After Comiskey suspended seven players indicted in the Black Sox scandal, Yankees owners Ruppert and Huston telegraphed an offer to lend their entire team to help finish the season. Comiskey declined, explaining league rules barred transfers after August 31.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 29 September 1920 · page 1
SOX CANNOT TAKE PROFFER
[By Associated Press.} N'KW TORK, Sept. 28.?A telegram offering to place the entire New York baseball team at the disposal of Charles A. Coiniskey, who today suspended seven of his players In dicted in connection with alleged fix ing of games, was sent tonight to ?the White Sox club owner hy Jacob Ituppert and T. K Ifusto'n, owners o!
A Cook County grand jury returned indictments against eight White Sox players, with Cicotte tearfully confessing and Jackson reported to have admitted his role in throwing the 1919 World Series. Comiskey immediately suspended the seven active players, vowing to banish them from baseball if found guilty, while declining the Yankees' offer to lend players to fill out his roster.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 29 September 1920 · page 1
CHICAGO GRAND JURY FINDS INDICTMENTS AGAINST 8 WHITE SOX
Comiskey. With his team only one game behind the league leading Cleveland Indians, the White Sox owner served notice on his seven stars that if they were found guilty he would drive them out of organized baseball for the rest of their lives. Lifts Curtain of Jury Room. Officials of Chief Justice Charles McDonald's court, desir ous of giving the national game the benefit of publicity in its purging, lifted the curtain on the grand jury proceedings suffi ciently to show a great hitter, Joe Jackson, declaring that he deliberately just .tapped the ball; a picture of one of the world's most famous pitchers, Cicotte, in tears, and glimpses of alleged bribes of $5,000 or $10,000 discovered under pillows or on beds by famous athletes about to retire.
See moreSee less
Around the courtroom at one time or another were some of baseball's greatest leaders, among them John J. McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, awaiting a call to testify, and John Heydler, president of the National League, -who went before the grand jurors this afternoon.
Cleveland virtually clinched the American League pennant after the suspension of key Chicago players implicated in the alleged World Series fix. The Indians increased their lead to a full game, while the depleted White Sox must field a patched-together team for their remaining games.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 29 September 1920 · page 8
CLEVELAND ALMOST SURE
blanked, by a score of 6-0. Johnston's smashes, deadly in their accuracy and unreturnable with their terrific speed, almost alone won the fourth and deciding set of the match and the decisive match of the tourna ment. Iiosers Are Good Sports. The victors and the vanquished left the field together, being forced to battle their way ' thru an admiring throng that paid Individual tribute to the high sportsmanship that had pre vailed thru the two days of the short tournament. Tall Tilden and tiny Johnston were popular ; victors while the veteran Brookes, the hero of tennis in the Antipodes, was given a most generous demonstration.
See moreSee less
When the two Americans were mak ing their way slowly thruthe crowd to the club house, Tilden was slapped on the back by an enthusiast and told: "Well, if we can't keep the cup. w don't know of any one we would rather have take It."
Clipping to come
Richmond Times-Dispatch · Richmond, Va.
Following the Cook County grand jury's indictment of eight White Sox players, prominent baseball figures including NL president John Heydler, Dodgers owner Charles Ebbets, Giants manager John McGraw, Yankees co-owner Jacob Ruppert, and AL president Ban Johnson gave statements condemning the corruption. Several suggested the indicted players should be barred from the World Series, with some saying no series should be played at all if the Sox had won the pennant.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 29 September 1920 · page 8
Charge of Conspiracy Chicago, Dec. 31.—The charge under which it is hoped to extradite White Sox baseball players indicted on charge of "throwing" games in the 1019 world series is conspiracy, according to an announcement from the state's attor ney's office. Conspiracy is a felony and an extraditable offense. Chief Justice McDonald, it was an nounced, has drawn the assignment of the indicted White Sox players and oth ers connected with the baseball expose. He ordered the grand jury investiga tion which resulted in indictments.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
The Cook County Grand Jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Weaver, for allegedly conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series for gamblers' money. Cicotte reportedly confessed before the jury, and all indicted players have been suspended from the team.
Alexandria Gazette · 29 September 1920 · page 1
ALL ARE SUSPENDED
American Association St. Joseph, Mo.. Dec. 31.—Announce ment is made by his attorney here that Edward J. llanlon. of Sioux City, Iowa, has sold the St. Joseph Western league club to George Beiden, president of the Minneapolis American association club. It is understood that the club is to made a farm of the Millers. The purchase price is not made public, nor is it said whether the club will be transferred from St. Joseph, as llanlon had Intended.
Clipping to come
Alexandria Gazette · Alexandria, D.C.
The Cook County grand jury returned indictments against Chicago White Sox players after Eddie Cicotte reportedly testified and wept, following gambler Billy Maharg's exposé in Philadelphia. Club owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended all indicted players, effectively ending the team's pennant hopes.
Alexandria Gazette · 29 September 1920 · page 1
ALL ARE SUSPENDED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Barre Daily Times · Barre, Vt.
Shoeless Joe Jackson claims teammate Swede Risberg threatened to kill him for confessing, alongside Eddie Cicotte, that eight White Sox players split $80,000 to throw the 1919 World Series. The Cook County grand jury continues its investigation, with indictments against gamblers like Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein expected next.
The Barre Daily Times · 29 September 1920 · page 1
RISBERG THREATENS TO 'BUMP ME OFF' FOR TELLING SAYS JACKSON
To Be Indicted. . Chicago, Sept. 20. Indictments against five or six gamblers were con sidered to-day by the Cook county grand jury investigating "throwing" of baseball games, according to Hartley Replogle, assistant state's attorney in charge of the inquiry. lie said that Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, and Arnold Rothstein of New York were involved in testimony presented to the grand jury. Attell, h was said, handled the money paid ' hite Sox players for "throwing" the If 10 world series. More ball players might be indicted il was also indicated by Replogle, after the grand jury had heard the testi mony of Presidents Johnson and Heyd ler of the American and National leagues to-day.
See moreSee less
Copies of telegrams sent prior and during the 1013 series by Hal Chase and Bill Burns, former major league players, have been obtained by Hevdicr for presentation to the graijd jury,' .;onu j, xuci.raw, manager ot the Giants, waa asked by the grand jury to appear to-day to tell about the re lease of Hal Cha.se, Lee Magee and lleinie Zimmerman by the Giants last year. Statement by several ball play ers, in connection with the 191! series liave involved Chase in the deal by which gamblers are said to have paid 'ight White Sox players to "lay down" to the Cincinnati Reds. Cicotte told the jury that he under stood the eight players were to get 80,01)0. but that they were double crossed by the gamblers and so far a lie knew only three, himself, Jackson and Williams, ever received any money for throwing the series. The amounts they were to have received, he said, were:
State's attorney Hartley Replogle revealed grand jury testimony naming Abe Attell and Arnold Rothstein as organizers of the 1919 World Series fix, with Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson confessing their roles and detailing promised payoffs to eight White Sox players. Cicotte tearfully described deliberately pitching poorly before winning one game, while Jackson tearfully admitted the fix was real to young fans outside the jury room.
The Barre Daily Times · 29 September 1920 · page 1
were: : Fddie Cicotte, pitcher, $10.00(1. Claude Williams, pitcher, $10,000. Charles Risborg, shortstop .10,000 '"Buck" Weaver, third baseman, f.VOOfl. .Ie Jackson, left fielder. $."i.(MMI. 'Happy" Felsch, irnter fielder, $.",000. "Chirk" (tandil, former first baseman, f.'O.(MH). Fred McMullin, utility plaver, flS.ftOO. ' ' With tears in his eyes, Cicotte told the gland jury how he had lobhed the ball up to the Cincinnati batters in the first game of the series, "so that they could read the trademark on it." Repenting after having thrown two panics, he said, he pitched hard to win his third start. Kither Candil. who Cicotte mid firt arranged the "throw ing," or Abe Attell, the go between of
The report describes Cicotte and Jackson confessing to the grand jury about the fixed 1919 World Series, with Cicotte detailing how Gandil and McMullin organized the scheme and how he demanded $10,000 cash in advance. Jackson confirmed his guilt to a group of young fans outside the courthouse, and Comiskey suspended all eight accused players upon hearing Cicotte's confession.
The Barre Daily Times · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
A Cook county grand jury returned the first indictments against gamblers accused in the 1919 World Series fix, naming Sport Sullivan and a man named Attell as the 'fixers' based on pitcher Lefty Williams's confession. Williams detailed how Chick Gandil first approached him and later described a meeting at the Warner Hotel with Cicotte, Gandil, Weaver, Felsch, and two gamblers, while separately Brooklyn authorities opened their own probe into alleged bribery attempts on National League players.
The Seattle Star · 29 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Seattle Star · Seattle, Wash.
Pitcher Lefty Williams testifies about being approached by gamblers to fix the World Series for $5,000 each, describing a meeting in Chick Gandil's hotel room in Cincinnati with other players. He explains how the promised $100,000 payoff never materialized, how he eventually received only $10,000 to split with Jackson, and mentions a newspaper claiming to have Happy Felsch's confession as well.
The Seattle Star · 29 September 1920 · page 14
"Oandlll told me In Cincinnati that Hill llurni* and AN' Attell were fix In* It ao we would get 9100,000. t never got It. "We had a meeting In CMck Own dtll'i room, at Cincinnati. We ju*t dropped in one at a time. There were Km k Weaver, KiMlf Clrotte, Chick (Undtl, Happy Keloch aod my •elf there.
The Cook County grand jury continues probing the 1919 World Series fix, with Jackson naming gamblers while Cicotte heads home; Jean Dubuc is subpoenaed and Abe Attell threatens to reveal details implicating Arnold Rothstein, who denies the Astoria hotel bribe offer. Meanwhile Jackson claims the 1920 White Sox played honest baseball all season.
The Seattle Star · 29 September 1920 · page 14
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The Cook County grand jury, investigating crooked baseball, indicted eight White Sox players for allegedly throwing the 1919 World Series and began pursuing the gamblers involved. Testimony from Eddie Cicotte reportedly detailed specific payoff amounts given to each implicated player.
The Milwaukee Leader · 29 September 1920 · page 9
tors went into the gamblers’ part In the SIOO,OOO plot. Officials announced they had sufficient evidence, apparently ob tained from the “confessions” of Joe Jackson and Eddie Cicotte, White Sox stars, to obtain indictments of gamblers in New York, Chicago, Cin cinnati, St. Louis, Detroit, Des Moines and other cities.
The article details amounts White Sox players allegedly received for throwing the 1919 World Series, based on Eddie Cicotte's testimony. It also covers further details of confessions from Cicotte and Jackson, including Jackson's account of why he decided to confess.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
The Milwaukee Leader · 29 September 1920 · page 9
j SI,OOO. ! Charles Risberg, shortstop, In lielder, $2,000. j Chick Gandil, first baseman, I 20,000. | Fred-McMullin, utility, $15,006. j from the battered contraption to present a front for the remaining games. Gleason’s pitching staff will be Faber, Kerr, Hodges and Wilkinson, with Schalk receiving. He intends Shifting J. Collins to third, playing McClelland at short, E. Collins at second and Jourdan at first. His outfield would be Strunk, Murphy, Liebold, with F. A. Lynn as the only utility man. They open a three game series in St. Louis Thursday with Cleveland one game ahead in the pennant ?ha^e t .
