The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
League presidents Heydler and Johnson, along with White Sox owner Comiskey, manager Gleason, and others, are called to Chicago as the investigation into the 1919 World Series fix expands. Subpoenas are also issued for players Rube Benton, Heinie Zimmerman, and Lee Magee amid allegations of fixed games.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 21 September 1920 · page 6
Fixed Ball Games.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Chattanooga News · Chattanooga, Tenn.
This report previews a crucial three-game series between the Chicago White Sox and Cleveland Indians starting in Cleveland, with the American League pennant potentially hinging on the outcome. It details the remaining schedules for both teams, including matchups against Detroit and St. Louis, and notes Brooklyn's position in the National League race.
The Chattanooga News · 22 September 1920 · page 9
SINGLE SERIES MAY DECIDE RAG
After Unletting with the Indians the White Sox play Detroit. Two games sir scheduled with the Tigers In Chi cago. Then they go to St. Loula to finish the season with three games with the never-easy Browns. The Indians have practically the same program., Finishing; with Chicago, they st" to St. Loula for four games. Inas much as tho Browns have proven hard nuts for the leaders all season, they may be expected to furnish a thrilling quurtct of games. Then the Indians go to Detroit to wind up the season with four frames n the Tlgor lair. In tho National league the day Is only delayed. Brooklyn needs three games, one of which must be captured from the Giants to cinch the pennant.
With Cleveland holding a slim lead over Chicago, both teams rested before a crucial three-game series that could decide the American League pennant. The report lays out remaining schedules and win scenarios for both clubs down the stretch.
The Chattanooga News · 22 September 1920 · page 9
bothIIoxTnd indians rest on oars Cleveland, O.. Sept. 22. The Chicago White Sox. triumphant in their last six games, and the Cleveland Indians, win ners of seven straight In the American league pennant scramble, rested here toduy for their Important three-game series, which starts tomorrow. With Cleveland setting the pace and Chicago only a game and a half behind, the series may go a long way toward de ciding the pennant winner. Both clubs faced open dates today and Manager flleason decided to bring the Chicago players hero for the idle period rather than remain at home.
See moreSee less
Chicago must win two straight to displace Cleveland in the percentage table and three In a row will be neces sary In order that the White Sox may leave here leading the league. Victory in any one of the three games will be sufficient to keep Cleveland in the lead, although If the White Sox take two out of three they will be only a half a game behind. Eacn team Is prepared to present Its strongest line-up. for both managers, facing weak clubs the past few days, made their pitching assignments so as to save their stars for this series. Slenson has Kerr, his most dependable hurler. ready for tomorrow's game, Wille Jim Bnghy, winner of twenty glne contests this season. Is due to Work for Cleveland in the first contest.
The Chicago White Sox open a crucial three-game series against the league-leading Cleveland Indians, needing to win at least two games to remain in pennant contention. Dickie Kerr will pitch the opener against Cleveland's 29-game winner Jim Bagby, with all tickets sold out for the series.
The Milwaukee Leader · 23 September 1920 · page 7
SEVEN Sox Must Take 2 Out of 3 to Stay In Pennant Fight
Sold Out for Sox Series. There is not a reserved seat to be had for any of the three games, scheduled for the White Sox to play
Assistant state's attorney Hartley Replogle says five to seven White Sox players are implicated in fixing the 1919 World Series, based on grand jury testimony from Ban Johnson, Comiskey, and sportswriters. Giants pitcher Rube Benton is alleged to have won $3,800 betting on the series after a tip from banned gambler Hal Chase.
The White Sox defeated the Indians 10-3 behind pitcher Dick Kerr, aided by a disputed hit by Joe Jackson that was ruled a double only because fans crowding the outfield blocked Cleveland's fielder. The report also notes the grand jury investigating the Series had adjourned, while other AL and minor league results are listed.
Grand Forks Herald · 24 September 1920 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Schang.
AMERICAN LEAGUE
See moreSee less
Cleveland, Sept. 24.—The Cleveland team yesterday met Chicago in the first of a series of three games that is expected to decide the American League championship, and broke down under the attack of the White Sox, losing by 10 to 3. Chicago outplayed the Indians in every department of the game. As a result, Cleveland now leads Chicago by only half a game.
Available space in the park was taken, with the exception of right field, where Manager Speaker protested against permitting spectators to gather. However, only three balls were caught by the right fielders. It was the presence of the crowd in left field that started the downfall of the Indians, as Jackson received credit for a two-base hit in starting the sixth inning that would have been an easy out for Left Fielder Evans had the public not been allowed to take possession of that part of the field.
Although he split his finger in the fourth inning, Dick Kerr pitched masterly ball throughout. Jackson, Felsch and Schalk led in the attack on the Cleveland pitchers. Every member of the White Sox except J.
Collins made at least one hit. Score: R. H. E. Chicago .... 000 103 150—10 15 1 Cleveland .. 100 000 020— 3 8 3 Kerr and Schalk; Bagby, Caldwell, Uhle and O'Neill.
Boston yesterday, 7 to 6 and 6 to 1. Stengel had a home run in each game. Pitcher McQuillan scored Boston's only run in the second game, with a home run liner into the left field bleachers. Scores:
The report describes the ongoing Chicago grand jury investigation into whether gamblers bought the 1919 World Series, with American League president Ban Johnson claiming a syndicate paid $100,000 to five White Sox players. Johnson is to be recalled to testify about an alleged blackmail plot, with other witnesses including Heydler, George M. Cohan, and Mont Tennes expected.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Grand Forks Herald · 24 September 1920 · page 8
Boston 001 000 000—1 8 0 Philadelphia 022 110 OOx—6 13 0 McQuillan. Pierotti and Gowdy Hubbell and Wheat. BASEBALL GAME INVESTIGATION INCLEVELAND Charged That Gamblers Bought Last Season's World's Series. Chicago, Sept. 24.—Interest in the grand jury investigation into alleged "throwing" of baseball games by dis honest players switched today from mag.Tuesday, watching nates and fans 5 3 leading Indians" at Cleveland may deKoog cide the future cour.se of the investi |gation. If the White Sox win' they iwill displace Cleveland and lead the !league by a half game. the White Sox do not dare win the paying $100,000'to five White Sox
A source describes learning from a Cincinnati gambling commissioner that a Pittsburgh gambling syndicate arranged for White Sox players to throw the World Series, naming Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, and Felsch as involved. The grand jury is also set to probe a statement attributed to AL President Ban Johnson about gamblers threatening to expose players.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Evening World · 24 September 1920 · page 2
?deny raj-art*" tka?fc Zimmerman waa Pased b-TtV? N*w York Nationals ret that reason. Reporto ^fcbat Zimmer? man was suspended a year ago for try? ing, to throw a game and not for break? ing training, as was announced, were m denied by Mr. Heydler. ?Tip O'Neill, former Western League president, came to me after the first world series game last fall," he said, "and told me Comiskey and Gleason felt that something was wrong, but that they did not want to go to Ban Johnson because of the bad feeling hetveen him and Comiskey at the time.
See moreSee less
I considered the matter preposterous at first, but after Gleason and I had ?oiked the games I went to Johnson. Gave Leads to Johnson "Ha dismissed me with a curt re ?ark, I continued to confer with Comiskey and Gleason, and finally gave Johnson what I considered good leads. I then felt it was up to him to act and ?at my affair. The players accused ?are American League men. "Gleason told me there was no doubt is his mind that something was wrong aad that some one had 'reached* the White Sox players." Concerning the Chicago-Philadelphia National game of August 1, which is ?aid to have been "fixed" for Philadel? phia to win, Mr. Heydler said his in vtetifation convinced him that a de liberate attempt ?had been made by at-?? one to Injure the Chicago club. Tmident Navin sent a letter to Baa Johnson saying that $50,000 was hat on the game and that $10,000 of it Wa bet in Detroit," he said. "This Jatta* waa turned over to me, but I ???a been able to learn of only $3,000 Mt In Cleveland! and $1,300 in Cincin? nati. I have not finished investigat fef." Praise? McGraw's Work -Pr?sidant Heydler said that the New Tafrlc National League club had done
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
The Chicago grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix has adjourned until next Tuesday, with attention now turning to whether the White Sox will win their current series against Cleveland. Reports suggest gamblers are spreading rumors that the White Sox don't want to win the pennant, and League president Ban Johnson will be recalled to testify about an alleged blackmail plot tied to the scandal.
Evening Public Ledger · 24 September 1920 · page 20
BASEBALL PROBERS WATCH WHITE SOX
Chi aura 1 Xn York SI. Loals.. , Chlc-, Sept. 24.-lntern in the J&IhUiiA rnd jury investigation Into alleged netrolt 'fhrnwW of baseball eames bv dlsAthletics . honest msrers switched today from fTKIafrn tn ninriOsrid. ' With the gand jury adjourned until next Tuesday, baseball magnates and fan are watchtne the White Sox, for their Tictory or defeat lu the series with the league-icsatnp; inuians u Cleveland may decide the future course of the Investigation. If the White Sox win today they will displace Cleveland and lH thi Ipninip bv half a game nan Johnson, president of the Amer- (A&u&l tfi kan League, is reported to have received I numro Cle rumors that gamblers are trying io create an impression that the White Eox do not daro win the league pen nant.
See moreSee less
According to statements quot time). ing Mr. Johnvm published by papers here, the syndicate of gamblers which. It has been charged, "bought" Inst year's world series by paying 100. OOO to five white Sox players, threatens to expose the plot If the Chicago team wins the race. Mr. Johnson, It was announced to day, will be recalled by the grand jury next week to tell what he knows about this alleged blackmail plot. Other wit nesses Include President Heydler, of the National League.
Reports describe the Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fixing scandal, with Rube Benton testifying about a telegram tipping him to bet on the Reds and naming players including Gandil and Felsch. Cincinnati's Herrmann says the man Benton accused of fixing claims could not be located, while State's Attorney Hoyne says he believes at least one Chicago player was corrupted.
Evening Public Ledger · 24 September 1920 · page 20
CLEAN BILL FOR REDS, SAYS HERRMANN
I understand his and uuouc s miormaaecr on the series. I bet $20 on the first game and won it. I spent it for drinks in the bar room where I made the wnger. I did not even touch the money. "After the first bet Larry Doyle and 1 made a piker bet on every game. Doyle liked the White Sox and bet on them. I had had my 'tip' and liked the Ilcds. But my winnings were very small, only $10 or $20 a day."
Pitcher Rube Benton testified that a gambling associate named Hahn told him the 1919 World Series fix was engineered by a Pittsburgh gambling syndicate, with White Sox players demanding $100,000 to throw games. Officials including Herrmann and State's Attorney Hoyne pledged to push the investigation further, with Hoyne stating he believed at least one Chicago player was corrupted.
Evening Public Ledger · 24 September 1920 · page 20
SAYS HERRMANN
Giants' pitcher, who told the prnnd Juv yesterday of being offered a bribe to lose a game, named "Buck Her og, Hal Chase and ' Heine" Zim merman in connection with the nlleged offer. In a statment published today he named four White Sox players as having been mentioned to him bv an alleged member of a basehill gambling ring in a discussion of alleged "fix ing" of the 1910 series. Benton, in his story of the alleged "fixing" of the world scries last fall. Hid: "Last fall after the series, a man named Hahn. who halls from Cincin ati and is known as a betting com missioner, visited me at my home in
Cook County grand jury foreman H. H. Brigham told reporters that the name of the man who fixed the 1919 World Series for Cincinnati has been given to the jury. He said this man represented a gambling ring that had offered White Sox players money to throw games.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 25 September 1920 · page 1
Foreman of Grand Jury Says Name of Man "Who Fixed" 1919 World Series Is Known to Jury
« •Makes New barges of Graft ; Sept. 27—President Char ge of the Chicago Ameri jf club tonight received . Jilly Maharg, former box a business partner of Bill !x-major league pitcher, has rspaper men in Philadelphia lite Sox players approached ire the world series last yeai him it had been “fixed” for li to win. tnt Comiskey immediately led Maharg asking him tc ie and present his evidence W County grand jury. Co laid he would give Maharg this charges were proved, ermore I’ll see that every nplicated is fired from or biebail forever,” he said, to statement, as received by , said that Eddie Cicotte pitcher, who lost two games nes approached him with an M saying that he could “yers to throw the games, ate Sox were promised $100, Mowing the games, accord kut receive(1 °nly $10, PU' former featherweight taopion “double crossing’
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
The grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series scandal is reported to have identified the man who allegedly made the fix offer to White Sox players. Comiskey criticizes the American League's prior inaction while pledging full cooperation, and pitcher Rube Benton tells reporters he heard of a gambling syndicate's $100,000 deal involving five White Sox players.
New-York Tribune · 25 September 1920 · page 10
Grand Jury Finds Man Alleged To Have "Fixed" World Series; Foreman Who Made Offer To White Sox Players Is Known
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Rube Benton tells the grand jury he never won $3,800 betting on the Series and recounts how a gambler named Hahn told him the fix was engineered by a Pittsburgh syndicate. He names Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, and Felsch as implicated, says Weaver and Jackson were not mentioned, and recalls Hal Chase and Jean Dubuc also profiting from inside tips.
proached him before the ■world series last year and told him it had been “fixed” for ; Cincinnati to win. f President Comiskey immediately tele* \ graphed Marharg asking him to come here \ and present his evidence to the Cook » county grand jury. Comiskey said he £ would give Maharg $10,000 if hts charges t Iwere proven. “ “Furthermore, I’ll see that every player - effected is barred from organized base X liall forever.’’ — i lie OLnicinvii l oaiu Jesuitic? Ivwvvvj ■■ j* lost two games in the series, approached him, saying he could, furnish sufficient ^ players to throw the game.
See moreSee less
White Sox were offered $100,000 for throw ing the series, said Maharg, but received only $10,000, double crossing them. Ma harg’s statement as received by Comis- ; key, virtually was as follows: -Last fall Cicotte approached Bill •'"Burns and myself in a hotel in New j York. He told us that he could supply I
Clipping to come
Indiana Daily Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
The Brooklyn Dodgers appear poised to win the National League pennant as the Giants make a final push against them in a crucial series. Meanwhile in Cleveland, the Indians and White Sox play the finale of their postseason 'little world series,' with Cleveland having already dealt Chicago a setback that ended the Sox's pennant hopes.
Indiana Daily Times · 25 September 1920 · page 7
THEIR BATTING PUT BROOKLYN ON TOP
ithat the White Sox players ap proached him before the ■world series last year and told him it had been “fixed” for ; Cincinnati to win. f President Comiskey immediately tele* \ graphed Marharg asking him to come here \ and present his evidence to the Cook » county grand jury. Comiskey said he £ would give Maharg $10,000 if hts charges t Iwere proven. “ “Furthermore, I’ll see that every player - effected is barred from organized base X liall forever.’’ — i lie OLnicinvii l oaiu Jesuitic? Ivwvvvj ■■ j* lost two games in the series, approached him, saying he could, furnish sufficient ^ players to throw the game.
See moreSee less
White Sox were offered $100,000 for throw ing the series, said Maharg, but received only $10,000, double crossing them. Ma harg’s statement as received by Comis- ; key, virtually was as follows: -Last fall Cicotte approached Bill •'"Burns and myself in a hotel in New j York. He told us that he could supply I
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
The Cook County grand jury investigating the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series has found evidence of a nationwide gambling ring's attempt to corrupt baseball, and will continue in special session beyond its scheduled term. Comiskey, Johnson, and pitcher Rube Benton gave conflicting testimony, and the names of players whose World Series checks were held up—including Cicotte, Williams, Felsch, Weaver, Risberg, Jackson, and Gandil—were revealed.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 25 September 1920 · page 3
GRAND JURY FINDS EVIDENCE OF AN ATTEMPT BY A NATION-WIDE RING OF GAMBLERS TO POLLUTE THE SPORT
and got left out in the cold." THREE GAMES “THROWN” Philadelphia, September 27.—The first, second and third games of last year’s world’s series were “thrown” to Cincinnati by eight members <*f the .... Chicago Americans, according to rev elations said to have been made by Billy Maharg, former boxer and well known in local sporting circles. Maharg’s story, as printed today in the Philadelphia North American, says that he and “Bill Burns, former American League pitcher, were .he first to be approached in the conspir .acy. •‘I received a wire frorfi Burns from York the middle of last Sep tember Inviting me to take a hunting trip with him down on his ranch in New Mexico, said Maharg.
See moreSee less
“We were to take Bill James, one of the White Sox pitchers, with us. James had nothing to do with subsequent events, but while we were there in the oom talking Cicotte came in and started to talk in a low voice to Burns. “I heard enough to know that he j said that a group of prominent plavers i of the White Sox would be willing to N ‘throw’ the coming world’s series if a syndicate of gamblers would give them ~ $100,000 on the morning of the first game. “When Cicotte left Burns turned to me and repeated ' Cicotte’s conversa tion. part of which I had heard. Burns said ‘do you know any gamblers who would be interested in this proposi tion?’ “I said I would go tot Philadelphia and see whfet I could do. Burns said ’ be would go to Montreal to close an oil d* al and that he would wire about j the progress of the deal. / SAW GAMBLERS
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
The report details testimony before a grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix, including Rube Benton's claim that a Pittsburgh gambling syndicate paid $100,000 to Chicago players. It also names the eight players whose World Series checks were withheld: Cicotte, Williams, Felsch, Weaver, Risberg, Jackson, Gandil, and McMullin, and notes a disputed report that gamblers threatened to expose players unless they lost the current series.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 25 September 1920 · page 3
Affairs of Boston Bank (Associated Press Leased Wire) BOSTON, Sept. 28. — Bank Com missioner Joseph C. Allen today took over the affairs of the Fidelity Trust company. His action marked the closing of the sixth banking institu tion in this city within two months. Among others were the Hanover Trust company of which Charles Ponzi, the "financial wizard,” was a director and largest individual de positor.
Clipping to come
Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
The Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix found evidence of a widespread gambling conspiracy and will extend its session to continue the inquiry. Foreman Brigham said a man who arranged the fix for Cincinnati had been named, and the jury planned to subpoena Arnold Rothstein, Bill Burns, Abe Attell and others; pitcher Rube Benton reportedly testified the White Sox got $100,000 to throw the series.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 25 September 1920 · page 1
FOREMAN DECLARES FEW PLAYERS ARE INVOLVED
Claude Williams, pitcher. Joe Jackson, outfielder. Chick Gandill, former first base man. Assoun cement tha%, the indict ments had been votftd fey the gfend Jury was made by Foreman H. H.
Clipping to come
Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
A grand jury official decries gambling's corruption of baseball while urging public tips, and Comiskey publicly blames Johnson for lacking support in investigating his players. Johnson testified he had evidence of attempted fixing in 1919 but not 1920, while a separate report that gamblers threatened Chicago players this season was dismissed by the team as foolish.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 25 September 1920 · page 1
PLAYERS ARE INVOLVED
Jury was made by Foreman H. H. Brijham of the grand jury. The In dictments had not yet been drawn up at the time the announcement was made, bat had been votei], and there may be several counts. The indictments were based on in formation given by a mysterious wit ness who was before the jury from 12:30 until 1:30 today. The witness appeared before the jury without knowledge of newspapermen and As sistant State's Attorney Replogle re fnsed to make his name public. Alfred Austrian, attorney for Charles Comiskey, owner of the •White Sox, conferred with Replogle shortly before the indictments were returned.
See moreSee less
The information given. to the Jury which led to the indictments is under stood to be substantially the same as that made public in the statement alleged to have been given out by a Philadelphia gambler today. Rnmore of a scandal in connection *ith the series started immediately after the first game was played in Cincinnati. Investigations were start ed by Owner Comiskey and other baseball officials, but no criminal action ever actually got under way until Judge McDonald of the crim inal court instructed the present Cook county grand jury to take up alleged crookedness In baseball in general and the 1919 world series in Particular. Among the first witnesses called were Comiskey and Ban John ®°n, the latter president of the Amor ton league. They gave the grand Wfy the results of their private in T«tigations. Arrangements were made to hear ^eydler, president of the Nana' league John McGraw, man *®fr the New York Giants, and otters high in the baseball world, 0? f*l kno*ro they were not mii raiiea. -The announcement of the inbefore these men came besurprise6 ^ary hig grand caused a The indictments were voted at ,when national baseball tbe n' highest body in the the m*Vo I worldmeeting here to was for the 1920 world series. »ro^ 0vIDa^0n ^hich has been gathby officials tended to indicate
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
Chicago infielder Fred McMullin, who scouted the Reds before the World Series, is reportedly linked to gamblers in grand jury testimony. Former club president Charles Weeghman reveals that gambler Mont Tennes told him before and after the 1919 series that it was fixed and that seven White Sox players were involved.
Brownsville Herald · 26 September 1920 · page 6
UTILITY MAN IS NAMED IN PROBE
Weeks at Cincinnati Study ing Style of the Reds — (lly Tbt? A*8oci;it«*<| I*rr gft i CHICAGO, III., Sept. 25.—Mi Replogle refused to confirm or deny reports that Fred McMullin, Chicago utility infielder, who spent the two weeks before the world’s series at Cincinnati studying the Cincinnati style cf play, hud beer linked with. I the gamblers in testimony given the jury. Charles Weeghman, former presi i dent of the Chicago National league club, in an interview today said tha‘ Mont Tenncs of Chicago, -told him be fore the series that it had been “fixed."
See moreSee less
“Tennes came to me in Sartoga.j N. Y.," said Weegharr. “and said: ‘Charley, a big New York gambler has got the world series fixed.’ After the series Tennes told me he knew seven White Sox players had been fix ed. Their names all have been men tioned in the grand jury investigation,
The Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix postponed subpoenas for Eddie Collins, John Collins, Ray Schalk, and Eddie Murphy until the season concluded, so as not to disrupt the White Sox's pennant chances. Witnesses alleged eight players had agreed to throw games, with Pittsburgh gamblers also implicated and under separate investigation.
Brownsville Herald · 26 September 1920 · page 6
"We do not wrant to interfere with the chances of the White Sox to win the pennant,” said Mr. Repiogle. The players for whom subpoenas were issued earlier in the day but j held up by Mr. Replogle’s orders were j Eddie Collins, field captain of the I team; John Collins, first baseman; Ray Schalk, catcher; and Eddie Mur phy, utility outfielder. Mr. Repiogle said tonight that the! investigation would last two months or longer. President B. B. Johnson of the Am erican League and President John 1 Heydler of the National League, will be the first witnesses when the jurv reconvenes Tuesday. rpv The A*tMelated Press*
National League President John Heydler made public evidence from a private investigation suggesting gambling by major league players. He stated that White Sox officials Comiskey and Gleason believed the 1919 World Series had been fixed, though they lacked direct proof.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 27 September 1920 · page 1
Baseball Officials Sure World Series Fixed, Claim
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
NL President Heydler testifies about multiple gambling investigations, including Magee's confession, suspicions about Zimmerman, and warnings from Gleason and Comiskey before the 1919 World Series that something was wrong. He also discusses an alleged fixed game between Chicago and Philadelphia and Benton's grand jury testimony about Herzog offering a bribe.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 27 September 1920 · page 9
")i true bills against the following toase ,ball players in connection with its investigation of alleged "throwing' \h^oi world series games last year: jjddle Cicotte, Claude Williams, "Chic^", Gandil, "Happy" Felscn, Charles Risberg, Joe Jackson, Fred
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
President Heydler discusses letters about betting amounts in Detroit, Cleveland, and Cincinnati, and describes testimony from Benton about Hal Chase offering money to throw a game. He also reveals McGraw purged Chase and Zimmerman from the Giants over gambling suspicions.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 27 September 1920 · page 9
M'GRAW WRECKS CHANCES
McMullin, "BucJ^' Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans, (White Sox.) H~ The eight players axe charged ^-Svith conspicacy to violate the state '.4aw & Voung of the indictments Vaa' ot a jficia^y announced by H. H. Bhgham,^ {^foreman of the grand jury, following conference with Chief Justice Mc Donald and Alfred S. Austrian, at» vs^*tbrn«y for the White Sox club. "While the indictments at present £'s cont&ln but one count, "conspiracy to ^\^®altl«al act," Assistant State ^Afctorpey Replogle, in charge of the grand Jury Investigation, announced that ipore wlU probably bo added af ter t&e gtfauid Jury session thte -after poon.
See moreSee less
r»e. "bidi&ieittii VV Qandil, while-stilt the property of the Chicago club, has not been with $ -.4^the team this year. It was understood ^#^hat he could not reach an^ agree -«nent with them over salary. Just before the indictments were announced a witness yf&s ushered out Of a disused rear door of th$ grand jury room. He t^aa reported to be Eddie Cicotte, the White Sox star pitcher. Cicotte, who was named, in the story of tl^e alleged gamblers' plot, told" at Philadelphia by Bills' Alaharg, former prize fighter, is said to have signed an immunity waiver and then gone before the grand jury and testified. The sudden voting of ^4^ the true'hills followed. Assistant State Attorney Replogle announced that Cicotte was taken in to custody scfter leaving the grand 1 Jury room and is no,w in charge of ^Yilliam fiullivan, a detective of the igl} state attorney's office. 'He declined ?"$ to say where the pitcher was Ueing taken., v'l I Indicted Men Suspended.
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
National League president John Heydler disclosed evidence from his own investigation into baseball gambling, saying Comiskey and Gleason suspected the 1919 World Series was fixed after the first game. He also implicated pitcher Jean Dubuc and detailed the Hal Chase and Lee Magee gambling cases.
Arizona Republican · 27 September 1920 · page 1
"Fixed" Games Republican A. P. Leased Wire CHICAGO, Sept. 26. Present John HeyRr of the National league to aight made public evidence lie has gathered in a private investigation of alleged baseball gambling and game "throwing." and at the same time de clared that President Comiskey of the
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz. · and 1 other paper
NL President Heydler describes how Comiskey and Gleason suspected something wrong after the first World Series game, and how he brought concerns to Ban Johnson who dismissed them. He also discusses separate allegations against Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman, and Magee's confession of attempting to throw a game.
Arizona Republican · 27 September 1920 · page 1
Heydler, "and told me that Comiskey and Gleason felt . that something was wrong, but that they did not want to fp to Ban Johnson because of the bad l'eelirjr between him and Comiskey. I considered the matter preposterous at first, but after Gleason anI had analyzed the games. I went to John son and told him about it. "He dismissed me with a curt re mark. I continued to confer with Comiskey and Gleason and finally gave Johnson what I considered good leads. I then felt that it was up to him to act and not my affair.
See moreSee less
The players accused were American league men and I did not feel that I should meddle Gleason Felt Something Wrong "Gleason told me in conferences be tween games that there was no doubt in his mind that something was wrong and that some one had 'reached' the White Sox players." Concerning the Chicago-Philadelphia game of August 31 which is said to hare been "fixed" for Philadelphia to win, Mr, Heydler said his investigation convinced him that a deliberate at tempt had been made by some one to injure the Chicago club. "President Xavin sent a letler to Kan Johnson saying that J56.O0O was bet and $10,000 was in Detroit," he said. This letter was turned over to me, but I have been able to learn of only $3,000-bet in Cleveland and $1,300 in (Continued on page 2)
National Commission president Heydler insists the upcoming World Series will be clean, amid startling unconfirmed claims that gamblers had already fixed the 1920 series for Cleveland over Brooklyn. Brooklyn's Charles Ebbets denounces the charges as ridiculous, while a mystery witness, Mrs. Henrietta Kelly, is revealed to have been subpoenaed by the grand jury investigating the scandal.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 27 September 1920 · page 1
BALL MAGNATES MEET
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
National League President Heydler revealed evidence from a private investigation into baseball gambling, including suspicions that the 1919 World Series was fixed. He implicated Jean Dubuc and detailed earlier cases involving Hal Chase and Lee Magee.
New-York Tribune · 27 September 1920 · page 1
Heydler Gives Out Facts on Ball Scandal
Men on Sixteen Teams CHICAGO, Sept. 26.?President John A. Heydler of the National League to lirht mide public evidence he has gath? ered in a private investigation of al Itgti baseball gambling and game ?throwing." He declared President Comiskey of the Chicago Americans ?nd Manager Gleason were convinced, after th? first world series game last y?ar, that the series had been "fixed" tad looght his aid in an investigation. Th? matter was brought to the atten? tion of President B. B. Johnson of the Aateriean League, but Mr. Johnson did sot seem very enthusiastic over starts iag ti?nvestigation, Heydler said. Mr. Heydler brought *:he name of Josa Dubuc, former Detroit American pitcher, into the scandal, and also gave hitherto nnrevealed details of the Hal
NL President John Heydler detailed testimony about multiple corruption cases: Benton's knowledge of the fixed World Series via a telegram, Magee's confession of attempting to throw a game with a Hal Chase check, and suspicions about Zimmerman. He also recounted being warned by Tip O'Neill after the first World Series game that Comiskey and Gleason suspected something was wrong, and his own investigation into a suspicious Cubs-Phillies game.
New-York Tribune · 27 September 1920 · page 1
?deny raj-art*" tka?fc Zimmerman waa Pased b-TtV? N*w York Nationals ret that reason. Reporto ^fcbat Zimmer? man was suspended a year ago for try? ing, to throw a game and not for break? ing training, as was announced, were m denied by Mr. Heydler. ?Tip O'Neill, former Western League president, came to me after the first world series game last fall," he said, "and told me Comiskey and Gleason felt that something was wrong, but that they did not want to go to Ban Johnson because of the bad feeling hetveen him and Comiskey at the time.
See moreSee less
I considered the matter preposterous at first, but after Gleason and I had ?oiked the games I went to Johnson. Gave Leads to Johnson "Ha dismissed me with a curt re ?ark, I continued to confer with Comiskey and Gleason, and finally gave Johnson what I considered good leads. I then felt it was up to him to act and ?at my affair. The players accused ?are American League men. "Gleason told me there was no doubt is his mind that something was wrong aad that some one had 'reached* the White Sox players." Concerning the Chicago-Philadelphia National game of August 1, which is ?aid to have been "fixed" for Philadel? phia to win, Mr. Heydler said his in vtetifation convinced him that a de liberate attempt ?had been made by at-?? one to Injure the Chicago club. Tmident Navin sent a letter to Baa Johnson saying that $50,000 was hat on the game and that $10,000 of it Wa bet in Detroit," he said. "This Jatta* waa turned over to me, but I ???a been able to learn of only $3,000 Mt In Cleveland! and $1,300 in Cincin? nati. I have not finished investigat fef." Praise? McGraw's Work -Pr?sidant Heydler said that the New Tafrlc National League club had done
National League President Heydler reveals evidence of baseball gambling, including Jean Dubuc's alleged role and Lee Magee's confession involving a check from Hal Chase. Players Fred McMullin and Buck Weaver are reported making denials amid the unfolding scandal.
Evening Star · 27 September 1920 · page 19
HEYDLER LAX AS TO CHICAGO INVESTIGATION
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
With a week left in the season, the Cleveland Indians hold a half-game lead over the Chicago White Sox in the tight American League race, while Brooklyn's Dodgers are on the verge of clinching the National League pennant. The report details the remaining schedules and what each team needs to do to win its flag.
Evening Star · 27 September 1920 · page 19
INDIANS-WHITE SOX AND ROBINS NEED ONE
Weaver, McMullin, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson and Gandil. Information leading to the indict ments is understood to have been substantially the same as that made public in, a statement alleged to have been given out by a Philadelphia gambler, who charged the players had been promised $100,000 for throwing the series with Cincinnati. The statement said the players only received $10,000, having been dou ble-crossed out of $90,000 by Abe At tell, former featherweight boxing champion.
Clipping to come
Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.
National League president John Heydler discusses conferring with Comiskey and Gleason about suspicious White Sox games, and describes his investigation into the August 31 Chicago-Philadelphia game as showing a deliberate attempt to injure the Chicago club. Prosecutor Replogle notes the White Sox are now fighting hard to win the pennant regardless of past actions.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 27 September 1920 · page 1
Before Grand Jury. Chicago, Sept. 28. Indictments gainst tight member of the Chi cago Whlta Sox for alleged crooked' ntaa In tha 1919 world'a aarlaa were voted by the Cook county grand Jury, which haa been probing con dltlona In organized baseball, thla afternoon. Tha men indicted r! Chick Qandlt, former flrat bane man; Fred McMuiim, utility In. flelderj Happy Felach, eenterflelder; "Swede" Rlaberg, ehortetop; Eddie Cicotte, pitcher; Claude Williams, pitcher; Joe Jackson, left fielder, and Buck Weaver, third baaaman. TIib true bills charge conspiracy to commit am Illegal art. Eddie Cicotte, atar pitcher, was one of the flrat witnesses before the grand Jury today and hie testimony ii be lieved to have been one of the factors that Induced the grand Jury to return tin.
See moreSee less
Indictments. Ho la said to have made a complete confession and to have signed an immunity waiver. Charge Verified. Hla admlaalons are declared to have Verified with the statement of Billy Miirhag Philadelphia pugilist, who ac cused Clootte of having been the prin cipal In the promotion of the "fixed" aeries. The men Indicted are the eight men said to have been Implicated In the 1 00.000 bribe to throw the seriea and whose bonus checks were held up by the white Sox management while an Investigation was made after the aeries closed last fall. All Eight Suspended. Charles A. Comlakey, owner of the White 80x, announced Imme diately after he heard of the voting of the Indictments by the grand Jury that all eight of the playera would atand suspended from the White Sox. This Is virtually the elimination of the White Sox from the pennant race as none of tha eight men, several of whom are bulwarka of the club, will be per mitted to play In any of the re malnlng games of the season. The action of Comlskej in suspend ing those indicted leaves Eddie Col lins. Bay Schalk John Collins and A inns Strunk as the only regular field ers In pood standing and Dick Kerr and Red Faber as the only regular pitchers. Comlakey Issued the following state ment addressed to each of tho Indicted players: ' "You and each of you are hereby notified of your Indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League Baseball club. Tf you can prove your innocence you will ho returned to the team in good standing. If vou are. found gulltv you are out of or ganized baseball for the rest of your lives." Kddle Cicotte was immediately taken in custody by an officer and taken to the criminal court building.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
NL President Heydler disclosed evidence from his private probe into baseball gambling, stating Comiskey and Gleason suspected the 1919 World Series was fixed right after the first game. He also detailed the Hal Chase, Lee Magee, and Heinie Zimmerman gambling allegations and named Jean Dubuc as newly implicated.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 27 September 1920 · page 3
Before Grand Jury. Chicago, Sept. 28. Indictments gainst tight member of the Chi cago Whlta Sox for alleged crooked' ntaa In tha 1919 world'a aarlaa were voted by the Cook county grand Jury, which haa been probing con dltlona In organized baseball, thla afternoon. Tha men indicted r! Chick Qandlt, former flrat bane man; Fred McMuiim, utility In. flelderj Happy Felach, eenterflelder; "Swede" Rlaberg, ehortetop; Eddie Cicotte, pitcher; Claude Williams, pitcher; Joe Jackson, left fielder, and Buck Weaver, third baaaman. TIib true bills charge conspiracy to commit am Illegal art. Eddie Cicotte, atar pitcher, was one of the flrat witnesses before the grand Jury today and hie testimony ii be lieved to have been one of the factors that Induced the grand Jury to return tin.
See moreSee less
Indictments. Ho la said to have made a complete confession and to have signed an immunity waiver. Charge Verified. Hla admlaalons are declared to have Verified with the statement of Billy Miirhag Philadelphia pugilist, who ac cused Clootte of having been the prin cipal In the promotion of the "fixed" aeries. The men Indicted are the eight men said to have been Implicated In the 1 00.000 bribe to throw the seriea and whose bonus checks were held up by the white Sox management while an Investigation was made after the aeries closed last fall. All Eight Suspended. Charles A. Comlakey, owner of the White 80x, announced Imme diately after he heard of the voting of the Indictments by the grand Jury that all eight of the playera would atand suspended from the White Sox. This Is virtually the elimination of the White Sox from the pennant race as none of tha eight men, several of whom are bulwarka of the club, will be per mitted to play In any of the re malnlng games of the season. The action of Comlskej in suspend ing those indicted leaves Eddie Col lins. Bay Schalk John Collins and A inns Strunk as the only regular field ers In pood standing and Dick Kerr and Red Faber as the only regular pitchers. Comlakey Issued the following state ment addressed to each of tho Indicted players: ' "You and each of you are hereby notified of your Indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League Baseball club. Tf you can prove your innocence you will ho returned to the team in good standing. If vou are. found gulltv you are out of or ganized baseball for the rest of your lives." Kddle Cicotte was immediately taken in custody by an officer and taken to the criminal court building.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
NL President John Heydler recounts how he was warned before the 1919 World Series that something was wrong, and describes evidence of bribery involving Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman, and Magee. He also discusses a suspicious August 31 Phillies-Cubs game and disputed betting figures reported by Detroit's Navin.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 27 September 1920 · page 3
closed last fall. All Eight Suspended. Charles A. Comlakey, owner of the White 80x, announced Imme diately after he heard of the voting of the Indictments by the grand Jury that all eight of the playera would atand suspended from the White Sox. This Is virtually the elimination of the White Sox from the pennant race as none of tha eight men, several of whom are bulwarka of the club, will be per mitted to play In any of the re malnlng games of the season. The action of Comlskej in suspend ing those indicted leaves Eddie Col lins.
