Officers capture a twelfth suspect in the Green-Kelly murder case, part of a gang believed to have killed wholesale while rustling cattle. Investigators now suspect the San Isidro gang's crimes may rival those of the Bender gang in 1870s Kansas, with rancher Daniel Young among the suspected victims.
The Springfield Herald · 3 September 1897 · page 2
THE SAN ISIDRO GANG.
gang. He is now supposed to he in Old Mexico. The second startling chapter com prises developments which go to show that the gang, eleven members of which are now In jail, committed murders by wholesale in carrying on their thieving operations. In fact, it is now believed that the gang planned murder on the same scale as did the Bender gang iu Kansas in the early ’7o’s, ami perhaps ns extensively. Tlir**e of their victims are now known, and the officers have a long list of missing men who are now believed to have fallen victims of tin* San Isidro gang.
See moreSee less
The officers expect to lie able to prove before ticy have done with the • ase that Daniel Young, n wealthy and prominent cattleman of Colfax county. New Mexico, who was siiot and killed whil riding over his range near Fol s,,m some time prior to the murder of the two Trinidad ollicers, was mur dered by this same band of outlaws. He had suffered heavy losses from cat tle thieves, and was trying to detect the culprits when he was killed.
A retrospective piece recounts the infamous murder method of the Bender family and repeats a tale from the late Captain Carroll claiming a secret party hunted down and executed them, with Kate Bender's defiant last words. It revives decades-old lore about the family's unknown fate.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 22 days later.
Wrong
Blackfoot News · 4 September 1897 · page 5
The Lott Story of The BentJera. Aimoot every pcnon 30 year» old ro her* something about the murrier Ifeader family of Montgomery tr. Kaatas. Their victim« num bered 30 aad the moet of them were killed by the daughter, Kate Bender. It will ha bered they kept a of entertainment. One of the partition walla of their hou>e waa of cloth. A arat wa« ao arranged that the the traveler would ait aad reat hi« bead agaiaat the doth. Kale, in the opposite , would »trike him on the bead with aa ax aad then one of the family «ou Id throw the victim through a trap door into a cellar where he would cut hi« throat, rob him and afterward* bury the r imais* in a garden.
A special report from Wichita relates a deathbed confession by a Capt. Carroll, given to W. H. Coon and later revealed to a judge, claiming a vigilante posse tracked down and killed William and Kate Bender while letting Mrs. Bender escape. The confession, made three years earlier, purports to finally resolve the 25-year mystery of the Bender family's fate after their notorious murders of 1872-73.
CHARGE OF FLEET AT HONOLULU. Bender Mystery Cleared. A special from Wichita, Kan., says that a deathbed confession, made by cant. Carroll, a iormer resioeni of Montgomery county, to W. H. Coon of Cripple Creek, Colo., who was also from that county, clears up the mystery that for a quarter of a century had shrouded the fate of the notorious Ben der family, whose who'esale murders, committed in 1872-73, attracted nation al attention. The confession was made atBeartice, Neb., three years ago, and Mr. Coon kept his secret until yesterday, when he related it to Judge W.
See moreSee less
D. Webb, late of the Atchison county distrcit court. The Bender house, as is well known, became a slaughter pen. The number of the family's victims have been var iously estimated at from 15 to M. in his confession Capt. Carroll said that he was one of a posse who dealt quick punishment to the murderers after many villainies were discovered. He declared that a posse of deter mined men followed and overtook the Benders, William, his wife, and Kate, 25 miles from their home, and first filled the old man full of holes. Kate Bender and her mother looked on un moved. Kate was then told that her time had come and she stood unflinchingly until several bullets had pierced her body, then fell to the ground dead. The work was too bloody for some of the pursuers and Mrs. Bender was told to run for her life. She got away and nothing was ever heard of her afterward. The lynchers swore secre cy, which has been observed until the present confession.
The article reports a deathbed confession by a Captain Carroll of Cripple Creek, Colorado, supposedly revealing what became of the Bender family after their murders. It recaps the 1872-73 killings at their Kansas inn, including the disappearance of Dr. York and the discovery of the murder site after the family fled.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.