New details emerged Wednesday about the confessions of Cicotte and Jackson, including Jackson's account of receiving threats, his $5,000 payoff, and his conversation with Judge McDonald. Jackson also claimed the third World Series game was thrown despite Dickey Kerr's pitching, while Happy Felsch dismissed the grand jury indictment as 'all bunk.'
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Pitcher Claude Williams testified before the grand jury, confirming the 1919 World Series was fixed and naming Chick Gandil as the players' chief contact with gamblers Brown and Sullivan. Williams said he was promised $20,000 but received only $10,000, half of which he claimed to have given to Jackson.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 29 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
WHITE SOX MAKE A CLEAN BREST OF 1919 FRAME-UP
Claude Williams Joins Cicotte and Jackson in Confessing "Throwing" of World Series
See moreSee less
CHICK GANDILL NAMED AS CHIEF GO-BETWEEN
(By Associated Press.) CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--Identity of alleged go between and gamblers who bribed White Sox players was revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude Williams who joined Cicotte and Jackson in making a clean breast of the 1919 world series frame-up.
Williams named Chick Gandill former White Sox player against whom a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team and a "Brown and Sullivan,' gamblers, from either New York or Boston as go-between for the gamblers.. The jury voted true bills for Brown and Sullivan.
Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson the same but that he received only $10,000 half of which he gave Jackson.
He said Gandil told him that Bill Burns veteran pitcher, and Attell, former prize fighter, were fixing it for the Six hired to get $100,000.
CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--At 12:30 o'clock pitcher Claude Williams appeared at the criminal court building and was conducted to the grand jury room.
Williams has made a complete state- (Continued on Page 4)
WHITE SOX MAKE CLEAN BREST OF 1919 FRAMEUP (Continued from Page 1.)
ment Attorney Austrian announced. He said Williams furnished considerable information about the gamblers involved in the purchase of the Sox players and also named the go-betweens, it was announced.
Williams named "sport' Sullivan, a Boston gambler, and another Boston gambler named Brown as two of the principals in the deal. He said that he received $10,000 for his part in "throwing" the series.
Five thousand dollars of this amount he gave to Jackson he declared. He said he personally paid the $5,000 to Jackson, his testimony being at variance with previous reports.
William before making his statement signed a waiver of immunity. Assistant States Attorney Replogle stated that another of the White Sox players was expected at the criminal court building this afternoon to make a statement. The announcement was believed to refer to McMillan who was said to have made a statement to Attorney Austrian.
CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--Further confessions by some of the seven White Sox players who with one former player were indicted yesterday in connection with the alleged "throwing" of the 1919 World's Series will be made within a day or two, Alfred Austrian, attorney for the ball club announced today.
It has been rumored that at least two of the seven were anxious to supplement the confession of Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson with their statements. William ("Kid") Gleason, manager of the White Sox disclosed today the march of events which culminated in Cicotte's confession and the voting of indictments.
Last Monday according to Gleason he had gathered enough evidence to know that some of the players had been bribed to lose the series. Cicotte came to him Monday night and declared he had "a load on his chest" and wanted to get rid of it. Gleason told him to see "Commy.' Charles A. Comisky, owner of the Sox.
Comisky heard Cicotte's story which tallied with the evidence gathered by his private detective and then called his attorney, A. S. Austrian, and told him to take the pitcher to Judge MacDonald, Chief Justice of the Cook County Criminal Court. The confession and indictment followed.
True bills naming three ball players, not members of the White Sox and three gamblers, were expected to be voted today by the grand jury. Members of the jury said this morning they had sufficient evidence on which to base indictments. It was reported that true bills against two National League players were being considered.
CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--Charges that some of the same players who are accused of "throwing" the world series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennant winners this season were made today by several members of the White Sox who have not been mentioned in the grand jury testimonies.
NEW YORK, Sept. 29.--District Attorney Lewis of King's County, announced today he would start an immediate investigation of the report that a clique of gamblers planned to bribe members of the Brooklyn Nationals purposely to lose games to their American League opponents in the coming world's series.
In a telegram to State Attorney Hoyne of Chicago, whose grand jury investigating charges that the 1919 series was fixed has indicted eight White Sox players, Mr. Lewis said he was acting on the following statement appearing in a New York evening paper yesterday:
"Information has been gathered by officials tending to indiacte that the same clique of gamblers which is alleged to have fixed the 1919 series have made plans to have Brooklyn 'throw' the coming series to the Cleveland Indians."
Lefty Williams confessed to State's Attorney Austrian, naming gamblers Sport Sullivan and Brown as organizers and admitting he received $10,000, giving $5,000 directly to Joe Jackson. Manager Kid Gleason also described how Cicotte's confession led to the indictments after Gleason and Comiskey gathered evidence of the fix.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 29 September 1920 · page 4
WHITE SOX MAKE CLEAN BREAST OF 1919 FRAMEUP
It lias been rumored Unit at least two-of tiv seven were anxious to sup plement the confession of Eddie t'icotte and doe Jackson with their statements. William ." Kid”) Gleason, manager of the White Sox disclosed today the march of events which culmi nated in Cicotte's confession and (he voting of indictments. East Monday according to Gleason lit had gathered enough evidence to know that some of the players had keen bribed to lose the series. Cicotto ' ime to him Monday night and declar i d he had “a load on Ills ihest” and wanted to get rid of it.
See moreSee less
Gleason told him to see “Comnty. ’ Charles A. t'nmisky, owner of the Sox. Comisky heard Cicotte's story which 'a'lied \v:ii the evidence gathered by his private detective and then culled hN attorney, A. S. Austrian, and told him to take the pitcher u> Judge Mac Donald. Chief Justice of the Cook ih unty Criminal Court. The confes sion and indictment followed. > True liiils naming three ball players, not members of the "White Sox and three gamblers, were expected to be voted today by the grand .way. Mem bers of the jury said this morning they tied sufficient evidence on which to base indictments. It was reported that true hills against two National League players were being considered. CHICAGO, Sept, 29.—Charges that seme of the same players who are ac cused of "throwing” the world series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennant winners this season were made today by several members ef the White Sox who have not been mentioned in the grand jury testi monies.
The report describes how pitcher Eddie Cicotte confessed to Comiskey after approaching manager Gleason with guilt over the fixed 1919 World Series, leading to grand jury indictments. It also notes new allegations of gambling schemes involving current games, including a reported plot to bribe Brooklyn players against Cleveland.
The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 29 September 1920 · page 4
A Cook County grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiring to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati for gambler payoffs, with Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson confessing their roles. Club owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended the seven players still under contract, crippling his team's pennant chances.
The Wheeling Intelligencer · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Eight White Sox Indicted; Cicotte and Jackson Confess
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Laramie Republican · Laramie, Wyo.
Following Cicotte's confession that he found bribe money under his hotel pillow in Cincinnati, a new Hamilton county grand jury has been summoned. The jury will convene Monday to investigate the circumstances surrounding the bribe.
The Laramie Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
AFTER THEM AGAIN. TT” Ohio Grand Jury to Invaetigate Con fession by Cicotte. - — — "rjkfe, By. the Assastated . Cincinnati, 0., Sept. 29.—As the re sult of Cicotte’s confession that h® found bribe money under his pillow at . a hotel here, a new Hamilton county grand jury has been summoned to as semble. Monday and will inquire into the circumstances.
The club attorney announces that additional White Sox players indicted the previous day are expected to confess to fixing the 1919 World Series, joining Cicotte and Jackson. The grand jury is also considering indictments against other players, gamblers, and a boxer, and has extended its term to complete the investigation.
The Laramie Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
READY TO JOIN EDDIE CICOTTE IN MAKING CLEAN BREAST OF THROWING SERIES
Prize Fighter Involved. Chicago, Sept. 29.—Eugene Dubuc, of the Toledo American association club, was summoned to be questioned, it was said, about the reports that the games were “fixed” on a barnstorm ing tour In which he and Hal Chase participated last fallEvidence al ready placed before the grand jury, It Is known, involves Abe Attell, the for mer prize fighter; Lee Magee, Chase; Helnie Zimmerman, former members of the Giants; three eastern gamblers, whose names were not divulged, and at least two National league players. Hartley Replogle, the assistant state's attorney, who confirmed these facts, admitted there were ten or twelve indictments in the prosecution.
See moreSee less
The grand jury, whose normal period of office expires tomorrow, will be con tinued definitely, to complete the baseball investigation, Mr. Replogle said. Williams Tells Story. I When Charles A Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, reached the office shortly before noon, he found enough letters and telegrams from friends and sympathizers waiting to fill two good sized barrels. "It’s been tough, but I feel better after reading some of the messages,” he said. Mr. Comiskey, Manager Gleason and Harry Grabiner today began working out a new bat ting order, assigning the reserves to fill the seven vacant places in the regular line up. At 12:30 o’clock Williams appeared at the criminal court building and was conducted to the grand Jury room. Williams made a complete statement, Attorney Aus trian announced, who said that Wil liams furnished considerable informa tion about the gamblers involved In the purchase of the Sox players, also the names of go-betweens. It was an nounced that he had signed an im (Continued on page Four)
The Cook County grand jury continues its probe into the fixed 1919 World Series, with testimony implicating Abe Attell, Hal Chase, Lee Magee, Heinie Zimmerman, eastern gamblers, and White Sox players. Pitcher Lefty Williams appears before the grand jury and gives a full statement naming gamblers and go-betweens involved in the fix.
The Laramie Republican · 29 September 1920 · page 1
Pitcher Claude 'Lefty' Williams testified before the grand jury, signing an immunity waiver and giving a full statement implicating gamblers 'Sport' Sullivan and a man named Brown. He admitted receiving $10,000 for his part in throwing the series and said he gave $5,000 of it to Joe Jackson; attorney Austrian said more players' confessions were expected soon.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 5
WILLIAMS' TESTIMONY INVOLVES SEVERAL.
“Fixed.” CINCINNATI, O. —A letter from a woman couched in loving terms, af fidavits of ball players and John J. McGraw relative to gambling and the fixing of ball games, testimony by August Herrmann, president of the Reds, regarding the incidents which led to the suspension of Hal Chase when first, baseman of the Reds, featured the hearing of the divorce suit of Mrs. Anna M. Chase, wife of the former ball player. Mrs. Chase named the woman who wrote the letter to Chase. The mis sive was postmarked Port Chester, N. Y. Mrs. Chase testified that after Chase’s suspension by the Cincinnati club he visited the woman for two weeks.
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Following indictments of seven White Sox players and Cicotte and Jackson's confessions, club attorney Austrian says more players will confess soon. The grand jury is also considering indictments against gamblers and other players including Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman, and Abe Attell for separate fixing allegations.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 5
FURTHER CONFESSIONS DUE IN CHICAGO FUND
Knew of Crooked Series. When questioned by Atty. How ard Ragland regarding Chase’s sus pension from the Cincinnati team, she testified: "He admitted to me he had been caught with the ‘goods.’ He also ad mitted he knew all about the crooked deal put over by members of the White Sox in the world series of 1019, and was helping it along. “Because of his associations with gamblers I was frequently insulted when down town with him, as hisi associates thought I was one of the • type he went with.”
