As the Papers Told It

The Passenger Pigeon · As the Papers Told It

Act Four

A Reward for a Nest

July 1906 – July 1913

John Burroughs believed the men in the Catskills who said they had seen pigeons, and Pennsylvania’s game secretary had a letter about three hundred nesting in Clearfield County. In 1910 the ornithologists offered $3,000 for nests, and a Canadian claimed a prize. By 1911 the papers knew of one passenger pigeon for certain, a female in the Cincinnati zoo, and Pennsylvania’s chief game protector said there were no others anywhere. Still, boy scouts in Missouri guarded a nest, a lone bird was said to summer in a Chicago park, and in 1913 a Pittsburgh man said he had found three hundred.

Doves do not nest together

Secretary Kalbfus of the Pennsylvania game commission has a letter from H. H. Rishel of Westover, Clearfield county, about a flock of at least three hundred nesting near him for two seasons. Kalbfus suspected doves, but Rishel says they nest together, and doves do not. The paper recalls a roost near Sheffield, Warren county, thirty years ago, and the Cornplanter Indians who ‘made a good living’ netting the birds.

Montour American · Danville, Pa.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 12 days later. CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Dakota Farmers' Leader, 22 June 1906, The Sun, 23 June 1906, Montour American, 5 July 1906.

Wrong

Montour American · 12 July 1906 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

KALBFUS BELIEVES PIGEON STORY

A story was sent out from Poughkeepsie, N. Y., last week to the effect that John Burroughs, the author-naturalist, has returned from a trip to Sullivan county, N. Y., where he investigated reports that wild pigeons had been recently in that locality, with the impression that he had every reason to believe that the men who saw the birds were telling the truth, as they were familiar with the passenger pigeon in the olden days when there were flocks of millions in this country.

See moreSee less

Secretary Kalbfus, of the State game commission, was asked if he had any information concerning wild pigeons in this State, and said he had received reports of some being seen, but had not yet investigated. Several months ago Secretary Kalbfus received a letter from H. H. Rishel, of Westover, Clearfield county, in which he stated that there had been nesting for two seasons past a large flock of wild pigeons within a mile of where he lives, and he was confident there were at least three hundred in the flock.

Dr. Kalbfus asked for further information concerning these birds, thinking perhaps that they might be doves, and Mr. Rishel told him that they nested together, which to the game commissioner is an indication that they were really wild pigeons, as doves do not nest together, and it was a peculiarity of the wild or passenger pigeons of thirty years ago to nest in large flocks. There can scarely be any mistake about these being wild pigeons, and it leads to the belief that they are coming back to this State.

Thirty years ago there was a large wild pigeon roost in the vicinity of Sheffield, Warren county, and the stories told of their numbers seem almost incredible. When the birds set out to feed in the morning and returned to the roost at night they were in such numbers as to obscure the sun, and passing over a town, flying low, they resembled a huge cloud. Millions of them were killed and sent to the larger cities, while thousands were trapped and used at shooting matches.

The Cornplanter Indians in the northern part of this State and Southern New York netted myriads of the birds and made a good living from their sale. If the wild pigeon returns to this State a stringent law will be passed to prevent its extermination.

See the clipping

Half a pint of mast apiece

An Idaho paper reports that John Burroughs has followed up and, ‘so far as may be,’ confirmed sightings in the Catskills; a growing colony may live northwest of Kingston. It cites W. B. Mershon’s book: one dealer shipped one hundred and seventy-five thousand live birds from a single nesting. And it gives Alexander Wilson’s arithmetic: a column of over two billion birds, each eating half a pint of mast a day.

The Kendrick Gazette · Kendrick, Idaho · and 3 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Kendrick Gazette · 1 November 1907 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

PASSENGER-PIGEONS.

From time to time for several years reports have come from New York State, and especially from the Catskill region, that flocks of genuine passenger-pigeons had been seen there. John Burroughs, the naturalist, has followed up and, so far as may be, confirmed these reports, until it seems probable that in the mountainous district northwest of Kingston there actually exists an increasing colony of birds of a species supposed to have become extinct.

