As the Papers Told It

Belle Gunness · As the Papers Told It

Act Three

Discovered in Several Cities at Once

July – August 1908

At the end of July the coroner announced that Dr. Walter Haines had found arsenic and strychnine in the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness and two of her children, and Lamphere’s lawyer said he would ask for his release or lower bail. In August she went on, as one paper put it, being discovered in several cities at the same time, and a legal expert looked ahead to a trial in which the state would first have to prove that she was dead.

Arsenic and strychnine in the bodies

Coroner Mack announces that Dr. Walter Haines of Chicago, who found poison in Andrew Helgelein’s stomach, has found arsenic and strychnine enough to kill in the stomachs of Mrs. Gunness and two of her children. Lamphere’s lawyer says this clears his client and will seek his release or lower bail. At the trial Haines could not say whether the poison went in before or after death.

The Salt Lake Tribune · Salt Lake City, Utah

The Salt Lake Tribune · 31 July 1908 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

F THAT MRS. GUNNESS BABES WERE POISONED RTE, Ind., July 30.—Coroner Mack d today that Dr. Walter Haines, Medical college, Chicago, who the stomach of Andrew Helgelein een. S. D., the last victim of le Gunness, finding strychnine ic in fatal doses, has also found machs of Mrs. Gunness and two ildren arsenic and strychnine in a sufficient to have caused death. y Worden, who represents Lam-arged with the Gunness murder being an accomplice of Mr. In the Helgelein death, declares discovery shows that his client e had nothing to do with the woman and her children.

See moreSee less

result of the finding the lawyer noon announced that he would repare papers to go before the urt and either ask for the re-amphere upon a writ of habeas ask for the reduction of bail.

See the clipping

A Colorado paper on the many sightings

A brief comment in the Glenwood Post says Mrs. Gunness ‘contiues to be discovered in several cities at the same time’ and supposes she has vanished as completely as Charley Ross and Willie Tascott. The coroner had ruled her dead in May, but reported sightings of her would go on into 1909.

The Glenwood Post · Glenwood Springs, Colo.

The Glenwood Post · 1 August 1908 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

MRS. GUNNESS contiues to be discovered in several cities at the same time. She is probably in that limbo which swallowed Charley Ross and Willie Tascott.

See the clipping

Imagining the locked room upstairs

Citing the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, a long feature uses the knives, surgical instruments and basins found in the ashes to imagine the always-locked ‘Secret Room’ upstairs as the place where bodies were dismembered. Nearly all of it is conjecture, pictured, it says, ‘from the known facts and the objects found’. One named man appears: George Anderson of Tarkio, Mo., who woke to find Mrs. Gunness standing over him.

Paper unidentified

Paper unidentified · 21 August 1908 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

The Gunness Home Veil of Mystery.

La Porte, Ind.—The veil of mystery is now being lifted from the "Secret Room" of the Gunness house. Numerous strange finds among the ashes of that grizzly dwelling, it is believed, will enable the detectives at work on the case to "reconstruct" that chamber as scientists "reconstruct" some long-extinct animal.

See moreSee less

Strange surgical instruments of known and unknown make, queer knives with razor-like edges and all sorts of peculiar articles are being found. And this has led, says the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, to the theory that the "Secret Room" was a sort of finishing department in the murder factory, the place where each "job" was polished off, as it were, and given the final touches, which consisted of the complete dismemberment of the corpse and preparation for burial of the pieces.

No phase of the Gunness establishment has been invested with such romance, eerie and wierd, as that "Secret Room." Everyone who knew of the house at all know of the perpetually closed chamber—the apartment no eyes save those of the dreadful mistress herself ever looked into. But nobody knew why the door was ever closed, why the apartment was a "Secret Room."

And that fact constitutes the value of the finds now being made. They seem to reveal, little by little, the ghastly secret, and the mental conception of that room, built up by speculation and analysis of the meaning of what has been picked up in the ashes, is a thing to cause a shudder to seize the very handiest.

The fact that a human being could deliberately murder a large number of other human beings for money was not so astonishing. That has been done before, though not on so great a scale as Mrs. Gunness conducted her business.