Clipping to come
Paper unidentified
Following Cicotte's confession that he found bribe money under his pillow in a Cincinnati hotel, a new Hamilton county grand jury will convene Monday to investigate the circumstances. The report is brief, citing Associated Press wire service as the source.
Paper unidentified · 29 September 1920 · page 5
CINCINNATI JURY TO INVESTIGATE EVIDENCE
Ohio State? (G. P. S.) If a man tights and liis manJ ager. after deducting his share of i the money, buys the fighter some-I thing witlx the remaining money, j is the tighter regarded as a proses-S sional and ineligible for college | sports? (A. M.) What American league team f drew' the greatest number of bases on balls last year? (H. F.) What was the distance covered | bv Broeco and Coburn in winning; the last six-day bicycle race? (E. ’ E. C.)
Clipping to come
The Nenana Daily News · Nenana, Alaska
The Cook County grand jury indicted eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiring with gamblers to throw the 1919 World Series. Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams gave confessions detailing payments from gamblers, with Williams naming two Boston gamblers as principals.
The Nenana Daily News · 30 September 1920 · page 1
PLAYERS INDICTED; MAKE CONFESSIONS
TRADE BALANCE SLUMPS. WASHINGTON, D. C., Sept. 30 ■—Commenting on the recent slump in favorable trade balance, O. P. Hopkins, acting director of foreign and domestic commerce, declares that the reduction in no way re flects an unsound economic condi tion. The slump, he says, has befen expected for months, and should not be regarded with uneasiness by Am erican businessmen. SEATTLE, Sept. 30.—The Wash-; ington correspondent of the Times has informed his paper that Repre sentative George W. Edmonds, Rej publican, of Pennsylvania, is authori-} ty for the statement that an effort will be made, during the coming j session of Congress, to impeach ; President Wilson, because of his rei fusal to carry out the provisions of j the Jones bill, by which the Presi dent was instructed to annul exist ing treaties between the United CHICAGO, Sept.
See moreSee less
30.-—The Cook i county grand jury, which is engaged in an investigation of charges that the 1919 world’s baseball series be tween Chicago and Cincinnati was thrown at the instigation of a Chi cago gambling ring, voted true bills yesterday against eight members of the Chicago American team, and it is understood the indicted men, who are all White Sox stars, will not be permitted to finish the season with their team. Those indicted are: Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, Chick Gandil, Happy Felsh, Charles Risberg, Joe Jackson, Fred McGillii^ and Buck Weaver. Makes Cob feu ion. Claude Williams, White Sox pitch er, made a complete statement yes terday morning, supplementing the confessions made previous by Jack son and Cicotte. He named two Boston gamblers as the principals in the deal, and said that he re ceived $10,000 for his part in throwing the series. Cicotte previ ously stated that his share also was $10,000, and Jackson said he was to have received $20,000, but got only $6,000. .When Cicotte appeared before the grand jury on Tuesday he broke down and cried like a baby. He said he took the money because he
Cicotte reportedly broke down before the grand jury, admitting he took money found under his pillow before the Series opener to support his family. Comiskey suspended the indicted players, and a new gambling scandal was reported brewing around the upcoming Brooklyn series.
The Nenana Daily News · 30 September 1920 · page 1
MAKE CONFESSIONS
Conspiracy Charge. The indicted players are charged with conspiracy to violate the state law, and it is believed that others will be added to the list of those now under arrest. An official of the court is authority for the statement that Cicotte engineered the whole deal for the gamblers, resulting in the loss of the series for the White Sox. Comiskey has suspended all of the indicted players with the excep tion of Gandil, who is not playing this season.
Chick Gandil, indicted along with teammates for conspiring to fix the 1919 World Series, denied any wrongdoing from his sickbed in Texas. The report notes that Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson had already confessed, naming Gandil as the go-between with gamblers who paid about $100,000 to throw the games.
The Alaska Daily Empire · 30 September 1920 · page 1
ACCUSED PLAYER DENIES BRIBERY
Chicago White Sox players and otl series scandal were to be pigeonht their guilt. Recent reports to the e accused men are faulty and that tl followed by insinuations that soinc whole affair to be dropped for fear erty may be involved, while not gi porters of the game, have served 1 action?to be given some concrete game?make good their promise for The action of the state's attorney is hailed by the public as a sign thai something finally is to la done toward establishing the guilt of those who have dragged the good name of the
Clipping to come
The Mena Weekly Star · Mena, Ark.
A Cook County grand jury indicted seven current and one former Chicago White Sox player on conspiracy charges related to fixing the 1919 World Series. Club owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended the eight players, likely costing the team the pennant, while the Yankees offered their own roster to help the White Sox finish the season.
they do not surrender for trial. Delay in the opening of the prosecution is attributed to the fact that the testimony given at the original grand jury investigation was so voluminous that the state's attorney has not been able to complete reading It. It will be a bad thing for base hall if the trial is not started within a short time. In about a month the players and club officials whose testimony will be needed will be hiking south for spring training, and their
Clipping to come
The Mena Weekly Star · Mena, Ark.
Comiskey indefinitely suspended seven White Sox players — Cicotte, Jackson, Williams, Felsch, Weaver, Risberg, and McMullin — after information linked them to the 1919 World Series scandal being probed by the Cook County grand jury. Court sources described dramatic testimony, including Cicotte's tearful confession to taking $10,000 and Jackson's admission of deliberately misplaying balls.
The Mena Weekly Star · 30 September 1920 · page 1
the scandal proves a iiasco all the widely advertised steps taken to rehabilitate the game will count for timningTw* Long Jump* for Griffn. Although th? grueling exhibition trip indulged in by the Nationals with the Cincinnati Reds last year is
Clipping to come
The Mena Weekly Star · Mena, Ark.
Eddie Cicotte tearfully confessed before the Chicago grand jury to accepting a $10,000 bribe and deliberately pitching to lose the 1919 World Series, describing how he lobbed easy pitches to the plate. The grand jury returned true bills against eight players, and owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended them, paying off Weaver, Cicotte, and Jackson on the spot.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Pitcher Claude Williams and outfielder Oscar Felsch gave statements admitting they were bribed to throw the 1919 World Series. The Chicago grand jury investigating the scandal also returned indictments against two alleged gamblers identified only as 'Brown and Sullivan.'
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 September 1920 · page 1
WILLIAMS AND FELSCH CONFESS THEY HELPED THROW SERIES OF 1919
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
The report details sworn confessions by Claude Williams, Joe Jackson, Eddie Cicotte, and Hap Felsch describing how they bartered with gamblers known as "Brown and Sullivan" to throw the 1919 World Series. It explains the payment amounts given to each player and describes the grand jury's uncertainty over whether these gambler names were real or fictional aliases.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 September 1920 · page 1
ARRESTED BY SCHOLEY Mary Kazube of 709 Strong street appeared in the municipal court this morning to answer to the charge of making moonshine. The woman could not speak English and had to be ques tioned through an interpreter. She decided to waive preliminary examin ation and admitted that she had made and sold moonshine. The woman had two small children with her that were attractive little tots and in making her plea for leniency she stated that if she was held, the children would suffer. As nearly as could be found out, the woman came to Kenosha from Penn sylvania about a year and a half ago.
See moreSee less
The place from where shd came could riot be discovered but she stated that at the place there, her husband had deserted her. The woman had a small child in a hospital that was placed there because it was in such a filthy condition that the health officials de cided that the woman was not a com petent person to have charge. The ba by was later given to her but it soon was neglected and it was again placed in the hospital where it is at the pres ent time.
Clipping to come
The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.
Williams, Jackson, and Felsch's confessions to the grand jury are detailed, including payment amounts and how the fix was arranged with gamblers Brown and Sullivan. Heydler and McGraw also testify about prior suspected fixing by Hal Chase, Lee Magee, and Heinie Zimmerman.
The Birmingham Age-Herald · 30 September 1920 · page 1
BARTERED WITH GAMBLERS
To Try White Sox Players Shortly (By United Press) I Chicago.—The trial of eight White Sox players indicted on charges of conspiracy to throw the 1919 world series to Cincinnati will start in two
Clipping to come
Arizona Republican · Phoenix, Ariz.
McGraw testified before the grand jury that he released Zimmerman and Chase from the Giants due to suspicions of game-throwing, and that Zimmerman allegedly offered Benny Kauff money to help fix games. Heydler also testified about his private investigation into White Sox suspicions and a confession obtained from Lee Magee.
Arizona Republican · 30 September 1920 · page 2
Heydlers testimony was largely th interview he gave newspaper men Sunday night telling of his private in vestigation; how Conuskey naa toin lim a year ago he suspected some of the White Sox players and how he and William Veeck, president of the Chi cago Cubs, had obtained a confession
Brooklyn captain Zack Wheat denied rumors that his teammates had been approached about fixing the upcoming World Series, expressing surprise that players would be questioned by the district attorney. A separate note reports that Chick Gandil, named as a ringleader in the 1919 fix plot, is recovering from an appendicitis operation in Texas and declined to comment.
Norwich Bulletin · 30 September 1920 · page 1
Include Sullivan and Attell. Among them are “Abe” Attell and “Sport” Sullivan, alleged gam blers, and Chick Gandil, former Sox In the event they first baseman. make a tight against coming into the court's jurisdiction extradition papers for their arrest will be asked. Attorney Thomas D. Nash, counsel for some of the indicted players. for stated yesterday he is ready trial and is hopeful of acquittal. The present status of the case indicates that unless some unforseen obstacle presents itself the trial will be well under way by the end of this month.
See moreSee less
State's Attorney Crowe is anxious to dispose of the case before the spring training begins and he will relieve Prosecutor Gorman of his routine work in court so that ne can give his undivided attention to the baseball matter. Grand jury investigation of an al leged plot to sell minutes of the grand jury relative to Chicago news papers by the New York Herald and Sun. will be resumed tomorrow. The offer came shortly after publication of an article by that newspaper in which it was "stated that the case would be pigeon-holed and forgotten. Was McDonald Libeled? The grand jury is also inquiring whether Chief Justice McDonald, who fathered the inquiry that re sulted in the indictments, was crim inally libeled. Attorney Henry A.
Clipping to come
Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.
Testimony from Cicotte and Jackson detailed how eight bribed players caused teammates to lose out on bonus money from winning the World Series. Comiskey estimated his financial losses from the scandal at $230,000 in lost player value.
Norwich Bulletin · 30 September 1920 · page 1
"CROOKED" PLAYERS LOST THEIR TEAMMATES $1,952.65
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Norwich Bulletin · Norwich, Conn.
As a Chicago grand jury investigated the 1919 World Series fix, a Brooklyn district attorney launched his own inquiry into rumors that the same gambling clique was trying to fix the 1920 series. He summoned Brooklyn players to testify and pledged full prosecution of any crooked dealings found.