See moreSee less

In the natural history of America there is no more remarkable story than that of these beautiful birds which formerly frequented the entire central part of the continent in unbelieveable numbers. Novelists and story-writers have frequently referred to the old-time "pigeon shoots," and pigeon pie was a favorite dish of our grandfathers and even of our fathers. The birds were lessened in number by indiscriminate slaughter for fifty years, a single dealer, says W. B. Mershon in his book on the pigeons, having shipped one hundred and seventy-five thousand live birds to market from a single nesting one spring, besides thousands of barrels of dead birds. This formed but a small part of the catch at that nesting.

Probably no more remarkable account is given by any naturalist than that of Alexander Wilson, the earliest of American ornithologists, who visited in Kentucky a nesting-place forty miles long and several miles wide, in which every tree held from one to one hundred nests, and many trees were broken down and every growing thing was killed by the roosting birds.

"About one o'clock," says Wilson, "the pigeons, which I had observed the greater part of the morning flying northerly, began to return in such immense numbers as I never before had witnessed. . Coming to an opening by the side of a creek where I had a more uninterrupted view, I was astonished at their appearance. They were flying with great steadiness and rapidity at a height beyond gun-shot, several strata deep, and so close together that, could shot have reached them, one discharge could not have failed of bringing down several individuals.

"From right to left as far as the eye could reach, the breadth of this vast procession extended, seeming everywhere equally crowded.

"Curious to determine how long this appearance would continue, I took out my watch to note the time and sat down to observe them. It was then half past one. I sat for more than an hour, but instead of a diminution of this prodigious procession, it seemed rather to increase in both numbers and rapidity; and being anxious to reach Frankfort before night, I rose and went on.

"About four in the afternoon I crossed the Kentucky river at the town of Frankfort, at which time the living torrent above my head seemed as numerous and extensive as ever. Long after this I observed them in large bodies until six o'clock that evening.

"I have taken from the crop of a single wild pigeon a good handful of the kernels of beechnuts, acorns and chestnuts. To form a rough estimate of the daily consumption of one of these immense flocks, let us first attempt to calculate the numbers of that at Frankfort. If we suppose this column to have been a mile in breadth, and I believe it to have been much more,—and that it moved at the rate of a mile a minute, for hours, the time it continued passing would make its whole length two hundred and forty miles.

"Again, supposing each square yard of the moving body comprehended three pigeons, the square yards in the whole space multiplied by three would give two billion, two hundred and thirty million, two hundred and seventy-two thousand birds, a number probably far below the actual number.

"Computing each of these to consume half a pint of mast daily, the whole quantity at this rate would equal seventeen million, four hundred and twenty-four thousand bushels of mast a day.

"Heaven has wisely given these birds rapidity of flight and a disposition to range over vast uncultivated tracts. Otherwise they must have perished in the districts where they resided, or devoured up the whole product of agriculture as well as the products of the forests."

See the clipping

$3,000 for a nest

The American Ornithologists’ Union offers $3,000 in prizes for the nests of the passenger pigeon, with every find to be reported to Dr. C. F. Hodge of Clark University. In Massachusetts, the paper recalls, people with poles and nets once killed fifty and sixty at a time.

The McCook Tribune · McCook, Neb. · and 1 other paper

The McCook Tribune · 14 April 1910 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

REWARD FOR WILD PIGEONS.

Ornithologists Offer $3,000 For the Discovery of Their Nests.

See moreSee less

Three thousand dollars in prizes is offered by the American Ornithologists' union for the discovery of nests of the passenger pigeon, or wild pigeon. Dr. C. F. Hodge of Clark university, Worcester, has charge of the reward and all finds must be reported to him.

This species of pigeon was once thick in Massachusetts, and people armed with poles and nets often would kill and gather in fifty and sixty at once, so closely did they roost. The slaughter assumed such proportions that the pigeons are almost extinct today.

A full grown wild pigeon is about fifteen inches long from its bill to the end of its tail. The male is blue gray above and on the head and reddish beneath. The female is of a duller color, inclining toward brown. The birds nest during April and May.

See the clipping

A Canadian claims the reward

Two months later Dr. Hodge names the probable winner of a $1,000 prize for the first nest: C. H. Patience, of a town in Ontario that Hodge will not name, who has wired that he found one ‘with a female sitting on it.’ Hodge says he will go at once to see it.

The River Press · Fort Benton, Mont. · and 2 other papers

The River Press · 8 June 1910 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

FINDER OF WILD PIGEON NEST

Canadian Claims $1,000 Reward Offered by Naturalists.

