A Wheeling, W. Va. dispatch reports that Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Pike County, Kentucky, confessed to States Attorney Lee Ferguson his participation in the killing of the three McCoy brothers—Talbert, Farley (Pharmer), and Randolph—who were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot. The confession also implicates him in the killings of Jeff McCoy and of 'Alifera and Alvin McCoy.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
San Antonio Daily Light · 8 April 1889 · page 1
caped While in Pike county, Kentucky. Cun ningham learned of a plot to buah-whack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Ellison Hatfield,Black Elliott Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, mur derers of the McCoy children, and also
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The report describes the Hatfield-McCoy feud as having quieted down, with jailed Hatfields awaiting trial in Pike County, Kentucky after a jurisdictional dispute resolved by the U.S. Supreme Court in Kentucky's favor. It reveals that Ellison Hatfield (alias Mounts) voluntarily confessed to participating in feud murders and outrages before the county attorney and witnesses, despite being told it would not reduce his sentence.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 8 April 1889 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Confession.
ELLISON HATFIELD'S STORY
See moreSee less
Of the Part He Took in the Famous Hatfield-McCoy Feud.
The Murders and Outrages in which He Participated.
HIS VOLUNTARY STATEMENTS
To the State's Attorney in Pike County, Kentucky, Jail.
The Intelligencer Correspondent Secures a Copy of the Document—The Principal Feature of It—How Governor Wilson was Deceived.
Special Correspondence of the Intelligencer.
PIKEVILLE, PIKE COUNTY, KY., April 6.—The great Hatfield-McCoy feud on the Kentucky border of this State, about which so much has been published in the newspapers during the past year, and the history of which is familiar to all newspaper readers, has been almost suppressed, and for several months there has been no word of any outrages being perpetrated by the outlaws on either side of the line. It will be remembered that a number of the Hatfields were arrested by the Kentucky authorities and placed in the Pike County jail, where they still languish awaiting trial for a long list of the most heinous murders and outrages chronicled in the criminal annals of this country. An ineffectual effort to gain posession of the prisoners was made by Governor Wilson, of West Virginia, the matter being finally decided in favor of the Kentucky authorities by the U. S. Supreme Court.
Since then the State's Attorney of Pike county has been unceasing in his efforts to obtain sufficient evidence against the West Virginia gang to convict them. He found it a difficult matter on account of the unwillingness of those in posession of any knowledge to give testimony.
Recently, however, Ellison Hatfield (alias Mounts) consented to make a confession, which he did in the presence of County Attorney J. Lee Ferguson, the Jailor, and five others, one of whom was J. M. York, a lawyer. Hatfield voluntarily told his story after being told that a confession would not in any manner lighten his sentence. His relation of the horrible acts, in which he was a principal actor, is of a thrilling character. The correspondent of the INTELLIGENCER has succeeded in obtaining a copy of it from the County Attorney. Following are the main features of
HATFIELD'S CONFESSION:
Ellison Hatfield in the presence of the above witnesses said, in substance:
I was present and participated in the murder of the three McCoy brothers, namely, Tolbert McCoy, Farmer McCoy, and Randolph McCoy. It was on the night of the 9th of August, 1882, at the mouth Blackberry creek, Pike county, Ky. The three brothers were taken from a log school house in Logan county, W. Va., where they had been guarded for a day and a night, and brought over the Tug river, which separates West Virginia from Kentucky. They were tied arm in arm with a plow line and led by one Charles Carpenter to the river and placed in a small boat, accompanied by Ans. Hatfield, Bill Hatfield, Tom Mitchell, Alex Musser, Dan White, Mose Christian, Sam Mahorn, Joe Murphy, Jeff Whitt and myself. We brought them to the Kentucky side and led them by the rope up the bank about fifty feet from the river. Carpenter tied them to a paw-paw bush and hung a lantern over their heads. Ans Hatfield then said to them: "Boys, if you have any peace to make with your Maker, you had better make it."
Tolbert and Randolph began praying but Farmer (we called him Dick) did not. However, before the boys had time to finish their prayers, John Hatfield shot Farmer dead. Ans. then gave the order to fire, and shot as he gave the word, killing Tolbert and then emptying the contents of the revolver into the dead body. Alex Musser then fired and killed Randolph McCoy. As soon as the first shots were fired the others followed suit, and all the bodies were riddled with bullets.
A TERRIBLE OATH.
The parties who were engaged in the shooting of the boys were Ans Hatfield, John Hatfield, Cap Hatfield, Bill Tom Hatfield, Alex Musser, Charlie Carpenter and Thomas Mitchell.
After the boys were killed we crossed the river back into Logan county, West Virginia, where we found Wall Hatfield and some others waiting for us. Wall then ordered us into line and administered an oath to all of us binding us to take the life of the first to divulge the name or names of any who were along, and to solemn secrecy, and wound up the oath by asking us if our feelings were not gratified. Ans, Cap and Johns Hatfield and Tom Mitchell said "yes." We then left. I went to Pat Hatfield's and stayed all night, and all the rest went to Elias Hatfield's and I went there next day. The corpse of Ellison Hatfield was at the house of Elias. Prior to our going into Kentucky with the McCoy boys we bound ourselves to have revenge for the death of Ellison Hatfield [the prisoner's father who had been shot by the McCoys] and to kill all the murderers.
[Wall Hatfield, who administered the above oath, was at that time a Justice of the Peace.]
BEATING HELPLESS WOMEN.