Astounding Degeneracy.

That which invested the whole enterprise of this somber female fiend with an atmosphere altogether unearthly was the manner in which she treated and disposed of the bodies after she had committed the murders. In that process was revealed a degeneracy, a cold cruelty, a calm disregard of everything human or divine that the minds of normal persons can hardly grasp or conceive to exist.

It was supposed from the first that the "Secret Room" had to do with this revelatin of depravity the like of which the world has never known before. But that was a suspicion only. Now, it would seem, the ashes have given up evidence in positive verification of that suspicion.

The world is full of "Secret Rooms." Perhaps some of their secrets would make the flesh creep and the hair stand on end. Perhaps in some of them are skeletons and skulls, whose hollow eyes have looked upon things too dreadful to tell.

There are "Secret Rooms" in every city, rooms a knowledge of which might send men or women, now highly respected, to the penitentiary for life, or maybe, to the gallows. But all "Secret Rooms" do not conceal crimes. Some have merely scandals and those heartaches we call family "skeletons in the closet."

But the "Secret Room of the Gunness house hid things the like of which no other chamber of the kind ever knew. It was steeped in horror, dyed in blood and chilled by cruelty. Ghosts dwelt in that apartment, a throng of them, but the iron key, that moved so noiselessly in the ever well-oiled lock, held them fast, prisoners forever until the fingers of the flames unlocked the door for good and all and set them free, to roam up and down the country, wailing their accusations against the woman who had presided over the grizzliest charnal chamber in all history.

And that room, with its blood stains, its uncanny, aparatus, its ghastly trappings, its gilbbering ghosts, the mind is now able to build up again in mental picture by means of things found in the ashes, unconsumed by the fierce blaze which came so near covering the exit of Mrs. Gunness with a veil that might never have been lifted.

A remarkable and significant fact concerning all bodies unearthed at the Gunness farm was this, that they had been cut in pieces by someone skilled in the work of dissection and possessing a profound knowledge of human anatomy. The dismemberment of those corpses showed beyond all doubt that they had been operated upon by one whose hand had long had been accustomed to cutting up human flesh.

Skillful Surgery Shown.

The joints were severed with a dexterity that would have done credit to a surgeon. Each bone was taken from its socket with nicety and precision. Nobody could have done such skillful work without the possession of the finest instruments.

And there must have been some place where this work was done. It was not performed in the living rooms, neither in the barns nor outbuildings. It must have been performed in the "secret room" and the "secret room" must have been admirably equipped for the work.

Mrs. Gunness, it is believed, was thoroughly informed upon the subject of surgical asepsis. She was too close a student of anatomy and pathology to take any chances of infection. Therefore, the "secret room" contained, it is believed, apparatus for perfect sterilization.

In short, the chamber had the appearance, to a great extent, of an operating room. The instruments are thought to have been arranged in an orderly manner, with the sterilizing tank close by. They shone with the radiance of highly polished steel and presented the immaculate appearance of an instrument case in a surgeon's office. Probably, also, there were vials of disinfectant for use in cleansing the hands of the dextrous dissector. And perhaps, for this purpose, the metallic wash basins found in the ruins stood about the room.

Any surgeon would recognize at once that, unless the most modern antiseptic was at hand the terrible frequency with which cadavers were cut up in that secret chamber would have been attended by disease. Mrs. Gunness, so shrewd in all things else, is believed to have furinshed, is believed to have forestalled, by cleanliness and care, any such catastrophe.

The surgical instruments found in the ashes enable us to comprehend one phase of the appearance of the "secret room," namely? its likeness to an operating room. This resemblance is thought to have been carried to the extent of an operating table upon which the bodies rested while subjected to the sharp tools of the archmurderess. However, no traces of such an object has been found in the ruins, and quite naturally, for it probably was consumed by the fire.

And then, having pictured that phase of the room, it is easy to conjure up in the mind a picture of Mrs. Gunness at work in the chamber of mystery. She was a big, broad-shouldered, muscular woman, who dressed plainly. When in the "operating room" it is believed she wore a surgeon's apron to protect her clothing.

