As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

The Pigeon Trade

May 1867 – July 1881

The netters’ ‘stool pigeon,’ a blinded decoy made to flutter on a perch, gave the language a word. Prices rose: a dozen that had cost a quarter fetched seventy-five cents. A Chicago man wrote to the postmaster of Columbia, Tennessee, for help catching 100,000 live pigeons for his city’s trap-shooters; he had caught 93,000 the year before. Carloads from Michigan reached the shooting grounds with hundreds smothered in the coops. Wisconsin forbade shooting near a nesting in 1877, and in 1878, at Petoskey, Michigan, the trappers shipped barrels by the dozen every day until sportsmen had four of them arrested. A year later the papers wrote of the pigeon’s ‘threatened extermination,’ and by 1881 a trapper had to go to the Indian Territory, a hundred and ten miles from a railroad, to find a roost.

How the stool pigeon works

An Ohio paper explains a phrase ‘often used, and not always understood.’ Netters fasten a pigeon by its feet to a hinged treadle, its eyes sewed up, and make it flutter over scattered grain until a passing flock alights and the net is pulled over. The editor suggests the phrase might fit a Legislature at Columbus, made to flutter by a string pulled at Washington.

Urbana Union · Urbana, Ohio

Urbana Union · 29 May 1867 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

STOOL PIGEONS.

This phrase is often used, and not always understood. It is good—a good word, as Polonius says.

See moreSee less

At the season when the wild pigeons fly in great flocks, men went forth a netting, but formerly more than now. They selected a level piece of ground in an open field on which to spread the net, which is a large square net, fastened to the ground on one side, along it's whole length, and kept distended by a stick at each end, so that it may turn like the leaf of a book. And this turning is caused by the pulling of a long rope fastened to a brace in the net. Over the space in front of the net is strewed a quantity of grain. In the centre of this space is driven a short stake, on the top of which is hinged a long treadle, on one end of which a pigeon is fastened by its feet, its wings clear and its eyes sewed up. This treddle is worked by a long cord which is carried to a bush house of the netting party:—When a flock passes over, one netter pulls the treddle cord to make the stool pigeon flutter, and another netter throws up the other pigeons, with long twines fastened to their feet, and their eyes sewed up. By these arts, the passing flock alights about the stool pigeon and while the birds are picking up the grain scattered for them, a pull at the net rope which is also extended to the bush house, brings the net over them, when the managers gather round the gentle captives, squeeze their heads, taking care to spare the stool pigeon. The net is turned back and set for another flock.

The stool pigeon is quite an innocent bird used to take in others, and is made to flutter by men behind a bush pulling a long string or wire. The phrase might be applied even to a Legislature at Columbus, and the stool pigeons made to flutter by the pulling of a string at Washington.

See the clipping

Pigeons by the dozen, then and now

An Ohio paper remembers when wild pigeons cost 20 to 25 cents a dozen and could be shot with a club. Last week every one brought to town sold at 75 cents. ‘Now you have to take ’em on the fly.’

Urbana Union · Urbana, Ohio

Urbana Union · 14 April 1869 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

In the good old times of 11 to 15 years ago, one could get all the wild pigeons desired for 20 to 25 cts., a doz. Last week all brought to town were readily disposed of for 75 cts. a dozen. In the good old Times, however, you could shoot 'em with a club—they were so plentiful; now you have to take 'em on the fly. And if you do take a pigeon on the fly, it's fowl. Pigeons are selling in West Liberty for 50 cents a dozen.

See the clipping

Bogardus wins, and the pigeons run out

The Tribune reports the second day of a match for $2,500 a side at Dexter Park, where A. H. Bogardus of Illinois beats James Ward of Canada at wild pigeons, the single birds having ended in a 77-all tie in a gale. A smaller match stops when ‘the supply of pigeons gave out,’ and today Bogardus is to try to kill 500 pigeons in 645 minutes.

Chicago Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

Chicago Tribune · 15 May 1869 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

THE TRIGGER. Conclusion of the Pigeon Match Between Bogardus and Ward, for $2,500 a Side. Bogardus the Winner by Ten Birds---A Splendid Display of Skill. The Great Match To-Day Against Time and Endurance. The second and last day of the great pigeon shooting match between A. H. Bogardus, of Illinois, and James Ward, of Canada, for $2,500 a side, was begun at 11 o'clock yesterday forenoon, at the Dexter Park grounds, the attendance, owing probably to the threatening weather, being but moderate. Since the first day's shooting, on Tuesday, the changing of the direction of the wind from the southwest to the northeast necessitated the replacing of the traps, which were set so as to give the birds the wind.