Cap. Hatfield told me that Tom Wallace and himself had gone to Pike county from West Virginia to the house of Bill Daniels, and found Daniels and his family in bed; that Tom presented his gun at Mr. Daniels and told him that if he moved he would kill him; that he (Cap) wrapped the hairy part of a cow's tail about his hand and beat Daniels' wife almost to death with the stub part of it in the presence of her husband. He then took the gun and held it to Daniels' head while Tom committed a similar assault on the old man's daughter. They then went back to West Virginia.
MURDER OF JEFF M'COY.
Cap. Hatfield told the deponent that he and Tom Wallace captured Jeff McCoy, tied him with a halter to their saddles and drove him down the road to William Ferrell's house, in Logan county, W. Va. Cap. went into the yard, and while he was there Jeff freed himself from the halter and ran across a field to Tug river. His late captors pursued him, firing several shots. He succeeded in swimaing [swimming] across the river without being hit, but as he was running up the bank on the Kentucky side, a shot aimed by Tom Wallace struck him, and he fell dead.
MURDER OF ELIFIRI M'COY.
On January 1, 1888, I was at work at my mother's house, on the Guian river, when John Hatfield and Tom Mitchell came after me and said that Cap Hatfield had sent for me. He told me that the Kentucky people had offered a reward of $500 for me—and that I had better stand in with them. So I went with them. We met Ans, Cap and Bob Hatfield at Dow Steel's, on Island Creek. We went from there to Henry Vance's, and from there to Floyd Hatfield's.
The prisoner described visits to all the Hatfields in turn and continued:
Finally, on Sunday morning we arrived at the house of Jim Vance, sr. We stayed there for quite a while, and Ans and Cap Hatfield and Vance went to one side and talked a while. They called me to them and said some of these Kentucky people must be killed, and that I must go along. Ans said he was sick and not able to go, and told Jim Vance to take command of the party. Before we started out Vance held up his hands and repeated three times:
"May hell be my heaven, I will kill the man that goes back on me to-night, if powder will burn."
Nine of the party left Vance's house and went up the river to Cap Hatfield's, arriving there about 4 or 5 o'clock p.m. Sunday, and got our supper there. We all stayed there until some time after dark, and all left together and went to the West Virginia side, to Amos Hatfield's house, opposite the mouth of Peter creek, in Pike county, Ky. We then went down to the river, pulled off our shoes and rolled up our pants and waded the river to the Kentucky side, to the mouth of Pounding Mill Branch, and up it and over to the Peter Fork of Blackberry, down to main Blackberry creek and up it to the mouth of Jerry Hatfield's branch, and up it and over to the Blackberry fork of Pond creek, and down it to near Randolph McCoy's house, where we made a halt. Cap Hatfield, John Hatfield and Jim Vance put on masks.
Jim Vance, Sr., directed each man where to go and what to do. He then directed Mitchell, Gillespie and Ellis to go to the lower of the big houses and told them to watch and not let any men come out dressed in woman's clothing. If they did to capture them. He then directed Elliott Hatfield and Bob Hatfield to go to the lower door of the kitchen. He told Cap Hatfield and me to go to the upper door of the kitchen, and he said that Johns Hatfield and himself would go to the upper door of the big house. We arrived at the house about half-past ten o'clock that night.
When we got very near the house we all slipped up very easy and made no noise. We all took our positions as directed by James Vance, Sr. Vance changed his voice and called to the McCoys to come out and surrender as prisoners of war. Cap Hatfield asked: "Are they coming out?" There was no response from inside the house and Cap said: "G—d d—n it, fire it! fire it!"
THE MURDERS.
We began shooting through the doors of what we called the big house in opposite directions. There was several shots fired from the inside of the house, and the shooting continued for some time from inside and out.
Calvin McCoy got upstairs and shot one of our party. Jim Vance, Sr., went to the house and found some cotton hanging against the side. He lit it with a match and placed a part of it in a joist hole, and the rest against the shutter of the door. Two shots were fired through the door from the inside of the house. We heard Calvin McCoy call to the girls (his sisters), who were in the kitchen, to go out and put out the fire. Vance said: "Boys, if they come out, d——n them, shoot them."
About this time a girl opened the door of the kitchen and Cap. and Johns both cried to me: 'D—n her, kill her.' I had a 32 calibre Winchester rifle, I fired at her and she fell in the doorway. I heard her sister ask her if she was hurt. She muttered something, but I could not understand it. I heard one of the girls say: "Farewell sister." Calvin McCoy called down stairs to know if anyone was killed and one of the girls said, "Yes, they have killed Alifari." The firing from both sides kept up for some time, until I was shot through the left arm by Calvin McCoy. The ball entered just above the wrist below the elbow. Cap and Johns Hatfield both told me afterward that they killed Calvin McCoy. They were both bragging about it, and each one claimed that he killed him. But I think from the position of the two that Cap killed Calvin McCoy. Three of our party was wounded. Tom Mitchel was shot in the right hand, shooting off three of his fingers and some of the shots went into his belt. Johns Hatfield was shot in the top of the right shoulder. He had on a heavy overcoat and the shots only entered the flesh very slightly. I saw the shots taken out. They were bird shot. We did not know that we had killed Calvin McCoy until the next day.
When we left the house it was in a good flame. The women were crying and begging for help to put out the fire. We returned to West Virginia by the same route that we came. I fainted on the way from loss of blood. We arrived at Cap Hatfield's about daylight and took breakfast.
DECEIVING GOV. WILSON.
The prisoner then detailed subsequent but unimportant events in which he bore a part, concluding as follows:
On the Thursday or Friday night after the house burning we all went together to Harve Duty's house, in Logan county. Joe Simpkins, a justice of the peace, was present, and each of us told where he was on the night of the burning of McCoy's house, and swore to it. This was done for the purpose of sending the affidavit to Gov. Wilson to keep him from honoring the requisition from the Governor of Kentucky. These affidavits were sent to Gov. Wilson and seemed to have the desired effect, but there was not a word of truth in them.