Wrong
The Ketchum Keystone · 11 September 1897 · page 2
Their Death. The deathbed confession made by Captain Carroll, of Cripple Creek, Col., clears up a mystery that for a quarter of a century has shrouded the fate of the notorious Bender family, whose wholesale murders committed in 1872-73 at tracted national attention, says the Cleveland (Ohio) Plaindealer. The confession was made at Beatrice, Neb., three years ago, and Mr. Coon kept his secret until recently, when he related it to Judge W. D. Webb, late of the Atchison county district court. William Bender, his wife and son, John Bender, and daughter, Kate Bender, lived in a small house few miles from Independence, a Kas., where travelers frequently stopped for food and shelter for the night.
See moreSee less
Lodgers were so numerous that the family fitted up accomoda tions for travelers. The little but became a regular slaughter pen, and the number of victims is vari ously estimated at from fifteen to thirty. This system of murder and robbery was carried on for many months before any suspicion was directed against them, as the coun try was new and means of com munication meager. One day a physician named York, on his way from the east to visit his brother, Alexander M. York, who lived in Montgomery county, stopped with the Benders over night When he failed to arrive at bis brother's house an investigation was made, and the doctor was traced to the Bender house, but no further. Kate Beuder, who is cred ited with being the one who always dispatched the visitors with an ax, told the searchers to come the next evening and she would throw herself in a cataleptic state and tell where York was. When the searching party returned for the revelation it was to find the house deserted. An investigation of the premises disclosed the horrible fact that there was a temporay receptacle for dead bodies beneath the house, and that the garden was filled with corpses. The body of Dr. York was found, and numerous others, which it was impossible to identify. What be came of the Benders nobody has ever professed to know, until the ante-mortem statement of Capt. Carroll. • He declared that a posse of deter mined men followed and overtook the Benders-r-^William, his wife, and Kate-~twenty-five miles from their homes, and first shot the old man full of holes while . Kate Ben der and her mother looked on un moved. Kate Bender was then told that her time had come, and she stood unflinching until several bul lets had pierced her body, and then fall dead. Mrs. Bender got away, and nothing was ever heard of her afterward. The bodies of the two Benders were then buried and their graves concealed. John Bender, who was arrested in Texas by a member of the same poss, commit ted suicide. The posse was com posed of men sworn to secrecy, and Captain Carroll is the first one to tell of the work. The Bender house was constructed
This article recaps the Bender family's murders of travelers near their Kansas inn, including the disappearance investigation triggered by Dr. York's death and discovery of bodies in the cellar and garden. It also relates a late claim by a Capt. Carroll, made on his deathbed, asserting that a secret posse tracked down and killed William and Kate Bender while the mother escaped and John Bender later committed suicide in Texas.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 15 days later.
Wrong
The Ketchum Keystone · 11 September 1897 · page 2
One day a physician named York, on his way from the east to visit his brother, Alexander M. York, who lived in Montgomery county, stopped with the Benders over night When he failed to arrive at bis brother's house an investigation was made, and the doctor was traced to the Bender house, but no further. Kate Beuder, who is cred ited with being the one who always dispatched the visitors with an ax, told the searchers to come the next evening and she would throw herself in a cataleptic state and tell where York was.
See moreSee less
When the searching party returned for the revelation it was to find the house deserted. An investigation of the premises disclosed the horrible fact that there was a temporay receptacle for dead bodies beneath the house, and that the garden was filled with corpses. The body of Dr. York was found, and numerous others, which it was impossible to identify. What be came of the Benders nobody has ever professed to know, until the ante-mortem statement of Capt. Carroll. • He declared that a posse of deter mined men followed and overtook the Benders-r-^William, his wife, and Kate-~twenty-five miles from their homes, and first shot the old man full of holes while . Kate Ben der and her mother looked on un moved. Kate Bender was then told that her time had come, and she stood unflinching until several bul lets had pierced her body, and then fall dead. Mrs. Bender got away, and nothing was ever heard of her afterward. The bodies of the two Benders were then buried and their graves concealed. John Bender, who was arrested in Texas by a member of the same poss, commit ted suicide. The posse was com posed of men sworn to secrecy, and Captain Carroll is the first one to tell of the work. The Bender house was constructed
A Columbus, Kansas report describes the trial of the Stalleback brothers and their mother for the murder of Frank Galbraith, with testimony pointing to additional victims thrown down a mine shaft. The story explicitly invokes the Bender family's notoriety as a yardstick for the new crime's horror.