Downstairs in the basement was the "ice-box." After the body which she desired to dismember had been placed on the table, she went to work. Nobody saw her unlocking the instrument case, taking therefrom the cruel-looking knives and saws, and, after stripping the corpse, beginning her work.

Then she mush have been in her element. She is thought to have reveled in adding more greenbacks to the fat role of thousands she wore in her belt. But these joys were nothing, it is believed, to the delight she took in cutting up a body.

She Reveled in Death.

There is not other explanation of her mistreatment of the corpses of those she killed. There was no apparent purpose to be served. It was simply the fiend gorging herself with the greatest and most exquisite joy her distorted soul was capable of feeling.

After she had finished her work, the remnants were placed in a sack and carried, with the lamp that had lighted her work, for burial in the barnyard, after wich she retired for her morning nap.

But there were other things in the "secret room" besides the surgical instruments and paraphernalia of the operating room. There were, it is thought, wardrobes and chests wherein were kept the raiment stripped from the bodies of the murdered men. Perhaps the clothes were folded nicely, arranged in piles, each pile belonging to one individual. She knew them without labeling them, for though her victims had been numerous, she had a marvelous facility for carrying great masses of information relative to details in her head.

The clothes presses and the surgical apparatus, with some simple furniture, such as stout chairs and the like, evidently completed the furnishings of the "secret room."

Servants Were Terrorized.

Such, then, as near as can be pictured from the known facts and the objects found, was the celebrated "secret room, that ever-locked, ever-silent chamber, which none dared to go near, which even the servants in the house had not courage to approach, much less to try the door to see if it were locked. But this was not because anybody suspected the uses for which the apartment was reserved. It was because the uncanny terror inspired by Mrs. Gunness in the hearts of all who approached her, whenever it suited her purpose to inspire such terror.

But there were other secret rooms in that house. There was the "ice box." That was a small apartment in the basement, which, like the "secret room" on the second floor, was perpetually closed and locked. It is generally believed, by those who have given the closest study to the Gunness case, that the basement chamber was exactly what its name indicated—an ice box.

It is conceded that there the bodies were kept, preserved by refrigeration, until the time arrived when it suited the murderess to indulge her fancy for dissection. After the dissection had been accomplished the bodies were placed in "ice box" until buried.

One More Secret Room.

But there was one more secret room—a secret room that, with the great "secret room" and the "ice box" constituted a trinity of chambers of unearthly mystery.

This third place of secrecy was the room occupied by the men who came awooing Mrs. Gunness. It was the scene of the murders, the grewsome stage upon which the grim finale of each tragedy was enacted.

In appearance it was like the other sleeping rooms. The door was not kept locked, and many persons who knew the house have seen the interior of that room. By daylight it was apparently an open book, but in the night, veiled by darkness, it became a secret room. It was here that George Anderson, of Tarkio, Mo., woke up and saw Mrs. Gunness standing over him.

Possibly there were all sorts of hiding places in that chamber where Mrs. Gunness could conceal herself if about to be detected, or where she could wait, with her hard, cold eyes fixed on the doomed guest, until the propitious moment arrived. And thus it came about that that chamber, too, had blood-curdling things to tell, could the dumb, inanimate objects with which it was furnished have put into speech what they had witnessed.

It is possible that, forever and forever, there will be mysteries connected with the Gunness house that none ever can unravel. But this much is certain: little by little study and search, in view of the coming trial, are revealing the mysteries of the three secret chambers in the House of Death. And, perhaps, the day may come when a description of these three apartments may be made as accurately as though one actually had looked into each one of them at the most interesting moments and made careful note of all that was to be seen.

There have been many secret rooms in history. There is the fabled "Bluebeard's chamber," where were the headless bodies of many wives. And recently students have come to the conclusion that the story of Bluebeard is no mere bit of folklore, but the legendary history of a person who actually exist.

There is a famous chamber in an English castle that had not been unlocked for centuries until quite recently. When it was thrown open the skeleton of a monk, in his monastic robes, was found seated at a table. It is thought he fled to that apartment some time during the Puritan uprising and starved to death.