See moreSee less
Bay Schalk John Collins and A inns Strunk as the only regular field ers In pood standing and Dick Kerr and Red Faber as the only regular pitchers. Comlakey Issued the following state ment addressed to each of tho Indicted players: ' "You and each of you are hereby notified of your Indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League Baseball club. Tf you can prove your innocence you will ho returned to the team in good standing. If vou are. found gulltv you are out of or ganized baseball for the rest of your lives." Kddle Cicotte was immediately taken in custody by an officer and taken to the criminal court building.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
National League president John Heydler discusses conflicting grand jury testimony, noting Benton first said Herzog offered him money to throw a game but later said it was Chase. McMullin and Weaver deny involvement, though reports allege McMullin acted as go-between and brought a package to Weaver's home.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 27 September 1920 · page 3
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
NL President Heydler recounts how he received tips that the 1919 World Series was fixed, including warnings from Tip O'Neill and his own observations with Kid Gleason, but was initially dismissed by AL President Ban Johnson. He also discusses related corruption cases involving players Magee, Zimmerman, and Hal Chase, plus a separate fixing attempt in an August 1920 NL game.
Evening Public Ledger · 27 September 1920 · page 17
SERIES WAS FIXED
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
NL President Heydler described his investigation into alleged betting irregularities surrounding the 1919 World Series, citing specific sums wagered in various cities. Reds manager Pat Moran separately dismissed rumors that the White Sox had thrown the series, insisting his team won fairly.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Public Ledger · 27 September 1920 · page 17
CHICAGO, Sept 2S.—Hhe Cook j County grand jury this afternoon voted true.bills against the following base ball players in connection with the in vestigation of alleged “tbi owing world series games last year: Eddie Cieott$. Claude William, Chick Gondii!, Happy Felscta, Charles Relsberg, Joe Jackson. Fred McMillan and Buck Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans. The eight players are charged with conspiracy „to violate,.a state law. Assistant State’s Attorney Replogle announced that Cicotte was taken into custody after leaving the grand jury room and is now in charge of William Sullivan, a detective of the state's at torney office. . - He derteed to my where the pitcher w«o httag takes.
Clipping to come
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah
NL President Heydler discusses the investigation into game-fixing, including testimony that Chase (not Herzog) offered Benton money to throw a game, and McGraw's cryptic remark to Benton before that contest. He also addresses the Chicago-Philadelphia game suspected of being fixed to injure Chicago's pennant chances, and notes Zimmerman was actually suspended for trying to throw a game rather than for breaking training as originally announced.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 27 September 1920 · page 8
Johnson what 1 considered good leads. 1 than felt thai it was up tt him to act, and not my affair The players accus' 1 were American league men and did not feel that 1 should med dle SOMETHING WRONG, "Gleason told me in conference.- be tween games that there was no doubt in his mind that somethlnK sa.s wrong and that some one had "reached" the White Sox players." Concerning the Chicago-Philadelphia
National League president John Heydler told reporters about grand jury testimony concerning an alleged bribe offer to Giants players Herzog and Benton, implicating gambler Hal Chase. Meanwhile, Chicago players Fred McMullin and Buck Weaver denied involvement in the World Series fix, even as reports described McMullin delivering a suspicious package to Weaver's home.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 27 September 1920 · page 8
Hearings Tuesday ports of evidence given the Cook 00 un ity grand Jury said that McMullin had acted as 1 he "go be( a een" of a ring of gamblers and Chicago players. It also a n said that McMullin had tato n 1 small oblong package to Weaver's home after one of the games and that' 1 Weaver when he came home and; (found the package refused at first to accept lt but finally did keep it. McMullin said he 'had visited Weav ers home at the Unit he was nilegedi 10 have delivered the package, but Bald It was nobody's business but his own why he went there"
NL President John Heydler describes testimony linking Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman, and Sherry Magee to game-fixing schemes, including a confession from Magee and a check from Chase. He also recounts how Comiskey and Gleason suspected the 1919 World Series was fixed but avoided reporting it to Ban Johnson due to personal animosity, and that Johnson dismissed Heydler's concerns when raised.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 27 September 1920 · page 1
Cicotte’s next appearance in the series was in' the sixth game, when Cincinnati'had four victories against one defeat. Richard Kerr, the diinin utive left handed pitcher, having shutj out the national league cham pions in the third game. The vet erai twirler who today confessed the big gambling deal went through nine innings and held his opponents to sev«m hits. Chicago won the game 4 ti 1, hitting Sallee hard in the first five innings. Jackson and Felsch each getting two hits and between them drove in all" of Chi cago’s runs.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
Billy Maharg told reporters that White Sox players, including Eddie Cicotte, were approached before the 1919 World Series and agreed to throw games for $100,000 but received only $10,000. Comiskey demanded Maharg testify before the Cook County grand jury, vowing to banish anyone proven guilty from baseball.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 28 September 1920 · page 1
« •Makes New barges of Graft ; Sept. 27—President Char ge of the Chicago Ameri jf club tonight received . Jilly Maharg, former box a business partner of Bill !x-major league pitcher, has rspaper men in Philadelphia lite Sox players approached ire the world series last yeai him it had been “fixed” for li to win. tnt Comiskey immediately led Maharg asking him tc ie and present his evidence W County grand jury. Co laid he would give Maharg this charges were proved, ermore I’ll see that every nplicated is fired from or biebail forever,” he said, to statement, as received by , said that Eddie Cicotte pitcher, who lost two games nes approached him with an M saying that he could “yers to throw the games, ate Sox were promised $100, Mowing the games, accord kut receive(1 °nly $10, PU' former featherweight taopion “double crossing’
Billy Maharg told Philadelphia reporters that White Sox players approached him before the 1919 World Series to say the fix was in for Cincinnati to win, with Cicotte arranging the scheme through Abe Attell. Comiskey wired Maharg offering $10,000 if his charges were proven and asked him to testify before the Cook County grand jury.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
MAHARG SAID TO HAVE BEEN TOLD 3 GAMES "FIXED"
Comiskey Asks Former Boxer to Present Evidence Before Grand Jury Probing Baseball Scandal
See moreSee less
By Associated Press
Chicago, September 27.—President Charles Comiskey, of the Chicago American league club, tonight received word that Billy Maharg, former boxer and a business partner of Billy Burns, ex-major league pitcher, has told newspaper men in Philadelphia that the White Sox players approached him before the world series last year and told him it had been "fixed" for Cincinnati to win.
President Comiskey immediately telegraphed Marharg asking him to come here and present his evidence to the Cook county grand jury. Comiskey said he would give Maharg $10,000 if his charges were proven.
"Furthermore, I'll see that every player affected is barred from organized baseball forever."
The statement said Eddie Cicotte, who lost two games in the series, approached him, saying he could furnish sufficient players to throw the game.
White Sox were offered $100,000 for throwing the series, said Maharg, but received only $10,000, double crossing them. Maharg's statement as received by Comiskey, virtually was as follows:
"Last fall Cicotte approached Bill Burns and myself in a hotel in New York. He told us that he could supply enough players to assure the throwing of the game. We made the deal. Abe Attell acting as the 'fixer' or 'go-between.'
"The Sox were double-crossed and so were many of the gamblers by Attell, however, and Burns and I lost every cent we had by betting on Cincinnati to win the third game of the series which we thought also had been fixed. We cleaned up on the first two games.
"According to the story Cicotte told us, eight Sox players were in on the deal. They were the men whose names have been most prominently connected with the Chicago grand jury investigation.
"Thousands and thousands of dollars were made on the series but the men who engineered the deal were double crossed and got left out in the cold."
THREE GAMES "THROWN"
Philadelphia, September 27.—The first, second and third games of last year's world's series were "thrown" to Cincinnati by eight members of the Chicago Americans, according to revelations said to have been made by Billy Maharg, former boxer and well known in local sporting circles.
Maharg's story, as printed today in the Philadelphia North American, says that he and "Bill Burns, former American League pitcher, were the first to be approached in the conspiracy.
"I received a wire from Burns from New York the middle of last September inviting me to take a hunting trip with him down on his ranch in New Mexico, said Maharg. 'We were to take Bill James, one of the White Sox pitchers, with us. James had nothing to do with subsequent events, but while we were there in the room talking Cicotte came in and started to talk in a low voice to Burns.
"I heard enough to know that he said that a group of prominent players of the White Sox would be willing to 'throw' the coming world's series if a syndicate of gamblers would give them $100,000 on the morning of the first game.
"When Cicotte left Burns turned to me and repeated Cicotte's conversation, part of which I had heard. Burns said 'do you know any gamblers who would be interested in this proposition?'
"I said I would go to Philadelphia and see what I could do. Burns said he would go to Montreal to close an oil deal and that he would wire about the progress of the deal.
SAW GAMBLERS
"I then went to Philadelphia and saw some gamblers there. They told me that it was too big a proposition for them to handle and directed me to Arnold Rothstein, a well-known and wealthy New York gambler. In the meantime Burns had returned to New York and I went over again and joined him. We met Rothstein by appointment and put the proposition up to him. He declined to get into it. He said he did not think that such a frame-up could be possible.
"We left Rothstein and hung around New York for a while. I returned to Philadelphia, thinking that everything was off until I received the following telegram from Bill Burns. It read:
"'Arnold R. has gone through with everything. Got eight in, leaving for Cincinnati at 4:30.'
"I went the next day and joined Burns. He said that after I had left New York he ran into Abe Attell, the fighter, who had gone to Rothstein and fixed things up. Burns said he had seen Cicotte and that eight members of the team were in the deal. Attell was then quartered in a large suite of the Sinton and had a gang of about 25 New York gamblers with him. He said they were working for Rothstein.
"I had my first suspicion on the morning of the first game when Burns and I visited Attell. We asked for the $100,000 to turn over to the White Sox players to carry out our part of the deal.
"Attell refused to turn over the $100,000, saying that they needed the money to make bets. He made a counter-proposals that $20,000 would be handed the players at the end of each losing game. Burns went to the Sox players and they seemed satisfied with the new arrangements.
"Burns told me that he saw the players were restless and wanted the full amount, and he was afraid they would not keep up the agreement.
"The players, however, told Burns that if they lost behind Cicotte and Williams, they wouldn't win for Kerr. So we went to Chicago and bet all of our personal winnings of the first two days on Cincinnati to win the third game. As a matter of fact, the Sox got even with us by winning this game Burns and I lost every cent we had in our clothes. The whole upshot of the matter was that Attell and his gang cleaned up a fortune and the Sox players were double-crossed out of $90,000 that was coming to them."
Billy Maharg's statement, given to Comiskey and published in the Philadelphia North American, describes how Cicotte approached him and Bill Burns with a plan for White Sox players to throw the World Series for $100,000. Maharg details how Burns contacted Arnold Rothstein through Philadelphia gamblers, and how the players and many gamblers including Burns and Maharg were ultimately double-crossed by Abe Attell.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 13
THREE GAMES "THROWN"
the third game of the series which we | < thought also had been fixed. We cleaned | up on the first two games. “According to the story Cicotte told ! us, eight iix players were in on the j deal. They'^were the men whose names | have been most prominently connected l with the Chicago grand jury investlga ~ tlon. “Thousands and thousands of dollars were made on the series but the men who engineered the deal were double crossed and got left out in the cold."
Billy Maharg recounts how Bill Burns overheard Cicotte offering to throw the World Series for $100,000, leading them to approach gamblers in Philadelphia and eventually Arnold Rothstein in New York. He describes Rothstein's initial refusal and a later telegram suggesting Rothstein had changed his mind.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 13
the progress of the deal. / SAW GAMBLERS •f then .vent to /Philadelphia and saw j seme gamblers there. They told mo that it vas too big a proposition for them ; - to handle and directed me to Arnold ] Rothstein. a well-known and wealthy j New York gambler. In the meantime i Burns had returned to New York and 1 ! went over again and joined him. We met Rothstein by appointment and put the proposition up to him. He declined to get into if. He said he did not think that such a frame-up could be possible.
See moreSee less
“We left Rothstein \nd hung around New York for a while. T returned to Philadelphia, thinking that everything was off until T received the following telegram from Bill Burns. It read: “ Arnold R. has gone through with
Chicago White Sox owner Charles Comiskey announces the suspension of eight players amid allegations they conspired to throw the 1919 World Series. The move comes as the scandal breaks into public view.
Douglas Daily International · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT PLAYERS INDICTED FOR ‘FIXING’ GAME (Associated Press Leased Wire) CHICAGO, Sept. 28. — Charles Comiskey, president of the White Sox, suspended every member of the team indicted today In connection with the alleged fixing of baseball games. Seven of the eight indicted are affected, Chick Gandil, the eighth is not playing this year. The suspension practically kills all hope of the White Sox winning the American league pennant this year. CHICAGO, Sept. 28. — The Cook county grand jury this afternoon voted true bills against the follow ing baseball players in connection with its investigation of alleged ‘throw ing of world’s series games last year: Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, “Chick” Gandil, “Happy” Felsch, Charles Risberg, Joe Jackson, Fred McMMullip, “Buck” Weaver.
See moreSee less
AIL are members of the Chicago American club. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state law. Gandil, while still the property of the Chicago ..club, has not been with the team this year. It was under stood that he could not reach an agreement with them over salaryWhile the indictments at present contain but one count, “conspiracy to do an illegal act,” Assistant State’s Attorney Hartley. Replogle, in charge of the grand jury investigation, an nounced that more probably would be added after thp grand jury session.this afternoon. Just before the indictments were announced a witness was ushered out a disused rear door of the grand jury room. He was reported to be Eddie i Cicotte, the White Sox pitcher. i Maharg Testifies Cicotte, who was named in the I story of the alleged gdmblers’ plot, i told at Philadelphia last, night by Billy Maharg, former prize fighter, is said to have signed an immunity waiver and then to have gone before the grand jury and testified. ’Hie sudden voting of the true Lills fol. lojwed. Assistant State’s xlttorney Kep logle announced that Cicotte was taken into custody after leaving tne grand jury room, and now Is in charge of William Sullivan, a de tective of the state’s attorney's of fice. He declined to say where the pitcher was being taken. Sends Telegram
A Cook County grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy related to fixing the 1919 World Series. Club president Comiskey immediately suspended the indicted players, effectively ending the team's pennant hopes.
Douglas Daily International · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT PLAYERS INDICTED FOR 'FIXING' GAME
CHICAGO, Sept. 28. — The Cook county grand jury this afternoon voted true bills against the follow ing baseball players in connection with its investigation of alleged ‘throw ing of world’s series games last year: Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, “Chick” Gandil, “Happy” Felsch, Charles Risberg, Joe Jackson, Fred McMMullip, “Buck” Weaver.
A Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players on charges of conspiracy to commit an illegal act related to the 1919 World Series fix. Pitcher Eddie Cicotte reportedly testified under an immunity waiver before being taken into custody, and club attorney Alfred Austrian telegraphed indefinite suspensions to all eight accused players.
Douglas Daily International · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Charles Risberg, Joe Jackson, Fred McMMullip, “Buck” Weaver. AIL are members of the Chicago American club. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state law. Gandil, while still the property of the Chicago ..club, has not been with the team this year. It was under stood that he could not reach an agreement with them over salaryWhile the indictments at present contain but one count, “conspiracy to do an illegal act,” Assistant State’s Attorney Hartley. Replogle, in charge of the grand jury investigation, an nounced that more probably would be added after thp grand jury session.this afternoon.
See moreSee less
Just before the indictments were announced a witness was ushered out a disused rear door of the grand jury room. He was reported to be Eddie i Cicotte, the White Sox pitcher. i Maharg Testifies Cicotte, who was named in the I story of the alleged gdmblers’ plot, i told at Philadelphia last, night by Billy Maharg, former prize fighter, is said to have signed an immunity waiver and then to have gone before the grand jury and testified. ’Hie sudden voting of the true Lills fol. lojwed. Assistant State’s xlttorney Kep logle announced that Cicotte was taken into custody after leaving tne grand jury room, and now Is in charge of William Sullivan, a de tective of the state’s attorney's of fice. He declined to say where the pitcher was being taken. Sends Telegram Following the indictment Alfred S.
The Cook county grand jury continues investigating baseball gambling, with Mrs. Henrietta Kelley and league officials including Heydler, Johnson, and Gleason expected to testify about conversations with Chicago players. Comiskey telegraphs Billy Maharg, who told reporters White Sox players admitted the 1919 World Series was fixed for Cincinnati to win, asking him to testify before the grand jury.
Arizona Republican · 28 September 1920 · page 1
BASEBALL JURY TODAY
CHICAGO, Sept. 29—Further con fessions by some of the seven White Sox players who with one former player were indicted yesterday in connection with the alleged throw ing if the lest world's series will be made within a day or two, Alfred Austrian .attorney for the ball club, announces! today. it has i\en rumored that at least two more intend to supplement state ments by Cicotte, pitcher, and Joe Jackson, outfielder, with their stories. True bills naming three players, not members of the White Sox and three gamblers are expected to be voted to day.
See moreSee less
Claude Williams, “Lefty,” went be fore the jury today and reveald the identity of the alleged go-betweens and gamblers who bribed White Sox play ers. Williams named “Chick” Gandil as the chief go-between on the team and “Brown and Sullivan, gamblers” from either New, York or Boston as the go-between for the gamblers. The jury immediately voted true bills against Brown and Sullivan. Willianms said he was to get $20,000 but. he received only SIO,OOO which lie split with Joe Jackson. Evidence already before the grand jury is said to involve Abe A,ttel, former price fighter, Lee Magee, Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman., former members of the New York Giants and three eUstern gamblers, whose names .have not been divulged and at least two national league players. Hartley Repigle, assistant state’s attorney, woh today confirmed these facts, admitted that ten or twelve in d.ctments are i& prospect. The grand jury whose normal period of office ex res tomorrow will be continued in definitely to complete the baseball in vestigation.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
A Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the 1919 White Sox team on conspiracy charges related to the World Series. The indictments followed testimony from a mysterious secret witness and came as the National Commission met to plan the 1920 series.
Evening Journal · 28 September 1920 · page 2
Indict Eight White Sox In Baseball Scandal
CINCINNATI JURY READY FOR ACTION (Hv Associated Press) CINCINNATI, Sept. 29.—As the, re sult of Cicotte’s confession that he found the money under his pillow' in the Hotel Cincinnati, the Hamilton county jury just summoned will inquire into the circumstances. Cicitte confessed !|j received SIO,OOO the night before the, firsL tMWvn Cincinnati, finding it under his piilow.
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Reports allege the same gambling syndicate behind the 1919 World Series fix is now blackmailing White Sox players and plotting to have Brooklyn throw the 1920 series to Cleveland. Grand jury testimony reportedly described a $100,000 bribe offer to a player, who it is claimed recruited teammates and received advance payments from an unnamed Eastern backer.
|v«>r loving < up and the league leathng >■ I ^lllKger res(«ondad in the sixth inning tth « home run for his two hundred and bun.'mth bit i«f the season, breaking T\ 1 .|il> s r«M'ord of IMS made in 1911. Boston eloaed its season by dividing a double-In-ad«'r with Washington. The |{,si Sox won the first 5 to it while the S ' ator> w «Te romi'elletl to go ten innings to win 7 to A. Tbe only games scheduled in (be Niv tional Isiagu«' were two b»'<w«H'n Pitts burg and Cincinnati who have become Mi 'ib f'»r third plarx- 'I h«> Ke<is won both hx" tlw> scores 2 to 0 and S to 0. •urn*«
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
The report states that indicted players led Black Sox gamblers to believe a wealthy Eastern banker, who lacked funds himself, had financed the fix. It notes that two of the indicted men, Williams and Jackson, had previously played for the Harlan team in Wilmington.
Evening Journal · 28 September 1920 · page 2
VNOWS MUN IN RING. "However. I am of the opinion that all the crooked work was not coasied to this serie. Just how many and what ether games have ben thrown' I am not as yet in a position to say. but there is little question that so of those played this year have looked gqter. "Naturally we are perhaps more in terested in prosecuting the crooked gamblers who are responsible than the 'men who were upable to resist temptation. "We have learned the names of at least two of the 'triple ring' that had headquarters in New York and fur nished the money to buy up players. Te name of the third I hope to gut tedey."
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Chicago grand jury returns true bills against eight White Sox players for conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, prompting Comiskey to suspend seven of them. The report also includes Billy Maharg's account of the plot's origins, naming Abe Attell as the key figure who arranged bets and payments.
Evening Star · 28 September 1920 · page 1
WHITE SOX SUSPENDED AFTER BEING INDICTED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Billy Maharg, a former boxer, gives a detailed account to reporters of how the fix was organized, naming Abe Attell as the key figure who took $100,000 from gambler Arnold Rothstein but double-crossed the players out of $90,000. Maharg describes how Eddie Cicotte first proposed the scheme to pitcher Eddie Cicotte through Sleepy Bill Burns, and how Attell later reneged on paying the players the full agreed sum during the World Series.
Evening Star · 28 September 1920 · page 1
'CROOK ON EVERY TEAlS." A report that the ghasblers maim aimed at least ee moan and io some eases two er three on every teae i the mager leagues em their payroll nad in this mmcer sought, virtually to esatuel the sert will be given a thorough Imvestigatilo. The White Sox expect to give a practical demonstration of the value of reserve strength to a ball club in the remaining gantes of the season. Ray Schalk, Bird Lynn and ClydeYion lard make up the catching staff which is intact. "Red" Faber. Dick Kerr, Ray Wilkinson and Shorty" Hodge make up four pitchers.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
Billy Maharg recounts how Bill Burns and Abe Attell arranged the fix with eight White Sox players, describing how Attell's gang profited while the players were shortchanged $90,000. The Cook County grand jury investigation resumes with League presidents testifying, while Eddie Cicotte denies knowing Maharg or discussing a fix.
Evening Star · 28 September 1920 · page 1
crooked players $100,000. Cicotte be- ; lleva* they gave this amount to Gandil. Somewhere in the deal, however, $75r 000 was lost. Cicotte said he believed Gandil or else Abe Attell, who acted for the gamblers, held out the money. There was only $25,000 passed around, according to Cicotte. He said ha received $10,000; Williams received $10,000 and Jackaon received $6,000. Jackson, who to.k tha stand after Ci? cotte, admitted that he had received the amount attributed to him. It was then that the grand jury voted the in? dictments. There will be two indictments re?
See moreSee less
turned against each of the men, it is said. One will charge them with the operation of a confidence game. The other will charge them with conspiracy with gamblers to obtain money through the operation of a. confidence game. * Conviction of the ftrat charge carries with it a penalty of from one to ten years' imprisonment. The penalty for conviction on the second charge is five years' imprisonment and a fine of $2,000. No arrests have been made yet. The indictments will be formally returned i before the latter part of the week, it was announced at the state's attorney's office. Mean time the accused men will fiot even be under surveillance. Cicotte Weeps on Stand Cicotte's testimony was accompanied by tears. He was on the witness stand for nearly two hours. He cried, "I don't know why I did it. I must have been crazy." Cicotte said that he found his bribe money under his pillow; that after the first game of the series he had gone to his hotel alone, and the money was half concealed beneath the pillow. "There was no note, he said, but he knew what it was for. "Before Gandil? was a ball player he mixed in with gamblers and low char? acters in Arizona," said Cicotte1. "That's where he got the hunch to fix the world series. Abe Attell and three .Pittsburgh gamblers agreed to back ?Jiim. Gandil first fixed Williams and McMullin. Then he got me in on the ?eal, and we fixed the rest. It -was easy to throw the game. Just a slight _jbesitotion on a player's part will let a i man get a base or a run. "I did it by giving the Cincinnati ' batters easy balls and putting them right over the plate. A baby could have hit them. "Then in one of the games?the sec ? ond, I think?there was a man on first and the Reds' batter hit a slow grounder to me. I could have made a double play out of it without any ? trouble at all. But I was slow?slow ? enough to permit the batter to get to , first and the man on first to get to second. "It did not necessarily look crooked on my part. It is hard to tell when a ; game is or is not on the square. A 1 player can make a crooked error that will look on the square as easy as he can make a square one. Sometimes the square ones look crooked." Cicotte said he had been troubled with his conscience evler since the serios. "I've lived a thousand years in the last twelve months," he said. "I would not have done that thing for % million dollars. I didn't need the money. My salary was $10,000 a year and my job was sure. "And now I've lost everything?job, reputation and friends. My friends all bet on the Sox. I knew it, but I couldn't tell them that the Sox would
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
The Cook County grand jury returned true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players—Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Weaver, Risberg, Jackson, and McMullin—for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. Comiskey immediately suspended all indicted players still on the team, ending Chicago's pennant hopes, while Cicotte was reported to have signed an immunity waiver before testifying.
Americus Times-Recorder · 28 September 1920 · page 1
8 OF WHITE SOX TEAM INDICTED AND SUSPENDED
crooked players $100,000. Cicotte be- ; lleva* they gave this amount to Gandil. Somewhere in the deal, however, $75r 000 was lost. Cicotte said he believed Gandil or else Abe Attell, who acted for the gamblers, held out the money. There was only $25,000 passed around, according to Cicotte. He said ha received $10,000; Williams received $10,000 and Jackaon received $6,000. Jackson, who to.k tha stand after Ci? cotte, admitted that he had received the amount attributed to him. It was then that the grand jury voted the in? dictments. There will be two indictments re?
See moreSee less
turned against each of the men, it is said. One will charge them with the operation of a confidence game. The other will charge them with conspiracy with gamblers to obtain money through the operation of a. confidence game. * Conviction of the ftrat charge carries with it a penalty of from one to ten years' imprisonment. The penalty for conviction on the second charge is five years' imprisonment and a fine of $2,000. No arrests have been made yet. The indictments will be formally returned i before the latter part of the week, it was announced at the state's attorney's office. Mean time the accused men will fiot even be under surveillance. Cicotte Weeps on Stand Cicotte's testimony was accompanied by tears. He was on the witness stand for nearly two hours. He cried, "I don't know why I did it. I must have been crazy." Cicotte said that he found his bribe money under his pillow; that after the first game of the series he had gone to his hotel alone, and the money was half concealed beneath the pillow. "There was no note, he said, but he knew what it was for. "Before Gandil? was a ball player he mixed in with gamblers and low char? acters in Arizona," said Cicotte1. "That's where he got the hunch to fix the world series. Abe Attell and three .Pittsburgh gamblers agreed to back ?Jiim. Gandil first fixed Williams and McMullin. Then he got me in on the ?eal, and we fixed the rest. It -was easy to throw the game. Just a slight _jbesitotion on a player's part will let a i man get a base or a run. "I did it by giving the Cincinnati ' batters easy balls and putting them right over the plate. A baby could have hit them. "Then in one of the games?the sec ? ond, I think?there was a man on first and the Reds' batter hit a slow grounder to me. I could have made a double play out of it without any ? trouble at all. But I was slow?slow ? enough to permit the batter to get to , first and the man on first to get to second. "It did not necessarily look crooked on my part. It is hard to tell when a ; game is or is not on the square. A 1 player can make a crooked error that will look on the square as easy as he can make a square one. Sometimes the square ones look crooked." Cicotte said he had been troubled with his conscience evler since the serios. "I've lived a thousand years in the last twelve months," he said. "I would not have done that thing for % million dollars. I didn't need the money. My salary was $10,000 a year and my job was sure. "And now I've lost everything?job, reputation and friends. My friends all bet on the Sox. I knew it, but I couldn't tell them that the Sox would
Clipping to come
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the 1919 White Sox—Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Gandil—on conspiracy charges related to fixing World Series games. The indictments followed testimony from a mysterious witness and were announced by grand jury foreman H. H. Brigham, though formal charges had not yet been drafted.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 28 September 1920 · page 1
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
The Cook County grand jury has voted indictments against players including Jackson, Gandil, and Cicotte based on testimony from a mysterious witness, though the indictments had not yet been formally drawn up. The probe began after Judge McDonald directed the grand jury to investigate alleged crookedness in the 1919 World Series, with Comiskey and Ban Johnson among early witnesses.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Jury was made by Foreman H. H. Brijham of the grand jury. The In dictments had not yet been drawn up at the time the announcement was made, bat had been votei], and there may be several counts. The indictments were based on in formation given by a mysterious wit ness who was before the jury from 12:30 until 1:30 today. The witness appeared before the jury without knowledge of newspapermen and As sistant State's Attorney Replogle re fnsed to make his name public. Alfred Austrian, attorney for Charles Comiskey, owner of the •White Sox, conferred with Replogle shortly before the indictments were returned.
See moreSee less
The information given. to the Jury which led to the indictments is under stood to be substantially the same as that made public in the statement alleged to have been given out by a Philadelphia gambler today. Rnmore of a scandal in connection *ith the series started immediately after the first game was played in Cincinnati. Investigations were start ed by Owner Comiskey and other baseball officials, but no criminal action ever actually got under way until Judge McDonald of the crim inal court instructed the present Cook county grand jury to take up alleged crookedness In baseball in general and the 1919 world series in Particular. Among the first witnesses called were Comiskey and Ban John
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
A grand jury voted indictments against Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy in fixing the 1919 World Series, with Eddie Cicotte taken into custody by a state's attorney investigator. Reports also claimed gamblers were blackmailing the Sox and plotting to fix the upcoming 1920 series between Brooklyn and Cleveland.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Told Game Was Fixed. DES MOINES. Iowa, Sept. 28.—That Des Moines baseball gamblers had advised him that the world series of 1919 between the White Sox and Cin1315J oeuweeu me yv m«.c au
The Cook County grand jury voted true bills against Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, McMullin and Weaver for conspiracy in the 1919 World Series fix. Comiskey immediately suspended all indicted players, and Cicotte reportedly signed an immunity waiver and testified before the grand jury.
Evening Times-Republican · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Indicted Players. CICOTTE MAY HAVE SPILLED THE BEANS f*. Star Pitoher Signs Immunity Waiver and QOM Before Grand Jury—Ci cotte, Weaver, Felseh, Gandil, Wil liams, Jackson, MoMullin and Ris barg Indicted—-Sox to Finiah Sea •on With Chinaman if Nacaasary. By Associated Press. —The Cook coun Chicago. Sept. 28 afternoon voted ty grand jury this ")i true bills against the following toase ,ball players in connection with its investigation of alleged "throwing' \h^oi world series games last year: jjddle Cicotte, Claude Williams, "Chic^", Gandil, "Happy" Felscn, Charles Risberg, Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin, "BucJ^' Weaver.
See moreSee less
All are members of the Chicago Americans, (White Sox.) H~ The eight players axe charged ^-Svith conspicacy to violate the state '.4aw & Voung of the indictments Vaa' ot a jficia^y announced by H. H. Bhgham,^ {^foreman of the grand jury, following conference with Chief Justice Mc Donald and Alfred S. Austrian, at» vs^*tbrn«y for the White Sox club. "While the indictments at present £'s cont&ln but one count, "conspiracy to ^\^®altl«al act," Assistant State ^Afctorpey Replogle, in charge of the grand Jury Investigation, announced that ipore wlU probably bo added af ter t&e gtfauid Jury session thte -after poon. r»e. "bidi&ieittii VV Qandil, while-stilt the property of the Chicago club, has not been with $ -.4^the team this year. It was understood ^#^hat he could not reach an^ agree -«nent with them over salary. Just before the indictments were announced a witness yf&s ushered out Of a disused rear door of th$ grand jury room. He t^aa reported to be Eddie Cicotte, the White Sox star pitcher. Cicotte, who was named, in the story of tl^e alleged gamblers' plot, told" at Philadelphia by Bills' Alaharg, former prize fighter, is said to have signed an immunity waiver and then gone before the grand jury and testified. The sudden voting of ^4^ the true'hills followed. Assistant State Attorney Replogle announced that Cicotte was taken in to custody scfter leaving the grand 1 Jury room and is no,w in charge of ^Yilliam fiullivan, a detective of the igl} state attorney's office. 'He declined ?"$ to say where the pitcher was Ueing taken., v'l I Indicted Men Suspended. Charles ?omiskey, president of the White Sox, todfy suspended every niember of the team^ indicted today in oonectiOn with the alleged fixing of baseball games, xfieven of the eight men indicted are affected. "Chick" eandil, the eighth, is not, playing this year. The suspension practically kills all hope of the White Sox winhing the '.! American League pennant this year, To Play Out/Schedule. .o "Wo will ptfry out the schedule if '. •^tve have to g«4^ Chinamen to replace tfcAhe suspended players," Harry Grab nar, eecretary of the White Sox, an .^nounced this afternoon. tfe ComiskeyXActs Quiokly. Alfred S. Austrian, attorney for th& club, sent the following telegram to *i _. Risberg, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch \%-"Weaver, w'illiams and Cicotte: !r "You, and each of you, are hereby V^,-notified of your indefinite suspension |f as a member of the Chicago Ameri can League baseball club. "Your suspension is brought about by information which Jias Jtist come to me directly /Involving you, and each' Of you, in thef baseball scandal (being investigated by the present grand jury of Cook county) resulting from the world series of 1919. "If you are innocent of any wrong 4olng you, and each of you, will be reinstated if you are guilty, you will be retired from organized baseball for the rest of your lives If I cstn ac complish it. "There is a flnalty to this Investi gation. It Is due to the public that I take this action even tho it costs Chi cago the pennant. "Charles A. Comiskey."
A Chicago grand jury returned true bills against eight White Sox players, charging conspiracy to violate state law in connection with the alleged World Series fix. Eddie Cicotte reportedly signed an immunity waiver and testified before the jury, and club owner Comiskey immediately suspended all indicted players still on the roster.
Evening Times-Republican · 28 September 1920 · page 1
McMullin, "BucJ^' Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans, (White Sox.) H~ The eight players axe charged ^-Svith conspicacy to violate the state '.4aw & Voung of the indictments Vaa' ot a jficia^y announced by H. H. Bhgham,^ {^foreman of the grand jury, following conference with Chief Justice Mc Donald and Alfred S. Austrian, at» vs^*tbrn«y for the White Sox club. "While the indictments at present £'s cont&ln but one count, "conspiracy to ^\^®altl«al act," Assistant State ^Afctorpey Replogle, in charge of the grand Jury Investigation, announced that ipore wlU probably bo added af ter t&e gtfauid Jury session thte -after poon.
See moreSee less
r»e. "bidi&ieittii VV Qandil, while-stilt the property of the Chicago club, has not been with $ -.4^the team this year. It was understood ^#^hat he could not reach an^ agree -«nent with them over salary. Just before the indictments were announced a witness yf&s ushered out Of a disused rear door of th$ grand jury room. He t^aa reported to be Eddie Cicotte, the White Sox star pitcher. Cicotte, who was named, in the story of tl^e alleged gamblers' plot, told" at Philadelphia by Bills' Alaharg, former prize fighter, is said to have signed an immunity waiver and then gone before the grand jury and testified. The sudden voting of ^4^ the true'hills followed. Assistant State Attorney Replogle announced that Cicotte was taken in to custody scfter leaving the grand 1 Jury room and is no,w in charge of ^Yilliam fiullivan, a detective of the igl} state attorney's office. 'He declined ?"$ to say where the pitcher was Ueing taken., v'l I Indicted Men Suspended.
Charles Comiskey suspended seven indicted White Sox players and vowed permanent banishment if they were found guilty of fixing the 1919 World Series. Pitcher Eddie Cicotte denied knowing Billy Maharg or being involved in any $100,000 plot to throw the series.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Times-Republican · 28 September 1920 · page 1
A Cook County grand jury indicted seven White Sox players and Gandil on conspiracy charges for throwing the 1919 World Series, prompting Comiskey to suspend them. Cicotte reportedly confessed to the grand jury that he received $10,000 and Jackson $5,000 to lose the series.
The Daily Star-Mirror · 28 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
CHICAGO WHITE SOX INDICTED FOR THROWING WORLD SERIES
CHICAGO—(By A. P.)—Seven members of the Chicago White Sox, and one of the former players were today indicted by the Cook county grand jury, charged with conspiracy to commit an illegal act in connection with last year's world series, in which they have been accused of "selling" to a coterie of gamblers.
See moreSee less
President Comiskey immediately suspended seven, thereby forfeiting all chances of winning the American league pennant.
The White Sox were only half a game behind the league leading Cleveland team. Comiskey notified the accused players that if they are guilty he will drive them out of baseball, if possible.
The suspended players are Cicotte, Williams, Felsch, Risberg, Weaver, Jackson and McMullin. Gandil is the former player indicted.
Say Cicotte Confessed to Being Bribed
Eddie Cicotte, one of Chicago's star pitchers, confessed that he engineered the deal whereby the White Sox lost last year's world series, a court official announced this afternoon. He says Cicotte told the grand jury that he received $10,000 and Joe Jackson received $5,000 for losing the series. He said they found the money under their pillows the night before the first game.
The Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy related to fixing the 1919 World Series. Cicotte reportedly confessed and signed an immunity waiver, corroborating accusations from boxer Billy Maharg about a $100,000 bribe scheme.