See moreSee less

At the beginning of the shooting yesterday the wind blew strong and cold, but its violence at length moderated, and the larger part of the day's work was done under most favorable auspices. The shooting began at the fifty-third bird, Bogardus having killed 50 and Ward 29, with William Wachter acting as judge for Bogardus, Edwin Thomas, Jr., for Ward, and Chauncey C. Wilkinson as referee. In this, as in the other portions of the match, disputes were of rare occurrence, and the proceedings throughout were characterized by the utmost of harmony and good feeling. The wild pigeons were furnished by C. M. Hogle, Esq., and were splendid birds in every respect—fat, lively and swift of wing. The score for the first division of the match, including that of Tuesday—100 single birds each, from H and T ground traps, 21 yards rise and 80 yards boundary—was as follows: BOGARDUS—1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 0*, 0*, 0, 1, 0, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, ... WARD—1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, o, 1, 1, 1, WARD—1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1—77. *Dead and outside of boundary. Best consecutive shooting—Bogardus, 13; Ward, 13. The fact that the single rise shooting resulted in a tie, 77 each, is remarkable in view of the splendid skill of both marksmen, but if any one takes occasion to sneer at the score with its 23 ciphers in each case, he has only to remember that this part of the match was shot during a furious gale of wind—such a hurricane, in fact, as could scarcely prevail in any other locality than the level open prairie which surrounds Dexter Park. THE DOUBLE BIRD MATCH. At half past 1 o'clock, the first part of the contest having ended, the party repaired to the Transit House, where a hearty dinner was eaten, and then the guns were cleaned, and again they returned to the field to do the double bird shooting, the termination of which, no matter if by a single bird's difference—the wager being based upon the sum total of birds killed in both matches—should decide the whole contest. The double bird shooting was from II and T plunge traps, placed 10 yards apart, 21 yards rise—3 yards greater than is usually the case in double rise matches—and 100 yards boundary. The judges and referee were the same as in bird shooting was from H is usually the case in double rise matches—and 100 yards boundary. The judges and referee were the same as in the previous shooting. At the first pull of the traps Ward brought down his pair of birds handsomely, and did the same at the next pull; while Bogardus, not yet having the hang of the traps, suffered the mortification of seeing his first two pairs go whistling away entirely unhurt. Hereupon the Wardites became elated, and several bets were offered and promptly taken by the friends of the strapping Illinoisan, whose initiatory failures were considered by no means irredeemable. The subsequent shooting amply justified the opinion, Bogardus striving out with four straight pairs beautifully killed, so that the first ten pairs saw the score precisely even. From this point forth the shooting was magnificent on both sides, Ward, however, slowly falling behind, until, at the forty-sixth pair, he was eight birds in the rear, with no earthly show of winning the match unless Bogardus should miss every bird in the remaining four pairs—a possibility not for an instant to be apprehended—and even then result would be a tie. The good-natured Canadian, recognizing the fact that a victory for him was simply impossible, turned to Bogardus and pleasantly offered to "lay him" ten dollars on the remaining four pairs, which proposition was accepted as a matter of course. But the recalcitrant pigeons, like Banquo's ghost, would not "down" at Ward's shooting. He lost two birds out of the four pairs, while Bogardus brought to earth every one of his eight, winning the match, one of the most interesting on record, by eight birds. The record of the double rise match is found in the following score: Bogardus—00, 00, 11, 11, 11, 11, 10, 10, 11, 10, *Dead and outside of boundary. Best consecutive shooting—Bogardus, 6 pairs; Ward, 4 pairs. ANOTHER MATCH for $50 a side, between G. D. Hunter, of Lincoln, Ill., and Henry Conley, of Chicago, 25 single rises each, from H and T plunge traps, 21 yards rise and 80 yards boundary, was then shot. When both parties had shot at eighteen rises the supply of pigeons gave out, and the remainder of the match was necessarily postponed. The score of the shooting, so far as it went, was as follows: HUNTER—1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0—15. CONLEY—0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 0*, 1, 1, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 0—12. THE SHOOTING TO-DAY promises to be still more interesting than any of that which has been done so far. The contest is one of striking peculiarity—a man pitted against time and strength to endure. R. M. Patchin, the maker of the match, binds himself, in the sum of $1,850, to produce a man who shall kill 500 pigeons in 645 consecutive minutes, or ten hours and three-quarters, with one muzzle-loading gun; single birds on the wing; 21 yards' rise from three ground traps placed 16 feet apart; boundary, 50 yards to the right, left and front of the centre trap, and 31 yards directly back of the centre trap. A. H. Bogardus, the winner of the above contest, is to shoot the match. To kill that number of birds within the given space of time is generally set down to be simply out of the question, even by a marksman of great ability; sportsmen all agree that the thing can't be done. Mr. Patchin, in order to make himself whole in the match—the making of which, it would appear, savors more of wine than of wisdom, or perhaps more of heated argument than cool judgment—has wagered $1,050 that the 500 birds will be killed in eleven and a quarter hours, and $2,570 that it will be done in twelve hours, the last of which, and possibly the second, he hopes to win. Should Mr. Bogardus be successful, even within twelve hours, he must needs average, throughout the entire time, without allowing for rest or food, one dead bird in one minute and a fraction over twenty-six seconds, while every miss or bird that falls dead outside the boundary, will reduce even this short average time. This would be better shooting than was ever known, and the certainty of seeing perhaps the tallest trigger-pulling on record, has attracted the attention of marksmen throughout the entire country, and will bring a great crowd to Dexter Park to-day. The shooting will take place directly in front and in view of the grand stand, in which comfortable and eligible seats will be reserved for ladies who shall be in attendance. Shooting begins promptly at 7 o'clock in the morning, and will continue throughout the entire day until 7 o'clock p. m.