But, gloomy and terrible and mysterious as have been the secret rooms of legend and history—gloomy and terrible and mysterious as are the secret rooms that exist today—it is now believed there never have been any chambers of secrecy and mystery comparable to the three rooms in the house of the great archmurderess.

See the clipping

A legal expert weighs Lamphere’s chances

Ahead of the trial, an unnamed legal expert says the state must first prove Mrs. Gunness is dead, and sets out each side’s case: the dentist and the rings against Lizzie Smith’s alibi, the missing head and the poison in the bodies. He predicts doubt will remain even if Lamphere is convicted. In November the jury found him guilty only of arson, in what was reported as a compromise verdict.

The Washington Herald · Washington, D.C.

The Washington Herald · 23 August 1908 · page 27 · transcribed from the page image

NOTED TRIAL NEAR

Lamphere to Answer for the Death of Mrs. Gunness.

See moreSee less

CRITICAL ANALYSIS GIVEN

Evidence For and Against the Only Prisoner in the Great Laporte Mystery Is Gone Over—Can They Prove that the Woman Is Dead? Otherwise Case May Be Dropped.

By LEGAL EXPERT.

Is the greatest murder mystery of modern times to be cleared up at the coming trial of Ray Lamphere? Or will his trial leave the disappearance of Mrs. Gunness still more of an enigma than it has been ever since that gray dawn last April, when her house went up in smoke?

Is there sufficient evidence to convince twelve unprejudiced jurors that Mrs. Gunness is dead and that Lamphere killed her, or will the evidence submitted by the State's prosecutor simply becloud the minds of the jury and the public and leave the vanishment of the woman slayer a more inexplicable puzzle than it is now?

There are seven indictments against Lamphere. Four of these charge him with the murder of Mrs. Gunness and her three children. One charges him with the murder of Andrew Helgelein, one charges that he was an accessory with Mrs. Gunness in the murder of Helgelein, and the seventh charges him with arson in the burning of the Gunness home.

But an indictment is not an evidence of guilt. The law expressly says so. Indictments are often returned on the merest suspicion of guilt, and often simply as a means to hold a prisoner in the hope that more evidence against him may be obtained.

The jury which goes into the box to try Ray Lamphere for his life will be instructed by the court that the indictment is no evidence of guilt and that he is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty beyond a reasonable doubt, and that this presumption of innocence accompanies the accused throughout the trial or until it is removed by evidence of guilt which the jurors cannot in reason doubt.

Gunness Case First.

The prosecution will undoubtedly elect to try Lamphere first upon the indictment charging him with the murder of Mrs. Gunness, for unless he can be convicted of that he cannot be convicted of any of the other six alleged crimes.

The prosecution must first prove what is known in law as the "corpus delicti," which means "the body, substance, or foundation of the offense," which in this case is the dead body of Mrs. Gunness.

Before the case against Lamphere can have any standing in court the prosecution must first prove that Mrs. Gunness is dead, and it must establish this fact beyond a doubt. If the prosecution should fail to prove this the defense would, at the end of the State's case, file a demurrer asking that the case be thrown out of court and the prisoner discharged for want of proof of the "corpus delicti."

The State undoubtedly has enough evidence of the death of Mrs. Gunness to warrant the judge in allowing the case to go to the jury. It will introduce Dr. J. S. Norton, the dentist who put the gold bridgework in the mouth of Mrs. Gunness, and he will testify that the bridge work found near the body in the cellar is the same. The rings found upon the hand of the dead woman will be introduced in evidence, and the State will try to prove that they were hers by the engraved initials "P. S. to J. S." and "P. G. to J. S." She went once by the name of Jennie Sorensen.

Must Show Motive.

Before it can prove its case the State must also show that Lamphere had a motive for the death of Mrs. Gunness.

The State will try to prove that he was very jealous of her and that she had discarded him and that he thought she kept a large sum of money in her home and wished to rob her. But the strangest theory of the State will be that Lamphere assisted her in the murder of Helgelein; that he knew this death was to be investigated, he knew the body would be found buried on the murder farm, and that he would be jointly accused with Mrs. Gunness for the crime, and that if he killed her and her children and burned the house he would stop the investigation.

