As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

December 1888

17 articles

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

Cunningham, a former Deputy U.S. Marshal who helped arrest seven Hatfield-McCoy feudists, reports a second attempt on his life via a poisoned apple planted in his pocket while in court. He claims to have a clue and expects an arrest soon.

Wheeling Register · 3 December 1888 · page 1

AFTER A DETECTIVE

E E. Ellis, a Deputy Sheriff, Shot Dead at Grey, W. Va., BY ELIAS HATFIELD, AN LIGH1 EEN-YEAR-OLD SON OF "DEVIL ANS” HATFIELD—EACH HAD A WINCHESTER AND BOTH FIRED AT ONCE, BUT HATFIELD WAS THE BETTER MARKSMAN AND PUT A BULLET THROUGH EL LIS'S HEAD—MURDERER ES CAPED TO KENTUCKY—FEUD MAY BREAK OUT ANEW. (Special to the Register. ' GREY, W. VA., July 3.—At noon to day when No. 11 N. & IV. passenger train pulled into the station here from he South on the rear platform of the rain stood H.

See moreSee less

E. Ellis, deputy sheriff Mingo county. Elias Hatfield, an eighteen-year-old of “Devil Anse” Hatfield, came walking up to the train With a Win chester on his shoulder. He began cursing the deputy sheriff for having arrested his brother, John S. Hatfield, a few years ago and raised his Win chester off his shoulder preparing to take aim at Ellis. The deputy sheriff sprang inside the car and grabbed his own Winchester and a moment later faced the youthful, but already notorious Hatfield. Both raised their winchesters and fired at the same instant. Hatfield had taken the better aim. The ball from his Winchester penetrat ed the deputy sheriff’s skull and he fell to the car platform a corpse without ut The bullet from the deputy’s Win chester penetrated Hatfield’s arm, mak ing only a fle»h wound. Hatfield ran to Tug river and crossed over into Ken tucky. Afier reaching the Kentucky shore, he brandished his Winchester and yelled: "I have accomplished my aim at last.” It is said that the young murderer promised his aged mother years ago that he would kill Deputy Sheriff Ellis be cause it was he who captured his broth er, John Hatfield, who is now serving a life sentence in state’s prison. A posse of twenty or more men was soon formed who are now scouring the hills of Kentucky for the young des perado, If he is captured, which he is not likely to be without bloodshed, all indications point to a. lynching bee. H. E. Ellis, the murdered deputy, was one of the influential citizens of •Mingo county. He was a Mason and an Odd Fellow, and to-day’s tragedy may cause an uprising in this county such as was never before witnessed. The Hatfield clan will, of course use every effort to prevent the capture of Elias and that great trouble is just ahead is a foregone conclusion. Sheriff N. .1. Keadle, the most fear less officer in the State, is leading the posse in pursuit of Hatfield. With Kea dle’s posse is William Bevins, a man who knows no fear and who has brought <to justice a number of both

Clipping to come

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

George McCoy, described as one of the notorious Hatfield-McCoy desperadoes, was arrested and brought to Charleston by law officers from Ironton and Huntington. He is held in jail pending word from Logan county authorities, and reportedly speaks freely about the vendetta, including details of the killing of Vance.

Wheeling Sunday Register · 9 December 1888 · page 1

A SAVORY CHARACTER.

MAY BREAK OUT ANEW. (Special to the Register. ' GREY, W. VA., July 3.—At noon to day when No. 11 N. & IV. passenger train pulled into the station here from he South on the rear platform of the rain stood H. E. Ellis, deputy sheriff Mingo county. Elias Hatfield, an eighteen-year-old of “Devil Anse” Hatfield, came walking up to the train With a Win chester on his shoulder. He began cursing the deputy sheriff for having arrested his brother, John S. Hatfield, a few years ago and raised his Win chester off his shoulder preparing to take aim at Ellis.

