In 1909 Lamphere lay dying of consumption in prison, still saying he was innocent, and the governor refused him parole. A jury awarded Helgelein’s estate $3,145 from hers. Reports about Mrs. Gunness kept coming: a sailor arrested in Norway said he had killed her, a man thought to be one of her victims was reported alive in Nebraska, and a man said he saw her on a train in Texas. Lamphere died on 30 December 1909 and made no statement about the Gunness cases.
◆
Lamphere dying of consumption in prison
Four months into his sentence, a United Press dispatch from La Porte reports that Lamphere, called Roy here, is dying of consumption in the Indiana penitentiary. He still maintains that he is innocent of the crime charged. The illness would kill him in December 1909.
The Daily Alaskan · Skagway, Alaska
The Daily Alaskan · 3 April 1909 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MURDERER IS SLOWLY DYING
(By United Press.)
See moreSee less
LA PORTE, Ind., April 3—Roy Lamphere, who was sentenced to the state penitentiary in connection with the notorious "Gunness murder farm mysteries," is dying of consumption in the Indiana penitentiary. He still maintains he is innocent of the crime charged.
A dispatch from Christiania says a young United States sailor is under arrest at Frederickstad after telling his captain that he helped Mrs. Gunness kill four people on her farm and then killed her himself. He is not named. Confessions had come before: in June 1908 a prisoner in Texas, Julius G. Truelson, Jr., swore he had been her aide, then called his story a lie.
The Newark Star and Newark Advertiser · Newark, N.J.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Newark Star and Newark Advertiser · 26 May 1909 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
SAILOR DECLARES HE KILLED MRS. GUNNESS.
CHRISTIANIA, Norway, May 26.--A young United States sailor is under arrest in Frederickstad, near Christiania, as a self-confessed murderer. He told his captain that he helped Mrs. Belle Gunness kill four persons on her farm near La Porte, Ind., and that he then killed Mrs. Gunness herself.
A Laporte circuit court jury awards $3,145 to Fred M. Pitner, administrator of the estate of Andrew Helgelein, in a suit against Wesley Gogle, executor of the will of Mrs. Gunness. The sum is the money she is alleged to have obtained from Helgelein, with 17 months’ interest. At the Lamphere trial a bank cashier had identified a photograph of Helgelein as the man who drew $2900 with her in January 1908.
The Irish Standard · Minneapolis, Minn.
The Irish Standard · 3 July 1909 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
HELGELEIN ESTATE WINS CASE.
Administrator Awarded $3,000 from Gunness Estate.
See moreSee less
La Porte, Ind., July 1.—Fred M. Pitner, administrator of the estate of Andrew Helgelein, of Aberdeen, S. D., who was lured to Laporte in January, 1908, by Mrs. Belle Gunness, was awarded $3,145 yesterday by a jury in the Laporte circuit court in a suit against Wesley Gogle, executor of the will of Mrs. Belle Gunness, this being the amount with 17 months' interest, which Mrs. Gunness is alleged to have obtained from Helgelein before she murdered him.
An Associated Press dispatch from Milwaukee passes on a report from Waukesha, Wis., that Frank X. Reidinger, believed to have been one of the victims of Mrs. Gunness, is alive at Freeport, Neb.; a letter from him arrived that day. As early as May 1908 a La Porte report had noted that relatives’ fears for several missing persons rested on circumstantial evidence.
The Pensacola Journal · Pensacola, Fla.
The Pensacola Journal · 27 August 1909 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
SUPPOSED VICTIM OF MRS. GUNNESS ALIVE.
By Associated Press.
See moreSee less
Milwaukee, Wis., Aug. 26.—It is reported from Waukesha, Wis., that Frank X. Reidinger, supposed to have been a victim of Mrs. Belle Gunness, at LaPorte, Indiana, is alive and at Freeport, Neb. A letter was received from him today.
A special from Dalhart, Texas, sent on from El Paso, says that Heinrich Fritz, formerly of La Porte, recognized Mrs. Gunness on a train bound from Fort Worth to Denver. It adds to a run of sightings on trains: in December 1908 Lamphere’s attorney had cited an affidavit from a La Porte woman who said she rode with her in Iowa.
The Roswell Daily Record · Roswell, N.M.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Roswell Daily Record · 8 October 1909 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
MRS. BELLE GUNNESS BOBS UP IN TEXAS. El Paso, Oct. 8.—A special from Dalhart, Texas, says that a man named Heinrich Fritz, formerly of La Porte, Ind., recognized Mrs. Belle Gunness on a train enroute from Ft. Worth to Denver.
Declaring that ‘the demands of justice have not yet been met’, Governor Marshall of Indiana declines to parole Ray Lamphere, imprisoned for setting fire to the Gunness home. The paper notes that Lamphere is suffering from tuberculosis in the Indiana penitentiary. He would die there at the end of December, still serving his sentence.
Batesville Guard · Batesville, Ark.
Batesville Guard · 15 October 1909 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
WILL NOT PAROLE LAMPHERE.
Declaring that the demands of justice have not yet been met, Gov. Marshall of Indiana has declined to parole Ray Lamphere, convicted of setting fire to the home of Mrs. Belle Gunness of LaPorte murder fame. Lamphere is suffering from tuberculosis in the Indiana penitentiary.
Ray Lamphere dies of tuberculosis in the Michigan City penitentiary on 30 December 1909, still serving his indeterminate term for arson. He makes no statement about the Gunness cases. The paper calls him the slayer of Mrs. Gunness and her children, though his jury had convicted him of arson only, and in April he had still said he was innocent.
The Bennington Evening Banner · Bennington, Vt.
The Bennington Evening Banner · 31 December 1909 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
RAY LAMPHERE DEAD
Slayer of Mrs. Guinness Died Without Confession
See moreSee less
Laporte, Ind., Dec. 30.—Ray Lamphere, the slayer of Mrs. Belle Gunness and her children, died tonight of tuberculosis in the Michigan City penitentiary where he was serving an indeterminate term for arson. He was attended at death by the physcian chaplain, but made no statement about the Gunness cases.