As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

January 1889

45 articles

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report recounts how detectives shot and killed the escaped desperado Tom Wallace after he opened fire on them, and describes his dying confession that he and Cap Hatfield were paid to kill Jeff McCoy two years earlier. It also details an earlier atrocity in which Wallace and Cap Hatfield brutalized the Daniels family while searching for a kidnapped woman.

The Indianapolis Journal · 1 January 1889 · page 2

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.

The report describes Cap Hatfield beating an elderly, sick woman (Mrs. Daniels) nearly to death while searching for a fugitive girl, then later capturing Jeff McCoy near Thacker Creek. McCoy broke free and tried to swim to safety, but was shot dead on the riverbank as his mother watched in anguish.

The Indianapolis Journal · 1 January 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Pittsburg Dispatch · Pittsburg, Pa.

This daily news digest entry from January 30 reports that Governor Wilson dispatched troops to suppress the ongoing Hatfield-McCoy conflict. It is listed alongside unrelated news items such as the Pope's jubilee gifts and Senate postage debates.

Pittsburg Dispatch · 1 January 1889 · page 9

Oregon volunteers on board, were sighted oil Point Reyes Wednesday. The big trust smelter at Omaha is shut down, the fires in several of the furnaces being out, and others are to follow. The shortage of coal is given as a reason. Charges have been filed against Indian Agent John S. Mayhugh, of the White Rock agency, in Nevada, alleging, among other things, arbitrary administration. Elias Hatfield, the noted desperado and of "Devil Anse" Hatfield, the older, of eon the Hatfield-McCoy feud that cost 141 lives, has surrendered to Governor Atkin

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A dispatch reports that Tom Wallace, an ally of the Hatfield clan, was shot by detectives and made a dying confession claiming he and Cap Hatfield were paid $50 each to kill Jeff McCoy two years earlier. The report also recounts Wallace's earlier abduction of a McCoy relative and brutal assault on an elderly woman while searching for her.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 1 January 1889 · page 1

A MOUNTAIN TERROR. THE DEATH OF A NOTORIOUS DESPERADO AT THE HANDS OF DETECTIVES

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

The report recounts how Tom Wallace and Cap Hatfield beat an invalid woman searching for a hidden girl, then captured Jeff McCoy, tied him up, and shot him dead as he tried to swim to safety across the Tug River. It frames this as the 'peculiarly horrible' crime behind Hatfield's recent jail escape.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: San Antonio Daily Light, 31 December 1888, The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer, 31 December 1888.

Wheeling Register · 1 January 1889 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

In the story →

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

This news-and-comment column jokes that eager journalists who spend their time composing thrilling stories about feuds and murders in West Virginia's mountains should take a trip through the actual Hatfield-McCoy country. It sarcastically suggests a skilled 'liar' might get lost along the way but would at least have died in a good cause.

Wheeling Register · 1 January 1889 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

If a few of the enterprising journalists who spend the most of their waking hours in composing thrilling stories of family feuds and murders in the mountains of West Virginia, would take a trip through the Hatfield-McCoy country it would be a great relief to the West Virginia public. A skilful and industrious liar or two might get lost by the wayside, but there would be the consolation that they died in a good cause.

See the clipping

The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis

Detectives David Stratton and 'Kentucky Bill' tracked down and killed Tom Wallace near Flat Top Mountain after he opened fire on them; before dying, Wallace reportedly confessed that he and Cap Hatfield were paid to kill Jeff McCoy. The report also recounts Wallace's earlier crime of a mock marriage and abduction of McCoy's niece.

The Indiana State Sentinel · 2 January 1889 · page 8

SLAIN BY DETECTIVES.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis

The report describes the shooting death of outlaw Tom Wallace, who on his deathbed confessed that he and Cap Hatfield were paid by a Virginia deputy sheriff to kill Jeff McCoy two years earlier. It also recounts the earlier abduction of Miss Daniels, the beating of an invalid woman, and the brutal killing of Jeff McCoy as he tried to swim to safety.

The Indiana State Sentinel · 2 January 1889 · page 8

SLAIN BY DETECTIVES

His unole tumbled over dead, shot near the heart. Cleland Smallwood was in the notorious Hatfield-McCoy vendetta, and was a desperate outlaw. The Plague Ileoord.

Clipping to come

Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.