See moreSee less

The deputy sheriff sprang inside the car and grabbed his own Winchester and a moment later faced the youthful, but already notorious Hatfield. Both raised their winchesters and fired at the same instant. Hatfield had taken the better aim. The ball from his Winchester penetrat ed the deputy sheriff’s skull and he fell to the car platform a corpse without ut > tering a word. The bullet from the deputy’s Win chester penetrated Hatfield’s arm, mak ing only a fle»h wound. Hatfield ran to Tug river and crossed over into Ken tucky. Afier reaching the Kentucky shore, he brandished his Winchester and yelled: "I have accomplished my aim at last.” It is said that the young murderer promised his aged mother years ago that he would kill Deputy Sheriff Ellis be cause it was he who captured his broth er, John Hatfield, who is now serving a life sentence in state’s prison. A posse of twenty or more men was soon formed who are now scouring the hills of Kentucky for the young des perado, If he is captured, which he is not likely to be without bloodshed, all indications point to a. lynching bee. H. E. Ellis, the murdered deputy, was one of the influential citizens of •Mingo county. He was a Mason and an Odd Fellow, and to-day’s tragedy may cause an uprising in this county such as was never before witnessed. The Hatfield clan will, of course use every effort to prevent the capture of Elias and that great trouble is just ahead is a foregone conclusion. Sheriff N. .1. Keadle, the most fear less officer in the State, is leading the posse in pursuit of Hatfield. With Kea dle’s posse is William Bevins, a man who knows no fear and who has brought <to justice a number of both

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

George McCoy, described as one of the notorious Hatfield-McCoy feudists, was arrested and brought to Charleston by Ohio and West Virginia lawmen. He is held in jail awaiting word from Logan County authorities and reportedly speaks freely about the vendetta, including details related to the killing of Vance.

Wheeling Register · 10 December 1888 · page 3

A SAVORY CHARACTER.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Shepherdstown Register · Shepherdstown, Va. W. Va.

The paper notes another reported arrest of a Hatfield-McCoy gang member but mocks the flood of arrest and death reports, joking that the country must be depopulated if every tree were a Hatfield or McCoy. The tone suggests skepticism about the accuracy and volume of ongoing news coverage.

Shepherdstown Register · 14 December 1888 · page 2

Snld io He burronndetl. Williamson, W. Va., July 5. It is re ported here that a posse under Sheriff Keadle has Ellas HatQeld, son of Devil Anse Hatfield, who killed Deputy Sheriff

Clipping to come

The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.

The passage briefly references the earlier Hatfield-McCoy 'trouble' in Logan County as an example of lawlessness, now being surpassed by White Cap violence in Ohio and Indiana. It treats the feud as a settled matter of public reputation rather than breaking news.

The New Dominion · 15 December 1888 · page 2

Deputy 11. E. Ellis, of Mingo county. Ellis and his posso surrounded a small hut In which Hatfield had taken refuge for the night, and at break of day ho was forced to surrender and his trial was speedily held. Ho was sentenced to life Imprisonment. Ellas Hatfield then stated that he would soma day

Clipping to come

Martinsburg Independent · Martinsburg, W. Va.

The brief notes that George McCoy, described as one of the principals in the McCoy-Hatfield war in Kentucky, was arrested at Ironton, Ohio. No further details are given about the charges or circumstances.

Martinsburg Independent · 22 December 1888 · page 2

Wealths Greatly Interested. Hatfield Mel'oy Fend May be Revived— Desperate Man Keititr Flosely Hunted* Masons in the Chase—Events that Led to the Affair. Williamson, W V., July 6.—De spite the determined efforts of a number of the best officers on the line of the Norfolk and Western Railroad, Elias Hatfield, Jr., the boy desperado, who killed H. E. Ellis is still at large. Sheriff Buskirk and Prosecuting Attorney Feck, of Logan county, who went to the scene of the killing with a posse of 20 of Logan county citizens, passed through this place on their way home.

