A dispatch from Reedsburg, Wisconsin describes a massive flock of birds flying north, identified as genuine American Passenger Pigeons, a species believed extinct for nearly 20 years. The sighting caused great excitement among local residents.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 17 days later.
Wrong
Decorah-Posten · 9 May 1899 · page 1
Wisconyhin. En stor Flok Bandredner Befolkningen i Lime Ridge var for nylig Vidne til et Syn, som ikke har været seet der paa 20 Aar, berettes fra Reedsburg. Det var en Flok Duer, som drog mod Nord i en Strimmel saa lang, at den første af Flokken var ude af Syne, endnu før den sidste var passeret forbi. Det maa have været en Flok af de ægte »American Passenger Pigeons» (Vandreduer), og deres Tilsynekomst har vakt stor Interesse blandt Befolk ningen. I næsten 20 Aar har denne Dueart været anseet som uddøet.
A newspaper reports excitement near Lime Ridge, Wisconsin, after a reputed mile-long flock of passenger pigeons was seen flying north, the first sighting in twenty years. The article recounts past theories for their disappearance (mass slaughter, disease, migration to the seashore) and speculates they may have migrated to South America, expressing hope they can be protected and become numerous again.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 14 days later.
Wrong
The Sun · 10 May 1899 · page 6
An Ornithological Mystery
An Ornlthologlcnl Mvsterv. Yom (Ae .Vinntapolif Tribune. BKKnsnuno. Wis , May fi. There was general excitement at Lime llldgo recontly when a flock of American passenger pigeons passed north ovor that place, tho flock being n mil long and so denso as to nearly obscure tho sun, Their appearance has created interest, ns these birds havo not been seen for twenty years and even specimen hunters could not secure a single bird. They formerly roostnd nonr Lime Bidge, and camo every summer by millions in nest and broed. The people made pigeon bunting ono of the principal sourcos of rev
Iowa County Democrat · Mineral Point, Wis. · and 2 other papers
Residents near Lime Ridge, Wisconsin report seeing a massive flock of passenger pigeons passing overhead, a species believed extinct for fourteen years. The article recalls past theories for the birds' disappearance—storms at sea or disease—and notes scattered earlier sightings, expressing hope the species may be returning.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 13 days later.
Wrong
Iowa County Democrat · 11 May 1899 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image
Wild Pigeons Come Again.
People of Lime Ridge, near Reedsburg, declare that a fortnight ago they saw a flock of pigeons go by—not a few, but a great cloud of them, a stream so long that the first of them were out of sight before the rear of the procession had passed. Old settlers saw the wonderful sight, and no one questions but that they know the American passenger pigeon when they see it. Why it is that no one shot at least one of them—but we forgot the game law!
See moreSee less
For fourteen years these birds have been supposed to be extinct. Older people have caused children to marvel by tales of the pigeons hiding the sun, so great was the number. Even collectors, willing to pay any price, have not been able to get a bird to stuff. They were killed spring and fall in great numbers, for they were good eating and easy mark. As it says in Genesis, "The dove found no rest for the sole of her foot."
There were theories that the birds had chanced to be together when a storm swept them out to sea and to death; and some other wise fellow had an idea that an infectious disease got among them. But, whatever the cause, it was certainly remarkable, for the disappearance was sudden. A writer in the Reedsburg Free Press says he saw three at Camp Douglas eight years ago this spring—a male and two females—and refrained from shooting them, though they could probably all have been killed at one shot, as they perched on the limb of a tree, billing and cooing in their loving way. Others have reported seeing small numbers around Reedsburg in later years, and it is hoped they may return:
Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · 10 May 1899
The Wisconsin Tobacco Reporter · Edgerton, Wis. · 12 May 1899
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A newspaper reports that a mile-long flock of American passenger pigeons, so dense it nearly obscured the sun, passed north near Reedsburg, Wisconsin. The birds had reportedly been absent from their former roosting grounds near Lime Ridge for twenty years.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Topeka State Journal · 11 May 1899 · page 2
PIGEONS COME BACK.
Reedsburg, "Wis., May 11. At Lime Ridge a flock of American passenger pigeons has passed north, the flock be ing a mile long and so dense as to near ly obscure the sun. These birds have not been seen for twenty years. They formerly roosted near Lime Ridge, but suddenly disappeared.
