As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · As the Papers Told It

Act Six

The Mystery

March 1917 – July 1930

With the bird gone, the papers turned to why. It was ‘one of the strangest mysteries in American natural history,’ one wrote in 1917; by 1919 most scientists, another said, agreed it was man. A single egg was worth $1,000, and still there were sightings, of forty birds in a Colorado forest in 1926. In 1930 a paper told the whole story again, beginning where it began: no one had regulated the slaughter, ‘for the supply was considered unlimited.’

A puzzle that has baffled scientists

A New Hampshire paper calls the wild pigeon’s disappearance a puzzle that ‘probably never will be solved.’ Half a century ago, it says, flocks of tens of thousands could take the better part of an hour to pass. Gunners killed vast numbers every year, but many investigators hold that other causes must have played a part.

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · Manchester, N.H. · and 1 other paper

New Hampshire Farmer and Weekly Union · 28 March 1917 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The Wild Pigeon Mystery. That the wild pigeon, once so common in the United States, has become extinct is one of the strangest mysteries in American natural history. It is a puzzle which has baffled scientists and which probably never will be solved. Half a century ago wild pigeons were abundant in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana, Kentucky and all the states of the middle west. In their migrations they traveled in flocks numbering tens of thousands, and it sometimes took a single flock the better part of an hour to pass a given point.

See moreSee less

Vast numbers of the pigeons were killed every year by gunners, but many investigators hold that the complete disappearance of the species must have been due in part at least to other causes. No other bird was ever so numerous in this country as the pigeon.

See the clipping

Man’s warfare on the nesting grounds

A Viroqua paper finds scientists divided over the wild pigeon’s disappearance, but most agree the prime cause was ‘man’s warfare on the bird’s nesting grounds.’ There is no evidence of disease or parasites. Nesting colonies sometimes 40 miles long made the slaughter easy, and the birds left after the great forests were cleared were probably driven to the far North, where they perished.

Vernon County Censor · Viroqua, Wis. · and 1 other paper

Vernon County Censor · 11 June 1919 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

WILD PIGEONS SLAUGHTERED

Scientists Agree That Disappearance of Birds Was Caused by Man's Warfare.

See moreSee less

There are differences of opinion among scientists concerning the disappearance of wild pigeons, but most agree that man's warfare on the bird's nesting grounds has been the prime cause of its extinction. There is no evidence that disease or parasites brought about their extinction. Wild pigeons were very gregarious in their habits, nesting together in large colonies with many nests in a single tree. These colonies were sometimes as much as 40 miles long and several miles wide, making it easy for hunters to slaughter the birds. Millions of them were sent to the markets each year for food, while others were captured alive and used for the sport of pigeon shooting. Those that remained after the clearing of the great forests were probably driven to the far North and perished.

See the clipping

One egg, $1,000; a nesting pair, $7,000

The University of Illinois owns a passenger pigeon egg, now valued at $1,000. A standing offer of $7,000 waits for anyone who can prove a nesting pair exists. The bird, the item says, ‘is believed to be extinct.’

The Frontier · O'Neill City, Neb. · and 1 other paper

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: New-York Tribune, 17 April 1921, East Mississippi Times, 22 April 1921.

The Frontier · 28 April 1921 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

An egg of the passenger pigeon is now estimated to be worth $1,000 by the University of Illinois, which possesses one. The bird is believed to be extinct. There is a standing offer of $7,000 to anyone proving the existence of a nesting pair.

See the clipping

Two pigeons become forty on the Cochetopa

A game report from the Cochetopa National Forest in Colorado says two pigeons noticed a few years ago, left unmolested, have returned each year and increased to forty or more, perhaps passenger pigeons, judging mainly by pictures. The Denver item calls it ‘hardly possible’ that they are the true bird, yet grants that they display ‘to a striking degree’ the characteristics of the extinct pigeon.

Arizona State Miner · Wickenburg, Ariz. · and 2 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 79 days later.

Wrong

Arizona State Miner · 13 February 1926 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The Phoenix-Like Passenger Pigeon Denver.—Out of the ashes of racial extermination, has arisen apparently a new passenger pigeon, according to a recent game report issued on the Cochetopa National forest, in Colorado. The observations which have led to this conclusion are as follows: "A few years ago two pigeons were noticed in this locality and due to not being molested they have returned each year and increased until now there are forty or more of the birds. It is believed that this may be the passenger pigeon (Ectopistes migratotia) now supposed to be extinct in the United States.

