As the Papers Told It

Black Sox · As the Papers Told It

Act Two

World Series of 1919 Fixed

September – October 1920

In late September 1920, with the White Sox half a game behind Cleveland, the story broke. Billy Maharg of Philadelphia said the players had been promised $100,000, with Abe Attell as go-between, and had been paid only part of it. Eight players were indicted on 28 September and Comiskey suspended seven of them, giving up the pennant. Cicotte, Jackson and Williams confessed to the grand jury, and on 29 October thirteen men were formally indicted for conspiracy.

A year later, a new pennant race

September 1920, and the White Sox are chasing another pennant. In the first of three games expected to decide the American League race they beat Cleveland 10 to 3, Dick Kerr pitching on with a split finger and Jackson, Felsch and Schalk leading the attack. Cleveland’s lead is down to half a game. On 28 September Jackson and Felsch were indicted, and their suspension all but ended Chicago’s hopes.

Grand Forks Herald · Grand Forks, N.D.

Grand Forks Herald · 24 September 1920 · page 8 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Schang.

AMERICAN LEAGUE

See moreSee less

Cleveland, Sept. 24.—The Cleveland team yesterday met Chicago in the first of a series of three games that is expected to decide the American League championship, and broke down under the attack of the White Sox, losing by 10 to 3. Chicago outplayed the Indians in every department of the game. As a result, Cleveland now leads Chicago by only half a game.

Available space in the park was taken, with the exception of right field, where Manager Speaker protested against permitting spectators to gather. However, only three balls were caught by the right fielders. It was the presence of the crowd in left field that started the downfall of the Indians, as Jackson received credit for a two-base hit in starting the sixth inning that would have been an easy out for Left Fielder Evans had the public not been allowed to take possession of that part of the field.

Although he split his finger in the fourth inning, Dick Kerr pitched masterly ball throughout. Jackson, Felsch and Schalk led in the attack on the Cleveland pitchers. Every member of the White Sox except J.

Collins made at least one hit. Score: R. H. E. Chicago .... 000 103 150—10 15 1 Cleveland .. 100 000 020— 3 8 3 Kerr and Schalk; Bagby, Caldwell, Uhle and O'Neill.

Boston yesterday, 7 to 6 and 6 to 1. Stengel had a home run in each game. Pitcher McQuillan scored Boston's only run in the second game, with a home run liner into the left field bleachers. Scores:

See the clipping

A Philadelphia boxer tells how it was done

Billy Maharg, a former boxer, tells a Philadelphia paper that Eddie Cicotte offered to throw the series for $100,000, that Abe Attell handled the gamblers’ side, and that the players, short-paid, turned and won the third game, costing Maharg and his partner Bill Burns ‘every cent we had’. Comiskey wires him to repeat it to the grand jury. Burns would be the state’s star witness at the trial.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · Birmingham, Ala.

The Birmingham Age-Herald · 28 September 1920 · page 13 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

MAHARG SAID TO HAVE BEEN TOLD 3 GAMES "FIXED"

Comiskey Asks Former Boxer to Present Evidence Before Grand Jury Probing Baseball Scandal

See moreSee less

By Associated Press

Chicago, September 27.—President Charles Comiskey, of the Chicago American league club, tonight received word that Billy Maharg, former boxer and a business partner of Billy Burns, ex-major league pitcher, has told newspaper men in Philadelphia that the White Sox players approached him before the world series last year and told him it had been "fixed" for Cincinnati to win.

President Comiskey immediately telegraphed Marharg asking him to come here and present his evidence to the Cook county grand jury. Comiskey said he would give Maharg $10,000 if his charges were proven.

"Furthermore, I'll see that every player affected is barred from organized baseball forever."

The statement said Eddie Cicotte, who lost two games in the series, approached him, saying he could furnish sufficient players to throw the game.

White Sox were offered $100,000 for throwing the series, said Maharg, but received only $10,000, double crossing them. Maharg's statement as received by Comiskey, virtually was as follows:

"Last fall Cicotte approached Bill Burns and myself in a hotel in New York. He told us that he could supply enough players to assure the throwing of the game. We made the deal. Abe Attell acting as the 'fixer' or 'go-between.'

"The Sox were double-crossed and so were many of the gamblers by Attell, however, and Burns and I lost every cent we had by betting on Cincinnati to win the third game of the series which we thought also had been fixed. We cleaned up on the first two games.

"According to the story Cicotte told us, eight Sox players were in on the deal. They were the men whose names have been most prominently connected with the Chicago grand jury investigation.

"Thousands and thousands of dollars were made on the series but the men who engineered the deal were double crossed and got left out in the cold."

THREE GAMES "THROWN"

Philadelphia, September 27.—The first, second and third games of last year's world's series were "thrown" to Cincinnati by eight members of the Chicago Americans, according to revelations said to have been made by Billy Maharg, former boxer and well known in local sporting circles.

Maharg's story, as printed today in the Philadelphia North American, says that he and "Bill Burns, former American League pitcher, were the first to be approached in the conspiracy.

"I received a wire from Burns from New York the middle of last September inviting me to take a hunting trip with him down on his ranch in New Mexico, said Maharg. 'We were to take Bill James, one of the White Sox pitchers, with us. James had nothing to do with subsequent events, but while we were there in the room talking Cicotte came in and started to talk in a low voice to Burns.

"I heard enough to know that he said that a group of prominent players of the White Sox would be willing to 'throw' the coming world's series if a syndicate of gamblers would give them $100,000 on the morning of the first game.

"When Cicotte left Burns turned to me and repeated Cicotte's conversation, part of which I had heard. Burns said 'do you know any gamblers who would be interested in this proposition?'

"I said I would go to Philadelphia and see what I could do. Burns said he would go to Montreal to close an oil deal and that he would wire about the progress of the deal.

