother

Prosecutor Smith reads the jury copies of three letters Mrs. Gunness wrote in March and April to A. K. Helgelin of Aberdeen, S. D., asking him to come to La Porte with plenty of money while his brother Andrew lay buried on her farm. The letters speak of ‘that crazy Lamphere’. A bank cashier had identified a photograph of Andrew as the man who drew $2900 with her in January.

Bisbee Daily Review · Bisbee, Ariz.

Bisbee Daily Review · 17 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

METHODS OF GUNNESS WOMAN SHOWN BY LETTERS TO HELGELIN Arch Murderess Invited Broth er of Man She Killed to Visit Her. LA PORTE, Ind., Nov. 16.—Prose cutor Smith played another trump card today when with A. K. Helgelin, of Aberdeen, S. D., on the stand, he offered in evidence and read to the jury copies of three letters written by Mrs. Belle Gunness to the witness during March and April of this year, in which references to "that crazy Lamphere" are made. These letters portray the methods employed by the arch-murderess in allaying the suspicions of relatives of persons she murdered.

See moreSee less

Even with Andrew Helgelin lying dismembered in her private graveyard, she was asking his brother to come to La Porte to investigate and to bring plenty of money with him. Correspondence between A. K. Helgelin and the First National Bank was also offered in evidence, Cashier Pitner having identified a photograph of Andrew Helgelin as the man who came to the bank with Mrs. Gunness early in January and drew $2900. Mrs. Gunness is supposed to have murdered Helgelin on January 14.

See the clipping

Defense will argue she was a suicide

Lamphere’s friend and neighbor Wm. Slater testifies that Lamphere had chased Andrew Helgelein with a gun, and that Mrs. Gunness had promised to marry Lamphere once he joined a secret society and took out insurance. Attorney Warden then states the defense’s line in court for the first time: it will try to show she was a suicide, though before the trial his side had said she was alive.

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · Vinita, Indian Territory Okla.

The Vinita Daily Chieftain · 17 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

DEFENSE TO CLAIM SHE WAS SUICIDE

Friend of Ray Lamphere Testifies That Mrs. Gunness had Promised to Marry Defendant

See moreSee less

By Associated Press

La Porte Ind., Nov. 17—That Ray Lamphere had confessed to intimacy with Mrs. Belle Gunness, and that he had chased Andrew Helgelein with a gun, and that Mrs. Gunness had promised to marry Lamphere when he joined some secret society and took out insurance, were sensational facts, testified today by Wm. Slater, a friend and neighbor of the defendant. The first positive statement of the defense in conrt to show its line of defense was made by Attorney Warden, when he remarked that an effort would be made to show that Mrs. Gunness was a suicide.

See the clipping

Lamphere’s strange tale to the sheriff

The hired man Joseph Maxson denies the defense suggestion that Mrs. Gunness ‘doped’ him with oranges on the night of the fire. Sheriff Smutzer testifies that in January Lamphere told him she was looking for Helgelein, a man wanted in South Dakota for murder and a $10,000 robbery. Aberdeen wired back that no such crime had occurred. A month later Lamphere said Helgelein had left for Chicago.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 19 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LAMPHERE CORNERED

Evidence Strong That He Caused Death of Fecale Bluebeard

See moreSee less

He Is Closely Connected With Mrs. Gunness' Helgeline Deal

Laporte, Ind., Nov. 18.—Carefully working up to the denouement, the evidence by which it is sought to show that Ray Lamphere set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness and thereby caused the death of her and her three children, Prosecutor Smith today unravelled before the jury the stories of the fire, told by the men who were earliest on the scene.

The greatest interest naturally centered about the testimony of Jos. Maxson, the hired man, but it varied in no great particular from the story he told to the court and which he related before the coroner's jury.

Indirectly Wair, for the defense, on cross examination, tried to imply that Mrs. Gunness, on the night of the fire had "doped" Maxson in the oranges which he ate, but he denied this.

According to the defense, Maxson was alleged to have told his sister such a story, but he denied positively on the stand that he had made such a declaration or that he ever believed that there was any "dope" in the oranges.

The explanation of the $10,000 story referred to in the letter from Mrs. Gunness to A. K. Helgeline regarding the disappearance of his brothtr, was made today. Lamphere is under indictment for the murder of Andrew Helgeline and for alleged complicity with Mrs. Gunness in that murder.

