In 1886 a dealer who had sold thousands told a reporter that a wild pigeon could not be bought in the city. Some writers thought the flocks had only moved west. A woman who had grown up on Lake Otsego remembered a morning in 1847 when a flock lost in the mist settled on the village lawns. In 1897 the Smithsonian announced that a liberal reward had not brought it a single live specimen, and that the species was extinct; a Wisconsin paper put the blame on the market hunters and the trap-shooters. Flocks were still reported, in California, in Wisconsin, and none was ever confirmed.
◆
Gone from the market, like the buffalo
A Bottineau paper reprints the New York Times: a dealer who once handled many thousands of wild pigeons says not one could be bought in the city yesterday. A few barrels a year now come, chiefly from the Indian Territory, and Chicago pays $1.50 to $2 a dozen for birds from the Northwest. Before the war one dealer often sold 1,000 dozen at retail in a day. The chief cause, the Times says, is ‘the destruction of forests.’
The Bottineau Pioneer · Bottineau, N.D. · and 1 other paper
The Bottineau Pioneer · 25 November 1886 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Wild Pigeons Exterminated.
The wild pigeon is disappearing from North America, like the Buffalo, before the march of civilization. A dealer who has in years past bought and sold many thousands of these delicate birds, told a Times' reporter that a wild pigeon could not be bought in the city yesterday.
See moreSee less
The supply has been decreasing yearly during the past years, until now we get but a few barrels a year, which are received chiefly from the Indian Territory. It costs less to transport them from there than from the far Northwest, which is now the favorite nesting place for them. Chicago gets a small supply of the birds netted or shot in Minnesota or elsewhere in the Northwest, the prices paid being usually $1.50 to $2 a dozen, and St. Louis and other Western cities get a few, for which about the same rates are paid. Lovers of this game in this city have nearly ceased to ask for wild pigeons in the market, having been so often disappointed in not finding the birds they seek. There is consequently no vigorous effort made by game dealers to procure them, the profits upon their sale being small.
Within the memory of many middle-aged persons hereabouts, hundreds of thousands of these birds have been seen flying in great flocks over the large cities of the Atlantic states, appearing like black clouds against the sky. When these great flocks roost in the woods their weight was so great as to break down the limbs of the trees. It is while these flocks are roosting that the birds become the easy prey of the pigeon hunter, either by net, shotgun or in other ways. The professional pigeon hunter in the west, although his victims are easily killed, leads a rough life in hunting birds, and is poorly remunerated for his labor and the hardships he is forced to undergo.
A large game dealer said that before the war and when the birds were plenty he had frequently sold as many as 1,000 dozen pigeons at retail in one day. They were then quite cheap and within the reach of poor people. The chief cause of the thinning out of wild pigeons is the destruction of forests in all parts of the country. The pigeons are thus deprived of their nesting places, and of their favorite beechnuts and the food they get from the oak and other trees that were once so plenty near here.—New York Times.
A Kansas paper reprints Forest and Stream, which doubts the widespread opinion that the wild pigeon has disappeared from the continent. Scattered flocks may still live in the Far West, it suggests, moving their nesting grounds with the mast they feed on, and nothing has happened that would explain an extinction. Still, it grants, the bird has not stemmed ‘the current of settlement and civilization.’
Thomas County Cat · Colby, Kan. · and 1 other paper
Thomas County Cat · 20 September 1888 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
Fate of the Wild Pigeon. The fate of the wild pigeon is under discussion, and a very widespread opinion appears to prevail that because these birds are not seen in many sections where they abounded they have disappeared from this continent. It is probable that this hypothesis can be proved an unsound one, and the wild pigeon may still be found in scattered flocks in the Far West, their flight and nestling grounds changing with the fluctuations of the mast supply on which they depend for food. Such flocks have been reported within a few years, and since that time there has been no event which might be accepted as an adequate explanation of their extinction.
