As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · The full archive

April 1899

5 articles

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

Col. Noah Parker, a collector of mounted birds, recounts how the once-superabundant wild pigeon disappeared almost overnight around 1878 with no one able to explain why. He describes competing folk theories, including the idea that all pigeons belonged to one vast colony that vanished as a whole.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Sun · 9 April 1899 · page 19

WHERE IS THE WILD PIGEON

nlprnSt to the spoilsman nnd pot hunter nnd trart" ' " "' ''-'' l'y ""'"rallsta nnd ol I ,rtln wonlaniet that the wild pigeons formed ene great eo'.onv This theory seerned iboraa out by the fact that sometimes In cn rr' of ,h" fun,r5' tlmy would cover an irnof woods mora than ten miles square for thir noting and roosting place, while tlicy irotili' i."t t' heard of nnywhoic olseexcept. t-rlial Ir io'ated (locks op the wing, ovi dutlvloii' l'"rthe common nesting ground. Bat v hi e th wild pigeons mny huv been ono .reatei-ony f tiida '.hay generally nrranao.l linet m two cthree colonies In different i ruts nf the eounti v.

See moreSee less

according to theoondit:on ol the feeding grounds. ' Proximity toia'' beech woods waatheori-m'i Ifff fir'hs innu.il pigeon roost, and t.'s; 'fne whr tli' iim'hw ostein part of Pnntiarivii'U always a favorite lesnrt o! the colony. Tim AglnM H. ei eounti's weron dense vf llder aessffiie '"d liein'ock. bniderlnp nnd ln-irper-ed anions hIiii'Ii wein thousands of ,rnji!le' ii ttii. s tnoetini; the ipriiireniit8 o'ilieuB'v' Th" list time nny patt of the i ei, in -i il'Ii "m .' ii'l of Westoin Pennsyltam.1 n.is i" l'i 1 1'" iniiiii bivlj nested tlre '.it it) Isw' nii.'ii it flllo! flvo nil'es i.uir .i r..'' ' M.vid as mirj'-In tlio v,iiti'""i' li'h.Mn ii Ai lieu. Vim f.ivoi In wli .Ii th" h-M'i 'iel, he I .til 1 beech woods of this ic on w. re lifld hi 'ho wild pIireoKa Is shown I y tlii! leu ii i'.' nifh which thev lulled It, there "'' I ni' f '.ecu iir vlthin tho r Kemoir f aii i o "h.it some Luce pnrt of the great I "'i ' ' 't rno theie, inh."-stho hecch ei.ter'P ii. ! I eon a failure tlix joar bofore Tie r a ' 'i itself illlei! thesn woods In l-i;T l"W, I-T1. :i": nnd 1 Sh( I,i tho last ii-iririt ' f the main I'llnnv nested In the li' lUii'luiii" li. lwsi! tlio tiicnt bml of tho fvmu : M -.-nuri fn tho off years of Wi.-'epi IV 'ImiiI.i. piitieul.irly after tho Jori-'s r".'. in.iii omititv, N. .. nnd Vn no tr ' IM ' irti''. I'.i . had bien cleared away l the 'mi t i in ii. thntv ean ,iko. the r.wns(.ui;lit th v U" i.'.in.idauiul MieluSii i inu.iit.i.it a f ictor iveie tlic-o l.iuU In "h e..i r.-mv nf Wi-tcrn IVnnivlvaiiiath.it tli"irliii i i .in Mi:u' t the haeUwoods iaen.li 'I t r ' "in! nettei-. of the blid as a 1 n aim i-: i- .' 'us n the ill.apienrntice of tl.e w in Nth. I'i-i'Iii s on hi h;io b.'cn. 'Hie '.i-t i .'i-i'ii ft-.iinU that coer much of tl.e,iia uii;'i ti hi iitTnideil t'm food that at Intel li-p ee ttli.. lo-'alitv. eieiy fruit ful bee 'In uf 1.. ir i.e'tic u o to be follnwod bv tie an iMi im i I the liinN in creater or fin'-i nun'-- Th" l'eelimit tree Nun rertiitii, i'- ie I ! nuts, and seldom hears tueieir-ii, -ii". s-i hi When tlio trees hear tli id liquids i nil ihoti-nnds of bimhcls of theaiiNfi'l ' th-mound after the frosts of ajtinin rii i ireosered by the falllne !mip, iiid I inel le.i beneath flueeeedliiK niia r'n ii -outline nnd sweetness are

See the clipping

The Sun · New York, N.Y.

The passage describes the mechanics of pigeon netting: baited ground, hidden ropes and hickory stakes that snapped nets over flocks, and the use of a blinded 'stool pigeon' to lure wild birds down. It explains how hunters could capture hundreds of birds in a single netting using this method.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 24 days earlier.