Sheriff Smutzer told on the stand of the circumstances which could have prevented Helgeline's presence in Laporte. He said that early in January Lamphere came to him and said: "If I want to tell something, I can make it interesting for her." Sheriff Smutzer understood him to mean Gunness. Lamphere went on to tell the sheriff that Mrs. Gunness was looking for a man named Helgeline, who was wanted in South Dakota for murder, having held up a man in a gambling house and had seized $10,000, but had been forced to kill the fellow before he could get away.

Sheriff Smutzer immediately wired the authorities in Aberdeen, the town named by Lamphere, and received in reply, a telegram that said that there had been no murder nor $10,000 robbery and that Andrew Helgeline was a well known farmer in that vicinity and that he was not wanted there for any crime.

Sheriff Smutzer, with this disclosure, paid no attention to Lamphere. A month later Lamphere, when questioned by the sheriff regarding Helgeline, told the officer that Helegeline had left Laporte for Chicago that morning on the 5:10 train.

Sheriff Smutzer also testified to seeing Lamphere watching Mrs. Gunness one day in the court house, when she came to his office. She complained about Lamphere annoying her and when the sheriff went to Lamphere and asked him why he did not leave the woman alone, he did not answer.

See the clipping

Neighbors swear they saw her in July

Daniel M. Hulzen, a neighbor hired by the sheriff to dig in the ruins, says he saw Mrs. Gunness on 9 July and ‘could not be mistaken’, though a black veil hid her features; his daughters, aged 11 and 9, back him. John Anderson saw a strange woman with her the Saturday before the fire, the woman the defense says was the adult body in the ruins.

Los Angeles Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

Los Angeles Herald · 22 November 1908 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

BELLE GUNNESS SEEN AFTER FIRE STRANGE WOMAN MAY HAVE BEEN SUBSTITUTE DEFENSE THINKS SHE KILLED GUEST RESEMBLING HER Sensations Sprung in Trial of Ray Lamphere at Laporte—Witnesses Positive in Identification of Slayer

[By Associated Press.]

See moreSee less

LAPORTE, Ind., Nov. 21.—The sensations in the Lamphere trial today were the stories told by Daniel M. Hulzen and his daughters, by Fred R. Rickman and by John Anderson, who saw a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness on the Saturday before the fire.

Hulzen and his daughters declared they saw Mrs. Gunness July 9, but they were unable to distinguish her features through a black veil. Hulzen, a neighbor of Mrs. Gunness and one of the men hired by the sheriff to dig in the ruins of the house for the bodies after the fire, declared he knew Mrs. Gunness so well he could not be mistaken. He said:

"I saw her on the road near the hog pen on July 9. I was returning from town with a rayrack and saw two persons at the Gunness place.

"She had on a light skirt, black waist, wide brimmed hat, a white veil on the hat and a black veil that came down to her chin.

"There was a man with her. He weighed about 150 pounds and had a gray mustache and gray hair.

Afraid to Follow Them

"When I got to within two wagon lengths they got into their buggy and drove on, and I tried to follow them.

"They got ahead of me, and I did not like to follow them. There was too good a chance of getting a chunk of lead. The buggy had a low running gear and black top. The horse was gray with dapples on his hips as large as a half dollar."

Evelyn, the 11-years-old daughter of Hulzen, who followed her father on (Continued on Page Two)

BELLE GUNNESS SEEN AFTER FIRE (Continued from Page One)

the stand, testified she saw Mrs. Gunness in "hay time" near the woods. She was in a buggy with a man. They passed her in the road.

The girl said Mrs. Gunness had on two veils, a black one and a white one, the black one being over her face. The girl said:

"When I saw her she turned her face away from me."

Still Another Witness

Eldora Hulzen, 9 years old, said: "I was playing by the big gate by the road. I saw Mrs. Gunness go by with a man. She had on a double veil and a wide brimmed hat. I did not know the man."

John Anderson, another neighbor of Mrs. Gunness, saw a strange woman with Mrs. Gunness the Saturday before the fire. This is the woman who, the defense contends, was murdered by Mrs. Gunness and whose body was tht adult body found in the fire ruins.

Fred R. Rickman testified he had worked for Mrs. Gunness three different times. One afternoon under her directions he dug a hole five feet deep and five feet long. Later an automobile with two men arrived.