Indiana Daily Times · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT WHITE SOX STARS INDICTED IN BIG SCANDAL PROBE
••Swede” Risberg, shortstop. Eddie Cicotte, pitcher. Claude Williams, pitcher. Joe Jackson, left fielder. Back Weaver, third baseman. The true bills charge conspiracy to commit an illegal act Eddie Cicotte, star pitcher, was one of the first witnesses before the grand jury today and his testimony is helieved to have been one of the factors that induced the grand jury to return the indictments. He is said to have made a compile oou fesion and to have signed an immunity waiver. His admissions are declared to have verified the statement of Billy Ma harg, Philadelphia pugilist, who accused Cicotte ol' having been the principal in the promotion of the ’•fixed" series. *IOO,OOO SAID TO
The report says Cicotte made a full confession and signed an immunity waiver, corroborating Billy Maharg's claim that Cicotte was the principal figure in arranging the fixed World Series for a $100,000 bribe. Comiskey immediately suspended all eight indicted White Sox players, crippling the team's pennant hopes.
Indiana Daily Times · 28 September 1920 · page 1
the promotion of the ’•fixed" series. *IOO,OOO SAID TO HAVE BEEN BRIBE. The plavers indicted are the eight men said to have been implicated in the SIOO.- 000 bribe to "throw” the series and whose bonus checks were held up by the White Sox management while an investi gation was made after the series closed last fall. McMullin, Gandil and Cicotte were mentioned in several stories as the prin cipals in the arrangements for the huge bribe which Abe Attell. former feather weight champion, is alleged to have un dertaken to raise.
See moreSee less
McMullin had been named as the chief paymaster for the gambling clique. Charles A. Comlskey, owner ot the White Sox, announced immediately after he heard of the Noting of the indict ments by the grand jury, that ail eight of the players would stand suspended from the White Sox. This move by Comiskey is virtually the elimination of the White Sox from the pennant race, as none of the eight men. several of whom are bulwarks or the club, will bo permitted to play in any of the remaining games of the sea son, it Is raid. ONLY FEW SOX
Mrs. Henrietta Kelley testified before the grand jury that she overheard Eddie Cicotte tell his brother Jack, "To hell with 'em—I got mine," after a World Series game Cicotte had lost. The statement was presented as evidence of Cicotte's guilty conscience regarding the fix.
Indiana Daily Times · 28 September 1920 · page 1
CHICAGO, Sept. 28.—“T0 hell with 'em —I got mine,” is a statement made by Eddie Cicotte to his brother .lack, according to a statement made today by Mrs. Henrietta D. Kelley, the “woman of mystery.” in the baseball scandal, who was a .witness before the grand jury today. •‘1 overheard a conversation be tween Eddie Cicotte and his brother •lack during tbe world’s series, Mrs. Kelley said "It was after one of the games lost because of Eddie's pitching. I heard him say: ‘To hell with ’em—l got mine.'”
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The Cook County grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series, after pitcher Eddie Cicotte confessed and testified. The eight suspended players included Cicotte, Jackson, Weaver, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, and McMullin.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Members of White Sox Team Must Face Trial for Crookedness
Abe Attell Threaten#. NEW YORK, Sept 29.—Threats to tell some things about the "inside BtorT-fOt the last world's series that .will w-ftck open the baseball world," were made here today by Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, and mentioned as coe of the "fixers'* of the last series. Attell claimed that he !s being "made the goat" of Arnold Roth stein, wealthy New Yortc gambler who has maintained that he refused to go in on the deal with the gamblers who told him that enough White Sox players coold be "fixed" to throw the series to the Cincinnati Reds.
See moreSee less
"Rothstein is whitewashing himself at my expense," he saM. "They are all against me, but I can fight back. If they want me to talk Fll talk and in tell a story that will crack open the baseball world. I'll tell 'em about the Astor deal. "That story that I offered $100,000 bo the White Sox is a lie." Rotbstein coold not be reached.
Clipping to come
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Eddie Cicotte secretly testified before the Cook County grand jury about the fixing of the 1919 World Series, leading to indictments against eight White Sox players. Comiskey immediately suspended seven of the indicted players (Chick Gandil, the eighth, was no longer on the roster), effectively ending the team's pennant hopes.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Abe Attell Threaten#. NEW YORK, Sept 29.—Threats to tell some things about the "inside BtorT-fOt the last world's series that .will w-ftck open the baseball world," were made here today by Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, and mentioned as coe of the "fixers'* of the last series. Attell claimed that he !s being "made the goat" of Arnold Roth stein, wealthy New Yortc gambler who has maintained that he refused to go in on the deal with the gamblers who told him that enough White Sox players coold be "fixed" to throw the series to the Cincinnati Reds.
See moreSee less
"Rothstein is whitewashing himself at my expense," he saM. "They are all against me, but I can fight back. If they want me to talk Fll talk and in tell a story that will crack open the baseball world. I'll tell 'em about the Astor deal. "That story that I offered $100,000 bo the White Sox is a lie." Rotbstein coold not be reached.
Clipping to come
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Following grand jury indictments, Comiskey sent suspension notices to the implicated White Sox players, stating they would be reinstated if innocent or banned for life if guilty. The grand jury investigation continued with league presidents Johnson and Heydler expected as witnesses, along with Mrs. Henrietta Kelly and Dr. Raymond Prettyman.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Efforts to "Fix" World Series. N 1 Chicago, 8ept. 29.-—Identity of alleged go-betweens and ganrr biers who bribed White Sox play •rs was' revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude ("Lefty") Williams, who joined CieoU* and Jackson in0 making vclean breast of .the 1919 world series frpme-up. .. -f py Associated ^ress. Chicago, ^ept. 29.—Further con .• fesaion* by some of the seven White 86* .• players ^irho, with one farmer player, were indicted yesterday in connection with the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series, will be ma^ within ft day or two, Alfred S.
See moreSee less
Aus triak attorney for the ball club.an n^unced today. 1 It has been rumored that at least two of the seven were anxious to 'v. supplement the confessions of Eddlo Cicotte and Joe Jacksoji with their statements,
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
A Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy related to the 1919 World Series. Named players include Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Gandil, with testimony from a mysterious witness preceding the vote.
Paper unidentified · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT WHITE SOX ARE INDICTED IN BASEBALL PROBE
ChaUfy Blatterr, $20,000. Fred McMullin, $10,000. 1 To Extend to Other Leagues^ vThe grand jury today sent a tele 's* gram. to EugenV-Dubuc, of the Toledo team, of the American Association, formerly jjhth the Tigers and Giants, asking him to appear here Monday. True bills naming three ball play 'era not members of the White Sox £j' and three gamblers are expected to be voted today by the grand Jury. Members of the jiiry -said this morn ing they had sufficient evidence on which to base tndltftmenta. \*t was reportea• that ti^xi bills against two National League placers ajw beln*~fconsidered,c
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
A Cook County grand jury indicted seven current and one former White Sox player for conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series, after Eddie Cicotte confessed to engineering the fix. All eight were immediately suspended by club owner Charles Comiskey, though the team will finish the season.
The Topeka State Journal · 28 September 1920 · page 1
WILL NOT STOP SCHEDULE
,'i, x) ?ill Burns* veteran pitdher, and Abe f1, "i-M «fttel, fomier Jri*e fighter, were fix ig it fo!| fjbe Sox players ^td- -get flakes Sworil Statement. pins' b^tore the grand jury made the following sworn statement to Alfred Austrian, attor %w fqr the White, Sox. W'Zl situatifir was first 'brought v'• !ft to me in New York. Mr. Gandil called me to one fide out in front of $3 Hotel 4-nsonja and asked me if jay tipdy ha& approfohed me about iN- 'the world series, and I says, 'Just Wltat do you mean?'
See moreSee less
He says, 'that 0XC series is to be fixed if they were fj&ed what would you do about it? Woqld you talce a» active part or wWatf I says, 'I am in no position t0"say5 right) now.' I says, 'I will give you mf answer later.' 3 "After coming to Chicago I wa? called down^ to the Warner hotel, #here the eight members ywho are named.—not eight, I will take that back—I will name them for you,— Eddie .Cicotte,^Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver and jiappy Pelsch, and two fellows introduced as Brown and Sullivan,supposed to be the gamblers or fellows that were fixing it for the gamblers, one of the two, ,they didn't say Which. They introduced them
Clipping to come
The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas
Eight Chicago White Sox players, including Eddie Cicotte who testified before the grand jury, were indicted for allegedly conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. Club owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended the accused players, threatening to ban them from baseball for life if found guilty.
The Topeka State Journal · 28 September 1920 · page 1
WILL NOT STOP SCHEDULE
Immediately indicted. he only received $10,000 and gave half of it to Jackson. until after his recovery. Gandil In Hospital, Refuses to Talk Further Confessions of Consplratiors Promised
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
A Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox for their roles in fixing the 1919 World Series, after pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified and told the jury what he knew. The indicted players included Cicotte, Jackson, Weaver, Felsch, Williams, Risberg, McMullin, and Gandil, with additional witnesses including John McGraw scheduled to testify later that day.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT CHICAGO PLAYERS INDICTED FOR ILLEGAL ACTS
Claim GÄng Trying Same Game This Year. New York—(By A. P.)—District Attorney Lewis, of Kings county, today announced that he will start immediately an investigation of the report, that ■a clique of gamblers plan to bribe members of the Brooklyn Nationals to lose sthe games to the American league opponents in the coming world's series. Cincinnati Grand Jury Starts Investigation Cincinnati—(By A. P.)—The Hamilton county grand jury was summoned to assemble Monday and will inquire into the circumstances of Cicotte's con fession that he found bribe money under his pillow in a Cincinnati hotel. Ruth Gets Fifty-Fourth Home Run Philadelphia—(By A. P.)—"Babe" Ruth scored his fifty-fourth home run
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
A grand jury announced it had voted indictments against several White Sox players, including Weaver, McMullin, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Gandil, for conspiracy related to the 1919 World Series. Cicotte testified before the jury just before the announcement, and the jury was set to reconvene to hear additional witnesses including John McGraw.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 28 September 1920 · page 1
(By United Press.) Chicago, Sept. 28Eight members of the White Sox Baseball club dur ing the 1919 world series with the Cincinnati Reds were indicted by the Cook county grand jury today. The indictments were voted for Eddie Cicotte, White Sox pitcher during the series, who appeared before the grand jury and told all he knew about the alleged crookedness throughout the series. The indictments were voted by the grand jury which investigate alleged crookedness th Amon indicted were Happy thos Felc cente Weaver,- third baseman Fred McMullen, util fielder Buc ity in-ti?lder Swede Risberg, short stop EdtMe Cicotte, pitcher Claude Williams, pitcher Joe Jackson, out fielder Chick Gandill, former first baseman.
See moreSee less
Announcement that the indictments had been voted was made by Foreman Brigham, of the grand jury. The indictments had not been drawn up at the time the announce ment was made but they had been voted and there may be several more counts" Cicotte was taken before the grand jury to tell what he knew. Immedi ately after he had given the jury the inforiMk&n which he possessed, an nouncement was made of the indlctCicott has been the central figure in the rumors which have existed for nearly a year regarding the crook edness of the 1919 world series. The-grand jury was to re-convene at 2:30 to hear the testimony of ten additional witnesses including John J. McGraw, manager of the "Giants, Dr Prettyman and iMr. Kel ly, both White Sox players Cicotte was accused of a conspiracy to do an illegal act.
A Chicago grand jury indicted eight members of the 1919 White Sox—Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Gandil—on conspiracy charges for allegedly throwing the World Series. Eddie Cicotte publicly denied taking part in the fix, though he admitted meeting Bill Burns before the series.
The Butte Daily Bulletin · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT CHICAGO WHITE SOX INDICTED
CICOTTE DENIES CHARGE. (Special United Press Wire.) Chicago, Sept. 28.-Eddie Cicotte, named in a published statement as the White Sox player who volun teered to throw the 1919 world's series to Cincinnati for $100,000, positively denied participation in the deal. Cicotte admitted he met "Bull" Burns in a New York hotel shortly before the world's series, .as Billy Mdharg claimed, but he denied hav ing a whispered conversation in a private room. He said the meeting was in the lobby with several other players present.'
The report recounts how Heine Zimmerman denied being a crook, claiming Zimmerman had once refused a $500 bribe offer, while also revealing that Buck Herzog was separately accused by Rube Benton of offering a bribe. It notes that McGraw suspended Zimmerman for the rest of the season, giving no reason beyond alleged training violations, a cover story that persisted until Zimmerman mysteriously vanished from the roster the following spring.
Omaha Daily Bee · 28 September 1920 · page 8
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
National League president John Heydler disclosed evidence from his own investigation into alleged gambling and game-throwing, saying Comiskey suspected the 1919 World Series was fixed after Game One. He also implicated pitcher Jean Dubuc and detailed testimony from Rube Benton about Hal Chase's betting.
Omaha Daily Bee · 28 September 1920 · page 8
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox for conspiracy following secret testimony from pitcher Eddie Cicotte about the fixed 1919 World Series. The jury planned to hear more witnesses, including Giants manager John McGraw, as investigators debated whether a low-level gambler rather than a major figure orchestrated the plot.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 28 September 1920 · page 1
INDICT EIGHT SOX PLAYERS GRAND JURY ACTION FOLLOWS TESTIMONY OF EDDIE CICOTTE PIKER BACK OF PLOT
I YIEST QCEEE PLAY. ( Chlcaffo, Sept tt (Hnltcd Tress.) The Brut queer1 plar ihe 1919 world series, thrown Sr some of the Chicago White Jex players to Cincinnati for J1MMHX), eaaie In the fourth In ag of the first game at t'ln Jaaatl whea the score was 1 lo L This was the play which ire rise to the saspleioa that ho game was fixed and which wased the fight between Ray Jehalk, catcher, and two of the )rooked players In the clnb ieBiie after the game. fiClaelnnatt was batting with 0 ont.
See moreSee less
Dinean singled and 'opf seat an easy grounder to JeVtte, rated as one of the best Jetdlag pitchers la basebalUI'ieotto started to throw to weead base, hesitated and then !aaily threw low to Rlsberg's' Mi, whea the ball should have toae on the Swede's right for a table play. Klsberg retired aaean but was oat of position, ae to the bad throw and could tot complete the double play, lopf was safe at first. fire raas followed aad CI. totte was replaced by Wilkint ' ! ' HONEST THIS YEAR.
Clipping to come
The Beatrice Daily Express · Beatrice, Neb.
The grand jury's indictments accused eight White Sox players of conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series, naming Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Gandil. The plot allegedly involved a go-between offering $100,000 from a gambling syndicate, though the actual backer was a lesser gambler who couldn't produce the full sum.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 28 September 1920 · page 1
PIKER BACK OF PLOT
Chicago, Sept 29. Indictments Jiast tit or six gamblers were nattered today by the Cook coun r grand Jury investigating the BrewiUK' of baseball raises, acJjjhl to Hartley Replogle, as nvmat state's attorney in charge of me inquiry. Abe Attel, former mUhtrwelght champion, and Ar oU Rothstein of New York, were SSld by Ranlotl ta hmvm heen inolred in testimony presented to e grand Jury. Attel, It was said. aaiM tne money, paid White Sox liajors mmn fnr ."tkrnvin." ho 19 world's aeries; also Indicted r Replogle, after the grand Jury as heard the testimony of Jreei tont Johnson and President Heydt oi ue American and National ltii, who are to testify today.
See moreSee less
Cootei of telegrams sent prior to earing the 1919 series by Hal Jtoe aad Bill Burns, former "te Players, hare been obtained tfleydlor for presentation to the tory. r Where the Cash Went
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
The Cook county grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players, including Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, and Buck Weaver, for conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series. Cicotte reportedly confessed to engineering the fix, with details matching an earlier account given by Billy Maharg in Philadelphia.
The Bismarck Tribune · 28 September 1920 · page 1
NO. 273 THIRTY-SECOND YEAR. SURE-THING THIEVES IN $100,000 BASE BALL PLOT TO BE BROUGHT TO BOOK Confessions of Cicotte and Jackson That White Sox-Cincinnati World Series Games of 1919 Were ‘Fixed* Leads to Determined Effort to Rid Game of Gambling Incubus and Puts Chicago Grand Jury on Trail of Gang That Put Up Huge Corruption Fund, Chicago, Sept. 29.—The Cook county grand jury, investigating crooked ness in baseball, hit the gamblers’ trail today. After indicting eight members of the White Sox team for alleged throw ing of the 1919 world series to the Cincinnati Reds, the investigators went into the gamblers’ part of the 1100,000 plot Officials announced they had sufficient evidence, apparently obtained from the "confessions” of Joe Jackson and Eddie Cicotte.
See moreSee less
White Sox stars, to obtain indictments of gamblers in New York, Chicago, Cincinnati, St. Louis, Detroit Des Moines and other cities. In addition the grand jury was prepared to take up alleged crooked playing in other games by Chicago teams. The Philadelphia-Chicago game in the National-League of August 31 especially was under scrutiny. Sheriff Peters announced the arrest of the men against whom indict ments were voted would not be made until the indictments were formally returned. The grand jury was expected to return the indictmnts to the court during the day. The greatest baseball machine in recent years.was piled by the way side as the result of the wreck caused by the indictments. Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the Sox, has built many pennant winning 66 QUEER” PLAY THAT
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
A Chicago grand jury indicted Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, Weaver, and McMullin for conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, and club owner Comiskey immediately suspended the indicted players. The same day, Cicotte—who had reportedly signed an immunity waiver and testified before the grand jury—publicly denied ever meeting gambler Billy Maharg, contradicting the confession story already circulating.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Bismarck Tribune · 28 September 1920 · page 1
CICOTTE CONFESSES
court during the day. side as the result of the wreck caused by the indictments. Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the Sox, has built many pennant winning 66
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
Eddie Cicotte denied ever meeting Billy Maharg or being involved in a $100,000 plot to throw the 1919 World Series, calling the fix talk a joke. Meanwhile a widow who housed White Sox players was questioned by the grand jury, and prosecutors hinted at a pending case.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Bismarck Tribune · 28 September 1920 · page 1
THIRTY-SECOND YEAR. Put Up Huge Corruption Fund, ness in baseball, hit the gamblers’ trail today. into the gamblers’ part of the 1100,000 plot Louis, Detroit Des Moines and other cities. court during the day. side as the result of the wreck caused by the indictments. Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the Sox, has built many pennant winning machines in his 25 years in baseball, but always pointed to the present ag gregation as the nearest perfection. The club has been virtually intact since winning the world's champion ship in 1918. Comiskey has insisted the team should' have won the 1919 series, claiming “it was the best ball club," and had every expectation of repeating victory this year.
See moreSee less
"Kid" Gleason, manager, today be gan taking the few good parts from the battered contraption to present a front for the remaining games. He stoutly insisted the Sox were still in the running for the American League pennant and capable of a fight for the world’s championship. Gleason’s pitching staff will be Faber, Kerr, Hodges and Wilkinson, with Schalk receiving. He intends shifting J. Collins to third, playing McClelland at short, E. Collins at second and Jourdan at first His out field would be Strunk, Murphy, Lei bold, Falk and Lynn as the only util it men. They open a tnree-game series in SU Louis Friday, with Cleveland one game ahead in the pennant chase. Plans for the world series will not be changed, according to Ban John son and John Heydler, constituting the National Commission in charge of organized baseball. ments for the world series had just been completed when the indictments were announced. The penalty under the conspiracy act, on which the indictments were voted, provides a fine up to $5,000 and imprisonment up to two years. One question which was still unde cided today was whether the White Sox players were "on the square” | during the hot contest this season. Gamblers and known to have wagered huge sums that the Cleveland Indians would win this year’s pennant in the American | League. Ban Johnson, president of the' league, admitted he had heard ru mors that the White Sox did not dare ' to win the pennant this year. gamblers who had bet on Cleveland had the White Sox in their power! through the crooked dealings a year ago, according to these rumors. The , gamblers are alleged to have threat ened the White Sox players with ex posure if they did not lose. Cicotte, the Sox’s star pitcher, failed miserably in the pinches this season., Manager Gleason forced him to do several hours extra practice a day, and then put him on the bench for a time. Rumors of the scandal caused con stant wrangling among the Sox them selves during the year, and the won der was that they were able to keep in the pennant race, even if they were playing on the square. Just before the recent "crucial" series with the New York Yankees, one of the White Sox players who was on the square was interviewed' by a United Press staff correspondent. "Who are you going to pitch tomor row?” the correspondent asked. “Cicotte,” was the answer, “and if he doesn’t win we will mob him on the field." Cicotte pitched and won the game. Further details of the confessions by Cicotte and Jackson became known today. Jackson said he decided to tell his story when he received a letter threatening to “bump him off” unless he confessed. “I heard that Ciootte had con fessed,” Jackson said, “and decided those birds couldn’t put anything over on me. I wanted to be on the ground floor when the squawking came.” “Shoeless Joe" said he Jost his nerve the first time he called up Judge McDonald. "I just told him I was on the square," Jackson said. "He said, 'You are not’ and hung Then I went over to his room up. and started to tell him any story, as I figured they had the goods on me. "I told him I got $5,000 of the $20, 000 promised me. It was handed me by Lefty Williams. Judge McDonald said he didn’t care what I got He said that if I had got what he thought I ought to have for crabbing game of kids, I wouldn’t be tel him my story?’ Jackson said he "climbed Risberg and McMullen” about the $15,000 which he claimed was still coming to him. “They told me. 'You poor simp, go ahead and squawk. We will say you are a liar, and then where do you get oft? " Jackson said the third game of the world series, which the Sox won, (Continued on Page Two.) NO. 273 66 to 1. the game. play. at first. The arrange bookmakers were The covered. the 1910 count. ten-year period. the tiling last decade.
Clipping to come
The Chickasha Daily Express · Chickasha, Indian Territory Okla.
The Cook county grand jury indicted eight members of the 1919 Chicago White Sox on conspiracy charges following an investigation into baseball crookedness. The same day, the National Baseball Commission announced revised World Series dates, starting October 5 in Brooklyn.
The Chickasha Daily Express · 28 September 1920 · page 1
CHANGE DATE OF
Know Gamblers' Xames. The First "Queer" May. Chicago. Sept. 29. The first "queer" play in the 1019 world series, thrown by some of the Chi cago White Sox players to Cincin nati for $100,000, came in the fourth inning of the first game at Cincinnati when the score was 1 to 1. This was the play which gave rise to the suspicion that the game was fixed and which caused the fisht between Ray Schalk. catcher, and two of the crooked players in the cluh house after the game. Cincinnati was batting with one out.
See moreSee less
Duncan singled and Kopf s; nt an eaav grounder to Cicotte. rated as one of the best fielding pitchers in baseball. Cicotte started to throw to sec ond base, hesitated, and then final ly threw low to P.isberg's left when the ball should have pone on the Swedes risht for a double play, ltisberg retired Duncan but was out of position due to the bad throw and could not complete the double plav. Kopf was safe at first. Five runs followed and Cicotte wns replaced by Wilkinson.
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players on conspiracy charges after investigating alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series. Eddie Cicotte testified before the jury, and all eight players were immediately suspended by team management.
East Oregonian : E.O · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Chicago, Sept. 29. The first Indict ments against gamblers alleged to have been connected with the con spiracy to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati were returned ' by the Cook county grand jury today. Sport" Sullivan of Boston and a man by the name of Brown, named as the "fixers" by Claude Williams, the third of the indicted players to con fess, were charged with a conspiracy to do an illegal act. Three gamblers will be indicted to day on charges of conspiracy in con nection with the "fixed" 1919 world series by the Cook county grand jury which yesterday indictei".
See moreSee less
eight mem bers of the White Sox baseball club. This information was made pumii: before the grand jury jlirv went into sessinn bv Assistant ' State's Attorney Hartley Replogle. in charge of the in vestigation into the baseball scandal. None of the gamblers are in Chi cago, Replogle said. He refused to di-v.ik-c their names. Replogle also stated three otner nastuau i with the j none of whom are connected White Sox club would als De in dicted. I No umpires -are under investigation, he sai-1;.
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
The Cook County grand jury returned indictments against Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Risberg, Jackson, McMullin, Weaver and Felsch for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. The report also claims a separate 1915 series-fixing plot and alleges gamblers were blackmailing the Sox to throw the 1920 pennant to Cleveland, while Cicotte publicly denied the charges.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
East Oregonian : E.O · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Alfred Austrian, representing Charles I'omiskev, announced. He said these men probably would be permitted to go before the grand jury next week and tell what they knew. Their stories are substantially the same as those t'vbl by Cicotte and Jackson, Austrian tJThe grand jury will also hear Jean Di'l.uc next week in connection with its investic-ition of alleged gambling Dubuc is now in the National league. ji o.uher for the Toledo American astociation team. He was formerly with the New lorn Nationals. rn-iin in a statement toaa, sam the White Sox players had no dealings with the gamblers this year, as far as he knew.
See moreSee less
Jackson pave tno sri.." al-l 4..-,. nf fnmn nrs wno miJ" . . . jtt . . i tct .rid l. sed to .i to nave ii.xeu ie .av series. -' Cicotte did not know the names oi i rimblers. saving all his dealings were der -ith other Olivers, who. he un i in touch with the gam bl.Ts." Ciro'te left for his farm in Michigan today. ' Consratuiate Sox Owner.
Clipping to come
Capital Journal · Salem, Or.
The Cook County grand jury returned true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Weaver. Team owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended all indicted players, effectively ending Chicago's pennant hopes.
Capital Journal · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Snoopologist is well illustrated by this incident. ness. he is. gladly tell him so. good-bye. That the attempt made the other evening to run down the banner carrier employed by the Musicians' according to onlookers.
Clipping to come
The Madison Daily Leader · Madison, S.D.
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series against Cincinnati. The indictments came after pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified secretly before the grand jury, confessing what he knew of the fix.
The Madison Daily Leader · 28 September 1920 · page 4
Series Games. - (ContinwU "rm rf Oo.) i i - single over second bsseV that sent ! Rath to. third and he sc6rcd when j Croh died to Jackson, Rath beating Jackson'sjthrow to the plate. !' : Chicago tied thia tun in the next ' Inning, Kopf putting Jackson on ' second with a wild throw. Felsch sacrificed him to third and Gandi i; dropped a little fly aifely in center, 1 vr scoring Jackson. . The end of Ciipotte's pitching and , '--the runs that ultimately won the ; .--game, were scored by Cincinnati in the fourth inning.
See moreSee less
All the damage was done with two out. With Kopf f 'on first, Neale" and Wingo singled and Keuther. the hard-hitting Cm cinnati pitcher, drove a three-base hit to the center field bleachers. .'Rath doubled and Paubert singled) i?'the combination resulting in five H'runs. Wilkinson took Cicotte's U;'jplace after Daubert's single , and K sVrpb flied.to felsch. The final B ,;sore of thia game was 9 to I.
Clipping to come
The Chattanooga News · Chattanooga, Tenn.
A Cook County grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players—Gandil, McMullin, Felsch, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Weaver—on conspiracy charges for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series. Cicotte reportedly confessed before the grand jury and signed an immunity waiver, corroborating boxer Billy Maharg's accusations.
The Chattanooga News · 28 September 1920 · page 9
Before Grand Jury. Chicago, Sept. 28. Indictments gainst tight member of the Chi cago Whlta Sox for alleged crooked' ntaa In tha 1919 world'a aarlaa were voted by the Cook county grand Jury, which haa been probing con dltlona In organized baseball, thla afternoon. Tha men indicted r! Chick Qandlt, former flrat bane man; Fred McMuiim, utility In. flelderj Happy Felach, eenterflelder; "Swede" Rlaberg, ehortetop; Eddie Cicotte, pitcher; Claude Williams, pitcher; Joe Jackson, left fielder, and Buck Weaver, third baaaman. TIib true bills charge conspiracy to commit am Illegal art. Eddie Cicotte, atar pitcher, was one of the flrat witnesses before the grand Jury today and hie testimony ii be lieved to have been one of the factors that Induced the grand Jury to return tin.
See moreSee less
Indictments. Ho la said to have made a complete confession and to have signed an immunity waiver. Charge Verified.
A grand jury returned indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players, including Jackson, Weaver, and Cicotte, for conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series. Cicotte reportedly gave a full confession under an immunity waiver, prompting owner Comiskey to immediately suspend all eight players from the team.
The Chattanooga News · 28 September 1920 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
CHICAGO STARS ARE INDICTED
Cicotte, Gandil, Jackson, Risberg, Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, Williams Named.
See moreSee less
CONSPIRACY IS CHARGED
Cicotte Reported to Have Made Complete Confession Before Grand Jury.
Chicago, Sept. 28.—Indictments against eight members of the Chicago White Sox for alleged crookedness in the 1919 world's series were voted by the Cook county grand jury, which has been probing conditions in organized baseball, this afternoon. The men indicted are:
Chick Gandil, former first baseman; Fred McMullin, utility infielder; Happy Felsch, centerfielder; "Swede" Risberg, shortstop; Eddie Cicotte, pitcher; Claude Williams, pitcher; Joe Jackson, left fielder, and Buck Weaver, third baseman.
The true bills charge conspiracy to commit an illegal act.
Eddie Cicotte, star pitcher, was one of the first witnesses before the grand jury today and his testimony is believed to have been one of the factors that induced the grand jury to return the indictments. He is said to have made a complete confession and to have signed an immunity waiver.
Charge Verified.
His admissions are declared to have verified with the statement of Billy Marhag, Philadelphia pugilist, who accused Cicotte of having been the principal in the promotion of the "fixed" series.
The men indicted are the eight men said to have been implicated in the $100,000 bribe to throw the series and whose bonus checks were held up by the White Sox management while an investigation was made after the series closed last fall.
All Eight Suspended.
Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, announced immediately after he heard of the voting of the indictments by the grand jury that all eight of the players would stand suspended from the White Sox. This is virtually the elimination of the White Sox from the pennant race as none of the eight men, several of whom are bulwarks of the club, will be permitted to play in any of the remaining games of the season.
The action of Comiskey in suspending those indicted leaves Eddie Collins, Ray Schalk, John Collins and Amos Strunk as the only regular fielders in good standing and Dick Kerr and Red Faber as the only regular pitchers.
Comiskey issued the following statement addressed to each of the indicted players:
"You and each of you are hereby notified of your indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League Baseball club. If you can prove your innocence you will be returned to the team in good standing. If you are found guilty you are out of organized baseball for the rest of your lives."
Eddie Cicotte was immediately taken in custody by an officer and taken to the criminal court building.
The Cook County grand jury returned true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players—Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, Weaver, and McMullin—for conspiracy to violate a state law over the alleged throwing of the 1919 World Series. The report includes Cicotte's denial of involvement and notes testimony from former boxer Bill Maharg and widow Henrietta Kelley, at whose home players had roomed.
Paper unidentified · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT WHITE SOX INDICTED IN INQUIRY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.
A Cook County grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players, including Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, and Buck Weaver, on charges of conspiracy to commit an illegal act related to throwing the 1919 World Series. Club president Charles Comiskey immediately suspended all the accused players, despite the team being only half a game behind the league-leading Cleveland Indians.
El Paso Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 1
SERIES FIXED GRAND JURY SAYS; ARREST CICOTTE
31.939 . . . I 41.MT mo... A minus sirs (-) denotes decrease. important the American league peasant this year. land Indians today. possible. The suspended players are Eddie Cteotte. Claude WUBams. TJalcfc" Oandu, "HappyFalse. Charles Kle berg. Joe Jacksoa. Dred McMuIlln aad "Buck" Weaver. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state taw. Gandll. while still the niuautj of the Chicago dub, baa not bean with the team this year. It waa understood that he oould not reach an agreement with them over salary. Voting of the Indictments waa of ficially announced by H. H. Brigham. foreman of the grand Jury. foUowlng a conference with chief Justice Mc Donald ant Alfred s. Austrian, attor ney for the White Sox team. More Indletmenta Coming.
A Chicago grand jury returns indictments against eight suspended White Sox players for conspiracy, after Eddie Cicotte reportedly signed an immunity waiver and testified before leaving by a rear door. He was then taken into custody by a state's attorney's detective, and team attorney Alfred Austrian telegraphed suspension notices to the implicated players.
El Paso Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 1
ARREST CICOTTE
ney for the White Sox team. More Indletmenta Coming. While the Indictments at present contain but one count, conspiracy to do an Illegal act," assistant state's attorney Hartley Replogle, in charge of the grand jury investigation, an nounced that more probably would be added after the grand Jury session this afternoon. Just before the indictments were announced a witness waa ushered out a disused rear door of the grand Jury room. He was reported to be Eddie Cteotte. the White Sox star pitcher. Cicotte. who was named in the atory of the alleged gamblers' plot, told at Philadelphia last night by Billy Maharg.
See moreSee less
former prise fighter, is said to have signed an immunity waiver and than to have gone before the grand Jury aad testified. The sudden voting of the true bills fol lowed. Assistant state s attorney Jtaplogla ! announced that Cicotte waa taken ' in custody after leaving 'he grand Jury room aad now is in charge of : William Sullivan, a detective of the i state's attorney's office. He declined ' to say where the pitcher was being t taken. I Letter ef Suspension.
The Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix voted indictments, with Cicotte reportedly breaking down in tears and expressing regret. Comiskey announced he suspended the implicated players and would finish the season using replacement players, pledging reinstatement if they're innocent and lifetime banishment if guilty.
El Paso Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The grand jury continued its session, calling National League president Heydler and manager John McGraw to testify. Heydler called the scandal the most deplorable event in baseball history, while Comiskey was reportedly too distraught to comment after suspending seven players.
El Paso Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 8
EIGHT WHITE SOX MEN INDICTED BY GRAND JURY
1T MO.NIN. JOUHNAL .MCIM. LIUI1 WIHt Chicago, Sept. 28 by the Asso ciated Presa.) Indictments were voted against eight baseball stars today and confessions obtained from two of thera, when the Old Roman, Charles A. Comlskey, owner of the oft-time champion Chicago White Sox, smashed his pennant chasing machine to clean up baseball. The confessions told how the Sox threw last year's world's championship to Cincinnati for money paid by gamblers. Seven Sox regulars and on former player had true bills voted against them by the Cook county grand Jury and the seven were im mediately suspended by Mr.
See moreSee less
Comls key. With his team only half a game behind the league leading Cleveland Indians, the White Sox owner served notice on his seven stars that If they were found guilty, he would drive them out of organ ized baseball for the rest of their lives. Jackson "Tapped the Hall" Officials of Chief Justice Charles McDonald's court, desirous of giv ing the national game the benefit of publicity in its purging, lifted the curtain on the grand Jury proceed ings sufficiently to show a great hitter, Joe Jackson declaring that he deliberately Just tapped the ball, a picture of one of the world's most famous pitchers, Cicotte, in team, and glimpses of alleged bribe of $5,000 or $10,000 discovered un der pillows, or in beds by famous athletes about to retire. Around the court room at one time or another were somo of base ball's greatest leaders, among them John J. McOraw, manager of the New York Giants, awaiting a call to testify tomorrow; and John Heydler, president of the National league, who went before the grand umrs this cfternoon. . The exact nature of the Informa tion Mr. Comiskey put before the grand Jury was not disclosed. The r.ien whom the Jury involved as a jvsult of testimony uncovered by their owner were: . Tho Men Indicted. Eddie Cicotte, star pitcher, who waived Immunity and confessed, , according to court attaches, that he took a $10,000 bribe. Arnold "Chick" Candll, former first batcmsn. . "Shoeless Joe" Jackson, heavy . hitting iett fielder. Oscar "Happy" Felsch, center fielder. Charles "Swede" Rlsberg, short stop. Claude Williams, pitcher. George "Buck" 'Weaver, third : baseman. . Fred . McMulHn. utility player.. While the grand Jurors voted " their true bills the Old Roman, i neated In the midst of his crumbling empire out at White Sox park, Is sued the telegram suspending those involved, paid off Weaver, Cicotte and Jackson on the spot and an nounced that checks for pay due the others would be sent them at once. With his voice trembling Mr. Comlskey, who has owned the White Sox since the Inception of the American league, said this was the first time scandal had ever touched his "family" and that it distressed him too much to talk about It. Cicotte Weeps For Children. The rush of players to bare their part in the affair started today when Ciontte appeared at criminal cpurt building and asked permis sion to testify. ' Cittrtte wept, coutt attaches wtiif, and exclaimed in anguish his sorrow, for his two small children as he' told how he
Clipping to come
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah
A Cook County grand jury returned true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players, including Cicotte, Jackson, Weaver, and Risberg, charging them with conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series. Club owner Comiskey had already suspended the accused players, costing the team a shot at the pennant despite being only half a game behind Cleveland.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Chicago Loses Chance To Win League Pennant; Risberg Among Accused
stop. Claude Williams, pitcher. George "Buck" 'Weaver, third : baseman. . Fred . McMulHn. utility player.. While the grand Jurors voted " their true bills the Old Roman, i neated In the midst of his crumbling empire out at White Sox park, Is sued the telegram suspending those involved, paid off Weaver, Cicotte and Jackson on the spot and an nounced that checks for pay due the others would be sent them at once. With his voice trembling Mr. Comlskey, who has owned the White Sox since the Inception of the American league, said this was the first time scandal had ever touched his "family" and that it distressed him too much to talk about It.
