As the Papers Told It

The Bloody Benders · The full archive

January 1897

3 articles

In the story →

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

A Michigan convict's statement describes a route to find the Bender family, last reportedly seen camped near the Pecos River and possibly heading further south into Mexico. Captain W. H. Ward, a former Kansas official, denies rumors that the Benders were lynched, citing a dubious anonymous article as the source of that myth and affirming state investigations concluded the family escaped.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 31 January 1897 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

THE BENDER FAMILY.

SUPPOSITION THEY WERE LYNCHED IS ERRONEOUS.

See moreSee less

THE OFFICIAL INVESTIGATION.

SHOWS THE MEMBERS OF THE FAMILY ESCAPED TO TEXAS.

A Convict of the Michigan State Penitentiary Knew Them Well—He Makes a Statement—Tells of Their Life on the Frontiers.

To begin with, you would like to know the best way to go to the place where I last saw the Benders. If I were going there I should go on the cars to Denison, Tex. Then I would go by saddle horse, arms and outfit to camp out, to Henrietta, Clay county, Tex., which is about 110 miles west, settled all the way. On the way would stop at Red River station, to make inquiries for Tom Lawrence, Del Short or Dugan and others. At Henrietta find Dan Koozer, a brother of Ed Koozer, who is with them. If I didn't find where they were I would go to Domes' ranch, about 120 miles a little south of west. The place where they were camped when I saw them last is sixty-five to seventy miles from there, southwest in the mountains and at the head of Pecos river, no road or trail to it, but it is not likely they are there now. I think they have either gone farther south on the Stake plains or in the Gaudalupe mountains, or have gone with the Kickapoos, southwest of Saltello, Old Mexico.—Extract from the statement of Sam Merrick, a Michigan convict, regarding the Bender family.

"The prevailing impression that the members of the Bender family, the noted murderous pioneers of Labette county, Kas., were lynched is wholly without foundation," said Captain W. H. Ward yesterday. Captain Ward was private secretary to Governor St. John, of Kansas, during the administration of the latter from 1879 to 1883. At that time the efforts to trace the Benders were still active, and much information regarding them passed through the hands of Captain Ward. He is now a resident of Kansas City, Kas.

"Several years ago," said Captain Ward, "a Chicago paper printed an article, purporting to be a letter from Kansas City, in which the writer claimed to have seen and talked with a dying man who had confessed to complicity in the lynching of the Bender family. The writer of the article failed to reveal his own identity, or that of the 'dying man' who had told the story. The dates and facts mentioned were so erroneous as to show that the story was the product of a faulty memory and a vivid imagination, but from its publication the opinion seemed to become general that the lynching of the Benders was an actual fact. The story was absolutely unfounded, and the Benders escaped. Probably some of the members of the family are still alive."

The facts in the matter, as they appeared from the investigation made by the Kansas state officials, seem to show conclusively that the lynching story was a myth. It was about April 4 or 5, 1873, that a wagon, team and dog were found abandoned in a ravine back of the little town of Thayer, Neosho county, Kas. An account of this was published in the Thayer Headlight at the time. This was in the days when that territory was on the frontier, and the finding of the team was one of the strange happenings which not infrequently occurred on the border of civilization. It created considerable comment, but it was not until about thirty days later that the real excitement occurred.

On May 3, 1873, a posse searching for Dr. York, who had been missing for several weeks, came to the Bender residence, and found it abandoned. In the stable was tied a calf which had been left behind and which had been starved to death. Everything indicated that the place had been without occupants for a month or more. The Benders' place had been a sort of half-way house and its unexpected desertion created surprise. About the place were discovered several sunken mounds resembling new made graves, and the members of the posse, on opening one of them, discovered in it the body of Dr. York. Seven or eight more of these mounds were opened and in each a body was found, two bodies being taken from one of the mounds. Then the mysterious abandonment of the team in the ravine near Thayer was recalled and persons who knew the Benders and their team went to Thayer to investigate. They identified the horses and dog as having been the property of the Benders.

Senator A. M. York, a brother of Dr. York, states that he last saw the Benders on April 3, 1873. It is supposed they left their Labette county home the following day, and that the team was abandoned the night of April 4, or the morning of April 5. The station agent of the old Leavenworth, Lawrence & Galveston railroad (now the Southern Kansas branch of the Santa Fe) at Thayer, remembered, and his records bore out his recollection, that four persons, the descriptions of whom answered to that of the Benders, had purchased tickets at his office April 5, from Thayer to Humboldt, Kas. Here the absolute trace of the Benders was lost. It is supposed that they went on the Leavenworth, Lawrence & Galveston to Chanute or Humboldt, where they could have made close connections with the south bound train of the Missouri, Kansas & Texas, for the frontiers of the Indian Territory, which was then populated largely with criminals and desperate characters, fugitives from justice.

