The San Francisco Call · San Francisco, Calif.
A Wichita report relays a deathbed confession by a 'Captain Carroll,' who claimed to have been part of a citizens' posse that hunted down the fleeing Bender family and shot the father and daughter, sparing only Mrs. Bender. The account, passed secondhand through W. H. Coon to Judge Webb, purports to finally resolve the long-standing mystery of the Benders' fate after their 1870s Kansas murders.
UnconfirmedNo later report in this collection bears it out.
The San Francisco Call · 28 August 1897 · page 1
SLEW TWO NOTORIOUS BENDERS / Father and Daughter Shot Down by a Citizens' Posse. / REVEALED BY DYING CONFESSION. / Clearing of the Mystery Connected With the Kansas Murderers. / THIRTY PERSONS KILLED IN THEIR DEN. / When the Pursuers Overtook the Fleeing Family They Spared Only Mrs. Bender.
Only Mrs. Bender. WICHITA, Ka*s., Aug. 27.— Another chapter has just been added to the grew some story of the Bender family, whose home in Montgomery County, over twenty years ago, was the scene of upward of thirty murders, by the deathbed confes sion of Captain Carroll, who declares that tie was a member of a citizens' posse lhat followed the Bender family after their flight a,nd killed two of them. The fate of tne Benders has heretofore been veiled in mysiery. Captain Carroll made the confession two years ago to W.
See moreSee less
H. Coon of Denver, and yesterday Mr. . Coon communicated the facts for the first time to Judge Webb of Atchison. The home of the Benders was in Montgomery County, not far from Independence,, and travelers passing through that new country frequently put up there. The house was small and an addition was built. Between the two downstairs rooms was a partition made of thick cloth tacked to the studding. Along this parti tion a rude bench was constructed, and unwary travelers would sit there and rest their heads against the cloth partition. Kate Bender, the daughter, in the adjoin ing room, would then take a large ax and strike the stranger a terrible blow on the head. The victim would then be thrown through a trapdoor into a deep hole dug for the purpose and his pockets rifled. After taking all the money and valuables from the pockets the stranger would be buried in the garden.' j .V The whole family, William Bender, the father, Mrs. Bender, Kate, the daughter, and John, the son, were engaged in the horrible business of robbery and murder, and on account of their quiet inoffensive appearance the cunning with which they covered up their tracks and the newness of the country, they managed to escape de tection or even suspicion for several years. The murder of Dr. York In 1873 was the crime that led to their undoing. - Dr. Yoric stopped there over night while en route to the home of bis brother, and that was the last time he was ever seen alive. Owing to nis prominence and the nearness of hi 3 relatives a thorough seprch was made. The Benders did not deny that he stopped there, but claimed that I c had traveled on. Suspicion was directed toward them, however, and they fled the country the following night. John Bender was after ward arrested in Texas, but cheated the gallows by committing suicide. The citizens of Montgomery County be gan to search the Bender premises, and they found that the yard was full of bodies in various stages of decomposition, all with skulls crushed by blows from an ax and with their throats cv». The whole county was startled with the revelation, and the best detectives in the land ex hausted every possible means of finding the fugitives, but only John Bender was ever captured. Captain Carroll confessed that a band of citizens, sworn to eternal secrecy, followed the Benders and filled the old man and Kate full of lead, but let Mrs. Bender go, with a warning never to return on pain of death. He said that Kate and her mother stood by and stoically watched the men riddle the body of William Bender with bullets, and then, when Kate's tern came, she stepped out like a tragedy queen and said: "Blaze away." She wa3 shot down like a dog, but when it came to shooting tho mother, the hearts of the posse men failed them and they allowed her to go. The bodies were carefully buried and the graves concealed. The township in which the Benders lived seems to have inherited a curse, for in addition to ihe Bender murders the following are among the violent deaths that have since occurred :• John Hallifer, shot and killed his wifo and himself; Wesley Rat liff, committed suicide; John .Geary killed by James Parks. The Bender farm is tenantless and covered with weeds, and the house is believed to be haunted by the ghosts of the Bender victims. ."..■.*.*- -- . ' • -^