Clipping to come
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah
The Cook County grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Weaver, on charges of conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series. Cicotte reportedly confessed before the jury and was taken into custody, while Comiskey suspended all indicted players.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 28 September 1920 · page 1
LIST OF INDICTED.
stop. Claude Williams, pitcher. George "Buck" 'Weaver, third : baseman. . Fred . McMulHn. utility player.. While the grand Jurors voted " their true bills the Old Roman, i neated In the midst of his crumbling empire out at White Sox park, Is sued the telegram suspending those involved, paid off Weaver, Cicotte and Jackson on the spot and an nounced that checks for pay due the others would be sent them at once. With his voice trembling Mr. Comlskey, who has owned the White Sox since the Inception of the American league, said this was the first time scandal had ever touched his "family" and that it distressed him too much to talk about It.
Clipping to come
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah
Eddie Cicotte broke down before the grand jury and confessed to engineering the plot to throw the 1919 World Series, leading to indictments. Comiskey immediately suspended seven indicted players, while prosecutors took Cicotte into custody and rumors circulated that other players had also confessed.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 28 September 1920 · page 1
CROOK PLAYERS FIND MONEY IN BED AFTER GAME
Drive Promises to The first three hours of the drive yes terday for the civic fund of $7,500 re sulted in rounding up over one-fifth of collected. the amount aimed for by the committee that framed the program of progres siveness. The total cash value of the few hours' work was $1,576.26. and the business section was not touched by the different teams who started on the campaign. The largest individual subscription was taken by Mrs. M. E. Rinkle, who took two units, while practically every one who was found during the short time the committees were out took up one unit.
See moreSee less
This is as the program plan proposed. The individuals are Carson. subscribing what they can stand, and from appearances this sort of subscrip tion will today carry the quota to a point where the business interests can carry the rest of the quota over the top without any serious straining of resources. The teams started out again this af ternoon and a report will be made at headquarters this evening. Many are other line of work.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
Suspended White Sox outfielder Joe Jackson appeared before the Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix, conferring first with Judge McDonald before testifying. Jackson reportedly said he was paid $5,000 by pitcher Claude Williams, naming Risberg and McMullin as the main payoff men.
The Seattle Star · 28 September 1920 · page 1
SUSPENDED FROM GAME J. JACKSON CALLED BY GRAND JURY
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
Chicago pitcher Eddie Cicotte's confession to the Cook County grand jury is revealed, detailing payments to himself and Joe Jackson from gamblers in exchange for throwing the 1919 World Series. He describes money hidden under pillows at the hotel and expresses deep shame over the scandal.
The Seattle Star · 28 September 1920 · page 1
VERY LATEST CHICAGO PITCHER CONFESSES ACCEPTING CROOKED MONEY
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
The Cook County grand jury voted indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players on charges of conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, naming Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, Weaver, Felsch, and Gandil among others. Comiskey immediately suspended the accused players, stating they would be reinstated only if proven innocent.
The Seattle Star · 28 September 1920 · page 1
SENSATION IS SPRUNG BY PROBERS
iflte them out of organized baseball for S rest ot tl,dr ,IvcsPlayers Suspicious Cbirges that Home of the same playfwbo arc accused ot "tnrowing" me Grid's series to Cincinnati last year kite uxed their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennnnt win ners this oefti'on, werq made today by .(Ttral members of tho White Hox who lire not becu mentioned In the grand fat " "J. .... ,..... .. OnO piajcr inuuu wiu raiunuis Biuiu- "When we started on our last cast rn trip we bad every reason to believe v would win the penuant.
See moreSee less
Suddenly Williams and Clcotte seemed to go bad without any reason. Home of uh talked it over nnd agreed It looked like they were grooving the boll. "Then Jackson, FelBoh nnd Rlsbcrg bn dumping the ball to the Infield Tery time they came to bat when wo bad a chnucc to get runs. "We thought at first they might Just be In a batting slump, but when some of us compared notes regarding the pitching nnd hitting we became more than suspicious. , "It may as well bo suited that some of us believe ever since the last world's itrits that we were B61d by Cicotte and ethers. "Well, wncn mc sumo men we sus pected of crossing us at that time began m rs bad on the lost eastern trln we decided there must have been another 1-out. "Had we nlaycd anvthlne like our rmlsr came we would have como' homo with the pennant cinched. We all hope the grand Jury looks into this end of the affair. If it falls to net we may tike come action ourselves if we can cet hold of the players wo feel sure did the cheating." John Collins, veteran llrnt basemnn f the White Hox. said : "Wo are sorry ;n a wy for the fellows who ore caught n this lam. but we arc Rind everything b going to be shown up. "We suspected some or tnem in the orld's series and we suspected them gain because of the way they played in the last eastern trip. Some of them ot only didn't try, but really ncted ! though they didn't want to win. I ire no idea what influenced their acKiosi." "fled Fnber. veteran pitcher, who tried Ms club to victory in tho 1017 world's series, said the playing of the jox on the eastern trip made ROino of :he others believe something was oolrd. "It looks like we were double- :ro!ied In the world's series lost, and a the pennant raen this year, but wo re not tnrougn yet. We are going to it. loiiis with a ball team on which my man will be tnine nnd we will tfit to get into the world's scries. If e land we will be suro of one thing e will not hare a Judas on tho team hen wo go into the big scries."
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
A Cook county grand jury indicted eight members of the 1919 White Sox—including Felsch, Weaver, Cicotte, Jackson, and Gandil—on conspiracy charges related to the World Series scandal. The indictments followed testimony from a secret witness and came after Judge McDonald ordered the jury to investigate crookedness in baseball.
The Milwaukee Leader · 28 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT SOX MEN INDICTED IN BALL PLOT
Clcotte Needed Money "Hlsbere. Gundil nnd McMulIln wero tme for n Week before the scrim utnrr. mi,' Eddie Clcotte told the grand Jury n his confession. "They wuntcd me to o crooked. I needed the money. I d the wife nnd kids. They don't bow this nnd I don't know uhnt .hey'll think. I hnd bought a farm. rkete was n S4000 mnrttrnire. I nndl hit off with crooked money. . ine eight of us tho eight under In letment sot together in niv rnnm irte or four days before the scries tilted.
See moreSee less
Gandll was mnstcr of the eremonles. Wc talked about throwing terles and decided we could get it with It. Wo agreed to do it. I was thlnklnir of the wife and kids how I needed tho monev. I told em I had to have tho cash in ndvniice. did not want any checks. I didn't mt any promises, I wanted the money i bills before I nlterud n ball. We all talked nnlte n wlilln nhnnt it. Yes. all nf IIS riwiilcri In tin nur hokt o throw the games to Cincinnati. Then "nan ann .tic-Muiim tooK us nil. one T one, away fiom tho nthets and we u turKey. They asked mo ray price. ioia inem .tu.uuu, paid in advance. ' Jt was (iandll I wbb talking to. He anted to eivo me somo money ot the Ime and the rest after the games were jvm oaii loai, " "Caih in hdvanee, not O. 0. D.'. feminded him. 'If you cannot trust ft I CSn't trimf vrm Tnv nr T nlnr 'ill.' Well. th flrcument wnt on for "at dhjrs. but 1 etood pat. I wanted $10,000 and I got It." 'How I wish that I hnd not! The 3 oefore I went to Cincinnati I put It D tO t)rfi ftmiflrnlv fnf tht Inftt ttmn would bo nothing unless I had money. 'That nlettt I found tho monev unw my pillow. I had sold out 'Cumey and the other boys to pay off a OrtnCfl On n fnnn onrl fiv ihn vft ud kids. "The firaf ho11 T :v,,i T ,,1 'Mt the wife and klddtos would sov they ever found out I was a crook. ,. I Pitched the best ball I know how Her that first boll. Unt I lost because I fas hit, not because I was throwing game. JacItSOTt's Confenslon I Joe Jackson described Ida confession wo grand Jury as follows: I heanl T lm v.n .ii..i t cided these men could not put anyel) m n tno' called up Judge Efi . . -i!i iiubucb v.uuries a, cDontdd. of the Superior Court, who u 1.1 the grand Jury Inquiry) and ; uiio a was an honest man. lie
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
The report describes grand jury indictments stemming from testimony by a mysterious secret witness, with Comiskey's attorney conferring with the prosecutor beforehand. It also recounts investigations into the 1919 World Series fix and alleged gambler plans to fix the upcoming Brooklyn-Cleveland series, plus biographical background on White Sox player Happy Felsch.
The Milwaukee Leader · 28 September 1920 · page 1
ERS SAY. Sept. 2t—Three Ramblers will be indict ud today on charges of conspiracy in connection with the fix od 1919 world series by the Cook •county fcrand iury. which yesterday inukted ei^h't mor.ibcr» of the White So* ball club. Assistant States At torney Replogle refused to disclose the names, but said none are now in Chicago. He declared three other ball players, none of whom are con nected with the White Sox, will also be indicted. No umpires are sus pected, he said. John Heydler, pre sident of the national league, said he would present evidence to the grand jury that an entirely different clique of gamblers has operated in the na tional league.
See moreSee less
Heydler said the na tional league gamblers did not pay any fixed sums to players, but gave crooked players one-third of their winnings for throwing the games. Joe Jackson, one of the White Sox players, who confessed, told the United Press today, that the White Sox played honest baseball all this year. "We did everything we could to win the pennant," Jackson said. "As far as I know none of the play ers had anything to do with gamblers this year." Jean Debuc, former pitcher for the New York Nationals, now with the Toledo American as sociation club, was ordered to appear before the grand jury October 4. De buc may know something of gambl ing in the National league. The states attorney said, Eddie Cicotte, first of the WThite Sox players to make a clean breast of the conspir acy to throw the last world series to Cincinnati, hurriedly left Chicago to day. Presumably for his Michigan fur iu. York, 8ept. 29.—District At torney "Harry E. Lewfs, announced •that he will begin an immediate in vestigation of reports that gambling clique planned an attempt to bribe Brooklyn National league players to lose this years world series.
A Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, naming Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, McMullin, and Weaver. Comiskey immediately suspended all team members named, including those still playing, dealing a blow to the team's pennant hopes.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 28 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
COMISKEY SUSPENDS BALL PLAYERS INDICTED BY COOK COUNTY GRAND JURY CHICAGO, Sept. 28.—Charles Comiskey, president of the White Sox today suspended every member of the team indicted today in connection with the alleged fixing of baseball games. Seven of the eight are indicted. Chick Gandill, the eighth is not playing this year. The suspension practically kills all hope of the White Sox winning the American League pennant this year. (By Associated Press.) CHICAGO, Sept. 28.—The Cook County grand jury this afternoon voted true bills against the following baseball players in connection with the investigation of alleged "throwing world series games last year: Eddie Cicotte, Cicotte.
See moreSee less
Claude William, Chick Gandill, Happy Felsch, Charles Reisberg, Joe Jackson. Fred McMillan and Buck Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state law. Assistant State's Attorney Replogle announced that Cicotte was taken into custody after leaving the grand jury room and is now in charge of William Sullivan, a detective of the state's attorney office. He declined to say where the pitcher was being taken. torney
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
The Associated Press reports that eight former White Sox players—Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, McMullin and Weaver—were indicted for conspiracy in the 1919 World Series, and Comiskey immediately wired suspensions to seven of them still active on the roster. The report also notes Cicotte reportedly broke down in the jury room and that rumors swirled of other players confessing.
The Laramie Republican · 28 September 1920 · page 1
HE SUSPENDED 7 OF PLAYERS OWNER COMISKEY OF CHICAGO WHITE SOX WIRES MEN FOLLOWING INDICTMENT
dictment. Chicago, Sept. 19 Charges that seme ef the same players who are accused of "throwing" the world's series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent--the Whit Sex from becoming pennsnt winners this season, were made to day by several members of the Chi cago Whit Sox, who have not been mentioned In the grand Jury testimony. One player, who refused to allow hla name to be used, made the following statement: "V "When we started on our last east ern trip we hod every reason to believe we would win the pennant.
See moreSee less
Suddenly Williams and Clcotte seemed to go bad without any reason. Some of us talked it over and agreed it looked like they were grooving the ball. , "Then Jackson. Kelson unit lllsneri? Kan dumping the ball to the infield very time tney came to Dat wnen we d a chance to get runs. 'We thought at first It might be Just batting slump. But when some of s compared notes regarding the pltchng and hitting we Decame more man uspiclotiB. I "It may as well be stated that some If us believe ever since the last orld s series thut wc were sola out Clcotte and others. Well, when the same men we suscted of, crossing us at that time ben to go Dart ontne last eastern irip o decided there Tnmt nave oetn anher sell out. However, wo have never en able to prove this. Had we played anytmng like our gular game we would have come me with the pennant otnenea. we an pe the grand Jury will look into this A of the affair. If It falls to act we y tr'te some action ourselves u we n eet hold of tne pioyers we ieei re did the cheating." Collins Talks. nhn Collins, veteran first baseman the White Sox said: We are sorry in a way tor tne leii who are caught in tnis jam. oui are glad everything is going to be we suspectea some or tne.m m uic rorld's series and we suspected them oain beuu ill 'u Win nag " tly Tlayed if mi' n n id. iiiuuuiM- ...... "Red" Kaber, veteran pucner, wno mpn n col lu iniuij m viitj . , i . .. . i ii.. .nn.Aikln. nine i"ni. 'i. "It looks like we were douoie crossea the world's series last year and in - . .. ikl. .,nar Kut ora am we Win spo io ni. xjuuib who .1 a wm. . 1 1 Ka tm. ng and we win ngnt to get imu uic May Indict Gambler. Indictments against five or lx gamDMni were conniuereu XAir county orami jury uiYTniiii'ii mi-owing oi unofuau a,. .,, ......... - - a io nariiwy jroioai,;, . isiant wiaie s aituiimj, m e . .1 A pn.lll Wilt I I " I IKIU I. O 1 1 U' ,.- " . . ... . an H ktl I ' .
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 29 September 1920
Paper unidentified
A Chicago grand jury indicted eight White Sox players—Felsch, Weaver, McMullen, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson and Gandil—on conspiracy charges related to fixing the 1919 World Series. Pitcher Cicotte reportedly broke down and gave testimony that led to the indictments, while rumors swirled of further confessions and a new scheme to fix the 1920 series.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 28 September 1920 · page 1
Grand Jury Returns Findings Today in Investigation of Baseball Scandal; Cicotte Gives Evidence, Claim
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · and 1 other paper
A Chicago grand jury indicted seven current White Sox players plus one former player for conspiracy related to the 1919 World Series, and owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended all of them. Pitcher Eddie Cicotte reportedly broke down in the jury room, saying he wished he hadn't been involved.
The Laramie Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
. .1 A pn.lll Wilt I I " I IKIU I. O 1 1 U' ,.- " . . ... . an H ktl I ' . . . . t u.,.., In ten I- ...n.... n.iL.nnlnrl IA in, f r II III! I II 1 V . A I - talt. It was said, handled the money paid White Sox players for "throwing' the 1919 world's series. More ball players may be Indicted it was alio tin riited oy iwp,oK, the grand Jury has heard the testimony of Presidents JohnBon and Heydler, of the American and National leagues, who ar to tetify today.
See moreSee less
Copies of telegrams ent prior to and during the 1919 aeries by Hal Chase and Bill Hums, former major league players, have been obtained by Heydler for presentation to the grand Jury. the John J. McQraw, manager of the (Hants, also has been asked by tell grand Jury to appear today to I.ee i . u: l.au of Hal Chase. 1 1 " ' II I. Ill I I . Il-V - - Mage and Heine Zimmerman by the Giant last year. Statements oy sev eral baU player in connection with tne 1919 series hav Involved Chase In the ileal by which gamblers are said to have paid eight White Sox players to lav down" to the Cincinnati Reds. According to Eddie Clcotte s eonres slon before the grand Jury. HO.Oftfl was paid to the White Sox Players, dlvl led
Clipping to come
Also printed in 1 paper
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo. · 28 September 1920
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
A Cook County grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati, with two players reportedly confessing to taking gambler bribes. Owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended seven active players, while Yankees owners offered their own team to help Chicago finish the pennant race.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 29 September 1920 · page 1
COMISKEY SUSPENDS SEVEN OF HIS STARS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
The Cook County grand jury voted true bills against seven White Sox players, who were immediately suspended by owner Charles Comiskey despite the team trailing Cleveland by only half a game. Court officials revealed details including Cicotte's tearful confession of taking a $10,000 bribe and Joe Jackson's admission to deliberately mishitting the ball.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 29 September 1920 · page 1
SEVEN OF HIS STARS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · Pine Bluff, Ark.
The report describes court officials' account of Cicotte's grand jury statement, detailing how he deliberately gave up runs in the first and fourth World Series games. It includes play-by-play of Cincinnati scoring, including Cicotte's wild throw and a muffed relay that let in a run in game four.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 29 September 1920 · page 6
NEW tORK TEAM frS OFFERED TO THE MANAGER OF SOX ^^^Continued From Page One show that in the first inning of the ^first game he started by hitting Rath', the first Cincinnati batter, in the back. Daubert followed with a single , over second base that sent Rath to third and he scored when Groh flied to Jackson, Rath beating Jackson’s throw to the plat. Chicago tied this run in the next inning, Kopf putting Jackson to sec ond with a wild throw. Felsch sac Jackson. the runs that ultimately won the game were scored by Cincinnati in the fourth inning.
See moreSee less
All damage was done with two out, with Kopf on first, Neale and Wingo singled and Reu ther, the hard hitting Cincinnati pitcher, drove a three base hit to the j centef field bleachers. Rath doubled, arid Daubert singled, the combination! resulting in five runs. Wilkinson! took Cicotte’s place after Daubert singled and Groh flied to Felsch. The final score of this game was 0 to L Fourth Thrown Away. The fourth game, played at Chi ! cago, was also deliberately thrown away, according to court officials who heard Cicotte’s statement to. the grand jury. The Reds won this game ! by a score of 2 to 0, Ring, pitching for Cincinnai, holding $he American league champions to three hits. Both Cincinnati runs were made in the fifth inning, when two of Cincinn ati’s hits were bunched with a wild throw to first by Cicotte and a bad throw to the plate by Jackson, which the pitcher intercepted and muffed. The play at this inning was sent ov er the Associated'Press wires as fol lows: "Roush was out, Schalk to Gandill, the ball rolling half way to the pit cher’s box. 'Duncan was safe when Cicotte threw his drive wide to first, the ball going to the stand and Duncan reaching second. Kopf sing led to left and Duncan stpped at . third but scored when Jackson threw wild to the plate. Kopf reached sec ond. Correction: The official scor er gives Cicottte the error for muf fing Jackson’s throw. Neale sent one over Jackson’s head and Kopf scor ed. Neale reached second. It was a two base hit. Wingo out, Ed Col lins to Gandill, Neale going to third. Ed Collins got and threw him out at first. Two runs, two hits and two errors." The rest of the game was played sharpley, and, so far as the records show, cleanly, Cicotte pitched through the nine innings. Cicotte’s next appearance in the series was in' the sixth game, when Cincinnati'had four victories against one defeat. Richard Kerr, the diinin utive left handed pitcher, having shutj out the national league cham pions in the third game. The vet erai twirler who today confessed the big gambling deal went through nine innings and held his opponents to sev«m hits. Chicago won the game 4 ti 1, hitting Sallee hard in the first five innings. Jackson and Felsch each getting two hits and between them drove in all" of Chi cago’s runs. Sox Double Crossed. ifclly Maharg, Philadelphia prize fighter, who last night, in Philadel phia, issued a statement connecting Cicotte with the gambling deal and changing that Abe Attell, former fighter, headed the gambling cique, assorted that the Sox were double croised by Attell and never received flOfl.OOO which had been promised thetn. It was late in the series be fore they found this out, Maharg as serted as Attell kbpt postponing the day! of settlement, saying he needed the money to bet. ■" * Besides the two defeats registered against Cicotte in the series three others were chalked up against Claude Williams. The latter, a “side arm” left hander, was wild in the second and fifth games, which went to the Reds 4 to 2 and 5 to 0. In the eight and last game of the se ries, he was found for four solid hits in the first inning and that game and the title of world champions went, to Cincinnati teir to five. Wil liams’ lack of control was generally recorded as the cause of his defeats, the records of the second game say ing: “While Cincinnati obtained only four hits, these came at opportune times, when they had been preceded by bases on balls off Williams.” The fifth game of the series was a shut out triumpth for “Hod” El ler, the big “shine ball” expert of the Cincinnati pitching staff. Four of Cincinnati’s five runs were grouped in the sixth inning. Eller doubled, Rath scored him with a single, and moved tosecond on Daubert’s bunt), perfectly laid, as ■the report of the game said. Wil liams walked Groh. Roush drove a three base hit to Felsch’s territory scoring two runners and himself tal lied after Duncan flied to Jac/son. Both Cicotte and Jackson were closeted with the grand jurors for • considerable time today and later court officials reported that they told their stories in substantial Re tail** As they left the roopi they weztt taken/in custody by Detectives of |the st/tes attorney’s office and taken asn. Their detention was not in the iatare of arrest, and it was animurged they would be released la ter. IP vrko bad vehemently de Cie part in. the alleged plot, nied 'u Maharg at Philadelphia, I 'on the stand, officials of ■•14, that the Philadel-’ wnT substantially cor-l __ in the the White font the waiver price.!iTackson w«S bought from CleV*lhh<i in 1915 Jot a large sum in cash and some play I ers in trade. Felsch was purchased ! from Milwaukee, of the American as sociation, in 1914; McMullen from Los Angeles in 1916; Kisberg from I Vernon, of the Pacific coast league ' in 1916; Williams from Salt Lake | in 1916 and Weaver from York, Pa., I in 1911. The purchase price of the eight, paid by Comiskey, represents a tidy fortune. The investigation by the grnnl jury will continue until all phases of baseball gambling have been bared, it was said by officials. The inves tigation started two weeks ago fol lowing reports that a game played here August 31, by the Cubs and the Philadelphia Nationals was "fixed” and the inquiry into last yeur’s world series came up only as an incident to the other inquiry. Assistant State’s Attorney~Hartlev Replogle, in charge of the case said tonight that indictments to be drawn up tomorrow on today’s true bills may contain several counts. The true bills themselves specified but one of fense “conspiracy to commit an il legal act.” The penalty provided upon conviction on this count would be one to five years in the peniten tiary and a fine of not more than ? 10,000. Just Beginning. “This is just the beginning,” Mr. iRepolgc suitl tonight. “We will have jmore indictments within a few days and before we get througn we will have purged organized baseball of1 everything that is crooked and dis-j honest. “We are going after the gamblers now. There will be indictments within a few days anginst men in Philadelphia, Indianapolis, St. Louis, Des' Moines, Pittsburgh, Cincinnati and other cities. More baseball play ers wi|l also be indicted. We’ve got the goods on these men and we are going the limit.” Harry Grabner, secretary of the White Sox, announced that the club would play out the schedule to the end if it had to “employ Chinamen” to fill the vacancies i nthe team. Mr. Comiskey tonight made the following statement to the Associated Press: “The consideration which the grand jury gave to this case should be greatly appreciated by the general public. The Hon, Charles A. McDon ald, chief justice, and the foreman of the grand jury, Harry Brigham, and his associates who so diligently strived to save and make America’s great game the clean sport which it is are to be commended in no un certain terms by all sport followers in spite of what happened today. And, thank God, it did happen. Forty ; lour years of baseball endeavor have convinced me more than ever that it is a wonderful game and a game worth keeping clean. “I would rather close my ball park than send nine men on the field with one of them holding a dishonest thought toward clean baseball—the game which John McGraw and I went | around the world with to show the people on the other side. “We are far from through yet. We have the nucleus of another cham pionship team with the remainder of the old world’s championshin team.” He named the veterans, Eddie and John Collins, Ray Schalk, Urbun Fa ber, Dick Kerr, Eddie Murphy, Nemo, Liebold and Amos Strunk, and de-i
The article recounts play-by-play details of the 1919 World Series games, including Cicotte's errors and wild throws that helped Cincinnati score, referencing his confession to the gambling fix. It also describes Billy Maharg's claims that the Black Sox were double-crossed by Abe Attell, who never paid the promised $100,000.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 29 September 1920 · page 6
Sox Double Crossed. ifclly Maharg, Philadelphia prize fighter, who last night, in Philadel phia, issued a statement connecting Cicotte with the gambling deal and changing that Abe Attell, former fighter, headed the gambling cique,
The report recaps the 1919 World Series games lost by Cicotte and Williams, including pitching details from the fateful games against Cincinnati. It also describes Cicotte and Jackson testifying before the grand jury, being taken into custody afterward, and notes the investigation into baseball gambling continuing, including purchase histories of the implicated players.
Pine Bluff Daily Graphic · 29 September 1920 · page 6
■the report of the game said. Wil liams walked Groh. Roush drove a three base hit to Felsch’s territory scoring two runners and himself tal lied after Duncan flied to Jac/son. Both Cicotte and Jackson were closeted with the grand jurors for • considerable time today and later court officials reported that they told their stories in substantial Re tail** As they left the roopi they weztt taken/in custody by Detectives
After Comiskey suspended seven indicted players, Yankees owners Ruppert and Huston telegrammed offering to place their entire team at his disposal to help finish the season. Boston's Frazee likewise proposed that every AL club donate a player to help rebuild the White Sox if the accused men are found guilty.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 9
FELLOW CLUB OWNERS OFFER TO HELP SOX
were: : Fddie Cicotte, pitcher, $10.00(1. Claude Williams, pitcher, $10,000. Charles Risborg, shortstop .10,000 '"Buck" Weaver, third baseman, f.VOOfl. .Ie Jackson, left fielder. $."i.(MMI. 'Happy" Felsch, irnter fielder, $.",000. "Chirk" (tandil, former first baseman, f.'O.(MH). Fred McMullin, utility plaver, flS.ftOO. ' ' With tears in his eyes, Cicotte told the gland jury how he had lobhed the ball up to the Cincinnati batters in the first game of the series, "so that they could read the trademark on it." Repenting after having thrown two panics, he said, he pitched hard to win his third start.
See moreSee less
Kither Candil. who Cicotte mid firt arranged the "throw ing," or Abe Attell, the go between of the gamblers, got fcT.I.IHM) which the tight players were to have received. When Joe Jackson left the grand jury room after his confession a crowd of mall boys gathered round their heavy-hitting idol and asked: "It isn't true, is it. .Joe?" "Yes, buys, I'm afraid it i " Jack son replied. , Cieolte and Jackon were not prom ised immunity in return fr (heir con-(-ion. Replogle aaid. hut are liable t prowes-nt ton the same a other play er named in the eight indictments re turned. The eight wrre suspended by Presi dent Comikey of the Sox as soin he had heard CicoUc'a cnfeion and turned him over to the ohib's attor ney, Alfred Austrian, to he taken be fore the irrand jury. Manager (Benson of the Sox de r'arwd that' the remaining mehmer were still fighting in the cnnrit raT nd would start their rlotnz three rame aeries at St. Ixiiiia Friday de termined to do all they enild to win. In spite of the upheaval which took seven regular mit of th line up
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Yankees owners Ruppert and Huston offered to lend their entire team to help the White Sox finish the season after Comiskey suspended suspected players. Comiskey declined, citing league rules barring trades after August 31, though he praised the gesture.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 9
COMISKEY APPRECIATES THE OFFER BUT MUST REFUSE
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
A Cook County grand jury voted indictments against eight White Sox players for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati for gambler money. Pitcher Eddie Cicotte broke down in tears confessing, Joe Jackson also admitted his role, and Comiskey immediately suspended seven active players including Gandil, Weaver and Risberg.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 29 September 1920 · page 1
With Eight Indicted Players new in baseball, hit the gamblers’ trail Wednesday. tors went into the gamblers’ part In the SIOO,OOO plot. cinnati, St. Louis, Detroit, Des Moines and other cities. In addition, the grand jury was prepared to take up alleged crooked playing in other games by Chicago teams. The Philacfelphla-Chieago game in the National league of Aug. JI, especially, was under scrutiny. The greatest baseball machine in recant years was piled by the way sida as the result of the wreck caused by the indiotments. Gleason Rebuilding Team. “Kid” Gleason, manager, Wednes day began taking the few good parts Suspended.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The grand jury returned true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players after testimony revealing bribes, including Cicotte's tearful confession of taking $10,000 and Jackson's admission to barely tapping the ball. Comiskey suspended the implicated players and paid off Weaver, Cicotte, and Jackson immediately.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 29 September 1920 · page 1
tors went into the gamblers’ part In the SIOO,OOO plot. cinnati, St. Louis, Detroit, Des Moines and other cities. In addition, the grand jury was prepared to take up alleged crooked playing in other games by Chicago teams. The Philacfelphla-Chieago game in the National league of Aug. JI, especially, was under scrutiny. The greatest baseball machine in recant years was piled by the way sida as the result of the wreck caused by the indiotments.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
The suspension of Chicago players over the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series has virtually assured Cleveland the American League pennant. With their regulars banned, the White Sox must field a patched team while Cleveland extends its lead over St. Louis.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 29 September 1920 · page 5
Suspension of Chicago Men Gives Cleveland Cinch On American League Pennant
Ban Johnson, president of the league admitted he had /heard rumors that the White Sox did not dare win the pennant this year. Just before the recent “crucial scries” with the New York Yankees, one of the White Sox players who was on the square, was interviewed by a United Press staff correspond ent, “Who are you going to pitch to morrow?” the correspondent asked. “Cicotte,” was the answer, “and If he doesn’t win, we will mob him on the fleM.” Cicotte pitched and won the game. Further details of the confessions' made by Cicotte and Jackson be came known Wednesday.
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
A photo caption reports that Chicago White Sox left fielder Joe Jackson told the Cook County Grand Jury how he helped throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati. His confession came after that of pitcher Eddie Cicotte.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 29 September 1920 · page 5
CHICAGO, Sept. 29—Identity of alleged go between and gamblers who bribed White Sox players was revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude Williams who joined Cicotte an-.l Jackson in making a clean breast of the 1919 world series frame up. Williams named Chick Caudill form er White Sox player against whom a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team and a “Brown and Sullivan,’ gamblers, from either New York or Boston as go-be tween for the gamblers.. The jury voted true bills lor Brown and Sulli van.
See moreSee less
Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson the same but that be received only $10,000 half of which he gave Jackson. He said Gandil told him that Bill Burns veteran pitcher, and Attell former prize fighter, were fixing it for the Six hired to get $100,000. CHICAGO, Sept 29.—At 12:30 o’clock pitcher Claude Williams ap peared at the criminal court building and was conducted to the grand jury room. Williams has made a complete state (Continued on Page 4)
Clipping to come
The Montgomery Advertiser · Montgomery, Ala.
Cicotte testified before a criminal court, weeping as he confessed to deliberately pitching poorly to lose the 1919 World Series after finding $10,000 under his pillow from gamblers. The report details specific game plays from the first game showing how Cincinnati scored runs off his pitching.
The Montgomery Advertiser · 29 September 1920 · page 5
Eight Chicago Players Are Indicted When Comiskey Sets Out to Clean Up National Game
there is nothing to indicate any lower prices. The financial conditions of the country are the very best. Why should you wait and pay rent, every time you see the landlord or the Real Fstate man coming towards your home, it makes you thiuk the house you live in is sold, and you will have to give possession and no houses for rent. Muke up your mind at once and buy your own home We have properties in all parts of the city. Have a number ot properties at the old price.
See moreSee less
Can sell you a property and give you pos session within thirty cays. It is not necessary to have all rush to buy a home. You can pay a small payment down and the balance as you are able. If you have a property you desire to dispose cl ouickly list it with us. We are in touch with good prospective pm chasers for all kiuds of Real Estate.
Clipping to come
Douglas Daily International · Douglas, Ariz.
Cicotte details to the grand jury how Gandil organized the fix and how he demanded cash upfront to pay off his farm mortgage. Weaver, Felsch, and Williams deny any involvement, citing their game statistics as proof of innocence.
Douglas Daily International · 29 September 1920 · page 6
(Continued from Page One) termined to do all they could to win in spite of the upheaval, which took seven regulars out of the lineup. Deny Taking Part Both Weaver and Felsch denied having taken any part in a ‘•frame up” to toss the series to the Reds. Williams said he would tell his story to the grand jury if called and would not discuss it further. “Nobody’s got anything, on me,” said Williams. “My wost is as good as Jackson’s. They are not stampeding me. I’m not talk ing for publication.” Weaver declaring his batting aver age of .333 and four errors in thirty chances during the series, were his alibi, and vigorously denied he re ceived any money for helping to ‘ throw” games or knew anything of the scheme.
See moreSee less
“It's all bunk as far as Pm con cerned,” said “Hap” Felsch. I’ve always been on the square. All I want is a chance to face the grand jury.” “Risberg, Gandil and MeMullin were at me for a week before the series started,” Cicottee said he told the grand jury in his confession. “They wanted me to go crooned. I needed the money. I had a wife and kids. They don’t know' this and I don’t know what they’ll think. Paid Mortgage.
Cicotte recounts to reporters his confession before the grand jury, describing how Gandil, Risberg and McMullin recruited players to throw the World Series. He explains he demanded $10,000 cash in advance to pay off a farm mortgage, found the money under his pillow, and later turned himself in to Judge McDonald.
Douglas Daily International · 29 September 1920 · page 6
know what they’ll think. Paid Mortgage. “I had bought a farm. There was a $4,000 mortgage. I paid that off with crooked money. “The eight of us got together in my room three or four days before the series started. Gandil was master of ceremonies. We talked about throw ing the series and decided we could get away with it. We agreed to do it.” Wanted Kale in Advance.
Eddie Cicotte's confession details receiving $5,000 to throw the 1919 World Series, describing his guilt, his confrontation with Judge McDonald, and threats from teammates Gandil, McMullin, and Risberg. A related dispatch reports a New York DA investigating claims that gamblers are now trying to fix the 1920 World Series involving Brooklyn.
Douglas Daily International · 29 September 1920 · page 6
Because he won it, these gamblers Wasn’t Wise to Gaff. ’’They've hung it on me. They ruined me when I went to the ship yards, but 1 don’t care what happens now. I guess I’m through with base ball. I wasn’t wise enough like Chick, Gandil to beat them to it.
Pitcher Claude Williams confessed to the grand jury, naming Chick Gandil as the players' go-between and implicating gamblers Brown and Sullivan, as well as Bill Burns and Abe Attell. Williams said he and Joe Jackson were promised $20,000 each but received far less.
Douglas Daily International · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Douglas Daily International · Douglas, Ariz.
Pitcher Claude Williams gave a full statement to the grand jury naming gamblers Sport Sullivan and Brown, and said he personally paid Joe Jackson $5,000 of his own $10,000. Eddie Cicotte also testified in tears about deliberately pitching poorly, detailing the payoff amounts promised to each of the eight players.
Douglas Daily International · 29 September 1920 · page 1
I ARE INDICTED CHICAGO, Sept. 30. —'Confessions from Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch, admitting they were bribed to "throw" last year's world's series, were made public yesterday and at the same time the grand Jury investi gating the baseball scandal took its flrvl action against gamblers who are said to have engineered the deal by Indicting two men whose Identity was only partly revealed. "Brown" and "Sullivan" were the names under which true bills were voted against the alleged gamblers and both were said lo be from Boston. oq.N'ew York. Later, however, it came out that the Jury believed these names *0 be mythical and us"d only by the tnçn when 1 h ■- v disc used hie sect's 'throwing" with the ball players Pos sibility that they are two men whose names already have been broucht he ïore the Jury and who are nationally kolrwn.
See moreSee less
was expressed by offlcals in he Stale attorney's office. ' The statement by Williams and Ih" newspaper reports of Fslsch's confes •kta tallied with those made on Thurs day by Eddie Clcotte and Joe Jack son. They revealed that last year's wrt.-ld series was «etlled in a liny room in a small south side hotel In this room, occupied by Eddie Cl colle, once the American League's leading pitcher, the deal was made which "threw" the world series, wrecked a world championship team «no brought some of the, greatest idols In baseball to disgrace. According lo the »worn statement, male by Claude WilllanK, who lost three of Ihe world series games, he and "Chick" Oandll, "Buck" Weaver. Eddie Clcotte, who lost two games, and "Happy" Felsch, whose error helped lose one. ®ame, met here to barter with "Brown" and "Sullivan" to lose the games. After we had agreed that we were willing to 'throw* the series," Wil liams said, "we went out one at a time and made our bargains with Brown and Sullivan." Williams said he received 810,000 an(1 that he gave 85,000 to Jackson, a statement which taille« with Ihe con fession made by Jackson yesterday. He wag supposed to get 820.000, he said. Felsch. according to reports of hh confession, said he received 85.000, which he found in his locker at the Clobhouse, but that he never had a chance to really help lose the series. His one glaring rror of the series— w^.en he dropped lha fly ball—was an aeoident and he was warned after wards by the other players not to be so awkward in making his mis plSys. he was quoted as saying. The outfielder declared he did not \Aant lo "get In on Ihe deal." at first, but the other players at the hole! conference told him ii would tc easy. Ho said he had been promised 820,000 but was double crossed Abe Atlell and Gan d'j won ill - onebe bclfew) guilty of the doiible-rrosslng. Frlsrh denied that the White Sox had thrown any game, this season. and said the men implicated In the bribery had felt all season they would be exposed sooner or later. W confirmed tfie confession« of Cicolt? and Jackson. John Heydlcr, president of the Na tional League, and John McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, yes terday told the jury details of the Lee Mlg e ind IlalQhase casre and also of dropping of Heinie Zimmerman. McGraw was requested to return Tlesday and bring Fred Toney, New York pitcher, and Bennie Kaulf, out fielder Heydler was asked to appear again at his convenience after the wvrld serle«. McGraw is said to have told the that he dropped Hal Chase from
Clipping to come
Douglas Daily International · Douglas, Ariz.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte tearfully told the grand jury he and other White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for payments ranging from $5,000 to $20,000, though he said gamblers double-crossed most players and only he, Jackson, and Williams got paid. Joe Jackson also confirmed to reporters that the fix was real, and Comiskey immediately suspended the eight accused players.