A. J. Mixer of Pikeville tells reporters in Louisville that the reported killing of Wallace in Charleston, West Virginia, would likely end the Hatfield-McCoy feud. He reasons that most of the parties involved in the conflict are now dead.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Los Angeles Daily Herald · 3 January 1889 · page 5

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A. J. Miles of Pikeville said the reported killing of Wallace in Charleston, W. Va. would effectively end the Hatfield-McCoy feud, since most of the interested parties are now dead. The brief dispatch treats this as a hopeful sign that the long-running violence is winding down.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 3 January 1889 · page 1

A HATFIELD KlUSAFPEU. Taken to Kentucky to Answer For Morder. Williamson, W. Va., Aug. 9— Yesterday Jim Moore and Bill Bus kirk. of Logan county, came here with a warrant for Bill Hatfield. Hatfield has been serving a sentence in jail and his time was up. Moore and Buskirk had written SneritT Keadle to have a hack ready to take him to Logan when he was released from jail. The hack took the Logan road, hut when it passed the ford in 'lug river the driver was told to cross to the Ken tucky side, and instead of going to Logan Hatfield was taken to Pike ville, Ky., where he was wanted as a participator In the McCoy murders.

See moreSee less

This is the second one of the family kidnapped. .Johnson Hatfield being taken last spring and *s now serving a life sentence in Frankfort. Moore and Buskirk were friends of Doc Ellis, who was killed by Elias Hat field a short time ago, and Bill Tom was kidnapped for revenge. The goat is the butt of many a poor joke.

Clipping to come

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A. J. Miles of Pikeville claimed that the recent killing of Wallace, reported from Charleston, West Virginia, would likely end the Hatfield-McCoy feud. He said most of the people involved were now dead.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 3 January 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.

Thomas Wallace, a member of the Hatfield faction in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was killed by officers at Flat Top Mountain, Virginia, while resisting arrest. The item appears amid a roundup of unrelated crime briefs from around the country.

The National Tribune · 3 January 1889 · page 8

CRIMES AND CASUALTIES.

R g - DEVIL ANSE” CAUGHT “‘\;_;«?1‘ ; . Ry : (e B His Son and Son-in-Law He - ~ Surmendered After a Fight, R 4 ..'.:' 4 e ‘ ~ Foars That Ellas Hatfield Will Be Lynched .‘.““» e o Before His Trial Ends. ‘ WMW Va., Sept. 12.—The long j’:? pxpected attack upon the old Hatfiell \'* ” @ posse of citizens of this (Min ' county was made late last evening. 3L e ‘ - and after a sharp fight in which many - shots were fired “Devil Anse” Hutrield, ~ his son Bob and his son-in-law, John ~ Dingess, surrendered.

See moreSee less

V,‘W" Hatfield, the most notorious of uim. managed to escape, as did s{; p half a dozen others, but a portion ~of the posse is still in pursuit, and it is ,5’,;,q,,, Vel M‘tpdr capture will be ef "";{ wil Anse” is the father of “Cap.” .He won his title when he led the party . Which shot khree of the McCoys across o x"fi' er into Kentucky and burmed " “Eheir bodies at a stake, “Devil Anse” . Wwas never before arrested. He has more . than a score of times led his kin in ~ baktle against the authorities both of - Kentucky and West Virginia. ~ & The posse which made the raid yes " ay was organized at the request of . dudge Dolittle of this circuit, and fifty . Winchester rifles were sent here from - the state capiial for the use of the bosse. - - Inside the oid fort which has shielded rr {atfields for so many years were ¢ found ammunition and provisione 55 . h to supply a company of troops, 802 il Anse” wept Dbitterly when “of his past life. His one plea L > s that he may noi be taken to Ken- ‘ "‘,}} trial .of Elias Hatfleld for the A"r.'i:f | ¥« - “murde of Deputy Sheriff Eitis i{s now .In progress at Willlamson, Ming) coun ';am it 18 feared that he will be ~ lynche ‘before the trial ends. ‘

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

The item reports that Tom Wallace, a member of the Hatfield gang, was killed by law officers while resisting arrest. Before dying, he allegedly confessed that he and Cap Hatfield were each paid $50 by a Buchanan County deputy sheriff to kill Jeff McCoy of Pike County, Kentucky.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

The Big Sandy News · 3 January 1889 · page 2

,5’,;,q,,, Vel M‘tpdr capture will be ef "";{ wil Anse” is the father of “Cap.” .He won his title when he led the party . Which shot khree of the McCoys across o x"fi' er into Kentucky and burmed " “Eheir bodies at a stake, “Devil Anse” . Wwas never before arrested. He has more . than a score of times led his kin in ~ baktle against the authorities both of - Kentucky and West Virginia.

Clipping to come

Helena Weekly Herald · Helena, Mont.