See moreSee less
The fact remains that the wild pigeon has not held its own, nor stemmed the current of settlement and civilization which has swept it from the great areas where its hosts once darkened the heavens. - Forest and Stream.
W. Brewster, the New York Sun reports, finds the great flights now confined to the wilds of British North America; the Michigan flight of 1888 vanished across the Straits of Mackinac, to the netters’ distress. An observer at Cadillac recalls the 1876-7 nesting running about twenty-eight miles from Petoskey to Crooked Lake, and puts the netters of 1881 at 500 men averaging 20,000 birds each.
The Mason County Journal · Shelton, W.T. · and 2 other papers
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 58 days later.
Wrong
The Mason County Journal · 18 April 1890 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
FLIGHTS OF PIGEONS.
At the Present Time They Occur Only in British Columbia.
See moreSee less
It is not so many years since that flights of wild pigeons occurred during the autumn over the Eastern and Middle States. The younger generation of sportsmen, however, has probably never seen a living specimen of that bird, its acquaintance with it being entirely confined to the plucked specimens on the stands of dealers in the market. Mr. W. Brewster, who has made a thorough and exhaustive study of the causes of the disappearance of the wild pigeon from its former haunts, has established the fact that its flight in a vast body is now entirely confined to the great uninhabited wilds of British North America. Mr. Brewster, in the course of his investigations, followed the route of the flight which occurred in the southern peninsula of Michigan in the spring of 1888. The main body of birds disappeared across the Straits of Mackinac, much to the distress of the netters, who were making preparations for an old-time harvest. At Cardillac Mr. Brewster learned from Mr. S. S. Stevens, an experienced observer, that in 1888, near there, the pigeons appeared in a considerable number; but that not more than a few hundred were seen in one body. In speaking of the great nesting of 1876-7 Mr. Stevens said that it began near Potosky and extended to Crooked Lake, for about twenty-eight miles, averaging three or four miles wide. The birds arrived in two separate bodies, one directly from the south by land, the other following the east coast of Wisconsin and crossing at Manitou island. The latter body came in from the lake at about three o'clock in the afternoon. It was a compact mass of pigeons at least five miles long by one mile wide. In the nesting season of 1881 Mr. Stevens estimates that 500 men were engaged in netting pigeons, and that they secured on an average 20,000 birds each during the season.
What has contributed more than anything else to the annihilation of the wild pigeon is the reckless netting of that bird. Mr. John Mortimer Murphy, in describing the taking of pigeons in nets, speaks of them as seines which are so rigged that upon being sprung they fall upon the birds which at the moment may be upon the ground. There are two methods by which the pigeons are decoyed; the one by baiting, whereby a single pigeon, attracted by the food scattered about, calls a great number of his fellows, upon whom, when collected in sufficient number, the net is sprung. It is not an uncommon thing to trap from two to three hundred pigeons at every cast, and as the casts are numerous, the number taken throughout the day is very large. Another method consists in trapping the pigeons as they fly over the net. This requires the use of decoy birds, whose eyes are sewn up, and a light weight attached to their legs to prevent them from flying away. These are thrown into the air when a flock is passing by to attract its attention, while trained decoys—that is, pigeons trained to act as if alighting—are worked industriously at the same time. If these bring down the flight, the net is sprung and fastened at the four corners. The captives are taken out and disposed of according to the purpose of the netters. Some are kept alive in coops, while others are killed and packed immediately for market. From 500 to 1,000 men were sometimes engaged at one time in netting, and each averaged 1,000 birds a day. This account applies to a period when flights of pigeons were large and numerous all throughout the Middle and Western States. As stated above, the last occasion when nets were profitably employed was at the great nesting in 1876-7 in the Northwest.—N. Y. Sun.
Susan Fenimore Cooper, writing in Harper’s, remembers the morning of June 8, 1847, when a flock bewildered by fog dropped into the village, on lawns, in the churchyard and on the street elms, until the mist rose. In 1849 several thousand nested in a wood in the Susquehanna valley. Ask about wild pigeons there now, she writes, and the answer is ‘None that we have seen or heard of lately.’