Douglas Daily International · 29 September 1920 · page 1
I ARE INDICTED CHICAGO, Sept. 30. —'Confessions from Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch, admitting they were bribed to "throw" last year's world's series, were made public yesterday and at the same time the grand Jury investi gating the baseball scandal took its flrvl action against gamblers who are said to have engineered the deal by Indicting two men whose Identity was only partly revealed. "Brown" and "Sullivan" were the names under which true bills were voted against the alleged gamblers and both were said lo be from Boston. oq.N'ew York. Later, however, it came out that the Jury believed these names *0 be mythical and us"d only by the tnçn when 1 h ■- v disc used hie sect's 'throwing" with the ball players Pos sibility that they are two men whose names already have been broucht he ïore the Jury and who are nationally kolrwn.
See moreSee less
was expressed by offlcals in he Stale attorney's office. ' The statement by Williams and Ih" newspaper reports of Fslsch's confes •kta tallied with those made on Thurs day by Eddie Clcotte and Joe Jack son. They revealed that last year's wrt.-ld series was «etlled in a liny room in a small south side hotel In this room, occupied by Eddie Cl colle, once the American League's leading pitcher, the deal was made which "threw" the world series, wrecked a world championship team «no brought some of the, greatest idols In baseball to disgrace. According lo the »worn statement, male by Claude WilllanK, who lost three of Ihe world series games, he and "Chick" Oandll, "Buck" Weaver. Eddie Clcotte, who lost two games, and "Happy" Felsch, whose error helped lose one. ®ame, met here to barter with "Brown" and "Sullivan" to lose the games. After we had agreed that we were willing to 'throw* the series," Wil liams said, "we went out one at a time and made our bargains with Brown and Sullivan." Williams said he received 810,000 an(1 that he gave 85,000 to Jackson, a statement which taille« with Ihe con fession made by Jackson yesterday. He wag supposed to get 820.000, he said. Felsch. according to reports of hh confession, said he received 85.000, which he found in his locker at the Clobhouse, but that he never had a chance to really help lose the series. His one glaring rror of the series— w^.en he dropped lha fly ball—was an aeoident and he was warned after wards by the other players not to be so awkward in making his mis plSys. he was quoted as saying. The outfielder declared he did not \Aant lo "get In on Ihe deal." at first, but the other players at the hole! conference told him ii would tc easy. Ho said he had been promised 820,000 but was double crossed Abe Atlell and Gan d'j won ill - onebe bclfew) guilty of the doiible-rrosslng. Frlsrh denied that the White Sox had thrown any game, this season. and said the men implicated In the bribery had felt all season they would be exposed sooner or later. W confirmed tfie confession« of Cicolt? and Jackson. John Heydlcr, president of the Na tional League, and John McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, yes terday told the jury details of the Lee Mlg e ind IlalQhase casre and also of dropping of Heinie Zimmerman. McGraw was requested to return Tlesday and bring Fred Toney, New York pitcher, and Bennie Kaulf, out fielder Heydler was asked to appear again at his convenience after the wvrld serle«. McGraw is said to have told the that he dropped Hal Chase from
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
Comiskey praises the grand jury for investigating the Black Sox scandal and says he would rather close his ballpark than field dishonest players. He lists remaining veteran players and expresses confidence in building another championship team.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Cicotte Threw Old Roman Sacrifices Fortune In Effort to Keep Baseball Clean
I ARE INDICTED CHICAGO, Sept. 30. —'Confessions from Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch, admitting they were bribed to "throw" last year's world's series, were made public yesterday and at the same time the grand Jury investi gating the baseball scandal took its flrvl action against gamblers who are said to have engineered the deal by Indicting two men whose Identity was only partly revealed. "Brown" and "Sullivan" were the names under which true bills were voted against the alleged gamblers and both were said lo be from Boston. oq.N'ew York. Later, however, it came out that the Jury believed these names *0 be mythical and us"d only by the tnçn when 1 h ■- v disc used hie sect's 'throwing" with the ball players Pos sibility that they are two men whose names already have been broucht he ïore the Jury and who are nationally kolrwn.
See moreSee less
was expressed by offlcals in he Stale attorney's office. ' The statement by Williams and Ih" newspaper reports of Fslsch's confes •kta tallied with those made on Thurs day by Eddie Clcotte and Joe Jack son. They revealed that last year's wrt.-ld series was «etlled in a liny room in a small south side hotel In this room, occupied by Eddie Cl colle, once the American League's leading pitcher, the deal was made which "threw" the world series, wrecked a world championship team «no brought some of the, greatest idols In baseball to disgrace. According lo the »worn statement, male by Claude WilllanK, who lost three of Ihe world series games, he and "Chick" Oandll, "Buck" Weaver. Eddie Clcotte, who lost two games, and "Happy" Felsch, whose error helped lose one. ®ame, met here to barter with "Brown" and "Sullivan" to lose the games. After we had agreed that we were willing to 'throw* the series," Wil liams said, "we went out one at a time and made our bargains with Brown and Sullivan." Williams said he received 810,000 an(1 that he gave 85,000 to Jackson, a statement which taille« with Ihe con fession made by Jackson yesterday. He wag supposed to get 820.000, he said. Felsch. according to reports of hh confession, said he received 85.000, which he found in his locker at the Clobhouse, but that he never had a chance to really help lose the series. His one glaring rror of the series— w^.en he dropped lha fly ball—was an aeoident and he was warned after wards by the other players not to be so awkward in making his mis plSys. he was quoted as saying. The outfielder declared he did not \Aant lo "get In on Ihe deal." at first, but the other players at the hole! conference told him ii would tc easy. Ho said he had been promised 820,000 but was double crossed Abe Atlell and Gan d'j won ill - onebe bclfew) guilty of the doiible-rrosslng. Frlsrh denied that the White Sox had thrown any game, this season. and said the men implicated In the bribery had felt all season they would be exposed sooner or later. W confirmed tfie confession« of Cicolt? and Jackson. John Heydlcr, president of the Na tional League, and John McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, yes terday told the jury details of the Lee Mlg e ind IlalQhase casre and also of dropping of Heinie Zimmerman. McGraw was requested to return Tlesday and bring Fred Toney, New York pitcher, and Bennie Kaulf, out fielder Heydler was asked to appear again at his convenience after the wvrld serle«. McGraw is said to have told the that he dropped Hal Chase from
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
Abe Attell, former featherweight champion named as a ringleader in the baseball gambling scandal, says he has retained a lawyer and will soon make a statement. He denies passing $100,000 to the White Sox, suggesting Arnold Rothstein is behind the accusations against him.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
PROMISES TO "LIFT LID" BASEBALL SCANDAL
Then Roush knocked a home run. ] Magee had to come in with the tying j run and Roush's run, of course, won i the game." Heydler is said to have told the jury ] that Magee confessed to him and Veeck | ?hat ha took part in the throwing of several games. When Heydler left the jury room he was applauded by the jurors. "We want to thank vou for giving your time to help in this investiga? tion," said Harry Brigham, foreman. "We're the ones who should be thank?
See moreSee less
ing you," replied Mr. Heydler. "When a jury does what you have done for baseball it's time for baseball to say 'Thank you.'" Mr. Heydler said he did not testify concerning the Chicago-Philadelphia National League game of August 30, which was said to have been "fixed" for Philadelphia to win. According to an official in the State's Attorney's office the names of two broth? ers in Des Moines have been brought before the jury. They are said to have placed large bets on the world series and to have been tipped that it was fixed. , Further indictments against gam? blers may be expected within a day or two, it was said. The jury will not consider baseball at its session to-morrow, but probably will resume the investigation the next day. < Felsch Sorry He Did It "Well, the beans are all spilled, and I think that I am through with base? ball. I got my $5,000, and 1 suppose the others got theirs, too," said Felsch in* his confession. "I don't know what I'm going to do now. I have been a baseball player during the best years of my life, and I never got into any other kind of busi? ness. I'm going to hell, I guess. I in? tend to hang around Chicago a while until I see how this thing is going to go. Then maybe I'll go back to Mil w ? u 1c ? c " The smile that gave him the nick? name of "Happy" Felsch faded as he considered his prospects. "I wish that I hadn't gone into it," he said. "I guess we all do. We have snore than earned the few dollars they gave us for turning crooked.? "All this season the memory of the world's series has been hanging over us. The talk that we 'threw' games this year is bunk. We knew we were sus? pected and we tried to be square. But a guy can't be crooked part of the time and square the rest of the-time. W knew that sooner or later somebody was going to turn up the whole deal. "Cicotte's story is true iqupvery de? tail. I don't blame him fortelling. I naver knew where my $5,000 came from. It was left in my locker at the club? house, and there was always a good deal of mystery about the way It was ?dealt out. ' That was one of the reasons why we never knew who double-crossed us on. the split of the .$100,000. It was to have been an even split. But we never got it. "Who was responsible for that dou? ble-cross I can't say. I suspect Gandil, because he was the wisest one of the lot and had sense enough to get out of baseball before the crash came. But I have heard since that it was Attell. Maybu it was Attell. I don't know him, but I had heard that he was mixed up with the gamblers who w?re backing -us to lose. Didn't Want To Be Squealer "I didn't want to get in on the deal at first. I had always received square treatment from 'Commy' and it didn't look quite right to throw him down. But when they let me in on the idea too many men were involved. I didn't -like to be a squealer and I knew that if I stayed out of the deal and said nothing about it they would go on
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
Chicago grand jury indicts eight White Sox players for conspiring with gamblers to fix the 1919 World Series, with Cicotte and Jackson reportedly confessing to taking bribes of $5,000-$10,000. Owner Comiskey immediately suspends the seven current players and vows to banish them from baseball if convicted.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT CHICAGO STARS WRECKING SUSPENDED CICOTTE AND JACKSON CONFESS GAMBLERS "FIXED" WORLD SERIES WITH CHICAGO PLAYERS FOR SUMS RANGING FROM $5,000 TO $10,000 PLAYERS DOUBLE-CROSSED
Then Roush knocked a home run. ] Magee had to come in with the tying j run and Roush's run, of course, won i the game." Heydler is said to have told the jury ] that Magee confessed to him and Veeck | ?hat ha took part in the throwing of several games. When Heydler left the jury room he was applauded by the jurors. "We want to thank vou for giving your time to help in this investiga? tion," said Harry Brigham, foreman. "We're the ones who should be thank?
See moreSee less
ing you," replied Mr. Heydler. "When a jury does what you have done for baseball it's time for baseball to say 'Thank you.'" Mr. Heydler said he did not testify concerning the Chicago-Philadelphia National League game of August 30, which was said to have been "fixed" for Philadelphia to win. According to an official in the State's Attorney's office the names of two broth? ers in Des Moines have been brought before the jury. They are said to have placed large bets on the world series and to have been tipped that it was fixed. , Further indictments against gam? blers may be expected within a day or two, it was said. The jury will not consider baseball at its session to-morrow, but probably will resume the investigation the next day. < Felsch Sorry He Did It "Well, the beans are all spilled, and I think that I am through with base? ball. I got my $5,000, and 1 suppose the others got theirs, too," said Felsch in* his confession. "I don't know what I'm going to do now. I have been a baseball player during the best years of my life, and I never got into any other kind of busi? ness. I'm going to hell, I guess. I in? tend to hang around Chicago a while until I see how this thing is going to go. Then maybe I'll go back to Mil w ? u 1c ? c " The smile that gave him the nick? name of "Happy" Felsch faded as he considered his prospects. "I wish that I hadn't gone into it," he said. "I guess we all do. We have snore than earned the few dollars they gave us for turning crooked.? "All this season the memory of the world's series has been hanging over us. The talk that we 'threw' games this year is bunk. We knew we were sus? pected and we tried to be square. But a guy can't be crooked part of the time and square the rest of the-time. W knew that sooner or later somebody was going to turn up the whole deal. "Cicotte's story is true iqupvery de? tail. I don't blame him fortelling. I naver knew where my $5,000 came from. It was left in my locker at the club? house, and there was always a good deal of mystery about the way It was ?dealt out. ' That was one of the reasons why we never knew who double-crossed us on. the split of the .$100,000. It was to have been an even split. But we never got it. "Who was responsible for that dou? ble-cross I can't say. I suspect Gandil, because he was the wisest one of the lot and had sense enough to get out of baseball before the crash came. But I have heard since that it was Attell. Maybu it was Attell. I don't know him, but I had heard that he was mixed up with the gamblers who w?re backing -us to lose. Didn't Want To Be Squealer "I didn't want to get in on the deal at first. I had always received square treatment from 'Commy' and it didn't look quite right to throw him down. But when they let me in on the idea too many men were involved. I didn't -like to be a squealer and I knew that if I stayed out of the deal and said nothing about it they would go on
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
This report describes the 1919 World Series Game Four, detailing how Cicotte made costly errors—a wild throw to first and muffing a throw from Jackson—that let in Cincinnati's two runs. The account ties these plays directly to Cicotte's confession to the grand jury, explaining the game was deliberately thrown.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 2
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
The article reviews the 1919 World Series game by game, noting Cicotte's losses and a game Chicago won 4-1, while referencing his confession to the gambling scheme. It also cites Billy Maharg's statement implicating Abe Attell and the players in the fix, and recounts Hod Eller's dominant pitching performance.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 2
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The report recounts details of the 1919 World Series games and reveals that Cicotte and Jackson testified before the grand jury, admitting their involvement in the fix. Cicotte reportedly confirmed Maharg's account and claimed Gandil had double-crossed the players by withholding promised money from Attell.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 2
Both Cicotte and Jackson were clos eted with the grand jury for a consid erable time today and latir" court of ficials reported that thoy told their ttories in substantial detail. As they left the room they were taken in cus tody hy detectives of the state's at torney's office and taken away. Their detention was not in ihn nuture of an arrest and it was announced they would be released, later. Cicotte, whoearlier in the day had vehemently denied any part in the al leged dot, as described hy Mahargat Philadelphia, admitted on the stand, officials of the court said, that the Philadelphian's story was substantial ly correct.
See moreSee less
The court officials also quoted Ci cotte as saying that the players had believed that "Chick" Gandil, who, he said, was interested in the dealings with the gamblers, had "double crossed" them and that Maharg's story was the first intimation they had that Attell had "held out" on the $100,000 which had been promised them. The eight players named in the true bills had been with the White Sox for periods ranging from four to nine years. Cicotte was purchased from Boston in 1912 for thc waiver price. Joe Jackson was bought from Cleve land in 1915 for a large sum in cash and some players in trade. Felsch was
The suspension of the Chicago White Sox players implicated in the 1919 World Series fixing scandal has effectively handed the American League pennant to Cleveland, as the depleted Sox must field a patched-up team. Rival club owners, including the Yankees and Red Sox, offer players or entire rosters to help Comiskey rebuild the team if the indicted players are found guilty.
Arizona Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 20
WHITE SOX TEAM ON THE ROCKS
Williams and an unofficial confession by Oscar Felseh. There has been considerable friction reported in Hoyne’s office since the Illinois primary election two weeks ago. Hoyne was defeated for renomination. Assistant State’s Attorney Hartley Re plogle issued a statement urging that Congress pass a law making it an illegal net for any one to offer a bribe to a base ball player who plays in different States. Hoyne had instructed his assistants not to complete the grand jury probe un til he returns from New York; ex pressed doubt that the White Sox play ers who confessed to “throwing" games of the 1919 world’s series are liable to criminal prosecution and declared that the ii dictments voted by the grand jury are not really indictments as yet because they have not been returned in court.
See moreSee less
BELIEVES COM IS KEY’S
Clipping to come
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
The report says investigators expect more players to be implicated and plan to probe claims that gamblers kept men on every major league team's payroll to influence games. It also details the depleted White Sox lineup for the season's final games and notes Comiskey received offers of player loans from rival owners after suspending his own men.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 29 September 1920 · page 6
McMuUin, it was reported, would follow Weaver. Both opened negotiations for the giving of their testimony, It was said. "Swede” Risberg, shortstop, is said to have declared he was not going to con fess because be has nothing to confess. "And if anybody squeals on me,” he is reported to have s.td, “I'll put them out of business.” '•Chick'' i.’andil, former first baseman, who was indicted with the seven present la'emberß of the team, is in a hospital at Lufkin. Texas, it was learned today, where he recently was operated on for i appendicitis, lie is quoted in dispatches received here as saying that charges that he was the paymaster and ring leader In the plot to “throw" the 1919 series are “all bunk.” The grand jury is believed to be chiefly interested now in the status of charges of corruption In the National League.
See moreSee less
After hearing the testimony of President John A. Ileydler and Man ager McGraw of the New York Giants, the grand jury asked McGraw to bring with him before the inquisitors Benny Kauff, formeri Giants’ center fielder, and Fred Toney, pitcher. Each of these plav ers is said to have been offered money to “throw ' games by Helnie Zimmerman, who was suspended last season by McGraw. The whereabouts of Eddie Olcote, the first of the indicted players to confess, are something of a mystery today. Ho checked out of his rooms night before last and was reported to have gone to Detroit. Reports from Detroit declare, however, that he has not appeared at his home there. EMPIRES TELL
Clipping to come
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
After confessing to the grand jury, Cicotte and Jackson remain unarrested, with Jackson under guard following a death threat; both signed immunity waivers and are expected to testify for the state. Cicotte tearfully detailed how Risberg, Gandil, and McMullen recruited him and how the players were double-crossed on the promised bribe money, describing specific methods used to throw games.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 29 September 1920 · page 6
The ball parks may Just as well be closed up next year. Pitiless publicity regarding all facts! rotten conditions Is the terrible part of it all.
Clipping to come
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · Bridgeport, Conn.
Cicotte describes how the eight players met at the Warner Hotel to plan the fix, agreeing to throw games for money, but says they were double-crossed and only three received payment. Jackson's confession details how he deliberately misplayed fly balls and made weak throws to help Cincinnati score runs.
The Bridgeport Times and Evening Farmer · 29 September 1920 · page 6
laid all the facts at his command De ,fore the Jury. He knew he was wreck-- his ball club, but is big enough to realize there is but one way to save the game clean it. He cannot turn the trick alone, how ever. The other magnates must "come clean," too. The "white" players who have knowledge of their teammates' I indiscretions or crookedness must, siep forward. The time for belittling reports of thrown games and "bought" players is past. So Is the time for shielding crooked So is the time for confining the in vestigations of crookedness to private sleuthing by baseball officials or pri vate detectives hired by the clubs.
See moreSee less
So. also, is the time for simply re leasing guilty or suspected players without stating the real cause of their departure. It Is up to the baseball mag nates and square players to lay their cards on the table before the public. For about a year we had heard re ports that the 1919 world's series wa3 not on the level that some of the White Sox players "threw" the series and got pay for so doing. Most ardent ly did the baseball heads deny the lumors and try to hush discussions in the papers regarding the reports. And now ve read that eight mem bers of that .White Sox team have been indicted by a duly sworn grand jury for "conspiring to do an illegal act" in other words, for conspiring to fix the series. These indictments were returned without the complete testimony of the league and club offi cials. And the jury promises more startling news. The list of eight men does not , A cover the field of players suspect ed of crooked work in the game. Thma of these eight perhapsare b -innocent, txit have vital testimony. That some other star players who have dropped out of the big leagues in tho lnct rrMinTo nf fipnenna vro, allowed to give business reasons and "salary differences" as the cause when in fact they were really given the gate because of their connection with gamblers has now been begrudgingly admitted by the moguls. The Indictments of theseefght men is not the astounding thing. The fact that the magnates were cognizant of and covering up such
Clipping to come
Imperial Valley Press · El Centro, Calif.
The Chicago grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix returned more indictments, with pitcher Claude Williams confessing and naming Chick Gandil as the players' go-between and two gamblers as contacts. More confessions and ten to twelve total indictments are expected, with the investigation now reaching toward National League players and eastern gamblers.
Imperial Valley Press · 29 September 1920 · page 1
MORE INDICTMENTS RETURNED IN BASE BALL PROBE CONFESSIONS EXPECTED
(By Associated Press) CHICAGO, Sept. 29—Further con fessions by some of the seven White Sox players who with one former player were indicted yesterday in connection with the alleged throw ing if the lest world's series will be made within a day or two, Alfred Austrian .attorney for the ball club, announces! today. it has i\en rumored that at least two more intend to supplement state ments by Cicotte, pitcher, and Joe Jackson, outfielder, with their stories. True bills naming three players, not members of the White Sox and three gamblers are expected to be voted to day.
See moreSee less
Claude Williams, “Lefty,” went be fore the jury today and reveald the identity of the alleged go-betweens and gamblers who bribed White Sox play ers. Williams named “Chick” Gandil as the chief go-between on the team and “Brown and Sullivan, gamblers” from either New, York or Boston as the go-between for the gamblers. The jury immediately voted true bills against Brown and Sullivan. Willianms said he was to get $20,000 but. he received only SIO,OOO which lie split with Joe Jackson. Evidence already before the grand jury is said to involve Abe A,ttel, former price fighter, Lee Magee, Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman., former members of the New York Giants and three eUstern gamblers, whose names .have not been divulged and at least two national league players. Hartley Repigle, assistant state’s attorney, woh today confirmed these facts, admitted that ten or twelve in d.ctments are i& prospect. The grand jury whose normal period of office ex res tomorrow will be continued in definitely to complete the baseball in vestigation.
The Chicago grand jury votes true bills against Brown and Sullivan as Williams admits splitting $10,000 with Joe Jackson, with ten to twelve indictments expected involving Abe Attell, Hal Chase, and other players. Meanwhile Cincinnati impanels a jury to probe Cicotte's confession of finding bribe money under his pillow, New York announces a probe into alleged plans to bribe Brooklyn players, and federal officials threaten tax prosecutions.
Imperial Valley Press · 29 September 1920 · page 1
TO INVESTIGATE SCANDAL THIS YEAR
CINCINNATI JURY READY FOR ACTION (Hv Associated Press) CINCINNATI, Sept. 29.—As the, re sult of Cicotte’s confession that he found the money under his pillow' in the Hotel Cincinnati, the Hamilton county jury just summoned will inquire into the circumstances. Cicitte confessed !|j received SIO,OOO the night before the, firsL tMWvn Cincinnati, finding it under his piilow.
The Cook County Grand Jury indicted eight members of the 1919 White Sox, with pitcher Cicotte and outfielder Jackson confessing to being tools of gamblers and receiving $10,000 and $5,000 respectively. Prosecutors said gamblers would be indicted next, no umpires were under suspicion, and White Sox president Comiskey vowed to continue fielding an unscarred team.
Evening Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
TOOK ESTION TE 1 M INDICT GAMBLERS NEXT FOR PART IN BASE BALL SCANDAL
tests, Today's game was a virtual walk away for Cleveland. Weilman who was . knocked out of the box' by Cleveland Sunday, started again and In ' addition to being hit freely is- -. sued five passes, finally leaving the ;ame after the seventh inning with XP visitors holding a five-run lead. Vangilder who succeeded him also was wild and made two errors that allowed three more runs to score. ' Covclrskie wis master of the sit-
Clipping to come
Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.
Court attaches reveal that Eddie Cicotte confessed to the grand jury, admitting he received $10,000 from gamblers and found the money under his pillow before the first World Series game in Cleveland. The report also lists the eight accused White Sox players and quotes Joe Jackson denying any gambler involvement in this year's pennant-winning season.
Evening Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Want to Tell Story to Inquisi torial Body Chicago, Sept. 30.Positive assurance was given today that objections of state's attorney Maclay Hoyne will not interfere with the Cook county grand jury investigation into the "$100,000 baseball scandal." Chief Justice McDonald, who order ed the inquiry, will issue a statement later in the day answering Mr. Hoyne's declaration that the actions of the grand jury, was frank in his statement that the injury would bo continued. "We are well on our way in thrashing out this matter and we in tend to go right along with it."
See moreSee less
3V/\ Brigham said. Today is the last of the jury on routine affairs. It is ex pected that tomorrow it will be in panelled as a special body. No Reason Today No "baseball session" was schedul ed for today. However, it was re ported that two other baseball piayeis members of the White Sox, have been negotiating to tell what they know bf the grand jury plot and it is be lieved the grand jury will care for this contingency if the players desire to confess. One of the ironies of the "throw ing" of the world series is related in the confession of "Happy" Felsch centerfielder. The one glaring erroi he made was accidental—others were made purposely. Felsch said he re ceivced $5,000, which he found in hislocker at the club house, but that "he never had a chance to really help lose the series." When he made tho one glaring error, other players warned him not to be so, "raw" he said. Felsch said he had been promised $20,000 but was double-crossed, he .be lieved by Abe Attell and Chick Gau dil. Felsch denied that the White Sox had thrown any games this season and said the men implicated in the bribery had felt all season that they would be exposed sooner or later. He confirmed the confessions of Cicotte and Jackson. John Heydler, president of the
Clipping to come
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte and outfielder Joe Jackson testified before the Chicago grand jury, confessing their roles in fixing the 1919 World Series and detailing the payoff amounts promised to each player. Jackson tearfully admitted the fix to a crowd of boys outside, while teammates Weaver, Felsch, and Williams denied involvement.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 29 September 1920 · page 10
CICOTTE AND JACKSON
! to Cincinnati batters in the first game | of thV series "so they could read the trade i mark on it." Repenting efter having thrown two he said, he pitched : hard to win his third start. Either < .an «Jil. who Cicotte said, first arranged the "throwing" or AI»e Attell. the go between of the gamblers, got *75,000 which the eight players were to have received. When Joe Jackson left the grand jurv room after his confession, a crowd of small boys gathered round their heavy hitting idol and asked; "It isn't true, i« it Joe'' "Yes, boys, I'm afraid it is.
See moreSee less
Jackson replied. Cicotte anti Jackson were not promised immunity in return for their confessions Renlogle said. The eight were suspended by President Con us key of the Sox, as soon as he had heard Cicotte'» confession ami turned
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
Weaver, Felsch, and Williams publicly deny taking part in any 'frame up' to throw the 1919 World Series, saying they will tell their story to the grand jury if called. Other White Sox players accuse the same men of deliberately losing games during the 1920 pennant race, citing suspicious play on the team's last eastern trip.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 29 September 1920 · page 10
payers we foci sure did the cheating." John CJhns, veteran firet baseman of the White Sox, said: "We arc sorry in a way for the fellows who are caught in this jam but we are glad everything is going to be shown up. "We suspected some of them in the world's series and we suspected them again because of the way they played on the last eastern trip." Red I'Yiber, veteran pitcher who carried lus chib to victory in the 1917 world's scries, said the playing of the Sox on the eastern trip made some of the others be lieve somettung was crooked.
See moreSee less
It look» like we were double crossed in * • the world's series last yeftr and in the pen nant race this year, but we are not through yet. "We will go to »St. Louis with a ball team on which every man will be trying and we will fight, to get into the world's sen os. "if we land we will be sure of one thing —we will not have a Judas on the team when w e go into the big series."
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · Wilmington, Del.
Anonymous White Sox players accuse Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, Felsch, and Risberg of deliberately playing poorly during the pennant race, suspecting another fix after the 1919 scandal. The report also notes suspect Chick Gandil's movements in California and the pennant race status between Chicago and Cleveland.
Every Evening, Wilmington Daily Commercial · 29 September 1920 · page 10
CHARGE LAY DOWN IN THIS SEASON'S PLAY
Baltimore, Md , Sept. 29, 1920. out However, we have never been able to prove this. l,os Angi lcs, Sept. 9Chick Gandil, iffdiet cd in Chicago^ came here last winter and liought a home.* Later he went to St. Anthonv, Idaho, to manage a ball team, hut returned saying his health wan better in California. lie played baseball at Bakersfield and elsewhere ibis season, w«N*k agn he sold his home and left with Mrs. Gandil bv automobile for the an nouneed destination of New Orleans. — St. T/onis. Sept. 29,—Holding a one game lea«!
See moreSee less
over Chicago in the fight for the American longue flag. Cleveland today had an opportunity to further widen the breach bv defeating St. Louis in the final engagement of the series while the White Sox are idle The Indians have scored three eonxecu five vietories here. Bv four games of (he five remaining on the schedule Cleveland will clinch the pennant, ir resjieet ive of the outcome of the series of three games which Chicago starts here 1 ndav to round out the season. —
The report presents photographs and captions identifying Joe Jackson, Buck Weaver, Chick Gandil, and Fred McMullin as central figures in the fixed 1919 World Series scandal. It states Jackson admitted receiving $5,000 (garbled as $6,000) and claims Weaver also received a $6,000 bribe share, while Gandil is named as the fix's leader who received $50,000.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Washington Times · 29 September 1920 · page 1
PRINCIPAL FIGURES IN SCANDAL
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
Assistant DA Lewis announces an investigation into reports that gamblers planned to bribe Brooklyn players to throw the upcoming World Series to Cleveland, asking Ebbets to have all players report for questioning. Separately, the Chicago grand jury is expected to hand down a dozen more indictments following Joe Jackson's confession, with more gamblers and National League players implicated.
The Washington Times · 29 September 1920 · page 1
RUMOR DODGERS IN PLOT
Flag. (By Hie Associated Frrm) St, Louis. Bejt. is. Cleveland pained another lap on Chicago In the mruKgle for the American league championship today, win nljig from St. Louis 10 to 2 and making a clean sweep of the fourtame series. . The victory PUta tha Indians a game and a half ahead of the Whits Sox and in a position to clinch the pennant by winning three more contests. -Today's game was a virtual walk away for Cleveland. Weilman who was knocked out of the box by Cleveland Sunday, started again and in addition to being hit freely, Issued five passes, finally leaving the game after the seventh Inning with the visitors holding a five run lead, Van Gilder, who succeeded him also was wild and made two errors that allowed three more runs to score.
See moreSee less
Coveleskle was master ot the sit uation, keeping his hits well scat tered and would have a shut out hut for errors by Gardner and SewelL Speaker, Wood and O'Neil led the attack for the visitors, the letter's double in the first inning driving over two runs and sending Cleveland off ahead. Score: Cleveland. AB. R. H. PO. A. E.
Clipping to come
The Washington Times · Washington, D.C.
A prosecutor says he expects more indictments following confessions by Cicotte and Jackson, and suspects other 1920 games may also have been fixed. He has identified two of three gamblers in a 'ring' that financed bribing players, with Lefty Williams and John McGraw expected to testify next.
The Washington Times · 29 September 1920 · page 14
CARRY ON PENNANT FIGHT. Comiskey and Gleason are making plans for finishing out the 1920 sea son and delare that, despite the fact .that seven cogs in the pennant ma chine are out of .the game for this year, and perhaps for all time, the White Box are not yet out of the bat tIe for the flag. It was expected that Claude "Lefty" Williams, White Box pitcher, will be a witness before the grand jury today. Williams is under indictment but It is believed he will go before the inquist tore and tell what he knows of bow the White Box sold out the 1919 world series to a clique of unscrupu lous gamblers.
See moreSee less
Williams was named in the confessions made to the grand jury by Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jack son. as one of the men who joined in the plan to "throw" the series to Cin cinnati for a price. John J. McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, who dropped sev eral members of his team, also was scheduled as a witness today. McGraw has promised to give the jury,a full account of every fact he has regard ing alle dishonesty in baseball. The gland jqry's investigation is now expected tb be directed chiefly at gamblers who are accused of cor rupting baseball players. Indictment of several gamblers whose names have been mentioned since the investiga
The report describes expectations that the gambling investigation will expand to implicate players across multiple major league teams, with rumors that fixers had agents on nearly every roster. It also details the depleted White Sox lineup for the season's final games after Comiskey suspended the implicated players, and notes the support he received from fellow owners for his decision.
The Washington Times · 29 September 1920 · page 14
CROOK ON EVERY TEAM
LEAD FORLORN HOPE. An infield with John Collins at fiWt base, Eddie Collins at second and Hattey McClellan at short does not look so bad but -the fans are wonder ng who will replace'Buck Weaver at third base. That is the biggest hole tb fill. For the outfield the Sox have Strunk. Liebold. Eddie Murphy and Bib Falk. In a pinch Ted Jourdan could be sent back to first base and John Collins could return to the out field. This is the aggregation that will carry the hopes that White Sox fans refuse to forsake in the three remaining games of the 1920 schedule.
See moreSee less
Although heartbroken over the din cster that hap fallen upon the ball club he has given his life to build up. Comiskey was greatly cheered to day by the offers of aid and sympathy that came to him from his fellow baseball magnates and from theu sands of fans who -commended his action in wrecking his ball club rather than win a pennant with players he believed dishonest.
Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson confessed to the grand jury about the fix, signing immunity waivers and agreeing to testify for the state. Cicotte tearfully described how Gandil, Risberg, and McMullin recruited him, how the players met at the Warner Hotel to plan the fix, and how he deliberately grooved pitches to be hit.
The Washington Times · 29 September 1920 · page 14
TURNED STATE'S EVIDENCE. Both Jackson and Cicotte sigged immunity waivers, but it is under stood that they will be given con sideration because of the testimony they gave to the grand jury, and that both will testify as witnesses for the State when the cases come to trial - Cicotte told his story to the grand jury with streaming eyes and halting tongue. He tbld how Risberg, Gandil and McMullin had broached the pis" to him, and how, because he "needed the money for his wife and kids," he agreed to join in the alleged conspir acy.
See moreSee less
He told how-the eight men met in his room at the Warner Hotel here, and discus'ed the plan and agreed that they could get away with it. "We lived up to our agreement," Cicotte said, "but 'we were double crossed. Only three of us got any money, and none of us got as much as had been agreed upon. I don't know what become of the other 575, 000. I think Chick Gandil got it or else Abe Attell. Chick was supposed to slip us our share of the bribe. He told me later he never got it from the gamblers."
A grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players, and Cicotte and Jackson confessed to accepting $15,000 from gamblers to throw the 1919 World Series. Former boxer Abe Attell denied being the paymaster of a reported $100,000 deal at the Hotel Astor, instead accusing gambler Arnold Rothstein, who denied involvement.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Abe Attell denies responsibility for passing $100,000 to White Sox players, accusing Arnold Rothstein of trying to pass blame to him. A Rothstein family member counters that Maharg's account is substantially correct and that Rothstein was never involved in the deal at any stage.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
A Rothstein family member tells reporters that Maharg's account of the Hotel Astor meeting is accurate but insists Rothstein refused to join the fix and never sent Attell money or telegrams during the Series. Separately, Comiskey announces indefinite suspension of the eight indicted players, promising reinstatement if innocent but lifetime banishment if guilty.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Cicotte testified tearfully that he and other players took bribes to throw the World Series, naming amounts given to himself, Williams, and Jackson, with Gandil suspected of withholding the rest. The grand jury voted indictments on confidence game and conspiracy charges, though no arrests had yet been made.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 2
Cicotte Weeps on Stand Cicotte's testimony was accompanied by tears. He was on the witness stand for nearly two hours. He cried, "I don't know why I did it. I must have been crazy." Cicotte said that he found his bribe money under his pillow; that after the first game of the series he had gone to his hotel alone, and the money was half concealed beneath the pillow. "There was no note, he said, but he knew what it was for. "Before Gandil? was a ball player he mixed in with gamblers and low char?
See moreSee less
acters in Arizona," said Cicotte1. "That's where he got the hunch to fix the world series. Abe Attell and three .Pittsburgh gamblers agreed to back ?Jiim. Gandil first fixed Williams and McMullin. Then he got me in on the ?eal, and we fixed the rest. It -was
Two indictments are being prepared against each of the accused players, charging confidence game and conspiracy with gamblers, though no arrests have yet been made. Cicotte testified tearfully, confessing he deliberately threw games after Gandil organized the fix with gamblers, admitting he took bribe money found under his pillow.
Cicotte describes deliberately playing poorly and his guilt over the fix, while Jackson details receiving $5,000 from Williams and intentionally muffing plays in the outfield to help Cincinnati win. Both named Gandil as a ringleader, and Weaver is reported denying involvement after his indictment.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 2
??He also said Qandil, Risberg and Mc iMulIin were the only clique that exI Jsted and thart Gandil was the leader. ! /Wie players ?bought it was Gandil i *who had doubUe-crossed them on the ?money end of the deal, he said, but they found out afterward it was "Attell. 2 After finishing their testimony both 'Jackson and Cicotte were escorted from *the grand jury rooms by a deputy ?heriff. It was reported the accused *?m<?n feared an attack by "fans" who lined the corridors of the building. Weaver Denies Charge "Buck" WeaveT, after hearing of his indictment and suspension, denied that She had agreed to throw any world .?series game* and that he had received any of the money.