A one-line chronicle entry reports that the long-running feud between the Hatfield and McCoy families, based in Pike County, Kentucky, and Logan County, West Virginia, flared up again on July 25. No further detail is given about the specific incident.

Helena Weekly Herald · 3 January 1889 · page 6

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Indian Chieftain · Vinita, Indian Territory Okla.

A dying desperado named Tom Wallace, killed by two men in West Virginia, reportedly confessed that Cap Hatfield and another Hatfield were paid $400 each by a Virginia deputy sheriff to kill Jeff McCoy about two years earlier. The report is explicitly framed as a confused or unreliable deathbed statement.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Wrong

Indian Chieftain · 3 January 1889 · page 1

A Dying Man's Confusion

Alex Shepherd, of Washington, D. C„ sold his mines at Batopilas, Mexi co, for $3,000,000. Sheriff Henderson and posse captur ed “Devil Anse” Hatfield, his son. Bob Hatfield, and a relative, John Dingess, near the Hatfield fort and ‘has taken them to Pike. There was no blood shed. This breaks the back of the Hatfield-McCoy feud.

Clipping to come

Evening Tribune · Pawtucket, R.I.

A federal marshal from Pikeville says the killing of Wallace in Charleston, West Virginia, should effectively end the Hatfield-McCoy feud since most participants are now dead. He notes sentiment in both Logan County, WV, and Pike County, KY favors punishing the jailed Hatfields and restoring order for economic development.

Evening Tribune · 3 January 1889 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

A former U.S. marshal says the killing of Tom Wallace, reported from Charleston, W. Va., will likely end the long-running Hatfield-McCoy feud since most key participants are now dead. He notes local sentiment favors punishing the Hatfields currently jailed at Pikeville and restoring order for economic development.

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 3 January 1889 · page 1

END OF THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.

A Louisville dispatch quotes A. Juxier of Pineville saying the killing of Wallace, reported from Charleston, W. Va., would effectively end the Hatfield-McCoy feud. He claims the feud's most interested parties are now dead.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 8 days later.

Wrong

The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 3 January 1889 · page 1

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Springdale News · Springdale, Ark. · and 1 other paper

This is a year-end roundup of disasters and crimes, listing dozens of unrelated killings, fires, and explosions from the preceding year. Among them is a brief entry claiming the Hatfield gang killed Mrs. McCoy and two children and burned her husband and two youngest children to death.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Springdale News · 4 January 1889 · page 6

Hatfields Again. Wharncliffe, W. \ a„ Sept. 12.—“ Devil Anse” Hatfield, now 58 years of age, and who for fifteen years has led the clan

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The American Citizen · Topeka, Kan. · 11 January 1889

The Mankato Free Press · Mankato, Minn.

This is a single-line entry in a year-end chronological digest of world events for January 1889, listing 'Hatfield McCoy row' under January 19. No details of the incident are given, only its place in a running list of notable happenings.

The Mankato Free Press · 4 January 1889 · page 4

September 7 and 21 and October 5 and 19 are the dates of the remaining Penn i sylvania Railroad popular ten-day excur sions to Niagara Falls from Philadelphia Baltimore, and Washington, and interme diate points. Excursion tickets, good for return pas sage on any regular train, exclusive of limited express trains, within ten days, will be sold at 810.00 from Philadelphia, Baltimore, Washington, and all points on the Delaware Division; $11.25 from At lantic City; 89.60 from Lancaster; $8.50 from Altoona and Harrisburg; $9.60 from Sunbury and Wilksbarre; $5.75 from Wil liamsport; artd at proportionate rates from other points.

See moreSee less

A stop over will be allowed at Buffalo, Rochester, Canandaigua, and Watkins within the limit returning. A special train of Pullman parlor cars I and day coaches will be run with each ex cursion. An extra charge will be made for parlor car seats. An experienced tourist agent and chap eron will accompany each excursion. Tickets for a side trip to the Thousand • Islands (Alexandria Bay) will be sold in 1 lb. f packages.^ torious “Cap” Hatfield. To their dis appointment the fort was vacated, but in the same was ammunition and provisions enough for a small army. "Cap” Hat field had evidently escaped to the mount ains on hearing the firing at his rela tives, anti a portion of the posse was in the mountains last night and hope to lo cate him. The prisoners arrested were taken to Williamson on the special. Elias Hatfield, who murdered “Doc” Ellis on a passen ger train last summer, is now on trial at Williamson. There is great excitement in Mingo tonight, and it is difficult to pre dict the outcome of today’s captures. At least 40 more Hatfields and relatives are hiding in this region, and should the posse come upon them in a body a bloody battle may result. All the men arrested car ried Winchesters. It is predicted that a lynching will occur before the trial of Elias Hatfield is concluded.