See moreSee less

Dr. Clifton H. Hodge of Clark university announced the other day that the probable winner of a $1,000 reward offered for the discovery of the first nest of North American or passenger pigeons in America is C. H. Patience of a town in Ontario, Canada. Dr. Hodge would not reveal the name of the town.

A telegram has been received from Mr. Patience stating that he had discovered a nest, with a female sitting on it, and Dr. Hodge stated that he would immediately go to Ontario to investigate the claim.

The reward is part of a subscription of $3,800 by naturalists of the United States and Canada to be used in the work of preventing the extinction of the bird. This particular breed of pigeon was numerous in America up to the early eighties, but since then has been gradually dying out until now the species is very rare.

See the clipping

The last one, at the Cincinnati zoo

A Wyoming paper carries the news from Cincinnati: a female passenger pigeon in the zoo there, eighteen years old, her mate dead at twenty-four, is all that remains of the species. A $1,500 offer for a nest has brought not one claimant, and the Audubon societies now appeal for funds to save the upland plover and two terns.

The Wheatland World · Wheatland, Wyo. · and 11 other papers

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Wheatland World · 13 January 1911 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

LONE PIGEON LEFT

One Ohio Bird Survives Breed of Several Billions.

See moreSee less

Ending Her Days in the Cincinnati Zoological Garden Is All That Remains of a Species Once Numerous.

Cincinnati, O. — One solitary passenger pigeon, ending her life at the Zoological garden in Cincinnati, is today all that remains of an American species that early in the last century swarmed over the continent in flocks numbering billions. With the death of this sole survivor of a bird tribe, whose nesting places often covered hundreds of square miles, there will soon disappear the last race of the wild pigeons that have been slaughtered by the million by men who fed their hogs upon the carcasses they could not carry away. Though it is too late to save this species, special efforts are now being made by the Audubon workers to bring about the restoration of other birds of economic value that must otherwise share the same fate.

For many months systematic search has been made throughout the continent by officials of the Audubon association for relics of the once prolific passenger pigeon. Members of the organization headed by Prof. C. F. Hedge of Clark university have made a standing offer of $1,500 to anyone discovering a nest of this species; but, though thousands have been trying eagerly for the prize, not one single claimant has appeared. In response to a recent inquiry by T. Gilbert Pearson, secretary of the National Association of Audubon societies, the authorities of the Cincinnati Zoo have just furnished the last chapter in the tragic tale of these butchered birds. The "Last of the Passenger Pigeons" is a female, eighteen years old, whose mate died recently without issue at the age of twenty-four.

Passenger or Wild Pigeon.

As late as 1877 what is now known to have been the last nesting place of these wild birds was found in the state of Michigan, where their nests thickly covered the trees over an area 28 miles long and four miles wide. Residents of New York declare that in 1850 they flocked over Manhattan Island in such numbers that they obscured the sun and that ships loaded in bulk with the bodies of these birds lay at the wharves selling them at a cent apiece. Audubon is quoted as observing a roosting place of wild pigeons in Kentucky early in the last century that extended 40 miles and was three miles in width. On its edges men with guns, nets, clubs and torches slaughtered the roosting birds, each often bagging 500 in one day.

Declaring that practically all the gulls and terns in America today have survived solely through the work of protection and restoration at their reservations, leaders of the National Association of Audubon societies are now appealing to the people of this country to support the work of preserving dying species of native birds which they have already begun. The Upland Plover, Cabot's Tern and the Least Tern, they assert, can now be saved to the nation by quick emergency measures for which special funds are to be raised.

See the clipping

Pennsylvania says: extinct

Pennsylvania’s chief game protector, Joseph Kalbfus, says the passenger pigeon is extinct, ‘not only in Pennsylvania, but throughout the world.’ Hodge has run down several hundred reports, and every bird proved to be a turtle dove or some other species. Kalbfus’s own theory begins in 1879, when, he writes, sailors reported sailing for hours through floating dead pigeons.

Belding Banner · Belding, Mich. · and 8 other papers

Belding Banner · 2 February 1911 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

PIGEON IS EXTINCT

So Declares Game Commissioner of Pennsylvania.