See the clipping

Wanted from Tennessee: 100,000 live pigeons

R. Murray Pachin of Chicago writes to the postmaster at Columbia, Tennessee, asking who nets wild pigeons there and how best to ship live birds. He means to put in 100,000 live pigeons this season ‘for amusement of first class business men in Chicago,’ having caught 93,000 last year, and he asks for a copy of the local paper.

The Columbia Herald · Columbia, Tenn.

The Columbia Herald · 8 April 1870 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CHICAGO, Ill., March 14, '70.

POST MASTER, Columbia, Tenn.:—Dear Sir—As I do not know the name of any person in your county, I beg to intrude a little upon your time. Will you have the kindness to answer me according to the best of your knowledge the following questions, as far as you can and believe when you do it that your kindness will not only be fully appreciated but fully reciprocated, and I will pay you for any time and trouble you may give in correspondency with me.

See moreSee less

1. What is the population of your place?

2. Have you any men there to your knowledge who devote any time in hunting or netting of wild pigeons? At what seasons of year are they plenty in that section of country. I see by papers that Maury County and Morgan County Tennessee have been alive with them for weeks past. I intend to put in 100,000 live pigeons this season for amusement of first class business men in Chicago, for snooting at the trap. I caught 93,000 last year, and I will probably come to your country late next fall if pigeons are plenty there and will pay some of your men well to assist me.

3. Pleas tell me the most direct route to ship live birds from there. Try and think of the name of some one in your section of country who would be likely to interest themselves in such a matter.

Do you think the pigeons have emigrated from your section of country north. Is there a paper published in your place? what is the Editors name, and name of paper.

Do you know a man by the name of Peter Ladd in your county? I saw an account or his shooting large quantities of pigeons in Maury county, I think on Leiper's Creek.

One of my agents was in Tennessee a few weeks since and he said during the winter months millions of pigeons were in Middle Tennessee.

I would be very much pleased to receive from you a copy of your paper published there and if at any time you chance to see a notice of wild pigeons in your section of country through your paper, I would be pleased to receive any and all information you can give me. In giving some attention to this you will not only confer a favor on me, but upon many of my friends in the Post Office Department, and you will never do me a favor without fair compensation. What are the terms of your paper per year?

Yours Truly, R. MURRAY PACHIN.

See the clipping

Driven out of the Pike County woods

From Pocono Summit, the New York Herald follows a flock twelve miles long. Guarded by game constables on the Beaverkill, the birds left after a heavy snow and settled in the beech woods of Pike and Monroe counties. There two bark-peelers killed hundreds with poles, and men with torches killed or wounded some 10,000 in two hours. No one asked the law to protect them, the Herald says, and when the slaughter began again on Saturday they flew west.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 17 April 1876 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

FLIGHT OF WILD PIGEONS.