See moreSee less
' "I batted .333 and made only four terrors out of thirty chances in the world series," he said. "That should ^,be a good enough alibi." i Evidence on which the White Sox "players were Indicted was uncovered by Comiftkey, president of the club, and furnished* by him to the grand jury, -Attorney Austrian said while Jackaon 'was testifying. Austrian said he had examined ?jCieotte and Jackson at Comlskey's di? rection, and then had taken Cicotte be ?fore the grand jury, where he gave the
With eight White Sox players suspended amid the grand jury probe, Cleveland is set to clinch the American League pennant and face Brooklyn in the 1920 World Series. The report details ticket demand, game locations, and the approval for rookie Joe Sewell to replace the slain Ray Chapman.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 12
World Series Opening Shifted to Brooklyn - Suspension of White Sox Players Makes It Practically Certain That Speaker's Tribe Will Capture American League Flag; Official Scorers Named
By W. O. McGeehan - Despite the sensational developments in the investigation of the world series of 1019 arrangements are being: completed for the handling of the world scries of 1920. The suspension of eight indicted players on the ChicaRo White Sox makes it certain that the Comiskey team is out of the American League race, and that the series will be between the Brooklyn Dodgers and the Cleveland Indians. The first three tames will be prayed .
The report covers administrative details for the upcoming World Series, including official scorers and a new system for dividing series money among players. It also notes that the indictment of eight White Sox players has effectively ended the American League pennant race, with Comiskey suspending his regulars and fans expressing relief at the grand jury's thorough investigation.
New-York Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 12
players on the Chicago Whito ^ox team of course Btops abruptly all' in? terest in what promised to be one of the most sensational league races in the history of the game. Comiskey has suspended almost all of his regular team, and the pennant race in the American Lea_ue is over to all intents and purposes. At the time the White Sox knocked
Following confessions from Pitcher Cicotte and Joe Jackson, a Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox for conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series. Club owner Comiskey immediately suspended seven of the players, vowing to ban them from baseball for life if found guilty, even as the team sat a half-game out of first place.
The Ocala Evening Star · 29 September 1920 · page 1
COMISKEY SCORES TRAITORS Chicago, Set. 28. -Seven members of the White Sox and "one former player were indicted today by a Cook county grand jury charged with con spiracy to commit an illegal act in connection with last year's - world's series, which they have .been , accused of "selling" to a "coterie of gamblers, The seven players were immediately suspended by Charles A: Comiskey, president of the club, who apparently thereby threw away all chances of winning the American League pen nant this year. The Sox are only a half game behind the league leading Indians today.
See moreSee less
The "Old Roman," who has spent a lifetime in building up his team, told the accused players in the notice of suspension that if they were , found guilty he would ( drive them out of baseball for the rest of their lives, if possible. ' .- Assistant State's Attorney General Replogle announced, that Gicotte was 'taken into custody after leaving the grand jury room and is now in charge of William Sullivan, a detective of 'the state's attorney's officgf5. He de " clined to say where the pitcher was being taken.- - Alfred S. Austrian, attorney for the club, sent the following telegram to Risberg,'; MeMullin Jackson, Felsch, weaver, Williams and Cicotte: "You and each of you are" hereby - notified of your indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League baseball club. "Your suspension is brought about by information which has just, come to me directly involving you and each of you in the baseball scandal (now being investigated by the grand jury of Cook county) resulting from the world's series of 1919. If you are in nocent of any. wrong doing you and each of you will be reinstated; if you are guilty you will be retired from .organized baseball for the rest of your lives if I can accomplish it. Un til there is a nality to this investiga tion it is due to the public that take this action even though it costs Chicago the pennant. "Charles A. Comiskey." "We will play out the rest o fthis schedule if . we have to get Chinamen to substitute for the suspended play ers," Harry Gribner, secretary of the " White Sox said today. The Cook county grand jury this afternoon voted true bills against the following baseball, players in its in vestigation of the alleged "throwing" of world'3 series games last year: Ed die Cicotte, Claude Williams, "Chick' Gandil, Happy Felsch, Charles Ris berg, Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin and ; Buck Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state law.
A Cook County grand jury returned true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy to fix the 1919 World Series, and club owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended them. Comiskey sent a telegram warning the players they would be banned for life if found guilty, while pitcher Eddie Cicotte was taken into custody by a state's attorney detective.
The Ocala Evening Star · 29 September 1920 · page 1
COMISKEY SCORES TRAITORS
Risberg,'; MeMullin Jackson, Felsch, weaver, Williams and Cicotte: "You and each of you are" hereby - notified of your indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League baseball club. "Your suspension is brought about by information which has just, come to me directly involving you and each of you in the baseball scandal (now being investigated by the grand jury of Cook county) resulting from the world's series of 1919. If you are in nocent of any. wrong doing you and each of you will be reinstated; if you are guilty you will be retired from .organized baseball for the rest of your lives if I can accomplish it.
See moreSee less
Un til there is a nality to this investiga tion it is due to the public that take this action even though it costs Chicago the pennant. "Charles A. Comiskey." "We will play out the rest o fthis schedule if . we have to get Chinamen to substitute for the suspended play ers," Harry Gribner, secretary of the " White Sox said today. The Cook county grand jury this afternoon voted true bills against the following baseball, players in its in vestigation of the alleged "throwing" of world'3 series games last year: Ed die Cicotte, Claude Williams, "Chick' Gandil, Happy Felsch, Charles Ris berg, Joe Jackson, Fred McMullin and ; Buck Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state law.
The Cook County grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players—Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, McMullin, and Weaver—charging them with conspiracy to violate state law over the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series. Comiskey vowed to ban the players from baseball pending the investigation's outcome, and the team's secretary said they would finish the season even if forced to use substitutes.
The Ocala Evening Star · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Pitcher Claude Williams told the Cook County grand jury that Chick Gandil was the chief go-between for gamblers, identifying bribery contacts as 'Brown and Sullivan.' The jury voted true bills against these gamblers and considered further indictments against other players and gamblers as the investigation continued.
Americus Times-Recorder · 29 September 1920 · page 1
(Continued From Page One.) X thoroughly by the grand jury, and may result in subpoenas being issued for gamblers in Kansas City, Des Moines and cities where major league clubs ane not represented, but wheie considerable money was wagered on baseball games. Additional evidence on the 1919 world’s series was expected to be handed the grand jury today by State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne. Hoyue was also ex pected to clear up the report that he had instructed an assistant over long distance telephone from New York to halt the probe and hold up the return of indictments.
See moreSee less
Despite these repo:ted instructions, the grand ' jury yesterday decided to proceed, regardless of Hoyne, and was prepared to be sworn in as a special grand jury. Hoyne is said to have evidence which he says will clinch the prosecution of the White Sox players involved in the 1919 world’s series scandal. This evidence, the state's attorney declares, was given him by two men who are neither baseball players nor gamblers, but it tallies with admissions made by Cicotte, Jackson, Williams and Felseta. The two men. Hoyne said, are willing to go before the grand Jury and testify. Among those mentioned as likely to be called before the grand jury today are •’Buck” Weaver and Fred McMullin, White Sox players already under indict ment; Clyde Elliott, a motion picture dealer, who is said to have accompanied • Kid” Gleason, White Sox manager, to ’St. Louis when investigation of charges of corruption in the 1919 world’s series was made by White Sox officials, and Dr. Raymond B. Prettyman, a dentist, who is an intimate friend of several Sox play ers. . „ , The probe of alleged ‘‘fixing of games this year was believed to have been given a good start in evidence that has been presented. In confessions of some ball players only the part In reference to the 1919 world's series was made public, but other testimony, It was said, indicated occasional , games were “thrown” In 1920. Several “square’’ players of the White Sox have said that after the second game of the 1919 world’s series. “Happy” Felsch, indicted outfielder, gave to Mrs. Felsch $15,000 which she deposited in her own name in a Milwaukee bank. Felsch has confessed to receiving $5 000 of the SIOO,OOO bribe that was promised the players to “throw” the series. Mrs. Felsch is said to have withdrawn the money from the bank last Monday anil she is expected to be asked by the grand Jury to tell what she knows of the trans action.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
White Sox manager Gleason describes how Cicotte's guilt-ridden confession to Comiskey led to the grand jury investigation and indictments. Joe Jackson recounts his own confession, says Judge McDonald doubted his honesty, and claims Risberg threatened him, while attorney Austrian expects more player confessions soon.
Americus Times-Recorder · 29 September 1920 · page 1
(Continued From Page One.) X thoroughly by the grand jury, and may result in subpoenas being issued for gamblers in Kansas City, Des Moines and cities where major league clubs ane not represented, but wheie considerable money was wagered on baseball games. Additional evidence on the 1919 world’s series was expected to be handed the grand jury today by State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne. Hoyue was also ex pected to clear up the report that he had instructed an assistant over long distance telephone from New York to halt the probe and hold up the return of indictments.
See moreSee less
Despite these repo:ted instructions, the grand ' jury yesterday decided to proceed, regardless of Hoyne, and was prepared to be sworn in as a special grand jury. Hoyne is said to have evidence which he says will clinch the prosecution of the White Sox players involved in the 1919 world’s series scandal. This evidence, the state's attorney declares, was given him by two men who are neither baseball players nor gamblers, but it tallies with admissions made by Cicotte, Jackson, Williams and Felseta. The two men. Hoyne said, are willing to go before the grand Jury and testify. Among those mentioned as likely to be called before the grand jury today are •’Buck” Weaver and Fred McMullin, White Sox players already under indict ment; Clyde Elliott, a motion picture dealer, who is said to have accompanied • Kid” Gleason, White Sox manager, to ’St. Louis when investigation of charges of corruption in the 1919 world’s series was made by White Sox officials, and Dr. Raymond B. Prettyman, a dentist, who is an intimate friend of several Sox play ers. . „ , The probe of alleged ‘‘fixing of games this year was believed to have been given a good start in evidence that has been presented. In confessions of some ball players only the part In reference to the 1919 world's series was made public, but other testimony, It was said, indicated occasional , games were “thrown” In 1920. Several “square’’ players of the White Sox have said that after the second game of the 1919 world’s series. “Happy” Felsch, indicted outfielder, gave to Mrs. Felsch $15,000 which she deposited in her own name in a Milwaukee bank. Felsch has confessed to receiving $5 000 of the SIOO,OOO bribe that was promised the players to “throw” the series. Mrs. Felsch is said to have withdrawn the money from the bank last Monday anil she is expected to be asked by the grand Jury to tell what she knows of the trans action.
Clipping to come
Americus Times-Recorder · Americus, Ga.
Eddie Cicotte tearfully testified before the grand jury that he deliberately pitched poorly in the 1919 World Series after receiving $10,000 from gamblers. Both Cicotte and Shoeless Joe Jackson corroborated Billy Maharg's account of the fix and were detained by detectives after testifying, while prosecutors vowed further indictments of gamblers and players.
Americus Times-Recorder · 29 September 1920 · page 1
ATTELL TELES OF CLEAN-IP. NEW YORK. Oct. I.—Ten gamblers “cleaned tip” at least $250,000 as a re sult of bribing members of the Chicago American League baseball team in the 1919 world’s series, said a statement made here Thursday by Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, whose name fre quently has been mentioned In connec tion with the Chicago investigation. “There Is a ‘master mind,’ who evolved and operated the entire scheme." said Attell. "Os course, he was assisted by several others. “His name and their names I know, but I do not care to reveal them at the present time. Later I shall give namej and particulars.”
Clipping to come
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
Pitcher Lefty Williams gave Chicago's grand jury a full confession detailing the fix of the 1919 World Series, naming the same eight players implicated by Cicotte and Jackson. He also named gamblers Sport Sullivan and a man named Brown, prompting officials to say they now had enough evidence to indict both players and gamblers.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CONFESSIONS OF JOE JACKSON AND EDDIE CICOTTE GIVE SUFFICIENT EVIDENCE TO OBTAIN INDICTMENTS AGAINST SEVERAL PARTIES
ments Against Several Parties.^ it Can in Crippled Condition. aitad Press Leased Wire Service.] HICAGO, Sept. 29.—The third con by White Sox players Indicted alleged throwing of the 1919 's series to Cincinnati, was an ~ced by authorities today. "Lefty" Williams, pitcher, told of part in the alleged conspiracy, As "t State's Attorney Hartley Rep le in charge of the investigation, tmced. Williams was named by "Shoeless" Jackson as the man who gave him 15,000. Williams named all of the gamblers were involved in the deal, Rep umounced. ShortlyAfter noon, Williams was totO Judge McDonald's office it wts %xpeete¥ h« would go beJury.
See moreSee less
Indictment of gamblers was expected soon after grand jury goes into session, ogle said. odge McDonald announced Wil made "a complete confession." ediately after telling his stdry to judge, the player was taken be tfce grand jury. llama involved the same eight yers as Cicotte and Jackson men "ed in their story, the judge said, now have all the evidence neo to go ahead and prosecute yone interested in the conspiracy "ayers and gamblers alike," the said. "We do not need any evidence." iMami mm v.„ mtr nnn tt Jacksrm mm .J in tin8 ,?6 which they split between them. Ms testimony, Williams men "Sport" Sullivan of Boston and man by the name of Brown, of York, who he said were gamblers. during the day. by the indictments. chase. cha*JgeTdHerdI,er' were announced. Williams said he was New York. a8me a the worlds what I would do about it.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
Pitcher Lefty Williams gives his account of being approached in New York about fixing the World Series for money, describing the offer and his hesitant response. Meanwhile manager Kid Gleason outlines a patchwork lineup for the Sox's final games, and Ban Johnson confirms World Series plans proceed despite the indictments.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CROOKED GAMES ARE PROBED
Press Leased Wire Service.] ICAGO, Sept. 29.—The Cook grand jury, Investigating edness in b&seball, hit the Dlei's trail today. ®r indicting White Sox tag of the 1919 world series, to' Cincinnati Reds, the fcnvestigagambler's part in toto the JMO.OOO plot .c*^8 announced they had suffl ®«dence, apparently obtained tne "confessions" of Joe Jack *_Bddie c,cotte, White Sox to obtain Indictments of New
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
Lefty Williams recounts being approached by Chick Gandil, who told him games would be fixed regardless of what the players did, naming Cicotte, Weaver, Felsch and two gamblers. Williams says he never saw the gamblers again after being promised $10,000 following the second game.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
Pitcher Claude 'Lefty' Williams recounts his grand jury confession, describing meetings with Gandil, Cicotte, Weaver and Felsch about the promised $100,000 payoff from gamblers Burns and Attell. He details receiving only $10,000 instead of the promised $20,000, splitting it with Joe Jackson, and suspecting a double-cross when the fix seemed called off.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 29 September 1920 · page 2
ROUND UP OF GAMBLERS NEXT
1 didn't get this until the fourth game and lie then said the gamblers Had been called off and I figured then there was a double cross someplace." "On the second trip to Cincinnati, Cicotte and 1 had a conference. 1 told him we were double crossed and 1 was going out to win if there was any chance. Cicotte said he felt the same iWiny," said Williams. Qaiidill told me «n Cincinnati that Bill Burns and Abe Attell were fixing it so we would get $100,000. I never got it.
See moreSee less
"We had a meeting in G-andill's room at Cincinnati. We just dropped in one at a time. They were Buck Weaver, Eddie Cicotte, Chick Gandill, Happy Felsch and mystelf there. "We asked Gaiudili when we were going to get the $100,000 that Burns and Attell were supposed to give us. He said: 'They are supposed to give $20,000 or $30,000 after each game.' If they gave it to him I know nothing about it. "1 didn't get any money until after the fouith game and then I got $10, 000. I kept $5,000 and the other was
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
In grand jury testimony, pitcher Lefty Williams described receiving fixed-series money from Gandil in two envelopes and splitting it with Jackson. He also revealed the original plan was to lose the first two Cincinnati games, with uncertainty about whether the third, which Kerr won, was part of the fix.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 29 September 1920 · page 2
Abe Attell Threaten#. NEW YORK, Sept 29.—Threats to tell some things about the "inside BtorT-fOt the last world's series that .will w-ftck open the baseball world,"
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
Chicago's Cook county grand jury planned to indict three gamblers and three additional players beyond the eight White Sox already indicted, while Eddie Cicotte fled Chicago for his Detroit-area farm. Separately, Brooklyn's DA announced a probe into rumors that gamblers were trying to fix the current World Series by bribing Brooklyn players.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 29 September 1920 · page 2
To Indict Three Gamblers. CHICAGO. Sept. 29. Three gamblers will be indicted today on charges of conspiracy in connection with the "fixed" 1919 world's series by the Cook county grand Jury which yesterday indicted eight members of the White Sox baseball club. This information was made public before the grand Jury went into ses sion by Assistant State's Attorney Hartley Replogle, in ctoarge of the investigation into the baseball scan dal. None of the gamblers are in Chi cago. Replogle said. He refused to disclose their names. Replogle also stated three other baseball players, none of whom are connected with the White Sox club, would also be indicted.
See moreSee less
No umpires are trader investiga tion, he said. John Heydler, president Of the National league, who was to testify beforo the grand jury today, said he would present evidence thai an en-
Claude 'Lefty' Williams confessed to the grand jury, joining Cicotte and Jackson in admitting the 1919 World Series fix. The investigation is expanding beyond the White Sox, with indictments against National League players being considered and Comiskey citing $230,000 in lost player value.
Evening Times-Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
TO EXTEND TO OTHER CLUBS
ComisKey Loses $230,000. Indictment of his seven playera cost Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, 1230,000, the amount for which, he could have sold their. .services, he said today. The club owner fixed the valuation of the •S' seven at: ^4 .... Joe Jackaon, $50,000. ^3% Buck yeaver, *&0,000.> -c
The report details the indictment of seven White Sox players and a former player, with Comiskey estimating the financial loss from losing their services. It also includes Cicotte's and Williams' sworn statements naming Gandil as the go-between with gamblers Brown and Sullivan, and amounts of money allegedly paid to players.
Evening Times-Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
INDICT GAMBLERS
ChaUfy Blatterr, $20,000. Fred McMullin, $10,000. 1 To Extend to Other Leagues^ vThe grand jury today sent a tele 's* gram. to EugenV-Dubuc, of the Toledo team, of the American Association, formerly jjhth the Tigers and Giants, asking him to appear here Monday. True bills naming three ball play 'era not members of the White Sox £j' and three gamblers are expected to be voted today by the grand Jury. Members of the jiiry -said this morn ing they had sufficient evidence on which to base tndltftmenta. \*t was reportea• that ti^xi bills against two National League placers ajw beln*~fconsidered,c
Court officials reveal portions of sworn statements from Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson describing how Gandil and gamblers organized the scheme to throw the World Series. One player's statement recounts being approached in New York, promised payment, and later feeling double-crossed when the full amount wasn't paid.
Evening Times-Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
,'i, x) ?ill Burns* veteran pitdher, and Abe f1, "i-M «fttel, fomier Jri*e fighter, were fix ig it fo!| fjbe Sox players ^td- -get flakes Sworil Statement. pins' b^tore the grand jury made the following sworn statement to Alfred Austrian, attor %w fqr the White, Sox. W'Zl situatifir was first 'brought v'• !ft to me in New York. Mr. Gandil called me to one fide out in front of $3 Hotel 4-nsonja and asked me if jay tipdy ha& approfohed me about iN- 'the world series, and I says, 'Just Wltat do you mean?'
See moreSee less
He says, 'that 0XC series is to be fixed if they were fj&ed what would you do about it? Woqld you talce a» active part or wWatf I says, 'I am in no position t0"say5 right) now.' I says, 'I will give you mf answer later.' 3 "After coming to Chicago I wa? called down^ to the Warner hotel, #here the eight members ywho are named.—not eight, I will take that back—I will name them for you,— Eddie .Cicotte,^Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver and jiappy Pelsch, and two fellows introduced as Brown and Sullivan,supposed to be the gamblers or fellows that were fixing it for the gamblers, one of the two, ,they didn't say Which. They introduced them
A Cook county grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players—Gandil, McMullin, Felsch, Risberg, Cicotte, Williams, Jackson, and Weaver—for conspiracy related to throwing the 1919 World Series. Cicotte's testimony reportedly corroborated boxer Billy Maharg's account of a $100,000 bribe scheme.
The Idaho Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
EIGHT INDICTED IN BASE BALL SCANDAL
Comiskey Suspends Seven flayers. Seven members of the White Sox team were suspended by Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the team, when Eddie Cicotte’s confession implicated them in the alleged fixing of the 1919 world’s series. The players suspended are Risberg, McMiii’in, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver,
Clipping to come
The Idaho Republican · Blackfoot, Idaho
Following the grand jury's indictments related to the bribery scandal involving Abe Attell and gambling payouts, Charles Comiskey announced the indefinite suspension of all eight implicated White Sox players, effectively ending the team's pennant hopes. Eddie Cicotte was immediately taken into custody and brought to the criminal courts building.
The Idaho Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Daily Star-Mirror · Moscow, Idaho
Pitcher Claude Williams confessed to the Black Sox scandal, naming former player Chick Gandil as the players' go-between and identifying gamblers Brown and Sullivan, who were then indicted. The report also notes more confessions expected, a new investigation into possible gambling in the 1920 World Series, and a Cincinnati grand jury probing Cicotte's confession.
The Daily Star-Mirror · 29 September 1920 · page 1
IN CROOKED BASEBALL DEAL
until after his recovery. ball club's attorney, announced today. Gandil In Hospital, Refuses to Talk Further Confessions of Consplratiors Promised Claim GÄng Trying Same Game This Year.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Lefty Williams confessed to the grand jury, naming Chick Gandil as the team's go-between and identifying gamblers Brown and Sullivan, as well as Bill Burns and Abe Attell as fixers. The club's attorney said more players were expected to supplement the confessions already given by Cicotte and Jackson.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 29 September 1920 · page 1
MORE PLAYERS TO TELL PART IN "SCANDAL"
OTHER PROBES CALLED (By Associated Press) CHICAGO, Sept. 29. Further con fession by some of the White Sox players, who with one former player, were Indicted yesterday In connection with the alleged "throwing" of the 1913 World Series will be made within a day or so, A. S. Austrian, attorney for the ball club, announced today. It has been rumored that at least two of the seven were anxious to sup plement the confession of Eddie Ci cotte and Joe Jackson with their statements. Two bills, naming three ball players not members of the White Sox and three gamblers were expected to be voted today by the grand jury.
See moreSee less
Members of the jury said this morn ing they had sufficient evidence on which to base indictments. Names Go-Betweena Identity of alleged go-betweens and gamblers who bribed White Sox play ers was revealed in a confession made to the grand Jury by Claude "Lefty" Williams, who Joined Cicotte and Jackson In making a clean breast of j the 1919 world series frameup Williams named "Chick" Gandill. former White Sox player, against whom a true bill was returned yes terday, as chief go-between of the team, and "Brown and Sullivan, gamblers," from either New York or Boston, as go-betweens for the gamblers. The Jury voted true bills for Brown and Sullivan. Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson I the same, but he received only $10,000, half of which he gave Jack son. He Bald Jackson told him that Bill Burns, veteran pitcher, and Abe Attell, former prize fighter, were fix ing it for the Sox players to get $100,000. Williams told the grand jury he be lieved the names "Brown and Sulll
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Lefty Williams told the grand jury he was promised $20,000 but received $10,000, half of which he gave Joe Jackson, and named gamblers Bill Burns and Abe Attell as organizers of a $100,000 fix. Comiskey received congratulatory messages after the indictments, while authorities began probing players' income tax filings and considering charges against National League players as well.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 29 September 1920 · page 1
OTHER PROBES CALLED
Williams told the grand jury he be lieved the names "Brown and Sulll van," given by the eastern gamblers, j were fictitious, but he said he could identify both men if he saw them again. It was Intimated at the crim inal court building that Assistant State Attorney Replogle was working on the theory that "Brown" and Abe Atell might bo the same person. Joe Jackson, who last night was in cus tody of a deputy sheriff, has been re leased and will leave tonight for his home in the south, it was learned to day.
See moreSee less
It was said this afternoon the indictment voted yesterday would be returned in court tomorrow. Comlskey Congratulated When Charles A. Comlskey, owner of the White Sox, reached his office before noon he found enough letters and telegrams waiting for him to fill two good sized barrels. Baseball officials, players and fans from all parts of the country tele graphed their sympathy and congratu lated the Old Roman on the matter in which he had cleared his team of the accused players. "It's been tough, but I feel better this morning," Comlskey remarked, after reading some of the messages. "I'm glad the worst is over. The boys who are left are clean. They have never sold a ball game and never will."
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
Assistant state's attorney Hartley Replogle revealed grand jury testimony implicating Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein in paying White Sox players to throw the 1919 World Series. Cicotte testified that eight players were promised $80,000 but were double-crossed, with only himself, Jackson, and Williams actually receiving payment.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Consider Two Bills. It was reported that two bills against two National League players were being considered. Abe Attell, former feather weight champion, and Arnold Rothstein, of New York, were said by Hartley Replogle. assistant state's attorney, to have been involved in testimony presented to the grand jury. Attell it wa-s said handled the money paid White Sox players for "throwing" the 1919 world series. More ball players may ho indicted, it was also indicated by Replogle, after the grand jury has heard the testi-' mony of Presidents Johnson, and Heydler, of the American and National Leagues, who are to testify today.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified before the grand jury, breaking down in tears as he admitted deliberately losing games in the 1919 World Series after receiving $10,000 from gamblers. He described intentionally bungling plays, including lobbing pitches and making deliberate errors in the field to ensure Chicago's defeat.
South Bend News-Times · 29 September 1920 · page 4
White Sox Ball Players Admit Throwing Games
SATURDAY, OCTOBER 2, 1920. SYMPATHY WITH COMISKEY. Charles A. Comiskey, the manly, honest and popular owner of the White Sox has the sympathy of the whole world interested in honest sports. A telegram offering to place the entire New York American baseball team at the disposal of Charles A. Comiskey, who suspended seven of his players, indicted in connection with alleged fix ing of games, was sent Tuesday night to the White Sox club owner by Jacob Ruppert and T. L. Huston, own ers of the New York American club. The message follows: "Your action in suspending players under suspicion, although it wrecks your entire organization and perhaps your cherished life work, not only challenges our admiration, but excites our sympathy and demands our prac tical assistance.
See moreSee less
You are making a terrible sacrifice to preserve the in tegrity of the game. So grave and unforeseen an emergency requires un usual remedies. "Therefore, in order that you may play out your schedule and, if neces sary, the world series, our entire club is placed at your disposal. We are confident that Cleveland sportsman ship will not permit you to lose by default and will welcome the arrange ment. We are equally certain that any technicalities in carrying it out can be readily overcome by action of the na tional commission."
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte confesses to the grand jury that he deliberately threw games in the 1919 World Series, describing specific errors and bad throws he made on purpose. The report compares his confession to Bill Maharg's account and cross-references official game records from the first and fourth games to verify details.
South Bend News-Times · 29 September 1920 · page 4
SATURDAY, OCTOBER 2, 1920. SYMPATHY WITH COMISKEY. Charles A. Comiskey, the manly, honest and popular owner of the White Sox has the sympathy of the whole world interested in honest sports. A telegram offering to place the entire New York American baseball team at the disposal of Charles A. Comiskey, who suspended seven of his players, indicted in connection with alleged fix ing of games, was sent Tuesday night to the White Sox club owner by Jacob Ruppert and T. L. Huston, own ers of the New York American club. The message follows: "Your action in suspending players under suspicion, although it wrecks your entire organization and perhaps your cherished life work, not only challenges our admiration, but excites our sympathy and demands our prac tical assistance.
See moreSee less
You are making a terrible sacrifice to preserve the in tegrity of the game. So grave and unforeseen an emergency requires un usual remedies. "Therefore, in order that you may play out your schedule and, if neces sary, the world series, our entire club is placed at your disposal. We are confident that Cleveland sportsman ship will not permit you to lose by default and will welcome the arrange ment. We are equally certain that any technicalities in carrying it out can be readily overcome by action of the na tional commission."
Clipping to come
South Bend News-Times · South Bend, Ind.
The report recounts Cicotte's grand jury testimony describing how the first, fourth, and other World Series games were deliberately thrown, including a play-by-play of errors in the fourth game. It also notes Billy Maharg's statement implicating Abe Attell in double-crossing the players out of promised payoffs, and mentions Claude Williams' involvement in other lost games.
South Bend News-Times · 29 September 1920 · page 4
Transcript to come.
Clipping to come
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Pitcher Claude 'Lefty' Williams testified before the grand jury, confessing his role in the 1919 World Series fix and naming Chick Gandil as the chief go-between with gamblers. His testimony led the jury to immediately vote true bills against gamblers Brown and Sullivan.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 29 September 1920 · page 1
BILLS VOTED AGAINST BROWN AND SULLIVAN; FOR CORRUPTING TEAM
McGraw, of the New York Giants.) These affidavits, he told the newspa-j | per men, absolutely proved the guilt jf Chase and Magee. State's Attorney Hoyne today ap- \ proved of the continuance of the In- ' \ estlgation. He says he believes the ! Jury has enough evidence to vote two 1 more true bills. It has been per-! sistentlv reported thai at least three ! more players and several gamblers ! and go-betweens will be indicted. At least six of the 1019 major 1-ague games were "fixed." State's Attorney Hoyne declared tonight.
See moreSee less
Moreover, the dame band of gamblers who reaped a harvest of gold in the) !a.?! world series were preparing to clean up again this year. The forthcoming world Herles was to be ??fixed," Hoyne also stated. Hoyne predicted ?hat the biggest s-Mndal of all is still to come and ?rt!l be exposed as soon as his as sistant* complete their investigation. "While In New York I gathered together loose threads of the 1920 ccandal in baseball, which far sur passes that of last season," he said. Veeck's statement that gamblers, by sending phony telegrams, forced j the Cub management to switch pitchi ers Just before the game of August j ?;:i, caused considerable surprise. It j had been generally charged that the I Kame had been fixed for Philadelphia1 to win.
Clipping to come
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The Cook County grand jury, having indicted eight White Sox players, now considers true bills against three gamblers and possibly two National League players, with foreman Harry Brigham calling the Sox players 'tools of a gambling ring.' Comiskey values his indicted players' lost services at $230,000, and NL president Heydler plans to testify that a separate gambling clique operated differently in his league.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 29 September 1920 · page 1
FOR CORRUPTING TEAM
McGraw, of the New York Giants.) These affidavits, he told the newspa-j | per men, absolutely proved the guilt jf Chase and Magee. State's Attorney Hoyne today ap- \ proved of the continuance of the In- ' \ estlgation. He says he believes the ! Jury has enough evidence to vote two 1 more true bills. It has been per-! sistentlv reported thai at least three ! more players and several gamblers ! and go-betweens will be indicted. At least six of the 1019 major 1-ague games were "fixed." State's Attorney Hoyne declared tonight.
See moreSee less
Moreover, the dame band of gamblers who reaped a harvest of gold in the) !a.?! world series were preparing to clean up again this year. The forthcoming world Herles was to be ??fixed," Hoyne also stated. Hoyne predicted ?hat the biggest s-Mndal of all is still to come and ?rt!l be exposed as soon as his as sistant* complete their investigation. "While In New York I gathered together loose threads of the 1920 ccandal in baseball, which far sur passes that of last season," he said. Veeck's statement that gamblers, by sending phony telegrams, forced j the Cub management to switch pitchi ers Just before the game of August j ?;:i, caused considerable surprise. It j had been generally charged that the I Kame had been fixed for Philadelphia1 to win.
Clipping to come
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Assistant State's Attorney Replogle announced the grand jury indicted eight White Sox players, saying the gamblers involved had left Chicago and no umpires were under investigation. Williams gave a full statement naming gamblers 'Sport' Jackson and a Boston man called Brown, admitting he received $10,000 and personally paid Jackson $5,000, contradicting earlier reports that Jackson said he found the money on his bed; meanwhile Brooklyn authorities probed a reported new bribery attempt for the coming World Series.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Yankees owners Ruppert and Huston offered to lend Charles Comiskey their entire team to help the depleted White Sox finish the season. Comiskey called it a splendid offer but said league rules forbade such action at this stage.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 29 September 1920 · page 15
OFFERED YANKEES.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
The Cook County grand jury indicted several gamblers, including Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein, based on testimony describing payments to White Sox players for throwing the 1919 World Series. Cicotte and Jackson gave detailed confessions naming amounts paid to each player, while Jackson separately told reporters the 1920 season was played honestly.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 29 September 1920 · page 15
HONEST THIS YEAR
BrewiUK' of baseball raises, acJjjhl to Hartley Replogle, as nvmat state's attorney in charge of me inquiry. Abe Attel, former mUhtrwelght champion, and Ar oU Rothstein of New York, were SSld by Ranlotl ta hmvm heen inolred in testimony presented to e grand Jury. Attel, It was said. aaiM tne money, paid White Sox liajors mmn fnr ."tkrnvin." ho 19 world's aeries; also Indicted r Replogle, after the grand Jury as heard the testimony of Jreei tont Johnson and President Heydt oi ue American and National ltii, who are to testify today. Cootei of telegrams sent prior to earing the 1919 series by Hal Jtoe aad Bill Burns, former "te Players, hare been obtained tfleydlor for presentation to the tory. r Where the Cash Went
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified before the grand jury describing how Gandil organized the fix and how he received payment to throw games, while Weaver and Felsch denied any wrongdoing. Officials clarified that Cicotte and Jackson were not granted immunity despite their confessions.
The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 29 September 1920 · page 15
, So. Inunanttr Premised. Clcotte and Jackson were NOT promised Immunity in return for their confessions, Replogle said, but are liable to prosecution the same as the other players named in the eight indictments returned, t Manager Gleason of the White Sox declared the remaining mem bers were still fighting In the pen nant race and .would start their closing three game series at St. Louis Friday, determined to do all they could to win in spite of the upheaval which took seven regulars out of the lineup. Weaver and Felsch denied' baring taken any part in the "frame-upK-to toss the series to the Reds. Wil liams said he would tell his story to the grand Jury, if called and would not discuss it further.
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight White Sox players for throwing the 1919 World Series and turned to pursuing the gamblers behind the $100,000 fix, using confessions from Jackson and Cicotte as evidence. Indictments of gamblers in several cities were expected, and other possibly fixed games were also under scrutiny.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 1
SURE-THING THIEVES IN $100,000 BASE BALL PLOT TO BE BROUGHT TO BOOK
ness in baseball, hit the gamblers’ trail today. After indicting eight members of the White Sox team for alleged throw ing of the 1919 world series to the Cincinnati Reds, the investigators went into the gamblers’ part of the 1100,000 plot Officials announced they had sufficient evidence, apparently obtained from the "confessions” of Joe Jackson and Eddie Cicotte. White Sox stars,
Officials said confessions from Joe Jackson and Eddie Cicotte gave enough evidence to indict gamblers in several cities, with indictments expected from the grand jury that day. Comiskey's championship-contending White Sox were decimated, forcing manager Kid Gleason to rebuild the lineup while the World Series plans proceeded unchanged.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 1
TO BE BROUGHT TO BOOK
Louis, Detroit Des Moines and other cities. court during the day. side as the result of the wreck caused by the indictments. Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the Sox, has built many pennant winning machines in his 25 years in baseball, but always pointed to the present ag gregation as the nearest perfection. The club has been virtually intact since winning the world's champion ship in 1918. Comiskey has insisted 66
The report describes new details of Cicotte's and Jackson's confessions to the grand jury, including Jackson's account of being threatened into confessing. It also notes rumors that gamblers who fixed the 1919 Series may have pressured the White Sox to throw the 1920 pennant race as well.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 1
TO BE BROUGHT TO BOOK
League. Ban Johnson, president of the' league, admitted he had heard ru mors that the White Sox did not dare ' The to win the pennant this year. gamblers who had bet on Cleveland had the White Sox in their power! through the crooked dealings a year ago, according to these rumors. The , gamblers are alleged to have threat ened the White Sox players with ex posure if they did not lose. Cicotte, the Sox’s star pitcher, failed miserably in the pinches this season., Manager Gleason forced him to do several hours extra practice a day, and then put him on the bench for a time.
See moreSee less
Rumors of the scandal caused con stant wrangling among the Sox them selves during the year, and the won der was that they were able to keep in the pennant race, even if they were playing on the square. Just before the recent "crucial" series with the New York Yankees, one of the White Sox players who was on the square was interviewed' by a United Press staff correspondent. "Who are you going to pitch tomor row?” the correspondent asked. “Cicotte,” was the answer, “and if he doesn’t win we will mob him on the field." Cicotte pitched and won the game. Further details of the confessions by Cicotte and Jackson became known today. Jackson said he decided to tell his story when he received a letter threatening to “bump him off” unless he confessed. “I heard that Ciootte had con fessed,” Jackson said, “and decided those birds couldn’t put anything over on me. I wanted to be on the ground floor when the squawking came.” “Shoeless Joe" said he Jost his nerve the first time he called up
The Cook County grand jury issued indictments against gamblers Sullivan and Brown for conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series, based on confessions from White Sox players including Cicotte and Williams. The report also recaps the suspicious fourth-inning play by Cicotte that first raised suspicions of a fix.