The Sun · 9 April 1899 · page 19

of Cook of plceoni flying over, and they would olrcle around and comn down neartho spot. evN denlly curious to aco what was Dm matter with the capllvej)lceon They would not bo loiitf , In discovering thoballod Kronnd. and tlinn llmv would crowd upon this si ot until evory Inch of It would be blue with piceons, Then thn Hot ter sprang tho not by pulllnc the rope out of the notches In the atakf The hickory nolo would fly back to their ikjsUIoiis like a (ln-h. hooting the net out oxer the ground ooiered with th birds, and In a second hundreds of pigeons would be held cnptlio In and bencnth the meatus.

See moreSee less

A manynal, KM) birds hnxebeou oaught t one netting. During nesting tlmo a stool pigeon was used to lure the flocks to the snare. This was a pigeon that had bcon tialned for tho purpose. Experience showed that no matter how well one of those blrda waa trained It would never fall tolve warnlneto tho wild birds of their danger If It could bco them. Thn stool pigeon was thateforo blinded by sewing Its eyelids to gether. Thla poor bird would bo secured on a perch lu the rear ol the not, near tho gioutid. whloli was manipulated by a string In tho hnnds of the hidden notter so that this pigeon would be kept fluttering. This would attract tho attention of tho Hy ing blrda. and they would gnthor In treoa mound nnd watch the movements of the docoy bird a long time. At Inst one or two plgeots would enturo to fly down to tho Kround to got closer Inspection, then they would And tho snlt or buckwheat, when tho moiemcnt of thn decoy bird would bo for gotten and the pigeons would begin to feed on the baltod ground. That would at once bring flock after flock bvtooplng down, nnd soon tho spacn would bo covered with the groedv birds, and tho net would ho sprung as described. In spite o! all tho destruction thnt weather, notteis, hnntois, hawks, crows nnd other ene mies of the wild pigeon worked lu a pigeon roost, it was ehient that more pigeons would ler.ve the woods when the roost broke up than ontare.J It at tlm beginning of nesting. In tho nemorable pigeon year of 1MH() pigeons began to ar'lvo lu thn woods ns tarly ns Kebruaiv, nnd for two weeks there was a ceaseless Influx. Tlm snow was ntlll deep, but thn pigeons swept dmvn upon it by millions, nnd by using their wings uncoMited tho burled beech mi's. Un told thousands of tho birds perished from star vation and cold during the (Irst two weoks of tho roost. Another largo division of tho main colony sought feeding grounds In that year tn tho Indian Tnnltory. and anotherin the Michi gan wilderness, but tho toost In l'ennsvlvatiiti was so much Iniger than tho others, and so easy of access and eonvonient to market, that tho piofesslon.il potters enmo Irom all part9 of tho "ountty to western I'onnjylvania. As usual. almost din entire population of tho back woods. Including the Indians from the reserva tions as far as irom Cattaraugus county. X. Y , began its onslaught upon the birds, killing them with gun, with clubs, with nets and raps. They were not content with this slaughter by day. but kept It up dminc tho night in ih toosts by torchlight. The roost did not break up until tho latter part of April, yet It wa plr.lr. to any one that 'he woods were more eiowded with pigeons when tho birds Ibesau to take tholr flight than thev wcio when tho roost was stntted. It wns estimated that tho oilginnl toost or pigeon clt. ns these enormous gatherings of the birds were called, contained '.'(Mi.Olxl.OoO pigeons, which number wns naturally In creased bv iNal.tWMt.iinn by tho pigeons hatched during the stny in tho woods Thero were per haps 1.000 persons constantly In tho woods day nnd night during the llfty days that tho roost wns maintained, slaughtering pigeons nnd squabs Indiscriminately, and If each killed 1.000 birds a dav. which Is not likely, they would not hae reduced the colony by one twellth even of its increase while the slaughter was going on. This would not apply to that particular pteeon city nlone, but to every one ever known, so that the theory that the wild pigeons have become oxtinct. like the buffalo, bv ruthle-s slaughter will not hold. That theory, mm cover, is over thrown by the fact that on tho Inst appearance of the wild pigeon, in 1HS!', which was in north ern Michigan, the colony wns fullv ns large as it had ever been known In that fnvmitc roost ing and breeding place of tho msstertoiis bird The Inst appearance of the wild pigeon In nny niitnborsas far east as its old nesting nnd feed ing ground In western Pennsylvania was In 1HMI. It had deserted its former favorite re gions in southern New YorK and eastern Penn sylvania ten years before that No wild pig eons, except in isolated flocks in tho fall, have been -con east of the Alleghany. Hivei since 1H7H. The last great pigeon root enst of that was In Sullivan county, N. Y . and the adjacent Pennsylvania counties in that vear. The writer remembers It well, as he was fortunnto enough to bo an eyewitness of It. One day In the last week of March. 1K7U. lumbermen fiom the headwaters of the ISoa verkill and the beeeh woods of tho wilderness of Sullivan. Delaware and I'lster counties. N Y.. biought In tho news that thoo regions hnd beer, tnkeu iiosession of by wild pigeons In untold ntimbeis and that thev were prepar ing for tho nesting season. Two days befom theskvhad been obscured in .1 great poitlun of Sullivan county by the passing over ot nn nppaien'ly endlos flock of pigeons going r.oitlm.ird. The incessant pro-ession gave to the sin louiiillngs the sonihte appearance that ncooir tunics the gibbering and lasslng of lienvy thumlir clouds. It was ?r.bsoMinntly learned that theninssof pigeon . etondoil to the oistward more than twelve miles in uu litoken lltm. Hiitiiers. betters and people gciu-r-allyllo-kod In the great pigeon roost and It was found Mint Inlf had not been told of its v.i-t-ness. The bird had ceaiecly begun their nesting when r. severo Miowt-torni ."inn." on. Snow fell to tl.e depth of more Mum .'. foot .ill tliiougli that thon nild nnd i-olnted inglo'i. When tho snow hail cense.! falling an unusual nnd peeu'iai stit was noticed tl'iuughout the whole e.tcnt of 'ho great nii't. .itv! 'it t.oon on thu lUth day afloi their coming Into the lie.-h woods the jilKivtis I'.wi t take flight, i.'l go ing iIiih west. In nt. hour thero ".ti not a single !i".o plseoi. left in tha lo-.iljtv Irom :u :id of th ', '. to tin othi r.. That -Hmouay. (i nb ii't a iiunitcrot 1 ,n tha nfteinooi,, Cllntoii Waists ami Isaac Heniictl. woodehoppeis iit.d b.ulv pcclot. wcio in tho depths of tlm roi'ouo licccti woods, then ntiact of fmest '. cling laige amis In 1'iko. Wiiyno, Luzerne and Monron counties. IV. Suddenly Ii U'gau to ttoiv dark, and a noho llkothat produced by u galoof wind or tho toll of dis tant thunder btoke on theircus. Siiiiultano 0U5r. thy woods began to (111 with wild pigeons. Tieoaltor tree becamo bur leneil wl'htheiu, uud still the air was black with an apparently Ititcrtninablo mass of inrushlng birN. Tho pigcns s-ttled in thu trees n su-h mini-ti-ic thai gtcat branches broke beneath their iveigbt. and this occurring c n Htantly on e.eiv hand tbtoiigbout the woods presented tho appearance of a windfall in tho forest. The two men could not Imaglun vvliern the pigeoncould havo como from so suddenly, but when. '..'. couraoof time, the nous of their presonee in the l'ennsvlvntii.i vvlldornuss i enehed. Sullivan count v, people thero know that tho pigeons wore tho ones tliat had been driven outof tho llenv erk 111 country by the Miowsturni. Tho nce.rost point in tho Pennsylvania woods where tho birds rested alter tholr flight from Now York Stntn wns fnrty-llve miles from tho Benverklll In n straight line, showing that the pleeons must have flown at least ,i mll a mln uto In changing 'heir nesting place. After tho (It si excitement attending thonpreliance of thla vast colony of wild pigeons hnd pnssod. Wnltert and Dennett began t abiughlcr the blrda. They had no gun-, hut with long polea they slow tho awnrmlnc Pigeons by th hundred. Uvery sweep of u club laid doiena of tho birds dead or wounded