A FLOCK TWELVE MILES LONG AND FIVE MILES WIDE SEEKING A NESTING PLACE—A FLIGHT ACROSS TWO STATES—SETTLING IN THE BEECH WOODS AT PIKE COUNTY, PA.—FORCED TO TAKE WING BY RUTHLESS AND INDISCRIMINATE SLAUGHTER BY HUNTERS—TEN THOUSAND KILLED IN A NIGHT WITH CLUBS.

See moreSee less

POCONO SUMMIT, Pa., April 14, 1876.

About a month ago, early one morning, the people living at Barnum's, Sullivan county, N. Y. were surprised to see the air thick with the flight of an apparently endless flock of wild pigeons, which was passing over that section to the northward. For over a quarter of an hour the flight continued in an incessant stream, obstructing all view of the sky, and giving to the surroundings that sombre appearance caused by the gathering and passing of thunder clouds. It was not known at the time how far the flock extended to the eastward, but it was subsequently learned that it reached over twelve miles in a continuous line. The birds were too high to be shot at with any degree of success, although during the flight quite a number were killed by unusually fortunate gunners. Old hunters said that the pigeons were seeking nesting places, but from the altitude of their flight it was not supposed that they would rest short of the North Woods, in John Brown's tract. Two days afterward, however, lumbermen from the head waters of the Beaverkill and the beech woods of the upper wilderness of Sullivan county, brought in the news that these sections had been taken possession of by wild pigeons in enormous numbers, and that they were preparing for the nesting season. Law and order sportsmen, acting as individuals and for fish and game societies, at once set about taking measures to

PROTECT THE BIRDS

from lawless destruction. The woods were found to be literally swarming with pigeons. Deputy game constables were stationed in considerable force in the wilderness, cabins being erected for their accommodation. They had orders to deal as summarily with all gunners or trappers seeking to disturb the birds as the laws would warrant. Unparalleled sport was anticipated in due time; but unfortunately severe weather intervened, snow falling to the depth of nearly a foot along the Beaverkill a few days after the pigeons rested. After the storm had ceased the constables noticed an unusual stir among the birds throughout the region, and about noon on the fifth day of their stay they

BEGAN TAKING FLIGHT,

and in a few hours there was not a pigeon to be found in the entire territory. They took a direction northwest, and in due time were heard of as having passed over the counties of Delaware and Broome in this State, and Susquehanna and Bradford in Pennsylvania, and took up their quarters in the beech woods of Pike and Monroe counties.

The beech woods of these counties comprise thousands of acres of almost primitive wilderness, they being invaded only by lumbermen, bark peelers and sportsmen. In their fastnesses the black bear roams at will and the wild deer finds security from hunter and hound. On Friday last Clinton Waters and Isaac Bennett, two bark-peelers, were in the depths of the beech woods, about five miles from this station, selecting a place to build a cabin for the ensuing bark-peeling season. The sun was shining brightly, not a cloud being in the sky, when suddenly the sun was hidden as if by a dark cloud, and a noise like that produced by a gale of wind or the roll of distant thunder broke on their ears. Simultaneously the woods commenced filling with wild pigeons. Tree after tree was filled with the rapidity of lightning, and still the air was black with one great moving mass of birds as far as the eye could reach.

SLAUGHTER OF THE BIRDS.

After the first excitement attending the appearance of the pigeons had passed off and it was apparent that the great body had found resting places, Walters and Bennett, true to the instinct of the human race, began to wage war against the birds. They were possessed of no guns, but taking each a long pole, they swooped about them among the pigeons, right and left. With every blow dozens of the birds fell killed and maimed to the ground. The men slew hundreds in this way. The pigeons in a tree that they attacked would fly at the first assault, only to seek the nearest resting place. This ruthless destruction of the pigeons was kept up by the two men until they were actually glutted with killing, when they picked up fifty of the dead birds and started for this place, leaving the ground strewn with others, dead, dying and wounded.

For the purpose of seeing how far the woods were occupied by the pigeons they walked for five miles through the forest. As far as they could see on either side the birds occupied the trees, and when they stopped in their walk to turn off to the Summit, they could not discover the end of the flock. When they brought the news of the great pigeon roost to this place the excitement was great among the lumbermen and others, and dozens of men started out to kill them at night on the roost. They were armed with guns and clubs. Each man carried a lantern or torch made of pine knots. On reaching the roost a continuous slaughter was kept up for two hours. The birds, alarmed by the guns and lights, flew blindly about among the trees, some dashing against the lanterns and singeing themselves in the torches. The noise made by the disturbed pigeons flying from their roosts was terrific. It is estimated that 10,000 were killed and wounded, the most of which were left on the ground. The party returned loaded down with birds, which were distributed throughout the neighborhood.