See moreSee less

They left the greater part of their party in the vicinity of Grey, to continue the search for Hatfield, while they returned to Logan coun tv to organize a larger pursuing party. 'Che Hatfield clan has committed a number of atrocious crimes in Lo gan county and the officers there, as well as in this ( Mingo) county are fully determined that Elias Hatfield Jr., shall be made to answer for the tnurder of Deck Ellis.

Clipping to come

The New Dominion · Morgantown, W. Va.

A newspaper editorial criticizes other papers for expressing horror over the Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia, pointing out that Ohio has its own organized gang of over a thousand committing nighttime outrages. The piece uses this comparison to argue that lawlessness isn't unique to West Virginia.

The New Dominion · 22 December 1888 · page 2

THREE STATES TO ACT TO-GETHER. It it believed the Governors of the three States will make the honor re quisitions on and through each oth er tor every member of the gang wanted in either State for any crime, and a sufficiently large party of men will be sent out to effect their cap ture. Besides being a member of a num her of other orders, Ellis was a Roy al Arch Mason, and was to-day bur ied by Logan Lodge, to which he belonged. The Masons are lending their influence to effect Hatfield’s apprehension.

See moreSee less

. Scouts from time to time report, but up to this time the fugitive iias not been sighted nor is bis exact hiding place known. When last seen he was crossing Tug river, in Kentucky, and he is still believd to be there. The cause which led to the shoot ing was a grudge borne against Ellis for having aided a posse of officers in capturing Johnson Hatfield and kidnapping him to Kentucky. John son was subsequently tried and sen tenced to life imprisonment for the killing of a McCoy girl years ago, when the famous Ilatfield-McCoy feud was at its worst. Ellis was single, about 10 years old. and a wealthy lumberman.

Clipping to come

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A report states that Johnson 'Johnse' Hatfield, son of feud leader 'Bad Anse' and participant in the New Year's 1888 attack on Randolph McCoy's house, has died after being left ill along a roadside near Louisa, Kentucky. The identification was uncertain, based on recognition by one or two acquaintances, though the report claims little doubt remains.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.

The Evening World · 26 December 1888 · page 1

Johnson Hatfield's Death.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

The item reports that Johnson Hatfield, described as the worst of the Hatfield gang, died near Louisa, Kentucky, and recaps his alleged role in the pawpaw-bush killings of three McCoy boys and the New Year's attack on Randolph McCoy's house. It credits him with ruining a McCoy daughter and leading the deadly raids.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Evening Star · 27 December 1888 · page 10

THE WORST MAN OF THE HATFIELD GANG DEAD

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A one-line item in a miscellaneous news summary column states that Johnson Hatfield, described as the 'chief desperado' in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, has died in Lawrence County, Kentucky. No further details or context are given.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 27 December 1888 · page 1

STORY OF THE TRAGEDY. Governor Atkinson and Private Sec i retary Boggs left Charleston yesterday i 'eh' defense. afternoon announcing that they were going to Gray on the Norfolk and Western, to make personal iuvestiga- , tion into the facts of the murder of H E. ( Doc.) Ellis by Elias Hatfield which occurred at Gray, Mingo county, Mon day, Juno 3. The Governor's real mis sion, however, was to bring Hatfield to Huntington, and for this purpose a guard of personally selected m»n ac companied him. The party passed through this city late last evening for Kenova, leaving there at 1:30 and arriving at Gray at o:io mis morning.

See moreSee less

The news of the Governor's arrival spread like wild fire through the little mountain village and the country around, and crowds began collecting Some were friends of the Hatfields, some were friends of peace and good government, and some were enemies to both, and as all parties were armed it looked as though the soil of Mingo would be the scene of another bloody tragedy. Those who were expecting trouble, however, were doomed to disappoint ment. When Elias Hatfield wTas in formed that Governor Atkinson was at Gray the young outlaw came in from

Clipping to come

The Evening World · New York, N.Y.