SAW GAMBLERS

"I then went to Philadelphia and saw some gamblers there. They told me that it was too big a proposition for them to handle and directed me to Arnold Rothstein, a well-known and wealthy New York gambler. In the meantime Burns had returned to New York and I went over again and joined him. We met Rothstein by appointment and put the proposition up to him. He declined to get into it. He said he did not think that such a frame-up could be possible.

"We left Rothstein and hung around New York for a while. I returned to Philadelphia, thinking that everything was off until I received the following telegram from Bill Burns. It read:

"'Arnold R. has gone through with everything. Got eight in, leaving for Cincinnati at 4:30.'

"I went the next day and joined Burns. He said that after I had left New York he ran into Abe Attell, the fighter, who had gone to Rothstein and fixed things up. Burns said he had seen Cicotte and that eight members of the team were in the deal. Attell was then quartered in a large suite of the Sinton and had a gang of about 25 New York gamblers with him. He said they were working for Rothstein.

"I had my first suspicion on the morning of the first game when Burns and I visited Attell. We asked for the $100,000 to turn over to the White Sox players to carry out our part of the deal.

"Attell refused to turn over the $100,000, saying that they needed the money to make bets. He made a counter-proposals that $20,000 would be handed the players at the end of each losing game. Burns went to the Sox players and they seemed satisfied with the new arrangements.

"Burns told me that he saw the players were restless and wanted the full amount, and he was afraid they would not keep up the agreement.

"The players, however, told Burns that if they lost behind Cicotte and Williams, they wouldn't win for Kerr. So we went to Chicago and bet all of our personal winnings of the first two days on Cincinnati to win the third game. As a matter of fact, the Sox got even with us by winning this game Burns and I lost every cent we had in our clothes. The whole upshot of the matter was that Attell and his gang cleaned up a fortune and the Sox players were double-crossed out of $90,000 that was coming to them."

See the clipping

Eight indicted, and a confession

The Cook County grand jury indicts seven White Sox players and a former one, Chick Gandil, and Comiskey suspends the seven with his team half a game out of first place. A court official says Eddie Cicotte has confessed: $10,000 for himself and $5,000 for Joe Jackson, found under their pillows the night before the first game. Next day Lefty Williams testified that he paid Jackson himself.

The Daily Star-Mirror · Moscow, Idaho

The Daily Star-Mirror · 28 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

CHICAGO WHITE SOX INDICTED FOR THROWING WORLD SERIES

CHICAGO—(By A. P.)—Seven members of the Chicago White Sox, and one of the former players were today indicted by the Cook county grand jury, charged with conspiracy to commit an illegal act in connection with last year's world series, in which they have been accused of "selling" to a coterie of gamblers.

See moreSee less

President Comiskey immediately suspended seven, thereby forfeiting all chances of winning the American league pennant.

The White Sox were only half a game behind the league leading Cleveland team. Comiskey notified the accused players that if they are guilty he will drive them out of baseball, if possible.

The suspended players are Cicotte, Williams, Felsch, Risberg, Weaver, Jackson and McMullin. Gandil is the former player indicted.

Say Cicotte Confessed to Being Bribed

Eddie Cicotte, one of Chicago's star pitchers, confessed that he engineered the deal whereby the White Sox lost last year's world series, a court official announced this afternoon. He says Cicotte told the grand jury that he received $10,000 and Joe Jackson received $5,000 for losing the series. He said they found the money under their pillows the night before the first game.

See the clipping

Comiskey’s word to the eight

A Chattanooga report names the eight and notes that their bonus checks had been held back after the series while the club investigated. Cicotte is said to have confessed in full and signed an immunity waiver. Comiskey suspends all eight in a statement addressed to each: if found guilty, ‘you are out of organized baseball for the rest of your lives.’ His waiver, with those of Jackson and Williams, later vanished from the state’s attorney’s file.

The Chattanooga News · Chattanooga, Tenn.

The Chattanooga News · 28 September 1920 · page 9 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

CHICAGO STARS ARE INDICTED

Cicotte, Gandil, Jackson, Risberg, Felsch, Weaver, McMullin, Williams Named.

See moreSee less

CONSPIRACY IS CHARGED

Cicotte Reported to Have Made Complete Confession Before Grand Jury.

Chicago, Sept. 28.—Indictments against eight members of the Chicago White Sox for alleged crookedness in the 1919 world's series were voted by the Cook county grand jury, which has been probing conditions in organized baseball, this afternoon. The men indicted are:

Chick Gandil, former first baseman; Fred McMullin, utility infielder; Happy Felsch, centerfielder; "Swede" Risberg, shortstop; Eddie Cicotte, pitcher; Claude Williams, pitcher; Joe Jackson, left fielder, and Buck Weaver, third baseman.

The true bills charge conspiracy to commit an illegal act.

Eddie Cicotte, star pitcher, was one of the first witnesses before the grand jury today and his testimony is believed to have been one of the factors that induced the grand jury to return the indictments. He is said to have made a complete confession and to have signed an immunity waiver.

Charge Verified.

His admissions are declared to have verified with the statement of Billy Marhag, Philadelphia pugilist, who accused Cicotte of having been the principal in the promotion of the "fixed" series.

The men indicted are the eight men said to have been implicated in the $100,000 bribe to throw the series and whose bonus checks were held up by the White Sox management while an investigation was made after the series closed last fall.

All Eight Suspended.

Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox, announced immediately after he heard of the voting of the indictments by the grand jury that all eight of the players would stand suspended from the White Sox. This is virtually the elimination of the White Sox from the pennant race as none of the eight men, several of whom are bulwarks of the club, will be permitted to play in any of the remaining games of the season.