A report describes a flock of American passenger pigeons passing north over Lime Ridge, Wis., so large it was a mile long and nearly obscured the sun. The item notes the birds had not been seen in that area for 20 years, after having formerly roosted there before suddenly disappearing.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Rock Island Argus · 16 May 1899 · page 4
At Lime Uidge. Wis., on day last week a llock of American passenger pigeons passed north, the llock leing a mile long and so dense as to nearly obscure the sun. These birds have not been seen in this section for 20 years. They formerly roosted near Lime Uidge, but snddenly disap
A mile-long flock of passenger pigeons reportedly passed over Lime Ridge, Wisconsin, causing excitement since the birds had not been seen in 20 years. The article speculates on theories for their disappearance, including mass killing, disease, or migration to South America, and concludes the species is not extinct after all.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The Beatrice Daily Express · 18 May 1899 · page 4
ORNITHOLOGICAL MYSTERY. Appearance of Passenger Pigeons at Lime Ridge, Win., Creates Interest. There was general excitement at Lime Ridge, near Reedsburg, Wis., re cently when a .flock of American pas senger pigeons passed north over that place, the flock being a ..mile long and so dense as to nearly obscure the sun Their appearance has created interest, as these birds bave not been seen for 20 years, and even specimen hunters could not secure a single bird. They formerly roosted near Lime Ridge, and came ev ery summer by millions to nest and breed.
See moreSee less
Tbe people made pigeon hunting one of the principal sources of revenne in those days. They were slaughtered by the hundreds of pounds, but still seemed to increase in number. They suddenly disappeared, and were sup posed to be extinct until their recent appearanca Several theories were advanced as to their disappearance, some thinking they had all been killed aid others say ing they had gathered on tbe eastern seashore in great numbers and had been driven out and perished. Others claimed an infectious disease had destroyed them However this may be, they are not extinct. It is a great mystery where they have been for so many years, as they bave not frequented their southern feeding grounds during tbe winter for the same length of time. The only pos -ible theory now is that they migrated to South America. The people will do everything in their power to protect the biyds from being needlessly slaugh tered! and it is hoped they may again become as numerous as formerly.— Minneapolis Tribune. Selliaar Coppers at lO Cents a Doseni ‘‘Pefihies—10 cents a dozen,” is a sign that has been put up in a cigar store in Anderson, Ind., and trade is brisk. The place is filled with the penny alluring slot machines, and tbe dealer is taking the risk that most of his cut rate coppers will remain in tbe build —Cincinnati Enauirer.
The article recounts eyewitness descriptions of massive passenger pigeon flocks in Pennsylvania decades earlier, including a flock estimated at 800 million birds, and traces their disappearance through New York, Pennsylvania, Indian Territory, and Michigan by 1889. It speculates that the pigeons have merely migrated to Canadian forests rather than vanished, leaving their winter whereabouts unexplained.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
Williston Graphic · 19 May 1899 · page 4
$eonb ^eeeli woods, tlvn a tract.'of for- «&.• •••.. -•.• •. T... ... 1 A^'Veni^rKe are«8 n. Pike, Wayne, T&IERNE and Monroe'counties PH. Snd it beuan to xt'ow dark, and 1 noine |j|e (lint pc.oduced'hy a cide of wind or rtiii.blinv of d.:tuiit tliunder broke 'ion their ears, SiinultaneonR'y the 'i^woods began to fiTI itia wild pigeons. Tree aftfr tree became burdened with tliem, and stiil the air was black witli an .apparently interminable mass of inrunli jing birdf. The .pigeons settled in the 1 trees in Btich numbera that great branch es broke beneath their weight, nnd this occur ring constantly on every hand throughout the WOOIIR presented the apHianee of a windfall in the forest."
See moreSee less
tis single flock of pigeons was esti mated to have numbered 800,000,000 ps^irdp. 1 In 1886 the pigeons disnppeared front Pennsylvania, when they turned up in the,iliidi«ti Territory. They were last Been iii Michigan in 1889, and althougb they were still in the san countless i.V tjiousands in lmmherivnothing han been Mfen nor beard of them since. What iecairie of them 110 one knows. It is in Sf At" that they were exterminated -credible like the buffalo, since as we have' jiu-t noted, their numbeis were not at all di minished when last seen only ten years *'§go. It is advanced,.as an explanation, vlhat the wild pigeou always goes in a (jingle "colony" and becwaoe no single Jocality in the country now affords the IjJfii'ns of sustenance for tlionsauci "^Qliiiti birds the pigeons have gone to ffcvyfli* estens've forests »f Canada, but how can mierate to a warmer eliinate in si winter without being observed in: crosti V^itK our country in not explained*-
A farming miscellany column from 1899 notes in passing that the American passenger pigeon, once numbering in the untold millions forty years earlier, is now practically extinct with none known to remain in the country. The item appears amid unrelated notes on orchard damage, crop advice, and farm economics.
The American passenger pigeon, ol which there were untold millions forty years ago, is practically extinct and none are known to be left anywhere in this
The article recounts a joke played by scientists at the Smithsonian Institution, who spread a false rumor that passenger pigeons were dying out and that the museum wanted specimens, prompting people to mail in dead birds for payment. The piece treats the pigeon's supposed decline as an implausible jest, asserting the species is so numerous it will surely endure.