A roundup of brief national news items includes a one-line report that Johnson Hatfield, described as the chief desperado of the Hatfield-McCoy feud, has died in Lawrence County, West Virginia. The item appears among unrelated news briefs about politics, deaths, and disasters.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Evening World · 27 December 1888 · page 3

Those who were expecting trouble, however, were doomed to disappoint ment. When Elias Hatfield wTas in formed that Governor Atkinson was at Gray the young outlaw came in from

Clipping to come

Wheeling Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A Louisville dispatch claims 'Johnse' Hatfield, described as the worst of the Hatfield gang and implicated in the killing of three McCoy brothers and the 1887 attack on Randolph McCoy's home, has died at Granville Thompson's in Lawrence County, Kentucky. The report characterizes him as a central villain of the feud's bloodiest episodes.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

Wheeling Register · 27 December 1888 · page 1

JOHNSE HATFIELD DEAD.

A'NOTiHER PA R DON. WASHINGTON, July 11?The presi? dent has pardoned W. D. Westmore? land, who pleaded guilty to resisting United Slates officers and sentenced to 5 years imprisonment by the District court for the western district of Vir? ginia. This action is taken because of the precarious condition of the priso? ner's health. "Devi! Amte'?" Sou In Limbo. (By Telegraph.) CHICAGO, July 11.?A sp.-eial to tho Record from Louisville. Ky.. says: Ellas Hatfield, the noted desperado and son of "Devil Anse" Hatfield, leader of the Hat field-McCoy feud that cost HI lives, surrendered to Governor Atkinson of West Virginia, in person today, ai Gray.

See moreSee less

Ha'tfleld shot Sheriff Ellis a week ago and has been holding off a posse in the Kentucky mountains. He sent word that he would surrender to Governor Atkinson only. Governor Atkinson and guards ar? rived at Gray this morning. Hatfield Immediately approached and shook hands with the governor. The prisoner left with the governor for Huntington. Hatfield looks for acquittal on the ground of self defense.

Clipping to come

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · Sacramento, Calif.

A dispatch from Charleston, W. Va. reports that Eureka detectives raided the Hatfields in Logan County and arrested Anse Hatfield, while also claiming that 'Johnston Hatfield,' described as the worst of the gang, had just died after being involved in the McCoy killings and the New Year's attack. The account confusingly merges him with 'Anse Johnston Hatfield,' called the most ferocious desperado next to his father.

UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out. CorrectionThis set right 4 earlier articles: Evening Star, 27 December 1888, The Evening World, 27 December 1888, The Evening World, 27 December 1888, Wheeling Register, 27 December 1888.

Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 28 December 1888 · page 1

A BAD SET.

TICULARS OF THE SURRENDER. Elias Hatfield is safe behind the bars Governor and said: of the Cabell county jail. The Advertiser yesterday evening Here is my gun.” gave an account of the surrender and that the party would arrive here on the 5:30 shuttle, but owing to a wreck on the N. & VV. they were detained one.” longer than at first expected, and they arrived here on No. 18, over the C. & O. which gets in at ten o’clock, fast time. Hatfield was in charge of Gov. G. \V.

See moreSee less

Atkinson and his private secretary E. L Boggs, who at once proceeded to the Adelphi hotel. Judge E S. Doolittle, w’ho had been notified by telegram, met them at the hotel and a consultation was held. Gov. Atkinson had promised the rela tives of young Hatfield that he would be taken on to Charleston, and that when the court was ready for trial, he would be returned, but Judge Doolittle refused to allow the prisoner to go out side of his jurisdiction, and accordingly was turned over to the authorities here. Gov Atkinson received a telegram Monday afternoon from relatives of Elias Hatfield asking him to come to Wbarneliffe, saying that Elias desired to surrender and wanted the Governor to furnish protection. Preparations were hurriedly made and in less than thirty minutes from the receipt of the message the chief executive and bis secretary were on their way. Upon their arrival at Wbarneliffe, Tuesday morning they were met at the station by Bob Hatfield, a brother of Elias, who escorted them to his home a short distance away where breakfast was served and after a short conver sation with the officers, “Devil Anse" Hatfield, father of the boy, left saying he would go and get him. In about half an hour the two returned from up one of the hollows, beiut; admired and Elias at once went before the

Clipping to come

Waterbury Evening Democrat · Waterbury, Conn.