Clipping to come

Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.

A Louisville dispatch claims Johnson Hatfield, called the worst of the Hatfield clan, died in Lawrence County. It recounts his alleged role in killing the three McCoy brothers and in the New Year's raid on Randolph McCoy's home.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

Shenandoah Herald · 4 January 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

The report says detectives Stratton and 'Kentucky Bill' tracked down Tom Wallace, an alleged Hatfield gang member, on Flat Top Mountain and killed him in a shootout after he fired first. Dying, Wallace reportedly confessed that he and 'Capt. Hatfield' had been paid $50 each by a Virginia deputy sheriff to kill Jeff McCoy two years earlier.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 4 days later. CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

Wrong

The Superior Times · 5 January 1889 · page 1

SLAIN BY DETECTIVES.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Martinsburg Herald · Martinsburg, W. Va.

Thomas Wallace, a member of the Hatfield faction in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, was killed by law officers at Flat Top Mountain, Virginia. He was shot while resisting arrest.

Martinsburg Herald · 5 January 1889 · page 2

Henderson of Logan county and a posse of 15 went to the Hatfield fort In the mountains 30 miles from here and wlthoutJilpodehed captured Devil Anee fTatfleld his son Dob and John Dingoes a relative of the Hatflelds by marriage The prisoners will be taken to Pike county and tried on charge of murder grdwlng out of the Hatfield McCoy feud Captain the

Clipping to come

New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn. · and 2 other papers

The report recounts how Tom Wallace tricked a McCoy relative into a mock marriage, then with Cap Hatfield brutally beat her invalid mother while searching for her, and later murdered Jeff McCoy by shooting him as he tried to escape across the river. This history is given as context for Wallace's recent capture after a previous escape from jail.

CorrectionThis set right 2 earlier articles: Indian Chieftain, 3 January 1889, The Superior Times, 5 January 1889.

New Ulm Weekly Review · 9 January 1889 · page 3

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Also printed 3 more times, in 2 papers
  • · · 10 January 1889
  • · · 10 January 1889
  • · · 17 January 1889

Iron County Register · Ironton, Mo. · and 1 other paper

This brief appears in a year-end compilation of notable disasters and crimes, listing a Jan. 18 entry that the Hatfield gang killed Mrs. McCoy and her two eldest children and burned her husband and two youngest children to death. It is one short item among dozens of unrelated murders, accidents, and disasters from late 1888 and early 1889.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Iron County Register · 10 January 1889 · page 6

Special Dispatch to the Intelligencer. HUNTINGTON. W. Va., Sept. 21.? j Sheriff J. E. Peck, of Logan county, j brought here this evening Ellas and 1 Robert Hatfield. They are lodged in the Jail, the former to await the final <

Clipping to come

Also printed in 1 paper
  • The Russellville Democrat · Russellville, Ark. · 10 January 1889

Barton County Democrat · Great Bend, Kan.

A newspaper's year-in-review of 1888 crimes briefly notes that in Pike County, Kentucky, the Hatfield clan killed Mrs. McCoy and her two eldest children and burned her husband and two youngest children to death. The item appears among dozens of unrelated murders and disasters compiled for the year.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

Barton County Democrat · 10 January 1889 · page 6

brought here this evening Ellas and 1 Robert Hatfield. They are lodged in the Jail, the former to await the final < decision in his case upon the motion for J a new trial for the killing of H. E. < Ellts,- and the latter to await the next < tarm of the Mingo clrnilt court. Their father, "Devil Anse." gave bond to-day < in the sum of $5,000 for his appearance f at the next term of court. 1 Andrew ("Coon") McComas, of Sheri idan. who Is over seven feet tall, and ] known as the giant of the Ouyandotte valley, wns.

See moreSee less

It Is thought, fatally hurt by a saw log rolling over him while timbering at Six Mile creek a few mlleH I from his home. He is thought to be the tallest man In the state. TjcwIft-HnhlnMon. '

Clipping to come

Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D.

The report recounts how Tom Wallace and Cap Hatfield brutally beat an invalid woman searching for a fugitive girl, then later captured and killed Jeff McCoy, shooting him as he swam across the river to escape. It also notes Wallace had previously escaped custody by knocking down a jailer.