"The above and many like tricks were resorted to to keep Gov. Wilson from handing us over to the Kentucky authorities."
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A Pike County confession, obtained from a man identified in the article as Ellison Hatfield (apparently Ellison Mounts), describes how the McCoy brothers were tied, shot, and killed by a group of Hatfield-allied men at South Blackberry Creek in August 1882. The county attorney obtained the statement after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Kentucky's favor on jurisdiction, aiding efforts to convict the West Virginia gang.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 8 April 1889 · page 1
HIS VOLUNTARY STATEMENTS
Throughout the northern spurs of tho Alleghenics the name of Hatfield is u terror. Devil A use and his clan have for ycart, and almost with Impun ity ravaged the mountain region of four states, Virginia, West Virginia. Kentucky and Tennessee, with murdei, arson, and all ether crimes of violence. The murders perpetrated by them In i the Hatfleld-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes. Nowhere in criminal annals is there another
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
A deponent describes in detail how the McCoy boys were shot by a group of Hatfields and associates, then recounts how Wall Hatfield administered an oath binding all participants to secrecy under threat of death. The testimony also describes related violence, including an assault on Daniels' family and the pursuit and killing of Tolbert McCoy.
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · 8 April 1889 · page 1
A TERRIBLE OATH
The murders perpetrated by them In i the Hatfleld-McCoy feud are only a small part of their crimes. Nowhere in criminal annals is there another family with so foul and bloody a l co ord. In their own homo legion of South ern West Virginia their dominance is complete. There Is a saying there, backed by a long and grim record, that to offend a Hatfield Is the surest form of suicide. Even tho offlcers of tho law seldom interfere with them and though the aggregate of IndictmenU against the clan amounts up into tho hundreds, its membeis, armed to tha teeth, not only ride free in their own mountains, but even visit the cltie?
See moreSee less
unmolested when they choose. If the take a grudge against a man they hunt him to his death, and their list of victims was a long one before any man, except the McCoys, raiding in re
Clipping to come
The Wheeling Daily Intelligencer · Wheeling, W. Va.
The piece discusses a voluntary confession by Ellison Hatfield, described as one of the feud's leaders, which was published that morning and reveals how West Virginia authorities were misled into defending the Hatfields. The editorial calls for justice against all those involved and suggests a confession from the McCoy side would be equally illuminating.
A dispatch from Wheeling, W. Va. reports that Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Kentucky, has confessed to the murders of the McCoy brothers and others, naming various Hatfield family members as killers. The account describes the McCoys being tied to a tree and executed, and recounts other killings including that of a McCoy girl.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Sacramento Daily Record-Union · 9 April 1889 · page 4
Anso and bad heard bis side of the Hat-Cold-McCoy history. Shortly after that he toyed at tho house of Jim Vunve, ono of tun Hatfield leaders, who hud been killed while, raiding In Kentucky, and heard from Vance's widow tho story of tho butchery of thrco defenHelcss McCoy children by a force
Clipping to come
Los Angeles Daily Herald · Los Angeles, Calif.
A jailed Hatfield confesses to the ambush killing of the McCoy brothers—Talbert, Farley, and Randolph McCoy—describing how they were marched to a tree and shot by name. The confession also covers the earlier 1888 killing of Jeff McCoy and the burning/shooting of the McCoy home that killed Alifair and wounded Alifair McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Los Angeles Daily Herald · 9 April 1889 · page 6
The Virginia Vendetta
Whllo In riko county, Kontucky, Cun nlngham learned of a plot to bushwhack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of tho McCoy family. Ellison Hutfleld, Black Elliot Hatfield and Tom Mitchell, mur dcrers of tho McCoy chlldron and ulso of Miss Allopharo and Colvln McCoy, In tho attack on did Randall McCoy's house, Had planned, to go from Jim Vanco's house, which Is u few miles within tbo West Vir ginia line, over tho border Into Tike county, and lay for Phillips there. Cun ningham planned n counter ambush, in which ho enlisted Hill Nappor, an exper ienced hunter, aud a young man named Gibson of less experience, but equal game nets. Tho marshal know that auy one of tho Hatfield gang would kill him on sight
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A dispatch from Wheeling reports that a jailed Hatfield feudist has confessed to participating in the 1882 killing of the three McCoy brothers, tied to a pawpaw bush and shot by the river. The confession also implicates others in the murder of Jeff McCoy and of Alifera and Calvin McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
New-York Tribune · 9 April 1889 · page 1
CONFESSION OF CAPTAIN HATFIELD. HIS ACCOUNT OF THE MURDER OF THE M'COY BROTHERS IN WEST VIRGINIA.
■ty United States Marshal Daniel W. Cunningham of the district of West Virginia. While in Pike county, Ivy., Cunning ham learned of, a plot to bushwhack and murder Frank Phillips, a partisan of the McCoy family. Eilison Hatfield, Black Elliott Hatfield and Tom Mitch ell, murderers of the McCoy children and also of Miss Allaphare.and Colvin McCoy in the attack on old Itaudall McCoy’s house, had planned to go from Jim Vance’s house, which is a few miles within the West Virginia line, over the border into Pike county, and lay for Phillips there.
See moreSee less
Cunningham planned a counter ambush, in which he enlisted Bill Napper, an experienced hunter, and a young man named Gib son, of less experience, but equal game ness. The marshal knew that any one of the Hatfield gang would kill him on
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A captured Hatfield faction member gives a detailed confession describing the execution-style killings of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy Jr., including Anse Hatfield's order to fire and the administering of a death oath to conspirators. He also describes the 1888 raid in which Alifair McCoy was shot while trying to extinguish a house fire and the killing of Calvin McCoy.