Detectives hunting Hatfield gang members on a Kentucky governor's requisition cornered Tom Wallace, who opened fire and was shot dead. Before dying, Wallace confessed that he and Cap Hatfield were paid $50 each to kill Jeff McCoy about two years earlier.

Waterbury Evening Democrat · 31 December 1888 · page 1

ONE OF THE HATFIELD GANG.

Transcript to come.

Clipping to come

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

A dispatch reports that Kentucky officers trying to arrest Thomas Wallace, wanted for the murder of Jeff McCoy, shot him dead after he opened fire on them in Virginia. Before dying, Wallace allegedly confessed he and Captain Hatfield were paid $500 for the killing by a Buchanan County deputy sheriff.

Evening Star · 31 December 1888 · page 8

WALLACE, A MEMBER OF THE HATFIELD FACTION, SHOT DOWN BY OFFICERS.

SURRENDERED TO THE GOVERNOR. Louisville, July 12.—Elias Hatfield, the noted desperado and son cf “Deyil Anse” Hatfield, leader of the Hatfield McCoy feud, that cost 141 lives, sur rendered to Governor Atkinson, of West Virginia, in person, to-day at Gray, Hatfield o S eriff { Ellis a week ago, and has been holding off a posse in the Kentucky mountains. He sene word that he would surrender to

Clipping to come

In the story →

San Antonio Daily Light · San Antonio, Tex.

A wire dispatch reports that detectives tracking Hatfield gang members under a Kentucky governor's requisition shot and killed Tom Wallace near Flat Top Mountain after he opened fire on them. As he lay dying, Wallace allegedly confessed that he and 'Capt. Hatfield' had been paid $50 each by a Virginia deputy sheriff to kill Jeff McCoy about two years earlier.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

San Antonio Daily Light · 31 December 1888 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

LATEST TELEGRAPHIC NEWS

The Hatfields and McCoys. NEW YORK, Dec. 31.—A Charleston, W. Va., special says: Still another member of the great Hatfield gang of murderers, has been slain by detectives, who are prowling night and day over mountains of the wilderness, on the borders of Kentucky and West Virginia. David Strattan and Kentucky Biil, have been hunting down Tom Wallace upon a requisition from Governor Buckner, of Kentucky. They found them at at the Flat Top Mountain on the day before Christmas. Wallace is a dangerous man. When the detectives ordered him to halt he whipped out a big revolver and opened fire.

See moreSee less

His first bullet passed through a portion of Stratton's coat. The detectives returned the fire and Wallace fell dead; as the dying desperado breathed his last he confessed that he and Capt. Hatfield, were paid $50 each, by the deputy sheriff of Buchanan county, Va., and others for killing Jeff McCoy about two years ago. The murder money was placed in the hands of "Devil Auce" Hatfield, the father of the captain, and was paid to them when the bloody work was completed.

See the clipping

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.

Kentucky officers reportedly killed Thomas Wallace, said to be one of the Hatfield-McCoy feudists, while trying to arrest him on Flat Top Mountain, Virginia. Before dying he allegedly confessed that he and Cap Hatfield killed Jeff McCoy for a $50 payment arranged by a Virginia deputy sheriff.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.

Wrong

The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 31 December 1888 · page 1

A DESPERADO KILLED. One of the Hatfield-McCoy Gang Shot by Kentucky Officers, ON THE FLAT TOP MOUNTAIN, While Endeavoring to Arrest Him. He Confesses Before Dying—A Deputy Sheriff Paid Him to Kill McCoy—What He Got.

The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.

Clipping to come