Norwich Bulletin · 30 September 1920 · page 1
BASEBALL MAGNATES ALERT TO KEEP GAME SQUARE
LEGALIZING OF RACING IN WASHINGTON FAVORED OLYMPIA, Wash., Feb. 9.—A fav Oakland Club of the Pacific Con: i League, now under contract to the Detroit Americans, was ordered in a local court yesterday when the complaining witness refused to pros
Grand jury testimony reveals that Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, Happy Felsch, and Joe Jackson confessed to conspiring with gamblers 'Brown' and 'Sullivan' in a hotel room to throw the 1919 World Series. Williams detailed payments received and distributed among players, while Felsch claimed he received $5,000 but was 'double-crossed' on promised amount of $20,000.
Evening Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
ADMISSIONS BY TWO MORE SOX
Williams and Felsch Confess Part in Scandal
See moreSee less
GAMBLERS ALSO ARE INDICTED
CHICAGO, Sept. 30. — Confessions from Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch, admitting they were bribed to "throw" last year's world's series, were made public yesterday and at the same time the grand jury investigating the baseball scandal took its first action against gamblers who are said to have engineered the deal by indicting two men whose identity was only partly revealed.
"Brown" and "Sullivan" were the names under which true bills were voted against the alleged gamblers and both were said to be from Boston, or New York. Later, however, it came out that the jury believed these names to be mythical and used only by the men when they discussed the series "throwing" with the ball players. Possibility that they are two men whose names already have been brought before the jury and who are nationally known, was expressed by officials in the State attorney's office.
The statement by Williams and the newspaper reports of Felsch's confession tallied with those made on Thursday by Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson. They revealed that last year's world series was settled in a tiny room in a small south side hotel.
In this room, occupied by Eddie Cicotte, once the American League's leading pitcher, the deal was made which "threw" the world series, wrecked a world championship team and brought some of the, greatest idols in baseball to disgrace.
According to the sworn statement, made by Claude Williams, who lost three of the world series games, he and "Chick" Gandil, "Buck" Weaver, Eddie Cicotte, who lost two games, and "Happy" Felsch, whose error helped lose one game, met here to barter with "Brown" and "Sullivan" to lose the games.
"After we had agreed that we were willing to 'throw' the series," Williams said, "we went out one at a time and made our bargains with Brown and Sullivan."
Williams said he received $10,000 and that he gave $5,000 to Jackson, a statement which tallies with the confession made by Jackson yesterday. He was supposed to get $20,000, he said.
Felsch, according to reports of his confession, said he received $5,000, which he found in his locker at the clubhouse, but that he never had a chance to really help lose the series. His one glaring error of the series—when he dropped the fly ball—was an accident and he was warned afterwards by the other players not to be so awkward in making his misplays, he was quoted as saying. The outfielder declared he did not want to "get in on the deal," at first, but the other players at the hotel conference told him it would be easy. He said he had been promised $20,000 but was double crossed. Abe Attell and Gandil were the ones he believed guilty of the double-crossing.
Felsch denied that the White Sox had thrown any game this season, and said the men implicated in the bribery had felt all season they would be exposed sooner or later. We confirmed the confessions of Cicotte and Jackson.
John Heydler, president of the National League, and John McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, yesterday told the jury details of the Lee Magee and Hal Chase cases and also of dropping of Heinie Zimmerman. McGraw was requested to return Tuesday and bring Fred Toney, New York pitcher, and Bennie Kauff, outfielder Heydler was asked to appear again at his convenience after the world series.
McGraw is said to have told the jury that he dropped Hal Chase from his club after President Heydler had told him Magee had confessed that Chase bribed him to throw games. He said he had heard of many other gambling activities of Chase's before the Magee case.
Zimmerman was dropped from the New York team, McGraw is said to have told the jury, because information had come to the New York manager that the third baseman offered Benny Kauff $500 to help throw games.
"I believe Kauff was innocent," said McGraw, "but I got rid of Chase and Zimmerman, even though I know it would seriously injure my team, because I didn't want such men on the club."
Heydler's testimony was largely the interview he gave newspaper men Sunday night telling of his private investigation, how Comiskey had told him a year ago he suspected some of the White Sox players, and how he and William Veeck, president of the Chicago Cubs, had obtained a confession from Lee Magee.
"One incident in Magee's case is amusing," said Heydler, "for while I think he tried to throw this game, he really helped win it.
"In July, 1918, Magee was playing second for Cincinnati against Boston. He came to bat with two out and hit an easy grounder, which took a bad bound and he was safe. He was ordered to steal second and ambled down. When half way to second he stopped, but Art Wilson made a wild throw and Magee had to go on to third. He might have scored with the tying run, I think, if he had tried, but he didn't. Then Rousch knocked a home run. Magee had to come in with the tying run and Rousch's run of course won the game."
Heydler is said to have told the jury that Magee confessed to him and Veeck that he took part in the throwing of several games.
According to an official in the State's attorney's office the name of two brothers in Des Moine have been brought before the jury. They are said to have placed large bets on the world series and to have been tipped that it was "fixed."
Further indications against gamblers may be expected within a day or two, it was said.
McGraw testified he dropped Hal Chase and Heinie Zimmerman from the Giants over gambling suspicions, including Chase's bribery of Lee Magee and Zimmerman's offer to Benny Kauff. Heydler recounted his private investigation into the scandal, including Comiskey's year-old suspicions and Magee's confession of throwing games.
Evening Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 11
Suhday nigtit telling of his private Investigation, how Gomiskey had told him a year ago he suspected some of tho White Sox players, and how he anfl William Voock, president of the Ohlicago Cubs, had obtained a confes
Grand jury testimony reveals Cicotte and Jackson admitted taking bribes of $10,000 and $5,000 respectively to throw the 1919 World Series, with eight players implicated in total. Comiskey estimated the suspended players' combined value at $230,000 and calculated the financial losses from the fixed series for both bribed players and their honest teammates.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 1
Two Gamblers Indicted; More Players Confess Plot to Throw Games
William S. ("Bill") Hart and his horse appear tonight at the Grand. This announcement is generally enough to bring the crowd, as Hart is one of the stage favorites in this city. Anytime he and the horse get into the limelight the people want to see him. The Grand management was disap pointed in the receipt of "The White Circle," which was billed for this even ing, but was fortunate to a certain deVOTES UNFAVORABLY
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
District Attorney Lewis of Brooklyn announces an investigation into reports that gamblers who allegedly fixed the 1919 World Series were now plotting to have Brooklyn throw the upcoming series to Cleveland. Team president Charles Ebbets pledges cooperation and player interviews, while captain Zach Wheat denies any approach or wrongdoing.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 1
To Go To Trial Chicago, 111., Feb. 9.— Eight Chi eafo White Sox ball players who were indicted with Attell and several others for throwing the 1919 world aesies at Cincinnati,, wUi £o to trial here March 14th. O n
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
The Chicago grand jury made public confessions from Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch admitting they were bribed to throw the 1919 World Series, matching earlier statements by Cicotte and Jackson. The jury also indicted unnamed gamblers known only as 'Brown' and 'Sullivan,' believed to be aliases for figures already before the jury.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 1
Men Known as Sullivan and Brown Accused as Fixers; $15,000 Given to Williams and Felsch; Cicotte Suspected On Last Trip East; McGraw Testifies on Chase and Zimmerman; Asked to Get Toney and Kauff
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
Heydler tells the grand jury that Magee confessed involvement in thrown games, and the jury thanks him for his help. Happy Felsch gives his own confession, admitting he took $5,000 to throw the World Series and corroborating Cicotte's account.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 2
Felsch Sorry He Did It "Well, the beans are all spilled, and I think that I am through with base? ball. I got my $5,000, and 1 suppose the others got theirs, too," said Felsch in* his confession. "I don't know what I'm going to do now. I have been a baseball player during the best years of my life, and I never got into any other kind of busi? ness. I'm going to hell, I guess. I in? tend to hang around Chicago a while until I see how this thing is going to go.
See moreSee less
Then maybe I'll go back to Mil w ? u 1c ? c " The smile that gave him the nick? name of "Happy" Felsch faded as he considered his prospects. "I wish that I hadn't gone into it," he said. "I guess we all do. We have snore than earned the few dollars they gave us for turning crooked.? "All this season the memory of the world's series has been hanging over us. The talk that we 'threw' games this year is bunk. We knew we were sus? pected and we tried to be square. But a guy can't be crooked part of the time and square the rest of the-time. W knew that sooner or later somebody was going to turn up the whole deal. "Cicotte's story is true iqupvery de? tail. I don't blame him fortelling. I naver knew where my $5,000 came from. It was left in my locker at the club? house, and there was always a good deal of mystery about the way It was ?dealt out. ' That was one of the reasons why we never knew who double-crossed us on. the split of the .$100,000. It was to have been an even split. But we never got it. "Who was responsible for that dou? ble-cross I can't say. I suspect Gandil, because he was the wisest one of the lot and had sense enough to get out of baseball before the crash came. But I have heard since that it was Attell. Maybu it was Attell. I don't know him, but I had heard that he was mixed up with the gamblers who w?re backing -us to lose. Didn't Want To Be Squealer "I didn't want to get in on the deal at first. I had always received square treatment from 'Commy' and it didn't look quite right to throw him down. But when they let me in on the idea too many men were involved. I didn't -like to be a squealer and I knew that if I stayed out of the deal and said nothing about it they would go on
An unnamed player confirms Cicotte's confession is accurate, describing receiving $5,000 left mysteriously in his locker and suspecting Gandil or Attell of double-crossing the players on the promised $100,000 split. He explains he reluctantly joined the conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series after being pressured by teammates, fearing he'd lose money without stopping the scheme if he refused.
Happy Felsch describes the Cicotte hotel room conference where players discussed throwing the Series for gamblers' money, admitting he shared blame and that Cicotte secured his $10,000 upfront. Lefty Williams' sworn statement to the White Sox attorney recounts Gandil's initial approach in New York and a later meeting at the Warner Hotel with players and two men identified as gamblers named Brown and Sullivan.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 2
nothing about it they would go on ?rithout me and I'd be that much money ?t without accomplishing anything. "I'm not saying this to 'pass the b-?ck* to others, I suppose that if I had refused to enter the plot and had stood my ground I might have stopped the whole deal. We all share the blame equally Vl'm not Baying that I double-crossed th? gamblers^but 1 had nothing to do with the loss of the world's series. The breaks just came so that I was not given a chance to do anything toward throwing the game.