Drank Wine Together

Mrs. Gunness was in town, but upon her instructions the witness told the men the key was under the mat. They went into the house, he said, and there was some drinking.

Before he went home one of the men gave him a glass of wine and on the way home he became unconscious and did not know anything until the next afternoon.

One of the men gave Mrs. Gunness money to pay him.

Dr. Walter F. Haines will go on the stand Monday to tell of the finding of poison in the stomachs of Andrew Helgelein and the supposed Mrs. Gunness and two of her children.

See the clipping

The judge tells the jury arson is enough

Judge Richter will tell the jury to convict Lamphere of arson if he set the fire, even if the fire killed no one. The medical expert Dr. Haines found arsenic in the stomachs from the ruins but could not say whether it entered before or after death, and the undertaker says he embalmed the bodies with an arsenical compound before the autopsies. The jury would convict on arson alone.

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · Ottumwa, Iowa

Ottumwa Tri-Weekly Courier · 26 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

COURT DEALS A BLOW TO HOPES OF LAMPHERE

JUDGE RICHTER ADVISES JURY THAT IT CAN CONVICT HIM OF ARSON IF IT IS FOUND HE FIRED GUNNESS HOME.

See moreSee less

CASE GOES TO THE JURY LATE TODAY

LAST WITNESS FOR DEFENSE, DR. HAINES, PROVED UNWILLING TO TESTIFY POISON CAUSED GUNNESS DEATHS.

Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25.—The state scored a big victory today in the Lamphere trial when Judge Richter announced that he would instruct the jury that if the evidence showed that Lamphere set fire to the Gunness house, even if the fire did not cause the death of any persons therein, the jury must find him guilty of arson. Also that if the jury finds any person in the house lost his life as the result of the fire and that Lamphere set that fire, then it must find Lamphere guilty of murder or manslaughter.

Laporte, Ind., Nov. 25. — Testimony in the trial of Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children, was closed yesterday afternoon, following expert testimony which was considered damaging to the defense. Today was taken up with arguments and instructions to the jury. It is expected the case will be in the jury's hands by evening, with the possibility of a verdict before midnight.

Dr. Walter S. Haines of Chicago yesterday testified as a medical expert. For an hour and ten minutes he occupied the witness stand, telling what he found by analysis in the stomachs of the three bodies taken from the Gunness house ruins. He also described the contents of the stomach of Andrew Helgelein.

In so far as the attorneys for the defense expected Dr. Haines to testify that arsenic and strychnine in fatal quantities were found by analysis, their expectations were fulfilled. But the expert stated frankly he did not know whether the poison was introduced into the bodies before or after death.

Unable to Tell Cause of Death.

Dr. Haines added he could not determine the cause of death by his analysis, or even tell whether the poison had been inside or outside the stomach, owing to the fact that three stomachs were in one jar, and were in advanced stages of decomposition.

In the case of Helgelein, Dr. Haines said he found both strychnine and arsenic. In his testimony he said:

"On May 27 I received three sealed jars form Laporte. One jar contained three stomachs together. Another jar contained contents of the stomachs. A third jar contained the stomach of a man named Helgelein. I analyzed for poison. Helgelein's stomach contained arsenic in abundance, and a considerable quantity of strychnine. I examined a third of the stomach, finding a little less than one-third of a grain of strychnine. If the stomach was of uniform composition I would conclude the total amount of strychnine to have been about one and a half grains. About one-third of a grain is the smallest amount that records show has caused the death of an adult.

"The stomachs in the other jar were run together to the only possible thing to do was to analyze the whole mass. I found an abundance of arsenic and concluded that the whole mass contained between one and a half and two grains— enough to cause the death of three persons."

Dr. Haines was followed by Alexander Neddo, living two miles from the Gunness place, who testified that he saw the fire at 3 o'clock on the morning of April 28.

Prosecution Uses Its Bomb.

In rebuttal the prosecution exploded its bomb against the prison theory. Austin Cutler, undertaker, testified that before the autopsies were performed on the bodies of the Gunness family he embalmed them with from ten to fifteen pounds of arsenical compound in powdered form and about two gallons of light embalming fluid, composed chiefly of formaldehyde.

As he failed to account for the presence of strychnine, the defense seized upon this point to convince the jury that a reasonable doubt of Lamphere's guilt exists.