The Herald · 15 September 1897 · page 5
KANSAS CRIME Al Family of Crooks Worse Than the Benders COLUMBUS, Kan., Sept. 14—A story of crime rivaling the deeds) of the noto rious Bender family comes to light in a murder trial now in progress here in the district court. Ed and George Statle back, brothers, and their mother, Mrs. Wilson, are accused of the murder of Frank Galbraith in June,last at Galena, Kansas. The evidence is so direct that George Statleback and his mother were speedily found guilty of murder in the first and second degree respectively and the trial of Ed Stalleback is still in pro gress.
See moreSee less
The family were keepers of a dive in Galena. Galbraith was shot to death and robbed in the place, following a quarrel with the mother and sons over the woman's daughter. His body wa<? thrown Into an abandoned mine shaft,
A murder trial in Columbus, Kansas, compared in brutality to the notorious Bender family, has revealed further crimes by the Stafleback family. Testimony implicates mother and sons in the killing of Frank Galbraith and possibly other victims thrown down a mine shaft near Galena.
New-York Tribune · 16 September 1897 · page 4
——at——— MURDER TRIAL REVEALS OTHER MURDERS Columbus, Kan., Sept. 15.—A story of crimes rivalling the dgeds of the notorious Bender family comes to light in a murder trial now in progress here. Edward and George Stafleback, brothers, and. Mrs, were accused of the Wilson, their mother, murder of Frank Galbraith in June last, at Galena, evidence was so direct that George Kan, The and his mother were speedily found Statleback first and second degree. guilty of murder in the The trial of Edward Stafleback is still in progress. The family were Keepers of a dive.
See moreSee less
Galbraith was place, following shot to death and robbed in the sons over the he mother and with t a quarrel thrown into an His body was woman's daughter, Stafleback, wife shaft. Mrs, Cora abandoned mine of George, and two other inmates of the house gave testimony from which evidence of a triple mu at Galena has been secured. rder
A newspaper reports on the murder trial of the Stafleback family in Columbus, Kansas, comparing their crimes to those of the notorious Bender family. The article recounts how Frank Galbraith was killed and robbed at the family's dive in Galena, with testimony hinting at a prior triple murder as well.
Arizona Republican · 18 September 1897 · page 4
FOUR MURDERED IN A DIVE.
Columbus, Kan., Sept.. 17. A story of crimes rivaling the deeds of the notorious Bender family comes to light in a murder trial now in pro gress here in the district court. Ed
Trials of the Staffleback family in Columbus, Kansas have revealed a series of murders spanning several years, with family members confessing to killing a peddler, two girls, and others whose bodies were dumped in mining shafts. Vigilantes are guarding the jail, threatening to lynch the family if more bodies are found as described.
The Savannah Tribune · 18 September 1897 · page 1
A MURDEROUS FAMILY.
Staftieback murder trials at Columbus, Kas.> have brought to light some bloody butcheries that rival the crime of the Bender family twenty years ago. The Staffleback family, consisting
The article recounts the 1873 Bender family murders in Kansas, describing their house, method of killing travelers, and the discovery of Dr. York's body and seven others in their garden. It frames this history while covering the 1897 Galena, Kansas digging for Staffleback family victims.
New York Journal and Advertiser · 26 September 1897 · page 24
even suspected. The Stafflebacks are the only persons who have ever approached in the number and the brutality of their murders the record of the Benders. With both families murder was apparently a trade, and in the general character of their hideous crimes the two families
This 1897 article retells the Bender family's murder method and the discovery of Dr. York's body and seven others in their garden, then describes their flight and the belief they were lynched by pursuers. It also transitions into an unrelated account of the Staffleback murder family of Galena.
New York Journal and Advertiser · 26 September 1897 · page 24
at the shadow of the traveller's head was easy. The murdered men were then tumbled through a trap door into a cellar under the floor, where they were robbed and afterward buried, in the garden at the rear of the house. On one occasion Kate Bender murdered a travsllor In l-.la horl nnrl then Inv rtnwn null slept beside the corpse until morning. * . Dr. York, of Independence, was the last victim of the Benders. He disappeared in the early part of April, 1873. Search was made by his brother.
See moreSee less
He was traced to the Benders' house. They acknowledged that Dr. York had been there, but said he had lot stopped' over night. Mr. Yon went Into the garden and found a si ".ken spot that looked like a ?rave. It v as dug into, and the body of Dr. York was. found. In other portions of the garden seven more bodies were found. The Benders, packed up their household joods and fled toward the Indian Territory, rhey were fo.'lowed by a hastily organized jarty. The pa '*ty returned the next day, laying that the;' had not been able to find he Benders. They have never been heard from elnee hen, and the reneral inference is that