The action of Comiskey in suspending those indicted leaves Eddie Collins, Ray Schalk, John Collins and Amos Strunk as the only regular fielders in good standing and Dick Kerr and Red Faber as the only regular pitchers.

Comiskey issued the following statement addressed to each of the indicted players:

"You and each of you are hereby notified of your indefinite suspension as a member of the Chicago American League Baseball club. If you can prove your innocence you will be returned to the team in good standing. If you are found guilty you are out of organized baseball for the rest of your lives."

Eddie Cicotte was immediately taken in custody by an officer and taken to the criminal court building.

See the clipping

Cicotte is led away by a detective

A brief bulletin, with several names misspelled, repeats the eight true bills and the charge of conspiracy to violate a state law. Its one fresh detail: Eddie Cicotte, leaving the grand jury room, was taken into custody by a detective of the state’s attorney’s office, and Assistant State’s Attorney Replogle would not say where the pitcher was being taken.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 28 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

COMISKEY SUSPENDS BALL PLAYERS INDICTED BY COOK COUNTY GRAND JURY CHICAGO, Sept. 28.—Charles Comiskey, president of the White Sox today suspended every member of the team indicted today in connection with the alleged fixing of baseball games. Seven of the eight are indicted. Chick Gandill, the eighth is not playing this year. The suspension practically kills all hope of the White Sox winning the American League pennant this year. (By Associated Press.) CHICAGO, Sept. 28.—The Cook County grand jury this afternoon voted true bills against the following baseball players in connection with the investigation of alleged "throwing world series games last year: Eddie Cicotte, Cicotte.

See moreSee less

Claude William, Chick Gandill, Happy Felsch, Charles Reisberg, Joe Jackson. Fred McMillan and Buck Weaver. All are members of the Chicago Americans. The eight players are charged with conspiracy to violate a state law. Assistant State's Attorney Replogle announced that Cicotte was taken into custody after leaving the grand jury room and is now in charge of William Sullivan, a detective of the state's attorney office. He declined to say where the pitcher was being taken. torney

See the clipping

Cicotte’s confession, in his own words

A Chattanooga roundup prints Cicotte’s confession in his own words. He demanded $10,000 in advance, found it under his pillow, and paid off the $4,000 mortgage on his farm. Outside the jury room small boys ask Joe Jackson if it is true: ‘Yes, boys, I'm afraid it is’. At the trial all three confessors said they had been promised their words would never be used against them.

The Chattanooga News · Chattanooga, Tenn.

The Chattanooga News · 29 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Think This Year's Race "Thrown" Too

Loyal Sox Players Discuss Work of Indicted Stars This Season.

See moreSee less

HAD PECULIAR SLUMP

Cicotte and Williams Lost Effectiveness—Jackson Failed to Hit in Pinches.

More Indictments.

Chicago, Sept. 29.—Twelve more indictments against ball players and gamblers probably will be voted today or tomorrow by the Cook county grand jury which yesterday indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox, according to a statement today by Harvey L. Replogle, assistant state's attorney, who is conducting the probe before the grand jury. Three eastern gamblers and two baseball players on national league teams are said to be among those facing indictment.

Chicago, Sept. 29.—Charges that some of the same players who are accused of "throwing" the world's series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennant winners this season, were made today by several members of the Chicago White Sox, who have not been mentioned in the grand jury testimony.

One player, who refused to allow his name to be used, made the following statement:

"When we started on our last eastern trip we had every reason to believe we would win the pennant. Suddenly Williams and Cicotte seemed to go bad without any reason. Some of us talked it over and agreed it looked like they were grooving the ball.

"Then Jackson, Felsch and Risberg began dumping the ball to the infield every time they came to bat when we had a chance to get runs.

"We thought at first it might be just a batting slump. But when some of us compared notes regarding the pitching and hitting we became more than suspicious.

"It may as well be stated that some of us believe ever since the last world's series that we were sold out by Cicotte and others.

"Well, when the same men we suspected of crossing us at that time began to go bad on the last eastern trip we decided there must have been another sell out. However, we have never been able to prove this.

"Had we played anything like our regular game we would have come home with the pennant cinched. We all hope the grand jury will look into this end of the affair. If it fails to act we may take some action ourselves—if we can get hold of the players we feel sure did the cheating."

Collins Talks.

John Collins, veteran first baseman of the White Sox said:

"We are sorry in a way for the fellows who are caught in this jam, but we are glad everything is going to be shown up.

"We suspected some of them in the world's series and we suspected them again because of the way they played on the last eastern trip. Some of them not only didn't try, but really acted as though they didn't want to win. I have no idea what influenced their actions."

"Red" Faber, veteran pitcher, who carried his club to victory in the 1917 world's series, said the playing of the Sox on the eastern trip made some of the others believe something was crooked.

"It looks like we were double crossed in the world's series last year and in the pennant race this year, but we are not through yet.

"We will go to St. Louis with a ball team on which every man will be trying and we will fight to get into the world's series.

"If we land we will be sure of one thing—we will not have a Judas on the team when we go into the big series."

May Indict Gamblers.

Indictments against five or six gamblers were considered today by the Cook county grand jury investigating "throwing" of baseball games, according to Hartley Replogle, assistant assistant state's attorney, in charge of the inquiry. Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, and Arnold Rothstein, of New York, were said by Replogle to have been involved in testimony presented to the grand jury. Attell, it was said, handled the money paid White Sox players for "throwing" the 1919 world's series.

More ball players may be indicted, it was also indicated by Replogle, after the grand jury has heard the testimony of Presidents Johnson and Heydler, of the American and National leagues, who are to testify today. Copies of telegrams sent prior to and during the 1919 series by Hal Chase and Bill Burns, former major league players, have been obtained by Heydler for presentation to the grand jury.