The investigation of the disappearance of the Bender family conducted during the administration of Governor St. John, and the information resulting therefrom, all of which passed through the hands of Captain Ward, is exceedingly interesting. The most important feature was in the statement of Sam Merrick, a convict confined in the Michigan state penitentiary at Detroit. The statement is corroborated by all the other evidence which could be secured by the officers. It conclusively removes the theory that the Benders were lynched. In substance Merrick's statement follows:

"In 1872 I was with Lee Dyer's herd of cattle at the old Spark ranch, on the Little Wichita river, about four miles from the mouth of it, in Clay county, Tex. Missouri Bill had charge of the herd at that time. The house was one of those double log houses built before the Indians drove the people out in 1868. We stayed in one end of it. In the other was a family by the name of Slimp. They used to talk about their affairs to me. They said their sister would come down in the fall or winter with their cousins, the Benders, from Labette county, Kas. Floyd, their second son, said their mother and old Mrs. Bender were cousins. Their mother was dead. I went to the Arkansas river in September. In 1873 I guided Dan Waggoner's herd to the Big Wichita. In the spring of 1873 I passed near Slimp's place and stopped there to get a bridle that belonged to me. Their sister had come a little while before on the cars to the end of the Missouri, Kansas & Texas, and then hired a conveyance from Sherman, Tex., to Slimp's. The Benders had come three days before with a team. I was made acquainted with the old woman and John and Kate. They went by the name of Gardner. Kate was called Jennie Gardner. The old man and Slimp and another man, who came with them, were away looking for some safe place to go, somewhere on the head of the Little Wichita, they said. John went by the name of Bill. The old woman talked a little 'Dutchy,' but John and Kate did not. In coming through the nation they all wore men's clothes.

"They crossed the Arkansas river at the Old Creek agency, passed through Stonewal, Chickasaw Nation, and crossed Red river at Sobe Leaves, following a route that was not traveled much. While I was at Slimp's Frank McPherson, brother to Missouri Bill, who had been a conductor on the railroad between Sedalia and Parsons, killed a man, at Parsons I believe, at any rate it was a Dutchman, a restaurant keeper, and he got away from the officers by jumping through the car window, arrived. He stayed at Missouri Bill's at Red River station. Before I left that country in March the Benders had moved about thirty-five miles farther west onto Wanderer's creek, west of the Pecos river. I did not come back until the winter of 1874. I stayed at Missouri Bill's. Frank McPherson had gone to the Bender camp, which had moved to Prairie Dog canon, about twenty miles still farther west. While I was there a dectective named Sullivan came to Henrietta in search of the Benders. John Bender went into town to see him, and came back and said he was not afraid of that fellow, he was too stylish, but there might be others with him. I went South and came back through the Staked Plains in 1876. I went over to the Benders' camp, which was sixty-five or seventy miles from the nearest whites. Kate complained of their poverty and John said they would always be worth $1,000 apiece. (The amount of the reward offered for each of them.) Kate dressed like a man most of the time. They thought they would leave in the winter for some other place, for they were afraid the buffalo hunters might run across them. They wanted to go North, but the Apaches said they would find a good place for them in the Guadalupe mountains. The Kickapoos wanted them to go to Old Mexico. They said they would go either to the Gaudalupe mountains or some other place on the Staked Plains. I told them of a good place at the head of the Colorado river of Texas. It is a place a person might pass close to and not know it was there. I was there with some Indians. I left there to come North and have not seen them since that time. I have been a prisoner since 1877.

"The Slimps were living between McKinney and Pilot Point, Tex. They might know where they are, but if a stranger should make any inquiry of them, or of any of the others, they would not find out anything, and they would send word to the Benders if they know where they are, which is more than likely, and a man's life would not be worth more than a cartridge, for he would be killed."

This statement of Merrick was made in the fall of 1879. It was submitted to the county authorities of Labette county, but they felt that so much money had already been expended in an effort to capture the Benders that they could not afford to bear the expense of following up the clue. Merrick has since been released from prison and his whereabouts are unknown. The detective, Sullivan, of whom he speaks, had called on Senator York, a brother of Dr. York, one of the victims of the Benders, before he had gone to Henrietta, where Merrick knew of him. His statement regarding Frank McPherson is substantially correct, and his description of the Benders tallies exactly with that given by those who knew them well. Captain Ward states that he often stopped at the Benders' house while they were in Labette county. He placed implicit confidence in Merrick's statement, and ridicules the theory that the Benders were lynched.

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

This report, looking back nearly 25 years, declares the famous story of the Benders being lynched a myth, citing Kansas state investigation records. It reconstructs the 1873 discovery timeline: the abandoned wagon near Thayer, the found bodies at the Bender farm, and the family's apparent escape by rail toward Chanute or Humboldt.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 31 January 1897 · page 8

FAMILY ESCAPED TO TEXAS

bodies being taken from one or the mounds Then the mysterious abandonment of the team In the ravine near Thayer was re called and persons who Knew the Benders und their team went to Thayer to In vestigate. They identified tho horses and dog as having been the property of the

See the clipping

Kansas City Daily Journal · Kansas City, Mo.

The report describes an investigation into the disappearance of the Bender family conducted under Governor St. John, centering on a statement by convict Sam Merrick from the Michigan state penitentiary. Merrick's corroborated testimony undermines the theory that the Benders were lynched, instead describing a family connection to relatives near the Little Wichita River in Texas.

Kansas City Daily Journal · 31 January 1897 · page 8

fined In the Michigan state penitentiary at Detroit. The statement is corroborated by all the other evidence which could be se cured by the olllcers. It conclusively re moves the theory that the Benders were

See the clipping