The Topeka State Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
SIX MORE FACE CHARGES
Know Gamblers' Xames. The First "Queer" May. Chicago. Sept. 29. The first "queer" play in the 1019 world series, thrown by some of the Chi cago White Sox players to Cincin nati for $100,000, came in the fourth inning of the first game at Cincinnati when the score was 1 to 1. This was the play which gave rise to the suspicion that the game was fixed and which caused the fisht between Ray Schalk. catcher, and two of the crooked players in the cluh house after the game. Cincinnati was batting with one out.
See moreSee less
Duncan singled and Kopf s; nt an eaav grounder to Cicotte. rated as one of the best fielding pitchers in baseball. Cicotte started to throw to sec ond base, hesitated, and then final ly threw low to P.isberg's left when the ball should have pone on the Swedes risht for a double play, ltisberg retired Duncan but was out of position due to the bad throw and could not complete the double plav. Kopf was safe at first. Five runs followed and Cicotte wns replaced by Wilkinson.
The Cook County grand jury returned its first indictments against gamblers, including Sport Sullivan and a man named Brown, identified by Claude Williams as the fixers. Four more White Sox players reportedly offered to confess their involvement, while Comiskey's office was flooded with supportive letters and telegrams.
The Topeka State Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
SIX MORE FACE CHARGES
Chicago, Sept. 29. The first Indict ments against gamblers alleged to have been connected with the con spiracy to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati were returned ' by the Cook county grand jury today. Sport" Sullivan of Boston and a man by the name of Brown, named as the "fixers" by Claude Williams, the third of the indicted players to con fess, were charged with a conspiracy to do an illegal act. Three gamblers will be indicted to day on charges of conspiracy in con nection with the "fixed" 1919 world series by the Cook county grand jury which yesterday indictei".
See moreSee less
eight mem bers of the White Sox baseball club. This information was made pumii: before the grand jury jlirv went into sessinn bv Assistant ' State's Attorney Hartley Replogle. in charge of the in vestigation into the baseball scandal. None of the gamblers are in Chi cago, Replogle said. He refused to di-v.ik-c their names. Replogle also stated three otner nastuau i with the j none of whom are connected White Sox club would als De in dicted. I No umpires -are under investigation, he sai-1;.
With the White Sox roster depleted by suspensions, Yankees owners Ruppert and Huston offered to lend Comiskey their entire team to finish the season. Comiskey called it a generous offer but said league rules forbade such a move at this stage, while manager Gleason said he was confident in the players he had left.
The Topeka State Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CAN'T BORROW PLAYERS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight White Sox players, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams, for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. Williams's confession named Chick Gandil as the players' go-between and implicated gamblers Brown and Sullivan, who were also indicted.
Richmond Daily Register · 29 September 1920 · page 1
WORST SCANDAL IN BASEBALL HISTORY
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Daily Register · Richmond, Ky.
A Cook County grand jury voted true bills against Cicotte, Williams, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Jackson, Weaver, and McMullin for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series. Cicotte reportedly confessed and wept before the jury, while Comiskey telegraphed the players their indefinite suspension from the White Sox.
Richmond Daily Register · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Richmond Daily Register · Richmond, Ky.
Comiskey suspends eight White Sox players pending investigation into the 1919 World Series scandal, vowing to field a team even if he must use substitutes. Eddie Cicotte reportedly confessed to the grand jury, saying he received $10,000 hidden under his hotel pillow, while Joe Jackson received $5,000 in the same manner.
Richmond Daily Register · 29 September 1920 · page 1
(By United Press) Chicago, Oct. 5.The head the gambling-, syndicate which fixed the play in the^ 1919 world series, was expected to" be named in evi dence presented the /Cook county grand jury probing crooked base ball TlPTft todftV evidence has been procured showing that -a millionaire New York gambler headed the betting Ting. Evidence, it is said, will show that he sent an agent to Cincinnati with instruc tions to plunge heavily on the Reds to beat the "White Sox, and will cite a\beto 133, with a big Chicago gambler made by the New York gambler's agent. 1 The Chicago gambler, (vWho has been in the East until recently, was expected to give evidence.
Clipping to come
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · Bemidji, Minn.
The Cook County grand jury returns indictments against gamblers Sport Sullivan and a man named Brown for conspiring with White Sox players to fix the 1919 World Series. Pitcher Lefty Williams becomes the third player to confess, naming Joe Jackson as another participant, as prosecutors prepare further indictments against gamblers and players.
The Bemidji Daily Pioneer · 29 September 1920 · page 1
THREE GAMBLERS WILL APPEAR BEFORE GRAND JURY TO ANSWER CHARGES
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Commonwealth · Greenwood, Miss.
Claude Williams told the grand jury that Chick Gandil was the team's go-between with gamblers Brown and Sullivan, and that he himself received only $10,000 of a promised $20,000, splitting it with Jackson. The jury is also considering indictments against gamblers Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein, with Buck Weaver and Hap Felsch named among players already indicted.
The Commonwealth · 29 September 1920 · page 1
INDICT MORE BALL PLAYERS
,1. foro Investigators B V Cnfragrr, Oct. S. Resumption of the Investigation Into alleged "fixing" of isajor lcaguo baseball games today jbeught several more baseball notables before tiie grand jury, which was rciaisrd Hn n unoMnl hnArr in rn nplnile the 1if11 t...lH-H -i tt ...!. ri -"nii 'uiiius Itlivi tfccl rcRuittt ocay slons ended last week. Only matters pertaining to baseball will be considered 14 Manager John JT. McOraw. of the "on jtorK -uinnrs; manager lviu aiedson.-of the Chicago "White Sox. and ' Mar)arcr Hughle Jennings, of the De troit Tigers, were scheduled to appear tochiy, and others wlw have already ar rived to testify or aro expected soon In clude Pitcher Fred Toncy and Out fielder HcnnV Keuff, of MeOraw's club.
See moreSee less
"Jean'- Dubnc, former Giant pitcher, was -also expected to testify today. I'l , Shortstop Arthur Fletcher, of the Tipo O'Nell, former president of the "Western League and now in the busi ng 'office of the "White Sox, will also bo'tvltncssos noon. .ITiidle PnlllnH. ftpcnnrl Tmmnn ni1 ( , cntijaln of the "White Sox, and Rny i Schalk, catcher, will be called later. Assistant State Attorney .Replogle said.
Clipping to come
Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.
Following a grand jury conspiracy indictment against seven White Sox players and Comiskey's suspension of them, Yankees owners Huppert and Huston telegraphed an offer to lend their own players so Chicago could finish its schedule. Comiskey said he appreciated the gesture but could not accept it because league rules forbade trades after August 31.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
HELP OFFERED
Tipo O'Nell, former president of the "Western League and now in the busi ng 'office of the "White Sox, will also bo'tvltncssos noon. .ITiidle PnlllnH. ftpcnnrl Tmmnn ni1 ( , cntijaln of the "White Sox, and Rny i Schalk, catcher, will be called later. Assistant State Attorney .Replogle said.
Clipping to come
Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.
The Cook County grand jury voted indictments against eight White Sox players, and confessions were obtained from Cicotte and Jackson implicating others in the scheme to throw the 1919 World Series for gambler money. Comiskey is portrayed as dismantling his own championship team to purge the scandal from baseball.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
C. COMISKEY SMASHES PENNANT MACHINE TO CLEAN UP BASEBALL
a xood idea who this man was. He rcr inRffited It was a peculiar circumstance: tl ilj. persons in certain circles were1 hi sfening to absolve the man he had In m tfd of all connection with the scan dair 3Ir. Swann declared ho was unable tajio through with the grand jury pro ceedings he hod planned for estcrday, bccSuse ho could not set hold of cer tain witnesses. Of these, he said, Abe Attell, the former prizefighter nnd g4rabler, for whom process servers had beea searching with grand jury sub poenas, wai the most important.
See moreSee less
le had also been In touch with "two vdry wealthy, but none too wise, gen tlemen of the city," who lost $00,000 nnd $15,000 respectively on last year's world serieR. They had been persuaded toT bet on Chicago ngainst Cincinnati by -tho man who Swann believes to be the master mind of the fixing deal nnd who got the suckers' money. The District Attorney says he is" unable to persuadD these two men to tell him of the grand jury about it, because they are nqwllling to let it be known that they were taken It. They deny, too, all .knowledge of the fixing. For the first time a member of the bench was dragged into the scandal. Hp'la said to have been present nt the Hritel Astor when Arnold Rothsteln was' approached by the would-be fixers and with whom, runs the story, he nearly came to Hows in turning down the' proposals. Mr. Swann said that he '.would present n case against any man, however prominent, as soon as lifsi office obtained the necessary infor mation. It was reported yesterday that "Bachlc" Brown, a gambler known to have been associated with Rothsteln, departed hastily on a liner Saturday for Europe. It is possible that Brown knew something of the throwing of last year's baseball games, and that he left the country to tsnpe questioning. It was recalled that n man known simply n "Brown" had been indicted by tho Chicago grand jury in connection with the fixing Kcnndnl.
Clipping to come
Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.
A Chicago grand jury returns true bills against seven current and one former White Sox player in the Black Sox scandal, leading Comiskey to immediately suspend the accused stars. Courtroom details emerge, including Cicotte's tearful confession of taking a $10,000 bribe found under his hotel pillow, as baseball officials like McGraw and Heydler await testimony.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CHICAGO. Met Resumption of investigation into alleged fixing'' of major baseball games today was to bring several more baseball notables before the grand jury Manager John J. McGraw. of the Yew York Giants. Manager ' Kid " Icason of the Chicago White Sox and Afanager H:ighie Jennlngf. of the De troit Tigers, were scheduled to appeal today, and others who have nlread' arrived to testify or are expected soon Include Pitcher Fied Toue and Out fielder Benny Kauff. oir ftfcQra lub Jean Dubuc. former Giant pi'h er, waa also expected to test rfy todaj P' Shortstop Arthur Fletcher, of tru ly .j I'hillie.-.
See moreSee less
formerly with the Giants, and H Tip" i Neil I. former president of the HH Western league and now in the buaiHH rest offVeof the White Sox. will alo H be witnesses soon. B Eddie Collins, second baseman and HH captain of the White .Sox. and Hay snags Schalk. .utcher. will be called later. JyUaj Assistant State's Attorney Replogle 1 'aid. to discuss technical baseball and gH should how a seemingly slight error B might have a deciding effect on the gS result of a game. They will also be H asked whether the believe games mm thrown bj members of their H tOJUn this year. Some players have B barged that their former team-mates on the White Sox club, who have been HK indicted and suspended "threw" games fl this season to insure that Cleveland HH vuld Vln the pennant.
Clipping to come
The Butte Daily Bulletin · Butte, Mont.
Eddie Cicotte, once hailed as a hero, was escorted tearfully through the Chicago criminal court building after confessing before the grand jury to the plot to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati. The report captures his visible remorse and fall from public idolization.
The Butte Daily Bulletin · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CICOTTE SOUNDING DEPTH OF REMORSE
(Special United Press Wire.) Chicago, Sept. 29.-Information has been gathered by officials tending to indicate the same group of gam blers which is alleged to have "fixed" the 1919 world's series, had made plans to have Brooklyn throw the coming series to Cleveland. These reports said the Chicago White Sox were be ing blackmailed by the gamblers who had gotten the players indicted under their grip last year, to throw this year's pennant to Cleveland. Bookmakers on baseball are known to have passed the tip that Cleveland would win the American league pennant as well as the world series.
A Chicago grand jury prepared indictments against gamblers and players connected to the 1919 World Series fix, based largely on confessions from Cicotte and Jackson. Cicotte fled Chicago while Jackson denied any wrongdoing, insisting the White Sox played honestly.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Butte Daily Bulletin · 29 September 1920 · page 1
GAMIBLE'R,4 TO BE INDICTED. (Special United Press Wire,)) Chicago, Sept. 29.-Three g;at. blers are to be indicted today on charges of conspiracy in g.onnectio) with the "ftLing" of the16: 1 wod',s series, Assisytant United States Attr nhey Replogle annouaced this morn ing. Me refused to disclose their inamrue:;. Replogle said tinee other players, none of whom are connected with the White Soex are also to be indicted. Other offer. to confeSS' "connection with the "fixed" series have been made, it was announced. Replogle said he had receved many anonymous letters asking hint to probe the 1914 series between Boston and Philadelphia.
See moreSee less
Officials announced they had suf ficient evidence, apparently obtained from the confessipas of Cicotte and Jackson, White Soex stars, to obtais indictments of gamblers ' in New York, Chicago, Cinciniiati, St. Louis, Detroit, Des Moines and other cities. In addition the grand jury is pre. pared to consider alleged crooked players in ther teams. ,Cicotte, the first Whtie Star player to confess regarding the con spiracy to throw gaines, has hurried ly left Chicago. It is reported he went to his farm near Detroit. "The White Sos pltyed honest ball this season," Joe'Jackson, one of the players who confessed, told the United Press. "We did every thing we could to win the pennant." So far as I know none of the men had anything to do with the ganm blers this year," he said.
This report covers multiple developments in the Black Sox scandal: pitcher Williams reportedly confessed to the conspiracy and named gamblers involved, leading to indictments of Sport Sullivan and a man named Brown. Jean Dubuc was ordered to appear before the grand jury, and Abe Attell threatened to reveal the inside story, claiming he was being made a scapegoat for Arnold Rothstein.
The Butte Daily Bulletin · 29 September 1920 · page 3
PLOT TO THROW
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
A grand jury returned true bills against seven Chicago White Sox players for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati. The report details Cicotte's confession describing how specific games, including the fourth game, were deliberately lost.
Omaha Daily Bee · 29 September 1920 · page 2
Series Games. - (ContinwU "rm rf Oo.) i i - single over second bsseV that sent ! Rath to. third and he sc6rcd when j Croh died to Jackson, Rath beating Jackson'sjthrow to the plate. !' : Chicago tied thia tun in the next ' Inning, Kopf putting Jackson on ' second with a wild throw. Felsch sacrificed him to third and Gandi i; dropped a little fly aifely in center, 1 vr scoring Jackson. . The end of Ciipotte's pitching and , '--the runs that ultimately won the ; .--game, were scored by Cincinnati in the fourth inning.
See moreSee less
All the damage was done with two out. With Kopf f 'on first, Neale" and Wingo singled and Keuther. the hard-hitting Cm cinnati pitcher, drove a three-base hit to the center field bleachers. .'Rath doubled and Paubert singled) i?'the combination resulting in five H'runs. Wilkinson took Cicotte's U;'jplace after Daubert's single , and K sVrpb flied.to felsch. The final B ,;sore of thia game was 9 to I.
The report recounts Cicotte's statement to the grand jury, describing how he and Jackson deliberately threw the fourth World Series game through wild throws, and also covers a later game Cicotte won. It includes Billy Maharg's claim that Abe Attell double-crossed the players by withholding promised gambling payoffs.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Omaha Daily Bee · 29 September 1920 · page 2
, . Pitches Sixth Qany. Cicotte's next appearance in the series was in the sixth game whn Cincinnati had four victories to g credit against one defeat, Richard Kerr, the diminutive left-handed pitcher, having shut out the champ ions in tne third game, the vetersn twirler who .today confessed the big gambling deal, went through nine innings' and held his,opppnents to seven bits. Chicago won the gsme 4 t9 1? hitting Salle? hard in the firsj f'v$ innings. Jackson and Felsch each got two hits and be twe.en them drove in all of Chicago's runs.
See moreSee less
y '"Billy Maharg,-Philadelphia prize ft fighter, who last night in Pliiladclf, ihia issued a statepient connecting ! Cicptte with the gambling dral and i charging Abe Attell, former fighter, . headed the gatfibling clique! asserted ; the Sox were double-crossed by At C te'l never received $1QO,000 j" which had been promised them. It J was late in the series before they $ found this out, Maharg asserted, as f; Attell kept postponing the day of settlement, saying he needed the moneyao bet. p .Besides the two defeats registered jcjjj against Cicotte in the series, three others were chalked up against Iaude Williams. The latter, a "side g arm" left bander, was wild in the fij second and fifth games, which went to the Reds, 4 to 2 and 5 to 0. In g the eighth aNid last game of the se $i ries he was found for four solid hits in the first inning and that game and the title of torld's chatnp'.ons went ta Cincinirati, 10 to, 5. Williams' lack of control Tvas jrenerally re X fa corded ?s the cause of life defeat, I?, the rxeord of the second contest , g saying: S "While ('Cincinnati obtained oply v ur hits, these c4me at opportune gi times when they had Ix'en receded 5st,v bases on balls off Williams." j 4 ' Fifth Game Shutout, i' The fifth game was a shutout triumph for x Hod Eller, the big E "shioe ball" expert of the Cincin jjf nati pitching staff. Only three hits were made pff hini jnd he estabr f " lished a world's scries record by v' sirikitig out the side in two successivs innings. All told, Eller had iilj'riine strikeouts that day. Foir of "i Cincinnati's five runs were grouped I. itt the sixth inning, iller doubled. Rath scored him wit If a single, and I moved to seebnd on Daubert's jj 'bunt perfectly laid," as ihe referee ot tht game Sail. Williams walked -SS'Greh. Rousch drove a three-base I'V to Felsch's territory, scoring fw'l IX limners and hi-nsclt tallied after ;i Ouncan flicd to Jackson, ii Both Cicotte qnd Jacksop were f closeted with the jury for a consid . ?fable time today nd later court officiats reported that they told their J stories in substantial detail. As they Left the.oom ihey were taken in i"? custody by detectives of the state's ;4 ittorney's office and taken away. Their detention v. as not in the na " lure of an arrest and it was ani ouneed that they woHld be re J! .'east ed later. code, who, curlier in the day, had vehemently denied any -part in :he alleged plot described by Ma larg at rhiladc'phia. admitted oil the stand, officials of the court said, lhat the Philidelphian's story was substantially correct. .
The article reviews pitching performances and scores from the 1919 World Series games, including Cicotte's and Williams' losses and Eller's strikeout record, while referencing Cicotte's confession and Maharg's allegations about Abe Attell shortchanging the players. It notes that Cicotte and Jackson spent time testifying before the grand jury.
Omaha Daily Bee · 29 September 1920 · page 2
, . Pitches Sixth Qany. Cicotte's next appearance in the series was in the sixth game whn Cincinnati had four victories to g credit against one defeat, Richard Kerr, the diminutive left-handed pitcher, having shut out the champ ions in tne third game, the vetersn twirler who .today confessed the big gambling deal, went through nine innings' and held his,opppnents to seven bits. Chicago won the gsme 4 t9 1? hitting Salle? hard in the firsj f'v$ innings. Jackson and Felsch each got two hits and be twe.en them drove in all of Chicago's runs.
See moreSee less
y '"Billy Maharg,-Philadelphia prize ft fighter, who last night in Pliiladclf, ihia issued a statepient connecting ! Cicptte with the gambling dral and i charging Abe Attell, former fighter, . headed the gatfibling clique! asserted ; the Sox were double-crossed by At C te'l never received $1QO,000 j" which had been promised them. It J was late in the series before they $ found this out, Maharg asserted, as f; Attell kept postponing the day of settlement, saying he needed the moneyao bet. p .Besides the two defeats registered jcjjj against Cicotte in the series, three others were chalked up against
Pitcher Claude 'Lefty' Williams becomes the third White Sox player to confess before the Cook County grand jury, detailing how Chick Gandil recruited him and naming gamblers Sport Sullivan and Brown as fixers. The grand jury immediately returned indictments against the gamblers, and prosecutors say they now have sufficient evidence against all players and gamblers involved.
The Beatrice Daily Express · 29 September 1920 · page 1
TELL STORY OF BRIBERY; PLAYERS CONFESS SHARE IN FIXING OF SERIES; INDICT THREE GAMBLERS
Throwing Was Open. So openly and so notoriously waa the attempted prostitution of the world's series carried out that before the first ball was pitched hundreds believed that the thing was fixed and that the gambler at last had succeeded in corrupting the sport which had been considered Incorrup tible. It was my -mJafortaae to bo com pelled to reveal the truth concerning the playing of the series. The s-tgbt that the wschFa se ries etsded and Ctaade WUttems lest the steal game im the first limine I wrote in the Kl Paso Herald.
See moreSee less
Tsui are seven e-f the Chicago White Sax who win not he eta the team next apring." My anthorfty was charie ACeemiskey. evener of the tease, who then believed that his team had a-een eetsapted. Ls ter. on advice at trie-Ms and Ms lawyer, aad tarsi by denbtt-, he sJlewed all aare one ta retsrn to the teasa. But for the catching of two fierce line drives the Beds would have scored early and often in the last game. Yet not a score waa regts t ttred until the fourth inning. In the irst half of that inning with runners -n second and third for Chicago, Gon dii acted as if he waa afraid he might hit the ball safely. Ha choked his bat and iabbed st the ball for an easy out. In the P.eds half of the fourth -tviUisms issued bwo passes and Rousch slapped a hit part eecond which Risberg almost reached. Felsch (Tabbed the ball and hurled it use lessly toward the plate. The Bads got three runs. Only the great flew ,ng of Eddie Collina prevented them from getting more. chalk Begins Fighting. That night there waa a clash which killed the last hopes of the White .Sox or the honest ones among them. Rav Schalk. the greatsst and earnest ' .ttls catcher in the business fighting wKh very ounce of nerve in his body and desperats over defeat. Informed manager Gleason In detail as to what iiad happened. He told Gleason that -epeatedly. In the opening game of tbi series. Cicotte had pitched straight balls with "nothing on them" whan he had signaled for shiners or curves He .aid that In the decisive inning of he second game the fonrth -Williams had "crossed him" four times, pitching straight balls when he or dered curves. x "How many times has ne crossed vou this season?" Gleason demanded. "Not once during the year." Shalk. that evening, in cor rooms told several of tn that things looked bad. Ke told us about what he had told Gleason. He had already act-used two ball players of crooked ivork to their faces, and yet refused to charge them publicly with trying !o lose the series. That night a boaeh of gamMers aad sports, drwak. walked threagh the crowded le-sby of the Mate. siagiagt They are alveary throwing ban
Clipping to come
Hickory Daily Record · Hickory, N.C.
Chicago authorities report additional confessions from White Sox players expected soon, while Brooklyn DA Lewis investigates a separate rumor that gamblers plan to fix the 1920 World Series. Gleason recounts how Cicotte's confession to Comiskey triggered the indictments, with new evidence implicating former Giants players and eastern gamblers.
Hickory Daily Record · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CHICAGO By tho Associated Press. j Chicago, Sept. 29. Further confes sions by some of the seven White Sox players who, with one former player, were indicted yesterday in connection with the alleged throwing of the 1919 world series will be ma le within a day or two. Alfred S. Austrian, at torney for the club, announced today. It has bcn rumored that at least two of the seven were anxious to supplement the confessions of Edd:3 Cicotts and Joe Jackson that they were bribed to lose games. True Bills naming three ball play ers not members" of the White Sox and three gamblers were expected to be voted today by the grand jury.
See moreSee less
Members of the jury said they had sufficient evidence. It was reported that true bills against two National League play ers were being considered. Williams "Kid" Gleason, manager cf the White Sox, . disposed today the march of events which culmi nated in Cicotte's confession and the voting of indictments, Last Monday, according to Glea son, he had gathered enough evidence to knew that some of the players had been bribed to lose the series. Ci cotte came to him Monday night and declared he had "a load on his chest," according to Gleason. Gleason told him to see Commy Charles Comiskey, owner of the Sox. Comiskey heard Cicotte's testimony which tallied with the evidence gath ered by Austrian, his attorney, and told him to take the confession to the chief justice of the Cook criminal court. The confession and .'the in dictment followed.
Following Eddie Cicotte's confession about finding bribe money under his pillow before the opening World Series game, a Chicago grand jury has indicted seven White Sox players, with jury foreman Harry Brigman stating evidence implicates gamblers, former players Hal Chase, Heine Zimmerman and Lee Magee, and unnamed National League players. Separately, a Cincinnati grand jury will convene Monday to investigate Cicotte's bribery claims from that city.
Hickory Daily Record · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The indictment of his seven play ers cost Charles Comiskey. owner of the White Sox, $230,000. the amount for which he could have sold them for. Mr. Comiskey said.
A deputy commissioner of internal revenue stated that if investigation reveals Chicago White Sox players received money for throwing the 1919 World Series and fail to report it for tax purposes, prosecutions will follow. A related note mentions investigators were working to identify the gamblers and go-betweens who bribed the players.
Hickory Daily Record · 29 September 1920 · page 1
By" the Associated Press. Washington, Sept. 29 Should an investigation disclose tbt the Chi cago White Sox players who receiv ed money for "throwing" the 1919 world series fail to make a return to the internal revenue bureau on these funds for puurposes of taxes, prosecutions will be institutec', it was said today by Geo. C. Newton, deputy commissioner of internal rev enue, said today.
Lefty Williams testified before the Chicago grand jury, confessing his role in throwing the 1919 World Series and naming Chick Gandil as the team's go-between with gamblers Sullivan and Brown. He said he received $10,000, of which he personally gave $5,000 to Jackson, contradicting earlier reports that Jackson simply found money on his bed.
The Bismarck Tribune · 29 September 1920 · page 1
RUSH TO CONFESS ABOUT THROWING OF GAMES
Chicago, Sept. 29.—Identity of tin alleged go-between and gamblers who bribed White Sox players w.as reveai ed in a confession made to the gram jury by Claude "Lefty" Williams, whi joined Cicotte and Jackson in making a clean breast of the "throwing"- oi the 1919 world series. Williams named "Sport" Jacksoi and a gambler named Brown, both ol Boston, as two of toie principals ii the deal. He said that he receivei $10,000 for his iiart in throwing thi series, $5,000 of, which amount he gave to Jackson. Williams declared he personally paid the $5,000 to Jackson.
See moreSee less
His testi mony being at variance with previom reports that Jackson testified hi found the money on his bed. Williams, before making his state ment, signed a waiver of immunity Williams named Chick Gandil, for iner White Sox player, against whon. a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team am. Brown and Sullivan, gamblers, as go betweens for the gamblers. The jury immediately voted trut bills for brown and Sullivan. Williams said he was supposed ti get $20,000 and Jackson the same bu. that he received only $10,000, half ol which he gave to Jackson. He sail Gandil told him that Bill Burns, vet eran pitcher and Abe Attell, forme: prizefighter, were fixing it for the So* players, to ,get $100,000. The details of the charges agains the eight White Sox players'againsi whom true bills were voted yesterdaj have not been completed, According ti assistant state's attorney Reologle. Pending this action, he said, the true bills alleged but one offense "conspiracy to'commit art illegal act. An official of the court said that unde, this heading charges might be drawi that were punishable on conviction imprisonment up to five years or fines up to $10,000. Pitcher Cicotte was quoted in Chi cago papers today as saying "he wa worried about the status of basebal bribes in income tax returns." True bills naming three ball player: not members of the White Sox am three gamblers are expected to be voted today by the grand jury. Mem hers of the jury said this morninc they had sufficient evidence on whic) to base indictments. It was reported that true bills against two National League players are being considered Cost $230,000 Indictment of his seven players co-u Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, $230,000, the amount for which he could have sold their ser vices, he said today. The grand jury today sent a telegram to Eugene Du buc, of the Toledo team of the Amer .lean Association, ofrmerly with the Tigers and the Giants, asking him to appear Monday. Evidence already placed before th" grand jury, it is known, involves Abe Attell, former prize fighter Lee Ma gree, Hal Chase, and Heine Zimmer man, former members of the Giants' three eastern gamblers whose names have not been divulged and at least two national league players. Hartley Reoplogle, assistant state's attorney, who today confirmed these facts, ad mitted that 10 or 12 indictments were in prospect. It is reported here today that Eddie Cicotte had gone to Detroit. Efforts to find him have failed. Players Only Tools The eight players indicted are "ap parently only tools of a gambling ring," according to Harry Brigham. foreman of the grand jury. The rami fications of this ring, he s£id, extend everywhere that professional baseball is known. "It is evident that some of these boys yielded to the influence of those whose names will appear in the list (Continued on Page Six) ^T T7
Lefty Williams testified before the grand jury, naming Chick Gandil as the players' go-between and Bill Burns and Abe Attell as organizing the gamblers' side, claiming he received only $10,000 of a promised $20,000. The grand jury voted true bills against Williams, Gandil, and other players and gamblers, with more indictments of players and gamblers expected, and Comiskey estimated his loss at $230,000.
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight members of the White Sox for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series against Cincinnati. The indictments came after pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified and told the jury what he knew about the fix.
The Devils Lake World · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Albuquerque Morning Journal · Albuquerque, N.M.
A Cook County grand jury returned true bills against seven current and one former Chicago White Sox player over an alleged conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series for gambler money. Comiskey suspended the seven current players, and confessions reportedly came from two players, including Joe Jackson admitting he 'tapped' balls deliberately.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 2
: With Alleged Gambling. 1T MO.NIN. JOUHNAL .MCIM. LIUI1 WIHt Chicago, Sept. 28 by the Asso ciated Presa.) Indictments were voted against eight baseball stars today and confessions obtained from two of thera, when the Old Roman, Charles A. Comlskey, owner of the oft-time champion Chicago White Sox, smashed his pennant chasing machine to clean up baseball. The confessions told how the Sox threw last year's world's championship to Cincinnati for money paid by gamblers. Seven Sox regulars and on former player had true bills voted against them by the Cook county grand Jury and the seven were im mediately suspended by Mr.
See moreSee less
Comls key. With his team only half a game behind the league leading Cleveland Indians, the White Sox owner served notice on his seven stars that If they were found guilty, he would drive them out of organ ized baseball for the rest of their lives. Jackson "Tapped the Hall" Officials of Chief Justice Charles McDonald's court, desirous of giv ing the national game the benefit of publicity in its purging, lifted the curtain on the grand Jury proceed ings sufficiently to show a great hitter, Joe Jackson declaring that he deliberately Just tapped the ball, a picture of one of the world's most famous pitchers, Cicotte, in team, and glimpses of alleged bribe of $5,000 or $10,000 discovered un der pillows, or in beds by famous athletes about to retire. Around the court room at one time or another were somo of base ball's greatest leaders, among them John J. McOraw, manager of the New York Giants, awaiting a call to testify tomorrow; and John Heydler, president of the National league, who went before the grand umrs this cfternoon. . The exact nature of the Informa tion Mr. Comiskey put before the grand Jury was not disclosed. The r.ien whom the Jury involved as a jvsult of testimony uncovered by their owner were: . Tho Men Indicted.
The grand jury returns indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series, with pitcher Eddie Cicotte tearfully confessing to accepting a $10,000 bribe and deliberately pitching poorly. Owner Charles Comiskey suspends the implicated players, including Jackson, Weaver, Felsch, Risberg, Williams, Gandil, and McMullin, while league officials await their own testimony.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 2
stop. Claude Williams, pitcher. George "Buck" 'Weaver, third : baseman. . Fred . McMulHn. utility player.. While the grand Jurors voted " their true bills the Old Roman, i neated In the midst of his crumbling empire out at White Sox park, Is sued the telegram suspending those involved, paid off Weaver, Cicotte and Jackson on the spot and an nounced that checks for pay due the others would be sent them at once. With his voice trembling Mr. Comlskey, who has owned the White Sox since the Inception of the American league, said this was the first time scandal had ever touched his "family" and that it distressed him too much to talk about It.
Cicotte testified before the grand jury, tearfully confessing he deliberately lost games after accepting $10,000 from gamblers, detailing specific errors he made intentionally. He and Jackson were briefly detained after testifying, and Cicotte corroborated Maharg's account of the fix, naming Gandil as a key figure.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 2
Tell Stories In Detail. Both Cicotte and Jackson were closeted with the grand Jury for a considerable time today and later court officials reported that they told their stories in substantial de tail. As they left the room they were taken In custody by detectives of the state's attorney's office and taken away. Their detention waB not in the nature of an arrest and it was announced that they would be released later. Cicotte, who earlier In the clay had vehemently denied any part in the alleged plot, as described by Maharg at Philadelphia, admittol on the stand officials of the court said, that the Phliadelphlan's story was substantially correct.
See moreSee less
The court official also quoted Cicotte as saying that the players had believed that "Chick" Oandil who, he said, was interested iti the dealings with the gamblers, had. double-crossed" them and that Maharg's story was the first Inti mation they had that Attell hnd "held out" on the $100,000 which had been promised them.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte confessed he found bribe money under his pillow after losing the World Series opener, prompting a Hamilton County grand jury to investigate. A related item reports Brooklyn's district attorney also investigating alleged attempts to bribe Brooklyn players in the upcoming World Series against Cleveland.
The Evening World · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CINCINNATI JURY TAKES UP SCANDAL
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Evening World · New York, N.Y.
Pitcher Lefty Williams becomes the third White Sox player to confess, telling the grand jury of the bribery conspiracy and naming the gamblers involved. The Cook County Grand Jury indicts gamblers Sport Sullivan and 'Brown' on conspiracy charges, with officials stating they now have all evidence needed to prosecute all players and gamblers involved.
The Evening World · 29 September 1920 · page 1
WILLIAMS CONFESSES $5,000 BRIBE TO FIX BALL GAME; JURY INDICTS 2 GAMBLERS
JURY IN PROBE Chicago wOet.o i.gO.—The special grand Jury' investigating the base ball scandal yesterday received evi dence indicating that a gambling "ring" had planned to "fix" another world's series in addition to the 1919 one between Cincinnati and Chicago, but that the plans were never carried out, -according to Hartley Replogle, "assistant state's attorney in charge of th*1 ino'iiry. Mr. Replogle refused to say what world series it was. The jury heard further evidence concerning the activities of Hal Chase wftjle in the major leagues,,delved into the baseball pools conducted in Chi-, cago, and also interested itself in the proposed reorganization of baseball as outlined at the meeting yesterday ofthe eight National league club owners and representatives of three American league clubs.
See moreSee less
Ban Johnson, American ^league president, and John Heydler, Na tional league head, were the chief witnesses. Other high baseball offi cials called to testify were excused. Johnson was said to, have presen ted new evidence concerning gam bling which he has gathered in the last few weeks in New York and other cities. The jurors questioned Mr. Johnson concerning the proposal of baseball reorganization, but he re plied that "he knew nothing about it."
Clipping to come
The Sun and the New York Herald · New York, N.Y.
Billy Maharg, a confessed participant in the fix, gives new details claiming Abe Attell was the real culprit who cheated both the players and Maharg himself out of money. He also explains that White Sox utility player McMullin was not originally part of the scheme but forced his way in after overhearing players discussing it.
The Sun and the New York Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 1
ABE ATTELL IS BLAMED
ijt'ilcon arrived yesterday from Sacnmrnto. Calif., at the request of ihe American League president. His connection with the 191 !> series had horn under investigation, and Johnrom?o?t<vd the iurv to withhold action until Gedeon had ?*i chance to appear. Gedeon agreed to sign an immunity waiver. When questioned by Judge Charles A. MacDonald and Assistant States Attorney Hartley Replogle. Gedeon denied any direct knowledge of the
Clipping to come
The Sun and the New York Herald · New York, N.Y.
White Sox owner Charles Comiskey issued a statement indefinitely suspending seven players named in grand jury indictments—Risberg, McMullin, Jackson, Felsch, Weaver, Williams, and Cicotte—for their alleged role in fixing the 1919 World Series. He stated that innocent players would be reinstated but guilty ones banned for life, even though the suspensions could cost Chicago the pennant.
The Sun and the New York Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Sun and the New York Herald · New York, N.Y.
Cicotte testified he refused to pitch until paid, finding cash under his pillow at a Cincinnati hotel as prearranged with gamblers; Jackson similarly described receiving payoff money the same way. The Grand Jury returned indictments against all eight accused White Sox players, with prosecutors naming Gandil as the bribe distributor and promising more indictments of gamblers to come.
The Sun and the New York Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Arnold Rothstein of New York. Joe i Gedeon. second baseman of the St j IIs Browns, and H. G. Redmond, i theatrical manager of East St. Louis, j were the star witnesses yesterday, ; Rothstein repeated the story of how i
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
The Chicago state attorney's office announced three gamblers will be indicted on conspiracy charges related to bribing 1919 White Sox players, following the grand jury's indictment of eight team members the day before. The investigation is expanding, with anonymous letters prompting scrutiny of the 1914 World Series and reports of a gambling clique planning similar schemes with other teams.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Games and Players l Br United Press CHICAGO, Sept. 29. The state at torney's office today announced that three gamblers will be indicted on charges of conspiracy in connection with bribing the 1919 World Series baseball players. These indictments are expected to be voted today by the grand jury which yesterday indicted eight members of the White Sox club. Assistant State Attorney Replogle, in charge of the investigation, said he has received many anonymous letters ask ing him to probe the 1914 series be tween Philadelphia and Boston. In quiry has also begun into reports of gambling clique plans to attempt to
A Chicago grand jury indicted gamblers 'Sport' Sullivan of Boston and a man named Brown, accused of conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series. The indictments followed a full confession from Pitcher Williams, the third of eight indicted White Sox players to confess.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 1
j bribe the players on the Brooklyn team to drop the World Series. Gamblers Indicted IBy United Press CHICAGO, Sept. 29. The grand jury today indicted the gamblers alleg ed to have been connected with the conspiracy by which the White Sox are said to have thrown last year's World Series to Cincinnati. The in dictments name "Short" Sullivan of Boston, and a man named Brown. These two were accused today in a complete confesion made by Pitcher Will iams, the third of the eighth in dicted players to confess. volunteering their quota, as cards in dicating their subscription are being collected.