No one took interest enough in the pigeons to ask the protection of the law for them, and on Saturday the same slaughter was commenced again. The birds had chosen the beech woods as their nesting place, but the determined cruelty and barbarity of the adjacent inhabitants resulted in their again taking flight and seeking other fields. They rose from the woods about nine o'clock Saturday morning, and in a short time all had disappeared. They took a course directly west, flying very high, and have settled probably in the wilderness of Western Pennsylvania. Old and experienced hunters say that this was the largest flight of wild pigeons ever known in this region. The flock was certainly twelve miles long and four or five wide.

See the clipping

Two carloads a day through Detroit

A Cheboygan paper reports fifty-four thousand wild pigeons shipped from Shelby, in Oceana county, on the 17th, which ‘looks as if somebody had disregarded the law’ against shooting them within five miles of a roost. North of Grand Haven, where the woods are swarming, some parties are killing them wholesale for Boston, New York and the seaboard, and two carloads of ‘defunct doves’ pass through Detroit daily.

Northern Tribune · Cheboygan, Mich.

Northern Tribune · 29 April 1876 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Fifty-four thousand wild pigeons were shipped from Shelby, Oceana county on the 17th, which looks as if somebody had disregarded the law about shooting those birds within five miles of a "roost!"

The woods north of Grand Haven are swarming with pigeons, and some parties are killing them by wholesale, and shipping them to Boston, New York, and other cities on the seaboard, two carloads of defunct doves pass through Detroit daily.

See the clipping

Six hundred smothered in the coops

Two carloads of wild pigeons reach Dexter Park from Michigan for the shooting clubs, packed so tightly that Agent McDonald of the Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals finds 600 smothered on arrival, with as many more expected to die. Sorting the dead from the healthy took two days. The Tribune’s only comment: ‘This sort of treatment of the birds might be improved upon.’

Chicago Daily Tribune · Chicago, Ill.

Chicago Daily Tribune · 15 July 1876 · page 10 · transcribed from the page image

During the early part of this week two carloads of wild pigeons came to Dexter Park from Michigan, consigned to the shooting-clubs. The birds were confined so closely in the coops that 600 were found smothered to death by Agent McDonald, of the Society for Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, upon their arrival here, and as many more will die. It took two days to take the dead birds out of the coops and sort out the healthy ones. This sort of treatment of the birds might be improved upon.

See the clipping

Wisconsin guards the nestings

A Kenosha paper prints Wisconsin’s new act forbidding anyone to kill or disturb wild pigeons within three miles of a nesting, from the start of brooding until the last hatching. The fine is twenty to fifty dollars an offense, with jail until it is paid, half the fine goes to whoever made the complaint, and justices of the peace may try the cases.

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis. · and 3 other papers

The Kenosha Telegraph · 8 March 1877 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

CHAPTER 24.

AN ACT to prevent the killing or disturbing of wild pigeons while on their brooding grounds.

See moreSee less

The people of the State of Wisconsin, represented in Senate and Assembly, do enact as follows:

SECTION 1. It shall be unlawful for any person or persons to use any gun or guns or fire arms or in any manner to maim, kill, destroy or disturb any wild pigeon or pigeons at or within three miles of the place or places where they are gathered for the purpose of brooding their young, known as pigeon nestings. Nor shall any person or persons fire at or attempt to kill or destroy any such wild pigeon or pigeons, or disturb their nests within said limits anywhere within this State, at any time from the beginning of such nesting or brooding until the last hatching of such birds, and every person offending against the provisions of this section shall be punished by a fine of not more than fifty dollars nor less then twenty dollars for each and every offense, together with the costs of suit, and shall be imprisoned in the county jail of the county wherein such offense was committed until such fine and costs are fully paid, or until discharged according to law; and in all convictions under this act one-half of all fines shall be paid over by the Justice of the Peace before whom such trial is brought, to the person who shall have made the complaint in such case.

SEC. 2. Justices of the Peace shall have jurisdiction to hear, try and determine all cases arising under the provisions of this act; provided, the defendant shall not be deprived of a jury trial nor of the right of appeal as in other cases.

SEC. 3. This act shall take effect and be in force from and after its passage and publication.

