The Topeka State Journal · 28 April 1897 · page 3 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
LYNCHING OF THE BENDERS. The "Only Absolutely True"
Story Published.
See moreSee less
Captured and Slain by Friends of Dr. Yorke.
Seventeen Vigilantes Use Lassoes to Catch Them.
YELLOWHAIREDCHILD Found in the Cellar, Arouses Cowboy Wrath. Story Related in Chicago by a Kansas Man.
[From the Chicago Chronicle, April 26.]
When the murderous Bender family disappeared from their Kansas farm shortly after their final murder—that of Dr. Yorke—it was reported that they had escaped, it was hinted that they had been lynched and some frontier folk submitted the theory that possibly they had committed suicide. But the real story of their dropping out of sight has never been known until within the past week. One of the best known men in Kansas, a man who has held high political office in the state and is known and trusted the length and breadth of it, stopped at one of the principal hotels in the city a few days ago. A writer for the Chronicle, knowing him to have been personally familiar with the facts surrounding the mystery of the disappearance of the Benders,hunt- ed him up and asked him about the matter.
'Why do you want to rake up that old affair?" he asked.
"Because you know and I know that the true story of it has never been told," was the reply. "And I know that you have the real facts in your pos- session. Look at this letter. You were right there in the county when they went away, but of course you knew nothing of their disappearance except from what you learned afterward." "Of course," said the Kansan imper- turbably. "Come up to my room." The two repaired to the Kansan's room and the story was soon told.
"I know all about it, as do a dozen men yet living in my state, and I sup- pose you might as well have it as it actually happened. I got the bottom facts from an old fellow living on the Ninnescat river last fall and it made a deep impression on me. You know I was well acquainted with Dr. Yorke and his brother. Doc was the last man the Benders killed. His brother, you may recollect, was the state sena- tor who sprung the $7,000 bribery sen- sation in Kansas when Anthony and Pomeroy were running for senator. Well, when Yorke was missed the neighbors and some friends of the missing man decided that there was reason to pay a visit to that farm. This was what the old man told me, you understand. He said there were seventeen of the party and not a rifle or a shotgun in the crowd. There were four cowboys who were as handy with a rope—a lasso, you know—as any men on the range, and a few had navy sixes strapped on.
"The searchers made up their minds to go over there and rope the outfit and make a search of the house, the cellar, barn, yard and all about the house. If they found murder there the Benders were to swing. If mistaken, they intended to present their regrets and apologies. Well, they drove up to the house and the women were there. The old woman was inside and Kate was at the wood pile chopping wood like a man. A big, strapping hell-cat of a woman she was. John was just leading a horse to a watering trough, and the old man was not in sight then. The seventeen were in the yard and ready for business quicker than snakes. Three of the boys looked after the teams and fourteen rushed in on the family. "Jim—well, one of the cow punchers, roped John around the neck before John knew what had happened. The horse he was leading broke loose as the man's feet went into the air, and some of the boys yelled: 'Whoa, there! whoa, there!' That brought the old man out of the barn and another of the boys roped him by one of his legs as he stepped out and stretched him on a manure heap like a steer. Meanwhile a couple of the boys had covered the old woman with six-shooters and tied her hands and feet with a rope taken along. She was as sullen as a Sioux squaw, and looked like one a little bit, too.
"Three of the boys had made a rush for Kate, but she backed up against the wood pile, swung her ax and yelled, 'Come on, you cowards.' The boys could have picked her off with their guns, but they didn't want to kill her before an investigation. But they held her to the wood pile with their revolvers until a couple of cowboys came up. One of the ropers made a swing and caught her ax and jerked it out of her hand as neatly as anything you ever saw. The other rope caught one of her arms as the ax was snatched away, and Kate came tumbling over in a lot of fresh cut chips and stove wood. She was cursing terribly all the time. As soon as the boys had her tied they took something off a clothes line and stopped her howling. When they got the family all tied and Kate gagged the old man explained to them that this was a little informal call, as the callers were looking for a friend.