A jailed Hatfield reportedly confessed to State's Attorney Lee Ferguson his participation in the killing of the three McCoy brothers, describing how they were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot. The confession also claims involvement in the killing of Jeff McCoy and mentions the murder of Alifair and Alvin McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 April 1889 · page 1
THE HATFIELD-McCOY GANG.
At the first wrench after they had clinched both went over the bank. In the rocky creek bed they struggled now in the water, now' out of it. nevei on their feot. the Hatfield tearing and biting as his captor like a wild beast, the marshal striving to get the hand cuffs on his man. Endurance and con dition won the battle. Moonshine wtais ky is bad for the vind, and when Nap per and Mitclsell returned empty hand cd Ellison was tied and handcuffed •while Cunningham was washing hit bruised and bloody face In the creek Thereafter' whenever Cunningham tras iii t.-' ; part of tlK’ State the Iiatlields followed hiin.
See moreSee less
Thai they never succeeded in eatching up to Ilia would seem'to indicate a lack of coal on their part, difficult to reconcile with the terror of their threats. Three years ago the marshal gave them an excellent chance to get him had they been on the alert. In a drunken revel one night they had instituted a little Tit". il” otjaoJr cTfaThiiefttffrally In their driving him into a. pond, where he was drowned. His 9-year-old boy they took to bring up in their clan. The boy’s uncle learned of It and ad vertised a reward lor the recovery of ite child. Nobody came forward to apply for the job until a friend sug gested that Mr. Duffy write to Dan Cunningham. That official took three days off. rode alone Into the Hatfield settlement, found the boy at a house within half a mile of “Devil Anse's” homestead, grabbed him up on his horse and galloped away. If the Hat fields followed, he did not know It. Thus was spoiled an outlaw in the making. in-uuueri, u. \ a., lives ijoc i-Jllls, a well to do timber owner. Against him the notorious Jonce Hatfield had sworn a grudge for some fancied grievance and sent word that he would kill him on sight. As it was a great detriment to Eliis' business to have a Hatfield gunning for him he hired a crack shot named Hopkins to keep watch for Jonce and shoot first. Neither Hop kins nor Jonce had had any luck in their shooting, when Dan Cunningham came to Gilbert and put up at Ellis’ house. Ellis told him of Jouce’s threat. “I’ve got a little business with Jonce myself,” said Cunningham. “Reckon I’ll hang around for a few days.” Two evenings later Hopkins came in and said that two men with Winches ters were lying out in a ragweed path near the house. One of them, he thought, was Jcuee Hatfield. “We’ll go out and get them,” said Cunningham. Hopkins was willing, and a lumber man who had dropped in volunteered to go along. Counting in Ellis, the par ty was four strong all aroiind. But Jonce had a reputation as a dead shot, had killed a dozen men, and he and his companion had all the advantage of the position. Cunningham led his forces out of the house by a rear exit and around by a gully to a spot near the ragweed patch. He had made a study of the ground about the house previously and knew just how to go ahead. With Ellis close behind him he crept up close to where Jonce crouched. The outlaw had his gun pointed at a lighted window of the Ellis house, waiting for a figure to show. The curtain was down. It al ways was in that house, for just such a reason. “Don’t reckon we'll get him tonight,” tiie attacking party heard Jonce mut ter to his companion. “Shall I shoot the vile murderer?” whispered Ellis. “No," replied Cunningham. “I want i him alive.” Then he broke cover and went ; straight for .Tonee. Hatfield wheeled, but Cunuingham’s rifle pointed straight ! between his eyes. The other man dropped on all fours and scuttled away through the weeds. Jonce stood par alyzed. ! "lianas up: commanaea cunning 1 ham. The outlaw hesitated. “Reach for the stars! Quick!” came the sharp order. The outlaw’s rifle fell, and his hands went up. Cunningham took from him a .44 caliber revolver and a fine Eng lish dirk and left him in charge of Ellis while he went after the other man. The man was soon found and captured. 'He was Auk Dameron, and, as Cunningham knew nothing at that time against him. he was released. This proved to he an error, for it was afterward found that Dameron had broken jail under sentence of death for the murder of a deputy sheriff in Virginia. Cunningham took .Tonce Hat i field to Kentucky, where he broke down and confessed. He is now serv ing a life sentence for the murder of the McCoy children. Naturally that i ( —1 ~ . ", -U
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
A captured Hatfield faction member gives a detailed confession describing the execution of Tolbert, Pharmer (Farley), and Randolph McCoy by the river, including the oath of silence administered afterward. The confession also describes the killing of Jeff McCoy and the house-burning murder of Alifair McCoy.
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 April 1889 · page 1
THE HATFIELD-McCOY GANG
The Cincinnati Times-Star Thursday refers to "the famoua McCoy-Hal Held feud in Mason County, Ky." The T. S. missed it by about two hundred miles.
Clipping to come
The Indianapolis Journal · Indianapolis, Ind.
This editorial piece references the Hatfield and McCoy type of desperado as an example of reckless, bloody feuding more barbarous than tales of the Wild West. It uses the feud rhetorically to argue that Kentucky and Virginia produce more thrilling violent dramas than frontier cowboy country.
