The Chattanooga News · 29 September 1920 · page 1 · transcribed from the page image
Part of this page is damaged, so some words could not be read with certainty. Letters and words in [brackets] are our reading of what survives.
Loyal Sox Players Discuss Work of Indicted Stars This Season.
See moreSee less
HAD PECULIAR SLUMP
Cicotte and Williams Lost Effectiveness—Jackson Failed to Hit in Pinches.
More Indictments.
Chicago, Sept. 29.—Twelve more indictments against ball players and gamblers probably will be voted today or tomorrow by the Cook county grand jury which yesterday indicted eight members of the Chicago White Sox, according to a statement today by Harvey L. Replogle, assistant state's attorney, who is conducting the probe before the grand jury. Three eastern gamblers and two baseball players on national league teams are said to be among those facing indictment.
Chicago, Sept. 29.—Charges that some of the same players who are accused of "throwing" the world's series to Cincinnati last year have used their efforts to prevent the White Sox from becoming pennant winners this season, were made today by several members of the Chicago White Sox, who have not been mentioned in the grand jury testimony.
One player, who refused to allow his name to be used, made the following statement:
"When we started on our last eastern trip we had every reason to believe we would win the pennant. Suddenly Williams and Cicotte seemed to go bad without any reason. Some of us talked it over and agreed it looked like they were grooving the ball.
"Then Jackson, Felsch and Risberg began dumping the ball to the infield every time they came to bat when we had a chance to get runs.
"We thought at first it might be just a batting slump. But when some of us compared notes regarding the pitching and hitting we became more than suspicious.
"It may as well be stated that some of us believe ever since the last world's series that we were sold out by Cicotte and others.
"Well, when the same men we suspected of crossing us at that time began to go bad on the last eastern trip we decided there must have been another sell out. However, we have never been able to prove this.
"Had we played anything like our regular game we would have come home with the pennant cinched. We all hope the grand jury will look into this end of the affair. If it fails to act we may take some action ourselves—if we can get hold of the players we feel sure did the cheating."
Collins Talks.
John Collins, veteran first baseman of the White Sox said:
"We are sorry in a way for the fellows who are caught in this jam, but we are glad everything is going to be shown up.
"We suspected some of them in the world's series and we suspected them again because of the way they played on the last eastern trip. Some of them not only didn't try, but really acted as though they didn't want to win. I have no idea what influenced their actions."
"Red" Faber, veteran pitcher, who carried his club to victory in the 1917 world's series, said the playing of the Sox on the eastern trip made some of the others believe something was crooked.
"It looks like we were double crossed in the world's series last year and in the pennant race this year, but we are not through yet.
"We will go to St. Louis with a ball team on which every man will be trying and we will fight to get into the world's series.
"If we land we will be sure of one thing—we will not have a Judas on the team when we go into the big series."
May Indict Gamblers.
Indictments against five or six gamblers were considered today by the Cook county grand jury investigating "throwing" of baseball games, according to Hartley Replogle, assistant assistant state's attorney, in charge of the inquiry. Abe Attell, former featherweight champion, and Arnold Rothstein, of New York, were said by Replogle to have been involved in testimony presented to the grand jury. Attell, it was said, handled the money paid White Sox players for "throwing" the 1919 world's series.
More ball players may be indicted, it was also indicated by Replogle, after the grand jury has heard the testimony of Presidents Johnson and Heydler, of the American and National leagues, who are to testify today. Copies of telegrams sent prior to and during the 1919 series by Hal Chase and Bill Burns, former major league players, have been obtained by Heydler for presentation to the grand jury.
John J. McGraw, manager of the Giants, also has been asked by the grand jury to appear today to tell about th[e] release of Hal Chase, Lee Magee and Heine Zimmerman by the Giants last year. Statements by several ball players in connection with the 1919 series have involved Chase in the deal by which gamblers are said to have paid eight White Sox players to "lay down" to the Cincinnati Reds.
According to Eddie Cicotte's confession before the grand jury, $80,000 was paid to the White Sox players, divided as follows: Eddie Cicotte, pitcher, $10,000; Claude Williams, pitcher, $10,000; Charles Risberg, shortstop, $10,000; "Buck" Weaver, third baseman, $5,000; Joe Jackson, left fielder, $5,000; "Happy" Felsch, centerfielder, $5,000; "Chick" Gandil, former first baseman, $20,000; Fred McMullin, utility player, $15,000.
Cicotte Cries.
