As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

February 1897

3 articles

In the story →

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A reporter visits the old Bender farm 24 years after the murders, finding it overgrown and unfarmed while surrounding land thrives. He learns the surrounding area has seen 13 violent deaths total, including the nine Bender murders and other killings like a father who murdered his child.

The Topeka State Journal · 16 February 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image

FARM ACCURSED.

Crops Wont Grow on the Old Bender Place.

See moreSee less

No One Can Be Found Who Will Stay There.

NEW BLOODY CHAPTER

In the History of a Neighborhood of Murderers.

Brockman Who Murdered His Child, Lived Next the Benders

Oswego, Feb. 16.—The Independent sent a reporter to the old Bender farm the past week who describes the historic spot as it is today, nearly 24 years after the York murder:

Nine and one-half miles northeast of Cherryvale, in Osage township, this county, section 13, you strike the northwest quarter of the Bender farm. Three large mounds on the south and east are known as the Bender mounds.

Farms surrounding it are well tilled, improved and abound with orchards and vines—the curse of human blood rests upon the Bender farm—it is a mass of cockle burs, weeds and matted grass. Not but the land is not as rich and fertile as the land adjoining, but the parties who have owned, rented and farmed it for 20 years past, seem to have operated it in a disheartened and meaningless way. A small strip of corn had been planted along the line where the bodies were found—the stalks looked like popcorn on other farms, and were scarce higher than the enormous cockle burs, which seem more than usually laden.

When the reporter made the trip through the tangled mass and emerged into the road he presented much the same appearance of a colt which has been running loose in a corn field all winter. While engaged in disengaging himself from the friendly burs, the reporter asked something about the history of the township in a criminal way and was astonished to learn that in a strip of land embracing that upon which he stood, 2½ miles north and south and 1½ miles east and west, 13 violent deaths had occurred. There were the nine Bender murders; an old man by the name of Hallifield, a storekeeper at Mortimer, who shot and killed his young wife and himself—jealousy; in 1887, Wes Ratcliff, 19, a farmer's son, suicided by shooting, for reason he had shot his father's mule; and the killing eight years ago of John Geary in self-defense by a brother of Ben Parks, who married Geary's daughter against his will. Then there was the Forest-Buckles transaction of 12 years ago. After an altercation with Forest one night, Buckles fled the county that night without hat or coat. Forest was arrested for murder, the people were greatly excited, wanted to lynch somebody and somebody did get strung up, but escaped with his life. Buckles was still missing, and staid missing a number of months, and the case was continued from term to term and he eventually turned up sound. The Bender farm is now owned by Margaret Keefe but was previously the property of Silas Yeagle—it pays no dividend, and the interest on the mortgage is steadily increasing, as if nine murders were not enough to damn it and render it forever cursed, a Kansas mortgage—has fastened upon it, and hot winds blight the corn, the rust strikes the oats, and the voracious little black devils of chinch bugs destroy the wheat.

People in the immediate locality of the famous Bender farm are pretty well satisfied as to what disposition was made of the Benders. So much so, that when effort has been made to follow various clues in recent years, men of standing and property holders have discouraged the movement.

Jesse McDaniel, late of Labette county, now of Fall River, writes to the Independent of the crime. He says:

I notice in your columns that Rudolph Brockman is now on trial for the murder of his daughter, Mary, under aggravating circumstances. From the fact that his farm in Osage township joins on the west the notorious Bender farm, and from the part he played in the excitement following the flight of this murderous family, whose crimes shocked the whole country at the time, it brings to mind recollections of the past which may be of interest to the rising generation and to those who have located within the confines of the south tier of counties.

In the spring of 1873 (I cannot give the exact date) I was in Independence on Wednesday, and excitement was high—one Dr. York, brother of State Senator York (at that time) was missing, and men were scouring the country in search of him. He had left Ft. Scott and was traced to within, I think, one and a half miles of the Bender place on the previous Thursday. There all trace was lost and he disappeared completely. I went with others to the place where he was last seen and the search was renewed. We were at the Bender farm frequently. Saw Kate Bender and was all over the farm. As we abandoned the search and before dispersing to our several homes, quite a number of su stopped at the house that evening. Kate told us if we would come the next day she would throw herself in a clairvoyant state and tell us where Dr. York was, if dead. Not having faith in that kind of business, did not go. On the following morning, Friday, we went to Thayer, Kan., and saw a team standing some distance from the L. L. & G. railroad, one mile south of the city, close to a pond, which attracted our attention as being something unusual; no one with it, or no cover on the wagon. On the next morning we again went to Thayer for the early morning train, and saw the team still there. A cold rain had set in. I noticed the team were eating the wagon box. I went to the nearest house and inquired as to the team and was told by the woman at the house (now Mrs. Cody of Oswego, I think) that it was there Friday morning when she got up and no one had been near it since. We reported it to Ed Malburn, a liveryman at Thayer, and asked him for the sake of humane treatment, to get the team and care for it, which he did that afternoon.