Approved Feb. 20, 1877.

[Published March 1, 1877.]

See the clipping

Three and a half tons from Forest County

A Pennsylvania paper reports that netting wild pigeons is ‘an immense business in Forest county,’ with at least five hundred people at it in one township, most clearing ten dollars a day. On one day last week three and a half tons of pigeons went over the Allegheny Valley railroad to game dealers in New York.

The Cambria Freeman · Ebensburg, Pa.

The Cambria Freeman · 12 April 1878 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Catching wild pigeons with nets is an immense business in Forest county, and at least five hundred persons are engaged at it in one township, most of them clearing ten dollars a day. It is stated that on one day last week three and a half tons of pigeons were sent over the river division of the Allegheny Valley railroad, consigned to dealers in game in New York city.

See the clipping

Petoskey’s great industry

At Petoskey, Michigan, every available man and team is catching and shipping pigeons: fifty to sixty barrels a day, 35 dozen to the barrel, from close to 200 trappers paid 35 cents a dozen. One haul of one net took 111 dozen.

The Weekly Oskaloosa Herald · Oskaloosa, Iowa

The Weekly Oskaloosa Herald · 25 April 1878 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

The pigeon business is just now the great industry at Petoskey, Michigan. Pigeons are there in uncounted millions and all the available men and teams are engaged in catching and shipping them. From fifty to sixty barrels per day are shipped, each barrel containg 35 dozen. Trappers are paid 35 cents per dozen, and one man with net will take from fifty to sixty dozen per day. One haul of a net the other day produced 111 dozen. There are not far from 200 trappers there.

See the clipping

Four trappers arrested at the nesting

In the same day’s papers, the Saginaw and Bay City Game Protection Club has four people arrested for killing pigeons in the nesting, fifteen miles from Petoskey. The trappers begin moving out to the legal limits, and the club means to enforce the law ‘against the wholesale slaughterers of pigeons.’

The Lake County Star · Chase, Mich.

The Lake County Star · 25 April 1878 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Representatives of the Saginaw and Bay City Game Protection Club have caused the arrest of four persons for killing pigeons in nesting. The arrest was made 15 miles from Petoskey by Sheriff Ingersoll of Emmet county, and has caused intense excitement. Pigeon trappers are taking warning and are moving to the proper limits. The sportsmen propose to enforce the law against the wholesale slaughterers of pigeons.

See the clipping

Express charges at Petoskey: $2,000

In June a Wisconsin paper finds Petoskey ‘a lively little place’ while business everywhere else is dull, and the pigeon catchers are the reason. In seven weeks the express charges on birds shipped from the end of the line there came, it was reported, to $2,000.

The Kenosha Telegraph · Kenosha, Wis.

The Kenosha Telegraph · 13 June 1878 · page 4 · transcribed from the page image

Petoskey is a lively little place, being an exception to the general dullness prevailing elsewhere. It is made lively by the shipping of pigeons by the pigeon catchers in Michigan. It is a little place in the woods near the north end of Lake Michigan and is the terminus of a railroad running from Detroit to the Lake. The Express charges on pigeons shipped at Petosky in seven weeks amounted—so reported—to $2,000.

See the clipping

Sportsmen ask for a closed season

Sporting papers are ‘full of complaints’ about the netters and trappers at the Michigan nestings, and a Chicago paper suggests that every state where the pigeon breeds forbid killing it for three years, with the marsh blackbird as a stand-in. The same week, 14,000 pigeons are caged at Peoria for the Illinois sportsmen’s annual shoot.

Essex County Herald · Guildhall, Vt. · and 1 other paper

Essex County Herald · 17 October 1879 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Threatened Extermination of the Wild Pigeon. Sportsmen are waking up to the fact that the indiscriminate and wholesale slaughter of pigeons is rapidly thinning out the species. Sporting papers are full of complaints about the manner in which netters and trappers capture and kill the birds at their nestings in Michigan and elsewhere. It is suggested that a law be passed by all States in which the pigeon brings forth its young, prohibiting the killing or trapping of the birds for three years. It is claimed that this would give the flocks a chance to recuperate to such an extent that similar laws would not have to be passed for years afterward.

See moreSee less

As a substitute for the pigeon during the years that pigeon-destroying is barred, the marsh blackbird is suggested. This bird is very abundant on the Calumet, Kankakee, and Illinois rivers. It is claimed that they are great corn and grain destroyers, and that they could easily be spared. To show the way in which sportsmen themselves massacre pigeons, 14,000 birds have recently been caged for slaughter at Peoria. The Illinois State Sportsman's Association is holding its great annual shoot there this week.—Chicago Journal.