See moreSee less
"Whether I could actually have got up enough nerve to carry out my part in throwing the game I can't say. The gold looked good to ail of us and I suppose we would have gone ahead with the double-cross. But. as I said, I was given no chance to decide. "When we went into that conference in Cicotte'B room he said that it would be easy for us to pull the wool over the eyes of the public, that we were expert ball players, and that we could throw the game scientifically. "It looked easy to me, too. It's just as easy for a good player to miss a ball as it is to eatch it?-just a slow start oi a stumble at the ri__ht time, or a slo? throw, and the job is done. "But you can't get away with thai atuff indefinitely. You may be able U tool the public, but you can't fool your Mlf." "How did Cicotte get $10,000?' Felsch was asked. "Because he was wise enough t< stand pat for it, that's all. Cicotte hai b>?ins. The rest of us roundheads jus1 toek their word for the propositioi that we were to get an even split oi the $100,000. Cicotte was going t< make sure of his share from the jump off. He made them come across with it "I'm going to see 'Buck' Weaver am get him to go over to see the State': Attorney with me. I'm going to ge through with all of this. It will be i load off my mind to tell everything know. It's been hell for me." William?'? Statement Before going before the grand jury to-day Williams made the following ?worn statement to Alfred Austrian, attorney for the White Sox: "This situation was first brought up to me in New York. Mr. Gandil called me to one side, out in front of the Hotel Ansonia, and asked me if any? body had approached me about the world series, and I said: 'Just what do you mean?' He says: 'That the series be fixed; if they were fixed what -">uld you do about it? Would you take an active part, or what?' I says, 'I am in no position to say right now.' I says, 'I will give you my answer later, after thinking it over,' "After coming back to Chicago I was called down to the Warner Hotel, where the eight members that are named -not eight, I will take that back. I will name them for you?Eddii Cicotte, Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver and Happy Falsch, and two fellows in? troduced as Brown and Sullivan" "They were the gamblers?" "They were supposed to be th? gamblers." "What names were those?" "Brawn find Sullivan, supposed to b the gamblers, or fellows that were fix ing it for th? gamblers, one of the two they didn't say which. They said the wer? from New York; thev introduce them ai Brown and Sullivan froi New York. They wanted us to thro? the series to Cineinnati for 15,000." "Apiece?"
This editorial argues that the scandal threatens baseball's integrity, originating from outside gamblers rather than internal sport disputes. It credits Comiskey and Gleason for exposing the indicted White Sox players despite financial loss, while urging that both players and gamblers be punished to restore public confidence.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 10
The Gambler's Trail
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
New-York Tribune · New York, N.Y.
This column quotes Cicotte's trial testimony that he threw games because he needed money for his wife and kids, juxtaposed with an earlier quote of him denying wrongdoing before the Series. The writer mocks this sentimental justification with satirical verse, then notes all eight indicted players were married, undercutting the sympathy angle.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 10
LATER?Each of the eight White' Sox players indicted ?3. married. Dry your tears. Our wagers on the 1D19 series were with the sole thought of buying things for the Wife and the Home. We bet, it may be recalled, on the Sox, confi? dent in the puissance and skill of Mr. Cicotte. If Eddi?;' as tender-hearted a pitcher as ever hurled a shina ball, had only known! When we learned there wasn't any Santa Claus we felt a good deal the way we did npon the discovery that throwing a ball game was possible.
See moreSee less
We had always contended that it couldn't be done; that too many players would have to be reached for the thing to be feasible; that a player's reputation was more to him than the most money he could maktf by being crooked; that if more than two players were in on the deal the crookedness would tran? spire, and the consequent scandal would give Organized Baseball a blow it never would recover from. And, in the main, that still is our contention. Baseball is honest, automatically. And we'll bet $44, which we just have planked down for two seats for four games in Brooklyn, that the American League takes the series. Doubtless Mr. Cicotte finds it hard to sleep these nights. His fitful slum l?er, at any rate, probably is disturbed by dreams in which he hears the entire American public yelling "Take him out! Take him out!" No gambler had the nerve, you may have noticed, to approach Mr. Edward Trowbridge Collins. Our bet 13 that the redoubtable Eddie would have knocked him for a goal. The newspapers agree that baseball needs a housccleaning. A few evictions would make it easier. It transpires that Joe Jackson threw a game straightcr than he threw a ball.
A humor column riffs on the indictment of eight White Sox players, joking about betting money meant for family needs on the fixed 1919 World Series. It mocks pitcher Eddie Cicotte's guilt and notes that Joe Jackson 'threw a game straighter than he threw a ball,' reflecting public belief in the players' guilt.
New-York Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 10
THE WIFE AND THE KIDS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Evening Star · Washington, D.C.
State's Attorney Hoyne reportedly expressed uncertainty about whether Cicotte, Williams, and Jackson actually committed a prosecutable crime, noting any such act might only be a misdemeanor in Illinois. The report also touches on past gambling attempts in baseball and Brooklyn's reaction to fix rumors before their World Series.
Evening Star · 30 September 1920 · page 29
^ HICAGO, September .10.?Stati I to State's Attorney MacLay him as expressing doubt wl committed by the White Sox player C'icottc, Claude Williams and Joe Jai statement made by Oscar Felsch to / "I am uncertain." Mr. Hoyne is < lias deen committed." The statement said Mr. Hoyne h they might be prosecuted was that ( a misdemeanor in Illinois.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
The Cook County grand jury investigating baseball crookedness will continue despite State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne's request to delay until his return from New York. Officials indicate the jury will be reappointed as a special body, with a special prosecutor possibly named if Hoyne persists in his demand.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 30 September 1920 · page 1
JURY IS TO BE CONTINUED
Hughey Jennings did not show up at the offices of the Giants yesterday afternoon. hut promised to be In this morn- ' ing Hughev and Mrs. Jennings were too busy shopping for their trip to Ran Antonio. Jesse Burkett will be 'n charge of the Giant squad which will leave here a week from to-morrow.
Clipping to come
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · Keokuk, Iowa
The Cook County grand jury investigating the 1919 World Series fix will continue its work despite State's Attorney Hoyne's demand from New York that it be halted, with Judge MacDonald expected to reappoint it as a special body. Indictments against eight players and two gamblers have already been voted, and attorneys dispute Hoyne's claim that the players cannot be prosecuted.
The Daily Gate City and Constitution-Democrat · 30 September 1920 · page 1
Virginia fans are preparing to look their prettiest next 'thursday night at the Wardman Park Hotel. Tonight, at the City Club, the banquet committee will meet at 7:30 o'clock. It Is hoped that all details down to the very last will be eleaned up. leaving only Chairman Roland S. Robbins, of the entertainment committee, to labor for the good of the party. Mt. Robbins is planning an excellent vaudeville entertain ment for the fans who turn out to welcome George McBride and when he starts anything, he always fin ishes it.
See moreSee less
Washington fans are hoping that Ban Johnson will be present and, if he is. that he say something about the progress of the baseball scandal case. The fans are generally opposed to the appearance of any of the in dicted players in major league line upi and if Ban wants to make a big hit with Capital rooters, all he needs to do is to say something to the point on this bWning subject.
Clipping to come
Indiana Daily Times · Indianapolis, Ind.
Judge McDonald ordered the grand jury investigation into the Black Sox scandal to continue despite State's Attorney Hoyne's objections. The report details conflict between Hoyne and Comiskey's attorney Austrian, confirming Cicotte, Jackson, and Williams had confessed to fixing the 1919 World Series.
Indiana Daily Times · 30 September 1920 · page 12
STILL AFTER GAMBLERS (Continued From Page One.) employment or property of another * * * shall be deemed guilty of a conspiracy.” Austrian declared the men could be prosecuted under this statute. Austrian also vigorously denied the implication contained in Hoyne’s state ment as published here that the investi gation was started by enemies of Com iskey to ruin the White Sox’ chances for winning the pennant this year. Austrian announced he was asked by representatives of the State's attorney's office and Judge MacDonald if Com iskev desired to postpone the investiga tion until after the close of the present baseball season.
See moreSee less
"I told them that Mr. Comiskey would rather lose the pennant than to play a single game with u bunch of baseball players he knew to be crooked.” He also informed them he could pro duce evidence warranting indictments, and the next day the confession of Eddie Cicotte was made. It was quickly fol lowed by that of Joe Jackson and Claude Williams and an unofficial confession by Oscar Felseh.
State's Attorney Hoyne, recently defeated in the primary, expressed doubt that confessed players could be prosecuted for a confidence game since they actually threw the games as promised, suggesting only misdemeanor gambling charges might apply. He was also reported to suspect the scandal's exposure was engineered by Comiskey's enemies, and had delayed the grand jury probe pending his return from New York.
Indiana Daily Times · 30 September 1920 · page 12
court. BELIEVES COM IS KEY’S ENEMIES AT WORK. y Hoyne is declared to have tried to halt the grand jury probe because he suspected that the entire exposure of the 1919 world’s series scandal has been brought about by persons antagonistic to Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox. It is admitted that the in dictment of seven present members of the White Sox men has virtually killed the team's chances for the 1920 penn.-.nt.
State's Attorney Hoyne suggests the players might only be guilty of gambling misdemeanors since they did throw the games as promised. The passage also covers Weaver and McMullin's expected testimony, Cicotte's disappearance, Risberg's defiance, Gandil's denial from a Texas hospital, and the grand jury's expanding interest in National League corruption involving Zimmerman, Kauff, and Toney.
Indiana Daily Times · 30 September 1920 · page 12
McMuUin, it was reported, would follow Weaver. Both opened negotiations for the giving of their testimony, It was said. "Swede” Risberg, shortstop, is said to have declared he was not going to con
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · Richmond, Ind.
A sportswriter argues that eight indicted White Sox players and the scandal's fallout threaten baseball's survival, with two players having confessed and implicated others. He calls on Comiskey, other owners, and honest players to fully disclose all facts about fixed games to save the sport.
The Richmond Palladium and Sun-Telegram · 30 September 1920 · page 13
COME CLEAN!
Pitiless publicity regarding all facts! and rumors concerning alleged crook ed players and "fixed" games is me only thing that will save the sport Owner Comiskey of the White Sox has taken the right stand. He has laid all the facts at his command De
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte confessed to Chicago authorities that he and seven teammates were paid by gamblers to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati. The report lists specific payoff amounts for each player, including Cicotte, Williams, Risberg, Weaver, Jackson, Felsch, Gandil, and McMullin.
This article was wrong. The papers corrected it the next day.
Wrong
Abilene Weekly Reflector · 30 September 1920 · page 1
THREW THE GAMES
Transcript to come.
No clean clipping could be cut from this page
Abilene Weekly Reflector · Abilene, Kan.
Pitchers Cicotte and Williams, along with Joe Jackson, confessed to intentionally throwing games in the 1920 World Series for gambling money. Williams named Chick Gandil and two Boston gamblers as intermediaries, and the grand jury immediately indicted the gamblers involved.
Abilene Weekly Reflector · 30 September 1920 · page 1
The day was also enlivened by a tilt between Comlskey and Ban John son growing out of the rumors that the 1920 series has already been fixed, that the Box, half a game be hind Cleveland, dare not win the pennant, and) that Cleveland will take the world's series from Brooklyn, Brooklyn being touted as the better team, the gambling syndicate will be able to get odds for Its money. Claude Lefty Williams, Chicago pitcher, confessed his full part In throwing the world series. He said he received $10,000 of which he gave Joe Jackson half.
See moreSee less
He named Chick Gandll, former first baseman, as prin cipal go between for players and two Boston gamblers, Brown and Sulll van, as principal go betweens for the gamblers. The grand Jury Immediately in dieted the gamblers. Harry Brlgham, grand Jury foreman, said the play ers were apparently only tools in the conspiracy and ramifications of this ring extended everywhere that organ lzed baseball is known.
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
A Cook County grand jury voted indictments against eight Chicago White Sox players for conspiracy to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati for gambler payoffs. Eddie Cicotte reportedly confessed to taking a $10,000 bribe, and owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended seven active players.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 30 September 1920 · page 5
EIGHT WHITE SOX PLAYERS INDICTED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Springfield Weekly Republican · Springfield, Mass.