See moreSee less
One of the pleasing incidents is the subscription of the Golden Hotel of Reno. Application No. 1 for a unit subscription was received from the Golden management, which is appre ciated. By tonight some idea of the working results will be available, for if by that time tlie subscriptions pass the 50 per cent mark the committee feels that it is over the summit. From all indications this week is going to make the quota look like a real budget for a Greater Carson.
The Cook County grand jury resumed its investigation into the baseball scandal that already led to the indictment of eight White Sox stars. Team owner Comiskey and manager Gleason are assembling replacement players to finish the 1920 season despite losing key stars like Buck Weaver.
The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · 29 September 1920 · page 1
IN BASE BALL
ML . indicted are: Ball Fixed High. uie Cicotte, Joe jaeiiaon, (Williams, Fred McMulIm, i Weaver, Oscar ieiscn ana fees Risberg, White Sox playArnold 'CChick Qandll, WilBurns, former white Sox fcrs; Hal Lnase, iormer new Giant: Abe Atlell, former ; Joseph "Sport" Sullivan of i and Rachael Brown of New Bel Justice McDonald anIced that he would fix bp.il at ) on each Indictment or
Clipping to come
The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · Bucyrus, Ohio
With indicted players barred, the White Sox discuss replacement lineups for Weaver and others while Comiskey receives sympathy and player offers from rival owners Ruppert, Huston, and Frazee. Cicotte's tearful grand jury confession is detailed, describing how Risberg, Gandil, and McMullin recruited him and how the players were double-crossed after fixing games.
The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · 29 September 1920 · page 1
) on each Indictment or Ifor each of those named, e conspiracy indictment conI five counts, including charges niipiraey to obtain money unpretenses and to injure b.iiitss of the Chicago AmerI league baseball club. fcotte, Jackson and Williams fed to the grand jury they accepted bribes to lose the i last year, and named the r ;is icirnes to the plot. (tradition papers have been 1 by the state's attorney for. thirteen and efforts will be I immediately, it was announ. I to obtain their return to ChiAttell is reported to be in ; Cicotte in Detroit; Qandll teas; Jackson and Weaver In 1 Carolina' and the wherefctsof the othere is not definitesown to the state's atorney.
Clipping to come
The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · Bucyrus, Ohio
Cicotte told the grand jury how Gandil, Risberg and McMullin organized the fix and how he deliberately threw games, while Jackson described muffing catches and misdirecting throws to help Cincinnati win. Both players signed immunity waivers and are expected to testify for the state at trial.
The Bucyrus Evening Telegraph · 29 September 1920 · page 1
past.” Loyal Five Meet Today. Directors of the American league met here today to decide whether they will accept the Lasker plan providing for reorganization of base ball, or whether five of its member ship will array themselves against the 11 other major league clubs. Refusal of the five clubs to join with the other 11 owners was ex pected to precipitate a baseball war. Intimations were made today that a counter-proposition will be offered by the five “loyal” American league clubs. None of the magnates who have not joined in the proposed plan for reorganization has expressed opposi tion to it.
See moreSee less
Several have said they favored reorganization of some kind when taken up at a “regularly called meeting of the league in ac cordance with the league’s constitu tion,” maintaining that the previous conference was not of that nature.
Clipping to come
The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.
The Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix heard testimony implicating gamblers Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein, with more player indictments expected. Eddie Cicotte testified that eight players were promised $80,000 but were double-crossed, detailing the amounts actually paid to himself, Jackson, Williams and others.
The Daily Ardmoreite · 29 September 1920 · page 1
MORE PLAYERS TO BE INDICTED FOR BASEBALL SCANDAL - GROWS AS TALES OF BRIBERY ARE TOLD BY ONES WHO THREW SERIES
Evidence of Fixing in Cub-Philly Game CHICAGO — Reopening of the probe of crooked baseball by the Cook county grand jury, which' was scheduled to Return indictments of bah niftyers and gamblers in con nection with the fixed 1919 world series, today is threatened by report ed discovery by President Ban Johnson of che American league, of alleged crookedness in the National league. Johnson was said to have new evidence in connection with the Aug. 31 game between the Cubs and Philadelphia hud beep obtained. This was the game on which gam blers were said to have wagered heavy pools.
See moreSee less
Charges were made at the time that the gafne was fixed. The new evidence, it was said, will show through files of a tele graph company that a Cub player wired a friend to bet on the Phil lies for that game.
Clipping to come
The Daily Ardmoreite · Ardmore, Okla.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified before the grand jury that eight White Sox players were promised $80,000 to throw the 1919 World Series but were double-crossed, with only Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams actually receiving money. The report details the alleged payment split among players and describes Joe Jackson's tearful confession to reporters as he left the grand jury room.
The Daily Ardmoreite · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Several White Sox players denied involvement in fixing the 1919 World Series after Eddie Cicotte's confession became public. Cicotte detailed how Gandil, Risberg, and McMullin approached him before the series, and how he used $4,000 in payoff money to cover a farm mortgage.
Pitcher Claude Williams becomes the third White Sox player to confess to throwing the 1919 World Series, naming Chick Gandil as the go-between with gamblers Sullivan and Brown. The Chicago grand jury returns true bills against the gamblers, while New York authorities separately investigate a new bribery plot targeting the Brooklyn Nationals for the upcoming World Series.
East Oregonian : E.O · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CLIQUE CROOKEDNESS IN TEAMS MAY BE BARED
Gamblers Kntanglcd.' CHICAGO, Sept. -29. U. P.) Three gamblers will be Indicted today on charges of conspiracy in connection Ith "fixed" 1919 series. Assistant United States Attorney Rep'osle an nounced today. He refused to dis close their names and said that three other players, none of whom are con nected with the White Sox will be connected with the affair. Other of fers to confess connection with the "fixed" series have been made, Jt waa announced. Officials announced they had suf ficient evidence, apparently obtained from the confessions of Clcolte and Jackson. White Sox stars, to obtain ind ctments of gamblers in New Tork. Chicago Cincinnati. St. Ixiuia, Detroit.
Pitcher Claude Williams becomes the third White Sox player to confess, admitting he received $10,000 and naming Chick Gandil as the team's go-between with gamblers Bill Burns, Abe Attell, Brown, and Sullivan. Chicago authorities announce grand jury indictments against the gamblers and expect further player confessions.
East Oregonian : E.O · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
East Oregonian : E.O · Pendleton, Or.
Following confessions from Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson, officials announced sufficient evidence to seek indictments of gamblers in multiple cities, with further player confessions expected soon. The investigation also expanded to include a former pitcher questioned about National League gambling and allegations reaching back to the 1914 World Series.
East Oregonian : E.O · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Baseball Scandal Chicago, Oct. 20—Two indictments charging 13 persons with operating a confidence game and conspiracy were re turned in court today by the grand jury investigating the baseball scandal. Seven members of the Chicago White Sox, three former ball players, a boxer and two gamblers were named in the true bills voted recently. The charges grew out of the alleged "fixing" of last year's world's series between the White Sox and Cincinnati.
Clipping to come
Capital Journal · Salem, Or.
Pitcher Claude 'Lefty' Williams told the grand jury that Chick Gandil acted as the players' go-between with gamblers named Brown and Sullivan, and that he was shorted on his promised bribe money, giving part of it to Joe Jackson. The jury indicted Brown and Sullivan and expected more indictments of players and gamblers, with attorney Alfred Austrian predicting further confessions soon.
Capital Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Further Confessions of Players Involved Are Promised; Alleged Plot to "Frame" Series Investigated in New York; Cleveland Court Also Takes Hand
U Named by Grand Jury. Chicago, Oct. 29. Two indict ments charging 13 persons with op erating a confidence game and con spiracy were returned in court to day by the grand jury investigating the base rail scandal. . Seven members of the Chicago White Sox, three former base ball players, a boxer xnd two gamblers were named in t'ne true bills voted recently, t The charges grew out of the al leged "fijeing" of last year's world's series between the White Sox and Cincinnati. , ' Those indicted are: Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, Claude Williams, Fred McMullin, George Weaver,'- William Burns, Oscar Felsch and , Charles , Risberg.
See moreSee less
White Sox players; - Arnold "Chick" Gandil. former White Sox player; Hal Chase, former New York Giants; Abe ' Attel, former boxer; Joseph "Sport" Sullivan of Boston; and Rachael Brown 'of New York: The conspiracy indictment con tains five counts, including charges . of conspiracy to obtain money under false, pretenses and to injure the business of the Chicago American league base ball club. Three Confess. v ' Cicotte, Jackson and Williams Confessed to the grand jury they had accepted bribes to lose the series' last year, and named the oth ers as parties to the plot. Extradition papers have been pre pared by the state's attorney for the 13 and efforts will be made im mediately, it was announced, to ob tain their return' to Chicago. At ten is reported to be In Canada; Cicotte in Detroit, Gandil in Texas, Jackson and Weaver in North Caro lina. . T.r Mill against three owners of base Mil pool were voted today by the special trend Jury Investigatingbase bell. Owner of tbe Oreat Western. Universal end American-National pool are named In the -bills., 411 are Chicago men. Chief Justice McDonald announced that he would tlx ball at $5,000 on each Indict, men or 10,00(TTor each of those named. To Meet Again Not. S. Investigation of the pools resulted from numerous complaints received by the rand jury from men holding winnings, who were unable to collect ond their slips. The special grand Jury adjourned late today until November (, when it will b dissolved unites further evidence Is brought up for consideration. Those against 'whom true bills were voted today arei. -. 'William Chellue. Martin Carlln and F. C Walters, all of Chicago, While ths grand jurors were returning the. Indictment before Chief Juetice Charles A. McDonald. Ban Johnson, presi dent of th American league, turned over to , Assistant Stats' Attorney Hartley Ireplogl a letter from a Kansas City sport ing, editor alleging that "Frog" Thompson, I Kansas City gamt!r( received a. tele Irani, from Claud Itendrli, Chicago1 Cub tft advising, him to ''bet 11,000 on th opposition" In rke game between Phila delphia, and Chicago her August 2. , It ; Wag the circumstance surrounding the Cuba defeat on that data that started the base ball gambling Investigation. The Kansas City letter also alleges that Thomp son received a telegram from Hal Chase, who was then In California, confirming IhJ Bendrlz mesage.
Clipping to come
Capital Journal · Salem, Or.
The Chicago grand jury is expected to indict two National League players and three gamblers, with Pitcher Eddie Cicotte testifying that only he, Jackson, and Williams actually received money from the promised $80,000 bribe. Related wire stories report a new investigation into a possible plot to fix the 1920 World Series and federal scrutiny of unpaid income taxes on the Black Sox bribe money.
Capital Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CICOTTE SAYS GAMBLERS PAID ONLY PART OF $80,000 THEY PROMISED CHICAGO PLAYERS
men or 10,00(TTor each of those named. To Meet Again Not. S. Investigation of the pools resulted from numerous complaints received by the rand jury from men holding winnings, who were unable to collect ond their slips. The special grand Jury adjourned late today until November (, when it will b dissolved unites further evidence Is brought up for consideration. Those against 'whom true bills were voted today arei. -. 'William Chellue. Martin Carlln and F. C Walters, all of Chicago, While ths grand jurors were returning the. Indictment before Chief Juetice Charles A.
See moreSee less
McDonald. Ban Johnson, presi dent of th American league, turned over to , Assistant Stats' Attorney Hartley Ireplogl a letter from a Kansas City sport ing, editor alleging that "Frog" Thompson, I Kansas City gamt!r( received a. tele Irani, from Claud Itendrli, Chicago1 Cub tft advising, him to ''bet 11,000 on th opposition" In rke game between Phila delphia, and Chicago her August 2. , It ; Wag the circumstance surrounding the Cuba defeat on that data that started the base ball gambling Investigation. The Kansas City letter also alleges that Thomp son received a telegram from Hal Chase, who was then In California, confirming IhJ Bendrlz mesage.
Clipping to come
Capital Journal · Salem, Or.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte tearfully told the grand jury he deliberately threw games, confessing to lobbing pitches so batters could hit them, and named the payment amounts promised to eight players. Joe Jackson also confessed, admitting it to a crowd of young fans outside the grand jury room, while teammates Weaver and Williams denied involvement.
Capital Journal · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
The report notes that a Cook County grand jury was expected to return true bills against three White Sox players and three gamblers. It also mentions consideration of indictments involving National League players, amid the unrelated Bergdoll conspiracy verdict coverage.
Evening Public Ledger · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
Reports from the Chicago grand jury describe testimony by Eddie Cicotte and Claude Williams detailing how the $68,000 bribe was split among the eight White Sox players, with specific dollar amounts listed for each man. Williams reportedly named gamblers 'Sport' Sullivan and Brown as go-betweens and said he gave $5,000 of his own money to Joe Jackson.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Evening Public Ledger · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CLAUDE WILLIAMS RECEIVED $5000 FROM WHITE SOX PITCHER TELLS GRAND JURY HE GAVE SIMILAR SUM TO JACKSON
! shoulders above other teams In the (conference this year. Wyoming lost Its f’.rst game to the Aggies by two touchdowns and then dropped the sec ond battle. "But Coach Corbett and the Wyom ing state institution has turned out an eleven that has defeated the Colorado Miners, Nebraska Wesleyan, Denver I University. The team has lost only ! by a scant margin to both the Tigers • ami Colorado state. ••Corbett, had the ‘makings’ of a great team last season and this fall ihe has rounded his old material to gether with his greener timber —well, ,it will be an unforgivable offense if the conference officials leave the small Wyoming state institution out i in the cold again this year.
See moreSee less
I "Course there may be a reason for I passing up Wyoming. Back in the 'Missouri Valley conference, Oklahoma tried for many seasons to get into the I conference. Hardly more than a sea -1 son ago, the University of Oklahoma finally was admitted. This season, ■ Oklahoma is giving a fair example of what It is doing in athletics. Oklahoma already has defeated Kansas and Missouri, generally con sidered the best in the valley with 'Nebraska kicked out because it would not behave. And the Sooners turned Ibe trick in each instance by decisive scores. .'Nobody expects Wyoming to set the world afire as soon as Oklahoma did. lierause the state* university is too small an institution at the pres lent But the conference powers will pass up a good bet by not admitting the Cowboys. Layman, the fast backfield man of I the University of Wyoming eleven, is developing into a real football star. His end runs and open field sprints were sensations in the Colorado Col lego game and figured fundamentally in the scores there.” — — i
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
Pitcher Lefty Williams gave a full statement to the grand jury, naming 'Sport' Sullivan and a gambler named Brown as principals, and said he received $10,000, giving $5,000 to Jackson. Comiskey received an outpouring of sympathetic letters and telegrams, and Gleason described how he gathered evidence leading to Cicotte's confession and the indictments.
Evening Public Ledger · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Chioasro. Nov. 23. Record of the old National baseball commission have hern transferred from Cincinnati to ( hicnco in preparation for the opening of oftlrcs here for .fudge I.andis as ruler of the major league. One of Jiidjre Landis first decisions, it is expected, will relate to , the di vision of about $15,000 among mem bers of the White Sox team which earned second place money in the lfWQ race. Strong opposition lias arisen in some quarters to Hip proposal to ex clude from Bhare , the seven former White Sox players under indictment for participation in "throwing" the 1919 world's series.
Clipping to come
Evening Public Ledger · Philadelphia, Pa.
A grand jury investigation led to Cicotte's confession detailing how White Sox players conspired to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati for money, resulting in indictments. Teammates not implicated expressed suspicion that the same players also sabotaged the 1920 pennant race, describing suspicious slumps and poor play during a crucial road trip.
Evening Public Ledger · 29 September 1920 · page 15
than suspicious. , "It may as well bo suited that some of us believe ever since the last world's itrits that we were B61d by Cicotte and ethers. "Well, wncn mc sumo men we sus
White Sox players like Dick Kerr, John Collins, and Red Faber describe their suspicions that teammates threw the 1919 World Series and recent games, citing poor play on an eastern road trip. Eddie Cicotte's grand jury confession is quoted, detailing how Gandil and McMullin recruited him, how the eight players agreed to throw the series, and how he demanded $10,000 in cash in advance due to financial need.
Evening Public Ledger · 29 September 1920 · page 15
"fled Fnber. veteran pitcher, who tried Ms club to victory in tho 1017 world's series, said the playing of the jox on the eastern trip made ROino of :he others believe something was oolrd. "It looks like we were double- :ro!ied In the world's series lost, and
The grand jury foreman says the indicted players were 'tools' of a wide-reaching gambling ring and expresses sympathy for the 'unsophisticated country boys' who were corrupted. Comiskey discloses the sale value he placed on seven indicted players, totaling $230,000, as the investigation into baseball gambling continues.
Evening Public Ledger · 29 September 1920 · page 15
Charles A. Comlskcy, owner nf the White Sox, $.2.10,000, the amount for which he could have sold their bcrvlccs, he said today. The club owner fixed the valuation of the seven at:
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight White Sox players and prepared to indict three more, while NL president Heydler alleged a separate gambling clique operated in his league. Joe Jackson told reporters the White Sox played honestly in 1920, and Eddie Cicotte left Chicago after confessing to the 1919 fix.
The Madison Daily Leader · 29 September 1920 · page 1
ERS SAY. Sept. 2t—Three Ramblers will be indict ud today on charges of conspiracy in connection with the fix od 1919 world series by the Cook •county fcrand iury. which yesterday inukted ei^h't mor.ibcr» of the White So* ball club. Assistant States At torney Replogle refused to disclose the names, but said none are now in Chicago. He declared three other ball players, none of whom are con nected with the White Sox, will also be indicted. No umpires are sus pected, he said. John Heydler, pre sident of the national league, said he would present evidence to the grand jury that an entirely different clique of gamblers has operated in the na tional league.
See moreSee less
Heydler said the na tional league gamblers did not pay any fixed sums to players, but gave crooked players one-third of their winnings for throwing the games. Joe Jackson, one of the White Sox players, who confessed, told the United Press today, that the White Sox played honest baseball all this year. "We did everything we could to win the pennant," Jackson said. "As far as I know none of the play ers had anything to do with gamblers this year." Jean Debuc, former pitcher for the New York Nationals, now with the Toledo American as sociation club, was ordered to appear before the grand jury October 4. De buc may know something of gambl ing in the National league. The states attorney said, Eddie Cicotte, first of the WThite Sox players to make a clean breast of the conspir acy to throw the last world series to Cincinnati, hurriedly left Chicago to day. Presumably for his Michigan fur iu. York, 8ept. 29.—District At torney "Harry E. Lewfs, announced •that he will begin an immediate in vestigation of reports that gambling clique planned an attempt to bribe Brooklyn National league players to lose this years world series.
White Sox teammates describe how Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson seemed to deliberately play poorly, with pitchers grooving balls and fielders mishandling plays during a crucial road trip. Players say they suspected a second sellout beyond the 1919 World Series fix, and a grand jury is investigating gamblers who may have paid players, with more indictments possible.
The Chattanooga News · 29 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Think This Year's Race "Thrown" Too
Loyal Sox Players Discuss Work of Indicted Stars This Season.
See moreSee less
HAD PECULIAR SLUMP
Cicotte and Williams Lost Effectiveness—Jackson Failed to Hit in Pinches.
More Indictments.
Chicago, Sept. 29.—Twelve more indictments against ball players and gamblers probably will be voted today or tomorrow by the Cook county grand jury which yesterday indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox, according to a statement today by Harvey L. Replogle, assistant state's attorney, who is conducting the probe before the grand jury. Three eastern gamblers and two baseball players on national league teams are said to be among those facing indictment.
Chicago, Sept. 29.—Charges that some of the same players who are accused of "throwing" the world's series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennant winners this season, were made today by several members of the Chicago White Sox, who have not been mentioned in the grand jury testimony.
One player, who refused to allow his name to be used, made the following statement:
"When we started on our last eastern trip we had every reason to believe we would win the pennant. Suddenly Williams and Cicotte seemed to go bad without any reason. Some of us talked it over and agreed it looked like they were grooving the ball.
"Then Jackson, Felsch and Risberg began dumping the ball to the infield every time they came to bat when we had a chance to get runs.
"We thought at first it might be just a batting slump. But when some of us compared notes regarding the pitching and hitting we became more than suspicious.
"It may as well be stated that some of us believe ever since the last world's series that we were sold out by Cicotte and others.
"Well, when the same men we suspected of crossing us at that time began to go bad on the last eastern trip we decided there must have been another sell out. However, we have never been able to prove this.
"Had we played anything like our regular game we would have come home with the pennant cinched. We all hope the grand jury will look into this end of the affair. If it fails to act we may take some action ourselves—if we can get hold of the players we feel sure did the cheating."
Collins Talks.
John Collins, veteran first baseman of the White Sox said:
"We are sorry in a way for the fellows who are caught in this jam, but we are glad everything is going to be shown up.
"We suspected some of them in the world's series and we suspected them again because of the way they played on the last eastern trip. Some of them not only didn't try, but really acted as though they didn't want to win. I have no idea what influenced their actions."
"Red" Faber, veteran pitcher, who carried his club to victory in the 1917 world's series, said the playing of the Sox on the eastern trip made some of the others believe something was crooked.
"It looks like we were double crossed in the world's series last year and in the pennant race this year, but we are not through yet.
"We will go to St. Louis with a ball team on which every man will be trying and we will fight to get into the world's series.
"If we land we will be sure of one thing—we will not have a Judas on the team when we go into the big series."
May Indict Gamblers.
Indictments against five or six gamblers were considered today by the Cook county grand jury investigating "throwing" of baseball games, according to Hartley Replogle, assistant assistant state's attorney, in charge of the inquiry. Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, and Arnold Rothstein, of New York, were said by Replogle to have been involved in testimony presented to the grand jury. Attell, it was said, handled the money paid White Sox players for "throwing" the 1919 world's series.
More ball players may be indicted, it was also indicated by Replogle, after the grand jury has heard the testimony of Presidents Johnson and Heydler, of the American and National leagues, who are to testify today. Copies of telegrams sent prior to and during the 1919 series by Hal Chase and Bill Burns, former major league players, have been obtained by Heydler for presentation to the grand jury.
John J. McGraw, manager of the Giants, also has been asked by the grand jury to appear today to tell about th[e] release of Hal Chase, Lee Magee and Heine Zimmerman by the Giants last year. Statements by several ball players in connection with the 1919 series have involved Chase in the deal by which gamblers are said to have paid eight White Sox players to "lay down" to the Cincinnati Reds.
According to Eddie Cicotte's confession before the grand jury, $80,000 was paid to the White Sox players, divided as follows: Eddie Cicotte, pitcher, $10,000; Claude Williams, pitcher, $10,000; Charles Risberg, shortstop, $10,000; "Buck" Weaver, third baseman, $5,000; Joe Jackson, left fielder, $5,000; "Happy" Felsch, centerfielder, $5,000; "Chick" Gandil, former first baseman, $20,000; Fred McMullin, utility player, $15,000.
Cicotte Cries.
With tears in his eyes, Cicotte told the grand jury how he had lobbed the ball up to the Cincinnati batters in the first game of the series "so they could read the trade mark on it."
Repenting after having thrown two games, he said, he pitched hard to win his third start. Either Gandil, whom Cicotte said first arranged the "throw," or Abe Attell, the go-between of the gamblers, got $75,000 which the eight players were to have received.
When Joe Jackson left the grand jury room after his confession, a crowd of small boys gathered around their heavy-hitting idol and asked: "It isn't true, is it, Joe?"
"Yes, boys, I'm afraid it is," Jackson replied.
Cicotte and Jackson were not promised immunity in return for their confessions, Replogle said, but are liable to prosecution the same as the other players named in the indictments returned.
The eight were suspended by President Comiskey, of the Sox, as soon as he had heard Cicotte's confession, and turned him over to the club's attorney, Alfred Austrian, to be taken before the grand jury.
Manager Gleason, of the Sox, declared the remaining members were still fighting in the pennant race and would start their closing three-game series at St. Louis Friday determined to do all they could to win in spite of the upheaval which took seven regulars out of the line-up.
Pair Off Mortgage.
"Risberg, Bandil and McMillin were at me for a week before the series started," Eddie Cicotte told the grand jury in his confession. "They wanted me to go crooked. I needed the money. I had the wife and kids. They don't know this and I don't know what they'll think.
"I had bought a farm. There was a $4,000 mortgage. I paid that off with crooked money.
"The eight of us—the eight under indictment— got together in my room three or four days before the series started. Gandil was master of ceremonies. We talked about throwing the series and decided we could get away with it. We agreed to do it.
"I was thinking of the wife and kids and how I needed the money. I told them I had to have the cash in advance. I didn't want any checks. I didn't want any promise. I wanted the money in bills before I pitched a ball.
"We all talked quite a while about it. Yes, all of us decided to do our best to throw the games to Cincinnati. Then Gandil and McMillin took us all one by one, away from the others and we talked turkey. They asked me my price. I told them $10,000 paid in advance.
"It was Gandil I was talking to. He wanted to give me some money at the time and the rest after the games were played and lost.
"'Cash in advance, not C. O. D.' I reminded him, 'If you cant trust me I cant trust you. Pay or I play ball.'
"Well, the argument went on for some days but I stood pat. I wanted that $10,000 and I got it.
"How I wish I had not.
"The day before I went to Cincinnati I put it up to them squarely for the last time there would be nothing doing unless I had the money.
SOLD OUT 'COMMY.'
"That night I found the money under my pillow. I had sold out 'Commy' and the other boys to pay of a mortgage on a farm and for the wife and kids.
"The first ball I pitched I wondered what the wife and kiddies would say if they ever found out I was a crook. I pitched the best ball I knew how after that first ball. But I lost because I was hit, not because I was throwing the game."
Joe Jackson described his confession to the grand jury as follows:
"I heard I had been indicted. I decided these men could not put anything over on me. I called up Judge McDonald (chief justice Charles A. McDonald of the superior court who directed the grand jury inquiry) and told him I was an honest man. He said 'I know you are not' and hung up the receiver.
"I figured somebody had squawked and that the place for me was the ground floor. I went to tell him what I knew.
Williams Confesses.
Identity of alleged go-betweens and gamblers who bribed White Sox players was revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude ("Lefty") Williams, who joined Cicotte and Jackson in making a clean breast of the 1919 world's series frame-up.
Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson the same, but that he received only $10,000, half of which he gave Jackson.
He said Gandil told him that Bill Burns, veteran pitcher, and Abe Attell, former prizefighter, were fixing it for the Sox players to get $100,000.
Williams named "Chick" Gandil, former White Sox player, against whom a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team, and "a Brown and Sullivan, gamblers," from either New York or Boston, as go-betweens for the gamblers.
The grand jury immediately voted true bills for Brown and Sullivan.
Williams named "Sport" Sullivan, a Bosotn gambler, and another Boston gambler named Brown as two of the principals in the deal. He said he received $10,000 for his part in throwing the series. Five thousand dollars of this amount he gave to Jackson, he said.
Williams declared he personally paid the $5,000 to Jackson, his testimony being at variance with previous reports.
Joe Jackson, who last night was in custody of a deputy sheriff, has been released and will leave tonight for his home in the south, it was learned today.
The report describes Eddie Cicotte's tearful confession to the Chicago grand jury, detailing how he and seven other White Sox players took bribes to throw the 1919 World Series. It lists the alleged payouts to each player and notes that Joe Jackson also confessed, with both men warned they still faced prosecution despite cooperating.
The Chattanooga News · 29 September 1920 · page 1
eral baU player in connection with tne 1919 series hav Involved Chase In the ileal by which gamblers are said to have paid eight White Sox players to lav down" to the Cincinnati Reds. According to Eddie Clcotte s eonres slon before the grand Jury. HO.Oftfl was paid to the White Sox Players, dlvl led :.s follows: Eddie Clcotte. Pjer, $10,
Joe Jackson described his grand jury confession, admitting he took money to help throw the 1919 World Series despite pitching his best after the first payoff. Lefty Williams also confessed, naming Chick Gandil as the players' go-between and gamblers Sullivan and Brown as financiers, and said he gave Jackson $5,000 of his own $10,000 payoff.
The Chattanooga News · 29 September 1920 · page 1
SOLD OUT 'COMMY'
knew. William Confess. Identity of alleged a-o-het gamblers who bribed White Sox plav ers was revealed in a confession made to the grand Jury today bv Claude ("Lefty") Williams, who inlned ri.mttn and Jackson In making a clean breast of the 1919 world's series frame-up. Williams said he .was supposed to got 2O,000 and Jackson the same, but that he received only $10,000, half of which he gave Jackaon. He said Oandll tod him that mil Burns, veteran pltnhar. aaaV-Alw ,AU1V former prlsefighter, Wr fixing ft "for the Sox players to get $100,1)00. Williams named "Chick" Oandll. for mer White Sox player, against whom a true nut was returned yesterday as
Claude 'Lefty' Williams confessed to the grand jury, joining Cicotte and Jackson in admitting the World Series was fixed, and named Chick Gandil as the go-between with gamblers Brown and Sullivan. The grand jury also considered indictments against gamblers including Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein, with more player confessions expected soon.
Brownsville Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CONFESSIONS EXPECTED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Brownsville Herald · Brownsville, Tex.
The Cook County grand jury considered indictments against gamblers including Abe Attel and Arnold Rothstein after testimony from Cicotte and Jackson, who confessed to the fix. Comiskey suspended the implicated players and paid off Weaver, Cicotte, and Jackson immediately, while a separate probe began in Brooklyn over fears of a new bribery plot.
Brownsville Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.
Cook county grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix heard testimony from pitcher Eddie Cicotte, who admitted selling out for $10,000 and said eight players were promised payment but only he, Jackson, and Williams actually received money. Gamblers Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein were named as being involved in handling the payoff money.
El Paso Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 10
Attempt To "Buy" Series Is Report; And Joe Jackson Tell Of "Framed" "I Sold Out Chicago and "Commy" for $10,000" Declares Premier Twirler; Risberg Scares Jackson
Chicago. Dec. 8. Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald seized tiie evi dence in the "baseball scandal follow ing discovery that copies ot papers iii the case had been obtained by MacLay Hoyne, state's attorney, shortly before his retirement from office on Monday. All. of the original papers were turned over to the judge, who order ed them impounded by the clerk until the cases of the eight White Sox players who were indicted come to trial. Judge Robert Crowe, wtfo succeeded Mr. Hoyne as state's attorney, or dered an investigation after Hartley Iteplogle, former assistant state's at torney, who, conducted the base ball investigation, notified Judge Mc Donald that Mr.
See moreSee less
Hoyne had demand ed copies of the papers last Friday. George T. Kenney, private secre tary to Mr. ,H(jyhe, ordered Mr. Rep logle to surrender the papers, the latter told the chief justice. Mr. Replogle' said he refused until Mr. Hoyne personally ordered the copics. Mr. Kenney said he gave the copies t( -"Mr. Hoyne's stenographer to be delivered to Mr. Hoyne at his home. Tliofnas E. Nash, attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicated on a charge of ac cepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 World's series, said that the original evidence was in court lfist Friday, as he had seen it at chat time. Mr. Hoyne said he had asked for the records Mmply to put them in the cass^in his office, for which lie i-efcp$isible, and that they were there ndwf sealed up. "Therfris no 'scandal' and nothing wrong," said Mr. Hoyne.
Clipping to come
El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte testified before the grand jury that eight White Sox players agreed to throw the 1919 World Series for payments ranging from $5,000 to $20,000 each, naming Gandil as the organizer and Abe Attell as the gamblers' go-between. Joe Jackson also testified and admitted to a crowd of boys outside that the fix rumors were true, while Comiskey suspended the players and Weaver reportedly denied wrongdoing.
El Paso Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 10
Chicago. Dec. 8. Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald seized tiie evi dence in the "baseball scandal follow ing discovery that copies ot papers iii the case had been obtained by MacLay Hoyne, state's attorney, shortly before his retirement from office on Monday. All. of the original papers were turned over to the judge, who order ed them impounded by the clerk until the cases of the eight White Sox players who were indicted come to trial. Judge Robert Crowe, wtfo succeeded Mr. Hoyne as state's attorney, or dered an investigation after Hartley Iteplogle, former assistant state's at torney, who, conducted the base ball investigation, notified Judge Mc Donald that Mr.
See moreSee less
Hoyne had demand ed copies of the papers last Friday. George T. Kenney, private secre tary to Mr. ,H(jyhe, ordered Mr. Rep logle to surrender the papers, the latter told the chief justice. Mr. Replogle' said he refused until Mr. Hoyne personally ordered the copics. Mr. Kenney said he gave the copies t( -"Mr. Hoyne's stenographer to be delivered to Mr. Hoyne at his home. Tliofnas E. Nash, attorney for George Weaver, one of the White Sox players indicated on a charge of ac cepting a bribe in connection with the 1919 World's series, said that the original evidence was in court lfist Friday, as he had seen it at chat time. Mr. Hoyne said he had asked for the records Mmply to put them in the cass^in his office, for which lie i-efcp$isible, and that they were there ndwf sealed up. "Therfris no 'scandal' and nothing wrong," said Mr. Hoyne.
Clipping to come
El Paso Herald · El Paso, Tex.
Cicotte's grand jury confession describes how Gandil, Risberg and McMullin recruited him days before the Series, and how he demanded $10,000 cash upfront due to financial desperation. Jackson and Williams spoke to reporters, while Weaver and Felsch denied any involvement, citing their own performance stats as proof of innocence.
El Paso Herald · 29 September 1920 · page 10
The procedure on the coast Is par- <?. ticuiarly interesting here because of ; theeffect it may have in the prosecu- ! tions of the eight players of the j
Clipping to come
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · Ogden, Utah
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte confessed his role in the scandal to the Chicago grand jury, weeping and expressing deep regret over the shame brought on his family. The report includes editorializing about the corrupting power of money in American sports and warns the conspirators will face permanent disgrace.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 29 September 1920 · page 4
WHITE SOX SCANDAL. When L'icottc, the famous White Sox pitcher, told the story of his infamy to the grand jury m Chicago, he w ept and when he oamf out of the confessional he said. "I have regretted a thousand times in the pasl year the crime 1 coramitied. I dread to think of theffect my wrong-doing will I have on my children.
An editorial condemns the White Sox players involved in the scandal, warning that their reputations and careers are permanently ruined and praising Comiskey for suspending the indicted men. It frames the scandal as evidence of corrupting money's influence on American sport and youth.
The Ogden Standard-Examiner · 29 September 1920 · page 4
startling. There is a demoralizing suggestion in this baseball scandal which may not sink home now that the swift hand of retribution is upon the White S'ox team. oung men might have gained th idea that honesty no longer is essential to character and reputation, had L'icottc and his team mates evaded the chastisement which has over whelmed them. Not one of the gang will find a comfortable spol in all this world. Even the bush leagues could not attend to engage One of them. Whenever the conspirators appear in the future they I will hear the word of reproach anil condemnation, Their lives, as j highly respected and honored sports, are ended Comiskey, as owner of the White Sox, did the rijrht thing when he telegraphed the indicted men.
See moreSee less
thai they were suspended and, if found guilty would he driven from organized baseball. In the census of 1920, Montana has made a most creditable showing and with an increase oi 1" 6 per cent, the copper state has gone ahead of Utah and Idaho Many of the farming communities have grown in population and the mining camps hae taken on new life, although in the past, year Butte has been slumping owing to the depression in the copper industry. Montana's increase has been from 376, 000 in 1910 to 047,594 in 3920. or a growth of 171,540. Nevada's entire population will not equal Montana's increase in ten years. 'ew Mexico has advam ed slowly but fast enough to overtake Vermont, which is now the fort -fifth state in the union m point of population. Louisiana today has 1,797,798, Or an increase of 141,410, which is 30.000 less than is credited to Montana. Our southern states are not developing as rapidly as their resources warrant. This, no doubt, is due tu climatic conditions. Complaints are being received by the city commissioners to the' effect that the apartment houses of Ogden have closed their doors to prospective tenants with children One of the hotel men of Ogden has stated that family after fam ily has left the city owing to the refusal of apartment house own ers to allow children to enter. A woman with four children has tramped over the greater part of Ogden, seeking accommodations for herself and Little ones, and the one answer she has received is this: "We do not want children in our apartments." How is this city to grow, if children arc to be barred from shelter? Unless a family has a home of its own. serious trouble is eon fronting the father and mother. Once they are outside the protect ing roof of a house, little encouragement is given them. They can beg and entreat, but the one reply will be: "Too bad. We an do nothing tor you. You have children.' Geod-bye." I POLITICAL SPEAKERS. j Utah, ai never before, is receiving attention from the political . j parties.
Charles Comiskey suspended seven White Sox players indicted in the 1919 World Series fixing scandal, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Weaver. His telegram stated they would be reinstated if innocent or banned for life if found guilty of wrongdoing.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CHARLES} A. CO.U1SKKW Comiskey Suspends All Indicted Players; Will Drive Them From Game If Guilty IOr Asso<-tated Ptcs?.) CHICAGO. Sept. 28.?Chnrlea ComUkrTi pmldtnt of the White Sox, today xniipruilrd every mem "1'onr suspension la brought nhout by Information which has Jnat come to me directly Involving