See the clipping

The sheriff scatters the shooters

The Sheriff of Warren county and a posse of six or eight make ‘a scatterment’ among the pigeon shooters on Minister creek near Balltown, after the much-shot-at birds moved their roost over the county line. The Tionesta paper prints the game law: twenty dollars for firing near a nesting, ten dollars a bird for netting in the nesting season. Most people it talks to think the law ‘an outrage.’

The Forest Republican · Tionesta, Pa.

The Forest Republican · 24 March 1880 · page 5 · transcribed from the page image

—The Sheriff of Warren county, with a posse of six or eight men made a scatterment among the pigeon shooters on Minister creek, in the vicinity of Balltown, on Monday last. It seems the pigeons, on account of being shot at so much, kept moving their roosting place until they finally got over the line, into Warren county, whereupon the bombarding ceased as above stated. For the benefit of those who may not understand the law on this subject fully, we copy below Section 15, of the game laws, which gives all that relates to the capturing of pigeons.

See moreSee less

Nearly every one with whom we have conversed on the subject seems to think the law is an outrage, and ought to be repealed, excepting that portion which relates to shooting in the roost or nesting grounds. Following is the section referred to: "No person shall kill, catch or discharge any fire-arms at any wild pigeon while on its nesting ground, or break up or in any manner disturb such nesting ground or the birds therein, or discharge any fire arms within one-fourth of a mile of such nesting place of any wild pigeon or pigeons within their roostings, under a penalty of twenty dollars: Provided, That no person except citizens of this commonwealth shall trap or catch wild pigeons with nets in any of the counties of this commonwealth, unless he shall have first taken out a license from the county treasurer, of the county in which said pigeons are found, for which license he shall pay the sum of fifty dollars for the use of said county, under penalty of one hundred dollars: And provided further, That no person shall at any time or place within this state kill or take any wild pigeon with any net, trap or snare, nor set any such net, trap or snare for the purpose of taking or killing any of said pigeons during the nesting season, nor shall any person sell or expose for sale any of the said pigeons after the same shall have been so taken or killed, under a penalty of ten dollars for each bird so taken."

See the clipping

Pigeons from the Indian Territory for Coney Island

The Daily Astorian reports a carload of 8,500 live pigeons reaching Jersey City, bound for a shooting tournament at Coney Island. Their trapper, Mr. Thomas, says this year’s roost was in the Indian Territory, 110 miles from the nearest railroad station, and describes the nets, the stool pigeon and the Tom and hen flights. The place is so remote, he says, that the increase is ‘larger than ever known before.’

The Daily Astorian · Astoria, Oregon · and 2 other papers

The Daily Astorian · 1 July 1881 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

WILD PIGEONS.

AN IMMENSE ROOST IN THE INDIAN TERRITORY.

See moreSee less

PIGEONS FOR CONEY ISLAND--HOW THEY WERE TRAPPED AND TRANSPORTED.

One night last week a car arrived at Jersey city from the Indian territory, containing 8,500 wild pigeons, the first installment of 20,000 contracted as supply to the New York State sportsmens association. The pigeons were in pens like low, close sheds. An incline plane of slatted framework in each pen furnishes the pigeons with a roost. A slight noise on the outside of a pen produces a loud whir on the inside. When the trap door of a pen was cautiously opened to allow the reporter to peer inside, the twitter and rustle made up a strong volume of sound. "They make a good deal of noise," said Mr. Thomas, "but it is nothing to the din at the pigeon roost,

Where These Were Trapped.

I have heard the cackling of the pigeons, as they were settling on their nests in the evening, fully a mile away. Mr. Thomas makes a business of trapping pigeons for field sport. He will get four more car loads from the Indian territory, making a total of 40,000 pigeons "The business will not be a profitable one this year," he said, "because we have to go so far to get them. Heretofore the pigeons have roosted in Pennsylvania or Michigan. But this year, owing to the late, cold spring, they did not come as far north as usual, and they made a roost in Pottawattomie reservation of the Indian territory, one hundred and ten miles from the nearest railroad station. I had to transport all my lumber and supplies from Atoka, and the pigeons had to be hauled there for shipment. At one time I had fifteen wagons on the road. It took a wagon about three days to make the roost to Atoka. The roost is the largest I have ever seen. The country there is thickly grown over with what thay call post oak timber, from the fact, I suppose, that tree trunks are just about post size. The acorns are so abundant that it is a