The report lists the eight White Sox players indicted after a grand jury investigation into the 1919 World Series fix, including Cicotte, Jackson, Gandil, Felsch, Risberg, Williams, Weaver, and McMullin. It describes leaked grand jury testimony, including Cicotte's confession of receiving $10,000 under his pillow and Jackson's account of being promised $20,000 but receiving only $5,000.
Springfield Weekly Republican · 30 September 1920 · page 5
PLAYERS INDICTED
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
Daily Kennebec Journal · Augusta, Me.
Chick Gandil, named as a ringleader in the plot to throw the 1919 World Series, is recovering from an appendicitis operation at a hospital in Lufkin, Texas. He issued a statement saying he has nothing to say about the charges and won't comment until his doctors clear him to return to work.
Daily Kennebec Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 4
Gandil Recovering From Operation, Refuses to Talk
By W. J. Macbeth Organized baseball has been handed another wnllop. Whether a black eye results remains to be seen. But fol lowing so closely as it does upon the scandal associated with the throwing of the 1919 world's series by the Chi? rac?' White Sox. the blow is certainly n< : going; to improve the countenance of ' he national sport. Heinie Zimmerman, formerly tr*?rd baseman of the New York National League club, who was dropped by Mc Graw a year ago, makes affidavit that three of his former team mates -'ill associated with the game arc dishonest.
See moreSee less
These h ? says, are Outfielder Benny K.-.-i?T and Pitchers Rube Renten and Fred Toney. Zimmerman says he car? ried an offer of bribery to the three named from a Chicago gambler, of fering each $100 to throw a gam-J to the Chicago Cubs back in 1919. We hold no brief for the lleirie Zimmermans of baseball. His affidavit condemns him in his attempt to con? demn others. He certainly convicts bimse**** as i *: accessory before the fact of alleged crime. Charge Was Common Gossip Put we do condemn those who until recently had the administration of baseball law in their keeping. What Zimmern.an has just sworn to was pub lie gossip as lonp as a year ago last December. He t?*ld his story to the **,r:tethen, but he refused to put it in affidavit. The writer informed high officials of organized baseball as to Zimmerman's charges. He has heard of no official investigation since. There seems just one hope for or? ganized baseball. His name is Judge Kei'.esaw Mountain Landis. He is the commissioner of organized baseball. Judge Landis has promised to go to the bottom of the whole baseball mess. He stems to have been serious in that de? liberation, for he has written all of the club owners in organized baseball to furnish him all the data at their fin? gers' ends. He has asked the names, ? addresses and salaries of the entire club rosters; a list of players out on optional agreement, and the terms and conditions of such agreement; the names of players suspended, and why suspended, and a list of the voluntarily retired. The judge, moreover, has demanded the names and home addresses of all officials connected with the various clubs, as well as the scout lists and various representatives in the minor leagues. It is to be presumed from this he has mapped a course of cam- - pa i i:'1. Zimmerman's chief "squawk" to the writer fifteen months ago alleged a breach of faith on the part of Mc Graw for failure to declare him in on a share of the second position m noy from the world's series. Zim was sn pended in late August without pay. He took part in 12*3 of the 140 gam? s scheduled of that year. Players Held Out Money Secretary O'Brien said yesterday this case was one in which the New York . club was not concerned. The division of money was made by the players and ;. e players voted out Zimmerman because of indifferent playing. They held, he said, that Zimmerman might have . sured them a pennant. But Mr. O'Brien admitted a contract for $12.1 b en ? . ered Zimmer? man next spring. To offer Zimmerman <t contract if .-itwere uis'u ?nest was all wrong. To attempt to drive him from the game by sucn an insult if he were honest was quite as shameful. It smacked of the "backstairs politics" which ..;-.ve disgraced baseball for many years. It is to be hoped Judge Lan??3 will immediately go to the bottom of the Zimmerman charges. Kauff, who is implicated, is under indictment on a charge of alleged automobile thievery. Benton, also accused, has admitted win? ning money on the 1919 world's series, which it is said he knew was "fixed" an oifei.se which drove Joe Gedeon from the St. Loui? Browns.
Clipping to come
Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.
A confessional account (apparently a player's statement, likely Jackson's) describes being approached about fixing the World Series, naming Eddie Cicotte, Chick Gandil, Buck Weaver, Happy Felsch, and two men called Brown and Sullivan who claimed to represent gamblers offering $85,000. The player describes payments being delayed and suspecting a double-cross when promised money did not arrive on schedule.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 2
charge of alleged automobile thievery. Benton, also accused, has admitted win? ning money on the 1919 world's series, which it is said he knew was "fixed" an oifei.se which drove Joe Gedeon from the St. Loui? Browns. The cases of Kauff and Benton are identical with tu se of the indicted White Sox players." Until they can clear themselves to public satisfaction they should have no part in baseball. Tne country will look to Judge Landis for signal action. It is not likely to be disappointed.
Clipping to come
Great Falls Daily Tribune · Great Falls, Mont.
Pitcher Lefty Williams testifies before the grand jury about receiving money from Gandil after the fourth game, describing envelopes marked for himself and Jackson. A separate item reports New York authorities investigating rumors that gamblers plan to bribe Brooklyn players in the upcoming World Series.
Great Falls Daily Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 2
aay poetpoaemeat,” _._;_ (AandaM Press) CHICAGO, March 9—An attempt to obtain a postponement Of six months In the trial of the Chicago White Sox baseball players Indicted' for the al leged throwing of the 1919 world ser ies probably Jvill be made next Mon day when the case Is called, according to attorney^ who will prosecute the a case. Indications however, were that " not more than one month's delay would be granted. Judge Georgs Barrett, who . was re tained, about a week ago by the Am erican league to represent It at the trial, today said that he had come in to the case so recently that he was not familar with its’ details and wanted additional time to look Into It.
See moreSee less
Six months would *be desirable, he said. Two state attorneys assigned to the case have been called out of the city, It was said at the state’s attorneys’ office and consequently the delay would be necessary., Judge William El.' Dever who Is to preside, was 111 today, but ,hls clerk said that the judge had Indicated that he would not grant “much more than a month’s delay." Judge Dever frequent ly has expressed a desire to get the trial started as quickly as possible.
Clipping to come
Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.
The U.S. Treasury's income tax unit announced it would investigate whether Chicago White Sox players failed to report money received for throwing the 1919 World Series on their tax returns. Deputy Commissioner George B. Newton said prosecutions would follow if irregularities were found, noting intentional tax evasion carried penalties of a $10,000 fine or up to one year imprisonment.
Omaha Daily Bee · 30 September 1920 · page 10
On Money Given Them " Washington, Sept. 29. Should an investigation disclose that the Chi cago White Sox 'players vho, rt teived money for "throwiieg" the
An Omaha newspaper recounts how Police Judge Fitzgerald and friends who attended the 1919 World Series believed the White Sox had simply 'gone stale,' citing poor play by Jackson, Felsch, Cicotte, and especially Eddie Collins. The piece reflects on the ongoing Chicago grand jury investigation into the alleged fixing of the series.
Omaha Daily Bee · 30 September 1920 · page 10
JfcVBK JBENTON.. 'When Police . Judge .JameV M. FitzgtrAld, Ralph Roche, Frank Afahbney, Dfck Maher and ; other members of a little Omaha p.arty at the world's series last year saw the wretched display of Jackson, .Felsch, Cicotte and othrr indicted members of the White Sox team they felt that Gleason's crew was "through" -tljat the great White Sox team had "gone stale." "They played like a bunch of ama teurs;" smiled Judge Fitzgerald, when he read an account of the scandal probe in Chicago. "With the possible exception of Joe Jackson, Eddie Collins put up the most wretched exhibition of all.
See moreSee less
Collins couldn't get anything" between, him and first base" 'Every1 time he came to bat his btest effort resulted in a erounder to the ditcher or: to the shortstop. Weaver appeared to me. to be. playing good ball. Kisberg we knew to be erratic, so we didn't sec anything unusual in hi& playing.
An editorial reflects on the shock of learning the 1919 World Series was fixed, calling it a devastating blow to baseball and American fandom. It praises White Sox owner Charles Comiskey, "The Old Roman," for immediately suspending the indicted players despite the cost to his team's pennant chances.
Omaha Daily Bee · 30 September 1920 · page 10
their honor for gold. ; . II is indeed-'a cfuel blow to American' fandom. But more, it, is a witherincr blight ori orofessional base ball. It is inevitable that fans will Id IVII. nnriC3 r. .JimMt V ! tiu iritcai ui jiaii:. xit lias been, called ."The Old Roman." His immediate suspension of, the in dicte'' pinvors coining at a time when his club war's in a neck-and-iicck race, for the pennant, shows him to merit the title. His lifetime has been devoted to building the great White Sox machine and presiding it a home second to pone.
See moreSee less
Yet When the indictmcSts were returned he wrecked that, machine with a single blow. , " . q An indictment is-not a conviction.. Comiskcy 'could have chosen to finish the season. with his team intact, but by wreckirtg it he revealed that true American sportsmanship values honor above honors. Long live the Old Roman v , t r
Claude Williams confessed to the grand jury, joining Cicotte and Jackson in admitting the 1919 World Series fix, and named Chick Gandil as chief go-between along with gamblers Brown and Sullivan. He said he and Jackson were promised $20,000 each but he only received $10,000, splitting it with Jackson, and that Bill Burns and Abe Attell arranged $100,000 for the Sox players.
The Oakes Times · 30 September 1920 · page 1
BALL PLAYERS IN BIG SCANDAL
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Bismarck Tribune · Bismarck, N.D.
Chicago's Cook county grand jury investigation continues despite state's attorney Hoyne's objections, with Chief Justice McDonald vowing to proceed. Happy Felsch's confession reveals he received $5,000 but was promised $20,000, while McGraw and Heydler testified about related gambling cases involving Hal Chase and Lee Magee.
The Bismarck Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 1
OTHERS ARE TO CONFESS?
No "baseball session" was schedul ed for today. However, it was re ported that two other baseball piayeis members of the White Sox, have been negotiating to tell what they know bf the grand jury plot and it is be lieved the grand jury will care for this contingency if the players desire to confess. One of the ironies of the "throw ing" of the world series is related in the confession of "Happy" Felsch centerfielder. The one glaring erroi he made was accidental—others were made purposely. Felsch said he re ceivced $5,000, which he found in hislocker at the club house, but that "he never had a chance to really help lose the series."
See moreSee less
When he made tho one glaring error, other players warned him not to be so, "raw" he said. Felsch said he had been promised $20,000 but was double-crossed, he .be lieved by Abe Attell and Chick Gau dil. Felsch denied that the White Sox had thrown any games this season and said the men implicated in the bribery had felt all season that they would be exposed sooner or later. He confirmed the confessions of Cicotte and Jackson. John Heydler, president of the
McGraw and Heydler testified before the grand jury about the Lee Magee, Hal Chase, and Heinie Zimmerman gambling cases, with McGraw explaining why he dropped Chase and Zimmerman from his team. Heydler recounted his investigation into Comiskey's suspicions and the confession he and Veeck obtained from Magee.
The Bismarck Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 1
OTHERS ARE TO CONFESS?
Heydler's testimony was largely the interview he gave newspaper men Sunday night telling of his pri vate investigaton how Comiskey had told him a year ago he suspected some of the White Sox players and
Assistant state's attorney Hartley Replogle says he has identified the man who allegedly fixed White Sox players, with the name given to a special grand jury. The report also notes testimony that NL president Heydler said player Magee confessed to taking part in throwing several games.