See moreSee less

This assertion is based mainly on pictures of the passenger pigeon." It is hardly possible that these are the true passenger pigeon. Despite the general tendency to doubt the possibility of such an unusual occurrence, the fact remains that these pigeons display to a striking degree the characteristics of the extinct pigeon.

See the clipping

The heath hen takes Martha’s place

Elmo Scott Watson writes that a single male heath hen on Martha’s Vineyard now holds the place ‘Martha’ held in 1914, last of his race. In the same weeks two Michigan men, the Munising publisher Robert H. Wright and Dr. Samuel R. Landes, report seeing passenger pigeons, but William B. Mershon and Professor Norman A. Wood say there is ‘not the remotest chance’ of a single survivor.

The Midland Journal · Rising Sun, Md. · and 2 other papers

The Midland Journal · 4 July 1930 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

The Passing of the Heath Hen

By ELMO SCOTT WATSON

See moreSee less

IN 1914 there died in Cincinnati a famous native American. "Martha" was her name and her fame consisted of the fact that she was the last of her race, the sole survivor of the countless millions of passenger pigeons which once darkened the skies in their flight in the Mississippi valley. Today somewhere in the protecting scrub oak which covers the green plains of Martha's Vineyard there wanders another native American who is the successor to the unique position once held by "Martha." He bears no man-given name, for where "Martha" died in captivity he is spending his last years in the freedom of a vast reservation which was created 20 years ago to save his species from extinction. But the effort has failed for today this single health hen, a male, on Martha's Vineyard is the last of his race.

When the earliest settlers came to New England the heath hen was the most abundant of all game birds in the East, being distributed from Cape Ann to Virginia and especially abundant in the lowlands of Massachusetts, Connecticut and Long Island. In fact, in Governor Winthrop's day this bird was so common around Boston that laborers "bound out" to employers stipulated in their agreements with their masters that it should not be served to them as their food oftener "than a few times a week." But when the settlers began cutting off the forests the decline of the heath hen started. The spread of civilization and the increasing number of cats and dogs which preyed upon its young further decimated the heath hen and by a century ago they were gone from the mainland of Massachusetts, although a few lingered for another decade or two on outer Long Island and on the Jersey plains.

Eventually it was discovered that the island of Martha's Vineyard off the Massachusetts coast, was the only place where these birds could be found and even there they were engaged in what seemed a hopeless struggle against death.

In 1876 they were reported extinct and the introduction of foxes and racoons to the island the following year made the death of the race seem certain. But somehow the heath hens re-established themselves. In the early '90s William Brewster reckoned that there might be 200 birds left on the island. The grass fire of 1894 ruined their breeding ground, and observers could find only five birds that autumn. In 1897 a hunter with a bird dog failed to start a single bird. Yet again they came back, only to suffer in another fire in 1906. Massachusetts game wardens set the heath hen population at twenty-one in 1907 and at fifty or more in 1908. Then the state took a hand and gave the birds active protection.

By 1916 the colony had grown to a thousand. The foxes and raccoons were exterminated; other pests were kept down. But that summer another fire swept over the heath hen reservation, and that autumn great flights of goshawks descended on the island and preyed on the survivors. In 1917 fewer than 100 heath hens were left; these increased to more than 400 in 1922, when a cold, wet season almost wiped out the colony. Perhaps fifty birds were left in 1923, possibly thirty in 1927. Despite the care of the state and of the Martha's Vineyard Rod and Gun club, despite distribution of food, cultivation of clover and sunflowers, despite the destruction of cats and rats and crows and hawks, the colony dwindled steadily.

And now there is only one left. Prof. Alfred O. Gross of Bowdoin college, who for several years had made an annual census of the heath hens on the island, returned to Boston recently and submitted his annual report. In it he said:

"During the year 1928 the number of heath hens dwindled from three to one lone bird. This bird was alive at the time of the annual census taken March 30 to April 3, 1929. Though suggestions have been made to the state department of conservation to collect and preserve this last bird for science, it has been allowed to live its normal life among the scrub oaks on the sandy plains of Martha's Vineyard Island.