With tears in his eyes, Cicotte told the grand jury how he had lobbed the ball up to the Cincinnati batters in the first game of the series "so they could read the trade mark on it."
Repenting after having thrown two games, he said, he pitched hard to win his third start. Either Gandil, whom Cicotte said first arranged the "throw," or Abe Attell, the go-between of the gamblers, got $75,000 which the eight players were to have received.
When Joe Jackson left the grand jury room after his confession, a crowd of small boys gathered around their heavy-hitting idol and asked: "It isn't true, is it, Joe?"
"Yes, boys, I'm afraid it is," Jackson replied.
Cicotte and Jackson were not promised immunity in return for their confessions, Replogle said, but are liable to prosecution the same as the other players named in the indictments returned.
The eight were suspended by President Comiskey, of the Sox, as soon as he had heard Cicotte's confession, and turned him over to the club's attorney, Alfred Austrian, to be taken before the grand jury.
Manager Gleason, of the Sox, declared the remaining members were still fighting in the pennant race and would start their closing three-game series at St. Louis Friday determined to do all they could to win in spite of the upheaval which took seven regulars out of the line-up.
Pair Off Mortgage.
"Risberg, Bandil and McMillin were at me for a week before the series started," Eddie Cicotte told the grand jury in his confession. "They wanted me to go crooked. I needed the money. I had the wife and kids. They don't know this and I don't know what they'll think.
"I had bought a farm. There was a $4,000 mortgage. I paid that off with crooked money.
"The eight of us—the eight under indictment— got together in my room three or four days before the series started. Gandil was master of ceremonies. We talked about throwing the series and decided we could get away with it. We agreed to do it.
"I was thinking of the wife and kids and how I needed the money. I told them I had to have the cash in advance. I didn't want any checks. I didn't want any promise. I wanted the money in bills before I pitched a ball.
"We all talked quite a while about it. Yes, all of us decided to do our best to throw the games to Cincinnati. Then Gandil and McMillin took us all one by one, away from the others and we talked turkey. They asked me my price. I told them $10,000 paid in advance.
"It was Gandil I was talking to. He wanted to give me some money at the time and the rest after the games were played and lost.
"'Cash in advance, not C. O. D.' I reminded him, 'If you cant trust me I cant trust you. Pay or I play ball.'
"Well, the argument went on for some days but I stood pat. I wanted that $10,000 and I got it.
"How I wish I had not.
"The day before I went to Cincinnati I put it up to them squarely for the last time there would be nothing doing unless I had the money.
SOLD OUT 'COMMY.'
"That night I found the money under my pillow. I had sold out 'Commy' and the other boys to pay of a mortgage on a farm and for the wife and kids.
"The first ball I pitched I wondered what the wife and kiddies would say if they ever found out I was a crook. I pitched the best ball I knew how after that first ball. But I lost because I was hit, not because I was throwing the game."
Joe Jackson described his confession to the grand jury as follows:
"I heard I had been indicted. I decided these men could not put anything over on me. I called up Judge McDonald (chief justice Charles A. McDonald of the superior court who directed the grand jury inquiry) and told him I was an honest man. He said 'I know you are not' and hung up the receiver.
"I figured somebody had squawked and that the place for me was the ground floor. I went to tell him what I knew.
Williams Confesses.
Identity of alleged go-betweens and gamblers who bribed White Sox players was revealed in a confession made to the grand jury today by Claude ("Lefty") Williams, who joined Cicotte and Jackson in making a clean breast of the 1919 world's series frame-up.
Williams said he was supposed to get $20,000 and Jackson the same, but that he received only $10,000, half of which he gave Jackson.
He said Gandil told him that Bill Burns, veteran pitcher, and Abe Attell, former prizefighter, were fixing it for the Sox players to get $100,000.
Williams named "Chick" Gandil, former White Sox player, against whom a true bill was returned yesterday as chief go-between on the team, and "a Brown and Sullivan, gamblers," from either New York or Boston, as go-betweens for the gamblers.
The grand jury immediately voted true bills for Brown and Sullivan.
Williams named "Sport" Sullivan, a Bosotn gambler, and another Boston gambler named Brown as two of the principals in the deal. He said he received $10,000 for his part in throwing the series. Five thousand dollars of this amount he gave to Jackson, he said.
Williams declared he personally paid the $5,000 to Jackson, his testimony being at variance with previous reports.
Joe Jackson, who last night was in custody of a deputy sheriff, has been released and will leave tonight for his home in the south, it was learned today.