See moreSee less

Dr. Kalbfus Asserts That Those Who Claim to Have Seen Wild Birds Are Merely Careless Observers.

Harrisburg, Pa.—To the ever recurrent question, "Are there any wild pigeons in Pennsylvania?" Chief Game Protector Joseph Kalbfus once more answers an emphatic "no."

Dr. Kalbfus has been investigating this subject on his own hook, and in co-operation with other seekers after knowledge for years, but feels that the wild pigeon, or passenger pigeon, is extinct, not only in Pennsylvania, but throughout the world, notwithstanding reports to the contrary.

The cause for the disappearance of this bird, which existed in flocks of millions a generation ago, can only be conjectured, but it seems that other causes beside wanton destruction by man are found. Dr. Kalbfus sums up the general situation in a letter on the subject, which he wrote to a group of local sportsmen who asked him for information on the subject. He wrote:

"So many inquiries are coming to me regarding the presence of wild pigeons in the United States that I think it best to write you this short letter explanatory of our understanding of this matter. For some years past certain individuals have been attempting to collect data that would prove the presence of the wild pigeon somewhere in the United States or in the world.

"In the Forest and Stream issue of September 3 will be found an article by C. F. Hodge, who is connected with the Clark university, Worcester, Mass., who has been for some years past investigating this matter. This gentleman writes that he has received several hundred communications relative to this matter, but that up to this time he has failed to prove the presence of a passenger pigeon anywhere in the United States.

"Many people write him that they are certain of their identification, that they know what wild pigeons are and are sure the birds are passenger pigeons. Investigation has invariably proved them to be turtle doves or the band tail pigeon, or some bird other than our passenger pigeon. Mr. Hodge says in concluding his article that while his investigation is not encouraging, it does not prove beyond the question of a doubt that passenger pigeons may not yet be found and he proposes to continue his investigation for another year. This, it seems to me, covers the ground absolutely, no difference what reports may be printed in the newspapers; no single instance of the existence in the United States of the presence of the wild pigeon has been proved.

Many reasons for the disappearance of the pigeon have been made; the one that seems to be the most plausible to me is that during the time when these birds were everywhere, there was a horde of predatory birds and animals living upon them, following them up and down in their passage through the country. For some reason during the year 1879 vast numbers of these birds were destroyed either by geese or by being blown to sea in the Pacific, sailors reporting that they sailed for many hours through floating dead pigeons. This, it seems to me, depleted the supply to such an extent that those remaining were not able to withstand the attacks of their many enemies and gradually fell a prey to those enemies until they became extinct."

See the clipping

Boy scouts guard a nest

Near Independence, Missouri, boy scouts are guarding what is believed to be a pair of passenger pigeons and their nest, watched only through field glasses for fear of frightening them. If they are real, ornithologists say, the birds are worth at least $1,000 apiece; here they once sold for as little as 50 cents a barrel.

Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · and 4 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Gilpin Observer · 13 July 1911 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

NEST OF PASSENGER PIGEONS

Pair of Birds of Race Almost Extinct Raising Young—Specimens Worth $1,000 Apiece.

See moreSee less

Independence, Mo.—What is believed to be a pair of passenger pigeons, supposed to be almost extinct in this country, where once there were millions of them, has been found in the deep woods east of Independence, and members of the Independence patrol of boy scouts are guarding the nest until the young are hatched. After that, probably, the birds will be taken and efforts made to propagate them under conditions as nearly as possible in their wild state.

The only other known survivors of the once vast flocks of these pigeons are, or were until recently, in the zoological gardens at Cincinnati, O.

Ornithologists here say that if the birds now being guarded are real passenger pigeons they are worth at least $1,000 apiece. For fear of frightening them away, no effort has been made to observe them closely, but from what the ornithologists have been able to see of them with field glasses they have every characteristic of the true passenger pigeon. Their color is a dark, slaty blue on top, fading off to a soft brownish tinge underneath.

The pasenger pigeons once were so plentiful in this locality that they could be killed with clubs, and during their migrations so many of them were killed that they sold as low as 50 cents a barrel.

See the clipping

A wild pigeon in Jackson Park?

At 4:30 in the morning Charles E. Hayden, an old-time sportsman, watches what he is sure is a male wild pigeon in Chicago’s Jackson Park for an hour, and says ‘there was no mistake about it.’ Scientists doubted an earlier sighting there by a high school teacher, but a passing attorney who knows the mourning dove agrees with Hayden.