The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · Thibodaux, La. · and 1 other paper
The Weekly Thibodaux Sentinel and Journal of the 8th Senatorial District · 7 October 1893 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image
VANISHING WOOD-PIGEONS. The Gradual Disappearance of Birds Which Were Once Very Numerous.
Very remarkable has been the history of the native wild-pigeon, a bird entirely peculiar to North America, from the gulf of Mexico to Hudson bay. Its history is not only very interesting, but quite wonderful in some of its details. The bird itself, taken singly, as we rustics know, is elegant in form, and very pleasing in its slate-colored plumage, tinged with a pale shading of red on the breast. It is very gentle and peaceable, entirely harmless, and even timid by nature. Who would have thought it possible that gentle birds like these should have swept over the interior of the continent within a century in flocks so vast as to obscure the sun at noon as though the country lay under an eclipse, while the ceaseless rapid motion of millions of wings produced a loud roar like an approaching tornado? Accurate and experienced men of science—Wilson and Audubon—tell us of vast flocks covering one hundred and eighty square miles of country in Kentucky as recently as 1813. They tell us of vast breeding-places in western forests many miles in extent, where ninety nests were counted in one tree. They tell us of roosting-grounds forty miles in length, with a breadth of several miles, the up-roar from this roosting-ground being heard at a distance of three miles. They tell us of one column of these birds in flight covering two hundred and forty miles of country in length!
See moreSee less
Grand indeed must have been the movement over the continent of that vast living-winged cloud, a marvel of nature. Nothing to equal it has been known elsewhere on earth.
The old pines on the hill-tops about the Otsego water some forty years since must have been frequently overshadowed by flocks of the wild-pigeon, much less wonderful than those farther west, but still remarkable in their numbers.
On the early morning of June 8, 1847, the lake and the village lay shrouded in a summer mist. A large flock of wild pigeons became bewildered in the fog, and lost their way—an unusual incident in their history. Instinct failed to guide them. Their naturally keen sight could not pierce the mist. They dropped on the nearest trees, in the heart of the village, on our own lawn, in the church-yard, in the gardens, and on the elms and maples shading the streets. With the first rays of the sun appearing above Mount Vision the mist rose, the birds took flight.
In the early spring of 1849 a large flock of pigeons, supposed to number several thousands, selected for their breeding-ground a wood in the valley of the Susquehanna some miles to the southward of the lake. The details were similar to those reported of the vast breeding-places at the west—nests carelessly built of twigs, a number in close neighborhood in the same tree; broken limbs of trees; a low murmur of wings. But the ground occupied was a narrow one.
Since those years no large flocks of wild pigeons have passed over Lake Otsego. A few only have been seen where formerly they were numbered by the hundred. To-day you inquire if any wild pigeons have been recently found in these woods. "None that we have seen or heard of lately," shall be the answer to your inquiry. What a change within forty years! Alas for the vanished wild pigeon!—Susan Fenimore Cooper, in Harper's Magazine.
A Mississippi paper reports a flock of wild pigeons ‘so numerous as to recall the hunting stories’ of days thought gone for good, settled in a grove in Shasta County, California. Out foraging, the birds are said to form a line a mile long, their wings sounding like a furious storm; at night they seem to cover every bough over about 160 acres of black oak forest.
The Free Press · Poplarville, Miss. · and 1 other paper
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 37 days later.
Wrong
The Free Press · 17 June 1897 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
A flock of wild pigeons so numerous as to recall the hunting stories of days that were supposed to have passed forever has taken possession of a grove in Shasta county, Cal. When the birds are on their foraging expeditions they are said to form a line a mile in length and from 100 to 200 yards wide, while the sound of their wings is like that of a furious storm. At night they gather in a black oak forest, where, over an area of about 160 acres, they seem to cover every twig and bough.