The Bismarck Tribune · 30 September 1920 · page 1
PROSECUTOR IN BASEBALL PROBE
BASEBALL PROBE! Hartley L. Kepoglo (Top) and Henry l'rigliani (Lower) CHICAGO'- Hartley .Repogle (top), assistant state's attorney, who is conducting the investiga tion of the charges that the world series last year was "fixed" for Cincinnati to win, declared he has the name of the man who is al leged to have "fixed" the members of the White Sox, which has been given to the special grand jury. The lower picture shows Henry R. Brigham, foreman of the grand jury, which is investigatin'g the scandal charges. N
The Cook County grand jury voted true bills against eight Chicago White Sox players, including Cicotte, Jackson, and Weaver, for conspiracy related to throwing the 1919 World Series. The report also notes a possible IRS investigation into unreported bribe money and recounts Billy Maharg's statement implicating Cicotte, Burns, and Attell in arranging the fix.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 30 September 1920 · page 1
BASEBALL PLAYERS
The words of this article could not be separated from the rest of its page. Read it in the clipping.
Billy Maharg recounts how Eddie Cicotte and Abe Attell arranged the fix with gamblers, but the players were double-crossed and received only $10,000 of a promised $100,000. The grand jury continues gathering evidence involving Attell, Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman, and others, with more indictments expected.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 30 September 1920 · page 1
Cost Comlskey $230,000 In^ctquentB of his #even players cost chas. a.j Comlskey, owner af the White Sox, %230,000 the •mount for -.which he could have sold their services, he said today. The grand jury -today sent a telegram to Cngene Dubyc, of tbe Toledo team, of. the .American As sociation, formerly with the Tigers and Giants -asking him :te appear Monday. Evidence already placed before' the grand, jury, It' is known, in voIve^ Babe Attell, former prize fighter, Lem Magee, Hal Chase, and Hlenie vZlmmerman, former of the Giants threfe eastern gamblers, whose napes have not been divulg ed' and at least 2 national league players. Harfey Replogle, assistant states attorney, who today confir?n „ej! these,, t^cts,, .i*dpiitted, that ten •or twelve indictment^ were in pros
The report covers the aftermath of the Chicago grand jury's true bills against eight White Sox players, noting indictments were still being formalized with possible charges of conspiracy carrying up to five years imprisonment or $10,000 fines. It includes testimony details, including Jackson's claim of being promised $20,000 but receiving $5,000, and Williams' admission of intentionally pitching poorly, while Cicotte reportedly fled to Detroit amid worries about tax implications of the bribes.
Jamestown Weekly Alert · 30 September 1920 · page 1
to $10-000. Pitcher Cicotte was quoted in Chicago papers today as saying he was worried about the status of baseball bribes in income tax re turns. The eight players indicted are "apparently only tools ®T a gambl ing ring", according to Harry Brig ham, foreman of the igrand jury. The ramifications of this ring, he said, extend everywhere that pro fessional baseball is known. "It is evident that some of these "boys yielded to the Influence of doubtless will on, Mr. 'Brigham said. "I er
As a Chicago grand jury investigates the 1919 World Series fix, New York authorities open an inquiry into rumors that gamblers plan to bribe Brooklyn players to lose the 1920 series to Cleveland. The report also recounts confessions by Williams and Felsch admitting they took money to throw the 1919 series, with Williams giving half his $10,000 to Jackson.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 1
CROOKED WORLD'S SERIES PLANNED BY GAMBLERS IN 1920, IS THE RUMOR
-j i OV (BY THE ASSOCIATED PRESS) New York, Sept. 29. While a Chicago grand Jury was Investi gating charges that the 1919 world's series was "fixed" New
Claude Williams and Happy Felsch gave confessions admitting they were bribed to throw the World Series, with Williams detailing payments and a meeting at a hotel with gamblers known as Brown and Sullivan. The grand jury also indicted two men under those names, though investigators believe them to be aliases for already-known figures.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 1
WILLIAMS AND FELSCH BARE DETAILS OF PLOT
ial in tho state's attorney's office. The statement by Williams and the newspaper reports of Felsch's confession tallied with those made yesterday by Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson. They revealed that laat year's world series was settled in a tiny room in a small south side hotel. In this room, occupied by Eddie Cicotte, once the American league' leading pitcher, the deal was made which "threw' the world's series wrecked a wnrld championship team and brounht some of the
John Heydler and John McGraw gave grand jury testimony about the Hal Chase, Lee Magee, and Heinie Zimmerman gambling cases, describing how players were dropped from teams due to suspected game-fixing. McGraw said he removed Chase and Zimmerman despite the cost to his team, while Heydler recounted his private investigation and Magee's confession.
Albuquerque Morning Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 2
want such men on the club." Heydler's testimony was largely the lnt' i vlew he gave newspaper men Sunday night telling of his private Investigation; how Comls kev had told him a year ago he suspected some of the White Sox nlavers and how he and wiiuam Veerk. president of the Chicago Cubs, had obtained a confession from Lee Magee.
A player testifies before the grand jury about being promised $20,000 but receiving only $10,000, of which he gave half to Jackson. He describes meetings with gamblers Gandil, Attell and Burns, and his suspicion that the players had been double-crossed on the payoff.
The Sun and the New York Herald · 30 September 1920 · page 2
were Duck Weaver, Eddie Clcotte, Chick Oandll, Happy Pelich nnd my self. Q. And what conversation did you have there? A. We aBked him when we wore roIiir to cot the 1100,000 that Hums nnd Attell were auppourd to give us. He aavi: "They are mippoaed to give me 120,000 or $30,000 after each Rame," Which If they gave him that, I know nothing of at nil. Q. When did he say you would get eome money? A, Hq didn't nay; ho didn't make any statement. I wa u poned at first to get no much get J 10,000 after the fourth game.
See moreSee less
Q. And how much did you receive after tho fourth game? A. Ton thousand dollars. Q. Did you keep tho ten? A. No, I did not. Q. How much did you keep? A. I kept 15,000 of It. Q, Five thousand wan for you and 15,000 for Jnckson? A. That wa what I was Instructed.
National League president John Heydler tells the Grand Jury that baseball's governing structure, the National Commission led by Garry Herrmann and Ban Johnson, failed to investigate the 1919 World Series scandal due to conflicts of interest. He criticizes the lack of a unified governing body and notes the eight indicted White Sox players were allowed to play the entire season despite suspicions.
The Sun and the New York Herald · 30 September 1920 · page 2
ing between President Johnson of Uie Amorican League nnd Charles Comlskey of the White Sox mitigated against any real assistance from President, Johnson. "Tli fact aro self-evident tho eight Indicted player of the Whlto Sox havo been pcrmlted to play nit season. Presi dent Comlskey of tho Whlto Sox at tho close ot tho world's series held up their check for uovcral weeks. With a big
The report describes infighting among State's Attorney staff over control of the Black Sox grand jury investigation, with Replogle promising more indictments against gamblers and possibly players. It also includes a player's (Kelsch) confession-like account of how the White Sox conspirators planned to throw games and how Cicotte secured his payoff.
The Sun and the New York Herald · 30 September 1920 · page 2
Just the moment wa tu? nur lli.yers on the ovldonco connecting htm with tho fixing of the White Sox players wfc will vote a true bill." The Grand Jury la not expected fo hold n "baseball" session to-morrow. However, It is known that two more players are negotiating to confess, and if they do this will change the plan, and iucuvn nui uv jicuru io-ay.
Brooklyn's Kings County DA investigates reports that gamblers tried to fix the 1920 World Series, summoning Dodger players for questioning while Zack Wheat denies any approach. Meanwhile in Chicago, Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch reportedly confess to taking bribes to throw the 1919 series, and two gamblers are indicted.
The Morning Tulsa Daily World · 30 September 1920 · page 1
MORE WHITE SOX CONFESS
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The grand jury investigating the Black Sox scandal returned indictments against two alleged gamblers using the names "Brown" and "Sullivan," believed to be aliases used by players when discussing the fix. Officials suspected these aliases might actually represent two nationally known men already named in testimony, as confessions from Williams, Cicotte, Jackson, and Felsch continued to implicate Arnold Rothstein and others in planning the fix.
The Morning Tulsa Daily World · 30 September 1920 · page 1
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
The grand jury investigation into the Black Sox scandal is temporarily halted pending State's Attorney Maclay Hoyne's return from New York, with additional witnesses like Kauff and Toney still to be summoned. Hoyne reportedly expressed doubt that any felony was committed, suggesting only a gambling misdemeanor charge might apply, while Felsch's confession to the grand jury is still pending.
The Chattanooga News · 30 September 1920 · page 14
CHICAGO PROBE MARKING TIME
published here today credited to State) Attorney Mnrlny Hoyne. who I In New York, ciunted htm a expressing doubt whether any serious leral offen was rum mi.tad by the White Son pin vera named In the confession of Fid dle Cicotte, Claud Williams and Jo Jackson before the grand Jury and the statement made by 0ar Felach to newspapers. "1 am uncertain." Mr Horn if quoted a snylng, "whether any crime haa been onmmltted." The statement aald Mr. Hoyne field that the only rharg under which they might be prosecuted was that of gambling or conspir acy to gamble, a misdemeanor in Illlnola. I
The passage reports grand jury testimony in the Black Sox scandal, including conflicting statements about Felsch's alleged $5,000 payment and his denial of wrongdoing. Claude Williams names Brown and Sport Sullivan as the gamblers who paid him and Jackson, while Weaver denies involvement despite being suspended.
The Chattanooga News · 30 September 1920 · page 14
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Pitcher Eddie Cicotte details how Gandil and others recruited him to throw the series, and how he demanded $10,000 cash in advance to pay off his farm mortgage, finding the money under his pillow before the first game. Joe Jackson's confession account also begins, describing his call to Judge McDonald after learning of his indictment.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 30 September 1920 · page 10
JOE JACKSON'S CONFESSION
a ball. All In on tlie Denl. "We all talked quite a while about it. Yes, nil of us decided to do our best to throw the games to Cincinnati. Then Gandil and McMullIn took us ..all, one by one. away from the others and we talked turkey. They asked ' me my price. I told them $10,000 paid - In advance. 'It was Gandil I was talking to. He wanted to give mo some money at the time and the rest after the games we.ro played and lost. " "Cash in advance, not C.
See moreSee less
O. TV I reminded him. 'If you can't trust me. 1 can't trust you. ray or 1 play ?Tball.' "Well, the argument went on for some days, but I stood pat. I wanted j that } 10,000 and 1 got it. "How 1 wish that 1 had not'. "Tho day before I went to CincinJ .Jnatl I put it up to them squarely |
McGraw and Heydler give grand jury testimony describing suspected game-fixing by Hal Chase, Heinie Zimmerman, Lee Magee, and Benny Kauff, including Magee's partial confession to Heydler and Veeck. A related item notes the IRS may prosecute players who failed to report bribe money as taxable income.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 30 September 1920 · page 10
?%. ? ' Tells of InveMtlgatlana. Heydler's testimony was largely the Interview he gave newspapermen f, 'Sunday night, telling of his private i"*?Investigation: how Comiskey had told him a year ago he. suspected some of the White Sex plajers. and how h5 ?" aW! William Vceck, president of the , fc,5".{lUcago Cubs, had obtained a con
The grand jury investigation continues with reports of two Des Moines brothers who bet on the tipped 'fixed' series, and Jean Dubuc summoned after Rube Benton's claims about a Hal Chase telegram. Comiskey receives public support, and Williams gives a sworn statement describing Gandil first raising the fix idea in New York.