John J. McGraw, manager of the Giants, also has been asked by the grand jury to appear today to tell about th[e] release of Hal Chase, Lee Magee and Heine Zimmerman by the Giants last year. Statements by several ball players in connection with the 1919 series have involved Chase in the deal by which gamblers are said to have paid eight White Sox players to "lay down" to the Cincinnati Reds.

According to Eddie Cicotte's confession before the grand jury, $80,000 was paid to the White Sox players, divided as follows: Eddie Cicotte, pitcher, $10,000; Claude Williams, pitcher, $10,000; Charles Risberg, shortstop, $10,000; "Buck" Weaver, third baseman, $5,000; Joe Jackson, left fielder, $5,000; "Happy" Felsch, centerfielder, $5,000; "Chick" Gandil, former first baseman, $20,000; Fred McMullin, utility player, $15,000.

Cicotte Cries.

With tears in his eyes, Cicotte told the grand jury how he had lobbed the ball up to the Cincinnati batters in the first game of the series "so they could read the trade mark on it."

Repenting after having thrown two games, he said, he pitched hard to win his third start. Either Gandil, whom Cicotte said first arranged the "throw," or Abe Attell, the go-between of the gamblers, got $75,000 which the eight players were to have received.

When Joe Jackson left the grand jury room after his confession, a crowd of small boys gathered around their heavy-hitting idol and asked: "It isn't true, is it, Joe?"

"Yes, boys, I'm afraid it is," Jackson replied.

Cicotte and Jackson were not promised immunity in return for their confessions, Replogle said, but are liable to prosecution the same as the other players named in the indictments returned.

The eight were suspended by President Comiskey, of the Sox, as soon as he had heard Cicotte's confession, and turned him over to the club's attorney, Alfred Austrian, to be taken before the grand jury.

Manager Gleason, of the Sox, declared the remaining members were still fighting in the pennant race and would start their closing three-game series at St. Louis Friday determined to do all they could to win in spite of the upheaval which took seven regulars out of the line-up.

Pair Off Mortgage.

"Risberg, Bandil and McMillin were at me for a week before the series started," Eddie Cicotte told the grand jury in his confession. "They wanted me to go crooked. I needed the money. I had the wife and kids. They don't know this and I don't know what they'll think.

"I had bought a farm. There was a $4,000 mortgage. I paid that off with crooked money.

"The eight of us—the eight under indictment— got together in my room three or four days before the series started. Gandil was master of ceremonies. We talked about throwing the series and decided we could get away with it. We agreed to do it.

"I was thinking of the wife and kids and how I needed the money. I told them I had to have the cash in advance. I didn't want any checks. I didn't want any promise. I wanted the money in bills before I pitched a ball.

"We all talked quite a while about it. Yes, all of us decided to do our best to throw the games to Cincinnati. Then Gandil and McMillin took us all one by one, away from the others and we talked turkey. They asked me my price. I told them $10,000 paid in advance.

"It was Gandil I was talking to. He wanted to give me some money at the time and the rest after the games were played and lost.

"'Cash in advance, not C. O. D.' I reminded him, 'If you cant trust me I cant trust you. Pay or I play ball.'

"Well, the argument went on for some days but I stood pat. I wanted that $10,000 and I got it.

"How I wish I had not.

"The day before I went to Cincinnati I put it up to them squarely for the last time there would be nothing doing unless I had the money.

SOLD OUT 'COMMY.'

"That night I found the money under my pillow. I had sold out 'Commy' and the other boys to pay of a mortgage on a farm and for the wife and kids.

"The first ball I pitched I wondered what the wife and kiddies would say if they ever found out I was a crook. I pitched the best ball I knew how after that first ball. But I lost because I was hit, not because I was throwing the game."

Joe Jackson described his confession to the grand jury as follows:

"I heard I had been indicted. I decided these men could not put anything over on me. I called up Judge McDonald (chief justice Charles A. McDonald of the superior court who directed the grand jury inquiry) and told him I was an honest man. He said 'I know you are not' and hung up the receiver.

"I figured somebody had squawked and that the place for me was the ground floor. I went to tell him what I knew.

Williams Confesses.

Identity of alleged go-betweens and gamblers who bribed White Sox players was revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude ("Lefty") Williams, who joined Cicotte and Jackson in making a clean breast of the 1919 world's series frame-up.

Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson the same, but that he received only $10,000, half of which he gave Jackson.

He said Gandil told him that Bill Burns, veteran pitcher, and Abe Attell, former prizefighter, were fixing it for the Sox players to get $100,000.

Williams named "Chick" Gandil, former White Sox player, against whom a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team, and "a Brown and Sullivan, gamblers," from either New York or Boston, as go-betweens for the gamblers.

The grand jury immediately voted true bills for Brown and Sullivan.

Williams named "Sport" Sullivan, a Bosotn gambler, and another Boston gambler named Brown as two of the principals in the deal. He said he received $10,000 for his part in throwing the series. Five thousand dollars of this amount he gave to Jackson, he said.

Williams declared he personally paid the $5,000 to Jackson, his testimony being at variance with previous reports.

Joe Jackson, who last night was in custody of a deputy sheriff, has been released and will leave tonight for his home in the south, it was learned today.

See the clipping

Lefty Williams confesses too

Lefty Williams follows Cicotte and Jackson before the grand jury, names Chick Gandil as the players’ go-between and two gamblers he calls Brown and Sullivan, and says he got $10,000 of a promised $20,000. Manager Kid Gleason tells how the confessions began: Cicotte came to him with ‘a load on his chest’, and Comiskey had his attorney take the pitcher to the judge.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · Elkins, W. Va.