The Indianapolis Journal · 9 April 1889 · page 4
Important West Virginia (ase Appealed. BITTERLY FOUGHT FOR MANY YEARS Appellants Msmbers of Notorious Hatfield Family — Attorneys Fired Upon, One Shot, and One Assailant Killed. Under the title “S. D. Hatfield and Naney C. Rutherford vs. Henry C. King,” an appeal now pending before the Su preme Cecurt of the United States, is con cealed what in many respects is one of A ———— RNA RR TER AREER EAT. m= the most remarkable cases ever brought before that court for adjudication. The appellants in the case are members of the family made notorious by the Hat field-McCoy feud.
See moreSee less
| Involved in it is not only the title to about 809,000 acres of valuable agricul tural timber and mineral land in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Virginia, to gether with the constitutionality of the land laws of the State first named, but also the question of disbarring from prac tice before the Supreme Court of two attorneys against whom have been filed charges of fixing up a fictitious and fraud ulent suit to be used for the purpose of obtaining a judgment against the 400 and odd settlers now in possession of that part of the land in West Virginia. Old Morris and Clinton Traets. One tract of this land known as the Robert Morris survey, consisting of 500.000 acres, lying in the three States mentioned, was granted to Robert Morris, of Philadelphia, by the Commonwealth of Virginia, under patent dated June I3, 1795. The other tract, embracing 142,000 acres, was granted by Virginia to DeWitt Clinton as assignee of William Duval, February 19, 179. This lies entirely within the State of West Virginia, and it is claimed, overlaps in part the Morris grant. in 18%4 the West Virginia authorities, acting under a State law providing for the forfeiture of lands not entered in the land registry or upon which taxes had not been paid for a period of five years, brought suit against that portion of the Morris tract within Wyoming, Lo gan, Mingo, and McDowell counties. The period in this instance was at least eleven years, and upon some parts of the a ———— tract it was shown that the holders themselves had paid the taxes for more than twenty years. Orizin of Present Litization. Acting upon a detree in its favor the "State sold the lands to about four hun dreé individuals and corporations who are now in possession and against whom suits of ejectment have been filed by Henry C. King, of New York, who claims ownership of the entire tract under con vevance from Robert Morris. This litigation for possession, instituted by King in 18%5, has been going on ever since in the chancery, county, State, and United States eircuit courts of West Vir giuia, and has previously been before the Supreme Court of the United States in one form or another on three or four occa sions. King. in additien to innumerable suits for ejectment. has sued cut mary injunc tions to restrain the occupants of the lands claimed by him from disposing of the timber or coai thereon. Attorneys Repeatedly Fired on. The feeling against atlorneys im that part of the State was so intense that they have been fired on repeatedly. One of them, Stiles. wa= wounded, and one of his assistants was killed. In the eoriginal action King set up the claim that there had been no forfeiture of the lands, aliegiog a decree patenting the Jands under the State law had been ob tained by his predecessers in 1882, but he offered, if that decree were deemcd in valid. to pay all back taxes due. Before the chancery suit was decided, however, King brought an action in the United States Cirenit Court to eject the various holders of the land, and from the adverse judgrient of that court he appealed to the Supreme Court of the United States. Pending the hearing of this appeal an agreement was made by King's attorneys and filed in court that no uetion shouid be had in ithe chancery | case or the proceedings before the com missioner of school lands in Wyoming county. } King's Alleged Breach of Faith. Notwithstanding. and in violation of this agreement, King, it is alleged, ob tained in 1897 a report from the com missioner, and, without notice to the parties concerned, they claim, obtained from the Circuit Court of Wyoming county a decree of redemption for that portion of the 560,000 acres in West Virginia. The decree fixed the boundaries as claimed by King, a large part of the
Clipping to come
St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.
A Wheeling dispatch reports that a man identified as Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Pike County, confessed to attorney Lee Ferguson his role in the murder of the three McCoy brothers, describing how they were tied to a pawpaw bush, forced to pray, and shot by multiple Hatfield men. He also claimed involvement in the killing of Jeff McCoy and of Alifair and Alvin McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
St. Paul Daily Globe · 9 April 1889 · page 1
CONFESSED HIS CRIME.
One Assailant Killed. Under the title “S. D. Hatfield and Naney C. Rutherford vs. Henry C. King,” an appeal now pending before the Su preme Cecurt of the United States, is con cealed what in many respects is one of the most remarkable cases ever brought before that court for adjudication. The appellants in the case are members of the family made notorious by the Hat field-McCoy feud. | Involved in it is not only the title to about 809,000 acres of valuable agricul tural timber and mineral land in West Virginia, Kentucky, and Virginia, to gether with the constitutionality of the land laws of the State first named, but also the question of disbarring from prac tice before the Supreme Court of two attorneys against whom have been filed charges of fixing up a fictitious and fraud ulent suit to be used for the purpose of obtaining a judgment against the 400 and odd settlers now in possession of that part of the land in West Virginia.
Clipping to come
St. Paul Daily Globe · Saint Paul, Minn.
A captured Hatfield recounts in detail the pawpaw-bush killing of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy, as well as the slayings of Jeff McCoy, Alifair McCoy, and Calvin McCoy. He also describes an oath of silence sworn by the participants after the killings.
St. Paul Daily Globe · 9 April 1889 · page 1
CONFESSED HIS CRIME.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Helena Independent · Helena, Mont.
A jailed participant identified as Ellison Hatfield reportedly confessed to the killing of the three McCoy brothers—Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph—describing how they were tied to a tree and shot by name. The account also details earlier killings of Jeff McCoy and the 1888 raid in which Alifair and Alvin McCoy died when the Hatfields burned their house.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Helena Independent · 9 April 1889 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Daily Morning Astorian · Astoria, Oregon
A dispatch reports that Ellison and (Wall) Hatfield, held in a Kentucky jail for the Hatfield-McCoy feud, confessed to killing Tolbert, Pharmer (rendered 'Farley'), and Randolph McCoy, describing how they were tied to a tree and shot. The account also describes the earlier killing of Jeff McCoy and the burning of a house in which Alifair and Calvin McCoy died.