Three weeks from the following Thursday was at Independence when a man from the Bender neighborhood came in and reported the Benders gone and that there were dead bodies in the house or cellar, as the stench was such when he opened the door that he could not enter. To say that people became excited, does not express it. A crowd started for the scene at once. Owing to pressing business I did not get there until the next day. The house was examined from top to bottom. The stench came from the cellar. It was dug out to fresh earth on the sides. No bodies were found, but as the stench arose from decomposed human blood, it was an evident fact that murder had been committed. The house was moved from its foundation, but no clue was discovered to the burial place of the bodies.

In the evening a depression was found the size of a grave in the lately plowed and harrowed ground south of the house. At this place the body of Dr. York was found. Four bodies were taken out when we arrived, and I helped to take out the remaining five, four grown men and one little girl about 4 years old. One of the dead men was the father of the little girl. He had lived a few miles west of Independence, and his wife having died, started with four horses and his little girl to return to Indiana to his people. The sight still haunts me. In a hole about four feet in diameter, nearly round, and about four feet deep, were father and child. The father was doubled up in order to get him in the middle of the hole and the little child placed on top of him. She had on a little hood, from which her flaxen curls were seen, mittens were on her hands which were pressed over her face as though to keep the dirt out of her eyes—that child was buried alive.

From the construction of the house you will understand how these murders were supposed to have been committed—two rooms were down stairs, one living room, and one in which they kept some refreshments, such as oysters, crackers, etc. The partition was studding, covered with heavy ducking. A wooden bench was across the room at that point. Any one sitting down on the bench would naturally lean his head against the partition. A blow from a hammer in the hands of a person behind the partition crushed the skull of the victim. (A hammer was found whose end fitted the indentations in their skulls.) After their throats were cut the bodies were dumped into the cellar until such time as they could be buried in secret, in the darkness of night.

After the bodies were disinterred and identified, finding that the victims had property in the shape of two wagons and seven horses, it was the conclusion of all that the Benders had help from the outside, as far as disposing of the stock was concerned. Upon inquiry it was found that the Benders had but one neighbor with whom they had social intercourse—one Dolph Brockman. He was visited by a committee, but denied strenuously any guilty knowledge of the Benders. A rope was placed about his neck and he was elevated by willing hands. He was let down and still denied knowing anything. The third time he was hoisted and again let down. And now it is this same Brockman, a quarter of a century later, accused of one of the foulest crimes ever committed by man—the murder of his own flesh and blood under circumstances most damning and foul.

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

The report catalogs thirteen violent deaths in a small township area, including the nine Bender murders and several other local killings and suicides. It also recounts the Bender farm's subsequent ownership and ill fortune, and introduces a letter from Jesse McDaniel recalling the 1873 search for Dr. York amid the excitement following the Benders' flight.

The Topeka State Journal · 16 February 1897 · page 3

NEW BLOODY CHAPTER

and he eventually turned up sound. The Bender farm is now owned by Mar garet Keefe but was previously the property of Silas Yeagle it pays no dividend, and the interest on the mort gage is steadily increasing, as if nine murders were not enough to damn it and render it forever cursed, a Kansas mortgage has fastened upon it, and hot winds blight the corn, the rust strikes the oats, and the voracious lit tle black devils of chinch bugs destroy the wheat. People in the immediate locality of the famous Bender farm are pretty well satisfied as to what disposition was made of the Benders.

See moreSee less

So much so.that when effort has been made to follow various clues in recent years, men of standing and property holders have dis couraged the movement. Jesse McDanlel, late of Labette coun ty, now of Fall River, writes to the In dependent of the crime. He savs: I notice in your columns that Rudolph Brockman is now on trial for the mur der of his daughter, Mary, under aggravatingcircumstances. From the fact that his farm in Osage township joins on the west the notorious Bender farm, and from the part he plaved in the ex citement following the flight of this murderous family, whose crimes shock ed the whole country at the time, it brings to mind recollections of the past which may be of interest to the rising generation and to those who have lo cated within the confines of the south tier of counties. In the spring of 1S73 (I cannot give the exact date) I was in Independence on Wednesday, and excitement was high one L)r. York, brother of State Senator "iork (at that time) was missing, and men were scouring the country in search of him. He had left Ft Scott and was traced to within. I think one and a half miles of the Bender place on the previous Thursday. There all trace was lost and he disappeared completely. I went with others to the place where he was last seen and the search was renewed. "We were at the Bender farm frequently. Saw Kate Bender and was all over the farm. As we abandoned the search and before

See the clipping

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

A letter writer recounts his personal recollections from spring 1873, describing the search for missing Dr. York, visits to the Bender farm, and Kate Bender's offer to use clairvoyance to locate him. He also describes finding an abandoned team and wagon near Thayer, Kansas, and the eventual report that the Benders had fled and bodies were found at their farm.

The Topeka State Journal · 16 February 1897 · page 3

The words of this article are printed with the report it shares its clipping with. Read them there or in the clipping.

See the clipping shared with another article on the same page