The Elkins Inter-Mountain · 29 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

WHITE SOX MAKE A CLEAN BREST OF 1919 FRAME-UP

Claude Williams Joins Cicotte and Jackson in Confessing "Throwing" of World Series

See moreSee less

CHICK GANDILL NAMED AS CHIEF GO-BETWEEN

(By Associated Press.) CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--Identity of alleged go between and gamblers who bribed White Sox players was revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude Williams who joined Cicotte and Jackson in making a clean breast of the 1919 world series frame-up.

Williams named Chick Gandill former White Sox player against whom a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team and a "Brown and Sullivan,' gamblers, from either New York or Boston as go-between for the gamblers.. The jury voted true bills for Brown and Sullivan.

Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson the same but that he received only $10,000 half of which he gave Jackson.

He said Gandil told him that Bill Burns veteran pitcher, and Attell, former prize fighter, were fixing it for the Six hired to get $100,000.

CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--At 12:30 o'clock pitcher Claude Williams appeared at the criminal court building and was conducted to the grand jury room.

Williams has made a complete state- (Continued on Page 4)

WHITE SOX MAKE CLEAN BREST OF 1919 FRAMEUP (Continued from Page 1.)

ment Attorney Austrian announced. He said Williams furnished considerable information about the gamblers involved in the purchase of the Sox players and also named the go-betweens, it was announced.

Williams named "sport' Sullivan, a Boston gambler, and another Boston gambler named Brown as two of the principals in the deal. He said that he received $10,000 for his part in "throwing" the series.

Five thousand dollars of this amount he gave to Jackson he declared. He said he personally paid the $5,000 to Jackson, his testimony being at variance with previous reports.

William before making his statement signed a waiver of immunity. Assistant States Attorney Replogle stated that another of the White Sox players was expected at the criminal court building this afternoon to make a statement. The announcement was believed to refer to McMillan who was said to have made a statement to Attorney Austrian.

CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--Further confessions by some of the seven White Sox players who with one former player were indicted yesterday in connection with the alleged "throwing" of the 1919 World's Series will be made within a day or two, Alfred Austrian, attorney for the ball club announced today.

It has been rumored that at least two of the seven were anxious to supplement the confession of Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson with their statements. William ("Kid") Gleason, manager of the White Sox disclosed today the march of events which culminated in Cicotte's confession and the voting of indictments.

Last Monday according to Gleason he had gathered enough evidence to know that some of the players had been bribed to lose the series. Cicotte came to him Monday night and declared he had "a load on his chest" and wanted to get rid of it. Gleason told him to see "Commy.' Charles A. Comisky, owner of the Sox.

Comisky heard Cicotte's story which tallied with the evidence gathered by his private detective and then called his attorney, A. S. Austrian, and told him to take the pitcher to Judge MacDonald, Chief Justice of the Cook County Criminal Court. The confession and indictment followed.

True bills naming three ball players, not members of the White Sox and three gamblers, were expected to be voted today by the grand jury. Members of the jury said this morning they had sufficient evidence on which to base indictments. It was reported that true bills against two National League players were being considered.

CHICAGO, Sept. 29.--Charges that some of the same players who are accused of "throwing" the world series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennant winners this season were made today by several members of the White Sox who have not been mentioned in the grand jury testimonies.

NEW YORK, Sept. 29.--District Attorney Lewis of King's County, announced today he would start an immediate investigation of the report that a clique of gamblers planned to bribe members of the Brooklyn Nationals purposely to lose games to their American League opponents in the coming world's series.

In a telegram to State Attorney Hoyne of Chicago, whose grand jury investigating charges that the 1919 series was fixed has indicted eight White Sox players, Mr. Lewis said he was acting on the following statement appearing in a New York evening paper yesterday:

"Information has been gathered by officials tending to indiacte that the same clique of gamblers which is alleged to have fixed the 1919 series have made plans to have Brooklyn 'throw' the coming series to the Cleveland Indians."

See the clipping

Felsch’s share: $5,000 in his locker

Reports of Happy Felsch’s confession say he found $5,000 in his clubhouse locker, that the fly ball he dropped in the series was an accident, and that he was promised $20,000 but double crossed, he believed by Attell and Gandil. The deal, the paper says, was struck in Cicotte’s small room in a South Side hotel. Felsch’s statement was said to have gone to a newspaper reporter, and the trial judge would bar it.

Evening Journal · Wilmington, Del.

Evening Journal · 30 September 1920 · page 11 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

ADMISSIONS BY TWO MORE SOX

Williams and Felsch Confess Part in Scandal

See moreSee less

GAMBLERS ALSO ARE INDICTED

CHICAGO, Sept. 30. — Confessions from Claude Williams and Oscar Felsch, admitting they were bribed to "throw" last year's world's series, were made public yesterday and at the same time the grand jury investigating the baseball scandal took its first action against gamblers who are said to have engineered the deal by indicting two men whose identity was only partly revealed.

"Brown" and "Sullivan" were the names under which true bills were voted against the alleged gamblers and both were said to be from Boston, or New York. Later, however, it came out that the jury believed these names to be mythical and used only by the men when they discussed the series "throwing" with the ball players. Possibility that they are two men whose names already have been brought before the jury and who are nationally known, was expressed by officials in the State attorney's office.

The statement by Williams and the newspaper reports of Felsch's confession tallied with those made on Thursday by Eddie Cicotte and Joe Jackson. They revealed that last year's world series was settled in a tiny room in a small south side hotel.

In this room, occupied by Eddie Cicotte, once the American League's leading pitcher, the deal was made which "threw" the world series, wrecked a world championship team and brought some of the, greatest idols in baseball to disgrace.

According to the sworn statement, made by Claude Williams, who lost three of the world series games, he and "Chick" Gandil, "Buck" Weaver, Eddie Cicotte, who lost two games, and "Happy" Felsch, whose error helped lose one game, met here to barter with "Brown" and "Sullivan" to lose the games.