The Daily Morning Astorian · 9 April 1889 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.
A man identified as Ellison Hatfield, held in the Pike County jail, reportedly confessed to State Attorney Lee Ferguson about his role in killing the three McCoy brothers—Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph—who were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot after being forced to pray. He also implicated other Hatfields, described an oath of silence being administered afterward, and claimed involvement in the killing of Jeff McCoy and the deaths of Alifair and Alvin McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Memphis Appeal · 9 April 1889 · page 2
THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.
A prisoner's confession describes the Hatfield faction's killing of three McCoy brothers tied to pawpaw bushes, including shooting Farley before he finished praying, then binding witnesses to secrecy with an oath. The confession also recounts the earlier cross-river raid that killed Alifair and Alvin McCoy, including the burning of the McCoy home.
The Memphis Appeal · 9 April 1889 · page 2
THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Waco Evening News · Waco, Tex.
Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Pike County, confessed to Kentucky's state attorney that he took part in the 1882 killing of three McCoy brothers tied to a pawpaw bush near Tug River. He described Anse Hatfield ordering the shooting, named several participants, and also referenced other killings including Jeff McCoy and the McCoy family members Alifair and Alvin.
Waco Evening News · 9 April 1889 · page 1
Carnival of Crime
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Salt Lake Herald · Salt Lake City, Utah
A dispatch from Wheeling reports that Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Kentucky, confessed to details of the killing of the three McCoy brothers and other feud murders, naming participants including John Hatfield, Ans Hatfield, Alex Messer, and Wall Hatfield. It also describes the burning of a house and killing of Allifair and Alex McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Salt Lake Herald · 9 April 1889 · page 1
THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · Cheyenne, Wyo.
A dispatch from Wheeling reports that a man identified as Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Kentucky, confessed to the ambush murders of the three McCoy brothers, Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph, describing how they were tied to a tree and shot by name individuals. The confession also implicates the same group in the 1888 killing of Jeff McCoy and the burning of a house where a girl was shot.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Cheyenne Daily Leader · 9 April 1889 · page 1
THE HATFIELD-McCOY FEUD
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis
A Wheeling dispatch reports that a Hatfield feud participant, jailed in Pike County, confessed to State Attorney Lee Ferguson his role in the 1882 killing of the three McCoy brothers (Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph) at Tug River, as well as the later murders of Jeff McCoy and of Alifair and Calvin McCoy. The confession details how the McCoy brothers were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot by Hatfield gang members including Anse, John, and Alexander Messer.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 10 April 1889 · page 8
A MURDERER'S CONFESSION.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Indiana State Sentinel · Indianapolis
A confessed participant describes the execution of the McCoy brothers tied to a pawpaw bush, naming Anse and John Hatfield as shooters, and details other killings including Jeff McCoy and Alifair McCoy during the New Year's raid. He also describes an oath of silence administered afterward by Wall Hatfield.
The Indiana State Sentinel · 10 April 1889 · page 8
A MURDERER'S CONFESSION.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.
A dispatch from Wheeling reports that Ellison Hatfield, held in the Pike County jail, confessed to the state attorney his role in the 1882 killing of the three McCoy brothers at Tug River. The account details the binding, shooting, and mutilation of the victims and references an oath of silence among the participants.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The Portland Daily Press · 10 April 1889 · page 1
BOASTED OF THEIR CRIME. One of the Hatfields Confesses the Murders by the Gang.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Portland Daily Press · Portland, Me.
A captured member of the Hatfield faction details the execution of Tolbert and Randolph McCoy, describing how Cap Hatfield gave the order to fire and others emptied their revolvers into the bodies. He also implicates others in the killing of Jeff McCoy and the burning of the McCoy homestead during the January 1888 raid that killed Alifair and Alvin McCoy.
The Portland Daily Press · 10 April 1889 · page 1
BOASTED OF THEIR CRIME.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · Butte, Mont.
A Wheeling dispatch reports that Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Kentucky, confessed to the killing of the Maze brothers and gave details of other feud-related murders, including that of Jeff McCoy and two McCoy sisters. The account names various Hatfield family members as participants in the killings.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Butte Semi-Weekly Miner · 10 April 1889 · page 1
CONFESSION OF A VILLAIN.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · Santa Fe, N.M.
A dispatch from Wheeling, W. Va. reports that Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Kentucky for his role in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, has confessed to murdering McCoy brothers Talbert, Farley, and Randolph by tying them to a tree and shooting them. The report also claims Hatfield and Tom Wallace killed Jeff McCoy, and gives details of the 1888 killing of Alifair and Calvin McCoy by the Hatfield gang.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Santa Fe Daily New Mexican · 10 April 1889 · page 1
Deadly Feud
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
A jailed Hatfield feud participant, Ellison Mounts (called 'Elli-od Hatfield'), gives a detailed confession to the state attorney describing how the three McCoy brothers were taken from a schoolhouse, marched to the Tug River, and shot. He names several Hatfield faction members as participants and also mentions the killings of Alifair and Calvin McCoy and Jeff McCoy.
A captured Hatfield gang member describes in graphic detail the night the three McCoy sons—Tolbert, Pharmer ('Farley'), and Randolph Jr.—were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot after a mock prayer, with various Hatfield men taking credit for different killings. The confession also implicates the group in other murders, including Jeff McCoy and the burning of the McCoy homestead that killed Alifair McCoy.
Reporter and Farmer · 11 April 1889 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.