Splendid Feeding Ground

For them. I went into the roost for about ten miles without finding any signs of an end. Every tree was thick with pigeons, the branches bending down with their weight. When the birds have been coming home from the feeding grounds in the evening I have seen a stream about a mile broad flow through the air for two hours, thick enough to hide the sun, and making a noise like thunder. I should judge the roost to be about twenty miles long and fifteen broad. There has been little or no shooting, and that has been a good thing for us, as shooting makes the birds scary and harder to trap. There is plenty of deer and turkeys on the reservation, and the Pottawattomies do not care for pigeons, so they do not hunt in the roost. The Indans are very friendly. Men go about with poles punching the squabs out of their nests. They are packed in barrels with ice, and sent to all the large cities as far north as Boston. My business was altogether with the live pigeons, which we caught in nets." Mr. Thomas explained the methods of the trappers. The nets used will cover a space of forty feet by thirty. One end of the net is fastened to a rope, which is drawn taut, so that when let go

The Net Is Thrown Out like an Arrow.

Falling upon the pigeons that have gathered in front of it. The pigeons are caught on their feeding grounds or water beds. When a good ground is located the nets are set, and the trapper puts himself in a hut of boughs at one end of the net line. When a flock of pigeons is seen coming, a pigeon is thrown up in the air to attract the attention of the flock, the bird being pulled down again with a string. This bird is called the flyer. Another decoy bird called the stool pigeon is made use of at the same time. He is tied to a perch on the free end of a strip of iron band about four feet long. As the flock approaches a string is pulled, which makes the spring bounce him up and down, and he flaps his wings to keep his balance. He presents the appearance to the approaching flock of a bird hovering over a feeding ground, and they settle down around him. "I once saw sixty-seven dozen caught at one cast of the net," said Mr. Thomas, "but thirty or forty dozen is an average big catch. Sometimes there will be only a dozen or so. I have seen the net lifted up on the wings of the pigeons until it

Bellied Out Like a Balloon.

A number of pigeons toward the edge are apt to get out, but the men are quick, and work around the edges, stowing the birds in crates as fast as they get them out, and rolling the net up as as they work in, until they have got all the pigeons, when the net is set again for another cast. The pigeons are caught on water beds as well as on feeding grounds. A water bed is made by filling an excavation with water. The pigeons on their way home from feeding will stop to drink, and are caught under the nets. Sometimes salt is used. "This season," said Mr. Thomas, "the acorns were so plentiful that the birds did not have to search for feeding grounds and did not decoy well. The water beds did not draw well, either, as they had the Canada river, the water of which is alkalinine, so that salt also had no attractions for them. We caught the most on gravel beds along the river as they would settle down for stones to put in their crops to grind up the acorns." Pigeons are methodical in their habits in these great roosts. Early in the morning the Tom flight occurs. This is composed of the male birds on their way to the feeding grounds. When they have fed and drank, they return to the nests, and the female birds go to feed. The hen flight takes place between 8 and 9 o'clock. In the afternoon there is another Tom flight, and towards the evening another hen flight. The

Birds Stop for Gravel or Water

On their way home from feeding. The crates in which the birds are put when caught are simply large flat coops. The netters are spread over an area of twelve or fourteen miles. Every evening the teams make a round and collect all the crates. It is now necessary to get the birds on their feed, or else they will die. They are put in pens and given corn to eat, with plenty of water to drink. For several days after they are captured they will hardly eat at all, and it is only after they have become accustomed to the change that they can be again crated and shipped. Two men travel in the car, and the pigeons are regularly fed and watered. The car load which arrived on Saturday was shipped on Thursday morning, and the birds were fed and watered four times while en route. Pigeons nest four times a season, having one egg to a nest. "One result of the inaccessible nature of the locality of this years roost," said Mr. Thomas, "is that the increase is larger than ever known before. The number of squabs killed and pigeons netted is insignificant in comparison with the number hatched out. There are millions of them there. These wild pigeons are smaller than the domestic pigeon. Their plumage is a mixture of slate and gray. They have long tail feathers, and are birds of far quicker and stronger flight than ordinary pigeons. The pigeons now penned near Jersey city will be used in the pigeon shooting tournament at Coney island.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Countless