See the clipping

Richmond Dispatch · Richmond, Va.

A reader writes to the newspaper's Queries and Answers column asking what has become of the wild pigeons. The query reflects public puzzlement over the birds' apparent disappearance.

Richmond Dispatch · 16 April 1899 · page 7

2 xn THeDateCh * sienr of iP Dispatch? To the Eq tas many questions asked and I gee whet th pispatch. Please tell us answered ome of the wild pigeons, wha 3 \ n i Ya. i 8.

See the clipping

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · New Haven, Conn.

A Connecticut newspaper notes that wild (passenger) pigeons, once abundant and netted by the thousands for market, have mysteriously vanished from the region, much as some swallow species have also disappeared from their old haunts. The writer questions the usual explanation of failed food supply, noting pigeons have also vanished from food-rich areas like Kentucky and Indiana, leaving their fate undetermined.

The Daily Morning Journal and Courier · 20 April 1899 · page 2

Connecticut The Swallows, Etc. Not all the ways of birds are known, even to the ornithologist. One strik ing thing is noticed but not explained. Several kinds of birds have a way of suddenly disappearing from any given locality, where for long generations they had been very abundant. This was the case with the "wild pigeons." Sixty years ago these birds flew In enormous flocks over many parts of Connecticut, and settled , down by thousands in certain localities, where they were captured in large spring-nets that were set on poles around a level plat of ground duly covered with food that attracted them.