Reporter and Farmer · 10 January 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch from Charleston, W.Va. reports that Cap Hatfield and his father Anse Hatfield are trying to negotiate peace terms with law officers in the Hatfield-McCoy feud. They appeared armed at Logan court-house seeking a settlement contingent on acquittal, and officers made no attempt to arrest them.

CorrectionThis set right 3 earlier articles: Los Angeles Daily Herald, 3 January 1889, Sacramento Daily Record-Union, 3 January 1889, The Cheyenne Daily Leader, 3 January 1889.

Evening Star · 11 January 1889 · page 6

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Iola Register · Iola, Kansas

A newspaper's end-of-year crime roundup briefly notes that in Pike County, Kentucky, the Hatfield gang shot Mrs. McCoy and her two oldest children and burned her husband and two youngest children to death. It appears as one line among dozens of unrelated murders, shootings, and disasters compiled for the year.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Iola Register · 11 January 1889 · page 6

"Devil Anse," chief of the notorious Hatfield gang of Kentucky, has been captured by a sheriff's posse. Like terrible Hatfield ran like a deer when the officers came In sight, and, when •ornered, surrendered with hardly a •how of resistance. There 1b a material difference between cabin-burning or ambuscade at midnight and aetand-up fight with armed, sheriffs who can •hoot straight and are perfectly will ing to do BO An English scientist has solved the or the

Clipping to come

The Grenada Sentinel · Grenada, Miss.

Amid a long list of American murders, suicides, and lynchings from the past year, the item states that the Hatfield gang shot and killed Mrs. McCoy and her two eldest children in Pike County, Ky., and burned her husband and two youngest children to death. This brief entry compresses the notorious New Year's Night attack on the McCoy home into a single garbled line within a broader roundup of violent incidents.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right an article from the day before.

The Grenada Sentinel · 12 January 1889 · page 2

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Cincinnati reporter falsely claimed that armed Hatfield-McCoy gang members had arrived in the city to support Republicans, prompting Democrats to arm themselves in response. The city's Mayor stated the report was false and that no gang members were actually present.

Wheeling Register · 14 January 1889 · page 1

No One Believed That 'Fake.'

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A brief news item reports that Captain Hatfield and several associates in the West Virginia feud captured three detectives who had been sent from Charleston to arrest them. The item appears as a short entry in a daily news summary roundup.

The Evening World · 15 January 1889 · page 4

Transcript to come.

No clean clipping could be cut from this page

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A report from Charleston, W. Va., says 'Bad Anse' Hatfield, Capt. Hatfield, and allies trapped and captured three detectives, including Dan Cunningham and Evans, who were hunting them. The detectives were arrested on a peace warrant and jailed at the Logan court house pending bond to keep the peace.

San Antonio Daily Light · 15 January 1889 · page 1

SL'CK ETS i t ' mence to describe the s a of the Hattif-ld ai families in Kentucky. They it by the bai rell . left. A:i item XWest Virginia Hatflelds and McCoys :ought and bled. They do not know • ; afraid. But their neigh when a Hatfleld Bfa I ta the jury is v i ,ing anything whl • ■ ■ the family feelii For •■• are very clannish, so use of one Is the fight 11. So the juries disagree thing rather than to ms« Ivea a part of the family ■ ; M.