"The bird continued to visit the farm of James Green, West Tisbury, during the early spring of 1929, and was reported as late as May 11. After that date, as was the custom of the heath hen in the past, this individual disappeared among the dense scrub oaks to live in seclusion during the summer months. In October, after going through the ordeal of moulting, it again appeared at the Green farm to announce to the world that it was still alive.

"It was seen at irregular intervals during the winter, and since the first warm days of March it has made daily visits to the traditional 'booming' field, the old meadow along the state highway between Edgartown and West Tisbury, in a place less than a hundred yards' distance from Mr. Green's house.

Almost simultaneously with the announcement that the heath hen was traversing the last mile of its road to extinction came the news also that the supposedly extinct passenger pigeon had staged a "come-back." At least two Michigan men, Robert H. Wright, Munising publisher, and Dr. Samuel R. Landes of Traverse City, both of whom knew the passenger pigeon in the days of its abundance, declare that within recent months they have seen passenger pigeons in northern Michigan. Wright, his wife and son declare that from a distance of 10 feet they saw two adult pigeons sitting in the road near Munising, and Doctor Landes and his brother state that they saw a flock of approximately fifteen between Kokomo, Ind., and Indianapolis, while driving from Florida to Michigan.

William B. Mershon of Saginaw, one of America's leading authorities on the subject, and Prof. Norman A. Wood of the University of Michigan say there is not the remotest chance for the survival of a single passenger pigeon. Reports have long been received of the pigeon's presence in various localities, but investigation has proved the observers mistaken. Usually the psuedo "passenger pigeon" was found to be a mourning dove, or the band-tailed pigeon from the West.

The extermination of the passenger pigeon was accomplished even more swiftly than that of the heath hen. The state of Michigan was their principal nesting grounds and their rookeries in the northern part of that state covered dozens of square miles with as many as a hundred nests, each occupied by one or two squabs, in a single tree. The farmers considered them a pest and the slaughter of the birds which began in the sixties reached its high tide in the seventies, when the commercial possibilities of the birds were realized.

No one took steps to regulate the slaughter, for the supply was considered unlimited. No matter how many thousands or even millions were killed, the enormous flocks still streamed out of the South in April. They still darkened the sun—broke the branches from trees by their weight. Their rookeries still filled the woods. Then shortly after 1880 the pigeons suddenly disappeared.

Pigeons were observed near Cadillac in 1888, but disappeared a month after their arrival. They were traced northward as far as Oden, Emmet county, and are presumed to have crossed the straits of Mackinaw into the Upper Peninsula or Ontario. After 1888 no large flocks were seen anywhere, and the appearance of a single bird was considered worthy of mention in scientific journals.

Another American bird which is now extinct—and has been for nearly a hundred years—is the great auk. It was different from any other American bird, in that it could not fly, although it had great powers of swimming and diving. Its native habitat was the coast and islands of the North Atlantic and from the first arrival of white men on the shores of the New World they preyed upon these birds, seeking out their eggs for food and killing the birds for their feathers. The slaughter of the defenseless birds went on for more than two centuries when it was suddenly discovered that the great auk was all but exterminated. The last specimens, a male and a female, were killed on Fire Island off the southwestern coast of Iceland in the North Atlantic on June 3, 1844, by the crew of a sloop which visited the island for a cargo of meat and feathers of other seafowl which inhabited the place. Today either mounted specimens or eggs of the great auk command huge sums whenever, which is a rare occurrence, they are offered for sale. It is estimated that there are about 70 eggs in existence today while the number of skins or mounted specimens does not exceed eighty.

The great auk and the passenger pigeon are extinct. The heath hen is nearing extinction. And not far behind it on the road to oblivion, in spite of all the efforts that have been made to preserve them, are other species. Notable among these are the majestic trumpeter swan, which is today a rarity even in zoos, and the snowy egret, which is all but extinct because its dorsal plumage in the breeding season furnishes the much-sought aigrette for the ornamentation of women's hats. And so widespread has been the destruction of our national bird, the bald eagle, that only recently a bill was introduced into congress forbidding the killing of an eagle, except when it is caught attacking live stock, in an effort to save it from the fate which has already overtaken some of our birds and is threatening so many others.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Five: Martha