The State will attempt to prove that he said he would burn her house to "get even with her," that he came to town the night before without good reason, and that he followed Mrs. Gunness into a grocery when she bought coal oil, and that he knew where she kept the oil on a porch where he could reach it easily.

The State will attempt to prove that Lamphere might have slept at the home of Lizzie Smith, and yet have time to get to the Gunness house and kill them and get away. It will attempt to show that he was near the Gunness home soon after the fire burst forth, and that he did not keep to the road in going away, but cut across fields, and that he ran part of the way, going ten miles without breakfast, a suspicious circumstance in itself.

The State will show that Mrs. Gunness loved her children, and will argue the improbability of her murdering them and of committing suicide simply to escape prosecution for murder.

Turn of Defense.

Then will come the turn of the defense. It will first dispute the death of Mrs. Gunness, introducing numerous witnesses who knew her well and who viewed the dead body of the woman found in the ruins, and who will testify that the dead body was much smaller in every way.

It may admit that while the rings and the gold bridgework might have been hers, she might have placed the body of another woman there to deceive the public, and, in that case, she would naturally have put the rings on its finger, and she might easily have taken the bridgework from her mouth and placed it there, too. The fact that the head of the woman's body was gone will be strong evidence for the defense in casting doubt upon the identify of the body.

The defense will show her motive for disappearing either by suicide or by substituting a body for hers and then escaping in the darkness. It will prove that the day before her death she received a letter from Helgelein saying he was coming to investigate the disappearance of his brother. She had murdered that brother. His body was buried in her dooryard, and she knew discovery was at hand.

If she fled, she could not take three children with her; that meant detection, and they knew something of her crimes and might be strong witnesses against her. Her love for them would not keep her from killing them She loved Jennie Olsen with equal fervor, and she did not hesitate to kill her when the girl showed that she knew too much about murders in the Gunness house.

The defense will show that the day before the murders Mrs. Gunness made her will, leaving her real estate to charity, evidence that she intended to kill her children. It will prove that she told that she feared Lamphere would kill her, thus preparing the way for suspicion to be directed against him when the bodies were found, and making it easier for her to escape. That she bought an unusually large amount of coal oil the day before her house burned will also be proven.

The alibi testimony of Lizzie Smith, that Lamphere slept in her house until 4:30 o'clock the morning of the murders, and that the Gunness house was seen afire about 3 o'clock, will be strong evidence for Lamphere. Other evidence in his favor will be that of Joseph Maxon, the hired man who slept in an annex of the Gunness home. He will swear that the dog did not bark that morning, and that it would have barked if Lamphere had come there.

But the strongest evidence for Lamphere, enough in itself to create grave doubts of his guilt in the minds of any man, is that poison has now been found in the stomachs of the four bodies. It is admitted even by the prosecution that if Lamphere fired the house, he must have done it quickly. He could have had only a few minutes at the house.

Up to the Jury.

It will be hard to make the jury believe that he went in the house and administered poison to four persons, especially when Mrs. Gunness was suspicious of him.

And the bodies were found on the cellar floor without debris beneath them. The sleeping rooms were on the second floor. If they died there, the debris of two floors would have been beneath them. The bodies must have been carried to the cellar after death, and the defense will argue this as positive proof of Lamphere's innocence.

The defense will admit that Lamphere was near the Gunness home while the house was burning. He had to pass it on his way to the farm where he worked, and when he saw the flames, he knew at once that he would be suspected, because Mrs. Gunness had told that she feared he would kill her and burn the house. So he ran part of the way to the farm where he worked, and there he awaited the officers who came later in the day to arrest him.

Having shown these things, the defense will ask the jury to acquit Lamphere, and it will ask that the other six indictments be quashed.

And if he is acquitted the mystery of the disappearance of Mrs. Gunness, the arch-murderess of modern times, will be as inscrutable as ever. And even if he is convicted, the doubt of his guilt will yet remain strong in the minds of many who have followed the remarkable case closely.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Two: Mrs. Gunness Is Dead