"After we had agreed that we were willing to 'throw' the series," Williams said, "we went out one at a time and made our bargains with Brown and Sullivan."

Williams said he received $10,000 and that he gave $5,000 to Jackson, a statement which tallies with the confession made by Jackson yesterday. He was supposed to get $20,000, he said.

Felsch, according to reports of his confession, said he received $5,000, which he found in his locker at the clubhouse, but that he never had a chance to really help lose the series. His one glaring error of the series—when he dropped the fly ball—was an accident and he was warned afterwards by the other players not to be so awkward in making his misplays, he was quoted as saying. The outfielder declared he did not want to "get in on the deal," at first, but the other players at the hotel conference told him it would be easy. He said he had been promised $20,000 but was double crossed. Abe Attell and Gandil were the ones he believed guilty of the double-crossing.

Felsch denied that the White Sox had thrown any game this season, and said the men implicated in the bribery had felt all season they would be exposed sooner or later. We confirmed the confessions of Cicotte and Jackson.

John Heydler, president of the National League, and John McGraw, manager of the New York Giants, yesterday told the jury details of the Lee Magee and Hal Chase cases and also of dropping of Heinie Zimmerman. McGraw was requested to return Tuesday and bring Fred Toney, New York pitcher, and Bennie Kauff, outfielder Heydler was asked to appear again at his convenience after the world series.

McGraw is said to have told the jury that he dropped Hal Chase from his club after President Heydler had told him Magee had confessed that Chase bribed him to throw games. He said he had heard of many other gambling activities of Chase's before the Magee case.

Zimmerman was dropped from the New York team, McGraw is said to have told the jury, because information had come to the New York manager that the third baseman offered Benny Kauff $500 to help throw games.

"I believe Kauff was innocent," said McGraw, "but I got rid of Chase and Zimmerman, even though I know it would seriously injure my team, because I didn't want such men on the club."

Heydler's testimony was largely the interview he gave newspaper men Sunday night telling of his private investigation, how Comiskey had told him a year ago he suspected some of the White Sox players, and how he and William Veeck, president of the Chicago Cubs, had obtained a confession from Lee Magee.

"One incident in Magee's case is amusing," said Heydler, "for while I think he tried to throw this game, he really helped win it.

"In July, 1918, Magee was playing second for Cincinnati against Boston. He came to bat with two out and hit an easy grounder, which took a bad bound and he was safe. He was ordered to steal second and ambled down. When half way to second he stopped, but Art Wilson made a wild throw and Magee had to go on to third. He might have scored with the tying run, I think, if he had tried, but he didn't. Then Rousch knocked a home run. Magee had to come in with the tying run and Rousch's run of course won the game."

Heydler is said to have told the jury that Magee confessed to him and Veeck that he took part in the throwing of several games.

According to an official in the State's attorney's office the name of two brothers in Des Moine have been brought before the jury. They are said to have placed large bets on the world series and to have been tipped that it was "fixed."

Further indications against gamblers may be expected within a day or two, it was said.

The jury will resume the investigation tomorrow.

See the clipping

Detectives hunt for Abe Attell

The inquiry turns to the gamblers. New York detectives search for Abe Attell, the former featherweight champion, whose lawyer will not produce him without a charge, and Boston’s ‘Sport’ Sullivan is reported ready to name the ‘brains’ of the plot. Weaver, McMullin, Felsch and Risberg hire counsel and demand quick trials. Neither man stood trial: Sullivan was never caught, and Attell beat extradition.

The Topeka State Journal · Topeka, Kansas

The Topeka State Journal · 2 October 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

HUNT HIGHER UPS

Chicago Grand Jury Will Continue Ball Probe Tuesday.

See moreSee less

Detectives Hunt for Abe Attell as Material Witness.

CALL IT GRAND LARCENY

Cook County State's Attorney Cites Law Covering Scandal.

New York Authorities Investigate 'Fixed 1919 World Series.'

Chicago, Oct. 2.—Judge Charles McDonald today issued an order extending the period of the September grand jury indefinitely, to permit continuation of its investigation of the baseball scandal.

The grand jury will meet again Tuesday to hear testimony of John McGraw, Fred Toney and Benny Kauff, in connection with the allegations that Hal Chase, Lee Magee and Heinie Zimmerman were dropped from baseball last year because of gambling.

May Tell On "Brains."

Interest in the investigation today hinged on reports from New York that John "Sport" Sullivan, of Boston, against whom a true bill was voted last week, would come to Chicago to reveal the "brains" behind the gamblers' plot which led to the bribing of White Sox players to lose the world's series last year.

"Buck" Weaver, Fred McMullin, "Happy" Felsch, and "Swede" Risberg have employed counsel to defend them and have demanded trials as soon as the indictments against them are returned. Chief Justice McDonald said that he would grant them immediate hearings.

Hunt for Abe Attell.

New York, Oct. 2.—Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, whose name has been connected with rumors that the 1919 world series was "fixed" by a syndicate of gamblers, will be forcibly brought to the office of District Attorney Swann, of New York, for the questioning, if he can be found by detectives, who are searching for him.

District Attorney Swann, in announcing this today, said he intended to prosecute any persons here who profited thru "any crooked gambling scheme connected with the last world's series."

Would Be "Grand Larceny."

There is a special law under which he can proceed, he declared, and in addition he thought the crime would come under the grand larceny statute. Sinister gambling after the games had been "fixed" would constitute "grand larceny by trick and devices," he said.

Eugene Magee, a partner of William J. Fallon, counsel for Attell, said today that Mr. Fallon has informed the district attorney's office that he will not produce his client unless there is a charge placed against him.

See the clipping

Jackson goes home to Greenville

Joe Jackson and Lefty Williams drive to Greenville, South Carolina, to stay with Jackson’s parents. The ‘companions in misery’, as they call themselves, hint that men higher up in baseball were to blame. Jackson says he is through with the game: ‘I'm going to work’. Old friends at Brandon Mills, where he first played, greet him warmly. By December he had recanted, saying he confessed under duress.