"Three of the boys guarded the outfit and the rest commenced to search. Then old man, the leader, said: 'God above, but it was awful. The half has never been told of that slaughterhouse. Bones everywhere, and one or two decaying corpses. And Doc Yorke all right; I'll swear to that. And when we came to a little child's skull, with yellow hair like cornsilk streaming from it, the boys gave a yell and we all ran out to where those four fiends lay roped. Two of the cowboys begged me—I was the leader—to let them burn the whole Bender outfit after they had tied them to wagon wheels. I never saw a man act so insanely as that cow puncher they called Coyote Billy. I'll swear they had to take his six-shooter off him, and I hope I may never see another sun if he didn't get down on his knees and beg me to have those devils burned. He was crying, that cowboy was, and he stirred the crowd up like a prairie fire.
"'But I told them all that only a dog's death would do for that gang. No wasting of honest fuel. Hang them one by one and let each see the other die. The old man weakened some and he swore John did all the killing and that he was afraid John would kill him if he told anything. The old woman was sullen and wouldn't say a word. John asserted the old man put him up to it all and Kate sat up against a log in the yard gagged and tied, her eyes snapping like a wild cat's. We loaded them into the wagons late in the afternoon and started for the Verdigris river. It is a little stream that runs through the country between Cherryvale and Independence. It had been a dry summer and the river, or what you would call a creek in the east, was nearly dry. Here and there in the river bed were little pools of water with plenty of dry spaces along the river bed. We had brought some shovels along and we brought the Benders out and sat them on the bank of the river until the moon came out.
LYNCHING THE BENDERS.
"'The moon came out and flickered down through the cottonwoods, and I remember now I heard a whippoorwill in the brush somewhere. The boys dug them a nice, spacious grave there in the sand, and the Benders watched them while they shoveled the stuff away. It was hard work, and the boys made a sort of trench of it, and they dug it pretty deep. Along about 12 o'clock we hanged the old man. We put a lasso around his neck and swung one end of it over a cottonwood limb, and then put him on his feet in the back of a wagon and eased the wagon along until he fell off the back of it—had the tail gate down, you know. His neck wasn't broken by the fall, as the boys were anxious to give him plenty of time. Then we strung the old woman up in the same way, let her teeter around for about fifteen minutes and brought her down. The old man and the old woman died pretty hard.
"'Then we trussed up Kate, still gagged, and the she-devil never flinched. We had been quite a little while doing this, and the coyote cowboy suggested that we just dump John tied into the grave with the others and cover him up gradually. Most of the boys were well pleased with this idea, and the cowboy, when I vetoed it, went along by the back of the wagon and eased the last Bender down.
In about two seconds he cut the rope with his knife and hollered, "He's dead, boys." So we took them all down to the Verdigris and dumped them into the trench. They were all tied hand and foot. I never was so cussed certain whether John's neck was chafed any by the rope or not, and I reckon he was about 99 per cent alive when they shoveled the sand in on him, but when I think of that young one with the hair like corn-silk I don't lose any sleep over John. The rains in the next two days washed down and covered the tracks made by the men on the river bed.' " 'Talk about the Benders getting away. It's a lie, and a black one. Their bones are rotting under the sands of the Verdigris, and I am one of a score that know it. Talk about Leroy T. Dick, that Kansas sheriff, going to Kansas City and identifying a job lot of bogus Benders! How about some of the old residenters in that neck of woods who knew the Benders? Leroy Dick knew the real Benders. How about Leroy's father, Billy Dick, didn't he live in that section? Mind you, I ain't saying a word against anyone. I helped lynch that crowd, but I didn't recognize anyone in the crowd except two of the cowboys. They've both gone over the divide since; one by the whisky, the other by the pistol route. But the Benders are rotting under those Kansas sands, and if anyone tells you they got away he's been "locoed;" he's crazy.' That's the way the old man told me," said the Kansan, as he lighted a fresh cigar.