See moreSee less

Coys. Thi imilies are now Hke the • g '■'• • T along prosperity. ■ le Samuel is looking down the line for the real thing in fightIng men. The Hatflelds and McCoys ara I r. •- for tr ible; they have a liking f • iking. They have also a particular fondness for killing nig gprs. So it was h trouble for the spruce reci er to secure the services of a Hi country when there ■were about eight million niggers, more or leas, ■ the Philippine*. That was just about the size of his ap petite Bul t killed them yet, and the bait was Btlll dangling when a partisan of the McCoy family Jumped at the allur lnp tidl.it. ■ Eight millions of niggers to be killed." just think of It! And then not even own cartridges. 1 Bang! What a time! Blood till the rivers run red and no dis agreeably inquisitive court proceedings afterward to bother about it. So it nmc that at Fort Thomas, Ky., wpf 1 enlisted \\. the Thirty-first Infantry. United States Vi lunteers, two men whose education had been to kill each other. It was not long before they nv-r. They were thoroughbreds and like them did not : any time In preliminaries, but start , ] without delay to get a line on each r. The two men were seized and dis armed, one to nurse bis slow wrath, the other to meditate sudden vengeance. Their officers gave them such a lecture on military duties as only West Pointers know how to give, and as the men of their company had particular reasons for not wishing to Btop any 0 tes magazine rifle bul lets with their three-mile range, it was solemnly promised that there should be nothing but good behavior, with all bul lets reserved for Filipinos. Jt has been said that that the feud com menced when the first Hatflelda and Mc- ( 'oys were born, but the first time it ap pears in authentic history was when citiEens of Pike County, in the eastern part of Kentucky, asked the Governor of the State to provide them with arms and am munition with which they might defend themselves from an expected attack upon the various members and friends of the McCoy family, which was to be made by an armed force consisting of nearly 100 of the Hatfleld family and adherents, who were coming from West Virginia under the leadership of "Devil" Anse Hatileld and Cap Hatfield. This contemplated expedition of the Hatflelds lacked only Government sanc tion to give it the title of war, for there were as many men and as much method in their preparations as In many of the Government's military exploits during the early history of our country. It was the culmination of an election fight that took place in-Pike County in 18S2, when a McCoy shot a Hatfleld, but even back of this there seemed to be faint shadows of beautiful faces and bold hearts that loved not wisely, for like all of the sons of Mars they were no lag gards in love. Law was laxly administered in that wild mountain region, where the moonshiner defies even the Government's most wily secret service men and the power of the military combined, so the Hatflelds, in order to prevent any miscarriage of Jus tice and also to give a salutary warning to any other men who might be Inclined to send bullets trespassing within their anatomies, captured four members of the McCoy family who had been con o^rri'd in the disturbance and forcibly carried them as prisoners to West Vir ginia. With the prisoners once in their power, however, it seemed to them that to execute them in West Virginia was a sort of "killing sheep too near home." Besides the laws of West Virginia were more actively enforced. So by secret mountain trails and through wild forest paths the unhappy prisoners were re turned to their native State and shot by their captors. The Governor of Kentucky thereupon made a requisition on the Governor of West Virginia for some Hatfleldp. The "West Virginia Governor was evidently well acquainted with his citizens, and not desiring to suddenly leave his office va cant, firmly but politely refused the request. This unusual proceeding caused a storm of popular feeling. Large re wards were offered for the Hatfields, and the Sheriff of Pike County finally ex tended his strong arm and his Jurisdic tion Into the State of West Virginia until It embraced three Hatflelds. The Hatflelds now considered that not only their own honor and feelings were outraged, but also that their State had been Insulted. Another Hatfleld foray was organized to raid the McCoy home In Pike County. Again the Hatflelds crossed the border and succeeded in attacking and burning the McCoy house and killing while con fined in the burning houße McCoy's wife, daughter and son. The elder McCoy escaped, persuaded thirty of his relatives and friends to join him, Invaded Logan County, West Vir ginia, killed two Hatflelds and captured six, whom they took back with them and turned over to the authorities of Pike County. It was now the turn of the West Vir ginia Governor to plead for the return of his citizens, but the Governor of Kentucky not only refused but under the authority vested In him by law for the suppression of crime offered a reward of $5000 apiece for each and every one of the West Virginia Hatflelds who had been engaged in trespasses on Kentucky soil. The size of this reward made the Hat fields much-sought-after people, and, de siring to be somewhat more retiring and exclusive than formerly, like all who at tain prominence, they withdrew them

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A telegram reports that Hatfield family members, including 'Bad Anse' and Cap Hatfield, lured bounty detectives Cunningham, Evans and a third into the mountains of Logan County and captured them. Using peace warrants, they had the detectives arrested and jailed at Logan Court House pending bond.

Wheeling Register · 15 January 1889 · page 1

A SLICK DODGE.

ms« Ivea a part of the family ■ ; M. Coys. Thi imilies are now Hke the • g '■'• • T along prosperity. ■ le Samuel is looking down the line for the real thing in fightIng men. The Hatflelds and McCoys ara I r. •- for tr ible; they have a liking f • iking. They have also a particular fondness for killing nig gprs. So it was h trouble for the spruce reci er to secure the services of a Hi country when there ■were about eight million niggers, more or leas, ■ the Philippine*.

See moreSee less

That was just about the size of his ap petite Bul t killed them yet, and the bait was Btlll dangling when a partisan of the McCoy family Jumped at the allur lnp tidl.it.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The article reports that 'Bad Anse' Hatfield and associates lured three detectives into a trap in the Logan County mountains and forced their surrender. The detectives were reportedly taken to the Logan courthouse and jailed pending peace bonds.