A Potosi, Missouri, paper reports that the Smithsonian has tried in vain to get a living specimen of the wild pigeon, once found ‘in countless millions,’ and after a reward offer and much correspondence has concluded it is extinct. The seals, it warns, are going as fast: this year’s North Pacific catch is little more than half of last season’s, and three or four years more will finish them unless the slaughter is stopped or regulated.
Potosi Journal · 8 December 1897 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image
The rapidity with which a wild animal may be exterminated can be judged from the fact that the Smithsonian institution has recently tried in vain to obtain a living specimen of the wild, or passenger, pigeon which was formerly found in this country in countless millions. After the offer of a liberal reward and much correspondence it has been concluded that the American wild pigeon is extinct. The seals are going just as fast. This year's catch in the North Pacific is little more than half that of last season. Three or four years more will wipe out the seals unless their slaughter is stopped or regulated.
The Kansas City Star, copied in Topeka, says the wild pigeon no longer comes to southwest Missouri with the mast. In a roost ‘no skill was required to shoot pigeons’: a shotgun fired at random into any tree brought down game, and hogs fattened on the crippled birds. The last roost of any importance near Springfield, by Hopewell church south of the James river, was about twenty-four years ago.
The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · and 3 other papers
The American Citizen · 28 January 1898 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Deserted by Wild Pigeons. From the Kansas City Star: The wild pigeon no longer visits southwest Missouri, with the return of the mast season, as formerly. Years ago the woods of the Ozark region were full of these birds from October to January. A pigeon roost was the wonder and delight of the pioneer hunter. Millions of the birds would gather in some thick forest at the approach of night. From all directions and for miles away dense flocks of pigeons could be seen flying toward the roost. The unerring instinct of the birds guided them to the place, and by sundown the flutter of countless wings sounded like an approaching storm in the vicinity of the roosts.
See moreSee less
Hunters killed the birds by the thousands, for in a roost no skill was required to shoot pigeons. A shotgun fired into any tree or bush at random never failed to bring down game. The ground was over nearly covered with dead and wounded birds after a volley ha[d] been fired into a tree loaded [d]own with pigeons. Hogs fattened on the crippled birds left in the woods and hawks, owls, foxes and other wild animals had a continual feast. The last pigeon roost of any importance near Springfield was not far from Hop[ewell] church, south of the James river, about twenty-four years ago. The birds occupied several acres, and remained three or four weeks.
Asked why the once abundant pigeon has vanished, a Dakota paper, quoting the Wisconsin Agriculturist, answers: wholesale butchery at the nesting grounds, old birds and squabs alike, shipped to the cities by market hunters. The trap-shooters who bought the live birds were ‘accessories,’ it says, though the market hunter’s greed was mainly to blame.
The Black Hills Union · Rapid City, S.D. · and 4 other papers
The Black Hills Union · 13 January 1899 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image
Where Are the Wild Pigeons. In response to an inquiry as to the cause of the disappearance of the once abundant wild pigeon, the information is here given that the wholesale butchery of these birds resulted in almost exterminating the species, says Wisconsin Agriculturalist. The market hunters followed the birds to their nesting grounds, where countless thousands of wild pigeons congregated to breed, and a merciless slaughter was indulged in, year after year, until few of the species remain. The larger portion of the pigeons (old birds and young squabs, indiscriminately) were killed on the roosting grounds, and shipped to the larger cities.
See moreSee less
A smaller percentage was netted or trapped and sent alive in crates to sportsmen's clubs and associations for trap-shooting purposes. The trap-shooting sportsmen of America are therefore "accessories" in the nefarious work of destroying the wild pigeons of the country, though the greed of the market hunter is mainly responsible for "the deep damnation of their taking off."
People near Reedsburg, Wisconsin, say a stream of pigeons passed so long that the first were out of sight before the last went by, and old settlers vouch for them. The birds have been thought extinct for fourteen years, and collectors cannot get one at any price. Nobody shot one to prove it; the paper’s joke is that the game law forbade it.