See moreSee less

Tens of thou sands were captured in this way, until the birds were cheap in the Hartford market. Southwlck, Mass., was a noted place for netting them for mar ket. So far a9 appears, these Im mense flocks of pigeons had visited Connecticut every summer or fall for as long a time as anybody could re member. The readiest explanation of their disappearance is, of course, the alleged failure of the acorns or other food upon which the pigeons subsisted; but if that is the correct explanation for Connecticut, why not for Kentucky, or Indiana, Where, though their feed is still abundant, the vast and crowd ed "pigeon roosts" in the woods are said to have disappeared. Where the pigeons have gone seems to be unde

See the clipping

New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.

Colleagues at the Smithsonian played a prank on a bird expert by spreading a false report that passenger pigeons were mysteriously dying out, prompting people to mail him boxes of the birds for pay. The piece insists pigeons remain so numerous they will likely survive as long as humanity does.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 31 days later.

Wrong

New-York Tribune · 23 April 1899 · page 50

FUNNY THINGS HAPPEN IN THE SOME SMITHSONIAN INSTITUTION. ¥rcm The Washington Star, The brother scientists of one of the chief “birdologists” at the Smithsonian Institution had some fun with that good-natured gentleman —one of the most eminent exponents of the | science pertaining to feathered creatures in the world—not long ago. They caused an item to work its way into circulation and to be spread | broadcast throughout the country, to the effect that the ordinary passenger pigeon of birdology was, for some inexplicable reason or other, dying i out go rapidly that the Smithsonian Institution desired a number of specimens of the same for stuffing and mounting purposes.

See moreSee less

Now, passenger pigeons are net so numerous [English as sparrows, of course, but, all the same, there are so many of them extant that they stand an excellent chance of enduring as a species as long as the human race inhabits this globe. The bird scientist declines to state just how many boxes of passenger pigeons he has received up to date, together with “please remit” bills through the mails for the same, but the passenger pigeons are said to be still a-coming. They are sent back, express charges (!, O. D,, in each case, and howls come in a-plenty to the effect that some of the birds have expired on the return trip, and demanding payment for these dead ones. The Smithsonian Institution does not look at first or even second glance like an outfit wherein there is likely to be any fun worth speaking of, but the corps of really distinguished scientists who work over there do, in fact, enjoy their daily quota of humor right along. It doesn’t necessarily follow that because a man is a or scientist with a lot of queer initials after his name he docs not partake of at least some of the distinctly human attributes of his genus. The truth is that they are an extraordinarily | cheerful, unassuming set of gentlemen, and they are unceasingly poking fun at each other's attainments and ambitions, One has only to see one particular member of this scientific staff a man who is renowned throughout the world for the depth of his learning and his remarkable researches in his specialty--sitting back in his shirt sleeves in a tip-tilted chair, smoking a short and very disreputable briarwood pipe, to understand how thoroughly compatible science is with what might be called humanness. The scientists at the institution get a good deal of fun out of letters that come to them from all parts of the country. Not long since a out in lllinois wrote to the institution woman that she had six toes on each of her feet, and that she would be glad to place herself on ex1 hibition in the institution for a pretty stiff figure, which she stipulated. She was politely - informed that the institution was not hunting for live human exhibits. Then there are alleged fossil finders all over the country who write requesting that their expenses be paid for the trip to Washington, in order that they may bring their fossils along with them to the institution, Needless to state, their modest requests are not | acceded to. Their fossils generally belong to species decidedly not extinet. Again, scattered | throughout the country are many people who come into possession of collections that they ——— suppose to be valuable, and these write to the Smithsonian Institution with the view to mak ing a dicker. For example, not long ago a | Massachusetts woman wrote to the institution, stating that her father, a retired sea captain, had recently died, leaving her nothing much | | besides a large collection of curious shells, many of which, he had told her, were of inestimable value because there were no duplicates of them in any known collection. She was poor, she said, and she wanted to transfer the collection of shells to the Smithsonian Institution for a consideration which she named-a pretty sizable consideration. The institution did not send a man up that way for the single purpose of examining this collection, but one of the scientists who recently happened to get near to the town from which the letter was written went over to look it over, and he wrote the institution to the effect that there wasn’t a shell or conch in the array that wasn’t already on file in the institution's exhibit of that sort. Pathos occasionally creeps into these letters to the institution. A few months ago Professor Langley received a letter from a poor woman whose mind had apparently been unseated by the death of her child. The woman stated that she had a pair of the little one’s shoes which she considered very valuable, and she thought the Smithsonian Institution might like to have them to put on exhibition. There was a good deal of superfluous coughing and nose blowing among the scientists when that poor scrawl was handed around, and Professor Langley’s autograph reply to the letter is said to have been a nice thing to read. — *

See the clipping