As the Papers Told It

The Hatfields and the McCoys · The full archive

February 1889

2 articles

Wheeling Sunday Register · Wheeling, W. Va.

A dispatch from Charleston reports that detective Dan Cunningham, earlier arrested by the Hatfields in Logan County, was released after a writ of habeas corpus was granted by Judge Guthrie. The report claims his arrest was a ploy by the 'Hatfield-McCoy gang' to help its members evade detectives pursuing them.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 57 days later.

Wrong

Wheeling Sunday Register · 10 February 1889 · page 1

A During Enterprise. rock crek bd thy stugged, ow i th While In Pike county, Kentucky, Cun watr.nowou ofit nv onter' et ningham learned of a plot to bushwhack th' afedtern n iin thscp antt murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Ellison Hatfield, Black Elliott Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, murder ers of the McCoy children, and also of Miss Allaphare and Colvin M.%cCoy, in the attack on old Randall McCoy's house, had planned to 'ieawldbat h arhlsrvn to go from Jim Vance's house, which Is a togttehncfs nhsmnUnu few miles within the West Virginia line, over the border into Pike county, and lay ranc an0odto o th ate on for Phillips there.

See moreSee less

Cunningham planned a counter ambush, in which he enlisted Bill Napper, an experienced hunter, and a young man named Gibson, of less experi ence, but equal gameness. The marshal knew that any one of the Hatfield gang would kill him on sight. but that If he killed any of them he must stand trial for it, as the state administration of 'West Vir ginia was, for reasons of its own, friendly to the Hatfields. It looked like a dubious proposition, for the three Hatfield men had Winchesters, but Cunningham determined

Clipping to come

The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.

A brief notice reports that the West Virginia Legislature is said to be preparing an investigation into the Hatfield-McCoy troubles. It adds a wry quip suggesting the feuding families might instead investigate the Legislature's own troubles.

The Big Sandy News · 14 February 1889 · page 2

MARSHAL CUNNINGHAM. In Their Mountain Fslnfif of West Virginia, the llntflelils Defy the Law, and Terrorise Its Officers, Imt Cunningham Seek* Them Out in Tlielr Own Territory and Takes Them nt the Point of the Rille. The Triangular Fight That Ended in the Capture of Ellison Hut Held, donee Hntlield Taken ns He Was Lying in Wait for a Man Aunln.t Whom He Had a tiratlff —Capture of Gillespie and Messer, Who Help ed to Harder the McCoy Children. Charleston, W. Va., April s.—Through out the northern spurs of the Alleghanies the name of Hatfteld is a name of ter ror.

See moreSee less

Devil Anse and his clan have for years and almost with impunity ravaged the mountain region of four states. Vir ginia, West Virginia, Kentucky and Ten nessee, with murder, arson and all other crimes of violence. The murders perpe trated by them in the Hatfield-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes. Nowhere in criminal annals is there an other family with so foul and bloody a record. In their own home region of Southern West Virginia their dominance is com plete. There is a saying there, backed

Clipping to come