A dispatch from Wheeling reports that Ellison Hatfield, held in a Kentucky jail, confessed to State Attorney Lee Ferguson his role in killing the three McCoy brothers—Tolbert, Pharmer (Fairly), and Randolph—who were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot after being marched across Tug River. The confession details Anse (Devil Anse) Hatfield ordering the executions and names other participants, including John Hatfield and Alex Mahon/Messer.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.
Wrong
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 11 April 1889 · page 9
THE HATFIELD-M'COY VENDETTA
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Austin Weekly Statesman · Austin, Tex.
A captured participant recounts how Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy Jr. were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot after being told to pray, followed by an oath of silence among the killers. He also describes the earlier January 1888 raid on the McCoy homestead in which the house was burned and Alifair McCoy was killed while trying to put out the flames.
The Austin Weekly Statesman · 11 April 1889 · page 9
THE HATFIELD-M'COY VENDETTA
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The New North-West · Deer Lodge, Mont.
A report claims Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Kentucky, confessed to killing the three Maze (McCoy) brothers after a staged execution, and also detailed the killing of Jeff McCoy and the deaths of two McCoy women in a house fire set by the Hatfield gang. The account names several participants and describes an oath of silence sworn among the gang.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The New North-West · 12 April 1889 · page 2
THE HATFIELD-M'COY VENDETTA.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The United Opinion · Bradford, Vt.
The brief item states that Ellison Hatfield, a participant in the Hatfield-McCoy feud, is held in the Pike County, Kentucky jail and has confessed to the state attorney that he took part in killing the three McCoy brothers, Tolbert, Pharmer (Farley), and Randolph (Bud). It appears amid a column of short unrelated news items from April 10, 1889.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 6 days later.
Wrong
The United Opinion · 12 April 1889 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.
A man identified as Ellison Hatfield, jailed in Pike County, confesses to the State's Attorney his role in the murder of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy, describing how the brothers were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot by lantern light while praying. The confession names several participants and describes an oath taken afterward to kill anyone who revealed the others' identities.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 5 days later.
Wrong
Macon Beacon · 13 April 1889 · page 1
HATFIELD'S CONFESSION
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Macon Beacon · Macon, Miss.
A captured Hatfield confederate describes in detail the execution of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy Jr. by the river, including Ellison 'Cap' Hatfield's vow of secrecy among the killers. The same confession also recounts the earlier 1888 New Year's Night raid in which Alifair and Calvin McCoy were killed during the burning of the McCoy home.
This is a review announcing the publication of T. C. Crawford's book 'An American Vendetta,' which compiles a complete account of the Hatfield-McCoy feud. The notice praises the book for gathering newspaper coverage, previously published piecemeal, into one graphic narrative.
The Morning News · 15 April 1889 · page 7
BOOK NOTICES.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn. · and 1 other paper
A man identified as Ellison Hatfield confesses to State's Attorney Lee Ferguson about his role in the murder of three McCoy brothers, describing how they were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot. The confession also covers the killing of Jeff McCoy and other feud violence.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
New Ulm Weekly Review · 17 April 1889 · page 2
A Horrible Tale of Murder
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
Reporter and Farmer · Webster, S.D. · 11 April 1889
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · Prescott, Ariz.
The article claims Ellison Hatfield, held in a Kentucky jail, confessed to the murder of three McCoy brothers who were tied to a tree and shot, and also described killing Jeff McCoy and the deaths of Alifera and Alven McCoy. It attributes further details of the feud's killings to this confession.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Arizona Weekly Journal-Miner · 17 April 1889 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
New Ulm Weekly Review · New Ulm, Minn.
A captured Hatfield gang member confesses to the execution-style killings of Tolbert, Pharmer (Farley), and Randolph McCoy Jr. by a river, describing how they were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot one by one. He also details the January 1888 raid on the McCoy homestead where the house was burned and Alifair McCoy was killed, plus the deaths of Jeff and Calvin McCoy.
New Ulm Weekly Review · 17 April 1889 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The National Tribune · Washington, D.C.
A brief item states that Ellison Hatfield gave a confession detailing his own role and that of his companions in the numerous murders stemming from the Hatfield-McCoy feud in West Virginia and Kentucky. The notice appears amid a roundup of unrelated crime and disaster items from around the country.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The National Tribune · 18 April 1889 · page 12
CRIMES AND CASUALTIES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Big Sandy News · Louisa, Ky.
The item states that Ellison Hatfield, held in jail at Pikeville, confessed to his part in the McCoy murders. This brief notice appears amid a roundup of unrelated local news items.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Big Sandy News · 18 April 1889 · page 2
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
West Virginia Argus · Kingwood, W. Va.
Ellison Hatfield, also known as Ellison Mounts and jailed in Pike County, Kentucky, confessed to State Attorney Ferguson his role in the killing of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy Jr. He described how the brothers were taken from a schoolhouse, brought to the Tug River, and shot by several Hatfields after being made to pray, with an oath afterward binding participants to silence.
A prisoner's testimony recounts the ambush and killing of Tolbert and Randolph McCoy near the river, followed by Wall Hatfield's oath binding the group to silence. The same account describes Jeff McCoy's killing after escape, and the earlier New Year's raid in which Alifair McCoy was shot in the doorway and Calvin McCoy was killed.
West Virginia Argus · 18 April 1889 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Logan County Banner · Logan, W. Va.
This is a legal notice listing numerous tracts of land purchased by various parties, including several Hatfield family members, warning the public against trespassing on these lands. It is surrounded by unrelated advertisements for hotels, general merchandise, real estate, and professional services in Logan, West Virginia.