The undertaker further testified that about 200 persons had access to the bodies before the autopsies, making it appear that opportunity existed for introducing poison in the bodies while they were lying in the morgue.

See the clipping

Guilty of arson, not of murder

After a day of deliberation the jury finds Lamphere guilty of arson only. Within five minutes he is sentenced to two to 21 years in the state prison at Michigan City, fined $5000 and disfranchised for five years. Jurors are said to have compromised, several holding out for murder; his attorney, Worden, calls the verdict ridiculous, since if guilty at all ‘he was guilty of murder’.

Lewiston Evening Teller · Lewiston, Idaho

Lewiston Evening Teller · 27 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

IS GUILTY OF ARSON

VERDICT OF JURY IN LAMPHERE CASE—GETS FROM 2 TO 21 YEARS IMPRISONMENT, $5000 FINE AND DISFRANCHISED.

See moreSee less

La Porte, Ind., Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, charged with the murder of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her three children by setting fire to the Gunness house, was found guilty of arson last night by the jury, which had deliberated since 5:30 o'clock the night before. Within five minutes after the verdict the defendant was sentenced to the state prison at Michigan City for an indeterminate term of from two to 21 years, fined $5000 and was disfranchised for five years.

Attorney Worden, for the defense, said that a motion for a new trial would be made, and should it be refused, an appeal to the Indiana supreme court would follow. The Indiana supreme court is two years behind in its work, so this case could not be reached until after he had served the minimum time of his sentence. Mr. Worden declared the verdict to be ridiculous.

"If he was guilty at all," said the attorney, "he was guilty of murder. He should have been acquitted. The motion for a new trial will be based on the judge's instructions that a jury could find Lamphere guilty of arson."

Should the case be carried to the supreme court and sent back for retrial, Lamphere could not be tried on any charge in this particular case except arson, the crime for which he was convicted. However, in an event of that kind the state would elect to try him on one of the indictments, probably the Helgelein case.

Members of the jury are reticent in discussing what occurred in the jury room, but enough has been learned to know that but for two members Lamphere would have been found guilty of murder or manslaughter, the verdict being a compromise. Several members of the jury held out for murder in the first degree, with a life sentence. So far as could be learned none was for hanging.

See the clipping

Lamphere becomes prisoner number 4140

Lamphere rides from the interurban station to the prison gate in an automobile, going to prison ‘in style’, as the paper puts it. He is entered on the register as number 4140, bathed, photographed, measured and dressed in the grey suit of the middle grade; his conduct will decide whether he moves to stripes or to blue. He would die in the Michigan City penitentiary at the end of 1909.

Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.

Arizona Republican · 28 November 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

RAY LAMPHERE GOES TO THE PEN IN STYLE He Is in a Position to Choose the Kind of Clothes HeWants. La Porte, Nov. 27.—Ray Lamphere, convicted of having set fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness, went to prison in style today. He rode from the interurban station to the prison gate in an automobile. Stepping up to the window of Chief Clerk Lorimer, the sheriff handed that official the commitment papers and the prisoner's name was entered upon the register. He was assigned number 4140 and then passed along to the receiving clerk, who escorted him to the Bertillion room.

See moreSee less

There he was given a bath, photographed, measured and garbed in a prison suit of grey, the middle grade. Upon his future conduct depends whether he will be given stripes or a better grade of blue suit.

See the clipping

An affidavit from a train in Iowa

Three weeks after the verdict, Worden, who defended Lamphere, says he has evidence that Mrs. Gunness is alive. A La Porte woman who knew her well has sworn that she rode twenty miles with her on a train in Iowa, recognized her on waking and talked with her, before the woman left the train abruptly with a man. The paper does not name the witness.

The Daily Gate City · Keokuk, Iowa

The Daily Gate City · 19 December 1908 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

IS MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE OR DEAD?

Attorney Worden Says He Has Evidence that Murder Farm Owner is Alive.

See moreSee less

LAPORTE, Dec. 19.—Attorney Worden, who defended Ray Lamphere, declared today that he had evidence that Mrs. Gunness is alive. He said that a LaPorte woman who knew Mrs. Gunness well, made an affidavit tnat she rode with her twenty miles on a train in Iowa. She said that she was sleeping in a seat across the isle and recognized her when she woke, and talked with her. She left the train abruptly with a man.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: Discovered in Several Cities at Once