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · and 2 other papers
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.
Wrong
Iowa County Democrat · 11 May 1899 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Wild Pigeons Come Again.
People of Lime Ridge, near Reedsburg, declare that a fortnight ago they saw a flock of pigeons go by—not a few, but a great cloud of them, a stream so long that the first of them were out of sight before the rear of the procession had passed. Old settlers saw the wonderful sight, and no one questions but that they know the American passenger pigeon when they see it. Why it is that no one shot at least one of them—but we forgot the game law!
See moreSee less
For fourteen years these birds have been supposed to be extinct. Older people have caused children to marvel by tales of the pigeons hiding the sun, so great was the number. Even collectors, willing to pay any price, have not been able to get a bird to stuff. They were killed spring and fall in great numbers, for they were good eating and easy mark. As it says in Genesis, "The dove found no rest for the sole of her foot."
There were theories that the birds had chanced to be together when a storm swept them out to sea and to death; and some other wise fellow had an idea that an infectious disease got among them. But, whatever the cause, it was certainly remarkable, for the disappearance was sudden. A writer in the Reedsburg Free Press says he saw three at Camp Douglas eight years ago this spring—a male and two females—and refrained from shooting them, though they could probably all have been killed at one shot, as they perched on the limb of a tree, billing and cooing in their loving way. Others have reported seeing small numbers around Reedsburg in later years, and it is hoped they may return:
The American Museum Journal reports that twelve wild pigeons just added to the museum’s collections were secured ‘only with much difficulty.’ Within fifty years one of the most abundant native birds, the species is now ‘practically unobtainable.’
The Hood River Glacier · Hood River, Or. · and 3 other papers
The Hood River Glacier · 18 April 1902 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
The American Museum Journal reports that the twelve specimens of wild pigeons recently added to the collections of the museum were secured only with much difficulty, because of the surprising fact that this species of our native birds, which within the past fifty years has been one of the most abundant, is now so rare, not only in a state of nature, but also in collections, that it is practically unobtainable.
A Rhode Island paper reprints the New York Post’s history of the passenger pigeon: Wilson’s flock of 1808, four hours passing, and Audubon’s schooners at New York loaded with pigeons in bulk at a cent apiece. After 1860, it says, came the slaughter, by gun, pole, club, net and sulphur pot, and at the last known large nesting, in 1878, ‘a billion birds were killed during the season.’
The Olneyville Times · Olneyville Providence, R.I.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 9 days later.
Wrong
The Olneyville Times · 15 May 1903 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
TRAGEDY OF ANIMAL LIFE.
Something Pathetic In the Career of the Passenger Pigeon.
See moreSee less
To him who knows the story of the passenger pigeon this group of beautiful, grayish brown birds with the iridescent golden sheen upon their throats is the last word of a tragedy of animal life. America was once the land of the wild pigeon. Early American writers are full of references to it. Alexander Wilson, the father of American ornithology, estimated that a flock seen by him in 1808 contained over 2,000,000 individuals. It stretched from the horizon to the horizon, as far as the eye could see, and was over four hours in passing a given point. He saw a nesting colony forty miles long and several miles in width.
In 1805 Audubon saw schooners at the wharfs in New York loaded not in packages, but in bulk, with wild pigeons caught up the Hudson river and sold for a cent apiece. Up to 1860 the bird continued fairly abundant. Then a frightful slaughter began to supply an increased food demand. Gun, pole, club, net and sulphur pot were employed. Thirty dozen birds were captured at one spring of the net. One man netted 500 dozen in one day. In the nesting season trees were shaken or felled and wagon loads of squab taken nightly, droves of hogs being turned in to utilize what the "hunters" had left. Wherever the distracted flocks appeared the slaughter began. At the last known large pigeon "nesting," in 1878, a billion birds were killed during the season. Like the bison, it was effectually exterminated, showing the terrible efficiency of man when he sets out systematically in pursuit of a lower species.—New York Post.