Evening Star · 16 January 1889 · page 6

the various members and friends of the McCoy family, which was to be made by an armed force consisting of nearly 100 of the Hatfleld family and adherents, who were coming from West Virginia under the leadership of "Devil" Anse Hatileld and Cap Hatfield. This contemplated expedition of the Hatflelds lacked only Government sanc tion to give it the title of war, for there were as many men and as much method in their preparations as In many of the Government's military exploits during the early history of our country. It was the culmination of an election fight that took place in-Pike County in 18S2, when a McCoy shot a Hatfleld, but even back of this there seemed to be faint shadows of beautiful faces and bold hearts that loved not wisely, for like all of the sons of Mars they were no lag gards in love.

See moreSee less

Law was laxly administered in that wild mountain region, where the moonshiner defies even the Government's most wily secret service men and the power of the military combined, so the Hatflelds, in order to prevent any miscarriage of Jus tice and also to give a salutary warning to any other men who might be Inclined to send bullets trespassing within their anatomies, captured four members of the McCoy family who had been con o^rri'd in the disturbance and forcibly carried them as prisoners to West Vir ginia. With the prisoners once in their power, however, it seemed to them that to execute them in West Virginia was a sort of "killing sheep too near home." Besides the laws of West Virginia were more actively enforced. So by secret mountain trails and through wild forest paths the unhappy prisoners were re turned to their native State and shot by their captors.

Clipping to come

Wichita Eagle · Wichita, Kan.

Reports state that Hatfield family members, including 'Bad Anse' and Captain Hatfield, lured and captured detectives Dan Cunningham and Evans in the Logan County mountains. The detectives were taken to the Logan courthouse, arrested under a peace warrant, and held pending bond.

Wichita Eagle · 16 January 1889 · page 1

TRAPPED THE DETECTIVES.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

Evening Capital · Annapolis, Md.

Three members of the McCoy party were arrested on charges of plotting to kill 'French' Ellis and 'Anse' Hatfield. This brief item appeared amid other short news items in a 'Brief Mention' column.

Evening Capital · 16 January 1889 · page 4

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Central Presbyterian · Richmond, Va.

Capt. Hatfield and his father Anse Hatfield, central figures in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, sought to negotiate a settlement and end the violence. They appeared heavily armed at Logan Court House but were not arrested by officers present.

The Central Presbyterian · 16 January 1889 · page 1

PIKE COUNTY, KY. Bill Tom Hatfield, who was kid napped in Mingo county a little more than a year ago and taken to Pike county, Kentucky, charged with being implicated in the Hatfield-McCoy feud years ago has just been given a trial. The jury found him guilty of murder and he has been given a life sentence in prison. I)r. Bull’* Coush Syrup i* unequalled for bronchitis, loss of voice, hoarseness, and other throat and lung affections, more quickly than auy other medicine 501

Clipping to come

Paper unidentified · and 3 other papers

Detectives hunting Tom Wallace of the Hatfield gang on a Kentucky governor's requisition found him at Flat Top mountain, where he opened fire and was fatally shot. Before dying, Wallace allegedly confessed that he and Cap Hatfield were each paid $50 by a Buchanan County deputy sheriff to kill Capt. McCoy, with the money funneled through 'Devil Anse' Hatfield.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Paper unidentified · 17 January 1889 · page 2

Death of a Desperado.

which doubtless had its incep : the Hatfield-McCoy feud of a few i years ago. Such tragedies as th > I which have occurred within th-- ;m few days are greatly to be deplore ! not only because contrary t > i > ■. both human <nd divine, but b -a . unkind attention is sure to be a< j traded. The outside world must not judge us harshly and take the tragedies as an indication of tic character of West Virginians in general. West Virginians, as a pc - \ pie.

See moreSee less

are not vicious, but are sober, industrious and peaceable, with a moral standard as high as that of the citizens of any state in the Un ion. It cannot be denied, however, that the g -neral impression from such affairs as these does West Vir ginia a great injustice.

Clipping to come

Also printed in 4 papers
  • New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn. · 9 January 1889
  • · · 10 January 1889
  • · · 10 January 1889
  • Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 10 January 1889

Virginia Free Press · Charlestown, Va. W. Va.

A Charleston telegram reports that Capt. Hatfield and his father Anse Hatfield, weary of the feud, visited Logan Court House seeking to negotiate a peaceful settlement and possible acquittal. Though heavily armed and trailed by detectives, they were not arrested.

Virginia Free Press · 17 January 1889 · page 3

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

The Superior Times · Superior, Wis.

A dispatch reports that 'Bad Anse' Hatfield and his kinsmen, grown notorious in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, turned the tables on detectives hunting them, seizing Dan Cunningham and another operative. The Hatfields obtained a peace warrant against the detectives and had them jailed at the Logan court house.

CorrectionThis set right an article from 2 days earlier.