Gilpin Observer · Central City, Colo. · and 5 other papers

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later.

Wrong

Gilpin Observer · 31 August 1911 · page 7 · transcribed from the page image

LONELY WILD PIGEON

Only Survivor of Species Believed to Be in Chicago.

See moreSee less

Reward of $500 Offered for Any Pair, and Public Is Warned: "Don't Kill This One If You Find It."

Chicago.—Is there a wild pigeon in Jackson Park? Is an individual bird of a species once numbered by the millions, but now supposed to be extinct, making Chicago its summer home and thereby reviving hope that somewhere there are others and that the pigeons one day may come back to their own?

The story of the reappearance of the bird has much to give it the color of truth. Most scientists are convinced that the wild pigeon, ectopistes migratorius they call it, has gone never to return. The other day, however, Charles E. Hayden, an old-time sportsman and bird student, told Ruthven Deane, president of the Illinois Audubon society, that he had seen a wild pigeon in Jackson Park and that "there was no mistake about it."

About three weeks ago a high school teacher, a man who has made ornithology a study, reported that he had seen a wild pigeon in Jackson Park. The discovery was recorded in the papers, but the scientists who had run down hundreds of reports of this kind, only to find a mistake had been made, were skeptical to the point of disbelief.

Now comes Mr. Hayden, who knew the pigeon when its tribe numbered millions, to make positive statement that a fine male bird of a supposedly extinct race was under close observation by him in Jackson Park for an hour.

It was 4:30 o'clock in the morning when Mr. Hayden went "bird studying" in Jackson Park. He was astounded when he saw the pigeon. He knew the tribe was supposed to be extinct, and that a reward of $500 had been offered for authentic knowledge of the existence of a single nesting pair. He made allowance for deceptive lights and shadows, conditions which might exaggerate the common mourning dove to the size and semblance of its bigger relative, and then was convinced that the stranger was the wild pigeon which he had known in youth.

There was another early morning stroller in Jackson Park, Attorney F. A. Pennington, and Mr. Hayden called him over to see the bird. Mr. Pennington pronounced the bird a wild pigeon. He is familiar with the bird only from description and picture, but he knows the mourning dove, the only species with which the pigeon is likely to be confused, and he knows it well. Mr. Pennington said that barring what appeared to be a motling of the feathers on the back of the neck of the bird was a wild pigeon to a dot.

See the clipping

A captive since 1888 dies at Montville

A New Jersey paper notes in one line that a passenger pigeon kept in captivity since March 1888 has died at John Norwood’s farm in Montville, New Jersey.

The Penn's Grove Record · Penn's Grove, N.J. · and 1 other paper

CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Penn's Grove Record · 23 August 1912 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

A passenger pigeon, which has been in captivity since March, 1888, died at the farm of John Norwood, in Montville, N. J.

See the clipping

The surveyor of the port finds a roost

M. M. Garland, surveyor of the port of Pittsburg, says he has found 300 wild pigeons beginning to nest in a wooded tract near Edgewood. He followed their cooing to the roost, has been close to them three times in two days, and is positive they are ‘perfect specimens of the supposedly extinct passenger pigeon.’ Efforts will be made to take several alive.

Atlanta Georgian · Atlanta, Ga.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 3 days later.

Wrong

Atlanta Georgian · 13 July 1913 · page 6 · transcribed from the page image

Wild Pigeons Found; Bird Thought Extinct

Surveyor Locates Roost of 300 "Passengers" in Wooded Tract Near Pittsburg.

See moreSee less

PITTSBURG, July 12.—A flock of 300 wild pigeons has been located by M. M. Garland, surveyor of the port of Pittsburg, near his home at Edgewood. The birds have gone to nest in a heavily wooded tract, and efforts will be made to secure several of the birds alive. According to Mr. Garland, he has been very close to them on three different occasions during the last two days, and he is positive they are perfect specimens of the supposedly extinct passenger pigeon.

Mr. Garland discovered the birds while hunting through the woods. Hearing their "cooings" at a distance, he investigated and discovered the roost. The birds had just begun building their nests.

See the clipping

← Back to Act Three: Where Are the Wild Pigeons?