The Logan County Banner · 18 April 1889 · page 3
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 1 other paper
A Hatfield-faction prisoner, confusingly identified as both Ellison Hatfield and Ellison Mounts, confesses to Kentucky's state attorney about his role in killing the three McCoy brothers—Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph Jr.—who were tied to a bush and shot after being marched across the Tug River. He also describes the killing of Jeff McCoy and implicates numerous other Hatfield family members by name.
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 24 April 1889
Fisherman & Farmer · Edenton, N.C. · and 1 other paper
A captured Hatfield gang member describes how the three McCoy brothers were shot and finished off after being lined up, and recounts later killings of Jeff McCoy, Alifair McCoy, and Calvin McCoy by Hatfield raiders. The account also describes an oath of silence sworn among the participants after the killings.
Fisherman & Farmer · 19 April 1889 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Abbeville Press and Banner · Abbeville, S.C. · 24 April 1889
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D.
A prisoner identified as Ellison Hatfield confesses to Kentucky's state's attorney about his role in the killing of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy, describing how the captives were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot. He also implicates other Hatfield faction members, including Anse (Devil Anse) Hatfield, and describes a sworn oath of silence and the earlier killing of Jeff McCoy.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Pioneer Express · 19 April 1889 · page 1
A HORRIBLE TALE OF MURDER
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Pioneer Express · Pembina, N.D.
A captured Hatfield gang member confesses to the killings of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy at Pawpaw Island, describing how they were forced to pray before being shot. He also details the earlier raid on the McCoy homestead where Alifair McCoy was killed trying to extinguish a fire set by nine Hatfield men led by Jim Vance.
The Pioneer Express · 19 April 1889 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Sun · New York, N.Y.
A literary review column covers several new books, including T.C. Crawford's 'An American Vendetta,' a narrative account of the Hatfield-McCoy feud published by Belford, Clarke & Co. The reviewer describes it as a 'ghastly narrative' detailing fifteen years of murders, assassinations, and pitched battles between the rival families along the West Virginia-Kentucky border.
The Sun · 20 April 1889 · page 5
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Custer Chronicle · Custer City, Black Hills, S.D.
A jailed participant in the Hatfield-McCoy feud confesses to State's Attorney Lee Ferguson, describing how the three McCoy brothers were tied to a pawpaw bush and shot to death near the Tug River. He also implicates himself and others in the killing of Jeff McCoy and the deaths of Alifair and Alvin McCoy.
A captured Hatfield confederate describes the execution of Tolbert, Randolph, and Calvin McCoy at a pawpaw bush, naming who fired the fatal shots and describing an oath of silence. He also details the earlier killing of Jeff McCoy and the 1888 New Year's raid in which Alifair McCoy was shot and the McCoy home burned.
A short news brief states that Ellison Hatfield, described as one of the Hatfield-McCoy gang, is in jail and has confessed to three cold-blooded murders. The item appears amid a column of miscellaneous short news items from around the country.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
Pullman Herald · 20 April 1889 · page 1
KENTUCKY.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Memphis Appeal · Memphis, Tenn.
This is a review of T.C. Crawford's book 'An American Vendetta,' which recounts his visit to the Hatfield-McCoy feud region, originally serialized in the New York World. The reviewer praises Crawford's vivid depiction of the feud's savagery and notes he relied on the protection of Assistant Secretary of State John B. Floyd to safely interview the Hatfields.
The Memphis Appeal · 21 April 1889 · page 4
BOOKS AND MAGAZINES
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
A jailed Hatfield, held awaiting trial in Pike County, gives a formal confession to the county attorney describing his role in killing the three McCoy brothers in 1882. He recounts how the brothers were held captive, moved across the Tug River into Kentucky, and executed near Blackberry Creek.
ELLISON HATFIELD'S STORY. WEST VIRGINIA'S DEADLY FEUD, A GRAPHIC DESCRIPTION OF HOW THE McCOY BROTHERS WERE SHOT DOWN IN COLD BLOOD—FIRING UPON A GIRL WHO TRIED TO STOP A FIRE.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
A newspaper correspondent obtained Ellison Hatfield's confession, given before the County Attorney and witnesses, describing how he participated in the 1882 killing of Tolbert, Farmer, and Randolph McCoy. The confession details how the brothers were abducted, tied, and shot on the Kentucky riverbank, followed by a secrecy oath administered by Wall Hatfield.
Shenandoah Herald · 26 April 1889 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
Shenandoah Herald · Woodstock, Va.
A captured Hatfield faction member gives a detailed confession describing the 1882 killings of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy, the oath of secrecy administered by Wall Hatfield, the killing of Jeff McCoy while fleeing captors, and the January 1888 raid on the McCoy homestead in which Alifair and Calvin McCoy were killed. The confessor admits to shooting Alifair McCoy himself and describes the house being set ablaze during the attack.
Shenandoah Herald · 26 April 1889 · page 1
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.
A dispatch claims Ellison Hatfield, held in a Pike County jail, confessed to participating in the 1882 murder of the three McCoy brothers near Blackberry Creek. The confession describes the abduction, binding, and execution-style shooting of Tolbert, Pharmer, and Randolph McCoy by a group of Hatfield men.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 65 days later.
Wrong
South Branch Intelligencer · 26 April 1889 · page 1
Ellison Hatfield Confesses.
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
South Branch Intelligencer · Romney, Va. W. Va.
A captured Hatfield gang member gives a detailed confession describing the ritualistic execution of three McCoy brothers by the river, followed by an oath of silence, and recounts the 1888 New Year's raid in which Alifair and Calvin McCoy were killed. The account implicates numerous named Hatfield partisans in both crimes.
South Branch Intelligencer · 26 April 1889 · page 1