Richmond Times-Dispatch · 30 September 1920 · page 10
Dubuc Got Tip to Met on Iledn. The summoning of Jean Dubuc to testify before the grand jury, it was learned, followed statements by Pitcher "Itube" Benton, of the Giants, last week that Dubuc had received a tele-gram from Hal Choso last fall during the world's series, advising him to bet on Cincinnati. Benton said he read the telegram over Dubuc'-s shoulder. The Toledo player is also to be questioned, it was said, about reports that -games were "fixed" on a barn storming tour in which he and Chase participated last fall.
See moreSee less
Chase, according to information in the hands of the State's attorney, re ceived an offer to "throw" the first game of the barnstorming series, which was played with the Atlantic City Giants, a ne<gro team, at Phila delphia. Chase is said to have made live errors in that game. When President Comiskey arrived at his office today lie found enough letters and telegrams waiting for him to fill two good-sized barrels. Baseball officials, players and fans from all parts of the country tele graphed their sympathy, and con gratulated the old Jtoman on the manner in which lie had cleared his team of the aeeused players. "It's been tough, hut I feel better now," Comiskey remarked after read ing some of the messages. "i am glad the worst is over." he added. "The boys who are left arc clean; they have never sold a ball game and they never will." AVIlllnmn Make* Clean l^reaat.
Pitcher Lefty Williams confessed to the Cook County Grand Jury, implicating gamblers 'Sport' Sullivan and Brown in fixing the World Series for $5,000. Felsch and McMullin also reportedly confessed and received payoffs, following earlier confessions by Cicotte and Jackson.
The Bennington Evening Banner · 30 September 1920 · page 1
WILLIAMS CONFESSES
Commissioner of Baseball. almost a year ago. I lers in the 1919 world's series. tllinois lav to have said indictments voided at once. .-??em brazenly thrust into the case at this time. order to embarrass or disgust him. By W. J. MACBETH
Clipping to come
Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.
Newspaper excerpts describe confessions by Eddie Cicotte, Claude Williams, and Joe Jackson about conspiring with gamblers to throw World Series games. The players detail meeting gamblers individually to strike deals and reveal payments, including $5,000 given to Jackson.
National League president John Heydler testified before the grand jury investigating baseball gambling, detailing the Lee Magee and Hal Chase cases and the dropping of Heinie Zimmerman. A White Sox player reportedly said he was promised $5,000 but was double-crossed, and named Abe Attell and another man as responsible for the betrayal.
iUC Lin m M'f. FELCH MADE REAL ERROR and he was warned afterwards by other players not to he so awkward not want to "get In on the deal" at but the other players at the hotel e.renri? initi unit il w uuni lie fittt . said he had beep promised $;r,fiO0, was double-crossed, Abt; Attell and dll were the ones ho believed guilty hn double-crosslne. elsch denied' that the White Sox had men Implicated in the bribery had all season they would be exposed ner or later. He confirmed the conterday KlDLKIi IICirVKh liKAiNU JUIil ohn Heydler, president of the Naiai braguri Uliu uuini ..iiwitv, iiiAiii.- of the New Vork Giants, to-day told jury details of the Lee Macee and Chase cases and also of dropping einie Ziimmerman.
See moreSee less
wcuraw was re sted to return Tuesday and bring iny Kauff, outfielder. Heydler was ed to appear again at his convenn after tho world Reries.
The report describes testimony before the grand jury including Lee Magee's confession to Veeck about taking part in throwing games, and details of Hal Chase's gambling activities that led to his being dropped by the Giants. It also mentions suspicions about Benny Kauff and two Des Moines brothers who placed bets on the World Series after being tipped it was fixed.
The grand jury investigation into the Black Sox scandal continues, with reports of Cicotte testifying in tears and alleged bribes of $5,000 to $10,000 found hidden under pillows or beds of implicated players. Baseball officials including Giants manager John McGraw and National League president John Heydler appeared at the courthouse to testify.
M for the state, but defense at taneys said this would be con tend. A postponement of 30 days is 'mrht br the defense to allow forW Judge Barrett, American league Ittorney, to siuay ine grana jury iridence and charges.
Clipping to come
Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.
A Chicago grand jury indicted eight White Sox players for conspiring with gamblers to throw the 1919 World Series to Cincinnati, with Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson confessing to taking bribes. Owner Charles Comiskey immediately suspended seven of his stars despite the team's pennant race with Cleveland.
INDICT SOX PLAYERS FOR THROWING WORLD SERIES TO THE REDS
The Indicted Players. The White Sox players indicted h connection with the alleged con niricy .were Edward V. Cicotte, fttchex who lost two games and toe one in the series; Claude Wil Htms, pitcher, who lost three limes; Joe Jackson, outfielder; Orar Felsch, outfielder; Charles A.
Clipping to come
Burlington Weekly Free Press · Burlington, Vt.
The Cook County grand jury returned indictments against seven White Sox players and a former player for conspiring with gamblers to throw the 1919 World Series, and owner Comiskey immediately suspended them. Pitcher Eddie Cicotte tearfully confessed before the grand jury, describing how he deliberately pitched to lose after finding money hidden under his pillow by gamblers.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
Happy Felsch's confession, printed by the Chicago Evening American and given to the grand jury, admits he took $5,000 and calls himself guilty as the rest. He says he found the money mysteriously left in his locker, suspects Gandil and later Abe Attell of controlling the payoffs, and insists he missed a fly ball by accident, not design.
The Milwaukee Leader · 30 September 1920 · page 10
Happy Felsch In Confession Admits Getting $5,000 "Guilty As the Rest," He Says; Found Coin in His Locker
RADICAL ARRESTS Cleveland, O., March 14.—Most of the arrests for alleged radicals sinde the war-were made by private detec tives unlawfully in the pay of the de partment of justice, said Louis F. Post, former secretary of labor.
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
An unnamed White Sox player describes the mechanics of the fix, suspecting Gandil or Abe Attell of shorting the payoff money, and recounts deliberately or accidentally muffing a fly ball during the Series. He says he plans to go with Weaver to tell the state's attorney, while a separate note describes the depleted White Sox lineup after the suspensions.
The Milwaukee Leader · 30 September 1920 · page 10
Chicago, March 14.—Batting and fielding averages of the eight Chicago White Sox basebaU players charged with throwing the *1919 world series will be introduced by the defense in contending the innocence of the in dicted men whose trials began here today, according to their attorneys. Attorneys for the defense have made no secret of the fact that they will contend that none of the, players actually made deliberate misplays or actually took part in any game throw ing. It is known that they will con fend there was no conspiracy, for that was brought out in affidavits filed when the defense (Jemanded a bill of particulars in .the case a few weeks -ago.
See moreSee less
In proof of this' contention, the world series batting arid fielding aver ages of the accused players as com pared w^th the averages of their op ponents and their own regular aver ages will be offered as evidence. The ^ate then will be challenged, it is be lieved, to prove that the players did not do their best to win and that they made iqore than the normal number of errors to be expected when under the strain of world series games. The averages of the players con cerned show that Buck Weaver, third baseman, outhit. and outfielded his opponent, Heinio Groh, and also surpassed his own regular season averages, both fielding and batting. Jackson equalled Weaver's feat, but Risberg and Felsch were outplayed mathematically by their opponents and fell slightly below their own regu lar season averages. Gandil also was below his opponent and his regular
Clipping to come
The Milwaukee Leader · Milwaukee, Wis.
With seven regulars suspended, Manager Gleason assembles a patchwork lineup using substitutes like McClellan, Murphy, and Leibold to face the Browns. Gleason expresses relief that the truth about the 1919 World Series fix came to light, despite the blow to his pennant hopes.
The Milwaukee Leader · 30 September 1920 · page 10
Bowling'Teams Have En tered Annual Event. Ten Grand Forks bowling teams have been entered in the City Handi cap bowling tournament, which will open here Tuesday evening on the Wilde allays. The five-men team events will be started on Tuesday, the first shift commqncirlg at 7 p. m. Six teams will accupy the alleys. At 9:30 o'clock the second shift will start with four teams getting ipto action. The teams are composed of the best bowlers in the city and close compe tition is expected. All of the Grand Forks ball slingers are going at their best at the present time and some top heavy scores are expected before the tourney closes.
See moreSee less
The single and double events will be started Wednesday evening. The teams will line up aq follows on the alleys tomorrow night:
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
A Cincinnati dispatch reports that the Hamilton county grand jury will investigate Eddie Cicotte's confession that he found bribe money under his pillow at a hotel after losing the first game of the 1919 World Series. The grand jury is expected to convene soon to examine the matter.
The Telegraph-Courier · 30 September 1920 · page 1
OHIO JURY TO ACT.
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
The Associated Press reports that seven current White Sox players and one former player were indicted the previous day in connection with the alleged fixing of the 1919 World Series. Club attorney Alfred S. Austrian states that additional confessions are expected soon to supplement those already given by Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson.
The Telegraph-Courier · 30 September 1920 · page 1
White Hose Players) Cllle.UiO, Manli 1.1 TinrnD of CIiIpiikij White Sox baseball players and others indicted for tho IlllcKed Ihl'OWlUK of the 1319 World hoi leu, U scheduled to bu railed by JuiIro William 13 Dever of the county courts tomorrow, but a postponement of nt least 30 thus Is considered ceflaln. Tho state tonlKht reiterated its Intention of movInK to have the caso taken off of tho court call, whkh would prevent Its coniltiK up for nt lenHt six mouth. while tho defene was prepared to fltflit any attempt to postpone th trial for tnoiu than 30 adyit.
See moreSee less
That !?:iRth of lime would bo Kr.Tntod as u courtesy to Judce Scolt, Ameri can leaRue attorney, so that he could familiarize himself with tho charRes, it was wild. Cl. udi! Williams. Jon .laeksort, O.scat Kelsch, Iluck Weaver, l'-red Mc.Mullln and Swede UlsberR to nlRht were ready to t!n Into court, while Kddle Cleotte was expected to reach here frot Detroit tomor row. Chick (landll, thu other In dicted player, was not, expected. No word has been received from Hal Chase, Kachel llrown, Hill Hums1 or Joseph J. Sullivan, charRcd with beltiR tho men who nrranKcd tho alleged conspiracy.
Clipping to come
The Telegraph-Courier · Kenosha, Wis.
Pitcher Claude 'Lefty' Williams became the third White Sox player to confess to the Cook County grand jury that the team threw the 1919 World Series, with Joe Jackson stating Williams received $5,000. A Chicago paper separately published a purported confession from Oscar 'Happy' Felsch claiming the eight players were cheated out of an even split of $100,000.
The Telegraph-Courier · 30 September 1920 · page 1
Williams Confesses Gamblers Indicted
The scan of this page is too worn for a reliable transcript. Read it in the clipping.