The New York Herald · New York, N.Y.

The New York Herald · 5 October 1920 · page 2 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

JACKSON AND WILLIAMS THREATEN EXPOSURES

Blame Men Higher Up for Baseball Scandal.

See moreSee less

Special Despatch to The Herald.

Greenville, S. C., Oct. 4.—Joe Jackson and Lefty Williams, two of the eight indicted Chicago players, arrived to-day by automobile to spend several days as the guests of Jackson's parents, at their home in a suburb of Greenville.

The "companions in misery," as they termed themselves, said to-day that if the investigators will work thoroughly they will find men higher up in baseball responsible for the scandal, and they intimated they may be led to make some exposures.

Jackson said he was through with baseball for good, and that he does not intend even to play independent ball. "I'm going to work," he said.

Jackson visited some of the scenes of his boyhood, where he first played ball at Brandon Mills, and if his old friends held any less admiration for him it was not evident in the demonstration of cordiality that greeted him. Jackson will go from here to his winter home in Savannah.

See the clipping

Rothstein says he turned the fix down

New York gambler Arnold Rothstein tells the grand jury that Bill Burns and then Abe Attell brought him the fix and he sent both away: he ‘was on the square when it came to gambling’. Harry Redmond of East St. Louis says he told Comiskey’s people that winter, the first sign, the paper says, that the club’s attorney had evidence before the 1920 season. At the trial Burns named Rothstein among the organizers.

Evening Star · Washington, D.C.

This article was wrong. The papers corrected it 2 days later.

Wrong

Evening Star · 27 October 1920 · page 25 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Lost on 1919 Series, Says Rothstein

TURNED DOWN ATTELL AND BURNS, HE STATES

See moreSee less

CHICAGO, October 27.—The special grand jury investigating "fixed" base ball has recessed until Friday. No additional indictments have been voted. Friday a formal report will be submitted to Chief Justice McDonald of the criminal court covering the inquiry, and there will be a return of the thirteen indictments voted several days ago against the eight White Sox and five other former base ball players and alleged gamblers who are mixed up with the alleged "fixing" of the 1919 world series.

The grand jury will not vote any further indictments unless it is against Chicago base ball owners. Chief Justice McDonald intimated that efforts will be made to extradite Abe Attell, one of the indicted "fixers," who is vacationing in Canada.

Arnold Rothstein of New York, Joe Gedeon, second baseman of the St Louis Browns, and H. G. Redmond, theatrical manager of East St. Louis, were the star witnesses yesterday. Rothstein repeated the story of how he was approached by Bill Burns, ex-White Sox pitcher, and Abe Attell, who declared that several members of the White Sox team had been fixed to "lay down" in the 1919 series to Cincinnati.

Tells of Visit by Burns.

"A few days before the series opened," testified Rothstein, "I received a call from Bill Burns at the Astor Hotel. Burns outlined at length a proposition to clean up thousands on the series. Burns said that all the groundwork had been laid, that certain players on the White Sox had been 'fixed,' and all I had to do was to put up $100,000 to pay the ball players.

"I told Burns that I was on the square when it came to gambling, and any 'sure-thing' propositions were over my head. I also called him a few harsh names. The following night I received a telephone call at my home from Abe Attell. I was entertaining company, and I declined to talk to him. A day or so afterward Attell approached me in the Hotel Astor and assured me that everything was O. K. on the proposition that Burns spoke about. Attell told me all I had to do was to supply the bank roll. I told Attell to go to h——."

Rothstein was asked if he knew the gambler who had supplied the money to bribe the White Sox players in the series. He replied that he did not.

Redmond followed Rothstein. He told the grand jury that he had given last winter to Charles A. Comiskey, owner of the White Sox; Harry Grabiner, secretary of the club, and Alfred S. Austrian, its attorney, much of the information that has lately been unearthed by the grand jury.

Redmond's story is the first direct testimony unearthed by the grand jury tending to show that Attorney Austrian, in charge of the investigation for Comiskey, had actual evidence against alleged crooked players before the 1920 season started.

Redmond substantiated the story told by Kid Gleason, White Sox manager, that the latter went to St. Louis soon after the finish of the 1919 series. He said that Gleason interviewed several others besides himself and that he had told him of his knowledge at that time.

Gedeon Tells of Being "Tipped."

Gedeon told the jury of being tipped by a White Sox player that the series was "fixed," but he declined to tell the jury the name of the player who tipped him off, and the question was not pressed, state officials saying they "already knew."

"Sport" Sullivan of Boston and R. Brown of New York, against whom the jury has voted true bills, were mentioned by Gedeon as men he understood were back of the bribing. Both were named by Claude Williams, White Sox pitcher, in his confession.

Attell and Chase, Gedeon told the jury he believed, were the instigators of the game selling.

See the clipping

The gamblers go broke on game three

Harry Redmond, an East St. Louis theatre owner, tells the grand jury that after Dick Kerr won the third game, Attell, Burns and St. Louis gamblers met at the Sherman House, broke and needing $25,000 more for the players. Joe Gedeon, a St. Louis ballplayer, admits one of the eight wired him the tip. Two of those gamblers, Carl Zoark (later spelled Zork) and Benjamin Franklin, were indicted the next spring.

The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · Rock Island, Ill.

The Rock Island Argus and Daily Union · 27 October 1920 · page 12 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

COMISKEY TOLD OF 'FIX' IN '19 JURY INFORMED

St. Louis Man Exposed Crooked Players, He Swears.