HUMOR IN SCIENCE. rfome Funny Things Happen in the • Smithsonian Institution. Thi* brother scientists of one of the •liief ■'bitil.il igists” at the Smithsonian Institution had some fun which that l .oil-natutvd gentleman—one of the most eminent exponents of the science pertaining to feathered creatures in the worldnot long ago. They caused an Item to work its way into circula tion and to be spread broadcast thiollghout tite country, to the effect ill it the ordinary passenger pigeon of tdology was. for some inexplicable i e ;son or other, dying out so rapidly that the Smithsonian Institution de d * number of specimens of the me for stuffing and mounting pur 1,.,..
See moreSee less
s. Now, passenger pigeons are not a,onerous as English sparrows, of cans. , inn, all the same, there are so no ay of tlnan extant that they stand ! excellent chance of enduring as a .,„ i i. s is long as the human race in hibits this globe. The bird, scientist . i;:, s to stat" just how many boxes pass uger pigeons he has received up to date, together with “please re .;ii• " lulls through the mails for the ni". but the passenger pigeons are ii ! to lie still a-eoming. They arc : t baek. express charges C. < •. 1>.. in ii case, and howls come in a-plenty to the effect that some of the birds have expired on the return trip, and d. minding payment for these dead ] ones. The Smithsonian Institution does not 1 look at first or even second glance like sa outfit wherein there is likely to be any fun worth speaking of, but the i corps of really distinguished scientists J ■.ho work oyer there do, in fact, en j ,y their daily quota of humor right
A writer in the Pittsburg Dispatch describes the supposed reappearance of the passenger pigeon after about twenty years of apparent absence, noting earlier fears the species had gone extinct due to hunting. The piece recounts the historical abundance of the bird, including Alexander Wilson's famous estimate of a flock containing over two billion birds.
Ten years’ experience, Satisfaction guaranteed. Correspondence solic ited. 62tf. j why cannot the Germans stand our | pacific attitude? They can join us if they wish. I should hail with I pleasure every addition to the , union. When we get over the fighting mania that has seized our people— and I think it will not last—let us unite with Russia in the disarms ment. The hard-working masses are anxious for peace. We need it; all need it. Do not let us trouble ourselves about the Anglo Saxon question.” An Epidemic of Whooping Cough.
See moreSee less
Last winter during an epidemic of whooping cough my children contracted the disease, having severe coughing spells. Wo had used Chamberlain’s Cough Remedy very successfully for croup and naturally turned to it at that time and found it relieved the cough and effected a complete cure.— John E. Cli.i.fohd, Proprietor Forwood House, Norwood, N. Y. This remedy is for sale by E. H. Pigeons Come Back. A writer in the Pittsburg Dis patch tells of the following phenomenon in ornithology. All lovers and students of birds will bo interested in the reappear ance of the passenger pigeon. For at least a score of years this splen did bird was not seen in North America and most ornithologists were of the opinion that it had become extinct. Many regrets were expressed that it had been destroyed by ruthless hunters. It was once .more plentiful in the woods than the buffaloes on the plains and apparently suffered a similar fate. The numbers of passenger pigeons once living in the United .States were beyond estimation. They passed to and fro over the country in Hocks of almost incredi ble size. They traveled indeed, in swarms rather than flocks.. Alexander Wilson once saw a flock which, calculating the rapid ity of flight and the time of pass age, he estimated to bo 240 miles long and to contain more than 2,000,000,000 birds. The passenger pigeon is a hand some bird. It is larger than the turtle dove and somewhat longer than the common domestic pigeon. It has a short bill and n rather small head, with long and power ful wings and a long wedge-shaped tail. Its color is a grayish blue above, light brownish red on the throat and sides, and nearly white underneath. The tail is black in the middle and bordered with white. The migration of these pigeons were for the purpose of finding food, and they always travel in immense swarms. They went to the far South in winter, and to Canada in mid-summer, but at other times they were continually passing here and there over the country lying between the Appa lachian Mountains and the great plains. They never frequented any country devoid of forests. Their breeding grounds were, for probably hundreds of years, in the great woods of Tennessee and Kentucky. Wilson describes one of their Kentucky breeding places. It was three or four miles wide and 40 miles long, and in that ex tensive territory every tree was j litterally thronged with nests. The' eggs were laid about the middle of { April and the young birds were able to fly away with the other birds before the end of May. The ancients believed that rheu matism was the work of a demon within a man. Any one who has had an attack of sciatic or inflam matory rheumatism will agree that the infliction is demoniac enough to warrant the belief. It has never been claimed that Chamber