The Superior Times · 19 January 1889 · page 1

ARRESTED THE DETECTIVES.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Butler Weekly Times · Butler, Mo.

The report describes how Bud, Anse, and Cap Hatfield lured three detectives into the mountains of Logan County and forced their surrender. Using a peace warrant, the Hatfields had the detectives arrested and jailed at the Logan courthouse pending bond.

The Butler Weekly Times · 23 January 1889 · page 6

HATFIELD TO BE PARDONED THE SLAYER OK ‘ DOC” ELLIS SAID TO RE DYING AT MOUNDSVILLE Wheeling, W. Va , Apr 4—The hoard of pardons which is in session at the Moundsviile penitentiary this after noon decided to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, of Harfield-McCoy fend fame, who is serving a ]•_* year sentence. They will give as a reason the fact that Hatfield is dying of con sumption. Attorney Charles ,T Schuck and Captain Ewing had Hatfield's eese and pleaded for his pardon yesterday.

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

A Charleston, W. Va. special reports that Cap Hatfield and his father Anse Hatfield are trying to negotiate a settlement in the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The two met officers at Logan Court House, armed but unmolested, expressing a wish for peace if assured amnesty.

The Big Sandy News · 24 January 1889 · page 3

MOUNDSVILLE Wheeling, W. Va , Apr 4—The hoard of pardons which is in session at the Moundsviile penitentiary this after noon decided to recommend a pardon for Elias Hatfield, of Harfield-McCoy fend fame, who is serving a ]•_* year sentence. They will give as a reason the fact that Hatfield is dying of con sumption. Attorney Charles ,T Schuck and Captain Ewing had Hatfield's eese and pleaded for his pardon yesterday.

Clipping to come

San Marcos Free Press · San Marcos, Tex.

This is a compressed year-in-review listing of notable 1888 crimes and events, including a one-line note that war between the Hatfield and McCoy factions in Pike County, Ky., and Logan County, W. Va., broke out afresh. The item appears amid dozens of unrelated crime items (bank defalcations, murders, Whitechapel killings) with no further detail given.

San Marcos Free Press · 24 January 1889 · page 2

THE CAPTURE OF HUNTING HATFIELDS The Dangerous Pursuit of a Deputy United States Marshal. HAS CAPTURE FOUR OF THE CLAN Deeds of Daring in the Moun tains of West Virginia. AT TIIE RIFLE'S POINT Writte-n f,.r The Evening Star. Throughout the northern spurs of the Al leghanies the name of Hatfield is a name of terror. Devil Anse and his clan have for years and -almost with Impunity rav agen the mountain region of four states ohUNHtfIelds H aTbee LDSrcpn Virginia. West Virginia, Kentucky and Tennessee--with murder, arson and all other crime~s of violence.

See moreSee less

The murders per ofThe Dauruan dangrut osptalityo petrate~d by them in the Hatfield-'McCoy feud aire only a small part oif their crimes. Nowhere In criminal annals Is there an Ueita ed tos ofman,on other family with so bloody a record. In their own home region of southern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield Is the surest form of suicide. Ev-en the offi cers of the law seldom interfere with them, and though~the aggregate of Indictments against the clan mounts uip Into the hun dreds, its members, armed to the teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cities unmolested when they choose. If they take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding In re prisal from across the border of Kentucky, dared Interfere with them. But now they are being hunted In their own state by a man who has already captured four of them and sent one to the gallows. This is Deputy United States Mlarshal Daniel W. Cunningham of the district of West Vir ginia. His First Capture.

Clipping to come

South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.

A Charleston dispatch reports that Hatfield family members lured detectives into the mountains near Logan County and had them arrested on peace warrants, turning the tables on their pursuers. The detectives were jailed at Logan Court House, and the Hatfields reportedly sought warrants against detective agency leaders for conspiracy to arrest them illegally.

South Branch Intelligencer · 25 January 1889 · page 2

THE HATFIELDS CAUGHT THE DETECTIVES

Nowhere In criminal annals Is there an Ueita ed tos ofman,on other family with so bloody a record. In their own home region of southern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield Is the surest form of suicide. Ev-en the offi cers of the law seldom interfere with them, and though~the aggregate of Indictments against the clan mounts uip Into the hun dreds, its members, armed to the teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cities unmolested when they choose.

See moreSee less

If they take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding In re prisal from across the border of Kentucky, dared Interfere with them. But now they are being hunted In their own state by a man who has already captured four of them and sent one to the gallows. This is Deputy United States Mlarshal Daniel W.

Clipping to come