See moreSee less

Chicago, Oct. 27.—Harry Redmond, owner of the Majestic theatre at East St. Louis, Arnold Rothstein, New York gambler, and Joseph Gedeon, second baseman of the St. Louis American league team, told baseball grand jury yesterday details of their knowledge of the bribing of White Sox players in the 1919 world series with Cincinnati.

Redmond told of advance knowledge of the "fixing," his unwillingness to believe the tip, and of losing $3,500 on the first two games. Then, convinced the tip was straight, he plunged on the Reds. Losing again, he attended a conference of the "conspirators," who were bemoaning the fact that little Dick Kerr had thwarted their plans for a tremendous cleanup by beating Cincinnati in the third game of the series.

Gamblers Sought New Pool.

At this meeting in the Sherman house were Abe Attel and William Burns, already indicted; Benjamin Franklin, Carl Zoark, and Joe Pesch, St. Louis gamblers, and Gedeon, the ball player. The gamblers, according to Redmond, expected Cincinnati to win five straight games. They went broke when the Sox won with Kerr pitching, and attributed it to their failure to pay the amounts originally offered the crooked players. They needed another pool of $25,000 for the players, and Redmond was asked contribute $5,000. He refused, but did bet on the Reds to win the series, and recouped his losses, he said.

Regarded as tending to prove the contentions of Ban Johnson, was the admission of Redmond, that at the solicitation of Sam Pass and the Ascher brothers, he, Redmond, had told all he knew to representatives of Charles Comiskey and had named the players involved who have since been indicted. That was shortly after the series.

Refused Bribe.

"I was in the office of Comiskey's attorney, Alfred Austrian, with Joe Pesch when the 'sellout' of his players was described to Commy. We refused to accept any part of the $10,000 he had offered for proof that his team had deliberately thrown away the title of world's champions," Redmond asserted.

"Pesch and I first learned that the series was off color through a remark made by Zoark, a manufacturer of shirt waists, which was overheard."

In making a clean breast of his connection with the affair, Gedeon admitted it was he who gave the St. Louis gamblers their first intimation that all was not well with the White Sox. One of the eight indicted Sox players had sent him a wire to get in on the good thing. He refused to name this player to the grand jury. Not knowing the best manner to place large wagers, he conferred with gamblers. This introduced Zoark and Benjamin Franklin into the scandal for the first time.

Assistant State's Attorney Hartley L. Replogle, in charge of the investigation, announced last night that no more witnesses would be called.

The baseball pool or lottery games will be passed with only recommendations for their suppression.

See the clipping

Thirteen names on the true bills

The grand jury returns its indictments in open court: thirteen men, seven White Sox players, Gandil, Hal Chase, Bill Burns, Abe Attell and two gamblers, Sullivan and Brown, charged with conspiracy and running a confidence game. The paper recalls where the inquiry began: suspicion over a Cubs game lost to Philadelphia on 29 August. In March the state would drop the case and indict the players again.

Omaha Daily Bee · Omaha, Neb.

Omaha Daily Bee · 30 October 1920 · page 20 · transcribed from the page image

Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.

Thirteen Are Indicted for Ball "Fixing"

Seven Members of White Sox, Three Former Players, Boxer And Two Gamblers Are Named by Grand Jury.

See moreSee less

Chicago, Oct. 29.—Two indictments charging 13 persons with operating a confidence game and conspiracy were returned in court today by the grand jury investigating the base ball scandal.

Seven members of the Chicago White Sox, three former base ball players, a boxer and two gamblers were named in the true bills voted recently.

The charges grew out of the alleged "fixing" of last year's world's series between the White Sox and Cincinnati.

Those indicted are:

Eddie Cicotte, Joe Jackson, Claude Williams, Fred McMullin, George Weaver, William Burns, Oscar Felsch and Charles Risberg, White Sox players; Arnold "Chick" Gandil, former White Sox player; Hal Chase, former New York Giants; Abe Attel, former boxer; Joseph "Sport" Sullivan of Boston, and Rachael Brown of New York.

The conspiracy indictment contains five counts, including charges of conspiracy to obtain money under false pretenses and to injure the business of the Chicago American league base ball club.

Three Confess.

Cicotte, Jackson and Williams confessed to the grand jury they had accepted bribes to lose the series last year, and named the others as parties to the plot.

Extradition papers have been prepared by the state's attorney for the 13 and efforts will be made immediately, it was announced, to obtain their return to Chicago. Attell is reported to be in Canada; Cicotte in Detroit, Gandil in Texas, Jackson and Weaver in North Carolina.

True bills against three owners of base ball pools were voted today by the special grand jury investigating base ball.

Owners of the Great Western, Universal and American-National pools are named in the bills. All are Chicago men.

Chief Justice McDonald announced that he would fix bail at $5,000 on each indictment or $10,000 for each of those named.

To Meet Again Nov. 6.

Investigation of the pools resulted from numerous complaints received by the grand jury from men holding winnings, who were unable to collect ond their slips.

The special grand jury adjourned late today until November 6, when it will be dissolved unless further evidence is brought up for consideration.

Those against whom true bills were voted today are:

William Chellus, Martin Carlin and F. C. Walters, all of Chicago.

While the grand jurors were returning the indictments, before Chief Justice Charles A. McDonald, Ban Johnson, president of the American league, turned over to Assistant State's Attorney Hartley Replogle a letter from a Kansas City sporting editor alleging that "Frog" Thompson, a Kansas City gambler, received a telegram from Claude Hendrix, Chicago Cub player, advising him to "bet $5,000 on the opposition" in the game between Philadelphia and Chicago here August 29. It was the circumstances surrounding the Cubs' defeat on that date that started the base ball gambling investigation. The Kansas City letter also alleges that Thompson received a telegram from Hal Chase, who was then in California, confirming the Hendrix mesage.

See the clipping

← Back to Act One: Fans and Players Ready for Series